Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 17

(..

)



()1
. , . (),
.
, , , ,
. .
; . , ,
:
- ,
.
: , , , , , , , ,
, , , ().
Nun Kassia (Tatiana A. Senina). The Doctrine on the Energy of God
and the Problem of Status of the Divine Revelation in the Works of
Hieromonk Anthony (Bulatovich).
Summary. The author studies the means used by Hieroschemamonk Anthony
(Bulatovich) to demonstrate that the energy of God differs from His essence but is
inseparable from it and is God itself and could be communicated to the creatures.
It was a hard task for him given that he knew almost nothing from the works
of St Gregory Palamas or other dogmatic works of the Fathers of the Church,
and so he was limited to the texts of the Holy Scripture and the hymnography.
Fr Anthonys doctrine that the energy of God is triple and, in the same time, unique
is also treated. It is demonstrated that it is also quite traditional for the Orthodox
theology. The paper also deals with Fr Anthonys doctrine of divine revelation and
words of God in the Bible as uncreated energies of God. It is demonstrated that
this doctrine is in conformity with the views of the Fathers of Eastern Church as
well as with the Old Testament theology of Divine Name.
1

, :
. (), .
. ., 1913.
. . () . , 1914.
. , ,
. , 1917.

. . .

61

Keywords: Christianity, Orthodoxy, Russian Theology, Byzantine Theology,


Bible, Onomatodoxy, Triadology, Divine Energy, Name of God, Palamism, Judaism,
hieroschemamonk Anthony Bulatovich.

()
,
191020- . .2 , ,
XIV .3 , , - , (, . 203).
, . , ,
, ,
, , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, (, c. 5).
(. C. 17),
,
, , .
. , , ,
, .
1. .
4 , , :
2

.: . ?
19101920- . ., 2002 ( : .
- , . . II /
. ., . . . . ., 2005. . 9961043 =
. 191020- .
., 2006. . 339); (),. .
. ., 2002. . I. . 289637;
., . .
1910- . ., 2004. ( . ) . 21137.
3
., : ., .
. / . .. .
.. .. . ., 1997. (Subsidia byzantinorossica, 2).
4
.: , . 327343; .. ( ). : () // -

62

. . 2.

(, c. 6), . , . ,
,
( ).
: , ,
,
. , . , .
5 . <...>
,

(, c. 67).
, , 6 , , .
, ,
, , . ,
. -, . . ,
. , , 89 2009 . / . . .. . ., 2009. . 117118, 122.
5
. ., 4 ( : ?):
. , . . ., , . ,
, .
; / ,
, ( 1913 ., ,
..
() (); ., .: ., .
.
1910- . ., 2004. ( . ). . 5967, 91137).
6
. : , . . . (. : . . , 2001. . 393416),
.. . ( ). ., 2003. ( . ).

. . .

63

7 ,
. , ,
, , , , . , , . :
, , .
, . : ,
-, ,
, ,
, , , , ,
(, c. 6).
, , , (, c. 66),
, ,
, ,
, . ,
(. 12:21), , ,
: <...>. () . ,
(, c. 101).
:
(1 . 5:12)8 : ? ,
() , ,
(, c. 162).

, : ., 4;
, 6, , . , , ., . ( ), :
. ., 1879.
8
..: . , .

64

. . 2.

. . , 2- 5-
4- 9 ,
,
: , . .,
,
o , (, . 3435).
. 3- . ,
10 .
, ,
? , ,
- (, . 3536).
, . . ,
11 ,
,
. : ,
,
, , . ,
. . ,
, ,
, ,
, 9

.: , . 14. ., 1981. . 510.


Theol. III, l. 158168 // Symeon le Nouveau Theologien. Traites theologiques et
ethiques / Introd., texte crit., trad. et notes par J. Darrouz`es. T.I. Paris, 1966. (Sources
Chretiennes, 122). P. 166. . . . : .. ( ). .
() // . . XV. 2009. . 3959.
11
; .: ,
. . . . 217.
10

. . .

65

, 12 .
, , . , . ,
:
, , ,
, ,
.
, , , :
, , ,
,
, .
:
. , ,
. , , ,

(, . 53).
, , ,
, : ,
, , ,
,
13 .
12
.: Perczel I. Saint Symeon the New Theologian and the theology of
the Divine Substance // Acta Antiqua Hungarica. Vol. 41. 2001. P. 125146; . . (. : :
Dark Ages ( )); . : .. // . . . / . .
.. ; . . .. . ., 2009. (Smaragdos Philocalias; , 5). . 138141, . . 78.
13
. - / ., . .: . . ., 1995. ( ).
III.2.7 (C. 313, . .). . ,
, .: , . . . . 288300; (), .
. // . 19521983 . ,
, . , 1996. . 145174.

66

. . 2.

, , . .
(., . 4). 14 (. 1:1) ,
. , , , ,

; . :
, ,
(., . 30; , . 13); (
. 1:1),
(, . 7). , . (., . 30),
. , ,
15 .
; . ,
,
: . . . ,
, <...>.
, ,
? . <...> , ,
, , ,
16 .
, , .., ,
, , , ,
: ,
,
, , ,

(, . 1819),
14

.
.: . , II.2(16); , . , : .
/ . . .. , .. , .. , .. . ., 2002. ( ). . 156337.
16
, . . . III.2.67 (C. 310311)
15

. . .

67

,
, , ,
(, . 1314):
,
;
,
(, . 17);
; , , , ,
, , .
,
(, . 37). ,
,
, <...> , , , (, . 18). . 13
, ,
(, . 5254, 92, 166, 173, 176). ,
, . ,
: : ,
, (1 . 5:7),
: : ,
. <...>
, ,
(, . 15).
(. 3:1317, . 1:911, . 3:2122)
(. 17:113, . 9:19, . 282836) .
: ,
(, . 20).
(. 17:10) :
, -, . ,
: , ,
, . , , ,
, .. , (, . 36)17 .
17

.:
, C. 3839, 4647, 49, 5153, 84, 118119, 221.

68

. . 2.

. , . : , , , <...> , <...> ,
, , , , .
., .
- (. , . 2136).
? ,
, ,
. , , ,
, , : ( ) <...> - () , , ,
, : , : , - . ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
18 .
, , , .
. , . : . . . .
, ,
, , , , ,
; , , ,
19 ; , :
, -, . , 20 . .
, . , : <...>
:
18

, , I.8, . I.14 (. 172173


184).
19
. 28, // . . I.
., 2000. . 477.
20
, 45, // . . 807.

. . .

69

, , . ,
, , , ,
, (. 5:8),
. ,
. , ,
,
,
21 .
, , . ,
,
,
, . : . . . ;
, ,
. ,
, ,
(perichoresis): (. 14:11). <...>
perichoresis , , , - . , , : ,
; (. 15:9)22 .
2.
. -, .
- . , . 1:13,23
21

, .
. , 2003. . 62.
22
., . .
/ . . . . , 2001. . 263264. . 14
, (C. 256269), . . : ,
. . . . 292, 296.
23
, , ,
. ,

70

. . 2.

, , <...> , ,
, - (, . 8, 20, . . 11).
, , , <...> , <...>
(, . 96; . . 108),
(, . 111). :
, . ,
(. 15:23). <...> , , . ,
, . <...> ,
, , , .
, : ,
: .
, ,
, ! (, . 140141).
, . ,
(, . 38),
, (, . 9394).
(. 13:323), . ,
,
,
; ,
, .
, ,
, ,
, , (, . 9495).
, ,
, , , ,
, , ,
, ,
,
(, . 58, 8788, 110, 134135, 137, 144,
148, 154155, 165, 170171, 213);
, .. (, . 136),
, , .

. . .

71

: ,
,
, ,
, <...>,

24 .

?
, .

. , , . , .
,
(, 27:7825 ); .
, . 6:63, :
, ,
,
; ,
. <...> : , ,
(. 6:63), , : .
, , , .
<...> :
: ,
(. 13:2). ? , ,
. <...> Ce , :
, , , , ,
, ( , 16:1314)26 , ,
. .
. 27 , , , . .
24

(), . .
., 1913. . 58.
25
, ,
. ., 1996. . 233.
26
, , . ., 1900; . Victoria, 1991. . 255257.
27
-; ,
, . .
. I (Vatic. graec. 694) / ., .,
, .: .. . ., 2002. . 37158.

