Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 9

10, 2013, 4

Vol. 10, 2013, No.4

ISSN: 1812-5220

K
Scientific and Practical Journal

Issues of Risk Analysis

-

()

12

614.84:665.74

ISSN 1812-5220
, 2013

.. ,
.. ,



,
.

.. ,

,
.

.. ,

,
.

, 10, 2013, 4

, 25 3 , -05-039-96, 03-409-01, 09-540-03,


12.13130.2009, 12.3.047-98 TNO. -05-039-96 TNO 810 .
,
() . 41,40 961,25 . TNO,
500
.
.
: , , , , , .

1.
2.

:
ME ( TNO)
TNO Nederlandse Organisatievoor Toegepast Natuurwetenschappelijk Onderzoek (
)
TNT ( TNO
03-409-01)

VCE Vapor Cloud Explosions ( )




.. . C

13

. , 1000 , 70- 90- , 38%


VCE1 [1]. VCE [2].
, Industrial Fire World
[3], , 4 2013
138 , , VCE 39%2. ,
510- [4].
,
VCE, .




[5]
.

.

VCE TNO [6], [716].
[1722].

1.

25 3 .
100 2, 35 ,
101 . - 1

VCE
[6, 2932].

19 (13,8%) .


: 769 /3, - 10,9519,80,
151,2 /,
0,7%, 1,3%, 42,9 45,8 / . [1722].

2.
-05-039-96[23], 03-409-01
[24], 12.13130.2009 [25], 12.3.047-98 [26],
09-540-03 [27] TNO [6]
(. . 1). , , ,
[28], , , 03-409-01 ME
TNO 20%3 [8].
2 , [1722].
2 ,
09-540-03, 12.13130.2009 12.3.047-98
1, 2 3-
. ( ) .
-05-039-96 03-409-01
09-540-03
, 4-
, 118 /. 09-540-03,
03-409-01 TNO, -
.

-05-039-96
3

[8] VCE, , RIPRAP ARAMAS.


[6] RIPRAP .

14

, 10, 2013, 4

VCE

09-540-03
1.

09-540-03
(, , CS2, NH3, .)
, ,
VCE

[8, 33, 34]

2.

VCE

[8, 28, 3537]

12.13130.2009, 12.3.047-98
3

. 2

[35, 36]

[28]

03-409-01
5

VCE
100 /, 15

[35, 36]

VCE
(),

[35, 36]

[28]

-05-039-96
8

, VCE ,
, .
VCE

[28]

TNO
9

- VCE

[6]

10

.
. TNO

[38]

1012- (. . 2),
( , ).
VCE
-05-039-96, 03-409-01, 09-540-03,
12.13130.2009, 12.3.047-98 TNO 3. ,
.
-05-039-96 5%
.

,
[23]. 03-409-01

()4 (1).

, , [24].
F ,
(1)

50 180

F = 50 2 [24], F
( ), ; ,
3600 [24].
=

, .

.. . C

15

R,

TNT

ME

100

511

373
87

27

50810
2911

70

631

503
127

11

12

31

61810
5211

28

1091
952

1833
734
217

18

21

49

113811
9012

14

1731
2052

3793
1614
455
627

29

61

79

169812
7213

8821
12652

27343
12364
4255
1436
1237

151

121

494

881812
41513
24414
12515
4316

.
1
6

. 2 . 3 (v) 300 /. 4 v = 200 /. 5 v = 121 /.

v = 72 /. 7 . 8 10- VCE. 9 9- VCE. 10 8- VCE. 11 7- VCE. 12 6- VCE.

13

5- VCE. 14 4- VCE. 15 3- VCE. 16 2- VCE.

12.13130.2009 12.3.047-98 (m) (m)



(2) (3).
, ()
[25, 26].

= WFT ,

q
Z ,
Q

(2)

(3)

W , W = 106 M P,
, = 3600 [25, 26],
P , .q , /, Z
, Z = 0,1 [25,
26], Q0 , Q0 = 4,52 106 / [25, 26].
09-540-03 -

() (4) [27].

