Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 18

IV: .

2006. . 2. . 63-80

(PROSWPON)

. .
,

, , ,
, . .

, ,
. .
.
,
, .
- 60-

, , .
()
, ,
. , 63

, . , ,
.
1. ()

,

, , . ,
, , , . , .
. 1.
IV . (prswpon).
, .
,
(), (), (),
(), (), (), .
,
() , ,
2. (), 1 . , . . , ,
, .
.
2 

64

.. ()


()3.
4 , , 5.
IV ,
, .

(monarca) , 6
(koinwna) , 7.
.: Ndoncelle M. Remarques sur
lexpression de la personne en grec et en latin // Explorations personalistes. Paris, 1970.
P. 47184; De Vogel C. J. The concept of personality in Greek and Christian Thought //
Studies in Philosophy and the History of Philosophy. Washington, 1963. Vol. 2. P. 2060;
Milano A. Persona in teologia. Napoli, 1996. P. 16, 6771.
3 Athanasius Theol. Epistula ad Afros episcopos // PG 26. Col. 1036. L. 2021;
Theodoret of Cyrus. Eranistes. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1975. P. 64. L. 911; Theodoret.
Kirchengeschichte. 2nd edn. // Die griechischen christlichen Schriftsteller. B. 44. Berlin:
Akademie-Verlag, 1954. S. 113. L. 1314; Hieronimus. Epistula 15 // PL 22. Col. 457a.
4 (329379); (330389)
(335394).
5 Basile, st. Lettres. Vol. 2. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1961. Epist. 210. S. 5. L. 3436;
Ibid. Epist. 214. S. 4. L. 1122; Ibid. Vol. 3. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1966. Epist. 236.
S. 6. L. 2228 ( :
. . , 2003. . 312, 319, 369); Gregor von Nazianz. De spiritu
sancto (Orat. 31) // Gregor von Nazianz. Die fnf theologischen Reden. Dsseldorf:
Patmos-Verlag, 1963. S. 9. L. 812; Gregorius Nazianzenus. Orat. 33 (Contra Arianos et
de seipso). S. 16 // PG 36. P. 235-236; Orat. 39 (In sancta lumina). S. 11 // PG 36.
P. 345. L. 3949 ( : , . :
2- . .: - , 1994. . 1. . 448, 490491, 537538).
6 Basilius Cappadociae. Contra Sabellianos et Arium et Anomoeos // PG 31. P. 605.
L. 3638 ( : , . : 5- .
., 1993. : ., 1846. . 4. . 381); Ibid. P. 609. L. 1921 ( :
. . 383384); Gregorius Nazianzenus. De filio (Orat. 29) // Gregor von Nazianz.
Die fnf theologischen Reden. S. 2. L. 111 ( : ,
. . . 1. . 414).
7 Basilius Cappadociae. De Spiritu Sancto // Sources chrtiennes. Vol. 17 bis. Paris:
Cerf, 1968. Ch. 18. S. 45. L. 23 (PG 32. 194C) (. .: , . .
. . 3. . 300); Basile, st. Lettres. Vol. 1. Paris: Les Belles Lettres, 1957. Ep. 38.
S. 4. L. 4550 ( :
. . . 67). . : Zizioulas J. D. Being as Communion: Studies in
Personhood and the Church. Crestwood (NY): St. Vladimirs Seminary Press, 1993.
P. 134. .: . .
. . : . ., 1914. . 496.

65

. , 8.

, ,
XX . . ,
(. 1935) () (.
1931) .
, , , , 9. (19261992), ,
(12961359),
10.
8 ,
,
. , (),
IV ,
, , (Hierotheos (Vlachos), metr. of Nafpaktos. The Person in the
Orthodox Tradition / Transl. by E. Williams. Levadia-Hellas: Birth of the Theotokos
Monastery, 1999. P. 6875).
, . . : . . // , . : / . . . . .: , 1997. . 433437, 439, 450451; , .
// . 1998. 2 (16). . 258;
, . // . .,
2001. 3 (16). . 210228.
9 . : / . . . . . .: , 1992. . 7273; Zizioulas
J. D. Being as Communion. P. 4849 ( : (),
. . / . . . // . ., 2002. . X. . 49).
10 , . : /

66

.. ()

.
, . , , , .
IV (451 .)11 ( ) ( ) ,
,
12.

