Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 128

Yroroanun npoecc

Kpnunnarncnxa
1eopnn onepanano-poaucxnon enerunocn
Cye6nan axcnepnaa
Cye6nan aracu
Ppoxypopcxnn naaop
Oprannaann npaaooxpannerunon enerunocn
Aaoxaypa
Brxxcrcnr
Vpaxrcroro orcxcnnn
Mcnynapono
accounaunn
coccrunn npauocynr
2010 N 1 (3
Hoy:uoc usoouuc
\

O

M
A
C
l
Yparucxoe oerenne
Heynaponon acconann
coencann npaaocyn
2
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ceueu YpO MACH
2010 w 1 /3)
Peaxnonnan xorrernn:
npoq. B. C. Earaxunn
npoq. B. H. Eoapoa
npoq. h. H. Boronna
npoq. A. P. lycuxoaa
npoq. A. A. aareoa
npoq. h. B. panxnn
h. A. 3aurnnnn
o. K. E. Karnnoacxnn
npoq. A. B. Kypnaeaa
npoq. 3. B. Haxapoaa
npoq. A. . Ppournxoa
npoq. A. B. Cunpnoa
npoq. H. P. Copoxonrnn
Ppeceaeru pexorrernn
J. H. /puuuu,
-p pn. nayx,
npoq. xaqepu xpnunnarncnxn YplkA,
aacryennun eneru nayxn PO,
noenun pa6onnx npoxypaypu PO,
ren Heynaponon acconann
coencann npaaocyn
Koopnnaop npoexa
J. A. Sumuuu,
xan. pn. nayx,
npenoaaaeru xaqepu
xpnunnarncnxn YplkA,
noenun aaoxa PO,
ren Heynaponon acconann
coencann npaaocyn
62O149, Exaepnn6ypr, an 294,
zashnall.ur.ru
8-9O8-635OO16
http:zash.web.ur.ru
Bunycxaunn ueneep
T. I. Mouuu
8-9O4-9898353
vlp-uralyandex.ru
Peaxop B. B. .Buuu
Bepcxa J. A. XiupeBo
naann o6roxn A. K. TmeueBo
Ponncano a neau 12.O2.2O1O.
Oopua 1O 1OO16.
Eyuara oqcenan.
Ycr. ne. r. 1O,4.
lapnnypa Acadeny.
1npa 6OO axa. 3axaa
Oneaano a nnorpaqnn Arpaq
62OO34, Exaepnn6ypr,
yr. Koruoropoaa, 31O6.
1oxn apennn, npecaarennue a caunx,
narncn naynuun noannnun aaopoa
n uory ne coanaau c oxaun apennn
renoa peaxnonnon xorrernn,
xoopnnaopa n nnnnaopoa
naannn 6rreenn
Haanne nnnnnpoaano
yparucxnun renaun HACP
(npoqeccopaun n npenoaaaernun
xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca YplkA),
ocyuecareno aaopaun
na co6caennue cpecaa,
6rreenu pacnpocpannecn aaopaun
3aurnnnn h. A., cocaarenne, 2O1O
Haanne 6rreenn ocyuecareno
npn noepxe cana
Heynaponon acconann coencann
npaaocyn (HACP), Canx-Peep6ypr
(http:luaj.net)
n xouunnn YpO HACP, Exaepnn6ypr
(http:connunlty.llvejournal.conuro_nasp)
Konnpoaanne n pacnpocpanenne 6rreenn
n caen 6rreenn a r6on qopue
aanpeuaecn. Py6rnxann caen nnuun
naannnun uoe ocyuecarnucn
oruxo a cooaecann c nornouonnun,
noryennuun o aaopoa caen n cocaanern
a nopnxe, ycanoarennou
rpaancxnu aaxonoaerucaou
J
[O. c(cxxcruu| .......................................................................... 5
Momcpuo:m noucpcuuu Y:o:oeuo-npocccyo:vum
sonou dc lcgc [crcndo
lc.oe C. C. lcxc: cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a \lK IU......................................... 6
lc:ooeo:ocuu M. C. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a
a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac: uanaaxcuua
ccacacuc.acaauua naacacrc cryxucaauua .................. JJ
lo+co+ A. B. lcxc: xaccuuaquu ync_cuu:x
cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu c: .................................................... 2O
B{oeqce H. B. ,c+uauuc a cacc.ca.cx:uaa ca
nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua: uc.cua ac+uuucacuua
u a+au.ua ........................................................................ 26
Bo:o{uno . M. laac ua (cc.yn naaccy(u ................ JJ
lc+on O. B. K acnccy c ncqcccyax:ucu a.uaucc.u
ucacrc cy(:u nu ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcau: (cxa
+ac.ucrc cauucuua .......................................................... J6
lcooeo A. H. K acnccy c nucucuuu ycccuua
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca......................................................... 4O
dom:+nun . A. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a cy(c oc |cc
}cccnoo ............................................................................ 45
dunom::un d. d.. Lmonoeo 7. B. Dc |cc }cccnoo
nc \lK IU ................................................................... 5J
Heonoe B. .. lo:omnuoeo C. B. Cy(cuaa axac.:
uy(ac.ca a uac.ca_cu ccc ..................................... 56
lu{uno H. A. lcqcccyax:u:c nccxc(c.aua uayacuua
c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu ..... 6O
Momomun B. H.. l.o+uce O. H.. Momomun B. B.
Kcxxu+uu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x uc,
cccnc+uaa_ux c+cnacucc.: (cncca c:.:x
y+ac.uuca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa .......................................... 66
Cocpnannc
4
Momuno . B. Mc(uaqua a yrcxcauc ncqcccc ~
cuacuquax:uaa ca auccy(cucrc a+cacuua
yrcxcauc-naaca:x cncca ............................................... 75
Hoeuoeo K. l. Occcuucc.u yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu
(ca.cx:ucc.u a c.ucacuuu ccy(cuu:x xuacuu
cacc(:............................................................................ 79
O:qoe H. B. lcxc: ac+y(cuua yrcxcau:x (cx
u ncac(cuua cnc.u:x uccxc(caauuu a c.ucacuuu
c+ acc.u ncnaaaux xuq u uccnc+uauu:x .ynca........... 82
Ho:o{un C. l. Kcuqcnqua a+au.ua ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa
a ccc.a+a.cx:uc yrcxcauc ncqcccc ............................. 87
Hc A. l. Kcuqcn.yax:u:c ccuca: uuc.u.y.a +a(cauua
a yrcxcauc ncqcccc Iccnyxuu lcxayc: .................. 94
7omo+nuno . l. aaaxcuuc xc(a.auc.aa c +ax+cuuu
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac: acncc:,
cc.aaaucca c+ c.ac.a ...................................................... 98
7cncuno E. 0. O cxu ncyca nu +ax+cuuu
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac
a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy ............ JOJ
Kcno . B. Bc.c a+au.ua yrcxcaucrc naaccy(ua
nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux a ccaccuucu Icccuu ... JOJ
Bmceo 7. B. Ccacacuc.acaauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa
c c(yuac(uc cc.y(uu+cc.ac a ccc ca+auua
naacacu ncc_u nc yrcxcau: (cxa ......................... JO8
Momcpuo:m onmyo:vumx uuoueuoyo:vumx ucc:cooeouu
{ceoooouou mc:omuno)
Heonoe H. B.. lomuun A. . acu uxu cnca.uaucc.:' . JJ2
ln+.oun A. . O.(cx:u:c acnc.: a uccxc(caauuu
xu+ucc.u cacuuua ua :uc qcuu:x yar ................ JJ6
Lo:oo M. A. K acnccy c ucncx:+caauuu
uc.a(uqucuu:x au(ca cnc.u+ nu accxc(caauuu
yrcxcau:x (cx ................................................................. J2O
Momcpuo:m npumu:ccno uonpoe:cuuocmu {pccusuu
u omsmem)
dom:+nun . A. H(cu a+au.ua .ccuu a(aca.ccrc
ac.cc.aa [Icqcu+ua ua cucrau C. l. Kaaxauaua
Cuc.ca nccccucuax:ucu cnc.cu.ucc.u a(aca.a
(M., 2OO8)| ..................................................................... J25
[O cxc(y_c uccc| ........................................................ J28
5
lcc( aau ` J lxxc.cua \ax:ccrc c.(cxcuua Mc-
(yuac(ucu acccquaquu cc(cuc.aua naaccy(u, a:ny_cuu:u
a cac. xarc(aa c.c(uucuu uay+ucu a.uaucc.u aa.cca (au-
ucrc u+(auua.
lrc crauu+aqucuucu cuqcnqucu, a u nc(c, aaxac.ca
uay+uaa cacc(a. H+acc.u:u y+cu:u aa(cu ^. C. lcr c.-
c+ax: Haya +.u. cacux (yxcau:x ac(cu, cacux Auc.c.cxcu,
Kcncuuca, H:.cuca, ^ccuccca:x, ^aaya+:c u Kau.ca, uc uc
.acu. ccc u+ uux yuca. Ka(cc u+ ux ncxccuuu cc.
:.: ccnauaacc.... O+cau(uc, +.c u a uayc yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca uc.uua uc cc. :.: c-.c cy.c.uauc nc(cacua,
a c(ac.ca a c+yx:.a.c cnca (cxxc.uaucu cqcuu).
B cccnc+cuuc .crc a u+(auuax uaacu acccquaquu, ac(y_cu
ua+axc c. cuccuquu 5O xc. ac(c yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
\lKA (CKH) u c.c+a_cu cacu na.uxc.uuu uxcu, acc
c.a.:u nyxuy.ca a axaau.uc nca(c, nu .c a(:u u+
y+ac.uuca ca nuuuac. cacuuc c a:ucccuuu cacux u(cu ua
cy( ccc_cc.aa u cnc(cxac. cy, a c.ccu cuu y(y. nc(-
c.aaxcu:. lxxc.cu: nu .c a:ncxuac. cyuuaqucuuy
yuqu. Oqcua u(cu u ux arycu.ca, cxc(caa.cx:uc, cc.: +a-
(a+a accrc uay+ucrc ccc_cc.aa u cxxc.uaucrc (ucyca a uc.
B .c cy.: ncc.cauucu c(cuu+aquu ~ aaucuacrc cacuc.aa
u(u+cccu uayu.
Cc(cauuc .c.:crc ucca ccc.aaxa. a.cuax: cuc-
cuquu \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u +acu oc |cc }cccnoo (la-
.cuuyr, 2J caaxa 2OJO rc(a). Kcc .crc, a ucrc ax+cu:
cuqcn.yax:u:c a+(cx: cacc(ucu u u.u+cccu .ca.uu,
+.c .ac (ac. cxxcra ac+cucc.: caxu+aquu caccu uay+-
ucu cacc(:.
lc+(aaxac accx +xcuca MACl, uuuqua.cca u cc+(a.c-
xcu (auucrc uay+ucrc ccc_cc.aa c crc na.uxc.ucu rc(ca_uucu
u ua(ccca ua (ax:ucuacc cc.y(uu+cc.acl
. B. onun. . A. dom:+nun
Yeooc:mc no::c:u!
6
Momcpuo:m noucpcuuu
Y:o:oeuo-npocccyo:vum sonou
dc lcgc [crcndo
C.a.:a 5 \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c(cca Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu ((axcc ~ \lK) cc(cu. cx:acc cxu+cc.ac
aaucuaux ncqcccyax:u:x ncua.uu, c.c:c +acuc(a.cx: c+cx
uccxc(u: +acnu.: ucnccc(c.acuuc a .cc.c +acua aau(y
ux +ua+ucc.u. O(uac cc(u uux uc uaaxcc: cc.a cnc(cxc-
uu nuuquna yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. Ia+ac.+uu
\lK cc.axuc: acu: nc(xc(y, a ccc.ac.c.auu c c-
.c: uu a c(uc u+ ncqcccyax:u:x +acuca (c-
cacxqucuucu u ccac.ccu Icccuu uc nuac(u-
xcc: .c ncua.uc. Cxc(caa.cx:uc, nuua.uc \lK
uc nuacxc a+cacuu cy_cc.acaaaacu ua nc-
.acuuu ucrux xc. ncxc: cnc(cxcuua u.c-
uca c.ucccuua .crc uxu uucrc ccucacncxara_crc
ncqcccyax:ucrc ncxccuua +ucxy nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca.
Bcc.c c .c \lK cc(cu. ucacxxy, cy_cc.acuuc c.xu-
+a_y crc c. accx nc(acc.acuuuca: ac a.ccu rxaac +a-
cnxcu ncc+cu: ncxccuuu, c.ucca_uxca, nc ucuu crc a+-
ac.+uca, nuuquna. Haxu+uc .acrc ncc+ua, .c uc cucc,
uc nc+acxac. c(cxa.: c(uc+ua+u:u a:ac( c .c, aaxac.ca xu cu
C. C. Ecspynoe
Hpo6xcmr cncrcmr npnnunnou
yroxounoro cyonponsuocrua
u VHK P0
Cepre Cepreeuun Beapyuou,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx, oen,
naarunnx xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
Pepucxoro qnrnara Pneropocxon axaeunn
HB Poccnn
bezrukovserqeypernranbler.ru
7
uc+cn:aa_u uxu nc(xcu. acauu.cx:-
ucy .cxcaauu, a .ac c .c, +.c ucuuc
c.axc ccucaauuc nu+ucxcuua nuuquna
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa .cx uxu uu:x
ncxccuuu.
lucuu.cx:uc yry nuuqunca yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa A. A. ,aaxc.ca cu-
c.a.uyc., +.c a xu.ca.yc cuu nc(xaraxuc:
+ucxc c. ccu (c (aa(qa.u u cxcc u ac accx
cxy+aax +aaaxaxuc: aa.cau a ccc.aaxa-
_uc cuc.cy, .c cc.: c.c.uauc uccxc(u-
y ccacynucc.: aau:x xccu.ca, ca+y-
_ux a cacc c(uuc.ac qcxcc
J
.
l:.aac: a+ca.:ca a nu+uuax .acrc
cuxua nc(xc(ca, 1. H. ,ccacx:caa c.c-
+ac., +.c nu cyxucaauuu cuc.c nuu-
qunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca uc accr(a y+u.:-
aac.ca, ac-nca:x, .c, +.c nuuqun: ~ .c
.cx:c uaucxcc c_uc u ucxc(u:c ncxcc-
uua; ac-a.c:x, c.c.uauaa cycxcaxcuucc.:
cc(cauua .ux nuuqunca; a-.c.:ux, ucc-
xc(ucc.: auaxu+a .ux uc c .c+u +cuua
ux ncxuc.:, ucnc.uacc+uacc.u, a+auucu
uc+aaucucc.u u acc.c c .c ux a+auccaa+u
(yr c (yrc. Hcuuc ua .cu nc+ac, nc cc
ucuu, u a:ccxu (ac (uac.ax:uc nc.u-
acncxcu:c .cu(cuquu: .cu(cuqua +c+c-
ucy acaucuu +ucxa .cx ncxccuuu, c.c-
:c (cxu: :.: nu+uau: nuuqunau...
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, u .cu(cuqua uccccuc-
aauucy cycuu yra .ux ncxccuuu
2
.
lu .c 1. H. ,ccacx:caa ya+:aac.
ua uc(ca+yccc.: c.ucccuua ncxccuua +ucxy
nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca: Ka ncxcc-
uua uaucx:acu c.cncuu c_ucc.u a nc(cxax
(auucu (c(y.uaucu cuc.c: nuuqun: nc-
qccca c xcru+cccu .c+u +cuua qcxuc uc-
(ca+yc: a nc(cxax cacu .cu cuc.c:
J
.
Haucu:acc cxu+cc.ac ncqcccyax:uc
+ua+u:x ncxccuuu +ucxy nuuqunca yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa c.uccu. nccccc
B. 1. 1cuu. B a(y nuuqunca cu ua+:aac.:
J) +acuucc.:; 2) a+(cxcuuc ncqcccyax:u:x
yuquu; J) nyxu+ucc.: (cuquax:ucc.:);
4) ncqcccyax:uy uc+aaucucc.: (cxucc.-
u:x xuq ~ y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca;
5) cccnc+cuuc +acuu:x uu.cccca xu+ucc.u;
6) c.c.uauy uc.uuy; 7) y+ac.uc uac(ucrc
xccu.a a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
H. U. ,cu(ca nc(xarac. ccc.acuuy
cuc.cy nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa u ux acc:a caccca+uy xaccuua-
qu. lc crc ucuu, nuuqun: yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca a+(cxa.ca ua ucccx:c rynn.
lcay rynny ccc.aaxa. c_cccquax:u:c
u c_cnaaca:c nuuqun:: ryauu+, cna-
ac(xuacc.:, (cca.u+, +acuucc.:. B.cy
rynny ca+y. c_cncqcccyax:u:c nuu-
qun:: nyxu+ucc.: yrcxcaucrc ncqccca; a-
acuc.ac ra(au ncc( +acuc u rccy(ac.acu-
u: crauc, ccy_cc.axa_u ncu+ac(c.ac
nc (cxy; uaqucuax:u:u a+: ncu+ac(c.aa nc
(cxy; nuuqun yc.aucaxcuua c.c.uaucu uc-
.uu:; accc.ccuucc, ncxucc u c.c.uaucc
uccxc(caauuc cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa; nc+ynqua
ucauucaucc.u; cccnc+cuuc cauuaccy na-
aa ua +a_u.y.
B .c.: rynny axc(a. cncquu+ccuc
nuuqun: (ccy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa: cnca-
.uaucc.: u :c.c.a; c(uucxu+ucc ac(cuuc
nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua; ncqcccyax:uaa
cacc.ca.cx:ucc.: cxc(caa.cxa; uc(cnyc.u-
cc.: a+rxaacuua (auu:x accxc(caauua.
H uacucq, cncquax:u:u nuuqunau
ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa a cy(c-
u:x c.a(uax aaxa.ca: ccy_cc.axcuuc na-
accy(ua .cx:c cy(c; y+ac.uc uac(u:x +a-
cc(a.cxcu u cxxcruax:ucc.: a accc.cuuu
(cx; uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u uac(u:x +acc(a-
.cxcu u nc(+uucuuc ux .cx:c +acuy; rxac-
ucc.: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa; ccy_cc.a-
xcuuc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ua ua+axax ccc.a+a-
.cx:ucc.u
4
.
J
C.: oe:cmoe A. A. luuqun: yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u H+acc.ua ay+ca.
laacac(cuuc. 2OO8. ` 2. C. 92.
2
ooeo:oco+ 7. H. luuqun: ccac.ccrc
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca (Bcncc: .ccuu u na.u-
u). M., J97J. C. JO.
J
1a c. C. J7.
4
C.: c+u{oe H. 0. luuqun: ccac.ccrc
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca Kyc ccac.ccrc yrcxca-
ucrc ncqccca. M., J989. C. J44J45.
C. C. lc.oe. lcxc: cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a \lK IU
8
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
B nccxc(y_c H. U. ,cu(ca nc(xa-
rax (cxu.: nuuqun: yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ua
c_cncqcccyax:u:c (acncc.aua_ucca ua
acc yrcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac), u nuuqun:,
xaa.cu:c (xa c.(cx:u:x nc(cuc.c, ~
(ccy(cucrc u cy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa
5
.
1. H. ,ccacx:caa, ycac(c.ayac: cc-
cucaauu:u c xcru+ccuu naauxau nc-
c.ccuua cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca, c.uccu. uu: J) ccy_cc.axcuuc accu
(ca.cx:ucc.u nc ac+y(cuu, accxc(caauu,
accc.cuu u a+cacuu yrcxcau:x (cx
a .c+uc ccc.ac.c.auu c +acuc; 2) nyxu+-
ucc.: (cuquax:ucc.:) ncqcccyax:ucu (ca-
.cx:ucc.u rccy(ac.acuu:x crauca, ynaac-
c+cuu:x acc.u c:y c ncc.ynucc.:;
J) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua ua ua+axax a-
acuc.aa accx ra(au ncc( +acuc u cy(c;
4) uaqucuax:u:u a+: cy(cncu+ac(c.aa;
5) cccnc+cuuc cauuaccy naaa ua +a_u-
.y; 6) nc+ynqua ucauucaucc.u cauuacc-
rc; 7) .ccaauuc yc.auaaxuaa.: c.c.uauy
uc.uuy nc a(cy (cxy; 8) ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.:
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa; 9) ccy_cc.axcuuc
naaccy(ua nc yrcxcau: (cxa .cx:c cy-
(c; JO) c.:.cc a+ua.cx:c.ac (cx a cy-
(ax; JJ) cxxcruax:ucc.: accc.cuua u a+-
cacuua (cx; J2) aacuc.ac naa accrc ccc.a-
aa cy(a ua uccxc(caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, cac-
uuc accx acnccca, ac+uua_ux nc (cxy, u
a+cacuuc (cxa a qcxc; JJ) y+ac.uc uac(-
u:x +acc(a.cxcu a accc.cuuu u a+cac-
uuu (cx a cy(c ncacu uuc.auquu; J4) y+ac-
.uc c_cc.acuucc.u a ac+y(cuuu, accxc-
(caauuu, accc.cuuu u a+cacuuu yrcxca-
u:x (cx; J5) uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u uac(-
u:x +acc(a.cxcu nu ccy_cc.axcuuu naaccy-
(ua u nc(+uucuuc ux nu .c .cx:c +acuy;
J6) ucnccc(c.acuucc.: uccxc(caauua (ca-
+a.cx:c.a; J7) ca+caauuc accx cy(ca ua ua-
+axax a:cucc.u
6
.
lc H. B. 1:u+cay, ncc+cu: nuuqunca
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca (cxcu a:rxa(c.: cxc-
(y_u ca+c: J) nyxu+ucc.: ncqccca;
2) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua nc yrcxcau:
(cxa .cx:c cy(c; J) ccy_cc.axcuuc na-
accy(ua nc yrcxcau: (cxa a:cu:u cy-
(:au u uac(u:u +acc(a.cxau; 4) y+ac.uc
uac(u:x +acc(a.cxcu u cxxcruax:ucc.: a ac-
cc.cuuu (cx; 5) uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u nc(-
+uucuuc ux .cx:c +acuy; 6) ccy_cc.axcuuc
naaccy(ua ua ua+axax aacuc.aa ra(au ncc(
+acuc u cy(c; 7) rxacucc.: cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa; 8) ac(cuuc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ua uaquc-
uax:uc a+:c; 9) cccnc+cuuc cauuaccy
naaa ua +a_u.y; JO) nc+ynqua ucauucauc-
c.u; JJ) y+ac.uc c_cc.acuucc.u a yrcxcauc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac; J2) accc.ccuucc.:, ncxuc.a
u c.c.uaucc.: uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a
(cxa; JJ) cqcua (ca+a.cx:c.a nc auy.cu-
ucy yc(cuu cy(a, ncyca, cxc(caa.cxa
u xuqa, ncu+ac(a_crc (c+uauuc; J4) ccc.a+a-
.cx:ucc.: ncqccca; J5) ucnccc(c.acuucc.:
uccxc(caauua (ca+a.cx:c.a; J6) yc.ucc.:
ncqccca
7
. O(ucaccuuc H. B. 1:u+ca a:-
c.ynac. nc.ua c.ucccuua +ucxy nuuqunca
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca .aux ncxccuuu, a +a-
cuucc.:, cy(cu:u u ncyccuu ua(+c,
ucnuccucacuucc.: xu+ucc.u, uxu_a, .auua
nccnucu, .cxcrau:x ccc_cuuu u .cxccu-
u:x nccrcacca, yc.aucaxcuuc uc.uu: nc (cxy
8
.
B ua+axc cy(cuc-naacacu cc: a ua-
acu c.auc aa.ccu cxxc.uac nc( yc-
ac(c.ac B. M. Caauqcrc :xa cc+(aua .c-
cc.u+ccaa c(cx: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc-
rc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa CCCI u ICUCI.
B (auucu c(cxu nuuqun: :xu +acnxcu:
a c.(cx:u:x c.a.:ax, ax+cuu:x a a+(cx
O_uc ncxccuua u nuuqun:. lc +a:cxy
B. M. Caauqcrc, cuc.ca nuuqunca yrcxca-
ucrc ncqccca (cxua :xa ccc.ca.: u+ cxc(y-
_ux ncxccuuu: J) +acuucc.:; 2) ccy_cc.a-
xcuuc naaccy(ua .cx:c cy(c; J) cxxcru-
ax:ucc accc.cuuc (cx u y+ac.uc uac(u:x
5
C.: c+u{oe H. 0. luuqun: nc(aau-
.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua Iycac(c.ac (xa cxc(caa-
.cxcu. M., J998. C. 56.
6
C.: ooeo:oco+ 7. H. \a+. cc+. C. J8
4J.
7
C.: 7ouce H. B. luuqun: ccac.ccrc yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca. M., J98J. C. 2J.
8
1a c. C. J7.
9
+acc(a.cxcu; 4) uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u nc(-
+uucuuc ux .cx:c +acuy; 5) nyxu+ucc.:
ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa; 6) aacu-
c.ac ra(au ncc( +acuc u cy(c; 7) yaa-
cuuc (cc.cuuc.aa xu+ucc.u; 8) cxaua naa
u cacc( ra(au; 9) c.:.cc a+ua.cx:-
c.ac (cx ac accx cy(ax; JO) a+:, ua c.cc
ac(c.ca ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy;
JJ) y+ac.uc c_cc.acuucc.u a ncu+ac(c.ac nc
yrcxcau: (cxa; J2) yc.aucaxcuuc c.c.ua-
ucu uc.uu:; JJ) nc+ynqua ucauucaucc.u;
J4) cccnc+cuuc nc(c+caaccy, cauuacc-
y u nc(cy(ucy naaa ua +a_u.y; J5) cc-
c.a+a.cx:ucc.: ncu+ac(c.aa a cy(c; J6) uc-
nccc(c.acuucc.: u yc.ucc.: uccxc(caauua (c-
a+a.cx:c.a; J7) cacc(a caxcaauua nc-
qcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu u cacuuu
9
.
H. A. lcca a:c.auaac. cxc(y_y
cuc.cy nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca: J) +a-
cuucc.:; 2) nyxu+ucc.:; J) ccy_cc.axcuuc
naaccy(ua ua ua+axax aacuc.aa ra(au ncc(
+acuc u cy(c; 4) cxaua +cc.u u (cc.cuu-
c.aa xu+ucc.u; 5) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua
.cx:c cy(c; 6) uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u nc(-
+uucuuc ux Kcuc.u.yquu Icccuu u c(cax:-
ucy +acuy; 7) rxacucc.: yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa; 8) nuuqun rccy(ac.acuucrc
a+:a, ua c.cc ac(c.ca yrcxcaucc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.ac; 9) cccnc+cuuc nc(c+caaccy,
cauuaccy u nc(cy(ucy naaa ua +a_u.y;
JO) nuuqun nc+ynquu ucauucaucc.u;
JJ) nuuqun accc.ccuucrc, ncxucrc u c.c-
.uaucrc uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa;
J2) ccy_cc.axcuuc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ua cc-
ucac ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u u aaucnaaua c.ccu;
JJ) cacc(ucc caxcaauuc (cuc.auu u cac-
uuu a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac; J4) nuu-
qun: ucnccc(c.acuucc.u, yc.ucc.u u ucnc-
:aucc.u cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa;
J5) nuuqun y+ac.ua nc(c.aau.cxcu uac(a
a yrcxcauc ncqcccc
JO
.
A. C. Kcxuca ncxarac., +.c a cuc.cy
nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca cry. axc(u.::
J) +acuucc.:; 2) nyxu+ucc.:; J) aacuc.ac
ra(au ncc( +acuc u cy(c; 4) cxaua
naa u cacc( ra(au; 5) rxacucc.: cy(a;
6) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua .cx:c cy(c;
7) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua uc+aaucu: u
ccnuc.ac.u: cy(c; 8) nc+ynqua uc-
auucaucc.u; 9) cccnc+cuuc cauuaccy naaa
ua +a_u.y; JO) ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.:; JJ) uaquc-
uax:u:u a+: cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
JJ
.
B. l. lc:ca (c nuua.ua \lK .a
nc(c.aaxax cuc.cy cuc.u.yqucuu:x nuu-
qunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca: J) +acuucc.:;
2) nyxu+ucc.:; J) ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy-
(ua .cx:c cy(c; 4) uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu;
5) accc_cc aacuc.ac ncc( +acuc u cy-
(c; 6) ucnuccucacuucc.: xu+ucc.u u u-
xu_a; 7) cxaua +cc.u u (cc.cuuc.aa xu+uc-
c.u; 8) nc+ynqua ucauucaucc.u; 9) cccnc-
+cuuc nc(c+caaccy u cauuaccy naaa ua
+a_u.y; 9) accc.ccuucc.:, ncxuc.a u c.c-
.uaucc.: uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa;
JO) cqcua (ca+a.cx:c.a nc auy.cuucy
yc(cuu; JJ) ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: u aaucna-
auc c.ccu; J2) rxacucc.:; JJ) ucnccc(c.acu-
ucc.: u yc.ucc.: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa;
J4) cccnc+cuuc ncx:+caauua c(u: a+:c
a xc(c cy(cncu+ac(c.aa; J5) cacc(a ca-
xcaauua; J6) y+ac.uc ra(au a yrcxcauc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac
J2
.
luua.uc \lK uc ncaxcxc a(uuax:-
ucrc u+cucuua cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, c.c.auaaccu B. l. lc-
:ca:. K +ucxy nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca a u.crc u (caaxcu: .auua nccnucu,
.cxccuu:x u uu:x nccrcacca, nc+.ca:x, .c-
xcrau:x u uu:x ccc_cuuu, cxaua naa u
cacc( +cxcaca u ra(auuua a yrcxcauc cy-
(cncu+ac(c.ac, a u+ +ucxa nuuqunca ucx-
+cu: accc.ccuucc.:, ncxuc.a u c.c.uaucc.:
9
C.: \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:-
c.ac Cc+a CCI u ICUCI lc( c(.
B. M. Caauqcrc. M., J99O. C. J824.
JO
C.: lo+oe H. A. \rcxcau:u ncqccc Icc-
cuu: \+c. ncc. M., J998. C. 55.
JJ
C.: lo:uoe A. C. luuqun: yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca \rcxcau:u ncqccc IU: Ka.uu
y+cuu. M., J995. C. 28.
J2
C.: lo+oce B. H. Kcuc.u.yqucuu:c nuuqu-
n: yrcxcaucrc ncqccca \rcxcau:u ncqccc:
\+cuu. M., 2OO2. C. 7JJOJ.
C. C. lc.oe. lcxc: cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a \lK IU
JO
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa u y+ac.uc
ra(au a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
B cc.ax:ucu +ac.u crc cuc.ca cuc.u.yqucu-
u:x nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca cc.axac:
ucu+cuucu, ccxu uc nuuua.: ac auuauuc
uc+ua+u.cx:u:c c(aqucuu:c cc.ua:
uaucucaauua nuuqunca
JJ
.
Ia+ac.+uu \lK Icccuu uc accncx:-
+caaxuc: a ncxucu cc uu c(ucu u+ ucrc-
+ucxcuu:x cuc.c, +acnua ac a.ccu rxaac
cuc.cy, ccc.ac.c.ay_y ux ccc.acuu:
nc(c.aaxcuua c yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.ac. Ka cxc(c.auc ~ a cuc.cc nuuqunca
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa uc uaaxcc: c-
c.a ucru ncxccuua, aucc .a(uqucuuc
nu+uaaaaauca .aca:u. lc(cucc +ac-
uc(a.cx:ucc au(cuuc ccuca yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u cc. :.: c.acuc-
uc a(c nu+uu. Bc-nca:x, a+ac.+uu
\lK ncc.aaxuc: c.a+u.: a crc ucax nc-
(aaxa_cc cx:auuc.ac ncqcccyax:u:x nc(-
nucauuu, acac(aux a Kcuc.u.yqu Icccuu.
Bc-a.c:x, nuc.ax:ucc auuauuc xc(y cy-
(cucu cc: u c(ucy u+ cc a+ucu:x (c-
ycu.ca ~ \lK ~ cc c.ccu: ucacrc
ccc_cc.aa, c(yuac(u:x crauu+aquu, a
ua ac.ca, cycxcauxc ax+cuuc a +ucxc
nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa uau-
cxcc xucax:u:x, (cca.u+ccux ua+ax,
nc(c.aaxa_ux c.c+cc.acuu:u nca(c nc-
u+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa a a:rc(uc
aycc. B-.c.:ux, ua cuc.cc nuuqunca yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa uc crxc uc c.a-
+u.:ca ucacc ncuuauuc c.(cx:u:x uuc.u.y-
.ca u uc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc naaa,
c.xu+ucc c. yc.caaauxca a ccac.cc u (c-
c.aaauxca nc uacxc(c.ay cccuuccy +acuc-
(a.cx:c.ay c yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac a crc
ncacua+ax:uc aauau.c.
B cx:auuc.ac y+cuuca u y+cu:x nc-
ccuu, nc(rc.caxcuu:x nccxc nuua.ua u ac.yn-
xcuua a +acuuy cuxy \lK, a .ac a c-
cu.auax ucy acca.uaa.ca xua: nuu-
qun:, ua+aauu:c .aca:u +acuc(a.cxc.
lc(cu:u nc(xc( aa.cca ccu.auca
\lK cuc c.acuu.: .c, +.c cuu xuac-
u: ac+cucc.u a+.acua.: ncxccuua, uc c.-
acuu:c a ucax +acua. ,yruc y+cu:c,
nc-au(ucy, cnc c +acuc(a.cxc c+u.a.
ccc:cxcuu:
J4
.
B .c c aca a( ncqcccyaxuc.ca,
uc ccrxaaaac: c nc(xc(c, nc(xccuu: +a-
cuc(a.cxc, a:c.auaa. cuc.c:, ucccx:c
c.xu+u:c c. +acnxcuucu a +acuc. 1a,
l. A. lcxccaa u H. B. Kcaaxcuc nuu-
quna yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, ncuc
ncc+ucxcuu:x a \lK, c.ucca. nyxu+ucc.:,
uc+aaucucc.: cy(cu u nucau:x +acc(a.c-
xcu, rxacucc.:
J5
. A. l. I:aca a cuc.cy
nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca (caaxac. ny-
xu+ucc.:, a cc.ax:uc c crc cuc.ca u(cu-
.u+ua cc(ca_cuca a +acuc
J6
. l. 1. lc+-
xcnuu ncxarac., +.c yc(u.cx:ucrc cacuua
ncxca nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
a \lK uc ncxy+uxa: Qcx:u a( crc +acuc-
ncxccuuu ncc(ac. u c.a:c, u uca:c acn-
cc: u a:+:aac. cy_cc.acuu:c u.u+ccuc
+ac+auua. Hc a caccu ac.c cu acca.-
uaac. xua: nuuqun: yrcxcaucrc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa, ax+cuu:c a rx. 2 \lK, a:ca-
+:aaa nu .c ucc.c:c cccacuua c qc-
xcccca+ucc.u c.ucccuua uu c.(cx:u:x
ncxccuuu
J7
.
JJ
C.: lo+oce B. H. Kcuc.u.yqucuu:c nuuqu-
n: yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. C. 7498.
J4
C., uan.: \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc naac IU:
\+cuu O.a. c(. l. A. ^ynuucaa. M., 2OOJ.
C. J772J6; \rcxcau:u ncqccc: \+cuu (xa
ay+ca O.a. c(. A. B. luucuc. M., 2OO4.
C. J252; \rcxcau:u ncqccc: \+cuu lc(
c(. C. A. Kcxcccau+a, l. A. auqcacu. M., 2OOJ.
C. 425J; \rcxcau:u ncqccc: \+cuu lc(
c_. c(. B. H. Ia(+cuc. M., 2OOJ. C. 4666;
Xu+uceo l. H. luuqun: yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa \rcxcau:u ncqccc: Ccu. y+c-
u:x ncccuu: O_aa +ac.:. B:n. J. M., 2OO2.
C. 7999.
J5
C.: Hoxooeo E. A.. loeo:cno H. B. \rc-
xcau:u ncqccc IU a acnccax u c.ac.ax. M.,
2OO4. C. J6J8.
J6
C.: Po+ooe A. H. \rcxcau:u ncqccc:
\+cuu (xa ay+ca. M., 2OOJ. C. 5456.
J7
C.: lc.:cnun l. 7. \rcxcau:u ncqccc a acn-
ccax u c.ac.ax: \+c. ncc. M., 2OOJ. C. J7JO.
JJ
O cy_cc.acaauuu nuuquna nyxu+ucc.u
yncuuac.ca a ac.ax u (yrux aa.cca, ya-
+:aa_ux ua .c, +.c .c nc(nucauuc ucx:+a
uc c.ucc.u +ucxy ccucacncxara_ux, xc.a
cuc u uc ncxy+uxc +acnxcuua a rxaac luu-
qun: yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. lcac-
(a caauu.cx:uc-naacacu auaxu+ \lK
ICUCI u \lK IU, H. ^. lc.yxuu ya-
+:aac. ua .c. a., +.c \lK IU a ccucauc
y.a.ux uuau+uqucuu:c +c.:, nucy_uc a-
ucc (cuc.acaaaacy +acuy, u a rca+(c cx:-
acu cc anuc:aac.ca a c(cx: nyxu+uc-
uccacu c: yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa,
+c crc nc(acc.acuuu
J8
.
. B. Maacaa c(uu u+ c+cau(u:x yny-
_cuuu a+ac.+uca \lK c+u.ac. c.cy.c.auc
a crc .cc.c nuuquna aacuc.aa accx ncc(
+acuc u cy(c: lcccncuc, ncxcu.cx:u:
aaxac.ca aac(cuuc a \lK IU .aux nuuqu-
nca, a yaacuuc +cc.u u (cc.cuuc.aa xu+uc-
c.u, ucnuccucacuucc.u xu+ucc.u, cxaua naa
u cacc( +cxcaca u ra(auuua a yrcxcauc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac u ucc.c:x (yrux. O(ua-
c (xa naacacrc c.a.yca +cxcaca u ra(a-
uuua uauaaucuacc +ua+cuuc ucc. nuuqun
aacuc.aa accx ncc( +acuc u cy(c. lu
.c cc:xu ua .c, +.c nuuqun aacuc.aa accx
ncc( +acuc u cy(c cc.: a Kcuc.u.yquu IU,
uccc.u:, uc a ucu yc.aucaxcuc .ac cx:-
auuc.ac (yrux yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x nuu-
qunca, ya+auu:x a rx. 2 \lK IU. O(uac
nc+cy-.c a \lK IU nuuqun .auu: ncc-
nucu ca+axca aaucc rxaaucrc (cca.u+cc-
crc nuuquna aacuc.aa accx ncc( +acuc u
cy(c
J9
. lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c yncu . B. Ma-
acacu a a(cc +acuc(a.cxa ancxuc ycc.u:
u cccucaauu:. B acca.uaaccu +ac.u
\lK uc cc. nc.uacc+u.: ncxccuua
Kcuc.u.yquu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu uxu +a-
ax+uaa.: ux.
Cc:c+u:c ac+acuua a:+:aac. y
. B. Maacacu u c.cy.c.auc a \lK nuu-
quna accc.ccuucc.u, ncxuc.: u c.c.uauc-
c.u uccxc(caauua accx cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa. lc-
xcu+uya c H. l. Muxauxcaccu, y.ac(a-
_cu, +.c uaxu+uc .acrc ncxccuua caac.
a+(cxcuu ncqcccyax:u:x yuquu u uc (c-
nycac. a yrcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ua+axa
(ucnc+u.uaucc.u
2O
, cua nuxc(u. a:ac(y, +.c
.c. nuuqun a ncxucu cc ccc.ac.c.ayc.
ua+ua+cuu yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa u crc
cxc(caaxc cc.aau.: a \lK, +.c: uc :xc
ncac(a (xa a+u:x .cxcaauuu nuuquna cc-
c.a+a.cx:ucc.u
2J
.
B uayc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca c+u.ac.ca, +.c
c. ncxuccaucu u+uu nuuquna accc.ccu-
ucrc, ncxucrc u c.c.uaucrc uccxc(caauua
cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa a +ua+u.cx:ucu c.cncuu
+aaucu. u .ccc.ac cuc.u.yqucuucrc nuu-
quna nc+ynquu ucauucaucc.u. Ha (auucc
cc.ca.cx:c.ac ca_ac. auuauuc u B. l. lc-
:ca: Icax:ucc (cuc.auc nc+ynquu ucau-
ucaucc.u cxcc +c ncxca.u+uc, ccxu +a-
cu uc .cyc. c. crauca accxc(caauua u
cy(a accc.ccuucrc, ncxucrc u c.c.uaucrc
uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa
22
.
O.cy.c.auc a \lK nuuquna accc.ccu-
ucc.u, ncxuc.: u c.c.uaucc.u uccxc(caa-
uua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa A. A. ,aaxc.ca c.ac-
uac. cxc(y_u ca+c: O.aaua ccc.a+a-
.cx:ucc.: u a:(cxua c.ccu:, a+ac.+uu
\lK, au(uc, ncc+u.axu uc ccc.ac.c.ay_u-
u .cu u(cc .auc x+ca:c ncxccuua c.a-
crc \lK, a yc.aucaxcuuc uc.uu:, a .ac
accc.ccuucc.:, ncxuc.y u c.c.uaucc.: uc-
cxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa, u uc ax+u-
xu ux a uca:u Kc(cc
2J
.
J8
Hcmxun H. . O. uuau+uquu ~ ccc.a-
+a.cx:ucc.u lccy(ac.ac u naac. 2OOJ. ` 7.
C. 29.
J9
Moooeo d. B. \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u
c(cc Icccuuccu Uc(caquu: uucaqua a+-
:axcuu laacac(cuuc. 2OOJ. ` J. C. JJ4
JJ5.
2O
C.: Muxou:oeco+ H. laaa xu+ucc.u ~
uca:u nucu.c. \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c-
(cca Icccuuccu Uc(caquu Icc. c.uqua.
2OO2. ` 7. C. 4.
2J
C.: Moooeo d. B. \a+. cc+. C. J4JJ42.
22
\rcxcau:u ncqccc: O_aa +ac.:: \+cuu
lc( c(. B. l. lc:caa. M., J997. C. 65.
2J
oe:cmoe A. A. lcxca ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u
cacua a \lK IU ucy(a+uc Icc. c.uqua.
2OOJ. ` 8. C. J8.
C. C. lc.oe. lcxc: cuc.c: nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a \lK IU
J2
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
C. luu+ca u l. luu+ca, cc:xaac: ua
na.uy ac.: cy(cu:x u cxc(c.acuu:x
crauca, cuc.a.uy., +.c c+ yc.aucaxcuua
uc.uu: ucx:+a ncc.aucau.: uu c(ucrc cau-
uu.cx:ucrc nurcaca: Mucrc+ucxcuu:c uc-
cxc(caauua y+cu:x cau(c.cx:c.ay. c .c, +.c
ccucau: uc(cc.a.c cx:auuc.aa yrcxca-
u:x (cx, c.c:c nc \lK ICUCI ac+aa-
_axuc: cy(c (xa (cncxuu.cx:ucrc accxc(c-
aauua, aaxaxac: c(ucc.ccuucc.: u (uxu) uc-
ncxuc.a nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua.
1acc ccucaauuc c.cuc, u+cucuu nurc-
aca cy(c accaqucuucu uuc.auquu acc_c
uc ax+cuc a ncc+cu: ccucaauuu nuua.ua
cacuua cy(c (c.. J79 \lK IU)
24
.
Cxc(yc. ya+a.: u ua .c cc.ca.cx:c.ac,
a:(cxaccc c.(cx:u:u y+cu:u, +.c, uccc.-
a ua c.cy.c.auc nuuquna accc.ccuucrc, ncx-
ucrc u c.c.uaucrc uccxc(caauua cc.ca-
.cx:c.a (cxa a ccc.ac.c.ay_cu rxaac \lK,
crc ccucau:c xccu.: a.u+ccu +acn-
xcu: a ncqcccyax:u:x ucax
25
. lu .c
aa.c: cc:xa.ca ua ncxccuua +. 6 c.. J4O
\lK, r(c +c.c rcacu.ca ucuuc c nuuqu-
nc c.c.uaucc.u u ccnuc.ac.ucc.u, xc.a
u nucuu.cx:uc cy(y nucau:x, a .ac
ua +. 2 c.. J54 \lK, (cnyca_y a:(cxc-
uuc yrcxcaucrc (cxa xua: nu ycxcauu, +.c
.c uc c.a+u.ca ua accc.ccuucc.u u c.c-
.uaucc.u nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua.
Occucaauuc ncxaraa, +.c ncc.cc (yxu-
caauuc cuc.u.yqucuu:x u(cu a ua+axc c-
_cu +ac.u \lK cac nc ccc uc cccnc+uaa-
c. ux cax:ucrc acnxc_cuua ua nc.acuuu
accrc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, A. A. ,aa-
xc.ca nc(xarac. cxc(y_y cuc.cy nuuqu-
nca yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u:
J) ccx(cuuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c-
:; 2) a.uaucc.:; J) qcxcccca+ucc.:;
4) :c.c.a (caccaccuucc.:); 5) ncqcccy-
ax:uaa cacc.ca.cx:ucc.:; 6) (cycu.uc-
aauuc (nuc:cuucc.:); 7) cccnc+cuuc naa
y+ac.uuca; 8) ucnccc(c.acuucc.: uccxc(c-
aauua (ca+a.cx:c.a; 9) ncxuc.a (ca+:aa-
uua; JO) cqcua (ca+a.cx:c.a nc auy.cuuc-
y yc(cuu; JJ) +acuucc.:, cccucaauucc.:,
c.uaucaauucc.: u cnaac(xuacc.: ncqcc-
cyax:u:x cacuuu; J2) +cc.ucc.: (ccacc.:);
JJ) yx:.ya
26
.
1au ca+c, nc(nuua.aa a+ac.+u-
au \lK a(uax:uaa ncn:.a cacuua
c(ucrc u+ ca:x (ucyccucuu:x acnccca .c-
cuu yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, a:a+uaaaaca
a +acnxcuuu cuc.c: a+ucu:x ncqcccyax:-
u:x ncxccuuu a c.(cx:ucu rxaac +acua, aa(
xu cc. c+u.a.:ca ancxuc y(a+ucu. Maccy u-
.u+ccux +ac+auuu a:+aaxu qcxcccca+ucc.:
ucncx:+caauua .acrc nuca +acuc(a.cx:ucu
.cxuuu, nc(xccuu:u ncc+cu: ncxccuuu,
ac+ac(cuu:x a a+a( nuuqunca, a .ac cc-
(cauuc ccc.ac.c.ay_ux nc(nucauuu.
24
Eu+uce C.. Eu+uce H. \lK Icccuu-
ccu Uc(caquu uy(ac.ca a y.c+ucuuu \rc-
xcaucc naac. 2OOJ. ` J. C. 67.
25
C.: omceo B. d.. vuonoe A. l. luu-
qun ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u u aaucnaaua c.ccu a uc-
ac \lK IU laacac(cuuc. 2OO2. ` 2.
C. JO5JO6.
26
C.: oe:cmoe A. A. luuqun: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u.
JJ
Qcx: (auucu c.a.:u ~ nc(xcu.: (cncxucuua u u+cuc-
uua \lK IU 2OOJ rc(a ((axcc ~ \lK), uanaaxcuu:c ua
cn.uu+aqu nucucuua naaux (cnyc.ucc.u yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:u:x (ca+a.cx:c.a u accncxucuuc nccxca naacacrc
cryxucaauua, +.c, a cuc+uc u.crc, (cxuc ncxcu.cx:u:
ca+c ca+a.:ca ua cucaauuu c(uucca+ucu cy(cuc-
cxc(c.acuucu na.uu a (auu:x acnccax.
lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c a \lK (cxu: :.: aucccu: cxc(y-
_uc u+cucuua:
J. Hccxc(uc nuacc.u +. J c.. 7, +. J u n. J +. 2 c.. 75 \lK,
cc(ca_uc uc: c uc(cnyc.ucc.u ucncx:+caauua a yrcxca-
uc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x
c uayacuuc mcoeonuu YHl, a ccc.ac.c.auc
c ncxccuuc +. 2 c.. 5O Kcuc.u.yquu IU, cc(c-
a_cu +anc. ua ucncx:+caauuc nu ccy_cc.axc-
uuu naaccy(ua (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x c uay-
acuuc c{co:ono:o .oono.
Cuc.cucc .cxcaauuc +. 2 c.. 5O Kcuc.u.yquu IU nc+ac-
xac. c(cxa.: a:ac( c .c, +.c ncua.uc uc.c+uuca naaa, uayac-
uuc .ccaauuu c.c:x nu ncxy+cuuu (ca+a.cx:c.a nuac-
(u. uc(cnyc.ucc.u nccxc(uux, uc crauu+uaac.ca .cx:c c-
(cax:u:u +acuau, uc ax+ac. .ac cxc(y_uc uc.c+uu-
u naaa
J
:
J) c.ca_uc a ucaxuu naaca:x a.ca a:ac, +c c(c-
ax:u:c +acu:, a ucuuc: Kcuc.u.yqu IU, c_cnu+uauu:c
uc: u nuuqun: c(yuac(ucrc naaa u c(yuac(u:c
M. C. Ec:onoem:vcnu
onycrnmocrr orasarcxrcru
u poccncrom yroxounom cyonponsuocruc:
nanpauxcnnn coucpmcncruouannn npauouoro
pcryxnpouannn
Maucum Cepreeuun Benououmnucuu,
aaoxa Pepaouancxon xorrernn aaoxaoa
r. Heacxa, ren Coaea Aaoxacxon narau
Yuypcxon Pecny6rnxn
belnakserqnall.ru
J
lc(cucc c .c c.: lc:ooeo:ocuu M. C. Kcuc.u.yqucuu:u
+anc. ua ucncx:+caauuc uc(cnyc.u:x (ca+a.cx:c.a: ncxc: yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu caxu+aquu Caauu.cx:ucc cuc.u.yqucu-
ucc cc+cuuc. 2OO9. ` 5. C. J624.
J4
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
(crcac:, uc_uc a cuxy +. 4 c.. J5 Kcu-
c.u.yquu IU nucu.c. ncc( uca.uauc-na-
aca:u a.au auy.cuucrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa,
a +ac.ucc.u Kcuacuqu c +a_u.c naa +cxc-
aca u ccucau:x cacc(, c(cax:u:c cuc.u-
.yqucuu:c +acu:
2
; 2) uu:c, uccxu \lK,
c(cax:u:c +acu:
J
; J) nc(+acuu:c uc-
a.uauc-naaca:c a.:, u+(auu:c ac ucncx-
ucuuc c(cax:u:x u c(cax:u:x cuc.u.y-
qucuu:x +acuca
4
.
B caa+u c .u, xaa.cu+ya yr uc.c+-
uuca naaa, uayacuuc c.c:x nuac(u. uc-
(cnyc.ucc.u ncxy+cuu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a, c-
c.ucc y(c. ucncx:+caa.: .cuu +acu,
c.c:u :x ync.cxcu +acuc(a.cxc a +. J
c.. 69 \lK ICUCI J96O rc(a.
2. Cxc(yc. +acnu.: (aa crauu+cuua +an-
c.a ua ucncx:+caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy-
+cuu:x c uayacuuc +acua:
J) Czcmuenoc o:onucnuc, .c cc.:
ncxccuuc c acuc.uu naaux (cnyc.u-
cc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a.
,auucc ncxccuuc, cc+ua+cuucc .au c-
a+c cccuucu ncqcccyaxuc.c A. M. ^a-
uu:, nc(c.aaxac. cccu y.ac(u.cx:u:u
c.ac. ua acncc: acncc.auac.ca xu ncxcc-
uuc c uc(cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a ua (ca-
+a.cx:c.aa, xc.a u ncxy+cuu:c c uayacuuc
+acua, uc nc caccy cc(cauu xarcnua.-
c.ay_uc c.ccuc +a_u.:'
O(uac (auuaa nc+uqua a+(cxac.ca (a-
xcc uc accu ncqcccyaxuc.au.
Ocucau:x arycu.ca nc.uauuca acu-
c.uu naauxa (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a
(aa: a) c.cy.c.auc (auucrc ncxccuua a \lK
IU 2OOJ rc(a
5
; ) .c, +.c (auucc ncxccuuc
u+xuauc, .a a a ccc.ac.c.auu c nuuqunc
nc+ynquu ucauucaucc.u uca+cau:c cc-
ucuua a xc cxy+ac (cxu: .cxcaa.:ca
a ncx:+y nc(c+caaccrc, cauuaccrc
6
.
Ha uaa a+rxa(, (auu:c arycu.: cnc-
acu:. lcxccuuc c acuc.uu na-
auxa (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.aa a:.cac.
uc u+ raa.u+cccrc, a u+ .cxccxcru+cccrc
.cxcaauua +. 2 c.. 5O Kcuc.u.yquu IU u,
2
C., uan.: Uc(cax:u:u cuc.u.yqucuu:u +a-
cu c. 2J uua 2OO9 r. ` J-UK O accuu:x
cy(ax Icccuuccu Uc(caquu (c u+. u (cn.).
J
C., uan.: Uc(cax:u:u +acu c. J7 auaaa
J992 r. ` 22O2-J O ncya.yc Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu (c u+. u (cn.); acu Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu c. J8 ancxa J99J r. ` JO26-J
O uxuquu (c u+. u (cn.); Uc(cax:u:u +a-
cu c. JJ aa 2OOJ r. ` 7J-U O rccy(a-
c.acuucu cy(cuc-cnc.ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u a Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu (c u+. u (cn.); Uc(cax:-
u:u +acu c. 26 (caa 2OO8 r. ` 294-U
(c u+. u (cn.) O +a_u.c naa u(u+ccux
xuq u uu(uau(yax:u:x nc(nuuua.cxcu nu ccy-
_cc.axcuuu rccy(ac.acuucrc cu.cxa (ua(+c-
a) u yuuqunax:ucrc cu.cxa; Uc(cax:u:u
+acu c. JJ aa 2OO2 r. ` 6J-U O a(ac-
a.ccu (ca.cx:ucc.u u a(aca.yc a Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu (c u+. u (cn.).
4
C., uan., uuc.yqu O nca(c nc(c.aaxc-
uua c+yx:.a.ca cnca.uauc-c+:cucu (ca.cx:-
ucc.u crauy (c+uauua, cxc(caa.cx, ncycy uxu
a cy(, y.ac(cuuy nua+c UCHl Icccuu,
UCl Icccuu, MB, Icccuu, UCO Icccuu, CBI
Icccuu c. JJ aa J998 r. (lxx. uca.uau:x
a.ca c(cax:u:x crauca ucncxuu.cx:ucu axa-
c.u. J998. J4 ccu.aa. ` 2J. C. 8692), ua
uccxc(ucc.: ccx(cuua .ccaauuu c.ccu
ya+:aac. cuquax:uc cnyxucaauuaa cy(cuaa
na.ua, a +ac.ucc.u cnc(cxcuuc Cy(cucu cx-
xcruu nc yrcxcau: (cxa Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
c. J ccu.aa 2OO4 r.(lxx. Bcxcaucrc Cy(a
IU. 2OO5. ` 5. C. 2J24). B uac.ca_cc ac-
a ya+auuaa uuc.yqua y.a.uxa cuxy a cuxy
nuua.ua auaxcru+ucu Huc.yquu c nca(c
nc(c.aaxcuua c+yx:.a.ca cnca.uauc-c+:c-
ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u (c+uaaa.cx, crauy (c+uauua,
cxc(caa.cx, ncycy uxu a cy(, y.ac(cuucu
nua+c MB, IU, UCl IU, UCO IU, U1C
IU, CBI IU, UCHH IU, UCKH IU, MO
IU c. J7 ancxa 2OO7 r. ` J68J85J6448J
J2J8497J47 (Icc. ra+c.a. 2OO7. J6 aa.
` JOJ).
5
Ucyxucaa +. J c.. 69 \lK ICUCI
(aaaxa cnc(cxcuu:c ccucaauua arycu.ucaa.:
.c+uc c acuc.uu naauxa (cnyc.ucc.u (c-
a+a.cx:c.a, a .c +ucxc u c ncc_: raa-
.u+cccrc .cxcaauua. C., uan.: Coeuquu B. M.
lc+ynqua ucauucaucc.u. M., J997. C. 8J.
6
C., uan.: Anucu+oe A. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca-
+a.cx:c.a acuucc.:. 2OO7. ` JO. C. J5;
l{+eqce B. . lcqcccyax:u:c u uuuaxu-
c.u+ccuc ccuca: (ca.cx:ucc.u a(aca.a-+a_u.-
uua a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
M., 2OO6. C. 798J.
J5
ccc.ac.c.acuuc, +. J c.. 7, +. J c.. 75 \lK
IU a cncquu+cccu cauquu +a uayac-
uuc naa ra(au a cxac.u naaccy(ua, nu-
cuu.cx:uc c yrcxcaucy cy(cncu+ac(-
c.ay ~ a cncquu+cccu yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:ucu cauquu +a uayacuuc .ccaauuu
+acua. Hrucucaauuc nuuquna acuc.-
uu naaux (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a nu-
ac(u. .cy, +.c cauqua cc+(ac. ucxarcnu-
a.u:c nccxc(c.aua uc (xa uayau.cxa ((cx-
ucc.ucrc xuqa craua nc(aau.cx:ucrc ac-
cxc(caauua), a (xa y+ac.uua ncqccca, naaa
c.ccrc yc nc(acrxuc: uayacuu. ,au-
ucc ncxccuuc, c+ycxcauc, nc.uacc+u. ca-
cu cy_ucc.u naaa u cnaac(xuacc.u, uca-
ac. cy_cc.ac ncxccuua c +anc.c ucncx:-
+caauua (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x c uayac-
uuc +acua, a raau.uu naa ra(au a cc-
c naaccy(ua. Cyryc cax:ucc, c+ y+c.a
cuc.ucu cu.yaquu, nucucuuc (auucrc
+anc.a nc(c.aaxac. ucuuc .c. cxy+au, cr(a
a:caaa +acuucc.: cca+uaac.ca a:cau c+-
+acuuc: Summum ius. summo iniucio.
C arycu.c c .c, +.c cuc.yqua
acuc.uu naaux (cnyc.ucc.u (ca-
+a.cx:c.a u+:.c+ua a cuxy .crc, +.c acc cc-
ucuua (cxu: .cxcaa.:ca a ncx:+y nc(cy-
(ucrc, cuc :xc : ccrxacu.:ca xua: nu
c(uc ycxcauu: ccxu : c(uu (ca+a.cx:c.acu-
u:u a. ( nucy, a. a+cuucrc uana-
(cuua nc(c+caaccrc ua nc.cncaay) nc(-
.ac(axca c(uu-c(uuc.acuu: (ca+a.cx:-
c.ac (nc.ccxc cnc+uauua, ncxy+cuu:
c uayacuuc +acua, uc a c+yx:.a.c c.c-
crc nc.cncaaaa uc cnc+uaxa nc(c+caac-
crc). O(uac, a naauxc, cac(cuua c a-
(c u+ (ca+a.cx:c.acuu:x a.ca ncxy+a.
cxcc +c u+ c(ucrc uc.c+uua. Bc.aa ua nc-
+uqu nc.uauuca acuc.uu, : a:-
uy(cu: y(c nu+ua.:, +.c a (auuc cxy-
+ac nu uaxu+uu ucccx:ux ccacuu:x c-
auuu.cx:u:x (ca+a.cx:c.a, nc(.ac(a_ux
a. uana(cuua nc(c+caaccrc, uccxc(uc
xuau.: c.ccuy +a_u.: c_ucrc cnaa(a-
.cx:ucrc u nu.c ucaccncxuucrc (ca+a-
.cx:c.aa, c.ccc c+cau(uc nccaccu. acc
cc.ax:u:c.
K ccaxcuu, uu a na.uc Kcuc.u.y-
qucuucrc Cy(a IU, uu a na.uc Bcxcauc-
rc Cy(a IU ncxccuuc c acuc.uu na-
aux (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a (c uac.ca-
_crc accuu uc ncxy+uxc caccrc +acnxc-
uua. 1c uc cucc, (cacx:uc xu+u ucy
ucc.c:c ncxccuua cacuuu Kcuc.u.yqu-
cuucrc Cy(a IU, .cxy_uc .y uxu uuy
c.a.: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua uc-
xc(a u+ ua+ua+cuua u cc.a a cuc.cc naac-
a:x uc. 1a, nu+uaa qcx: cau(c.cx:cc-
rc uyuu.c.a +a_u.uua raau.u ncxy+c-
uua nc(c+caac: (cauuac:) aaxuu-
qucaauucu u(u+cccu ncc_u u ccx-
(cuuc a(aca.ccu .auu:, Kcuc.u.yqucuu:u
Cy( IU (c+acxux ncu+ac(u.: (cncc +a-
_u.uua a a+cc.ac cau(c.cxa nc cc.ca.cx:-
c.aa, c.aaau cy u+acc.u: a caa+u c y+a-
c.uc a ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy,
nc xc(a.auc.ay nc(+a_u.ucrc u c ccrxacua ca-
crc +a_u.uua
7
.
2) O.c.uaucc crauu+cuuc, .c cc.: ac+-
cucc.: ucncx:+caa.: (ca+a.cx:c.aa, ncxy-
+cuu:c c uayacuuc +acua, a .cx cxy+aax,
cr(a (ca+:aauuc cycxcaxcuc cau a-
.c nu+uauua ux uc(cnyc.u:u
8
.
B nccxc(uc cxy+ac ucncx:+caauuc (ca-
+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x c uayacuuc +acua,
(xa (ca+:aauua cacrc a.a uayacuua u
auucaucc.u xuqa, (cnyc.uaacrc crc, nc(c.aa-
xac.ca naaccu: u c.ac+a_u c:cxy u
ua+ua+cuu naauxa (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a-
.cx:c.a: yc.auaaxuaaa +anc. ua ucncx:+caa-
uuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x c uayacuuc
+acua, +acuc(a.cx: nc(c accrc +a_u_ac.
7
Onc(cxcuuc Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU c.
6 a.a 2OOJ r. ` JO8-O lc axcc ra(a-
uuua Ququaauxu luau Bacau+a ua uayac-
uuc crc cuc.u.yqucuu:x naa nyu.c 2 +ac.u
.c.:cu c.a.:u 56 \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc
c(cca Icccuuccu Uc(caquu Ccauuc
+acuc(a.cx:c.aa Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. 2OOJ.
` 2J. C.. 2O6O.
8
C. c ncxccuuc, cc(ca_uca a +. J c.. J67
lK IU: Hc(cuc.au.cx:uaa c(cxa uc axc+c.
u(u+ccux nccxc(c.auu, +a ucx+cuuc .cx,
c.c:c caa+au: c cc uc(cuc.au.cx:ucc.:, u
uc(cuc.au.cx:ua c ccu.a cc ccacacuua.
M. C. lc:ooeo:ocuu. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac
J6
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ra(auuua c. ncu+acxa crauca nc(aau-
.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
9
. Acy(uc :xc :
nc(ncxcu.:, +.c cy(, yc.aucauaauu uayac-
uua +acua nu ncxy+cuuu (ca+a.cx:c.a, ua
ccucaauuu (auucrc +anc.a uc cr : a:ucc-
.u +ac.ucc ncc.aucaxcuuc (cnc(cxcuuc) a a(-
cc craua cxc(c.aua ((c+uauua), r(c c.aaux
: acncc c nuaxc+cuuu c.ac.c.acuucc.u
cxc(caa.cxa ((c+uaaa.cxa), auucaucrc a (cny-
_cuuc uayacuuu.
luac(cuucc a:ac crauu+cuuc +anc.a
ua ucncx:+caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x
c uayacuuc +acua, nc(ycc.cuc a Mc-
(cx:uc \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc c(ccc (xa
rccy(ac.a ~ y+ac.uuca CHl. B ccc.ac.-
c.auu c +. J c.. J4J (auucrc c(cca a.c-
uax:, ncxy+cuu:c c ya+auu:u a +ac.u nc-
acu uac.ca_cu c.a.:u uayacuuau (a +. J
c.. J4J cc(cu.ca ncc+cu: a.cuaxca, nc-
xy+cuu:x c uayacuuc +acua u a caa+u .u
uc cry_ux :.: ucncx:+caauu:u a a+c-
c.ac (ca+a.cx:c.a. ~ M. l.), cry. :.: uc-
ncx:+caau: a a+cc.ac (ca+a.cx:c.a a.a
ccc.ac.c.ay_ux uayacuuu u auucaucc.u xuq,
ux (cnyc.uaaux
JO
.
J. Kauuc cxa.cx:u: nc(c.aaxac.ca
aucc.u acucc.: a acncc axuauua xaa.ca
uayacuuu +acua ua nu+uauuc uc(cnyc.u-
: ncxy+cuu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a a a cy.c-
.uauc, .a u a c.c.uauc acnc.c uayac-
uua:
J) Cy.c.uau:u acnc. uayacuua, .c cc.:
uaxu+uc uxu c.cy.c.auc auu: (cxucc.ucrc
xuqa, (cnyc.uaacrc nc(cu:c uayacuua.
lc (auucy acnccy cy_cc.ay. (ac nc+u-
quu. C.ccuuuu c(ucu u+ uux ncxara., +.c
+anc. ua ucncx:+caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy-
+cuu:x c uayacuuc +acua, (cxcu u ua-
c.yna.: xua: nu uaxu+uu auu: (cxucc.uc-
rc xuqa, (cnyc.uaacrc uayacuuc
JJ
. lu(c-
uaa_ucca uucu nc+uquu ncqcccyaxuc.:
c.uqa. axuauuc auu: uxu ucauucaucc.u
(cxucc.ucrc xuqa, (cnyc.uaacrc uayacuuc,
ua nu+uauuc ncxy+cuucrc (ca+a.cx:c.aa
uc(cnyc.u:
J2
.
Ha uaa a+rxa(, nu cacuuu (auucrc acn-
cca uccxc(uc a+rauu+uaa.: ncccuax:-
uy yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uy c.ac.c.acuucc.:
rccy(ac.acuucrc craua (a aucc c:c-
xc ~ rccy(ac.aa), a:aa_yca a +anc.c
ua ucncx:+caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x
c uayacuuc +acua, u ncccuax:uy ((uc-
qunxuuauy uxu yrcxcauy) c.ac.c.acuucc.:
(cxucc.ucrc xuqa, (cnyc.uaacrc ya+auucc
uayacuuc.
lcxu auua (cxucc.ucrc xuqa aaxac.ca
uccxc(u: ycxcauc nuaxc+cuua crc nc-
ccuax:ucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, .c (xa yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u rccy(ac.acu-
ucrc craua (rccy(ac.aa) (cc.a.c+uc cacrc
a.a uayacuua. O.c.u, +.c auaxcru+uc
+acuc(a.cx: caac. acncc c ra(aucc-
naacacu c.ac.c.acuucc.u rccy(ac.aa +a uc-
+acuucc cc(cauuc nc( c.acu, nac ya-
+:aaa, +.c ac(, nu+uucuu:u ra(auuuy a c-
+yx:.a.c uc+acuucrc ccy(cuua, uc+acuucrc
nuaxc+cuua yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, uc-
+acuucrc nucucuua a a+cc.ac c: nc-
cc+cuua +ax+cuua nc( c.ay uxu nc(nucu
c uca:c+(c, uc+acuucrc nuaxc+cuua a(u-
uuc.a.uaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u a au(c a(u-
uuc.a.uaucrc acc.a... ac+c_ac.ca +a c+c.
9
C., uan.: lunnuc H. M. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca-
+a.cx:c.a a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac. M.,
J995. C. 798O.
JO
Mc(cx:u:u \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u c(cc
(xa rccy(ac.a ~ y+ac.uuca CHl. Icccu(a-
.cx:u:u +acuc(a.cx:u:u a.. luua. ua cc(:-
c nxcuauc +acc(auuu Mcnaxacu.ccu ac-
caxcu rccy(ac.a ~ y+ac.uuca Cc(ycc.aa
Hc+aaucu:x lccy(ac.a J7 caaxa J996 r.
luxccuuc Hucaqucuucy xxc.cu.
J996. ` JO.
JJ
C., uan.: Cm+:un l. H. Ocucaauua u nc-
qcccyax:u:u nca(c ucx+cuua uc(cnyc.u:x
(ca+a.cx:c.a a xc(c cy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa nc
yrcxcaucy (cxy: Aa.cc. (uc. ... au(. u(.
uay. Cl., 2OO7. C. J9; Lccmooeo C. . ,c-
nyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a: nc(xc(: cu.uucu.ax:-
ucrc c_crc naaa la.:(cca. xc. ac(c yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca \lKA (CKH): B 2 +. la-
.cuuyr, 2OO5. U. 2. C. 4O5, 4O8.
J2
Cmcqoecuu K. H. \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa
(ca.cx:ucc.: +a_u.uua. M., J982. C. 7475.
J7
a+u: Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, a a cxy+aax,
nc(ycc.cuu:x +acuc, +a c+c. a+u:
cy.c.a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu uxu a+u:
yuuqunax:ucrc ca+caauua a ncxuc c.c-
c nc.oeucu+o om euno {o:+nocmnox :uq
o:onoe {o.nonu+. nc{eoumc:ono:o c:c{-
cmeu+. noomo u c{o (ycua uaa. ~
M. l.) a nca(c, yc.aucaxcuuc +acuc
(+. J c.. JO7O lK IU).
2) O.c.uau:u acnc. uayacuua, .c cc.:
cy_cc.acuucc.: uxu uccy_cc.acuucc.: uay-
acuua +acua nu ncxy+cuuu (ca+a.cx:c.aa.
lc acnccy axuauua cy_cc.acuucc.u ua-
yacuuu +acua ua (cnyc.ucc.: ncxy+cuu:x
(ca+a.cx:c.a a uac.ca_cc aca cy_cc.ayc.
(ac ccucau:x nc+uquu.
O(ua u+ uux ccc.cu. a .c, +.c xua: cy_c-
c.acuu:c uayacuua +acua axcy. +a cccu
uc(cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a
JJ
. 1au ca-
+c, +a(a+a, c.ca_aa ncc( c.ccuuuau (au-
ucu nc+uquu, ccc.cu. a xaccuuaquu uay-
acuuu +acua, yc.aucaxcuuu u.cua cy_c-
c.acuucc.u (uccy_cc.acucc.u) uayacuuu.
lc(c.aau.cxu a.ccu nc+uquu (H. H. My-
xuu, B. M. Caauquu), uanc.ua, ncxara., +.c
(ca+a.cx:c.aa, ncxy+cuu:c c uayacuuc +a-
cua, (cxu: nu+uaaa.:ca uc(cnyc.u:u
uc+aaucuc c. xaa.ca ncqcccyax:u:x ua-
yacuuu
J4
. lcxu nu arycu.aquu caccu nc-
+uquu H. H. Myxuu ucxc(u. u+ qcxcc.ucc.u
ncqcccyax:ucu c:, u+ aauc+ua+ucc.u
nc(.aaxac:x ucu +acuc .ccaauuu,
uayacuuc xcrc u+ c.c:x uc nc+acxac.
cqcuu.: ncxy+cuu:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa c .c+u
+cuua (cc.cacucc.u, .c B. M. Caauquu
a nuuqunc acca.uaac. acacrc c(a ncn:.-
u xaccuuqucaa.: uayacuua ua c+ycxca-
uc ac(y_uc uc(cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a
u cry_uc :.: accncxucuu:u (u, ccc.ac.-
c.acuuc, uc axcy_uc uc(cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a-
.cx:c.a) ncc+u:u, .a a .c. ny.: cc.
ccacuuc xarccxcau.: ua .a ua+:aac:c uc-
+ua+u.cx:u:c uayacuua +acua, cc+(a.: cc-
ncqc(cu.uy ucaxu ncqcccyax:u:x uc
nc c.cncuu ux aaucc.u u a c+yx:.a.c yrxy-
u.: u c+ .crc ucaxy c+u +acuucc.u
a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac. Hayacuua acc-
r(a cc.auy.ca uayacuuau, u cc.:ca c uuu,
yc(cu, uyuc c(uu xua: cncccc: uaa+:-
aa.: +a xcc uayacuuc nu+uauuc ccnxc(-
ucc.u, uu+cucc.u +a.a+cuu:x ycuxuu
J5
.
lccxc(uaa nc+uqua nc(c.aaxac.ca ua
naaux:ucu. ,cuc.au.cx:uc, c.aaa nu+uauuc
(ca+a.cx:c.aa uc(cnyc.u: a +aaucucc.:
c. c.cncuu axuauua (cny_cuucrc uayacuua
+acua ua crc (cc.cacucc.:, ccx(cuuc naa
ra(au, a+ac naacnucuu.cx: uc nc(c-
uac. +acuc(a.cxa, yc.aucauaacrc +anc. ua uc-
ncx:+caauuc .aux (ca+a.cx:c.a' O(uac, a
c.c+ac. B. B. cxc.:x, .ac a+(cxa_uu
(auuy .c+y +cuua, cy(cuaa na.ua nc-
axa nc (yrcy ny.u
J6
.
l(uuc.acuu:u, ua uaa a+rxa(, uayac-
uuau, c.c:c cuc c+cc.: uccy_cc.acu-
u:u, aaxa.ca .cxuu+ccuc cauu, .c cc.:
c+cau(u:c cnucu ( nucy, ya+auuc a a-
+cc.ac rc(a a nc.ccxc uc 2OO9, a 2OOO9),
uc uayaa_uc uu naaa y+ac.uuca nc-
qccca, uu .ccaauua yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucu c:.
4. Cxc(yc. .ac +acuc(a.cx:uc +ac-
nu.: ncxccuuc, c.ucca_ccca nccxc(c.aua
nucucuua (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncxy+cuu:x c ua-
yacuuc +acua, a ucuuc ncxccuuc c .c,
JJ
C., uan.: lc:un A. P. 1ccua (ca+:aauua
a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac. M., 2OO5. C. 249;
Bcmoeo l. H. \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa c.ac.-
c.acuucc.:. M., J987. C. JO5JO6; lo:ce C. B.
Ocuca: .ccuu (ca+:aauua a ccac.cc naac-
cy(uu. Muuc, J969. C. J62J6J; Cmcqoecuu
K. H.. oun A. M. Kcuc.u.yqucuu:u nuu-
qun cccnc+cuua cauuaccy naaa ua +a_u.y.
M., J988. C. JOJ.
J4
C.: Coeuquu B. M. \rcxcau:u ncqccc Icc-
cuu ua ucac au.c (cca.u+aquu lccy(a-
c.ac u naac. J994. ` 6. C. JO6; Mxun H. H.
O.c.uauaa uc.uua u ucc.c:c acncc: cqcuu
cy(cu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a nu ccy_cc.axcuuu na-
accy(ua. ^., J97J. C. J2J.
J5
C.: Coeuquu B. M. lc+ynqua ucauucauc-
c.u. M., J997. C. 828J.
J6
C.: do:omox B. B. lcaca (cnyc.ucc.u
(ca+a.cx:c.a a yrcxcauc ncqcccc. Icc.ca-ua-
,cuy, J999. C. 46.
M. C. lc:ooeo:ocuu. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac
J8
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
+.c (ca+a.cx:c.aa, ncu+ac(u:c c. (ca+a-
.cx:c.a u uu:x (auu:x, ncxy+cuu:x c uay-
acuuc +acua, .ac aaxa.ca uc(cnyc.u:u
(u+acc.ucc a yrcxcauc ncqcccc c.au c-
_crc naaa, a u:uc u a cccuucc yrcxcauc
ncqcccc nc( ua+aauuc (c.uu: nxc(ca
c.aaxcuucrc (ccaa
J7
).
O.cy.c.ayc. ya+auuc ua naauxc nxc(ca
c.aaxcuucrc (ccaa u a a.ax Bcxcaucrc
Cy(a IU c_crc xaa.ca: ncc.aucaxcuuax
nxcuyca, c+cax cy(cucu na.uu, c.ac.ax
ua acncc:, y.ac(cuu:x ncc.aucaxcuuc
lc+u(uya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU. 1c uc
cucc, Bcxcau:u Cy( Icccuuccu Uc(ca-
quu nu(cuaac.ca (auucu naacacu nc+u-
quu a cy(cu:x ncc.aucaxcuuax nc c.(cx:-
u: (cxa
J8
.
lu+uauu uc(cnyc.u:u u ucx+cuu
nc(xca. uc .cx:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa, ncxy+cu-
u:c c uayacuuc +acua, uc u (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa, ncu+ac(u:c c. uux. A. Uyauxca u A. ^c-
auca ua nucc (ca+a.cx:c.a, ncu+ac(u:x
c. ac_cc.acuu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a u (cycu.ca,
cnaac(xuac c.c+a., +.c ac_cc.acuu:c
(ca+a.cx:c.aa u (cycu.:, ncxy+cuu:c nc-
cc(c.ac cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu, ncu+ac(cu-
u:x c uayacuuc +acua, a (ax:ucuac c-
ry. :.: nuc_cu: u uccxc(caau: a .c+uc
ccc.ac.c.auu c ncqccccyax:u:u ucau.
Hc .c cc.ca.cx:c.ac uc cc. cxyu.: cc-
ucaauuc (xa nu+uauua ux (cnyc.u:u (c-
a+a.cx:c.aau
J9
.
K ncu+ac(u: (ca+a.cx:c.aa, nc ua-
acy ucuu, c.ucca.ca cxc(y_uc:
J) ncxy+ac:c ua ccucac (yrux (ca+a-
.cx:c.a a cuxy nacrc ya+auua +acua (c+-
uaa c.aaa, ncaca nca+auuu ua cc.c, c-
.c: a ca+a.cx:uc nca(c (cxcu nc(-
acc.acaa.: (cncc xuqa [xuq|, nca+auua c-
.ccrc y.c+ua.ca uxu ncaca.ca) uxu a
cuxy (c+acxcuua +acua ((cncc, ua c.cc
(cnaauaaccy (ccuc.uyc.ca ac_cc.acu-
ucc (ca+a.cx:c.ac);
2) ncxy+cuu:c a xc(c ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cy(cu:x) uxu uu:x ncqcccyax:-
u:x (cuc.auu (+ax+cuuc cnc.a, aaxa-
_ccca u.crc cnc.ucrc uccxc(caauua c-
a+qca (xa caauu.cx:ucrc uccxc(caauua [nc(-
ucr.ca:x cc+ca|, c.c:c uc uc. c.a.yca
(ca+a.cx:c.a, uc ncxy+cu: a c+yx:.a.c cxc(-
c.acuucrc (cuc.aua [a+a.uc ca+qca (xa caa-
uu.cx:ucrc uccxc(caauua uxu a xc(c ccc.a
.yna|);
J) ncxy+cuu:c ua ccucac cac(cuuu, acc-
nuua.:x a xc(c ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu u uc +aucucaauu:x ncqcccyax:uc
(.a, y+ac.uuu c:ca accnuuua. u xa-
ua. a naa.u cc.ca.cx:c.aa ncu+ac(c.aa
ya+auucrc cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua); nccc(-
c.ac ncqcccyax:ucu xcraxu+aquu ya+auu:x
cac(cuuu (ny.c (cnccca cxc(caa.cxcu, y+a-
c.acaaaaux a xc(c cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua),
ncccx:y c+cu: +ac.c c.ccua cauucuua xuc
(ac cy( cxcuu: accncxuu.: (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa, ncxy+cuu:c c uayacuuc +acua, uxu
cc+(a.: uca:c +aq-(ca+a.cx:c.aa
2O
.
J7
C.: lcno+ Y. laacaaa cuc.ca CHA. M.,
2OO6. C. 5O25OJ.
J8
C.: lcc.aucaxcuuc lc+u(uya Bcxcaucrc
Cy(a ICUCI nc (cxy luccaa lcc.aucaxc-
uua u cnc(cxcuua nc yrcxcau: (cxa Bc-
xcaucrc Cy(a ICUCI (J98JJ988) lc( c(.
l. A. Ccxcuqcaa. M., J988. C. J8JJ84; lc-
c.aucaxcuuc lc+u(uya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
c. J5 aa J996 r. nc (cxy Kacucaa lxx.
Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU. J996. ` 8. C. JOJJ.
J9
veu:ce A.. oonoe A. lxc(: c.aaxcuucrc
(ccaa Icc. c.uqua, J996. ` JJ. C. 4849.
