ЭФФЕКТИВНАЯ РОССИЯ Производительность как фундамент роста

McKinsey Global Institute
McKinsey & Company

McKinsey & Company ,
. McKinsey
,
,
. McKinsey
,
, .
McKinsey
,
. McKinsey
1993 .
500
.
McKinsey (MGI) 1990
McKinsey
.

,

.
McKinsey (www.mckinsey.com/mgi)
,
.
Copyright McKinsey & Company 2009
2009 .
9
13
1.
20
2.
30
3.
38
49
75
101
123
153

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, , ,
.

McKinsey, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
.
.
1999 . McKinsey &

Company
,
, . 1998 .
, .
40% 1990 .,
50%.

. 1998 . 7% ,
72- 53- .

26% .
2008 .
,
.

.
:

.

.

,
-, ,
.

, .
,
,
.
,

, ,
1.
. .

.

12 2.
. .
.
-
: 26%
.
,
2020 . .
6%.

. ,
,
.

,
.
1. .
30 80% .
,
, ,
.
2. . 40%
,
16% .
20 60%
.
. .
() 8 2008 .
. . 8 2008 .
.
10
3. .
, 515% .
, ,

, ,
.

.
.
.

,
. .
,
.
,
.
,
.
.
.
,

-. -

.
,
.

.
,
.

,
, ,
, ,
.

.
,
.
, ,
. ,
, ,
,
.
.

. ,
,
, ,
.

.
,

,
.

.
.
,
,

,
.
,
.
,

.
11
12

,

3.
, , ,
,
(
), (
) ( ).
, ,
,
. ( -)
,
, . ,
( ,
), 4, (
-) , .
3
.: William W. Lewis. The Power of Productivity: Wealth, Poverty, and the Threat to Global
Stability. University of Chicago Press, 2004.
,
.
:

.

.
, .

. 2008 .,
, ,

: 5 1999 .

: 6%
2 3 (. 1),
.
18%
( , 1999 .) 26% 2007 .
( )6.
: 33%
, 31% , 23%
, 21% 15%
(. 2).
10 1,7 , .

, 1998 2007 . 13%

.
: Unlocking Economic Growth in Russia.

, 2007 .
30% . ,
, ,
,
. :

.
13
14
. 1
1998 ' & %%

#%" ! $
'
, ).(. %"". 2, 19982007 .
$ '
1, ).(. %"". 2
7,4%
0,7
14
1,4
0,7
13,9
0,4
4,1
7,3
X2
1998
1998
2007
%() &'%%)"/$%()
)'*
%() -("$$%()
'%-
(".
$$ 2007
-("$$%()
$("$1
1 ')) &%!*&)"/$% (&%(%$%().

2 '"/$.+ ,$+ 2005 .
()%-$!: Global Insight; $()'()% 0!%$%#-(!%% ')1 ; $" McKinsey.
. 2
!

+&'*!+$4&' ,)'&6 2, %
!,
+3*. '$$. , 2007 .

95
/!6
78
&
75
*(-6
71
'$41
'**!6
+$$!+"&6
()'%31$&&'*+4
' &!0&6 +')'$6
30
X3
31
' &!0&3 &#'*#!

,*$,!
23
!$!2&'
*+)'!+$4*+'
$#+)'5&)+!#
41
331
21
151
*)&%
(' )**%'+)&&3%
*#+')%
1 ''#,(&6 ()'! '!+$4&'*+4 -#+')' ()'! '*+ 5$#+)'5&)+!# 80%, *+$$!+"&'"

()'%31$&&'*+! 54%.
2 ' )' &!0&'" +')'$ ! *+$$!+"&'" ()'%31$&&'*+! )*0+ '*&'& & &&3. (' 2007 .,
(' &#'*#'%, *#+'), ! 5$#+)'5&)+!# 2006 ., (' *+)'!+$4*+, 2002 .
*+'0&!#!: Global Insight; EIU; IMF; '**++; McKinsey.
26
15

:
, .
, 1998 . 45%, 2007 .
80% (. 3), :
, 1998 2007 .
25 70%.
,
.

2007 . . 2020 .
10 .
. 3
1999

! , %
1990
1995
: ; IET;

.
1998
2000
2007
16

,
. 1991 . 6 ,
2020 ., ,
142 134139 7.

,

.
1998 2007 .
13%, 9 ( 3
).
2020 .
10 . ,
.

.
.
, 2005 .
,
. ,
18%
8, 15 16% .
, , ,

.

( ,
), ,
.
.

. , 2007 .
-
6 , , , .
.
: 60
55 .

. (
)
71%. ,
,

.
7
. . .
. 2003. 78; . ., . . : ,
. .:
, 2006.

2020 . .

6% . , 12
.
,
14 30 . .
20 .
.

? , ,
1,5

.
.

.

,
. ,
. ,
, ,
, . ,
, ,
,
, - .
.

,
.
, ,
,
.

,
2020 . ,
, ,
.
17
18

, 2007 .
,
.
, ,

, 35%9
.
2009 . 16%
.
2009 . 2,2%
1314%.
: , ,
1998 . 50%.
,

.

: ,
, ,
,
.
,
,

,
.
24 2007 . 198- 2008

2009 2010 .
,

.

.
?
,
:
( )
-

( ).
, .
,
.
2020 .
. ,
,
.

:
-, (
), (
). ,
.
, ,

.
,

,
. -

. , ,

,
. , ,

, 25 ,
.
,
. , ,
90%
.

.
, ,
.
19
20

.

.

. ,

-, ,

-
10.

,
, . ,
2540% ,
, , (. 4).

.
,
.
10 .: Turkey: Making the productivity and growth breakthrough, McKinsey Global Institute,
February 2003 (www.mckinsey.com/mgi).
21
. 4
& & %$, # !

& & &
'",
%"". $ 1 !)
& & #

",
'% $ 1 !. #
%(!
2,5001
945
*"$
752
%$%$
1,800
'.
414
#
388
'
720
626
'
331
275
28%
34%
1 '$22 %,$! &'%!)$% ()%#%() ()'%)"0() *%"0$/+ 1"!)'%()$, 2008 .
()%-$!: Renaissance Capital, steel business briefing; Economist intelligence unit; companies' data;
experts interviews, Ministry of economic development; McKinsey.

,
- .

.

, .
,
. ,

, ,
, (. 5)11.
- .
,

.
.

,

, (. 6).
11 Dealing with construction permits 2008.
22
. 5

%"-()% $
'%%
%&/)
X6
%((3
!'$ '"3
)
$3
+()$ ,3
$

1 (("%$ (#'$%% $! &'%3)(3 &'#'/ ''.$ , !%)%'/ $%+%#% &%"*-)0 "3
()'%)"0() *+1)$%% (!". )%%/ %,$! (%%))()*2) #)'"# $)'02 %)$%()"0$%
()'%)"0() #$%%!')'$/+ %#% %((.
()%-$!: Dealing with construction permits, (#'$/ $!, 2008 .; $)'02 ( 1!(&')#; $" McKinsey.
,
, ,
.

.
. 6
$"& &$!) "%% ! & "$" ".+ $ !,

*
%$*
!0& ! %" %*&

""
"#"!! %*&
""
& %" %*&

""
6,08,0
X5,0
6,5
4,0
1,8
1,6
##+

"*%&" %"&$'!",
'*%&'/,( #$")%%1
##+
### ###
1
2

5,0
3,0
1,0

1,7
"*%&" ' !-(

"' !&"1
3,0
2,0
X3,8
X2,2

2,0
### ###
1
2
1 * "%!*' " ###' "#' .

#$ ): & "(+, !" #$+ $; McKinsey.
##+

23

, MGI 1999 ., ,

, - .
. 40%
40 ,
28%, 12%, 3%. 16%
,
, - ,
.

