"Вестник общественного мнения" № 1-2 (117) за 2014 год

. .
12(117)
4 . 18-

(-)

()
:
..
..
..
..
.
..
..
:
..
( )
..
..
( )
..
..
(. )

87847
2014

.

37
.

( ISSP)
50
.
(
. )
66
. :

83
, .
, :

96
.

106
:
. :

115
.
124
.
130
.
135
.
141
.
2012
155
..
.
..
198
IN MEMORIAN
(31.12.1946-20.08.2014)

:
SUMMARY
209
210
211
252

..
,
. .

..
(-)
109012, , . , 17. . : (499) 755-40-30
E-mail: direct@levada.ru
()
119571, , . , 82. .: (495) 564 8582

,
77981 10 2003 .
-, , 2008 ISSN 2070-5107
The Russian Public Opinion Herald

Data. Analysis. Discussions
12(117)
Quarterly
Analytic Centre
Yury Levada
(Levada-Centre)
The Interdisciplinary
Academic Centre for
Social Sciences
(InterCentre)
Januaryjun 2014
CONTENTS
MONITORING OF CHANGES: PRINCIPAL TRENDS
PROBLEMS OF MODERN RUSSIAN SOCIETY

Stability of social justice perceptions in public opinion (by Luidmila
Khakhulina)
37
Public Perceptions of Fairness and Efficiency in the Health Care

Systems of Different Countries (ISSP 2011) (by Olga Karaeva)
50
The perception of prices by the patients as the key point in medicine

marketisation (case of Moscow dental market (by Elena Berdysheva)
66
Social expulsion of migrants from the Russian society: law and practice
(by Anna Morgunova)
83
Members of
the Editorial Council
Abel Aganbeghian
Anatoly Vishnevsky
Leokadia Drobizheva
Natalia Rimashevskaya
Teodor Shanin
Vladimir Yadov
Yevgenii Yassin
Editorial Board
Lev Gudkov
(Editor-in-Chief)
Alexei Grazhdankin
Ludmila Khakhulina
(Deputy Editor-in-Chief)
Marina Krasilnikova
Natalia Zorkaya
(Executive Secretary)
How Contract Workers Find Clients and Companies Choose Freelancers:

An Empirical Analysis of Self-Employment in Contemporary Russia
(by Maxim Markin and Elena Nazarbaeva)
96
Current status and problems of Russian secondary vocational education
(by Diana Migunova)
106
THE POST-SOVIET SPACE: CIVIC MOVEMENTS
Beyond the Nation-State: Indirect impact of Nationalist Movements
onPublic Opinion in Belarus and Ukraine (by Marharyta Fabrykant)
115
Belarusian Maidan: is it possible? (by Sergej Nikolyuk)
124
Belarusian respond to the Ukrainian challenge (by Sergej Nikolyuk)
130
Euromaidan. Before and After the victory (by Vladimir Paniotto)
135
Protest and self-organization (by Alexej Levinson)
141
OccupyAbay protest street camp in Moscow in May 2012 through

the eyes of its participants (by Denis Volkov)
155
IN HONOUR OF TATIANA ZASLAVSKAYA

Soviet competition with capitalism in the fate of Tatiana Zaslavskaya
(by Alexander Nikulin)
198
IN MEMORIAN
Boris Dubin (31.12.1946-20.08.2014)
209
Authors of the issue
210
INFORMATION: SURVEYSFINDINGS
211
SUMMARY
252
1. (
;
)*
4,8
4,6
4,4
4,2
4
3,8
3,6
3,4
3,2
3
2,8
2,6
2,4
2,2
2
1,8
1,6
1,4
1,2
1
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0
. 94
. 94
. 94
. 95
. 95
. 95
. 96
. 96
. 96
. 97
. 97
. 97
. 98
. 98
. 98
. 99
. 99
. 99
. 00
. 00
. 00
. 01
. 01
. 01
. 02
. 02
. 02
. 03
. 03
. 03
. 04
. 04
. 04
. 05
. 05
. 05
. 06
. 06
. 06
. 07
. 07
. 07
. 08
. 08
. 08
. 09
. 09
. 09
. 10
. 10
. 10
. 11
. 11
. 11
. 12
. 12
. 12
. 13
. 13
. 13
. 14
. 14
* 1, 3-6, 8 2008 . N=2100, 2009 - N=1600.

N=1600
2013 . 2010 . , , .
2014 . ,
(1994-2014 ). .
12 (117) 2014
2.
,
? ( % )
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 14
. 14
13
. 12
. 12
. 11
. 11
. 09
10
09
. 08
. 08
. 07
. 07
06
. 05
. 05
. 04
. 04
. 02
03
02
. 01
01
. 00
. 00
99
. 98
. 98
. 97
. 97
96
3.

?

100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
,
12 (117) 2014
14
13
. 12
. 11
. 11
. 09
10
. 07
. 07
06
. 05
. 05
04
. 03
. 03
02
. 01
01
. 00
. 00
99
. 98
. 98
97
. 96
. 96
95
. 94
. 94
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
. 14
. 13
. 12
. 11
. 12
. 10
. 10
. 09
. 08
. 08
. 07
. 06
. 06
. 05
. 04
. 03
. 04
. 02
. 02
. 01
. 00
. 00
. 99
. 98
. 98
. 97
. 96
. 96
. 95
. 94
. 94
.
. , 2008 ., , .
4.
. ,
, ?*;
,
? ( % )
60

50
40
30
20
10
. 14
. 13
. 14
. 13
12
. 11
. 11
. 10
10
. 09
09
. 08
07
. 07
06
. 06
05
. 05
. 04
04
03
. 03
02
. 02
01
. 01
00
. 00
. 99
99
98
. 98
. 97
97
96
. 96
95
. 95
. 94
94
* 1997 . , ?
12 (117) 2014
. , , /
(, , ) ?*;
,
? ( % )
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 09
. 09
. 10
10
. 10
. 11
11
. 11
. 12
12
. 12
. 13
13
. 13
. 14
14
94
94
. 94
. 95
95
. 95
. 96
96
. 96
. 97
97
. 97
. 98
98
. 98
. 99
99
. 99
. 00
00
. 00
. 01
01
. 01
. 02
02
. 02
. 03
03
. 03
. 04
04
. 04
. 05
05
. 05
. 06
06
. 06
. 07
07
. 07
. 08
* 2001 , , / () , , , ?
, 2012 ., ,
(
)
.
5. ( )
3,6
3,4
3,2
3
2,8
2,6
2,4
2,2
2
1,8
1,6
1,4
1,2
1
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0
. 14
. 13
. 13
. 12
11
. 10
. 10
09
. 08
07
. 06
. 06
05
. 04
. 04
03
. 02
. 02
01
. 00
. 00
99
. 98
. 98
97
. 96
. 96
95
. 94
. 94
,
,
12 (117) 2014
. ,
(. . 3)
, .
6. ?
,

4,2
4
3,8
3,6
3,4
3,2
3
2,8
2,6
2,4
2,2
2
1,8
1,6
1,4
1,2
1
0,8
0,6
0,4
0,2
0
14
13
. 13
. 11
12
11
10
09
. 09
08
. 07
07
06
05
. 05
04
. 03
03
02
01
. 01
00
. 99
99
98
. 97
97
96
95
. 95
94
. 93
93
7. ?
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20

10
04
. 04
. 04
. 05
. 05
05
. 05
05
05
. 05
. 05
06
06
. 06
. 06
07
07
. 07
. 07
08
. 08
. 08
. 09
09
. 09
. 09
. 09
. 10
. 10
10
. 10
. 10
. 10
. 11
. 11
11
. 11
. 11
. 11
. 12
12
. 12
. 12
. 13
13
13
13
. 13
. 14
14
14
12 (117) 2014
8. ?
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
,
09
. 09
. 10
. 10
. 10
. 11
. 11
. 11
12
. 12
. 13
. 13
. 13
. 14
. 14
. 94
94
. 94
. 95
95
. 95
. 96
96
. 96
. 97
97
. 97
. 98
98
. 98
. 99
99
. 99
. 00
00
. 00
. 01
01
. 01
. 01
02
02
. 02
03
03
. 03
04
04
. 04
05
05
. 05
06
06
. 06
07
07
. 07
08
9. , , 56 ,
( % , ,
3%, )

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.

,

2008
I
VII
1
2
3
3
10
9
14
5
9
9
23 10
1
1
2
3
2
3
3
6
39 36
5
3
4
4
65 54
2
1
<1
4
3
2
2
17 16
8
13
2009
I
VII
2
2
4
3
10
11
2
2
9
9
7
6
1
3
6
6
3
4
4
6
42
41
3
3
2
3
56
53
1
2
3
4
2
2
13
16
15
15
2010
I
VII
2
2
4
4
9
10
2
3
8
9
3
6
2
3
4
6
2
2
3
3
39
39
4
3
4
3
48
48
2
2
3
4
1
1
13
15
17
16
2011
I
VII
3
4
4
3
10
14
2
2
9
11
5
3
3
2
6
8
2
2
3
8
39
35
3
5
8
7
4
4
1
44
40
2
1
4
4
5
1
4
15
21
19
21
2012
I
VII
2
<1
3
1
12
10
2
<1
12
11
3
2
5
3
5
4
1
1
5
3
28
22
8
4
7
3
4
2
8
5
41
41
1
1
4
3
3
2
2
1
11
11
17
18
2013
I
VII
1
<1
2
1
10
9
1
<1
11
10
3
1
2
3
4
4
2
2
4
4
21
15
4
3
5
5
2
2
6
5
38
38
2
2
5
4
3
4
2
2
18
18
19
18
I
1
1
8
1
9
2
2
6
3
2
13
3
5
2
5
34
2
3
3
2
19
19
2014
IV
<1
1
9
<1
7
1
1
17
3
3
16
3
5
1
2
53
3
4
2
2
23
13
VII
1
1
11
1
10
2
2
16
4
5
18
3
4
2
2
55
2
4
2
1
22
13
10
5
14
6
14
6
15
7
17
5
18
5
23
5
16
6
14
6
14
6
13
6
17
6
15
5
12 (117) 2014
16
7
22
4
10. . . ( % ,
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 00
00
. 00
. 01
01
. 01
02
02
. 02
03
03
. 03
04
04
. 04
. 05
05
. 05
06
06
. 06
07
07
. 07
08
08
. 08
09
09
. 09
10
10
. 10
11
11
. 11
12
12
. 12
13
13
. 13
14
14
2008 .( - )
. , . . , 2008 . .
.
11.
?
?
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 99
. 99
. 00
. 00
. 00
. 01
. 01
. 01
. 02
. 02
. 02
. 03
. 03
. 03
. 04
. 04
. 04
. 05
. 05
. 05
. 06
. 06
. 06
. 07
. 07
. 07
. 08
. 08
. 08
. 09
. 09
. 09
. 10
. 10
. 10
. 11
. 11
. 11
. 12
. 12
. 12
. 13
. 13
. 13
. 14
. 14
()
()
()
12 (117) 2014
()
12. ?
100
90
,
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
,
14
. 14
. 13
13
. 13
12
. 12
. 12
. 11
11
. 11
10
. 10
. 10
09
09
08
. 08
. 07
. 08
. 07
. 07
07
07
. 07
. 06
. 06
06
06
. 06
06
. 05
2014 .
, , ,
, .
13.
?
100

90
80
70

60
50
40
30
20
10
10
12 (117) 2014
14
14
. 13
13
13
12
. 12
12
. 11
11
11
. 10
10
10
. 09
09
. 09
. 08
. 08
. 08
. 07
. 07
07
07
07
. 07
. 06
. 06
06
06
06
. 06
. 05
14. (), 2008 . = 100%

110
100
90
80
70
60
50
. 14
. 13
. 13
12
11
. 11
. 10
10
. 09
. 09
08
. 07
. 07
. 06
05
. 06
04
. 04
. 03
. 02
03
. 02
01
. 00
. 00
. 99
98
. 99
97
. 97
. 96
. 95
96
. 95
40
90-
() . , ,
, ,
. , , ,
, , , .
, . , , ,
.., , (!) .
, .
( ) , (
), , .
, ,
, , .
:(1) ,
(2) . .
, ,
,
( - ).
90- , ,
, . 2002. , .
, , .
(), (),
() (). , .
( ) .
, , , , .

12 (117) 2014
11
( ),
. , , , ,
.
( ) . 2008.
.
( - ). ( , )
, , . 2008. (
). .
, 2011. ()
, ().
. , ,
,
, .

( , ), () ( ).
.
, , . () , , ( ).
( ),
( - ).
, , ,
. ( 2014.) ,
.

15. (), 2008 . = 100%

110%
90%
70%
12
14
14
. 14
14
. 13
. 13
13
13
. 13
13
. 12
. 12
12
12
. 12
12 (117) 2014
12
. 11
. 11
11
11
. 11
11
. 10
. 10
10
10
. 10
10
. 09
. 09
09
09
. 09
09
. 08
. 08
08
08
08
50%
()

()
()
()
2013
99
2014
98
2014
102
2014
103
2014
110
2014
107
101
99
102
105
107
107
99
97
101
102
112
107
,
, .
, , ,
, , . 10%
, ( ()
112 , 107 ).
107 ,
- , 2008.
( 2014 87% 2008.).

. .
. , .. ,
, 2008..

16.
: ? ? ( ).
. 18 ,
. , 1989 (. 1).
1

60
55
50
45
40
35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
. 94 . 95 . 96 . 97 98 . 99

. 00
. 01
. 02
. 03
. 04
12 (117) 2014
. 05 . 06
. 07
. 08
. 09
. 11
13
1996 : , , , 1989 (. 2). 1998

1998 : , (. 3). 1999 (.4) (.5, 6).
: 5 ,
,
(.7). 2012
(.8).
1989
2
3
1989 1993
1989 1996
1
2
1
2
3
4
4
5
5
6
6
7
8
9
10
10
4
1989 1998
5
1989 1999
1
2
1
2
4
5
8
9
9
10
14
12 (117) 2014
10
6
1989 2000
7
1989 2004
1
2
1
2
3
3
4
4
5
6
7
7
8
9
10
10
8
1989 2008
9
1989 2012
1
2
1
2
3
5
6
6
7
8
9
10
10
. ,
, , ; , , , .
.
, , ; , ,
.
. ,
, .
, ,

12 (117) 2014
15
,
.
, ( ) .
, , , . , ( 1998 )
. ,
, ,
: , , , .
13 . , 2,5 . .
, :
. , ,
: , , , ,
, .
, - . , . , :
1998
, .
2008
, . , , . , :
, ,
. , 2006 26% ,
,
2007 (. . 1). ,
, ,
. ,
. , ,
.
. , .

16
12 (117) 2014
-
I. : - *

1. ?
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 14
14
14
. 14
13
12
11
10
09
08
07
06
05
. 04
03
. 02
01
00
. 99
. 98
2. ? ( )
100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 14
. 14
. 14
. 13
. 12
. 13
* () . 2040 , ( ) ( 2014 .)
, 18 .
12 (117) 2014
17
3.
?
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 14
14
14
. 14
. 13
13
. 13
. 12
12
. 12
. 11
11
. 11
.10
10
. 10
. 09
09
. 09
. 08
08
, , ,
, ,

4. ? ( )
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
. 14
. 14
. 14
. 13
. 12
. 13
, , ,
, ,

5.
,
( -)
,
( )
06
09
14
14
14
14
10
22
32
21
71
68
59
52
48
53
11
15
10
21
10
12
14
18
12 (117) 2014
6. ..?

( -)
14
14

( )
14
14
10
12
29
39
15
10
50
47
56
59
10
10
10
II. *

1. ?
13
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
13
18
12
12
20
16
15
21
35
44
46
48
46
45
48
49
40
40
31
29
30
34
29
29
30
17
10
10
()
18
2. , ? ( % ,
)
14* 14 14 14 14 14 14
26
36
31
30
33
37
34
53
45
50
49
47
45
48
, , ,
15
10
12
12
10
3. ? ( )
14 14 14 14 14
94
92
91
94
93
, ,
21
24
26
27
25
- (, , )
16
22
17
18
17
12
13
11
15
12

9
12
10
11
11
9
11
9
11
8
1
3
2
2
2
<1
1
1
1
1

1
1
1
1
1
* , 14* 14*
12 (117) 2014
19
4. , ,

14 14
16
20
47
50
25
18
4
2
9
10
14
22
48
18
3
9
14 14 14
34
29
2
45
45
12
12
14
44
2
3
22
7
10
21
14
3
9
40
30
19
14
4
14
34
30
18
5. ,
. , ,
?
,
,
,

14
15
10
58
17
14
17
12
54
18
, ,
6. ,
?

14*
9
35
28
10
19
14
17
36
21
11
15
14
18
33
23
12
14
7.

?
14

,
, ,

20
12 (117) 2014
35
34
12
19
8. ,
,
?
14 14
14
14 14*
58
54
41
41
43
- , ,

28
34
42
41
41
10
10
12
11
9. ?
14
57
31
6
1
4
14
54
36
4
1
5
10.
?
14
31
34
19
47
3
1
<1
3
7
1
,
,
,

14
30
38
23
46
3
<1
<1
3
11
2
11.
?
14*
14
14
86
88
86
12 (117) 2014
21
12. ?
14
-
- ,

6
85
9
13. , ,
?
14
14
14
,
,
79
75
80
, , ,

15
13
11
11
14. ,
? ( )
14
14
62
54
39
36
32
34
, ,
,
18
15. ,

, ..
**?

-

,

14
14
14
14
7
19
33
19
17
6
5
12
29
30
19
5
5
15
28
28
19
5
8
11
28
32
16
4
** 2014 , , ..,
?
22
12 (117) 2014
16.
?
14
14
14
27
28
21
46
51
48
10
13
10
17. , ?
14 14 14 14
17
19
16
15
25
29
22
15
18
19
20
20
24
29
26
37
17
16
12
18. ,
?
,
,

14
28
26
14
7
26
19.
( )?
14

20
27
27
18
12 (117) 2014
23
20. ()
,
?
.14

2
11
28
48
11
21. , ,
?
.14
,

37
35
5
14
9
22. , ,
?
-
-

-
-

14
51
26
10
2
1
9
14
61
24
7
1
<1
7
23. ,
?
14
23
53
13
11
14
36
45
10
9
24. ?
24
14*
37
46
10
3
5
12 (117) 2014
14
24
42
18
7
8
14
32
45
12
7
3
14
31
43
18
3
4
25. ,
?
14
4
24
39
16
9
8

/ ,

14
3
15
40
24
11
8
14
3
13
34
28
13
8
26.
?
14
36
38
11
2
13
14
30
39
11
5
14
14
17
38
18
11
16
14
13
28
23
20
16
27. , ?
14
34
57
9
14
26
59
15
28. ?
14
,
, ,

55
31
14
-
29. (,
)? ?
14

35

25
,
21

6
,

13
12 (117) 2014
14
26
36
14
23
41
14
21
40
17
17
18
15
12
16
25
30. ,
-
?**
,
,
,
,

14*
49
30
10
2
9
14
38
29
15
4
15
14
25
33
21
9
12
14
21
30
24
7
18
** - , ..?
31. ,
?
14
24
48
8
3
17
32.
- ?
14

64
20
33. ,
?
14
- , -
,
51
44
30
, , ,

27
, -

22
<1
26
12 (117) 2014
34. ,
?
14
10
39
21
6
26
14
11
39
21
8
21
14
12
44
16
5
23
14
12
38
22
8
20
35. ,
- ?

14
15
44
14
6
21
14
16
43
15
5
22
14
17
38
18
4
23
14
17
38
14
9
22
36. , -

14
14
14
14
14
14
36
48
9
2
6
36
46
10
3
5
26
42
19
7
6
26
40
23
6
5
21
33
23
15
9
21
31
27
13
8
37. , ?
,
,
,
,

17
15
24
33
12
15
17
25
31
12
38. , ,
?
*
5
13
25
50
7
12 (117) 2014
5
12
25
50
8
27
39. ,
?
*
2
9
19
62
8
2
7
22
64
5
40.
?

14
14
24
37
15
4
20
20
44
13
6
17
41. ,
.

-
(, )

( )

28
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
14
, , , ,
53
37
5
2
47
39
8
3
34
55
7
<1
47
45
3
2
46
42
6
2
22
48
15
5
42
37
12
4
36
37
14
6
3
3
4
3
5
9
5
7
14
17
41
20
12
10
14
14
14
14
14
14
29
26
11
16
10
41
35
32
20
24
16
40
17
19
32
24
34
12
8
12
24
21
27
4
11
11
14
16
14
4
12 (117) 2014
42. ,
,
, , ?
14*
9
36
28
10
17
43. -
?
14
38
15
18
12
16

,
, ,

44. ,
?
14* 14 14 14 14

22
36
47
40
30
**
14
14
11
17
21

13
10
14
11
17

25
12
11
8
15
<1
2
1
2
1

27
27
16
22
17
** 2014 . : .
45. ,
?
14*
, ,
, , ,
,
, ,
26
52
10
<1
12 (117) 2014
29
:
46.
?
14
3
27
35
8
26
7
14
4
28
40
9
25
4
47. ,
?
14
,

,

58
20
13
10
48. , ?
14 14 14 14
,

63
24
13
52
34
14
59
34
9
53
38
9
49. ,
,
,
,
,
,

,
,

, ,

,

**
14
75
12
13
14
67
20
13
14
61
24
16
14
55
32
14
14
60
22
19
14
55
30
15
14
68
17
15
14
66
20
14
14
36
46
18
14
38
47
15
14
20
63
17
14
25
60
16
* .
** .
30
12 (117) 2014
50.
12
5
7
9
10
6
11
5
8
8
10
7
4
7
7
5
9
8
6
7
7
44
28
35
29
28
26
42
31
34
29
26
25
22
29
26
31
36
28
25
27
23
30
48
43
40
42
40
31
42
40
39
43
39
45
40
37
42
35
37
39
37
38
9
1
12
18
16
25
9
17
16
21
18
27
23
21
27
15
17
23
27
26
29
6
5
3
4
4
3
7
4
3
3
4
3
6
3
3
8
4
5
5
3
3
51. ,
?
, , ,

**
,

14*
14
38
23
13
12
13
29
20
15
13
8
15
**
52. , ?
14*
,
,
,
,

5
20
38
26
11
12 (117) 2014
31
53. , ,
, ?
14*

39
33
12
10
54.

?
14

36
42
55. -
?
14

63
27
56. , -

?
14

49
32
10
32
12 (117) 2014
57. ,
, ,
?
14
35
41
15
9
58. , ,
, , ,
?
14
34
/
, ,
, ,

, , ,
,
,
29
12
3
8
14
59. ?
14
23
19
45
()
() , , /
() ,
,

10
4
III.
1. ,
,
?

,

12 (117) 2014
07
42
14*
61
30
27
28
12
33
2. 10 ,
, ?
12
25
32
34
9
14*
44
22
25
9
3. ,
( ;
)
14

,
,
34
7
10
14
14
21
6
9
5
4
12
21
12
8
16
5
8
6
8
10
12
16
15
17
20
23
24
30
15
47
41
44
44
48
27
18
13
10
17
25
13
9
16
5
6
4
3
3
4
6
2
2
3
5
3
5
7
-40
-31
-31
-31
-28
-22
-9
-8
-5
-5
-4
-1
-1
0
1
2
2
5
7
8
9
13
14
17
18
21
26
12 (117) 2014
. 98
12 (117) 2014
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
. 06
10
10
. 09
09
. 09
. 08
. 08
. 07
. 07
07
07
07
. 07
. 06
. 06
06
06
06
11
14
14
. 13
13
13
. 12
12
12
14
14
. 13
13
13
. 12
12
12
. 11
. 11
. 11
11
11
. 10
. 10
6. ?
10
10
09
. 05
. 05
. 09
05
05
. 90
. 93
99
. 99
. 99
00
. 01
. 01
. 02
02
. 02
03
03
03
. 03
. 04
. 04
04
. 04
. 05
. 05
05
. 05
. 06
. 06
06
. 06
. 07
. 07
07
. 07
. 08
08
. 09
09
10
. 10
11
. 11
12
. 12
13
. 13
14
. 09
. 08
08
. 08
. 07
10
. 07
. 05
05
10
07
. 03
. 04
20
. 07
. 07
. 06
. 06
06
06
06
. 06
. 05
. 05
05
05
05
. 05
. 04
. 03
. 02
. 01
00
90
4. ?
80
70
60
50
40
30
10
5. ?
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
35
36
12 (117) 2014
14
. 13
13
13
. 11
. 09
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
. 12
. 11
11
. 11
. 10
10
. 10
. 09
09
. 09
. 08
08
. 08
. 07
07
. 07
. 06
06
. 06
. 05
05
. 05
. 04
04
. 04
. 03
03
. 03
. 02
02
. 13
. 14
. 14
14
14
14
13
. 13
14
. 12
. 13
. 13
12
5. ?
13
13
13
. 13
. 12
. 12
12
12
12
. 12
. 11
. 07
11
11
. 01
. 02
06
07
. 07
10
11
10
. 11
. 10
10
. 10
. 09
. 09
09
09
. 07
. 07
. 06
06
. 06
05
03
00
. 99
. 98
10
. 06
06
06
. 05
03
00
. 99
. 98
97
95
4. ?
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
6. ?
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20

.
,

. ,
,
70%
, 5%

.
, ,
.

, , ,
,
. ,
,
.

, , , ,
, ..,
,
.

.

, , ,
, ,
.

, . ,
,
,
.

- .

, . .

. ,
, ,
.

,
.
,
, ,
12 (117) 2014
37
1.
,
, 20
2000- ,

.
1991, 1996, 2003 2009 ,
,

2.

, , .
,
.
. . , . . , . .
. ,
,

.
, ,
.
, ,
. Social Justice and Political Change
(ed. J.Kluegel, D.Mason, B.Wegener; N.Y.Aldine de Gruyter),
.
90- . . . ., 2003, .77103. ., ., . .
: . : , 6, 1996, . 19-26
2
, 1991 1996 ,

-, 2003
2009.
1
38
,
.
20 ,
.
,
,
,
.
,
,
.
, ,
,
.

1990- 2000 ,
.

: (), .

,

.
.
- , (. 1). ,

10 .. ( 6% 17%)
,
.
12 (117) 2014
1
,
- ? (% )
100
80
60
52
51
37
40
34
20
15
20
32
29
27
42
11
17
10
2003
2009
9
0
1991
()
1996
,
(. 2).
,
, (
40%),
: 1991
, 2009
. 3
,
.
()
20 ,
, , ,

,
.
,
,
, .
-
2
, , ,
, , ? (% )
100
14
80
10
12
27
21
16
24
35
60
8

()
40
20
43
46
43
1991
1996
2009
()
12 (117) 2014
39
.
,
(1991 .) ,
21 % , 29% ,
19% .

43%.

, ( 80%)
90- , :
, (.3).
()
: ,
, ,
, (.4). , -
, , . ,
( ,
). ,

.
,
:
,
, , ,
.
, ,
. ,

3
, , , ,
? (% )
91
88
100
87
81
80
()
60
40
()
20
0
1991
1996
2003
2009
4
, , ,
? (% )
100
84
79
80
76
73
()
60
()
40
20
4
11
16
0
1991
40
1996
2003
12 (117) 2014
2009
( , ,
, ), 2000- . , ,
. ,

, , ,
,
, ,
,

. ,
.
,
, , ,
, ,
,
(.5).
,
,
, . , 50% 1991
,
,
, - , ,
.
2000-
:

, .

, 20
(- ), . 2000- 2/3
20
, ,
, ,
, .
.
,
1991 . ,

20 ,
,
, ,
, , .
, , ,
. ,

(.7).
(.6). 1990-
, 5-6

5
,
? (% )
100
80
60
60
60
()
65
50
()
40
31
24
20
22
14
14
1996
2003

18
14
0
1991
2009
12 (117) 2014
41
6
, , ,
? (% )
100
16
21
80
28
50
60
6
()
40
17
63
51
20
28
()
0
1991
1996
2009
, ,
. 90-
60% ,
2009 40%.
, ,
,
(.8).
,
,
: - , , ,
.
,
.
.