,
.
,
.
,
. , , , 13.
,
, , 14.
. . // . 2000.
. V. . 2425. . : . . // . .
. . ., 1991. . 102148; (), . . / . . ., 1998. . 19.
11 Concilium universale Chalcedonense anno 451 // Acta conciliorum oecumenicorum. Vol. 2.1.2. Berlin: De Gruyter, 1933. P. 129. L. 23 P. 130. L. 3 ( : . 4- . ., 1996. . 3. . 48).
12 . : , . . ., 1998. . 21.
13 .,
: . . / .
. . . . ., 1999. . 932, 5456.
14 . : / . . . . . : , 1999. . 210211.

67

2.

2.1.
15,
16, 17

.
,
. , , , , , , , .
.
18 19. . ,
20.

21. .
15 .: 1. 2627; 5. 1; 9. 6; 2. 23; 3. 9.
16 .: 2 7. 28.
17 .: 14. 20; 17. 911; 17. 2026.
18 .. // -

. . : . ., 2000. . 291.
19 .. . C. 91;
. . . 101. .: .. // . . . . 316317; (), . . Essex: Stavropegic Monastery of St. John the Baptist, 1985.
. 238.
20 .. . . 296297.
.: , . VVIII . ., 1992. :
Paris: YMCA-Press, 1933. . 123124.
21 .. . . 298299;
. // .. . . ., 1991. C. 273.

68

.. ()

.


. 22.
. ,
-,
,
-23, , -, . , , , 24.
. ,
, , , 25.
.

, , , 26. , , ,
, , , . , , , , ,
, , , 22 .. . . 93;
. // .. . . 484.
23 (), . . - :
/ . . . // .
.: . , 1997. 2. . 1. . 4344.
24 . . . 102; Staniloae D. The Experience of God. Vol. 1 /
Transl. and ed. by I. Ionita and R. Barringer. Brookline (Massachusetts): Holy Cross
Orthodox Press, 1994. P. 131132; John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Man the Priest of
Creation: A Response to the Ecological Problem // Living Orthodoxy in the Modern
World. London, 1996. P. 182.
25 .: John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Being as Communion. P. 3940 ( : (), . . . . 38).
26 .. . . 268269; .
. . 102; , . :
. . 2324, 2627.

69

27.
,

, . ,
, ,
28.

, , , 29. , ,
30.
. , .

- , , .
. , .
, , ,
. . 27 . . . 66; John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon.

Communion and Otherness // Sobornost incorporating Eastern Churches Review. 1994.


Vol. 16. 1. P. 17; John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Human Capacity and Human
Incapacity: A Theological Exploration of Personhood // Scottish Journal of Theology.
1975. Vol. 28. P. 408; " . % &%  ) )  ,
-. Ay^hnai, 1970. S. 1315. .: . / . .
.. // . . ., 1999. . 480.
28 53. 9; 8. 46; 14. 30; 1 2. 22; 1 3. 5; 2 5. 21; 7. 26.
29 John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Communion and Otherness. P. 18.
30 Ibid. . 20; John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Human Capacity and Human
Incapacity. P. 412; John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Preserving Gods Creation: Three
Lectures on Theology and Ecology (Lecture Three) // Kings College Theological
Review. 1990. Vol. 13. P. 12.

70

.. ()

. , . .
, ,
.
. 31.
,
.
, , , , , , ,
,
.
. . ,
, , 32.

