Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
General
-S.C. judges= appt by pres; confirmed by Senate. Most of American law is bases on Eglish
system, especially English common law tradition, decisions made by judges is important source
to laws.
successors, they established Kings court curiae regis to unify the country. Uniform
set of rules was sought and as # of cases increased, most important were recorded in
Year books. They used the previous courts cases to decide on those similar cases.
When unique case, judges made new law basing decision on prior principles of
earlier cases.
1. Common Law- Judge-made law originationg in England from decisions
shaped according to prevailing custom. They were applied to similar situations
and gradually b/came common to nation.
B. Deciding new cases in ref. to former decisions, precedents , b/came cornerstone of
Eng. and American judicial systems and is in doctrine of stare decisis--“to stand
on decided cases,” judicial policy of followed precedents established by past decisions
1. Ex) lower court of state must follow S.C. precedents
2. Stare decisis is basis for judicial decision making in all countries having sim.
Law systems; US, Brittain, 13 others having common law systems
II. Sources of American Law
Body of American law includes: fed/state const, leg. Statutes, administrative law, case law-
legal principles of court decisions
A. Constitutions
1. Fed gov and states const. sets forth general org., powers, & limits of gov.
US const.=supreme law of land. No unconstitutional law allowed. State const.
supreme in their borders, unless conflicting w/ fed laws. Defines what
state & fed. Powers can extend to.
a) Const as supreme law due to dissatisfaction w/’ weak fed gov
under Art. Of Confederations(1781)
B. Statutes and Administrative Regulations
1. English common law provides basis for civil and criminal legal systems, and
have more important to define rts of individuals.
2. Fed statutes relates to any subj. concerning fed gov. and covers the following
ranges: hazardous waste to fed taxation.
3. State Statutes include the following: criminal codes, commercial laws.
4. Ordinances: statutes passed by cities, counties; deals with the following:
zoning proposals & public safety. Rules and regulations issued by administrative agencies is
another source of law
C. Case Law
1. Case Law formed because of common law tradition,(in which stare decisis
plays role).
2. Case Law: rules and principles announced in court decisions. Includes judicial
interpretations of common law principles of doctrines as well as
interpretations of const law, salutatory law, and administrative law.
III. The Federal Court System (p.456)
U.S. has dual court system(fed & state, each state having its own system of courts)
A. Basic Judicial Requirements
Before case can be brought to either state/fed court, 2 requirements must be met.
Jurisdiction
a) jurisdiction: authority of court to hear and decide a case. Not all courts
have authority to decide all cases. Place of court case origination &
subject matter are jurisdictional factors.
b) State courts exercise this over residents of the region/ county /district.
States highest court has jurisdictional authority over all residents in
state. Fed jurisdiction also limited(Art III, Sect 1)
1) const. limits jurisdiction of fed courts to cases on
federal question( question pertaining to const, acts of
Congress/treaties. Provides basis for fed jurisdiction
or citizenship diversity).
2) Diversity of Citizenship: exists when parties to a lawsuit are
from diff. states/ when suet involves us citizen gov. or
foreign person. Amt in controversy must be at least $75,000 before
fed court can take jurisdiction
Standing to Sue
a) or sufficient stake in matter to justify bringing suit. Suer must have
suffered harm/threatened. Requires controversy at issue by justifiable
controversy(real/substantial controversy)
B. Types of Federal Courts
3-tiered:1) US district courts w/limited jurisdiction 2) intermediate US courts of a
appeals 3) US Supreme court
reasoning on which ruling was based. self- perpetuating and demand funding
that will result in continued existence of agency
2. Many times case is affirmed
Affirm: to declare court ruling valid and must stand
3. Reverse: to annul or make void court ruling on account of some error or
irregularity
4. Remand: to send a case back to the court that originally heard it. For a new
trial or other proceeding.
5. Sometimes court’s written opinion is unsigned( opinion per curiam).
If chief justice was w/ majority opinion, but if not then senior justice of
majority side decides who writes opinion.
6. TYPES OF OPINIONS
a) Unanimous opinion: court opinion all judges agree.
b) if not a unanimous decision: Majority Opinion: court opinion
reflecting views of majority of judges
c) Concurring opinion: sep. opinion, done by judge supporting majority
decision who wants to clarify a particular point or to voice
disapproval of grounds which decision was made.
d) Dissenting opinion: sep. opinion which judge disagrees with majority
conclusion; expounds her views
1) forms basis of arguments used in prior yrs causing court
F) then S.C. announces decision publicly after opinion written.
Published in United States Report.
V. The Selection of Federal Judges p. 463
A. Judicial Appointments (Art II, Sect 2)
Over 850 fed judges; for life unless die, resign, retire.
- candidates suggested by dpt of justices, Sen., other judges, interest groups
1994.
3. Civil Rights
a) generally conservative in Rehnquist court. One decision refused to
action.
2. Rarely does pres refuse to enforce judicial decision; they usually use influence
by appting new judges and justices as federal judicial seats. Ex of refusal and