Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 198

. ..

1 (22)

2010




2004 .


..
.. ,
..
..
..
..

..
..
.. , .
..
..


.. , - . ,
.. , - . , (. )
.. , - . ,
.. , - . ,
.. , . . , - . ,
.. , . . ,
.. , - . ,
.. , - . ,
.. , . . ,
.. , - . ,
.. ,
.. , . . , (. )
.. , - . , (. )
.. , - . ,
.. , . . ,
.. , . . ,
.. , - . , (. )
.. , - . ,
.. , - . , (. )



:
644077, -77, . , 55,
,
E-mail: kmarina84@mail.ru

. .. , 2010


-
,
30-
. ..
(13 2009 .)

,
.. ........................................................................................ 7
.. - ............. 12
..
.......... 20
..
( ) ........................................................................... 26
..
...................................................................................... 29

.. ...................................... 35
- ..
......................................................................................... 41
.. :
............................................................................................................................. 49

.. ............................... 56
.. ,

............................................................................................................................... 60
.. ..................................................... 68
.. -
............................................... 73
..
........................................................................................................... 77
..
( ) ............ 82
..
................................................. 95
.. : ................................... 100

.. ............................ 101
..
............................................................................................................................................. 107

.. 102
.............................................. 111

..
..........................................................................................116

.. - (
1917 . 1941 .) ......................................................................................................................123
.. : .......................................125
.. 26 ......................130

..
......................................................................135
.. - .......................................139
.. - :
................................................................................................................149
.. - ,

...........................................................................................................153
.. .................................157
..
................................................................................................................161
.. XVIIIXIX .
.........................................................................................................167

,
, , ,

.............................................................................174

.. ..
2- ., ., . .: , 2007. 448 . (
) .......................................................................................................176
.., .. ..
- . :
- . . , 2009. 240 . ......................188
............................................................................................................190
.................................................................................................192
.................................193

CONTENTS
ON THE MATERIALS OF ALL-RUSSIAN RESEARCH-TO-PRACTICE CONFERENCE
THE PROBLEMS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT IN MODERN RUSSIA,
DEVOTED TO 30TH ANNIVERSARY OF LAW FACULTY OF OMSK STATE
UNIVERSITY OF DOSTOEVSKY (THE 13TH OF MARCH 2009)

CONSTITUTIONAL, STATE AND INTERNATIONAL LAW


Buchakova M.A. The conception of sustainable development in the context
of international accepted statutory environmental defense............................................................. 7
Philatov E.YU. On definition of constitutional legal responsibility ............................................. 12
Simonova V.V. The correlation of international and interstate rules in the regulation of
constitutional status of the minority group in the Russian Federation.......................................... 20
Syryanov A.V. The State as a system with the social regulative self-organization feature
(synergic approach) ...................................................................................................................... 26
Kiselyov I.A. The influence of decision of federal jurisdiction on the expenses of Omsk
region budget ................................................................................................................................ 29
FISKAL AND FINANCIAL LAW
Maslov K.V. On the definition of tax administration .................................................................... 35
Tsvili-Buklanova A.A. Threatening of Russian tax security in the context of modern
state development ......................................................................................................................... 41
Knyaskova M.A. Legislative novels of small business approval: estimation and
prospects ....................................................................................................................................... 49
CIVIL LAW
Philippova O.S. Economic companies in the pre-revolutionary Russia ....................................... 56
Nevsgodina E.L. Legal effect of the overrunning, prescripted for the exercise of powers
of Russian civil law representative ............................................................................................... 60
Shlotgauer M.A. The computation with the housing salesman..................................................... 68
Vershinina D.V. On the civil responsibility of judges for the harm-doing during the
judicature in the RF ...................................................................................................................... 73
Bakhitova D.Ph. The notarial certification and the state registration of real property
business......................................................................................................................................... 77
Spiridonova A.V. The definition and the particularities of cartel agreements (concertde
actions) owing to Russian anti-monopoly legislation................................................................... 82
Gryzykhina E.A. About pledge as a way of maintenance of execution of obligations
of the builder under the contract of participation in share building.............................................. 95
Temnikova N.A. Registration of marriages in Russia: range of problems .................................. 100
CIVIL AND ARBITRAL PROCESS
Nemtseva V.B. On the principle of judicial act sequence check ................................................. 101
Perminova E.V. Submittal target of cassational appeals for the arbitration court
determination .............................................................................................................................. 107
LABOR AND SOCIAL LAW
Laptev G.S. The convention International Labor Association 102 On the minimal
social service standards as a source of the law of social security ............................................. 111

Maslov N.A. The problems of law enforcement by the realization of rights and liberty of
military service for a regular term ...............................................................................................116
CRIMINAL LAW AND CRIMINOLOGY
Fokin M.S. State-religious relations in the USSR (the period since October 1917
to 1941)........................................................................................................................................123
Grinberg M.S. The technological crime: Historical perspective. ................................................125
Popov I.V. Conceptional questions of perfection of Criminal Code of the Russian
Federation 26th chapter ................................................................................................................130
CRIMINAL PROCESS AND CRIMINAL SCIENCE
Revenko N.I. The investigation of the objective truth the pre-trial procedure problems
fulfillment means of the investigator...........................................................................................135
Lebedev N.Yu. The structure of criminal procedural conflicts ...................................................139
Boyarskaya A.V. The criminal procedural procedure and the proceeding: competition of
ideas.............................................................................................................................................149
Kirilin S.V. The perfection of criminal procedural status of the person, in respect of
which the procedure according to the enforcement measures of medical character
application ...................................................................................................................................153
Gumerov G.G. On the necessity of the pre-trial procedure reform .............................................157
Popova T.Yu. The functional characteristics of the investigating authority chief powers...........161
Kashtanova N.S. Enforcement measures of material character in the XVIIIXIX before
the lawmaking .............................................................................................................................167
THE GUEST OF EDITORS OFFICE
The interview with the Omsk regional office chairman, the honored artist of the Russian
Federation, the doctor of juridical science, professor, Omsk State University holder
of chair of criminal process and criminal science Vladimir A. Asarov.......................................174
THE SCIENCE LIFE
Kozhevnikov V.V. The review on the textbook of L.A. Morozova The theory of state
and law. 2. issuance. M.: Ekmo, 2007. 448 p. .....................................................................176
Asarov V.A., Tarichko I.Yu. The review on the monography of O.Z. Chelokhsayeva
Modern criminal procedural policy of state. Vladikavkaz: publishing office of
V. Gassiyev, 2009. 240 p. ........................................................................................................188
INFORMATION ABOUT AUTHORS ............................................................................................190
INFORMATION FOR AUTHORS ..................................................................................................192
OMSK STATE UNIVERSITY PUBLICATIONS ..........................................................................193

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 711.


.. , 2010

342


-
THE CONCEPTION OF SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN THE CONTEXT
OF INTERNATIONAL ACCEPTED STATUTORY ENVIRONMENTAL DEFENSE
..
M.A. BUCHAKOVA

.
The questions of environment protection are considerate on the international level.
: , , , , .
Key words: environment, protection, management, international, sustainable development.

,
,
,
.

( ,
, , ,
,
. .) .


,
.

-
.
,
.

- . .

,
,

[1].
.
,
[2], [3], , ,
[4] .
- , . ,

. ,
, ,
.
7

..

I . .

.. . : ,

, homo sapiens

[5].
- ,
[6].
. ,
.. , , [7].
I .

.
.
. - . ,
,
, .

8

1972 .,
,
1982 ., -- 1992 . 1972 .
. , ,
, .
().
: 1) , ; 2) ; 3) (

). ,
[8].
, ,
, , , - .
1982 .

.
,
,

,
1992 . -- ().

, -

.
:
,
, , ,
. , I . ,
,
, I .

, . ,
. ,
,
,
[9].
,
.
, ,
. ,
,

.


.
2000 . -

, I [10].
,
,
2015 . , . , :



.

2002 .
. ,

.
, , , ,
.
,

.
, 1992 . ,
,

,
.
,
.
,
.

.
c ,

9

..


[11]. ,

, . , ,
, , , , - [12].

, . -,

; ,
Homo sapiens ; -,
(, , , .),

.
,
.

[13]. .
.
. .
[14].
, 10

.
, .
, ,
, .
.

.

. , .
, .. ,


.
-
. ,
, .



, ,
[15].


.

.

,

,
. .
(1982 .)
.
:
(1973 .);

(1973 .); . , , (), ( ), () .
,
, , , .
, , .
__________________
1. . . , // . 2007. 2.

2.
3.

4.

5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.

12.

13.
14.
15.

.: .., .. . ., 1982. . 392.


.: .., ..
:
// . ., 1981. . 31.
.: ..
// . ., 1980. . 33.
.. . . ., 1998. . 70.
.: .. -
. ., 1982.
. 115.
.: ..
. ,
2005. . 24.
.: .., .. . /, 2007. . 576577.
/ . .. . ., 1994. . 440450.
.: URL: http://www.un.org/russian/goals/
.: Lafferty W.M. The politics of sustainable
development: global norms for national implementation // Environmental politics. 1996.
Vol. 5. 2.
.: .., .., ..
. .,
2002; .. //
: . ., 2001; ..
,
//
. . 12. .
2004. 5; .. // . 1999. 4.
.: .. . ., 2005. . 340.
.: .. . . . 342.
.: / . . .. . ., 2005. . 182.

11

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 1219.


.. , 2010

342.03

ON DEFINITION OF CONSTITUTIONAL LEGAL RESPONSIBILITY


..
E.YU. PHILATOV
, .
.
The article is devoted to problems, relating to interpretation of constitutional liability. The author
researches different view points and presents his own treatment.
: , , , , .
Key words: liability, obligation, legal relation, punishment, compulsion.


-
. , ,
-
, [1], -
- ,
, (
) [2],

, [3]. ,
-

.
,
12



, ,
,
-

() ,
,
.

.

: (, )
()
. : ()
(, ). , ,
(-

) ,
. ,

, .
I.
()
, ( )
(
( ), ) .
:
,
[4].
, , : ,
, ;
, ( , ); [5];


[6].

,
[7],
, -

,
.
II.
()


, : .

,
.
.
1. .
,
,
.. [8].
,
, () .

. () ( )
, , ,
- .
,
() [9].
..
,
13

..

,

.
[10].
, , ,
,
.
.. , ,
.

, .. ,
, ,
.
2. .
,
() ;

, . ,
, , .
.
14

2.1.
.

: ()
[11],
[12], ,
[13].

,
.
[14].

.


.
( ) (),
, (),

.

, .
- , -, ()
(,
), -,
, :
() ,
. ,
(

, . .), : 1)
(. . )
() ,
, , ; 2) ()
() ,
, ,
- .
, , .
, .

( ,
)
.
,
- ,
-
, ( ) :
,
, , .
, ,

, , , ,

. , ,
. . , , , -

.
(
) . .. , - , [15].
, ,
, ,

. . , ,


( ).

( ,
, . .),
,
[16].
: ,
-
,
, ,
(, ) [17].
,
[18].

( ) ,

.
15

..

,
, :
,

.
2.2.
() ,
.
,

[19].

, (
() ) [20].
.


, .
, : , -
(. 5 ),

(. 192, 238, 385
).
2.3.
.

,

; 16

( ,
) [21].
, ,
.
.
1.
: ,
.
2.
( ) ,
,

.
3.

( )
.
,


( ,
. .). ,

, . .
(
),
-
, .
, . -

, ,
,
, , (), ,
. ( , . . )

,
.
4.
.. , , , [22]. , , , .
5.
. ,

, , ,
, . .,

,
( ,
. .).
,
.

. ,
, 19 , ,
(
. ..) , , ,
; , 2.9
, ,

,
, ,
, , ,

,
.
2.5.
() ,
.


, ,
[23], , ,
,
, [24].
, ,
, , , ,

,
. .
,

17

..

,
, .
() ,
.

.
1. , () .
,
.
.
2.

,

.

( ),

.
3.
,
,
.
,
.
,

, -.
18

- . , - .
-, ,
. , -
.
-, ,
-


- ,
(,
-,
).

, ,
.

.
,

.
___________________
1. ..
: - .
., 2006. . 96.
2. .. . .,
2001. . 321.
3. .. . . ., 2002.
. 283.
4. ..
(- ). .: - . -,
1990. . 18; ..

5.

6.
7.

8.

9.

10.

11.
12.

13.
14.

: . , 1996. . 8.
.: .., ..
. ., 2007.
. 131137.
.. : : . ., 2004.
. 203.
., : ..
( ): . . . . ., 1985.
. 4142; ..
// . 1998. 1. . 9596;
.., ..
// .
2008. 3; .. .
. .,
2008. . 302; .. :
, , . .,
1985. . 131133.
.: ..
// . 2008.
1; .

.
., 2008.
..
// . 2008. 1.
. 143.
..

.
., 2008. . 21.
.. . .: , 2007. . 501.
. : .. . ., 1976. . 20
(
.. ).
.. // . 1973. 4. . 30.
., : ..
. .,
1972. . 101; .. //

15.
16.

17.

18.

19.

20.

21.

22.

23.

24.

. 1972. 9. . 36,
38: .. // .
. . 1977. 4. . 45.
.. :
. ., 2006. . 407.
.. :
. ., 2004. . 480; ..
: . .,
2008. . 364.
.. // . 2003. 4. . 32
33; .. //
. 1998. 1. . 96.
.: .. //

: - / . .. . : , 1999. . 2528.
.. : .
: - , 2005. . 255.
..
( ). .: - .
-, 1983. . 140.
..
( ). , 1985.
. 87; .. . .:
- . -, 1985. . 172.
.. - : . . . . . ., 2008.
. 15.
..
// .
2001. 5. . 5657; ..
: . .,
2006. . 411.
..
( ): .
. . . . , 2006.
. 11.

19

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 2025.


.. , 2010

342




THE CORRELATION OF INTERNATIONAL AND INTERSTATE RULES
IN THE REGULATION OF CONSTITUTIONAL STATUS OF THE MINORITY
GROUP IN THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION
..
V.V. SIMONOVA

.
The article is devoted to the some problems of international and national law correlation in adjusting
constitutional status of human minorities in Russia.
: , , , ,
.
Key words: constitutional law, international law, human minorities, human rights, democracy.

,
,

- [1],
. .
.

, ,
,
, , , , .

. ,
. .
- [2].


, 20

,
[3].

,
,
[4].
, ,
,
[5].
, .
. , ,
, , ,
, ,
-

. ,

,

, - [6]. - ,
.



.

. 1 , , ,
. . . 71

, . . 72


. - ,

.
. 3 . 37
... ,
.



, ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
,

,
. , ,


,

.
. 19
,

, , , .
,
, .
. 2 1
,
; (. 26); (. 28);
(. 30), ,
, .
, , . 4 . 15
,
,
.
- 5 10 2003 .
. , ,
.
21

..



,
, ,

,

.
,
,
[7].
,
,

, ,
, .
[8], , [9],
, . 26
[10].
14


[11].
[12],
[13],
1948 . (
1993 .) [14], [15].


.
. 1
14 1960 . [16]
, ,
22


, , , , , , ,
.
111

,
,
.
2000/43/
29 2000 .
[17] , ,
.


[18], ,
.
,
,
, ,
(. 2) [19].
, ,

[20].
,
[21], ,
.
, -
, ,
.

