You are on page 1of 123

()

,
2012

. (IDFI)
,
, (IDFI)
.


() .
,
.

()
, -
,

(, , , , ),

, , ,
, , /
,
- , ,
.

- .

. .
. - ,
, . .

:
()
:
( )
()
()
(IDFI)

, .
, .

-------------------------------------------------- 4
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ 9
: -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 15
- ----------------------------------------- 15
------------------------------ 28
---------------------------- 58
- .
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 83
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 111


()
(IDFI)
.

72 192

2010 (100 )
http://www2.unpan.org/egovkb/global_reports/12report.htm
2012

-
.
,

:
http://www.unpan.org/Regions/AsiaPacific/PublicAdministrationNews/tabid/115/mctl/ArticleView/Mod
uleId/1467/articleId/31880/Default.aspx

2012


-,
-
. IDFI-
-.
-
. IDFI-
,

http://www.idfi.ge/?cat=monitoring_method_1&lang=ka .

.
- . ,
-

.


, (); ;
;

, .

,
.
, ,
- ,
.
,
-
,
IDFI

.

IDFI-
(
) .
2011 .

OGP- .
OGP-

. IDFI-
-

IDFI-

.
,

()

.
IDFI-,
OGP- .
2012
, .
OGP- ,

, IDFI- OGP-
.
,
OGP- ,

.
, -

IDFI-

()



.
( III-
)
2012 ( III -
),

. IDFI

.
6

, , :
4. 27- :
) :
)
,
, ;;
) ;
) :
) -

.


:
36- :
36.


.
-
. ,
.
:
37- :
-2 -3 -4 :
3.
.
4.
.

2013
1
7

218- -4 :
4. 2013 1 ( )
28- -2 37- -4
().

2013 1 .
,
, ,
.

( )

2011 (
)
() ( ), 2010

"

-)

.
:
;
;

;

.

(2011-2012) 104
-.
: (3 -,
.. ), (21 -, ..
), (60
-,

-), (8 -),

(3

-),

(2 -),
(2 -), (5 - , ,

,
).

2 2

21

8
3
3

(..
)
-

60

(.

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Chapter%20IV%20geo.pdf),


-
, 154 .
,
- ,

- - ,
121 (. -
http://www.idfi.ge/?cat=monitoring_method_1&lang=ka).

: http://www.unpan.org/egovkb/global_reports/08report.htm
10

, ,
.
,
.
,

, -
.

(.

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Government%20of%20Georgia.pdf).

,
3 000 .
, , :
, .
- .
:
.

-
.

11


- http://www.idfi.ge/?cat=monitoring_2011_charts&lang=ka

-
-
-
.
,
III (
)
-



,
,
.

- ,
-
.

12


( .
, / .. )
-.
,
,

- .
, -
, .
,
. (
)
.

. ,
:


, -

;

, -

;
- , -

13

;

,

-
-


;
-
,
,

- -
,

, ,

;
-

,
,
;

,
-
,
. ,


,
..
14

112

,
-
(-
, -
..).

104

,
/.
.

www.police.ge

03 , 2011

31.67%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/MIA%20Mon
itoring%202011.pdf

www.gbg.gov.ge

06 , 2011

27.7%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Border%20P
olice%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.policeacademy.ge

07 , 2011

22.24%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Academy%20
of%20the%20MIA%20Monitoring%202011.pdf

www.spd.ge

09 , 2011

26%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Security%20P
olice%20Department%20Monitoring%202011.pdf

13 , 2011

15.14%

http://saagento.security.
gov.ge

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Service%20A
gency%20MIA.pdf

www.mod.gov.ge

14 , 2011

28.14%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/MOD%20%20Monitoring%202011.pdf

15

www.cadet.mod.gov.ge

17 , 2011

24.23%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/cadets%20m
onitoring%202011.pdf

www.heritagesites.ge

21 , 2011

17%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/heritage.pdf

www.folk.ge

22 , 2011

28.63%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Folk%20cent
er.pdf

www.gnfc.ge

24 , 2011

23.8%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/cinema%20c
enter%20LEPL.pdf

www.opera.ge

28 , 2011

21.3%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/opera%20mo
nitoring%202011.pdf

www.rustavelitheatre.ge

29 , 2011

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/rustaveli%20
theater%20monitoring%202011.pdf

10

11

12

26.80%

13

www.gpb.ge

29 , 2011

21.7%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/GPB%20moni
toring%202011.pdf

www.moe.gov.ge

04 , 2011

33.1%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/MO%20Envir
onment%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.dpa.gov.ge

06 , 2011

25.28%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Agency%20of
%20Protected%20Areas%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.nea.gov.ge

08 , 2011

20%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Environment
%20agency%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.mrdi.gov.ge

12 , 2011

26.28%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Regional%20
Development%20&%20Infrastructure%20Monitoring
%202011.pdf

