Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 33

:

. , .



, ,
, - .
,
.
,
. , .
: , ,
, .
JEL: E6, H11, O1, O4, P4.

(1998 2009.)
.
20002008. 83%,
70%, 2 . 1999.
() 9,3. ., 1/4 ,
2008. 21,6 . . ( 78%
). ( )
: 0,6 2,7%. :
3,4, 2,8 .
( , ) ,
1998., .
20002008.
6,9%, (20092013.) 1,0%. ,
, ..., . - (-); (egurvich@eeg.ru),
. .-. ., ().
4


( %)
/

20002008

20092013

4,3

3,2

6,5

5,3

10,4
6,9
6,7
6,2
4,4
4,2
3,7

8,9
1,0
7,0
2,2
1,2
1,9
2,7

: (IMF, 2014).

,
(. 1.)
, :
(
) ( ).
, . 2012.
20132015. 13%,

4%. : 12 2%.

.
10 13% 1% , ,
, ( 20092013.
285 .).
,
.
, , ,
.
, ;
, , ,
. ,

, , .
20002013.

? 2 .
5

. , .


( %)

20002008 20092013 20002008 20092013

82,5
134,7
102,6
145,3
343,8
199,9
93,6
433,4

5,3
7,8
16,0
20,9
12,6
5,1
8,0
18,8

6,9
9,9
8,2
10,5
18,0
13,0
7,6
20,4

1,0
1,5
3,0
3,9
2,7
1,0
1,6
3,5

: .

,
, .
, .
, ,
- , .
,
,
, ,
.
,
- 1999.
( ).
1999., 17,2 ./.,
1990- : ( 1999.)
19,6 ./. 20002008. 5 15% ( 9,4%
). , 20102013.,
12,5 14,5% . ( 2001 2002.) 4% . 20122013.

(. 1).


20002013. 2,1 . ( 2013.).
0,9 ,
1,2 . , 7,5 1999. (,
).

.
2002.
6

: .

. 1

,
( 70%), (, 2010).

(
) 40 20002008.,
8 1.

.
: , 2008.

.
,
.
,
, , , ,
(. 3).
(

).


. .

(
). :
20002008. 8,5 (!) 27% .
1
, ,
, .

. , .


( %, 2000 . = 100%)

2008/2000

2012/2000

315
205
249
258
236
289
335
359

386
229
279
265
263
355
413
417

: .

,
2006. . , .
. (2013), 1%
0,22%.
20002008.
,
,
.
( 161
. 2000. 41 . 2008.)
.
,
. ,

(Fatas, Mihov, 2009),
(, 2006; 2013; Davis et al., 2003).
,

. ,

,
(Gonzlez et al., 2013).

.
,
, ,
,
,
.
2000 2013. (
, 2009. ..)
8

215 . ( 2013.).
, 10%
15%
. ,

3,5%.
,
,
, ( , 20002013.

).
-
,
.
,
. -,
,
(. 2). (20002007.)

20 !
-,
, .

.
(11% 1999.)
(7% 2007.).
, . ,
2006.
(

( .)

: IMF, 2014.

. 2
9

. , .

). :
,
, (,
).
2007.,
, (
1999.)
100 . , (), 1 ./.
1 .

. 3
,
, 11,3 20002008.
( 10 41% ). ,
. ,

46 ( 53% !).
4 ,

. , . (
300 .) 2007.,
250 . .


.
, , .


( %, 1 . 2000. = 100%)

: .

. 3
10



( . 2013.)

: .

. 4

2.
.
,
5 ..
, , ,
4 .. . ,
,
, .
, , 1,1 ..,
0,8 .. ,
, , , ,
2 .. 2009.,
( 7,8%) ( 0,5%).

. :
0,15 (Kuboniwa, 2012), 0,2 (Rautava, 2013) 0,240,25 (Ito, 2008;
Korhonen, Ledyaeva, 2010). . , 20012006.
2,5 .., 0,2 (Suni, 2007).


, 33,5% . , 6,9%

( ) .
3,54% 4,3%
.
.

11

. , .

( 2% ),
: 20002008.