[22], ; 27 1978 . [23],
.




[24].


: 107

, , 169 , , [25].
- - , ,
[26]; [27];
[28],
[29], . 19
;
97 - ( 1949 .); 118
; 143
- ; 157
[30]. R(2001) 17
-

[31].

.
.
[32],
,
,

182

. 162 [33]
, .

,
, .



[34].
13 2006 . [35]
,
,
, .
[36], M
18 1988 . [37].
, ,
18
1979 . [38] [39]. . 21
: , , , -
,
.


[40],


.

, , 5
1966 . :
,
23

..

,


, [41].
, ,
.
,

. 4 . 15
, . . ,
,
, . , ,
, .
86 106 . 6 1419

101- 15 1995 . .

, , .
,
.

,
.
,
[42].
, . 1 . 3
, . 4

.
24

___________________
1.
(., : . // : / . . .. . .: ,
2001. . 481482). ,
, ,
, , ,
(. : .. - ()
//
: - :
/ . .. . : , 2002. . 2281).
2. .. /
. .. . 22- . .: .
., 1990. . 348349.
3. : / . .
.. . .: , 2001. . 258.
4. ..
,


(.: ..
: 2 . . 2. .: . ., 1981.
. 138139).
5. ., : .. :
. . .: , 2004. . 383.
6. . : . . 2- . .: , 2004. . 9192.
7. . 2003. 12.
8. .
217 (III) 10
1948 . // :
/ . . .. . .:
, 2003. . 20 ( ).
9. 2200 (III)
16 1966 . //
. . 4849.
10. 2200 (III)
16 1966 . //
. . 4849.
11. 4 1950 ., // . . 324.
12. 7 2000 .
,

, () // . . 338339.

13. 18 1961 ., // . . 327332.


14. . 30
1948 . // . . 371.
15. -
26
1981 . // . . 383.
16. 11- , 14 15
1960 . // . . 188191.
17. ,

, , ,
.
,
,
. , , , . .: . . 362365.
18. , 14
1960 .
, . 13
. 13 .
19. 47/135
18 1992 . // . . 2425.
20. 1 1995 ., // URL:
hr-bs.ru. 05.04.2009 .
21. 2106 () OOH 25 1965 . // . . 5358.
22. 3068 (VIII) 30 1973 . // . . 6869.
23. 20- , 24 28 1978 . // . . 165
166.
24. 5 1992 ., // URL:
echr-base.ru. 05.04.2009 .
25. . . 244255; 298313.

26. 40/144
13 1985 . //
. . 4447.
27. 45/158
18 1990 . // . . 116145.
28. 526 (VII)
26 1954 . //
. . 153.
29. 28 1951 . , 429 (V)
14 1950 . //
. . 154.
30. .: . . 205207; 218
236; 260267; 268278; 284297.
31. 27.11.2001 .
774- // URL: hr-s.u.
05.04.2009 .
32. 44/25
20 1989 . // . . 92115.
33.
. , 23 1980 . // URL:
www.ilo.org. 05.04.2009 .
34. . . 339.
35. 61/106
13 2006 . // URL:
www.un.org. 05.04.2009 .
36. 2856
(VI) // URL: www.un.org.
05.04.2009 .
37. 17 1988 . -
// . . 374.
38. , 34/180
18
1079 . //. . 7589.
39. 649
(VII) 20 1952 . // . . 8991.
40. 36/55 25 1981 . //
. . 2730.
41. ,
1966 . // . . 183.
42. . : .. .
.: , 1974.

25

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 2628.


.. , 2010

34


( )
THE STATE AS A SYSTEM WITH THE SOCIAL REGULATIVE
SELF-ORGANIZATION FEATURE (SYNERGIC APPROACH)
..
A.V. SYRYANOV
,
,
.
In presented article denominated attempt of the cognition to essence such notion, as state and person, by
means of synergic of the approach with inherent its method of the system analysis of the processes and
phenomenas.
: , , , .
Key words: state, synergic of the approach, system analysis, cognition to essence.

. .: (), , , ,
.

.
, ,
.
, .
, . , ()
, , , ,
26

.
, ,
, [1].

,
.
, , . ,
. ,
, . .
.


, , , .
,
,

.
,
,
[2].

,
, , . . ,
. .
.
- , . .
,
. , , ?
, ?
,
, ?

, ,
,
, ,
[3].

, ,

. , ,

. . , , , , . ,
, ,
, . , .
.
, , . ,

.

.
,


, . - .


- . , .
,
,
.
,
.
[4].
,
, ,
:
.
, ,
, .
. ,
,
.
, ,
.
, ,
. . , .
, . ,
. , ,
27

..

,
. ,
, , .
, , .

,
, . , . . () ().

, , , . .
, ,
.

, , [5].
,

, . , , ,

28


, . ,
, , , -,
.
,
-
.
-,

. .
, . .

,
,
,
,


, .
___________________
1. .. . ., 2004. 417 .
2. .. . ., 2001.
414 .
3. .. . ., 2005.
347 .
4. .. . .,
2005. 394 .
5. .. . .,
2005. 474 .

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 2934.


.. , 2010

336.153.1



THE INFLUENCE OF DECISION OF FEDERAL JURISDICTION
ON THE EXPENSES OF OMSK REGION BUDGET
..
I.A. KISELYOV

.
, .

, .
At present the practice of transfer of federal authority execution to the regional level without the required
financial compensation is wide-spread. Yearly this situation causes the increase of expenditure of regional
budgets which can never do without governmental subsidy and it is also typical for the budget of Omsk region.
It is considered to be necessary to change the approach to the delegation of additional authority to the regional
level and find proper methods of evaluation of resources range required for their realization.
: , ,
, .
Key words: transfer of federal authority execution, inter-budget relations, regional budgets, budget of
Omsk region.



.

,
.
.
,
,

.

,
.
, 2006 .


.


2006 . 120 %, 2007
119 %, 2008 120 %.

, ,
150 %,
, .
2007 . 129,6 , 2008 . 44,6
.
29

..

5.1 29 2006 .
258- [1] 1
2008 .
:

( , , );

( );

( ,

);
,
( ,

.
24 2007 . 198- 2008 2009
2010 [2]

.
2008 . 43,7 .
, 1 2008 . , ,
. .
30


2008 .
108,3 ,
320 . .
. .
2008 2009 2010

.
, ,

.
4.1 1 2008 .
, ,

, .


36 17 2007 . 230-
, ,

417 ,

.

,

( -

, - , ).


161,4 .


2008 . 750
450,5
,

2008 . 299,5 .
,
.


.
,

, , , ,
,
.


,


,

27 2006 . 169 -




,
[3],


,
,
18

, , .
,
,
,
,
.
2006 .
254,7 .
, ,
2007 . 360,0 . ,
2007 . 1,01,8 ,
1,82,8 .
, .
, ,
2007 .
26 2006 . 99-
,
31

..

- [4].
,

,
15 . ,
, 788,7 . .
, , 2006 . 3 , , . 2007 . , , , 88,6 , 2008 . 81,5
.
2008 .

,


, 18 22 .
,
, , , . ,
,

.
, , ,


32

.
,



.
-
, . , .
17
24 1995 .
181-
[5] , -, , . ,
-,
.



,
- , () .
6
24 1995 . 52-
[6] ,
, , .

, -

, 23
2007 . 537

,
2008 [7].

,

, .
2007 .
152,1 . .

, .
,
,
, ,
, , .


(
2 000 ,
11 041 , 2 549
,
177 309,70 , 10 1 032 ),

, , .
, ,
.

.
, ,
, , ,
.
, 2006 .
(. -).
. ,


450,0 ,
2008 . 115,0
,
27 ,
, 100,0 ,
687,0 .

2008 .

1,4 .


.
,

33

..



, .
.

.

32
20,4 7,3 .

,
.
,
( ).




, .

,

34

.
___________________
1. 29.12.2006 258-
// . 2007. 1 ( I).
. 21.
2. 24.07.2007 198-
2008
2009 2010 //
. 2007. 31. . 3995.
3.

27.03.2006 169
,
// . 2006.
14. . 1548.
4. 26.07.2006 99-

, ,
- // . 04.08.2006.
5. 24.11.1995 181-
// . 1995. 48.
. 4563.
6. 24.04.1995 52-
// . 1995. 17.
. 1462.
7.

23.08.2007 537
, 2008 // . 2007. 35.
. 4320.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 3540.


.. , 2010

347.73


ON THE DEFINITION OF TAX ADMINISTRATION
..
K.V. MASLOV
,
.
, ,
.
This article is devoted to the definition of tax administration as a category, used in monographies of tax
law more often last years. The author analyses definitions of tax administration, written by lawyers and
economists, and gives his own definition.
: , , , , .
Key words: administration, taxes, management, law enforcement, the notion.

, ,
.

[1],
[2] [3].

,
-,
, , ,
[4].
, ,



. ,
, -

,
,

,
.




.
-,
.
, .. .
, ,
, . 35

..


[5].
.. ,

, ,

,

[6].

,

[7].
,
.. ..
, , ,

. , .


..

, [8].
.
: ,
,
; - () [9].
36

.
, .. ,
[10]. (
, , , ,

, . .
,
- , , [11]), , ..
.
.. ,

,
, ,

[12]. ,

.
,

.

. , ,

, ..

[13].
[14], ,
, .
..
,
(
, . .) [15].


.
.. ,
[16].
.. ,
, ,
-,
(
); -,
, [17].
.. ,
, ,
,
[18].
.. ,
,
[19].
,
,

,

,
,

[20].

.
, ,
.

,
, ..
(), ,
,
,

, , ,
, , ,
[21].
,

,
.
.. ,

[22].
,
,

37

..

. , ,
.

.. . ,
,
,
,
[23].
,
, .
,

: ,
,
,
, . ,
, .

,

,
-.
,
,
, , .

,
.
38

- ,
[24].

, .
, , :
- .


,
, (
)

[25]. , , ,
.

.
, (
) . , , ,
.

,
,
. :
[26]. , , . , ,
,


.


[27].
,
.
- ,
,
.
,


, .

8.

9.

10.

11.
12.

___________________
1.

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

.:
23.06.2008 .
20092011 //
. 26. 07-13.07.2008.
.:
2012 . (.

17.11.2008 . 1663-) // .
01.12.2008. 48. . 5639.
., .:
(
1 30.05.2007 .
-3-06/333@) // .
2007. 23.
..
: ? //
. 2006. 6 (.
: )
..
/
: . 2007 /
. . .. , .. .
., 2008. . 49.
..
: . . . .
. ., 2007. . 5.
.: .. : /
. .. . , 2005.

13.
14.
15.
16.

17.

18.

19.

. 40; .. //
: -
(2324 2007 .) / -
. , 2007. . 129.
.. //
. 2007. 9 (. : ).
.. : // .
2008. 2 (. : ).
.: .. : . ., 2002 (. : .. / : . 2007 /
. . .. , .. .
., 2008. . 74).
: /
. .. . ., 1996. . 132.
..

/ : . 2007 / . . .. , .. . ., 2008. . 16.
.: .. . . . 49.
. : .. / . .. . ., 2007.
.: .. . . . 16.
.: . 2007 ( 27
2006 . 137-


) //
. 2007. 3. . 5.
.. :
/ : . 2007 /
. . .. , .. . ., 2008. . 59.
.. // . 2005. 6 (. :
).
.. / : . 2007 / .
. .. , .. . .,
2008. . 175176.

39

..

20. ., .: .. // . 2005.
7. . 6; .. : - : . . . . .
, 2005. . 3; .., ..
// .
2006. 3. . 12.
21. ..
. ., 2007. . 366.
22. .. / : . 2007 /
. . .. , .. . ., 2008. . 73.
23. .. -

40

24.
25.
26.
27.

/ : . 2007 /
. . .. , .. . ., 2008. . 80.
.: .., ..
.
., 2002. . 4.
.., .. . ., 2004. . 463.
.., ..
.
., 2006. . 23.
. : //
. 2003. 8 (. :
).

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 4148.


.. -, 2010

347.73



THREATENING OF RUSSIAN TAX SECURITY
IN THE CONTEXT OF MODERN STATE DEVELOPMENT
.. -
A.A. TSVILI-BUKLANOVA
.
, .
,

.
In this article the author considers the problem of maintenance of the tax safety of the state. There is a
list of the basic threats and their modern condition. The author suggests forming the mechanism of estimation
and neutralization of threats of safety in the tax sphere and proves the necessity of development of the state
strategy of maintenance of the tax safety of Russia.
:
.

Key words: the economic safety, the tax safety, threats, modern condition.

, , , , , . ,
.

, ,
, ,
[1].
,
, .
,
(, , ) [2]. , -


, , ,
. , ,


.
,
.
,
. , , ,

, [3].

,
41

.. -

, ,

[4].
,
, ,
, - ,
,

.

.

, , , ,
[5].

,

.
. ,
,
, , ,

.
. [6].
: 1) ,
42

- , ; 2)
[7]. [8] , ,
, .
.
[9] (. 3)

, ; [10].
,
,

. ,

,

.
,

, -

,
.

, , [11]. , , . ,
, .
,
.

,

:
1) , , , , ,
;
2)
,
,
, ;
3)

, ,
(
, )
, .
, , , , , ,
[12].
,
, , ,
,
,

;
4) ,
, ;
5)
;

6) , ;
7)
.
,
, ,
.
.
,

, , , -
,
,

.
,


,
[13].

. , 1 [14] , 2000
2008 . (22 ). ,
, , , , ,
, ,

,
, .
, , ,

.
43

.. -

,

.

124
[15].


,


. , 6
1991 . 1992-1
[16] 1 1992 .
1 2001 .
25 ( 3 1992 2000 .,
2 1993, 1994, 1996 1997 ., 5 1995 .,
1 1998 ., 4 1999 .). 4

, 3 , 3
.

,
- ,
.
, ,

.

,

, [17].

[18]. , ,

, .
. ,
44

, - , , . , 1990- .
, :
; ;
; ; ;
. [19].

, ,
, .

,
.
.
,
30 50 % [20]. 28 2006 . 64 : ,
, [21].

,
,
. , 2005 .

6 412 638 , 2006 . 7 065 020
, 2007 . 6 833 778 ,
2008 . 5 994 502 [22].


, ,
.
, , .

,
. ,
,
,
, . [23].


,
, .
,
, ,
. , , ,

. ,
, , ,
.

,
.
,
.
,
-

, [24]. ,
20 % [25].
,

48 % [26]. , 35 40 %
[27]. , 1,5
2 .
, .

300 700 .

,
30 [28].

.
( ,

). ,
, () [29]. ,
, . ,

.
, 2008 .

(31,6 %) (21 %) [30]. ,
, .
,
45

.. -

, ?
. 10 % [31].
,

.
,
.
,
.
. 1998 .
3 953 , 1999 . 11 820,
2000 . 22 352, 2007 . 26 785,
2008 . 17 967.


[32].


,
. ,
6
2008 . 17,9 . .
( )
44,85 .,
34,25 . [33].

, , ,
, .
, ,
46


, ,
,

[34]. , , .

, ,
. , ,
,


, . ,
, , ,
[35]:
(, , , . .),

;

,


, ;
, ,
-

, ,
, , .

,
, .

.
, .
,
,



,
, . ,

,

[36].




, .
, , .
,
,
.
. : , , , , , :
, ,
, , , , , , -

,
, [37].
( ).