, (, ), (, , ).
- . ,
, (, ).
, ()
, ,
,
7
, ? (% )
100
80
63
60
67
()
57
55
40
()
24
20
14
17
23

14
16
14
1996
2003
16
0
1991
42
2009
12 (117) 2014
8
, ? (% )
100
80
60
()
56
57
59
42
()
40
22
20
11
19
26

18
26
17
17
1996
2003
0
1991
. .
20 , ,
, ,

.
, , ,

,

.
,
1, ,
, (. 9).
90-,
: 58% 1991 20%
2009 .,
(6% 39%).
.
, ( ),
,
, ..
10% 10%
1991 2003 . 4,5 14,3 . . : , , . . 2005,
. 39.
1
2009
,

.
.
90- , -,
.

20
(. 10). ,
, ,
. 90-

. , , , , ,
.

38%.
,
, ,
, , .
, ,
-
12 (117) 2014
43
( ) . .
,
,
. , ,

.

,
, 1.

, , ,
,
,
,
, . , - ,
90- ,
,

,
.
9
, , ? (% )
100
()
80
58
60
41
38
39
28
29
22
20
11
13
12
1996
2003
2009
()
40
24
20
12
34
15
6
1991
10
, ,
? (% )
100
80
()
58
60
37
38
40
38
20
19
38
27
16
24
()
35
18
7
1991
1996
2003
2009
.
, . 307-318.
1
44
12 (117) 2014
, ,
,
,
(.7, 8). , , , ,
.
, , ,
, .
, , ,
, , .
,
( ,
, ).

(,
,
). :
,
,
, , .. .
,

, , ,
(, , ).
- ,
, ,
,
.

,
,

( ,
,
, , ).

80- 90- .
20 .

.

.
,

, . ,

. ( ).

.
,
. ,

, ,
.
,
, .
/
.
12 (117) 2014
45

, .
,
. ,

, (
).
,
.
, ,
. 20

, , ,
, .

: , , ,
.
, ,
, , - ,
, . , , .
, . , .
,
,
.
,
, , , .
. ,
20%
, 50% , -
46
. (, 2012.)
, , .
,

( 8-12% )1.

, ,
, , .
90- ,
, , 1996 ,
(.11).
13
12.., ,
10 ..

, , ,
,

.

, ,

.

,
.
, , , ,
.

,
1
. , . 2007, . 320.
12 (117) 2014
11
, , , , (% )
100
80
60
22
29
32

13
16
16
40
()
59
20
51
47
2003
2009
()
0
1996
.
90-
: 40% , ,
, , 43%
(. 12).
, , ,
90- .
10%
, 1.
, ,

, -
.
, , ,
,
,
.
2009 ,
( 2001 20,5% (
))2,
.

,
, ,
, .. ,
. 1.
2000- -
12
, , , (%
)
100
80
31
43
58
60
40
20
14

()
12
40
13
51
()
24
0
1996
2003
. . 2003,
.89.
2009
12 (117) 2014
47
31,4 .1.
2009
(58%) ,
, ,
.
.

,
. ,
1991 2/3 , , ,
.
2000- , .. 10
,
45-47%. ,
,
, , (.13).
.
2000-
90- .
90-. 2000-

,
, ,
. ,

, .
, ,
90- ,
,
.
, 20 :
1) - ,
(
, )
.
,
, , , ,
, .
2)
,
.

, , , -
13
, , , (%
)
100
12
80
60
22
6
6
24
38
6
30

12
13
18
40
()
60
58
20
45
47
2003
2009
()
0
1991
1996
: , , .
., 2005, . 147-148.
1
48
12 (117) 2014
,
. , , .

, , ,
: , , .
20
, , , ( ,
, , (. 14). -
, ,

. , ,
, ,
,
, , (.14).
14
, , , (% )
100%
90%
20
80%
70%
17
60%
12
11
22
19
12
19
50%
()
40%
30%
57
54
50
1991
1996
2009
20%
()
10%
0%
) .
, ,

.
3) 20

,
( ). , , , .
, :

,
.
4) 20
,

***

,

. , ,
,
,
.
,
- ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
, , , , , , .
12 (117) 2014
49

( ISSP)
,

.
. . ,
.

.
, .
,
, ,
.
, ,

.
,
,
. -,
. -,
,
,
.

,
.
,

, , .
50

.

, , , .

, , .
, , .
1 (1) (
), (2) (3)
.
( )
. ,

, ,

.
- ,
-, , , .
Tanner M. The Grass Is Not Always Greener: A Look at National Health
Care Systems Around the World // Policy Analysis. 613 (March 18,
2008), InLiberty URL: http://www.inliberty.
ru/library/study/1392.
1
12 (117) 2014

.

, .

,

.
, . 1, ,

. .2,
,

. . 3,

,
, ,
.
, .
, ,

. ,
,

.
. . .: , 1998.
2
. : . ./. . .
... . 2-.-.: , 2010. 536.
3
. , / ; .
. . . . .. .: ,
2008. 424.
1

(The International Social Survey
Programme, ISSP4) 2011
.
,

.

, .

, ,

.

,
,
.

XIX XX
(. , . ,
.).
, .

, .

, , , , ..5
,
,
.
- 1991 , . http://www.issp.org/.
5
Waltzer M. Spheres of Justice, 1983, . : Healy K. Last Best
Gifts: Altruism and the Market for Human Blood and Organs. The University
of Chicago Press, London and Chicago, 2006.
4
12 (117) 2014
51
, ,
, ( )
,
1. ,
.

,
.
,
2.
,
, ,
,
.

,
,
.

. .3. , ,
, .

,
, .
,

.
, , ,
, .
Healy K. Last Best Gifts: Altruism and the Market for Human Blood and
Organs. The University of Chicago Press, London and Chicago, 2006, p. 6.
2
Castro De L.D. Commodification and Exploitation: Arguments in Favour
of Compensated Organ Donation // Journal of Medical Ethics, Vol. 29, No. 3
(Jun., 2003), pp. 142-146.
3
Titmuss R. The Gift Relationship. From Human Blood to Social
Policy, 1970, . : Steiner P. Gifts of Blood and Organs: The Market
and "Fictitious" Commodities// Revue franaise de sociologie, Vol. 44,
Supplement: An Annual English Selection (2003), p. 149.
1
52
, , , .
,

, ,
, 4.
, ,
,

, .
,

,
, ,
5.

,

.
, ,

.
XIX .
6,
, ., . . .: . , 2013, . 5960.
5
.. :
// (
), 2012, . 13 (1).
6
. :
XIX / / ( ),
2010, . 11(2), . 60.
4
12 (117) 2014
. , ,

.
,

,
1.
,
.
,
.

. ,
,

.
1200$, , .
, .

,

2.
,
, ( , ) ,
3 .

, ,
.
, 65.
Zahedi F. Fazel I. Larijani B. An Overview of Organ Transplantation in Iran
over Three Decades: With Special Focus on Renal Transplantation// Iranian
J Publ Health, Vol. 38, Suppl. 1, 2009, p. 146. URL: http://journals.tums.
ac.ir/upload_files/pdf/_/13384.pdf.
3
. : , , /
. .. . .: -, 2007.
1
2
. . 4,

. , ,
, ,
.
,

,

.

,
,
. ,

( XIX ). .

, .

, .
1881 .
.
,
, .

.

, ,
.
. ,
. . : / . . . . .:
, 2006. . 134.
4
12 (117) 2014
53

.
.

.
- , .

.

.
, 1960-

.
,
, .
,
.

,
, 1.

.

.

.

,

. .
, ., . . .: . , 2013, . 71.
1
54
,
(
-
) . ,
,
- , -
.

.

.

,
, .
, .
,

,
.
.

, .
,

. , ,
,
.

,
. ,
, , ,
,
,

.
12 (117) 2014
, , ,

,
.
,
? ,

? (
)
?

,
.

.

ISSP
2011 .

, . ,

,
,

.

5 : , , ,
.

, , , ,
, , , .
,
. ,

.
, .

, , .

.
, ,

, , . ,
,
(reimbursement), ..
, .
, , , .
,
( ).

,
, , .

, .
. ,
,
.
,

,
.

, , , .
12 (117) 2014
55

, .

.
.
, ,
.

,

.
,
, .

,
,
(. 1).
10%
,
,
3,8% .

(), ,

, 1.

: ,
.
.
, , , ,
2. , ,
- ,
.

.
1
( % )
90
79
79
81
82
81
81
80
%
82
80
83
80
80
78
77
75
76
76
74
81
79
74
12
74
69
69
70
53
60
50
40
30
10
6
9,7
9,5
9,4
9,3
7,8
20
6,9
6,8
6,7
6,6
6,6
4
6,1
5,8
5,4
5,1
10
4,1
4,1
3,9
3,8
3,7
3,2
1,3
2
0
: United Nations Development Programme: Human Development Report 2010. Life Expectancy Index2012; The
World Bank. World Development Indicators,2012.
/
, URL: http://www.who.int/healthsystems/ru/.
2
.., .. . - .: -, 2012.
1
56
12 (117) 2014

.
,

.
,
, ISSP.
, .
ISSP, 90%
.

54% . , ,
(17%), (15%), (14%) (11%).
,
.
, , ..
,

90% ,
( 2).

( ),

.

8% .

. ,
, (26%),
( 36% ).

,
. , 45% , .
,
, .
,
, .

,
-
2
, 5
( 100%, .. )

36
52
22
93
82
78
44
26
30
36
23 1 18
90
8 64
90
464
12 (117) 2014
57
,
, (
).
ISSP,
,
. , 60% ,
, . , ,
,
. 15%.
,
. ,
,
60%

. ,
,
.

,
, ,
60%.
,

, , ,
. . ,
,

,
(.4).
,
,
(51% 42%),

.

20%
.

. -
3

71
62
68
62
64
61
59
42
38
29
21
15
58
12 (117) 2014

(35%). (66%, 75%),
, .

. ,
, (56%),
(. 5).
50% , ,
. , ,
. -

. ,

,

.
, ,
. ( ) , , , , ,
,
.
-
4
,
5
86
89
79
77
72
68
77
71
66
60
57
43
40
27
24
23
18
35
5
5
58
56
52
45
38
34
26
23
24
33
27
27
12 (117) 2014
59
,
, ,

(.6). , 57% , ,
. 65%.

, ,
, . ,
, ,
, 35%
. 15%, 60% .
,
,
, ,
,
. ,
,

.
,

. , ,
, .
,
,
. , ,

.

. ,

.
,

,
,
.

.

, ,
,
.
, .
65
57
47
46
60
35

: "

,
"
15
12 (117) 2014

1:
,
.
,

.
, .
, , , ,
.
,

.
, :
, 2. , ,

, , -
.
, ,
(. 7). 20%
.

.
,

.
.

.

.3
.
( 53% 73% -
7
, ,
, 3.
60

50
48
47
45
46
41
40
33
30
20
24
21
20
17
17
12
12
10
17
9
12
9
11
6
20%
18

(2040%)
28
25
19
14
(4060%)
, ., . . . : . , 2013, . 49.
2
. . - [] / .
. .. ; . . .. ; . . - . .: . ,
2014, c. 10.

(6080%)
20%
TOPBOT ( 10- )
.
3
12 (117) 2014
61
).
. ,
, 1.
,
.

.
,
- , .
, ,

.
,
,
, , .

. ,
20%
(.1). ,
,
,
30 36% 15 18%
.

:
(, , ) ,
.

.
(, , ), ,
.
, , - .

/
, ,
(. 2).
,
,
,

.
, , , , , , .
1
: , (% )
21
18
15
15
30
36
61
69
72
70
55
47
18
13
13
15
15
17
.. : ,
, ( )//
. 2011. 4, .5 .
1
62
12 (117) 2014
2

(% )
89
91
82
90
72
88
87
72
74
80
65
89
59
55
61
65
53
73
82
92
83
89
72
83

,

.
, , ; ,
30 70 ; , (. 8).
,
, ,
,
.
,
, -
,

.
48% 37% .
,

.

.
29- , ,
.
8

(30 VS 70 ), () .

38
37
35

61

49
48
(30 70 )

68

54
58
" "

65
51
59
60
58
63
58
65
75
12 (117) 2014
63
,
,
.

, ,
(14%),

.
.
,

.
.
,
,
(33% 37%) , .
,
. ,
.

,
. (.9). , 85%
, , , , 60%
,
.

.

(95%),
.
.
,
.

.
, .
,

(22% 24%). ,
,
(
).
,
9
(% )
95
79 80
65
55
30 30
49
43
64
58 56
52
44
61
41
33
24
86
31
23
19 22
30
64
12 (117) 2014
.
,
,
,
. ,

.
-
,
.
.
, , -
.
, .

, ,
,
.

, .

,
. , , ,
,
.
,
, .
,

. ,
.

.
, , ,
,
.
,
, ,
,

.
,
-

29- . ,
, ,
,

.
,

.
,
.
. .

,

, .
12 (117) 2014
65

( . )1
. ,
,
,

, ,
, ..
, , , , ,

. 1
, ,
. 2.
, ,
.
,
.
-,

.
, , ,
, .
,
3.

. ,
11-010162 ?: . ( ), 2012-2013 .
2
Timmermans S., Almeling R. 2009. Objectification, Standardization,
and Commodification in Health Care: A Conceptual Readjustment // Social
Science and Medicine. 69: 2127.
3
Walzer Michel. 1983. Spheres of justice. New York Basic Books Inc.
1
66
, ,
4. , ,

5,
XIX
..6 , ,
,
,
,
.

.
-, ,
,
, 7.
,
,
,
. ?
, ?
-,

.
Hughes Donna. 2000. The "Natasha" Trade. In the Shadows: Promoting
Prosperity or Undermining Stability? // Journal of International Affairs.
53(2): 625-651.
5
Zelizer Viviana. 2000. The Purchase of Intimacy. Law and Social Inquiry.
25 (3): 817848.
6
Zelizer Viviana. 1994. Pricing The Priceless Child: The Changing Social
Value of Children. Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University Press.
7
Mandel R., Humphrey C., eds. 2002. Markets and Moralities:
Ethnographies of Postsocialism. New York: Berg.
4
12 (117) 2014
.

,
.
, -, .
,
1. -

. ,
, 2.

.
,

3.

.

.
.

.
,
( , , ); ,

,

4.

(judgmental process),
5.
, 1 Morgan M. 1991. The Doctor-Patient Relationship. In. Graham Scambler
(Ed). Sociology As Applied To Medicine. - London, Bailliere Tindall.
2 ., , .., .. (2014)
: //
. 2. 154182.
3
Espeland W., Stevens M. Commensuration as a social process // Annual
Review of Sociology. 1998. No. 24. Pp. 312-343.
4
Callon M., Muniesa F. 2005. Economic Markets as Calculative Collective
Devices. Organization Studies. 26 (8): 1231.
5
Forsberg P. 2009. Testing Prices in Markets. How to Charter a Tanker //
Ethnography. 10(3): 267..
6.
, .
,
, .
,
7.
, ,
,
. ,
,
.

.
, , 8.
,
,
.
, ,
,
9.
Muniesa F. Market technologies and the pragmatics of prices // Economy
and Society. 2007. Vol. 36. No. 3. Pp. 381.
7
Zelizer Viviana. 1994. Pricing The Priceless Child: The Changing Social
Value of Children. Princeton, N.J.: Princeton University Press; Zelizer
Viviana. 2000. The Purchase of Intimacy. Law and Social Inquiry. 25 (3):
817848.; Espeland W., Stevens M. Commensuration as a social process //
Annual Review of Sociology. 1998. No. 24. Pp. 312343; Karpik L. Valuing
the Unique: The Economics of Singularities. NJ: Princeton University
Press, 2010; The Worth of Goods: Valuation and Pricing in the Economy
(eds. P.Aspers, J. Beckert), New York: Oxford University Press, pp. 106130; Beckert J., Musselin Ch. (eds). (2013). Constructing Quality: The
Classification of Goods in Markets, Great Britain. Oxford University Press.
8
. (2007) // . . 41 (11 2007 .). [ ].
URL: http://bd.fom.ru/map/projects/dominant/dominant2007/dom0741.
9
.. (2012) :
// Laboratorium. . 2: 91-114.
6
12 (117) 2014
67

.
,
,
,
, . .
, . ,
,
.
, ,

. ,

, ,
, 1.
,
,
,
, ,
.
.
,
. ,
,
. ,
.
,
. , .
,
,

.
,

: , ;
, ,

(
) .
.
, ,

,
. ,

.
:

, ,
, .
, , , (sociology of
cognition) , , ,
,
, .

, 2.
,
,
(communities of thinking.), . ,

.
3.

.
, .
Zerubavel E. 1997. Social Mindscapes: An Invitation to Cognitive
Sociology. Cambridge: Harvard University Press. P. 31.
3
Ibid. P. 17.
2
. (2007) . .: .
1
68
12 (117) 2014
.

,
1. ,

2. ,
. ,

. ,
,
3. ,

, 4.

5.
,
, 6.
XX

.
Reisine S. 1981. Theoretical Considirations in Formulating Sociodental
Indicators // Social Science and Medicine. 15A: 756.
2
Davies A., Jr J. Measuring patient satisfaction with dental care // Social
Science and Medicine. 1981. Vol. 15A. P. 751.
3
Vermaire J.H., N.J.A. van Exel, C. van Loveren and W.B.F. Brouwer. 2012.
Putting Your Money Where Your Mouth Is: Parents Valuation of Good Oral
Health of Their Children. Social Science and Medicine. 75: 2200-2206.
4
Nettleton S. 1989. Power And Pain: The Location Of Pain And Fear
In Dentistry And The Creation of a Dental Subject // Social Science and
Medicine, 29 (10): 118390; .., .. (2000) // . 4. (URL: http://www.medicus.ru/stomatology/
spec/?cont=article&art_id=5167).
5
Finch H., Keegan J. and Ward K. 1988. Barriers to the Receipt of Dental
Care a Qualitative Research Study. London: Social and Community
Planning Research.
6
Davis P. 1980. The Social Context of Dentistry. London: Croom Helm Ltd.;
Anderson R. and D.W. Thomas. 2003. Toothache Stories: A Qualitative
Investigation Of Why And How People Seek Emergency Dental Care //
Community Dental Health. 20 (2): 10611; Exley C. 2009. Bridging A Gap:
The (Lack Of A) Sociology Of Oral Health And Healthcare // Sociology of
Health and Illness. 31 (7)
1
, ,
,
,
7.
,
, , .
, XX ,
,
8.
, ,

,
9.
. ,
, , . ,
, 16 17
,
. : 10.

, ,

, 11. ,
, ,
12.
. (1997)
. " ", .
8
Goffman E. 1990. [1963] Stigma - Notes on the Management of Spoiled
Identity. London: Penguin Books.
9
Featherstone, M. 1982. The Body In Consumer Culture // Theory, Culture
and Society. 19 (2): 20611; Giddens, Anthony. 1991. Modernity and Selfidentity: Self and Society in Late Modern Age. Oxford: Basil Blackwell Ltd.
10
Gibson B., Drennan J., Hanna S., Freeman R. (2000) An exploratory
qualitative study examining the social and psychological processes involved
in regular dental attendance, Journal of Public Health Dentistry, 60, 1, 511.
11
. Exley C. Bridging A Gap: The (Lack Of A) Sociology Of Oral
Health And Healthcare // Sociology of Health and Illness. 2009.31(7).
12
Gregory J., Gibson B. and Robinson P.G. Variation and change in
the meaning of oral health related quality of life: a grounded systems
approach// Social Science and Medicine, 2005. 60, 185968; .. (2012) :

7
12 (117) 2014
69

. , , ,

, , 1.

, .

.
. . (social
relationships of services).
,
(,
,

)2. , .

, 3.
,

.
, . , ,
4.
Gourevitch P. 2011. The Value of Ethics: Monitoring Normative
Compliance in Ethical Consumption Markets. In Aspers P., Beckert J. (eds).
The Worth of Goods: Valuation and Pricing in the Economy. New York:
Oxford University Press. P. 87.
2
.., .. (2014) : // . 2.
154182.
3
.. (2012) :
4
. (2007) . . . : / .
.; . . , . . .. . .: ; .: . . 197.
1
70
(,
,
).
, .

.
, , .. 5. , ,
. , ,
, ,
, .
20 .
6.
,
. ,
, . ,
,

.
, ,

7.

, ,
, .

, XIX . /
-
, . . . [ ]. URL:
http://www.historymed.ru/static.html?nav_id=184&ti_id=323.
6
., ., ., .
. .: . 2004.
7
.. (2002) : , . .
5
12 (117) 2014
,
. ,
,
, 1.
,
, . . , 90- ,
, .
90- ,

. , ,
,
2.
2000- .
,

3. ,

.
, .
2000- .
,
4. ,
, ,

.
,
6 1996 .
2
2003 .: (Dental Management Group). [ ]. URL: http://www.
edentworld.ru/lib.pl-cid=&DocID=1266.htm.
3
.
(Dental Management Group). [ ]. URL: http://www.
edentworld.ru/lib.pl-cid=&DocID=1261.htm. 2013.
4
. . (-
) // : , . 2010. 19(3): 132-158.
1
,
..
. ,
,
, , . ,

. ,
,
.
.
, .

. , .

.
, , ,

5.
,
.
,
, , . ,
.
,
,
.
, .
,
. . (-
) // : , . 2010. 19(3): 132-158; . : . . -.
. 2011.
5
12 (117) 2014
71
,
.
, .

1.
,
, 2.
, .
, . ,

,
, 3.

23-
. 2012
2013 .
, .

. ,
, .

.

,
. ., . :
, . .: ,
2001.; Glaser B.G. Theoretical sencitivity: advances in the methodology
of grounded theory. Mill Valley (CA): Sociology Press. 1978; Charmaz K.
Constructing grounded theory: a practical guide through qualitative analysis.
Thousand Oaks (CA): Sage Publications. 2006.
2
.. (grounded
theory): . // 4. 2011. 32. . 129.
3
Glaser B.G. Theoretical sencitivity: advances in the methodology of
grounded theory. Mill Valley (CA): Sociology Press. 1978. P. 44-45.
1
72
. ,

:

,
, ,

.
, , . , ,

, ( ).

,
, , , 12-4.
.
,

,

.
, .
.
WeftGDA,
.
:

,
,
, , ,
.
, . ,

Guest Greg, Arwen Bunce and Laura Johnson. How Many Interviews
Are Enough? : An Experiment with Data Saturation and Variability// Field
Methods. 18: 59-82. 2006.; Thomson S.B. Sample size and grounded theory
// JOAAG. 2011. Vol.5. No.1.
4
12 (117) 2014

, , .
, .
,
,
.
.
,
.
.
,
. .
, ,
,
.
, - ,

.

. , ,
.

, .
.
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
, . , , ,
,
.
.
. .

. ,
, .
, , ,

,
. ,
, . -
12 (117) 2014
73

,
,
.

,
.
,
( )
, ,

.

,
,
,
: ,
. ,
, , 2 , 3. - .
(,
, ).

.
,
, , . ,
, , , .
, ,
, ,
, , ,
, ..
,
, ,
,
, ,
.
. , , :
?. .
: , ,
, , , ,
(, 49 ).
, ,
. , ,
, -
, .
74
, -, ,
. , ,
, .
.

,
, . , ,
, .
.
, . , ,
,
,
( ) , .
-, ,
, ,
.
, ,

.
.
, .
, .
:
, - .
,

.

, . ,
.

. -
12 (117) 2014
, ,
, , ,
.
, .
- .
, 300
. , . , . : , , ,
. .
. ? (,
36 )

. ,
, .
.
, .
. ,
,
.
, , . ,
, , ,
- ,
, .
, .
, . , ,
, , 1.
, ,
.
, .

. . (2007) . .: .
1
. .
,
,

.
. ,
, ,
.
, ,
,

,
,
. .
versus .
,
.

. -,
, . -,
.
, , ,
.
, , , , ,
, , .
-, ,
,
.
.
- ,
.
12 (117) 2014
75
vs
vs
vs
vs
vs
vs

. , .
,
(, 46 ).

,

.
, , , , .
, , .
.

, , , (, 41 ).
, . ,
, ,
, ,
(, 49 ).

,
.., (, 67 ).
, ,
, , , .
, ,
, ,
. , , , .
,
76
. , , , .
(,
46 ).
,
,
. ,
. , (, 41 ).
, , ,
.

, ,
.
, .
,
, ,
(, 49 ).
, ,
, , .

.
, .
, , ,
? : ,
. , ,
, . : ,
, .
. , .
(, 49 ).
12 (117) 2014
,
. . ,
(, 56 )
,
,
(, 28 ).
, , ,
, -
, : . .
(, 37 ).
versus
,
, .
. , ,
, , .
, ,
: ?
, ?. ,
. .
: ?.
, ,
(, 36 ).
60 .
,
. ,
-:
, ,
,
, ,
(,
25 ).
. , ,
.
. ,
, .
, , , ,
.
,
, ,
, ,
.
(, 67 ).
, ,
. , .
(, 40 ).

, , ;
,
,
;
, , .
, , ,
. , (, 55 ).
, ,
, ,
,
(, 30 ).
,
, ,
, . ,

. ,

. ,
.
,
: , ,
- , , -
;
. , . ,
: ,

(, 36 ).
12 (117) 2014
77

.

,
.
,
. ,
.
,
, .
, ,
,
.
.
...(,
67).
, , , -? ,
--- .
,
.
, 20
.
(, 51 ).
,
,

.
,
.
, , ,
. , ,
(, 56 ).
, ,
, ,
, ,
: , ,
, ,
78
- .
. ,
,
,
(, 49 )
,
-.

1. ,
. , , , 2.

, , ,

, -. ,
, ,
, ,
, , ,
, , , ,
.
, , ,
,
.
, , , 3.
,
.. (2012) :
2
. . .: , .
1998.
3
.., .., ..
. . 9: 3-17. 2010.
1
12 (117) 2014
,
,

1.

,
,
.

(
- ),
.
:

, , in vivo .

, , ,
2. ,
, ,

,
.
,

, .

. , , , ! .:
? .: ,
, ,
(, 56 ).

, .
, , , , ,
.
,
, :
., . : . .
12( 1): 4367. 2011.
2
http://ru.wiktionary.org/wiki/%F0%E0%E7%E2%EE%E4.
1
,
,
, , , . ,
,
.

, ,
(, 49 ).

. .
,

.
, -
.
,
,
.
,

,
.
- , .
,
, , -
, ,
,
. , ,
,

,
,
(
, ).
.: , , ? .:
- - , , .
, .
12 (117) 2014
79
, , , ,
, (, 40 ).
, ,
,
, ,
. - .
, .
. - , ,
. : , (, 53 ).

,
( ).
, ,
, ,
, .
: ,
300 . ?
.: - .
, ,
. .
, ,
. , ,
, ,
, -, -.

, (,
51 ).
,
.
- ,
(, 36 ).
, ,
.
, , ,
,
. , ,
- , , -,
, ,
,
(, 40 ).
,
, .

,
80
, .
, ,
. .
,
,
(, 51 ).
, ,
16 000,
, - ,

,
, .
(, 25 ).

.
, - , 10 000, . ,
. -,
(,
40 ).
,
. , ,
, . (, 36 ).
, ,

, , , .

,
-.
, , , , .
- , ,
, , (, 28 ).
, , ,
, - . ,
? ,
, ?
? , .
(, 25 ).
12 (117) 2014
.
.
.
, , ,
1.
,
. . ,
(storytelling)2. , ,
,

, , , , . , ,
- (guiding
stories)3. , ,
4.
, , 5.

