Habermas nd the PublicSphrre a

P|olnaiq'F'qo0'6 frnrNs$'h36rifth}DEkR Uh'oco&!cdJ*i*.Puubibno Den& ss* rd drc DubLrpk / did m 0r!r N t o!). %4ndit br ct i doui. () s'dtua4

Sphere I lntDducrion:Habe.mNandthc Public I Philo$phic! Mod13 On 2 Prrlcal Dcours: ih Rclariool Monlny

,oiF | H&tu lofD L !sh{Flo d{ or{fiLk 4MdJhdrvJ.4lde'!o|id@b''.l3tl4|cj[@'

3 Mdels PublicSpaccllanah A.endr,the ot bnl Tradion,andjrsn Habs ModclsandBoDdarrcs Sphere: 4 Tb Publi t 5 Rcrhrnl'nsthe Prbl( SPhercA Contribudon A(ully E*islingDac'a.v 'h cnuquc;r IfSo Wh? SPbrc? 6 Ws l'hee Evcr2 Pubic CaF R.n.tins on !h Aneican 7 lolilial Thory ad Historical Adalys 164 99

3 De6ning.c Public Sphftc in CcmuyFran.e:Vaiationson a

I Religion, s.in.c,rn.l PrinliDS rlc Purrlic i sDhc,cs Scvcnrecnrh n, Cenrr}' tnsland l{J llahcrDnr,Hntr}, n.l Crnn2l'fheorl ll CrD.iorin.l I'ubli. A..cs: $onc.s Pliti.s in Ncrcr.r)lccntury Ameica l! Nrrnns. I\ltics,a Pohric Cult'rs: Itlz.ing l lxr{ nls in the NincrccnLh CcDLurl lit Ihc frgrrii. [ns ofPopular I'olni.s tll PblicConuni..ron 'lhc l4 lvrcdia ![c PulJlicSIh.rc rnd 15 lhe Mas h'lti. nd rhc M$ Sbjcct l{; T.xt'ality, ltldia on, and I'ublicDcou'rc rv can.luion and RsPonse

2t2

259

239

402

l7 lfurrhcrRcllcctio.s tlrc Publi.Sphcre on tH crnr.hdnrg Rc,arts

421 162

r:lTrL5 undcstand rhc histof, fouDdaons, and nrernal Lo pfocc$csol public dcouBc are gainirg inporancc nr scvcFl dciphcs,Thcy nrforn dcmcfa.iclhcry in poliril xicnce. tlc sclajcflcctionolhcrrfyard othcullualcidcs, drc mod ernn/porrodc!rirm dchatciD philosophyad .ulral s ies,new appfoachcs cdricsa'rdjurisprudence,and mpiricl in 'l rudics in sociology, hisbry. an.l conmuni.ations. he debaie hs been innu.nccd dccply byz vrrietl otJrgn Hbermr's lorks. Surprhnrgyabscntfmn re dis.usion. at les in En glilh. h$ beenoneofHabcrmal! morimporhntznd di.e.tly rerv:nr .' ry rorks, 7 /, s.zrht rrmfatuio f th tttbli SPa,.I'l'hough thh worl hs been rnong Hernass nor i n f l u r n r i ailr c i , m " n . , ' , d ' h , " g l irrbnr inr"in Englhb,27 rn.l,r"d serrrl languges,it has only re.endl rppa.cd Itr afkr publicarionof thc Cerman original l l r r ' J - , r i o n i . t ' - p i r i u ' R l ) m , d I h " b ! r i . ! i j r J i o r u inform scolarshipon prcblems of the relationshipof rie and.ivil so.ietl, the origins ofrnd prospc.a fo dcno.nq, and ihe inpacr of c media. Phrps even nore imporunr, the book\ integr2red trelrment of ihcse and olhcr iss'cs promisesb eni.h curremvork by druring rsea.hei lron, d ' r r ' " n r d i . , i p l i n e .i r r r ' r r m - r d n ' ' u . . ( a , , - l 7 " , h /rm will rko surpre rcadersor Hbermajs Ller Nrk (including nor only hi5 lns tur sonc vho deid. hn s l'c ol ncs Prr$nr). This is by far the m{ hiiorid ly.rr.rrk HrbenrJs najor worls, building it teorcrnxl ,xutr(ln

h'grltonrolsvn rcli. .trpifi.l disusions of ll tn,,Fmn.t, aDd (;errrrny bc61t. rhc *vcnre nd r'll rkotilrh nr !8(r rorriF trcsrnt von'nc ori8ir.cd aSpt'nbcr tDcc oi rhr o..!sion ol rhc pnblirio ol rhe l'rglihtnn* tt'kr\ ot Ttu stru.htl ,nl,motkt oI th I'rLht slh.. (lhnr'r prodennraq nor.D.nr rd (innng o rlr h..ll "l itr rhr nri(Grol l. . innnation of Cenkal nl hrq" i'roF, rlk (onlrc ( n.nr more than a pu,dJ Jm.t, .ri'n uscnrknrf l inning the.onfercn(. tid (o k.{p tun[ \rnrl( nrrisitJn,ry narureol,] xrncsoiI'onr ba.kgrounds hirkty, c in lr,hkir'H. l'ni.il,\.r!( (rnmtrnicLions, nnd phi,roIhy. sr'irl {icn.cs, hcrrrurr, (rr', rh. pcasurc\ rhcro,,ltcnccuasin sciItS howwcrr ol |c ,i{otrBc spafkc.U llcflhaJs book .oul(t rtgfate ' l n 1 n ( .l ' , . n ' ' l ' c ( \ . ' r n ^ l i . . . p l i n " \ l i u r l ' ( n , { n ) ' n . "nd rrrli\.innDry con.eB rcl,r&Drd bI Frti(ipner lcn!trm, ' irs, drrnrti. x,la4.\. hr .n' {iri( rhort. cuhurali nrrkcd l,t n ld.l of .ngg.nrc rDd rn nrmr $r "L xl)*Dceoapo(dng rlat.on\in.e ma.y oi 6 rErt ![ai e bli. splcr uas nor slrogcrId l,rr tn thclac rwcnricLh.n r!ry. Ol .ourse,dri: cngngcnict$ rcv.lc se ol Lhe ll irs ol thrt publi. sdc: t dn$ onc niShrtl'c tin-l' {,irni {lismurs ofrscnrl{otrrc (orlr..r ,sr r) srh pr.h fctauran.llt opclled rl'xr rhc proprietool l(nrl 'ish !' I'r,g on r glsnd s.r a purpor o ri!ctblh hc rklf Nrs pu.eful dininS.N loud corer{fn'. prcFrnr8 rlis lmk for n ,tr8nning rh.onf.r.c lion, I har inoi Ld runlf,r oach$.Iinn M.Crnhy t,trhlk ,trrl NlrishcPoronenot oly thpc 'nto$r rcdi'rgoSm ol h1,tt t tur:luaatian blt n lpc in lhc plaDniLs thc conlr rr,. irl rllcrcd sufnl( o nrcs on my irrlrrrnn,. Rckha l\lnrl' lnni ar.l Rr| Slivirrdcd as ablc,\upl'oflivc,nd con I'rNkdxrblcrsinns tlnoughour plnningrnd Lhc hc l, '.r(r: Rurh slain ako l)roDifcdrb nrdcx.xcv srrgnr ,.trtr. ,hou,jh nirh lsGrn. mrupotur rn l,gir'.al
.hii.utrr'llt( n' |nrin.il{ fd ihe contc.cnccrnnc fron ()lrrr ol (l( Uircrsnl oo. Cri's pad rl'. l1n,^i\ ,l n\ it,ttrr i rl'c l,roAhn in Stral lhcory rnd Cros

'lhc

Culunl snnlirr. I am grakll al$ o rl.olleagxcs in rh {nnrk'inA,onnunir\ t , q r a m .H I r , f ' , , \ i J t i d n r \ " r r r h wnhin whi.h r) t,rtpnrc t and.onrlmr rlt mnferen.c.'l hc Ccnte lor l\y(houill Srudiesin (lhi..rgo ..nriburcd nnrndallf b thc (onlrcnrc bur rl$ phycd rn cvcn nor .cDrl role, sin.c n sN f rcnding ol Shlkhnl lrrlarmaLkr itr s *trrr on srii thror,v thd c.nn. Ih. originrl ide fr A ' ' h e a n l ' 1 ( r . ( , , , r n m ' r r u ' \ I 1 . , ) d l . ' tr \ p F i l h n r ' r Itrnt rolc. s prlx's scre diril,utcd ,dhlr rhan prscnLtl .'louJ,,,mr,c'r,i.{\ lh,l' r1.rLrn,at'Dr\il'iln, ^ n,i. iring diKn*ntr,. lrlof l$ rook rhL rnnf !' pfcpfc.aRful, N' tc,- u!mn,r'i! rh,.r tr.,r'r Ll.! tr!., u, rl,ctr .u'.n,Lutrn\ ro rlGboo[. B.rirnrir) l!c, vnohnd l(n div. pticipaDr. Ea.ioulrnqrpo i )lill Lrcpla.Llcliwhn F!cdn.Jncrn, was r the 1r ritrf. iblc to.od.r h .odmenrrry. I . ' n 'J l g r r r l n l x , I l " r F a u ' B r ' . h l i , n r n \ l . r a lH l ' m i \ !s! rcvnn,* rh. nn,.un,l rntral(rJn, ol |rc purrli. sphe'r aor rhs rdnnc: Iah Fl{tuG abv h.hd cdn th In( brr no i., grrrrnl ro,jl\{en rlab.nDs, (ho tnk rinc lio!' r vcry brsy s.hcdulc 0 p(i.iparc trir .onfcEtr.c. I onll h.pc th h. lu n $ vhabc i thc vriDs pri.DrB ll lbund hi\ os.or!ibuti{,Ds. H n,y connnens lnn !|[ rl.or an(l oDcn d .oD$u.rivc r.spon* rh. .onhBion scrc innen{ly cLitying rnd rnrhhlc f rc hccrlo'n fm \rni() ! pEtn{.1 r,vd for or ol us $ho .lisared snh hnn. he rcDins x 'nod.l interl(nror0l hc blic sp[crc

re:l {ok.1r r ntd rbd\,tr.

M@ turiki rhd, 1tu(;6d

lu'Ji'h!t,ddjil|tr. v&, tdvdd di r I

d)

r,trrl,tu,,

r. r. '.troi q, r-,

tii:E
- ! E 5 . :

fij;
li 3;

; il.

i;;i ;

d!sF l

ifiEE i iEE:I :

, ig:l::

Ini.oduction Habemas and the Public sPher

ciitioi i' n'ixdl .d prni( .oi p.opLe romeD,Fe norice o that bcsics rorclli'rs n jcrins rhcy Iiv. trnoLl'cr.ii.ri'nnt, nn.lr, 'Bunlg.

Jrgen H2benars impartant erly ha.l t hr sttudal lia Plhtix slhr zsrs wn nd under kba condi ltntuatkn of h Lions dr arsunent ol mixed conpanies .ould b.ome rudroribtive hases poliii.la.tbn. I hequesion, Habefmd for slbws, is cD.ial oDe for denrocr2icory. wh2r are rhe $.irl .onditionr. he as[s, fof ] rional .rnical deb2te2bor publi. nsuescandu.kd bl pdvak peNonswilling ro lct argx nrirrd n.i \ r.e.ddr,nircde.i.i,n.? | hn ndr ilqui') atonceinb nornr2riveidealsand a.ru2l hisbry. lt lbcuse upon dr boufgeoi politi.al life of re sveDteendr ough nd twemie cenLuries, yr jl ains Lo r2.h bqond ihc Sawcd n 'n^vc- !m,'\ind,,f,,,nrinuinS ',,|i'c.,, li. Lii.i, nornarivc inrporuce This somcrhing is an imnutionar ro crLiontr pr.ri.al Eason in publi. tl:ix ad Ib c accon p!yingvalid, il olicn dc.cptivc, cLins ofaormal dcnua.y. Hrbcrms's so.ialihcor/ is olien interpred2s movingovel Lbc fcars fton HeglianM2rxisr orienration ro a v)rL ol (amian oricmrtion. fhough not without truth, rhn vicN un ,11,\':m,r\ rh! un:J in hi" ini ll!' rurl p'oi' r. Xin' , ..'tn. .cntl plrc in Situl Talni, rhc tico'ist *h,, as

ollir. nre tuller arLi.ulaion of thc idcal ot th lbrg.ois IU li' t. r c. In rl i. pLLli \p1.1..1n:'-l'f.!"h.riii. Lud,rali?d ihrorgh norns ot rcnsncd discoursci *hi.h 'F'nrn . ni '" 'F u' 'd.liiun., \ '. rv L, L n:!. 'I hough llbernrtrs .eje.* tundrn cpisrcn,oloAr rnd its corollry ahirori.rlrxaltxlion oi pl'ilo:ophys l,iLcnd lau. dartun of all ricn.r and .rlru,o, his rc..nr tork hc Donerhele$agucs rh:r son,crhn,Srcnlunr cru.il lo rhc Ka.titrn viN ol mode.nny Abrc nll clsc, rhn is a nolion ot 'pro.cdurrl rtionxlnf rnd ns :'tlli1l ro givc .rcd.c. ro our viersnr thr tln cc rus o|objr.tik knowlcdgr,mon'ilr.tic| insighr,xDd xcnhori. 'dgnrnr. r Th$ tr)cc{uhl rflinrliry k li'ndrn,cnhllf ! nrntrool tnsn,gjudgnc or r.rotrs. Hxbernnls trsl n, Snrrl fy,r,rtr is io dclcbp r crnique 01 rhk .trLcgory bourgcoissoclctt nb{tr8 both (l) ot ns nc,nrl rcnrnnr lnd rhc hcros tl,t l.d ro irs rslon. [ ]nd tx'rirl dcgencrxtionr..l (2) r clc.,cnt ol trrth rd cr ndp'r porcrLirl rlL n co rnrcrl dcspilc irs idc.l8iQl 'ci.cir. ',n',1, , 1i,i:, ', ,.'n ,u'i'li,riu', ll'l.yi pli.n, il 'rrl,o lignrlv exprcsrd. rhc quorrnD rlDvc lnn K,rr 1","."'1 .1.,'t..l'. 1.k."l(.tur' ru."rc'r'.. r poln{ drFnds uPn borh qudnt ol is.oBo qutirt o, px'ri.iDro,'. Illhcrnsdcrclopsth.l'd r.!rirc!.nLiD.rar,publi. tdoc ol thc scvo.xli',g ho\ rhr .lasinl bour8cois cconrl' rnd .igl'rccnrh cc urics Nrs consnurcd rroud 'rnn,L.,irrrl rrsun'.rr, i. rIi.h rlc rcrns.l af8unctrt 'n,l'r,..1., i,1,.'rii,.-1,,.bur..('r,ru.i.I I rr.l l,.i Lo rrv I'o,n Xrnr. rl,rn, $ tlc Dhunl ol rguDeri ris rrc'riso ol 'cx!,, Ns rlic vlil,1. kcn.| in rc tlrcd nlcJlvg',1' l""';, { t{'.li t,r'. X.n'l\".v.'.r.'i' clnnn, n, d'cNiy ho norc L n$c nusincs pcoplc and cvcn wono nal,r rfinr. r)uLrhc rtr,d)8is cn b. pt o hc P.s ..\!. i".- t {,',. u 1 . ' i | n . ^ f c , r ' r .r i i " . , , t . i,'F Llr drbilitics rhr kc vnc 8uo\ ' .aplblc ol rvc,1o lntrior (nnl rltra ir is r r('l {lillcuL .r lioD {soibcd fntNi rlr pdrrr,.nrly d.lrrlc !,nc pcoplc).on thc o.o htrd,tudi g Krr rlrc c*irivclt. rc scc t,rlbnrcspco. plc nd *on,cn rr nor "lrlc krsonc$, d wc comc .rosi rh. rlirlc.bc loiDg r,ll)cc.h)c ol rhc tbli.5poc.

'I

hc crrly lrurycos publi. sphcrosrctt co'PosedoI nruw {gnrcn6 ol d,c [mten popuhtio, mainly edu.rtcd, pro' pcficd nrcn, an.l tlrcy.ondu.tcd n discorscnor only ex.1L6c ofoters but prcjudicialb the intcrcrs f d,osx.h'dcd. Yct thc L.rnlo.rntiois of th public sPhcrc rhar H2bIas dc' ribes rurn l.r8cLy o it.ominu cxPrnsionro in.lutc no'c and nor pifriciDants(2sucLl's o hc evelopmcrt ol large '.',. . '." 'r' 'i'i i ar ildn ou 'l t itJ_ "' " ,riggcss- ihar nltinatcly rih inclusivitybrought dc_ io'r..:' ion). He generarionn thc aurhl of dikourtc. bur h conicrds th:t hfh thc r.qui,crenl! of dcnrcraq nd tlt nltue oI.o!tcn! porry h,8c.$le m.itrl ognir ri mcan that it tu nnPo$ihh t! prurc$o'1tr) h, tsu'nLrtrl L r clnnt PuLln t'l'.r A'rJ'.A' ! i'-. -pr'.!li'"FM"l.J\ "ru'.8o'\-. rcsrro.nrs ro ,lrrrrT,?,ry'ir,r", the nc tlrosc lho re$ rhc isn,c of. ionnl, crnicldcbaicnd thc quc$ios of ti., N[cnce n .mc, whclb.r ir sa\ cler ealy s n,.h as dc, nrl \rhy ir dcchrc, il nrt c n did.'l bcrc nrclso rlr.se r',*'1c ts.L. l t'."'.'1."^r. ro'4.',bu"'l! "\'lu i"' "l'o ry.hara.rc. ol drc oxrly P(l)li. tdrrc lnd thc gains soD by tl'osc (ho ft,Dshrto cmd ir rxl ansldn it. Scvcral,ir.rDd n,s Bcnhabih, l.rscr, El.y, rxl Rlan. fo.u on tlrc su of cc;o, n exch6ion Lhrt Halc'as noted butorc rhat isoly

i,'o'r,.,

" I'nn-'t'.onirrn'cd'h ' , . ' l y s .r 1 L ' l ' - ' | ! ' r ( "u'] rh' rJ'li IUlJ .Dlc"i. ,'r\'ll'cr'n'1"'. ,Lr " rh.lcs.la.ly linkcd orhc c'nc of tanlonnatioD hl mas i.aiion than h cx.lL'sio.D clas groundri n.lusionolsnarr nu.cs oleltu, kcrr. womcD,roukl noi luvc unsfornrd rlrc houryeoispubli. sphoc n't) a mrs. S.hurlson l.usson rhc cxrenr of prrLi.iPrtio rs an cseniid dnnc.sion ol publi. nc$, n ltey.cion lo.orauring a Publi. stn'cc.A. th smc lnc hc nises qc$ioni bout {hcdrcr ealier .osi.uiion\ ol tllc publi. sphererc2lly prodtrccdnore rrtional ..iti.l dchr' rlu rhoic of fc.cnt ycars. Indc..l, ro :omc .o.rctr'prrlv rhcor6, th very cnphnsis n .ional.ii.l d.Dk inrlnitr nnrcapa.nv!)derlIairll$irh nlcnLityPoliti.i'd{o!.r'\ .rxn'ln. Irdilf.fc.e. lt is vnh this in rird Lhrr Wnrr,l!' lruics o fubli.ny in gcn.r1,rdhcr Lhn on i1snrrlrknt

1) s'"Fl

\i.'\n1 rl'.n.'t'.1li.^\'

{ilh rtionrl-.rnicrl dcbrtc.Cir.ham xn.l Wrn'c snrouhar 'datcdly,li(us or Itrb. raJslairly *hotrsrtc ilcorForrion ol tbc Frillnr Schools.ririqc oi rs rtrlrurc,a tlrr nisc qu.fions l' slcrlc l$ undcriardnrg ot rDd.m nas .rlia n rrt\Drc. Ii al t[c$ cnscs, rhcyar. iur nrl !nllv I n,{,or.,ri rr,c(lull.n3.-l'.."hna.r'r, "apunt inat sLu,trttt l\a^Iurut@t t\ ' t*F tu[\ n, nrind t{h.,.l m2s! lo+nkl .onfnurior ol. .r'*ory ol pnhli. sphcE 3ssirnlnD.otrJr rlxN rr qDrlirydr l;n ol 'ad)ril..riril 'ri\, u,\.frl rtn rr"' q ^f . 4tr,n...!, n tunxt,prri p a i b n .l h i s i l o , n * n o L K t h i s . l i i r i , bru r h h N h l ca p t pro.h, nrNr' as Ic ruc'npn k, '(!,rl rhc enrlDrnrgtt vluab[ nl(,rl ol 1,. bourgeopubln sfh$e lRn ns liron.auyr'rr,li(rnlxn prrialrli7triir, rn rrx\ rfrod rnf es2y r prcpos riDlt k, ol.lr snyopsis.f I h shnd . t,,fondi I tt. t\l n s . rot tc Ixncnr ol ,r'.(l.rs Dor linili2r {iin rla!rl. I sill hrienr
i t t r i r \ h t n t t t , ^ t u t t tn ' r l r l J ' ( . ' r ' ! r r r - , H J . lirnnis .ll!.nl prcje.( md ll rd l! oni.rl .omnEnt rn .ll)rrx oa ny oB. Si'r. r[c pap.tr in rhx bool sptrlt r|cselvesand2r rsubi oi dcrild.m, l;f mntcs ffnrcrl h0e,I will inodur ih.h otrl),very brieny.