:
,
,

[38].
______________________
1. .: ..
-
: . . . .
., 2004. . 27.
2. .: .. //
: , , .
, 2008. 1 (8). . 152.
3. 2007 .

7 781,120 6 965,3 , . . 89,5 % .
4. .: .., ..
.
., 2005. . 3.
5. .: .. . .,
2006. . 9.
6. .: .. .
., 1978. . 757.
7. . ., 2000.
. 934.
8. .:
17 1997 . 1300
( . 10 2000 . 24) // . 1997. 247. 26 .
9. .: 5
1992 . 2446-1 ( .
26 2008 .
103-) // .
10. .. . ., 2006. . 115.
11. .: .. : , , . . 4. ., 2002.
. 128.

47

.. -

12. .: .., .., .. . , 2003. . 30; ..,


..
20 19911997 .: .
., 1999. . 66; .., ..,
.. . , 2003. . 38; ..
( ). ., 2001. . 236; :
/ . .. .
., 1997; .., ..

. , 1999.
13. .: .. : .
. . . ., 2006. . 8.
14.
( ) 31 1998 . 146-
( . 30
2008 . 108-) // . 1998. 31.
. 3824.
15.
( ) 5 2000 . 117-
( . 13
2008 . 172-) // . 2000. 32.
. 3340.
16. .: 6 1991 . 1992-1 ( . 24 2001 . 118-) // . 1991. 52.
. 1871.
17. .: .. : . .
. . , 2004. . 121.
18. .: .., .. . .
., 1999. . 66; .., ..,
.. . . . 38; : / .
.. . ., 1997. . 473.
19. .: .. // : , , . , 2008. 1 (8).
. 164168.
20. .: / . .. . .,
2007. . 3.

48

21. .: 28 2006 . 64
//
. 2007. 3.
22. .: ( 4-)
,

( 20052008 .) // URL:
http://www.r55.nalog.ru/index.php?topic=
statistic55
23. .: .. .
., 1997. . 41.
24. .: ..
(
)
// . 2008. 3 (2).
25. .: www.gks.ru/wps/portal.ru
26. .: http//teneveconom.org.ru/2.html;
http://www.ecsocman.edu.ru/db/msg/;
www.spravedlivo.ru/position/
27. .: ..
( ): . .
. . . --, 2006.
. 13.
28. .: .. . . . 13.
29. .: .., .. . .
. 38.
30. .: http://www.gks.ru/bgd/regl/b09_01/
IssWWW.exe /Stg/d01/2-6-1-2.htm
31. .. -
: . . . . .,
2004. . 99.
32. .: .., .. . . . 4.
33. .
34. .: .., ..
. ., 2001. . 65.
35. .: .. -
: . . . . .
., 2008. . 15.
36. .: .. :
, , . ., 2000. . 18, 118.
37. . . . --,
1998. . 57.
38. .: 5
1992 . 2446-1 ( .
26 2008 .
103-) // .

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 4955.


.. , 2010

347.73

:

LEGISLATIVE NOVELS OF SMALL BUSINESS APPROVAL:
ESTIMATION AND PROSPECTS
..
M.A. KNYASKOVA
-
.
, , ,
.
Measures of financial-law support of small enterprise are researched. Particular attention is given to
legislative changes of taxation, crediting, control of small business owners and also allocation of
accommodation.
: , , , .
Key words: small business, supporting, finances, taxation.

.
,

,
.
.
,
.
,

.

; -

.
.
, . :

,
. 1 2008 .
, .
,
.
.

24 20 % ,

. ,
, .

,
49

..

.
20-
, . ,
.
,


.
, ,
. ,

,

.

. ,
, .
( );


;
(
), ; .
, , , 15
5 % , ,
.

, 50

.
, 2012 .
,
,
.
.
, ( );
, .

. -,

5 , ,

.


. , ,
. , ,
,

, ,
. ,
- ,

550560 .
. -,
, [1].

19 2008 .
, .

15
2008 . 797 -


[2].
() [3]
, [4]
. ,
,
,

, 3/4 , , - , , .


.
,
,

.
1 3 .
,
20 .
.
, ,
.
- . , , .

, . , - .
, ,
. ,
, ,
50
. ,

50 .

. , ,

(
),
. ,
(),
.
().
,
, . , , .
-
, ,
51

..

. ,
, ,
.

,
. ,

. , ,
,

.
, ,
.

. ,
. ,
,
23 .
,

.
.

. , ,
,
.


.
,
.
24 2007 . [5]
52

6
2003 . [6]


,
()

. 159- 22 2008 . [7],
,

.
.


1 2009 .

, ,
. ,
. ,
159-.

.
30 2008 . [8],


. ,


. ,

,
.

, ,
15 2008 .
,
.
1 2010 . ,

, .


.
. ,
,

. BusinessVision,
30
40 %.
. . 2008 .


. ,
.
,

.
10 .
,
30 % ,
.
. 50 70 % ,

.

-


.

.

.

: , , , .


.
.

( 20 % ),
. , ,
,
.

. , , 1 . 42
. . 2008 . . ,
, .

24.
, . ,

,
53

..

. ,
.



.
, . -, ,
, ,
,
, .
. ,
2008 .
3,8 .,
6 , 2009 .
4 .
, , . - .
, 110 , 33 23
.

:
1. , ,

. ,

.

.
2009 . 10,5 , 6,2 .
, 20102011 .

54

. , 2010 .

17,5 , 2011 . 22 .
, 20092011 . 50 .

.
2. . ,
.
3.

.
,
, , .
4. ,
,

,

.



.
5.
.
2005 .
,
,
, ,

. , ,
,
6. . . ,


.
___________________
1. . 2008. 22 .
2.
:
. 15 2008 .
797 // . .
. . ., 1990.
3. ()
: .
26 . 2009 . // .
. . . ., 1990.
4. -

5.

6.

7.

8.


,
: .
26 . 2009 . // .
. . . ., 1990.
: . 24 2007 // .
. . . ., 1990.

:
. 6 2003 //
. . . .
., 1990.

,


, : . 22
2008 . 159- // .
. . . ., 1990.


: . 30 2008 . 108 // . .
. . ., 1990.

55

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 5659.


.. , 2010

347


ECONOMIC COMPANIES IN THE PRE-REVOLUTIONARY RUSSIA
..
O.S. PHILIPPOVA
(
, ) .
The article is devoted to the law status of the trading company (company limited and company with extra
responsibility, join-stock company) in the pre-revolutionary Russia.
: , , ,
.
Key words: kinds of associations, the companies on actions, the companies on equal footing, responsibility
of members of associations.

,
, .
, , 8
1998 . 14- , 26 1995 . 208- .

, .

?
?
,
IX
.

, 56

.
.. , 1896 ., , (2125 .) : , .
(2129)
: ,
.
, , , ,
,
. : , . , , ;
, ,
[1].

? .. .. -

,
[2]. .
.. , ,

,

(. XIV, . .
. . 1916 . . 218) [3].
.. :
,
, , .
.

(),
, ,

. ,

. , ,

.. : (. . . 55; . X, . 1,
. 2128), (. . . 77),
(. . . 58; . X, . 1,
. 2139), :
(. X, . 1, . 2139),
(. X, . 1, . 2131), (. .
. 55). ,
: ,
.

,
, ,

,

, . , ,
.
,
, . . , (, ). ,
.

:
1.
(. 2128) , ..
..
,
. , , . , ,
1880 .

( )

, , , [4].
,
, , -,
, ,
,
, , , , , ,
, -, ,
, -, ,
,
, .
.. , , ,
57

..

. :
a) , , b)
, 500 ., , c)
, . , , ,
, , . ,
, (. .
. 1898, 31).
2. . 2139
:

,
, ,

[5]. .. , ,
; ; . ,
:
,

,
,
, , ;

. .
,
, ,
,
, .
3. , 58

,
;
4. .
, ,
, .
, , .
, , , ,
.

,
. , ..
:
,
, ,
, ,
, ? , : ,
, , , ,
.
( ),
, ,
;
, ,

,
, ,

,
.

- (1 . . .
30 1873 .) ,


;
:

. , , 2128 . . .,
, , ,
.
, ..
..

, ,
. . ,
( ) ,
. , .

,
,
,
,

.
, IX XX .


()

, ,
, . .. :
,

,
, . ,

, [6].
, .
________________
1. .. .
.-: ,
1896.
2. .., ..
. ., 2002.
3. ..
( 9-, ). .: , 1919.
4. .

,
(. 1).
.:
, 1880.
5. ..
. (). .: , 2008.
6. ..
. .,
1924.

59

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 6067.


.. , 2010

347

,


LEGAL EFFECT OF THE OVERRUNNING, PRESCRIPTED FOR THE EXERCISE
OF POWERS OF RUSSIAN CIVIL LAW REPRESENTATIVE
..
E.L. NEVSGODINA
,
, .
Various variants of excess of the limits established for realisation of power, and their legal consequences
are considered.
: , , , , .
Key words: representation, power, excess, abusing, limits.

,
,
, : 1) ( ), , ,

; 2) , . 3 . 37 . 3 . 182 [1].
(
, ).

. . 1 . 10
( ,
) ,
. ,
.. ,
,
,

60

, [2].
,
, ,
.
(. 179 ).

,

. , , ,
, ,


.
. ,
, . , ,
,
.

. 3 . 37 . 3
. 182 .
. 3 . 37 ,

,
,


. . 3
. 182
,
,
(
).
,


,
.
(. 182,
168 ).
,

, .
.
,
,
, , ,

, -.
,
, , ,
, .
,
-

,

(
). . 3 . 182


.
,
, . 3 . 182
(
).
,
,
. 3 . 182
.
,
, ,
.
. 3 . 182 (. 3
. 62 ) .
,
, ,
.
,
(
) ,
.
, . 3 . 182 ,

,
(. 2 . 184
).
,
,
61

..

,
, .
,
, ( )
, ,
, , ,
() .
, ,
,

() . ,
,
.

- ( ).
.
,
, . , : 1)
, ,
, . 3 . 182
,
, ; 2) , ,
, ; 3)

, , . 3 . 182

:
62


,

,
,
, .
. 2, 3 . 182 ( ,

), . 3 . 37

,
,

. , ,
. 1 . 37 ,
, . 37 .
,
, ( ), ,
.
,
,

. ,
,
, ,
( )
[3]. ,
,
,
, . .
, .


( )

, .
, [4], ,
, (,
), ,
, , ,
,
, , . .
, . ,

, ,

. 2 . 64
.
,
.

.. ,

. , . 9


,
,
,
, ,

,
, [5].
(,
)
..
[6].
,

.

,
, . 2 . 183
,
. :

,

(, )

? , ,
, .

. , ,
,

. , ,
,
,
,
[7].
. 2 . 183
.
, .
63

..


,

,
.

. ,



, , , ,
,
,

, .

,

,
, - ,
.
,
(, ),

.
,
,
, (,
),
, .
, , .
.
,

64

.

( ),
(. 1080
).
,
( ), , , .
, , , .
, , .
.. ,

.
,
,
,
(. 179 ).
. ,
(
), (

) ,
, .

,
.
,
-

, , ,
( )
.
. ,
,
, ,
.

, , , ,
,
.
,

.
,
,
.
, , ,
, , ,
, ,
,
(. 1 . 183 ).
, ,

( , ,
).
.
,
, , , .
- -

( ),

.
()
,
[8].
,
. 1 . 183
,
()

.
,
-

. 1 . 183 . ,


(. 53 )


( -).
. ,
,
, .
168, 174 ,

14
1998 .
174 .
. 174 ,
,
,
, ,
,

, , , ,

65

..

.
, () ,
(

), ,
, ,
.
,
. 174
, ,
.
( ) . 174 ,
( ) , . .
. , . 174 ,
( ) (. 3
. 1044 ).
, , ,
, ,
. ,
, ,
. 174 ,
, , . 6
. 2 . 183 ( ).
,
, ,
. 174 , , ( )
, , 66

, :
(. 7
14 1998 . 9).
.

- ( ,
. 1 . 124
) . - ,
,
(. 2 . 124 ). , ,
-

, (. 168 ).
,

- , [9], , ( ) :
(),

( ,
). , ,
.. ,
.

,
.

[10].
___________________
1. .

2.
3.

4.

5.
6.

.: ..
. ., 1972. . 39
.
.: ..

// . 2001.
34.
,
() ,
( .. // : - . ., 2004. . 74).
.. : . ., 2004. . 305.
.: ..
( : , , ): .

. . . /, 1981.
. 121122.
7. ,
, .
.. ,
, ,
,
( .. : . ., 2004. . 179).
8. . .
9. .: 14 1998 . 174 .
10. ..

// . 2004. 11. . 99.

67

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 6872.


.. , 2010

347


THE COMPUTATION WITH THE HOUSING SALESMAN
..
M.A. SHLOTGAUER
,
- . : ,

.
In the article the theoretical and practical problems arising at the parties at execution of a contract of
purchase and sale of living quarters are justified. The author has tried to answer on when, as well as in what
size it is necessary to execute to the buyer the responsibility to transmit to the seller the caused sum of money.
: , , , ,
.
Key words: calculation, living quarters, banking unit, the deposit of the notary, registration office.

, ,
- .

,
.
-
, .
. 2 . 558
. -
, .
.
(. 551
).
, - ,
68




, -
.
.
,
, -.
,
, , ,
, . . 2030 . , ,
, , 34 - . (, , -

. .).
,
,
.

-
: , ,

?
.1 . 486

,
,
. ,
. . 487
. 486 , , . ,
- (.
. 487 ).
-


.
()
.
, .
,

-
.

,
,
,

.


, ,

.
,

. . 5 . 488
, -, , ,

. , , , , , . ,
,

, ,
, - ,
.

,

, .
,

,
,
, . .
.

,
, ,
.
69

..

() .
, - , .

. , ,
, , ,
. ,
.

. ,
.
, ,
, .
, ,
,
[1].
. ,
. .
.. , , (,
),
(-, ,
.) [2].
..
.. : ,
[3].
70

, ,

,
[4].
. .. : , ,
,
, minimum minimum.
minimum
,

,
,
,
: , ,
[5].
. 4 . 421 ,
,
.
. 555
.

.
,
, . 3 . 424 , .
, ( ) -

.
, ,


, , ,
,
, , -

, .
(. 170, 179
) .

,
, , .
,
, , , . ,
.
,
, , ,
.
, ,


, .
[6].


.

, .
. ,


.
,

. , .
.
,
-
, ,

.

. .
, , ,


. .
: ,
.

.

( ).
,
.

. ,

-.

, ,
,
-

( )
.
71

..

,
.
-.
. , ,
, , ,
, , , , (
).

, , [7].

:
.
.. , [8],
, ,

. , ,
,
.


- ,
80 % .
, ,
,

72

.
-
.

,

. ,

, .

.
_________________________
1. .: .. // .
2. .:
( ) /
. .. , .. , .. . ., 1996. . 306.
3. .., .. . . 1: . 2-
., . ., 1999. . 391.
4. .: .. . ., 1998. . 425.
5. .. : 2 .
., 1997. . 2. . 231.
6. .: .. // -.
2004. 50. . 8.
7.

http://www.kommersant.ru
8. .. // -. 2004. 50.
. 8.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 7376.


