Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 18

modelo de planilha para o mtodo de Hardy-Cross

soluo inicial

trecho
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

noi
1
2
2
4
5
4
7
8
5
3
6

nof
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
8
6
9

L (m)
700
990
600
600
500
600
620
480
500
500
450

i (mm)
400
300
300
200
150
250
150
150
150
250
200

r
108
620
376
2708
9160
913
11359
8794
9160
761
2031

anel

S|DH|

Q0 (m/s)
0.700
0.250

DH0 (m)
55.85
47.72

DH/Q
79.78
190.90

Qi (m/s)
0.700

DQ (m/s)

SDH (m)

SDH/Q

DQ (m/s)

iterao

DHi (m)
55.85

...

DH/Q
79.78

iterao final

Qi (m/s)
0.700

DHi (m)
55.85

DH/Q
79.78

... DQ (m/s)

SDH (m)

SDH/Q

...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...
...

SDH (m)

SDH/Q

...
...
...

mtodo de Hardy-Cross
soluo inicial

trecho
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

noi
1
2
2
4
5
4
7
8
5
3
6

nof
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
8
6
9

L (m)
700
990
600
600
500
600
620
480
500
500
450

i (mm)
400
300
300
200
150
250
150
150
150
250
200

r
108
620
376
2708
9160
913
11359
8794
9160
761
2031

anel

2 10 -5 -4 -3
4 9 -7 -6
5 11 -8 -9

1
2
3

Q0 (m/s)
0.194
0.018
0.149
0.040
0.017
0.090
0.058
0.037
0.000
0.000
0.000

DH0 (m)
5.20
0.37
11.10
7.02
4.88
10.62
58.57
19.74
0.00
0.00
0.00

DH/Q
26.80
20.40
74.52
175.54
286.94
117.97
1009.81
533.51
0.00
0.00
0.00

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.040
0.127
0.018
-0.005
0.090
0.058
0.037
0.000
0.022
0.000

DQ (m/s)
0.022

SDH (m)
-22.64
-62.16
-14.86
99.66

SDH/Q
557.39
1303.32
820.45

DQ (m/s)

S|DH|
n1
NA=30,00 m
Estimativa inicial
de vazes: ti,Qo

t1,194

n2: 27 L/s

n3: 18 L/s

DQ1

t3,149

t10,0

n5: 23 L/s

n4:
19 L/s

t4,40

t6,90

DQ2

n7:
32 L/s

t2,18

t7,58

t9,0
n8:
21 L/s

t5,17

n6:
17 L/s

DQ3

t11,0

t8,37

n9:
37 L/s

0.030

iterao

iterao

iterao

DHi (m)
5.20
1.60
8.27
1.61
-0.50
10.62
58.57
19.74
0.00
0.65
0.00

DH/Q
26.80
40.17
65.08
89.25
100.56
117.97
1009.81
533.51
0.00
29.63
0.00

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.040
0.127
0.048
-0.005
0.060
0.028
0.037
0.030
0.022
0.000

DHi (m)
5.20
1.60
8.27
9.86
-0.50
5.01
15.21
19.74
13.96
0.65
0.00

DH/Q
26.80
40.17
65.08
205.19
100.56
83.57
543.54
533.51
465.18
29.63
0.00

SDH (m)
-7.13
-67.58
-20.24
94.94

SDH/Q
324.69
1217.03
634.08

DQ (m/s)

SDH (m)
-15.38
3.60
-34.20
53.18

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m) SDH/Q DQ (m/s)


440.63
0.018
-18.38
551.44
1297.48
-7.31
1063.66
0.007
1099.26
-5.92
824.49
31.61

0.017

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.040
1.60
0.127
8.27
0.048
9.86
0.012
2.51
0.060
5.01
0.028
15.21
0.020
6.43
0.013
3.05
0.022
0.65
0.017
1.06

DH/Q
26.80
40.17
65.08
205.19
211.37
83.57
543.54
318.72
231.36
29.63
63.03

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.058
0.109
0.030
-0.006
0.060
0.028
0.020
0.013
0.040
0.017

iterao

iterao

DHi (m)
5.20
3.20
6.23
4.13
-0.74
5.01
15.21
6.43
3.05
1.97
1.06

DH/Q
26.80
55.12
57.14
137.63
120.98
83.57
543.54
318.72
231.36
49.32
63.03

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.058
3.20
0.109
6.23
0.037
6.11
-0.006
-0.74
0.053
3.97
0.021
8.87
0.020
6.43
0.020
6.75
0.040
1.97
0.017
1.06