14

15

16

17

16

18

www.mdf.ge

14 , 2011

24.16%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Municipal%2
0Development%20Fund%20Monitoring%202011.pdf

www.georoad.ge

19 , 2011

25.2%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Roads%20%2
0Department%20%20Monitoring%202011(1).pdf

www.lsg.gov.ge

01 , 2011

24.15%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Center%20fo
r%20Effective%20Governance%20Monitoring%2020
11.pdf

www.csb.gov.ge

05 , 2011

30.67%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Civil%20Servi
ce%20Bureau%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.moa.gov.ge

09 , 2011

22%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Agriculture%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.samtrest.gov.ge

11 , 2011

26.75%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/samtrest%20
monitoring%202011.pdf

www.nfa.gov.ge

15 , 2011

31.3%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/National%20
Food%20Agency%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.naec.ge

17 , 2011

32.6%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/National%20
Examination%20Center%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.esida.ge

19 , 2011

28.41%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Esida%20mo
nitoring%202011.pdf

www.nea.ge

22 , 2011

25.67%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/nea%20moni
toring%202011.pdf


19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

17

28

www.tsu.edu.ge

25 , 2011

34.31%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/tsu%20monit
oring%202011.pdf

www.mes.gov.ge

25 , 2011

28.78%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Education%20and%20Science%20monitoring%
202011.pdf

http://mandaturi.gov.ge

31 , 2011

24.36%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/mandaturi%2
0monitoring%202011.pdf

www.mfa.gov.ge

30 ,2011

31.87%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Foreign%20Affairs%20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.rustaveli.org.ge

02 ,

25.8%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Rustaveli%20
fund%20monitoring%202011.pdf

26.63%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/TPDC%20Mo
nitoring%202011.pdf

33.51%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20sport%20monitoring%202011.pdf

17.90%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Academy%20
of%20science%20monitoring%202011.pdf

32.65%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/legalaid%20
monitoring%202011.pdf

29

30

31

32

2011


33

www.tpdc.ge

02 ,
2011


34

www.msy.gov.ge

07 ,
2011


35

www.science.org.ge


36

07 ,
2011

www.legalaid.ge

08 ,
2011

18

37

www.mra.gov.ge

09 ,

27.93%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20refugees%20monitoring%202011.pdf

24.37%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Probation%2
0center%20monitoring%202011.pdf

31.94%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Corrections%20and%20Legal%20Assistance%2
0monitoring%202011.pdf

23.18%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Probation%2
0Agency%20monitoring%202011.pdf

23.78%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/ema_gov_ge
%20monitoring%202011.pdf

28.54%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Turism%20ag
ency%20monitoring%202011.pdf

27.35%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20enenergy%20monitoring%202011.pdf

24.70%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Accreditation
%20Center%20monitoring%202011.pdf

2011

38

www.pptc.gov.ge

13 ,
2011


39

www.mcla.gov.ge

16 ,
2011

40

www.probation.ge

16 ,
2011

41

www.ema.gov.ge

42

2011

www.gnta.ge


43

20 ,

22 ,
2011

www.minenergy.gov.ge

26 ,
2011

44

www.gac.gov.ge

27 ,
2011

19

45

www.him.ge

29 ,

29.63%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/mediaton%2
0service%20monitoring%202011.pdf

16.42%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/antipfund%2
0monitoring%202011.pdf

24.62%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/economy_go
v_ge%20monitoring%202011.pdf

26.12%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Gnims%20M
onitoring%20NEW%202011.pdf

17.85%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/sakvarelidze
%20monitoring%202011.pdf

34.38%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Health%20monitoring%202011.pdf

22.90%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Investigation
%20service%20monitoring%202011.pdf

2011


46

www.atipfund.gov.ge

()

03,
2011


47

www.economy.gov.ge

03 ,
2011

48

www.geostm.ge

04 ,
2011

49

www.ncdc.ge

06 ,
2011


50

www.moh.gov.ge

18 ,
2011

51

www.is.ge

26 ,
2011

20

52

www.mofacademy.ge

26 ,

29.38%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/mofacademy
%20monitoring%202011.pdf

25.91%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Ministry%20
of%20Culture%20monitoring%202011.pdf

25.42%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/fas_ge.pdf

29.76%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/diaspora%20
monitoring%202011.pdf

34.98%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/rs_ge%20mo
nitoring%202012.pdf

31.19%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/seragency%2
0monitoring%202011.pdf

26.45%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/treasury.pdf

7.97%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/rama_moh_
%20monitoring%202011.pdf

27.5%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/State%20Car
e%20Agency.pdf

2011

53

www.mcs.gov.ge

28 ,
2011

54

www.fas.ge

28 ,
2011

55

www.diaspora.gov.ge

01 ,
2011

56

www.rs.ge

57

02 ,
2011

https://seragency.gov.ge

07 ,
2011

58

www.treasury.ge

10 ,
2011


59

www.rama.moh.gov.ge

16 ,
2011

60

www.deoagency.ge

16 ,
2011

21

61

www.va.gov.ge

18 ,
2011

1.13%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/veterans%20
department%20monitoring%202011.pdf

-
, -
,
,
.