.. , 2010

347.918(075.8)

-

ON THE CIVIL RESPONSIBILITY OF JUDGES FOR THE HARM-DOING DURING
THE JUDICATURE IN THE RF
..
D.V. VERSHININA
-
,
.
This article describes the problem of the civil legal judges responsibility for making harm by jurisdiction
nowadays in RF, also it has a few examples of regulation this questions by foreign laws.
: -
, , .

Key words: civil-law responsibility, judicial responsibility, justice departure, harm indemnification, recourse.

,
()
(. 53) [1], .


.

, ,
,
.
, , ,



.
-

.
,
-
.
,
[2],
[3],
[4],
,
-
, ,

.
- .
, . 2 . 1070 [5]
, , ,
, .
73

..

, ,
, -,
, ,
, .
,
, 2
1070 ,

() (), , [6].
, , ,
, (
)
,
( ) , - ( ), - . , ( ) ,

,
[7].
, (
)

, ( ) (),
.
,
,
,

.

74


, ,
,
, ,
, . . [8], ,

, ,
, [9].
,
,
,

, ,
, . ,
( )
, :
,
. , ,
[10].
-

.
, ,
. , , , .
-


. . 1
79-43 18
1979 ., ,
. , ,
[11].


-
.
,


.

-
. 1613 ., ,

-,
.
,
, .

. ,
.
.
, , , ,
,
. ,
. , (ultra
vires), , [12].
. -

,

,
.
. 1871 .
, 1983, 42 U.S.C., , ,
, ,


, , , ,

.
, ,
1483 , , . , ,
.
, ,
[13].
839

:
,
, .

.

, ,
- ,
75

..

,
,

, () ,
.
-
,

[14].
,
-
, .
, , .
,
, ,
.
-
, ,

76


.
___________________
1. // . 1993. 237.
2.
31.12.1996 . 1-
// . 1997. 3. 6 .
3. 26.06.1992 . 3132-1 // . 1992. 170. 29 .
4. , VI 02.12.2004 . //
. 2005. 2.
5. .
2 // .
1996. 5. . 410.
6. 08.02.2001 . 43- //
. 2001.
4.
7. 25.01.2001 . 1- //
. 2001.
3.
8. ., : 17.11.2005 .
05-519 // .
9. ., : 06.12.2005 .
5-05-106 // .
10. .. //
. 2007. 12.
11. ..
,
// . 2001. 9. . 55.
12. . . 5657.
13. . . 59.
14. . . 55.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 7781.


.. , 2010

347



THE NOTARIAL CERTIFICATION AND THE STATE REGISTRATION
OF REAL PROPERTY BUSINESS
..
D.PH. BAKHITOVA
. .
The Correlation of the public registration and public certificate of contracts of purchase and sale of
dwelling house. Positive and negative aspects.
:
.

Key words: civil law, contract, real estate, state registration, notarization.



,
,
, ,
,
. , . 54


- , . , , ,
,
.
,
.


- ,
: (1)

, (2) ,
(3)
(4)
.

, ,

.


.
- ,
.
-

77

..


.
-
: - .
,
,
- .
,
.
,
()
.
, , . 18 .
, .
,
,

- ,
,
, ( ), .


, - ,
.

78

, ( )
.
, , ,

. , ( )

-
.
,
,

.
, , ,
,

- .

,
-


, .


- , ,


.
, ,
, .


.
. ,


.
- ,
, .
,

,
, .

,
. ,


,

,

,
,
, , .
,
-

.
.

,
.
,
. , - : , , .


-.

,

.


,
?
. ,

, -
, . , ,



, 79

..

.


: ,
,

. , ,

-
, ,
,

, , ,

.
,
,
-
, ,
,


.


.

, , ,

.

80

. , - ,
.
.

[1].

,
. ,

,
.


,

.
- .

,

.


, -



.
- ,


,
,
.
, ,
, , .

-

. , . 121,
122 -

,
.
,

.
-
- , ,
.
___________________
1. , .
, 2003 .

81

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 8290.


.. , 2010

346.546.1


( )

THE DEFINITION AND THE PARTICULARITIES OF CARTEL AGREEMENTS
(CONCERTDE ACTIONS) OWING TO RUSSIAN ANTI-MONOPOLY
LEGISLATION
..
A.V. SPIRIDONOVA
,
( ) .
( ),
.
Present clause is devoted to the actual problems connected with revealing and suppression of
anticompetitive agreements (the coordinated actions) managing subjects in the commodity market. The special
attention is given attributes of such agreements (the coordinated actions), examples from practice of work of
antimonopoly bodies are resulted.
: , , .
Key words: cartel agreements, legislation, market.


, , .
,
, ,
. ,
: , ,
.
. :
2008
20 %,


2009

,

[1].
82

(), , (),
(
) (
). ( ) , , ( ),
( )
. .. , ,
,
,
().

,
-

( )

,
, , [2].

,

.


1998 . , .
,

[3].
,
. .. ,
,
,
,
,
,

[4]. .. , , ,
, ,
,

[5].

,
[6].

.
.. , -

XVIII . 1911 1929 . 550


1500 ; 1905 . 400 .
50 % [7].
,
:
; ; ( ); ;
; [8].
. 18 . 4 (
) [9] ,
, .

. -, . , ,
[10]. -, ,
,
,

.
.
,
- .
,
[11]. . ,

, , [12].
83

..

, - - ()
, ()
.
,
, . , , , , ,
, , [13].

, .
. , .. , .. , , , ,
,
, , , ,
()
. .
,
, , , ,
, , ,
[14]. . , ,
, ,

[15]. .. ,
, , ( )
[16]. ,

, ,
( )

[17]. ,
84


,
[18].

ICI v. Commission (1972) (ECR 619,
(1972) CMLR 557, paras. 64 and 65) , ,

.
,

,
[19].
,

. . 8
,
,

, :
1)
,

; 2) ,


. , ,
, , ,
,

-

( )

, .
, ,
,
- , (, , ,
)
, ()
[20]. ,

, ( ),
(
).
, , , ,


.
,
,
:

,
.
, ,
, ,
[21].

,
.
,
- -

2008
2009 .
- ..
( 10)
2008 .
, , , - -
, 80100 %. , ( )
.

, ,
(, ) . 2030 %.

:
. - ,
,
, [22].
4 2009 . -
11


,

[23].
,

, , , ,
- ,
. 85

..

, ..
, ,

,

[24]. , . 2 . 8 ,


.
( )
: )
( ) [25]; )
( ) ;
) (
) ; ) ( ) .


(
).
, ,
, . , ,
, [26]. .. , , ( ) ,
. , [27]. . ,

. 6 [28], 86


,


[29].
, ,

[30].

( ): .
,
.

, , , ,
[31].
,
,
[32]. . 19 . 4
,
,
,
.

(
) ,
[33].

,
. ,
, , , - ,
.

( )

,
(), , ( ) (
), . ,
,
( ) , , .
( )

. , . 1 . 11
, ( ), . . per se.
, ,
(), , () ; ,
; , ,
. ,
1999 .
, -
- , [34].

. ,

- [35].

( )
,
, ( ) , . . , . 1
. 13 , , (-

) , ,
(), , ,
,
: 1) ,
, ;
2)
(), (), (),
, . ,
. 12 ,

( ), .
( ),
.

, . . ,
.
, . , ( ), - . ,
.
1978 . 87

..


.
,
5 . 70
80- . , .

[36]. .. , 30- . XX .
.
15 1933 .
.
, ,

, . [37].
, ,
,

. ,
, 1999 . ,
, 500
225 [38].

, [39].
( ), 88

, . ,
.. ,

,

[40].
, ,
- ( ) 30 %
,
( ). ,
- 10
[41]. ,

,
, ,


,
.
, ( ) , , , ,
, , .

(
), ,

,
.
. ,
1993 .
20 [42].
, [43]. , ,
. ,


, ,

( )


[44].
,
.
. , . 14.32 [45] ,
,

,


()
,
,
.
___________________
1. . URL: http://www.fas.gov.ru/
news/n_22350.shtml
2. ..
,
// -
. 2000. 12/13 (5/6). . 75.
3.
//
.
URL: http://www.fas.gov.ru.
4. ..
XIX XX : - : . .
. . . , 2005.
5. .. : - . .:
, 2001. . 264.

6.
7.
8.
9.
10.

11.

12.
13.
14.
15.

16.
17.

18.

19.

20.
21.

/ .
.. . .: ,
2001. . 196.
.. . .:
, 2002. 548 .
2007 .
.

26.07.2006 135- // .
2006. 162.
.., .. : . 35 000 .
.: , 1990. . 118; .. : . 57 000
/ . .-.
.. . 19- ., . .: , 1987. . 606;
/ ; . .. . .: ,
, 2001. . 538.
.., ..
,
//
. .: .
-, 2003. . 411.
. // . 2002. 12. . 36.
. . 36.
.., .. . . . 413.
.
,
// . 2003.
2. . 1730.
.. // . 2004. 1. . 4850.
09-3376/2003- 25 2003
.
() ,
// .

- 15
2000 5622220/99 // .

//
.
URL: http:// www.fas.gov.ru
.
30.06.2008 . 30
,
//
. 2008. 8.

89

..

22. -

. URL: http://www.fas.gov.ru/article/
a_21856.shtml
23. .
24. .. ,
(
- ) // . 2005. 7. . 35.
25. .:
.. : - : . .
. . , 2007.
26.
, 2001. . : .

, .
. 22.
27. .. : . . . .
., 1995. . 99.
28. 22.03.1991 948-1 // . 1991. 16.
. 499.
29.
-
31.08.2006 //
. URL: http:// http://www.fas.gov.ru/
news/n_8297.shtml.
30.

-
13.11.2006 // .
URL:
http://
http://www.fas.gov.ru/news/
n_9519.shtml
31. .. (
): . .:
, 2000. . 191194.
32. . . . . 28.
33. .. . . . 76.
34. .. . . . 74.
35.
- 29
2003 132760/0314 //
.
36. ..

: - . .: , 1992. . 29.
37. .: .. XIX XX -

90

38.

39.

40.

41.

42.
43.
44.
45.

: - : . . . . . ,
2005.
..

:
// . 2003. 3.
. 149.
2007 . 273 783 000 Heineken, Grolsch
and Bavaria. , InBev, ,

. InBev ,
.
,
19961999 . ,
.

, , ,
.
// ,
.

URL:
http://www.fas.gov.ru
..
:
// . URL: http:// www.garant.ru.
..

// 30 2006 .
.. . . . 154.
.. . .
.. . . . 39.
30.12.2001
195- // . 2001.
256.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 9195.


.. , 2010

347



ABOUT PLEDGE AS A WAY OF MAINTENANCE OF EXECUTION
OF OBLIGATIONS OF THE BUILDER UNDER THE CONTRACT
OF PARTICIPATION IN SHARE BUILDING
..
E.A. GRYZYKHINA

.
In work features of pledge as way of maintenance of execution of obligations of the builder under the
contract of participation in share building are considered.
: , .
Key words: pledge, participation in share building.


.
90- .


, ,

, , ,
, ,
.

,
, ,

.
2004 .

(
, )

, ,

.
,
, . 13
. ,
()

() ()
() ,

, , , ()

() .
,

91

..


.
.

,


. ,
.
. 335 ,
( )
,
.
, , ,
. ,
, [1].
, ,

, .

.
,

, ,
, .

, . , .. ,
.
, ,

[2]. .. , . 2 . 703 , , ,
92

[3].
,
[4]. , ..
, ,
, . 211 [5],
,
.
, , (. 1 . 218 ).
, ,
. . 1 . 218 ,
.. , , ,
[6].


.

, ,


, ,
. .
. (
)
, , , . , ,


, .
-

,

.

.

()
.
, , ,
, ,
,
,
, .
,
,
.
,
.

, ()
(. 2
). ,
.
,
. 36 ,
. ,

, .


,


.


(. 16
).
()
()
.
.
,
.
. , ,
.
() ,
, , ,
.
-,
. 3 . 13 , ()
, () , ()

,
, ,
93

..

. .. , , ,
[7],
, . .

.

, . . 12.1 :
1) ,
;
2) ,
()
(, ) ,


;
3) , () .


.
. , .
. 8 . 13
,

,
,
.

.
, ,
94

(. 7
) [8]. ,
.
.
, ,
, ,
, ,
, , . .

, ,
. 12
.
, , , -, , .




[9].

,
[10].
, . 3 . 13 , . .
,
.

, . , -

, , , , , .
.

:
1)
;
2)
()
()
, ,

.

,
, ,
.
, -

;
.
, .
(,
-
)
.
____________________
1.
, . 1 . 63 -

( ), ,
, // .: ..
// .
2006. 1.
2. .: .. - . .: , 1999.
. 240.
3. .: .. //
. . 2: ,
, - / . .. , .. , .. . .:
- ,
1996. . 368. , ,
,
,
( .., ..
. . .
. .:
, 2003. . 148150).
4. . 1996. 9. . 81.
5. ..
. .: , 2000. . 407.
6. .: .. // . 1997. 2. . 59.
7. .: ..
//
. 2005. 9. . 24.
8.
// .: .., .., .. ,
// . 2009. 5. . 261.
9. .:
06.07.2009 09-4572/09-6
60-2269/2009-9; 06.07.2009 094596/09-6 60-2304/2009-9.
10. .: .., .., .. , // .
2009. 5. . 262263.

95

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 94100.


.. , 2010

347.6

:
REGISTRATION OF MARRIAGES IN RUSSIA: RANGE OF PROBLEMS
..
N.A. TEMNIKOVA
,
, .
In this article the author considers the problems of marriage registration and proposes its solution.
: , , .
Key words: registration of marriage, marriage age, marriage registration procedure.


, , 1918 . ,
18.12.1917
[1] ,
,
.
, 1871 . [2].
90

.

, . , (1)
, 18- ;
(2) .
(1)
.
,
,

. ,
,
. , 96

, .

(
,
).

[3].
18 1917 . , [4] , 18 ,
16 . , 16 , 13 .

, ,
[5], ,
.
. . 77
, , . ,
-

, .
,
[6]
18 .

.
. 5
, ,
[7].
, 1944 .
, , ,
,
(. 3).
,
, . 15
[8].
, ,
.
,

(. 13 ). (, )
,
, ,
,
,
.
, , . , ,
.
,
(. 148 )
[9]. ,
. -


(1303 , . 12
) [10].
, ,

(, . 23
[11]) (. 10
,
. 18 [12]).
, , , , .

-, -
.
.. ,
, -
,
[13].

, , . ,
, .

,
.
,
- , ,
. .
-
. , (
,
)
97

..

. , .
: . .. :
,
[14].
,
, (
) (,
,
)

. , , , ,
.
, , , , - ,

.
(2)

() [15].
, .. [16], , , - ,
.
,
,
, .
,
,
.. , [17],
-
,

98

,
.

,
[18].
,
, : (1)
; (2)
; (3) .
: 1) ; 2) , ;
3)
,
(. 26 ); 4) [19].
[20],
, ,
.
,

.

, ( ,
)
.
.. ,

,
( ) , [21].

.
,

. ,
-
,
.
,
.
, .
,
.
.
, , ,
? ,
, , ,
,
.
. 3 . 28 , ()

, . .
, .
.
, , ,
, ,
de lege ferenda .
,
,
, ,

.
(. 26)
, -

,
,
(, , , , ,
).
.
. 3 . 160
, ,
,
( ), .
,
, .
, ,
. ,
.
, . de jure , de facto
.

