Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 76

1

2011

1998 .

The academic journal is established in 1998

( )

,


(.:
27.10. 2010 . ) , .

Bulletin of the Moscow State Regional University (all its series) is included by the Supreme Certifying Commission into the List of the leading reviewed academic journals and periodicals, in which
the basic research results of Ph.D. and Doctorates
academic degree thesis should be published (See: the
List of journals edited 27.10. 2010 at the site of the
Supreme Certifying Commission) in corresponding
series.

The founder of journal:


The Moscow State Regional
University

(),

(www.elibrary.ru),

(www.vestnik.mgou.ru)

The journal is included into the database of the Russian Science Citation Index, has a full text network
version on the Internet on the platform of Scientific
Electronic Library (www.elibrary.ru), as well as at
the site of the Moscow State Regional University
(www.vestnik.mgou.ru)


:
. , . , .10, 98
.: (499) 261-43-41; (495) 723-56-31
e-mail: vest_mgou@mail.ru
: www.vestnik.mgou.ru

The Editorial Board address:


Moscow State Regional University
10 Radio st., office 98
Moscow, Russia
Phones: (499) 261-43-41; (495) 723-56-31
e-mail: vest_mgou@mail.ru
Site: www.vestnik.mgou.ru


. ,
, , .

.
.
.
.

At citing the reference to a particular series of


Bulletin of the Moscow State Regional University
is obligatory. The reproduction of materials in
printed, electronic or other editions without the Editorial Board permission, is forbidden. The materials
published in the journal are for non-commercial use
only. The authors bear all responsibility for the content of their papers. The opinion of the Editorial Board

of the series does not necessarily coincide with that of the


author Manuscripts are not returned.

Issued 3 times a year

Series JURISPRUDENCE
Bulletin f the
Moscow State Regional University

2011

-
Publishing council Bulletin of the MSRU
.. ..., .,

. .. ...,
.,
.. ..., ., . -

.. .-.., . ()
.. -
( )
.. ..., .
.. ..., . . ..
.. ...,
.. ..., .,
.. - . . ., ..
B.C. .., .
. ..
.. .-.., .,

. . , . -
()
..., .,
()

Chairman of the Council V.V. Pasechnik Doctor of Pedagogics., Professor, the Principal of the SRU
Deputy Chairman of the Council S.G. Dembitsky Doctor of
Economics, Professor, the Vice-principal for education of the
SRU
A.V. Abramov Ph.D. in Political Sciences, Associate Professor,
the Head of the editorial department of the Bulletin of the MSRU
B. E. Belozerov Doctor of Physics and Mathematics, Professor
of Dnepropetrovsk National University (Ukraine)
K.F. Zatulin the Head of Institute for Diaspora and Integration
(Institute of the CIS Countries)
P.A. Lekant Doctor of Philology, Professor of the MSRU
M.N. Marchenko Doctor of Law, Professor of Moscow State
University
L.L. Nelyubin Doctor of Philology, Professor of the SRU
V. F. Nitsevich Doctor of Politics, Professor, the Principal of the
Oryol Regional Academy of Public Service
Yu. M. Polyakov Ph.D. in Philology, editor-in-chief of
Literaturnaya Gazeta
V.S. Pusko Doctor of Philosophy, Professor of the Bauman
Moscow State Technical University
S.D. Traytak Ph.D. in Physics and Mathematics, Associate
Professor
Klaus G. Troitzsch Doctor, Professor of Koblenz-Landau University (Germany)
Hu Gumin Doctor of Philology, Professor, Institute of Foreign
Languages of Ukhan University (China)


Series editorial board Jurisrudence
. c .. ,

. . . ..
, , .
. :
.., , , ( . .. );
.., , ; .., ,
, ; ..,
, , ()
. ,
()

Editor-in-chief V.G. Golyshev, Ph.D. in Law, Associate Professor


Deputy editor-in-chief V.M. Klychnikov, Ph.D. in Law, Ph. D. in
History, Associate Professor
Members of Editorial Board:
M.N. Marchenko, Doctor of Law, Professor, Honourary Scientist
of the Russian Federation (Moscow State University); A.V.
Grinenko, Doctor of Law, Professor A.N. Nikitin, Doctor of History, Doctor of Law, Professor A.S. Podshibyakin, Doctor of Law,
Professor,Honourary Scientist of the Russian Federation ( Moscow State Institute of International Relations) B. Bayer, Doctor of
Law, Honorary Professor of MSRU (Germany)

ISSN 2072-8557
. . 2011. 1. .: . 76 .

ISSN 2072-8360
Bulletin of the MSRU. Series Jurisprudence. 2011. 1. : MSRU Publishing house. 76 p.




. 77-26300.

The series Jurisprudence of the Bulletin of the Moscow


State Regional University is registered in Federal service on
supervision of legislation observance in sphere of mass
communications and cultural heritage protection. The registration certificate 77-26300.

3 .

Issued 3 times a year.


36756

Index series Jurisprudence under "Rospechat"agency


catalog 36756

. . 1 / 2011

.

 .. - 
1992 . 
( ) ...............5
 .. 

.....................................................................12
 .. 