1hr shtdn Itu:lannation af tht r't)t slh xs hor i) .nLovcrlf rrl s likly k) ronrue b sl)rl .ontrM.slr. lr oigin2kd rs tllrrnat (ltcsis I IFr, Hilrrrhl debr! qunllnrrnr requircd of (jrnn pn'lsvxon.l B imendc lr {rlnision ro l2i Horhlenq (nd rheodo. rdono)ar tkion. Ho.lin an ^on,. hosere4 ap t r . 1 , l L r l - r q h r . r r L n . . i n \ u l h , c n r l )( ' 1 r . ' l u l r h . r l l u \ i ^ n . .nxl dngerf t.rdcncis ot an lnligh..nnrcnt (nrceptin ol (lonn,.,arirpuhli lil, espe.ialll nr n$ r(idry, nd kDradi.al i', ns t)oliri.lly l,)cscrlcrll lar an ntr r) go betonrl liberrl (onrtruri'ml ,rf.rions i pusun 01 !uor Lrocrz.y. Ha Ir'tr'r\ sk(\riillt submntd ii b w.ll8ing ^b.nd.orh ar l\llbua.r lrlhhfial in tie 2rly yer o c nudcn( nok, tnn, \hoat titnrlomtio sD dEw i.isn rmm rh2r

li'e(nnr s q!ll {hon loung lfrisis atrackrdn i,r firusnrg on Lhcbourycois prbli. rphreto e cxclusnn, rhc polcol ri"n one,for D illdu!ute grasp ofcverydrl lil (ir.ldnrg nas nredb)iD dvn.cl cpnafism. lir cxrAgcnrinsrhc rnd c'nan.ipakn.ypoknril i rhe idalizcdlx,uryq' pui. rphre..Habcr.xs hiDrt $:s ppaemlt trnhppyNi(t' rh. $ork, or ar lr{ .o(irrs of rlr hryc noum ol cnrpiril re$r.h doft oD rlt!.s rclo?nr ro ir.turg rh t!,t., for oft of e rc3vrr lr r r:rld trnslation rl'ar nc had $a inrended fryrB b kworl tlri tcxt.H. ruvcr{ll.but fcd, r may be srprirc how rnl oI Hon'rss Inrcr Licnrs rfc prcligncd (r.l olirn Bi!n llrn .! frn)bgical orn'uhtion and hist'irrllr slJdili. trc.!ci0 n, rhir s.rk. rr l$ .nrcrs nfo n crcriE atrd inpofr tirk)Aucsiih otl,er lq, so.k ol hc id trcric c.t!rt, ror"bly rlar of Ilnnh Ar.ndr.. ^tr.| rhc bool rcmarerhoklnD:ill g rill thc Dnxrriili(r D cf $ork oD irssie.r. ,jrri!e. Tt surrj(r n rht hnrnlh 3pc.i6. pheDonrcDon th of lour8co pulrl. sphcrc.rcrcrt oui ol e li(nr lxre.n rnpialis id tl'. rak n, rh serenre[nn c'ghtcmh r.rtun6. Hcrnrs scBou( ro esabl lhr lc deg(,r) of p(blic D.nr n, bou'gq, ciciy and h.w ir Drclnnr8 rnd n ' J ' . r i Ju t { ' , r ( r ' \ r ' r r ' , i \ f . ' , , c d . n l , e , , 1 r n ' ! a r t r r . {o. utioi, Thc nrrirnrim t rhlsliesltrryoll i rr nrcmpr ro rcvilc rc ptugrasivcporenrial "fornral lcn!).n.ynd nr l . . w , , lr l a x , ! \ r r r . ' r t , nr \ r i ' ' c 3 t , a rn r r t cl \ l , r h l tc I rrdirioD M.r sBrili.ly, njs pr of Hrrrnrsr lillong .ffor ro rcBroudrhr F nkfu S.hoolpmte ot .rncatthc ury i olc ro Scr our of rlt p.lsini3ri. .Dl dc r'. shkh ll.rrhiE, d ^{lonr) fouDdemsehsinrcp(6r*nrcn. ln a nuBlell. tl[ nrer,F b Iond a vLionol s{i.h rrnr InrmaionnD hutrri eman.ipaon on r p!'lcrri hrd InDnrlercd. h..xl).ricn.e.l fakism an ,c rc ol rhc cul
'.".'l'1,1u.',),rnl

' 1 , . ir h - c s . , . - , I n { , ( , ' . \ r , i r , ,- n \ 1 h l ' r i r n . n r i 8 l i t{" thci' h.Fs l' rnDrrrdng.apiralism. HahN$ $rd rray rfonr . Mr1 li, sncn a subjr.r D{lrvcl',t{d ir c.ounr of in.\ubiivc .onnruniavc prxcss\ n l|.n t'an.iparory Fforn inpla.eof antphilo$t,hv(lr p,rk1)

.1,Srrflrd,,,n.-nr

la,ndl

!,.x,h,.,!

ol rlr n)j.a. ^t Lhe e.t riDre H f,r rs sn,ghr ro nr.or Itnk nruisrhcoryIullrPpc.irri(Dnl rh0inrpli.arioDsoa sbk .l'x6 rlr( hr tr urr. in borh l)nnlisn' rDd-l-tu dr!.' risc of nlxlcry us tnrgf ttr Fnod of $cr.n rlt Inrf. drxrrr,n, rlf Prcblemdhrnn' ol .onsnnP..n (r3 rh. inr.escsn [ixnktnc.apr.r). n r.rF xc k) rK.rslii xn,l nrs dLDcBcv d.velrDcnr of rhe 5o.i2l Nelfrc ra. xlltrlkia lrh rhe.ondnn,ns rhr lrc,l rhc vi(wof.lasi.al VrxisD rnl rhc roririons ol bourgd'i\ vxidy nll. ln rhn l-r\hrrrtor ilr l)r'rllls nn.h of the tc:Dt, s\\tutrd ol ;r rnkfti Srhool\ rmlysn ol rlr 1'rntiri,n, Ii.n libral b,ngrnif(l,rt)i(rhin I h r i n , t r r x r ( c o l r i e D u b l i .{ P n . t l i c si ' r n s P r c n a l a s a nnxlr ol vrnrl i.JBLion. I'>li. l(ou'\c (Dd NIL H,|rrnr\hkr in nrc gcn.nlyclll(onnnn.irca.tion)is r ^\itlf nxnlc o .rDrdn ior of Lun'r lil, n$ re rate nx[c\ and ,$rrc non_ ptr,.' rn(l nrrkcr cononi..Iur lcr rheory ,ln.n'sn( xl$ .t .mrdnrri.n, r\ Hrlirtrft! t x a t r n x ' h r n h n ' i d ' i r \ {'.sf.. 'r'r) llfl ru,nt"ni ol ruv rn \Lill. rnd rhey sufltr lrn r.d..ici towrl {lor,tr,rri,r! rn '?ifi.arion. st rnd c(ooty rc dru! both .,u.iil rrDirs l,n rnd ivnls.l rhr tnnri. Drblic sPhe.e nor.l*s rhu{ (d.cr$ Iirr bI srkil lrtfrfldo rfirA r) cvcl,)p r hirori.allt sDt.iln rd.rNrrdnrg oi 'h nnrlr tric,,'y ol publicDcss ll,c l'*cis lubli. sPhcrc n x(rqor) rlrrnt,vpulof inclxrh lrrnrtrorhcabra.kd '.ivil so.ictr' lrotrr hr unnrc devck,PDcnrrl hnlry Dl I( on9atn,g fi rtu ti! ot I{iAh lilid\LryAt( (;.nlvhiftl dlr ^gclr no' .rn n b.rnnsLncd, n[l rrl)i.llt AcDcrlrtd, r' nv n!tr,lEr of hisori..lsnuarnnr tl!rt rcDrcscnifornrllr -l-l'c firligrcnrtrt .tegor)\nihr .on{cllrtions (p \fii)." G.cI rn..{o'i iur as t 's lio is.hsi.rl rh$ illm lrll.rcr lnn ni tnslbrnod (nctrtr'ry dcs.ndnr (lr.t t|lnlght nlt r $ong irisnn l{ts..n Publi. n.l thcGrerk t ) r i v r k r l l , n s . $ u r i . r l cP r i r r t cr c r h o l r | . ' i , only ..cs y. liccdon wrs h.rd ,,1 r houschokl.lDfDrc t, 14 lunl nr publi., though ol !trtsc tlr Public rcalm ol of a.h ,rr(irrn,n* .irDf,ns rcstd on thc pivdr rt!ny \ r ffr oi houscold (nron ol ,rln)scnrcrDcr uer ex_

'l-hc ,h'dc,l liom rhc publi.) bou.gcois puDlic stn)Lrc rhrl I nrH mrs c\pl,!s shras $mc reriDrcslnh rhG pi.nft, nr r fseffs r rfv ccD.rr. lr n de6nd 2s Lhepublic ol /nh nnlirnu3ls $h..i,,i ir dclxrc of scs bcarir o shtc u rll)fnl: Lnlilc r[c ckrk .on.cprion. n]dniduh rr hrfc x ' ! l ' F r d r , b c i { r i ( l t { ' n , r ' l r i n r h p ' n c ' . J h t r ,r ' .hding fnilt. M,rov(r, rhc privat rflln un.riq}d ,,. ,,nr uf f'er.fiin 'h l'," !, br dctndcd rArr rln, !t,m' seventcenl!inl cighLcc'rh.cnrufy rolior rvck)tr nlo,$ide rhe rhc rnd oisln'rnarion of rhc nnxcrtr fiLu. d '!cil ion rhc lnsisol crpirlnr c.onomic !.iivnl. t hc nntcr nrrr.onrnuLed thc pul)lic r spe.i. relm rgrir (s nd rhrCreekpolh).ltrnrc hnlc lAcs. publi.ncs hd hcrr nxc ! ' r r r 5 " t r r i h D t ( , , 7 ) . I ' s a s a . h a r a c r r h L i .o a r h c! u t c r lxrnl ern b) hh r\s. In r $ord of lina3 Fh.l{ sI ''Ltrr(, r'er nr)i, r( )rl,li. 'fa.oumry di.l no crisr p ln king rDd hisrrui. Ihntras the hetdq ol 1(frcsn'rrna putli.nr. rn l(rrkhip $Js rpernrcd 1 It Dnr l{f;'r rlr p., t( t, h,. rirlurlh. hre\cr ti'n vrnl) (lc\ rlope.l inro thc rcw trr ol .(xirbilq of eighicDll( Lurt ,lu'.. \'n',, .,n\ I,,r.,L l!.nl'nr'^,e n rh .'r v tr{n*coA l)ubh. sphe. Hbdnnr 06 nor mcn b srgg.r rhd whr nirdc th. Dubli( stn,rc l)orscDfi yassimply rhe ch$ kRd|c, n ws r.i.il tlr {$ bour. t,'ion ofns mcnn* B.o, rnd tourgcoirsridt FDduccda.rtain nrot publi. \drcR..' TIk n$ vnibilnt, bstther snh rh rarnrrtrrii.t (li{o(r* (l'd g.ew i r( rlo's (rnd.offe houscs orlrcr l t ' l . G ) . d r p t n d c . l . n r h r r G c o f a t i o n a l a n d r c r r i r it x s c r rr$ or rr brsis ol rc erl)- .pihln .ommrr.il .\ oonl: Ihis prr5s kd r) rtr i(le ol sriety sepante rmD rlr n'tcr ('tr rlr ktc) nd ol privre ratn separare frcn ha put,ti.. I hii notion ol .ivil k!icry n brsic ro Habcrnra3s rorm ol rl'c putli. spherr, r,1 ir rrc(rnt in tu.n offr i r.rr dcal f irhnes ro orr.Dr i{ usions or.ivil sorirvtld ( orc ( 1(N ro cttu{ng I rlith rhc prirare narkLr: Civil\xidl, i rhr \crrDrremh rnd ci8h!orth.cntr'ris, dvlopcd$ 1h. xqr dorrain ol Drivrc ruk,mr Ithatl {oo.t opp'"(,t i' t'. "i'rc (p. {rr" l2). (jpnrr nr lctc.ononis forncrl rlr 1,,n ol -lhe

tr driscivilsdicrv,b n nrcludc2 gooddalnoc 'han D.

i..i.4 r'"ir,.*

onlr .-,irtnd dn.ursc looielv "t I f\ l d n ' F ' u l ' h e r u n \ n n r r ' r ' - . J ' - d u ' h c c J " . n r
rh.L,s ruJu.e.l r'nnnr mo' 'n i! or !'vrr luucv ,r'. p-';tt. " l'gu "\ nrnrd .^n!i'r" n ' i. -'., ",. .JPr Inn H'Lflnr' l,''h '{'c'\'v \or rn"L ' ,"'"i'.-.."r ,". '''1",' d r^r ' l 'ra dr n -o',^mr' l-!"il l-,,J "1' ..,'"'."',^". r'nu' rin'mra;''rv^ .,;;;.;,.,..,, " d r r '\ f'! v-" J.r''.cdr'l ' r;'nsriun '!J -i^--,"'.,' \'fPlnr rl'uv 'r_' .' " ' , . i " - . ' t i i j , dr.r"'orirr'r'8"J"^Y'I :;;;;.' .

isencc s rh.oollary of a.tcperonrli2cd \bte ruth'ritv' (p l9).lt Dc.ane po$iblc k, c.osnizscic.v in thc rclarn'nshiPs rnd ornizd;ns crcatedIrsusaining lifcand to bring thcsc 'lr ' n r - r , u l ' l i ,' . 1 ^ , , . . ' ) b " S ' q J 'nlo'srd"flc
,.D, ,lF.L-'"""nd-"1' !nvl lt! 'r'l'h' qtr

r.r r.,'1'.r .r i.,tt \.an.ri'u'ing .,:.,,"in.d..ft .t,'.. dre Juli. and tlrrcbl transLmrcd thc ab*ra.t 'tion ol rr' ,rrl; s.ou.rcrDrt to Dblic aurhofnv inio 'n.h nbrc i""ccte *r D;.iices. Th ncncr of tl' elie Pblic "t beFu) ro st rh.;Nelves rlnDush thir crrcsorr .ot \L xs 'hc ,'r,,'d....r'., ' l.Jnfv'crrolD' l Jhu':'v

""' 1"'p!'l b-'l' r mu' r_ l'. '."'. .- *' "l'g'odrr i ir'l drd A""rr' cP ..'eJJ l !'' \ J' Ji' in'or\'Jrl l lt^! li'\rlLlr . - ,u ,. p,l' i nfa'mJ '" lt ,r ,-,.,

rp'nr"

Ll r''

r'o'f'.r'r.

di ' ' "! i^-l '":',' - 'lr. , or -'' ,.," ",... i'ro nrionartcroi\ an i.*,1'.ii,',,,"*" **" *";.d . dnrnristc' thcsc'crntoris 1 h' t r'. r'ua- $. g."* "P aucracies agcnG PcIr'"'r " of ihc f ateLf or s cvol,r!neni icw trdnnrirdion,bulocscil bv shDdingarnics 'rrcd i n r 'cr'rtrr'\ \-"'ndir'^s{ '"r' h" r'r"J"1's 'i'urf i r,i.,',.r"i ' ,; ,1{,,,..r.'-..". '"''"'.' ' n d ' } ' 1 p ' ' \ _ ' n ' " h r.'rn qr ' l ' 1'
1r'r'J | r d r li c { . d J N ' r rr' i'l" L r rv n '\r "l'' "n ..i"."". *.i1,' ll"- ,..'-on Pcoplc rio see x'hrtcd 'l]lnnic ir, this rtrrovcr sc vas synonlnor th tro.r ir. ' \r' ''r'-r"f nlc"l,i.l .j l\, lt'''I lnhr"\r

"_

.";. .d e'.,i'. ,i "(l' smc ol r PUbk lLkiri urc(n ns revn'. 2) lhe lrr ph'as of rlrc quotc i5.ru.i2l Thc bourgco P"Hn notjr.1 rr frcr imnutioMlncrl. c.ordnrgb Halfiai !)l i'krers rl rn oDDosnbnb.rs.en fttc Dd rx'dy brr " ll,u.. !' 'r..t.t,.,,.u'..rp".rr.,,m' r'- 'lr r{^* n ' r _J'1, i"".'.',,'r" ,,i

'',cr,"ri, -r''.
',..

.-,

.', " i-ir"',,,"'..' . ' r '

."".""i*i.

T'r\

";;" " '

r-

"."

