Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
1.0 Introduction
5.0 Conclusions
APPENDIX
REFERENCES
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
1.0 Introduction
The logic of marketing is shifting from the exchange of goods toward intangibles
service, interactivity, connectivity and ongoing relationships (Vargo and Lusch, 2004).
Many companies have recognized and managed customer as assets and adopting
customer-centric strategies, programs, tools and technology for efficient and effective
CRM and etc have been introduced for commercial application. The majority of these
tools promise to provide individual applications and services allow company to focus
Organizations that invest in flexible, proven CRM solution will position themselves
for success both today and tomorrow (http://www.finchannel.com/, 2009). So, what
is CRM? Simple explanation, CRM is putting customer at the heart of the business. In
this report, we will study further on the conceptual foundation for understanding the
the definition and importance of CRM, CRM framework and contemporary practices
of CRM with KM environment. The main objectives of this report are as below:-
Page 2 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Over the past decade, the information technology (IT) vendor community and
Management (CRM). The terms “relationship marketing” and CRM are often
with selective customer to create superior value for company and the customer
(Parvatiyar and Sheth, 2001). Vavra (1992) defined CRM as seeking customer
retention by using a variety of after marketing tactics that lead to customer bonding or
staying in touch with customer after a sale made. Some even said CRM meant a
loyalty card scheme, a database, a help desk or a call center. Definition of CRM is
description of CRM (Figure 1); Payne and Frow (2005) had summarized as below:
Page 3 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
According Customer Think Corporation (2004)’s survey, 68% of customers leave due
to service problem (Figure 2). Therefore establishing and strengthening long term
relationships with customer is the key to success. CRM is important to pursue mutual
benefit among customers and sellers. Customers can enjoy personal treatment,
together with appropriate advice on getting the best out of their purchase; while the
firms are able to improve retention and increase the volumes sold. In fact, CRM also
helps to simplifying the sales processes and helping sales staff to close deal faster.
The organizations are able to provide greater opportunity for cross-selling and up-
selling to their customer who is loyal and committed to firms through CRM. This will
helps the organization to improve the quality of its relationship management with
Research shows that acquiring a new customer cost 5 to 10 times more than retaining
an existing one, and Cannie and Caplin (1991) also suggested that keeping customers
for life rather than with only making a one time sale.
rapidly, the most prudent way to keep track of customer change and appropriately
Page 4 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
CRM also creates new knowledge sharing platforms and processes between
companies and their customers. Many case study evidence proven that CRM is a
There is a consensus from marketing, sales and services that data are highly valued;
but information has no value if it is not transformed into knowledge (Oubrich, 2003).
leverage the value insight. KM can be defined as the process of extended knowledge
becomes key value added resources shares among the company; however, CRM
proposed an additional dimension that “if only we also knew what our customers
know” (Gibbert et. Al., 2002). CRM may seem just another name for KM, but it can
2002).
CRM process required customer knowledge to pursue the goals of relationship market
(Bueren et. Al, 2005). Belbaly et. Al (2007) argued that customer knowledge creation
enables the management of the knowledge embedded in the new product development
process. There are three sorts of knowledge required in CRM process which play an
importance in the interaction between a firm and its customers (Bueren et. Al, 2005 &
Salomann et. Al, 2005). Firstly, knowledge about customer (needs and wants) is to be
Page 5 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
products and firm is to support buying cycle. Thirdly, customer posses’ knowledge
knowledge in CRM processes; this is proven that KM capabilities in a firm play a key
KM is useful for CRM activity and it has become strategic resource of organization to
maintain their competitive advantages. Furthermore, CRM and KM having the same
goals to provide an organization with the information on their customers’ wants and
needs; it is help to identify their valuable customer, generate quality sales lead, and
Page 6 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
literature, common sense, and experience (Eisenhardt, 1989). Due to the different
influences may leads to the different development of CRM framework, but there is no
one “right” CRM framework for every business sector (Duane, 2009). Many
researchers have addressed that the integrated and comprehensive framework should
Payne et al. (2005) develops a framework for CRM based on five generic processes:
(1) the information management process, (2) the multichannel integration process, (3)
the value creation process, (4) the strategy development process and (5) the
review on Payne et al. (2005)’s CRM frameworks combining with actual CRM tools
CRM now has to support a wide range of roles, channels and devices in order to
support and adding value to a wide network of partners, customers and employees.