..............................................................22


 .. 
................................................................31
 .. -
.........................................................................37


 .., .. 
............................................44


 .. 
- 
..............50
.. ......57
 .. 
- ...........................................63


 - 


2010 ..........................................................68
.....................................................................74

. . 1 / 2011

contents
history and theory of state and law.
Political Issues
 . Golysheva. Historical and political aspects of Kalmyk 
A
republics participaion in signing 1992 treaty on Federation...............5
M. Marchenko. Interaction and interconnection of EU legal
system with the legal systems of the incorporated states...................12
R. Tarasikov. The participation of Russian Armed Forces officers 
in political processes moulding state and public institutions in presentday Russia ..............................................................................22

Individual issues of law and enforcement


 . Alekseyev. Traditional and innovative techniques 
R
in teaching law ........................................................................31
T. Alyabyeva. Moral aspect of teaching law ..............................37

Private law and entrepreneurship


 . Prokopenko, A. Rozhkov. Towards the problem 
O
of legitimation of business contracts ............................................44

Tribune young scientist


 . Melnichuk. Towards the notion and legal regulation of contract
N
for carrying out research work for state needs of the Russian 
Federation ..............................................................................50
P. Savin. Necessary defence as result of sociogenesis .....................57
Y. Sokolova. Deposit agreement in the system of civil liabilities ....63

Scientific life
 n the outcomes of the research of Civil Rights Department 
O
of the Moscow State Regional University in 2010............................68
OUR AUTHORS .......................................................................74

. . 1 / 2011

.

342.228 (470.47)

..

-

1992 . (
)
A. Golysheva

Moscow Institute of Business and Law

HISTORICAL AND POLITICAL ASPECTS OF KALMYK REPUBLICS


PARTICIPAION IN SIGNING 1992 TREATY ON FEDERATION
.
. 1991 .

.
1992-1993 .

, , , ,
1991
. . 1992 .
..
,
-
, .
: ,
, , , , , , .

Abstract. The paper deals with historical and


legal aspects of Kalmykiyas participation in the formation of a new Russian state. The collapse of the USSR
in December 1991 stimulated sovereign processes in
republics incorporated in the Russian Federation.
During 1992-1993 the Parliament of Kalmykia
was occupied with legalization of national state symbols. The Law on Citizenship, Presidency, hymn, coat
of arms and flag were to substantiate the sovereignty
of the republic declared in 1991. Kalmykias President
K.N. Ilyumzhinov, who took office in 1992, suggested
his own variant of Federal Constitution declaring that
legal status of republics is equal to the rest of Russia.

Key words: Treaty on Federation, the Constitution of Russia, the Constitution of Kalmykia, sovereignty, Parliament, flag, coat of arms, hymn.

 ..

I. .

. . 1 / 2011
90- . XX . ,
, , , ,
, , -
.
24 1992 .
, [1].
.., , , , , [2].
3, 3
, , [2].
, ,

.
, .. , ,
. , , ,
[2].
..
, , [2].
..

[2].
. ,
.. , . ,
[2].
.. , [3].
, , , , [3].


I. .

. . 1 / 2011
. , ,

[3].
, ,

.

31 1992 . .. ,
:
- -, 1-1 , , , ;
- -, 3 1-1 , [4].
, - , - ,
.
, , , ,
1990 . .
- , 14
1992 .
, , , :
- -, ( 2);
- -, :
, ,
; 10 ;
(.15) [5].

, . -

I. .

. . 1 / 2011
. ,
, , , [8].
28 1992 . . . [9], 30 1992 . [10].
- , 24-25 1992 . .

, ,
,
. .. , , ,
[7].
, :
- -, ,
, ;
- -, ; ;
- -,
[6]. .
, , , ,
, , , .
, , ,
.
, ,
. , ,
, ,
.
XV
.. .. , , 

I. .

. . 1 / 2011
, ,
[11].
1992 . . , , .
.
.
. , 4 1992 . XVI .. , .. [12].
.
, ,
[13].

, 1993 .

[14].

, 14 1992 . - ,

.. .. [12].
, :
- -,
, 1992 .,
;
- -, ,
;
- -,
;
- -,
[14].
, [14].
,
,

I. .

. . 1 / 2011
. , , . ,
.

XVIII , 27 1993 . [15].

.. ,
, 14 1992 ., (300
1037), ,
[15]. , , , , [15]. ,
,
. - [15].
. , .. ..
, , , [15]. ..
,
[15].
, .
-

.
.


, , .

.
,
.
10 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
, .
1992 .
. ,
.
, , ,
. , . , ,
.
:
1. . 25.03.1992. 54
2. . 26.03.1992. 55
3. . 27.03.1992. 56
4. . 09.04.1992. 65
5. . 11.04.1992. 67
6. . 28.04.1992. 78
7. . 30.04.1992. 80
8. . 09.06.1992. 105
9. . 30.10.1992. 204
10. . 03.11.1992. 206
11. . 09.06.1992. 115
12. . 17.11.1992. 215
13. . 13.11.1992. 213
14. . 18.11.1992. 216
15. . 09.02.1993. 24
16. . 08.04.1993. 65
17. . 20.11.1993. 215

I. .

11

. . 1 / 2011
341:342(4/9)

..




M. Marchenko

Moscow State Regional University

INTERACTION AND INTERCONNECTION OF EU LEGAL SYSTEM


WITH THE LEGAL SYSTEMS OF THE INCORPORATED STATES
. ,
,

,

.
.
,

.
.
: , , -.

Abstract. The article deals with the EU legal


system relations with the legal systems of its member
states. There have been ways and forms of influence
of European law on national. The expansion of the
regulatory impact of European Union law on public relations has been pointed out, as well as the increase in
the number of normative legal acts of a supranational
nature. The author suggests his own view of the peculiarities of the EU legal system.

Key words: legal system, the European Union,


the right of Member States.

,
,
, ,
, - [1; 2; 5; 6; 24].
,
 ..

12 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
, , .
, ,
, ,
, [4, 301]. , -
,
, , - [4, 302].


,
[13, 53] , , ,
,
[17, 43-59].
,
-,

,
, , , [18, 499-517].
- -, , , ,
, ,

. ,
, , [17, 57].
, ,
, ,
[22, 228-235].
, ,
: ) ,

I. .

13

. . 1 / 2011
, , ; )
, , , , ,
[17, 106]; ) , ,
,

- [17, 52]; ) ,

,
, ,
, ,
, ) ,
, [11, 107119].

, , , ,
,
, , ,
, , ,
, .

, , - , ,

, .
, , - ,
, -
. , 14 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
,
,
[15, 325].
. , , , -,
, , ,
, , ,
, , -
[15, 325],
, .
, ,

()
- [3, 106].
,

, , , , , ; - ; , ,
, ; -
; , ,
, , [19, 43-46].
,

-
,
, .
, , , -, , ,
, , , . , -,
,

I. .

15

. . 1 / 2011
; -, ,
,
- , , [23,
2-6].
,
, , ,
- [17, 43]. , , ,
-

, [17,
43].
, , , , ,
- [14, 263-268] , .
, , , , ,
, ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
[20, 303]. ,
, -, ,
[20, 303].
,
-, , , , - - ,
,
16 I. .

. . 1 / 2011


, [3, 106].

,
, ,
, .
: ) ,
,
; )
:
; ) , ,
,
,
, , -, ,
) , , ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
, , , ,
, , [14, 485].
, ,
[18, 31], , ,
,
,
, .

I. .

17

. . 1 / 2011
, 1983 . 4566 , 1989 . ,
9767 .
, , 1998 . 53 52 799
[16, 57]. , , , ,
,
- [16, 1-7].
-

, .
: ) , ; )
, , ,
, ) , ,
, ,
, ,
[12,1-2].
,
,
.
,
,
, ,
,

[17, 282-297].
,
, , .
, , ,
, ,
18 I. .

. . 1 / 2011

, , ,
,
[10, 53-54].
,

, ,
,
- [22, 234-237].
,
, , , .

, : )
; )
, , :

-, ; ) [6, 75-76]; )
, , , , , , , . [21, 279335]; )
- ,
; )

, , [17, 47-59; 15, 325-341; 7,
376-390; 8, 499-517].
, , ,
, ,
,

[18, 31-35].

I. .

19

. . 1 / 2011
.

,
, , .
:
1. . . . ., 2005.
2. / . . . . . .. . .,
2004.
3. / . .. . ., 2004. .
106.
4. .. . ., 1998. . 301.
5. .. . ., 1998.
6. Andenas M.and Usher J. The Treaty of Nice and Beyond. Oxford,
2003.
7. Bartolini St. Restructuring Europe. Oxford, 2005.
8. Claudina R. The Supremacy of Community Law Before the French Constitutional. Court // European Law Review. 2006.
9. Cichowski R. The European Court and Civil Society Litigation. Mobilization and Governance. Cambridge, 2007. P. 43-46.
10. Darbyshire P. English Legal System. L., 2005. P. 53, 54.
11. Fabio U. The Allocation of Competences Between the European Union
and Its Member States // Andenas M. and Usher J. The Treaty of Nice and Beyond. Oxford, 2003.
12. Hofmann H. and Turk A. EU Administrative Governance. Northampton, 2006.
13. Kohler-Koch B. (ed.). Linking EU and National Governance. Oxford,
2003. P.53.
14. Kumm M. The Jurisprudence of Constitutional Conflict: Constitutional Supremacy in Europe Before and After the Constitutional Treaty. European Law Journal. 2005. 3. 15. Lenaerts K. Nuffel P. Constitutional Law of
the European Union L., 2005. P. 325.
16. Ladeur K.-H. Conflict and Cooperation Between European Law and
the General Administrative Law of the Member States // Ladeur K.-H. Europeanization of Administrative Law. Transforming National Decision-making
Procedures. Sydney, 2002.
17. Ladeur K.-H. Flexibility and Cooperative Law; The Coordination of
European Member States Law. The Example of Environmental Law // Burca
G. Scott J. Constitutional Change in the EU. From Uniformity to Flexibility?
Oxford, 2001.
20 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
16. Maurer A. Mittag J. and Wessels W. National Systems Adaptation
to the EU System: Trends, Offers and Constraints // Kohler-Koch B. (eds.).
Linking EU and National Governance. Oxford, 2003. P. 57.
17. Murray Ph. The European Transformation of the National State //
Murray Ph. an Holmes L. (eds.) Europe: Rethinking and Boundaries. Sydney,
1998.
18. Schendelen R. Machiavelli in Brussels. The Art of Lobbying the EU.
Amsterdam, 2002. P. 31.
19. Schiemann K. Europe and the Loss of Sovereignty // International
and Comparative Law Quarterly. 2007. Part. 3. Vol. 56. P. 485.
20. Schmidt V. The Futures of European Capitalism. Oxford, 2002. P.
303.
21. Schutter O. and Deakin S. (eds.). Social Rights and Market Forces: is
the Open Coordination of Employment and Social Policies the Future of Social
Europe? Brusselles, 2005.
22. Steyger E. National Traditions and European Community Law. Sydney, 1997.
23. Tiersky R. Introduction: Euro-skepticism and Europe // Tiersky
R. (ed.). Euroskepticism. A Reader. Oxford, 2001.
24. Ullrich H. (ed.). The Evolution of European Competition Law. Whose
Regulation, Which Competition? Northampton, 2006.

I. .

21

. . 1 / 2011
316.334.3:355.332(470), 328.182:355.332(470), 355.332(470)

..






R. Tarasikov

Moscow State Regional University

THE PARTICIPATION OF RUSSIAN ARMED FORCES OFFICERS


IN POLITICAL PROCESSES MOULDING STATE AND PUBLIC
INSTITUTIONS IN PRESENT-DAY RUSSIA
.

.
,
,
.


, , ,
,
, ,
, .
: ,
, ,
,
, , .

Abstract. The article analyses the participation of Russian armed forces officers in political processes of forming new state and public institutions in
present-day Russia. Army officers have always been
an active political force in the system of state institutions. Historical tradition of military men greatly influencing power structures stimulates involving officers
into politics. The role of officers in political processes
of present-day Russia is one of the peculiar factors
under the circumstances of transformation of state and
public institutions.

Key words: political processes, political participation, officers, armed forces of the Russian Federation, state institutions, public institutions, transformation.

 ..

22 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
. , .
. ,
.
, ,
.
, , ,
.
, .
, , ,
, , , . ,
, , ,
.

. ,
,
, ,
[6, 443].
, , ,
, , [9,
161]. . ,
,
[15, 184].
, , , (, , . .) [10].
, -

I. .

23

. . 1 / 2011
, , - , -
. .
, , , , , ,
, . .
.
,
. . , .
. .

. , , ,

,
, ,
, , , , .

, .
.
, ,
,
. ,
,
.
, , ,
,
, . . , 24 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
, , .
[2, 55].
.
, . , , , , ,
.
, .
, ,
() [3, 195]. , ,
.
, .
,
, , , , [14, 602].


.
, , .
, , , .
, . :
,
.
.
. , , -

I. .

25

. . 1 / 2011
.

, .
, .
, , 9 , , ,
, ,
, . <...>
[13]. ,
,
. () , , ,
,
.
,
. . .
, , .
, .
? 90- . - ,
. 1991 . , , ,
( , ). 1991 .
.
( , , ).
(,
1992 .). , , .
-
, .
, : 23
1993 ., ,
. .
.
, .
26 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
.
. ,
. , , ,
. , , , , ,

, ,
[8].
,
:
(, . .) () [11, 73]
, , .
. , , , 1, .
, .
- , -
.
,
. , , , .
, , , , , , . ,
,
.

, . , 

1
, ,
, - . . . .: 14 . .-., 1935. .8. .80

I. .

27

. . 1 / 2011
, .
, ,
, , , . XIX .
.. : , : [7] , , , , ,
,
.
. ,
, , ,
.
, , , ,
, , .
, .
, , ,
.
,
.

.

.
,
(. . ),
, .
, ,
, .
.
, 28 I. .

. . 1 / 2011
,
, , , ,

, ,
.

, .

. ,
, . , .
.
.
, , [1, 86; 4, 284; 5; 12, 383].
,
.
, ,
-
, .
, , ,

.
,
,
, ,
, , .

, .

I. .

29

. . 1 / 2011
:
1. ..
// ?.. : , , . .: , 1996. . 86-90.
2. .., .. :
. .: , 2003. . 55-56.
3. .. / .. , .. ,
.. .; . . .. . .: ,
1995. . 195.
4. .. // ?.. . .: , 1996. . 284-293.
5. .. : , ,
? .: , 1999.
6. .. . . 12-. . .. . .: , 1978. .443.
7. . .. // [- Vrazvedka.ru] URL: http://
www.vrazvedka.ru/main/main-idea/dragomirov.shtml ( :
11.10.2010).
8. // [ ..]
/ . URL: htpp://circumflex.narod.ru/politics.
htm ( : 11.10.2010).
9. : / . .
.., .., .. .. .
.: , 1999 . 161.
10. [ 03.06.2010; 09:25] // [ -] URL:http://www.
grozny-inform.ru/main.mhtml?Part=11&PubID=19003 ( :
13.10.2010).
11. .. / .., ..,
.. . . .. , ... 2- ., .
.: , 2003. .73 -74.
12. 27.05.1998 N 76- (. 22.07.2010)
// . N 22.
01.06.1998.
13. .. :
// ?.. , , . .: , 2000. .383.
14. Herbert Spenser. Principles of Sociology vol. 2, New York, 1895.
P.602.
15. Nadel S. The Foundations of Social Anthropology. Paris, 1951.
P.184.
30 I. .

. . 1 / 2011



37.016:345

..



R. Alekseyev

Moscow State Regional University

TRADITIONAL AND INNOVATIVE TECHNIQUES IN TEACHING LAW


.

.
, .
: ;

. , : ,
,
.
.
.
.
,
, .
: ,
,
.

Abstract. The article considers different approaches to teaching law. The main focus of the article
is the peculiarities of traditional and innovative techniques and their combination. The author presents
different forms of innovations (new integral disciplines
and teaching methods) and shows the influence of innovative teaching on the structure of educational establishment and pedagogical work.
Such forms of innovations as module, systemformatted, partial and their applications have been
the authors special concern. Among the law teaching
techniques the methods of brainstorm and mediation
have been distinguished. Information technologies are
also of great importance for teaching purposes. To
make the classes more efficient it is recommended to
combine different methods of teaching law. The necessity of a constant search for new law teaching techniques and their development and putting into practice
is underlined.

Key words: teaching approaches, traditional


and innovative techniques, types of innovations.

 ..

II.

