QV1ESl'IO

LIX.

De 'VO/U1ll4ie An(]flo~Hin_ .

) ~'. .

$ Y M AI A. L J T T E R .4.

X UD J T 0 omtli eo quod pertinet ad intellt:'£\'um Angdi.ip(o ordine dolhjn~ tr:1nuc O. Tho. ad ea qua: de ipferum velunrsre agenda (unt'.Ec i~ h2C q\1:dl.a~it~e jpfa_ V'Qlunta_c~ _corLim perquatuor articulo5}in rcque~-: n de aeEu voluntatis ,. qUI en- amor, per qurnqne,

In primo ergoartic. ofi:endit dari in Allgdis vclunrarem', quia d:uur , _ indinario confecnra ad naturam c(lgnofcC'ntern, regufadltl";que cagl'litiO-

fie; &. non eognitlone feufitiu>1, qua: in cis non en, fcd intelleCl:iua ~ ergo habe~u volun~

ut~m. _ __ ~

In art.l, oR-end it hane perenetam voJunraris dHl::ingui in Angeli.; at-> j1"l[eiJetlu, & l natl.1racQtUtD.DHlinguitur quidern a namra,qnia prxdic:uaconftllufm:l nluurz i_~t~a ip{am _indudunttlr, nee ad ahqnid extra fe refpkilJ!>f, vel ab eo fpccificancur. V q_}tJr.t.:s au .. ' tern. tendit adaHquid cxtra,qt1i:l. eft inclinatio in bonum non folum prop,r:utn,; (tdcdam· otritlfecurri. Ab intcllcCln aurem diftinguitur, quia ifirdlea-Ils cognofcitcrihendD reI. ad fe, voluntas rendendo, & impellendc Ie adillas, Diuerfa: surem Vlrt\uis c::lt: trahercres ad (c jntdligihilitcr,aut in eas lit fune in fe,tendete. niG fit virtus incrc:::u:a.qu% Intra {c habee omne bonum.nee indigee ali quo extra fe , nequo ad jmelligendnm , ocque :.lei velendum.

In art.J.oll:::ndit in Angdi5 elfe liberum arbierium, idq\lc multo excdlenrio~quam itl , Dobis.qu::i. ell; j~jplh aldor inrdldlus cum m:linrj vniucrf.ll;tate, ~ j"drtf:;r.;mia refpidens obicd-um (ullm. ex illdHfcn:mtia aurem Judicij circa bonum nafcitur liDcr(as in \'0:.lunraee ad rendendum.

. Inart.4.ofteildit nOll di!l::ingui in AngeHs appcrieum concupi{cjbHc:m. & ira[cibilem. I)eque ficut in nobis, in quibus difiinguuntur jfti apperleus iil pute fenfitiu:z • qua (:~tc::,

. Angdllsineque vUo alio modo • quia volunras cftappctitus bon] fCCllndum vniucrfalc:m rarionern boni , vnde non por:dblari appetims in parte: imellediua • feu voluJlt.u) qua:

dill:mgu.ltUt penes bona particularia. i

~u~,(1h,~~~Atthtrt'1~rf,h,~tf,,f,,t,rt,*A\ht~~:~Rt:~A\:rf,htrf,

QVlE'STIOLX.

De Amort fJ d;/cc1iont Ang(lorllm~ s r M M.A LIT T E R .4.

,

t

,

Mit N, art. r .o-ftcnd it quOd in AilgeHseR- ::unor nanlralis erg:1 aliqu:t obiella.Et (ami ... iI\i rur ly R4ftSrllli4 non pro appctitu iWLUOt fed proatl:u appcti,u5 el.cni, qUi t~rncri precedir neceffariQ. &; non Iibere.ab ipfo. EtranoeR- iquia inomni natura datu," aliq~aindjn4tio iuxra rnodum t.lliS naturz.dqaead%quara,&propordonat~quz ncccfw

{anD iIIi conuenit:crgQ & in Datura intdleanJ:I debet talis inc lin:nio.non dcdfe. .

In :1ft." .oftendit dati edam in Angc~jsdilc:aionellJ. elca-iu<lm,id de Uberam,& ex arbi .. , .:rio procedens ,non ex neceffitatc:licet cnirp aliqua debe-at voluntas naturaliter-appctcre. Geut 6nc::s,aliqua ramen deaioe, &libcrd appetir, Grot media.qnia media non denccc(. fir;ate fimpliciter apperuntur, fcd propteraJiud. &- 1o't cenducune ad :;iliudj Illudaurem aliud pr~?tc:r fe appc:tilUr,&: non propter aliud:fie enim e-!fc.1: abite in infinitum:ergo aliquadebee libereappetetctfcil.quzin fe'non h~bent bouiQ(em nCI;df:ariam.&propu:r {o appr:tibilem>~lillaUtc:mnatura1itorlciL qua: ratione (ui :app¢[Unrur.& cximmediata ad.:{quatiQue c,uql voluntaee, Inrclligitur appeti neccifario quead fpc(:,fiClotionem•

In art. 3 .oflendir quod Angelus Ceipfum diligit, tum llat.Utali diJea-~O}Ie-, lUCP eIeai~

JOlIlJ.), s. ThlJ7tJ.iTJ l.p",nD. T~. Tomus al".r., (i G g a. N:I£QraU

-4-2.8 §bJ.41.tXA De proauttione Angeforum int.fenatur&.

Naturali quidem.in quantum natutal~ ap~et~~aliq~od~on~ll1libi dUig.i~, vt;clf~~ y~

re &c. Elell;iua surern in quanrum ahquod bonum hbc:re Ubl vult. .

) In arc.4.ollendit quod aliu!l'f Allgelum e~lll.d.hgit narurali dik6tldfic: 6tutJe:ipfurnj Jtlquam_um conuenie (ec? m i~~~~ar~; .~c ~11~ d~ltgit i Ilumticilt (~~ UcUt [u~m ~a~. ram, in qua alter conuemr : dlhglt enarn hbere ,111 quantum ab eo ddfcftiife1 In 3_11qW ..

bus aliis quam in [lamra conl,lcnit fecum. . ... ,'". . ,

111 art. 5 .of1:ell'iitqubd natural! dileGf;ione plli5,8c principalius diHgic Angclus;& hemo Deurn.qusm [cipCum) quia nanrralis habitude, &: inclinatio plus eft ad bonum tota. 1c,& vniuerfale, quam ad parrerri, cum magisex tOtO dcpendeat conferuatle partis,ideoque naruralicer panern exponic natura pro con(eruatione totius, Deus aurcrn eft vniucrfale bQriulnJAngdus ;tUUall pars..Plus ergo natUra AIlg4H tcn'ditin D~'U~~ilJvin-c

~. (j , , ~

QV JE S.T 10

LXI.

De produc1ione Angelorum in eft nalur&.

9J~~~' X 1J r, r c AT ~ natura Angdi,ciUJqueproprictaribus,(cquitUugCfC: d.e 1"""

duchone in etTe.Et primo 10 effe mturz, fecundo in cffe g~a(ha'. ;

In prime ergo arciculo oltcndj,AagdoS' habere eaufam li.l.i c:tk, quiif~ creature, &: entia per parelci patiooem I fohu. ;UlCI:m eft. CUl1l3cffe,&i a fe. : ,In art. z..oO:endlt Angdum non eITe produLlwn ab.;et!;1no, qui.! nihil a.b ~terno pl'~: du&m eO: a D,=o~ Il't fides dccec, fed £llnth f.llh (une i.Q tempore pol~ quam nihUfuCJl'un;.

In art. }.ol1t:ndj[ nee etlam fuilfe '\'1gdos creates ante mundum ccrpcreum.Ied cum. hac 'IlllUerrO ill principio u:mpori$,faao~ fwlfe, qu::a- pat'S fum:: vniuedi;& vnum faciull( cum narura corporea, q.uarnui5 ceneranum non Iic erroneum j prOE(~Ii~idl p,ropter aut~ riI;ltc:m Nilziarrz.eni.

In arr + orll!ndlt creams f\lifre Angelos in clio empyreo, qnla 6 crea,jfWltcuttH)[» ,bne:&d hut; v,o.il,lcr(u iii in aliquaj! hus patte creari de buerum,& cUm GOt amnh:rcat1J(a corporalitupcriOrc!, ehue pr:rfidente! ) in fupremo COqt05¢ quod eft c:elUUl empyreilrn debuerunr crean : quarmnsenam d1ci pofIit quod.fupc:rinres.A.ngeliinf~prc:mocorpofCj alIj aucem in inferiQribus corporibus~llt ctcati. .

~Att~,t,Mtf,~;t,it\:Af,~41~~",:rl\ft,~~;t,rft ~"'IMt~.

Q V lE.5 T I 0 L X II.

Ve perftCiione Angdorum in ejfo grati& J f5 glorill. s r M ./If A. L r T T E;R ce.

~~~1J N artie. Lo{tendit D- Tho. quOd Angeli non (unt crt:atiin be2titudine (~ pernaturali , qUia hzc bcaritudo non ell :diq~id nJ~ur%,(c:d finis fupetior f:la-!;

• tnrzacquirendusper merirauion c;rgo iniUafuntcreati.bclletamen int41i ...

• cirate naturali. ; . .

- Inart.l..o{l:cnditquod Angelus indigueril' gratia adconuenendum Ie in Deum faper .. na~t~l~ter,co quod inclinatio ad idquod efHuptr naruram non p~,ea oriri nili ab alfqllO" ptlDClplofupcrnaturali moueatur ralis natura! fiCllEcalor non pOtl;\agenc:rarc earn em. ve mouenn ab igne, fcd vtmouctur ab anima j e~o nulla creatura rationali~ poreft habcfC!' motum ordiD3tu£n ad Cupetnaturalem beatimdinem ~ niti Vt mouerue a Cupetnaturali

agcnte~& bocvocatur ,auxilium guti~. . .

In art. 3 -oftendit quM Angeli cteati Cunt in grltia, vtpoee magin-on{onurn dill:is San~ [t:ln1:n. E~ quia gra~ia dit:;itUf [.men Dei.r.Ioann.j, fleuetn prima ctc:;uione corporalil' cre.uut'% indira; rUnt illi ratiD1\ts femigales omnium effelhtum naturalrum ~ ita conue, niensfuir,. quodinrclleaualictenuU! infunderentut a Pdncipio {cnlluJ.c$ rOlrioncsef..

f~m fIlPCnl2lOur;iliull1~quia ad:iUos ordinabatur, t!.

In

, .

.' §l!!,1j1.;o LXll1;.Dt, Angeloium,inAlJij4~ - 419

!. :In.artic.4- Qacndi&Angdum (uam. b'l1titud{nem~etUi{fe-:I quia be1dtudo dlfinjj excedens roram.namram, &. fi.c'htmoIi'L~[.e" ip(j natut'a.fa4 ex-dono Dethabeult. ~ano. ~wm .pl':tmiiliti virtuci&; ergoop~rtct:qlJ~ merieum ~cOOat aa. maIn i:x.part~ .;:ius qUi alfequitur bcatitudinem. Vnde c::tJ01I}'l propeerhoc oportUit qu6d~grau~eifcl;, in An-

gcl.is',anteglonam.· >, .::. ,,' :'".'", • .: '.;~.' ' •• '., ;"',.'" •

In artie,5' o£lendi~ quod AnFli lb&itn. po!hnum.:alhull Jt;!orjtori.uaa habue~un¢ bMd£v.d~n"rti s- quia ,ptoptius mDdUs..~p&tand i in Amgdis::c:ft~ q liodfuaml ~fea:iopenl non acqulrant per difcurfum I Ieu per multos ~aus,t4:'anf~dn,dc impcrfeao acigerfc...> ll:u~ ~ tCct quOd Jl:3titn: babeane toeam pCffctlion mIl, quO!! fwi de: betur Jau£ datur: ergo ,nmi ,{M modus non di:Aru2tUi'. a.grath11 [c:apertici::itur'i 0pQlI-tull: '1iJoactiam,in fupcrM Rafucihbasnon. per frnJIlOS ailus acqui~ fuam.peifcaionon'l} (tclpcl' ,vnicum habeat: id

quod no: pet plures., , , . . _, . '. _ . . .'

l~4. "attf¢ulcr:'; ·offendi.: qubd Angdr b)bllcrunt gratlam;& glorfam.uq;t'\ quantitatem fitOiliih daturalinm,aonqllia.natlltafuc!:(iG'difpofttiorad'gratianr,t {Cidquia Deus fuz ya'?ntate- ..;&' gtaria. ira d!fpoft:t1t diuctfos 8r~dus' in naUJra ,hngcju;a quOd illos ;ui diuer .. los eriarn gradus gratiOf: ordinauit,qu1a g(atlOl modo 2!!:cndi PaEurz fe aeccmmodae t narur;aurcm Angeli quaritO. fupe-riar efr, tllJltO cfficacias opef':mlr f &: iiI: etiam gratia-in-

t('Pilot" vi iIla.ol.lnouer., .' , ~ . . .

I n artie. 7. oU end it quod in Angeli! b~tisr.em:lOit. c;ognicw., & dilcaio natUralir, quia per beadtudincm non ddl:rultut~{c:& [alUattlr natura: ergo &, aa~s natUr~1 qU% c:&

opt;ra~i" naturalis. " ~. ". _. . .

: .. lrl,:mic.8. ofrendit qui)d Angelus beantS non patefr pecFare; qriianuUus Beatus po... tef1:-aliquid opet:iti relmquendo vel omiclcndo vj{i~ile~ pei"fcd~ttC:lldc'ndoad Hlam: ~UUU5 autem arrendens a,d Dcum itt (ua ~cratione Eotdl peccare, quia pcccatum con«

ti~t ex defeCtu. at auerfione a l'egula,qll,Z en: DCllJ.. . . :'

" In artie 9. ofiendit quod J\ngeli bea,i' non poff'unt prQfi'ere in beatimdinc qua-n-

o rum ad hoc quod V'idcant Deum darIUS ~ut melius, quia beadeudo ca: ttnis vlrimus vl .. era quem non ,eli progrelflis~ vndeacqulfito nne vltimc In eo tt'l:mino .qui a. Deo prit"figi ....

tut.~n eft ykc:rior progrelflu., .

Q V A3 S TI o LXIII.

, Dc,4ngt/orum malitia. , s r M Ai A L J T 'I E K. t.<~~.

iN artie. I. oRenditD.Thoi qll0dill AngcliS, ficur &: in quaIibetcreatura p~.ell: eifc peccarurn , 'quia qudlbc[ creatura confidersra ex (u~. natUra. .non habet Iibi innzrenteQl rcgnlam (uz reCtiuldi!lis t quia ilzccll V(~un~ tas diu[na:lIndc pote-A: ab el ddicere pre iua hbertaie.

~~~.. In ardc. 1._ ol1:endit quod in Angtlis [olum eft peceamm fupl'lt'biziJ

. & inuidiz quantum ad affctlum, quiaaff'etlus fpjriEuaJis fubftamiz dire-

~e non :eil: ad bona (:orpor:tlia ~ fcd ad bona fpirilt1aua, in quibus non eft pecca(um,nHi .

In qU~~ltum in cis apperendis (uperioris r~g~la non fcr-w[';lr,quod propric pcninct ad: fllperOlam,qu~ ICbmt fubiici ordini fuperiom. ex quo feqUft'Ur pel"~atumjnuidjz. Poffunttamen abapc6CllU dfein D;anoniiWS (ccundum reatum in quantum ad ilia indu-

eunt homines. . . I

: In .artie.j. ollcndit quod Di2bolu5 appeticrit eire vt Deus. non quidem pet zqua8 llcatem in gradanarurz, quia hoc etatimroffibik, fed pet fimili.udine~; non quidem tl;1 eo in quo creamra debet' imitari Deum, quod eft in exercido virrurum, kd qU.DtUm, ::td hoc in quo Deus non eft imitabilis , "t quod voluerir habere vJtimuni 6n~m ~ Oil ~D1c:ndkando mum a Dee per gratiam,fed ex fU2 n:arura. vel (altern [t'lluendo iJJumu.

bere ex liberalirate DelJ&:: fohlm rcmancsdoin fu:.. naturali fdicw.c. .

. Inanie4, olb::ndir quOd D;tmones non Iimt natur.ui~er r:rJi , fcd ex Iibere ubi .. ~rio,quja llatun; t:Qtum a Dc::o faCta eft ~ & "rdinata in bom..n: ergo nOlI d\ ex {nan .....

lura males, , . .

lnanic.j" ()fu:ndit quiad i&cn culpam c~ Ijbl:t~ :u-bifrio non habuerit An,gduS"ia

eGG£, J primo

430 §lJJ.,fl·LX II/. De L!fZge~ort;Jm ",alfila:

p[itnoinn~ndrl1:r:ctcatiori!s, eo quOd operatio,~ua: .iD.dpit ~um ~~e~ei,ptOuenit .!pG. l. Cu" gencrante. Vn~~non pateil:c~:de:fc;hloCa ilIa pn~a o~crano, DIU ge~erans:l ql1~ 'mouerur dc:fcl1:U05C tnOUCiit. :Q!!I aurem Angdum prQdu:lC:lt Deus cil:,qlll dcf:8:uosr:

mou.e:rcnQfi:potc{l'; : :.:'. . . •.. ,.:,:).:., ;. . .

. In artie.G. of};(:ndit quod Dlabolus fl:atim po{l primum inilans fu:t cr~2donis pecea:= lIir,qui;1 cum- in ipro ,primo inftanti habu~ril; attum my~itorhl~ ; C~tti quo cri!ati.U eft a D~o,& Angeli per vaicum atl:um merirorium acquHiermt bcautudlnem,u non pe-cc.aff~ foa prinlWil. inibns,beatituwnem acccpiffet.. .., . .. ".'; I, :.,

In artie,7. oR::endit quOd Angdus fuprernus mter peccantes fuerll: {impllcltcr fupre .. mus interomnc:s,quia habuit mains moriuum ad peccandum proptet malceem exc~Hl!nti~tIi:& pcc~tutninAngdi$ non fuit ex aliqua pronitat¢ vel fomite pc:cc;&,i,fed folll,mcjt libero arblrrio, - - . p

b artic.S. oftendit quod peccarum prirnl Angeli fuit allis caufa -peceindi nOD fet modum cogendi.(cd pcrfuadc:ndi:Gc enim traxit Draco Iecum certiam parrem ftella.rumj vt dtcieur A pocal u .. Edn hili US fignurn ca:-tcti Demones filbduntUf primo Angdo pc~

cuoriin pO!'na,cui confenferune m culpa, , _ .

In mie.,. oflendirplures permanfill"e de Aligelis in bono, quam ceddiffc in male, quia in naruris pc:rfc(.l;is na~\1ra in paucioribus deficit,&-; in plUIibu5 confcquituf fuuincf ... fectum : pec,:mHn autem eft dc:fcaus conu':I, naturam.

R,Mht;ft.t,"'~~4\:zt,~rt%~,f, DISPVT ATIO XXI II.

De meriro , &' pcccatO { Angclorum.

ARTICVLVS I.

, .

rtrlltiJ J"ri po/it &UAtfirlS ex foil nAlllr& impeuiJ6ilil?

[I VLLAM d~ride r~Clointdleauattm creamr.am, ql\2 ex f(: i.ll1p~cl;,1biliS Ut,:lh(oIUl:l fide$ ell: • cum,d arena ScriptliI~ tc{taur.collig~n$ emnem _ _ crearuram inrcllttlualcm. Cdl, AD~ ·gcliclm,&: humaDlm > Be iIIis :luribuCjU pc:cc~bmcl[rnI,licUt lob 4. diciiur NlJwJlfid bmta Dri ~~p.rtf1iollt i~ftlfir:llbltu"; iflll foOdre {HI pUTicr eTil ~ir! Em ilil/mliMII' ti noll fW1' j1J1bila , &' .11 ...111- !,tlp !;';H'7trit prNlif.JI/tf!!> '1lrlf!lr~ 1Jflfgil bi qUi b,,-bUll'" tUTflQS IliUM. &c:. £t il1fr). C.I r· £ (erring f~Q~1 t~ rIm,l) immur;tbilu. ". ,eli rum [rm, tfJllml; in "n[ptllJi fl •• 'JUAn';' mAf.¥ .:z{,cmin"bi1ii~ & inll.til;" hvmo I &c. Q.!:ibus verbis omocll1 c:na~lIr;lIn Sc:ripmr,1 complcaitur. & loquitllf vpiucrrJlircr. 'It pout!: illis vethis l1nn~ immllr..wli4·~ lice. f!.{ hoc mrn (ando5 ;:it\~.(ed qU2cumque c:rc:atuu. i11lpc=c:tilhili.s dic=lttll" r~ntl2 Cft:f!EB Ii inter fOll15:0S neme immllfabilj$. nulla (Iel.IDra Ganfra eft ilnpecCibilis, IdcDlIlcduciwt c:dllo [)f:d!ni 1'11. NQ1J ik.j1iftclII>:Iflfr in &otJ[ptEl. is' _is 'fIiIHlIr. 'l!!ml locum pond'f;~ S. HictQ!lym. tpift. 146. ;ul Damafllm, 'JUod non dicit SaiptUr2 oronis homo, fcd omois ¥juciU ,id eft , N.lI EflAlI!rlip ..• _ .AP,jlO{lII>nOll Pro,br,Jljlld nr~I''' ,"iJjimdo.trM .Anl,tli,~ Thr#JJi tJ~l1 Ihlflinl(r;'''(!1~ Iluf P,,,jLIfU '~'trlf'l"' Y in"fQ: folt" VllfI 1(1 i~ q- 9t&tAIII1!J 11m t .. dit • till"" tlim lint libtri fP6ilt1J itJtt"_qtlt PAn_ {IIAI1I fitnt.,.tf~!-"r 'f6mil,'trir. Et .S.htgurt..li~. th ftJ~ u rnrltm rq.~~ IJttJ"Iff.'4." ptIfJ.". rnft~m pilI. pmt) ilti. ~~,tq"II!" ~ iJl~tkfo"'~i.J,mbiJ, J-U.[tUIi.'£t ~.1;' FmIIi_/f","I;iW)d' mlll.-VINJ J.

blrUdmfltm rr't.tlurifmll(;ru7'Jillr mUlllbiltm, .& l Dto /mmiJtlfb;U j.f[fJim. ElItdcl1l utionem qUare mnrlis crc:~tllr:l IIr pcceabiils , qili~ ex ntbtlo f;lGb en, affiglli11lt Nj([cnll~ Iip'7' J~ .lib4T17 IIrbitr:io flip· 'lJftim~.D.lm:!fc.lib.ftdfi t,.,Cllp.17' qUlIs dt.lt. f~!l~"'! turque S.Tb.q.l+dt'U6Tit.R1't.7·&;r.I hMq.6J.ilri.

J,& aliislodspo!ld.ciundis.· , ,

DiJlkulras ell in affign.lnd.1 ratione. qu~C" im- i. plil~t co mtaJitlionml • qu ad ;lliqlll CteJruU non poffit elfc impccc;lbiIi5.Et diffic:ulca, dl: ind!l:cobu1. Ptimo in dcfenJcnJis r3tiDnibu~ D. Tb.qll2! in hac pu~c alfcrt. Sc=,ulldo,an probenr omllclJ) ereseur~pi d'fe pcc:c;lbilem.tam in ordi,i~ ad JiIlCP1 rup~'!' naruralem , qll.lm in ordine ad finem natuulem

• ramulJl~it~ Vt intulimites n~S' ordinis pIa:g~

se Gnt Angr:li capaces pec:cru., .

.

Rt'foilltio (X D. -rhi;flJI.

Duabu! condu6onibIlH~(pondel'llus,

Prima dl: Ration!:s D. ThD.cflic:actt~r prgbant Angdum. &: quamlibtt crC:lturaro intdleflualem Jibcr.ttn i:l1'cpecc~bil!:m Cit narura[\I;l,& ~IUmpct

gratiam reddi poll\: impec a hil~m. .

Secunda tondlllio dl:Angdll$ inrra limitdOl'''' din!! n;l.tutalis tontiderauu) & in ordine ad ~ tI:ltut:l.lem ramum I (ub hae ra!ion"pr#'c:ise~ ilia aliu5 ordo feu ba bi~udo a dda(l1t. ptcc;uc non po-:. tcll>licet modo pccr;~ndodc fado conna fintm le-:. g~mque (uperl1;uuralem dircGl~ J cd~m contra legem naturalem , qUiZ a fUpt!tllatUrah (lIpponirur. peccsre poretl:. V tuqlle" conduIio ruo$lIoi.het con-

ltadidor.r;s. " ;-

Cenera primam conclufton~'1Il p~lIci .?t fere Dulli runt Alfthom qui Clpp.ofitum tcnc=:mt,lit:et in J elus reddenda ratione hareanr, Nam quOd G~:o briC!] ill 1..J.ijI.l J ,lin.,.&, ·z.&: Maior ibidt71"J"~fl. ~.~Qntl.".& f. fc:ntium polfe:: pfoduda. Deo volunr;ltcl1l impc:ec~bil~m,~ ideo eft, quia e:tillim~nt polr¢ de potencia ahfolin'i dari volllnc~(~m eresl;lln.qu;r: non lit libcut{ublata aurem hbcrrare [01- liwr peccabilil31. Et hoc ell quia (f(~rUf2rn intd~ lc:au:llc:m put:l_nt potle elle brutal cm.Ali'lui ¢ti~~ e::lillim:llunt pone:: dad crC:<trurilm cui lit conn.turalc: lumen gloria:: , vrtctulimus. &: impugna\lLo m!1$p~~;l.,ltmll difp.l+4rt.". Et hi fac:idllrqa-o turam imp«cabilem. qUi;!. n atllf;llir¢r. faciUflt b~licam,., l(fanidpuiontm di!lini. &fllpmltuualiS

. s o~Jillis.

DifPul. XX / tt.

ordinis,no n ~*trinrccam POIlUI1t.& gr~llJilam.red debil:am.& natuul~m. Amiliuilllrum~n O,~alli ~ J,Jifl'44.fJ~.i.ltA z,tlllb;wn, qudd te-neat ft pr.i?"bilc:. polfe prolillci Angdum vel hominem 31. tcdus (pcdei.quip=!:!:;Ibilis non lit. S'OII.15 vcra;1i ;.dip.1J,qJJ.'I.mkA,§.Di&11 igitllr,in fi-z,) licet tl:nc~t non polfe produci crcaIutalll i mp~cabjJem pef natu,am • tanten id magis tenet ptop[~f allthorit;;lt~5~ quam ell: ratione ~ dudtLlr autern authotitate Hictonymifopr;l'i,.& ALlgu!1:.llb.~. mlrra Ma)tim. (:";';& AnCelmi lib. 1. cllr 'Dnu hI)mlJ, coIo.in /int, C·~'lrra fecli!:id:im :lIUem cenclu lioncrn cenCI V ar~ q1l';Z. hl, JjlJr •• J L~+ Suarez, lib.;. d~ .I1flgtl.f·7_' )tol.h;" 9" t'iJ.Art.l. Ell: ramen Duran,H ;111. diJI· ~ ;'91t1.1. Capr. ;;J 1.difl.l ~.tJu,'1mita "Yi. ~ . .1 pineip.io.C~i~f.l" 1M. 9H,G5.;Jrt.I,§.Cir," crmfi1rmffiaffl, /k earn f~nmt multi ~ccemjQr"$ Thomilb:. de qlllb~, vidl: Nauarrene hi, ~/)ntrtJlf,.7!1' C:umcHunum Colltgiurn mu1'7' de Ange/~ difpM'51' dub.

j.&). '

PIt! expli~anda crgoratioDI= D,Tho. arc' pd& msm l;onc;lllfionem: in hoc enim lOU c:hn dlHi.. ~I[as contillit)!llppol1c:ndum ell nosloqui in pra:~ (~"d de cre~IUt;j, imd!cCtllali libc(~ : narn (ubbra llpeqat~ vel m~nc:bit G~U! brumm • quod dllciuu !I):Alntl:u. nen 2Eblrtio, vel etit bear:,&: vreus vi~ (Jonel c:~r;r. Dei '. & lie c::rgHrnandum Dcum '~r~t libc:nille,& c(lokquenti:r non poreftpcccim:. quia gUI peecse , Dcum non arnar. ~r liter verum fit 'lIlO~ omnlHreltula imcllcCiuahs, e~ VI incelle~u~lwlti5 non potcH ClrtfC libl:rure. fed babe-at ~lIJJ?,' qlliilhodpCo qllQJ itltdlcll:U2li~ '~.h.lb~f ~li&lcnlm vnluetf~le. &; confe'lucntrr !I1dlff~H'nl ad omne bonum; 8{ lie niJ'ilUIb quod Infinirum ~9f1 fir dm: vifum PQicl\ ill:I!D vniurrCllirau:m &.mplcrc. & can(cqucmef aeque nc:ccffit,i(c.tamcn ~c in ptz(end iupponendum ell non probandlJlJIok coadbnd;! ell. difpiJr~til) ad c:rc:::lnJum inll;l1eGlu.dc;In Iib~am, an videlicet aliqua crc:arura imeIleClualis , &. libera poffit prodnci.quz impecpbifu fi~. quiJo Jilibeta Don fupponitur • nan dl: qUlI:illo.Eodcm modo (uppon~ndllm ell: quod per iroltia~ pordl:: illiquis I;l:ddi impeccabilis) quia. vi 9ltc:ndit S. Tho. qu.G"z..pt.8.impoffibi)e ell via, n'tlD Deum .non ;llnare ipfum;& arrendete: Ii trga f1c:~dr3do amat, non fiat non amare amore ip li ~(. biro,qui ell alDot fUp"tc;ma:: fubic:tiionis. &: lpprc· liilrionis,qlli ~Illtrn peeta •• Dc:um non amat, qui", :lb eo ~Ill:tlitur: ergo ptr il1am gmi;1.ID per qu.:un Eedditur nc:,l;(farin1 amor Dei. reddiwtimp",abilis volunras. Et Ikct pgffif dici qltQrt de potentia apfol!na pulfculiquis vickre Dc:um, .& jmpl:diri~ {ell !ion k"lui amOfC_m, ,amen hoc non elt con~aturalt ipli b~aIQ, led ita cIt debitum (:II: vi viliapj~ prodirc m llllor¢rll Dei nc:cc:a~uium.ql.lod H de: {;laO l10n prodlrcr.!alrcm in oppofimlD exire'non Fofiit.quia ilb vilia ita 3dhzr~ ttni vltimo. ilium. ~nc manifdlolt valunt:lti vr fummum bonum, & prim2m rcgulam. quod non poffit in clicic:nda aliqUl!. .. aion. e ab iUo aucm:re cQnfp~allW. lk fegulnioncro t illque add! lU;'10C a.!!llm dit:tn: J;('gul~ ~li auafum. Q.!!lid it g[ati~ ba=c fcddit impcccabilrm volunra.rem~e[lfl(l:quente( Ii aliqu.a natura,. (tU {ublbnti:1 C:E fe lubet connamralc; Ilimen g_iotia'. &:vilioncm Oei.uQIi pJ)(efi~ pet'~rc: h cDim ... 0- {unt.u,"1u~ ~,cidentalitct • k pa«i,ipaliue ell: .bc:::t~ U,tIOn pordl pc:'~u, quanro m"gis .li {ublbmialiter. Be IlUIlr:Mi~I be;;at;l. fuerir l Q..tlare mut 1 di{· put~tionc itb rciicimus v. oIUBrar«n(UIil grana \'Ieatilka .. & Icquimut de DaNIa Doll b~ ita t¢U~UiS fubfl::Qlt~m flltcroa.luralc:'!l' Ii cIlC:( polijPi:Iit,C}Q~ i~~~O}l~~~(I_n~u;tl~_.bqpa. . .v.,(q-,~~

,,_ ""'--~

. .AttJc~t· .'.,'. _ 43t'

~Q co~lli"o de ¥~!llra ill~lle~ual.1 l)~11 fu~cth:li. lutlilirer q.ta~2·,~ ~i~cra~S: d~ l).~~ djci~us Uliot,d D.T~Ci. l!uin~eIe cJ.1.3~~illlPli~c.~ crl!m~a~i4iot\ebi non t:(fl; pC=';~lf;l.ilcft!. _,

R,uionc=s auU:m D. Tb.runt dUIi;~

. Prim~ ~l .t;jl~' .cr~a~ur;dib~rac:~ef i;)j~iio Faaa; f

Ie-rgo ex tla£\lca fUa. d,~feCiibt1~ ~ ~ F~~biJ.i~ v~ unraee,

, Secllncb.: ta.lis, ~I't'lItli(~ nb 0 en per rt:iam natu~ ram. & il'ltrinCc:c.1m ratioocin vhiuet(~lis, rcgl.lf4 o~nis bOI:i\; (eu cwujs boncopcmicnli: ergoali allquOl. POfCft ddic:tn:. Ad quam f;ido~em ,edul;i~ tur mat (Iued crelltllra non haber tationcm omnii bonitC'rgo .po(c~defi,tre ab iliquo liono. quill h~ bere r.ttlOl1em omnis bcni, &: habc:rc tegulam vni" ucd~l~m omnis bC!ni,fw omniloperaribnlfbonct

idem eft . ,

_ Vis primz rationis feu tonre-quend~;quain fit , Tho, pCli'li' j,+d~ 1,1"'1.117.; .1. ralis cfh Natura q~

t=fi ex nihilo; til vewbili •• &. mutabili:t innibilum qU(l"d ",IfCick he baber pofcnfialltar~m.& non purum adum:crgo C"liam ciu! opci'I1tib,'lUZ CtlpCIt~~

Ie d1e fundatut > ell mutabilis i (I:, pafttliolle- ilJ ddc(i;mn. Prcbo conCtqucmiami NuJlu,fmalgf dcfcdus rclpcdll enris , & bani ~ quallH10fi drd ho~ enun tOlalit~rJ& comraditt"fie opponitur ipil cae,&: ipli pcrfctHoni: ergo natura qU2 eft up .... (ummi dtfcc1uI,& lllllfabili,at!s. quafi~ ell tt4l~{j;,

eus ad non rlf::. qucd c:!l rorslirer ddi,c:~c. «J;l,. erit ,apax dc:fcttus • &~lltilbilitati$ in opetandli refpc:cru bani linis, lieuE natUra ril (~P~X d~fcaElSt

&: mUlaiionh in ~Jfe. Hotccon(e'lucnriol prob~lur. qnia pDrcncia ~ctacina) Be modlis operandi (tIJi;iioo

tur modum camel: erg';. porelJcia opcEatiua Ilbcf* flJlld;lta in natura mucabili,('til1m in 'lumuJm o,e~ raliu;;! lib~l·a.mlit;lbiU, ~a:ctgatlon h3~ Jibcrra-. fern immnrabilem,8c tirm:mlln in bono-.Ced pOtc1l mlJlari sb ilia I MIII3ri .;iutern ~ bono ¢(l ddlc"et ergo hoc ip[o quod libe";i~ ea murabiJiI in r~io~

DC (}pcrationi~ hb~r:c.. hoc ipfoefi: defetliblli$. Eft aurem murabilis. hoc ipf I) quOd It1fcilllt e;t U:UUI. murabili, &; dcfc:tbbili in !llbilum : ergo hOI: il'fq 'luild ~liqua c:'cam(a 1:11 ex nlbilo. ctlt Gilp~ dcf~

tlus.& pcc.,ui. _

Dices : bane rationem D.Th. aJi'UUlcrC ai1fe(~ 7 dens impcninenJ • &: illfcrrc confcqllmriMl1' j(,. kgilim~m. Elt quidcn1 apr~cedelu irnpcrd~cnfj quia ereamram e(le faaam ex ~ihilo ~a idem qllu,

elfe w:lrlltaI1J;& fic ratio ".IIIZ reddum: ad proban.o dum q'l lid C(e.ltU{a lir p~'CJ.bili, • ell: qllia creaCIUa

cit cre~Ullr3 ,quod elt inepcam reddc:re fatiollc:m. Elt.'~urtm c"enkq~CJ1riam'giri~a, quia pl~infen-. qUolm conilnctur III anteCtdcnEJ: i:1 eo CIIlm quo! n:uuu cfi: dcfcflibllh in dfe, ("Jam fcquifQt quOd

clus ormt'o pollit Jdic::crc in ttft:,quod (minimUm c!l:Cc::d q~iDd poffit dc6.ccre mQ~allICr tbnte

dfe cnrlr;uiuo oprr,!!i on!!. non ~pp;UI;r qllolllod!1

eJt u.li antccedcnd infe~'1[Uf • ,,1m G~ ddicimlia 1

fine qu:t non pordi inferri ex: ddicirnrill ab elfcs uc::udic;b £"orpora c;rJc!l:j;l. poffitJt ddleCTC: in fUI) 1 eai: Vel" anllihILuiotltm,&' edufionc:m ab elf" .poll camrll req"itDf quOd paffillt dc:6cerc C1 puu: rna. tr.i;c p,~r madum COrn:lptioP",JPi;~ iQfcnuta ma.-

ieri ddicienti;). per toralem amribilationcm. miMI' deJic:ienria pa t"ouup,ionem: ergo DIf'jUe pC' ipfum dfc t1 nihilo. quod infcndcfetlllfn p~ ~ .nihibrlonem. infeu,» minor ic6cicntill. qlllJt cit

, dc-tidcnria monlis pef ptCt.1l:um. DC1liquc: cU~ Angflos bcari~5 vd ,onfi~~ in gfatia dl n: JIi..o hilo. '" (upc:rnamra!iJ fDbJb,luia etiam eft t:~:'li-hil". ~ r~tntD prOVt takl.lullf i~pet'alnle$ ; eritP ~~PIhilo,llQO 1(1lIJdliW;pt~~a "!J .~rli

. . ., . ..' ffQ;.·

,

§J.t!.41io LIZ.fic. t» ·merilo,e5 pceCAla Angelorum.

p(:cc~bil~. ali" qit:uuliu P?n tollct~ Ub radix;, maulri:itn non cITe [otaliter completam pet for.;

non poilct c;:reatura reddi ImpC:C:~~I~' non rolli- marn, quod iion lbrim confequirur ad cITe limira-

tllr aUtem hoc quod cll: elfc ~j[ ~bilo per con6r- rum, &. ex nihllo : a~ vcro-modlls opcr~ndi {cmpet.

mationem in graria vel bc:-~t1mdm.em , & [amen fcquitur medurn cll~ndi>& in illo fuodatut, & 1i 1i~

r~~dilUr imp~ccabilis creatura p~llblJl. Sf hoc modes operandi libcrih& moralirer , cti~m fcqui.

ideo dl:. qllia eire ~lI: nilUlo {olum opp.Dni[~t ei ear modus operalldi dc::fectioilirC(. ~ mut.lbilirer

quod ell dfe i {e. & ci qu~ eft ha~cre In6Jlft2~ iii ratione formali opcrationislibera:,q\lz cit actin-

perfeaioflem: c:lTe ~u.r.cm 'mpeoc.abl~em nOIl~xl- gentia fini~: Ergo cx eo quod volunta~ Iibera crea-

git inJinit~ pa'fecho~crn~ fed fumelt d~tcnJllI:Q- ta lit c:t nihilo r bene {cquinll' quod nen {ohlm

'fio ~orllnratl$ CIga. red:ltlldmc:m regullt. c:n!ita~juC:. fl':d ctiilm,op::tatill~. &. 'anCequen_tcc

ReCponderut ad pdmam quod obiititut contra morahtc:r, lit defi:t1lbdk, 'luod eft polfe pet;.-

~ntecedens. ·jUud elfc:: "aIde conduccn; ad hsnc cue,

probatiollem. quia ereaturam c:Jfc fa.d:am ell; nibi- Ad terrium contra eandem confequc:nti.imt 10:

10 non ell: idl=tn quod elfe creanmJn, ~ ell ecn- ReCpondctur quod Angelu1 benDs vet con6rma.. '

didQ annexa c[earur;t , flcut creaturam df, limit~+ tUS in gratia ell irnpcccabJlis: u m::cidend. non Cii:

tam •. & ciTe: c:auC:!ram • at lion ell', adurn punun, natura; & ideo non rcquiritur quOd ilOIl fir Cl: ni~

lIoil ell idem quod clfc crcat1,jt,im, {cMunr eondl- hllo, ql1j~ hoc quod ell elfc el nihilo nOli dhadis

cione! fine quibus lion ell; creatUta. {icm .non ell: p;ccabilitatist nili CGcuildulI1 namram i pardi ,a.

ens, fin, vere ~ & bono. non tamen ell: idtm ens mcn comp.ui quod fir impccc.abili5 eX :!c,idcl1df&:

lIuod vcn1tn,~ bonum. Sic ergo CrC:ltuf:L dicit ali- sb ~ninleco l 8( lit e: ni hilo.quia remanet sb in-

quid c:onlhns ex omnibus iIIis cpnditioniblls. non ttitlfeco pcccabilii.& ClI: principiis natUt2. V ndc VI:

Calilcn per 'luamlibet condirionem tX plicatlluo- aliqua cr~tura rtddatuf impcccabilis c:xaccidc:nri~

EllS conceptus crc:aturifl licut ens Increatum habet &. sb utrinfeco. noll debet tolli radix m~ ell'cildi

lTIulr.!. atttibuta. nee umen ql,lolibet: arrriburc ex- .;x nihilo. quia h~.:: fohim debet tolli ad lux: vr aile

pli,amr (otUOl quod ell: diuinitas; &. lie: bene po. 'III id lir impe,~bih: per nafuram ; Yf Qucem flame

lell; alfumi pro anttced~lld, quOd CrC:ltUf~ dl ex natura pe~~bjJj r~~datur impccc:a~i!i.s per gratia,.

l1illilo tanqu:up conditiu qllzdam ad hoc quod lit non reqtnntur quod nol!. fir ex nlhi,lo. (ed quod

creatura, Vt inde infc:raluf, quomodo b:.be;;Jr dcfe- pcrfcll~ranteI tenesrue in gatia,(eu in 1iliquo prin~

t\um;& mutabllimcm, cipio grl[llito cui incompolIibile fit PCCC2tUIU. Si

Ad ptimum centra ilIationcm confequentiz. alUcm 4;n:crur fllbllanria fupctnatllulis. ilia elf"

Refpol;ld~tur:quod c:t (kirclemi~ in dIe UQ folUm t:l nihilo t:lnq\i~m gr~tia, non unqu:lm natura fine

il\f~nur dcfc:dibiliu$ opcrafionis in dfcndo, fed glalia,dc qua falum loquimur in pr.,;(cnti:(ea quia

etiam in auing~nria 6ni5, qlll1: ell formalic:uopc~ implicattalcm (ubJl"anriam darl , vr IIKQfop,;, cir.'

i:idonis,vf mor:dis ell:. Nam qllOd operatio lit de~ olic:ndil'llus in ,r~ml.iom~. ideo vUtlmque fequi~

fttiibili~jn tlf~. nen hlbedn qUMnUDoperatjo, tur, & quod fit c!tnihilo in quantum crumf2. &.

ftd ill qllantum enricas clt,quiaordo ad tlfe: Cohlm quod lit impccc:!bilis in qllantlllD fitbll:antililitc,

(opuenft ali cui in quanmm eft en I. V ade Ii e:t eo circe grati:t.Et ncgamll5 non (e~uiri ipfinit~m pl:l:~

quod "tUUEa h~.bc, deficientiam ill clfe Colum, f~ctIOD~ ad hoc Vt aliqui$ tit impe-ccabilis perna-

infeUllt ql.h.ld opef.:uiCl habear defieere in dfe tidE mram,quia requirimr quod babeat ctfc: indc:feeH.

dicc:r.c:tur in amc:cCd!;Dfl:t quod in ccn(cquc!lri,h- bile,&. im.mutolbilc: in elf.odo, \'[ edam ill opc!3n-

quidi ereaeurs d~ficielil in clf!: en CIc::u:Uta in quri- do {If indefc:lUbili$, non potell aUtem dan elfc

tum Lm5,&: operatio deficiens in dfe eft eti~qllzdli immurabile , &:: indcfetlibildn elfcpdo, niG ha-

ct~tUta inqu:mrii eN. <l.!!ar~ CJ: dclicicnria crea- beat in6nitam p~rfcaioncm; qllia cL:~~ J:UCfCt

rllf'i in clfc?do inferrll~ dc.lic:icm.i~ OpCf:l.lioDis.et~i PQtcnti:ditate• quod ell eJfc- aClIIIJI PUnlfli. t &:

{Db forrnahure opcraltODI! • quaa fub 1nc rtlniiali- confequcntc:t habere inlinitllm dfc, & pcue~

Ute Optt:Jticnis (1Illd3tllt in ipf" efi"c. & modu, aiol1tltl.

t)pt:~di fc:quitUr PlOOUIil dl~ndi: crgoeti~tuin Pro nplican!b {Ci:Ullda ratione D.Thom.ad~ Ii

hiCJationc fDitn:lll QPc:r:ullli tnf~ttur iilln.ahilitn, uerrendum eft quOd rimnis actus moralis ell idetn .

I( potc:ntia}itUJ&con(c'Iucnter dcfetlihilitu.For- quOd. adus fL'guJatlli. {Cll fubieCius alieui rcgulz,

~:WS :aur~m r;lri.oop~m~onis ~ i? quan_[ull1opC!r~- ad quam lit:ol'ifotmcrur 1 babet retlicudinem : Ii

flQ,tll: :ltclngmtt;J oblclli; &: nms. qUia per (lrdi~ diforlncrUl",obliq\li[~[em. V nde opontE" quod prill-'

iltlD ad obicaum,& finan rpecilkatur;JClin~ pr.:il;- cipi:z a quibns depcndcl talis actul hab~nt fibi iii-

feuim 111m-a: ago Ii in quanmm libera hoc ipro defcl!bbili[cr coniundam tetHludincm. n opera.-

Cl.U~ ~Il eR'~ ; &: ex nihilo. cll mmabilis.& dtfc~ rio indc:fcC'l:ibili5 lidn (u.a n:gubJ;ione. Quod a

ilibilis. CliarD in ;lttingeflli;l. obielti • & liois dcfc- principia :r. q_uibu5 dependct nOli habeant fib! an-

aJbilis erir. quia (Ou bote :mingcmu. tit modu5 nc:urn indtfcd:!bilircrrcglllam retiitudinis. ne..

opet:.tndi CC'luitut modum effendi, &: fundarllc in celie eft quOt:!. ip(:a opetoitio in q1lantum [cgula~

eJf~;c:rg(l erit pc:cc.abilis. quu peccatc dl ddicere ?& non fit indefc:dibilitcr (cda. [eu indefeO:ibilitct

nnc,&: a redundin~ obicdi. J~glllat;I. liquidem non potel!: actlH cITe: indef~ai-

Ad id Veto quod dicitur de corpore c:zlefl:i, biliter rrguli1~s > (i princ~~iU :applicans feQ eliciens

q_uod nDn iMcntlt quod lit defeaibile ex pure a!!lum non Jir Indefecbbdit~ Il:gubns. 6quidelli

nllleri2:. vel cOtn:lptioirl$ tlE. eo quOd lit di::fiZebhi- indcfc:-aibiliw reg&l.:lri cfl'o:ntialirer pender t~

kin dre, at quOd es maiori dd'«libilirate non in- principiis applicanlibw, feu danuhUJ i1li regula..

fenur minor; Rcrponnauf quOd non infcnuf mi- riQQem. •

Itor COrtUp.libiliru a tMiori , qUlndo vn:! non re Ex hoc ergo deducitur cilia: conrc!qlll!'nri~ O. 1 i

lubct cOl!fcqum.ru ad albm.ira fluOd noP. fund~ T. VoIUDr~ libera ell: de rc: indilfetcns ad dil.lctfas

til! in illaiG ."im:m in ilb. Eundarur. & toilkquintt, OFfarionl!$ • ira quOd eX natUra fU:l non til: deter.

htne .infcnu£ CY ilia. Defi~tnl~ a.utc:ra ~:i: pate miflat3.ad vnnm:ergo oponc=t quOd Vt tOlli, vol Un-

tnAl«lZ j Ie pet' taodum (~P!lODI$ ~ ltif~ as lir indd"eftibilis in illis opcmionibus. ad qUlII5

1;1 eQ quod ~um fit annlhibbile. qwanop tlm- ell indiffcrens~ pcr fCipCam elfcndaJittt Jit fUll rCa

4btllI in dc6citntia mnibiWillrris • dcfiatnda. Be ~ 'leI ~ iIlam inCcpatabilirtt libi anneSam.

·tl:nwbililas ",au~: ad hmi,; ~ ni&imr Q,aOd ji, nK pn CcipCam etC leluIa ~ DCC aJil1Odf;

habn:

s

Di!Jmt4tiD' XXIIl-' Artie. /.

habet iIIam iridefc_4ibiiitet ailnu::un z ergo ell:. fe defedibifi; ell; 1 rcgul;:ergo p~abilisJq\da nibil :lliud ell:p~(:carc:,qlilrn deficeee a rc:gLJla. Primum ergo, lcilicet q uod Yolaflt~¥ C[eat~ per reip[~m. &: elfcnri;iliter non fit fila rcgula,collftatj quia volun~ Us !;(eat<1 opcr.uur vr fublcda volunttui (uperiod. iUXfil iIIud Rom;t 3' Om"iI ammfl pmjliltiblU [uhJimio7ibfN rHbdlf~ fit, Item quia omnis 'tC~ta Yalunras ell capax Jegt" a.: imperij a Deo , quia ex ratione crl!~rur: I!ll felU3 ~ &. fubh:cta domlnio Dei: ergo potdl a Dec "bi irnpcrari,& lcxirnpeni:ctgo non r:1l fuaregula per (cip(~m. qlli':& non ell fua.lex I nee (uumimpctium. fed imp~r~tiir.&: dirigitiii' a Oeo. Ec eadem ratione probamr' fcreundum. Q.uia amnis lex, is! imperium erga erea-. hlta$; dcriuatllt llbere a 01:0 : ergo nulli crc:aturz ell:: indi:feCl-ibi/irer ann en applicado il1illg legiS. & obedienrjz ad mam ex natura cresture , fcd ~~ gmia .irtihs Dei t4jllra de fe ,rc;uura hoe ip(o qtlod indiff'ctcm ell: ad (uas opemiones. & nulli cuufn regula: eli infeparabiliter anm:r;c~,: ipi. nay cur.! indifferentia: volulliads: ergo ell: vi ~alis natOfZ' non h~bc, ind.fedib11c:m tonn~ionem cum h:ge m~gis. qnam cum allis ohicc!lis , quia ad ornfti~ iJ!diff'ercJu ell : ergo P?fell ab ill:) Mficere, Iicor 1 quocumquc alt() obiedo •

. t . Sea dke!: N,ltn,li hze urio allqllid probo1t,

j eliam probm:r Contu fecund:llt1 conduJioocmj quOd polfet Angellls p~,c~re immedi~u~ conrra legem fltllUralem , quia edam ifta lex prout:Di[:i Deo Iib~rc, &. non til: jn(eparabilitcr applicata ornni a~honi Iibc:r~ ~ ergo potell ab ea dioerrclc; " deficcu~ ; &. fie pecc\lre e~lDrr2 ilium; vel Ii lion pOldt • cur eriam non dicemus qllOd citca finem {upclMlunlcln Don pl)ffit i Deinde vr- ohiicic S I;OtDS , quia lictt aliqua fac:uitas opc:mio3 non fiduaregula • petell: . t~en nceclfuio ~ 1St eon, nattltalin:r elfc: dctcrminara circa ilbm • ficut jn~ tdleAu5 c,!l derc:rmiDatDS ~rca prima pri!]cipii1i & ramen nOD ell ilJtdk~ ip&. principia. ~od .Ii di~rur pro eodem rc:puwe D. Themam , regul3rn :diquam dlemiilliter de ipfumme( principiuln operandi. vel c1fc illi infallibilirtf couinnd:um • qUia 6 ell fU:imc:t r~gllia. dt: ilb. fOiiiialiter ; Ii vero dim.mmiCc infallibilis I;oniuntiio Cllrn r7gllla. ell (ua tcgola virmafircr feu radicalifer. quia etr~lia ell virtualit(l id quod dj~a~ nar i fe J qlJ~ "idetu( eire Colutio C"'c:t. ill ",.,. t; hllillS '1fJ~ft ,6;. Comrac:41, quia in hac folunonl:' eodcm modo reitar probandum. qllod aliqu;t volomas Don pOmt h:ilb«e fibi infaIJibiljrer I & neGcifario eoniunthm regulam rcae operandi, ir~ quad inCeparabilircr iUi adh.uut. eli!l!lJ amc vifiClnt:m clanm ipli tiS {ummi bani.

ReCpolld. ad prnnUItl J e. fequClld'c~nduliont: pctend"m etTt: diJparirattm intI!( legem lU!UU. lem • &. fllpema~uralcm • quomodo· .. vna 2dh:r~ rear. vel non adh.rreat inutlDbilirct ipf1 operanIi. Pro nUnC dicimus Q1100 liccr Vlt:lqudex libe. rl! e dttur 1i Deo quantum ad hoc quod ell. iDeo dt;riuari. UtUt c:tmn d.anu a Deo liber~. idea, prodDcimf ip(;!: n:l.lura. &: potelniz eitl~. &e;, ramcnqu~ v(uro appJicnionemqllC taliHegu~ l:r cft Jifp;r nno intcr {lJpem;tur~km • &. narll[;!lem • quod In: n.mualis in ipC .. m« tomprehl:nfionc n:!Iur:e: habrnn;. ita qQod c:ognofccrn. do Angelus (uam natmam pe(feCle • non pote-ll aUefTCIC aCpet!wn filum Uege lIaturali. nee crrorcm ~ aur dl!Cc=ptiollcrn circa hzc nalu, .. ha.. IX NturalireJ: bbi imprclfa pali porcll primo • & di«dc • id tit) incipicndo ah iprot nallJn. Vr poll.

JIIIB,ilS.7'bgm.if11.pan.JJ.Tb. TOIllIlf ~lcr.

4H

d d(cctur. ,Non f~rur. autem Abgel\j~ inal!lo. q~I~~ obic.!l:u~ n:m.lule-,niii vr COtiremLi~ iii prin .. ClpUS na.rtIrallbus. vilde neque In practicii poccil fcui in obieQ:ultl naturale, nift \It comCnUIID ~fliilis principii~) Cl {ccundum quod. t;(Innm:ntut In lege nannali , & in principiis fynd~rdis Siau~

. rem comra lc:gem naturalcrn peccaree, irnllJ~diat! dcbercr indperc: auerfion em , & errore-It! pr~ai& cum in intc:lJe~u ab ipftl,lc:,ge narurali,'& a b eills prifiCfpii~ ~ quod IlJ[C ncn pardi:; til to nolturalil eogjjidtJ in Allgelb dcficc:rc, Ik err:m: non po(~ fir m~gi!; qulin in nohlS ip{,1 cognitio. principi~ .. rum non pou:fl ddkcrc. Angdu! aUrcm OfiUU2. l13tllraiIa cogfiDf~if in (Ui, ptlncipiis ." quia pl:'r C:C;ml'!'dltnfiontn1 illa attingit ~ & £lnf'dHcJ:lrfu. «cOII(c:quenicrln in(pclfiofli: prindpiotu; & fit non " pordl acddere d~fc:d:tls incipie-JJdo a ilatimli CogoidoliC. At "ere, In: aH~ {UpCfD.iHif:dIS non CDgno(cit I1f ab Angelo Jic,qu cd n6 perffi£ ab ea ~oep;. sere :![pcaii, & crrorcm pilti praWcllm,feuinconJidtwiDliCfii circa c~in! & lie potdl: citc~illoim d,nce-re, « e!( confcquenti circa ea rd~tiJ 'It:Ii~ natur~1i [cgl: dH~lanrur. quatcnm dc(efuiunc fi'pcr~ n;lturallbu~ priJJdpl(s < a qlilbU$ auctcitllr. ,std dcr

hoc Jbninl ~mrlhi~ dicemus. . '

Ad rf'CUnrlu~l Rr:fp. (~DO? Ii ."dIuflras cr!:.ua l-+ non ell [UIlrt.'g!I'd •. & hoc Id,o q~lI;1 fcgulatur pct !rgub'm. & fl:'gellJ ahcu-us !upcdo~IJ. Iletdfe

cit· quod de le non lit Jttlirnll"~ril ad raJem ~C!'gillam. nf'qut ,ll:E1tiOllj· ec, ,(u:rfi lit ip(a ttrtm;a legis , n"lllt' 'I!f(,l.Ilitcr • qllilti ab il'a dimilN:E

'1l propria pJffi(l ipl,i adha: fiD. &. d'-'fcrlDlll2rio

ad fcgul~m ~ (cd uporw quod ilT!'pnmafO~ (ibi talil c:lc:{ermln~!i(J,&' adh:tfio,ab ipfo lilpc:rwri ferente Icgt'tn • veIl Dco aurbore nnUr% per niUu.. raJcln legl' noti(i~m, &. prindpfmum eillf Hcul didtur PI~lm, 4- Sil."lft1jJl1 ,j1If1rnm 'fl1l/ltN Ifti DtI& tml1i fop,,. ttlll • &:. Rornan.l.lpJi jib. [11fI! {tX, 'ltd fljlmdflf1' 0p1l4legiJ flripl1if1f Iff ttJt'drfJ1N foii:vd ill!, adh~fio. & de£C:ftninatil)" ad ligem elt a Dec 011:1 • there [npern~tnrali ~ qui fiem legem iplam.& r~ gulam.lupem:lu:mdc:m Imnifefl:n. ita petefi. (~ proleCl::iolll:!. (5l benefielo gf:lti:lt conF.rmatc ~ n. volunm cre~l:t ddlcet~1 a legc. Hoc (c(dildo rna ..

do porell confirmari voJUi:lt~!l. &: rl:ddi impe",,%hfli$ drc3 legem Illpcmaturalcm • f.:'d bendicio gmiz,non I:X fdol natura_ Et te(rettu huilU nOD procc:dit arguml:n[illli t qllia cum fu iJJJI non (O~ bim fupr:norislir.fcd .cliaJn lit[upctnalurali,. noll porcH: eire nlUlj;t[itcr dcttlmiD;\ra voIllJJt~$ trca-

t,l 3d iIIilln. & con(C'qucmcr bene colliglt D. Tha. qllod G volunuJ crc .. u non ell (ua regula, fed de,..

bel cxpelbiC rcgnlam ;\ volul1r,m: (lip~riori~ ron-' tam(quDtI ralum upfdIic S, Tb.i",4, I.hllill.f 'l-GJ'), ne,eJ1e ell quod tiJsOl ;diqUlID legubm nun iit . ell: natura {u"" d~'fcrmin"la L~li$ volumaii t &: lie el!: natura Cua polli, ab ilia dencne ~~f tl: bl:lJ¢£icio. & gra (;11. ipfills fup,rioris pulbt IIi adh?:rc~

Ie jlnmobiliu:r. Plirno' am~m tnt)do fir ckrcrmim.tio4ir,a ftgem n2uualcm ~ qlJallcfiu OP";UI.l£ n.nur1 Angeli iorn Jintit~ cOitnr;:r, iuxta nwd~t)l

ubi connauuaiefii, id c:11: ~ vrtndo principii, naIU-, r.dibu, iu:n~ modilm '1"0 tt inu:lligit~ ftilktt pIe ... ni.&: comprchentiui! • & 1ir\c atore i &. fte 1'~ JUIltaS e:t dcfr:tlll mori5 pratlici in intel/till! ii, ptoa:dc:nrc non POlCn. peccare. Vode non rrm",-

nc~ prubandum IP hac {:lrionc:: D. ThoaJ. quod

non poffil habcr~ VohJJ1~ CfC;it! illfaliibili(tfl

& necdhrio .. !lion(totm fibi reguJ.un. til;\lt ha ...

bc:r ptilm pdncil:'~' quia lefpcttu . reg~J~ {up~r~E!ltali'.nl FolWliodtg~ c:nraordJn;u')3 tmpohr•

H H b a [llfCliDfi

4~4 ~£jiO t.rx.&f:. be ;neri'o;~retiJijo AiJgelorum. .