,

. ,

, ,
6.
, ,

, 7.

,
,
. Guyer J.I. Composites, Fictions, and Risk: Toward an Ethnography
of Price. In Chris Hann, Keith Hart (Eds) Market and Society: The Great
Transformation Today. N.Y.: CambridgeUniversity Press: 203 220. 2009.
2
Forsberg P. Testing Prices in Markets. How to Charter a Tanker //
Ethnography. 10(3): 267. 2009.
3
Ibid. P, 267.
4 Darke P.R., Dahl D.W. Fairness and Discounts: The Subjective Value of a
Bargain // Journal of Consumer Psychology. 13(3): 330. 2003.
5
Haws K.L., Bearden W.O. Dynamic Pricing and Consumer Fairness
Perceptions // Journal of Consumer Research. 33(3): 304-311. 2006.; ..
// . 4: 20-27. 2008.
6
Hajdkov, Iveta. Discreet Economy: Luxury Hospitality in the Context
of Postsocialist Transformation of Czech Society // Laboratorium.
. 5 (1): 73-97. 2013.
7
. .
. : . . . .:
. 2007.
1
, , . ,

, . ,
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
,

8. ,
,
.
,
, , ,
(

)9, ,
,
,
,
, ,
, ,
. , ,
, ,
,
, .
,
.
,
.. :
// Laboratorium. . 2:
91-114. 2012.
9
., , Gell A. Technology and Magic. In. J. Benthall (ed.)
The Best of Anthropology Today, with a preface by M. Sahlins. L., N.Y.:
Routledge, 280287. 2002.
8
12 (117) 2014
81
,

.
,

, ,

.

.
.
.
. .
,

,
1. ,

2. , ,
. , , .
,

. ,

, , ,
.
,
.
Bolton L. E., Warlop L., Alba J.W. Consumer Perceptions of Price (Un)
Fairness // Journal of Consumer Research. 29: 474-491. 2003.
2
. ( ): . .: . . 233. 2005.

. ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
3.
. , ,
, .
, ,
.
, ,
. ,

,
, ,

. ,
,
, ,

.
82
3
Prasad Monika. The Morality of Market Exchange: Love, Money and
Contractual Justice. Sociological Perspectives. 42(2): 181214. 1999.
12 (117) 2014

:
, ,
, ,
.

.
,
. ,
,
.
, , , ,
, , 1.
,
,
, ..
,
.
, ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
- , ( ), -
( ).
, :
, ,
, .. . , .
1
, ,

, ,
..

, , ,
.

: ,
, , ,
, .. , ,

,
.
2
, .
.

, : .
, ,
- ,
, .., ,
Tong Jahoni,
, , .
2
12 (117) 2014
83
1.
,
.
,
, , - . ,
,
,

. ,
,
,
.

, .
,
,
60-70 2,
.. ,

.
, ,
, ,
..

.

.., .., ..
: .
, 2011; .
- 7 -2020
?, 4 2011
http://strategy2020.rian.ru/stenograms/20111007/366171816.html.
2
, . , ,
- ..,

:
http://trudprava.ru/about/events/768.
1
84
, .
,
. ,
2012
2015

, ,
3.
()
20132018 .
300 ..4
,
, .
.
.
, 4-6 ,
5.
, , 6. ,
:
, ..

.
. http://www.kremlin.ru/acts/15635
2025
.
4
20132018 , http://www.fms.gov.ru/upload/iblock/plan_fms_2013-2018.pdf
.3 12.04.2014 .
5
. , .
http://www.rg.ru/2012/03/22/migranty.html, , http://lenta.ru/conf/migranti/.
6
, 2013 , ,
- . . -
, - () (), . 6. http://trudprava.ru/images/events/
%%2016.09.2013/_-2.pdf.
3
12 (117) 2014
,
. ,
(
).
, ..
,
. , -, , -,
, . :
( )
.
,

. , ,
.

, 1.
,
,
.
,
, ,

2 . ,
( ,
..), ,
. , (. .1).

.3

,
, :
, .. : , .
,
(
), ,
4.
- . ,
-,

1
?3
2006 2008 2011 2012 2013

31
53
17
25
54
21
20
57
22
20
64
15
15
73
13
N=1603
,
:
, .
3
.
- 25-28 2013 . , http://
www.levada.ru/05-11-2013/rossiyane-o-migratsii-i-mezhnatsionalnoinapryazhennosti.
4
. //
, 18, 12, 2011-
2012, .28, http://www.vedi.ru/red_r/2011/ed120111_migr.pdf.
2
, , .
, ,
, ,
. .
1
12 (117) 2014
85
-
1990 . ( ). , , -,
, ,
, ..1
,
.

: ,
.

, , .

(,
, ). , ,
.. .

, :
,

. .
,

2. 2013
,
.
,
,
, .
: ,
, ( ,
..),
. .
, , 2013 ., . 364-365, http://trudprava.ru/expert/research/
miscsurv/1016.
2
., , http://pan.md/news/V-Rossii-priostanovili-vidachupatentov-grajdanam-Moldovi/50938.
1
86
3, , ,
. (,
):
,

. , , ,
,

, ..
,
,
,
.. .
,
(
,
, , ), - !
,
, . ,

(. 1), , , .
, ,
: ,
,
!
,
(
)
( /
). , , ,

, , ,
.
,
.
,
,
, ,
- .
3
12 (117) 2014
1
, - 2013 1 ( . . )

10
15
20
25

.
, () . .
,
,
. ,

, ..:
,
, , , , .1
,
,
2, -
, ,
,
.

, , .
, , ,
,
: , , 3, ,
, .
.
, ,

: . http://www.
cbr.ru/statistics/print.aspx?file=CrossBorder/Rem_countries_13.
htm&pid=svs&sid=TGO_sp_pos.
2
:
.
( !!!), ..
,
1 .
, .
,
,
, , -
, , ,
.
3
., , . ,
. http://www.fergananews.com/articles/7708. .
12 (117) 2014
87
, 2014
. , , ,
,
. ,
, , ! !
-
-
,
, .
() , . , ,
, , :
1.
,
, ( ,

). : , ,
, 2
( !)

,
.
.. ,
, ,
..
2
.
. 2009. http://www.hrw.org/sites/default/files/reports/
russia0209ruweb.pdf; :
http://www.hrw.org/ru/news/2013/02/06/rossiyatrudovye-migranty-v-sochi-podvergayutsya-obmanu-i-ekspluatatsii. -
,
- ()
(),
. 14-17, http://trudprava.ru/images/events/%%20
16.09.2013/_-2; .. http://adcmemorial.org/www/777.html/.
1
88

. -, 2010
2123.
,
,
() .
2010 ,
70-80%4 ,
, , ,
.
, ,
:
. ,
,

.
, ,

,

.
, , 5,
, , 212- 24 2009 . http://base.consultant.ru/cons/cgi/
online.cgi?req=doc;base=LAW;n=156033;fld=134;dst=4294967295;rnd=0.
3096432143356651;from=149840-0.
4

. ,
-.

, .

.
5
, . ,
,
. , ..
,
. ,
, ,
,
3
12 (117) 2014
, ..
,
,
.
,
(
) . 108,
2013 ()
, , ,
.. , 1. , (
,
,
2 ..), ,

, .
, ,
..
, 2012 (. 28
2012 . -535/03 , http://www.garant.ru/
products/ipo/prime/doc/70094560/) . 2014 ,
,

90 , ,
, . ,
,
.
,
, ,
,
. ,
.
1
. ,
2018 . http://trudprava.ru/expert/analytics/
migrationanalyt/666.
2
., , .
,
http://www.sochinskie-novosti.com/-----,
http://scandaly.ru/2013/06/19/
sochi-gastarbayteram-ne-platit/, http://trudorg.ru/page/orenburzhec-zashilsebe-rot-trebuja-zarplaty. , , .
, . ,

( ) , , ,
.
, ,

.

,
3.
,
- , ,
, ,
, , .
,
.
-4 , , , , ,
. , ,

, , 5. , :
. // - : : - . , 17-18 2008 . ., 2009.
. 76.
4
1 .
5
. -

, - () () 2013 ., . 6. http://trudprava.ru/images/events/
%%2016.09.2013/_-2.
3
12 (117) 2014
89
,
- , ,
- ,
,

.
,
1.
.
,
, , (-
- )
-,
.

()
().

, ..
,
( ) - .
, 2.
,

[ ]
, , , , ,
3.

. .
: / . .
WP3 " ". 2013. WP3/2013/01 . 33. http://
www.hse.ru/data/2013/03/20/1292438237/WP3_2013_01.pdf.
2
, 14 2011
VII . http://fnpr.ru/n/249/6183.html.
3
.
1
90
:
, .
, 4.
5.

/ . (
),
,
6. , , , , .. ,

. ,

, ,
,
.
,
. ,
7, ,
, 8.
,
:
,
-. . . . . 27 2011 .
http://ktr.su/about/doc/doc1.php.
5
,
, , -.
.
6
., , https://novoprof.org/2013/02/v-nevskom-rajonevnov-zabastovali-dvorniki-migranty.html.
7
, ,
. . ,
, ,
.
8
. . ? // XXI . 2 (17), 2013 . 53-55.
4
12 (117) 2014
,

,
,
.
.
,
, ,
..

:

, .. .
,
,
.
, ,
. , -
.

, , .
,
-
, -
,
.
,
.
,
,
( ,

, , ),
.

,
. .
, , ,

-1.

- .
: ( , ), ,
,
.
,
, , -, ,
,

(,
, ..).
,
:
1) ; 2) ,
, ;
3) , ..

,
, .

,
, 2
, ,
.
.. .
- , ,
,
-. , , ,
, ,
. -. .
http://www.profmigr.com/index.php?option=com_contact&Itemid=3.
2
,
,
: , ,
..
1
12 (117) 2014
91
( , ,
). ,
,
:
, ,
. , ,

,
, .

,
, ,

,
.

, 2012
1 ( ,
),
.

. ,
,
,
2.
. 20 2012 . 121- "

, " ( ) http://base.garant.ru/70204242/.
2
., , .
. . (
), 24
2012 . http://www.fms.gov.ru/upload/iblock/208/mykomel.pdf.
,
, . -
, - () () 2013 . http://trudprava.ru/images/events/
%%2016.09.2013/_-2.
1
92

. ,
, .
, , ,

.
, ..

,
,

.

, . :
, , , () .
.. :
,
, 3.
. ,
.

.
4

, 1990
.
. 2012 , , , ,
, http://tvrain.ru/articles/svetlana_
gannushkina_u_nas_s_putinym_antagonisticheskie_vzglyady-280252.
. http://www.memo.ru/d/122013.html.
4
. // 2012/51
- , , 2012,
http://www.carim-east.eu/media/exno/Explanatory%20
Notes_2012-51.pdf..
3
12 (117) 2014
. ,
, ,
: (,
, ), .
,
:
. ,
2014 . .. :
(,
),

,
, ..
,
,
,
, ,
. ,
: , ,
.. , ,

.
,
. ,
( ,
,
,
-,
, .. ).

, : ,
,
: , ,
, , -, .

, ..
, , ,
. , ,
.

. ,
,
, ,
, ..
, ,
, , ,
. , ,
.
.
: (

, ).
, ,
.

,
. , , , . ,
(
), ,

.
-
12 (117) 2014
93
,

1.

. , .
,

. (
),
:
,
, ,
.
1-2 , , ,
.

: , ,

, . , ( ).
, ,
, ,
. ,
.
, ,
()
, . , .
, // : :
[. .]/ - ; . .. .. . .
: , 2008, . 183.
1
94
,
, .. .

.
,
, 2
, . ,
,

.
. ,
.

, , , ,
.
,

-,
,
,
..
,
.
.
, ,
, ,
: , ,
, . ,
, , .. ,
.
2
12 (117) 2014
.

. : , ,
, , ,
..
, ,
,
,
..
,
,
.
, ,
. :
, , , ,
, , , ,
1. ,

.
, ,
, . ,
, , ,
,
,
2.
Homo sacer. . .: , 2011, .220.

2
Homo sacer. . .: , 2011, . 222.
1
12 (117) 2014
95
,
:

-
.
. -
--. (
)
,
,

, 1.
,

. -, , . -,
. -,

. ,
,
. 2.

.
-
, . : // / . .. . .: ,
1995. . 324-328.
2
.., .. :
// . 2009. . 10.
5. . 11-32.
1
96
3.

, , ,

. , -.
,
.
, , ,
-. , ,
4. ,

.
5 ,

.: ..
:
- // . 2009. . 10. 5. . 72-92; ..
- :
// .
2012. . XV. 5. . 246-257.
4
Gulati R., Gargiulo M. Where Do Interorganizational Networks Come
From? // American Journal of Sociology. 1999. Vol. 104. No. 5. PP. 1473,
1482.
5
.. .. .
- 10-04-0015 ,
,

2010-2011 .
,
2014 .
3
12 (117) 2014
, .

.
2010. Freelance.ru, .
1275 . 2011 .
( 2008.) 7179 1.
.
, ,
,

. ,
, -,
, -,

, -,
2. , ,
, , ,
3.
.
.1,
, (
63% ),
,
(62%) (59%).

(43%) - (38%).
.: .., ..
// :
/ . .. . .: .
, 2012. . 13-16.
2
Gold M., Fraser J. Managing Self-Management: Successful Transitions
to Portfolio Careers // Work, Employment and Society. 2002. Vol. 16. No. 4.
PP. 585-587.
3
Dex S., Willis J., Paterson R., Sheppard E. Freelance Workers and
Contract Uncertainty: The Effects of Contractual Changes in the Television
Industry // Work, Employment and Society. 2000. Vol. 14. No. 2. PP. 283305.
1

(11%), , (10%)

(6%).
1
( %
)4

,

,

, /
(.)
63
62
59
43
38
29
28
20
11
10
6
3
6594
,
, -,
(

,
, ). -, -,

. ,

,
,

100%, .
4
12 (117) 2014
97
1. ,
, .

2. , , ,
.
. -,
, ,
. -,

,
.

,
.

, , 3.

. ,
, ,
. - ,
4,

.

.: . // . 2009. .10. 4. .31-50.
2
Baines S. Servicing the Media: Freelancing, Teleworking and Enterprising
Careers // New Technology, Work and Employment. 1999. Vol. 14. No. 1.
PP. 25-26.
3
Antcliff V., Saundry R., Stuart M. Networks and Social Capital in the UK
Television Industry: the Weakness of Weak Ties // Human Relations. 2007.
Vol. 60. No. 2. PP. 380-387.
4 .: .
: () // . 2007. . 8. 3. . 51-56.
1
98
. ,
,
,
-, , , , ,
. ,

, 5.
,

.
, , ,
,
,
. , , , 6.

.
,
, , .

,

, . ,
, ,
7.
. ,

.
, , , ,
Wathne K., Biong H., Heide J. Choice of Supplier in Embedded Markets:
Relationship and Marketing Program Effects // Journal of Marketing. 2001.
Vol. 65. No. 2. P. 56.
6
.., .. :
// . 2009. . 10.
5. . 13.
7
.. . .: .
, 2007. . 202-206.
5
12 (117) 2014
, . ,
, 1.
,
, , ,
,
- ,
. , , ,

.
,
, , .
, -
-.
. 2

.
.
, , , , , -,
, .
.
, , , , , ,
3.
Henninger A., Gottschal K. Freelancer in Germanys Old and New Media
Industry: Beyond Standard Patterns of Work and Life // Critical Sociology.
2007. No. 33. PP. 67-68.
2

. Varimax
. , , . 1 ( ),
59% .
3
,
.
, .
1
.
, , -,
, -,
.
.
, , , ,
/ , -, - , -,
.

. , ,
-,
, -, - .
, ,
,

.
4

.
(54%)
.
.
(40%)
.
.
(6%)
.
.
,

. (94%)
k-.
3% .
.
4
12 (117) 2014
99

(
-),
6%
.
- .
() - .
,
. . 2
, - : , .1
,
,
. ,
,
(43% 39% ).
. 26 29 . ,
,
, 48% 62% . ,
69%.
, - ,
,
.
,
-
-. ,
(
,
). , ,

60%
50% 2.
. 3

.

.
, ,
,
1 (33%). ,
,

.
. , ( ,
) ,
, ,
- . . 4 .

, .
(25% 14% ) (22%
29% ).
,

2
- 1
-
(%)
()
(%)
63
28
59
59
30
69
. 0,01
100
57
26
48
61
29
62
. 0,001.
12 (117) 2014
(.
. 5). ,

(38% 28% ),
(31% 38% ).
,
, . ,
.
, . 6, ,
.
3
(%)1

24
23
16
23
10
4
27
24
16
23
9
3
33
27
13
17
7
2
26
24
16
22
10
3
1
1
2
3-5
6-10
11
4
(%)2

45
9
12
7
27
41
4
25
8
22
42
8
14
7
29
39
8
14
7
31
5
(%)3
/
/
/ /
27
18
36
6
10
5
29
12
30
22
41
5
8
5
26
8
26
23
31
4
10
5
38
10
29
20
38
5
9
5
28
10
14
11
13
12
. 0,001.
. 0,001.
3
100%, .
1
2
12 (117) 2014
101

, -, , (
83%
), -,
(72%).

,
. (58%)
,
(41%) , (30%)
. ,

, .1

, , .
(36%) , -,
, -,
. ,
.
-
,
. ,
,
, , , 2.
,
,

(8%) . (
(31%) ).
, ,
, ,
.

(
(37%)
).
-

.
6
( % )1

,

,
,

(.)
83
72
58
41
37
36
36
31
30
30
12
12
8
8
7
4
1139
StoreyJ., SalamanG., PlatmanK. Living with Entrerprise in an Enterprise

Economy: Freelance and Contract Workers in the Media // Human Relations.
2005. Vol.58. No.8. PP.1033-1054.
2
100%, .
1
102
12 (117) 2014

, ,
,
1.
, (30%)

. , (
)
(7%) . ,
,

. ,
.
.
2 .
-.
, , -,
, -, , ,
-, .
.
, , -, , -,
, -, ,
-,
.
. , , -,
,
, -, , ,
Templer A., Cwasey T. Rethinking Career Development in an Era of
Portfolio Careers // Career Development International. 1999. Vol.4. No.2.
PP.70-76.
2

. Varimax
. ,
, . 6 ( ),
51% .
1
-, .
.
, , -,
, , .
.

, , -, , -,
,
-,
.
, ,
,

.
3
.
(35%)
.
.
(35%)
. .
(11%)
.
.
(11%) . .
(8%)
-.
-.
,
.
,

.
,
k-.
3% .
3
12 (117) 2014
103

, ,
Freelance.ru, , ,
.
, -.

(65% 74% ) ,

,
., 1.

.
,
.
(87% 78% )2
, 19% 14% ,
, 11% 4% .

. , (90%
78% )
. ,
,
.
,
(59% 78% ) .

, , , -.
.
: () // . 2007. .8. 4. .54.
2
. 0,01.
1
104
, (39% 31%
)
. , ,
. , .
, -
3.
- .

,
( , ..).

. . 7 , , ,

(47% 31% ).
,
,
. ,
, ,
(24%).
(49% 60% ).
***
,

, . ,
,

. ,
,
. ,
.
, FenwickT. Contradictions in Portfolio Careers: Work Design and Client
Relations // Career Development International. 2006. Vol.11. No.1. PP.6679.
3
12 (117) 2014
7
(%)1

47
53
33
67
34
66
27
49
31
69
31
60
24

.
, .

, ,
.
. , .

.
, .
, . : ,

, .

.
, ,
. -
.
- ,
, . .
, .
,
.
, , .

. , .
, .
,
-, . ,
. ,
,
,
.
.
0,001.
1
12 (117) 2014
105
1

2 .
-97
5 ( )
3.

,
4.

18,7 , 26% ,

(
,

. .
2
- , , ,
(, , ..)
[ . . // , 4, 2011.
.214230].
3
.., .. : . - :
,
2001..13-14; Indicators of Education in the Russian Federation:
Data Book. Moscow: National Research University Higher
School of Economics (HSE), 2013. 280 p.
4
.., .., .. : ? // , 4, 2010,
.247-267.
1
106
25 20% 5).
2703
23 , 1,98 (. 1).

, , ,
.
( 50%), (10%).
( )
6.

, ,
. ,
,
. ,
, .

, , , , Indicators of Education in the Russian Federation: Data Book.
Moscow: National Research University Higher School of
Economics (HSE), 2013. 280 p.
6
..
// , 7, 2010, C. 88-96.
5
12 (117) 2014
1
( 1)
,

:

, .
:

10 000 .
, .

10 000 .
, .
, , ,

.
, , , ,
,
, :
,
, 12.
1990- 2012
. 2013
278
. , 92%

. (
10% )

,
// gks.ru: [-]. 2014. 22 . URL:http://www.gks.ru/free_doc/new_site/population/obraz/
sp-obr1.htm.
2
. . // ,
4, 2010. .5
1
1990 2000 2005 2010 2011 2012
2013
2603 2703 2905 2850 2925 2981
2703
2603 2589 2688 2586 2665 2725

114 217 264 260 256
2488
215
2270 2361 2591 2126 2082 2087 1982,1

2270 2309 2473 2027 1984 1984
52
118
99
98
103
1856
126
153
162
181
149
146
146
85
90
103
85
76
72
, 2010
.
2005-2013

. . 2013
2005 25% 36%
(. 1).
,
, 2013 . 26%. ,
. 2005 .

35%, 27%. 2005.

( , 1980- 1987 .) ()
3.
,

,
.
,
. ., . . : // , 2 (33), 2006. .35-51.
3
12 (117) 2014
107
1

854
850
799
771
800
750
703
705
694
700
650
660
684
700
656
637
699
671
600
631
550
572
500
518
450
486
439
.
,
: , , 1,
35% , 59%
6% . , 2013 , 18% 9% 11 , 14%

, ,
.

, 2. ,
. 2002 ,
,
.
2
84% 2013 , ,
.
1
108
2012
2011
2010
2009
2008
2007
2006
2005
400
2013
900
3.
.

4. , 80% , .
. 2000-

, 2012 .
. , : 12
10%, , , 2%. , 2012.

51%, 31%, 17%.
: 12

7%, ,
, 3% (. 2).
. . - // , 2, 2012, C. 103-109.
4
.. . ? // , 1, 2004, . 14.
3
12 (117) 2014
2
(%, 1)
2000
2012
28
25,8
20,7
29,6
28,6
26,2
21,7
30,4
22,7
19,3
11
16,4

,
12,
3.
,
( 15% ), 4.
,
,
. ,
- 5. , -,
,
, ,

2013: .. / M.,
2013. 661 c.
2
2013 . // , 1, 2004, . 232273.
3
., ., .
// , 6, 2005, . 106-122; .., ..,
..
: ? // , 4, 2010, . 247-267.
4
. . - // , 2, 2012,C. 103-109.
5

//akvobr.ru: [-]. 2014. 22 . URL:http://
www.akvobr.ru/regionalnie_sistemy_spo.html.
1
-
6.

, ,
, 7. 2013
, , . ,
22% , 13%

, 9% 8 (. 3).
, . ,

, ,
, .
. . - // , 2, 2012,C. 103-109.
7
. : //
, 6, 2010. . 52-56;
: /
. . . 2. - . 2006. 126 .
8
, .
6
12 (117) 2014
109
3
(%)
(30%)
(11% , 8%
, ). ,
.
,

1. ,
, , 2. ,
2013 , ..

// . .. 3, 2009, . 95-100.
2
. . // , 4, 2011.
.214230.
1
110
, /
, ,
,
,

, ,
,

, .
22
41
14
27
11
28
13
9
29
21
10
8
12
10
8
2
11
13
8
1
2
1
4
2
1
0
1
1
0
1
2
2
1
0
1
2
71
2
4
49
1
1
80
2
1
64
1
1
84
0
4
63
0
0
85
(
) 2 40%
.
,
(. 4).
4

(%)

(,
, ,
)

2011-2012 .
25
16
17
14
21
4 5,
12 (117) 2014
2

100%
90%
26
80%
70%
51
60%
50%
51
40%
30%
36
20%
10%
22
0%
5
(% )

( )
( )

(, ,
, )
32
20
14
8
21
18
12
11
7
14
68
80
86
92
79
82
88
89
93
86
16
10
84
90
, (3,6 5) . 2.

. 2012
82-87%
( ). ,
, , , .
,

, (. 5).

.

. ,
- , , ,

1.

//akvobr.ru: [-]. 2014.22 . URL:http://
1
12 (117) 2014
111
, -
,
. , : ,
.
- ,
1.

: ,
, - ;
,
. 40%
.
,
,
, ,

, ,

,

.

.
, ..

.
: // akvobr.ru: []. 2014. 22 . URL: http://www.akvobr.ru/modernizacia_
spo_evropeiskaja_versia.html.
1
112
, ,
2,
-
3,
.
, .. ,
,
,
(. 6).

(. 7).

2012 . , , . :

45%,
35%4. ,
, .

. ,
. , .
,

, , . . //, 6, 2006.
C.75-81.
3
..

// . .. 3, 2009. . 95-100.
4
.., .., ..
.
. .: , 2012.
2
12 (117) 2014
6
1

2000
2005
2009
2010
2011

, . .
214,7
801,8
1783,5
1893,9
2231,8
11
11,8
11,1
10,8
11,2
10,2
43,3
102,2
102,1
115,3
, . . ( )
38,1
162,1
418
442,8
553,4
% ( )
3,7
4,6
4,3
4,4
5,1

, . .
5,4
18,7
37,6
32,1
35,2
11,5
7,2
6,4
, . . (
)
176,6
628,6
1345,9
1450,9
1728,4
17,4
21,4
21,5
21,9
22,5

, . .
4,8
24,6
64,5
70
80,8
2,7
3,9
4,8
4,8
4,7
%

, . .
%
7
(%)

2008
2010
2011
2012
32
34
31
19
40
44
48
60
( ..)
( )
( )
18
14
12
12
11
,
1.
, 2011
2011-2015

11

//akvobr.ru: [-]. 2014.22 . URL:http://
1
10 ,
.

,
, -
12 (117) 2014
113
,
. , : , ,
, 1.

(,
2),
3.
,
,
. .
50% 36
59 , 10% 60- 4. -
,
, .
,
.

,
- . ,

,

. , ,
, .
2013 . // , 1, 2004. . 266.

2
..

// . .. 3, 2009. . 95-100.
3
.. . ? // , 1, 2004. . 5-32.
4
. //
akvobr.ru: [-]. 2014. 22 . URL:http://www.akvobr.ru/
napravlenie_proryva.html.
1
114
12 (117) 2014
:

1

,
, . ,
, ,
,
( ,

, - ).
, ,
.
: ) ,
, ; )
; )
, 1
, -
- .
- .
( , 28.03.2014).
.
1
2. ,

,

, .

, - ,
, . ,
.

, ,
, ,

.

,
,
.
,
Way, L. Authoritarian state building and the sources of regime
competitiveness in the fourth wave: the cases of Belarus, Moldova, Russia,
and Ukraine. World Politics, 57(2), 231-261. 2005.
2
12 (117) 2014
115
, . ,
, .

,
, . ,

, .
,

,
, , , , ,
, ,
. , , , ,
- ,
,
1.
(
).
,
, -
.

,
.

,
19- .
,
2 .
. ..
: . . . . . . 1. 114. . 20-28.
2003.
2
, , , .
116
, ,
, , ,
.

.
,
.
. , ,
- ,
, 3.
,
(, ,

?),
( ) .
.
(,
, , ,
D)

. ( , , )
19-
, ,
,
, ,
-
Hroch, M. Social preconditions of national revival in Europe:
acomparative analysis of the social composition of patriotic groups among
the smaller European nations. Columbia University Press. 2000.
3
12 (117) 2014
1. ,
, ,
, ,
-
.
.
(
) ,
,
.
(
)
.
, , -
,
( 19- ).
, , ,
, ,
. ,
- ,
.
,
,
, ,
- .
, .

