Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 12

-

2010

2011

Finkelberg A. Parmenides Foundation of the Way of Truth// Oxford Studies In


Ancient Philosophy. 1988. N 6. P. 3967.
Furth M. Elements of Eleatic Ontology// Journal of the History of Philosophy.
1968. V. 6. 2. P. 111132.
Gomperz T. Greek Thinkers. A History of Ancient Philosophy/Transl. Laurie
Magnus/Vol. I. London: John Murray, Albemarle Street, W. 1920.
Mourelatos A. The route of Parmenides (originally published in 1970). Las Vegas:
Parmenides Publishing. 2008.
Nehamas . On Parmenides Three Ways of Inquiry// Deucalion. 1981. V. 33.
4. P. 97111.
Owen G.E.L. Eleatic Question// Logic, Science, and Dialectic. Collected Papers
in Greek Philosophy/Ed. M. Nussbaum. Cornell University Press. 1986.
Palmer J. Parmenides & Presocratic Philosophy. Oxford University Press. 2009.
Stokes M. One and Many in Presocratic Philosophy. Cambridge, 1971. P.
112127.
Tarn L. Parmenides. Princeton: Princeton University Press. 1965.

..


.
, 1, .
. :
, , , [1]
, [2] , [3]
, 2.

, 3 ,
( ).
.

. .
( )4.
. 348 358 . 6,
, 364 . (McGuckin J.A. St. Gregory of Nazianzus: An
Intellectual Biography. Crestwood. New York. 2001. P. viii; Calvet-Sebasti M.
A. Introduction// Sources chrtiennes 405. P. 1995. P. 31).
2
,
, ,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 6. 12. 1420).
3
. , , , , .
4
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 31. 13; 34. 13. 3. , . (Moreschini C.
Filosofia e letteratura in Gregorio di Nazianzo. Milano. 1997. P. 48).

32

33

.. .

, 5, .. , 6.
:
, , , 7.
, , . 8, , -

( )9.
, . (
) ,
10. , , , ,
, 11.
, , , 12.
, 13
,
, .

. ,
,
( . . .
. . 2009. . 59),
- .
,
(Dionysius Areopagita. De divinis nominibus II. 3. 16), . (Maximus Confessor. Ambigua 4// PG 91. Col. 1105C), .
(Joannes Damascenus. Expositio fidei I. 4. 37; I. 12b. 18) .
( )
, : , ,
, , , .. . , ,

.
6
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 31. 4142.
7
, , , ,
; .: Soph. 219b: (Stead Ch. Divine Substance.
Oxford. 1977. P. 2531).
. , :
, .. (Clemens Alexandrinus. Excerpta
ex Theodoto III. 45. 2. 34). . : (
(Athanasius Magnus. Epistula ad afros
episcopos 4//PG 26. Col. 1036. 2324). ,
( (Theodoret of
Cyrus. Eranistes/Ed. G.H. Ettlinger. Oxford, 1975. P. 64)),
: , ( ,
(Theodorus Raithuensis. /Ed. Diekamp F.// Analecta Patristica.
Texte und Abhandlungen zur griechischen Patristik. Roma. 1938. S. 201)).
, (Lampe G.W.H.
A Patristic Greek Lexicon. Oxford. 19611968. P. 980).
8
Moreschini C. Introduction// Sources chrtiennes 358. Paris. 1990. P. 72.

34

Plato. Respublica 509b; Plotinus. Enneades V. 3. 1314; V. 3. 17; VI. 8. 21; . .:


Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura P. 1168.
10
, , ,
, ( ) , , (Plato. Theaetetus 185),
, , , . ,

, ,
, .
11
(Aristoteles. Metaphysica
1028. 3031). , , , XIII .
.. . XIX XX . ( .. . . 2003. . 48; . :
Aristoteles. Metaphysica 1017a-b).
12
,
, ,
. , (Gregorius Nyssenus.
De anima et resurrectione// PG 46. Col. 93B).
13
.
,
, (Plato. Respublica 508
c; Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 30. 12; 40. 5. 34). , . , , , , , ,
(Daley B.E. Gregory of Nazianzus. New York. 2006. P. 67).
9

35

.. .