" a !ilp~tiod no habct in [e \,olllnt-U CleM_i r~~ci~~ cit;. ~IIJ .~~ attingem tOtum qUod ??(e~ in re ilia;

l[~ prilldpi~ vt ilnmobiljrct itlh~reatca~lle~l, ~Ul;l. fiqllld~ hl~ c.ll modus procedcndl In U1tdlcd~

hoc 11'(0 quOd. ipfa libi non eft lel, fed a voluntatc AligelJ ~ q1ll dlrcu~(iuus nan etl ( _licue . o~ulus eb-

)ibera CllpetiQris venit,ltoll potell ex (Il~ n3fura ne- frat! ahquando vlde~ t ~ n~n diCcllrfiuc) Ea?,e~

telfario dcteunlnari adillam. R¢(pc:lhl ... ero na- nonp1enc.& clarhl!lngu. HcqllC non CO~IlU1'1"

tuulis legis detl:rminati011cm. habet. tIC ncceJlario rut plene: m:'fl:I ,dum pcr fidem &mbulat: ,potcl\

hauer adiLiodam regularn bene operandi quandill ergo ex vi r:aiis luminis ptor:edendo alieni •. f!' non

connaturali mode pracedir. vql:atim dic:efJl~s clr- conlidcrart :atquc: ddeGlu_ose pr~(;ere. qUia noli

~recundam condutionem. Sed hoc non f;l~" An- plena eemprehenjione :u!,d coguur.

gdum lin'lplicitct impc:cc~bilc:m, &; pro oll1nj.lb.~ . Q,yod vero I? deua.ti9ne ad CUPml:lfll~,;i~ t'

11I;&:reCpell:ll omlJisreglll:e,fedColumproahquD Ira I;OlilleXa finc db obl!::fra. & ordmatlo·11l

fulU 1'1J;[iclllati.} vrfum'.lue !inem [ilpcrnatuulem > ~ n:i(u:alelll~ quod (1 :l,l1eIUnlr ab vno • auermurab ahO'. eJ; co c:onltat. quod fi aucrriuli ~ fine CilpernatutaUJ hoc: ipCo non amac Deurn Cuper .lmnb. ~ i:fgO non fubiicit illi omnia .. ergo nee cli:aln in ip~ tutW'1 .. Ii ulledionc illi pttfc_a~ Cubiicimr ~ qlli:i n,ullra': lis dileuio. edi ditede. (olum Umd1[ in.;Jlatura-. lem finem , ramen eriam petit. v[ noli i~pilgnci voluntas Cype~rulfurdi ordini t quad Ii renuit ci Cubiid • ~non poccll:: pc:rfeehm li1bicaionem in nsmrahbus rc:tiutlfc. V nde non POlc:il: :iliquis ~ (upc:rnac utaliblls eadere , quin edam in naturali .. bus vnlneret\lr .ncaliquod PC:C:'-ltum en contta (upcrnaturalia ~ quin c~i;uilG contra natUr,aiil. vi truli (olct 1.1''1l1ltjl. 7.11':. 1. quis ncn porl:l1: p~. caeum elf~ niG Gt contra oulincm rati"mi, • &:. di(~ polirionctn n;ltUr:e • quia ctiOl1Uin. ordine ad CliP". Jl3tl1[alia t;Itio dilht vr illis noll repugn=t ncqllG euereaeue , quia bonum c::1I: ... nlmu;c.lic deuari ad fupc:ma.turalcm lillem. Q.!! -u:c: non liar ddh:CJ:e i [upern3nlrillibus,& quo:1d 6m;Q:I naruraicm, &: principia praltjca l'Il.I.lla'C int~(llm, eft!) in (pe-e ubliuis manfc:rtinr omnia i!lteg[a ill. D:DlIlonibus.

Dcnitjllc flotandllm eft quOd Angc:Ws cifca 6-. '7. ncmnanualem. lk in puris natUt2libus conlidcra-

rus porc!! dllpl icieer procedere ,Jeilica coptU-oo tllralirer,& hu:ra mOdll11l.quCln oarat~ ip&. (i;"eul1~· dillIl it: pOll\1la.r,~tlt non CODD;JEucaliter, Ilccw:ta modum • quem de (I: polluLu P1!llU. ( • .:1 pl%tct. ilIii.Nam c:onD3fur;Ili$ modl1s Angdi cft 'i't in natUf:llibllS verit.1tihu5 fiue pt1tlicis !iue fpc:cuiatiuis procc:~ cam plena. & euident] comprehenJiOoo

ne , quia pcrfeltus imc:lletlu5 ell: • & in atlll~noll

in potc:ntia. E"Crp~aU n:u;waliwu. p[:ECU natura.

lem auremmodum procedeeee , fi D~UI t:i d"I1!!~ gatet ill:301 pelfdC:ionem. &: eomprchentionC:1lI debitam • & imperfeac: uqll!: incuidentcr auingc-

ret finem nalUf~lenl. &'p;!ndpia :l.tquc c:onclll .. Gones.feu medic prA$col,tU:Ut fi bomini non ,oIl. cederct Deus ",t euidcntcr cognoCcc:rcdpra prima prindpia (pccLl'~tiua. I vd prolClic:I. non contu~ mralitcr (e h~bllr~[ mNr3 r.uionalis. T.lIltllndclll

c:rgo (cqucrc:n~r Ii Ang~lus non eUidcntet. &. in~ dc:fed:ibiliter a(ling~rc:r c:om:hllionci. '" media praaica,qllia p~r fe.& euidl:nu:r feu comprc:bc:n-

Gill: :urlngit media.!l( Jine,coucltrliona ~ & plinci.

pia.

His iuppofitis (ecunda. cQndulio fupra pOUta IS prohatur.Erin ptimis quoad primam panem oR:e,,ditw-.&'ex: D. Thoma. &: 19: c1uS furu1ml~tQ.E{lqllidcm D. Th. qui:! exprc:fic canHr:ldir ;n If. 16.M malD Mr. S • .Q,lIidquid. inqlli£~41i". difi PM:IP.9fUJd

"J. ar!li1r,1n nlllll"" PVljrttllt. jn hilI: ,i. tt1,un11l unJifl,rr l1~n PQtuit : m.thmJ ~r1J ;tllfl. inlUnir"" ,n

hil 91f11! [lJIIt Inti?" 48;; .Pd fllilrn in bil in I/lli"," pmltti" pllllJl jip .. rifri 4b "Q. 'lit dicit in 5." mtrh~,. .ARf.tli _t~ vnma jk ~{j1tditj /vnl .1JllJliitlqllltl pmin.f .d nlltUflfl,1fl PuftElil}1tnn t(mvn ~ j1.tiJlJ ,l pritt&ipio ' fUir. "'f.riQ1ru h4VuU'illl: '_11 ITllnt inp~tf1rfi" .. fo,unlllllrffljif b,JUJ ~ flU'" 'l)1i I,Th

U.

-, SwmJ.i tfJndufia.

i r ,Pro fecutidz condllhollis e"xpliationc quoad Yfr~mque (111 parlcm,noundlllJ1 ell: quod finislla· tUrali5.& regula: ;l;tl:ionum liberarorn ell Deus, vt naturalkc:r cognltlls • ~ di.ligibilis ruper omnia, quia I'Hltllfatc prindpium pl'adicum eO:, Dculll,qlli I:I!; {ummum.& prinl11m omnium prmcipium . elfe Qb omni Cteatma tolclldum,&' amandii.qllia [LIm. mum prindpium cit .Ex quo rCf e61equc:mianl dc~ duchur eui~nrcm,quod omnia eius przc~pm imp !cnda f um~& ornn ia creara dillgendatont propcer ipfinn, & ordinlnd.l in ip(ilm, quod pi:rtillCt ad cleaion ern ,fell ad rcd:ibtJtionem acllJum 'Ill i ver{3n1llI circa med I.:!.. Hzc omnia in gentIe ordirlls naturalis tamum I;ogriit.:l.,& :unat:a regul.ue diOlD~ lUf ad:;onl:s Angeli In otdinc n;1turali. Ccu intra limitei n;u:ll(a! ranulm. Q!!:ll\do :uuem A:lgeills delI.tllr ad o{d incm (npcmatllrdcm. nou (olum CO~ g!JoCcit Deft altiori modo,& pe[ dincrfos dli;d:us. . qu~m pt!f narurales/c=dcdam in modo cognofccndi~ Be am:an dl :l.lit~r fe h~ht'Ct quam dre.:!. n~tllra lia, & ex paree rei cl;lgnit~, 6{. :lma:r~. qUi ell: l)ells,Vt :luthor (dperl1atuuUs. it.uendit in ip(UIn quOd ei fubiidt ornni:1, q LIz pc:rdncot ad ordinera n.:l.tut~4 kill; r~li nexu, &; fubordinatione • quOd Ii dcddlt. rep ;ua'drur a Oeo !t!pcrn:rar::tlitct cogllito • &:

Authorc fupern~tura!J. non pOlflt integr~ [e hahe_ JCt & msnere rdpcaJJ Dei authcris Ilatn~I~5. fed debet I;ri;;LlIl :ab eo auerri c:x cop(equenri • Be indifeac. ~od ergo diuer(o modo procedar cifca Ileum authorern natllralcmt ~ pet pfinC:ipi3 naeunlia cognltnro.OIrqu., DC:Llm :lutbotcm (ilpernlru.. ru~m,in eo fun • quod circa printiph mtutJIi 1, B; Dcum n;l.t\lralitcr cognifum pr~c;is~. lion foh:tf1l puu:edit Allgdas line dili:urCu.quia fimplici imui~ulc:dttialD i:um plena comprehcnlionl:. quia vedUJ iIla natUtalli ubi plcDt: ell: proportionata nuc \1"110 dcfc:ttll,kcogllita &multo mdius qulm qu;clibet vedas fupl:mJturalis,quam in vi~ obCcurc Co~ gno(ccbjlf. lit pate: per ~dem)no cuidc:ntcr.G:_ilt r~t nanwlcs. Vnde feqUItUf quOd rcfpellu terU C:UId~nter c:ogniurum.8c Cutll. c:optehenJione non poretatAngclus inpHC: defedu.(l'ccuIariUtIin in his q1J2: unquarnpAf1cipia fpec:uJatiUl proponebll1[Ut neqae circa principia; Ile-qll~ eke;!. conclnliolle$. qub. (am ilIa.quam mas rodcm fimplici laminc in~.~l.~ comp!ehrnlio~ principioru, Circa pnnapl~ :atltc:m pr~aiQ limiliter non poter:l.r Angelm defcelll'm babae incipicndo :!o iIIis. &' ~~do!pr!S. q~ia C~m pl('na.& pcrfcllaal~uc cD • .I!I~~~ JlIce: 'rl'atflmprchendir _i & lie vi(i$ pnnclpus i 'lu:zo: rUIlt !inet I fi.athn vidct medi;,. cam ill.dd'cllibilitcr. Clllili'.l prjn,ipia • quia pl~n:i c:omprcbenlio ipfa p~i~pia iningiJ: • cQmpr~htD60 au{cm nob prnnunt dc6ctfC' ab aliquo t. qlli; nihil later ¥idmr!i!m. At vero. In (upermtlualibus cUln pro:tdu- obrcurej li~at IinipliQ modo procC!dtt t id

, "",

DifPul. XXI/I" '.ArJic. 1.

. ti.im tDfffoIJiifpJtir,,"t.'Yml, relil1lJuUur. tJu~d p'tcJ 'tal_ 'DillboH II~" fumt in 4liqul1d, quad p,nintt tid tJrJ.illt'IIJ '1'IIlturaJtm .' red [windier;; «liquid {u'ptTniltllyalt. Lathh bllt flindil.mctHUrti r:ltClldit idem S.Doccor iff elul"l1lo~o .. ,.t.f.vbi illquit :.A.ng~l$ in ipjirpril/dpHs inttml/l~" omflU Ctltl(IUf_u. qll~ ad 71lftUr,,{tm tlffll11J tl1gitililJl1tm p"tinmr. Er ideo fililt immohi/iter :rm habernUf in togtJitilln~ pri. mmtm prin&ipifi"H11'i. jtA imtlk[!/{J t~rllm i1ntIJobiihtrft ha/gt fil't .. wmli" <flU ffaUmtUm tdgnufoit. ,£r'I"'1I 'Ilolsll1tdJ prUpl11',iuIM{f,.,. i1lf,O,[/ui, lliJ1l{ttJ"e"r ,p _if/oJ ~tilJm 'lJolmultJ '"tim na'turnliur pi f11/1li1uabi1u circd til ~ '/Iii. ltd fJrdintm "(jtllT'/' pey~ 'tif1t1l1. r t7U111 ~ft IfImm 'JUdd ftfl1ti" pm"ti" ytjft(lll mmu tn [uptrRl1f11ralia ,jiUt ptr C011litrjio'film Jillt Pit' .-illlfjiD,um. r mit h", filA ,"Hlittiil in ti4 r1ft pouj1 t 'Ill a~ graatl ;;Alilril ipforufli 1fmwmtfil' in ia '1u#d ~fl [uprJ nafJiMm I;OrJIittUnai1 fl. ll~l 'flHtTitttd~ :ftd 'J"i{Z omn« qrwi IIt/tuttif IIIi&HI,ffdufnit ti flt:llndhm mqdum flil; rzatllr& , ,utlfiqutfll lfl, '1.11 immobititu Angeli peT!ttUrmt 1 ~,~l ilf(:I1f1fUTjion' re!prau !lIptmllumtliJ b~l1i.Sk D- Thomas: vbi claf~p,lter qllo-d clim leI fl:nftllda D.Thom. fit omnino conlhns, AllgelDS non pot.liilc pecc:ue in primo inll~nti r:~ :0 quod eranr in illo inlhnti in- _ C:lp",ce"s dlC(:lIDltlU dc;fed:ll.oli. ex eadem fundamente debete dcduci quOd non pollim~ per fe pti9 rno , & dirc:ltc pcr:c:are coners nsturelem refilmdinem,qll;aionaturalibas non (umc~paec5-Ji~ minis dcfc:tluoG;nec roredt vna f~nEcn[j ... fine alia tehedefclldi. Vnd~ D.Thom.etbm in h~t: i.P+ 6~. a~r. i. confirmat hanc (cmcmi~m quOd non porfir pcccare Allgdu~ cOn[r:1 ordhlcm naturalem, '''12m in [ollitio71t Ad ~,dkk • quod J n atli971e rlliumdi )f"l.tli nail pouft tJfo mill rim inQrditlllfiMH, btn, Iflmm' [mfmJkm lI[fiIJI1Ulllib"i4YbiIr~: S:oi· tim \"CIO Alilliottl! Ifl3' addlE. quod NRtUtlllujl

. A71gtfu '1uU ct1lltJt7tal(h' in Dtllm ./t(Mmlkm qlloJ. rjlpl'il1tipillm "'6111,,"1" lifo: fid 1"M t:lfflHrWl1l1r t~ ipfum Jt~urldit111 iJfI~d eft obie!iHm . h;Iflld;"jl [fIpt'r-mtturaliJ, h~( t{i tx gfl1~r grptf1litu • .i '1"11 RJjm~ potuil pt((lIrrdu_ Vbi tl3re S,Thomas ;lgnofcit pe-Cr c.-nUm in Angdo f<ih'lifl n:fpea~l conuc:diorm in Denm, V[ ell obicdum beuirudmi5 fupcmamralis. Silh:ndo ~rgo Intra n;ullralisordinis hmitef, &:: fi· ;"Jl:: n:fpedu :ld [ilpt[nattJ~alia , vt"! pf;f:tttm(lJ[,uia.non eft in A!lgdi~ principium 0pl'[;ltIdi malum.

J 9 Et fund~mcfnl1m huius !lon ell: 3liU4 qtlam if-

Iud quod poficLlm en aD. Tho.quI'!' Angdus conIidaatu5 folum ill puri~ n;uurAhbos, & liilc ordinead leg~m,vd lim:rn (UpCf":ilUtaJcm,nolJ pOleft hlbcre opcrand(J cOlJnaUlrali~r:r ad modum (u% flatuf;!: dd'i:tfllOfllnl dicbmc;n fariohis: ergo nOll r~m:'ft pro...-t fie Pt'"UJfc-.Col!f 'q, P~{ct. quia d,fethi$: morahsln vOhmt:lte non paten otiri nifi ex: dcfean dilbminis {cgllbmist 11:11 appllc31J[Jsd:

P2rte inrclledlls. qUia cum 3aU~ ...-ollJiJtaris fit rc:gohuu,& in (uHcgulalione, lml. &. in rua did ~tltia onmillo d~ p~n dc=n$c ab imdledo > quia ni· hil voli£um > quin p{l1=CQgnifum. irnpoilibue eJl cOl'ldperc in VQlont:iU: mOflJm • ftu attllm de='dentcrn in rcgulariohe p;lffin3. nlff lit dcJcClus ex- patte regll13!1oni! c:ognirtt, & pt~ imdtcttam

, Ftopofit;r, qu:l:' t!1I: u~gulatio aaiua.Po~ell qUidem yolunf_,u pr(]poG[llm ubi obiettum bontUn~ &. rllgullllJ! rtpdlcre; ~ed hoc crir ex P'0I:~(ltwne ull! n-puh«. qu,:c pw IfKc:UcAum cffi,~cnJS p~opon.il.~ rur j lie hoc Iplum cltftltnofufD ,,11 J &. ddedus ;I~f'licationiutgulte< Qi!ue' (icutIc:pugnatvolunw: ta~em fcrri in aJiqiJid nib Eognirum, iu rcpn gnu {tui in aIPqaid dc:fcauo~e. nih dtfc:duc,i; -cogn,ir tam, :UII prl-pnIi1um. EI,ho~,~11 quod commull~

lMf1."S,Thr/1.irll,fIl7l.D.Th. TomU5 ahet.

.1" '4\1

ter dicifllr qll0il oml'lis pee-can; ell: ei-dns,iCit I'd ~ tHce. k,ltcccn. veto probattir : narn: dcfcll:m de Ctamimsfoh\m I:ii; duplid capite pmell:udfl: aui quia regula ipfa P"f qU:'ln aa:li~dirlg~ndll~cll.non plene ,ollude-ml!f, IKe applrcarur kcundilm (c ad omnia regul:tbilia , ~m qUi,\ alrqmd conerarlum ipli regule atcipi.tur vr conuenieneijrs f.bi, rt-gu.

1a vero r~tioni$ , & l'IaulrJIis lex abummatur , ~

e dic h~berllr, aUf -(lmmilUr, Hot: (eclmdo mo& non pOlell Angr:f!ls pe[ (e, & dirt'de legem ;pfant.

&: regllhm (Ui sbncere , &: odic hahere ~u! Dmjj. rere, qlli:l fcg\lla m~ • I'.: Ie;: dl ip:'uifi bonum n.l." film: eiu~.qllo_d am~CUf IlcccOJru) quoad Ipccl.I!canonem per fe loquclldo • & ex vi Ipliu~ njtur.,Jjg ?Oni;erg~ Jl~n .fOldl odio h.;bcr1 p~r (~l(_)qLlfI'irl~,

Ita quOd lI'1rlrl~t voliinrM ab lp!O OI:hO-Il.uurafisi honi,(c-d COltlID pef accidCri~ pr.[crit odlo h~bcl'i-. quando ~oJJIi.-h,r:ttor aliqllis df~d:u, j f~!I0neCu-

ius dllphcet vo!lliJrad,~~ial1l proprturn eH~, it..! bennrn naiUfl', VI If aliquis pwprcl pl'l':n:\~ qiJj~ lutl:inet veller non df~. 3U~ De urn na;o h,lb~at,cx quo con(~qucnter non vulr iphml '1I-n~rc Vt fintml;:t-o ruriilem ; crg(J P[{ k,N d!tdt~ non p.}u.:H ~olUr~ legel1l nernralem agcf(; ex odio, c. ilbkcl:one; ipfius , liqllidcm illud bonum naumde arnarur CC:-~ celfario qno~d fpr:.ilicalioncrn_ Sl_'!l~"(~ 11'1 ho~ mine. quia C:llm'li. c:omp()IIIU~ ell. IllHlIl kl,jlei-

ua , & tadanaH , hJ!'~£ eeiam dl1rl~lf bC:lfIurt< prc.pEium in quod poffie fem illrra lilItltes. prol r,j bo~

ni , (dike, bonum lpifini~l~ • ~~ b\Jllllltr ~td!Lji~.

& putefl bonum kn(rbl!c ~m~II: IlN1U;1Ltl p~o;. pi'ltim bonum, ericm rclinqLlcrA" rp.um hCJn}rIi fatioJ1i~,6i: ramen in n~lu i~nlJtellri:r , W ~lliU bonurn [~nlibik ctat H;j;:.htn IiTbid.tr,m regql;r :r:;If rit.lIlls, non pOrl:UHlr.a ,iprum in'lp~r" PCCCo'IU;!tI. quoufquc rn~ (upcrior r~liom; :."cncr~n;r a Dco~ Nee pordl Dem! ip!i: ill bot om 1l-1mr~;~ tIt, &: vt ttsuhm r~doni~ proponJt UmJ"lr.Gl •• rc, in qL!atlwm [:tlil "dio hlbcri,quoulqo~ in a, ;{,_fJ ,lfr.'li:pr~~er dfethl5 narurales :cpr~CC:1T re, ,tr <'tl''lwd" tatiolJ~ C'uiu~ p~[' ;u:ddms o_dio h;.be.w~-Ddu , vel ip! .. m bonum n;ullri.lc:. '--l.Eandm auteIt:l wnfidet;l[llf ip-

(a naNra , & dfc'hu du~ n.a(UI:-.h~ • nihil dl:-Ibi quod nOll penineat ad Del1~ auliu;lrem n.turiJ'" !em ,'" ~d bfJnum naruralc iplilU Angdi. Edie tolilln hoc djligimr liJb r~gul:l- ralii'!nis. ~ Cub rarlonc legis natur:dls. At vaD primo weao , fd~\ Iicetex indc:bir:z, confiden~ione kgis :p;l(ur:llis"

f(:lI C;( ol1lilliollt! ali qua c:i_fC3l=ognrtioncm "tins noli roteft Angelus pC~r:lfC ~OlHra iIla!n • QOi3 quid..;. quia pmJnl:t ~d legt m na{l~r.llc=m ~ IX ~d bonupt f;tlionis Angelus comprl;ht'nlioe c:og:1ofcit,qnili c(Jgngfdt lllud in cogllltiot)"t' fult praptiz f1:1mra: 'ILIaD) ,omp~~hcmJi~ ,U {rUlpcr h~bl:l ~t pr(l,;(c=n" t(m • nee .. b ilia, potcft :lu&:u6te: :ltptaum ~ celli

fir primum ,&- imnll:di~tI-Jm ,ogni!UIII. &. ohic-,. Glum formale [ui ,"ollllafuialirer lcqtr.:ndo: ergo ihicC!mpr~-l!~niiue oognofdtle'gcm 1l~~uralern,qllZ:

ad iplam p~till,,"r natpram i cOlllprchll:ndClldo ·;lU'" tt:m c:aID • vidct pdnc ipi:t legis abn~fali~. ~ con~ duliollis. qua: u: rahbLlspliricipiispr~ake JeJu-> ClInmr. fiqnidrnltodcm -p;U!i:o rangir cOftdufio.c ne5, Uellt principia. & .[;lOt adh;t,ct his. quam lUii. hocipf(l-'Juo(h:ompr~hmfi.ue proctdi{;.". ' .

Dkcs:Cut non pored. Angelus vidcndo Jtgcil" iti

n~lllnlcm>""bolJllInr;ttiQnil~JiQIJ qlJ.id(lb miolll- _

,a oditfc ilIarn. (c:a "omp:mniu~. quiafdl.aliqu"o4 bOllllID ptorrium~" 's ,tlctllenria pJDptia.aUt m~

du! cognolc~n4i. JimilHqlJO: pc:dediom5 Angc:~ Ilea:; anuntu[ plufqnioJ¥ J<:lt D?'uulis ptfin1Hit, idill.noil u ftlbieCiioae ~D~um 1Ilthore-n.uurale-;,

~ anrillJ Itg~lXll.ul eriafllDdio bab.;nd9,alWttal.·

_ HHh ~ J\ns~

it!.41.Lix. is,,. De mcriIO;f5 pt"c~to Angelor"m.

"j.36

Afigelum, ~ li'~t enim bonum proprium vnufquifque amee quoad fpecifi'adonem n~t:df:tEio. ~on 'umen bonum :J.licnLlm,n~quc: alrerum t\[)gdul11. . laJ,cm quoad id in qllo di,ftctt vnus Angelus ab

alia, 'It docer S. Tho.fllprllq. 60,",+. .'

Rdponderllc: non poJf~ propool omnia dla Angelo courra legem narura]ctlJ 'It fequcnda, nJ G hi ~liquibl1~ prindpiis,ill quibus fibi [cp{a:fenlet~r it DOIJ um id quod dh'ontra legem Jlllturalc:m,q lila I"IJll13turak elt AlIgdo omnia qua: ~d naturam fpcltant in fuis; pr~cipiis c~usifquc cogn()!'~n:, qlli~ (omprehcnfiuc procedir. Hoc aurem l1:~ndo Jlltra limltc~ o,lO{\ilJis naturalis fic:rinon poref], qUia .Angelus omnia qu~ naruralis ordinis {umcol1lprc:hcn(jll~ cogno(cit lam (pecu!atiua, quam pra~ica, &u\tlUlio principio n~tu[~1i potel!: rrpm:fc.lltati, IX ,ognord aliquid v[ (equendum Concra legem naturalem. V nde propriHxcdlcntiil, '" c.l9.u~ ad p~(lrriam excellennam peninent. non pOI1Uflt repr;r(cntari Vf immcdiarl:, & direa:~ contra ipbm legem n~tllr~lcm dillglbilia, QI1l.i lex namralls iu. iJ'nnlt.bllitc::r, oS( adhercnrer [Cpra:rCnt3IUr Angelo. lieu! 'pCa ..xccJ]c:nllapfopril, IX vnum eli. conecnlis [lib ipGt l~sulll dt tpla propri:i excellcntia vt cOJ1ucni~tH(;;r diligcnd~, & cum rubii:tboill: 3d fihlrn prH1dpiUtll: :Igo "um Angdm prQCCclolt per cemprebentioncm fpc~lIlatill;lI11 • &, p,'a,bc~m ip-: fills leg'l,&.' r~gnl.Y !UU1raU~. OPQtt~t quod ex vi uli~ cotllprch~pliolll~ it.!. imrncbrluer adh.ereat ipfis rtincl piis vniucrf"libl,ls I~'gis naruralis, quOd eusm OIT,Illbl'ls ccnrcnris i~lb iII~,qI1Clmm vnurn ell: excellcnria propri~, eadem inIlTIoblilr •• !c: adh:e, rear. liquid~m eodcrn m.),ln Aogl:l{\~ .adh~[ct ptindpiiJ,&: condufionibll5 r,lm 10 rr.lctici~qu:1m itdp:cnbtiuis. 5i aurcm Jmmoblhtcradh.t~~! 1:1.~lIcjHior proJptl:J:: vr CO(1t~lIlZ' tub lege, non pOldl u1hzrcre Jlli CQl1tra l~gcm,ni6 il.lb ~liis principiis, vel fub :I1i_.ll.:!p ponatur, proprer quam relinquend~1ll vel Ic:quc:mhm c~,elic:nu~ llatJ.![alis , etiam COlltu prcpriarn naturalem regulam, smerur. Hoc IUlt"em iam dl: pOllerc Angtlum cx.tra lirnires pure naturales, quo C;l.ell nDS POll loquimur in pra:Cemi, ~Qd Ji i pt3 exaUc:mi2 u:cipi.ltur y~ primii ptincipium,& regu_l;J.,lligcnda; & lic fubt[~hullr a. regula ralionis • hlb qUl comillctUt~li: vi IUtuU\iUIU prillcipioruM,hoc flne no prudillifi murande (0- n~tur"cm modii p(oced~lIdi in Angelo; qUia Ii cx:

DiUJl(2.!i cognitionc: cOlnpreh~{jua,& perfea", cognaCcitut cx:cellenri~ proptianoi'l 'It prima re" u la. ~ principillm .fcd vu;ooteiltiHub .... uiuc~f.li prill,jpiQ. «per modum·boJli pmiculati5 rub line. lion potdl Augc:dus ihtra limilts n2luralis ordids lCf:ipcre itlun v, ptindpium, niG: immutet OUli7 Dan cognofcendi lIaNralcm. j[3 Vt ex conchdiotiibm f,lcU,1 priDeipia • & lie compr~hen liue nOll plOcedat. quod ell proprjlltn cognitionis impctfca~ difcUrtmos Be. flU~I1:lIuis * JlIDdo ab VllD) Modo ah alio • qllod Angelo CQDl13mialc non eft, li=d COntr~ eins Il;i.[uram. Si talbell JloUa Be ~"trinr~ le~ p0mtilr AngdQ~ qu~ ~!lmtu[alis non fit, elli [ubiici:!tUI Pfopt~ cr.ccllentia. • potent id rcf!U~. & lUfi': iridirc:C1e edam rubtrah« iUam 1. f,f~pm: Ic=gul:J;~Ili.c4ione. &, bcllitt qU36 prin: ~IPIIl~ JeQldio:l.tlODl' pIQpd:iM ~1ccllcllt~m • yt AII1 du::cmus.

11 Q,J!od attinn ad dilctliDn~m prox:imi > dicimus

qtlQd eodem moJo AngtlIH qi1igJE cum e. vi Icgi~ na!ura~.' neut fei~(l1ln. 1i~it ordine quodaJn {~lp.UIU ddigar, ~ 2lium. qui~ p~cipaMs dili~ &It fc. &: nc:ccCf,mo quold rpeclliC3t!oncm. aliUIU alll.CI'rI Ue diligit nlm n.:cdfwQ qUQ,1,d fpcci6- QDO.nua. W.~ij, ilium ~ dileCti(ln~.

C.cude • in quantum (ccaro ~~uenit in ratione. genetic;! • vel 'pecilica, V£ di~it s. l'horn.[U;t4 tJlI~ft.fiO.Mt.4' in quantum lIutcm diifc(t 1 (=,di!.i"! git ilium non dile~ioo(: lI4mfali,{cd e1ed:iua j Et quantllm ad diledioncm n~(Urglem diCit ibi S. D. ad J.qilod non pOt~!l rernocen in Angc:li5,n~cil1 Demonlbus remouerunnec cohn babent od.lo alioS Angelo; quantUm ad id in quo .:oniiiluni~nf.,i ei~ in narlita,(cd quantum ad diletiionC"m e1c::d;iua. & 'luantuln Old id in '1uo dijf,~rum4ngeli iut:&: fa poU·unt !;tl$ habere odlD. CiI'terum iflu~ odiu non potell pa: {e • & dirc:m indpetc ex PUfD mDUUO narurJli,&: Ihnte AngelD in ~l1ru nanlulibus,quia, tiilediD alecrius Angeli I vo:! bcminis > c:riim iDeO in quo ditferlln~. rcpr:t'~nr;lt\lr Angelo. vrCODueniens.ranquam qUid ,DntCmUm IIllcgt IUfWaU, quia en vnum cX ptd!c~ptis naumlibll5 dJligc:rc: at.. tWIRl ncut (e. Vndc h(~r Cit merieis Obf~thpolf" Ang~lil non dii1gcrc ahcrum •. quia nen dl nc:cc(limus quold Ip~'lhcafiolle Cltc~ ben um ,uit:num, tiCUt circil proprillm ,tiln'\cn ip qU.1lJtumiUudbQnum dilcdiollis alterius Angcli cotinelurfub principlisvnii1etCaliblis legis naturali.i. &; Angcll1l con~nlf~li modo prQccdir tJdcln immobih'~le, f,C comprc:hcll_fiolle circa nntm , &. ti,c~ n~l:di~~circa principia. lie circa cenclufiones • provt he nOll po~ (cll:. cdio h~bcre ~lu:(um Angthll11 ,qllia non po§ tell cgredl a limjdbu5 Haus ,cgul:e, & legis nam.. rslis , quandiu irma.limilcs ordiliii n~rolali5 apt:'~ ratur ctlnl1i1lur.uimodo; id eli. wmpr~hcnG~, '" p~lf.d ... cognidonc prot.:di:1".s, ficut e):.Jgit natUra fil.~tbene Carnell Ii (lIppollatUt :du:ri leg; IUu4 benUII~ dlleAiopis ,dt~Iius Angeli t L:Ui legi 6 nolit {c fubordin;ue. poterifcx aliqllibus elf~ajbus.q.i fi.. hi comrarij aut dia~rcntes videnEur, aliuUl AngJ!:lum odio h:l,betc,tti;!'ID non ferU1.!ldo legem nullr.llem,vt mOl amplill5expli!l:l.bitur.

~oad (ccund~iIl ergo pmcI'D cQnciuG(Jnil po- 120 lit:t pr<lb:ltllr ,tum ~x c:lld,'ID lQ<:j$D.Tbomz vbi :!drnirtir peCCatlim polfe tile in Angclis C1 erdine' ad ea q1,la!: (tlpernanJ~aIi1 (unt , ftu in oIditll 3dl~gcm {upematura!em; tum quia[uFr;''J.60 •• ~ s.aa f.do'~i:, ~Il~d IOi.qui n~n ,!!!Ilent Dtllm P~J. .. -: [WIt ex td'Qjlilllu tffiU.blM. '1m enum flD/H1fj~J CD1flr" .. idhtliY' D~fim 04;" h ... ~e~l.qtlod. vliqu.e. COIl-

rra natutalc:m 1cg(111"eft ; tunt quia vr dim jnfr. S. Tho.IJU, 6,.. If". ]..IId. f. ONJnu ,,[{ta ;Dun/miu:.: 'fID/Rnt"" arl,bmttiJ pr~wlmJ > ~fl maiM, a£]taAUtem batura{il b~ntld # ffi porrft, & JII1lJm t.m inm4 tiE/it 4~IIU;1ffHr ad malJil'It :tum d::llique qui;J. om-

nia pectaI:! {CCllndun'l reamm dl'c inD<En.ollibus .. qlla~enilS ad C:I hOIl.inC5 in~.it~nt > dOl;et ipre 5. D.

m h,;J~ q.6 ; • ..zrt .1..ilucr q\l:l;: (lim multl colltta ordioem l~gcmqut n~ruralem.

Rltio autcm a p~iori huills cit t quia nOll porelli aliqua voluntJ.$ fcnu~re CU~J.C'Honem 3d:regulam fuptrnamralem , nili ell: confcquend. & indm:=aa. a natllr.ui regula (e ~mu; tum quia lk~t Q,UUulis regub non d;a~I de fIJPc'n~turahblls ~liquid. didaHillncn ruhii~icDdJ.m clI'e b:me rcgul.m,rC"'" Aulz.;lli (uperiori.&llo dTe: abiiciendam.ficut 1&:):. PI~rori£'diaat (ubiidend:tmetle [cnlcntiam [uam,. & iudiciQ1Q.iudi~io Impl;~atoris vel R.cgis:vnde Ii.. clIr non nat quod aliqlliJ rcae vetit p~rc:(e: iudlci~ PrOl[oril.~ nolit Cubhci iudicio) & leg\ Rcgi .• ita. non Ibt: quOd :l.liqui~ inE~g;t~. & rct£e it lubC:1c (etulldum legem n.atur.alc:m. fi rcnuit (ubiici r~guJ~ fllp'enuturali, f~d. hoc ipro mallet mlncu., ~ non fe-elUS Circa nuur.lem lcgem. • quia lzdinu:· natutdis I" in. eo q.uod dictat ful;niti ql:betc (Ilperiori: hDC enillJ. bonum natUra:. tit deu.ui· ad [uetritu. Si ~'go ~ hi~ ~OJ) JzairlU" leI·

. D~1U'31i5

DiJ}NfAlio .XXllf.· Arlic. J.'~,>,~" .. . ~;,

jUUiI:aHs , h¢c: fpCo Affgdl1' mu!ar coflnatuta," Angell. 1ft Mtilralia 'acclpbt tbnipfehl!i'lttU~. et Iem lUodum proccdtridi prol&ic,;" 6{ in aliqlllbu!' vniu~.& non didid;i.t fic::ut nos polf~ml1j di~idcr.

f:l'b.in (pe,uhitiu~; nlm qUid.em f!;(pc-ch eorum ob nolhum. impatfeetummo-dum pldced~ndL it

qu~ i1~lutaliter '(Jgnaf~t fet~itb.ti.ue; h~cC'J\im ita G Deus de potc:rtiillabfiJjll~ica ptQducerct An ...

im=gra mancrit in Angelo j q,da limplex ell: Eiu~ Ium In pur-a natura·, qU'od non daret· ei rnodllttl

lumen. modU(que t'osnofl:en~i. (cd ifi'quantUm (Ullin ptocedenm connacliraJem. (ttl q\lCld'e~ qu.

aburiuir ad il1dn:audum r::ti.am de his qil~ natura- nuuralia fn:ilf wme • ~ ai:l:;:qa:ue non inre}Hgelcr)

lirer nora nOll [urltiurnillr:: lito: "uk~f.lim prot(um- fed :lHquid ftlblrabl!rer. min coordi~.ate imdlige.l!~

ptucue pr:zcipit3fC iIJdicium. ;;iUt d~ intaioribui do au! apprcbcndendo cum (uo principio t 'fUlle

cogiradollibus pint ludIclndQ; :iUr ~c rebus Cupcr- 11011 repu§Ullrn ARgc:lllm peccare t':"6nrra legem

blultalib"uj. vr dOCi::C S. Tho. fllptA l/tq&;"". f~« nautralcm pdmd,&imrl'l~d'rate~q!li;i.runc:: libl ptll,;

iJfi.ll.b 1114/# fir/.G, In pam: autcm alf~aiU3j fell P?nercrUt impeffea(~& ad cum modum.qwa nei ..

prac!lic! etbm ludicat "ppetendusn aliqll;ll1da id &" prQPOuiiUi Ulle: plena, & perfeall comprehen..; quod ~ PPc:Cc ndurn non clU~t ball tolUm i nde pre- li onc, arqtie a~~t\ poffet illuer~creordinc:m ~u.f!i

IiImir quod AngelUI pecans bOO relinct in ope·· qua=: renerur dlhgete ptQ [lla hbemwp(lffet enun

r3l1do mDdu.m eonnalur:d em fumIljl'lec intra ilIl1m ex pam: ditbmln;s di aiderc,&" non pfopoii~fe 11:11

fe vult COhfinc:rc:.ModlJ$ anrcmconflaturalis efl:- Vt ;1ni~g~fc vnum (ubo~diJ1at~ ad a!tcmn!; a;quc:!

pro.l1edlif ff'mp4l:r indilIiiibili modo. '" ('ompr,h~n~ :Ideo ncque c¥ p~rteo Irb~tan' j ftcqul: e:t' P:l<rIC dfl

Jiuo,& infr:dllum fc .;ontinc:lr; Si COl," hoc ob- a~mifijs imp,"ccabili!l e!li:r. . ,

feroare{ Angelus, vtiqne non pt'c:carc:t :viderct eni m Q.!!od Ii .~ica5: ~rgo Ii potdl: ~nget~H'in~ertcr: 1 +

quod n:l'U':lli~ 1,x in omnibus obruuand:l ell:. & connaturalem ordmt"m openndr, /!r{. IIm:lhgcndl

adUmiJi:! {c:debcTCt exrendere in iplis p.rifJC!piis. cia qua: naturalis I'Jrdinis !"t1tIH:i r~ccalllfinc:rJ:i";

anin8emp~t iordle'ttum. & v()lunrarem omnia iJ1'< pertla!urali t po[C"rir dlcUfi'l!{e; fiq:uidtm ex ali

cis content:!, Vltum ;Ulnm eX conrchm, ell dkl;l.- lion dilcurrir. qUi:! cQmptchc:nfiu! ptoeediH « ...

men iIIud kgi~ llatl1rali" 'ILIad ,uicumquc: r"guL:e go li pote-Ii non comprehentiuC' procc:du~jpo(i-J

fup~nori dcbcdubiici.etiarn (upern J [IHalj. V ,Ide Ii rit d,!currere.

Di:ibolus :lis. h~c:lc-gefc(ubrrahit, iam non indillj· Refpofl,negJfldo COrt[~q.£ud pro&ationem dl-:'

iibilftc" nee. vuff!! , ~ comprthl:llfitl~ omni;i qt1~ dlUr quod r;llio non difwm:ndi in Angc-fo, elf

{Ilni ,OntC"nta fub kge narurali ampl~akur. Sed qUIa compteh~nfiaeptocC"di(.~illinguo.quia com-;

.htlC'nonell_ilicipittJdo nllUpere hanc indiuifibiH· prchcnlitlc procedit ex p;lHe modi 0reralid,,& {,.

urem ab ipla.l~g(! n~mrali ab[oilltf lilmpra,&:; con- ~lJn,Mm eXtg'!l'Iii~mfu~ n<l.tllfZ. '~CI;"d'IJ! q:lli~

It;! t'~1ll ~gendo,(i:d caltlp~t:ltiI!C.(eu refpcl!iUc ad compn'henfiui: procl:dlt ez: par{.;' rtr cognItz, U

legem (uperiOi'e-m. cui non vlllrTubiici.& In hoc {ccllndtl!Ji ~pp!ic:ltiom:m ad hane vel ilIam m.-.ti·

eri:l~ ltgem natllralem·rumpit."Vndl: hoc iplo di. riam dctecmin3re , tu:gQ. iraqul! porefi Angdl1~

ilempmtur.& :aC:cipitptO priricipia 1 cui Jnb~rC'at, rfon~dm:, non" comprcilcnfttll in :lifiqtta mired.

iUam propriam e:a:cellenriam J q"~ erae C(.nr':fifa quoad 'I (tim illS Iff. (e,u quoad Clfc-nlioncm ad om~

arm:.\ fubt~gula nawnlifnOll >Ie prine/pium I {cd Ili~,quz inallqniblfs principii. riianifdbmln'. nol:l

'¥t me-diiftn • feu ,ooch:llio j IX confC'qoehr;:, fadt ramen- potclt modam comprehmlWnUl I:XIJeii

CQI'Uti l't!gnlam rmtfl\ll~m. & deotaiJ1,i, omnia,f~. qu aneum ad hoc quod limpJfci intwns p~Qced.at in

IlimsfintmGhi vldmum c-x:iJIoq!ilJd Ie hab~bar Vi: materia circa qua:mop~2tur. & IlOll"pa- lwnenif ... ·

medium, &. dim in Qmnibu. nolir Ie lubiicere re- larillUIIl,lta quOd duplid h:uninc proced:lf.1_qQe:t~

gulz ~Ofern3iIUtali ._in omnibuJ re~ed~r cx cenfe- osro eu1io; atqtldta,vno vctbo,porctE-norr fro'.'

qllcnu a- tcgub finIS 113turalls ~ q~l:i murat con-: cedere ,ompreh~n_liuc, quoad eifmlion~m obic""

rl:UUml=m modum operandi comprc:br:nfluc, /!-I; dorum.nollquo~d iincnlionem in mOOtJ oper~

iudiniflbilitct c~ vi principiomm naltlr31l1lm, dr.&:: cit primo non infcrclll difcllr(u5. {cd fofam at

fed diuidc:.ndo ilia. qUia lion tcndir in finem naru- [ceundo • qDi:t a.d di(curfum o?orrc:r qudd tumm-

Ja}tm.& l"cgulam fc("undum omnia , qQ;1!: rub tali non fir limplex. fed tUat1I1UW, id {:"ft -mmn htmdi'

tine f;ontincntur; Vnde vl[eriu~ etiam In (pc(ui;l[j- orrum, tit coordinatnm er ~lio. Ad hac:mt:m 'If -

uo'iudicio fc:rc"ildo non fe contin«imu modllm. Angelus pcdtt 1 fitffidt diuidc:ii comprdtt:ntio ....

& limirl:m n~turalem; {cd przcipirilmeugir i~di· oem ex parte obicltorum.(qui:l; cbicGfa [Iln~ q:tlZ'

c:~ndo ~ QatlJr~llblu vlrr:l id QI100. ipfa manifc-l1a- mOllr:nl [r:clIridilm boniratcm, & idiiucmcnrin'U}

I"e cenQ~& c:omprehenfiue POflUl:lf,dlquc, 'It Ceffil' ira vt in Hit, non f~Ut:"'OfdinrnJ, quem ibrur.aIitci

accipumdo, fOllnlant obitGla, iddf quod lint'" Vl'oltUr 'It fine,&:"

~ J Ex qtl(1 ftquJtur verom elTc quod fupd notiZlIi- pri!lI:ipii$ 'It' prlndrii~, & mc-Pia r~1!4u:1m medio,

ilIIIS. q\ldd Ilia cOflcluJio p,ocedit fupponrndo non veil} qllt'!"d ira diuia..t nirllT:Mtn' filbordi~

quOd Angc:lus proctdat c-onnatur:lliu~r. (eu. iltllta tionem,qllod vellr vd media 'It' £inti non (nm,td"i";'

modum fUllm cGnnaturalemageudi,quod non jil- nando ilIud legi filpctll3nJr<di i &. c:'% cotifeqU!nrii

tcUigitnr lie. qlJoJ p.ocedit qaando AngellU opt--- nt'"qrtc: (ub n.1tmaJi tl[iI,"I~inmdn; Et liter in #!iz~

r.nut connaulfalitcr. id dl: iUJ;ta id q:uod Uigif (ua flml nmm C"ogniriont patrlt" mire A'ngditt fd

ntlrut"QI in r~g!lLlrione uCt4, quaG JiJodus connam- [Ilis (p~~cicbll!·inad.riJ·Q:ir~ • &: non-- orilrlJa ad qn6

rOIl is fit ipf:! rUDiediD :ld I"egulzm mrurafem. qo:e . !'oJfunr (c tXrend~e iirriul incdJ;g«c-,quO!f t(fnolY-

l:eCta eft : hoc ~im idem clfer,ac dice« quOd pon comprl:hend;;ic illas quoad d:'~nfionem > ner rU

pa~cft: p~care contra legEm nawulem , qualldill' mm in hoc p«c:rre i ,:tt~n!' dHClngc d~(ua~

O~C2IUt rceundulD r~uL1.1U llatlHtiltJU. ten orin- tiD qU3m in pr:r(imi. quia aliud tft Angdum jnad_~

Fleft peecate Coorn. regul~; q~.lIdill oper:ItUf zqu:!tt vti .pnidin$ qutJ:'Id c~orce.rida obi~4$'

lccvndum ttgubm. Non He Intelhgtrtlq fc=d quod. carom. '~Iilia jflordimf~ • ft"n tnr!!nfem otdi'.aad·

IJDn'pec:Cl!f c;onm·l!.!gcID n:ttutalcm.qllaml"itl cpe- inuc:rrrncfd; i'r;t Vt' pdtlciplint:nbtprd.;QlI¥o .. '

ratur,co1tfl~tur.dirct t lie in:ut'!I!odvm (IlZ n:lillrz~ ne,vd ,ondllfion~m ;)_ ... eipi~f pro priricipio,ac meo;

idelt p1ncipia ipfa'namt.-.liz t ~ nnem narotalem dium '"ccipiat pro lint,aut e canna. 'area ~idem

inteU!gendo.& accipieudo- c:OtnptdjrnGue.& ~ni- . Arigc:lUi emmill' ptnis D~turillbn! .. ri iNdltqvar!l le:Ji«lt ciliut:a.ntt~poftulal~ tan fp«ul.atint quam fuiS IPfCh:bus.& POV d~'nia'6liicd:t q:VZiB qtJ;t6 pnakhSK:'CSliDl'~~~=di~ jibe. cCJtti1mSEar~tillgm: "on Ian'lCllitGt fadl '

HHh, lIifi

fi!!.~jf.LIX. eSc,' De merito,.f1 pt.ccatoJ!lhgtlOyum.

citando ad rcr p~ccat:l·. -g11~' ·liunr'ab' homittibiB! coorralegem nlt~~a::dii'dettl·;I.titem ptbhibitionis' cft,[1oI1 f;tcet~ ilia;&: nQIl' incit~te' ad'iIl:t, Similitct, Da!lIloll ,habc~ modo odiumE>d" ·~Jana.oru.m Angdorum, &. ho~inUm(qu~ornnia;{untc0!ltJ:~ I~gcm n~nlr~. "Ergo ethtrnpD'fhrm p~ccare-ADgdi imm<=diatc contra legem nilmrz. PrDoatur cOtlfeq~ quia G VOlllllUS Angdiex 'prihCipii$ <!Iaturalibus , cit irnpotc:nsad peccandumsqucmcdo e~ ~!etJatio,! ne ad (inem (npetnaturalemporefl: -r.:ddi potc:'ns

. ad p eccandum contra candcm. legem natutalem/, He enirn fi'ttct Deo 'aurhotc deterior.& ex cleua. none diuina jrnperf.;-d:ior.N;uIi non'potre p~cate COIlIU kgcm naeeralem, pCtfeI2:iDc~.6cate con~ WI potentill ad·peccandurn,dcfctlus efl::ergo,fi. an-

te eleuaricncm non h~b~t- Volub~' Angeli mum c:lc:fc:lhlln. & poll deU~tlollem 'nabC"f ::fir ergo da-' fcdllolior,& der~rior Decaurhcre, O~indc quja liberilU volllnt'lti~,& cognido intdldhis circa be .. num ordini~ namralis imrin[ece immutat;J tn3.nen, ante eleuarionem ad finem (hperuaruralc;m.& pclh ergo Ii ante non portlal![ pc-cafe comr.:! iUllm n_. DCIII,Il~qllC polid puu:runt. Be e eenuerfo , JiqUI;' d~1ll non POIC!t lint "liqu3 murarlone intIinh~ca V(}im11J5 ilUpo[cns ad petcandum. reddi patens:, wei C contra • eX d~IIJtjolle .uuem ad finem fIlP~f;' naruralcm n-hil llbermis. ;l.l1t ifllfinlec~ immur;loo nonis :u:quint i\l,1 libertI'S> Denique fi dicanlr iD~ lfin(~'~ non rnutari bbc=ru[em , aUt aliquid ac'1w .. rcre puiU.a.m dC\l~lionem. quod anrea.iion habe.. tcr,(c~!;Ib allq'Jo cnmin(cco, lell. ex neuo motilio", '1llod ani~ non pt(lpone~ar.ur ; c;qnum omnajn>'. Ibn!i:!! !).V;lJiluu hied,[p" f J.t.f. & Su:m::z lib.'

3 ,d~ A "!.di4 c. 7.Arm bali5 bi~ d.'jp. 179'''' t, &: aliarum q U:1: rcfumcntiJr in hoe; <{'tOP Angell" 6 ell:

((: cRct impcccabtlis contra legem n;ltur .. l~ QUi.-: ]0 InO[iIIO aut tin!': poller Inoued ad PCCC2DdIllU conrra illam, Q,!!od t1 modo habet morilla. :ld·plC~ l:Jndun1 • qu:r: in Ib[1l ffil:tC D.atpqli non h~b!:rfl"": in pnrnis non o.nma motiu . .t. ~odo (QAt connannem furcrnacura.!c:rn: !lam.edam peccsne , li'.Ddi"o habene Deum.inuiqcl'lriamqne aliis. quia [evjdcllt cruciarl , Ijl non {'ohlin qUia beadmdlrlc hint pri-uati , nee appucr • qua: nccc:ffitas Gt.Vt Angeliad peccandum. debeant prius moueri ex ,notiuoJinis' fupcrnaluralis • & non poffint ex. moduQ natura Ii inuidere a!ii~ Angeli.:!, aurodic hlbl:fe Dcum.qu~ 3d hoc non mouenrur ex ipf.:!. lege fiJP;:matiJrali~ _ ftd CHO quod videnrfepriuaros donis grarilE. ft· lic:er minora motiua fortllc fub llam PU[~ natillali , ad pccc,mduID,quam modo fint III {btu damnatio.. . ni$;t3m~n tunc omnino nOll dt:cJfenr • quia:ad hoc non rcquiti[ur error 3lilllli5, fcd dc:fcuus confide.. r~tionis • "X quo rninu$ dli,a~ltI:r ~pprch~ndi(ll! bonum hllndtum,qtlam. dclcCl:abilc nJ vule propriU[ll; ntllla 3Ulnll ~pp~rtt r~p\lgn:mria, Cllr nOD roll;:t babcr!:: Angelus in flatu purznarur;tfalern . defea.uID inconiidc:ratiollis,UI;UUlloQO h.lbct,fup- , po!ita nOlilia legis fuptrllatur~lis. At deniq!l~ quia Angelus lic~t modo pracedar u rnoliuolcgis.rn • pematurali' >" feu colllra ilIam. tamen vtri1, &. pro- . pde PCCl;:U; conm ipr~m legem naIUfaJcm .. liqui- ~ darn abiea-um circa quod pecc::ar eft· prohibitum lege llat1.lr~ Ii, ~ participll maliliam cius; ergo U4 gnum til Angc:lum ex n~rur3. (lla. 8c irma Ihnit~J , purl: n:ulltz non tift: oruninQ ;geii:rmin~tllm.3d . lcg~m rc:gulilIllquc n3t1.tralem:Yc_c,llim nOll PQ1l'~ . 'yae~& P(Ipric mint pcccare C9~~(a il!arn. " . : . .

_' Adprilpum Re(pon. Angelum pro m~;thtll""" nOli ha,buc lihcnatcm cp.nu:ar!e~atls. ad.p~m- : dllPl loottaiJlum . .,6ncm 'natmillcm ut: foh,aiio-;

4¥nf~U!DJl(~#1~wP~~~~'~' ~~~5;~1

tafCd1

bUI [ertt.li'JIlo ardinem formale,", , quo ipfa:: ipe~ks J1atUr.llit~Ilr~p'r;'tfcrlC3nt. fcil. vt :vidca~ us ~", (uis p.tillcipiis,quia-i1"iUis c,ontin,en~llr .. & fimph~llu~ mine, id cll.l1ondupll!:~lo,l~,qu.Qd vnum onarur ex alio,qllalc dUumcll iIla!i~u?-,~ SL non limplici JUltlille vriru r, noll [9i1)ro.a~llIttitur ,comprchclilio > fer! edam ad-mini,ILII' di(clldllS~ vtin ,nobis,quia fit lu,n~n iIla;juum~ 5i vtitur [urnine fimplici,rep ncn (erll~[ ordillcpj.(cufubprdilla:tiQIlCl11 obiedorum. fed .tirm: _in.~jio· t;lll.quall\ line. .non Juhordinando illud fini,pcccat.liccr,non diCclmat;fcd ramen non pOlclHunc ordinem i[Jue~lcrc ~ngdllsop~ralldo. protcis~' ex.lll'Pln~ natursli , qUia ,ila~u~.ale lumen ff,mper p[oJ,:~dit .or4i,nc (110 es p~mc[pll5 ad. conf~nt:l. i.o i.llis. (imodo connarurall , /j(. for,mall pro,cd:tt) non tnodtl pOlcnd.ali, &: confu(o;GcUt IlOS, 'lui moM Q~ hj$,modo ab ilHs prccedimus. Vn~c Vt AngcllJ5 hunc ordincm illucrtar. 0POHCt quod. natl1ralii ma. fllbiicialltllt aliis principiis/eu rc~ul;l;. fcilJl:Ipet/1:ltut~li; cul cum Angel U5 non fubikiatllf

. ~ ex ipfa vi n~rur:JJis lumini" potcll3b ilia (c {ubt~ .. - t.tre, non fubiid!':uJo illi c~ qu.t n.:muiliia {unt.&: (libiiei debeccnti<llHiu Ii lion Iubiiclmr, {cd Cubt.aliil\1t ab ilia. hoc ipfo non vrieur Al1gdll~ propria !;l,~llcotiil. vc medic , (&:d vr finc,& principio ~ &: c~nfliquellfcr, ncquc fubHch ilbm Hni IUlurali. feu I)e.o authod Ilatlluli.quia!umil:n l1~tl.lf~lc.hcct nibil. diCl:ct de rUpcrn3tUr~1i linc, poiitiLl~.djlla! ~.i~ In~n non clre illi Il:pllgllandulll. ne ilb co lilbtra~cl1dum. &: ~K hac p3rt~ rUinpitur, criam fubordil];lIiD.~ {ubii!!tio ad linem IlatUrakm.& vulner~tur in OOltu(alibu$ ; qui Don fc: fubii!:it ~lc:~ibu~. ,_

~' .

: ~ni!.llihilominu~ pr~ciplla:: obicaion.:s rdbnt conru. (C=;;Ul'.l.larn cOllclulioncm.

2. 5 . riril1la,qu fa. 11 ngdul edam 11] pura Ilatur, ell; liq,cr bbcnati: .colH(.\(h.:liollis,&: ccmrarierads, non miDU,~ qu~m nunc:: ergo petell p~!:are. Conrc:q. p:nct. qUia libcrras connarietaris c:li circa bonum, t!?nl3.lum.Alite,~d.p:net,qui:J il'l {btu naturlilis ordi:us non omnia. obiclb amar nec;dl~rio nc:cCffitil~ fF~cili~[onj5,hili tantum bon u m prop(~um.cl::11 in qllo nen ~pparet 1I1iqu3 £JEil'! mali • & ramen natpr~ lex C(i.OLt:Il plQr~ prxcipit ClrCil beeum alie.l!Ql1!t!~quod ribi non vis.aiu:ri ne feceris, &c. crg~ potell DOn ;nnatC iUud t & lie pc:c:care contu. il-

ht(J.· .

~. Conne. 9,~~ .intt3 puram hllur3ffi ell: Angdus QP~~ v t fibs Iluponatur pr;tc;cp.rum :lliquod poG. f~':Ium non fupc:rnaruralc'-Cc:d mere nJ.tur3[c. v.g. quod p~;r:eipi3.[ Deus 1Illg~lo ire lid falem lo~u,", vel quod mirtifcl1c~ t~lclII c;ogit~ioncm (uam 31- t!:ti,\'d qllid 6wile.« iUe po~trit Ienue~e;Dccl;nim ell; !Ic:cclliums ob~dirc omni prz~cpto potiduo. ri~ 3prarc~ r~rio an' pOffiE 3 p{a:~ri~ Cupernatur~jblll fe (Ilbducere • & ~Oll ~ politiuis naturalis «dinin .Ergo mrralimite5 pura: naUlfa' porerit .Angdu$pc:c:cire fine aliquo ordine ad (upqlU.tll-

1.~i.L. . .

. . C(mlir.CeNndO, quia AngeloS !:Ion pDtell Yiti~ bus (uis line gl:ltLl. {('l:ua.re I_oram legem naruraIf'9>fine gfoUU inqluM. ordinis n~tuulis • &.. 3uxiJig De.II~Wlern:i!:ergD tllm dt: impc'Q,~ili' ab in· 1!j~(E~. ~ih non 4;l1ct g(~tia qllcd non pc:carec.

~.rI;[lPr~ lc:s~lll. . ..

.l' StCU_lld<l: d!ili!:ul~ ell: iam .cupr! inlill~~uiil Angclu5 {and dt:.UliI?-S :& ~ (Ilpcm.u)t;!,b. pCltcll l't£qre (;Qu!:ta ~atutalem li:,em. 'It modo de fa.. QO~~nb fCt:~tlO~a ;,cmll&~!n.~.

~

'. -

DifpNtlltio ~ Xl/I. Art. J~ ", , ' ~t.Jc)

rar~m 'ad pecc:an'duin COlma eundem finem • noli de matcrl~ bona i &: ardlnaia iii bonum 6n~m' S&

{olit:aria. &' (carfum ac-c:('ptu~ in puro ordine nil- confequcnfet" rub illc . fine ri~tilrali (Oocentum·.11l

mr:rli,Ced .... rcnniuntJ:um.reu lubicCl:UiU fini {lifer- ell:f~b. D~o aur~~re n~tuf~li, ec,in ~rdine ~d ipsii;.

lI~ur2Ii, 'It expliC-2tlJm eft. Rctn;1I1~C ume_n in An- ,[cd III Ipfa cognltlC:me~'" ddhmllic quo D ctl~ pro:.

gdo libett.u quo ad exefdriurn. & rc(pedo hnlus, pOriilllt' 'Ie finis naturalis;& lic anmut, & ~'e:pri. '

v el illlus oper~tionis cird bonum: nee enim nced- tur , hoc ipfo ;lccepi:anror omnia pt:tcepta (ub taIl.

r. =fb~uod Jibmasv~ tidlbmaJ~fit d~fca:uC(ii, &: fine ordin~bilia, qui:dUdillis ~m,uuI Cuper omnia;

eirea malum pro ornni lb.iu. & ~ontid~arionl:. Et ergo Angelus fie diligens ilium finem , virtualirel:

cum in(btut quOd valunlu no ne,cffir:lcuc quoad omnia ptle",epra rub Ealt6ne otdmabilia indudir"

'f!ecificatiom:m amlUc!omnia. bOlla qU;te pr~cipitln- v~dc: non pacet!: :diqllod eX: jlJi~ pra:ceptis non ad .. ·

tlU lcge namrali; pr~(enim qn:t 'Ia~ntl1r erga at- mlltc:,o t hili (imiu~t amotem ifllus tinfs n:i,urilii

tCllun.ltefpon. n fupd diCti5,non neccllirari pef niperom~ia. quod cll non haben ilium PIO firic.

fe. Be ex mcritiiobietli,lcd cx modo quw Angdus ~f~~e. adeo ~Ii i,?mob~Jjtgr ad~retc ~ prihcipili

G;lfU' ell: ;1pprc~dere.~ &. p'fPonerc ca qu:t ad 1111 vmn«fah pratiu:o. (ec:undum quod di!iginili:

naumllemordiiicm (pctbiit.quandiu lion (ubdun- Deus nayu(:i1is, a\uho~ {uper omnia. <1.:!!are egc;

Wt (upcdori ,egul~, fed iliX~ nafUi:dem 'modum nul lam vde~ ddrl:renn~m IIi~ct przeerta nacuralJ2.

ab Angelo afungnntUI,& dltbmc::n formatud fie , IX polidlllt III hac pane:. qUia p~;'C¢'1'{a DacunJja,

enjm 'ill~cmnqiie Cub pr:tc('p'I;I n:ifurdi cadunr~ qu~ yct(anUir circa media d~d (iilc:;, u. <i.~ (uni

tUnit~g!jlcfiU1f ptf Dtdlfirnl ~d finem natnralem, ad nnt!1fi a.::cepr:iiitUf ab Angelo in ip(o line, in

$c ex principiis nauuahbus dedncaprll:, in ip(~~ct qnom;dia attingft ordin3t3 ad falcm finem ~ vfide

nne ab Angelo ~unglmmr. &: eadem ImmDbllll:i.~ njjln'po t~ft ftare,quo& diligarur ilk fini! (uptr Om-

tt: fenu£ dLclaPle:fi Angeli,Be voluDfB circa iIIa;at- nla , &. non ac;(c:pt~ntUt media, ad f31;m tiilem or:'

que circa ip(uJn finem, (,c circa principia vniaer{a- dina,a.& 'onfcqllc:nt~r ipfa ofd(naEio ti:n pra:tc~

lia , quia iRc ell modus connatuulis cognof,encii. mmralia, quibu5 talia Incdia ~d iUul'll fil1l:m OfQj~

Be yolc:ntIi in Allgclo. Vndc ex: vi hniuJCoOlrit.uUf nanmr.Sed Jilbllitct hoc Ipfo quod diligihl4" ille li~

ad IlOD velendum allquid I,lppoliUlm l!:gi narura!i nis (uper omnia in genen: natlJr~. vjct~Hu:raccc.;.

nHi mut~ mooum rendendi in legem ex {"bie- praror quidqllid prll::cipi poteit pOHdlle in ordin~

ltioncad legem (up=[io~em quam pofiimr reeufa- ad c:.tlf!de:m linem,quia li pta:cepio po6~iuo tenu~~

te.& ex confequ.enri enam n::l.tucali legl nee lilbdi. ret lubiicij liD!: ipfo no n diligerc:t DclUU Cup« om-

qlli~ ram; n on ex vi iplius: namralis luminis u:ndir nia: ergo ex (uPPuHtionc quod 6ni~ c:n a~l!tPtlira'

in ralem Iegem;Cc:d ex ordine :&diincm (uperioremt tal\(.2 comprchen~onc; ~ im~bili,af¢ io ."It in: ipfli

.2d cDius amorem nen nc:eeffiutl1t quoad fpc(ifi", :I'ccptt'm"~ Omnia media te''ludifa. ~ qllJdqt!ld a4

c;nioncm.neejcx nacuwi dc:rermination!:. &; ordi- ealem fincm ordlnari arleU , & de Dccduc:ue p~

natione. te!l.q~lia ?i1igi,u{ (~~er oln.ni.i!erg~ n~(i.ictro'1C'cUt

20 8 ,Ad cOQfimmioncm Re(pan. dre circa hoc dr- AnSdu;: 10 amore dlhl$ 6111$, & pmu;'p'j vnkretQ.;

u~&s Ceiltallias, eD:1M inter ThomHlu. Nam all- lis pra-did. non pore-It UIli pricepta aliiicm::. fi",i

'lui {cntiuru: poal: pe~c;ue Angelum in pum natllra nee n~turali .. ~ qwa in ho~ DUlla eLl dif'.irenflll a:

pet viobdon': pr:t'c-¢pO pofitiui quod poffer D CDs {uppofiti(Wl(! quad Angel." in 'p(a eognitiOllC'#

ilDponc:re ilIi in «dille ad /inem p~wull!m" li~ct & ;jcecptarioac finis:, cogno(dt I 6c l!a:cpfat p~c

non p~e "ioLuionc:m przccptomm. quz fllllt de eomprebcm6oncm > & filDJ'lkcm atiwn immo-

iDtc oa[ur:E.lr~ BannL-Z. & Nazariug foptr hltfle q~. bilcrn emnia mL-dia qu: f;: habrnr v. conclufitlDef

, 6;.sn.r. & prob.tbi!l:J:epurat Ledefma M P.tif<'"je,· COnnela: bni. .

