Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
family of IEDs developed specically to
implement its core values through full native
compliance.
So far, we have concentrated on the
IEC61850-8.1 station bus. However, we
are now focusing on the IEC 61850-9-2
process bus that enables current and
voltage measurements to be transmitted to
protection and control devices via a bre-
optic communication network, resulting in
reduced copper cabling and increased safety.
New horizons in substation
protection and control
The process bus also supports the
standardised integration of non-conventional
instrument transformers (NCITs), bringing
performance improvements and further
reductions in cost and space requirements.
NCITs also improve safety because they
eliminate the risk of voltage hazards, which
can ari se i n conventi onal transformer
circuits.
In 2012, we saw the rst fully compliant
commercial installation of IEC 61850-9-2
process bus technology. This was installed
for the Australian utility, Powerlink, to pro-
vide advanced automation functions to
enhance availability and grid reliability at
Loganlea, a key substation serving south-
east Queensland, a-fast growing region of
Australia.
Ibrahim Cobaniglu, ABB UK Sales and Marketing manager for Substation
Automation, outlines some of the latest developments in protection and
control technology.
01
19 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Power system protection and control
Communications
AFS Family Solutions
Driven by IEC61850 and other Ethernet
based communication protocols, switches
are now fi ndi ng thei r way i nto uti l i ty
networks. Green field developments in
particular are an ideal opportunity to con-
sider this type of solution in substation and
distribution communication networks.
ABBs AFS650 and AFS670 family offers
many features which are required in the
utility environment, including fast protec-
tion schemes as well as redundant pow-
er supply and alarm contacts. They also
enable the stepwise introduction of Smart
Grid applications, such as integration of
renewable energy sources, advanced dis-
tribution automation solutions and similar.
Extension for Stones System
Verication Simulator
The outstanding success of our unique
automated factory acceptance test (FAT)
system at Stone has recently seen it fur-
ther extended and upgraded.
The traditional method of conducting
a FAT on bay control and protecti on
equipment is to hook up the IEDs (Intelligent
Electronic Devices) and relays to a network
of switches, relays and lamps selected to
simulate the substation plant. Our view
is that this approach, which relies heavily
on manual switching and recording of
results, does not offer the levels of rigour,
repeatability or the full audit trail appropriate
for state-of-the-art protection and control
schemes. That is why we offer our own
dedicated, fully automated, computer-
control l ed test i nstal l ati on, or System
Verication Simulator (SVS).
The computer-controlled SVS is linked
to ABBs own engineered modules that
simulate the behaviour of substation plant
such as circuit breakers, disconnectors and
earthing switches. In effect, we can dupli-
cate the whole substation within the labo-
ratory, and run automated, self-monitoring
test sequences to establish that the sub-
station interacts correctly with the protec-
tion and control panels. Over a period of
time we have established a library of test
routines to cover all potential situations.
The real advantage of this unique facility
is its repeatability. It responds just like the
real plant, without human intervention to ick
test switches and so on. And because the
tests are automated, we have been able to
uncover some aspects of the equipments
behaviour, such as timing issues, that
could not be picked up by manual testing.
Portable relay rooms
For a number of utility projects in the UK
we are now delivering portable, fully-con-
tainerised relay rooms. They provide all
the vital protection and control cubicles
and accessories in a fully tested factory-
assembled package that creates what is
virtually a plug and play solution. Not only
are the systems easy to install and com-
mission, they are fully portable so can be
relocated as needs change, while offering
a 40-year service life.
Total service
While delivering state-of-the-art protection
and control systems is crucial, it is vital that
they are fully supported throughout their
operational life-cycle. So we have devel-
oped a range of service packages including
24/7 support for critical systems.
01 Australias Loganlea Substation has been
fitted with the IEC 61850 process bus
02 AFS switches are modular and IEC 61850
compliant
03 Factory acceptance testing at Stone
02
03
20 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Substation communications
Take control: Tropos
brings a new dimension
to utility communications
Andy Osiecki, General Manager of ABBs UK power
system network management business, explains how
the recent acquisition of Tropos Networks adds to ABBs
ability to meet the needs of its UK power generation and
transmission customers through private wireless networks
that deliver secure control over grids whatever the weather.
Data Centre
Fibre/PTP
2.4/5/8/3.65 GHz
900 MHz
HAN (ZigBee)
HAN
Energy Storage Device
Substation
Feeders
21 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Substation communications
I
n a world where wireless communica-
tion is becoming the norm and where
Smart Grids are becoming reality, ABB
is now able to offer a new service to
power utilities in the UK following its ac-
quisition of Silicon Valley-based Tropos
Networks.
Now part of ABBs Utility Communications
product group, Tropos provides private
wireless networks which free operators
from the need to lease costly bandwidth
from third parties. The wireless networks
also ensure network availability when and
where its needed, the ability to run multiple
applications with high bandwidth and low
latency and a high level of security.
Tropos has been developing its wireless
network technology for nearly a decade
and has experience of installing end-to-
end solutions, with over 70,000 routers in
operation at more than 1,000 customers in
50 countries. It has established itself as the
industry leader in the eld and is an excellent
t with ABB, bringing a new dimension to
our offerings.
With a client list that includes blue-
chip organizations in sectors ranging from
utilities, through mining and oil & gas, to
Smart Cities and ports, the Tropos business
offers huge potential for ABB, especially in
the UK power utility market.
Networks and applications
So what exactly is the offering? Tropos
describes its two main areas of expertise
as being Smart Grids and Smart Cities.
Its solutions include networks of routers
and directional radio systems, arranged
in a mesh or grid structure, along with the
architecture and network management to
support them. These networks can handle
an assortment of applications. In the energy
sector, these include Advanced Metering
Infrastructure (AMI), demand management
and response, distribution automation
and control, outage management, mobile
workf orce appl i cati ons, di stri buted
generation and video security.
