Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 15

-

..

13

-
2013

..


66-65 . ..:

, , 1.
- . , . ,
2.
-

,
66-65 .3 , ,
. ,
, ,

. , ,

, .
, , , : Gruen E.S. Notes on the First Catilinarian Conspiracy // CPh. 1969. Vol. 64.
P. 20-24; Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution of C. Manilius // Latomus. 1970. Vol. 29.
P. 595-607; Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of C. Manilius in 66 B.C. and Ciceros Pro Manilio // Phoenix. 1980. Vol. 34. P. 323-336; Idem. Asconius P. 60 (Clark), prima pars: the
trial and conviction of C. Manilius in 65 B.C. // AJPh. 1985. Vol. 106. P. 367-373; Seager R.
The first Catilinarian conspiracy // Historia. 1964. Bd. 13. P. 338-347; Ward A.M. Politics in
the trials of Manilius and Cornelius // TAPhA. 1970. Vol. 101. P. 545-556.
2
. (Gruen E.S. The last generation of the
Roman Republic. Berkeley-L.A.-L., 1974. P. 261-262). . Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein
biographischer Versuch. Wiesbaden, 1969. S. 60.
3
..
1

..
67 ., (Ascon. 45; 64-65 Clark; Plut. Pomp.,
30)4. 10 67 .,
.
(lex de suffragiis libertinorum):
, , , ; ,
35 (Dio XXXVI, 42, 2).
,
, 67 ., 5 (Ascon. 64 Clark).
, . . , ,
, . :

(coetus), (Ascon. 45 Clark).
,
67 ., .. 29 , 6;
, , , 7. , , ; , , , (. . 6)8.
. (Val. Max. VI, 2, 4) .
, , . .: Gruen E.S. Pompey and the Pisones // CSCA. 1968. Vol. 1. P. 160162. . , , ,
, (Cic. Flac., 93) ( . : Mnzer F. Manilius (10) // RE. 1928. Bd. XIV. Sp. 1134).
5
, 65 .,
(Cic. Pro Corn. apud Ascon. 64 Clark). .
6
, 67 . 29 ,
(feriae conceptivae), (Varr. Ling. Lat., VI, 29).
7
(Dio XXXVI, 42, 2). ,
senatus consulto damnata esset (Ascon. 65 Clark).
8
.. : .. // 4

240


: [], , ,
[] ;
, , , . ,
(Dio XXXVI, 42, 3-4)9.
, . , , ( ) - . , ,
. ,
(ab ipso quoque Manilio non ultra defensa est)
(Ascon. 65 Clark), , , . , , (Dio XXXVI, 42, 2)10. , ,
, .
;
, , . .
. , , ,
.
. ,
11. . ,
, ,
. ,
/ . .. . ., 2010. . 388.
9
, .
10
- ;
(., Plut. Cic. 9, 4).
11
, , ,
(aquae et ignis interdictio), . .: Bauman R.A. Crime and punishment in ancient Rome. L.-N.Y., 2005. P. 27.

241

..
. , : . , .
; , ,
12.

, 13. ,
; 67 . . , , ,
, .
- , . , ,
(lex Manilia de imperio Cn. Pompeii).
, , . , . , 14. , .
, ,
:
, . 10 66 . .
(Cic. Corn., I fr. 8 Puccioni apud Ascon. 62 Clark).
, , : ,
lex Cornelia repetundarum, 81 . . .. ; , (Hardy E.G. The Catilinarian conspiracy in its context: a re-study of the evidence // JRS.
1917. Vol. 7. P. 156). .
13
, - , , , (Ascon. 57; 61 Clark).
14
.: ..
//
. . . . ., 1990. . 153-156.
12

242


, peculatus () (Plut. Cic., 9). , , , quaestio de
repetundis (Cic. Cluent., 147; Leg. Man., 1-2; Ascon. 62 Clark),
quaestio de peculatu , (Cic. Cluent., 94)15.
, ,
.
(de vi).
, . ,
, , ,
16. , , quaestio perpetua
de vi 17.
(Lex Acilia, 2), ,
, , . . , , ,
, , , 18. . :

lex Cornelia repetundarum
, , quo ea pecunia pervenerit19.

20. 15
. Phillips E. J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 597; Ward A.M. Politics in the trials
P. 545-546. . , ,
de vi
66 . (Greenidge A.H.J. The legal procedure of Ciceros time. Oxf., 2004. P. 457),
.
16
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 597. . (Bauman R.A.
The crimen maiestatis in the Roman Republic and Augustan Principate. Johannesburg, 1967)
, lex repetundarum , de maiestate, ( . : Ward A.M.
Politics in the trials... P. 549 n. 15), ,
, .
.
17
Hough J. The lex Lutatia and the lex Plautia de vi // AJPh. 1930. Vol. 51. P. 142.
18
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 597.
19
.: Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of C. Manilius... P. 329-331.
20
., ,

243

..
(Cic. Q. fr., II, 11(13), 2; Ascon. 59 Clark). , , , . , , , (ut mos
est) (Ascon. 59 Clark). -, .
29
, 21.