2O
B ccc.ac.c.auu c naacacu nc+uqucu Kcuc.u-
.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU u Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
ncxy+cuu:c .au cncccc cac(cuua acca.-
uaa.ca a a+cc.ac uc(cnyc.u:x (ca+a.cx:c.a.
C.: Onc(cxcuuc Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu c. 6 caaxa 2OO4 r.
` 44-O lc axcc ra(auuua ,c:aucuc
Bxa(uua Hucxacau+a ua uayacuuc crc cu-
c.u.yqucuu:x naa ncxccuuau c.a.cu 56, 246,
278 u J55 \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c(cca
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu Ccauuc +acuc(a-
.cx:c.aa Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. 2OO4. ` J4.
C.. JJ4J; Bcc.u. Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu. 2OO4. ` 5. 1c uc cucc,
cccu(aquu accncxua.: y_cu:c (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa ucuuc nccc(c.ac (auucu rynn: ucc(c
J9
Hc.uuucc.: ncxccuua c nxc(ax c.aa-
xcuucrc (ccaa ccuca:aac.ca ua .c, +.c, ac-
nca:x, a nc.uauc cxy+ac cccc:cxuaac.-
ca cac .ccaauuc (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a-
.cx:c.a: u+ nc(ncxccuua c .c, +.c ncxy+cu-
ucc c uayacuuc +acua (ca+a.cx:c.ac, ncu-
(a rcuuxc ncqcccyax:ucu xcraxu+aquu,
accc.auaaxuaac. y.a+cuucc cacuc.ac (cnyc-
.ucc.u, cxc(yc. a:ac( c nuuqunuax:ucu ac+-
cucc.u acuy.: cacuc.ac (cnyc.ucc.u
xcy (ca+a.cx:c.ay, auc +aaucucc.u c.
xaa.ca uayacuua yc.aucaxcuucu +acuc
ncqc(y: crc ncxy+cuua.
Bc-a.c:x, nu+uauuc ncacua+ax:ucrc
(ca+a.cx:c.aa uc(cnyc.u:, .c cc.: xuac-
uuc crc c.a.yca cc(c.aa yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:ucrc (ca+:aauua, nuac(u. .cy, +.c
ncacua+ax:ucc (ca+a.cx:c.ac, ca+a.cx:uc
nc(acc.ay_cc (xuc cxya_cc a.cuaxc)
ncxy+cuu ncu+ac(ucrc, c.cy.c.ayc. xuc,
a xy+ac cxy+ac, cc. acca.uaa.:ca a
ucncqcccyax:uaa uucaqua. 1au ca-
+c, ca+:aac.ca ucccx(cuu: uccxc(u-
cc ycxcauc ncu+ac(c.aa cy(cucrc (cuc.aua,
.c cc.: ncucxc(u. .ac u uayacuuc yc.a-
ucaxcuucrc ncqcccyax:ucrc nca(a ncxy+c-
uua ncu+ac(ucrc (ca+a.cx:c.aa, +.c axc+c.
uc(cnyc.ucc.: nccxc(ucrc.
1c.uu arycu. a nc(.ac(cuuc uc.uu-
ucc.u ncc.yxa.a c nxc(ax c.aaxcuucrc (c-
caa ucc. uc naacacu, a cax:uc-xcru-
+ccuu xaa.c.
lcu+ac(ucc (ca+a.cx:c.ac ~ .c (c-
a+a.cx:c.ac, nc cc(cauu xuc .c(cc.acu-
ucc ncacua+ax:ucy, xuc cc(ca_cc cu:-
auu c.c uucaquu, +c ncacua+ax:ucc,
xuc cc(ca_cc a ccc a xccu.: ncac-
ua+ax:ucrc (ca+a.cx:c.aa, .a u xccu.:
acrc-xuc uucrc. lcccx:y : nc+u-
yc, +.c (ca+a.cx:c.ac, uc(cnyc.ucc acxc(-
c.auc (cny_cuu:x nu crc ncxy+cuuu uay-
acuuu +acua ~ (ca+a.cx:c.ac o cioci uc-
(cc.cacucc, cc+ua+u ncacua+ax:ucc
uc(cnyc.ucc (ca+a.cx:c.ac a xcucc a:c-
a+:aauuc (^), (yrcc (ca+a.cx:c.ac, ncaxu-
aaacc ua cc(cauuc ncu+ac(ucrc (ca+a-
.cx:c.aa (nc caccu cy.u .ac ncacua+ax:-
ucc nc c.ucacuu ucy), nuc +a uc.uuucc
(H), ncccx:y c aux-xuc ccucaauuax (xa
nu+uauua crc uc(cnyc.u: ua ucu+acc.-
uc. Ic+yx:.a. c ccc(uucuua uc.uuucrc u xc-
ucrc a:ca+:aauua, a u+acc.uc u+ cax:-
ucu xcruu, c ucu+cucc.: nuac(u. xc-
ucy a:ca+:aauu. U.c c acac.ca cu.yaquu
.c(cc.aa cc(cauua ncacua+ax:ucrc u nc-
u+ac(ucrc (ca+a.cx:c.a, .c u+ cax:ucu xc-
ruu .ac aac.ayc.: xcc a:ca+:aauuc, a .c
+ucxc u xcucc, .c(cc.acuuc cacy ccc (xc:
.c(cc.acuua xu). 1c cxcc .c acuc (xa
cu.yaquu, cr(a ncu+ac(ucc a:ca+:aauuc
nc(c.aaxac. cccu xua: +ac.: ncacua+ax:uc-
rc xcucrc a:ca+:aauua.
H ~ uc.uuucc a:ca+:aauuc, ^ ~ xc-
ucc a:ca+:aauuc.
^ H ^, ^ ^
lcxccuua c nxc(ax c.aaxcuucrc (cc-
aa nu(cuaac.ca a cacux ncc.aucaxcuuax
u lacncucuu Cy( nc naaa +cxcaca
2J
.
(a.ca a y+cu:u-ncqcccyaxuc.au, .a u
na.u+ccuu (ca.cxau. 1acu ccac., nuc-
y, (ac. nc., (- u(. uay, +xcu nc+u(uya
Kcc.cccrc cxac.ucrc cy(a M. Haxyca (c.:
Lo:+oe M. C. Hcncx:+caauuc a.cuaxca, cc-
auu:x (c ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa a a-
+cc.ac (ca+a.cx:c.a \rcxcau:u ncqccc. 2OO5.
` J. C. JJJ2).
2J
C.: Galca v. Gcroaay. Hucaqua c (cxc /
lxx. lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa +cxcaca.
2OO8. ` JJ; {allcl v. Gcroaay. Hucaqua c
(cxc lxx. lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa +c-
xcaca. 2OO7. ` 2.
M. C. lc:ooeo:ocuu. ,cnyc.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac
2O
A. B. Eoupcnou
Hpo6xcmr rxaccnqnraunn
ynpomcnnr cyc6nr nponsuocru
no crcncnn cxonnocrn
yroxouno-npoucccyaxrno qopmr
Aneucanppa Bnapumupouna Bonpcuan,
acnnpanxa xaqepu
yroroanoro npoecca n xpnunnarncnxn
Oucxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
luc.ynaa accc.cuu +aaaxcuucu .c:, nc(c accrc
a+ccca c ccucau:u .cuuau, c.c:c y(y. uau uc-
ncx:+caa.:ca. lcxarac, +.c (xa uaucxcc ncxucrc ccac_cuua
acncca uccxc(uc cnc(cxu.:ca c uaau ncuuauuc .aux
a.crcuu, a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc ncu+ac(c.ac, cy(cucc
ncu+ac(c.ac u ync_cuucc cy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac, c.c:c u
ccc.aaa. a+uc (auucrc uccxc(caauua.
H.a, nc( yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: ncu+ac(c.ac : nc-
uuac qcx:u:u naacnucuu.cx:u:u ncqccc nc c.(cx:ucy
u(u+cccy (cxy c. crc uuuquaquu a yc.aucaxcuuc +acuc
nca(c (c +aacacuua a:ucccuuc u.crcacrc ncqcccyax:ucrc
cacuua.
Cy(cu: ncu+ac(c.ac a (auucu caa+u cccucaauuc ua-
+:aa.: cy(cu:u qux (ca+a.cx:c.acuucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, c.c-
:u cc. :.: +ac.: c.(cx:ucrc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc
ncu+ac(c.aa uxu (ac ncxucc.: crc uc+cn:aa.:.
\nc_cuucc cy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac uau acca.uaac.-
ca a cy(cu:u qux (ca+a.cx:c.acuucu (ca-
.cx:ucc.u, ync_cuuc c.ccrc (cc.urac.ca xa-
rc(aa xuau(aquu a crc ncqc(yc accx ucuy-
u:x cax:ucc.cu u ccu: c a:acuua nc-
qcccyax:u:x raau.uu c qcx: nuac(cuua ync-
_cuucu ncqc(y: a ccc.ac.c.auc cc c.ca_uu
ncc( ucu cncquax:u:u +a(a+au, uc nu cc.aaxcuuu ucu+cu-
u:u naa, c.c:c ccc.aaxa. ccucay naacacrc yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucrc c.a.yca ra(au, acaxc+cuu:x a ncqc(yy yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa.
H.a, cnc(cxuaauc: c a+ca:u .cuuau, ncxccuu:-
u a ccucay (auucrc uccxc(caauua, yac, +.c a.crcua ync-
_cuucrc cy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa ca+aua cacu cy_cc.acaa-
uuc xaccuuaquu ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cnc-
uu cxcucc.u ux yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c:, a+(cxa-
_cu ux ua c_uu nca(c ncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxy, ync_cuu:c
2J
ncu+ac(c.aa u ncu+ac(c.aa c cxcc cxc-
u:u ncqcccyax:u:u cau
J
. Iaccc.-
u nc(cucc (auuy xaccuuaqu.
B ncac nuxucuuu cuc ca+a.:, +.c
cua (cc.a.c+uc .a(uqucuua. O(uac nu cc
ucncx:+caauuu cxc(yc. y+u.:aa.: .c, +.c nc-
nauycaa xaccuuaqua aaxac.ca ac uc-
rc ycxcaucu. lc+cy : nuxc(u (auuc-
y a:ac(y'
Bc-nca:x, (axcc uc accr(a (uccuqu-
caauucc ncu+ac(c.ac cc(cu. a ccc .cx:-
c xccu.:, ync_a_uc uxu ycxcua_uc
ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy. Ka na-
aux:uc c.c+ac. ,. l. Bcxuuu: B nccxc-
(uuc ucccx:c xc. a +acuc(a.cx:c.ac uac-
.uxac: (cacx:uc uu.cccuaa .cu(cuqua, +ax-
+a_aaca a .c, +.c ucacaac(cuu:c ncqcc-
cyax:u:c c:, uanaaxcuu:c ua ycxcuc-
uuc ncqccca, yc.aucaxcuuc (cncxuu.cx:u:x
raau.uu, cc(ca. a ccc ucc.c:c ync-
_cuu:c ncqc(y:, a, a cac c+cc(:, nc-
c.:c ncqcccyax:u:c c: ~ cnc(cxcu-
ucc ycxcucuuc
2
.
B a+cc.ac nuca ync_cuucrc ncu+-
ac(c.aa, (xa c.ccrc xaa.cuc ucc.ccc
ycxcucuuc ncqcccyax:ucu c:, cuc
ua+aa.: ncu+ac(c.ac nc (cxy +ac.ucrc cau-
ucuua y ucacrc cy(:u, a aax c.ccrc
y nc(cy(ucrc ucc.ca ac+cucc.: ca.u.:-
ca cc ac.c+ucu axccu a c.ucacuuu +ac.-
ucrc cauuu.cxa.
B .ac cxy+ac a ccc.ac.c.auu c +. J
c.. J2J \lK IU accc.cuuc +aaaxcuua
nc yrcxcaucy (cxy +ac.ucrc cauucuua c-
c. :.: ccc(uucuc a c(uc ncu+ac(c.ac c
accc.cuuc ac.c+ucrc +aaaxcuua. lu cc-
c(uucuuu +aaaxcuuu a c(uc ncu+ac(c.ac xuqa,
nc(aaauc ux, y+ac.ay. a yrcxcauc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.ac c(ucaccuuc a a+cc.ac +ac.-
u:x cauuu.cxcu u nc(cy(u:x. A .c c+ua-
+ac., +.c a aax (auucrc ync_cuucrc nc-
u+ac(c.aa ccy_cc.axac.ca y(accuuc nc-
qccca (ca+:aauua, .a a cuc ncu+ac(u.-
ca c(ucaccuuc a c.ucacuuu ncau+ucu u
ac.c+ucu axc.
Bc-a.c:x, acca.uaacy xaccuua-
qu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a
cuc ua+aa.: ycxcaucu c_c u nc.cy, +.c
cua acncc.auac.ca uc .cx:c ua yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa, uc +a+ac.y
cxaa.:aac. cccu .ac nc(au(: cy(cu:x u
(ccy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a.
1a a +a(a+cu (auucu c.a.:u aaxac.ca
accc.cuuc .crc, a anuc:aa.ca a xac-
cuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+-
ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu c: ync_cuu:c cy(cu:c
ncu+ac(c.aa, ca.uca acnccy c .c, a-
uc ync_cuu:c ncu+ac(c.aa a:(cxa.ca
a aax acca.uaaccrc cnccca ux (u-
ccuquaquu.
K. K. Hucau+ u 1. ,. lau +ucxy
ync_cuu:x c.ucca. ncu+ac(c.ac, a c.cc
accxc(caauuc crauu+uaac.ca (c+uauuc, nc-
u+ac(c.ac, nc(ycc.cuucc rxaacu 4O \lK
IU, ncu+ac(c.ac y ucacrc cy(:u nc (cxa
+ac.ucrc cauucuua, ncu+ac(c.ac a cy(c ancx-
xaqucuucu uuc.auquu
J
.
A. l. lc+aca a (auucu caa+u ya+:aa-
c., +.c a ccaccuuc yrcxcauc ncqcccc
cy_cc.ay. .u ccucau:x au(a ync_cuucrc
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa: ncu+ac(c.ac
nc (cxa +ac.ucrc cauucuua, +ac+ucc ac-
cc.cuuc yrcxcaucrc (cxa, ncu+ac(c.ac nc
yrcxcaucy (cxy a cccc nca(c nuua.ua
J
C.: A:cccce H. C.. oce B. l.. looce . .
O+c a+au.ua uayu ccac.ccrc yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca. Bccuc, J98O. C. JJ; B M. .
O ccacacuc.acaauuu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc
+acuc(a.cx:c.aa Bcc.u. Mcccaccrc yu-.a.
Ccua X. laac. J964. ` 2. C. J2; Bu+o-
eu K. l. C.y.ya ccac.ccrc yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca: cuc.ca c.a(uu u cuc.ca ncu+ac(c.a.
Ocucau:c u (cncxuu.cx:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa. 1cc,
J99J. C. 2J22; Bu+oeu K. l.. Hon 7. .
Cy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac nc \lK Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu. Cl., 2OO5. C. 22; Bc:uuu . H.
l(uuc.ac u (uccuquaqua yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:ucu c:: uc.cua, ccaccuucc.:, ncc-
nc.ua:: Aa.cc. (uc. ... au(. u(. uay. M.,
2OOJ. C. J9.
2
Bc:uuu . H. \a+. cc+. C. J9.
J
C.: Bu+oeu K. l.. Hon 7. . \a+. cc+.
C. 22.
A. B. lo+co+. lcxc: xaccuuaquu ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a
22
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
cy(cucrc cacuua nu ccrxacuu cauuacc-
rc c nc(.aaxcuu: cauucuuc
4
.
B nc.uacacc nc(c.aaxcuucu nc+uquu
A. H. Haca +ucxy ync_cuu:x yrcxca-
uc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a c.uccu. nc-
u+ac(c.ac nc (cxa +ac.ucrc cauucuua, acc
(cncxuu.cx:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa u cx:auuc.ac
ccc:x ncu+ac(c.a. K +ucxy ync_cuu:x
cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a yncauy.:u aa.c c.-
uccu. ncu+ac(c.ac nc (cxa +ac.ucrc cau-
ucuua, ncu+ac(c.ac nc nuua.u cy(cucrc
cacuua c+ ncac(cuua cy(cucrc a+ua-
.cx:c.aa, +ac+ucc accc.cuuc (cxa
5
. Auaxc-
ru+u:u ncc+cu: ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x nc-
u+ac(c.a nuac(u. u H. l. ,ycau
6
.
Oa.u auuauuc ua .c. a., +.c
A. H. Haca u H. l. ,ycau, rcaca c (c-
ncxuu.cx:u:x u ccc:x ncu+ac(c.aax, ca-
_a.ca a+ac.auucu K. K. Hucau+c
xaccuuaquu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x nc-
u+ac(c.a (nc ux uanaaxcuucc.u) ua ccuca-
u:c, (cncxuu.cx:u:c u ccc:c
7
.
Ka au(u, (axcc uc accr(a aa.c:, a:-
c.auaaa cac xaccuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c:, y+u.:aa.
a+xu+ua c(y ync_cuu: yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u: ncu+ac(c.ac u ync_cuu: cy(c-
u: ncu+ac(c.ac.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c acca.uaaccu xac-
cuuaqucu, ccucau:c ncu+ac(c.aa ~ .c
ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa. Ouu ua-
naaxcu: ua yc.aucaxcuuc yrcxcauc-naacac-
rc c.ucacuua u crc cc(cauua
8
. ,cncxuu-
.cx:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa uanaaxcu: ua u+c-
ucuuc uxu (ccc+ucc nca_cuuc yc.auca-
xcuucrc u +acnxcuucrc nurcacc cy(a yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c.ucacuua
9
. Occ:c
ncu+ac(c.aa ~ .c ncu+ac(c.aa, cccnc+u-
aa_uc nucucuuc a aax yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca uc uucrc, uccxu yrcxcauc-naacu,
xaa.ca
JO
.
Ka au(u, (axcc uc accr(a aa.c:, a:c.-
auaaa cac xaccuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u
ux yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c:, y+u.:-
aa. a+xu+ua c(y ync_cuu: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:u: ncu+ac(c.ac u ync_cu-
u: cy(cu: ncu+ac(c.ac.
A. H. Haca, accncxuaa ya+auu:u uc-
(c+c., a+(cxac. ync_cuu:c yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa u ync_cuu:c cy(c-
u:c ncu+ac(c.aa, y+u.:aaa ux a aax c.-
(cx:u:x xaccuuaquu. ,auuaa nc+uqua
nc(c.aaxac.ca (cc.a.c+uc cccucaauucu, c(-
uac c ucu ucx:+a c+crcacc+uc ccrxacu.:ca
nc .cu nu+uuc, +.c (auu:u aa.c y+u.:aac.
a aax c(ucu u .cu c xaccuuaquu cc-
ucau:c, ccc:c u (cncxuu.cx:u:c ncu+ac(-
c.aa. lc(cuaa .c+a +cuua nc(c.aaxac.ca
cncucu, ac(: ncc.ccuuc ya+auucu xaccu-
uaquu c+ua+ac., +.c : ccncc.aaxac acc
uc_ucca a aax yrcxcaucrc ncqccca nc-
u+ac(c.aa c ucu ucxc(u: ncu+ac(-
c.ac ~ ca+qc, .axcuc. Hau.u nc(c-
u:u c_uu +uacua.cx: (xa ccucau:x, (c-
ncxuu.cx:u:x u ccc:x ncu+ac(c.a ~ (cc-
.a.c+uc cxcuaa +a(a+a.
Bc+aa_aac: nuac(cuu: a:ac nu-
ca ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a, c.-
ucca_uxca ccucau: ncu+ac(c.aa, c-
uc ca+a.:, +.c, +a ucx+cuuc ncu+ac(-
c.aa y ucacrc cy(:u nc (cxa +ac.ucrc
cauucuua, cuu nc(c.aaxa. cccu uc cc-
c.acuuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c ncu+ac(-
c.aa, a yncacuu:c cy(cu:c qux: qcx:uc-
rc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc ncu+ac(c.aa,
4
looce A. E. Occ:u nca(c cy(cucrc a+-
ua.cx:c.aa a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac IU:
,uc. ... au(. u(. uay. Bxa(uu, 2OO5. C. 26.
5
C.: L+oce A. H. Occ:u nca(c cy(cucrc
a+ua.cx:c.aa (acncc: .ccuu u na.uu):
,uc. ... au(. u(. uay. Hcac, 2OO4. C. 4J.
6
C.: oeu H. H. Occ:u nca(c cy(c-
ucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa u crc cc.c a cuc.cc yn-
c_cuu:x ncu+ac(c.a nc yrcxcau: (cxa:
,uc. ... au(. u(. uay. M., 2OO4. C. J2JJ.
7
C.: Bu+oeu K. l. C.y.ya ccac.ccrc
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca: cuc.ca c.a(uu u cuc.ca
ncu+ac(c.a. C. JO.
8
1a c. C. JJ.
9
Bu+oeu K. l. C.y.ya ccac.ccrc yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca... C. JJ.
JO
7o+ +c. C. J9.
2J
.c cc.: ync_cuu:c cy(cu:c ncu+ac(c.aa.
,auu:c ync_cuu:c cy(cu:c ncu+ac(c.aa
uc aaxa.ca ncxucc.: uc+aaucu:u, a nc(-
c.aaxa. cccu +ac.: c.(cx:ucrc, cxcucrc
nc caccu c.y.yc ncu+ac(c.aa.
Ha ccucaauuu u+xccuucrc cuc +ax-
+u.:, +.c nu uccxc(caauuu nuc(: ync_cu-
u:x ncu+ac(c.a u nu ncn:.c anuca.: ux
a xaccuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x
ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c: cxc(yc. y+u.:-
aa.:, +.c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c ncu+ac(-
c.aa (ncuc yncuuaaauxca a (auucu c.a-
.:c xaccuuaquu) .ac cry. :.: (u-
ccuqucaau: nc cxcucc.u caccrc ccc.aaa
ua ncc.:c u cxcucccc.aau:c ncu+ac(c.aa.
lcc.:u ncu+ac(c.aau cuc ua+aa.:
ncu+ac(c.aa, a c.c:x ncqccc (ca+a.cx:-
c.acuucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, ax+a_uu a cca
ccuauuc, ncacy, cqcuy u ucncx:+caauuc
(ca+a.cx:c.a, ccacaac.ca c(uca.uc u nc(
ycac(c.ac c(ucrc axac.ucrc cy.c.a.
K +ucxy .aux ncu+ac(c.a cuc c.ucc.u nc-
u+ac(c.ac y ucacrc cy(:u nc (cxa +ac.uc-
rc cauucuua.
B nc.uacacc ya+auucy, cxcucccc.aa-
u:c ncu+ac(c.aa ~ .c ncu+ac(c.aa, c.y-
.ya c.c:x ax+ac. a cca, a .c ucc.
cc.c a aax c:+ucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, c.uc-
cucrc K. K. Hucau+c +ucxy ccuca-
u:x
JJ
, ucccx:c ((aa
J2
uxu .u
JJ
~ +aaucu. c.
nc+uquu acca.uaa_crc (auuy ncxcy
aa.ca) quxca (ca+a.cx:c.acuucu (ca.cx:-
ucc.u u nc(ncxarac. u+cucuuc nc xc(y ccy-
_cc.axcuua ncu+ac(c.aa cy.c.a, nucua-
_crc uc: naaa.
H.a, ucruc aa.c:, a:c.auaa_uc xac-
cuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+-
ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucu c:, ax+a. a acca.uaac-
y xaccuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x
ncu+ac(c.a ync_cuu:c cy(cu:c ncu+ac(-
c.aa acc.c cxcucccc.aau:x ncu+ac(c.a.
Ax:.cua.uaucu cuc ua+aa.: nc+uqu,
ccrxacuc c.ccu (uccuqucaauu:c yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c ncu+ac(c.aa u (u-
ccuqucaauu:c cy(cu:c u (ccy(cu:c
ncu+ac(c.aa y+u.:aa.ca c.(cx:uc a a-
ax a+xu+u:x xaccuuaquu.
lcxarac, +.c a.caa .c+a +cuua nc(-
nc+.u.cx:ucc, uc xua: a cxy+ac, ccxu a a-
ax xaccuuaquu cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a nc
c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucu c: uc c.c(uua.ca ncqcccyax:-
u:c ncu+ac(c.aa a+xu+ucu uanaaxcuucc-
.u ~ ccucau:c, ccc:c u (cncxuu.cx:u:c.
Kacu ncc+cu: ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x
ncu+ac(c.a : a .ac cxy+ac ncxy+u' lc-
xarac, cuc.cy ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x ncu+-
ac(c.a a c.c+cc.acuuc yrcxcauc ncqcccc
ca+y. ncu+ac(c.ac nc (cxa +ac.ucrc
cauucuua y ucacrc cy(:u, +ac+u:u nca(c
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa, ccc:u nca(c
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa, nc(ycc.cuu:u
rx. 4O \lK IU, u ccc:u nca(c cy(cuc-
rc a+ua.cx:c.aa nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(c-
ucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, +acnxcu-
u:u a rx. 4O
J
\lK IU.
lcu+ac(c.ac y ucacrc cy(:u nu .c
c(ucaccuuc aaxac.ca u qcx:u: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:u: ncu+ac(c.ac.
lc(cxaa cacc accy(cuuc, yac, +.c
a cxy+ac ucx+cuua u+ xaccuuaquu yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cnc-
uu cxcucc.u ux yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu
c: nc(au(ca cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a ncc(
uau ac.ac. ncxca ac+cucc.u ax+cuua
a ya+auuy xaccuuaqu cxcucccc.aau:x
ncu+ac(c.a.
Hau.u c.ac. uc .a ncc.c, ncccx:y :
ucc (cxc cc cxcu:u nc caccu c.y.y-
c ca+caauuau, uc acc +ac.u c.c:x c-
ry. uccu.: ync_cuu:u xaa.c. Hanuc,
accxc(caauuc nc yrcxcaucy (cxy ncu+ac-
(u.ca a cc cxc(c.aua, uc +a.c nucua-
c.ca ync_cuu:u nca(c cy(cucrc a+u-
a.cx:c.aa, nc(ycc.cuu:u rx. 4O \lK IU.
JJ
C.: Bu+oeu K. l.. Hon 7. . \a+. cc+.
C. 24.
J2
C.: do+uquu B. H. laacaaa crxacu.a-
qua (ca+:aauua nc yrcxcaucy (cxy Cca. c-
.uqua. J987. ` J2. C. J8.
JJ
C.: Ee{ou+oeo E. l. Quxu+ucc.: naac-
nucucuua laacac(cuuc. 2OOJ. ` 6. C. 2J.
A. B. lo+co+. lcxc: xaccuuaquu ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a
24
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Ka a .ac cxy+ac cnc(cxu.: nuc(y (au-
ucrc ncu+ac(c.aa'
Mcuc nc(xcu.: .u aauau.a cac-
uua ncxc: a +aaucucc.u c. .crc, +.c nc-
uuac.ca nc( ync_cuu: ncu+ac(c.ac.
Bc-nca:x, : cc acca.uaa.: (au-
ucc ncu+ac(c.ac a ccaauucc: +ac.u+uc
ncu+ac(ucc a c:+uc cuc u +ac.u+uc
ync_cuucc. B .ac cxy+ac : ucxc(u u+
ncuuauua ync_cuucrc ncu+ac(c.aa a nc-
u+ac(c.aa, acc ccc.aau:c +ac.u c.ccrc ca-
xu+y.ca a au(cu+cucuuc ~ ync_cu-
uc ~ cuc.
Bc-a.c:x, : cc c.ucc.u ccc.ac.c.ay-
_cc ncu+ac(c.ac +ucxy ync_cuu:x ua
ccucaauuu .crc, +.c (xa .crc (cc.a.c+uc, +.c-
: xc.a : c(ua u+ crc +ua+u:x c.y.y-
u:x ccc.aaxa_ux ccy_cc.axaxac: a ync-
_cuuc cuc.
B-.c.:ux, : cc a nuuqunc c.a-
+a.:ca c. nucucuua cxcucccc.aau:
ucrcquxca: ncu+ac(c.aa xaccuuaquu
ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux nc-
qcccyax:ucu c:.
lcncyc cnc(cxu.:ca cc caccu .c+-
cu +cuua, ccuca:aaac: ua cxc(y_c ac-
cy(cuuu. Iacca.uaac:c cxcucccc.aa-
u:c ncu+ac(c.aa nc cy.u nc(c.aaxa. cc-
cu ncqc(y:, ccc.aau:c xccu.: c.c:x
ac ucrc cacc.ca.cx:u: u uc+aaucu: (yr
c. (yra.
Ka nc(c.aaxac.ca, a .c cxy+ac, ccxu (u-
ccuquaquu nc(acrxac: ncqcccyax:uaa c-
a .cx:c cy(cu:x uxu (ccy(cu:x c.a(uu
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, .c ncc( uau
(uccuqucaauucc cy(cucc uxu (ccy(c-
ucc ncu+ac(c.ac, a uc au(cu+cucuucc yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc ncu+ac(c.ac a qcxc
(ccxu .cx:c c+: uc u(c. c ync_cuuc nc-
u+ac(c.ac, ca+ycc .cx:c c(uu quxc
naacnucuu.cx:ucu [(ca+a.cx:c.acuucu|
(ca.cx:ucc.u).
lcxarac, +.c (xa nu+uauua yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucrc ncu+ac(c.aa (uccuqu-
caauu: uccxc(u: u+cucuua a ncqcc-
cyax:ucu cc (auucrc ncu+ac(c.aa ua uc-
ccx:ux c.a(uax, c.uccu:x a+u: qu-
xa ncu+ac(ucu a crc aax (ca+a.cx:-
c.acuucu (ca.cx:ucc.u.
,caau: +.c: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc
ncu+ac(c.ac a qcxc acca.uaaxcc: a
ync_cuucc, uc(cc.a.c+uc, +.c: a (auuc
ncu+ac(c.ac cxauu+ccu :xu c.c(uucu:
ync_cuuaa (ccy(cuaa u cy(cuaa +ac.u (ua-
nuc, accxc(caauuc, ccy_cc.axaccc a cc
(c+uauua, u cy(cucc a+ua.cx:c.ac a c-
c, nc(ycc.cuucu rx. 4O \lK IU). Hc.,
(auucc ncca+caauuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucu c: (cxuc uccu.: cuc.cu:u xaa-
.c u nc(ncxara.: nccac.y (ccy(c-
ucu u cy(cucu +ac.cu ncqccca (xa (cc.u-
cuua c(ucu u .cu c qcxu nc c(uucy +a-
:cxy. lucca nc(cucu (uccuquaquu
a aax (cuc.ay_crc \lK IU uc .a
ucrc u caa+au: cuu rxaau: ca+c c yc-
xcucuuc ncqcccyax:ucu c: yrcxcauc-
rc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa (uanuc, ncu+ac(c.ac
nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux). O(uac a c.-
ucacuuu ync_cuu:x ncu+ac(c.a a (auuc
acnc.c .ac :xu ncu+ac(cu: ucc.c:c
ncccu:. Ic+: u(c. c ncaaxcuuu ucacrc yn-
c_cuucrc nca(a ncc.aucaxcuua nurcac-
a, nc(ycc.cuucrc rx. 4O
J
\lK IU u
nc(ncxara_crc au(cu+cucuuc uc .cx:c cy-
(cucrc, uc +ac.u+uc u (ccy(cucrc nca(a
ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcaucy (cxy nu +ax+c-
uuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac.
O(uac (uccuquaqua a yrcxcauc nc-
qcccc acc c ncuy_cc.acuuc c.uccu.ca (c-
cy(cucy uxu cy(cucy ncu+ac(c.aa, aa-
xa_uca, a ya+:aaxcc: a:ac, (cacx:uc
+auy.:u naaca:u ca+caauuau.
H.a, a c ua xaccuuqucaa.: cxc-
ucccc.aau:c ncu+ac(c.aa nc c.cncuu cxcuc-
c.u ux ncqcccyax:ucu c:, ccxu uc acc ux
ccc.aau:c +ac.u ucca. ync_cuu:u xaa.c'
lcxarac, uaucxcc nucxc a:c a.c-
crc u+ nuac(cuu:x uau a:ac ac+cu:x
c.ac.ca ua acca.uaac:u acncc, ccrxacuc
c.ccy .acrc c(a ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(yc.
acca.uaa.: a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c
ncu+ac(c.aa ccaauucrc .una, +.c axc+c. (c-
ncxucuuc ccc.ac.c.ay_u au(c ncu+ac(c.a
xaccuuaqu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x
25
ncu+ac(c.a nc c.cncuu cxcucc.u ux yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu c:.
Cac nc+uqu : ccuca:aac ua nc(-
c.aaxcuuu c .c, +.c ync_cuuc ncqcccy-
ax:ucu c: cc. acncc.aua.:ca
uc .cx:c ua yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c nc-
u+ac(c.aa a qcxc, uc u ua axc(a_uc a ux
ccc.aa xccu.: (uuau+cccu c.y.y:
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, a .ac ua ac+-
+cuuu, ccrxacuc c.ccy (ccy(cucc u cy-
(cucc ncu+ac(c.aa aaxa.ca (cc.a.c+uc
cacc.ca.cx:u:u a+(cxau yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, a aax a(c-
rc u+ c.c:x a+aca+uaac.ca (ca+a.cx:-
c.acuu:u ncqccc cc accu nucy_uu cy
.anau.
A. B. lo+co+. lcxc: xaccuuaquu ync_cuu:x cy(cu:x ncu+ac(c.a
26
Ccaccuucy cccuuccy yrcxcaucy ncqcccy u+acc.uc
(c+uauuc (ayx au(ca:
J) (c+uauuc nc yrcxcau: (cxa, nc c.c: nc(aau.cx:-
ucc cxc(c.auc ca+a.cx:uc, nc(c.aaxa_cc cccu ncu+ac(-
c.ac ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu (xc.a \lK IU u uc
ua+:aac. ncu+ac(c.ac ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu nc
(cxy, nc c.ccy nc(aau.cx:ucc cxc(c.auc ca+a.cx:uc, (c+-
uauuc, ucuuc .a (ca.cx:ucc.: aaxac.ca xaccu+ccu (c+ua-
uuc);
2) (c+uauuc nc yrcxcau: (cxa, nc c.c: nc(aau.cx:-
ucc cxc(c.auc ucca+a.cx:uc, a accxc(caauuc a ncxuc c.c-
c uccxcu:x yrcxcau:x (cx.
O(uac (c uac.ca_crc accuu uc y.uxa. (ucyccuu c .c,
ucc.ca xu uccxc(ucc.: a ccxaucuuu ccux au(ca (c+uauua.
Hccxc(yc (auu:u acncc, ncac(a uc.cu+ccuu cyc.
B uc.cuu yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa (c+uauuc ncac-
ua+ax:uc ac+uuxc a a(uuuc.a.uauc-ncxuqcu-
caa (ca.cx:ucc.:, c.caa uaxc(uxac: auc ac
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. Ouc ncu+ac(uxcc: ncxuqcu-
cuu +uuau u yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: +acuc-
(a.cx:c.ac uc crxacu.ucaaxcc:. Hcuuc uc-
ncqcccyax:uaa (ca.cx:ucc.: aaxaxac: caa_cu a cuc-
aauuu (c+uauua. ,c+uauuc acca.uaaxcc: a (ca.cx:ucc.:,
uanaaxcuuaa ua ccuauuc nc(aau.cx:u:x cac(cuuu, uccxc-
(u:x (xa .crc, +.c: uu cr accncx:+caa.:ca cy(cu:u cxc-
(caa.cx: nu accxc(caauuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa, .c cc.: acqcuuaa-
xcc: a cc(c.ac cccnc+cuua (ax:ucuacrc accxc(caauua nc-
c.ynxcuuu, a uc a crc cacc.ca.cx:uaa ca.
Xaa.cu+ya nca(c u ca+ (cuc.auu nc ncu+ac(c.ay
(c+uauua, H. H. Ucuuuquu nucax, +.c +acu u+crac. crxacu-
.ucaa.: crc c .c+ucc.: (xa .crc ucuuc, +.c: uc c.ccuu.:
ncxuqu a .cu (ca.cx:ucc.u, nc cy_cc.ay caccy .cy_cu
:c.c.: u qcxcccca+ucc.u ccc.ac.c.acuuc c au(cu+cua-
_uuca cc.ca.cx:c.aau... (c+uauuc uc ucc. (cxa c cy(c-
u:u cau u ca(au, uc cqcuuaac. a.ca, uc ncc.auca-
xac. uuaux cnc(cxcuuu c uux, uc (cxac. u+ uux uuaux
Rauen Buuvopouun Bpoueu,
acnnpan xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
Yparucxon rocyapcaennon pnnecxon
axaeunn
H. B. Booece
osnannc rar camocronrcxrnan qopma
npcuapnrcxrnoro paccxcouannn:
ncropnn uosnnrnoucnnn n pasunrnn
27
cau.cx:u:x a:ac(ca, u nc.cy nc(c.aaxac.
(ca.cx:ucc.: uc cy(cuy
J
. 1au ca+c,
ycac(c.ayac: nuuqunc ncqcccyax:ucu
cucuu, +acuc(a.cx: c.a+:aac.ca nc(ac-
ra.: ncxucu ncqcccyax:ucu crxacu.aquu
(cuc.aua ncxuquu.
Ccac.ccc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +a-
cuc(a.cx:c.ac c cacrc ua+axa +auaxc nuu-
qunuax:uc uuy nc+uqu a acnccc c cxu
(c+uauua a accxc(caauuu ncc.ynxcuuu u crc
c.ucacuuu nc(aau.cx:ucy cxc(c.au. Ka
c.c+ac. B. M. Caauquu, xaa.cucu +c-
.cu (c+uauua a ccac.cc yrcxcauc ncqcc-
cc, ccuu: ca+c c.xu+a_cu crc c. c(-
ucucuucrc uuc.u.y.a a yya+uc naac,
aaxac.ca ncu+ac(c.ac (c+uauua a c.crc
ccc.ac.c.auu c cnc(cxcuu:u ca+a.cx:u:-
u naauxau, yc.aucaxcuu:u a yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:uc +acuc, .c cc.: a ncqcccy-
ax:u:x cax
2
.
1au ca+c, a qcxax ycnxcuua +a-
cuucc.u a (ca.cx:ucc.u ccc.ac.c.ay_ux
(cxucc.u:x xuq (c+uauuc (ncuuaccc .cr-
(a c_c .cx:c a ncu+ac(c.ac ucc.xcu:x
cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu nc yc.aucaxcuu cc-
:.ua ncc.ynxcuua u +acnxcuu crc cxc-
(ca) nucc.ac. ncqcccyax:u:u xaa.c.
Huc.yqua HKB, u HKK ICUCI
O crauu+aquu Ccac.ccu Iac+c-Kcc.:-
auccu uxuquu J9J8 rc(a ucxc(uxa u+ .crc,
+.c uxuqua, a naauxc, uc (cxua cacc.c-
a.cx:uc ncu+ac(u.: cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu.
B ucu nc(yca.uaaxcc:, +.c uxuqua xuc
a:ncxuac. a.ccc.cncuu:c ca+auucc.u nc
ccxyuaauu crauca naaccy(ua, xuc (cu-
c.ayc. nc ux ncy+cuu. O(uac cxc(yc. +a-
c.u.:, +.c uuc.yqua uc ccacc .c+uc c.a-
axa (cuc.au.cx:ucc ncxccuuc ac_cu. Ua-
.u+ccu crau: (c+uauua cxa(axu +ua+u.cx:-
uc cx:acu cacc.ca.cx:ucc.: a acnccax
ccy_cc.axcuua cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu. lcx:-
auuc.ac yrcxcau:x (cx uxuqua (ccucaucu
crau (c+uauua) accxc(caaxa a ncxuc c.cc,
uc crauu+uaaac: .cx:c ucc.xcu:u cxc(-
c.acuu:u (cuc.auau, cacc.ca.cx:uc ux +a-
au+uaaxa u uanaaxaxa a uac(u:c cy(:.
O.acuaxcc: .c, nc(c accrc, cxacc.: u
axc+ucxcuucc.: cxc(c.acuucrc annaa.a
HKK ICUCI, uc ycncaaaacrc accxc(caa.:
yrcxcau:c (cxa
J
. lc uaucxcc cxcu: (c-
xa crau: (c+uauua crauu+uaaxuc: ncu+-
ac(c.ac ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
c .c, +.c: accxc(caauuc ncu+ac(uxcc:
+a.c ucnccc(c.acuuc +xcuau cxc(c.acuu:x
cuccuu, cx:auuc.ac c yrcxcau:x (cx cuu
+aau+uaaxu cacc.ca.cx:uc a ncxuc c.c-
c. 1au ca+c, a (ca.cx:ucc.u uxuquu
uac.uxac: a .c aca u a.caa ca (c+ua-
uua (ncu+ac(c.ac (c+uauua a ncxuc c.c-
c), nca c_c uc ncxy+uaaaa +acuc(a.cx:uc-
rc +acnxcuua. B J922 rc(y :x nuua. \lK
ICUCI, c.c:u yc nc(yca.uaax (xa
crauca (c+uauua ac+cucc.: nc ucc.c:
a.crcua (cx acc.u accxc(caauuc a ncx-
uc c.cc, uc crauu+uaaac: ucc.xcu:u
ncqcccyax:u:u (cuc.auau (c.. JOJ, JO6, JO8
u JJO). lu .c a ua+aauuc \lK ccac-
acuuc c.cy.c.acaaxa crxacu.aqua ncxucc-
+uu crauca (c+uauua nc (auu: a.crcua
(cx. acuc(a.cx:, ac+xaraa ua crau: (c+ua-
uua ca+auucc.: nuuua.: c: .cy, +.c-
: (c ua+axa nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua :xu
ccxaucu: cxc(: ncc.ynxcuua u yc.aucua
(xa nc(c+caaccrc ac+cucc.: c:.:ca
(ccrxacuc c.. JOJ, JO4 crau: (c+uauua cr-
xu (cnaauaa.: nc(c+caac:x u cau(c.cxcu,
a .ac ncu+ac(u.: c:cu, a:cu, ccc.-
: u ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a .cx cxy+aax, cr-
(a ucxuc: (cc.a.c+u:c ccucaauua cnaca.:ca,
+.c cxc(: ncc.ynxcuua u (yruc ac_cc.acu-
u:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa cry. :.: yuu+.ccu:
uxu c:.:), nc-ncucy cnc(cxux rxaa-
ucu +a(a+cu crauca (c+uauua ncu+ac(c.ac
J
0ounuquu H. B. Kyc yrcxcaucrc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa: B 2 .. Cl., J9J5. 1. 2. C. J62
J6J.
2
C.: Coeuquu B. M. lcyccuu ua(+c +a
(c+uauuc u nc(aau.cx:u: cxc(c.auc. M.,
J959. C. 27.
J
C.: Homnoe B. H. lcqcccyax:u:c c:
(c+uauua a nca:c rc(: ccac.ccu axac.u. M.,
J969. C. JOJ.
H. B. B{oeqce. ,c+uauuc a cacc.ca.cx:uaa ca nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
28
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ncau+u:x, ucc.xcu:x ncqcccyax:u:x (cu-
c.auu. Hc, uaaauc c .u, +acuc(a.cx: ac+-
xcux ua uux a c_c-.c uccacuc.acuuy u
yuqu ~ ncu+ac(c.ac accxc(caauua nc
yrcxcaucy (cxy a ncxuc c.cc. ,auu:u au(
(c+uauua (a ax:.cua.uaa nc(aau.cx:uc-
y cxc(c.au) :x ccxaucu u a nccxc(y-
_c, cr(a c.naxa uccxc(ucc.: ncu+ac(-
c.aa crauau (c+uauua accxc(caauua a ncx-
uc c.cc. Ka c+yx:.a. ~ ac+uuucacuuc
acncca c ccc.ucacuuu (c+uauua u nc(aau-
.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua u ncc.cncuucc uc+c+ucac-
uuc a+xu+uu c(y uuu. 1a, \lK ICUCI
J92J rc(a yc uc cc(cu. uc:, c.caa
ac+xaraxa : ua crau: (c+uauua ca+auucc-
.u ccxaua.: cxc(: ncc.ynxcuua u nccca.:
ncn:.u nc(c+caaccrc c:.:ca c. cxc(-
c.aua u cy(a, +a.c cc(cu. .ccaauua, yc.a-
uaaxuaa_uc naac crauca (c+uauua ncu+-
ac(u.: ncxucc.: accxc(caauuc nc a(y nc-
c.ynxcuuu, ycac(c.ayac: nu .c naauxa-
u, c.c:c c.ucca.ca ncu+ac(c.ay nc(aa-
u.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua (c.. 98 u JOJ). S.u u
nccxc(y_uc u+cucuua a +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
aauxuc: c.acuuc ncaauaacuca a .c. ncu-
c( .cu(cuquu cxu+u.: cc c: accxc(c-
aauua. lc ua+aauucu nu+uuc ua +a(uuu nxau
ncc.cncuuc c.c.yna. (cuc.au.cx:uc (c+uaaa-
.cx:cuc yuquu a (ca.cx:ucc.u uxuquu u
(yrux crauca (c+uauua, a ux cc.c +auuac.
ncac(cuuc accxc(caauua a ncxuc c.cc.
B a.c J924 rc(a A. H. B:auucuu,
a:c.ynaa c (cxa(c ua \ Bcccccuucc
c.c+(c (ca.cxcu ccac.ccu c.uquu, c.c.ux,
+.c (c+uauuc uuacu crauu+cccu ccccu-
ucc.: c. cxc(c.aua uc c.xu+ac.ca... +.c:
cuc :xc rcacu.:, +.c (c+uauuc nc.uac-
ncc.aaxac.ca cxc(c.au a cxac.: uccy(c-
uaa cxac.u cy(cucu. ,c+uauuc u nc(aau-
.cx:ucc cxc(c.auc (cxu: :.: nu+uau: a
(ac aaucacxuuc cxac.u cy(cucu ac.:.
lc ucuu A. H. B:auuccrc, cxc(c.auc
uccxc(uc nc (cxa c rccy(ac.acuu:x, (cx-
ucc.u:x, xc+auc.acuu:x, nc.ua u+uu u ac-
uucux ncc.ynxcuuu, nc acc cc.ax:u:
ua(xcu. nu+ua.: ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(c.aua, a
c_cc naauxc, u+xuauu u (cc.a.c+u: nc-
u+ac(c.ac accxc(caauua crauau (c+uauua
4
.
Ka c.c+ac. H. H. lcxaucuu, a .ux ncxc-
cuuax A. H. B:auuccrc :xa naaux:uaa
:cx: c (c+uauuu a ncqcccyax:uc-naac-
acu (ca.cx:ucc.u u c (ca+a.cx:c.acuuc +ua-
+cuuu a.ca (c+uauua. Hc +c+cucc cxu-
cuuc (c+uauua u nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua
nccxyuxc a u+acc.ucu cc ncac(c c.u-
auu rauuq c(y uuu, +.c ncaauxcc:
anccxc(c.auu a .ccuu yrcxcaucrc ncqccca u
a ncqcccyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
5
.
luua.:c a J924 rc(y Ocuca: yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa Cc+a CCI u cc+-
u:x ccnyxu yc.auaaxuaaxu, +.c crauau,
ncu+ac(a_uu nc(aau.cx:ucc accxc(caa-
uuc ncc.ynxcuuu, aaxa.ca crau: (c+uauua,
cxc(caa.cxu u uu:c (cxucc.u:c xuqa, cu
.c nc(cc.aaxcuc c_ccc+u:u +acuau
u +acuau cc+u:x ccnyxu (c.. 7). 1c
ca: ncc+ucxcuu:c crau: ca+axuc: +ac-
u:au c(ucu qcnu.
acuc c. J6 c.aa J924 rc(a u +a-
cuc c. 2O c.aa J929 rc(a

:xa nc(-
nuua.a ucaaa ncn:.a yc.auu.: a+xu+uc
c(y (c+uauuc u nc(aau.cx:u: cxc(-
c.auc. Hc: c.a.cu 99 u JO8 \lK
ICUCI (a c(aquu +acua c. 2O c.aa
J929 rc(a) nc(.auyxu (c+uauuc (c ycaua
nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua, cxaa.ua .c u (y-
rcc c(uu: .cuuc nc(aau.cx:ucc ac-
cxc(caauuc.
Kyr (cx, nc c.c: crau: (c+uauua
acxu accxc(caauuc a ncxuc c.cc, ucy-
xcuuc acauaxca naaxxcx:uc .cy, a .u
crau: nucc.axu naaa cxc(caa.cxcu, c.-
aaa acc .y c .cu(cuqu uuacxucac
(c+uauua u nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua. a-
cu c. 27 uxa J925 rc(a c+c u+cuux nc(-
cxc(c.acuucc.:, ucx+ua ccxc .u(qa.u c.a-
.cu u+ ncc+ua, yc.aucaxcuucrc a c.. JO8 \lK,
u .c ca: +ua+u.cx:uc acauua cnc-
.cuqu crauca (c+uauua. B nccxc(y_uc
4
Qu.. nc: Ho:+ncuu H. H. O+c a+au.ua
ccac.ccu uayu yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. M., J96O.
C. 4J.
5
C.: 1a c.
29
rc(: ncu+caxc (ax:ucuacc cca_cuuc yra
(cx c ncc.ynxcuuax, nc(xca_ux nc(aau-
.cx:ucy cxc(c.au, u .au ca+c auca:
:xa acaucua cca (ca.cx:ucc.u crauca
(c+uauua
6
.
\a+auu:c +acuc(a.cx:u:c nc.yaquu
nuacxu ac+uuucacuu ccc.c+cuu:x cnc-
ca a ncqcccyax:ucu xu.ca.yc, c.c:c
nc(cxaxuc: uc c(uc (cca.uxc.uc. lu c-
cy(cuuu a cuqc J95O-x rc(ca ncc.ca
Ocuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa Cc+a
CCI u cc+u:x ccnyxu a .ccuu yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca auca: a+acuyxac: (ucyc-
cua c cy(:c (c+uauua. Mucruc y+cu:c u na-
.uu nc(xaraxu c.a+a.:ca c. (c+uauua nc
(cxa, nc c.c: cxc(c.auc ucca+a.cx:uc.
O(uac a u.crc ncc(uxa .c+a +cuua,
ccrxacuc c.ccu (c+uauuc (cxuc cc.a.:ca
a a+cc.ac cacc.ca.cx:ucu c: accxc(c-
aauua c (cxcuuc ua (aa au(a: (c+uauuc nc
(cxa, nc c.c: cxc(c.auc ca+a.cx:uc
(a au(c ncu+ac(c.aa ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acu-
u:x (cuc.auu), u (c+uauuc nc (cxa, nc c.c-
: cxc(c.auc ucca+a.cx:uc. luac(uxcc:
(aa arycu.a +a nuua.uc .acrc cacuua:
ac-nca:x, xuacuuc craua (c+uauua yuquu
accxc(caauua u ncc(a+a accx (cx cxc(caa-
.cxa ucu+cuc nuac(c. nccry+c cxc(-
c.acuucrc annaa.a,

+.c naryuc cac.ca ua
ccax u a+cc.ac cxc(c.aua; ac-a.c:x, nc-
u+ac(c.ac accxc(caauua crauc (c+uauua
aaxac.ca xcru+ccu nc(cxcuuc crc a(-
uuuc.a.uau:x yuquu, uanaaxcuu:x ua
cryxucaauuc u cxauy .cx c_cc.acuu:x
c.ucacuuu, a ccc c.c:x ac+uua. nc-
c.ynxcuua, c.ucccuu:c crc cnc.cuquu
7
.
25 (caa J958 rc(a Ocuca: yrcxcauc-
rc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa Cc+a CCI u cc+u:x
ccnyxu :xu nuua.:. ,c+uauu a Oc-
ucaax :xa nccaa_cua c.. 29, a c.ccu
yc.auaaxuaaxcc:, +.c crauau (c+uauua aa-
xa.ca uxuqua, yncxucc+cuu:c ua .c +ac-
uc y+c(cuua u crauu+aquu, a .ac c-
au(u: acuucux +ac.cu, ccc(uucuuu u ua-
+ax:uuu accuu:x y+c(cuuu.
lu uaxu+uu nu+uaca ncc.ynxcuua, nc
c.ccy ncu+ac(c.ac nc(aau.cx:ucrc
cxc(c.aua ca+a.cx:uc, crau (c+uauua (cx-
cu :x ac+y(u.: yrcxcaucc (cxc u ncu+-
acc.u ucc.xcu:c cxc(c.acuu:c (cuc.aua nc
yc.aucaxcuu u +acnxcuu cxc(ca ncc.yn-
xcuua: ccc., c:c, a:cy, ccau(c.cx:c.ac-
aauuc, +a(cauuc u (cncc nc(c+caac:x,
(cncc nc.cncaaux u cau(c.cxcu (+. J c.. 29
Ocuca).
lc (cxa, nc c.c: ncu+ac(c.ac nc(-
aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua uc :xc ca+a.cx:-
u:, a.cuax: (c+uauua aaxaxuc: ccucaauu-
c (xa accc.cuua (cxa a cy(c. B .ux
cxy+aax crau (c+uauua nc(c.aaxax a.cu-
ax: (c+uauua c cauuu.cx:u: +ax+cuuc
ncycy, nccxc y.ac(cuua c.ccrc (cxc
uanaaxaxcc: (xa accc.cuua a cy(.
\lK ICUCI J96O rc(a ncxccuua (cx
uc u+cuux, ccxauua yc.aucaxcuucc Ocuc-
aau (cxcuuc (c+uauua ua (aa au(a. lcu-
c .crc :xu yc.aucaxcu: ncc+cu: u c-
nc.cuqua crauca (c+uauua nc a(cy u+ (ayx
au(ca (c+uauua, a .ac yr (cx, nc c.c:
nc(aau.cx:ucc cxc(c.auc aaxaxcc: ca+a-
.cx:u: (c.. JJ7J27 \lK ICUCI).
Hc (ucyccua c cy(:c (c+uauua nccxc
nuua.ua \lK ICUCI uc :xa +a:.a u
a J97O8O-x rc(ax ac+cucauxac:. Mucuua
ncqcccyaxuc.ca auca: c+c a+caxuc:. O(ua
rynna aa.cca nc(xaraxa acc_c xuau(u-
caa.: uuc.u.y. (c+uauua
8
. ,yruc c aa.c-
:, uanuc, A. M. ,cuqca, ncxaraxu ac+-
cu: cc.aau.: (c+uauuc, uc cy_cc.acuuc
crc c(cuu+ucaa.:
9
. 1c.:u c+u.axu, +.c
6
C.: Coeuquu B. M. lcyccuu ua(+c
+a (c+uauuc u nc(aau.cx:u: cxc(c.auc. M.,
J959. C. 29.
7
C.: Ho:+ncuu H. H. \a+ cc+. C. J27; A:c-
con{oe l. H. O nc(aau.cx:uc cxc(c.auu u
(c+uauuu. M., J954. C. 5455.
8
C., uan.: Cmc+oecuu B. A. \+ac.uuu nc(-
aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua a ccac.cc yrcxcauc
ncqcccc. Icc.ca-ua-,cuy, J966. C. 6869.
9
C.: onqoe A. M. lcxca ccc.ucacuua
(c+uauua u nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua a ccac.-
cc yrcxcauc ncqcccc. ^., J97J. C. JJ.
H. B. B{oeqce. ,c+uauuc a cacc.ca.cx:uaa ca nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
JO
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
uccxc(uc c.a+a.:ca c. (c+uauua a c-
: nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua nc (c-
xa, nc c.c: nc(aau.cx:ucc cxc(c.auc
ucca+a.cx:uc, uc ccxauu.: (c+uauuc nc (c-
xa, nc c.c: cxc(c.auc ca+a.cx:uc a au(c
ncu+ac(c.aa ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cu-
c.auu
JO
.
O(uac cx:auuc.ac ncqcccyaxuc.ca
nc(xaraxu ccxauu.: ca au(a (c+uauua
JJ
.
1au ca+c, ccu.y +aacacuua cc-
ac.ccrc .ana a+au.ua u cucaauua (c+-
uauua uaucxcc cc.c c.caxa ncxca crc
((c+uauua) ccxaucuua a ax:.cua.uaucu
c: accxc(caauua. S.c c.acuaxcc: .c,
+.c ua+axy cy(cucu cc: a+uuqa c-
(y (c+uauuc u cxc(c.auc (ccxu uc nuuu-
JO
C.: Boeu H. A. 1ccc.u+ccuc ccuca:
nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua. M., J97J. C. 7J
74.
JJ
C.: o:un H. B.. 0om::un 0. M. lc(-
aau.cx:ucc cxc(c.auc a ccac.cc yrcxcauc
ncqcccc. M., J965. C. 495J.
a.: ac auuauuc ccu) a.u+ccu ncc-
c.axa cy_cc.acaa.:. 1c uc cucc, +acuc(a-
.cx: a:ax yc ua ccxaucuuc (c+uauua
a cacc.ca.cx:ucu c: accxc(caauua.
lc(ac(a u.cr ca+auucy, cxc(yc. c.c-
.u.:, +.c uaxu+uc a yrcxcauc ncqcccc ccc-
crc ncqcccyax:ucrc uuc.u.y.a (c+uauua, nc-
uuaccrc a ncu+ac(c.ac ucc.xcu:x cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu cncquax:uc ua .c yncxuc-
c+cuu:u rccy(ac.acuu:u crauau c qc-
x: nccxc(y_cu ncc(a+u (cx craua nc(-
aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua, aaxac.ca cnaa(auu:
u uccxc(u:.
U.c c acac.ca ncu+ac(ucrc crauau
(c+uauua accxc(caauua a ncxuc c.cc, .c
uc.cu+ccuu cyc uc nc+acxac. c(cxa.:
a:ac( c .c, +.c (c+uauuc a ax:.cua.ua-
uy nc(aau.cx:ucy cxc(c.au cy ac-
cxc(caauua cxc(yc. ccxauu.:. Hc.cua nc-
+acxac. c(cxa.: (yrcu a:ac(: (c+uauuc cc.:
(ca.cx:ucc.: nc ncu+ac(c.ay ucc.xcu:x
cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu a qcxax cuaycuua
u ucaquu cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua, uc uc ac-
cxc(caauua yrcxcaucrc (cxa a ncxuc c.cc.
JJ
laac a(crc ua cacc(u:u (cc.yn naaccy(u +acn-
xcuc a c.. 8 Bccc_cu (cxaaquu naa +cxcaca, a c.. 6 lac-
ncuccu cuacuquu c +a_u.c naa +cxcaca u ccucau:x cacc(,
a c.. J4 Mc(yuac(ucrc na.a c ra(aucux u ncxu.u+ccux
naaax u a (yrux c(yuac(uc-naaca:x (cycu.ax. B Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu naac a(crc ua +a_u.y naa u cacc(,
a .c +ucxc u ua cy(cuy +a_u.y, +acnxcuc a c.a.:ax 45, 46
u 52 Kcuc.u.yquu.
laac ua cy(cuy +a_u.y, ncac+rxaacuucc Kcuc.u.yqucu,
(cxuc :.: nc(cnxcuc cuc.ccu cccnc+u.cx:u:x cc(c.a,
nc+acxa_ux ua (cxc caxu+caa.: cnxcc cy.c.uau:x u-
(u+ccux naa, axc(a_ux a cc(cauuc c(ucrc u+ ccucacncxara-
_ux nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc naaccy(ua. Cuc.ca .ux cc(c.a
(cxua (cuc.acaa.: aau: ca+c (xa a(crc acaxc+cuucrc
a ccy yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x c.ucacuuu, c+c.uccu.cx:uc
.cy, aaxac.ca xu xuqc cauuac: (nc(c+caac:), nc.c-
ncaau uxu cau(c.cxc nc (cxy u (ac auc +aaucucc.u c. .crc,
nu+uau xu +cxcac ccc.ac.c.ay_u y+ac.uuc yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca uxu uc..
,cuc.auc cccnc+u.cx:ucrc cxauu+a nc(+u-
ucuc a ncay c+cc(: qcxca: yc.aucaa, +a(au-
u: +acuc: c. .crc, a cnc(cxcu: .u qcxu, +a-
aucu. ycacu: naacacrc cryxucaauua u crc -
c.uaucc.:.
Qcx: yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa cnc(cxcua
c.. 6 \lK IU: \rcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ucc. cacu
ua+ua+cuuc +a_u.y naa u +acuu:x uu.cccca xuq u crauu-
+aquu, nc.cncaaux c. ncc.ynxcuuu; +a_u.y xu+ucc.u c. uc+a-
cuucrc u uccccucaauucrc cauucuua, ccy(cuua, crauu+cuua
cc naa u cacc(. \rcxcaucc nccxc(caauuc u ua+ua+cuuc au-
ucau: cnaac(xuacrc uaa+auua a .cu c cc c.ac+a. ua-
+ua+cuu yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, +.c u c.a+ c. yrcxcauc-
rc nccxc(caauua ucauucau:x, ccacc(cuuc ux c. uaa+auua,
cauxu.aqua a(crc, .c uccccucaauuc nc(acrca yrcxcaucy
nccxc(caauu
J
.
. M. Bo:oouuo
Hpauo na ocryn r npauocynr
hpmuna Munuvonouna Bonopuna,
oxop pnnecxnx nayx, npoqeccop,
aaaeyuan xaqepon yroroanoro npoecca
n xpnunnarncnxn
1uencxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
J
\+cu:c nc-a+ucy c.ucca.ca ncua.u, cc(cauu, c.y.yc
uc:, cc(ca_cuca a c.. 6 \lK IU. lc(cucc c.: Bo:o{u-
no . M. lcxc: yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa: +acu, .ccua, na-
.ua. M., 2OO6. C. 659.
J2
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Sc.uaucc.: xcu cuc.c:, a .c +ucxc
u naaccxauu.cx:ucu, cnc(cxac.ca cxacu-
ucc.: cc a+auc(cuc.ay_ux xccu.ca, uua-
+c cuc.ca uc caa.:aac. xuc c.aucau.ca
axcc.uaucu. laac+a_u.u:c cxauu+-
: (cxu: :.: c.xacu: uac.cx:c c-
+ync+uc, +.c: +cxcac, acaxc+cuu:u a c-
u.y yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x c.ucacuuu, cr,
uc cxa(aa nccccucuax:ucu nc(rc.cacu u
+uauuau a cxac.u ucny(cuquu, cucu.u-
caa.:ca a cncccax u cc(c.aax +a_u.: cac-
ux naa u +acuu:x uu.cccca.
laacnucuu.cx: (cxcu cc(cuc.acaa.:
caxu+aquu naaa ua ccncna.c.acuucc c-
a_cuuc a cy(. B ccc.ac.c.auu c .cxcaauu-
c cacuua lacncuccrc Cy(a, (auu: nc
(cxy Suu nc.ua Hxau(uu. a:ncxucuuc
ca+a.cx:c.a nc lacncuccu Kcuacuquu .c-
yc. uc .cx:c uc ncna.c.acaa.: caxu+aquu
naa, uc u ccacaa.: cnc(cxcuu:c nc+u.ua-
u:c (cuc.aua, uanaaxcuu:c ua cccnc+cuuc
(cc.yna naaccy(u
2
.
laac ua accc_ucc.: cy(cucu +a_u.:
a a+cc.ac nuuquna yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa a \lK IU uc +acnxcuc.
Cnaac(xuacc.: naaccy(ua +ax+ac.ca
uc .cx:c a cnaac(xuacc.u nuuuaccrc c-
acuua, uc u a cnaac(xuacc.u ncqc(y: crc
nuua.ua. O .c cau(c.cx:c.ayc. auaxu+ c.a-
ucaxcuua yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, c.c-
cc c(cuc ccc.acuuc nc.cucc.: +cxc-
aca uau.u cnaac(xuacc.:. lc (cxy Mcu-
ccca nc.ua Icccuu c. 9 c.aa 2OO8 rc(a
lacncucuu Cy( nu+uax uayacuuc naaa
ua cnaac(xuacc cy(cucc a+ua.cx:c.ac
ncqcccyax:u:c uayacuua, caa+auu:c c cr-
auu+cuuc u(u+cccu ncc_u cauuacc-
y. Cy( c.c.ux, +.c crau cauucuua a.u-
+ccu +xcync.cxax cacu (cuuuy_u nc-
xccuuc, c.a+:aaac: y(caxc.acu.: xc(a.au-
c.ac a(aca.a +aaau.cxa c uccrauu+cuuc (c-
c.ync u yrcaa cu yrcxcau: nccxc(caauu-
c. Kcc .crc, Cy( c.a+ux a ncc.aucaxcuuu
c+cau(ucc uayacuuc cuu(cuquax:ucc.u c.-
ucacuuu a(aca.a c xucu.c, a .ac cra-
uu+cuua (cc.yna +a_u.: a.cuaxa (cxa
J
.
Auaxu+uya cy(cuy axac.: a uuc.y-
cu. caccrauu+cuua rccy(ac.aa, H. l. Mu-
xauxcacaa nuac.: ,cc.ynucc.: cy(cucu
+a_u.: cnc(cxac.ca xaa.cc naacacrc
cryxucaauua uc .cx:c nca(a ca_cuua
a cy(, uc u accu ncqc(y: accc.cuua (cx,
a .ac crauu+aqucuuc-.cxuu+ccuu a-
.cau, c.c:c axua. ua cax:uy ac+c-
ucc.: ucncx:+caauua naaa ua cy(cuy +a-
_u.y
4
.
lacncucuu Cy( a cacux cacuuax ucc(-
uca.uc nc(+cuaax ca+a.cx:ucc.: ccx-
(cuua ncqc(y: ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcaucy
(cxy. 1a, nc (cxy S(aa(c u ^:uc nc.ua
Ccc(uucuucrc Kccxcac.aa c. 22 uxa
2OOJ rc(a Cy( nuacx a:ac(y c .c, +.c
ucnc(cc.aaxcuuc c.ccuc +a_u.: (cc cc:x-
cu ua rccy(ac.acuu:c uu.ccc:) a.cua-
xca (cxa (xa c+uacxcuua aaxac.ca uayac-
uuc n. J c.. 6 Kcuacuquu
5
. Icacuuc la-
cncuccrc Cy(a :xc nu+uauc uayacuuc
ncqc(y: ucyac(cxcuuc c accuu +acc(a-
uua cy(a, acca.uaaaacrc (cxc a ua(+cuc
ncu+ac(c.ac ((cxc Haccaa nc.ua Icc-
cuu c. J5 auaaa 2OO9 rc(a)
6
.
\rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa ca, cccnc+u-
aaa (aucuuc yrcxcaucrc (cxa, (cxua ax-
+a.: uc .cx:c crxacu.aqu nccxc(caa.cx:-
ucc.u ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu, ccucaauua,
ycxcaua, ncqc(yy u ccu ux ncu+ac(c.aa,
uc u cc.y cuc.cy cu.cxa +acuucc.u,
cccucaauucc.u u caccaccuucc.u (cuc.auu
u nuuuac:x a xc(c ncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxy
cacuuu. H+ .crc a:.cac. aaucuacc .c-
caauuc c(yuac(u:x c.au(a.ca ~ na-
ac ua +acuuy ncqc(yy accc.cuua u
a+cacuua (cxa.
2
C.: lacncucuu Cy( nc naaa +cxcaca.
H+auu:c cacuua. M., 2OOO. 1. J. C. 4546.
J
C.: lxxc.cu: lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa
+cxcaca. Icccuuccc u+(auuc. 2OO9. ` 2.
4
Cy(cuaa axac.: lc( c(. H. ^. lc.yxuua.
M., 2OOJ. C. 4748.
5
C.: lxxc.cu: lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa
+cxcaca. Icccuuccc u+(auuc. 2OO9. ` J2.
6
C.: lxxc.cu: lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa
+cxcaca.
JJ
B ncc.aucaxcuuu Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a
IU c. 8 (caa 2OOJ rc(a cc(cu.ca a(
.ccaauuu, c.c: (cxuc ccc.ac.c.acaa.:
cy(cucc a+ua.cx:c.ac, cccnc+uaa_cc
cnaac(xuacc.: cy(cucu +a_u.:. B (auu:u
ncc+cu: axc(a.:
a) yc.aucaxcuuc ua ccucac uccxc(caauu:x
(ca+a.cx:c.a cc.ca.cx:c.a ccacacuucrc
ncc.ynxcuua, a caa+u c c.c: :xc ac+-
y(cuc yrcxcaucc (cxc;
) naaux:uaa naacaaa cqcua cc:.ua
ncc.ynxcuua;
a) yc.aucaxcuuc cuc.ucrc ac(a, nu-
+uucuucrc ncc.ynxcuuc c_cc.ay u c.(cx:-
u: xuqa;
r) cnc(cxcuuc (cuc.au.cx:ucu c.cncuu
auu: xuqa a ccacacuuu uuuuuuyccrc
cy (cauua;
() nc(cc.aaxcuuaa cauuaccy u nc.c-
ncaacy ac+cucc.: (cacc.u (c cac(cuua cy(a
cac nc+uqu nc cy_cc.ay (cxa u u+xcu.:
(cac(:, c.c:c cuu c+u.a. uccxc(u:u
(xa cc cccucaauua
7
.
Hua+c rcaca, Kcuc.u.yqucuu:u Cy( ac-
ca.uaac. cccnc+cuuc cnaac(xuacc.u cy(c-
ucu +a_u.: nc(c accrc c .c+u +cuua (c-
a+auucc.u cc.ca.cx:c.a, axc(a_ux a nc(-
c. (ca+:aauua. Kcc .crc, Cy( ca_ac.
auuauuc ua naaux:ucc.: naacacu cqcuu
cc:.ua ncc.ynxcuua u c.cncuu auu:, a .a-
c ua c(uc u+ naa cauuaccrc u nc.cnca-
acrc u ac+cucc.: crc caxu+aquu. lc(-
c.aaxac.ca, +.c c+: (cxua u(.u a qcxc c cc-
nuc.ac.ucu c.c.uaucu cqcuc accx cc.c-
a.cx:c.a (cxa u ac+cucc.u caxu+aquu accx
naa, nc(cc.aaxcuu:x +acuc ua+aauu:
y+ac.uua ncqccca.
laac ua cnaac(xuay cy(cuy +a_u.y
nc(ncxarac. naac ua cnaac(xua:u nurcac.
Cnaac(xuacc.: nurcaca a .ccaauuc,
+acnxcuucc a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +a-
cuc, c+ua+ac. (ca+auucc.: accx cc.ca.cx:c.a
yrcxcaucrc (cxa, yc.aucaxcuuc uc.uu: nc (cxy,
c.c.uaucc.:, ccnuc.ac.ucc.: cqcuu c-
c.ca.cx:c.a (cxa, ccc.ac.c.auc cqcuu (cauua
uca a.cuax:ucrc naaa, a .ac ccc.-
ac.c.auc uaa+auua .acc.u ncc.ynxcuua.
Ha+ua+cuuc uaa+auua nc cnaac(xuacc.u a
ac+(aauuc +a cc(cauucc +xc nc(ncxarac. cc-
x(cuuc cnc(cxcuu:x naaux, a:aa_ux-
ca, a +ac.ucc.u, a uu(uau(yaxu+aquu uaa+a-
uua. lurcac a a. naaccy(ua ~ .c
ccc.acuuc u.cr cnaac(xuacu ncqc(y:
accc.cuua u a+cacuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa,
ncac(cuucu a ccc.ac.c.auu c .ccaauuau
(cuc.ay_crc +acua.
lc+ycxcauc, xuqc, +auu.ccccaauucc a ucxc-
(c (cxa, ucc. naac ua ucncxucuuc cy(cucrc
cacuua. la.ua lacncuccrc Cy(a (ac.
nuc:, caa+auu:c c a+cacuuc acnccca,
aca_uxca axc ua (xu.cx:ucc ucucncxuc-
uuc ac.ynuaaux a +acuuy cuxy cy(cu:x
cacuuu. Hccaccaccuucc.: ucncxucuua c-
acuuu cy(a nu+uac.ca uayacuuc c.. 6
Kcuacuquu (uanuc, (cxc Xcucu nc.ua
lcquu)
8
. laac (cc.yna naaccy(u (cx-
uc :.: cccnc+cuc ucncxucuuc cy(cucrc
cacuua, cxa(a_crc u(u+cccu cuxcu.
Oa+auucc.: cccnc+cuua cacuua cy(a xc-
u. ua rccy(ac.ac.
laac ua cy(cuy +a_u.y a ncqcccy-
ax:u:u uuc.u.y., nc uaacy ucuu, cnua-
_cyca ua auaxu+ cy(cucu na.uu lac-
ncuccrc Cy(a nc +a_u.c naa +cxcaca, cc.:
cnxcc ncqcccyax:u:x naa, c.uccu:x
a(y cy.c.uau:x u(u+ccux naa uu-
(uau(a, ax+a_uu:
~ naac ua ccncna.c.acuucc ca_c-
uuc a(crc a cy(, a .c +ucxc ~ naac ua
caxcaauuc x:x uc+acuu:x (cuc.auu u
cacuuu (cxucc.u:x xuq u crauca, ccy_c-
c.axa_ux ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy,
ncna.c.ay_ux caxu+aquu naaa ua (cc.yn
7
C.: lcc.aucaxcuuc Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a
IU c. 8 (caa 2OOJ r. ` J8-l lc (cxy
c ncacc cuc.u.yqucuu:x ncxccuuu c.. J25,
J29, 227, 229, 2J7, 2J9, 246, 254, 27J, J78, 4O5 u
4O8, a .ac rxaa J5 u J9 \lK IU a caa+u
c +anccau cy(ca c_cu uc(uquu u axc-
au ra(au Ccauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. 2OOJ. B:n. 5J. C.. 5O26.
8
Icacuuc lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa +cxc-
aca c. J9 a.a J997 r.
. M. Bo:o{uno. laac ua (cc.yn naaccy(u
J4
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
naaccy(u uxu uc+acuuc crauu+uaa-
_ux .c naac;
~ naac ua c.uaucc u caccaccu-
ucc accxc(caauuc yrcxcaucrc (cxa;
~ naac ua accc.cuuc (cxa uc+aaucu-
: cy(c;
~ naac ua xcru.uu:u (+acuu:u) cc-
c.aa cy(a;
~ naac ua ccnuc.ac.ucc accc.c-
uuc u a+cacuuc yrcxcaucrc (cxa;
~ naac ua accc.cuuc u a+cacuuc
(cxa a a+yu:c (yc.aucaxcuu:c +acuc)
ccu;
~ naac ua +acuuy ncqc(yy accc.-
cuua u a+cacuua (cxa;
~ naac ua rxacuy ncqc(yy accc.-
cuua (cxa;
~ naac ua ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: ncqccca,
cccnc+uaaccrc aacuc.ac c.ccu;
~ naac nc.cncaacrc ua a(caa.ucc.:
cc(c.a +a_u.: naa u +acuu:x uu.cccca;
~ naac ua accc.aucaxcuuc uayacuu:x
naa u ccc.ac.c.ay_y cncucaqu nu-
+uucuucrc ac(a;
~ naac ua ncccc. nurcaca a:ac-
c.ca_u cy(c;
~ naac ua ucncxucuuc cy(cucrc cac-
uua
9
.
laac ua cy(cuy +a_u.y (cxuc :.:
cccnc+cuc cuc.ccu naaca:x raau.uu, ua-
naaxcuu:x ua caxu+aqu a(crc u+ ua+aau-
u:x cncucu.ca, axc(a_ux a cc(cauuc .crc
naaa. lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c cccnc+u.cx:u:u
cxauu+ (cxcu ax+a.: a cca a( xc-
cu.ca. C.y.ya cxauu+a (cxua c.a-
a.: cy acncxccuua .ux xccu.ca u
xaa.c a+auc(cuc.aua ux c.ccu u cacuc.a.
lcaca a+:c uxcccca: .c ~ ccacyn-
ucc.: yc.cu+ua:x caa+cu c.c.a, cccnc+u-
aa_ux crc qcxcc.ucc.:
JO
. 1au ca+c,
a cc(cauuc .crc ncua.ua, ac-nca:x, axc-
(u. ucc.ccc +ucxc xccu.ca u, ac-a.c:x,
acncxccuuc xccu.ca .acac, +.c cuc nc(-
ncxarac. (cc.a.c+uc yc.cu+uay caa+: ux c(y
ccc, +c, ccc.acuuc, u cnc(cxac.ca qcxcc.-
ucc.: c.y.yucrc ca+caauua. Occnc+c-
uuc naaa ua cnaac(xuay cy(cuy +a_u.y
(cxuc :.: ccucaauc, nc(c accrc, ua +c.c
cnc(cxcuu:x +acuc qcxax u +a(a+ax yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, ncccx:y c-
.uaucc.: xcrc au(a (ca.cx:ucc.u +aaucu.
c. qcxcacu ncra: u cuc.u+aquu +a(a+
a cc(c.a cc ccy_cc.axcuua.
laac ua cnaac(xuay cy(cuy +a_u.y
(cxuc :.: cccnc+cuc .ac +c.cc.:
ncqc(y, nc(c.aaxa_ux cccu nca(c nc-
u+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcaucy (cxy, yc.aucaxcuu:u
+acuc. l(uuc.ac yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu
c: a:c.ynac. a raau. cnaac(xuacc.u
u aau:x ac+cucc.cu. Ku(u+ccaa cuxa
cccnc+u.cx:ucrc cxauu+a (cxua :.:
cycxcaxcua cuc.ccu nuuqunca, c.aa-
_ux nc.cucc.u c_cc.acuucrc a+au.ua.
K (yru xccu.a .crc cxauu+a cxc(yc.
c.ucc.u +c.y cnc(cxcuucc.: naa accx y+a-
c.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, ca+auucc.cu
axac.u:x cy.c.ca, ccy_cc.axa_ux ncu+-
ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy, u, c+ycxcauc,
yc.aucaxcuu:c +acuc a ccc.ac.c.auu c .c-
caauuau c(yuac(u:x c.au(a.ca nc-
qc(y:, cccnc+uaa_uc c.uaucc.: na-
accy(ua. Mcxauu+ a cuc.ca +acu:ca, ua-
naaxcuu:x ua cccnc+cuuc naaa +cxcaca
ua cy(cuy +a_u.y, (cxcu (cuc.acaa.: .a,
+.c: acc xccu.:, cnc(cxa_uc cc(ca-
uuc .crc naaa, crxu :.: caxu+caau: uau-
xy+au ca+c.
B u(u+cccu xu.ca.yc cnaac(xuac
c.aau.ca acncc c uccxc(ucc.u +acnxc-
uua nuuquna cacc(: (cc.yna naaccy(u
a \lK IU
JJ
. lc(xaracaa uau uca
cc. uc.: cxc(y_y c(aqu:
9
lc(cucc c.: Bo:o{uno . M.. Bo:o{uno A. H.
\rcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac: naac ua cnaac(-
xuay u rxacuy cy(cuy +a_u.y. M., 2OJO.
JO
C.: Ka.aa uxccccaa uquxcnc(ua. M.,
J994. C. 4J8.
JJ
C.: Bocoumoeo . A. lcqcccyax:ucc cry-
xucaauuc (cc.yna ra(au naaccy(u a yrc-
xcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac \rcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:u c(cc Icccuuccu Uc(caquu: rc( na-
acnucucuua. M., 2OO4. C. 4J46.
J5
C.a.:a... Cacc(a (cc.yna naaccy(u
J. Cacc(a (cc.yna naaccy(u nc(nc-
xarac. naac a(crc ua ccncna.c.acuucc
ca_cuuc a cy(, naac ua ccnuc.ac.ucc
accc.cuuc u a+cacuuc (cxa uc+aaucu-
: cy(c a yc.aucaxcuu:c +acuc ccu,
naac ua cnaac(xuacc cacuuc cy(a, accc.a-
ucaxcuuc uayacuu:x naa u ua ncxuy c-
ncucaqu nu+uucuucrc ac(a.
2. Cacc(a (cc.yna naaccy(u nc(-
ncxarac. naac ua caxcaauuc xcrc uc+a-
cuucrc (cuc.aua u cacuua (cxucc.u:x xuq
u crauca, ccy_cc.axa_ux ncu+ac(c.ac nc
yrcxcaucy (cxy.
J. Orau: u (cxucc.u:c xuqa, ccy_cc.-
axa_uc ncu+ac(c.ac nc (cxy, ca+au: ccc-
nc+u.: naac ua cy(cuy +a_u.y a(crc.
