Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 200

-

-
C. .
- : ...................................... 3
. .
- - ,
- .......................................................................... 10
. ., . .

.............................................................................................................. 12
. .

........... 15
. .

- - .................... 18
. .
()
- ................................................................................ 21
. ., . .
...................................................... 23
. ., . ., . .
- ....................................... 27
. .
-
- ............................................................................................. 33
. .
- - ,
........................................................................................................................ 35



. .

, ................................................................................. 41
. ., . .
............................................................. 46
. .
......... 50
. .
:
...................................................................................................................... 56
. .
............................ 59
. .
...................................................... 64
. .
....................... 66
. .
, ............................ 68
. .
() ......... 72
. .
..................................................... 78
. .

.................................................................................................. 81

. .
- .................................................................. 84
. .
...................................... 88
. .
: ........................................................ 92
. .
- , .............................................................. 97
. .
........................................................................................... 101
. .
....................................................................... 105
. .
,
- ............................................................................................ 109
. .
, ................................................... 115
. .
(-) ................................................................................................. 118
. .
............................................................. 125
. .
............................................ 128
. ., . .
......................... 134
. .
e : - ............................ 139
. .

......................................................................................................................................... 143
. .
......................................................... 148
. .
............................................... 152
. .
,
.......................................................................................................................................... 155
. .
: ................................................................................. 158


. .
(19411945 .) ...................... 164
. .
19201935 . ........... 169
. .
: 2009 . ...................................................... 173


. .
-
............................................................................................................... 179
. .

............................................................................................... 187
, , .. 190
,
........................................................................................ 199
=2=

3(12)

-


-

C. . ,

,

- :

. - , .
,

. , , .


, . - .
, , ,
,
.

. ,
80 , - 40, 5.
,
, ,
, 2009

.
, , , , .


. ,


. , .
1550 .,
IV ,
, .
1649 .
, .
, XV XVII ., ,

. -,

, . -,
: . -,
.
, - ,
=3=

,

- .

.
XVII
XVIII ., . . .
,


.
,
.
, XVIII . ,
, .
II , . - ,
. , .
,
. , . , ,
, ,
,
.
.
, .

.
1778 .
II , =4=

. .
,
; ,
, , . -
,
XIX . .
, , ,
, ,
.
XIX . 1819 . I
-
(: ), 1917 .
, . ,

. ,
,
, , ,
.
,
.

-
.

,

3(12)

.


. ,
, , ,
.
, . .

.
- . 1832 .
(: )
.
, .

.
,
.

- XIX . .


. 1860- . .
,

,
,
, 2009


,


(. : . . ,
. ., 1999. . 67).
1879 .

,

.
. , .

,

.
- . 1887 .
,
, , . .
. , . , .
-

(1895 .).


,

.
, ,
- . , 1909 .
. =5=

.
- ,



-. -
1915 .
,

. ,
, ,
, ,
.
.
, XVIII .
XX .
-
- -, . . .
1917 .
.
, . ,
, .

. ,
, .
( ).
,

=6=

. . ,
- , .
1917 . , . . ,
. .

, .


.

,
. . , , .
,
, ,
.
, 19181920 .
, .

.

. 1924 .
- ,
.
,

3(12)

. ,
-
,
,
.
-
, .

. 1922 .
, , - .
1920- . .
.
- .
,
.
1930- .
. ,
.
,

. 1941 . 2 .,
1950- . 2,4 .
,
,

.


. ,
, 2009


.
,
, -, ,
-,
.

. . .

- . 1950- . - , ,
. 1958 .

, -
. , , .

- .
, 1961 .,
,
,

, , . ,
, ,
, , , .
,
,
=7=


. ,
-
1961 ., -
1969 . - , 19701971 .
, 8- , .
- , .
.
, , ,
, .

.
-
.
1963 . -, , . 1960- . .


.
,
19601980- . .
, ,
. , - , ,
.
=8=


1990- .
. -
,
.
, , , .
, -
- . - ,
,
. .
.
-,

,
, . -,

-;
. -,
.
,
,
.

,
. ,

.

1998 . . -

3(12)


,
. , . ,

XIX .
, . .
- . ,
,
, .
, ,
.
- ,
.
,
, .
.

.
, , .
,
.
- .
- ,
.
,
.

, 2009


, ,


.
2004 .
.
.
,
, ,
, ,
,
, .
, :
- ,
. ,
, ,
,
.
. , ,

.

1. , . . , / . . . ., 1999.
2. , . . / . . . ., 1924.
3. , . . - / . . . , 2006.
4. , . .
/ . . . ., 1889.
=9=

. . ,

-

-

- ,

-


,
,
, .
,
,
- , - (: ),
- .
, - ,
-,
, -
.

,
, , ,
.
- ,
, , .
, , , , .
- , , , -,
- =10=

; -,
,
; -,
,
, .
,
, , ,

- .
, , - ,
,
.
,
.
:
,
,
, , .;
,
;
, .


-
.
,
.

,
, , (, . .).
, .
, -

3(12)

.
,
, , ,

.

. , , .
, . .
-
-

-, , , ,

- ( . . ,
,
: . . .
. . ., 1982).


. . , . . ,
. . ( . .

(- ) : . . ... . . . ., 1984 ; . .
: . . ... . .
. ., 1984 ; . . : .
. . . ., 1985).

(), -:
,
, 2009

. ., () , .
, -.
. , - ,
.
, - -
( , ) , ()
, -

,
- , .
,
-
- .

1. , . . : , , .
/ . . . ., 1988.
2. , . . / . . . ., 1992.
3. , . . -
: . /
. . . . , 1992.
4. , . .
, , :
. . ... . . . ., 1982.
=11=

. . ,

-

. . ,

- ,


-




, - .
, . ,
, , , .


. , ,
. ,
, . , ,
,
(. . ., 2009).

, , , , . , ( / . . . . . .
., 2001).
: =12=

, .
XIX . ,
,
, ,
, .
XIX
XX . ( . .
, . ., 1902 ;
. . (
). ., 1902. . 2 ; . .
. ., 1889). :
,

(
,
, , ),
-
, . .
1819 .


I (19 1819 .) , , .


. . , . . , . . ,
, . .
. .

. . , - . . . , -

3(12)

,

.
, ( . ., . . : . 2- ., . . , 2003).
,
5 1866 . - , 19 1909 ., (, , ).
1917 .

:
,
,
, ,
.
.

,
( . . (- ). , 1998).
XX XXI . ,
, , ,
, , ,
,

, , .
,
. ,
,
. ,
, 2009

, .
.
, - ,
,
,

-
.

, , ,
, .
,
, ,
,
,
.



, . ,
. ,
, ,
,
, , , ,
, , , .
=13=

,
.
.

. ,

.
, - .
,

, .


.
.
, .

,
.
, .
, , .

.
,
,
.



,
=14=

, ,
,

, .
,
,
:
1) ;
2) (
,
);
3) (
, ,
)
( . ., . . , : .
. , 1990).

,
,

.
:
) , ;
) () ( . . : .. . , 1998).




, .
:
1.
: ;
; .
2. ,
,

3(12)

,
.
3. ,
. . ,
.
,
,
, .


1. , . . (- ) : . /
. . . , 1998.
2. , . .
:
.-. / . . . , 1998.
3. , . .
: / . . ,
. . . 2- ., . . , 2003.

. . ,

-


,




,
. ,
, ,
.
:
? , .
, .

. , ,
,
(
, ,
).

,
. , ,
, , . ,
.
-


. ,
,
,
.


,
,
. :

,
- .

,
(: ).
, 2009

=15=

, ( ,
, ),
, .
,

,
. , ,
.

.
IV , ,
,
, . 1 . 87 .
, ,
,
: ,
; ,
.
,
.

. ,
,
,
, , ,
.
, , ,


.

, ,
=16=


, . 3 . 87

. ,
,


. , , , .
, ,
.

. -
, ,
,
, ,
,
. . ,
( ) , ,

. , , ,
, .
, , ,
.

.
,
,
--

3(12)

. ,
, , . ,
.
,
, ,
: , , .

, , ; ,
, ; ,
; ,

; , .
,
,
. ,
; ,

;
,
; -
; , ; ,
, , 2009

; , ,
,

; ,

; ,
- , .
,
. ,
. , ,
,
,
, , . . ,
,
.

. . ,

, () ( ). ,

,

,

, ,
,
( . . - ,
, //
. .-. . ( 1997 .).
, 1998. . 2425).
,
=17=


.
,
,
,
.
, , -
.
, , - , . . . , . , . ,

.
. .


.
. . ,


(. )
,



-

,
( =18=

, ,
.
, .
, ,

, ,
, ,
, .

1. - /
. . . . . /,
2008.
2. (2006 ) . ., 2006.
3. , . . /
. . . ., 2007.
4. - . ., 2009.
),


.
1.

, , ,
27 1993 . 4866-1 , (. .
1993. 12 ),
2 2006 . 59- -

3(12)

( . 2006. 5 ), ,

18 1981 .
,
,
( .
. 1981. 21, . 741)
, , 28 2006 . 10/1-2571
( ).


, .

( ) .
13 2004 . 1313
(. . 2004. 19 .)




(. . . 2001. 3).

. .
12 2002 .
154
, 25
2001 .


(URL: http://www.allbussiness.ru/BPravo/DocumShow_DocumID_22474.html).
, 2009




,

.

22 2002 . 45 .
2. ,
(2006)
(URL: http://www.prison.org/law/eur_pr.shtml).
3. ,

( ,
) , ,
, , , , 11 1999 .
499-, 29 2001 .
232-
, , ,
,
(. . . 1999.
47, . 5655),
.
4.
29
2007 . 36
-- ( . 2007. 9).
5.
,
=19=


.
6. -

.
, . 17 :
, - , -

,
, , , .
. 1 , 17 1979 . 34/169 106-

(
: . . ., 1990. . 319),
.



, .

, , , ,

, ,
, . .
, =20=

,
, , , ,
,

,
. . 285
. 58

( : . .
23 . 1992 . 4202-1 //
. .
. . . 1993. 2,
. 70) .


,

. ,
,
, ,
, . 119 .



, , ,

( - -
20062010 :
18 . 2005 . 10/8/1-100. . . ),

- 2011 1,
1

, , , 11 2009 . . .

3(12)


, () .

1. , . . / . . .
. , 1999.
2. -
. . ,




(. )

()


,

( . . : . , 1999. . 1. . 56).

, , , ,
,
( . .
- : . , 2000.
. 123124). ,

.
, 2009

/ . . . . . ., 1997.
3. , . . :
, , / . . . ., 1991.
4. , . . - : . / . . .
, 1994.
- .
, ,
,

-, - (

- : .-. /
. . . . . ., 2007. . 67).

.
-

, , , ,
.
, - :

;
=21=

, ;
,

;


;
, -, -
;

;
,
;
,
, - ;


;

;
;

, -, -
.
,
,
, .
, , ,
.
=22=

,
. , ,

, .
-
, ,

, ,
.
- .
, ,

,
,
. ,


.
, .
, .
,
, , :
, . . , ,
.
, , .;
,

(
, , , , );

3(12)

, . . , ,

,
, , ;
, . . , , ,

.
,
-
:
1.
,
.
2.
.
3.
.
4. .

5.
, , ,
, ,
,
- .
6. ,

.
7. , ,

.

. . ,

-
. . ,

- ,


-



.

,

.
,
, . -



, 2009


1. , . .

: / . . . , 1999.
2. , . . :
. / . . . , 2000.
3. , . .
, : . / . . [ .]. ., 1995.
4. - : .-. /
. . . . . ., 2007.

=23=

,
.


.

.
.
,
, , : , .

.

. , ,
,

, , .

. ,
,
, .



.
-
, . . , .


,
=24=

, ,
, -
( . .
//
, : . . . , 1992).
, .
, ,
,
, , , , . (
,
, ) ,
( () . , 1993).

,
. , ,
,

.

3(12)


.
,
, , , : ,
, ,
, , , , . , 60 %

, . , , ,
, . .
,

.

,
. , ,
, , ,
, .


.
.
. ,

.
,
.
,
, 2009


, .

, .

, .
.

,

.
, . , ,
: ,
.

, , - -,
. ,
, .
- , ,
.

, , , ,
,

. , =25=

, , , ,
, -
, .


,
.
. ,
.


.
. , ,
, , , . .
.

. , -
.

.
, .


, , , ,
, ,
.
,

. -

=26=



- .
,
,
,
.

,
, , ,
. , ,
,
.
,


:
, , , ,
, , -, - .

1. () . , 1993.
2. , . . -
/ . . // , : . . .
, 1992.

3(12)

. . ,

-

,
. . ,

-

,
. . ,




-

-
, 1990- .
, ,

.
?

, , - .
, , , , , , ,
. . , ,
. , (PublicPrivate Partnership )1. 1



, 2009


,
.

.
,


. ,

, -

, 2.
:
( );
,
; .


.
-
- (:
- (),
. , , , - ().
2
, ,
: , , ,
,
; , , ,

,
, , (URL:
http://www.finam.ru/analysis/forecasts00342/default.asp).
=27=

),

, , ,
( - (

. // .
2007. 2). 21
2005 . 115- (. .
. 2005. 30, . 2, . 3126),
22 2005 . 116- ( . 30, . 1, . 3127),
23 2005 . 694
( .
48, . 5043) ,
. , 1
2008 . 134


( . 2008. 10, . 2, . 932).
- , ,
, ,
-
,
, , ( -
:
2 . 2007 . 372. . .- ).
,

=28=

- ( -
- : - 25 . 2006 .
627-100. .
.- ). ,
,
, .
,
- ,

, - ,
.
: ,
(
), , - ,
, , . .

( . .
// . . .
2005. 9. . 8696).
, , , ,
, ,
, , , ,
,
, . ,

, -

3(12)

,
1.
,
,
, . ,
, , . .
.

.
,
. , ,
,
.


, (
) , , ( .

-
// . 2008. 1.
. 53).
,

.
, 1

. 1 . 179.2 ,
, - (.


1 2008 . 134).
, 2009

, , (
) - .
,
. 3 . 13 21 1993 .
5473-1 ,
(: ) , , ,
( . . . .
1993. 33, . 1316). , ,
(. 1 . 103 ).

, (:
) .

,

. , ,
,
,
, , - . . (
-
- . . // . 2007.
1. . 5).
,


, =29=

,
- . , ,
, ,
( .-. . 2007.
9. . 515).


(: ) (

,
,
:
7 . 2005 . 660 // . . . 2005. 46,
. 4676).
,

,
(
- (20072016 ) : 5 .
2006 . 540 // .
. . 2006. 39, . 4075).
, (

// .-. . 2008. 6. . 317 ; ,

// . 2008.
2. . 222), ,
=30=

21 2005 . 94- , ,
(. . .
2005. 30, . 1, . 3105).
,


, , . . .
,
(


- ()
,
, ()
, :
1 . 2008 . 80 //
. . 2008. 16 .).
,
,
. ,

, . ,
.
( .-. . 2008. 6. . 15).

3(12)



. , ,


.
.
: 1)


; 2) ,
, .
,
. , ,

10 2008 .
1714-
,
( . 2008. 2).

.
, ,
,
,
,
,
(. 4 . 11 ). ,
. 14
:


, , ;

, 2009

,
;

,
- ,
- , .
, ,


,
- , ,
, (. 17
).
,
- :
1) ,
,
,
,
.
, , , , .

. 21
.
25 1999 .
39- ,
(. . .
1999. 9, . 1096)

.

, ( , )

(=31=

: / . . . . , . . . ., 2006. . 2. . 148).

: , -, ,
. ,

;
2)
, ,
;
3)
, .


,
. , , , , (. 8 10
12 1996 . 7- (. . . 1996. 3, . 145)).
, -
, ,
,
, ,
(,
) ( . . .
: . . ., 2003. . 204).

,


( ., .
=32=

. ., 2001.
. 495),
.

. ,
, . 4
21 2005 .
115- , ,
,
, ,
, , .

,
.
-,
,
, .

- .
-, ,
21 2005 . 94-.
-, ,
.


,
, ,
( ),
,

3(12)

. .
,

-

.

-
, ,
, .


1. : . 2 . . 2 /
. . . . , . . .
., 2006.
2. , .
/ . , . . ., 2001.
3. , . .
. : . / . . . .,
2003.
4. , . . / . . // . .
. 2005. 9.

. . ,
-



. 1 . 1 . 40
,
,
- .
12 1995 .
144- - . 1 ,
, ,
- ,
. 6, ,
, , , (. . 1995. 18 .).
. 13 , , , - ,

, :
1) - (: ) (
);
2) (, ,
);

-


,
; , , ,
,
, . .
( - . URL: http://slovari.yandex.ru/dict/buppdic/article/source/g0000
282.htm).


.
. 1 . 150

. , ,
, .
, 2009

=33=

3)
;
4) ,
(,
, )1;
5) -
,
.
-
, ,
.
84 ,
: ) ,

; ) ,


; ) , ,
, ; )
,
.
. 2 . 40
:
)
, , , . 32 ;
) ,
, , . 157 .
, . 1 . 2 . 40 ,
1




.
=34=

,

, , , () ,
,
- . ,
- .
. 21
. VIII
. 5
. 2 . 157 ,
-

, (
, ).
, ,
, ,
, .
.
1.