72

. . 2.

, , ,
, ,
, : ,
, <...> ,
() (
, XIII.12); ,
, , ,
, ( XXI
I); , , <...>
. , , .
, , ,
( , XII.17)28 . ;
.
. , , ,
: , ,

? <...> , , , ,
,
, ? ,
(, . 9697, . . 178; , . 178, 202203).
VII . : ,
,29 , ,
, , ,
, !
, , ,
30 . , , , ,
<...> , 28

/ . .: .. . .:
, 2002. ( ). . 133, 152, 322.
29
.. ,
.
30
. . IV: VI . VII . ., 1996. . 437;
. . . . : Sacrorum Consiliorum Nova et amplissima
collectio / Ed. J.D. Mansi. T. 13. Floretiae, MDCCLXVII. ol. 45

. . .

73

,
; 31 . , , ,
, , , , ,
- .
, :
, ,
.
, ,
- ( ),
, ,
- , ,
, 32 . Theophaneia School Marquette
University (, ) , ,
,
/, ,
,
33 .

, ,
,
. , . ,
, ,
34 , ,

31

. . IV. . 461.
.. Theophaneia School: // Scrinium. T.3: The
Theophaneia School: Jewish Roots of Eastern Christian Mysticism. 2007. P.x.
33
.: Alexander (Golitzin), hierom. Christian Mysticism Over Two Millenia //
Scrinium. .3. 2007. P. xxixxxiii, 1- Scrinium.
34
Philonenko-Sayar B., Philonenko M. LApocalypse dAbraham. Introduction, texte
slave, traduction et notes. Paris, 1981. (Semitica, 31); . : // . . XV. 2009.
. 186187, . 1.
32

74

. . 2.

, 35 . ,
, <...>
, ,

36 , , ; (33:1820),
, ; ,
, 37 .
,
( , ) ( , ). , , . :
(. 71:19). . ,
, ,
; , , (. 134:1). , ,
: . , , , ,
38 . .
, , ,
(., . 4:36 , , )
, ,
,
39 , , . , ,
,
40 . , (Shem),
35

A., . . . , C. 191.
, C. 192; .: Weinfeld M. Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic
School. Oxford, 1972.
37
A, . . . , C. 193.
38
, . ., 1997. . 341, 636.
39
A., . . . , C. 194.
40
Mettinger T. N. D. The Dethronement of Sabaoth. Studies in the Shem and Kabod
Theologies. Lund, 1982. (Coniectanea Biblica. Old Testament Series, 18). . 124.
36

. . .

75

, 41 . ,
, , ,
, .
XII.17 , ,
, ,
,
: ,
; ,
, .. ,
42 . , .
, ,
-
43 , ;
, , II - ,
: , ,
44 . ,
. , (, IVV), ,
,
, , , :
, -
, (, . 62).
41

Ibid., P. 124125.
.: Orlov A., Golitzin A. Many Lamps Are Lightened from the One: Paradigms of
the Transformational Vision in the Macarian Homilies // Scrinium. . 3. 2007. P. 213229;
Alexander (Golitzin), hierom. Et Introibo ad Altare Dei. The Mystagogy of Dionysius
Areopagita, with special reference to its predecessors in the eastern christian tradition.
Thessaloniki, 1994. (Analecta Vlatadon, 59). . 373385.
43
.. . .
, 2002 [ 1914 .]. . 128133.
44
.., .. . . ., 2006. . 48.
42

76

. . 2.

, . , , , , , .. ,
, ,
(., . 5, 17, 23, 38, 187188; , . 8687, 178), ,
/, ;
, - , -, . 45 .
, . , , ,
, , ,
, . . ,
, ,
46 .

45

. : . . ( ).
() // Acta eruditorum. . 6. 2009.
. 8791.
46
- . ,
, : .. - .. . . -, 2011
(http://www.spbu.ru/files/upload/disser/phylos/2011/avtoref-Senina.pdf).

Оценить