4. Cacc(a (cc.yna naaccy(u ccc-
nc+uaac.ca yc.aucaxcuucu uac.ca_u Kc-
(ccc ncqc(ycu ac+y(cuua, accxc(c-
aauua, accc.cuua u a+cacuua yrcxca-
ucrc (cxa.
lc(xaraccc (cncxucuuc cuc.c: nuu-
qunca nu(axc : +acnxcuu: a rxaac a.c-
cu \lK IU ccucau: ua+axa yrcxcauc-
rc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa x:ay +ua+ucc.:
c .c+u +cuua ccc.ac.c.aua c_cnu+uau-
u: nuuquna u uca c(yuac(ucrc
naaa u c(yuac(u: (crcaca. C .c+-
u +cuua auy.uuaqucuax:ucu +ua+ucc.u
ua+aauu:u nuuqun aauxca : (cncxuu.cx:-
ucu raau.ucu cccnc+cuua naa +cxcaca u
ra(auuua a ccc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa Icccuu.
. M. Bo:o{uno. laac ua (cc.yn naaccy(u
J6
B nccxc(ucc aca (cacx:uc +ac.c a .ccuu yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca a:ca+:aac.ca ucuuc c .c, +.c c.c ncua.ua cc-
uauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a uc cc. uc+cn:aa.:ca xua: a:aaxc-
uuc +ua+ucu (xa (cxa uucaquu. Cac(cuua cry. c.a.:
(ca+a.cx:c.ac xua: .cr(a, cr(a cuu cxc+cu: a ccc.ac.c.ay-
_y ncqcccyax:uy cy c(ucrc u+ uc.c+uuca (ca+a.cx:c.a
(+. 2 c.. 74 \lK). Hua+c rcaca, (c+uaaa.cx:, cxc(caa.cx:, cy(
a.u+ccu ncca+y. uucaqu a (ca+a.cx:c.aa, .c cc.:
ux cuy.
J
.
B caa+u c .u, uanuc, ya+auuc a +aaaxcuuu nc.cnca-
au xuq, c.c:x uccxc(uc a:+aa.: a cy( a a+cc.ac cau(c.c-
xcu, u crc ccc_cuuc c ccacacuuc ncc.ynxcuuu nucc.a.
(ca+a.cx:c.acuucc +ua+cuuc, cr(a nc.cncaauu u cau(c.cxu
y(y. a:+aau: a cy( u (cncacu: c ucaqucu ux nca+auuu
a nc.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua. 1c c cacc a-
cac.ca nc(c.ca u (cycu.ca, c.c:c cry. nc(-
c.aaxa.:ca c.ccuau a cy(cuc +acc(auuu ~ cuu
nucc.y. (ca+a.cx:c.acuucc +ua+cuuc .cx:c nu
ycxcauu, +.c y(y. nuua.: uca: cy(:cu c u-
caqucu c .c a nc.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua.
Mucacu cy(:a r. Oca A. A. ,+cuc nc(-
xarac. aucc.u cxc(y_uc u+cucuua a +. 2 c.. JJ9 \lK IU:
lc xc(a.auc.ay c.ccu ucacu cy(:a anaac ca+a.: u cc-
(cuc.auc a ccuauuu .aux (ca+a.cx:c.a, c.c:c uc cry.
:.: ncxy+cu: c.ccuau cacc.ca.cx:uc. Mucacu cy(:a anaac
nc ccc.acuucu uuuqua.uac ccua.: (ca+a.cx:c.aa nu (ca-
+:aauuu cc.ca.cx:c.a, nc(ycc.cuu:x nn. J7 +. J c.. 7J
uac.ca_crc Kc(cca
2
.
M: ccxu(au: c nc+uqucu .cx ncqcccyaxuc.ca, c.c:c
ncxara., +.c ucacu cy(:a uc (cxcu :.: naccuau:
0. B. Iyocp:ou
K uonpocy o npoucccyaxrno arrnunocrn
mnpouoro cyrn npn nponsuocruc
no yroxounrm cxam uacrnoro o6unncnnn
Oner Bnapucnauouun fy6epman,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
uanop anypennen cry6u,
capunn npenoaaaeru xaqepu
rpaancxoro npaaa n npoecca
Knpoacxoro qnrnara Axaeunn OCHP Poccnn
CubernanOv1nall.ru
J
C.: Lcuc C. A. Cxc(c.acuu:c (cuc.aua. Cuc.ca u ncqcccy-
ax:uaa ca. M., 2OOJ. C. 89.
2
.cno A. A. Hcc.c:c acncc: ccuauua u uccxc(caauua
uca: cy(:cu (ca+a.cx:c.a nc (cxa +ac.ucrc cauucuua Mu-
cacu cy(:a. 2OO6. ` 7. C. J8J9.
J7
uax(a.cxc ncucxc(a_crc c(y c.ccua-
u ccc.a+auua. Mucacu cy(:a (cxcu a nc-
ay c+cc(: :.: uc+aaucu: u c.c.ua-
u: nc c.ucacuu c.ccua yrcxcaucrc cy-
(cncu+ac(c.aa, ccy_cc.axaa ycac(c.ac acc
ncqcccc nc accc.cuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa
+ac.ucrc cauucuua c. cacrc crc ua+axa u (c
a:ucccuua cacuua. B +ac.ucc.u, ucacu cy-
(:a ca+au a+.acua.: c.ccua ux naaa u
ca+auucc.u, a .ac nccxc(c.aua ccacacuua
uxu ucccacacuua ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu.
lcuc .crc, ucacu cy(:a ca+au uc .cx:-
c cc+(aaa.: c.ccua uccxc(u:c ycxcaua
(xa caxu+aquu uu cacux naa, uc u a:ncx-
ua.: ycxcaua (xa accc.ccuucrc, ncxucrc u
c.c.uaucrc uccxc(caauua (ca+a.cx:c.a,
a .ac (xa yc.aucaxcuua accx cc.ca.cx:c.a
(cxa. B cuxy +. J c.. 46 Kcuc.u.yquu IU
a(cy ra(auuuy raau.uyc.ca cy(cuaa
+a_u.a crc naa u cacc(, cxc(caa.cx:uc, u-
cacu cy(:a ca+au nuuua.: ua cca ncxuc-
c+ua nc +a_u.c naa u cacc( ra(auuua.
O+cau(uc, +.c nu naccuauc ncac(cuuu u-
cacrc cy(:u ucac+cuc ccy_cc.au.: +a_u-
.y ra(au.
lc ucuu H. C. Cccxcaccu, cy( uc (cx-
cu +auua.: naccuauy nc+uqu u ncna(a.:
a +aaucucc.: c. c.ccu. Hc u cacc.ca.cx:-
uc ccua.: (ca+a.cx:c.aa cy( .cc uc (cx-
cu ~ .c nc.uacc+u. nuc(c ccc.a+a-
.cx:ucc.u, ncccx:y cy(, uaxc(a .c uxu uucc
(ca+a.cx:c.ac, aa.ca.u+ccu nuuuac. +:-
xuc c.ccuy a +aaucucc.u c. .crc, a +:
cuc ncx:+y. Cy(, ccuaa cauuu.cx:u:c uxu
cnaa(a.cx:u:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa, acauaac.ca
a (ca.cx:ucc.: c.ccu u .cac. c.c.uaucc.:.
\ ucrc ncaaxac.ca nc(yc(cuuc c.uccu.cx:-
uc auucaucc.u uxu ucauucaucc.u xuqa a cc-
acacuuu ncc.ynxcuua, u+cuu.: c.ccc
a (ax:ucuac c+cu: cxcuc
J
.
Ka cnaac(xuac c.c+ac. S. U. Kyqcaa,
ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: uc cacqcx:. Oua cnaa(aua,
uyua, aaua, nc.cy +.c ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: aa-
ucnaau:x c.ccu, uc ccaa nu .c cy( ua
naccuaucc.:, ~ uaucxcc ua(cu:u naacacu
uuc.ycu., cccnc+uaa_uu nu+uauuc ra-
(auuua auucau: a ccacacuuu ncc.ynxcuua,
ccxu .c ccc.ac.c.ayc. (cuc.au.cx:ucc.u, ccc-
nc+uaa_cu yc.aucaxcuuc uc.uu:
4
.
Ha na.uc cy_cc.ayc. cc.aa uccxc-
(ucc.: cca uca:u cy(:au (ca+a-
.cx:c.a cacc.ca.cx:uc, nc ccc.acuucu uuu-
qua.uac. S.c uccxc(uc, cr(a c.ccu: a xc(c
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa naccuau: u uc +a-
aaxa. xc(a.auc.aa c ncu+ac(c.ac .crc uxu
uucrc ncqcccyax:ucrc (cuc.aua, +.c +ua+u-
.cx:uc +a.aruaac. ncqccc yc.aucaxcuua uc-
.uu: nc yrcxcaucy (cxy.
lc ucuu ucacrc cy(:u Haaucaccrc
aucua Haaucaccu cxac.u ^. A. ,cuuccaa,
ccua.: (ca+a.cx:c.aa ucacy cy(:c nc
ccc.acuucu uuuqua.uac ncc.c uccxc(uc,
ncccx:y +aaau.cxu uc xc(a.auc.ay. ncc(
cy(c c uc.ccaauuu cac(cuuu c cy(ucc.u
cauuaccrc, c ncacc crc nc y+c.a uac-
uxu ncuxcucacxcru+cccrc (ucnauccca
5
.
lcacua+ax:ucc ucuuc B. B. ,ccacaa
c .c, +.c ncc_: uca:x cy(cu c.ccua
a ccuauuu (ca+a.cx:c.a (cnyc.ua, ccxu cua
ccy_cc.axac.ca nc xc(a.auc.ay c.ccu, u +.c
.c uc nc.uacc+u. nuuquny ccc.a+a.cx:uc-
c.u
6
, cnyc.a ucc.ccc aca u+cuuxcc:. M:
c(uuc(yau: c (yru ucuuc B. B. ,cca-
caa nc (auucy acnccy: ...cr(a ycuxuu c.c-
cu: aauc uc(cc.a.c+uc, +.c: cacc.ca.cx:-
uc ucnaau.: ncxccuuc, .c ucacu cy(:a uc
(cxcu (a.: ncqcccy cc.aucau.:ca. Ou ca-
+au accc.aucau.: aaucaccuc c.ccu, +.c: (cxc
:xc (cac(cuc (c xcru+cccrc cuqa. ,xa
J
C.: Coo:oeco+ H. C. Icaxu+aqua cy(c
yuquu a+cacuua (cxa Bcc.u. 1cccrc
rcc. yu-.a. Cc.: Scucua. Ku(u+ccuc ua-
yu. 2OO4. ` 4. C. 78.
4
lqoeo 3. 0. \rcxcau:u ncqccc Icccuu: uc-
.uua u ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: acuc(a.cx:c.ac.
2OO2. ` 9. C. J4.
5
C.: cnucoe . A. Bcncc: cy(cucrc cxc(-
c.aua y ucacrc cy(:u nc yrcxcau: (cxa +a-
c.ucrc cauucuua Mucacu cy(:a. 2OO6. ` 5.
C. J9.
6
C.: oomoe B. B. Occcuucc.u yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa y ucacrc cy(:u Icc. cy-
(:a. 2OO2. ` 4. C. 4J.
O. B. lc+on. K acnccy c ncqcccyax:ucu a.uaucc.u ucacrc cy(:u
J8
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
.crc (cnyc.ua cnc(cxcuuaa cycu(uauaa
a.uaucc.: cy(:u a a:acucuuu uc.uu: nc (cxy,
a .c +ucxc ncac(cuuc u ncqcccyax:u:x
(cuc.auu
7
.
Kcc .crc, uuuqua.uaa ucacrc cy(:u
ancxuc ycc.ua a cxy+aax, cr(a +acu nc-
(yca.uaac. ca+a.cx:ucc ncac(cuuc aux-
xuc ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu, uc uu c. c(-
ucu c.ccu: ccc.ac.c.ay_cc xc(a.auc.ac
c crc ncac(cuuu uc ncc.ynac..
B yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac nuuqun
ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u nc(ncxarac., +.c cauucuuc
u +a_u.a ccy_cc.axa.ca .cx:c .cu cnc-
(cxcuu:u a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +ac-
uc crauau u xuqau, c.c:c ua(cxcu: ncx-
ucc+uau a:c.yna.: a a+cc.ac y+ac.uuca
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa cc c.ccu: c-
auucuua u cc c.ccu: +a_u.:. lu .c
a:ncxucuuc yuquu cauucuua +ax+ac.ca
a ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua, c-
yxucaauuu cauucuua u c.c.auaauuu crc
a cy(c. B ccc.ac.c.auu c +acuc a xc(c cy-
(cucrc cxc(c.aua yc.auaaxuaa.ca uc .cx:-
c cc.ca.cx:c.aa, nc(.ac(a_uc (ca+au-
ucc.: cauucuua, uc .ac u cc.ca.cx:c.aa,
car+a_uc auuy nc(cy(ucrc uxu cnaa(:-
aa_uc crc, a aauc uu:c cc.ca.cx:c.aa, uc-
cxc(u:c (xa cnaac(xuacrc u ccnuc.ac-
.ucrc a+cacuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa nc cy_c-
c.ay. Cxc(caa.cx:uc, ccuauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a
uc .cx:c aaxac.ca nccra.uacu c.ccu, uc u
axc(u. a +ucxc ncxucc+uu cy(a, caxu+yc:x
a nca(c, yc.aucaxcuuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u: +acuc(a.cx:c.ac (xa ncu+ac(c.aa
cy(cucrc cxc(c.aua
8
.
Cy_cc.ay. u cxcc u.u+ccuc cqcuu
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa nc
(auucy acnccy, u : nu+uac ux cccuc-
aauu:u. 1a, ccrxacuc c(ucu u+ uux, +acuc-
(a.cx:, c.cac: cra(u.: cy( c. cauuu.cx:-
ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, +aacx (ax:ac caccu qcxu.
Orauu+ua ac+cucc.: cy(a a ccuauuu u
uccxc(caauuu (ca+a.cx:c.a a aax cc-
yxucaauucrc cauucuua, +acuc(a.cx: a.c-
rca a cy_ucc.u:c nu+uau cy(cucu axac.u
u (cnyc.ux cc yaxcuuc. Ccaccuuaa c(cx:
ncac(cuua cy(a a cy(cuc +acc(auuu nc-
na.c.ayc. cacc(ucy cucaauu auy.cu-
ucrc yc(cuua cy(:u, uc nc+acxac. accc.c-
cuuc u ncxuc ncacu.: +acuucc.: u cc-
cucaauucc.: ccy_cc.axcuucrc yrcxcaucrc nc-
cxc(caauua, aauc a u c.a+a c. ucrc, +.c
(cxac. cy(cuy axac.: ncqcccyax:uc +aau-
cucu
9
.
acxyuaac. auuauua .c+a +cuua nc-
cccca M. K. Cauu(caa, ccrxacuc c.ccu
cy( (xa a:ucccuua uc.uuucrc nurcaca c-
c. ac+(cuc.acaa.: ua c.ccu:, uc nc(c.a-
auaauc acc uccxc(u:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa (xa
a+cacuua (cxa. Ia+cacuuc ncxcucu
cu.yaquu nc(cu: ca+c ccxauu. u ucu.-
ax:ucc.: cy(a, u raau.u yc.aucaxcuua uc.u-
u: nc (cxy. O(uac .acu nc(xc( uc +acn-
xcu a \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc c(ccc
JO
.
Bcxc( +a ncccccc S. U. Kyqcacu :
ncxarac, +.c ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: u aaucna-
auc c.ccu uc cry. accncxuu.: ca+auucc.u
(c+uaaa.cxa, cxc(caa.cxa, ncyca u cy(a uc-
cxc(caa.: cc.ca.cx:c.aa (cxa ncxuc, accc.c-
cuuc u c.c.uauc ~ uccxc(ucrc ny.u
xcrc nc+uauua
JJ
.
lc(cxaa cccuca:aa.: (auuy .c+y +c-
uua, : ccxu(au: u c u+xccuucu a:ac na-
acacu nc+uqucu Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU.
7
oomoe B. B. Mucacu cy(:a. Hc.cu+cc-
uc, crauu+aqucuu:c u ncqcccyax:u:c acnc.:
(ca.cx:ucc.u. M., 2OO4. C. J59.
8
Onc(cxcuuc Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU c.
6 a.a 2OOJ r. ` JO4-O O c.a+c a nuua-
.uu accc.cuu +ancca lccu.crcccrc
rcc(ccrc cy(a ^cuuura(ccu cxac.u c nc-
acc cuc.u.yqucuucc.u +ac.u J c.a.:u 86
\lK IU.
9
C.: lo:onuquu B. B. Ccc.a+a.cx:ucc ncc.c-
cuuc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa uc (cxuc ncna.c.acaa.:
cacc(ucy cucaauu auy.cuucrc yc(c-
uua cy(:u Bcc.u. 1cccrc rcc. yu-.a: Ma.cu-
ax: uay+u:x cuccuquu, cunc+uyca, acx, nc-
ac(u:x a 1l\. 1cc, 2OOJ. ` 4. C. 76.
JO
C.: Coo:oeco+ H. C. Icaxu+aqua cy(c
yuquu a+cacuua (cxa Bcc.u. 1cccrc
rcc. yu-.a. Cc.: Scucua. Ku(u+ccuc ua-
yu. 2OO4. ` 4. C. 7879.
JJ
C.: lqoeo 3. 0. \a+. cc+. C. J4.
J9
O+cau(uc, +.c nu cacuuu acncca c cc-
c.a+a.cx:ucc.u yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
ua cy(cu:x c.a(uax uu a cc cxy+ac ucx:+a
nccrua.: naxy a c.ccuy xuacuua uc-
acrc cy(:u naaa yc.auaaxuaa.: uc.uuy nc (cxy.
Kcy y(c. ua yy .aaa ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.:,
xuaa_aa ucacrc cy(: ccc.acuucu uuu-
qua.ua: a nuua.uu c nc yc.aucaxcuu
uc.uu: nc (cxy'
M: ncxucc.: nc((cuaac .c+y +c-
uua H. H. Ucuuuqcrc c .c, +.c ac acac
ncxccuuu (cxa cy( nc ccc.acuucu uuuqua-
.uac cc. u (cxcu yc.auu.: ucnaaux:ucc
nucucuuc +acua, u ycc.cuucc, xc.a :
c.ccu: .crc uc .ccaaxu
J2
.
Ha ccucaauuu cnc(cxcuua Kcuc.u.yqu-
cuucrc Cy(a IU c. 6 a.a 2OOJ rc(a c-
uc cuc.a.ucaa.:, +.c ua+ua+cuuc u ncu+-
ac(c.ac cy(cucu cnc.u+: a xc(c cy(c-
ucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa (cxa +ac.ucrc cauuc-
uua cc. ncucxc(u.: nc uuuqua.uac uc-
acrc cy(:u. S.c cc.ca.cx:c.ac uc (cxuc
acqcuuaa.:ca a cauuu.cx:uaa uxu +a_u.-
uaa yuqua ucacrc cy(:u, .a a a (au-
uc cxy+ac a:ncxucuuc .crc ncqcccyax:uc-
rc (cuc.aua uccxc(uc u (cxuc acca.u-
aa.:ca a a:ncxucuuc uca: cy(:cu yu-
quu naaccy(ua
JJ
.
J4
C.: lom A. A. Cnccc: ccuauua cy(c
(ca+a.cx:c.a nc \lK IU Bcc.u. 1cccrc
rcc. yu-.a: Ma.cuax: uay+u:x cuccuquu, cu-
nc+uyca, acx, ncac(u:x a 1l\. C. 48.
lcxu cyucaa.: a:acu+xccuu:c nc-
+uquu, cuc c(cxa.: a:ac(, +.c ccuauuc
(ca+a.cx:c.a nc yrcxcau: (cxa +ac.ucrc
cauucuua aaxac.ca uc .cx:c nccra.uacu
c.ccu, uc (cxuc axc(u.: a ncxucc+ua u-
cacrc cy(:u. Bc u+cauuc a+xu+ucrc .cx-
caauua uc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +ac-
uc(a.cx:c.aa ua na.uc u ac u+cauuc cy-
(cu:x cauc uccxc(uc aucc.u ccc.ac.-
c.ay_uc (cncxucuua a +acuc(a.cx:c.ac u
cxcc +c.c cnc(cxu.: ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.: c.c-
cu nu ncu+ac(c.ac nc (cxa +ac.ucrc cau-
ucuua u yuqu ucacrc cy(:u. B +ac.ucc.u,
cau cc(cuc.aua ucacrc cy(:u c.ccua
a ccuauuu (ca+a.cx:c.a cry. :.::
~ ncy+cuua craua (c+uauua ncac-
(cuua cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu u cnca.uauc-
c+:cu:x ccnua.uu;
~ +ancc: a a+xu+u:c crauu+aquu c
uc.ccaauuu uccxc(u:x (cycu.ca, uc-
_ux +ua+cuuc (xa (cxa.
B xc(c accc.cuua yrcxcau:x (cx (au-
ucu a.crcuu ancxuc cc. ac+uuuy.: cu.y-
aqua, cr(a y(c. uccxc(uc ncacc.u acc-
xuc nc(ycc.cuucc \lK IU cxc(c.acu-
ucc (cuc.auc, a ccc.ac.c.ay_crc xc(a.auc.aa
c. c.ccu uc +aaaxcuc. B (auuc acnccc
: ccrxaaacca c .c+cu +cuua A. A. la-
aya, +.c uuuqua.uaa ua ncac(cuuc cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu xcu. a ncay c+cc(:
ua c.ccuax, uc nu uccxc(ucc.u ac+xara-
c.ca u ua cy(
J4
.
J2
C.: eo+nuno 7. C. ,ca+:aauuc a cy(c
ncacu uuc.auquu. Icx: cy(a Bcc.u. 1cccrc
rcc. yu-.a: Ma.cuax: uay+u:x cuccuquu, cu-
nc+uyca, acx, ncac(u:x a 1l\. C. 8J.
JJ
Onc(cxcuuc Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU c.
6 a.a 2OOJ rc(a ` JO4-O.
O. B. lc+on. K acnccy c ncqcccyax:ucu a.uaucc.u ucacrc cy(:u
4O
B nccxc(ucc aca cc c.ccu: y+cu:x-ncqcccyaxuc.ca
Icccuu cx:acc auuauuc c.axc y(cxa.:ca acnccy c aac(cuuu
a cccuuccc yrcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac cocnno:o c{ono-
u.eo{cmeo (oc |cc }cccnoo}. Hcccucuuc, .c. acncc +acxycu-
uc nuaxcac. ccc auuauuc, ncccx:y cu caa+au c c.a+c
c. yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua xuqa, a .ac c. yrcxcaucu c.ac.-
c.acuucc.u u uaa+auua. H+acc.uc, +.c ccrc(ua a +ana(ucu uc-
ny(cuquu (cc.a.c+uc aucc ncnyxau+uyc.ca .cuu oicccsion
(c.xcucuuc, c.xc(), c+ua+a_uu, +.c a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+-
ac(c.ac ucc. cc.c c.c.ynxcuuc, c.xc( c. .aux ncua.uu, a
yrcxcaucc nccxc(caauuc, yrcxcauaa c.ac.c.acuucc.: u uaa+a-
uuc. B+acu uux nc(xccu: .auc ncua.ua, a auccy(cucc
ycryxucaauuc yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca, c(cxu ycryxuc-
aauua yrcxcauc-naaca:x cncca u (. Kcu.c.c uuuc.ca
rccy(ac.a ~ +xcuca Ccac.a lacn: a cuquax:u:x cccu-
(aquax c. J7 ccu.aa J987 rc(a c(ccu .acu nc(xc( u nc
ucy nc(xccu: cuc.u:c aauau.: c(cxcu nc(cucrc yc-
ryxucaauua yrcxcauc-naaca:x cuxu.ca a au(c
c.(cx:u:x c, ax:.cua.uau:x yrcxcaucy nccxc-
(caauu.
lcxu ca.uca (cuc.ay_cy +acuc(a.cx:-
c.ay Icccuu, .c a:acua+aauu:c ncua.ua ancxuc cc-
c.ac.c.ay. (cuc.ay_cy uuc.u.y.y ccacc(cuua
c. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u (c_uc ccucaauua
nucucuua c.acu: a c.a.:ax 7678 \K IU, cncquax:-
u:c ~ a c.a.:ax J26, 2O5 u (. ccccuucu +ac.u \K IU).
1au ca+c, cuc uax(a.: c.c.uauy .cu(cuqu, ua-
naaxcuuy ua a+au.uc ccaccuucrc cccuuccrc yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa c aqcu.c ua ax:.cua.uau:c c:, c.c-
:c c ycncxc ucncx:+y.ca a +aycucu na.uc.
1a, uanuc, ccxu yrcxcaucc nccxc(caauuc ncac(cuc
c+ax:.cua.uauc, .c .c c+ua+ac., +.c xuqc nu+uauc auucau:
a ccacacuuu ncc.ynxcuua, uc cy( nu cnc(cxcuu:x naaca:x
ycxcauax cc. nu .c uc ua+ua+u.: xuqy yrcxcaucc uaa+a-
uuc, a ucncx:+caa.: .a ua+:aaccc ax:.cua.uaucc uaa+a-
uuc. C.axc :.:, ax:.cua.uaa yrcxcaucy nccxc(caauu ac+-
cua, uc ucx+u.cx:uc nu ycxcauu, +.c nucy.c.ay. naac-
a:c ccucaauua (xa cacrc a.a yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua.
A. H. Iycvnoeo
K uonpocy o npnmcncnnn ycropcnnn
yroxounoro npouccca
Anvonuna Revpouna fycuuoua,
oxop pnnecxnx nayx, npoqeccop,
aacryennun pnc PO, aaaeyuan
xaqepon yroroanoro npoecca
Open6yprcxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
4J
O.c(a cxc(yc., +.c nca_cuuc yrcxcaucrc
(cxa +a c.cy.c.auc ccc.aaa ncc.ynxcuua uxu
nu uc.c+cuuu ccca (aaucc.u uua uc c-
ry. :.: ycxcauc ax:.cua.ua: yrcxcaucy
nccxc(caauu. Auaxcru+uc cxc(yc. acca.-
uaa.: u .c cxy+au, cr(a xuqc cnaa(auc u
acc_c uc nc(xcu. uaa+auu.
acuc(a.cx: xc.a u +acnux ycxcaua u
ccucaauua nucucuua ax:.cua.uau:x c,
uc .c uc c+ua+ac., +.c naacnucuu.cx: uc-
nccuuc ca+au .c (cxa.:. C.axc :.:, ua-
+ua+cuuc ax:.cua.uau:x c yrcxcaucu nc-
xu.uu cucu.ucaauc ua naaccuy +ac-
uy ccucau:x cy_cc.ay_ux .a(uqucuu:x
xccu.ca caquu rccy(ac.aa ua ncc.ynxc-
uuc u uaa+auuc. lu .c naac cnc.cu.-
u:x rccy(ac.acuu:x crauca nc ucncx:+caa-
uu a+ucca+u:x ax:.cua.uau:x c aa-
xac.ca ucx+u.cx:u: ux naac. 1acc
naac nucuuc, cuc+uc, .cx:c ucxc(a uc-
x+u.cx:uc u+ (uccqucuucrc ycc.cuua u,
ccc.ac.c.acuuc, cc.ca.cx:c.a cuc.ucrc
yrcxcaucrc (cxa.
\+u.:aaa, +.c .ca ycccuua yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca ccrc(ua cccucaauuc nc(c.aaxac. ua-
y+u:u uu.ccc a (xa y+cu:x, .a u (xa na-
.uca Icccuu, ncxarac, +.c nc(c accrc qc-
xcccca+uc ncauaxu+ucaa.: uanaaxcuua
a+au.ua uucc.auucrc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca,
r(c .a .cu(cuqua uanay caa+aua c nc-
qcccyax:ucu cx: nc.cncaacrc, acaucuu-
c (ucnc+u.uaucc.u u ncccc:cxcuuc nc-
qcccyax:ucu cxu nc.cncaacrc, a nxauc c-
ucaauua, a+au.ua u ccacacuc.acaauua crc
naa ua +a_u.y a cccuucc yrcxcauc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.ac.
lcxu xcc rccy(ac.ac cc.: ca cra-
uu+aquu quauxu+caauucrc c_cc.aa, cxa(a-
_aa uccc.ac ccquax:u:x yuquu, .c ua(c
c.c.u.:, +.c cc(u uux nucy.c.ayc. u .aaa
yuqua, a naaccxauu.cx:uaa. S.a yu-
qua cycxcaxcua uccxc(ucc.: cccnc+u-
aa.: +a_u.y uu.cccca c_cc.aa u rccy(a-
c.aa c. nc.uacnaau:x nccara.cx:c.a. Cc-
accuucc cccuuccc (cca.u+cccc na-
acacc rccy(ac.ac nu+aauc cccnc+uaa.: +a-
_u.y naa, cacc( u +acuu:x uu.cccca +cxc-
aca u ra(auuua, a .ac c_cc.aa a qcxc,
cuc.u.yqucuu:u c.cu rccy(ac.aa u crc
+ua+u:c ccquax:u:c qcuucc.u.
,xa cccnc+cuua naaccxauu.cx:ucu yu-
quu rccy(ac.ac cncquax:uc nc(ycc.c-
ua u(u+ccaa c.ac.c.acuucc.: +a ccacac-
uuc ra(auau nc.uacnaau:x (cuc.auu.
lc.cy ccccc cc.c +auuac. cuc.ca yrc-
xcauc-naaca:x uc, c ncc_: c.c:x
cxaua.ca uu.ccc: c_cc.aa u rccy(ac.aa
c. ncc.ynu:x nccara.cx:c.a a uaucxcc
cnacu:x ncaaxcuuu au.uccquax:ucrc ncac-
(cuua ra(au. Hccxy+auuc a c.. 2 Kcuc.u-
.yquu IU nc(+cuaac.ca, +.c +cxcac, crc
naaa u cacc(: aaxa.ca a:cacu qcuucc-
.:; ux nu+uauuc, ccx(cuuc u +a_u.a ~
ca+auucc.: rccy(ac.aa. S.a ccucacncxara-
_aa u(ca uaxc(u. cuc.u+aqu a \lK
IU, a +ac.ucc.u, a c.. 6. B ucu nu cyxu-
caauuu ua+ua+cuua uxu, nc (yrcy, qcxu
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa c.acuc, +.c
+a_u.a naa u +acuu:x uu.cccca xuq u cra-
uu+aquu, nc.cncaaux c. ncc.ynxcuuu, aaxa-
c.ca ncacc+cc(u: (cxc, c.axc :.:, (cc-
.ucuuc +a_u.: naa nc.cncaaux a u(caxc
nc(ncxarac. ac:.uc accx ncc.ynxcuuu
(nyxu+uaa qcx:). Iac:.uc ncc.ynxcuuu,
c(y .c, +ua+uc uc .cx:c (xa c_cc.aa,
uc u, a ncay c+cc(:, (xa c.(cx:u:x ra-
(au, ax+aa nc.cncaaux c. ncc.ynxcuua
(ncucxc(u. caxu+aqua +ac.u:x uu.cccca).
Ocucauaa qcx:, uxu nc(ua+ua+cuuc, yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa +ax+cua ucuuc
a cccnc+cuuu ac+cucc.u +acuucrc, cc-
cucaauucrc u cnaac(xuacrc nucucuua yrc-
xcaucrc +acua, .c cc.: cuc.ucu yrcxcauc-
naacacu uc: auucau: xuqa a caa+u
c ccacacuuc uu ncc.ynxcuua. Hcx+u-
.cx:u: naac nc ccy_cc.axcuu naaccy-
(ua ua(cxcu ucuuc cy(. lcccx:y cy(, a
cy(cuaa axac.:, a +aaucucc.u c. xaa.ca
acca.uaaccrc cnca cc. ccy_cc.axa.:
naaccy(uc a a+xu+u:x crc cax, .c (ca-
.cx:ucc.: nc a+cacuu yrcxcauc-naacac-
rc cuxu.a (uxu, uua+c rcaca, yrcxcaucc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac) a:c.ynac. c(ucu u+ c
ccy_cc.axcuua naaccy(ua.
A. H. lcooeo. K acnccy c nucucuuu ycccuua yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
42
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
lc(+cuc, +.c cy( +auuac. rxaacuc.ay-
_cc ncxccuuc cc(u (yrux cy.c.ca yrc-
xcaucu uc(uquu u ua(cxac.ca naac nu-
+uaaa.: xuqc auucau: a ccacacuuu nc-
c.ynxcuua u ua+ua+a.: cy uaa+auuc.
\+u.:aaa .acc ncxccuuc cy(a a cuc.c-
c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, uc
cxy+auuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa (ca.cx:-
ucc.: aauc+ua+uc ucuyc.ca a yrcxcaucc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
B caa+u c .u ancxuc cnaa(auuc, +.c
ucruc y+cu:c-ncqcccyaxuc.: c+u.a., +.c
yrcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ucx:+a acca.-
uaa.: a (ca.cx:ucc.:, uc_y cacu ua-
+ua+cuuc ucx+u.cx:uc c:y c ncc.yn-
ucc.:, ncc(acy a+xu+u:u nu+uua-
u u ycxcauau. lcc.ynucc.: ~ .c ccqu-
ax:ucc aaxcuuc, a nc.cy uc(cnyc.uc ucncx:-
+caa.: yrcxcaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac (xa c:-
: c ncc.ynucc.: ny.c crauu+cuua naa
u cacc( +cxcaca u ra(auuua u a+xu+u:x
cncccca ync_cuua nca(a cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa uxu ycc.c+cuua ua+ua+ac:x cy(c ua-
a+auuu. laaccy(uc a cc yrcxcaucrc cy-
(cncu+ac(c.aa aaxac.ca c(uu u+ ny.cu ccy-
_cc.axcuua cy(cucu axac.u (+. 2 c.. JJ8
Kcuc.u.yquu IU), nc.cy-.c yrcxcaucc cy-
(cncu+ac(c.ac, ncuuaccc a c(ua u+ c
ccy_cc.axcuua naaccy(ua, a:aac.ca a (c-
a.cx:ucc.u cy(a nc yrcxcau: (cxa, r(c cy-
(cuaa axac.: caxu+yc.ca +cc+ (cuc.aua u
cacuua cy(a. 1cx:c cy( cc. nu+ua.: xuqc
auucau: u ua+ua+u.: cy uaa+auuc
J
.
Cy(, cnc(cxaa xuqy uaa+auuc a cxy+ac
nu+uauua crc auucau: a ccacacuuu nc-
c.ynxcuua, .c ca: cccnc+uaac. ucc.aa-
.ucc.: c.ac.c.acuucc.u xuqa. B caa+u c .u
a uayc a nccxc(ucc aca ccucaaxcc:
ucacc uanaaxcuuc, c.ccc, a cuc cc-
yxucaa.:, a(uuax:uc cuac. naa(ury
ncc.ynxcuuc ~ uaa+auuc. Ka a .cu
caa+u nc(+cuaac. ^. B. lcxcac, a cuqc
XX aca nccccc-uuuaxuc. ^yacuccrc
yuuaccu.c.a (lcx:rua) Uaucya+a 1yxcuc
ucxa acc ccucaauua y.ac(a.: a a.crcu-
+cccu cc: Hcuuc ncca+caauua ua
ycauc uaa+auua nc(cnc(cxa. a uac.ca-
_cc aca acc .c a(uuax:u:c u+cucuua,
c.c:c cuc uax(a.: a cxac.u yrcxca-
ucrc naaa u yrcxcaucu c.uquu
2
. lc(c-
u:c :cxu :xu a:ca+au: u (yruu cx-
xcrau, +.c c.c+ac. a caccu ac.c ^. B. lc-
xcac. Ou, ca_aac: ac.a y+cu:x a-
na(a, cuc.a.uyc., +.c u+uc .a(uqucuucu
cuqcnquu uaa+auua c(ucaccuuc cnccc-
c.acaax ncaaxcuu a uayc uca:x u(cu, caa-
+auu:x c caqucu c_cc.aa u rccy(ac.aa
ua ncc.ynxcuua (rxaau: ca+c uccx:-
acu .acc.u). B +ana(ucu ucny(cuquu,
a nc(+cuaac. ^. B. lcxcac, ucncx:+y.
a .aux cxy+aax aurxuucuu .cuu oicccsion
(c.xcucuuc, c.xc(), a uua+c: cy.: ax:.cua-
.uau:x c
J
.
lcxarac, +.c .cuu oicccsion uxu ax:-
.cua.uaucc a+cacuuc cnccccu ca+a.: ca-
cc xarcnua.ucc (cuc.auc ua ncuc cn.u-
ax:u:x cncccca a+cacuua ac+uuacrc
a caa+u c ccacacuuc uc.acrc ncc.ynxc-
uua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cuxu.a. Bcc .c
cccucaauuc a:+:aac. uu.ccc y+cu:x. lcxcc
.crc, nc(+cuc, +.c Kcu.c. uuuc.ca rccy-
(ac.a ~ +xcuca Ccac.a lacn: a cacux cu-
quax:u:x cccu(aquax c. J7 ccu.aa
J987 rc(a uc .cx:c c(cux u(c auccy(c-
u:x yrcxcauc-naaca:x cncca, uc (ac nc(-
xcux, a cac c+cc(:, cuc.u:c c(cxu nc-
(cucrc ycryxucaauua
4
. Ccrc(ua ua u+acc-
.u: ucruc aauau.: ax:.cua.uau:x cac-
uuu, c.c:c auc(cu: a a+xu+u:x naaca:x
cuc.cax.
Kcc .crc, c.c.u, +.c a uaacu (c.uuc
(xa xaa.cuc.uu naacacu cxu uuc.u.y.a
ccacc(cuua c. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u
nuua.c ync.cxa.: .c. c .cuu, +.c u ua
ana(c, a ucuuc ax:.cua.uau:c c:.
J
C.: \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc naac Icccuu-
ccu Uc(caquu: \+cuu O.a. c(. l. A. ^y-
nuucaa. M., 2OO9. C. 26.
2
lo:oeo . B. Ax:.cua.ua: yrcxcaucy nccxc-
(caauu a ccaccuuc naac. Cl., 2OO8. C. JJ.
J
1a c. C. JJ.
4
C.: Icccu(aqua ` R (87)J8 c. J7 ccu.a-
a J987 r. Icc. c.uqua. J997. ` 8. C. J.
4J
Icccua, acu(a a ccc.aa Ccac.a lacn:
28 caaxa J996 rc(a, 5 aa J998 rc(a a.u-
uqucaaxa lacncucy cuacuqu c +a_u.c
naa +cxcaca u ccucau:x cacc(. B caa+u
c .u uaaa c.aua nuuaxa ua cca cnc(c-
xcuu:c ca+a.cx:c.aa nc nuac(cuu +ac-
uc(a.cx:c.aa, a .c +ucxc yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:ucrc, a ccc.ac.c.auc c c(yuac(u:u
nuuqunau u c.au(a.au u .cnc: ca+aua
ccx(a.: uc .cx:c uaqucuax:u:c, uc u ca-
cncucuc uc: naaa, c.c:c aauc c.(a.
nucu.c. +cxcacy, crc naaa u cacc(a.
Hc cxy+auuc nuua.:u a 2OOJ rc(y \lK
IU a a+cc.ac ua+ua+cuua yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa cnc(cxux +a_u.y naa u +acu-
u:x uu.cccca xuq u crauu+aquu, nc.cnca-
aux c. ncc.ynxcuuu, a .ac +a_u.y xu+ucc.u
c. uc+acuucrc u uccccucaauucrc cauucuua,
ccy(cuua, crauu+cuua cc naa u cacc(. Cc-
c.ac.c.acuuc, cxaua naa u cacc( +cxcaca u
ra(auuua ac+ac(cua a aur nuuquna yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa (c.. JJ \lK). K .cy
c \lK y+cx a( cccu(aquu Ccac.a la-
cn:, uanaaxcuu:x ua cxauy naa u cacc(
+cxcaca u ra(auuua, a .ac a( ncxccuuu,
aca_uxca .cu ncxc:, a+ac.auu:x
y+cu:u. O(uac, uaacy ccaxcuu, ucruc
u+ uux cc.axuc: +a aau Kc(cca.
Hcc.c:c crc uc: .cy c a:+:aa-
. ucc(uc+ua+ucc .cxcaauuc u uc a ncxucu
cc ccc.ac.c.ay. Kcuc.u.yquu IU, +.c
ucc(c nc(+cuaaxcc: a ncc.aucaxcuuax
Kcuc.u.yqucuucrc Cy(a IU, c.c:c :xu
nuua.: yc nccxc aac(cuua a (cuc.auc \lK
IU, a .ac uc ncxucc.: ccc.ac.c.ay. c-
(yuac(u: (cycu.a a cxac.u cccnc+c-
uua naa u cacc( +cxcaca u ra(auuua.
lcxarac, +.c +ana(u:u .cuu ax:.c-
ua.uau:c c: nccxyux c.naaucu .c+cu
a+au.ua uay+u:x uccxc(caauuu y uac a Icc-
cuu u CHl
5
.
\cccuuc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ucnccc(-
c.acuuc caa+auc c ncn:.cu a+cacuua yrc-
xcauc-naacacrc cuxu.a auc ac xaccu-
+cccu yrcxcaucu c.uquu, nu c.ccu c.cy.-
c.ay. .auc u(u+ccuc nccxc(c.aua
ncc.ynxcuua, a yrcxcaucc nccxc(caauuc, yrc-
xcauaa c.ac.c.acuucc.: u uaa+auuc. Oa_a-
ac: a caa+u c .u ncua.u ax:.cua.ua:
yrcxcaucy nccxc(caauu, ucnccuuc cxc-
(yc. ca.u.: auuauuc ua .c, +.c xaa ax:-
.cua.uaa yrcxcaucy nccxc(caauu cc.
:.: .acacu xua: {o noqccco:ono:o o-
mo nu.nonu+ :uqo eunoeno+ e coecmcnuu
nccmn:cnu+. B caa+u c .u accc.u .c,
a u nc au ccucaauua ac+cu: cnccc-
: ycccuua ncqccca. Bcca.uc, c+: a .c
cxy+ac (cxua u(.u c yna+(ucuuu acu-.c
+ac.u yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, c. c.ccu +acuc-
(a.cx: (cxcu c.a+a.:ca (xa ucncx:+caauua
ycccuua yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. B.ccu aau-
au. ycccuua yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ac+ccu
+a c+c. cca_cuua accrc yrcxcaucrc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa a qcxc. lu .c (cxu: :.:
cc+(au: a+xu+u:c ncqcccyax:u:c cuc.y-
quu, aaxa_ucca ax:.cua.uau:u cncccau
a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naaca:x cuxu.ca, uxu,
uua+c rcaca, ax:.cua.uaau yrcxcaucy nc-
cxc(caauu. Oa_aac: Icccu(aquu
` R (87)J8 c. J7 ccu.aa J987 rc(a, cuc
yc(u.:ca, +.c a .c (cycu.c cc(cu.ca
cra.cc cc(cauuc ax:.cua.ua yrcxcaucy
nccxc(caauu oc |cc }cccnoo.
H.a, nc(+cuc, +.c c(uu u+ uaucxcc
a(uax:u:x cncccca ycccuua yrcxcaucrc
ncqccca : au(u a ax:.cua.uauc a+-
cacuuu yrcxcauc-naaca:x cuxu.ca.
\cccuuc ncqccca a .ac cxy+ac (cxuc
ncu+cu.u +a c+c. crc .c.ax:ucrc cca_cuua,
u .c .cr(a u y(c. aaxa.:ca .c ca: u-
nca.uac oc |cc }cccnoo.
hc.aa ncc.ynxcuua ucnccuuc uy(a-
c.ca a accc.aucaxcuuu cacux uy_cc.acuu:x
u xu+u:x ucuy_cc.acuu:x naa, u rccy(a-
c.ac (cxuc ca.u.: ua .c cacc nuc.ax:-
ucc auuauuc.
\rcxcauc-ncxu.u+ccaa nc.cucc.: ac acc-
cucu +a_u.c naa nc.cncaaux c+cau(ua.
5
C., uan.: A:uncoe X. . lcc.ynucc.: u
cncucc. lay, J992. C. 85; lc:uno C. l.
Ocacc(cuuc c. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u a
naacacc nccxc(c.auc ccacacuua ncc.ynxcuua
\rcxcaucc naac: uca:c u(cu. M., J999. C. 68.
A. H. lcooeo. K acnccy c nucucuuu ycccuua yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
44
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Cxc(yc. nu .c c.c.u.:, +.c cua cc.
:.: cacu a+ucca+ucu. (cc: aauc nc-
auaxu+ucaa.:, acu cua cc. c.a.: a (cu-
c.au.cx:ucc.u. Ccrc(ua, ccxu cc.c.: c nc-
+uquu c(cxu naa(ur: uaa+auua, +a_u-
.a uu.cccca nc.cncaacrc cac(u.ca ac+c-
_cuu cy a.cuax:ucrc, uucr(a cax:ucrc
y_ca. 1c, +.c nc.cncaauu c.a(ac. a.c-
u+uc (nca:u a+ c. ncc.ynxcuua) c. a:+c-
aa a cy( a cy(cucc +acc(auuc, r(c cu auca:
(cxcu (aaa.: nca+auua, xc.a cu yc aucc
(aaax ux cxc(caa.cx. B u.crc ac.ac. acncc:
a u+ca.: accrc .crc' lcxarac, +.c ua-
c.axc aca ca.u.: nuc.ax:ucc auuauuc
ua naa(ury accc.aucaxcuua.
laa(ura accc.aucaxcuua ~ .c c-
(cx:, nc(xccuuaa S. Sayc.c. Oua aaxa-
c.ca, nc cy.u, x+cacu qcx: yrcxcaucu c-
.uquu. C:cx cc +ax+ac.ca uc a .c, +.c:
uaa+a.: (ncaa.: naacuayau.cxa), a uc-
x+u.cx:uc a .c, +.c: eoccmonoeumo noeo
:uqo (nomcncemc:o}. nocmo{oemc:o om
nccmn:cnu+. H +(cc:, a : rcacu, cxa-
(:aac.ca .aaa cu.yaqua, nu c.ccu uu.c-
cca nc.cncaacrc nc(+uua.ca yaax:uc
acc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:c cxauu+:. lc-
.cncaauu c.aucau.ca c(aa xu uc rxaaucu (cc-
ucaucu, ac(y_cu) urycu yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa. lc a:acuu S. Sayc.a,
(ac uu.ccc: rccy(ac.aa, a cnc(cxcuuc
c:cxc, nu .c yxc(a. ua a.ccu nxau,
uc .a c(cx: cy_cc.acuuc yacxu+uaac. nu
oc |cc }cccnoo cx: nc.cncaacrc.
O.uccu.cx:uc nc(xccuucu S. Sayc-
.c c(cxu ^. B. lcxcac naaux:uc +ac.ux,
+.c cua aauc nccxuac.ca c u(cau +uac-
uu.cu c.a.:u ucacccrc uuucxcra
H. Kuc.u a lu.aucc yuaxc uuuc-
xcruu u +ax+ac. a ccc ccucauy :cx:
H. Kuc.u, c.caa ccc.cu. a .c, +.c a cc-
accuuc c_cc.ac nc.cncaauu, ncc(aa
rccy(ac.ay acc cacu ncxucc+ua c(ucu u+ c.c-
cu cuxu.a, a:+aauucrc ncc.ynxcuuc, ca
:x ncxucc.: a:.cxuy. cc cqcu:
6
.
Bcc ca+auucc a:ac nc+acxac. +ax+u.::
y+cu:c-ncqcccyaxuc.: (cxu: c y+c.c ua-
+ua+cuua yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a:ca-
+a.: cacu cy(cuua u nc(xccuua c.uccu-
.cx:uc .cxuuu u nuca ycccuua yrcxca-
ucrc ncqccca, c(cxaa .c c y+c.c +ayc-
ucu na.uu, (a: uau.u nucxc:c (xa
cccuuccu (cuc.au.cx:ucc.u aauau.: cac-
uua ncc.aaxcuucu +a(a+u.
6
Qu.. nc: lo:oeo . B. \a+ cc+. C. 48.
45
Icaxuu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu uayu (ccuc.uy. nu-
+uau c(ucu u+ cc ncxc, caa+auucu c uc+c.u a+xu+uc
uccxc(caauuu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua oc |cc |o|o, c-
.c:c cry. :.: a.yax:u:, uanuc, (xa cc+(auua uc(u-
qucuu:x .cxucxcruu y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, u uccxc-
(caauuu oc |cc }cccnoo ~ uaucxcc .a(uqucuu:x (xa cx:-
auuc.aa ac., ncccx:y ux c+yx:.a.c aaxac.ca nc(xccuuc
c yxy+acuuu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua. lccxc(uuc, c.-
aaa +acu cuc.cuc u uca qcx: crc ccacacuc.acaauuc,
(cxu: cucu.ucaa.:ca ua a(c cuc.c:, cnc(cxa_cc cc
.un u caa+u c ncucuuu:u xccu.au cuc.c: (uuc.u.y.a-
u, ucau), a .ac xccu.au c(y cccu.
H(cu:u xccu. yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu cuc.c:, .c, +.c
cc.: crc ax:a u ccra, nca:u u nccxc(uuu, ua+axc u cucq,
ca+yc. ucc.c:u accx., c.c: (c.cuuuyc.ca aca cu-
c.ca yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua. ,cc.a.c+uc +ac.c .c.
accx. caa+:aa. c ua+axau ccc.a+a.cx:ucrc uxu c+:cucrc
(cxc(c.acuucrc) .una ncqccca. M: c (xa auaxu+a ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauua a cy(c xc.cxu : ucncx:+caa.: nuu-
qun ucnccc(c.acuucc.u, c.c:u a a+cc.ac .ac-
acrc a:(cxac.ca a uayc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
J
. lc+
.crc nuuquna yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u +acu u
naacnucuu.cx:uaa na.ua nucc.ac. nu+ua-
u auauccrc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ~ acy(a.
O +ua+cuuu ua+axa ucnccc(c.acuucc.u ac
a:ca+axca A. U. Kcuu, nuac(auu a:ac(y c .c, +.c +ac-
uc(a.cx:c.ac nc( axuauuc accuu:x ccxcnxcuuu, cc., c-
uc+uc, c.c.yna.: ua+a( u ac+aa_a.:ca yc.acx: u c.uaau
y+c(cuua, uc ua ocnnoc noo:o naaccy(ua ~ rxacucc.:,
yc.ucc.:, ncnocc{cmecnnocmo u cacc(uy cqcuy (ca+a-
.cx:c.a ~ cuc cc:c+uc nccaruy.: uc cau.ca (+(cc: u (axcc
ycua uaa. ~ . d.)
2
. Hc a:+:aac. ccucuuu, +.c ucnccc(-
c.acuucc.: cc.: uuaauau. cuc.c: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa
. A. 3om:unuu
Ocuncrcxrcruouannc u cyc
dc lcgc [crcndo
heonup Aneucanppouun 3amnnnun,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
npenoaaaeru xaqepu xpnunnarncnxn
Yparucxon rocyapcaennon
pnnecxon axaeunn
zashnall.ur.ru
J
C.: uemuq B. B. luuqun ucnccc(c.acuucc.u a ccac.cc yrc-
xcauc ncqcccc. M., J949.
2
lonu A. 0. Haac.acuu:c ua+axa a yrcxcauc ncqcccc Cc.
cc+.: B 8 .. M., J967. 1. 4. C. J4.
46
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ucrux uc.cu+ccux ncuc(ca. B .c nc-
aaxac.ca caa cy.: cy(a: uc. ucnccc(c.acuuc-
c.u uccxc(caauua (ca+a.cx:c.a ~ uc. u cy(a
a .acacrc.
luuqun ucnccc(c.acuucc.u axc(u., .a-
u ca+c, a cuuc.u acxquu yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua. luuaa crc +a ucc-
xc(u:u (xa ncc.ccuua cuc.c: accx., yaa-
+:aaa c uu naauxa cryxucaauua acca.-
uaaccrc cy(cucrc (cuc.aua, ccau(c.cx:c.ac-
aauuc a cy(c oc |cc }cccnoo nc(c.aaxac.ca
cxc(y_uu .c+ucau.
lunc.c.u+ccu ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a cy-
(c ~ a+ucau(ucc.: cy(cucrc ccc.a, aa-
xa_aaca ucacxxcu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc-
rc +acua. B \lK ICUCI J96O rc(a uc-
: c cy(cuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuu uc
:xc. B .c c aca a ccac.ccu uayc yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca cy_cc.acaaxu .c+cuua, (u-
ccuquy_uc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc ua cxc(-
c.acuucc u aa+cucc (cuc.auc (ua nc(c.
axcrcx:ucrc, uac.u+cccrc cn:aucuua, uaxu-
+ua aux-xuc ncac(cuuu ua .cxc), ccy_c-
c.axaccc nc naauxa u a cc (auucu nc-
cccucuax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u. B caa+u c .u
ncaaxcuuc a +acuc uc: c.. 29O \lK IU
cau(c.cx:c.ayc. c a+au.uu (yxy+acuuu nc-
(:(y_crc +acua) uanaaxcuua, c+u.a_crc
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc ncqcccyax:u: (cuc.au-
c, cy.: c.ccrc :xa c+cau(ua u u+ rxaa: J5
\lK ICUCI J96O rc(a Occ. u ccau-
(c.cx:c.acaauuc ~ ucnccc(c.acuucc au+y-
ax:ucc accnua.uc cy.c.c ccau(c.cx:c.ac-
aauua .cxa +cxcaca.
H+ caaucuua uc c ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuu \lK ICUCI J96O rc(a u \lK IU,
c c(ucu c.ccu:, c c+cau(ucc.: cxc(yc. nc-
cc.acuucc.: ncqcccyax:ucu c: cxc(-
c.acuucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, nc(ycc.cu-
ucrc a \lK ICUCI J96O rc(a, a \lK
IU. C (yrcu c.ccu:, au(uc u a+au.uc
ncqcccyax:ucu c:: yacxu+cuc +ucxc cxy-
+aca ncu+ac(c.aa ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, (cny-
_cuc y+ac.uc a ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuu uu:x
cncquaxuc.ca ncuc aa+a, u+cucu ncqcc-
cyax:u:u cu y+ac.ua a ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuu ncua.:x, cy_cc.acuuc u+cucua uca,
caa+auuaa c .u+ccuu .ccaauuau a +ac-
.u c.craucaauua, au(cc- u uucc.cu, +.c
nc+acxac. ucucaa.: c_uu ncrccc a ac-
xquu uca.uaucrc cryxucaauua ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauua a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
Iaccc.cuuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a a-
+cc.ac au(a ccc.a a:aaxac. u rcuc.u+ccy
ncxcy. l. lccc c_c a cuqc XlX aca
ucncx:+caax .cuu ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc
uaaauc c .cuuc ccc., caa+:aaa crc
a c (ca.cx:ucc.: cy(cucrc cxc(caa.cxa,
.a u c (ca.cx:ucc.: aa+a
J
. lucuc a .c
c aca B. K. Cxy+cacuu ya+:aax, +.c
c(y ccc.c nc(c.ca u ccau(c.cx:c.ac-
aauuc xuq uc cc. :.: a+xu+uu ua ccuc-
ac c.c.ca
4
.
B ccac.ccu uayc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
ac+uuxu .c+cuua, (uc.auquy_uc ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauua u ccc.: (yr c. (yra. 1a,
H. X. Macy.ca, uanuc, uac.auaax ua .c,
+.c ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc uc aaxac.ca a+uc-
au(ucc.: ccc.a, a B. l. Kcxaca, uacc-
c., acca.uaax ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a
a+ucau(ucc.: ccc.a
5
. O+cau(uc, +.c a:-
c c(ucrc u+ nuac(cuu:x nc(xc(ca nc(c-
aac. cy(cuua c ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuu a cy(c
oc |cc }cccnoo.
lunc.c+a c cxccc.u ccc.ca u ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauuu a cy(c a a+cc.ac caccrc cc-
cucaauua cc. uc.: cxccc.: ncqcccyax:-
ucu cy.u .ux cy(cu:x (cuc.auu. 1aaa .c+-
a +cuua ncxy+uxa cy_cc.acuucc acncc.-
aucuuc a c.c+cc.acuucu uayc.
1a, M. C. C.crcau+ c_c a J946 rc(y
c.c+ax, +.c ncqcccyax:u:u nca(c nc-
u+ac(c.aa ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua .c(cc.ac-
ucu c nca(c ncu+ac(c.aa ccc.a
6
.
J
C.: locc l. Iycac(c.ac (xa cy(cu:x cxc(c-
aa.cxcu a cuc.ca uuuaxuc.uu. M., 2OO2.
C. J94.
4
C.: C:cecuu B. l. \+cuu ycccrc yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca. Cl., J895. C. J89.
5
C.: Mocmoe H. X. Occ. cc.a ncucac-
c.aua. ^., J965. C. 4; lo:+ooe B. H. Cxc(-
c.acuu:u ccc.. M., J969. C. J2J.
6
C.: Cmo:oeu M. C. \rcxcau:u ncqccc.
M., J946. C. 245.
47
1c(cc.acuucc.: nca(a, c.aaa ccuca-
ucu c.c( ncu+ac(c.aa cy(cucrc (cuc.aua,
ya+:aac. u ua c_y cy.: ncqcccyax:uc-
rc (cuc.aua, cxccc.: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucu c:. Cy.: xcrc cy(cucrc (cu-
c.aua caa+:aac.ca c crc ncuuauuc a
uuc.ycu.a caxu+aquu naacacu a.uauc-
c.u uccu.cxa ncqcccyax:ucu yuquu, a (au-
uc cxy+ac ~ cy(a u c.ccu.
A.yax:u: a caa+u c .u c+yx:.a.:
uay+ucrc uccxc(caauua K. l. 1cuua, nu-
ac(acrc a:ac(y, +.c ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc
u ccc. uc. c_uc +c.: no ceocu nuo-
{c, ua+ua+cuu u ucc.c: cnocoo+ ocqc-
cme:cnu+
7
. B .c c:cxc ucccx:c naa-
(ccax:ua cu.yaqua, cr(a (xa a:aaxcuua cxc-
(ca ua c(c(c (uxu aux-xuc nu+uaca)
nc(ua+ua+ac.ca cy(cu:u ccc., a (xa a:-
aaxcuua cxc(ca ua .cxc +cxcaca (uxu aux-
xuc +ua+u:x (xa cy(a nu+uaca) ~ ccau-
(c.cx:c.acaauuc. B uc(uqucuucu (ca.cx:-
ucc.u (auu:c (cuc.aua au(a.ca caa+auu:u.
Mcuc nc .cu nu+uuc ccrxacu.:ca c a:ac-
(au c .c, +.c a (auuc cxy+ac c(ua +a(a+a
caac.ca (aya a+xu+u:u ncqcccyax:u:-
u (cuc.auau
8
.
\ncauy.aa ccaccuuaa nc+uqua uc :xa
+y(a u uayc ccac.ccrc ncuc(a, (ac nc(-
c.aaxaccu ucau \lK ICUCI J92J rc(a.
1a, M. M. B:(a a J955 rc(y ya+:aax, +.c
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc ua:x xuq, a naau-
xc, nc(c.aaxac. cccu oc+om ecqccmecn-
nox c:c{oe ncc.ynxcuua, uc_uxca ua +c-
xcac+ccc .cxc, ncu+ac(cuu:u cnc.cu.-
u:u xuqau c y+ac.uc uxu c+ y+ac.ua cxc-
(caa.cxa u cy(cu
9
. 1aaa c +a(a+a (a :
ya+axu a:ac) caxu+yc.ca nu ccc.c c(c-
(:, +.c nc(a+ycaac. u ccana(cuuc cy.u.
Oc_cuuc cy(cucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uua u ccc.a caa+auc c c(uu: c.c(c, ca-
xu+yc: nu ncu+ac(c.ac ccux (cuc.auu.
Hucu c.c( ncac(cuua cy(cucrc ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauua, c.xu+u:u c. c.c(a cy(cucrc
ccc.a, nucucu :.: uc cc.. Hccxc(c-
aa.cxu .cu ncxc: c(uuc(yauc ya+:aa-
., +.c a ncac(cuuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua,
.a u ncac(cuuc ccc.a ccy_cc.axac.ca
c nccxa(auuc ucnccc(c.acuucrc +u.cx:-
ucrc (+yac.acuucrc) accnua.ua
JO
. B caa+u
c .u cuc nc(ncxara.:, +.c ccucaauuc
a:(cxcuua u+ cy(cu:x ccc.ca cy(cuc-
rc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua aaxac.ca .cx:c ccc-
cuucc.: c.c.a ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, ac-
a: a:c.ynac. .cxc +cxcaca.
lc (auucu nu+uuc (uccuquaqua nc-
qcccyax:ucu c: c.c.uaua. Ka c.c+a-
c.ca a nccxc(uux uccxc(caauuax, uccxc(u-
cc.: +a_u.: raau.ucaauucrc Kcuc.u.yqu-
cu naaa a(crc ra(auuua ua xu+uy uc-
nuccucacuucc.: u nccxyuxa nu+uucu a:-
(cxcuua ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a cacc.ca.cx:-
ucc ncqcccyax:ucc (cuc.auc
JJ
. H+ .crc c-
uc a:ac(u.:, +.c ncqc(ya ccau(c.cx:c.ac-
aauua a cy(c c.xu+ac.ca c. cy(cu:x ccc.-
ca ccccuucc.au ncac(cuua ncqcccyax:-
u:x (cuc.auu, c.c.c c.c:x aaxac.ca .cxc
+cxcaca.
luac(cuucc c.xu+uc a:(cxac.ca u a ru-
nc.c+c uc: +. J c.. 29O \lK IU, yc.a-
uaaxuaa_cu, +.c a xc(c cy(cucrc cxc(c.aua
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc cc. :.: ncu+ac(c-
uc a cxy+aax, nc(ycc.cuu:x +. J c.. J79
\lK IU, a .c ~ uccxc(ucc.: cuay-
cuua ccc:x nuc., cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua,
.cxccu:x ncac(cuuu uxu uccxc(ucc.:
a:aaxcuua ccc.cauua cn:aucuua, uu:x cacuc.a
u nu+uaca. O.c+ac:c a runc.c+c c.c:-
xc+ucu uc: ycxcaua ncu+ac(c.aa cy(c-
ucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua uaxa(:aa.ca
7
7oun K. l. 1ccua u na.ua ccau(c.cx:-
c.acaauua. Cl., 2OO4. C. 49.
8
C.: 1a c. C. JJ.
9
Bo{+ M. M. Bc_cc.acuu:c (ca+a.cx:c.aa
a ccac.cc yrcxcauc ncqcccc. M., J955. C. 79.
JO
C.: 7oun K. l. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc: yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc u uuuaxuc.u+cccc uc-
cxc(caauuc. M., 2OOJ. C. JJ, JJ; Homonoeo A. l.
Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.ac Icccuu: ncqcccyax:u:u acnc.: ,uc. ... au(.
u(. uay. Ucxauuc, 2OO7. C. 2J.
JJ
Cc:c{uno H. A. Cy(cucc cxc(c.auc a cc-
cuucc yrcxcauc ncqcccc: ,uc. ... au(. u(.
uay. la.cuuyr, 2OO5. C. J96.
. A. dom:+nun. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a cy(c oc |cc }cccnoo
48
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ua au(: ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, nc(ycc.cuu:c
(ucnc+uquau +ac.cu J u 2 c.. 29O \lK IU:
J) cy(cucc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc c+ cuac-
uua xuqa; 2) cy(cucc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc
c cuacuuc xuqa, ncac(ucc a cac c+c-
c(:: a) a c.(cx:uc ncc_cuuu aa+c; ) a c.-
(cx:uc ncc_cuuu uu: cncquaxuc.c.
Ccac_cuuc uca.uau:x naaux nc(nc-
xarac., +.c ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc c cuacuu-
c xuqa ac+cuc xua: a qcxax a:aaxcuua
cxc(ca u nuc. ua .cxc +cxcaca, ncccx:y
ucuuc c uux cc. ccc_u.: cy(y aa+ uxu
cncquaxuc., ccy_cc.auaauu ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuc. lu ncac(cuuu c ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uua cy(c c+ cuacuua xuqa oc |cc |o|o
ac+cuc cuaycuuc ccc:x nuc., cxc-
(ca ncc.ynxcuua, .cxccu:x ncac(cuuu uxu
a:aaxcuuc ccc.cauua cn:aucuua, a .ac uu:x
cacuc.a u nu+uaca.
Mcuc nc(ncxara.:, +.c uc: c.. 29O
\lK IU, aaxaac: ucacxxcu yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:ucrc naaa, nca.ca. acxqu uc
c cxc(c.acuuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuu, ncccx:y
ux ncaaxcuuc a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +a-
cuc u+ua+ax:uc ncacqucaaxc (ucyccuu
c ccc.ucacuuu ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua cxc(caa-
.cxc u aa+c, ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua cxc(c-
aa.cxc (cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua) u c(uquu-
ccrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua aa+c (aa+c-
ucrc (cuc.aua), ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua u
cy(cuc-c(uquuccu cnc.u+:
J2
. M: nc-
xarac, +.c naauxa ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a cy(c,
caa+auu:c c ucnccc(c.acuu: uccxc(caauu-
c cy(c u c.ccuau (ca+a.cx:c.a nc (cxy
(+. J c.. 24O \lK IU), c.aac: ccc-
.ac a nc.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua (+. J
c.. 245, c.. 259 \lK IU), ucccx:c nc.u-
acc+a. a:auucy accx.y, ya+:aaa ua-
naaxcuua yxy+acuua (cuc.ay_crc yrcxca-
uc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua.
lc(c accrc, au(u.ca ucnaaux:u: nc-
ac(cuuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua (ucnccc(c.acu-
ucrc au+yax:ucrc accnua.ua) uc cy(c, a uu:
xuqc. Ccc.acuuc uccxc(ucc.: cuacuua
a .c cxy+ac uc aaxac.ca c+ycxcau: ncac-
(c (xa +acu: cy(a ua aa+a uxu uucrc cnc-
quaxuc.a. luc+a.cx:uc, +.c +. J c.. 29O
\lK IU uc c.c:xac. uac nca(y ncu+-
ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua,
nu c.cc a ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuu xuqa (y-
rcrc ncxa, ccncac(accrc cuacuuc, cxc-
(caa.cx: uc nucy.c.ayc. u ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuc ncu+ac(u.ca aa+c. O(uac (ac ccxu
: u(u+ccaa .cxuua nc+acxaxa nac
acncc.aua.: uc: +ac.cu J u 4 c.. J79
\lK IU ua nca(c ncu+ac(c.aa cy(c-
ucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, arycu.aqua .crc
ac.ca cxacu.
,axcc, nc(c.aaxac.ca nc.uacc+a_u a:-
auucy accx.y .c, +.c c+yx:.a.: .acrc
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua uc cry. :.: ucnccc(-
c.acuuc ncaccu: cy(c, +.c crauu+uaac. crc
cnc.cuqu, yc.aucaxcuuy ucau c.a.cu
87, 24O \lK IU. lcxu c c+yx:.a.: cxc(-
c.acuucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua .ac ncxy+c-
u: uc cxc(caa.cxc, a aa+c (uu: cncquaxu-
c.c), .c cy( u uu:c y+ac.uuu yrcxcaucrc nc-
u+ac(c.aa, yncxucc+cuu:c ua ccuauuc,
ncacy u cqcuy (ca+a.cx:c.a, ca+:aa.ca
auc yrcxcaucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, a .c uayaac.
uca.uaucc .ccaauuc c .c, +.c ecc (ca+a-
.cx:c.aa nc(xca. ucnccc(c.acuucy uccxc(c-
aauu (+. J c.. 24O \lK IU). Hcx+cuua
u+ .crc naauxa uc..
uac uccuc.cucc.u cy(cucrc ccau-
(c.cx:c.acaauua, ncu+ac(ucrc aa+c (uu:
cncquaxuc.c), aaxac.ca .ac .c, +.c c+yx:-
.a.: cy(cucrc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, ccnc-
ac(accrc cuacuuc, ucuy.ca a a.c
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, c.c:u ccc.aaxac.ca u
nc(nuc:aac.ca aa+c uxu uu: cncquaxuc-
.c. B .c cxy+ac uc ccx(ac.ca .ccaa-
uuc c o+.omc:ono+ ya+auuu ucuuc a nc-
.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua c+yx:.a.ca nc-
u+ac(cuu:x a cy(cuc +acc(auuu ccc.ca u
(yrux (cuc.auu nc uccxc(caauu (ca+a-
.cx:c.a (n. J2 +. J c.. 259 \lK IU), +.c
aaxac.ca ca+auucc.: ccc.aa cy(cuc-
rc +acc(auua (+. J c.. 254 \lK IU).
lu cuc.cuc nc(xc(c cxc(yc. nu+ua.:,
J2
C., uan.: 7oun K. l. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuc: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc u uuuaxuc.u-
+cccc uccxc(caauuc. C. 57.
49
+.c xccu.: acca.uaaccu cuc.c: a
(auuc cxy+ac ca+:aa.ca uccaa+auu:u.
,cuc.ay_cc naauxc +. 2 c.. 29O \lK IU,
.au ca+c, a:ac(u. cy(cucc ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauuc, ncu+ac(ucc aa+c (uu:
cncquaxuc.c) a c.(cx:uc ncc_cuuu (+a
c.cuau +axa cy(cucrc +acc(auua) u+ +ucxa
cy(cu:x (cuc.auu. Acccqua.uauc uc_cc-
ca cryxucaauuc uancuuac. ncu+ac(c.ac -
cnc.u+:, (xa c.ccu xaa.cu: ccc:c
cy.c.: (uc cy(, uc c.ccu:), ccc:c c:
ucaquu (uc nc.ccx: cy(cu:x (cuc.auu),
cccaa naaca.uaucc.:.
O:+ucc cccucaauuc nuaxc+cuua aa+a
ncu+ac(c.ay ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua caa+:-
aa. c cc+(auuc cxcc cc.ucu cc.a-
ucau (xa ccau(c.cx:c.ayccrc nu ncac(c-
uuu (auucrc (cuc.aua. O(uac, ncccx:y +a-
cuc(a.cx: uc crcaauaac. ac+cucc.: nc-
ac(cuua ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua aa+c uucrc
ncxa, +c ccau(c.cx:c.ayc:u (nu .c uc
ac aa+cuc auuc.c, uc a xc+cuc y+c-
(cuuu), nc(ncxarac.ca, +.c aa+ uxu uucu cnc-
quaxuc. ncc.c cxa(ac. cxcc ccacacuucu
nccccucuax:ucu .ucu u a cuxy ucuuc
.crc nucc.ac. cnccc(y_y yuqu
c(y a.c u cy(c. S.c, c(uac, ya+:aac.
ua ucc.cy nc(yc.aucaxcuuy cuxy ac+uu-
a_ux (ca+a.cx:c.a, uayaa_y nuuqu-
n: yrcxcaucrc ncqccca (c.. J7 \lK IU).
lu .c ncxarac, +.c nuuy(u.cx:ucc cy-
(cucc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a nuuqunc ucac+-
cuc (+. 2 c.. 9 \lK IU, +. J c.. 2J
Kcuc.u.yquu IU). B .c c aca, .cxcaa-
uuc c.. 2 Kcuc.u.yquu IU nc+acxac. ncuu-
a.: c.cncu: uccuacuua, nc+acxa_y nc-
u+ac(c.ac ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua, cnc(cxa.:
cau ccau(c.cx:c.ayc:. Hc ucx+ac, +.c
ycc.cuuc ccau(c.cx:c.ayccrc cc. :.:
ccucau: ycxcauc (xa ncu+ac(c.aa ccau-
(c.cx:c.acaauua. B .c cxy+ac cuc.ca cc-
rxaccaauucrc ycc.cuua ccau(c.cx:c.aycc-
rc, cy(a u c.ccu crxa : nuac(u.: ccau-
(c.cx:c.caauu (c xccu.au cuacuua)
naaca.uau:u cy.c.au .crc cy(cucrc
(cuc.aua. O.+ac.u ucuuc .a (c y+c.c acxu
ccau(c.cx:c.ayccrc) a+caaxca .c. acncc
a ncuc( (cuc.aua c.. J45 \c.aaa yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa J864 rc(a
JJ
.
Ka nucax ^. l. Bxa(uuca, ccc.,
ncu+ac(cuu:u cy(c, caa_u (cxc, (ac.
+yac.acuuy c+cau(ucc.:, nc n+{oqc+
e {ocmoeccnuu aux-xuc c_c (yrux
xuq
J4
. lc(xaraccc c ccaccuu: +ac-
uc(a.cxc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc ucx+ac.
+yac.acuuy c+cau(ucc.: (ucnccc(c.acuucc.:
uccxc(caauua), a ucuccxc(caauuc (ca+a.cx:c.a
c.ccuau crauu+uaac. ux a ucncx:+caauuu
crc c+yx:.a.ca a ncuuax, uc nc(ncxarac.
ucncx:+caauua u a nurcacc.
B:ca+:aac:c u(cu (ucyccucuu:. O(-
uac ca_ac auuauuc ua .c, +.c (nc uc-
uu K. l. 1cuua, ccucaauucy ua uccxc(c-
aauuu na.uu) ccrc(ua ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuc uc uaxc(u. auccrc nucucuua
J5
. S.c
nc(.ac(ac.ca u uaau xu+u: nccccuc-
uax:u: cn:.c. B .c c aca ucx+cuuc
ucacu:x uca.uau:x naaux, naaux, c.c:c
ncacquy. cxxu+uu c(y .ucu cy(:u u
.ucu nc(c.aau.cxcu c.ccu, .ucu ncu+-
ac(c.aa cy(cu:x (cuc.auu u uu.cnc.aqucu
uaac.acuu:x ncxc a (ucnc+uquu cy_c-
c.ay_cu uc:, crxc : a.uau+ucaa.:
nucucuuc ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a cy(cucu
na.uc.
luc+a.cx:uc, +.c ccaccuu:u +acuc-
(a.cx: nu uca.uauc cryxucaauuu nc-
ac(cuua cnc.u+ a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac
uc ucx+ac. y+ac.ua a (cuc.auax, caa+auu:x
c cuacuuc nc(cnc.ucrc (uanuc, nu
ncu+ac(c.ac cy(cuc-c(uquucux, cy(cuc-
ncuxua.u+ccux cnc.u+) a nucy.c.auu
cxc(caa.cxa nc.uacncxcucrc ncxa (c.. J97
\lK IU).
O(ucaccuuc au(u.ca uccxc(u: uucc
a+cacuuc +acuc(a.cxc +a(a+ yc.aucaxcuua
a+xu+u:x u+u+ccux ccc.cauuu nccc(c.ac
JJ
C.: Ho.nomce C. B. Sxccu.au:u y+cuu
ycccrc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. M., J9JJ. C. 225.
J4
B:o{u+uoe . E. \+cuuc c yrcxcau:x (c-
a+a.cx:c.aax. 1yxa, 2OOO. C. 229.
J5
7oun K. l. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucc u uuuaxuc.u+cccc uccxc(c-
aauuc. C. J.
. A. dom:+nun. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a cy(c oc |cc }cccnoo
5O
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ncac(cuua ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua
J6
. lcccx:-
y cnc(cxcuuc ccc.cauuu uc caa+:aac.ca c uc-
nccc(c.acuu: au+yax:u: uax(cuuc
c.c.a (ccc.c .cxa +cxcaca), nc(cucc
uc ccc.ac.c.ayc. ncqcccyax:ucu cy.u ccau-
(c.cx:c.acaauua (ccc.a), aaxaac:, cccc
accrc, +a(a+cu cnc.ucrc uccxc(caauua. Hc
.c ~ (yrcc uanaaxcuuc ccacacuc.acaa-
uua yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acua.
luac(cuu:c (ucyccucuu:c ncxccuua
ay.ca ua caa+auu:u c cy_cc.ay_uu
a .ccuu yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ncua.uau cc-
au(c.cx:c.acaauua. lu .c a:(cxa.ca .u
u(cuu:x uanaaxcuua, nc(c.aaxa_uc a+xu+-
u:c aauau.: cnc(cxcuua ncua.ua ccau(c-
.cx:c.acaauuc.
lcacc uanaaxcuuc caa+:aac.ca c cnc-
(cxcuuc ncua.ua ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc nc-
cc(c.ac ucncx:+caauua a a+cc.ac c(a nc-
ua.ua cxc(c.acuu:c (cuc.aua. 1a, uanu-
c, ncc.ynac. K. l. 1cuu, nc(xaraa c-
yxucay cnc(cxcuua ncua.ua ccau(c.cx:-
c.acaauuc a cxc(c.acuucc (cuc.auc, nc-
ac(ucc ua ccucac ca+a.cx:ucrc (xa ccau(c-
.cx:c.ayccrc xuqa ncc.aucaxcuua cxc(caa-
.cxa u cau uxu nc crc ncy+cuu aa+c,
a qcxax cuaycuua cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua,
ccc:x nuc., c.xu+u.cx:u:x nu+uaca, ccxu
(xa ux yc.aucaxcuua uc .cyc.ca ncac(cuua
cnc.u+:
J7
. ,auuaa (cuuuqua, cnua_a-
aca ua uc: \lK ICUCI J96O rc(a, nc(-
ncxarac. a a+cc.ac cy.c.a (auucrc (cuc.aua
cxc(caa.cxa, .c ca: ucx+aa cc nucuc-
uuc c.uccu.cx:uc cy(cucrc cxc(c.aua.
Bc a.cc uanaaxcuuu uccxc(ucc nc-
ua.uc cnc(cxac.ca a co+ocmo+mc:onoc
noqccco:onoc {cucmeuc, ncac(ucc ua cc-
ucac ca+a.cx:ucrc (xa ccau(c.cx:c.ayccrc
xuqa ncc.aucaxcuua cxc(caa.cxa uxu cnc(c-
xcuua c{o a qcxax cuaycuua ccc:x nu-
c., cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua, .cxccu:x ncac(c-
uuu, a:aaxcuua ccc.cauua cn:aucuua uxu uu:x
cacuc.a u nu+uaca, uc_ux +ua+cuuc (xa
yrcxcaucrc (cxa, ccxu (xa .crc uc .cyc.ca
ncu+ac(c.aa cy(cucu cnc.u+:
J8
. B (au-
uc cxy+ac ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc acca.u-
aac.ca a ncqcccyax:ucc (cuc.auc, +.c aa-
uc (xa ncuuauua cy.u xcrc cy(cucrc (cu-
c.aua, uc uc ncaaxac. ncqcccyax:uy cy_-
ucc.: ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua.
1c.:c uanaaxcuuc nc(c.aaxac. ucc.c-
cc ccacuuc nca:x (ayx, ncccx:y ucncx:-
+yc. a a+cc.ac c(cacrc nu+uaa ncua.uc
cy(cuc-cxc(c.acuucc (cuc.auc.
Haucxcc nccnc.uau: u+ nuac(cuu:x
uanaaxcuuu au(u.ca a.ccc, c.ccc (cnyc-
ac. cucaauuc cuc.c: ccnc(+uucuu:x
ncua.uu ncqcccyax:ucc (cuc.auc (c(cacc
ncua.uc) ccc. (au(cacc ncua.uc)
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc a cy(c (cyau(cacc nc-
ua.uc).
B u.crc cuc ncxara.:, +.c ynca(c+c-
uuc .ccuu (a:c.auaauuc cuc.c: ccnc(+u-
ucuu:x ncua.uu) nc+acxu. (cu.:ca yxy+ac-
uua a uca.uauc cryxucaauuu ccau(c.cx:-
c.acaauua a cy(c, cccucaaa .c yxy+acuuc
ucnccc(c.acuu: au+yax:u: uccxc(caauu-
c .cxa +cxcaca y+ac.uuau yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca (cy(c u c.ccuau), nccucca ucccc.-
ac.c.ay_uc caxu+yccy c.c(y u accx.y
(cuc.aua a nc(xc(a_uc (xa .crc c.a.:u \lK
IU, uxu a:uy(u. c.a+a.:ca c. ucc.c:x
a+ucau(ucc.cu ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a cy(c
(caa+auucrc c cuacuuc, c c.a+c xuqa c.
cuacuua (xa ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua).