.
2. ,
-
,
11 2006 . 250 (. . 2006.
5 .), , , -

3(12)


(. 3 . 151 ),

.
3.
, , ,
, , 11 2006 . 250,
.
, ,
- -


. . ,

-


-
- ,

, , , ,
.
, . (1/3 , , 25 ).
, ,
, ,
.
, , , , ,
, 2009

- .

1. , . . / . . . , 1999.
2. - : . 12 . 1995 . 144-
// . . 1995. 18 .
3. , : .
21 1993 . 5473-1 //
. 1993. 33. . 1316.
4. , . .
/ . . . ,
2007.
5. - . ., 2008.
, .
,
-.

9 2001 . 25- (.
. 2001. 14 )
-
-.

- , ,
, ,
, ,
.
,
,
. . ,
, ,
, ,
,
.
=35=


60 %
56 . 2008 . (64 %) ,

.
: 175 2002 . 275 2008 .
2006 .
502 , . .

, ,

7,5 %. , 6 , .

.
-,
:

, , ,
;

;

, ;
;
-
.
, ,
,

- , .

- -
,
=36=


.
,
,
- -.

, .

-, , ,

;
- .
20072008 . -
, -.
, 2008 .
, -, 474
2007 . 275 (42 %). 1 4,96 %, 3,7 , (1,31 %).
2008 . .
, 14,3 %
,
. 321 , ; 300 % (. 105
); 43,4 % (. 313 );
56,2 %
(. 314 ); 8,3 %
(. 228, 228.1 ). , , 39,1 %.

. 1


1000 .

3(12)


-.
, 2006 . 14 , 10 , ,
,

. ,
,
13 , , .
,
, .
, , .
, , .
, . .
, . ,
2006 . -5
12.00 ,
, , . 162
.
2007 . -9 23.30
, 2009

.
. ,
00.30 3.40
.
,
,

,

,
,
,
- .
, ,

-
, , ,
.
- . ,
-
.

-.
75 % ,
. , ,
,
,
, .
,
-7
,
=37=

, .
.
,
,
. -
, 70 % .
-

,
,
.
, -, -5,
, 10 , .
..
, , ,
.

, , , . 112, 119 .
, ,
: ,
-,
- ,

.

,
, . , 2007 .
-3 . ,

. 2
. 181 =38=

.

.
-,

, pe.
, 2007 . -11
,
,

. 2007 .
106 ,
. 313314 .

- . . , ,
,
. , -

,
- , .

.
,
:
1) , , , , ;
2) ( ) -

3(12)

, ;
3) ,

,
, ;
4) , ,
, ,
;
5) , . .
,

;
6) , . . , ,
, ,
, , ;
7) , , , , ,

( );
8) , ,
,

;
9) ,
, , ,
, ,
-

( : . / .
. . . . ., 2003. . 731733).
- ,
, . , 2009

,

73 % , (47 %)
( . . : . . ., 2002. . 112).
- 20072008 .

-,
, ,
-, .
- 20072008 , - ,
2007 . . .

- , ,
, 2092 , 5 %
, 6 , 798 ,
, 640 , 486

. 2008 . 6732
, ,
5,4 % 2007 ., 2083, 1,8 %.
2007 2008 . 7 8

. ,
,
. ,

. , , .
=39=

, , -, , . 4 . 78 , ,
, - ,
.
- ,
- . -
- , ,
, -

=40=

, .

1. , . . -
: . . / . . , . . . ., 2003.
2. , . . - .
: / . . ,
. . . ., 1990.
3. , . . , ,
: . / . . , . . , B. C. . ., 1997.
4. : . /
. . . . . ., 2003.

3(12)




. . ,

-




,

,
. ,
,


. ,
:
, ( . .
.
, 1987. . 104).
, , ,
,
, .
, .
, 2009

. . ,
, ,
:
; ;
;
,
;
; ;

; (, . .).
,
. . , ( . .
-
, : . . . .
, 2004. . 4142).
. . ,
, , :
;
, ; ; ; ( . . ,
: . .
. . , 2002. . 22).
. .
, ,
, : , =41=

(
); , ;
; , (
); , ;
(, , ) ( . .
,

: . ... . . . , 2001. . 2829).
. . ,
, , : ;
,
;
; ,
;
;
; , ( B. C.
, : . ... .
. . , 2003. . 24).
, . . ,
, , :
, ; (,
, );
( ); ; ;
( . . , =42=

- : . . . .
, 2002. . 2223).
, ,
, ,
, , .

,
()
,
( . ., . ., . .
( ) // . , 1980. . 42).
() ()
, . . ,
, , ( . . : . .,
2001. . 230231).
,
, , :
) ,

;
) ;
) ;
)
;

3(12)

)
, ,
;
) (, ).


, .
1.
, , , (.:
. .
// . , 1977. . 178 ;
. . . , 1988. . 5 ;
. . // . , 1981. . 27 ; . .
//
. , 1982. . 25. . 13 ; . ., . .
// . .
1982. 8. . 7175 ; . .
// . . 1979. 30. . 120121 .).
,

, .
,
. ,
, 2009



. , ,

( . . .
, , . . ., 1988. . 176177).
,
(), ,
, , ,
.
2.
. , . . , ,


,
( . .
: .
. ... - . . ., 1970. . 10).

. . ( . . . . . 211217).
, ( ,
)
() ,
.
,

.
,
,
=43=

, , , , .
,
, ,
, , ,
( ) ,
,
( . .
// . ., 1984. . 38).
, , ,
( . .
. 3 . . III: , . ., 1997. . 313).

, ,
, .
,
,

.
3.
.
,
, .
, , .
: ,
=44=

, .

,
, , .
4.

,
, ( . .

. , 1975.
. 33). , . , , - - , ( . . .
-
. ., 2002. . 4243).
,
, ,
, ,
, .
5. , ,
,
.

, ,

.
, -

3(12)

(, , ,
. .)
, , , , ,
. ( /
. . . . ., 1995. . 55).

, , ,
,
,

( . .
. . . 40).

,
,
,
( . ., . .
, . ., 2001. . 16).
6. ,
,
( . . . . 3435)
( . .
// . , 1980. . 4955). , ,
. ,

, , ,
( , , , ,
, ,
, , 2009

. .) ( . . : //
. ., 1984. . 910).
,
. , , ,

(. . 52).
( . .
. . 39).
,
, , ,
, . .
, ,
,
.
, ,
.

,
,
.
,
=45=

, ,
,
, ,
.

1. , . .
,
. . ,



,
. . ,






, . - , , , , , . ,


, , .
, ,
: , =46=

: .
. . . , 2002.
2. , . . - ,
: .
. . . , 2004.
3. , . . ,
: .
... . . . , 2001.
4. , B. C. , :
. ... . . . , 2003.
, -.

: ) ,
, ; )
,
; ) ,
-
, ,
, .
: ,
,
; ;

.
:
,


; - ;
.

3(12)

- , .

.

:
.

,
,
, ;
.


,
;
( )
;

.
, , , ,
, ,
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
(:
. . .
, 1993 ; . . . 2- . ., 1989 ; . .
. , 2007 ; . / . . . . .,
1974 ; . / .
. . . ., 1990).
, 2009

,
, ,

.
( )
, ,

. , , .
, , ,


,
-

.
70- 80- .

.
,
. ,

, .
,
. . 1979 .
(
),


.


( / . . . , . . .
., 1992. . 1, . 5).
=47=

. . , ,
, . . ,
:
;
;
( : / .
. . . . . . . ., 1997. . 6469).
,
, . .
, . -, ,
.
,
. -, , ,

. ,

, , .
,
,
,
.



, :
)
,
;
) .

, , =48=


.
:
) ; ) ( : / . .
. . . . . .
., 2008. . 5256).
- ,
,
, , . .
,
, .
,
,
, ,

.



. ,
,
(- , - . .)
( / . .
. . . ., 1992 ; : / .
. . . . . . ),
,
( . .
-
: . .
. . ., 1993 ; . . -

3(12)

,
: . . . . ., 2000). ,

,
, ,

.
, , . , . . ,
,
,
, - ,
, ,
(?!), , . ,
, - , ,
... ( . . - :
//


: . .-.
. , 2005. . 280283).


, , ,
( . ., . . . .
., 2003. . 2223).
, ,
, , , .
, :

( , ,
, );
, 2009


, , ,
, ;

,
? , , , , ,
, ,
,
.
,
,
, , ,
... ( : .
/ . . . . ., 2003.
. 42). , ,
-
, , ; , ,
, ,
,
, , .
, ,
,
,
,
, , ,
, , . ,

,

=49=


.
,
( ) (- , - ,
. .),
. . ,

,
,
, .
,
( . .
: . -
. . . , 2008).
,
, , , , . .
(, -

-), , -
, ,
. ,
,
, , , , ,
.

, , , .

. . ,



. , ,
. . ,
, , ( . .
//
. ., 1997. . 38).
,
, -

, ,
.
=50=


1. , . . :
. - . . . , 2008.
2. : . /
. . . . ., 2003.
3. : / .
. . . . . . . ., 2008.
4.

:
/ . . . .
. . . . ., 1997.

3(12)

: , , , , , , ,
.
,

, , . ,

.
, (). ,
(.: . .
. , 1995 ; . .,
. .
. ., 1990 ; . . . ,
1983 ; . . . ., 1981 .).

(. 187191 ),
-
, ( / . . . , . . .
., 1994. . 276).
,


, , .


( , ). , , ,
, 2009

.
.

, , ,
, :
1. ,
. . ()
, ,
,
,
.
,
, ,
. ,
,
.
2.


()
(.: . .

. ., 2001 ; . . . , 1984 ; . .
. , 1978 .). . 307 306 .
.
3. ,
, ,
=51=

(),
.
, , . , ,
.
4. ,
, ,
.

, .
5. , () .
. , .
, .
,


. , ,
, , , , , .
, =52=

,
, , ,

, , . 1/3 ,
, .
,
, ,
,
.
, ,
. . ,
.
, , .
. 26
18 1991 . 1026-1
( : . .
. ., 2001. . 1. . 136),



, .
, . , ,
,
, .
:
1) ?
2) ( -

3(12)


)?
3)
( ,

; )?
4)
,
?
, ,
,
, , , .
,
.
, , , ().
(
),
(
). ,
, ,
, . ., ,
.

, .
, .
, ,
, , , .
, 2009

,

,
.


.
, ,

,
, ,
. ,

,
. , ., . ,
:
. , , ,
(.
. 2007 . . 1151754
. 2 . 105 ).
()
.
,
, ,
.
, () ,
, ,
, .
=53=

,

.



(

,
, . .
).
, ,
( ,
-
.),
, , ,
,
.
.


.

, , .
, ,
, , ( ,
);
, ,
.
, ,
. . , =54=

,

, , . ,
, ,
( . .
: . .
. . , 2003. . 160).

,

(
,
. .).
,
, ,
.




.
, ,
,
. . , , ,
, , ,
.
2003 2008 .,

, 65 ,

.
.
-

3(12)

(.:
. ., . ., . .
. .,
1969 ; . ., . . : . . ., 1988 ; . . , .
., 2002 .).
, , . . ,
; , , ( : . / .
. . . ., 2001. . 612).
()
. -,
, (),
. -,
, () , , , , .
,
,
. . ,

( . . . , 1973. . 120).

, , . ()
,
, 2009

(. 51 ). ,
() , .
() : 1) ;
; 2) ,
, , ,
; 3) ;
4) ,
.
,
.
,

,

.
()
:
1)
; ,
, ,
;
2) ;
3)
;
4)


, , - .
,
, , ()
,
=55=


, .
,
.
, , .
,
,
,


.

,


.

. . ,

-


, .
,
:
;
;
;

; ,
.
.


.
29 2009 . 141-
-

-

(. 40 )
. . , :

, , , =56=


1. , . .
/ . . // .
., 1997.
2. : . /
. . . . ., 2001.
3. , . .

: . .
. . , 2003.
4. , . . , / . . . ., 2002.

3(12)

(. .
2009. 3 ).
, . 61 . 5 :
,

.
,

: ,

, (. . ,
,
) ,


,
. ,
, ,
.



, .
,
.
: , ,
, ,
.

40.1
, 2009

.
, ,
.

, ,
:
,
;


;
;
, , ,
( );
;

, ;



.

,

.
.



,
=57=



,
, ,
.
,

.

; , , .

.


, .
: , ,
, ,
. .
, . 4 . 317.6

,
.
. 316
, . . ;
=58=


. :
1) , , , ;
2) , , , ;
3) ,
;
4) ,
, , ;
5) ,
, ,
.
. 2 4
. 62 , ,
, . ,

. 64, 73 80.1
,
,
.
,

.
,
, . 241 . ,

, , ,
, .

3(12)

, ()
, , .
. 7 . 317.7 ,
, 43 , ,

, ,
43
, . ,
, . . , , ,
.
,
,

.

:

,

- ,
, V
. , ,
. 317.8 , . ,
, V ,
: 48
49
.
29 2009 .
141- ,
,
, , ,
. , .

, .

. . ,


13 2000 .
849 : . 11 . 2008 . // . .
2000. 16 ).
,
-
.

,
, ( .
// :

,

9 ( :
, 2009


1. -
() / . . . . .
6- ., . . ., 2008.
2.
: . : [ 29 2009 .
141-] // . . 2009. 3 .

=59=

. 2008. 2. . 51 ; . , // . . . 2008.
2. . 68).
, . ,
( . , // . . 2000. 20 ; . . !
// . 19 ; // . 16 ).
. . , ,
, , . 71 ( . .
: // . 2009. 1).
, 24 1997 . 1-

17 1996 .
(. . . .
1997. 1),
, ,

,
-
, .
, ,

.
, ,
,
.
, . . ,
=60=




-
. - ,
( . .
. .).
. . ,
, , , 90- . XX
, ,
, ( . .

:
. . .-
).
, . . ,
,
( . . //
. .
2003. 1. . 5).

,

.
, - ,
,
.

.
. . :


-

3(12)

( . . -
// . . . . .
2002. 1(30). . 9).


. . : ,
, ,

,
. ,
, , ,
,
( . . . .).
, .
.

13 2000 . 849,
(
: . 5 2000 . 98.
. . ).


( ), .
.
, , 2009


, , .
,


,
, .
:




,

. ( . 17 .
2008 . 67 // . 2008. 7).
,

,

, , .
,

. 8 : 1.
,
,
,
.
2. , 1
=61=

, , ,
,

, ( : .
17 . 1992 . 2202-1 : .
17 2009 . // . . . .
1992. 8, . 366 ; . . 2009. 21 ).
,
. 54 , ,
.

, , .
,
. 8 , ,

. 54,

,
,

,
.
,
( )
.
,

, ,

. , -, =62=


(

).

.
, . . ,

, ,
,
. , ,
, ( . . // . 2005. 4).
, ,
. . , , , ,
.
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
.

.
, ,

.
.

3(12)


, ,
, ,
.

,


.

, , .


,


, -

.

,
.



, , , ,

,

. , , , .
, 2009


.
-, . 3.2

,
, ( -
).

-

, .
-, . .
-, ( )
() .
, ,
.
, ,
.
, -, , , -,

=63=

,
-,

.
, ,
,
,
.
, ,
, .




.



.
,
, .

. . ,

-


,

.
, - .
, . 166 , ,
, .
, , ,
. , , ,
,
.
. 166 -



,

, . ,
, . , .
,
, .
(: ), =64=


1. , . , / . // . .
2000. 20 .
2. , . . /
. . // . 2005. 4.
3. , . . -
/ . . // . . .
. . 2002. 1(30).
4. : . : [ 17 . 1992 .
2202-1 : . 25 . 2008 .] // . .
. . 1992. 8,
. 366.

3(12)

,


.

.
,
,

, , .
,
( , ) , . .
. 168
: , , .
, . 59

, . , ,

, ,
. , ,

. ,

.
,

. 59 , . 12,
: ,
,
, .
, 2009

. 25
8 1994 . 3- (. . 1999. 8 ; 2009. 15 )
, ,
(),
() ( )
.
, ,
, , . , , , ,
.

,
. 1 . 178
: (. 1 . 1 . 81 )
(. 2 . 1
. 81 )
, ,
( ).

,
, .
.
,



, .

=65=

,
,

.

1. , . . /
. . , . . . ., 2008.
2. , . .

. . ,





,
, ,
, ,
,

.

,
, , .
,
. .


,
.
=66=


/
. . // . 2008.
10.
3.
/ . . . . . 4- . ., 2008.
4. , . . : / . . // . 2007. 4.
. 4 . 31 ,
.
, .
(,
, )
, , .
, , : 1)
; 2)
. ,
, ,

.
. ,
. ,
,

, ,

, . . ( . .
. .,
2002. . 319).

3(12)

-, , .
, . . ,


.
, ,
,
.

,
.
,
,
. ,

, ( . . . .,
1974. . 159).
. . . ,

. .

( . ., 2007. . 6:
. . 523).
? , .
.

,
,
.