50% (244%).

5. ,
2009.
0,57,
20092013. 0,93 (!).
( %)

: ; .

. 5

,

.
.
,
.
(
), , ,
1998.
2009.
, -
.
,
(Rautava, 2013),
(
) . , (World Bank, 2014).
, ,
.
12



, : -,
,
; -, ,
,
? , , ,
.
,

. 2000- ( , , ,
, )
(
,
).
, .
.

- - ,
, ,
().
, ,
( ) ,
. ,
,
., .

, 2000- .
2002. :
,

- , ,
.. , 2010.,
: 30% ,
( 1991.).

.



. 13

. , .

2012. 2,9% 3. , ,
. ,

.
,
(, 2010).
: , 20072010.
73%
92% .

:
,
. 4,
,
,
. ,
, . ,

,
.
: ,
, 2000.
10,6%, 2008. 9,6, 2012. 9,9%4.

. ,
:

2008
2012
2008
2012


21,1
21,7
25,7
24,1
27,1
31,8

4,5
15,9
13,8
5,5
25,9
21,8

26,1
24,2
18,2
25,0

: , 2014: . ./ .
., 2014.
3
2015
2016 2017 . www.minfin.ru/common/upload/library/2014/07/main/
ONBP_2015-2017.pdf.
4
, 2014.

14

,
( 2009.).
,
2000- ?
, , ?

(. 5).
, 20022008.
( ).

,
. ,
. ,
, ,
.

( %)

2001

2008

2013

0,88
0,28

1,21
0,30

1,02
0,33

0,94

2,67

2,81

: International Trade Centre.

.
6,
. 20032008.5 4,2% (
, 4,8%),
9,6% . ( 3,5 ), (
93 91% ).

. ,
, . ,
, ,
(. 6).

. ,
,

2002.

15

. , .

( %, 2002 . = 100%)

: .

. 6


( %)




1999

2008

2012

14,5
18,1
18,6
16,6
32,2

13,4
14,8
23,0
18,4
30,4

14,3
13,2
27,5
15,4
29,6

: .

(Oomes, Kalcheva, 2007; Dobrynskaya, Turkisch, 2010 .). ,


,
(Kuboniwa, 2012).
, , - .
,


(Beck, Laeven, 2006). ,
,
(De Rosa, Ioott, 2012).
. ,
, ,
( ,
, ..),
. ,
, (
, ,
..), ,

16

.
.
20092013. .
2011. , , .
, 2007.,
. ,
. ,
,
2013., 1,3%
15 ( 2009.).
: ,
? ,
.
.
2011. .
,
. ,
2014. , 20% (IMF, 2014) (.7).

()6, 2019. 80 ./.
,

(. 2013./.)

. 19651983. Arabian Light, 1984


2013. Brent,
, 2014.
: BP (BP, 2014) (IMF, 2014).

. 7
6
IEA Medium-Term Oil Market Report (MTOMR), June 2014. www.iea.org/publications/
medium-termreports/.

2. 12

17

. , .

,
.
2014. ,
.
,
,
(Jacks,
2013; Shafiee, Topal, 2010). 7,
( ) 30 .
,
. ,
15 .
. , 15
7.

, , .
. 2 ,
20092013. 400 .


. , ,
,
8.
. ,
9.
15 7%.
8% 2030.
.
.
. 20062013. 8 ..,
7,3 .. (. 8). ,
,
,
(
).
. 20082013.
2,6,
2,5 .
http://economy.gov.ru/minec/activity/sections/macro/prognoz/doc20131108_5.
World Bank Global Economic Prospects. June 2014. www.worldbank.org/en/publication/
global-economic-prospects.
9
www.gks.ru/wps/wcm/connect/rosstat_main/rosstat/ru/statistics/population/
demography/#.
7
8

18


( %)

: .

. 8

, 70%
,
. , .
2014.,
.


.
.
.
,
, .
,
, . ,
, , ,
. ,
,
, , .
,

. , , . ,
,
( )
.
,
, , .
,
2*

19

. , .

.

