Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
U.S. Coast Guard Used Motorcycles to Watch Beaches During World War I
By William R. Wells II
merican soldiers were now on the battlefields of Massachusetts, was part of an experiment during World
A Europe, and Edward Forbes was patrolling Florida
beaches for any signs of the arrival of German soldiers,
War I by the Coast Guard to fulfill one of its missions of
guarding the nation’s coast.
sailors, or spies on American shores during October 1917. There had been concern that Germans might try to bring
To help him do his job, the Coast Guard had provided him the war to America’s shores, and the revelation of the famous
with a motorcycle—to patrol more areas quickly and to return Zimmerman telegram—in which the Germans sought to
to his post with news of any sightings as fast as possible. bring Mexico into the war against the United States—had
This day, however, he was caught by the surf and left the fueled fears of invasion and prompted patrols along the
motorcycle on the beach after he couldn’t get it started before nation’s Atlantic and Gulf coasts.
the rise of the tide. The next day, he was able to pull it out Motorcycles had been requested for patrols on Florida’s
and spent the next four days cleaning it up—removing rust east coast and the Texas coast along the Gulf of Mexico.
from the brightwork and getting the ignition back in work- They were to be part of America’s arsenal in what would be
ing condition. But the clutch was frozen as well, and that called the World War.
took another day to disassemble, clean, and reassemble.
This was not a good beginning for a war patrol, nor would
Above: W. C. Leaird’s bicycle shop in Fort Lauderdale, ca. 1916, where
it get any better. In the meantime, those on foot patrol contin- repairs were made on some Coast Guard motorcycles. Surfman
ued their five-mile round trip patrols on the beach. Wallace King (left) was part owner. The Coast Guard purchased 12
Forbes’s use of the Indian motorcycle, manufactured by motorcycles for stations along the Florida coast and one for the Point
the Hendee Manufacturing Company of Springfield, Isabel, Texas, station.
The addition of a telegrapher’s key to the Richardson added an exception for cost about $152 each, the patrols could not
World War I patrols became the communi- Lemon City (Station No. 209), which had a be justified much longer. Except for the
cation model used by the Coast Guard beach seven-mile stone road, as well as the special motorcycles that Richardson wanted saved
patrols during World War II. During 1918, patrol at Boynton, Florida, which also used a for stone road use, he recommended the
the stations received telephones to enhance stone road for about 35 miles. In previous remainder be disposed of “to the best advan-
communications, but these telephones were months, the stations themselves sent com- tage of [the] Coast Guard.”
to be used only for emergency work. In addi- plaints that the motorcycles were useless on The war’s end was likely as great a factor
tion, each surfman received, on average, some mudflats and sand dunes. The Coast in Richardson’s decision as the deficiencies
increased pay to about 14 dollars a month. Guard station at Port Isabel, Texas, retained in the motorcycles. Once the war ended, so
Mechanical failures, bad weather, and at its motorcycle. did the Navy’s funding. In January 1919, W.
least two accidents plagued the motorcycle Richardson listed the lack of repair parts B. Furcher, commandant of the Seventh
patrols. The first accident occurred in as a leading cause for infrequent use of the Naval District, Key West, wrote Richardson
February 1918, when Surfman Wallace motorcycles. He complained that repair asking him whether or not they should
King, operating from Fort Lauderdale, parts were not available locally, and those retain any or all of the motorcycles. Giving
wrecked when he ran over a log covered with ordered from the manufacturer took from 4 Richardson a hint to the answer he wanted,
seaweed. Forbes’s accident was potentially to 12 weeks to receive. He was frustrated Furcher added, “now that hostilities have
more serious. As if in a silent film slapstick that when the parts did arrive, “some small ceased and they are no longer needed for
scene, Forbes reported that the footboard item such as an additional screw or other military purposes.”