31

. . 1 / 2011
,
,
, [5,14;
6, 8; 7, 50]. , ,
, ,
, .
, ,
, - . ,
, .
,
, , .
.

, [4,107]. , : , , ,
. . .

.
, , , -. , .
, , - [3, 9; 9, 23].
.
, , , ,
.
, ,

, . . , , . 32

II.

. . 1 / 2011
, ,
. ,
, . , ,
.
, , , , :
,
,
, , , , . , ,
, .
, , , , ,
,
.

.
, , , ,
[9, 27].

, , , . ,
XX .,
,
,
,
.
, 90- . , ,
.

: , [9,29].

, . .

II.

33

. . 1 / 2011

, . ,


, .
: , ()
-
(), - . .
,
.
,
, ,
.
.
, ,
, . ,
,
- . - ,
. , .
, ,
: , , .
,
,
[11, 35].
. [2, 40; 8, 40],
, .. [10, 212],
.
34

II.

. . 1 / 2011
, , . ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, . , , .
, .
, ,
.
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
.
, .
. -
, , , .
,
, ,
.
,
,
.
, , :
, , , ,
. , .

II.

35

. . 1 / 2011
() [1,1].
, XXI . .
,
,
.
:
1. . ()
. URL: http://nauvi-1.hosting.parking.ru/law/doc/9235.pdf
( : 13.10.2009).
2. . . //. 2006, 2. . 40-42.
3. .. . ., 1994. . 9-10.
4. B.C. : , , . 2- ., . .: , 1991. 224 .
5. / . .. , .. . .: , 1982.
6. . ., , 1999.
7. .. . .: , 2000.
8. . //
. 2006. 2. . 40.
9. .. . ., 1998.
10. .. :
. .: . , 2003. 400 .
11. .. . .,
1994.

36

II.

. . 1 / 2011
37.016:34

..

-

T. Alyabyeva

Moscow State Regional University

MORAL ASPECT OF TEACHING LAW


.
.
.
, . .


, - .
: , , , , ,

Abstract. The paper is concerned with the role


of the course of Jurisprudence in forming legal culture in the period of building up a legal democratic
state. The author reveals the content of legal education at the present stage of Russias development and
covers some negative features that have appeared
in Russian society during the transitional period from
totalitarian regime to democracy. The causes of such
phenomena have been studied and the ways to avoid
them have been suggested. The role of teaching staff
and educational establishment administration has
been revealed in forming the sense of justice, especially its moral aspect.
Key words: legal democratic state, sense of
justice, legal culture, distortion of the sense of justice,
legal education, morality.

, .
, 12 1993 . , , -
, , , . , ; ;
. . :
,
 ..

II.

37

. . 1 / 2011
,
.
-
. ,
. -
, , .
.
,
,
, ,
. ,

, , , , , .
, .
, .
,
(, , ),
, ,
,
. , ,
, .
-I . . 1980- .

- , . , . .
38

II.

. . 1 / 2011
,
,
, ,
.
, [13],
,
.
,
, , . , .

( , ,
), [12, 2
2010]. ,
, ( , , , , .;
, ) [14, 42].
, , .
, ,
, ,
[1, 3 (16), 2005].
.
, 80 % ,
[16; 17, 8; 18, 58].
.
,
, , ,
.
. ,
, . , ,
, . .
, ,
, , .

II.

39

. . 1 / 2011
, ,
, , , ,
.
: ; ,
; , .
. ,
.
, , .

[21,
3 (12), 2004 .]. ,
, , . ,
,
,
, . , ,
. .
-
. , , . 10-12
,
12 [7, 206], [8; 6, 6063]. .

, . , ,
, - .
.
,
40

II.

. . 1 / 2011
,
.
, , .

.

.
.
, .
. , , ,

. [9, 66]. . ().
.
.
. ,
. , . .
, .
- . , ,
, ,
.
.
, ,
. , , ,
,

II.

41

. . 1 / 2011
. -
.
,
, , ,
,
.

.
,
, ,
; ;
, .
,
, .
,
.
, , ,
,
.
,
, , . , ,
, , ,
, , .
.

42

II.

. . 1 / 2011
:
1. ..
// . 3 (16). 2005.
2. . // www.
uchitel.com
3.
/ .., .., ..
4. .. ( ) // - . 11. 2006.
5. .. : // . XXI , 2008. 1.
6. .. . .: -
, 2001. . 60-63.
7. . / . ... .: , 2005. . 206.
8. ..
// http://www.libsakh.ru/?div=express&hid=119
9. .. // . 1996. N 4. . 66.
10. http://www.intelros.ru/readroom/nz/nz_61/3264-mozhno-li-schitat-sovremennuju-rossiju.html
11. http://www.inosmi.ru/stories/07/04/23/3507/237987.html
12. Governance indicators. 2 2010.
13. http://www.calpers.ca.gov/eip-docs/about/board-cal-agenda/agendas/invest/200702/item07b-01.pdf
14. http://www.polit.ru/img/pdf/dmitriev.pdf . .42.
15. // NEWSru.com // // 29 2008 .; NEWSru.com //
// 11 2007 .
16. www.fom.ru 07.02.2008. , 2003-2010.
17. , .. :
. . . . . --., 2004. . 8.
18. , .. -
: . . . . , 2005. . 58.
19. www.uvao.ru/uvao/ru/pages/print/o_95418
20. http://dpr.ru/pravo/pravo_9_19.htm/ ..
. // . 3 (12).
2004.

II.

43

. . 1 / 2011


347.440.66

.., ..