[21].

m=

E .
46000

(4)

TNO-
q''v
(5) [6]. ,
, [22] (6),
(Center for Chemical Process Safety of
the American Institute of Chemical Engineers) [39].

q"v = 0,004786( uw,10 )0 ,78 ( 2rp )0 ,11 Sc 0 ,67

Pv , (5)
RTps

16

, 10, 2013, 4

VCE

()

TNO

VCE

961,25

435,44

41,40

452,98

809,78

, VCE,

?
43,54 (TNT)

39,29

42,29

? (ME)
80,98 (TNT)

.
+ ; ; ? .

VCE 500


P, k

R,

ME

100

401

383
97

20

23

43810
2411

70

501

663
147

25

13

26

55810
4911

28

881
1042

1913
764
237

42

22

42

91811
7312

14

1391
2242

4003
1684
505
687

67

65

67

134812
4913

7001
13502

28623
12944
4555
1576
1357

344

129

431

793812
39613
18314
10415
3416

.
1
6

. 2 . 3 (v) 300 /. 4 v = 200 /. 5 v = 121 /.

v = 72 /. 7 . 8 10- VCE. 9 9- VCE. 10 8- VCE. 11 7- VCE. 12 6- VCE.

13

5- VCE. 14 4- VCE. 15 3- VCE. 16 2- VCE.

.. . C

17

q"v = 0,0083

Pv 0,018 3
,

RTps

(6)

uw,10 10 , /, r p , ., Sc (Schmidt number),


Pv
Tps, Tps ,
, ,
/, R .


41,40 961,25 . ,
, -05-039-96, 03-409-01, 09-540-03,
12.13130.2009, 12.3.047-98 TNO .
,
500
.
VCE 4, , -05-039-96

ME TNO
810- VCE. 12.13130.2009, 12.3.047-98
TNO
14 .
,

[36],
.

VCE
. -05-039-96, 03-409-01, 12.13130.2009,
12.3.047-98, 09-540-03 ME TNO

.
, VCE
. , ME
TNO .

1. . .
: . . - . . .,
1997. 38 .
2. . ., . ., . .
// . 2010. . 19. 10. . 5355.
3. Industrial Fire World [ ]. : http://www.fireworld.com/IncidentLogs.
4. ., ., . . .
: 2 . .: , 1986. . 1. 319 .
5. - .. () //
[ ]. :
http://www.mchs.gov.ru/articles/comments/ item/263367.
6. CPR 14E. Methods for the calculation of physical
effects. Yellow book / by ed. C. J. H. van den Bosch,
R. A. P. M. Weterings. Hague: Gevaarlijke Stoffen, 2005.
870 p.
7. . . // -
. 2011. 10 (164)
. 2. [ ]. : http://
archive.nbuv.gov.ua/portal/soc_gum/vsunu/2011_10_2/
safonova.pdf.
8. . ., . ., . . .

- // . 2011. 9. . 7077.
9. Tauseef S. M., Rashtchian D., Abbasi T., Abbasi S. A.
A method for simulation of vapour cloud explosions
based on computational fluid dynamics (CFD) // Journal
of Loss Prevention in the Process Industries. 2011. Vol. 24,
5. P. 638647.
10. Park D. J., Lee Y. S. A comparison on predictive models of
gas explosions // Korean Journal of Chemical Engineering.
2009. Vol. 26, 2. P. 313323.
11. Alonso F. D., Ferradasa E. G., Perez J. F. S. et al. Consequence
analysis to determine damage to buildings from vapour

18

12.

13.

14.

15.