62

www. tcj.gov.ge

63

18 ,

23.95%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Training%20
Center%20of%20Justice.pdf

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Legislative%2
0Herald%20of%20Georgia.pdf

2011

www.matsne.gov.ge

21 ,
2011


.
:

47.18%

-

,

,

,


.

64

www.constcentre.gov.ge

25 ,

12.01%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Constitutiona
lism%20Research%20and%20Support%20Regional%
20Center.pdf

22.91%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/The%20Natio
nal%20Archives%20of%20Georgia.pdf

28.2%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/NOTARY.pdf

37.18%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/napr_gov_ge
.pdf

2011

65

www.archives.gov.ge

25 ,
2011

66

www.notary.ge

28 ,
2011

67

www.napr.gov.ge

02 ,
2011

22

68

www.nbe.gov.ge

69

07 ,

43.99%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/NBE_gov_ge.
pdf

20.04%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/zspa_ge%20
monitoring%202011.pdf

28.47%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/cra_gov_ge.p
df

26.28%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/GCCI.pdf

36.03%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/procurement
%20agency%20monitoring%202011.pdf

27,02%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Reintegratio
n.pdf

2011

www.zspa.ge

09 ,
2011

70

www.cra.gov.ge

71

2011

www.gcci.ge

72

14 ,

19 ,
2011

www.procurement.gov.g
e

22 ,

www.smr.gov.ge

27 ,

2011

73

2011

74

www.dea.gov.ge

03 , 2012

25.28%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/exchange.pdf

www.eu-nato.gov.ge

04 , 2012

24.59%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/eu_nato.pdf

75

23

76

www.meca.gov.ge

05 , 2012

27.98%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/apkhazia.pdf

www.investingeorgia.org

08 , 2012

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Investingeorg
ia.pdf

77

78

52.67%

www.moecs.ge

10 , 2012

31.03%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/ajara.pdf

www.justice.gov.ge

13 , 2012

37.50%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/justice_gov_
ge.pdf

www.mof.ge

19 , 2012

38.07%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/finance.pdf

www.mofea.ge

24 , 2012

23.77%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/finance%20a
nd%20economy.pdf

www.moa.ge

26 , 2012

30.94%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/agriculture.p
df

79

80

81

82

24

83

www.forencis.ge

01,

29.77%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/samkharauli.
pdf

34.19%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/apkhazia%28
1%29.pdf

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/ajaratv_ge.p
df

2012

84

www.abkhazia.gov.ge

02 ,
2012

85

www.ajaratv.ge

03 ,
2012


.
:

34.76%

-

,

.

86

www.geostat.ge

87

08 ,

34.1%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/renewed%20
statistics.pdf

23.33%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/ajara%20arch
ives%20.pdf

37.38%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/kontrolis%20
palata.pdf

31.845%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Government
%20of%20Georgia.pdf

26.65%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/gnerc%20mo
nitoring%202012.pdf

2012

www.archivesachara.gov.ge

09 ,

www.control.ge

10 ,

2012

88

2012
89

www.government.gov.ge

90

14 ,
2012

www.gnerc.org

17 ,
2012

25

91

www.sakpatenti.org.ge

21 ,

28.06%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/sakpatenti%2
0monitoring%202012.pdf

30.215%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Government
%20of%20Ajara.pdf

21.12%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/fms%20moni
toring%202012.pdf

29.815%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Communicati
ons%20Commision.pdf

41.135%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/parliament%
20monitoring%202012.pdf

2012


92

www.ajara.gov.ge

22 ,
2012

93

www.fms.gov.ge

23 ,
2012

94

www.gncc.ge

95

2012

www.parliament.ge

96

27 ,

29 ,
2012

www.electionreforms.ge

3 , 2012

23.035%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/electionrefor
ms%20monitoring%202012.pdf

www.cec.gov.ge

9 , 2012

37.53%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/cec_gov_ge%
20monitoring%202011.pdf

www.molhs.gov.ge

15 , 2012

19.135%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/mohls_ge%2
0monitoring%202011.pdf

www.tbilisi.gov.ge

15 , 2012

27.43%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/tbilisi_gov_g
e%20monitoring%202012.pdf

www.ombudsman.ge

23 , 2012

29.845%

97

98

99

100

26

101

www.businessombudsma
n.ge

26 , 2012

27 , 2012

36.155%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/nbg_gov_ge
%20monitoring%202012.pdf

02 , 2012

32.93%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/president_go
v_ge%20monitoring%202011.pdf

34.07%

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/ssa_gov_ge%
20monitoring%202012.pdf

29.57%

102

www.nbg.gov.ge

103

www.president.gov.ge

104

www.ssa.gov.ge

06 , 2012

11

11
10

9
7
6
4

2
1

4
3

1
0

1
0

1 1
0

,
, ,

27

,
.

.
, 104 -
,
, - -
. .
,
:

40%- ,
- 57.7 %-.