A key feature i s that there i s no
restriction to a single application vendor,
giving customers the freedom to choose
the applications that suit them. Its possible
to run any application that operates over
an enterprise IT network or the internet.
Performance and exibility
Because every router in an ABB Tropos
network i s i ntel l i gent, data i s routed
effi ci entl y to where there i s capaci ty.
This minimizes delays and gives Tropos
customers real-time visibility and control
of their assets.
Networks are also scalable, meaning
that customers can choose to start small
and grow when needed. As the network
grows, each smart router will automatically
reconfi gure i tsel f, maki ng expansi on
relatively simple. The mesh network design
offers inherent reliability, as the network
can handle any outage by redirecting data
intelligently and seamlessly.
Rugged and reliable
With an IP67 rating and tamper-evident
casings, ABB Tropos routers are designed
to cope with almost any physical challenge,
a necessity when routers are routinely
installed in outdoor locations in the eld.
Equipment is designed to withstand
temperatures from -40 C to +85 C, wind
speeds of up to 165 miles per hour and
sandy or dusty environments as well as the
damp, salt-laden climate found in coastal
locations. The option of adding mobile
routers enables the network to be extended
whatever the location of eld staff one
mobile router even gave uninterrupted
network access throughout the launch of the
rocket on which it was installed. This build
quality contributes to network accessibility
gures of better than 99.99 per cent.
Recognising customers demands for
networks that are both reliable and secure,
Tropos has integrated a high level of security
into its products, which have been deployed
in military and law enforcement applications.
Each device is equipped with multi-
layered security, including VPN, WPA2
encryption, AES encryption and support
for multiple VLANs. Networks also feature
software alarms and authentication and
security measures to restrict unauthorized
access.
Unique position
While there are other providers of wireless
mesh networks in the market, only ABB
Tropos has a track record in delivering end-
to-end solutions for utility applications and
distribution networks. The company has
worked on networks for power generation,
substations and utilities longer than in any
other sector.
As the number of applications managed
over a wireless mesh network grows, so
does the nancial benet. Some customers
have achieved return on investment in as
little as one year when integrating several
applications on to their networks.
Network router
22 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Renewable connections
S
ubstations form an essential el-
ement in the grid connection of
renewable energy schemes from
onshore and offshore windfarms to wave,
tidal, solar and biomass power projects.
To meet the specific needs of this sector,
ABB has developed a broad portfolio of
substation solutions.
This includes the design, installation and
commissioning of gas insulated switchgear
(GIS) and air insulated switchgear (AIS)
substations up to 400 kV and beyond,
including civil engineering works as required.
Our scope covers both high-voltage
(HV) and medium-voltage (MV) substations
for transmission and distribution network
connections. All of these substations utilise
ABBs extensive portfolio of modular and
compact switchgear solutions as well as
transformers, reactors, lters, control and
protection systems, alongside dynamic
reactive compensation solutions to ensure
grid code compliance.
For HVAC connected offshore wind
farms, the ABB Grid Systems business
can supply the turnkey solution for the
complete electrical transmission system,
incorporating both onshore and offshore
HV substations, plus design and supply
of the offshore platform.
Substations the vital link
for renewable energy projects
Offshore substation for Thornton Bank
wind farm
September 2013 saw ABB complete the
delivery of the subsea transmission link for
one of Europes largest offshore wind farms
with the commissioning of the 325 MW grid
connection for the Thornton Bank wind
farm. The project, carried out for Belgian
company C-Power NV, was delivered on
schedule.
The transmission link was constructed
as part of an expansion of the Thornton
Bank wind farm. In the rst phase of its
development, six wind turbines with a
total capacity of 30 MW were built and
Kevin Mills, ABBs Sector Manager for renewable energy connections,
outlines ABBs range of substation solutions for onshore and offshore
renewable energy projects.
01
23 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Renewable connections
a temporary connection to the mainland
was built by ABB. The second and third
phases of the project involved adding 48
wind turbines, which takes the wind farms
capacity to 325 MW, which is transmitted
30 km ashore via the transformer station
platform.
ABB was responsible for delivering the
grid connection as a turnkey project, which
included the system engineering, design,
supply and commissioning of the AC sub-
sea cables, land-based cable systems and
the offshore substation and platform that
houses it.
Hadyard Hill wind farm
ABB power transformers and associated
hi gh-vol tage swi tchgear and control
equipment play a vital role in connecting
SSEs 120 MW Hadyard Hill wind farm
development to Scotlands main power
transmission grid.
For the Hadyard Hill project, ABB supplied
two 90 MVA 132/33 kV power transformers,
an 11-panel 33 kV switchboard, two 5 MVar
capacitors, a 145 kV dead tank circuit
breaker, six CVTs, six surge arrestors and
line traps.
PASS M0 saves space for distribution
substations
ABBs innovative PASS M0 space-saving
hybrid AIS and GIS switchgear module can
save up to 70 per cent of the space normally
required for a conventional AIS substation.
This enables renewable energy operators
to make optimum use of the restricted
installation footprint often available for
the construction of a suitable distribution
substation. It also reduces the need for civil
works such as foundations, steelwork and
cable trenching operations.
The pass M0 design, which has full
Energy Networks Association (ENA) and
Scottish Power approvals, is based on a
hybrid of ABBs traditional AIS and metal-
clad GIS switchgear units. Rated at up
to 145 kV, it integrates all the necessary
substati on swi tchgear bay functi ons,
including a circuit breaker, one or more
combined disconnector/earthing switches,
bushings for connection to single or double
busbar systems and a current transformer
in one compact module, eliminating the
need for separate pieces of equipment for
each function.
ABB supplies the PASS M0 module as
a completely pre-fabricated, pre-wired and
pre-tested unit. It ts into a standard truck
01 Hadyard Hill wind farm substation
02 Cleve Hill substation serves the London
Array (Photograph courtesy of London
Array Limited)
03 Thornton Banks offshore grid connection
container for delivery without any special
packaging. No special arrangements are
needed for shipping and transportation, and
once on site just a simple 30 rotation of
the outer poles completes the nal layout.
A key feature of the PASS M0 is its
virtually maintenance-free design. The line
and busbar disconnectors, as well as the
earthing switches, are integrated within the
breaking chamber. These components are
completely immune from all environmental
conditions, ensuring lifelong reliability, and
eliminating routine maintenance of high-
voltage parts to overcome a major weakness
of AIS substations.
02
03
24 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Distribution substations
Fitting into a tight spot
ABB has delivered an 11 kV packaged
substation to act as the main power distri-
bution hub for the UKs second largest oil
renery, Total Lindsey Oil Renery (LOR).
Both the short project timescale and the
space constraints at the selected location
at the heart of the renery gave the project
team challenges, particularly in carrying out
the substantial deep piled foundations to
withstand blast shockwaves to ensure
continuity of service in case of an explosive
event at the site.
Housed in a single thick blast-proof
container, the substation contains 26 panels
of UniGear ZS1 medium voltage switchgear,
together with protection and control equip-
ment, and back-up batteries.
It was the slimline design of ABBs Uni-
Gear ZS1 that enabled the substation to
t within the connes of a single six metre
standard container. The 50 kA fault rated
ZS1 features front cable access, which
allowed for two front facing rows joined via
a low-level bus-trunking link and a central
walkway. Not only is the six metre standard
container the largest size permitted on UK
roads, any larger and it would not have
fi tted wi thi n the confi nes of the si te
a crucial factor in ABB winning the contract.
The other critical factor was the ability
to deliver the substation within a tightly
dened 32-week project window to meet
LORs planned Turnaround and Inspection
outage.
Raising airport standards
ABB has won two important contracts from
UK Power Network Services airports divi-
sion to supply a total of 16 packaged sub-
station transformers for Heathrow Airport.
A key factor in winning the contract was
that our medium voltage (MV) transformers
installed in the substations have recently
been fully type tested, including rigorous
short circuit tests carried out at an inde-
pendent European test laboratory.
ABB is a well established supplier to UK
Power Networks Services for distribution
transformers that step down the supply
from the airports MV power network to the
low voltage supply required for general use.
Generally, transformer manufacturers are
only required to provide documented proof
of their ability to withstand short circuits
by means of calculations. However, as part
of a new initiative to ensure the reliability
and continuity of critical airport power net-
works, UK Power Networks Services has
called for all its future transformers to be
fully type tested to demonstrate that they
can withstand short circuit conditions.
As the rst transformer manufacturer to
Distribution Substations
ABB has more than 100 years of experience in building and upgrading air and
gas insulated distribution substations around the world. This has provided
ABB with the expertise necessary to deal with all kinds of challenges in the
construction of indoor and outdoor substations.
The refinerys main power distribution substation is housed in a single blast-proof container
25 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
meet the new UK Power Network Services
requirements, ABB was therefore in the
perfect position to be awarded the order
to design, build and deliver 16, 1 MVA
packaged substations for Heathrow Airport,
each comprising a distribution transformer,
close coupled ring main unit (RMU) and LV
cabinet.
Future-proong older MV switchgear
A fast track project saw the completion of
a major contract to improve the safety and
reliability of 60 circuit breakers at eight
Scottish and Southern Energy Power Dis-
tribution (SSEPD) substations on Scotlands
east coast.
With the goal of boosting the safety of
the substations, ABB and its OEM partner
P&B Switchgear carried out a retrot of the
existing oil lled circuit breakers, some of
which date back to the 1950s.
ABB and P&B launched the retrofit
servi ce i n response to Ofgems 2010
introduction of a health and safety index
rati ng of equi pment, whi ch rates the
condition of plant from a low score of 5 to
a high score of 1.
After surveying their equipment, many
DNOs (Distribution Network Operators)
have found that much original switchboard
equipment, such as housings and busbars,
remains in good condition but that the
moving parts of the switchgear are showing
their age, leading to low safety scores.
The servi ce, assessed by the ENA
(Energy Networks Association), can boost
the safety rating from a level 4 to 2, at
the same time as extending the life of the
equipment by 20 years or more and it costs
around 30 per cent less than completely
replacing a switchboard. It can be extended
to equi pment manufactured by GEC,
Reyrolle, South Wales Switchgear, Brush
and many others. Hundreds of retrot and
circuit protection permutations are available.
The project for SSEPD included the
replacement of 60 South Wales Electric
C4X and C8X circuit breakers with retrot
units based on ABBs well-proven Vmax
vacuum circuit breaker. At the same time,
the ratings of the circuit breakers were
upgraded to double the current they can
handle.
A further benet of the retrot project was
that it took as little as four hours to work
on each individual panel. This meant that
the project for SSEPD could be delivered
Distribution substations
with minimal disruption to the substations
operati on and the swi tchboards were
upgraded and operating to higher safety
levels within three months.
James Pierce, ABBs Power Products
Medium Voltage Service Manager for the UK,
said: Thanks to the successful completion
of the ENA assessment process by P&B
Swi tchgear, our OEM partner, we are
currently the UKs rst and only switchgear
supplier to offer an ENA assessed retrot
service for MV switchgear.
Retrofitting can boost the safety rating of switchgear
26 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Site management
Its all about
project delivery
Electrical Installations Manager Chris Hensby explains how
ABBs approach to site management means that his team is
ready to take on any technological and programme delivery
challenge.
01
27 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Site management
W
e have a team of around 50 site
managers, site supervisors and
commissioning engineers who
deliver construction and installation con-
tracts across the UK. Projects range in size
from 1 million to 100 million and up,
covering all sorts of transmission and dis-
tribution technologies, including substations,
generation, small power generation, trans-
mission, distribution, cabling, HVDC and
FACTS, to name but a few.
Site management is about driving the
programme forward while looking after the
site, our client and subcontractors, plus
reporting progress effectively. Its important
to keep a close eye on the work to make
sure the scope and time frames are deliv-
ered as expected. Our site managers protect
the interests of everyone by maintaining
effective control of exactly what happens
on site.
On site, it can be easy to focus on just
the practical aspects of project delivery but
its equally important to make sure that the
contractual side is also well understood,
so our site managers play a vital role in
ensuring that we comply fully with the con-
tract requirements.
A very substantial proportion of the day-
to-day work is focused on health and safety,
including making sure that contractors are
working to the daily briefs, appropriate risk
assessments and method statements and
managing the site induction process.
With such a broad portfolio of projects,
site teams can vary from just a handful of
operatives for a small job to 100 operatives
covering a variety of skills. For example,
for the new 400 kV substation at Connahs
Quay, we have a lead site manager over-
seeing a team of specialists who look after
key aspects such as the mechanical or
electrical build and the commissioning work.
While responsibilities can vary widely,
all of our site managers receive the same
training to ensure the work is delivered to
the required procedures and safety stan-
dards expected within ABB. When projects
interface with third parties coordination and
interface meetings are held with all stake-
holders to ensure all safety and design
issues are addressed.
Theres often a community relations or
an environmental aspect to the work and
well take on that too. One recent example
was where we had waste palisade fencing
at one site, and our site manager arranged
to deliver it and install it at a nearby school.
We also often work with ecologists to survey
for wildlife, such as bats or newts, and take
the appropriate course of action, whether
thats to stop work to avoid nesting bats
or moving wildlife to a place of safety.
Over the years since I joined the team,
it has grown and now includes specialist
site managers, site supervisors and com-
missioning engineers that together offer
unrivalled site management capability for
customers.
The team is also well structured to offer
exceptional career opportunities to support
the development of young professionals.
It is very important that we have both expe-
rienced hands and apprentices coming up
through the ranks. We support apprentices
through a programme of academic quali-
cations and on-the-job training to get the
right electrical and mechanical training and
commissioning experience to develop into
a fully edged site manager in the fullness
of time.
This strong team means that ABBs site
managers are willing to take on jobs the
length and breadth of the country and
deliver new technologies, with recent proj-
ects including substations from 11 kV to
400 kV across the country, solar, protection
and control and even a wave power project
in Orkney.
Much of our work is driven by the out-
ages planned by our clients, which are xed
and immovable. These hard deadlines mean
that ABBs team is focused directly on the
on-time delivery of key project milestones.
And when the project is delivered, we
know that our site delivery team will be
standing alongside the customer, helping
to energise the equipment and bring it
online. This total visibility and responsibility
at every stage, from site preparation to nal
handover, is central to our commitment to
a comprehensive, high quality service that
makes ABB's site delivery team best in
class.
01 ABB has a site management team of
around 50
02 An ABB site with time served AIS and
a new GIS building
02
28 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Innovation
T
raditional substations have been
substantially over-engineered the
logical approach for installations
where the safety and reliability demanded
by clients are paramount. However, the
world has changed and new commercial
imperatives call for a demonstrable return
on investment (ROI). It is now critical to
adopt value-added engineering principles
to achieve a t for purpose design, one
that removes unnecessary costs while
maintaining the essential elements of qual-
ity, reliability and sustainability that ABBs
clients expect.
To implement these value-added engi-
neering principles we keep our substation
design processes under constant review.
This means challenging the norm and ask-
ing searching questions, especially when
it comes to elements that have always
been done this way. ABBs global 145,000
strong workforce gives us the advantage
that we can tap into what the rest of the
worl d i s doi ng and appl y i t i n the UK
context.
The strength of our team is vital to value-
added engineering and it includes senior
engineers with a wealth of experience and
newly qualied engineers, who offer fresh
new ideas. Its a combination that helps
guide our customers to the ultimate value-
added solution a substation project based
on efcient, high quality and sustainable
design. This ensures competitive costs,
shortened delivery schedules, managed
capital investment and improved operational
performance.
A key element in value-added engineering
is to support operational management.
For example, improving system access
and reducing maintenance requirements
can help ensure security of supply. This is
a crucial consideration as an outage that
interrupts customer power supplies could
result in daily losses of around 300k, so
a focus on continuity delivers signicant,
measurable value for our substation clients.
Value-added engineering also reduces
Value-added engineering
the time and red-tape involved in planning
consents by creating designs that need
less infrastructure, smaller wayleave require-
ments and possibly less land to be pur-
chased. Innovative design can also reduce
vehicle movements a traditional AIS
substation might require 40 deliveries to
site, whereas a hybrid PASS switchgear
design can reduce that to three or four
deliveries.
Naturally, we pride ourselves on being
able to deliver ideal customised solutions
for every application. But that is not always
necessary, or desirable. Standardisation of
designs can reduce programme and instal-
lation complexity and signicantly reduce
re-engineering times with a direct positive
impact on health and safety both during
and after construction.
Essentially, ABB is keen to ensure deep
commercial understanding across the board,
and how design directly inuences total
operating costs. This includes not just
capital investment in equipment, but hidden
costs, such as infrastructure and full life-
cycle costs.
For example, a conventional GIS sub-
station design surrounds the equipment
with expensive access gantries and walk-
ways. But now we question if this is really
needed, when temporary equipment could
easily be hired in as and when required,
Leigh Turley, ABB T&D Engineering Manager, explains how ABBs value
added engineering initiative is focused on driving out unnecessary costs
while maintaining quality helping to deliver the optimum cost-effective
substation project.
29 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Innovation
which we know from experience works well
in other countries. Another example is that
substation fencing and cable trenches are
relatively expensive. We can usually reduce
the amount of fencing and trenching with
no compromise of safety and functionality
of the nal design, helping to take out sig-
nicant project costs.
Value added engineering is denitely not
about penny-pinching and we never lose
sight of our quality goals. However, through
the rigorous application of this approach,
ABB is now delivering optimised substation
designs that exceed performance and safety
requirements, while driving down costs
(TOTEX) throughout their entire life-cycle.
Mobile substations move ahead
ABBs new mobile substations are an excel-
lent example of value-added engineering
taken to its logical conclusion. Combining
primary equipment, protection and control
and transformers in an easily transportable
format, they are ideally suited for three key
application areas:
Emergency replacement to ensure
security of supply in cases such as a
transformer failure.
Planned outage management to
keep outages to a minimum when
carrying out essential maintenance
and repair work.
Customer connections for example
to bring a new wind farm or solar
power installation online as soon as
possible so that customers receive
an early return on their investment.
Innovative engineering and intelligent design
enable the mobile substation to be built
and tested off-site, then quickly deployed
to provide reliable and safe connection to
the power grid. This reduces civil works,
installation, testing and commissioning on
site. It also cuts delivery times from months
to weeks and reduces the infrastructure
signicantly compared to a conventional
air insulated switchgear (AIS) substation
bay.
Mounted on a trailer for easy transpor-
tation and deployment with no need for
special licences, the mobile substation is a
hybrid version of an outdoor AIS and a GIS
substation. It is based on ABBs pioneering
PASS (Plug and Switch System) modular
concept, rated at 132 kV or 400 kV, that
combines all the functions of a complete
AIS or GIS switchgear bay circuit break-
er, current transformer, disconnectors and
earthing switch in a single gas-insulated
module. This signicant reduction in the
number of components and moving parts
makes PASS exceptionally compact and
virtually maintenance-free.
ABB mobile substations are fast becom-
ing an important tool for utilities worldwide.
They can be transported by road, rail or air
and quickly deployed whenever and wher-
ever they are needed for periods typically
ranging from six to 10 months, a period
that could allow a wind farm operator time
to obtain planning permission for a perma-
nent grid connection substation. But with
emphasis on a solution that is mobile rather
than temporary, they are fully engineered
for a long service life of over 20 years using
the same technology used in fast-track
permanent substation solutions.
Mobile substations offer the reliability of a fully
engineered solution
30 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Project design
A
ll ABBs customers are unique and
have different drivers for substation
development, when reviewing tender
documentation we aim never to go into
a project with pre-conceived ideas. Our
philosophy is to look at every site on its own
merits. While we often put forward a solution
that follows the initial indicative layout, our
customers are usually very happy for us to
sit down with them to discuss alternative
desi gns that mi ght offer consi derabl e
technical and commercial advantages.
Innovative
substation
design makes
the difference
GIS versus AIS
One example is the choice of switchgear.
When repl aci ng an AI S (ai r i nsul ated
switchgear) substation a like for like AIS
solution could seem the obvious approach.
We often surprise customers when we show
them that a GIS (gas insulated switchgear)
al ternati ve can be onl y sl i ghtl y more
expensive in terms of initial outlay (CAPEX),
and when considering the total cost (OPEX)
of a substation over its 40 year lifespan,
GIS can work out signicantly cheaper, due
to the reduced maintenance requirements
and system reliability.
The classic reason to use GIS over
AIS is when theres a limited installation
footprint available. But GIS can be ideal for
many other reasons. For example, when a
substation needs a signicant amount of
piling. We only need to pile just the small
footprint of the GIS building, as opposed to
a large outdoor AIS site, saving both money
and reducing the programme delivery time.
Its not always possible to use GIS.
Sometimes a customer doesnt want a
building or cant get planning permission for
a building. But we now have innovative AIS
alternatives, such as the compact hybrid
PASS concept. There are some schemes
where weve installed a single bay of PASS
switchgear in place of a conventional H
AIS conguration that would take the space
of a car park.
Disconnecting Circuit Breakers
Another recent innovation is a Disconnecting
Circuit Breaker with Fibre Optic Current
Sensor (DCB-FOCS). The new switchgear
has enabled a combined disconnector,
circuit breaker and current measurement into
a single compact device, which requires less
maintenance than conventional technology,
as it integrates the two switching functions
into a single piece of switchgear and uses a
David Dewitt, Bid Manager Power Systems, explains how
innovation is ABBs way of staying ahead of the competition.
31 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
current measurement technology that does
not require regular recalibration.
Integrating the FOCS with the DCB
reduces footprint while delivering a smart
gri d enabl ed sol uti on that i s vi rtual l y
plug and play and yet flexible enough
to accommodate customer needs. This
makes it ideally suited to new and upgrade
substation applications with the added
benet of enhanced power availability and
reliability.
Because the DCB-FOCS combines the
space-saving aspects of both DCB and
FOCS technologies, the new module has
the potential to reduce the overall physical
footprint of a substation by 60 percent
compared with a conventional arrangement.
It is supplied with standard ethernet cable
connections, which make it simple and
safe to install and operate, while improving
efciency by cutting electro-thermal and
electrical losses. It can be delivered on a
standalone basis or as a component part
of a complete switchgear bay.
Developments in GIS
New developments in more compact GIS
units offer considerable opportunities, as
Project design
at a project in London. The initial scheme
involved a two stage building construction
allowing a phased circuit transfer. We have
been able to devise an alternative arrange-
ment, with all switchgear set out in a dog-
leg conguration tting in just half of the
proposed building. Now the second building
extension is no longer required, saving the
customer both time and money.
Site security
Site security is another important consid-
eration. Copper theft is prevalent on AIS
substations, where its easy for thieves to
target and remove the easily visible copper.
Housing a GIS substation inside a building
with high security doors can eliminate theft
and its associated costs (which of course
include the cost of operational outages,
the price of replacement copper and the
resource to replace it).
Local resourcing
Weve also started with a fresh sheet of
paper with a new wind farm connection
project. Not only are we going the extra mile
in sourcing a high percentage of the project
resource and equipment locally, we also put
forward an alternative technical solution to
the client, which they have adopted.
Although the original scheme was sized
for the wind farm to be operating at 100%
capacity, we put forward the case that wind
farms rarely operate at that level. Instead, we
suggested an alternative design based on
a more realistic wind farm model. This not
only removed one high voltage transformer
from the scheme altogether, but also the
associated switchgear, cables and civil
engineering works. It also enabled the
optimisation of the 10 km underground
cable link, the overall impact on pricing
was a saving in the region of 1 million for
the customer.
Its this willingness to question the norm
that sets ABB apart. Well always look
at a scheme and apply our knowledge
of the latest technology, constraints and
environment. The aim is always to nd the
best overall through-life solution for the
customer in terms of programme, cost and
technology.
32 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Civils and commissioning
Substation
commissioning
the buck stops
here!
ABBs philosophy has taken commissioning from being the
last link in the chain to place it at the heart of the overall
design and construction process.
Site experience is fed back to the design office
33 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Civils and commissioning
C
ommissioning is the critical stage
of any substation design and build
project. It is the rst time that all
the various equipment is tested as a com-
plete entity. The pressure is on to prove
that the project works safely, that it will feed
power at the right levels and the protection
and control systems function correctly. So
it really is a case of the buck stops here
especially when working within a xed out-
age period to get the project signed-off and
handed over to the customer.
Traditionally the industry has regarded
commissioning as the last link in the project
chain from winning the order, developing
the design, carrying out civil works, install-
ing the equipment and then calling on the
commissioning team to prepare it for hand-
over. It was not unusual for the commis-
sioning engineers to arrive on site cold
with little prior project knowledge. They
would then be bombarded for requests for
test schedules, risk assessments, working
documents and so on. Resulting in a great
deal of work being done on the hoof, with
little forward planning.
Documented programme
Clearly, there is a better way to do things.
So our commissioning management team
is set up to deliver a more structured and
ful l y documented commi ssi oni ng pro-
gramme with the aim of ensuring that the
commissioning engineers are fully prepared
when they arrived on site. An important
stage in this process is the development
of a commissioning le for each project.
With some 20-plus sections, the folder
includes accurate documentation of:
Inspection and test plans
Switching programmes
Thermal rating schedules
Stage-by-stage documentation
Protection settings
Emergency return to service
Method statements and risk
assessments.
ABBs commissioning engineers are also
fully integrated within the project design
and installation team. So rather than arriv-
ing on site and trying to make someone
elses design work, they can provide direct
input to the design as it happens, right from
the very start. Not only does this provide
another pair of eyes to review the design,
the feedback of practical site experience
proves invaluable in ensuring that the sys-
tems will function as designed, and can
actually help to shorten the commissioning
process as well. We nd this approach really
helpful in developing the best value-added
solution.
A people business
Naturally, the success of the commission-
ing process comes down to nding the right
people. And we have worked very hard to
build a team with the right qualications,
and authorisations, such as TP141, com-
bined with experience in design, protection
and control and site management. Crucially,
we look for people who do rather more than
just follow a set of rules, who can check
what other people have done, and think
round problems. We also aim to develop a
close working relationship to support the
customer throughout the project and to
understand fully how they like to work.
Planning ahead
The ability to plan ahead is especially impor-
tant when dealing with events such as an
emergency return to service. Sometimes,
for reasons completely out of our own
control, we may lose the outage window
we have taken for example when a fault
occurs at a neighbouring substation. So
whatever stage we are at, the commission-
ing engineers must have a contingency
plan to restore the circuit as quickly as
possible.
Expanded scope
ABBs particular approach expands our
scope to offer extra added-value services
that can relieve some of the burden on the
customer. For example, it was usual for the
customer to develop the switching pro-
gramme to ensure that the new HV equip-
ment was energised safely and correctly.
This can now be performed by the com-
missioning team. Furthermore, we can
ensure safe energisation of LV systems
through the development of our own authori-
sati on process, where commi ssi oni ng
engineers become ABB nominated persons
to carry out the LV switching design pro-
cess, helping to develop the optimum
added-value solution. It greatly reduces the
potential of unexpected design issues aris-
ing on site, so that the commissioning
process runs as smoothly as possible. Most
importantly, it enables customers to be
assured that the commissioning will provide
complete proof that when the substation
enters service, it will function safely and
correctly, exactly as it has been designed.
Complete proof
In summary, ABBs approach to commis-
sioning provides a formalised structure at
every stage, with all the work to be carried
out fully documented and presented for
customer approval before we arrive on site.
It enables site experience to be fed back
into the design process, helping to develop
the optimum added-value solution. It greatly
reduces the potential of unexpected design
issues arising on site, so that the commis-
sioning process runs as smoothly as pos-
sible. Most importantly, it enables customers
to be assured that the commissioning will
provide complete proof that when the sub-
station enters service, it will function safely
and correctl y, exactl y as i t has been
designed.
A commissioning programme provides structure
34 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Skills
Building ABBs
substation team
of the future
Jon Clarke, Engineering Support Manager for Power
Systems, explains how ABB is building its substation
engineering resources at all levels.
Jon Clarke with some of ABBs recent apprentices
35 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Skills
P
lanning for the future is one of the
great challenges for any business,
and although its impossible to
make exact predictions, one thing is for
certain: as a society, were demanding
more of our electricity generation, trans-
mission and distribution systems.
Renewable energy and Smart Grids are
denitely part of the future and well need
smart engineers to deliver them, which is
why we are planning now with a structured
path for attracting and developing talent.
This includes a commitment to encouraging
young people into engineering careers,
through a school outreach programme that
has been running for more than 10 years,
along with our apprenticeship and graduate
schemes.
The rapid pace of technological devel-
opment in recent decades means that
having people with the ability to learn, adapt
and apply new skills is a must-have for
ABB. The business world has never been
more volatile but it is also full of untapped
potential. We are looking for people who
are agile and curious, as well as bright and
willing to move with the company. This both
helps the business succeed and helps our
people develop their own careers.
At all levels of the organisation, we
look to hire and develop talented people.
Through the performance and development
appraisal process, we work with our high
performing employees and provide oppor-
tunities to develop and gain experience in
the UK and overseas, opening up a world
of possibilities.
In 2011, ABB Power Systems ful l y
restructured its apprentice scheme, work-
ing with Newcastle-under-Lyme college in
Staffordshire to create a tailor-made pro-
gramme, which combines real-world expe-
rience with rigorous tuition and guided
study. Those who have joined us on the
programme are now on the road to an
exciting and rewarding career in electrical
engineering. The emphasis is on both
classroom learning and providing practical
experience, and right from the start our
apprentices are involved in working in spe-
cic teams to help deliver projects for ABBs
customers.
Our approach to attracting apprentices
is by building on the school industry days
we hold for 14-year olds and subsequent
work experi ence for 15-16 year ol ds.
Schools that focus on STEM (science,
technology, engineering and maths) subjects
are especially fertile ground for ABB.
Around 16 pupils visit from each of the
schools involved in our industry day pro-
gramme. During these industry days we
challenge them by setting a small project
that gives them experience of considering
technology, plus safety, the environment
and teamwork. At the end of the day, they
give a short presentation on the ndings of
their project together with the lessons learnt.
During the course of these days we are
able to invite those people that have shown
keen interest in the company back the next
year for meaningful work experience and
maintain a link with them to ensure they are
contacted personally the following year to
consider applying to join the apprenticeship
scheme. This has developed into a channel
to attract the most enthusiastic and bright
young talent to join the company.
The apprentice scheme in particular has
created a fantastic level of engagement
across our engineering teams, with estab-
lished staff providing a great deal of input
and encouragement to those undertaking
their studies. Our management team is
actively involved and with many of them
having come through apprentice schemes
themselves, often going on to study at
degree level and beyond, they are keen to
encourage this new generation to follow in
their footsteps.
Classroom learning
36 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Service
Lifetime service for
substation assets
ABB offers a comprehensive service that supports critical transmission and
distribution substation assets throughout their life. The aim is to maintain
substations in optimum performance and avoid costly failures so that our
customers continue to enjoy safe, reliable, efficient and profitable performance
from their assets, large or small, during their lifetime.
Transformer fault analysis
37 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Service
W
e have the people, skills and in-
depth knowledge to cover the
full spectrum of substation asset
service requirements, from routine inspec-
tion of an 11 kV network, right through to
the construction management, installation
and commissioning of a new 400 kV GIS
substation.
Our service is not restricted to equip-
ment supplied by ABB equipment we can
support equipment from just about any
manufacturer across all the major business
sectors including:
power generation
utilities
industrial processes
transport
construction
public sector
renewable energy
data centres.
Supporting distribution networks
ABB speci al i ses i n t he i nspect i on,
maintenance and repair of electrical power
distribution equipment and networks up
to 33 kV for utility, industrial and public
sector customers. Round-the-cl ock
emergency support provides an immediate
response to network problems isolating
the fault, restoring supplies and making a
permanent repair quickly and safely.
Qualied personnel, high-voltage tters
and cable jointers are all ESI trained to the
highest nationally recognised standards
and operate under a set of distribution
safety rules to ensure the reliable and safe
operation of distribution systems.
Using dedicated HV test vehicles, ABB
engineers can identify disruptive and costly
system faults. Permanent faults are precisely
located using a combination of pulse echo,
impulse current and capacitor discharge
devices. Excavation and jointing can then
be carried out to restore the network. To
track intermittent faults, the engineers use
fault burning, equipment with high current,
but low voltage, to accelerate degradation
and make the fault permanent and so easier
to locate.
Getting more from HV assets
ABB can take complete responsibility for the
inspection, maintenance and repair of high-
voltage (HV) transmission assets, as well as
associated control and protection systems.
Specialist engineers ensure that critical
high-value network assets are maintained in
optimum condition to guarantee maximum
reliability, safety and availability.
System support contracts are offered
for generation, utility and industrial trans-
mission customers. These can range from
simple hotline support through to life cycle
agreements.
24/7 system support
ABB offers cost-effective long-term support
for the overall substation. Based on profes-
sional life cycle predictions for products
and systems, including component reliability
calculation analysis, a 24/7 hotline guar-
antees a fast response when needed.
Maximum Transformer
Availability
ABB has a complete portfolio of services
to keep generation, system and grid power
transformers running at maximum efciency
and distribution reliability. We can also co-
ordinate the transport, erection, commis-
sioning and training needed to bring new
ABB transformers safely online as fast as
possible and ensure a smooth hand-over
and a complete after-sales service.
The emphasis is on providing a whole-
life service from installation, through normal
preventive maintenance and repair, and
retrot programmes that can provide an
extra lease of life, to end-of-life manage-
ment with minimum environmental impact.
This portfolio includes:
Understanding your assets
In-depth knowledge of the actual status of
equipment, based on its recorded history,
a revi ew of i ts desi gn and advanced
diagnostic techniques, enables potential
faults to be identied before they happen.
Thi s al so provi des a sound basi s for
the implementation of condition-based
maintenance or corrective action.
Fast repairs
Should a major problem arise, ABB provides
a fast response for repairs such as parts
replacement, tap changer refurbishment
or more extensive work. The usual starting
point in such cases is an in-depth diagnosis
to assess the condition of the unit. Where
possible, all work is carried out on site.
Cable fault location
However, when more extensive work is
required, full factory repair and refurbishment
can be arranged in one of ABBs transformer
repair facilities.