'rr' ' i'^ r' r ;, r,'h" 'rr'r'-" 'r'

{ lrh\''drh\ i"nr
7'r s '\irr1'''J'o'rdJirvne

icaoftl,. DublicNnsbscd nLm.iendvrsi. Lhard.onrs. bur il icc n.t bc dhnncd l,y D:'tidlar n{crcrr ( leari iIr Princidc) an.l Loold hc a [uer of mnal 0p,.].h to a objr.tirc order, tl' is b sr' ' L rlr"ne\ ' ! 'r, r- r11 otr': a.la ' 'rL " " 1 lr" ' 'lL r 'ril', -...,i., .o.,i.,."'..r - - J ' nl' o"n rr'\{ 'L' "d

''t. "-.i,',"e rt', r' q'r|' ''rn' n n , l q . , h L l \' ' , d n . , " o. ihc noon dl generxLrre(

L.L\ol tle {n. ,n I lrr'i. Il"'n'l" ll Dulii' j'lr"

'

i" ' li,rt

d,|'-!',''//'.'''.'''''''||i'\'|''|:l'

"-"e

onccrhe rnrc {ascon'nLcd

L', *i' l^\ - f" ,'Ph1' L'u'rr\ iur.\ ! -couldr ' a ' - n . r i (:ivil so'ctv dre ro cx kc on Dublic rclcvlc'

".," . ' ' ' v " l ' " u . ' . ' p " .' ' , ; J J 0 ' | . ' n 1 v ' "

ii.,i,''

'r.

, . , , ' " r ' " ' r r ' - , a " P ' n a - -r ' r h e

loplc5 ptrbli. usc.r 'hei' rc!

:n'. ,r,-, -.-'.

'' q'

i -"lli'
(l' 7)

lvnh rhr s.n.rrl.trgory ol prblic sphoc crblishcd,sc.an no$ Id,k rr rvrrl ol llabdJ! norc sp.cilicargurenB siru' DUr i8 ri rnrti,,)r. Ali ns nnnxluc.ory sedion, hrt 7i@:lndn"t is nrq.t\iz.(l I rcca.cd scriesor thenres: rrc socilrruduro. Ftni.rl tun.rionnd idcology analyzd ' l , ' { l u ' r l r ^ ' . r r r n i ' l ' h . ! l , , i . , 1t l c , c n d r h c ' ,f " i ' 1 cgc.rnri!. lrNli,rnrrnr.ri1ou8h.hc b.ok l,asperhps ol bcc rrr ollLtr il)r irs ccour l rlc dcgcnertion ils nrnudon rb. Dbli. stfrer., rl). orlirr lrguDcDt abou. onc is b.h n.oFn'l nrl nrc ircrcring. I hrcuAhot, ,r\ t{r(rr ii l 'h,nr\ li'nilur ro rddi,\ of Hab.,mJ\'\ ' s! !s txGqa ncltr.(lt, nrnrionaliz.e publi. spherc (orn ef,icrfand urhar coporadons the in n r,'t11! ol erlr r*n1 (ri IiN, c fa'nily $as rfronsrnkd as n intnnlrr \tnh( rl'!r S'otrndc lxrh th. e\zlarire alr'nxton .l ora'!f lile rn ol ..onon,c.dvny aldd b abor rnd nr tr'nit rn{ ol iB ptrirch3l h.ad in the pblicsphrrr. s . , . , r | [ t , r l , l nl n r ( v r s i n n r l l l c o m t r e n r s o r k r id n l ( i 1 1 r .s l ' . , 1 't ' . r ( l ' l k h r r f n ' r h a 'o , i r n r r dr o p l i ' i \ 'I h. r' t,ro(,$.1*.( inte(snrcd. tor exanple,arlynovcls |r\r,l !, ,nruL)n. r visnn]of iminate sentimenhhy,..nr nn[nrrn'g ni rl'. rurbrB ofrhc herary pnbli. sphcrcjur ho{ rl'ry s|lr,l,l rRl.,{rnd tle hean of pnvrtc lifc. 'lhc nnt.stnrr. ligurcsimpodantlyin Ha.rrdr tcouL: hc ttr'lni,r u'nlcr*rDdingofthe publi. nscolrc.so gcworI u^auidcd \nriln'lll by .h tnivrrexprin.cirs ol thc rulicR. o,nird r'bje.tivity or rre.ogal lmilr\ nrnnrrc don,ai', llisrnnrlll.le later rzs rhc sour.cofpr! \rtc"$ i!' tlr 'r"J.," .c' { , J ,tu,cJ r lr( i' r.ornr" (p. 23).l'r '|r nr\ .osalramily, pnvtc mcr nor mcrclyr|t nlcn ol nr.csitl. a: in clasidl Crec.c.nd nor only thr protxny{n$i',t prir.y or Konomi. .nrol .n her Rlther, rl[ hrily ,ui uDdoskd a ar lcar lDrilly .lilLL .ntrl f'.trn'nrtai'l'nn",l'in Ju{ {.,.nri \tricrv *.8 spln,so c.ootr,r rn{l li,,nil) (hc nfimac sder)s.r dirnrl.lishd wnhin rlrc prirrr r.lm. Thc n,bjdirny h

lr,ilt ru,tu'rd Nrs aDdien..orieDed lR..s.it wrs playd ,r in {lrn,rs {Ad aor e .her n.r rs ol tlc h'nily (rn'ori',9 rh. irlea olTefe hy.he srnin.rrlit(aturc ryps In tl,ir sly dr fe.onceivd familyelFd l.a r, n !{on rcrtrLtnin ofhunanny nself.o lr mph{rizea.liHoll. rhe rtrnrrnyot ns hcad.This rced on rlr pfivd(owrcrsl|iPol nnr tpdrt. bur rhc orion of Lhcin'inrc lrily cxdtrud llurr i$ .oc, Lhusprovidinga kcy clc'rnr ol r|t tlsc .on(i!trsrcssol rhr bonrgcois. Thc family w! hclicv.d to br irrlrprndcnr ol rbc narke! kbercrs nr rrurl n {$ prol'nnlly cu8hr up ir rhc requircncnb ol rl,c nrrta. lc rn'bnrccc oi thc lunily as an qcDL ol r,.icry tcr sinulhr, .1\,r 'h rn'nitr'rd.run,iprid f',rtr *i(r) Drnts k\kal itsll in rcsnuaLion ofrhc liniy n('nlrn, on rheo 'rnd, rlE $crchcd ro8.rh&bt p rir.halrurriry: otr lc ,hcr. tlq $crc bord to orc norkr l4 hunrDckxcrL5' l\ r Drnicd i'irnlual, lcrt{r,$os $nsr$o rhn,gs onc: l oN,cr of Soorls pcN n ok hun'u b.n'g rnrnrg and oa, i.t.. 6urq.n.nd Io ( 55). hhily $^ idul t.d rs rhe prclt unn rcnln ol nnnnrcrrhrnnshF lIr$ccnhrnn heings w. uq hc 8isol rl'c fnnill, wcn mrln,g n,orc .in hunan (p. ,r8i. At r,. fln'r nr, rl trrnnlq of rhc family p'.n,is.1 lil[rii,r! llon rlrc con a \'inc ofNhrxisred,fronr 'rccesny, bNus. n sas r rcahn !'J t,urc intcioritylollosing i! trr lwsn or.t cxtcrnl Itrrtxar. In rhk sp{ifi. notionof humniyr .on.(Driin of $1,..xiskd ys promulgatcdli.hin rhc lrrLoh rorrd $tnh pmniscd rcdc'prion fio'. rcconrirf dt $1[r cx'ncrl vnhout cacping nro a traD!.ndcDrL r0rlN Ih! conrft)rn,ns trans.enden. ofuhr was nnn[m r'ft nrccccnr !,1lrurh thar raisdbourgcoiiidol,)slly,vc iddon,Ey nsetr, frrr lnndnnblly in ihat arcawhercrhc spriccc.f 1* f'nnl originated (p.43). Ihe fa'ily htrp)rirlcn m'.irl l,,hNl.r the immanenr .ririquoa'hcl'usc.h fuhli. sdrcru nlf. In, n rughr rhar therwar b'dh, c$orirl !) hur'rncsr rhat.ononi. ororher M(uscokl nd fukr iq.,, l-nrnrurc ofrh priod.6p.iallyscri.nncnrh nfllcl\ lil( Ri.hrfdson! P-l, relidon an fcilirr rhn \x'.

scn$ ol hr Drrnnc$. Thi\ u2s2 ndtd ot.rs of 'lrif .onGnt cvcl,'t,cd rh snre: by bLoi th. rur!'rcdcr relationsllip ''Thr r.rios lxtwccn auoi Norl, rnd pulic .hnsed. rchrnrshitx luwcctr Priearird Thct bccnrc nrnndc 'nDrual iniriuahrho trrrc p$rhologrc t nr.rc(.d in sh2t ua 'hunatr,ir scll:loNldsc,and n cnrFnt (p. 50).Ar rh. $nE nc, c ircrarypbli. sphcrc hclfrl b .l.vloPrht rincivcy nnxi(nr ide of.alturc I in rlln'onous realn: ''Innsnuchs ,untr'c b..amr ..nnorlitt r us ,iallf cvolvcnn& lrlitr,c nr rhc sp.cili. rcn\c (r\ $mins rht prc.cdsn) cxi{ rrr'ly lo nsorn vlc), n {N ained 3sc o o rcdyk,l'n fr,liusnD drroughwhnhrnx icncc ientcd subjc.rivny.on, nrnarLwirlnsclf 0. 21r). .onibDrnDsof thc Bcton.l rl'i\ r,,hje.vnl.thc Arcarsr sJt'T ay in the d6cllicrry prbln loc to rhc poi.ical rrn'{hl f'on n"aing opnrnr l n^'rtrriindl bq\ llrr 'l-hns rbrxlli|x. drly ph.r r' nnnrk t, $Lb6oa si,l hours b lirus n(c ot Brnnh hnsn(s .n 'd nr coafec rde, nrhdn'grhc l.rs, ehirh f,ar.onrn,gimo cv- dcr houscs rhlid dmc hy .ir.u|xtnn,.lrtrtl('n id 3,00{r coffe wjlh r corc ol rcg1a6. Tc of thc righrcil L.ntrl. cach out .onvenlrion ol these nd. cncbsbrunchcrl into aliais ol i b r r d n , n i $ r n t n n d p o l i . i c s . j o u f l k o r o p i n i o n $ c c c of zred,whichhrkc Lhcthousands sial.r.i'!l{s in Lonon wcr oii.n UBcdar parlc zd tlroujhur rhc.ou!t. I hesc iD ulr.lL. houscr nrl rcplicatd rlrn (nrrDkrhc rylcoa .onrivi.l.x.hnn{c. l FFnc,salons,p n iBtitriiotrsl@@d in prir. bnles, prtd a rru.il rolc, brid8inEn hcnr' pti. spctu dornrd bt a.iro.b *n[ th. cmcrger s l o r ' B u rp ' l n r l t , t r l i ( p h f l e . h r ( : i ' r ' i \ . t l l . 1 d d n \ dr.r t.g..l. r .spcll y cadni.sr'ns)oth.r $rs or pe} imjtutio$ !$ rcry rnal plr. Th. Iubli otrrsic hs severzl ledurs w.rc.ru.irl. hc rs h' allrhcscirNhDC.s, p.hrD r,r b ic was 'a kind ol :i ir.r.ousc that, xnd l,'' lD p'lsPposs rhc quftyol sror$,i$cgrrlcd raus but lo*d[d (p. li). ()r.outre, d,n ws nDt lnly rcalizcd, l'( i,l(! hr, r mDorGn.eofits o*.' l-his nnru silliC snDtrlhnLoudt suspend o r.$ t' r,ru nc ,{nrn rcles "nd qr hNc on .justiiibl InGt hr sihin ,hr rcn ,rrlnl

is Dubli. prupposnrs rlrcd cla$ in.efe*-liicnd-oFloc rrlaioDswcrc nr d irDt))$ibc(p,l3l).'the Do.nrol.on! n)n inkfcr r trur or ritrpolicy.hus u crgi cd tc ''b':.krins ol su.ui dillrctrccs.1h wa, i un hrkcd roa *.ond crudl frarnc,rl norionihar ntionl rr|1rnn.nrsas r|[ so. arbne ol ant issuc.n llowcrcr ofrn rl[ orn ss brcrched, idcarl rl'c b.st monalarynrnr d nor rh rhe nlcnI ol c sprl|(tr es snpposdb .rry .e dnt K.s nNtn o,lizcdas vaihblcclain.-Ihird, discnsnr snhin u r,.h r publi. p,rsupro\rrhe p.oblenariza)n nrcK ha. ot ' . n ' i lr h c nh J J r r l o n , r N ' o n d p 3 6 r \ l l v h , l npn\ ovcr whi.h.hu,.h n.l srtc aurornics hitlc , crtrcircd had
i t . ' ' - .m u o P l n n . r { t d r J " u n \ r ' p n l n ! 1 r , . \ ' n ! i , . rasnnch r c publi. rlclincd its discourse lcusn,g oD arl tr,atrus of .om'non .1nrccrn.Iion h, the cmc.Ai'r{publi. estublnhd iell 6 in.lunc itr pdn.iple- Anpnr sirl, ..cs ro ,uliral p.rrdtrdFlxrls, plys,joum"rFhrd t lct nen trl.lrimontlc cDri,n,olrhr.lr-dbaringptrbli.. Ho$ rr,lurir. rln publn n,iBh br in nt gi\rtr nNrrr., il "\f' ronld n.crdN iscll oif cndr.lr a.d bronr .onv,lidared .iquc; tur n lvrys undc6hd nd lnd nsdfin,netred ,litllin r orc n,.luivc Dubli. of all privat pcoplc, pcnans ,lhrinsohr r q {Lrc p.opried rnd cluuicd{s readf's, lircnc$, .t stJc.rrrn: .ould rvil thcnNclvci ri dre ir'k.rof tl[ olJicdr 'hr Mre r'bjc.r rodi$u$n,r" (p.37). 'I his lilcrry pobl. rlnicre produ...l rh. pr/Lrnr ollnerry ' i ' i ( n r n l \ c J l \ , ,l l , ' l n a d r h l l c 3 2 ) . h . n n i u nh . ' \ c n ' i r T _ncre n: nnd r.ndeF {s not initlt slrp. lr "shn re ic{.B ol hc r,li|fr ofS.hill.r and S.hlqcl{l not rgard 'hunrclrcs a !x, llod ro. lu'niDus nrnbrl a.rny of 'hGrr,'lclyjgnkoatheprivat p.oplrrih i'r.rer t r ' l i ' ( , a , u , cI ' J , l h c c n ' h { u u u ' k h / . J ' t , I ' i 7 , l r r l r n ' n { , i f r n ' , i r , i n , n , ' 1 . . n JL l o u ' \ ' , ' l ' u ' , , h j r , h l " { 1.rrnrD coccm ht .old Lr .arric ov.r iEcrly Db ,'l { ' r ' h l c l-hc pr.c$ in ryl,ichrlc frrc-s,Jvcrncd l,uhicl dcusnr: pnblicsphcc sas fpn)tritcd rt rl). prblic.a,rivntc lJcollr itrrkinF usc ol rcn 'ar, a.d {a cshtl|c rr n rtn,c'c or ( 'ni.isnt or public aurhorrt Ms oncoalucn,nnlly tok'nnN rh( tuLrc cDlcrcn'l'. trordol ld.rs alrcay .r,'i'1tr!lNnh

'D in{-r'hi\ l rhr trl Jrd 'r\ r'u\ l' dn'u*'on 1l a.dn',J rnJ lr' rlre''r' 'md''rilrl'vunF\'rrhr quA""n , l " i l , r c . u \ c ' r i s r r v\ r ' \ a r h r r u h n r s r n c u l "l ,'b.i'r,, Jon r{,lu"t l'"" 1'rr nrw t)Dhl" 'phcm f ' nil qi.rv nHrlc is n,irialDoliticl D2k tlorgl 'omnmmn' ro the taitf, rxl nscni; or "itselr(r't. Nli' oD$ior)as rht onlr lSrnk sn'r.c otis In (p 5'l) 3
'n _' l m!uJ) 'r \iaL"|'(' l' 1".'rl '|tr\"...r1'.F l''prrn !'..'lr!,'la lrc-\"'"il'i) l"\\r' ' ll bb{{ nd 'lr' ! rld ) d un nd li\tr

n'g i'nanciri.ririr. Icvollim lollovcrlqtrickly, nd fro tlr pubicdhcou$crs bcsnn,ins wrsn D'Lrol orgcois n ru.h playcd .entnl rol., rnd hor rs Dob !.tior. ll'c .llr ov.rnight rD cxro'linart rangcof pulrlidn's spransp. I |t Con{nurn ol l7!,1 dcLlJed rhd rl'c llcc Lo'nn'uniu. rin' of nks i o)n)nn*is onc oi tl'c r )r.(nrB riahc Germny l4g.d hcnnl lran...Th.rc1he p{$li.\ rntior .,ni.l debarL polnnl nxtc tml plnc. prcdotrrirnd/in ol rlt prirdesrlornll ol rreDUrsoisi. (p.72). I |t nol'ilnr 'cmaind.otr,/rtcydqJendcron th..oub rd rlnrslnild !) dselop n,oDg rnorglr linrs or .onnurnri,, wnh lluF , 1 , , ' n ' , 1 1 , - ' u , ' . \ r ' t , . ' r t r ' t 'r!' , ' . . r t r r 8 ' . ' , { , ' f , l ' ( " y scp:tc lior ri. fnrc. Noncf,cl.ss,.jourlswirr lb|ni.al . { , ! n r P l u . ' 1 " ' k .rln l .br.l r,c,nln{ ""rf ""r".' $cn il tht lDhinlrfli.ng oarhn pblicr!nnrd hnnd. In Jllrlrr. wrrr'*,\rn. drgrrroi rAoru,{rl Las l' I.'li, \tlna s.ar{,,1,1'r,I H mJ( {, c\{i rh. r run'i' r.rndrions: I n(ial pr(oinon lor lis !l.rlrp. t'uraois publn sd'.tu sas a m l.t tR, 'cilnr{ ,l-r lb.'l.d, macrl]nnr ii tc apn.rcol smi rcprou.rior s nN.h rs p{sibl. r rntrLr priv c ..p1.lcli !) rh.hsrlvcs ol ol u,d so hnll) .orplcrc 1l)cprivtiLion civil r).i.ry (p. 7l). Ihis ntntrri,D irLior ol cw ad $nrHcr scscol' triu.r s ncc tdr!'l ol produ.rivcpfopcrl w r crucial ,ontributio.ol.dr.1i\Drro th. publicsDhcfc. Nri rH.d.d r '{ 'rr Conrr'rr I rlx ,u'l'..ron of.,v'l h\, $h"n l,r{. pirrte lia.doN actu Auramc.al. c$rc nk InnA ,lin,cnul Frnt irf Frsons$d csrablhhed. .orrcsFndins r' rh nrDg o$Drb oi .onrnoiiBn nenarltt rnrnDg (urrcd nxlivnl"nkn' [. pbli.spncre. lush m ll pec |lc NcrL hl l.8rl nn)jc.6, ll suchlcgalsubic($w.r..joi'c or ,n r n'orc or lc$ uldilid.nrir0d ca.cgofy pcBdrs.trTnc .l f\rrnsion ol nrc$ trori(,isinro rc docoics hi*cri'n! I''d rv.n li.. flfl. rnbrg rrios brough!c {l!vcl,'[rcn( ! .irilso.icy is (|r privrsphoc cnracitrc{ ftn t)rl)li. ,rorny o s lirld dr.n, rnoughn lrcd ol lr 'r'L b|nnu d'.rcr n hc ng nnroryofpihl dc\.({,cr