. , ,
, .
, . , . , , .
, ,
22. . 23, , , Pro lege Manilia24. . ,
(Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 546).
.
21
nominis delatio
, quaestio de repetundis
(Seager R. Pompey the Great. A political biography.
Oxf., 2002. P. 64; Fantham E. The trials of Gabinius in 54 B.C. // Historia. 1975. Bd. 24.
S. 439 n. 34). , ,
. nominis delatio
28 ( ), 27 ( ): .
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 596, Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of
C. Manilius... P. 323-324 n. 4.
22
. Crawford J.W. M. Tullius Cicero: the lost and unpublished orations. Hypomnemata: Untersuchungen zur Antike und zu ihrem Nachleben. H. 80. Gttingen, 1984. P. 65;
Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 547.
23
Smith R.E. Cicero the statesman. Cambridge, 2010. P. 81.
24
Cic. Leg. Man., 69: , , , ;
, , , .

244


, , ,
. , ,
, , 29 ,
. , , ,
, 25. , , : , ,
. , -
, . : ,
, . , ,
.
,
. : , . , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, : .
. . ( , ) , , ,

(Plut. Cic. 9, 4-6 .. ).
: ,
, , , , , , , , , , ,
, (. .. ).
25
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 599-600.

245

..
. , . , ,
, , , ; , ,
. .
(Dio XXXVI, 44, 1-2). , ,
, 26.
, . , . , , contio 29 , , 27.
, , 66 . . , , , 66 . 65 .28. , 66 . .
, , , .. 29.
, , , , , 30. ,
26
. Millar F. A
study of Cassius Dio. Oxf., 1964. P. 46-55.
27
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 600.
29 ( . ).
28
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 603; Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch. S. 60, 65.
29
, , . : Gruen E.S. The last generation P. 262.
30
. , , , . , , ,
, , , (Phillips E.J. Cicero and the
prosecution... P. 600-603). . . - contiones,
. ( ) , ,
(Morstein-Marx R. Mass oratory and political power in the late Roman Republic.

246


. ,
. : ,
, .
, 66 . . 29 , , .

. .
, . ,
. , , . .
, .
:
,
.
, , . ,
. .
: , 65 . 31. ,
, . , (de maiestate) (Schol. Bob. 119 Stangl). .
de maiestate , 29 66 ., , ,
32.
Cambridge, 2004. P. 160 ff., 281). , 29 ,
, ,
, .
31
. , ; . ,
(Mnzer F. Manilius (10) // RE. 1928. Bd. XIV.
Sp. 1134).
32
.: Mommsen Th. Rmisches Strafrecht. S. 582.
, . , . , 65 . -

247

..
:
(operarum duces) (Ascon. 60 Clark)33. -,
(Schol. Bob. 119
Stangl). : , . , .
, , .
. , , ,
, (magni homines)
(Ascon. 66 Clark). , , ,
.

66 65 . , 29 66 . , (cum telo), (Cic. Cat. I, 15).
,
, , .
34.
, 5 , quaestio de repetundis
(Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 603-606). ,
de maiestate (
., .: Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of C. Manilius... P. 334; Ward A.M. Politics
in the trials... P.548-549). . : 65 . ,
de repetundis, de maiestate (Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of
C. Manilius... P. 331 n. 37). . (Crawford J. M. Tullius Cicero: the lost and unpublished orations. P. 65) .
(Gruen E.S. The last generation P.262 n. 5), , de maiestate. . (Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch. S. 60, 65) . (Stockton D.
Cicero. A political biography. Oxf.-N.Y., 1988. P. 71): , .
33

66 ., - (Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch. S. 63; Griffin M. The tribune C. Cornelius
P. 209, 212). .: Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 549; Ramsey J.T. Asconius P. 60 (Clark)... P. 368-369.
34
, : Gelzer M. Sergius (23) // RE. 1923. Bd. IIA. Sp. 1697; Seager R. The first Catilinarian conspiracy // Historia.

248


, -
, -, .
66 . , . .
, - , ,
35.
, , ,
65 .36
, , . , ,
magni homines: - , 37.

38. ,
1964. Bd. 13. P. 344-345; Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 602-603. ..
, magni homines , 29 66 . (Hardy E.G. The Catilinarian
conspiracy... P. 161). .
, , , , , . Cic.
Cat. I, 15 . ,
29 , , , , , ,
(.: Ascon. 92 Clark; Sall. Cat. 19, 1-5), .
35
C. Gruen E.S. Notes on the First Catilinarian Conspiracy // CPh. 1969. Vol. 64. P. 2024; Seager R. The first Catilinarian conspiracy // Historia. 1964. Bd. 13. P. 342-345.
, .
36
videtur: L.
Catilinam et Cn. Pisonem videtur significare (Ascon. 66 Clark).
37
. . , , , 67-66 . (Gruen E.S.
Notes P. 24). :
- ,
.
38
.: Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch. S. 65-66;
Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 551-552.
.: Parrish E.J. Crassus new friends and Pompeys return // Phoenix. 1973.
Vol. 27. P. 358 ff.