.
. ,
2030. 2,8%, 2030 2060. 1,2% (OECD, 2014).
(2013),
2,2%.
, ,
.
2014. ,
1,3% (IMF, 2014).
( 3,7 2,3%
),
.

. -,
, , . , .
,

. ,
( ), ,
,

.

,
, .
, .
(
),
. ,
, .
.

2018 10 ,
23% ,

. ,
,
, .
http://government.ru/info/761/.

10

20



. (Rodrik, 2010).

,
, ,
..
.
:
,
( ).
.
, ,

(, ).
: ,
, .
,
,
. , (
27% )
( 24% ). (
,
).
3,3% ,
7,5% . ,

, ,
,
30% . ,
.
?
, ( ,
, , ).
, ,

.
(, , ),
21

. , .

. ,
.
, , ()
( ) . , ,
:
, ,

( ).
79 . 20032008. ,

,
(Bogeti, Olusi, 2013).
, ,
(Vahabi, 2012). ,
,
. ,
(, Sharafutdinova, Kisunko, 2014),

, , . ,
. ,
, ,
(Karas et al., 2008). ,
, , .
( )
. , - ,
(.: Easterly, Fischer, 1994; Brixiov, Bul, 2002).
, ,
19601989. .

, .
,
, , ..

, ,

, .

.
22

.
(), ,
,
(, 1990).
,
( ,
, ..),
, , ..
( )
(Bartel, Harrison, 1999).

,
.
,
.

,
(
, ..),
.
, ,
.

. , ,
, (Ospina, Schiffbauer, 2010).
,
(Aghion, Bessonova, 2006). . ,


-

(, 2010). ,
,
,
,
( ).
,

, .
: , ,
, ,
23

. , .

(Hallward-Driemeier, 2009).

, .
,
2010. (Wang et al., 2010).
45 ( , )
3400. 3800 . . ,
39%
400 . .
: ,
40 . , (58% ),
( 63%), (80%) .


-
:
,
.
, ,
.
,
. , , ,

,
,
.
,
. , -
,

. , ,
,
.
.
, ,
,
.
/
( ).
,
24

( )

, (
), .. ,

( ). ,

, .

, ( 1998
20082009.).
,

. , 2014.,
,
.
, , 28 . ,
2014., .
, . ,
,
. ,
,
.
,

, . ,
, .
,
. -,
, , ,
( ) .
, . -,
,
,
(Warner, 2014). , -,

(
)
(Morozumi, Veiga, 2014).
, 1015 ,
(2730% )
(, ), (, 2002).
25

. , .

, .
, , , , ,
,
,
.
,
,
(), . ,
,
, 51 2012. 11 2018., 423 56.
.
, ,

.
.
,
2003. ,
,
. 2008.
155- 178 11.

, , ,
, ,
.
, .

.
, , .

1.
, (Libman, 2012). ,
.
2. ,
20052010., (Reisinger, Moraski, 2013). .
(2015) ,
, ,
, , .
11
Doing Business-2008/ World Bank. www.doingbusiness.org/~/media/GIAWB/
Doing%20Business/Documents/Annual-Reports/English/DB08-FullReport.pdf.

26


3. 1199 21.08.2012.,
. , ,
.
, ,
.
4.
.
,
.

(Alexeev, Kurlyandskaya, 2003).
,
, , .

1. 120-
144 (, 2014). ,
.
2. 111-
144 (, 2014).
3. ,
20% 20% 1020
( ., 2007). -
, .
. ,
, .
4.
, (. 7)12.

.

, 2012.

9,1
41,2
16,2
35,2
65,4

10,3
76,0
28,1
51,4
73,9

: , 2014.

12

, 7, 50
, .

27

. , .

,
( ), ,
,

, .
.
, .
,
,
13. ,
,
14.
, ,
.
,
,
. 8 ,
,
( ).
, ,
8 ,
,
. ,

. , ,
, .


.
, (2013) .
, ,

:
;
;
;
,
;
13
.
(2012) . (2013), -2020 (2013).
14
7 2012. 596 ; 7 2012. 601
.