il,Li"-d\ ''. 'h' nnshl r'culrl'cdr_ ,i"-1. 'u.., -"'' ' r ' l k ! " 1 ' 1 t rp h . f l r \ r ' ' 1 " 1 . 1 ' t r c t J m P l c l B t \rl{n 'l- il,-"',uu- 'i '1. -iu'""n ul .trn'ilrl' r"n nrr'd ll' rr'" rA n.'*, , rf. tlr\(lopm.ir ul lihli. 'h'oxr\' '"'ran ol Ilrtrnrion d\, lunA'nlontrrrion 'rudrr' ^nl''r F'h'' 1,"tri',rh( Dtrl(nr'nFr'onroJirt.rrrt l, \' r' lhir,n r@ arft i- 'i-"li.'.-.""",.n-on ' l ' L h n { ^ k c \ " l x r i n , r l ' . " n r ' u r ' " l A r l F l i ' i 'r l u P p n ' { ' rcvrt ro violcNc n, hd thrDugh 'h' shilicd sry l'o ni.l.l.brrc ol tlt Publi., n Lool rhc l{r ol r pennancn( controvcny bctrccr tlt governngPrfy nn LhcoPPosnirn ' rn Frrnft rDrrlicrhatoiti.allvdhrrc(l'lii'ali$us2ro$ Lv1' rhrn r .nI r.rr r|r rr!llc 'l 'hc .iSlrc.rrl' '{n'\ n P U l ' c 'u n t l i'',rri'xl m{di";rlt. l,.icl rlt.,{,,r!'o r Rdolft;. Icrcrus norhn! liktrlt lrish hrlanenr' r Do|nid Pres wnh nsaknd I t'1, n tl'( vcr'\ rr brfu'c ,* *ri'- '.,r,ry'"ppo'ir-" \ L h LR ( \ , , l u r i "l r , l h Fp h ' l u p c r " ' r r h c r I ' B r l r r c n ' n p 'lrrr' fhc t" 'rdint 'f l'r'1,rrr( 'ni rligur' r'"'., .. l'(u r'' ; '' "rn ! Ir'lr! .l"l-rnl[r"r'l\ "'ri']Ll8hJ rtrc l7;0: lh! Il')'i'('is u'1c !rrr' rnl -r'r,n:r, ' 1 " j , d c c r l , c I t n r a u , n n i r r ' t r 1 n i ' ' r ' r h t sI ' L L l r d n ' u u h ' r l n x 1 ' l { ' J r n , t h . A . v c " " n r r - r ' i { n r l a ' I n ' h l h" l r i (his. as.rnr rhe nn .'r lrroniirg crrtcc Thc tr.nsi't lr Msrrtr govcrnncnrsSros nnnu!',n,qol rh.Btrcs(kncnl

lrro!8h clnsn?l trono_ C..cptually, frcn rh phtsitras or tlrc tnarkr*cr scenns I s. n us fu.irl rhar tlp her naturl order Hcn.c, .iril $cicty .ol tc undcrrood as nttr' Inl rcF'din* DMcr rd .nri'-bon. JnLlib da,urc onh 'nr'r' "l d'q;lrrng th( ri8hr PUh(i.\ lor dllokrrS ib rnll 'lh. unsurinnlnrrc ^n !nil Jcvcl'{'n,enr f'cdnd(d I ' v cP u b h \ l ' l ' " ' r ' 'rehr;,c! nc.i,nn rhr hn.'l "n rrfd "' ol publi trhc' .n\nn8 rhc lufl s \ub' | d ;rEna o'din,i'on 'o 'lt tr.cd\ .l , invt (l lflc rYlf tr.n ri lr iculted d rrFrfds Pow.r:,nd rlonrirtion ll!s rl'e con_ {ituri,nral norN i'nDli. I n,odcldl ,ivilsoci.rv rh3r b/ no 'u r\ rai'rt rl' {{r fl'h 'r{r'ddxrrn\ 'ncrn\,.'rr!\,d In rhr Fnnd ol \ $ouhl r' trn; la m. "i(lmnn( horcvcr. th publit rill ..!srood nsll cb$nxl ilo*.IiItg, as usirg its .'nnrl dcblc n.r ro chrcr .o l'n"nss or r) crc'lisr poL(cr,Lur rarhcr o d.ovcr laws nmrcnt t r{ f., nr ol sirr. " hc'donrnrion of tlr Pl. n.mrdin* ' its o$n ie, srs ar ordcr in Nti.h dornairr iccll rft Lo . h'blic dcbre sas sPPosc tnslorm o,'t di$ vd. ink, r rhaLin rhcpublic.onDc.iri,nrof plivarc rgu cnl .u,c nno bcinx r rhi oxcns atxnr shd ss pn ticallv nf\\rD rr rh. inrc'c{ nl rll ft i: 33' llc e. ( r._ n . k , 1 , ' n l r , , n o ' r " . " n , 1 h i F L D rr l u r l r n l c r o f l ' ' n t s l r $ { p u r c h r D ' , ' n r yd . t ' 1 , 1 r ' l^ u ' ' i ' n r l u r r n , n l " n ' i l v ' th!uuli' !n"', 'n rr'nflr 'cmrrrd '@'Al n' rh( wnrlll or lcrr cven s ir suncd Pitiol Inn.ions h 16[ l oldr,clircpDbln nscon*itrrivcol.hcNhol.lclevrnt.itizcnry. fd l'1,(rtrr, rn.l IUDc'ry ^"n,' lrp \.!. n\ '\d.'"'L' -l,"isi"n. tritr;nt "l rh rmn.l,h. d'rl not lH\c 'o lr vi.rr s rrnrions oftlt Prbli. spnerc ui could bc cr' D,rc rer is \Dcre lcrl nifi.ari,)n ol a {rn6 .ra'ncd c(n icauy tu rhc Priv"rc \Phcre" {P I5) Thcat rlualiliaonr 'ntr, ai is. tlt flllv.xFblc aD dnld n "ubnonoos nk. nno.hc rrrionalcrit.l diru(c o x'eD.onp.tcnt ;!! rc s;n.r in.ercr. For rh Drivrtc Per$n, thcre wrs no l,r.l bcrw.ci ,o,. rnd.14,, ri lona a! rl'c/,',t ws rrs snuhnuslv ar osn.rof pri{at. p'oPy sbo s.r)a' rhr srrbiliJ ot th prcPeny ofer a3 r Privrc ont ro t)t.{r

(, 8?).so.rnr,lNrs tr D'cnom.non rharHnlxras (r.hG younIMrx)ses in n the oriSinol idslogl ii,,r{r.sscsofrl'c irsrlll i', rhc i,ong sc thrt grcun& imrno( criques lell a\ es.ril*s lake.oscDusncs:
alionr of rhc qrilll ncfsfit <rio$i,s i', ih csni,lf'lny, irthcr. ir an asF 'h' thrt 'hc !r' r 1u, i" ', .' " r ds un{'i:; rrihio. cvcn ircnl! r,' ptrryls . r !ofn iusli.?rn,,, thn nl('to '{ i6onsn' houltl be 'hr .1. !,'Jrs,

,,,1i',. r.'l'i, r,i 'r ""|'c r'{ 4

L"i.ft n!{n

. nr"l('.

ot '\| I'nll! in 'l'"

lr .hrpio 4 Hrbcrmns rn)s ro ilcology,.stJc.illl jn rh '(i!! ol rh nr*r "adv.c idca! rd gutcf (hinkcF ol t$c d2l\ ln)n Hbrf,s ,ltc rnr.. Hcrc rlc nokn. ,|,rtn'h lftlc, rlr phyri,).rs rnd Rousa b Xani I r f , 1 ' r ^ H . g c l , l t f . ' r \ l r l l . r ' d l ' \ , l u c \ ' l h . $ h d t r h (n ' J : , r . ' 1 . , t ' r l ' r l r l ' d , n r ' 1 n . , 1 . r ' r , q i ' - n l t , , ' l ' l B o l , i n i ' r r , .rr '(MDed lbnofKrr roth. I his repl(s tlrt rons !,1 l)ul)li. opinnr 3s rht !n.rc opinidi Or arbnr t-'yicst ol aohrr,lindivnhuk takcn ir! th. ggrt{rte, ihc rl,ubtio.1r dnorfs in Lhr ri.orr ispcsc.l opirn,ns, (l thc oPion Rrk'. publn opinior.o,..s ,r rln. .onmon r'.toftrodc. k, 'rl(r nrorc xnn?lt ! l ri8* I'tld bI rlxs. *lr io,n r 'Ii,r'rl'.nti.al dcbk o rn sDe. l),\t)irc his rnpntli. lotoinc ol absolLc $vocigry, ll'l)ln:sdid brn,I nct rsDcroopi',iln] bt nlcnrifln,g n NirI ({\(irn.e (xnl .onraounts). His \or dcvnhrtion oI rcr' Akr,\.onvi.r, ret r .oraspondn,gDpsr r.vrludon of ,rlid,Dinio.. h it r^s I).lc rho lullv frcd DDi,ion f'un l 'l r.ri" fu' n"turli'( Rcd.'nrrd.'.rr^r,u'.' (nnf,red opion rl r's fnrnnhlll flircnr f.nn .d' 'I', ltr.'e" opn,bn tl r lnn s.cn 3se vultri The Dht \i!tr'rs nrovc rill tuhor rlong il,is t)arh ol sQrdrg.r rit,k l\onr oDn,i,),.t leai fnr rhc ciighrccd t)!Lli.

RKrcru.oa ou6c. ea. mo.c .ompl.|. hc PhtsF (r8 sDlc out in awr of an lbslutsn c.nplcmcncd by a pubtic ;pcre ar {.s a plftc or cnial ac.vty; Rouse"u {nrcd dcmocra.y*nhoutpublicdb"re (P 99). rcseDeral of will {s onctheles n rrt ol tn'bli. opion, r conscDsus rubMnce, hlrs rrhcr an.r8u!n1. ll,srcrpolarizc{l Inth sidcs follosd cuzofsrn,.tion lo *.! lfcr h, anrl o tcll i (o powr" (qucdon P l0l) sn.c !u(r wasrhe obi o crnicalftfldn,n nr ih sn uill ilc, e .oikl rr nre.pErd c h I qr'{ polirical.r'lc Gsk s5 to rnri,rlir polni.sin rh. nrn!. of moRfty I Nclls tuth. nor voia,tollou_ ln h Druit, Ki l)(onc l[ pismalic ins R,rNscuon Lh. irle ol rhc uill ofi[e wholctoPl but rhernirrfnlighcrcnt rhkcBon rhe the Dhi,,s,phcsand ccnonlnrof c.ni rcsn, lii tr?stht.ror fuly dcvcloPed aphen.BtrhttrsvG, Kant Dhl(dy oae burgd,npDlic 'lvhat 13!:nli,l cn'.m? iriivu|. $ould ha Ennrcrl itr thc r hrrl inE worring h.n My oui oftutelage. n,bilnyro nrl. urcor undrrdn8 wnlmurdretu.l dir.ction rnlish. nnont bc6me norc lD$ible in tre publi. dikourE ln rcg.lll k, cnlightennrct.rhcfctore, rlinlinS lor oneslf Ni hnrkiszloudd th. u5co, rcasn sccncd coincidc ro {nhnrpublicuse (p. I04,connnnirarionrdcrnicrn'we ol .conll!'lhus ev.n Knnrin! noLions u,{cBahrn cosno_ s c r c c u n r r u r r n r h e( t n m r n ' o n 'd ,rrirm.ndvnn'. (a crlldon f,.igtrctroc rhink;l abnnlbcinss. wnen s o dd.cs the 'world, or b b n i ot lE orld, r tublicrphcrc sas sn.irl !, is dcniionll vcryuritJ anrl .liJity.f Lhhurr.n sD(ics wasreverl.d.iD Prr, D) iB.a_ Drny k,.ioin in Publicdi$u.se: world crc Pintd h hunanny a :pdics, bur h har sxis. i' whi.h ns nity a, t , c !n r c , i b c l r , n d p t ' c , r n c c , l , c " o ' l d o l , r i r r l l v , l c b a r i n E ,(,xli,'r tubh. r ' rh. rin'c w. tu{ rhitrt rrnhin c ir l'.ri(r |fu'sroA {',ir- rt i06). EngEnr.n t!'c PUhln llnN. sas rh nds by shicl r.o8i.iF Driv cllsof r,!ri,n'rl t{ople .ol b. brcughrinto lmrmoy. l his .onll nc_ !DD.r bcussdi.ty, prricll.ly thc privi 0conimy, p.'i(. in'u 'o rhc urrdi'Dn!lJ' ru r'ir',{

n'orlnJ.rya.ould b.ontlkd snh ru be rlB n n { r \ $ . b m t u m u ' d . ' , \ o n n { r u !r r d r h i j u { c c frir,icc var inrfttrr h li.c commr.c.r! ll Krnr ollrr th fullf philosophy boraois publicot ncs, Hcgcl!'jlrc rh firrcrituc, rlcnoun.iDg publicol e {ivil soci.rynr i(lcoogy. Publi. opn,idr harlthe fon af cn! nDn sensri w$ rlir6. g pcoplei Lbc lrm or prejud.es, k knowl.dg.: i rool r forunous for rhc or Ixn,nef. "ll!g(lrol thc rcdh ou ofrh ideaof c ptrbtrc ' n h r ' . o f . i r ' l r r d ) . l u r n r h r r r l r n r g o n b n.i l \ o i r r y ( , l i d r o ' , . , n { n t r kr h f p u L | r ( p h c ' . ,. n u n ! ' p a r e I ' u n d , , m i . d Ditionan.l i'N!rt. iio th. inr.rtrcn. ofpose., in $hi.h rutonomou prierrc pcopcreaed oN another"(p. 122). i, Ihis did not prcvi. tic basisld rrdrming polniralrn, tln,.itl int, r!nl authorny,lore or inkrcr imo rcaynr. (:nil sdiety (n,ld nor dpesc Fnh doinaonbut on rhr (otrary ..rluira{,i causeof a edcnq roMrd dnntugrnk N$ onll r shor rep ro Mr's .run.iarior of publir opnionrs a n,sk lor lFnfao chs id6( Th. ublir \dere Nnh whichMarx s2whnrcll.onlrdnrcd.o.nkli.rcd (rovn prddc or univesala..esibihy-rhc pbli..oulrl no onscr .lrnn r, bc idcnri.J knh drc rtion, .ivil soci.ywttr rllof iuidy (p 124).Sinilafly,ot.rrso. pr.pot oNir !,trld not bc sccnas equn?k'n to hlnrn lxinSs i gcnral. I ' n l , a d r l ' . n a r r l r ^ ' o n o f . r . n , l! . k r , . " n r d l c d h h . r . .nn,g.iisionol rl'r p.on b pul,lic n prnnrc.l hc Drrnk '.rh.lid nor offc..ue respne froo [bli. ctuions, drc aor l.unilyrnd t,c nnDtespher gekrlw. hnrltd lJt thc in F , . \ i r . o l L , l n t rt.L r ' L ' , h r l p ' u p c , 1 w n r h l . , p n r l , { ' . ' . \ r ' . . ' i u n I n M . r \ \ \ h . , , n ,' h c n . i " \ , { , 1 , 1 c J l a o r l * , 1 ! , L r !icry. nd Mri(r,al plzninS wouklcnblc rhc dcvclofnrcnr !l r nrnncfhcr seL rrce rrtnn ccomnicluncrions (p. l!r,) Itr rhis visnnr, im.a.Lion rould lE cnrarciparcd fDrr 'l'( drrds ol Rf,ial lboi and prndc rclioshipsrou lr l'{ lnn r|t nad ror anl legalrcgularioN Bhindrh. \I,tr\isr \i.N. l)oseve! yr sll (hc ici oa a.uol orlq\r,tr{ d*rARr ot sith rhe g.nrrl irlcabui onl},wh rh(

chn! ilai b.trrgo ciril s{icil @ni.u(cd c naruDl ordcr r't.ou.|girc ri* b lffDorious hunr rclati{xhips. I-ilrHls lilc Mil n.l li{qucvillc wcrc $illing. tlbermas n,ggcrs. ro hkc rl' rep of (i{2rn,g rhc norion of rn n' drfltirg n,rl olcr dcquaLcb groun r phikxophy of hkiorvn shi.h F'lnica woul bo.onc moralny.^.ccpringrl,e dhhn,ony of 'ru.lr ot crpnalisr .ivil s.icry, dr libeasn rl,r! du!dnp.d snuFn.,rcd unInrl.'nr|n,ri,on\.'rl,rivc t 'lhe not Derfer. lrccdom poliical ptrblic sphcrc, in eir ac counr, did Dot rer on 2ny nar hasis, ough so.,e brn of rl' botrrgcoh publi.rpherc did nr.d tobc dcf.ndcd hmugh -Il'e .omnon rensc pruen.e and ftnn.k k.y nru. that rlFt.onfronkd sas hos b 'naimri cridks o pbli.lte rhilc s sizc in.L.Rd rr ns.ongxnion changdl. lhis cn,BtiLion ofrhc public spherc sa nn incvibble esuh of r h r r n s i o nb . { \ . c n n r u r d i n l , l $ n r , r i , . n \ d , d n r n ' i n . l , 'pl.d upcnFs. "Fh. rnrl ,rnm' \ar rhL 'upi uf 'l,F nn'e. r.ytr.ctry: no l,)8c thr trnkite of publiciiy as such,as l,tl &cn uc in c.igliccnth (citury, br oathe claryeD.nr of th publi." (p. l:is). As tle Fbli. was.hli8cd, hocvc. tuhli obn nrll crnc ro sced d'rar, Dadi.uarlr shcn n *.ncd to ivolv r onprkiu' " rorard .ontorit/ 'l-h$ trnr. thh cririrl iscor6c. n wsrlrr ,oth Ml ahd 'li(qucvill. woric, n,. c*nnplc. alblt pror.cnq niorncs l{n t'\1uri,' Lt rrjurirics.lhd, rrull) ,rntdrrr. n, fiii.? tlou8h ln t)rr,oI protcctins 'c p6iltlityolir, opnioi itsci Hcr. Fc rl.nrt se rr innl theorcri t)$|n:

or dn.ordr..c

r,n{.bihr or unircHt tncru .iod'.tp. t!5) Ilt 'principlc or'c pblic spherc. fjricnt ptrbtic dikou*, {,ned 'n j.n :n {'cnFh 'n p.4pnn,oi ! ir c\rcnd.d rt I ' P h . ' c ,p r r \ r r , , u \ .i ' ! , o F t u r n t h , i u N n ' h . D r i v J k . , . t '

l inr.rcah .kisrin in fkian c n.

