Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 136

10-15-20:

10
15
20

:

- (New York Academy of Sciences,


NYAS)
. 200 1817
,
,
.
, -,
.
: -
,
,
.
,
,
, , , ,
.
NYAS 26 ,
,
,
.
-
- www.nyas.org.
,
-

250, 40-
.-, - 10007-2157
.: 212-298-8600

The New York Academy of Sciences, August 20, 2010, All Rights Reserved


: (Karin Ezbiansky Pavese), -

(Chris Hayter), -

(Daniel Satinsky), Russia Innovation Collaborative B.E.A. Associates
: (Mattias Chesley),-

(Ben Levitan), -

(Christopher Cooke),

:
- (Chet Bowling),
Alinga Consulting Group
- (Michael Crow), (Arizona State University)
- (Maria Douglass), ImPart
- (Esther Dyson),
EDventure Holdings Inc.
- (Alexei Eliseev), Maxwell Biotech
- (Yoanna Gouchtchina), Investment Advisory Group
- (Trevor Gunn), Medtronic Inc.
- (Mianheng Jiang), (Chinese
Academy of Sciences)
- (Alexandra Johnson), DFJ VTB Aurora
- (Klaus Kleinfeld),
, Alcoa Inc.
- (Martti Launonen),
. (Vantaa
Innovation Institute)
- (Richard Lester), Industrial
Performance Center,
(Massachusetts Institute of
Technology)
- (Randi Levinas),
- -
(U.S.-Russia Business Council)
- (Tidu Maini),
(Qatar Science & Technology Park)
- (Valentin Makarov),
(RUSSOFT)
- (Sam Pitroda),

(National Knowledge Commission)
- (William Pomeranz),
(Kennan Center), (Woodrow
Wilson Center for International Scholars)
- (Ilya Ponomarev), ,
,

- (Timothy Post), RuNet Labs

ii

- . (John T. Preston), C
Change Investments, Continuum Energy Technologies, LLC
- John Rose ( ), Rose
Creative Strategies
- (Ellis Rubinstein),
-
- (Blair Ruble), (Kennan Center), (Woodrow Wilson Center for International
Scholars)
- (Anna Lee Saxenian),
(University of California,
Berkeley)
- (Michael Sohlman),

- . (Joseph E. Stiglitz),
(Columbia University)
- (Nam Pyo Suh),

(Korea Advanced Institute of Science and
Technology)
- (Alexis Sukharev),
Auriga Inc.
- (Johan Vanderplaetse),
Emerson
- (Jeroen van der Veer), Royal Dutch Shell
- (Ed Verona), (U.S.-Russia Business
Council)
- (Vivek Wadhwa), Senior Research
Associate, Labor and Worklife Program, Harvard Law School
- (Kendrick White), Marchmont Capital
- - (Ernst-Ludwig Winnacker),
Human Frontier Science
Program
- (Julie Meier Wright),

, .- (San Diego
Regional Economic Development Corporation)
- (Philip Yeo),
( , ) SPRING, Singapore
,

.


- 10-15-20 , ..
.
10-15-20 ,
10 , 2020 ,
2020. .
, 25 , 20
10 . , 2020 , ,
.
10-15-20
: , , , . 15 ,
. ,
20 , , .
- , ,
,
. ,
, .

.
, 24 18 2010 , . , ,
. , ,
. 10-15-20
, .
, , ,
, . ,
,
.
. .
, , , , ,
.
, .

iii

.......................................................................................................................................................... ii
........................................................................................................................................................................... iii

................................................................................................................................................. 2
............................................................................................................................................................ 3
...................................................................................................................................................... 4
................................................................................................................................................................. 4

................................................................................................................................................................... 5
......................................................................................... 6
................................................................................................................................................................................... 8
............................................................................................................................................................. 8
................................................................................................................................................................................. 9
1973............................................................................................................................................................... 11
BIRD.............................................................................................................................................. 13
1980- ................................................................................................................................. 14
............................................................................................. 17
.............................................................................................. 17
.................................................................................................. 18

19

................................................................................................................................................................. 19
................................................................................. 20
................................................................................................................................................................................. 22
........................................................................................................................................................... 22
............................................................................................................................................................................ 23
......................................................................... 23
............................................................................................... 28
....................................................................................... 31
....................................................................... 33


................................................................................................................................................................. 35
............................................................................................. 36
................................................................................................................................................................................. 38
........................................................................................................................................................... 38
............................................................................................................................................................................... 39
................................................................................................................. 40
......................................................................................................................................................... 42
................................................................. 42
............................................................................................................. 43
- ...................................................................................................................... 44
(ARPA-E).......................... 47
(TIP)....................................................................................................... 47
................................................................................................... 48
- ....................................................................................... 51
MIT................................................................................................................. 54
: ......................................................................................................................................................... 56

iv

59

................................................................................................................................................................. 59
60
................................................................................................................................................................................. 62
........................................................................................................................................................... 62
.................................................................................................... 63
: .................................................................... 63
: .................................................................................................................................. 65
: .................................................................... 66
IT- ............................................................................................................................................... 69
............................................................................................................................................ 70
72

75
................................................................................................................................................................. 75
76
................................................................................................................................................................................. 78
........................................................................................................................................................... 78
................................................................................................................................................... 79
1970- ITRI........................................................................................................................................ 80
....................................... 83
....................................................................................................... 84
........................................................................................................ 86
............................................ 86
: .................................................................. 87
..................................................................................................................................................... 88
........................................................................................................................... 88

89

................................................................................................................................................................. 89
........................................................................................................................................................ 91
1990- ........................................................................................................................................................ 91
2000- .......................................................................................................................................... 93
.................................................................... 94
..................................................................................................................................................... 94
, 97
...................................................................................................................................................... 100
.................................................. 100
..................................................................................................................... 101
............................................................................................................................... 103
................................................................................................................. 103
SWOT- ............................................................................................. 104
......................................................................................................................................................... 104
............................................................................................................................................................ 104
................................................................................................................................................ 104
...................................................................................................................................................................... 104

107

15 ............................................................................................ 107
20 ............................................................................................................ 121
.................................................................................................................................................................... 123

4 . 124

, , , .

: , . -

1987 . , , ,
, . ,
, ,
1, 2.
, , , , . ,
, ()3. , .

, , , .
,
. , , , .
,
,

. (Growth Theory and After). ,


(, ). 81987.

. . : DARPA (The Connected Science Model for


Innovation: The DARPA Role) XXI : .
(21st Century Innovation Systems for Japan and the United States: Lessons from a Decade of Change.
Report of a Symposium). , : The National Academies Press, 2009.

- . : (National
Systems of Innovation: Toward a Theory of Innovation and Interactive Learning. : Pinter, 1992. . .
. : (National Innovation Systems: A Comparative
Analysis). : Oxford University Press, 1993.

1. 4
. , ,
,
. , 4 . . , , ,
.

5
, , ,
.
.
, , , ,
, (. 1).
, .
: , .
: , , (R&D), . (-, , , ..), 4

. . (The Elusive Quest for Growth). , : MIT Press, 2002.

. (Measuring Regional Innovation). ,


: Council on Competitiveness, 2005.

; - , ; , , ,
.
. , . , , . ,
, . . ,
, ,
. , , , .
.
, , .
.
, , , .
, , .
, .



. , ,
, , .
, .
,
, , , , .
- , ,
.
, , . - :
, , .
, ,
, .
,
.


, , , , , . ,

. ,
. 24 18 . ,
, , , , , .
, , ,
, .
. .

, , , .
. , .
- .
, , , , , , .


.
, , , ,
. , , , . , , , , ,
.
,
.
, , . .
, ,
, . ,
, .
.
, .
, , . , , .





1948, ,
.

,
, .

-,



( 1968)

RAFAEL

1948

.
RAFAEL

Discount Investment Corporation, DIC

1961
,

(Office of the Chief Scientist, OCS)

1968

,

.
1,3

-


(Binational Industrial Research
and Development Foundation,
BIRD)

1977

,

.
BIRD
110 ,
.

,
, BIRD


(Technology
Incubators Program)

1990 OCS

Yozma

1993 OCS


. Yozma
170

MAGNET

1992
OCS

- ,

,
.
MAGNET
( 66%) ;

.