, , , , ,
, . ,
.
1
.
: ?

2,
- 3. (
) ,

-
,
, .

(

), 4.
, ,
, ,
( ).

,
, , .
1995 .
, Abdelal, R. Memories of nations and states: Institutional history and
national identity in Post-Soviet Eurasia. Nationalities Papers, 30(3), 459484. 2002.
3
,
, , . Dawisha, K., & Parrott, B.
(Eds.). Democratic changes and authoritarian reactions in Russia, Ukraine,
Belarus and Moldova (Vol. 3). Cambridge University Press. 1997.
4
,
, , , .
2
12 (117) 2014
117
.
,
, . , ,
, ,

. ,
1. , , ,
.
,

2. ,

.

,
.
1990- . ,
, (
),
.
, ,
, , .

,
,
1980- Marples, D. R. Belarus: a denationalized nation (Vol. 1). Taylor & Francis.
1999.
2
Wilson, A. Belarus: The Last European Dictatorship. Yale University
Press. 2011.
1
118
3. ,
,
.

, - .
,

,
. ,

- .
?
,
,
,
. ,
. , ,
, ,
.
, . ,

,
- ,
. ,
. , ,
, ,

.
,
3
, . ., & , . . : 2 . ,
. 2003.
12 (117) 2014
(, , ) ,
,
.

,
.
, , ,
.
,

.

1980 1990- - .
,
,

.

, , ,
1.

2. ,

, .
-
,
.
, ,
. ,
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
. -,
, 3. ,
- ,
..
, . ,
, , ,
. ,

, , ().
, ( )
.
-, ,
,
,
,
4. ,
,
,
Rosenberg, W. G. (Ed.). Bolshevik visions: first phase of the cultural
revolution in Soviet Russia (Vol. 1). University of Michigan Press. 1990.
4
Savchenko, A. Toward Capitalism or Away from Russia? Early Stage of
Post-Soviet Economic Reforms in Belarus and the Baltics. American Journal
of Economics and Sociology, 61(1), 233-257. 2002.
3
Halfin, I. From Darkness to Light: Class, Consciousness, and Salvation

in Revolutionary Russia. University of Pittsburgh Press. 2000.
2
Kolonitskii, B. I. Antibourgeois Propaganda and Anti-" Burzhui"
Consciousness in 1917. Russian Review, 183-196. 1994.
1
12 (117) 2014
119

,

,
, .
,
-
, , - , ,

.
( ), .

(
), , ,

.
( -

). , ,
.
,

, - , , .

. ,
, , , -
.
, , ,
. .

( ) ,

? , -
120
.
,
.
,

. , .

.
, , , .
,
, ,

,
1. , , ,

,
, , ,
,
. ,

2005 ,
, ,
?.
, ,
.
, ,
, , ,
. , ,
,

Goujon, A. Genozid: A rallying cry in Belarus. A rhetoric analysis of
some Belarusian nationalist texts 1. Journal of Genocide Research, 1(3),
353-366. 1999.
1
12 (117) 2014
, , ,
. ( ,

) , (
, )
, 1990- .
,
, :

.

.
: ?
.

,
,
.
, ,
1.

( ) , (
). , 2.
,
3. , , -
,
, .

. ,
,
.
,
.
, ,
4. ,
,
(,
, , , , ).
, :
.
1990- ,
, , 5.
,

, .
, , ()
- .

, , -

6.
Miller, A. I. The Ukrainian question: the Russian Empire and nationalism
in the nineteenth century. Central European University Press. 2003.
5
Mudde, C. Extreme right parties in Eastern Europe. Patterns of Prejudice,
34(1), 5-27. 2000.
6
, . ., & , . . : , . . . .: , 158-170. 2003.
4
Subtelny, O. Ukraine: a history. University of Toronto Press. 2009.

2
Reid, A. Borderland: A journey through the history of Ukraine. Basic
Books. 2000.
3
Subtelny, O. American Sovietology's great blunder: The marginalization
of the nationality issue. Nationalities Papers, 22(1), 141-155. 1994.
1
12 (117) 2014
121
, ,
, , ,
.

- , 1,
,
2,
. , , , -
, , ,
.

? , (
), , ?
:
, ,
,

?

,
3.
,
4,
, Umland, A. Starting Post-Soviet Ukrainian right-wing extremism studies
from scratch. Russian Politics and Law, 51(5), 3-10. 2013.
2
Rudling, P. A. Organized anti-semitism in contemporary Ukraine:
Structure, influence and ideology. Canadian Slavonic Papers, 48(1-2), 81119. 2006.
3
Arel, D., & Khmelko, V. The Russian factor and territorial polarization in
Ukraine. The Harriman Review, 9(1-2), 81-91. 1996.
4
Kubicek, P. Regional polarisation in Ukraine: Public opinion, voting and
legislative behaviour. Europe-Asia Studies, 52(2), 273-294. 2000.
1
122
. ,
,
,
. ,

, , .
, ,
. ,
, 5
. 48-
, ,
,
. , -
,
,
.

,
. ()
.
,
. ,

, , ,
.

. ,
, , ,
5
Fabrykant, M., Marchenko, A., and Tregubova, N. The game of time:
reflecting varieties of soviet in post-Soviet nation-building via textbooks.
Apaper presented at the 41th World Congress of the International Institute
of Sociology, Uppsala. 2013.
12 (117) 2014
1.
,
, ,
, .
,

,
, .
, , ,
-
,
.

, .
, ,

. ,
( ) , , ,
,
,
, . ,
,
( ) .

,
.

. (
)
, , ,
. , ,
, ,
,
Rudling, P. A. (2011). The OUN, the UPA and the Holocaust: A Study in
the Manufacturing of Historical Myths. The Carl Beck Papers in Russian and
East European Studies, (2107).
1
. ,
, ,

.
,
,
.
,

, ,
.
.
, , ,
.
, , ,
. ,

.
,
.
.
, ( ) ,
, , ,
, .
,
. ,
, .
, ,

,
, .
12 (117) 2014
123
?

- () .
( ) .
,
1994.
. , . .
,
1994. 44,8% ( ):
() 36,3%, () 63,1%. ,
: 12,8%, 21,2%, 4,7%.
,
,

: 81%, 85,3%.
,
,
, .. 1996. .
. 2010. , (.1).
, ,
.
.

1994 . . 2. , ,
.
, ,
1. , 73
.
-
1
( )
.
.
./ .
1994
42
27
1,6
2001
49
45
1,1
2006
64
51
1,3
2010
52
63
0,8
2
( )
.
.
./ .
29
45
29
52
1
0,9
40
50
44
46
0,9
1,1
. .
. 2003. . 244.
1
124
12 (117) 2014

, , (. 4).
1994.,

.
.

. 5 (. 3).

. 11 . ,
.
,
,
.

, .
4 2010 , 2010 58,9%

. 12% 39% . - (
, 7% ).
: 68% 60

24% 18 30 ; 75% 470, . 29%
23, 170.
; 47% ,
29% .

, . . , 3
( )
1999
60
10
<1
<1
<1
8
19

/
/
2003
75
13
1
<1
<1
<1
10
<1
2012
79
11
1
<1
<1
<1
9
<1
4
, ? (
)

1999
2010
46
39
48
41
49
38
5
, ? ( )

1999
59
47
11
17
13
14
17
22
12 (117) 2014
. 2010
41
41
33
36
16
14
10
9
125
. 2013. :

, ?
37% ,
45%.
, , ,
/ .
,
( ), .
, , .
,
..
,

. 20
.
.
: ,
1,
23 . ? :
.

.

.
, , , ,
,
. , , 2,
, .

.
1

BNS (Baltic News Service)
http://www.belta.by/ru/all_news/president/Lukashenko-majdana-vBelarusi-ne-budet_i_660937.html.
2
.
,

, : , , , ,
. ,
, . ,
,
, ,
,
3.
. 2013. 6,25
.
, . . 2013. 2,14 .
.
.
,
,
,
2013 ,
100
. -
1442 .
300 100 . . ,
214 100 .
4.

.
( ) .
2011 . 26.5 ( 23.5,
43).

. , 2012.,
, 10 . (16% ).
2013. , 15,8%.
126
http://news.tut.by/politics/389179.html.
http://www.belaruspartisan.org/life/252193/.
12 (117) 2014
- 19,5% (/),
. -
2011.
. 4,7%, ,
3,9%.
,
. .

. ,
,
, -
. 2013. (28,1%),
(3,6%).
.
(
(), ()
())

(. 6-8). 5, 13
14 .
,

.
. 6-8
,

( ),
6
? ( )
.
2010
25
58
16
9
2011
2
23
73
71
2013
13
56
29
16
2013
14
63
22
8
.
2013
12
64
22
10
.
2013
13
58
28
-15
* ( )
7
- ? (
)

.
2010
31
41
17
14
2011
12
20
56
44
2013
15
45
27
12
2013
18
49
24
6
.
2013
18
47
28
10
.
2013
13
46
36
-23
8
,
? ( )

/

*
.
2010
54
33
13
.
2011
17
69
14
2013
35
51
14
2013
40
46
14
.
2013
39
47
14
.
2013
32
54
14
21
52
16
-22
12 (117) 2014
127
2011., .
-
2013 . .
14, . . , ,
,
.
.
,
. , .
(35% ) ,
, . ,
2011 .

.
2013 .
, , (. 9).

,
,
1. , , .

2013 . , -2015. ,

2001, 2006 2010 ? ,
,
.

, ( , ).
2014 .

.
(
) .
.

(2004-2008 .), 14,5%.
.
.

. , .
. 2012.
21%.
2013.
54,9% 2012. 10,1
. : , , 2012 .
45%.

2014 .
,
, .
, , .
9
, ? ( )

.
2011
88
8
4
2012
77
15
8
2012
72
21
7
.
2012
64
24
12
2013
65
25
10
2013
60
30
10
.
2013
57
32
11
.
2013
69
22
9
http://polit.ru/article/2007/10/19/furman/.
128
12 (117) 2014
21 2013 ., ,
:

. . .
.
,
, :
,
?
, . , ,
1.
2013. - 2014. , 2014.
(3,3%) .
,

, . .
,

.
.
2013 .
40,7%.

. 28
:
, . , , 2.
2013. .

, .
,
:
43% , 35% (. 10).
http://president.gov.by/ru/news_ru/view/vstrecha-s-rukovoditeljamibelorusskix-smi-7880/.
2
http://president.gov.by/ru/news_ru/view/aleksandr-lukashenko-provelsoveschanie-o-sostojanii-i-razvitii-potrebkooperatsii-belarusi-7912/.
1
10

( )
2013
33
2013
37
2013
41
.
2013
43
.
2013
35
.
, , .

, .
,
, , .
***
.
, .

1996 .

. , 70 . ,
18
.

.
.
2013. . , , .
.

,

ultima ratio.
, -. ,

? , . . ,
,
.
12 (117) 2014
129

? (
1-2),
- (),
. 2013 .
, .

, -
.
(
24 2 ) .
, ,

.

. 2008.
.

-.

,
?: 35%, 54%, 11%.
(), 71%, - 24%1.
, , ,
,
http://www.belaruspartisan.org/politic/265044/.
130
(+21)
(+16) ( .1-3

2010. 2011
).

, . , ..

2013 .
. 2013.
8
(41% vs. 33%), 2014 .
32% (-9 ),

35% (+ 2 ).

69 55% , , .

1,8 ,
:
63% vs. 35%.
, ,

, ,

? (.4).
,

, 1-3.
, 7% ,
. -
12 (117) 2014

, .
2008. .

:

35 40%, 38 46%.
62% ( 10
!). ,
(40%)
.
5
2008 . .
: -
1
? ( )

.
2010
25
58
16
9
2011
2
23
73
71
2013
13
56
29
16
2013
14
63
22
8
.
2013
12
64
22
10
.
2013
13
58
28
-15
2014
10
63
25
-15
* ( )
2
- ? (
)

.
2010
2011
2013
2013
.
2013
.
2013
2014
31
41
17
14
12
20
56
44
15
45
27
12
18
49
24
6
18
47
28
10
13
46
36
-23
24
45
26
-2
3
,
? ( )

*
.
2010
54
33
13
21
.
2011
17
69
14
52
2013
35
51
14
16
2013
40
46
14
4
.
2013
39
47
14
8
.
2013
32
54
14
-22
2014
40
46
14
-6
4
, ,
? ( )

,

12 (117) 2014
%
7
28
62
3
131
5

2008
-6
10
11
()
()
()
.
, , . ,
(. 6). 2009 .
,

(
2008 .: 54% vs. 26%).

15 !

. ,

2%, .

, ,
73%.
, , , 6%.
.
,
.
, -
2013-2014
.
-5
16
23
.
21
-24
11
.
-10
-11
-8
.
-16
-23
-22
-15
-3
-6
.
.
.
.
,

. , .

, - 1.

( ),
. 66%, 15% (
).

, .
(56%)
, 16%
vs. 21%.
6
,
? ( )
.
2008
.
2009
.
2010
.
2011
.
2012
2013
2013
.
2013
2014
46
42
38
41
38
37
41
37
52
30
42
38
39
43
42
41
45
33
24
16
24
20
19
21
18
18
15
http://polit.ru/article/2014/03/13/acident/.
132
12 (117) 2014

:
8,3 , 5 (.7). ,
.
. .
. ,
. ,
.
2006. 500 2010 .
.
2015 ., ,
1000 , .. (540
2014.). , 100% (
45% 2012.). ,
.
, . 3
: ,
, ,
,
. , , , , <>
. , , : ,

.
, . , ,
7

( )

,
?
(52%)
(33%)
/
(15%)
?
, (16%)
25
3
13
, (21%)
9
45
8
(56%)
59
46
68
?
,

(37%)
50
20
30
,
(37%)
25
55
38
. ?
, (55%)
69
33
53
(28%)
18
47
19
, , , , ?
(4%)
1
10
1
, (23%)
14
39
19
(70%)
83
45
77

12 (117) 2014
133
.
500-600 , 1.

.
.

.

. 2012.
23 . , .. . - 8 . .
,
, 3,5-4 . .
. . 9 ,
, ,
. .
,

, .

,
.

-
, .
,
2013 . 40%,
. -2014 ()
.
.
.
,
-2014:
: .
. .
.
2.
2014 .
. , ,
. ,
.
***
- ,
,
. , , . .
, , ,
,
.
,
. .
http://president.gov.by/ru/news_ru/view/aleksandr-lukashenkoobraschaetsja-s-ezhegodnym-poslaniem-k-belorusskomu-narodu-inatsionalnomu-sobraniju-8549/.
2
http://president.gov.by/ru/news_ru/view/aleksandr-lukashenko-posetits-rabochej-poezdkoj-minskuju-oblast-8649/.
1
134
12 (117) 2014
, ,
.
, .
, .

,
, .
, , :
1. ;
2.
;
3. , c , ;
4. ;
5. ;
6.
. . . . . . . . 2013, 3-4(116), .3-16,
.
. 2829
. ,
.
24
, 50 100 ,
2004 .
,
.
,
.
. 30 4
,
,
. ,
,
,
.
, (8 ) 700 .
.

( , ,
).
7 8 2013 ( )
. faceto-face 1037 . 20
-.
, ,
(70%),
(54%)
(50%).

, (82%),
12 (117) 2014
135
(80%), (75%),
(71%),

(58%).
- - , (81%), -, 57%
. (52% 42% ),
-
.
64%,
13%. 60%
, ,
, ..
-
. - , 50%.
, ,
, ,
.
, ,
,
.
. ,
, . .
.
, . ( ,
, 6 2014, http://gazeta.
zn.ua/socium/komandir-otryada-samooboronymaydana-vse-u-nas-budet-horosho-_.html).

. . ,
. .
(http://topor.od.ua/
protivoretchivy-maydan/).
136
, ,
(,
-; )
. ,
, - ( )
.
,
, .
,
, . ,
10- ,
. , 16 , 12 , (
). ,
, ,
6 (
,
, , ).
5 .
, , ,
.

. , ,
. 19 ( ) (,

). , , . ( , ,
) .
( ,
) ,

.
12 (117) 2014
, ,
- . , ,
- .
. , , ,
, , ,
. , ,
.
, - ,
,
. , ,
, . -
, ( , ).
, , ,
, ,
, , .

.
,
, .
,
. , ,
.
. ,
. !
!, .
,
, . ( .
In Re. , 14 2014 http://
gazeta.zn.ua/internal/in-re-_.html ).
, ,

( ), ( ! !) ,
. , ,
,
.

. . 28
- .,
(. ) ,
. 28 , 16 ,
2- .

,
. ,
, .
17 , .

2004 , .
,
, () ,
. . .
3 ( 20 ),
-
- (
, ). ,
: ( 38% 56%), ( 19%
41%),
( 21%
50%). , , ,
, ,
. .
8 18 ,

( face-to-face

2032 ). 1 ,
12 (117) 2014
137
1
? ( % )

3
80
13
4
23
40
32
5
11
51
33
6
32
20
42
7
52
8
39
1
40%
( 23% ),

10 ( 8%
80% ):
. 17 , , ,
.
18
,
2004 . ,
( ),
18
.
.
, . , ,
, .
, , , 9 (
).
,
. ,

-24 , . , ,
,
. ,
19 20 , , (
),
1. 18 20
. ,
, 100 2, 5 (),
1,5 100 .
., , The New
Times http://www.newtimes.
ru/articles/detail/79622/. .
, -, 21
.
,
, ,
.
. 21
, ,

.

,
, . ,
21 .
.
,
,
48 , 2004
( , ,
, ).
2014 . ,
.
, , (http://zn.ua/UKRAINE/ubiystvana-maydane-obnarodovany-plany-ih-organizatory-i-prichastnye-139660_.
html).
138
( ),
,
.
12 (117) 2014
, . ,
48
2004 . , , , , ,

18- ,
.
, , , ,
.

, , .
, . , ,

, ,
- .
,
, , .
.
,
,
. ,
.
, , .
(
)
. ?
, ,

(, ,

8% -,
22% , 70% ,
). ,
, , , .
-.

2012
. .

, , .
. ,
,

, :
, .
, ,
, . ,
.
, -,
, ,
( ),
, .
.
. ,

.
, , ,
,
. , , -
. , . ,
04 2014 http://www.pravda.com.ua/rus/
articles/2014/02/4/7012683/.
2012 .
, .
( ,
, ,
) .
.
,
, , -
12 (117) 2014
139
,
, (http://volnodum.
livejournal.com/879170.html). ( .
. http://eajc.org/page279/news43756.html).

(
) ,
(http://
eajc.org/page279/news43505).
, ,
,
,
(., , http://commons.com.
ua/?p=17444). 4 18 .
,

,
.
, ,
( , ,

, ). ,
,
. , ,
.
(CATI),
7 9 2014
(dual frame) 1020 ,
, ,
18 .
. 83%
140
, 9% . ,
. 93% ( 4%), (93%
3% ), 73%
15%, 68% 15%.
. . 21 2014.
, ,
. ,
,
, - , -
.
. , ,
.
. -, , .
, , .
, ,
, . , ,
, ,
. , , , , , ,
.
(, , ,
) ,
, ( ).
, ,
. ,
- ,

, , .
- ,
, .
12 (117) 2014

.
,
.
,
. , , , ,

.

. .

,
. .
,

.

,
.

, .
.
1980- - 1990-

.

,
. .
.
.

( ).
, .
,
. , , ,
-, : .
, , , ,
.
, , .
.

.

, .. ,
.
, ,
,
,
.

,
. .
.

, .
, : ,
12 (117) 2014
141
, ,
.
,

, , ,
, ,
.

, .. , - .

,
. . ,
.
, .
. .
,
. .
.
, -, .
,
.,
. , .
. ,
, , , , . ,

. ,
, -
142
, , .
, . ( , ).
. ,
,
,
.
. , ,
. . , - ,
. ,
,
. ,
, .
,

,
. , ,
.

.

, .
.
. , .
, ,
.
,
. .

12 (117) 2014
. ,
. ,

, .

, .
, .
, .
,
,
.
, .
,
.
. ,

. .
,
.
.

, .
: , , , ,
,

.

, , , , .
, ,
.

,
. .

, .
,
. . .
,
,
. , ,
,
. ,
,
.
, . ( -, ,

, ).
.
, ,
.
, , ,
,
, .
2011-2013 .
2011 2013 , ,
,
, . ,

. , , ,
. ,

.

.
- , -
12 (117) 2014
143
, ,
.

, ,
. .

,

,
.

.
, . , , , .
.
, , ,
. . ,
,
, -. ,
, ,
, . ,
. .
.

, ,
, .
: , , , , .
, ,
. , , , .

?
,
. , .
144
, ,
, .
,
.
, ,
. , ,
. - ,
.
,
,
.
, .
.
,
, , ,
( ,
).
, ,
, .

, . ,
, , . ,
.
, .
,
,
. ,
, , ,
. , , . :
1990- ,
500 : ,
!.
,
.
! ,
, ,
12 (117) 2014
, .

.
, , .
,
, . ,
. , ,
. ,
,
, ,
. .

, , , ,
.
, ,
.
, , , ,
.
, ,
.
, , :
,
,
.
2011
. 10 24 ,
, .
. ,
.
, ,
.
2011 1825 ,

, ,
.
.
1960- -1980- , .
: ,
, .
: . ,
.

,
, ,
.
, . .

- .
, , .

. -, 1930- , ,
,
, ,
.
,
, ..
,
, ,
,
. .
,
.
, .
12 (117) 2014
145
- . ,
.
- , - ,
, , .

. ,
.

. , -

, , . , , .
,
,
, . ,
(, )
,
-, ,
. , , , ,
, ,
.
, . ,
.

, . , ,
.

. ,
,
.
.
2011-2013 . , , .
-
146
. ,
, ,
,
.
.
, .
, .
, ,
.
, .
. ,

. ,
, , ,
,
.

. , , ,
, .
, .

. ,

, .
-
-.
,

(, , ..)
.

. ,
( ,
), , ,
, ,
. , -
12 (117) 2014
.
,
, . .

.

, ,
.
- .
, , , , ,

.
, , ,
.
,
.
,
,
; ,
, .
, . ,
, ,
:
, .
,
, , , , , - .
,

, .
, ,
. ,

:
. ,
, ,
, .
, . , ,
,
. ,

. , , .

.
. ,
.
, ,
.
,
, ,
.
6
2013 . .
. .

,
. ,

.
,

, , ,
-, , ( ). ,
, , 1991., , .

,
, ,
12 (117) 2014
147
. ,
, ,
,
.
,
.

( , )
, .
(
) , , .

. , .

. -
.
, . ,
.

,
(
, ). /.

, , , .
. ,
1920- 1930- , ,
,
. ( ,
-
148
, ,

,
.

, .)
,
,
, ,
/ ,
.

.

, .

, .

,
, , , , .

, .
- ( ,
,

)
/ .
, ,
.

. ,

12 (117) 2014
, ,
. .

.

- .

.
.

, - -.
,

.
,

. , ,
.

.

,
, .
, .
,
. ,
, ,
,
. , ,

,

,
.

,
, , .
, ,

.
,
, 2011-2012 .
,
, ,
( ),
,
, . , , .
, , ,
,
.
:
,

,
. ,

, 2011-2012-2013 . ,
: ,
.
, .
,
. ( 6
,
, ).
() .
(),

(),
,
12 (117) 2014
149
. , , , 2004-
2014
,
.

,
. ,
, , ,

,
.
. (
,
) ,
.
.
6 2012 .

,

,
. ,

. ,

.
.
,
,
( ) .
,
,
,
150
, , , -.

( )
,
.

.
,
,
(

).
- .
.
,
.
, .
, .

, , .
( 2004)
.
.

,
.
,

,
.
, ,
.
12 (117) 2014
.
, .
.
,
. ,
, .
, ,
, . ,
, , . ,
, ,
,
.

, ,
, .
. ,
( , )
.
- .

, , .
. ,
, , (
).
. ,
, ( -) - - .
.
,
,
. ,
. , , .

. , .
.

, .
. . .
, , , .

, . (
, ,
).
. , , .

. ,
, ,

,
, , , -
.
, , .
,
. , ,
.
.
.

, -
12 (117) 2014
151
,
.
, - .

.
, . ,
,
, ,

.
,
, ,
. ,
. , , ,
.
, ,
,

.

, .
, ,
,

, ,
. ( , , ,
. ,
,
).
,

,
,
.
,
.
152
.
-
: , , , ,
, , , ,
. ,

,
, , .
-
, .
, .
,
,
, , ,
. ,
.
, , 1.
, .

,

. , ,
. , .
.
.
. -2004 -2014

,
, -
. , .
1
12 (117) 2014
.

.
.
, , ,
.
,
, .. ,
. .
. ,
.
-,
- .
. ,
, ,
,
.
, , , ,
, . ,

. ,
, . ,
, , , , .

. . ,

,

,
,
.

.
,
, .
, , ,
. . ,

, . , - ,
.
. ,
,
,
.
, , .
,
. ,
, .

, :

.
, .
,
, ,
.
,
,

. , , ,

.
, , , ,
. ,
,
,
, .

, , , , , ,
.
12 (117) 2014
153
. , -

. , ,
.

.
, . .
,
. ,

. , , ,
,

, .
,
, . ,
.
, , , , :
,
. -
,
, .
154

.
***
,
,
, ,

. ,
.
,
..

,

, ,

.
,
.
.
, , ,
,
.
12 (117) 2014

2012
. 5 2011 ,

.
. 9 16 2012
,
,
,
Occupy Wall Street
.
:
. ,
, ... [] : , ,
, , .
- . ( 3,
)
[] . ,
, ,
. , , , , -
,
. ,
. , , , . ( 8, )
, , . ,
...
. ( 12,
)

1. , . .
2011 2012 .: / , 2012, 2 (112). . 73-86;
. 1
:

( , .),
.
,
OWS,
.
.

,
.

6 .
.
, ,

, ,
, , .

:
.
! , .
, ...
? , ,

- . ( 18, -)
, , ,
, .
( 21, )
/ , 2012, 3-4 (113). . 141-185.
.
.
12 (117) 2014
155

: , ,
, ,
( )
.

. ,
,
. .
,
, .
, , ,

, , ,
,
.
.

- 2012
,
.

, : , , , , .
,
: , , , .
( ) ,

OWS , , .
:
, 6 2012
, , .
,
,
:
, -
156
,
,
,
,
.
.
21 2-
6-9 2012 (
). 2013 ( ),
2012 .
,
.
- ( ), 2 Skype.
,

2012 .
,
,
( ) ,
, , ,
, .

,

2011 2012 . ,
,

( , , ,
, , ).
,
,
.

,
12 (117) 2014
, ,
(, .)
,

, . ,
.

, , .
,
. ,
. - ,
, - , .
,
, ,
1.

()
()
(-)
(-)
(-)
-
( )
( )
( )

22
23
25
29
27
27
22
24
30
19
22
23
26
30
36
37
40
50
21
22
24
38
, , , , .
I.
. , , ,
6 2012 . 9 16 .
2012 .
.
6

,
. ,
. ,
.
, . Twitter Facebook
, .
7
, :

.
, .
-, .

. ,
, .
-, .
.

1 -. , , https://twitter.com/#!/
navalny. . http://echo.msk.ru/programs/
albac/885769-echo/.
1
12 (117) 2014
157
,
-1. .
.
7 8
,
.
. ,
,
.
: , , , , .
- , ,
,
.
, -, - , ...
! , ,
- . ,
. ( 21, )
[] : , .
, ,
.
. , .
. ( 1, )
. -,
,
. .
8
.
, ( ) ,
.
.
.
,
,
(
) .

-
150 / . 8 2012 http://www.gazeta.ru/politics/
news/2012/05/08/n_2332301.shtml.
1
158
,
, - , ,
,
. ,
, ,
. .. ,
,
, ,
( 1, )
8 , , . ,
,
.
9
, .