Basically, CRM activity will involve collecting customer, suppliers, partners and
other relevant data through multiple channels such as web, phone, fax, email and etc
vision and objectives must be clearly identified (the strategy development process) in
order to transforms it into programs or business process that deliver value for the
customer, business and associated co-creation activities (the value creation process).
Page 7 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
The CRM process cycle for next step was to interact with customer through multi
process). Finally, proper monitoring processes are needed to safeguard against failure
and helps to keep track the alignment of goals, results, and resources (performance
assessment process).
processes, supported by integrated technology across the enterprise and its supply
chain which provide the right information at the right time (Radcliffe, 2001). To
ensure that technology solutions support CRM, CRM tools must be making tradeoffs
must match to the needs of the business. However, CRM tool is just a supplement to
The strategy development process shall include basic steps of strategy formation,
decision making and implementation. Bell (2000) points out that understanding the
present allows people to attain an orienting perspective to provide a basic for moving
forward. Hence, the strategy formation for CRM shall be based on the company
mission and objective with taking into consideration of value creation for customer,
Page 8 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
employees and investors. Then, decided on the long term plan and operating plan
based on the objectives set. Finally, take necessary action to effect implementation.
customer needs; to identify existing and potential customer profitability for decision
on customer acquisition and customer retention activities; and the organization's value
strategy and value creation into value-adding interactions with customers. These
include all pre-sales communications, the sales interaction, post-sale service and
support with the customer. Now days, there are many channels option available in the
market such as field sales forces, internet, direct mail, business partners and telephony;
important for company to define distinct channel roles and tailoring them to the needs
Everywhere”.
Page 9 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
The performance assessment process covers the essential task to monitor CRM
indicators is aligned with the objectives set; which helps managers collectively
formulate plans, make decision and guide ongoing daily activities. Kaplan & Norton
(2001) pointed out that the traditional financial measurement tools such as profit and
loss statements, balance sheets and cash flow statements are measuring the past
activities and are “lag” versus “leading” indicators. Since companies implement the
measurement methods very differently based on their internal decision making styles,
involving the point of view from a variety of different business units. The CRM
Page 10 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
(This part of report is solely used for academic purposes only and it should not be
AirAsia is the largest low cost carrier with the widest route connectivity in Asia.
AirAsia recognized as the lowest fares, quality services and dependability LCC; and
with the unmistakable tagline, “Now Everyone Can Fly” (Annual Report 2008).
AirAsia is working out with five fundamental values – Safety, Valuing Our People,
“The most important thing about great customer service is ensuring that the customer
has an opportunity to speak with you” said Tony Fernandes, Group CEO of AirAsia;
and he strongly believes that CRM is a very useful tool if managed well. Many types
of CRM tools in the market, but the common CRM framework for airline will be as
Page 11 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
AirAsia has invented to new CRM system in March 2009. Ideally, CRM system is
analyzing the information gathered to gain insight into each customer’s needs and
behavior, and used it to improve the customer’s dealing with company. But in actual
fact, is AirAsia able to mange well their CRM system? In this section, we will analyze
AirAsia has an effective CRM system to address the route that has proven to be high
yielding and delivered sustained profit. In fact, AirAsia has identified and expected
the Malaysia to Singapore route can delivered a sustained profit and will double up
the destinations link to Singapore by end of 2009. By the way, AirAsia also identified
their high value customer, and provide loyalty program to serve them better.
/AK.htm (Figure 7), out of 98 customer review, 36% of the rating is below 5. The
main reasons for low rating are flight cancellation without notice (48%), poor
customer service or call center (22%), flight delay or change schedule without notice
(17%), and others (13%). This is proven that AirAsia only managing the early part of
the customer life cycle and neglecting service after sales and very little attempt on
customer complaints.