Yozma II

1998 Yozma

Yozma,

.
,
-,


40 % - ,
. , ,
, , . OCS BIRD
,
. OCS
,

2. ( )
: , ( 15 2010).

3. ( )
: , ( 15 2010).


ff
.
ff ,
. BIRD
(
) - .
,
.
ff , ,
. ,
, ,
, .
ff
;
- .
ff ;
.
ff (OCS) -
. OCS
.
OCS ,
, .
ff .
.

ff - ,
- .
ff OCS
.
ff ,

.
ff (start-up),
.
.


. XIX XX , ,
, , , . ; , , ,
, , 1934. 1948

. ,
.
, ,
. , . , , ,
, . , : , 1960-
, .
, , , 1959 1969
. . (, , )
, , .
, 1968,
. , 6.
, . ,
.
.
.
(
), . RAFAEL (, )
- ,
. RAFAEL ,
,
.
RAFAEL , ,
, , ,
6

Dan Senor, Saul Singer. Startup Nation The Story of Israels Economic Miracle (New York: Twelve, 2009): 177.

.
, , RAFAEL 1956. ,
,
.
, ,
.
RAFAEL , , .
,
. ,
34. , , ,
.
1966, , RAFAEL, - ,
. , ,
, ,
R&D, 14 - . .
, , . 1967 , ,
, , , .
, 1968, .

, ,
-.
- . -
,
.
R&D
1968 (OCS). , , , . ,
, , .
R&D
, . , 1965
, .
,
. , ,
,
.

10

. ,
, 1970- .


1973 -.
, : 1967,
.
, . ,
, , , .
, ,
, .
- . ,
, 1968 , R&D .
OCS .
NASDAQ 1970- , Elscient, , , .
, 1970- , . -, ,
, ,
, . -,
-
, ,
. , ,
, , .
. ,
, . , :
RAFAEL. , ,
.

. 1970- ,
,
. , . , , .
, ,
,

11

,
- , .
, , . OCS,
.
yy OCS .
. -, OCS
,
50 % ,
.
,
: OCS 10 . -, OCS ,
, .
yy OCS. OCS ,
, .
, . OCS, ,
, .
, , ,
.
yy OCS .
, , . , -
, .
- , . , , .
OCS ,
-. -; .
yy . ,
,

. , - (BIRD). BIRD, ,
- .

12

BIRD

, 110 , .
, . OCS.
, 1978
. ,
. , OCS .
,
, . ,
, , .

BIRD
BIRD 1977,
1978. . , BIRD - Tyco International,
, .
, , .
, 70-
. , ,
. , -
.
BIRD , R&D , ,
. , ,
. ,
.
BIRD , , . ,
, .
. ,
, - 7.
BIRD , . , BIRD 50 %
.

13

, , Intel .-, 1974


. Intel
- . ;
.

1980- 

500. 1 , 35 ,
100. 20 . OCS, BIRD , , . : 5 %
, 150 % . BIRD
. BIRD,
OCS.
BIRD . ,
, .
BIRD , , , . , BIRD
, ,
.
OCS BIRD, ,
.
. , National Semiconductor, Digital Corporation, Motorola, IBM, Intel , - . IT- 1980-
.
, BIRD OCS :
1992 60 % , - , 75 % ,
NASDAQ, BIRD8.

1980-
1978 , . IT-, , ,
. OCS ,
. , , .
, OCS,
. -, , ,
. , 1984 ,
, OCS .
, ,
. . ,
. , DIC ,
1961, , IT-. 8

Senor and Singer, 164.

14

1980-

DIC , Elscient, Elron, Elbit,


NASDAQ, , DIC
OCS BIRD9.
, ,
(Israeli R&D Associates, IRDA), 1980- , . ( )
, OCS .
, , . 1985
,
.
, , , ,
( ). BIRD
.
, Inbal, . -, 70 %
. Inbal ,
, , , ,
10.
Yozma OCS 1992 , Inbal. Yozma :
-, ,
; -, , ,
; -,
. , BIRD. Yozma . 80 , 8 10
, 40 % . 20 .
, Yozma . 10
, 20 . , 1998, Yozma II. 170 . , -,
, 11
.

9
10
11

15

Dan Breznitz. Innovation and the State: Political Choice and Strategies for Growth in Israel, Taiwan, and Ireland (New Haven:
Yale University Press, 2007): 49.
Breznitz, 78
The Yozma Group. About Yozma Overview. www.yozma.com/overview (26 2010.).

1980- 

Yozma -
(Technology Incubators Program). 1990- ,
. : ,
, , . ,
, , , .
30 24 . 10 ( ), -
350600. .
1,8 12. 85 % , , -
. 2001 13 ,
13.
, , , .
, 1990- , MAGNET (
1992). OCS MAGNET - ,
, , . MAGNET, , -
, .
MAGNET ( 66 %); . . , .
, MAGNET, , ; 90 % , 10% 14.
yy . MAGNET. , .
3 6.
yy . ,
.
yy . .
, . , 800. .

12
13

. www.incubators.org.il/.
. Lopez-Claros and I. Mia Israel: Factors in the Emergence of an ICT Powerhouse. Global Information Technology Report:
2005-2006. Hampshire, England: MacMillan, 2005

14

The Magnet Program. About Us. http://www.magnet.org.il/default.asp?id=26 (26 2010.).

16

yy . , . ,
. , 100. , 10% .
, RAFAEL, 2002 .
,
. RAFAEL
RAFAEL Development Corporation, - Elron .


- ,
. , , ,
, IP, , ..
( ),
.
( ) , , , .
, , , .
yy ,
, RAFAEL, .
yy , OCS BIRD, ,
,
.
yy ,
.
, ,
.


yy , ,
RAFAEL, ,
,
. , - (RAFAEL) .
yy RAFAEL, OCS,
BIRD - , .
yy , OCS BIRD , ,

17

. ,
, ,
.
yy
.
yy , .
yy , ,
.
( Inbal),
, (Yozma) .


yy ,
, IT-. - .
yy , . , ,
. OCS, BIRD , .
yy , .
,
.
yy
. ( ) , .
, , , , 1967, :
? IT- , ,
.
yy , ,
. ,
, , ,

.

18




XX , 1990-, , .

. ,
,
.

19



( 1991 )


VTT

1942

Sitra,

1967

Nokia

1967

Nokia Ab, Finnish
Rubber Works Finnish Cable
Works;
1990-
1970


1982


.
,


,
,
.
Sitra

,

,
.
260
- . 5 .

,
. Technopolis Oulu.
,

,
, ,
. ,
Tekes
. 2009 Tekes 579


, ,

. 100 % .

.

,

Tekes,

1983


(Research and
Innovation Council, RIC)

1987

1994


1990

2001


,
.


. .
- .

20

4. ( )
: , ( 15 2010).

5. ( )
: , ( 15 2010).

21


ff
.
ff .
ff .
ff .
ff .
ff :
.
ff Nokia ,
.
ff .
,
.
ff .

ff (Nokia)
.
ff , ,
.
ff ,
, , .

22

,

. :
- ().
,
.
, -
. ; (
) , 15.
,
16. -
,
, 17.
, ,
.
:
,
, .


5060- .
,
- , .
,
18.

.
,
, , .
,
,
19.
1960-. ,
, ,
, .

23

15

Charles Sabel, AnnaLee Saxenian. A Fugitive Success: Finlands Economic Future (Helsinki: Edita Prima Ltd, 2008): 16.

16

Jaako Simonen, Philip McCann. Innovation, R&D Cooperation and Labor Recruitment: Evidence from Finland. Small Business
Economics 31 ( 2008.): 181.

17

Elina Berghll. R&D, Investment and Structural Change in Finland: Is Low Investment a Problem? (Helsinki: Government
Institute for Economic Research, 2009): 10.

18

Jussi S. Jauhiainen. Regional and Innovation Policies in Finland. Regional Studies 42 ( 2008.): 1035.

19

Markku Sotarauta and Mika Kautonen. Co-evolution of the Finnish National and Local Innovation and Science Arenas:
Towards a Dynamic Understanding of Multi-level Governance. Regional Studies 41 ( 2007.): 1092.