, ,
,

.

, , ,
(. 31.07.2000 16) , ,

99

..


. .
- , ,

(. 4 . 28 ). ,

.

. , , ,
.
____________________
1. . 1917. 11. . 160.
2. .. . .,
2003. . 44.
3. .
4. . 1917. 11. . 160.
5. . 1918. 7677. . 818.
6. . 1926. 82. . 612.
7. .: .. . .; .,
1949. . 31.
8. . 1969. 32.
. 1397.
9. : .. . ., 2008. . 84.
10. / . .
. . ., 2006. . 335.
11. :
2947-III 10.01.2002 . //
. 2002. 7.
12. 17.12.98 321-I. , 2009.
. 6; 09.07.99
278- . URL:
http://www.levonevski.net/pravo/norm2009/num
37/d37089/page5.html

100

13. .. .
. 23.
14. ..

//
. 2009. 12. . 23.
15. ., .: .. . ., 2010. . 123.
16. .: .. - //
. 19251989: . . ., 2001. . 162164.
17. .: .. / .., .., .., ..
, 2002. . 139.
18. : .
15 1997 . 143- // . 1997. 47. . 5340; 2001. 44.
. 4149; 2002. 18. . 1724; 2003.
17. . 1553; 28. . 2889; 50.
. 4855; 2004. 35. . 3607; 2005.
1 (. 1). . 25; 2008. 30 (. 2).
. 3616; 2009. 52 (. 1). . 6441.
19.
. 11 .
20. ,
, , , .
,

(,
, ,
). .: . 3031
(URL: http://meget.kiev.ua/).
21. .: ..
, . .,
2008. . 71.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 101106.


.. , 2010

347.9


ON THE PRINCIPLE OF JUDICIAL ACT SEQUENCE CHECK
..
V.B. NEMTSEVA

.
The author argues about possible conflict between courts of second and subsequent instance.
: , , , .
Key words: period of appeal, appeal, cassation, supervising.

,

, , [1]. () [2]
, , ,
, , , . .


, [3]. , ,
res judicata [4].
: 1) ,
, -

,
, ; 2)

,

, (. 4
12 2007 17

) [5];
3) ;
4) ,
, ,
, (. 304 ).
, , . ,
,

, 101

..

.
-,
, . ,


.

.

, , , .
-,

. ,
(. 2 . 117 ). ,

(. 259, 276, 292, 312 ).
-, . , . 3 . 292


.

20.12.2007 .
14569/07, ,
28.04.1995 1-


.

,
. , , .
102

-, ,
.

, . , .
-,

, , .
, , .
, , , .
, ,
,
[6].

,

,
, .
,
,
,
,
[7].
-,
,
. , . 6 . 299
,
, .

.
.
12
( ,
).

, (. .
) ( ),
,
.
, ,

(1)
(2)
(3)

; , ; . :
,
. ,
,

, , 7.
.
,
5, 6, 7, 8, 11 .
. 17
12.03.2007 . 17
,
,
,


() , ,

(4)
(5)
(6)

(7)
(8)

(10)
(11)
(12)

(9)

,

. 1 . 1 . 143
() .
,
() ,
,
(), ()
. 1 . 1 . 143
, .
24.09.1999 . 13
,
, .
103

..

,
.


.
,
(5, 6, 8, 11) , () . ,
, .
, ,
,
. , ,

,

.
. , .
(. 275 ).
(
), (7) ,
,
. . 2
13 24.09.1999 . , ,
,

104

, . . 1 . 1 . 281 .

. , .
,

14.02.2008 . -40/7-08 :
(16.01.2008 .)

( 11.01.2008 .), . ,

273 290
.
. 3
24.09.1999 . 13


, , . ,

. 1 . 85
1995 ., . 1
. 150 . ,
. 3 . 151 ,
,
,
,
,

.
,
, . 3 -

,
. 2 ,
,
,
. , , .
,

,
,
(9) (3),
(. 08.05.2008 . 5591/08,
20.12.2007 . 14569/07, 27 2007 .
8545/07 .). ,

, . . 148

.
, , ,
?
,

: 1)
; 2)

; 3)

.
,
(
) ,

,

.
,

, .
,
.
.
, ,

. , , , () (
)
.
()
, .

, ,
.

.
___________________
1.
,
.

.
2. , . ., .: .. . ., 2006.
3. ., .: .. . .; ..
. ., 2007.
4. ., .:

24.07.2003 . 52854/99; 16.05.2007 . 6- .
5. ,

105

..

6.

106

. .: ..
: . . - . . , 2008. :
14.02.2008 . 14 .
.:
17.11.2005 . 11-,

7.

16.01.2007 .
233--, 234--.
.,
: .. :
. .:
, 2006.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 107110.


.. , 2010

347.918(075.8)



SUBMITTAL TARGET OF CASSATIONAL APPEALS
FOR THE ARBITRATION COURT DETERMINATION
..
E.V. PERMINOVA
,
.
This article contains the information of problem moments connected with calculation of terms on
submission of cassational complaints on decision.
: , , ,
, .
Key words: terms of appeal, the cassation appeal, the court's decision, the procedural deadlines, time limits.



.

.
, .
, .



(. 1
. 272, . 3 . 188 ),
.
. 3 . 188

, , .
,
. 3 . 188 , ,

. 290


, . 35
.
,
. 276 ,
,

, .
.
.
. . 188 ,

.

, , .. [1], .. [2], .. [3],
.. [4], . [5].


.
,
-
107

..

24.04.2008 33-2784/07-021316/08 , ,
, . 276 ,
. 188 [6].
.


,

.
. 15 13 24.09.1999 (
13), , . [7].
, , .. [8], .. [9].
, ..

, ,
[10].
,
, , ,
[11].

. ,
- 14.08.2006
21-6169/04-2
108

[12].
.


( ).

.

. 188, 272, 275, 276 290 .
. 3 . 188

. 290 , . 290

,
[13].
. ,
.
, 09-3139/03-


,
.
290
,
, ,
,


.
3 188
, , .
1 276
.


,

. 1 180
,

,
[14].

, ,

.
. 3 . 188
(),
,
.

99 22.12.2005,


,

.

,
,
,
.

, ,
. . 3 . 188
, . ,
,
,
.

13 ,

1995 ., , 2002 . . ,
13
2002 .
,
,
.
. ,
,
,
,

[15].


. ,
.

, , ,

,
.
,
24.12.2008 16924/08 ,
. 276
, , . 188 .
07.02.2008
841/08
, ,

. 21 , . . . 3
. 188
.
109

..

, ,
.


,

.
___________________
1. : /
. .. . .: , 2005.
2. : /
. .. . , 2007.
3. () .. , . (
, 2003) //
.
4. ..

// . 2003. 12.
5. .
// -. 2002.
18.
6. . : -

110

7.
8.

9.
10.
11.
12.
13.

14.
15.

20.11.2008 04-2348/2008(1782846-11);
04.09.2008 -41/7591-08-;
26.11.2008
64-6331/07-8;

07.04.2008 09-1706/08-6.
., .: / .
.. , .. . ., 2003.
..
// . 2007. 2.
.. // ().
2008. 4, 5, 6.
.. . . . 163.
.
. : -
14.06.2006 05-17208/2005-2.
.
// .
. 2006. 3.
2006 .

10.10.2003
09-3139/ 03-.
.
// . 2006. 1.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 111115.


.. , 2010

36

102

THE CONVENTION INTERNATIONAL LABOR ASSOCIATION 102
ON THE MINIMAL SOCIAL SERVICE STANDARDS
AS A SOURCE OF THE LAW OF SOCIAL SECURITY
..
G.S. LAPTEV
,
.
This article describes the order of acceptance of conventions of International Labour Organization, and
also the problem of ratification this conventions with the account of Russian legislation.
: , 102, ,
, .
Key words: International Labor Organization, ILO convention number 102, social security, ratification,
unemployment.




. -, ,
. -, () [1].




.

,
. , .. , ,


, ,
[2].
, . 102 (
102),
28 1952 . [3].
- , :
, , , ,
, , ,
. , 111

..

102, , ,
,
, .
102 , ,
,
.
102 ,
. , ,
, , ,
-
.

.
102,
, ,
.

,
. ,
, ,
, ,

,
,
.
[4], 50
102

112

, ,

. , :
102 40
-, , ,

;

,
, 102;

, , ,
102;
102 ,
,

;

, , , 102.
102 , :
.

.
, ,
.

,
-; , ,
-.

102

102 18 1961 .,
,
1996 ., ,
,
, 102

.
1964 . ,

, , 102 .
, 102

45 % ( ), , 45 % ,
(
).
.


. 102
,
,
,
, . ,
,
.

102 40 %.


.
.

(,
1969 . 60 % ).
, ,
102 ,

,

.
102
(,
102

[5]).
.


:


. ( 1, 2, 4
. 19), ,
. , , , ,
, , ,
, . ,
,
113

..

, () , (),
.
(. .
)
, 12 - .
.. , , , ( )

. (
- ,
)
,
.
,

,
,
,

[6].

.. , , . 4 . 15



. ,
[7].
.. , ,
. , , ,
, , [8].

(,
.. ) [9] , 114

.
, , . .
, , , , .

, ,
.
,
,
,
.
,
, .
. 19 ,
. ,


(, ), ,
.

, , , , , ,

, , .
,

, ,
[10].
,

102

, , . . .

.
.. ,
.
,
[11].
, , 102
,
, , , , ,
, ,
,
,

102
.

,
,
102,
( -

)

, .
___________________
1. ..
// .
1997. 3. . 94.
2. ..
. // . 1994. 8
9. . 67.
3. , . 19191956.
. I. : ,
1991.
4.
. : , 2003. . 21.
5. ..
// . 2005. 1.
. 513.
6. ..
( ): . -
. . ., 1977. . 72.
7. .. . . . 95.
8. .. . . . 73.
9. .. : . . ., 1998. . 208.
10. ..

: . . . .
:
, 1999. . 10.
11. .. :

// . 1997. 7. . 17.

115

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 116118.


.. , 2010

340.132



THE PROBLEMS OF LAW ENFORCEMENT BY THE REALIZATION OF RIGHTS
AND LIBERTY OF MILITARY SERVICE FOR A REGULAR TERM
..
N.A. MASLOV
(
, , ), .
The role of law enforcement in implementation of the main rights and freedoms of a human and a citizen
(the rights to life, the rights to health, honour and dignity) and other rights in condition of statutory service.
: , , , , .
Key words: military soldiers, duties, rights, law enforcement, service.


, .
,

[1]. .
. .

. ,
.

.
.
. .
,

[2].
. 116

.
,


.
. - ,

.
,
.

( , ,
). [3]. , 20022003 . , , 9 673 12 739 , 676 826, 2 379 2 803,
3 204 4 607,
2 228 3 904, 44 63 [4]. ,


. , 8090 % [5].
.
,
.
.

, , , .
.
, ,
,
. (, ), , .
. . 2. . 16 27 1998 .
76- 11.06.2008 .
86- , ,
, ,
, - , ,
.

14
1993 . 2140 ( 10.11.2007 . 1495), ,
,

. , .

-


(. 347). ,
,
,
,
.
[6].
,
,
, ,
. , ,
,
.
, .
.
. ,
, ,
,
.
[7].
.


,
[8].
.
-,
,
. -,
,
, , , . ,

117

..

, . .

.
, (, ), , ,
. . 240

,
. , , - .
,
, , . . ,
.
,

118

? ,

, - ,
.
___________________
1. .. . .,
2007. . 395.
2. ,
.
.

(1874 .), .
1917 .
3. ..
: - : . . . .
., 2002. . 58.
4. .. XX . ,
. .,
2005. . 768.
5. ..
: - : . . . .
., 2002. . 58.
6. .. . .,
2007. . 396.
7. .., .. . .,
2005. . 558559.
8. . . 559.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 119124.


.. , 2010

343

-
( 1917 1941 .)
STATE-RELIGIOUS RELATIONS IN THE USSR
(THE PERIOD SINCE OCTOBER 1917 TO 1941)
..
M.S. FOKIN
( )
-

.
In article on an example of various statutory acts (including departmental and party acts) are considered
development of state-religious relations during the period prior to the beginning of the Great Patriotic War from
declaration of principles of toleration, through effort of antireligious propagation, to struggle with religious
associations.
: , , .
Key words: religious relations, the criminal liability, a policy of atheism.



. 1917 . ,

.

, , . ,

-:
. , . .. .

. , ,
,
. -

. , ,
[1]. .. ,
, ,
,
.
, . . ,
,
[2].
,
,

.


119

..

23 1918 . [3],
.. .

,
,
[4],
,
.
(
, .).
1917
1918 . ,

( 1923 .).

.
, . , ,
. , .. ,
, ,
[5].
, ,
,
,
. , ,
[6].
. ,


,
120

(, )
[7].
,
(,
, ). 1918 .

, . ,
.
:
) : , , -,
, :
,
,
;
) , - , ,
;
) ,

,
,
[8].
, (, ) , -
.


[9].
, ,
. 1918 .

. [10].
VIII ,
1919 . () [11]
,

.

- ( 1917 1941 .)

.
,

-
[12].

. 13

() ( 1921 .) 13
.

. , , , ,
[13].


,
. 1918 . [14] . 13
,

1925 . [15].
1920 . XIV . 4 . ,

[16].
.
1922 . ,

. 12
1923 .,

-

, . . 7
. , 27 1924 .

. . 1924 . . ,
. , , 1925 .
, ( 1929 .,
, ).
,
, .. , .. -, .. .
. .

.
:
1931 .
5 ,
60 ( 1926 .
87 ,
1929 . 465 , 1930 . 3,5
). ,
1937 ., ,
.

: 30
16 84 % ( 25 )
, 68,5 45 % ( 30 ).
,
.


, .
121

..



1919 . [17]
. 24
1917 . 1

, [18].

,
,
,
.
1920 . ()
,
,
[19].

,
.
, ,

.. () 19 1922 .,
: [20] ,
, , ,
, , .


, .
, [21].
, .
: 122

, [22]
,

( ) [23], .
,
,

.
,
[24],
, , .
.
,
1924 . [25], . (, ,
1922 . [26]).
, , ,
.
,
,

,
.
- ,


, 8 1929 .


[27],
[28].

- ( 1917 1941 .)



, [29].
, , .
.
, ,
, .
,
.
5 1936 .
[30], , :
, .
. , , ,

.
, .

( 1935 . 1,3 ). ,

, , .
. 124 125 .
, , . ( )
1941 .

, , .
____________________
1. ., . . . 1. ., 1968.
. 414415.
2. .. . .:
, 1973. . 54.
3. // . 1918 . 18. . 263.
4. (. 3 ).
5. .. -
90-
XX (- ): . . . . ., 1999.
. 18.
6. .: :
. .: , 1999. . 33.
7. .. . . . : , 1983. . 162.
8. . :
. .: . ., 1969. . 61.
9.
,
.
10. . , . .:
, 1965. . 152.
11. .: , . . 1.
.: , 1954. . 420421.
12. . . 1920.
13. .: : . .: , 1965. . 5760.
14. 1918 //
. 1918. 51. . 582.
15. 1925 //
. 1925. 30. . 218.
16. . 1929.
4748. . 495.
17.
( , , , ),
1922 .
18. .: .
/ . .. , .. . .: , 1997. . 48.
19. .: .. . . . 20.
20.
, .
21. . 1990. 5. . 73.
22. 25 1925 .