16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22.

cloud explosions using characteristic curves // Journal of


Hazardous Materials. 2008. Vol. 159, 23. P. 264270.
Tang M. J., Baker Q. A. Comparison of blast curves from
vapor cloud explosions // Journal of Loss Prevention
in the Process Industries. 2000. Vol. 13, 35.
P. 433438.
Sari A. Comparison of TNO multienergy and Baker
StrehlowTang models // Process Safety Progress. 2011.
Vol. 30, 1. P. 2326.
Mercx W. P. M., van den Berg A. C., Hayhurst C. J. et
al. Developments in vapour cloud explosion blast
modeling // Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2000. Vol. 71,
13. P. 301319.
Pape R., Mniszewski K. R., Longinow A. Explosion
phenomena and effects of explosions on structures.
II: Methods of analysis (explosion effects) // Practice
Periodical on Structural Design and Construction. 2010.
Vol. 15, 2. P. 141152.
Raman R.,Grillo P. Minimizing uncertainty in vapour cloud
explosion modeling // Process Safety and Environmental
Protection. 2005. Vol. 83, 4. P. 298306.
. ., . ., . . .

. I. . -05-039-96 // . 2010. . 19. 5. . 3747.
. ., . ., . . .

. II. 03-409-01 // . 2011. . 20, 1. . 2127.
. ., . ., . . .

. III. 12.13130.2009 //
. 2012. . 21, 1. . 3338.
. ., . ., . . . . IV.
12.3.047-98 // .
2012. . 21. 6. . 3437.
. ., . ., . . . . V. 09-540-03 //
. 2012. . 21. 8. . 3235.
. ., . ., . . . . VI. TNO-
( 1) // . 2013. . 22.
7. . 000.

, 10, 2013, 4

23. -05-039-96.
(. 31.12.96 100). .: , 2000. 40 .
24. 03-409-01. (. 26.06.2001
25) [ ]. : . .
25. 12.13130.2009. ,
( . . 1, .
09.12.2010 643) [ ].
: .- .
26. 12.3.047-98. .
. . ( . 03.08.1998 304).[ ]. : .- .
27. 09-540-03.
, (.
05.05.2003
29). : .- .
28. . ., . . //
.
2006. 2. . 3545.
29. Assael M. J., Kakosimos K. E. Fires, explosions and toxic
gas dispersions. Effects calculation and risk analysis. Boca
Raton: CRC Press, 2010. 329 p.
30. Casal J. Evalution of the effects and consequences of major
accidents in industrial plants. Amsterdam: Elsevier, 2008. 363 p.
31. Bjerketvedt D., Bakke J. R., van Wingerden K. Gas explosion
handbook // Journal of Hazardous Materials. 1997. Vol. 52,
1. P. 1-150.
32. CCPS. Guidelines for evaluating the characteristics of
vapor cloud explosions, flash fires, and bleves. N. Y.: AIChE,
1994. 394 p.
33. . .


: . - . . ., 2005. 304 .

.. . C

34. . .

// . 2009. . 6, 2
. 6469.
35. . ., . ., . . .
. : . . . -,
2002. 178 .
36. . .
: . - .
. , 2006. 395 .
37. . . // . 2008. . 5, 2. . 2634.
38. Lea C. J., Ledin H. S.A review of the state-of-the-art in
gas explosion modeling // Report HSL/2002/02. Buxton:
Health & Safety Laboratory, 2002. 180 p.
39. CCPS. Guidelines for chemical process quantitative risk
analysis. N. Y.: AIChE, 2000. 770 p.


: ,
, -
,
-

: 270, 10
:
, ,
:
: 620049, . , . , 54
.: +7 (343) 374-16-82
E-mail: 3608113@mail.ru

19

:
-
: 20
:

:
: 614990, . , . , . 53
.: +7 (342)-210-42-21
-mail: asipl@ugps.perm.ru
: ,

: 500 ,
9 25 -
: , ,

: 620075, . , . , 42
.: +7 (343)-374-65-11
-mail: nmbarbin@mail.ru
: ,
-

: 139 ,
45 -
: ,
:
: 620049, . , . , 54
.: +7 (343) 374-16-82
E-mail: guryev.evgeny@gmail.com