O. Prokopenko, A. Rozhkov

Moscow State Regional University

TOWARDS THE PROBLEM OF LEGITIMATION


OF BUSINESS CONTRACTS
. ,
.
().
. ,
,
, . , : ,
- , ,
, -
.
: , ,
, , , - .

Abstract. The possibility to determine independent participation in civil transactions requires a


set of adequate tools. The most efficient of them is
a contract. The article attempts at justifying the expediency of singling out the so-called business contracts into a separate group. The author gives some
proofs that taking into consideration the needs of the
contemporary society the terms dogovor (contract)
and soglasheniye (agreement) cannot be treated as
synonyms. It is suggested that the system of contracts
should be considered proceeding from the needs of
the participants of a civil transaction. The contracts
whose parties are official institutions and that include
the elements of private connections should be treated
as mixed constructions both containing civil agreements and some elements of business contracts.

Key words: contract, agreement, business contract, unnamed construction, innovation, state-private
partnership.

 .., ..

44

III.

. . 1 / 2011
, ,
.

,
.
, , .
, , , , .
. 2 . 421 , ,
.
, , . ,
. .

, : , .
.. , ,
, [15, 123].
. ,
, [4, 30]. ,
, , .
- . , ,
,
, ,
. ,

.
.. ,
, . , -

III.

45

. . 1 / 2011

[12, 28]. ,
[9, 2123]. ,
.
, -
, :
; ; , ; .

. , ,
. . 12-31.20
[1].
. ,
?

.
, , ,
, .

: , ; , , ; ,
.
, , , , -.

, () .
.. ,
, ,
( ,
) -, [6, 3].
46

III.

. . 1 / 2011
, , , .

,
-.
: -, -, -,
.
.
,
, , , ,
, ,

(culpa in contrahendo),
[9, 25]. , ,

. , , ,
, ,
.
. , ,
, .

.
, , ,
() [10, 40-53; 13, 98; 16, 225], , [3, 14; 5, 59; 11, 50-59].
, , , . , . , .
, : ,
.. , , ,

III.

47

. . 1 / 2011
,
- , ,
[11,
53-59].
, -,
[2, 74]. .. [8, 35]
. , ;
(
)
[7, 6-9].
, , , .
,
,
, , , . , ,
, .
-
[14, 176-178]. , , , .
, , ,
-
.
,
() ,
.

48

III.

. . 1 / 2011
:
1. 22.07.2005 116- (. 25.12.2009)
// .
25.07.2005. 30. (. II). . 3127.
2. , .. . .: . , 1992.
3. , .. . .: . , 2001.
4. , . . .: -,
1948.
5. , .. - . . . ... .
. . ., 1979.
6. , .. () .:
, 2006.
7. : , , . .: , 2002.
8. , ..
// : , , . 2009. 1.
9.
. .: , 2009.
10. , .. ,
// , .: - , 1975.
11. , .. .
.: , 2002.
12. , .. : // /
. .. . .: , 2008.
13. , .. .: , 1974.
14. , .. : //
-
. .: .
, 2009.
15. , .. . : -. , 1990.
16. , .. . . .: , 2005.

III.

49

. . 1 / 2011


347.454

..




N. Melnichuk
Moscow University of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia
TOWARDS THE NOTION AND LEGAL REGULATION OF CONTRACT
FOR CARRYING OUT RESEARCH WORK FOR STATE NEEDS
OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
.
, .
- , ,
.
, .

-
. : , - ;
;
, - .
: ,
-
, - , , , .

Abstract. The article deals with two important


problems arising at making a contract for carrying out
research work for state needs. In the first part of the
paper the author reveals the notion of the contract
under study and determines the factors influencing
its conclusion. The definition of state needs is analysed.
The second part of the paper is concerned with
the problems of legal regulation of the contract for carrying out research work for state needs. The following
aspects are under the authors special attention: basic
conditions and their reflection in legal documents, fixing the results of intellectual activity and the problem
of constructive approach to the question of legal regulation of contracts for carrying out research work for
state needs.

Key words: state contract, contract for carrying


out research work for state needs, research, legislation, basic conditions, intellectual activity output.

 ..

50

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
, , .
,
, .
,
.
, , ,
, , , .
- ,
,
,
.
-
, .

, , , [5, 344].
, . , ,
, , ,
, ,

, ,
[10].
, , , .
.
, , ,
, -

IV.

51

. . 1 / 2011
, .

, , , , ,
, , ,
, ,
, ,
, , , ,
[10].
, , :
- ;
-
;
- , ,
;
- ;
- [8].
,
- . , ,
,
,
,
, , , , [11].
- :
- , ;
-
- , ;
52

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
- ;
-
,
- ,
, ,
;
- ;
- ;
- , - ;
- , -
;
- - [11].
, , - ,
, , , ,
.
,
- . , ,
.
.. ,
- - [1,1].
, , - .
,
, . ,

IV.

53

. . 1 / 2011
, -
,
.
- .763768 [4,235].
, , ,
, , , , ,
. , ,
.
-
. , , :
- ;
- ;
- ;
- [3].
: - , ,
; , ,
,
,
[6].
- ,
- , ,
,
, , ,
,
8 1997 . 305 ,
, [9].
-
54

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
,
, .
- [7]
,
- , , ,
[2,14].
, : -,
-
. -, , , , ,
- .
:
1. .. , -
: ... :
12.00.03. ., 2009.
2. . -,
- // . 2002. 6.
3. . . 2 26.01.1996.
4. . : / . .. . 2- ., . . .: , 2002.
5. : 2 . II. 1: . 2- , . . . .. , . .: 2004.
6. -
,
2002-2010 . //http
//www.altlinux.ru/media/otchet dlia publikacii/
7. 02.09.1999. 982 - .
8. 26 1995 . 594.
.