28


,

,

1) 01.12.2012. ,
50% ,
( 596).
2) 01.03.2013.
( 596).
3) ( 20122013 .
728., 86 .).
4) 2016.
, ( 596).
5)

( 596).
6) .
01.09.2012. ,
()

( 596).
1) 01.09.2012. , ( 601).
2) 01.01.2013 .
, ,
-
,
: , ; (
601).

:
;
;

.
(-2020, 2013. . 23).
1)
.
2)
.
1) 01.10.2012.
( 596).
2) 01.12.2012.


( 596).
1) 01.01.2013.
()
,
( 601).
2) ,

(-2020, 2013. . 18).

29

. , .


,
(
, 2013.).
1) ,
.
2) .
-
,
- .
( )
- ,


(
20142016.*)
1) , 2013.,
-
( 596).
2) 01.06.2012.


1 . ( 596).
01.12.2012 . , ,
(

596).

, ,
. .

2014

2016.* , :


;
;
.

, ,
.


*
20142016 . www.kremlin.ru/acts/18332.

, .
:
) ;
)
;
) .

,
, .

.
30

, ,
. ,
. , -,
, ; -,
; -,
.
, :
) (
1000
, ); )
,
; )
.
, :
,
;
;
(
) ;

;
;
.
,
. , ,
.
, -, ,
, 2015.,
; -,
, . ,

,
.
(.: -2020, 2013; , , 2012; , 2011).
, .
,
.
.
, , .
, ,
31

. , .

,
.
, . ,
. ,

. , - 30
( ).
,
, .
, :
;
-
;
,
.
8 , .
(
,
).

, , ,
. .

2,5% (, 2012).
.
3050%,
4060% (Hsieh, Klenow, 2009). ,
.

( , ,
) 6% 13% (Bouis, Duval,
2011). ). : ,
1 .

,
. ,
(Christiansen et al., 2009). ,
, ,
.
32

, , . , .

.
1. ,
(
20002013. 2 .) .
,
,
. -
, .
2. ,
.
.
3.
,
- .
,
,
.
4. , , , .

,
, .
5. ,
.
.


, .
6. , ,
. ,
,

.
7. ,
,
.
3. 12

33

. , .


. . (2010).
//
. 1. . 106127. [Bessonova E. V. (2010). The Impact of Internal Competition and Foreign Investments on the Efficiency of Russian Industrial
Enterprises// Prikladnaya Ekonometrika. No 1. P. 106127.]
(2014). 20142015/ . [WEF (2014). The Global Competitiveness Report
20142015/ World Economic Forum.]
., ., . . (2007).
. .: . [Golikova V., Gonchar K., Kuznetsov B. et al. (2007).
Russian Industry at the Crossroads. M.: SUHSE.]
. (2010). // . 11. . 424. [Gurvich E. (2010). Natural Rent in the Russian Oil and
Gas Sector// Voprosy Ekonomiki. No 11. P. 424.]
. (2011). // .
4. . 431. [Gurvich E. (2011). Roadmap for the New Pension Reform//
Voprosy Ekonomiki. No 4. P. 431.]
. (2013). // . 3. . 732. [Gurvich E. (2013). Long-Term Development
Prospects for the Russias Economy// Ekonomicheskaya Politika. No 3. P. 732.]
., . (2013).
// . 9. . 439. [Gurvich E., Prilepskiy I.
(2013). How to Secure External Sustainability of the Russian Economy// Voprosy
Ekonomiki. No 9. P. 439.]
(2013).
: , , . -. [Institute for the Rule of Law (2013). Law Enforcement Activity in Russia:
Structure, Functioning, Ways of Reforming. St. Petersburg.]
. (1990). . .: . [Kornai J. (1990). Economics of Shortage.
Moscow: Nauka.]
. (2006). : //
. 2. . 2845. [Kudrin A. (2006). Stabilization Fund:
Foreign and Russian Experience// Voprosy Ekonomiki. No 2. P. 2845.]
. . (2012). //
. 2. . 5972. [Kudrin A. (2012). What We Expect from aNew
Government// Ekonomicheskaya Politika. No 2. P. 5972.]
. (2013). // . 3. . 419. [KudrinA.
(2013). The Influence of Oil and Gas Exports on Russias Monetary Policy//
Voprosy Ekonomiki. No 3. P. 419.]
., . (2012). //
. 3. . 5279. [Kudrin A., Gurvich E. (2012). Population
Aging and Risks of Budget Crisis// Voprosy Ekonomiki. No 3. P. 5279.]
. . (2002). , 19611990.
. [Ponomarenko A. N. (2002). Russias National Accounts in Retrospect,
19611990. Moscow.]
(2012). : // . 6. 553. [Russian
Presidential Academy of National Economy and Public Administration (2012). The
Consequences of Weak Competition: Quantitative Evaluation and Policy Implications (Think Tank Report)// Ekonomicheskaya Politika. No 6. P. 553.]
-2020 (2013). -2020:
. . 12. .: . [Strategy-2020 (2013). Strategy-2020: ANew Model
of Growth New Social Policy. Vol. 12. Moscow: Delo.]
34