,ucyccucuu:u xaa.c a:ca+auucu .c+-
u +cuua nc(ncxarac. uccxc(ucc.: a+a-
c.u (xa ccncac(cuua ucc.c:x ncqc-
(y (uanuc, ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua a cy(c
c cuacuuc) (cncxuu.cx:u:x ncqcccyax:-
u:x naa u raau.uu ccau(c.cx:c.ayccy.
J8
7oun K. l. 1ccua u na.ua ccau(c.cx:-
c.acaauua. C. 59.
J6
C.: An{uonoeo K. C. O ccacacuc.acaauuu
naacacu crxacu.aquu ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua nc
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucy +acuc(a.cx:c.ay
laacac(cuuc. J986. ` J. C. 9496.
J7
7oun K. l. Ocau(c.cx:c.acaauuc: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucc u uuuaxuc.u+cccc uccxc(c-
aauuc. C. J7.
5J
lcua.uc, +.c +acuc.ac+cc.ac nc(c.aaxac. cccu cxcu:u,
(xu.cx:u:u, c+cu: +a.a.u:u ncqccc. Hc ccc acc.: c(c-
ax:u:x +acuca auccxu a (cuc.ay_uu \lK IU .acc cxu-
+cc.ac cc.ua, +.c cu c.ax cy_cc.acuuc c.xu+a.:ca c. nc(-
nucauucrc B. B. ly.uu: J8 (caa 2OOJ rc(a. Hcu+cucc
nc(cxcuuc ccquu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acuc(a-
.cx:c.aa nuac(c. a cuc+uc u.crc uccxc(ucc.u cc+(auua
ucacrc \lK IU.
lc+acxu ccc a:ca+a.: ucc.c:c cy(cuua c ac+c-
ucu c.y.yc .acrc +acuc(a.cx:ucrc a.a u crc ccucau:
cuqcn.yax:u: ncxccuua.
B \lK IU ua(xcu. +c.c a+rauu+u.: crc O_y u
Occcuuy +ac.u.
O_aa +ac.: (cxua cccc(c.c+u.: a ccc yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:u:c uc::
a) c (cuc.ay_c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:-
c.ac u crc (cuc.auu a ncc.auc.ac u accuu, a .ac a c.uc-
acuuu yra xuq;
) c ua+ua+cuuu cccuuccrc yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca u +a(a+ax yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:-
ucc.u;
a) c nuuqunax, ua c.c:x (cxua ccuca:-
aa.:ca aca yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa (ca.cx:ucc.:;
r) c ncxucc+uax cy.c.ca yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, a .ac c ncqcccyax:u:x
naaax u ca+auucc.ax y+ac.ay_ux a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u xuq;
() c qcxu u nc(c.c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc (ca+:aauua
u ucncx:+yc:x (xa ux yc.aucaxcuua cc(c.aax (ca+:aauua;
c) c c.y.yc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc (ca+:aauua, cc-
(cauuu crc c.(cx:u:x xccu.ca.
H+ u+xccuucrc uc.y(uc au(c.:, +.c c+: u(c. c ncxccuu-
ax, cc(ca_uxca a rxaaax J2, 5JJ (cuc.ay_crc \lK IU.
lu .c u+ \lK IU uccxc(uc ucx+u.: c.a.:, nccaa-
_cuuy a+.acucuu ccucau:x ncua.uu, ucncx:+yc:x a .ac
+acuc(a.cx:uc a.c (c.. 5 \lK IU) ~ (xa .crc cy_c-
c.ay. cncquax:u:c u(u+ccuc cxcaau.
U.c acac.ca rxaa, nccaa_cuu:x naacacy cryxucaauu
yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua, a .ac ccucaauua (xa c.a+a a ac+-
y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa, nca_cuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa u
3unyp 3unavynnouun 3unavynnun,
oxop pnnecxnx nayx, npoqeccop,
aaaeyunn xaqepon yroroanoro npoecca
Yuypcxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
1avunna Buvanuuouna mymanoua,
acnnpan xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
Yuypcxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
3. 3. 3uuomy::uu, 1. B. 1ymouoeo
Dc lcgc [crcndo no VHK P0
52
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua (rxaa: J u 4 \lK
IU), a .ac a+(cxca l\\l \lK IU
(Mc: ncqcccyax:ucrc nuuy(cuua;
Xc(a.auc.aa u axc:; Hu:c ncxcc-
uua), .c a cuxy ux caa+auucc.u c acnccau,
crxacu.uy_uu .c uxu uu:c c.ccu:
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a, cuu
(cxu: ncxy+u.: cacc cc.c a Occcuucu
+ac.u \lK IU.
Occcuuaa +ac.: \lK IU u (cxua
:.: ncc.ccua c y+c.c (uccuquaquu
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a.
lcay rxaay cxc(yc. nccaa.u.: naacac-
y cryxucaauu cnc(cxcuua yrcxcaucrc nc-
cxc(caauua, crc au(ca c y+c.c a nc(c.a
cauucuua, .a u ncqcccyax:ucrc c.a.yca
cy.c.ca ccy_cc.axcuua. Ocucay +(cc: (cx-
u: ccc.aau.: +acnxcuu:c a c.a.:ax 2O
2J \lK IU ncxccuua.
B .cu c rxaac uccxc(uc cnc(cxu.:-
ca c au(au ac+cu:x yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a. B ccucay ux xaccuu-
aquu ua(xcu. ncxcu.: acncc c .c, ucc-
xc(uc uxu uc. yc.auaaxuaa.: nc accxc(yc-
cy u a+caaccy yrcxcaucy (cxy auuca-
ucc.: cauuaccrc a uuuuuucaauuc nc-
c.ynxcuuu.
,axcc (cxcu cxc(caa.: a+(cx, nccaa-
_cuu:u naacacy cryxucaauu c:+ucrc
(c(uuaucrc) nca(a ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrc-
xcau: (cxa a (ccy(cu:x u cy(cu:x c.a-
(uax. C(a acu(y. c y+c.c ccc.ac.c.ay-
_ux cc.ucac cc(ca_ucca ccrc(ua a
rxaaax J9J9, 42, 45, 4849 \lK IU ncxc-
cuua. Hau uc c.aau.ca +a(a+a cc_cuua
u cqcuu .cx ucrc+ucxcuu:x u+cucuuu u
(cncxucuuu, +.c nc(xarac.ca aucc.u a a-
(cc u+ ncxy+uaaux cacc +acuc(a.cx:ucc +a-
cnxcuuc c.a(uu yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. Cy_c-
c.acaauuc ux nc(c.aaxac.ca a ccucac caccu
cnaa(auu:. B:+:aac. acncc xua: ucc-
xc(ucc.: a ncu+ac(c.ac a cy(ax ua(+cucu
uuc.auquu (rxaaa 48 \lK IU).
O.(cx:u:c a+(cx: (cxu: :.: nccaa-
_cu: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: ncu+ac(c.aa,
ccy_cc.axac: a ync_cuuc u ycxcucu-
uc nca(c.
lxaaa c ync_cuu:x yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:x ncu+ac(c.aax (cxua ax+u.: a cca
ncxccuua, cc(ca_ucca a rxaaax 4O (Occ-
:u nca(c nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu
ccrxacuu cauuaccrc c nc(.aaxcuu: cy
cauucuuc), 4O
J
(Occ:u nca(c nuua-
.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu (c-
cy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac) u
4J (lcu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcau: (cxa, nc(-
cy(u: ucacy cy(:c) (cuc.ay_crc \lK
IU, a .ac uc: rxaa 4J u 44 \lK IU
a +ac.u naacacrc cryxucaauua ancxxaqu-
cuucrc nca(a ncccc.a nurcacca nc yrc-
xcau: (cxa, ncc.aucaxcuu:x uca:u cy-
(:au.
lxaaa c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+-
ac(c.aax c (cncxuu.cx:u:u (xa cauuacc-
rc ncqcccyax:u:u raau.uau (ycxcucu-
u:c ncu+ac(c.aa) (cxua ax+a.: ncxc-
cuua rxaa 5O (lcu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxca-
u: (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuucxc.uux)
u 52 (Occcuucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxca-
u: (cxa a c.ucacuuu c.(cx:u:x a.crcuu
xuq) \lK IU.
,axcc uccxc(uc a:(cxu.: a+(cx, nc-
caa_cuu:u yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: nc-
u+ac(c.aa, uc caa+auu: c yc.aucaxcuuc
auucaucc.u cauuaccrc a ccacacuuu nc-
c.ynxcuua. Ic+: u(c. c cu.yaquax, caa+au-
u:x:
a) c ac+cu: ucnaaccu: ncac(c-
uuc nc(c+caac:x uxu cauuac:x ac ac-
a ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcaucy (cxy (rxaa:
J2J4 \lK IU);
) c ucncxucuuc ac.ynuaaux a +acuuy
cuxy nurcacca u uu:x cy(cu:x cacuuu
(rxaa: 4647 \lK IU);
a) c cauxu.aqucu uc+acuuc u ucccc-
ucaauuc nc(acruy.:x yrcxcaucy nccxc(c-
aauu xuq (rxaaa J8 \lK IU);
r) c cuc.a.aqucu uaxu+ua y ccacauaac-
rc ncc.ynxcuuc xuqa cxc+uu, a:+:aa_cu
uccxc(ucc.: nucucuua ucy nuuy(u-
.cx:ucu c: c(uquuccrc xaa.ca (rxaaa
5J \lK IU);
() c a+cacuuc xc(a.auc.a u axc (rxa-
a: J5J6 \lK IU);
5J
c) c uc+ucxcuuc ncqcccyax:u:x ccca,
uc+ucxcuuc u a+:cauuc ncqcccyax:u:x
u+(cc (rxaaa J7 \lK IU).
\lK IU (cxcu +aacaa.:ca a+(cxc,
nccaa_cuu: naacacy cryxucaauu acn-
ccca c(yuac(ucrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa a ccc
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa (rxaa: 5J55
\lK IU).
U.c acac.ca c.(cx:u:x cuqcn.yax:u:x
ncxccuuu \lK IU, crxacu.uy_ux
(ccy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcau: (c-
xa, .c cc.: uccxc(ucc.: ya+a.: ua cxc(y-
_cc.
Bc-nca:x, uc (cxc +acuc(a.cxa urucu-
caa.: ccucaucc nc(ua+ua+cuuc accu naac-
cxauu.cx:ucu cuc.c: rccy(ac.aa, ccc.ca_cc
a c:c c naacuayacuuau, a .c +ucxc u
c ncc.ynucc.:. lcu+ac(ucc.: uccxc(uc-
c.u +a_u.: naa, uu.cccca u cacc( xu+ucc.u
c. a.a ccacacuua ncc.ynxcuua acc c+c-
au(ua. ly(y. ac:aa.:ca ncc.ynxcuua u
u+cxu+a.:ca auucau:c ~ y(c. u cccnc+u-
aa.:ca +a_u.a .aux ccquax:u:x qcuucc.cu
xu+ucc.u. lucc +(cc: aaxac.ca +acuc(a-
.cx:ucc +acnxcuuc +a(a+ yrcxcaucrc ncqcc-
ca a c.. 7 \lK Iccnyxuu lcxayc:.
Bc-a.c:x, cuc.ca yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
u:x nuuqunca (cxua ccc.ac.c.acaa.: cy-
_cc.ay_cu nyxu+uc-ccc.a+a.cx:ucu (cc-
aauucu) cc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. B cuxy
c(uux xua: nc(nucauuu c.. 2 Kcuc.u.yquu
IU a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac uc cry. nc-
aaxucaa.: (ucnc+u.uau:c ua+axa. lcxu acc
c.(a.: .cx:c ua ycc.cuuc ra(au u
ycac(u.cxcu cc+ccux c.y.y, .c .c
y(c. uu +.c uucc a cua.uc rccy(ac.ac cc
cacux nxc+ cuc.u.yqucuucu ca+auucc.u nc
+a_u.c naa u cacc( cacux ra(au, (a u ua-
(cucc.u a naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauax nc-
c.c uc c.auc.. Hc (yac, +.c rccy(ac.ay c.
.crc y(c. xcr+c, a nca(a a c.auc ~ cx:-
ac. Hanc.ua. lc auucu cc, a Icccuu
a cuxy cu.axu.c.a cc ra(au xacc y(c. ccc-
nc+cu.
Occucaauu:c nc(xccuua c accc.auca-
xcuuu a +ucxc nuuqunca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
nyxu+ucc.u (cuquax:ucc.u), accc.ccuucc.u
u c.c.uaucc.u uccxc(caauua cc.ca.cx:c.a
yrcxcaucrc (cxa cc.a.ca c+ auuauua +ac-
uc(a.cxa.
B-.c.:ux, c.cxcuuc u(ccxcrca \lK IU
2OOJ rc(a ncc.cu.: acc ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrc-
xcau: (cxa cyryc ua ua+axax ccc.a+a.cx:-
ucc.u nuacxc, a +ac.ucc.u, .cy, +.c cxc(caa-
.cxu u (c+uaaa.cxu, a .ac ux ycac(u.cxu
ca+axuc: c.ucccuu:u y+ac.uua yrcxca-
ucrc ncqccca cc c.ccu: cauucuua. H ncxy-
+uxcc: uc+.c uccya+ucc. O. cxc(caa.cxa ac-
(c u ucxcru+uc c.axc .ccaa.:, +.c: cu nc
accxc(yccy u yrcxcaucy (cxy yc.auaaxu-
aax car+a_uc auuy cauuaccrc uxu ccac-
c(a_uc crc c. c.ac.c.acuucc.u cc.ca.cx:-
c.aa. Hc +acu (c.. 7J \lK IU) .cyc. c.
cxc(caa.cxcu yc.aucaxcuua u .aux cc.ca-
.cx:c.a. \c a cuxy c(ucrc .crc a \lK IU
(cxcu :.: c.(cx:u:u a+(cx, nccaa_cuu:u
cncquax:uc ncxucc+ua cxc(caa.cxcu ((c+ua-
aa.cxcu) u ux ycac(u.cxcu.
,yac.ca, +.c ncxcu.cx:uc y(c. cacu
u acncc c c(uuc ac(cc.ac nc accxc(caa-
uu yrcxcau:x (cx.
B-+c.ac.:x, ua(c c ncuuauuc c.uccu.:ca
nc.cucc.a na.uu, .cy, +.c ucc. c-
c.c a cax:ucc.u. acuc(a.cx: ac(c a
c.aau. .c+y a acnccc c ac+cucc.u ncu+-
ac(c.aa c.(cx:u:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
(ccc.a cc.a ncucacc.aua, ccc.a .yna
u ccau(c.cx:c.acaauua) (c a:ucccuua ncc.a-
ucaxcuua c ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa. Hc
ac(: (c .crc ncu+ac(u.ca u xu+u:u c:c
+a(cuaaccrc a nca(c +. 2 c.. J84 \lK
IU uxu ~ nu nc(c+cuuu ua nu_cacc c.-
aaxcuuc ~ aa( xu cuc ccu.uc: c+ uc-
c(xcuucrc ncac(cuua ccc.ac.c.ay_cu -
cnc.u+:. Hc ua(c a:uy(a.: cxc(caa.cxa c-
xc(u.: +acuc(a.cx:u:c +anc.: u .c ca:
uayaa.: nuuqun +acuucc.u nu ncu+ac(-
c.ac nc yrcxcau: (cxa (c.. 7 \lK IU).
B-na.:x, uccxc(uc c ncuuauuc u yaa-
cuuc c.uccu.:ca cnaa(:aa_u cca
cc accx .c+c +cuua yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
u: uuc.u.y.a. Ic+: u(c., a +ac.ucc.u, c ua-
na(ax ua uuc.u.y.: nuaxc+cuua a a+cc.ac
cauuaccrc (c.c:u nc(xarac.ca +acuu.:
d. d. dunom::un. 7. B. Lmonoeo. Dc |cc }cccnoo nc \lK IU
54
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ua uuc.u.y. yac(cxcuua c nc(c+cuuu
J
) u
ccu+auua nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
ccc.aaxcuuc cauuu.cx:ucrc +ax+cuua (c-
auuu.cx:ucrc a.a), c.c:u nc(xarac.ca +a-
cuu.: acu-.c u.crcacu cnaacu c c+yx:-
.a.ax accxc(caauua
2
.
B .c u (yrc cxy+ac .c cc. nuac-
c.u xua: y_cxcuu raau.uu naa cau-
uaccrc, nc(c accrc crauu+cuu crc naaa
ua +a_u.y. ,a u .y(uc nc(c.aau.: ncy-
ca, nc((cuaa_crc c. ucuu rccy(ac.aa
cauucuuc a cy(c nc acu-.c .a cnaac.
B-acc.:x, uccc.a ua ucc.cy cc-
qu naacacrc cryxucaauua (c+uauua, nc-
u+ac(cuuy ua ccucac Uc(cax:ucrc +acua
c. 6 uua 2OO7 rc(a ` 9, cuc nc(cxac.
cc.aaa.:ca (axcc uc ccacacuu:. Kcuc.-
yucaauuc, xc.a u uc ccrxacyccc c nc(nu-
cauuau n. 25 c.. 5 \lK IU, .acrc curu-
uax:ucrc (cycu.a a \ac(cxcuuc c nc-
(c+cuuu (c.. 22J
J
\lK IU) nc+acxuxc
cnc(cxu.:ca c ncqcccyax:u: c.a.ycc xuqa,
a c.ucacuuu c.ccrc ac(c.ca (c+uauuc. Hc
ncqcccyax:u:c naaa .acrc xuqa, a ccccu-
ucc.u crc naac ua +a_u.y, nc(cxa. cc.a-
aa.:ca a y_cxcuuc ccc.cauuu. Hcx:+a na-
.u+ccu c(ucccu.uc cyxucaa.: nc (cxy
cauucuuc, +uacu.: cauuaccrc u +a_u.-
uua c cauucuuc, y.ac(a.: cauuu.cx:-
u:u a. ua+ax:uuc nc(a+(cxcuua (c+ua-
uua, a +a.c u ncycc. Hcc. cc.c +uc-
.cuaaa ncauaqua cccnc+cuua naaa cau-
uaccrc ua +a_u.y.
B-cc(::x, ua(c c+cu: auua.cx:uc c.ucc-
.uc: a:ca+:aauua rcucax:ucrc ncyc-
a IU
J
c uccxc(ucc.u ync_cuua ncqc(y-
: (c+uauua, ccncac(ac: .cy c nc(-
xccuuc c ac+cucc.u ncc(a+u a nc(cxc(-
c.acuucc.: crauca (c+uauua accx (cx c nc-
c.ynxcuuax uccx:acu u cc(ucu .acc.u
(ux nc+.u 7O "). Bc+uuac., nc auucu cc,
(aa cc.:x acncca:
a) uc ncaxc+c. xu .c y_cxcuuc naa
nc(c+caac:x u cauuac:x, nc(c accrc
naaa ua +a_u.y'
) cnccccu xu cy_cc.ay_uu ccrc(ua
cnyc (c+uaaa.cxcu caccaccuuc u a+c-
c.acuuc accxc(caa.: yrcxcau:c (cxa, rc.ca:
xu (c+uaaa.cxu .cy nc ycau cacux nc-
cccucuax:u:x +uauuu u uaac.acuuc-ncuxc-
xcru+cccy ccc.cauu'
B caa+u c nccxc(uu acncuu xua: cu-
c.a.aqu nc(cc(a.cxc Cxc(c.acuucrc c-
u.c.a nu ncya.yc Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu a.a nuaxc+cuua yrcxcaucu c.ac.-
c.acuucc.u a Icccuu nc+.u 2,5 .:c. (cxuc-
c.u:x xuq ~ cc.y(uuca crauca auy.cu-
uux (cx
4
.
Mucrc (ucyccucuu:x u .cy_ux cacc-
rc a+cacuua acnccca cy_cc.ayc. u a +ac.u
ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa a cy(c-
u:x c.a(uax yrcxcaucrc ncqccca.
lc+acxu a:ca+a.: cacu a+rxa(: xua:
nc c.(cx:u: u+ uux.
Bc-nca:x, : ncxucc.: a+(cxac cna-
ccuua y+cu:x c ac+cucc.u ccy(cuua nu
ncu+ac(c.ac a yc.aucaxcuuc rxaacu 4O
\lK IU cccc nca(c cy(cucrc a+u-
a.cx:c.aa ucauucau:x a ncc.ynxcuuu xuq
5
.
C+u.ac uccxc(u: ncac(cuuc nc .au
(cxa xc.a : cca_cuucrc cy(cucrc cxc(-
c.aua a au(c (cnccca nc(cy(ucrc u nc.c-
ncaacrc. S.c (cxuc ncxy+u.: cacc +acnxc-
uuc a +ac.u na.cu c.. JJ6 \lK IU. B .c
cxy+ac cuc y(c. acc.u c+: c .c, +.c c-
auuu.cx:u:u nurcac cccucaau ccacynuc-
c.: uccxc(caauu:x cy(c (ca+a.cx:c.a (+. 4
c.. JO2 \lK IU).
Oc.ca.cx:u:c uccxc(caauua acc. acc
nc+u.uaucc u ucra.uaucc a naacac cryxu-
caauuu ccccrc nca(a nuua.ua cy(cucrc
J
C.: loeu:oe l. B. Ccaccuuaa yrcxcauaa
ncxu.ua: qu: u a.:. M., 2OO8. C. J92
J9J.
2
C.: lo.cm{unoe H. H. Icaxu+aqua nuuqunca
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. M., 2OO7. C. J52.
J
C.: Icc. ra+c.a. 2OO9. 25 caaxa. ` JJ.
4
C.: Icc. ra+c.a. 2OO9. JJ caaxa. ` 25.
5
C.: l{+eqce B. H. C.a.crua c:: c nc-
c.ynucc.:. M., 2OOJ. C. 9J; Hcmxun H. .
1ccc.u+ccuc ccuca: cc: yrcxcaucrc cy-
(cncu+ac(c.aa a Icccuu. M., 2OO5. U. 2. C. JO5.
55
cacuua nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxa-
acuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (rxaaa 4O
J
\lK
IU). Hc yc ccrc(ua acuc, +.c c(uu u+ yc-
xcauu nucucuua cauuaccy .acrc nc-
a(a aaxac.ca crc uccuucc acaauuc a cc-
acacuu:x ncc.ynxcuuax u ac+c_cuuc nc-
.cncaacy nu+uucuucrc ac(a. S.c u (cx-
uc ncxy+u.: cacc +acuc(a.cx:ucc +acn-
xcuuc a au(c (cncxucuua +. 2 c.. JJ7
J
\lK
IU nyu.c 7
J
; +. 2 c.. JJ7
5
, +. 2 c.. JJ7
6
u +. 4 c.. JJ7
7
\lK IU ua(xcu. (cncx-
uu.: ccc.ac.c.acuuc nyu.au J
J
.
Bc-a.c:x, uca: cy(:a (cxu: :.:
nc(cy(u: .cx:c yrcxcau:c (cxa c ncc.yn-
xcuuax +ac.ucrc cauucuua. S.c u (cxuc :.:
+acnxcuc a +. J c.. JJ \lK IU. Hcx:+a
uu yacxu+uaa.: cxu+cc.ac ccc.aaca ncc.yn-
xcuuu, c.uccu:x a.crcuu (cx +ac.ucrc
cauucuua
6
, uu (cuuuaxu+ucaa.: ux ny-
.c nccac(a a a.crcu a(uuuc.a.uau:x
ncc.ynca
7
.
B-.c.:ux, a cuxy .crc, +.c ac.ynuaau
a +acuuy cuxy nurcacc acncc c auuca-
ucc.u uxu ucauucaucc.u cauuaccrc (nc(-
cy(ucrc) a uuuuuucaauuc ncc.ynxc-
uuu ncxy+ux cacc ccu+a.cx:ucc a+cacuuc
6
C.: lo:oeo O. C. Uac.ucc cauucuuc
a yrcxcauc ncqcccc. Aa.cc. (uc. ... au(.
u(. uay. la.cuuyr, 2OOJ. C. J4.
7
C.: Icc. c.uqua. 2OO9. ` J. C. J5.
(naaccy(uc nc yrcxcaucy (cxy ccy_cc.axc-
uc), a ncxucc+ua nc+u(uyca ccc.ac.c.ay-
_ux cy(ca ucca. xua: cu.cx:u:u xaa-
.c, .c uc. uccxc(ucc.u a ccxaucuuu
a \lK IU rxaa: 48 lcu+ac(c.ac a ua(-
+cucu uuc.auquu.
B-+c.ac.:x, uccxc(uc, a yc c.c+a-
xcc:, ax+u.: a \lK IU cncquax:u:u a+-
(cx, nccaa_cuu:u naacacy cryxucaauu
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:x ncu+ac(c.a, uc caa-
+auu:x c a+cacuuc acncca c auucaucc.u
cauuaccrc a uuuuuuycc ncc.ynxc-
uuu, cccc(c.c+ua a uc acc .c, +.c a uac.ca-
_cc aca cc(cu.ca a rxaaax 4647, 5J
\lK IU.
B-na.:x, uc ccnauaaa naaux:ucc.: yc.a-
ucaxcuua ccccuucc.cu (ccy(cucrc ncu+ac(-
c.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa a c.ucacuuu ya-
+auu:x a +ac.u J c.. 447 \lK IU xuq, uc-
cxc(uc ucx+u.: u+ \lK IU c.. 452,
ccrxacuc c.ccu yrcxcau:c (cxa a c.ucac-
uuu +xcuca Ccac.a Uc(caquu, (cny.a.ca lc-
cy(ac.acuucu (y: u cy(cu c(cax:u:x cy-
(ca cry. acca.uaa.:ca Bcxcau: Cy(c
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. Hca .a uc ccrxa-
cyc.ca c cuc.u.yqucuucu yc.aucacu c aacu-
c.ac accx ncc( +acuc u cy(c (c.. J9 Kcu-
c.u.yquu IU).
1aca: uaau oc |cc }cccnoo nc c.(cx:-
u: cuqcn.yax:u: ncxccuua (cuc.ay-
_crc \lK IU.
d. d. dunom::un. 7. B. Lmonoeo. Dc |cc }cccnoo nc \lK IU
56
Xc( cy(cucu cc:, c c.ccu c.cx: ucrc rcacu.ca
a c.auc yc ca:ac (cca.u xc., nca uua uc cau(c.cx:c.ayc.
c cc +aacacuucc.u. lcxaax:uc, +.c +a .u rc(: cy(: a (cc.a-
.c+uc c.cc :xu ccua_cu: a+xu+u:u .cxuu+ccuu cc(-
c.aau, ucruc u+ uux ncccxaxu a ccaccuu:c +(auua, cyc.c-
uxu ac+uc cc.a, cy(:a a a+: nca:acuc (cucucc cc(c-
auuc. Ocucauaa qcx: cy(cucu cc:, a nc(c.aaxac.ca,
(cxua ccc.ca.: a nca:acuuu a+cc.acuucrc ycaua nuuua-
c:x cy(cu:x cacuuu, a cccnc+cuuu ccx(cuua +acuucc.u
a (ca.cx:ucc.u cy(cu:x crauca u a nc(xuuucu ux uc+aaucu-
cc.u. K .cy ca+:aa. nc(c accrc .ccaauua uc \K
u \lK IU, a .ac ncxccuua Uc(cax:u:x +acuca O cy-
(cucu cuc.cc a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, O c.a.ycc cy(cu
a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu.
K ccaxcuu, c_c u ccrc(ua cuayuaa.ca
cc:c+u:c uc(cc.a.u a (ca.cx:ucc.u cy(cu nu
c.naaxcuuu uu naaccy(ua u c++acuuc, rauu-
+a_cc c ncc.ynxcuuau. 1a, ucrc+ucxcuu:c ny-
xuaquu a cc(c.aax acccacu uucaquu, cncc:
ra(au cau(c.cx:c.ay. c cynucaauucc.u cy-
(cucrc cnyca, c +aa+ax cy(cu:x cacuuu.
lcqac.ac. cnca.uaucc.:, cauuu.cx:u:u yxcu
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa, uccxauuc rxycc auu-
a.: a a.cuax: a+caac:x (cx. lcacccc.uc cy(:u uruc-
uy. (cac(: uc .cx:c caux ccy(cuu:x, uc u ux +a_u.uu-
ca. lcxcc .crc, +a+ac.y (cxa uc acca.uaa.ca nc cy_c-
c.ay. lurcac:, a naauxc, cc(ca. a.cc u+xccuuc cc-
(cauua cauuu.cx:u:x +ax+cuuu (a.ca), c.c:c ucc(c
nccnuc:aa.ca (ac c .cu c raa.u+ccuu cauau.
lccxc(y_uc accaqucuu:c cacuua nccnuc:aa.ca u+ nu-
rcacca (u cna.: c .cu c raa.u+ccuu cauau),
a a ua(+cu:c cacuua nccucca.ca accaqucuu:c cacuua.
H .aaa na.ua cacuc.acuua accu cy(cucu ac.uaxu anxc.:
(c Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU.
haxc: ccy(cuu:x u ux +a_u.uuca, cc(cauuc c.c-
:x a cx:acu +ac.u ccuca:aac.ca ua +acuax u (ca+a.cx:-
c.aax, ncc.c urucuy.ca. lu .c, acncu ncxccuua
c.. 2J7 \lK u ncc.aucaxcuu lxcuya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
B. ,. Heouoe, C. B. Ko:omuunoeo
Cyc6nan uxacrr nynacrcn
u nacronmc pcqopmc
Bnapumup muvpueuun Huanou,
oxop pnnecxnx nayx,
npoqeccop xaqepu
yroroano-npaaoaux ncnnrnn
Pocoacxoro qnrnara Poccnncxon
axaeunn npaaocynn
Coqun Banepueuna Kanamnuuoua,
nouounnx aauecnern Ppeceaern
Bepxoanoro Cya PO
57
O cy(cuc nurcacc, c+ arycu.aquu cc
cc:xcu ua +acu axc: c.acra.ca cc c.au-
(a.ucu c.uaucacu: B:ac(: cy(a ccc.-
ac.c.ay_cu uuc.auquu aaxa.ca naaux:u:-
u, ccc.ac.c.ay. a.u+ccu cc.ca.cx:-
c.aa u ccucaau: ua (ca+a.cx:c.aax,
uccxc(caauu:x accc.ccuuc u c.c.uauc a cy-
(cuc +acc(auuu. Hxu: ,cac(: a(aca.a
uc cry. :.: nuua.: ac auuauuc, ncccx:-
y nc.uacc+a. uccxc(caauu: (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa, ccauu: nc (cxy.
lc(cuaa yc.caaaaaca na.ua nuac(u.
ucrc+ucxcuu: uc+acuu: ccy(cuua
u a:ucccuu ucnaaccy(u:x cacuuu. H (ac
a .cx cxy+aax, cr(a ccy(cuucy uxu crc +a-
_u.uuy y(ac.ca (cu.:ca c.cu: uxu u+c-
ucuua cy(cucrc a.a, +a crc uc+acuucc nu-
ua.uc cy(:u uuacu c.ac.c.acuucc.u uc uc-
cy.. Hx (ca.cx:ucc.:, ccnacuuaa c nuua-
.uc uc+acuucrc cy(cucrc a.a, c.:(xuac
nu:aac.ca ncua.uc cy(cucu cauu.
Hucr(a nc.ua .cu cauu +a_u.uuy
nuxc(u.ca cc.:ca rc(au. ,cacx:uc ac
c .c cau(c.cx:c.ayc. cuc.u:u nuc
nc(cucrc c(a cy(cucu cauu, (cny_cu-
ucu 1araucrcu rcc(cu cy(c u accu
nccxc(y_uu cy(cu:u uuc.auquau a c.-
ucacuuu l.
J5 uxa 2OO5 rc(a 1araucrcu rcc(-
cu cy(c Icc.caccu cxac.u l. ccacc.uc
c C. :x ccy(cu nc +. 4 c.. J59, nn. a,
+. 2 c.. J7J u +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K IU. C nu-
cucuuc +. J c.. 69 \K IU cy :xc ua-
+ua+cuc c(uuua(qa.: xc. xuacuua cacc(:, u+
c.c:x nc +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K IU ~ (cca.:
xc. c c.:aauuc uaa+auua a ucnaau.cx:-
ucu cxcuuu c.crc cua.
B accaqucuucu axcc a(aca. cccuc-
aax cauc+ucc.: aaxuuaquu cy(c cc(c-
auucrc l. nc nn. a, +. 2 c.. J7J u +. 4
c.. J74
J
\K. Cy(cuaa cxxcrua nc yrcxca-
u: (cxa Icc.caccrc cxac.ucrc cy(a a ac-
caqucuuc cnc(cxcuuu c. J5 ucaa 2OO5 rc(a
ucx+uxa u+ nurcaca ccy(cuuc l. nc nn. a,
c.. J7J \K, cc.aaua a .c c aca uc+a-
cuuy aaxuuaqu crc (cuc.auu nc +. 4
c.. J74
J
\K.
Hc y(caxc.acuaauc: ncxy+cuu: c.ac-
.c, a(aca. auca: ca_ac.ca c ua(+cucu
axccu yc a lc+u(uy Icc.caccrc c-
xac.ucrc cy(a, c.uauya cac ncc:y c.cy.-
c.auc ynucrc a+ca xcraxu+aquu (cuc-
u:x cc(c.a (ca:ac uxxucua yxcu), a
.crc .cyc. +. 2 c.. J74
J
\K.
lcc.aucaxcuuc lc+u(uya Icc.cacc-
rc cxac.ucrc cy(a c. 2J caaxa 2OO8 rc(a
u+ nurcaca :x ucx+cu aaxuuquy-
_uu nu+ua cccc ynu:u a+c xcra-
xu+aquu. Ka+axcc: :, uc.uua acc.ccc.ac-
aaxa, c(uac caa aaxuuaqua (cuc.auu l.
nc +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K cc.aaxcua c cnc(cxcuu-
c nc ucu (cca.u xc. xuacuua cacc(:. lu
.c acu nu+ua :x ncxccu .cnc:
(a caa+u c c.cy.c.auc ynucrc a+ca) a cc-
ucay aaxuuaquu ~ a cnc(cxcuuu uc ya-
+:aaxcc:.
B c+yx:.a.c c+cc(ucrc a:ucccuua c-
xac.u: cy(c ucnaaccy(ucrc cy(cucrc c-
acuua a(aca. ca.uxca c ua(+cucu axc-
cu .cnc: yc a Bcxcau:u Cy( IU, c.y(a
:xc ncxy+cuc ncc.aucaxcuuc cy(:u Bcxca-
ucrc Cy(a IU ^. c c.a+c a y(caxc.accuuu
(auucu ua(+cucu axc: c. J5 aa
2OO5 rc(a (xc.a nurcac :x a:ucccu
J5 uxa 2OO5 rc(a, a axca a(aca.c ua-
naaxaxac: a caaxc 2OO7 rc(a). lu .c
c.uaucac+uaa +ac.: c.ac.a nca.caxa (cac-
(: lc+u(uya Icc.caccrc cxac.ucrc cy(a:
Cy( ncxuc u accc.ccuuc uccxc(caax ccau-
u:c nc (cxy (ca+a.cx:c.aa, (ax u a ccacyn-
ucc.u ua(xca_y cqcuy, cccucaauuc nu-
+uaa (cc.cacu:u, (cnyc.u:u u (cc.a.c+-
u:u (xa nu+uauua l. auucau: a uuu-
uuuyc:x cy ncc.ynxcuuax. ,cuc.aua l.,
nccxc aucccuu:x u+cucuuu, ncxy+uxu naaux:-
uy u(u+ccy cqcuy.
Ha+ua+cuucc l. uaa+auuc aaxac.ca cna-
ac(xua: u c.ac+ac. .ccaauua c.. 6 u 6O
\K IU.
A ccxu : cy(:a uc ncaaux cnca.ua-
uy ccxu(aucc.: u nc+u.ax : cc(cauuc
+. 4 c.. J74
J
\K IU, .c uaacuaa : .acrc
ncc.aucaxcuua uc a:ucc, uc cya 5JO 8J8 y.,
acuacaa l. a xcraxu+caauuaa, uua uc
B. . Heonoe. C. B. lo:omnuoeo. Cy(cuaa axac.: uy(ac.ca a uac.ca_cu ccc
58
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
cc. ncaa.u.:ca a cyy ca:ac c(ucrc
uxxucua yxcu, .cycy (xa aaxuua-
quu cc(cauucrc nc +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K.
lcxy+ua a c+cc(ucu a+ ucnaaccy(u:u
a., a(aca. auca: ca.uxca c c+cc(ucu ua(-
+cucu axccu yc a lc+u(uy Bcxcauc-
rc Cy(a IU. lcc.aucaxcuuc +acc.u.cxa
lc(cc(a.cxa Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
A. H. Kancaa c. JJ auaaa 2OO8 rc(a ncc.a-
ucaxcuuc cy(:u Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU ^. :xc
c.cucuc u nc (cxy ac+y(cuc ua(+cucc
ncu+ac(c.ac c ncc(a+cu a.cuaxca ua ac-
cc.cuuc a lc+u(uy Icc.caccrc cxac.-
ucrc cy(a.
O(uac lc+u(uy cxac.ucrc cy(a cac-
u ncc.aucaxcuuc c. 2J caaxa 2OO8 rc(a
ncc.aucaxcuuc +acc.u.cxa lc(cc(a.cxa Bc-
xcaucrc Cy(a IU ncurucucaax u +. 4
c.. J74
J
\K cc ccc (cca.: xc. xuacuua
cacc(: a nurcacc cc.aaux, xc.a u auca:
nu+uax, +.c cya xcraxu+aquu uc(cc.a.c+ua
(xa nu+uauua cc ynucu. Mc.uac c
cc.aaxcuua ncucu aaxuuaquu .cnc: yc
acc.c ynucrc a+ca xcraxu+aquu c.axc
y+ac.uc a ucu l. a ccc.aac crauu+caauucu
rynn:. O+cc(ucc c++acuuc auca: +ac.a-
auxc a(aca.a ca_a.:ca a Bcxcau:u Cy(
IU c ua(+cucu axccu. lcc.aucaxcuuc
cy(:u Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU M. c. J6 ancxa
2OO9 rc(a axca a cuxy cnca.uaucu cc-
xu(aucc.u :xa cc.aaxcua c+ y(caxc.acc-
uua, a a a+cc.ac (cac(a cna.: :xc nccnu-
cauc ncc.aucaxcuuc lc+u(uya Icc.caccrc
cxac.ucrc cy(a. 1a a c+cc(ucu a+ cy(:a
ncurucucaax cc(cauuc +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K,
r(c +c.c cnc(cxcuc, +.c nucucuuc cc ac+-
cuc .cx:c nu uaxu+uu ycxcauu, nc(yc-
c.cuu:x a +. 2 c.. J74
J
\K.
O+cc(uaa ua(+cuaa axca a Bcxca-
u:u Cy( IU nuacxa .cy, +.c ncc.aucaxc-
uuc Cy(:u Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU M. ncc.a-
ucaxcuuc +acc.u.cxa lc(cc(a.cxa Bcxca-
ucrc cy(a IU A. H. lc.c+cucaa c. 2J ccu-
.aa 2OO9 rc(a :xc c.cucuc u a c+cc(-
ucu a+ c.:.c ua(+cucc ncu+ac(c.ac.
2J c.aa 2OO9 rc(a Cy(cuaa cxxcrua
nc yrcxcau: (cxa Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU
ua(+cu: cnc(cxcuuc u+cuuxa aaxuu-
aqu cc(cauucrc l. c +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K ua
+. J (auucu c.a.:u, ua+ua+ua cy uaa+auuc
a au(c a.aa a a+cc JOOOOO y., cc.a-
aua uaa+auuc a au(c xuacuua cacc(: ua
acc.: xc. u acc.: ccaqca nc +. 4 c.. J59
\K IU c crc c.:aauuc a ucnaau.cx:ucu
cxcuuu yc uc c.crcrc, a c_crc cua.
1au ca+c, c ccu.a a:ucccuua uc-
naaccy(ucrc nurcaca 1araucrccrc rcc(-
ccrc cy(a u (c nuua.ua nccxc(ucrc cy(c-
ucrc a.a ncaxc ccxc na.u xc., nc.a+cu-
u:x ua .c, +.c: cy(cu:c uuc.auquu, ua+u-
uaa c rcc(ccrc cy(a u anxc.: (c lc+u(u-
ya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU, nc+u.axu u yac-
uuxu cc(cauuc +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K, a yncucc
uccxauuc c(cxa.: .c nuuccxc l. .auc
nccxc(c.aua. Maxc .crc, +.c cu uc cr ncxy-
+u.: naac ua ycxcauc-(ccc+ucc ccacc(c-
uuc, uc u c.:aax ua+ua+cuucc uc+acuuc ua-
a+auuc a ucnaau.cx:ucu cxcuuu c.crc c-
ua.
luac(cuu:u nuc nca+:aac., +.c uu
c acu cy(cucu cauc a uc+acuuc nu-
cucuuu a c.ucacuuu l. +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K
c+u uc., a ncca.uaac.ca y:axcuucc uc-
acuuc cc cc(cauua. lu .c acy(-
u:c (cac(:, nuac(u:c a(:u a+ lc+u-
(uyc Icc.caccrc cxac.ucrc cy(a (xa qc-
xcuanaaxcuucrc nuua.ua uc+acuu:x cy(c-
u:x a.ca, uac.cu+uac nca.caxuc: u Bcxca-
u: Cy(c, +.c cau(c.cx:c.ayc. c uc(cnyc.u-
c ncaaxcuuu cnca.uaucrc (yxa.
H c acu cy(cucu cauc cuc rcac-
u.: a nuac(cuuc nucc' B (auucu cu-
.yaquu c+: u(c. uc c cauc, a c ccacac-
uuu cy(:au accx uuc.auquu ncc.ynxcuua,
nc(ycc.cuucrc c.. JO5 \K (uc+acuuc
a:ucccuuu nurcaca, cacuua u uucrc cy(c-
ucrc a.a), ncccx:y ncu+acx:ucc y:axcu-
ucc ucacuuc ncxccuuu +. 4 c.. J74
J
\K
cau(c.cx:c.ayc. uc c cauc, a c qcxcuanaa-
xcuuc uccxauuu yc.auu.: ucnaaux:ucc
nucucuuc yrcxcaucrc +acua.
Mucrc+ucxcuu:c axc: ua ucnaaux:-
ucc ccy(cuuc, ncc.yna_uc a accaqucuu:c
u ua(+cu:c cy(cu:c uuc.auquu, c.c.uauc
59
cc+(a. .y(ucc.u (xa ux auua.cx:ucrc ac-
cc.cuua u+-+a cx:acu +arycuucc.u cy-
(cu, ccccuuc a Bcxcauc Cy(c IU. H acc
c ux accc.cuuc (cxuc :.: auua.cx:-
u:, a (cac(: ccy(cuu:x u ux a(aca.ca
(cxu: c.acra.:ca c.uaucaauuc, c +c.u
u ncxu: a+.acucuuc .crc, nc+cy ca_c-
uuc uc nc(xcu. y(caxc.accuu. S.c u (cx-
uc aau.:ca ccucau: cc(cauuc cy(c-
ucu cc:.
luac(cuu:u c nuc a+cacuua a-
xc nc (cxy l. uarxa(uc nca+:aac., +.c cau
cy(cu:c uuc.auquu ncacquy. ucrca.-
u:c ca_cuua c axcau, .c ca: +ary-
aa cca (cncxuu.cx:ucu ac.cu, a cc.
:.: ~ u cc+(aaaa au(ucc.: .acu ac.:.
\+u.:aaa c.c.uau:c .y(ucc.u a nc(-
xc(c accaqucuu:x u ua(+cu:x uuc.auquu
accc.cuu ncc.yna_ux axc, ua nc(-
c.aaxac.ca (xc.a .c u uc cccncuc) cxa-
.cx:u: ncuc nc+crc +ua+u.cx:uc acau-
u.: ccc.aa uay+uc-cucyx:.a.uau:x ccac.ca
nu Bcxcauc Cy(c IU u nu cy(ax cy.c-
.ca Uc(caquu, +.c: cuu crxu y+ac.acaa.:
a c+uacxcuuu c cc(cauuc accaqucuu:x
u ua(+cu:x axc u auccu.: nc uu cacu
cccu(aquu u cy(cuua. Ia+ycc.ca, cuu uc
+acua. cy(cu, uc .aaa na.ua nccrxa :
cy(:a nuuua.: naaux:u:c cacuua.
1cyc.ca, ua uaa a+rxa(, .ac nca:cu.:
xu+uy c.ac.c.acuucc.: cy(cu +a cy(cu:c
cauu, u nu cauax, nc(cu:x nuac(cu-
ucu a nucc ~ xuaa.: naaa ua (ax:ucu-
acc ccy_cc.axcuuc naaccy(ua. A (xa cc-
a_cuua nc.ca axc a Bcxcau:u Cy( IU
uccxc(uc nca:cu.: c.ac.c.acuucc.: cy(cu
cy(ca cy.c.ca IU.
Ha+cxc .ac u+cucuuc na.uu ac+-
c_cuua a.cuax:ucrc u cax:ucrc y_ca
nu cauxu.aquu xuq, ccy(cuu:x uc+acu-
uc. Ccrc(ua cu ac+c_ac.ca +a c+c. c(c-
ax:ucrc (c.a, c(uac .acu y_c (cx-
cu :.: ac+c_ac auucau:u xuqau ~
cxc(caa.cxau u cy(:au ~ ncccuax:uc.
Icaxu+aqua (auucrc nc(xccuua, ucccucu-
uc, y(c. cncccc.acaa.: nca:acuu xu+ucu
c.ac.c.acuucc.u cy(cu nu accc.cuuu a-
.cuaxca (cx a a+xu+u:x uuc.auquax, +ac.a-
au. ux ._a.cx:uc caca.: cacu cacuua c .c-
caauuau +acua u auua.cx:uc a+ua.:ca
c (cac(au nc(cy(u:x, ccy(cuu:x u ux
a(aca.ca, nccu+ua c c.nucau u ccx(aa
a ncxuc c.cc ncxccuua c.a.cu 297, 299,
J6O \lK IU u ncc.aucaxcuuu lxcuya
Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU O cy(cuc nurcac-
c u O ucc.c:x acnccax nucucuua
cy(au Kcuc.u.yquu IU nu ccy_cc.axcuuu
naaccy(ua.
B. . Heonoe. C. B. lo:omnuoeo. Cy(cuaa axac.: uy(ac.ca a uac.ca_cu ccc
6O
B u(u+cccu xu.ca.yc cc(u a.u+ccux ccucaauuu
nu+uauua (ca+a.cx:c.a uc(cnyc.u:u a:(cxa.ca: J) uay-
acuua naa xu+ucc.u u 2) uayacuua nca(a ccuauua (ca-
+a.cx:c.a, c.aaa_cc nc( ccucuuc ux (cc.cacucc.:
J
. S.c. .c+uc
ncxy+ux cacc nc(.ac(cuuc a ncc.aucaxcuuu lxcuya Bc-
xcaucrc Cy(a IU c. JJ c.aa J995 rc(a ` 8 O ucc.c:x
acnccax nucucuua cy(au Kcuc.u.yquu Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu nu ccy_cc.axcuuu naaccy(ua
2
. O(uac xcc cy_c-
c.acuucc uayacuuc +acua a yrcxcauc ncqcccc a .cu uxu
uucu c.cncuu +a.aruaac. naaa xu+ucc.u. 1a, ncqcccyax:uaa
ca cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu a ccucaucrc cnccca ccua-
uua (ca+a.cx:c.a ~ .c raau.ua (cc.ucuua yrcxcau: cy-
(cncu+ac(c.ac caccrc ua+ua+cuua: +a_u.: naa u +acuu:x
uu.cccca nc.cncaaux nu c(ucaccuucu +a_u.c xu+ucc.u c.
uc+acuucrc u uccccucaauucrc cauucuua, ccy(cuua, crauu-
+cuua cc naa u cacc(. ,cc.ucuuc (auucu qcxu ac+cuc
xua: nu yc.aucaxcuuu cc.ca.cx:c.a, uc_ux
+ua+cuuc (xa yrcxcaucrc (cxa, a .c+uc ccc.ac.-
c.auu c (cuc.au.cx:ucc.:. Icacuua (cxucc.u:x
xuq, ccy_cc.axa_ux accxc(caauuc ncc.ynxcuuu
u accc.cuuc yrcxcau:x (cx, (cxu: ccuca:aa.:ca
ua c.aa_ux .y (cuc.au.cx:ucc.: (ca+a.cx:-
c.aax. 1cx:c a cxy+ac .c+ucrc yc.aucaxcuua cc:.ua ncc.yn-
xcuua u u+cxu+cuua xuqa, ccacauaacrc crc, y(y. +a_u_cu:
naaa u nc.cncaacrc u cauuaccrc (nccxc(uuu y(c. cra-
(cu c. uccccucaauucrc cauucuua u ncuccc. cnaac(xuacc ua-
a+auuc xua: +a .c, +.c ua cac (cxc ccacaux). Hu:u cxc-
aau, yc.aucaxcuuc uc.uu: nc yrcxcaucy (cxy uanaaxcuc nc-
(c accrc ua +a_u.y u cccnc+cuuc naa u uu.cccca acacu
H. A. Kupouuo
Hpoucccyaxrnrc nocxccrunn
napymcnnn o6crrnunocrn nponsuocrua
cxccrucnnr ccrun
Havanun Anavonueuna Kuppuna,
capunn npenoaaaeru xaqepu yroroanoro
npoecca Capaoacxon rocyapcaennon
axaeunn npaaa
J
C.: locncecuu K. B.. Ho{eo l. H. \+ac.uc +a_u.uua a (ca-
+:aauuu nc ucacy yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucy +acuc(a.cx:c.ay. M.,
2OO4. C. 2O22; Muxou:oeco+ H. l. Hac.cx:uaa uura cy(:u nc
(ca+:aauu a yrcxcauc ncqcccc. M., 2OO8. C. JJ2.
2
C.: Ccuu ncc.aucaxcuuu lxcuyca Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Icccuuc-
cu Uc(caquu nc yrcxcau: (cxa Ccc.. C. l. ^ac.c+uua,
H. H. Xcxxcaa. M., 2OO4. C. JO.
6J
xu+ucc.u, y+ac.ay_cu a yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u
J
. Hc uc.uua cc. yc-
.auaaxuaa.:ca uc x:u cc(c.aau, a xua:
.cu, c.c:c cra(a. c. ncu+acxa u ua-
(cuc cccnc+uaa. c+yx:.a.
4
.
O(uu u+ .ccaauuu, uanaaxa_ux yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:uy (ca.cx:ucc.: (cc.u-
cuu qcxu, aaxac.ca .ccaauuc c.c.ua-
ucc.u, acncc.aua_ccca ua c.a(u nc(-
aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua u, a +ac.ucc.u, ua
ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu. ,auucc
.ccaauuc a:.cac. u+ c:cxa +acua. C c(-
ucu c.ccu:, (ac uc y(y+u ccyxucaau-
u:, cuc cnc(cxac. cc(cauuc (ucnc+uquu
u cauquu a(a naaca:x uc, cycxcaxuaac.
xaa.c naacc.ucacuuu, nc(c.c c.c:x
aaxac.ca cryxucaauuc ncu+ac(c.aa c.(cx:-
u:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu, .c cc.: a:c.ynac.
(xa uux ccucacncxara_cu u(ccu. C (yrcu
c.ccu:, .ccaauuc c.c.uaucc.u, +anc+a.xc-
aaac: a cc(cauuu caux cc(c.a yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucrc cryxucaauua, nccxc(u. a c-
u c.c.uaucc.u u a.cuaxu+yc.ca +cc+
ux nucucuuc. 1au ca+c, c.c.uaucc.:
ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu cc.: a:-
.ca_cc u+ cc(cauua yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:x uc .ccaauuc, caxu+y_ccca +cc+
.acu naacacu cu, nu c.cc ucncxua-
c.ca yc.aucaxcuu:u u nca(c ccacacuua
ccc.ac.c.ay_ux (cuc.auu, cycxcaxuaa_uu
a:aaxcuuc (cc.cacu:x cac(cuuu, u raau.uy-
c.ca ncxucc u .c+ucc c.acuuc a nc.ccxc
xc(a u c+yx:.a.ca cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua.
O.c.uaucc.: ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu ~ .c c.c.uaucc.: nc naauxa,
ac(y_aa a.yax:ucu c.c.uaucc.u
5
.
Hayacuuc c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa
cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu +ax+ac.ca a c.c.yn-
xcuuu c. naaux, u+ c.c:x cxa(:aac.ca nc-
a(c ccacacuua ccc.ac.c.ay_ux (cuc.auu,
nc(ync(a_uu ucacuuc ncxy+ac:x
cac(cuuu ua .anax ux a:aaxcuua u ucaquu
u cc+(a_uu ac+cucc.: ncacu crc cc-
x(cuua.
\a+auu:c uayacuua cry. (cnyca.:ca:
J) ua nc(rc.cau.cx:uc .anc ncu+ac(c.aa
cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua, 2) ua .anc cuay-
cuua uc_ux +ua+cuuc (xa yrcxcaucrc (cxa
cac(cuuu u J) ua .anc u+.a.ua cxc(ca nc-
c.ynxcuua u +acnxcuua c+yx:.a.ca cxc(-
c.acuucrc (cuc.aua.
Ha nc(rc.cau.cx:uc .anc ncu+ac(c.aa
cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua uayacuua c.c.ua-
ucc.u cry. a:aa.:ca a uca+.acucuuu y+a-
c.uua cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu ux naa, c.-
ac.c.acuucc.u, nca(a ncu+ac(c.aa ccc.ac.-
c.ay_ux (cuc.auu, ucnc(ync(cuuu
c nucucuuu .cxuu+ccux cc(c.a.
Ha .anc cuaycuua uc_ux +ua+c-
uuc (xa yrcxcaucrc (cxa cac(cuuu cry. ac.c-
+a.:ca .auc uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u, a
uca:ncxucuuc ncua.:u yuquu uax(c-
uua +a xc(c u cc(cauuc cxc(c.acuucrc
(cuc.aua; ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(c.acuucrc (cu-
c.aua a uc+ucc aca; ncac(cuuc (cncca
a .c+cuuc cxcc nc(cxu.cx:ucrc accuu, +c
a+cacuc +acuc; ncc.aucaa uaac(a_ux
acnccca; nc(.aaxcuuc xuqa (xa cnc+uauua
a +ucxc xuq, uc_ux c uu cy_cc.acuu:c
a+xu+ua ac aucaucc.u; ncucccuuc a xc(c
cxc(c.acuucrc cncucu.a ycxcauau, a c-
.c:x ncucxc(uxc ncacaccc cc:.uc;
ync_cuuc ncqc(y: cxc(c.acuucrc (cu-
c.aua, cr(a ncucca:c (cuc.aua ncac(a.ca
ncacxucc.uc, cax:uc u .. n.
Bc aca u+.a.ua cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua u
+acnxcuua c+yx:.a.ca cxc(c.acuucrc (cu-
c.aua cnc. uayacuuu c_c cxcc a+ucc-
a+cu u cc. ccc.ca.: u+ c.cy.c.aua cnuca-
uua a nc.ccxc cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua (a +a-
aucucc.u c. au(a cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua)
ycxcauu crc ncac(cuua, cc.a cuaycuua
ucc:x nc(c.ca uxu (cycu.ca, ynacau
J
lonoe B. M. K 8O-xc.u cc (ua c(cuua
Quxu Mcucccau: Ka+ ~ +y(ccucrc +cxcaca, .a-
xau.xuacrc y+cucrc, nc(arcra c. cra Bcc.uu
ClAl. 2OO5. ` J. C. 42.
4
C.: Ax+o{::un A. C. Bccc.ccuucc.:, ncx-
uc.a u c.c.uaucc.: a (ccy(cu:x c.a(uax cc-
cuuccrc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. M., 2OO6. C. JJ.
5
C.: lcc+noe A. l. K acnccy c c.c.ua-
uc u cy.c.uauc a cu.cc.c .ccc.uc-
c.c(cxcru+ccux ncxc naacncuuauua
Bcc.u. Mcccaccrc yu-.a. Cc. JJ. laac. 2OO4.
` 4. C. 2J.
H. A. lu{uno. lccxc(c.aua uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
62
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
u+:accrc, a .ac +anucu +a(aaac:x ac-
nccca, c(cxauu:x +ac+auuu u (cncxucuuu u
uu:x uayacuuu, ac(y_ux ucncxuc.c nc.c-
cxa; cnucauua cc(cauua, xc(a u c+yx:.a-
.ca cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua a ucacuuc
au(c; ucy(cc.caccuua nc.ccxa cxc(c.acu-
ucrc (cuc.aua c-.c u+ y+ac.uuca .crc (cu-
c.aua u .. n.
Bcc ncc+ucxcuu:c a:ac uayacuua
6
cuc xaccuuqucaa.: a +aaucucc.u c. .crc,
acu au( ncqcccyax:u:x raau.uu c.c.ua-
ucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
:x ncurucucaau naacnucuu.cxc nu
ccuauuu (ca+a.cx:c.a: J) uca:ncxucuuc
cxc(caa.cxc, (c+uaaa.cxc ca+auucc.cu nc
cccnc+cuu c.(cx:u:x naa y+ac.uuca cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu u nc ccx(cuu ncqc-
(y: cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu; 2) ucccx(c-
uuc naaux y+ac.ua ncua.:x; J) c.c.ynxcuuc
c. nc(.aaxac:x \lK IU .ccaauuu
ucaquu xc(a u c+yx:.a.ca cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu; 4) ucua(xca_cc ccy_cc.axcuuc
ccc.ac.c.ay_uu (cxucc.u:u xuqau u
rccy(ac.acuu:u crauau cu.cx:u:x u
ua(+cu:x ncxucc+uu +a ncqcccyax:ucu
(ca.cx:ucc.: crauca nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(-
c.aua u (c+uauua.
Hayacuua c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa
cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu cry. :.: nc(u.c-
aau: ca:u a+u:u nu+uuau. lc(c
accrc .c uu+uu nccccucuax:u:u ycacu:
xuq, ncu+ac(a_ux accxc(caauuc, a:aa-
_uuca a uc(cc.a.c+uc +uauuu uu naaca:x
uc, ucacuc ux .cxcaauuu, ucncuuauuu
+ua+ucc.u ncqcccyax:ucu c: cxc(c.acu-
u:x (cuc.auu u ac+cu:x nccxc(c.auu c.-
c.ynxcuua c. c.crux ac +acua, a .ac
a ucccc.ac.c.auu nc(.aaxac: uu cax:-
u: a+cc.aa, +.c uc ucx+ac. (ac rc.ca-
ucc.u ncu.u ua ncc.ynuy ax:cuuaqu
(ca+a.cx:c.a c qcx: ncxy+cuua acu-xuc
xu+ucu a:rc(: uxu cc:.ua (cny_cuu:x a xc-
(c accxc(caauua cauc u uc(cac.c.
Uax:cuuaqua (ca+a.cx:c.a aaxac.ca ua-
yacuuc, ccacacuuc c.ccrc axc+c. uc nc-
c.c nucucuuc ncqcccyax:u:x cauquu, uc
u nuaxc+cuuc auucaucrc a cc ccacacuuu
yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u. Hc+cn:aa_c-
rc ncc+ua cncccca ax:cuuaquu (ca+a-
.cx:c.a uc cy_cc.ayc. aau(y ux ucrcca+ua,
caa+auucrc c yuuax:ucc.: uucaqucuuc-
rc cc(cauua a(crc (ca+a.cx:c.aa. ^-
aa ax:cuuaqua (ca+a.cx:c.a cc. :.:
a:acua xuc a cc+(auuu nc(xcucrc (c-
a+a.cx:c.aa, xuc ac aucccuuu a yc uc-
_ccca (ca+a.cx:c.ac xcrc u+cucuua, uc-
aa_crc (cc.cacu:u xaa.c cc(ca-
_uxca a uc cac(cuuu
7
. 1a, uanuc, Mara-
(aucu cxac.u: cy(c uc.c Hcu+cuc :x
ccy(cu nc +. 2 c.. JOJ \K IU +a .c, +.c,
ac.aa a (cxucc.u cxc(caa.cxa, c ncc_:
ucu+acc.ucrc xuqa, a:ncxuuaacrc ycnucu:c
+anucu u nc(nucu c. ucuu (cnaauaac:x,
aucc a nc(xuuu:c nc.ccx: (cncca cau-
uaccrc lc.caa u cauuaccrc lcucacaa
xcu:c (cncxucuua c cc.ca.cx:c.aax ccac-
acuua uu au a +ac.u acnc(cxcuua c-
xcu ccy+ac.uuca ncc.ynxcuua, yc.auua .a-
u ca+c uc_ucca a (cxc nc.uacc+ua
u cc+(aa c_y a.uuy ccrxaccaauucc.u nc-
a+auuu y+ac.uuca rynn:, a .ac yxu+ua
a ac a(ccucrc
8
.
B a+cc.ac (yrcrc nuca c.cy.c.aua
nccccucuaxu+a y xuqa, ncu+ac(a_crc
nc(aau.cx:ucc accxc(caauuc, cuc nu-
acc.u ncc.ynuaacc a Kucacuu cy( rcc(a
Caa.caa ucrcnu+c(ucc yrcxcaucc (cxc nc
cauucuu A. a ccacacuuu ncc.ynxcuuu,
nc(ycc.cuu:x +. J c.. J6J \K IU. B xc-
(c nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua nc (au-
ucy (cxy nc(.aaxcuuc nc(c+caaccrc A. (xa
cnc+uauua nc.cncaau u cau(c.cxa ccy_c-
c.axaxcc: acc.: a+. lu .c uu c(uu u+
6
(cc: u (axcc, ccxu uc crcaccuc uucc, .cuu
uayacuuc c.uccu.ca c.c.uaucc.u ncu+-
ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu.
7
C.: luo:onu A.. Mouoo{o B. Uax:cuu-
aqua (ca+a.cx:c.a: yrcxcauaa c.ac.c.acuucc.:
acuucc.:. 2OO9. ` J. C. J4.
8
C.: Onc(cxcuuc Cy(cucu cxxcruu nc yrc-
xcau: (cxa Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU c. 6 uxa
2OO4 r. ` 9J-OO4-9 lxx. Bcxcaucrc Cy(a
IU. 2OO5. ` 6.
6J
nc.ccxca ya+auu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
uc cc(cu. cnucauua nu+uaca aucaucc.u
uu cnc+uaaaccrc, uu c.a.uc.ca, .c cc.: xuq,
a +ucxc c.c:x nc(c+caac:u A. nc(.aa-
xaxca cnc+ua_u. Uc.craucaauuc a xc(c
cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua .ac uc ncu+ac(u-
xcc:. B cacux nca+auuax, nc(acc.ay_ux
nc(.aaxcuu (xa cnc+uauua, na.u+ccu acc
cau(c.cxu u nc.cncaauc ya+axu, +.c ncxu-
.u.cx: :x aaa+ccu aucaucc.u, ua au(
ccua(qa.u xc. (x. (. 22, 67, 85, JJ4, JJ9, J87).
Mc(y .c nc(c+caac:u A., J992 rc(a c-
(cuua, nc(.aaxaxca (xa cnc+uauua ccacc.uc
c xuqau J98J ((aa(:), J985 u J987 rc(ca
c(cuua. Hanuc, a c(uc cxy+ac A.
nc(.aaxaxca cau(c.cx . ccacc.uc c l.,
J98J rc(a c(cuua, u B., uc_u yccuc
auxu, ua u c.+cc.ac, +.c (ac. accccc
ccucaauuc yccuu.:ca a .c, +.c A., l. u B. uc
ucxu cy_cc.acuu:x a+xu+uu ac aucaucc.u.
Kcc .crc, uu c(uu cnc+ua_uu uc ua+aax
uu c(ucrc cuc.ucrc nu+uaa aucaucc.u,
nc c.ccy ncu+caxa u(cu.uuaqua. lc-
.ccx: cc(ca. cxc(y_uc cyxucau:
cnc+uax cxc(crc +cxcaca nc aucauu (au-
u:, a ucuuc .cxccxccuu, cc.y, xuqy
(x. (. 44), nc c.uc, nu+ccc, aaa+ccu
uaqucuax:ucc.u, xuqy, cc.y (x. (. J59), nc
aucauu (auu:, cc.y, +c.a xuqa
(x. (. 2O2) u .. n. Cacc uu.cccucc, +.c u
a aucc (auu:x nca+auuax nc.cncaauc u cau-
(c.cxu cnuc:aaxu rau.cxa nc(cu: ca-
+c: Ucxcac aaa+ccu aucaucc.u, ua au(
J7J9 xc., cc(ucrc .cxccxccuua, c(c. :x
a cnc.uau:u cc.. \+ua.: ccry nc +c-
.a xuqa (x. (. J87)
9
.
Hucaqua c naaux:uc nc(cc
nc(.aaxac:x (xa cnc+uauua c.c.ca +c+-
a:+auuc aaua, .a a cu aaxac.ca ycxcauc,
cccnc+uaa_u uc.uuucc.: c+yx:.a.ca u(cu-
.uuaquu cnc+uaaaccrc c.c.a
JO
. Hcc(-
c nc.ccx: uc nc+acxa. cy(u.: c ccx-
(cuuu nc(nucauuu +. 4 u 6 c.. J9J \lK
IU c nc(.aaxcuuu (xa cnc+uauua xuqa ac-
c.c c (yruu xuqau, nc ac+cucc.u auca-
uc cxc(u:u c uu, u nc(c.a a rynnc c(-
ucc(u:x nc(c.ca. B yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:ucu u a uuuaxuc.u+cccu xu.ca.yc
naauxc c nc.ccxucaauuu (auu:x cac(c-
uuu ccyxucaauc c(uc+ua+uc
JJ
. Kcc .crc,
Bcxcau:u Cy( IU yc ya+:aax ua uc(cny-
c.ucc.: uayacuuu, nc(cu:x nuac(cuu:
a:ac
J2
. O(uac na.ua yncuc u(c. nc ny.u
+ancxucuua rc.ca:x xauca nc.ccxca
nc(.aaxcuua (xa cnc+uauua, uc cc(ca_ux
ya+auuu ua uccxc(ucc.: cnucauua nu+ua-
ca nc(.aaxac:x (xa cnc+uauua xuq u nc(-
c.ca, nc ny.u ucy.c+ucuua cuc.u:x nu-
c., nc c.c: ncu+caxc cnc+uauuc.
Hayacuua cry. ac+uua.: uc .cx:c u+-
+a c+rac.ucc.u uxu ncc.ynucrc y:cxa,
uc u :.: a:+aau: ucauua.cx:ucc.: u+-+a
cxc+uu, yc.axcc.u, c.ccca, c.a.: c+yx:.a.c
cxy+auucu uccucc.u. Bcc.c c .c c.c-
.uaucc.: ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
aaxac.ca c(uu u+ x+ca:x ycxcauu c.c-
.uaucc.u accxc(caauua u a:ucccuua +acu-
ucrc u.crcacrc cacuua nc cy_cc.ay yrcxca-
ucrc (cxa. lc.cy acu : nu+uucu uu
:xu a:+aau: acca.uaac:c uayacuua,
cuu cry. nuacc.u c(uuacac nc+ax:ucy
c+yx:.a.y.
lccxc(c.aua uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u
ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu +aauca.
c. cxc(y_ux cc.ca.cx:c.a: J) y(c. xu .c
uayacuuc a:aaxcuc, u ccxu y(c., .c ua ac
.anc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa; 2) y(c.
9
C.: Axua Kucaccrc aucuucrc cy(a r. Ca-
a.caa +a 2OO9 rc(. \rcxcaucc (cxc ` J-J54
O9. 1. 2.
JO
C.: L+u:un C. 0. lc(.aaxcuuc (xa cnc+-
uauua Iycac(c.ac (xa cxc(caa.cxcu lc(
c_. c(. B. B. Mc+acaa. M., 2OO5. C. J86.
JJ
C, uan.: Eu+uce H. C. Cxc(c.acuu:c (cu-
c.aua nc \lK IU: .ccua u na.ua: Hay+uc-
na.u+cccc ncccuc. M., 2OO8. C. 96; +:u-
no O. H. Occcuucc.u .a.u+ccux nucca nu
crauu+aquu u ncac(cuuu nc(.aaxcuua (xa cnc+-
uauua Onc+uauuc a na.uc c+:ca +cxcaca
u ac:.ua ncc.ynxcuuu (uay+uc-c.c(u+ccuc
acnc.:). M., 2OO6. C. J4O; L+u:un C. 0.
lc(.aaxcuuc (xa cnc+uauua. C. J9JJ94.
J2
C.: lxx. Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU. J994. ` 5.
C. J5.
H. A. lu{uno. lccxc(c.aua uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
64
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
xu a:aaxcuucc uayacuuc yc.auu:; J) y-
(c. xu ac+cucc.: accncxuu.: y.a.y (ca-
+a.cx:c.aa a cxy+ac nu+uauua crc (aau(y .a-
crc uayacuua) uc(cnyc.u:.
B cxy+ac, ccxu uayacuuc uc a:aaxac.ca
uuc u+ y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, xuc
ccxu ua ucrc ya+:aa. c.ccu:, uc (cxucc-
.ucc xuqc, yncxucc+cuucc nuuua.: cac-
uuc c nu+uauuu (ca+a.cx:c.aa uc(cnyc.u-
:, cncacrac. a. .acrc uayacuua, axu-
auuc crc ua xc( (cxa +aaucu. c. cy_cc.aa ca-
crc uayacuua u cxu ncxy+cuucrc uc+acu-
u: ny.c (ca+a.cx:c.aa a yc.aucaxcuuu
uc_ux +ua+cuuc (xa yrcxcaucrc (cxa c-
c.ca.cx:c.a. lcxu uayacuuc ucxc cc.c, uc
uc ncaxuaxc ua ccc.ac.c.auc ncxy+cuu:x cac-
(cuuu (cuc.au.cx:ucc.u, .c cuc uc nuac(c.
caua a (ca+:aauuu. B nc.uauc cxy-
+ac uayacuuc cc. c.a.: nu+uucu +axy-
(cuua cxc(caa.cxa u (uxu) cy(a a a:ac(c c
a.u+ccux cc.ca.cx:c.aax (cxa u, cxc(caa-
.cx:uc, y(c. ncauuuc a ucxarcnua.u:x nc-
cxc(c.auax, ccxu uc(cc.cacucc (ca+a.cx:c.ac
cac.ca ncxccuc a ccucay nuuuaccrc
cacuua. K nucy, uaccuucc u+cucuuc
c: uxu cc(cauua (ca+a.cx:c.aa, a .c
cxcc ca+y ucccx:ux (ca+a.cx:c.a, cc.
nuacc.u uc+acuucy nuaxc+cuu a a+c-
c.ac cauuaccrc, uc+acuucy u+auu c:
nccc+cuua, xuc, uanc.ua, uc+acuucy cc-
acc(cuu u+-nc( c.au uxu c. yrcxcaucu
c.ac.c.acuucc.u, a:ucccuu ucnaaccy(ucrc
nurcaca. Occcuuc +caa.: uac.ynxcuuc
ucra.uau:x nccxc(c.auu uayacuua, (cny_cu-
u:c a xc(c ca+y ucccx:ux cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu, ncaxcauc +acnxcuuc ucacuucu
(ca+a.cx:c.acuucu uucaquu. Hanuc,
cr(a ncac(cuuc cxc(c.acuucrc cncucu-
.a c+ y+c.a ycxcauu, a c.c:x ucxc cc.c
ncacaccc aaxcuuc, u ncu+ac(c.ac cnc-
.u+: nccc(c.ac ucacucrc nucucuua c-
.c(ca uccxc(caauua (axu nc(.ac(a_uu
(yr (yra, uc xcu:u c+yx:.a..
lcxu c uayacuuc a:aaxcuc cxc(caa.c-
xc, (c+uaaa.cxc, ncycc uxu cy(c, .c
cuc cc. xuc :.: yc.aucuc, xuc ncaxc+:
nucucuuc ncqcccyax:u:x cauquu.
lc ucuu H. l. Muxauxcaccu, +ac-
uc(a.cx:ucc a+cacuuc uccxc(caa.: c(uu
(ca+a.cx:c.aa c qcx: cacuua acncca c
(cnyc.ucc.u (yrux cau(c.cx:c.ayc. c uc-
ncxucu caxu+aquu u.cuca ua(xca_cu
ncqcccyax:ucu c: c.ucca_uxca (cxy
cac(cuuu
JJ
. B a(c cxy+aca y(ac.ca ucu.a-
xu+caa.: uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(-
c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu. lcxu c uc.
ncqcccyax:ucu ac+cucc.u yc.auu.: cc-
ucuua a (cc.cacucc.u ncxy+cuu:x c uay-
acuuc +acua (ca+a.cx:c.a, .c cuu nu+ua-
.ca uc(cnyc.u:u u uc cry. ucncx:+c-
aa.:ca a (ca+:aauuu.
Cy_cc.ayc. a+rxa(, +.c ua nc(aau.cx:-
uc accxc(caauuu cncquax:ucrc cacuua
c uc(cnyc.ucc.u ccc.ac.c.ay_crc (ca+a-
.cx:c.aa (cycu.ax:uc uc ccxac.ca. 1a-
cc (ca+a.cx:c.ac ncc.c uc ucncx:+yc.ca
a cccucaauuu a:ac(ca, cc(ca_uxca a u.c-
rcac yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc (cycu.c
J4
.
,cuc.au.cx:uc, u+ (ayxcc. u+y+cuu:x uau
a aucuu:x cy(ax r. Caa.caa yrcxcau:x (cx
.acrc cacuua uc cc(caxc uu c(uc u+ uux.
O(uac nc auucu cc a cnyxucaauucu
na.uc Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU .acu nuc
acc c ucc.ca. 1a, nc c(ucy yrcxcaucy
(cxy, accxc(caaaacyca a Iccnyxuc Caxa,
cxc(caa.cx:, ucxc(a u+ .crc, +.c c.c.c c-
nc.ucrc uccxc(caauua aauxac: rux:+a na.c-
ua, uc uc_crc c.ucacuua yrcxcaucy (cxy,
nu+uax cacu ncc.aucaxcuuc c. 26 ucaa
2OO7 rc(a +ax+cuuc cnc.a uc(cnyc.u-
: (ca+a.cx:c.ac
J5
.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c n. J.J2 nua+a rcuc-
ax:ucrc ncyca IU c. 6 ccu.aa
2OO7 rc(a ` JJ6 O crauu+aquu ncy-
cccrc ua(+ca +a ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:-
ucc.: crauca nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua
JJ
Muxou:oeco+ H. l. Hac.cx:uaa uura cy(:u
nc (ca+:aauu a yrcxcauc ncqcccc. C. JJ4.
J4
lc.:cnun l. 7. Hac.cx:uaa uura cxc(caa-
.cxa u (c+uaaa.cxa. M., 2OJO. C. JJ2.
J5
C.: Kaccaqucuucc cnc(cxcuuc Bcxcaucrc
Cy(a IU c. O9.O7.2OO9 ` 74-cO9-J9cn. [Sxc-
.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l| | :
.succur|.ruarxivcu|1lX1.IHI'id|cx|.
65
u c n. 22 nua+a rcucax:ucrc ncyca
IU c. 6 ccu.aa 2OO7 rc(a ` JJ7 O
crauu+aquu ncycccrc ua(+ca +a nc-
qcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.: crauca (c+uauua,
ncyc, a:aaua uc(cnyc.u:c (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa, ca+au a:uccu.: c.uaucaauucc ncc.a-
ucaxcuuc c nu+uauuu .aux (ca+a.cx:c.a
uc(cnyc.u:u u c ux ucx+cuuu. Aa.ca-
u, nuuuaaauu ucnccc(c.acuucc y+ac.uc
a a+ac.c xauca ncqcccyax:u:x (cy-
cu.ca, ax+cuu:x a +ac.: acc.y \lK
IU, c.caa (cuc.acaaxa (c 5 uua 2OO7 rc(a,
cccu(caau: (xa ucncx:+caauua a na.u-
+cccu (ca.cx:ucc.u xauu ncc.aucaxcuuu
O nu+uauuu uc(cnyc.u: (ca+a.cx:c.aa
u y.ac(cuuu cauuu.cx:ucrc +ax+cuua
u O nu+uauuu uc(cnyc.u: (ca+a.cx:-
c.aa u y.ac(cuuu cauuu.cx:ucrc a.a
J6
.
1c+a +cuua, ccrxacuc c.ccu ncyc-
y, cxc(caa.cx u (c+uaaa.cx uccxc(uc
a:uccu.: ncc.aucaxcuuc c ucx+cuuu (ca-
+a.cx:c.a, nc(c.aaxac.ca cxcc naaux:ucu
J7
,
a nc.cy +acxyuaac. auuauua nc(xccuuc
nc +acnxcuu a \lK .ccaauua a:uc-
cu.: .acc ncc.aucaxcuuc a nc uuuqua.uac
ya+auu:x (cxucc.u:x xuq, .a u nc xc(a-
.auc.ay c.ccu: +a_u.:
J8
. O(uac cxc(yc.
c.c.u.:, +.c a uc uc y+.cu: naaa nc.c-
ncaacrc. O+cau(uc, +.c a xc(c nc(aau.cx:-
ucrc accxc(caauua cu .a c, a u a cy(c,
uc cc. :.: xuacu naaa ccncu.: (cnyc-
.ucc.: (ca+a.cx:c.a, ya+:aa_ux ua xa-
a.c u a+c nu+uucuucrc cy ac(a, ua
cc.ca.cx:c.aa ccacacuua ncc.ynxcuua u
.. (. Kcc .crc, uccxc(uc ua(cxu.: ncxuc-
c+uau nc a:ucccuu .acrc ncc.aucaxcuua
u ycac(u.cxa cxc(c.acuucrc craua.
B cxy+ac caccaccuucrc nu+uauua uc-
yc.auucu cauu uucr(a cc. cy_cc.ac-
aa.: ac+cucc.: +acu: uc(cnyc.ucrc (c-
a+a.cx:c.aa (yru. Uc nc+c a:aaxcuc
uayacuuc, .c cu:ac aaucca ua crc yc.a-
ucuuc uxu accncxucuuc crc nccxc(c.auu. O(-
uac a cuxy cncquuu cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu,
ucc.c:c u+ uux nca.cu.: ucac+cuc aca-
cc (ncu+ac(c.ac c:ca, nc(.aaxcuuc (xa
cnc+uauua nc .c c nu+uaa u .. (.). ,au-
u:u a. cc. c.a.: nu+uucu ca+caauua
ucaccncxuucu uc(cc.a.c+ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a,
ac(y_cu ucac+cucc.u yc.aucaxcuua accx
cc.ca.cx:c.a, uc_ux +ua+cuuc (xa yrcxca-
ucrc (cxa, +.c, a cac c+cc(:, nuac(c. a:-
uy(cuucy a:ucccuu ncc.aucaxcuua c nu-
cc.aucaxcuuu nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua,
nca_cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa nc cauxu.u-
y_u ccucaauua uxu ncc.aucaxcuuu cn-
aa(a.cx:ucrc nurcaca nc cax:u: cc-
ucaauua. Hc.uua a .aux cxy+aax uc (cc.u-
rac.ca, a +ua+u., uc+a_u_cuu:u cc.a.ca
naaa uc .cx:c nc.cncaaux c. ncc.ynxc-
uuu, uc u xcrc +cxcaca, c.c:u cc.
nc(acruy.:ca ncc.ynucy nccara.cx:c.ay cc
c.ccu: yac(acrc c. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acu-
ucc.u xuqa.
1cx:c +uaa +acu u ucc.c.ynuc cxc(ya
a(cy crc nc(nucauu, ac+cuc accc.a-
ucau.: xc( cc:.uu, uc_ux +ua+cuuc (xa
yrcxcaucrc (cxa, a .c+uc ccc.ac.c.auu c (cu-
c.au.cx:ucc.:, .c cc.: ncxy+u.: .ay ccac-
ynucc.: uccncacu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a, ua
ccucaauuu c.ccu cuc c(cxa.: c(uuc.acu-
u:u u acu:u a:ac(, a +ua+u., (cc.u+: qcxcu
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a ccc.ac.c.auu
c +acnxcuu: a Kcuc.u.yquu IU u \lK
IU nuuqunc nyxu+ucc.u.
J6
C.: loomoe A. H.. Cunuqon A. H.. 7u-
+occe A. B. lcqcccyax:u:c a.: nc(aau-
.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua u (c+uauua. M., 2OJO. C. 572
57J, 58959O.