, ,
, ,
- ., .
. -

, ,

:
- , - -. , , ...
, .
,
, ,
- , ,
. [ ]
- .
, ,
, , -
, -, - ,
,
,
, , , . ( 14, )

, .
. , , , ,
, , .
12 (117) 2014
, , , . , , . . , -
, -
, - . ( 5, -)
13
(
),
. . .
15
,
,
,
, 1.
16
.
. 2. -
,

,
.
19

, 3.
19 20
.

.
/
15 2012 http://www.interfax.ru/russia/txt/245810.
2
- / NewsRu.Com 16 2012
http://www.newsru.com/russia/16may2012/barrik.html.
3
/ 19
2012 http://www.interfax.ru/moscow/news/246502.
1
.
.
.
12

.

, , ,
.

.
26
6 , ,
.
15

. ,
, .

, , ,
.
,
, , ,
,

(,
-) .
-
,
, .
-
.
, ( , ).

,
.
III. : . -
12 (117) 2014
159

( ,
, , )1, - .

: (1) ,
, , , ,
, , (2) , , , ,
, (3) , , , (4) , ,
(5) , , . , ,
, .
,
,

2.
,

.
[ ]
,
. .
. , ,
... , - , .
, ,

, . ( 13, )3.
,
,
.
2
. . 75.
3

,
- ,
, ,
( 10
!), .
1
160
(1) , , ,
. (2) (,
, ). , (3) ,
, ,
, ,
,
.
,
, ,
, 6 2012
, :

, 6
, . , , , , ,
, . ( 3,
)

. , ,
, , - ...
5 -
, ,
,
...
, ... ,
, , ,

( 9- ), ,
. ,
,
- .
, ,
. ( 6,
-)
[ ]
. [- ] ,
, ,
-
12 (117) 2014

. [-]. ,
. ? - ,
... , , . ,
, :
, ? :
, .
,
, - , - ,
, , ,
. ( 10,
)
6 ,
,
: , .
, () ,
, 1. ,
-
. ,
, .
, (
)
, ,

. (
)
2.
, (, ,
.).
. , .
2
.
, ,
(, , , ).

,
,
.
1
-

, .
, ,
.

, , ,
(
) ,
, . -
,
,
.
, ,
2011
,
, !. ,
. -

. ( 12, )
[ Occupy Wall
Street]. ,

, [] ( 17, )
,
. , .
, .
, ,
, , , , ..
, ...

. ( 4, )
12 (117) 2014
161
,

.

,
,
, , (..
). , ,

. -, , . -,
,
, ,
, .
,
.
, ,
,
, .
(
, ), .
(1)
(2) , .
, , , . ( ,
, )
.
, (3) , .
. , (4)
:
162
,
,
. , ,
, ... ,
. ( 4, )
- ,
, . ( 14, )
[]
, ,

, , ,
.
. . (
19, -)

, , ,
- . ,
, ...
( 10, )

. , ,

.
, .
, .
,

,
,
. ,
. ,
,
. ,
. . . ( 8, )
, ,
, ,

12 (117) 2014
, 6 , , . . ( 15, )
,
. ,
-.
,
.
( 3, )
, , ,
. ( 12, )
, , 1

,
. ,
. , ,

. ,
, .
, ,
.
- , , , , , . , . ,
, ,
... , ,
. , , ,
. [] ,
[] ,
,
, . ,
. ( 12, )
,
. .
.
.
, ? . . ( 3, )
VIP , , .
1

,
, , .

, , .
- , ,
, , ,
,
.
.
,

,
, .
. .

,
, .
, .
, , ,
,
. ( 22, )
.
, . , . ,
? ( 11, )
, ( ) ,
( )
( ) . ,
.
, .
: ,
.
12 (117) 2014
163

.
, , ,
,
:
[ ] .
- , ,

, .
, . ,
, ,
. , .
,
, . ( 15, )
-
, , , , , ,
, , 200-400 .
, , , ,
( 16, )
,

, .
, , , .
... ,

. ( 11, )
, .
,
, .
, , ,
, ,
,
. , , ,
, ,
,
. ? (
13, )
164

. , -,
,
.

.
,
, ,
. ,
, .
. ( 12,
)
., ., ,

,
-,
, [- ] 26
.
, ...

( 7,
)
, 6- , . ,
, . : - ? .
10-15 . ( 10, )
,
7- -. -
, . , .
. (
15, )
, ( )

, ,
.
. , , . , -
12 (117) 2014
,
.
, .
.,
, . . . ( 2, )
. , , , , 98 :
. ( 11, )

.
- . (
13, )
,
, ,
,
:
24.
, , . ( 10, )
-, -, ,
, .
-
[ ] : ? : . . , ,
, ,
, .
: , ,
- ,
. , - , - , . (
13, )
,
. --.
, ,
. , , , . ( 22, )

.

, .

, ,
.
, ,
, , ,
:
,
. .
. ,
. ,
.
, -. , ,
- ,
. . ,
, ,
, .
[] .
. ,
. ,
, , . -
[ ],
. ?.. , -
,
-
: , , ,
, ,
- . ,
-
, -.
,
. ( 21, )
, , , . ,
. ,
-, .
,
. 15 ! (
15, )
12 (117) 2014
165
, ,
,
, :

,
- , []
, . - . ( 3, )
,
,
,
. ,
:
. ,
,
... ( 2, )
,
, , , ,
.
, ,
.
, .
( 15, )
. ,
, , - , .
? ! ,
, ,
.
, ,
, . , - .
, ,
2005.
, - . ,
- , .

, , , . ( 21,
)
, -
166
, ,
, .
, , , .
, .
-, ,
.
, -, -
,
. , ,
. , . ( 2, )
,
. . , .
, ,
, , :
,
[], . , -
. ( 12, )

, . (1)
,
. (2) ,
,
( , )

. (3)

, . :
[ ]
- . -,
, . , ,
,
. ,
, . , -,
12 (117) 2014
, - . .

, ,
.
,
. ,
. , - , ,
. ( 21, )
,
. :
,
, . .

. :
(1) 6 (2)
( , )
, (3) , (4)
( ),
, (5)
, .
,
. ( 22, )
. -
: 3- . .
, , , , .
, ,
, .
( 1, )
,
.
. ,

,
( 18, -)

.
,
, :
. ,
, ,
. , , , ,
. ( 1, )
:
, - . ,
. , , .
, ,
. . ( 19,
-)
- , , :
, ? ,
, : , ?
. ?
. ? --, .
, : , 50 20 ,
. , 40 . , 40 . ,
,
. . ,
, , .
. ? - , . ?
- ,
. , ,
, ,
1 . ? ( 13, )
, .. .
1
12 (117) 2014
167
, ,
- , ,
: , , . ,
, - ,
. ,
. ( 1, )

,
, . ,
, , ,

, . ,
, ,
6 .
- ,
, . ,
, , ,
:
[ -] ,
,
. ,
, , : , . -
. ( 5,
-)
,
,
.
, . , ,

. -
. ( 3, )
. . , ,
. , ,
, :
,
,
. : ,
! , - .
!.
168
- , -
,
? ?, , . ,
. - .
( 4, )
[ ] ,
. . , - , :
, , . ,
. ,

.
, ,
. ( 16, )
,

. ( 17,
)
, :
-
? ?
. ( 22, )
, .
. , , , (1)
, ,
, (2)
,
, , .
, (3)
,
, , (4) .
- , , .
: ! !, , .
( 1, )
, ,
. -
12 (117) 2014
, , ,
. , ,
,

.
. , . ,
.
( 22, )
, , , . (
13, )

.

:
[- ]
, ,
( , ),
- , - , , .
, ... (
2, )
.
, , -
... ,
,
, ,
- . ,
, . ( 19,
-)
IV. . ,

, , ,
.
,
,
, :
-
,

,
. , , , , - , - ,
- , - , - , -
. ( 7, )
,
: 1) , 2) , 3)

,
, 4) . , , 5) ,
,
,
.

-.

(
,

) ( , ),
( .). - , -
, - - ( , ).
, 7- .
, ,
-. (
2, )
.
, - ,
. ,
: , , ,
,
, ,
. ( 14, )
, -

12 (117) 2014
169
, : , , -. , . , -
.
, .
, , .

. ? ... -
. . .
- . , , . ( 10, )
, , ,
. ,
. , , .
, , , , .
, , , .
. ( 14,
)
, - ,
.
,
, . ( 12, )
,
6 , .
.
,
.
, ,

( ,
).
-
-
170
-: 1) , -,
,
2) ,
, 3) - , 4)
, ,
.
, , .
:
-
, , .
- ,

. [ ] , .
! -
. , ,

. ( 8, )

, ,
,
, , . ...
, ,
.
, , , , ,
.
( 7,
)
, , ,
. , . -,
11-
.
, ? , , . ,
- , . ( 10, )
,
. ,
. ,
... ( 11, )
- .
12 (117) 2014
- ,
, , ,
, .doc,
- , - ,
-. . ( 13, )

,
( )
,
. ,
.
, , ,
-,
.
, ,
, .

. , . ,
. , . ( 13, )
,
,
, .
,
,

.
:
.
- -,
- ,
, - ,
[-].
: - .
. ,
, ...
,
,
. ( 5, -)
, ,
( )
,
(

, ).
:
: , ... ,
. , -
, , . , ... :
, , ,

,
. , , ,
,
-.
, , , - . ,
- . , ,
, ,
- .
, - , .
, - ,
, ,
, ,
.
. . . , , - .
.
, ,
.
, ,
,
, ,
, . ( 16, )

,
. ,
,
. ,
,
. ,
:
.
-. ...
,
12 (117) 2014
171
, ... , . ,
. ,
,
,
- . ,
. .
( 12, )
. ,
.
, , .
, ,
, - ,
- . ,

,
.. , , .

. ( 6,
-)
V. :
. ,
, 2011

OWS
. ( , ),
-
, .
,
,
. ( 8,
)
,
, .
, , , ,
,
..

, .
172
,
,
, , . , ,
. ( 2, )
, , . . ,
,
- , - -,
- . ,
. ,
, ,
. .

.
.
, ,
, ... -?
,
.
, .
, . ( 4,
)

,
,
,
:
,

,
! , , .
, ,
. ! , ,
. (
6, -)
, ,
, , ,
.
12 (117) 2014

, , ,
, , .

,
,
,
, . ,
,

. ,

, ,
:

. , Pussy Riot ,
, .
,
1.
, ,
.
, ,
-
[ ] ,
, . ( 17,
)
,
.
, , ,

, , , ,
. .
. ( 3, )
, .
1
,
.

(, ,
: , .),
,
:
. ... ,
. ( 4, )

. ,

.
, , ... ,
- , .
( 4, )

, , : 1) , ,
,
2)
,
, 3) ,
, ..,
, 4) .

, , , (
). ,
- - , . ,
, ,
, - , . ,
,
,
. :
12 (117) 2014
173
[]
, . , ,
, . ( 15, )
, ,
,
. - . ( 3,
)
, . [, ]
,
,
. ( 13, )
, ,
, , .
,
( , ).
, .
.
, ,

, .
(, ),
.
,
,

. , ,
- . ( , ,

174
, ).

. , .
.
. ,
. ,
. . , :

, , . ( 18,
-)
, , ,
( ),
,
.
,
. ,
, .
(
)
. :
,
,
. ( 12, )
,
, .
,
:
, .
, , :
, ! ( 13,
)
, - :
[ ] ... ,
, , .
,
12 (117) 2014
,
. ( 11, )
.
, ,
,
, .
, ,
[ ]
, ? ( 5, -)

, , :
...
, .
, . - ,
.
, . , , -
, -
, , - , , .

, ; -
, , , , , , ,
,
, , ,
. ( 16, )
,
,
,
,
.
:
. , ,
... -
( 8,
)
,
, , , . ( 12,
)
VI. .
- .
.
, (1) ,
, , ,
.
,
(2) : 6
2012 , ,
9-10 .
, (3)
, ,

(
1). (4) ( ),
- .
, , (5)
, .
,
, , ,
:
, , , .
,
... . ( 12, )

, ,
. :
, ... , ,
.
( 21, )

5 2012
, ,
.
, ,
, . ., , / Lenta.
ru 6 2012 .
1
12 (117) 2014
175
, ,
,
:
20
, ,
, , .
- . ,

, .
- , , . ( 20, )

. , ,
( ), ( ), () .
, ,
1968 .
, ,
:
.
50-60 ,
, ,
, , -
, , , . ,
. ( 6, )
.
, - , ,

,
, ,
. - -
176
.
,
, .
, ,
. ( 2,
)
, 2012 Occupy
,

,
,
, . ,

,
.
, 1) , , (, ),

. 2) .
Occupy
. ,

, .
, .
. , ,
! ... ,
.
, . . ( 3, )
[] . ( 4, )

, , , ,
, -
,
,
,
. ( 20,
)
12 (117) 2014
2012 , :
.
,
... , , 6 ,
. ( 8,
)

2008 ,
, ,

,
. ( 11,
)
[] , , ,
,
,
,
, . . ( 7, )
6-8

,

6-8 2012,
-

,

, 9 , .
:
6 .
.
.
.

. . ,
.( 15, )
, , - .

,

, - ,
. ...
! ! ( 21, )
6 ,
... 6 , ,
, ,
. ( 12, )

[ ].
, , ,
, ,
. ( 4, )

(
)

2011 2012 . ,
, 13
2012 .,
, :
,
. - , ... [ ]
,
6 . (,
, 2012)1.

, 7-8 ,
, .

( ,

2011 2012 ). :
. . 159.
12 (117) 2014
177
,
, .
,
,
, . ,
,
, 1.
, , (
)
, ,
. (

),
,
.
,
, .
, , , , .
, ,

.
,
, ,
,
.
,

. ,
6 .

.
, (
, , ,
, .,
). - ,
, .
, . 157.
178
... , 6 , .
, ,

, ,
, ,
5- .
. , ,
, ,
. , ,
,
. ...

,
, -

. , ,

, ,
,
. ( 15, )
,
, , ,
, , -
:
6 . , , [
9 ,
],
,
. , . 10 [2011 ]
. , !
...
[ 2010 ], ,
, , -
, . ,
- , ,
, , -
12 (117) 2014
[
] - .
. ( 16, )
, , ,
- . , ,

:

. . ( 15, )
.
.
,
,
. ,
:
, [] -
. ,
- , , ,
,
. , , , , . ( 16, )
[ ]
, . , ,
. , , 7 , . (
21, )
, ,

. , ,
. - . - .
( 15, )
,
- ,
- - . . . (
3, )
, , 6 - .
.
,
, , , .
,
, .

,
.

Facebook, 2012 Twitter.
[ ] . ,
. , , ,
,
,
, #OccupyAbay
, , .
. ( 15, )

6% .
. -
,
, .
2012 ,
:
, [
Twitter], . ( 7,
)
7 ,
, . . .
( 3, )
. ,
. ( 6, -)
- ,
. ,
. ,
12 (117) 2014
179
, -
, ,
. ( 15, )

.
,
() ( ,
)
, -1.
, 2011 ,
Facebook2,
2012
.
. ,
, :
,
, , - - . , ,
. , ,
.. ( 19, -)
.
. ,
-
.
. . ( 5,
-)
, . -,
(
) -

. -,
,

, , ,
, , , , ,
, , ., .
: - . 2-
., . . .: - , 2009. . 112.
2
. . 80.
1
180
, :
- , , , .
-, , , .. ( 14,
)
,
, , [ ], , ,
, , , ,
. ( 15, )
-, ,

,
()
()
, () . ,
.
: ,
, , , ... , .
( 15, )
. 300 400 .
( 3, )
, , .

, ,

, ,
. ( 15, )

, - (
, ).
-
12 (117) 2014
,
,
.
.
,
, - ,
-.

. ...
.
. , ,
, ... [
] .
. ( 3,
)
-
-,
,
-, [ ] . ( 2, )
-
, .
. , -,

,
,
.
VII. , , .
,

. , . , ,
, , .
, ,
, ,
, ,
.
: 1) , 2)
, 3)

;
4) (
); 5) () 6) ()
() ; 7)
( ).
1.
6
.
, ,
.

.
,

, .
- . ( 21, )
, , 6
.
, ,
. , . ( 1, )

,

.
, , 1 , - , .
. 6 .
, ,
, , , -

... , (
), , -
. . / 13 2012 http://ria.ru/
society/20120513/647830860.html.
.
1
12 (117) 2014
181
, ,
, ,
.
, , . , 6
, , ,
, - . , ,
, , . (
2, )
, ,
-.
. ,
...
,
. - . ( 1, )
,
6 , ,
... , ,
, . ( 7, )
. -
, - . ,
, , ,
. ( 12, )
,
, ,
, ,
, ,

. ,

2012.
2.
. ,
,
. ,

. .
182
,
,
, ,

.
,
,
, ,
, ,

, , , . ,

. . ( 4,
)

, ,
, -
. !
. (
18, -)
... , .
! - ,
: , ,
[ ] -
. ( 14, )
, , , , , ,
,
.

, ,
, !, ,
. , , ,
, ,
, , ,
,
.
12 (117) 2014

, , , ,
. , ,
, .
[] , ,
. (
21, )
, , , ,
, ,
,
.
,
:
,
.
, ,
. ( 22, )
3.
,
, ,
.
,
,
, , ,
1. ,
-
.
. () , .
,
,
, , ,
., , , ,
, . /
http://www.
levada.ru/proekt-demokratiya-v-rossii/07-12-2012/samoorganizatsiya-isamoupravlenie-v-dvizhenii-occupy.
, ,
,
- ,
- . ( 2,
)
, . . ( 8, )
- . ,
[].
, , , , .
,
2.
( 14, )

( ,
).
2012
( ), 2011 .

,
. ,
,
.

( ),
.
?
- , , , ,
:
- , ,
, - , ,
- , -
. ( 3, )
. ,
, , , ,
, ,
,
(), ,
,
. .
2
12 (117) 2014
183
, . ( 15,
)
, , , ,
, . ( 4, )
, ,
, ,
, ,
, , . ( 3, )
,
,
. :
. ? ... . ( 3, ). , ,
:
- . , . ,
. ( 5, -).
,
, : - , .
, ,
. ( 8,
)
,
, , .
, ,
...
, ,
, ,
.
,

. ,
, ,
,
, . ( 8,
)
,
. , ,
184
. ( 7,
)

. , , ( , ,
) .
, , . , ,
, ,
. ,
,
.
.
, , ,
, ,
: , ,
,
, ... , , , . -
. , ( 7, )
.
,
. , , . ,
, , . ( 7,
)
,

, ,
,
, ,
, .
,
,
, ,
.

.
12 (117) 2014

:
, ,
, ,
, - , .
( 15, )

,
,
... . ( 7,
)

,

, .
( . ,
), , , ,
:

, .
,
, , , ,
.
.
, , . ( 9, )
[]
. ,
. - ,
, ,
, .
, , ( 2, )
,
,
,
. ,
, , ,
, :

, .
,
.
, , , , . ,
,
- . ,
. ( 18, -)
:
[ ] , ,
- , - , ,
. . -
, , ,
, , .
. , ,
. ( 18,
-)
, 2011 ,

( 5
10 , ). . . 24
,
.
, , ,
. ,
(
, ,
,
),
(, , ).
,
.
, ,
12 (117) 2014
185
,
-,
. ,
, , .
, , , , ,
. ,
.
,
.

,
:

,
: ,
, , , , ,
, . , , ?
,
, . ( 15, )
( ) ,
1. ,

( , ,
,
, ),
. ,
,
.
, , ,
, ,
, ,
. ( 2, )
, , ,
., . 152.
186
, - , -
, . ( 6, )
- ,
,
. , . , ...
, . ( 8, )
, , , , ,
. ,

, , -,
2012 ,
, 2.

,
, .

. -
,
2-3 3.
11% , 5%

( , , , , , .), 4%
,
, 3% , 2%
- ,
.
,
,
.
3
. 2014 , 1000 .
2
12 (117) 2014

.
, , ,
...
,
- , ,
...
, , . (
18, -)
4.
-
, ,

, ,
, ,
. .
:

, ,
, ,
, , ,
,
. ( 4,
)
, ,
, , ,
. , ,
. ( 12, )
. ,
. (
2, )
, Occupy, , ,
. , (
).
,
,
.

,
. ,

. ,
,
,
, ,
, , , . ,

- ( ),
.
, -
1.
:
, , , - ,
, . ( 3, )
, ,
, ,
. .
- , - . .
( 7, )

.
-
- ,

2013 . , 6 ,
. ,

:
2012
2013 .
1
12 (117) 2014
187
.
, :
.
,
, . .
( 9, )
, [] ,
? ,
, ,
.
. (
7, )

, , ,
, (
)
( ), ( ),
:

- ...

. ,
. - , .
, ,
-.
.
. (
14, )
:

, - . ,
,
, , ,
, ,
:
, ... , , , .
( 2, )
188
. ,
- , . ( 10,
)

,
, , , ,
.
. , ,
, . ( 15, )
, ,
, .
:
,
,
, ,
.
, , ,

,
:
[ ]
. -,
- :
, , ,
- , .
( 4, )

. ( 6,
-)
-
:
,

. , , ,
. ! ,
! ( 19, )
[ ,
] . ( 21, )
12 (117) 2014

:.
, .
, ,
, , , .
, .
, ,
,
. , .
( 18, -)
- ,
,
,
,

, - :
... , , . ,
,
, ,
. , , , . ,
, [ ] -
. ( 12, )
5. ()

.
.
( ) ,
.

. , ,
.
, , . ( 2, )

, [ ] , , ,
. ( 4, )
:
(, ,
, ) (
, , ,
).
, , ,
. , ,
. ,
(
, ), ,
6 ,
,
( ).
,
, , , ,
,
. ,
,
(, ), .

, ,
.
, (1) ,
, , . (2)
, ,
,

, , . , ,
, , (3)
,
12 (117) 2014
189
.
,
.

,
, , , ,
.
,
(4) ,
.
, (5) , ,
.

, .
,
, ( ,
),
,
,
, , .
,

.
,
, .
[ ] , . ,
. ,
- , , . ,

. , , -
, ,
... ,
. - ,
. ( 8,
)
. []
190
.

. , -
, ... ( 9, )
, , : ,
, , ?
. ,
. ( 2,
)
,
, . (
),
,
:
, ,
. ( 12, )
,
, . ( 14, )
,
( ), .
,
. 1. , , ,
. ,
, , ,

, ,
. , : !
, ,
. : ,
, . ( 14, )
,

: ,
,
:
.
1
12 (117) 2014
. , , ()
.

,
, . , (1)
,
;
(2) ,
, ,
(, , , .); (3)
, (4) ,
, ,

( ,
). , ,
, - , :
,
...
,
. .
( 10, )
,
.
.
,
, ,
. (
15, )
, Twitter,

, ,
, , - , , , .
, ,
.
, -
, , -

, ,
,
, ,
, , ,
... , ,
,
, , , .
( 14, )
- ,
-, .
- - , , - ,
.
, ,
, ,

,
. , . ( 10,
)
,
. .
( 11, )

,
.
,
, . .
, , .
, ,

(
,
), , ,
. ,
, ,
, (, ,
- , ).
12 (117) 2014
191
,

[]
. . . ,
, , - .
. . ( 22, )
, -
, ... - , -
.
, -
( 11, )
,
, , . .
. ,
- , - . ,
-
. ( 2, )
,
,
. ( 18, -)
.
,
.
, . (
9, )

,
.
,
, .
,
, , ,
. : ,
, , , , ,
.
, ,
, , ,
192
, . ( 14, )

, .
, ,
, 1. , .
, (1) ,
. , (2) .
, , , , . , , (3) ,
, , , . ,
(4) ,
, , .
, , :
,
, , . (5) ,
, , - , . (6)
, , ,
( , ).
, (7) ,
, . , .
(8) , ,
,
. , , (9)

.
6. ,

, , , 1)
,
; 2)
;
, .
,
,
.
1
12 (117) 2014
3) , :
, ,
,
. : ,
, , , .

,

.
:
( 6, -)
. , , .
,
( 3, )

, :
, , . ,
...
- .
.
, ,
. . -
,
.
. 300 400
...
, 9 10

: ,
, . ,

. , ,
, , . ,
.
.
.

.
. (
3, )
, , ,
, 1.
: 5
5 , , - .
, -
- . ,
, , . ( 6, -)
5 . ,

: , ,
,
, 5 ,
- .
, [
]
, . , ,
, ,
, - . .
( 7, )

.
.
,
-13
(
): ,
- . : ,
, , ,
, , . , - .
5 , 150 ,
25 . . / .

2013 , 16 2014 http://www.asi.org.ru/
news/doklad-o-sostoyanii-i-razvitii-fondov-v-rossii/.
1
12 (117) 2014
193
:
[ ] , [ , ,
, ]. , 30
, ,
. , , ,
, , .
,
,
, ,
, ,
.
.
. ( 12, )
, ,

, .
,
.
, , . ,
.
( 9,
)

,
, ,
. ,
, :
[] ,
. , , ,
, , , , ...
,
, , . ,
, . ? ,
, ,
194
.
, ,
. ( 17, )
, - ,
,
- , - , . ,
,
... ( 20, )

6 ,
,
.
, .

. , , , 6
. , 6

,

1.
.
-,
. , ,

, , .
.
-,
.
:
, , . ( 1, )
, [ 6 ]
, . (
21, )

-
2012 .
1
12 (117) 2014
(

1).
,

,
, .

,
(
) ,
,
.
6
,
, 6 .

. , ,

2
,
,

.
6
:
[ 6 ].
- , . . .
,
. ,
. . ,
.
. , , , .
. .
( 9, )
,
6 ,
, :
start-up , ,
-.
2
6 ., . The New Times / The New Times, 43-44 25
2013 .
1

, , ,
. 6 . ,
, , , ,
. ( 18, -) ,
,
:
, ,
.
, ,
,
, 6 ,
,
.
. (
18, -)
6 , .
,
. . ,
, . , , , .
( 8, )
, ,
.
, .

6. ,
,
, - . ,
.
( 9, )
, , 6 ,
.
,
.
, -
12 (117) 2014
195
(
-, , ). ,
,
.
, ..:
,
.
, , [26 2012 ]

[],
6 , . ( 4, )

. ,
.

,

, , ,
... ,
.
,
, , .

.
, .
.
6 . ( 9, )
, ,
: , , [ ]!
!.. , , . ,

,
,

, .

. , , .
6
196
, .
, , , -, -
-,
. ,
2012
, .
***
, 9-16 2012 ,

20112012 .
,
, ,
1.

6 2012 ,

. ,
, ,

,
,
.

, ,
, .
1
-,
, 1-2%
, 6% . 12% . 60% , , - , , .
( 30-31 2013
500 , 6,7%). ,
-, 85%
( 1000 8-16 2011 , 4,3% http://www.levada.ru/1912-2011/moskvichi-ob-oppozitsii-i-aktsiyakh-protesta-vystupleniyakh-vpodderzhku-edinoi-rossii.
12 (117) 2014

,

,
,
.
, .
.

, .,
,
, (), .
, ..
,
,
,
,
. ,
,
,
,

, .

,
,

. , , ,
.
( ) ,
, ,
.

6 , ,
.

, ,
.
,
6
- , .
,

.
, 1,
,

.
,
, .
. . / 7
2014 . http://nvo.ng.ru/ideas/2014-04-07/9_protest.html.
1
12 (117) 2014
197
..
.

..

,
.., -
1960-
- 1980- .
,
, .

, , ,
...

- .
(1927 2013.)
,
1950- 1980- .

1950 1963 . .. ,
,
, 1955 .
198

, 1965.
1. 1964. .. .
(
)

. 1987.
- ,
, ,
2.
-
- ..
. 1968 .
..
: (1958)
(1966).
2

: (1970); - (1974); (1974);
: (1977);
(1977); -
: (1980);
(1980); - (1987)..
1
12 (117) 2014
-,
1981. .
1980- .
..
,
.
, 1988 . ,
.
..