, , , ( ).
,
, 14. :
15, ,
, 16. ,
. , :
,
. , , ,
, - .
, : ,
.
. .
, , (

). , ,
: 30.18 38.717,
.
30 . ,
18. , , , . , ()
(.3:14). :

.: Moreschini C. Filosofia e
letteratura P. 97116.
15
(Origenes. Contra Celsum VI. 64. 14).
- (Origen. Contra
Celsum/Ed. Chadwick H. Camblidge University Press. 1953. P. 379 n. 9;
Origene. Contro Celso/Ed. Ressa P. Moreschini C. Morcelliana, 2000. P. 489
n.327), , (.: being; dellessere).
16

(Origenes. Contra Celsum VI. 64. 2022; . : Ibid. VII. 38. 12). , , , -,
, ,
, , , (Ibid. VI. 64.
2528). ,
, ,
, (249 .), ,
, .
14

36

, [] ,
; 19
, , ,
, !,
20.

. ,
( ).
:
[1] , : ; [5] ,
- ,
21. . ?
, , 30 38 380 . (McGuckin J.A. St. Gregory of
Nazianzus P. x). , , , 38- 45- (
383 . Ibid. P. x).
18
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 30. 17. 1.
19
, . , , ,
,
.
20
, ,
, , , , , ,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 30. 18. 1418).
21
Aristoteles. Metaphysica 1022a 2536.
17

37

.. .

22. , ,
: () ,
, , 23, ,
24. 25.
, . , , 26, ..
, , ,
. . , 27,

. (VI .): -,

28. .
29.
, ,
.
. .
,
( . ), 30,
, ,
, , ,
: ,
, , 31. ,
.
, () 32, ..
33. ,

: , , , , , []
( , (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 29. 11. 12)).
23
(Aristoteles. Topica 132a).
24
,
(Aristoteles. Topica 132a 45).
, : 1)
; 2)
, 3) , ; 4) (=) , . , : (Isagoge sive quinque voces//Porphyrii
isagoge et in Aristotelis categorias commentarium/Ed. A. Busse. Berlin. 1887.
S.12, 19, 20). , , , ,
.
25
, , , (),
, () (. .: Basilius
Magnus. Epistulae 214. 4. 79), .
26
, (Athanasius Magnus.
De incarnatione verbi 32. 1. 13).
27
, , : ( ),
(
), .
, , () ,
, ().
, () ,
(Basilius Magnus. In Hexaemeron IV. 5. 2531).
22

38

,
(Theodorus Raithuensis.
S. 217. . .. ).
29
, . ,
() (Joannes Damascenus. Dialectica sive Capita philosophica 14. 22),
, , (Ibid. 5. 3031,
4647). , , , ,
(. // .
. . 1990. . 99 .).
30
. .: Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 42. 17. 812.
31
Isagoge sive quinque voces P. 20.
32
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 30. 18. 12).
33
,
, - , (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 30.
17. 1113).
28

39

.. .

,
, , .. ,
, 34, , 35.
, ,
36, .. . , ,
37, 38 . , ?
, .
( ),
( )39.
, :

41.
, 42,
43, , 44, , , , ,
45
- 46.

, , .

40, . ,
, , , , .. ( ),
, , . . ,
, ,
(Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 11. 1214).
35
. , , ,
. , . .: Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 18. 4547, II. 14.
5559, 1.1, 1.8 3.14.
36
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 20. 12. 14).
37
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 25. 17. 89).
38
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 29. 4. 17).
39
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 6.12. 19; 28. 9. 10; 30. 18. 16; 31. 23. 10; 38. 7. 5;
45. 3. 36.
40
. : ,
, , ,
. , ,
, , ,
, , , (Plato.
Timaeus 37e-38a/. . ).
34