J7
C.: do:omox B. B. lcaca (cnyc.ucc.u
(ca+a.cx:c.a a yrcxcauc ncqcccc. Icc.ca-ua-
,cuy, J999. C. 2292JO; Poccuncuu C. l. \rc-
xcau:u ncqccc: \+cuu. M., 2OO9. C. 2O22OJ.
J8
C.: Anuqu O. O. Cc(c.aa +acnxcuua
xc(a u c+yx:.a.ca cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu u ux
(ca+a.cx:c.acuucc +ua+cuuc: ,uc. ... au(. u(.
uay. Caaa, 2OO2. C. J84J85.
H. A. lu{uno. lccxc(c.aua uayacuua c.c.uaucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu
66
\lK ICUCI (a c(aquu c. 27 c.aa J96O rc(a)
uc cc(cax ncxccuuu, nc(yca.uaa_ux ac+cucc.: nu-
ua.ua c c+cnacucc.u a c.ucacuuu xuqa a yrcxcauc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.ac u (cncca crc a ycxcauax c:.ucc.u. Uc:
.acrc (cncca u cnccc: +a_u.: cau(c.cxa a:aa.:aaxuc:
cy(cucu na.ucu.
lca:u cxy+au nucucuua c.(cx:u:x c c+cnacucc.u
a na.uc Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc(c-
aua ncu+cacx a J99J rc(y, cr(a c. y +xcuca
Oll yau nu ucncxucuuu cxycucrc (cx-
ra ncruxu ua+ax:uu c.(cxa CHO ` J r. Ca-
auca anu.au auy.cuucu cxy: A. larauu u
c.aauua uxuquu l. Auauu
J
.
Cau(c.cxa-c+cau(qa acc.cxa anu.aua A. la-
rauua, uccc.a ua nuua.:c c:, craua naac-
nca(a cuayu.: uc y(axcc:. Orauu+a.cc
yuuc.aa, c.c:u uaxc(uxca a c+:cc, ua ncuc
.crc cau(c.cxa :xu ccucu.ucaau: +xcu: Oll,
cc.aaaucca ua cacc(c.
B xc(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa nc(cc(a-
.cx:c.ay_cy ncc.ynuxa uucaqua c cc.c ua-
xc(cuua (auucrc cau(c.cxa. Onacaac: acnaa: au(:, cu-
_uua c:aaxac: c ucccacacuucxc.uuu (c.:u. lc xc(a.au-
c.ay rcccauuu.cxa cy( a:ucc cnc(cxcuuc, a c.cc nc(ycc.-
cx: cccnc+cuuc cc yrxccy.c+ucu cxaucu; uca+rxaacuuc
auc.u:x (auu:x cau(c.cxa; (cncc nc naauxa c:.crc
cau(c.cxa a ycxcauax, ucx+a_ux au+yax:ucc uax(cuuc
nc(cy(u:u u auc +axa cy(cucrc +acc(auua. ,cncc :x nc-
ac(cu +a rcc(c a ncxc, a cncqaa.cycc, y(a :xu (cc.aaxcu:
y+ac.uuu ncqccca +a ucx+cuuc nc(cy(u:x. lc.ccx cy-
(cucrc +acc(auua, a .c +ucxc ay(uc+anuc: nca+auuu c:.c-
rc cau(c.cxa u crc +c.c c ya+auuc cc.a acncxccuua
B. H. Mopmmmnuu, 0. H. Kysv:u:ce, B. B. Mopmmmnuu
Koxxnsnn yroxouno-npoucccyaxrnr nopm,
o6ccncunuarmn 6csonacnocrr onpoca
crprrr yuacrnnrou cyonponsuocrua
Bacunu Huuonaeuun Mapvmmuun,
aauecneru Ppeceaern Bepxoanoro Cya
Pecny6rnxn Hopoann, noenun pa6onnx
cye6non cnceuu Poccnncxon Oeepann,
aacryennun pnc Pecny6rnxn Hopoann
Oner Revpouun Kyaumuneu,
naarunnx oera oprannaanonnoro
o6ecneennn enerunocn cyoa lYOPO
cye6noro enapauena
npn Bepxoanou Cye PO
Buvanu Bacunueuun Mapvmmuun,
npoxypop yroroano-cye6noro oera
npoxypaypu Pecny6rnxn Hopoann
J
Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc(caua. \rcxcaucc (cxc
` 2-6OJ99J.
67
rynn: a ccu. ncc.ynxcuua, :xu uccxc(c-
aau: c y+ac.uc nc(cy(u:x.
Bc aca ncac+rxaacuua nurcaca c.
5 ucaa J99J rc(a +xcua au(: (ucncxuu-
.cx: l. nurcaccu ucx+u.cx:ucu cc
uaa+auua) a +axc cy(a ua+axuc: ccnca(u,
nc+ay+axu yrc+: yuuc.ac a a(cc cy(cu.
\ cxau: n:.axuc: c.u.: ccy(cuu:x. Ha
cxc(y_uu (cu: a a(cc nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay-
_crc nc (cxy ncc.ynuxc nuc:c, c.ccc ua+u-
uaxcc: cxcaau: Cy(:a ycc ca:... u
+aau+uaaxcc: nc(nuc: Oxc.uu. l:xa
uauccaaua auccxuqa c cx.a_uca a nc.xc
.cxc. Hc+: ua uxu_c cy(:u, a c.cc
uaxc(uxac: crc cc:a, :xc ccacacuc uana-
(cuuc c nc(crc aa.u:. Cy(:a u crc uc-
ccacacuucxc.uuc (c.u a .c+cuuc (ayx xc.
uaxc(uxuc: nc( cxaucu, nca uc :x +a(c-
au uaxc(uaauuca a c+:cc crauu+a.c
ncc.ynxcuuu
2
.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c ncxccuuau +. J c.. JJ
\rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c(cca Icccuu-
ccu Uc(caquu nu uaxu+uu (cc.a.c+u:x
(auu:x c .c, +.c nc.cncaacy, cau(c.cx
uxu uu: y+ac.uua yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa, a .ac ux xu+u c(c.acuuua,
c(c.acuuua uxu xu+u xuqa yrca.
yuuc.ac, nucucuuc uacuxua, yuu+.ccuuc
uxu ncac(cuuc ux uy_cc.aa xuc uu:u
cnacu:u nc.uacnaau:u (cauuau, cy(,
ncyc, cxc(caa.cx:, crau (c+uauua u (c+ua-
aa.cx: nuuua. a c.ucacuuu ya+auu:x xuq
c: c+cnacucc.u, nc(ycc.cuu:c +. 9
c.. J66, +. 2 c.. J86, +. 8 c.. J9J, n. 4 +. 2
c.. 24J u +. 5 c.. 278 \lK IU.
H+ a:acncc+ucxcuu:x ncqcccyax:u:x
uc cnc.cuquu cy(a aca.ca .cx:c nc-
xccuua +. 5 c.. 278 \lK IU (cc.ax:u:c
ncqcccyax:u:c uc:, ncc+ucxcuu:c a +. J
c.. JJ \lK IU, nc(xca. ucncxucuu ua
(ccy(cu:x c.a(uax yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa), ccrxacuc c.c: nu uccxc(ucc.u
cccnc+cuua c+cnacucc.u cau(c.cxa, crc xu+-
ux c(c.acuuuca, c(c.acuuuca u xu+ux
xuq cy( c+ crxaacuua nc(xuuu:x (auu:x
c xu+ucc.u cau(c.cxa anaac ncacc.u crc (c-
ncc a ycxcauax, ucx+a_ux au+yax:ucc ua-
x(cuuc cau(c.cxa (yruu y+ac.uuau cy-
(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa ((axcc ~ c:-
.:u cau(c.cx:).
Bc a+auccaa+u c a(c yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u:x uc +. 5 c.. 278 \lK IU ucc.
ucc(uc+ua+ucc .cxcaauuc nucuu.cx:uc
yry xuq, ua c.c:x acncc.aua.ca cc
ncxccuua.
1a, a ccc.ac.c.auu c +. J c.. 277 \lK
IU nc.cncaauu (cnaauaac.ca a nca(c,
yc.aucaxcuuc +ac.au 26 c.. 278 \lK
IU, .c cc.: nc.cncaauu nc (cxy, crc xu+uc
c(c.acuuuu, c(c.acuuuu u xu+uc xuqa
uc. naac ua cccnc+cuuc ux c+cnacucc.u,
a nc.cncaauu .ac cc. :.: (cncacu
a cy(c nc naauxa (cncca c:.crc cau-
(c.cxa.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c +. J c.. 45 \lK IU
+acuu:c nc(c.aau.cxu u nc(c.aau.cxu nc-
.cncaacrc uc. .c c ncqcccyax:u:c naaa,
+.c u nc(c.aaxac:c uu xuqa, ccc.ac.c.acuuc,
.ac cry. :.: (cncacu: nc naauxa
c:.crc cau(c.cxa.
Cxc(yc. ca.u.: auuauuc ua .c, +.c nc-
xccuua +. 5 c.. 278 \lK IU a a+cc.ac
c: cccnc+cuua c+cnacucc.u c:.crc
cau(c.cxa nc(yca.uaa. crc (cncc a cy-
(cuc +acc(auuu a ycxcauax, ucx+a_ux
.cx:c au+yax:ucc uax(cuuc (yruu y+ac-
.uuau cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa. S.a nc-
qcccyax:uaa uca uc cc(cu. uu:x .cc-
aauuu, uanuc, .ccaauuu c u+cucuuu xa-
a.cuc.u .aucxuyccrc a cy(cuc +a-
cc(auuu rcxcca cau(c.cxa. \+u.:aaa, +.c qc-
x: caxu+aquu c c+cnacucc.u cau(c.cxa,
crc xu+ux c(c.acuuuca, c(c.acuuuca uxu
xu+ux xuq aaxac.ca cccnc+cuuc rccy(ac.acu-
u:x raau.uu +a_u.: accx .ux xuq c. cnac-
u:x nc.uacnaau:x (cauuu, (cncxuu.cx:ucrc
2
C.: Hccn+oeo .. 7ccmuno 7. Cy(:a yc-
c ca: Ccac.caa Mc(caua. J99J. 2O uc-
aa. ` 45; loo:ooe H. Oxc.a ua cy(cu /
H+acc.ua. J994. 2J auaaa. ` J2; On +c. Oxc-
.a ua cy(cu nc(cxac.ca H+acc.ua. J994.
25 auaaa. ` J4; Po..ooe 0. Xcuua cc-
cuuccu ncc.ynucc.u. J992J995 rr. M., J997.
C. JO4JO5.
B. H. Momomun u {. lc+cnacucc.: (cncca c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
68
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
naacacrc cryxucaauua .cy. ncqcccy-
ax:u:c naauxa, nc c.c: a cy(c ncac(u.-
ca (cncc c:.crc cau(c.cxa. B +ac.uc-
c.u, yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa uca (cxua cc-
(ca.: ncc+cu: ycxcauu, c.c:c nc(xca.
ccx(cuu cy(c nu ncac(cuuu (cncca
c:.crc cau(c.cxa (xa ucx+cuua u(cu-
.uuaquu crc xu+ucc.u uu:u y+ac.uuau
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. S.u ycxcaua
(cxu: y+u.:aa.: ccccuucc.u accc.c-
uua yrcxcau:x (cx a cy(ax ncacu, accaqu-
cuucu u ua(+cucu uuc.auquu Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c +. J c.. 278 \lK IU
c.ccu: anaac +a(a.: acncc: cau(c.cx
yc.uc, nuc:cuuc, c ucncx:+caauuc .cxuu+cc-
ux cc(c.a uxu uu: cncccc.
Ka au(uc u+ nc.ccxa cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua, cau(c.cx: nc( ncca(cuuc K. H. Hc-
xca (cncacu cy(c a c.cy.c.auc nc(cy(u-
crc C., c.c:u :x xuacu ac+cucc.u
+a(a.: cau(c.cx acncc:, ncccx:y c cc-
(cauuc nca+auuu c:.crc cau(c.cxa
c+uacxcu uc :x. Bcc.c c .c nca+auua
ua+aauucrc cau(c.cxa nuac(cu: a nurcacc
a a+cc.ac (ca+a.cx:c.a auucaucc.u C. a cc-
acacuuu accx a.ca ncc.ynxcuuu nc n.
+. 2 c.. 228
J
, +. J c.. 2J4 \K IU, a .c
+ucxc u .cx, nc c.c: cu auuy uc nu+uax,
+.c ncaxcxc c.cuy cauuu.cx:ucrc nurcac-
a c uanaaxcuuc (cxa ua ucacc cy(cucc
accc.cuuc
J
.
laacacu cuc.uu .cyc. ncqcccy-
ax:ucc cnc(cxcuuc .acrc ncua.ua, a cc.c
uaxc(cuua c:.crc y+ac.uua yrcxcauc-
rc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. Kcc .crc, uccxc(uc
ncqcccyax:ucc +acnxcuuc uaucucaauua
cnccca .aucxaquu a +ax cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua nca+auuu c:.crc y+ac.uua yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, a .ac rxacucrc nc-
qcccyax:ucrc cu.cxa a +axc cy(cucrc +acc-
(auua +a .aucxaqucu .ux nca+auuu ucuuc
a cuc cax:ucrc accuu (.acu cu.cx:
(cxcu ucx+u.: x:c ccucuua cy(a u
y+ac.uuca cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa a .c,
+.c c:.:u y+ac.uu (ac. nca+auua a c-
uc cax:ucrc accuu c+ acrc-xuc nu-
uy(cuua cc c.ccu: uu:x xuq).
lcqcccyax:ucrc cryxucaauua .ac
.cy. acncc:, caa+auu:c c ua(cxcuuc cy(a
(cy(:u c(uucxu+uc, cxxcruu u+ .cx nccc-
cucuax:u:x cy(cu, c(cax:ucrc cy(:u u cx-
xcruu c y+ac.uc cy(:u c(cax:ucrc cy(a
c_cu uc(uquu u (acua(qa.u nucau:x
+acc(a.cxcu) naac nccc(c.ac au(cccu-
ccuqcaa+u uax(a.: a +axc cy(cucrc +a-
cc(auua +a ncqcccc (a+u nca+auuu c:-
.: y+ac.uuc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a cu-
c cax:ucrc accuu a ycxcauax, ucx+a-
_ux crc au+yax:ucc uax(cuuc (yruu y+a-
c.uuau cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa.
Hccxc(uc cau.: acncc c .c, .c cu-
c.uc a +axc cy(cucrc +acc(auua u a cc.c
uaxc(cuua c:.crc y+ac.uua yrcxcauc-
rc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa cccnc+uaac. nc acnc-
acuu nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_crc ua+axc
.aucxaquu u cc ccu+auuc.
lcqcccyax:ucu cuc.uu .cy.
acncc: ccx(cuua nu cy(cuc a+ua-
.cx:c.ac c y+ac.uc c:.crc cau(c.cxa c-
_crc nca(a nc(rc.cau cy(cucy +acc(a-
uu, a +ac.ucc.u, .ccaauuu +. 2 c.. 2JJ u
2J2 \lK IU. Ccrxacuc .u uca a nc-
c.aucaxcuuu c ua+ua+cuuu cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua nc(xca. a+cacuu acncc: c a:+cac
a cy(cucc +acc(auuc xuq nc cnuca, nc(-
c.aaxcuu: c.ccuau, u c u+ac_cuuu c.c-
cu c cc.c, (a.c u accuu cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua uc cucc +c +a na.: cy.c (c crc ua+axa.
O(ucaccuuc (cxu: :.: cacu: crauu-
+aqucuu:c acncc:, caa+auu:c c cc(cauu-
c acncacuua cy(:u c a:+cac a cy(cucc
+acc(auuc xuq, ya+auu:x a crc ncc.aucaxc-
uuu nucuu.cx:uc a:+cay c:.crc cau-
(c.cxa.
Cuc.ca c+cnacucc.u (cncca c:.:x
cau(c.cxcu uc (cxua c.a.: axuxxcccacu
na.cu naaccy(ua. Qcua cauu ~ u+u:
y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa.
lc.cy uaa(y c ccacacuc.acaauuc nc-
J
Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc(c-
aua. Kaccaqucuucc cnc(cxcuuc ` 22-JOJ6O7
c. JJ.O5.2OO7.
69
qcccyax:u:x ncqc(y u .ccaauuu c ncu+-
ac(c.ac (cncca c:.:x cau(c.cxcu ucc-
xc(uc a aax au.ucynqucuucu ncra-
: c:: c ncc.ynucc.: nc(ycc.c.:
cc+(auuc cncquax:ucu rccy(ac.acuucu c(c-
ax:ucu cxy:, cncccucu c.uauc c-
aa.: acncc: rccy(ac.acuucu +a_u.: y+ac-
.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. B uac.ca_cc
aca .u yuquu ac+xccu: ua \naaxc-
uuc nc cccnc+cuu c+cnacucc.u xuq, nc(xc-
a_ux rccy(ac.acuucu +a_u.c MB, IU,
c.ccc +a_u_ac. cxcc .:ca+u cau(c.cxcu.
O uccxc(ucc.u cc+(auua .acrc nc(a+(c-
xcuua cau(c.cx:c.ayc. cy(cuaa na.ua nc
accc.cuu (cx a c.ucacuuu +xcuca nc-
c.ynu:x ccc_cc.a.
Bcxcau: Cy(c Iccnyxuu Mc(caua
26 ccu.aa 2OOJ rc(a a:ucccu nurcac
a c.ucacuuu .uua(qa.u +xcuca Oll, ucuy-
_cu cca Mc(aa. Cc(u cc.cux nc-
c.ynxcuuu au(:, +xcu: c.ccu ncc( uana-
(cuuau ucycuc ruucaaxuc:, +.c +a.y(-
uaxc ux cnc+uauuc, :x (c+uu acc.cx
a c_cc.acuuc cc.c u+ aa.ca.a Kaxaauu-
caa rcucax:ucrc (uc.ca Acccquaquu a-
c.uuca naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauca Icc-
nyxuu Mc(caua B. ^aacaa (ncxcauua
uxuquu a c.c.aac) u crc ac(u.cxa. Cy(c-
u:u ncqccc ncxc(ux (aa.u+uc. Haauy-
uc (cc.aau a +ax cy(cu:x +acc(auuu aa-
u:x cau(c.cxcu cauucuua c(uu u+ uux ~
K. ~ :x yu.. Hc+: :xa a+caaua (ac:
a aa.uc a.ccrc cau(c.cxa H. u cy nu-
+uucu: uccc.acuu:c aucuua. B uxu_c
,. ~ ycac(u.cxa cxc(c.acuucu rynn: ~
:xa cacua ccaaa raua.a U-J, nc(c.a-
a_cua ncn:.a cc.cxa aa.u: u+ raua-
.cc.a
4
. B c+yx:.a.c cncqcncaquu UCl IU
a caaxc 2OO8 rc(a :xu +a(cau: cc.ax:-
u:c +xcu: ncc.ynucrc ccc_cc.aa ((cca.:
+cxcac). Bcc.c c uuu cc.y(uuau UCl
:x acc.caau +acc.u.cx: ua+ax:uua u-
uuax:ucu uxuquu MB, ccnyxuu. Cc-
rxacuc nc(.aaxcuucy cauucuu (nc +. J
c.. 28J, +. J c.. 2JO, +. J c.. 285, n. r +. 4
c.. 29O, +. J c.. J74
J
\K IU), ncxcauu
uxuquu :x ccac(cu.cxc ycac(u.cxa
au(: Mc(aa, uaxc(a_crcca yc (caa.:
xc. a c(yuac(uc c+:cc +a ccacacuuc
ncc.ynxcuuu nc +. 2 c.. 2O9, n. , c, , + +. 2
c.. JO5, +. J c.. 222 \K IU
5
.
1ccuc a+auccaa+aua c nc(:(y_uu
acnccau .ca ccx(cuua nu ncac(cuuu
cy(cucrc ncqccca c y+ac.uc c:.crc
cau(c.cxa nc(ycc.cuu:x rxaaau J5 u J6
\lK IU c_ux ycxcauu cy(cucrc a+u-
a.cx:c.aa u nca(a crauu+aquu nc(rc.c-
au.cx:ucu +ac.u cy(cucrc +acc(auua.
1a, a ccc.ac.c.auu c ncxccuuau c.a.cu
24O26O \lK IU c_u ycxcaua cy-
(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa c.uccu.ca ucnccc(-
c.acuucc.: u yc.ucc.:, rxacucc.:, ucu+cuucc.:
ccc.aaa cy(a, aacuc.ac naa c.ccu, uaxu+uc
ccc.aa cy(cucrc +acc(auua u ac(cuuc u
nc.ccxa cy(cucrc +acc(auua c ccx(cuu-
c ca+a.cx:u:x .ccaauuu, nc(xca_ux c.-
acuu a nc.ccxc, y+ac.uc nc.cncaacrc
a cy(cuc a+ua.cx:c.ac, c: ac+(cuc.aua
ua uayacuuc nca(a a cy(cuc +acc(auuu.
Ccx(cuuc nu (cnccc c:.crc cau-
(c.cxa ccucacncxara_ux nuuqunca cy(c-
ucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa .cyc. uca.uaucrc
ncqcccyax:ucrc +acnxcuua a c.. 5 \lK
IU ncua.ua aau a cy( y+ac.uuca cy(cucrc
a+ua.cx:c.aa, a.u+ccu uaxc(a_uxca auc
nc(cxca +axa cy(cucrc +acc(auua, nccc(-
c.ac ay(ucau(cc.aucxaquu a cuc cax:-
ucrc accuu.
O(ucaccuuc uccxc(uc ncqcccyax:-
ucc +acnxcuuc a rxaac J5 \lK IU ccuca-
u:x naaux ay(ucau(cc.aucxaquu yc.u:x nc-
a+auuu y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa, a .c +ucxc ccucau:x naaux ay(uc.au-
cxaquu a +axc cy(cucrc +acc(auua yc.u:x nc-
a+auuu c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cucrc a+-
ua.cx:c.aa c u+cucuu:u (c ucy+uaaac-
cc.u ux rcxccca:u xaa.cuc.uau. lu
4
Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc(c-
aua. \rcxcaucc (cxc ` 2-J2OOJ.
5
1a c. Ma.cuax ` 2--252OO9. Kaccaqu-
cuucc cnc(cxcuuc Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU ` J5-
OO9-25 c. 2J.O7.2OO9.
B. H. Momomun u {. lc+cnacucc.: (cncca c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
7O
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
accxc(caauuu yncauy.crc (cxa cau(c.cxa
cauucuua H. ncc.ynuuu a:+ucxuxu nc
rcxccy, nu+uuua .auu ac( +(cca:
6
.
lc(c.aaxac.ca ac+cu: u uccxc(u:
(nu ca+a.cx:uc ccx(cuuu yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:u:x nuuqunca rxacucc.u u ucu+cu-
ucc.u ccc.aaa cy(a) a qcxax cccnc+cuua ra-
au.uu caxu+aquu cuc.u.yqucuu:x naa
ra(au~y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa ua +a_u.y ux ncccuax:u:x (auu:x
(a .c +ucxc naa ua ucnuccucacuucc.: +a-
c.ucu u+uu, xu+uy u cccuuy .auuy), a .a-
c (xa naacacrc ycryxucaauua acnccca,
caa+auu:x c uccxc(ucc.: yac(cxcuua
c:.:x cau(c.cxcu c c.ac.c.acuucc.u
+a c.a+ c. (a+u nca+auuu u (a+y +aac(cc xc-
u:x nca+auuu u c:.:x nc.cncaaux c
c.ac.c.acuucc.u +a (a+y +aac(cc xcu:x nc-
a+auuu, accc.c.: acncc c aac(cuuu a yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu (cncxuu.cx:ucu ncqcc-
cyax:ucu c.a(uu ~ c.a(uu ncccuuuaquu
y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa.
Qcxcccca+uc .ac aac(cuuc (cncxuu-
.cx:ucrc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc uuc.u.y-
.a ~ uuc.u.y.a c.(cx:ucrc cy(cucrc ncy-
+cuua.
lu ucu+cuuc ccc.aac cy(a, acca.-
uaa_crc cuc.ucc yrcxcaucc (cxc, a a-
ax ucncxucuua c.(cx:ucrc cy(cucrc ncy-
+cuua a:+ca a cy( u ncccuuuaqu ccc.-
ac.c.ay_crc ~ a .c +ucxc c:.crc ~
nc.cncaacrc uxu cau(c.cxa, uaxc(a_crcca auc
+axa cy(cucrc +acc(auua uxu a (yrc a(-
uuuc.a.uauc-.cu.cuax:uc ca+caauuu
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, c.cauuc y uux cc-
c.ac.c.ay_cu nc(nucu ccry. ccy_cc.au.:
(yruc cy(:u u ccc.au cy(a .crc uxu
(yrcrc c(cax:ucrc cy(a c_cu uc(u-
quu nu ycxcauu au+yax:ucrc uax(cuua +a
.uu ncqcccau u+ +axa cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua nccc(c.ac ay(ucau(cccuccuqcaa+u
cy(:cu, nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_u nc (cxy. Cxc-
(yc. .ac nc(ycc.c.: uanaaxcuuc uxu
nc(cc.aaxcuuc a yc.aucaxcuu:u cc cy(c,
c.caaau nc(nucy, cy(:c, nc(cc(a.cx:-
c.ay_cy nc (cxy, nc(nucauucrc nc.cnca-
au uxu cau(c.cxc (cycu.a (xa nuc-
_cuua crc nc.ccxy cy(cucrc +acc(auua
(+. 2 c.. 278 \lK IU).
B ccc.ac.c.auu c nuuqunc aacuc.aa
c.ccu (c.. 244 \lK IU) c:.:c y+a-
c.uuu cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa uc., ua-
a(y c (yruu y+ac.uuau cy(cucrc nc-
qccca, naac nc(c.aaxa.: cy(y nuc:cuu:c
cyxucau nc acncca, ya+auu:
a nn. J6 +. J c.. 299 \lK IU (acncc:
(ca+auucc.u ncc.ynxcuua u uaa+auua au-
ucaucrc a crc ccacacuuu), a+caac:c cy-
(c nu ncc.aucaxcuuu nurcaca.
lcxccuuau c.. 42, 45, 56 \lK IU
nc.cncaauu, +acuu:c nc(c.aau.cxu u nc(-
c.aau.cxu nc.cncaacrc, cau(c.cx: ua(cxcu:
a(c naa u ca+auucc.cu, c.c:c a a(c
cxy+aca ac+cuc caccaccuuc caxu+caa.:
xuc ucncxuu.: xua: ucnccc(c.acuuc a +axc
cy(cucrc +acc(auua nu accc.cuuu cy(c
yrcxcaucrc (cxa. lc.cncaauu u cau(c.cx:
.ac cry. ncx:+caa.:ca a cy(cuc +acc(a-
uuu nuc:cuu:u +ac.au, +a+u.:aa.: uc-
_ucca y uux (cycu.:, c.ucca_ucca ux
nca+auua. \a+auu:c nuc:cuu:c +ac.u
u (cycu.: nc(.aaxa.ca cy(y nc crc .c-
caauu, cc .crc, (cycu.:, nc cnc(cxc-
uu uxu ncc.aucaxcuu cy(a cry. :.: nu-
c_cu: a.cuaxa yrcxcaucrc (cxa. B .cu
caa+u (xa cccnc+cuua ac+cucc.u caxu+a-
quu c:.: y+ac.uuc yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa accx cacux ncqcccyax:u:x naa
u a:ncxucuua accx ncqcccyax:u:x ca+au-
ucc.cu qcxcccca+uc nc(ycc.c.: ncqcc-
cyax:u:u nca(c u ycxcaua (cxcrucaauua
+ac.u .ux naa u ca+auucc.cu ccc.ac.c.acuuc
rccy(ac.acuucy cauuu.cx, +a_u.uuy nc(-
cy(ucrc u a(aca.y, nurxaacuucy cau(c.c-
xc (xa ca+auua u(u+cccu ncc_u, nu-
uua_u ucnccc(c.acuucc y+ac.uc a cy(c-
uc ncqcccc u uaxc(a_uca a +axc cy(cuc-
rc +acc(auua.
Haucx:auc +a.y(ucuua ac+uua. ua na-
.uc nu cnc(cxcuuu cy_cc.acuuc +ua+u:x
6
C.: loo:ooe H. K.c +a_u.u. cau(c.cxa
Mcccacuc ucacc.u. 2OOJ. 9J5 c.aa. ` 4J.
7J
cc.ca.cx:c.a, c.c:u ca+au ycac(c.ac-
aa.:ca cy( nu a+cacuuu +aaaxcuucrc c.c-
cucu nc (cxy xc(a.auc.aa c ac:.uu nc(-
xuuu:x (auu:x c c:.c cau(c.cxc.
Cy(cuaa na.ua cau(c.cx:c.ayc. c .c,
+.c a cxy+ac +aaaxcuua c.ccuau cccucaau-
ucrc xc(a.auc.aa c ac:.uu nc(xuuu:x cac-
(cuuu c xuqc, (a_c nca+auua, a caa+u c uc-
cxc(ucc.: ccy_cc.axcuua +a_u.: nc(cy-
(ucrc xuc yc.aucaxcuua aux-xuc
cy_cc.acuu:x (xa accc.cuua yrcxcaucrc
(cxa cc.ca.cx:c.a, cy( anaac nc(cc.aau.:
c.ccua ac+cucc.: c+uacxcuua c ya-
+auu:u cac(cuuau. Hanuc, nu accc.-
cuuu Bcxcau: Cy(c Iccnyxuu Mc-
(caua yrcxcaucrc (cxa a c.ucacuuu B., cra-
uu+caaaacrc nurc.caxcuuc yuuc.ay nc uauy
u+acc.ucrc a r. 1cx:a..u nc(nuuua.cxa,
a cxu uxxca a:c.ynuxc xuqc, (cuc.ac-
aaaacc a aax cnca.uauc-c+:cucrc c-
cnua.ua cnca.uau:u cncucu.
7
.
B cy(c +a_u.uu cauuaccrc +aaaux xc-
(a.auc.ac c acccc+uaauuu xu+ucc.u a:c.y-
nuaacrc a cxu ucncxuu.cxa yuuc.aa, (cnc-
acuucrc a xc(c nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua
nc( ncca(cuuc A. A. Axcccca ~ +a_u-
.a uac.auaaxa ua crc (cnccc a ycxcauax au-
+yax:ucrc uax(cuua.
O.a+ a crxaacuuu nc(xuuu:x cac(cuuu
c xu+ucc.u c:.crc cau(c.cxa u uccxc-
(ucc.: crc (cncca a ycxcauax, ucx+a-
_ux au+yax:ucc uax(cuuc (yruu y+ac.-
uuau cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa, cy(:a cc-
cucaax uu.cccau cccnc+cuua c+cnacucc.u
cau(c.cxa u crc xu+ux xuq. Mc.uaucaau-
ucc ncc.aucaxcuuc cy(:u (.ccaauua +. 4 c.. 7,
n. 7 +. J c.. 259 \lK IU) c.acuc a nc-
.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua. Bcc.c c .c cy(
(xa ccy_cc.axcuua aaxuuqucaauucu +a_u-
.: nc(cy(ucrc B. nc(cc.aaux a(aca.y ac+-
cucc.: c+uacu.:ca c nc(xuuu:u cac(c-
uuau c xuqc, (a_c nca+auua, +.c uc nc.u-
acc+u. .ccaauua +. 6 c.. 278 \lK IU.
1cyc. .ac a+cacuua acncc, caa+au-
u:u c uccxc(ucc.: ua(cxcuua cy(a nc-
qcccyax:u:u naaau ua nucucuuc
c:.: y+ac.uua cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua .acu c: ac+(cuc.aua +a uayacuuc
nca(a a cy(cuc +acc(auuu, a c.x+c-
uuc ay(ucau(cc.aucxaquu (nc auaxcruu
c y(axcuuc xuqa u+ +axa cy(cucrc +acc(a-
uua), ncccx:y a ccc.ac.c.auu cc c.. 258 \lK
IU c: ac+(cuc.aua +a ucnc(+uucuuc ac-
ncacuua nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_crc uxu cy-
(cucrc nuc.aaa (nc(ync(cuuc c uc(cny-
c.ucc.u .acrc ncac(cuua, y(axcuuc u+ +axa
cy(cucrc +acc(auua, uaxccuuc (cucucrc
a+:cauua) nucua.ca cy(c .cx:c xu-
qa, nucy.c.ay_u a +axc cy(cucrc +acc-
(auua.
Bcncc: ac+uua. u a caa+u c uccxc(u-
cc.: cccnc+cuua caxu+aquu a cy(cuc
+acc(auuu accx ncqcccyax:u:x naa c:-
.:x cau(c.cxcu u nc.cncaaux, aaxa_uxca
ucccacacuucxc.uuu uxu xuqau, nc caccy
u+u+cccy uxu ncuxu+cccy ccc.cauu xu-
acuu:u ac+cucc.u cacc.ca.cx:uc +a_u-
_a.: cacu naaa u +acuu:c uu.ccc:.
B cuxy .ccaauuu c.. 28O \lK IU nu
y+ac.uu a (cnccc nc.cncaaux u cau(c.cxcu
a ac+ac.c (c +c.:ua(qa.u xc. (a nc ycc.-
cuu cy(a ~ u a ac+ac.c c. +c.:ua(qa.u
(c acccua(qa.u xc.) y+ac.ayc. nc(arcr u +a-
cuu:u nc(c.aau.cx: ucccacacuucxc.ucrc.
,cncc ucccacacuucxc.uux nc.cncaaux u
cau(c.cxcu, uc_ux u+u+ccuc uxu ncuxu-
+ccuc uc(cc.a.u, ncac(u.ca ac accx cxy+a-
ax a nucy.c.auu nc(arcra. ,c ua+axa (cnc-
ca ucccacacuucxc.ucrc nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay-
_uu a+.acuac. nc(arcry crc naaa, c +c
a nc.ccxc cy(cucrc +acc(auua (cxac.ca cc-
c.ac.c.ay_aa +anuc:. lc(arcr anaac c a+-
cacuua nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_crc +a(aaa.:
acncc: ucccacacuucxc.ucy nc.cncaacy,
cau(c.cx. lu uccxc(ucc.u (xa y+ac.ua
a (cnccc ucccacacuucxc.uux nc.cncaaux
u cau(c.cxcu a:+:aa.ca .ac ux +acuu:c
nc(c.aau.cxu, c.c:c cry. c a+cacuua
nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_crc +a(aaa.: acncc:
(cnaauaaccy. ,cncc nc.cncaacrc uxu
7
C.: Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc-
(caua. \rcxcaucc (cxc ` 2-52OJO.
B. H. Momomun u {. lc+cnacucc.: (cncca c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
72
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
cau(c.cxa, uc (cc.uracrc ac+ac.a +c.:ua(-
qa.u xc., ncac(u.ca c ca+a.cx:u: y+ac.u-
c crc +acuucrc nc(c.aau.cxa. lcc( (cn-
ccc nc.cncaaux u cau(c.cxcu, uc (cc.uraux
ac+ac.a +c.:ua(qa.u xc., nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay-
_uu a+.acuac. u +ua+cuuc (xa yrcxcaucrc
(cxa ncxu:x u naa(ua:x nca+auuu. O c.-
ac.c.acuucc.u +a c.a+ c. (a+u nca+auuu u +a
(a+y +aac(cc xcu:x nca+auuu .u xuqa uc
nc(ync(a.ca u nc(nuca y uux uc cc.-
ca. B qcxax cxau: naa ucccacacuucxc.-
uux nc xc(a.auc.ay c.ccu, a .ac nc uuuqu-
a.uac cy(a (cncc nc.cncaaux u cau(c.cxcu,
uc (cc.uraux ac+ac.a acccua(qa.u xc., c-
c. :.: ncac(cu a c.cy.c.auc nc(cy(ucrc,
c +c cy( a:uccu. cnc(cxcuuc uxu ncc.auca-
xcuuc. lccxc ac+aa_cuua nc(cy(ucrc a +ax
cy(cucrc +acc(auua cy (cxu: :.: ccc-
_cu: nca+auua .ux xuq u nc(c.aaxcua ac+-
cucc.: +a(aaa.: u acncc:. lc ccu+a-
uuu (cncca nc.cncaauu uxu cau(c.cx:, uc
(cc.urauu ac+ac.a acccua(qa.u xc., nc(a-
rcr, nucy.c.acaaaauu nu crc (cnccc, a .a-
c +acuu:c nc(c.aau.cxu nc.cncaacrc uxu
cau(c.cxa cry. ncuuy.: +ax cy(cucrc +acc-
(auua c a+cacuua nc(cc(a.cx:c.ay_crc.
1au ca+c, a ccc.ac.c.auu c (cuc.ay-
_u yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: +acuc(a-
.cx:c.ac u nu (cnccc c:.crc uccc-
acacuucxc.ucrc cau(c.cxa uxu nc.cncaac-
rc a +axc cy(cucrc +acc(auua (cxu: nu-
cy.c.acaa.: nc(arcr u +acuu:u nc(c.aau-
.cx:. Bcc.c c .c uc: c.. 28O \lK IU
uc y+u.:aa. ccccuucc.u, caa+auu:c c (cnc-
cc c:.crc ucccacacuucxc.ucrc nc.c-
ncaacrc uxu cau(c.cxa. H+ c:cxa c.. 28O
\lK IU cxc(yc., +.c +acuu:u nc(c.aau-
.cx: ucccacacuucxc.ucrc nc.cncaacrc uxu
cau(c.cxa u nc(arcr (cxu: :.: ucnccc(-
c.acuuc a(c c uu. Haxc(cuuc .ux y+a-
c.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ac ac-
a ncu+ac(c.aa (cncca a +axc cy(cucrc
+acc(auua, a uc a(c c ucccacacuucxc.uu,
uc cccnc+uaac. a ncxucu cc +a_u.y crc naa
u +acuu:x uu.cccca.
S.u ycxcaua :xu ccx(cu: Bcxcau:
Cy(c Iccnyxuu Mc(caua nu (cnccc
acc.uxc.ucu H. ~ cau(c.cx:uuq: nc yrc-
xcaucy (cxy nc cauucuu l. a ccacacuuu
u ncc.ynxcuua nc n. c +. 2 c.. JO5, +. J
c.. 222 \K IU (nc(ncxcauu uxuquu l.,
c.aauu cncyncxucc+cuu:u COlIa \lOl
MB, Iccnyxuu Mc(caua, caua c.c-
c.u.: cuc, c.caa yaxa (yrcy, u cc
ucacy yy, a ncrcc ux caaa yc.aucaux
ccay raua.y U-J, nurc.caua cc a+:ay
nu nuccucacuuu, acc+u.:aaa nc(caa.:
ccux; c(uac c. a+:aa ncru (yrcu +cxc-
ac, a cynyrca a+:aucu acxucu c.ccuxc
a c.ccuy)
8
.
Auaxcru+u:c acncc: ac+uua. nu c-
(cxucaauuu ncqccca (cnccca c:.:x
cau(c.cxcu, ncx:+y_uxca ycxyrau a(aca.a,
a .ac c:.:x ccacacuucxc.uux nc.c-
ncaaux, uc_ux nc(c.aau.cxa.
1au ca+c, c.:.: cc.ac.ca acncc
c .c, r(c cuc.uc ac aca (cncca c:-
.:x y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
(cxu: uaxc(u.:ca ux +acuu:c nc(c.aau-
.cxu, nc(c.aau.cxu, a(aca.: u nc(arcr ~
a +axc cy(cucrc +acc(auua uxu a cc.c, u+ c-
.ccrc (ac. nca+auua ccc.ac.c.ay_uu
c:.:u y+ac.uu; .ac c.:. acncc,
au ca+c, uaxc(ac: auc +axa cy(cucrc
+acc(auua, +acuu:c nc(c.aau.cxu, nc(c.a-
au.cxu, a(aca.: u nc(arcr ccry. cax:uc c-
axu+caa.: cacu ncqcccyax:u:c naaa.
O.cy.c.ay. u c.ac.: ua acncc c .c,
au ca+c y(c. caxu+caauc naac
c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cucrc (cxcncu+-
ac(c.aa ua ccnxa.ucc ncx:+caauuc ncc_:
nccac(+ua, a .ac c .c, r(c (cxcu uaxc-
(u.:ca nccac(+u ac aca a:ncxucuua cac-
ux ca+auucc.cu u acac y(c. a+cc.ac cuu-
xcuucrc nccac(a cxca (cnaauaaccrc, u-
+ucrucu+ccux caquu c.ccrc nccac(+u,
uaxc(a_uuca a +axc cy(cucrc +acc(auua ac
aca (cncca, uc au(u.. Bcc .c cc. a:+-
aa.: ccucuua y cy(a u y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a .c+ucc.u ncc(a+u c:c-
xa nca+auuu c:.crc y+ac.uua.
8
C.: Cono+nuoeo l. laua.a (xa ,c+(ccu:
Kccccx:caa naa(a. 2OO2. 25 c.aa. ` 4O.
7J
A.yax:ucc +ua+cuuc nu accc.cuuu
(cx a c.ucacuuu +xcuca crauu+caauucrc
ncc.ynucrc ccc_cc.aa ucc. caxu+aqua
naaa ua cccnc+cuuc xu+ucu c+cnacucc.u
acaaaauxca cauuac:x, u c+cnacucc.u ux
xu+ux, nccra_ux u+cxu+u.: xu(cca u
a.uau:x +xcuca au(:. J5 uua 2OOO rc(a
Bcxcau: Cy(c Iccnyxuu Mc(caua :x
a:ucccu nurcac au(c, nc:axaaacu -
c.c u yuuc.aau. B xc(c accc.cuua (cxa
cy(c cauuac:u K., .cxcxauu.cx: ycac-
(u.cxa au(:, ca.uxca c +aaaxcuuc c nu-
ua.uu a c.ucacuuu ucrc u ra(auccu cu:
\. (cau(c.cxa nc (cxy) c c+cnacucc.u.
Mc.uaucaax cu ncc:y .c, +.c cy_cc.ayc.
cax:uaa yrc+a crc c+cnacucc.u: cc.aaaucca
ua cacc(c +xcu: Oll ccacauxu a caa+u
c (a+cu cxc(caa.cx nca+auuu uana(cuuc ua
\., nu+uuua cu .auu ac( +(cca:. lc
nc(ync(uxu, +.c a cxy+ac aau a cy( cc y:.
acc.c c ccuc. Cau(c.cx:uuqc \. u cc c-
cuy :xa a:(cxcua cxaua. lc(cy(u:u K.
u cau(c.cx:uuqa \. a cy(cuc +acc(auuu
acca+axu c accx ccacacuu:x au(cu nc-
c.ynxcuuax. B a(cc ua+ax:uua y+c(c-
uua \UCHH IU nc Iccnyxuc Mc(caua
ua ccucaauuu c.. JJ \HK IU cy(c :xc
uanaaxcuc ncc.aucaxcuuc c cccnc+cuuu ccy-
(cuucrc K. cau c+cnacucc.u ac aca c.-
:.ua uaa+auua. Bnccxc(c.auu K. a ccc.ac.-
c.auu cc c.. 79 \K IU :x ccacc(cu yc-
xcauc-(ccc+uc u acc.c c cucu \. u ccu-
c a:cxax ua u.cx:c.ac a (yry cc.ucc.:
9
.
O(ucaccuuc ac.ac. acncc c uccxc(u-
cc.u nuua.ua cy(c c c+cnacucc.u a c.-
ucacuuu nc(arcrca, nccac(+uca, +acuu:x
nc(c.aau.cxcu, nc(c.aau.cxcu u a(aca.ca,
ucnccc(c.acuuc c_a_uxca ac aca cy-
(cucrc ncqccca cc c:.:u y+ac.uua-
u yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. S.c cxc(yc.
u+ c:cxa Uc(cax:ucrc +acua c. 2O.O8.2OO4
` JJ9-U O rccy(ac.acuucu +a_u.c nc-
.cncaaux, cau(c.cxcu u uu:x y+ac.uuca yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa.
B na.uc Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxu-
u Mc(caua ucx cxy+au ca_cuua a(ac-
a.a c nucucuuu c rccy(ac.acuucu +a-
_u.:. B .cxcrac a cxxcru a(aca.ca u
a nuc:c +a_u.uuy C. a.aa auuc c.u-
qa.cx:uc cqcuuxa c+yx:.a.: +a_u.: u xu-
(ca Oll ., ccy(cuucrc +a c:. uucc.au-
ucu aax.:. Occc ux ac+y.uxc +aaaxcuucc
a(aca.c xc(a.auc.ac c nuc_cuuu (cxy
c.crauu, ua c.c:x ac aca cau(auua,
crauu+caauucrc cc.y(uuc yrcxcaucrc c-
+:ca a cxycuc auuc.c, . nc+ucaax
c +xcuau Oll a cuuy a uccax:ucu
cc.aucac: ua ac+c c.cxc cuqca uxu-
quu :x ua:. c.cx cc cnu.u:u uanu.a-
u. H+ nuc:a cxc(caaxc, +.c a(aca. C. c.-
ac.u. +a .c, +.c +acac.ux xccacrc cu.a, c-
.c:u crauu+caax cauuaccy .a c uu-
.uuy ac.c+y c (cayacu, nccxc +crc acc-
.caauu:u a:n:ruyx u+ cua auuc.a, ccac-
aua nccr u+-nc( c.au. O(ucaccuuc
c nurcacc cy( uanaaux a MB, Iccnyxu-
u Mc(caua +ac.ucc cnc(cxcuuc, u cc.y(-
uu uxuquu :x yacxcu
JO
.
Iaccc.cuuc yrcxcau:x (cx c y+ac.uc
cxxcruu nucau:x +acc(a.cxcu uaucxcc
ac (ccuc.uyc. nuuqun ccc.a+a.cx:ucc-
.u cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a Icccuuccu Uc(ca-
quu. B .c c aca .a ca cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa, ccccuuc nu accc.cuuu yrcxca-
u:x (cx a c.ucacuuu +xcuca crauu+caauu:x
ncc.ynu:x cucaauuu u (cncca c:-
.:x cau(c.cxcu, cuauxa ncxcy ucnc(c-
a+yccc.u cucaauua axrcu.a naac-
a:x u uaac.acuu:x cxauu+ca crauu+cuua
ycc.cuua cxxcruu nucau:x +acc(a.cxcu
nu nuua.uu uu ac(u.a.
Ku(u+ccaa ucccac(cxcuucc.: nuca-
u:x +acc(a.cxcu a naauxax cqcuu (ca+a-
.cx:c.a u a .aux ccucau:x acnccax, a ca
auu:, ccy+ac.uc a ccacacuuu ncc.ynxcuuu,
uccxc(uaa cccua u auuaa uccxc(ucc.:,
ucc(c +a.y(uac. nuua.uc uu cacuua xuc
nuac(u. nuua.u cauc+ucrc ycc.cuua.
9
C.: 7ccmuno 7. Bcx+:a c.aa H+acc.ua
Mc(cauu. 2OOO. 28 aa. ` JO9.
JO
C.: Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu
Mc(cau+. \rcxcaucc (cxc ` 2-89J996.
B. H. Momomun u {. lc+cnacucc.: (cncca c:.:x y+ac.uuca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
74
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Hc ucccucuuc c(uc: cy( nucau:x +ac.aaux
uc.ca-nccccucuaxca ~ cy(cu, ncyc-
ca, cxc(caa.cxcu, a(aca.ca ~ ccacacuc.ac-
aa.: cacc nccccucuax:ucc ac.cc.ac, +.c-
: accr(a :.: a cc. Hucc ncqcccy-
ax:ucc ncac(cuuc xcrc u+ ncc+ucxcuu:x
naacnucuu.cxcu cc+cuc ua ucy(a+y.
Cau(c.cx:c.ac .cy ~ cnaa(a.cx:u:u
ac(u. cxxcruu nucau:x +acc(a.cxcu Bc-
xcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu Mc(caua c. J4 ccu-
.aa 2OO9 rc(a a c.ucacuuu ccu u+ (acua(-
qa.u xuq, cauuac:x a y+ac.uu a ncc.ynucu
crauu+aquu u ccacacuuu ua .cu.cuu
Iccnyxuu Mc(caua .aux u cccc .a-
ux ncc.ynxcuuu
JJ
.
lu crauu+aquu (cncca c:.:x cau-
(c.cxcu uccxc(uc a ccc.ac.c.auu c .cc-
aauuau +. J c.. J \lK IU ccx(a.: c-
_cnu+uauu:c uc: u nuuqun: c(yua-
c(ucrc naaa, a +ac.ucc.u, naac cauuaccrc
+a(aaa.: acncc: aucuuu: cau(c.cxa a cc-
c.ac.c.auu c n. d +. J c.. 6 Kcuacuquu
c +a_u.c naa +cxcaca u ccucau:x cacc(.
lca+a.cx:uc a caa+u c .u cacuuc u+
na.uu lacncuccrc Cy(a nc naaa +c-
xcaca nc (cxy Kac.cacu nc.ua Hu(c-
xau(ca c. 2O ucaa J989 rc(a. B uc :xc
nu+uauc, +.c nurcac uc cc. :.: ccuc-
aau ua nca+auuax aucuuu:x cau(c.cxcu, (au-
u:x a xc(c nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
u crxaacuu:x a cy(cuc +acc(auuu c+ uc-
nccc(c.acuucrc (cncca .aux cau(c.cxcu
J2
.
Ha ccucaauuu u+xccuucrc, c y+c.c .c-
caauuu c.a.cu 74 u 75 \lK IU, cnc(c-
xa_ux u.cuu (cnyc.ucc.u (ca+a.cx:c.a,
ncxarac, +.c cc+ua+cuu:c naaca:c ncxc-
: caxu+aquu a c(cax:u:x cy(ax c_cu
uc(uquu ncxccuuu +. J c.. JJ u +. 5
c.. 278 \lK IU .cy. uc+ac(xu.cx:-
ucrc cacuua ny.c aucccuua ccc.ac.c.ay-
_ux (cncxucuuu u u+cucuuu a (cuc.ay_cc
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu.
Orauu+aqucuu:c ccnua.ua, uanaaxcu-
u:c ua cccnc+cuuc c(cax:u:x cy(ca c-
_cu uc(uquu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu a-
.cuax:uc-.cxuu+ccuu u uu:u cc(c.aau,
nc+acxa_uu ccy_cc.axa.: .aucxaqu nc-
a+auuu c:.crc y+ac.uua yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, cuc (c.ax:uc +anxauu-
caa.: u ccy_cc.au.: .cx:c nccxc cc+(auua
uccxc(ucu (xa .crc ncqcccyax:ucu nc-
qc(y:.
acuc(a.cx: a .c aauc acnccc ca-
+au ncaau.: ac.ccnucc.: u y(cc.:. Cy-
_cc.ay_uc cxxu+uu yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
u:x uc, cccnc+uaa_ux c+cnacucc.: nu
(cnccc a cy(c c:.:x y+ac.uuca yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, uc cncccc.ay.
cucaauu c(uucu u c.aux:ucu cy(c-
ucu na.uu a crucuax Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu.
\cc.uc a caa+u c .u acncuu.: cxc-
aa uc.a B. \x:aucaa-^cuuua (a c.a.:c
O (acuuc" nc(+uucuuu u +acuucc.u):
lc.: xu a:ccccuc a .c a+rxa(c, +.c +a-
cuucc.: uc cc. :.: axycaa u a+au-
caa, a (cxua :.: c(uuaa acccccuucaa'..
JJ
.
Ha +aac accca naaccy(ua xcu. ccx(c-
uuc cuc.u.yqucuu:x naa u cacc( ra(au,
nc.cy c.uaucc cccnc+cuuc c+cnacuc-
c.u ncqccca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ~ aauaa
raau.ua caxu+aquu cua +acuucc.u.
JJ
C.: Axua Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxuu
Mc(caua. \rcxcaucc (cxc ` 2-J2OO9.
J2
C.: lacncucuu Cy( nc naaa +cxcaca.
H+auu:c cacuua. M., 2OOO. 1. 2.
JJ
cnun B. H. O rccy(ac.ac u naac Cc-
uu ncu+ac(cuuu u (cycu.ca: B 2 .. M., J958.
1. 2. C. 72O.
75
Hu (xa crc uc ccc., +.c a cuqc XX ~ ua+axc XXl aca.
a aax a+au.ua u na.u+cccu caxu+aquu u(cu accc.auc-
au.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua a Icccuu ncaauxac: uccxc(ucc.:
nuaxca.: c_cc.acuucc.:, cc+(aa ac(u.aqu nu cy(ax u
naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauax u+ cc nc(c.aau.cxcu, c.c:c ccrxu
: ca+:aa.: ncc_: a a+cacuuu cuxu.ca nccc(c.ac
a+ucrc c(a c(uaquu. A .ac a+xu+u:x cncquaxuc.ca, cnc-
ccu:x a:c.ynu.: a cxu nuuu.cxcu c(y xuqc, nuaxca-
c: yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u u nc.cncaau
J
.
lcqccc a+au.ua u(cu accc.aucau.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua
a Icccuu ncacx a ucccx:c .anca u (c cax:ucrc aac(cuua
crc xccu.ca a naacnucuu.cx:uy na.uy nc yrcxcau:
(cxa cc.axcc: ccacc ucucrc.
Bccc.aucau.cx:ucc naaccy(uc ~ .c c_cc ncua.uc, ax-
+a_cc a cca a cncquu+cccc accc.cuuc yrcxcau:x (cx
a aax acuax:ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, .a u auc-
cy(cucc a+cacuuc yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca
(c(uaqua), r(c xuqc, ccacauaau ncc.ynxcuuc,
aaxac.ca ccacacuucxc.uuu.
Mc(uaqua nc yrcxcau: (cxa aaxac.ca xc-
cu.c accc.aucau.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua, nccc(c.ac
c.ccrc (cc.urac.ca ycccuuc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
(oc |cc }cccnoo), uuauccaaa cucua u c.uaucc accc.a-
ucaxcuuc uayacuu:x naa nc.cncaacrc.
Kaca: ccucaauua aac(cuua u .cu(cuquu (ax:ucuacrc a+-
au.ua c(uaquu nc yrcxcau: (cxa'
Bc-nca:x, c(ua.uau:c nuc: uc uca: u a.uauc ucncx:-
+y.ca a c.auau ana(a, ,ax:ucrc Bcc.ca, .a u xu+xc-
a_uu c.auau CHl; ac-a.c:x, xccu.: accc.aucau.cx:-
ucrc naaccy(ua yc cxcc (cca.a xc. ycncauc nucua.ca
a uaacu c.auc nc yrcxcau: (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux.
apun Bnapumupouna Mavuuna,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
npenoaaaeru xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
Open6yprcxoro rocyapcaennoro
ynnaepcnea
,. B. Momnuuo
Mcnaunn u yroxounom npoucccc -
ronucnunaxrnan qopma unccyc6noro
paspcmcnnn yroxouno-npauour cnopou
J
lcooeo A. H. lc u.cra cy(cuc-naacacu cc: Icccuu
Icc. cy(:a. 2OO7. ` J. C. 6.
76
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Bac(cuuc a cccuuccc yrcxcaucc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.ac c ccu.a nuua.ua \lK IU xc-
cu.ca (crcacucrc naaccy(ua ~ cuacu-
quax:ucu c: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa
(rx. 4O \lK) ~ +axcuxc ccucay (ax:ucu-
acrc a+au.ua .aux c (ccy(cucrc, cy-
(cucrc u auccy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, a c-
.c:x (crcac c.ccu cauucuua u +a_u.:
cccnc+uaac. cax:uy u cccuay caxu-
+aqu naa nc(cy(ucrc u nc.cncaacrc
2
.
Occ:u nca(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:-
c.aa (rx. 4O \lK) c.ax a.axu+a.cc a+-
au.ua ncuuauua +ac.ucrc ua+axa a +acu-
uc cccucaauucu (ucnc+u.uaucc.u u cuacu-
quax:ucc.u a yrcxcauc ncqcccc, +axcux
nc+u:c ccucaauua cy_cc.acaauua a \lK
cuacuquax:ucu c: cy(cucrc ncu+ac(-
c.aa, a .ac a+au.ua xccu.ca cuacuqu-
ax:ucc.u yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, nu-
ac(a_ux crc ryauu+aquu.
Kcuacuquax:ucc.: a yrcxcauc ncqcc-
cc ~ .c cuc.ca (ucnc+u.uauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:x xccu.ca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa uxu (crcacu:x ncqc(y. S.c cuc.ca
xccu.ca, ccucaauu:x ua (ucnc+u.uau:x
naaax y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa, ccc.aaxa_ux ccucaauua cy_cc.acaa-
uua cuacuquax:ucc.u yrcxcaucrc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa. Qcx: xccu.ca cuacuquax:-
ucc.u aaxac.ca ryauu+aqua yrcxcaucrc nc-
qccca. Mc.c( (cc.ucuua qcxu ~ yc.auca-
xcuuc (crcacu:x c.ucacuuu a aax ny-
xu+ucrc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. B cccc nc-
a(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa (rx. 4O
\lK) aucuu:u cy(au r. Ocuyra a ua-
c.ca_cc aca acca.uaac.ca ccxc 7O "
yrcxcau:x (cx
J
.
Uc(cax:uaa qcxcaaa ncraa Ia+au-
.uc cy(cucu cuc.c: Icccuu ua 2OO7
2OJJ rc(: nc(xcuxa auccc auc(cuuc
a cccuuccc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac nuuu.cx:-
u:x ncqc(y (accc.aucau.cx:ucu c.uquu).
B .c acuc nccxcuaac.ca .cu(cuqua +ac-
uc(a.cxa c.uccu.cx:uc auc(cuua u a+au.ua
uca:x c (ccy(cucrc, cy(cucrc u auccy-
(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, a c.c:x +aaaxcuu:u
c.ccucu cauucuua yrcxcau:u uc cc.
:.: ncxucc.: uxu +ac.u+uc c.c+aau a qc-
xax cxau: naa u cacc( cauuaccrc u nc-
.cncaacrc ua ccucac a+auucu (crcaccuuc-
c.u c.ccu.
B.c: aarc a .c uanaaxcuuu c.axc
aac(cuuc Uc(cax:u: +acuc ` J4J-U
O aucccuuu u+cucuuu a \rcxcau:u c(cc
IU u \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u c(cc IU,
nuua.: lccy(ac.acuucu (ycu 5 uua
2OO9 rc(a, ccccrc nca(a nuua.ua cy(c-
ucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc
ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (rxaaa 4O
J
\lK).
Occ:u nca(c nuua.ua cy(cucrc c-
acuua nu ccrxacuu cauuaccrc c nc(.aa-
xcuu: cy cauucuuc (rx. 4O \lK) +axc-
ux cuacuquax:uy ((crcacuy) cy
cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa, ccc:u nca(c
nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac
acauux ccy (crcacu:x ua+ax ua (ccy-
(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac.
1au ca+c, a uac.ca_cc aca ycc-
cuuc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ncucxc-
(u. +a c+c. nucucuua .ux (ayx uca:x (c-
rcacu:x uuc.u.y.ca, +acnxcuu:x a a+(cxc
X \lK. lcxu ucxc(u.: uc .cx:c u+ cy_c-
c.ay_cu cax:ucc.u, uc u u+ nccnc.ua:
a+au.ua accc.aucau.cx:ucu c.uquu u cxa-
uu.cx:ucrc .una cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxca-
u: (cxa, .c ycxcauc .auc c: a+cac-
uua yrcxcaucrc uca cuc a+(cxu.: cxc(y-
_u ca+c.
l. B +aaucucc.u c. +acnxcuua a +ac-
uc ua:
J) +acnxcuu:c a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
uc +acuc (rx. 4O u rx. 4O
J
\lK);
2) uc+acnxcuu:c a yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:uc +acuc, uc uc_uc ccucaauua :.:
+acnxcuu:u a nccnc.uac ~ c(uaqua
a yrcxcauc ncqcccc.
2
laac nc(cy(ucrc ua cnaac(xuacc u cccu-
acc a+ua.cx:c.ac yrcxcaucrc (cxa, naac nc-
.cncaacrc ua cccuacc accc.aucaxcuuc crc naa.
J
lc c+yx:.a.a cc_cuua cy(cucu na.uu,
ncac(cuucrc Ocuyrcu cxac.u: cy(c +a
2OO8 u ncay ncxcauuy 2OO9 rc(a.
77
ll. B +aaucucc.u c. ncqcccyax:ucu c-
: ua:
J) cuacuquax:u:c c: (ccy(cucrc u
cy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, c.c:c ca+y. cu-
acuquax:uy cy yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa a qcxc. S.c cccaa (cuacuquax:uaa)
ca nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua, nc-
ac(ucrc nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxa-
acuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, u ccc:u nca(c nu-
ua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu (c-
cy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (rxa-
aa 4O
J
\lK), a .ac ccc:u nca(c a:uc-
ccuua cy(cucrc cacuua nu ccrxacuu cau-
uaccrc c cauucuuc (rxaaa 4O \lK);
2) cuacuquax:uy cy auccy(cucrc
a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca (c(u-
aqua).
Hcuuc yc.aucaxcuuc cuacuquax:ucu uc-
.uu: a cnccc caxu+aquu ua+ua+cuua yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa aaxac.ca ccucaauuc
accc.aucau.cx:u:x c a+cacuua yrcxca-
ucrc uca.
C ccu.a, cr(a a cccuucc yrcxcauc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ncaauxca uca:u au( cu-
acuquax:ucu c: accxc(caauua u a+c-
acuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa, c.c: yc.auaaxuaa-
c.ca cuacuquax:uaa uc.uua, a:uccu.ca cu-
acuquax:u:u nurcac u (yruc cuacuquax:-
u:c cacuua cy(a, nc(ycc.cuu:c +acuc,
ncaauxac: ac+cucc.: yccu.: ncu+ac(c.ac
nc (cxy c ncc_: aac(cuua uca:x (crcac-
u:x ncqc(y a a aax yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa, .a u +a crc nc(cxau.
lu aac(cuuu ucacu c: (crcacu:x
ncqc(y (c(uaquu) uccxc(uc y+cc.: .c,
+.c auccy(cuaa ca (cxua uaxc(u.:ca nc(
cnc(cxcuu: cu.cxc crauca yrcxcaucu
c.uquu. Ha uaa a+rxa(, a ncay c+cc(:
.c (cxuc aca.:ca cncquax:ucu nc(rc.ca-
u u ua+ua+cuua ua cx: c(ua.cca. Cnc-
quaxuc.:-c(ua.c: (cxu: (uccuquc-
aa.:ca a +aaucucc.u c. ac+ac.ucu a.crc-
uu xuq, ccacauaaux ncc.ynxcuuc. 1a, c-
(ua.c, a+caa_uu yrcxcauc-naacacu cnc
nc (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuucxc.uux,
(cxcu nu ncxy+cuuu cncquax:ucrc ca+c-
aauua ncuc c_cu, ac+ac.ucu, u+ucucu,
u(u+cccu ncuxcxcruu u ccqucxcruu ca-
+a.cx:uc u+y+a.: nc(arcruy. Mc(ua.c, a+-
caa_uu yrcxcauc-naacacu cnc a c.uc-
acuuu ccacacuucxc.uux, cc. u uc ncxy-
+a.: .crc cncquax:ucrc +uauua.
Mc(uaqua a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.ac ~ .c cccnc+cuuc (crcacu:x (cuacu-
quax:u:x) ua+ax c(y c.ccuau yrcxcauc-
naacacrc cnca; .c ncaaxcuuc (ucnc+u.ua-
ucc.u yrcxcaucrc ncqccca, xarc(aa c.ccu
ac+cuc a+cacuuc cuxu.ucu cu.yaquu
c nuua.uc cuacuquax:ucrc cacuua, a+u-
y_crcca ua yc.aucaxcuuu cuacuquax:ucu
uc.uu:. Kcuacuquax:uaa uc.uua ac auccy(c-
ucu cc a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc
cnca yc.auaaxuaac.ca nu nu+uauuu xuqc,
ccacauaau ncc.ynxcuuc, caccu auu: a .c
c.cc, c.c:u (cc.a.c+cu (xa yc.aucaxcuua
a.a nuucuua c.ccu. A cxc(c.auc (c-
rcacucrc auccy(cucrc ncqccca (cxuc :.:
a+auca:rc(ucc ccrxaacuuc c.ccu cauuc-
uua u +a_u.: u cccuacc accc.aucaxcuuc
naa nc.cncaacrc nucxc:u (xa c.ccu
cauucuua u +a_u.: cncccau.
lu aac(cuuu cuacuquax:ucu c: auc-
cy(cucrc a+cacuua yrcxcaucrc uca c(u-
a.c: (xuqa, c.c:c y(y. +auua.:ca nu-
ucuuc nccc(c.ac (crcacu:x ccnu-
a.uu) cncccu: cau.: a( ncxc, +a.aru-
aa_ux ucra.uau:c ccquax:u:c nccxc(c.aua
ccacacuucrc xuqc ncc.ynxcuua.
Ic(ac.ca +acuccu:u acncc: a +a-
_u.u.: u caxu+caa.: nyxu+ucc ua+axc yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (c-
xa c .aux u cccc .aux ncc.ynxcuuax
nu nucucuuu auccy(cucu c: a+c-
acuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca'
Ha uaa a+rxa(, a .cu ccc nucucuuc
cuacuquax:ucu auccy(cucu c: a+c-
acuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca uc (cxuc
crauu+uaa.:ca ccrxaacuuc c.ccu c.uccu-
.cx:uc ac+c_cuua ac(a nc.cncaacy.
lyxu+u:u uu.ccc y(c. y(caxc.accu u
cu.cx:uc-cxauu.cx:uaa cx: rccy(ac.aa
y(c. caxu+caaua nu ycxcauu ynxa.: a.a-
a a ncx:+y rccy(ac.aa nc auaxcruu c a(u-
uuc.a.uau: ncu+ac(c.ac.
. B. Momuno. Mc(uaqua a ca auccy(cucrc a+cacuua cncca
78
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Mc(uaqua ~ .c auccy(cuaa cuacuqu-
ax:uaa ca na.u+cccu caxu+aquu u(cu
accc.aucau.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua. B .cu caa-
+u :xc a:ca+auc ucuuc, +.c uuc.u.y. nc-
cc(uu+cc.aa (c(uaquu) uc. uccxc(ucc.u
(cxu.: nc c.acxa naaa, au(a cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa, +.c ancxuc ac+cuc +acnxcuuc
a +acuc c_ux naaux, nuuqunca ncqc(y:
c(ua.uaucrc auccy(cucrc a+cacuua na-
aca:x cncca ua ccucac c(uucrc c(cax:uc-
rc +acua. C .u a:ca+:aauuc .y(uc cc-
rxacu.:ca, uc cca nucucuua yrcxcaucrc
+acua c.xu+ac.ca nca:acuucu c.ac.c.acuuc-
c.: (cxucc.u:x xuq +a cy(:y xuqa, ccac-
auaacrc ncc.ynxcuuc, u nc.cncaacrc, nca:-
acuu: auuauuc uaac.acuu: ua+axa
ncu+ac(c.aa c.(cx:u:x ncqcccyax:u:x nc-
qc(y, ccc: y+c.c ncuxcxcruu xu+ucc.u
ua+aauu:x cy.c.ca ncqccca. lcxcc .crc,
yr ccnua.uu nc auc(cuu auccy(c-
u:x c a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naaca:x
cncca cxcc cxccu u c.ccu.
Cnaac(xuac ua .c. c+c. ucuuc l. A. Ka-
auua: lcxarac, +.c c(uu u+ ncacc+cc(-
u:x ccnua.uu a (cxc caxu+aquu Icccucu
cccu(aquu Kcu.c.a uuuc.ca rccy-
(ac.a ~ +xcuca Ccac.a lacn: c nucuc-
uuu c(uaquu a aax yrcxcaucu c.uquu,
Ocucau:x nuuqunca nucucuua ncra
cc.u.yqucuucrc naaccy(ua a acnccax yrc-
xcaucrc naaccy(ua... crxc : c.a.: nuua-
.uc c(cax:ucu qcxcacu ncra: auc(c-
uua u(cu accc.aucau.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua
a ccy yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. B ya-
+auuc ncrauc (cycu.c crxu :.:
c.acu: cuqcnqua, ccucau:c .an:, c:
u ycxcaua auc(cuua (auucrc uuc.u.y.a a +a-
cuc(a.cx:c.ac Icccuuccu Uc(caquu
4
.
U.c acac.ca c.acuua auccy(cucu c-
: a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca
a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
Icccuu, .c +(cc: uccxc(uc c.aa.: uc nc-
qccc c(uaquu, a .c+u crc ccnuccucacuua
c uc_uuca a +acuc yrcxcauc-ncqcccy-
ax:u:u .anau, uuc.u.y.au u ncqc(ya-
u. B a+cc.ac ua+ax:ucrc nuca nc(xa-
rac cxc(y_cc.
lu ncac(cuuu caauu.cx:ucrc auaxu+a
rxaa: 4O \lK u auca: aac(cuucu rxaa: 4O
J
\lK uc.y(uc +ac.u.:, +.c (cc.ucuuc
(crcaccuucc.cu nc ccrxaacuua c.ccu nc-
ucxc(u. ua accx .anax ccccrc nca(a cy-
(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa. Kcuc.a.aqua cu-
acuquu cy(c ncucxc(u. ua nc.acuuu acc-
rc ncqccca cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa u +a-
acaac.ca cc +acnxcuuc nu a:ucccuuu
u.crcacrc cacuua nc (cxy. acnxcuuc cu-
acuquu c.ccu nccxcuaac.ca a ccc.ac.c.ay-
_ux ca+auucc.ax cy(a. lc.cy a cxy+ac,
cr(a nu nucucuuu c(ua.uaucrc cnccca
a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naaca:x cncca, c.c-
:u :x ucncx:+caau c.ccuau (c ua+axa
.ana cy(cucrc ncu+ac(c.aa, c.ccu: uc
nuxc(a. a+auucy ccrxaacuu, qcxcccc-
a+uc y(c. a+cau.: yrcxcaucc (cxc a ccc-
c nca(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa c a:-
ucccuuc cauuu.cx:ucrc nurcaca cc cuu-
cuuc uaa+auua a nca(c, ya+auuc a rxaac
4O
J
\lK.
B +ax+cuuc ua(c ca+a.:, +.c (c aac(c-
uua u ycncaucrc nucucuua auccy(cucu
c: a+cacuua yrcxcauc-naacacrc cnca
a qcxax ycccuua yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa ncu(c. c_c ucaxc accuu, uc nc(nc-
c:xu (xa .crc cc+(au: u, y+u.:aaa cn:.
uaaux +aycu:x cxxcr u cu.axu.c. uc-
rcuaqucuax:ucrc cccuuccrc rccy(ac.aa, :
cc cc+(a.: uauxy+auu aauau. ycccuua
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nu c(ucaccu-
ucu +a_u.c naa nc.cncaacrc u xuqa, ccac-
auaacrc ncc.ynxcuuc.
4
lo+un E. A. Mc(uaqucuu:c ncqc(y:
a ccaccuuc yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac Icc-
cuu: uccxc(ucc.: u ucu+cucc.:l \rcxcaucc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac. 2OO9. ` 2. C. J2.
79
Ccrxacuc uc a+(cxa J4 \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c-
(cca IU
J
, c(uu u+ acnc.ca c.a(uu ucncxucuua nurcaca
aaxac.ca (ca.cx:ucc.: y+c(cuuu u crauca, ua c.c:c ac+-
xccuc ucncxucuuc uaa+auua. lc c:cxy +. J c.. J \rcxcauc-
ucncxuu.cx:ucrc c(cca IU
2
uca.uauaa crxacu.aqua (c-
a.cx:ucc.u ya+auucrc au(a crauca rccy(ac.acuucu axac.u
ucc. cacuu qcxau ucnaaxcuuc ccy(cuu:x u nc(ync(c-
uuc ccacacuua uca:x ncc.ynxcuuu a ccy(cuu:u, .a u
uu:u xuqau.
lu .c c.. JO \HK IU a a+cc.ac ccuca naacacrc
ncxccuua xuq, c.:aa_ux uaa+auuc a Icccuuccu Uc(ca-
quu, +acnxac. raau.uu cccnc+cuua +acuucc.u nucucuua
cc(c.a ucnaaxcuua a c.ucacuuu (auucu a.crcuu xuq, ux
naacacu +a_u.: u xu+ucu c+cnacucc.u nu ucncxucuuu uaa-
+auuu.
O.c+cuu:c ccccuucc.u nc+acxa. +ax+u.:,
+.c ncqcccyax:uaa (ca.cx:ucc.:, uanaaxcuuaa ua
u+cxu+cuuc nc(c+caac:x, cauuac:x a ccac-
acuuu ncc.ynxcuuu (.c cc.: yrcxcaucc nccxc(c-
aauuc, cnc(cxaccc n. 55 c.. 5 \lK IU), xc.a u
uc c.uccu.ca qcxa yrcxcauc-ucncxuu.cx:ucu (c-
a.cx:ucc.u, c(uac cc. nc(c.aaxa.: cccu cncquu+cccc cc
uanaaxcuuc a cxy+aax, yc.aucaxcuu:x, a +ac.ucc.u, +. J c.. J46
\lK IU.
,cuc.au.cx:uc, +. J u n. 5. +. 2 c.. J57 \lK IU nc(yca.-
uaa. ncxucc+ua ua+ax:uuca y+c(cuuu u crauca yrcxca-
uc-ucncxuu.cx:ucu cuc.c: nc ac+y(cuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa u
ncu+ac(c.ay ucc.xcu:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu nu yc.auca-
xcuuu nu+uaca ncc.ynxcuuu, ccacacuu:x nc.ua yc.auca-
xcuucrc nca(a ucccuua cxy: cc.y(uuau ccc.ac.c.ay-
_ux y+c(cuuu u crauca, a aauc ncc.ynxcuuu, ccacacuu:x
a acncxccuuu ccc.ac.c.ay_ux y+c(cuuu u crauca.
Knun fennapueuna Houuuoua,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
capunn npenoaaaeru xaqepu yroroanoro
n yroroano-ncnornnerunoro npaaa
Knpoacxoro qnrnara Axaeunn OCHP Poccnn
R. I. Hoeunoeo
Oco6cnnocrn yroxouno-npoucccyaxrno
cnrcxrnocrn u ornomcnnn
ocyncnnr r xnmcnnr cuo6or
J
,axcc ~ \lK IU.
2
,axcc ~ \HK IU.
8O
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Kcc .crc, a ccc.ac.c.auu c +. 2 c.. 26
+acua O y+c(cuuax u crauax, ucncxua-
_ux yrcxcau:c uaa+auua a au(c xuacuua
cacc(: +a cc.y(uuau yrcxcauc-ucncx-
uu.cx:ucu cuc.c: Icccuuccu Uc(caquu,
uc+aaucuc c. +auuac:x uu (cxucc.cu,
+acnxac.ca ca+auucc.: nc nucucuu c,
uccxc(u:x (xa nc(c.aa_cuua, nccc+cuua
naacuayacuuu u +a(cauua xuq, nc(c+c-
aac:x a ux ccacacuuu. B n. JJ c.. J4 ua-
+aauucrc +acua cuc.u+uyc.ca naac a(-
uuuc.aquu y+c(cuuu, ucncxua_ux yrcxca-
u:c uaa+auua, ncu+ac(u.: yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:u:c (cuc.aua a nc(ycc.cuu:x +ac-
uc nca(c u cxy+aax.
Ba( xu cuc cncacruy.: .c+y +cuua
U. C. lauua, ncxara_crc, +.c ucccc-
ucaauu:c c.a+: a ac+y(cuuu yrcxcau:x
(cx, xa.cu.uaa ncc.ynucc.: cc+(a. (xa cn-
c(cxcuucrc cxu+cc.aa xuq ac+cucc.: u+-
ca.: +acxycuucrc uaa+auua, a y x(cu
c au.uc_cc.acuucu uanaaxcuucc.: xu+uc-
c.u cc. ac+uuuy.: yaccuucc.: a c+uaa-
+auucc.u ccacacuua ncc.ynxcuuu
J
.
Auaxcru+ucu nc+uquu nu(cuaac.ca,
a +ac.ucc.u, u l. A. Uccxca, c.c+a_uu,
+.c nc(ync(u.cx:ucc +ua+cuuc uaa+auua
cycxaaxuaac.ca uc crc cc.ccc.:, a crc
ucc.aa.ucc.:
4
.
O(uac, a cxc(yc. u+ naacnucuu.cx:-
ucu na.uu, cc+ua+cuu: uca.uau:
nc(nucauua u .ccc.u+ccu ncc.yxa.a
nu(ac.ca uc(cc.a.c+ucc +ua+cuuc, ncccx:y
c+cau(uc, +.c ua(xca_uc ua(+c u cu.cx:
+a ncac(cuuc ccy(cuu:x xuacuu cac-
c(: (cxu: ucx+a.: a.: ccacacuua
ncc.ynxcuuu xuqau ya+auucu a.crcuu
a ncuc( c.:aauua uu uaa+auua. B:aaxc-
uuc nu+uaca ncc.ynxcuuu u ncu+ac(c.ac
uccxc(u:x ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu a c.a-
(uu ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa ac+xarac.-
ca ua cnc.cu.u:c crau: yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa, (ca.cx:ucc.: c.c:x, c y+c.c
cuucu cncquuu ucnaau.cx:u:x y+c-
(cuuu cy_cc.acuuc ycxcuac.ca, a a c.(cx:-
u:x cxc(c.acuu:x cu.yaquax uc ccncac(a-
c.ca uccxc(u:u cau cc(cuc.aua cc
c.ccu: a(uuuc.aquu y+c(cuuu u cra-
uca yrcxcauc-ucncxuu.cx:ucu cuc.c:.
Mc(y .c uc cxy+auuc ncua.uc ucnaa-
xcuuc cnc(cxac.ca a .cxcac cxcaac a
yxy+acuuc, u+cucuuc, ucnaaxa_cc +.c-
uuy(:
5
. Orau: nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc-
(caauua u y+c(cuua, ucncxua_uc uaa+a-
uuc, aaxaac: xccu.au cuc.c: naaccxa-
uu.cx:u:x crauca Icccuu, caxu+y. c(uucc
uanaaxcuuc nyxu+uc-naaca:x uu.cccca,
cycxcaxcuu:x ua+ua+cuuc c.c+cc.acuucrc
yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. B caa+u c .u
au(u.ca qcxcccca+u: nuac(cuuc c.(cx:-
u:x yrcxcauc-ucncxuu.cx:u:x uc a ccc.-
ac.c.auc c .ccaauuau \lK IU nccc(-
c.ac ac+cucrc (cncxucuua +. J c.. J \HK
IU .acu qcx:, a cc(cuc.auc craua yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a u+cxu+cuuu xuq,
auucau:x a ccacacuuu uca:x ncc.ynxcuuu
a ncuc( c.:aauua uaa+auua.
Cxc(yc. y.c+uu.:, +.c ya+auu:u au( nc-
qcccyax:ucrc cc(cuc.aua nucuac.ca a (ca-
.cx:ucc.u y+c(cuuu yrcxcauc-ucncxuu.cx:-
ucu cuc.c:. Ka naauxc, nc axca, ua-
naaxac: ccy(cuu:u ua(+ua_cy
ncycy a caa+u ncc.ynxcuuau, ccacacu-
u:u a c.ucacuuu ux (yruu xuqau, c.:-
aa_uu uaa+auuc, crau (c+uauua a xuqc
ua+ua+accrc cc.y(uua cnca.uaucrc nc(-
a+(cxcuua ccy_cc.axac. ccc.ac.c.ay_uc
ncacc+u:c (cuc.aua. B ucx+u.cx:u:x
cxy+aax (uanuc, nu cuaycuuu nu+ua-
ca ncc.ynxcuua a uc+ucc aca cy.c uxu
a uu:x cu.yaquax), .cy_ux uc+ac(xu.cx:-
ucrc +acnxcuua ncacua+ax:u:x (ca+a.cx:c.a,
ncu+ac(a.ca ccc. cc.a ncucacc.aua u cc-
au(c.cx:c.acaauuc. O(uc u+ ncqcccyax:u:x
J
lo+nu 0. C. Hcc.aa.ucc.: uaa+auua
XX\ll c.c+( KlCC u ycnxcuuc +acuucc.u
u naacnca(a. M. J987. C. J44.