“flopped to [an] upright position, lacking [a] similar part is needed and consequently [the] Bertholf wrote Richardson in early
brake pedal, causing him to lose control of machine is again placed out of commission February 1919, and officially ended the
machine and ran into railing [of Hobe for another month or two.” wartime motorcycle patrol on February 7,
Bridge], breaking headlight, footstep starter The motorcycles at stations Nos. 202, 1919, except for those asked for by
and Mag[neto] control.” 204, 205, 206, and 208 were out of commis- Richardson. As directed, Richardson select-
By November 1918, the enthusiasm sion for months at a time. It appeared to ed the best five motorcycles, retained all the
exhibited earlier for the motorcycles waned as Richardson (as a whole nation would ulti- spare parts, and shipped the remaining
they became more nuisance than assistance. mately learn about automotives) that the motorcycles to the Navy at Key West. Now
The general disappointment showed as older the machines became, the more repairs without the bothersome motorcycles, the
Richardson wrote now Commodore- they needed. stations resumed the prewar foot patrols of
Commandant Bertholf on November 13, Richardson estimated that 75 percent of about two and a half miles on either side of
1918: “Owing to the great expense in keeping the motorcycle fleet was out of commission the stations.
up motorcycles and unfavorable results . . . it at any one time. The cost was too high. Bertholf also informed Commandant
is recommended the motor cycle patrol at When Fort Pierce (Station No. 206) received Furcher where the motorcycles were going to
Florida East Coast Stations . . . be discontin- a second motorcycle, its repair costs rose to be stationed and that the “double patrols”
ued.” Richardson’s use of “unfavorable more than $125 for both its machines from (around-the-clock) would cease and each
results” was an admission the motorcycles June to November 1918. The motorcycle station would reduce its complement to nine
had not been as reliable or useful as hoped. used by Forbes at Hobe Sound “is beyond men. The ending of the war and motorcycle
The hopeful 1916 reviews of motorcycle use repair owing to the length of time this use forewarned the ending of another era. By
by the U.S. Marine Corps and the Spanish machine being used and the mean character November 1919 the Coast Guard reduced
Army dimmed. of the beach.” Considering the motorcycles East Florida stations Nos. 202, 203, 204,
NOTE ON SOURCES
Archival sources used in this article are mainly Classification 701: Complements, File 1910–1922, 1949 U. S. Naval Institute publication, The United
drawn from the Records of the U.S. Coast Guard, Entry 82A, RG 26) and provided the names of the States Coast Guard 1790–1915.
Record Group (RG) 26, at the National Archives men familiar with operation of motorcycles. The “American Motorcycles for European Fighting
in Washington, D.C., and in Atlanta, Georgia. men were Brice F. George, Station No. 202; Gray Men,” Scientific American (February 5, 1916): 154.
The National Archives in Atlanta has Logs of D. Love, Walter W. Osteen, Commodore G. “Germans Discharged from Coast Guard,” New
Lifesaving Stations, Entry 245. The only journals Huskey, Colon Hutchinson, and Guss Tyson, York Times, February 8, 1917, p. 2. Only natural-
available for this period were those for the Fort Station No. 203; Earl E. Kyzer, Station No. 204; H. ized Germans were allowed to remain in the U.S.
Lauderdale station: Fort Lauderdale, Florida, Spencer Fromberger, Ralph C. Bragg, George W. Coast Guard, U.S. Lighthouse Service, and the
Station Journal, May 19, 1917, to January 30, Duncan, and Buren W. Parsley, Station No. 205; U.S. Transport Service. All others were discharged.