249

..
. ,
. ,
, , . ,
, ,
, . ,
. .

(Sall. Cat. 19, 1)39. ,
40.
, , . , - .
:
, . ,
, .
. , , , . .
, 41 , , , (Ascon. 65-66 Clark). , . .
,
- . , 65 .
(Ascon. 60 Clark)42.
: ,
. : Gruen E.S. Notes P. 24; Idem. Pompey and P. 159-161.
Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 552.
41
, , : [] (semper venalis et alienae
minister potentiae) (Vell. II, 23, 1).
42
.: Marshall B.A. The vote of a bodyguard for the consuls of 65 // CPh. 1977. Vol.
72. P. 319-320. , , 65 . (Phillips E.J. Cicero
and the prosecution... P. 604-605). ( ,
39
40

250


, , . ,
, 43. ; .
, 66 . .
Pro Manilio: hic ego non solum confiteor verum etiam profiteor ( , [ ]
) (Cic. Man. 397-398 Schoell). , - , , . 44.
, , , , . ,
. ,
;
.
. : ,
, ,
.

.. // / . .. . ., 2010.
. 341-396.
) 5 : Seager R. The
first Catilinarian... P. 345; Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 606.
43
Ascon. 60 Clark: non respondisset atque esset damnatus.
. : non respondisset absensque esset damnatus
(Ascon. 49 Stangl). , , (Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 554).
44
. , , 66 . (Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch.
S. 60 Anm. 72; 65). . (Phillips
E.J. Cicero and the prosecution... P. 606) . (Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of C.
Manilius... P. 335-336). , - , . (Gruen E.S. The last generation P. 262 n. 7), .
(Ward A.M. Politics in the trials... P. 552-553) . (Seager R. Pompey the Great P.
212 n. 16). . , (Crawford
J. M. Tullius Cicero: the lost and unpublished orations. P. 64).

251

..
.. // . . . . ., 1990.
Bauman R.A. The crimen maiestatis in the Roman Republic and Augustan Principate.
Johannesburg, 1967.
Bauman R.A. Crime and punishment in ancient Rome. L.-N.Y., 2005.
Crawford J.W. M. Tullius Cicero: the lost and unpublished orations. Hypomnemata:
Untersuchungen zur Antike und zu ihrem Nachleben. H. 80. Gttingen, 1984.
FanthamE. The trials of Gabinius in 54 B.C. // Historia. 1975. Bd. 24. S. 425-443.
Gelzer M. Cicero. Ein biographischer Versuch. Wiesbaden, 1969.
Greenidge A.H.J. The legal procedure of Ciceros time. Oxf., 2004.
Griffin M. The tribune C. Cornelius // JRS. 1973. Vol. 63. P. 196-213.
Gruen E.S. Pompey and the Pisones // CSCA. 1968. Vol. 1. P. 155-170.
Gruen E.S. Notes on the First Catilinarian Conspiracy // CPh. 1969. Vol. 64. P. 20-24.
Gruen E.S. The last generation of the Roman Republic. Berkeley-L.A.-L., 1974.
Hardy E.G. The Catilinarian conspiracy in its context: a re-study of the evidence // JRS.
1917. Vol. 7. P. 153-228.
Hough J. The lex Lutatia and the lex Plautia de vi // AJPh. 1930. Vol. 51. P. 135-147.
Marshall B.A. The vote of a bodyguard for the consuls of 65 // CPh. 1977. Vol. 72. P. 318-320.
Millar F. A study of Cassius Dio. Oxf., 1964.
Mommsen Th. Rmisches Strafrecht. Leipzig, 1899.
Morstein-Marx R. Mass oratory and political power in the late Roman Republic. Cambridge, 2004.
Mnzer F. Sergius (23) // RE. 1923. Bd. IIA. Sp. 1693-1711.
Mnzer F. Manilius (10) // RE. 1928. Bd. XIV. Sp. 1133-1134.
Parrish E.J. Crassus new friends and Pompeys return // Phoenix. 1973. Vol. 27. P.
357-380.
Phillips E.J. Cicero and the prosecution of C. Manilius // Latomus. 1970. T. 29. P. 595-607.
Ramsey J.T. The prosecution of C. Manilius in 66 B.C. and Ciceros Pro Manilio //
Phoenix. 1980. Vol. 34. P. 323-336.
Ramsey J.T. Asconius P. 60 (Clark), prima pars: the trial and conviction of C. Manilius
in 65 B.C. // AJPh. 1985. Vol. 106. P. 367-373.
Seager R. The first Catilinarian conspiracy // Historia. 1964. Bd. 13. S. 338-347.
Seager R. Pompey the Great. A political biography. Oxf., 2002.
Smith R.E. Cicero the statesman. Cambridge, 2010.
Stockton D. Cicero. A political biography. Oxf.-N.Y., 1988.
Ward A.M. Politics in the trials of Manilius and Cornelius // TAPhA. 1970. Vol. 101. P. 545-556.

N
252