123

..

.

,
.
,
(.: : . . 105109). ,


.
23. 19181920 . 28 ,
(.: . . . . 165).
1922 .
2 691 , 1 962 3 447 ( .. XX . ., 1995. . 106).
24. , 1922 .: . 121

124

25.

26.
27.
28.

29.
30.

; . 120

.
1924
//
19171952 . ., 1953. . 36.
1922 // . 1922. 15.
. 153.
. 1929.
35. . 353.
1 1932 .
,
-

-
( .
1932. 8. . 41).
.: ..
. ., 1985. . 123.
( ) // . 1936.
283. 6 .

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 125129.


.. , 2010

343

:
THE TECHNOLOGICAL CRIME: HISTORICAL PERSPECTIVE
..
M.S. GRINBERG

.
Formation and development of the Russian legislation on crimes in sphere of interaction of the person and
technics is traced.
: , , ,
.
Key words: technical crimes, norms about technical crimes, criminal law, punishment.


, , .
- ,
,

, ,

.


(, ... 60
[1]).
1649 .,
1864 .,
1885 . ,
,
, ,
, , , , , .


, , ,
. ,

, (

), , ,

( )
, ,
:
( ), .
:
, .
,

, , ,
. ,

().
125

..



, , - .
, .. ..
, ,
-
[2].
ab ovo ( ), , , ( 20- . )
,
, .
,
- . ,
()
. , 1923
1924 . ( , , ) , , 0,22 0,15 % [3].
10 1919 .
.
-



16 1921 . ,


. 218
1922 . ,
, 126

. 13 1929 .
, . .,
. 172 . 593
1926 .



. 9 1941 .


-.
,
,
(
, ).
. 593 1926 .
, . 86
1960 . ,

,
. , ,
.


,
. ,
11 1918 .
, , ,
. 17 1921 .

, -

. 1926 .
,
(. 752).

23 1931 . , . 173 (. 593
1926 .),
( ,

. .),

, , ,
,
,
,
()

.

. 1932 .

.
. .593


, , .
1935 . . 174 (. 593 1926 .),

. 175 (. 593 1926 .) .
1936 .
. 593

-

,
15 1950 . ,
, , .
1960 .
. 211
(
). ,
,
. 212. 30
1963 .
,

.
211
,

.
, 19 1963 .

, , ,
,
,
, ,
,
.
, ,
.85 , ( 593
1926 .) .
,
,
, , . 85 211
,
. . 127

..

, . 593, . 85
. .
, , , ,
,
.
1996 . . 263, 264, 266, 267, 268,
, , .

,
,
,
.

. 2111
. 2112 ( 19 1968 .),
,
. 2113 ( 1 1985 .),

(
3 1965 .), ( 17 1973 .),

( 10 1973 .), , , , . 223
, , ,
. 223 (
128


30 1988 .).

,
.
1922 .
. 217
, . 1926 .

,
.
1935 . . 1081
,
.
1960 .
. 214, 215 216. , , , ,
. 217
. 220.
1922 .
. 132
, , ,
, . 156
,

.
. 133
1926 . 1960 . . 140
, .

. 143 1996 .
, .

(. 252),
(. 253) -

(. 254 ),

,
, .
1996 . . 350, 351 352.
,
: 1922 .,
1926 ., ,

1960 .,
1960 .
1996 . ,
1960 . ,
. 84, 85, 86, 140, 211, 2111 , 2112, 2113, 213,
2131, 2132, 214, 215, 216, 217, 2171, 220, 2232,
2235, 252, 253 254.
, ,
, , ( ,
. .).
, ,
.
, ,
, ,
-

. ,
.
1996 . , . 1, 2 . 143, ; . 1, 2 3 . 211

; . 1, 2 3 . 263
,
; . 1, 2 3 . 264

; . 1, 2 3 . 266

; . 1, 2 3 . 267

; . 1, 2 3
. 268 , ; . 1, 2
3 . 269
, ; . 270
; . 271
.
___________________
1. II . ., 1897. . 8.
2. .: .., .. // . 1985. 3.
. 29.
3. . 19231924.
., 1925 . . 1013, 9195.

129

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 130134.


.. , 2010

343.775

26
CONCEPTIONAL QUESTIONS OF PERFECTION OF CRIMINAL CODE
OF THE RUSSIAN FEDERATION 26TH CHAPTER
..
I.V. POPOV
26 ,
.
,
.
The concept of unifications of only those deeds, mentioned in Chapter 26 of the Criminal Code of the
Russian Federation, which offend the nature the habitat of the live beings of the Earth, is grounded in the
article. The author suggested to name this chapter as Natural Environment Offences and to transfer some
components to the other Chapters of the Criminal Code.
: , , .
Key words: ecological crimes, offences, natural environment.




. , ,


.


. 26 .

() (. 256, 258, 260
). ,


(. 246, 247, 250, 251, 252, 254, . 2 . 261),

, . (.
259 ,
130

).
,
.
. 26 , - .


, .
. 26 , . .
26 .
.


.
. oikos logos ,
[1].
,
.
.

26

, , ,
[2].
, , ( ) , .
,
,
.
,
,
, ,
, .
, , , , . .,
, .
. , IX
,
,
, , , (. 359) [3]. XI ,
1825 2005 .,
R(81)12 1981 .
,
,
[4].
,

, . ,
, ,


.

. 26 . . 26
. , . 248
. ,

.


(). , .
. ,

. , .
,

.

,
, . 248
,
.

(),
. .

,
. 249
, . . 1 14 1993 .
4979-1 ,
,
131

..


,
, . 15 2000 . 99-
,
,
,
, , .
, , . 249
,
,

.
. 26 . 253
. ,
,
. , . 67
,

,
.
30 1995 . 187- ,
.
,

.
,
132


, . 17 1998 . 191-
,
.


. ,
,
,
,


.


1960 . 11 1974 .
(. 167.1 ),
,
15.04.1996 . 167.1
, . 253 ,
,
;
,
, .
. 253 ,

.
167.1

13 1996 . 30-
- . . 167.3 -

26

,

. . 167.1
, ,

,
.
, ,
.
,
.
. 253 -

. . , , , .
255

.

. 21 1992 .
2395-I ,
, , , ,
.
. 1.2
,

, , .
,
, ,
. . 7 . 23
, -

, ,
, .

. .
. 255 . .

,
. , ,
.
,
,
.
. ,
,
. 26 , -
.
70- . .. .. ,
.. -
, ,

, . ,
[5].
.
,

. , . 1
133

..


,
- . , , , , , ,
,

, .

. .. ,
environment
. , , . . [6]. . 26

.
, - ,
.
,
,
. 26 ,
. ,
, . 26
.
, -

134

. 26 , . ,
. 248
. 249
,
. 25 . 253

. 255
. 22
.
___________________
1. / . .. . 4- . .: ,
1980. . 422.
2. ..
( ). .:
, 1983. . 7.
3. A/CONF.169/16/Rev.1.

. ,
29 8 1995 . // URL: http: un.org/
Russian/conferen/docs/9crim
4. . , 1825 2005 . //
URL: http: un.org/Russian
5. .., ..
-
/ . 1979.
11. . 116.
6. .. // :
- . :
, 2005. . III.
. 6.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 135138.


.. , 2010

343.1



THE INVESTIGATION OF THE OBJECTIVE TRUTH THE PRE-TRIAL
PROCEDURE PROBLEMS FULFILLMENT MEANS OF THE INVESTIGATOR
..
N.I. REVENKO

. ,

.
The article is devoted to the study of the necessity of the objective truth establishment during pre-trial
process. The research being performed lets us make a conclusion that one can protect individuality and the
society from the consequences of a criminal act only by force of the objective truth establishment by
investigator in a particular criminal case.
: ,
, - .

Key words: objective truth, use and tasks of criminal proceedings, formal truth, criminal procedure
establishment.


, (. 2).
. , .. ,
,
, . . , [1].
,
.

,

,
, .

, ,

, , , , .

, , . , [2]. ..
,
-
,
[3].

( )
.
135

..

,
,
[4].

, [5].
,
,
[6].



[7].
-

,
. ,

()
.
- (. 2, 20,
. 2 . 26, . 71 .).



- .
, .. : () ,
, ,
,
,
[8]. ( , )
.
..
,
136

[9]. ,


. ,

[10]. . : ,
,

[11].
. , . : , ,
,
, ,

[12]. , ,
,
,
, , .
- () [13].
,
,
.
.. ,
,


18 1963 . ,

[14].
- ,
1 2002 ., -

. [15]. ,
, , ,
, (. 297 ). ,
, .
.. :
-
,
, , [16].
, ,
, : , (. 297 ) ;
; . 6
?


(. 6 ) [17],

[18].
,
, ,
, ,
,
.. :
:
,

. , -

,
[19].
..
[20].
,
. -
,
; (
, );
[21].
, , .
,
- .
. ,
, [22]. , ,
.. ,
,

.
, [23].
.. , - , , ,
,
,
137

..

,
[24].
..
, ,

[25]. ,
[26].
,
,
, (. 6 ).
, ,
.
___________________
1. .. . , 2001.
. 3.
2. .. - . , 1991. . 3.
3. .: .. - . , 2003. . 61.
4. .: .. . ,
2003. . 4.
5. ..
. ., 1968. . 1. . 132, 308.
6. .: - / . .. .
., 2001. . 161.
7. ., .: .., .. // -
. 1994. 11. . 132139; .. . . . 2433.
8. .. //
: . .-.
. ., 1996. . 17.
9. .. . . . 27.
10. .. / . . -. .
, . .. . ., 2004.
. 58.

138

11. .

1997 // . . 1997. 9. . 9.
12. . //
. . 1998. 2. . 21.
13. .:
. 1997. 2. . 78.
14. .. . . . 115.
15. .: .., .., .. - : . ,
2002. . 66.
16. .. 2001
- //
- : . . , 2003. . 6.
17.
, , , , ,
, , .
18. .: .. - //
: . . . . -
. . -. , 2004.
. 1. . 3; .. 2001 - . . 3.
19. ..
. : : .. . , 2003. . 22.
20. .. ( ): . .
-. . . , 2001. . 33.
21. .: .
22. .. ( ). . 27.
23. ..
// : . .-. ., 95- . , 2004. . I. . 6.
24. .: ..
. . ., 1971. . 135.
25. .., .., .. . . . 67.
26. .: .. . . . 170.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 139148.


.. , 2010

343

-
THE STRUCTURE OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL CONFLICTS
..
N.YU. LEBEDEV

-
.
In presented article, on the basis of the analysis various approaches to internal structure of social and
legal conflicts, the developed structure of criminally-remedial conflicts is offered and the maintenance of its
basic elements is considered.
: , , ,
, .
Key words: conflict structure, object of the conflict, the subject of the conflict, the objective party of the
conflict, the subjective party of the conflict.

, , , , [1].
,
, , , , , ,
, [2].

,
,
[3].

, . ,
,
, , ,
, ,
, .

.. , , , , , ,


[4].
. ,
: () ,
, ,
,
[5].
: 1) , (
); 2) ; 3)
( ) , ,
;
4) ( )
, ;
5) (, ), [6].
139

..

..
, ,
: ,
, , [7].
- .. ,
: 1) ; 2) () ;
3) , ;
4)
[8].
.. , :
1. , , ()
(
);
2. , , (
, );
3.

,
;
4.
, .

. , ;
5.
, [9].
.. : ,
, [10].

..
.
1. .
140

;

;
; ; ; ,
.
2.
.
3. ,
, , ,
.
4.

[11].
, , ,
. .. ,
, . . , .
, , [12].
, , .. ,
,
, : , , .
,
, . .
. , .

, . ,
, , [13].

, .. ,
- , , ,
,
.
.
, [14].

-

, .
, -
,
, .
, , .
, , . , ..
(, , , ), (
) [15]. .. ,
, ,
-

,
, - [16]. .. .
, ,
, , - ,
-
[17].
,
-
( ).
1. - :
) ;
) ;
) .
2. , ,
- :
) ( ,
.);
) (, , , .);
) (, , .).
3. -

(

):
) , (, , , , , )
, ,

;
,
, (. 2941 .);
) , 141

..

(, , , .)
, , , ,
;
,
, , . (. 4260 .).
4. - ( ):
) , ,


, ,
. ,
,
;
) , ,

,
.
5. - ( ):
) , ,
,

, . ,
, , ;
) , 142

,
, ( (. 307
), - (
(. 117, 118 ).
.
.
,
, . .
.. ,
, , , ,
.
[18].
,
,
.
, - ,
. -

, , ,
, .

- ,
,
- .
.. , .

. , , -


, . .
,
, [19].
, , :
1.
;
2. ;
3.
;
4.
;
5. ;
6.
;
7.
;
8.
;
9.
;
10.
.

.

- ,
, - , .
-
.

, , .


,
,
, [20].


,
, [21].
,
[22].
.


, ,
[23]. ,
,

.
:
, , ;
, ,
[24].
, .

.
,
143

..

,
.
,

. - , [25].

.. , ,
, . ,
. ,
- [26].
,
, -
.

-


, , ,
-
,
.

. :
1)
( ,
, ,
);
2)
, ,
( , );
3)
( );
144

4) ( , );
5) ( );
6)
- (
, , );
7)
- ( , , );
8) (, , )
- .
, . .
, - , ,
,
: , , , ,

- , , , .

,
,

- .
,

[27].

[28].
, ( ,
), (-

)
( -
) ,


[29].
-



, .
. , .
, , , , ,
[30].
-
, .

, , [31].
-
, , ,
.
-
: ,


( ).
-

- -

, .
-
.

- , . .

, . , , .
,
. , [32].

.

.
, ,
,
,
.
, , [33].


. ,
,
,
. / , ,
. ,
,
, [34].
145

..


,
. , [35].


,
, , .
-
,
, ,
.
-
, -,

,
, -, ,
, - ,
.
,
, [36].
-
, , ,

.
,

: . , , .
,
146

, .
: , , ,
,
,
.
-
-
. -
, ,
. - , .


, , ,
, ,
.
, , - , ,
, , , , .
, - :
,
.
, , , , ,

, , ,
, .
- ,
.
,
, ,
(, .)
- .
,
- , , ,
,
, .
,
, ,
,
.
___________________
1. .. - : . .
- . . ., 2007. . 32.
2. : , - / . . .. . 2- ., . . .:
-, 2005. . 65.
3.
-
2002.

URL:
http://www.myreferates.ru/referat/42099/
4. .. . URL: http://
www.ref.shopinform.ru/referat-12-418-0.html
5. .. - .
2001. URL: http://refodrom.ru/interrelation_

6.
7.

8.

9.

10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.

17.

18.

19.
20.
21.
22.

23.
24.
25.
26.

of_a_socially_psychological_climate_and_level
_of_a_conflictness_in_pedagogical_collective/s/
42991/1.1.html
.