SDH (m)
-4.45
-13.04
-9.17
26.66

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


420.18
-6.43
996.09
0.02
734.09
0.008
-12.87
19.33

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
55.12
57.14
164.73
120.98
75.11
424.29
318.72
333.23
49.32
63.03

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.058
3.20
0.109
6.23
0.037
6.11
0.002
0.11
0.053
3.97
0.021
8.87
0.012
2.41
0.012
2.54
0.040
1.97
0.025
2.23

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


447.28
0.010
-7.29
997.36
-4.19
835.96
-2.61
14.09

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
55.12
57.14
164.73
49.86
75.11
424.29
202.83
212.62
49.32
88.72

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.068
4.34
0.099
5.17
0.027
3.31
-0.008
-1.30
0.053
3.97
0.021
8.87
0.012
2.41
0.012
2.54
0.050
3.03
0.025
2.23

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


376.16
0.19
876.74
0.005
-6.99
554.02
-4.01
11.20

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
63.47
52.45
124.29
156.02
75.11
424.29
202.83
212.62
60.10
88.72

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.068
4.34
0.099
5.17
0.031
4.43
-0.008
-1.30
0.048
3.37
0.016
5.65
0.012
2.41
0.016
4.60
0.050
3.03
0.025
2.23

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


456.32
-0.92
836.30
0.00
660.19
0.005
-6.07
7.00

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
63.47
52.45
142.00
156.02
69.62
344.93
202.83
279.30
60.10
88.72

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.068
4.34
0.099
5.17
0.031
4.43
-0.004
-0.30
0.048
3.37
0.016
5.65
0.007
0.99
0.012
2.54
0.050
3.03
0.030
3.03

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


474.03
-1.92
835.85
-2.05
726.87
0.001
-0.81
4.78

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
63.47
52.45
142.00
80.07
69.62
344.93
134.99
212.72
60.10
102.09

10

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.068
4.34
0.099
5.17
0.031
4.43
-0.003
-0.19
0.048
3.37
0.016
5.65
0.007
0.80
0.011
2.23
0.050
3.03
0.030
3.19

DH/Q
26.80
63.47
52.45
142.00
64.95
69.62
344.93
121.96
200.15
60.10
104.50

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


398.09
0.003
-2.03
769.27
-2.37
529.87
-0.03
4.43

SDH/Q
382.96
756.70
491.56

iterao

11

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.071
4.69
0.096
4.89
0.028
3.70
-0.006
-0.67
0.048
3.37
0.016
5.65
0.007
0.80
0.011
2.23
0.053
3.36
0.030
3.19

DH/Q
26.80
65.72
51.15
130.84
115.39
69.62
344.93
121.96
200.15
62.98
104.50

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.071
4.69
0.096
4.89
0.031
4.26
-0.006
-0.67
0.046
3.09
0.014
4.31
0.007
0.80
0.013
3.13
0.053
3.36
0.030
3.19

DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


0.12
0.002
-3.09
-0.51
3.72

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


426.08
-0.44
745.54
0.00
542.00
0.001
-1.41
1.85

12

DH/Q
26.80
65.72
51.15
139.60
115.39
66.87
304.40
121.96
233.94
62.98
104.50

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.071
4.69
0.096
4.89
0.031
4.26
-0.004
-0.42
0.046
3.09
0.014
4.31
0.005
0.52
0.012
2.58
0.053
3.36
0.032
3.45

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


434.84
0.001
-0.70
744.80
-0.55
575.79
-0.07
1.32

13

DH/Q
26.80
65.72
51.15
139.60
92.68
66.87
304.40
100.57
214.11
62.98
108.34

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.072
0.095
0.030
-0.005
0.046
0.014
0.005
0.012
0.054
0.032