1918. Also in Atlanta is Customs Inspector Francis Richards and Lawrence N. Borland, Station Felix J. Koch, “Keeping a City’s Police
Quinan’s report on “strange doings and night sig- No. 206; none at Station No. 207; Wallace King, Motorcycles in Repair,” The American City
nalings”: confidential letter titled “Motorcycle Alonzo Lee High, John Luther Simmons, Station (September 1917): 250. This article describes the
Patrol,” sent by J. W. Quinan (U.S. Navy Aid for No. 208; and Henry C. Matthans, Jerry Roberts, usefulness and problems of motorcycle patrols in
Information, Key West), August 20, 1917, to and Rudolph Roberts, Station No. 209. Wallace Cincinnati, Ohio. The primary use was to check
Inspector (Capt. D. P. Foley, USCG), Letters Sent King appeared a good choice. He was a partner in speeders exceeding eight miles an hour, but the
by the Fifth, Sixth, Seventh, Eighth, and W. C. Leaird’s bicycle shop in Fort Lauderdale. motorcycles were under constant repair because
Thirteenth Districts, Eighth District, RG 26, Bertholf apportioned the stations and numbers of patrol work and rough roads.
NAB. The May 15, 1917, letter referenced by of motorcycles in a letter to the U.S. Navy Bureau “Coastal Telephone Service,” Proceeding of the
Quinan was not located. of Yards and Docks on June 19, 1917 (General U. S. Naval Institute 43 (March 1917): 584. On
Correspondence at the headquarters level is at Correspondence, 1935–1941, File Classification February 13, 1917, Navy Secretary Josephus
the National Archives Building (NAB) in 602, Station and Watch Bills, Seventh District, Daniels asked for a $250,000 congressional
Washington, D.C. The investigation of rumors of Entry 82B, RG 26): appropriation to enhance the Coast Guard “tele-
submarines being built on Hog Island is recorded in No. 202, Ormond, Fla. (2) phone signal service.” Daniels admitted the Coast
a report by 2nd Lt. William P. Wishaar, USCG: No. 203 Oakhill, Fla. (2) Guards telephone system was better than that of
“Investigation of Alleged Neutrality Violation,” No. 204 Titusville, Fla. (1) the War Department, Navy Department, and the
March 9, 1917, to his commanding officer, Capt. No. 205 Vero[Beach], Fla. (2) Lighthouse Service. He used the Coast Guard’s
Henry Ulke, General Correspondence, 8th District Superintendent, Jacksonville (2) communication model for his department.
1910–1935, File Classification 64, Cooperation No. 206 Fort Pierce, Fla. (1) However, there were no Coast Guard–connected
with Other Departments, State Neutrality, No. 208, Fort Lauderdale, Fla. (1) telephone systems south of Beaufort, N.C., and
Comanche, Entry 82A, RG 26, NAB. This report No. 209, Lemon City, Fla. (1) none on the Gulf Coast. However, the Coast
was classified “confidential” by the secretary of the No. 222, Point Isabel, Texas (1) Guard shrewdly allowed the Navy Department to
Navy on March 15, 1917, and declassified by Printed sources: “Saboteurs, Subversives take full control of its communication system
NARA (NND867200) on February 1, 1993. Thwarted,” The Coast Guard Reservist 10 (July with the full knowledge the system would return
Superintendent J. W. Richardson (Jacksonville, 1963): 1, 3. to the Coast Guard in an updated condition.
Florida) sent a May 26, 1917, telegram (General Evans, S. H. and A. A. Lawrence, “The History Digital sources: Google Patents (www.google.com/
Correspondence, 1935–1941, File Classification and Organization of the United States Coast patents, accessed February 10, 2009) for L. J.
602: Station and Watch Bills, Seventh District, Guard.” (U.S. Coast Guard Academy, 1938). This Husted’s patent No. 1,222,630 of April 17, 1917,
Entry 82B, RG 26) in response to a May 19, 1917, is the source of the 1938 Jacksonville District chart. “Ariel Torpedo Steering Mechanism.” A prolific
letter from Captain-Commandant E. P. Bertholf This history is unpublished, but some of it was used inventor, elements of Husted’s 1917 torpedo
(General Correspondence, 1910–1935, File later by Capt. Stephen H. Evans, USCG, in his patent was used in torpedo design into the 1970s.