28

- www.nbe.gov.ge -
(40.03%) (43.99%) - IDFI-

- www.procurement.gov.ge . (57.7%) - IDFI-

29

, , :
-
13.91%-, - 39.7 %
, -
,
- 26.85%-.

57,7%

43,99%

40,03%
39,797%

26,854%
13,918%

,

-

, - ,
,
,

- .
, .

. ,

30

( , ,

-,

..)


. ,
- - (
- 17.25%). ,

, ,
,
-
.
, - , ,

-,
.

31

.
17,256%

41,406%

29,331%
16,165%

28,233%

40,3%

14,583%

49,583%

32,083%
12,989%
26,074%
12,81%
27,128%
11,07%
25,208%
7,779%
18,941%

39,171%

41,447%

39,345%

30,104%

,
(5 - - ,
,

. ,

)
-
, ,
- 104
-2 , (33.4%),
(41.13%) .

32

- www.parliament.ge -
-2 - IDFI- .

33

-
-

40,03%

47,95%
43,99%

()

33,4%

22,22%

21,54%


( )

( )

53,52%

37,53%
19,7%

53,92%

38,07%

48,87%
41,135%

55,06%

37,38%
17,93%
27,43%

36,93%

17,05%
29,845%
16,95%
29,815%

42,64%

42,68%

14,28%

51,58%

32,93%
14,03%

54,35%

34,19%
13,68%
29,765%
11,04%
27,725%

45,85%

44,41%

34


(, , -,
..),
. , , -
- (
).

-
. ,
- .
- - ,
, ,

0,4
. , ,

-
-

,
.

35

43,449% 45,61%
37,078%

40,543%
36,875% 38,96%

37,29%

40,746%

38,312% 39,285%

28,039% 30,122% 29,723%


25,135% 26,137% 26,69%
19%

32,366% 34,108%
24,948% 25,769%

16,794%
13,936%

13,396% 13,313%

24,568% 24,688%
21,049%

12,837%

12,605%

10,936%

10,824%

10,09%

9,733%

21,664%

9,22%

, , ,

() - ,

.
- ,

-.
36

40,38%

40,67%
33,74%

31,945%

23,51%

33,52%

32,65%

24,63%

24,375%

23,185%

15,01%
12,85%

37



53,37%
47,95%

51,29%

43,99%
37,505%
40,03%

37,58%

37,18%

39,48%

33,63%
28,475%

21,64%

47,18%

41,96%

38,6%

28,2%

23,07%

22,915%
19,37%

25,285%

23,955%

17,8%

23,59%

12,2%
8,61%

8,43%
0%

38

53,92%

53,83%
49,7%

45,31%
38,07%

40,84%

38,24%

34,98%
29,38%

37,43%

30,845%
25,425%

22,22%

26,455%
22,905%

16,13%
13,45%

12,69%

12,61%

12,07%
8,38%

39

53,42%
41,98%

41,52%
39,18%

42,95%
39,09%

34,2%

34,31%

41,29%

28,78%
27,1%
15,58%

25,8%

26,63%

22,26%

25,675%

17,905%

17,4%
14,08%

13,88%

31,33%

32,6%

28,415%

13,55%

20%
12,26%

24,36%
18,4%

11,78%

12,015%
8,67%

7,43%
5,63%

40

44,61%

40,78%
31,49%

33,095%
25,28%

20,035%

21,58%
9,78%

8,58%

35,36%

44,14%

42,13%

31,3%

22,02%

8,68%

26,75%
18,46%
11,37%



""

41

40%
26,28%

12,56%

24,16%
15,11%

39,31%

36,64%

33,21%

25,2%

24,15%

13,76%
8,99%

42

.
52,67%

46,65%
33,07%
24,62%

33,18%

23,78%

39,63%

26,125%

28,54%
24,705%

16,17%

41,68%

38,34%

26,28%

26,335%

14,38%
12,62%

11,43%

11,07%

10,88%

0%

-
-

43

48,53%
44,41%
31,67%

22,24%
14,81%

42,05%

32,35%

12,13%

27,725%

26,06%

24,22%
15,145%

11,04%

10,07%
6,07%

44

43,74%
34,83%
28,14%
21,235%
12,54%
7,64%

45

51,71% 51,96%
45,92%

44,27%

34,385% 34,07%
29,635%
17,06%

16,18%

26,67%

27,5%

17,85%
13,35%

10,73%

9,03%

24,38%

16,42%
8,46%

14,02%
7,97%
1,92%

0%
0,565%
1,13%

46

45,18%
35,32%

25,91%

34,89%

23,8%

37,63%
28,63%

24,83%

16,97%

16,5%
12,71%

26,8%
21,275%
13,4%

12,08%
9,11%
4,92%

0%

47

-

-,
- - 31.08%,
- 15.52% . - 46.64% ,
-
- 24.14%, - 13.07%-
. - 35.21% . ,
,
- ,
- .

..

46,63%

30,215%

43,16%
32,73%

31,035%
19,77%

13,8%

18,91%

19,135%

23,33%

34,23%

34,76%

23,77%

18,5%

17,38%
13,93%

13,31%

0%
..