SDH/Q DQ (m/s)
412.13
724.98
0.001
515.71

iterao

14

iterao

DHi (m)
5.20
4.80
4.81
4.03
-0.59
3.09
4.31
0.52
2.58
3.46
3.45

DH/Q
26.80
66.44
50.73
136.03
108.51
66.87
304.40
100.57
214.11
63.90
108.34

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.072
4.80
0.095
4.81
0.030
4.18
-0.005
-0.59
0.046
3.01
0.014
3.98
0.005
0.52
0.013
2.82
0.054
3.46
0.032
3.45

SDH (m)
0.01
-0.78
-0.24
1.04

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


425.61
-0.14
721.41
0.00
531.55
0.000
-0.48
0.62

15

DH/Q
26.80
66.44
50.73
138.31
108.51
66.15
293.64
100.57
222.94
63.90
108.34

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.072
4.80
0.095
4.81
0.030
4.18
-0.005
-0.49
0.046
3.01
0.014
3.98
0.005
0.44
0.012
2.62
0.054
3.46
0.032
3.54

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


427.90
0.000
-0.23
721.04
-0.20
540.38
-0.01
0.44

16

DH/Q
26.80
66.44
50.73
138.31
100.26
66.15
293.64
92.60
215.71
63.90
109.74

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.83
0.094
4.78
0.030
4.10
-0.005
-0.55
0.046
3.01
0.014
3.98
0.005
0.44
0.012
2.62
0.055
3.50
0.032
3.54

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


419.65
0.00
713.80
0.000
-0.27
518.30
-0.07
0.34

17

DH/Q
26.80
66.67
50.60
137.16
105.36
66.15
293.64
92.60
215.71
64.20
109.74

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.83
0.094
4.78
0.030
4.16
-0.005
-0.55
0.045
2.99
0.013
3.87
0.005
0.44
0.012
2.70
0.055
3.50
0.032
3.54

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


423.99
-0.05
712.65
0.00
523.41
0.000
-0.15
0.20

18

DH/Q
26.80
66.67
50.60
137.96
105.36
65.89
289.85
92.60
218.80
64.20
109.74

iterao

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.83
0.094
4.78
0.030
4.16
-0.005
-0.52
0.045
2.99
0.013
3.87
0.005
0.41
0.012
2.64
0.055
3.50
0.032
3.57

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


424.79
0.000
-0.08
712.50
-0.06
526.50
0.00
0.14

19

DH/Q
26.80
66.67
50.60
137.96
102.74
65.89
289.85
90.04
216.50
64.20
110.18

iterao

20

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.85
0.094
4.77
0.030
4.13
-0.005
-0.54
0.045
2.99
0.013
3.87
0.005
0.41
0.012
2.64
0.055
3.51
0.032
3.57

DH/Q
26.80
66.75
50.55
137.56
104.51
65.89
289.85
90.04
216.50
64.30
110.18

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


422.16
0.00
710.20
0.000
-0.09
519.46
-0.02
0.11

SDH/Q
423.67
709.80
521.23

21 iteraes de Hardy-Cr

resultar erro mximo de


um anel...

12 iteraes de Hardy-Cr

resultar correo mxim


um anel...

iterao

21

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.85
0.094
4.77
0.030
4.15
-0.005
-0.54
0.045
2.98
0.013
3.84
0.005
0.41
0.012
2.67
0.055
3.51
0.032
3.57

DH/Q
26.80
66.75
50.55
137.82
104.51
65.81
288.62
90.04
217.51
64.30
110.18

DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


-0.02
0.00
0.000
-0.05
0.06

SDH/Q
423.93
709.75
522.24

iteraes de Hardy-Cross para

sultar erro mximo de 0.05 m em

iteraes de Hardy-Cross para

sultar correo mxima de 1 L/s em

mtodo de Hardy-Cross, variante fazendo a correo simultnea nos trs anis


soluo inicial

trecho
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

noi
1
2
2
4
5
4
7
8
5
3
6

nof
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
8
6
9

L (m)
700
990
600
600
500
600
620
480
500
500
450

i (mm)
400
300
300
200
150
250
150
150
150
250
200

r
108
620
376
2708
9160
913
11359
8794
9160
761
2031

anel
1
2
3

2 10 -5 -4 -3
4 9 -7 -6
5 11 -8 -9
S|DH|

Q0 (m/s)
0.194
0.018
0.149
0.040
0.017
0.090
0.058
0.037
0.000
0.000
0.000

DH0 (m)
5.20
0.37
11.10
7.02
4.88
10.62
58.57
19.74
0.00
0.00
0.00

DH/Q
26.80
20.40
74.52
175.54
286.94
117.97
1009.81
533.51
0.00
0.00
0.00

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.040
0.127
0.044
0.005
0.064
0.032
0.027
0.016
0.022
0.010