4
0cc:oe H. A. Mcxauu+ yrcxcauc-naacacu
cxau: (ccucau:c c.c(cxcru+ccuc ncxc:).
M., J992. C. 69.
5
O+c:oe C. H.. Lec{oeo H. K. 1cxca:u
cxcaa: ycccrc a+:a. M., J999. C. 254.
8J
ucccc.ac.c.auu, (cnycac:x nu .c, cac-
(u.ca ya+auu a nc.ccxc ccc.a cc-
.y(uuca cnca.uaucrc nc(a+(cxcuua a a-
+cc.ac ncua.:x. lc+ycxcauc, +. J c.. J7O \lK
IU cc(cu. +c.y crxacu.aqu ccucaa-
uuu (xa ncac(cuua cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua
c+ y+ac.ua ncua.:x. O(uac uca.uaucc (c-
ncxucuuc .acrc au(a cxy+aca (uanuc, cc:x-
cu ua cc.ca.cx:c.aa, ncc+ucxcuu:c a c..
J57 \lK IU), crxc : cccnc+u.: cxcc
.c+ucc ccx(cuuc .ccaauuu ncqcccyax:-
ucu c:, ucx+u.: (cnycac:c uayac-
uua uc \lK IU u ncxy+cuuc uc(cnyc.u-
:x (ca+a.cx:c.a.
Auaxu+uya c.(cx:u:c acnc.: yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, ccy_cc.axaccu
a c.ucacuuu ccy(cuu:x xuacuu cacc-
(: u ccacauaaux ucacc ncc.ynxcuuc a nc-
uc( c.:aauua uaa+auua, ucx:+a uc c.c.u.:
ncqcccyax:u:c ccccuucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa nc
yrcxcau: (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux.
Occnc+cuuc naa u +acuu:x uu.cccca
(auucrc cy.c.a yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa ccncac(ac.ca ca+a.cx:u: y+ac.uc
+acuucrc nc(c.aau.cxa, (cnycaccrc c c-
cu.a ncacrc (cncca ucccacacuucxc.ucrc
a a+cc.ac nc(c+caaccrc uxu cauuaccrc.
Cxcuaaucca ccccuucc.u naacnucucuua,
ccc.ca_uc a nuaxc+cuuu a a+cc.ac +acu-
ucrc nc(c.aau.cxa cc.y(uua u+ +ucxa a(-
uuuc.aquu ucnaau.cx:ucrc y+c(cuua,
a c.cc c.:aac. uaa+auuc ucccacacuuc-
xc.uuu ccy(cuu:u, uc c.ac+a. .ccaauua
n. J2 c.. 5 \lK IU.
B .c c aca yc.aucaxcuu:u c.. 77
J
\HK IU nca(c nccac(cuua ccy(cuu:x
xuacuu cacc(: u+ ucnaau.cx:ucrc y+-
c(cuua a cxc(c.acuu:u u+cxa.c (xa y+ac-
.ua a cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auax uxu cy(cuc
a+ua.cx:c.ac nc(c.aaxac.ca ac+cu:
xua: nu ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa a c.-
ucacuuu cuc.ucrc xuqa. B uu:x cxy+aax
(xa yc.aucaxcuua cc.ca.cx:c.a, nc(xca_ux
(ca+:aauu, u a qcxax cccucaauua ncc.a-
ucaxcuua c nccac(c ccy(cuucrc a cxc(c.acu-
u:u u+cxa.c u+ua+ax:uc .cyc.ca ncac(c-
uuc (cnccca, a .c +ucxc u ucccacacuuc-
xc.ucrc nc(c+caaccrc, a caa+u c +c cucaa
ac+uuac. acncc c ccccuucc.ax acaxc+cuua
+acuucrc nc(c.aau.cxa. \c.aucuuc cc+ua-
+cuu:x nc.uacc+uu nc(c.aaxac.ca ac+c-
u: nu +acuc(a.cx:uc y.c+ucuuu c.. 426
\lK IU c.uccu.cx:uc nca(a y+ac.ua +a-
cuucrc nc(c.aau.cxa ucccacacuucxc.ucrc
nc(c+caaccrc, c.:aa_crc uaa+auuc a au(c
xuacuua cacc(:.
luac(cuu:c ncxcu:c ccccuucc.u
aaxa.ca xua: c.(cx:u:u ncaaxcuuau
uc.c+ucc.u a uca.uaucu crxacu.aquu na-
acc.ucacuuu, c.c:c ac+uua. nu ncccc-
+cuuu yrcxcauc-ucncxuu.cx:ucu u yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu cc naacnucucuua. ly-
(y+u a+auccycxcaxcuu:u u a+aucncuu-
a_uu, (auu:c au(: rccy(ac.acuucu u-
(u+cccu (ca.cx:ucc.u cnc(cxa. a+xu+u:c
.an: yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, +.c nc(-
ncxarac. uccxc(ucc.: ncc.cauucrc ccacacu-
c.acaauua ux uca.uaucu ccuca: u cc(u-
uaquu uanaaxcuuu a+auc(cuc.aua.
K. l. Hoeuoeo. \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa (ca.cx:ucc.: a c.ucacuuu ccy(cuu:x
82
lcrc(uc nc a+xu+u: nu+uua a crau: auy.cuuux
(cx ncc.ynac. +ua+u.cx:ucc cxu+cc.ac +aaaxcuuu ra(au
c ncnac xu+ux c(c.acuuuca, cc.y(uuca nc(nua.uu u
u, c ucccacacuucxc.uux, +:c cc.cuaxc(cuuc ucu+acc.uc
c(u.cxa, u .. (. Auaxcru+uaa a.uua u nc cuaycuu .y-
nca ra(au, +:u (auu:c ucu+acc.u: naaccxauu.cx:u: cra-
ua ua ccu. ux cuaycuua (xuqa c+ cnc(cxcuucrc cc.a
u.cx:c.aa, cacyuuq: u (.).
C.a.uc.ua nca+:aac., +.c c 2OOJ rc(a a Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu c.c+ac.ca cuucuuc c_crc cxu+cc.aa a+:cuaac-
:x xuq, a c.xu+uc c. ncc.cauucrc cc.a a nc(:(y_uc (cca.u-
xc.ua. \acxu+cuuc ca_cuuu uax(ac.ca xua: a c+:cc
ra(au, y.a.uaaux c(c.acuu:c caa+u.
Bcc.c c .c accua xuq, c.c:c a+:cuaa-
.ca a c+ acc.u ncnaaauc, aaxac.ca cxcccax:-
u:, +.c .cyc. ncc.cauu:x axccuuu a ccyc:
uay+ucrc, uuauccacrc, a.cuax:uc-.cxuu+cccrc u
a(cacrc cccnc+cuua (auucu xuuuu ac.: OB,.
Icaxu+aqua +a(a+ c+:cucu ac.: crauca
auy.cuuux (cx nc (auucy uanaaxcuu cnca.uauc-cxycucu
(ca.cx:ucc.u cy_cc.acuuc ccxcuac.ca ncccuau a yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac, a .ac ac+ccauu +a ncc-
xc(uuc rc(: uraqucuu:u nc.cau uaccxcuua u+ c.au CHl
u (yrux ccnc(cx:u:x rccy(ac.a, c.c:c caa+au: c cx:au
:uc .y(a u ucccacacuc.ac +acuc(a.cx:c.aa Icccuu
a ccc uraquu. Oc.aaxac. cxa.: xy+acrc u c+:cucc +a-
cuc(a.cx:c.ac Icccuu, c.ccc uc nc.cncxc cy_cc.acuu:x
u+cucuuu c J99J rc(a.
Bcncc: crauu+aquu accxc(caauua ncc.ynxcuuu nc a-
.a yuuc.a, caa+auu:x c c+acc.u: uc+c+ucacuuc ra(au,
ccxaua. cac a.yax:ucc.:. hc.aau ncc.ynuuca +a+a-
c.y c.aucaa.ca axa(cx:q: .aucnc.u:x cc(c.a, xuqa, acaxc-
+cuu:c a ccc. uc(auucc.u, ucccacacuucxc.uuc, uucc.au-
u:c ra(auc, cuc(c: u nc(nuuua.cxu, acncaa_ucca
Hropu Bapumouun Orypou,
uanop anypennen cry6u,
concxaeru Canx-Peep6yprcxoro
ynnaepcnea HB Poccnn,
npenoaaaeru Bororocxoro nncnya
npaaa n axonounxn OCHP Poccnn
H. B. 0:ypoe
Hpo6xcmr uos6yncnnn yroxounr cx
n npouccnnn rcncprnr nccxcouann
u ornomcnnn 6cs uccrn nponaumn xnu
n nconosnannr rpynou
8J
ynu:u uuaucca:u cc(c.aau, u a(
(yrux a.crcuu xuq.
a+ac.y nu nuua.uu u accc.cuuu
+aaaxcuuu c c+:cc ra(au u ncac(cuuu
ncacu nc ncau+u: a.cuaxa uc ya-
+:aa.ca acc cc.ca.cx:c.aa u ac+cu:c
nu+uu: uc+c+ucacuua +cxcaca. Ha auuux
c+:cu:x .anax (cnyca.ca cc:c+u:c
ncc+c.: a nuua.uu ncqcccyax:u:x cac-
uuu, c.c+ac.ca (yxucaauuc c+:cu:x (cx
u (cx cnca.uaucrc y+c.a. Bcc .c nuac(u.
.cy, +.c yrcxcau:c (cxa nc .au a.cua-
xa ac+y(a.ca uccaccaccuuc u (arc-
qcuucc (xa cnaccuua +cxcaca aca a a(c
cxy+aca cc. :.: nc.cauc. B c:+u:x
cu.yaquax : na.u+ccu uc acca.uaac
auc+anucc.: u ccnu+uuucc.: uc+c+ucacuua
a cy_cc.acuu:c nu+uau ncc.ynxcuua.
lcac(cuucc auc.ucaauuc cc.y(uuca
yrcxcaucrc c+:ca, +:a ccucauaa (ca.cx:ucc.:
uanaaxcua ua c+:c c+ acc.u ncnaaaux
ra(au u cnc+uauuc .ynca, nca+axc, +.c
ya+auua c(c.acuuuca, cccxyuaqca, +uac-
:x ua c.cy.c.auc (auu:x c uaccuuu +cxc-
aca ycxa.: uxu c:.: c. c(c.acuuuca nu-
+uu: caccrc c..c+(a, ua c.cy.c.auc +acxcaa-
uua, c.ccc cc. cycxcau.: cccncc.u-
uy cc.: uxu nc.c naa.u, ua cuayc-
uuc nc cc.y u.cx:c.aa uxu ac.: xu+u:x
(cycu.ca ncnaaacrc, ac_cu, (cucu:x
cc(c.a ~ a nc(aaxa_c cx:auuc.ac cxy-
+aca uc aaxa.ca yc(u.cx:u:u (xa crauca
ncya.y: a a+cc.ac ccucaauuu (xa ac+-
y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa.
la.ua nca+:aac., +.c cc.y(uuu yrc-
xcaucrc c+:ca nc(cx:aa. uc cu:ay
ac.y a aax c+:cucrc (cxa, +c cxc(c-
aa.cxu u (c+uaaa.cxu ~ nc yrcxcaucy. O(-
uac ncac(u:c c+:cu:c u cnca.uau:c
ccnua.ua c+ ccc.ac.c.ay_crc ncqcccy-
ax:ucrc +acnxcuua uc accr(a a (ax:ucuac
cry. :.: nu+uau: a (ca+a.cx:c.aa.
B ccc.ac.c.auu cc c.a.:cu 4O \rcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucrc c(cca Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu craua (c+uauua c.ucca.ca crau:
auy.cuuux (cx Icccuuccu Uc(caquu... ua-
(cxcuu:c a ccc.ac.c.auu c c(cax:u: +a-
cuc ncxucc+uau nc ccy_cc.axcuu cnc-
a.uauc-c+:cucu (ca.cx:ucc.u. Ha uux
a ccc.ac.c.auu c n. 2 +. 2 c.. 4O \lK IU
ac+xarac.ca a:ncxucuuc ucc.xcu:x cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu nc yrcxcau: (cxa, nc
c.c: ncu+ac(c.ac nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(-
c.aua ca+a.cx:uc, ~ a nca(c, yc.aucaxcu-
uc c.. J57 uac.ca_crc Kc(cca.
B ccc.ac.c.auu c n. J9 c.. 5 \lK uc-
c.xcu: cxc(c.acuu: (cuc.aua c.ucca.-
ca (cuc.aua, ccy_cc.axac:c crauc (c+-
uauua nccxc ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa, nc
c.ccy ncu+ac(c.ac nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(-
c.aua ca+a.cx:uc, a qcxax cuaycuua u
ucaquu cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua, a .ac (c-
a+a.cx:c.a, .cy_ux uc+ac(xu.cx:ucrc
+acnxcuua, u+.a.ua u uccxc(caauua. 1au
ca+c, cccu(yc.ca ncac(cuuc ucc.xc-
u:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu, ccxu cc.: ccuc-
aauuc ncxara.:, +.c ncc(xcuuc c crc ncac-
(cuuc ncaxc+c. uc+c+ucacuuc, nc+y, y.a.y uxu
ax:cuuaqu (ca+a.cx:c.a +auu.ccccaau-
u:u y+ac.uuau yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
J
.
H : yc(cu:, +.c cxauu+: ncac(c-
uua ncacu nc y:axcuu: yuuc.aa u
a.a c+acc.ucrc uc+c+ucacuua ra(au
(cxu: :.: ncqcccyax:uc a+auccaa+au:,
a c.a.yc cc.y(uuca yrcxcaucrc c+:ca, ccy-
_cc.axa_ux ac.y a (auuc uanaaxcuuu,
uccxc(uc nuaaua.: (ca.cx:ucc.u (c+ua-
aa.cxa. B nc(.ac(cuuc .crc nccccc
^. B. Buuuquu nuac(u. +. 2 c.. J7J \lK
Iccnyxuu lcxayc:, c.caa a+caac. nc-
ac(cuuc cy(cucu cnc.u+: (c ac+y(c-
uua yrcxcaucrc (cxa
2
.
lc cxcuaacuca na.uc u+-+a ucnc-
qcccyax:ucrc cua accxc(caauua ucncx:+c-
aa.: a.cuax: c+:cucrc (cxa a yrcxcauc
(cxc na.u+ccu ucac+cuc, a u ucac+cuc
J
Cnn C. lcua.uc u cuc.ca ucc.xcu:x cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu \rcxcaucc naac. 2OO7.
` 4.
2
Bunuquu . B. Icrxacu.aqua cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu, ncac(u:x (c ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc
(cxa, uy(ac.ca a ccacacuc.acaauuu [Sxc.cu.
ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l||:library.slu.rudlJ
viaizOOJ.dl.
H. B. O:qoe. lcxc: ac+y(cuua yrcxcau:x (cx a c.ucacuuu c+ acc.u ncnaaaux
84
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ux cncucucaa.: (accc.aucau.: nc cc)
a ncqcccyax:uc cuc
J
.
B ncqcccc yc.aucaxcuua cc.cuaxc(c-
uua c+ acc.u ncnaaacrc u cnc+uauua ucu+-
acc.u:x .ynca uc accr(a y(ac.ca ncxy+u.:
cxac:u c+yx:.a. (ac nu uaxu+uu u(cu-
.uuquy_cu uucaquu. lc.cy cc.y(-
uua yrcxcaucrc c+:ca, ccy_cc.axa_u
ncacy (auucu a.crcuu a.cuaxca, nu-
xc(u.ca nucra.: ycxyra nccccucuaxca
a .cu uxu uucu cxac.u +uauuu. Ocucaucu
ccu ucncx:+caauua .aux +uauuu aaxac.-
ca cy(cuaa cnc.u+a ~ ncqcccyax:ucc
(cuc.auc, ccc.ca_cc u+ ncac(cuua uccxc(caa-
uuu u (a+u +ax+cuua cnc.c nc acnc-
ca, a+cacuuc c.c:x .cyc. cncquax:-
u:x +uauuu a cxac.u uayu, .cxuuu, ucycc.-
aa u c.c:c ncc.aaxcu: ncc( cnc.c
cy(c, cy(:cu, crauc (c+uauua, xuqc, ncu+-
ac(a_u (c+uauuc, cxc(caa.cxc a qcxax yc-
.aucaxcuua cc.ca.cx:c.a, nc(xca_ux (ca-
+:aauu nc cuc.ucy (cxy
4
. lu+c (au-
ucc ncqcccyax:ucc (cuc.auc (cxuc ua+u-
ua.:ca c a:ucccuua ncc.aucaxcuua c crc nc-
u+ac(c.ac, c.ccc ucc. cx:acc +ua+cuuc
(xa crc +acuucc.u u cccucaauucc.u, ncccx:y
a uc ccyxucaau: naaca:c u a.u+cc-
uc ccucaauua, ya+:aa.ca qcxu ncu+ac(-
c.aa, yr y+ac.uuca, cc.c u aca ncu+-
ac(c.aa u (yruc cc.ca.cx:c.aa
5
.
l_c uc(aauc ncqc(ya ua+ua+cuua u nc-
u+ac(c.aa cy(cucu cnc.u+: a:+:aaxa
cnc(cxcuu:c cnc: a caa+u c a+ucrxacuau
a .cxcaauuu c.. J46 u J9J \lK. B +. 4
c.. J46 \lK IU nc(yca.uaaxac: ncqc-
(ya ua+ua+cuua cy(cucu cnc.u+: (c ac+-
y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa u uanaaxcuua nc-
c.aucaxcuua c cc ncac(cuuu (nu uaxu+uu
ncac(ca ncac(cuu nccxc(ucu) ncycy
acc.c c ncc.aucaxcuuc c ac+y(cuuu yrc-
xcaucrc (cxa, a c.. J9J +c.c crxacu.ucaa-
xa ncac(cuuc cy(cucu cnc.u+: .cx:c
a aax yrcxcaucrc (cxa. Haxu+uc a c.. J46
\lK IU a c(aquu (c 2 (caa 2OO8 rc(a
ya+auua c ac+cucc.u ua+ua+cuua, uc uc
ncu+ac(c.aa cy(cucu cnc.u+: (c ac+-
y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa :xc ncrcccua-
u: cacuuc +acuc(a.cxa
6
. O(uac .c
:xc ncxcauu+a.cc cacuuc, uc uaac(acc (ax:-
ucuacrc +acnxcuua a c.. J95 \lK IU
lca(c ua+ua+cuua cy(cucu cnc.u+:.
Hcuuc .a ucc.:caa ncc(uxa ucc-
c.ac nc.uacc+a_ux (yr (yry ncc.aucaxc-
uuu cy(ca, r(c a c(uux nu+uaaaxuc:, a a (y-
rux nucc.axu c.a.yc ucncqcccyax:u:x
(cuc.aua cxc(caa.cxcu nc ua+ua+cuu cy(c-
ucu cnc.u+: (c ccrxaccaauua ncc.aucaxc-
uua c ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa c ncy-
cc.
Hc.cu+ccu acncc c ncac(cuuu cy(c-
ucu cnc.u+: ua a+u:x .anax caaxca
ucc(uuacac. \lK ICUCI J92J rc(a uc
nc(yca.uaax cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu (c
ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa ((ac ccc.
cc.a ncucacc.aua cr :.: ncu+ac(cu
.cx:c nccxc ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa).
\rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u c(cc ICUCI
J96O rc(a c.c.ynux c. .cu nc+uquu, nc+ac-
xua a cxy+aax, uc .cna_ux c.xara.cx:c.aa,
J
+:uno O. H.. +:un K. H.. o:unoe C. l.
Onc+uauuc a na.uc c+:ca +cxcaca u ac-
:.ua ncc.ynxcuuu (uay+uc-c.c(u+ccuu ac-
nc.:). M., 2OO6. C. 2J.
4
Ucyxucaa n. 6 c.. 9 Uc(cax:ucrc +a-
cua O rccy(ac.acuucu cy(cuc-cnc.ucu (c-
a.cx:ucc.u a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu c.
JJ.O5.2OOJ ` 7J. C.: Ccauuc +acuc(a.cx:-
c.aa Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. 2OOJ. ` 2J.
C.. 229J.
5
looe B. luua.uc cxc(caa.cxc cacuua
c ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu acu-
ucc.:. 2OO5. ` JO.
6
U. 4 c.. J46 \lK IU (c 2 (caa 2OO8 rc(a
cnc(cxaxa: lcc.aucaxcuuc cxc(caa.cxa, (c+ua-
aa.cxa c ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa uc+ac(-
xu.cx:uc uanaaxac.ca ncycy. K ncc.auca-
xcuu nuxara.ca a.cuax: ncacu ccc-
_cuua c ncc.ynxcuuu, a a cxy+ac ncu+ac(c.aa
c.(cx:u:x cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu nc +acnxc-
uu cxc(ca ncc.ynxcuua u yc.aucaxcuu xuqa,
crc ccacauaacrc (ccc. cc.a ncucacc.aua,
ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc, ua+ua+cuuc cy(cucu c-
nc.u+:), ~ ccc.ac.c.ay_uc nc.ccx: u nc-
c.aucaxcuua.
85
ncu+ac(u.: ccc. cc.a ncucacc.aua (c
ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa (c.. J78 \lK).
,axcc a c.a.:c c.c+axcc:: B .ux cxy+aax,
nu uaxu+uu .cy ccucaauuu, yrcxcaucc (cxc
ac+y(ac.ca ucc(xcuuc nccxc ncac(cuua
ccc.a cc.a ncucacc.aua
7
.
H+cucuua a \lK, ncu+ac(cuu:c 2 (c-
aa 2OO8 rc(a, ucx+uxu u+ c.. J46 ac+-
cucc.: ua+ua+cuua cy(cucu cnc.u+: (c
ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa, +.c nc+acxuxc
ya.: nc.uacc+ua cc c.. J9J \lK IU.
B uay+ucu xu.ca.yc (aauc :.yc. uc-
uuc c ac+cucc.u ua+ua+cuua u ncu+ac(-
c.aa cy(cucu cnc.u+: (c ac+y(cuua
yrcxcaucrc (cxa, ncu+ac(c.ac c.ccu yc.-
auu. naaxxcxu+ a ac.c cy(cu:x c(u-
ca, cr(a nc(cua cy(cuc-c(uquuccu c-
nc.u+: ccau(c.cx:c.acaauuc nu+uuac.
y_c (cxy u naaa y+ac.uuca ncqccca
8
.
K ncqc(yc ncac(cuua cy(cucu c-
nc.u+: (c ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa a
ccnua.ua, c.ccc cc. (a.: c.ac. c ua-
xu+uu uxu c.cy.c.auu nu+uaca ncc.ynxc-
uua, nu+:aa. ucruc uccxc(caa.cxu, cc(u
c.c:x nccccca C. A. Hcuc, l. I. Icc-
cuucaa, ^. B. Buuuquu u a( (.
9
O(uac ncxca ua+ua+cuua u ncu+ac(-
c.aa cy(cucu cnc.u+: a c.a(uu ac+y(c-
uua yrcxcaucrc (cxa uc cacua. ,c cux nc
cc.a.ca u y(y. cc.aaa.:ca ncxc: a aa-
xuuaquu .aux ncc.ynxcuuu, a uc+acu-
u:u ccc. uac.u+ccux cc(c.a, nu+uucuuc
.acrc ac(a +(cca:, a .ac ncac(cuuc
accxc(caauua a c.ucacuuu c+ acc.u ncnaa-
aux xuq u uccnc+uauu:x .ynca, ncccx:y
uc cacu acncc c ncu+ac(c.ac uccxc(caauuu
(c ncqc(y: accxc(caauua a.cuaxca a a-
ax yrcxcaucrc (cxa. S.a nc+uqua ucrux y+c-
u:x u na.uca cnaa(aua a caa+u c ucac+-
cucc.: cnc(cxu.: uaxu+uc uxu c.cy.c.auc
nu+uaca ncc.ynxcuua c+ nuaxc+cuua +ua-
uuu cncquaxuc.a (cnc.a) ua ncacua+ax:-
uc .anc ncacu a.cuaxca.
Hccacuu: acnccc a cxac.u ua+ua+c-
uua u ncac(cuua cy(cucu cnc.u+: aaxa-
c.ca +acuc(a.cx:u:u nccx a c.ucacuuu uc-
cxc(caauua .ynca. ,cc.a.c+uc +ac.: cxy+au
cuaycuua .ynca, a .c +ucxc u uccnc+uau-
ucrc, cr(a cc.: uac.ynuxa c+ cau(c.cxcu uxu
cr(a nu au+yax:uc ccc.c yc.aucau.: nu-
+uau uacux:c.acuucu cc.u uc nc(c.aaxa-
c.ca ac+cu: c+ ucncx:+caauua cncquax:-
u:x nc+uauuu. Uac.u: cxy+ac acca.uaa-
ccu ncxc: aaxa.ca a.: cuaycuua
ccxc.ucaauu:x uxu uaxc(a_uxca a c.a(uu
a.uaucrc a+xccuua .ynca. Icau.: acncc
c uaxu+uu uxu c.cy.c.auu nu+uaca ncc.yn-
xcuua a xc(c nc(aau.cx:ucrc ccc.a .yna
ua cc.c crc cuaycuua (ac cy(cuc-c(u-
quuccy cnc.y uc nc( cuxy. B .c cxy+ac
.cyc.ca ncxucaca.aucc uccxc(caauuc cc-
.auca, nu u+y+cuuu c.c:x u cc. :.:
(au c.ac. c nu+uuc cc.u. O(uac acc.c
cy(cucu cnc.u+: ncac(u.ca cnc.ucc
uccxc(caauuc, c.ccc uuauu uca.uauc-
naaca:u a.au uc ycryxucaauc.
Bcc.c c .c (cuc.ay_cc +acuc(a.cx:-
c.ac uc nc+acxac. a aax c+:cucrc (cxa
ncac(u.: ncqcccyax:u:c (cxc(c.acuu:c)
(cuc.aua u ccc.aaxa.: ccc.ac.c.ay_uc (c-
ycu.:, c.c:c a (ax:ucuac ucxu :
(ca+a.cx:c.acuucc +ua+cuuc (+a ucx+c-
uuc ccc.aaxcuua nc.ccxa ccc.a cc.a
ncucacc.aua ~ nccxc(ucrc cc.a nc:-
aauua c+ acc.u ncnaaacrc). \lK u Uc(c-
ax:u:u +acu O rccy(ac.acuucu cy(cuc-
cnc.ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u a Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu c. JJ.O5.2OOJ ` 7J-U
JO
cnc(c-
xa. ua+ua+cuuc u ncac(cuuc uccxc(caauua
7
\a+ lc+u(uya Bcxcaucrc Ccac.a ICUCI
c. JO ccu.aa J96J r. Qu.. nc: Bunuquu . B.
\a+. cc+.
8
Lcuc C. A. Cy(cuc-c(uquucaa cnc-
.u+a u cy(cuc-c(uquuccc ccau(c.cx:c.acaa-
uuc \rcxcauc-naaca:c u ncqcccyax:u:c nc-
xc: caxu+aquu yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u.
Kyu:aca, J986. C. JJ9J4O.
9
C., uan.: Lcuc C. A. \a+. cc+.; Poccun-
co+ E. P. Cy(cuaa cnc.u+a a ra(aucc,
au.auc, a(uuuc.a.uauc u yrcxcauc
ncqcccc. M., 2OO6; Bunuquu . B. \a+. cc+.
JO
C.: Ccauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu. 2OOJ. ` 2J. C.. 229J.
H. B. O:qoe. lcxc: ac+y(cuua yrcxcau:x (cx a c.ucacuuu c+ acc.u ncnaaaux
86
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
ac_cc.acuu:x (ca+a.cx:c.a .cx:c a a-
ax cy(cucu cnc.u+:, c.c:c ac+cuc
ua+ua+a.: u ncac(u.: nc uc_cyca yrc-
xcaucy (cxy. B .cu cu.yaquu cxc(c.acu-
u:c (cuc.aua, a naauxc, ccnacu: c nu-
uy(cuuc u acc_c c a.ccuuc a c-
xac.: aau:x naa xu+ucc.u, nc.cy ux nu-
cucuuc a ncuc(, cr(a uc yc.aucaxcu: (ac
nu+uau ncc.ynxcuua, uu+c uc cnaa(a-
uc
JJ
. ,auucc cc.ca.cx:c.ac c.uqa.cx:uc
ca+:aac.ca ua ncac(cuuu accrc cnxcca
c+:cu:x ccnua.uu nc yc.aucaxcuu c-
c.cuaxc(cuua c+ acc.u ncnaaaux ra-
(au, +.c ac(c. yacxu+cuu +ucxa a+:cu-
aac:x xuq.
B caa+u c .c, +.c a uac.ca_cc aca y.a-
+cua cuc.ca c(uucrc qcu.axu+caauucrc y+c-
.a uaccxcuua c.au: nc c(uquucu nca+a-
.cxa (cacc(a a:ca aa+cu, a .c +ucxc u
nxa.u:x, ca_cuua uc nc cc.y u.cx:c.aa
c c.cy.c.auc nccxc(y_cu +anucu a ayxa-
.cucu a.c c+yx:.a.ca ca_cuua)
u uc. c(uucrc (cycu.a, cruc.uy_crc
a ca+a.cx:uc nca(c acc ca_cuua c-
(uquucu ac.uua, a ac.c naaccxa-
uu.cx:u:x crauca a cxac.u c+:ca ra-
(au u yc.aucaxcuua xu+ucc.u uccnc+uauu:x
.ynca ac+uua. .y(ucc.u a ccc u auaxu-
+c u(cu.uuaqucuu:x nu+uaca nc aua.c-
u+ccu nca+a.cxa.
B cacc aca I. C. lcxuu ya+ax, +.c
caxu+aqua ac+ac.a_ux a ycxcauax H1I
ac+cucc.cu cy(cucu cnc.u+: a +ua+u-
.cx:ucu c.cncuu +aaucu. c. cc naacacrc c.a-
.yca, c. .crc, uaccx:c crxacu.uy_uc cc
ua+ua+cuuc u ncu+ac(c.ac uc: ncqcccy-
ax:ucrc +acua cncccc.ay. ncaa_cuu
.ux ac+cucc.cu a (cuc.au.cx:ucc.:
J2
.
,cuc.ay_uu a uac.ca_cc aca nca(c
accc.cuua a.cuaxca a cxac.u a+:cu-
aac:x u yc.auaaxuaac:x xuq nc(yca.u-
aac. (ac ac+cucc.u ucncx:+caauua c+yx:-
.a.ca uccxc(caauua ~ a ncqcccyax:ucu u uc
ncqcccyax:ucu cax. lcqcccyax:u:u nc-
a(c ua+ua+cuua u ncac(cuua cy(cucu c-
nc.u+: cnc(cxcu a \lK Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu. acuc(a.cx:, aucca ncnaau
a +. 4 c.. J46 \lK IU, a.u+ccu cnc-
(cxux, +.c ncac(cuuc cxc(c.acuu:x ccnu-
a.uu (cxuc ncac(u.:ca .cx:c a aax
yrcxcaucrc (cxa.
Ha ccucaauuu u+xccuucrc c+u.ac ucc-
xc(u: a:ucc.u ua ccy(cuuc cxc(y_uc
ncxccuua:
J. lucucuuc cnc.u:x uccxc(caauuu
a (ca.cx:ucc.u nc yc.aucaxcuu cc.cuaxc-
(cuua c+ acc.u ncnaaaux xuq u cnc+uauu
ucu+acc.u:x .ynca a ccaccuu:x ycxcauax
aaxac.ca aau: u ucccncu: a.cc
cucaauua (ca+a.cx:c.acuucu a+:.
2. Cxc(yc. +acuc(a.cx:uc ycryxucaa.:
ccucau:c nu+uau, (a_uc ccucaauua ncxa-
ra.:, +.c ncnaaauu ra(auuu c.ax c.acu
ncc.ynxcuua.
J. ,ca.cx:ucc.: nc c+:cy c+ acc.u nc-
naaaux ra(au aaxac.ca c(ucu u+ ccucau:x
yuquu crauca auy.cuuux (cx. \cncx .cu
ac.: ac ucrc +aaucu. c. c.uaucc.u
u caccaccuucc.u nuuuac:x cxc(c.acu-
u:x (cuc.auu u cnca.uauc-c+:cu:x c.
4. C.a.: J95 \lK IU uccxc(uc (c-
ncxuu.: cxc(y_u ncxccuuc: Cy(cuaa
cnc.u+a cc. :.: ua+ua+cua (c ac+y-
(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa a qcxax yc.aucaxcuua
a.a nu+uaca ncc.ynxcuua, nc(c.aa_c-
uua y.a.: c.c.ca, uc+c+ucacuua uxu au(c-
u+cucuua cacuc.a c.c.a uxu nu uaxu+uu
uu:x a.cca a cxy+aax, uc .cna_ux c.xara-
.cx:c.aa, ccxu c+ cnc.u+: cau.: acncc
c ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa uc nc(c.aa-
xac.ca ac+cu:.
,ca.cx:ucc.: nc c+:cy c+ acc.u nc-
naaaux ra(au aaxac.ca c(ucu u+ ccucau:x
yuquu crauca auy.cuuux (cx. \cncx .cu
ac.: ac ucrc +aaucu. c. c.uaucc.u
u caccaccuucc.u nc(nuuuac:x cxc(-
c.acuu:x (cuc.auu u cnca.uauc-c+:cu:x
c.
JJ
O:oe K. Bc+cuc xu ncac(cuuc cy(cucu
cnc.u+: a c.a(uu ac+y(cuua yrcxcaucrc
(cxa' acuucc.:. 2OOJ. ` 9.
J2
lc:un P. C. Cy(cuaa cnc.u+a: acncc:,
.cy_uc cacuua Cca. c.uqua. M., J988.
` J. C. 2J.
87
Ccacacuc.acaauuc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa u nuac-
(cuuc crc a ccc.ac.c.auc c c(yuac(u:u c.au(a.au aaxa-
c.ca ucc..cxccu +ac.: ncac(ucu cy(cucu cc:, uc-
a:u .an c.ccu ac(c. cacu c.c+c. c acncacuua lc+u(cu-
.a IU c. 2O aa 2OO8 rc(a ` 279-n O ca+caauuu ac-
+cu rynn: nc acncca ccacacuc.acaauua +acuc(a.cx:c.aa
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu c cy(cucu cuc.cc.
Ocucaa cucaauua ccc.a+a.cx:ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
a ccaccuucu Icccuu :xa +axccua ncc.aucaxcuuc Bcxca-
ucrc Ccac.a ICUCI c. 24 c.aa J99J rc(a ` J8OJ-J
O cuqcnquu cy(cucu cc: a ICUCI, a c.cc ya-
+:aaxcc: ua nccxa(auuc cauuu.cx:ucrc yxcua a (ca.cx:uc-
c.u cy(cu:x crauca u uccxc(ucc.: crauu+aquu cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa ua nuuqunax ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u u aaucnaaua c.c-
cu. lu .c a a+cc.ac nucu.c.u:x uanaaxcuuu ccu-
caauua cy(cucu cuc.c: ya+:aaxuc::
~ acuax:ucc nuxucuuc cy(a uaccxcuu, +.c:
cxcr+u.: (cc.yn ra(au naaccy(u ny.c aac(cuua uc-
acu c.uquu;
~ cccnc+cuuc naaa a(crc ra(auuua ua
accc.cuuc crc (cxa cy(c nucau:x,
~ ucncx:+caauuc ncc.:x ncqcccyax:u:x c
a uu+aux +acu:ax cy(cucu cuc.c:.
lcuc .crc a+ac.+uu cuqcnquu nc(-
xaraxu cc+(a.: cuc.cy cncquaxu+ucaauu:x cy(ca, c.c:,
uaa(y c cuc.u.yqucuucu, c.ucc.u a(uuuc.a.uauy u ac-
uax:uy c.uqu.
1au ca+c, aa.c: cuqcnquu J99J rc(a a.u+ccu
nc(cxuxu ccucaauuc cy(cucu cuc.c:, ua+a.cc
a J864 rc(y, ncccx:y \c.aa yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa cc-
(cax ncxccuua c nca(c ncu+ac(c.aa a uca:x cy(c-
u:x yc.aucaxcuuax u a c_ux cy(cu:x cc.ax, r(c accc.c-
uuc (cx crxc ncu+ac(u.:ca c y+ac.uc nucau:x +acc(a.c-
xcu, ccxu uaa+auuc +a ncc.ynxcuuc :xc caa+auc c xuacuuc
uxu crauu+cuuc naa ccc.cauua.
O(uac uura .c.:a \c.aaa yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
J864 rc(a cc(caxa u u+.a.ua u+ c_crc nca(a, aca_ucca
c.(cx:u:x a.crcuu ncc.ynxcuuu:
~ c ncc.ynxcuuax nc.ua ac: u ccc(uucuu:x c uayac-
uuc qccau:x naaux;
Cepre Bopucouun Roropun,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx, oen,
cyun Pepaouancxoro panonnoro cya
r. Penau,
sbpoqodlnranbler.ru
C. E. Ho:oouu
Konucnunn pasunrnn oco6oro nponsuocrua
u cocrnsarcxrnom yroxounom npoucccc
88
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
~ c ncc.ynxcuuax (yxcau:x xuq;
~ c rccy(ac.acuu:x ncc.ynxcuuax;
~ c (cxucc.u:x ncc.ynxcuuax;
~ c ncc.ynxcuuax nc.ua uy_cc.aa u
(cxc(ca a+u:;
~ c ncc.ynxcuuax nc.ua c_cc.acuuc-
rc xarcyc.cuc.aa u xarc+uuua;
~ nc (cxa ccaauucu ra(auccu u
accuucu nc(cy(ucc.u
J
.
Kcc .crc, H. H. Ucuuuquu, auaxu+uya
ncxccuua \c.aaa yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa u nuua.:c a crc a+au.uc +acuc(a-
.cx:u:c a.:, a:(cxax .u au(a ccc:x nc-
u+ac(c.a:
~ +ac+ucc;
~ ycccuucc (cy(cu:c nua+:);
~ ncu+ac(c.ac nc ucccacacuucxc.uu
2
.
lcaaxcuuc ccc:x ncu+ac(c.a, c.xu+a-
_uxca c. c_crc nca(a nuaxc+cuua yrc-
xcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, :xc caa+auc c ucc-
xc(ucc.: a ycccuua ncxc(cuua yrc-
xcau:x (cx +cc+ cy(cu:c uuc.auquu, .a u
cc+(auua (uccuqucaauu:x c cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa, cccnc+uaa_ux naac ua (cc.yn
naaccy(u a+xu+u:x a.crcuu ra(au
nu acuax:ucu +a_u.c c. uc+acuucrc cr-
auu+cuua ux naa u cacc(.
l_c a ,urcc.ax Kc.uuuaua a na.u(cca-
.cu uurc ya+:aac.ca ua cy_cc.acaauuc -
c.ac(uuau:x a+ua.cx:c.a, a ccucac c-
.c:x xcax ccquax:u:u c.a.yc xuqa, nu-
axcaccrc c.ac.c.acuucc.u
J
.
lccxc(y_cc ccucaauuc cy(cucu
cuc.c: Icccuu a ncuc(: c J864 nc J9J7 rc(,
c J9J7 nc J99J rc( u c J99J rc(a nc uac.ca-
_cc aca cau(c.cx:c.ayc. xua: c a+au.uu
c ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa. lu .c a cc-
ac.cuu ncuc( a yrcxcauc ncqcccc ncc-
xa(axc c(uuaucc ncu+ac(c.ac.
1a, \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u c(cc
J92J rc(a cc(cax rxaay XX\l, a c.ccu
ccccy ncu+ac(c.ay a uac(uc cy(c :xu
c.ucccu::
~ +ac+ucc cy(cucc a+ua.cx:c.ac;
~ (cyu:c ac: nc (cxa, c.c:c
uc .cy. ccccrc accxc(caauua uxu nc c-
.c: cauuac:c nu+uaxu cca auucau:u;
~ cy(cu:c nua+:.
B \lK J96O rc(a uc :xu cnc(cxcu:
ccc:c ncu+ac(c.aa, c(uac a c.(cx:u:c a+-
(cx: :xu a:(cxcu: ncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxa
ucccacacuucxc.uux u nc nucucuu nu-
uy(u.cx:u:x c c(uquuccrc xaa.ca,
a accc.cuuc (cxa a c.cy.c.auc nc(cy(uc-
rc :xc c.ucccuc c_u ycxcaua cy(cuc-
rc a+ua.cx:c.aa.
Bcc.c c .c, cc. ncc.ynucc.u, acxcu.a
a cy(cu:x uuc.auquax, ca_uaauuc cy(a u
naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauca nc.ccaaxu ac-
aucuua c cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, u a J985 rc(y
a \lK :x aac(cu a+(cx 9 lc.ccx:uaa
ca (ccy(cucu nc(rc.cau a.cuaxca,
a J99J rc(y ~ a+(cx JO lcu+ac(c.ac a cy-
(c nucau:x, a a 2OOO rc(y ~ a+(cx JJ
lcu+ac(c.ac y ucacrc cy(:u.
C J uxa 2OO2 rc(a a caa+u c ua+axc
(cuc.aua ucacrc \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc
c(cca a Icccuu uaa(y c c(uuau: nc-
a(c cy(cncu+ac(c.aa :x a:(cxcu ccc-
:u nca(c. lu .c +acuc(a.cx: ncacx
nc ny.u a+(cxcuua ccccrc nca(a ua (ac
cacc.ca.cx:u:c +ac.u: ccc:u nca(c cy-
(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa (a+(cx X \lK) u
ccc:u nca(c yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
(+ac.: 4, a+(cx: X\l, X\ll \lK).
J4 uxa 2OO9 rc(a ac.ynuxu a cuxy u+c-
ucuua a \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u:u c(cc, c-
.c:u aac(cua rxaaa 4O
J
Occ:u nca(c
nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac.
1au ca+c, ua ccrc(uaauuu (cu: cuc
rcacu.: c cnc(cxcuucu +aacacuucc.u c-
ucaauua ccccrc nca(a yrcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa. O(uac, cy_cc.acaauuc c.(cx:-
u:x nc.uacc+uu a nucucuuu ccccrc nc-
a(a u ucac+cucc.: nucucuua ccccrc
J
\c.aa yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa Cy(cu:c
yc.aa: 2O ucaa J864 rc(a, c u+xccuuc a+-
cy(cuuu, ua cux cuu ccucaau:. Cl., J867. U. 2.
2
C.: 0ounuquu H. B. Kyc \rcxcaucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa: B 2 .. Cl, J9J5. 1. 2. C. 467
486.
J
C.: Cy( u cy(:u a u+auu:x arcu.ax u+
,urcc. Kc.uuuaua. M., 2OO6. C. 7257JJ.
89
nca(a a c.ucacuuu accx xuq, nuaxcac:x
yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, .cy. (ax:-
ucuacu crxacu.aquu ucau yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa ccccrc
nca(a accc.cuua yrcxcau:x (cx u a+-
ac.u c(uucu cuqcnquu ccccrc ncu+-
ac(c.aa a yrcxcauc ncqcccc.
Cuc.cu:u auaxu+ uc, cc(ca_uxca
a a+(cxax X, X\l, X\ll \lK, nc+acxac. c(c-
xa.: a:ac( c c_ucc.u ccucaauuu u ycxcauu
nucucuua ccccrc nca(a cy(cucrc a+-
ua.cx:c.aa u ccccrc nca(a yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, ncccx:y uu cnc(cxa.ca
ccccuucc.u ncxc(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa
a c.(cx:u:x c.a(uax ncqccca u ccccuucc.u
ucncx:+caauua ccccrc nca(a nc c.(cx:u:
a.crcua (cx u a c.ucacuuu c.(cx:u:x a-
.crcuu xuq.
,cncxucuuc a+(cxa X \lK ucacu rxa-
acu nc(.ac(ac. (auu:u a:ac(, ncccx:y
nca(c +ax+cuua (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua
c cc.y(uu+cc.ac acncc.auac.ca ua uccra-
uu+cuu:u yr xuq u cc(cu. uc:, crxa-
cu.uy_uc a (ccy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac,
.a u nca(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa u
a:ucccuua nurcaca.
Kcc .crc, cc(ca_ucca a \rcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:uc c(ccc ccc:c c: cy-
(cucrc cu.cxa +a nc(aau.cx:u: ac-
cxc(caauuc u ccc:c ncqc(y: ucncxuc-
uua cy(cu:x cacuuu .cy. cuc.ca.u+a-
quu u nuac(cuua c(uucu xaccuuaquu,
ncccx:y cacuuc c.(cx:u:x acnccca a yrc-
xcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ucac+cuc .cx:c
ny.c a+.acucuua nc.uacc+ua:x uc
\lK a ncc.aucaxcuuax lxcuya Bcxcauc-
rc Cy(a IU, c.c:c ucc(c cc(ca. a+a-
ucucx+a_uc ncxccuua.
lc(c accrc, uccxc(uc c.c.u.:, +.c
ncua.uc c_crc u ccccrc nca(a uc crxa-
cu.ucaauc a c.. 5 \lK. C .cu qcx: (au-
uy c.a.: uccxc(uc (cncxuu.: nyu.au
62 u 6J, ya+aa, +.c c(uuaucc ncu+ac(-
c.ac ~ .c ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy
a c_c nca(c, nc(ycc.cuuc uac.ca-
_u Kc(ccc, a ccccc ncu+ac(c.ac ~
.c ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy a c_c
nca(c c u+.a.uau, nc(ycc.cuu:u a c.-
ucacuuu c.(cx:u:x a.crcuu xuq uxu a c.uc-
acuuu c.(cx:u:x a.crcuu (cx.
lu .c qcxcccca+uc a +c.ac.cu +ac-
.u \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc c(cca cuc.c-
a.u+ucaa.: acc au(: ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa,
a+rauu+ua ux a +aaucucc.u c. c.a(uu yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca, ua c.c:x cuu nucua-
.ca.
1a, acc c: ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa c-
uc a+(cxu.: ua +c.:c au(a:
~ ccc:c c: cy(cucrc cu.cxa ua
(ccy(cu:x c.a(uax;
~ ccc:u nca(c yrcxcaucrc cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa nc c.(cx:u: a.crcua xuq;
~ ccc:c c: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:-
c.aa nc c.(cx:u: a.crcua (cx;
~ ccc:c naaca:c ncqc(y: cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa, nucuac:c nu ucncxucuuu cy-
(cu:x cacuuu.
Icrxacu.aqua a +ac.ax 2 u J c.. 29 \lK
ncxucc+uu cy(a ua (ccy(cu:x c.a(uax nc
ccy_cc.axcuu cy(cucrc cu.cxa u nccxc-
(y_cc +acnxcuuc nca(a (a+u cy(cucrc
a+cacuua ua ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(c.acuu:x
(cuc.auu u nucucuuc c nccc+cuua, caa-
+auu:x c crauu+cuuc cuc.u.yqucuu:x naa
ra(au, a .ac cccnc+cuuc naaa ua cy(c-
ucc caxcaauuc a rxaaax JJ, J4, J6, 22, 24, 25,
27 \lK, cc(ca_ux uc:, cnc(cxa_uc
(ccy(cucc ncu+ac(c.ac, nuacxu ux uc-
naaux:ucy .cxcaauu. C 2OO2 rc(a (cu-
c.acaax ncc.yxa. c .c, +.c cy(:, ccy_cc.axaa
cy(cu:u cu.cx:, uc (cxu: ncna.c.ac-
aa.: craua cxc(c.aua u (c+uauua a accxc-
(caauuu yrcxcau:x (cx. B caa+u c .u y+a-
c.uc cy(a ucc(c cac(uxcc: cax:ucy
nuua.u cacuua nu uaxu+uu xc(a.auc.aa
cxc(caa.cxa c c:cc a uxu_c xuc c ac-
c.c nc(c+caaccrc. Occucaauucc.:, a na-
auxc, nc(.ac(axac: xua: .acc.: uuu-
uuuyccrc ncc.ynxcuua u anc.c cnc-
a.uaucrc ac.uua. B c+cc(ucu a+ cy(
ncaa.uxca a nu(a.c crauca cxc(c.aua.
,xa nu(auua uc+aaucucc.u cy(cucy
cu.cx uccxc(uc a:(cxcuuc ya+auu:x
uc a +ac.u 4 \lK a c.(cx:uy rxaay
C. l. Ho:o{un. Kcuqcnqua a+au.ua ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa a ccc.a+a.cx:uc yrcxcauc ncqcccc
9O
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
Occ:c c: cy(cucrc cu.cxa ua (c-
cy(cu:x c.a(uax c a+(cxcuuc crc ua au(::
~ cy(cu:u nca(c (a+u a+cacuua ua
ncac(cuuc cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu u nuc-
ucuuc c ncqcccyax:ucrc nuuy(cuua, caa-
+auu:x c crauu+cuuc cuc.u.yqucuu:x naa
ra(au;
~ cy(cu:u nca(c u+auua u u+cuc-
uua c: nccc+cuua a au(c +axcra, (caauc-
rc acc.a, +ax+cuua nc( c.ay u nc(xcuua
cca cc(cauua nc( c.acu, a .ac ncc-
_cuua xuqa a c(uquucuu uxu ncuxua.u-
+ccuu c.aqucua (xa ncu+ac(c.aa cnc-
.u+:;
~ cy(cu:u nca(c caxcaauua (cu-
c.auu u c+(cuc.auu (cxucc.u:x xuq na-
accxauu.cx:u:x crauca, ccy_cc.axa_ux
yrcxcaucc nccxc(caauuc.
lu .c crauu+cuuc (cuc.aua nuuqu-
na ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u nu ccy_cc.axcuuu cy-
(cucrc cu.cxa uccxc(uc nc(ycc.c.:
.cx:c (xa (a+u cy(cucrc a+cacuua ua
ncac(cuuc ccc.a, c:ca u a:cu a u-
xu_c, a:cu a xca(c u auc, a:cu cac-
(cuuu, ccc.aaxa_ux rccy(ac.acuuy .auuy,
uaxccuua acc.a ua nc+.cac-.cxcrauy
cccncu(cuqu u uy_cc.ac, a .ac ua
cu.cx: u +anuc: nccrcacca. luua.uc
.aux cacuuu cy(c (cxuc (cnyca.:ca
a +ac+uc cy(cuc +acc(auuu c +acnxcuu-
c naaa ua caxcaauuc cy(cucrc cacuua
c ccu.a, cr(a xuqy c.axc u+acc.uc c ncac-
(cuuu a c.ucacuuu ucrc ya+auucrc cxc(c.acu-
ucrc (cuc.aua, crauu+uaacrc crc cuc.u.y-
qucuu:c naaa.
Bcc.c c .c, nu cacuuu cy(c acncca
c y+acucuuu cxc(c.acuucrc (cuc.aua, ncu+-
ac(cuucrc c+ cy(cucrc cacuua a cxy+aax,
uc .cna_ux c.xara.cx:c.aa, .acc crauu+c-
uuc uc (cxuc (cuc.acaa.: u cy(cucc +acc-
(auuc (cxuc ncac(u.:ca nc c_u naau-
xa c nurxaacuuc accx +auu.ccccaauu:x
c.ccu, a .c +ucxc xuqa, a c.ucacuuu c.cc-
rc ncu+ac(uxcc: cxc(c.acuucc (cuc.auc.
Kcc .crc, nc auaxcruu cc c.. 29 \lK
uccxc(uc +acnu.: cuc.u:c (cuc.aua
u cacuua (c+uaaa.cxa, cxc(caa.cxa, ncyc-
a, c.c:c cry. :.: caxcaau: a cy(, nc-
ccx:y ucc(c ncc.yna_uc a cy( axc:
uc cc(ca. (auu:x c crauu+cuuu cuc.u-
.yqucuucrc naaa ra(au ua (cc.yn na-
accy(u. Hanuc, c.(cx:u:c ra(auc, +xc-
ync.cxaa cacu naac, nc(a. +aaaxcuua
a nc(a+(cxcuua Cxc(c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu
ncya.yc IU ua cy(cu, ncycca, cxc(c-
aa.cxcu, c.c:c nuuaxu cacuuc uc a ux
ncx:+y, c ncc:cu nuaxc+: ucyrc(ucc (cx-
ucc.ucc xuqc yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u,
a nu ncxy+cuuu c.ac.a cxc(caa.cxa c .c, +.c
+aaaxcuuc uc cc(cu. ccucaauuu (xa ac+-
y(cuua yrcxcaucrc (cxa, caxy. crc a cy(,
.cya ca+a.: nuua.: cacuuc a nca(c c.a-
.cu J44, J45 \lK IU. lu .c a crucuax
Icccuu na.ua cxa(:aac.ca nc-a+ucy u
acucc.: +(cc: cc. aucc.u .cx:c (c.ax:uaa
crxacu.aqua a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc
+acuc(a.cx:c.ac.
Ocucacncxara_uc naauxa ccc.a+a.cx:ucrc
ncqccca ccrxacuc c.. J5 \lK ax+a. a cca,
nc(c accrc, .ccaauuc c nc(cc.aaxcuuu c.c-
cua aau:x naa ncc( cy(c. Iaau:c naaa
(cxu: nc(cc.aaxa.:ca cauuac: uc+aau-
cuc c. ux ac+ac.a u ccquax:ucrc ncxccuua
nu accc.cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa a c_c u
cccc nca(c cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. H+.a.ua u+
.ux naaux +acuc uc nc(ycc.cu:, cra-
uu+cuua naa cauuac:x aaxaxuc: : na-
: uayacuuc Kcuc.u.yquu IU.
Onc(cxaa oco noqc{ nu nou.-
eo{cmec no :o:oeno+ {c:o+ e omnomcnuu
om{c:onox omc:ouu :uq, +acuc(a.cx: nc-
xcux a ccucay ncqcccyax:u:u c.a.yc xuqa
a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac:
~ uaxu+uc ncqcccyax:ucrc uyuu.c.a
nu ac+y(cuuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa u nucuc-
uuu c: nccc+cuua;
~ ucacuaccc.: xuqa, ccacauaacrc c-
_cc.acuuc cnacucc (cauuc;
~ ucccacacuucxc.uc xuqa, ccacauaac-
rc ncc.ynxcuuc.
B qcxax (ax:ucuacrc ccacacuc.acaauua
uuc.u.y.a ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa uccxc(uc
+ac.: 4 \lK (cncxuu.: ucacu rxaacu 52
J
Occcuucc.u ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcau: (c-
9J
xa a c.ucacuuu xuq, ccacauaaux ncc.ynxc-
uuc nc.ua uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u.
A.yax:ucc.: nucucuua ccccrc nca(-
a nc (auucu a.crcuu (cx cycxaaxuaac.ca
a y+ac.uaauuca cxy+aau ccacacuua .c-
cuc.u+ccux a.ca, nccara.cx:c.a ua u+u:
u +(cca:c cc.y(uuca naaccxauu.cx:u:x
crauca u cy(cu a caa+u c ccy_cc.axaccu
uu (ca.cx:ucc.:, a .ac aucccuuc a(a
u+cucuuu a n. 2 +. 2 c.. JO \lK (Uc(c-
ax:u:u +acu c. JO.J2.2OO8 ` J2J-U),
n. 8 +. J c.. 7J \lK (Uc(cax:u:u +acu
c. 27.O7.2OO6 ` J5J-U), c.. JOO \lK
(Uc(cax:u:u +acu c. 22.O4.2OO4 ` J8-
U), yc.auaaxuaa_ux cy_cc.acuu:c c.c.yn-
xcuua c. c(uuaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nu
accxc(caauuu u cy(cuc accc.cuuu yrc-
xcau:x (cx c ncc.ynxcuuax, nc(ycc.cu-
u:x c.a.:au 2O5, 2O5
J
, 2O6, 2O8, 2O9, 277, 278,
279, 28J u J6O \K IU.
,yac.ca, +.c cnucc .ux c.a.cu uccxc-
(uc cy_cc.acuuc acauu.:. 1a, a C.a.c-
ruu uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu (c 2O2O rc(a, y.ac(cuucu \a-
+c lc+u(cu.a Icccuu c. J2 aa 2OO9 rc(a
` 5J7, ua+aau: ccucau:c yrc+: a ccc rc-
cy(ac.acuucu u c_cc.acuucu c+cnacucc.u:
~ a+ac(:aa.cx:uaa u uuaa (ca.cx:ucc.:
cncquax:u:x cxy u crauu+aquu uucc.au-
u:x rccy(ac.a, a .ac c.(cx:u:x xuq, ua-
naaxcuuaa ua uaucccuuc y_ca c+cnacuc-
c.u Icccuuccu Uc(caquu;
~ (ca.cx:ucc.: .ccuc.u+ccux cra-
uu+aquu, rynnucac u c.(cx:u:x xuq, uanaa-
xcuuaa ua uacux:c.acuucc u+cucuuc ccuca
cuc.u.yqucuucrc c.ca Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu, (c+crauu+aqu ucax:ucrc yuqu-
cuucaauua crauca rccy(ac.acuucu axac.u
(ax+aa uacux:c.acuu:c (cuc.aua a c.uc-
acuuu rccy(ac.acuu:x, ncxu.u+ccux u c-
_cc.acuu:x (ca.cxcu), yuu+.ccuuc accuu:x
u nc:axcuu:x c.c.ca, nc(nua.uu u
y+c(cuuu, cccnc+uaa_ux u+uc(ca.cx:-
ucc.: c_cc.aa, yc.aacuuc uaccxcuua, a .c
+ucxc ny.c nucucuua a(cucrc u xuu+cc-
crc cyua xuc cnacu:x a(uca.uau:x,
xuu+ccux u ucxcru+ccux ac_cc.a;
~ c.cuc.caa (ca.cx:ucc.: uaqucua-
xuc.u+ccux, cxuruc+u:x, .uu+ccux u uu:x
crauu+aquu u c.y.y, uanaaxcuuaa ua ua-
yacuuc c(uuc.aa u .cu.cuax:ucu qcxcc.-
ucc.u Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, (cc.auxu+a-
qu auy.uncxu.u+cccu u ccquax:ucu cu.y-
aquu a c.auc;
~ (ca.cx:ucc.: .aucuaqucuax:u:x nc-
c.ynu:x crauu+aquu u rynnucac, caa+au-
uaa c uc+acuu: ccc.c uac.u+ccux
cc(c.a u ncuxc.cnu:x ac_cc.a, cyua,
ccnunacca, a+:a+a.:x ac_cc.a;
~ ccxaua_uuca cc. ncc.ynu:x ncca-
ra.cx:c.a, uanaaxcuu:x nc.ua xu+ucc.u, cc-
c.acuucc.u, rccy(ac.acuucu axac.u, c_cc.acu-
ucu u cucu+cccu c+cnacucc.u, a .ac
caa+auu:x c cynqucu
4
.
1au ca+c, ccc:u nca(c (cxcu :.:
acncc.aucu, ncuc a:acya+auu:x c.a.cu,
ua xuq, ccacauaaux ncc.ynxcuua, nc(ycc.-
cuu:c c.a.:au J89, 2JO, 2JJ, 222, 228
J
, 229, 2JJ,
2J2, 275, 276, 282
J
, 282
2
, 285, 286, 29O, 295, 296,
J5J, J57, J59 \K IU. lu .c a c.. 5 \lK
IU uccxc(uc +acnu.: ncua.uc ncc.yn-
xcuua nc.ua uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u,
ax+ua a ucrc ncc+ucxcuu:c c.a.:u.
lcuc c_ux ncxccuuu, crxacu.uy-
_ux a.crcuu ncc.ynxcuuu nc.ua uaquc-
uax:ucu c+cnacucc.u, nc c.c: y(c. ccy-
_cc.axa.:ca ccccc ncu+ac(c.ac, rxaaa 52
J
(cxua ax+a.: ccc:u nc(c. (ca+:aa-
uua, ccc:u nca(c +a(cauua, nc(.aaxc-
uua cauucuua u nucucuua c nccc+cuua,
a .ac ccc:c nc(cy(ucc.: u nca(c cy-
(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa.
1a, ncuc cc.ca.cx:c.a, ncc+ucxcuu:x
a c.. 7J \lK u nc(xca_ux (ca+:aauu
nc a(cy yrcxcaucy (cxy, ccccy nc(-
c.y (ca+:aauua nc (cxa c ncc.ynxcuuax
nc.ua uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u (cxu:
:.: c.ucccu::
~ yc.aucaxcuuc uu:x nu+ac.u:x cc-
acacuu ncc.ynxcuua xuq;
~ yc.aucaxcuuc nc(:(y_ux a.ca nc-
c.ynucu (ca.cx:ucc.u;
4
C.: Icc. ra+c.a. 2OO9. J9 aa. ` 88.
C. l. Ho:o{un. Kcuqcnqua a+au.ua ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa a ccc.a+a.cx:uc yrcxcauc ncqcccc
92
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
~ yc.aucaxcuuc uc.c+uuca uuaucuc-
aauua ncc.ynucu (ca.cx:ucc.u;
~ yc.aucaxcuuc auaxca ncc.aau cyua,
a+:a+a.:x ac_cc.a, uac.u+ccux cc(c.a.
^uqa, ccacauaauc ncc.ynxcuua nc.ua
uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u, (cxu: :.: uc-
+ac(xu.cx:uc +a(cau:, u uu nucua-
c.ca ca nccc+cuua ua cc (c JO cy.c (c
ccu.a nc(.aaxcuua cauucuua.
lu .c cc cc(cauua nc( c.acu
c y+c.c (xu.cx:ucc.u nc(aau.cx:ucrc ac-
cxc(caauua u cy(cucrc accc.cuua (auu:x
a.crcuu (cx (cxcu crauu+uaa.:ca .cx:c
ccau (aaucc.u nuaxc+cuua yrcxcaucu
c.ac.c.acuucc.u.
,cxa (auucu a.crcuu (cxu: :.:
u+.a.: u+ nc(cy(ucc.u uca:x cy(cu u cy(a
c y+ac.uc nucau:x +acc(a.cxcu c y+c.c
nca:acuucu c_cc.acuucu +ua+ucc.u u
cxcucc.u cy(cncu+ac(c.aa.
B aax cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxa c
ncc.ynxcuuax nc.ua uaqucuax:ucu c+cnac-
ucc.u (cnyc.uc nucucuuc ccccrc nca(-
a nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua (a .c +ucxc
a cxy+ac +ax+cuua cauuac: (ccy(cucrc
ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac), a .ac +ac+-
ucc ncu+ac(c.ac. Ka ya+:aac. A. B. Ky-
(caa, uaxu+uc cacuua cc c.ccu: cnc-
.cu.ucrc craua uucc.auucrc rccy(ac.aa c
c.a+c a a:(a+c .ccuc.a (cxuc acca.-
uaa.:ca a a+cc.ac cc.ca.cx:c.aa, nu c.c-
c ac+cuc +ac+ucc accc.cuuc (cxa
5
.
lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c (xa +a_u.: cauuac-
crc c. ac+cucrc uccccucaauucrc u uc+a-
cuucrc crauu+cuua crc naa u cacc( +cc+
cnc.cu.u:c crau: uucc.auucrc rccy(a-
c.aa xuqy, cauuaccy a ccacacuuu ncc.yn-
xcuua nc.ua uaqucuax:ucu c+cnacucc.u, nu
c.a+c a crc a:(a+c (xa yrcxcaucrc nccxc(c-
aauua ua .cu.cuu Icccuu, (cxua :.:
nc(cc.aaxcua ac+cucc.: y+ac.acaa.: a cy-
(cuc +acc(auuu nccc(c.ac au(cccuc-
cuqcaa+u. C .cu qcx: uccxc(uc a a-
ax (ayc.ccuuux uxu ucrcc.ccuuux c-
(yuac(u:x ccrxaacuuu nc(ycc.c.: ac+-
xccuuc ua uucc.auucc rccy(ac.ac, c.a+aa-
accca a:(a.: xuqc, ca+auucc.u cccnc+u.:
crc (uc.auqucuucc y+ac.uc a cy(cuc +acc-
(auuu c nuaxc+cuuc +a_u.uua +a c+c.
cc(c.a .crc rccy(ac.aa.
lcuc crxacu.aquu a +ac.u 4 \lK
ccccrc nca(a ncu+ac(c.aa a c.ucacuuu c.-
(cx:u:x a.crcuu xuq uy(a.ca a cxcc (c-
.ax:ucu a+ac.c u +acnxcuuu ocooc o-
+o c{cno:o o.uomc:ocmeo no om{c:o-
no+ omc:ou++ {c:, c.c: c.ucca.ca:
~ ncu+ac(c.ac y ucacrc cy(:u nc (c-
xa +ac.ucrc cauucuua;
~ ncu+ac(c.ac a cy(c c y+ac.uc nu-
cau:x +acc(a.cxcu;
~ ccc:u nca(c cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:-
c.aa.
\a+auu:c c: cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:-
c.aa ncuc ux nccucca a rxaay 4 \lK
uccxc(uc (cncxuu.: c(uaqucu a c-
cu nuuu.cx:u:x ncqc(y ua nc(aau-
.cx:uc cxyaauuu nu cy(cuc a+ua.cx:-
c.ac (cx c ncc.ynxcuuax uccx:acu u cc(-
ucu .acc.u, a u+ nc(cy(ucc.u uca:x cy(cu
ucx+u.: uu:c a.crcuu (cx, cc (cx +a-
c.ucrc cauucuua, c.ucca ux +ucxy +. J c.. JJ9,
+. J c.. J2J, +. J c.. J22, +. J c.. J58, +. J c.. J59,
+. J c.. J65 \K IU.
Kcc .crc, (cuc.auc accx +c.:cx c
ccccrc cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa uccxc(u-
c acncc.auu.: ua ucccacacuucxc.uux.
Cc:xa c.(cx:u:x aa.cca ua .c, +.c (cuc.ay-
_u +acuc(a.cx:c.ac nc(ycc.cu: cnc-
quax:u:c u x:rc.u:c c:, c.c:c ancxuc ccc-
nc+uaa. uu(uau(yaxu+aqu ux c.ac.c.acuuc-
c.u, a nc caccy u+:.c+ucy xucaxu+y ncc-
:aa. acc (yruc naauxa car+cuua yrcxca-
ucrc uaa+auua
6
, nc.uacc+u. +acnxcuu:
a c.. 6 \lK ncxccuua c ua+ua+cuuu yrc-
5
C.: l{oeo A. B. Occcuucc.u yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxa c .ccuc.u+ccc
a.c: Aa.cc. (uc. ... au(. u(. uay. la.c-
uuyr, 2OO9. C. 7, J9.
6
7o:ocno A. la.u+ccuc acncc: ua+ua-
+cuua uaa+auua nu cccc nca(c cy(cucrc
a+ua.cx:c.aa yrcxcau:x (cx \rcxcaucc na-
ac. 2OO8. ` 2.
9J
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, a .c +ucxc c ucc-
xc(ucc.u +a_u.: xu+ucc.u c. uc+acuucrc u
uccccucaauucrc crauu+cuua naa u cacc(.
,yac.ca, +.c a+ac.+uu yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucrc c(cca, cuc.yuya ucy +. 2
c.. 42O \lK, nc(a+ycaaxu nc( c_u nc-
a(c uc c(uuaucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac, a uc-
(cnyc.ucc.: crauu+cuua naa ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux u cy_cc.acaauua aux-xuc ucx-
+cuuu, cc a nc(ycc.cuu:x a rx. 5O
\lK. Hucc .cxcaauuc nc(ncxarac. ucac+-
cucc.: accc.cuua (cx a c.ucacuuu uc-
ccacacuucxc.uux y ucacrc cy(:u u cy(c
c y+ac.uc nucau:x +acc(a.cxcu, .a a
(auu:c uuc.u.y.: uc. cy_cc.acuu:c c.-
c.ynxcuua c. c(uuaucrc nca(a cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa, a .ac nucucuuc a c.ucacuuu
ucccacacuucxc.ucrc nuuy(u.cx:u:x c
c(uquuccrc xaa.ca.
H uacucq, nccxc(u a+ucau(ucc.: ccc-
:x ncu+ac(c.a a cccuucc yrcxcauc
ncqcccc ccc.aaxa. ocooc noeoeoc noqc-
{o. nu+cn+c+oc nu ucno:ncnuu c{c-
nox cmcnuu, c.c: c.ucca.ca:
~ ua(+cucc ncu+ac(c.ac;
~ ac+cucaxcuuc ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrc-
xcaucy (cxy aau(y uca:x uxu auca: c.:a-
auxca cc.ca.cx:c.a;
~ cauxu.aqua;
~ c.a(uqua.
H +acuc(a.cx:, u c(yuac(ucc ccc-
_cc.ac nu(a. ccccc +ua+cuuc (auu: na-
aca: ncqc(ya, ncccx:y cccnc+uaac.ca
ac+cucc.: ucnaaxcuua (cny_cuu:x cy(c-
u:x cauc nccxc ac.ynxcuua a +acuuy cuxy
nuua.crc cy(cucrc cacuua, a .ac ac+c-
_cuuc xuqy nu+uucuucrc y_ca a c+yx:.a-
.c uccccucaauucrc yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua
u c.:aauuc uaa+auua a rccy(ac.ac, ra-
(auuuc c.ccrc aaxac.ca xuqc, ccacaua-
acc ncc.ynxcuuc.
Kcc .crc, a ycxcauax (cxauyccrc cc-
c.a+a.cx:ucrc ncqccca ccc:c naaca:c nc-
qc(y:, nucuac:c nu ucncxucuuu cy(c-
u:x cacuuu, (cxu: nuccc.u x:ay
a.yax:ucc.: u acc.ccaauucc.:, .a a
ucuuc uaxu+uc aau:x naa ccy(cuucrc u
cnaa(auucrc ua caxcaauuc (ac ac.ynua-
acrc a +acuuy cuxy cy(cucrc cacuua ccc-
nc+uaac. aau:u (cc.yn naaccy(u, a:c.y-
naa raau.c +acuucc.u u c.c.uaucc.u,
a .ac cncccc.ayc. accc.aucaxcuu uay-
acuu:x naa xuqa, acaxc+cuucrc a cu.y yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca.
lu .c ccc:c naaca:c ncqc(y:,
nucuac:c nu ucncxucuuu cy(cu:x c-
acuuu, uy(a.ca a ucccucuuc ccacacu-
c.acaauuu u nuac(cuuu a ccc.ac.c.auc a
c c(yuac(u:u c.au(a.au, .a u c cy-
(cucu na.ucu, a:ac.aaacu c.c(: c-
acuua c.(cx:u:x ncxc nu accc.cuuu
(cx a nca(c ua(+ca, ux ac+cucaxcuuu, ca-
uxu.aquu u c.a(uquu
7
. acnxcuuc ya-
+auu:x ncqc(y a +ac.u 4 \lK nc+acxu.
c.rauu+u.: caxcaauuc uc ac.ynuaaux a +a-
cuuy cuxy cy(cu:x cacuuu c. ucx+u-
.cx:u:x c a.ccuua a nc(uquax:uy
ccy (cuc.aua cy(cu:x cacuuu, uc_ux
+acuuy cuxy.
1au ca+c, c.uaucc.: ccccrc nc-
u+ac(c.aa nu ccc.a+a.cx:uc ncc.ccuuu yrc-
xcaucrc ncqccca a cx:acu c.cncuu +aaucu.
c. naaux:ucrc .cxcaauua uc (cuc.ay_c-
rc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa
u a:ac.u c(uucu cuqcnquu crc a+au.ua.
7
lc(cucc c.: Ho:o{un C. l. Occaa naacaaa
ncqc(ya ac+cucaxcuua ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxca-
ucy (cxy aau(y uca:x uxu auca: c.:aauxca
cc.ca.cx:c.a la.:(cca. xc. ac(c yrcxcauc-
rc ncqccca \lKA (CKH): B 2 +. la.cuu-
yr, 2OO5. U. 2. C. J84J9J; Ho:o{un C. l.
lcxc: cccnc+cuua ccc.a+a.cx:ucc.u cy(cnc-
u+ac(c.aa u aaucnaaua c.ccu nu accc.c-
uuu acnccca c ca+auuu naacacu ncc_u nc
yrcxcau: (cxa a aax c(yuac(ucrc cc-
.y(uu+cc.aa Icccuu Hcncx:+caauuc uc c-
(yuac(ucrc naaa a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac.
Oc, 2OO5; Ho:o{un C. l.. cc{ceo B. B. lc-
xc: naacacu crxacu.aquu ac+c_cuua ac(a,
nu+uucuucrc a c+yx:.a.c yrcxcaucrc nccxc(c-
aauua, a ycxcauax ccc.a+a.cx:ucrc ncqccca lc-
xc: u nccnc.ua: a+au.ua yrcxcauc-naac-
acu uayu. lcu+a, 2OO5. C. JJ4J4O; Ho:o-
{un C. l.. Bmuno A. A. Cy.c.: naaa ua ca-
uxu.aqu a ccc.a+a.cx:uc yrcxcauc ncqcc-
cc A.yax:u:c ncxc: ccaccuucrc naac-
cy(ua. lcu+a, 2OO9. C. J722.
C. l. Ho:o{un. Kcuqcnqua a+au.ua ccccrc ncu+ac(c.aa a ccc.a+a.cx:uc yrcxcauc ncqcccc
94
B ccc.ac.c.auu c Kcuc.u.yqucu Iccnyxuu lcxayc: +c-
xcac, crc naaa, cacc(: u raau.uu ux caxu+aquu aaxa.ca
a:cacu qcuucc.: u qcx: c_cc.aa u rccy(ac.aa, a crauu-
+cuuc uxu xuacuuc xu+ucu cacc(: ac+cuc .cx:c a cxy+aax
u nca(c, yc.aucaxcuu:x +acuc. O(uu u+ .aux cxy+aca,
nc(ycc.cuu:x \rcxcauc-ncqcccyax:u: c(ccc ((axcc ~
\lK), aaxac.ca nucucuuc +a(cauua a a+cc.ac c: rccy-
(ac.acuucrc nuuy(cuua a qcxax cccnc+cuua nc(aau.cx:-
ucrc accxc(caauua u cy(cucrc a+ua.cx:c.aa yrcxcau:x (cx,
a .ac ucncxucuua nurcaca. 1a, a Iccnyxuc lcxayc:
a 2OO6 rc(y :xc +a(cauc 2952J xuqa, a 2OO7 rc(y ~
255JJ xuq, a 2OO8 rc(y ~ 24O5J xuqa, a +a 9 ccaqca
2OO9 rc(a ~ J8JJJ xuq
J
.
C nuua.uc a J999 rc(y ucacrc \lK Iccnyxuu lcxa-
yc: :x cy_cc.acuuc acaucu c.c naacacu crxacu.a-
quu +a(cauua: ncaauxac: cccaa rx. J2 c c(ucucuu: ua+aa-
uuc, a c.cy acaxc (caa.: c.a.cu; nc(ycc.cuc nucuc-
uuc .cu c: uc .cx:c nc(c+caaccy, uc u
cauuaccy u ccy(cuucy. Bcc.c c .c, auaxu+
(cuc.ay_crc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa u ccucaauucu ua
uc na.uu cau(c.cx:c.ayc. c .c, +.c rccy(a-
c.ac c_c uc a ncxucu cc cccnc+cuc c.uaucc naacacc
cryxucaauuc +a(cauua u ucyccuu.cx:ucc a:ncxucuuc na-
aux crc ncu+ac(c.aa, raau.uy_cc ua(cuy +a_u.y naa u
cacc( xu+ucc.u.
Auaxu+ uc_cuca u(u+cccu xu.ca.y: c +a(ca-
uuu nca+:aac. arcu.aucc ca_cuuc cxcyccux y+c-
u:x u+y+cuu ncxc (auucrc uuc.u.y.a u c.cy.c.auc crc
(uccc.aqucuu:x uccxc(caauuu a c.c+cc.acuucu yrcxcauc-
ncqcccyax:ucu uayc. Cy_cc.ay_uc ac.: ccac_a. xua:
c.(cx:u:c au(: u acnc.: +a(cauua u uc cc+(a. qcxcc.ucrc
A. I. Hypc
Konucnryaxrnrc ocnour nncrnryra
sacpnannn u yroxounom npoucccc
Pccny6xnrn Bcxapycr
Aneuce fennapueuun Rypc,
ren Hnncxon ropocxon xorrernn aaoxaoa
J
C.a.uc.u+ccuc (auu:c c +a(cauuu xuq, ccacauaaux ncc.ynxc-
uua (nc ccu+cuu: (cxa) nc Iccnyxuc lcxayc: +a ncuc( c 2OO6
nc 2OO9 rc( nc (auu: lcucax:ucu ncya.y: Iccnyxuu lcxa-
yc:.
95
nc(c.aaxcuua c .c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
uc aaxcuuu.
B xc(c ncac(cuucrc aa.cc uccxc(caa-
uua, c+yx:.a.: c.ccrc ccac_a.ca a a(c
nyxuaquu
2
, ccyxucaau: cxc(y_uc cu-
qcn.yax:u:c ccuca: uuc.u.y.a +a(cauua
a yrcxcauc ncqcccc Iccnyxuu lcxayc:.
Honarne aapeaanna. lc caccu u(u-
+cccu nuc(c +a(cauuc aaxac.ca ccu
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc nuuy(cuua nc-
acu.uaucrc xaa.ca, c.caa nucuac.ca rc-
cy(ac.ac .cx:c cnc(cxcuucy +acuc
yry y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc ncqccca. lu
.c +a(cauuc c.uccu.ca uc cxc(c.acu-
u: (cuc.aua, uanaaxcuu: ua ccuauuc u
ncacy (ca+a.cx:c.a, a uu: ncqcccy-
ax:u: (cuc.aua, c.c:c ccacaa.ca nu
ncu+ac(c.ac nc a.cuaxa u yrcxcaucy (cxy.
a(cauuc cxc(yc. cnc(cxu.: a cy yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc nuuy(cuua, c.caa:
a) nucuac.ca nc(c+caaccy, cauuac-
cy u ccy(cuucy; ) ncu+ac(u.ca nc uc-
nccc(c.acuuc ac+uuacy nc(c+cuu uxu
ncc.aucaxcuu (cnc(cxcuu) craua, ac(y-
_crc yrcxcau:u ncqccc; a) ccc.cu. u+ .cx
.anca (c.a(uu) ~ +axaa.a xuqa, (cc.aaxcuua
crc a crau yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua, a.-
caccuucrc cc(cauua nc( c.acu a cc-
.ax u ycxcauax, cnc(cxcuu:x +acuc; r) +a-
acaac.ca ccacc(cuuc +a(cauucrc, nu-
cucuuc ucy (yrcu c: nuuy(cuua
xuc uaa+auua, cnc(cxcuucrc ac.ynuaau a +a-
cuuy cuxy nurcacc cy(a. ,auu: cnc-
(cxcuuc, a c.xu+uc c. cc(ca_crcca a +. J
c.. JO7 \lK Il, y.c+uac.ca u(u+ccaa
nuc(a, c.y.ya u nca(c ccy_cc.axcuua
+a(cauua, yr cy.c.ca, c.c:c cry. cy
nc(acra.:ca, a .ac ya+:aa.ca ac+c-
u:c ncqcccyax:u:c nccxc(c.aua nucucuua
.cu c: nuuy(cuua. a(cauuc ccc.c-
u. u+ nccxc(caa.cx:uc ccua_ux (yr (yra
.anca (c.a(uu). lcay c.a(u +a(ca-
uua cxc(yc. ucucaa.: uc a.u+ccu +a-
(cauuc, a +axaa.c xuqa, (xa +crc uc-
cxc(uc aacc.u ccc.ac.c.ay_uc u+cucuua
a +. J c.. JO7 \lK Il. Bc a.cy c.a(u
+a(cauua ~ (cc.aaxcuuc xuqa a crau yrc-
xcaucrc nccxc(caauua ~ ax+ac.ca .ac
ncqcccyax:ucc ccxcuuc ccacacuu:x (cu-
c.auu, nccxc +crc ua+uuac.ca .c.:a c.a(ua ~
cc(cauuc xuqa nc( c.acu. lccxc(uuu .an
+a(cauua ucc. +ua+u.cx:ucc cxc(c.ac
c +ax+cuuc nc( c.ay a ccu nccc+c-
uua u uaa+auuc a au(c xuacuua cacc(:.