40

. LXX,
,
, , . ,
. 3:14,
, :
, (hyha rXa hyha) , . ,
: , (Origenes.
Hexaplorum// PG 15. Col. 347350).
.
42
( , ) . (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 25. 16. 2526; 31. 23. 10
11; 38. 7. 6; 41. 9. 2; 44. 3. 19; 45. 3. 3637). . ( .
Greek Philosophy and Christian Tradition in st. Gregory Nazianzus: Unity
Triplicity// . , 1998. . 90),
(Plutarchus. De E apud Delphos
392e).
43
, , , , . , , .
( )
:
(Plato. Symposium 210d). , ,
. ( ) :
(Basilius
Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 16. 79).
44
, .
45
. ,
, (Ambigua 94// PG 91. Col. 1288b-c).
46
.
,
41

41

.. .

, ,
. . , . ,
: ,
47. ,
, , ( ).
, .. ,
? , ?
, , . (, ),

48, .
. , , ( )
49; :
50.

, , -,
, : ,
.
, .
: , 51.
, 52, :
( 17:28). -, , : 53,
, .
. . :
, ,
, (1 . 8:6),
: , 54.
,
, 55.

, .
, ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 38. 7. 111; 45. 3. 3143).
47
, (Gregorius Nazianzenus.
Oratio 31. 23. 1011).
48
. , ,
( )
(Plutarchus. Pelopidas 2. 3).
49
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 21. 1.
23). .
. (Joannes Chrysostomus. De laudibus sancti Pauli I. 2. 56).
50
(Gregorius Nazianzenus.
Epistulae 154. 1. 3). .
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Carmina de se ipso // PG 37. Col. 1198. 1). , ,
, ,
.
42

, ,
, , , .
52
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Poemata Arcana I. 2. 56).
53
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 38.7. 111; 45. 3. 3143. . 11 , -; 9-:
, , (Joannes Damascenus.
Dialectica 39. 910).
54
, (Oratio 39.12. 23). . ( 11.36),
: , , .
55
, (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 25. 17. 89), (Ibid. Oratio 29. 4. 17) .
, ( 8), , ( ), ,
()
, ,
, .
- , , ,
, ,
: 51

43

.. .

. , ,
, 56.
, , , , , ,
, : , , 57,
, 58.

. . :
,

, 59. , ,
, 60. , ,
, ,
()
61. ? .
. , , ,
- 62. :
,
63,
64. ,

() , ()
.
56
, (Gregorius Nazianzenus.
Poemata Arcana I. 5. 23).
57
. , . , (
(Joannes Damascenus. Expositio fidei I. 9. 2122)); . : Basilius
Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 12. 89. :
, ,
, - , (Gregorius Nazianzenus.
Oratio 28. 5. 1118). .
: ,
, , ,
( . Greek Philosophy and Christian Tradition in st. Gregory Nazianzus:
Unity Triplicity// . . 1998. . 91).
58
: .
( , (Aurelius Augustinus. De
civitate Dei XI. 10// PL 41. Col. 325)),
,
. . , , -
,
(Larchet J.-C. La thologie des nergies divines. Des origines saint
Jean Damascne. P. 2010. P. 181;
.: Ibid. P. 163181).
44

,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 10. 2022).
60
, (Gregorius
Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 19. 910).
, .
61
. ():
(Yahweh), ,
: , , .
, ,
, , , , . , ,
, , , ( (), .
. . 2007. . 292293).
62
. : ( )
, () (Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 9. 2427). . . .: Norris F.
Faith Gives Fullness to Reasoning: The Five Theological Orations of Gregory
Nazianzen/Intr. and comm. Norris F.; transl. Wickham F., Williams F. Leiden,
New York, 1991. (Supplements to Vigiliae Christianae; 13). P. 192.
63
, , ,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 17. 12).
64
Ibid. 28. 17. 410; . : 29. 11. 1719; 38. 7. 1922.

59

45

.. .