, -
. 35%
, 70%.

.

.
12
, .
,
10%, 7% (. 7).

: ,
. ,
, , ,

.
.
. 7
! " $ #!

" "
,
&%'. ,*'!$/"#
100% = 3824
%$,*(''1
)%, "2
$"
93869
3994
%$,*(''1
)%, "2
33%
0%
0,1
72%
90%
%, "
(,%'"4.3
"

,
*+.(1 ' ()%,- ,*-,
(%%. ' 1 ,*'!$/"31
$"
0,6
67%
21%
(++"4
7%
10%
0%
%, "
(,%'"4.3
"*%'1
1 ''1 )( ! 2007 .

3 $%304 ,*'!$/"" 0*! '$(&,1, "',*', " *-" ,(&,"!"*(''1 $'%1 )%, #.
4 $%304 ,*'!$/"" (,%'"4. '$( " )(0,(1. (,%'"4..
+,(0'"$": /',*%2'1 '$", ((1 (,0,1 $(&)'"#, '%"! McKinsey.
1,2
24

. ,
,
,
.

,
, . ,

: , ,
, . .
(, )
, .

, ,
.
-
,

.

,
. MGI 1999 .
,
,
. 10 ,

.

. ,
20
. 18
. -

, ,
,
, .

, ,
,
12.
12 . .
, 2006.
25

,
.
, ,
, 50- .

,
,
.

1998 2007 .
19% , , .
1999 . ,

. 2007 . .
90- ,
.
,
. -

. , ,
2020 .
2530% .

.

,
(. 8).
, .
. 8
# !&" ) "

(%) '
%-#"6" 3"**6" 0) %
$ !&" ,

%, 2007 .
459
./*6" !+( +6" 0) %

+.0!-./"**6"
!+( +6" 0) %
*'+.'%" '(!6
442
409
399
380
340
282
161
32
47
149
18
170
83
,+*%:

%/&
33
61
25
35
121
106
123
176
141
35
"(%'+- +*
-%/*%: "-+
80
$%- *!%:
95%".:
-6*'%
$%%
8 5
46
+..%:
-%)"4*%": .(+#"*%" 8(")"*/+ )+#"/ *" !/7 .0))" 0'$**09 "(%4%*0 %$-$ +'-0 ("*%:.
./+4*%'%: $ !**62 McKinsey ,+ )%-+6) 1%**.+6) '/%); Global Insight.
30
59
+./+4*:
-+,
26

, 1998 2007 ., , 6%
.
, ,
.
, ,
,
.

.

, -
.
. -

, .
2000 2007 .
24%,
60%.
.
,
.
,
.
.
1999 .
.
.
.

.

,
,
,
.

,
.

,

. ,
, ,

.

,
.

,
.
,
, .
,
,
.
2530% ,
, , 5060%, 90%. ,

, , , ,
. 6 79
.

.

.

.

.
, .
,
, .
12
.
27
28
26%

1997

1,7

29
30

,
. ,
.

.

, .

.
,

,
.

.

.

.
,
,
, . .,
.

.
,
-
, , ,
,
.
,

.
, ,
,

.

,
,
.

.
,

.
,
.

.

.

. ,

. ,

.
,

, .
,

.
31
32

,
.

,

, , ,
. .

, . -,

, , , ,
. . -, ,

,
.
, ,

. , MGI,

, 13.

,
.
,
.

,
.

, ,
.
,

:
(,
), ,
.

, .
13 .: Tony Danker, Thomas Dohrmann, Nancy Killefer, and Lenny Mendonca. How can
American government meet its productivity challenge? McKinsey & Company, July 2006
(http://www.mckinsey.com/aboutus/mckinseynews/pressarchive/pdf/American_govt_meet_
prod_challenge.pdf).
,
,
, .
.

,
.
,
,
.

,
.

,
.

- .

,
-
.

.
,

.
.

(due diligence) , ,
.

90- ,
1998 .,
.

,
,

.

33
34

.
, ,
.
, ,
.

,
.

,
.
. McKinsey ,
, - ,
,
2,5 . ,
, ,
(, ,
)
, .
,

, . ,

.

2020 .
23 .
.
,
,
,
3 .
.

,
.
,
1 .
8090- .

. 19861996 .

200 . . ,
,
(
).

.
90-
Volkswagen:
20% . .
18%.
Volkswagen
11 . ,
.
.
.
50
;
.
,
. ,
,
.
. ,
,
.
.
,
,
.
,
.
.
.

,
.

.
,
, 20 .
.
35
36

MGI ,
14.

.
,
,
.

, .
,
,
.
.
.
,
,
. ,
(
, ) .
,
,

.

.
( )

.
.

.
14 .: Putting Chinas capital to work: The value of financial system reform. McKinsey Global Institute, May 2006 (http://www.mckinsey.com/mgi/reports/pdfs/china_capital/MGI_chinacapital_execsum.pdf). ,
,
,
14 . .

62 . . , ,
,
259 . .

.

.
,
,
.
( 6 12 )
.

.
, ,
.

. ,
,
,
.
37
38

. McKinsey ,

.
, , ,
,
.

.
,

.

. ,
, .

.
,
, ,

.

, ,
.

,

.
,
.

.
.
,
, .

, ,
. .
,
.
(,
. .) .
,
,
.
,
. ,
,
.
.

. -,

,
. -

.

.
39
40
* * *
.
,
.
,

.

. -,

, ,
,
.

. ,
,
.
,
.
,
,
.

, .

.

. 1997 .
64%.
2007 . 54% .

,
.
. ,
3,5 , ,
.

, .
.

.

-
.

:
1.
,

.
2. - ,
,
.
3.
,
.
4.
,
.
41
42

:
6% 8% .
2020 .
21 33 . ,
.
,
.

.

21% 33% .

. -,
, , ,
. -,
.

.

.
, ,

.
,

.
:
1.
,
.
2. ,
,

.
,

.
3.

.

. 7 , ,
, 10% .

.
: 35%
11% .
.
.

. ,
, .
,

.
.

:
1. .

,
,
.
2. .

. ,

.
3. .
,
,
,
.
4.
,
,
,
.
43
44

. 2000
2007 . 60%. ,
, , ,
.

.
, ,
.
400 .
, ,
, , .

: 23%
, .

, ,
:
,
.

:
1. .
, ,
.
,
.
2. -.

,
- .
3. .

, .

.
.
4. .

,
.

.
.

,
.

(80% )
.
15% .

. 2010 . 40%
, ,
40 .

. .

.
( )
,
. ,

.

.
:
1. .

; ,
;
.
2.
.
,
, .
3. .

;
,
;

;
.
45
46
: ,

,

; ;

;
;
;
();

;

2020 .,

:
,

,
(2003)
,
Open Health Institute
Demoscope
Lean
Russia:

Sustaining
. economic
growth
through
improved
productivity
47

15 60
,

,
UN World Population Prospects
Doing Business

Global Insight
Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness

, 60
Economist Intelligence Unit
, .
, 60
Petrobras
Enterprise Ireland
Forsight 2007, Ireland
OECD PISA

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, ,
, .

McKinsey, , ,
.
2009 .
50

. , ,
,
McKinsey & Company . ,
1999 .1,

.

.
1997 . 64%. 2007 .
54% .

,
.
. , 3,5
, .

, .
.

.

-
.

:
1.
,

.
2. - ,
,
.
3.
,
.
4.
,
.
1
: , 1999 .
51
52

.
: 3%
6% .
400 000 . ,
,
1 .

20
. 1991 .
. 1994 .
, 1998 .
: 10
5% (. 1).
. 1
C 1998 . 2005 .
1991 .
+5%
55
56
12%
47
49
+0%
45
49
51
50
59
62
53
43
38
39
39
38
36
1991 1992 1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
: Steel Statistical Year Book, 1996, 2007; ; Iron and Steel Statistics Bureau; McKinsey.
,
: , , 2007 .
40% .