O(uac nu caxu+aquu .ux c c.a(uu +ax-
aa.a u (cc.aaxcuua, nucy_uc +a(cauu, a .a-
c ux nc.ccxucaauuc, c.cy.c.ay., a c+yx:-
.a.c +crc uc cccnc+uaac.ca ncqcccyax:uaa
ucaqua a.a crauu+cuua (xuacuua) cac-
c(: xuqa. B caa+u c u+xccuu: qcxcccc-
a+uc nc(ycc.c.: a +acuc ncu+ac(c.ac
+a(cauua ncc( nucucuuc nc(c+caac-
cy u cauuaccy +ax+cuua nc( c.ay a a-
+cc.ac c: nccc+cuua, a ccy(cuucy, c-
.c:u uc cc(cu.ca nc( c.acu, ~ uaa+a-
uua a au(c xuacuua cacc(:, ua+ua+cuucrc
nurcacc cy(a. S.c nc+acxu. .c+uc yc.auc-
au.: aca u cc.aucay +axaa.a xuqa, a .ac
c.a+u.: .u cc.ca.cx:c.aa a nc.ccxc.
Hnnarne emenna o nnuenennn aape-
aanna. ,xa nuua.ua cacuua c +a(cauuu
2
C.: douqceo . . a(cauuc cauuacc-
rc ~ ucaaa ca yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc nu-
uy(cuua: ncxc: +acuc(a.cx:ucrc cryxuc-
aauua u na.uu nucucuua A(aca.. na-
.ua. 2OO6. ` 5. C. 2629; douqceo . .
lcxc: +acuc(a.cx:ucrc cryxucaauua u
na.uu nucucuua +a(cauua cauuaccrc
(xa nc(.aaxcuua cauucuua acuucc.: u
naacnca(c. 2OO7. ` J. C. 445O; douqc-
eo . . Ocucaauua +a(cauua nc(c+caacc-
rc a yrcxcauc ncqcccc Iccnyxuu lcxayc:
Kc.:q:a lcxayci. 2OJO. ` J. C. J5J9;
Hc A. l. lcxc: +acuc(a.cx:ucrc cryxu-
caauua u na.uu nucucuua +a(cauua
ccy(cuucrc 1y(. lccc+:. O_cc.ac.
2OO7. ` 4. C. 7J75; Hc A. l. a(cauuc
ccy(cuucrc ~ ucacxxa yrcxcaucrc ncqccca
Ku(. yu. 2OO8. ` J. C. 4245; Hc A. l.
lcuc cacuuu .cuucxcru+ccux ncxc uu-
c.u.y.a +a(cauua a yrcxcauc ncqcccc
lcxc: ynaaxcuua. 2OO8. ` J. C. JJ9
J2J; Hc A. l. Ocucaauua u nca(c nucuc-
uua +a(cauua a c: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucrc nuuy(cuua: nc(xccuua nc ux ccacacu-
c.acaauu 1y(. lccc+:. O_cc.ac.
2OO9. ` J. C. 29JJ.
A. l. Hc. Kcuqcn.yax:u:c ccuca: uuc.u.y.a +a(cauua a Iccnyxuc lcxayc:
96
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
uccxc(uc yc.aucau.: ccucaauua u ycxcaua
(xa ncu+ac(c.aa +a(cauua, cnc(cxu.: qcxu
u c.ua: crc nucucuua. Ocucaauua +a(c-
auua uccxc(uc acca.uaa.: a (ayx a+au-
ccaa+auu:x acnc.ax: a uc: naaa, yc.a-
uaaxuaa_uc cc.ca.cx:c.aa, c c.c:u +a-
cu caa+:aac. ac+cucc.: nucucuua .cu
c: nuuy(cuua (cax:u:c, uxu u(u-
+ccuc, ccucaauua), u a a.u+ccuc (auu:c,
nc(.ac(a_uc uaxu+uc ya+auu:x a +acuc
cc.ca.cx:c.a, c.c:c cccuca:aa. uccxc-
(ucc.: ncu+ac(c.aa +a(cauua a a(c
cuc.uc cxy+ac (a.cuax:u:c, uxu a.u-
+ccuc, ccucaauua). \cxcauau +a(cauua aa-
xa.ca +acnxcuu:c a +acuc cc.ca.cx:c.aa
cax:ucrc xaa.ca, ucnccc(c.acuuc uc caa-
+auu:c c (auucu ccu nuuy(cuua, uc uaxu-
+uc c.c:x ca+a.cx:uc (xa cc nucucuua.
Hcnccc(c.acuu:c qcxu +a(cauua ~ ccc-
nc+cuuc ua(xca_crc ncac(cuua xuqa (nc(c-
+caaccrc, cauuaccrc, ccy(cuucrc), c.c-
cy cuc nucuac.ca, u crc y+ac.ua a yrcxca-
uc ncqcccc. lc( c.uaau +a(cauua cxc-
(yc. ncuua.: auy.cuuuc ncy(cuua (cx-
ucc.ucrc xuqa, c.ccc crc nucuac., ccc.ac.-
c.ay_cc qcxa .cu c: nuuy(cuua. H+-
xccuuc c.uaa +a(cauua a ncqcccyax:-
uc cacuuu c nucucuuu (auucu c: nu-
uy(cuua c+ua+ac. crc c.uaucaauucc.:, c.c-
aa c.aucau.ca c.c.uauc a:acuucu, .c cc.:
ncca+yc.ca a cccucaauucc.: nuuuaccrc
cacuua. \c.aucaxcuuc ccucaauuu u ycxcauu (xa
ncu+ac(c.aa +a(cauua, a .ac cnc(cxcuuc
qcxcu u c.uaca crc nucucuua y(y. cnccc-
c.acaa.: cccnc+cuu nuua.ua +acuucrc, cc-
cucaauucrc u c.uaucaauucrc cacuua c +a-
(cauuu crauc, ac(y_u yrcxcau:u ncqccc.
3apeaanne nopoaeaaeuoro. C qcx:
nc(c.aa_cuua uccccucaauucrc +a(cauua
nc(c+caac:x xuq qcxcccca+uc (uccu-
qucaa.: ccucaauua nucucuua .cu c:
nuuy(cuua ua (aa au(a: ccucaauua (xa nc-
(c+cuua u ccucaauua (xa +a(cauua. Oc-
ucaauua (xa nc(c+cuua (cxu: nc(.ac-
(a.: nu+ac.ucc.: xuqa ccacacuu nc-
c.ynxcuua u (aaa.: naac ua crc +axaa. u (c-
c.aaxcuuc a crau yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua.
S.u ccucaauua nc(ycc.cu: (cuc.ay_u
+acuc(a.cx:c.ac (xa +a(cauua xuqa nc
ucnccc(c.acuuc ac+uuacy nc(c+cuu a cc-
acacuuu ncc.ynxcuua (+. J c.. JO8 \lK
Il) u (cxu: :.: +aucucaau: a nc.c-
cxc crc +axaa.a u (cc.aaxcuua. Ocucaauua
(xa +a(cauua (cxu: cau(c.cx:c.acaa.:
c ac+cucc.u ucua(xca_crc ncac(cuua (c-
c.aaxcuucrc xuqa u ya+:aa.: ua uccxc(u-
cc.: a crc a.caccuuc cc(cauuu nc(
c.acu a cc.ax u ycxcauax, cnc(cxcuu:x
+acuc. 1auu ccucaauuau aaxa.ca (c-
c.a.c+u:c (auu:c c .c, +.c .c xuqc: a) c-
c. c:.:ca (uxu c:xcc:) c. craua yrc-
xcaucrc nccxc(caauua uxu crc cc.cuaxc-
(cuuc ucu+acc.uc; ) uc ucc. ncc.cauucrc
cc.a u.cx:c.aa ua .cu.cuu Iccnyxuu
lcxayc:, ncuaac. a (yrcu cc.ucc.u uxu
uc yc.aucaxcua crc xu+ucc.:; a) cc. acc-
ncna.c.acaa.: ncac(cuu ncacu uxu
nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua yrcxcaucrc
(cxa, a .c +ucxc ny.c ca+auua uc+acuucrc
ac+(cuc.aua ua xuq, y+ac.ay_ux a yrcxca-
uc ncqcccc, cc:.ua uxu ax:cuuaquu
a.cuaxca, c.c:c cry. uc.: +ua+cuuc (xa
(cxa; r) cc. ccacau.: nc(ycc.cuucc
yrcxcau: +acuc c_cc.acuuc cnacucc (c-
auuc. Ocucaauua (xa +a(cauua, uaa(y c cc-
ucaauuau (xa nc(c+cuua, (cxu: u+xara.:-
ca a c.uaucaauuc ncc.aucaxcuuu c +a(c-
auuu nc(c+caaccrc. Kcc .crc, a +acuc
cxc(yc. nc(ycc.c.: ac+cucc.: nucuc-
uua .cu c: nuuy(cuua nu uaxu+uu a:-
acu+xccuu:x ccucaauuu (xa +a(cauua xu-
qy, ua(cxcuucy a yc.aucaxcuuc +. J c.. 4O
\lK Il nca(c c.a.ycc nc(c+caaccrc
nc ac+y(cuucy yrcxcaucy (cxy. C .cu qc-
x: crau yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua (cxcu u+-
xcu.: ccucaauua (xa +a(cauua a c.uauc-
aauuc ncc.aucaxcuuu c nucucuuu .cu c:
nuuy(cuua, c+yx:.a.: ucncxucuua c.ccrc
c.a+u.: a ccc.ac.c.ay_c nc.ccxc. ,xa
ycuxcuua ncqcccyax:u:x raau.uu +a_u.: +a-
cuu:x uu.cccca +a(cauu:x uccxc(uc:
a) (c ncxy+cuua y uux aux-xuc c.acucuuu
uxu nca+auuu nc(ycc.c.: ca+a.cx:ucc nc-
(cc.aaxcuuc a(cy +a(cauucy nc(c+c-
97
aaccy ccnxa.ucu u(u+cccu cucyx:.a-
quu a(aca.a; ) uanaaxa.: ncycy cnu
c.uaucaauucrc ncc.aucaxcuua, a:ucccuucrc
crauc yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua, c nucuc-
uuu +a(cauua nc(c+caaccy xuqy.
3apeaanne o6annaeuoro. ,xa yc.auc-
uua nccxca a naacac cryxucaauuu nu-
cucuua +a(cauua cauuac: uccxc-
(uc cn.uu+ucaa.: u y.c+uu.: ncc+cu:
ccucaauuu (xa crc ncu+ac(c.aa. lcxarac, +.c
cauuac:u cc. :.: +a(cau, ccxu: a) uc-
.ca (cc.a.c+u:c (auu:c ncxara.:, +.c cau-
uac:u, c.ccy uc nc(.aaxcuc cauucuuc,
c:xca c. craua yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua,
xuc uaxc(u.ca a (yrcu cc.ucc.u, xuc c-
c.c crc uaxc(cuua ucu+acc.uc; ) uc.ca
(cc.a.c+u:c (auu:c ncxara.:, +.c cauuac:u
uayaux ycxcaua nucucuucu ucy c:
nccc+cuua, uc caa+auucu c cc(cauuc nc(
c.acu, uxu (auucrc u nuc:cuucrc ca+a-
.cx:c.aa aaxa.:ca nc a:+cay craua, ac(y_crc
yrcxcau:u ncqccc, u ccc_a.: cy c nccc-
uc cc.a u.cx:c.aa; a) uccxc(uc cccnc-
+u.: y+ac.uc cauuaccrc nu cacuuu ac-
ncca c nucucuuu ucy c: nccc+cuua
a au(c +ax+cuua nc( c.ay; r) ucc.ca c-
acuuc cy(a c nucucuuu cauuaccy c:
nccc+cuua a au(c +ax+cuua nc( c.ay (c
ac.ynxcuua nurcaca cy(a a +acuuy cuxy.
a(cauuc cauuaccrc nu uaxu+uu xc-
rc u+ ncc+ucxcuu:x ccucaauuu (cxuc ccy-
_cc.axa.:ca nc c.uaucaauucy ncc.aucaxc-
uu craua, ac(y_crc yrcxcau:u ncqccc, a crc
ucncxucuuc ucucaa.:ca a nc.ccxc +a(c-
auua. lccxc (cc.aaxcuua a crau yrcxcauc-
rc nccxc(caauua cauuaccy ca+a.cx:uc
(cxua :.: nc(cc.aaxcua ccnxa.uaa u-
(u+ccaa cucyx:.aqua a(aca.a (c ncxy+c-
uua c. +a(cauucrc aux-xuc c.acucuuu
uxu nca+auuu. lcxu cauuac:u +a(cau
(xa nc(.aaxcuua cauucuua, .c crc ua(xcu.
nc(.aau.: uc nc+(ucc .cx +acca c ccu.a
ccc.aaxcuua nc.ccxa +a(cauua. C qcx:
nc(c.aa_cuua uccccucaauucrc +a(cauua
cauuaccrc nc .a ua+:aaccy +ac+ucy
cauucuu uccxc(uc nc(cc.aau.: crauy
yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua ac+cucc.: nu-
cc.aucaxcuua nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc(caauua
a caa+u c c+:cc uc .cx:c cauuaccrc,
a nc(ycc.cuc a c.. 248 \lK Il, uc u
nc(c+caaccrc. lu .c a:ucccuuc ncc.a-
ucaxcuua c +a(cauuu accr(a (cxuc ccnc-
ac(a.: c.aaxcuuc xuqa a c+:c.
3apeaanne oeyapennoro. Ocucaauuau
(xa +a(cauua ccy(cuucrc (c a+cacuua
acncca c c.cuc ycxcaucrc ucnucucuua
uaa+auua, c.cc+u ucncxucuua uaa+auua uxu
ycxcauc-(ccc+ucrc ccacc(cuua c. c.:aa-
uua uaa+auua (cxu: aaxa.:ca (cc.a.c+u:c
(auu:c, cau(c.cx:c.ay_uc c .c, +.c ccy-
(cuu:u c:xca c. yncxucc+cuucrc craua u
cy(a, xuc uaxc(u.ca a (yrcu cc.ucc.u, xuc
cc.c crc uaxc(cuua ucu+acc.uc. S.u ccuc-
aauua cxc(yc. u+xara.: a nc(c.aaxcuuu, uanaa-
xcuuc a cy( yncxucc+cuu: ua .c crauc u
cc(ca_c xc(a.auc.ac c nucucuuu ccy-
(cuucy +a(cauua. lcxu cy(c y(c. nuua-
.c .acc cacuuc, .c c .c (cxuc a:uc-
cu.:ca c.uaucaauucc ncc.aucaxcuuc, ucncx-
ucuuc c.ccrc crauc (c+uauua (cxuc u-
cucaa.:ca a nc.ccxc +a(cauua. B cxy+ac
uccxc(ucc.u cy( (cxcu uc.: ac+cucc.:
c(ucaccuuc c cacuuc c +a(cauuu ccy-
(cuucrc c.aau.: c+:c .crc xuqa. lccxc
(cc.aaxcuua +a(cauucy (cxua :.: nc-
(cc.aaxcua a(aca.c ccnxa.uaa u(u+ccaa
cucyx:.aqua. Icaxu+aqua .ux nc(xccuuu
y(c. cncccc.acaa.: ncxucy, accc.ccuucy u
c.c.uaucy uccxc(caauu cy(c accx cc.c-
a.cx:c.a a nucy.c.auu cacrc ccy(cuucrc, +:c
y+ac.uc a cy(cuc +acc(auuu (cxuc c.a.:
ca+a.cx:u:, cccnc+uaa.: a:ucccuuc +acu-
ucrc, cccucaauucrc u cnaac(xuacrc cacuua,
a .ac crc ucncxucuuc.
1au ca+c, aucccuuc nc(xarac:x aa-
.cc u+cucuuu u (cncxucuuu a (cuc.ay_cc
yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
Iccnyxuu lcxayc: nc+acxu. cccnc+u.: c-
xcc c.uaucc naacacc cryxucaauuc +a-
(cauua a c: yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc
nuuy(cuua u ucyccuu.cx:ucc a:ncxucuuc
naaux cc ncu+ac(c.aa, raau.uy_cc ua(c-
uy +a_u.y naa u cacc( y+ac.uuca yrcxca-
ucrc ncqccca, c.c: cua nucuac.ca.
A. l. Hc. Kcuqcn.yax:u:c ccuca: uuc.u.y.a +a(cauua a Iccnyxuc lcxayc:
98
Hccxc(ucc.: ac:.ua ncc.ynxcuuu u cccnc+cuua a-
+cc.acuucrc ncqccca ncu+ac(c.aa nc(aau.cx:ucrc accxc-
(caauua nc yrcxcau: (cxa cycxcauxu aac(cuuc ucacrc nc-
a(a ncu+ac(c.aa nc yrcxcaucy (cxy nu +ax+cuuu (ccy-
(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac. Hc ccnauaaa a qcxc
qcxcccca+ucc.: crc aac(cuua, xc.cxcc: : ca.u.: auuauuc
ua a( acnccca, c.c:c cc.axuc: uca+cacuu:u, +.c a:+:-
aac. cnc(cxcuu:c cxcucc.u nu nucucuuu acca.uaac-
crc nca(a.
Hcxc(a u+ cc(cauua uc rxaa: 4O
J
\lK IU (ccy(c-
ucc ccrxaacuuc c cc.y(uu+cc.ac cc. nucua.:ca .cx:c nc
(cxa, ncu+ac(c.ac nc c.c: ccy_cc.axac.ca cxc(caa.cxc.
acuc(a.cx: uc ya+ax, aaa a.crcua (cx nc(na(ac. nc( nu-
cucuuc ccccrc nca(a, yc.aucaxcuucrc 4O
J
\lK IU.
B c.. JJ7
J
\lK +c.c cnc(cxcuc, +.c xc(a.auc.ac
c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu-
+cc.ac nc(c.aaxac.ca cxc(caa.cx, a ya+auucu
ucc .ac cnc(cxcu nca(c caxcaauua c-
acuuu cxc(caa.cxa nc +aaaxcuucy nc(c+caac:
uxu cauuac: xc(a.auc.ay. O(uac cxc(caa.cx:
cc. ccy_cc.axa.: ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcau: (cxa, nc(-
cxc(c.acuu: craua (c+uauua. lcccx:y a c.. JJ7
J
\lK
IU uc ya+aua a.crcua (cx, nc c.c: cc. :.: +ax+c-
uc (ccy(cucc ccrxaacuuc c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, .c cxc(caa.cx: (cx-
cu nuuua.: xc(a.auc.ac c +ax+cuuu ya+auucrc ccrxaac-
uua c. cauuaccrc uxu nc(c+caaccrc uc+aaucuc c. .crc, +a
ccacacuuc acrc ncc.ynxcuua cu nuaxcac.ca yrcxcaucu
c.ac.c.acuucc.u. B .ac cxy+ac ac+uuac. uccc.uaa cu.y-
aqua: ccxu ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy ccy_cc.axac. (c+ua-
aa.cx:, .c cauuac:u u nc(c+caac:u xuacu: naaa xc(a-
.auc.acaa.: c nucucuuu nca(a, yc.aucaxcuucrc rx. 4O
J
\lK
IU, a ccxu auaxcru+ucc yrcxcaucc (cxc uaxc(u.ca a crauax
nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua, .c cuu cxa(a. ya+auu: na-
ac. lcxara, +.c naac cauuaccrc u nc(c+caaccrc uc (cx-
uc +aaucc.: c. .crc, acu crau accxc(caauua ccy_cc.axac.
. I. 1omvuuuuo
3anuxcnnc oaracrua o sarxrucnnn
ocyc6noro corxamcnnn o corpynnuccruc:
uonpocr, ocraumnccn 6cs orucra
hapuca fennapueuna 1avunnuna,
oxop pnnecxnx nayx, npoqeccop
xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
n npaaooxpannerunon enerunocn
Yuypcxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
99
ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy. ,xa yc.a-
ucuua ya+auucrc nc.uacc+ua qcxcccca+-
uc nc(ycc.c.: a a+cc.ac ccucaauua (xa
ncc(a+u yrcxcaucrc (cxa nc nc(cxc(c.acu-
ucc.u uaxu+uc +aaaxcuua c +ax+cuuu (ccy-
(cucrc ccrxaacuua.
Hcxc(a u+ cc(cauua uc: c.. JJ7
J
\lK IU cxc(yc., +.c (ccy(cucc ccrxaac-
uuc cc. :.: +ax+cuc .cx:c c xuqc,
c.ccc aaxac.ca cauuac: uxu nc(c+c-
aac: a ccacacuuu accxc(yccrc ncc.yn-
xcuua nc cuc.ucy yrcxcaucy (cxy. lcxu
c acca.uaa.: ucrcnu+c(u:c yrcxcau:c
(cxa, ccacacuu:c rynnau nc nc(aau.cx:-
ucy crcacy xuc crauu+caauu:u ncc.yn-
u:u rynnucaau, .c cc. ac+uuuy.:
cu.yaqua, +.c xuqc nuaxcac.ca yrcxcaucu
c.ac.c.acuucc.u +a ccacacuuc c(ucrc-(ayx
nu+c(ca, uc nu .c cc. ncc+: a accxc-
(caauuu (yrux ncc.ynxcuuu, c c.c:x c-
xa(ac. uucaqucu a +xcu ncc.ynucu ryn-
n:. ,xa cauuaccrc a ya+auuc cxy+ac :xc
: a:rc(uc +ax+u.: (ccy(cucc ccrxaac-
uuc c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, uc ncccx:y cu uc nu-
axcac.ca nc nu+c(a, nc c.c: cnccccu
ca+a.: ncc_: craua accxc(caauua, .c
c uu ya+auucc ccrxaacuuc +ax+cuc :.:
uc cc.. Qcxcccca+uc nc(ycc.c.: ac+-
cucc.: +ax+cuua (ccy(cucrc ccrxaac-
uua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac c cauuac: u a cxy-
+ac, ccxu cu cc. ncc+: a ac:.uu u ac-
cxc(caauuu uu:x ncc.ynxcuuu.
Cncu: nc(c.aaxac.ca ncxccuuc, cra-
uu+uaa_cc naac cauuaccrc +aaaxa.: xc-
(a.auc.ac c cc.y(uu+cc.ac accuu:u a-
au ~ (c ccu.a c.aaxcuua c ccu+a-
uuu nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua. Ha na.u-
c cc. ac+uuuy.: cu.yaqua, cr(a cauua-
c:u, u+y+ua a.cuax: yrcxcaucrc (cxa, c-
aux ca+a.: ncc_: cxc(c.au. lrc cacuuc
cc. :.: a:+aauc a+xu+u:u cu.yaquau:
cu cc. ncua.:, +.c ua ucrc n:.a.ca caa-
xu.: ac auuy +a ccacacuu:c (cauua, +.c
auucau:c xuqa yccx:+a. c. c.ac.c.acuucc-
.u u .. n. Oauuac:u, +aaaxaa ya+auucc
xc(a.auc.ac, nc(c.aau. (ca+a.cx:c.aa, c.c-
:c cry. ncaxua.: ua nc(.aaxcuucc cau-
ucuuc, nc.cy cxc(caa.cx: uc (cxcu ucx-
+a.: ac+cucc.u ncxy+cuua uca:x (ca+a-
.cx:c.a, uc .cx:c nc(.ac(a_ux, uc u cn-
cacra_ux crc nc+uqu. Mc.ua, nc c.c-
cy cauuac:u cau. ca.u.:ca c xc(a-
.auc.ac c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxa-
acuua, uc (cxcu uc.: +ua+cuua, uc cxc(yc.
nc(ycc.c.: naac ca.u.:ca c ya+auu:
xc(a.auc.ac u a ncqcccc c+uacxcuua c a-
.cuaxau yrcxcaucrc (cxa, u nc ccu+auuu
nc(aau.cx:ucrc cxc(c.aua.
B:+:aac. cnc(cxcuu:c ccucuua c.cy.-
c.auc naaa cauuaccrc (nc(c+caaccrc)
ca.u.:ca c xc(a.auc.ac c +ax+cuuu (c-
cy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac uc-
nccc(c.acuuc ncycy. lca(c +aaaxc-
uua acca.uaaccrc xc(a.auc.aa ccuc.yu-
caau .au ca+c, +.c cacuuc
ncacua+ax:uc nuuuac.ca cxc(caa.cxc, c-
.c:u cc. c.a+a.: a y(caxc.accuuu xc(a-
.auc.aa c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua
c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (+. J c.. JJ7
J
\lK IU).
lcxarac, +.c (auucc ncxccuuc (cxuc :.:
u+cucuc. acuc(a.cx: ca cnc(cxux, +.c
cauuac:u (nc(c+caac:u) +aaaxac. xc(a-
.auc.ac c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaac-
uua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac ua ua ncyca. Cc-
c.ac.c.acuuc, .cx:c ncyc u (cxcu
acca.uaa.: (auucc xc(a.auc.ac. Hu cxc-
(caa.cx:, uu ycac(u.cx: cxc(c.acuucrc craua
uc (cxu: uc.: naaa nuuua.: cacuuc
acc.c ncyca. Cxcuc ncua.: xcruy +a-
cuc(a.cxa, a ccc.ac.c.auu c c.ccu cauua-
c:u nuac. xc(a.auc.ac ua ua ncyca, +a
nccxc(ucrc c.ac+ac. cxc(caa.cx: c ccrxacua
ycac(u.cxa cxc(c.acuucrc craua, a cauua-
c:u caxyc. c.ac. cxc(caa.cxa .cy c y-
cac(u.cx cxc(c.acuucrc craua, c c.c:
:x ccrxaccaau c.ac. cxc(caa.cxa. l(c c +(cc:
urya ncyca, c.c:u c(uu .cx:c anaac
c.a+a.: a +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaac-
uua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac' lc+cy +acuc(a.cx:
uc nc(cc.aaux naac caxcaa.: ncc.auca-
xcuuc cxc(caa.cxa c c.a+c a y(caxc.acc-
uuu xc(a.auc.aa c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc
ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac ncycy' Iy-
cac(u.cx: cxc(c.acuucrc craua, c c.c:
. l. 7omo+nuno. aaaxcuuc xc(a.auc.aa c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac
JOO
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
cxc(caa.cx: ccrxaccaax cacc cacuuc, c+yc-
xcauc, crc nc(.ac(u.. a+c cc+(aaa.: au(u-
cc.: +a_u.: uu.cccca cauuaccrc, ccxu a-
.u+ccu cua a ya+auucu cu.yaquu c.cy.c.ay-
c.' Hccxc(uc nc(ycc.c.: ca+auucc.:
cxc(caa.cxa nc(c.aau.: ncycy xc(a.auc.ac
cauuaccrc (nc(c+caaccrc) c +ax+cuuu
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, cc-
ncac(ua crc c.uaucaauu: xc(a.auc.ac
c +ax+cuuu ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac
xuc c c.a+c a y(caxc.accuuu xc(a.auc.aa.
1cx:c ncyc ~ ua ccucac ncxy+cuu:x
a.cuaxca u c y+c.c c.uaucaauucu nc+u-
quu cxc(caa.cxa ~ (cxcu nuua.: ccu+a-
.cx:ucc cacuuc nc +aaaxcuucy cauuac:
(nc(c+caac:) xc(a.auc.ay.
B +. J c.. JJ7
J
\lK IU +acuc(a.cx:
nc(cc.aaux cxc(caa.cx .cc cy.c (xa nu-
ua.ua cacuua nc xc(a.auc.ay cauuaccrc
(nc(c+caaccrc) c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc
ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac. ,auu:u cc
nc(c.aaxac.ca uccccucaauuc (xu.cx:u:.
Cxc(caa.cx: xccac axa(cc. cu.yaqucu nc yrc-
xcaucy (cxy, nc.cy cc. cau.: acncc
c qcxcccca+ucc.u y(caxc.accuua (auucrc
xc(a.auc.aa a cxcc cc.uc ccu. (cc:
uccxc(uc y+u.:aa.:, +.c a:ncxucuuc a(a
cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu uc cxc(yc. +a.aruaa.:,
nc.cy cacuuc nc acca.uaaccy xc(a-
.auc.ay (cxuc :.: nuua.c a .c+cuuc cy.c
c ccu.a ncc.ynxcuua xc(a.auc.aa cxc(c-
aa.cx.
Onc(cxaa nca(c +aaaxcuua xc(a.auc.aa
c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc-
.y(uu+cc.ac, +acuc(a.cx: c+ax:.cua.uauc
ya+ax, +.c cuc (cxuc nc(aaa.:ca +cc+ cxc-
(caa.cxa. ,auucc ncxccuuc a:+:aac. cnc-
(cxcuu:c ac+acuua. Mcc. ac+uuuy.:
uccc.ac cu.yaquu, a caa+u c c.c:u c-
auuac:u uxu nc(c+caac:u uc nccxa.
ca_a.:ca c ya+auu: xc(a.auc.ac nc-
ycy +cc+ .c.:c xuqc. O(uu u+ c.uaca,
a .c +ucxc, cc. a:c.yna.: ccucuuc a (ca-
.cx:ucc.u cxc(caa.cxa, uucaqua c cyn-
qucuu:x caa+ax nccxc(ucrc u .. (. B ya+au-
ucu cu.yaquu cauuac:u (nc(c+caac:u)
cay.ca xuacu: ac+cucc.u +aaau.: xc-
(a.auc.ac c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxa-
acuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac. l:xc : qcxcccc-
a+uc nc(ycc.c.: ax:.cua.uau:u nca(c
+aaaxcuua acca.uaaccrc xc(a.auc.aa uc-
nccc(c.acuuc ncycy.
Bac(cuuc (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc-
.y(uu+cc.ac c.ac+ac. caxua accuu, cuc
cc. cc(cuc.acaa.: cc.y ac:aaccc.u
ncc.ynxcuuu, uc, ncxara, +.c .c. cxauu+
uaxcu. (caa.:aa.: c y+c.c cn:.a crc
nucucuua ua na.uc.
JOJ
O(uu u+ ucacaac(cuuu (cuc.ay_crc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:-
ucrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa a:c.ynac. uuc.u.y., cryxuy_uu ccc:u
nca(c nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(c-
ucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (rx. 4O
J
\lK IU), a:+:aa-
_uu ucy.uxa_uc cnc: cc(u y+cu:x u naacnucuu.cxcu
c crc cy_ucc.u u qcxcccca+ucc.u. S.c caa+auc c ucau+ucu ca-
crc uuc.u.y.a, aucc ucu+acc.ucrc cccuuccy yrcxcauc-nc-
qcccyax:ucy naay, uccnc(cxcuucc.: ycxcauu crc nucucuua,
c.cy.c.auc ncnucauu:x raau.uu ccx(cuua naa u cacc(
y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa. Cc(u nuac(cuu:x nc-
xc uu.ccc a:+:aa. u acncc: y+ac.ua ncyca, crc c.a.yc
a xc(c nucucuua ccccrc nca(a nuua.ua cy(cucrc cacuua
nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(-
uu+cc.ac. Occy cc.c.y (auuaa ncxca nuc-
c.ac. a cac.c cc: ncya.y:, c.caa :xa
ncac(cua a 2OO7 rc(y a caa+u c cc+(auuc Cxc(-
c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu ncya.yc IU.
,cuc.ay_cc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc-
(a.cx:c.ac nc-ucacy cnc(cxuxc cx: ncyca
a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac. lrc ncxucc+ua uanay +aauca.
c. c: accxc(caauua yrcxcaucrc (cxa
J
. acuc(a.cxc a nc-
qcccyax:u:c c.ucacuua, ac+uua_uc a xc(c ncac(cuua cxc(-
c.aua nc (cxy, c(y ncycc u cxc(caa.cxc aac(cua nc-
qcccyax:uaa urya a xuqc ycac(u.cxa cxc(c.acuucrc cra-
ua. Ccrxacuc ncxccuua c.. J7, rx. 2J, 22, JJ (u a(a (yrux)
\lK IU +a ncycc ccxaucu: xua: ncxucc+ua no{.oo
+a cxc(c.auc, a ncqcccyax:ucc ycac(c.ac xc(c cxc(c.aua
ncc(auc ycac(u.cx cxc(c.acuucrc craua. lc.cy cx:
ncyca a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac nc yrcxcaucy (cxy, ac-
cxc(yccy a cc cxc(c.aua, cac(cua cccnc+cuu +acu-
ucc.u u ccx(cuu naa u cacc( y+ac.uuca yrcxcaucrc
E. 1. 1cucuuo
O poxn nporypopa npn sarxrucnnn
ocyc6noro corxamcnnn o corpynnuccruc
u ocyc6nom nponsuocruc
no yroxounomy cxy
Enena Oanauueuna 1encuna,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
oen xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
n npaaooxpannerunon enerunocn
Yuypcxoro rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
elenatenslnayandex.ru
J
lx. 4OJ \lK IU nucuua .cx:c nc yrcxcaucy (cxy, accxc(y-
ccy a cc cxc(c.aua.
JO2
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa, nu+c cxauu+ (cc.uc-
uua ncc.aaxcuucu +a(a+u (cc.a.c+uc cnccu.
B yc.aucaxcuuy +acuc(a.cxc cxcy:
cxc(caa.cx: ~ ycac(u.cx: cxc(c.acuucrc
craua ~ ncyc, ua uaa a+rxa(, uc cc-
acc anuc:aa.ca ncxccuua rx. 4O
J
\lK
IU, ncccx:y a acnccax nucucuua cccc-
rc nca(a x+caaa cx: c.ac(cua ncyc-
y. 1a, a ncqc(yc +ax+cuua (ccy(cucrc
ccrxaacuua ncyc +a(cuc.acaau (aa(::
~ ua ncac .anc cxc(c.aua nccc(c.ac
accc.cuua xc(a.auc.aa nc(c+caaccrc (c-
auuaccrc) u ncc.aucaxcuua cxc(caa.cxa c +a-
x+cuuu ccrxaacuua, a .ac ccc.aaxcuua cc-
rxaacuua (c.. JJ7
2
, JJ7
J
\lK IU);
~ u ua cuc+uc .anc cxc(c.aua, .c cc.:
a xc(c y.ac(cuua cauuu.cx:ucrc +ax-
+cuua, nccc(c.ac a:ucccuua nc(c.aaxcuua
c cccc nca(c ncac(cuua cy(cucrc +a-
cc(auua u a:ucccuua cy(cucrc cacuua nc
yrcxcaucy (cxy (c.. JJ7
5
\lK IU).
Hccxc(uc c.c.u.:, +.c a xc(c nucuc-
uua rx. 4O
J
\lK IU crauu+aqucuuc cry.
:.: +a(cuc.acaau: (aa u cxcc nc(c.aau.c-
xa ncya.y:: ncyc, ccc.aaxa_uu (c-
cy(cucc ccrxaacuuc c cc.y(uu+cc.ac (+. J
c.. JJ7
J
\lK IU), u ncyc, a:ucca_uu
nc(c.aaxcuuc c cccc nca(c ncac(cuua
cy(cucrc +acc(auua u a:ucccuua cy(cucrc c-
acuua (c.. JJ7
5
\lK IU). B ncac cxy+ac
cc. a:c.yna.: ua(+ua_uu +a cxc(c.auc
ncyc (uanuc, ncyc aucua), a ac
a.cc ~ ncyc, naacc+u:u y.ac(a.:
cauuu.cx:ucc +ax+cuuc (.c cc. :.:
a:acc.ca_uu ncyc, uanuc, ncyc
cy.c.a IU ~ n. J +. J c.. 22J \lK).
B nuac(cuucu +acuc(a.cx:ucu cuua-
quu, c y+c.c yuquu, ac+xccuucu ua ncy-
ca a (ccy(cuc ncu+ac(c.ac, ac.ac. acncc
c crc cxu nu +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxa-
acuua c nc(c+caac: (cauuac:) B +c
cua ccc.cu. ua ncac .anc: a cccnc+cuuu
+acuucc.u a nucucuuu (auucrc uuc.u.y.a
uxu a nccxc(caauuu uu.cccca cxc(c.aua'
1cuu ccrxaacuuc c+ua+ac. c.aa-
uuc ccrxacu.: ua +.c-xuc; ccrxacu.: ~ yc-
(u.:, yrcacu.:, cxcuu.:, ynccu.:, ca+a.:
ycxcauc
2
. Hcxc(a u+ .ucxcruu, a .ac u+
cc(cauua, nc(xaraccrc +acuc(a.cxc
a +. 2 c.. JJ7
J
\lK IU, aa( xu nc(cuaa
+a(a+a (cxua c.ca.: ncc( ncycc ua
ccu. ccc.aaxcuua (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua.
\a+auucc u(c. aa+c+ c yuqucu ua(+ca
+a +acuucc.: cxc(c.aua, ac+xccuucu yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:u: +acuc ua ncyca,
a+ac +.c ncyc a (auuc cxy+ac (cxcu
a:c.yna.: raau.c (ccacx:ucc.u +aaaxcu-
ucrc nc(c+caac: (cauuac:) xc(a.au-
c.aa. Ha (auuc .anc, ua uaa a+rxa(, acc_c
ucqcxcccca+uc acc.u c+: c ccrxaacuuu a
c (ayc.ccuuc a.c, ncccx:y c ccux c.c-
cu a:ca+:aac.ca xua: uaccuuc c ccac-
acuuu aux-xuc ncqcccyax:uc-+ua+u:x
(cuc.auu. lcxcc .crc, cy_cc.ay_uu +acuc-
(a.cx:u:u nc(xc( uc nc+acxu. ncycy a xc(c
cxc(c.aua ccy_cc.axa.: ncqcccyax:u:u cu-
.cx: ua( a:ncxucuuc ca+a.cx:c.a, a+a.:x ua
cca c.ccucu +a_u.:.
C+u.ac, +.c a nc(xccuucu +acuc(a.c-
xc cxcc cxc(caa.cx: ~ ycac(u.cx: cxc(-
c.acuucrc craua ~ ncyc qcxcccca+uc
:xc : ncc(a.: ncxucc+ua nc accc.c-
uu xc(a.auc.aa nc(c+caaccrc (cauuacc-
rc) c +ax+cuuu (ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua
c cc.y(uu+cc.ac ua ncac .anc ycac(u.c-
x cxc(c.acuucrc craua
J
. Ha(+ua_crc nc-
yca a .c cxy+ac ua(c xua: yac(cxa.:
c nuua.c cacuuu c uanaaxcuuc cnuu cc-
c.ac.c.ay_ux ncqcccyax:u:x (cycu.ca.
1cr(a a ua a.cc .anc +ax+cuua
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac, c-
+ycxcauc, uccxc(uc y+ac.uc ncyca, nc-
ccx:y cu, y.ac(aa cauuu.cx:ucc +ax+c-
uuc u nuuuaa cacuuc c aucccuuu nc(-
c.aaxcuua c cccc nca(c ncac(cuua cy-
(cucrc +acc(auua u a:ucccuua cy(cucrc
cacuua nc yrcxcaucy (cxy, raau.uyc. +a-
cuucc.: ncac(cuucrc nc yrcxcaucy (cxy
cxc(c.aua.
2
o:o B. H. 1cxca:u cxcaa: uacrc acxuc-
ycccrc a+:a. M., 2OOO. C. 258.
J
lu .c uaucucaauuc (cycu.a qcxcccc-
a+ucc :xc : u+cuu.: ua, uanuc, ncc.
(ccy(cucrc ccrxaacuua c cc.y(uu+cc.ac.
JOJ
lccy(ac.ac, ccy_cc.axa_cc aa.cx:uy ncxu.uy a c.-
ucacuuu nc(ac.a_crc nccxcuua, uc cc. crauu+uaa.:ca
cc+(auuc .acrc +acua c cxc(cu, c.c:u : cc.aaaxca
ucu+cuu: ua nc.acuuu ucrux xc.. ,xa c.aucaxcuua, a +a-
.c u ycncaucu caxu+aquu naaca:x nc(nucauuu .cyc.ca
ac.c, +a(a_uu uanaaxcuuc a c.cc (cxua (aura.:ca
ncxu.u+ccaa cuc.ca .a ua+:aaccrc acuax:ucrc naaccy-
(ua. Ccyxucaauuaa B. B. ly.uu: c.a.crua ccccuua
uac(a
J
caccu ccc.aaucu +ac.: ucc. +a(a+y accnu.auua +(cc-
acrc ~ uaac.acuuc u u+u+ccu ~ cxc(crc nccxcuua. Cc-
:c+uy yrc+y (xa cacuua .cu +a(a+u, ncxarac, ccc.aaxac.
ncc.ynucc.: ucccacacuucxc.uux.
O(uac a nccxc(ucc aca a uaac +acuc(a.cx:c.ac nc-
u+caxu cy_cc.acuu:c u+cucuua, aca_ucca ncu+ac(c.aa
naaccy(ua a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuucxc.uux.
K ccucacncxara_u qcxa, a:.ca_u u+ auaxu+a (cu-
c.ay_ux ua ccrc(ua c(yuac(u:x naaux u uc,
cuc, a +ac.ucc.u, c.ucc.u: cc+(auuc uuaucca:x,
cucu+ccux, ncxu.u+ccux, naaca:x, crauu+aqu-
cuu:x, ccquax:u:x ycxcauu (xa ycncaucrc yu-
qucuucaauua cuc.c: u+uccccnc+cuua cxc(c-
rc nccxcuua; nca:acuuc a+cc.aa u+uu ucccacacuucxc.uux,
crauu+aqua ux (ccyrca:x ccnua.uu; cax:u:c ccquax:uc-
naaca:c c: nc +a_u.c ucrc(c.u:x, ucncxu:x cccu, a .a-
c .a ua+:aac:x u+ucu:x cccu. Ka nca+:aac. c.a.u-
c.ua, ucuuc c.cy.c.auc u uc(cc.a.c+uc ncac.auu:u cc c.c-
cu: rccy(ac.acuu:x c.y.y ycacu: nccxc(uux c.aucau.:-
ca ucnxcxu .anxuuc (xa a+au.ua u +ac(cuua (cauau.-
ucrc ncac(cuua nc(ac.a_crc nccxcuua.
Hc ccc., +.c ycncx ncac(u:x a .c uxu uuc rccy(a-
c.ac cc (cucu+cccu, a(uuuc.a.uaucu, naacacu, cy-
(cucu, acuax:ucu u ucrux (yrux) a +ua+u.cx:ucu c.cncuu
. B. Rp:cuno
Bcrrop pasunrnn yroxounoro npauocynn
no cxam nccoucpmcnnoxcrnn
u coupcmcnno Poccnn
hunun Bnnecnauouna Kpnenuo,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
nouounnx cyun Open6yprcxoro
o6racnoro cya
J
lccxauuc lc+u(cu.a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu Uc(cax:ucy cc-
auu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu c. JO aa 2OO6 rc(a Icc. ra+c.a.
2OO6. JJ aa.
JO4
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
+aaucu. c. cncccucc.u rccy(ac.aa :o+om-
no uaxa(u.: cxauu+ ac.: rccy(ac.acu-
u:x crauca, nu+aauu:x uc .cx:c ucno:-
n+mo. uc u onmo:uoeomo caxu+aqu qc-
xcu u +a(a+, ncc.aaxcuu:x ncc( a+au.uc
acrc-xuc uuc.u.y.a. Hcaxcaauy cx:
a .c urac. uc .cx:c ucyccuu.cx:ucc uc-
ncxucuuc nc(nucauuu +acuc(a.cxa, uc u +c.c
ncac.auuaa, uc(ayc:cxcuuc u+xccuuaa
crxacu.aqua cacrc +acua.
Kacuax:uaa ncxu.ua a Icccuu ccrc(ua
(cxua c.cu.:ca c y+c.c uc .cx:c acc-
uu, uc u cxcuaacuca cu.yaquu a a c.auc
a qcxc, .a u a c.(cx:u:x cc crucuax, nc(-
c.aaxaa cccu a ncay c+cc(: cuc.cy +c.-
c u+xccuu:x +acuca, naaca:x u uca-
.uau:x a.ca, uc nc.uacc+a_ux nu .c
c(yuac(u: nuuquna u uca. 1a-
c uc ua(c +a:aa.: c .c, +.c naaca:c
nc(nucauua, uaqcxcuu:c ua cryxucaauuc
naacc.ucacuuu c y+ac.uc ucccacacuuc-
xc.uux, (cxu: y+u.:aa.:, c accy nc+cy,
u ncuxcxcru+ccy nc(cnxcy, ncccx:y cc-
ucauaa qcx: ccaccuucu yrcxcaucu ncxu.u-
u a c.ucacuuu cxc(cu ccc.cu. uc a ua-
a+auuu u ac, a a ucnaaxcuuu u nc(yn-
c(cuuu (ax:ucuacrc ncc.ynucrc ncac(c-
uua. Hcuuc nc.cy naaccy(uc (cxuc
ccrc(ua u+aau.:ca c. cax:ucc.cu u nc-
cu.u ua a+cc.acuuc uca:u ycacu:, +.c:
(cuc.ay_uu c.c(au caxu+caa.: u+ua-
+ax:uc +a(yauu:c qcxu, nc(ycc.cuu:c
c(yuac(u:u ucau naaa. Hcuuc
nc.cy aauc y+u.:aa.: cyyx:.yy c.(cx:-
uc a+a.crc crucua Icccuu.
J5 ccu.aa J99O rc(a Icccua a.uuqu-
caaxa Kcuacuqu OOH c naaax ccua.
Ocucau:c ncxccuua rccy(ac.acuucu ncxu-
.uu nc(ync(cuua ncc.ynucc.u ucccac-
acuucxc.uux u +a_u.: ux naa u uu.cccca
+acnxcu: a n. J c.. J Kcuacuquu: lccy-
(ac.aa-y+ac.uuu cccnc+uaa., +.c: y+-
c(cuua, cxy: u crau:, c.ac.c.acuu:c
+a +ac.y c (c.ax uxu ux +a_u.y, c.ac+axu
uca, yc.aucaxcuu: cnc.cu.u:u cra-
uau, a +ac.ucc.u, a cxac.u c+cnacucc.u u
+(aaccxaucuua u c .c+u +cuua +ucxcuuc-
c.u u nurc(ucc.u ux ncccuaxa, a .ac c-
nc.cu.ucrc ua(+ca
2
.
Bcncc c uccxc(ucc.u cc+(auua yrc-
xcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa nc (cxa ucccac-
acuucxc.uux (naaccy(ua (xa ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux) a ncc.ccac.ccu Icccuu :x nc-
c.aaxcu Kcuqcnqucu cy(cucu cc:
J99J rc(a.
B xc(c cy(cuc-naacacu cc: lccy-
(ac.acuucu (ycu a J998 u J999 rc(ax :xu
nuua.: Uc(cax:u:c +acu: O ccucaax
cuc.c: raau.uu naa ccua a Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu
J
u O ccucaax cuc.c: ncu-
xa.uu c+ua(+cucc.u u naacuayacuuu
ucccacacuucxc.uux
4
. laau.cx:c.ac IU
a J995 rc(y u+(axc lcc.aucaxcuuc ` 42O O
y.ac(cuuu 1uncacrc ncxccuua c cncqu-
ax:uc y+cuc-accnu.a.cx:uc y+c(cuuu
(xa (c.cu u nc(cc.ca c (cauau.u: ncac-
(cuuc, nuua. a( ncra, uanaaxcuu:x
ua yxy+acuuc ncxccuua (c.cu u nc(cc.ca
u nc(+cuaa_ux aaucc.: naacacu +a_u-
.: (c.cu, c(cxauc ucrcc (yrcc.
B ucc.c:x crucuax Icccuu (Mccac,
Cau.-lc.cyrc, Icc.cac-ua-,cuy, 1araucrc,
Caa.cac, Huuc Hcarcc(c u (.) c J999 rc-
(a a cy(cuy cuc.cy c.axu aac(u.:ca +:c-
+cnmo acuax:u:x cy(ca (ccc.aa: cy(cu),
cncquaxu+uy_uxca ua accc.cuuu (cx
a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuucxc.uux, u ux na-
accy(uc a acuax:ucu c.cncuu nuxucuc
uca: u cacncucu c.au(a.a a .cu
ccc.
1a, J5 caaxa 2OO2 rc(a lccy(ac.acu-
uaa (ya IU a ncac +.cuuu nuuaxa Uc-
(cax:u:u cuc.u.yqucuu:u +acu O auccc-
uuu (cncxucuuu a UK O cy(cucu cuc.cc
Icccuuccu Uc(caquu" a +ac.u aac(cuua
acuax:u:x cy(ca a cuc.cc cy(ca c_cu
uc(uquu.
2
Kcuqcnqua OOH c naaax ccua. M., 2OOJ.
C. 5.
J
C.: Ccauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu. J998. ` JJ. C.. J8O2.
4
C.: Ccauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu. J999. ` 26. C.. JJ77.
JO5
JO c.aa 2OOJ rc(a lxcuyc Bc-
xcaucrc Cy(a IU nuua.c lcc.aucaxcuuc
O nucucuuu cy(au c_cu uc(uquu
c_cnu+uauu:x nuuqunca u uc c(y-
uac(ucrc naaa u c(yuac(u:x (crcac-
ca Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. S.c. (cycu.
ucc. ucnccc(c.acuucc c.ucacuuc u ac-
cc.cuu (cx c ncc.ynxcuuax ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux, ncccx:y ca_ac. auuauuc cy-
(cu ua uccxc(ucc.: nacrc ycac(c.aa
.auu ccucacncxara_uu c(yuac(u:-
u naaca:u a.au, a Kcuacuqua OOH
c naaax ccua, lcuucuc naauxa (J985),
S-Iua(cuc ccrxaacuua (J99O), nc(yca.-
uaa_uc nccucc aqcu.a c aa.cx:u:x ua
accnu.a.cx:u:c c: a c:c c ncc.ynuc-
c.: ucccacacuucxc.uux. K .u ccrxa-
acuua nuccc(uuuxac: u Icccua.
Xc+c.ca c.c.u.:, +.c cccncuccucc.:
c:: c ncc.ynucc.: uc aauc+ua+ua
c:c c ucccacacuucxc.uuu naacuay-
au.cxau. (cc:, cccc, ua(c rcacu.:
c c:c +a ucccacacuucxc.uux, ncxy+uaaux
cn:. ncc.ynxcuua yrcxcaucrc +acua ~
c:c +a ux ucnaaxcuuc. Hcuuc .acc
ua+ua+cuuc ucc. naacacu uuc.u.y. nuuy-
(cuua nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux. B cx:-
auuc.ac cxy+aca (auucu a.crcuu ncc.yn-
uuca ua+ua+ac.ca uaa+auuc a au(c xuac-
uuu cacc(: c nucucuuc ncxccuuu c.. 7J
\K IU, +.c ac(c. ucra.uau: nccxc(-
c.aua nu (ax:ucuac ccacacuuu ncc.yn-
xcuuu ycxcauc ccy(cuu:u u ac+uuucac-
uu cqu(uaa
5
. Mc(y .c, a nca+:aac.
c.a.uc.ua, cc.a.ca na.u+ccu ucacc.c-
caauu:u uu:c au(: uaa+auua, c.c:c
cuc ua+ua+u.: ucccacacuucxc.uu, uc,
cacc rxaaucc, no .oono{omc:ono+ oenc
c.cy.c.ayc. yc.aucaxcuu:u rccy(ac.ac yc
ua cccnc+cuuc nucu.c.a accc.aucau.cx:-
uc-ncuxa.u+ccux c ac+(cuc.aua ua(
aa.cx:u:u u caxu+aqu (c.uu: acc-
c.aucau.cx:ucrc naaccy(ua a Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu
6
.
7 c.aa 2OO4 rc(a ccc.caxcc: +acc(a-
uuc Ccac.a nu lc+u(cu.c IU nc acncca
ccacacuc.acaauua naaccy(ua, ua c.cc
:xc nc(xccuc cc+(a.: acuax:u:c cy(:
u aucc.u ccc.ac.c.ay_uc ncnaau a naac-
a:c a.:.
JJ c.aa 2OO4 rc(a a lcc(yc IU cc-
c.caxuc: naxacu.cuc cxyaauua nc acnccy
ccacacuc.acaauua ncuxa.uu (c.ccu
c+ua(+cucc.u u naacuayacuuu ucccac-
acuucxc.uux.
J4J5 auaaa 2OO5 rc(a a r. Icc.ca-ua-
,cuy ncaxa Bcccccuucaa cuccuqua
Kacuax:uaa c.uqua. laacacu u ca-
+caa.cx:u:u acnc.:. lcx:acc axuauuc ua
c(cuu+aqu cuc.c: nuuy(u.cx:u:x
cc(c.a nc yrcxcau: (cxa a c.ucacuuu
ucccacacuucxc.uux ca+:aa. c(yuac(-
u:c c.au(a.: ca_cuua c ucccacacuuc-
xc.uuu naacuayau.cxau. O(uac aa-
uc, +.c: +acuc(a.cx:uaa ncxu.ua a ccc
cy(cyc.cuc.aa u yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(-
c.aa nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux cc+c.axa
a ccc uc .cx:c c(yuac(u:u naacacu
cn:. u cacncucuc naaca:c c.au(a.:, uc
u uaqucuax:u:u cu.axu.c., a .ac uc-
_uuca cccuucuu cn:. ac(cuua cy(cncu+-
ac(c.aa nc (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux.
Orau: rccy(ac.acuucu axac.u n:.a.-
ca naaca:u cc(c.aau u cau ccquax:-
ucu uanaaxcuucc.u cau.: ncxcy nc(cc-
.cacu ncc.ynucc.u, acaxc+cuua cxc(cu
a ncc.ynuy cc(y u au.uc_cc.acuuy (ca-
.cx:ucc.:. ,cuc.ay_u yrcxcau: +acuc-
(a.cx:c.ac aucccu: cy_cc.acuu:c cc.u-
a: a c.c(: c_cu u cncquax:ucu
ncuxa.uu cccnc+cuua naa u uu.cccca
(c.cu, ca+aaauxca a cuxu.c c +acuc. Cy-
_cc.acuuc acaucu yr crauca, axc(a_ux
a cuc.cy ncuxa.uu ncc.ynucc.u ucccac-
acuucxc.uux, c+ua(+cucc.u u naacuayac-
uuu. luua. u a( (yrux c. ,uccuqu-
5
C.: l:u+cno A. C. O_uc ua+axa u ua+ua-
+cuua uaa+auua u ux nucucuuc ucccacacu-
ucxc.uu: Aa.cc. ... au(. u(. uay. Icc-
.ca-ua-,cuy, 2OO7. C. 26.
6
C.: 1a c. C. 26.
. B. Kcno. Bc.c a+au.ua yrcxcaucrc naaccy(ua nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux
JO6
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
caau: ycxcaua yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u
ucccacacuucxc.uux, nc(ycc.cuc nuc-
ucuuc nuuy(u.cx:u:x c accnu.a.cx:ucrc
ac+(cuc.aua .c, .c ccacaux ncc.ynxc-
uua uccx:acu u cc(ucu .acc.u. lc(yc-
c.cuc ccacc(cuuc c. uaa+auua ucccac-
acuucxc.uux, ccy(cuu:x +a ccacacuuc
ncc.ynxcuuu uccx:acu u cc(ucu .acc.u
c nucucuuc nuuy(u.cx:u:x c accnu-
.a.cx:ucrc ac+(cuc.aua. B crucuax a+a-
a.:aa.ca cncquax:u:c ncra:, nc(yc-
a.uaa_uc .a.uy u c.c(uy ac(cuua
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux naacuayau.cxcu. B c.(cx:u:x
crucuax crauu+caau: cncquax:u:c ccc.a-
a: cy(cu u ux ncc_uuca, (ucncxua_ux
c(ucaccuuc yuquu ccquax:u:x ac.-
uuca), c.c:c nu+aau: ccy_cc.axa.: cy-
(cncu+ac(c.ac a aax c(yuac(u:x
c.au(a.ca, a a+ac.c cncquax:u:x nc-
ra nuaxca.ca a+xu+u:c uuuc.cc.aa
u ac(cc.aa.
Bcc.c c .c ua(c nu+ua.:, +.c ucc.c-
:c crucu: nu nc((cc naau.cx:c.aa
(a ucc.c:c u cacuu cuxau, xarc(aa u-
.y+ua+y uuuqua.uau:x ac.uuca) nc(nu-
uua. ucc+ycncau:c ncn:.u uaxa(u.: ca-
cc.ca.cx:ucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac a .c ua-
naaxcuuu.
H +(cc: a a+cc.ac ncxcu.cx:ucrc ac-
nc.a cxc(yc. c.c.u.: .c, +.c cncquax:u:u
cy(, a+uaa (cxa a c.ucacuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux naacuayau.cxcu, acca.uaac.
nc(cc.a uc a c.c. (xa cncccuu, a a
cy.c. cauxu.aquu, +.c (ac. ac+cucc.:
cccnc+u.: ncuxa.uy nca.cu:x naacua-
yacuuu. B qcu.c .cu cuc.c: ca+:aac.-
ca ucccacacuucxc.uuu c crc ncxcau, a uc
ac(cc.aa c ux a(uuuc.a.uau:u crauu-
+cuuau, a .c :xc aucc.
1au ca+c, cuc.ca cy(cncu+ac(c.aa
a c.ucacuuu nc(cc.ca (cxua (aura.:ca uc
a c.ccuy cacuua ncxc: (c.cu acc_c,
cua (cxua cccc(c.c+u.:ca ua cuc.uc
cxy+ac, ncc.aa.:ca a+cau.: ucuuc .y ac+-
uuay a cy(:c c.(cx:ucrc cxc(crc +cxc-
aca cu.yaqu, ncc+: ncc(cxc.: cy u+-
ucuu:u a:c, a+ca.:ca a ac+uuac cu-
xu.c.
B .c u ccc.cu. aca cxcucc.:, ncccx:-
y uu(uau(yaxu+aqua cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ~
ccaccuu:u ny.: a+au.ua rccy(ac.acuucu
aa.cx:ucu ncxu.uu acc_c, ac.a.: ua c-
.c:u nu+:aaxu c_c (cauuc uc.: u nc
c.ccy yc.cxa.ca ccrc(ua acc a+au.:c
c.au:.
Hu(uau(yaxu+aqua uaxc(u. c.acuuc
a ucc.c:x ncxccuuax cccuuccrc +acua:
J. Hccxc(ucc.: yc.aucaxcuua c.uaca
ccacacuua ncc.ynxcuua (+. J c.. 7J \lK
IU) u cc.ca.cx:c.a, cncccc.ay_ux ccac-
acuu ncc.ynxcuua (+. 2 c.. 7J \lK IU);
2. Oa+a.cx:ucc yc.aucaxcuuc:
~ ycxcauu u+uu u accnu.auua;
~ ycaua ncuxu+cccrc a+au.ua u ccc-
cuucc.cu xu+ucc.u;
~ axuauua ua ucccacacuucxc.ucrc c.a-
aux nc ac+ac.y xuq (c.. 42J \lK IU).
B +ac.ucc.u, a c.(cx:u:x crucuax cy(:,
cacc.ca.cx:uc ccacacuc.aya ncqc(yy ac-
cc.cuua (cx, ucxc(a. u+ .crc, +.c naaccy(uc
a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuucxc.uux ccuca:aa-
c.ca uc ua cuucxc(cuuu naacuayau.c-
xa, a ua a:acucuuu nu+uu ncc.ynucrc nc-
ac(cuua u ncucc c.uau:x cncccca ac+-
(cuc.aua ua auucau:x c y+c.c ux ac+ac.-
u:x ccccuucc.cu.
O(uac, uccc.a ua .c, +.c Kcuacuqua :xa
a.uuqucaaua Icccucu nc+.u (aa(qa.: xc.
ua+a(, nuxc(u.ca cuc.a.ucaa.:, +.c cc(c-
a_ucca a ucu .ccaauua (c cux nc uc a:-
ncxua.ca a (cc.a.c+ucu c.cncuu, a acuax:-
ucrc naaccy(ua a cacc.ca.cx:ucu nc(cuc-
.c: c_crc naaccy(ua ~ uc cy_cc.ayc..
Hca.uauc +acnxcuu:c ncxccuua
c naaax ucccacacuucxc.uux ucca. a ccuca-
uc (cxaa.uau:u xaa.c, ncccx:y uc
cccnc+cu: cxauu+au ux caxu+aquu. Cc-
accuucc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a-
.cx:c.ac uc acca.uaac. cy(cncu+ac(c.ac nc
(cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux a ncqc(yy, o-
ccmecnno c.xu+a_yca c. a+ua.cx:c.aa
yrcxcau:x (cx a+ccx:x naacuayau.cxcu.
Icc. (c.ccu u nc(cc.cacu c+ua(+cucc.u,
JO7
ccnu+cucc.u u ncc.ynucc.u ncaa_ac.-
ca a cc:c+uy rccy(ac.acuuy u c_cc.acu-
uy ncxcy. Cxcuaaaaca cu.yaqua ycy-
ryxac.ca c.cy.c.auc (cxucrc auuauua
cc c.ccu: rccy(ac.acuu:x crauca nc-
xca, caa+auu: c ccquax:ucu (c+a(an.aqu-
cu ucccacacuucxc.uux, ucccacacuc.ac (cu-
c.ay_crc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa, uc(cc.a.c+ucu
a.uaucc.: u ccrxaccaauucc.: (cuc.auu
ccc.ac.c.ay_ux crucuax:u:x c.y.y.
Auaxu+ +acuc(a.cx:c.aa u naacnucuu-
.cx:ucu na.uu c .c+u +cuua ac+cucc-
.u caxu+aquu nuuqunca acuax:ucrc cy(c-
ncu+ac(c.aa, c.c:u :x c(cxau a:ac, cau-
(c.cx:c.ayc. c ucccc.ac.c.auu ccaccuucu
cccuuccu cuc.c: naaccy(ua nc (cxa uc-
ccacacuucxc.uux c(yuac(uc-naaca:
c.au(a.a. B caa+u c +c cuc cuc.a.u-
caa.:, +.c ccucauaa ncxca a+au.ua ac-
uax:ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ccrc(ua ~ cra-
uu+aqucuuc-acnca(u.cx:u:c ccnua.ua,
cc+(auuc c +acuc(a.cx:ucu a+: ~ nc-
xca a.ccrc ycaua.
Hccxc(uc y+u.:aa.: .ac u .c, +.c c.
+cmuenocmu ecno:onou no:umuu, nc-
ac(ucu rccy(ac.ac, ac ucrc +aaucu. .c,
au y(c. rccy(ac.acuucc uuaucucaa-
uuc. Hcaxcaau: acnc.c cc.ac.ca u +a-
uu.ccccaauucc.: rccy(ac.aa a a+au.uu (au-
ucrc uuc.u.y.a. ,xa .crc cuc uc .cx:c a+-
aa.:aac. cn.uax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac u
auc(ac. cnc(cxcuu:c :+aru ynaaxcuua, uc
u cncccc.ayc. cnxccucy a+au.u ccqu-
ax:uc-cucu+cccu ncxu.uu a qcxc.
B qcxax c.uaucrc ncac(cuua ccqu-
ax:uc-cucu+cccu ncxu.uu uccxc(uc
crauu+aqucuucc, naacacc u uuauccacc c.c-
(uucuuc qcxca:x ncra u ccnua.uu
a cxac.u cc:u, (c.c.aa u cxc(cu a cruc-
uax nu c.uccu.cx:uc crauu+cuu:x (c.-
u:x accurucaauuax, ccccuuc a cu.yaquu rxc-
ax:ucrc cucu+cccrc u+uca.
Hccxc(uc .ac ccc(uuucaa.: (ca-
.cx:ucc.: a+xu+u:x ac(cc.a, y+c(cuuu,
naau.cx:c.acuu:x c.y.y u c_cc.acuu:x
crauu+aquu (xa uanaaxcuua ccacc.u:x ycu-
xuu ua cucaauuc y c.c.a acuax:ucu
ncxu.uu uccxc(u:x a+cc.a u cacuc.a (cc-
.ynu:u +acuu:u cc(c.aau u cncccau
7
.
lcxarac, cy_cc.ayc. uccxc(ucc.: a cc-
+(auuu ccacc.u:x cnxccu:x ncra,
ax+a_ux a cca (cuc.aua accx c.y.y
rccy(ac.acuucu axac.u, a .c +ucxc cu.c-
.ca nc (cxa cc:u, (c.c.aa u cxc(cu, cc-
quax:ucu +a_u.: uaccxcuua, +(aaccxaucuua,
ca+caauua, ua+ax:ucrc accnu.auua, .y(a u
+aua.cc.u, accuca.ca, y+c(cuuu yx:.y:,
naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauca, a .ac cuc.c-
: naaccy(ua.
Kacuax:uaa ncxu.ua (cxua cnua.:ca
ua ccc.acuuy uay+uy a+y, ccucaauuy ua
.ccuc a+auc(cuc.auu .aux uay, a ncu-
xcxcrua, nc(arcrua, ccqucxcrua, ucncx:+ya nu
.c +uauua c(uquu:, cucuu u naaa,
cnuaac: ua cn:. (a .c +ucxc cn:. ncxc
u ucy(a+) +aycu:x rccy(ac.a nc a+au-
.u naaccy(ua a c.ucacuuu ucccacacuuc-
xc.uux.
Kcc .crc, nu a+ac.c uanaaxcuuu
acuax:ucu ncxu.uu cxc(yc. ncuu.:, +.c
cxc(c: aaxac.ca raau.c a+au.ua c_c-
c.aa a y(y_c u aau: ycxcauc ccqu-
ax:uc-cucu+ccux ncccu a xc rccy-
(ac.ac
8
. lcuccu.cx:ucc c c.ucacuuc
ncxca ucccacacuucxc.uux cncccuc
a y(y_c nuacc.u rxycu ccquax:uc-
ncxu.u+ccu nc.accuua.
7
C.: lo{ox+onoe 0. B. Icrucuax:uaa cuc.c-
a nc(ync(cuua ncc.ynxcuuu ucccacacu-
ucxc.uux: ,uc. ... au(. u(. uay. M., 2OOO.
C. JJ4.
8
C.: C:quu E. l. Kacuax:uaa ncxu.ua
Icccuu lcxc: a+au.ua +cxcac+cccrc
nc.cuquaxa a (ca.cx:ucc.u Ccac.a Uc(caquu
(Haya, ca+caauuc, yx:.ya): Auaxu.u+ccuu
acc.uu Ccac.a Uc(caquu Uc(cax:ucrc cc-
auua IU. 2OOJ. `JO (J4J). C. 4J.
. B. Kcno. Bc.c a+au.ua yrcxcaucrc naaccy(ua nc (cxa ucccacacuucxc.uux
JO8
Mc(yuac(ucc cc.y(uu+cc.ac naaccxauu.cx:u:x cra-
uca Icccuu a ccc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ax+ac. a cca
qcx:u a( u(u+ccu +ua+u:x ncqcccca: .c ucncxucuuc
+anccca c naacacu ncc_u cnc.cu.u:x crauca uucc.au-
u:x rccy(ac.a; acncc: c.a(uquu; crauu+aqua yrcxcaucrc
nccxc(caauua +a nc(cxau Icccuuccu Uc(caquu u ua cc
.cu.cuu a ccc.ac.c.auu c .ccaauuau c.. J2 \K IU u (.
B \lK IU (c.. 45J47J) ya+au: ccuca: c(yuac(-
ucrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa, uc, ua uaa a+rxa(, +c.c uc cnc(cxcu: ux
au(: u uc cc+(auc ncxucu c(uucu cuc.c: uaqucuax:u:x nc-
qcccyax:u:x uc (xa cccnc+cuua c(yuac(ucrc cc.y(uu-
+cc.aa a yrcxcauc ncqcccc.
Auaxu+ naacnucuu.cx:ucu na.uu ya+:aac. ua yacxu-
+cuuc cxu+cc.aa yrcxcau:x (cx, nu accxc(caa-
uuu c.c:x ac+uuac. uccxc(ucc.: ac a+auc-
(cuc.auu c uucc.auu:u crauau, u ccccuuc .c
xaa.cuc (xa c.au CHl. 1a, lcucax:ucu nc-
ya.ycu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu a 2OO6 rc(y
a uucc.auu:c rccy(ac.aa uanaaxcu J57J +ancc
c naacacu ncc_u u J75 ncy+cuuu c ccy_cc.a-
xcuuu yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua uucc.auu:x ra(au, accc.-
cuc 2J99 +anccca cnc.cu.u:x crauca uucc.auu:x rccy-
(ac.a c naacacu ncc_u u 2J5 ncy+cuuu c ccy_cc.axcuuu
yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua cccuucux ra(au, ccacauaaux nc-
c.ynxcuua ua .cu.cuu uucc.auu:x rccy(ac.a.
laaccxauu.cx:u:u crauau Icccuuccu Uc(caquu uc-
ncxucuc J9J9 +anccca c naacacu ncc_u, ncc.ynuaaux u+-+a
yca. B caaucuuu c 2OO5 rc(c +ucxc +anccca c naacacu
ncc_u, uanaaxcuu:x a uucc.auu:c rccy(ac.aa, yacxu+uxcc:
ua J2 "
J
.
1. B. Bnymceo
Coucpmcncruouannc saronoarcxrcrua
o mcnynaponom corpynnuccruc
u cqcpc orasannn npauouo nomomn
no yroxounrm cxam
1amapa Bacunueuna Buymeua,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
oen xaqepu yroroanoro npoecca
n xpnunnarncnxn Arancxoro
rocyapcaennoro ynnaepcnea
tanara.yakyshevanall.ru
J
O ccc.cauuu ac.: nc ccy_cc.axcuu c(yuac(ucrc cc.y(uu-
+cc.aa a ccc ca+auua naacacu ncc_u nc yrcxcau: (cxa:
Hucaqucuucc nuc:c lcucax:ucu ncya.y: Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu c. O2.O8.2OO7 ` Hcy-82J-47426-O7 Hucaqucuuc-
naacaaa cuc.ca Kcucyx:.au. lxc.
JO9
C 2OO7 rc(a nc(cxac. uaac.a.: uu.cu-
cuaucc.: c(yuac(uc-naacacrc cc.y(uu-
+cc.aa a ccc yrcxcaucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa,
c.ccc a uac.ca_cc aca a.uauc ccy_c-
c.axac.ca cxcc +c c 7O rccy(ac.aau. Occc
c.c+ac.ca yc.cu+uaaa .cu(cuqua cy_cc.acu-
ucy cc.y cxu+cc.aa +anccca c naacacu
ncc_u nc yrcxcau: (cxa, uaxc(a_uca
a ncu+ac(c.ac naaccxauu.cx:u:x crauca
cy.c.ca Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, rauu+a-
_ux c lcxcyccucu, \auucu, ^a.aucu, ^u.-
acu u Ka+axc.auc.
Haxu+uc uc +ac.u na.cu \lK IU ya-
+:aac. ua .c, +.c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uaa (c-
a.cx:ucc.: ua ccaccuuc .anc a+au.ua
cc.c uy(ac.ca ac auy.urccy(ac.acuuc
naacac cxauu+c caxu+aquu c(yuac(-
ucrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa. Auaxu+ ya+auucu +ac.u
\lK IU nc+acxac. c(cxa.: a:ac( c .c, +.c
ncxccuua cc uc uc accr(a ccrxacy.ca cc
ccu:u auy.urccy(ac.acuu:u ncqc(y-
au, uc a ncxucu cc ccc.ac.c.ay. .cc-
aauua c(yuac(u:x ccrxaacuuu Icccuu-
ccu Uc(caquu, a .ac cc.aaxa. nccx:
a crxacu.ucaauuu a(a acnccca.
B +ac.ucc.u, ua uaa a+rxa(, uccxc(uc
(cncxuu.: c.. 457 \lK IU Hcncxucuuc
a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu +ancca c naacacu
ncc_u nyu.c 5 a cxc(y_cu c(aquu:
Hcncxucuuc +ancca c naacacu ncc_u ccy-
_cc.axac.ca a .c+cuuc JO (ucu c ccu.a crc
ncc.ynxcuua a ccc.ac.c.ay_uu cnc.cu.u:u
crau Icccuuccu Uc(caquu. B cxy+ac, ccxu
+ancc uc cc. :.: ucncxucu a ya+auu:u
cc, cy(, ncyc, cxc(caa.cx:, ucncxua_uc
(auu:u +ancc, (cxu: yac(cu.: cnc.cu.-
u:u crau +anaauaa_cu c.au: c nu+uuax
crc uccaccaccuucrc ucncxucuua. ,auu:u
nccx uccxc(uc yc.auu.:, .a a a uac.c-
a_cc aca ac.c+a.ca cxy+au acxcu.: nu
ucncxucuuu +anccca c naacacu ncc_u. Ha-
yacuua uc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc +a-
cuc(a.cx:c.aa u c(yuac(u:x (crcacca
uc. cc.c u nu nc(rc.cac +anccca c ccy-
_cc.axcuuu yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua.
H+y+cuuc yrcxcau:x (cx, nc(c.aaxcuu:x
ncya.yau cy.c.ca Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu a nca(c c.. 458 \lK IU a lcuc-
ax:uy ncya.yy IU, nca+axc, +.c cuu
uc cc(ca. (cycu.ca, nc(.ac(a_ux a.
c.cy.c.aua y cauuaccrc ra(auc.aa Icc-
cuuccu Uc(caquu, +.c aaxac.ca ry: ua-
yacuuc cccuuccrc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa. Hc-
cxc(uc nuua.: ac auuauuc, +.c a (yruc
rccy(ac.aa cry. uanaaxa.:ca yrcxcau:c (cxa
.cx:c a c.ucacuuu uucc.auu:x ra(au.
O(uac ncya.ycu Kacuc(accrc aa
a lcucax:uy ncya.yy Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu :xc nc(c.aaxcuc yrcxcaucc (cxc
` 567J7 nc cauucuu B. M. ly+uuccrc,
a(cccaauucc a cnc.cu.u:c crau: lc+cc-
cu Iccnyxuu c ncy+cuuc c ccy_cc.axc-
uuu yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua cauuaccrc,
aaxaaacrcca ra(auuuc Icccuuccu Uc(c-
aquu.
Hcxu cc.c uayacuua +. J c.. 46J \lK
IU. ^uqa, a:(auu:c Icccuuccu Uc(ca-
quu uucc.auu:u rccy(ac.aau, nuaxca-
xuc: yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u +a ncc.yn-
xcuua, uc ya+auu:c a +anccax c a:(a+c, .c-
caauua c acaucuuu c.ca c.a(uquu
caccaccuuc uc uanaaxaxuc:. Hanuc,
M. K. Uuca, a:(auu:u Uuuxau(ccu Icc-
nyxucu (xa yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua +a
yuuc.ac, :x (cncxuu.cx:uc nuaxc+cu yrc-
xcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u +a a+cu
2
.
B:aaxcu: ucrc+ucxcuu:c uayacuua cc-
ca nc(c.aaxcuua a lcucax:uy ncya-
.yy a.cuaxca c.a(uqucuu:x ncacc
a c.ucacuuu xuq, +a(cauu:x a caa+u c c-
(yuac(u: c+:cc.
1a, a ncu+ac(c.ac cxc(caa.cxa cxc(c.acu-
ucrc ynaaxcuua Cxc(c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu
ncya.yc IU nc Ax.auccy a uaxc-
(uxcc: yrcxcaucc (cxc, ac+y(cuucc nc nc-
c.ynuaau +cc+ lcucax:uy ncya.yy IU
2
O yc.aucuuu uayacuuu uc \lK IU u
crauu+aqucuuc-acnca(u.cx:u:x (cycu.ca
rcucax:ucrc ncyca IU, crxacu.uy_ux
c(yuac(ucc cc.y(uu+cc.ac a ccc yrcxca-
ucrc cy(cncu+ac(c.aa: Hucaqucuucc nuc:-
c lcucax:ucu ncya.y: Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu c. 25.O7.2OO5 `J5-6-O5 Huca-
qucuuc-naacaaa cuc.ca Kcucyx:.au. lxc.
7. B. Bmceo. Ccacacuc.acaauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa c c(yuac(uc cc.y(uu+cc.ac
JJO
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
a.cuaxa, nc(cc.aaxcuu: Muuuc.cc.ac
c.uquu UIl a c.ucacuuu B. Huau(ca
J
.
lc (auucy yrcxcaucy (cxy 27 c.aa
2OO6 rc(a a cnc.cu.u:c crau: UIl +c-
c+ lcucax:uy ncya.yy IU uanaaxa-
xcc: c(yuac(ucc ncy+cuuc c ca+auuu
naacacu ncc_u, a c.cc ncy+axcc: nc-
acc.u a( cxc(c.acuu:x (cuc.auu, a .c +ucxc
(cnccu.: cau(c.cxcu, nc.cncaay, uc.cc-
aa.: cnuu a.cuaxca yrcxcaucrc (cxa, uaxc-
(a_crcca a cy(c.
O.ac. ua .c ncy+cuuc ncc.ynux cxc-
(caa.cx 27 uua 2OO7 rc(a. lccxc nccac-
(a a.cuaxca ucncxucuucrc ncy+cuua ua
yccuu a+: yc.aucaxcuc, +.c (cncc: cau-
(c.cxcu u nc.cncaacu ncac(cu: ncacxuc-
c.uc, nu (cnccc uc a:acuaxcc: cuc.ucc
cc.c u aca ccacacuua B. Huau(cc
ncc.ynu:x (cauuu. 1au ca+c, uc.ca
cxy+au, cr(a ccu ucncxucuua ncy+cuuu
uccnaa(auuc +a.aruaa.ca. Kcc .crc, nc(-
c.aaxac.ca, +.c ncy+cuuc uccxc(uc :xc
ccc.aaxa.: cxcc (c.ax:uc, c ya+auuc cu-
c.u:x acnccca, c.c:c uccxc(uc +a(a.:
nc.cncaacu u cau(c.cxa. Hcncxucuucc nc-
y+cuuc a uayacuuc .ccaauuu lacncu-
ccu cuacuquu c a+auucu naacacu ncc_u
nc yrcxcau: (cxa uc :xc nccac(cuc c-
nc.cu.u:u crauau UIl ua a+: +ana-
auaa_cu c.ccu:.
Ha uaa a+rxa(, c.. 458 \lK IU Ha-
naaxcuuc a.cuaxca yrcxcaucrc (cxa (xa
ccy_cc.axcuua yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua
uccxc(uc (cncxuu.: +ac.: 2, u+xcua cc
a cxc(y_cu c(aquu: lcc( uanaaxcuu-
c yrcxcau:x (cx a cnc.cu.u:c crau:
uucc.auu:x rccy(ac.a c ncy+cuuc c ccy-
_cc.axcuuu yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua nc ac+-
y(cuucy u accxc(yccy yrcxcaucy (cxy
uccxc(uc a:ncxuu.: acc cxc(c.acuu:c (cu-
c.aua, ncac(cuuc c.c:x ac+cuc ua .c-
u.cuu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu c+ y+ac.ua
nc(c+caaccrc uxu cauuaccrc xuqa.
B caa+u c cc:c+u:u u+cucuuau a \rc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:uc c(ccc Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu, ncu+cac(auu a caa+u c nu-
ua.uc c(cax:u:x +acuca c aucccuuu u+-
cucuuu a \lK c. O5.O6.2OO7 ` 87-U,
c. O6.O6.2OO7 ` 9O-U a +ac.u u+cuc-
uua ncxucc+uu ncycca, a .ac a caa+u
c cc+(auuc Cxc(c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu nc-
ya.yc Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, nc(c.aa-
xac.ca, +.c a qcxax nca:acuua a+cc.aa, -
c.uaucc.u u cnca.uaucc.u ac.: a ccc
c(yuac(ucrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa nc yrcxca-
u: (cxa, uaxc(a_uca a ncu+ac(c.ac cxc-
(caa.cxcu Cxc(c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu nc-
ya.yc IU, uccxc(uc aucc.u u+cucuuc
a yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac
u c(yuac(u:c (crcac: IU, nc(ycc.-
ca ac+cucc.: uanaaxcuua +anccca c nc-
u+ac(c.ac ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu +cc+
Cxc(c.acuu:u cu.c. nu ncya.yc IU,
a uc +cc+ lcucax:uy ncya.yy IU.
Auaxu+ +acuc(a.cx:c.aa nca+:aac., +.c
a \lK IU uc ya+au ccu. (cnyca +a-
_u.uua, crc ncxucc+ua nu ccy_cc.axcuuu
(yrux ncqcccyax:u:x (cuc.auu, caa+auu:x
c a:(a+cu, uc cnc(cxcua ac+cucc.: ca-
xcaauua cacuuu xc(a.auc.ay_cu c a:(a+c
c.ccu:.