IV.

55

. . 1 / 2011
9. 8 1997 . 305

.
10. 21 2005 . 94 , , . .4. . 1.
11. 23 1996 . 127 - .

56

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
343.233

..


P. Savin

Moscow Institute of Economics, Politics and Law

NECESSARY DEFENCE AS RESULT OF SOCIOGENESIS


.
.

.
. ,

. ,
,
.
: , ; ;
; ; .

Abstract. The paper studies the cause of necessary defence. The periods of mankind evolution are
considered: from primitive societies to first constitutions of democratic states. The criterion for such period division is state attitude to the right of necessary
defence. The author arrives at the conclusion that the
right of necessary defence has come into being and
developed as a result of human society evolution sociogenesis. The author suggests a theory according
to which the process of globalization will lead to making a uniform world standard of the right of necessary
defence.

Key words: circumstances excluding the criminality of act, necessary defence, the right of necessary
defence, sociogenesis, period division.

. , .

, , , , nullum crimen sine lege (.) [2, 86-88] .
.
, Homo sapience sapience [6,12-16], , ().
,

 ..

IV.

57

. . 1 / 2011
. :
;
, .
, , , 
(Hominidae), , . , 
, ,
,
. , -
, Homo sapiens sapiens .
,
. :

?
, , , ,
, -XI , . .
,
.
() : , , , - , ,
[3, 635].

. ,
, , :
1. : , ;
2. :
, , [4, 307].
,
,
.

58

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
[4, 307]. , ,
,
.

, . , .
, , [3, 847].
, , .
, ,
,
. , ,
, . , ,
, .
, : ; , ;
[7].
:
, , , . ,
.
[5,104-107]. , .
, , , ,
, . , . ,
, .
: ,
:
[9,18].

.
-

IV.

59

. . 1 / 2011
, . .
:
, [1, 238-273]. , , ,

. - , : , [10].
, , ,
-
,
, .
- ,
. , .. , ,
.
, . .. ,
:
, ,
[8, 478].
, ,

.
,
,
, , . :
1. ,
, , ,
;
2. ,
;
3.
, , , , ,
60

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
,
;
4. , , ;
5. - ,
;
6. ,
, .
,
, . ().
, , , , , ,
.

:
1. , .. , .. : . .: - , 1998. 682 .
2. : : 2 ./ . .. ,
.. . 2- ., . .: , 2008. .1: .
592 c.
3. / . .. . .: - , 2008.
928 .
4. : . /.. , ..
.; . . .. , .. . .: -
, 2008. 336 .
5. , ,
./. .. . .: - , 2000. 1104 .
6. /. . .: , 1996. 1200 .
7. Cuban religion. Human beings. URL: http://www.cuba-junky.com/
cuba/religion.html ( 12.05.2010).

IV.

61

. . 1 / 2011
8. Ferzan, K.K. Self-Defense and the State. Ohio State Journal of Criminal Law. 2008. URL: http:// moritzlaw.osu.edu /osjcl/Articles/Volume5_2/
Ferzan-PDF.pdf ( 12.05.2010).
9. Kopel, David B. The Torah and Self-Defense. Penn State Law Review,
Vol. 109, No.1, 2004. URL: http://www.davekopel.com/2A/LawRev/TheTorah-and-Self-defense.pdf ( 12.05.2010).
10. U.S. Constitution Online URL: http://www.usconstitution.net /
const.html#Am2 ( 12.05.2010).

62

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
347.45/47

..


(. )


- 
Y. Sokolova

Baikal State University of Economics and Law (Irkutsk)

DEPOSIT AGREEMENT IN THE SYSTEM OF CIVIL LIABILITIES


.
-
;
, ,
. 2 . 779 ,
39 .
: , , ,
.

Abstract. On the basis of current legislation


and existing in legal literature points of view the
author of the article attempts at determining the place
of deposit agreement in the system of civil liabilities.
The researcher suggests the mentioned agreement
should be referred to a group of liabilities directed at
delaying recovery of the same property or repayment.
In connection with the previous statement the wording
of item 2, article 779 of the Civil Code of the Russian
Federation regulating the incidence of chapter 39 of
the Civil Code of the Russian Federation should be
changed.
Key words: deposit, classification of agreement,
directivity of result, the purpose of liability.

44 ( ) [2].
: ; ; . .

. , , ()
, .
,
(., .. , ..
), ,
 ..

IV.

63

. . 1 / 2011
(., .. , .. ) [1, 400-401;
3, 156-157; 4; 6, 453-454].
.. ,
: ,
. ,
[5].
:
, (,
) ,
,
, . .
. , ,
, [5].
..
.
,
, , , , .
, ,
(. 39-53). . 2 . 779 ,
39 , , , , , , , ,
, , 37, 38, 40, 41, 44, 45, 46, 47, 49, 51, 53 .
,

?
.. , .. [7, 3].
.. , :
, [4]. , , , ,
. ,
, [4].
64

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
.. ,
.
, ,
, [5].
.. , . , ,
, . ..
,

. , ,
. . , -
. , ,
, . , , , .

[5].
.. - [1,
403]. , (. 1 . 779).

, . , .
: ,
(-,
, , , ); ( , , ); ,
(); ( ); ( ) [1, 401].
,
, -

IV.