- , .
,
, , . , ,
, .
31 .. . . 214215; (),

. . . 182; Staniloae D. Op. cit. P. 127.


32 .. . . 93;
. . . 102103; (), . . Essex: Stavropegic Monastery of St. John the Baptist, 1999.
. 24, 97, 190191; Staniloae D. Op. cit. P. 245; Zizioulas J. D. Being as Communion.
P. 49 ( : (), . . . . 50); John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Communion and Otherness. P. 1718
( : (), . . /
. . . // . , 1995. 3 (172). . 19).

71

, , 33.
- ,
, ,
.
,
, 34.
,
. ,
(, , , ) , (, , ,
) 35. , 36.
. : (4),
(), (), (5) , : (), (), (), (5) 37.
33 Basile, st. Lettres. Vol. 1. Epist. 9. S. 2. L. 1617 ( :
. . . 31); Ibid. Vol. 2.
Epist. 210. S. 5. L. 2830 ( : . . 311312); Gregor von Nazianz.
De filio (Orat. 29). S. 6. L. 2223 ( : , . . . 1. . 417).
34 .. . . 299300;
(), . . !.. / .
// (), . . . , 2000. C. 175;
Staniloae D. Op. cit. P. 126127, 134, 135. .: Kloczowski Jan Andrzej. Midzy samotnocia wsplnot
. Wstp do filozofii religii. Tarnw, 1994. S. 153.
35 Athanasius Theol. De incarnatione verbi // Sources chrtiennes. Vol. 199. Paris:
Cerf, 1973. Ch. 18. S. 1. L. 18 ( : , . .
.: - , 1994.
. 1. . 213). .: Richrdus a Sancto Victore. De Trinitate. IV, 7 // PL 196, 934935.
36 Basilius Cappadociae. Ep. 38. S. 2. L. 1119 ( :
. . . 64); Joannes Damascenus. De
fide contra Nestorianos. S. 3. L. 47 ( : . . . 142); .
. . 66; (), . . !.. C. 178.
37 Grgoire de Nazianze. Lettres thologiques // Sources chrtiennes. Vol. 208.
Paris, 1974. Ep. 101. S. 2021; Joannes Damascenus. Expositio fidei // Die Schriften des
Johannes von Damaskos. Vol. 2. Berlin, 1973. S. 52. L. 5256. .: Didymus Caecus.

72

.. ()

2.2.
, , , VI . -, (354430)
38. -
, (.
480524)39. , , , , ,
, 40.
, , , , . , ,
. , 41.
, ,
, , ,
42.
De Trinitate. Buch 1 // Beitrge zur klassischen Philologie. B. 44. Meisenheim am Glan:
Hain, 1975. Ch. 27. S. 32; Ibid. Lib. 3 // MPG 39. P. 788. L. 13; P. 969. L. 1924.
38 John (Zizioulas), metr. of Pergamon. Communion and Otherness. P. 8. .: .. . . 294. , , . : Benjamin R. Notion de personne et personnalisme chretien. Paris, 1971.
P. 104119.
39 Boezio S. Contra Eutychen et Nestorium // Boezio S. Gli opuscoli Teologici.
Genova, 1974. P. 326. . :
Ndoncelle M. Les variations de Boce sur personne // Intersubjectivit et ontologie. Le
dfi personaliste. Paris, 1974. P. 235271; Lutz M. Natur und Person in den
Opuscula Sacra des A. M. S. Boethius // Theologie und Philosophie. Vol. 58. 1983.
S. 4870; Milano A. Op. cit. P. 319387.
40 .. .
. 137138; John (Zizioulas) metr. of Pergamon. Being as Communion. P. 167.
41 Staniloae D. Op. cit. P. 276.
42 (), . . / . . . // (), . . . ., 2002. . 289290.