,
(), 1969,
20.
,
.
yy Sitra, , ,
,
.
, ,
21. Sitra 1967
50- , 100
(25,8 ). ,
[]
[ 22],
[] . ,
Sitra .
, 1991 Sitra
23. .
yy 1970
.
,
. 1997 ,
,
. 2008 380 ,
1992.
yy Tekes, , 1983
( ).
1980 ,
,
. Tekes,

- ,
, 24.
,
. Tekes
, 25. Sitra, Tekes

20

Sotarauta and Kautonen, 10891090.

21

Sitra. This is Sitra. www.sitra.fi/en/About+Sitra/sitra.htm (26 2010.).

22

Finnish Markka Multimedia Information, SanDiegoAccountantsGuide.com, Discovery Media. www.


sandiegoaccountantsguide.com/library/Finnish-markka.php (12 2010.).

23

www.sitra.fi/en/About+Sitra/sitra.htm.

24

Tekes. Milestones. www.tekes.fi/en/community/Milestones/628/Milestones/1552 (12 2010.).

25

Sotarauta and Kautonen, 1091.

24

, . Tekes
. ,
, , Tekes ,
26.
yy (VTT) 1942
. VTT
. 1960-
- 26,
400 . 2006
VTT, ,
,
. VTT
.
yy -. 1982,
1990. 1994 1996 , -,
15.
,
. 2,15
, .
, ,
50100.

. , ,
, .
, ,
, , ,
.
(. ), . ,
, ,
,
, . ,
, ,
27.
yy .
, -
. Technopolis , 1982,
1999 21 28.

25

26

Tekes. How We Work. www.tekes.fi/en/community/How%20we%20work/342/How%20we%20work/1287 (12 2010.).

27

Pier A. Abetti. Government-Supported Incubators in the Helsinki Region, Finland: Infrastructure, Results, and Best Practices.
Journal of Technology Transfer. 29 (2004): 2528.

28

Mariagrazia Squicciarini. Science Parks: Seedbeds of Innovation? A Duration Analysis of Firms Patenting Activity. Small
Business Economics. 32 (2009): 172.

- 29.
Technopolis ( HEX )
, , , , ,
- .
Technopolis
, . ,

, ,
30. , , , ,
, 31.
Technopolis Helsinki-Vantaa.
-
, , -
Aviapolis, . Aviapolis,
- , ,
,
.
yy ( 1987,
).
, -.
,
, 32.
,
, 33.
(. ), ,
, 34.
2009 35.

. .
1969 Nordiska Mobil
Telefongruppen (NMT)
29

Kysti Jskelinen. The Role of Science Parks and Centers of Experise in Finnish Technology Policy. In Veijo Ilmavirta and
Charles W. Wessner, eds. Programs to Support Innovation and the Development of Small Business in Finland and The United
States: A Review of Current Policy and Research, Conference Proceedings (Helsinki: Picaset Oy, 2001): 112.

30

Squicciarini, 175.

31

32

Charles Wessner, Veijo Ilmavirta. Introduction. In Veijo Ilmavirta, Charles W. Wessner, eds. Programs to Support Innovation and
the Development of Small Business in Finland and The United States: A Review of Current Policy and Research, Conference
Proceedings (Helsinki: Picaset Oy, 2001): 25.

33

Research and Innovation Council, Finnish Government. www.valtioneuvosto.fi/hallitus/tutkimusneuvosto/en.jsp (14


2010 .).

34

Marja Hyrinen-Alestalo et. al. Changing Governance for Innovation Policy Integration in Finland. In Governance of
Innovation Systems, Volume 2: Case Studies in Innovation Policy (Helsinki: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and
Development, 2005): 127.

35

The Science and Technology Policy Council of Finland. Review 2008 (Helsinki: The Science and Technology Policy Council of
Finland, 2008): 3.

26

36. 1980- NMT


, 37.
, .

, Nokia Ericsson,
.
1991 Radiolinja
(GSM),
38.
Nokia , 1967
Nokia Group. ,
.
: - ,
(Finnish Rubber Works) (Finnish Cable Works)39. 1963
, 1965- 1970- 40. ,
, 1991 Nokia .

41. 90-
-.
Nokia NMT
42. , GSM
. Nokia

.
Nokia
; 1980 1995 Tekes
8% , Nokia .
,
.
- .
, .

. ,
, .

27

36

Sabel and Saxenian, 63.

37

Palmberg, 134.

38

Palmberg, 134.

39

Manuel Castells and Pekka Himanen. The Information Society and the Welfare State: The Finnish Model. Oxford University
Press: 29.

40

Navin De Silva, Matti P.T. Juvonen, Roopinder Singh. Innovation at Nokia: a Case Report (London: Imperial College of
London): 45.

41

Castells and Himanen, 30.

42

Sabel and Saxenian, 6367.

, 43.
1980-
44.

. , 1960- 1970-
- . 1960
. 1965
, 45.
, 1970- ,
(VTT), , ,
46. 1987 Nokia
. 2000 15. -
47.

. ,
, , .
1980- .
.


, 1990- ,
. 1993 1990 9,5%.
17%. ,
48. ,
. ,
, ,
,
.
, ,
. ,
. ,
, Tekes,
, . 1990
1990-
,
49. ,
.
43

Sabel and Saxenian, 3839.

44

Sabel and Saxenian, 27.

45

Sotarauta and Kautonen, 1090.

46

VTT Technical Research Center of Finland. www.vtt.fi/?lang=en (6 2010.).

47

Sotarauta and Kautonen, 109293.

48

Jauhiainen, 1036.

49

Jauhiainen, 1036.

28


. -
3% 50. 1988

. 1993
,
.
1990 ,
. ,
,
( 1995)51.
1990- ,
.
( 1994).
. ,
,
, 52. 1990
53. 21 .
2007
21 54.
, , ,
55.
( 2001).
, .
56.
, (
),
( ) .
3457.
Tekes
. 2009 579
. (,
, , )
, (,
, ). Tekes

29

50

Berghll, 6.

51

Jauhiainen, 1036-37.

52

Jauhiainen, 1039.

53

Jskelinen, 113.

54

Oske Centre of Espertise Programme. Idea of Oske and Central Concepts. www.oske.net/en/oske/idea_of_oske_and_
central_consept/ (6 2010.).

55

www.oske.net/en/oske/idea_of_oske_and_central_consept/

56

Jauhiainen, 1041.

57

The Regional Centre Programme. www.intermin.fi/intermin/hankkeet/aky/home.nsf/pages/indexeng (6 2010.).

236 343 .

58.
1980- Tekes .

, , .
,
, 59.
Tekes ,
( 1984 1997 ) 60.
,
Tekes, 2008
,
61.
Sitra . 1980-

. 1990-,
Sitra
62. 2009 Sitra
38 , 63.
Sitra
Tekes.
1990-
-64. Nokia, ,
, -
.
Nokia Nokia
Mobile . ,
Nokia - ,
,
, Nokia 65.
1990-
. 1993 1998
, .
66.
58

Sabel and Saxenian, 113.

59

Sotarauta and Kautonen, 1092.

60

www.tekes.fi/en/community/Milestones/628/Milestones/1552.

61

Ministry of Employment and the Economy. /www.tem.fi/index.phtml?l=en&s=2072 (12 2009.).

62

www.sitra.fi/en/About+Sitra/history/history.htm.

63

Sitra. Auditors Report. In 2009 Annual Report of Sitra. The Finnish Innovation Fund, To Parliament (Helsinki: Sitra, 2010).

64

Berghll, 9.

65

Castells and Himanen, 3234.

66

Sabel and Saxenian, 69.

30


,
. ,
, ,
. ,
, : 2009
7,8%67. 1990-, ,
.
Tekes Sitra -
, .
, ,
Tekes ,
68. Tekes ,
, 69.
, Sitra (
) -
.
.
, ,
.
,
70. ,
2009 ( , Sitra
), ,
71.
,
72. ,

73.
-,
, .
- ,
, ,
. , , 74.

31

67

Oxford Economics. Country Briefing: Finland (Oxford: Oxford Economics, 2010).

68

Sabel and Saxenian, 113.

69

Sabel and Saxenian, 98.

70

Sabel and Saxenian, 19.

71

Sitra, 2009. Annual Report, 11.

72

Oxford Economics.

73

Darren C. Zook. The Curious Case of Finlands Clean Politics. Journal of Democracy 20 ( 2009.): 163.

74

Berghll, 24.