#t: D,i q •. 6.,frlq.in ffJ;.Tti~ull11..1k idc:m:l(uihllJ- Q.\!od Ii dieas ; lJ.!!ia poreflAngduf in ip(a J9

tilt ZlJmcl {"PlT brlC Arti~Hl.~irPffl~. Ab, "he;) di- principle; non :lCctptlite ill:ml kgem poliouam ~ ~ ,

wpuIi D.Tho.wroluti\ & line limirafione docent non (I: iIIi fllbikcrc ell. amore acelIttuizpi'opri%~

iJ1 ol:dine Old fuu:m nalutalclU Don POtfll pccc:lre {i'llt t'~uit fe rubiiccrc fin! fupmutlltali t & a

primo.&: iwmc:dbra,non diltingllcnrcsde'bis quz c;onfcqllcnti pecca~e: CO!ln;1 tegulam • &:6nenl IIa-o

iubenlilf pet pt~eeptum politiuum. vel iere 0:1(11- tur:llcm. Ilt::C fe ilii Cubiicere; .1;1011 ankm eX fUl'P04.

rZ,ticur fenriullt Autb(lr('~. '1110$ ford ciraui.Jnu5 lidone: amoris ip~uf fini~ proc~dmdo, quia ho~

pro Dollra fentc:mu.lh. in IpC'cic: Ql10d cii:lrn polito (Ilppo(i[() non pordl rettOl:edae. & miicetl; pr,.;~

przcepto ponrino de Ie nari! naturali adbuc An· cepta q n:t in ordinc ad ip(um ponuntut~ GCUt :u;-

gelus nOD pollir pecc:zrc dir~de. lk p;r (c primo CCpt;lto line Cupernarur21i,& djlig~ndo ilJum fllp:i

COnrta mOIlUl1m merenamrale (ecundum ule: prz- omnia. nOlI potcft Angelu. rmncre pra::c~pt;l po.

c:cptum poGthl3 &fcndunr l'hu.trtUI: hi, ~gf1iTQ.. iidua qll:;t tirca ulem fin em fib, impOCl~ntu,: ted

""fiI'7!";' t, 6c Carlnelit~i SIl{ll3Iltlc. Irlfilq.J, UITI~n perell fi:uc quod l1b initio quando Ang:fni

Angtlil,di{Put.,. J.b,j,.n~flI'H'& f I. liE vidrIilr debuir ac«prU'c legem n,aflltaicm t&eaquz ~d

anagis pr"pender(: D.Thom.in func (c:ntntriam. ip(;lm otdiD3bantUI > rcnu~a: aliquod pr<!:[rprnn1

quia Dufqaam dHHm:ir jIllc£' pr.tc~ta Ilaturalill~ pofitiuUtn libi impotirum proprer ClI:ccUcm:ia.ai

Be pofiriua quantllm ad hOG quod non poffir ptC- propriam. 'lndnefuharct nOD ;tCcqJtare c:t cOt:lfe~

care Angd\lS Contra prima. bene (.lmen !:ODtra fe- quemi legem narunlcmj& in (urDm:l, quod ptocea

C1l!1da. (~d ab(elurc docuir nen poLfe: pecore e:1 dace Angelus: circa mud przccprum p06tiuum.;

lIilobno mere mnuali, & {olilln admitit polfe pec:- bCU[ arca pr~ccpttlm de fuJe (npernat1luli~ ,

are eX modll(l eelato ;Iii fine:1ll fllpeInar:uraICiU, Vt Re(pon. idem :ngIlPlrn£lUn prQrfU1 fieri po-ffc

mlotU{lipr;',it.videriporr;{t. de q\klllbetpriccpro natDuli c:(mc~mo rub 6n6

:r. 9 Q3!arc dll:(nd!lm ell. quOd Ii Angelus m.nct til DalUnJiJ v,g.dc diligcndo aheti:l Angelo,Be iwni~

puI:lna~Dta t prZ'cr;P"!m q~odc\1mq!lt: ei P_O~anif flidtndo jlli dona namrafii, ~ de timilibiJJ i qual

poGdul!lll.dc6et ea'e Cite,," aJu:tuam reID wdiua iu- polftt Angelus rcnu«e filc p~ecptlrin Ciica il!zm (uulls = natn fi dl circa tem ordinis fupenUfUta1is~. nmeri~m ~ & 'eODaew ad propj)all2 tieelkntiam

ialll mUCahU' cafu~.& nOll Ie:mallet Angelus in PIl- vf:td finem.& m,de 6:: tOllf!:qllalU ~bilcetC- ~ k k~,

ra DatUfa. Si ergo ponirur pIII:(:~ptum 21iquQd 1'0- gem n~ttlral,m; Q.!!Qd 6 hoc non :aa'niiuitut. qui~

tililium. oponn quod iit DfdinamlD ad flnem na.. talc przecpniin naturale l;omirmUf ru& tin~ Hlo

tuni!;lU.quia alm De PIZ(q't urn i nco.dcbct elf' ClJdiml nannlis i 0«" potdi ftt'u Angdu.s- in nle..

e ' digiti

~fO

Hium aliquod.nHi ex aliql10 bne, licut nee eenclunOlles,nili in :iliquilnisprindpii'~idt::t;I di~cmus de pt;l;ccpro pofitiUO (upetad~lro. qU~B CII;n;' tale pt~ccpmltl contif1~mf f ~b 1110. I1nc;cum ~rd~CIU( ad ilhltl1,quia verfatllr c,rc,a,al.'quod rne~l~m,n~,? 1iliisex pr~(:epcb naturali dlhgltul'; ~:'h:ils tile ?Ihgitu[ Cuper omnja;a.t~tJcBdco omDlul.la pr~cepta msnenr vi(tualircr ,hi a'"prata.& vohta, Nee potell e)::~cnentiam propd~m accipetc= r:lnquam finelll ad qUl:tn COtlut'tt~tur ~uhU"ahclldo.iU.a~ 1 {lIblcCliQ!lc .Anis n1tUIal!$,CDI tanquam allquld In(crills naturalirct (ubiicjrut, Difi tilpponendo 31iquem c:lcfed:um ab aliq?o fin~ ) rarione ~~iu$ accipiat propdam exeellennam ve .6nem ~ qma Ii COnnaturali lJlodn operam~. debet propnam. excellen[ialll (emper acc:ipete v[ cont~nnm Cub fine., Si autem 'accip1[ mam v~ fincm. & non 'It medtum ccnteutum Cub nne.hoc ip(o deficit sb aliq 110 fine. fub quo eentlnerur. Non a naturali immediue, quia ex ilIo incipit actul'!!. (uurn : ,ago a fupernat\l(ali:crfi iRe non Q:ttur,oonddicu. Et fie opOUet quJd incipiat hoc peceattlm Angc:H ab aliquo deftflu dtca nncm. &: circa rnodum eenraruralem operandi, Q.!:i quidcm defeau. optime ct:rnimr quanJo intc:rul::nitordo ad "oem (upcrn;mlr~lcm. elli AlIgclu$ renuir (I: rubiicerc:; tunC eiiim (ub r~1i dc(,d;u.t. t;ilj fine dendt a ceenaeurali , & proprio modo operandi. VtfoprR di'limus; PO[cCtqul: a,dpere propriam excellentiam VI .6m:m ad qucm'd'. uertatur , quia iam £illis natural is • qUi cit Deus vt auctor n;I,tur~ non pl~na, & p~rfeac 3ttiligitur. hocipCQ qllQd renuit Angelus (e Iubiicere finl fil~ p'~rn~turali. Non ramen hoc cODringir fi tc:nUat Ce rubii~c~e Pta'll;ept~ pofiduo. Circa ?liqllod medium fubordln(lnllIl finl natur~h, qUI:l cum. Angelus nunquam operetur ni" inripiendo :l principiis. Be l fine(liue pc~ fllbic:frionem. fiue per .11l~rGonem) propter pcrfeltiffimum modum intellcllualem quem haber in opc:rando; ideo non potdhclluere hoc pt:tceptum patriculuc quod de fc ell: conrenUUI rub aq10r~ finis ... Itimi n:nunlis. niu iDCipiac hane ren Ilcmi:lln ab iplo fin!:'. E~ cum (uppon3tur non c:Jli: atius finh quim n~uurali5 j & circa ilium en neeefficams quoad fpeeificaliou"m , qui.1bonu jutur~ eft. non. pOtcll: intra limhes put;t: natU~ ptOCedcDl~& modo connuDrali. id cit incipicndo a printipii5 ad concluliones • & i £inc:;d mtdia renllerc fubieaionc:m iIlam 3d ule przecpuun poft .. tiUll!tl 1l'U,gis.qulm lei alia pr;zcepta n:1,utali:llqu~ Vetrantur circa. media contenta (ub ilIo fine: mtu-

r.!i· <

Ad rCGund.am conF.argmnelni, Rtfpon. quod, \It docerS. Thorn. '.i.q".!o9.oIn.~. h).lmo in lhru nUU~~ inugrz(& idem cll:d~ Angdoex (u:l.n.1tu~ rHonfidet:l.EO ~ Vt ibi fe referud.locuP'1 I.p. Ybi id rra.!t:iuit.(cil.tj". fSl.4rI-fo) ad dilig~ndum Del1m {IlPcr omnia non indigl;t dono gtal iz (upetilJditz Duur.allbus banis.lict!: jndigl::at auxilio Dei adboc eum rnouenris.Sic ergo dicimus quOd AD gelos ad obfauid~m legem 1Utunlem indigcr 2u'tilio moUtO[l:. ~ concuf{u gcn~li. qui dig-tUI grati:! gencrali modo. non au(ctn indigeuliquo dono gramiro CiJpctaddito naruralibus h9nis. V IIde non 1:01- litll~ quod. lit impmahilis e~ yi .il!ius Il~t~s. & in ordUlt ad Ulum !inem untum. Ilcef aUXlho geller uli indiguc:rit (lcur ad omoia .alia opera) lie ficut indigeUl-~i ad a~dum Dcum.

Ad lec.undJm d.it'ti.cultltelll R.:rpoodmu u: di-

!lis negudo ~nCequCDIiam. .

3 I . Ad prim;m ptob~r.dicirur • qllOd AogdUf nOB .ttdditurpotcm ell. c1ClUfiouudCllpmu.t1Ir,wa ad pC'Wld~ fcd pufucddiw pOWlSadfupuna-

§If!.41.LIX.e/e. De merifO,e; pcecalo Ante/arum.

turaliter oper~ndomlquM vero inde (ump(cdtoc"; cafionc:m Angelu~ ad pcccandum, hoc ell; 'ell: defc .. au fuo,non ex (lp~mione Dei,qui ad ["pe~iu~ bo-" num elcuabatAngelum, !ieet ipre bcneHcio Dei. abllfus fit ndknslc f~nro b,ono, &; Cuperiori Iegl: fubiicere. Non cllautcm ineonueniens, quod ex ~en efi~il) pri!!c!pal,iori ?ci.(um~m: oecafic maio,: tiS mali • {iCUt mC:ttna[lo Verb, fUlt (ummum DCI bone6cium,&: ramen ell: eo oc:cafionatum en p~!l~ eatum maximum eorum qUi iI:,OIUCElint ;pfum recipc:re , imo; &: ipCum occitlcrunr. V nde diccba, Dominu$ fuis: Si tiD" 'Ile"iJIotJ.& l~t:ut"' til nQft luiffim,pI(filtll,nnlJlt hilbererl1;11I1ifil ""um tXtll.!4Iiotzi1iJ nOlI ~b~", J, ~~tDfH4. IO;D;,sf. EtApollolu. dic(:bat Rom'7' O&IJlijilJfI"".:tpt" ptWItNmDpti'.~ fum ejl i'l me DmtJtm '~l1cllpi[mtljiWI : [Ille ltgt ;nim "m.tH111 mgrU,um trill. 5imilitercrgo in Angc:lo ante cleuarioncm ad Cuperna~uralia potentia erae, ad pccc.and Llfrt.& defielendum Ii c:lcu.,ctut) &. fibi proponctetur l~:t (upcdor. non aUII:m ad pcccandum Ii inrra naturalcm legem mal;lt:tCI, &. in modo 'I;Inll~tur:l.li e per andi. V"de per cleuationan noli. ;Ic~~pjt pote~ ... u~~ p~ccand!)nec Iibttt~ im(l)l1t~u cn; fed mntcrra rn:ll(ltu boni, &: benefiCium malus d3!l1~1'1 t'1!~ vndc omfionc:m :acccpit AngeJu! pec~ candi , non ell: pordlaEc noua ad ptccandl1ln data, {cd oC~:IfiQne acccpta. V nde Angelus non fit Deo aurhore dctcIior,fc:d melior f,ld:u$.ct:ca!ionem Cumit ex fe detaloralioni~. Er cum dicil;Ut" quod anra !lOll habc:b:lt potcntiam ad pcccandum J & modo h~bct; Refpon.quod c:tiam ;mr~ babclm porenrii. ad pccc:mdl.lm .11(11} quidem intra nauu:alem crdlnem roul':ndo~ ltd hab",bar pUlemiam YI cum Ot~ dine ad flipem;ltUt~1ia de Ii 1::'1: re poffet. V nde aleu.:i~ done peliu,. implct:ttll' conditio. IX IXc~fio ab ip(o a,cc:prJ dc.6'ieJldi. Edie pattt ad fc:c:undut'll quomodo non mutarur intrillkec libc:nas, fcd Cohim eXlrinCc:ce ponitur Ol;calio drca quam pofiit delicerc::iarn enirn amc babebat poreftatcm ad defici<:ndLlln pofita hac occa lione.

Ad tcrdam Rcrpon. quod Ii Angelus elIi:~impcccabilis Ilh inuin(ccQ ;ab(oluu; ~ & Gmplidtet. ,Z nullo mOliuo pOlfet ad peccandura mouen , rm Angdrots ex k;&: ab inrrinfeco ell: pt«abilis • Ii po~ natllt in ec ordo ad [upcrnatUralia1dl aurem jnde~ feltibilis fi talis ordo non demr. & alias QPc[enn il1:na Clltim mod 11m I;onllaturalem. Vt dix.in:uu. Et qlundQ~idmcquod l11odopcce;lm.eri;l.mC:l:mo~

duo mer~ Darutali, V't qUi:!. (:tUci;lntur~ ~ non (o~ Jum quia ami(c=tl.lnt bcamudinem, dieimus. quod

non polfunt ex i11(1 ml;lJiuo llil~llrali p~l;c3:re. nui ' provr tilpponir,& oritur ex alia priofi m,oriuo.quo

ipfi n()I\I~tllm fubiid regllla: (upcrna{U{;l.ii, fcu or .. dinui pcr c:~m; (~d C~ ftlia~ conl1erIi ad pfapriam euellcmi:ull, qua dcordin:uionc {uppolica. erianl

in lege naturali tlcordinati [um, & po tUmlnt Con-

tra ilbm pcccare. 'It diximus. {cd incipiendo (c:m.~ per, & v(cndo ilia prim3 abulionc, &: non Cubietl:iQt)c ad regu lam (upernlturalem yr tnoliuo,quia. {upcrbia ell przcipullnl motiuum r;ornm • quod viuualite:~opl;ratur.& mallet in allis particul~ibu.l moriuis • quia Angeli Ltmpct opcramlJt incipieodo

ab vni uerb.libus principiis, & a nllc; p~:ttctquam quod cruciatlls quem nunc b~bent> ordincm. &; (onnezioncrn habet cum fine fupernaEUrali. £icut

&' ,riuario beati(udinjl. q~lia vmimquc ex pecc:ltO COil~ ~c:gc~Tupnn~t~ulcm ~m;l.nauit., EE fimili-

ret lnUldcnua de bClnl~ Angdl5 ell: CJ: ao quod vi~ 'aO:P[ mo~ cJl.cclltnuffimis donis (upCfliawf3libus clllIluLuOf.quiblls ipfi c.arcnr,quod forum ordincm elicit acl Cupernatllt:lliai & hi) dicit D. Thorn. {I~pr4 '1114jl.!iQ.JIft.4Hlg 3.qulld,Oaitfnl bM1I1 ..AtlgdllJig IJuntlf11J

DifPul. Xx Ill .

q~4>1Jlll/1 difltf,;jitWIfI#' PfWI iu{1i til,'i1I, & inillftitiil.

~ 0'11'1. f _lid f .dicit.qtlOd ·OJill h.fbt'lt n,H", i" '1l1ii. tm1f fMit f~ ,14 p.mimfara tjfif1JU. qUi ~~'"m 'V~IIiTi~ Illfi ~11.'1IY.t"J4Iftllr"l.l!Jr.! non ell needle qilod Dz~ motlC!~ .mOUCilUtllr lemp:r ex I~e {upernaHtrali, fed (tt!ij:iI q'194comr~ Colin, vel ex aliql10 dicenee ordlncrn ~J-ilr~m,v.el {upponcnrc: ilIam.vt diaa dl.

3 J Ad id quod dicil~: de moriuls ad peccandum,

qlldd pcrueeune dan In flltU pmi\'! nai:ura:.ltcetno ror.G~ur in (hru damnuioniJ,uicimus non rc:gulad impc:ccabilic2te'm Angell in ill!] llam penes pludmcm,l(el plut'alirarem moduoril ,fcd propler mo-

'dum turu:oper.tndl,ex qtto 11011 dah~IUdocus formmdi dca:~meil d~fcctu(nii quandiu opc:mb;uur cann3.turali mod.:, fUG, id ell procedcndo cornprehentiue.&: tam Jmrnobilire( in priildpii~ qullll 111 cOllciulil,lniblts:,in ,fiQc,quim in mlrdiif. 'It 3.mpliul illf.dijf.14·lI. t. dll:cmr:lic enlm cum tiO.ll propenetcmr illi nili fillj$ n;\t.ur~lis ;td quem ex nafura rLia dcrcrmitllUB;& imml)blliranu ell,& Cub iIIo conEitlcb.lnrur C;l qll% por!:'ut pro fine vleimo pCfUcr~C \ h,lbcn:.lcil,e(c~Hed3. propria,llccclfc:: em libj proponi alia nncrn cui C~ IlQII (1IbHeerer. V't polT'c, ab IIIl'lI;'J~ filii, ~1I::rfi(Jn= .incipicnJo operuf dcf.;'~ a~o~~.&: ex: his q:u:: lub fine Il~ult'ali conEinc:b3.tur nn1: Jib, '1him .. i ~QfI~i~ucr~. Er cum !nll:a~ur. quo~ no t repl.lgn,1,[ ClI;:ml III IluLi n.amrah dan defeihJ. alrq1lcm conlideratiort'is,fariDtle,cuiuJ PQllir pfOpOni v~ contlmi~rls bomtm ddcil'lIbik, fell proprium booum .rdicb b mo h::mc,lo.Refp.non repns'u%'c defechun COr1(a~miotlj~.& quod hl;Jnum propriii aotcponuur.J U It! modI;) ilte def.:l'hu (:onfid erarionit derur in~ipien.io ab atiquo 60: i quo (caucnat. vel qu~m fcqu,amr. qlli:l pmpfi!l!, &. conrJa(lIrllli~ modll' operidi in Angelo ,ell incipitndo lline. Ii. ~lIt in irudled:u incipielldo i rrin.:ipH~, eo quod intcllcfru;l.lis natur.e ell pcrfdta:,& c6prebcllliua: in fuo modo procc:dc:re;& lic (;;mper iodplr .3 prin. eipiis.Cumanrem in Ihtu narllrali lolum pOnlintlJf pcincipi~ n~tllr~li~.&:: finis natut;!-1~s fUb. quo omnia bona 'ol]tmentur~& £:1: arnore ralis . iou Angelus incipi:zr.iQ ebquc: omnia que fub ilto ordirumrUfl. 3.,lringn,quia 'oprc:h=nJill~ proce4ir > & '1oie;!. immobil! ;uting:cnd~.tarn circa principia. qlllm ~irca conclu!ioncs,fin:s.s: mcdiil,indc: 6r,quOd no polIit omim:r;: conli.bratiollc linis;&: inerpere ab aliquo bono cenrenro (ub rali line, &: iIIij.fibi vt fine prQ~ poncr~.qui~ h(],c(f~t inu;:m:re rdodii rOIlIl:!t!lrali procc:dc:nlli.ql.lod flue lion potelt.ni6 aliqlli! d~fedurn [upponcmlo.uriotle CUiU5 idquod no eft fi· nis, accipii\cur v[ I1nil ,qllod dE· rlon petdt. !JiG anertendo fc ah aliq!IO fin; > JCIl lien filbifdtndo fc altcri Rm.qulm nlt!lrJIi; <J.tlb huk n~mf~lit~r ~d~ h;'l:tet. &. non pOten 3D Iphus auerlionc: Ultlpc:re, cumlir neceme:l[U$quo~d fpeci6cationem ad IptU. ltaqtle APgdu~ POtc:!l dd~aii conlidcr:Jtionis pa~ tiled fempcr fcrulndo modlirn htom. qlli dl im:ipi~dQ ab aliquo I1n~ • vd pl:l' conlJ~rlionclt1 • vd per alJcrfionern;vude {i 1 fine nlltur.aH aumimr, eft C:J: altaa fine aqno incipir,&; iIlc nOll pord! tire naruratil ipft: nnis- • quia bonus eft. ntc a!i(}uid .;Qlltentum rub illo fine na~ur01li-. quia La(: DOn (,arell itCc~pi Yf I1nh inllent-ndo conn.nmdc OIdia ne,nin ex non fllbietiione ad alium fine cui dtbe~

. m (ubiici. quod non Jbt niG rcfpcchl finis (uPCtmUlfali5 : !101m rerpcllu fi:llunJi~ per fc fubiicin:ar.

14- Ad v!timum didrllf:Angdutn peccante1n canera fidem (Ilpcrnatu!alcm edam vioure legmJ I!alUfatem • lit iUin, maliti:z teum dfe ~ binI:. tamm non furtJltnr 3rgllmcnrnm quod poffir AngdllJ ~iolarc e.andcm legem namtoliem l1:ando in mero !bcu na'turali. fc:d ('x motiuo. & ordil!c aliquo:v1

l"_,,.; S:l"b~IlI. in I. ,,,n.D. Til, TamilS ill!:!:

I

. .Artic. ll. 44t

fupcrnaturaliil,1 quibcu ti alf~hltllr , etlam ell. eM -, f~quend auerri pOldl a fine rlamrali. VI dit'h,m ell: ; & lic Jetcrtilin.i[lj~ til: ad Ii nem n ltul'<1lein qu~ndiLi non petiitur alius finis ell: CUIUS all~diofie poillr ctiarn "antra finerti naturalem agerc: fi auecm pon,:llur talis finis, (:(li Angelus naturaliter non fit fuhicctus , perell (e sb ilIo auerreee ~ &. el 'onff"qllcnri a fine: naturali ve cxplic:.aEllm en.

AR TIC V L V S I I.

YJr~m Angtit14 POffUTit pmlJfe jj

prim« itijlimfi f

D·£ £1';1'0 Angd~ ~on p;ccaie inptilno iti~ 1 l1:1on filz tr~~tIOnl5 ir:! 'it tum ipCa crealion!!: fuidic n?(i~remt.u' nllli,Qrnnino cereum ellf~ oppallIum iudieaeur 'II erroneum, non folum fi dicamr Angelum tlfe: n2tufaliter ltlalflrid ell, ell: natUr~ (ua.~ non eX libero 31'bitrio ; ira quOd natu[~ Dlt,:, moms matt ftlcrfr ~ & ~ malo DI;'Q 'tc;i.ta • qlla: cit hrerclis M~nich~orl.lm 7 Icd eEi~mpenl!'ildo qned ~ngel~$.libcrO (uo arbitrio filerit malui in prhno mJl.tml,!ta quod nunQIl!:7r fueric bonlls:hcc rnim et.iam SCtiPIUfZ contrariarur. 'lila: do,ctl~;tmone al,quando flljJl~ bonii;vt Ezechielis 2.&.vbi didwE'

. de primo Angdo qui '10&mlr Cherub praregt=iu. pdfoElm in 'VIis r Ni1 a d,l ,oruiitj~tlis r,; <f;Mn~( inurnfa tjlifliql#IM m rdh lo:mn.S.dicitur de DiabQlo~ qu3d in 'fw·irJltt 71(JTI jlliit ~ga (uppol'litllr :aliquado in ycrit~rt; fuifl"c.fr in Caflonica lud:t dicimr, Angt/oJ 'flli nQIJ [mwmll7lt[uum priflfipt4lum,[tJ d~nli'l"trlfltl [fllml 4lJmit:ilillm ifl.iuJi&itJrn 1tllig1Il !liti rub (dUgitll rtflrHo!!IUil.El'gll,lubu~tllnt aliquidQ principatllm quem pcrdidmmt, non in natUf2j quia hll:c imegt" m':1I1Iic; ergo in gratia. VtuJe S. Lco POIpli tpifJ. ,H'· ',air quod Di./'ol", bU"""Iffit fi in tI '1110J /Il!bu eft ptrrnATI"ef. Er Ita in CO~ (ilia Brachucliu t Jnrer '~pitub '1l1ibuS' Prifctallia~ na ~rcjjs d;zttlna~ur. feptimnm capillllum lie; h:;,.. ber , Siquir dicit Di"bIJII,1n·1IQ/t IlIlff, pnHi'ulJn!,UI Angtl14m A 'Deil [~allTll,I1!1l Dt; IJp4i(}jIf7f' fk1fo ""~ IUYAm tiU!,&(.~illtrhtmA fil r '1bi IY,,71HI tignlmoiit: ~lIratione .empcFis,retl iOfr~1l5 aliquod 4,uraHonif,

in quo Diabolu5 bonus Allgclu~ fuir. 'lEo,d edam ill~cndcr~ "'Ideml' ~o.ndiiurn .. ~~,~~;mfnfr: inc.Fn:~ vm~,d~ f-m~ 7';'bm"r~, vb! pJ'jm dceer Angeb- _ cam qC.!ttlram.llrur& h~m.1lJaru ~b.inltII)Umpotis cOl1diram eiT~ 1 DeC! ,& mOl: luhdrr ; Djll/;lQlfII tlt,,,,,& ali] ,u,nfn&; it Deg 'lllidltiJ nliflltft crlAI; fimt '. bUlIi l vriqtll: in jllo initio tempom. d~ qu'o db:t'tae) {td ipfi p'Y fi [<lEli ["1I1 tnltli. III ~llqlW agoitiP~ii' fuerunr hOI)i.fcil.eilnH,e~d rund~!<1Je D.T .vhiqlh:docer home opiniaIlcrn.:le pecc3to AngeH 'lulJd (ollrig~rir in primD mlbllii {lIZttmtli~ni~ rtputaram fudf: t:mqlJ:JID ~rOl'le3m a MaglllrlS,ulqut' rao. tionolDilircr, vr pCit~til'l hac '1. (i~. 1fT1+& ;fl1; difl.

;.4].1.,;11". J.& If~ JG Je.1JII,fo IIr;:Jf. ' , _

Difficlll~ t:rgl;J~n.Vtrum in iIIo primO'inthnii z. pec(;;l,r~ pomtnnr. lic;tr de (~~o non F~CC:1I1([inr. ~Od ft non pOtUCfur. vnd"'proueniat ill:~ hnpct\cOibiJir.upro;Uq primo inlbndi:6~ fuppDnimus An,:. gclum hlbuilfe in iIIo pdmo hl{hnd elcllarioneail (upan;irut;ll ia • ne dicamus deelTe iIli u boat r~rce (ondJlioni:m rcquiliram ~d pC'~c~rtdum c;orifti. (~ gcm fuperna1uralem, dara quod not! PfJfJit £on ..

mt folaml~gC:!ll Illl[Ur~J~drd przci$i dldiJli .. CUkH • an rldon~ iHius dur.ttfanis ~ (clflect prltni irdb.nti~ • feu plimi ;;ttu=>qU(tll dicit AngdUs d~ .. tar.'pcdalis rer!.lgl1~dald p«C~dUin III Allgdo.

Er Idem ell pnmum Jnfilm,JK pwnuJ allin, qu.~m Angchu hWu4 io flimo inlbuti quo cill,utI' eft

. Ill' 9IJia

-

~£Jl.LJ?C. f5c. pc me!/to~e$ peccato Ange/orum.

3ccipt:r~> &. crc'ati ill pur3 natura. & in. ordi,ne ~d finclD naruralem conrra quc~ in ~liquoru fcnte~ ria pc~car!: potUCfliM • \It arj.prtt(;~J.. vidimus. Po~ tuerunt.ctiam crearicurn ordine ad Ilnem. {upernatllu!em,& CLlIl! .cog~ltiollc. illius pet fid.:: • led Ii_~c g[atJ~ pro tllo pruno Hub.utI, danda; ramen pro aho, inlt1iri Ii (c dilplJner~nt in primo,tn hoc coim nu!l~ ~pparct repugnamia. eli. es libera DCI difpofidone lugitio f.:mCtI6(;~nijs grati(l: dependeer. V nde; potuerune habere wncf!l!1icitnu~mr;uioncrn.& elmnia requifita vr peCC.Ullnt operando contra legem Iupernaruralcm qu~m eogoofccb:lnt per .6dqn, ~ potcrant noll, iIli lubiici pedlheu:J~cm qUia noodum rune ',dpW!flf grntiam d1ic~,crtl. lJ.!!:m: il~ Iud fund.1lllCrlUIPl film ploecdir ;.blolUle. fcd ex fllppofitionc quod in primo inlt~nti Angeli (.maificarcntunfic cnim 1I0Il polko(' limul p,cc;uc. Setundb ~lij proccdunr ex .llio'fundal1u:mo,qllia 5 CXUHnMlt primlm opt:r~tionem Angeli non dTc J,bcI'J,sicqui: 1100 df.: '~PdCC:1l1 !,cc(;.Iti. (ed m:quc rucrin.Funaanmr.vcl quia prima QP,'utio liD proccdit eX de hbcr<luo nt',dln1 lit piilll:lLonlJlium , &. non prxlllppo!1;!t 31iam per ~u~nl (~mOlu:at ddibcr.llllk;:ctgu ell mdclibcr~(3;l;rgo non l,b~ra:V c:l qlli.1 oall.:lli~IWlll 1I11bnd tt'mporis nOll,polft.ali-: qllcm eisccrc llberam oprr:uiol1cm. nifi tempore anrcccdenn potur.lit Cc d~dncrc r M in iIIo in/l:inti cliceret.Et ratio corum ell:, quia in codi:minlbmi 110n dl: porens libcrtas opef3ri, &' non orerari, bQC enirn comradiCl:iollcm il1!lollljl;ad liberratem aUlc rcquiritur,qllc..1 .lli':lui:llir'polils opc:~ri tunc qui-

do 110n OpCr-~iUf,¢'l e comra.Ergo pOIeil'ia libcrta-

lis upcdita non pot ell r~gulaQ. vnico inlbwti, {cd debet conftare ll1~io~idur;\tionc qnam inltama!lc ... , qui.l in VIIO infbmi n6,rotelloperari; 11.: no't,opf:~ rari;polcft aurern ytnlmqnc pro diucrfis inlliidblls. CUIIl ergo Angelus in prime inlbntiir.capcrit durarioncm (uam,[lOn rr~,cffil ;,me aliqilod inll::tns. vddurldL) ,r.Hiolll! cuius poll~t Ytrulllquc. Ceil • f;lP~~J(j>& non opcrari.In illo crgoin!tmti ru5dilm potem Iibcrtas eius exerccri. SUIl[ qUi Caictano a~~ uihtlat I(;nfi!le ;11 hilt q.6; .il.5. quod Angelus non potuc~it pecearcio prilDo inll:ami.quia ciusopcu-

tio em n!=C'cffJ.tia. Sed Caier. exprtlSt luqlliuIt de n~alfJrio quoad fpe'ific;ltionr:m,non quoad c::xer~ cidum • vt parce;'l eo4:m art.§. Ad b« bYtuiul':ibi enim cXpt~[li[.& fClltlim[ S.Tho.qui ,bjf~llil.gd~. di~it,quOd Angc:lu~ in primo inlhuti "1;1; l;fe.4tio~

nis putlli( In~rcti q!lo<llillc liberrare adus • {altcm q~lo~d CXCtCillum ibrt non poteLl

Vndc flllld.;.mell~unl ,hoc c dilmmo pllgnat 6 emn D. Tho qm.ub'tilmc doect Allgc:lnm III pti~

1110 m ft.1I\tI polIc di ger.: aCl::u hbeti ~rbirrij, Vt Pl-

{~'I il'l '1. J<I.Jr malolf+ E.t ic,[um ipcdJiirC'f in pri-

IlIo inlland Angdorom cognofdt meritum in bore q.6j..,m.j .rld ,. ergo & lib!:n~tem.qujl mefed ti-

Ile libe(!) aa\l>,6tr3~tidio cll~ilc(;e!faria ellimlal1- clem nOD meremur, nee pra:rnil1mtcrgo no hw~nt rnctitu.& iterum D. Th.;.,P ''1. H·a.~. expr~fs~ inquidf,& dert;fminat quod Chrillus Dcminl4 in primO' inll.lDri fu~ cOl;cptionii habucdt adii mer(forium hbcd arbirtij, co ~uod in ptimo inijanti habuerit grad~ln,qui:J. ~ p~imo innand fUit plcnus gr;ui:r.& vcriud5.&: e3puf ornl1iurn > quod (alum

per gr3ti.li11 dl!:' romit. Non pou;!\: l!Qte did quod, ilbm grati2m > & illud gt(JU5 (andi6catlOJlil ~~ ddc::nralis habuerit Chl'iftus impl!T(ed" modo. ficut fanaific:aIlWl p~ruuli • fcd perfeao > Ui:ut :\duhi,id eft !:oncurtl!mc propria difpobrione.DiC-

po lido autcm fit per.ilfruln liberum c:onuerfiopi,

ill Deum: ergo Ii in primo lnlhnti dl: capa; vo-. lomas huius .f~.DCtilicatiQnis ret gtamm)) ad mQ-

, > dum

qllia crcatus ell; .. ro ~Cti1 opt1a~$,.~i[1t,:lJjgc?5,qLli~ !\alUr:! p~[fCail.& non iJll~cdml,1t1 Iplo pr~!T'o JIlnand quo pcrfed:c p!oduGlt.ut.& habet 7!1c,Ulllul opcraiur.

Duplexeft p,ri ru:ip.ali~ r,.~!t~ti.i in ~:iC p;me. , . prima doce r p o tllilfc Angdu in pnffi?1n (tall tJ, (eu in ptimCi "au peccare. H;rc ell: SCOtl pi 1. d,ft· r-q,2.qucm:aHj ex annquis f~qul1ot!lr '" ve Maior; Gab~.;P3Iacios.!IC(;.Elt rccemionblls candern (t=nrentlsm fequUfl,tllf Mol.ina l.p.q,6;.arl.5. Y;lI~mi:J ibiq.4,p1mflq .. V~(q,bl& dirp. 156. c. ;. & eX parte Suarci,vt f1.atiltl .aicclllus,Alarcoo Irafi.6. dc, AI7-

gtliulirp. i .c. ~.&. 3Iiis., " . .

Silcundl lcmcllrh ClC'Tcmc conrrarra affir]fia('m Angelis non p,e-tuHfc clui peccatii in primo inllall~ ri , [~!1 in primoattu,liccc ex diuerfis fundamcr.di diu~r Ii proccdanr. Hec d~ cxpu: 11'a fentcntb S, Th. ,in bll' q,GJdJrl. f'~ ali~lam {tlfrtl,lux 'Iii. 16. de 11111/Q,& 1I12.foff;t:flli.t~um, Emn (cql.luntur omnes thlHIHcipuli in hac luto I.,.vb, \,ldctlr.0rdl:: Caict. Dancz;N a:U.t illS .Zum d,C jrnl~ lit. S ,\ nun tic. d,lt. I t.dllbi~ 'Unicil.C~pn=oJm j~ 1.dlf1 . .;,.q. ' .• t, I.(~nd. ot.F~,wi. ;.t:liflrr'<'i (Jmr. t. !')9. §. Sed circa p"ltd/a ... Arrubll dJ/P.I79·c.1.& 4.Granado~ "'rU.I~,dtlJ+ Deuique communcm clle lcnt~ndam fllcrllf SU:lt,?: Gir~ndus.& pl~lrc$ aff'cct Va(q.titatilS. Fuir, eda mulrorurn nntiquorum(entmtia Alb~rti,Rithardi> ,Argcmin:c,Holt;.o!h,l\d~ll1. H.'nrnd ,quos cit-lOe CJrlllcli(.t~c" diUo,Eam edam [cqLliLUf Hugo de S. Vill:. Iii (Hmf/la1r.J-.&.Lanribuililrq; clii 1). A II Cd.

Illfer has rcnlcnriaS Il1cJialli viam voilm P. Suare~ cUciliarc.Er p.rirno luppunir potuine AngelO: rn Pl1ris n;uur:d.ibus p,,~c:l(e in prilll!) , in!l-at't.i con.rca ,Ic.g:m naturalem, vt doccr lib, 3,. ,",Angdu C.9,J. n, ~. O,indc a~l.Jk {Jb·7.c: to.J1 . .4-].& foq.tl:guUtim.4!< . rccunaijm,ordin'ninll prouiden.tia Dei nO. po~iljll;:

,Allg~lum pcccafe in iIIo inllapti (:o,mr:\ legem (il,p~matur31I;m.Er in (Ulllm) hoc quoJ til:: non I'ec_,.aile Angc:lum rcducit :ldrnanutC'I1~uii Dellpcd~lc,qllll: ramen no !!f.1t d~bita Angdl' ~bt'oillte.&

.~,lnplidtCI.Er Ge dccer quod de potcntii1 ~b(olilu. &: non fccundum leges ordillUias poruie Angclus p'CCCiltc ill primo il1lhmi;qlla Gillinttionc viaeult ubi ~QndliaJfc"C"ntenlia1l) D. Th.&: Scod.

-~ljgitl"·lfnt~71ii". D.Thom",fJjhlJdittir alio:

I ~' rllm tfllthorum Int!ftOJUs #ffi yatitmEJ.

, Comml,lpi$ igiuif fem"ntia a nobis rc::nend:l ~t:Il,qllz ell cx;pcdTa D. Th. [cil.implicate quod pri. nb opcnth;t A!lgeli,& prirn\l~ .1aU5 CiIlS, :mIl! qui nullus prot(:,:: ffiI>6t,pc~cJn'i.Hzc con.c1ulio nOll i:O&, .dent mooo proballir~b Allrhoribus qui c:irn re.nEt-. Yndc 0P9f;,t.d:,p~iu~ vi derc totum fundJmell 1'01 ¥t;ld veram.J¥ effi':l;Cs:;tnD. Th.I3tionc a"edalllUs.

4- Primo igirot~~!ldl:bJbcndum pro (Ilffidenrj

fUJ\dllDcmo.quM i!leO Angeli Don pOtlle'{iit pce.r;u_e. (OnU;! 6ne fupe'rouul4kmio primQ inl1.mti, 411lit lum: gUli.am aa:ep~i1m.& iulli6cati lul'lt>(e~ .pugnlJ: ;al¥cln GII\Uliqc:Qd6inibntidfe gmiam,& Pefc.Rult'l,l!iTe e,JinJ1CIII volunUt~m ronucr(:.m > & ti~tr(~ l DN'I~[:-:r~H!m 'I'un Augel! pc~ PfQPli,ii dlpq,GUOlll:IU lu.llftan filll'& Ii t 11011 lillum h~bltualcll) gr~dm1lubu~unr.r~dcfi~1l1 atluall:fll lUur E~~ ~nilcdionis in P~Un'l.Qlmqllo nOll compa~ituual1i!.1is lI\otll~ ~.u~diOlli$ i Del'. C;efcn1m f\ffiJ,lmcotum hoc·llon.,cJl (ufficic{}s : (alum cnill1 o!ll:lldir Angelos. non pO-fuille pil;'~~e in primo iblianli ex {uppotirione quod ip iUo ill!hnri ~cce~ullr &r~ .. J;lPllll;fllUt, ~~i:B grilliarn lUOC nii

, , Dij}tlfiltifi,'X s: ttl. - -·~,~r'-I;· iI. 4'4'1

dum adlllto'rIlllh i::t.!:mt'cCl: r;:~pax lIttUJ !ibm. t< iea-urn ~ vi propotiriOl1i$ i.lfditfcrcl1ti~. Vn..!c &i-

m~itorif. Dcniqllc Chtillus in pri!_lla inlbfid fllit cimus, quod fjbems ncn ell;!ld OP"t1r.!hull , vel

bGatiu. & compreh;n(or.~lib nOir';hiblliJlbt gta- non opmildllm limn] in eodeill illliami.1k in fm.

fia.mperf~lIm.ac:·pleMID j fieC: cJJet pICDlI$ .... eri- Iu compQfiw; led dJliufictiiib • &: irdelifu dilli(o.

tate a primo lnfbnn; Ii cune nen viu!:t D!:um. {cd qlJia ad neurrum dl dc:termin,ua velunras ell; (COl

iilconul:nicns ell dicere ~uod iliquis in ~liqqo in.. vd e)( meriris obictli,&ex vi illditfcren!12 iudicij.

Banri ill: capax prttmiJ • &: f lI~m~ p:;rft:tlloni~ ill fed pore:1l c:llgetc a1rerutJt quod volner!t ~x pro-po-

inrcUc:dll, &: vobm_cilte ,ql,lall5 eft vIlla, & amOE litiJ;& fie potelhliuifiue opcrari.vd nen operati.

DGi in (;: • IX nOll fit. '.lip:ll~ meritj. qui eli arnor noll COlliullttim op~rJri, (!.t. Mn opr:~~ri. Et ad hoc

l)d il:lJp~rtcfi~or,ql.lam ~n ~atria, I'r:tfertilll __ cu?l (iI_ffitit ql~od {it PO(¢IlS ad vEEillYiquepqtcntla ;jnt~;'

amQ.t' Del eS VlaOI1O" beaf.t ertus j licur reHtI( In Cedemi,Ju:er non poffie vrrumquc IimuljpotctnU

Dmm nCI;c/fario j jf~ in, crca,EUra$~ qUM _proprer ~onfequcnli;iden.C:lim~tfca:u fimltlV£ti\qu~,con.

Deun'l amJt hb;r;~ef80 m pruno mllaml potel1 IIlngendQ.Et hoc modo e.d;lmdtlm(lpe~nJt'in co-

elf!: merirom .' Be a!!lus libe.,. Vlld~ cum Ailgc:l.i ill dem Inlbnfi volunu$ vhum,;ld:llffi.p.ordC-oppol1"

primo inlbml {uz cre:ltiOilli gran.2m ucepe.nmj tllm porenda ~nu:ced.~l\ti. Ceuln fenfd diaifo > "

1Ion imperfecto modo. "cUr jl~ntnJj. fed pe.rf~cfo. qllancum dr 0: (t;, licer iIOn potend:l ~ofifequenf ••

heUt ad uld; fUc:rulil c:apaC:C:I aaus Jibed. '1110 di~ lk in £emfll C()rll_folieo • (cu ex (l.IpPQfidone • qu04

(ponerem: fe ad gr ~tiani j!l iIIn prim" inlbmi. opc:r.!.tut• Et fie tul1kic quOdpdlls quam opcr~'¢nlf

Er racio b II1U5 iI priori e-Il,.quia An~dus. cum. fit hune :1~U~ priodUtc n1fur;r .potuit ~d oppofit~m

ptt f~dz natufol: ImeIlea:aahs.potdt III primo 111- detc:rmln~u t qU;:In t um ell CJ: vi. fu: mddf~'fellfl;r~

lbmi perfc:d:!!, &: c;omprehenliu~ inrtlligc=tc. quia !ide ex fuppolicion e quod "pemur hune atlulli

f111i!UIEI cl1impcdirncntllm qllomibus natura perfe- iam nOn pom, oppolimm. nee ;'Ia·hoC' fil: 1'JJa Ii-

tta potIJr pc~fc:a~ opmf~ boc.ip{1i ~uod .b~bct bcn~~,V'.t poffit vlfu~~l~e limul.l:oniulIgcrc. •

pCEfC'ctum clle,qu:.:I; opcuu (~'lUlt.11f dIe: fe~ p_~r. '. T 'mup:ob~."t :1.1" Im~offibdlfilr'm peC[!afi~' s

feltiJ;& comptchcnliu.1 operatlo mt~J1ed-U.:l;llf In- In Angelo In p'I~O !!llbnu eX: eo quod nOD Po~U!'

tdJigif "bietllln'l ,um vnjf.Jcrf~litllte,& inddre~en- ill C!CJ iilftanci ptoponi effi~ac'hj5 cogir.:uiO boni de;-

f~limgo fotmn i~dfc~um imilffctc:.ns:crgo ~c:gIi12~ ~ectJbi!is qll~m h~nc:lli : ergo non patal. p.~ ill~

"pum ;(a:u~ Ilbetl,qun ex pl;opofinone IQddr.:l;cn- mtbnu deillare a bono boncfio •. & ,(CqUI pro-

ti iudic~j.r~quim' .opcr~lio~um jn.djff~l:"ntia.jn v~- prium. C~Il(c'I' pi'~~:l.t~r. ~uia pe,e~t1un nonpo~

Inmate: cigo {i In pnmo mtUnu ell upax lUdtcJj u:ft connngcre , nlIt ex; ailqllo dcfcGlu confide ..

indijfd"enti~,&' perrelH .. edam I:"a capn ope-ratio" t'ationj~, q~~r~nlis_dt bono hOllino, quod eft de.

nb lib~rll." tic perf~~;r.qu~ ~ tali iudiC!O orieur, bmlin; ~ le:qu==ru!llm, f10,II!U diicacicc:r ~on(ld~

V nde_(oluutlt~~f In~~~tl:': i'lIIaE~l.r~ I1h. pan:~.. tat ,li'lI~ de bono c.onna~lo ,u~d di fug,cndUnH.

Ad pttm:ltli cmm ditlIDUil, qtto ~hud CtlllCtIO- ergo Ii lIle: dcfecclU -cogmUloflls don poteft elte

7' J'!cm ~jfc ddiba;l.rilQJ~ &: aliud libcram ; fumcndo in Angelo in primo jnllami,ncqw: potcft drc pt~

dclib"a'lIill~a,one proprie.& in rigotc pta opc:t27 uEuID.AntC"cltd. fall ptob.anlr. qllJa in p.imo m.

lil)i1t ilia ~IJZ Ffocedit ~~ .alia priori. a qu~ aliqui! Rami Ii Angelus format libi c:ogitatianem • de'bec

k moll« t UI;. CUlm atlio dcliberara vc:rI~uJt circa founare cam ID quam mjgif ilidinaflU' ipfa o.1(U-

m~pia,a~; (e- moun ~liqlli:J C1;hllc:przconct:ptO_ ra , &; !:uilu viuaclorc5, &fo'fio£e$ha~rfpc:ries;

Ad ip(ulD ;lPIC 6n~ no Ii: mOIlC:~ C~ tJdibWidone. w;lgis aurem. iuc:lin:lltur in bonum honcfiuM

. f~u t:uJ,quoad:u.priori. & ideO. rcdudtllf.morio quam inapparws. ~ fOrlh;ltC:l fPC::Clt:l babet de:

Filma VOIUnfliti~cX inrdldtus ill Dcuttl.CztmJm dlo. pluraqu~ moriu;1,& cffil:aci«:l r ergo ilb om-

V radio 11~ libcra,(uJlidt qllod fm~nE in obiedum nia fordul. IX vcbcmcmii'u eonlickillbif ~ quia

'JI1I1 indiifer':J)ci~;& 6 LOp 'luau! (pccj6.cationc~& tum: in prime inft~nti tlp::mur !pfa indinalionc:.~

eX. pun' obietli • fdu:m qlloJd a:ctdtillm • 1St CJ: illlpetil B3t1Ir<C • dcinde tcmpore preccdence: !jhae

Fai[~ atim.l}ui:l. po~1l dh:c:c hUn{: :Iitlum • vel it· potcrit dlUClt e rC cOgic;'Irionl.'mJu primo vml dill

JU.m; &. ik Ipfamet diciania ~au5propl;m.iWf cum non habc:t quo diu .. n'l'; (cd iUlU.a n~tllrz jncliuol-

ind;lfo::rmria • idc:cqlle regulatur pel' r~ltm propo- Eionc:m. & pEOpotiu:nn opc:raUl.I;.Si vcro lDco im-

pri.o9-c:m libcn.u qlloid txercidl.lm, ~are 11011 ri1imtll~ rune; cagitario • immjrtcTc debet cfJiea~

:repugn;1t quad primus all us lir liber ql.lp:id c:xu~ cioro::w.& viuaciorcm quim pro.f ipfa lWur.a :An";'

cidum) Ii ptoce:di[ CUQl perfetto iudicin, lit« non gdl (erundum (e. quod Ii Mn fc:(ait j innig3bil

fir d~libeJ:uus;id c:1l.n alio priori "Glu p,oco::dem" ad malum. edtqtlc call(il pt:'cc.ui , quia:poRubmc

ell t~mcll prindpiu.m ddibcrarionis. qll:l.lC'rms c:1l fl:I'Uf~ rotiionm 1 & viuacil.lr&m ~ggif;'ldonem.

principium a1rerilll ~aliJ. N.;:c dil:ifU[ ~io iude- DC:QI minUs dJic2rcm immiltlE, H:fc d1 uri!)

l!ber~ta, Ii Iy ~11delibtr"tli (6maEUr priuari.m:'? k Am~b31i~ urI flip"" r;l.rllp.1. &. ad eum l1l~dnn1

.:umlmperfelhonc pro attunDnh,;b~-nEemdiffc:- UahIUOitlOnt:lJl. & fundllmentnm n.Thorn. mh4C"

remi:un/edpotclldiciinddibtw"1iS iI~lItiUC.qua. 1II''t.f. propolirum • pote:-Ilqnc (ali; iuuari tX hi:!!

tCIl. us nOD cll: ex-aIio :ldll ptiorh1e AlJgcfG 1~C:1l qu:uradiripfe S.Dgti:o( itii.tliJl_;. 'I_I. IITI. t ... bi

pru:efh.liqllQ modo did iIle athu ptimu$ viniL1-o docu quod N tmpl1uft ~/Ji PIWIIII", rit&. "'"_

lifC:! dclibttanJ$ quaEcnus eod~ aClu fmllt in ,WnHm.{tJ mclt flni[nniJIf{tti Itpp~TmJ ."41'1 P9Uft full:rn,& in medi", Sed qllia fenuT ex motiODc M'mI Jill'; 'lfnll,nth 'Jrr4'_ 1Jni[f11Ji/,.ttiji p~pci.(kooncxmodollCfui.ql.li"DOnfllppOnifprioo- cIJ",inIIIkS", 'flaibMi.& it .. in primd inp4fll; gp1 allum. quo.fcc_mou~al ~id~o limplicirC(. & pllit iin~flfTri in Wi,il_ b4i/fj/J.", t{t"'fII-.

~ormalf,er non diciJllr delibcrne. pn')"dcn~ ~ Jic~ ''''''11 ~/~ lInfJr. [lill t tilt ·Fmfl· IIfltlilfllJ fno ..

Jlbefc in illo primo.iDfi.lnli.· . ~ - t1 ifl ""RiBl, JIM 'Ua6fmnlt~In culm eti~JJJ 6gllu!I1

_ L.Ad u:cunibm dieiEllf fidiadum cITe dicere quOd S. Do&lt non ne:g;r ab(oIUl; POD. polk Jlberum

!!l~Ul!fi1S quz 1:1 fUQ QlOdo operandi p"ftlto iD';' 2Ebicritmll1bfDlure;pcC"carein primo(d2 ae:nionis

ll:uuan= cPeTilluiJndigcatrmlP'»'~.vtJibc:TI!¥ il:dli!Dri' fed Iqbimqt!;!l!dodl in ~ta imcgn.

~ct~r,;Umpomt-ininll:;a~ri.propnni li~i j~ vt y.u~.~:,. ';If.3~'R"f..JJprim_.~bii~qiJlf:

U:lddfacn$ .• & cum jn;nOn vel eSiacioti propoti~ butt,. ItIm'_ ",lmNII1II "t;l/ld~ JII fTn1n i1fPllfl.~

rione vllius obitd.i qulm aherius ~ vndC' VQIUllUl Ii Q"mfh1i.J ,illjlmff£m Ad bl1l1It1J m,.,IIfJ,. ttmJ,

m:tilttexpedi'~ v{ po flit digerc.&:: fmi in ~Ie of,. 1I/fI,f/utll1lll_,"&II1IIkJir"tJinll'l1lH_r.ji, illl'tr~

. J'lln.4S.Th,m. 'fl I. f"'I.D. Th. Tonu.n aIm:. 1I i :a Scnti"

s

Semil ergo quod Ii non t.~ inrcgr.a t.potc:lI: meuer] lid Itld.um,quia,Y'idclicct in n:ltUrll. rnregra c:Elicachh nillUI:UU circa bonum hanefi:um ; &. id~o eli debitum lUi fie meuerl circaililld, quad ill naturji. non itltcgra.reU cortu~ra, dcbin~m Jlan.c~. .