1998 2007 . .
( ,
)
53
.

.
,

2007 .
( )
54% .
,
: 1999 .
33%
. ,
10 64%.
80%
,
(. 2). 1998 .
50%, 2007 .
80%.
. 2
1997 . ,

,
% 2007 .
54
2
19
33
1997 .1
2007 .
1 MGI 1999 .
2007 .
: McKinsey.
54

,
.

, : ,
, .
.

,
. (
), ,
.

,
(. 3).
, , ,
,
6570 .
. 3
1900 2006 .
700
650
1952
600
550
1970 2005 .
500
1970
450
400
350
300
2007
250
200
150
100
50
0
0
5 000
10 000
15 000
20 000
25 000
30 000
35 000
40 000
,
. . , 1990 .
: IISI; JFK; Global Insight; McKinsey.
, ,
,
. ,

.
,

.

2009 . . ,
,
-

.
.
,
.
, , ,
, 2540%, 2030%.
,
30% , .
, ,
: , .

10% .

,
.

,
.

, , , .

.

.
1990-
(,
),
1998 .
, .
55
56
3
,
77%

57
58

,
. ,

54% 2007 . ,
,
, (. 4).
. 4

,
% 2007 .

112
114
100
118
113
33
100
54

1 2006 .
124
111
100
88
: Steel Institute VDeH; McKinsey.

.

. ,

.

(. 5).
59
. 5

,
% 2007 .
,
.-. 1
31,1
3,5
100
77
66
22
7,0
8,0
,
1 .
2,5
3,0
2,5
1,1
: VDeH; McKinsey.
14%
40% -. ,
-

72%
2007 .
,
,
,
(. 6).
. 6

,
% 2007 .
100
18
28
54
1 .
: McKinsey.
60
1.

. 16% (),

, - (). ,

.
(. 7).
. 7

,
%
,
%
16
57
27
41
100
40
59
: (IISI); ;
McKinsey.
2.
-
, ,

-.

.
1,52 ,
2229%
1416%.
:
,

(
). ,

.

.
, -
.

( , ). ,
- ,

.

.
, -
.

, . ,
720 .
800 . . ,

: , 5%
12%
,
.

,
(. ).

42% ( 54%) .
2007 . 26%
,
2%. ,
,
: 43%
74% (. 8).

.

,
.
61
62
. 8
,
%
100% =

( , /
/
)

(, ,
)
63,0
99,0
19
20
10
14
12
32
24
8
26
20
: J.F. King; McKinsey.

. ,
,
,
, .
,

.

.
:
. ,

, , .
, ,
.

.
2007 .
(
) 140 . 2020 . (. 9).

.
63
. 9
( !"( # ( "'!"
( "!( ! ""' 140 000 %$
!!!
! 2020 .

31+*&1'+5(.<0145<,
9(..-9 0$ 1 5
%!" ("&$ !"" " ! !!,

5;4. 9(..
400
)+'$(/1(
41-3$:(0+(
2(3410$.$
130
150
.$01&;,
&;71' 0$ 2(04+=
$%150+-+,
06)'$=:+(4>
& 536'164531,45&(
2007
"&
",
/.0 5
2007
+471'> +* 631&0>
231+*&1'+5(.<0145+
#
250
110
140
2020
+471'> +* 631&0>
231+*&1'+5(.<0145+
#
~10,8
~3,5
3,5
63
63
73
: Steel Institute VDeH; 18(0-$ $0$.+5+-1&; McKinsey.
, ,
. ,
.
, 1020%
.

(,
).
64

,
.
.
,
-,
.

.

.
.

-

.
.
,
: 1)
, -
, ;
2) ,
(, ).
,
.

,
.

,
, .

. ,
,

.

1999 . ,

.
, ,
.

, .

;
.
,
.
,

. ,
(

).

.

,
.
0,31,5%
. , ,
3 0,1% .

.

, - .

.

. ,

. ULSAB (ultra-light steel auto body)
.
1990-
Porsche. ULSAB

.
65
66

, , .

,
. ,
,
,
.
,
,
,
.

.

,
,
,
.
67

.
1986 1996 . 12
200 . (. 10).

.

.
. 10
1986 1996 . % % " &

" 40%
!'
# ' !"#, %
" 12 %1

550 000
500 000
450 000
400 000
350 000
300 000
250 000
200 000
150 000
100 000
%

$'
"
%
!!"#
50 000
0
1
(*, !#*, !*, !%*, *, !*, " *, #*, )"$!, !',
!#$*, !%*
"#&: "##$# "# VDeH.

:
, ,
.

.
,

.
( 50- )
, ,
.
68

.
, 34
60 .
.
(,
) .
.
.

.

.

.
* * *

,
.
.
,

.
.
1.

,
,
, .

. ,
.

, .

,

.
,
.

.
:

( ),
.
, .
,
.

,
, .
, ,
.
.
;
.
:
, (
).
.
69
70
,

.

.
,
,
.
1999 .,
, .
,
, . ,

. ,
McKinsey
.
,

.
71
2.

, ,

Metal Courier
MGI 1999 .
; ,

;

; ,

;

McKinsey
(VDEh)
72
McKinsey Overhead Benchmarking

Initiative
J. F. King
73

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, ,
, .

McKinsey, , ,
, .
2009 .
76

. 7 , ,
, 10% .
1999 2007 . .
15 31%
1.
.

,
5 .
:
35% 11% .

.
.

,
.

. ,
, .

.
.

,
,
.

. ,

.
.

, ,
,
1
2007 .
1999 . 67% 2007 .
77
78

.

.

, ,
,
.

.
79
,

, .
10% ,
, 10% . ,
McKinsey 1999 .
,
.

19992007 . 73
421 . (. 1).
800 6700 .
.

.
,
(. 2).
. 1
"$ $ $ $ #
,*!/&.1 +$.)$3
$ $

"$ , 20022007 .,
%
*--$3
532
19,9
426
)!$3
15,9
$.%
14,9
)!
318
249
196
9,1
6,4
2,4
240
26,1%
14,4
"'$&*,$.)$3
+*)$3
"$ $ (20002008 ., ! )1,

(',! !*''.
28,91
,#$'$3
"&-$&
"+,*!**'2-."))1" .*,1
84
39
45
2000
105
49
120
56
148
89
235
68
79
106
135
64
01
02
03
04
05
1 *'2&* *, )$#*))3 .*, *'3, )*($)'2)1" ."(+1 ,*-..
145
114
57
-.*0)$&$: *--..; ")"--)- +$.' (22 !"&,3 2008 .).
191
292
173
06
07
08
80
. 2
" " '"+" ! ) $ ")
&'#'!)1
*&'#'!)1
(!*$)'1
'-%$$1
#$1
, #", !!(%!, ! #" ,

%
*) &)
( &'") )%'1 &% $!# -$#
)'$4 % )%#, .)% #$ (#1 $! -$1, *.) *)"2$%
%') (#1 $! -$1 $ )%'1, !%)%'1 4 .0 (% &%!*&3

"*) ))
()2 !') &%()%4$$%%

&%!*&)"4, 304
&'#*0() &' '*"4'$1,
&%!*&!,
'%()"4) %#%$%()2
&%!*&! !')
) !%
#$ ()2 %%$.$4,

&%!130, (!)2
(&-"2$1 -$1 !-
!! ""
!% )%'$% '*&&

()2 1%' &'"%$
&% $!#, ('$# 1(%!#
-$#
'") )%'1
(%()$$% )%'%% #'!
&% 1%$% -$
#) (#1 /'%! 1%'

)%'%, !%)%'1 4 &%!*&3
/ "
'%%) "*./ !- &% )%'#,

!%)%'1 4 .()% &%!*&3
()% '!"#'*) (&-"2$1

&'"%$4 (( &%#%023 +"'%,
), ).&.)
()%.$!: (("%$ McKinsey How The World Shops 2.