!(-

rsp.rsc b

stru.nl hnrnrnario

ol rhe public

{nhor [rilnnd rkqucville tln6 rcccttcd individualisnr ,mrpar.blc otion ol rlc w]oc a lcsi8ncdrnalvc t, !n{c iIcrlcr ro d.
txri'i,D o i'r.r6k i' r ptrbli. lph.rc vA dissui&d a\ pr.(Nhr .t)n,irDolorr lRrusc rft pairi."lr inr.rcr: wcrc no ronscr ner. \"11| r{,rr rrr,{kr'|, 'e opn,ioN inro rhi.h th.I br idlog. ,,r\ rrblfa(r l3^5c$e n nkr rr !r 'c,$on r'ol publi.opi',ir l.lcd rhc objdivc swac

l rcunderminnBofrh. foundarionotrtrcpulti. rp$c.dnr Jlnur. HrF" \u8gc\L, rhrorf,t,. (k,.d,,i!;i,i ut n. , i,rv "l-h( mndrl,t rhr huurBcon I,ulJi, \t,h,e p,$urr!d n' i, r \.F'z'on ol rl' ruhh.trun ,tr tfnd. ,ath l; { h J s"v rh' .hc t/rblr tplFrc, 'DJdcu of prN,r. pft,ti. rr., '.'r r3tsrr.rr J p"Lli r\ J"i,uhrind rl! ncrdr nr nfirry "nLl lirh rho farc, $as n$clf.onsitl.rcdp!tr ofrhc privrre rcitm. (t)p i75-176).Sr.uctrn rranrf{trnatn,ncarhcaboui,h.qt"",, $ privrtc organirrio bcg'rr in sngly! rstrme pubti. t,ow(r r r one hand,yl crhc rar.pe'r.rrcd rhe irnnk rcihn o c ohor shrc ad iry, onft rtirinc( ;&:r,c rir r4 kcJ. -hcput,t,,rp,cr. ki nR .sty I r.,nt,oflncrl a ' h c , l n r i r r r n nl 'E r " . m p r , l i (J n dp , r a r c m \ r b t u , r c d,h f (r'nro bc$ccnhr iNnnr \dcn rnd pri{re ifc brot rl rn snh polararnn faorilnd cononri. of rdicly. 'i,,nal{rn. drb{ Anrwayo Lh(onsumprior otcu u,u. l h r b l d r r n 8 o i r r h ' u n sb { u ( n , ! , , v , i r a i d e u b t i .i n . ',rqd,rnorttr rr'co\ ut 'hcn-tu, rh-r .n." Li.,t,mil). . r . h r i v r l !e t J lp c ' \ , n ! L h o i n ' t , . . ' , l i, h n n " ' q m i A h J t ' r $ ' h c u n g J i o ri u h t i . , n r c r n t ' { . r l , cx r ' q u J i r i c t N I . p ' ( . n r , n , n i t q i e , , ! . ^ c d r . rr'r'rtru'cd-'ntt h.n'crsrcrtrhrdrnof rtrvusionarl (rnn. Ihis hrppccd &trh bccaus. tscindtuatics!as N'de ($ ih 'h arc ol girm @rpohtiont m tEuyid,c l'^i ,n ul mx' popli, in rhr putt,!sphc,cnrdc r in,F\. 'ni n .lrFf, rldrc$rna rF .tJs dnn,n ot (tr, -,xI} rr(an\c. Inr cxanrple, shc ol l* proplc s.rc cx.hk(( J'!trn rhe aramhir or lktrd b privacosDtFni, ot rhr n'.,rLol prlurrio. hr(':0e )sis otcDrrxrivc rurr

:,lir: **1,;l :lri: :;;rtll:l;ilr: lilli

1"'l rtr'lrli' r'ntriirtruorr "' r' "
ntrDu ! r' "_-.-^ 'h-t i. Lt-urltt i' r{ r) 14

- ' t d ' t r ' a L t ' 1 n '

s und'd

L rdl! rh' nrr'r

l'i*.it-rt -l! ,'i 'l:i.J l;"";il=t*.fr; .,ir ,'i' l:li":l

::"'.':::""'i.il:,,;if ';;;" . r'rr'

:.,r.. .i.,:.i,,,, ..,,.,,',,.. r.f'

_ " tl1:;t':'".",,y1:;,1;,1;1 h b'1'rn'nB'r're

'd a\:'r''6hs 'n" I I : l . I - . . . - , t , ,, i ' r r i . : \ ' ' - ! m dr' n l ^ : : . . . . . , , , , ; ; . . ' . . , ' - , ' r r { r . { n n r ' 1 1 ' -h ' ' r ' . ' p v r " ' i r '\ c r r ! . u l:;., ,:,. h: ; '' '^.h . l l : . . , . . . , : " , n . n1 r;' " r ' " ron1'rt'nr'ri'r'r ,;..',. ..'t'' -,-,

l;.:;:, : ;,,,,,,,,,., i:"t;,;r'i,,1,1,"',1:i: ;",. ":':t' r- ,. 'F. 'r.Ld I'i J {'onl snu rP -i ""
'^.'," i-o"r" r''';r'''r'''''f :f il:l:"-"' r" tr"\r"l':d'1'r' lJ
illi ,.,,,,, -r..r,'j""." .,,r:,,""., { ,rcn I rhl 'c " f' | lr:,,:.'1,,.J..;i, "

'

.."--, h ^k

'r'r' , ''r"''.''"'. r,"+ ''':" 1ir:lill ',:.',i,:^';: ,'. .,, P"'l\ "i,,,,.. . r'..' r ' J ' c " l r " " ' b . * ;r,.,.,h. "1 . Ja
"lrhuut

iupplr" A

l'll::,,1 : : ;l :i; -l;. i '.'r'; " r" i'trh.r' {!J :"i" if _ r' "':
lrf n'ii' lrin.\{J', . l l, f n a _ " . . ,..,Li,_ , , , . , , , , . , , " . " . , , ; " , , . . , , , . d . , r d r r r , u , ] .r i laJr'r"\"'1 " i.-i ..i,,,.,1 r-,.^."'h'li'

.-1",; ' r ,' 1 r ' - r ' r' .' u r t ''' l'l:,,,',i:1," ' :";i*n "r"l- nr' r'i.'"r'"""F ' l:.;;.'i ,"; . ,r r u
i'.,.1.r,l' .,"'r'" 'j;;.rl:..

;,,i,", ,,d r..'r' i

(lr r1 L

dh' r''r'dJrnur " "'rrLr:

. - , , i l n t { i . r l u t rI ' r

'hr' '", ;,,.::,:;,.;,,- nn r'.r"{,.,.. ,.ni.r-.,,'.^, e!l . rrr'' ''i'i,':,.. ; ' , " - ' ; " s F " ' n J ' u ' r " m * ' t''t" t 'l;'.";,.i1

' :,lr-,'.:; "''r". " '" ''

(rnicrl xturil! ol publi. discourc bl a morc pssilc culiure on (onrnnDuor oi rhc one hand d an zpoliricnlsociaDilny -c i. rlnr,,lvl ,h., triqre 't-,it;' tt..'Trr.,",' ol tr s.!lr. wnich ncrcr ofthe irnk{nd S.hoolhad xlrca.lr pllcd p'.nrinem rolc. IIe 2ko borror cscriPons 0/rarn'r,, ol rulrurl'.! s..ial lif fion, Willirnr ll WhyLc's pu.silof grcuPne$ nscnd i'r ibelf ,!r, to il[srrcdrc lhnr pfticipnl\ i so.ial 8hcin,$ lor thc scnsc oJ re Dlalnd in virtucsofrsuntcr thar tunt nn rlc 'cmbers r 'r rlr ndla. o l ..rru'\ !Ll. \tl'e'c LJl'r-Jr '!" '^u'!r-lu'. '.rru'v. rh" rv."E..ts r.' ns , ,,'rn'y'.'.^r,unl lb h,'-u". ( 1.1\ 'n ul""'rr (,trrn!{ d.spitc tleir egi..l trd mtional iiroriy: rb{' no.c lior li.crry and poliricl dbatc On thc cw moder rhr corvivial .li!cu$ion ano8 i'tliliduals A,rc {af !o nore o, Lcs ioDco'nniil goup divni (p 163) 11 id not niun rl'r (hcrc w2s not n slnri8 .f .ulturc, oolt thr t uas ''o'rln. ' 'r"n{r n t' l1 l'r"n 'tndivniualI i*lction i nof rfuLul .fii(uc (and produ.rion) )rcds nriAh bc a.hivc.l , lrrbli. I:rsbion,irclJ. i'r rhe ,o pxDy ol nny oihers; liut n pDblic sPhc.c n$ll did nor . Rrrion2l crni.l cbatchad fno'Fc lr.Dr ch a snufior. ,' roDifui.y ro hc rcpla.cd bI .ontu'P n, xnd c w.h or Itr,bli( ,rnmuni.tbn unrrclc.l inro atu ol nivi uatcd e ,(rri,n,. wcvcr unili,n m nod'(p 161).Whc!c worls of lir;'rr, fr cxmple, had DIcvusly b{o aP[oPriarcd not r' ' '.', uAh,nl,id'Ll 'f,'J' 'A l.' r\"'uBl d'u-l li u ior ', l(. i'',,ldn"'l,- ur .'r' ') publi'.'uo\.'la n'lc'r trrr(liD .\c nodern rtlc uf appmpriarion rciDvcd rrre -'{ l r.r i 'nnmln. r'o'.'l'^u' ulkr nd l".nian'np'i ir.(j 1 ld).:r'l hus, lhc *orld lshioncd bI tl. lras n.dn ^.' ruUic sDhcrein rrrpra..c.nl/" (p l7l) 01.tcss,tlt f.fm Whd lrlDcncd urs th tlrccxPaDsion ,l priri.Drion sas tiully alicled rnnov?rions(har oPcncd ntrxnii. rcccs to thc pulJ)i. sphefend rhc rchn of high ,,'lrtr'c. c.A.,chcapere.liiionsofbft,!s {nor b nclion h'ghc rt!trn6ol rca.lcrt, a.crorlyof pr2isc urldrgsntcthcst ln l ir' . r, 1 . . ^ . . r ' t . ) , n w l l g r ' . 'r . r ' l i ' r i " n u r '1"' lo Jnp,c'i'riu"r l l 'o'. lr'll.fr'i" "ri "tu.'rJ

no!
'tf

$ s o ,i t r ^i \ ' l \ c n , c n r i r h . u h n ' . ) ' o t l r l . sl i . ' l i 1 ) -t.r h i l r

F'f"r.{ l.'.,ir''''" i

,.rr,.,"lrl

-\r'.al'i l nni,'r'l{n .1r'.1! '"r' ' l"'"

r{'

l"rnir i 1a\ 'rn". '""1{'!' r(" rrl o\rd1r\n. 'l ln'ili,tr: rl'r' bt\.n c(!i!'trn oD.rng.'.' rrr.'rDrmj: q i ' , ' l l ,l . . i n r r , ' r ,, .'rttn'l'l (lo.5 I r'.'Jr\d rl', ll,'1tr] tr,r\ ..n .14'r'. "'r,\ ! '{' ,"'l'li r' l' r't | ''i' | " " _ r '1 '. r ' ,.,..-1, r,, ','."ts t"r " i " b l I c t r ! ) v L" l o ,f rh. tn' ! \t,ltrr. x'rl i'\ itr'l)r'i\lrD(rf (ri'irl !1tr.,f"! l ch'in,r, rlr ' ( l n , s l t r ' l ' L r .' l n ' o l n , f . I h l ) , . $ r 1 ' ! r b n r r r f ( t P o l " r r l n n ' . . r ' . , r . L l ! l n ( u $ r n r r l ) c l l n r s' t r r ^ r r s r n l u n r I n i ( 1 . r l i ( . r h r ' ( , o n u r r D u b l ' ! l i ^ ( r ' l ' o i ' r n . c 1 . t r d . t, ' , t r n, l ( t n l ) l ' . \ ) l d r , r l ' ( ' [ t , ' l l ( t ( ( r . r ' c r h r r l' ' r'r"'-'ll" ', '.' rl'r n' lr r- l L ' rJ1 "'Fl l' ';,rl.,.'l' t"'l r'lin_1" ""'" "i.. f, 'lr '.'". '- i I'i. ' i i i l i d v r f " r l r ' r r i v l c . r i \ n i r i r l ' r r l i ' D k r lr h ( r r l r i p n b l i . l i l . i n ( l ' r , ^ i , l ( l i r s r r i ' r 1 r n t r Nr , l r l ' l n ' l ) l nl i l i i ( . l l l \ (lirr)s r l , ( r n x l f q c n ( ) 1 ! dh r l r n r s r t r c h h r s r r k c r o r r h r h t r r \ ! , i r ( o l ' \ ' r l ' n o l i ' r r n r r \ 1 l ) 1 7 2 ) .\ \ ( nn'tr'. i'D \irh ]n . t r D . ' i . n f , . r 1 t r ,l.' 1 n , . . ! n {rlc l d n n [ , o (,,r.' hrn rl r (l!i'r(k1nrk ol rlr Prinr.d n'xn.ir l, is ilrr wtr " i)'x ,'l 'l ( ll.6 ol thn !n' Dtrl,ln n(rrv ''r)' l.rr'! or thc rtr' rr'\i'l r(lrt5 irl ,on(dr!rA ' ' r ' l r l . r r ' i | | r' I i 1 'q"'r'i1" 'r-.'1,'n,'l " r r n r ( l h l n r r i ! ! l l t r' v n r r . o . r r nli'i[,1'tr,a'r !rxIdnrini!tr]'rlti{hItr'ii!s \ubr.(iv( ,ru,ii\ l,r 'rri,tr,xl irni\ni ol lr'l)li, rrrhtill crcn U \|trr. ir trli*h' ,i)lrifcl) lill b. !,os'I. (1, l7!) ,\ Pc'rnr r l t c , l D , ' l i r r s' o n e I c I r c s . D h r ' v f l , t r l , l n i r ) n ' r k n ' g ' a n \ { { l i ' l t r k ii ' r , ) n n r l i , L r , s . ' r a r r ! \ r u r i ' r o r l , r n . $ D u b h r ' r c l d i , n x n n l r { , \ l r r n n c s fn ) r n H i ' r 1 1( ! ' t r o D r n r ' n g r h o rl'l'r..rt'r' r\c" r(".'rtr ,rF,'trk1,,i'tr.r.,rl""r

hr. rl1 t),qrr r,rp,nirrns o tr)lril)l , , 1 , ! r , i c ,!.! l , , , , r r , . . . n ' in,.'rrrir(t I'rrrttytirt)o r i 1 1 , r ! r i r r r D \ n { ! r , r f i r t r o r r f \. r f L r r n f n ro l l r l \ f ,.frr. n$ Puhl'( tDtrlr un L , \ . , ! l \ i ' \ ' l l i t r ,' l ( , { l ( l f r \ ! r t r ( . l l ( I n ( t ) ' . o r r r n : .onr!q\ inr!'t\( rhc l.rt\c . { i , i , . r r h c J r c . , n , I , , n ( l , ( , D t c r h o f ! . i ,r, . , .t ..,rt ,. ,.,i i. ,1, r,'r, t\, ' tln t1,.ri. , o d r . n . . r \ l ! ! n . , s f ! tr t t r p t t r r s , r r t i n , . t r h , H r r ( , , , $ r \ . i h . , r r i . , d l { r u t r \ t , t r1 ' n r l trr'lr'r Il,.'s.!truiDt{i!tr1'trrnrnl t r , n ' l \ L ( r r 1 \ r I n Ln i r , r , k , l , D ri n ' r I n f r l i ( { 1 , 1 r , t t'rf r r o l , r
, i' r.'l IiL r.' ,!trN.'trrs ,,

r r , ! r n . , l ( | n ' s l r l ) ( t r i l , l n i r . o r i r { ) D , . , ' k 1o l n s r \,' ,r$) f'f'.,'i. llng rnj(: (o.{'mr\ !, r'l,!rrr,,l ,"r'l)r'f\ (tr th. rr.n\. IIrHmr\.b!rtr l\rh f,rc | , , r , , ! . r \ f ' t r . r . r l ' ( . r \ u , n t ) r i Du l r , . 6 \ ( r L ' r , r t r r ( . , ! \ I r n'l'. n,(rs .trl u'b.rnr.fnn, I lr trr^r rl',f (,n|l I h . ' , 1 , .! , ' n ' r r t r r t r ' l r \ r l i : n r h i g h o r r , r r l ' , ^ c r r l x , n , . L l , h ! . o u r { , ' t ) t , 1r l r t r l u l r o r . , \ f , l r l k ' t r n ' 1 ' n r , t N , | t \ t n r r . . t r , ' \ ! | ! , 1 . n r n 5 l . ' r , o . o , i A r l i L r t r ( l itrr!)l\cs .' Lnrrrl d s nrot, ri,r) \!trh i ( L N ! f r r o r r r , , 1{ . " r r . r r ( c r r n f ( l r l n . ' n t o l x l t r r , ftrre orn,ri{r,, l,c r'(n'hd\ ,'l rhr t,nr,li, t)|lir kxc s ' , ! , t r' d o n * ' ! , l l h f ( r s n n r r n ' ! t r r r r , i r ' 1 f n , ) s " r' ol p,,!rtlr\isn.rl, pl.asc " ( t , ) ! n l { $ . !t r o l ' i . ' , i ! r {. r.rk1 \!tr ,rl\ ."c rl'cs.,rr !l)l(k(1..ro'rli',g ) k r! rrrrr. k,,rh('rn.'lnr($i!trr: l rl'.trr'fx.h.s rorf , \ r L ' L ! ! r r r r ' , t r b r t rr ) t R n l , f r \ o r \ f d r o u t rb r . . i , i , r , k l ' ( r ' L . r l r ' 1 1 ,l 7 l ) N o ' h i , s ' r r i n t n r l ' l o r r r r l ,,,r\ nnl)\, ll,nl,'etlrr,lv(\d!'!,,11 IBtrrr .!n'ol ' tri,,f rhroft( rinn,f( r.Lr!rrhLl) i, \11 ' (trlrr','l t,,!flr(c'1rn (!r,riDkrr lr i\. II,'lrrrr,A L' , . . 1 , , 1 ( n r \ i r l ' i h i \ h ' . r k r l , r n n . l l . , r ' L r l \ f * n ii ! ) l ! ! r , h l , r n n t r| n , . L U n i l r l t r \ c \ r l i o t r . d ! { . ( r l r r ' ( i ' \ { , i ' r . , 1 !r , ' ' r.rii\ (r. rhd )r'n) dnrgunh(|. rltra hrr , . t l ' i r , r l ) ( n ( l \ ( . r h ( n n ! , h ' i o l , , r n r l i e t , 1 , 1 (! l ' ] , e

l t ' t , i . ' N ' r l . t r r f 1 , l r l i c n l , , 1 ! , g i ) n i k ! , i , r f , r , L r l ' ( , ( t r , , ] ) i /l . ( i , r ' o l r h . b , o x . L \ . r i ' , g l ' \ { l n lhfir rcr \ llrr!(l n, rr',trrit rlr \.r'!.l r1ar,{ rcr (orr "tr '"i.i'1,,., ' ' 1,,. ii,i,,,..|, ,,!,t'r. ,,, k) ollr rh. nilxn'1'ir w rhorr tit)l! r ( l , n u t r ' l i r 1 r l r , l u ( d i l n ro , ' c n , . d i c s , r r l , cl i , l i i r r l i , f . i , L r r { r \ o ' . , \ ( 1 , 2 0 3 ) . i il , l t b i f i r . \ ' . p h . . t ) " l n i { r l i s , \ ! \ \ h f n t i . , , 1 c l r r c ( , n r \ r i i r r r d \ g r o r t \ ! r f f \ . ' l (I x \ , ir I t, ,|l \tn'rrc l-rAinxlrr nao A1i, 1,.. D,,rnL,ik\, tt,\, hht tlttt .trtttt\ \!\t r i , , , r N p r ' r i , 1 r ) L h rp r l ) i r s l n ' d r r n h p l i r r . l n r n ( l i r * " rl,q n'l r.r bo born n) )