. (2015).
: , // . 1 [].
[Yakovlev A. (2015). Incentives in the System of Public Administration and
Economic Growth: The Experience of USSR, China and Russia// Obshchestvo
iEkonomika. No 1 (forthcoming).]
Aghion P., Bessonova E. (2006). On Entry and Growth: Theory and Evidence// Revue
de lOFCE. Vol. 2006/3. No 97 bis.
Alexeev M., Kurlyandskaya G. (2003). Fiscal Federalism and Incentives in aRussian
Region// Journal of Comparative Economics. Vol. 31, No 1. P. 2033.
Bartel A., Harrison A. (1999). Ownership versus Environment: Why Are Public Sector
Firms Inefficient// NBER Working Paper. No 7043.
Beck T., Laeven L. (2006). Institution Building and Growth in Transition Economies//
Journal of Economic Growth. Vol. 11, No 2. P. 157186.
Bogeti ., Olusi O. (2013). Drivers of Firm-Level Productivity in Russias Manufacturing
Sector// World Bank Working Paper. No WPS6572.
Bouis R., Duval R. (2011). Raising Potential Growth after the Crisis: AQuantitative
Assessment of the Potential Gains from Various Structural Reforms in the OECD
Area and beyond// OECD Working Paper. No 835.
BP (2014). BP Statistical Review of World Energy, 2014.
Brixiov Z., Bul A. (2002). Growth Slowdown under Central Planning: AModel of
Poor Incentives// William Davidson Working Paper. No 448.
Christiansen L., Schindler M., Tressel T. (2009). Growth and Structural Reforms:
ANew Assessment// IMF Working Paper. No WP/09/284.
Davis J., Ossowski R., Fedelino A. (eds.) (2003). Fiscal Policy Formulation and Implementation in Oil-producing Countries. Washington: IMF.
De Rosa D., Ioott M. (2012). Are Natural Resources Cursed? An Investigation of the
Dynamic Effects of Resource Dependence on Institutional Quality// World Bank
Policy Research Working Paper. No 6151.
Dobrynskaya V., Turkisch E. (2010). Economic Diversification and Dutch Disease in
Russia// Post-Communist Economies. Vol. 22, No 3. P. 283302.
Easterly W., Fischer S. (1994). The Soviet Economic Decline: Historical and Republican
Data// World Bank Policy Research Working Paper. No 1284.
Fatas A., Mihov I. (2009). Macroeconomic Policy: Does It Matter for Growth? The Role
of Volatility// Commission on Growth and Development Working Paper. No 48.
Gonzlez A., Iacovone L., Subhash H. (2013). Russian Volatility Obstacle to Firm
Survival and Diversification// World Bank Policy Research Working Paper.
No6605.
Hallward-Driemeier M. (2009). Who Survives? The Impact of Corruption, Competition
and Property Rights across Firms// World Bank Policy Research Working Paper.
No 5084.
Hsieh C.-T., Klenow P. (2009). Misallocation and Manufacturing TFP in China and
India// The Quarterly Journal of Economics. Vol. 124, No 4. P. 14031448.
IMF (2014). World Economic Outlook. October. Washington.
Ito K. (2008). Oil Price and Macroeconomy in Russia// Economics Bulletin. Vol. 17,
No 17. P. 19.
Jacks D. (2013). From Boom to Bust: aTypology of Real Commodity Prices in the Long
Run// NBER Working Paper. No 18874.
Karas A., Schoors K., Weill L. (2008). Are Private Banks More Efficient than Public
Banks? Evidence from Russia// BOFIT Discussion Papers. No 3.
Korhonen I., Ledyaeva S. (2010). Trade Linkages and Macroeconomic Effects of the
Price of Oil// Energy Economics. Vol. 32, No 4. P. 848856.
Kuboniwa M. (2012). Diagnosing the Russian Disease: Growth and Structure of the
Russian Economy/ Institute of Economic Research, Hitotsubashi University//
Japan Comparative Economic Studies. Vol. 54, No 1. P. 121148.
Libman A. (2012). Democracy, Size of Bureaucracy, and Economic Growth: Evidence
from Russian Regions// Empirical Economics. Vol. 43, No 3. P. 13211352.
3*