: 1997 .
5 2.

.
,
, ,
.
,
(. 3).

.
,
(. 4).
, .
81
. 3
! # !

2008
"!
!
"
!
!

1989
1997
1999
2001
2003
2007 #' $

$
2005
": ! ; %&.
. 4
#& %) !" !* %",+' !"

%!"
2007 .
$$
! !!"#.
20022007 ., %
6 000
50
( ,
. , 2007 .
*
900
27
X5
37
868
5 320
47
"
2 197
43
3 671
58
Metro Group
82
4 801
77
&
55
3 200
135
"#&: """ #; !; "# #!; !"#'; $!%( .
82

,

(. 5). ,
:
, , , 23 ,
.
. 5
", 2010 # !

! 50%
# "! ,
%
% %
%
#

"! ,
20072010 .
9
12
&%

%
&

! %
! %
%
%
" %
24
25
2001
2
2003
47
3
2005
2007
2008
2010
2009
(#) (#) (#)
$: MGI; # PriceWaterhouseCoopers 2008 .; McKinsey.

.
.
,
.

:
,
,
.
,
(. 6).

.
,
,
,
.
. 6
( 2008 . ,

'
% %%
A

((
# &%
"
&$ # (, # $%

#

&$ # (, # %
) ) $!

&$ # (, # % %
(private label) ( !$ $ "% #
&
,

(&%
#$(
$

!
%'(

&$ (, # ( %
% ), # '

&$ % & % )
#

&$ # (, #
)( #& !$ $ "% #
&$ # (, # %

%$%! %! " !
&$ % # &

$
#: HTWS 2008; HHTWS 2006.
83
84
11%

31%

85
86

.
,
(. 7).
. 7

,
'+&'*!+$2&' ,)'&4 1, %
+$$!+"&4
()'%1/$&&'*+2
332
' &!.&4 +')'$4

' &!.&1" &#'*#!"
! &*
!$!0&'
*+)'!+$2*+'
$#+)'3&)+!#
152
*)&% (' !**$'&&1%

'+)*$4%
1 &&1 (' )' &!.&'" +')'$, *+$$!+"&'" ()'%1/$&&'*+! 2007 ., )' &!.&'%, &#'*#'%, *#+'), ! 3$#+)'3&)+!#
2006 ., !$!0&'%, *+)'!+$2*+, 2002 .
2 ''#,(&4 ()'! '!+$2&'*+2 -#+')' ()'! '*+ *+$$!+"&'" ()'%1/$&&'*+! *'*+$4+ 54%; 3$#+)'3&)+!# 80%.
*+'.&!#!: Global Insight; EIU; ; '**++; &$! McKinsey.
. ,

, 1999 . ,

,
,

.

, .

-

1999 . ,

87
: 2007 .
31% (. 8).
. 8
# ! #" ,

" #
#
" ",
"&!"%&,!" '$"!. 2007, %
69%
2007
2003
2003
2003
2003
2007
1999
%&"*!: "%%&&; Euromonitor; #$! %&&%& !%&$%& &$' ; )"!,!+ !%&&'&
%&&%& -"!" *%( %%"! ($!).); !!+ " #!; MGI; ! McKinsey.

(. 9):
1.
;
2.
.
. 9

,
! !' "( 2007 ., %
! !
%!
&$
#!
%
!
!%: McKinsey.
! !
%!
!' !
!" $
&$ #!
88

.
35%
,
82 86% .
11% ,
, 60% 81% (. 10).
. 10
% (&* % ( * '# # *

)"" ' $' " '
+ #1#)((4! /)+'-4
)+!'!((4! /)+'-4
( * '#

( ' ,
*+)1!(-4
( ( ! $,

-4,. )&&. , *) C2 ( 1 "(8-))
)+!'!((4!
/)+'-4
81
92
60
29
11
),,#8
20071
)&53
2007
+(1#8 !+'(#8

2000
2000
2000
+ #1#)((4!
/)+'-4
1 1!(% McKinsey.
2 +#-!- *)%.*-!&5()$ ,*),)(),-#.
,-)2(#%#: MGI; ),,--; Euromonitor; 7+) -+. ))$ ,--#,-#%# (); 1#)(&5(4$ #(,-#-.- ,--#,-#%#
# 6%)()'#2!,%#0 #,,&! )(#$ (+(1#8); Statistisches Bundesamt; EHI; IFH; BEA; BLS; ING Rynek Spozywczy
2007; GFK; !(-+&5()! ,--#,-#2!,%)! .*+&!(#! ()&53); ((4! %)'*(#$; (&#" McKinsey.
,
, ,
, . .
36 . 12 . . .

,
.

,
,
.
,
.
.

23 , :
0,130,17 . 1 . 0,21 ,
0,34 0,55 . (. 11).
89
. 11
! #! #! "

. ' ,)+ ' ((40 -)+)40 *&)3 $ ( 1 !#- &5

0,40
3
)),##+,%
),%
%- +#(- (%-.+

- +.+
)()(
.* 2- +#!
+&#(
+#
+(%/.+-
+2
,-)1(#%#: Jones Lang LaSalle; #"( , (&#-#%; (&#" McKinsey.

.
,
,
- .
,

.
,
.
,
- .
.
.
, : 6 31
.
,
.
.
.

.
,
,
,
. ,
.
,
(. 12).
90
. 12
"" $!* " !&)% )', &

!* " "#,%, #!$+(% !*"#) #!,

! A
!
!
!
: " ; McKinsey.

,
.
.
1 .
,
. ,
, ,
(. 13).
. 13
!""" !% $!* #!$#!# )', &

#&&
&"# !#
" 1 ',&. . !

180
150
120
90
60
30
10
11
12
13
1 *" McKinsey " #&"# "",) $# 8 %($",! %#&&&! &'.!, -+. $%!%',.
&'#+": Deutsche Bank; "", #!$"; Euromonitor; " McKinsey.
14
15
16
17
!++ (* ,

',&. . !
91

1 .
.

36 . . ,
46 . (. 14).
. 14
$'' 3 & $!/, &$(# $ # &(#. "(&,

+" , #$ %&.!/ # 1 #0($$ # '$ # 22%
.&)+ ' ($&$$ %!$-,
'-&. # . /. !
$&$( # 1 &$(# ,
'-&. # . " 1 %#'"
$!+'($ &$(# $ &'+(

# !+#) ($&$.* %!$-,
" '-&. . !
&$$(!/#$'(/1,
'-&. # . " 1 %#'"
x3
-22%
!$0 %&.!/,
% -%(,
1 $#$%# " C 1 '#%# $%### .&'""-! '#%! (#/))+"' 1,37).
&'#,": &!%"- "; 0%# '%(## &''&' ; +#" ."- "&''(' &''&' /#"#!,&*
&& #" (%"+1); ""- #!$"; " McKinsey.

:

.
, .

.
, (. 15).

,

, .

. 40100%

.

.
.
,
, -
. ,
.
92
. 15

% !
$ !
% !

1

1
& # %&# .
'& ! ( "! "!.
%: McKinsey.
.
-
.
.

, .
()
. -

- .
-
.
,

, ,
,
.

, , .
,
:

, -
.
, ,

.

.

:

.
, ,
,
.
,

. ,
, ,
.
.
,
. ,

,
,
.

.

.

, .

93
94
,
.
. ,

,
,
.
,
, .

. ,
.
, ,
.
.

,
.
* * *
1999 .
.

.

. , ,
.

.
1.

, .
,
.
, (,
).
,
,
(
).