65,
66,

. ,
, , .. ,
, 67.
,
, , , , ,
,
,
, ,
68, ,
, ,
69.
, ,
. ,

, 70, , 71. . 72,


, 73. , 74,
, 75 76, 77,
,
, 78,
, ,
79, - , ,
, ,
80.
, . 81:
- , . - , .
Ibid. Oratio 28. 7. 13; 40. 7. 2.
, (Ibid. Oratio 34. 8. 4; 38. 7. 78).
72
Ibid. Oratio 28. 31. 13; 34. 13. 3.
73
(Oratio 29.14. 19; 6. 12. 18). .
, ,
, , : , , , ,
, , , ., ,
,
(Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura P. 4042).
74
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 2. 76.
67).
75
(Ibid. Oratio 34. 9. 89).
76
Ibid. Oratio 28. 31. 20.
77
Ibid. Oratio 38. 9. 2; . : Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura P. 5154.
78
5 , ,
.
79
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 9. 2324.
80
, , (Ibid. Oratio 28. 31. 4142).
81
(Ibid. Otatio 39. 8. 1718).

70

. .: (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28.


11. 1112).
, .
66
Ibid. 28. 17. 1113.
67
, (Ibid. 28. 17. 89; .: 1 13.12).
68
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28.17. 67. , ,
( ) , ,
( 81.1,6) . , , , (2 1.4),
(1 15.28),
( 21.1). , , . () ,
,
: ( (), .
. 291). . , .
, .
, , .
69
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 17. 911.
65

46

71

47

.. .

? 82.
83:

()87. ,
, , . 88. , ,
,
, ,
,
, .
, , .

:

!84 ? , , ,
, 85.

86. , . ,
, , ,
.
. (),
.
; . (Ibid. Carmina moralia II. 24. 1320).
83
(Sichere
M. Ein neoplatonischer Hymnus unter den Gedichten Gregors von Nazianz//
Gonimos: Neoplatonic and Byzantine Studies Presented to Leendert G.
Westerlink at 75. Buffalo, New York, 1988. P. 6183). . , (Bernardi J. Saint Grgoire de Nazianze. Le Thologien et son
temps (330390). P. 1995. P. 304306).
.. , : , ( 29 31 ..)
( 30 32), ,
,
29 30, 31 32
( .. . // . 2- . . 2. . . . . 2007. . 792).
84
(Moreschini C. Filosofia e
letteratura P. 37).
85
; ,
, , , , (Gregorius Nazianzenus. Poemata
Dogmatica I. 29// PG 37. Col. 507508).
86
Plotinus. Enneades V. 2. 1; . .: .. . : , (PLOT. 11.5.2.1.24:
ETC.) // . ., 20052006. 5/6.
.688.

, ,
, , , ,
, ( -
, )89; ,
, ,
, , 90.

82

48

,
, : , ,
91.
. :
, ,
Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura P. 43.
Ibid., P. 42.
89
. ,
, : , ,
, (Plotinus. Enneades V. 3. 14); , , ,
(Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura
P. 39).
90

, , ,
, ,
, , (Gregorius
Nazianzenus. Oratio 28. 9. 1824).
91
, , (Ibid. Oratio 38. 7. 1516).
87
88

49

.. .

, ,
(). - , .
, , , , . , ,
, , .

. . 4 . ., 19751983.
. // .
. . 1990. . 5144.
, . . . 2002.
. /. .. // .
. . 1939. .5383
. 2- . . 1. . . 2007.
. . .
. . 2009.
. /. ..// .
. . . 2003. . 375458.