35

. , .
Morozumi A., Veiga F. (2014). Public Spending and Growth: The Role of Institutions//
NIPE Working Paper. No 11/ 2014.
OECD (2014). Economic Outlook No 95: Long-term Baseline Projections. May.
Oomes N., Kalcheva K. (2007). Diagnosing Dutch Disease: Does Russia Have the
Symptoms?// IMF Working Paper. No WP/07/102.
Ospina S., Schiffbauer M. (2010). Competition and Firm Productivity: Evidence from
Firm-Level Data// IMF Working Paper. No WP/10/67.
Rautava J. (2013). Oil Prices, Excess Uncertainty and Trend Growth. AForecasting Model
for Russias Economy// Focus on European Economic Integration. Q4/13. P.7787.
Reisinger W., Moraski B. (2013). Deference or Governance? ASurvival Analysis of
Russias Governors under Presidential Control// Russias Regions and Comparative
Subnational Politics/ W. Reisinger (ed.). London: Routledge. P. 4062.
Rodrik D. (2010). Diagnostics before Prescription// Journal of Economic Perspectives.
Vol. 24, No 3. P. 3344.
Shafiee S., Topal E. (2010). ALong-term View of Worldwide Fossil Fuel Prices//
Applied Energy. Vol. 87, No 3. P. 9881000.
Sharafutdinova G., Kisunko G. (2014). Governors and Governing Institutions. ACompa
rative Study of StateBusiness Relations in Russias Regions// World Bank Policy
Research Working Paper. No 7038.
Suni P. (2007). Oil Prices and the Russian Economy: Some Simulation Studies with
NiGEM. Helsinki: The Research Institute of the Finnish Economy.
Vahabi M. (2012). Soft Budget Constraint and the Parastatal Sector// MPRA Paper.
No 37926.
Wang M., Rieger M., Hens T. (2010). How Time Preferences Differ: Evidence from 45
Countries// Swiss Finance Institute Research Paper. No 09-47.
Warner A. (2014). Public Investment as an Engine of Growth// IMF Working Paper.
No WP/14/148.
World Bank (2014). Russia Economic Report No 31. Washington.

A New Growth Model for the Russian Economy


Alexey Kudrin1, Evsey Gurvich2,*
Authors affiliation: 1 St. Petersburg State University (St. Petersburg, Russia);
2
Economic Expert Group (Moscow, Russia).
*Corresponding author, email: egurvich@eeg.ru.

The recent slowdown of the Russian economy has fundamental roots and
cannot be overcome by simple measures like alleviation of monetary or fiscal
policy. The major impediment to growth is marked weakness of the market
environment, explained primarily with dominance of state-owned and quasi-state
companies. Strong incentives for efforts to enhance efficiency by both business
and public administration are required. The key objectives of policies needed to
develop anew growth model are listed.
Keywords: growth model, oil and gas revenues, soft budget constraints,
incentives for growth.
JEL: E6, H11, O1, O4, P4.

36