,
, ,
,

.
, ..
,
,
- ,

.
-
,
,
, . ,
, ,
, .

,
, , , , ,
, , ,
.
,
1, ,
, , ,

,
.. .

(1960-61.), . ..
1982-83 .,

.
,
-
,

.
, : , -,

, -,

- , .

, : 1974 . -
. 3- 1975
.
.
,
, 10-
(1965 .) ,
.. . ,
, , , , , .
. .. . 2. :
. - .: , 2007. . 580-581.
1
12 (117) 2014
199
,
(,
, 10 ),

:

1. ,
, .
, ,
( ..2), ,
,
, ,
.
,
1960- . - ,
,
3.
.. .
-

.
, .. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 641.
2
. (. .. ) .: . 1993.
3
, 1962 , ,
:

. ,
, . ,
, , ; , , , ,
,
. -
. .. 3. :
. - .: , 2007. . 460-467.
1
200

:
;
;

- .

- .

.

(1959-1961 ).
, . ,
,
.
..
: ,
.
. ,
: , 4.

XX .
, -
- :
, ( ),
( ),
.. , , ,
.. , 5- , . 34, . 198.
12 (117) 2014
,
1.

,
.
,
:
10-12 , , 1917. 1927.,

,

.
1939 ., , . 1940-
1950- ,

.
- . ,
;
;

- , . ,
, .
, , ,
, ,
, .
- ?

. ,
", ,
,
, . ..
., 5 ., . 39, . 21.
1
19271929 . ( ), 1936-1938 .
( ), 1949 . (
)
,
,
,
2.
, -
, 1957 .
, , ,

3.

,
( ) ,
.
.
, , ,
- .
, , ,

.
, , ,
,
.
1930.

VIII 16
1928 : - ,
, , , , , , .. ..
, ,
. . ,
. .., .
16 . 11.
3
.. 22
1957 . .. . . 8, ., 1962.
2
12 (117) 2014
201

-,
,
,
1. ,
, . 1937-38 . -,
.
1930- 1940-
-,
- . 1940-
, .
, ,
.
1957 1961.

, , 2.
1959 .
, ,

, , , -
1,5
-.
., 1930.
2
(
) -, , , , , 1975 :

,
? , ,
,
, . , ,
, ,
..

22 1957 . ., . . 15-16.
1
202
,
. ,
,
.
- -
.. . 1937-38.
1940.,
- 3- ,
,
,
.
3.
, 1930-.
4,5 . ,
, .
,
,
4.
, ,

.
,
.. .
3
. // , 1940,
2, c. 46-65; // , 1941, 1, c.53-79.
4

.. . , . 1, . 32, . 1-86, . 33, . 1-117,
620.
12 (117) 2014

. .
,
4,5 , 3,5 .
( !) ,
1.
,
.
,
.. , ,
, ,
2.
, .

- .
, -, .
.
20 ,
, , , :
, 3.
:
, , .. , 4.
, . . .
,
-
, -,
, , -, , , , ,
, , .. .
:

,
, ,
.
:
, , .. ,
, . ,
,
,
5.
1960.
,
. . . ?
,

20- 6.
1950-.
4,5 ( : 2 , 810 )7.

-
, , , ,
.
-
. // 1941.
6. . 85-96.
2
.., ..
1939-1941 // , 2005, . 9.
3
.. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 448.
4
.
. . 449-450.
, ,
,
, , - , ,
.
7
.. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 451.
6
12 (117) 2014
203
.
, .
,
,

, . ,
-
, .
.
, -,
- .. . ,
-,
3,75 . , ,
3 1.
,
4,5 ,
,

, 3 ?!
- -
,
. ,

- . , ,

,
.

. .
. , - .. . , ,
3,75

. : 3 , .: . . . 3. . 453.
1
204
,
-
.. . ,
- .. ,
.. , .. .. ,
-.
,
-,
, ,
(, , ) (, )

2.

- : .. :
,
, .
,
. .

, .

, .
, ,
.
3.
-
-, 1940. 1960. , ,
,

4,5 .
, .
, 1940.
.: // , . 8, . 42, 633,2,
. 85-91.
3
.. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 455.
2
12 (117) 2014
3,5 ( ), 1960. 3,75

( ), . , ,
, . , ,
,
- ,

, .
,

. , ,

.

,
, , - ,
.
,
, , , , .
, , 20- - -
. ,

. ,
-
,
,
, , , .
,
-

1960-, 1970-
-
-
.

- .
, ,

, . ,
- 1.
1982-1983.
,
.
,
- , .

- .
, ,
- ,
.
1982 .
,
, , . . ,
1949 ., 1950-
.

1958-1961 .,
XX . , , ,
1966-1971 . ,
-. - ,
1980- .
1
12 (117) 2014
205
.
1983.
,
- - .

.

, ,
.

1.

?
-
?
,
. .
:

, .

.
, ,
, . ,
,
.
, ,

;
- 1985. 3.
1991 .
.
1
206
;

, ..
- .
:
2.
- , 3. 4.
- ,
.

,
,
,

.
,

,

, .
,
- .

.
98 .
. . ,
,

The Washington Post.
.
13 1983. .. ..

.
-
12 (117) 2014
.
,
,

(
, ) (

).
..
,
. .
: ,
, . ,
, ,
1.

, 11 1983 ,
:
, ,
( , , )
,
,

, . , , ,
, .
,
.

? ,
?
.. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 529.
1
,
, ? .
2.

, 1980- .
- , .
,
, ,

,
,
.

( )
.
1980- . - ,
, .

. 1980- .

.
1991 . 1991 . ..

.
. ,
.
, m-me
N, ,
, : 1991 .
M-me N
, ,
, ?
. , :
. . 531-535.
12 (117) 2014
207
, , 1.
.. , ,

, , , , ,
. - : 22 1991 .,
, , ,
, ,
m-me N ,
2.
, .
, , ,
, ,
.
? ,
, .

. ,
( ) .
,
.. ,
, ,
- -
.
, , , ,
,

, .

,
...
.. . 3. : . - .: , 2007. . 667.
2
.
1
208
12 (117) 2014
IN MEMORIAM
(31.12.1946-20.08.2014)
. .
-, , .
. ,
, , , , . , . , , , , .
, ,
, .
12 (117) 2014
209

( )
(-)
(-)
(-)
( )
( )
( , )
( )
(, )
(
, )
( )
( )
(-)
210
12 (117) 2014
I. , ,
A. . , ,
212
. ,

224
II.
A. . , ,
234
. ,

243
- .
, 22-25 2014 .
. 3,4%.

18-
1600
45
130
13 1 . ;
14 500 . 1 . ;
28 100 500 . ;
39
10. ;
36 .
12 (117) 2014
211
212
I. , ,
A. , , ,
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
1. , , , ?
1.
2.
9.
64
22
14
61
25
14
66
20
14
70
19
11
67
20
14
64
23
13
58
26
16
67
24
9
64
21
15
62
23
15
61
21
18
50
37
13
64
20
16
69
20
11
67
19
14
55
33
12
73
16
11
64
22
15
57
26
17
66
20
14
14
61
19
3
4
26
63
9
1
1
18
63
14
2
3
11
63
21
2
3
9
59
21
7
5
17
61
16
4
3
12
61
21
3
3
15
66
12
3
4
13
61
18
4
5
7
51
31
6
5
13
66
16
2
3
18
60
15
4
3
25
57
13
2
3
12
51
29
6
1
14
66
15
3
2
17
55
24
2
3
11
66
15
2
6
17
63
12
4
3
9
46
34
10
1
10
44
35
9
2
12
44
35
8
1
8
46
36
8
1
13
48
28
8
3
9
50
29
8
4
6
37
40
16
1
10
47
33
8
3
14
51
29
6
1
9
42
42
5
2
14
29
43
11
3
11
50
32
5
2
8
49
35
8
1
10
43
33
12
3
10
51
29
8
3
9
44
32
12
3
6
44
33
13
4
11
39
33
12
5
7
44
34
9
6
3
32
34
22
8
8
42
35
11
4
11
50
27
9
4
9
41
36
11
3
14
29
31
22
3
9
48
35
6
3
6
46
33
11
4
7
41
30
18
3
8
44
33
8
7
2. ?
1.
2. ,
3. ,
4. ,
9.
14
62
17
3
3
15
63
15
3
3
3. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
10
47
33
8
2
10
46
35
8
1
11
47
31
9
3
15
49
26
7
3
10
49
32
7
2
4. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
8
43
33
12
4
7
40
37
12
4
9
46
29
12
5
9
43
32
11
6
10
43
33
9
5
6
45
32
14
2
8
42
32
13
5
5. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
16
51
20
8
6
16
49
24
7
4
15
53
16
8
8
15
53
19
8
5
15
54
18
6
7
15
50
22
10
3
17
48
20
8
8
16
52
18
11
4
14
51
22
8
5
17
49
21
7
6
16
52
18
5
10
12
46
22
13
8
14
52
20
7
7
20
53
17
6
4
17
45
26
8
3
17
31
27
17
8
17
56
20
5
3
12
54
20
6
8
18
48
18
12
5
15
54
19
5
8
86
13
1
79
19
2
71
28
1
91
9
1
86
14
0
81
17
2
85
14
1
6. , ?
1.
2.
:
84
15
1
84
15
1
84
15
1
88
11
1
86
14
0
84
15
1
81
17
1
84
15
1
85
14
1
82
16
2
85
14
1
76
23
1
86
13
1
7. , ?
1.
2.
:
67
31
2
65
33
2
69
29
2
72
25
4
69
29
2
66
33
1
64
34
2
69
29
2
65
33
2
64
34
2
68
29
2
54
44
2
66
32
3
75
24
1
65
33
2
57
42
1
76
23
1
67
32
2
63
34
3
66
32
2
65
33
2
48
50
3
59
39
2
72
27
1
65
33
2
58
41
1
72
28
1
61
37
2
55
43
2
61
36
3
8. , ?
1.
2.
:
62
36
2
60
38
2
63
35
2
69
27
4
63
36
1
60
39
1
60
39
2
63
35
2
59
39
1
61
37
2
9. , ? ( , - )
1.
2.
:
66
33
2
64
35
2
68
31
2
73
25
2
68
32
1
63
35
2
63
35
2
66
33
1
63
36
2
66
33
1
71
28
1
55
42
3
65
33
1
71
28
1
71
27
2
63
37
0
69
31
1
61
38
1
63
35
2
70
27
3
53
45
2
33
63
3
48
50
3
57
42
1
53
45
2
42
54
4
61
39
1
44
54
2
46
51
3
46
51
3
10. , ?
1.
2.
:
49
49
2
47
51
2
51
47
2
60
38
2
49
50
2
45
53
2
48
49
3
48
50
2
46
52
2
51
47
3
11. , ? ( )
213
2.
1. ,
12. ,
4. ,
3.
15. ,
24. ,
71
40
66
40
74
39
63
34
74
35
67
44
74
43
68
37
80
40
66
44
66
37
77
46
72
43
66
33
64
31
69
37
71
31
80
43
70
44
64
41
30
31
30
25
26
32
35
32
33
23
32
29
33
29
16
23
40
30
23
32
28
26
26
24
34
26
25
25
23
26
26
23
22
36
16
27
24
26
20
25
27
22
36
25
35
24
26
20
28
31
25
27
29
26
29
25
22
26
24
23
32
17
24
19
33
38
22
14
28
25
23
22
25
23
25
28
28
18
55
33
32
13
25
51
24
20
27
21
29
39
36
23
35
26
24
18
21
26
18
23
214
18-24
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
23
18
16
14
14
12
21
17
13
14
13
11
24
19
19
15
15
12
12
15
21
17
11
8
22
16
16
14
9
12
23
18
12
12
23
14
28
21
18
15
14
12
23
20
23
18
15
14
23
19
16
12
13
9
22
20
14
14
14
12
22
11
10
13
15
12
29
11
16
8
9
10
22
19
16
13
12
11
19
16
18
18
19
15
29
30
8
22
21
9
23
23
18
20
17
15
25
18
15
18
17
13
26
22
24
15
15
15
24
18
15
15
12
10
18
13
12
7
12
9
11
8
6
12
8
6
10
8
7
15
8
7
12
8
7
11
7
6
8
9
6
11
8
5
10
7
8
13
6
7
11
10
6
6
10
2
12
7
7
10
7
5
15
16
16
20
9
8
14
12
6
5
4
9
6
10
6
14
3
4
6
6
5
5
6
3
7
6
7
11
5
5
4
8
4
6
5
5
6
4
6
5
8
5
7
4
6
8
2
6
3
8
3
0
0
3
7
6
5
7
5
4
6
15
18
10
11
11
11
7
6
5
8
6
3
1
5
3
5
1
3
2
2
2
3
3
2
1
1
3
3
2
2
2
3
5
4
2
1
6
4
2
1
1
3
3
1
1
2
1
1
2
3
2
3
3
3
1
0
2
3
2
2
2
2
3
1
1
4
3
2
4
1
0
6
1
4
3
8
4
2
2
1
1
3
4
1
1
0
3
11
5
2
0
3
12
8
5
0
0
4
2
1
0
4
2
1
2
2
1
1
2
1
2
4
3
1
1
3
4
10.
6. , ,
13. ,
11.
7.
16. ,
9. ,
5.
17.
8.
,
19.
18. ,
21. , ,
..
20.

14. , ( , )
23.
22.
25.
26.
12. , , ?
1.
22
27
18
21
25
23
18
23
20
20
24
20
27
39
24
22
25
18
22
2.
44
43
45
39
46
44
45
43
45
46
42
45
47
40
35
34
46
47
46
42
3.
25
23
26
31
21
23
28
24
25
26
26
39
24
22
22
38
25
15
25
27
4. ,
9.
13. , ?
1.
41
43
40
49
46
34
41
39
38
44
47
35
43
40
51
30
42
45
39
45
2. ,
,

35
38
32
26
33
46
30
37
40
28
29
34
31
42
29
35
39
29
33
35
3. ,
13
12
14
11
11
11
17
15
12
12
12
18
13
10
14
32
12
11
13
9.
12
14
14
11
13
10
16
13
13
14
15
15
13
14. , , , , ? ( )
1.
81
82
79
76
79
82
83
81
77
85
81
75
83
80
72
74
81
78
88
78
3. /
15
13
16
13
11
18
17
15
17
13
12
22
12
15
22
18
16
15
16
11
2.
10
10
12
10
13
11
10
13
10
24
12
4. ,
5. /
6.
7.
15
10
8.
12
12
11
15. , , ? ( )
1.
65
64
65
59
63
62
71
66
61
67
66
77
68
52
73
79
52
68
69
65
3. /
42
41
43
43
41
43
42
39
42
38
51
54
41
38
45
43
40
46
46
37
2.
25
23
26
18
23
27
27
26
23
26
24
33
23
23
33
34
24
22
29
19
4. ,
22
25
21
25
25
21
20
23
24
20
22
19
23
23
20
11
30
28
21
17
5. /
12
11
12
12
11
15
15
6.
7.
8.
215
216
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
6
48
36
4
5
9
53
33
1
4
9
47
36
2
5
5
48
39
5
2
6
45
39
6
4
8
45
38
5
4
8
46
42
2
3
7
53
33
5
3
6
49
35
4
6
3
38
48
8
2
6
49
37
3
6
12
49
33
4
2
4
48
45
4
0
2
36
51
10
1
10
50
33
5
1
7
53
36
1
3
4
45
42
4
6
10
48
33
2
6
2
13
59
21
3
3
4
12
64
14
1
4
2
15
58
22
1
2
1
13
56
25
3
2
2
16
56
23
2
2
2
12
55
26
3
2
2
13
58
22
2
3
2
15
59
21
2
1
2
19
59
17
1
2
1
7
55
33
3
1
2
13
56
24
2
3
3
18
61
16
2
1
2
20
57
16
4
2
0
10
49
35
6
1
4
15
58
19
2
1
1
12
63
20
1
3
1
11
61
23
2
2
3
19
54
20
1
3
16. ?
1.
2.
3.
4. ,
9.
7
48
37
4
4
8
47
39
3
2
17. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
2
14
58
22
2
2
2
16
56
23
1
2
18. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
3
12
52
27
5
2
4
14
50
26
5
2
2
10
53
27
6
2
5
13
54
23
2
4
3
13
52
26
5
2
2
11
52
27
7
1
3
11
50
28
5
2
2
12
55
22
8
1
5
10
51
28
5
2
2
17
48
26
4
3
2
10
52
31
4
2
1
3
42
41
11
2
2
11
51
29
5
3
4
17
56
18
4
1
5
15
61
17
3
0
0
13
66
15
6
0
5
15
58
15
4
3
3
7
54
32
3
1
0
11
47
30
9
2
4
13
44
34
4
2
3
13
59
23
2
0
3
10
61
22
2
2
4
14
65
15
3
1
4
10
60
23
2
1
5
17
55
19
1
3
1
14
58
23
2
3
3
0
37
53
6
2
3
10
63
20
1
2
4
23
64
8
1
1
6
25
63
6
0
1
1
14
63
15
7
1
4
16
60
16
1
2
2
11
63
22
2
0
3
14
57
23
2
2
5
12
60
20
1
2
19. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
3
13
60
20
2
2
3
17
59
18
2
1
4
10
61
21
2
2
4
20
55
16
2
4
4
14
63
16
1
2
20. , ?
1.
11
12
2.
39
37
41
41
38
40
39
41
38
40
36
27
40
42
41
32
41
39
39
40
3.
34
36
32
28
36
34
35
33
37
32
32
49
34
29
31
53
27
33
32
36
4.
9.
18
17
18
22
18
15
18
14
16
20
24
17
20
15
15
15
20
23
19
21. , ?
1.
10
12
2.
30
29
31
33
35
25
28
32
27
30
31
25
29
34
34
22
29
30
31
33
3.
41
42
40
33
37
45
43
40
48
34
38
50
40
37
40
59
32
46
40
40
4.
10
10
13
9.
17
17
16
18
16
16
17
12
16
19
21
14
19
14
14
19
18
18
17
22. , 12 (, ) , , ?
1.
29
30
27
22
28
32
29
28
29
28
28
40
28
26
25
32
29
36
20
30
2.
54
52
55
56
54
54
52
51
55
55
55
45
58
53
42
47
50
53
59
54
3.
10
11
10
11
11
11
13
10
13
25
15
15
14
9.
12
23. , , - ?
1. ,
33
33
34
22
32
36
36
35
35
30
30
38
34
30
24
42
30
36
33
32
2. ,
49
50
49
58
51
47
45
50
48
49
49
46
52
47
46
39
47
50
52
52
3. ,
11
11
11
10
12
11
10
11
14
10
13
13
17
13
10
4.
10
5.
9.
24. ?
217
1. ()
23
26
20
35
28
19
18
24
21
25
23
20
22
28
20
20
20
30
26
20
2. () , ,
/
19
20
18
18
15
21
21
20
21
14
18
16
20
17
21
15
17
17
21
21
3. () ,

45
40
48
34
44
48
48
43
46
45
45
45
43
47
49
48
51
40
41
46
4. ,

10
11
10
11
10
10
10
15
11
15
10
10
9.
218
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
25. , ;
, ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
70
16
8
6
69
16
9
6
71
16
8
5
78
10
8
5
70
12
9
9
66
20
8
6
70
19
8
3
70
17
8
5
73
12
8
6
68
19
9
5
68
19
8
6
56
24
12
8
72
15
6
7
75
15
7
3
62
16
18
4
55
27
14
3
77
16
4
3
74
15
7
4
63
15
13
9
73
15
6
7
26. ; ,
?
1.
2.
3.
9.
72
16
8
4
72
17
7
4
72
15
8
5
77
12
7
5
71
15
9
5
74
18
6
3
70
17
9
5
74
15
7
4
73
14
9
4
69
17
8
6
70
19
7
4
59
22
15
5
74
15
6
5
75
16
6
3
64
15
19
2
58
29
13
1
78
14
4
4
74
14
7
5
68
14
12
6
73
17
6
4
35
43
19
3
0
1
34
48
14
3
0
2
34
49
13
2
0
2
32
45
19
3
0
1
38
44
15
1
0
2
35
44
16
3
0
3
25
48
18
5
0
3
35
46
16
1
0
2
36
46
15
3
0
0
43
40
12
5
0
1
32
46
17
6
0
0
37
47
12
2
0
2
24
53
18
2
0
3
40
42
15
2
0
1
36
42
18
2
0
1
27. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
35
46
16
2
0
2
32
48
17
2
0
2
37
44
15
3
0
1
35
48
14
2
0
2
35
45
17
2
0
2
28. , , ? ( )
5. : , ,
2. , ,
4. ,
3. :
7. :
45
37
29
44
39
28
47
35
30
42
31
26
47
34
23
44
38
33
47
40
33
49
32
28
43
39
28
46
37
33
44
39
29
52
51
32
42
34
29
49
36
27
39
32
31
58
38
32
43
31
30
49
33
27
44
43
30
42
38
29
24
21
21
21
27
22
21
21
24
24
27
19
24
22
25
27
26
18
21
19
24
20
28
20
23
21
25
23
25
22
29
19
25
24
23
28
21
17
26
20
9. : , ,
6.
11.
1. ,
8.
10. : ,
12.
13
12
11
10
10
1
13
11
11
11
10
11
1
14
14
13
11
10
9
1
13
21
13
11
9
14
0
23
11
11
13
13
8
1
11
12
12
11
9
10
1
11
10
13
10
10
9
1
12
15
12
11
9
11
1
10
11
14
11
8
8
0
13
14
10
12
14
10
1
14
10
10
12
10
10
0
16
8
14
6
12
14
1
10
11
10
13
10
8
0
17
17
13
11
11
11
1
8
11
15
17
5
7
1
13
18
18
11
20
13
4
9
17
14
13
5
11
0
11
12
12
11
7
10
0
15
11
6
10
14
7
1
14
8
14
12
10
10
0
13
29. , , ? ( )
5. : , ,
2. , ,
4. ,
7. :
3. :
11.
9. : , ,
6.
1. ,
8.
10. : ,
12.
39
38
39
34
36
40
43
40
36
39
39
50
34
42
36
51
35
47
40
30
30
24
31
23
29
25
23
23
29
23
33
28
32
24
29
25
33
23
27
23
29
27
44
33
28
23
28
23
21
22
35
24
21
26
29
23
40
25
28
23
22
22
22
22
26
23
19
28
23
16
19
19
21
26
24
20
23
32
16
22
19
14
19
13
18
15
19
14
16
15
20
13
20
14
18
12
20
14
14
15
21
17
22
12
17
16
21
13
15
16
13
12
22
17
19
11
16
13
20
16
13
10
12
9
13
11
19
12
12
8
12
10
12
11
15
11
13
10
14
9
8
10
7
12
10
8
19
13
18
10
15
15
17
12
17
12
6
5
12
10
9
9
1
15
10
9
0
16
9
9
1
14
8
13
0
22
9
8
0
16
8
9
0
13
10
7
1
12
10
8
1
12
6
8
1
14
12
11
1
19
8
8
0
18
10
8
0
9
8
7
0
18
10
11
1
12
9
14
2
15
14
10
2
10
5
11
0
12
7
10
1
14
14
4
0
15
7
10
0
20
16
42
35
3
0
5
18
43
20
15
0
4
17
50
27
4
0
3
30. , ( , ..)?
1.
2.
3. ,
4.
5.
9.
15
45
30
7
1
3
15
47
28
8
1
2
15
43
31
7
2
3
17
46
29
5
0
3
13
42
35
8
0
2
17
43
29
9
1
1
14
48
26
6
3
5
15
43
28
11
2
2
17
44
28
7
1
2
18
41
33
5
0
3
8
52
31
5
0
4
24
42
26
6
1
1
15
48
28
6
0
3
11
42
33
9
2
3
12
39
31
16
0
2
10
46
28
9
7
0
10
43
39
6
2
1
219
220
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
31. , ?
1.
2.
26
23
28
25
23
27
27
27
25
18
32
21
27
27
23
22
21
17
32
31
3. ,
41
43
40
46
45
37
40
37
39
56
37
37
43
39
47
36
52
44
34
39
4.
19
23
17
18
21
21
18
22
20
12
21
31
17
19
18
26
17
29
16
16
5.
15
10
9.
32. ?
1.
/
2. , /
3. ,
4.
9.
40
43
38
25
38
42
48
45
42
38
33
45
38
42
40
44
46
41
47
25
30
28
32
46
29
30
25
32
29
28
32
30
27
35
30
24
33
26
29
35
23
4
20
7
25
2
21
7
27
3
22
6
20
4
19
2
22
5
24
8
30
3
24
1
25
7
18
2
27
0
19
7
17
3
25
7
18
4
32
4
2
10
38
46
4
1
19
36
38
5
4
15
38
38
5
4
6
36
48
7
1
14
28
51
6
2
9
35
53
2
2
13
32
47
8
5
19
38
35
4
6
18
51
20
5
0
19
33
46
3
3
17
35
38
6
5
13
37
42
4
0
15
39
39
7
4
12
31
48
5
33. , ?
1. ,
2. ,
3. ,
4. ,
9.
3
15
35
42
5
2
18
35
41
4
3
12
35
44
7
7
13
37
39
4
1
16
34
43
7
3
19
32
40
6
34. , / , ?
1.
17
18
15
20
15
18
15
18
18
15
13
10
15
18
31
28
17
24
13
11
2.
78
76
79
72
81
78
77
77
76
78
82
81
79
77
63
63
80
68
81
84
9. ,
10
35. , ?
1. ,
10
10
10
12
11
10
2. ,
86
87
85
88
86
82
88
89
82
87
86
80
88
86
84
82
91
82
83
88
9.
10
36. , , / (, , ) ?
1.
12
12
11
11
10
12
13
15
13
11
13
32
39
10
18
2.
83
81
84
81
85
83
81
80
81
85
87
81
85
84
62
53
86
75
88
90
9. ,
37. , ?
1. ,
11
11
13
10
2. ,
87
88
86
87
87
86
88
91
85
87
85
80
88
89
81
81
90
83
87
89
9.
10
38. , ? ( )
3.
60
59
61
61
63
58
59
65
60
57
57
68
58
59
66
61
61
65
57
59
1.
56
57
54
54
53
53
61
53
61
49
58
62
55
53
65
63
54
58
55
53
4.
49
48
49
50
49
47
49
46
50
51
47
59
47
47
46
57
46
45
46
53
6.
39
39
40
44
38
40
38
41
41
35
39
35
40
39
46
42
39
43
34
42
8. ,
38
37
39
39
37
35
40
44
41
34
29
37
38
38
37
41
42
50
32
31
2.
36
34
37
38
36
35
35
33
42
32
35
45
34
35
42
37
37
37
34
35
5.
27
29
26
26
26
27
30
27
24
30
30
32
26
27
33
49
24
25
25
27
10.
24
25
23
27
24
25
22
26
21
26
22
25
22
25
36
48
23
25
19
20
13.
17
15
18
14
15
16
20
16
19
14
17
20
15
16
20
28
13
18
18
13
12.
16
15
16
18
17
15
15
16
18
14
13
12
15
18
19
32
20
16
11
12
9.
11
11
12
11
12
13
12
10
13
11
12
13
18
23
14
12
7.
10
10
13
12
11. ,
10
14
11
14.
15.
221
222
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
39. - , , , , , ? ( )
9. ,
5. ,
6. ,