.
Grgoire de Nazianze. Discours 13/Ed. Bernerdi J.// Sources chrtiennes
247. Paris, 1978; Idem. Discours 612/Ed. Calvet-Sebasti M.A.// SC 405.
Paris, 1995; Idem. Discours 2023/Ed. Mossay J., Lafontaine G.// SC 270.
Paris, 1980; Idem. Discours 2426/Ed. Mossay J., Lafontaine G.// SC 284.
Paris, 1981; Idem. Discours 2731/Ed. Gallay P., Jourjon M.// SC 250. Paris,
1978; Idem. Discours 3237/Ed. Moreschini C., Gallay P.// SC 318. Paris,
1985; Idem. Discours 3841/Ed. Moreschini C., Gallay P.// SC 358. Paris,
1990; Idem. Discours 4243/Ed. Bernerdi J.// SC 384. Paris, 1992; Orationes XLIVXLV// PG 36. Col. 608664.
St. Gregory of Nazianzus. Poemata Arcana/Ed. Moreschini C., Sykes D. Oxford,
1997.
Gregorius Nazianzenus. Carmina moralia// PG 37. Col. 521968.
Saint Grgoire de Nazianze. Lettres, 2 vol./Ed. P. Gallay. Paris, 1964; 1967.
Corpus dionysiacum I/Ed. B. R. Suchla. Berlin, 1990. (Patristische Texte und
Studien; 33).
Die Schriften des Johannes von Damaskos/Ed. B. Kotter. Berlin, 1973. (Patristische Texte und Studien; 12).
Isagoge sive quinque voces// Porphyrii isagoge et in Aristotelis categorias commentarium/Ed. A. Busse. Berlin. 1887.
Origne. Contre Celse. T. 3/Ed. Borret M.// Sources Chrtiennes 147. Paris.
1969.
Plutarchi vitae parallelae/Ed. K. Ziegler. Leipzig, 1968. Vol. 2.2.
Theodoret of Cyrus. Eranistes/Ed. G.H. Ettlinger. Oxford, 1975.
Theodorus Raithuensis. /Ed. Diekamp F.// Analecta Patristica.
Texte und Abhandlungen zur griechischen Patristik. Roma, 1938. S. 173222.
50

:
Bernardi J. Saint Grgoire de Nazianze. Le Thologien et son temps (330390).
P. 1995.
Calvet-Sebasti M.A. Introduction// Sources chrtiennes 405. P. 1995. P. 9112.
Daley B.E. Gregory of Nazianzus. New York, 2006.
Lampe G.W.H. A Patristic Greek Lexicon. Oxford. 19611968.
Larchet J.-C. La thologie des nergies divines. Des origines saint Jean
Damascne. Paris, 2010.
McGuckin J.A. St. Gregory of Nazianzus: An Intellectual Biography. Crestwood,
New York. 2001.
Moreschini C. Filosofia e letteratura in Gregorio di Nazianzo. Milano. 1997.
Moreschini C. Introduction// Sources chrtiennes 358. P. 1990. P. 9103.
Norris F. Faith Gives Fullness to Reasoning: The Five Theological Orations of
Gregory Nazianzen/Intr. and comm. Norris F.; transl. Wickham F., Williams
F. Leiden, New York. 1991. (Supplements to Vigiliae Christianae; 13).
Sichere M. Ein neoplatonischer Hymnus unter den Gedichten Gregors von Nazianz// Gonimos: Neoplatonic and Byzantine Studies Presented to Leendert G.
Westerlink at 75. Buffalo, New York. 1988. P. 6183.
Stead Ch. Divine Substance. Oxford. 1977.
. Greek Philosophy and Christian Tradition in st. Gregory Nazianzus:
Unity Triplicity// . . 1998.
.. . . 2003.
.. . //
. 2- . . 2. . .
. . 2007. . 567853.
51

(), . . .
2007.
.. . :
,
(PLOT. 11.5.2.1.24: ETC.)//
. . 20052006. 5/6. . 681688.

..



,
,
1,
, Corpus Areopagiticum, V
VI .
.
, IV . ,
- 2.
(. 281/300386 .), ,
. . 3, ,
. , . 355356 .
,
-
. .: Dionysius Areopagita (Ps.). De myst. theol., 2; Johannes Damascenus. Exp.
fidei, I 4; I 12.
2
.: Henry P. Plotin et lOccident. Louvain. 1934. P. 61; . . . //
. . 1996. . 3132.
3
.: Augustinus. Conf. VIII.II. 36.

52

53

Оценить