48

..

54,35%
38,94%
34,19%
27,98%

14,03%

17,02%

49


, 104 , .
(. ) -

,
,

.

- .
, -
-
. , 104
-,
,
. , ,
, ,
-,
2 .

..

-
, . ..
- - .
- ,
- .
,
,
,
- .

-, -
.
,
- ,
50

-
.

-





















-




-
,



-


-









,











,


37,18%
36,155%
36,035%
34,98%
34,31%
34,1%
34,07%
32,65%
32,6%
31,3%
30,845%
30,67%
29,77%
29,635%
29,38%
28,63%
28,54%
28,475%
28,415%
28,2%
28,06%
27,5%
26,75%
26,63%
26,335%
26,28%
26,125%
26,06%
25,8%
25,675%
25,425%
25,285%
25,28%
24,705%
24,375%
24,36%
24,16%
24,15%
23,955%
23,8%
23,78%
23,59%
23,185%
23,035%
22,915%
22,24%
21,675%
21,275%
21,235%
21,12%
20,035%
20%
17,905%
17,85%
16,97%
16,42%
15,145%
13,4%
12,015%

43,99%

51

-











-















,
-







-
-





.





,
,








0%
0%
0%

27,79%
27,1%
24,63%
24,14%
23,07%
22,84%
19,37%
18,46%
17,8%
17,4%
16,5%
16,18%
16,13%
15,11%
15,01%
14,38%
14,37%
14,08%
13,88%
13,55%
13,45%
13,35%
12,85%
12,71%
12,69%
12,62%
12,62%
12,61%
12,26%
12,2%
12,13%
12,08%
11,78%
11,43%
11,37%
11,07%
10,88%
10,73%
10,07%
9,85%
9,78%
9,11%
9,03%
8,99%
8,97%
8,67%
8,61%
8,58%
8,46%
8,43%
8,43%
7,64%
7,43%
6,079%
5,639%
4,92%

40,03%

52

- .





















-





,
-





-
-
,



















,


57,7%
53,83%
53,42%
52,67%
51,96%
51,29%
49,7%
48,72%
48,17%
47,95%
47,18%
45,92%
45,65%
45,31%
45,18%
44,27%
44,14%
42,95%
42,13%
42,05%
41,96%
41,68%
41,52%
41,29%
40,78%
40,67%
40,41%
39,63%
39,62%
39,48%
39,31%
39,18%
39,09%
38,6%
38,34%
38,24%
37,64%
37,63%
37,58%
36,7%
34,89%
34,83%
34,2%
33,74%
33,63%
33,52%
33,5%
33,27%
33,21%
33,18%
32,35%
31,49%
31,33%

26,8%
26,67%
24,83%
24,38%
24,22%
22,26%
18,4%

53

23,51%

22,22%

22,13%
21,64%
21,58%
20,51%
27,935%

35,36%

18,92%

48,1%

33,51%
18,91%

43,16%

31,035%
18,5%
19,77%
19,135%

17,77%

44,11%

30,94%
17,06%

51,71%

34,385%
17,02%

38,94%

27,98%
16,5%

35,32%

25,91%
16,17%

33,07%

24,62%
15,58%

41,98%

28,78%
14,81%

44,61%

33,095%

53,37%

37,505%

41,61%

31,87%

53,92%

38,07%

40,38%

19,135

48,53%

31,67%
13,31%
23,77%
12,56%
26,28%

34,23%
40%

12,54%

43,74%

28,14%
12,45%

42,25%

27,35%
8,68%
22,02%

35,36%

54

13,93%

32,73%
23,33%
13,76%
36,64%

25,2%
12,07%
40,84%

26,455%
11,04%
44,41%

27,725%
8,38%
37,43%

22,905%
1,92%
14,02%

7,97%
1,13%
0%
0,565%
0%

34,76%
17,38%

55

15,92%

47,77%
31,845%

14,03%

54,35%
34,19%

13,8%

30,215%

46,63%

56

13,68%

45,85%
29,765%

12,45%
36,74%
24,595%

12,3%

41,75%
27,025%

57


()

,
-
,
154 (.
- http://www.idfi.ge/?cat=monitoring_method_1&lang=ka). ,
,
,
,

.

,
.
,
, -
.
, , :

, .:
, , ,
, , -
..

22

/
/

58

, .:
, ( ),

, ,
,
..

, .:
, , , ;

(..

..

, .:
,
, ,
, ,
,
, ..

, .:
(,
);

),

,
,
- ..

,
,

, .:
;
;
, / , -,
-, -,
;

59

,
(, , ) ..

, .: ,

, ..

, .:
,

,
..

()

, .:

( );
;
;

,
,
( ) ..


, ,
, - . , -,
, - / ,
- ,

-
60

, -
,
-
, .. .
(

87

http://www.idfi.ge/uploadedFiles/files/Chapter%20IV%20geo.pdf).