. ,
,
75. 1990 .
,
. -
76,
77.
-, Nokia, .
,
, . ,
. Nokia ,
, -
78.
: Nokia
- 79.
,
.
, ,
80. ,
81. ,
200 , .
-
,
82.
83.
.
.
.
, -, Nokia,
Tekes 84,
.

75

Berghll, 1.

76

Sabel and Saxenian, 2728.

77

Oxford Economics.

78

Sabel and Saxenian, 7779.

79

Berghll, 20.

80

Berghll, 23

81

Berghll, 5.

82

The Science and Technology Policy Council of Finland, 10.

83

Berghll, 36.

84

Sabel and Saxenian, 74.

32


, ,
,
.
yy :
. ,
, .
. ,
, , ,
.
, .
, ,
.
yy :
,
. ,
.
.
yy :
.

.
. ,
.
yy :
.
, ,
, .
yy :
, . Tekes, Sitra
, ,
,
,
.
yy :
,
.
,
.

.
yy : Technopolis,
,
,
, .

33

yy
:
Nokia - ,
, ,
.

34


()
.
, ,
,
. ,
.
-,

35


(National Academy of Sciences,
NAS)

(National
Institute of Health, NIH)

1863


(National Science Foundation,
NSF)

1950

1887

, 1930 NIH

1901
(Na-
tional Institute of Standards and
Technology, NIST)


(Small Business
Administration, SBA)

(Small Business
Investment Companies, SBICs)


, , ,




, . NIST
2009 992 ;
610


, .
NSF 1 1983
(2,19 2010 ) 6,87
2010
.


,
,

1953

(Small Business Act)
1958


(Small Business Investments Act)

1958



(DARPA)
,
1971
NASDAQ (National
,

Association of Securities Deal . 1982
(NASD)
ers Automated Quotation
,

, NASDAQ

National Market (NNM), 1990

,
)
( 40 % )
Nasdaq Small Cap Market (SCM)
1976 ,
-

(Office of Science and
,
Technology Policy, OSTP)
,
.
.

US Chief Technology Officer (
1961

) Chief Information Officer (
)
-

1982
,



(SBIR)

1988
,

,


(MEP)


,

2007
,
(TIP)
America COMPETES (


)

(NIST)

2007

America COMPETES
, DARPA.
(ARPA-E)
400

2009 . ,
1

36

6. ( )
: , 15 2010

7. ( , )
: , 15 2010

37


, . -
, . .
.
2009 -
14 % ,
. ,
60 .
, .

,

ff ,
, .
ff , .
ff .
, ,
.
ff , ,
.
ff , .
ff ,
.
ff , ,
.
,
, NASDAQ.
ff , , ,
.
ff , .

ff , ,
.
ff .

38


. , , , - , ,
,
. 1791 ,
85.
, .
1798 1842 86.
, - . , 1802
-
, - - .

, , 1824
1828 . ,
,
. 1862
, .
.
, <>
87. 1890 .

, . ,
1887 , XIX .
- 1914 , , 88.
, , ( ) .
, , , .
, 1863 -

39

85

. : (, :
National Academy Press, 2001).

86

87

. . . 7. 14, 304.

88

. . - XXI (: Iowa State University Press, 2001).

. ,
1879 ( 1930 ), 1901 , 1937 ,
89.

. , - . , , ,
, - . , , , 1919 , -
General Electric (RCA),
, 90.


1940- -
.
-
. , ,
, .
, 1943 ENIAC 91.
1941 (OSRD) - .
, , OSRD
6. ; . , ,
92.
, ,
.
, , . 1945 ,
.
89

. - :
(, ..: National Academy Press, 2003).

90

. - . . :
XXI (-: IEEE Press, 1995).

91

. - . 2003.

92

. . : , (-: The Free Press,


1997).

40

, . OSRD 1950 (NSF),


.
- . , , . 1957
. ,

- ,
.
1958 (ARPA, DARPA Defense, ).
- , DARPA
, - .
DARPA ,
c , , ,
. ( ) , ,
, (GPS).
(NASA) 1958
,
. , , ,
, .. NASA ,
, , ,
. NASA
, , , , ,
.
. ,
1958 1 , , . , 1966 G.I Bill , 1944 1952 ,
, .
, ,
, 93.
1958 ,
(SBA) , 1953 ,
(SBIC). SBIC 93

41

..
: ( Teachers College, Columbia University, 1982).

, , . 5
, SBIC
. SBIC
10- 300 %, ( ) 108,8 94.
SBIC ,
, . 19701980- .


, ,

.
, ,
, . , ,
.
1970- 1980-
, , 95. ,
,
,
- .


. - , ,
, . 1980- . 96:
yy (1980 ). - , . , ;
yy (1980 ).
, , ,
.
94

www.sba.gov/aboutsba/sbaprograms/inv/esf/inv_sbic_financing.html.

95

(, ..: US
Government Printing Office, 1985).

96

. - . 2003.

42

,
,
;
yy (1986 ). ,
,
, .
- ;
yy (1989 ).
, , , -
(CRADA) .
1990- , CRADA
.
. , , -,
97.
,
-. ;
.
, ,
. ,

- 98.


.
, :
,
. , 19701980- , ,
- . , , , - , , , . ,
.

43

97

., - (: Stanford
University Press, 2004).

98

. ., ., . . : .
, 8 ( 2007).

- 

1984 (NCRA),
, , 99. NCRA, -, , (RJV)
: ,
. -,
, , 100.
NCRA ,
, , , NCRA - . ,
,
, , . 1993
(NCRPA).
NCRA, . NCRPA ,
, 101.

-

-
.
,
102. , 30 ,
.
, -,
, -,
103.
1982
, , 99

. A., . . (
, Microsoft). , ..
February 5, 1998.

100

., . , . : Oxford University Press, 1992.

101

. . ( , ).
-: Springer Publishing, 1997.

102

. : ., . . , : MIT Press, 1991.

103

. . , : MIT Press, 1995.


,
. ,
,
, [] .
. . . . -: Harper Business, 2000.

44

.
(SBIR). , -, ,
-,
- , -, , -, , - 104.
SBIR , , 100 0,2 % . 2,5 % .
yy SBIR 11 :
yy (DoD),
yy (NIH)
yy (DoE)
yy (NASA)
yy (Homeland Security)
yy (NSF)
yy (NIST)
yy (EPA)
yy (DoT)
yy
yy (USDA).
SBIR . 100 . ,
750 . . (SBA),
, . ,
, ,
105.
-
1988 .
() ()
(NIST, ). MEP , ,

. MEP- -
( Lean, .) ,
106.

104

. .

105 . .
106
.

45

. . www.nist.gov/mep
( 26, 2010).

- 

ATP
- , ,
- ,
- , 107. ATP , , ,
. , .
;
, .
1990- MEP ATP :
, . .
, 2007 America COMPETES. (TIP), .
, 19701980- , , , . - ; , ,
, .
, .
50 ,
7 , . , .
. , 2007 America Creating
Opportunities to Meaningfully Promote Excellence in Technology, Education, and Science, America
COMPETES ( , , , )108.
: Innovate America ( )109, 2004 , Rising Above the
Gathering Storm: Energizing and Employing America for a Brighter Economic Future ( : )110,
2007-. America COMPETES
: Innovate America , 107 , .
108 America COMPETES, 110-069 ( 21 2007 ., 9
2007 .).
109 . :
. , ..: Council on Competitiveness, 2005.
110 . :
. , ..: National Academy of Sciences Press, 2007.

46

(ARPA-E)

IBM, , ;
Rising Above the Gathering Storm , Lockheed Martin.
America COMPETES ,
(, ), (,
) , (, ). ,
(, - ).
, , , 1980-, .


(ARPA-E)
America COMPETES 2007 - (ARPA-E).
400 2009 ,
.
ARPA-E , DARPA:
,
111. , 2 2010 . ARPA-E , (Grid-Scale Rampable
Intermittent Dispatchable Storage), .
. ,
, . ARPA-E
, : ;
; ( ) . DARPA, ARPA-E
, 112.

(TIP)
America COMPETES (TIP)
, .
, , 111 ARPA-E. . arpa-e.energy.gov/LinkClick.aspx?fileticket=FzuPHgdX6r8%3D&tabid=184 (4
2010).
112 . , ARPA-E. apps1.eere.energy.gov/news/news_detail.cfm/news_id=12478
(4 2010 .).