IoN lbilomin\l$ h;rc rano Anub;(lls. qUl: aliquibus ~Ei~!1l pbect,'Jon c:xpJii::it plcn~ eflic:aciam r:Jtionis D.1bo. lcd 1I.lfumit :.liqu:I qa~, ollmino cerra non .~ilitl&: maiori inaigc:m probllione.Nam in primls tlOIH~l1:·c~rtum qllOQ ex duobu5 nbieliis jnil:qu,,"~ Ij!cr.rropo6ti~,lk cum ina:quali, vju,ttifaU:,aut clliClfi.~ el(;P;ltte intdl,l!:uJ, non poillt volunrss pro fua Hb~tate ineljll2re in id quod minus effic:~cj!l:~ proponi,SJu, rdi410 viuaciorl. Hoc rnim.in opiniom: p~6~iJm e:11:,~·fort3tfC dt probabilitn pojf~ vo. Il,Illwel11.iq minus bonum,&: mifill~ belle propofitil m inclin:l.re, melior! r di ao,d!: qtlO agendulll eft 1,1.clrt:lH].l t·.Non E1otcl"tergo vedtas ~c D. Til. flllld~fi iii rc tam im::'cm. Ddnde • qui;t Ike. Gall. fotlltltcr ad iII .. rn ptoccdem D.Thom. tamcn hot: ,lolum probaree dare Deum colLuionem a'ulI:ilij f 11£- 1icitutis pro ilia- pmc; quz viuac'hh ptopOllilur. non ramen probat qllOd Cempet ccnCMLlE Dl:ut dire ~L1xiliLlm dlieal( pro bono c:fti(:atil\s rroPQfito. Vnde enhn ad hoc: renerue ! Siquidcsn voluntu (empcr milnet illdiff'crtDl ;ld vnum & ad ~ilerum. R!!lfe ~rg() eenetur ex vi mtm~li$ «::ligenti:t dare I;Oncurfum.ft1IltD ad bonum hooellum t;mtum, ita quOd non poffit Deus QPpolitum,permjtt~e:N~1U dj~¢rc quod al,ias Deus elfet cau[a PCCCilri • ridiculum ell,alln in [celll1do,&: in tenio irt(bnli.& deineers D eus non t"nc:~r dare c:fficu aUlliliuOl ad bO,IUlln,quia rubic:S:um indjffm:nte:r Ce haber 1 nee ~:c co qllOd iIIud fllbr[~Im~ & pc:rmiuat pc:cc:uum. Ccqlli:\lt. quod D~as lit author peccati-. IIlib in qucuis jPlhJ1d el!rt'C:Eet eadelIl rario hoc ipCo quod DelU permittit peC~ltUm. Si ergo in ptimo in~ nand cci am indjifcren selbloluaw ~ !;lee: cih4ud (Illlclaml'n!um • & raslo ~t Dc:U5 mQIlCU ilWn effj'idte.t ad bonum .honettum , quaUJ indiQatio nJtur.lli. ad bonum potiUJ quam ad malum • non QPparet quomndoc:x hoc obligctUf Deus ad dandii eflicu, aUlilium.&opporrllnam feu (:ongrll:llll cogirarioncm lid bonum. iu Vt oPfolinun implicer~ Ctltlt ctiam in tora viu eadem lit tndilUtio in natllf~ Ang~Ii;l;d bonum PQriU5 qulm ad malum ~ obli· gatio enlm • &. neGeffir~ d:wdi conc:urClIOl sd benam • he: alias De.us·Ji£ author mali. nuU.1 ell. vt dfltilnusiqui~ Ii n.ltlUa de Ce ell: in Ibm inddr~ren. ti I cllque. proltime petCIlS ad fotmandum djebmel) dcfethofum 111 Dto pcrmitmtur. nnllo lute D~IJI obiigatur i1li ;!llill«c GllIn diGl:aminc tcCto nugi' in primo tnJi.tmiJqui in re!iquis cattUS ".i~. in quibu3 non :dia. UUOII!: Deus poretl pc(l'Qittc~ Je ptCCJf,um •. & dt:fdluofum ditbmen,ncc' (cnetill: (bre ttllltilium COOgCUlltll, DiG. qUi;l tmUt2. ipCa de fc: inditf~en$ • & mutabil:s e[l; ) '" de: fe potent pto:£ime .d ddidcnduDl • &: formandum diCbmc defeAuo6lm Ii ~ Deo pcrmittatur.Carc:rgo in pri~ IDO iniUnti fnagis tenctut DcU$ non pc:nII'inc{cdc:. fcctu~ , a~ CUt l1);lgiS feqllCl:ur qllod Gt Amho, PIX'(:nI ~ Ii in iIlo primo inJbnti iIlw:l pamiWf~ qillro ilUcliquis ~m inclinatio nllt~Wdkdu.. lis ad bonuln bonclhllll c.dtm 'empu 61'; quia ex Illtllra efhhaque vel Angdus io iU~ p.rilDQ..in!l:an~ ti en fin:'plicl,er POre1lS 3d fonnandum a:f.c piaUIUD ditbmen • & ad d~&iendum. ". pme '1'0- lunutiJ ) Ii i Dca pttmilU,l:lIf.1iF« ~.co quod ration~lis natura dt. & inte:grul:lillC' pcrfel4 magil in bonum ~t in~llara. qulin in ~ulII:vel DO" eli pOE"ns pro IUO mlbnri fomw'~ dill:.nnt.a PnPum iu 'lIlQd ;mt~ccdcm.."f(iollliJ POtc:Dl. &; 6!llplirl-

!j)jj,41.LlX. Sc"..De merlio.,fd plc,nlu,'4ilgelorum.

m. nOd confcquen~e[ Culillniid e~t !Jab. de uttO non pcc[:abi[:hoc enirn dl:·pJ...eri:£rincipium,q1.la.. re non pu-c.lblt. ~ dil1Crtcre a. difficultate. propot lira: nee enim qila:rilnus de fta-oj (c-d de poflibilil qllod cnirn de fado non po=ccet '.$(. rlippolit?'lJo~ faclo non pOt1I1: I:X cOfir~ql1enn pecc.rc ,'£C:s dl nullius difficultatis ; nee: (oh~m pro primo inllilntij led pro quocumque idem dic:i debc:rtquod Cc:illcc\:

Angelus bonus edam iR Iecundo jn'bmrroitim~,

. pc!:eabilh. eenfequenrer quia de f~ao non Circ pc~,:uurll$. Si ergo in prttil~ itdbnd eR: impotent edam amcc:cdcnterJ},l form!.i1dum ditiamcn.pr.J.. UUn!, ~ffignc[ Amlbal formam iricomp"ffibil=t !:UIn r~li ddkienria. &. radkelll1l.Ilde nanUa &\;. gdi proillo ~drno inllami 1:2mincompombilit~ tern habet • beUE G Angelo bcato ItIlig.niMUi fo(.i. mJ.m incompl;dIibilcm ip£am bcatirudinem , lie ill ChriP.o ipCam dillinam pcr(on~ll. QgQd Ii noti aJTigl1at .• di~iD~ra ~;met dUI ~atio.&: nihil probar. Sob enrm ]Jli:iJnarlo rationab!> lJ:itur:l::ui bonum pod!!> qll~m -;111 malum. & qu~ pc:tat dk:u:iui libi propolli bonu quam malum.h~c imporenriam non ofb:ndit, liquidem h:ec indinatio non eli nt'e!Iit~ns ad boIlU.n, rcd indiife(enri.un relinCJuen~

'" murabl!;r:m:m.llcG fohlm datllf ill priinO uJibn .. tiled ill roto rellquo lempore.n~c viuaciof;&: elli .. cat:ior illdinatio eft pro prime) i nlt~llti in ll.:itlU'.:i ralionali,qu!m in reliquo tempore: vodc:.c:nim con~ an oppoGtum,:mt ex qu~ forma. & ratione id fOot 1t11br 2 Et fie: qllalldiu nOD :zffignJrilr ilia tadi:t • &: cauu rcpllgnantia: ul ditbmrn pf;l;u\lm.diminu~ pcoc:cd,tur. 51 aurem pro lUo maanri pOreD! ,I j\ngelm formate diclamm pnllam. G. permut:ltuE'

3 Dee :.crgo ,~m pot~n$ elblClpeccandllm, i!Nam pecc;tbilis in primo inll:ilnd qulm in fc:cundo qua.. - rum eft de ic: • q~lia de f¢ {'Ocepl c:ft hlrmare did':t. men malum Ii i Deo penninzmr,' ~:lZ'q~ itlditfljfens, & comillgelll eft eX fe. atq_oe4nrcliqais'i,,;' ibntibus, cWn pro primo,loJfllflti uullam hab&t formaIn~cclfu:antcm magis qiWn il1tctiqui$; , . ~Od G femel ponimllHl.1ruram Aop-lidcifein tIT ilia primo infbmti non elfe impOr.l:iltcnt ad fomii~ , dum dithmen pULlum J IiCC habere nece~tc:trI a1iquamilluinfec2m ;JUt impedimentum ad fmma4 dum ilIn~ 6 ~ Dee pennia-3t1l!:;. ~aqliad.~~tenl:~ fure C(emollLs)~ natut;t Angeli prcr,lIll)ptJWlcdll-o iUnti.pOtCCi ell ex Ce dc:liccre • '& dilhmen de&-: d:ucfum formuctu DellS pcrmimt. noll PQlfumm iDucnire fundanlt'nturo. vnde implic« quOd,f)Ctlj non perlfliu:Lt,quia c:t pane: n.:ltllr~ Angeli id non impli'car.lix p;Lr~e ~D{Cm Dei non reptlgnat ~ quiz

ex bot qtlQd p'-'fmiu~t non erit autbor pecClti ma~

gis in primo ion and quam in ftlundb, neC magi. "

tCllltr.1inciinacioncm bon~lll natufll: facia ill pri-

mo inJbnti. quam in fc(undo. Vnde vel boc quod

eLl Deul» m~nurellcre Angdtull in primo inllUlti~

n~ peccet'. PCt permitterc v( ddid:Lr~eft gratia, &:; bc:ndidum Dei, vel dl debitum.& nl:cefi~rfum; St

eft grati=l;po~c:n: illam negate fioe YiOI:Ltionc vllius furls,& fillcho, quOd in Dcum rtfundarur pecc.1._

nUll. vr in A uthorem. 5i eft Jebirnm , & Jlecelfa-

riUID. debet affigrtari n p;mc c«alllt~ ftatus· vel

£o~ exigcIU rale dl:bitum,&:'fIeccffitatm ; nam

Ii <:x pme i:tl:lltutZ Don:'e'l'~igentia 'uiis debltt, ncc:c:fIiru, & Jctctnliru.tio 'ad lion pccc~ndl!mJ

&ufirl iniidtur ~o'n1o- onus, & ncc;effiras d~ anxilium c:ongruu~ j.&oondcnc:gandi illu&.~ p.mmncildl oppojjttllDde~Qllm. Ell crgo-..,.~tili Aml~ vddc indlic;;il;& velle<adeam rei.lli~ D.'rho~ fundammEUIJ:!~ eft ~cd.ctc ill~~~"

~ •• ~,,~}T

',,-' ,"T_>, ,,": n;r;,,·#,' ')1"Xl1't.

r, .• , .• ', - ! - -':Jr~. ,."\... :~,

Efjitlleill Ylltimis b.-Thmll,

I" ,~ Q!UC (o-fum fe!l:~r"i'l~ via' =ad dlie;u:it(!t probandml [':ntemiam D. Tboffiz;fi:iI.olfcndcrc: qUOQ ill jlJo- primo inthnti eft impotent/a el p:irtl: Angeli ad fonnanduin did:.l.mcn ptauum.& ad deadendum. Q.!!J::impownia. cum naI11l<1fc~tu, ex defct1:llli bertatiJ q lIo:ld c:tcuidum .quia conlhc in illo primo inllami mc:rlliife: Angelos per meeum liberi Irbittij • ~i:lm ipro ~D.Th, oma, auellantc:. reftar ve impo-tentla Old fOfilUfidLln\ dictamen pUUUIU fir ex luc '1n!.:a t~tlonc j qUia _ille a.!l:u! ell omnium prim, us,~ ,nee: in mo pOtclt fe mOUe,c Aligdus.Ced (blUm ab at.erian prindpio, niOile'ri ad formandum dilbmen. In hoc Ih(fo(a ratio imptic:.lItiortil D.ThtllDz 1 & pefULlJ mionls eiu:n AngciLu)& q:uz-cumque Cfaluca inrclleaualill in (ur; ptimo ada non potdl' fc mOUef~.nC(: i (c accipetc~& for~ mare dii!hmen,fcd l ptincipio exteriorl : ergo nili u.le prindpinm elCEeriw: mouen,.& dans Wi did-iA men tit: _pdn~ipiUln def~llofum, non pOicrit def"U:llofum ditbmclJ dare:, 1i ;1u,c:m pOmt d~e: defctiuQ(um dic!lamcn, poterit AngellO recipicns iI~ lud.dtlicere,& peccue; fine diaamiru.~ 411tcm defeaDO(O non potdl voluntas aliqlu pacelra. qllia yo-Iuntas temper vult ex. diretlionc. & motu ;/ltdkClus.. vnde h volunw dt:6cit circa bonum fihi ,ptopofimmt necefle ell quod in ira propoGEionc. Cell app. !ita. t: obietl:i volclldi Ii. t aliqui~ d&t;~ aUJ.w(~tn. qtl~ non corrigirJnec dninet Yol1illta~ rem.ne fcrafUl" in mzIum • ;tUt 'It non rcmdat in beJlum.Q.!pIre ipCllm determinare ad malum es- paue intellr:ltus.,:lut permittC'fc quOd volantas derermlm:mr.dc:fetl:ulI dit.bminis ell. quia {ahem in appli. e;llione regal:.: intdJc:ll-us manet d~6denJ.nec po. (ell: ct:mtineu: 'I'olunulrnl aut diuectetc ilum ne ,asdat lamdurm&:: ac ei Iuc p.UI'C ceq(c:,ur dia-~ mea. ,intdlc(luf a!" (JiUDino praul:lI1J.a obietlum malum p~oponat. aUt iOI;OIIlideratllJD Ilk rcpidam. 6 indlicac:iru pwpUDa~ bollLlIll. & vtrumqoe de{ctWoftPn dl.N~ po[Cli did quod zqll'!li(~r pro. ponat vnumque.&: voluncas pro fuo arhittiCf digar quod vult,mtllo defc:Au ll:un:c: eX pane dUlamillis, qUii li vnUm e:J: iIlis obicllis m~lum elf, hue espane lu4UUe: ex pane modi. non pOtcft u:cept.:lri 1 volllnutc:. nili qui::!. conueflien~ia eillS {wi manifc:Ramr, & nOn n-pUt:anlt n mulrum incouucllicJJ!:, quod'pro nunc accepectur: nec c:nim atih polfe[ volunras JIIud fcqui de fado Ii conuf'l1ientia. ciUi non n:pr,-d"cnt2rCfUf, fed {.,Il:!m id qllod inC-OIlIlenimria: eft. Hoc etgo til ditbmcn d¢fetlua(um. reprzrClnlarC cum c;onuenicnd.a,feil Vi 'onlleni~s I}u~ nihil nHi incol!oenienrilt habet: t '1a;dc cit P"'"'UUU ,CUiIlS COpgenicmia {olum cii appol" I'mr~

1 3 '. Reftu ergo prohuc: in iHa ratione: duo:Altmlm quM Angt:ld$ in primo aau nOD pateft feip(um .mou~& pak-ipfuin formate dicbmetJ. f~d dc; .. hu ad. illud mOllen ab alia prindpio ctleti(}fi. See!!nduw. ell. quod hoc prindpillm ~rerillS mo~ ~igtdle4um. & ttjbl1~ t:l primum diCbtnen non pon~1l: dc:fc:thlose mouere ~ & ita non pord cld'c:ltuofum did.mtc:1l c:miuere. EJ: his. duobau prill. clpii.S, m:J,nifdle ftquitur iitJpedimenfU~ in. eouitabih: in Angelo ad ptec'lndum ill primo inlboti, [cilicctqui:1 c.:urt: principia dctnmp.- dd'e..

~;' auos~ 1:':1 p-u(C dia'::lInini$ .' fciJi(:e{ ~I~ Dec a fcc forlmte illlld po(ell ,nequc ab alio e:nuiQP prindpio. defc;(lIlOCo. iIIud fl.l[dpcre ~ ergo ell: indt:fe-tUbill$ pro illo- intbmi ill ditbmine ~ &: moU(JnC aglmdi~ ergo impc:ccabiles:licut etiam quia bcatllJ ~op potcll dithmen Jcfe-elullf um ~b«t J rc:ru.

Artie. 11." 441

~nafi~c a~ hoc i~ra v ilion e b~~~6Q(i[~ fi Augeluj III ptlmo mllaml cn;t pmiC,p'o form.:m~~ ditl:a~ men praU\lIJi,&' dcf;;a~orLlItl,1I11'l!>ino reddhur in~ dcfea-jhih~,provt e!l;ifj illo primo inlblni.

PrimuITI ergo i][l1d proP.'I[l1r. f~ilket ql!od non pollit {eipCUID IDOUCH.~ in prime afru cHa[ion!: qU:l D.Th. 1.1.''1u.9.Art'4. prob~t ex ArHtor, quoJ' ill primo mQtu veluntas debet opemi ell' inHinthl ;l1i~uills ellrcriori. moru:ntii. qui" tdlicct volnnras nO,n ~ouec fe-;!d ;llfq~c:m aaum nili ?X' alia "all rf1nrl per quem conilimiiur in :lau ad [e mouen .. dum; v'tdere1imlltltdtqudd in ;'Iau omaium pEf.; ~o ?cm ?~tel1 ~c: tliQUCIC 'iolllnt~s- • quiafl~n lup.~ pontt :lIlu~ ptlorrnt ;I.(tum per qLTem ,educat I~ de potentIa In aaum , & idem ell de imd-

lellu. "'

Et bllin~ r,ad" dl.quia crane meuens efl: itlaC1'u

Be omne mobildnpoumtia, 8I"6-c mouen~ Hmo- t .. uen1 reducis mobtle de potemi;l .sd a(f;um. nulla auccm pOEendl reducieur ad adllm per potentbni,. , .fed per altum ~ ergo vi volunr~$ fe mouear, dc:bc:c (upponi in aau J & non foh\m in portl1ua. Ergo 'urn proccQit in primum .IttUltij ad Hlum non pu ..

tuie fe meuere , quia non f" it ~[iLI! prior aelu, pe, qUl:1D: mOU~f~rUr .:id ilillm. Nee iufficic habere aDA ii:ctUIlJ propWimm, :vd lurdb:.ttilT> hab·!t~ (pc-ciem iJliu" qllia ,m::iIi t~!t: I}bie~um.& I;ic.:a rall:lJ1 fpcciem adl'mc VDI~nt'l~ dt rn pomma V~ vche. vel nolie.&' jntdl&:clu~ ell in p',~~nrjili vdntd:ig.,r • 'lei non inrdligJt, &: 'l~ b~m! vA m~lc: l!1td1ig~( ~ 1:1 go (Dlum. & IJUdUlU obu:"lmn uon dt hlfiicien; adualilM vr p"r:;:nda hr:. (~mOl1eaf. ciisn potiiu fe: babc:at vr m:tt'..-'I;I. drl;,l qU:U(I debet fe fYWLlrrl:', «-

tic circa talc: ubitaulTl tit po{l:w;Olliriii If) voltlll~ tate-.& inr!:U"th" ad qUilm vlrfc:mda.m aClu;ll!ru dc:fidcumr! "go {olilm ex vna ~du.~'1i Ie ro(j,o uere ad :llil:unJ non Ycto t:l obidlo [Ofl'lffi i~ ma..

vet c.lm 'eir'a iliad indigeac: mou:ri.& ab ilia tInidem meuemr ~bictliue.. fcd non fcipUm4tumc:tj

niti ipfa eifu:idlrct Ie applic~ circa ,talc: QbiC'allrn~ liCUE eire m~tt:[i~ln. V nde £elte d~it Caicutt. eitRra 111&11, 1.2.~ quM .A/illd ~fl IUi"i fk valium,. 'illiud J~ 'lla/irilJ!u. '1)1 ',.' '{J/lfllnt"" ISpplkllfftt [Iipf4111 if A fI,lmdJffIJ. y,liti, lfti1li flihll 'iIl/,lId didt

lliji ,pmui'?{mllllJllIIffRtU , '111" '{IlIlt t 1fT ~m1lm ,(1 ,/llul Ai f/Ql~nJII11I f,.Jftrit '{1I1II1Ni4S-C_JJi,tlti. '6~il

ilfJ flD[mium J fe. It" '1H~d Iy ;\ r~ airl4t uTlj.t.lit,utl1l "F/'I;cilfJltt1li }t:jpf4m IIillflulmJJl1IZ mm{"II'" fI,ltl~

tllS &Jnjjabit[JIJ,{td e~igit_ f/iltiHuipl.ult1U Ji"t1b~ '1l1i" fltlk .f fll1l11i fotfml Impmil,· fliUt.foll "/P'I,fl, _"trt ft. 1liiJ qJlh; Upl11'Uf fttTi p,purjilllm • i1''''' ,zigit 7f"turllf.fltl fl11IPl>rl "fPlfillim pu. t!r fllltt ail .. fltl'ftrt h« '''(lUtjl 1~'1f1m/jl4m. h:l C~ictanlU. Vbi infi!JuatcffiC'~~ huim I;'arign"m .. & funlhmema.-o km,'!ui3homO .... ,,) Angelus fc moutm~n,aliqQ'O 2aU. dehet ~ fin~ ali quo {e mOIln:c:- nioquin ~ fu;!liter.& fonuito opet.ruc fife monendD,noD ex 21iquo 6ne ptoc;edit.& fe :!pplicar, Ex fonuir., .1;11.

rem mom non llOtfet rationalil ;opeulio dirigi. Vnde p6uenlcndo ad primum ~mnium :!Cl:um rim non polfu in ilia Ii:- applkn-t ..-olamas • & in .. (eUellU5 ex pt;l:'toncqno fin!: ~ (lporn=r~r quOd "mlliao fon!Jit~ &; uco modo (e appll,:!r"; vel quOd applic!:'ll1r;lb alio ezt«lori IUOll'elllc , " 6:... -"em altiexml p,r.-rhabt'nu:-. Vnde in prmrQ Dl'ot1l1

Cc:u a¢iu~ tam propCC{ 6fl~ ptoptcr qu~ mCiua.:-

mr ~ quam proptc:r atlQ:dlt::ItI:JQ (erondU!Jl qU:Im n'nlens 'm.ol!e{e de-bet, qu~ atlpaJiru (!mIllur ~ Jfi'ctlu. (eu ;l:liu circa. fin~m,J.KufbriDm eft tJuOcl in/fimQ coiufquc ra attu opcrJn.i: non £¢ lJlouHf;.

(e moue.2tur abaJjo.; ,

~~ iI:! ho~ intliwu"ilIWonii D.'Ih.in","tpI. 11

lli J 'J.IIt, ~

,

§}g_£jtio L1X.e5c;' De mcrito,f§ peGl'ltlo,Ange!orum.

(iJ.If'/,f. vidc:licet quOd iIlaoperario,qlla: fimtll i~. cipit Cl1m cite rei, ell c~ ab ~g,ent(; a quo ba~ct ~I1e. Qy;t ~Iottrm.l ell: vmucr(abllilIl" de Om"1 .prlma opcr~done agcnds, ',111:1; indpi~ ~11_1D clre,rei:le,lIlpcr enim prima opcra.tlO (uppom~~otenna~ ~ qua egn:ditllr,nOIl fc moUentcm J !I ," a (upponlt IIlam in potcll!ia. non in ~alJ:mou~lls autem ~t mouens (cmpct dl. in :aBu, heut mobile vr mobile (empc:r ell in pQ(cluia.. eo quod mouere elt reducere aliquid~.: potentia .ad aaum ; nor' rcrlucitur ~Ilm~ afiqllld de: potcnU~!tt:m ad atluID, Ill" pet afl:uaJ.. r;ltem, 110Il per potcnti~litalcm,quja p"~~lUialitas non redllciE; led reduchur. Vnrlc cum in prima optutione; qll~ limul eft tum ip[o dl~ non (111'ponamr po[~nti;t opcrans in afl:ual i rate ad mouenollm (drfam p~r;l1i~I~ prlerem :la,UI"! rUllm.~pot"~ rei tr~I\llrI: ad :ia:,nlmH~m exterlorlS ~gcllru • ve poffir p~r ipfiifil redlld de pOlenti~ ad ~a,lJm,qllod c:Jlsnoucrt ab illio;& fie prilDl opef:;do monlle, lk. appli~atiuc: d"b(f c,lli: ;1,& ali,c,; li~c: ,elidriu.) poffit sb ip[a PQrcntia el1e,qul~ t'htl~l1IiA fallli1H:fll:ma~ natio aWQllis.qua: vtJqll~ ab ipfa potc:utiJ c::tlicicll· re en. vt JPphc.l.r.1 tilfUl'Il,LIo: mol;! ad cperaadum. J\rplic~rc aurern (¢.& mcuercnen purcll pereuudem ~'tum "d qucm applic~tllr.& mouetllr~tiqui. Clem ad hoc appllca(ur,~ moucrur, v((IpcrOJriollcID iI/:lIn ~g~t: ergo ex ~Iio:l~n lippli':ltur ad iflum, lion pcrslturn C\:: mullet vtlp[ununct operetur.Ergo ill ip(o primo omnium aall~ qU:llc ell pWI)llm dictarnen,qlloa fOtll\.i! IUldlca:~sin prirno inlbn· tl (1Ia: Crcatiunis • non potell: furm:!u lllud ;\rc~& mcuendo (el! appli'<llldu fe,l~d l\~b"E .\lud h~bi:rc: a principio ('lIteciori Illotl;::mc. & ap!,lic~ntc:: in~elicctllm,e.: excitant!: Vt talc dia::l{ucn h'lb~at. qUia (urn fir primus ;taUS furm;;.re ilium nail porelt elf Frllp~l~ appllcl!.donc , &. ~X~U;1fiollc lcu morione fUI,

16' Sc'lJJ1dnrnqund ill ina ratione D. Tho.rdlu

prob.induri •• cit quod iltud prillcipiuru C':z:ninrctum mntl~nS Atlg~hlln in diD pumo iolbmi, & dans CI In:;r.uDCJ1. non patlir eire mouens d(:fe~ ltUO(I!n".,; (left,tllus~.quia Ii dicbmcl} dtCc:ChJolum·c:l. ~b ~g('n~c {i;u meuenre deft:aUD$e proll~~ nire J!.'bl!t:~b 3gcme enim rea~ vc [cd urn cit, dc~ f~l'.luoru! roDto~ proucniu: non potdi. Er quid~ factlis lIi~(tfUt ilia pcabatio, quia in iIIo prill10 actl1 moudUr a ello !~nrtante quod (11 Deus,qui folus produxit Ang~$ ip clfc=,& Colus ell Authur nana(c, & (olus paten intra mcmcm ilIabi; in el:tuc opmri. ctg(J folus Jp(e apcrari potcll ilium pri~ mum aehiln.& ditbrn~1'I ilIud pdmum intclledus forronc,llU ilIudque c:xcitare: Dew a.uu:m indc:fcllibile ;Igl:PS ell: cr,go nOD pon:ll dJ,rc di!bullen d,fclti1olum Angelo in primo igibQri. & ila fi non !:Il aliud agcn5 a quo dt:tur ,qoam l Deo.bene infc([ut quod de6ccrc non pOttit.

17 C~r¢nilll {i hot: itttim~ p"ctCpid.mu: non modi-

Clm b.;Jbet cMIic:uhatc:m. quia aporret nOq fobhn ptobare CJllOd Dcus fiE principiurtl woueD5 ad ilJud diCl:1QJm qllod fontlatut in iilo iofbnli, fed «{uDd iiI in fp~iale moUCu5, quOd pro ilia iolland llOt'! pOll:'n (omp.ui. quOd ab alio agentc: &:I;clittl t(Um QiOlltattll' intcl/caus Aflgt\i. qUi ([catur.l quo Ylique dcfc~uos~ poten moued. & coofe~ qllftUq impcdiri iUuddiCtarncn,qlloJ a Oco(fi [0- hl10pCtUetllr) infunductur. baquc ;trgumentum bencprobn quOd conna(uEale di<hmen ,quod pro tunc pollulat Angc:ills !it l D to, !Ion l;lliltn oftendirqllOd non pollit impediri ilflld dil!hmen. &,ab ,;allo agmt~ fell mommtc dcfeauofum t~ddi. Siati~ lim oponct otleodete quOd DCIl! fir if;!; fpcciale IDOUCils plO'illo inJbnti. v( non Jqffid.u Uloucr:c

p,hylicc;& cntiudu~ ad'attum ilium,&- CCClindt\(n. g""ieul"m modum'quo pr;l:mouet iI::liqua ~gcilljl ct'ca!iI,fed C:'dam quo~d mioll~m mOtalltOltisl iia \Ie Iamcdc moucndi mor~htt[ ipfe: (pecia/fter excftt:.t~ &: moueat. Speriali5 aurern moria \lei pou'Q :a~d~ . pi eJ; pane obl.:i!l:i, qUia ad obieaUIII fpeci:de meuer.v.g.ad lupcrnaturalem :llicuill5 obicdi, cognJtiollcm,vel t:II paw: (llbied:i I 'Ir (juia Ie haber f3D~ quam parti(:ulare, &:: immediarum :2gel,'l$ illiu, cf~, fethlJ,fi'l:llr pcr(ona diufna in ChciJ'io ell: {pt,iaUr~rinfhlC:ns 1I1.:1aU.i ~iam hilrnatlOS Cbrilti ;- vel dt:'ll:qnc eX p.1ne modi. Vt quia:dJicacircr c;on;:ul'o. m ad aliqliem c:tfc:ltUin a (e i;:!cntum, vtL liri~ conGmio alrerius i::Iu(;:t,fed fcrola, In ptdeiUh'to potell DClIs did (peci;de age~", (olum quia nlOUC~ ad obiellurn fpcci:M, v.$.ad Cupcnmuralc: • veI!i1! honcllum, tum qui~ pOfi~E Angelum cfi::tre in putis narur:tlibll$. tum 'lUi;i hoc di de quo inqllin. mus , cue non ~nffit in iIIo primo inlbmi moliere Deus itlua d,lpolillonem ipGu1 caU(:t (fCUZlU! cnrimcm mat~rblcm po:ccari , & non ad adum bDnum. 6 ita 2 !;'.\'cl.ab alia mOlu (uggel1iohe in .. (lufC:!Ur. (kut poll IUud primum illli311:S potdl rno uere ad cnrir:uem pcCCa!i,UhC hoc quod fit AI1~ thor r~(':i1d. N ee potdl in pr:dt mi ~ccipi (peclalit motic ilIo rccundo modo CJ; pane lllbrc:di. tUm erlsm eOnCllU:l1 YOIUntoll cr~'ata :ld elicielldulQ alturn,Ocus ;ll:Jfcrn hon Ie (010 • fed Vt pdU'la (au. 6, qu;t: c:rt concurfas gencralis. Rella, ergoquOd viJcamu5 quomodo rrc:cialitct concutIat ft.'ftio rnoao,(cil. lIIpplicmdo. feu cxclando iJudlethlln Angdi • &. fo(m3!1do Illius ditl.amto. i1:1 quod a niJUill$ :literiu5 fugg~fiionc pomt fommi. I

• ~am. quOd runt opete!'it Deus ranCJllilin ~ clplum Ipliulml:f hbl:natls aeu~. nOD Iolwn.n aclu primo.G:d Cri;lIll in atlu Ccc:Updo. non videtUr (uHiccre I quia hoc ctii dcbetfaluari in.41owi atlu. etlam poft primum inllanl, cllm omni$ atluaJiJ Ii .. b~[:I,Hl;duCI d~btat in rr~mumJibcnun., idcbcm= ad Omnt5 atlus nce:e.lbna dt p~mouo phyiica D~i) inquitimu$ surem qua ratione ita (p~cja.lit" debc:at c:11i:: a Deo in bee primGt inlbnri, quod non poffir comp~d pcccamm. Et D. Tho. cum reducii illos morus in Ocum) non (oJumid beit ex co quod hbenautlllum rcduci d~bet. & dcpend6e it prii1lo hberO'. &:: 2b ip(o aeaperc aClau1f;1u:lil, ho~ !=nim in qUOQlmquc adll libetott:p~riridc:. ber,qlli21 ptimo libero dtpel1dens clt,fed {pc'i;li~ fet hoc (CdIH;it ad IpCUnl primum dUhmen jore!;; ~et1us.quod de~~ t ctrc .a,b u'c:ri~d princi~io • .reil• ~ Deo, lit ex Arillotcle .n 8.ElhlC. docet Inft# If1io 8:. IIrl+aa ,.& CaicraDIlS ihi. &. J. ';,11ITII gmri/,; "Il"r04l1tJt/t 6. in p.,ultpitt4.& 1_2.-9"-9.47'10+ qui~ by, lads fc:mp~reQdnn ttnore procc:dir, quad ,Ito":

IlJm~1 mDUI;(Ur ab al:qno el!tcriori plindpio, quia mOUClur pcr coofilium(idc:m dl quod difumep) ; r & hoc con(dillmc:uliapriori VulUnk!lc~.&jIJa voluJitas ex 31i~ priori propolitigne inccUei!J:llJi; quoufque dc:ucnialur in ;lliquod primlllU imelle.-. aum, qllod non eft ~ YoluD(3fe. u.d "b a.liquo infiinClu uH:riori,& extaiori moueil~, edt· i DJlc.~:ttt: in hoc infil1:.:ndum cll {equc:pdo dO,ad-. nam D. Thorn;!:, quod Angdu5 in primo IlClu nofl purdl: lib alio accipc:r(' dictamen J ~ motum inEcl- . lcttus I ,ulm a Dco t & idcod>:feelaofllID dtal\~ me:n.&:' rnolioncrn mnl) habercnon pettfr. '

IQ hoc !lutern diUicultatem cantina uuo 0- I B Tho.quia non apparct ,Cllt non pollit in ilIo priiU!)" - inllwri a,cipne dic}amcn. dc:fl:'d:uo(u1D, Ii non 1, fr;,qoia ilIe: ell primus omnium altus, in 'lUI) non-. dum porcll (c app1i(arc,ok moucrc,lic~E poffif :;tail cd~uc.falltm ab ;dia Angelo nulo.PC!ll!tnus "pial

, . ~~

Difjut4Iio,XX11f: .Arlie. 11. 447

quod mod3 Dc:llj C{eet 'inurn Afige!nm- CUm ce- , {urn. Vt fi fulmen enm bpide cxcuti~ttir rmeum 1

gnitionl:! aliorumAn~c_loti1~. /5( inter iIIo~vid~aJ nube. ~id ergo prohibet q!uld (:onn~t1it:i.li!ct

Dzmol'lI:s,&: eorum didamHu ma!a,aut Qill;LDI:U5 Angclm prOdll[;31Ur ii DeC) cum reao dlo!:tamine

illi reuclae eerum pcffimas t.ogttadone.s. sur qUia. in prime i{llhl1ti. fed Camet! poillrabaliqucconm

Yidcdpfu,operaflccs , & 10qm::mc5 rnab, aut qUia trado impc:diri pc:rfuggdbolJcm prauarn, v[ in Ca-

ipCe Darmonm iIlomc[ li:ilhnti ~I:I quo Angclll~ de {Il pofire I Q.eod fi Dens renerur id hnpcdire,ira

DOUD crestur, (uggc;rit ei , & loquitur malum. In ve implicetcont[;jdiitinnem nrin impcdirc,affigne~

hoc enim nlllla impltcacio inuoluitur, & pr:'l:Ccrdm rur ex quo principio id ptoLltniat j Vt non poffit

qula potdt Deus dicefe: Da:moni quod in illo in· . p~tmitri.

f'bnci B. produect '1nUiD Angc:lum;& ipfc: pOiclf Nlhilomli'lug b~, nihil cuincunt COntra ratio- l.d

kiD.:re p.u-~E.lIn ruggcllioncm; &. dd1:rnmm ad il- nem D ,Thof Cnies Colida Vetita5 hoc {olo verbe

hun (uam cogl::uiolit::m,'1r confcllim ~tqnc predu- co~(picietui' • qu6d fotmui_o diaaminis lic~i pen-

catllt,videae illum, Ct cogitationcn1 ems mal am fi~ de~c i duobIlJ;Ccil.3; propofitiol1C: f~iHnanifdht!o-

bi pcduadcnrem, ':If habc.u iUud dilbmcn; Q.god ne C1biceli 'It a maceria ciru q!iam form3ci d~betJ

cohn loqlli pome Angdu! illi Angelo qui predu- 1St ab i:fficicmc feu :ipplicame pcr quem mouerur,

cIme it! ecdem inlhnli in quo crc~uir,patc~, quia ~pplicliUl:. '" formatu(, d}aa~~n; 9uoad ptimlltt1

~cnl:: ponll: agcns ere:~,!um .opcra~s, mfbrtrand paedt quldum cooprm I,n prim!) mlbmi aliqua

mouue.& agerc Iii tCm In eo mlhnu In quo crea- ~rc;uurg vr l:1t:cmphs :ll!a[i~ liJonar~ti'im d\iquaad

tur a DJ:!Q,Ii'iH fi modo crcaremrLuna1 v el ~Cr in {C,"ulldilm !olus Deus qui Imus in mcntcor.:;~.i

pra:[~nria Solis, in codemrner !nlbnl'i mllmin~tc:. potea,ipfa vera mens.feu vo!Unta~ m~Uerc fe noli

tLit ab e:o,& illuminm:calia> IX li ercarernr homo porcU;l1cQlle applica,c in ilia prlmo ate!" cao 1

j~ pra:'(l:ntIOi Soli,s ape!tis ,~cl1li~!n eod=:In inftanti ~eo mora,,,, "PPlic~la ilium diciat, vt iaIU of1::cfl'"

VldCfCl1quod ell: IIiUn'lJllatJ a hUPine SOhh Et ma- dimU1. QJ.1a:cumquc ~rgo crClcura nHIUl'llg volun .. ,

(\:tia prillu,in inlb,nti quo creatur pou:ft a gC[ll:~ r~r~nJ per fuggefrion~m. & lo~urionc:m feu pro- '

fa,ntc ilJHUlllati ~I form~n1 1i.1(~i~i~e.ficut lil qU(lt~- pofitio~cm objedi. ~IIO al~ici~rur VU!UfiI;il" fi:,n

die cum ex fp~'ICbul Euchafllbcls gcncrarnt ill· format I p(um dlcbme inru s II] ltlldktlu l~d Ipl e-

qUid ill eo inlhmi in quo {ubrogatur materia pri- mee intdleaus tint fopnar iIIud "" obieCt!s pro.

rna loco qUOllltitati$. Etgo edam in eodem inliant; pofili~,liul! ptoponantllr per {aggefiion~m.'" pr(l~

quo cremir Angdll$.pOt!!lbbalio Angdo iIIu!i'li~, pofitioncm, rCII PCE IUllic>nern ~kedus. liue ptr n~li ;& per fuggCfitOI'lCffi moucri • mulrq magi, propriani In\lel1lioi'lcm,~m inquihlionc:m. vel it' quam Uu~c: corpor.ll!.ti enim AngcllJs iile "caru!, il1lmimQn.&:m a D%o. EI, lic,vuliqli;:l ,reatUr:! 0-

armi! ~CL~lii vidcn~o ;diu~ ~Ilgelum:crgo pete- quamr ~Imi ~(j vi ei ruadc:at id quod inrendi'f 8(

fit ere;,.r! videndo ctUHoglunom:m. & diaamen de quo loqu1tll[. ncccll'c ell quod fupponat ni.

prauum.quod libi (uggerit. Ilcmcm cum coi fuadcrc vult qujj Cilm :;j:d iprum

~od (j hoc :ldmi£tirur I ruil' tatum fUDdamcu- qui audit (uggd!iofJcm, pcnilleat intra (c formatel

tumD:~~a.qui,dicc( l Dco. v~ aUE~orc ~mutzc diaam~n, !J1t' au.~m qui.plOpenlt, 8.q~"f,!,~dcrt

vel gt:1Uit' moue.arur Angelo! In lilo rruno Inftiln- non f~'lt alsl1d qlllm m~JlIrdta.c::'. &. CIlhibcn~ rna-

ti.~ pfOV[ . ab eo 'non pO.fIie in Angelo ell'e dC!f~- t~tiam 'It ~9tiu~ f~u (:uiollc:s 1I.!tta,beiltcJ § ,& alU-

¢luorum dil1oi1m~D. neql1cpC"atUID, tamtnql1l:1. ClcmeS,vt fsqn. audn fO'IDlltC (~,'pollit dll!larn~.

pocdt camp,Hi quod ab aitc:,o Angelo fibi Cuggc- ilJd~ eft quod pcr(uaJell~,Ccil aUideflu!rcrum d~~

f,UUt ~auum dllbmcn • lam ex ilia patte hlb"re, ber fupponcrJ:! ip[lIm cui loq_~itll' in flatu h.bdi

p,otdl Angelus principillm in I:jutJd l"c:fun~b(Urm~' ad fcpnandum dithml!ll cii. his quz fib. propo--

lida peccati,& non in Deum, (jCUt in aliil inlland- nuneur , quia is q Ili propo nit. r,On operamr inm.

b.us pritter prirnum potell C'X (ilggeftione :Jltc:tlas applic3ndo,t &. formando ,Iilhmcn, (cd tnanifc-

Ecc,are,line hoc quod refu!'lIhwdd in Deum.Ni- Ihndo ohlcdum. & ubibendo matcriall1. "lid"

Ii dicatur qUDd Dens,hI primo intbnti Fc:t rpcci~-· form~ri pollit ab co qui ;!. .. air, £t fie debet (ufpo"' lcm ,prouidc!lti~m vel m~nu[cm:nriam anen!t nc' nl esiftcns, qUt;l qnod flon ellactu,'" in faCio dId Da:n;mll (Ilggerilf malum Al1g~ 10 quem crcat • .:mt\, csHklu > op~r.;Itinon pordl:, III conrequcurtt nc-

li Cl1ggcfil. quod ilfc non tonte;nrjar. S~d tunc <J1u:: "'fet-liue (eu appht~tiue i aut motiue- f(>rm~ra

OpDrtt~!: ollc:ndrCl:! quoo illa. manmcnc:mia. &' pro~ hbi dlcbmen. Er rudi.u non (ufficj, quod fir e:ri-

uide:ntia fpedalis Ita fit debil.:!., qilod implict'f nap flen, • rcd i~;I in :It'll! quod polli. (I; mouett. & te§

.dui: nam Ii eli: poffibili~ [uggeltio rti.lla pro ilIo ducm: de potenri:! aJ at{um.:fd qUCid ftqufiitut~

It!llanri.,ut erir impo.ffibili5 Uri prouidtntia. qua: quOd fir ilia pDcr.:ntia iam f;tcbin :.Iau,qu~ efi COii~

iUam non impl)"diatl ~arf: Hie fecurius :ld rpec:i;i~ dill!;) feu JtUQ~ mOIfc:nri, • non in palencia rollii'll.

Icrn manllu:ncDriam Dd impomme, IX utntt'm qnl clHlatu5 mobili5. fell moel. Vnd~ pto primo

Me in1crponkur.qaia vel iIla {peci;dis 1n2ntlEl:me:n. aa:u cliciendo nuUa cre~rur~ mouere potc;fi , qnia

ria ell. ex grati;l. lIel ex debito. S, e:S" gr:.tia;ptlfc:l'l: ~ dio c:~ p;ute ¢~iflenli% pollcr did quDd futlidr il-

Deo ncgad.& pet"cai't Allgc:iU$,G ex dcbito,opor- 1a cxillcnria ilHI.!~ inftamis. v~ in illl1rn crc:atUnm

Jet ofiend«C'.cx qua caufa, & rationc id nt;,di:.rio agat lune .ipfam :tgem ,rcarum "lUone pare phy ...

exig'tt CtC:3tut=l'& ilIa c:rirr;Itioimpecc~bili'~$ an- ur;;i, & in q11a pUE? El:'lipiat ipfum mobile, ramen

te !lUnulencmi3m. Et Iic:et OJ:!'os n gcnerans. &: agerc in ipfam tola ;lcl;ione propon~mi!t &:: mani~

.Autbm' 'naruror rime: m"oea~ C"Of Angeli. " mm- fdr~ntis chielh:nn VI ipla forrnafC' fibi roffiE &i-

f"m~ Eamen (lpn~1.[io gcnfranri!> bene potdl imper damen ,plu5 tC'lllirit qU3m exilictuiam,fdtrem lie:

dirl qU:Ulfum cit ex {laturarel. nifi DeM (pe-dati C:tm~nrem.qI1Odpoffi( (c mClUetJ:!'. (( appliate, 6-

maDutenciltia id ruiret. dc quo in prz(tJlti nOn biqac: fonn;ue dUhml:'ll. q,~od ramen p~o primo

2gil_!l~ ticul' aqua a (uo g~ner'l,itrC ptodu~i poRtI~ aaD. eficien~o naltus hm:l1caU$ vell1oIunt~) In-

~h'jgid3. {k ramen patdl per imp~enUIJU b«.nollm11lmdl.

c:~mtrarium pwdnci c.ilida ) n' cUm prQdudtln'in V nde (j)hnmmr omnIOJ qu~ in Q}'potilllm albia. .1 J.

~afc tUh Sole ~ 6(. lapis a geneul'uc produrinu in. (unt.f alCIDur jpformando lifo di~bminr,& ptimo IQCo dcorfulU ~ vel cum mom ~r[tun. potcli: ra'-; =lau Uctllil lion dicf{pc-ciakm m.,tQftm vel flIno-

m~n e~ CDIUIUio iltlpedir:ntc prodLld injoeo {Ilf~ nc: fpedaln obieai,id ell iupcrnatur:dif ad qUQd

(WIlt 1'~ in !lube I imQ Cl!m mom violwta in ""'"" ; mOllea~ qlli~ ai.un 6 in puns natlJ£;alj~!II! Cft~Ul(

. . , An.&cif,lj,

448 !bi,£jl,LlX. e1c. t» merlto, f1 pcanto -:Ange/arum.

A)lgelu; J adhuc folus Dells op~rad dic::erur ilIuJ? m~ndllm dj~:imen,i1DJI ~Hter c;;HicUrrit qu~~p~~ ..

prilmlttldCl:ul11; fcd dicitur (pccl~Ir:.tTIOllc=ns, qma pO~l;lldo o.bl~tl:.tlm quali marc:mn;,quam 1I_ltCfln'!!'

non potu(l -sb alio volllntaS mOIl~rJ qilantl.l.~1 ad relhg~r,& InrdJr_gcndo fO~I11~t ~bl d~tbrn:n ,fed

:ppltcati!)uem dfl.'a:Jllaltl ill illo primo l~{bml,nec clft;~bua for~a!lO ,t!( ap~ hc:mo mr~flDt dtb~~ elfe:

~balio fo~milri dictamen iUud, yt apphcanrc, & ab Jp[o lludJl:'llt" ; vc:~ a Dec q~u operatur mrn

ente ad illud fOn1undum,Jicetobiedumpo(~ ipCurn. Vrtd(tpaqal1 mre-rca quod Angdus ~,.Ii

fi°i, alio propeni : Et tic coucedirnus Ql10d In illo nunccreatar videar (jitbmina, feu cogitarioncl

;;[~Il in!l:arlti opera~iJr Deus {pe.cia~i[~~ illo mo- ~Iiomm Angelorum fiue bon as! fiue mal~,niti ipfc:

do Cd!. non folurn VI p.rimum prmcipium llbero- mills (e rnouere polTir. & ~pplJc~n: CI: hiS 'iua:: Ill"

rum ad-uum quantum ad cmitatc:m;6i efle, 'It pri- tclligit ad ferrnandnm illud diaam~n. fed ilia ap-

mum dfidCJ1~ , C!:d edam vr primum pdncipmln pllcaflo deber venire a~ ex!tinftco principio, quia

CXCi!3J1S,& mouens illtclld.1:llltl ell: P"([~ formaria- !:II primus a,dllS , nee tupP.onit :lliulil pri(Jfcm quo

nis allbmli'lis.&: con(equcnn~t voluntatern con- Ie moue-at,& applin-t. Yude op<1ner quod redlll:li-

il:i[~tn5 in aCtu.l1ime requi~ra 'It mouear Ce. in eur ilia appliC3tio , IX modo forma"di (jjl!hmcn ad

(JilO genere ill'l.n potell: voIUn!;!S ?~~li.e iJl[dledu~ ip(I1lrtDeu~ • '1U~ in iIIo prime itillanri {olus po-

applkari ab alio agentc crc:ltO, nJU a 1010 Dco,q,11 tdl: runuere mtus Intcllcllum,& volumalem An~

c:1l proprium, ,&; imm~diarum prillc:ipil1li1 'Iol~n. . g~!i. Et Iidt moucae ad in rell-gendum ea qUI: ~b

'~ii$, &- intclled:l.ls. iIIumqllc gcner.il per "rC~[IO- alus ptoponUiJ[;Jr {jill: finr.bona, fiue mala;litllt In

nem lanquam vniuetr,tlilfimUIfi pril1cipi~m m~. codem pth11D i.nlhllri Angeli_ infcriorc=s i1hlmina-

uens iUa5PO!Cfltias , qU3!: proptt:r jU;II11 YIl1l1~t:ah- bantur. a lilr(:'t~ur~bus ;_. & i1~ i1lo~ conlicrrcbanrut

UteID a 1010 Dee g_encUlltUr, &: ab co aCCJplUIIE ~x rnouone DCI: I~d rarnen inrelligere , &. c"gno-

rrlmun) 1II0t\111l quo cm~mr~ll1lltllr in _attu ad ~c (cct~ I~ala quz alrer propcnir ~0l1d~11'l_1 eft ~:liu'.'\

1lIOUCJldLlIll. Gent cor aeCJp1t a {UD g~nerdntC pn· Icd tn1111a acerpcre \lr conformer it' IIIJ$.& IUlua 11-

mum motum vit,IICIII quo illdplt (0; mnuere , lice lud malum quod l'ibi proponirur vdit opcrati.Ad

sd illum motum pateR Ii: mouere cor, lice! illum hoc ~UII:'111 non lidlicli pr"pofilio m:la alretius.

diciJlt yi!.llit(;r. q'L1I:! dUll (it primus morus , non e,ufql1c cognilio,kll rcquirieur ddc,hrc(a ;lpplica~

{llrrOillr alilllJl pd()r~m (llJ? IC . .'l.pplice~>/!{_ .1110UC~t 1'0 ;}udicJ\fis,9li3 fe, ~rp!Jcrt :l.d con(enriendllm. i1~

ad Ilhun j &. tE.!. debet Jpl'lu:3rlJ & moucn ab alio malo ,& ad formanullm du1amcIJ cenferme db.

exrerior: pnncipro , CdL j_ g~nerame. ;. quo .lccipiE ~od Ii ipf!': ;!I!clicns no~ poffit Ie meuere pro iIIo

gCllltUin primarn morionem , & :tppIKat,oneltl_ila- inHautl·, ~ furmare fihl did-amen, fc=d ab allo de.

runlem, qua couilimhur illlhlU conucniemi hbi. bc.t! FOIIIIJti,&, nlolleri, ille allul dcfcauo!c'! (1= ha-

& debuo Jd (c moucndum Ceu vlucndum.ficur la- bl:hi!, fi :lpphcCI audknrem ad fOlnlandumillud

pi~ ~d qUldt!:ndlllll,vd 311 rettdcI101.lm in (uJm did:llncn dl:fcauoCum.Vndc non {ufliarin primo

quic~clll. Ira ViUCOtl:J vit~ il1!dh:-~u.'l.1i ~cdpi_ulU;l illa ill~hnri habere. aJ~[lucm {ugger~ftm. fi~i~-

Iuo g~ncrantc Dco qUI ell pmnum mii:lhgcm. lum dlchnlc:n, 'It II] il urn [anquam In prmclpmm

iplUJ11 ptimurn mctum fc meucnd] vi[;J illtdle- to[:!I,ter ft:dU[;aIUrprauit~5 iJb,&: malitia,redopOI~

J!iuali,& v,oltdlu .• id 1:11 ip(um primurn dlchmcn, rcr id reduci in ali1.ld princJpium, (cilic~t inillud 1

. & ap plimioll(:n'l ad illud j V; inde jncipi~nt (c mo- (1110 tlfediue Formarc debet rale di~hmcn,& mo-

ncrc , ira qUlld in "0 mOEU elt qu.l1i mOtU5CDrdis lI.:ri,l~u apph,:tri ad illud, Ert:um hocprineipiuID

inrdkCkllalis. &: hoc lolum pollum habere a Dec, clfl:diuum lie moucns, & appJicam non potIit dfc:

q'Jta POll eil: idiyd,1.~;ns qll~d jlJt~ainrellcau;k~, ipfc_Angdus,_qui _in ilia intl,aJU~ creatur • "" q!l~ al1~

lx voluntarcm pollnopt:ra[l, {!( influere feu applt- du Illam fllggelhoncm,qUla non potell {e mollcre

C:Jtc ilhnu primUln mceum, Er i111l111 quidcm Yo- in primo allu • f~d fD.ltls Deus poffirin iIIo primo

lun{:ll,& infd!ea-115 diclullt. qlli~ vitalis clt,& li- aelu mOllelc, & ~pp1ie~rc, inde fit quod railS {ug-

b:ro Ili(ldoc:lidum,quil cum ilJd,lfcrcntia ({:II. yni- geftio !ll;lli Angeli non pollir aliqu.d tunc Op'-:fari.

\lC(falitatc iud:icij. &. fine cOlelion;; 'Ioluniaus. eft. lIif! ipCc Deus, qui fohn in illo ;Id:l1 mOuct.& .ap.

fed non ad Hhun (c ItIOIlCnt , .:s.: ;applicant,quia plic:at COt Al1gcli , cOllformit~I ad ip(am mwm

pJimll5 ell; nih~l ~u[~m nlouct. &: applicalilifi tilggdl:iont!ll applil;e[ ad fOfmandum dithmcn

pet aaunt J nee moUnut Ilili Pf(lVC in por~l1li~. pmuun1 quod tllet rcf!lnucrc dcfdlum in ip(UiU

Vndc ad primum aJicuius rei :tdum, repllgnat Dcum. ~od cum Jl~re non pollit,dJicacirn- pro-

, quod res ill~ fe mQlleat. & applicct, lici':c iIlum bat D.Th. quod 110n poml in iIIo primoatlu..An§

prodllen,& cliGj:l.t. • , gd\1S p~ccaret eX co quod non dltur tunc 3liquod'

2.~ Ad id vero. ~uod argumcnlUm vrgct, quia po· ptindpium .iqllo mOUtatUf dcfea;uole, &. appli~

t~n poni,quQ..iangdqs qui modo clo::amr. ab alio cctUr ad fOflllandum ditlam(D prauum, nili refun..

Angelo m.uo :I.«ipiat didamcn defcduofum. ~ d~[ut dcfcdu5 il~ Ocum. qqi Coills ill mo primo

fie h~bctt' p'ltcfi; prindpium ad quod rcdu~aludl- aCtu mou~re po[ell:. Ncque hoc reduciturad fpe-

Ie dcfcti::U5 did-aminis, quo in pti1no inllanti mo- citllcQl m.'l.QutenentiiDci.quz in iIIo primo ina-an-

UeatUl' ; R.crpQP. quOd admHlo vel d~to q~Qd ita. ri fit indebira,fed ad Pllfl!n. & merun impoffibili-

}lollit Angelus iam c.xiltens loqui ad Angc:lum qqi melD aherius proxinlC- , & imlm'di3te mQuentis ad

denollo producitur in eQdemmt!t inlhnti in quo- forrnJ.tldum di,brncp,nili (olus Deus.

Cftatilt ,.f3IllCD h~ nOli (uffidt 3-d f~rm~ndum di- Ad.k! quod Yl~i~O add!t~r , qQ:o~ bene poten "i

Camen dlud • qUia Angdu~ vd qUICtifilql1C Ilxre-. op~rallo gentt.mtl5 In~plldlU ab a110 ermn(eco

ri\UrropO~t:O$. & fcp{:J;!ih'ltatu.al{l~{i .obiea:unl. :gc~tt',. vt in,exanfJ!s allans appam, r~rp.Dnde(l

non fuRiaL fiJrm.n-e dld~mi:" InIr.1 mtelletlum polle qmJl.'m IInpcdm, qL13ndo opcrano db de-

aildi~nd~. (cd ipfe: audiell$ focm.ltC' 9cbcr ex hil pcnde:t ab aliquo c:r;(tfiori. vdquando agens ex~'

qU3! .libi pt'opo_n~nlUti1b ;llio, YlJde. qUi I,Qqilic Ut rrin(e,um potell per (eim mc:di~~e im~~[ate ip(aQl

:U!tt'h &: vulnth ptrfuad;rc:nque !tills d,throen rc:in qll~ gel1c:r:!Hlr~& lIlau.! b~IU(ahdiLlenet=,Si

{orpure • d, ~ fUppDni!\'1l quOd me cui loquifur :lUre agens clmin f~u non fit ule quOd poSit irnul

DDn (alum Gt c:xillen~; red if :I. i;~mens quod poffir immnrate ip(um geniturn ad opcrandllm. red fo-

fe mOucr~. &. applicare ad e.1 quz au.di[ all. alio. lit Jum ~~uin(cc;e plop.oncrc, .& allicc=rc vt (c immllex iUis fonn= di~bmI;D~quja me qui Inqui!ut • ri::Il, t!:t.licut ell: in inreikClIJ • & yolunrare ~ 'tunt non propC!lIit. & monlittt mQlla :luilicutcm adfQI- pot~i' ADsellU {let fllggduonh-I:tmlml imqlu-

t~re

DifPUIAlitl X X 111. .Art. 11. 449

tare aht;d_lls' Angeli imc:llellum in ip(o primo in- Relpofi. nc:gand(l minorern, Ad ptimam ptO- 2. f

ilaIJII._ {!..t. prima opefati.one ~t1~,qui.anec ipfe Au- batiollcm dicilll{ quod D5h:llon fiiit {Qlh~iiUJ

gclus fuggercns porell mU'lIlplum 11mlJ.;tllim al- in omnibus locis tudfCC omnes rationes qu~

eeriLu 0 p~(IIri C'flicierllt:r ~ nee ilk cui Cuggeritur probam Angelum non polle pec'~at'e in primo ill-

p.~" illa primo i~aallti porcft. [cipCum iiiOtierc, Iland;(~d alii Ifj.didir in 1.[eflt. difl+~Ii;1m in q,"t

&. applicate. ad formandllUl dll~lamen t Ii autern 'IJR{~ Gil. alia in hac l;p''1.6~. ,,+ & illa vltima ynf-

ddloluatur ad. Deum , Vt ip(e irnrnuree , &; formcE uerf:dior eft~& c6plc:cHtuc .On'ifle eafum pro omni

dW:JITIcn in mente Angeli quem producic , rune opillione. id dl,fil1c Angelui iii primo hlilanti ha·

cernnn dl quod Deus potdl: rllud impfj~crc jmtll buerlt ad:i:llfi rtipematuul~m • fiue tantum natur;t ..

intelktlumAl1geli pcodUd:i,Ced eodclll modo cer- lem, Vf aliqui dberunr. lit ideo ilh racio vltima

fum cit quod non patcndcfc-~hloscarplic:ue J ne- ~Il efficacior, & vniUCECalior, nee negaeur a 1;'.

que mouere ad torroandum defefriJofum d{da~ Them. in alii~ loci, J vbi alias r:lIiol'lc, tradit; Is

limn;&' Jie neque iuxea a1cuill! [uggcnioncm pra- Hbm m[onem qu~rn tEadit.in 'lilli/I. 1 (i. 'ilt mel«, Ii

uam ad illnd (;Ollellmr~.~rc; iIla prima optr.ttio iilrelligimr in 1;ii'lIO rigotcc qyOd in pEimo inLhnri

inteUed:ualis t;te~lura: in p~imo (uz creationi! in- non h~bilCrit Ang~las ad:mri fupcmatura[em. (ed

fhntiita en Immedi:l~e a Dco,vC a geneumc;qllod nUUf4h':m tant\im,mnllat c:rncnQacam dfe quoad

nOll pardl:ab alia creato agentc'l'l(Einfe(:lIs im- hodn I".c I.p.vbi ",peqcdo~ct l\ngelum crcat~m

pedi{i proP(CE I:aEioni:m album. iii 8mti3 mcmHfc; 1n primo inllanti bcuiwdinem. ve pater inbli& qu41.GJ.ofrt'f.ofd ;.& ifTf.6.&[upii

SO/II/l11lnr ATff1lTiJinfA. .,.6~ •• m. f.& ~uod noll meruit flili pet conu~dio-

~ nem chai'i(:ni, .• qtlz ell per gratiam • doc" ibiJ,t11 4rl'4.Jm.~.& reS til ,ena. Q.!!atcin hocemendata

Primo arguirllr u auehoriute D. Tho. qlIia G ell: iUHafio.Er idto liccdbi [radira fuctitrltia Cut -,

'"4 implk~'tt comc<l.dUlioncm quOd Angdusil1 pd~ J\ngdu! non pcc,auctitin prhiiodnliami pro .,.no

momlbmi pf'C(:;lrct. vfliued;liirer id ~lli:t vesum earu cafifijrn~fcili'tt r. runc non habuit conllcrlia-

pro omni C:UIJIlII.I,& In omni cafu.liquickm id fii- nem niG namralcm, ramen illl»c /QCI1 lop. rndita

damns in hue qd3d G, prima operatic,&, prima jn~ eft ... niuerfaiior urio, edam pro caCti quo habuerit

Ibn! , in q'lO 11011 ra!c;amcu~i nilU Dee. At D. CLlpernuu(alem rnctum in ille primo inaanti.

Thoul. mil) ptO ormu calli ponit Allgelum non Ad [c,undalIl ptobat .. lx loc~ ;.p_Re[p.in pfim,s 2.e;

p o If" pc ccsre ill ptl roo inlh.mi : ergo iii Jlon ell conftmd:ioflcmlitterz rnagislc:gitimam fie dfe fa-

impl!t.:l~otil1rrl. Minor prob~rnt: n:irn in ptimh; in 'i~ndam, '(nod libetum iI~biltium 'et:lrurz pcndt

qH..:jl. 1(;. Jt 'fUlill "~it:. 4. docet > ide!) AngefHTn in primo inll.ultl crc-adonis mou~iadboJlllJn me--

PUfl pl&eaj{t hi primll infl4m.. 'flli4 in pyiTIJ~ jnflall- rendo, fi ramen MtUra Ilr inrcgr;l.. non aUt;m ad

ti fH& tTI:afi~tliJ 'p!lrfllir qllM elJllfltrltrnUr lid nli- anahun p~a:ando. ira q~lQd iJlaconditionalis Ji 11 ...

fur .. 111/'l [IIi ,ogni,j'l1itn fi&fln"H11I tJHII7iI n~n pml!' fHM fit f1lttgrlf Coltim cadat,& ('onJ1ruaiUt cUm ilb

pU(lfyt ; puPTllDdu71I411lt11l '71 iJ 'JIm#. tP fiiprll tllI- panicula "uJl muglri 1f11r,"'Q;nOn lIumn cum ilia.