104 -
,

(
57.5%),

34.42%


( 12.82%
), - 33.22% .

68,14%, , ,

- 47,61% .
- 29,2%,

, , ,
- 38,23% .
,
,
, -

.

61

-

57,500%

0,6

47,606%

0,5
0,4

38,232%
31,446%

0,3

25,221%
0,2
0,1

18,364%

15,721%

14,038%

12,821%

62

68,137%

49,378%

34,420%

29,198%

32,104%

38,428%

,

44,002%
()

29,466%

33,220%

63

,
-
47,61% ,
- 68,14%.

,
, ,
, .
,

- .

, , -
, -
,

- ,

, -
, , , /
,

.
-,

.

:
- - www.legalaid.ge

64

104 -, 95

, ,
- 43%-, - 52%-. 5
.



50 - 100 %-

5%
43%


0 - 50 %-

52%

80,95%

72,03%

80%

88,91%

77,27%

86,76%

76,19%

75%


72,22%

75,12%

65

-
-
31,45% ,
- 49,38%.

,
,
-
.
, ,
. , ,
(. ,
, ..) -
.

:
- - www.parliament.ge

66

104 -, 85

, ,
- 17%-, - 68%-. 15
.

/
15%

17%

50-100 %-

0-50 %-

68%

83,33%

48,5%

76,92%

38,05%

75%

61%

66,67%

65%

66,67%

47,54%

67

,
- 57,50% ,
- 34,42%.

,
-
, . ,

- .
,

, -
.

: - www.cec.gov.ge

68

104 -, 95

, ,
- 72%-, - 23%-.
- 5
.



50-100 %-

5%

23%

72%


0-50 %-

100%

56,5%

100%

50,1%


80%

59,38%

80%

54,5%

80%

46,13

69

-
-
38,23% ,
- 29,2%.

,


-
.
,
/ ,
, ,
.

,

- . , , , -
.

:
- - www.cec.gov.ge

70

104 -, 95

, ,
- 29%-, - 66%-.
- 5
.

-
77,78

29,4%


71,43

56,73%

71,43

47,1%

70,37

36,45%


69,23

45,11%


5%

29%


50-100% -


0-50% -

66%

71

-
-
25,22% ,
32,1% .

:
- - www.parliament.ge

, ,
-

- ,

,
- , ,
,

( );
,

,
, ,
,

.. ,
72

/
/

104 -, 88

, ,
- 5%-, - 83%-.
- 12
.

/
5%
12%

83%

50-100 %

50-100 %

100%

47,47%

72%

30,81%

63,64%

43,5%

56,52%

32,85%

52,17%

45,5%

73

-
-
18,36% ,
- 38,43%.

, -
,
-

.
( , . )

.
, ,
, ,
, ., ,

-.
, ..
FoI (Freedom of Information) (-)
-, , ,
:

,/

( ) , ;

, , ,
,

74

, , ,
..);


49-
;

:
- -
- www.nbe.gov.ge

104 -, 93

, ,
75

- 4%-, - 89%-.
- 7
.


50-100 % -

7%
4%


0-50 % -
89%

65,38%

73,32%

61,54%

36,06%

57,69%

42,9%

53,85%

24,86%


46,15%

23,79%

76

-
-
15,72% ,
- 44%.

, -
/ ,

.

(..

(/

).

, , (..
( ,
) ) , .

:
- - www.mdf.ge

77

104 -, 41

, ,
- 10%-, 31%-. - 59

-
, .

,
,

10%
31%
59%

50-100 %
-

0-50 %


100%
100%

69,6%
33%


80%

42,13%

75%

26,83%

60%

70,83

78

-
-
14,04% ,

- 29,47% .

, , -

,
-

. ,

,
,
,
. -. ,
, -
, ,

- ( , ..).

:
- - www.mfa.gov.ge

79

104 -, 32

, ,
- 11%-, - 21%-.
- 68

, .

11%
21%
68%

50-100 %

0-50 %

100%

26%

80%

80%

20%

80%

18%

60%

100%

33,75%

80

()

- 12,82%
,
- 33,22%.

, , -
,
,

. , ,

/ ),

/ ,
,
, ,

, -
.

,
- ,
, .

:
. - - www.tbilisi.gov.ge

81

104 -, 49

, ,
- 3%-,
- 46%-.

- 51


-
.

50-100 %

3%

51%

46%

0-50 % -

75%

49,58

75%

27,33

16%

57,14%

50%

50%

55%
16,25%

82

-
.

,
-
-
. .

121

(.

http://www.idfi.ge/?cat=monitoring_method_2&lang=ka

). ,

, ,
,
- .
.

,
.
-
.
, , :

,
: - , ,

/ ..

83

,
: -
,
,
.

,
, , ,
- HTML ,

..

/
.
.

84

,
: - , ,
,
, , RSS -
-
,

,
(XML , JSON ) .

,
: WAP ,

,
: - Opera,
Internet Explorer, Firefox, Chrome Safari, -

, ,
, () ..