DQ (m/s)
0.022
0.026
0.010

SDH (m)
-22.64
-62.16
-14.86
99.66

SDH/Q
557.39
1303.32
820.45

DQ (m/s)
0.019
0.006
0.010

iterao

iterao

iterao

DHi (m)
5.20
1.60
8.27
8.32
0.48
5.69
19.74
11.18
4.36
0.65
0.39

DH/Q
26.80
40.17
65.08
189.73
98.63
88.55
612.64
410.84
272.39
29.63
39.80

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.059
0.108
0.031
-0.004
0.058
0.026
0.018
0.012
0.041
0.019

DHi (m)
5.20
3.29
6.14
4.34
-0.40
4.75
13.55
4.97
2.67
2.05
1.39

DH/Q
26.80
55.84
56.75
140.75
91.33
81.55
515.44
283.15
217.44
50.25
71.30

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.065
3.99
0.102
5.47
0.031
4.32
-0.005
-0.60
0.052
3.83
0.020
8.09
0.012
2.51
0.013
3.07
0.047
2.70
0.025
2.19

SDH (m)
-14.81
-12.75
-14.67
42.23

SDH/Q
423.24
1163.31
821.66

DQ (m/s)
0.006
0.006
0.005

SDH (m)
-4.73
-11.30
-6.66
22.69

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


394.92
0.003
-2.51
955.19
0.003
-4.54
663.22
0.003
-3.99
11.04

DH/Q
26.80
61.02
53.84
140.41
109.55
73.89
406.76
206.81
231.93
56.95
87.89

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.069
0.098
0.030
-0.005
0.049
0.017
0.009
0.013
0.051
0.028

SDH/Q DQ (m/s)
421.77
0.002
852.99
0.002
636.19
0.002

iterao

iterao

DHi (m)
5.20
4.36
5.16
4.23
-0.56
3.45
6.06
1.37
2.85
3.04
2.77

DH/Q
26.80
63.56
52.39
139.10
106.54
70.39
356.19
156.49
224.23
60.22
97.99

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.070
4.57
0.097
4.98
0.030
4.19
-0.005
-0.56
0.047
3.24
0.015
5.01
0.007
0.88
0.013
2.77
0.052
3.25
0.030
3.12

SDH (m)
-1.42
-2.43
-2.02
5.87

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


421.80
0.001
-0.79
789.90
0.001
-1.29
585.25
0.001
-1.09
3.17

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
65.00
51.57
138.48
105.87
68.35
326.38
127.67
221.25
62.06
103.45

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.071
4.70
0.096
4.89
0.030
4.17
-0.005
-0.55
0.046
3.12
0.014
4.47
0.006
0.65
0.012
2.72
0.053
3.37
0.031
3.32

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


422.96
0.001
-0.44
754.47
0.001
-0.71
558.24
0.001
-0.59
1.74

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
65.79
51.11
138.14
105.11
67.22
309.62
110.83
219.28
63.07
106.52

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.072
4.77
0.095
4.83
0.030
4.16
-0.005
-0.54
0.046
3.06
0.014
4.18
0.005
0.53
0.012
2.69
0.054
3.43
0.032
3.44

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


423.22
0.000
-0.25
734.26
0.000
-0.39
541.73
0.000
-0.32
0.96

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
66.23
50.85
137.96
104.70
66.58
300.12
101.24
218.24
63.64
108.23

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.072
4.80
0.095
4.80
0.030
4.15
-0.005
-0.54
0.046
3.02
0.014
4.02
0.005
0.47
0.012
2.67
0.054
3.47
0.032
3.50

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


423.38
0.000
-0.14
722.91
0.000
-0.22
532.41
0.000
-0.18
0.53

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
66.48
50.71
137.87
104.44
66.22
294.80
95.79
217.64
63.96
109.18