, , r . k ! r r l \ \ , , , 1 r , . , t r t r r r r L rn c r 0 r l o f x r i d i o l { ." , , 11\ rhrtrrNh 's,n,tr irnfrcr eorps o .l orl)orr , i \ . l ( r A L . , \ h . . D . , r * r r L \ l r r p ' n t r r t ) x L o) | r i n s I n \ , ,,1 ,i',in* \irh ir r.nn).'l('irnrl , r l ' ! 1 x r n ' t , rr ! , g t r ' n d r l r ! t ) t u L r ! { t r n r 1 n ( l r i ( t i l U r t 1 l , 0 t r vt r $ n ) b u r , \ t n o x l n r . ' . n t , . r t , \ ' l l r r o r l i , t r t rr L r ! t r L Lrh x , ' l,r(nrl cl) brr rhr gh oll(,n,! r, ,1p'csonrlxxe ' , r r , . o l r l ' r p u l r l i .r l x r l , ) f n , r h . d ( ! n 1 i h , f , l , r p r r L c \ . r , L ql u , r r ' f t r r o $ r l p x , a l r \ ) n r D , ! l \ t r i / l . n , r c a n ., | !r,\urrlc' |tr])h.h\ hrrir.rrrn{irrrL,(p,.s0f 1 r q \ q o r r L h cn r 0 o i \ o l $ \ ! r x l i k . h o ' . I ] , ) n , f r D A l , . r r L ii \,! { l r h { I ) , i r r cs t t ' o r oi ' r o r h . p u b l i is d n l r ' ( t ) t l ) 1 ) . \\ ,.f i,\ ,l,rr xrc polni.i rn(l $ Nrn, Ll r{i.rr r( . r \ f f ( 1 ' r n n ( 1 . r h f r l r c r i u L ( n r l i r n r 1 l ' 1 0 1 . i! D L "
' '.,la,,.,,1,,,

,,,,.,

1.,,.,,,r..,,'.t,,-

t-..,,'

t,

,. ,, i. Lr, ,l1i'!, r'r,,' ' | r l'ln t,rbltr.lr!ii rhr(\r01 ir\nfcrnrlll rl.trri'rr ! , , , , , t r i N N o x r i . i t { k , f i )l ) t u kt , r l r co L . l b o u r g c op\t r b l ( i I rf l)( t,',9'.srir.la' !riL.hngc hxr rrx. ir\(tr' " _inr r f r , r , o { o r i , ' gI n I ltr)li \nm,rl,nriljh,h.rc(ludirtrrol niplcl)i!irl'\ .'(1,, ln,nrrillonLenr\.i!,{c,,rcn(\c n!f.rlr.'.\,1

'.,

1.,'.

. ,

., , i , 1

f!

, . ' , .-

 ! , . , l t r , ( t , f r { L , r ( t r , . t r rr o r b r ( r u \ . x n r o n ( { ! r r , r , ,,t ,,tr,r(.rn'l,f(tu.r r,t)trnrrnr hist)d!,rltrrI , i n l f 5 . , n l ! t r t r i { r r ) ' t r - ) p i ' r n r s in . o r I l o ! L r b c r r , . { r l , ( s ep c , r n r x L D i ' , i , r , o r d o , , i i l , r , g l LL h r i i , t r , , , 1 . . n n { l lc r r n r1 1 a p r h l n i r f ) r lr't} j , , , i , L 1 t , 2 r 1 ) ) f r h L n . l , t ) i , ' i t r rs e ' { hi s D x m ) k i ! , r ! ) c , n rlr. '(.rin\ il.\,lop. l,rL(lol gi.nl) psyd ojv r,' l D , r r . r ( t , , . . r t r iI i 6 , r , u r i h r r ! i c n ( c r ) t ) r L l i {r ( t , ' . , r ' r l h . , r h r . r b , , \ i \! r n i b n n d e l i ) r r r . D i b n , , c , ' l ! l r h . p t r l J l n . \ t t i c ,{r l h n r r x i x l n r k g r ) r i i r ' r o , l ^ , o r , \ r l I r c [ r x r i r n r .i I . r r ' e f , ' l \ . \ r ) n . l ) . t r c , I . n{ o n r . r i { r r x f ' r L ( r r h r n . l o t r r nrrr r,rns.or nn.l n,.u L I i. t)!,ltn( rhr').lv rl,lnlt ) r,ur r)ur xlr) x pr.r.$ r ,,, l t r \ l o ' t r r i r Dn r \ l . h ( ! t r r L \ . t r t u o . r d ) r ( t . o . ! ( t I ) \ r , r l i r n r b . ' . i L l t . ( l l r . ' i i r n i r L o Jr l ) . i ' n p L i { . r , . , r . L{ ! n l t ! t r , r r . r t t r r r r r , , . h ! n r . ' g i l i n g , r t r r r . { Lr l ) n t l o r l l l ) r r r k n r , n n A p ' n r c n r i i r i ( h r ) l s',i i r h r,', , (lr.scsol rr'rr i'n,il) , , n , L ( r r i l i , i , D . l r h . g r r f , r l g o o x \ l i b c r a lr h . . [ . r[$rrr,.,r,r-ol rh.rrixL 'h( (|t,] ol ptrr,lnnr-. . . h !tr|)t ,.trLtrtr'
,,1Llr r\.'!n! ,n !^irl.'l ,trl

', t, \d.n., 'h( d!,rr (nn',)l,,1rivrlorgrnizxrkrir , , , l \ ( , , r n , i f . . l k , t , r r ) l u r ) r \ r c A ' \b o r hr b . n .i ' n . f n i r c ' r ( r i , n, r n h o n cr n . r h . r i h , l , r i ' 1 ! ' ! 1 , ! l 0 ) I h r r f o . . ' L n r o n n l i D r i r c nn { r s i ' \ a s l. r, \,!r's prbhr:d'rru ol.ni{rl dcblc rtr!,rg t)!n,nc , \r | tr,,fkr,rLarilrr mnolltfus

/Ly''rktr kss slislyir( ,l ,1,, ,f -, | ,, ",,.. ,;. ..,, ,1,, t,, i I .. ,. L ' ,r a,, . hi,.,,t ,.,, , | . $ , D , ," -," " r r t L r ' , , ' ( . L l t / r i , t r \ c r v o l l ( r i v c") i I h ! ( ( o n n r o r i l ) , r l ,. i !tr \ {l h . r k c o r o r l t r n t . ( l ( r t ) i r L i\ \ \ h i r (

i ! r r h i L r, n s ,

t!
r,.rr lh\ll,rf , I r) rr,trf'!nnr. .'rrrn'.tr,rar* t)(trr{. 'r'i l,ur 111.'f r.'li!nr,p'tr'kc r\(ll(1' r r l h r , , N C l r g o! ) l ( . r t r t r L r r Dn t r d ! \ ,Lrlltr irrtx\!lr \irhorr ni.l' 5{rnrn i'fra',fitrr (r \ $rl' nrh lrJ$ n. .!trit1rl nf.s'kn,

, f r u , ( r r r L . r r a r . r u f ' t r k r i r t rn rr , , t ( '
oPl'i. !r\r)' \-rdli(l(*. rh.

Lri\rrra,rr r!!,r,tr h'\i hunr.D\.rtu$,untntrr,t(rs.rr*

( , ! , . L r v r ' r r t r i f $ f \ ! , 1i r \ o \ n : n n t f r t \ n , l ( . l r n d . d ( n r' ! , ( h n , f n ro l s r d n n t r r r l i , L . Ll,r,l.ll.'lrr frssl'lkrl hneDrnr l'r' ilrin{i'rri,i,l , { \ ' ( o f , ) l ' l , r h l , \ t l , f r c s r l , eb r \ i sL , d i r i n i { . , r i l l r , { t r ! D ' ! , r h r v x i l i r } { . D r N u n i r d $ l l \ i r D t r i ( nn i ) l l r t , r , r l f r h f h l . ' l ' ( l D n l sr l , o b r s n l ! , ' r t , ' , 9 ' . s r r . , '.1' i{ 1,,'rn,."i,.ri,'.,,J',,..,,,,rn\ ., 'r,',' . ' ' , r . L l o ' 1 . r t r r k r , ! n n , r . , p o ' r n , l k r i , t r | ' i t t rr. l r l r l'!nn l,inori.h \tmilk s,!r'nitrgl, , ' ' , ' r \ ' h , n ' L hr h ! t [ l , l i ( . d , r r t , . n , i h r l n n t r ' r u , i . , , t , l ,!'lri1,!l l)r.h.c) r^.rrl '.h,trr. on a , ' . h a r ' i , , l ( . ' l ) . r r u I l , u n ' r n . o n n n t r n n r r i t r ' .(,i .t r r N ' ' | ,( | of r'h tn,l(s n Jhc'..nro r, nrtrr\ rnd l , n v ! ( 1 , ' l n i r c $ r r n n , .( ) ' i r l , . t n l , ) n , |,'tr.rnk.'lycsrhrni'1\rltrc'pdrn,rl'.1i,trAol rh. , \ t r l . o f n r f r t r i ' i r ! , s l s r o D i .n r c g r r i t r ' r i r l ' i r s . r,,,D/'r.'r{L.t{,'ri{$ rrLlicortror'x'nt.fitrrir[ynr I , \ ,,{., 'lr , ,pn.rr ,.. t, '1, r,ii" v t r , r N { t r a f \ h ( f r , t r \r , ( t r l c t o p ( n n n ' r n k j n . r d u r '..tr '{ !tr11rl 'Ji!tr'rltlion rKI nr.rIi.r"LIIrnc . " ' L , . ' , r r l n . ' l { h r ' ! t r ' d i r ( h r D g cn , r h . t t r . \ r n , f l c ., i! l n . ' m N r ) . ' h n ( c, r h r ( n r I . l o , ( G 1 , 1 x i c h l , , , . i r t r ' " . r f n, h n h . ! ! ' , ' l . n ' r e r r n c p s c ' , l r !'li,h'nf L' t r ! " i , J n f L n r . 1 l t r ( x h i o . - r n t , (\ r i l o \ c f r h o t " ' . , I ' 1 t r . o i h . ' r , ( ! n r t i c s o u , l r s ,i r , r r f t t r n l xl rhcrcynl nn!osltrlh rs r rhr r ' , , ! . L l \ , t r x r l . , l , l , r r , f x l s o l r h c l i l r y o r k L .l , !'ii.\ 'l'tr\,trri,'r.\ k)\cokr \{ ro ,.d( ' rl,( 'rr , ! r l l ! , 1I r n , . ' l , l ( , n ( x , , n r; o n l o x ' l s l ) o s . , i \ t ) lr , . ' l , { \ . ' l t f . r , r r , t r r l r ! ) , l ( v . l o pr b r i l o ' , l n , r r r i , ' s r r r (

y r i r l d i ' i , r i , i ' \ l , ! y l , n r ' n n r i s h l ) ' o l ] r r $ . r [ i ' 1 1 \ ! ) c o r ( ) r r \ ' h c ( n i ' . t r , r . r c d d . L ) r D r t r r n N tl l ( f i r c r x P i l i ' l n ' x\ D'rnrirr i'rr,x*f\ irrho rlL' ('not lP'tr "l r d Lrrk. f \ h ; , 1 ' \ i l l ' f ! ' h { r h c n , )h r r r l c i ' ^ i ' , s r ' l ' r ' 1 ) r \ e so - l I Hor\d(' (l'.$i',r. rltrr!'li'{sh nt)pr.tr!,ol1,1rn. ri(ri nnt \Lt,la 1tutraun l,trr'(l rl'. hr!\ Iltr rhr /r)Dli p lr. 'r' rfr{n i \l'r | '.i '{ publn \r)ll '. rht rhr'! or onn ! ! i . ! l i ' \ r i 1 t r r i ! t ro l r h r r n r n ( r r i , t r 'l , x i k \ t l i . D n , r ' ! \ l ' n r t r ( r l . . \ ! ' l v r n g. o ' r [r'tr'i.ln.l'||liln.\o'{rpIi]!\J'| trr.'r'!)1 trrl\ $ !i ir\ ($t1( tr 'drk1 'll,t i ! t r 1 ). j ' l ( ' ( ' . , n r i o sx , ' , t t r l q,,f i,,,r,r|,f r1",.,'l''-,)l1!,''tr'i!rrnc{lirr.r'hd' \\lLf I'rt)t!,({l i', sD//r,/ 7t'iVorlr k, rirkt rl!\r \l{rr }rr(^.1\ kl Ilrxrn\ h\c k) f\c\ !,n,(si\; 'l).'rl,r, rl'. ri( hnrll\ \lr(n( rl -(L'lnslnu.orJl i' r" ''\' /,,,"/"!, " 1' l' '. r , L ' n d n b , i , i ! r ' r l J r i ! r r n ( l . r t r ' t r r r t r r o l l ) o h i . r i I ,lii',1rltr.r'F"d ln\ n' 'hf lrn,l'i,'d\,n rlit lDl hl nn{, Ilrli 'rfr\ hnn\tll{r1ni !, I , lrd' l)r'rrrr.d nrnt \ b r l , n i ( , t r , ' f f r h f d o s c d r t i ' t r ', ' l r l r ' l n ' ! ) L i . l , l t r T . t h x r l h r'cr(nii's ol n\ '.vnxltiri!' tnr,r'ghrrrigaovr' i ri\ l. Ir'i lirnrnrrr " DhI.'qrrviLilr')l'.hrirn\ l , r D , , ( ' ( $ ' r n { i r l i ' N r i , d ' i , n \ ! r l i . i r h o ' r l n \ r o f ( x D F i t r r h ! \ , n r r ' en r c , . n n r Y , n n r d ,.,1.;'.'"1 ,n,l '"ir kx,l ftr rl'.m lh. !,u{L'1(ltrr{r{' !trs nr{ sd,h('r r, 'irl'r uBl(ar'rlt dd(l,Unf r'l r('tnrr' ol I'nh { . r r l i n k r e n r r \ , , l ( ' ' ( . ' l r l n \ n ' g n ' r h . t r l ) r i ' \ . f o i ' l ' q r b r r r l ' l ! ! , l n r r r s { t h o ' o l i H l t r rr ' s l n ' f i n ro l ( i i L \ ! i l r k , r ' , , 1 rr l ' n o ( d , I i r l ) t ' r r \ r ' g h r I l r $ [ i i b r i r n l . nrtrt rrn\(tr!llfrl bAir Ir, lfrrt,'1{\ IIN shrr hr ..1". { ',". ',.' ( x r ) r i i \ r l L { , c s ( d r l r r P o l . ' r n l \ r u l ' l n i ! i r r l l \ I l c . h l l n r'l ' l{ \n h/. - rirr'r' ^,, '., l "r r r 1 " . . ' r ' r " !"t'^ ' ! '. -'r'.llt'l "l "{l "ll n,h Ini ! on,i',rbor b\ .rDnrlnD Jtr(t ltrn.ru'r. Po\.:

rl,r,in',r'rr I'l' i.N\\,!t l.nrh,rsr,D!r.r!'rrfsl il,.!trcri(llr,'s ,, I lli,'(*itrl,rrl,Atrr'rrbcsnnt,h Drc rt,.ili. nnfn.'L \cLnrse\ ol \ rn,l t'r,\1hr lrrl('.n,trnxL' olhnin"o!1tr(r(r) | .', n'!Lr .! lq.f rl,(5.l ,il.d,rNn*,irtrno n ",1 r , l i i t t r . ' ' l l r r ' l ' l l ' ) :I . . u , 1 1 {' o r l \ ' ' t r \ \ i . r .r , i\ a , " r , r ' t r , , r i r i ' \ , l ' r l t 1 l . v . l , ) I ' r c r ,o ' D ' n \ i ' r ' ! n n g "l , 1' ,'( $'tr\ ll(irtr' r h r t r ,r l n , st ) o r ' ( \! l ' i ( r l r t r , l D s $ " 1.. i { " \ t rtttlr 1\lt,L llii\isin,t)o'(r'f,lo' rlrrAliir i\lrI L,' !,'rri,,lh rlr,(l{'tr.il)(.hi\!nifrl\tuil!tr\,'lt'rst) tr , n'(Lc !rii'i-i'$'iitrri'l J(rrl.,'trD\ Nrc \r(t,/ r,i./,rP!r(.(lrrL'!e\.\o l{rl)c',Dri\likr'ln!,\ r \ , i ,. \..'fn($ n il,i r-r.rr1 lru^loudr ^rt' rrl i,1, ,l.\n,.rl luu'qr!'i. t,rhli.sd,c'f.'nil '. t^" 'tr.
,,,(.!LL

, r ,r, .fl

(qi!'\ ll.Lltr krtrl\ r, (ljc rlk.i!lr(ril' ",o , n n x n . ' l h . t n r r .r k.n. l r t,"\.rnl\lilL.