1 .
,
, .
:
1,37
1,01 .

,
-.

.
-, .
, , ,
.

.
,

(
).

,
.

.
95
96
,

.

.
.
,

.
97
2.
PricewaterhouseCoopers
Colliers International
, ,
, ,
,
,
Global Insight
Euromonitor
,

,

, ,
,
98
Doing business,

,
Deutsche Bank
Jones Lang LaSalle
Transport intelligence
IMD
Economist
Management ventures Retail

Insights US stores size figures
, ,
, ,
,
,

McKinsey
99

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, ,
, .

McKinsey, , ,
.
2009 .
102

. 2000
2007 . 60%. ,
, , ,
.

.
, ,
.
400 .
, ,
, , .

: 23%
, .

, ,
:
,
.

.
-
.
,
- .
,
.

:
.
, ,
.
,
.
-.
,
,
- .
103
104
.

, .

.
.
.

,
.
.
105

.
2000 2007 . 60% (. 1)1.

25% 2001 . 33% 2007 .
2003 . 20%.
. 1

, ,
%, 20002007 .
60,1
28,0
17,8
17,8
13,8
9,9
9,7
7,9
7,1
: McKinsey Global Banking Pools.

,
:
1,2% ,
.

. ,
2007 . 2,1% , 15
47% (. 2).
,
- .
106
. 2

1,
%
16,6
47,0
6,5
2,1
63,0
0,6
1,2
16,0
1 2007 . 15 2006 .
: ; Economist Intelligence Unit; McKinsey.

56%

2.
52% 32% 3.

1 4% ,
.
,
(. 3).

. 2002 .
27 5,4%
, 2007 . 61,
10%.
. ,
2005 .
80% , , , , ,
.
69 61%.
2007 . 38 12%
.
2

, .
53,2% , ,
, 56%.
: 1)
, 46%; 2)
: , , , , ,
, , - -; 3)
.
107
.
- ,

.
.

,
.
. 3
10
,
%, 2007 .
35,4
12,6
8 681
48,0
49,7
26,4
: ; McKinsey.
91,0
20
350
61,1
50,7
84
83,0
58,0
33,0
11,4
1 147
65,3
58,0
25,0
19,3
46,0
2006 .
77,1
63
108

. 400 .
0,6% . , ,
, , .

:
34%
66% , 30 70% .

11%
, 23%,
. ,
, 12 , ,
.

(4% )
(13% ) (. 4).
. 4

,

, ., 2006 .
81
65
60
34
21
, . , 2006 .
4,4
5,1
4,4
3,4
0,9
0,3
, . , 2006 .
10,8
10,5
8,0
5,5
0,5
0,2
: ; ; Mckinsey.

.

(. 5).
109
. 5

,
%
100
52
25
23
12
11
: McKinsey.

52
.

(. 6). ,
,
, .
. 6

25 ,
,

X2,2
X5,0
6,08,0
6,5
4,0
1,8
1,7
1,6
1
3,0
2,0
5,0
3,0
2,0
1,0

X
Y
1 .
: , ; McKinsey.
X3,8
110
.
.
, , ,

.

. , ,
9 2002 . 199-,

.
, ,
16 2004 . 1376-,
74 (. 7).

15 .

,
30 .

,

.
. 7

(
115-

207-)
,
,

(
199-)

(74
)
(
1376-)

15
: McKinsey.
.
.
199-:

. ,
111
,
. ,
.
- ,

.

,
(. 8).
25
.

, 70%,
90%. ,
, 12 .
. 8
, .
1 1
33
0
72
90
0,1
0,6
67
21
7
10
1,2
1 2007 .
2 , , .
3 .
: McKinsey.

, .

. , ,
,
,
.
.

, .
112
,
- .
, -,
-,
.
,
( ),
,
.

2012
250
, ,
.

20% 2012 .

8-
. ,
, 250 .
(. 9).
,
. ,
,
.
. 9
2012
250

2012 .1,
%,
2006 .
,

2006 .
%, 2006 .
159
100
2012 .1,
232
372

2006 .,
.
246
0%
8%
1 8%,
20%.
2 .
: ; Viewswire; McKinsey.
2008

, .

.
:
,
.

.

, .

13 . 100150 .
- .
7 . 3065 . .

,
.
, .
,

.

.
, ,
,
.
113
114
1000
46%

10
,

115
116

,
, ,
. ,
- .

.

:

.
, ,
.
.

,

(,
,
).
.
,
,
.

:

.

, .

,
, .
.
- .
,
,
.
117
,
.
.
,
, .

,
(, , -),
,
,
,
(
).

.
, -
.
-,

, ,
.
,
.
,
,
.

.
* * *

. , ,
,
,
, .
,

.

, , ,
.
118
1.

,

.
: 1) ; 2)
; 3) .
, .

,
, .
, ,
.

,
,
.
2006 .; 2006 .
.

,
.
, : 1) ; 2)
; 3)
, .
;
; ,
, , , ,
.
, ,
.

2006 .;

.

, ,
, , ,
.
,
, .
,
, .

,
,
.
, 2006 .
.
,
,
.

, ,

.
,
; ,

. ( ,
) ,
( ),
.

-,
.

. ,
, ,
,
,
.
; , McKinsey
, ,
. ,
,

( ) ,
McKinsey ,
, .

, . . ,
.

,
119
120
(
),
.
,
(
,
).
.

.

,
. -

, . ,

,

.
121
2. ,

,
,
,

( ,
. .),

,
,

,
, ,
, ,
,
,
,
,

Global Insight
McKinsey Global Profit Pools
McKinsey
-,

,

McKinsey ,

- . .

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, ,
, .

McKinsey, , ,
- .
2009 .
124
:
6% 8% .

.

2020 . 21 33 . ,
.
,
. - ,
, ,
.

.
21%
33% .
.
-, , ,
,
. -,
. , ,
,
. -,

,
, .

.

.
, ,

.
,

. ,
,
.
125
126
:

,
.
,
,

.
,

.

.
127
128

6%
(
).
, 8%
.
,
, , ,
1215% (. 1). ,
- 2000 2007 .
4650% .
. 1
"% " % %$ % #
!'(, /
/%!$%,
" !

#
# !!! %" #!$% !%#$, %, 19982007 .
"% " %%% !

!/ !* /%!$%, %, 2006 .
1215
%#!%,$%!
! ! (!
'(, / /%!$%,
$%#!%,$%
*/ (.)/
!'(, &.)
/%!$%,
$%!) : Global Insight; !$$%%; -$"#% + !( ; McKinsey.
90- .
1990 2000 . 7%
(. 2). 1998 .
, 2000 2007 .
10%.
,
40% .
,
, .
(, ,
, . .), ,

.
129
. 2

!

90-
! .
591
631
62
!&-&$'$
!!$%, "%&*
"%"%, "%&*
"%
%&*!, "%%,

,
20002007 ., %
-7%
61
11%
51
44
41
10
30
13
17
5
1980
1985
1990
1995
2000
2005
2006
2007
1 +(, !!) #" "%, "%"%" "%&, !&-&$'$' !!$%" "%&.

%&"(!: "%%&&; ! McKinsey.
130

2020 .
21 33 . .
. ,
,
2009 2020 .

(63 . ), 1985 . , ,
, 710 1 .
( ),
.
, 2007 .
61 . (. 3). ,

. , 10 15%

.