, , ,
.
, 2009

,
,
,
.
,
, ,
. ,
.
, . ,
, .
,
( . . . . . 319).


,
. ,

22 2004 . . . 30,
. 3; . 33, . 3; . 105, . 2, .

. .

.,
.
.
.
. , .
, .

=67=

, ,
, , ,
,
, . .

16 2004 .
,
,
. . , , , , . .
. 30, . 1; . 33, . 3; . 105, . 2, .
( . .
5-04-215 16 . 2004 .
.
.- ).
, (, , )
, -

.
,


.



, . , , . 34
,
.

. . ,


(. 1 . 67 ),
, ,
,
(. 2 . 67 ).

, ,
, . ,
, ,
,
. , -



.
. , =68=


1. , . . / . . . ., 2002.
2. , . . / . . .
., 1974.
3. . 35 .
. 6. / . .
. . . 2- . ., 2007.

3(12)

(, . 209, 210 ). ,
. 2 43 ,
(. 6 ) (

: . .
11 . 2007 . 2. . 1 // . .
. . 2007. 4. . 7),
. 67
,

, .
. .

,

, ( . .
: . . . . .
., 1972. . 7). . . ,
,

. ,
( . . .
, 1980. . 2324, 26. -
,

. : . .

// . . .
, 1991. . 86 ; . .

. , 1988. . 67 .). ,



, , 2009

,
.
, , , . . 60
,

,
, .

(. 1 . 34,
. 67 ),

(. 62, 64 ),

(. 1 . 89 ). ,
- ,


.
. .

: ) ;
) ; ) ; ) ( . . . .,
1999. . 157). ,

- ,
( , , , ). ,
,
.
=69=

. . , , ,

( . .
: , , .
., 2006. . 58).
. . ,
( . . . ., 1999. . 6263). ,
,
.
,
.
,
, , ,
(
, ,
-, , , ,
.). . 1 . 67 :
) ; ) ; )
; )
.

,

.

=70=

, ,
(,
, , ), (. . 1 . 63
) , : ) (
); ) , , ; ) ,
,
.
. . , , ,
,

( . .
-
. , 2005. . 32). , ,
,
, , , (. 1 . 209
). ,

( )
, - .
, , , (
, ,
,
. 2
. 67 ).

.

3(12)

,
5 1999 .
.
,
, , .
:
,
; , ,
. , ,
,
.
,
,


.
,
,
,
, . ,

, , , , ( . .
1999 . . .
5 . 1999 . ,
, , ).
, , , , ,
, . .

,
, 2009

. . 1 . 61 ;
. . 1 . 61 ; . . 1 . 61
, .
,
, ,
, . , ,
. 6 ,
, , , .
, ,
; , ,
.

- . ,
,
.
,
,
, ,
- .
, , , .
, , ,
, , ,
, , , ,
.

=71=

:
, , .
, (

2003 // . . . . 2004. 9. . 30).
, , ,
.


,
.
,
, ( . 8 14
2000 . 7

, , ,
-

,
(. .
. . 2000. 4. . 12).

, ,
,
,
,
.
, ,

,
, - . ,
,
.

. . ,



. . . 2008. 2)
(: 51)
, , , .
,
.

(),
.



()
27 2007 . 51
, (.
=72=


1. , . . : , , / . . . ., 2006.
2. , . .
- / . . . , 2005.

3(12)

,
51, ,

.
. 1 51 (: ) ,
,



. , , : 1) ( ,
), 2) .
,
, ( ).
,
(
: . 5 .
1986 . 11. URL: http://www.lawmix.ru/
docs_.php?id=2997). ( ) .
: , , .
, , -,
. 159 ,
. , 2009

,
.
. 2 3 51
, . : ,
, , , .
. 4 51 ,
, 5 1986 . 11

.
51
,
: ,

. ,
,
:
,
()
.

51

:

;
, .
, : ,
=73=

,
,
,

, , ,
,
.

: . 9
11 1972 . 4

(.
19241977. ., 1978. . 2), . 12
5 1986 . 11
, . 3
30 1989 . 13

(URL:
http://www.pravoteka.ru/pst/531/265298.html),
. 20, 21 10 2000 . 6
(URL:
http://zakon.kuban.ru/private/ppvs6.htm).
( ), ,
,

. .

,
.

-
( . .
:
. ., 2007). ,
. 5
=74=

51 , , , , ,
, ,

,
, , .
,

.

,

.
6 7 51 ,
.
. 6 23
1980 . 6
,
, () . .
(. 327 ) (. 159 ) (. ,
/ . . . . ; . . . . . ., 2008).
51 , ,
,
( ),

3(12)

. 327
.
. 8 51
,

,
,
. 173
, , , .
,
.
, . 173 , ,
( ), ( , ,
),
( , ). ,
, . 159 (
), , . 165 ( ). , ,
. ,
, .

51 ,
,
, ,
, , 2009

, ,

171 . , 18
2004 . 23
()
, (. . 2004. 7 .) . , , , , . 171
,
,
.

, ,
-,

, -,

,
. 171 .
, :
,
, , , , 159
238 ,
,
.
. 10 51 ,

, ,

(
), =75=

.
, , , ,

27 2002 .
29
, ,

, ,
, , ( . 2003. 18 .).
. 11 51
,
,
,
, , , ,
, , ()

.
,
( 31
1961 . 2 , , (. 19611993. ., 1994).
. 5 11 1972 . 4 ( ) ,
,

=76=


. ,


.

, . 1214
51: ,
,
,
, . 272 273 ;


() ,
,
,

, ,
.
, , , , () ,
28
1994 . 2
(URL: http://zakon.
kuban.ru/nd2/2001-1/2-94.shtml).
. 15 51 ,
. 8 28 1994 . 2.

51 ,

(. 165 )
(. 161 ). ,
,
.
. 21, 2327 51
, -

3(12)

.

, : ,
. 201 285 , , .
- ( . 201
). .
. 10
27 2003 . 58-
: ,


(, )
,
() . , , ()
(. . 2003. 31 ).
. 10 2 2007 . 25- : 1. , ,

, 2009


, ,
. 2. , , , ( . 2007. 7 ).
, , ,
, . 3 . 159
. 201 (285) ,
. 3 . 159 .
. 28 51
, ()
,

. , , ,

.

: -, , 51, ;
-,
, .

1. , . .
: / . . . ., 2007.
2. , : . .
27 . 2007 . 51 // .
. . . 2008. 2.
3. :
.
5 . 1986 . 11. :
http://www.lawmix.ru/docs_.php?id=2997.
=77=

. . ,

.

-

.

, ,
.

-.
.
, . . ,
, ,
,

( . . : //
. 2001. 3. . 78).
. . , ,
, ,
.
, , . . , ( . .

. ., 1975. . 64).
. . ,
,
, ,

=78=

( . .
. , 1984. . 102, 103).
. . : , , .
,
, ,
, , ,
.
( . . // - . , 1987. . 170171).
. . ,


.
, ,
( B. .
// .
, 1999. . 451).
(.: ., . // . 1998. 7 ;
. .
// . , 1998 ; . .
. ., 1996 ; . .
- : . .
. . ., 1994 ; . .
. ., 2001 .).

24 1998 . 82 , (
),


; -

3(12)


, ;
, .

,
,
. 20
2007 . 185
(. 2008. 1).
. 35, 36 17 1992 . 2202-1

(. . .
1995. 47. . 4472) ,
. -
. . 55 . 1 . 5 :
,
, . . . ( . .
(
) : . - . . ., 1997).
, ,
, :
,
,

. , 2009

,
, , .
,

:
1.
, .
2. , , ,
,
, , .
,
.
3.
. , ,
,
.
,
,
,
.
4. , , ,
,
.
.
, , =79=


,
.
5. ,

.
, .
.


.
, , ,

, .

, . . - .
,
,
, ,
( . . // . ., 1974).
, ,

.
,

(. 8 . 246 )
,

,
( )
.
,

=80=


,
, .
20 1999 . 7- (.
. 1999. 27 .) . 4 . 248

. , .
,


.

, , ,
, , ,
.
,

.
,
. ,
, ( . .
//
. . . -. . 11, .
2001. 1. . 94).
. . ,
( . .
// . .
. -. . 11, . 1999. 5. . 55).
. .

, -

3(12)

, , .
,
. . 7 . 246

. 254

( ., .
// . . 2000. 3).
,

, ,
.
, ,
, , ,

. .


,
,

, , .

. . ,



, , ,
,
.

, , ,

,
,
. ,



(: )
.
, , 2009


1. , . . / . . //
. , 1998.
2. , . .

/ . . .
., 1996.
3. , . . : .-. /
. . . ., 2009.
4. , . .
: / . . // .
2001. 3.
5. , . .
/
. . . ., 2001.

=81=

, .

,
,
,

.


-
-. ,

, 23 % , 59 % 18 %.

- :
,
,
;
- .
, ,
,
,
.
. , ,
- ,
, .
.
, ,
., , =82=

.,
SMS-. ,
,
,
, .
,
,
-
.
,
.
:
1)
,
( . .

, //
: . .-. . , 1998.
. 110 ; . .
- // :
. . . ., 1999. . 7); 2) ( . .
. ., 2001. . 6075 ;
. ., . .
// .
1999. 11. . 39).
, ,
,
.

3(12)

, , 87 %
, , 58 % ,
.
, ,
,

,
.

, , (: ).
,
, .

.
. .


. , , .

,

. ,

(

, 2009

,
).



, . ,
2007 . , , 2006 . 1/3, 32 %.

, , , .
, .
518
.
, , ,
, .
, (), -
-, .
() .
,
, 2 .

, ,
( =83=


, - : 27 . 2005 .
538 // . . 2005. 2 .), , , ,

.
,

- ( - ).
,
-,
,
.

. ,


.



.
, ,
,


, ,
.

. . ,

-

, . , . . ,
:
; ;

;

( . . : . . . . ., 2005. . 41, 42). . . , ,
, ( . .
( ) : . .


,
.
, , , . =84=


1. , . .
/ . . . ., 2001.
2. , . . - : . . - . . ., 1999.
3. , . .

/ . . , . . //
. 1999. 11.
4. : / .
. . . ., 1999.
5. : / .
. . . ., 2005.

3(12)

. . , 2006. . 57, 58).


. . -
, ,
, ()
( . . :
. . . ., 2000. . 52).
,
,

.
. . ,
,

( . .
: .
. . . ., 2007. . 5).

, (.:
. .
// . .
2009. 1. . 7, 8).
.

. , .
. . . ,
, 2009


, , ,
( . .
: , , . , 1989. . 18).
, - .

.

-
. ,
.
, , .
. . ,



( . .
: // . . 2008. 1. . 17).
, ,
,
.
-
- ( . . - //
. 2009. 4. . 3948).
. . , - ,
,

=85=

( . . 48).


, ,
.
. -
, , .
.

, , - , , ,

, .
- . 10 2002 . 7-
. , -
.
, ,
, .
. 1
,
,
,
, ,

, , ( ) (. . 2002. 12 .). =86=

:
( ) , . .
, . , , ,
.

,
,
.


. , ,

: , ( . . . . . 6).
,

,
. ,

.
,
,
- , ,
, ,
.
-

3(12)

,
.

.
,
- ,
. - .

- (). .
,

.
.



.

.
, .


.
,


.
. ( . . , 2009

- // . . 2006. 1 ; . . : . .,
2001. . 151). ,
( :
/ . . . . . . ., 1997. . 180).
,
,

: , , .
. , -,
, ; , , .
,
. .
.

1. , . . / . . // . . 2009. 1.
2. , . . :
/ . . // . . 2008. 1.
3. , . . : , , /
. . . , 1989.
4. , . . ( ) :
. . . . , 2006.
5. , . . : . . . .
., 2007.
=87=

. . ,

-





, , ,
, ,
.

, . , ,
, . .

- ,
,

. , , ,
,
.
,
,
, , , ,
.
,

: , ,

.
=88=

,
, .

,
, , ,
. .
70- . :


.
,

, ,


. ,

, ,
, , ( . . - . ., 1977. . 52).
,
( . . . ., 1982. . 13).

, , ,
, , , , . . .
,
, , -

3(12)

, , ,
, ,
.
, , ; , ; , ;
, ( . .
: , , . ., 1973. . 8).
, ,
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
,


( ) .
, , ,
( . . . . . 9).
, , , , , . , ,


, 2009

,
, .

, .
, , , , , , , ,
, .

,
.
: , , ( . . . . . 27).
,
.

, , (
), , . ,

.
,
=89=

, . . . ,
,
, , , , ( . . . . . 27).
,
, . .
, (, ),

. ,
.
-


:
,
, ,
,
.
.
,
. ,
, ,
.

, , ,
,
.
, ,
=90=

.
,
,

,
, ( . . 28).

, 2039 , . .
(. ).

, %

14
15

16
19

20
24

25
29

30
34

35
39

40
49

50
59

60
79

2,0

8,8

19,2

12,0

18,6

14,7

13,0

5,2

6,5

, ,
(, ,
, ).
,
,
.
-
(, , , .). , , ,
.
- ( .) ,
, .
,
, .

3(12)



, .

,
,

.

, , ,

.
, , , ,
,
.
70- . XX . . .
( . . . . . 69). ,
-
. ,
:
1) ;
2) , ,
;
3) , . .
(
,
);
4) ,
.

.
1. , 2009

.
, ,
,
, (,
, ). (, , (,

).
, ,

,
. , .
2. , , , ,
.

,
( , ).
,
, ,

.
3. , ,
.
,
( , ) . =91=


, (
,
).
, .
, .


,
,
.

-

,
,
, ,
.

. . ,

-

,
, () ,
, ,
()

, ;
, ,
, ( / . . . . . ., 2001. . 821822). (. justice)
,
,
(
. ., 1997. . 347).
, ,
,
, -


, ,

,
.
,

.

, ,
.
=92=


1. , . . - -
/ . . . ., 1977.
2. , . . /
. . . ., 1999.
3. : , , //
. .-. . . 2002.
2.
4. , . . / . . . ., 1982.
5. , . . : , , /
. . . ., 1973.

3(12)

, ,
,

.
, ,
,

, 1135 . ,
1667 .,

.
( . .), ,
,

1667 . 1727 . ( . .
: , , . ., 2006).

1832 . , I 14 1832 . 1917 . ,

75- - , ( . .

( ) // . . . . . 2001. 12).
1920- ., ,
,

.
21 1922 . , 2009

.

3 1931 . 5/298 . ;

,
, .

4 1991 . ( . .
. 1991. 30, . 1013) 5 1992 .
2447/1-1 (. . 2002. 27 ), 15 1992 .,
.
,
, . . , ,
, ,
, . 2
24 2002 . 95- ( . 1992.
16, . 836) :

,
,
, ,
,
, =93=

, , ,
;

;

;
;
;

, .
-


(URL: http://www.arbitr.ru/as/assys/struct.htm).
. , , ,
, ,
.
,
. 81.

,

,
.
20 .
10 ,

,
. .
=94=

, . 127
, ,
.

.


- .
, ,
. , , , ,

(
:
. . . // . .
2002. 19 .).
, 20022006,
20072011 . ,
, , , , ,
.

,
2002 .,
, , .
, -

3(12)

,
,
.
,
, .
, .
,
,

. ,
, :

,
, , ,

.
,

. . ,
85070-4

, 2007 .
:
, , , ,
,

,
,
, 2009

(. 1 . 165.1) ( . .
// . 2008. 3, 4).



, , , .

,
.
,
.
,

, , (
. .
13 2007 ., 15-

. URL: http://www.arbitr.ru/as/assys/15ann/index.htm).
, . , , .
,

. 20 %.

( 2007
2008 :
. . .
. .
=95=


17 . 2008 ., . -. URL:
http://www.arbitr.ru/as/assys/200ann/).

. -,


. -,
. , , , , .
, ,

, ,
. ,

.


. 267


( ).
,
,

. ,

(),
,
. , ,
( ), ,

, , , ,

.
=96=

,


, .
,
, ,
,
.
, ,

.
, (http://www.arbitr.ru) , , .
,
.
, ,
,
.
, 2007 .
713424 . 282981 , . . 40 %
( 2007
2008 ). , , 7080 %, -

3(12)

.

, .
, , (, )
.

, , ,
.

, . ,
,

. -

, ,
,
.



.

. . ,

-

. , ,
.
,
. , ,
,
, ,
.
,

, , ,
,
.

,
, XVIIIXIX . -
,
.
-

- ,

, ,
.
,
, ,
,
,
.

,
. , ,
: , .
19961997 . 200
, 2009


1. : / .
. . . . . 2- ., .
. ., 2003.
2.
// . . 2002.
27 .
3. , . . : , , / . . . ., 2006.
4. , . .

/ . . //
. 2008. 3, 4.

=97=

1
.

. - .
, , , , ,
(), . . ( . .
17981826 . / . . . . .,
1991. . 12).

:
,
,

( . . 304). . .
.
. ,
,
,
, ( : . .
- XVIII
XIX // . . 1998.
2. . 52).

. ,
,
. , ,
,
, ,
.
,
.
( . . - ,

() ,
( .
., 1987. . 30).
=98=

: . ... . .
. ., 2002. . 24).
-
70- . XX . 1979 .