1. , ,
17.
15.
16.
19. ,
3. , ,
7.
18. ,
2. , ,
8. , ,
11. , ,
12. , ,
10. , ,
14. ,
33
19
31
17
35
21
27
15
32
15
35
23
35
21
31
19
38
21
30
20
31
16
30
21
35
17
31
20
31
24
43
23
32
24
45
21
28
17
27
15
18
18
18
18
17
18
18
18
17
18
16
23
15
16
12
22
19
19
17
20
19
17
18
16
21
21
18
17
14
17
16
17
19
22
17
23
17
18
18
19
16
14
18
24
22
19
26
17
19
18
12
21
16
22
16
16
17
17
18
21
16
15
17
16
15
14
15
9
15
16
18
17
16
14
17
15
15
14
19
15
14
15
10
13
17
17
16
13
22
13
22
12
16
14
16
17
16
12
15
18
14
13
11
14
12
12
13
14
11
15
14
13
17
14
11
10
15
12
13
11
11
16
16
11
11
16
11
13
9
16
16
9
8
8
16
8
13
11
11
18
14
12
13
17
15
19
15
16
13
17
13
12
16
15
13
7
7
15
13
10
11
10
9
10
9
8
12
10
9
10
14
11
10
8
9
10
11
9
13
8
8
11
12
9
11
9
9
10
9
8
13
8
9
15
12
7
10
8
7
11
12
11
16
10
15
19
8
14
9
11
9
13
9
11
11
7
8
10
12
6
9
8
7
7
10
8
9
4
6
8
12
9
8
7
9
8
8
8
9
6
8
7
12
9
8
6
8
9
12
12
14
10
9
10
10
12
7
2
7
6
13
10
10
16
4. , ,
13. , ,

20.
14
4
6
4
6
4
6
4
10
5
6
3
5
3
6
7
4
3
7
2
6
1
9
1
5
3
7
5
5
8
9
10
1
5
6
4
5
1
9
2
7
25
48
27
17
51
32
20
52
28
33
31
35
22
58
20
19
44
37
14
56
30
22
50
28
20
50
30
40. , ?
1.
2.
9.
20
50
30
20
55
26
20
47
34
24
38
38
21
51
28
16
53
30
19
53
28
22
51
28
21
50
30
17
53
30
17
48
35
41. , , , ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
9
13
35
43
11
11
38
40
8
15
32
45
12
10
32
46
7
14
45
34
13
13
30
44
7
15
32
47
9
12
38
40
10
18
29
44
9
8
42
41
9
15
31
46
11
12
32
45
9
15
34
41
10
11
36
44
3
7
44
46
8
20
44
28
11
10
31
49
7
9
39
45
8
16
32
44
10
15
37
38
42. , - , , ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
73
4
15
8
73
4
18
6
73
4
13
10
63
3
24
10
74
1
16
9
74
6
13
7
76
5
13
7
72
5
15
8
79
2
12
7
67
3
20
10
73
5
16
7
83
0
15
2
71
4
17
8
74
4
12
9
68
7
19
6
71
11
15
4
70
2
17
11
77
2
11
10
78
4
11
8
69
4
22
5
43. , , ? ( )
223
3. ,
10.
8. , /
9.
1. ,
5. , / -
6. , / -
7. , / -

2. , ,

4. , / -
11.
12.
41
34
30
30
29
42
35
30
34
32
41
34
30
26
27
67
64
61
60
42
57
45
42
47
41
41
33
25
22
30
15
13
8
7
11
59
44
41
39
41
43
33
29
27
29
30
34
28
30
23
22
21
15
18
17
18
13
12
9
13
36
33
25
27
24
54
42
43
41
39
72
51
43
36
48
59
39
39
39
62
50
34
42
33
31
49
40
33
37
34
33
33
21
25
25
29
30
21
22
17
25
30
22
54
37
20
35
25
23
13
20
38
40
45
34
30
19
13
23
25
22
56
35
16
33
21
23
13
19
35
38
39
29
29
19
13
19
21
17
34
27
17
29
19
15
13
30
38
42
24
21
16
18
20
16
32
25
19
27
17
17
15
27
29
41
23
19
14
14
1
37
15
0
33
14
1
40
33
1
4
18
1
12
13
1
36
4
0
76
22
1
19
15
0
36
12
0
44
4
0
59
4
1
68
10
1
41
23
0
22
24
0
10
27
0
22
22
1
32
17
0
32
10
2
38
5
0
50
1600
510
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
, ..
224
. ,
305
1348
236
1. , , , ?
1.
2.
9.
64
22
14
68
23
10
67
22
11
58
23
20
82
8
11
49
29
23
46
42
12
44
45
11
42
43
15
61
22
17
72
13
15
19
70
11
14
62
17
3
3
18
61
16
3
2
17
63
15
2
2
9
60
20
5
5
18
66
10
3
3
8
57
27
4
4
13
49
26
7
6
13
61
24
2
0
10
55
28
6
1
15
66
15
2
3
15
65
14
3
3
8
43
35
6
7
10
47
33
8
2
11
51
29
7
2
12
48
31
7
2
8
44
35
10
3
15
58
25
1
1
9
35
49
8
0
8
35
44
10
2
6
41
43
7
3
5
31
35
26
3
9
44
34
9
4
12
52
31
3
2
4
15
43
37
1
9
46
32
11
3
7
39
34
13
7
12
55
28
2
3
6
34
41
17
3
7
26
40
24
4
5
40
33
19
4
5
25
36
30
4
5
42
34
11
7
9
48
32
6
5
2
17
37
43
2
16
52
20
8
4
15
50
19
8
8
20
63
13
1
4
17
46
24
5
9
22
32
25
16
5
4
39
36
18
3
9
37
26
22
6
13
49
22
9
8
18
56
17
3
6
4
21
34
39
3
2. ?
1.
2. ,
3. ,
4. ,
9.
3. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
4. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
8
43
33
12
4
9
47
30
12
2
5. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
16
51
20
8
6
17
50
21
9
4
6. , ?
1.
2.
:
84
15
1
85
14
1
86
14
1
82
17
2
98
2
0
83
17
0
65
30
6
66
31
3
63
37
0
82
16
2
100
0
0
0
100
0
7. , ?
1.
2.
:
67
31
2
68
31
2
69
29
2
63
35
2
87
11
2
52
45
3
51
47
2
47
51
3
39
60
1
63
35
2
78
20
2
7
93
0
44
56
0
47
51
2
47
50
3
38
61
1
53
44
2
72
27
1
7
93
0
8. , ?
1.
2.
:
62
36
2
65
33
2
63
35
2
59
39
2
83
15
2
9. , ? ( , - )
1.
2.
:
66
33
2
66
32
2
66
33
2
66
33
2
82
17
1
57
43
0
55
41
3
58
39
3
43
55
2
59
39
2
74
25
1
21
79
0
34
64
2
39
57
4
37
58
5
23
76
1
44
53
3
57
41
2
7
93
0
10. , ?
1.
2.
:
49
49
2
51
48
2
49
49
2
49
48
3
67
32
2
11. , ? ( )
225
2.
1. ,
12. ,
4. ,
3.
15. ,
24. ,
10.
6. , ,
13. ,
11.
7.
16. ,
71
40
66
42
69
38
73
42
72
32
68
63
67
51
57
29
73
45
73
38
71
38
71
53
30
25
27
36
30
42
32
24
26
28
32
23
28
26
26
24
23
18
16
14
14
12
26
28
30
29
20
20
17
19
14
17
28
27
26
26
20
17
18
16
13
13
28
24
25
21
27
19
14
12
16
9
22
25
24
21
25
18
17
16
19
13
42
22
32
13
30
21
12
6
12
6
24
6
25
30
19
22
12
22
24
17
26
16
39
16
28
28
9
11
15
11
33
38
23
29
20
17
16
13
3
13
33
26
25
28
16
15
16
12
12
9
26
25
26
24
24
17
16
15
15
12
34
33
27
23
18
23
14
8
6
14
226
, ..
1600
510
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
11
8
6
6
6
5
4
3
11
9
5
6
7
6
4
5
12
9
6
7
7
5
4
4
10
6
7
5
3
5
5
3
11
8
8
7
5
7
5
4
10
5
5
5
7
0
3
0
11
13
14
12
5
12
8
0
13
6
9
2
8
7
0
13
10
8
2
6
7
1
1
2
13
5
3
4
4
5
3
2
10
7
6
6
5
5
4
4
15
12
8
9
6
3
5
2
3
2
2
2
3
5
2
1
0
3
4
2
1
1
3
1
3
2
3
3
2
2
2
1
2
2
0
0
2
3
5
2
1
4
0
10
0
2
2
10
4
2
2
4
5
2
3
1
0
4
3
3
1
2
2
6
1
2
1
5
9. ,
5.
17.
8. ,
19.
18. ,
21. , , ..
20.
14. , ( ,
)
23.
22.
25.
26.
12. , , ?
1.
2.
3.
4. ,
9.
22
44
25
3
7
31
42
19
3
5
25
44
22
3
5
15
45
29
2
9
31
47
15
2
6
19
34
36
1
10
28
35
37
0
0
23
30
33
5
9
7
48
37
4
4
13
46
27
4
11
23
46
22
2
7
11
37
42
7
3
13. , ?
1.
2. ,
,
3. ,
9.
41
47
42
40
62
28
38
18
22
25
47
35
31
35
33
24
42
45
68
36
40
34
39
13
12
13
9
12
11
14
13
7
7
12
18
13
5
8
7
33
9
12
23
9
10
37
17
14. , , , , ?
1.
2.
3. /
4. ,
5. /
6.
7.
8.
81
10
15
5
4
2
4
7
79
15
12
7
5
3
3
9
80
14
11
6
4
2
4
7
82
16
8
4
3
1
3
7
92
11
15
4
3
1
1
4
67
9
12
11
3
3
3
13
80
15
27
6
0
1
7
2
45
5
5
2
9
0
24
16
64
6
10
6
7
2
7
12
88
9
14
3
2
2
2
7
88
11
15
5
3
2
1
5
44
4
7
7
10
3
21
14
15. , , ?
1.
2.
3. /
4. ,
5. /
6.
7.
8.
65
25
42
22
9
3
2
5
60
49
32
26
13
3
3
2
61
41
24
24
11
3
2
5
71
43
26
20
7
3
2
5
64
26
44
26
11
2
1
4
74
22
30
20
3
4
1
2
79
23
37
19
7
3
2
5
57
32
44
28
6
3
0
0
54
21
46
16
10
1
5
7
66
25
42
20
11
5
2
11
62
25
44
23
11
3
1
6
76
22
33
19
4
0
5
2
7
48
37
4
4
9
49
37
3
3
8
50
36
3
4
6
44
40
6
3
11
55
31
3
1
4
48
39
4
6
6
25
59
9
0
6
44
42
2
7
2
39
47
7
5
6
49
34
3
9
8
53
34
2
3
3
18
53
16
10
2
14
58
22
2
2
2
17
55
20
3
2
2
14
59
21
2
2
2
14
56
24
2
2
3
21
62
13
0
2
0
9
59
28
3
1
1
5
56
32
6
0
3
9
58
23
4
3
1
6
47
39
4
4
2
12
59
22
2
3
3
16
62
17
1
2
0
5
36
49
8
3
4
12
53
25
4
2
2
11
50
28
7
2
5
15
58
17
3
2
1
8
44
38
8
1
1
11
47
33
8
0
5
8
54
25
6
3
0
7
41
42
7
3
2
11
51
28
6
1
3
13
55
22
4
2
0
4
32
52
10
2
16. ?
1.
2.
3.
4. ,
9.
17. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
18. , ?
227
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
3
12
52
27
5
2
3
14
55
23
3
2
228
, ..
1600
510
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
5
18
60
13
1
2
4
16
63
15
1
2
3
9
56
29
2
2
3
17
67
12
1
1
3
10
51
34
3
0
3
11
56
28
2
0
9
16
57
11
3
4
2
8
53
32
3
3
6
11
60
20
2
2
3
15
63
16
1
2
4
7
43
40
5
1
9
37
34
4
17
8
40
32
3
17
3
37
37
4
19
10
49
24
1
17
2
30
48
4
16
3
24
51
8
14
5
42
37
4
11
2
28
39
7
25
5
35
39
5
18
7
42
31
2
18
1
23
48
14
14
7
34
41
5
14
7
32
40
7
15
4
26
42
9
19
9
40
33
2
15
3
18
51
12
17
3
20
50
8
18
8
24
51
7
11
0
21
42
17
20
5
24
45
9
17
6
32
41
4
17
2
19
42
28
10
19. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
3
13
60
20
2
2
20. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
6
39
34
4
18
21. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
6
30
41
7
17
22. , 12 (, ) , , ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
29
54
10
8
29
53
11
7
28
54
11
7
29
53
10
9
20
62
11
8
32
51
9
8
35
42
11
12
31
52
16
2
45
39
10
5
30
54
8
8
24
57
11
8
55
32
9
5
37
39
8
11
4
2
47
39
7
4
0
3
35
48
12
2
1
3
28
54
11
4
0
3
59
20
10
5
1
3
23. , , - ?
1. ,
2. ,
3. ,
4.
5.
9.
33
49
11
4
0
3
33
52
10
3
0
2
32
51
10
4
1
2
35
46
12
4
0
3
23
60
11
4
0
2
36
42
14
5
0
4
53
31
13
4
0
0
24. ?
1. ()
2. () , , /
3. () ,
4. ,
9.
23
19
45
27
20
42
27
18
43
16
20
49
29
19
45
19
23
45
27
21
33
18
21
45
18
14
44
18
20
47
25
20
43
8
12
56
10
4
9
2
9
4
11
4
5
2
11
2
14
5
11
6
18
6
10
6
8
3
19
5
25. , ;
, ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
70
16
8
6
72
16
8
4
72
14
8
6
67
19
8
5
90
5
2
3
60
20
15
6
56
26
13
5
50
42
5
3
46
32
14
8
60
17
13
10
81
9
6
4
11
59
15
16
26. ; ,
?
1.
2.
3.
9.
72
16
8
4
72
18
7
3
73
16
7
5
71
17
9
3
90
7
2
1
67
14
13
6
60
17
10
13
49
42
4
5
44
34
16
6
66
15
12
7
83
8
6
3
12
59
16
13
36
45
16
2
0
1
34
47
16
2
0
1
36
43
16
4
0
2
44
43
12
1
0
1
24
48
24
2
0
2
21
49
16
8
0
5
31
42
21
6
0
0
29
40
25
3
1
2
31
54
12
1
0
2
36
48
14
1
0
1
26
34
25
9
0
6
45
35
28
26
23
14
13
11
10
10
1
13
46
39
32
22
19
10
11
12
11
9
1
13
47
30
27
22
30
20
15
5
12
0
12
11
49
44
32
23
14
5
10
8
7
0
10
16
54
45
40
34
11
3
6
14
8
0
5
10
38
41
25
10
10
5
6
13
6
1
8
13
42
52
28
24
11
5
7
21
5
2
10
12
43
32
31
32
21
11
13
10
11
1
17
19
44
32
28
24
24
15
14
6
11
0
13
14
51
61
36
28
6
1
1
34
0
2
3
12
27. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
9.
35
46
16
2
0
2
28. , , ? ( )
229
5. : , ,
2. , ,
4. ,
3. :
7. :
9. : , ,
6.
1. ,
8.
10. : ,
11.
12.
45
37
29
24
21
13
12
10
10
1
11
13
52
38
29
25
25
16
14
8
11
10
1
11
230
, ..
510
1600
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
29. , , ? ( )
5. : , ,
39
46
38
40
34
47
47
46
39
38
37
48
2. , ,
30
29
29
32
20
37
37
38
47
29
25
59
4. ,
24
26
23
26
23
24
31
20
25
26
24
29
7. :
22
27
25
18
31
12
14
18
11
20
25
3. :
19
19
19
18
15
20
24
13
22
23
18
25
11.
14
16
14
11
16
12
10
21
16
9. : , ,
13
10
10
20
11
10
15
6.
10
12
10
13
12
1. ,
10
11
11
10
19
11
32
8.
12
10
10
10. : ,
12
13
17
12.
15
12
15
15
13
19
13
13
19
16
11
30. , ( , ..)?
1.
2.
3. ,
4.
5.
9.
15
45
30
7
1
3
10
45
34
9
0
3
15
44
30
9
0
3
15
47
29
5
2
3
16
48
28
5
1
3
9
50
28
8
4
1
21
32
34
13
0
0
17
50
23
4
3
4
14
37
32
10
2
5
13
44
32
9
0
2
14
47
30
6
1
3
18
31
30
15
4
1
8
11
52
21
4
3
0
20
44
33
0
3
12
20
32
32
3
2
1
10
38
28
18
6
1
22
47
16
10
3
4
28
43
18
3
4
4
9
32
28
25
3
31. , ?
1.
2.
3. ,
4.
5.
9.
4
26
41
19
6
4
4
27
44
19
4
3
5
23
43
20
6
3
2
29
39
18
6
5
5
38
38
14
2
4
32. ?
1. /

15
2. , /
40
45
38
44
37
52
52
31
44
42
40
42
3. ,

30
32
34
24
32
30
34
48
27
21
30
35
4.
23
16
22
24
26
14
13
23
28
24
17
9.
33. , ?
1.
2. ,
15
21
17
10
13
18
15
21
19
15
15
3. ,
35
33
34
37
42
30
28
51
22
30
36
29
4. ,
42
38
39
48
35
51
48
24
70
37
43
44
9.
10
14
13
34. , / ,
?
1.
17
19
18
15
13
10
30
25
23
15
14
29
2.
78
76
77
78
83
83
62
69
71
79
80
65
9. ,
35. , ?
1. ,
10
20
20
11
17
2. ,
86
87
86
85
92
80
73
69
85
86
88
75
9.
10
11
36. , , / (, , ) ?
1.
12
15
12
10
16
28
11
11
10
21
2.
83
80
84
80
88
86
76
72
76
83
85
67
9. ,
13
12
37. , ?
1. ,
18
13
20
2. ,
87
85
89
84
91
85
75
75
87
89
89
72
9.
13
231
232
, ..
510
1600
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
58
59
50
42
37
35
34
25
18
16
12
10
8
1
1
61
60
51
44
36
44
27
25
16
18
12
10
8
1
0
69
61
38
32
40
25
27
14
23
12
12
7
5
0
4
63
66
48
37
32
44
25
22
22
12
11
5
5
1
2
49
46
42
26
29
28
35
25
13
18
15
6
6
0
0
61
44
50
40
39
27
31
22
9
14
11
8
9
0
2
58
54
50
37
45
31
25
28
19
17
11
9
6
0
2
63
58
50
41
38
37
26
24
16
17
11
9
8
0
1
44
42
41
31
37
28
37
24
17
13
12
6
4
1
4
38. , ? ( )
3.
1.
4.
6.
8. ,
2.
5.
10.
13.
12.
9.
7.
11. ,
14.
15.
60
56
49
39
38
36
27
24
17
16
11
8
7
1
1
62
55
47
42
41
36
27
28
17
17
14
9
7
0
2
61
53
48
38
39
36
23
23
16
16
11
7
7
0
1
39. - , , , , , ? ( )
9. ,
5. ,
6. ,
1. , ,
17.
15.
16.
19. ,
3. , ,
7.
18. ,
2. , ,
8. , ,
33
19
18
18
18
16
15
14
13
11
11
10
9
34
20
21
15
18
18
14
16
16
14
11
9
12
33
19
19
15
18
17
15
15
15
13
11
10
9
34
20
17
22
18
15
14
12
10
10
12
9
8
31
19
14
15
18
14
14
20
14
13
9
9
8
35
20
16
15
25
18
15
6
9
6
13
13
5
37
18
12
15
14
24
15
15
12
7
14
6
16
44
15
29
33
16
23
13
4
13
21
18
6
14
36
18
27
23
14
12
15
10
16
11
9
11
11
29
20
20
16
20
21
18
10
11
9
14
10
6
32
19
17
16
18
16
15
16
13
11
11
10
8
39
22
23
26
15
19
15
4
16
12
14
10
16
11. , ,
12. , ,
10. , ,
14. ,
4. , ,
13. , ,
20.
9
8
7
7
5
9
11
8
10
7
8
8
7
8
6
9
6
8
5
4
6
8
4
5
5
10
7
14
4
4
5
3
8
5
8
19
1
5
18
17
13
14
7
7
4
8
6
10
9
4
8
7
7
6
5
13
9
10
8
9
4
6
6
7
5
6
2
6
2
6
5
5
6
2
7
0
5
7
3
11
3
6
7
5
25
40
35
30
41
30
30
49
21
14
47
39
17
51
32
30
51
19
40. , ?
1.
2.
9.
20
50
30
19
56
25
21
50
30
17
52
31
19
50
31
4
73
23
41. , , , ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
9
13
35
43
8
14
41
36
10
11
37
41
7
16
32
44
9
14
38
40
4
14
28
53
12
9
30
49
10
16
23
51
14
14
42
31
5
12
32
51
9
12
35
44
9
18
39
34
42. , - , , ?
1.
2.
3.
9.
73
4
15
8
70
5
17
9
73
4
16
8
74
3
15
8
80
3
12
6
86
1
10
4
64
5
23
8
58
14
18
10
58
1
31
9
73
5
11
11
79
3
11
7
40
8
41
12
70
54
54
51
91
52
49
41
56
34
1
0
65
55
47
47
46
40
37
30
28
23
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
100
43
36
33
32
32
26
25
19
17
15
0
36
22
16
13
14
12
6
6
10
7
5
1
63
44
33
30
31
34
27
20
14
20
15
0
34
42
28
33
27
38
30
30
26
25
18
1
29
44
39
29
32
32
25
24
17
20
15
0
35
45
38
29
30
24
31
25
21
20
15
1
31
42
34
31
30
29
26
24
19
17
14
0
36
35
34
22
25
29
21
18
16
20
17
0
42
43. , , ? ( )
233
3. ,
10.
8. , /
9.
1. ,
5. , / -
6. , / -
7. , / -
2. , ,
4. , / -
11.
12.
41
34
30
30
29
25
23
19
18
14
1
37
234
II.
A. , , ,
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
U1. , ? ( )
3.
6.
8.
7.
5.
1.
2.
9.
4.
10.
99.
31
31
13
7
3
2
2
1
0
8
1
28
31
14
6
3
3
3
2
0
9
2
33
31
12
9
2
2
1
1
1
8
1
31
26
12
6
4
1
2
1
0
14
2
29
32
14
7
3
1
2
1
1
9
2
29
31
15
6
2
4
2
2
0
8
2
33
32
11
9
3
3
2
1
1
5
1
33
32
13
7
2
3
1
1
1
7
2
29
32
12
9
3
3
3
2
0
6
2
25
32
13
6
1
1
2
1
0
17
2
36
26
15
8
5
3
1
2
1
5
1
41
26
14
8
3
0
0
1
0
5
2
26
35
14
6
3
2
2
1
0
11
2
33
27
12
8
3
5
3
1
1
6
1
36
27
8
17
0
2
1
4
0
7
0
21
29
16
14
5
1
1
4
1
7
1
31
36
11
9
3
3
1
0
1
5
1
38
31
11
4
1
3
2
1
1
7
4
29
31
10
9
2
3
1
2
0
14
1
30
27
19
5
3
3
3
2
0
8
1
15
49
28
7
1
15
48
31
5
1
12
36
38
13
2
11
45
36
7
1
17
49
30
3
1
18
56
20
5
1
16
50
28
5
1
14
52
29
5
0
14
42
31
11
2
15
47
33
5
1
18
54
24
3
0
13
46
32
8
1
16
51
28
4
1
11
42
36
10
2
9
56
34
2
0
15
53
25
5
2
14
52
28
5
1
17
45
30
7
1
14
43
34
9
1
U2. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5. ()
15
49
30
6
1
U3. , ? ( %% , )
1.
2.
3.
4. ,
, ,
9.
6
34
48
7
39
46
6
30
50
6
25
51
6
31
51
7
39
43
6
36
48
6
38
46
7
34
49
6
33
48
7
29
48
8
24
49
5
32
51
7
41
43
8
31
48
5
45
40
4
41
44
4
29
52
8
31
49
9
28
50
9
4
6
3
11
4
17
1
8
4
8
3
7
4
7
3
7
4
12
2
10
7
13
6
9
4
7
3
12
1
7
3
8
3
10
5
8
5
11
2
U4. ? ( )
1.
93
92
94
87
91
96
95
92
93
92
94
96
93
93
85
93
93
94
93
92
5. , ,
25
22
28
26
26
25
24
27
23
25
27
19
27
25
27
37
24
31
20
24
6. - (, , )
17
20
15
28
21
18
26
16
13
16
21
31
37
19
22
13
7.
12
13
10
18
17
12
16
12
12
11
12
12
19
12
2.
11
12
10
15
11
11
11
12
21
24
10
11
3.
11
11
18
19
4.
8.
9.
U5. , , , ?
1. ,
17
19
15
16
17
17
16
18
17
14
16
20
14
20
10
22
16
20
13
16
2. ,
12
13
11
14
10
14
10
13
17
11
13
23
17
14
14
3. ,

54
54
53
46
55
53
56
51
58
49
57
58
55
52
48
52
52
53
56
54
9.
18
14
22
24
17
16
18
18
16
21
18
18
20
14
19
18
20
21
16
1. , ,
15
12
18
11
20
15
12
18
13
12
16
17
12
17
32
24
13
11
12
19
2. (, )
18
19
18
15
17
17
22
23
19
20
17
19
20
14
32
18
16
18
16
3.
..
12
11
13
13
11
16
11
10
10
15
17
12
12
14
13
13
15
4. ,

34
40
29
32
32
35
35
32
33
32
40
30
36
32
30
25
35
33
39
31
5.
6. ,
13
11
14
15
17
11
11
17
15
14
12
14
13
11
11
21
11
11
9.
14
10
10
U6. ?
235
236
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
U7. ? ( )
4.
2.
1.
3.
5.
8. ,
6. ,
7. ,
9.
10.
40
37
30
16
3
3
2
1
9
2
40
38
32
16
4
2
2
0
8
3
39
36
28
16
3
4
1
1
10
2
37
37
26
11
2
2
4
1
13
4
39
34
30
16
3
3
1
0
11
3
40
34
30
16
4
4
1
1
10
2
41
41
32
18
4
4
2
0
6
1
40
39
27
17
2
4
2
1
8
3
42
37
32
16
4
3
1
0
9
2
37
33
29
14
4
3
4
1
12
2
38
37
34
17
3
3
1
0
10
2
38
40
39
22
2
3
0
0
14
2
39
36
29
14
2
4
3
0
10
3
43
39
29
17
5
3
1
1
6
1
28
32
27
13
7
5
0
1
13
5
39
30
27
25
8
6
1
2
6
3
41
38
24
16
4
2
0
0
13
3
43
39
33
15
3
2
1
0
8
2
39
40
32
14
1
4
3
0
9
3
36
34
34
16
3
4
3
1
8
1
U8. , ?
1.
2. ,
3. ,

4.
9.
10
11
11
16
11
15
13
16
12
16
14
16
13
15
16
18
14
16
16
17
15
13
16
15
23
38
15
22
39
18
25
36
14
18
41
21
24
36
15
23
39
14
25
37
14
27
38
12
26
39
13
18
38
21
20
35
19
23
48
10
19
38
19
27
35
12
48
27
10
23
39
5
30
34
14
23
45
11
23
37
19
17
37
19
U9. , ?
1. ,