65

. . 1 / 2011
.
.
, , , .
, , .. ,
,
,
.
,

, .
, .
, , .
, , .
( )
.
.
,
( ) . ..
, . , , -, .
,
( ).
.
.
. 2 . 779 ,
( 44), : 2. , , , , , ,
, , , , 37, 38, 40, 41,
45, 46, 47, 49, 51, 53 .

66

IV.

. . 1 / 2011
:
1. .., .. : . .: , 2007.
2. ( ) 26
1996 . 14- // . 1996. 5. .410
3. : 2 . 2. 1: /. . .
.. . 2- ., . . .: , 2002.
4. .. . .: ,
1975. URL: http://www.law.edu.ru/script/cntSource.asp?cntID=100031721
( 15.06.2010).
5. .. . URL: http://pravo.vuzlib.net/book_z996.html (
15.06.2010).
6. : / . . .. .
7. .. . . 2. .:
, 2005. ( ). URL: http://download.
nchti.ru/libr/books/Right/ClassicOfRussianCivilistic/Elib/content_sher07.
htm ( 15.06.2010).

IV.

67

. . 1 / 2011


.. , ..

-

2010
2010 -

. ,
- .
: .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , .. , ..
, .. , .. (
) 22 ... // , . 2010. (
( ). [ .., ..,
.. .] - .: - , 2010 - 354 .).
, .
.. , ,
:
19 ... ( : / . .., ..
, .. ,-5- ., . . -.: -:
, 2010.-335.- ( Dura lex, sed lex).
.. ..

8 ... ( : / . .. . -.: -: ,
2010. - 128 .
,
. :
68

. . 1 / 2011
( : ,
/ (.. .);
. .. , .. , .. .- 4- ., . .-.: -, 2011.-911.- ( Dura lex, sed lex)
- (- : ,
030501 / (.. .); . .. , .. , .. .- 5- ., . . - .:
-, 2011.-575 .- ( Dura lex, sed lex),
(: . , / (.. .);
. .. , .. , .. .- 5- ., .
.- .: -: , 2011.- 447.),
2011 .
, ,
.. : (1917-1920 .) //
( : (1917-1920
.). . - .: , 2010. 368 .)
.. : , , . ,

.
-
10 , :
1. ..
// : - .: -
. .-, 2010;
2. .. , // - .: - . . -, 2010;
3. .. //
. .. . - . 2010.
4. .. : ? //
, 2010. 1 //
- 2010. . - . 2010;
5. ..
210 // , 2010. 2;

69

. . 1 / 2011
6. ..
90- // , 2010. 4-5;
7. .. // , 2010. 1;
8. ..
: // , . 2010;
9. .. : // ,
2010. 1.
10. ..
( )
()
() // ,
2010. 1.

. , , ... ..,
:

.. .

, .
. , , ..
521.005.02 .. 12.00.08 (
; - ).
..
..
,
: 12.00.03 ( ; ; ; ).
.. :

, 12.00.03 ( ; ; ; ).
, .. III -
70

. . 1 / 2011


.
..
( 2010 . . ()
, ; 2010 . .

). , 2010 .
, .
, ..
..,
-
2010 .
.
..
12.00.03
212.341.04
( 07 2010 .).
..
..
12.00.03 ( ; ; ;
( 19 2010 . 521. 023. 02
).
.. ..

12.00.03 ( ; ;
; ) ( 23 2010 .
203.019.02 ).
, , . : .. ..
2010 -

71

. . 1 / 2011
.,
:
.
2010 .. 4 VIII ,
, .
.. 2010
VII- -
,

. .. .
- ..., .. .. .
2010 .
250 01.03.2010 .

.
2010 - :
16 .

, , , .
, 2010 .
.
, - ,
.
2010 .

.
.

, , 72

. . 1 / 2011
. 2010
.
, .. :

,
.
..
:
-
.. , 060104 65 - .
.. 18 2010
III - :
,

.

2010 . ,
, ,
- .

73

. . 1 / 2011

, ,

; e-mail: antonida08@rambler.ru.
, ,
; e-mail: kuza-marfa@rambler.ru.
, ; e-mail:
privatpravo@rambler.ru.
, , ,

; e-mail: ciwilist@rambler.ru.
,
- ; e-mail: lan 5309@yandex.ru.
, , , - .
,

; e-mail: natka2301@mail.ru.
, ,
-
; e-mail: olga300pp@mail.ru.
, ,
-
; e-mail: anrozkov@mail.ru.
, - , ; pavsanias@
rambler.ru.
, ,
; e-mail: sokolova@baikalinvestbank.ru.
,
; e-mail: kreml.9@mail.ru.

74




1998 . : , , ,
, , , -,
, , .
,

, .
().
.

(www.elibrary.ru), (www.vestnik.mgou.ru).



2011. N1
:
..
..
..
..
..
:
105005, . , . , .10, 98
.: (499) 261-43-41; (495) 723-56-31
e-mail: vest_mgou@mail.ru
: www.vestnik.mgou.ru
6086/8. . . SchoolBookC.
270 . .-. . 4, . ..4,5.
10.02.2011. 226.

105005, . , . , 10.


. , .
, , , , ,
.
.
() .
, , , . . ,
, .
. , ,
. (
) . , .

: 1) ; 2)
( ); 3) (, ), ( ); 4)
; 5) ( ); 6) () ( ).

: ,
.
, ,
, (www.vestnik.mgou.ru) (www.elibrary.ru) (.: . 1286
1238 ).
.


(http://vestnik.mgou.ru), .


105005, . , . , .10, 98;
. (499) 261-43-41; (495) 723-56-31;
e-mail: vest_mgou@mail.ru