Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 12

-

.
1997 .

I : 4 (36)

2011


I: .
2011. . 4 (36). . 2030

.
. .
: ,
?
, ,
.

, . , par excellence
. , , ,
, - (die lange Verchristlichung des Gottes)1. , ,
, , ,
, . , , , 2,
, . : - , ( )?3 ,
a priori .
4.
, , 1

Heidegger M. Beitrge zur Philisophie. Frankfurt am Main, 1989 (Gesamtausgabe; 65). S. 24.
Thomas Aquinas. Summa Theologiae I. 12. 2.
3
Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 10. 4243.
4
: . . . // : -
, 80- (23 2006 .). , 2006. . 3. . 2. . 1417; . .
// . 2004. . 7. . 159; . . . . // - .
: 2 . .; ., 2009. . 1. . 279. . : Hbner R. Gregor von
Nyssa als Verfasser der sog. Ep. 38 des Basilius // Epektasis: Mlanges patristiques oerts au Cardinal
Jean Danilou. Beauchesne, 1972. . 481; Vaggione R. P. Eunomius of Cyzicus and Nicene Revolution.
Oxford, 2000. . 133134.
2

20

. . . .

. , ,
,
, ?
, ,
.
. , ,
. - 5, , 6, . . ( )7. . ,
, , , ,
,
: , [] ( , ),
, ( ,
). (
), , (
). , ( ) 8.
. (I. 10),
. , ,
. . , ,
I. 9 8. 78 , I. 11
8. 1418. , I. 10, .
, , 8. 814,
8. 78, , , 9.
, , . . ,
- , , ,
5
()
- (atus vocis), , :
, , ,
, (Eunomius. Liber
apologeticus 8. 45).
6
Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 8. 3; Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 5. 126127.
7
Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 28. 3.
8
Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 10. 3337.
9
: [] ,
, , , , , , , -
, ( ), , - -
(Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 8. 814). ,
, ( ) ( ) .

21

10. , , 11, . 12. ,


, , , 13, ,
, , : , .
. , 14,
, ,
. , ,
. . : , -
( ), ,
- . , - [ ]15.
, , ,

, , , , ,
, , (I. 10).
. , ,
, . . . ,
, . ,
, , :
, , ,
, . . (
10

Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 7. 11.


, [] , , , - ( ), -
( ), -
( ), (Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 8. 1418).
12
, :
, ,
, . :
, , ,
, ,
(Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 5. 118122).
13
, , - [ ],
, , (Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 10. 4548).
14
.: . . . . 279.
15
, ,
. ,
(Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 10. 4345).
, , , , (.: 13. 1).
11

22

. . . .

: ).
, . . ,
, . .
, (). . 17- : : () ().
( ), 16.
. ,
: - ,
. . (//),
: , - [ ].
, . () (// ), . . , ,
( ). , , ,
17. , . ,
, .
, , ,
, , ,
, ,
, . . .
, , ,
, : - , , . . , , .
, . ,
18 16

Joannes Damascenus. Dialectica sive Capita philosophica 17. 210.


: , ,
- [ ], , , (Basilius
Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 10. 4548). , .
, , . . , ,
:
S S , (. . . . 278279). ,
. . , , Adversus Eunomium I. 12
( ), I. 10, -, , ,
, , .
18

(Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 214. 4. 912). . .
17

23

19. ,
, , , , . ,
, , .
, . .
. . . ,
20. . -, I. 10,
, . -,
( 21)
22. , I. 12 . , : ,
, !
, ? ? , , ,
23. ,
, , (
, )
(I. 10).
, : , ,
. . : ,
,
, , 24. 25. , ,
,
( 11. 6)26. . :
19
, , ..
, ( 4. 17),
(.: Origenes. Contra Celsum VI. 64. 1428).
20
. . . . 1417.
21
.: ,
(Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 236. 6. 12).
22
Idem. Epistulae 214. 4. 913.
23
; , (Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 12. 89). , -,
, , , ,
, ( ( ) ( )).
24
,
, (Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 234. 2. 812).
25
., : Joannes Chrysostomus. Contra Anomaeos I. 5. 371372; Maximus Confessor.
Ambigua 58 // PG 91. Col. 1188B; Joannes Damascenus. Expositio dei I. 4. 23.
26
, , , , , :
: ,
( 11. 6.). , ,
, (Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 14. 40-45).

24

. . . .

, , 27.
, , , , : ,
28. , , , ,
(Ding an sich),
. . , ,
, , . 29, ,
, . , ,
30. : , ( 5. 17), : , . , ,
.
, 31.
. , ,
,
32. , ,
33, , 34.
[], , ,
, , , 35.
:
27
,
(Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 235. 1. 911).
28
, (Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 234. 3. 1213).
29
Maximus Confessor. Ambigua 56 // PG 91. Col. 1180B1181A; 94 (1288B); . : Tollefsen.
Op. cit. P. 169170.
30
: , , , , . .
, .
31
Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 234. 1. 2731.
, ,
,
: , .
32
Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 24. 14, 2022; Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 31. 41
42; Vaggione. Op. cit. . 134, 249251.
33
Vaggione. Op. cit. . 246.
34
. . , (), ,

(), , ,
, . . ( . . // - . 239).
35
,
(Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 17. 13).

