Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 2


(A Powerful Play with a weak Plot)

In any tragic or serious play, the dramatist tries to give relief to the audience by
introducing comic scenes or episodes. The literary term for such comic interludes is
known as tragic relief. A tragedy is bound to create tension in the mind of the
audience and if this tension is not relaxed from time to time, it generates some sort
of emotional weakness in the mind of the audience. Hence, comic scenes are a
necessity to ease the tension and refresh the mind. There was a pressing demand
from the side of Elizabethan audience for such interludes. Hence, play wrights had
to introduce such comic scenes as the producers also demanded them for a
successful run of the play. The comic interlude may have an appropriate emotional
connection in the development of the tragic play. But it is also admitted that in
Marlowe’s dramas, this tragic relief seems to be crude and often verges on horse
play and buffoonery. For these scenes, it is often said that “Dr Faustus” is a
powerful drama with a weak plot.
A close study of Marlowe’s famous play “Dr. Faustus” shows us that there are
fourteen scenes in all. Out of them, comic scenes are five or six. According to the
critics, the comic elements in these scenes are low and vulgar, full of coarse
buffoonery and they can not be accepted as organic parts of the tragic play.
They are of the opinion that only in the first comic scene do we see worked out with
some care a comic burlesque of the main plot. Another objection on comic scenes in
Dr. Faustus is that most of them are later interpolation and not from the mighty
pen of Marlowe. Some of these critical arguments really hold good. If we study
Marlowe’s play “Temburlaine”, we find him in the prologue to this play, proudly
declaring that:
“From jigging veins of rhyming mother wits,
And such conceits of clownage keep in pay,
We shall lead you to the stately tent of war.”
This shows that Marlowe must have cherished a strong dislike for clownage
conceits. Then it has also been found that the first edition of the play was published
in 1604 and the second edition appeared in 1616. And the 1616 edition contains
more scenes of clownage with new additions. So it proves that these scenes were not
from the mighty pen of Marlowe. But there are also some prominent critics,
including T.S.Eliot who assert that Marlowe was not devoid of a high developed
sense of humour and Marlowe should not be judged by a Shakespeare standard in
this respect.
Marlowe introduced the comic scenes in “Dr. Faustus” for many purposes. First, he
had to introduce crude buffoonery because it was common stock-in-trade of the
Elizabethan dramatists who could not ignore the demands of the groundlings. This
was a pressing demand from the side of the Elizabethan audience. They even justify
the inclusion of comic scenes in which Faustus teases and trouble the Pope and his
guests, outwit the horse-dealer, and make a fool of the talkative knight, planting a
pair of horns on his head. They are essential for dramatic purpose to enable
Faustus to display his miraculous powers. Second, the purpose of the introduction
of the comic scenes is to offer a temporary relaxation of tension engendered by the
serious scenes. Third, Marlowe’s description about Faustus’ pranks on the Pope
shows Marlowe’s hatred for church and Pope.
Now we take up the comic scenes one by one and discuss their quality and
significance. We have five comic scenes in Doctor Faustus in which low comedy,
burlesque and crude buffoonery have been introduced. These scenes are: Act-I,
Scene iv; Act-III, Scene I, Act-IV, Scene i; Act-V, Scene ii, iv. Scene II in Act- I, in
which Wagner cuts jokes with the scholars and confuses them may also be treated
as a comic scene. According to the critics, the comic scene iv in Act-I where we find
Wagner and the Clown engrossed in a debate is closely integrated with the main
tragic theme. So this scene may be regarded as coming from the pen of Marlowe The
same may be said about the scene in which Wagner is found perplexing and
confusing the two scholars. The scene, in which Faustus teases and troubles the
Pope and his party, seems to be too crude and vulgar to come from Marlowe’s pen.
But the Ralph-Robin episode, in the first and second scenes of Act-lV seems to have
very little connection with the main theme of the play. The other two comic scenes,
Act-IV, Scene iii, iv which show Faustus as playing an ordinary conjurer’s role
either by making horns grow on the knight’s head or by outwitting and duping the
horse-dealer are really crude and vulgar. Probably the only justification for
including such farcical scenes was to cater to vulgar taste of the groundlings of that
There are critics who maintain that excepting Scene iv of Act-I and Scene I in Act-
III, all other comic scenes are later interpolations. But according to Boas, the two
Ralph-Robin scenes are the only interpolations. We may just conclude with the very
wise comments of Wynn on this topic:
“Nevertheless, Marlowe must be blamed for the utter incongruity of so many scenes
with high tragedy. The harmony which rules the construction of Tamburlaine
giving it a lofty coherence and consistency is lamentable absent from “Dr Faustus.”
Whatever may be the case it should be accepted that at least some of the clownage
scenes, if not all, were later interpolations and Marlowe should not he blamed I for
the low comedy and coarse buffoonery in such scenes.

Written&Composed By: