Teepexoii paiiounsiii cya ropoaa Mockser Aapokaros Mockosckoii Koasieruu aqpoKaToR «(panes 1 Haptnepsp Xaputonosa I.B., Opeumuxonoii E.A. P. Mockna, 1-ii Poayreunckuit nepeyaoK, 1.1, 3¢ OAL «omye», ocpuc 9, Tea. 739-2523 sgh 13 HOR 2008 NP MYRTO na JeiicTBHA caexoBaTesA No 0coG0 BAAHBIM aeaam CK npu MBJI Poccun Maiiopa ocTumun Crab4enko O.@. sammy Marnurexoro C.J. nto yronoBuomy seay Ne311578, Bbizeaennomy H3 yros1opHoro esta N2153123 HKAOBA (p nopsake cr. 125 YK P®) B npowsposicree crapuiero csletoBaTesiA 10 0coG0 BaXKHBIM esIAaM CreseTBEHHOTO komureta mp MBJl Pd matiopa wcruuun Cuib¥eHKo O.@. HaxouTea yromopHioe se0 10 oGBHHeHHIo MarnutcKoro C.JI. B CoBepLeHMH MpecTyruIeHHs, mIpenycmorpenioro 4, 2 cr. 199 YK P®. 16 oxts6pa 2009 roga Marautckomy C.JI. oGpapieno 06 oKoHyaHHH npeaBapurembHoro caeactBus u 20 oKTaGps 2009 rona, B COOTBETeTBHH co CT. 217 YIIK PO, npenbspsenist B MpOUIKTOM 1 IpoHyMepoBAHHOM BHse MaTepHastbl yrouopioro sles1a. Tip npexbasnenmu matepwanos yrososvoro jena 3amMta mM oGBHHReMBIii Marnurcknit C.JI. o3HaKOMHsIHcb ¢ HUMH, Nocse 4ero MarnureKHii C.JI. citesat 3aBIICHHE, 3aHeCeHHO€ B MIPOTOKON, B KOTOPOM, B 4aCTHOCTH, yka3alT: «TIpeXbaBneHHble MH CeroaHA MaTepHasbi yrouOBHOTO jlesIa CUIMTEI B TOMA, [IPH 9TOM KONA KarksOrO AOKYMeHTa cesoBaTesem CHiTbYeHK 0.0. He SaBepeHa, a NoMMMcAH THU NocKeaHHit nycTO! AMCT KaKLOTO TOMA c yka3aHeM HoMepa ToMa. ... ToMa CUIHTEI CI1OCOGOM, He HCKIIOYAIOLLUM 115 cnenoparens © CHNbHeHKO — BOMOKHOCTH — 3aMeHsITh —M_—_OGaBIATS slOKyMeHTSD». 22 oxtaGpa 2009 roya 3aumTa nonyanna or cienopatena Cunbuenko O.0. nomyio Konmi0 Toma Ne2, 0 eM cocraBnena pacrincka, HaxonAuaIcA y eneqoparens. 09 nosGpa 2009 r. caeqopatens Bapranios HLA. npextoxna Marnurcxomy C.J. Jui osHakoMuenus Tom Ni2 yrosioBHoro esa Ne311578, KoTOpsiii cyulecTBeHHOormnyaetcs or Toma Ne2 Toro x%*e yrosloBHoro jena H Apyrux ero TOMOB, MpenbABAIBUINXCA eMy 1 3aLLNTe 20 oKTAGps 2009 r. cnenoBaTeseM ['puutali P.A. Tak, sce npenbapassumecs MarnutcKomy C.JI. 20 oxra6pa 2009 r. Toma, BKuovad Tom Ne2, He MMe O610KEK, HH OHA 13 KONI, COMepKABUINXCA B TOMAX JOKYMeHTOB, He ObUa 3aBepeHa TyTeM I1pocraBIeHKA CoorBeTeTBy!OULell OTMeTKH H MloANHcH 3aBepsioulero AMMA HeMlocpenCTBeHHO Ha KOTHH KaxKOrO MOKYMeHTa, BMeCTO 9TOTO B KaKIOM TOMe 3a MocseAHHM ero ANCTOM GpLIA noguita cTpaniua ¢ nogmicantbm cheaosarerem Canpdenko O.®. saipnernem © KomMMecTBe NPOMIMTEIX H MPOHYMepoBaHHbIxX JOKYMetTOR B TOMe HO RepHocTH KONMii AOKYMeHTOB, KOHLI Ckpernmouel Kaxsbti TOM GeyeBKH Gb MpHkneewsI K TaKOH Crpakue HCTOM Gextolt Gymaru c newatbio NY? CK MBJL Po. Mpeabapsenteii Maraitecomy CJL. 09 Hos6p1 2009 r. tom Ne2 nomemten B pasrpadsennyio, Ho C MYCTBIMH, He3anonHeHHDIMH rpadani OOIOKKY 43 IJIOTHOTO KApTOHA, B KOTOPy!O NpenbABIABUIHTiCs 20 oKTsGps 2009 r. TOM He Mor Seite BUNT Ges ero pacuiMBaHHs. Jror, npexbaBnenHbili MarautcKomy C.JI. 09 Hosp 2009 r. Tom No2, cum HuTKoii, a He GeueBKoii, B Hem oTcyTeTRyeT NOCHE CTPAHMLLA C MONMCAHHBIMA calenoBaTeteM CHuIb¥eHKo 0.0. 3aBICHHIMH O BepHOCTH KONAMI H KomHYecTBe MHcTOB. Ha Kaxuoli crpannute npestoapsienHioro 09 HosGps 2009 r. Toma Ne2 croat orcyTeTBoBaBIUHe Ha BCeX crpannuax Toma Ne2, npeapapaspuserocs 20 oxta6pa 2009 r.: a) nevarb N°7 CK MBJI PO; 6) urramn MBJI Pocenst CK c ormerkoii «komma pepra) B) Ybe-TO WMS, BHO He aBNaIOMeecA UMeHeM CHIBYeHKO O.., nognuce 6e3 ykasaHisi pan, HMeHH, oTdecTBa M aOmkHOCTH sMUA, nocrapBuiero 3Ty NosHcb. Takum o6pa3om, Matepuasbi yronosHoro jena Ne311578, ¢ KoTopsmnat Mariitrekomy C.J]. B Hacrosiliiee BpeMs mpemtarair 3HaKOMHTSCH, He iBAAIOTCA TeMH CaMBIMH MaTepHanaMH, KOTOpbe MpetbsBisinc 20 oKTaGpa 2009 r., MOcKOABKY OHH, O4CRHAHO, OTAMHAIOTeA MO CHOCOSY NOATREPKNeHHA BepHOCTH BKIOYCHHBIX B MaTepHaitb KOMIHii, HHO crocoby noauIMBaHHs, HB OGOHX cay4asX MarepHassl GbUIH CUIMTS CTOCOGOM, He HCKMOYAIOULUM BOsMOXKHOCTH Hx pacuIMnAHHs, AoGaBAeHHs, yilaNeHHA HI 3aMeHbI OAHHX OKYMeHTOR ApyruMu, B cBsaH ¢ 9THM 3aulTa He HCKMO4aeT BOIMOxHOCTH Toro, 4TO 3TH MaTepHaLI pasIMYalOTes H 10 Comep»kaHHto. Ha octonanim manoxeHHoro, nockosbky MaTepHasisi yrononHoro ena Ne3 11578, ¢ Koroppimn Marunteknii C.JI. 8 Hacrosilee BpeMa 3HaKOMHTCA, OTAMMAIOTCA OT npenbaBreHHbix eMy 20 okTa6ps 2009 r., sauurTa 3anpaseT 0 TOM, 4TO 20 oKTAGPA 2009 r. o6sitisemomy Marnutckomy C.JI. 1 3auTe npeabaRasuIich COBCeM HHbIe MaTepHasl yronoBHOrO Jena, 3HAYHTesIbHO OTIMHAOUINeCA OT MaTepHasIOB je, IpeAbABNEHHBIX ANA O3HAKOMIIEHHA 9 HosGpa 2009 roga.Yeasannble xelicraHa opraHos mpexbapHrenbHoro cnenerBHa rpyGo Hapyuraror TOpsOK O3HaKOMeHHA OGBHHsAeMOrO H ero 3aLLUITEI ¢ MaTepHanaMHt yromoBHOTO fea, YoTAHOBNeHHBI BIaHMOCBAIAHHLIMH MOMOKeHHAMH cTaTeli 215 H 217 YOK Po, 3 comepxKaHa KOTOPBIX cuesyeT, TO CHeOBATEAD, MpHsHAB, ATO BCE cnenctRenHbie xelicraHa mo yronoBHOMy seny nporsBemeHsi, a coOpanupie MOKaRATENBCTRA TOCTATONHBI [UIA COCTABNEHHA OOBHHUTeMbHOFO 3akmMONeHHA, yBeMOMiseT 06 9TOM OOBHHKeMOTO H PasbACHAeT EMy MpaBO Ha O3HaKOMATeHHE CO BeeMH MaTepHanlaMH yronosHoro jlea, H BMocaeAcTBHM —npesaARAIeT Hx OOBMNAeMOMY H ero 2ALLATHUKY B MIOALITOM HM MpoHyMepoBantiom Bue. Mpexcrapnseres, To noxoGHOH opmysMpoBKoll 3aKOHOZATeT OAHOSHAIHO He MpelycMarpupaeT BOsMOXKHOCTh pacuIMBaHA HM H3MeHeHHA conepKaHHA MaTepHa1OB, MpeAbABEHHLIX OOBHHAEMOMY, B IIPOTHBHOM Cily4ae AAHHa HOpMa nlorepsia Gb BeaKHii cMBica. Mave, B Xoge BbillomHeHa TpeGonannii cr. 217 YIIK Po, cneqosarens B HapyieriMe mpusnuna coctsszatembHoctH cTopoH, Mor 6bI MeHsTS HM LONOAHATS AOKa3aTeNbCTBA 110 AeNy, sIMMIAA OOBHHAeMOTO H ero 3aLITTY Mpaba Ha OSHAKOMIIEHHe ¢ COGPAHHBIMH M10 Jey LOKasaTeMbCTBAMH. VaMenenna, BHeceHHBIe B MaTepHambt J[e:1a B Mpouecce O3HaKOMIeHHA C HHMH OGpHHseMOrO H eFO 3alllNTbI, CBHeTENCTBYIOT O TOM, 4TO yBEOMMIEHHE 06 OKOHMAHHM CreCTBEHHBIX AeficTBHit H IpeTbsABeHHe OOBHINeMOMY MaTepHastoB YronoBHoro ge ABHNOCH MpexeBPeMeHHbIM H, CHeAOBATEMbHO, 1e3aKOHHDIM, Tak Kak MaTepHanbl clencTBeHHOro mpoHsBogcTBA He GUTH cHcTeMaTH3HpoBatibL 1 MOAMUHTEI Hae KAMMM OGpa3oM K HaXasy BbITOTHEHHA TpeGowaHHit cr. 217 YIIK P®. Kpome toro, noxo6ubie JlelicrBis Mory’ ObITb pacueHeHibi Kak HonbITKa opration CAeACTBH BOCTOAHHTS HeAOCTATOK COOpaHHbIX AOKAIATEMBCTB MO Ley, 4TO MIpaMo mpoTHBopeynzo 6b1 TpeGowaHMam cr. 215 YIIK P@, cornacto KOTOpbIM K MOMeHTY Havasia OsHAKOMJeHHIA CO BCEMH MaTepHaslaMH TIO nemy BCe OKAaxATeNBCTRA CAETORATETEM AOIKHBI OBIT COOPAHBI H ABMITHCA AOCTATOUTDIMEL JUIA COCTaBeHHA ORUHMTeMbHOFO 3aKMONeHHA. Yronostio-npoueccyatbHoe 3akoHOTATeABCTBO He MIpemyCMATpHBaeT AONOAHENHE MaTepHaion cHeACTRHA B MIPOllecce O3HAKOMIeHHs C HUMH, 3a HCKTIONCHHEM caydaes Moga cootReTeTByIoMINX XosaTalicTB, 3asBIeHHDIX OHUM 13 yuacTHHKOB MpoH3BouCTBA NO aeny B nopamKe cr. 219 YIIK P®. [pu 9tom Cuenoparesb OGs3aH, B cooTBercrBHH c 1. 2 ykaIAHHOli CraTbH yRenoMHTH 06 DTOM JAPYTHX YHACTHHKOR, H MpeMOCTARAAeT HM BOIMOXKHOCTS O3HAKOMICHHA C HOMOAHMTENBHBIMH MaTepHasiaMn yronoaHoro wena. CaederBeHHbIe opranbi He yBenOMasaH HH OGsHiAeMoro MarnutcKoro C.JI., HH ero 3allLHTY, 0 KAKHX-1160 MOCTYNMBUIHX XOmaTalicTBAX, B CBAIH C KOTOPDIMH GOBLIN MpOHsBeLeHBL AONOTHUTeNbHBIE JelicTBHA, a MIPOH3BONBHOe ONONHeHHe cieqoRaTenem MaTepitasion gesia HedonycTHMO B cHaly yKasantbix HopM YIIK PO. Jlansias nosnuna HaxomuT cBoe orpaxenue B Onpenerenun Konerutyumonnoro cya P® or 16 mona 2009 r. N 979-0-O, Koropsiii, paccmorpes sKas106y rpaxknaiuna wa otcytcreue B ct. 217 YIIK Pd o6ssareaboro tpeGopanuaTIpeMbABHTS OGBHHAEMOMY HM efO 3aLLMTHHKy Henocpencrsento B Havaie O3HAKOMICHHA C YTONOBHBIM jeOM Be MaTepHaTBI B TOAHOM oGbeme, yeranosua: «Yacts neppas crarbi 217 YIIK Poccuiicoit eqepanun coneprKuT AlpecoBaHHoe cileMoparemo TpeGoBaHHe MpexbaBHTh oGBHHiKeMOMy mM ero SALIMTHMKY MOWIMTBIe H MpoHYMepopanuble MaTepHanbt yrosoBHoro jesta. Tpit dTOM B chy cTarbH 219 Toro x%e KojeKca B XoJe O3HAKOMeHHA OOBAHAEMOTO 1 €TO 3aLMHTHHKa C YFOTOBHBIM eNOM He HICKMOYAeTCA AOMOAHEHHe 9TOTO esa HOBBIMH MaTepHanaMH, OHaKO ToNbKO MPH HaNHHHH coorBercTByiouLero xoulatalicrba (4acTb MepBas) H MPH NocnestyiouleM yBeAOMseHHH OOBHHAeMOTO H €FO 3AallLHTHHKA 0G OKOHNAHHH MpOHSROACTBA JOMOMHHTeNbUBIX. cHeNCTBEHHBIX xelicteiii M mpemocrapieniM HM BOIMOKHOCTH O3HAKOMMTBCA C TOMy4eHHDIMIE Matepanamu (4acT BTopas). CoorBeteTBeHHo, camo no ceGe ocnapHBaemoe JAKOHONOOKEHME HE MpeANONaraeT BOIMOKHOCTS NPOHIBOABHOTO sOTOMEHHA MatepHaslop YFoTOBHOTO jle1a H O3HAKOMEHHA OGBHHAeMOTO H ero 3AILIITHHKA Cc MaTepuastaMH lea B HeTlonHOM oSbeMen. Takum o6pasom, o6:karyemme jlelicraust creqonaTens, 110 cyTH H3aMeHHBUIerO MH BOIMOAHO AONOANUBMTO AOKYMeHTHL, NpeTABLEHUBIE OGRUHeMOMy Maruutecomy C.J. 4 ero 3aumtre 20 oxraGps 2009 roa, aBamoTes HesaKoHNLIMH, rpyGo HapyuaroT mpaBo OGBHHseMOrO Ha OGbeKTHEHOE paccsledoBaHHe yrosoBHOro Ae-1a, a TAKA HA TOcyAApeTBeHHY1O H cyAeGHyO 3aMlNTY CBONX MpaB H cRoGoa, rapanTHponanuEx cratbamn 45 1 46 Koncrutyunu Poceniickoii @exepai, m npoTHBopeyaT npununnam YFoaoBHoro cyonponsnorcTBA, MpoBOsraAMAIOMHX cOCTHaTeTbHOCTE HM papnonpanue cropon. Ha ocHopaHiM H310%KeHHOrO H pyKoBoxeTRyscb cr. 125 YIIK Pb, TIPOCHM: 1. TIpusnare HesaKoHHbIMH nelicTBHA cnetoBaTess 110 OcoGo BaXKHBIM 2esaM Caegcraensoro Komuteta np MBJI P® Cuneienko O.®. 10 w3menenno 1 HOMIONHEHHIO MaTepHaTOB YroNOBHOTO jeEa NocHe NPeADIBNEHHA HX K o3HakommeHiio. OGs3aTe cnegonaters Cunpucnko 0.0. ycrpanure aonymennie HapylueHHta H BEITIOTHHTh TpeGoRanns cr.cr. 215, 217 YIIK P®. R Tpuioxenne: Opaepa agpoxatos Xaputorosa J.B. 1 Opeuminxopoii E.A. 3amumrnukn Marnutexoro C.J. Aaoxater J.B. Xapuronon E.A. Opeumimxona