25

,
, : - , - , , , 36,
37. .
, ,
, , , , , , .
, 38. ,
. ,
quod habet, hoc est , , 39. ,
- , . (
)
. . 40,
: ,
, ,
36

, .
Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 12. 810.
38
: ,
. , :
, , , , , .
[] , ;
, : , : , , () ; , : , : ,
, , ,
, , (Gregorius Nyssenus. Contra Eunomium II. 524526).
39
Ideo simplex dicitur, quoniam quod habet, hoc est (Augustinus Aurelius. De civitate Dei XI. 10 //
PL 41. Col. 325). ,
(.: Augustinus Aurelius. De Trinitate V. 4 // PL 41. Col. 913). , , , : , ,
, , ( , [
] ); ,
, , , .
, , , ,
(Augustinus Aurelius. De Trinitate VI. 8 // PL 42. Col. 929).
40
.-. , , , , , (.: Marion J.-L. Idipsum:
The Name of God according to Augustine // Orthodox Readings of Augustine / G. E. Demacopoulos,
A. Papanikolaou, eds. N. Y., 2008. . 167189). , ens et bonum conventuntur (. . .).
, , , , . ., , ,
, , , .
, (Augustinus Aurelius. De Trinitate VI. 11 // PL 42.
Col. 931), : [] , , ,
(Augustinus Aurelius. De civitate Dei XI. 10 // PL 41. Col. 325).
37

26

. . . .

, 41. ( 3. 14), , 42: , ,


43. ,
, 44, ,
. , , , 45.
, ,
. , .
. ,
46, , . , ,
,
. . , ,
, ,
. , -, ,
, , . , . 47, , -
( , ). . , , :
... , , , . , : , , , , , , , .
. I. 19 , : , (
), , , 41
(Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 8. 3). 3. 14,
: the acknowledgement that he is what he is (Vaggione. Op. cit. P. 43).
. : ,
(), ( ., . // . ., 2008. . 17. . 182).
42
Vaggione. Op. cit. . 133134, 139. , , , ,
3. 14 (, , ), .
43
(Eunomius. Liber apologeticus 28. 4).
44
. . 229.
45
Wiles M. Eunomius: Hair-splitting dialectician or defender of the accessibility of salvation? //
The Making of Orthodoxy: Essays in Honour of Henry Chadwick / R. Williams, ed. Cambridge, 1989.
. 166169. : , (), ,
( ) (Ibid. P. 167).
46
3. 14 ,
(Gregorius Nazianzenus. Oratio XXX. 18. 1215).
47
., : Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 1214. , , , (Ibid. I. 14. 4345).

27

, ,
, , , , , ,
48. ,
, , 49. .
, , , . :
, ( ) 50.
. , ,
,
51, . , 52 ,
: .
. 53.
54. , ,
, . , , ,
. , , , , . , , 55.

, . . , ( 3. 14) 56
. . ,
57, 48
,
, ,
, ,
,
(Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 19. 3240).
49
.: Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 29. 1521.
50
,
(Basilius Magnus. Epistulae 236. 6. 35).
51
Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium I. 19. 33; Idem. Epistulae 125. 1. 49; 214. 4. 1012; 236. 6. 4.
52
Idem. Adversus Eunomium I. 15. 33; Idem. De Spiritu Sancto XVIII. 46. 8; Idem. Contra
Sabellianos // PG 31. Col. 613 A; Idem. Epistulae 235. 2. 8.
53
., : Amphilochius. Epistula ad Seleucum 2527; Gregorius Nyssenus. Contra Eunomium, P. 169170; . : . . . . 269270;
.: . Ambigua
// . :
. ., 2007. . 436446.
54
., : Leontii Byzantini. Contra Nestorianos et Eutychianos 1 // PG 86. Col. 1280AB;
Maximus Confessor. Mistagogia 23 // PG 91. Col. 701A; et al.
55
Amphilochius. Epistula ad Seleucum 30.
56
. . . ., 1979. . 287288.
57
., : Justinus Martyr. Dialogus cum Tryphone 96. 1. 68.

28

. . . .

: , ,
, , 58.
,
.
.
: , ,
(,
), , , , , ,
. . , , ,
,
. , , , , ,
, .
. ,
,
, ( 8. 24).
,
, .
, : ,
,
, ;
- ( ,
)
59, 60.
. , , ,
, ,
. ( ) , ,
61,
62. , ,
, , . ,
63;
58

Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 18. 4547; . II. 14. 5759,
1. 12 3. 14.
59
.: , (Gregorius Nazianzenus.
Oratio XXVIII. 4. 45).
60
, , , . -
. , ,
( ) , , , .
61
Basilius Magnus. Adversus Eunomium II. 9. 2427.
62
Ibid. I. 10. 1719.
63
Ibid. I. 7. 1517.
29

, 64,
.
: , , , , ,
, , , .

GOD AND BEING IN BASIL OF CAESAREA


A. GAGINSKY
(Institute of Philosophy, Russian Academy of Sciences)

The article attempts to deepen our understanding of the problem of Gods essence
in Saint Basil. Does Saint Basil identify God with being or does he exclusively wish
to prove Gods total incomprehensibility? The author analyzes Saint Basils arguments
concerning this matter and compares Basils statements with those defended by Eunomius
with whom Basil polemicized. In defending his own position, Saint Basil dened several
fundamental points of doctrine.
Keywords: God, being, essence, identity, divine energies, He Who Is, ontology,
Saint Basil of Caesarea, Eunomius of Cyzicus.

64

Idem. Epistulae 234. 1. 2829; 234. 3. 19.