URL:
http://www.umk.utmn.ru/?section=discipline&
mode=1&d_id= 1421&dh_id=2295
..
(- ): . -
. . .: 2006. . 69.
.. .
. ,
2007. URL: http://refmaxs.ru/15/refs.php?id
=0154
: . 2- ., . /
. . . .
. . .:
, 2000. . 2934.
.. . .: , 2003. . 119.
.. . .
.. (- ): . -
. . . , 2002. . 115.
.. . . . 117.
.. :
. . ., 2006. . 55.
.. :
. 2- ., . . / .
.. . .: , 1999. . 90.
: . 2- ., . . / . .. ,
.. . .: ,
2003. . 56.
.., ..
: . 2- . /
. . .. . .: ,
2005. . 101.
.. . // :
. / . .. . ., 1999.
. 27. . 491.
.. . . . 75.
.
. URL: http://rl-online.ru/
articles/1-04/416.html
.. . . . ., 1977. . 36.
..
: 2 . ., 1986; .., .. . ., 1982. . 83.
. . URL: http://
society.polbu.ru/krylova_pravo/ch20_i.html

Subjective part of a crime. URL:


http://www.glossary.ru
.. . . . 155.
..
// .-. . 1998. 6. . 45.

147

..

27. /
. .: .. , .. ,
.. , .. . ., 1983.
. 708.
28. .. // . /
. .. .. . ,
1987. . 143.
29. .. . . . 159.
30. ..
// . 1983. 11. . 25.
31. ..
. ., 1996. . 340.
32. . :
/ .. , .. . .,

148

33.
34.
35.

36.

1997. URL: http:// www.pravoznavec.com.ua/


books/letter/254/%CA/ 18690
.. . . . 173.
-
. URL: http://www.jourclub.ru/9/
287/1
. .
. URL: http://
society.polbu.ru/krylova_pravo/ch18_i.html;
. URL:
http://interlaw.dax.ru/student/624/L8.htm
.. :
/ . .. .. . .: -, 1998. . 352.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 149152.


.. , 2010

343

-
:
THE CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL PROCEDURE AND THE PROCEEDING:
COMPETITION OF IDEAS
..
A.V. BOYARSKAYA
, ,
- .

.
The paper is devoted to matching of grades proceedings and judicial manufacturing. The aim of the
study is the comparison of these terms and conditions and to identify the causes of their competition.
: - , , , .
Key words: criminal procedure of judicial proceedings, criminal procedure, the enforcement process,
differentiated production.

,
- .
, - ? ,
. ,
,

. , , .
( ,
, [1]), -
, ,
[2].

, .
, , - , ,
, -

.

.
,
,
. ,
, , : , - , ,
.
, , .
, .
, ,
- .
,

149

..

,
, .
? ,
. .
, .

.
[3].



, .
:
, ,
[4].
,
-
,
,


. , ,
.. .. .
, ..

-
,
- : ,
[5].
,
- 150

[6].


[7].
, [8].

- ,
..
,
. ,
..
- .
.. , , : ,

,
,
,
,
[9].
..
- , , ,
.
- ,
,
.
, - ,

(
), , ,

- :

, ,
, , ( ) - ) [10].
.. , , - , ( ),

, [11].
, .. - :
. ,
, , ,
,
.
, ..
[12], .. .
.
, - , ,
.
, , ,
?
-, , .
,

,
.
, ,
,
,
.
,
,
.
,
,
, ,
, - . .
, , -,
- ,
- .
, - .
,
-
,
.
, ,
,
[13].
, -

. .. , -
151

..

, [14].

- . ,
, , , .
,
. ,
.
.. , .
, : ,
, .
? . , , ?
.
, , .
,
, ..
[15], ( [16]
[17] )

, .
, ,
.
152

- [18]. , [19]
,
-,
- .
______________________
1. .. : 70 000
/ . .. . .: . .,
1989. . 609.
2. .. :
.
. : - . -,
1991. . 3.
3. /
. . .. . :
, 1985. . 68.
4. .. : : .
.: , 1999. . 119; .. . : -
-, 1972. . 39; ..
. .: , 1972. . 192; . . .: , 1964. . 288.
5. .. . . . 10.
6. . . 11.
7. . . 13.
8. . . 19.
9. .. . :
- . -, 1999. . 85.
10. .. : :
. .: -, 2004. . 18.
11. . . 14.
12. .. . . . 11.
13. .. . . . 18.
14. .
15. .., .. .
.: - .
, 2005. . 24.
16. . // . 1987. 12. . 18.
17. .. // . 2001. 6. . 23.
18. .., .. . . . 24.
19. .. . :
- . -, 1999. . 11.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 153156.


.. , 2010

343.1

- ,


THE PERFECTION OF CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL STATUS OF THE PERSON,
IN RESPECT OF WHICH THE PROCEDURE ACCORDING TO THE ENFORCEMENT
MEASURES OF MEDICAL CHARACTER APPLICATION
..
S.V. KIRILIN


,
.
,
- ,
- .
The article is devoted to the gaps in law concerning of legal status of a person being conducted with
proceeding of application of forced medical arrangements. The main problems of legal practice during the
administration of forced medical arrangements, possible ways of solving them in conditions of criminal
procedural law currently in force are showed by the author and also proposals about perfection of Criminal
procedural law are formulated.
: , , , , , .
Key words: compulsory, measures, medical, character, the status, deranged.

, - ,
, .
19
,

, , ,
, , , , , , , , , .
, , , .

22.11.2001 - ,
.

- .

, . 51 .
. 433
. 441


,
,
,
153

..

, . 51.
,

, II

,

( ),
. 51
, ,



.


(. 402 444)
(
. 445).
437 438
,
.
,
- ,
,


.
() -
- ,
,
, ,
154

(,

,
, ,

, , ,
.), . .
.

20.11.2007 13-
.. , .. .. [1]

.
. 402, . 433,
. 437 438,
. 439, . 441, . 444
. 445
, , ,
,

, , , ,

, .
3.1 , ,

,
,
,
, .
,
,
,
20.11.2007

, , - .

.
, , ,

, ,

. .

, ,
, ,
, ?
,
()
-
, , , , .

- - ( - ).
,

,
.



, , , ,
.

()
,

.
, .
, ,

,
. ,

,
.
, , , , ,

,
-
,

-
.
, - 155

..

,
. 21

- .

-

, ,
. 7 ,

,
, . , , , , ,
, . 437 - .
,
, -

156


.
, -,
, - , , , , ,
, ,
. ., , , . . .
_________________
1. .: . 266 28.11.2007.

20.11.2007 13-

402, 433, 437, 438, 439, 441, 444 445 -
.. , .. .. .

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 157160.


.. , 2010

343


ON THE NECESSITY OF THE PRE-TRIAL PROCEDURE REFORM
..
G.G. GUMEROV
-

.
In presented article, on the basis of the analysis operating norms of the criminally-remedial code of
Russia, basic contradictions between a legal status and the proclaimed functions of some participants of
criminal legal proceedings come to light.

, , .

Key words: procedural function, preliminary investigation, participants of criminal proceeding, criminal
prosecution, charge, the prosecution.

.
24
1991 ., .

,
. , - -
[1]. , , (, ).
,
, ,

. - .

, .
:
1) , ;
2) , ;
3) , ;
4) ,
[2].

:
1) ,
2) ,
3) .
,
, ,

, , ,
.
157

..

, , , , , ,
.

, , , . 1 . 21
, , , . .
,
,

. . 2 . 21
: , ,


,
, .
.. , , , , [3].
: , , - -, [4].

. ,
.6 . .
.

, .
, ,
, .
, . 6
158

,
, , ,
. . 6

, ,
, ,
,
.
.
, . 73 ,
, , , : ,

, , , ,
. , , , : ,

(. 2 . 15 ).
, , , , ?
,
- , ,

:
1.

;
2. ;
3. ;
4. ;
5. .
6. , ;

7. .
, , , , ,
. : ,
, ?
,
, .
,
, . 15 ,
.
,
. , , . 8 , , , , , , , .
. , , . ,
, , ,
, ,
. : . 2 . 74 .
, , : .
, .
. ,
-

, ,
.
. , ,

, ,
. : ,
, ,
.
,
, ,
,
.
: ,
, , . ?


.
,
,
.

. ,

. ,
, , .

. ,
: 159

..

, .
:

.


, ,
. ,

:
,
,
, . .

- ,
,

,
, , , -

160

. ,

, ,
,

.

:
.
__________________
1. .: .. : .
.: -
(-), 2002.
2. .: .. : / .. , .. . 2- .; . . .. .
.: , 2005.
3. . ON-LINE. URL:
http://vidahl.agava.ru/ P070.HTM#1
4. : 4 . /
. .. .: . - . . ; . - . . .,
19351940. URL: http//slovari.yandex.ru

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 161166.


.. , 2010

343.13



THE FUNCTIONAL CHARACTERISTICS OF THE INVESTIGATING
AUTHORITY CHIEF POWERS
..
T.YU. POPOVA

1965 .
In the given article one may consider the authority of the leader of the investigation agency from the
moment of it`s appearance in 1965 up to the present time; from the point of view of it`s functional direction.
: , , .
Key words: the leader of the investigation agency, mandates, functions.

2007 .
,

,
- .
,
.
,
. , .


.
, .

1965 .
(
- ) 2007 .
.

, .
,
.
,
.
,
,
. , ,
, (

) [1].

1958 .,
.

.
161

..

6
1963 .
.
, 1963 .,
6 ,
,

. , .

, , 1963 1965 .,
. ,
318 8 1963 .


: 1)

, 2)
, 3)
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
. 1271 , : 1)

2) , . , ,
,
162

.
( )
. ,


,
.

. .
,
,
, [2].
,
,


: 1) ,
(
, , ), 2) , (
,
. .) [3].

.. , :
1) 2) [4].
.. ,

[5].
[6].

,
-

, , ,
, , [7].
, ,

[8]. ..

,
:
(
,
,

, , ,
) ( , ,
) [9].



,
.
,
-

.
.. ,
, .
; , [10].


,
, ,
,

. , ,
[11].
1960 . .
,
,
. ,
: ( , ,
, ,
) , , , , , ,
;

[12].
, , ,
,
:
1) ( );
2) ( );
3) -
(
);
4) .

. ,
.
.
( ) 163

..

. ,
, - . , ,
.
.

. ( ),
( ), .
.
,
,

1960 .,
1965 .
2001 .,
1 2002 .
,
,
, , , .
,
.
: 1)
, (
, ); 2)

,
( 10
); 3) , ,

164

.

, .

, ,
.
,

,
.
,
.
-

05.06.2007 . 87
-
,
07.09.2007 .
,
.

.
, :

, ;
,
; ;
,

, , , ,
(. 13
. 39 ).

(. 2 . 221
). , , ,
.
,
, .
, ,
, ,
,
.
,

,

.
, , , ,
- ,

.
,

:
- ,

, , -

,
( ,
. .).

:
(
,
; ).



,
,
.
,
, - . , ,

, ,
.

.
.
__________________
1. .: .. : . . ... . . .
, 2003. . 11.
2. ..
: .
. ... . . . ., 1974. . 9.
3. . . 11.
4. .: ..
: . : , 1981. . 7.

165

..

5.
6.

7.

166

.: .. . . . 910.
.: ..

. .
: , 1985. . 73; ..,
.. : . : . 2001. . 76.
.: ..
//
: . . . : -
. , 1980. . 106; .. -

: , , : . : , 1998. . 47.
8. .: .. . . . 109.
9. .: .. : . . ...
. . . ., 1982. . 910.
10. .: .. .
57 000 . 9- ., . . /
. . - . , . .. . .: . , 1972.
. 633.
11. .: . . . 268.
12. .: .. . . . 29.

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 167173.


.. , 2010

343.13

XVIIIXIX .

ENFORCEMENT MEASURES OF MATERIAL CHARACTER IN THE XVIIIXIX
BEFORE THE LAWMAKING
..
N.S. KASHTANOVA
- XVIIIXIX .
, ,
.
On the basis of the analysis of the criminal-remedial legislation of the period XVIIIXIX cc. and various
positions stated in the legal literature, the author considers(examines) measures of compulsion of property
character.
: - XVIIIXIX .,
, , .
Key words: criminally-remedial legislation XVIIIXIX centuries, property measures of compulsion, the
guarantee, monetary collecting.

. ,

,
.
.
,
1497 . 1550 ., 1649 .
[1], , , .
I 21
1697 . , , , , ,


, , [2]. 1697 .
:
.
-


1716 . , , ,
[3]. , 1697 .
16 , 1699 . 24 , 1700 . 19
: ,
, ; [4] ( . ..).
, , , ,
. ,
17 1697 . ,
,
, .
, , . ,

167

..

,
,
. ,
,
, , .
,
,
. : -, , ,
, ,
, I, , ; -, ,
, . X,
7594,
.
, , .
: 1699
1700 . [5].
, .
,
I 5 1723 . ,
. ,
: (
) , [6], . .
,

. ,
,
, , , .

.
[7]. , 168

1723 .,
,
: , ,
. , , ,
; ,
.

,
. ,
,
,
, ,
, ( 4344
. 5).
, ,
(. 8). , ,
, , [8].
, . :
, -, , ,
,
,

,
1723 . 5 [9].
I
1697 1700 .
,
,
5 1723 .
.
,
. ,
, ,
XVIII XIX . , , ,
.
, - ,

XVIIIXIX .

,
. , XIX .
.
3 1734 . ,
, ,
.
1737 .
421 ., . .
1767 . , ,
,
, ,
, ,
,
,
.
1724 .

[10].
1768 . . ,
I. .
, , 30 1767 ., ,
.

,
[11].
, II ( ) [12], , , ,
,

, -

, . , ,
,

.
1772 . ,
. ,
,
, , , , .
26 :
, , , , ,
, ;
[13].
7 1775 . -
[14]. , . 401 , . : ,
,
, .
,
, , , .
, ,
, ,

,
, .

, 25 ,

300 . 100 . . , ,
, ,
,
169

..

, .
,
.
, ,
, .

,
,
,
, ; , , .
, ,
. , Corpus habeas [15] . 401 , ,
.
,
,

,
,
, . , . 401
, .
29 1818 .


, , . ,
,
, , , , , , 100 .,
,
, , ,
- .
,
,
170

,
, ,
- ,
,
, .
,
, , .
XVIII .
I , , .
, -
: , ,

. .
I
,
[16].
,
, . , ,
, , , 1728 . 19 ,

, ,
, : ,
,
[17].

XVIIIXIX .


,
, ,
, , ,
,
,

. , 1727 . I,
,
,
( 5059) [18].

-
.. .
, . ,

:

, ; ,
,

.
,

; ,
. , , ,
,
, ,
.

,
[19] ( . ..).
,
, (.
1867 . . .
. . I; .
1868 . 4-). ,
XVIII
XIX . -

, , ,

XIX ,
85 621 .;
, , ,
1826 . 127 000 ; 1823 . 1 589 ,

5 019 , ,


;
, ; ,
,


. 1826 . , , , [20].
,
,
,
.
,

, :
)
; )
,
; )
; )
( . ..).
, , 1719 . 3 ,
- ,
,
, ,
: , , ,
, 171

..

;
5 .
[21] ( . ..).
, XVIII XIX .
.
,
.
26 1726 . , ,
( 4970).
17 1727 .
,
.
:
1731 . 5 , 5709; 1736 . 11 , 1
12 , 7095, 7114 7127; 1756 .
10 , 10538; 1761 . 2 ,
11319, 1764 . 3 , ,
( 12178) [22].
, .
, , XVIIIXIX .
: , .
- .
___________________
1. .
.
., 1868. . 66.
2. .: XXX .:
9 . / . . - . , .
.. .
. . 4. .: , 1986. . 395.
3. .: : . .: , 1995.
. 18.