Buying patterns are analyzed; customer will receive email or sms to suggest the
destination of interest with travel guide in website for their decision making.
Page 12 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
AirAsia has customized their service after sales by providing variety choice and
travelers; whereby AirAsia had predicted that some of corporate sector wish to cut
airline provided by Siebel and IBM on 2005 (Figure 6). But base on the customer
reviews (Figure 7), it justify that the call center and customer care emails is not
analyzing knowledge about customer. In AirAsia website, we can see that information
The deficiency analysis (Figure 8) shows that AirAsia is focus on targeting marketing,
merchandising, promotions, general information and other issue while have very little
Page 13 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Based on the review of situational analysis of AirAsia’s CRM system, AirAsia has a
"satisfactory" standard of core Product across most travel categories - but reflects
Without a doubt, poor or inconsistency services won’t have a relationship in long run.
philosophy to improve quality and reduce cost parallel with CRM system.
The simple objective of TQM is “Do the right things, right the first time, every time;
always striving for improvement and always satisfying the customer” (DOD, 1989 ).
Application of Deming Management techniques (Figure 9) may hold the potential for
improving both management practices and the quality of services provided through
AirAsia.
Failure Mode Effect Analysis (FMEA) is a globally recognized best practice risk
planning tool widely used by automotive, medical, banking, business and so on.
way by using FMEA rather than waiting for complaints from customers.
Page 14 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
FMEA analyses potential failure modes, potential effects, potential causes, assesses
current process controls and determines a risk priority factor. The purpose of the
FMEA is to evaluate processes for possible failures and to prevent them by correcting
the processes proactively rather then reacting after failures have occurred.
has done well on event notification; repurchase reminder, reward information and
portion that AirAsia miss out is service follow up. Service follows up such as a thank
you or a satisfaction check is to ensure that each customer leave with a smile on their
face, a feeling of having been well taken care of and for having purchased just what
Satisfaction guaranteed but not a guarantee, regular studies or market research shall
customer is our most important source of knowledge (Bill Gates). The results will
Make sure customers are recognized at all contact point rather than early part of
customer life cycle. Customers’ time is precious, respond quickly to customer queries
Poor service after sales and problem on customer complaint is mostly due to front line
staff can’t timely decisions nor effectively facilitating customer dissatisfaction and
defection. Front line staff such as flight attendant (FA), customer services staff shall
Page 15 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
be provided training on better knowledge and soft skill on customer service and
communication skill to deliver service excellence. Basically, front line staff shall have
good listening skills, problem solving skills and to be proactive and anticipate
customer problems.
Employees should be evaluated on their ability to deliver high level of service, and
expectations.
Assessment of results in CRM helps to safeguard against failure and mange conflicts
CRM performance; rather than only based on market share and total volume of sales.
The Balanced Scorecard (Figure 10) will allow AirAsia to monitor present
performance and tries to capture information about how well the organization is
Good assessment procedures shall included the periodic evaluation of goals and
results, initiating changes in the relationship structure if needed, and creating a system
We truly are in an era of transformation. If AirAsia do not give their customers some
good reasons to stay, their competitors will give them a reason to leave. The ability to
address these customer need, it will not only exhibiting best practices, but also to
Page 16 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
5.0 Conclusion
companies and their customer. However, the process cannot be completely enabled by
technology; it can only be done when the technology and KM are deployed. The
skill, customer service skill, and the ability to abstract, analyze, understand and act
ongoing, continually improving, and consistent results and this requires the active
reasons. When they fail it’s often because they lack of knowledge about CRM and
used to leverage the customer-centric vision across all departments and employee
levels. Key success lies on ensuring that customer experience is relevant, personalized,
“It is central to our philosophy as a company that provides 5-star service… every
single one of our staff is taught and encouraged to put our customer first” said Dato
Abdul Aziz (AirAsia Annual Report 2008). Understanding these attitudes is just the
start for AirAsia; it is an art to leverage this insight in the marketing effort. Bear in
mind that technology solutions is just a tool, but understanding the mind of the
customer goes far beyond technology, and it is a challenge yet to be widely met.