(

. . XLIII. ., 1989. . 99105).


. 1
,
,
( ) ,
, : , , -


.

1987 .
10 1987 .
7352-XI
( .
. 1987. 28, . 437) .
. 206

, ,
-

- .
,
.
. ,
, ,

. , ,

3(12)

.

.
(
: , , :
. ., 1993. . 237).
.

. ,

, .

.

. ,
.
,

( X. (
). ., 1980. . 179). VII . . . ,
( /
. . . , . . ,
. . . ., 1982. . 36). . , 333 .
. . III,
.
. ,
, ( : . .
. . . 99).

,
. . . .

, 2009

.


,
.
,

. , 5 1871 .
, ,
,

, ( :
. ., 1984. . 360).
, XVIIIXIX .,
XX . .
XX .
.
, . . ,
, ,
. ,
,
. 1920 . , ,

.


XX . 1932 .
,
,
.
,
=99=

.
, 1934 .
(),
, ,

.
, .
XX .
. 1930 .,

( 6070- . XX .).

.
, .
16 1941 . 100,
50
.
.
( . . - // . . . .
1993. 3. . 23).
, 5060- . XX . .
, , . , , , ,
, . 6070- . XX .

=100=

, , , , , , . 1975 .

,
1972 .,
.
1990- . - . ,
; ,
, , .




,
.


.
.
.
,
.
17 1998 .
,

. , 7 1998 .
.

- - 14 . .
,
. -

3(12)

. ,

.
,
. ,
,
,
, .
, ,
, . , ,

,

.

. . ,



,

,
.
, :
, , , , . , , -.

, .
,
, ( ), . . ,

,

, , ,
( . . : :
. . . . . ,
2006. . 71).

. . ,
, , -

-


. ,
,

.
, ... ( . . ., 1994. . 7).
, . . ,

( . . . .,
1981. . 2. . 270). ,
, , , , ,


.
, 2009


1. , . . -
XVIII XIX /
. . // . . 1998.
2.
2. , . . -
,
: . ... . .
. ., 2002.
3. , . . :

? / . . // . 1999. 3.

=101=

.
,
, ,
( . . //
: . . /
. . . . . , 2000.
. 1112).

,
(, ,
. .) ,

() .
() .
, , , , ( . . // . . . 2001. 3 (5)).
( , , )

,
,
.
,

, . ,
() .
, .
,
, .
. , . . ,

=102=

( . . // . . -. 11, . 1997. 3. . 6). . .


, , , ,
( . . // . 2001. 11. . 2425).
. . ( : .-. / . . . . ., 2000.
. 9). .
.

, , .
?
,
.
, , . , , . , . , . , . , . ,
, , ,
.

-,
-

3(12)


( X. : . . .
B. C. . ., 1996. . 42, 70).

, , - . ,
.
- , -,
. , , , ,
.
,
: ,
-,
, ,
.

,
,
,
,
.
- , ,
(, , .). ,
,
.
, .
, 2009

(, ) - ( . ., . . . ., 1995. . 749).

,
. , ,
.

,
, , ,
.
, ,
, , .
:
1) ,
; 2)
, ; 3)
,
,
; 4)
, .

. .
( . . . .
. 73). ,
. . , , ...
... =103=

, ,
( . .
//
. 1979. 5. . 48).

: , , ( ),
, ,
(, , ,
. .), , ,
, , ,
(, ,
, .),
, , , , , , , , , , (,
, ) . .

(, , ,
, ,
.). , ,

( : ,
, . / . .
. . . . . ,
1999. . 4257).
.
- ( , , ,
, , ,
. .) ,
.
-
: (,
, , , .) (, , , .).

(, =104=

) ( . . . . . 74).
: ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; .
, . . ( . .
: . . . . .,
2004. . 27), - ,
, , ,
, . (,
) - .
,
( )
( )
.
(, , , . .).

, ,

,
. .

, , , - .

1. , . . : . . . . . , 2006.
2. : .-.
/ . . . .
., 2000.
3. , X.
/ . ; . . .
B. C. . ., 1996.

3(12)

. . ,








,
. , - .
,


.

, -,
- .

;
,

( . . - : . . . . ., 2007).
.
,
.

( . .

// . 2004. 14 .). , , 2009

, .
,
.
, .
, .


14 1954 . (
. ., 1991. . 258281).
. 1
:
a) , ,
, ,
, ,
, ,

,
, , , ,
,
, , ;
b) ,

, . a,
, , , ,
, . a;
c) , ,
. a b,
( . . 319322).
,
=105=

,
, ,
( , , , ,
. .), .
1 , ,
19 1964 . :
,
,
, , , ,
, , , ,
, ( ).
. 1 , ,
14 1970 . ,

,
, , , ... ( . . 283290).

.
. . , ( . .
. ., 1979. . 4).
16 1972 . ( . . 290302). =106=

1 3 : ,
. , , , ,
,
, .

, ,

, .


, , ,
, ,
( , , .
., 1991. . XLV. . 482).



( , , , , , ), , , .

, ,
.
,
,

,
.
1970 . ,

.

3(12)


:
1)
;
2)
,
.
, 14
1970 .
, ( . . . . ., 1987. . 153),
, ,
, :
)
, , , ;
) , ,
, ,
, , ;
) (
) ;
)
;
) 100 , , . ..

- . 7
15 1993 . 4804-1
(. .
1993. 15 ),

,
, . ,
. 1 14 1970 .
: ... ,
, ,
. , 2009

. 164
: , ,
, ,
. ,
,

,
, , ( / .
. . , . . . ., 1999).
. 188
, . ,
(. 78 1960 .) ,

.
,
. . 3 . 44
, . ,

(. 158, 159, 160, 161, 162, 164).

: ,
.
,
.
, 1826 . ,
, . ,
=107=

.
, , XXVIII
, 18 1973 . 3187
( . .

(- ) // . 2000. 1. . 162165).
. I
, ,
, , , .


.
, 1940 .
.
( ).
,
. , : , -,
,
.
, , ,
.

, ,

. , , , .
=108=


.
(
,
)
,

.
,
.
, 1998 .
44
, ,

( ). , 470 , 1933 .
, 120
.
, , , ,
. .

50 60- . XX . , ,
,
.
. 90- . XX .


. ,
1996 . 7700
,
,
, , ,
. .

1998 .
. ,

,
,

3(12)

. , 70- . XX .
XVI .,
1990- . XVIII . . .
,

. ,


( . . .).

25 2002 . 73-
(
) (. . 2002. 29 )
, , , .



, ,
,
,
, , - -


.

, . 221 2006 . (
. 2008. 15 . . 5658).
,

-
.
,
, ,

,
.

. . ,

-


,

. , . 14 12 1995 . 144-
-
(. . 1995. 18 .) ,
- , , . 15 1996 . 145
( -



,
-


, 2009


1. , . .
/ . . . ., 1979.
2. , . . : . . . . ., 2007.
3. , . . /
. // . 2004. 14 .
4. , . .
(- ) / . . //
. 2000. 1.

=109=

. .- ) ,


.

23 1993 . 845
(.
. . 1993. 37, . 3453) . , , , - .
, , . ,
.

( . . 23 . 1999 . 19-99-1. .
.- ). ,
. .
( . . 7 .
2000 . 25-00-1.
. .-
).
,
,
, - .
,
=110=

,
, ( :
. . . .
11 . 1996 . 781-II
// . . .
1996. 49, . 5506), ,
.
: ;
; ; ; - - ;
,
, , ( : .
/ . . . . . 3- .,
. . ., 2005. . 159169 ; . . :
. ., 2006. . 331348 . .).
, ,
- , ,
- - ( ) ,
,
(),
, ()

,
( . . :
. . . ., 2005. . 22).
. . ,


-,

-
( . .
//

3(12)

- : . .
. . , 2005. . 89).
,
,
, . , , , 91 %
, 8 %, 1 %.
. , , ,
, ,

, 1015 . ,

,
-

. ,
,

,
( 78 % ).
, , ,
,
, ,
.
() , ( ,
. .), , , , 2009

, , - , .
,

, , , , , , , . 285

,


.
,
, , , ,

(

: . . 23 . 1992 .
4202-1 // . . . . 1993.
2, . 70).

, ,
,
.
=111=

, ,
, - . , , , - -

,
,
,
,
.
( ) ,

.
,

, , :
, ;
, ;


- , .


, ,
? ,
, =112=

, , .
.


,

13 1997 . 1009,



,
, ,

,
.
,
, , , (. . 1997. 21 .).
,
. ,
4 2007 .
88

, , (, .), ( . 2007.
24 ).



27 2003 . 484 ,

3(12)

( .
.- ). ,
,
, , ,
.
, ,


, , , , , ( . . .) - (. . 2007. 24 ).

, , (
,

: . 27 . 2006 .
630 // . . 2006. 10 . ;

:
6 . 2006 . 311 // .
2006. 18 . .).

,
, , ,
, .
,
,
, ,
, ,
, , 2009

(
- :
.-. . / . . . , . . . ., 1999).
,
.
, , ()
, , .
,
-
, , ,
.

-


. , , - .
,
,
- , -,

- , ,

.
- .
=113=

, ,
.
1. .
, - ; ,
;

- .
2. - .

. 6 .
: ,
- ,
, - -

- ;
,


- ,
.
3. - .

, , - ;
,
,
-
=114=


- , , , ,
368, 185,
164, 481,
32, 184,
97,
147 17 2007 . (. . 2007.
16 ).
4. ,
- .
,
,
- ,
- .
,
() , - ; ,
. .
5. , ,
, . ,


, .
6. - .
.
, , -
, -

3(12)


,
,

.

1. , . . : /
. . . ., 2005.
. . ,

-

,


(: )

(-, .).
,
,
() .
. ,
, : , , . : ;
; ( , ) .

.
, 2009

2. : .
/ . . . . . 3- .,
. . ., 2005.
3. : .-.
. / . . . , . . . ., 1999.
4. , . .
: / . . . ., 2006.
,
. .,
, . , ,


. ,
,
. ,

.
, - .
. 3 . 2 . 133
.


.
-. ,
,
. . . . ,

, =115=


( . . : ,
, .
. ., 1988. . 3763). , . . , ,
,

, , , , , ,
( . .
: ,
.
, 1986. . 77).
, , , , . 4 . 146

. 5 2007 . 87-
-

(. . 2007. 8 ).

, ,

. ,
, , ,
,
.
,
=116=

.
, ,

(. 144 ), , . 25.1
,
. , ,

,
.
(. 84 ).

(. 190 ).
,
. 25.1, 25.2, 25.6 . ,
.
,
, ,
, ,
, ,

(. 1 . 25.1).
, . 4 . 26.4
,
, ,
, .
,
.
: ,
, ?
,
,

3(12)

-
.
,

,
, . ,
,
, , .
, . 30.12
,
.

. , ,


,

.

(. 90 ), . .

12
1995 . 144- - (. . 1995.
18 . ; 2008. 30 .)
.
, 2009

:
.
, ,
.
1.
,
, ,
;
; ,
,

.
, ,

.
2. ,
.
3. ,
.
4.
.

1. , . . : , , .
/ . . . ., 1988.
2. , . . : , / . . . , 1986.
3. . ., 2007.
4. -
. ., 2007.
=117=

. . ,



(-)

(: ) 18 2006 .
230- (. .
. 2006. 52, . 1, . 5496) ()

. . 75
- ,

- .
, (:
) 31 1991 . 2211-1 ( . . 1991. 26,
. 733),
- .


. , -
, . , 1990- .,
,
(). ,
,
=118=

, .
, -
, . -

.

- (

: 13 . 1987 . 49 // .
. 1987.
9, . 40). , - -
, - , ,

( . . () // . . 2001. 7. . 100).

- -. - , ( . . . . ., 1976. . 6);
, , ,

( . . -
// . . 1980.
11. . 53). ,
- , ( . .
- // .
. 1974. 10. . 116117).

3(12)

-
,
.
- ,
, , , -, -
; ;
, ,
; , ,
,
( :
26 .
1979 . 11. ., 1979. :
1979 .). - .

-, ,
-. -,
-
, .
, , , . . -,

-,

. 1979 . -,
: ) ; ) ; ) ,

( . . -

// . . 1981.
11. . 86). :
-, ,
() : ,
, 2009

,
, ?
1990- .,
, , () , . -
,
-
, .
. 151 -,
. ,

.

- ,

. -,
; -,
; -,
. -
. ,

,
.
,
24 1990 . 443-1
(
. .
. 1990. 30, . 416)
- . , -
, .

,
=119=

- ( (-) / . .
[ .]. ., 1994. . 3256).
, ,
- (, , ), .
, -,

; - ,

-, . .
, -
. ,
29 1997 . 13
-, -
- ,
(
. . )

-

. 8 2006 . 64
1-
() ( .
.- ) - , ,
,
. ,
,
30 1994 . 51- (.
. . 1994.
=120=

32, . 3301) (
. 1996. 5, . 410),

.
1 2008 .
,
- . ,
,
-.
.
. 44 (. . 1993.
25 .).

, , ,
,
(. 1225 ).
. 138

, , .
, ,

( :
. 11 1964 . //
. . 1964.
24, . 407 ; :
8 . 1961 . // .
. 1961. 50, . 525 .).


-

3(12)

. ,
:
,

, ( . .
: . 2- . .,
2004. . 19); ,

( . . :
: . - . . .,
1999); , , ( :
/ . . . . . ;
, 2006. . 412) . .
,

, . 1225
,
. ,
,
,

.
. 128 ,
. VII
, (
(-),
. .).
,
.
,
, 2009

( : /
. . . , . . .
4- . ., 2005. . 3. . 109). . , . VIII . 2 ,
14 1967 . (,
. 250 (R).
, 1974) , , , .

24 1994 .,
, , -,
(. . . 1998. 8. . 374).
, . 1225
,
,

. ,
(-) .
,
(-)
, , ,

. ,
, -
.


. , -
.
=121=

( . . :
: . .
. . , 2004. . 58 . ; . . - //
. . 2007. 3 (10). . 1011 ;
. . //
.
2007. 2. . 38 .).
, .
-, . -,
, ,
,
.
,
. 1465 , ().
-,
.
,
-

. 1466
-
. ,
.
-, .

,
. 2 27 2006 .
149- , , (, )
(. . .
2006. 31, . 1, . 3448). ,
=122=

, , ,



( . . . . . 675676). , (,
, , .). , ,
-
,
, .
-, -.
, . ,
-
(
). , . -


.
-, -. ,

.
-,
-
-. , ,
, . . .
-, -

3(12)

.
: ) . 1225

; ) - . 75
VII

; ) ,
,
-,
29 2004 .
98- (. . . 2004. 32,
. 3283).
,
-. . , . 1225
,
-
- .
.

, .

. ,
: -, ,
( . . .
. . 675676); -,
,
( . . . . . 1819);
-, , -
, 2009

( . . ! // .
2003. 5. . 70), . .
, , ,
.
: ) ; ) ; )

; ) ; ) ; ) ; )

; ) . ( . .
:
// .
2006. 6. . 4850 ; . ., . . : // .
. 1991. 12. . 3742 ;
. . .
. . :
. . ., 2005. . 3839).

- , . ,
, , . , , -.
,
().

, , ,
.
, . ,
,
,
( . .
. ., 1972. . 910),
.
=123=

,


. . 1465 , -
- .

( ) - , . .
( ), ( , )

, . 257
5 2000 . 117- (. . . 2000. 32,
. 3340).
, -, , : )
(); )
.
-, -
, ,
. ,

, :
; ; ; . .
( . . ,
- =124=

// . 1999.
12. . 107112).

.

(-) - . , ,


(-).
,
. 75
,
(-). -
, -
.
, , ,
,
. . . 1465
, ,
-,
. 1465 , ,
.

,
(-) , (-)

, .
( ), -
.

3(12)


1. . : [. :
. 24 . 2006 . : (
8 . 2008 .)] // . .
. 2006. 52, . 1, . 5496.
2. , . . :

: .
. . . , 2004.
3. , . . (-) / . . // .
. 2001. 7.
4. , . . : . 2- . ., 2004.

. . ,


,
,
. ,
.

:
1. , (1942
1975 .).
2. - ,
- (: ) (1975 1990 .).
3. - , ,
(1990 1995 .).
4. ()
, , , , - ,

,


.
, ,
,

, ,
, ,
,

, ,
. .
,
( . .,
. .
: . ., 1998).

.
,
. . . 1980- . ( . .,
. //
. , 1982).
, 2009

=125=

( 1995 . ).

. ,
, ( , / . . [ .]. ., 1989).

.
- , , - ,
, . -,
, .
- ,
: ,
,
, ,
, ,
- ,
, , , , ,

,
-,
- =126=


, , .


, ,
, ,
,
, -.
90- . XX .

, , , , , ,
, .

,

, , , (: ). ,
1993 .

(35 ) 7 20 ,
.

- - (
25 . 1993 . 473 - , 30 2003 .
366 -

3(12)

- ),

- ,

, ,
. ,
- ( . )

-
,
.
2003 2008 . ( )

- ().
,
, -,
(95 % ), ,
( 6 %) . , 15
1999 . 1040 1 2000 .