47

TIP, , 113.
70 2010 .
TIP 3 3 9
5 . - 50 %
. , ,
, , . , .
TIP , ,
.


, .
,
.
128 , ,
. -, , : 1)
; 2) ; 3) ; 4) ,
.
.
(MIT)
. MIT, , -.
1861
114 115.
, , . , , 1940 , (OSRD) ,
. MIT 4000
- .
MIT, . , , 1951 .
- DARPA

113 NIST, . NIST . www.nist.gov/tip/upload/revised_


faq_website_1_16_2010.pdf (4 2010 .).
114

. . . 7. . 13, 34.

115

, : 128-
. : Harvard University Press, 1996.

48

NASA116. MIT , MIT . ,


, , MIT117.
MIT ,
(SBIC). 1946
, MIT . , - (ARD),
, -
118. , ARD, . - (
- ) .
, Raytheon, Digital Equipment Corporation (DEC)
Analog Devices, .
( ) MIT, , , . ,
,
. , , ,
- , ,
, 119,120.
1939
Hewlett-Packard, . - ,
121.
, , .
1940- , - , , -, . , Varian Brothers,

116 , . , 19202000.
. , .: Princeton University Press, 2010.
117 . . :
. R&D Management 37 (January 2007).
118 . , 15
119

120 , M. : . , .: Stanford
Business Books, 2000.
121 412417.

49

Hewlett Packard, Fairchild Semiconductor () Intel, , 122.


19501960- , ,
, .. Bay Area , Varian Hewlett Packard 1950-
. , , Fairchild DuPont, ,
123.
SBIC 1958 . 1960-
- SBIC,

. SBIC , .
SBIC
, (LLP), - ,
, SBIC124. 1968 1975 30 ,
. , , Xerox 1 , , Apple II, .
1970- 2030 %,
, . 1970- . 1978
50 % 28 %. , 1979 , (ERISA),
,
, . , , ,
, .
, NASDAQ
. NASDAQ 1971 NASD
. -
(NYSE) , NASDAQ , , ,
. IPO NASDAQ

122 Ibid.
123 Ibid.
124 .

50

, , ,
.
, , ,
-, .
, 128
, . ,
, The Regional Advantage ( )125.
, ,
.
- , ,

.

, . , , ,
. ,
. , , , .
, ,
,
128. , , ,
, . , , .

-
,
- . , , ,
2,2 (NIH)126, - , .
, ,
. -
1,3 . , , 2001 2006 8 %, 2,5 %127. ,
.
, . , MIT , 1914
125 . Culture and Competition in Silicon Valley and Route 128. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1994. . 226.
126 . II: , ,
- . : New England Healthcare Institute, 2008.
127 , 11.

51

- 

2006 23 , - 128.
, . , , 129 .
MIT ,
, - , . , 1906 26 , , -
.

- .
, , .
130. 1977 , ,
MIT, . ,
(NIH) c . , ,
. 1976
, ,
. 131.
, , , ,
. 1980 Biogen , - MIT. ,
, . 1981 . ,
, . Biogen ,
,
132.
, , , . 1970-,

128 , 2425.
129 . . . (, ), 8 1993.
130 , . : -
. European Planning Studies 16 (April 2008).
131 .
132 .

52

, ,
. , , .
, -, MIT. , 1960- MIT -,
-. , Biogen
Idec Genzyme,
133. Wyeth Novartis. .
,
, 134. , MIT, - 5 135.
- 95 136. , MIT .
2006 (Mass
Life Sciences Center).
.
, .
(-
)137.
2007 -
1 .
. .
- . , - ,
, , ,
, . 2008 Research Matching Grant 12
138. .
25 ,
, .
133 , 56.
134 . : .
. 1982 .
135 , 56.
136 ., . : MIT. : Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 2009.
137 .
138 .

53

MIT

. 9 , , 139.
1. (ITC). 10 % , , ,
.
2. , (FDA). 100 % , ,
, . , FDA.
3. 5 15 . , - , 15 .
4. ,
. , .
5. .
.
6. - . ,
.
7. ( ). .
8. , ,
.
9.
.

MIT
,
MIT . 140 MIT .
yy 1945 MIT (TLO)
MIT
141. MIT
. TLO , - ,
. 1,2

139 www.masslifesciences.com/incentive.html.
140 , .
141 .

54

MIT

. 15 %
. MIT ,
, . TLO MIT
, 224 10 142.
yy MIT (MIT Enterprise Forum), 1970- ,
, MIT, . 24 , 2010 143.
yy MIT (MIT Entrepreneurship Center) 1990-
30 MIT ,
. ,
, 144.
yy MIT (Venture Mentoring Service) 2000 , MIT, .
2009 88 145 .
yy (MIT Deshpande Center) 2002
MIT , 17,5
146. ,
, -
-147. 1,7 : 1,3 , 320 .
, 80 . . 250 .
: ( 50 .) ( 250 .)
. 64 7
. 18 % . 88,7 148.
yy - MIT (MIT Media Labs) , 1985 MIT ( . MIT).
,
, , . 1990-
,
142 , , 8.
143 , , 7.
144 , , 7.
145 , , 8
146 , , 9
147 . . - , 25 2010.
148 . ., . . -:
. : Kauffman Foundation, 2008.

55

: 

, ,
149. . ,
60 , , .
, Digital Life, Things That Think
Consumer Electronics Lab. 20 .
MIT . , . , , . MIT,
, .

:
, , , .
yy
, , .
yy .
, .
. : ,
.
yy . ,
.
yy .
yy
, ,
. , ,
. , , .
yy , MIT, , , .
yy ,
.
yy

149 MIT Media Lab. www.media.mit.edu/ (5 2010 .).

56

yy , ,
.
yy MIT .
yy ,
, ,
.
yy
yy ( ,
) .
yy
,
.
yy .
yy
.
yy
, .
yy .
, TIP ( ATP) DARPA (ARPA-E),
, .
yy . : ,
- , ,
, . ,
, .
. IPO NASDAQ , , , .
yy . ,
MEP SBIR, .
yy .
. , , ,
, .
yy . ,
.
, ,
.

57

: 

58



,



,
.

,

.
.
,

59

-

(CSIR)

(SIRDO)

1970
. (.
) . (BISR)
1971

,
.

-
,


.
-

-,
,
..

-
(19741979)

1974
-



(SIRDO)

-
(NSTEBD)

(STEP)

1978
.

1982


1984

(NSTEBD)

1940-
.
1985
STEP
, ,



1985
(MOST)



(TIFAC)


(SCII)

1942




IT- .


- ,


, ,
-

1988
,
, ,


, 1990


(SIDBI)


100150 % (
, ). .
, , .
.
,

60

6. ( )
: ( 15 2010 ).

7. (
)
: ( 15 2010 ).

61


ff , .
ff .
.
ff
, .
ff
.
ff ,
.
ff , ,
.

ff .
ff ,
, .
ff , , ,
,
.
ff , , ,
. .
ff ,
-.
ff
.

62


,
XVIII . , ,
1947 .

.
, - . - , .
.

.
. 1980-
,
, .
, .
:
, ,
. , , ,
150. , .
, 151.
, (License Raj),
.
, - .
, , . ,
, -
152.
, . , -

150 . . . . 36(2). 1998..903936.


151 . : ? . 1999. 19(67). . 403
412.
152 ., . : . :
Anthem Press, 2009.

63

153. ,
, ,
154. , .

. , 1950 ,
.
,
.
. , . , 1951 IBM , 155.
- (), . 1958, ,
156.
1974 - ,
, , , 157. 2. ,
24 ,
158. ,
,
, 159.
,
- .
, , - (CSIR). CSIR
- , 1942 1947 . , CSIR

153 ., .
. 2003.
154 ., . :
. 2009.
155 ., . . :
- . : , ,
. Imperial College, . 2010.
156 . (1958). -, .
157 . - 197479 . . 1976. .99104.
158 . K. - : .
. 31(1). 1987. . 87101.
159 .

64

160. 1958 1974 ,


: , 161. CSIR ,
, ,
162.
1977 , - 1974 , , ,
163. IBM
License Raj, 164. ( 1980 ), -
.
:

. - ,
. , ,
, 1974 165.
1983 ,
166. ,
, .
(TIFAC)167. 1985 Texas Instruments
168.
- , . , , ,
70 % .
.