20052007 .
. 3
( !( %( % !*

!
# "&" +, *#. ,
'( !!) !, $(

+ !+ % 2020 ., ,+- *#. , # $.%

86
#&5(;
.0#&$(;
&0,!-(;
41
38
37
(-+;-%(;
&+(*."0(2!-(;
&-$0(;
33
0&5(;
33
32

+ (2020)
2!+(;
+.#&-(;
.+97!
03'(;
+"!-(;
61
63
!*2(6&1*()
30.#&-9
(2007 $.)
12.0(6&1*()
,!*1(,3,
(1985 $.)
27
26
25
.0#!2(;
305(;
x2
30
29
&4(;
+ (2007)
&+!0319
129
49
45
25
21
21
19
17
1 0!#-(2&+9-8& %!--8& /. 120!-!, '! 19982004 $$.
12.6-(*(: UNECE; (-(12&012#. :*.-.,(*(; &-&11!-1 !/(2!+; !-!+(' McKinsey.
&."4.%(,8)
30.#&-9
131
.
,
, ,
.
.
, ,
, (. 4). -
2007 . 9%
22%
.
. 4
! " ! !
#
,
(%%. (, 2007 .
! "
1,
(%%. ! $. &, 2008 .

45 851
%"$(*",'"6
35 041
*&'"6
33 510
/"6
."6
'*"6
(++"6
&(',
36 418
24 480
19 240
14 676
2400
2668

"$(,
&'((4, '2# (&
'0+,*,
&'((4, '2# (&
2167
&-*,
&'((4, '2# (&
2313
,($(%3&,
&'(($*,"*'2# (&
*,
&++(2# +&',
2518
-)1,,
&'((4, '2# (&
2259
32403240
38004000
(++"6,
&'((4, '2# (&
2550 (! (++"")

1 '2 ' $*,"*2 4$('(&-$%++ (&++(2# *2'($), +$(**$,"*(''2 ' ()*",, )($-),%3'(# +)(+('(+,").
+,(0'"$": EIU; (++,,; )-%"$/"" ; "',*35 + 4$+)*,&"; '%"! McKinsey.
-
.
,
.

,
. ,

.
132
1997 .
40%,
3,3% .

21% 33% .

,
18 . 2007 ., 1 84 . , 2
53 51 . (. 5).
. 5

,

,
. ! "!"" !.&"" "

,
% "& '$"!. 2002 .
211
84
96
53
51
18

2002
92
x5
x5
32
151
131
! (. "%%. "%%.

2004
2004
2007
1997

2002
! (. "%%. "%%.

2004
2004
2007
1997
1 (!
%&")!: US Census; ("!+!. %&&%& !* (; "%%&&; !&$+- % ,%#$& ;

#'( ; MGI; ! McKinsey.

,
.
21 45%

129 . ,
, 1985 . (. 6).
2002 .,
.
2004 . ,
.
133
. 6
! " "

! "
"",
% "% &#"!,
!,
!. . "
129
x2
21
"$$,, 2007 .
45
61
"$$,, '*
%($
&#"!*
(2007 .)
x2
#& )
&#"!* ($#!
20092020 .)
$%"(!: "$$%%; !$%#$%" +"!" ($"" #%,; ! McKinsey.
.

,
, .

.
134

,
.

(. 7).
. 7
$ ! #%% % $

"
! ! % $ !,
% %) *'%$4 2002 .
%, 2007 .
1 2++!)$4 %'$-4
)'* $,)!
!"+-'%$$0, !'%
2 %())%.$% (&%"1%$
(%'#$$0, 0(%!%2++!)$0,
#)'"% !%$()'*!-
3 !4 %"4 #"%2)$0, %#%
$%())%.$0 #(/) &'%!)%
, 2002 .
21
49
24
100
()%.$!: US Census; %(()); (#'$0 $!; $)'13 ( 2!(&')#; &*"!- ; $" McKinsey.

,
49
.
:
, ,
,

.
,
,
,
,
.
,

. ,
,

- .

,
.
,
( ). ,
,
.

, ,
.

24
. ,

.

,
(,
).

,
(,
).
( )
17% ,
7080%.

6
. ,

30%. ,
,
, 32%
, 89%.
,
, .
,
.
.
. ,

2030% , .
135
136
700

21%

23
137
138

, ,
, ,
.

, ,

. , , ,

.

. ,
,
, ,
1998 2007 . 3%.
,

. , ,
,

(. 8).
, , ,

. ,

, ,
.

, ,

.
.
139
. 8

!
')'05 ()#+!#
)%5, &'-'!%' $5 ('$,/&!5 ) )0&!" & *+)'!+$2*+'1,
#'$!/*+' &"
6
'**!5
#)!&
) !$!5
!+"
-*+&
&!5
.!5
&

1 !**$'&!! *%!)&'' &# ()!& ()!%) ()'.,) *'$*'&!" $5 *+)'!+$2*+ ,-3+&''
*#$. '$,/&&1 '.&#! *''++*+,4+ ) ,$2++% !&+)24 * 3#*()+%! (' *+)'!+$2*+, %&''#)+!)&1'%' '**!!
*+'/&!#!: Dealing with construction permits 2008 (*%!)&1" &#); !&+)24 * 3#*()+%!; &$! McKinsey.

,
.
,

, .
-
, , .

, ,
,
,
. ,

1800 4000 .
1 3.

1800 . 1 .
,
(
) 2008 .
5000 . 1 . ,

.
, ,
.

,
.
3
101 27.12.2007 .
140

, ,
.
,
,
4 .
- (due
diligence)
.

.
:
,
,
.

,
.
, , ,
,
.
,

,
.

. ,
.

.

,
.

.
,
.
,
, .
4
,
( . .).

,
.
, , ,

, 1950- .
,
,
.
, 1990-

.
,
.
, .

,
. -

,
. -
,
,

.

,

,
.
.
141
142

.
, ,
,
, .

2006 .
.
,
.

,
,
.

.
75% ,

25% , (. . 9).
. 9
) ) #' ! ' &
!( $' !
&*#/, $%(&!#'%""/ )% 0"# + # $%#%!!# -,
! ". %(., 20062010 .
"& ! (
% "&

350 271
"/
%&*#/
#%
&$%#&2
"/
%&*#/
399
#%
$% #"21
78 839
271 033
930 691
23%
#%
$% #"21
77%
#%
&$%#&2
399
367 227
563 065
1 #%"+2 )#%!%#" "## ")%&'%('(%/.

2 ""&%#" "'&' $# $#',"#!( -"#!( %'#"1, &#+ 0"/* #.'# -"##
&'%#' 0&' ( 2 '%"# '..), 02 2 !# #/* &!.
&'#,": % 0"2 + 2 $%#%!! -; " McKinsey.
40%
60%
,
, ,
,
, .
,
:
,

.

.
. , ,
-2014
, .
:

,

,
, ,
.
.

,

,
.

.
.
.
,
,

.
,

, ,
.
.
;
,
.
143
144

.

.

, ,
, .
,
.
,
, .
, ,
( ),
.

. .
,
. ,
,
,
.
,
, ,
.
,
.

(, . .).

.
-

,
. , ,

. ,
.
,
.
,
, ,
.

.
,

,
.

,
,
, .

, .
, ,
? ?
?
,
,

?

,
.
.

,
,
.

.

,

, .
,
.
.

.
. ,
,
,
, .

.
145
146

.
,
- ,
,
, -
, .

,

. ,

.
,

,

, . ,

, .

,
,
.

,
,
,
,
.
,
.

.

.
,
,
.
.
147
,
,
.

,
(,
- ).
,
,
.

,
.

,
.
,
, . .

.
,
,
,

,
.

(,
,
. .)
.
* * *
,
,
.
,
,
, .

.
148
1.

. ,
.

.

,
(2002 . , 2004 .
2007 . ).

,
,
.

.

,
,
.

,
(
,
, )
.
McKinsey ,

.

,
.
149
2.
,

,
,
,
,

-
2020 .

Russian
homebuilders,

, Quans
ING Wholesale Banking
Russian utilities. Going strategic
150
US Census,

Metal Bulletin
Global Insight

(Dealing with
construction permits),
, 2008 .
SBB
, ,
McKinsey

151

. ,
McKinsey (MGI)
McKinsey & Company,
.
,
(
) .
,
.