18 .
, ,
, , ,
, ,
.
(20032008 .)
67 , 11 , , 2009

120 ,
95 .


.
. , - ()
. . ,

, ,
,

.
,
.
. ,
. .
,
.
-
1996 . 2000


.
23 1996 .
-
(
16 1996 . 450 =127=

-).
, , , .
, , -
,
,
. ,
, ,
, ,
,
(.: : 6
2006 . 35- ; 31 2001 . 73- - ), , , , , (
29 2005 . 511
-
, 10
2006 . 70 -
)
, -

, . , 2005 2008 .
,
,
45 %, 39 .
,
21 2002 . 1669

- ( )
,
, () , , ,
.

. . ,

-

, . ,
, . , , ,
.
, .



=128=


1. , . . : / . . , . . . ., 1998.
2. , . . / . . ,
. //
. , 1982.
3. , . . , / . . [ .]. ., 1989.

3(12)


,
, ,

. .
: ,
,
.
,
.
,
( .
. ., 1983. . 8).
. .
, ,
: 1. , .
2. , , . 3.
,
, ( . . / .
-. . . .
18- ., . ., 1987. . 585).
. , () .

, , , ( . .
. ., 1996. . 1: . . 76),
. . , .

, .

. .
, 2009

, , :
1)
, . . ()
, ,
. . , ,

( . . . .,
1959. . 285)
;
2) ,
,
.
, - .
,
( . . . . . 77),

(), .


.
60- . . , , , : (. . ), (. ., . . ) . ( . .
( ). ., 1967). , -, , ,

.
. . :

.




=129=


( . . . ., 1970. . 7).
, ()
( ) ()

, ( . . . . . 222256).
,
,
, , ,

( . ., . .,
. . .
, 2004. . 80).

.
.

,
- .

( () )
,
, , . .
(, , , , .)
: .

, .
,
, . =130=

- (, ,
,
,
, .). . .
, , ()
().

(, , ). , ,

( . instructio ),
,
,
, , . . , ( . .
// . .
. -. 2008. 3(8). . 209210).

( )
:
1) (
);
2)
( );
3) ( - ).

(
), , -

3(12)

, ,

. ., . .
, . ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, ,
. ,
28 1995 . 1050,
:
(. . . 1997. 43, . 4987).
. ,
. 4 :
21 :
, ;

24 . .
30
2004 . 111-


(. . 2004. 29) . 1.1
:
, 3 21
, 2009

, , ...;
. 1.3 :
,
13 5 21
, , 3 21
,

.
( ) , , , , . ,
, ,
: ,
,

,
( ., .
. . 25. . 11. . 357). ,

, ,
. . -.
,
, .
, .
,

, ,
, . , ,
, ,

(, =131=

, )
,
- .
, .
- , ,
,
. ,
. , Sanitron :
! 1. . 2. .
, (!) , , , :
;

;
/ ;

, .
, : , -.

, - , , . .
,
, . .
,
,
. =132=


.

( . .
. ., 1981. . 1. . 327, 332333).

-, :
, , ,
(), ( );
,
(
-);
, , ,
, ,
, , ( );
,
( ) .

:
(),
, , ,
, , , . .

, (


),

,
,

,
.
,

3(12)

:

.
, , , ,
( ), , ,
,
. ,
, . .
, , , , .
, ,
,
, . ,


- , . . ,


,
26 2003 . 283, :
, ,

, , , , () , 2009

, ,
, , -

:
(.
. 2003. 29 ). 5 2008 . 379 : 13 2004 .
1314 1.
- . 2. -
. 3.
. . (.
. 2008. 9).
.

1. , . .
. : . . . . .
. , 1992.
2. , . . /
. . . ., 2005.
3. , . . ( ) /
. . . ., 1967.
4. , . . / . . //
. . . -. 2008. 3(8).
5. , . /
. . ., 1983.
6. , . . / . . .
., 1970.
=133=

. . ,


,
. . ,





,
. ,
,
.
identificare ,

( . ,
2006. . 356).
( . . : . 53000 / . . .
. . . 24- ., . ., 2005.
. 1047). , ,
.

. ,
, ,
. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . .

.
,
.

( /
=134=

. . - . ., . . . . ., 1995. . 87).
,


,
. ,

, .
,
,
.


. . ,
, - ,
( . .
.
., 1977. . 14). , , ,


, ( , )
.
,

, ( . . 15).
, ,

.

3(12)


,
.

,


. ,
. . ,
,
( . .
. ., 2003. . 27).
,

, .
, , - ( . ., . .
: .-. . , 1984. . 19).
, , . .

,
( . .
. ., 1969. . 14). ,

, 2009


.
, , , ,
, ,
- , ,


.
, ,

, , ,
, ,
. ,
33621
- ., -
. .,
, . ,

-53.
, .

,
.
, , .,
,
. (
=135=

., , . ).
,
, ,

-53.

, - ., .
, ., , - .
, ,
(
. 1 .
. . 33621
(. 1-43/05), 2005 .).
,
,
,
.

. ( :
. / . - . ,
. . . . ., 1993. . 10).

.
, . , ,
, .
=136=

, -
.
. , ,

, , .
,


, , .

,
, , .

,
, , , .
- .
-
:
, ; ,
; ,
, , .

.
. ,
, -

3(12)


, ,
. , ,
, .


.
,
2008 .
08010102, ,

. , .
, ,
,

. ,
, . ,
,

.
14 , , ,
.

.
,
,
,
,
, , .
6 . , 14
.
, 2009

( . . . .
. 08010102, 2008 .)1.
, ,


, ,

,
,

. - . , - ,
.
,
, , ( . . -
: . . . . , 2007. . 76),
( . .
1


. . , ,
:
, ,
, ( . . . ., 1981. . 12). . .
, ( . . // : . . . . .-. . , 1972.
. 9. . 97).


, ).
=137=


: . .
. . , 2006. . 47) ( . . ,

: . .
. . ., 2005. . 38). , ,
,

.

.
148
,

. , ,
,

. ,

( ;
, ;
; ).
, 98,6 % ,
;
66,2 % . , , ,
,
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
=138=

, .


.
62,1 % .
:
(58,1 %); (45,9 %);
(43,2 %)
(29,7 %). , , .
,

, ,
,
, - , ,
, .
,
:

, ,
(
),

;
,
, , .

3(12)

, ,
,
,
,

.

1. , . . . . ,

-

E :

-

- ,

( +), : , , ( . . . ., 1989. . 2,
. 1. . 507). ,
, , : , ,
, , .


,
, . . .
. ,
,

( . // : . . . , 1965. . 183).
, 2009

: . .
. . , 2006.
2. , . . / . . . ., 2003.
3. , . .
/ . . .
., 1977.
4.

: . / . -
. , . . . . ., 1993.
5. , . . () : / . . . ., 1961.
I,
, - .

.
- - ,

() ( .
. ., 1856. . 127).
I .

,
-
( . . ., 1841. . 64, 66).
, , , . - ,
- .
: , , . =139=

.
I . : ,
( .
. ., 1869.
. 3. . 11).
. . , , , ( . .
. ., 1946. . 105).
. . -
,
,
(- . .
. , 1929. . 45). . .
: ,


( . .
. ., 1968.
. 25). . . ,
,
, , , , , , , ( . .
- . ., 1963).
. . , , , , ,
( . .
. ,
1974. . 29). . . . . =140=

,
( . .,
. . . .,
1965. . 189).
( . .
. .,
1975. . 62 ; . .
. ., 1951. . 56 ; . . . ., 1951. . 88).


. . . ,
( . . . .
., 1968. . 25). . .
,
( . . . . . 6061).
. , . .

( . .
// .
., 1970. . 296). . . ,

,

( . .
. , 1965. . 35).
,

, ,
- -

3(12)


( . .,
1971. . 31 ; . .
. ., 1972.
. 47). , ,
, , - ,

,
. ,
, ,
,
-
( . . . , 1973. . 910).
, .
, -
.

- ,

.
,
, . ,
,
, , .

.

,

: ,
; , 2009

; , ;
.
,
,
, , ,
, , , , ,
( . .
. ., 1995. . 9397).
,

, (
), , .
, ,
, .
,
,
,

1960 . ,
, - .
, ;
( , ,

); .

,
=141=

,
.
,
,
, . (. 16 ),

, ,
, , ,
(. 19 ).

. 15 - . . 3
, .

. . 4 . 15 , .
,
,



.
. 22 . 5
, ,
, . , , ,
, .

. , ,
. 20, 22 , =142=

, . . 100, 171173
,
. , .
,
.
. 40
,
, , . ,
, (. 246 ), . .
.

, ,
, . .
, , .
,
, :
, .
. ,
: .


: ()
, ,
.
,
.
. 1 . 47 , : 1) ; 2)

3(12)

. ,
.
,
,
.
,
,
.

.
,

.
,
. ,

.

, ,
,
.
, .


. (. 6 ).

. . ,
,


, ,

),
()
(
),


. ,
- ,

, (-) . , ,
, , .



, ,
,

, , (,
, 2009


1. , . . / . . .
., 1972.
2. , . / . . .,
1856.
3. , . . /
. . . ., 1946.
4. , . . / . . . ,
1965.
5. -, . .
/ . . -. , 1929.

=143=

( /)
() , . , /, .

( )
.
: ,
( . ., . . . : . ., 2002. . 193).
,
.
,
, , , , . 8 1998 . 14-
(: ), 26 1995 .
208-
(: )

. =144=

, ,

.

,
(),

(. 4 . 2 . 33 ).
, ,
,
,
,

(. 2 . 43 ).
. , ,

,

(
)
(. 8 . 1 . 48 ).

( ) ().
( ) (. 3
. 1 . 69 ). ,
,
,
(, ),

3(12)

,
, .

( ) ,
( )
(. 2 . 3 . 69 ).

. -,
,
. -, ,

(,
),
,
, , , . -, ,
,

,
( )
. -, ,
:
.
. 2 . 53 (: )


. ,
,
,


, ,
.
, ,

,
, 2009

. ,
, , .



.
.
, .
. 2.8 , , 31 2002 .
17/,



,
,
,
. . 3.3

, , ,
, . . . ,
,
, ,
.
,

=145=


. -
,

.
. 1
. 53
, ,
2 % , ( . . . ., 2003).
,
,
. ,
. ,
,

, ,
,
,


.
,

,
. 1 2 . 1 , . 2, 56, 273, 275 (: ),

(
29 2005 .
48-8552/04-9). ,
.
=146=

-
(, ), , ,
,
. , , , . . , , .
,

( . . . .).

, , , . . , , ,
, . .
,
( . . :
: .-. . ., 2006. . 457).
.
,

,

,
,
, .
,

3(12)


, , . ,
, ,
.
, ,

, ,
.
, . , ,
, (, , ),
() ( ).
De lege ferenda .

,
, ,

() .
, ()

,
, .

()
,
, ,

, 2009

, . (),
,

. . , (), , ,
. (), , , , -,
, -,



. ,
, , , , .

,

, ,
.

: , ,

,

.
, ,
, ,
.
=147=




,
,

,
.
, , , ,
.
,

, ,
,
. . ,

-



.

,
.


1864 .
I . - ,
.

, , , . =148=

( . .
. ., 2007.
. 393). , ,

.

1. , . . .
: / . . , . . . ., 2002.
2. , . . / . . . ., 2003.
3. , . . :
: .-. . / . . .
., 2006.
;

;
; . , ,
.
.
20 2004 . 113-

(. . 2004. 25 .) ,

. ,
.
- ,

3(12)

,
,
. , ,
.
,
, ,

, . , ,

.
.
,
: 25 ; ; ;

, ,
,
;
; , ; , .
, ,
, :
,
,
; ,
65 ; ,
, 2009

; ; , , , , ,
,

,
, ,
- , ,
(); .
. 7 . 326 60 ;
,
; ,

; ,
; ,

.
,
, ,
.
,
,
,
. , .
. ,

.

.
. 3
=149=

5 :
.
10 . ,

, , , ,
.
:

,

10 ? 10 ,

. 10- ,

10- .
. 1 . 10

, , , ,
.

, , . 42 .
: ,
, , ;

,
,
;
.
,
=150=

, :





,
.
,


, .
, , , 31 1996 .
1-
(. . 1997. 6 .), 26 1992 . 3132-1 (.
. 1992. 29 ),
20 1995 . 45- ,

(. . 1995. 26 .).
, . ,

,
, .
,
,
, ,
. -

3(12)

.
. 2 . 87
8 1981 .
( . 1981. 28, . 976)

,
, 21
1997 . 118-
(. . 1997. 5 .). , , .
,


(.
3 . 1999 . 226 // . . 1999. 15 .)

.
. . , ,
, , , ,
, ( . . , , // . 2005. 12).
. , ,
, . , ,
, ,
. , (URL: http://www.newtimes.ru).
, .
, 2009

,
,
.

. . ,
, ,
. , . 30 . 5 : , . . 54 . 5 :
, . ,
, , ( . // . . 2006. 1). ,
. ,

,
.
. 30 . 5
:
,
,
.


(. 2 . 333 ) .


, , , .
=151=

.
. , , , ,
, ,
, ,
( . : // . . 2006. 9. . 47).
,
, ,
,
,
. ,

, ,
, . 8 . 335 .
,
:

, . 118
.
. ,
,
, -


, ?!
, ,
( .
// . . 2006. 1).

1 12 . . , ,


. ,

,
.

. . ,


, , , ( . . . , 2007. . 51).
.




=152=


1. , .
/
. // . . 2006. 1.
2. , . .
, , / . . //
. 2005. 12.
3. : /
. . . . ., 2006.
4. :
: . .
. / . . , . . ,
. . [ .] ; . . . . ., 2004.

3(12)

, , ,
- ( . ., . .
(
). , 2003. . 82).
,

(

(. 23
), (
() () ,


) ( . .
// . . . 2007. 2. . 101).
,
( . .
// . . 1993. 3. . 71).

,

.


,
,
, 2009


( . ., . .
. ., 2003. . 121). . 35
: , ,
( ).
,

.
( )
. 210 .
. , ( ) (. 210 ) , ( .
( ) // . .
2007. 3. . 16).

,
.

,
, ,

. ,


, ( . . ,

// .
. 2006. 12. . 34).
. . 3 . 111

=153=

, ,
.
,
, ,
. ,
, , ,
, , ,
.
,
. . 3 . 111
. 4 ( . . 35).
. . 256, 258, 260

,
. . 3 . 256 . 2 . 258

.
() , ,
( . . 36).
,


,
=154=


( . 273 ,
). ,
, -
,
.


. , . 126, 127

.
.

,
, . ,

. . . -, ,
(- . .
. .
., 1998. . 162). ,
, , , .
-

3(12)


.
, ,
,
.
:
( .
. 163).
.


1. , . .
/
. . , . . . .,
2003.
2. , . .
, / . . // . .
2006. 12.
3. -, . . . / . . -. ., 1998.
4. , . . / . . . , 2007.

. . ,

-


, ( : . 10 . 2007 . 1495 //
. . .
2007. 47, . 5749).

, ( : . 28 1998 . 53- //
. . 1998. 20 ).
, ,
,
, , , , , 29 2005 .
39/1070/1021/253/780/353/399
(. . 2006. 25 .)
, 1 %
, 15 .
( 2008 .
., 2009).
- . ( )

. 59


. , ,
,
.

,
. , , ,
27 1998 . 76- (. . 1998. 2 ),
,
,
, 2009

=155=


.
7 2007 . , 1 2007 . 1004
(. . . 2007. 32, . 4122)

,


. .

- ,
, .
, .
7 2007 .
- (. 151152 ) ,
( , ) .
,
, , ,
, , , ,
,
, , , =156=


,
,
, ()
-

. 151 152 , ,
.
, ,
21 2002 . 4/27
. 126 (.
2002. 2), 21 2003 . 55
(.
. . . 2003. 2).

,
,
,
.
, ,
.
. ,
, ,
,
.
,

, . ,
-

.

3(12)



31 1995 . 8
.

,
(. . . . 1995.
12).
, . . 7 2007 ., ,
(. 8 . 151 ), ,
, .
29 2008 .
14/49

( . .- ). 2


. .
,

17 2008 . 33
(
. .- ) ,

, .
,

, ,
, 2009

,
, , ,
, ,

.
,
.

.
- ,
- , ,

. ,

. . . ,
. . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . ,
. . , . .
,
.

,
.
,
.
,


. 152 ,
,

=157=

-
,

( ,
.). ,
,

.
,

, , - ,
.

.



.


.
,
,

, .
. 151 152 , , ,

.

. . ,

-



,

6 2003 .
131-) (. .
. 2003. 40, . 3822), ,

( . ., . .
: .
., 2006 ; . .
,
-

6 2003 . 131- (:
=158=


1. :
. .
. . 21
2003 . 55 // . . .
. . 2003. 2.
2.

: . . 29 . 2008 . 14/49.
.- .
3. :
.
. 17
2008 . 33. .-
.
4.
:
1 . 2007 . 1004 // . . . 2007. 32,
. 4122.