,II,..1Im • '1ft{ lib 111 ",(lvlI.Ergo in cafn quo 111 primo & n~ ad malll'I'fJ'ttelln."'~ (cd ilia, dau(ul;t1flJtltlfIjl1ftanci eenuenererurjnon Cofllm in (ui n:ljJ~r31c:m wn 4" ,",,11f/11 P!WllItltJ C¢nfC"lIrarinrcrpafilaquau

cognirlonrnl ~ {cd edam in (lIpcrnarural em. patuit per p~rcl1tlie Gm. & ilia cOlidition.u~ ~Ji f1<fHlra jiI

pecc;lre.ConLbuutcm L'l: todtm D.'Tho.quod in il1le"YIt. referaHu ad polf. meteri, quiueucfa n

primo jnllanti me,uit Angdu5 ~titudill~m fu- panic fitted in primo i!lllami~ opom:t qnOd .Il;t. .

pc:tnamralem, & motUJ fuit fupcmllu~raliu:r per tura fit inltgt3 : Ii cnim per peccaruID lit "ma~~

gntiam, C.lffi rtcep:tit gmj:J': fanaj6c~ti0I1(!m in non porcti~ rune mereri. oSi Ifni! quis non :tcqUl-

illo prhno inlbllli per propri~1t1 difpofitioJlcm. Vt cCnt Jlli tontltufrioni 1i1CC:'~. qll~ fan! IcgiUlna

adultus ~ non 'It pamulu5. fieut cQnllat e'tf ipfo app~rc:t, fed conren dar I;(iam iII:un condidondc:l'Il

D;Thom.'" bdC 'JHllft.6~.<frtk.G. fIT j"prfl'1uft.61.. caderc Inper illam pmicllbm & 11011 ifd malUTiJ

IVI.r.& ~.plf1J. ql<l}f'H' (In.;_ lr~m qllOd aliqua pewzmlD.ira quod ad vtrumque. fcmce~.ad mc:r~

natura. in primo inlhnti mel eatur J &: non peeeer, ddnJ;& ad nan pcccsndum Ecquiratuf quod natuf~

vl!Ii6c;ltllr (olum Jj n;ltUrii lit im~gra • non Y4!IQ {it integra,1i '1ero lie cotrupta.quOd pecltnc: poffi~;

Ii fitCOffUpla ~ np:ttct 1(J.Hfi.tx j.p.QJl&j!'H.ill'r. ranC dlccndaln dl: quod narura vitiata perptt;;:z-

;,Aa I. vbl inquit ; £, idtfl /,berHm lI"i'bitr#m'l eTlll- eUIJI • Ceu non inttgr;l POrta pecC"lIrc IQ ptimo m-

rlQ~i'1ftI1l1I1JtJfl4mi mationu fl1llft mullfli lid bll, J1:ilnti tn-ationis, lIan fimplidrtt quando phy"ci

I1H11J f!1~UriJ~ • 1111r. aflltm "d TlIIf[rmqtu.nrdl1.fi tlf- w:atU( in elfe ,Icd quando mar~lit~r ,ie:! e fr,quando

- 111m nlftuYjI Jir ;11IIgr<l. Ergo i coPt'~tio Ii rl2,ura 'Ie-nit ad "fJjnHiltionis,& anri prz,cffit in clle. fioO

non fir inu:gr~. fi;;m in nobiS, non [[,pugnat quod CUI modo homincl. in quibu5, yt tlatim dictmllJ~

in primo infiami ~notl~J~u! ~d ptc,atam. Er Gc ptob.ihilil~ eLi FO~ in illp primo inlbntl v("i

(:uio ilb Qllz lDtLlm fund:mltomm ponlt in hoc ,:nicmi~ pcC"'~r~.Q.I!od locum lion baba in Ange-~

quod non poteQ pe,~(e Angdu~ f:ltionc plimi lis,in qu!hus n~tur;l non potell dre viti:;ui in ptimo

intl:anti$, IX quia pti m;t opeutl 0 dt,1lO1l rencr;fcd jnftami Cdor creationi~ phy 6,z, 'luod I:(ia I'll eft in-

jn!t:ltUr ill prinla opcu.ti olle natU!Z non intl:- fraJlJ II fll~ r;niQnis corum. qllia vitium yel elt

£12. originale ~ vd aaualc:-: originaJe in Angdis effi:"

Vnde c-on6r.argummtum qtlia bOM!nCS qu:m- non ('orcft • tUm non rropagc:ntllf, &. 'Dnfille~n-

da pc:rue.uiaIlE lid vfum I:uiQnis, in ille primo in- rut fub :iliqlll) ClIpite peccarore a qUI;t defccndwr.

l'bnci po(fum non cOllumi ad DCllm, & pc;(care. {cd a folD Oeo fimt itnmc:diouf. AChlaic vl:i"o.f1

vt concedi[ S. Tbomas , & cOIDmllnittt cillS difd- damE in- primo intbmi , non Cl1pponir natur~m Yi~ .

puli 1.Z.''1ltilfft.89Ii1Tt.6. ponc:nrc! q~ad in iUOJin. tiaram.fed c:iuJilltf'griuu;:m ddhui~,& prim6tlln~

Hanri quo ilKipir opc:ntio. potell dre p~tt:lllJm pC(aE,& hoc: didr U:r.in,poJlibile.Q!!aren~turi

ongilU!e cum mon~Ii, ft:d non CUm nnia1hcrgo nOll etU: imtgram. fcd 'litiaum CoIdm eorningcrt;

(entit quod in primo ip{bnti pel;cue pordi:ergo potdl in nobls,in. quibu, 'iui~ .VfU5 mlonil no eft

u eo pca:£ise quOd parnum inet ~ns, & priU!.:!. ope- opmrio~'luz nalolur .cum a~quJII~do cr~rut.

ratio Angdi eli,(JolI (olldill,hur quod non poU-it. fM IOllge tipurc patIca ;iducll1r,pon:!t lIJUttureaa..

pe(carc. Vf pate, in homim:. - rw:i diuuilll10cie d.ilpoJitamz ~ aduari,vunoilCio

. lUI,,'; S.TIJlin. '11 1. PIjU .D. Th. T (linUS :.h,,! . KKk. (0

I 4~Q ... §b!.41•L1X. E5c. De mcrito, e5pect;Alo Ante/orum.

re ec polJit in iIIo primo inibnd el prZQ(cepris ii"?tiil rqp~aturali.bu$ ir;tcipiu~ }!eg~rin~ ...

c:"gllitionibu; impcdc:tt_ii diCp0n.e~lltibUs _ ad lUlls ,!b.e:Ct]~u: grana Det.vI .d~fimtColJ(ll.. TncL

,.fum miolJis , vi mOX dlcemus.Katio erge D. ft!f.G'~'f.Etllt hocgmereInc"'pn~C:U»IIU;nlCr~.6C

Thom:z quam ponic in hat ill'fi~H{fI f. {"l~mro- app~icue p.~~ e~ercir~iione~·mc:"n'IJ;. ac 1I1j.mf;-

,~dit de operariol\t:; qua: umul ell' cum Ipla m- !tatlonem IU~. I,uxra !llud I(.1,:6f. & ROJII'!n. 10.

c~ptjone effecd.ijnamt<taucc~ ':I1_l~ opeumf ~um J Nllen,"'. ftim. d l1Ql1 qti~~flliJJus me , '_"l~ iI;;~

. rimoelfcrcl; non'!upponitar Imlata, fed rnre- farM hld,qUJ I11t"Ol1m,"r~!.cb"nt.Sl~rUln

_P ra • & difficultas eft an vitir;"l! per· prilnum Il- aliquibus qu~ foltlliro • &: colfu a(cidunt • {~A

~Ilt ~aum peccando, D. Tholnas autern affirmat illopina~o nobis cllc,nillQt • cdamft alib cog!t~

qllod Ill-=! !latura mererur, & 1101"1 pec.::at in plimo raLlS .~e re aJiqua , ramen ~IJa inopinata mani ...

jnlbnli; quz cum ipf;! in,a:prione t:{fcndj ope,J.~ fe/htlo ell !i. au(a (uPQlorn;} Del). UCll~ c11m

tllr;~tque'adeo fi ell imegra;1i vero fueritfiun in- didmr LMachab.'t. ~c [Il~. 1# ct1f.it!lilil ~ of,"

tcgr~,lcd viti:u~.vt 'Ojj!i~git in n?bis,nihil, ibi de- t;t,; h~tO(Aujl(lr~'~ 1H~J r(ljllii_~ltlm "~r IIfUliI;II

tdllllnar. (ca dlfputatiolU pennlmttde quo lam di- II /a&eTe/: &' matJII Jiu "1J1im fl1l1jitiflrtl' • &c.

«mus. Vbi ilia incidenti:! t:onhlij non mit in vi co~

:1 Ad confirm. Rerpon.quOdreColucorie loquen- t:1tionl, priorls , fed Iliquid non przmeditllnlni

1 d~ lfidauc mihi em:, CaiCfWO . (.~~iJUltft, 8~. ,,,,. r~nc primo ~ccer!f; V d. il)ccrprio ali'uill~neg~~

(i'.I/fc4Icuamn:t':I1MTIf ,quOd pctUcnlcns :ad vil1iD til non eft !imphc!tIl1" noua. led pa\lbwn- diG.

rationb potel! ex mai..J. confu.::rudine ante actus ponitur ex :dlqutbus przmc:ditati5 ~ am ex aliis

difcretionis moucri magis sd dclctb.bilia mala, nodriis pt~~ed ... mib 115 -. Vi: ih.al.iqliid lignum mOo

qu~m ad btJUllm hl;lnell:!.IID quod libi runc ptO- dd erumpar, Q93.IHlo lit bOt": {ccunda modo.cb&

I'l;Illlmr j I!J! pr3:~c~tim qllia Wud bonUlli hon~- ~Li~ eft quod ipfe ,huma PQttft [!Hies dc. n~1I1iJ

Ibm valdc dcbll!(cr; &; confuse rune propom- mClpl:rc_. Bot, dC:lcnnmuc fc J qt:loue.saie: rei1lun-

lilt , delcchbilia vcro fcnfus V;llde d6c.acitcr. cipit cogitare • trl3mfi inu:trumpat .p &: dOfe

lit iJd, • 'Ie ,hi bene nQt:if Cli=f. non p.'ItiJl tcfeu miat J '11113. opllfatllr in -vimltc pr~cedenihnll

quud dfue{C::1E puer ad. :mdietlda (plrirualia • & ho- netiliarilln. At yarD p~jJ1'lO modO fempcf illt.

n~Il:a. . , prima cxcimio incipl, a. (;;11.1.[;1 ru~iori, 6 {ida

R~rio vc:ro huiu,. & Gmlll difp.uips in~ec bonum per cxcitarionelU Dei intus Qperaatis ift

AlIgduDl .in prime inllanti creiltiol~is, &: puere intdkd:~. & veluntase , & c1ttiDfecll$ pODrom~

in primo in!b.nti. vfu} mionis cit, quia Ange- vel per (c t vel criam minillerio Angelorum. quia

Ius ,lIon b,l~et aliam opcmlo,u:m qt!llD intel- eX p.:1ytt: propofiliorus ~bje~li vt~luf De~1 mi·

Idbu~m • eamquc pr;tr;:~blll jill:' h.ibvr p~ul.- mllcno I\ngdOfUm. etlam in ordme gratl~ • 81

tim difpulti ab imp.:tfcao 3d pcrf!:Q:lIln v£ ve- fidei, ql1ia pet ~Ol iIIuminat homines • vc s.

niafu\ ~(tl~.r.1riOnis.~Jlhrllll3. ptin,ipio p~r~ Thom3~ decee illjfA.'1fUp;mllll:,KttK.r •.. ll~

£caum I!hht:IUln , & IL1tclhg~nfl3.m habce. V n- Jicur enam ~. utCnorcm cfedibJlium propoG..

dc Jet ip(lIm prilulllU :'IC1:I!llJ..nihil ~.:tu.uit3.lis r!lp. tionem vrirtlr minill:edo przdkatorpm ~.& m ...

prllli£ J ~1\1" ptilIlt'un (c e:z:citet • /!( (t: ItJOUc;tt in- lIillrOfultt. Si ycro fit imiuno in malum iineipit

rr~ (r:. fc:d. dd;lCf .Ib extenorl pril1l:ipio id proue- per fuggdlionl'm rpirillU mali .. ~ui rameD .in..

Dire. (cili.:et 1 Deo , qui [olin pateR: applkare (U$ intra intdleitum • ~ ... oIutJt,attm non opc<-

mc[![CID I &: formate iIlud dictamen.At veroho- (i!Wt. nee format ipl(lm diUamen. fed propoll.

rna ex C.:nfiblIS ,u:(;lpit. & di(PQnitur ad clcitan- Vt homo. fibi form~t. Er: pOleJl: homo tunc: fat ..

ehlll\ (e pt..::cognirione intclicCliuol. &:. in bae pan- marc: ~ Be re mouere. quia intelleth!s clUJ nail

Isdrn protedit. it~ vr pdmo inrdliglt (:onfu$~. ell in pur~ potentia ~ nce optr.uur ~un, primuDl

.& non cum d;(cra;olle. Be {uHicic:nti dUhminc ad:llm GmpliC:ircr. fed eX aliquibu~ aClihuJ prz~

ad libete Ce mouendum , (td talllen GltCl'll impc:r... cedentibus) qui virtute- mancnt til homine t efl:

(.:Qe inteUtS-it • &: fc dirponit ott Ctel':C:IlI:C: maio- in aCl:u Vt fe moue~t ad formandum. ditbmell

rcdaritue t &: ~pettiol1e (~nrllunl tandem pro- de 'his qu~ fibi (uggerunlllr'l Q..!!od non potrel

tull'lpat iii aatun hbetum, & ddiber:u:unI fe facer.: in primo ~d;n , quandO eft primul lim-

D1Qucndo. Et qUia ~rns mOUl:r c:rcmur.1S inlcllc=- pliciter, quia non fupponit aliquid prius. nequc

ttu,1ks iUli:b ~rum madum. & e:z:igeJlu:un • inde adu. ncquc virrme J' in vi c:uiu5 mouGat Ce. Et iil

fit quod peo primo ~au,qui ell prirnu$ 6rnplicirer,' huius fignnm COlin., quad Diabalu5 quando tCi1~ ipCc (olus mOU~t. quill non ell: alilld agens 1 quo t:lt • & (uggeri£ • (emper reprl.1:"Ccla"at aliqua ilJlra j~etuI int~lleCtw •. Iff fermet fibi diltamen • red- ca qUal aHquando {en limns. vel cspnri lumu,. tunGillr; attus in nobis ell v~lde impcrfetlus • & liCt~ ab ipili viuacjns elprimantur. de his yc:ro

paudwn ad libcn:atC'1n (ufllden.s. ~ndo vera quorum notitWn lIunquam IubllimllSovix POldi:

{o·t!1'lar didimcn fccundum v[nm rntlonis. & di[- 'ugg~rcre , '" [cnrare,licut czco.aarum non poret

"ctionis • tllac iam lubc£, &: pr~fllppopit in t"C: femat"r; de:: coloribllS.Et hO(; iueo quia folulD pro-

dirpolidopt:S ;m.te v(um talionis acquilitas; &: rno- paRil obic:Cb. Vt n05 formernu5 di4amr;o • quad.

tioOI;5 in (e f.lCbs 'SUilnu aauams ptnc:1I: in libe::~ tamell farmuc: oon PORUPlUS , Dee ad illud noi

mm dielamm pmrumpc:rc:. Et qUia iUll; motio- appli~e. nHi in vi alicuiuut'tuspnat eriti. DeuS

ll~ PO(fUllt elfe malz, pote~ iuxt~ iIIa5 forman autt:m potdl etiam de his qU:E nunquam nouim~

~lUl..tm;:n • n~e Dc:us , lenemr ililia auctCere. quia in fundete nobis {pe-c.it:tn • &. IUtoen.1k erota.

J:up ~on rol.ul opnaturiIJudt fed iUlI;t2. cauf. C(ca- tioDem ;,quamu15 etiam aliqU:1ndo fit: proponat

. ,~ d!(polit,onern.. . Vt rdinquu nos (ormare di!tll~en. Semper tao-

~8 PICt'S: Clgo aiam in cuiu(que negotiNncm- men in'U5 op~rafutillu", in1ell.c&uQl. &: velun~

pli"?~no.njncipit D~ n:ou.;rc.(tdpDUumus ~x rare?,. rclp~au bonorllm;C)UQa.d c:ntiratem.&

nobu ItU:lP£W aetetnlln.m. Erli It:.. ell: • ad qUId bonuatc:m. 'I;fpc:8.u malonim'. quoad emir.lteul

famanxic ~pimU!frzdetumiD3noncm Dei·rro rOlonim,non qu~d ltlalltlam,F.t rC:lpechl huius ~

omnIbus ~Ibus 1. .' . titatiui inHuxl.ls poninttilt~,pr.JIdl!t~n:ilrio:(em.

; R.dp,_qIlM incQ':pno alitlli,!," negonj vel eft naga per enam ocnnis caufa phy Gee: {ubC!tdinahlr< intlll.~,

m~D ~pJj(:ner ~.y, quando .:tliqdiJ ioclpir dt :l:ui Dci in qu«iiqllt o'Itlu; kd !1DD . kIPper ncittJ

IIO~ C:(I~c: 4e ~ ~llui\l1lS ame: nibil·fa.c:bar. tiollc,&' fOfiID.lione djllaminis ipf. folUS-(jpl;fll~

~. . ~CCUftdQ

,/

.': " "' DifJIlItifliit.N:*IN.' ':.CArtic.:"J/; ~1,\\<." "451

2.9 "5'eCiiIi4~-argfjinif: 'Arijel~;fif~pt!rilO Inlfan'h't dubio cetu: elL -& 'l~D -. l'hoh·U, tl~ruillhut q. ui; oper:tcriiliberil;liqaidii:nl rorell mC'rtfl j Be ilia; PO';;; dtmA/6 Art;,:. " e , pr:t'f6rim _folllt. ad s· & 7'& lit.

ufnda liberi'ell:' de(e:Q;ibilii 'ab imtlnfe,o,.& eune Iraque, AhgeluJ.p'fc;'UJO inlland llonpotcll: mQ~

!lOn ell:: impedl!a neqllil pltyfic~, neque In~raliref: lH!d Jlbf'HatCH:onmlriclalis pelJes velle hoc eb-

e_rgopoteftpecCJre.·Al1rc(ed.Je1ibmare meriti.D. ica:urn ( (cil; ,bomlm'f & oppblhurn eius, {cilice.t .

TIiQmas,& nos fatemuf:dc·{jefettibilirm: tlUtinw malum j qUis rriJ1'j~optlritioni, inquRntl.uD pri .•.

feca,& phylica etizmconlbt • qu~ eadem enfitas, ina j jncompolflbilis eft ddidenria drc%'bonum

& pordl!:ill. ·phyfica, volunratiil eit III primolnlbiJri; ex d.cft'1 It monent}, ad ilIud t feu formant!$ di ..

& in;feqLl~iiti,eadem etiam radix'pcccarit&: dC!ft~ thmCil d~fl:auo(tlm;; .potdl-·r:ullcn mouerili ..

t'tibilicatis; Cell,quod fir'::1 nihilo. Ex parce etiam bertate comcadidionl:J pcne~ velle , aUt .non vel.

mot2li, m~rionis non en Impcdjr~ tunc ad peccan- le,cx:efcere. vel nOrrUeicerc ipfun'l ac2llm. Ne£

dUI1I ,<1u1a EUn~ proponitur obietlum cum indff... oblbc quOd pro- ilia intbnti poffi~ (tbi a'qtl~Jj..

fcreniiai&'cum cogriltione hlllil5~& oppoJid:ers~ te! prQPoni bon'Dml1Hquod , &: malu~ tub fa.

non ell impcdfra nlOialitet ad pe~ClIndum;qui:l jm:~ . zionc b9ni t potelt'1l1e .liolum:!s pto (na : JiberIllE!!

ptdimiamiin fi'il:irenu; ell"ct b;brtlado inciiifc(ellw eI.igel'c minus bonum; vel. teqll~le, 'elmO' dtml~

~iz ~ pm~"obielH ptop"bl1th .;Um enim morali~ clift.lnu, enim , qllM lic~t demm .hee quod in

morio ten!::u (e 1:1 parce obie£li·. tune impedilltt po,elbrc volun(uis tll·ex dlloPII$ .qoalibll~ aut

moulih:r Itoluntas. quando eX'p . .ure obicai non stqu.litct propcJiriS-'eligere: zqualC'; vel Cllam mi ..

cum indilf~remia muuCt, &: rune manet expc-dira nus bonum imm~di~tc. ~ pCI' fe, lion impcDll'>

cuni ex. p3~tC il\djff~fmti;t obictl:llm nloile,;ergo do ;tliud dic'taltlen.ued. ad"uc ,amen non te:quto.

fi runc'nic;u~baw~ (Um indjffet~fi~~ non erae im- CUr 9uod poffi~ < el;gere minu; bonum. f{ela:qua-

pediraJibena~ ad p~ec~ndum. ~'. ~ . [e fine defcltil j quiahocipfum 'lutrddl pfOrO~

,0 < Sed dic~:cJfdibet-;1m 'IOI.lInfiliSin runc, & lion poni maioit'! Ifqualiter, vel mdillri mcde qtlilm

im~djl~m quoadlibmartm contradiltionh ~ & id quod cllin ft bcnurn ~u' non deEine:Ic. vc:lim-

uercifij,fdl ad v~lIe.& n~J'l velle,b!ne [ameD qdo.- pcdire \,oluDf2wP ne minm ben" ptopOhtUm eli-

ad libeu:iftin fpecifjcari()ni'~ & (!onnarietatis.quia· gar.m;lgnll!defe~u5 in ipfo dielamine,& pro'po~

in hoc cIt rune ncceffirat<l vohmr:u:ha-c colm libcr- lilianc ell:. :

f.1f non i:1l falum :dllc:II~.& non vell~,{etl ad ipsn .Ad rrim~rn fnllantit,?'d: ~mimo~e, R:~(pon: p

exe(citilln'i ;t!t'us.ttd ad ohitd::l ipfa,(cil, :id bonu, quod "olum.:l5_hab~t pnntlprum Qmlu~rtd. ex VI

vel ad nialum,rcfp::tlu :Jute mali.Ulne Car« lim- hbl!Uatls ;&q~antllmcll ex vi. & maitis obielti

me.CQr!!ta dt t.quia ti'fllncc:1l velunras hbers ad omHliol)c phyfia .qllz non ell' aliud<Jtl2m m:ga.~

vclle,Sc hUb velle.Ied no veUe e~ omiu('re:ergo ell: do' "au;. $& . fj"p=nfiQ (Jp~randrtp£f aCddens all§

libcr;i ad' 'ommcrc ':'l:1'go Ii pro ilia inJblltipona~ [('m,& tadone- pdmi inJlauii"in qo::iUlln jJleaa~

rur fib! pt:z~eprum(yule faao habucrunr)~r con- ell. primus • &.- primoloperandiotcaJio ,11011 pencil

ucrt~nrurin Oem». 6:' fufpenderenr aauln 1 & omiucrcmonIJfl:r, & c:ulp:.bilira ~oJJliffio cnrm

DOr! vi:Ut'IIr,·omin.:rmrprzeepEum; crgo pccc~ rporaJi~~d.Jir (lIpr4 phylid,quacilir.YoJunraria,vel

rtnt : ~igo hoc ipro qaOd·habenc Jibcrmein i14m vol ira. ·En·, ii, vplita • r-:qu1dt atlnln', cuilJ!!

conU'adittioni5,poifunf hllbtre &, conrr3Iieroari!l.lta obictl-lI111 fit tali,.·'omiffio ~ mbil cnim eft voli,nm

(<<undo, quill Angdum habere in iUo inllanri co· vc obi=Clum. niG-refpettu IIncuius atlu$ volido-

girationemillam ~nam el6colc:lCef mouenrem eli nis. Et lie fi datur in illo primo inrianti QIUiC.

gratia. Oti,m)n minus quam conrinuatio d us in fe- Go volita. darur volirio illilu. V n4c:: lam nOD dl-

cundoinibmi'ltpe-rteuefet:quomoaoc:niminrd- pun omiffio, (eod 3C1:U~ malllS yolens omillio-

ligi pOt~lI:, quOd jdem aui.ium primo collarum in. nc.11 malam .t'adhnqut: ell i'lIrio. illitJs ," eujuf-

hoc inl\-;Inti non lit gratia Dei. & in (ecundo. in.' climqdt: al{cril1~peccari cllrnmiJIioriis. c Vc iUtml

{hlOti id::mmer eontin'uamm61 gratia ~Et dc:inac;. QmilIio fit vaitlllmia .ifce, liOn 11tvol,,;I, requi-

,ui<l iIlud auxilium Ii: non rtllt gt;ilia. nee bencli- (itur quOd ilia "litumo emaner- a '1oiuora[e • fell

ciam Dei: ergo Angelus< finC' gr;lria mt't~b~furin volunras fir caula illius.EIi ain~ .(.:Iuf.-,.'1cl eJ:~

primo inlbnd. & con(~qUtntCl n vir:bus liberi prdla.. &: -dltetb·'1okndoiILUn·.d~quoi:lJn di-. _

arbilrii .quolldl h'z'rcd cum: ergQ qu lid iIli damur ximus. 'lei ilfdircchvolt;ndo -~li;n4 ,eJ: '1uo (e-~' '.

~u:lilillm ;1d. noripc«.lOduIU • fl:d ad opCt'anilum quimr omHlio. vel ;Ulrcce-drpti: 1Jiqlll':1' ado. vd

bene, non cnt dl:bitum hire CTcal.ioPi5,fed ex gra- c()n.;ornit~nti. Ih cum lUJi'c,e;deufernon duuc

till. Dei de:Cct'ndrns, licur & in DI':ihi1 t quOd 6 non alius achn .liqlJidc:m in iIlo:primQ: iDlb.nti t iUe

etoti dcbit3,pOi'er~f ncgui.& cOllicqllCIf:'t AlJgdlls dt Plimlll. relta. ~llod (olti~ poffit CODcomlranpeecan:,Tcttio.quia (ecltnduIP illrrinfec; candem ter lib omillio- eat' voiunraria .:quau:nuJ in il10

'potelhtem phylicam ~ &- morak-m ad pcccarulum prilJlQ illil~n,i voiUllt;l$ .;onumiHlfad,aUquod'

lubuir Angdllf in primo, &.in k~lli!do inllanfi Yt obied:ulD pet CJuodirnpl:ditlu. feu .. ddillit itnpll!'~

· ditlnm e-Ilmcc colm in fecundo inlbnd aliquid !Iii IC przceprl1lJ1 ,&. omiuit illVd ':& tll!s dll1f

2duenit inmn[e-d- , qnod :i{Jtta IlQn ba.bcrcr: ago cum ta.li circllmlbntia ol]liffiolm. pecta'tum ,eft.

limpticirer.& clnin(eci, principiis loquedo, potlli[ clIigltqUC didamt'n dcfcduofuUl. & iriconfid=---

· Angelus pC!ccare_in primo inftanti,quod Ii nOD po- I2tiol'lCtlf. Ii~m ,<{p:t'cllmque.:ilia pccca,a. Vnde

tuir.(o!um fllit a manutmen[u Dci a.trinten. pro flKll'3!i omillion~ fumtcpt~cepto pro < iIlO' DtniC(ue bomo in 'primo jnft:m~i patdi nafci primo ihllmti. t'go' non video .dHfelrnriam inm: cum mbinuli pec:c3f()j (cil.oliginali • qU(ld Jin,pli~ . omilIionctn mor.dem ,ulpabiIem .• vd t'ommilJi~

(iter ei ell voltlnuriunl :. ergo &: AlIgdm cum nem. .', .

· atluaJi,quod d ell'liberurn • &. {tcllr ex primo ha~ It q~ndo dianu ~u~ G (IlO:iI~,~lUnri vohu:tw 1 f

bituali nihil rcfunditur in DCDm. ita ~tquc a w elllibcta adomluendumoumJi~DJ:, phyfsu ~

(flo a&ultli, 'pra:fmim i quiabomo in pril1JQ in- &. (ecundilln .lihcrtatem.· comt:r.dftlioniJ ~ ~ po-

e ibtui 'lHiHaEioni'''pecc;lte patell a&alirer f er- 6ro pt'Zccpto, ilb Om illio erir p«,ar~m.&- fie po--

'go & Angelos in ptimo infianri fui veIlS r:ltionif. ~etiE pea:.uc Dminmdo.Kefp •. ,.am.n hie aFP~IJa~ .-& liber.J: op41-tionis "1ua: ~II: p£imum inftaru: <fttIt- rion~m a- pane i!lPu rhmioi' ~D' >j. it> quo

:plicltet.· .. ' frcqumfcr 61111t p?ralogi!n:aj . in hac materia - de

3 I ' Rc(~. "(uUQne data inrer ;;rgl.1mdQm qllz tine libim.tc 1 fD8i::liIb \'Da·(:IIl'OIlIti;.aal Foik Jub

, luiI,,,S.ThlHlI.;fl.I-F41f • .D.7b.Tomuu!t"t· KKk :l' iii',

"H i §..!!.,Jlio Ll'X.f!c. De .mtrito;f5-ptcc.tD:A1Jgelotum~

alia, ~ poG'e in rcnfu dfplfo. ad poffc:· in (onfll CII1lillio, Y't dC!~dtuora ~.~. c"I;uurarii[!. PtZ~9.quZ

compoulo.&: {exc:ctlu alia.Ellt>: p'I1/fo ~ £< Iy ,oWI- (ec~nd"!ll Ce nnpollibdll !lO~ cit , ~~i1Ii. ryl!l~-

,iA ttrminU5 imporWl. 5 ~pp~U~O.ilem elga .0. b- ratl ex ,parle: natU~1E ert;:'UiI:, ted raflO~~\ pe[CQ~~,

it&um.fuUi1l Be ordc ~ obie&um Cemper dc:be. .lieut euarn BcatQ, ratione: !luUI, etll~fot1ibIII.1

furoi formalit~ ;, 8.: ve ft~t (ub farina-ii ratione tCil- ~aio J "el omillio defctlibilis. & Don ex i'r.opriis~

dClidi ad Qbic:d:um, & umiliru ~iquid attentis &: ilminle.;isprinJ:ipiis yoiunratiJ:. ~ lt~turJ:.Ad

oDlnibu, non poretl:, '1Llod . cui alicurus rationil Jibena[~m ~ute~ f Llffidt ~uod ;diq~I~;D\)~ qtitu.

fotm~~s pr:rc:ise Cumput JlDn tepugnat , Y'c1 ctrll.M poffibilt: anrecedenECt , & mkni"uiliuifo;ltaqqOd

~ conu~rfo.Q_U;I: omnia pcz ocuhs valde haben- c~ propriis j k i.mrinCecis prindP~i' nOn eoa(ch:t

da(unt J alias contingct fadla paralogizare. ~jd. vohmt,ucmj & inqllalitunt peninere potdlad i"

mils ergO' quod in primo inlbnti pou:1I:: facere.LIe quod perfctlionif in yolunt~e cij: ,lieet in (m(u

lion. faCere Angelus, velle , veiomittere. ci)llfi.., ,(lmp,auro, ~ potenda confti-<lenti, 8c:.in ~

dctandoJy l1f1n/Il(;,r, > & I'lomitme. Vt Cun[e:nre~ film reduatur ad ali9uid. acft-!t;;bik: n.odpolJit

II',UIl1 tontr<ldiCl:ionis, &exctddj Iiberi. non vt Veti, quia bocimperfetlwnis ell,&: Don requitU:~

runt e~t£~nnltU eOllrtari~acis, &" eulpabilis ac VOw ad IjbmatclD • qnod (u~ omoi ratione. & appel.b-

lulitarl~ omiOionis,quz nigitallum t:oru:omitan.- lion~ aliquid poilir,ficQt}ll:c ad In.tc~aulD quOd.

tem,yel Qilfecede.nc,& Jmecc4ros darinon pordt, tub· omni modo.eli.un impr:rfcCl:o. iD.EdliVt• _,

cUm lid lit primuli:Ji aute' conComUaru dan:tur, ii AdCeCll n.d..:.m inlbiruiam, B.efp.qu&l in au~HiQ J r

non Ja~etur PUla omiffio,fed etism commHI'to. Li~ D ei,quod datu( ;iQ opcrandllm in primo billantit

b~rt;lS c.rgu ptO ilJo Wt:antifohhn eft: libcu:iScon- t:il dilhngucndum de I2l12;ilio Ulo. 'It lhpernatural;;

nadia-ionis 3d diut'tCoS ;'Iall' eiuldc:ro (petid nen ordinis c:it , &. datu, c:um "a1ote in"itQUO- "it~

C:OIIuuimtil, & i(;! £lcit hune atlrun quod non ~tcrn3: ; & Ii,: "I:II:: QIJUlinD grmliiuiU ~ miG, de-

COgitUf f.lcc~cillul\'I,·~ed pO,(dhll~ ~.u:c,cdntu hirum Afigclo ilitc ~catiC)?h ,inu ~li'l uo alio .ri~

c;nd~ fpee.em, IX Irol faat bane fpe-clem atlUSt tulo, quam ell: In .ra hperlhtite DC!.; p oKet emal

quOd noncogitUl' factrtillam.fcd potell n5 facw: dencgare Angelo qUidquid .{upcrnatunUtatis

quallium dhui obh:!l'i, &;'c:x mc:ritis imus. vi ell. Aliud POlcf1 coniidcrari in iIIe- au.ilio, (C:!l

bonum dl,& apPl:tibik;& tameD rub alia r:ltion.: c:oncdrfu. Ccilic:er., quOd nOD babe-at adiunthaa.

l:onGderatum iIlud obied:unl , {e:ilicet Vt de6ciens permiffionem peC:l:ati t etiamn in gen!:r; fupCl:na-

~ rcgu1is rationl5 lion pote!\: ab ili:a ... oll1nratc: bi, tIlfah non ",. Et hoc dt: debitum imc: aunonis.

&. nunc elfc ~ ollrum per ;1I:cidt:ns, &.ex ;ilia rario- nee eft gada fp«Wis , (c:d folulD gentralis. ncu,

ne, (,nice!: quia de:elt princlpium dl;£.:auos~ mo- conc~lu$ cum qlUcumqlic alia re IUSU (kbifUlD

UtilI, & dit'gCDS. Nec enlm ru:ceJfc ell:: qLlOd Vo- COile n~t"t;I: peo loco, &: tempore. Ef lic!t non 6t

JLlnr~' vdibt::ta lir,poait omiuere iIlum aaum,vd dtbirum Angelo :l.bfoliltcl •. el1: tam!:n debitum ipG

obic:tlum Cub amni ratj()n~~ modo;(u8icit quod Deo tllne:: mOl1tAti • &. C:Ii: Cuppotidone quOd Deus

in quantum (:onducir;ld Iiben;ltis indHfcttOliam. aeat A1lgdl11tt perfetlum ~ id ell: cum J?~atio~

feu lid non coat!liom:m porcnti= • poJJU i11l1d non De fila in prim!;! jnlbnti teneeur DC:1lI ipfu iure

v~llt,i d tfr~ ~QD e:ogauu ;J.~ilb a: ~r:ririf obi~ai; cfeation" iULlm. moueee, &" app liare "d agen-

& vppptubilc cil::fietn eDam Chrilbts DOlUliIUS dum, nee cft allud lUollCIl$ def'etlull(lIm a quo

ratlone pert(,n.-w:, & Butus raUoiU: flatus, & Deus &:tenninctur ilU ~rura I &: im:ra CUlm ditpg.;.

.ipfe ration.e fummz pCEfc;t};ionit non pol1Un~ vf:l!e firiolletn Deus (e acconlJllOdmdo ptrminat de-

c)(niDi(ln~m • ti::u iUud non &cere qll:1renus cL:fc~ £e:Cl:um , ideo non r:ll rccunmdum ad tpeclalclD

lluofum ell:: .Iie:ct Iibcrz yoll1nr:ws Gm.quia Don grariam pro illo inlbnti, fed ad ipCam exigemiaJQ,

ptn:inet :ul pe:tfedionnn libcmtis poJle y dlc , & cfnrionis lie £,1&c. &. "~ Incdkaiialis .ru:

lion velle, ~~an1 d~fcauos~. {cd polft ... dlll, '" morz t Vt pro iUa inlbnn nOiJ adiungatut e4 ~

non 'tclL:. DOn coatliue. & quoad <:wcltium. adiungi potJk Fmillio defctlus eE fuppolirione

quidquid fiUD ad yolendum d~ fr=fi:uosc necem. quOd 0pc:r,atlU" .Et :ad ipfuQl pr:cepwm {u~cma;.

WJlUr,quoad fpccUiatinn~m. ultalc duril:atis impltDdum indiget pna 'Peen-

3+ . QJ!:u:e cilin dkililr q~~d potd} Don. flcere, Ii t ~ (upt:m3tu.uli • DIJIl quia eUiuE_io P"Cad ell

etwn ftlUitC ~ccptD, diCt.nguo ,potcnna ;tore- prlEClse • fed qUia ;laus (lIpCmatUt2~ ell: lempQ'

ccdentl.reu in (eo(u diuifo • c:onc:edo j rotdl po- coim ~"od Cupcrnaturalc ~R:. gmia indigc:t fpeo-

Wlria cOnUquenri • & in ~(u eompoluo ~ nc:go. ciali fimplidttt • qui~ non rCocwr O(:UJ in oIdio.

diQntt peltnn:. UltCC,eilells. quz c:onfidcutUE le- nc rLlp~tnal\lf~1i d3re gt'.1liam • ac concw(tUD. m..

QlndWil (e .ante athtm • & Inte ~)ilmia (r:qllilita (OIIlU:, &. 6mplicit~r. Non Umt:n repugnlt quOd

ad :I~1Itn ; &. lie refpiclr obiedllm (ecundum (rr: ell (uppolitionc aliqll:l Deus babeat demu1m d~n-

przas! • &: hoc; c:lHn (cuen drui(o > fciliccr dilliA di gudam fuptma(ur~lt:m • quod ell. debirum (c-

dc:nd? ~ e:oneruo~ corum qU% c:oncutt\lIU , & e:unclum quid. nOil quidem ell: (0101 fuppo6rione

I'CIlllmuuur ad o~um hie: ~ at nUDC. eSc; fo~ quOd dat notitiam Angdo ~cep[i fupemaru.

l~r:~~ojdquod~flin obicao~ me- ratis;b:.:cc:.nim D.odtiacommunisdl ~rQprimo.

Plt$ ob.IKli. DIQtUt pOtenta coofC:'luens. ilbqtu: &: fecundo mlbnn. Sed ex :Ilia {uppofinon~nem~

. eft ~olund:a cum :Ian. {Ie rd"pidt adioDcm 'It pe qnia «cat Angeillm eltuatum ad ftatum (II.

, hci~ ~ ~ lc DUnc , & obietlum mPl' omni- pcrnatunlem cum. pr:z~pto illo) & ill inlbnd

bu. requlfim '" CODCWlf;ntibu5 adagendom. Yel ita t;oarcblo. quod non pOtcR: lab alio qu1m il

. lIonagendlllQ.Et tic Donrequiriluud li~atcin Dco di!tamcn (u(c:iperc • aCUt es fuppofitiollC

,uad poSit DO~ openri. :l.IU paaic circa, i.11~ ob- quOd Cbr!11:o impo~t, pr£ceptll.~ dile:flioni$ W-

lea~ t Ji irupamnn obietlum rub altqul fnc- pernaturab. , I:CIlefur Illt!btt: all.ihum fupetruanl-

~t & ,ef~ ip6 il1compoffibilJ. Et tit: uk,qub. perf on::!' impect.lbilis ell.

ilb ~aiOtt~lpabilih& iUud nOD &cere. !It Adtmiam init:mriam didtur qUod,nelia, S. 3'

,dtfeCbbik. &. 'ft coDU3tium ntiofti jo mLUllr im~ Thom.iuJI.16.J, _It Pl.,.. 1Id~. ~glhMpollibileilli ~eJorcr lIt;Cidcns.iIl elt. PfOpri- p~t"rrit ",'41'1 jn ~ i7JP(!l7Jlit ".. f";'.l1l1/-

c rna ~u ~ ~. ~~Um fe., .& QOn fubap- F'pilT tUftiIttrn .1l"M;. poJtmitl. ~ qfii p,j/tMIIImI

• pcllatioue ~alhilis rmpodibUe D(lD cLl. fl., f1lcrit f"pplmu • 7J(fMl F"P'" FIT{fSiMJ,. ~

Cbrillo ~. fCd'onz ,GddiUK impotWnIis . f'iI~ fltn" /,., ... -."" ~tfoJ.

,.. .P.OpIU

· DiA.'P· fltllliQ~ X r /11. ., Art. I J.

sr 411

"8,,1;- ".J;",m 4-. Q!!ac didmQS qu8d tOtUrn in Angelo. Ad id vero quOd dic.itur de pcrueli!cri-

'lllo!ietl irurinfcllum in potenrl2 pe"lndi. fuit in te ad "fum rarianis. q:UOdpOftlt pec;carc in primo

,dmo inlbnri.(c4 non omnc esItin{ccum_,quia de- ,jllfhnti aQualirer moralirer,iaM {HpJ ditlum ~n~ Juir dUlamcn d&a:ud(llm.~ lquo potfetforma- & c.r:pficatl diifc:rl::mia in,",hom1ncm • at MIC-

a. Et J1c lubuiryottridam ad pcccandum anreee- lum qumulln ad hoc"

dCDtti.~op ~nkqllmtcr:!l'ut c:ti:lm bc;ati '1wa ra~ , Tenia arguirur'. quia G 21iqu.a raria contlip~ J I

~ione llatus ,~enl' diaamme dcftltuoro.n~1l pof~ qlJod Angelus ,In primo inlla!lti noll poreft pc,e:l,~ {UJI!: pc:cc~J '11iaJDU1$ in Bearis hzc.in potCtlt~ fit re, maxim! ratio D. Thorn. quia alias dOl prima

magis ame'edml;& per (e, quia ~atw ille ell p~- operatlo atrribUlitutgt:ne:aoti;& genuis fit DCIH.

petUUIJ lic~t acejdEtaJis G, B~ato. in Angelo autem r~fundcrenjf pccatum jn Deum.At bite: ratio nOli

Eot",pecubiliru. " dcfc.:libilim incrinCc:sa quz problit! elgo. Minor ptdbatur ··timo q~lfa d:uo

elt 10 (i;',,:mdo inRmri eft in primo, & idl:o poten- 'i\lod pew ptltduet81inn pbylicf YOrunfliCetn ad

da ptcsandi cllin Ufo ~ {cd, non poiTepcel;':a,e no~ matecla!e p~ti.adbue non di,ilUf autbor pcc,a-

iroucnh'jn ,Uo e. defeauporeilii=t pbyC.cz. {eli ti;oee in il1unir~funaitut rilaliEia ,«lam I'i illi enrl-,

i" .tciden., lk ex Unpocenda di'bminis defe- cad In(cpatiibilit":t tit Adnexa malitia limo crlamG

~atwu. Q!!<i: impQ.=riJ.lil:~c moralif lit.ell tamC!n cogicilriQn"~ offer ... e~ qQiJ. vida fUlmum puca-

.mOta Ii; innin(CCIlJ& POD iohlm nrnn(eea.(ulliclt- cum, qUia hz, C()gifllfio liberate re!jnqui, V(i~UI1-

~Ue ad denommaaciwn Angthnn hmplisjctr Un- tatem, YC V~h nOn refnnditlif in'Dcum:ugo ~

lo(cntcm adpecFindwn, heut homo ~iam6 ha- lirer elhiluti Deus moueat. volUnratem Angeli in bC'at babi~! fdpC'tnatl1ra.ies, fi ,amen c;uet gr.:uia, primo inlhnti~non. ilIi atcEibtinur PlaJiri:loqu~ilgn ~a~c;Uy'potm; ell ad opcnndum ,qwa ~te, inauit vt c:lll(a deJic:iens,ne(:,Dew ampliu.J iDflw:c jillqao ~~plici,c:r reqiWito.ad potTe: ~& inttinth:! in primo inl\l1mi qua~ ad m,,"!a!e ,"~ati ~ Jwc.

u~u~elUe: C'z~anc In,ellca~"U.c~( ~ujae.1 pm.c enim. {olmn ellapalE mflu:c:us dU:lJn." eo vero po--

CblCt2'1 rn~cntJj {e tener excltano, diclltUr pem· fi(o,cum permHJionc, in£dlibifim (cquimr pc,"-

Jiet'e ad mor,alcm mOdOnCiUJYf c:ondi(linguitur ab IUm!"go Vt in primo inlbnd dtlur pcccatllm,(lIf..

,Qltf~uioll.:rhyfica. illln vO~IJ.nratl:~ opaaute. £c fidt'r q~odPelU pctmitt~t clUJ ,_ooi1ilUO cum!'f.i"

Jta nODfollc: monilIa duplielEer dl~ltdr. Vno me- dctcrm1l1~uone ad ma[I:I;IUem ellQ. enrifaiem, {e4

do, vtdifiinsaitllf contra Donpolfe bmplidfu. ex hoc '1nOd Dem in ilfo inB:llnEi penumat ttlaJi ..

",,110 modo VI diJlinguieur conui liOn pofkphyli- dam pecC::lri t & przd~tcrminct ad mnctialc. naa

,a. ~a,pcr fe, &nccdIluio requiratm ilia morali- ,refunditnr ali'ioa mali(ia in Dc:um~quia romlD boG

Uf. Primo ~odo mteJligitut quod poS"umusali~ habe~lIC in (e(:uJU!o intlanti j " famen in DCDJD

: g!lid GInpIic:itu. Iket dlfficultc:!: • & qwa diilicui- non rcfunditllf IDaltd3!UfO U ~ quOd DCUl fO"'

let t dii;imutnwtalitcr non poB"c. quia lDOallral nat in primo inlla(Jd qui~l1id requnitur IIi ~

iian dicit potdla{cm. (cd difficuJtatcm.' Ec in ho~ ~indl1m. & '1IiO polito inf~libiJI[ef {''{DetUr fCco> Jcn(u Pauu olim '(cfutabant Pel;lgitJlD • qUi dJ-cafum,non C~q1lifUr fiuod in ilium l'aundamrOJa-

.~K gcadam, dad ~ SlOD ve fimplidrn' pollimus lilia. QyOd Ii dicuur,in iJl.ll prima opmdonc Dei

lacerc , fed ~ (.adle. quau motalirCt potcllatcm Don (olum pflrdtr¢tminatc: ad mnr:riale pCCal~

~ ~ noll Gmp"'it«.Seamdo modo porefl ali~ fed edam idfdndertCQgitarionc:m o4endenrem jJ,.

quid monk,&: non phyliclllD tcqoiri fimplid~ ludilbieaum ad quod ciilla przda:eJmiDatio c:j;.

,mer ad. aliquid # ira quOd fine ilIo iimplicnn!lOn k mallUnt ~ proinde JlgO eJk ~1P,quz ~

.poflimus, lidt phyficutn non fat • JI~ phyl'icc!, girana cUm in dIG primo inll:nui fit a Deo • f':'}Ul-

modelt, fcucolll!Unat t {!CUt propofirio obic:o!li,& iur a Dee elfe PDtctltWn pe.:caiJdi; 8c fie U Dcas .,:

G'l1lZ ex p:lf(e propolirionis (c: [cnc:m:,nOD phy6~ d.at iIIam,~ ':lufa pc:ccati,qlKld per k O(ifUr i uli ~e InfIlIllnt intu volllnrarem ~ fed estet'itH di- pOtcnlidi~c rc:fponfio omnino fudJis ea.~ ciom:: • & ramC'n Gmplicirer Ieqllirunnn ~ ,Ra n tanquam Thomillllturo rc(poUfum h'f", f &' w~

;line,illa non diaiailttr poJJi, volunw ~ Ced,nnJlG impugo:1r Abfl.':on IrniU.J, .4ffgtiil difp ..•• ~~,.r.,.I..

modo pollit ; nibil cnim volinllD quill prOl!:cogni- 11. "~.<ll" fllJnnt. Sed,vt ~jdto~fingit IwftcJn qlJ~

wm.Et qu~ Angelus in primo iultilUtJ cainit di- {erm t & IJUgnam parll(Uram U. Apollolo :atfe~

~lDinc: ~cauo{o, nee ell: :aUqua pane potuit ':loa ro[am jlbm folutionc:m porcmaenemer. S_

iIIlld h.abere .1implidcer nOll pOlak p«~aI'C:. & nOli Qlulto labort opus ell,ciim conlterDwm P(C

non tOluan otdinari~ t {ell connanwahf" aut di.lJi~ legem,per dodrin:un,& per Qiulras &nths (og!u-

, culttr; Don tamen h4'EcimpOIe1lth 6mpHdfn On1. "jones olltndt'tt homimbu" & Angdis 'laid C~

fuR cs imp~cl:ltbilir:nc: phylicat& indtfc:aibilituc malum I & fugiendllm ab ipr.~ 'laid IlCID; a bQQ

U paue volunt.aris". ftd a indcfcllibilitafc mora- aUEcm velle Deam hc~rc 3.urhorcm paidl,. pec.-

Ii " pacte intdlc:ao~~inrtinf~'e llUlltD.&' JiDlplid- candi1Dullu5 niG inf.allu$ dicere pocdt,cil.m la &n.

tcr r.:quifira. ' tb 6,,& ~ qllll: ollmdit liuid fit malum.& fu..

'37 Ad qll~ inllantiam Kerp. u D. TLe.riI.ct;l giendum I na:umen n: co 'Jilod DCIP 4U legcm.

, 'lfl.J.16A twdun.+tf,h. quOd Anim4 iTt priu» ell: auc,Lor PO{c:miz peccaildi ~ :!Ul pccati ip61Lf~ wfl.um !fUgtifliMU t5ri1., fIllfLi ~ _ 1" .rflJ,- lidt otcauo~litcrex 1I0ritia p~;tri per legem ag~

ImII pnpU1n ~{ul pn'Tfnf41ff11J till trTrJ'.sinftlhm; gtauau ht concupifc:::mi.a opCl'ando conua illam~

:tr7!M 11m fji pli.J t'~;II • .A»grll1, tpU _ p«flit Vt argommraEar PlaIDs ad Rom. 7- nonllpottl:' Jilritll4l", l ,u/ip" ..alfm ~.lmque pa:Q- nos in hoc iiDlJloran, cUm hz, rcfponfio 1i0D adiuln originale non refunditur in, Veum ctiamli in miuanlr i IlQbii. '. f1iQl(l inlbDticontuhatur I Clan 11011 ex ipf. mo· SeeDod.} pfobamr~ minor.,warou (;lnO " done, aI' c:rt.1tionc Dei (IlnU;!mtar IICd c:s or- D. Tho. fumbtur in co quOd prinl,:i (JP-ro.quz

dine. &:: reCpetlll ad 'primum hominem.:l 'lifO incip~r CIIql dfe c:Il: illi 1 g~ ~ til:ullapidi

(eminali[u dcrl:mdir COIJlU5 f «Ii vniun ;Dima.~ moueri &(Ilfum. H!l:c aUf~ . ptopa6fio !lIlO"

.fit (oms homo lnCiDbntm mius primi homiuis t lie: yen. DiG ranrnm ilJ. jib opetariOJJC qua ;prom p- .

panicepspec:«ti ciIU p«pa:C.atanl fibi clllftlmani- niram pmiGilllr in Ram libi Qaluul~ lie peninemc

I!:XWD. V ide datu&: am DCQm au(a," tariG (Q(. ad complemePtuJDnuUrlt ipw., , f10n auttlil in iJ,.

'ciem habendi illud peccanlUi " non per atlionc:m lis opcruion ibm 'I" omnlDO IKcidcnrales funt,&:

f'oftWn" fJd p,,_taaiocag, CJ" son dauu: {gppOIl!Ult~~ Jam pkni c:omplcum in (110

, KKk f ilaq&

"+54 fl.t!dfl.LIX. (it.'De mt'tj{o~~:".,tcciltIJ;A!!ge!orum. .

ll:atu natutali,V'[ patet in igne , quia.litet gc:neranti ' (ruum q~~':id'VC:i'~uri~bon~~;~'lIbW~~tim,~ea'i:~

amjbLl~tllr qu6d,igni~ 'moue,l;turfl.lrCum?· tiO~ ra~ qi!o~d~pp,a!e~s:lo,dJ~i:?~Ia'"tr~a~. ~~~t~I.~~tf.orll~!

men ai~jbuiiur ilil quod,calenc1at •• "cl dl~lrnlOetj & .m ... o.~jo.n1S'l? I:.'I,noll 1~I.n~\~ cO!f~., rpf,.:& n~~ceifa. ~.I~ ..

eti4m({Hht attioncs . conucniGlnE ignl cum Ip~(i(LlO fUlr In f~~u?QO mfbntl,qmlltl '~JlPron~," ~~r ago

c;lfcill pritnoinlh:nrbrt_am !glliH·~de~in~~riquo dC',[ermi~atl~j .~ mOEIa fa&',n: ~~~~?O 'm~lJ~

:s e!ljilhJJIIinar;& in codc~ mfiallllqulc(C1tln l~t'O IlOIl ~fu.ndlnltlIJ Dcu~, ~~,pr~.?'~~~a~nu ~~ ..

fUlftllIl, ~cl mo~tetur ~:dlu~~1i fi,t exrra (to mod,o fnndltllrr,Er cur ,Pt~pOJi~IO b~m app~rerms,fatUl~

CIuo incipit lDot?S~ fC.Il.' e~t~.nCt~e,) ~ mOtU5 ~tlrF (e'.lln~o l~h~~l mO!l,Cr~ po~efr ad, ~~luil1, &. co:

buitUr g~n~1'll."u. q~l~ pemn~t ad compleIIl~tw? gnlCa rn ff'lllO lIl~tJ~~n ~eft: "." .. ~

gcncr.!ti'lIl1srero,c(~etP l~co.'noll ~,Uf,em am'!~llI~ . R.efp,~es.1ndo mln~t~m. ":'I"'~::, . '-.'~

tlltddcf~~io vt:l1ilnmlP~wo'j q\lla lila! aet~oD:s . Ad, pnn:'am~prob~!I,on~m:R,-~f~.:.'~?d ex r~J~ 41

non pcrtin~nt ad 'compl~mC:llmm gc:net.1(lonlsj pra:dctc[mlllatlOnc ael aa:Dmm~~rial~ p~cln~

nee ad cClIllinltionem eiusin ruo narurali tlaru;(ed vel ex pofldone togit~fiolli_s qudad :tritiraremevnL

ad olotionrm; Ce:u :l.Qionelll erguii"a. Non ~rgo de potcll or;.:i .·pec~amm~nidla f~fuhdi','l~m.didi

cmnis opcratia • Cpl£ HI: in primo intland amibui- in Deum, qusndo itlpponitLlfi;rt:ffUtam'fli1i1tii.IV.

t1!F gctlcram~. M~(~ ~ilJll5 attribuemur H1i l1~io- quOd pol1i_r, ~e ,noUCfCt&: f~~~arl; ~,t~im~n dc~:'

De, lIjtalcsmgt:ru~)' te" & adhuc mulro minus tluosu.Nottgo ncg~mus qli~d liue-In prl.mo;Jiue

2.ccidncsJtberz ;.quia:omnes Ub:non pertincnra4 in Iecundo, inll:~llfi praodet'em:inaflo Dd fiuepet

conR:ilucndam· rem in filo nattlr~i ~~tU, & e{f~. phyfidi irnl11ifrilfh;I~~ad fnil"tt'ri~lc·pcb::ad~6li:p~

ncqtlc ~d complcmcl1tum gc~erat.oUls. ftd ad eh~ pcrmlffi?nc:m ~~hn~. ;lllr,pet' Ipfiu5 togki1tl.o~~

ticllti~IP 3cl"iI,)flisiuppontnus rerum elfeprddu- produd1ollt:m In Inu:lIed;u quinrun;iW'diritarcm

durn,& iiI qili bun'lgir, &: opentur viuen.,n'on au- fil~m nihil m;lH[i~ rdunditin Dtumr~\fti1arowi'n

r~nl meuetur in Ie Icrgo non attdbuLinIutg~ne~ hoc 9peratllr inquantum cillid~nSjri(ilt in qu~tlJm.

umi, 11i~ l)mnC'lh~jonc5 qu:u,viuens ppcrlltUr, prillcipinffi' atlUJ' dl:'feltuafr.' C~terUnl tonun

iUhuribll~nrllr ; c,rgo nan :m.mct fun d~ta iJla:pto: h(l~ deber iiI pponefC: Ipr:itn :Cr~ai 1lr:a1](!i1, ttam.~~~

politio,quod omnl$ ~pcraIlO, quz cn ~umel1i.Hel bIll, 1t,polJi!'vrl propr~a 'mOil!)"'!:' i ~~.Ie:r'I.1tenCft

Qrrtibui{urgcncumt; e .- • .;'; .;"~'- ' (uggclbonc-founiirc dld:a!pcn dcfealioWm ,&;

40''' TCflilhad.em minor?tobamr 1& imcru:1tur prin- inco.Dli~c:r~r ~111, :uquc ita f~ _ ap'p!iC.~~e.'·V! peee-lii.

Cipium D.Tholn. 9L11a .non e(l: ncctUe omnem ~od It hoc non pOtd1:i qUia· ell'prlmol'aClu5. '"

opetationcm indp,icnrtm eu~cl1e.r:ci~dlc fohl~ 11 nullum tilillmpriofcmfuppon!t~; ~q~~..ro.J1it~€c

gcn~tanrc, fCIl eb Authore tabs u3[t1ra:,nilit:lot!111l mouere ad formapd1imiaJe-:du~blP~nfparu!h'IIi.

in his qu:d. (ologcnl!ra~u: peudcnt , lit: qua h ad rereR: quOll.:moucatud, DeCi r~d prll:~urmjiWtiiE:

ipCa!U gcneracioncm ·tiu('1ccomp]ementdlTI petti- phy(id a~ ~I~teriale pe,cllti,fi~eJt~ne'iD5eJle~s ;

ntor ~ non ad COl qU3!.6uUf a gen"~nn:,fcu ab Au- non ell: 1i~bililas vr fOrmetur·a'(c iIi~mcQ-. qu~

dore natUr.r umul emil ipel re que;: gc:nc!.:Inlr.licutprimlu ado, dl;(ed vi aec;ipiatillud'Ph ::zJlo;tiem..

1:11: al'l\ls libel',~ v,Ualk. liquidem pro C~ pirte:qua pc l DcI' : rune enim Ii cum :il~~ pr:tdttermin~ ..

pl.-n,icl ,lb,lpfa crcarura pOU:l'it olcfcltuofa eire •. Et none phy,6ca acclpiar, didamen' 'dcfetfuofutifl

UlIlilircl' b~IIC ip~c:UigitUf quOd iLla:-. ~iones tri- DC'G~maijtia ·ipf;!. in Deum refun.fuur. non qijj:l'ex

buuntllr Adlh~ri n3tllU'.(ecundum cam rarionem pr~4ettrrnil!arionc 'phyfieud ma~erial~ endtit'.

qua tuur ab iplo,& (a:llndUIIl principiaab:eo data, 'tern pr;e'i~': !i:fultCI nt.:lliria in 'Dcumj-fed quia'iO'..·

& qll:t fibl luhorJinlnmr .1I0~ fc.:undfun ea qU:I: tum ipCgtn·di.!l-alUen dcfefiiJo(um a Deo efrede..

Deo non fubordilLlPtllf, Ceil. fecundUm principia .bet, quia no n ab alio pordl fOfn),1ri. Si .auteni'di~

d~fedibilid; lie: enim ne(~llc non eft quOd mo-thID~n dcft:Cluolum non formemr:, non peccahit

ueautur a Dr:o:ergo cum in primo elft: concunant All gelul in-. iIIo primo aan -. propter· elJenti:!Ie!h

ilia ptincipia;lcil.qu;e p3rticipantur a Deo, & qna:: dtptndentiaID pcccad a defednoio dia:~lDhlli't «~ -

fu?t d~feCtibilia a p. eo, po~erit Allg~11l$ C~cundutn can(~UCDtet tlf.que przdcrermi n abi..mr 3. Dee ad

pl'll1luDcu.mQuet,.&non(ccundum ~1A,(c:dd=. JIliitmalepc,"c~u. - ,

licere fiue hoe quod idtcfllllda[ur in Dcum qUi Et cum infiamr quod in aliis initamibuspordl'

author dc6cicnuz nOD cit, fed pcccabit ve moms, Deus lic 'IlCtetillinarc imellcd:um Angeli, tine hOc 42.

&: appliclltt15 cxpropdis. que tUDC eognofcir,vcl 'quOd fiUUCt:Of n'l;lliri~.' '

Cl ruggclliollc akctius. qui fibi POtcll: in illo in- , R e(pondeU.lr quOd li in aliis inlbndbu$ Deus

llantiloq\li. VtJ#pl''' vidimus. lmocum Angelul ipfe form'lrct did:Ul1cn defcduo{um in mentc

poffit 'Rca plllf:l op~r.ui>qu.1:' fibi tUnC m;p.ifeftan; Angc:li. eoacill modo re-fundcrctur maUtia in ip.

tuf.non e/l: nccclfe: quod Pens mOIlC'at ordinate,&; (urn Denl'n.ft~ut in primo inftilnti. Sed quia in alifs

Ietl!! ipfum AngeltllD quoad. omnia, ted pOlCn inll:~mibus ipfe Angelus potdH: mout'rc. &" vel

moll.cte ilium. tl:d~ .'irca ell qua: (unt OJ;dinis natu- 1::10 propria cognil ione , vel ex alrcrius (uggiilione

talis. &; pmnit~ I;{uod ca.dar citu fupcrnarnra- fe applicate ad f(lnnalldl,l!il Gbi ditl;ntlcn. ideo

lia:nulb. mjn} in. boc 2ppateW~pugn3ntia.& UJu~ ~ tUnc no attribuitut dl:fetl-us Jp6 .Dco quantumnii

tilt quod operaril) ill:l lit i Dc:o. fed nOD quo;ld ad mJteriaie peceari pby ucc' pr~dctcrminet. vel

omma. Dmiquc vrgetUc' femp~ iUa p.u1ral dt in- cogitarionem ipfam quoad phy Gam enm:JtelP

fiauu ?rimo cllm inll:anti fC(lJorlo t k teliq!li~ ro· prQducar.Et cum dici[l]t quod ad peec,mull nihil

oIlS VI~~&: opaaticu!ce iJla pllm:l,qua: incipir cum aliud feqa irimr quam quOd Deus permittat' lIJali.,.

clfe rei, & de prinu. qua: ini:ipir in qllOlli~ alio nO. timl cum pr;tdercrmin.atione • & concur(Il:lld ~

gorin; non Qlim. ell malar mio CUr ilIil Cpeciillirer tmale pcccari. Clt quo nulla refundjEQf maliria fp .

6, 1 D~n. ,k bon ~. qua illCipiIDIlS q UIJdHbC:t Deuro. Rc(pondetur; Non amplius requiri io.

a1iud Il(:godum.in qUQ tamen fll:pe iocipimus pcc- Cubic-do porentl:: fe mouere,& formare dilbmcA

9lldo •• prauum linelllddidcr~ruio.F.ft erbm pa~defetluO[Dm : in co :lutem quod nan pou~a t vll'l

ntu in primo inlbnti , & in rcliquis,qui3. Angdus pOi ~ dur.t[ione.& tempote • quo DOn potdl. nnn

: blbui~ in primo.wlbmi cafdem potenriu qU03.d (uffidr illapt:tdl:tetminario,& penniffio.ni6 ttiaPi

, inuipl~u • 4%, qlJo~ d~f~chbi~i(at~ atq_ue in (c:,. adlit formad,o iplius d.i~inis dcfea~oli; quo~

(.tll'ldo milapu. , l'b~Ult 111 ptlmo mft.um pl~num Jj fonn;ntt a OeD r dt:6gt Dt-us. {) nOll fomj~ ..

"linn CQ&oWolili. &: olUDiiobicaac:ogno~non~w:J. :Dco £Ito illo iDJbnti ,DOli deficit "~~nna:.

--,~ ,_c, q\lia

'DifPut~ -~Xll/' .A~/ic.1J. _ " _- 451

qiiIa- ~r~ ~ non p~~pro iJlo primc;.aad~ "proprium.moms:ld ralem JOClltt1.dititut natllrll1i~~

.. J Qgo~ Ii io(b~! : Cl,!!id til faunar!:: cre:iCtlr.1m di~ nen propcc:rIocum,fc:d proptc:r quietcm in IDco.ttl-

chmcn dcfel!hroflilD ,'Ie:! quid:td hoo: cequirirur viuencibu$ antern ~ propria. & connaturalls petfe~

prztc:dpGnu pr;edr:camimtiOnCfii D.:i cum pcr~ aio dI:,quOd OP~[CfitUrCC mouendc , &; qUia non

miaior.ir:: maJiliz;& quare: m~giireflltldit iD D~(lm poOuntfe mouere oHi _ in quantum Dleml,&: apP!I_

mauriam form:Uio"dtGtaminu. qulm prz:dc::u:,mi- cata. t qu;c applicario, & tn~tio debet £ieri pet ali.