160 . - . . 159(4032). 1947. .


183184.
161 A. . . . 9(1).
1980.. 7496.
162 .
163 . K. .
164 , .
165 . . 87101.
166 . . .
27(4). 1998.. 429433.
167 . .
. . 71(8). 2004.. 855863.
168 .

65

- ,
1986 . 169.
, , ,
,
170. ,
,
; ,
.
1980 1989 ()
3 . : 0,1 % 171.
, 72 % , 13 ,
172. ,
,
, .
,
; .
:
1990- ,
173. , . ,
.
1991 174.
. ,
:, ,
.
51 % . , ; .
.
, , , , .
169 .
. . 17(1112). 1997. . 707714.
170 .
171 . : . :
. 12(4). 2006.. 413429.
172 . . . 11 2010.
173

. : . :
. 12(4). 2006.. 413429.

174

. . 1991. -, .

66

, - ,
. 1990- 2000- 70 % , ,
70 % 175.
1996 2007 0,8 %, 0,5 1,5 %,
2,6 %176.
, ,
2001 177.
, , . 1995 19 . 200178.
, . ,
, - :
- , .
-
2003 .
. ,
, . 179:
yy ;
yy ;
yy 2007 2 % ;
yy , , ;
yy
, ;
yy , ;
yy ;
yy .
, ,
. 1999 , 2002 2005 (1970) ,
.
, . 1991 ( -

175 , ().
. . 11 2010 .
176

www.uis.unesco.org.

177

www.data.worldbank.org/data-catalog.

178 .
179

67

. - . -, . 2003 .

, ) 375 180. 1992 2009 4384, 40 % (70 % 1991


)181. 20042005 (, ..),
, , ,
182.

. CSIR, 23 , 2007
, 183. ,
, , , . 72 %
.

- (IT-BPO) 1991 . , ,

IT-BPO,
. 1991 , .
60 % IT-BPO184. IT-BPO
71 ( 150 1991 ), 2,23 ,
5,8 % 16 % 185.
, , . 1996 (1013-
3- ), . (5- )
10 % (1- ). , , H-186, 25- , , ,
. , -

180 . / ,
. 14 2010 .
181 . 1991 ?
. . 5(1). 2010.. 542.
182

183

184

.
. . 2001.

185

NASSCOM. 2009 . - . , .

186 -( ) , .
, . ,
202, , 202 202 .
1023.

68

IT-

5,77, ,
(4,61 4,42 ), 13,3187.
: 68 %,
30 %188. ,
, . 189.

IT-
.
2009 15 , 30 % 190. , , . ,
.
1909 ,
(), - , 191. , ,
, .
1970- , , , ,
IBM.
Wipro , 192. , 1983 Infosys
, 193. Keonics ( ), ,
.
1980- 1985
Texas Instruments. TI - , 194. TI
, ,

187 SCIMago Research Group 2009 .


SCImago 14 2010 .
188

189 . The World Factbook. 2009 . 12 2010 .


190

. The Hindu. , 2009.

191

., . - 19992008
. . 97(3). 2003.. 304.

192

, .

193 . . Ind Corp Change. 14(3). 2004.


. 393418.
194

69

. : .
- . 15(3). 2010.. 247270.

, 195. TI 196.
Texas Instruments , 2005 (IBM, Microsoft, Google, Cisco Dell) ,
- Wipro Infosys.
,
, . ,
, ,
Wipro Infosys. ,
20 % ,
, 197.
,
.
, : ,
, IT-, 1990- 198.


. -
. ,
, , , , . , ,
.
, .
2006 . , ,
, , : ,
. , , . , , 199.
1950- , . , , . ,
, , ,
, .

195 , .
196 .
197 .
198 . : , , . 2 2006 . ,
. 2008.
199 ., . : ,
. . . , 2007.

70

- ,
.
, , . .
-, : .
, , , . 2 % 20 ,
200.
-, , ,
.
, , 201. . ,
, ,
.
,
202. , , : , . , .
, , .
, , .
, .
: ? - 2003
. , . 16 %
. 92
%. , , 2328 % ,
. , 12 %,
90 %, 68 %203.

1991 . , 200 . . : . World
Bank Publications, 2007 .
201 . : .
, 2006.
202 ., . : ? . 93(4). 2008.
. 452458.
203 .

71

. .
, , ,
204.
, .
, .
, . , . , - , .
, . , , .
, , : ,
205. ,
; ,
,
; ,
.
, , .
, ,
.
.
-. ,
.
, .
,
.


. .
yy , , .
yy
, .

204

. .

205 .

72

yy , , . , .
yy ,
,
, .
yy , . ,
, .
yy
.
-.
yy .
yy , , ,
. , ,
.
yy . , . ,
.
.
yy 2% ,
, .

73

74




,
,
.



,
,
.
,

75

1949
()

(
)

1959
(NSC)


(IDB)

1970

, ,
,

-

(ITRI)

1973


. ,
,

-
(STAG)

1979
-

-
-

-
(OSTP)

1979

,
(
)

1980


,
, , , ,
,

1993

1999


(SBIR)

1999

,

-,

2002


(
)


,
, . , 30-
.
20 ( 635 )

76

8. ( )
: , .

9. ( )
: , .

77


ff
. .


.
ff , ,
, , ,
.
ff
- .
ff
, .
ff .
ff
.
ff ,
, , ,
.
ff .
ff ,
.

ff
.
ff / ,
, .
ff , , ,
, .
ff ,
.
ff .
,
.

78


1949 ()
- , . , , , ,
. . 1960-.
, 1984 .
2 : , ,
. , - . 1950- , 1960- .
, , 206.
(USAID), , ().
, - . , .
, , 207.
, . -, , ( ) 208. -, 1959
(NSC), - .
, ,
1956 1957 209.

- .
, 1961
Fairchild Semiconductor Philips Electronics
. 1964 Philips General Instrument.
1965 .
24 . , 1960-

206 , . www.gio.gov.tw/ (20 2010 .).


207 .
208 , . About IDB ( IDB). www.moeaidb.gov.tw/external/view/en/
about/index.html (16 2010 .).
209 ,
- .

79

1970- ITRI

/ : , ,
210.

. , Admiral (1966), RCA (1967), Motorola (1970) Zenith
(1971), . , Matsushita (Panasonic), Sanyo, Sharp Toshiba, , , ,
. , , 211.
- . , ,
. , , .
, ,
. , . .

1970- ITRI
. 1966 1971
58 %, 37 %
212. 1970- .
,
, . . , . , , 1971
213.
, ,
, . 1973 , - -
(ITRI). ITRI

. ITRI , : . , 210 . ., . : . : MIT Press, 2003.
211 .
212 .
213 .

80

1970- ITRI

. ITRI - ,
.

, . 1974
, , Sarnoff
Labs RCA, - , () -, . , ,
.
(ERSO), ITRI,
( ) , .
ERSO - .
, , . 1976
ERSO RCA
ITRI. RCA ERSO ().
, 40 RCA , ERSO
, RCA. ,
1979 ERSO , RCA,
, 214.
, 1970-,
.
UMC. 1978 ERSO RCA .
51 % , ,
1980 United Mircoelectronics Corporation (UMC). ERSO
ERSO . UMC ,
ITRI/ERSO, .
STAG. , , , , - STAG. 1979
STAG , -. , .
. 1980 -
. ITRI .

214 , 106.

81

1970- ITRI

, , , , 215
216. ,
, ,
.
UMC .

,
(DRAM), 217.
, (ASIC), .
, , , ASIC
.
1983 72,5
ASIC. ,
( ). ERSO, , UMC,
Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Corporation (TSMC). TSMC ,
(48,3 %), 27,5 % Philips.
1986 TSMC , , . ERSO
, Taiwan Mask Corporation (TMC) 1988 Vanguard
International Semiconductor 1994-.
, , ,
. , , ASIC-,
. 1994 65
, . , .
, ITRI, (CCL),
, . , ,
ITRI ,
, , ,

215 , 106.
216 ,
, . . .
: . . .: Stanford Business Books, 2000.
217

, DRAM .
,
.

82

. AMD Intel, .