3(12)


(
) //
. 2007. 7 ; . ., . . : ,
: . ,
. ., 2004).
6
2003 . 131-
1 2009 ., , . 12
.
, , 6 2003 . 131-, , , , ( ),
, ,
. 11,5 .
, 6
2003 . 131-, ,
1 2008 . 24136
( - 6 2003 131-
2007 // . .
. . 2008. 12),
()
, . . ,
( . .

// . 2007. 18).
, 2009

40


( . . // . 2008. 2). , , , ,
127
2007 . () 80 . .
, 6 2003 .
131- 1 2009 .
,
.
-, ,
.
-, 1 2009 .
6 2003 . 131- , , . 83 6 2003 . 131-



. ,
23 2005 . 168-


(. . 2005. 365366)
1 2008 .
26 (
=159=

), 1 2009 .
80 ( ). ,

,

16
.
,
.
-, ,
8 2007 .
260-
(. . . 2007. 46, . 5556),
1 2009 .,

(: ). ( :
. 29 .
2000 . 904 // . 2000. 49,
. 4826), ,




()
, ,
.


=160=

,

() , , , .
, ,
, , -
.
. 1 . 43 6 131-
:
1) ,
, ( );
2)

;
3)
, ,
,

.
,
,
,

.
,
,

( . . // . . . 2006. 5).

, -

3(12)

. . ( . .,
. . . .):
1) :
( , ( .
// . 2005. 1 ; . .
: .-. . ., 2001) ,
( );
2) : , ():
) ( );
)
.
,
,
, . 37
. 43 6
2003 . 131-, , :
,
, , ,
,
,
,


;

,

, ,
, , ,
, 2009

, ;
(
,
);
,
, , ,
,
, ,
,

(
);


,

.

, -
()
;
3) :
) . ,

, ,
, ;
) ()
.
,
=161=


( . ., . . : //
. 2007. 5),


;
4)
: , :
) ;
) ,
;
)
.

,
, ,
(,
, . .)

( ), () , ,
. ( . . . .).
, 6
2003 . 131- (
, )
, ,

. ,
.
,
,
, ;
=162=

5) :
) ,
(,

,
);
) ,
.

.
, ,


.
-, .
. . ,
,
. ( . .
. .).
,

,
.
-,

,
, ,
, ,
-


.
. 1 . 34, . 7 . 43, . 6 . 1 . 44
6 2003 .
131-.
-, . 2
6 2003 . 131-

3(12)

() .
, , ,

,
.

1. , . .
: / . . , . . . ., 2006.
2. : . [ 6 . 2003 .

, 2009

131-] // . .
. 2003. 40, . 3822.
3. , . . :
/ . . , . . //
. 2007. 5.
4. , . .

/ . . //
. 2007. 18.
5. , . .
,
(
) / . . //
. 2007. 7.

=163=



. . ,


,


(19411945 .)



. , , .
.
1941 .
1 339 702 .,
67,4 % ; 1942 .
1 396 810 . 69,3 % . .
22 1941 . 1 1944 .
1 800 . , 2 900 . ( , 125 / .
. . . ., 2004. . 127).

- (: ). , -
, 1942 .
- (
, ).
, , =164=

,

. . ,
,


. ( . ., . ., . . : . . .,
2005. . 232).

. , ( .
. 3. . 1. . 125 ; . 1/4. . 94).
.

16
- (: ),
( . . 3. . 1. . 157).
1941 .

, ,
( . . 158).
,
, - - .
750 .
,
. 19411942 .
1 2 ( ., . ,

3(12)

19411945 // . 1991. 8. . 4143).


, , ,

. , 34 200 ,
1 308 , 5060
.
300 , 14 . (. . 9413.
. 1. . 23. . 130131).

,

. , ( . .
, . .,
1999. . 232233).

. , , , , ,

. . .
1 1942 .
3 20 1941 .
. 3 879 . 1941 .
2 .
899 ., 404 495 .
: 50 % ,
.
,
( . . . . . 233).
, 2009

,
-

,
.


, , , , .
10 % , 20
25 % ,
30 40 % - 60 80 %
(. . 9412. . 1.
. 19. . 93, .).
, , , (-
. ., 1989. . 447). ,
1942 . :
57 . (0,34 % );
48 . (0,25 %); 38 .
(0,20 %) (. . 9412. . 1. . 19. . 94).
,
,
23
1942 . 355
.

- .
,
, 600 .
.
,
. , , , , .
=165=

, , .
,

. ,
,
;
, , . ,
.
,
( . . , : . ... .
. . , 2005. . 190).

-
. , ,
, , . , , . , ,
, . 1942 . ,

. .
-
,
27 . ( . . 204205).

.
=166=

. ,
1941 . 100 997 .;
1942 . 248 877; 1943 . 166 967.
621 637 , 1934 1947 .
963 766 ( . : //
. 1989. 45). : 1939 .
0,25 %; 1940 . 0,1 %; 1941 . 0,21 %;
1942 . 1 %; 1943 . 0,8 % (
: . .,
1995. . 177).
, ,
. ,
.


, , , (.
. 9401. . 1. . 107. . 112112, .).

-
, ,
, - . 9 1941 .
-.

- - ,
. - -

3(12)

.

.
, , .

.

.
, , ,
,
,
.

.
. .

.
. 19411945 .
- .
,
, ( . . , 1917 1960- . (- ) : .
... - . . , 1998.
. 227228).
,
320 .
., - 171 .,
, 2009

448 .,

268 .,
200 . 350 ,
640.
350 225 .
( . .
19231953 .
( ) // . . 1992. 2. . 27). 34 %, 25 %, 11 %, , - 30 % ( . . 28).

: (,
, , ), ,
.

, , ,
: 1944 .
, .
,
1940 . : 35,6 %,
25,2 %, 15,6 %, 23,1 %.
1942 . :
19,2 %,
17 %, 38,3 %,
25,5 % ( ., .
. . . 4243).
,
( ) (20 .), .
(29 .), (40 .),
(7 .) ( . . . . . 114).


,
=167=

.

- , . .
, .
(3 1942 .)
: 266 .,
461 ., 422 ., 100 % 4 .
78 . (
, , ).

( 1942 .) 116 %.

,
, ,
.

. , 1153
384 .

.
( . . . . . 115).
. . , , , . , ,
,
. ,

=168=


( . . . . . 227228).


,
.

.
1944 . .
1944 . , .
,
,
150 . , . ,
.
, ,
.
, . , , ,
, ,
.

.
,
, .
: . ,
( ., . // .
2005. 1. . 3637).
,

. , .

3(12)

.
1945 .
. ,

.
-.
. . ,
.
.
. .
, , . , , ,
( ., . . . . 37).
,
. . ,

82 .


1
19201935 .

,
, ,
, , .
,

.
1

,
1920- . ,
1929 . , 1934 .
, ,
.
,

1920 .,
1935 .
, 2009

-
- .

1. , . . , / . . . ., 1999.
2. , . . , : . ... .
. . , 2005.
3. , . . , 1917
1960- . (- ) : . ... - . . , 1998.
4. -
,
125 / . . . . ., 2004.
, ,
, , ,
. , , 64 %

( . // .
1923. 1. . 40). ,

, , , , .

.
, , ,
.
, , 1920
1935 . - =169=

. , .
. , 1920 ., 1913 .,
, 1916 . 38,5 % ( , . .
. 24.05 02.07.1920. ., 1922. . 19),
.

1921 . ,
.
:
1920 . (: )
12 500 ,
. 1921 ., ,
32 585 ( (: ). . -56.
. 1. . 585. . 35).
, 1921 .

, ,
. ,
1921 .
, . , , , ,
,
.
, , , , .
. - ,
, , , .
, - ,
.
1920- .
. =170=

. ,
, ,
.

. , , , , , , ,
(, , ,
. .). ,

, , .
,
.
, .

, . ,
1921 ., ,
,
. , , .
, 90 %

( . . : .
-
.
. ., 1924. . 8).
,
, .
, ,
25 %, 40 % ,
34 % , 4,8 %
( . // .
1923. 5. . 160). ,
, -

3(12)

, . - . ,
, .


. , , .
,
.
: , ,
. , ,
, . ,
. . ,
,
, .
, , , . .

: 14 18 .

,
,
. ,
,
, .
,
, . , ,
, ,
.
, ,
, 2009

. , ,
. , .
,
.

:
14 28 % , 1416 32 %, 1618 41 %
( . . . .,
1925. . 160).

,

1929 .
, : 810
18 , 11 12, 12 30, 13
24, 14 49 (. . -3485.
. 1. . 252. . 75 .).



. 45
, . , ,
6 % ( 3,
. . . 793. . 1. . 340. . 44.). 1418

, ,
.
.

1315 . ,

.
1929 . ,

. , =171=

,
: 1 53 , 2
51 , 3 32, 4 16, 5
7, 6 5, 9 4, 11 1, 13 2,
17 1, 21 1 (.
. -3485. . 1. . 252. . 76).

, 70 % 50 % , 14 , , ( : . .
. . ., 1926.
. 14). , .
, . ,
. ,
.


.
, 1932 . 1 698, 160 (. . -169. . 1.
. 136. . 71).
.
,
,
. ,
100
81 - ,

.
, . 1927 .

- 28 960 . 30 000 (
1928/1929 :
=172=

1927/1928 . . . ; ., 1929. . 45). .


19241925 .
21,6 % (
1925/1926
. . ; ., 1927. . 64).
.
,
,
. , :
, , , , ,
, ,
, , ,
, , , , , , , .
7585 %
(. . -120. . 8.
. 63. . 58.).
91 % (
. . 13) (, ,
, ).
.

,
, , .
.
1924 . : , , .
, . ,
, , .
, 1929 .,
109
, 57, 7
(. . -3485. . 1. . 252. . 78).


( , -
.), 1927 .

3(12)

7 055 ( 1928/1929
. . 45).
. ,

,
( 90 %) (.
. -169. . 1. . 52. . 4).
.

, .
, , ,
. .
200 ,
.
.
. ,
, .
,
. ,

,
.
. 50 % , (

. . -1575. . 10.
. 228. . 12). ,
,

, .
.
, ,

. .
. , ,
,
, , ,


, .

. . ,


.



.

.


:
2009 .

155- ,
, 2009


1.
: . . .
. ., 1926.
2. ,
. . . 24.05 02.07.1920. ., 1922.
3. , . . /
. . . ., 1925.
4. , . / . //
. 1923. 5.

=173=

.
,

. XIX .
, . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . ,
. . , . . , . . ,
. . , . . , . .
, . . , . . , .
,
,
.
2009 .,
:
190 , ,
, ,
, , ,
;
170 , . .
. . , , ,

;
155 ,

,
,
,
;
140 , , ,

,
.
,
,
=174=

.
, . ,
, .
. . , , 1 1819 .
2- 1834 . , 1841 . .
.
1844 . . .

. 1845 .
( . . . . // . . . . -.
, 1956. . 116, . 13. . 1920). . . 1846 .
1848 . , , 1852 . .
,
. . . 1855 .

.
, , ,
: ,
( .
. . 18191856: . . // . . . .,
1914). . . ,
, :
, , ( . .
. . (18601916) // . . . 1917. 3(5). . 10). --

3(12)

, . . , , ,
( . . (1804
1917 .) // . . . -. , 1956.
. 116, . 13. . 41).
. . 1839 .
( . .
(16471917). .,
2005. . 429),

, 1860 .
( . . . . . 43).
. . . 1864 . . .
, 1865 . - .

. 1874 .
. . .
1884 ., 1885 . .

. .
. . ,
( . . . . . 11).
, . .
: ,



( . . . . . 45).
,
, 1854 .
, 2009

. , 1873 . ,
1875 . 1878 .
,
. 1880 .
. .

. 1882 .


. , 1883 . . 1883 1884 .
. . . 1884 .
. 1885 .

,
( . . . . 435437).
. .
1869 .

. 1911 .
-
, 1913 .
.
1914 . , ( 1918 .) .
1923 ., ( . . . , 1914. . 247).
. .
, ,
,
.
=175=


,
,
.
XIX .

, (. . , . . ,
. . , . . , . . ,
. . ), -
(. . , . . , . . , . . , . . ,
. . ,
. . ,
. . , . . , . . ) (. . , . . , . . ,
. , . . , . . , . . , . . , . . ).


(. . , . . )
(. . ).
(. . ,
. . ).
,
(. . ).
(. . ).


-.
(. . ). ,

(. . ,
. . , . . , . . ).
(. . , . . , . . ).
(. . , . . ).


=176=

,
. .
(. . ,
. . , . ).
,
(. . , . . ).


(. . , . . . ).
. .
.
, . . , . . , . .
. .
.
,
. . , , ,
. , . . ,

:
( )
(
) ( . . . . . 597).
, , . .
. , : statuta
personalia, statuta realia, statuta mixta ( . . (-

3(12)

. . ). . ,
1858. . I. . 56),
.
, locus regit
actum, , , , , ;
,
( . . 62).
. . ,
: , , ,
( ).

,
,

( . . . , 1855. . 512).


. . , . . ,

. ,
,
.
, ,
( . . , 2009

// . . . -. , 1865. . I.
. 136138),
. . . , . .
,
,
,
(
. . 151). (
) , . . , ,
( . . 152). : ,

( .
. 141).
.
. . .
: () , , ,
( . .
. , 1900. . 5, 6). . .
, (

), ,

, :
( .
. , 1889. . I.
. 61). ,
, ,

, =177=

,
( .
. . 111, 113).
,

, . . .
(. . ).
. . . , ,

. . .
. . , . . ,

( . . . 1. , , ?
., 1916. . 13). , , ( ).
,
, . . ,
;
(
). , : , ; -,
( . . 21).

, . . : , . . , -

=178=

, ( . . 23).
, :
, .

, ,
, ,
( . . 2425).
, , ,
. . .
. . .
,
, ,

,
,
.

1. , . .
(16471917) / . . . ., 2005.
2. , . . / . . //
. . . -. , 1865. . I.
3. , . .
/ . . . ., 1914.
4. , . . . 1.
, , ? / . . . ., 1916.
5. , . .
/ . . .
, 1900.

3(12)

. . ,


,

,
.
, , .


;
.
,
,
( /
. . . , . . .
., 1983. . 650).
(- )
- ,
.
- : .

, , .

() ,
XIX .
, ( , 2009

),
( . .
. ., 2007. . 15).

. ,
, ,
,
.
, , ( . . 17).
,
.
, , ,
, , : , , , .
( : . . ; ., 2008 ; . . : , , // . 2004. 1 ;
., - . . ., 1996 ;
. . . ., 2007 ; . .,
. . (, , ,
). ., 1998 .).


,
, - ,
.
(: ) (. . .
1996. 10)
=179=

(. 245), (. 246),
(. 247)

(. 249)
: ) ,
; )
,
, ,

() ,
,
; )
, ;
) ,
(
), ,

( ).
, , , , . .
.

, , , ,
, ,
,

.
,
(., 2001)
. -,
. 180
;
-,
: , . 182 , .
(,
2004)
=180=

. , ,
,
,
,
(. 182 ). , .
. 170
(., 2002).
. 181
(., 2002) ,

,
.
(. 181) (, 2005).
. 208 (, 2008), . 250
(., 2001) . 165
(., 2001) ,
,
.
,

(. 186) ,
. 208 ,

. , , . 214 ,
, , ,
.
. - , -

3(12)

,
. -, . -, . . 189 (, 2002)
,


,

,
.
, , , . .
, ,

, , , ,
, . , ,
(. c . 2
. 193 ).
, ,

(URL: http://law.edu.ru/norm/norm.asp?norm
ID=1243122&subID=100105882)
,
, , . XXII
(. 273),
. XVIII (. 267) . XI
(. 289).

, 2009

,
,
.

: , (. 189 ).
, ,
, .

(-, , , , ) ( : . . /
. . . . . ., 2000. . 111).
,
- ,

, :
1)
;
2)
, , , .


- . , -
, ,
.

,
, .
=181=

, (.,
2001) . 2 . 198
:
, ,
-
.
,
, ,

.
,
, , ,
,
. , . 213 : ,
, .
,
(. 1 . 2 ).

, . , . 214,

,
.


(

. 346 ).
, ,
,
,
. .
.
=182=



(., 2001). , 1 . 280

, , ,
(. 281).

,

. , . 282



( ), (
, ).
( 3 . 289).
, 12 . 115, ,
, 1 . 190,
.

: , . 190, ,
1.

, .
1

: ,
, ,
, ,
.

3(12)

,
. , 281
(., 2001) :
1) , , , , ;
2) ,
,
.
, ,
( 288 ).
. 195 (., 2002). ,
, ,
.

, : (. 181).

(., 2005) (
() . 402;
. 404).

: ) , (. 427),
) , (. 428). ,
. , , . , . 428 :
, , , , ,
,
, , 2009

,
,
.
.
, . .
. ,

, . .
,
(
: . . //
- / . .
. . , . . . ., 1988.
. 143 ; . .
.
, 1982 .).
(., 1998)
, (. 238, 239, 242). . ,
-
,

.
. 3 . 242, :
, .
, ,
,
.