.li .'lr'" ii{' " rr n r h o L U i n r l ' ( r n " 1r,) d , t r\ ' i Lr L , r l r ' \ , , r ' l i r r r I ' r r L ' x h ' o ' ) 1 1 , r r r o ' t r t ,rr) L r l c l ( ',( lLiiL.\ nii,triny r,1 'o.ovq rlr' r"fl, l',tr iicr , q L h { l n r r r ( { L ' r ' r i i ) t \ .i h i r i \ ( h r ' . ( r r i r r r ! n I ' n r ' , \ror(('fl'. .irlf.(Drh. r.,l rrrlrf il, ,rrru'k\ ' , 1 , . l , $ , ' ( . r t r ( ' f ! , 1r l , ( . r , l i r r I . , i r t r t ! l ' a n I l , n l r r , r l ' ( . r l r u l l . L ' r k l , , i , t r ( r n . t \ . r n r l n k r h . r t r ( l! { h r , ','1.'l,,!rrh.',,rrr),'1('nirlbnn(h!.'f rhrttr.*!trl r'r\(litrg o'trlns rr [ln!.\ orh n' , I . ( , i , t l ' r i ! r t r l , i l , , , l 1 ' o r r l \! ) l ) ! ' l i r ! , L!ll ^ ( ! t r n { I ' .' ' ,1.r',i" || Iq n.ii tl''.'t\ " I t L l i( \ p 1 1 c . l l t r ' . ! n i l t i , n , , l r i i ( r l t ' ) l n n r l ' , i L ! , t r L s L l tlrl r t i l t r r t r , l n s , c l i ' s r l ) ! t r i r r [ o x , r . , li n . f ( r,,r\r'Llrr .!llirrrorhis\i.r l\1,trr{,(r.r|rt,uh, , , , , t , , I i f r s r . , l i r I e n o r n ( r $ . " , 1 \ , $ ' t r n l ! tD ' l l r \, \ \rut,rt t"\lndhr suKs.{\.rrrr ir'(rc r'.r ,,:,, t r , , r l x ' Ll l , ' 1 t r ' t r , r s , ? r l i r dl , f r h f , , ! ^ , , l ( n r l l-'f

,\noihr' iNnnLr isi,. n Irl x n n t c o , i i \ . t r l q ( 1 , r p r . , l 2 ) , l n f c x r i r l ' L c .| . i r r s ! , r " !r'\ dn.u$( ln.l llit' Fn'1,)l( xl)\cr.r ol ,'rrnnrxLisr, p u h L i l n , c ' t ( r | . u g h r l , c h i { q r l ' ' i l D r h ! r ' " ' i .1 ,r n o l . ( ( $ r , i l v ( h r l t n r . r l i c : ( ! r ' n r l l x b r r n ' 1 \o l l ' r ' r ' f n ' l | r,ft ,.r "i " s r . c ; 1 h( , , r ' 1 , 1 D u b L n l n , o , c , ! r ' n . hL L ( l 5 ( b . r r \ ! ) c . r l ( n L \ !, rd,L(|l li su's. hd\o. t'l{, n) hoPrir !n x rhi'r"t$ ' ; i ! , n , r ( c ' : , n ( n h u c n r h o. ! r r h n r n n r o l r l d r "ro , L , r l ( r . r h i si : ' ( l l r c ( l , r r l r r l l ) l t $ r l l ) r \ n { t r ' t r l 'iI' ri ri rr;r'o.^\ lrrldrriD' ),tLrr'.Ll \riIi!r i'Lhn cnpi'niLl ,\r r lrrl.' o( r 1,hrltrc' fi). h! rend\ rr ryl)ifl cP' hs {(o . I'ir 1,1 " h . q r . \ r n n "l f s f l n r n n i ' ol rh. \ ll'^ l^'. r1",,,", , n r) r r b l ( ! n d ( . 1 . , { f , l ' r . A l x r r L I L r h t P r ! ) l l r t kr l \ r ' A l t r r . L < \ s \ t c lL h r r l l)li.!nn,.r'r|I;rgurkrnrll ii,fn,r'lr i ( l , , c s , ' r n c x nr l l n r n b l i . n i s ( 1 r n s h x \ r c J \ ( d i' rhc'r.. rjii\ . ' , , 1 , " i , | C ^ 1. " r l ' , i 1 s f l ' . c o l u r c r r i r i D A . i r t r f u ' l i l l u h c r q ' n r I I r b o ' n h h t r \r n o l ) r c d . . nLl Urlr'{rn,li'11. l l llli r l. t'l '^..l. |""! 1 r"l.'r''rl '.^ IJ -'l l , 1 nn ) | n r r . n . . , \ t ( i t h i r r l d , ! 1 . \ r { ' ) l f i \ n o l I n r i c d ,.t".r.,t, r r L r x \ , r r l n i .t r n '-l,ii,,i'!,'r,n rl,r i5.r\ di nl(riris rl'k.l iI pohLkrl (l'rlJnj l5). le ol rhc lq i,nqsl's. A\ v!rn,o, rLAgcrs '.l.ssn]L'h.\dr! L'\ (lirn!$ r' Lhr pnblr 5ln[,. s'trr ir\ l ' Il"i ( 1 , ! n ' ! h n r l u ' l . 1 l ) . r h o r H h t1 l ) r u l r i \r h c t $ ) s D.lirn\ iu rl,scnO.inlors 'rl .lcr\ tr,i'ltcrs Poirr .slc(ixllr r' o L l , nt h r n , r . l r r i r n r l s l ,n r l n n r rn r i h . t f | l n ( r ( r r ' n ' r m H r ' h ' l l,onndx,v)cL\..n pul,ln rn p'nrr b'orli(rL h\ 1rnN bv rhis \,'1'trnc cspL(itrLlt li{ r rn{l Rn 1 n ' i n n rr l l n ' g h r I x s p r t D r r f r ( , 1 t ) r . ' s5 n l l ) . l f ( r e d , !l!r. trrrr llin rnt trlnl n,rell(LrtrLda(o'fr ) Ponf p L h c i J f n u l r \ i r t ' r r r i | x s L n n n , !r h . P n l ) l i ' i l n n x r c { i ' h o ' !D\ ro cln r\ nutlY i{ llxbcnr rsrrc\ lh. dillrlrL's , !. , ., t.,, t, ..,h . . i i ' n p o r r r i r s k . l h a D . r l u { r d & " l r u n . 1 D o r Ig c ' ' s

1,s1 ' r r fcr lo,ri ii, l,iliQssio. ol ll.'q..'ir rar, ri"i " " ' l,( r f t r c \ r'1xr\ n " r ' ' r i t r r r ( \ r k l i f r l ' r r L , o u l l i r I n l l t 1 ' n , c dn t r o , t,' h \t,11(.h.rrt),,vt,nl'.\lisovn icorv l,'rl,rIn{ 1 l r c L i r . ' r $p r b l n s l n o r c i l n n \ c d r,,,.,',t"'tr\i,n,!,l .t.,..r,,,.,,,r.,it,,.. Li .i., \ctirA ol r,r , ! lll(L ) ni nilf(.fciL\ rn.l ro ,.i',lo,.c x r " ' , \ t r l ( ' f i r 1 t r , r ' c r l ) - , i \ r n n 1 . d n r n r . r \ t t ' r I c r t t , ' , ' I d , r . , , 1 r h r n l r ) l ) s i :.lo r l [ r i , r , o l d , , , . n , L '-; r'' 1,^"' l. r, , ,l'ld( tr,rr{lrpcr l,rr rl,trr L$ 1.\ plxlc,n t)ul)ln r , r"! \ \ N r , t r r I i a * r n ' g g . ! s , t u b L n r l i l ) r i d i t r 1 r ( ( , 1 ! , r 'i,L(rio,!l rs !,rt)l! {rd, rn rhox t olrltnl,rl ,,m' , , a , , r . i r r L , r l ) e ( L e Dn n , r . b r \ n x l l l r i ' o . ( \ i l r , l r r l , r , l h i i , ( x n ( l I \ o ! k l , 1 . ( o n { n t r i , n , )o l n t f r d \ ' r , .,11,,rnor:rrdrin)nn,g\olDublnrl'n( n{lrJncD'l : i, r'f rlru\rtrtr'g h. 'r,,irN,rl'v llnlrrlni\ '( trc\ r , , , . s $ n ' l L nr ' . h o l r g t . r r x l n r r d N ; h n ' h ( , L r i , , , . t r f , $ l , n o ! ) L n i ko ' { 1 , i r f ( r c r u ' { L \ ) ( . . 1 l r r , ' h l ( . . t r l h b r $ " t r r t t n r l o t r d i o ,r ) l , t r r r ri r n r , * t r i r h h 'a ll{t{ r , ! r h ' \ J r ' s r r n r , l l r I I r b c ' r , r l i r c ( tr ' , r f d ( r ' s h , i r L r o r h . s c D d . ' r . l n t r r u , e l r l , r t ) r b L n\ t ) l ! 1 ( . n . , o l . ! h ( r . \ i h . * n i n ' , o r l , s i l n . D 'o \ n , t c D d c , ol 8.n.f rr ' ,, '.(rir rl,r, nr thruxliirg thc r!( , r , t r pt h . i L h f t n N n r f , n x r o i . | o r o ! ' v t r r ' l t t r n p . r ' \ , ,, I vi,'!l)Hr nillirnrixli.lonrlbcrrblinnng(aL . , , t r r , f p u l ) n r . $ a m r t r r r o l r l r i ' r ( 1 i { n ,l , l n i t , ' l \ 1 r . ( \ L ! f ( l r J l , r c 'I t r n l A i i , r . t l j - . l , r P k , i r ) l J i l l o f . n . . \ r 1tr.(ldr(l' r kn.rrttdi n r h'(l o,' llrbdn c\ , ) , ,r ' r L l r l o r n ! ) h | o s i r i r o l l1 l r r v . ( l "...1 r r i r L . ^ \ , ' r s L f . r l r l , c l i g i , r , ,d o r c db r l , . ( , h l ) k r ' ! ) . r * , 1 \ . . L c r l l l , t r n ' , 1 r i ' p l i . i r l f1 l l o \ r r h r h i l , ! ' t n r \ . ol ' , , ' t r i A r l ) 1 r, ( h A i ! r ' r l n i . n . . n n t r r d n ' i r ( , , , 1 ' ( | . t r i t r N l , L f r ) . r . ) D o r h . r . l . o r n L l r l ( n' i i n i i o r , ' l'!hr.rrrcfr. ^{tr.o,Drt Il,rkhtnrrr rrt lcN rr I lri\ , r r i , ! ) s l ' r r c d r l ' n r n r { r h r r r e l i A n nr n r l ( l ( { L " r r \ I ii',1rr t),os,r$r\. 1hrs..trltrrt)n,i\l.ri.'!!l lr'

,cl !)l nr)d0nirf 'rl. {l{rclr ll"k(l !) rh ' f,Iktrr' , rnn J ,lir! tr'rr'. ljo$ rnt,ndn,n1l. I hn \n\r (('ihrn \ ' l l l 1 f , ' r l r \ b l i ' t r 1 f i ' r h f r o l ( . 1 , c l i g i , r , n h r \ r ( o ' i , r rh.nrr !)t,. r',l'L (\ t,!l,li. \tt,,. rDd ) urc,n r. c r r l u i , r s n r r r i , , , nl r ( i ' I I ' n n r r r n o lo n l \ o l l . : r t l , t r n l . r ! l ! i c ' f h H i ! r ' s( i ( l ) i r . , * a t ) c ' h r p \ i s i ' n l ) , r r x r r r ' l i r f , r ' ) ( l n ( ! n n r n ' p r ! ! , 9 , l c r x \ k r r h . D o l i r i . r p u r , l i .\ t n , ( ' ( l l l N J \ 1 \ ! , 1 ' t r ci " I r t r . . , { h . r r r l r r n r i , l o , i r l ! , b r a \ n t r \ - L rhi'11's.r. rr(no'5 !l rll \ n'ry L(i'Lg l r "1iAl,'.'rD(trr , a ' r D ' n r l ' s i n s r n , t i i r t r r l ) l i ' D r t r h c ' n ' \ \ , i r n ( c ' t r r 1 i l * , l i x \ r t ) h r ( , 1r f i t r , t r t r r r t ' L r x s 7 r { l n , N s ( { \ . t , ' n r h ' L \ l ) 1t ) : , ^ n h " ( r r r r l ( l , n , l ' \ i ' i r c { c , l ' { l n { ( r ' \ . . , ' . r r l n r .( l n , n , , . .\ h r l r l l , \ t r s f , f l . ' l n f ( f f ' \ r i i n \ l ! l * ( r l , i r [ . r r ' | ( L ( r ] l ! ) *h ( L { 'l h r t ) , ( u l , " n . ' c { l ol pi'(it,rb tr' ilrL rtrl '(rrlr'fd 'l,cn t)r,{.xL'nr(l i',(l(Li lhn'Lr.liL, hiLhh'(i,rL.(l,r,!!n','l rhc[r. f'.tr\ tfl,l( 5t'l(i(, bnr r Hrl).,nri' o, l.r, rl s'{. s(i. rlr.r\i.r'ni'ol'h.trlcJ,n!N((k,\trr'i!'fr(r\\ iltd rtrr.ri"r|l..(xti!trrol rl'('lrrrltrh|tr \t)lir'(. 1( 'r'( o,l'( ' lirn. rIl '.1r,'loljt of r l ' , r \ r \ I ' A h r ' t r . $n ) r b i n l , l i . r . ' s { l n i i r n ! c r r i r l , l c i 1 , o t rt, b l i ( i s o r r \ c x n dt ) o r 0 r L ' l l r i ' t ) r ' , ' r d n r ( . ! ^ . ' ,1,( nn !,1 rnrl( orr rlitr\ 1( l l.trr| .rr) i'll r'fI ,ubt, ! p i D i , r ir s n , c , , o l ) i n i ! t r ,1 I ' r \ . r : l l , L ( ' r n c \ . r h c , h N , r s . ) , t r |( , n n r . r r D x r n u h ' i , r r l ) " l t r n , , r { r\ nn'|.brl r D o rp ' i n , r ' r l i r l ' e r ' . u r l i l r n r ! . p u h l t r r i N - \ i \ r , r r \ . , ! l h r c n { lo l ' n r i { t r L , I i r l ore .l rh( Dr')nt il,rl nnghr rr li n nor.Dl\ n) rt,( lxk '.nr.rl},fnru'r ( ol fror{'c$ !i u ' B n r , l { r p i r , n i \ n r l , ) 1, \ l x \ i x l t c d , ' o n t ) u r , l i f c r ! f h i s ' h(n !lrpl,,t. l rltr,rr! (f ol rdn,n,nnrLi il3L,lr1 rxl i u ( o ' l , . r n i { r '$ n l ' ' h . p r ' l i . . t t n ' c rrl l '.r1 .llJ,' '." \ k.l k,l!'l\'f f 'r"',..1"" !(sl(,r ol {ri,l rr^(n,cDtr (,ln(r$fd iL') i', '1'rttr t r'!l l:l). l.'rxrniri\ ((n'rr !'f 'l'f t,rhln \dtrit fo'l,rl)\ (r' r.{1.'., .'.,.\r."tr t,..,1,..,[, fl, , , , .,r,! ,,i1 i " ! n , t n ) t r r r i h n I n ! , r l , i { h i ' x l n l \ b ' r ' s r l ' ( t r i d f r s i ' t r I ' i r n l ' f \ .l i d ) ' t u l ' l n { t i ! o r ' \ e ) t r { L l ( r i , n . y'lri.\. l'!trF (\i,. sfr u'(inllr irft(rr.(t l,\ !i.n r , ^ ! r , . t r r .n r , ' rl f . o ' ( r t t r u r l n L . a r ' 1 ^ n l i l I t t ) u h l i 6 r \ l l f \ .

, i , .t { f r l ) t r { \ . ' "t,\ii!! l!tr(( i,r{,rrro'trn(DLrtf h r,,.ntr, (,D!. !,,oorklfn,s rh..,gdrti,t tjrbln r h ( r ( n 1 .f l , f , ! r i , r . , r i 1 x , r l , ' , , L l , 1 , ! t r ! , ) l r t r . t l l , t i s l t r . r r ( , r m t r b o ) t r ! , . r q r srr {urrnrrq !r'rcnrnnr.irnx$(, !r ''.'',''',''J''''..''.'',.''','''..',,',''... , ' r, .,lr tr (\$r. lltr,l,a' llAribihvi\ rtr^,ru(,xtn, rt(ro(. !\ rfif^., i(irtDi^etr,.,r,,tr(,tr(r\i,n\fitr rtx.,.i,(L | , { ' ri rtr{ r)l n{ks lrrr ,l nnrrnid througttr rh. , r,' i',.!r'.LtrrcD'.' t'r\rt).nrntlro..rjon\fa, r{r u'.rD, !n rcr ronr. rt ,r,ri.t, I rtr:n nor N rrtr, , . t r t \ i 1 F t . . \ t . , , 1 . ,t,. . , . t . , t . , h f . , r , ! ' r \ l ' n \ r h n h n i h , . r t t ) s ! , t r \ t ) c t )r , e i n , . ltrtunrrsi r((!tr rhu\.n*, 1 , , \ . , i n , r r ( r r r , , r ) , , g c . r . r o r t , cN , r N s t c \t ) , s t r i . t j r h f ,,i t!tk \,,rrr,nt ir\p,trri,prfsrr.rrnc!rr,du,nn ,i .rL, lt.'nltrL.a.'t)p'r li(\rl,rr),bln \tn!1(rntir\,,"* \ , L . ' ' i ! t r . t r x n r \ i r . x , t r , , r gr t t r .s d r r r l l).*Lttf io,rsol , .,,1.,,r t bli! stnrrr\ ire ,ixhr ,,trr.Ptu.nrc if $. t),rtt I r ! i , l ( r r l i , ' rr l ' c ' . r n t ) . i r . p r b j n \ d , r ( . I d f l n , \,,1r.,1{'lr'\trrrhntDt,,,s,,f t,trrnii(rrotnrlri (. , , ! .'r.,ptrn* or ,rdkttr,s. trtli( \lt)c,(! t(ap r rkr. lrrlt.'. c,"tr.rr. xrit rrr!1) I'rf lrtr|ct)r.k , r , r h i i l i $ ! r ( f . r j j r n r i t r , , t , c n n x i \k a l t f n ( f , i,,D^ t ) r t , t n , n n it , n ( . r h n n r , o . ) s i i \ r . r ( h ( , tu t , I l r ! r r l . " r l i l , o ! t r r r| x r r r c . { , t r o , f x t . i v i l \ t r r ! , r . r , , , q (n . l o ' ) ' l ) r , b n i n r | l r i ( n h . n r i r . n , ) r a k . r l ( r c t r n h r rr r \ b r ( . t r \ r r n ' \ ' r , r t x t , a s\ n d \ ! ) \ r r r l j r t r , f 1 r r . .. r. t ,, t i nd r. t ,, ,t . ..,t t..,r- ,.. q,.1.,a , .L!,ih rt,,rn,,.,,i,.r,-.i,,,,,t.. , L ' i n t r D r i A h1 r p r o ( t ' d n c ' i r t r r ! ) r h j D [ ! t L t r r , .,r,.'r,\ i'notrtrg,L t,!kl ,t rt.u,tnr ron,tr1,r,r ,1 I n f c r \ ' I r t x i r r n s h r b { , , n p f . o r k 1 s( \ ( i , t { N . , , ! , r t r ' . r r ' q ' h r ! i r g n L , t nr ! . r h o , . \ L t , , ! ( i i ,.h'n.l\ *'(.nf' ('rn\ ot (oi'nn,i(.fr, \f[,, , ...,.,11,,1,t t1,,. .t,, .,.,..,...,,..,,,,,