73

, , ,
.
43.
2.3.
, , .
. ,
,
. , , , , , ,
44.
, 43 . . 290291.
44 . . . 99100, 107108. -


, . , : , ,
, , , (. /
. . .. // . . 3- . .,
19681972. . 3. . 1. . 258); , ( 20-30 ,
25-55 (. . 460e). .: . Rep. Lac. I 6.
. Lyc. XV 4. . . VI 772b-d. . . VII.
1335b, 2939 (. 7 (H). XIV. 1112) . . .), <...> , ,
,
, (. . . 3. . 1.
. 259). :
:
(. / . .
.. / . . ., 19791983. . 4. . 623).
, ,
(Lyc. XV. 4): , (. : - .. // . . 3- . . 3. . 1. . 630).

74

.. ()

, .
, , . , , , , , 45.
2.4.

.


, , .
,
, . . , -
46.


, ,
, () (18961993) () (19142003).
XIX .
, .. , .. 45 .. . . 95;

(), . . . . 228. .: , . TENEBRAE NOCTUM.


// . 1999. . II. . 16.
46 ., : ..
/ . . . // . 1996. 1 (8). . 198207;
.. : 19931994 . ., 1994. 53 .;
, . : . 3- . ., 1997. . I
II. 160 . . III. 292 .; . : .
. ., 2000. 232 .

75

, XX . .

.
XX . . , , , , , ,
. , , , .
, ,
. 47.
, , ,
, , (relatedness) .
, ,

48. 49.


47 1 . 15: 26.
48 .:  8.  9 , ,   9 , 8- //

. 1991. 37. S. 1519; Oliver H. Relatedness: Essays in Metaphysics and


Theology. Macon (Georgia): Mercer University Press, 1984. P. 40; Melissaris G. A. The
Challenge of Patristic Ontology in the Theology of Metropolitan John (Zizioulas) of
Pergamon // The Greek Orthodox Theological Review. Brookline (Massachusetts):
Holy Cross Orthodox Press, 1999. Vol. 44. 14. P. 479482.
49 Papanikolaou A. Is John Zizioulas an Existentialist in Disguise? Response to
Lucian Turcescu // Modern Theology. 2004. Vol. 20. 4. P. 604.

76

.. ()

.
50. , 51.
,
- ,
, ,
.
,
) , , , 52.
, , .

53, , .
, ,
.
,
, , 50 ., : Bowne B. P. Personalism. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company,
1908. P. 266.
51 ., : Brightman E. A Philosophy of Religion. New York: PrenticeHall, 1940. P. 364.
52 .: Papanikolaou A. Is John Zizioulas an Existentialist in Disguise? P. 605.
53 . : Zizioulas J. D. Being as Communion. Note 40. P. 4546;
 8.  9 , ,   9 , 8-. S. 1819; John (Zizioulas), metr.
of Pergamon. On Being a Person: Towards an Ontology of Personhood // Persons, Divine
and Human. Edinburgh: T&T Clark, 1992. P. 37; Papanikolaou A. Divine Energies or
Divine Personhood: Vladimir Lossky and John Zizioulas on conceiving the Transcendent immanent God // Modern Theology. 2003. Vol. 19. 3. P. 357385.

77

. , , ,
, .
, - .
2.5.

,
,
. , , , , ,
.
.
, , , , ,
.
,
,
.
.
.


. 78

.. ()

.
-

. ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
, , .
.

,
. , , .
2.6.



,
.

, .


. , , , .
79

, ,

. , , , .


. ,
, , , .
, .

THEOLOGICAL CONCEPT OF PERSONALITY


IN THE STRUCTURE OF METHODOLOGICAL PARADIGM
OF

ORTHODOX PSYCHOLOGY AND PEDAGOGICS


S.A. CHURSANOV

The report covers a number of problems connected with mastering a common comprehensive terminological system used in Orthodox Theology, Psychology, Pedagogics
and other humanities, where the focus is on the concept of personality, by Orthodox psychologists and teachers. The author outlines the main methodological advantages of terminological system related to the concept of personality.