( 267 (, 2003)),
.
=183=

(., 2000)
(. b . 2 244, . c . 1
250 .).
( 249 .), ( 240 .).

(. 140
(., 2000)) (. 156 ).
(., 2002), ,
,
,
. , , . .
. . 5 . 651
. 652

(., 2008) . ,




,
(. 669).
(,
) ,
.
(., 2001), ,
, ,

(. 175).
,
(. 176).
, (. 183
=184=

) . , ,

. ,
, , ,
( , , . .), .
(., 2001)

, (. 140 141),
: ,
,
(. 142 ).
,
(., 2007),

. . 349

,

,
.
350 .
:
1)
,
, ;
2)
,
(. 351).
,
, . -,

.
(., 2003)
-

3(12)

. . II . VI
,
(
)
, . , . 165 166
,
, ,
. 90 91 (
,
,
.).
.

. 168 169
: , .
,
.
, , , ,
,
, . , (. 119, 125, 125/2,
127/3, 130),
(. 126, 127,
127/3); (. 1 . 142).
(. 1 . 149/2),

(. 3 . 149/2), - -
(. . 2 . 149/3), , -
(. . 2 . 149/3) . , (. 2 . 149/2, . 1 . 149/3).
, 2009

(., 2002). , . 1 . 132.2


,
(ii)

.
, (.,
2005) ,
(. 336).
, ,
(. 337339 ) -: ,

( , , , , ),
( ).
(., 2003) . , . 494 : ...
: 1)
,

,
, . ,

.

(. 495
496), ,
(. 498).
. 197 . ,
, - , ,
. , .
- (, ,
.) , =185=

. , (,
1999) ,
,
(. 263) (. 274).
,
( . 236 (, 2000), ,
.
(., 2004)
(. 350),
(. 331-2)

. . 335, ,
(,
).
. 249
:
,
. .
, ,
,

.
,
. 32 , ,
. (. 222) :
, ,
, , , . (. 223) , ,
,
.
,
-

:
=186=

1.
, , , . . .
2. :
) ,
, ,
(. 182);
)
,
(. 189);
)
(. 65); , (. 189);
)
(. 197).
3.

, ,

.

1. // . . . 1996. 10.
2. : . . / . . . . . .,
2000.
3. , . . / . . . ., 2007.

3(12)

. . ,

-





, 1960- .
.
, , , .

privacy ()
,
, , .
privacy
.
(OECD), , ,
( ), .

privacy

(
(ETS 108),
. 28 . 1981 . //
, 2009

.
., 1998. . 106114).
.
, ( ).


( . . - : . . .
. ., 2006. . 169).

, , , , ,

,
.
/
( . .
. . ., 1999. . 119). . 1(3)
, ,
,
. . 4 78-17
,

,
, , , , , .
, =187=

, ,
.
, , ,
, .
, , ,

, , , , .
,
,
,
, , , , , .
:
, . .
, , , ( . . :
// . 2001.
8. . 113).
, , , , .
2005 .
, (23),

(, , ,
, . .). =188=

( . .
( ). (
). ., 2003. . 252). ,
, -
, ,
, , ,
, . . ,

, .
,
, , .
(Evoluation Criteria for IT Security ICO I IEC 15408 1,2,3 1999\E), , , , , , .
,
( . ,
// . . -. .
2003. 2. . 36), ,
.
. 1978 . (
-

3(12)

(ETS 100),
. 15 1978 . //
. ., 1988. . 362369).
.

,
,
.


, 24 1999 ., (

. URL: http://www.pravoteka.ru).

,
,
,
.


, , :
1. , .
2. , , 2009

,
.
3. , ,

.
4.
.
,
, ( ).
5.
, , .
,
-

, ,
,
,
, ,

- , .

1. , . . :
/
. . // . 2001.
8.
2. , . . - : . . . . .
., 2006.
3. , . . : . /
. . . ., 2004.
=189=

, ,

. .,
,
E-mail: olegan80@mail.ru
(19411945 .)
- , ,

, . , -
. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
,
, , ,
, ,


,
. ,
, ,
, , ,
. .,
,
E-mail: academy@bk.ru
. .,

E-mail: tula@mosu-mvd.com

; ; ;
;

, .

..,

E-mail: akdm@jin.mvd.ru

, , , , , , ,

,
. , - ,

,
,

. .,
-

E-mail: irgolovinskaya@yandex.ru
:
, , ,
, ,

=190=

Ashin . .,
the head of the Department of Criminal Law and Process Vladimir
State University candidate of law, assistant professor
Peculiarities of execution imprison punishment regard
for juveniles (19411945)
re-education policy in juvenile justice, imprisonment, Great Patriotic
War
This article is devoted to the peculiarities of punishment to imprisonment in juvenile justice, stemming from the Great Patriotic War.
Some aspects of re-employment policy, regulatory juveniles serving
sentences of correctional institutions
Bavykin D. Y.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Theoretical aspects of criminalistic characteristics of terrorism
acts, were committed by explosion
terrorism, criminal explosion, criminalistic characteristic, methods of
commission of crime, criminal personality, crime investigation
The article is devoted to the examination of the elements of the
criminalistic characteristics of terrorist orientated crimes committed
by the explosion. The author presented, on the basis of analysis of
theoretical and legal sources connected with the problematic of the
research, the modern features of typical investigation situations that
appear during investigation of terrorist orientated crimes, methods of
commission of crime, criminal personality and typical victims of
crimes committed by the explosion, and also the objects of encroachment and other conditions
Volynsky A. F.,
professor of Forensic Studies Department of Academy for Economic security of Ministry for Interior of Russia, doctor of law, professor
Tishutina I. V.,
assistant-professor of Forensic Studies Department Tulas Branch Moscow
University of Ministry for Interior of Russia, candidate of law
Some problems of social functions of Criminalistics
social functions, criminalistics, forensic support, criminality, detection and solving crimes
The paper is devoted to the forms of display and realizations trends
of criminalistics social functions, their correlation with forensic support and dependence of their realization from criminalistics theory
and practice. The authors their attention to the necessity to take into
account the influence of objective and subjective reasons on the development and possible forms of realization criminalistics social
functions
Galimov S. A.,
adjunct of faculty of management of bodies of investigation of
crimes Academies of management MBD of Russia
Features of interrogation tactics in the investigation of crimes
against pro-life police officers
preliminary investigation, tactics of investigative action, accusation,
militiaman, witness, victim, suspected person, victimness
The article examines tactical methods of the process of interrogation
on criminal cases, connected with some inquiries of the encroachments on lives of militiamen. The author, on the base of the study of
theoretical sources, criminal and procedural criminal legislation,
study of the practical activity of law enforcement agencies concerning solving and inquiry of this category of crimes, the author represented features of interrogation of various members of the criminal
procedure, which are typical to up-to-date criminogenic situation in
Russia
Golovinskaya I. V.,
head of the Department of socio-economic disciplines Vladimir Law
Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia,
doctor of law
Expansion of the special proceedings in the domestic criminal
process: the pre-agreement about cooperation
judicial decision, pre-trial agreement, the defendant, prosecutor, defender, personal safety

3(12)

40
. .,

E-mail: Gulyagin-prok@yandex.ru


, ,
, . , , : ,
,
, -,
. .,
82
.
E-mail: irina-egorkova@mail.ru
19201935 .
, ,
19201935 .

. .,

,
E-mail: emelyanov@vui.vladinfo.ru
- :
- , , , ,

. . ,

. ,

-, ..
. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru


, , , , ,
, , , ,
- , .

, .
. .,


E-mail: president@utmn.ru

, , , ,
,
, . , ,
,
, , ,
. ,
.

, 2009

The paper is devoted to supplementing the Code of Criminal Procedure RF by the new chapter 40.1 A special order of the court decision at the conclusion of the pre-trial agreement of cooperation
Gulyagin A. Y.,
the Deputy of the Vladimir region Prosecutor, candidate of law
The problems of coordinate activity to struggle against the
crimes on a stage of federals accounts
prosecutor, coordinate activity, federal account
The article uncovers issues of coordinate activity to struggle against
the crimes on a stage of federal account. Marks two important, as author see, problems: first, its necessity to introduce changings into
the legislation; second, its offer the mechanism of improvement effectiveness of that activity

Egorkova I. A.,
the teacher of a history and society of knowledge MOY Lyceum
82 of Nizhniy Novgorod
General characteristics of juvenile delinquency in Nizhni Novgorod province in 19201935
childrens criminality, homelessness, indifference
In the article on the base of archive documents the childrens criminality in Nizhegorodskiy region in 19201935 years in analyzed. As
the main reason of childrens criminality the author considers homelessness and indifference
Emelyanov S. N.,
Chief of Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Execution of Sentences of the Russian Federation
candidate of Pedagogic, assistant professor
Russian penal system: search for ideological principles
The Penal System, punitive politics, purposes of criminal punishment, correction of a criminals personal qualities, social adaptation
of convicts
The paper is devoted to the analysis of the ideological principles of
the Russian penal politics. The author studies the purposes of criminal penalty how they were realized by the Russian State beginning
from the ancient age up to the modern times. Researching into the
legislative acts and the Law enforcement the author argues that the
priorities of penal politics depend on the internal political course and
reflect the substance of the State system. The article describes the
evolution of the Russian States penal ideology from its repressive
forms to the penitentiary principles.
Yerokhina Y. Y.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
The new ways to the descision of collections in the institute of
guarantees and compensations
guarantees, compensations,, mission, employee, employer, business
trip, urgent labour contract, pensioneer, relief, labour contract
The article is devoted to the problems of the institutes of guarantees
and compensations in the social labour spheare and to the possible
ways of their decision. Removing the collision in the institute of
guarantees and compensations by adding the complements to some
articles in the Labour Code of the R. F. Is the attempt of harmonisation of the Labour Code and its perfection and efficacy
Esipov A. V.,
the post-graduate student of chair of criminal law and criminology
Tyumen state university
Challenges skills actions of other accomplices in the voluntary
refusal artist
Problems of qualification of crimes, the criminal liability, partnership in a crime, voluntary refusal, differentiation of the criminal liability, responsibility of accomplices
This article represents the actual research possessing the certain theoretical and practical importance. Considering the raised public danger
of the crimes made in partnership, their considerable prevalence that
causes an establishment of more strict sanctions for the persons committing a crime in partnership, and also increase of efficiency of struggle against the organized crime, special value gets a correct establishment of limits of responsibility of accomplices of a crime in a case the
executor of a crime up to the end. Unfortunately, by present time it is
not generated uniform experts and the uniform
theoretical position on the given question is not developed. In this con-

=191=

,
. .,


E-mail: president@utmn.ru
,

, , , , ,
.
.
, ,
- .
, ,
.

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
- ,
, ,
- , - , - , - , -

- , -
- .
, , , - .
- . -
-
. .,


E-mail: lawsfu@mail.ru

()
, , , ,
, , ,
,
, . 27 2007
, ,
,
, , . .
..
51,

().
. .,
.
E-mail: istra05@mail.ru

, , , ,

=192=

nection, there is a sharp necessity for legislative fastening of rules of


qualification of actions of other accomplices in case of voluntary refusal of the executor of crime fulfillment
Esipova I. V.,
the post-graduate student of chair of criminal law and criminology
Tyumen state university
On account when sentencing the person who committed the
crime in a group
punishment appointment, the person guilty, partnership, principles of
appointment of punishment, punishment individualization, responsibility of accomplices
As one of obligatory criteria of the general beginnings of appointment of
punishment the account acts at appointment of punishment of the person of
the guilty. Special value has studying of a direction of influence of the given
sign on punishment appointment at fulfillment of group crimes. Appointment as punishment court at fulfillment of group crimes taking into account
data about the persons of the defendant based on objective and subjective
signs allows to realise private-precautionary influence of punishment. It can
promote the decision of problems of increase of efficiency of practice of application of norms of the law, perfection of counteraction of criminality,
maintenance of realisation of a principle of humanism. The theoretical material is illustrated by judiciary practice materials
Efarov M. H.,
adjunct the department of scientific personnel training of Vladimir
Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of
Russia
The concept and characteristics of property crimes, committed
in penal institutions
criminalitys characteristics, operative-investigation characteristics,
operative-tactical characteristics, signs of crime, legacy in jurisprudence characteristics
This article goals the formation of unique notional apparatus for the determination of the operative-criminal characteristics of such kind of
crimes as thefts of material wares valued on the objects and institutions of
criminal-penitentiary system. In the article there are points of view of different scientists on the topic of notation of criminology and criminalistics;
legacy in jurisprudence, operative-tactical characteristics of crimes. According to the basis of studying the special literature, the author offers his
own Holton of operative-criminal investigation characteristics for the
sphere of thefts of material-wares valued taking place in criminalpenitentiary system. Understanding and knowledge of criminal investigation characteristics of examining and composing parts, allow to organize
in a right way operative service of criminal-penitentiary system in order
to prevent thefts of material wares
Zarybin A. V.,
the post-graduate student criminal law and process chair Legal institute of Krasnoyarsk state agrarian university
Comparative analysis of decisions of the Supreme Courts of the
USSR and the RF on fraud
swindle, assignment, waste, Plenum of the Supreme Court, crime
against the property, a deceit, breach of confidence, qualification of
swindle
A.V. Zarubins article represents the actual research possessing the
theoretical and practical importance. On December, 27th, 2007 the
Decision of Plenum of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation
About judiciary practice on affairs about swindle, assignment and
waste which is the first decision of Plenum directly devoted to such
forms of plunder as swindle, assignment and waste was accepted.
The given decision makes separate changes to understanding courts
of essence of swindle and its differentiation with other structures of
crimes. Specified above innovations Zarubina A.V.'s article also is
devoted the analysis. The author carefully investigates positions the
Decision 51, compares them to various decisions of Plenums of
the Supreme Courts of the USSR and RSFSR (Russian Federation).
Points out the defects and advantages of new edition of positions of
the specified decision
Idrisov M. M.,
senior prosecutor of Public Prosecutor's Office in Moscow
The objectives of the public prosecutor in the adversarial criminal process
defense, the defendant, prosecution of the state, adversary criminal
trial, denial a charges
The article deals with the implementation of the maintenance of public
prosecution in the context of adversarial criminal process and the role of
public prosecutor in criminal cases in courts of general jurisdiction

3(12)

. .,


E-mail: vladkoz30@mail.ru


, , ,
, , , -

,
(), ,
.
, -

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
-
- , ,
- .

. .,


E-mail: Komnatnaya@bsu.edu.ru
:
2009
, , , ,
. .. , .. , .. .. ,

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru

, , , , ,


. , , ,
, .

,
,

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
:
, , , , , , ,
, ,
, , , .

, 2009

Kozinkin V. A.,
head teacher of Forensic Studies Department Tulas Branch Moscow University MVD of Russia
Aspects of interaction between crime investigation units and
mobile-telephone operators
information, means of Digital Cellular systems, operations and
maintenance center, cooperation, law-enforcement agencies, the investigation of crimes, the system of operative-surching measures
The extract under discussion is considered some aspects of organization the cooperation between different law-enforcement agencies in
the process of receiving the information finding with the operators of
means of Digital Cellular system. The author pays attention to the
fact that in what practical and tactic forms does the cooperation between investigators and operative workers in order to receive the information from means of Digital Cellular system
Kolesnik I. U.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing
of Sentences of Russia
Environmental and legal activities as a kind of legal action
ecologo-juridical activity, juridical activity, subject of ecological law
In this article is paid much attention to the ecologo-juridical activity
as independent type of juridical activity. That means that this subject
must be widen and at the same time we must have another ways of
researching points of juridical regulation social relations in ecological sphere
Komnatnaya J. A.,
applicant for the chair theory and the history of state and law
of Belgorod State University
History of science of private international law: the anniversary
date of 2009 year
Interstate law, international private law, the system of international
law, law of conflict of laws, legal history
The article is about the anniversary dates in the history of the law of
conflict of laws. Along with short biographies of D.I. Meyer, N.P.
Ivanov, O.O. Eihelmann and A.A. Rozhdestvensky, the article includes the analysis of their views and estimation of their achievements in development of the law of the conflict of laws
Kostryukov K. V.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Victim of identity and behavior of victims of fraud
victimology, victimness, victims identity, crime victim, prevention
of crime, fraud
The article is devoted to the consideration of personality and behavior of a fraud victim based on theoretical and practical problems of
victimness of crime victims. This analysis permits to identify and detain a criminal, to study all the motives and to assume the measures
to prevent crimes. The realization of these considerations will favour
the development of the package of organizational and preventive
measures including psychological impact upon the individual meant
for applying on different types of criminals and some categories of
potential victims
Lobanova A. F.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Economic justice in the Russian Federation: problems of formation
justice, economic, arbitration, the structure of the court, the code,
problems, judicial proceedings
The present paper deals with the concept of justice, formation and
development of arbitration system of Russia, structure of the arbitration system of the Russian Federation, the problems of economic
justice, the basic questions and problems of arbitration legal proceedings, the ways of their solutions, etc.