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.072
4.83
0.095
4.79
0.030
4.15
-0.005
-0.54
0.045
3.00
0.013
3.93
0.005
0.44
0.012
2.66
0.054
3.49
0.032
3.54

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


423.45
0.000
-0.08
716.53
0.000
-0.12
527.06
0.000
-0.10
0.30

iterao

DH/Q
26.80
66.61
50.63
137.81
104.30
66.02
291.81
92.73
217.31
64.13
109.71

10

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.84
0.094
4.78
0.030
4.14
-0.005
-0.54
0.045
2.99
0.013
3.88
0.005
0.42
0.012
2.66
0.055
3.50
0.032
3.56

DH/Q
26.80
66.69
50.58
137.78
104.22
65.91
290.14
91.00
217.13
64.23
110.01

SDH/Q DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


423.49
0.000
-0.04
712.96
0.000
-0.07
524.06
0.000
-0.06
0.16

SDH/Q
423.51
710.96
522.37

11 iteraes ou 33 corre

para resultar erro mxim


um anel...

ser que ocorreria semp

convergncia fazendo to
ao mesmo tempo ou foi

iterao

11

Qi (m/s) DHi (m)


0.194
5.20
0.073
4.84
0.094
4.77
0.030
4.14
-0.005
-0.54
0.045
2.98
0.013
3.85
0.005
0.41
0.012
2.66
0.055
3.51
0.032
3.57

DH/Q
26.80
66.73
50.56
137.77
104.18
65.85
289.21
90.04
217.03
64.29
110.18

DQ (m/s) SDH (m)


-0.02
-0.04
-0.03
0.09

SDH/Q
423.52
709.85
521.42

iteraes ou 33 correes de vazes

ra resultar erro mximo de 0.05 m em

r que ocorreria sempre essa

nvergncia fazendo todos os anis


mesmo tempo ou foi sorte?

utilizando o solver do Excel para resolver simultaneamente as correes dos trs anis
soluo inicial

trecho
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

noi
1
2
2
4
5
4
7
8
5
3
6

nof
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
8
6
9

L (m)
700
990
600
600
500
600
620
480
500
500
450

i (mm)
400
300
300
200
150
250
150
150
150
250
200

r
108
620
376
2708
9160
913
11359
8794
9160
761
2031

anel
1
2
3

2 10 -5 -4 -3
4 9 -7 -6
5 11 -8 -9
S|DH|

final

Q0 (m/s)
0.194
0.018
0.149
0.040
0.017
0.090
0.058
0.037
0.000
0.000
0.000

DH0 (m)
5.20
0.37
11.10
7.02
4.88
10.62
58.57
19.74
0.00
0.00
0.00

Qi (m/s)
0.194
0.073
0.094
0.030
-0.005
0.045
0.013
0.004
0.012
0.055
0.033

DHi (m)
5.20
4.85
4.77
4.14
-0.54
2.98
3.82
0.40
2.65
3.52
3.59

DQ (m/s)
0.055
0.045
0.033

SDH (m)
-22.64
-62.16
-14.86
99.66

DQ (m/s)

SDH (m)
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.00

mtodo matricial da linearizao - quem se habilita a preparar esse exemplo de aplicao?

trecho
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

noi
1
2
2
4
5
4
7
8
5
3
6

nof
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
8
6
9

L (m)
700
990
600
600
500
600
620
480
500
500
450

i (mm)
400
300
300
200
150
250
150
150
150
250
200

r
108
620
376
2708
9160
913
11359
8794
9160
761
2031

anel

2 10 -5 -4 -3
4 9 -7 -6
5 11 -8 -9

1
2
3

n1
NA=30,00 m
Estimativa inicial
de vazes: ti,Qo

t1,194

n2: 27 L/s

n3: 18 L/s

DQ1

t3,149

t10,0

n5: 23 L/s

n4:
19 L/s

t4,40

t6,90

DQ2

n7:
32 L/s

t2,18

t7,58

t9,0
n8:
21 L/s

t5,17

n6:
17 L/s

DQ3

t11,0

t8,37

n9:
37 L/s

Вам также может понравиться