A new lease of life
ABB also offers a transformer remanufac-
turing service that can extend the life of
agei ng or faul ty power transformers,
enabling them to be fully refurbished then
recommissioned. Upgrades in specication
can also be incorporated as part of this
service. As well as being cheaper than a
new transformer, a fast turnaround can
have a transformer back in operation in
around one third of the normal delivery time
for a new unit.
38 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Energy storage
T
he UK power landscape is in a period
of dramatic change. There is a shift
from centralised fossil-fuelled gen-
eration to more distributed and inherently
variable renewable energy sources such
as wind, solar, wave and tidal. At the same
time, loads are changing, including large-
scale data centres, widespread use of air-
conditioning and the deployment of electric
vehicle (EV) charging infrastructure.
These fundamental changes i n the
architecture and controllability of the grid
call for smart, efcient power transmission
and distribution networks. And they require
the storage of energy at appropriate times
The BESS
way forward
and locations both to balance the rapid
change in 'ebb and ow' between genera-
tion and consumption and also to maintain
grid stability.
ABB offers complete battery energy
storage system (BESS) solutions that inte-
grate seamlessly into the power network.
We employ a variety of battery technologies
from world-class manufacturers to ensure
that we deliver the perfect combination of
energy storage and power technologies to
match a customers specic application
needs. BESS can perform a number of
important grid functions:
Frequency regulation
The energy storage system can be charged
or discharged very quickly in response
to fast increases or decreases in load,
maintaining the balance between supply
and demand. This approach to frequency
regulation is a particularly attractive option
due to its rapid response time, the accuracy
of the regulation and the emission-free
operation.
Base load levelling and peak shaving
Base l oad l evel l i ng and peak shavi ng
i nvol ves stori ng power duri ng peri ods
where perhaps renewable energy may be
being produced in excess of demand or
when costs are low and delivering it during
periods of high demand, when costs are
high. This approach can enable the deferral
of investments in grid upgrades or in new
generating capacity and avoids incurring
high power costs for short term peaks.
Power Quality
ABB technology is already used extensively
for the management of reactive power,
the addition of this technology into the
Battery Energy Storage Systems provides
a further dimension the management of
active power. Our power converter systems
have the capability to meet both reactive
and active power needs, providing the grid
with the exibility to manage any situation,
at any time in the daily demand cycle and
for prolonged periods of time.
ABB is building on the success of the
initial project by implementing a new a
Stuart Grattage, Head of Engineering for ABB
Power Systems in the UK, explains how battery
energy storage systems (BESS) can help keep the
grid in balance.
Dynamic energy storage solution
39 FFWD 1|14 Substations special issue
Power Station Load Leveling (Generation Utilization)/Frequency Regulation
Spinning Reserve
Large Residential/
Commercial/
Industrial Loads
Peak Shaving
Capacity Firming
Load Leveling
(Postponement of grid upgrade)
Renewables Voltage Support/Power Quality
110 kV
20 kV 380 kV
20 kV ring
33 kV 110 kV
380 kV transmission line
Load
Energy storage
software algorithm that adds predictive
charge and discharge control capability.
Ongoing trials will then demonstrate the
operation of the site as an autonomous
peak shaving asset.
Comprehensive system approach
Batteri es are based on di rect current
(DC). To connect them to the alternating
current (AC) grids mainly used for power
transmission and distribution requires a
conversion step, using power electronics.
ABB has an outstanding track record in
delivering power electronics systems, such
as our PCS range, that combine excellent
performance with instantaneous response
to create the essential stable interface.
As part of our total system philosophy, we
are also working very closely with our Power
System Network Management (PSNM)
team to take BESS control systems to the
next level to ensure that energy storage
is fully integrated within the overall grid
management system.
Furthermore, through Ventyx, the leading
enterprise software specialist that joined the
ABB Group in 2010, we are adding a new
dimension to energy storage as part of an
overall smart grid solution. By gathering
information from the wider network, we are
evolving energy storage beyond the simple
on or off approach to enable intelligent
management of power ows.
Overall, building an efcient, reliable
and durable BESS calls for a range of key
technologies and competencies from
circuit breakers and transformers through
batteries and power electronic conversion,
on through system- and grid-level control,
to smart forecasting. ABB can provide all of
these from a single source as demonstrated
in these current projects:
The Alaska BESS
The Golden Valley Electric Association
(GVEA) operates and maintains around
5,000 kilometers (km) of transmission and
distribution lines and 35 substations in the
Alaska region.
In 2003, ABB applied implemented
battery storage technology, combined
ni ckel -cadmi um batteri es wi th power
converters to create a spinning reserve
solution that provides back-up electricity
for GVEA when necessary. Recognised by
Guinness World Records as the worlds
most powerful battery system, it can supply
power at 27 MW for 15 minutes or 46 MW
for 5 minutes, which allows ample time for
local generation to come online.
Switzerlands largest battery energy
storage project
ABB recently commissioned the largest
battery energy storage project of its kind
in Switzerland with EKZ, a leading distribu-
tion utility and one of the largest energy
companies in Switzerland.
To enable additional power to be provided
to the grid on demand, ABB supplied and
installed a battery energy storage solution
using Lithium-ion (Li-ion) batteries that can
provide 1 MW of power for 15 minutes.
The storage facility is integrated into
EKZs power distribution network and is
being used to evaluate performance in key
areas such as balancing peak loads and
intermittent power supply, and the viability
of the solution for grid optimisation.
Dynamic energy storage
installation in the UK
ABB worked with UK Power Networks,
which supplies power to over eight million
homes and businesses in the UK, to develop
a dynamic energy storage solution for a
substation site in Norfolk. The installation,
commissioned in 2011, enables renewable
energy generated by local wind power plant
to be fed into the power network when
needed. It also ensures that some of the
energy is kept in reserve to regulate power
ow to compensate for the intermittence
of wind power and to support power quality
in the event of a fault.
To meet these needs, ABB implemented
a turnkey DynaPeaQ
solution incorporating
SVC Light