Dado concur(lls l. .quem motlilli' pri(l(tm. per qllelll coltn.imatur in

Rcrpond~r quad de bot: vltimo fids a nobis attn f",u moQUtUr ad fe moueildum~ ideo pcr~inet

diaum-ell fop,.;, n:atlmdo de volullt.ltiJ diuin'a:. nd gCIle[3n~em dare 'Jlum. prinwm Dlotum.nOIl

~,d~crc~oru~ elns CBi~;i~ia .. &; in P~Jfoa q~, ~f. FOpte:;: aliqu'lom quierc:m _ ted quia per ipfum IIP~

,;p.i(f'" flJu&M.NIIDedIClD'lIuformmol1c-mdltb.· plicaEut.&' IDCltU~il:lf;ad (e mOUc:'lldun:i!li£,lIr rnCtll1

minis _~rc~l1oli nibil aliud e~c- ~uim ~rop(l~'io- c?r,di$_ia .animalidalur 1 gen:rllme fanqll~m ptin-

nem OblCtll praLl! cum pratlu:;i. mccn bdc:mumc:. apmm VI~Z. 'ql1atciWf pu ~Iem IruIUidi con{ticui-

Crco;'itur.uD auiem forrnare: ~ ditbmcn t &: mo. Ell( animal io tadan~ ilWUetlUi fe. Et fici!t ralii rna..,

ue~e. re ;. (cu IIpp,li~ate ~ ~~Jclll fo~mari?nem. ~e- rus elidatQ( .~ villenn:. {lImm .qui. ptimus Illota,

qmnt. quOd ell: :i)iqllt) puorJ aau Yln~.ilIEer falcem etl,non mOiler flC! ~ ilium, fed InOUCEur vt famG:'"

r~manClue fc mOIlCat __ &:,applice, 3d (onnandum ~c:ar.&_ <J?ia ad cOfin:twraJem Ji:Uiim. viuenUJ fer-

Qltbmen iiuc prauum. fiue re&urn:iJon enim po-. itDtt; :l gellCflifite cL:bet em;-.· Q.!od aUretn fa~

ICft ip4 potl:nriuppllcarc-._& mOIl"C fe-ad. ali quid. mow$" cCltdis in mim:Ui quoad vitam fenfibiknl#

qiu :tiiq,u~ a~p.~ccGenre. quia m.(lIIC:fc:.aa~- ~~.it ,prima opcrado inEdktll1sQU02,d vilm. int,eJ...

~em diClt,~IJfII'lue (uppomf per quem poreJW~ l'glblitm. ~are non orolltS opcraU(Jiicl ')11"- m--

Jimc:~ fu~m ~edUC,ae i~ attorn; &. ira,vc lalXl POD~ (.ipi~n' cum Ipf(t ~lfc: auribuunlllr {pC:d;!li~erg~e.

4Ul\UfiiUSjaltud elt. dIcere j (til p£oducae :laun;.. raou • (ed falUm llLr qu~ {c habuit Y'E prl1lClpJam

~iild mouc:,,_ t fCIl applicate: fc ad ClUJ elic:ienli4m. C%cetanlm • &: ¢onRirllunr Ip{am f~m Sl;lliu~ in

(:,11111 Cfg.O illll_&U omnillm primo, wu in primO in~ flatu connanira!i, & haalli ad (e itlounldum • vc~

llanti nOll POllii 'upponi alius priQt adm, leu :Ilia opero1mium qUDzd alias; adionet, & motus. C21c~

¥luaJitu,quoi fe mouc:at.4 rcd,lltal: de potentia :ad fll4io enim. lie iUurninatio Iidt jiidpimt 'om ip(o

ad:UtU. oporr« qudd in 1;0 aau mOdl:"atUr iCu ap- die: ignis gcniri;- non toltlCJ1 incipient lanqllam

eliCecuf EO(aUEt( llb alia principiI) cstcdori. etiam principi:l ka reqllifira-; qu,bl1l c:oDflitu:uur ignis in-

j~ (ormatiDne buiUl: di~bmmiJ)ficut mlnotu',ordh lbtlJ C0Il1Ufl!t12U, & apto ad. (e moilcndllm. vel ad

animal moUemr 1 principio gen«.nr(: viram elliS. quie(ctlldum ;~~ o_perandum alia qm~ {un; pp£c-.

I;.t ita ill primo inthuui neque,1d bonulD,neque ad d;,ones c:amptenrc! ip(um ftaruIDlianrnalcm dem ...

4efcdllo(uln dUlamen (e :lpplicar~. & moucttpO- tUm ex vi generatioil!s ~. 6,1;1( etiam atliones ill.

(ell: ct~iIlra~. fed, ab ~(Cl:iori prilldpio iUe: moWS' inn:lletlUf , & ·volunrari.s.,4]uz poll ~mam (ODfc:..

cJeb!:tproac:nir~.Ii(:at prilDlU monu cord.s. Er lie q"llluur,nolJ atJribuunl::ar gelll;rdciJed {"JI1m illa.-

I}on fuflir;it f["detamilU~o Dei vi c.1U& Pfim~ pri.ma,qlla C"ona-icuifur in tfa~1J bUliJi ~ '6c'!_onnac.s--

q.u gm=cal!fot CUm quaUo« ca.u:.\ & ad quCmli- talJ ad [e monendum;ti,", tE;Un moCUJ waks,,]1i1

~ aaum i:O~ • ')uia przdcce'rmin~o mqllC {eqaumdr poll motum COEdit. non aurihtUinrur

~inlm:m dat ~~CDri,DfqU~ obie:Ch~ pfOP,Onit~3Ut gel)~Bnli, eri'lIDU umlJl ::t0rc ~f ~nunDt:1I

'l!:oIUll~an dingJf,ft:d IO(1Uh p"rcnOmJ,.vlttUtCJD- cordtS.fn Angelo ~U'¢tn li-· 0- _dz(dt pnm&- ope-

q!lC adiuinl-'rl:"a~am applicat • &; d~[tfmilUt iJiUa ratio.itlaconltiroit ~m~um inlQn,s ad '1U~ ~cni-

lJlodu!D (IlUm Vr lranfear: ~ add pOllIO ad (<<W1- QI:"JU qllZl:umque tub Ina opcraoone coordinm-

dllin.f.t quia phY(lCi,&:: cnri~rilJe(ranfitvolullUS. rur, Si vera :!b dl;t dcfidan(.&:: deofdjJJennu. ia ..

(rianl ,!'liP a{lwn ~~ud dicit. ideo ad Wls athu pertinenr 3daliud inlbn,. q.m opctadoQCS ipfal

enritarcm ~ &; eli.::iclltiam 'indigct ilia ptuppJig .. · diuidullf,non conriftU~ni.

gOlle t DtC ex Illa fCqtliEUf dcfr:dus alu miIitflLjg- _ Ac:hen:iam prob. n:fpoodC'tur: YCrnnH~4"'t qud4 4 f

Deum. fed cntir~tis iIliJlf actUS produ'iio in quan~ . prima opt'~il) fohim prnd1:l i gena .. ,e. feu all-' nun c:ntiw d\ ~_Iic:1U ncc.coutw(us fin\\lkmeus authort.namfz in his qll.-:t ab ipld gcn"ame, k'

cllm aClu peccari refundir m3liriam in Dcum. At per principia eiU$ 6l1nr. - NOB autml in hii qrla:;~t.-

v:«oC"xc;icario,plopolicio obiet}i.{uggeffio.fooua- :..iiis princ:ipii~ pendenr. fi lalia d«lf1ir. N...-gamll,.

~ uoquediCbmillil cUm. pon iilfJuat phy6ce in aa.~ ,(arpc.n quod in prim~ opcrariolle crumr.r ili(etk.

{~ itata aUil1icnuaw abiell!. non relpicir ptltCi1e du.lli~. (eu rei gmitZ' pom, dUl dcpcnd~ria ab-

entitarem all:us~ vt entiw eft,fed [arum quod ob.. alio qulm 3 gtncf;i·nTc. Sll prilJCip~il i gmeranlo

ic::tlum illudt& didamen, in fll b.Jb£t.rotum impri-.- dtriu:ltfs <Juantum ad ipr~m morioncnu~u appU~

mit v-olunrad.EE cUm in Clbiello nOn poOi[ fcp:zr.lR canonem ~-opuandurmquia <JuancumcumqIit:'i1l

ri emit:u,_rc=u r IIbJl:unia aGtuud qu~m -a11c:if.oi PU- ip(a {e ge'QitaJenlur alia principi3t1uc dcfctiibi~.-

JiLi.1 quam habet. ficut in c(lllcurfu' ad cnrituc::m line non, ralllen in primo inlbnri lIidb~a

przcjfi~ ;li!tUj fcpamuc • him; en: qli;jd 6 per ~ a~<1fU~; feu rei gcqi(~ polfullf f~OODUC:-I.C', ~ ~r--

numDa fonnarut diCbmcn pD.uum. n:finutirur pllt'iI~ ~dop~urn,(ed debePt ab e'lIknOfl pnn-

io tum deteaus. 1icur Ii ex lilggclljonf: Ollmiul- cipio applia..oj; Et cUm hoc ntniiI! f'iRcipium tit;,

fO[rD;I(c;DC. nOD 'lao refunditUf aeoqaod. phy- ip(e DCIJS,qui dl indtf~aibilis,hon porelhlicp,od'

lice ~.C'lltiiatem conC'Urnlt. . prittcipiwn creawr.d quo iIJa primaopmriode~

44 Aq, fecWJdam probar.lcl"p:orui«Ut; geneami ~.defcduDl~ liIourn. ,& applic.riad opct;zn ... ~ fQhlnumibui illol mOUlS. fiu Kius rei geuctafZo; dUm ~ lieer C:OII~ lid r:liciendpm ipf~ opm. quipet~ne?r. ad (?'Illi~riondn iplill$ -in Gun, rioncln : (me morione ;lUt'rID.&: app~~c dt"(~ c;Qnw:~n.& deblrQlUi id q~6bl toDDa(uidf,.; tluo6 nunqQ:uri flCruID(defcaqs''''.fkt~annD 111 c~ Cangemi, Hue (lpcRIldo.fiUcqui~;.,fioht . affiont qu .. i fali iDociont. & appliariOiie per fe ~~IlS~ &,aqium-. & lcuium;mriht!UurgenetaDu, ~pendef ~ ,fed (emp« iii- ret!tz appJiciano •. Q!!od quia. pu (;Ilem moE_IUD. ,!DOQttitt puc: ad cOMa". ttlam amlt in Jais quz Ang_clus ~ {aggdbone a]... Uuatan)~ •• biqaitU:ere. &colJ(e:uar-i de~ terial. vela pfoprilcogniliolll: potea opaariill

~~~pi:t&:Cti~, ~ fio~ raluun corporumcontillili jUo pOIJlO illibnri>C)1Ii;l omnia fila !KID pClttll, alfin~

IIlIP-':o 4llJ-lef~ :._ elk Il'a ,- PCAt .. nu-aloCiiID S"C niti vel Cc mo~ ~ ytl lUQiill ab alio. Er;

.' 'dm

4- ~ 6 §2t!.4flio L1X.FJc. De mcrito;fJ peccAto AngelofUm.

c\un non pollie in primo atlu (c mOuetc: • necdfe ... cll quM opc:~c[ur tanll\m V~ ~(mI5 a De~. '" conftqucntec ve tctlc morus, qUia morus qUI ell: ran-

lIiOI a D~o noll potdi non cI~c r~a:u~. '.' .

,; Ad id quod dicitur quod m.llIo mlh.Dn potel1:

.; Angelus ope[ar~ erga ~I~ra~&: Clfca vm~m dclic~re, & non cita aIlud; dlClIfIUS hac elfc lmpoffiblle. quialUa plura atti~$i~ ADgelll~ vt' cl;fordi~~ta, ~ sb vno primo prin.clpla , (eu rmna operauone derium,CX qua incipit(c rI_Iou~tC ~ve:~'jj dt;n~usquod iJla non (e: babl=i1t coordinate/cd dl(p;t[ate~ ramen in nullo purctl: incipere Ce ~ouC're. quia el~em.r.a~ rio cO; de VIlO stque de alia. red fcmper In pmna operafionc: deber reduci ad pdmllID mD~u,,? ", in quo no {I: mon CJt, (cd moucafur ab exrenon pnndfi~ '&.' iIlud rclpC'd:u Angeli ell: inJ"~ctll?i1e, q\lIil ~n lolus _Da1~ : IiCUf fi nng,=reITIU& In altqu!) anifil~1i dre plura ,ora:! qu:t {amul mouerenne Ii~ ne dependcnti~ vnius ab a11o,(ed difparatc, vtru~- ' que JIloUctemr immediate a genct:!'Il~~ncc: pollet in.:diquo dr!! dcfeclu$, nili in gtnmnty dc:fedu$ tiler. Sic diceltdum ell Ii fingerelni.U In Angelo vel cfc~1l1r3 illtdkallali cae plures :!,'CtU!. {ciu motU5 .quorum ~uil:bct cltet r~ima ~pcr.uio,non dependens JIb aha. In ,Y tra~ue IInmt'd~a(.~ meuereiur ;\ Uta, & non ponet efle defeau~ In Illo,pro\>f fie 11 Oct! ~ppliC::i!c:~ur. 5i autem [olu.m e:Il, vna t!pcratio primO!. in qua Angehn inlmeOi.irC mcuerur .i {I\O ge!lerante_De:o j II( reliq(la omnia.que inrelligit. [cu operatur deriu;lntllr Clt Illa p{ima operatione , 1100 pOtdt inrdligi quod in tdiquis peeler. qU~hdlU opcr:ltur ilIol vr (ubl;lrdin:ml prim:e qu;e pro IUD pdmo inllanli retta ell. vr rOorC Cubordinata Deo.Erquidcrn ptltdl: Deus noll mouere Angc:- 111m ~d obil;cb fllpctnarurali.1t fcd unltlm sd natliulia. fed,n h;u: dencgadone tUpcl'n3t11raltllm. nullurn cut peclrilt\ul1 • quia pUr.lllegario efl.: ltd fiue Deus moueat ad Cllpl!tll;lmrali~ .tiue: ad n~lUulii!. [amll1l1. hoc ipfo qllod in]1nl:dlat~ per {~ mo.uet t:lliqUlru fOn!l~M. ~ dalls·dilbmcn illius prim;!! ollemlonis,non potell ibi defethu iJ:u;idc:u:,& cOIIC~q ueuter ricquc in adu 'IoIUlltari$ inqll:mtum ex rah motione.& did:amine dc~iuatur.

47 Denique a.d p;lfit:ttr:tn iUam quor: fit inter p.ri-

n1l1m, & fCC:II11dum inn-ailS Angeli opclanris. lam fitpe rcrpondimu!: paritic~ri qUidem ilh inlbntia quoad illniprc;~ cntitatcm. &. defl!!l:ibili[~tem potenti;mlrn. Be quo3d pe:tfc<!liones ez polIte modi.fpeciemm. & lumipis 3d inctiligenduro • &: rcfp~tlu cU2m obieClonl1fl qllO;ld bonum.&: m~lum quz qu:dllpc~atju~ inlc!ligllntur. NOll cnim ell dubl!lm quOd in primo inRami imdJigit Angelu5 pe(cara.& Viri3.hCllt at: vinut~s • & bonum 3ppa""i,brut & honellum (p~l1lallue, &. q\l(l~crqui~ ditace£ illOl'unl: (Qltim diJf~(cmia ell.quod in primo inftanti • feu in prima o~ratione non potd!: operari AogdlU Vt [e moucns in intc:1ligcndo • U. \ro!.:lldo. lcd Vt morU$ a D~o~e:o quod iDa ell: pri - ' til.;). op~tario omnium,in rc:liqllis amcm inlbnribu$. potdl: opc:mi hon (alum v[ motuS ;1 Dc:o • fed etia Vt i"c: mQll~nl: &: iMo ilb prima opeutio nOn potell: dd!::d:uo5i proponttc:. &. cxci~.uc (~ dic1am~Q ~efcauofi~m fo~~re. quod, t~mc~ r:!iquz opm(10n'l pol1l1nr.mb gf~li.J. D~I COIl(e'lI~ntur;& ideo uipla nanlra pri,lUZ op«.iti~ni5. (alum qUIa prima:

ell*o5F,cJ; mono~,e Imm~d~ .. D~lproucnietls. ' Il9Jl p~cll ddicm.i licet ,in rdiqui5 , pilri6cl;'nlrc:qnl C~qu~tibl!.S

ore1'.lfionibll'. "IJ~ pof- .

• {UIU~UC'.

ART I C.V LV S

II I.

il!." ienere fmAli~' tf cirta qutl.ll (Ibid/11m pu&nlltrit ,.,1~

grtg,;i' '

I N .pr~{enti articulo mID foti\Jlillgirnu;. de generio: ip(o pecc3ti.f.:d etiam de fpecie: q.ccies mim eX Oblecto 'umifur, nee potdI d«I:Ir~'i:i obili:tlum in patti~ul3tj.nili ipcciet ipfa pl!cc~ti ~otc:fcat.

Grotl4l.tWlti Angdi.

,",

Peccad genus poteR: aUl;'lldi prima in f3Jiona' i monalis, vel YCi1bli~. Secundo in rarlone tommir.

tiiJill! vel omiffioois. ,

. De peccaro YCnio1li conllat non fuilf~fQJilrn in Angdis,fed !liorulim ptccafii:. Ell de fidC'.tunl_ locis quibu5 S c dptura up,jjc~1 genus Hilus peee#' l/. ciMquc: dfeC:hu, tUtti 'tx dari'ln.ariont {c(Ut2: confht cnim DiabDhlm elf.: dammitum pan;! 2;.' tl.'rna M.mh. t f./ (tin igm7nuh'mun IJHi PAYllltlIUJl' 'DiabDII,& Angtl4 tilU, {cdproptet pCCcaunn Vc.~ nlsle non debe tur pmna zterna : Don ergo Diabo .. Ius peccauit '{alum .vcoiAlitcr. Dedar~ruf edam' hoc pc:,!;arum Diabt!li· co gellerc pccc:ati, qgod moreale pecamm lignilicat, vt cUm diawr loan" 8.111e h~mi,;J4 trill Ifb it/it ill.&' in 'fIlYirll" nil1l Jniti homicidillm aueem am peccamm quod homitidio

"a:quiualcr • peccalum venial! non e:ft. lir l.imilir« PCCC;;lIUI_rI cill! fupc:rbiz fuilfc SCIipU1r.:l dcdl1tlr~ vr 1.ad'Tiinotb.;. N 4 in: fllPtl'bilZIII lltmu i" iiltlidum Im:J .. , 7)ilfboli .. Eccleliallid 10. / niliu1lJ#1II- 11;' pe~ellfi,foP"bl" j .;onlbt ,uUt:m primum pcc,a~ tum omnium. fUll1e pcccatiun Diaboli. Et fuperba de [uo genen: pcccarum morrale ell:fupabis C:ilim Deus [Cfiltir. &: pr~ICttimfupC(bia Diaboli, qua:: fuie pcaima.Ocolque nOn:'ine iniquhatis pc::cc;2uun Angeli nomin3tur Eu'(;bitJ;s 18.qllO notmDltl(JQ nifi ptC(;Itllm merrsle defign:It11r. dicltllt' aUtem ibi de ille Allgelo. qui vocarur Cherub rtttntus. &. pro[cgens i PfTfofll1l in vi/d fHM ill/i, unJiti~i; tH~ tlfmtc il'JUl>lta 1ft imqllitAf in It. Er de: ciUJ fup.e.:bia {ubditur: EltllllrKm ~fI CQT lHl1m it! diem" IH~ • ptl'J.idijii f"P;lllli41? IHam in dtem 111#. &e. ~are eX. omni p<!Ite tonftat peccarum Illud mertalc fuific.

Statim v ~ro fe oifcrl;bat ilia diflicultu. an babuerit Angelus p~CC~tllm aliquod vcnil1Je, lidt edam mottale h3hUC:lir, vel (altern an poffit An. gdm venialircr pctcarefScd hzc difficulr3HiaB'a.. tur ~ D.Tho.l.l..qll.S," o'Ir;.". & 1}"'7. de I'ltltlllll1'r. ,. Er reroluit non poll'c. quia nunqu3m Angelus leuit. t opcraim ,ltd incipiendo.i line' • .'!.:: in nne 3Eringens mr:dia.~are fi am vDlurmlS,&pr:u9:iclU' inu:lh:liust femp-=r C!tfaE ell:. line. '" 1i vult rc:ae~ el;hm reClitlldo intipit a fine; & Gc in omni aall lIlultuself Angelo. in bono nl~gnu~~&jn peceato. peffimu. •. Et in taU atl:u in q\lo ell pc:ccatUpl opor. tet quod delli~tia illdpiac a fine:illo enhn rttenro, nDn fbt circa media emm::,(eu in his <tu ad linem Cunr.licut noS. Q,!!:r dotirina aliquibus auert'avila el1:'1 lic.er cnim tOneedallt Angdum perrari: non poGe v.cnialiter ell [urrcp.rione , lk inddibrntriblle iudidJ ,: ;it pecr::aE3,venlalia •. qll~ tum ~erfccb. delib.cIatiMC nUDf,Cc:d C:J:.parUlCltem.rmz ledia timt. yt mQIdaoum ioo.ofum.&'iimilia. diCunt Angelo non rcpugn:tti:, quia hz, ex 1"01. inmnfea. tuionc: leuia (unt: ergo eX eo quod ab Angtlo liant.noa uddentl1( mouali~ ~ qqUG cnim repllslfabtt 'qund

Angc:lllj

Diipllt4lio' XXI/I.

AngeldJha.bcat allquam icaduencntiarn leu em {liffieicIUI::m ad yenialc,& non ad mortale.allc quatc don porefit Qper;Jd· (:l1m plena conCid«atione Jl'icmdii.cium;al1t aliam rem leuem illlmi m04urn,&' n,uuram t:i1iu=i h:uis ~ & non ex (uperbia. vel conlcmpttl,aut alio Jim: IDofuli ~ ~Od fi nem fa-. ci.tt, id crir ex prollideflfia :lliqail Dei eltrinCeca. prO' hoc Ham graIl!!:, in qua nee: bominemil}·fiatlk i!lnDc:cnIiz. nee t\ngdullIvoJl1it dcilicuC(e C:OQ-, gtu:ndliu! aU1Ciliis ad non peccandum "c:niaJirt'J; quaiidiu a cb~titafe no~ cJt:cidilfeo(.Et jra renene pleriquC' Aurooti:'hVt yideri porta apud Vafq. J.i •. 'l.8y.4rf-40iri MWiD'" ;miclIli,Granadof I.P' tl'"ll~ I ~.djrp. {.fi.8.AlarconirIlEl.G.d, Angeli. diJp.g. ~.J' & alii· .' .

3 Nihilomimu fentcnda D. Thorn. vcrilfuna. dr~

nempe Angelos iu:ua connaw,alml modum funni operandi eWe incapac¢; peccandi veni~lita~ vc ,it.l~~11 I .~.ttl!dit, & Ibi comrnuafrer dUJ. difc:ipuli Cait;uD!u.Conff.uius;·Mt'ciin:l.& alij.£unio. {upd. indlc~ra id CuBicienn:t prob.a_[ ,q:uia Angeli nunqullIl opmntut Y'llunradi.& delibc:nre7liud bene. {iucmaie 1nifi inciriendoA line.Gellt IlUftit ifirelHgu.t nili indpiendo . principiis.& If! hi' vjd~ docom:luJioncs line: dtfr;urfuiquia propriu ell COtil peoeedere cumprc:bc:nfini, &. in ipli! principih at=s= ~uidqujcl :ld i1~fr,l'aaf. &; i~ ~HDn.dne,uJ:".Su~jllll:[ VO!ilrJt:;iS Ifl·'pfo nne c:hglt Plc:tba, " ~on proeedic ad media, nih fub aliquo nne:;, '" in fine 7 ita qupd idem athu ell: nc:eeUariuJquoad (~l:citkadoDc:m. ex p3rt~ ~ni$).& li.bct ell: p~!te mediQtl,tnl (Urn pnrnam c:hglt, h,ttJn c:te~CIUo quo~ ad vtrumque liber lit. Cum ergo dcordinatiofC:C:c:ati veniabJ,fiue ell: p3tUJtatC marcriz .Gllc·cJt:1ndeHbc:r;ti"ne urionis:. nen Gt deordimllia c:ir~~ nllem • apercu quod Angelus opt:t«ur c:jr(:.ailIud e~ a lio ptiori fine. in quo r:di.a v~ni:di~ v~lit. E t qtlld~nlll finll tit bO!JUh 6: ·relic:: .... oheu' .. b Angdo • cUm ~Qd~ ;l.du • &. impctu. qIlo fatuI: in fiaem. fctatur in media. Don porc:1t rendere in finem bene. &: tine dcfl:Cid • id elt tioe deotdinltione lline. & in media rendere deerdhJ2te~ .quia 6e [~par;Jr~~ motum in ip~ mtdi:ll maw jp. finC:lIl. quod rolum in nobis e:on{ingi{.Ergo oporree quod G de:ordin3te cendit in aliqua mcdia~ {ell in 3liqlJam pJruitatt:m materi%. qu::e [alum pettin t'r ad malitlam m~diotum. tendat in i1b • vc:: dtordin~t;J in vi alicuiuJ 6n~ • &. in eo e:ootcnfa. in I:uills volition!;: funr vol!r!!; at non {eottim. adcyamim;\·linc. Ergo omni pai¢l:'ma~ rCfrz. v.olita: ab Angelo f~mp~t adlu!lg:irur grandlc;n alkuilu Snit • q~lia p;Jtuiw m.ntmc:: rempef pminet "d !nedi ... nunqi:lam ad hrlcrn ,quia finis Ilunq\lam ,.ft piruuI • c:ilm 'it rrin~ip1lim quo. eriam magna JirigUnEUf. Tzm impoffibile igittlt ell AngelO' p~ccare vmialk.:r in OIIiqllu aQu. .Gent (epOIueim a fipe ~Itingf:re mf:di~) 8( condu.uOIlCS c::m~ prindpia, & lolum il4 n;lmra .qtlz . alio aau :mingir finem, aliO' mtd~. "mea. .tetent;! n:cli6,3rjone cn-ca fi!lem {alrern habiruaIi.

euarc in applic4rionc • &: i:t~ndenrj:l crg;l media prztcr lincm > Ikc:t non (ontra fiDem. &: lie p«ace vmialitcr. Be non monaJitn. quod ell idem ae: pe,u(e. (eo aben-:l{C a mediil • nOn erundo l fine. At vera. ilia naruI:l ql12 Rg!l pordl tendae In media nili per eurukin adUni QLlo {t'nrur in fin ern .. nunquam deordimtllt i mcdiis. neque puuiratem JiJatc:rilt' amDgif ~ niG incipielJdO' dtordinarioncm l hue > arque ade3 ~diungendo illi circumlUnEiam nlona-Ian deordiIlJEionis:\ line. feu I;onttmptum ~ raEiollC cuj"us

J,4R,iJ S.TJmn.illl. FIJ,r,.D.Tb. TOilllU.utttl

Artie.11/.

r

4S7

rilruit~~ ilia .. ~AferiZ. V. g~ me~daei\lh\ qUlld u, (e ,v~male !:fl·, C{:Qrfum :l fine cOllhdcratum j ex pr~uo, fine. & ill ~ju£ deordinauone volitum. non,. patuum, eft. Et,hac. ita ccnuenk Angdo. Q(!B {olum ratione .!latus damnaeienis , in quo. nune opcra;Qt fc:mpcr U odia. & cant~mpru Dei,fed. ex natltia laa ,'quia. ex ipi:l pollulat operlU'i cit,.. Cit medi~ ~non ~orfum a nne. Cf4 e<iden:ultu" e:adcm orcUnatiQllc qua fct'rur in.linen .. Vnde Ii .. ; C:UtqUOllido, opcrantur u; tbarirare,;. in ipfo fine: lima,,,. amant 'mcdia • vcrbi giada. '" in Deo om ... nes pr(lilimos~. :ifa: qilando. Opcr...mllf cii'~a.aliqu~d malum i\'iedia~.op~ra~tllr e;t pr;tfuppofitoo fine: malo> ~ "'·,fir;:. adbu.: III plIca n~tura li operall~ Uit c1nne bono, Be retb eills intc:fltione.ibi nO'llcom~arillnnlt aIituius. "!Ial~ medii • e;iam el; pawuau: m::umli'. dcordinaciofitm. Si VC(ChUn quam dCJ)tdinanoncw patiuuiu,·, ilia jildpit 1 mai

lofine.· .' . .".. , '. .'.

, Vndcloluiltlf' oppoli,umfundam~ll1m. :0.."., 4- pliodc:nHI$ ,tiinim quOd Jictt aliqllll PCt;c:au unt

ell: nat~~ll {Ill t & martria' propria lroia ; ramell ql1ia .Angelu( lao conn:m~rah modo opmnS'p; non ,l'Qu:ftilla. aningerc nili Cub aJiquo line in qllO hilt VOlit;;!1& eadem aau quo ipfc fini" lieue: neque conclufienes ~ niG in principii!. ideo ill! pamir.are matefi~ {emper adiiltJgit pondils gra-

ue e:h:cLunftaptia: 6ni5>. atia qllm:l > vel lim: IJllac non pCt~ft patuir:ltetn illam Yellt::. t1equ~ cX leni aduc:nmri:i opera,j .:it.::!;· tnedi:l • &. cina p;Ji'uam materiam ( quz; (emfer ad mc:dia pcum.a) non operando ~tca finem. nee inC:ipiendo deordinaricnem 1 line • qUI!; fcmper gtaUI$'dl. Leuem :lUrem ~lIclfmdam habere nun '''mpe-ti' Angelo,; qui non jmperfctle procedit> (cd comptehcl'l,§ 6uUpG.m cli<l:m lDareriam pULlam .. 1i ::II:dpcrcC' non FtO media. red pro nne multo dfa gr.auillS~ quia pORtta nnc:.Ql in re Cti:ilf"7 &, £.;1M p..nuK NQP tnutar ergO' Angchl$ pan lam Wlltc:1'iall'l ill mc:ndado > ., .g.fcd aecumubt ptaag.m fin=m.a,nt~ cuius dcordinatlOf1Cm, maIi1m medium volitaw

non cli. .

Dico (eQuid.,. : G~UJ pC'ccad Angeli pri~· mum non potait elfe pccclitum omiffiollls • (I;'d commiffionis. Probatur e~. dia"~ ,quia prirriDm pl:ccamm An9tli inectpit in~o eX ali'lilo morillo circa nntm .kd prirPum mo,iuum. ~ finis A~ gdi DUB poUUt df= omiffio : ergD pTimum peccanlm Angeli non poroic cire ormilionu 7 f~d commimQPis. Maiar i::(llillar c;.J: iFfo cOilDarfitall

. modo Angeli in operando. r'iiicet ~"nne • Be ill 'fine: aningc:odo media. lieuE tondWjoJl~$ nlin porcll1uingete niG in priru:ipiiJ,ql.lia comprehiliue p(gi;edj, ; ergo dC"bui~ Angelus rrimum pC'r;utttm. incho!!re: t'.uJiquo motiuo ClrC:l fintm# uquid~m vo!umaJ in modo opct:!l1di Icmpct pioponicnll-rut mndo optundi irn:ellcll:lU. Vode: &ut iJl,. rdl~a\l$ propter vim ,omptehenliuam femp" incipit 1 principm,& in frinc;ipii1 'o!ldulio~ inrclligir , fie voJumai l. bne:, Ik in line ,aDSit. mC4 dia.MiIlo! probamr ~ 9ui~ ",iUi@o ill" non porui~ eJK Ft'c':UIIUl.ni.fi cJI'et volunwia. vel in fc volendo i!Llln, I(~I in ~liqua !:aub..yd oe:alione. t,h Eione cuius cik'ilicompoffibiliJ lIdimpt«io PiZ4 I;cp',i ~UUl ~i v.' olitione • :dia~ilin omiaio ill .. ~~pabdp non ~ • fi volunrana non e:~t. Sl ilIa omillio fir 'IIohmmia Eanqa.am· dkc&e YOlira, opona quod hoc ip(o imwlll:aqlt fbi :m.. quod peCC;l.UUD eOllllDlillonis,qllla qui vuh: ~ & pet (~o!lJim(ln~ tC)nn:.a pt':&c:c:ptlJlP. hoc ,pfo ill wi opWlion~rqr~.icaM aliqllid lruio{is booi.

L1.1 YJQCCM

4 f 8 ~41io LJX.fJc.' De meriio,f5 pecc;iioAngelorum~ .

vincell ilJud'bonum~ql1od~lI:ifi~impletione pt. att~~j ~Itilno~~ut tanquam ~edium~ve~ '~nd(ti'''!~i.

cepti dillini ;. omiffio enim vt ,,~imo '?fIl iiI p~j- lim lUi (Llb~rdmanml :efgo lam.fupro~lI~ ilIa "O~IC.

. & .. _ n ens nonparell-iMlooe ,(un:fi'c.vohra no lin. em alJqur:m 1I1t11nU~pnUs vohtum. «rion

uallo, no, r: '" ' , z., I '_ bo . _ ... ol ell:: DI:U& fiquidem.

ditea~,fcd vr ffel1:iruraliquo bono,~ttnappan:c,. DIlenl ~ ~~ nnm , • . ;', _. ..

EtG eftomHlio.przcepta. opOrtet ve rept;Zfcnte~u, fub tab line nen potdt ,fU~Il~~nat,. ~mlfii_~ pec ..

ali uodboJ1um .nonquolJiodo"mquc.f'edvm* camlnofa':er~o (UPPlJfUt_ finc,:~vlttm~mJI121Qms

ce~ iUud bonum quod ex adimpletione ,all, pIa; _ ~~ auer[llm a DCI1 antc:c:c:dei'l~CI ad omlffionC:,m.~

. wllfutgit vr pomr mOIi¢ri quis'a(Hrang~ndll m 1110 6ne; feu codenu'la.&: ImpccLl vult om.'ffio.

~~~cp.tllmdlr:tte:~t~a prid' ,debet .a_ffiti, volan- nem.Ergo peccatum" Angeli non indplt ab B~im.o"_.

iii' iUi bonO' j.iJuo vdlitur omlffio,'It c1 I:ILl, ~ppe~. DCjfe~:lD a,hqu~. vb~,?o linc , quem ~olHra DeulQ

tim ?on 'e~lllct ~aDg<:te ~rll:ctp[~m;~lic d.lte &l appent.l!c, ~n tall voliuone ~cccat., pon omlttendD_

valluo omlucnd, fempcr ilnpomt abqaam com- fed·commmendo.'feupol1t1u~~Pp~o.l;' conua

miffionem. "lei ~fllpp04ti\la. vet~~ncomit~IUf; p .. r:cccptUmiltg3t1UUmnond!ilg;:!ld~ ahquld Vt vl~

qu~ alliCiamr Ialitcr crga:iliquOd honu. Cello oblCtlu) ~finum .nnem pr~ter Drum. Nee obllat qu~ ~

vt ratione eiu~ non fe-CUCCI velle omiaionC:I11 , q\lZ' apromet Dec amado datu, przceprum aRirmllEluJi~

in r~ non c:~ aliqllid neqtJ~ bOlll1ii .. ~;lub~rlld i~- & bO:II;:. potcll Angl!~u, ftallgae:dlcirnu, enim .pof_

thm ffaaloueln pr~GcptJ affirmatnll;qula omDlI fe, q~id~ hangc(4: t~le: p.ra:ce:ptum, fed ex ali qUI)

ptlUafi.o, ft. 11 Dcgario i,n aliquo bon? i fe,u po~tiu,o pft(jf1 mQ~UO quo "c1~t aliqUI:Jla finem'7"'l,?lendo

fundatur. SI vc-ro Ilnnffio lIoll fir dlle¢h: ,yolu:a 10 dlu~.OlDluat tonuetf~ ad Dl".Utn finem vltllnUm~

f .. ,&:n oCo}.u=atJm , r~d Inditcru ex co qabd ell om.Oio'mhu aucdionJs ab ahquo fine non pcmdl:

aliquid priWi volitum.cum que no compatitur ad.. :app~d ~ fe pUmOjmii ex ~rlUc:rfumc:ul aJlq~":1D

impli;rio- przecpd.i*m,jlluJ priUs volitum pcrtiilc- finell1; Hcut nee eeeedere ), tennino • '1N",DI6 con--

bl! ~d :ltturn po Gtiuum volendi 0 IX non Coltlin umclldo fc ad fcnnJnu~ .rra 'f'Um > nee poteR: '10.

om it,~ndil& eit alia pane: ell: pecl:atlllll,qlli ell im- Juntas pu'~ ft: Cu!)cndete per neg_ananan omnis

p!:di~uum! ad, mplc(~on~s p.r~ccp~j. ~ QuJa. omlC- a¢lIU.,:e~iam a~feccdc:nt'i •. & q~i nll,':au(a. vel oc~

lioUts: ergo nc~lT3r1~ melp't pnmum pecc.o.tilm calio IlhusomtlJionis. qWiualis fl1fpcnlio( fief.

All geli ab aliquo meelue clllp2bilitl:rvolito.& noll fet dabllu)c:Jl"et purHufpcnfio pbylic:a,& DOP mo.

omilli») &: lit: t .. lr:'p~ccatumell: coMmi nioniS. ralis ,quia nee yo lunmil'.. vtpotc: non ptoec:denJ

, Sed quia poll'Ct 'illiqui~ dicere ,quod licer ve- :lb ipfil voluDIau: ahqilo modo t,vdatiusdicemt

rum (it quOd tale bonum prius volitum ell quidcm i .2..qll.1I.6.

eulr~biliEc:r volitum. fcd non .~E ali~m, culpam ,Dices; l)otuit Al)g~IQJ i&primo inJhnti).fc_u!n 7.

quam culpam Qmlffionls, qUlamde (ulmE tl)tOlID pnmo aflu pec:car~c,.,nua pr:t:CcptliJilalli~ull~

malitiam;lk lidorm:lliter eltpccc:atUJn omiffioni,. ergo pecc.uoom,ffionil.Confc:q.pam:.Anw:cdms

lic~t materi:direr habeat :ldi Iinaum aliquid tiimif~ ptOblEur. qllia in primo inlbnti fuit pf2cep1um ill

fi()nis quod viti;JnJt Cl omillione: , qu:e ellali vo- Ang.JO' conuatcndi (e ad DCUID. & «aE liber ad

Iitiont I~Uitut', & adimpletio przc:epti impcdi- ehciendum.vd non diCic:ndum > k faltan pta ~ .

EUf. cundo infhnti e:m Iib~ libm:ae c:riamconuuie-

. Contf:l. hoc infbUf;iEm argLllllennnn.&- confir.. JaCis, ira qu.Od potera!: pe~ergo per hoc: folum

l1l~tllr rnto addutlJj qUi hce In primo p~cc:ati,An. quod fU(pqldcttet atl:um aJUanm pecc:uc:r : porcrac

geli locum non h;1l;er • fed n~~ffimQ ilia OIDlf- ergo in iUo plimo- peccato incipc:re ab omiSioDe ..

flo, fiue indirtde W',,]jla e:l aliquo priori ~rup- qUI i esm lii;er crat aJ velle , qulm ad non~ a:iam

poliro ex quO' lubct£equi ,!iue direCta Yo1iu~Vt c:omr.uic. Q.!!i$ ~rgo prolukbat tunc nOn '1clle'Jf

"dhtaaliquo bono app:trenti. fcmpc:rdebel: prz- & inC:ipetd (u(pc:nlione a.:!lu5. Be hoc cIarpc:e:-

fl.ppon~re allquod pCCC3lllm cOPltnil1ionj$ pf:e~ CHc ~ Item qUi:L In ilia omillo-lie eiat pec:c:anuXl

cdWIlI:; ac:nim ilia omi Rio vr lit peccatllm,drbcr mowk : ctgo erat :l.uerJio a fine: vlrimo. & con-

e[;: in przcrpto.& dfc ,.olul1t~l1. Vt fupponi- uerlio ad fincm prallum: ergo POlecaE incipcrcl

mus t Anlr In; aUtern non pO,tc:1l ali qUid vcll~.nUi tali :lu~fionc: • &, ;\ ftaltiQut; Wius przccpti illice

in aliquo line. Vt kpe didum eft. quii naIuralis m:u:iui nolc:ndo ci obc:dire 1:): cOlltempna Dei. &;

modus 1:iW- eft vidert in ptincipiis condufiJ;mc:s.&:: omitrcndo eius pr;J;'cep~a, Et !ieat vella omlffio-

"file mcdill in fine. Ergo vel ipfa omiffio ell finis nctn il'tarP ~x alio .liM • tilmen cum non inr~c~

quem fibi AngeJus proponit, \fel in afiqllD line ell; ueniret ibi a,' ia m.1liti.1 quam omiffiollis ~ nequl!'

"olit .. unquE- mtdiu,vclcondidomedlj t ;lIlt deni- dicetUr ibl pc:ccare p~ccatO commillioDil. fed

qll~vuliquid~ubordin.tt~ !ini.Si ,ip(a ~miffio, ell: omiffioni$, u(:Ut qui vult propter lu4um mlf-

fims,przrc:rqua qllod ell: IInpollibilc. Cllm omlaiG (:un omittete) non pcc{at peo:aro cOJltmiffiOlJd

in fe folUni fit priuatio, & nibil. lice banitatem Iu- in ludelldo. fcd omUlionis in non audimdo fa...

~etiw in bocmaxime p~c:calum commduonis crum.

eft ~1l00 vult facete ipfam omillionl;m culp3bilem Refp.3Ii primum non pomiJfe Angelum peccare

fintltl vlrimum.ciim in (e nihil bonitafi5Iubl:~r~& in primo PC:l;QI:o.c; l'notiUQ QmjffionUl~d el roo-

ptzfmim,quia6 "ultillan) habere pro line 'l!'itimo. riuo tommlaionis, & lie: antl:cc:dcte: dcbuilfc pee-

d p~ c;0r01DiJlionis omnino Fp'ofiaum. Catulll colnmiffionis : licCr cnim eurrl:ret pmc-e.

& c:on~ pr~«ptum negariuull1 non (oliil1l aHir~ ptum afficmariuum conumeridi ft: in Deu!lY~f3rp~1l

rnariuu1U. fiquidcm non IOJilm YIlIr: fuugcu pr;l:'. ilbomillio non cut appetibi1is ab Angelo, nili in

«ptum impolitllm.quz ell omillio. vrpole Comra. aliquo finc • in ~uo primo alle:rtl:batllf 1 Dca. co

ptz«p~um affirmaliUllm. fed c:tilm _ vult in. '11104 in bono hne • & relt8 ord~ato nOll potc'~

ip6: ontiliiouc6oem '1ltimum ponere.quOd di cG- ~at Angelus velie:, ?!",iaionem (:uJpabilcm,~ quia

m ptZCepllltn ncgariuum.&: eft comroillio. Nee db DOn ern (cferlbdl5 In talml finc:m, neqlll: ilIi

patcll imagin.m quOd aliquiJ niG in(anlH velit Cllbordinabili$ ; ergo Cub aIiq\lo finc aucdo dc(,e.:

QlDIRionan ipfam f.tCeU: 60em vmnulin • 'It dl ret appeti,8c ilia conucdiO' ad raiel'Q linetn :Ij\teCc:w.

priuuio _ in fe ~ fed (eip(wn coullituit 6nc:m vlri- dens omiffioncm laID c:ratmala, &: non tnt "mif~

Inurn, nimis fe anundo, '" nillde Y'olmdo omk- hO ~ (ed commilHo. quia {o6riuo aau volira ~ &

lere fell £notes-c pf2ceptUm. Q,!!_M!iomiffiO'nc: VI 'luodd:tm appcnbilc. Horno alltelC nap eadem

"10k. IIQI1 'It~ .,kimwn~ kd n ~dioamm a(\u v Ilk ~J '" id quod (gb fuJc ~ntinc:(uti

~fi"

"DifPu(. '",XX-lIt·

" fie POtcll: velie omiffio!'u::m {eorCUID· nne commillijJll~.iiC~t bab~at.djqllctn :iClum,qu! tir !:!luG, & oeedio illiu5.vt mO(lllte~ vOliltaEia fit.St POte. J~t AiigehH velle, ,vel n_"lIc.di~iiiJ;,uo;nDI~e ~oral,~er ~ & voiuncane ~ prz(uppoficlonc :du:llJu$ n- 1i1~. rran(cat. fine: fall finc.llcgo • eo quad modus ,onnaturlllis in Angc:lo cit velie; vel nolle media rub :l.liqllo fine,&: e:oach quo vult,~c1 non vult 6- !li:m~omicccre alltem fiDem.bonuln pura omiBionc,s.:- nullnm alium finem appefclldolcdab omni aAu .::cOando 'n elerr;iti.MHlfi eft con naturale AD~ / gdo,imo neq<lC' hominl,quia non ell COllii:iturale voluntad • 6.; foi'f~ Ire impoillbilc ab omni atlu fd {urp~iidcre.& line vlIo vitali rngtu maDere, 'It la-

~lus l.l''1.6.dicetllt. .

8 Ad fecundum d~tln quod in omiffione • qlla::

ell pc:ccatllm mort~~ (lamr c"I1I1"60 • LIe auerfio

. a 6ne,dillingllo. t~lin:r q!lQd conucrfi" ad finem non fit ex mctids ipJidS omillionis ,'Ie pura omiC~ fao e:fi,concC'do ,.ranter. ~!lQd lie e% ;iliquo adiu~da quod non f!=t omdlioncm t fc:d pc:rcommlfftont:m. fell poliduum atl:1l1Tl ;lppcmur. tran{~f. Ne~ ip~ omitUo.vc dij;imnstpoti:H 1ubere radona: nail Ic:cundilm. (e.nifi indu3' aii'lllaaHationi.l qU;ti potiduhppcuuu,vt propterconicmptii;vd odiu Dei, proplcr commadltatcrn proptbm. vd ;ld 6:fcriendam Ilb«r.ltC'm , aUE illiquid fimilc:. quod pritis app=dmr vt flnis,&apP«liurnon omittcndoj fed poli(iUA volenJo. Ee CUm inlbrur quOd pOldt ell':: V!1lit.1. omllli, ex alio linc J qui non habese ali~un mdidam, qldm omiffionis. Rcfp.qaMnon, difplluooo modo aD in jUo atlu. 'lui ell caue. omi.ffi?n~$ ,edam dl:"lll{ proprta, ,& imrinCecarat.io pcceatJ) hC!:'t cum OJ"dmc ad omlffiOliem • heUt 11-

le: ludus,v.!i:. propter quem volo O.liliUete (actum, etiam in gen~re JUdi liar (IlEcrlluu$, & ",:du$ com.. milliu! , hoc inqllam omitro , ell (pe:ci:ilil fado in .Angelo. 'lui t::I: CD quOd non potdl inelpere dew orainatioR=m Cwm , & adurn volun~,j;, niG ;. fine ~ in quo. &; (i10 quo de-ordiDafUmem ornnem exercer , ide:e opOUCt quod Ii ip(am omiffiobl:m lion :l.ecipit, 'IE I1nem ill le ( quia eli pEinado. Be careDs boniutc ) pr:J:(upponat volitum finc:r4 di· ftinetum ab orniffione • in quo ipCa omi olo vt medium • vel qUid conrentum [ub nne yolita fit. & t:l.li~ finis malus eO: , lk nop reCh! voli[lls anrecedenrer ad omiffioR(:1n , qUia me 6nis vltimn$ Cub quo d~ordjn,ltecO: 1/oliu omiffio prz.::epti.ll~m po"(cit: effc bOnl15,neC De:us ipfe.quia. ad iltum non cit rcfaibilis;elll;"rgo aliquid·malum • .:k auc:rsii~ Deo

N Oil ergo inQpir pccc2mm Angdi ab omijfio!'!c: ••

Spuin !~mlti .4"gdi.

9 . Circa fpe;;:;em p,ec,ari Angdi 'Inurn ell: fae cel'. (urn 3pud AUlhon:s > ("liteE primum pcccarum d~ {:ttlo Pf!Ce3tUm fl.lpetbia: fullfe. Afind Veto. eontIou;du.m , ~~ m~dllum pc«-mdi in Angdi5 po(U~t ahunde:lnClp~c '{wrn ex; motiuo fupcrbi.z. It orca pnmum dn:o dfe fete e~rcum ~ n:lJll :di'lui ~Il~ con.m. hlnt all_ign:~1:' ~r~ peceato Ange~ Ii ~ ahqU! luxunam. ;ali'lul InUJdiam. Q.!!i lU:l1l-< riam al1ig~ar:nr liOn ddu~run~ inte:t' antiquos. Patres. qU11Er1am camaiem luxuriant Angdis ttibll~nl~t.(ic t~t'li.::ames mud Gen:{.6. Yidmtu {iliJ DIf Ji/IAiI hMJ1illtJm , &e. de quo Vldcti potefl Ta'lullianut lib. de ibl"''''ri~ ,.,.Ufianriuslib. 1. III~ P#1II.& ..... & aJiJ.Fonall'c anriqlliorc:s hi DoUorC$ c.z;iltinutUl!t Angelos C:OfPora hlbcre , lid" fubti* Jior.3 nol1:ris,d= quo ~gimUI filT'J. Jifj.lg ",.,t. 1. In ~(enti Calmn a~uenll hos Pmcs qUi tic: intripretan(unc locum, Ilium Gcne(cO!, Angel6rque in commi~tioncm camalcm cum Iili2blu hDmintUn .

IMII,;'S.Thlll1J. ifJ 1. pllfl.D.Tb. TamilS a1U1t

A1'II(. IJ 1.-

4S'

(ecidHfe cil:iGimam.tlt, nequjqu~m ,1oqUI de pee.

C3tO ptiltl~. dlaboli,qllando de "do e:uurbatu~ rCh nee enim ignorarc pomerunt i1li Panes , quod ilia rtmpate quo Scrlplur_a oatr:l.t olio'Dd appetiilfc fili:irllm hominum c6cubituffit Iam Diabolul,.pCC.C:1uera.t, Cum iIIud fa¢lum Scriptur:l conngilI'e l1:1.tret PQa rnubiplicarum genus humanem ; Dill." belum vci'o [sm peccam~t&: a. c:l0 fuitre e.xclufurn CUm ex eius ttmationi: ~ &. fuatione primi Doad parente! peccarur.ignofare. nuilus potdi. Q!!3pr<i'" pter ,Peca.rnm boc. primum Angdi catnllli! Immtii fuilJe,nemo quAd (dam rOtUff Cendte. Qsomodo verb loewille GcncJisde6liis Pr:i.& lHlabu$ha~ minurn Intellig:endu$ J1tJdiximu~ (itlltlJ Jifp .• ;.

Alite.1: c;'So lUil:uriam Angells :ltffibui[ SCOtW fit 1.Jij1,G.q.:t.ncrnpcnofl c.:irlialem t & pfopriam~ fed fpiritUilJem. qua pst nimium ;mOt~m, &: d~le~'tationein de proprio decore. &. f~lidtm" 'luau luxuriance vcnujfarc' ptOpri.:l. dde£far;fuDt. quod . {npi:rbiilill imptopri:;!m dr~ putat > propriam yet! (:tlpidirarc,&luil:llria fpirituale circa foum dC'corcm.

. lnuidiam fujaepecc;~rum Angeloruin dDcu,rUt non piluc:i,lici!t noil ita dare tXpUccml fuilf~ primf, PC:(:C:'ItUIn Angdi;'1uOd ~njm ex primo ptt~alO (upCfbia: fuerit pe:ccad'i inuidia: {ecurum,ncgari non porcfr.nec .~~T .~cgat=Et ScrlfCu.~ ;lp~cerdhiur. quod lmlsd.lR. D,,,,bIJ!t tlJlll"J mfT'-lIlt rn mllnJflm. Aliqui autt:(J1 hocptCc:mlln inuidi~ c:xpik:mtfll.iC. fe illuidi:lln "sa bominc~, 'It dedutitur ClI S. C tpti~lno (lpHfo.dl !f.f/u & "U~YflTl:nulli:lneJi P4,itrliie«: f .Bafilio in flrrllf1f1t J, i1lI#;II';I, Irena:o lI!'.",~. 78 .Ali; flli{f e inuidi~ er~ iprum Oominllm Chdfrum,eui dignimc:m 'TnEOn!; hrpO(lafi~ inuidc:::funtJlibiqae immoderate apptdctunt~qu(ld ckdud vidertu· cl: S.Bernardo hllflf. J7.iIJC"'I'.IIf4",dlupcnG~ . &: aJlif.quotum (cnrcmilim qUl1lltom lid I1ppetiwt,IJ y~iOl'lis hypolbci'Z {C'~ubur Gi'21la4m tYIIli;, ,. Jifi.:,foO. 4'3r. yrob:abiJem tc:pu,~~ Suar~ Itb.?

'"F. f ~.~ plulibll$ ConfiriIlaf. '

Clifcrum communis fcmtntia amibuit AJlgdis 1 Ii pc!ct:.1.t!.lm Cupet biz. ita quod iIIud fnctit p[lml;lm~

&. inirillm a:rerorllm. ita fent~anr ,"ommWlitet Thcologi cum Magillro in :,.diji'na.6.& D. T no. b:C'l.6~.an.~. \fbi vid~ri pOlfllnt inrrtpmes. Vi~ dc:amur ibi C;lic(. D~nc;z, Zllmcl, NJ:tariu5, Cumelirani Salmamkcnfc.'1'IIt1.6.4t ./Jngtlu.difp. (0'. dHbl.Vafq d~[P.t;1.(IIP'1' SII;lnz J,b'7.J~ .Ib'gdi; 1i.8,rsfo'l1' Granados 'IIbi ["PT;r jiEI.1.17.+ qn J eii. oppoutam lemenriaJII rcmerariam ",o,at. Lunatt auto» hoc ex Scripmta.&: Pambus:n enimfHpt~ IJOtilllimus.Scrip,ura ponit fllpm,ii pro initio emnis pccca.d)Ecddiaft. 10. & Tobj~ 'I' ip(um "!:1m pcccitilm Angdi. qui pfjmU5 intcr imcllcttualu "c:llum P("ldi[,liquidc n rim {uilfiQBC pe'u~ ptimlU hOIll.o,(uper~.2m fudk Iignjfi'2t~lu<m i~ ~fo loto :,.adTuD.~.N ImJ ftLf,.,bu~711 tl4IH4 ,rz 111Ji(1117R iflci4lft Di.JJoJi. JU in aliisJocis vhi fccundum con;JUilln¢m apoJidoni fttmD eft de Di~bolo, licit C!lb l:igur~ diotum principllm,:!putc du! pe'C2ulm cli-drur (upubi;!, ) vt Ezc,h,"1S.t/(IR1Mm tji,~ t.vm

in AI,Ut; I1mJfuW r4.Il..I#q$JltU miJiJl~ Jl ulll Lfldfn' • fill 1I11Z11' wieb6ril, 'Jffl JinPM in (".ae ttM:.

. /" cttlflm U1Z[m,JiIm ~ [up"" liP.,,, Dt; tX,drU6 f~

lillTn 71HHt;J ,1I{umum [aptr Idti,HdwltJt ,",bIBm~ IimUu n'1I.AllijJimlJ. Vndc; S. AmbJauQJ ,,11.',.. inquit ~ I}UOd SiNe in IlIpf» 'Z)iabf/i .I"~ m ,.,"~ ,ic.;iIn, 1nmi11i1 t 'nififl7/J pt~.fi jiipemtS ,ft • .k AllguJi.u • .u t;ifJIj/. (llp.6./lIiliHm inc)1nt ~__, f"ellli [fI,ttlnll. Ri~ pimIN J.jtElfR, ffr prim. i-.pi4 • pmmlmflit vlIJ_· liN; TilIIII'~. ~ , •• mf

&'r1"fIlUM ~ 'fit tt#tI f-Ij/lt. Vtd~ndllJ eft ~ tihus ill '#fU' ~.II.iI~.J d/. 'Vt7'b~ ; Dw l1!IIIPifl

LL 1,. 1"1"

J

460 fJ.i41.LIX.ffc. De meri/~~e; pitcdloAngeloruin.

Jijp~r ord~tm t:117ZtIlmtiiojUm,ct fuptrbnm.GrcgoriuJ dixit S. Thomas, Non ergo t:I.kslra Jine,patnon~ ,

lib 17.mor~liflm t:4p.J~. ~JJb.:'J.MP'4'. Hier~ny,?' repugllabit Angelo; Cl.!!dd Ii dl~_pe"~t3. Angelo

lib,z.lIrlutrpu /Duinil1f11lt;1&llf+ C~tdl~ Jjb.G,f1J nonrep!lgna~mergo pC:'lue,eoru~,~ou.Il~.& CO~ ..

Jliltf/rI,tJHtJlp.6.Pro(pcr in a,miJj" mlfP",16 cAp,l,& ~equcmc:t neque tepugna.b", a~ ~Il~ ~clpl:rc",!llli

2..& in lWYII de 'UiM,&IIIflunpialiud '~p.;, Befnatd~s I.btrtarcm ha~Angelll~ me,p,cndl pc:ccarc:~qlla ..

flrm+.it ,Aftr:17fJllfit. & ali; phm:s. Ql;lz omll~3. cumque mate~ot,_(:u o~u::d:o ,n7e b~bct allqu.ant

fidIidclltct p[obant de factQ accidUfe 10 Angebs r.cce'!lurc_m mc,p1cn~ it [Ilpcfb,a,. .~. I

pcc~arllm (lIpc:[bi~. , :, .. Ndll,lolUln~(entenna~,Tb.V~;l~lltl!mo~d;t; 1&,

, Q!!od,y~ro fucm (lIp~bla propna diCl:a,fiOlllu- (ed priUS expllcalula.Et enU espllt:auo conliillt IQ.

):uri:!. ilLl tpinrualis .. quam !icarus po nit. m~ife~~ dllob.1lS. . , .. . .. . .'

deducifUI;tUm cx Ipfa propritEatc locUtion1s Serl- ,PII!llum. quad JoqUlrnr S. Thomas de Angelo

P[u,~, & 55. pee: enim dicendum ell; tam fre- IUxtaluum connamralem?,"~Unl, & licutdc (&0-

queol¢s locutiones. improp,ri;as clfe ~nc fLtllda. ao 'tea(~s .ell plenus, faplI:nfl;l. & pcrfeflu! dc~

menro valdc vrgenu, quod 10 prz(t;nu non arp1~ cere • vr dlc:anu: E:ztC~u:t. d. V nde Ciqaimf quod

%Cr, Tum quia lib. dddlatio qU;lr(l ponit Scouu nnn po[c.at pecarc: III ~ppctCndo ,Jeu dr.GdcMl~

!lirc~ propriam pulchri(udlnem. &. ,amorem ,~d ~~i~fici~o mode aliquid,quodGbide~lfcr a, bonis

iilir deit"Cfatio de propria, cxccl!enrla CU~ r~blt:- tplntliahbus • qLlla plt:nu~ ,rat (imm~us ~I~ qu~

aione ad Dcum • vel line Ilia. 51 cum rubled:lonc: ubi debebanrur j Et fie eX pane boni (p1fltualit

ad Deum non Nit pCcCatlim • crilmfi (uerit vehe- quod ddidcratc porcrar (olum putfUt peccare de-

mens, ok [j1tenlll,quia dcleaado de piliebritudine. {id,ra~do aliq~ll? vltra propri:am mCnfUfaP1, ~ .

& de bono quod in fe bonum c:1l.dummodo non vIm Id quod hbl debebatur j &. qoo rt~ plernlii~

fir conn2 przc:epulln Dei. & eUm dC~fdin3don~ ;\ quod [,.cnina lid in(lrdinatum morUm proprilC cr.-:

nile non d1" pec,atum • ,um dele l13no fit (0011:- celh:nuol::. . .

qutnsamorem de: bono pr3:fJ:nci.li~ur qui dddb.- S~cundum ell , quod O,t:hom,n~n negat plQ~

tUt de plllchriUldioe Vltori'.aut de propriO decore. u aha pca::ar:l protter (upcrblam pone cG'e in An~

/k C:,pientia referende ilb omnia ad DtPID., non gdQ! fed loquiul,' de prim~ pecc • .aro, q'lantilm ad

pcccat ,Si autem ddcll:ams ell Angelus de Ilia pul- DlOrluum ; & obled:um C1I1 Illlimur Angc:lus:lwc

.:hritudinc, (inc: fubicllionc: ad Deum , hec fuit enim docct nondre aliue qlllm nioriuum inor-

propria (upetbia. quia apperirlls fupCfbi: proprii! dinar~ cxccll~Driz: • lic~ polito ilIo motiuo, Ie

,(umptlls eO: appaitu5 inQrdinams propri:t t"tel~ pccc~ro poffi~ W3.m ad ali:l. declinarctc:aquC! eo~

Imli;t tine fubiedlone ad fll.pCriQrcm > Yl docent miteere. V nde ill1.,J41. u. ["fr. elt"'if inquit D.. ,

Thcdogi cum :i.Thoma Z,1-,q.llh. Complacere Thom qt10d AIIDI'IITn Pfcc""rlfm 1Jt:t:.ji~ il,/t8ru

;I,\lttm; Sc'deledari de bilc IpC;} exeellenria, de bop ."q"u tJfo fo/ft. fo/~ 11"' r"ptI'hiif ~ft If". r"nu..

nore.de dil.liriis. &c. non foldE (pedalc: pC:CC3tum mm;1i1TJ tX p.rfiEiiMt {limit. Vbi S. Doaor Ola~

IUlmda:: ,qui.l ;;Iclc'b[io. (ell volupras de eo. ill nifell:a iodiear (e loqui de motino • (eu fundaDlen.

'1110 pece.uur. ell v alde gen~rlll~ CondItio pro om.. to ad pecc:andum in natura purtCl,), qUlllis eft

nlbu~ pcc:cads,. Omni3 ~Ilim pCCC3~l nUnt cum Angelica. q!lal non mouctur ad pccc~dum .per

quwm ~plctlone prOprliE' volununs. q~ velu- dr:feduID, !cd per cxcclfum • & (mODe! a11m.