l c \ { l , i n ( ' l n , i . r ! { o s i ' r . f r l ( L r 1 1 1 .r,s l r n a r ] a \ ( r l r r t r r t r ! s p n l ' l i ( L n " n ' r s ct i ' l ' i " r d n n r , n a i.t r l r \ r c i x l ' l x t r h ' x l \ i r l ' t r ' \ 1 ;i'n. &r rllc$, h'{"'' n,r' .,1.o o,Lrr'ql'ond nnr \ ,ar.t!,i(\.po'!i !r brri \' ni.! ol 'l( h'gd ntr ('1 oll.D,n,n'lIl)l( \ '(r,' (ounrorlNbr! lh.r nrhu\rr r . 1 r l f , | l n , r n l i r , 1 P r l ) l i , r n r t r r gl . ' Y r r N l h t s r r ' f ' r ' l ' t rr r , { r h l r { c , \ c t r r L { s l t r o ! r " { r ' \har rl'dmrr (,trikrf n tu(r\(\ l)rr il.o hn\ n n(r'rlh .'sx'tr. l'!r\ ir n nrri\ n. brnnnhrn* ind .hn'h g'ori| ,nrfr'rl(tr\ir' nr '(lrir !, 'lr.1,"{d lrul,Li r' vhfrlrIL\ vr)rr)it . n \ . \ n t r r l u n , r n r L , l ( 1 , \ n i ! r! 'l l . ' l r o r r l t l r n o c ( ll ! ' l l ,n J {lo irrnf nl(ol!){\ rli\ r,trr. .'L.n', rhr h.!(rr r,lf an( D.i'r. r,{ orl! n, r. rrrrxrt. ,f M'. l)lnI '"i lr 'iLl 'll -ri' '..!. tr'.'l,tr'I'r",r't{ x l \ ! )r ) , r . 1 , t r r r h \ i \ o l r \ r r r r ' m l r N r n v k ' i .i t r t r f r l r n * . ' 1 t r r r( n r t n f ' r r \ n c ! r r l n ) \ t u L r r t t t d r l t t L a l l n ' h e | , { h t r l l n ' l r r x , | , l . t r 1 r ' i . s i r l l , l \ o c ' i l r a ' . $ nr.'e ' ' . l r r i t r b r l t n r r t r r \ ! , 1 r r t r n r r r r i n r . r h f r )

r , , l ! . l , l c ' r r ^ ! , i c D r r , r { u { ! N r , { l c l i n s f ! ) Lr i v ! . . ' \ , L [ , ' n i !] h . n , r r l i u r . , 1 \ i]r ! . u l r . n r n r . r . t r r I o l x n ' D , 1, h { n i " . i r r , h " ' ( ' \ ' l : f t i d \ r rl!, rh.,r.c. I { \ . ' r h . r h ' r ' x h o u rn \ . \ r o n l o r l . l ) o u r A r , t rp r D h . \ \ . N t ) 1 ' n x r o . l b r ( l { r t r r l s I ' , t r r 'l N . l h . r . r ) l l,l('! ' 1 , I t r | r r r , h ! ) 1 ( r l k J ' b ' l r ( L o 'i n ( L ' A n i r r h r r r l ! , , t r ! t r c I \ , l ' . L l l ( t r q c \ . ' n lr h c p u n , i " L ! ) r $ n n r . s l o ' r ! . ! ' , 1 ! r r r i c ,,.,1.' \1,'r!tr'i. 'trrpnJn' trnb ol '. {,u{rilr r, ri.'l'lAh ' ( ! r ' l ( l c . r t r ' r \ l l . ' h r n ' , \ ( l ( ! r i b ( \ \ n c g ' i ' lr , l t r " . L ! , \ t t rr , r i r \ . l i l , l , ( r d o r ' , ' l r h r p , r $ , i n l i , r $ ' . , ' , ' l . ' , ( ! l \ l r , ( r ^ i s r sn r l , r \ o { . r L l c ( 1 (r i , f ' p u l n n \ t "l,nfr{(l ' i , r rtq.rtrrn !)l rxrirFLo t,rhh,irr$1.'$r\: in(!trnpk1c \ 'rdc(l t,"h r^ n\ !lirD r)

' , | ' , i r l , Nn n r r , r h m t r r r \ i ' r p l oo , f n r i , r I h c L r l , n ,'(r,'irtr t,1 { rn pul,li(n,r.ri\xL\,)pIr.1r L,ih"r , , , . , ' , r { . ( , t , ' , fh r h el r l l l t r . l l n r ( . n n p n , s ' n N , r h . , o ' , " , , , s , \ l ) u r ) 1t , t k ] . . . r r rr L , \ n s f . n r r r e o l ( , r n . c . , , , r s l ' r h r f , L1 t r . i hd r \ o l . , t r r r l ' o k , r l , r h r l r n " s r o a l

I' a tr,. ,i '.

1,1.fl" . 1' ' "'. rt ',.rrn\rilr 'l,c !(of i'.'l !rl r|r lx)l 'h.r h(r'c f\.' n'.ltr.rli n-n,i\ itrrh..tr,,","' ,'l drq-rr.nir, \.r \l r r{iLlh !tr!rn7.rtir.It I n a .r n \ p r b l i l \ l n u 1 ( n n f { . $ i ' l r {li( L"xlrc'irn li.\ol d,\i\itri,,.h(i,r\lil01 n'rr.rn(l !rh., (,trnurnr lcirr''s.51 Ilir trr,n rl."i"t rnd olrl' (ltd i'$r,r{. !tl rh'\ n( x ll.nn1rr,\'' dr(trki, rhri l'( (!rl(l PuII'e l'l(lxi.n' ltrnln g { n , . ' f r , o r r \ n l ( ) . r , l c ' n r ' n c n ( o u ' v ( 1 t r ' t r 'r h . . ' s l r ,:. rl, -,,t rdr'ni,a ltr,tr,r\!\', llrbrrn'r\ h.'( "ndd{rli '{ 'r rlritl- I r ' 'r' \ lr l' I 'r' r" ,r\1,.r,1,.rr,.n , '.,r'. llr''i'r' ( l f, i r r n \ f | l f r k n r I r L ' r ' {'Itrr$c(l j,lnrr \r\or !,1\ '; rl'( hnrnn:ll t),o,f\i (P \\ii). lhotrxf il!'trirnn'olrn'lr (lfPlrh,. |l! vnirnA !rii'l n)vtrrrir' i urA.,1 fin(r( . l u D i " r n ( c b u r ' r i { 1 i k r l n s r l {! ! ) r l , . r , r r I l r i l e ( lr ) r n ( l r l , c t t r r u ( , n t ) , ' l ) l ns r r . l ' r t r ' s h r ' . t rr l t n ri.n'i,D\ ,f 'he r . . ' i ! l. ' l i r h r t r " l r i ' r c s . l r h n . h ' n r v r ' llk lxrnr rr.'e \ k, , , r 1 , ! ! , 1r , r n x n s ,\ , t r 1 . ' \ r ' r l , i h t ^

r " ,, ., \,rn,s nrph.\ 'r,r 'h. Donif sn/r,r/ 7,!^ , L r \ , nrf, rh..r+c,u,itr1or r| pnbr,( t)rk1rri 5 f L r r ' r ' t r , , n i c $ r ' f l n i " ( l ( r n o ( ' r r i (r ( . o n r ! [ r k n , , r , l r i r \ , l , , ! * { n n r \ , ) r h c ,r ) i r i i ' , r h . n o \ . ' r l , ' n ! iitr1 ,r')c'\ l)r\r l1r nir , , ! , l b 1 r l r l o , r \( ' n n t r t r f [ c , . h r 1 h . . n t " \ r ' s i lt' trv!trak,n rl',i'l'enri'trtrLrprir!,lrh. r,tr'lrlr rltr.ltr!hall,ir\rlii(l,Hrlrrtr i.onriL'i.srhr ' l r h p n l ) l n\ n , c c I r l r r 0 , l t \ r ! , l ' r \ , l , ! r ' , f n . i l ( 1 1f.o ' ' D ) n \ . o n n n 1 , f r ! , s , r h n \ ! l , , r t ( { ' ! n r " n f r ) n l d f i l \ t l , r \ t r k , \ r l ' n h l t ' l ) r , L , h ! \ r l i ( r d n . . n l l x l \ ! ' s u \ t n l r n r l r . h . ' L i r i fo l \ ' , r , , , * ( , n p r l , L i , \ r c ' ( . l l ' i s i s , L ( x , l y i ' n p o ' L U rr s r , f I ' n r f i r l , l t r r i D r i , t r r .l h r o ' f r i , r L l l . h o \ . q r . r l i ( r,.,l.rk( l)d\.(n rh. i, \ctr l(a ngnif'( nr I' n | , , I l . L l n D r . r . l d ' r * r x n h .I i r r h h n o r , r l r ( " . ! \ , , , 1 L lr 1 ' ( i ' L , ' l l " t r r l h N . d n . ' i r l p r i . ' ( c n .

! r L l 6 r h . i , L l f i 1 ' r i , n r h t ( x i x l l r n r l x r n n Nn \ r r ' h r r (hrng. nrtrr nnrn nlcL ,ri' ln Dnnirlly ,rxltc (an Nl!ac r l n { 1 , k r " r r i t n n o r n r r i r ' , n r h r I , l , l nt l t r c r ) {il \\'h, 1tr. ,!r. Jt/rrl 7ft,r/u-,/n r' II)hdrr* (lclcrn'tr . !r .l vn'rn{or( r hoDe,l '1'n 5ho\"t l) ( " ; , l i r i t r q ( ' n r , n k , ' l ' r h I r l ( 1, o r k t n o r l u l r ' l l q d 1 r D ' , i i l ( ' t r , n n r r i t r ,, t r h . l n o s ' . s n ( I ' r n l o r ! r r t i ' t r ro l r | x ' ' t,. ', lrn{ ' !'lr' .r. .",,.,,..r i,,",', !) [nrnnrl .(oii'tr(ro rrnr !ri 1l ]ni,h l'\ lrrorrh i ' ) . ' , n ; i i ' ) h l \ h , , l t , , l! ' i x l t i r r s \ r , " ' N l ,,,;r ll, " ' u ! ! l t ' n r h.n u . ! n r l ' . ' d r i . { r d i | b ( r s . f n h ' s c j ( l ! ' l n 1 { , r ( r r ' . . r , I l ( q . I ' r ' l , r l . ( r i ,o l r l t a i r t ' d ' r \ . J l d k ) r n ! ' i , t r ,, l ! n { \ r l , . r L ' l \ ' . q , A l ( h ( n ' r i n n t i l r u r l i r r n r r(l !ntt N!'tr{hclc\t llxbf'tr\ hr\ r o l n " , c n i . d r l r i , n r , n n r . r x n c n rr r n l ' r t i l l , l r r ' h c lix ,,r!r.d'li. nrir'r1r. lior \lnil hnr.i.xl r{inlni'x Inuni'(rtrnnrnnr'' lhrt !'rr"\.'l(hr',r,14'i'rl , . I ' n Dk ' r j ' o u ! ( t h n n o , n r r l i r u . n s n o ' r '! , t ( 1 , , r r o D dhi!\ rl'A trntrh I l,,r n, (mrnrrr'( hnr!ilt'.qrc$ i r l ( . nr h J I ' l i ' i l i r 1 t r r g r n",i]rliv. hrrr i,li"1 sorr[r, ' 1.' $r i , 'r \, 'f.'rril{rr'ri\!rr!l!lr'rrrr\ r ! r r , r i ' r . r d h o s t ' t r r ' r c i,, (i'unrrrr.ti h' l,o, rht nltll lhtc ;","riiror r, 'hr httrtrrl \lnIl'.nr orl.' \i.',h. rdfili.' ,.dr r. in 'rnllrr.kn 'l ,in rl'tsn!' rlfl) t) ,i \hr,trr n r i , A I k . s c l i r nN l ' r i s i l r i r h n l)L\Dk. o' rJ.,hrr)s , r '*r_ tr.t{ or' r\ Drnf\ a{'r ' !'r hi)!r\ nnl nlr,'lot\.llrl)t'trr\.nrtrn\.(n lon', 'ni,n'c 'lr '.lh,uiril !'nr{n. rL " !'r nr'(tr'nnv \r1','( ho ttr'j1.'nlrr o! , 'niit,r.!n rl'( nl&l4ji.'l,otrr(lr riiB.l nn{nrriv. ho!!rr ! l ( k i x l \ i r s! n l n i i s l t r , lD , i { r t . l l r r r l ) r ' ) j o . n r r n v f \ x ' r r i ' t . , 1 / . ' i l o l ! t r i . u r l f . l c n r r r i s i l l l o D r i r r t n o 1l i r 1 , , r r h r r f , l x c r l n ' r l ' en o r n n . 1 ' l r D ) l n n iP n ) l ifrt r ' t n lht ,.hrhilirarn ol r,rn,rl d.nn'r(\ rhr' Ihnr\ \(.'r\ rgo 'l'l"x iJs '' .. ' .'l 'fr'l1r r \1"\Ff' 1{ " ,,, ., , t, ':,, ';., , .,, r l l r ' r r r ' t n o t ) I c ! r i r " 1t' . n a t h d d l r d r x r l ) o { n x n L r n i ! \ { l

, n , r\ ntr,1.hrl]h .tr ,,(1n.,1),tr |,.$csnl\. r tbosr, ' r'( .'. s(rLLirtr si[lis n' rl,s rrirntr,. at d,oi' r"-. , r ' !lt n c r f . ' 1 . 't ) ' ) n i s , ,a n ( l , " r l r n i s n r h x rr , t d l , c ' (,nr l ( r n n r h / r r t r ,! n r r l : n n , . g ( n r r r l \ . r } l v r l , , o 1 t '' 1,,,", i,l t{,,,',.,.,1,,',L"irl,'L','i!1li'i,.,l.r,1., qJ tb r'Ltn \!f tt\.t Eo, r, \h1,1t t'toidhr , . L lr ! , r l c ' n ' r l n , i ' n [ l r . l r \ I ' N r t r n ] l \ p . . i f n n ) . l , r c \ . ,,tr' .r,,.|| ,t,t., li,3 ,.,- t.- ,r.ii.,,,, t, r ,'..1'', 'lr '1,,.1 ,l ,{'.,,",,rf, ,,.'\. ,,{!t'rr llrn'gh rh.\ )'r not rhrr\\ l(\(l!,liyt..\rr,4/ / , , , / , 4 l r , r t r l ! , ( l n r \ n , u ( h . l r ' d o t r l ) i ' , g sr , . ' l , ! , 1 r n l , " 1 , , 1 , r l r r t r \ s r n . i r n ( r , n s t r r \u i ' l l d ( r l r nkr! ,..rrr,,s.tr rl'Jirr'l\.srh(lil1'rnlrn-n,1,.'.nrlr',,rtr,s , r r r , , , \ ' r t r b l i -y l , i h . r ' t i ' , g ! , r r o i l ' r L , f l r i i m r t r \ t t r r I L ' I l t r r o o r h i \ r i r t r r . r b e rn s ( \ , r ! , r r r s t r x i D d n r L I r f l ' { r l l l ) ' . \ . h t l l n r l r r r h o { r l l , \ r { i L ( l c \ ( . l o t )i r ] n l ,, r i" n\.lifle,(rr \,,\\ r r i ' t r r f . ' r , t r r r r ( \ r n t ro r r " \ , ' , 1 \ ' l i n o r! ' n r l ) s r n r u r l t r r i r , r . { r k l n d r h u r ', ,, , l\ r'" r, |,.r'..{.i,(h,, -.,, l.,,.1..'. , , 1 , , t r \ l r i \ ( n ' i , t r ' sr l ' , f n n r n , l , l { l , r , i , , i l , r " s a h . , r , x r i L { l n . . n . l \ r f i r t \ c r r 1 x r r r f r p r l ) t n J r r t r rr,) u r f,t r(n\ (r!trtrxtr\t\ rrnfh. r , r r , l n \ n , o , ! r n \ l x a , n ^ e! l n \ ' l r l n ( h u r r l l r l r . t r r c , I r , \ ' , \ h i . h n \ r \ f \ c . o r o t r t r (!.t r i r l . o ' s . ! ' r , t r r t r r l . ',,,{, -,.,:t^,.r,.,,..J,,.1.,t,,.,.,t,nr,rn{,. | r ) i t r ,r r g . r [ ( ' ] | n . ' i { r l l t s l ) ( ' f ' . r r t t s i s . t h h iDh,ltr(iJrn 'r.r,,trr'f n..nhxl ) rn lc,nh.{, rxlr (l(\rlot)(,1,o,nop , , , . s , , L l . , r ,o ( ' l ' ( \ f , 1 n , r ' . . n n l l ; u l d i , t r o f ll , rr \' .,1,,1..fl ,{ r, ,n.! !1r. wt rt ,:r,{r'rj i , r , t r L r r l , . { r ( h o r r r , . r , ! t r n s\ p o . l l n , t ) n | r | , Ia 'r,r!, rl^ln!lk xilll,n' r" nnlirpons.'l)lr rnl Do ! L,'r i ( l c ' r ' ( . l r n u l ( l r l s ! r ( o n r n n ' . ) i r l r t r n rr ' I l, 't,i i l\,t.\\',,Lr",ll, d'.!1.'lrl., r , , , r . , l , t r i t a t t r ,t , r [ t , . . ,r I l,h.t^ rh( nntr norr il rhn Dc$,r(Iii.tr),,1 . t t \rrrrluiar \tat<\ po\. lxl{'m$ \"trrs '. , i | ! , r r n n r , , t r r l c x h a r m n , ,, l n r ' t ) i r n c D i , ( n \ [ , t r |

ol niitlgv Prtr' no crhcd rl'r po'nr l rutrltcn8 !noqur $nh s 'nrnt rhvnutr( rclonrc rrks. C.rinh rh.In'l\ ' l i c o \ . ' ' n r l . { ' N i u n o l h { r r r q n o 'n r N ' 5.r!u.i. 'lr

\' i.li.i '.i '."r','"* " *ilnu'h on rhc(urcn' rRr*rr' r n i'l"l) a hf rl, n' t( rhJn rt st'u r t' 1' t 1r^\'n

, , Ln

.b,

ra. \@ ld

f.{. dftdtrn<rbr'i.1qq[4'

l,- ,:-".; , ;-,;,,",, i,:^:,-., ,,

rs' '?r7 ! 4 d*|i{urnjsdPirrl

.;,,\,i.'--d'-i"1r.

$ hr ri,/tua rrrr hq Na . rathal q t4& r\\ t. rk tdd 1i1t4 il rk st ,\, I

 r k {roi. qi, , r,,r

i/ rddv

In

\i

\i rrrrnrNr,\r.i4t

R lJ.'r!. rr r4,nk!& r\''

r{r

rs3)

(.6Dd'^dr

rtualdfue

lii

r!

.! i

lriir

r!!i

PhilosoDhicalModels