172

4.
5.
6.

7.

8.
9.
10.

11.
12.

13.
14.

15.

16.

.: .
. ., 1868. . 67.
. . 68.
XXX .: 9 .
/ . . - . , .
.. .
. . 4. .: , 1986. . 395;
.: ..
. ., 1868. . 69.
.: XXX .:
9 . / . . - . , .
.. .
. . 4. .: , 1986. . 395.
.. . ., 1868. . 69.
. . 70.
- .. - . , . ., 1957. . 714.
.: . . 714.
.: .. / . .
.. . .: - , 1956. . 3233; .: - .. .
, . ., 1957. . 720.
.. . ., 1868. . 73.
.: XXX .:
9 . / . . - . , .
.. .
. . 5. .: , 1987. . 169.
.: .. / . . .. ;
. .-.
. .. . .: , 1947. . 5, 63;
.: .. . ., 1989. . 130, 173.
.: - ..
- .
,
. ., 1957. . 714.

XVIIIXIX .

17. .. . ., 1868. . 8081.


18. . . 81; ( ) .: ..
. ., 1868. . 82.
19. .: - ..
- .

,
. ., 1957. . 728729.
20. .. . ., 1868. . 8485.
21. . . 91.
22. . . 95.

173

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 174175.

,
, , ,


The interview with the Omsk regional office chairman,
the honored artist of the Russian Federation, the doctor of juridical science,
professor, Omsk State University holder of chair of criminal process
and criminal science VLADIMIR A. ASAROV

. ?
.
. -, ,
, , .

,
.
?
, ,

.
6 , , , , .
.
?
?
, . , , ( , . .),
.
. 1982 .
. () . ,
, . , .
174

?
. ,
, , , , , . -,
.
. - ,
, .

?
.
. ( ) .
, , . ,
, . ,
, , , , ,
, , ,
. .. .
. . ,
, , ,
, , ,
, . , ,
,

.
? ?
(
). ,
( -, ), ( , ), ,
.

..

175

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 176187.


.. , 2010

..
2- ., ., . .: , 2007. 448 .
( )
THE REVIEW ON THE TEXTBOOK OF L.A. MOROZOVA THE THEORY OF STATE
AND LAW. 2. ISSUANCE. M.: EKMO, 2007. 448 P.
..
V.V. KOZHEVNIKOV

,
.. .
, ,
,
I
, , , .
, . ,
: 4 . 2 ; . 4
, , 4 . 7 ,

, . 9 , . 21 ; . 30
.
, ,


176

,

(. 10).
, ,


(. 9), ,
, , . , ,
:

. . 77, 423,

.. .. ., 1997, , ,
( . ..).
, ,

(. 442447).
. , ,
, .. ,

..

.. , .. .,
.. ,
.
,
, , : (. 12),
.. (. 22) , (. 24)
. . . .
.
.
.. , . . 12


(.. , .. , .. )
,

(. 12).
-, , ,
, - (. 11).
, , - . .
, , .. ,
, .
.. , ,

, ,

.. (. 13).
5 . 1 , ,
, . , , , , . ,

.. ,

, , ( . ..) , (
)
(. 22).
-, , , .
- (. 26). ,
,
,
: , -, ,
, .,
- , () .
: - () , ,
- , - ,
(., : - .., ..,
..
., 2003. . 3132). , - .
, , - ,
..
(. 25).
-, ,

.
:

,
(. 24). . 2 .
, , -,

( ) . , , 177

..

(, ) (. 29). ,
, .
,
(., 1974) , -
, (. 192).
,
,
,
.

(. 74).
,

.
, , ,
, , .,
(. 51).
,
, , ,
(. 5155). :
, ,
- ?
, ,
(. 64),
(. 65). ,


. , . , .
.). , :
. ,
(. 75); 178

(. 77).
,
,
,
,
,

-
, : , ,
, -,
, . .. , , , , , : , , ,
.
,
, ,
,
( ..
// /
. .. .. .,
2007. . 615).
, , , . ,
, 6 ,
. ,
,
, ()

(. 101). ,
,
, ,
, -

..

. , ,
, (), (), () -
(. 118). .
,
,
,
,
. , , .. ,
() (. 106).
,
: (. 106). ,
.
, .. :
.
, , , ,
, .
,
, , . .

( :
/ .
.. . ., 1997. . 284). ,
,
( . ..) , . .
, (. 123). ,
. .
, -

, , ( ), (,
, .). ,
, ,

, ()

,
(. 185).
, -
,
( .
..), , (. 181).
. 12

: 1) ; 2)
, , (. 199),
; 3) , ..
, ,
, , , (. 200
202), , , .; 4) ,
,
, (. 203). , . 205
,
,
,
, , , ; 5)
,
(. 203). -,
,
179

..

, ; 6) , ,
,
,
(. 204). ,
.

, ,
, ,
() , .

.
. (- ..,
.., .. . .
. 132). ,
, ,
; 7) . 204 , ,

, . , .
, ,
, . .
, ,
(. 224). ,
, (. 225). , ,
, . , , (, ) - , , ,
180

, -, -,
- .
,

, - (. 226).

- ( ). .
: -, - .
-, ,
-
. ,
.
,
, . 107 :

(. 228). , - ,
.
-,
.
,
, ,
(. 256, 263). 3 14
. ,
, ,
(. 229).


. ,
, , ,
(. 232233). . 15
, ,
, -,
( ); , -

..

, , , , , -,
,

-
(. 240),
,
;
, , , . , , , (. 272); -,

,
,

, , . (. 242),
. 243 ,

.
(. 262).
,
, , ,
, , (. 248), , ,
,
, , ,
(. 281). ,
(. 252253)
-
.
,
,
,
, . . ,

,
-
, ,
(. 260).
. 17
-

:
1) , . : -, - , ,
, ,
(. 266).
, ,
(),
.
. ,
: -, - ,

( . ., 1988. . 3948); 2)
. 267 ,

,
: ; ; . ,
.. , , ,
,
, . . ( .. // :
/ . .. . . , 1993.
. 56); 3) , () ,
.
,
,
(. 268); 4)

(. 273) ,
, (. 274).
5 . 14
: 1) , (
181

..

. ..)
(. 293294); 2)
,
(. 294). ,
, ,
.
( )
. , ( ).
,

.
, (.: - .., ..,
.. . . . 302).
, . 19 , .
, , .
.. ,
, , ,
- .

, , , (. 296).
,
,
, .
, , .
. 228 , , . .
. ,
. , , 182

,


(- .., ., .. . . . 364). ,
, . 49 . ,
.. ,
, ()
(. 299).
.
, , . 2
. 21 . 27
. , . ,
. 30
,
. 26

. 28 .
, .
,
, .
, , , (. 303). , ,
,
,
.

.

(. 305), ,
(, ,
). ,
,
, -

..

, ,

(. 305).
,
: 1)
(. 301) ,
,
: 2)
,
, . .
,
( ,
,
. .) (. 296).
. 20 ,
: 1) , , , , , :
- (. 312);
2) , , , , ,
(. 313),
(, ); 3)
- (. 315)
, ,
; 3)
, ,

(. 320), (. 312).
. 22 , , , ,
, -,
, ;
3) ,
. , ,

(. 330). , ,
.
,

, ,
, ; 3) : :
.
. , ,
(. 330). ,
, , , , -, , -
(. 331333) . , ,

.
. 24
, ,
: 1)



.. , .. , .. , .. , .. (. 348
349), - .. , , ,



.
, ,
, ,
. , ,
183

..

:
,
, (. : ..
: . ., 2002.
. 161168); 2)
(. 351); 3) . 353 : ) ; ) ; ) ( . ..); )
; ) .
: , (. 353).
,
, ,
, ,

; 4) ,
,
,

(. 354). ,

.
,

,
. ,
,
,
.
-
, . , ,

. ,
184

( ), , , , ,
,
,
, , , (.: - .., .., .. .
. . 102).
. 25 , : 1) , . 357 .. , .. ,

, ,
, ,
(. 357). ,
, , , , , .

. , , : ) ,
, ;
) ,
,
;
) ,
. ,
(,
, ).
,

. ,
, ( . ..) -

..

(. 233), ; 2) , , ,

,
(
. ..), ,
(. 359360), , , , ,
,
.
. 26 ,
, , . , , .
(. 361). ,
, , , ,
. 1 . 14 , .

,
(.: . 1 . 2.1 ); 2) ,
,
(. 361). ,
. ,
, , , (. 362).
,
-

.
,

(. 361). ,

(.
363), , .
, . 364 (,
, ),
. 3 : .
.. .. , - , , (. 369). ,
, :
(. 301).

, ..
,
,
.
,
(. 370). ,
. , , ,
, ,


().

(. 370). ,
, 185

..

, , .
, : 1) ;
2) ; 3)
.

. ,
() , . , . ,
,
, , .
, ,
, ()

(. 372).
, ,
.
,
( )

(,
,
, ).
,
186

(,

, . .
).
,
,

(, , ).
, ,
, . , , (, , ). ,
. , .
,
,
(.: .. ..
: . ., 2005. . 419).
, ,
,
.. - ,
,

(. 388). , ,
(. 382).
. 27


: 1) . 384



- ,

..

,
. .. , , ,
, , ,
(, , , , ,
) ( .. //
: /
. .. , .. . .,
2005. . 425); 2) ,
, - , ,
, (. 386). ,
,

, ,
, ,
; ,
,

; ,
,
(.: .. .
. . 426). ,

(. 385); 3)
(

),
, , , , , (. 338). , , ,
(, , , , ) , . , ,
: 1) . 10
(. 171) ; 2)

-
..
, 89 (. 85); 3) ,
. 32
. , 2 (. 428438).
,

: .. ,


, .

187

. . 2010. 1 (22). . 188189.


.. , .. , 2010

..
- .
: -
. . , 2009. 240 .
THE REVIEW ON THE MONOGRAPHY OF O.Z. CHELOKHSAYEVA MODERN
CRIMINAL PROCEDURAL POLICY OF STATE. VLADIKAVKAZ: PUBLISHING
OFFICE OF V. GASSIYEV, 2009. 240 P.
.. , ..
V.A. ASAROV, I.YU. TARICHKO


,
,

.
,

, .
, ,
. 1961 . - , 90- ., ,
. , -

.

.
-
.
188

- ,
.
. I
.. ,
, -
.
, -
,
, .
.. : -


(, ) , - .
, -

.. -

, .
, .. , . - .
, , (. 6)
(. 56, 63). ,
() ,
. ,
,
(. 240), (. 241), (.
242) (. 244) (. 56, 57,
115130). , ,
, , .

. - . , , , , - ,
, ,
.
, , , ,

, ,

,
(.: ..
//
. , 1995. . 23).

,
.

.. . 15 . 2: ,


.


, .
-
. () ,

.
, , , , , ..
..

: , ,
, , 2003 .

189

, . , ,
. .. .
(. 8 (3812) 64-61-77, lena-rozkova@yandex.ru)

. .. ; . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-61-77)
. . ,
. (. 8 (3812) 75-01-80)
-
, .
(. 8 (3452) 33-25-31)
, . , . .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-62-05)
. . ,
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)
-
-
. (. 8 (383) 21-01-357)

- . (. 8 (351) 267-99-00)
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-61-77)
. . (. 8 (3812) 36-06-90)

. .. ;
. (. 8 (3812) 25-32-71, 22-59-54)

. (. 8 (383) 223-57-60)
. ,
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-26-87)
. .. ; . (. 8 (3812) 53-02-21)
. . , , -
-
. (. 8 (383) 21-01-357)
190


. .. . (. 8 (3812) 22-59-54)
- - . (. 8 (3952) 39-49-89, 38-89-92, 41-09-82)
,
, . . , ,
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-11-56)

. .. ; - . (. 8 (3452) 79-95-35, 64-11-56)
. . ,
. (. 8 (3812) 75-05-60)
. (. 8 (3812) 75-05-60)
. . ,
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-61-77)
V
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 22-59-54)
. . ,
- . (. 8 (351) 263-58-82, 267-94-52)
. . , . .. . (. 8 (3812) 64-61-77, tarik69@mail.ru)
. . ,
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)

. .. ; . .. .
(. 8 (3812) 22-59-54, 22-98-21)
. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)
, . . , , . .. .
(. 8 (3812) 64-62-05)
- -
. (. 8 (3812) 75-05-60)

. .. . (. 8 (3812) 63-21-20)

191


4 200 .
.
( 3,5, CD) : 644077, -77, . , 55, , , , , . ..
e-mail: vestnik@omsu.omskreg.ru, kmarina84@mail.ru. . 8 (3812) 63-21-20.
:
1 ..,
0,8 ..
. , . . ( www.omlaw.ru).
, ,
. .


.
, , .
.
, .
: MS WORD 1,5 , 12 ,
Times New Roman, 2 .
. ( , ).
... . ...
. ( 24
, 11 ), .
(, [1]) . .
. : , , , ;
, ( ), ,
e-mail.
, , .
. .. , . .
1
.
!

192



:
9
9
9
9
9

;
(2 , 1 );
;
, e-mail: karpova@univer.omsk.su;
, , e-mail: karpova@univer.omsk.su
.
.

.., .., .. ,
: . : - , 2006. 560 .
().
,
. , , .

,

. .
, ,
, .

.., .. : . : - . .
-, 2008. 160 . ().
,
-
,
. ,
, .
, .

193

.. : . : -
. . -, 2009. 383 . ().

. , .
, ,
, , . , , , .
, ,
, ,
.

.. : / . . .. . :
- . . -, 2008. 288 . ().
, ,

(, . .). , , , . . , , , .

.
,
, ,
.

.. : . :
- . . -, 2009. 336 . ().
, , ,
. ,
.
.
. 30 2008 .
194

.. ( . .
): /
. .. . : - , 2005. 548 . ().
, - , .
,
. , , , , .
, ,
.
, , , , , , , ,
.

.. (- ): / . .. . : - . .
-, 2007. 552 . (. . -) ().
, , - . ,
,
. ,
. , , , , .
, ,
.
, , , , .

.. :
/ . . .. . : - .
. -, 2008. 568 . ().
, , . , ; ; , , , , , .
, , .
, , ,
.

195

.. : : 2 . . I. : - . . -, 2008. 276 . ().


. ,
. ,
.
. .

,
021100 .
, , ,
, , , , ; , .

..
: . : - , 2006. 247 .
().

. , , , . .

, ,
. ,
.
- , ,
.

.. : .
: - . . -, 2008. 232 . ().
. ,
-
.
,
.
, , , , ,
, .

196

.. : :
. : - . . -, 2009. 276 . ().

. , .
, .
.
-, , , .

..
: . : - . .
-, 2008. 220 . ().
. ,
.
,
, , ,
.
1 2008 .

, , : http://www.omsu.ru
.
:

644077, . -77, . , 55
: (3812) 67-32-55, 64-30-61
./: (3812) 64-13-07
e-mail: karpova@univer.omsu.ru

197

1 (22)

2010


77-21985 21 2005 .

..
..

23.03.2010. 6084/8.
. . 24,8. . . . 23,1. .-. . 20,6. 150 . 101.

644077, -77, . , 55