Fras qua:dam c: !I:,o!k dcltd:atio, Tunc 3Uto!:IJ1 dl lu- ius p ~rf(:aioDis , &; excellCDtia: intkbitz,& eJ:ce(.

"grla d~rc:rmip:lfe.qU3nJO ell in m.uerh intc:mpc- fiu~.

ralltiz circa (mlibilj;l bona, prot[errim venera in Rati{J aurem huius fumitllt. tum n: ipfa 1:1am· Ii

qinbus ;tlJimus dlJD..lit: in rcliquis pCC'c:!n5 dele- ta • &: modo (;Olnn~tllrali operandi Angeli. tulJi

&alio c:A:.(ed non Im:l.lrio'l, Edic:inordiil;!ws aIDor ex tolinjope oppoliri fundamo:nri> otkndcndo,.

p[Qpriz aC'dlenti~ ill Ang do foit ip toto rigorc quad licet alia pecc.tta non te:=pugnen, ArtgelD~

VCfa fupt:tbia, nee tr.l.l1llulir ad fpccicm Juxutilt: tepllgllant ramen c:l1"e primii motiuum ad pecesn-

dclcQatio hu.ie amori annen > qll~ gcncralis con- dG..Ex ipf ... natura,&' conp;ttuuli modo preceden-

ditio cli in peccatis. di in Angelo fUflli[urra~io ell iam!lIpr"inllnu,uiJ.

1 I Circa {ec:undum verb, quod. diximu$ centre- qu i:t An gelus non pnrdl peccare. nili incipiendo

ucr{um eLfe in hae pme > ncmpe an fucrit a1:ud "olitionem ab aliquo line 1 licut iDcipit cognitio-

mariuulll. qllo po~et Al'Ig.elus pc:ct;'lfc. in p.rimo l1~m fii~m a prin~ipii5,Finis autc~ debet ,cffc ali ..

peccato quhu rnonuum (tlperbl~ • (cluenu.1~. quod bQI'lIIn"J. CUI Angdus affic13EuH 6111$ enim ~.

Thomz ell DOn fuiJI"ealmd mor:iuum qulm Cllper~ dl: id quod 3ppetiWr tarionc:1ui) lie cillS gr:u:ia ....

bi~lta~umi[\u ex bis qua:: nadir ;11 h.(~'1.6).~,~: appc.tuD(ur al!a. Non potell: au~cm Angclnsler

&:1Tl",Jj.P·f.IJ,14.;.B(;!g~ndo de peccaropnml (cpnmo alIiCl adb!1numfenfibUe unquama fi~

bominis in ;.Jjp.i1'9.I.ATt.I.4~ 4. & lo.1. 1] •• 6;. nt=m. quia Il!;tn ell: 6bl propOItiOnafUm • Ilcqnc

~. [..d [.eli- ;. Vidc:rliJ.ne pOtcll: Caiet. jn p",{tntj t:Qnuenil:ns : finis. aUtem :lppcrhur v-c: coDlleniens.,.

,.,6;,b"1,1.&: ibi (:ommunil:ct Thomillz,Rc:fraga- 3: bonum ipli. appctcnn : dcbuir ergo dl"c: bonum

rut vaO hu.ic fcmd\tiz V afqu~ Id QlPltntnf;!rio aliquod fpiritltlle circa quod ranquam finem op~

hllill1""1'.& Auubo1l b~ Jlff.'.17S.". I.qui plnr~ alia retur Angelus. R.tlrli. us bonum fpiritualc (c:cnn~

pctQta aBig1l~.qllc Angelo c:oRp.rnucpoll'unr. dum fe l:onfornlC: ell: rationi. bee ilIi ConuariatQr.

hcut: d\ p~l1lm omilliollis frangendo pr;rcc:pta fiCUE in nobis bonum Cenfibile quandoquc ratio§

.sitnwiu;i·pa:awm odij t :l1lt dt:(p~ruionj$ ,aut Jli non {ubiicitlU'. fpiritllalc: autem bonum de (c

ino~dicatiZ'~ lJuia ~ p~ccata ~Dn '.olul1l, Yerf:!oI~ ra.tioni ~Il c:onfonnc , llc conucllfens;quia (pirir">

'tu (Ilea maten:lIfi fcnfibdtm. fed enam ~"lIC:a CPl- Ie ell : (olum !lUmB poteR: reddi Inalum kcun-

ritu~em 1 -" Gc hon lCPuglUnt AngdQ. hem elga dum ql!od excedit merifuram 1 Deo conllituum; boJDiues non rt:pus~nt quOd Angeli commiu:mt & fit: appwroI inQrdin.:ua. • feu. vita debifum

pecca~Utn iuiDltiti& occidcndlJ illos.aut m;lla: tta- ordincm. Et cUm Angdus produ&us lir pe~fe4

,41ndQ J 'IdleS (U2S l3DE cti~m peccattun inuidiz B:U$ • &: plcnu. omni pcrfedione ubi deblt~> noB

eOfUm ell:C:cUcnoz ipuidcndG.Pccc:aruaU ttiarn ib- pota~t inordinate :!pptttre acquilinonem carum

o~lldi~ non ~pugniil: AngelO'. qQia noncft de ia-I petfetlionulIl fpirirlialium. qua: tibi dehentur. v.

none IrZqu.Dd6rpalUo:iippemus{cnlitiui, fed [0.. g.(ciemi;e. Be eognitionis circa quam-Vitio eu";

lillnquOd tiuppctiw vindi~Ylr.,prA 1.10,111'.1. rioliuris'laboIUcr. SolUm ergo poPlir :i.p ,pna:c

, ali'lllcm

· \ - ;.DifJutati':X.JflfL" Arlie.lll.- 46"1

allqutmJDodum eJ"cclJentiz inotdinatU1ntv.g.(:ic. j;i~U5.& dircofill~i~ll$apprell!:.nclit.llr.Cb!od Yct3

Q poten'iam.~ & ho~ro,aut (uperioremJcitll'" prum ~pprehcn£iode Dec • prlZCcrtim. innatar&

fiam apperendo idquod fibi non dcbebatur ,alit perfeUa. & perfeac jilu:lligemc, (.CUE en AngelU$

1300 eo modo 'lllo de.bcba,ur~ v·g. cilmaliqllll fin- Ut apPfchcnllo Dei Vt difa;!Hutniends.omfi!no 'Ii-

gulariEate pc,-uli.lid.:1Ut ctlm ii1dep~d~nlia ab alio~ ceUfr c:ontra modulli eius tonqatutalelU •.. V rule S.

nl cum aliquo gcnu~ non fubieCljonis ConnaOf- T ha.1,.1.qtol. ~ ... mj of- dO-eel ideo' ~jum nOfidr.

dill:ltioncm Dei t quod tatUm pertiilet . ad {lIpet~ .... iliuQl capitalc. quia ilPfJ eft primum ill.detltl1-

biam.qu:I: ell apperitns snordilntz exccUcnti&,(cu alone: vifUl£um.(C'd. vJcimum;& fie paull; ell pee.

pl:rfetlil;lDis. A b ill" ergo dcbuit ineipac: ntDtiuum catum Hm.lc: ,!uhn ,;apicalc,feu inidalc-, fllpponcn$

pCCC:lti. in An.g~lo, flquidem im:_(C~iE ab aUlJuo a!~ (anUm cosmplionc:1ll in {Qbi~~ .• ~POtd! ab

fcall arc, {flmualc &onum; {ell cxc;:UcmlaJil :.116 co fllmmum bomtm apprchmdi vt di(cOOUCInCus.

qllamtqll:C Inordinafhppeticur.. .. fubic-a:o;: ho~awcm line 1li~~acottupijoncJicd

Qaarc nOD htgamUJ. multa alia pceara pode non poccll, & rUl'pan~o in fllbif:ftQfr~cc-4c.tQ

eire in Angelo, quz fpiriNaUa funt" fed negaInuJ alia pl'l~ j. e~ qlloriim(Mppgli~ej. & aff~Jl"

poJfe modo connaltltali prz:bere Angelo. priinum DeUI conl:ipilUf·:vtdifcornwn_ .. qtlia,«ill~nll:

motlullmpc(.cali~i;. qllia eX a1iii pc~,adJ mul,u V'ticonrrarii:l1 {ubiclto •. ,Nofi.C9dl:ipintt_.i9av»

{imt I quz prz(lIpponunE aJi;i peccata pra-:cellillc" cOiifraritJJipli naUI!Zja1lI p"&aidnieill,~;ciDJ he

vel {altern mOf!IIUm aliquod pcccatDit:lofum ~ (q.,- erimi1iiieiuJ prillfipiu!1Jt¥IiQtbm-iOdut":.t6"C';fcd.

pCtbia. ve.o ell ~ptilfim!1ro. ~ congtu;cntiJlimum (olum cqnppt:pord}·v( :coiUratiUl;' ~clin quan-

mcdlnm ..... r 6t primum.motilluro pcccandi in An",: tum infeft mil.a:pQ:~. $ bzaiamlilpposmnt(U[.J

,elo ~ quia fempa priJiiurn mOliullm p«amdi in pam. vel quaccnus prohihtt ip6 mala cWpz j & fie.

Angdo debet elfe es aJiquo line, & bono cui alii· ex affetl:tI ad illamala.qqlE p.ohibCf~ Deus neon-

cianlr ti & hoc non porell e-di: ;diquid corpOfale. trllriu$: •. ,at di!fonlls cOBcipi;lIr , Qdioquc fwbenll'.

i\1ia nen dl: propcntionanun natllt;E (pirituali , &: Sed boc jam fupponit :11ia.l\'lwculpz.EIIi,odill~

perfdtz ~ lieuE eft: Angela;, vtaflicintur illi tan~ nunquam ell peCCatll1il c!'pitale.& primum • quod

'lUlUU proprio bOli.o;exc;ellcnda aul~ proF.ia isn~ vCff;l,ur erg:a: aifc:Atlm cl6nc:m. (cd cft. pcccaCU5I1

modtta.te. lie: 'lura dcbium mcn[u~ volir.!;c:1l: finak'(w vlmnum fupponcmdia pec;cara, Clt'lai.

pori ffiaJlUn :ltttactiuulD, & alletl:iL1ullI UAtUrZ ira bus IDOUCtUE: 'luis ad ;pprchtndcndum DClJnI vi:;

perfett;£" • & fpiriEU)1lis. n'Di en: An_gelic~ 111114 ditfDDlJm t &. connarium Ilbi ~ qni~ velprobiba ...

ergo tnt primum. ml,lfjllum ~ ~ ilbufefr inoriuum vel punit i1la.peccata quibu;.qui$lf1i'ifur. .

CUferbiz. . Ad ea qU% obii,iuntIlf pro pee-ClIo; q~ vet- If

14.. E" '1110 fc::CClud~ rariD dedlicituc.qllz ell eriam, (;Ullin circa homines. Q!!od ~dnet ad pccata ill':"

folUtltl fllod.un.cnri oppoliti. nempe difi:IlCTc:ndo iufiiriZ';didmlP.·durlj~itc:r RAJ commiui.Pdmo 0;'

circulia pccc.tra.& oftc:ndendo quod,olUUfurali eo 'luodaJiqlli, 'Vule acdpere aliena in (omm~

modo lO'luende non. przbellt de (c primum ·m~ dum proprium, "tunc inh~l1i,ia nard",:r a iocr.-

tiUllpl pecl:.3ndi. Naill in primiJ pe-CC2PJm omuna.. dinafo ~UDotC.& conl;upiKCijfJa (lIi.SC:(Qndc\ e~ co

nb per (e • &: rationt fui non pri'tDCC F.imllrD mo- quod ;lliqui:f vutrCll!m in incommo4IJdl (ell noc,,·

tiU1I1Il pr:tCUldi.quU dc'fe ell n~gatiolcu priuario~ mentum ;literluf.1k lndemoue'w: ~ (agendum d

& it appttanlf debet yetliriali'lllO bono apparcn~ iniwiam 'ontl~ futlitiun. PWIDO modo nOD pm-dl

li.& aliquo Gne.r.lIione c:uins non m:ur:lt quiJ fta- Angelus velie- iniu ltitiam • feu jniuriam DC"&:: Ju;,.:-

.llioriun prlr(:rpri: ergo ip&. ominio»OP eft pri. mi?i .. i~o ncc.ltn.:ri Angc~. qnia_DOB poteti ipl.

mwn motiuumpe!;can3i.feu primum cui afficj p'0- c'_ JhlIltnS homlnllm nue U ii«tPUI?IlC faaOJm~

tell Angt:l'l$ tan'luam filli.hem odiupl I)l:i,& de- rum, vel ilJriom,aut '11 quibDC,umque- ipGU5 booif

fpcutio ncn potdl eonuenire Angelo. nih pr~w neri dilior,& comiuodior: quid cnim (ommodira-r

fiJppofim ;aliquo priori pccnto. [:l.rione cuius t~d- tis libi prollcnire poteR: C'4 bonD {m6&iIJbus Ito.-

~t dilfonum!:ius ditbrnini id quod. habftur mini5.aiw ipCc< Atigelm (pirittnli$fitiSx bom.fav-

odio. vel a qllo defpcratut. V[ S.Thomas aduttrit tent ciUi (pirimalibus nIhil porc~i funipae. atlE jp.

~(I fop,{uil.6:1: :..JJfI+'114. t.Art.;_ non enim m- iulliti:l.ln c()mrnim:re drea dla. quia non pqifon(

,uid lubemr odio.uec defperatu, ab ille, niu quia homine inuilo pefdi, nee roam (0. voJ¢mc fO(~

confideratut [eu iudiCliulf \1'[ dillanum. ok dilcan~ fUDr Angelo accrc-r'tre'J ~ propr~ iptim fini. Er

uenicns fibi; l" ficodio h:!bctur. Er hoc: ideO' eft. idem ell refpcc!h13lionlm Ailge.forum in bonis

quia odium, lie: dcfpuatio patine", ad qumJam fpirinwibtl5 corum. S«undo vno modO' F0ldt:

fll gam·voluncatis, qilarenul aliquid ;sppre bmdiuu· qUlde-m AngelllS nonre hamini, & iniofiiu:im fa

" dj[cOftucnie-1J1 veltl(lciuumj. 6( ti, Don amaUlr,· i1Jum comrniuerc. '" fonalfccdamiD ·~ngdQfP. ".

fed abominatione t vel inimicicia pfo{equinJf~ aut g iprOID vltta modum affiigendo.&- vtll:ando j fcd'

iudicatar ~t imf'4?6ihiIc adipifci. & fie non pro{e~ rale pe:'C;;Imm fllppolJitodlum~ &·maleuo!~iatp~-

quirurillud Cpa-led abitlo dciiciun,vcl fugii1tt,& «ga b(ltni~$conrf2. 'lUlU mouenl •• fiquldm:i~

hoc en defpemio. V nd1aqmglUt quOd Ange. lUI appedtU noecndi f:Jcit injllIiam • & hOCitcPUll fA:

inde illcipiarpec:arifoiPloriOllm,tumqoia odium~ pe~tum fugz.&abo~tiODj$t&: ~c dim3nitfti .' ~

&: dcfpcnrio pcninent ad fugam.non adaifctfum,: volirionc priori aliculDI linis ~ POD «go PCnJulD

Be pIorec:urioncrn.primum mtmnnorillum in .A~ p«CittliD cll iniulliti2 •. Dc inuidia aiim di,im~

gdo ~ft e~ a.jfctlu d,clt aliquem fiDem.{en &onll'M .:tim D~TIutm~i1Shlle q •. t>"'"t~l.cit.fl1" t~ i:J;,.!

quod fibico~ucniens appfmendic:6nismim \!'t fi~ f. quOd mgidia eft- dolor :lliei'l;EprQf~ris iii

~j amJlur.110n fugiUlri,1k Angelus in amorc finis: quaDtufD tll,infpedidu:l aIicuim bonJ'pWpriJ.Nuf·

Imgit ea qua:; (e lubet1t ad Jincm • non (eOI(unu Ii ~feJiciras ntquc Dei • ne;uc ahe-cluJ bo;.; lum ergo primwn motluum. " alfttlus finis dI; m JDin~ut Angdi eft inipcdiUu boDi prOjdI ipliu~ f'llga:rumquIa fl DC'll1 babcatllt odio,vd deCperc-· Angel4li 'IditoL: bOlluM pwpriDJP eo lJ1OcL:iquo

uu:-.dc:bct:zpptthendi n dUconnmjtn$. Non :ill- fibi 1 Dco· coUarum eft: 2 & cum {ubictlio!JC: ail

tan 2pprebcnditut DmntdifcOQ.Bc:niem niG C(Jf~ Deum, qg.i cliRribui, vnkuique" jD1ra JIlodum fibi

r-upto iam iudicio; & ulem fuppouendo :uudio- debinuD~Vndt (olum pofell aJietla. fdirn:u iIDpc:.

Qcm a& ip(o n aliis etfeaiblU vet atfdl:ibus.vr in~ dite bonum proprium ADgdi wQrdinarc VOfi(um,

"fOni:l"lUiudic:ill.m~ quo ~ Pm Ipfe VUIO-: v.g.nip(nIlIHK .. fm~a1!'l!lO bOlloJIt(u.

- Lt. 1 J ,"

per on'lnu gife. nee aliquem ubf pra:fcrd, etiam ex Dei ordinatione ~ & tunc inuidiam habere potell:; {cd fupponemern dcordjn~doncm p(i£c~dcnu:m circa aliud bonl1m;8c hoc ell: rllpponc:rcahud pee~acutrlJquod vtiquc ell: (upetbia: • ~um Gr citc'~ ~X4 cdlenriam p~?pria.m, ~ui opp.onulit bonum a~l~nUIll'qultCnUS impedlf proprlUm alit lipgulantarem clus. E.t qua.ndo diqt S.Dafilius in homiJjlJ d, il1u/di", q Ilo!ll oM idi~ implJl't pYI11t:iptm Pl4[orum DII.17I0llfflJ lid ~eUIf$.r quod ellam alii Sanai affirnl311t, dicfmu~ verum efle quod ad ~ellum cum homine,i",puli~ ilium inuidia. Sed banc.pr:uelfctat·pc.cat\1mfoperbi:2 comra Dcum. Nee eft mc.n~.l.1enienAJwiJd'in;codem inllami. licllr~ !lun.' n-lOa~'lin\UL Ang..Jui:dc: propria .n~dl.cnmt niolls ddo;4rtar;. .,t!.:;:d.:aticno bono.ttillcmr,& ecrrodatlldIiWSjIJJo:xdC"~, q'lia Ill] a.jfct'hl~ (unt citea diuet'f~ t!1ih::fb;Sc ·fic non pag~~inrc.~ fe. .'

Ad ca qii~ .,iicllntUt de jt~. an rep'ISIl't Angelo,dicimils D.Thomam. jf1h(lt:q»~(iJ' ;lrtit:.;z..ad l. exeledere 'Irsm ab Angelo,' quia dicir p.'ffioIJ~1;[i corporalcm. Oe.ita.vt:ro,qu~ cit Gmpltx voluntatil a tfc a:1.15 appl:umds vsndlfr.lln lint: p.ll1iunc eorpor~linihil d'~itjl{:d hoc 11011 ita Gur:c fuit l).Thll~ m(.quia ira ilb. quz ell /implcx affetlu5 volunratis. habet I;ltiOIlC!U auerficnir , & fugx rclp~ctu pc:r[Qn:c in qua\l'i appethur Yindlfra. Vndc non ferule ralls h:t pro rnoriuo primi ~ifet.l:U5 c:rga fi· nem ,ui affici[u[ operans . quia rlli$ ;Iif;.:a:us debet efle Iine fuga,fcd p~r p[oiecmionelll ~ &: amorem.

. Vl1d~appctitw vindid-a: non (croit pro primo P~'Ctto,(ll.Iia dl:.c:rg:rfincm ddidcr2rl.lm • /Jl. volitllm. quia c:!t finis otiuS:gtaEl3 ea:tcU 3ppCfllntUr.

. D~ vida c~Jrioliwi$ non ell quod illudanri· bu.lOlUS Allgdo in flatu quo creatus ell: plcaus fa- piellti~: Sfc enim non.lubuit quod defideraree inquirere circa cognitiollC"m libi poiIibih:m > & conIl.lturalem. quia Angelus nOR baber fcientiam acqui!i~jl~d Ihtl~tOl.m.& apinirio,pcJfeli:.1:n. Curiofitas alltCm dt virillm in cxcelliuo Il:l.lliio ;Icqlli. Jcndo:t ,og~itiODis fupc(Bu~. em:;! eognitiom:1D VCIQ (uperJi;lt!lf;llem p.>lIct III Angc:lo dfe virium, Ii dcudcrarct Cup~liore!'O {j:i~llti;un habere comu. utJ1I\ttndilIinum. & line [ubiedione ad Deum. (lllmcx(ubicaioneac3 ip(um~ &: fubordil!ltCad mum. pcccattnn non "ft.) Vell!: autl:an (d'ntiam fliperio[cmJinc Cubieetione. o'Id. Dcurn plus h.bct de fupcrbia, quam de CUl'lolimc ~ qui ... Angtlus,li qu~dibi inordilUte .lpp~t~ret. non to'lm ~tTct f~itc. qU;lnl e:itellerc.lic:ut cum EU~1Il ttl1raUlr de appc· tirll (dtntiz. magis.ibi cxprellit ddid~til.lm cx(;ellenti~. qulin ;lcqllilidolltm nOliri:c.di(ells. £~idd foB' Dij.!'imIU. Sic ergo 6 jJ appcliir Diabolu5, m·agis~ppetiirin,ilI.l.(ci~ri;a. (upttiorimcm. /jl e>;· c:eUentlAtJl. (UiC (!1blCe1:lOne ad Ow In • quod eft wo,iuum propriil1ilT!llnl (upetbi;c ~ tUI per accidens eft q!lQd fit in materia fcicl\ri~ > .vel pot~ntj~ • :jjlt ho~oris ~ vel cuillft\UIlque aherius cxcd-

. lcp.ti~ .

l' ... Mhuc ~mcn obiicies c:omea notlmm 4;onc;lu~on~1l1 ~d . proh!ln4um qudd non fueri, propIie J\\Qliuum (llpetbior primum pc:ccar.um Ang.c:li. Be i~ faui.m::1'!1 S1;oti : N;u'II in primo p~cc:.tU! Angdu! 11011 rl:rpWt f~~::r.t:D,r~m voliumill(um.pu:eUb ~.iill. ~ pon.r ~),i~i (up~fio~i • fed CglUm ranquam conditioli£Pl iliuiw; rt! vDIil:z. qULt c,a. voluir 11& bl inh;trtrc: ~ 'Vt vldmo ulli; aucflcndo (I:. '" non lilbiici~do CeipG Dco • quOit vtique nl1D p~rtin~ .1d fpcciale pe-catum Jilpcrbf;c.fcdcfi conditio ,t;Cft h=li$ . cukd·cuil.HjUe pl:,c.1ri impoHo'liitis auerbo-

ntm 1 Oto. VI,1 utcro eJI'~t Cpeone peearUJD {IJpl;,bi.t'~ofOIUtb;u 'iliad non falUm n coll,!lWo~Ccd

§2.i!N.ft.LlJ{. E1c. De. meriiD~ -fS fectato.:Atif;ilorum.

Vt te~'ybli(a . attingerctudpCum nOli rl!be~ [ltpew. riori,&" przc(fc·aliis .. Q.!!o4·l/ero. hOI;: non pomeri" elf.::- primurn motiuutn p:ccau, Angeli. probltllr.: qUIa vtdocct S.Tho.in hat qu.6~. ;lYI.iollid~. An..:: gdus non p.\':Ccauit eligendo malum ex p:liU~ tel· ytliitz. fed·eljgendo mal~ ex patte inordinat:E c::le~ Chonis circa obietrum bonum.Ae noHe fllbeJ1c (i1-~ period u: aCdpi~mr Vt res vo~i~aje1l: malum ob!e. dum,&: non {alum m~Ja conditiO ex parte ch:61aanis : crgoll(m potuidn primo ptccato eif~ pecea-

tum {ped~rc: [up~Ebia:'... .

Conf qlli.l·Angeiu5 nOil vult inordinaf;Un. & {l1pcr~uam I;x~JlclUiam fibi, nif; Cuppoll¢ndo di~ lcalQJl~m (Utt perfol:l~inordinaramjnan qUia proprie h~be:jC ad.[e amorcni :Ilnidli~ • fc.d qllia {e :lm~r W primum diligibrlc: • & t,;mquam obitttum, !:ui vulr quldquid vult, Erquia te lIlordmat~ YlIlt Vt per(on3ID, &. obrdbufi cUI,ilko vulr ubi ci"cd. lenrlam filpcrBl.lamj vr pr;J;el1c :l.hlS,nOn Iubiici r uperior.i. In ho~ anrem quod e(l; inerdinaram excel .. klltl;lIu,yl'llc,ell peeC;ltum {upcrbia: r in "a vw:I. quod ell fe nirnis amarc ~t p~rtonam.& obittlunl cui, non ellJcet.uum nili fiimiz dclc:ll:a!:ionis do (ciplo ;quo. pttlincr ad peCGatum IUXUfi~ rrid .. tn~lis.fimr IDnitOlics homines pc:cc~nt J1iilii~m de~ 1t'tl:;uiohcJIl capiclldo de :pirnu;llibuJ.:&: nolcndo cis C;I[CtC, :lut [;i!tt::m (alum c:!I:~.geller:;ilis condido omnis·.pecc::ui quo;! procedie '" inordinate ~m(l~e (uj ; I!rgo in 1Jlgeli~ prl:celIir peccarum (up~tbi:z.. nimia dd£4,uio. '" awox (ui. qui cft libido fpiri .. malis •

. Refpon.quOd non' (ubiici (upetioli potc!l- Cumi . QQIl (ollnn vr res yolita primo. & per [I: (fie: enlm non(Q\um ell r!laluM,(ed pcffimum > &" vilJ: :lppe • dbilc: niU fiult~. & per ertorem] {c:d potdi fumi VI: mtldus,& condmo obieai volin. If,: aliqu:lIldQ po_ rtlt: c IIi; con ditio g:cn e[alH pccCarOrl.lffi. ali quando

I pccialis, v el peccati inC! bedlcll ti~ > vel petcari (Q.~ pClblz, Eft conditio gelle-ralls pcec:ari, quando 11 1I07l jHhii'i fumitUf pro C:Q qutld til non fubiici fu. - period Vr regulaI1ti,& menluranri alllllfacjQru5:lic: enlm omni pcccato moulIli generale dl autrri 1 ~eguh cui ccnformarl dtbet ;Iaio. Eli conditiO' fpeci<l.\is in pec::c::alo inob~di~mi~ quando reCl.1fat aliquis faterc: rem pr;fccpr3m. ex hoe quod ab ipro [uperiod prOl:dpfmc t it;l qllod 1101\ vult lubdl'e at. mi v[pta:cipicnti,& (IJpCrlori, VI docet S.Tho_l. 2..911.1°4' E.lt ~ondido Ipedalis fupc(bi:e. in qnaq.. tum rccll[at h!.Jiici fl1pcriori ex moriua exct:llenIi:r: propria: ; villt fllim I;"lIcdlen!iam fU3m ita ftt~ uui qllod nulli rt'pmcu1r infcriot , & Cll htle (ecq.. f.:1r lilpcriori (iJbdli: Y( tlccllens m;lnear;& fie plO~ ptie non vult (ubtlfe- rupcriori~vt tllcellemi, idcQ~ que v£ S. Tho. ""plic;1t 1.J.''1U.161"",.,.6.Superbiil pc:rllcnit ro hoc, VI aucrfiollcm qu~ ituc:!iquis pccC3!iS til confcqul:ns,ip(a hlbear pro proprio.qll;lh=:nm deducitll[ vfql.ll: ad contttnptum Dci .fcd hoc tatum habet Cub motiuo exeellemiz propri: • & comc::tnnit Deum.r~1I w:u(at iIIi (ubdlc. Vt c:tc~l~ lemio\i (c • in co in qllo Dcus vuh quod c.cattlrA fe repllter infefi(lr~m; & idem ell: d~ a1iis (uperio~ [fb!ls,qu~ltcnu$l;'x hoc vfdctut propria ex~dlC:lltia dirnil\l!i.fcn tlon fcru~ri.Dicimus crgo,quodad fu~ pc[biam non FeULner velie ipCum non (ubdI;: vi: rCOI prim~. & per fe vQlh:lIn. {cd Vt modum.fca: cOllditionem rc:ql.liGtatn ad p,op,i~m ClICc:llella (hun. q U.:1ttnus nan vulI (ubcn~ ~lteri; V& clE,d~ lcmion fc. & flc fub radone c=xccllcmi.e> & tnocillO illius fertur in nOll {ubefl!:·. feu adtnitfir ex put~ modi volcndi. & digcndi ~ ipCum no n [Qbc1fc.

Ad CQnf.R.efpon. quod ~Ie: amo. (qi E~nqu;lm. l'clloa<t:

Difputlltio XX/II. .Art. 11/. 4"

perCOnz primo ~ilc~:t nOR ~ontljt_ujtfpccia1e ~ec. • ~ec~~dum i~ c:uitando enotem Cpecutatiuum:'

.:.:r.turn.(ed cit prlAcli'mm clllllfcumquc pe-Ccan, vt In Iudiclo rcqililito. &, pr.r(uppofito ad pecc:aA.

fLlllliuU' ~x D.Tbo.l.l,qil.77-"''''·4. Ncql1c faJis tum. " -

lamor in"rdin;ltuS Cui en le:p:lr:nuJ ab ... mere rei Ii· -lgifur circa prinmm obieaum~ fcil.,lrca :t'qU:diM

biYoiuz contr .. pta-:ceptum Dci,rarionctl.1iu$ rna- t~u~m Dei. pun:erro O. Tho.cuppoDir ;1'1 il7't. j,b".

milt,lutnitUf (pc:cialc peceatutD moaom excellen- ilU '1".6,. qllod-DiaboJus appctiir effe ... ~ Deus. ld

fia propria,lDodoiD ddl;chdone eibi, .aut vCfii:risl enim manjfca~ detiucifur ex' SctiptUta. rum lui. 1I10do in, polfc:ffiofll:: pccl1niz, &e. aut III quacum- . I ol·vbi ex pez(ona Luc;ifc:ri dicieur. Afo,,,Jttm {",,,. que alia te,qua: vel [cc~tadli~ ciino~c~, &: fuga~, td'!'~d't1tm ""b;"m, [nnflu "" .:Altipi"!' ~ &. Eu ..

vel fccLJndum (:oncuplit:~lam amngltut, Vt ,b... cblebs 18.Elfii"Ut11J eft ~DY IfI",",& 4ixiji;, Dllu 'g-

t!.tm tioccr S. Tho.folllt.1Id J. Q.!!are ilia ddcltario, [1i1ll,r!r in f4,h,JTIJ Dti fiJi in mJ, 'llt1l'fi4l.J' J,Jjfti

&;: !ltnOt de (cipCo c~ generalil cOJid~rio. omni.' c~ tuum ~.liji ~(jT Dfi :hjni qUia Cupetbia D;tm,o"'

peccati.&: rcfpc:du C:1l1l~(cllrnqtle p~ccatl. ~t!;im oti'J 01$ exccdlt omnem fiomirium Cupetbi;iIU, cum 'di-

Dei,aut iniulHti:t taut umiditanS, &c. p'itell: f:ieti (amr ipft lifo Rex /;;p,ram11u jib" !IIFlTbi.t, lob 40'

idem argumentiIin quod orieur eX amere nimio er- conj1.at :lUreni quOd Amiebrilluf in cantarn Ct'il11l- .

ga fc ~ 6, del~ltalione (ui,ob quam vulr :diquiJ ilia pet (uperbi3I'!f,'Vt (jj1tNIW fo flfIJlJJlMii fit D~ 1.:ld .

bona ubJ,;un nimit amando,aut nimi! timcnd(l. Et ThelI'alonic.1. Ergo multO. amplius h;ii'c Cuperbia

iic probata ai'gummmm quod ptO olnni pecam locum habuit in Diabolo,vr voluetj, ipfc hilberi 'It

iotc:,uenirec pcc~atum IU1mriz. qiJia incC'tue-nie f~· OeDS. Ex <Juo manent etiam firma tefUmonia alia ...

quam mcriuum, & ongo nimius amcr fui. &: de- fa ex Ezechie le,& IC~la: liam Jie~t aliqui velim ilia

hl!fario·d;. (C'.Didmus ergo quod cum fpc:ti!1s pee-. loqllj ad littmm de Principe Tyti. vd de Reg.

~[orum dl;c.;rmil'l.:l.IIi, &: in {pc-dati non (umatUt ex B;lbyJonis,non de Di.lbolo, tameil ex hoc cecilia.,;

amore (ui,v( przcl ,,: tmninatur ad (e. vc iUI pcrfo~ cirut eeiam ad Diabolum pminttc::nam {j eiUf (Il-

nalU cui 'lui, bon 11m) fed u ipfa maceda circa pcrbia e:t(;elli~ q!.1orumcumque homInoID ("pu"

qll<lm vedanta, ved;ltut~E[qllia Angelu5 fie voluil:: biam,& in iltis homlnibus fUlt talif (upubi'a.quOd

ubI lxinum,& ~mauide;quod iIlumamotem CXCf- volucJ:unt hlbeti'it Dnu, quanta magis tails w~

cui~ in uu .materia, (dl. ifi CI:c~llefi[ia propriO! voli. ~i~and~ eft Nitre- Cupcrbi.a Lucifer!. C1ai. ilIonltP

ta linc [Uble~bO-hC ad Cl:c!=lle-ntius bonum.&' ad fJ1~ lPHluorum capUt ell , 1St 11'1 fupablt:ndo IpCOS a·

p~()rem f,,:culldum r;,:gulam. &. menfuram Dei; l;elJitl . .'.

ideo dfuJ rc.:~atmn ~ parte materia: circ;lquam. Difficulra$ vero en, lUI pecC:luerif Angdul deli- 1 B

fUlt (p"ialH1i,n~ po:cO:ltUm [upnbiz, licj}t ex parte denudo dluiJiliatcm ipram fecundibn zqu.alif~

{IU princIpii,&: oiigmis (uppolilcrit;anlotem fIJi. & tlml. &: D:ltoram, an vCfodcfideIando (olilm ali ..

d di:-!ladonem de ,~. qUz elt principinm geuer:.tle q!lam iIlius 6militudinem 1 ]n quo D .Tho. ilpctt!

Qmni~m pt::~~:\t!,lrllm unq~~ m~[ilJllm gcncra- afl!nriat cil#il1lt1{l1jAn~c:1om n~n po(uHfe appctctc

Ie, nan .... ere 1e h~bct Vf mucrla Clilidi:tlmquJ; pc~ elle Vt Deas peu:qlufiflu:m. It. vt 'leU" n.an:rralii

cad.fed bite in Ange-Io fui, pfopria a«lJenria. E:E h~he-n~ dillinam, Ccil lolum apperiait eirc Deus pa

&more allfem (IIi non de-Dominamr aliqllod pec. Gmilimdinem.Aliqui ramen in 'boc D· Tl:u:unz re-

mum. eae IU:lur~.~ fed ex m.2(Cd1 volitat:irc;L fr:lgaDtUf.vt,P.Sl.1l1orezlib.,. II, ..,4llg,liu.u.. Vafq.

4fJam ell dclefudo. nen ex p.m'DDIIo ~i clI: voli~ hi; d,Jt.t H.".I.(fr ;L. Molini&I1If" fHttp.lSi' .n.;.

tum gC:Deraliter omne p~cat1lm 1I [dlicet eJ. ame- dlfP"'.'rInic")mmtbr~ ;. AI:ucon &'I'.a.6. tU Angd~

u- Cui. dijfr.9.e.%.,~(IJ1&[Uf.4' clri!;nrque ~.;mriq~ Scotmn~ <?wrjelcmjMajor~m.& a1iO$. ~ia v"o~rdbth_~ tlO O.Thom~.qu,a AngeluseuidemCf "ldeD,.&: fcien, imptJffibilirat:cm huiU$ obic:t!ti. (ciL (e effe creamram,& non polfe c:l'fc crearcrem fine: difp~ dio fui tlfe, 6c :tdhuc cnrn huius dilfendio idftace non pofie. Vt Dcosc:lfct pc:rtn,nfmUtatioDml Cui eJfc in ip[um~Gcenim cfIl::t Deus &tlus,. ODn DC:I1. "'CIU~ ; ideo dillingll,lInt duplicem appaimm II kiL dlicaccm quo inrcnditiJr rei conf~(udo • & jndi~ c:1ccm,qul'l r.,lum :zpprc:hcnfa bonito appron:tr,6: in ea quit dc:letlau1t. vt multl'ltit:5 in figmcnri!;-" impoffibililn15 edam cogno(cc:ndo quOd {alia (uor. ddc:tbmut : dicllnt ergo qllodprimo modo «rtum cll: Angdtllu n~lI1 pOUlitfe appc:rerc: Dei zqua~ lifalem,Y[ porc rctJJ omnino 'ilDpoffibilcm. quam nee ftul(us a1iqllis homo poLfrt lntentuc. qtWltl) Inagii Angdlls. Atfl=cundo mociopotllk-AlJgdus de lilo 6gmroro deleehri ~ rique r:l~~1WD DCIl(ll apprthendcte, Ik in hac de uti Jigme-D((J d.tlecl'a-

Eione pc:ccaa'C-1iiDtUQr:ID emm in iftis )'anum dL _

ElIiilimo IaniC:D omnino CCmlm ciTe AIIgelulD I, dircae ~ & formaliecr noll peccalfc hoc pet:ClfO limplicls Yl'lLmuris van: dcltdatiQols Wei ~ qna1ic::!fem cum Dco;nec app~?lfe ,cife Dc-PiU p~ 1J3tur.am,(cd per- qu:mdam fimiJltud.i~m~ An yeta

ex confcqurnti., & quafi Moaliter dra hoc cri201 p:C~dcn(.llujm dicam. Q_uzfnerit aafaD fi~ tudo ilI~ifl qua voluif eKe G~f Dcu •• dieClnJU IU· tiaudo difficuIfaus (~enec:s de appui ru vmoni .. Lypol1;a;lic:c; rdl11azionc (upmf~~laIi5 beuitudiA

nis u graria Dei ~ " ICJn.UllmUOl m 10la PlItunJi

kwlllc

SingllilJrilu pmAti .t1ngdi i ci1'~1J fliell Dhiel1SITi dtUrmmnle jil.ptTbleTiI ?

1 ~npetbia cUm 6[,iD~dinatIlJ ~ppctif1;U eud-

7 lcnn:t=. III qtn. vult ~qlll$ 6ngulamc:r c:mmc:t'c.pocuI! in Angelo mca diuet(a obklb vcrfari. Et dif~ fiC\llr~cm babel Jing.al.i.-r. ieer. 8{ determinate- aUignarc circ.a quod Dbi~tlum de fltC() hlpesbiccir. NUII'l('tati aucem polfunt quaroof obu:lb.

Priml!!D. ell dru ip(um Dcum In fe. "PPeteDd.o CiU5 ~qualjl;l(em in ~Ititudine.& mlieftatc:.

Set:uodllm ell: VilIO hypoftarica. appert:ndo ('''Ill fibi , all! d~dign;mdo quod human:!:! 1m.1lt"~ fumr

c::ommunic~ta.

T c:ttium bc:arimdo (upmlamrnlis. nole-oao cam habctt: e:l: indig~Eia diuini.lI!Uilij. auHUlD (:Oofottio homimun.

~"um ell b~ritudo.&:: r~licitiUnarllf~ig.voImdo ('alll faDtum habere. &: in jJJa onmibll5 aliis przclfc tine dr:t!lIdone ad (upernamnicm heati~ • ludincm j in qil:t poJfenr ali; ci zqU:iri alit" Cii:un fupcme.Gcur rupaatc d~bebat :wilDa Chrim ~ &:

DeariUimz Vitginif.

Circa itla labofamf in dlJobns.

Prnnulll-i~ alligti~ndo - ~bidlum cujus;tpperi~ t1U. non ilpp~rat impoffi_bilis,aut mUIl~ iJ:l ADgdo~ qUI PC~UIi t;!lm m~una. adgm.mua~ & ma,...

lilia. '

"""'::.

§l!t.£ji.LIX. e!c. De merito,'eJ pectAto AngelorfJ";.·~··

nurn fllp'ienfia, $I:. vafetrimum Draconem !Ilrn fa-: lem perlua6lfc An~e1i5 {uis ve van~ ~ & illeJliCIII;i quodam motu cogl rarenr, & ddidc:rarc:nt fc n~tU .. usn habere diuin3m, &. in hac ijj¢ptia immo-r;Ltcn..; tut! An pcrfuafiifc Allgelllffi illum (uprcmllm, ac inquicta negotiation!: {ollicitalfs inferiorum Ail"; gelorum peccatum. imemaLIequc Vt feque(enm,~ (e,.date ex Scrip1ura dcducinu: Ezceh.18.TuCht .. NIb tXUI1IH1,r.!fprotegtlll; efT F~ful r~ in m~I1I#·fona, Dti,St.c.l" ml,{titudinI1l,!,otilfill1l1U 'H~ repltt.[II1t1 il11triorll ["11 iniquitaltJ& ptm~jU. Ec infrA"l" m'ittiu~ditlt Jl1iQflihrtutn tNarum " & jniqtdttt" IItgMitf~ t.i~nu iHl.p{J1btlfli?",!ifi~"tiuMtjj .t~Ii1P, ~c. Er u'~i. 14- QgufJ1odo te&IJ.,p,-k- ,4/0 Lfl~I.Ttr') 'iN' 111111'1, ,"Jf-

b .. rMfotruifli in "tTtltfIl qui 'Vtdm.·IlhM !.tIItli i '1M; aictb.u in ewJt IND: I TJ ~41Ntn ~U1lftt1iJ.tfij, f ('P" IIjIrlf' Dtl ,xalt"bo follilm tntum, lI[clrr#llm {tiper illriulJi:' 111m l1ul1iHmJ'l1lnlu Irll AltiJlimu. Et in!r;': TUff/i. IIrram ·,tum ptrdld'fU. lu p~pHINm tlIlWl qt&W_fti, &c. Ecce quomodo pe,,:acum Angeli defcribitur~ non p~' rnodum IirnpUcis VO}UIlUlis. &: CQlIlplilcenti;c dere chimltfica. &. irnpofiibilill:d ,.nqulUD negotia~o qll:£d;'im,& indilaio 31i0l:'llln q U05 p~(~ didit.&: Vt illtc:ntiO rei quam dcfuierabat cOIiI~ulJ> fcil.arc:~dcre fuper ~a:I.llm. e~lrace_r~lium (upe! Illlrd,&: In hoc alIifililm Deo 1 noll dill;lr t.'£iJ1iillH . IrII 'D,o, aut·cro ip(t: Dc:us.fc:d Iimitis ere Alriffi~ mo , q III;u1 dicir non :tquipar.mliam diuioitard.(cd. :lffimilationem in maic::fiatc,in.ctlltu. Icc. DeniquequOd dclider:lucrit aliquid non cbima:ricIIID. &: ilupoffibilc ex fe.liclh illicito; &. prau!) modo fll~ pcrbi:t.o;omht tX ilk AnCcI,ni I,hyo tI, ".[110 Dini1a llil'bi ait. 'Did.bDlutn jJ "PPlllijfo,ll4 qHDJPtrl1fl1ijfof~ • ft fltiij{tI.lgirur Qbica:!ltJ'l\ eius non fun :l.liquid impolIibilc. IX chimzricum, red aliquid ad quod potct3t ~~rucn~ri aliquo mt_dio.lic~t ricn iIIoquo tpfe appcrllr. Ar Ip(um AflgclulIl dl.;= DCUQl fl:cundu!tl narnram • nullo medic CUI afii:t)uibile. nee -ad illud pcrucJlil1~t , erjam l1 Ilctiffc;r ; ergo iIIud non Nir primorn pr:cCatllm Angdi direa:a. &. per Cc prim6 defid!:ra[Um~'" volitum. I

Circa fecundam pattem conelufienis [upra po- ,,~ lira:,ncmpc, an ex confc:quenti.& qwu vinllalitcr Angc:lu. pOtucrit lit peccare volendc dre hCllt Deus p!:r :tquiparamiam; dicirnus hane voluerarem nOll tcpugnUe. quod lit}n Angelo Ulln vittll:l.lirer. & illd ilcdc t tUII1 fo nnalitt'f fel;:undum qu:m~m v~nitare~ poll: ~liud priLu pccc;'Imm in

qllo tamen Ipre etl3m ex prauo tine adiuna-o pcc. cabit motfllirer. Ell: quidtm virrwlitcr~ &. indire-

tt~ ) qu~tllnus in prolDpritudinc • &; aJfcGi:u an;mi eltoaio adncrfu5 Detlm. ita Diabolus clldi(p(Jfi~ [Us.qLlod,fi poUet ipfi c.ripcredillinit~tcm,& ab 1:"0 roll~r~, quod (jon eifel Dells. icl f.l~c;r« • &: eX" rl1~ pcrbia fua ita eft aifdlus, quod Ii polfet libiipfi diuinifl(Cm habcrcj& nl,llli fubclfeJ ira 'Idler,fle Ccil. alill$ ip(o eJ:cellc:mior effi:~. Et hoc ell vinllalircr vdl~ cOe Deum ill natUf3, & fecundum ttqulllit:t~ r~m.liid?on ~~~t irnp.o~bilc 1 feil. io prcmprim. dine.&: dlCpofinone3nunl, quantum en ex vi difpofiuonis.&: aifclllls quem babem.l:omra Dcum

n odio,&: complacenria: circa propri3m ~.J:CeUc:n. tiam cx r~p«bi~.Similit~ talis volunra1 poten tire fotl1l3litctrin Angelis,qui.l ipli bene cognofcLlnr illam cOllditionalclflJ Si pol1cm elf!: Deus per I'Il1tU" ram.h:!bcu~m Cllmnlal11 e)(cdlt'ntiam, ~ulli filbc[(em. libcure. ab his mi(c[i.is,&c. & bene eogn .. fCllnt quOd koc efl: pkanuftlcum. & cbimZflcum bonultl .liClh cbim~rict. fibi r~pr;J;ft mari pofih. y~ valdcddcd:abilc:.& cogitare qlwd mutta faccn:llf.

Ii hahcrent oml1iporcmiam diuin;llP: n3m, & nas iJ4cogitannu.& dclc~lllU~ (ello otios~) in Gmi-

-llblls

h~atitudine. 'Et ita quoad prim lim pattem,fcnlcnDim D. Tho •. non !"ohhn probabilctn, (!:d c~rta~ exilHmo. Et prebarur, quia pe~c;lu.i~ Ang.difillt dtc:uliquem fincm,qucm \lolint. ~ tnt51ldlt .'o~{cqui: ergo Ji9Jl fllit p~ccafum Cl~~ clr~a abquld imp'oillbile; nequc pOt\!lt (:pnIHlet'c rn ~hq.dO li.~pHd t lot: inefficaci _ ~ffi!au e~lInptacenCli% h~phci5 drc~ rem imrQJlibde~. ~on[cq.con!b.t.ql11~ OI.tfC&usintentiuU5 a(fc:cUtIOnls non pO,dt elfe circa impoflibile cognit'um vc rale:id eni~ om nino l1ulr!lln en; Angelus aUtern clare,'" eUldcnrcr cogno.kd,at clTeitnpoffibile quOd ipfe clfct Deus per eqlla!iratem~ !5!:'~ecundum lU~ura~. ~mcccd,.ver~ prob,primo eX.lpfa natUratchq\lla pnMLl5 limscut af6dmrvoluT1taS Angeli :lccipitut ve finis vlrimust cui liS gratia c~tcra Olnn iuppctUl'ltur. id alltem culUS grada omni1 Rum. non porcm ab Angelo aceipi id quo.d iudicab.u cfc impoflibil e. ~ cenfeqllelltc[ non Jibi 'O??C~II~IiS J ne~ adqlloJ earettl aGlioMscJlI(lJ[ J(ngJ!~jIC5 • QI Ii op~raIctllr C;X • magna igJj.or3nriaf~ llul~ilja:Lice:t et1iJ~ e~ca n:~ iltlpoaihikm .• /${ chimerlcam pofflt ;lhqulu~ne, /J(. otiose ddechd, & pCC'.1fe , eamen quod rem chim;eric;1~ , &. ilIlpoHibilcrn cognitam."1 ulcm vdie mliq.uis intenderc t~nqu~m lin em v[tlmum,&: id ~L1iu~ gmia ~teu f.lcial.omnillo vldFtUr hilpofubilc,&: vix 3.,lumrna iluitili;l itllaglnabile. QJ!oJnodo cnim tam (emu,&: deliberatas :ill:!oncs,ficut {lln( rdiquil:'omnc:s'qll~s homo bcit in viraCua, '"

~.. "cut fllcrunr dclibc:rat:i:. & cum omni aduertemia, qual Diabolus fecit. dicem.u5 propt,er qu.ndam rCI11 cbhnZ1ko~lnJ&: emninc unpoffibllcm fien? Et 6 f~rl;lIl\1r Aut bores Clt.id non potJlilf~ Angclum IIppe~ll\\ efficad vcllccllc Deum ptr a'qn~liratemt qllolll0do POtU;! i~ fibi proponcrc; vt rinem vltimum, cui reliqu.lS j,a:iOIl~5 filbOtdinater ~ cum in ilHs Illulr;zraa_lonC$ effiCJ.,c511nt. ill:c aU[cm origimiT; non PQ!funt ex indlicaci vclunrare Jioi$. qllia YO!III1tM nnis iclluit in omnes 3liOS atlus.qoi c:dine {ullt,c=rgo 6 IrHet irkos millti fUq[ c~. non roJlull\ jlH origilmi U ind1ic4cj VoluOt;lrerei impollibllis.ita.qaOd dus gmia rdiqu16a.ot. Non ergo potuit ille appctinu di~inira~i5. rc,un~um ;1:qu,lirnem eA:e veluaras finJ.S vluml,&: 1:111115 grolUHdiqua 6erent :crgo dcbuit ante ipfiun fllpponi ali'luid" ali!Ui pro line vlthuo. e.vi Cubordinabmult fdiqu:t p!:cc:unino(~ atlioncs;r:rgQ in il10 fllir pri;num pc:c:camm Angeli ~ non in JPpc:tim illQ ill!::ffica(:i «qualitatis diu~na:.

10 _ DcinJc: pfob=!lur idmt ~nEeecdens, quia Angt:~ lllS in fei v«iroue ill to qU(l'd appfriir in primo fuo ptcCato nop [alum i.ntcndit, & voluir indlic3cin:r dd~a:lrL. (ed voluir Dcgoriari; 5c Illud GOofequi. ~jorquc ;Ie! i& fnllicitauir. ~i~ ",Urcm dipt ropln . foUkitudinem. At nego1iationcm urn fublimi5~&:

tam fapiemis crearurz , G.,u£ fun primu~ A ngdu~ ~ tam inrdligentibus crc;:u:u(isloquc::ns. fi.cut crit Oilll\CS Angeli iUi inferiorcs in vniculO ilium fcg.. pum collinafie, 'Ilt in (c 0111011\0 impolIihlli. & '0- tnit:!. vuali.ddecbremurJ {ciI,incffiC3Citer, &: Ya.~ nc cogil:~ndo Cc c:l1'e Dcum pt:r n;truralU. Q.!!is.nQ!\ dico Angt!atumJred ('tiam nominum adllli(cct,Y d non ridebit. b:llll'; to(am fuiUe c:nram ",licuiu5 fapit:_nrilli:l~i ile ptu.dc:n.ri Iliroi intu omnes hOIl'l~llel .Vt mfinlus- fc:t! popuhs pccfu.u!aet V~mm. & liltpriffimam c:ogitJti(lPtm alic:uiw [~i impoilibilis.&: cbim3;riC3:. v.g.quOd defin~enujr in eogitando (&:; tile Angdos ~ a~t I'ol;u-e • GCq~ alleS,lUt (c h~bc:tc c:o~orj, c2lcfli3, aut diuiJUn'J b~bue natUrlm ~ Et in Jibe U'ram tuum. & «m:nuIII ruum ponere ~ yt perl'tlaikra imlJ!o.mi in jllis. Q.gJd. illCl'riu.flQ.!!.. 110- modo trgo ~~d\l1D eft ~U~ J\nSclnrn p1c-

\

DifPut. XXIIl

I,blls chhnzricis fUl::[ol1ibus ) &. hiR:oriis,lictt ilia flaa eKe cognofc:lmus. & mul,a fie chima:rka.&::

> fid~ i D:EmonlbUJ nobis proponimt, 'It In Hlis tJdemuf ,ficue llIulta poii~ica 'lana. 'It in iIIis deleilemu~. Etgoipll etiam poJfllnt in6milibuHhi~ mzricis~ & pha.nta!lid$ vane delet!.:tri,vt Ii poJfent (:ledo~ qUi fum in Ci'tlodciiccte ifiinfctnum.Chri. RUIIl IX Be:ltiffim.im Virgin!!IIi occidere.dellrnerc, & ccnculcare t & imer bee eriam pollum cogitate (e elfe ficut Deus in ~n.llitatc • {I,: qUid in rali ca(II facerefle ~ nee enim eft maier rstio cur in dellrllc:nc.lo Deum,& Chrillum. & r:lca:os, quod ell:: omnino chima:ricum pomnt jminotari; & noll in (:ogi(ando,Sc dC'fidctando (e elfe- Dcum,hddneflicaei, _& limplici affed:~ 1 E, aliqiii docent paCfe AngcJum hsbere yeilcnarem de hoc. non voluneaeem actl.la!cm. U ab(oluf;un , id eel VOIUIll;!n terti condieionatam,um e:.; parte ohieGli. '1u1m . ~ patte :iCCilS • qil:lJ explicatur dkendo. V diem hoc 1i elf:.:t paffibde, 110il qu~ uplicatur per aCtnm pra:fcmcm ) Volo hact v .g. Volo me dIe Deum.fi . ftc poffibilc:. quia Ii:~r circa, fUtllra rome dari oz4u~ ozbh;JiUil.15 (ub conditione renenre fe ~~ pane obi~CCi ,no-n ramen circ::a poffibilia, co 'Iliad p'JfflbilJras; velimp"mbilitli non conuenit (ub COIldi(iollc. Ied aDlo\uce Cl p'l!:l;iCa c~tmilJorum h,,blClldiilC lid rcpugnantia. Vlldc qllanrumui$ ponarur iIlacolldltiO, 1i hoc fuerit poffibile • nunquam redllcicur:ld veram poffibilirarem. fed Iernpet rnaner impoJlihik > & chlmerlcum illud obiedum fimpliciter. & abrolu(c. & am(cquemcr fine .:i.tiqtll .::ormcnicntia re(ped::! vohmtati,. vt poffit ~ppeti llC}il .abrolueo. Et lie rt.li5 conditio. Si hilt; Ilfol pDj]ibil, nihil omnino conducir • (ed zquo modo (e habet VOIUlltM erg:! illud 01:;1':ctum impombil~ pouta db condmene , vel Jine lila.

Nihilominu5 in hoc Don 0P£ltrct nllllnlrJl im-

;2.3 mOf:lri ~ Omittimus enfm GJipurare nunc i1I~m quzl1iDrlC:IIi qUid 6£ vc-!Ieitas. & in quo .::op(ifiat. -de quo ~grndum. ell 1.7.''11041,6. agcnres' de YOlunrario ex meru ill quo relinquieer vellc'ius. de oppoliro eius , quod cx metu operamur. Et nunc .~nirt1u.i vdlc'it.ttcrn. &::tlam :!hquo aau forIluhcxplicafi pOlfe:. faJu:m pef madum alieuius c:ompl.u:clltiz circa iO qLlOd rc:prz(cnmur nos f:IdUro! ; Ii hoc eJfet po llibltc. V nde lidt circa impollibih: ~iam adlctta condition~ ex pmc obicai non polIit dati aaus de faao , &: :tb(olutlls PCf moduro rcloilltionis. poruit tarnc-p did per modum fimplich cornplacenti;c- • qllia:ad hoc non reqlli,iuu: 'Ilia conditi!) poffiblliuri:l. lIIUt ';011- .ucnientia quold :l11£cllIiopem (ci • fc:d (uffidr ap. p.aUIU ill.;l. &: ttpra::Ccmata bC)nita~. 'It circa id VQIUnE.:tI dcldlmu. ranq\l;im cire;! queddam bonum :lpp~ren5. &: conu~niell! in r~iione pr~cHa boni fcpr;r(cnt.:tti. nop bani· alfequibiliJ. Et umetl ilia conditiQ ~di<:tb. fi cffc[ poffibile • iu~ uat • DOll qllidem Vt mouearUt qUis ad ~1fC'clltio-ncm lei impollibilk : ad hOI; enim nihil lila conditiQ conduc1r. (ed vt masi~ eXc1rClut animus ad complaccndum de (dU~ lub appn:henfione poCiibilimif condiriona!z. Vellllus ergo omnino condirionara eft ex pane obietH,& ex pattt .1.Ctus~ quamum ad OIdinem dlicac:i2". & alfccutloni!, :aurrc:lolurioncm .mimi cire:! i1bm7 non [amen ttl: condiiionanu aaus. kd de faal;J • IX fQtmalifct" daml: I{uantam :1& complacmdum • &- OEiandum ci{C:I illud, hem quatidie nperimuJ; in Debit: Similiter ergo poteft in Dzinotlibu! d.1ri a[h!!~ quo abfolme,& tit: faa!) ddetletur de re chimzrica, &. impoJlibili • liccr tit conditinna[us ex: P'liltC

btm,A S.Tham.iff I. flm.D.T". TQlDuuh~tt

..1rtic.·l11.

.. 46j

~ll:liS , & obiear quoadre(ohlliollclfi. &" nerer" minarienem afie-qllcndi; Be quoad hoc nplie~ttir per I y 1/,1/111; .• qued non dtfignac a~u:ti1 qui efl:. {cd qui etret. '

H:tcalltCm '1o!ufitas 6c conditiC:Hl:lr-a.& irnper~ 2; fech & incUicall: j de fc DOll habet auerfion~m vel connerficnem in p~'.:ato .... el mente (juanltll"ll ~d eledionetn • IX dcrerrninatioqem crga allq!l~m finero vel media, quia non pareR: vim eledionis

vel inrennonis habere, bene ramen potell habere peccatilm ociofi(~ti$ ,&: vanirad$ , aut difpenere ad ~lia peiot;!; peccara r in D;J;monibu~ autem <Jui~ id proccdi' cx odie Dei, & ad odium Dei dWponit; qU;UefiU; dclc{l;antur. & complacent; quod dfCllt DeLU el odie .::onrr:i D¢lifli;ideo in eo eflJtti gr;1uiaimc peccant, fed aliud Cupponendol non ptimllm t'cccalum lI:atucndo.

Et_ eceum hoc decerur a D. rhom. 'luiin pt~ mis :idmirdr ralem volllliCatem imprrfetbm • &; ifJdJiw:eiIJ dad palle de re imp-ollibili • qlla: 'IE{ .. lelra~ dicirur, Iic~t non volnnras dcaiu~. & p~rfecla.fC:U:ld affc,Jl(lonem tc:nd~n5, vt paret 1.1 • qllttp,lj.llr1i'.f. tid I, Deinde vere} leqnens de DOJ:nwnibp$ '1J14j1, H,. lir rUl[o lin; J. ~4 9' didr, quod Y I1IJ1f11iU tJH4 dt,jrHr itnFojfibilisl7/J nun 1ft pt,jtfla 1/11/;mMJ rmlilRJ in Illiquid (Of)fo~ '1fm;dJlffl • tJ"ill MOm /thail ifl it! q tied IXIj1i'". "JiIt ithfUffibilt. Jed rft qll~dlt7fl i1RPt~fiflJt 1)6[Hn~ r.u .qJliJ! di(;rrsr lI:Uiit.u, 'INA Ali_4 'fJ~lItf ul qltltd tXiflllfzat Imp~JlibtIl:, fod r"b h{l~ . ~onditiorr~ ji pl1r~ jibilr fit. TatiJ aFlum 11Im,II voltmr.u #flmJ1mir ~ & tOIiIiUjilJ7JU ;" qua fJuritHtif. (7 p"C"fllm ct)tt/iP"f. Vbi toea notha rcfahltiofatil clatCrtadicut 1

D. ThlJm~.

B-1( ditlii eriam facile (olil'f.:i. m2nCflf eppoG- if forum Aurhotllm fund.tmclUa. ct!!~ fcducunrut adhec , quod pllrcft tlliqUlt arpCt~(e .zliqllid lmpDl1ibile J I)on Jnteridendo CiLiS con(l:clmonem~

Ied t~nlllm compl~cendo • &. ddtcl:ando (c ill

illo • Ji'llt pmniei:n~ veller habere innocenriarn,

5: non pet:c~(fe. quod ramen V1det dIe imrol1i~ bile. &. mllltJ. impollibilia fingimlu m qWbUI ddl:Ctamut.ltem poRtlnt Dzmo!,c;s ct (ldio Dei velle ilium non dl~ • &. quod Ii poifa,ddlrucrent illam , quod non rnillUJ impotfibllc ttl" qllim velle Ie e:fle Dcutn: ergo ii[urho, modo appcdt

fin c errore lpecuiatiul;J, ira tine eod~1l; C'l"iOrC polUit eX fupcrbtll :PP!;ECre Ie c;l1c Drum in ptitno pf:c,a~o. hem nun obllar quad ad <lpp~.tndurn

fe dIe D,tun d" b~rc:t app£tuc filllm non cf-

fe : !lam in plimi5 non rcpugnar quod aliqllit appent nOn dfc :lpptthc:ndtndo i1lud V~ mm", m~lum ,ql.l.3m tokrar:.: alia pluJima .!Pal:;. quiblu '~rtrc 'tutr, I:ri.lm nOD exilh:ndo. Dcmde qui~ p(lu;"11 qui! in his impoffibilibu5 folum 3p-, p.:~crt ilbm C"onucnicll{i;l1tl boni im:lgitl.!;tl. nibil C"ollit~ndo de dcltfu4lopc fiJi cite. til;ut homo pOlea cogitarc > & dclidl:rare le dIe IInem , fc dl~ Angelllm,nib,l cogirando d~ delirnaionc (ui ejTe~

fed dd;chndo de COflll!:nienlia iIIill~ hom. Et eoocm modo POEen ~nis delcebri de: habenda diuinicaee.