=193=

. .,
-
. .,
- ,

E-mail: urac@cards.lanck.net

, , , ,



. .,
-
,
E-mail: skapunkin@yandex.ru

- , , , ,
- , , , ,

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
- ,
, , , , , ,
, . ,

.

. .,
- ,
E-mail: mironov.ufa@mail.ru

, - , , ,
,
. . -
. .,


E-mail: human@vui.vladinfo.ru

, , , ,

.
. .,
- ,
E-mail: aldan1973@rambler.ru
, -
- , , , , ,

- . .
,

=194=

Malenchuk V. F.,
chief GUFSIN of Russia on Saint Petersburg and Leningrad area
Kolesov V. I.,
professor of the Saint-Petersburg legal academy, director of the Innovative center Postpenitenciarnoe education
doctor of pedagogical sciences
The formation of the moral stability of convicts in places of deprivation of liberty in the process of educational activities
forming, moral stability, process, educational activity, liberation
In the article problems and ways of forming of moral stability are
examined convict in the process of educational activity and to preparation convict to their liberation
Malin P. M.,
professor of the department of criminal-executive law of Krasnodar
State University of Culture and Arts, candidate of law, assistant professor
The distribution of persons sentenced to prison terms of levels of
danger as a necessary condition for the implementation of international standards for the treatment of prisoners in correctional
institutions Russia
criminal-executive law, progressive system, level of danger, convicted person, imprisonment, European penitentiary rules
From the point of view of the criminal-executive law study and recommendations indicated in the text of European Penitentiary Rules, the
author of this article discusses important questions connected with the
expanding of convicted peoples personal traits to imprisonment in order to determine the level of danger of the convicted person
Melkumyan G. A.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Historical and legal analysis of actions related to the hostage-taking
hostage-taking, amanat, crime, criminal law, kidnapping, ransom,
law enforcement
The historical aspects of hostage-taking acts are analyzed in the article. The problems related with hostage-taking established in the
modern period in the North Caucasus are set forth in detail. Analysis
of legal provisions is carried out taking into account international
experience and based on studying of voluminous theoretical and
normative material
Mironov A. N.,
assistant-professor of management and law department of Ufa Law
Institute of the Russion Interior, candidate of law, assistant professor
Legal technique legal normative acts
Juridical technics, Juridical technique and means, Juridical terms, Juridical constractions
The article deals with the term and contents of juridical technique. It is
proved the necessity the only juridical technical means concerning to juridical technique. Essential juridical technical means are called
Nazarova M. G.,
senior instructor of the hair of Humanities of Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia,
candidate of philosophy
Problems of Cultural Property in Russia and abroad
cultural values, protection of national cultural values, restoration of
monuments and artifacts, restitution of cultural artifacts, cultural
heritage
This article deals with the problems of cultural heritage protection in
Russia and abroad. Its built on the basis of national and world documents and lws
Pavlichenko N. V.,
the deputy chief of operatively-search activity chair of Omsk academy of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of Russia, candidate of law,
assistant professor
Terms of conspiracy as a model of regulated public relations
arising in the operative-search activity
crime detection, conspiracy, the rules, legislation, the rights, the duties
The problems of classification of conspiracy rules in operativelysearch activity are considered in the article. Some conspiracy rules
are offered to be officially fastened in the uniform standard legal certificate. Special attention is paid en to the structure of the given
statutory act, its name and the form of official fastening

3(12)

. .,

,
E-mail: belaya@academjust.ryazantelecom.ru

- -
, ,
, , ,

-
-
. .,


E-mail: belaya@academjust.ryazantelecom.ru
() -
, , -
, ,

- .
- ,
.

, ,
.
,
,

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
,

- , , , - ,
, , - , - () -
, , - ,
,
,

.

. .,

E-mail: mehtay@yandex.ru
(-)
, -, , ,
(-).
- (-)

. .,

E-mail: olegan80@mail.ru
-

, , ,

, ,

, 2009

Panarin D.A.,
head of High Academic Courses of the Academy of Law and Management of the Federal Penal Service, candidate of law, assistant
professor
The perception of some of the recommendations of the international instruments on the rights of convicted persons in compliance with the regulations of Russia in the sphere of criminalexecutive process
international legal acts, prevention of rights and freedoms, European
Court of Human Rights, Council of Europe, organizational and legal
sphere of penal institutions and bodies activity, penal staff
The author of the article considers the issues of compliance of the
normative instructions of the international legal acts with the internal
legal sphere of the Russian Federation in order to prevent the rights
of prisoners during organization of the penal influence in correctional establishments
Panarina N.,
deputy Head of the International Collaboration and Science Department of the Academy of Law and Management of the Federal Penal
Service
Basic functions of a penal colony duty service as a subject of organizational and management activities
security and safety service, operational situation, informational and
analytical work, safety and security in the penal institution, the main
trends of security and safety services activity
In the article the main trends of the security and safety service of penal institutions are considered. The security and safety service is regarded as the subject of organization and management. The author
points out the analysis of informational and analytical work provided
by duty officers in penal institutions. The complex of organizational
activities and methodological approaches are used by the structural
subdivisions of the penal institution to analyze and estimate the operational situation. Also the author singles out the main requirements
to security and order services of execution and serving of punishment in penal institutions
Penkov I. M.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Some problems arise when investigating criminal cases on traffic
accidents
transport accident. examination of the place of happening, crime,
criminally-processing code of the Russian Federation, the Russian
Federation code of administrative violence of rules
In the actual article, taking in account the example of criminal cases
concerning road and transport incidents, considered question about
lacks of the operating criminally-remedial legislation of the Russian
Federation which allowed guilty drivers in road accident to avoid
the criminal liability for committed crimes.
Having analysed the criminally-remedial code of the Russian federation, the code of the Russian Federation about administrative offences, judicial-investigatory practice, the author has offered ways of
perfection of the current legislation, allowing to protect criminal trial
from not standard actions of its participants directed to descriditation
of evidentiary base of guilt of criminals.
The Work has practical value and is recommended for studying in
system of office preparation of various investigatory divisions of
Vladimir region
Protasov D. V.,
post-graduate student chair of civil law Tver state University
The notion of the right to a secret (know-how)
trade secret, know-how, intellectual property, confidential data,
commercial secret
In the article new institute of intellectual property trade secret
(know-how) rights was considered. The peculiarities of civil law
protection of trade secrets (know-how) in soviet legislation and legislation of Russian Federation were analyzed
Ruzevich O. R.,
assistant of the department of Criminal Law and process The Faculty of "Law and Psychology" Vladimir State University
Legal regulation of the term threat concerning property
crimes under the laws of foreign countries
comparative investigation, comparative jurisprudence, threat in
crimes against property, threat criminalization
The article deals with comparative analysis of law regulations of
threat in crimes against property first and foremost directed at the

=195=

, , - , . ,
. .,
-

. .,
- ,


E-mail: urac@cards.lanck.net

, , ,


. .,

E-mail: akdm@jin.mvd.ru

, , , -, - , - ,
. . ,
, ,

. .,
-
E-mail: psfsin@permonline.ru


, , ,
, ,

-
,

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru

, , , , , -
.
. .
, : 1) ; 2) ; 3) ,
, , . . -, -,
, ..

. .,
-
,
. .,
-
,
. .,

E-mail: grpd@vui.vladinfo.ru

=196=

Russian criminal law development and its goal solution in unification of criminal law standards providing for responsibility for the
similar acts. This comparative investigation allows the author to
make conclusions and formulate recommendation which will be useful for Russian legislator
Ruschak R. V.,
depchief GUFSIN Russia on Saint Petersburg
and Leningrad area
Kolesov V. I.,
professor of the Saint-Petersburg legal academy, director of the Innovative center Postpenitenciarnoe education
doctor of pedagogical sciences
Pedagogical aspects of correction of convicts in penal institutions
re-educate, pedagogical influence, teaching, education
In this article the questions of re-education of convict and way of their decision are examined through educate and educational processes
Sabanov A. U.,
adjunct of Academy of management MBD of Russia
Genesis and the current status of forensic explosive
bases of a modern condition explosion of engineering is carried
out(spent), the regional features of functioning of divisions specializing in
the field of prevention of criminal explosions are submitted
In clause the historical aspects concerning new branch of
engineering - explosion of engineering are considered.
The stages of development of the given branch of knowledge are in detail enough covered and his concept is determined. The
analysis of organizational, legal and methodical

Sergeychik A. L.,
lecturer of the faculty of natural-scientific disciplines of Perm Institute of the Federal Penal System of Russia
Legal regulation of confidential information modes in foreign
countries and its application in institutions of the Federal Service for Execution of Sentences of Russia
regulation, protection, information security, confidential information, personal data, service secret
The article is devoted to the basic directions of the legal regulation
of relations in the field of administrative-legal regimes of the confidential information in sphere of the government of foreign countries,
and the importance of foreign experience in maintaining of the activity of penitentiary institutions of Russia
Seidov M. Sh.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Varieties of instructions depending on the type of regulatory impact
non-normative regulation, normative regulation, instruction, social
instruction, technical instruction, social-technical instruction
In the article the notion regulation and its types are being analyzed. According to them M. Seidov presents authors classification
of instructions, which defines 3 main types of such documents:
1) instructions with normative content; 2) instructions with individual directions; 3) mixed instructions containing both normative
specifying directions, as well as personified orders and directions.
Basing on the analysis of existing definitions the applicant develops
his own definition of the notion job description. The article will
be of interest to lawyers-theoreticians, lawyers-practicians, as well as
for those studying law, as it helps to define limits and volumes of social relations regulations of different levels
Skryachev A. M.,
chief of the Civil Law Disciplines Chair of Vladimir Law Institute of
the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia, candidate
of law, assistant professor
Barinov A.,
deputy of the chief of the Civil Law Disciplines Chair of Vladimir
Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of
Russia, candidate of law, assistant professor
Gudcov A.,
chief of the Law Disciplines Chair of Self-funded Department of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia, candidate of law

3(12)

- , -
, ,
-

. .,

,
. .,

E-mail: upik@vui.vladinfo.ru

, , , ,
.
, . . ,
,
. , ,
. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
e :
-
, , - ,
, , , , , , , , , , , ,
-

, - ; -
. .,
, , ,
E-mail: tychin@duma.gov.ru


, , ,
,

.
. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru

, , , , , ,
, ,
, ,

. .,
-

E-mail: root@academjust.ryazantelecom.ru
-
-

, 2009

Public-private partnerships in the employment adaptation of


convicts
public-Private Partnership, forms of the public-private partnership,
required labour of convicts, joint activity
The article is devoted to the prospects of use of the public-private
partnership, as effective mechanism of required labour of convicts in
conditions of market economy
Tkachuk T. A.,
assistant-professor of Forensic Studies Department of Vladimir Law
Institute of the Federal Service for Execution of Penal Sentences;
candidate of law, assistant professor
Mikhailov A. Ye.,
teacher of the Department of Criminal Law and Criminology, Vladimir law Institute of the Federal Service for Execution of Penal Sentences
Forensic identification and its role in the disclosure and investigation of crimes
forensic identification, group membership, investigative measures,
presentation for identification, crime
The concept of forensic identification and its definition are the subject matter of the paper. The paper describes the practical use of forensic identification techniques, viewed in the framework of individual investigative measures; presentation for identification being one
of them. The importance of group membership in investigating and
solving crimes is also studied in the paper. Besides, the paper sums
up questionnaires, presented by investigation officers which demonstrate the importance of certain investigation activities for identification procedures. As a result, the authors offer their own definition of
the concept of identification which is done during investigation. Feasibility of the study of non-traditional presentation procedures
Turcova V.V.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
State prosecution: essence of the category of criminal procedure
charge, the state charge, the criminally-remedial code, office of Public Prosecutor, the public prosecutor, criminal legal proceedings, the
accused, remedial activity, competitiveness, criminal trial, court,
crime, guilt, the indictment, the bill of particulars, criminallyprocedural right
Article is devoted concept research the state charge and to its essence, the istoriko-legal analysis of an origin of a word charge in
Old Russian language and change of the term charge with development of the legal doctrine about the subjective party of a crime;
various interpretation of the Russian scientists-protsessualistov concerning concept charge are stated
Tychinskaya E. V.,
master of Private Law, the chief consultant of Staff of the State
Duma of Russian Federation on civil, criminal, arbitral and procedural legislation
The order of the conclusion of the contract on the implementation of
functions on a single executive body of the economic society
business entities, a sole executive body of economic society, the
education the sole executive body, the general director, managing
the organization
This article is devoted to the conclusion of the contract on realisation
CEO`s functions. The author offers the new approach to a procedure
of the conclusion of this contract
Urlekov N. V.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
On some problems of activity and status of the jurors
jury, status, power, rights, warranties, duties, responsibilities, qualifications, the verdict
The article deals with the problems of giving citizens the status of
the jurors. The article is devoted to the exploration rights, safeguards
and responsibilities of jurors
Fomichova . V.,
senior Lecturer-Methodist office methodical support of educational
process of the Training Division of the Academy of Law and Management of the Federal Penal Service
Problems of participation of penal institutions and organs in
criminal proceeding

=197=

- , - , , - ,
-
. .
-
, . ,
- , -
. .,


E-mail: chernisheva_dian@mail.ru

, ,
, , ,
. . , .
.
. , , ,

, .
:
.

. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
,
, ,
, ,
. .,
- ,
E-mail: shalomentseva@mail.ru
:
, , , ,

()
.


. .,
-

E-mail: adunkt@vui.vladinfo.ru
- - ,
-, , , , - , , , ,

, ,
,
-,

=198=

criminal procedure activity, criminal procedure legislation, inquest,


investigation and search operations, criminal procedure powers
In the article the author considers the issues of participation of penal
institutions and bodies in criminal process and the ways of problems
solving. The author studies the degree of the participation of the investigation and search subdivisions of the Federal Penal Service in
the procedure of emergency investigation operations. She points out
complicated organizational and methodological issues in this sphere
that it is necessary to solve. The author suggests the number of organizational and legal measures used in order to increase the effectiveness of criminal process issues solving in the activity of penal
system
Chernyshova J. N.,
adjunct of chair of criminal law of the Tyumen juridical institute of
the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation
Some problems of differentiation of criminal liability of accomplices
the criminal liability, partnership in a crime, differentiation of the
criminal liability, public danger of the crimes, qualifying signs, responsibility of accomplices
J.N.Chernyshovoj's article represents the actual research possessing
the theoretical and practical importance. Now norms, the differentiation of the criminal liability has no unequivocal definition in the theory of the Russian criminal law. It is means of a legislative estimation of public danger of crimes of a certain kind and their persons
made. As the competitor fairly marks, the position of the legislator
carrying fulfillment of a crime by a group of persons, a group of persons on preliminary arrangement and the organized group in some
cases to one part of article of the Especial part, in some cases to different parts is erroneous. Function of differentiation of the criminal
liability is caused by the basic quality of qualifying signs: to reflect
considerable change of typical degree of public danger .
At wrong construction of parts of the Especial part the given function loses the initial value
Chubchenko I. M.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Especially the definition of jurisdiction of criminal cases on crimes
committed in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation
competence of criminal case, offence, committed in armed forces
In the present article the issues of the procedure of identification the
competence of criminal cases about criminal offences committed by
enlisted personnel are raised
Shalomentseva E. G.,
chair of state-legal disciplines of the Vladimir branch of the Russian
academy of public service at the President of the Russian Federation,
candidate of economic, assistant professor
Municipal regulations: the system and classification
municipal union, local governments, the official of local government, the elective official of local government, the municipal legal
certificate
Article is devoted the analysis of activity of bodies and officials of
local government on acceptance (edition) of municipal legal certificates and offers on their ordering and classification. On the basis of
conclusions by results of studying of municipal practice changes in
the current legislation about local government are offered
Shpilevoy O. N.,
applicant for the department of scientific personnel training of
Vladimir Law Institute of the Federal Service for Executing of Sentences of Russia
Present status of operational and preventive work in prisons and
factors contributing to its effectiveness
colonies, special contingent, operational situation, investigation and
search operations, operational and preventive activities, escape, evasion of service of sentence, crime rate, crime dynamics
The article is devoted to the contemporary state of penitentiary crime
in colonies, analysis of the operational situation, factors that cause an
increase and qualitative change in crime in colonies and tasks of the
operative units of the Federal Service for Execution of Sentences of
Russia, aiming at preventing of delinquency of these correctional facilities

3(12)

,

1
(22 ). : , ,
, .
: 4; Times
New Roman; 14-; 1,25 ; ; , , , 2,5 .
: ( , ,
, , , , ( ), , , -mail); ;
; ; (34 ),
7.1-2003 . . .
7.05-2008 . , .
, ,
: .
,
.
.
, , .
- .
, : 600020, . , . , 67,
-mail: vestnik@vui.vladinfo.ru,
.
, . 3500 .
- .: (4922) 32-49-73,
32-25-60, -mail: vestnik@vui.vladinfo.ru.

( 17401000000)
3329012372 332901001
.
40503810900001000001

( / 03281175960)

041708001

.
. .
:
32030201010010000130 .3

( )
, 2009

=199=

!
!
.
.
1- 2010 .
36614
236 ., 472 .
: 25 , 25

=200=

3(12)

Оценить