, .
, ,
, . , , , , . .
1979 , ITRI,
(III). III :
. , , ITRI , III , . ,
, .
III ,

. ITRI : ERSO. , III
, . ,
III, , , , .
, III , Windows Office, . III , , Microsoft.
III , .
, . , , Microsoft , 218.
, III ( , ),
, , , III. ,
, ,
. ,
, . ,
- - , . III
218 ., . : -.
, 47. 2000 .

83

, . ,
, ITRI, 219.
, ,
. (. ) , , ,
, . : ,
. , , ,
-, , .


UMC, TSMC ASIC
ERSO, . ,
,
.
, , , .
1979 - .
, ,
( ITRI), . .

. () (ODM) , ; ,
. ,
.
, ITRI ODM-OEM- , . , 1983
Acer ERSO .
1990 , CCL
,
.
, - CD-ROM - TFT220.

219 III, ITRI


.
220

. ,
1994 . CD-ROM.
50 . . .

84

-.
, . 1980-. ITRI
,
. 1987 ITRI
, Giant Manufacturing Company
, , 2000 ,
high-end. - ,
(
); , (, ), , ITRI.


1990- ,
, . , 1992
, 66 , , . , .
, ,
, ITRI .
, ,
.
- . 1993

, ( ITRI) ; , ,
ITRI.
.
221. 1997
(
), ,
. ;
.
13,58 (420 ). 536 864 . , 15.
9,32 .
(SBIR). 1999
. 3 . , 221 , .
. www.doit.moea.gov.tw/doiteng/contents/b_acv/default.aspx?type=1&sn=5. 27 2010 .

85

12,1
(). SBIR, .
1 (1 30. ),
. , 5
(310. ) .
, , , , 222.
. 1999 .
, ,
. -, . 370 , 6500 ,
12 (373 ).
. 2002
,
. ,
. 100 29 . 35 ( ).



1990- , TSMC, Acer, Quanta . ITRI, .
,
. , ,
, , , , .
1999 (Basic Law on
Science and Technology, BLST), (Bayh-Dole
Act). NSC , . BLST . 2001 ,
,
(Technology Transfer Centers, TTC) 223.
2001 - (Themed Industrial Technology Innovative R&D Center), 222

http://doit.moea.gov.tw/doiteng/contents/b_acv/default.aspx?type=1&sn=5.

223 John A. Mathews, Mei-Chih Hu. Enhancing the Role of Universities in Building National Innovative Capacity in Asia: The Case
of Taiwan. World Development 35. June 2007.

86

, .
, NSC, .
, .
: 422 , 188 79 , , .
(Systems on Chip, SoC)
ITRI
- .
85 , SoC .
,
,
. 60 , . ,
. , ,
.
, .
, . NSC , :
- , .
.
,
, . ,

. . ,
, , , , .

:

. , ,
, ..
. ,
, , .

87

: 

.
, , , , ,
, .

yy , , ().
yy ITRI ,
,
, . ,
.
yy ITRI
-, , , () . ITRI , .
yy
( ) . , ,
, , ,
( , , ).

yy ITRI ,
. ,
, , , ITRI .
yy III , .
yy , ,
, , , . ,
, ,
.

88


, .
, , , .
, .

, ,

.
,

89

.
yy .

,
.
yy .
, .
.
yy
.
.
yy

,
, , .

yy , ,
.
.
yy ,
, .
yy , .
,
, , ,
,
.
yy
, .
.
yy
.
yy
,
.
( , ):
yy
;
yy
;
yy
, -
;
yy .
yy .
,
.

90


, , ,
. . - .
- ,
. .
. ,
.
. , ,
. . , , , .
.

1990-
, , . (
), . ,
,
, , , , .
, ,
.
, ,
,
, .

,
.
,
.
, ,
1990-, . (
), ,
,
. ,
,
. .

91

1990- 

, EPAM, Luxoft, Artezio, Exigen Services, Auriga .,


.
, .
,
,
. .
, ABBYY, Acronis, Parallels -.
.
- ,
,
.
-
. , ,
.
, , , :
.
, .
, .
, , ,
.
1990-
. ,
. ,
, ,
. Intel, Boeing,
Cisco, EMC, Motorola, Schlumberger PriceWaterhouse.
. ,
,
,
.
1990-
. , .
.

, .
-
:
. .

.

92

2000-

2000-
1990- , 2000-
2008 .

. 13 %, 2010
6- . ,
,
, , -
. 1998 ,
85 % 1987 .
,
.

, . 20002007
20 % , 40 %,
30 %.
.
,
, .
- , ,
.
,
. ,
, , , .
,
- , .
, ,
,
.

.
3040- - 2009 ,

.
- ,
, 1990-,
. , ,

, . ,
,
, .

. -
.

93

,
, .
,
. , IPG Photonics (www.ipgphotonics.
com) NT-MDT (www.ntmdt.com),
,
. , ,
;
.
4 : , ,

.
, ,
:
yy ;
yy ;
yy ;
yy ;
yy .
, , , , , , .
, , . , ,
.
.


, . , . , - , :
yy . -
,
. ,
I. 1990 535 .
.
, -.

94

yy . , ,
. ,
. 1992
450 , .
.
yy - ().
. ,
,
;
( ). 1990
75 % , 88 %
78 % 224.
, .
.
yy - - .

, .
,
, .
, , -
,
. , . ,
, - ,
- , ..,
, , - .
, , , .
.
, 225. ; .
,
. , , , , , . .
,
500 10000 200 10000 . , . ,

224 . . . 2003 . . 910.


225

95

. . 10.

, . 50 % ,
226. ,
, , , , .
,
. -
, , ...
.
, ,
, . . , , ,
, , .
, - .
.
2000-
. , .
2009 , ,
. 475
. , .
,
. , ,
, ,
,
.
, .
, , ,
- . ,
.
, . , ,
,
,
, .

226 ... - 2007 . . 93.

96




Initiatives
for Physical
Infrastructure
to Support Innovation

. ,
, ,
. :
yy
(http://i-russia.ru/).
. , ,
,
, .
yy (http://government.ru/ru/gov/
agencies/138/). .

.
yy (www.
iis.ru).
, , , ,
.
, ,

.
, :
yy (http://mon.gov.ru/).

.
2015 .
:
,
.
.
yy ,
(http://www.economy.gov.ru/minec/main/).
-
2020
2012 .
,
, ,
.
.
(www.
economy.gov.ru/minec/activity/sections/specialEconomicAreasMain/index.html),
().

97

Initiatives for Physical


Infrastructure
to Support
Innovation 

yy (www.minsvyaz.ru).
,
.
. , , .
, ,
. ,
. ,
,
. , , ,
.
: ,
.
.
-, .
, -
, . -
,
. , .
,
, .
, , () , , .
, , , . , , -, - .
, :
yy : , ;
yy -: -, , .
.
,
.
.

. , 1015
- , ,
. ,

98

. . ,
- , .

:
yy ( ) , ;
yy (, ) ;
yy - ()
, ;
yy () ,
, , , ;
yy (, ) ,
, , ;
yy ( ) ,
;
yy - - ;
yy , ;
yy .
, 2010 , ( ). ,
,
.
, , ,
.
-, . , - .
, , ,
, .

.
. ,
-,
. , , ,
, , ,
, .

. , , , , .

99

, , - . .. : 17 %.
1 %.
( ),
, , . 50 % . ,
, , . 227.


(www.i-gorod.com). , , , . 20000 .
, , . ,
3 7 . ,
- .
, , . .
, ,
, . 2010
(MIT) ,
.



, . :
yy () (http://www.rusventure.ru/) ,
,
.
1 . 2010
27 . 149
.

227 http://www.newsprom.ru/Raznoe/120663516001824/Stenogramma_vystuplenija_Dmitrija_Medvedeva_na_

prezidiume_Gossoveta_Rossii.html

100

yy ,
.
,
.
, ,
2010 ; , 30 % .
yy () (www.rusnano.com) 2007
.
5 , 5
.
.
50 %.
. - ,
.
,
, - . ,
, .
yy (http://www.rostechnologii.ru).

; ;

,
;
. .
yy 150
, 2006 . . 2010
.
yy (http://www.fasie.ru/Default.aspx).
- 1994 -
.
...... 1 2010
20000 7500.
, ,

.


