The American Scholar

How We Came Together

UNION: The Struggle to Forge the Story of United States Nationhood

BY COLIN WOODARD

Viking, 432 pp., $30

THE ANTHROPOLOGIST Sally Falk Moore thought that some portion of legal reasoning was really masquerade. Studying colonial East Africa, she found that legal changes billed as rational reforms were, when viewed over a century, simply mirroring economic and political changes.

The implication? Seemingly disinterested law is a cover for politics. Judges and lawyers may not realize it, Moore wrote, but their careful arguments of legal norms really function as a means of displacing responsibility. Those involved are not reasoning; they are unwittingly disguising the exercise of power behind a vague abstraction called The Law.

I kept thinking of Moore’s argument while reading Colin Woodard’s an exploration of the ideas that guided the country from its first days as

Вы читаете отрывок, зарегистрируйтесь, чтобы читать полное издание.

Другое от: The American Scholar

The American Scholar22 мин. чтения
The Patriot Slave
DURING THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION, four times more black Americans served as loyalists to the Crown than served as patriots. They joined the British in high numbers in response to promises of emancipation. And yet the enduring memory of black participat
The American Scholar4 мин. чтения
Commonplace Book
After every war someone has to tidy up. — Wisława Szymborska, “The End and the Beginning,” 1993 The road, just in front of the sidewalk where I sat and played jacks, would be ankle-deep in dust, and seemed to drink up the moonlight like folds of ve
The American Scholar5 мин. чтенияTech
Letters
Reading “No Ghost in the Machine” in the Spring issue of the SCHOLAR, I waited in vain for Mark Halpern to establish the salient features of human thought, of which he declares robots not capable. Underlying his reasoning is the idea of our self-awa