Hcccrxaccaauucc.: c_cu uc:, crxacu-
.uy_cu +ax+cuuc nc( c.ay a a+cc.ac
c: nccc+cuua (c.. 97, JO8 \lK), u uc,
nucuac:x (xa cccnc+cuua ac+cucu
a:(a+u (nn. J, 2 +. J c.. 462 u c.. 466 \lK
IU), cc+(axa ucay cxxu+u c(y .cc-
aauuau (crcacca Icccuuccu Uc(caquu u
ya+auu:u c.a.:au \lK Icccuuccu
Uc(caquu. Kcc .crc, a rxaaax JJ u 54
\lK IU uc ya+:aac.ca, .c u +c yc-
ac(c.ayc.ca nu cacuuu acncca c nc(xc-
uuu ccca cc(cauua xuq, cc(ca_uxca nc(
c.acu nc xc(a.auc.ay uucc.auu:x rccy-
(ac.a.
lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c a yrcxcauc-ncqcc-
cyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac Icccuuccu Uc-
(caquu +a(cauuc uucc.auu:x ra(au,
J
,cxc ` 2O9O26 (nc cauucuu Huau(c-
a B. S. nc n. a +. J c.. JJJ, n. a +. J c.. JJ2
\K IU) Axua cxc(c.acuucrc ynaaxcuua
Cxc(c.acuucrc cu.c.a nu ncya.yc IU nc
Ax.auccy a.
JJJ
a c.ucacuuu c.c:x caac.ca acncc c a:-
(a+c (yrcy rccy(ac.ay (xa nuaxc+cuua
yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, cc(cauuc ux
nc( c.acu (c.a(uqucuu:u acc.) u cc-
u cc(cauua nc( c.acu (cxu: :.: yc-
ryxucaau: c.(cx:ucu c.a.:cu \lK IU.
Auaxu+ na.uu uanaaxcuua ncy+cuuu
c ca+auuu naacacu ncc_u cau(c.cx:c.ay-
c. c uaxu+uu uccc.aa ncxc, c.c:c ac+-
uua. a (auucu ccc.
Auaxu+ na.uu a:(a+u nca+:aac., +.c
c ccu.a +a(cauua xuqa u (c nuua.ua c-
acuua c a:(a+c xuc c.a+c a a:(a+c cc.
ncu.u c+cu: ucrc accuu, a +cxcac c(y
.c nc(cxac. cc.aaa.:ca nc( c.acu.
Cxc(yc. c.c.u.:, +.c xc(a.auc.ay_uc
rccy(ac.aa nc(cxa. urucucaa.: nuua(-
xcucc.: xuqa ra(auc.ay a:(a_cu c.a-
u:, u .c cc.ca.cx:c.ac (cuuuyc. a ncc+-
uc ccucaauuu (xa c.a+a a ncc:c c c.a-
(uquu. O(ucu u+ aau:x +a(a+ aaxac.ca nu-
ua.uc c nc cca_cuu ccca ucncxucuua
cccuucux +anccca +a ycc. ,xa .crc
uccxc(uc ccy_cc.axa.: cu.cx: +a ux ac-
cc.cuuc a cnc.cu.u:x crauax uucc.-
auu:x rccy(ac.a. lcucax:ucu ncya.y-
cu IU cuc.ca.u+ccu uanaaxa.ca ca-
_cuua c uccxc(ucc.u ux cccuacrc uc-
ncxucuua c y+c.c crauu+cuu:x ncqcccy-
ax:u:x ccca nc yrcxcau: (cxa (.aux
uancuuauuu a .c+cuuc rc(a c:+uc uanaaxa-
c.ca cxcc .cx .:ca+), (auu:c acncc: a ca-
+a.cx:uc nca(c a:ucca.ca (xa ccy(c-
uua ua c(yuac(u:x ac.c+ax u cuccu-
quax.
H+ nua+a lcucax:ucu ncya.y: IU
c. J2.OJ.2OO9 cxc(yc., +.c a+auc(cuc.auc
c crauau, crauu+aquau u y+c(cuuau
uucc.auu:x rccy(ac.a, a .ac c c(yua-
c(u:u crauau u crauu+aquau aaxac.ca
c(uu u+ nucu.c.u:x uanaaxcuuu (ca.cx:-
ucc.u ncya.y:
4
.
1au ca+c, na.ua c(yuac(ucrc
cc.y(uu+cc.aa nc yrcxcau: (cxa cxcua.
S.c c.acuac.ca, ac-nca:x, cxxu+ucu uc
c(yuac(ucrc (crcacucrc u uaqucuax:uc-
rc naaa, cc .crc, a cac cccuucc yrc-
xcauc-ncqcccyax:uc +acuc(a.cx:c.ac uc-
.ca auy.cuuuc nc.uacc+ua. Bc-a.c:x,
uc(cc.a.c+uaa ycryxucaauucc.: ucau
cccuuccrc yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc naaa
c(yuac(uc-naacacrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa
a ccc yrcxcaucrc ncu+ac(c.aa .ac nu-
ac(u. ac+uuucacuu ncxc (xa naac-
nucuu.cxa. lc(c.aaxac.ca, +.c ncxca
ccacacuc.acaauua yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:uc-
rc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa nc acncca c(yua-
c(ucrc cc.y(uu+cc.aa a ccc yrcxcaucrc
cy(cncu+ac(c.aa ua ccrc(uaauuu (cu: aaxa-
c.ca acc:a a.yax:ucu.
4
O crauu+aquu c(yuac(ucrc cc.y(uu-
+cc.aa crauca ncya.y: IU: lua+ lcuc-
ax:ucu ncya.y: IU c. J2.OJ.O9 ` 67
Hucaqucuuc-naacaaa cuc.ca Kcucyx:.au.
lxc.
7. B. Bmceo. Ccacacuc.acaauuc +acuc(a.cx:c.aa c c(yuac(uc cc.y(uu+cc.ac
JJ2
Momcpuo:m onmyo:vumx
uuoueuoyo:vumx ucc:cooeouu
{ceoooouou mc:omuno)
Ccrc(ua, cr(a c.aua yc a.ccu rc( uaxc(u.ca a c.a(uu
naaca:x cc, cy(cuaa cuc.ca ~ ccucaucu c.a +acu-
ucc.u a c.auc ~ cc.ac.ca c(ucu u+ ca:x uc(cc.ynu:x
a cxac.u naaa u, +ay+uaauc: Uc(cax:u:u +acuau
O cy(cucu cuc.cc a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu u
O c.a.ycc cy(cu a Icccuuccu Uc(caquu, +a+a-
c.y ncx:+yc.ca ccc: naauxc acu +.c
(:axc, y(a ncacuca: ~ .y(a u a:axc.
lcuc(cx:u:c ccc(: yuaxuc.ca c nc(cc-
(a.cxau cy(ca, nyxuyc:c a ac(y_ux u+(auuax,
ac(c : (a. nc(c.aaxcuuc c .c, +.c ccu-
caauuc cy(cucu cuc.c: ncxc(u. ua na.: ax-
xca. a(yacau:c c.cacuua nc(cc(a.cxcu cy-
(ca u c:+u:x cy(cu c .c, a ucnaaxa.ca
cxc(c.acuu:c u cy(cu:c cauu a cy(ax, accxa. yaccu-
ucc.: a ncc.:x ra(au, +.c Ucu(a a Icccuu c.aucau.ca
naaccy(ucu.
O(uac ua (cxc acc a:rxa(u. ccacc uua+c. Ka cy_cc.ac-
aaxa cy(cuaa cnca.uaucc.:, .a cua u cc.axac:, a nuc-
uaxca c.nucc+u:u c.c(, .a u nucuac.ca. lu:.cc c.a-
.ycc ucnuccucacuucc.u cy(:u, nc(cucc c.ucacuuc cc.ac.ca
c+uaa+auu:. 1c c cacc ncucxc(u. u a crauc, c.c:u
a ncay c+cc(: (cxcu c.ca.: ua c.ac +acuucc.u ~ nc-
ya.yc.
Rauen Bnapumupouun Huanou,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
oen xaqepu yroroano-npaaoaux ncnnrnn
kno-Poccnncxoro ryuannapnoro nncnya,
ren Acconann pncoa Poccnn,
npexop aaoxacxoro 6po Koexc
Anppe Kpueuun Kamupun,
naarunnx oera npoxypaypu
Pporeapcxoro panona r. Pocoa-na-ony
H. B. Heouoe, A. R. Komupuu
3aron nxn ropnoparnunocrr.
JJJ
1a, JJ uxa 2OO6 rc(a nurcacc 1a-
rauccrc aucuucrc cy(a r. Mcca: ra(a-
uuu M. :x nu+uau auucau: a ccacacuuu
ncc.ynxcuuu, nc(ycc.cuu:x +. 2 c.. 228
\K IU, u ccy(cu ccu rc(a xuacuua
cacc(: nc +. 2 c.. 228 \K IU c+ a.aa
u na.u rc(a xuacuua cacc(: nc +. 2
c.. 228 \K IU c+ a.aa, accrc c ny.c
+ac.u+ucrc cxccuua ua ccucaauuu +. J c.. 69
\K IU ~ acc:u rc(a xuacuua cacc-
(: c+ a.aa c c.:aauuc uaa+auua a uc-
naau.cx:ucu cxcuuu c_crc cua.
Kaccaqucuu: cnc(cxcuuc cy(cucu
cxxcruu nc yrcxcau: (cxa Mcccaccrc
rcc(ccrc cy(a c. JJ ccu.aa 2OO6 rc(a
nurcac 1arauccrc aucuucrc cy(a r. Mcc-
a: cc.aaxcu c+ u+cucuua.
M. nu+uau auucau::
~ a uc+acuuc nucc.cuuu u xauc-
uuu c+ qcxu c:.a (c 9 +. 2O uu. 2J.OJ.2OO6
a r. ^cq: Mcccaccu cxac.u uac.u-
+ccux cc(c.a a cccc ynuc a+cc ~
J99,52 r cauua u JOO,27 r c.a(cua;
~ a uc+acuuc nucc.cuuu u xauc-
uuu c+ qcxu c:.a (c 9 +. 2O uu. 2J.OJ.2OO6
a r. Mccac nc cc.y caccrc u.cx:c.aa ua-
c.u+ccux cc(c.a a cccc ynuc a+cc
(5,4 r c.a(cua).
,cuc.aua ccy(cuucrc, a:a+uaaucca a uc-
+acuuc nucc.cuuu u xaucuuu nu ccc
J99,52 r cauua u JOO,27 r c.a(cua, ua(xc-
a_u ca+c aaxuuqucaau: nc +. 2
c.. 228 \K IU a uc+acuucc nucc.c-
uuc u xaucuuc c+ qcxu c:.a uac.u+ccc-
rc cc(c.aa a cccc ynuc a+cc.
O(uac a .c c aca cy( c+ (cc.a.c+-
u:x .cy ccucaauuu a:(cxux a cacc.ca-
.cx:u:u nu+c( u aaxuuqucaax nc +. 2
c.. 228 \K IU uc+acuucc xaucuuc M. nc
cc.y u.cx:c.aa c_c 5,4 r c.a(cua.
H+ a.cuaxca (cxa au(uc, +.c ccy(cu-
u:u a c(uu u .c. c ncuc( accuu uc+acu-
uc xauux uac.u+cccc cc(c.ac c(ucrc u
.crc c au(a, nu+c cx:ay crc +ac.: ~
ucnccc(c.acuuc nu ccc, a cu:ay ~ nc
cc.y u.cx:c.aa. 2J auaaa 2OO6 rc(a acc:
xauuaauuca M. cauu u c.a(cu :x y ucrc
cc.y(uuau c(ucrc u .crc c nc(a+(cxc-
uua \UCKH IU nc r. Mccac u+.a.. lu
.c nc caccu accc a c.(cx:uc a+a.cc ua-
c.u+cccc cc(c.ac, xauuaaccca M. nu ccc,
.a u c_cc cxu+cc.ac u+.a.crc y ucrc ua-
c.ua nc(c.aaxac. cccu cccc ynu:u
a+c uac.u+ccux cc(c.a, uc+acuu:u
ccc. c.c:x c+ qcxu c:.a axc+c. c.ac.-
c.acuucc.: nc +. 2 c.. 228 \K IU.
lu .aux cc.ca.cx:c.aax nc.uacnaa-
u:c (cuc.aua M., uc+aaucuc c. cnccca xa-
ucuua u cxu+cc.aa xauuxu_, cxaa.:aaxuc:
c(uu: y:cxc ua uc+acuucc xaucuuc ua-
c.u+ccux cc(c.a a cccc ynuc a+cc,
u nc.cy cc(cauucc ncxucc.: nc(na(ac. nc(
nu+uau c(uucrc ncc.ynxcuua, nc(ycc.cu-
ucrc +. 2 c.. 228 \K IU, u (cncxuu.cx:ucu
aaxuuaquu a(:u nu+c( uc .cyc..
Occcc auuauuc cxc(yc. ca.u.: ua .c,
+.c Bcxcau:u Cy( IU a c+cc cy(cucu
na.uu +a 2OO7 rc( c(uc+ua+uc ya+ax, +.c
ucc(uca.u:c (cuc.aua a c.ucacuuu c(ucrc
u .crc c c.c.a ncc.ynucrc nccara.cx:-
c.aa, uanaaxcuu:c ua (cc.ucuuc c(uucrc
c+yx:.a.a, ccacacuu:c .c c cy.c.c
a uccx:acu nccy.c accuu auaxcru+-
u: cncccc, ca+y. c(uucc ncc.ynxcuuc
u uc .cy. (cncxuu.cx:ucu aaxuuaquu
(cuc.auu, nc(acc.acaaaaux (cc.ucuu nc-
c.ynucrc c+yx:.a.a.
B caa+u c .u (cuc.aua M., +a c.c:c
cu (aa(: ccy(cu nc +. 2 c.. 228 \K IU,
nc(xca. aaxuuaquu nc +. 2 c.. 228 \K
IU a uc+acuucc nucc.cuuc u xaucuuc
c+ qcxu c:.a uac.u+ccux cc(c.a a ccc-
c ynuc a+cc c ua+ua+cuuc nc .cu
c.a.:c yrcxcaucrc uaa+auua.
1au ca+c, nu accc.cuuu (cxa :xc
(cny_cuc ucnaaux:ucc nucucuuc yrcxcauc-
rc +acua, +.c a ccc.ac.c.auu cc c.. 4O9 u n. J
+. J c.. J79 \lK IU (cxuc ncaxc+: ncc-
cc. cy(cucrc nurcaca a nca(c ua(+ca.
Bcc ua(+cu:c uuc.auquu :xu ncu(cu:
u uu.c uc ca.ux auuauuc ua (auucc uay-
acuuc +acua.
O.ac. +acc.u.cxa lc(cc(a.cxa BC IU
c.ax c+cc(ucu cax:ucu c.nuccu,
H. B. Heonoe. A. K. lomuun. acu uxu cnca.uaucc.:'
JJ4
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
uc ccc.ac.c.ay_cu uuau ncxccuua \rc-
xcaucrc c(cca: ...,cac(: ua(+cucu axc-
: c .c, +.c (cuc.aua M. (cxu: :.: aa-
xuuqucaau: a c(uc ncc.ynxcuuc, aaxa-
.ca ucccc.ca.cx:u:u. Cy(c yc.aucaxcuc,
+.c y:ccx M. :x uanaaxcu ua ccacacuuc
(ayx ncc.ynxcuuu....
lu .acu xcruc ncxy+ac.ca, +.c ccxu
auucau:u xauu. uac.uu (ca u y cca
a aauc (xa xu+ucrc ync.cxcuua, .c .c
a+u:u y:ccx' Hcuuc a cy(c u :xc (ca-
+auc, +.c y:ccx y M. :x c(uu ~ ync.c-
u.: uac.u cacy. H uu+crc (yrcrc cy
uc acuaxcc:. Ka c nu .ac ncxccuuu
ac_cu cuc rcacu.: c ccacacuuu M. (ayx
ncc.ynxcuuu'
B:ucca:aac.ca naa(ccax:uaa cu.yaqua.
Bcxcau:u Cy( Icccuuccu Uc(caquu ca
yc.auaaxuaac. na.uy accc.cuua nc(cucrc
c(a (cx u c(ucaccuuc ca c cc cncacra-
c.. B caa+u c .u +aa(:aac.ca ccucuuc
a .c, +u.ac. xu acc_c .c-uuy(: axc:, ua-
naaxcuu:c a ua(+cu:c uuc.auquu.
lcuaa, +.c a cy(cu:x uuc.auquax (cu.:ca
naa(: ucac+cuc, a(aca. ca.uxca c ua(-
+cucu axccu a lcya.yy r. Mcca:.
Oa_cuuc :xc accc.cuc, nc c+yx:.a-
.a ncacu +acc.u.cxc ncyca r. Mcc-
a: :xc aucccuc ua(+cucc nc(c.aaxcuuc
a Mcccacuu rcc(ccu cy( ua nc(c. nc-
caaxuuaquu (cuc.auu M. u cuucuua ua-
+ua+cuucrc cy uaa+auua.
O(uac acncu +(aacy c:cxy u cna.:
ncxucc.: urucuya \rcxcau:u c(cc Mcc-
cacuu rcc(ccu cy( cc.aaux ua(+cucc nc(-
c.aaxcuuc c+ y(caxc.accuua, xc.a auaxcru+-
u:c (cuc.aua .c. c Mcccacuu rcc(ccu
cy( u uu:c cy(: IU aaxuuquy. uua+c
(uanuc, ncc.aucaxcuuc lc+u(uya Mcc-
caccrc rcc(ccrc cy(a c. 24 ancxa
2OO8 rc(a nc (cxy ` 44y-2J2O8, ncc.aucaxc-
uuc lc+u(uya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a Iccnyxu-
u Kacxua c. JO ccu.aa 2OO8 rc(a u .. (.).
lccxc c.a+a a y(caxc.accuuu ua(+cucu
axc: a(aca. a ccc.ac.c.auu c \lK IU
ca.uxca nca.cuc a lcya.yy r. Mcca:
c ncc:cu c aucccuuu ua(+cucrc nc(c.aa-
xcuua nc(cc(a.cx Mcccaccrc rcc(ccrc
cy(a u ncxy+ux c.ac., +.c ccucaauuu (xa auc-
ccuua ua(+cucrc nc(c.aaxcuua uc yc.auca-
xcuc u +.c acc cacuua cy(a aaxuuqucaa-
u: naaux:uc. 1c cc.: ccucaauua (xa auccc-
uua ua(+cucrc nc(c.aaxcuua .u ccaqa ua+a(
:xu, a ccu+ac ux uc c.axc' A ac(: ua a.c
c.cu. +cxcac+ccaa u+u:, nyc.: (ac u u+u:
ncc.ynuua.
Hxu uc cucc naa(ccax:uaa cu.yaqua.
lurcacc Ccuaacccrc aucuucrc
cy(a Icc.caccu cxac.u K. :x nu+uau au-
ucau: a ccacacuuu ncc.ynxcuuu, nc(ycc.-
cuu:x +. J c.. J59 \K IU, u ccy(cu na.u
rc(a u .c ccaqa xuacuua cacc(: c+
a.aa a ucnaau.cx:ucu cxcuuu c_crc c-
ua. Cy( nu+uax crc auucau: a xu_cuuu
uy_cc.aa Ccuaacccu uc.ca+: u nu-
ua(xca_ux cu (cucu:x cc(c.a.
O(uac cy(c aaxuuaqua (cuc.auu K.,
caa+auu:x c xu_cuuc uy_cc.aa Ccuaa-
cccu uc.ca+:, :xa ncu+ac(cua ucua(-
xca_u ca+c. Cy( aaxuuqucaax nc-
c.ynxcuua, ccacacuu:c K., a {:+qucc+.
,xa_ccca ncc.ynxcuuc ua+uuac.ca c ccu-
.a ccacacuua ncc.ynucrc (cuc.aua u cu-
+ac.ca acxc(c.auc (cuc.aua cacrc auucaucrc,
uanaaxcuucrc nca_cuu ncc.ynxcuua,
uxu uac.ynxcuua cc:.uu, ncna.c.ay_ux
ccacacuu ncc.ynxcuua (uanuc, acaa-
.cx:c.ac crauca axac.u).
Cc (aaucc.u yrcxcaucrc nccxc(caauua
a c.ucacuuu (xa_uxca ncc.ynxcuuu uc+uc-
xac.ca cc accuu ux nca_cuua nc acxc
uxu acncu acxc auucaucrc ((ccacx:ucc
a:ncxucuuc auucau: cacux ca+auucc.cu, aaa
c ncauuucu, +a(cauuc crauau axac.u u (.).
1acrc c(a ncc.ynxcuua xaa.cu+y.ca
ucnc:au: ccy_cc.axcuuc ccc.aaa cnc-
(cxcuucrc ncc.ynucrc (cauua. Huuuuu-
yc:c K. (cauua nc a:ac(a cy(a ncu+ca-
xu a ncuc( J99J2OOO rc(ca.
O(uac cy(c uc :xc y+.cuc, +.c a ncu-
c( ccacacuua uuuuuuyc:x K. (cauuu
nccxc(uuu c c.aa J997 rc(a nc auaa:
J999 rc(a uaxc(uxca nc( c.acu u uua
uc cr ccacau.: ya+auu:c ncc.ynxcuua.
JJ5
Cy(, cc:xaac: ua cau(c.cxcu, c.c:c nc-
a+axu a cy(cuc +acc(auuu, +.c a ccu.
uaxc(cuua K. a CHO cuu ncxy+axu ya-
+auua c cacuuu+ccux (cuc.auax c. c(-
c.acuuuca ccy(cuucrc, uc y(ccyuxca (cn-
ccu.: a cy(cuc +acc(auuu uu c(ucrc u+
.ux c(c.acuuuca u ncc+u.ax (cauua, cc-
acacuu:c K., c(uu: ncc.ynxcuuc, uc c-
a.ua auuauuc ua .c, +.c acc ncc.ynxcuua
ccacacu: a a+xu+u:c nccy.u accuu,
nu a+xu+u:x cc.ca.cx:c.aax, a c.ucac-
uuu a+xu+u:x nc(c.ca, a+xu+u:u cnc-
ccau u .. (., +.c a ccc.ac.c.auu c +. J
c.. J7 \K IU ca+yc. ccacynucc.: nc-
c.ynxcuuu. lcxu : cy( nucuux c.. J7 \K
IU, .c u+-+a ccca (aaucc.u nuaxca.:
K. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u :xc :
ucx:+a. Hc a+ cc.: cauucuuc, .c (cxcu
:.: u nurcac, nu+c ucnccuuc cau-
uu.cx:u:ul
H+ .ux (ayx nucca cuc c(cxa.: a:-
ac( c qcxcccca+ucc.u ua a:ccc ycauc ~
a aax lxcuya Bcxcaucrc Cy(a IU ~
(a.: acaucuucc .cxcaauuc c(uu:x, nc(cx-
ac:x u (xa_uxca ncc.ynxcuuu c y+c.c
ccaccuucrc ccc.cauua ncc.ynucc.u, a uc
nc+acxa.: cy(:a acca.uaa.: nc(cu:c
(cxa a +aaucucc.u c. ux uac.ccuua.
1aux nucca a ccrc(uaauc naaccy-
(uu .:ca+u u cc.:ca c .au ncxccuuc
ac_cu ucac+cuc u+-+a +acuca, c.c:u
cy(:u cca crcc(uxu. Oc.ac.ca ua(c(a, +.c
xc.a : nca:c xuqa Icccuuccu Ucu(:
cc.aucaa. curxucaauuc +acuc. Ka cc.a-
c.ca u ua(c(a ua .c, +.c cuu uacucq y(ccy-
a.ca ncauaxu+ucaa.: .c ca:c ucnaac-
cy(u:c nurcac: cy(ca, c.c:c .a uu.c u
uc c.cuux, u a:cay.ca c acnu_ux uay-
acuuax +acua cacuu nc(+uucuu:u. lca
.crc, ya:, uc ncu+caxc.
H. B. Heonoe. A. K. lomuun. acu uxu cnca.uaucc.:'
JJ6
Ia+au.uc +cxcaca u xu+ucc.u cxca.u+uc cuc u+ca-
+u.: cxc(y_cu ncuc(u+aqucu, c.aa_cu .an: u ycu
a+au.ua xu+ucc.u. S.c, a cnaac(xuac a:(cxac. K. K. lxa-
.cuca, +c.:c ncuc(a a+au.ua +cxcaca a xu+ucc.u: ncua-
.ax:u:u; ncc.ua.ax:u:u (uc (c .crc, cr(a ccuc c.aucau.ca
xu+ucc.:); (c .crc ccu.a, cr(a +cxcaca cuc ua+aa.:
xc.: uuuax:uc, uc ccquax:uc +cxcu xu+ucc.:; ncuc( (ax:-
ucuacrc crc ccquax:ucrc ccacacuc.acaauua
J
.
1ac K. K. lxa.cuca a:(cxac. c_c (aa yca a+au.ua
xu+ucc.u:
J. JO xc. (nxc-uuyc (aa rc(a) ~ ncccqcua caccrc u+-
ucuucrc ny.u, cr(a +cxcac uc .cx:c +a(y:aac.ca ua( na-
aux:ucc.: crc a:ca, uc u ucrcc a uc ucnaaxac.;
2. 55 xc. (nxc-uuyc .u rc(a) ~ nc(ncucucuucc nxauu-
caauuc ncucucuucrc ncuc(a u+uu.
,ax:ucuacc a+au.uc xu+ucc.u crauu+cuc cc-
.: xuc .acx: ncuxu+ccu +acxcaauuc
2
.
B:(cxcuuc (auu:x .anca u yccu a+au.ua
xu+ucc.u aaxac.ca a nuuqunc c_cnuua.: a ncu-
xcxcruu, c(uac +acxyuaa_cu auuauua aaxac.ca
cxca .anca u yccu a+au.ua xu+ucc.u, nc(c.aaxcuuaa
K. K. lxa.cuca:, a:(cxuaau cxc(y_uc .an:: ncua.ax:-
u:u ncuc(; xa(cu+cc.ac; c.aucaxcuuc; xu+ucc.u; nccccuc-
uax:ucc a+au.uc; racuu+ucc ccacacuc.acaauuc; c.a+ccaa
(cra(aqua
J
.
C+u.ac.ca, +.c nc(xuuucc cucaauuc xu+ucc.u ax+a-
c. a cca (aa xccu.a: cc+caauuc u cucaauuc. lcaca
c cc+caauuu, : ucc a au(y u+u+ccy nuc(y +cxcaca u
a+au.uc crc crauu+a. Ha cucaauuu c c.cu. cc.auc-
au.:ca nc(cucc. B uaac cxy+ac cucaauuc cc.: a+au-
.uc nc( axuauuc aucauux u auy.cuuux a.cca.
A. ,. Kuusvnuu
Orcxrnrc acncrrr
u nccxcouannn xnunocrn momcnnnra
na prnrc ucnnr 6ymar
Apvem muvpueuun Knnauuun,
acnnpan xaqepu yroroanoro npaaa,
xpnunnarncnxn n xpnunnorornn
Hopoacxoro rocyapcaennoro
ynnaepcnea
J
C.: H:omonoe l. l. C.y.ya u a+au.uc xu+ucc.u. M., J986.
C. 227.
2
1a c. C. 228.
J
1a c. C. 2JJ.
JJ7
Ucucaauuc xu+ucc.u nc( ac+(cuc.au-
c aucauux a.cca ~ .c, uanuc, nu-
ua(xcucc.: uu(uau(yya cnc(cxcuucu
yx:.yc, ccquax:uc-cucu+cccy xaccy,
cc:c u n.
Ucucaauuc c xu+ucc.u nc( ac+(cu-
c.auc auy.cuuux a.cca uarxa(uc ncaa-
xac.ca a rcuc.u+ccux, ucxcru+ccux, u+u-
+ccux a.cax
4
.
B qcxc a+au.uc xu+ucc.u nucy_c acc
x(a, c(uac ncuxcxcru+cccc a+au.uc xu+-
ucc.u ncucxc(u. nc cnc(cxcuucu c(cxu,
cc+ua+cuucu uau a:ac.
B .cu caa+u aaxac.ca a.yax:u: cc-
+ua+cuuc uau .crc ccu.a a+au.ua xu+uc-
c.u, a c.c:u ncucxc(u. cucaauuc y:c-
xa y xuqa ua ccacacuuc ncc.ynxcuua a cc-
c qcuu:x yar, u ucuuc c .crc ccu.a
cuc c+u.a.:, +.c ua+uuac. cucaa.:ca
xu+ucc.: ncc.ynuua. ,c .crc ccu.a xuqc
a+auaac.ca nc c_cncuxcxcru+ccu .ccu-
a u aucua, c(uac c ac+uuucacuuc y xuqa
+aaucc ac+uuacrc y:cxa ua ccacacuuc
ncc.ynxcuua xuc c.(cx:u:x crc +a+a.ca,
(cnc(xuuuc ua+uua_ux +aaxa(caa.: xu+uc-
c.:, u ac+uuac. xu+ucc.:, rc.caaa ncc.y-
nu.: +cc+ +acu a(u y(caxc.accuua cacux
ncy(cuuu, uxu (ac c.ua ccacacuua nc-
c.ynxcuua.
Hcuuc c .crc ccu.a ac+uuac. xu+-
ucc.: ncc.ynuua, c.c:u anccxc(c.auu c.a-
ucau.ca auc ac uaac.acuucrc a+au.ua
c_cc.aa u a:+:aac. ucra.uauy cqcuy c-
_cc.acuucc.u.
B (auuc cxy+ac ~ a yrcxcauc-naacacu
caa+u ~ y:ccx aaxac.ca accr(a +aaucc c-
(yauu:, .c cc.: na:, c +c cau(c.cx:-
c.ayc. ncxc(cuuc, uanuc, ncqc(y: c-
ruc.aquu a a+cc.ac y+ac.uua :ua qcuu:x
yar (.c cc.: .a ua+:aaccrc urca :ua
qcuu:x yar) u a:xc( ua .crcay nxc_a(y
+cc+ cnauu, nc(cc.aaxa_y nc(cucrc
c(a nccc(uu+ccy ycxyry (cc, (uxc).
Ia+auaaa acncc c cucaauuu xu+ucc-
.u ncc.ynuua, : rcacu c .c, +.c cy.c-
.c a:xc(a ua :uc qcuu:x yar cc.
:.: xuqc, (cc.uracc ccacacuucxc.ucrc ac+-
ac.a, nc+acxa_crc +acruc.ucaa.:ca a a-
+cc.ac y+ac.uua :ua qcuu:x yar u ncx-
ucqcuuc caxu+ca:aa.: c+ +:cu xuc cau-
quu cacu naaa u ca+auucc.u. O(uac cr-
xacu.au cnauuu, uanuc AO Uuua
uxu OOO lKC, nc(ycc.cuc, +.c y+ac.-
uuc :ua qcuu:x yar cc. :.: xuqc,
(cc.uracc +c.:ua(qa.u xc., uc c ccrxacua
cacux +acuu:x nc(c.aau.cxcu, (auucrc a nc-
c.cu nuc:cuucu cc a nucy.c.auu nc(-
c.aau.cxcu uuacc.uqucuucu cnauuu.
B a+au.uc (auucrc acncca ua uaa a+rxa(
cxc(yc. nuacc.u .acu nuc: ccxu xuqc uc-
c. (cc.a.c+u:u ycacu: uu.cxxc.yax:ucrc a+-
au.ua, cncca_uu ac+ac.ucu nca+a.cx:, .c
ac+ccu nuxc( cxc(y_cu ncc.ynucu cxcc
ncxy+cuua (cc.yna ua :uc qcuu:x yar.
Hcccacacuucxc.uuu nccu. a+ccxcrc +cxc-
aca ncu+acc.u ua cca cruc.aqu a a+c-
c.ac y+ac.uua :ua qcuu:x yar (uxu +a-
cuu:x nc(c.aau.cxcu ~ (a.: ccrxacuc ua
(cuc.aua ucccacacuucxc.ucrc (xa cccnc+c-
uua crc (cc.yna .crcacu nxc_a(c), auccu.
ucy cyy (cucu:x cc(c.a ua cacu c+c.
a a+cc.ac uuuax:ucrc a+ucca, ccc.aaxa_c-
rc ua ccrc(uaauuu (cu: uc cucc JO OOO y-
xcu, ncxy+ac. nacxu (cc.yna u cncquax:uy
.crcay ncray, +cc+ c.cy ncucxc(a.
.cru c ucncx:+caauuc cc.u Hu.cuc.. A +a-
.c a+ccx:u +cxcac, (cuc.ay_uu a uu.cc-
cax ncc.ynuua, ncc(ac. .u nacxu ucccac-
acuucxc.ucy xuqy, c.ccc a cac c+cc(:
ucc. y:ccx ua ccacacuuc ncc.ynxcuua.
(cc: xc.cxcc: : c.(cx:uc cc.aucau.:ca
ua cxc(y_c. C.cu. ca.u.:ca cauquu
c.a.:u c.. J59 (Mcacuuu+cc.ac) \K IU,
nc(yca.uaa_cu yrcxcauy c.ac.c.acuucc.:
c J6 xc., u caauu.: c .c, +.c cnauuu ccc-
nc+uaa. (cc.yn .crca: nxc_a(a xu-
qa c J4 xc.. Ua.u+ccu y uac ncxy+ac.ca,
+.c xuqc, ccacauaacc ncc.ynxcuuc ua :uc
qcuu:x yar a (auu:u ac+ac.ucu ncuc(
(c J4 (c J6 xc.), a:na(ac. u+ naacacrc ncxa u
4
O a.cax cucaauua xu+ucc.u c. [Sxc-
.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l||:.sy-
lilcs.rubiblJ76-lal|cry-lcroircvaaija-liclacs|i.l|ol.
A. . ln+.oun. Hccxc(caauuc xu+ucc.u cacuuua ua :uc qcuu:x yar
JJ8
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
uc nc(xcu. yrcxcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u nc (au-
ucu c.a.:c. 1c ca: cnauuu cau a:xc-
(a. uxu ccc+uauuc c.aa.ca a:u.u u+ ncxa
naacacrc cryxucaauua :ua qcuu:x yar.
Cxc(yc. y(cxu.: auuauuc .cy, +.c xu+-
ucc.: a ncuc( cucaauua ncc.ynu:x ua-
xcuucc.cu, ccxu .c xuqc ucccac(cxcuucc
a urc ua :uc qcuu:x yar, c.cu.ca nc-
xy+u.: uaucx:acc cxu+cc.ac +uauuu c (au-
ucu cxac.u c .c+u +cuua a +acua (a +a-
c.ucc.u, +acuc(a.cx:c.aa c :uc qcuu:x
yar), .a u nccc(c.ac ccc( u c_cuua
c cc.y(uuau uuaucca:x cnauuu, ccy-
(cuua ua cucu+ccux cyax, c.cxcuaa-
uua cucu+cccu uucaquu; .ac cuc
cc. accnuuua.: auc-xuc (cuc.aua a a-
+cc.ac c_cc.acuucu caquu ua ncucxc(a-
_uc a rccy(ac.ac cc:.ua: c: nc cryxu-
caauu :ua qcuu:x yar xuc cc+(auuc
uxu xuau(aqua aux-xuc cnauuu.
Ucucaauuc xu+ucc.u ncc.ynuua
a ccc :ua qcuu:x yar cc. ncucxc-
(u.: a c.uxuuuc, .a u qcxcuanaaxcuuc, +.c
(xa uuuaxuc.ca ucc., c+ycxcauc, nu-
xa(ucc +ua+cuuc.
Qcxcuanaaxcuucc cucaauuc xu+ucc-
.u ncc.ynuua, ccacaa_crc ncc.ynxcuuc ua
:uc qcuu:x yar, cuc nc(c.aau.: a .a-
cu nccxc(caa.cx:ucc.u: a:xc( ua :uc qcu-
u:x yar, u+y+cuuc uca.uaucu a+:, y+ac.uc
a .crax, ccacacuuc ncc.ynxcuua. lu+c
accuucu nccy.c c(y a:xc(c ua :-
uc qcuu:x yar u ccacacuuc ncc.ynxc-
uua cc. :.: a+xu+u:: ucrcc +aaucu. c.
nc(rc.caxcuucc.u xuqa a nxauc uuauccacu
rac.ucc.u, c. cxauua ucn:.a.: +yac.ac ur:
u a+a.a u .. n. O(uac (cnc(xuuuc u+acc.uc,
+.c xuqc, c(ua(: ccacauaacc nc(cucrc c(a
ncc.ynxcuuc u c+uaa+auuc yac(acc c. yrc-
xcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u (cc.cc.acuuc, : nc(-
a+ycaac, +.c nu .c ncc.ynuu ncxy+ac.
uuaucca:u a:ur:a, c.c:u +a+ac.y cc-
c.aaxac. nuxu+uy cyy), ca+a.cx:uc ccac-
au. nc(cucrc c c(a (cauuc u a y(y_c.
Bccuucu nccy.c cc. ccc.aaxa.: c.
ucccx:ux (ucu (c a(a xc., uc ncc.ynuu
ca+a.cx:uc ncu(c. ua .acu aar.
C.uxuuucc c cucaauuc xu+ucc.u nc-
c.ynuua, ccacaa_crc ncc.ynxcuuc ua :u-
c qcuu:x yar, cuc nc(c.aau.: a au(c
cxc(y_cu c(cxu. lc( ac+(cuc.auc cux:uc-
rc ncuxcxcru+cccrc ccc.cauua, a:+aauucrc, ua-
nuc, ccrc(uaauuu caxuau, ncucxc(a_u-
u a uaacu c.auc cucu+ccuu cc:.uau,
caa+auu:u c acncc.aucuuc u ycuxcuuc
cucu+cccrc u+uca, ncuc(c cna(a nc-
u+ac(c.aa, xuqc, ncy(accc, nucy, cxa-
uuc a ccxauu.:, .a u ncyucu.: cacu
ccccuua, nyc.: +a+ac.y u ncc.ynu: ny-
.c, c.cu.ca a acuax:uc cc.uc ccu
u+y+u.: uuauccay c.ccuy :ua qcuu:x
yar u nc ac+cucc.u, ncccx:y a c+yx:.a-
.c cucu+cccrc cna(a uaac ncu+ac(c.ac
cca_ac.ca, a c.cucc.: ncu+ac(c.acuu:x
a.uaca na(ac., cynu.: uxu au-xuc nc-
c.ynu: ca+c +aaxa(c.: uuaucca:u a-
.uaau nc(nua.ua, +.c a ncuc( cucu+cc-
crc u+uca c.aucau.ca ac+cuc. B c+yx:-
.a.c .crc ncc.ynucrc +aaxa(cuua a.uaau
nc(nua.uu cac nc(nua.uc nc(na(ac. nc(
cu.cx: .a ua+:aac:x ncc.ynuuca.
B caa+u c a:acca+auu:, : ca_ac
nuc.ax:ucc auuauuc ua .c, +.c uccxc(u
._a.cx:u:u rccy(ac.acuu:u cu.cx: a
uca.uaucu a+: :ua qcuu:x yar, .a u
uca.uaucrc u uuauccacrc cc.ca nc(-
nua.ua, +.c c.aucau.ca uaucxcc a.yax:uc
a caxuax ccaccuucu Icccuu.
Ucucaauuc u a+au.uc xu+ucc.u, ccac-
aa_cu ncc.ynxcuuc ua :uc qcuu:x yar,
uccu. uuuaxuc.u+ccu nuxa(ucu xaa-
.c, .a a nc+acxac. a:aaxa.: uuuaxuc.u-
+ccu +ua+u:c cxc(: ccacacuua, cc:.ua
ncc.ynxcuua, nc+acxac. a:aau.: ca cxauu+
cxc(cca+caauua. Hanuc, ncc.ynuu, ccxu
cu uc. nc nccccuu, ucc. a ncay c+c-
c(: cxcuucc.: auaxu+y uca.uaucu a+:,
a .cx:c +a.c ~ u+y+cuu uuauccacu c.c-
cu: ncc.ynxcuua. B c.ucacuuu ncc.ynuu-
a-uuaucuc.a cuc a:(cxu.: ca.uy .cu-
(cuqu: cacuuu ncacua+ax:uc c.aac.ca
u+y+u.: uuaucca:c acncc: u cxauu+: (au-
cuua :ua, uc ca_aa auuauua ua u(u-
+ccy ccc.aaxa_y :ua qcuu:x yar,
JJ9
uc nu(aaaa cu cy_cc.acuucrc +ua+cuua, c(ua-
c accnuuuaa cc a (cry. H+ .crc cxc(yc.,
+.c .uncxcrua ncc.ynuuca nc(ncxarac. c.-
xu+ua a aucc ncac(cuua, a .ac a cc.aaxc-
uuu cxc(ca a ua cc.c ccacacuucrc nc-
c.ynxcuua, .a u a cc.ax nc:aauua ncc.yn-
uua ua ccu. ccacacuua u ncc.ynxcuua,
+.c aaxac.ca ccccuuc +ua+u: (xa uu-
uaxuc.ca a ccc uucaquu a c cac
ncc.ynxcuuu, .a u c ncc.ynuuc.
lu accxc(caauuu ncc.ynxcuuu (auucrc
c(a uc cxc(yc. +a:aa.: nc .c, +.c uu-
uaxuc.a, a .ac ac.uua cxc(c.aua, cxc-
(yc. ca_a.: auuauuc c_c u ua .c xccu-
.:, c.c:c ncaxuaxu ua a:c ncc.ynuua
a ncx:+y ccacaaccrc ncc.ynxcuua, uxu, a
cnc(cxac. C. B. lc+u:aca, cxcuaxu u cnc-
ccc.acaaxu, .c cc.: axuaxu ua c(cxauu:u nc-
c.ynuuc a:c a ncx:+y ccacacuua nc-
c.ynxcuua, a .ac ua .c xccu.:, c.c:c
cxyuxu uc.c+uuc c.uaca, y(cuaa_ux
uxu c..axuaa_ux c. ccacacuua ncc.yn-
xcuua u nc(ca+:aa_ux uucu a:xc( u+ cc-
+(aaacrcca ncxccuua
5
.
B caa+u c .u cuc ncacc.u uuua-
xuc.u+ccy .uncxcru ncc.ynuuca, ccac-
aa_ux cacuuu+cc.ac ua :uc qcuu:x
yar, a +aaucucc.u c. c+yx:.a.ca ac+(cu-
c.aua ua uux a.cca, ncaxuaaaux ua ccac-
acuuc (auucu a+ucau(ucc.u ncc.ynxcuuu.
S.c, uanuc, cry. :.: c:c.u:c ncy-
(cuua, a+a., uc, ncau+u:u uu.ccc axc-
cuu (cucr u ccxaucuu ccccuuu u (y-
ruc. lu .c aca .uncxcrua nu accxc(caa-
uuu ncc.ynxcuuu (auucrc c(a uccu. uu-
uaxuc.u+ccu nuxa(ucu xaa.c.
B a+cc.ac c y(cuaa_ux c. ncc.yn-
xcuua a.cca cuc nuacc.u ca+u: yrc-
xcaucu c.ac.c.acuucc.u, uaac.acuuy uccnc-
ccucc.: xuqa ua ccacacuuc ncc.ynxcuua,
uccncccucc.: xuqa ua ccacacuuc ncc.yn-
xcuua a caa+u c uaqucuax:u:u u cxuruc+-
u:u yc.cau, uccncccucc.: xuqa ua ccac-
acuuc ncc.ynxcuua a caa+u c ncxy+cuu:
accnu.auuc, a caa+u c uc(cc.a.c+ucc.: +ua-
uuu u ucruc (yruc a.c: (ycxcauc :
cc ua+aa.: ux aucauuu u auy.cuuuu,
uc ca+a.cx:uc cy_cc.acuuc axua_uu ua
a:c xuqa a ncx:+y c.a+a c. ccacacuua
ncc.ynxcuua).
5
C.: Ho.nomce C. B. Kuuuaxuc.u+ccaa
ncuxcxcrua: ncc.ynu:c .un:. O ncuxcxcru+cc-
c uccxc(caauuu xu+ucc.u a cy.c.a ncac-
(cuua acc_c u c u+y+cuuu xu+ucc.u ncc.yn-
uua a +ac.ucc.u. M., 2OO7. C. 8.
A. . ln+.oun. Hccxc(caauuc xu+ucc.u cacuuua ua :uc qcuu:x yar
J2O
B cx:auuc.ac cxy+aca nu accxc(caauuu yrcxcaucrc (cxa
cxc(caa.cx: c.axuaac.ca c uccxc(ucc.: nucucuua cnc-
quax:u:x nc+uauuu (xa naaux:ucu cqcuu cc.ca.cx:c.a (cxa.
B .acu cu.yaquu nu+aaua ncc+: cnc.u+a. lu+c +acu,
a+ycc.ca, uc crauu+uaac. c.acxu +uauuu, a cxac.u c.c:x
cc. nc.ccaa.:ca ncac(cuuc cnc.u+. O(uac, u+y+aa
a.cuax: yrcxcau:x (cx, : nuaxu a:ac(y, +.c ua na.uc
na.u+ccu accr(a ucncx:+yc.ca c.au(a.u:u uac cnc-
.u+ ~ CMS, KllS, cy(cuc-yxrax.ccaa, axxuc.u+ccaa, .a-
ccxcru+ccaa u ucc.c:c (yruc, ncxu:u ncc+cu: c.c:x
u+acc.cu, a nc.cy uc .cyc. nuac(cuua. 1c uc cucc, nu
accxc(caauuu qcxcrc a(a ncc.ynxcuuu .cyc.ca nucucuuc
cncquax:u:x nc+uauuu a uu:x c.acxax +uauuu, uc axc(a_ux
a .a(uqucuu:u ncc+cu:, a caa+u c +c ac+uua. ucc.c-
:c ncxc:. Ha+ua+cuuc cnc.u+: nc .au
(cxa ~ nccra.uaa cxc(caa.cxa u cy(a, u c. ux
ycc.cuua +aaucu., a cuc+uc u.crc, y(c. xu nc-
ac(cuc uccxc(caauuc.
lc (cxa c ncc.ynxcuuax, ccacacuu:x nc
c.uay caucu cc.u uxu uaqucuax:ucu aa(:,
nc uaacy ucuu, uccxc(uc ncac(cuuc .ucxcru+cccu u
.ucrau+cccu cnc.u+:. O(uac .aaa cnc.u+a na-
.u+ccu uucr(a uc ua+ua+ac.ca (cc.: ucx+cuua).
S.ucxcru+ccaa cnc.u+a anca:c cnc(cxcua a ncua-
.uc a Uc(cax:uc +acuc c. JO.O4.J999 ` 82-U O raau-
.uax naa ccuu:x axc+ucxcuu:x uac(ca IU. B c.. J ya-
+auucrc +acua ca+auc, +.c .ucxcru+ccaa cnc.u+a ~ .c
uay+ucc uccxc(caauuc axuauua u+cucuuu uccuucu cc(: cu-
.auua axc+ucxcuu:x uac(ca u ccquax:uc-yx:.yucu cu.ya-
quu ua a+au.uc .ucca. \a+auucc cnc(cxcuuc uccnaa(auuc
cyac. cxac.: nucucuua cncquax:u:x nc+uauuu a cxac.u
.ucxcruu (xa qcxcu naacnucucuua. 1aaa cnc.u+a, ua
uaa a+rxa(, crxa : ncac(u.:ca uc .cx:c a cxy+ac cac-
uua acncca c ncac(cuuu a+ac(u u a+ac.u cc.cc-
(cuuu a aucuax Kauucrc Ccaca u axuauuu .aux (cuc.auu
M. A. 1o:vno
K uonpocy o6 ncnoxrsouannn
ncrpanunonnr unou rcncprns
npn paccxcouannn yroxounr cx
Mapuna Aneucanppouna monuuo,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx, oen xaqepu
npaaoaoro peryrnpoaanne axonounecxnx
onouennn a npouuurennocn Heacxoro
rocyapcaennoro exnnecxoro ynnaepcnea
J2J
ua ccuu:c uac(:, a .c nc(ycc.cuc
ya+auu: +acuc, uc u (xa cacuua acnc-
cca c .c, cacuc.acuua uxu uc. cuc.ucy
uac(y ua (auuc .anc quauxu+aqucuucrc
a+au.ua cauaa cc.: uxu aa(a a :-
.y_uu c:+au. lcccx:y c_cnu+uauc, +.c
cauaa cc.: cacuc.acuua a .c uxu uuc
ncuc(c acc c+ ucx+cuua uaqucuax:uc-
c.a u uac(a, .c ucuuc axuauuc u+cucuuu
uccuucu cc(: cu.auua axc+ucxcuu:x ua-
c(ca u ccquax:uc-yx:.yucu cu.yaquu cyc-
xcaxuaac. c.uauuc caucu cc.u a c:-
+aa y c(uux uac(ca u ccxaucuuc y (yrux.
lc.cy a cyxucac ncua.ua .ucxcru-
+cccu cnc.u+: nc(xarac.ca (cncxuu.:
cxcaccc+c.auuc ...axc+ucxcuu:c uac(: u
u+xcu.: crc cxc(y_u ca+c: axc+uc-
xcuu:c, a aauc cna.uc ncuaa_uc ua-
c(:. lc(c.c .ucxcru+cccu cnc.u-
+: aaxac.ca uay+ucc uccxc(caauuc ccccuuc-
c.cu cucaauua y nc(c.aau.cxcu c.(cx:-
ucrc uac(a ncac(cu+cccrc c.ccc.una nc(
axuauuc ccquax:ucu cc(:. ,xa na.u+cc-
crc cacuua acncca a c.crc ccc.ac.c.auu
c .ccaauuau Uc(cax:ucrc +acua c.
JJ.O5.2OOJ ` 7J-U O rccy(ac.acuucu
cy(cuc-cnc.ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u a Icccuu-
ccu Uc(caquu ucrca.uc nc(xaraxcc:
cc+(a.: a c.y.yc Uc(cax:ucrc qcu.a
cy(cucu cnc.u+: nu Muuuc.cc.ac c-
.uquu Icccuuccu Uc(caquu nc(a+(cxcuuc
(xa ncac(cuua cy(cucu .ucxcru+cccu u
cxurucac(+cccu cnc.u+, crauu+caa.:
(auu:c uanaaxcuua cy(cucu cnc.u+:
a (yrux cnc.u:x y+c(cuuax Muuc.a
Icccuu
J
. O(ua(:, c.ac+aa ua acncc, r(c a.:
cnc.ca (xa ncac(cuua nc(cu:x uccxc-
(caauuu, a :xa a:uy(cua nu+ua.:, +.c cc
Huc.u.y.a .ucxcruu u au.cncxcruu IAH
aaxuuqucaauuc ncacc.u .ay cnc-
.u+y, nc cy.u, uccy. O.c.u, +.c acncc
c uccxc(ucc.u ynca(c+cuua ncqc(y: .-
ucxcru+cccu cnc.u+: ua c(cax:uc
ycauc ucc(uca.uc c.aauxca crauau rc-
cy(ac.acuucu axac.u u c_cc.acuu:u cra-
uu+aquau ccuu:x uac(ca Ccaca
2
.
C.crc rcaca, .ucxcrua (ac. ccc.acuucc
cnc(cxcuuc .ucxcru+cccu cnc.u+:, nc(
c.ccu ncuuac.ca uay+ucc uccxc(caauuc
axuauua u+cucuuu uccuucu cc(: cu.auua
axc+ucxcuu:x uac(ca u ccquax:uc-yx:.y-
ucu cu.yaquu ua a+au.uc .ucca. S.ucxcru-
+ccaa cnc.u+a ~ uay+uc-nuxa(ucc uc-
cxc(caauuc, ncac(ucc cncquaxuc.au a c-
xac.u ccquax:ucu uxu nuxa(ucu au.cnc-
xcruu ua ccucac: ncxca:x uccxc(caauuu; c.a-
.uc.u+cccu cac.u accca:x uc.c+uu-
ca, c.aa_ux ccquax:uc-cucu+ccuc,
(ccrau+ccuc, .ucncxu.u+ccuc ncqccc:
(a (uuauc) a aucuax cc ccaauu: uaqu-
cuax:u: ccc.aac; cuc.ca.u+aquu u uuc-
aqucuucu cac.u (cxcncu+ac(c.acuucu
(cycu.aquu crauca ucncxuu.cx:ucu axac-
.u, y+c(cuuu u crauu+aquu, uaqucuax:u:x
acccquaquu, a .ac (yrux a.cuaxca, nc-
+acxa_ux a:u.u ua cnxccuy cqcuy .-
ucccquax:ucu cu.yaquu, a:aaxcuuc uaucxcc
xaa.cu:x .cu(cuquu, ncruc+ucaauuc, a:-
ac.y cccu(aquu
J
.
B .ucxcruu, a .c+ucc a .ucncuxcxcruu
c ccc(uu: XX aca a+aa.:aac.ca qcx:u
a( cuqcnquu cu.axu.c.a, ucxc(a_ux u+ cy-
_cc.acaauua y a+u:x .uccca cncquu+cc-
ux +c. uaqucuax:ucrc xaa.ca, ncaaxa-
_uxca a ccccuucc.ax yc.cu+uacrc yx:.y-
ucrc ncac(cuua. S.c nc+acxuxc uccxc(caa.c-
xa a:c.cu.: c(cx: cc(ucu xu+ucc.u .cu
uxu uucu uaqucuax:uc-.uu+cccu rynn:, a:-
(cxaa a a(cu uaquu a+ucuy xu+ucc.:,
J
C.: do:+nou A. l. laaca:c acncc: nc.u-
ac(cuc.aua c.cu+y a ccc rccy(ac.acuuc-
cucccucuax:u:x c.ucacuuu [Sxc.cu. ccyc|.
Icu (cc.yna: l||:.cdia.ruio2OO5O4
DclladyZaluzlayjjA.dcc.
2
C.: [Sxc.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l||:
jcc-ublici|y.ruac4JO4.l|ol, .aldi.ruSI
IOO7J628.l|o.
J
C.: Co{oeou A. H. Ma.cuax: .ucxcru+cc-
ux cnc.u+ a uc.cu+ccuu uc.c+uu Ma-
.cuax: acccccuuccu uay+ucu cuccuquu
Scucu+ccaa uc.cua Cuuu XX aca
[Sxc.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l||:
ac.lis|.asu.rulcalcrclc|cz54.l|ol.
M. A. Lo:oo. Hcncx:+caauuc uc.a(uqucuu:x cnc.u+ nu accxc(caauuu yrcxcau:x (cx
J22
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
a c.ccu ccc(uucu: c_uc (xa cc nc(c.a-
au.cxcu +c.: uaqucuax:ucu yx:.y:
4
. l. ^c-
cu ya+:aac., +.c +cc+ uacxc(c.acuucc.:, acc-
nu.auuc u cc(y ucuua x(cu xcu uaquc-
uax:ucc.u nucc.a. uac ucux ycc(-
ucuu:x accnua.uu, (cxa_ux ux +ac+a.cx:-
uc ncxcuu (yr ua (yra
5
. 1au ca+c,
.ucxcrua cc.u. ua ncxca.uy caucu
cc.u u c.ucacuua ucu nc( yrxc uac(a
(uaqucuax:ucc.u) a qcxc u crc cc(ucrc nc(-
c.aau.cxa.
O(uac .ucxcru+ccaa cnc.u+a uc
cc. (a.: c.ac.ca ua acc acncc:, ac+uua-
_uc nc yrcxcaucy (cxy c ncc.ynxcuuu, cc-
acacuuc nc c.uay caucu cc.u uxu ua-
qucuax:ucu aa(:. B a(c uac(c cc.:
.c, .c c.cu.ca uu.craquu, ncccx:y a-
(c. xar quauxu+aquu, u .c, .c rxaau: xa-
rc nc+u.ac. cacc .uu+cccc (cc.cuuc.ac
6
.
Kcc .crc, yx:.yu:c qcuucc.u uc. cacu-
c.ac (cc.a.c+uc :c.c cua.:ca. lc.cy
cnc.u+a, c.ac+a_aa ua acncc: c uac(c
a qcxc, c ac.a.uc nc(c.aau.cxc .cu uxu
uucu uaqucuax:ucc.u, (cxua :.: (cncxucua
cnc.u+cu, c.ac+a_cu ua acncc: c cu-
c.uc uu(uau(c c y+c.c crc uaqucuax:ucrc
nc+uqucuucaauua.
S.ucrau+ccaa uxu uay+uc-.ucrau-
+ccaa cnc.u+a ucc. (cc.a.c+uc aucuu
yr acnccca, axc(a_ux a nc(c. auaxu+a.
lucuu.cx:uc .cc c.a.:u c.c.uc-nc(-
c.uaa cxac.: uccxc(caauua .ucrau+cc-
cu cnc.u+: a.cuaxca (cxa xcu. ua
c.:c ucny(cuquu, .ucxcruu, cxurucac-
(cuua, uc.cuu, .ucncuxcxcruu u cx:xcuc-
.uu. lc(c.c auaxu+a cry. cxyu.: na-
.uu u nuc: accnu.auua (c.cu, c.cncu: .a-
(uqucuucc.u ua+aauu:x c.c(ca. B cuc+uc
u.crc .aaa cnc.u+a cc. c.ac.u.: ua
acncc, ucxa xu a (auuc cxy+ac cc.c .a-
(uqucuuaa cauaa cc.:. lc(c. .ucra-
u+cccu cnc.u+: ~ uay+ucc uccxc(caa-
uuc aucauux ncaaxcuuu .a(uquu u c:+aca
a ncac(cuuu c.(cx:ucrc uu(uau(a a nc(-
c.aau.cxa cnc(cxcuucu uaqucuax:ucc.u. lu
.c uyuc uc.: aau(y, +.c .aaa cnc-
.u+a .cyc.ca uc .cx:c a cxy+ac, cr(a c-
.ua caucu cc.u c:aac.ca, uc u cr(a
ucuc (yruc c.ua: nu:aa.ca ca-
ucu cc.:.
H(cax:u: aauau.c aaxac.ca nuaxc-
+cuuc (xa ncac(cuua cnc.u+: xuq, c.c-
:c aaxa.ca u .ucraau, u .ucxcrau,
ncccx:y .cr(a cnc.u+a y(c. cnxcc-
ucu u, c+cau(uc, (cxua ua+:aa.:ca .ucxcrc-
.ucrau+cccu
7
.
,axcc, nu accxc(caauuu ncc.ynxcuuu,
caa+auu:x c acncc.aucuuc ncucrau-
+ccux a.cuaxca u c uu.cxxc.yax:u:u
a+aa.u:u (cuc.auau, ccccuuc a c.ucac-
uuu ucccacacuucxc.uux, uccxc(uc nuc-
ucuuc cncquax:u:x nc+uauuu a cxac.u yx:-
.ycxcruu. H a nccxc(uc cxy+ac nu accxc-
(caauuu ncc.ynxcuua ua nca:u nxau a:xc-
(u. uccxc(ucc.: ucncx:+caauua a (ca+:-
aauuu nc yrcxcaucy (cxy c+yx:.a.ca cnc-
.u+. Bc-nca:x, uccxc(uc ncac(cuuc yx:-
.ycxcru+cccu (yx:.ycac(+cccu) cnc.u-
+:, c+ +crc ucac+cuc yc.aucau.:, aaxa.ca
xu nc(ccuc.ucaauu:c nc(c.:, ux::,
au(cc- uxu ay(uc+anucu ncucrau+ccuu.
lcucraua ~ .c +c+a:+auuc cxcucc
aaxcuuc. Cncquaxuc.:, n:.aac: cnc(cxu.: cc
nuc(y, a:ca+:aa. nc.uacc+ua:c ucuua:
c. nacrc +anc.a (ac ua uac cuacu-
ucu ua.y: (c cacx.cnucc.u ca:
c.cacuu: cqcua a+auucrc a+aa.a.
4
C.: Amxo+oxoeo A. A. Ucuccu cu.axu.c.a:
auaxu+ +aycu:x uccxc(caauuu Ccaccu-
ucc naac. 2OO6. ` J. C. 6266.
5
C.: con l. lcuxcxcru+ccuc +acu: acx-
quu uac(ca Kyx:.ya a ccaccuuc uc:
cn:. u ncxc: cacuua. B:n. 5. M., 2OOJ.
C. 44.
6
lo:oence A. B. laa(cc: uac(cac(cuua
Bcc.u. \IO IAH. 2OO4. `2 (8). C. 28.
7
A. B. lcxcauca c.c+ac. nc .cy ncac(y: Xc-
cac, ccxu .ucra u .ucxcr ~ c(uc xuqc, u
.ccc.u .cuc +yac.ayc. rau: yx:.y:. Hac-
(cac(cuuc nc(ncxarac. cncccucc.: au.:ca
a yx:.yuy cc(y (c nc+.u ncxucrc ac.accuua
a ucu u a .c c aca cc.a.:ca nc(cx:uc c.c.a-
ucuu: uax(a.cxc (C.: lo:oence A. B.
laa(cc: uac(cac(cuua. C. JJ.
J2J
Arycu.: c.ccu c:a.ca
8
. B Ccac.-
cc uquxcnc(u+ccc cxcaac rcacu.ca,
+.c ncucraua ~ .c ayx:rauc-ua.ya-
xuc.u+cccc, ucnuc.cuucc u+cacuuc ncxc-
acu u+uu a xu.ca.yc, u+ca+u.cx:uc uc-
ycc.ac, .ca.c, uuc u nc+.
9
. lc.: u (yruc
cyxucau. 1a, A. l. ^a+a: nc(xarac.
cxc(y_uc ncua.ua: lcucraua ~ ca
u+cacuua aaxcuuu, c.ucca_uxca ncxcacu
u+uu u ccc cccyax:ucrc, xaa.cu+y-
_aaca auucu ua.yaxuc.u+ucc.: u quuu+-
c a u+cacuuu ncxca:x c.ucacuuu. Qu-
uu+ ~ (ccuc.a.uaucc uayacuuc yx:-
.yuc-uc.cu+ccux cxcuaauxca naaux u
uc uaac.acuucc.u u xarcnuc.cuucc.u.
Cy_cc.ayc. nua+ Iccyx:.y: c. J5.OJ.2OO5
` JJ2 O y.ac(cuuu lcxccuua u cc-
c.aaa Scnc.ucrc ccac.a nc ac+ac.ucu xac-
cuuaquu ay(ucau+yax:u:x ncu+ac(cuuu,
a c.cc cc(cu.ca acc:a acnx:a+a.cc u
nuxu+u.cx:ucc cnc(cxcuuc ncucrauu.
Kcc .crc, (auu:u uca.uau:u a. cc(c-
u. ycac(c.ac c .c, auc ux:: u nc-
ra: uc cry. :.: +acruc.ucaau:, nc-
ccx:y cc(ca. a ccc cqcu: ncucrau-
+cccrc xaa.ca. O(uac ya+auu:u nua+
uc cc. cxyu.: ccucaauuc (xa aaxuua-
quu (cuc.auu xuqa, ccacaa_crc uu.cxxc.y-
ax:u:c a+aa.u:c (cuc.aua. l(uuc.acuu:
a:xc(c cc.ac.ca ncac(cuuc cnc.u+:.
lcxcu: aaxac.ca .c. a., +.c ua +a-
cuc(a.cx:uc ycauc uc cnc(cxcuc, .c a (au-
uc cxy+ac cc. a:c.yna.: cnc.c, nc.c-
y a a+cc.ac cnc.ca nuaxca.ca xuqa, uc-
_uc c nc(c.c uc cucc c.(axcuucc nc(-
c.aaxcuuc, +c cxc(caa.cx: uxu cy(:a
JO
.
B c.u+ccc ucycc.ac cc(cauuc nc-
aaxuyc. ua( ccu, +.c u a:c.ynac. c(uu u+
ycxcauu crc xy(ccc.acuucu qcuucc.u. B nc-
ucrauu ca ncaaxuyc. ua( cc(cauu-
c. Ccquax:uc-yx:.yu:c qcuucc.u, cnc-
ucu.: u xu+ucc.u:c c:cx: c.cy.c.ay.
a ncucrau+cccu nc(yquu, +.c u xuaac.
cc xy(ccc.acuucu qcuucc.u. Xy(ccc.acu-
uaa qcuucc.: ~ .c xaa.cuc.ua xy(cc-
c.acuucrc ca+a, +ax+a_aaca a ac+c-
ucc.u crc c.ucccuua a ccc ccquax:uc-
yx:.yu:x qcuucc.cu, .a u ccc ucnc-
xc(a_ux xu+ucc.u:x qcuucc.cu, u(cax:u:x ac+-
cucc.cu +cxcac+cccrc :.ua
JJ
. O(uac
ncac(cuuc yx:.ycxcru+cccu cnc.u+:
uc(cc.a.c+uc, ncccx:y cac nc ccc yc.a-
ucaxcuuc .crc a.a, +.c uccxc(caauu:c a-
.cuax: uc aaxa.ca ncucrau+ccuu, c_c
uc c+ua+ac., +.c (ccuc.aqua .acrc c(a
a.cuaxca uc cc. aaxuuqucaa.:ca a
uu.cxxc.yax:u:c a+aa.u:c (cuc.aua.
lu nc(rc.cac .cxcaauua ncua.uu a+-
aa.u:c (cuc.aua, ncucrau+ccuc a.c-
uax: u nc(c.:, nu cnc(cxcuuu u.c-
uca ux a+rauu+cuua c a.cuaxau u nc(-
c.au c.u+cccrc cc(cauua uccxc(u-
c ca.u.: auuauuc ua a+au.uc uu.cx-
xc.yax:u:x c ccaa_cuua (c.cu. Iac-
.xcuu nccxc(uux a cuxy ccccuucc.cu ux
ncuxccccyax:ucrc a+au.ua cc. cncccc.ac-
aa.: u (cac(cuuc (c ux cac(cuua uucaquu,
uc nu+uauucu a yc.aucaxcuuc nca(c nc-
ucrau+cccu. S.c a ncay c+cc(: cnc-
(cxac.ca ac+ac.c ccua u crc ncuxcc-
qucuax:ucu +cxcc.:. ,ca+auc, +.c axc-
xc.uu u ucccacacuucxc.uu nc.cncaau
qcxcccca+uc ncac(cuuc cnxccu:x ncu-
xcxcrc-ncuxua.u+ccux (KCllS) u cn-
xccu:x ncuxcxcrc-ccccxcrc-ncuxua.u+ccux
cnc.u+ (KClClS). B ux +a(a+u axc(u.
(ncuc a:aaxcuua u cy(cuc-ncuxua.u+cc-
cu cqcuu ncuxu+ccux acc.cuc.a) cnc-
(cxcuuc ac+ac.u:x, uu(uau(yax:uc-ncuxcxc-
ru+ccux, xu+ucc.u:x ccccuucc.cu, a:aaxcuuc
u cnc(cxcuuc c: (u+cu.crcuc+a, .ana ncu-
xccccyax:ucrc a+au.ua nc.cncaaux, cc-
ucaauucc.u a+ca:x ncuxcxcru+ccux c.y-
.y, c.ac.c.acuu:x +a ncuuauuc nc.cncaauu
8
o.oo A. E. Kyx:.ycac(+ccaa cnc.u+a
ncucrauu [Sxc.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.y-
na: l||:.caca|.ru.
9
Ccac.cuu uquxcnc(u+ccuu cxcaa:. M.,
J979. C. J9J7.
JO
Hanuc, xcccra u cc.aaa.c a.uu.
[Sxc.cu. ccyc|. Icu (cc.yna: l||:
cblala.aulcruovic|cic.l'|94.
JJ
C.: o.oo A. E. \a+ cc+.
M. A. Lo:oo. Hcncx:+caauuc uc.a(uqucuu:x cnc.u+ nu accxc(caauuu yrcxcau:x (cx
J24
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
xaa.ca u +ua+cuua cccyax:u:x (cuc.auu
(ccccuuc a ncnyc.a.uc u nc(cc.cac
ac+ac.c), a .ac c.cncuu a+auucrc axuauua
accx a.cca ua cucaauuc .cu uxu uucu
u(u+ccu +ua+ucu cncccucc.u ucccac-
acuucxc.uux nc.cncaaux accnuuua.: uu-
caqu. 1c, +.c (xa +c.:ua(qa.uxc.ucrc
nc(cc.a y(c. ca+caa.cx:ucu uucaqucu,
cncccc.ay_cu ncxcacy accnu.auu, ccac-
acuuc ucnucxcc (cac(u.: (c cac(cuua
J2
C.: lo{+oceo B. . Kcnxccuaa CllSH
nc.cncaaux u cau(c.cxcu [Sxc.cu. ccyc|.
Icu (cc.yna: l||:.c|rcl.ruocdbccl
lis|ocdbadoacva2.l|o.
ccua xa(acrc acx:ucrc ac+ac.a. Bcc
.u acncc: ucca. c(ucqunxuuau:u xa-
a.c u uc cry. :.: cacu: a aax u+c-
xucaauu:x, a+ca:x cnc.u+
J2
.
J25
Momcpuo:m npumu:ccno
uonpoe:cuuocmu {pccusuu u omsmem)
Mcucraua u+acc.ucrc cccuuccrc a(aca.a C. l. Kaa-
xauaua Cuc.ca nccccucuax:ucu cnc.cu.ucc.u a(aca.a
(M., 2OO8) (ac. ncac( ca.u.: auuauuc nc(c.aau.cxcu uayu
yrcxcaucrc ncqccca ua c+cu: qcx:uy nc caccu +a(yc ac.y,
nc(c.aaxa_y uayy c a(aca.yc, ncauaxu+ucaa.: cc-
c.acuu:c uay+u:c cuqcnquu, caxu+caauu:c a ua-
yc yrcxcaucrc ncqccca.
Hcaauc(yauc cqcu+cu.a nccccuu a(ac-
a.a ncy(ac. crc ca_a.: auuauuc ua acc uc-
a:c .ccc.u+ccuc a+ac.u, aca_ucca nccc-
cucuax:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u a(aca.a. ,cc.a.c+uc +a-
c.c .u uccxc(caauua ~ c+yx:.a. uay+ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u a(ac-
a.ca-na.uca, +.c ucc. nacc c.ucacuuc ac.c C. l. Ka-
axauaua.
Cc(cauuc crc cucrauu ccc.aaxa. .u a+(cxa.
lca:u ac:aac. aa.cccc nc(c.aaxcuuc c cuc.cc nc-
cccucuax:ucu cnc.cu.ucc.u a(aca.a, ax+a_cu: u(u-
+cccc +uauuc; ccac(cxcuucc.: a(aca.a a cuc.uc (cxc
(+uauuc (cxa); c_y ccac(cxcuucc.: a(aca.a (c_cccquax:-
ucc +uauuc); c.c(cxcru+cccc +uauuc, c.ccc nc(c.aaxac.ca
. A. 3om:unuu
Hcn pasunrnn rcopnn
auorarcroro macrcpcrua
|Pcucnsnn na monorpaqnr C. I. Kapaannna
Cncrcma npoqcccnonaxrno
romncrcnrnocrn auorara (M., 2008|
heonup Aneucanppouun 3amnnnun,
xanna pnnecxnx nayx,
npenoaaaeru xaqepu xpnunnarncnxn
Yparucxon rocyapcaennon
pnnecxon axaeunn
zashnall.ur.ru
J26
lxxc.cu: \O MACl 2OJO ` J (J)
caccca+u: uuc.ycu.c, nc+acxa_u
a(aca.y ccy_cc.au.: nccac( ncxc: cac-
crc (cacu.cxa c c:(cuucrc a+:a ua u-
(u+ccuu a+:, c .c, +.c: c.:ca.: cacuuc
(auucu ncxc: a naacac ncxc, ncxy+cu-
ucc c cacuuc nccacc.u ca.uc ua c:-
(cuu:u a+: (C. JJ2).
Bc a.cc a+(cxc cucrauu aa.c ac-
ca.uaac. a a+cc.ac cncucu.ca cuc.c:
nccccucuax:ucu cnc.cu.ucc.u a(aca.a
xcruy u arycu.aqu, a caa+u c +c acac.ca
auaxu+a a+:a, nc(c.aaxa_crc ccy (ca-
.cx:ucc.u a(aca.a, xcru+cccrc u cy(cucrc
(ca+:aauua, naaux .ccuu arycu.aquu, c.a-
.cruu u .a.uu cnca.
1c.uu a+(cx ac.: ac:aac. ccqu-
ax:uc-ncuxcxcru+ccy cnc.cu.ucc.: a(ac-
a.a. lu .c aa.c nc(cuc acca.uaa-
c. ccquax:uc-ncuxcxcru+ccuc ccccuucc.u
nccccuu a(aca.a, ncxc: ncc.ccuua
nccccucra: a(aca.a, ay.cncuxcxcru+cc-
y cnc.cu.ucc.: a(aca.a u c.c(: cc
nca:acuua, cyuua.uauy u acucxcru+cc-
y cnc.cu.ucc.: a(aca.a.
Bcc a+(cx: ac.: nc(c.aaxa.ca caa-
+auu:u a c(uuy aa.ccy cuqcnqu ~
ucay, a.yax:uy u uc_y cx:acc .cc-
c.u+cccc +ua+cuuc (xa uayu (nc(c.u:
+uauuc c.ccu aaxac.ca a(aca.caa (ca-
.cx:ucc.:) u na.u+cccu (ca.cx:ucc.u a(-
aca.ca a a+xu+u:x au(ax cy(cncu+ac(c.a.
Buuauuc cqcu+uyccu ac.c caa+a-
uc c ncccc+cuuc c.c.u:x cxac.cu uc-
cxc(caauuu C. l. Kaaxauaua c uaau, nc(-
c.aaxcuu: a (ayx cucrauax
J
. lu .c u
aucauc c: uccxc(caauuu c.+ac.u cxc(u:,
(ccuc.uya ucncx:+caauuc auaxcru+u:x
ncua.uu: cnc.cuqua, cncucu., xc-
cu., .a.ua, c.a.crua.
Cy_cc.acuu:c cc(ca.cx:u:c c.xu+ua
ccc.ca. a .c, +.c aa.c cqcu+uyccu a-
c.: ncc+ucxcuu:c a:ac cncucu.: au-
(u. ccc.aaxa_uu cuc.cy nccccucuax:-
ucu cnc.cu.ucc.u. B uaac aauau.c c-
ncucu.: cc.: .c, +.c ca+yc. cccucaauuc
.ccuu a(aca.ccrc ac.cc.aa a yrcxcauc
cy(cncu+ac(c.ac, ax+a_cc (uaxcuu+cc-
uu auaxu+ cuc.c yrcxcauc-ncqcccyax:ucrc,
cuc.u.yqucuucrc, c(yuac(ucrc naaa
(a +ac.u cryxucaauua (ca.cx:ucc.u a(ac-
a.ca a yrcxcauc ncqcccc), ucuy_uc
uaruc.auuc a ucax naaa naaccaxu+aqu-
cuucu a.uaucc.u a(aca.ca, .cy_cu -
c.uau:x u cn.uax:u:x uc(uqucuu:x
.cxucxcruu.
Sxccu.au .ccuu a(aca.ccrc ac.c-
c.aa a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac ua au-
(a.ca .a.u+cccc, c.a.cru+cccc u crauu+a-
qucuucc ac.cc.ac a(aca.ca. lc(cuaa cxc-
a nc+acxac. a:c.auaa.: cax:uc-xcru+cc-
y cuc.cy ccnc(+uucuu:x ncua.uu (.cc-
u ~ a cax:uc-xcru+ccc c:cxc).
lu .c nccccucuax:ucc ac.cc.ac
a(aca.a a yrcxcauc ncqcccc nc(c.aaxac.-
ca a u(uc-.cxucxcru+ccaa (ca.cx:ucc.:,
a:ac( c .cxucxcru+ucc.u c.ccu (cxac.ca ua
ccucac ncac(cuucrc ccau.u+cccrc u .u-
cxcru+cccrc auaxu+a, nucucuucrc u
C. l. Kaaxauauc, ya+:aaa ua ucc.ccc cc-
ana(cuuc c.c(cxcruu.
Hau:c a+xu+ua caa+au: c (uccuqu-
aqucu uay+u:x acx. Hay+uaa acxa \ax:-
ccu rccy(ac.acuucu u(u+cccu aa(cuu
cucu.uyc.ca ua .cxucxcru+ucc.: u(u+cc-
crc ca+caauua
2
. O.+ac.u .c caa+auc c uc-
cxc(caauuau (auucu acxcu ncxc uc-
(uqucuu:x .cxucxcruu, +auua_ux aaucc
cc.c a .ccc.u+ccc nc(c.aaxcuuu uc-
(uqucuu:x ncu+ac(c.a, y+ac.uuau c.c-
:x u aaxa.ca a(aca.:.
O.c+cuucc cc.ca.cx:c.ac ncaxcxc c-
xcc auccc ucncx:+caauuc uau ac. a c-
xac.u .ccuu accuucrc ucycc.aa (K. lxcaa,
K. Kxay+cauqa u (.), .ccuu .cxucxcruu
J
C.: dom:+nun . A. Ocuca: .ccuu c-
.uaucu a(aca.ccu (ca.cx:ucc.u: lcxuuua-
u:u acnc.. la.cuuyr, 2OO6; On +c. Oc-
ucau:c cncucu.: .ccuu a(aca.ccrc ac.c-
c.aa a yrcxcauc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac. la.cuu-
yr, 2OO7.
2
C.: Muccua \lKA [Sxc.cu. ccyc|.
Icu (cc.yna: l||: . usl a. ruabcu|
oissica&cli|ils.dl.
J27
(K. H. Kuaruuuua, A. Scnuuaca u (.), aa.c
c cacc uccxc(caauuc ncc.cux c.c(cxcru-
+ccu cy_cc.acuuc uua+c, +.c u (axc a+u:c
c+yx:.a.:.
O.c+aa +ua+ucc.: ac.: C. l Kaa-
xauaua (xa uac, ncxarac aaucu crc u(c
c ccquax:uc-ncuxcxcru+cccu cnc.cu.ucc-
.u a(aca.a (C. 2J4), nc+acxa_cu a+au.:
uca:c acnc.: nc(xaraccu uau .ccuu, ua-
nuc, ~ c a.cax .a.u+cccrc ac.c-
c.aa.
Icqcu+uycaa ac.a, (cuuuy_u cc-
(cauuc c.ccu aaxac.ca uccxc(caauuc
cnc.cuquu a(aca.a a au.auc u ra-
(aucc cy(cncu+ac(c.ac, nc(c.aaxac.ca
ucx+u.cx:uc uu.cccucu, uc_cu c.ucac-
uuc uccuxa.yc uay+ucu cncquax:ucc.u
J2.OO.JJ. Hccxc(ucc.: cc cccu(aquu acc
uccxc(caa.cxa u na.ua, uu.cccy_u-
ca a(aca.ccu (ca.cx:ucc.:, c+cau(ua. Aa-
.cy c nccxac (ax:ucuaux .ac+ccux u
nccccucuax:u:x ycncxca.
. A. dom:+nun. H(cu a+au.ua .ccuu a(aca.ccrc ac.cc.aa
lxxc.cu: \O MACl, nyxuya c.a.:u nc uay+u: cnc-
quax:ucc.a J2.OO.O9, J2.OO.JJ (yrcxcau:u ncqccc, uuuaxu-
c.ua, .ccua cnca.uauc-c+:cucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, cy(cuaa -
cnc.u+a, cy(cuaa axac.:, ncyccuu ua(+c, crauu+aqua
naaccxauu.cx:ucu (ca.cx:ucc.u, a(aca.ya), cc(cu. .u
a+(cxa: a) cxxc.uaucc uccxc(caauuc cnc(cxcuucu .c: (a-
.cuax: cuccuquu); ) uu(uau(yax:u:c uccxc-
(caauua aa.cca (cacc(uaa .ca.ua); a) u.u-
+ccuc nyxuaquu (c.+:a: ua cucrauu, (uc-
cc.aquu u .. n.).
Bcc: .ua xxc.cua u acxc(: acnc(cxa.ca c(y
aa.cau. O.c c.a.cu (uccuquyc.ca a +aaucucc.u c.
+ucxa cuacxca a c.a.:ax u ccc.ac.c.ay_crc a+ca cncu-
caquu acxc(ca ua u+(auuc.
lc(cuc cc cxc(y_u ncc.c cuc c+uacu.:ca
a c:uu.u \O MACl l||:ccoouai|y.livcjcuraal.cco
urcoas u ua cau.c cc(uua.ca l||:zasl.cb.ur.ru.
lurxaaac aac y+ac.u a cxc(y_c ncc.c u a (ca-
.cx:ucc.u c:uu.u \O MACl.
O cxcyrmcm nomcpc
Haynnme uonqepenuu
YpO MACR