Page 17 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
APPENDIX
Figure 1
No. Definitions and Description of CRM Author
CRM includes numerous aspects, but the basic theme is for the company
5 to become more customer-centric. Methods are primarily Web-based Gosney and Boehm, 2000
tools and Internet presence.
Figure 2
Page 18 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Figure 3
Key Variables KM CRM
Employee, team, company, network of
Source of knowledge Customer database.
companies.
Unlock and integrate employees' knowledge Mining knowledge about the customer in
Rationale
about customers, sales processes, and R&D. company database.
Performance in terms of customer satisfaction
Objectives Performance against budget
and loyalty.
Figure 4
Page 19 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Figure 5
Page 20 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Figure 6
Figure 7
9% 7
Poor
11% 8 Customer
Service /Call
9 Center
10 22%
Sources: http://www.airlinequality.com/Airlines/AK.htm
Page 21 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Figure 8
IT KNOWLEDGE
MANAGEMENT
Moderate Moderate
- IT system is linked to most - Effectively targeting
customer touchpoints. market by analysing
- Call centre and customer care knowledge about customer.
email is no respond or inactive. - Providing information on travel
- No email / sms on flight guide, and recomemdation for
cancellaion or change schedule. customer to decide before purchase.
- Little effort on improvement plan for
customer feedback.
Page 22 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Figure 9
Figure 10
Page 23 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
REFERENCE
Bueren, A., Schierholz, R., Kolbe, L., and Brenner, W. (2005), Improving
performance of customer processes with knowledge management business, Process
Management Journal (11:5), pp. 573-588.
Cannie, J.K. and Caplin, D (1991), Keeping Customers for Life, Chicago: American
Marketing Association.
Croteau, A.M. and Li, P (2003), Critical Success factors of CRM Technological
Initiatives, Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences, 20, 1, 21-34.
Duane Sharp (7 Apr 2009), CRM Issues and Methodologies: Many Issues Need
Addressing in Early CRM Implementation Stages, http://customer-
relations.suite101.com/article.cfm/crm_issues_and_methodologies
Glen Urban (2005), Don’t just Relate – Advocate! A Blueprint for Profit in the Era of
Customer Power, Wharton School Publishing
http://www.airasia.com/site/en/pressRelease.jsp?id=1052e16f-c0a8c85d-eb784700-
8636418f&type=read
http://www.airlinequality.com/Airlines/AK.htm
http://www.finchannel.com/Main_News/Tech/49029_Leading_Organizations_World
wide_Choose_Microsoft_Dynamics_CRM/ (2009)
Kale, Sudhir H. (2004), CRM Failure and the Seven Deadly Sins, Marketing
Managemnt, Vol. 13, pp42-46
Kaplan, R.S. & Norton, D. (1992), The Balanced Scorecard – Measures that Drive
Performance, Harvard Business Review, 70, 71-79.
Page 24 of 25 20Nov2009
Knowledge Management (MGT 503) – Individual Coursework
Payne, Adrian and Pennie Frow (2005), A Strategic Framework for Customer
Relationship Managemnt, Journal of Marketing, Vol. 69, pp 167-176
Radcliffe, John, “Eight Building Blocks of CRM: A Framework for Success”, Gartner,
December 13, 2001
Salomann, H., Dous, M., Kolbe, L., and Brenner, W. (2005), Rejuvenating Customer
Management: How to Make Knowledge For, From and About Customers Work,
European Management Journal, (23:4), pp. 392-403.
Vargo, Stephen L. and Robert F. Lusch (2004), Evolving to a New Dominant Logic
for Marketing, Journal of Marketing, 68(1): 1-17.
Vavra, Terry G. (1992), Aftermarketing: How to keep customer for life through
relationship marketing, Homewood Ill.: Business One Irwin.
Page 25 of 25 20Nov2009