The Millions

Notes on the Art of Rhetoric

Sink every impulse like a bolt. Secure
The bastion of sensation. Do not waver
Into language. Do not waver in it.
        —Seamus Heaney, “Lightenings”

1.
For most of us, rhetoric boils down to what you learned in high school when the teacher drew a triangle on the chalkboard and wrote logos, ethos, pathos. “These are the three appeals to the audience,” the teacher said. Reason, character, emotion. “A composition will try to include all three of these for best effect,” you may’ve heard. But these three alone aren’t rhetoric. Instead, consider adding Kenneth Burke’s idea of “identification” from A Rhetoric of Motives, that states “[y]ou persuade a man only insofar as you can talk his language by speech, gesture, tonality, order, image, attitude, idea, identifying your ways with his.”

Prince Hamlet is a prime rhetorician in the Burkean sense. (Actually, , but I’m being generous.) After speaking to his father’s ghost, Hamlet confides to Horatio: “I perchance hereafter shall think meet / To put an antic disposition on;” antic, as in, grotesque; meaning, Hamlet’s fixing his words and actions to fit the ass-backwards scene in his home. Because “time is out of joint” in Elsinore. And Hamlet, too, will be out of joint if he doesn’t persuade everyone he’s nuts, but it will be against common sense, against prior character, and against what passes for royal emotion among his kin. That is a type of persuasion.

You're reading a preview, sign up to read more.

More from The Millions

The Millions9 min readPolitics
The Sex Worker Next Door
A writer learns of her grandmother's secret past, inspiring a novel's worth of research about the working women of contemporary China. The post The Sex Worker Next Door appeared first on The Millions.
The Millions7 min read
States of Strangeness and Wonder: A Great American Road Trip
Maybe that is the essential truth about America: there’s no giving up on it. There is always the possibility of reinvention and rebirth. The post States of Strangeness and Wonder: A Great American Road Trip appeared first on The Millions.
The Millions11 min read
Philosophizing the Grave: Learning to Die with Costica Bradatan
He offers us a claim about how some brave souls die for ideas, how their sacrifices illuminate those malignancies that threaten a society in collapse. The post Philosophizing the Grave: Learning to Die with Costica Bradatan appeared first on The Mill