, , , . , ,
- .
() (www.rvca.ru),
- (http://

101

www.russba.ru/language/ru/). , , , DFJ-VTB-Aurora.
, Barings Vostok Russia Partners,
.
.
, ,
, (IPO) . IPO ,
.
,
. . , 80 %
, 20 % . , , , , .
,
. ,
, , , Digital Sky
Technologies (Facebook, ICQ, Vkontakte, Mail.ru, .). , , , .
, . , ,
, , .

,
.
. , , .
.
,
. ,
, , .
, -, , , ,
.

102

,
.


, .
, , .
, , .
.
. , , -
, (
).
. ,
. ,

, .
, , , .
,
, , . ,
. ,
, Bar Camp .
, , , .
,
. ; ,
. ,
.


, . , , .
,
.
.
, , . .
.

103

SWOT- 

SWOT-

yy , , .
yy .
yy
.
yy ,
.

yy .
yy ( , , . .).
yy ( , ,
).
yy .
yy .
yy , .
yy .

yy .
yy
,
.
yy : , ,
.
yy ,
: ,
, .
yy
.
yy ,
.
yy ,
.
yy , .

yy ,
.
yy .
yy , .
yy .
yy .
yy .

104

,
, . ,

. , , , , ,
, , .
. -,
, ,
. ,
, .
, , ,
, ,
,
. , , .
, , , .
, ,
- , () ,
. , ,
-
228. , ,
,
(License Raj) ,
,
, .
, , . , 228 http://www.masslifesciences.com/incentive.html

105

,
, . , . ,
.
, , , , ,
.
, .
,
.
,
. ,
.
,
. , , .
, , 4 .. .

106

15

15
1 , , -

,
, . .


- .
,

, ,
. , .
.
, .
,
. .
35 , , , .
,
. .
, . ,
. ,
.
, .
yy . , ,
, . ,
. ,
,
.
yy :
- , ,
, , . .

107

15 

,

,
- .
yy - ,
, .
. ,
229,
230. .
,
.
yy ,
, , , , .
,
. :
III. ( ,
)
yy ,
.
, .
,
. 2010 ,
,
, ,
, .
yy
(, . .) .
.
yy
. , . ,
.
III. : , , (
)
229

, . 38-39.

230 , . 27-39.

108

15

yy , .
, ,
.
.
yy , , , .
, ,
, . ,
,
, , , .

.
yy , ,
.
, .
IV. ,
yy
,
, .
yy , , , .
yy
.
yy
, .
V.
yy ,
,

.
yy , - .

109

15 

yy -.
.
yy .

.
, . , ,
.
(, -
).
, .
.
, 1970-
.
.
1979 - STAG231, .
, , , ,
, , .

.
. 19911993
, , . ,
.
:
yy
(Russia Chief Technology Officer), .
231 STAG Science and Technology Advisory Group
(- ).
, ,
- . STAG 5 .

110

15

yy , ,
,
.
yy
,
.
yy (Russia Chief Information Officer),
.
, , ,
, .
yy , , , .

, .
19911993 , . .
. ,
.
, XX ,
,
.
:
yy
,
.
yy ,
, , , , .
, .

.
, ,
; , . , ,
, ,
. ,

111

15 

, .
,
,
. , .
BIRD VTT, .
, BIRD
. VTT BIRD
, ,
, , .
:
yy ,
,
,
.
yy
, - , .
yy
,
, .
yy , .
yy
.

, .
, 1,
, -
Nokia.
, :
.
,
.
, :

112

15

yy , (, ), (, ), (, ISO).
yy , ,
.
,
, , ,
, .
yy .
yy , (
).



.

.
, ,
, .
, , ,
( , ,
; : ).
, . , ,
. ,
.
:
yy ,
,
, , .
, , .
yy
.

113

15 

yy ,
, ,
, .
yy
.
.


,
, ,

. , .

, .
. , ,
. , ,
.
.
5 , . VTT. , . -
, . - .
, .

, RAFAEL, VTT, SITRA, DARPA, CSIR ITRI.
:
:
yy
.
yy , , .

114

15

yy ,
.
yy
-
yy , ,

, , .
:
yy - .
yy
.
yy , .
yy , .
yy .
yy
,
.
,
, , ,

.

-
, , , .
. , -
- 232. , , (MIT).

232 , .

115

1515




- , MIT .
, .
, , . , .

10

,
.
, , . - ,
, :
yy , .
, , .
yy , ,
.

11


.
.
, . , .
:
, .
, , , . ,

.
:

116

15

yy ,
, ,
.
yy ,

.
(,
) ,
, ,
,
.
yy
.
yy
,
.

12

, , . ,
,
. ,
, .
, ,
.
13 24
. Technopolis,

,
.
, , :
yy ,

: , ,
.
yy ,
, .

117

15 

yy
,

MIT.
yy
, , ,
.
yy ,
,
, ,
.

13


, , .
.
,
. TIP, SBIR DARPA ,
- (
, , ) .
, , 3.
,
, ,
-, , ,
, .

14

.
( , ). ,
. , , , . Yozma , ,
.
-

118

15


,
,
.
, .
,
(IPO) NASDAQ, .
, :
yy ,
- ,
,
.
(
limited liability partnerships, LLP) .
yy
( NASDAQ),
, .
, AIM LSE,
.

.
yy 5 %
, .
yy ,

NASDAQ.
yy

NASDAQ.
yy
.
yy

( , . .) .
yy
.

15

.
yy ,
.
yy - ,
,
.

119

15




.

yy

.
yy
.
yy .
yy
,
,
.
. ,
. .
, , . .

120

20

20
:

, . .

.
.

,

, .


, , .

-, , .

6
7
8

, ,
.
,
, ,
.
, (
Nokia), .

121

, .

10


.
.

11

,
, , , .

20 

12

, .

13

, , .

14


SBIC .

15

, ,
, .
.

16

. , ,
.

17

18

- ,
, ,
. , , , .

19


,
,
.

20


, .

122

,
.
, , , - ,

.
.
, ,
.
.

,

-

250, 40-
.-, - 10007-2157
.: 212-298-8600

123

,
,
, NYAS ,

, ,
4
.
4 .
, , . ,
, . , .
. ,
.

124

1. .

,
.
( , ,
)
yy ,
, .
2011 .
yy
: 2012 .
yy ,
: 2011 .
yy :
2020 .
: , ,
yy
: 2011 .
yy ,
: 20122020 .
yy : 20122020 .
yy ,
: 2011 .
,
yy ,
: 20112015 .
yy ,
: 20122016 .
yy
,
, ; 2016 .
yy
, : 2011
2012 .
yy
, : 2012 .

yy ,
,

: 2010 .
yy
, -
: 2011 .

125

yy
-.

: 2011 .
yy
: 2012 .
yy ,

: 20122015 .

2.

yy ,
,
: 2010 .
yy
: 2011 .
yy : 2011 .,
2012 ., 2013 .
yy : 2011 .
yy ,
, LLP: 2010 .
yy ,
: 2011 .
yy ,
: 2011.
yy : 2011 .
yy
: I 2011 .

yy : 2010 .
yy : 2011 .
yy : 2011 .
yy : 20112012 .
yy : 2011 .
yy : 2011 .
yy : 2011 .

yy ,
,
( ).
.
:
2010 .

126

yy ,
: 2010 .
yy
,
: I 2011 .
yy
.

yy ,

,
: 20102014 .
yy
, , : 20112015 .
yy
: 20112015 .
yy
: 2010 .
yy
: 20112013 .
yy
: 2011 .
yy
: 2011 .

yy

: 2012 .
yy ,
,

: 2012 .
yy ,
: 2011 .
yy
-
: 2011 .
yy , ,

,
, : 2012 .

127

yy
- ,
: 2011 .
yy ,
,
: 2012 .
yy
,
: 2012 .
yy
,
: 2012 .
yy
: 2011 .

4.
yy NASDAQ , ,
: 2012 .
yy

: 20102012 .
yy
: 2011 .
yy 20 %
NASDAQ: 2012 .
yy , ,
: 20102014 .
yy
: 2011 .
yy

: 2010 .
yy
: 2011 .

-

- (New York Academy of Sciences,
NYAS)
. 200 1817
,
,
.
, -,
.
: -
,
,
.
,
,
, , , ,
.
NYAS 26 ,
,
,
.
-
- www.nyas.org.
,

-

250, 40-
.-, -
10007-2157
.: 212-298-8600