85

,
: - ,
Facebook- , ,
Facebook-,
-
/
-.

,
: - -

, ,
-, -
,

..

10

,
: ,

(, , , ) ,
-, .

(mail)

..
86

11

,
: - ,
- ,
,
/ , .

12

,
: HTTPS , CAPTCHA
, GET POST- .

13

(SEO),

, - Favicon- ,

-,

-,
(XLS, XML ), -
gov.ge ..

87


80

70,99%

70
60

58,93%

51,17%

50

41,68%

37,69%

40
30

29,57%

39,82%
28,02%

20

25,32%

10
0

0,64%

10,58% 11,28%
0,38%

88

- .

, , - -
, ,

.

-,
. - ,
, -
, . .
, -
. -
,
. - ,
.

2%

50 - 100 %

12%

0 - 50 %-

86%

89

- ,
-.
-, ,

, . .
,
, :

- -:
.

90

,
. .
-
, :

- -

11%

31%

50 - 100 %
0 - 50 %-

58%

91

-
, ,
, , .
URL- , URL - -
,
- -
- - URL : www.site.gov.ge/news
: www.site.gov.ge/?cur_category=1
- URL :

- -, URL-

92

- , URL- .

,
,

.
,
, . .


1%

50 - 100 %

43%
56%

0 - 50 %-

93

,
.

,
.

- ,
, .

94

- ,
.

21%

50 - 100 %-

7%

0 - 50 %-

72%

95

,
.
, ,
, ,
.

. - ,
, .

-
1%
22%

77%

50 - 100 %-

0 - 50 %-

96

WAP

(Wireless

Application

Protocol)

, ,
- ,
, ,
.
- -

Sub

Domain-

WAP .
(PDA, Android ..). -
.
, , -
SMS .

- -
SMS .

97

WAP


(wap)
2%
0%
0 - 50 %-

98%

98

-
(Server-side programming)
(Client-side programming) ,
-
() .
Client Side ,
-
. -
() , .

-
-, .

99

- ,
.


1%
50 - 100 %-

23%

76%

0 - 50 %-

100


. , ,
Facebook, Twitter, Flickr -
. -
. ,
-
.
, - ,
, ,

- Facebook- Twitter-.

22%

26%

50 - 100 %-

0 - 50 %-

52%

101

-
.
- - .

- , , .
-, -
, -
, .


2%
50 - 100 %-

44%
54%
0 - 50 %-

102

10


.
,
(, , , ) , (
)
-,
, / - .
,

-.

-.


2%
50 - 100 %-

23%

75%

0 - 50 %-

103

11

-
. , :
,
- - .
- /
-.



2%
0%
0 - 50 %-

98%

104

12

- ,

,

,
.
- , XSS, Sql injection, RFI Bugs
, - ,
. , -
HTTPS (SSL) , -
.

40%

50 - 100 %-

15%

45%

0 - 50 %-

105

13

, :
,
. ,
-
.
, - , ,
.
, 2 3
. , , :

- -

106

-
-

- gov.ge
, , -
. ,
-.
Favicon- () -,
,
-.
,
- ,
.

107

-
-, Favicon

108

- ,
-, Favicon- .

109


1%
13%

50 - 100 %-

0 - 50 %-

86%

110



, ,
2010 ( - "
( -) )

. ,
2011 (
() )
- .
2010 48
( ,
) , 2011
46 - ,
, 2011 .
, -

/.

.
,

7,5 , ..

5,6 ,
- 8,5 .
, 2011-2012

- .

111



2010-2011

28,1%

2011-1012

29,97%
27,19%
24,35%

20,58%

18,75%

(46)

(15)

- (31)

,
-
,

21,2 . , ,
- 15,75
.
, , ,
- .

, .

112

10
21,18%

20,44%

19,28% 18,70%
15,75% 15,27%

14,47%

13,57% 13,16%
11,24%

113


2011-2012

2010-2011

31,8
33,095
31,16
28,78
30,68









,








,


29,635

20,03

19,9

19,44

25,8
32,6
26,28

19,09
20,035
18,3

17,18

16,49

..

16,47

16,42

15,89

15,58

14,86

12,71
15,145

12,33

12,33

9,49
8,72
8,1
6,85

25,91

22,02
22,24
24,15
26,06
30,845
36,035
26,28

17,85
29,38

10,68

29,635

20,2

43,99

37,18
30,18
28,475
29,32
31,87
28,26
34,07
28,12
28,14
26,51
31,67
25,88
24,62
24,59
25,28
24,57
24,16
24,57
34,385
24,48
27,935
24,31
32,65
22,6
27,35
22,35
23,185
22,23
28,415
22,17
37,505
21,76
28,2
20,91
26,63
20,76
31,945
20,7
25,675
20,38
24,375
20,36

36,76
38,07

23,955
16,42
28,54
26,125

114



()
2011-2012 104
- , :

-
- 13.91%-,
- 39.7 %;

- ,

- 26.85%;

-
- ( - 17.25%);

(,
)

,
;

, -
()
- ,
;

,
-,
2 .