MGI,
.
:
, ,
, .

McKinsey, , ,
, , .
2009 .
154
,

.

(, ),
1.
.
.

,
.

. :
, ,
.

,
,
.

,
.

.
2020 .
155
156

.
(, , ,
) ,

.

:
1) 2) .
1998 2008 . 2,3%
2008 . 1035 ..
(. 1).

221 . 46% , 23% ,
21% 10% .
. 1
% % $!

#
# ",
$ $ ,
*-,, 2007 .

19982007 ., %
4239
*!
1,4
3278
'&% 0
10,9
1160
&
1,3
2,1
1015
% 0
775
($% 0
637
%
602
(%+ 0
567
%0
&(0
440
( # 0
434
# "&( *% 0
398
)*&,% ": ** )* ,)" ! &&( $ (&&! .%(* " "&$'%
4,7
1,4
0,7
1,0
6,2
3,0
0,9
BP, /%- 2008 .
157

2006 . 60% (572 -)
,
,
,
.

, , ,
, ,
(. 2).
. 2
&( !( %( " $"

( &
( & &'

!$" ",
$# 1,
6-;
642,6)/?56&2
,=)&$B 3420></)11256?
$<,125642)1,)
)/?5.2) 92+B-56&2 , 4>%1$B

3420></)11256?
")//A/2+12-%70$*1$B 3420></)11256?
2%>;$ , 2%4$%26.$ 32/)+1>9 ,5.23$)0>9

4$153246,42&.$ 1)86,,
'$+$, 3)4)($;$ &2(> , 3$4$
573
10
16
17
18
21
42
42,+&2(56&2
$/A0,1,B
40
)86)(2%>;$
31
51
59
4$153246
!,0,;)5.$B , 1)86)9,0,;)5.$B
3420></)11256?
69
)86)(2%>;$
68
42,+&2(56&2 ;)41>9 , :&)61>9 0)6$//2&
160
47',) 264$5/,
41
42,+&2(56&2
:)0)16$
17
42,+&2(56&2
$+261>9 7(2%4)1,-
12
2%>;$ 7'/B
42,+&2(56&2
56$/,
)/)+12(242*1>64$153246
1 $11>) +$ 2006 '.

562;1,.,: # 255,,; #; ")164,1&)56; ($11>) .203$1,-; ,16)4&?A 5 @.53)46$0,; $1$/,+ McKinsey.

2006 .
. 20% ,
.
, -
(. 3).
158
. 3
#"# % $$%

!
$$% & #"# ,
2007 ., $"". /'-)
&'$)# ! : (#%$#$ *#%' )&!$ #'&'$ (), $&&
; #" McKinsey.

,

.
.
,
,
.
,
,
. ,
2020 .
( ),
. , ,
. ,

.

80% .

, , (. 4).
77%
96% .

.

, ,
, .
12% ,
,
, .

,
. ,
,
,
159
160
.
, -
(. 5).
. 4
#* "(!"( $" !"

)" ) " !! !!"*" 80%
" # *
% 2006 .
"(!"( "
48
#* "(!"(
$" !"
&
124
58
100
95
85
85
100
99
92
80
109
100
93
76
77
-23%
"(!"( " #

6
#* "(!"(
$" !"
)" ) "
119

, %
%%
100
73
89
42
-75%
25
* )$$"!"(
46
%1.5
#* "(!"(
$" !"
' !
42
112
100
104
151
100
108
112
94
+12%
"(!"( "
87
120
100
126
112
96
-4%
102
72
"(!"( " #

13
100
71
28
53
-90%
10
: McKinsey.
. 5
% # ! "

*%-!! % +#

*%-!! %

(&.! *,%&#&!!
$$ ,

% &* &/& &0$ '(&! &)*
0
5
16
16
27
10
47
58
43
19
3
4
17
3
)*&.%!"!: +%(&%& 1%(*!.)"& %*)*& (); &))!!; %#! McKinsey.

25% , 10%
(. 6). , ,

, .
161

(,
), ,
, ,
.
. 6
## $$

"# , "
#-% " #!$
## !
## "

x4
x10
"# %: ; ""; McKinsey.

,
.
12% , 7%.
,
.
8% , 6% , .

,
, .
4060% ,
, (. 7).
,
, .

,
.
, : 4% ,
1%.
162
. 7
" # ,

!
" # ,

+-/+#. +- /"2,4')#!&-/* 3&11)3/1))
100
.$,); ) :,92
(National Grid)
90
!.!%!
(Hydro Quebec)
80
70
)3!*
(!.5!* ) 2/2&%.)&
#/23/7.8& 01/#).6)))
3!,);
(Terna)
)%&1,!.%8
(TenneT)
(# 21&%.&-)
60
50
/2+/#2+)* 1&$)/.
40
20!.); (Red Electrica)
~50% 30
1&6); (PPC)
20
#&6); (# 21&%.&-)
/22); ( )
10
0
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
" $
7&,./+#. +-
23/7.)+): 25&-8 1/22)*2+)5 ,).)* 0&1&%!7 :.&1$&3)+); /22)); Energy Velocity; !.!,)( McKinsey.

15 , ,
. 2010 .
40% , ,
40 (. 8), 2020 . 60%.
. 8
40% # ! #

&*( '( ()'(#%
% &* '(& %%&!
/%(
$ ", " ! 2010 ! 40 ,
%
39
28
22
12
3
10,8
6,7
6,2
4,6
)*&.% " : #+ /%(* .)"&! %,&($- ; &0 '& "&&( %- '(. /#"*(&/%(
** )* .)" ! &% " *1 '& /%(* "; &)) ; %# McKinsey.
6,3
;
-

.
163

, ,
(. 9).

14%.
. 9
( ( ! ( (+ "$ (# '
367%7392:. 853'*2;
5*,*5'3', 45-2=7:.
' 1*+)82%53)23. 45%/7-/*
-/3'%= ,%(58,/%, 7
( * * %# ' ,

%
30
3673/
5,5
*'*53- "*275
%4%)
15,3
41,2
-&-5; 5*)2== !5%0

30(%
32,6
18,7
)(
* % (
39,9
$(
%2/7*7*5&85(
14,3
8,0
<1*2; 36/'%
11,0
16,1
!&
)( (
67392-/-: #; # 366--; 6-67*12:* 34*5%735:; %2%0-, McKinsey.

2020 .
1710 -, 16
.
2015 . 26 ,
1,2 .
, 2020 . 1250
1500 -. 2012 2020 .
811 (
).

,

.
.
, ,
186 450 . ,
164
2015 . 39 , 26
.

. , ,
13 ,
2015 ., .

.

,
.
,
, ,
5070 . .
,
, , 40 60%
14 8%, 17 6% (. 10).
. 10
&! !+ !" #"# '!" !!!"#"

!* " !" !"%+$
&(#+.!'4$ ) ')2(),-!$, "(#0 )3!'! #(!,-#0#$
#( !"% 2020 .1,

'&+
)&&.
" #"# '!" !!

) !$
&! !+
!" #"# '!"
~5070

"
)&5
!
!
)&5
"

32
26
74
54
186
186
50
110
15
11
1 ,/) 7 #" )0!(%# ,-)#'),-# ()4/ ,-+)#-!&5,- *+)!%-) 2008 ) . +),,#$,%#'# 6(!+!-#1!,%#'# %)'*(#7'#.
,-)1(#%#: ),,##; Energy Technology Status and Outlook; (&#" McKinsey.

.
,
. ,
.
,
.
2.
2
, .
165
, ,
, .
,
(

).
:
.

,
. ,
,
. ,

.

.

.