C~utU!'ll ill..\l_ u did:i~ manent (olnta. :1Ii

Ad pdmuffl didlur non tcpugn:lrc quod :lliqu!~ cogiler, (( fimpliciaiteClu deledC:Eur d~ n~ iropoffibili .volum;tte q!llilam imperft=tla.v.r e~ O. Tho. vidimlU. Rt"pugna~autemquod hoc:dfumatutvt finilV Irimu5 > qui eft finis cuilu gralia i & lie :Iffc:ctu cllicad irnendifur. Angduuu[C-nI in~k pCI;C3tUm fmun ab aliquo fill:' v hima. vr dictum. ell.toque eflic~j," ddi~alJit id ~irta quod }'fi-

roo pc"auit.

§li!£jl.LIX. fie. De fluritO,e; ptCcAto Angtlorum.

fime lulir. Et lj'~t in (eirfo j &. iri decere proprio {Ilpctbii:ri~.tanqllam ill pc:rfona. am~ra ) &. in fine cui; ramen ex parte rerum quas ubI Vt finl J & Vt ~~r(on:g maxime dilctI:tt vol,uir! vnum po~tiit erIe (umma ilia excd!cntIJ. VtHOnlS hypoftilucz,lI:"ftimans (licllt diellur de Arnan) nullum alium nili (c debere fie honorari l Deo. In hoe ergo nullam: inuenimus rcpugn<intillm, f~d ornnino ~ (011 forme fuHlc hoc abica-l1m immaniillmlC ilJi fupcrbi:r ; poruitque hoc obieCl:um in ptimoipfo PC:CtafO Allgdi ilJuenirj, pen per modurn finis

. cui : hie eliim fuit iplcmc:t Angelus, red per modum rei libi concl1pira:,. non ad:tquat~, Ii:d inad::equ.:I.tcHmer plura obiecl'a nmcrialia,qu~ libi pomie tunc appetere,&: matcriam·elcellemill: propri~ fJ(erc.

An vero ira de faCl:o contigent/ Res, vt dili.in. d. cent! eft. nee quidqusm remere pronuncbl1dum. Cerr! ICaia: 14. inter multa qu:e Lucifn pr., liJZ (upcrbi:e marcria defidl:clIuit , vnum fuirlc:d:m; in monte !en~mcmi ; S,d,btl. inquit, irwJDf1UItP4~ numi , Ifft~fldAm [uplr i/,1,#uJ;",m nUbtH11J. No~ mille aurem ltIontis rc:llamenri ChrillUnl intcUi~

gi , ratis no tum tll.Er hoc ad ip(um primum pcc.. carum pcnillllil1i: connat, quia return iIIud inquit PrtlphCEl ai:idlli: Ludferum in c:urde (uo.qu~ndo mane otkhatur. id eft, in ip(o pec(::llJdi inirio. Sirnililcr E~c,hii!Hs 18. di: eodem prime Angeli) ai.:imr ; £0 'l/foil dtU4tUffI ~p tut ttl1lm. 6- dirifli. DUll ego flim. & ilHtllhtdril Dri fiJi iii '0T(1~ m"f'iI~

& ',d'J'i ror 'JI#un tjH4i &ot' Dt" Qgz verbl line:

VlIl violcnliillie imdligi po{funt .dllilli Deus- ego rlllll,id dl digMs (urn Deus dfc petfonaJircr. fell hypollati'~.& fc:c:l~rc in cathc:chaDci.ficm CbdJlG ccnuenir (eden: in fede Del. Vndc hoc ip(u!U el ii i Illil1 Uar Bernardus {mn. 6'J' in CAnrit:,,> vbi 6~ gltilim aff.:l.l;afie D •• belumfedem Cbrifti:Slda. ;nqllir,i!Ji(ChriIlQ}.i dl;l:t';6 ,,,iJ • nDlI {Kb flJibHJ • ·\eJ!omodo amlt: quis pfflladlYI /O(ll1lJ '/Ifligmiti tllil PY,"ipiWlIy.Potlie fibi jldlliJ 111 txe~lfo.SllbfH'lIlt",. &4lhtJr4 ptjlil'"I;~.Cit:J.tut criam{J:nI1. ,y.ill 'CItIlIfI:"" fed ihiid expre(sc non dicir; fcd id quod il7ft.i ex ipro referemus,

Fundaimnta. oPPQfit;! COntra hoc nihil cODuin~ 1!i

cuar. Fatc:m.utinco:'pl{fe;: Angc:lum pec:culd.finc .

vlrimo non bono) fed dcordin.uo j in quo fioe Includieur Hnis tH;.id eft .ip(emet Angelus. &. Bni!

'l"i ,id ell: • rei volira fibi ~3nqualn matl!'ria prnprlz clCcllcntia=,Etin hac m~tctia V!lum e:t tcbllsvo~

I:lis f.lirvnio hypollatica, non in quantum adh:e-

fio :l.d Deum : lie enim adh;rre~e Deo ; eri.lm in vnitatc pt:'rron:J.: bonum dl, fed in quanmm ellcel~ lentia qtl xdam, qUlllllllum pr~(cr Ie dignum a:ai~ mabat. Et lie li~~ vnil) hypo{\.3tica k~undilm (c

non (jdinis '1llimns,id ell be;ttitudo fiuc (uperpa~ turali$,Jiuc natuulis, porc:1l ramen inordirune aliql1is dclidc:u[e iIIam Vt n13tcriam finis vltimi inotdin:J.tc,id ell: > Vt mat~rialn eJ:ccllc:nriz ptOpriol: inordinate ddideraram.

Adiccundum dicimu$ quOd in proprio decore deuJ[um cft tot Angeli t~nquam in fine tIIi.:!man. do (I; 'It pc:r(onam qu~1U rumm~ diligeb,n.& quam omni honore digllam illdicabilt;& fie e:~ pane: ma4 rcd~. &. rei '1Q!ic:E pro clccllcntia poruir libi ic~ pulchro, &. dc!eoro in oellimatione • velie: vnionem hypolhIicam 'It m~feriam m:lgn~e);Ctl1c:mi2,qua (ohim [c o:ellim:lba~ dignum. 0 c pecc;l[o innidiz contU Chrillnm hominc:m,dicimu5 ilium Don por~ . fc el1cptimum peccaIum Angeli.fed (qpponcre aff eli:um malum c(ga liJn::m .,.Ittmum,qui pr2ccdere dc:b~ in Angelo aha pcccat.:l.& morum tUum inuidla:.qai pcninct ;;.d fug:uu, feu abominarionem.

- . Aducucndum

Ad Cctundum iiim dilimus polfe ex odio Dcidcfidcra~c, &c::omr1:lccre de mis impoffibilibus, ~ ,limiliiet polle ilmplid .alfc~L1 cldidC;:~Jfe [c :11,; Deum ,non ,amen potill1l'e Iddt;: 11l0[IUU~ Ptln;tl pecc~ti • qUia incipic in· Angelo 1 voIUllt:L[c 6ms - vldml yt Jitim!ls.qulI: fcmper effie;!.':' eft de (e •.

. Ad :err;utn 6rnili[~r c:onrtae ex dials. quod ideo non Forea ~ppc:tere rc elfe Deum ,qclia apper~ret (e non elfc: loquendo de appetitu ell1c:aci. & intemi UO cDllfec:utioJlis • non de appctitu fimplicis aff.:ttll$ ,& .... dlc'iralis. Et qUia in primo aau dcbeb~r Angelus illdpere a fine: circa quem non da~w: (llium aff~aU5 {implex. (ed edam cflictlx; ideo bene infcnur non appetii!te Angdu,*, (e cll'c Deum in primo pecca[O .~lia5 appclcr'et fe lion elfe • qu la i1Ie apperitus debc:barcllc cf1icat. Non (ameo negamu5 pa/le appcli int'~caci[cr fine hoc quod "-{'pem Angel\!$ (cc non dlc:.

17 Clrcafccu~dum obicll:um ,{cil~cc[circ'lvni?-nem hypotb.w:atn , an p~,c~Lltm Angelus II· lam appcecndo ubi j & Chriflo ltomin] inuidcndo; multi nc:g;lllt ~ quia Angehu irica:pit pcceatum (llr.int a D1IC .... Idmn I ~ VOIO hypolblica ncque ell Iini$ vl{llnUS (up~rn3IuraliJ I qUi3 Mil cft bcatlUIi!o • nequ!: naruralis ,qllia ad ordlnem naturalem non;;(pdl:al. Similiter Angelus ruper~ biuirdrca ptoptium decoeem (I; eleuando , Vt dicitur E~l'ch. 18. Eleu.zt";JI eft &IJT fitI'm in d:&~" 1110. At Doll perrinuir vnio hypolb(iCJ ad perfe~ c!'tiencm ,/3.: decerem AIIgcli i.l quo cleuarerur, Nee CtiJnl potuir primum P.cccalum Al1gdi cITe: in te'LI(~ndo lilbiici bernini Chrillo. aut inuidcnde iIIi ~ quia PCCC:lflltu ioui.!ix. ~ilr non [Ilbic=d:ionis pcrtin~t aJ ;I dUOl ftlg:t ,lion profcclltiQn;: • pri· . mum aurem PC:CC'ItUIJ) Allgdi debuir incipcte 1 proii:'lI!iollc alicums finis nuli.

Nihi]omi\1us res illa iSleen;!. ell:: Sed tamen cilln ,~rtllrn tit Angdes in vi;l, b.lb~itrc notitiam huius mytlr:rij per 6dtm • VI ex Allguif. S. Tho. dacct ~'~'1".Z..4TI'7.(td primam, Illtllil :lpp;ltCtre~ puglllnl}a quod Illtef obittl:a materialia circa qll;c eorum jupelbi~ in pdmu pCC.lIO Ie c:tplicuir.vnum Cd~111 £ilcrit vllio hypolbric.t il'lordlnlte ilppedta ipfi t1uurz Angdic%. id eft, (olum ratione exccllcllriot propri:t~& quia (c: digniotem t'~i llimauit ill!) (ummo hano[e : hoc enim ad fupabiam pcr~ riner/rieut fuit ill,.; fupctbia magna Aman .qiJ~lIdD in corde ruo replIt3l1it QI10d nullulU alium Ret~ niu (c \'clle:t honorarc, Vt dicitur Elth~r ~.lic Di1- bolus qui omnium fupc:rborum til: c:lpm,nilliou.· tC potUir quod tantum honorcm. qUJlis ~ft hypolUrica vnio. non dtbere:t OI:U$ niG flbi tribuc:re non infim~ humana: naturz j & in hoe maxim! fuperhirc. Ell: cnirn conlidcundum quod in fu~ petbia • !ide for.nilis l"a.{io. & moduum fir pro- 1m elltellellti~tarnen materia. in qua hoc cxe[Crtll: multiplclI: CIl,&: varia.,licu( quichm ucel~ l~n~!J.uzrunt in nobilit3te gcneri~, alii in rc!eom , all) In <1piDu$.alij in gloria ~ &; vinutc rililirari. Et nC!? (~r!lg~t quod in his omnibus t vel plud. bUl3hqu~, c~~ellC1i(.iaJn qurrat • & (llpCIbi~t. Sic ergo, va,fim~lc clllil AIIg.tlJ contigillc, qui qu~r~Jn ptopr~ cxceUcnll:J. lupcrbirc. c:rimt CUln p~ltno p~caUlt. potuit ex pute matcriz non foJiun prop~um a::l;occ:m i!,Drdiou(: :appetc:rc. fed dLun VnlOncm hypolhtll:am rub ratiQ"C euiufdam otcIfcnriot: • qua nullum olium mil [c cxiiH. m:l~it.dignum~ & h~manzna.mra: libi long~ infenon ulilrn cdGtudin;m COlnmunimi indignif-

~,:; ., " D ifPutntio, X,'X 111. " 'An. ./ J 1.

',' Ad~~Cite~dl]1l! ~~1l"1~ ~Jl bu!]!! appcdt~m u~ c::dlcnti:t circa '(lIionc!!, hyptJlbdcalti noncodcm modo in o:t1'i'tbUJ c;x,idJlc, (tIJi:.nofi ornncs detid~rolb.mt ubi p~tron~lhe( vuronem hypolhticam, lid d~liderabam ·fatUIT.: ti~d in ItUUIi1 Angdica pomh,qu;\m In hurnana t. & rtlpremll~ Angelus defiderlbat fibi li!ilID pcdo!l.llit~r , qui.~ Ie,den: volui, ill monte r!:ltamenti, {jl in ,;atb~dt~ Dei.

3 0 Cir~a tertium obieClum,(cilicc:r circa beadHldi-

'pcnl rUpC~JiiiUrakiI1. ao drel! illarn c](erCl1erim ~l1gcli PC::CC.liliTII (uperbi:t?Dicimus. eriam in pri· me pc:ccaro Angeli Ifilcrucllirc potuille (up~rbialn ,jrca. fupernatnraklIl bcautudinem recufmdo; &. dc{pkic)'ldo ilIam.talilcr q~od vinum!Ju:r,& jlltCl'prchuillc voillit. non citDm grada eam b:ibc~ re, fed ell: pUJprils vitibtlf. Ill.'quc 'It communem multis,forl1lall(~r aUccm [ollim lfoJtllt cam cl1ic>1ci~ ICt recnlare, & In (11.1 namral. fdicliJfC,<"< pulchri~ rudrne qUlelcer;. Vnde non debet (~p.lr~ti in Angelo n:cu(Jdo b:,nimdilils rllpcnumr;l,li~!t ddcelationc: (lliie(cc;ndi. Be manendi in flla narursli fchclfUl.', jicm homo pccc.msper ~ppctiUIlIi r~ru jllf~tior\lm,&' (cnfib!IiUlI1 f.:ClIllr limnl frirJU!all~; & (llpClior.1 bOrlj~ li~c( veller C~ haber~ 'iuc labore.&: non carendo frilitiollc ref LIm fcnfibi!ium 5i, fc hJbuirin Angc:lo narurahs pukhdtudo.& fdidfa~,vnic,uque proplia • .io: ex propria cx c eI!cori:< habita.&: filpcrn~r.rali> bc;ni,:udov[ communis mul,i~,& ex gmia D~I h~bl:atquod !flam rc(ul;lr,qiJia ~Ol1lmUni5 omnibus. & ex gratia I qu:c iunt dua: ,oildinonc; nldc oppolilot' mmoti h! perbo,& primam ampl"a:ic',ir.in c:aquc'n:quidi:lr,quia p.fopria;

&. 'eli: ptopdh h"blta.. " " "

3 I ; H<lnc J;;nrcmj~m i'1~tO eJfe mrnit'm ipfiJlimam p. '.1'hom;J; > & per cam oprimt. CJplj,~ti quoJ.DQdo hie lntC(uen,c{it vera (upn'bla. & lion ~rtot (pLI(ula~iuus. 'iq~ Pfilaicill ' non dl:fuedr; 9.':'11' ell inronJi4c:ratio > IX ,ilnp~dentia oml1i- 6(j~ pccc!:ati~, comnmnis, Propter quod p3r~ ida dduptrnamrali beanrudine difficih~ vi(.l dtali-, qlflbos Authmibus;. & vel negam circa hoc ubicll:!-'It! fm.llc pec(:!lWiU [upcrbi.1:' Allgdicz, vel d!uernmt a r'nr~nrja. D. Thoma to e:~plicando quOd ~volutrj[ nan c~ g~a~ia, I'i=d virum: propria.. obtmcre illam bC.ldrudmcm.N<lm r.Suari:z {,b.7; ~i: .A"f.,etin.1p.~ ,.abiolu,[c doco;f,cl1c HllpolJibilem aif;:ch,millpmm AI1S'ilo eire .. be-atinulinem {upcinarur.lkm proprii5 vltlbu, obullcmhm. vd ~tbir:tm fibi. cuamf'_ ~lfdh,~ .fir hll<plu. filii dl;tllr aliqui~ c:rrorCp!='cu!ati.uus i,l il.rc!ll;tiu~ quo f;1bo pum poffibilcdlc:,' '~mpmr.:: iibi h~Oltima!ncm proprii~. "~~L~I'i' ,!\ddrt ~zfJ}l;rllb!JII'~n. 7,(;,~ 8. qUQd lie!;! Aogdu1 c:uiJtmn ,ognoinl Ie ,lon puffe phyGce.,,,btil~er.cb(:;II;wJinl:m m.M riribu~prfJpdjs'~C:f yb(l~a.ai;' b.rrcfi.& ({i'or~ c:t'n· tra fid~n ciiU hp,c. W~~II nort [~p'lgn~rl,': qlJud ~f~;i.Utljt Angelus. pu~an,5. ~Ji'lIr Pdagiw; ,.h:.bcff: .ex fi: medtum ,de cOIIJlgao. vr D t11S JarC"~ libt bClriraaincm. Cui ;ilfcntit P. Al .. r;;on m.a.6. diJ .Ang~lu JiJp'')'~''p.i.7fJlm.~~JjcC. txi!!iro't culpilhi..-; Jmi hUll' e[tgr~m !Jon ftl~lre primm}} pC'COlt~m ,in Angelo. Con,~di~ umcn SuafC:~ iIn4t1n,~ ,n!m; ". pumifr, habtrc Angeldm fup«bnm cir;, Cl q,~I:l!idam tii'umllan,ii~~ ~C'alitIldl,l1i~. fllf.~r-. natur"lis, dcfidCr3n~ iU~ Qtius libi dafij quam ~ Dco decretllm f IlCrat, &. il!dl&'lil; fcr~M _bon {b.~, tif!l {jbicOllcuil~, Q.!:od ~go· non aNO~ qqi:l fi ~gdu5 ccmcb;l~ fc mm poae h:J."~&loliam nili pet' mc[\tum,non potui!: b£C'lliuJ. mcmulJ} ~I>lider;Jrequ3mpu vnim~ infhQJ ~onlil:iU;.ltiulle £,1:3, peft w:ation~m '. <tuo F.(lIJI() ~a,ti.tn ~i ~re-. ~ bll7t.itS.Thno,ifll;FllfI.D,Th"TolUlIsahh;'

tur bearitlldo.i\hj. '~,; Vafqm:oz, difp. f~f.cilp,~,rc ... cun UIH ad cli'cuum tilllpfic{ltl { ~ illdilc~ttll1 eirc:! bcnrlruduiero , volclldo i & cotnplaccndo lihi de coutecurione iIIius tll: prop(ia virtute> kc lin~ mends, de lluO atfcChl inrerpreracur S.Tho. m,Hn /II hut: "., +1ull.jl.6J. dum dldt > 'VDIHI{fo An .. , g~htm (mllifmt'r1~m II/.vfJ h,1(,,~N;J: 1),rlltl [;It , non a: dll.iflQ ilu x ili», Et !~:nremiam SLlarez fcqntm .. turMolin.1 pd .tr,.:L~& 1.IJH(111 '1,6" mmbr. f. Be'Jnus/lb, ~,dt A'Jge(st c4p.""QIf41'7.5cntcMiam au« rem Viifq. (~qtiitur AHllbal "iff. i78. (ilF+ rfr ...

Alarcon jl/pra '11.& all;. . .

ClI:'tcrurn vr (!:memia D,Thom. qua: vCEfffiw 3 i rna eH, qdiultque lequLlnmr COmmu.lli'Cf di(c:ipl:I-

Ii cius ~ c"p~tcet\lr, POt~ndh\m ell qllodcirc~ bea~ rleudinern ILlf'crn~tunkrn. '\_UII! eft vicimtJ5 nniJ,

J trpHdrcr potuit illurdin;ua £up~rbi;l' Angcii O::Qn ..

[icicmi. '" ,

Primo volendo earn POUtlne. fi[lC: appt'fim ef~ fjc~d.Iille in(;Hic~" habere ex rropi'iiUn¢fjti~ ftue Od auxiflo.

S.'clindb vohmdoeam dlic:ac[tu fC'curare o::mn iHf~ cOIJ[lilJolJibll~ qlllhm a Deo propoJiu fOil. (cili,cc ·It (.(lmmUIIIS r.ln} A ngcli~ • quam homin'" hus ~ l!< VI habenda c:X gl~liil, & henencio ~pcciali Dei lI!quc :tulCilio cius ,non ex mcEidl p,o~ prii! • aUt debiro alrqco 'OnlilifUrali_ lfiz Clllirl do:r: condlncues V< b,m~nru ",ppotnnuur {ingtllarirau t &. fUP'lbLa" s . 'loa ille rpfr;t~ voltbar Jillgillatir3ttm .& drlH:,~bdt ~x,c:lklm~m. VndG FOUnt bca~ittldmml fupemawmJcm VI p~opo'it~il) f II b his ~olld ItiOllibu; dlicad,cr f"'\If~r~j;' & lic H'wlando fupcrblfe, r~c1tdllfifJU3.1id(;qiiod fine lfils em,dlrionlbtiS e:!1l1 libC'rtltr :<mplcdc .. rerur ,qllca de vhEllalirer velle hsbere bc;!titudinem propril5 Vif~bllj • {til nc·n eJ' gralia Dei. q~ tenus tee !Ir~n~ lubcre i1bm c:X g~~U;!. &. H ("m" muncm bonlinib1l5 " r~'fl~, &. vinuallttr r.DU U'cllfl1{ct illam fine pra:oitlil conm!iolllbus ,quod ru II IUJlic:s cOlifiaHIlUtillgcrc intc:r homilies ~ qui renuunr 3'(epra~c ahqlLlm qlgnitaclf't 'Id IJ1U· nus cum (,111 onere VI:! p~nliol1l:' ,- qu;!m il:ldlo;~, fc In,hgn~li1. 'I1jam unJet! bile: in" OP' rto accep !~Wl( ,.x inr ~'riJ1i ex proFE~ e:r;,dlC'I1ri;t .:dU .. matione p;oLu:mt recula,c; IHud n::.,IlIlU$' (Um ilia

on.:r~f· . c

Sic crg4 didmui Allgdum P(!O pc(:c:dfe' re~t:a< J) (0 Il1pC:lbiot'. illt~nd~lldQ plotCctlU~'I1'm' Dc,,"tml=> d,ni~ fUptlWaJf:lhs pofirme-. nt'qu~ (ffica..jkr~ qUIa cUI,l.:nrtr illciIC;1ba[ c.ll'c IInpefIiblle quOd lliribll~, naill[lhblls Hi d~bc=r!::wr',vd ph.yJi~i.~'1l1ir~[trllr. N,(: ill h~j' ,ll.ruun 'H(lfCM ,.4l1gcllU,; OIlir botf\;lim. qHia lieu ~omlctlif Il.WfZ- "Ii Jiit ptrfetlot ~noftm II'c<III"liullm inumcrl:. nequc: b.tnfilI1 h~b\llU'i: ("Unlit; Utqu~ in ilio Urore po.llllt pdmllUl (;,IUS pl:'C~1I11J1 PllnJ, qtli;l nOll 'OI'lI1~';' ~* (alll p(!'rf"a~ nauwt ill~lp(!'tC ab ~trDn: 'Ip~ cul:'lhID. qua: m:gnum defcltum fuypvnir;Nec: indlkad loii!tll appcri!u compla,cr.do. & Jc:kd~lj"o, de. alEcmionc ~3thlldifJis c,; prorri~ yinbll5 F~ccauit Arlgelus, quiJ. vr olknfllm eli i"pr,J. :lg.cndo d~ :lll'\CIltU a:qua:j(a~is Dei. Angdud!) :p.hno ,PfC('3IO nDn potuit ((;lum pec*, ,;uc' ex indnn(l ~r,ptJinl, Icd C111.hquo nne ef(inciter iptl.'nlO ; & (t!iu~ gt.1lia. CIIIc:tll. lIprel,(WnU~~ &, de: f;otlo pec:cauit ,~pcu:ndo '<IIi .. q!lrd ,'luoJ:',allc(lui [c;mauit. non dl'c~ quod in,c~~"i ramum cCI!l!plaC,nfiOl d~ngult. vI: ibi ollClljiillllb. :El fic (JJlU)i.a qll:t dl)umu~ ,onon~ indlical:cm ~PFtliwm IYqualifl~i5 dilllofl;t' 1 cllm!llr hk ,c:nua indlkaum ~rr(;ml>rn b~;r.J.lu-

~ di.ni!.N~c dI:W'lll':: 1i1Pfib~!li~ a} pcu:mlu p()ht1ui

};1 M m ~ oJl,u~m

----:·::.:i!~~

468

aliquam ci~cl1mlb.r.tiam b~atitudin.is ,.vr qtt?J d~ tillS damllr ubi bealimd". am ahql,ud 1111111e ~t ifl[lIprll o!1:endilnus:fads enim dlo d .. t.i di bc~cirldo j (uppotitO quod Cit m~itis dad d~?ujt •. cum_ dJta flied! poll primurn mlbns men.fa com!n\I~tum, on foq.dirp.~le~[Ut. N~c a~gl1&tl potent ah.~ qua circLllnftantl:!. in bcatlt!l~Hle rU?crll~tUtah, quam ex propriis vtribus poGer defiderate AllgeJus 8C non ex gL'.tda. fuppolito quod ipram beadtuJill~1n chllque a!fccutionem . in fingulari non pOleCat eX viribus propriis difiderarc conh:qui.

H lllt alia :l.melll .parte recu(;tl"io .b~:ltjtudi~~S f~. pem!rurillis lit Jibl olJecof:e cum alias conJltlOnlbus quad h.lbenda el1'~t C~ gutla Dei • lk cum communica!iollC ad h lmines eft obi.:allm vlild~ o;'ongcllum fiJpctbjz AlIgdic%. QUi1 vidc:ntcs di .. gllirarem (u.am :Ii appt!liertlln fingul;irit:l.!t::m, qua': 111;1.~iln~ cit propria (upcrboJ'Ul'i1j pra:(crtim tc:fugiendo commanic~re cum ilJfc:ciocibllS • qu~c$. eWit homin.es t & 6milirct noluerunr illiqllid labi chri ex gmla, & ",liclIQ b~neficio, qu~1i D1llb dteriu; grad .. in,Jigcndo, q\lod i:ti~m vldcmu, pallim in hominibu5 fupcrbis Inueniri- Hoc: ergo rna· xima (\.lit poffibilc,& congmuan fupC"rbj~ Angdi. Nee aliter voluerunt in ftl~ n~mrali btadllidine G~ fiel e , i5r; (:.a clfe coneenei • Ilili qUia p,.·r hoc: recu{;!,rum fllperiorcm be.Hit udinem, 'It ex fpcci;ili gratia libi daadam , &; Vt communem cum hominihus; quorum neurrurn h~b~ballr in fruitionc: p,opri~,

&. naeuralis bl=ati[udinis. .

3 ~ E! hoc:iu de f~aocomigirr~ fuadet tum P1lrtlm, Jt D. ThDm.J: ill hac p.mc explit:atill,'[ulll Scriptura: illllnllatio. Nam ell: P:mibus Bl,lnurd!.!s hoc apprime :migilform. 17' it~ Coirtliea. quilocus,lica, cir<:rllr :ld prob. andum quod AngehlS :l.ppctiit 'l"~' nion~.n bypo(i.ariC:lID. rellcr:l ramen id pon eE~ ptdlit. (cII (o,lum. id quod a nohiJ C~C:I fU~i:roa. tllulem beatltlJdl!H~m dl dllrn eft) bl.$ vcrbis:P"."it NllljngfT' (ft Ilf1Iitl'i inatJibik 1JD1J p1fttrw) pltllll7IJ jitPltntil&, &- ptrftF1um d«m Imtiin(J ft.· [rip; p~lujffi {HII"'IIS &nam, & PT(lft!lIlTtJS in p.trP/J I.lorilJiJl.{tJ. /iprl.foi.it • in Dlj fltybll~4brq1lt Jlfl,jq '(1;Jir.& ill rff~ /irm't ;lllllidit(inteUige in vctbo not) cine vi(o.(ed per ;Jliquam rcuclarioncm fpccialean) & 7fI~1i1t" ell h""" !ilhitl1DI. fo,iDI hdifl'AtHl.In.ftnnWlIl [14t1r. inquir. i'l/eriDrrFl"' illZtll"'.nDn ~~,.,

.~; tJitdlfo_. rltt: ~lMIa in glqri~.A.fI 1m; prlldit jm· ,;4J/J bllll!: lilY _hiIWillJJflII ilt.i p'40mpt!'lI{c&1'l"jiI.foffi'llW fi[!lijitllll.tttl"!,ifttriflllJ I AftlllttLtjlJ,in. '11h,.!,.prr mmlun tjmI[am. &' {ebbll in LiIlffiblU "",11111111;1.1'" Ai,ijJitni 9rth1J- p'lImIl. jifIJili'IIMtum d11iIW'tr • fi tJtl.tIilMtmJum ilk flip" ch"~ him /idens guf,mt41 'l1Vlillt Alfg~/i,.tm &1;iUfI,rll[1l, itl. dr ipfolllru. fttltm, yt!,""'1I1, gllflll hllmifl1l1111. Ecce c1pre{f3.1ll a Becnnd"o fupabiz iIIius diabo-lit:t: m1gnirudincm eire.). ~;itirndiliem(upC{natll~ talem. recufmdo iUam hlb~(: fine 6ngulwratc ptopria. (c:d communem cum bOlJlinjbus~a q 110 cOIJTeclltUln ell IIuOO voluerit (pecialcm lUpd 1;0$ hlbcr~ p~l,"it;JQcm porim qll~tD. c(Jmplunic~tjonem.1tt«iam D.Thom,fa~crwin b#I].6;.,,"+ ittu",. Aeccdit ad hoc aarhoriras S. Gregorij

. PlP~ J4.M~"!.,,,,.q .• IiAt17.tltll4.vbiinquit, AIIg"'1 pmlfi.,Jfo pgtiriP4t;i11l·"I/i,lil4;1I,pJ. 'lui,; P"fil~~ J#[,Jp"Ii,f1'II'1t.id eft.reeufarunE o;';Elellcm bc;jl~udlne.m ~ qUQ pmicip,lta J {k comtnUlli~ «at lDuhu. &: lolrun yol!!.CNm prill.:!tanl.ldlit.tE'lu;itenll5 priuaraml & pwpriam. '1l1il! pmVI 6e hl~ bl[ ~Utt CQodllionc5 maxim:: opponul1.ls (uPet~ biz,lcil.linguluiI:afCIl1 • (cQnihil commul)C lubctt: a:m inferiolibllS s qaod ipiis vulg~rc vfdeb;mtr~ cQmlncfi'« gkuiaWpc:tn.ul.lnJj~~nQn ~ ilo:

il!!,tlft.LIX. e5c. De merito,.fJ peccA/o dnge/fJrum. _

la:n ex (peeiali beneficio , IX gtada ; 8t quali p~t:.' CJ.rio: hoc enim m~ximc: r!:~nt fllpcrbi ~~ rna'. :r:imchecoC.:mit AlTgdus. E[ ad hocpertinttpar'~ bola ilia Lucz 14.de hcmine quifcdt camam rna .. gnlm, & veeauh mulros, & CUm vOalJletinliita~ ros co:pctunt fcH:x(::u(a(c-! ideo enirn fuft:llIis reca- . f;1Ut=ruOE ad illam cesnam venirc,quia magna erat. (5[. pro mulris , d,dignantes CODCOHiulD habere ~ cum ranro ollm4:ro,pouU(quc dcgerunt fu.u priua~ eas cCllnmodita[t:s;lid~t longe infttiQreii,"tp0tc na~ \utaH, ordinis. iltc qui~ Villoilil emir, i11e- qui:! iuga bourn f alius quia V$Q~em dlu:crat. vnu(quiCquc propriam cXi:u(ationcl1l pra:tcndc:ns , Be p'luamm bonum. quia propriu~. rec"fans vere) c(Cn~m. qui:!. magn3lD. & multis commlin em. 1fie ell. proptiiffimc fpiritu5 (Liperbi2. Denique Auglllt"elatUS a SUilrn. IIb'7.dt ,AlIf,llu (tip, J r, inquir 1 t. a. Ciuil.t;;p. Jquod .tf11!.lltu ip{e fibi old 'fIilA", bwIIlJJi.:m 'fIlIlJ/,,, .Et inf. M 1111 Angtli fUIi piJujlAII i" .. leEJ4ti 'Vtlllt .bonu,,; [Hum jibiff fi tJfini '* f"p;ritni hDnD.d pf"p~14 dtjl,.xmml.Et idem tefe£t D. Tho. eX Allgult.l,brD de lib"" Arhllril1.& 4' J. g,f1,/i U limf41lJ,irz '1. J 6.at 1lJlflOllrl.f,

Acca:ditad hanc mentem S. Tho. qUi pcrpetll~ J' deeee recuC;llfc Angdum habere be:ui,udinel1l fJlpcrnamralem el gratia, voleude fillere in fua n:uurali beafiruGini:;& it~ G ;lppeti.ir bc:uimdinem (upernatutalcln • ;lpp.ttiil: ilIam ex vjrtUtl: propri:l. VjJealur in JiM qIlIlJl.6J. ifn. J. '1biinquit: In bgg 4pp"ii, tit [tmili4 De, ) 9";'" IIIpptt;ir '(II ftrtmJ ",1- li",um (milituditlu i!l • lid ililld 'fIjtlfli' fu. nll,,.1. pDlm" PUNtn;". IIIII&r#11J [JlIU1J ifJiPttiltim ;'htiftj·

. rllJin~ [upn-'!.mmlli. 'IU. ,ft t}e 1:7'"ill Dti ( qlli fer...

me ell v=ddc f<lllllJlis in D. Tho. fcilicc;t aucums"

(eu rec;u(¥I$ bC.ltitudinem (upematllf.uc:m. quia.

ell ex gr:t.dl) Yd ji IIpp~tiit lIt flltii1lNm ftntm illAm Dei jimiJiludilltm 9HoC Jlftllr 'x [,1'11.1;'" t 'VDI.it wJIq hllb,l'~ ptr1JittJlltm fUll "ilttlr~ • If,,, IX aifliml '1%".. xiii, flclIlIJ.inJl Dei JijfDjlliDnem. £1 bile &fl1ft". Jil1i4 An/tlmi, qNi dicit 9uu4 ilpptiiil il1Htl"4 ill/Ill ptrlltl1lffir ji /lttijfor, e, blff J1III 'ffID~h in;_ y,dn4l1t • qui" ftCiJnJum '(1irH11J'fflt IIPP'liil ftlltlltlll Iltilli,ud,lItm pu fHMIJ ~im"f,", b./Jn"t • fflllJ '1' pr,pr'"m VIi, E.:c\': formollis rario qaiam b&~

buit (uperbia Diaboli'~ pro intento, (eUic:ee IJa.. herc bt:aticudinem. non 1:" grnria • Deqllc elO bc-R Ilcllcio {reciali j ad quod non r()quiritUf quod po-. jjriu~ intcnded!: habere bc:.uinldinJ:m Iilfernai:ll~ talcm ex vinute propria. C~d quod tecufauc:rit fI§

bm hOlb.!tc • {j ex: gmia habenda er:lt • '1inualiter innmdcns quod Ii lion ell: gr.ati3 haberl9:l1l'. iII:m veller. Vidcndu~ell: edam S. Do.!lorin;. rWII,.. G,llti/".p.l'IO.vbi inquit. quOd ..lltlgtlHi 1JDfI IIIp~ ,_iiit lll1i1"0d bOll"m, np 'Unum 'ililld 1ft Jih; P'~ 1";11111 ,foa in bJ1t: fuil P"coif"m t tj1l;" py;uumijir !"pcrilU b~it*m > ;n 91iod debuit DTJi7,.n: Ji'H' ti'lim

ill no/lu pU~.Jinn 1ft tX hJ1& • qflQd bllnA il1ftriDrIlJGiI. .ettrpDTis tfppairlJu$ "bfq"t naill' ril,iQllu;it. in Di;l.

b~l!J P«C41f11JJ fuli ill Inc, 'lIlOd PTl1p1ill$ ""nil",

ntln ',flllit in .lilli.8m bortllm. Iw:u hane (cn(um imdligitut quod dicit id'lIUft.!" UmIIIUYI.;l.,.Il4 +1illod 'D;~bl!l~ IlIJiJ '-PP'tiil .di1tMd ",.dIl11l tfitJ ,/llaJJII1tl#tmllm jibi CDnliti'liml. f1llmli1lIJzi lormtn.& ~1lf1I1M"Mi iih4J !iPF.tilt • ~~iif flilim .11. ~ tifpt/iil ,O.il. fit IIJftpmaMtll P" d'lIlttitn i,14U4m • rid plr r0pi~m fI;rtllll1n,IJJf,ad t7~ld~b"i __ tim [II. ,,~ Jim"u. Et .,,-!oft,. Fllr, pTlrfJllm "UI-111m Di ...

bpli in hit, tpfod Ad &ftlfo'fllmJam [1iptrtr4tlilr!lfnn hf4t;/~?tm qlll. '1J p/~rz" DI; 1JijitllJt f"njijlit , tlllfj

~ ,rtx" PI D~m. flllll'1l1lfm jilllfitm pqftOitmtm 'x

,'f14 1.".';. kjidmmJ t_ .4ngeli4 JimO;' fill tA11l ~flJfof"j 'tI1I/flil pIT l1i"llftm 1'/~ l1_tll,." ~ ;fH liPJ,"

. jin;

DijfNt. xxu:

p", Dt,;n 1t,"iflYlim uptr4f1tl; {ttl jiliiDl1i gYifrttlm bdjlr'II".OJ!~ fcllimonia li'~' lignifiC:lte vidc:~n~ CUr fuia'_; in Angelo intCl1tiim con(c:quendi politill~ g(oriam rille gratia, q~l,pd ftneertote (pccula£illa Ibre non potcEat j quem D.Thom. perpetuo ncg:i~ in Angdi$ imefucnille.,tamen re vera nOn fnnt i ntell iglttlda de Inrenra pofitiuII: I:on(eeueioais formalrtc:t • fed foh\m vitt(l;ilitc( • (I{ indi· !:t:4e {l':cuCaDdo iU.mJ habere: ex gratia, quod ell viuualircf vclle • Ii pOp dlCt cit gratia i C!i'liOi alia; 4:4'" c:onttadiltia In O. Tho.negolrm: Angelo erI"Ofcnt Cpc:culadullm ex Vn:i p~ne • 'It pate-c ,;, hilt: '1ri4ft.6~.;ij't.1. Rd .... & J,rllff'TIf gl11Uf.G4P. 110.ad primam rationcm. "" {llpfAqfU.jl.SS.ilff. f. &: 'Is. IG.Jl mit/ii ;ii't.6.~ 4{ib, fopt.& euliOi p;uce concC"ch:citC: intemum fotm~liler, & politiui cOiifequendi glo~_iMIi c,; propriis ml:r!ti, , Cum id fie emnino impoffibile,Et quia fati5 fe explicatl"","it.t'.t' ,.1 io,;;, j.~OIJIY~ G~ll#J.& 'l1art.j.hflilM'jlli.jJ. 6j. vb. cifF:l bC:llitudintm htpC'rnaruralcm admittit An&dum fc hlbuiife per mod.utn auc,dioni$ • {eu recnCuionis ; nolens marn es gtlltia • &. b~llefid? Dei. vnde viftLIalira > &. r~dtt ;;Idrnitu:rC'c iII~m)fi non cllet =x ben;6c:io gr'lruiro, {cd Cli: virrute propria. Er hanc racitam. Cell' vimukm volidonem bCjfitddinis ex propfiii meriris (ohim panit D. Th." in AngciiJ hoc ipfo qllod. admittit illOl peccaifc aUl:~[aldo (uumolppC~i!lim a fupc:~natur"li beatitudine • nee Yol ~ndo 11101111 ex graIl:!. Et (ju.:I.ndo addit quod Ii a.PJ'(;tl('(unf 'It 6 nem vlrimum besfirudjw:m lic aa':q'l{'nd~m, e)t virtute propria volurruni" illarn • fhelm fubdir. quod hoe in idem

.. edit cum ilia priori appcdru. quo v"luc::ftlnf n~ runleR!; rU:l1n be",rirudincm auerrendo (e , aut fe-cuuildo illam habere t'X gr,l[ia • quia bzc reeu{ari~ bc~t~t.udinis , 'It e~ .g'.&cia h2bl;Qda: •. eli viftualli volmo alJ'~qu~nd. dbm,non u grana.

_, 7 V Ilde in (enll~mia D. Tbo.non dc:bc:roIJJ (r:pamIC" dtJD5 a&U$ lupccbiz.vnum cira bc.uirlldinc:m nauralcm voleede in i1b Glletc. a1ium circa (upcrnaturafcm Intendende illam coo(equi ell. proFriis viribi.ls • fed vnus .. & idem adllS f\tjt.c:ld~lll'Ill: {up~rbi.l. rcruCans mber~ exgra[ia; &b~enOG O~I fupmI;l.ulr;dc:m bcatltlldmdn • 6: porrns c:Jigens in prop"~ 1it1~iC • qlUm il.bm fUPt:m'lUI,de-m ex gcaria habc:re;Et boc idea quia appl:tiros e8ku • & po6tille intl:otlUUS glotia: n propriis vitibtt5 dl pb,n~ impollibilis.eEiam homin. ltuh", nee dum Angdo inrd[igem iRimo. Arpetitu~ au~ ftID recu(alilllls gtori~ Vt bendicij gUtpit{ nOn pordi (uftketc ad Ibtucndum primum pecQturn Angdi fine alrcH' appericil. quo If tllC:f filterc: iQ fila ilaturali f~ljci[3tc • & txccUenfUi. (}uj;t me priJIllll appc:~it!u ell re,u(3.tionis. &. flIp. vhimlll :lUtCID lims dl:bet appc:u Vt ptofc:q\lc:ndUJ • nce po!fumul pro primo pCl;caro > qui in Angdtt in"pit ~ inu;ruionc 6ni5 affignu~ lolum mam fu- 801m. feu Jccnf:nioncm. nOD alligtUIJ~a prD(ecu-riOI::ti:m. E'go ti Angdu5 ddiquir circa Map Cupemam,alem rccubndo mum· 'it n gntia > Ikb 6. ClC vimu~ p~QPtia e~ct. non re.'llr~l"Ct i1Jllmsop.oc& ~r qllod In Ipfo ddu~l:o fupcrbl;1! affignrtur ellam finis in quo rcqukuir.& quem pnlfccums cfl. (cil. in. propria clI:e .. cllcl1ria flaIgr:r1i tiftnc~ po,ius qulm aliquid ell: guti2 b~bert:'.

3 8 Ex boc amem foluunlut omnci di!Jicu!f;atcs.

qu~ contra hoe fieri poflnnt. Ef fett tora mftamia comra O. Tbaw. fir in hoc. quia nop ponrit appe~ ,ereconfccutiQnem bc:atitudinis [upcm:uuram e:w.. propriis vjlibu5,nifi vel illdieando iIlampoffibilem. & hic dr~t mlgnu5 rnor.ctiam in fptculatione. vel i~do ilbm impollibi1cm.~ boc CaCt on-

.Attic. J J 1. . 4G,'~

gnl fi.t1irilia. ,oqari in ralem eot1rccurlontm j vel ' elre'£ lohlru incffic:ax. I$< IimplC:j( ailidhuillill$ bea-

tii I~ dinisline mcriru. foe ca!ls af.bctpt non CerUlt 1'~1;t vlrlme noc appc:tendo.qma appcmUI £~Ib 6hi~ de. beE .::lfe c8icax, &. pOfi£iua jmc:ndcn~ > c\lm fit id cuiu grati~. V cl frin eo aliqlio~ peCGatDrn fl:!ir, p{]titl~ fuir omiffioni" quam commlilioni5 , qUill amiJi r mne agetC ~ &: velie quod opoucbat 'ire. fuam {ailltem.'oriosi- occ.upal~~c:i~C;i ilI:lm .rJtnfl~~ Cem del(:'{btlonem j 8£ ullagut,1.f1am bea:mudlnls h~bendiC line merirb.lrem qu.ia. velie ilIlf~qiii bea~ firlidjn~m linl;' ~uliilio Dc:i poriUJ dl p«:catulii pr~~~mpt!ofil! t;:onrra CpCIII~ ~I!t jjjagtianjmjrarem~ C)llam fupethliC .;ornra blimilltatem;& ti, (rtdira p,cr iIlum ad::um cxplicllmu~ iPperbilirn Angdi:ziiC laltern pcc-atlit Angelin. &: labofaui£ h:i;(eu Peb .. gij,PUt3.fiS (iiffi~cte ad be~titudine~Cupem~ltIra.. . feat h",utalcs vires. ex qUlbll~ habcfl poirce mcri-

rum de condigno t~li$ beatitudini;. .

Hz!! omnia hura nollram cxplicatioDc:m carent J!i vi,"c': opon:ec in ;:is hnmQrati; nei: i:nim no~ d/cimus P~"~tum fupetbilt' ia Angelo pfl,jlceffi1f~ C1; judicIo in~eJldcntC"con[ecllrioliem bcafiwdinis; iiQ~ gdlj~.fcu ex viribul propriiJ:huiufmodf mim c:gleClltio non pOlule I;a~ fortn!", lint; crroIe;fed ona

fnit c:i: judicio fecufandi quodlibet bonum. ct,;1Ql glDri~m ex grad a • lk benefi'io a1ieno~&: line fin: gularim~ aJlqU<I. fed comlllUnlcllrldo (Urn fofmo. rib~s : hoc enim maJ.ilt!e d~~ign:intilr. fllpcrbi: Ec qilia Demenes fUPCIP' ffinn ftmullt; Idd. omJiml communication em cum alits inferioribuJ.;tti;nn in gloria,&: mnnem modum habendr~id ex gr;(~ tUifa bcne5cio • & flon V{ d,bitum.err.am glodam

ip (am iec::uf.1funm'nde: vin:ualirer V(lllIetDtn ilfl1m~

fi. ~on.l,!ffc;-r ~ gratia.(cd ex ptopfi.a V!ffil£t idfcqni .. billS. iF lie nullo modo e,; reum: JIi argdmcnm volucfunt polhiut. &. farmalirer beaflfudlnemled emc~mcf voluemnr illam t:ccu{ari: ~ quia uzr cs gratia. &; commtllJieibili,l (ImoibaJ.v imufjrl:l" ali>o

rem voh:bant ,nam.1i. fic non c:ifet: c6iaciEI:r lI'c;ro,.

&; poliriu~ aJhzreb~nt propriz ext;:dlenti~ vt Dnij' qUia ibitales LQndirioll~ non in~oidnq,. fc:d nat pfopda nen I;omm.uni~ ~ & 1100 ell: grana rpccUli~

fed falum Ulrcc:relrlonis eenaeniees Nccin ho~

EniE pC"cc~tum omillionis • fed commIfIioniS, quia v.oluctiJnr inordinate adb'Ziffe l'topria: CUtlteil~ ti::e,recur~ndo Cllpeu.lafurJlsm.;1d 'lu3m~ gratia ordrn.1bamur ii Deo. Scniper DiaboillS gmilm

Dci tlbominaulS dt Nee in hoc: habuit pcccamtn pr~rllmpIiOlli$ Cpntr;l fpern • au, COntU m3gmmi~ tnit3fem,'("drup'c:rb1~ COillf;i bgmi!it:um'J,qliiaip6 nolllcmQr eonlrqlli beoatirudinc.m line metiris.

hcut vult pntrurnpruofuJ • fed recuCarunt illun,'1i

erar Iubc:nrh p~~ gmi~rn • 'filed f;zdll:nf (uperbi.

Ncc: OpotfCC jUi arrribucrc C:Uorem Pdagij de botbendo menta condigt~.l Clt ftOpt;'" natllra ~ quia

ip" nOD valebant CO!llcqq~'torm.dif('l'.~ de faao glori.llll p:r flla U;I(UU!ia. Ced n:cufilbant fubetc iIIam,fi pet gfat~m confequtnda Q'ar,n: vu': «at. . Vnd:: lion b",bdUUn[ errore~ (~Juiuu.!U PC:Ugij,fed habnertmt mHimam(lIpexbiam. vnde.all-

pit (cirnilb t'nori~ Pehgij.

CitCili qllmum obiedum, (dthew(odinnn tJa- 40 mnlem.ao fdair mareria fnpnbiz Diaboli ! DidmlU Hnc dubio fuiffi:-, Vt conllat ex D.Thn. {tiff. I"ciafO. Sed dllbjranr aliqui AUfhorcs,qlfDn:t040 iii

hrn: appctito propriz ucellcnri:e • k mlUr:lm f,. - licif;lris fucrit pec~arIiJQ. aUt Ii (Pit , qQomoda fucrit Cupetbiz ? N~m in ~pperiru proprie • & a... lwaliJ fc:licitaris !I:omdlim l~ pccurum non eftt ima. v. [up;' diximus .nti~ ••• non potui, Angelus PCU2lc) G n~ , lk pu:,ise lIfterc:t in flliinatD!4-"

MMiD f J~m

470 ~4}i9 £1 X.f1c.Dcmerito;f1 pcccAfoAngelorurn.

r~libusj qlli.ladill~m er~t omnintl nc,ttllimnlS, & lern fdidcarcm. p~ac,l1ilrc Angelo ~ ~on Colu,~ v\:.

d~lwnilmIlS,red ()potf11it quod h~berct rdp.llull.1 .cQm~odOlJtcm,. nIIJlUlqL~:. moldl:.m rn ~c"u!~c?_;

.;Iliqucm ad fur.CrJl~tLlra]jol b01l3,Si,aulcm e:ouGdc- du •. Iicut l~oml1ws mall: b.landas carnrs adlcu!

. III' ordo ad 111pctllat·lJr~lcm beamu.dmclTI. ,non amnnr.ne (ptr\cuJl!um :lufictl.taU: moletlenru« hoc

~c p:rc! ~uol1lodo interllcncriribl p=ccatmn (ilp~r. Cnli!1 parurn paterac Angclu~ irredrc/7d .p!acl1iC-

J;e fine errore: (pecj)utillO,. qUi.l,ad pe"~t~rtJ In- f(: Angdo"e: a!fl,;thi lilp~r~l:!;' 11011 qUia tuam na-·

. tfbi<r: orolU:b~t qno.~ c:-:cdlcn!la~. Iuarn Ita ex- tur~l!;l~ fc,lclralclll ~mphCl!~r,~ abfolute,& ,!ilaG.

,~ollcr(t,vt r= ilia dcfpkcm ~l!pcrn:;~I~r;tlcm. vel ::r.tltatln,~ ~lI:.ccllemlUrc01 PUllUI,r fllp~malur,al~.aut s

iudical1dO elfe Infcriorem, lIel JmpOffiDllcrn,3U~ no Jlbm ~ac nnpomb,lcm, vel fibl lion ncce!lamm,

n 'cdT2r1Jm,vd non flit u ram ~x Dco . quod rotum vel 1I11!~m , {cd '11Ii;liuam naruralcm. & propr~m

r.~cerrorc IpcculiititlO Ihrc IlOJlpotu.it. Si auteru e ... ~cl1cotill.:n.iudic~bat ~n habc~i 1;,11. (p==ciali gr.1w

diucrtit a b~adtudine fuperI1:llllrali, t"am!Juc rC:l!~ I~a.& belll!hcII) Dc,,(e~ lure creaucnu.ncc vrmul-

. lalli, , non cum .tali crw~c (pccul~ti!lo, led [~hlln 115 COllliTlITlleJll,I,ed ii.hl fingl.'larcm; (u~e.rnatU,ra~

.CUIll praLiico,rccufaIldo !lIam 'ir~lilie:,lc.m fi~I.~I~t lern amc~ ~camudmcrn Yir3qul: ~ondjtloi:i,e db,

grau:1ll\& rr('pu:n~a. (0 !~Im ~uidccn,(J.o ln tali fch- taterc! & !Cleo tf'c~(~bat {~pc~ll~turale m beatlt!td1~

cjratenalUflli, qu:g m~l$ lib! dl £lClll~, I line: non IICIIl tub hac pr;1:el(a cQlllidcranonC'.vt ex gr~tJ;l.&c'

.cril ilIu·d peccanul1. fOlmalitcr (upcrbil.1,', (cd puG!- VI con~m~nt:m mu!tis! quiefeebar vero ~npropria:

i lanimi.talis, vel pigrid~, volendo b?c b[),Il,\lm,n()~ ve b,Iblt31UtC cr~anom5. &., no~ c; (p~Clali gUlia~

, quia propdum,& exccllens , (:d qma f.li:lilus., ~ll- I1.Ct')UC C,OIll,JIl1Illltcl';);d mulros, he:et a~,as.~xcdlen~

! nMqlle molellum ; licm hOnlUlCi·ddluur.t ad ICIl~ (lO£CI11, ludlcarel (lIpCrnJtllr3!~m bt3111udmcm. fcd

~ I JibHlabona fellah (pitilll~\jblls,qui:tillaapprthC"n- );lOI\ v.t flbi ccnuenienrem cum tali onere gt2tuid

duurur "t ~ciliora; ~lin{llql~c ~l,o!cll:l' qUO? non bcnchcij I ill quo nullus intcr~u:n,icbat rpec;~I:ltilltlg

I ell pCCC~!L1I1l ii.1rerb!Z ,It:.! plgrll1~.rC\l o1e~ cdl;!;. Et error • ~}L~la tot!ln~ hue: quod n1du;;1b~.~ ven~m,utli

vrgerurfccundo.qlll;l v~lk.rfOplljm. & i1:uU~31c:m ~m) (cd, ,~t~n.I<:mcbdt hllnm~ ~ilpe::rbJ.t, qUI:! 'pCe

fdlcimcm reliA;!. fuperJOrt, &. (u~rna.rur,\h, po- jpc~ulamH: WdlC3b:.t b~atmillmem (llpertl.1~Ura.

lil'15 til J~rcclJdtre • quam :.fcClldcrt: ; Ill:!: opor.ttt km d.:lri ex b~il~6do gfamiro, & cornmunker tam

111\11r""1111Cg(lti~ri in t~li f c licirMe qu:tfc:ndol. din} Allgcluqll~m bomlni, & hOi: VCtllffi erar , iudic:l-

1:" nm,!a (ua (;~J1'1 habcat. At pccratum LU'lfcri. bat ~)uoquc [ilam excellcnrhr» natur:llern"c~t len-

ac(cribhlll'rtr modum afccnfus, & cX:llUlionis, ge inf~riorl!m, CnC(~mCI1 fibi pcculi:m::rn, nee ex

, l(ai.14,1l01l dcCccnfus ad inferiora 1 &. per modum grada fpedl!i.[ed iure cttationis libi dad. Errawt

n~s.olla!ionis Ezcch, ~~. \It {ilfY;' pondcta1um ell, aurcm prtlaic~,quja filJgllbritatis :lUidus, & irnpa-

: Noncrg" in !laUI~lli felicilate: ql,.ucnda fl,it pcc- lkM (ltpel'ld~nfi:l: ab aliena gratia, &. nolens quid-

: (;:mlluiHutl (upclbi'1!. Et Ii dk~tllr fnilli: tCOQI:Il- quam prccado habere , 311N: pofyit infc:riorem ex-

riam ill cx,tlknti':lIn naturalem ptr Illodum cui- cellcntiam \'1 propriam • &. non c~ grati~ fpe~ia1i,

t:irioni~,tll!~IClllJS volebu eamnun ord.narc ill fu- CJccllciltire fUpl;riorl,Vf ex gratia d:lnda:. Etin boc

pcrnar"!"lkj~l bca_dt!lChl1cl~. Conrra ho'c~.qui,a tanrum c:rrauit rr.il.ai~~.quantu~ {Ilper~iuit.. .

wn~ f"(111.1hter lolul11 ~acr pece::.lturn omlffioms Vndc ~J £;JtJonC$1II conrranum mamfdlc patc:t 41.

~"fcr~lldi naruralem excellenriam ill Dcuil1,& non {olutio.

[xcr~cndi rune .. Cl:um chj[~ra[is. '.I!lod quidc":, eras . Ad prima~J dicitu~. verum e~e quod no~ peCCa~

conua pra:cc:ptum affiun:ltluum lupcnlaturallsor- ULr Angelus In appcfUu naturalis ucdlentla:. nHi

dinis,\ullc oblig~ns, non {amen conll:itucns 113tIl- cum ordinc ad fL1p.anarilralcm~. nolens hanc ad.

ralis cl(cd!cmia: lpp~dtum in ratione (upcrbi:t. Ii- rnitrere cum (;Inta rubortlilmionc ad gnrialll. Nee

quidcll'l tota, maht.i;)" i~lil1S apr~til,US r.:ducir::£ a~ ~rr~ui( ~pccu!.~du~ ~ir~aiplam.vto~enfu~ elt-,quia

boc,ql1od nut cauia IlInl5 cmulionis , &. h'atlwnJS lurnCLUlt vere , quod to lum ex: grana libi dabatur,

pra:,epd [cnd¢lldi. IX otdiIUndi [e ad {upelo;lm- fed nl;l.luit tic habc~l:. Err:lL1ic aurem prad:ie:i recu-

I;'Ilia. . .611<10111301 IlQ ex pufiJuIlin1ltate am pigriti;l,quali

Nibilominu$ eJ, dilHs citca appaiturn w;uran- graUl:ln,:lut m .. lclbm Ilbi,fed ex: (upcrbia,quia vi~

di bea~iludi"em fUPCIIJ~tuuical\,manct c~plicatum r.!cb.1t illam VI gtatuim bcneficio d.ndam. & com-

CJu.rlirer Hie appclitUi fillcndi in l1;1mrali 'cxcdlen- munic~nd""11 aHis , quod in (lll n~furali cxctll~nda:

ria fucric pe-CCOltUtll. & propriiRime pl:COIUm Cu- nOll dlb~lU(; &. idcQ liC~t ipf,rior t!fl;:f. m;lgis ilia

pcrbi:c, vt D. Th.'" «rr +hUU41J.6;, :tftitmar.& fc- d~lecbb3tur, ,

qlfllntllt Q~nts aIlS diCcipuli, Ikc[ id ~esc:t Su.r. AJ (entndam didmr quod licet Angelus vera'

lilt'7,JI.Aff!!li.t c. u:put.lDS;!d~d ~t:(dlar!Uln ~uif- Jcf,~ndit ~C!i)lq'lCIl~ rup~do~~ bona, & Vt_ Allg.

{c cnorem Tpc:c.,utmuum quo ~U~II;:,l.fC:U1r bCall[~- fllpr.t CIt ,JIClt ~cJIti.VIt lid l'r~prttl. tanten in '.U'l ap~

clo fl.lpern'IlIl('!.l!s .. 'it nOll neccl1an~> aut non polltA prd~cllJiulle akcntli:b.1t • & magn;! negDd~riont:.

bilil.vd funtra. Et feqllumllt iplum Arrub~1 bie cOIl~ba[n~ allis oaelld~rc,t!.: fatisfacere, ic in hoc:

Jifp.17S.f'f.Bec;mu;,Mo1in~,EJlhill$. &: allj quos magis Dei limililLldin,m in~cndcre. qub,tDinll,.·

ciunt Salmanlkc:n{Cs C.UtnCliI. (" ... U. b Angtlis dependentcr ab cius gratia. minlllqllc prcl;3rio· ,&"

Jijf.lo,dllb. f JI.l.6J. Va(qu.:llltern hic difp,1H .(". f. magis fingul~riter>& 1l~1l I;nmrnullic::mJo. cun/in~

Iket pUtcr nau,l(:llcll\ bc.uirudillcm Vf e:rcdlentcm f~rioribus proecdebiu;& lie:: dt:berc orones hoc (0-,;

porniit':: tlf.: obiedum fupc~bi(l; in Angelo, recur- lWn procurau, Vf in fuanaturali c:rcclIcntia mane.,:

rir IaUl~n:!d iI1ufIl fimplkcm alft-d.um, quo poruit rent ree:uf:lIldo fup«natufalem. Vndein boe: nOIr

~bi Mpli,t~(~ (upctmtl.l'al~s ~1;3_tjp.l,d.o. vr p~r me- cra~ fo[mJlit~ pCc'atllm ornlllionis. [ed fupc{bb:,-

fUU''i1l1Iib!'". u.nqu.1m bbl dlfficlils. & motofl. q!ll~ nol'! (u)unl frallgcb;u .pr~C~ptum allirma-:

:1fqUt:iuq\llcr'~tc .... c in fint: ~himp in ella IIl[IJr;l- timu\\ tQmlcttcndi fc lupemnur~litn in Oeum.

1i ell~ellc:nda • quod caiilm cOllCt:dit AiarGQP 'fib. f~d ,politiuc ;lrpcreb3[ lIil~~1113.btre cx ~tatia (pe~

["pM dlrr.9·1;:~·n.6. " . Clali.IlCC conumlne.ClIm alm,ctl.lmli e;nutatiui! ~C ..

. Ego ;lUt~nt lUlCU (UpfiIU$ ditlot. 3lhrmo n:uura- ret meiius)quod eft PC:CCo1tU c6wiflionis (upe.rbi~.

Q_V.£ST.