Score: 4 Criteria: Goal/Function Goal/function of the utopia is clear and insightful.

Explanations/justifications Explanations and justifications make sense, are organized, support the goal of the utopia, and reflect ideas generated from reading and group discussion. Ideas/concepts Ideas and concepts are fully developed and reflect the process, reports from jigsaws, and ideas generated from group discussion. Students have clearly made discoveries about betweenness utopia vs. dystopia binary. Presentation: Students clearly understand the task/process and can teach their own process to their peers. Important points are obviously made and audience understands the main points of presentation. Can answer questions from audience meaningfully. 3 Goal/function is clear but lacks complexity. 2 1 No goal/function for the utopia. Explanations and justifications are incomplete/no connection is made to goal of the utopia. Ideas seem made up. Students plainly report from articles. Binary between utopia/dystopia still exists. Lacks all complexity.

Goal/function is unclear. No purpose for the utopia is evident. Explanations and Explanations and justifications are clear, justifications are complete complete, and support but have gaps in goal of the utopia. Ideas logic/connection to goal of reflect facts reported from utopia is unclear. Reflects readings. ideas reported from readings. Ideas and concepts are Ideas and concepts are developed, reflect process, reports from jigsaws. No and jigsaws. Some new new ideas or concepts ideas are incorporated. incorporated. No attempt Some reporting. Students as discovery has been are on the brink of made. Binary between discovery. Some utopia/dystopia still exists. betweenness is recognized. Students understand Students do not task/process and report understand/confused their process back to their about parts of task peers. Important points process. Presentation is a are made. Audience bit scanty. Some points are requires some clarification left out. Students have a on confusing parts that hard time answering werent made clear. questions or cannot link Students can answer their answers to their audiences questions process. sufficiently.

No presentation created.