,

30% , , 40% , .
:
, ,

(. 11).
. 11
% % $ # $%

% 40%
% %
% &!,
! ' % %

&! " ,
#,)). + (0
,//&<
#,)). + (0
25001
25001
~280
!.,-
1050
~300
1800
~25%
~100
~370

&0'
,//&<
(-,0$+4&))
1450
1500
720
1450
,//&<
2007
0+#.0&- ,!86$+&$ -.,7$+&$ ,.9

,//&<
%4&<
:22$(0&!- )&4$+%&- / (,..1-4&$' (-,0$+4&))
+,/0&
.,!+&<
(,0(0*&)
%(1-,(
1 .$#+<< ,4$+( /0,&*,/0& +,!83 -.,$(0,! ! 2008 ". +$(,0,.8*& .,//&'/(&*& :+$."$0&5$/(&*& (,*-+&<*&.
/0,5+&(&: ,//&&; -1 )&(4&& ! ; &+0$.!9; / :(/-$.0*&; &+2,.*4&< ()&$+0,! McKinsey.
166

.
. ,

,
. .
,
, .
,
,
. ,
,
.

.
, ,
.

.

. ,

. ,
.
167
168

1 -
,

6
,

2540%
,
169
170

:
1. ;
2.
;
3. ;
4.
.
1.

,
.
,

. ,
:

, ,
,
;
,

;
,
;

, ,
( ),
,
3 (
,
).
2.

.
,
, ,
, .
:

;

,
;

, .
,
,
.
, . ,
.
,
,
.
3.

,

.
, ,
.

.

.
4.

,
.

,

57%.
171
172

:
1. ;
2. ,
;
3.
;
4.
;
5. .
1.

.

, , , .
,

,
, ,
.

,
.

.
2. ,

,

.

, .

,
.

,
,
.
,
.
3.

,
, .
, ,
. 12.
. 12
$*"#$# '+ !. "# . +).

!' -%%#"# "#!
%!
1
2
3
4
"#.
"#!#+
%$'
#!'. " #,+& %$' ($!),
, #, # ! ". .), #!"

)"')% !" ")%
"#!# !#, " !'

#+
" (. "#1 !$. ,(

! $#&*)% ")%
""# !., !.+& !$,##

"# #'
!#+, ! -!) '" -) "-

+$$"!" !" #
#& -%%# #!$

##'.
) !!") " -

(#) " * !", +" ) "')
""&- " # ")%
!") # - $ & !" ")%
-% (# #%" , $!, #)
1 " ! !""!" #-, # "'!",
! " " " ". .
!"': McKinsey.

,
.
.

,
,
.
173
174
4.

.

.
,

,
. ,
,

.
5.

,

.
,
.

,
, ,
,
.
,
.

(, , , ,
). ,
.
,

.

,

.
175
* * *

.

.

, .

.

,
, .

.

,
.

.
176
1.

, ,
,

: 1) ; 2)
.

- (-).

,
.

, . ,

,
.
,
, .

.
-

.
.
,

.

(, , . .).
,
, ,
.

, .

.

:
= a x b x c,

,
, , ,
,
a, b (, )
(a+b+c = 1).

.
McKinsey ,

. ,
,
,
.
, .
177
178
2. ,

;

; , ,
;

,
,
,

2020

,
,

,

179

, ,
,

,
,
,
( ),

Energy Information Administration
ABS Energy
Platts

,
,

BP annual statistical review
American Transmission Company

2009 .
Copyright McKinsey & Company
www.mckinsey.com/mgi

ЭФФЕКТИВНАЯ РОССИЯ Производительность как фундамент роста

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

ЭФФЕКТИВНАЯ РОССИЯ Производительность как фундамент роста

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey & Company

Copyright McKinsey & Company 2009

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

1999 . McKinsey &

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

: Unlocking Economic Growth in Russia.

1998  ' &  %% 

1 ')) &%!*&)"/$% (&%(%$%().

    !    

' &!0&3 &#'*#!

1 ''#,(&6 ()'! '!+$4&'*+4 -#+')' ()'! '*+  5$#+)'5&)+!# 80%,  *+$$!+"&'"

McKinsey Global Institute

   1999   

 :  ; IET; 

McKinsey Global Institute

24 2007 . 198- 2008

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

 & & %$, #  !   

& & #

1 '$22 %,$! &'%!)$% ()%#%() ()'%)"0() *%"0$/+ 1"!)'%()$,  2008 .

11 Dealing with construction permits 2008.

        

$"& &$!)  "%% ! & "$" ".+ $ !,

!0& ! %" %*&

& %" %*&

"*%&" ' !-(

1  * "%!*' " ###'  "#'  .

McKinsey Global Institute

!   " $ #!    

"      

1 ''1 )(  ! 2007 .

McKinsey Global Institute

 # !&"  )    " 

$ !&"   ,

./*6" !+( +6" 0) %

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

UN World Population Prospects

Institute for Strategy and Competitiveness

Economist Intelligence Unit

Forsight 2007, Ireland

Copyright McKinsey & Company 2009

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

McKinsey Global Institute

: Steel Institute VDeH; McKinsey.

McKinsey Global Institute

1998 ' & %%

1 ')) &%!*&)"/$% (&%(%$%().

!

' &!0&3 &#'*#!

1 ''#,(&6 ()'! '!+$4&'+4 -#+')' ()'! '+ 5$#+)'5&)+!# 80%, *+$$!+"&'"

1999

: ; IET;

& & %$, # !

& & #

1 '$22 %,$! &'%!)$% ()%#%() ()'%)"0() *%"0$/+ 1"!)'%()$, 2008 .

$"& &$!) "%% ! & "$" ".+ $ !,

!0& ! %" %*&

& %" %*&

"*%&" ' !-(

1 "%!' " ###' "#' .

! " $ #!

"

1 ''1 )( ! 2007 .

# !&" ) "

$ !&" ,

./*6" !+( +6" 0) %

( !"( # ( "'!"

( "!( ! ""' 140 000 %$

! 2020 .

%!" ("&$ !"" " ! !!,

1986 1996 . % % " &

" 12 %1

%

"$ $ $ $ #

$ $

"$ $ (20002008 ., ! )1,

1 '2& , )$#))3 ., '3, )($)'2)1" ."(+1 ,-..

-.0)$&$: --..; ")"--)- +$.' (22 !"&,3 2008 .).

" " '"+" ! ) $ ")

, #", !!(%!, ! #" ,

( &'") )%'1 &% $!# -$#

)'$4 % )%#, .)% #$ (#1 $! -$1, .) )"2$%

%') (#1 $! -$1 $ )%'1, !%)%'1 4 .0 (% &%!*&3

()2 !') &%()%4$$%%

#$ ()2 %%$.$4,

!% )%'$% '*&&

#) (#1 /'%! 1%'

'%%) "*./ !- &% )%'#,

()% '!"#'*) (&-"2$1

()%.$!: (("%$ McKinsey How The World Shops 2.

! # !

2007 #' $

": ! ; %&.

#& %) !" !* %",+' !"

", 2010 # !

$: MGI; # PriceWaterhouseCoopers 2008 .; McKinsey.

( 2008 . ,

&$ # (, # $%

(private label) ( !$ $ "% #

)( #& !$ $ "% #

&$ # (, # %

&$ % # &

#: HTWS 2008; HHTWS 2006.

' &!.&4 +')'$4

*)&% (' !**$'&&1%

*+'.&!#!: Global Insight; EIU; ; '**++; &$! McKinsey.

# ! #" ,

% (&* % ( * '# # *

( * '#

( ( ! $,

+(1#8 !+'(#8

! #! #! "

%- +#(- (%-.+

,-)1(#%#: Jones Lang LaSalle; #"( , (&#-#%; (&#" McKinsey.

"" $!* " !&)% )', &