,
-, - ,
-
-;

-
,
115

.. -
, .
.. -
- ;

.
,

- ;


, -
:


( 47,6% 95% -)

( , ,
, ,
);


( 57,5% 95% -)
( , ,
, );


( 38,24% 95% -)
( ,

,
.. ).


, -
:


( 14,04% 41% -)

( ,
,
..);

116


( 14,04% 32% -)
( ,

,
,
..);


( 12,82% 49% -)
( (
);

( ) ..).

- ,
( 100%- 68,14%)

- ,

- ( 100%- 29,2%)

, -
,
- -
. . ,
,

- ,


. -

, 104

117

40%- , - 57.7 %, ,
-

, -

.
. ,


-

,
.
, ,
- , ,

, ,
,
-
.
,
,
-
, ,
,

..
/ - PR , -

. ,
,
,
- ,
, , -
,

- ..

118

- ,
,
,

.

:

-
;

-
.

.
,


.

,

,
.


.

119

Chart Title

.
40,03

1 .

4.

21,54

5.

21,64

9.

14,03

18.

34,07

16,18

21,58

24,63
11,78
23,51
22,13
15,92

18,46
18,91

26. ,

17,77

27.
28.

12,62

30.

13,8

44,61
51,58

32,65
40,67

53,42

31,945
31,87
31,845

40,38
41,61
47,77
48,53

31,3
31,035
30,94
30,845

12,69

29.

48,1

31,67

14,81

25.

51,96

33,095

32,6

22.

24.

40,41

32,93

14,28

21.,

23.

54,35

33,51

18,92

19.
20.

41,52

34,1

27,79

14.

51,71

34,31
34,19

17.

53,83

34,385
27,1

16.

57,7

34,98

17,06

15.

48,17

36,035

12.
13.

51,29

36,155

16,13

11. ,

55,06

37,18

14,37

10.

53,37

37,38

24,14

8.

53,52

37,505

23,07

7.

53,92

37,53

19,7

6.

48,87

38,07

22,22

3.

47,95

41,135

33,4

2.

43,99

44,14
43,16
44,11
49,7

30,67

48,72

30,215

31.

17,05

32.

16,95

46,63

29,845
29,815

42,64
42,68

120

34.

13,68

35.

13,35

36.

13,45

29,765

27,725

17,93

12,3

52.

11,37

16,5
17,4
12,26

64. -

12,61

68. -

39,18
40,84
52,67
40
41,68
39,63

26,06

10,07

63.

67.

37,92

26,63

26,125

12,62

62.

66.

42,13

26,65

26,28

10,88

61.

65.

41,75

26,28

12,56

59. ,
60.

42,25

26,335

57.
58. -

36,93

26,455

12,07

55.

44,27

27,43

26,75

14,08

54.

44,41

27,025

15,38

53.

35,36

27,35

12,45

51.

38,94

27,5

49.
50.

39,62

27,935

20,51

46. ,

43,74

27,98

17,02

10,73

38,6

28,06

16,5

48.

42,95

28,14

12,54

45.

37,58

28,2

17,8

44. -

45,65

28,415

42.

11,04

45,18

28,475

13,88

47.

41,98

28,54
19,37

43.

45,31

28,63

40.
41.

45,92

28,78

11,43

39.

45,85

29,38

12,08

38.

36,7

29,635

15,58

37.

56.

29,77

22,84

33.

25,8
25,675
25,425
25,285

8,61

42,05

25,91
35,32
34,2

39,09
38,24
41,96

25,28

9,78
13,76
11,07

40,78

25,2
24,705

36,64
38,34

121

70.

24,36

7,43

24,15

8,99

74.

23,59

94.
95.

9,03

96.

104.

16,42

8,46
6,07

15,145

5,639

31,33

26,67
34,76
24,83
24,38
24,22

13,4

31,49

16,97

9,11

98.

36,05

19,135
18,5
19,77
17,905
13,55
22,26
17,85
17,38

0,565
1,13
0

33,27

20

8,67

1,92

34,83

20,035

8,58

102.

37,63

20,57

5,09

100.

33,5

21,12

8,97

99. ,

35,36

21,235

7,64

93.

33,63

32,35

21,275

4,92

92.

37,64

21,675

9,85

91.

33,52

37,43

22,02

8,68

90.

32,73

22,24

12,13

89.

103.

22,905

8,38

88.

34,23

22,915

12,2

87.

101.

23,035

8,43

86.

33,18

47,18

23,185

12,85

81.

34,89

23,33

13,93

80.

85.

39,31
39,48

23,77

13,31

78.

84.

33,21

23,78

14,38

77.

83.

41,29

23,8

12,71

76.

82. ,

33,74

23,955

8,43

75.

36,74

24,16

15,11

73.

33,07

24,375

15,01

72.

97.

24,595

12,45

71.

79.

24,62

16,17

69.

26,8

12,015
18,4

7,97
14,02

122