2. ,

3.
9.
58
57
60
59
56
61
58
57
57
56
65
61
59
58
47
54
55
65
59
57
13
18
10
14
18
12
13
18
9
12
17
12
13
20
10
17
14
9
11
20
11
13
20
10
13
20
10
20
11
12
7
18
11
10
20
8
13
17
12
15
18
9
19
21
13
17
23
7
15
19
11
10
15
9
11
21
9
16
15
13
U10. , , .., - ?
1.
2.
3. -
4.
5. ,
9.
5
12
33
28
5
14
35
26
5
11
32
29
5
11
34
31
5
16
29
29
4
11
36
27
6
11
34
26
5
11
35
29
5
12
34
26
3
12
34
30
6
16
28
26
7
10
26
32
4
11
34
29
5
16
34
25
7
9
34
25
4
9
41
33
3
15
39
30
9
7
28
28
5
12
29
27
5
15
32
25
16
6
15
6
17
6
16
4
16
6
13
8
19
4
16
4
17
6
14
7
18
6
21
4
15
6
14
6
22
4
13
1
10
3
20
8
21
6
15
8
U11. , ?
1. ,
2. ,
3. ,
4. ,
9.
15
17
16
17
14
18
15
16
15
18
17
19
13
16
16
18
15
18
15
18
12
14
9
13
14
16
18
19
21
26
11
29
15
15
15
14
15
18
16
18
25
31
12
25
30
12
24
32
13
23
29
17
25
30
12
23
33
9
27
31
13
26
30
10
24
32
11
20
31
16
29
31
13
28
43
7
27
29
14
22
32
10
19
19
14
37
14
9
25
32
13
25
38
9
25
30
13
21
32
13
6
13
23
50
8
5
11
24
48
11
2
13
28
51
6
2
6
24
64
4
4
11
26
50
9
6
15
25
46
8
9
16
26
37
12
6
25
28
33
8
2
11
30
48
9
7
8
25
56
4
4
12
23
52
9
5
12
23
50
10
U12. , , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
5
12
25
50
8
5
12
27
49
8
4
12
24
51
9
5
8
28
50
9
4
12
22
53
9
5
11
24
51
8
4
14
29
46
8
4
11
27
50
8
U13. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
2
7
22
64
5
2
8
21
64
5
2
7
22
64
5
1
7
25
65
3
2
4
23
67
5
1
10
19
65
5
4
8
22
60
6
3
6
23
64
4
1
8
21
66
5
1
10
21
63
5
4
5
22
63
6
4
3
17
73
3
2
6
21
67
4
2
9
25
58
6
0
20
22
50
8
0
11
29
59
1
3
9
24
58
6
1
6
18
73
2
3
5
22
66
5
2
8
20
64
7
31
56
12
25
59
16
22
64
14
32
57
11
24
57
19
26
54
20
18
71
11
24
62
14
22
58
20
29
62
9
45
46
9
36
51
13
28
61
11
23
61
16
30
52
18
18
66
16
U14. , ?
1.
2.
9.
26
59
15
25
57
19
27
61
12
24
54
22
U15. , ?
237
1.
2.
3. / ,
4.
5.
9.
3
13
3
10
4
16
7
13
3
15
3
16
3
10
2
15
4
16
6
9
2
11
3
20
3
12
3
11
9
25
1
20
3
13
0
12
6
15
4
10
34
28
13
8
38
34
9
7
31
23
17
9
36
19
17
8
33
32
13
5
31
30
12
9
38
27
13
10
31
31
16
6
34
30
10
7
39
21
15
10
35
30
12
11
22
25
22
9
37
31
10
8
33
29
17
8
43
6
7
10
36
23
10
10
31
28
18
7
32
36
11
8
34
27
12
7
39
25
13
9
238
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
U16. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
13
28
23
20
16
19
29
23
17
12
7
28
24
23
18
21
25
18
22
15
14
32
23
20
12
11
28
26
17
17
10
26
24
23
18
11
24
28
19
18
12
31
21
22
14
16
23
20
23
18
14
34
22
17
13
10
26
27
26
12
11
25
24
24
16
15
33
21
14
17
22
36
20
10
12
17
16
23
30
14
13
26
24
15
22
6
31
24
23
15
14
25
23
22
16
13
36
23
18
10
U17. (, )? ?
1.
2.
3. ,
4. ,
9.
21
21
21
26
19
22
19
20
19
22
24
22
20
22
22
20
24
20
18
22
40
40
39
36
40
41
39
38
42
39
38
43
40
39
33
36
38
39
41
42
18
18
18
14
19
16
20
19
19
13
20
17
17
19
21
29
16
17
17
16
6
16
6
16
7
16
5
20
7
16
7
14
6
16
6
17
6
14
9
16
3
16
4
15
7
17
6
14
6
18
6
9
6
17
8
17
6
18
7
14
12
40
17
7
25
12
33
30
7
18
14
37
22
16
11
13
34
33
11
9
16
25
26
11
22
15
37
18
5
26
8
49
24
4
15
12
42
13
10
23
18
38
12
10
22
18
36
17
7
22
13
33
9
5
39
17
26
27
11
19
16
36
17
6
25
18
43
13
6
20
16
39
10
10
25
18
40
9
12
20
U18. , - ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
12
38
22
8
20
13
39
21
7
20
12
37
23
9
20
7
37
22
7
27
12
39
19
9
21
15
35
21
8
21
13
40
25
7
16
15
34
23
10
18
11
38
22
8
20
8
40
25
5
21
14
41
15
9
23
15
41
23
11
11
U19. , - ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
17
38
14
9
22
20
38
11
7
25
15
39
16
10
21
25
38
10
9
18
16
39
15
9
21
18
36
13
9
24
15
39
14
9
24
16
35
17
7
25
16
39
13
10
22
21
41
9
10
18
16
38
13
8
24
15
46
13
10
17
U20. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
6
26
40
25
3
5
26
42
23
3
7
26
37
26
3
5
23
43
25
4
6
28
38
26
2
7
29
38
23
3
7
24
40
24
4
8
31
35
23
2
7
26
43
22
3
6
25
37
26
5
4
21
43
30
3
3
23
43
26
6
7
26
37
27
3
6
27
41
23
2
8
26
50
14
3
11
41
32
15
1
9
25
40
24
2
4
19
47
25
5
7
28
40
22
3
3
26
37
31
3
U21. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
7
25
39
27
3
7
23
40
27
3
7
26
38
27
3
6
21
41
28
3
6
26
37
29
2
7
26
36
27
4
8
23
41
24
4
8
29
34
27
2
7
25
41
24
3
6
23
37
28
6
5
19
44
30
2
4
20
41
28
7
6
25
37
29
3
8
26
40
25
2
12
23
42
21
3
16
37
27
19
1
9
27
36
26
3
3
20
44
27
7
8
25
43
22
3
3
21
38
36
3
48
44
8
58
36
7
46
48
6
54
39
7
50
33
17
67
27
6
65
23
12
54
38
8
50
42
8
38
54
8
41
50
9
44
47
10
50
38
12
60
35
5
63
29
8
U22. , ?
1. ,
2.
9.
53
38
9
57
35
8
50
41
9
53
34
13
54
38
8
U23. , ?
1.
2. , ,
,
3.
4. ,
5.
9.
15
17
14
16
12
15
17
12
17
17
16
17
15
13
24
19
16
17
19
29
13
8
20
15
28
14
8
21
12
29
12
8
19
18
19
13
4
22
26
31
15
8
21
13
26
12
12
23
13
34
12
6
16
15
30
15
9
21
14
30
9
8
23
14
21
17
6
20
19
34
11
8
16
15
27
9
13
21
13
29
14
6
20
16
29
14
9
19
17
29
13
5
20
9
18
15
4
28
16
32
15
6
24
17
32
10
10
20
13
32
11
9
23
9
24
15
9
11
22
U24. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
36
42
8
5
9
38
45
7
4
7
35
41
9
6
10
28
48
6
7
12
38
40
10
4
8
39
40
7
6
8
36
45
7
4
8
39
40
9
4
8
32
49
7
4
8
35
38
5
10
12
40
41
9
3
7
37
45
10
2
6
38
42
6
5
9
34
42
9
5
10
36
35
17
7
5
24
42
17
9
8
34
39
12
4
11
42
45
5
0
7
31
49
5
7
8
43
37
6
6
8
U25. - ?
239
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
63
27
5
1
4
64
27
4
1
5
63
27
5
2
4
66
22
5
0
6
61
28
5
2
5
62
27
5
2
5
66
27
4
1
3
63
28
5
1
3
62
29
4
1
4
61
24
5
1
10
67
24
4
3
2
67
29
3
2
0
63
26
4
1
7
64
25
6
2
3
59
36
3
1
1
46
39
11
4
1
67
26
4
2
2
69
22
4
0
5
58
31
5
2
5
67
23
3
1
7
240
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
U26. , -
?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
49
32
10
1
8
48
33
11
1
8
49
32
10
1
8
45
33
9
0
12
49
33
10
2
6
48
31
13
1
8
51
32
9
1
7
48
32
13
1
7
45
38
7
1
9
48
26
15
1
10
57
31
7
1
4
44
41
5
1
9
47
33
11
0
9
54
28
12
2
5
49
29
13
1
8
30
31
26
2
12
51
34
7
2
7
48
34
7
0
12
46
34
11
2
8
58
28
10
0
4
U27. , ,
?
1.
2. ,
3.
9.
35
41
15
9
33
45
14
8
37
38
16
9
29
45
12
14
29
48
13
10
38
40
16
7
41
35
17
7
33
43
16
8
37
43
12
8
36
38
17
9
35
39
16
11
42
37
15
7
35
42
14
9
31
44
16
9
43
32
14
11
47
39
13
1
33
45
13
10
36
38
14
12
37
41
14
9
31
42
19
9
U28. , , , ,
, ?
1. /
2. , ,

3. , ,

4. ,
, ,
8. ,
9. ,
34
35
33
35
32
34
35
37
32
28
40
29
33
38
34
19
32
40
37
34
29
29
30
24
33
29
29
32
31
27
25
29
27
35
28
33
33
28
30
25
12
11
13
11
15
13
12
12
11
14
19
10
12
18
30
11
10
14
8
14
9
13
7
14
9
23
9
12
8
12
7
12
5
11
9
14
12
17
6
14
8
13
11
17
3
9
4
12
3
9
7
13
9
12
9
13
8
17
U29. , ? ( )
2.
48
47
49
46
47
50
49
51
47
44
49
53
50
42
53
39
50
56
51
41
16.
47
47
46
50
43
50
45
48
48
43
47
49
46
45
54
45
43
59
47
42
3. ,
44
40
48
44
42
47
44
42
48
44
44
47
45
42
48
38
46
42
45
47
9.
44
43
45
46
42
47
43
46
42
44
45
51
41
44
56
36
42
57
42
42
5.
41
40
42
41
43
39
42
42
41
39
44
50
42
39
36
35
38
47
40
44
4. ,
27
30
25
34
26
27
26
28
29
26
25
25
27
28
33
25
35
26
24
26
23.
25
24
26
25
27
25
24
28
22
23
28
19
27
23
38
27
23
29
23
26
6.
18
17
19
19
18
19
18
20
17
19
17
17
20
16
24
26
13
25
18
16
11. ,
17
19
16
18
21
17
15
20
20
10
17
16
16
19
20
23
21
19
21
1.
16
17
15
22
15
16
14
17
14
18
15
14
16
17
20
22
19
16
11
15
18.
13
14
13
14
15
13
12
16
12
12
11
11
19
11
14
21
17
11
13.
13
10
15
12
12
14
13
15
11
10
14
13
14
15
23
15
13
12
12. ,
10
10
12
14
12
10
17
11
17.
11
10
10
13
15
11
11
7.
11
15.
11
8. ,
15
14.
12
21.
11
11
24. ,
20.
13
10.
26.
10
19.
12
27.
25.
15
22.
28.
10
11
241
242
25-39
40-54
55
500 .
100 500 .
100 .
18-24
1600
720
880
221
458
429
493
480
484
325
311
200
813
494
87
135
381
287
400
397
U30. , ? ( )
8. ,
10.
14.
23.
2.
19.
25.
1.
7.
22.
3. ,
9.
11. ,
18.
20.
5.
26.
6.
15.
27.
17.
16.
24. ,
4. ,
13.
21.
12. ,
28.
30
24
23
21
21
20
17
16
16
15
14
14
12
12
12
10
10
9
8
8
8
7
6
6
5
5
4
15
31
22
22
21
21
21
15
16
17
13
14
12
13
13
12
11
9
9
7
8
8
8
6
5
7
4
3
16
30
25
23
22
20
19
18
17
15
17
13
15
12
12
12
10
11
9
8
8
8
6
6
6
3
6
6
15
33
21
25
18
16
20
13
14
16
13
13
15
8
8
17
7
7
9
5
9
7
8
9
2
6
4
2
21
30
23
21
17
18
19
16
18
13
16
10
13
14
11
9
10
11
8
11
9
7
6
4
3
5
5
5
19
32
27
23
25
20
21
19
15
17
15
15
13
12
14
12
9
12
8
7
9
8
6
8
8
6
5
5
11
28
24
22
24
25
18
17
18
16
14
16
13
13
14
11
14
8
11
8
6
9
8
6
7
4
6
5
13
32
25
22
22
22
19
15
15
20
17
15
17
14
13
13
10
10
11
9
9
9
8
6
7
5
6
6
13
34
25
25
21
22
18
17
18
12
16
13
12
12
15
12
10
12
10
9
7
9
8
6
6
6
5
3
13
29
24
24
17
16
23
17
18
13
13
12
10
12
8
13
7
8
7
7
9
7
4
7
3
7
4
4
18
24
20
18
24
20
18
18
14
16
12
14
15
9
12
8
15
7
5
6
6
6
7
6
5
4
5
4
20
29
29
23
21
24
27
20
10
14
18
19
16
10
9
12
17
13
12
11
11
12
7
8
7
5
7
3
7
33
21
22
20
21
20
17
17
13
14
12
13
11
12
11
11
8
8
7
7
7
9
5
6
4
5
5
16
27
26
23
22
18
17
16
16
19
12
13
13
14
14
11
9
10
8
7
7
7
4
8
5
6
5
4
18
32
26
25
26
22
17
12
23
21
29
22
18
20
19
21
5
13
11
10
12
11
8
6
4
6
7
7
10
33
27
36
35
25
28
26
23
11
17
26
18
18
26
16
17
17
18
10
8
9
10
11
7
8
12
8
6
34
26
28
15
15
18
19
12
17
19
11
17
10
8
18
6
9
8
10
10
10
3
8
5
7
4
4
12
31
23
23
29
31
19
14
18
14
14
16
13
20
17
13
12
10
8
6
9
11
10
5
4
3
8
7
18
26
22
13
22
20
17
17
20
15
10
14
12
9
10
6
8
7
6
5
5
6
7
5
5
3
6
3
17
30
23
21
16
18
21
13
14
17
15
10
10
10
10
10
14
10
10
9
9
5
7
5
7
6
1
3
18
. ,
594
1006
510
1600
, ..
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
U1. , ? ( )
6.
3.
8.
7.
5.
1.
2.
9.
4.
10.
99.
31
31
13
7
3
2
2
1
0
8
1
32
29
13
7
3
3
3
2
0
8
1
30
30
13
7
3
3
3
1
1
9
1
32
32
12
8
3
2
1
2
0
7
2
33
34
12
6
2
3
1
1
1
5
1
36
33
15
8
0
6
0
1
0
1
0
23
27
15
14
5
2
5
1
0
7
1
29
35
8
8
0
6
8
0
0
4
2
26
23
14
8
3
0
1
2
0
19
2
31
28
13
7
3
1
2
1
1
11
3
32
33
13
6
2
2
2
1
1
6
1
21
21
15
12
3
2
2
1
0
20
2
15
49
30
6
1
20
52
25
3
0
14
48
32
6
1
16
50
27
7
1
18
51
24
6
1
13
53
33
1
0
21
49
26
4
0
23
46
26
5
1
12
38
38
12
1
8
50
36
5
1
15
49
29
5
1
11
43
34
10
1
5
34
49
8
4
7
35
47
8
3
4
37
46
8
6
12
48
37
2
1
8
28
55
6
2
6
34
44
11
5
3
28
54
12
3
6
33
48
9
3
9
36
44
7
5
U2. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
5. ()
U3. , ? ( %% , )
243
1.
2.
3.
4. , , ,
9.
6
34
48
9
4
8
41
42
5
3
7
34
48
9
3
244
, ..

1600
510
1006
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
U4. ? ( )
1.
93
92
91
96
96
92
97
80
90
93
94
89
5. , ,
25
31
27
23
26
30
19
20
24
25
26
23
6. - (, , )
17
42
25
16
20
30
17
19
16
19
7.
12
24
18
12
18
10
11
12
12
2.
11
14
11
10
11
17
16
10
10
11
13
3.
11
12
15
10
4.
8.
9.
U5. , , , ?
1. ,
17
20
17
15
15
11
27
16
18
17
16
21
2. ,
12
13
12
11
13
15
28
20
10
31
3. ,
54
55
53
55
64
57
49
39
38
47
59
24
9.
18
12
18
19
15
18
16
24
26
17
25
1. , ,
15
20
16
13
16
10
32
11
12
14
20
2. (, )
18
21
18
20
20
14
38
20
17
17
24
3. ..
12
14
12
12
11
22
15
10
12
13
4. ,
34
29
34
33
33
46
24
16
39
35
35
30
5.
6. ,
13
11
12
14
12
15
17
12
18
13
12
9.
16
U6. ?
U7. ? ( )
4.
2.
1.
3.
5.
8. ,
6. ,
7. ,
9.
10.
40
37
30
16
3
3
2
1
9
2
41
40
32
17
5
2
1
1
7
3
37
37
30
15
4
4
1
0
9
3
43
37
31
18
3
3
3
1
9
1
44
43
34
18
1
1
1
0
5
2
48
32
29
19
2
4
0
0
8
2
35
46
38
20
1
4
0
1
14
2
24
32
27
10
18
8
1
4
8
0
33
23
20
8
7
4
8
1
18
4
37
36
31
15
1
5
1
0
10
3
42
41
32
17
2
2
1
0
8
2
26
14
20
12
11
13
7
3
18
3
11
13
15
23
38
15
17
23
40
12
16
22
39
15
13
25
36
16
15
23
38
13
15
28
42
10
18
24
39
10
18
24
38
6
16
26
32
21
12
19
40
23
15
24
38
15
14
22
38
20
U8. , ?
1.
2. ,
3. ,
4.
9.
U9. , ?
1. ,
2. ,

3.
9.
58
60
59
58
63
65
55
51
40
60
61
38
13
18
10
16
18
6
14
18
9
12
17
13
8
19
10
7
14
14
10
24
11
27
17
5
26
20
14
16
16
8
10
18
11
35
17
10
U10. , , .., - ?
1.
2.
3. -
4.
5. ,
9.
5
12
33
28
16
6
5
16
41
20
15
4
5
12
33
28
16
6
6
13
32
28
16
5
6
13
39
21
18
3
1
13
28
21
21
15
4
10
25
43
18
1
2
25
26
29
14
5
6
11
20
50
10
3
4
9
36
25
15
11
5
12
36
24
17
6
7
13
17
48
9
6
15
17
25
31
12
18
21
29
25
8
15
19
25
31
11
15
15
25
32
14
16
15
23
36
9
18
8
34
26
13
21
23
26
21
9
19
31
16
29
5
8
24
23
28
17
12
15
28
28
17
16
14
25
33
12
10
38
23
18
12
U11. , ?
245
1. ,
2. ,
3. ,
4. ,
9.
246
, ..

1006
510
1600
594
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
3
13
25
49
9
3
9
27
56
5
4
11
32
46
8
9
26
18
44
3
16
26
27
25
7
4
14
15
51
17
5
10
29
46
10
4
9
27
53
7
11
27
15
29
18
U12. , , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
5
12
25
50
8
6
15
25
49
4
6
11
26
50
8
U13. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
2
7
22
64
5
2
8
25
62
2
2
8
23
64
4
2
7
20
65
7
1
6
22
65
5
7
2
18
67
5
4
8
25
62
1
4
23
26
43
4
1
5
18
71
6
2
10
23
62
4
2
7
21
65
5
4
10
25
58
3
26
59
15
30
59
11
30
58
12
18
61
21
28
64
8
23
47
30
23
69
8
61
22
17
23
55
21
16
64
20
24
62
14
39
42
20
2
12
33
28
17
9
0
9
33
51
5
3
7
10
49
19
11
6
8
28
28
16
9
10
8
19
36
19
14
5
2
11
32
37
10
8
2
11
33
31
15
9
10
26
37
17
7
5
15
52
10
16
8
6
19
21
27
26
6
26
25
26
16
14
30
24
18
15
4
22
24
31
20
U14. , ?
1.
2.
9.
U15. , ?
1.
2.
3. / ,
4.
5.
9.
3
13
34
28
13
8
4
17
34
27
14
5
4
14
34
30
13
6
3
12
35
25
14
12
U16. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
13
28
23
20
16
18
26
27
15
14
14
29
22
20
15
10
27
26
21
17
14
29
27
17
12
17
34
12
20
17
25
20
28
13
14
U17. (, )? ?
1.
2.
3. ,

4. ,

9.
21
40
24
42
22
39
19
40
25
42
14
52
18
40
33
29
22
26
12
42
22
42
13
25
18
18
18
18
16
19
21
24
17
19
16
27
6
16
6
10
7
14
6
19
4
13
3
12
4
17
6
9
13
21
8
19
4
16
18
18
25
38
8
5
24
11
40
18
12
19
7
36
23
10
24
12
38
21
7
22
14
37
22
12
15
31
35
8
14
11
13
31
17
11
29
18
40
8
13
21
18
39
12
7
23
10
29
21
21
19
U18. , - ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
12
38
22
8
20
16
38
24
6
16
13
36
23
8
20
12
41
19
8
21
11
40
25
6
18
11
42
19
7
21
26
27
27
10
11
U19. , - ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
17
38
14
9
22
18
44
14
7
17
18
37
15
10
20
16
40
11
6
26
18
39
15
8
21
10
47
15
3
25
23
31
15
6
25
U20. , ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
6
26
40
25
3
7
29
40
22
2
7
28
40
23
2
6
24
38
27
5
6
23
44
26
2
8
19
49
18
6
8
22
44
21
4
13
31
34
20
3
7
33
33
25
3
6
32
31
27
5
6
25
41
25
3
11
34
29
21
4
U21. ?
1.
2.
3.
4.
9.
7
25
39
27
3
8
27
38
26
2
7
26
38
27
2
7
22
39
27
5
7
22
42
28
2
7
18
49
19
7
4
24
48
20
4
17
23
33
24
3
8
29
28
32
3
4
30
33
29
5
5
24
41
28
3
15
31
26
24
4
50
40
10
50
42
9
60
33
8
55
36
9
57
34
9
61
34
6
57
43
0
53
39
9
46
45
10
55
36
9
39
53
9
U22. , ?
247
1. ,
2.
9.
53
38
9
684
594
1006
510
1600
248
, ..
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
U23. , ?
1.
15
13
14
16
17
16
20
19
11
12
14
15
2. , , ,
29
31
28
30
34
55
26
39
15
16
31
15
3.
13
18
15
11
19
20
15
12
19
4. ,
12
15
5.
20
19
19
22
13
14
21
42
20
18
35
9.
15
15
15
16
19
11
23
17
U24. ?
1.
36
35
34
40
45
39
22
30
28
29
39
22
2.
42
44
44
40
41
43
59
42
37
46
44
31
3.
13
15
4.
13
11
20
9.
10
10
13
11
12
U25. - ?
1.
63
62
63
64
74
67
57
49
48
58
67
39
2.
27
27
27
26
21
29
38
39
34
25
26
32
3.
11
4.
9.
13
U26. , -
?
1.
49
50
50
48
61
53
43
37
40
36
52
32
2.
32
30
31
35
31
34
40
23
30
37
33
26
3.
10
14
10
10
10
10
33
19
11
30
4.
9.
16
U27. , ,
?
1.
35
37
32
41
28
34
27
38
48
39
32
55
2. ,
41
40
44
38
45
38
48
40
36
42
44
30
3.
15
14
15
14
19
14
19
10
10
12
16
9.
10
14
13
U28. , , , ,
, ?
1. /
34
37
35
33
47
30
41
27
20
20
38
15
2. , ,
29
30
30
29
27
33
30
32
22
36
29
30
3. , ,
12
12
14
13
14
28
21
12
11
20
4. , , ,
13
12
13
16
8. ,
18
11
9. ,
14
11
21
14
19
14
249
594
1006
510
1600
250
, ..
684
152
95
79
245
305
1348
236
44
47
44
43
48
27
17
20
16
13
8
14
7
5
4
3
9
6
0
4
9
5
2
6
2
6
1
5
52
57
35
45
36
25
21
17
25
26
14
16
4
12
7
8
4
3
7
4
3
2
11
6
2
2
2
5
43
43
39
35
29
22
20
27
12
12
14
19
7
12
3
13
18
18
6
16
3
6
3
6
7
6
6
5
39
34
37
38
32
29
19
26
16
12
9
10
9
7
8
14
5
7
5
5
3
5
3
4
5
3
2
9
43
44
43
41
37
25
23
17
16
11
13
15
10
5
2
3
4
3
3
2
2
2
3
3
3
3
1
14
51
50
47
46
45
29
27
16
19
16
15
12
10
9
6
5
4
4
5
3
3
3
3
3
1
2
2
7
29
25
31
33
20
18
12
30
10
17
7
16
8
9
8
15
10
11
5
9
8
6
5
6
9
8
3
11
U29. , ? ( )
2.
16.
3. ,
9.
5.
4. ,
23.
6.
11. ,
1.
18.
13.
12. ,
17.
7.
15.
8. ,
14.
21.
24. ,
20.
10.
26.
19.
27.
25.
22.
28.
48
47
44
44
41
27
25
18
17
16
13
13
10
9
6
6
5
5
5
4
4
3
3
3
3
2
2
7
47
50
46
46
42
32
26
19
17
22
17
15
13
9
7
7
7
6
6
5
3
4
4
5
2
3
3
5
47
48
45
45
41
29
26
18
18
17
15
15
11
10
6
6
5
4
5
5
3
3
3
3
3
2
3
6
50
45
43
43
41
26
23
18
17
14
11
9
7
6
7
6
4
6
4
3
5
3
3
3
2
3
1
10
55
52
51
49
48
30
31
15
19
19
16
12
12
10
8
4
3
3
5
4
3
3
3
2
1
1
2
5
U30. , ? ( )
12. ,
13.
21.
4. ,
24. ,
16.
17.
15.
27.
6.
26.
5.
20.
18.
11. ,
9.
3. ,
22.
7.
1.
25.
19.
2.
23.
14.
10.
8. ,
28.
4
5
5
6
6
7
8
8
8
9
10
10
12
12
12
14
14
15
16
16
17
20
21
21
23
24
30
15
29
22
25
22
22
20
14
19
17
15
15
16
14
17
11
11
11
11
10
7
7
9
7
6
6
6
5
16
30
23
23
20
20
19
15
16
17
14
14
13
12
13
11
10
10
10
8
8
7
7
7
4
5
4
5
17
31
25
21
23
21
20
20
17
14
16
13
15
12
11
13
12
10
8
8
8
10
6
5
8
5
7
4
12
5
4
5
6
9
8
8
10
9
9
9
12
13
12
12
16
13
17
16
18
17
20
20
23
22
24
29
14
6
4
9
8
2
10
12
8
4
12
5
8
7
15
18
12
13
14
19
14
15
18
33
25
26
37
31
10
5
5
5
9
1
11
8
4
5
5
14
26
12
26
14
25
17
19
16
26
13
22
22
29
17
18
29
10
4
8
10
3
12
4
8
4
7
12
10
7
6
18
18
9
33
6
15
20
13
18
21
25
14
21
25
16
4
7
2
5
6
4
4
8
11
8
13
10
17
10
13
12
11
10
14
13
15
19
18
18
21
21
35
15
3
6
4
4
3
5
8
5
7
9
10
5
10
8
8
7
13
16
15
14
22
20
17
15
27
22
33
23
5
5
5
6
6
7
9
8
8
9
9
10
11
12
12
13
13
15
16
16
18
19
21
22
23
24
30
16
2
8
3
5
5
5
4
7
10
11
12
11
14
14
13
15
18
12
11
19
12
24
19
15
23
22
31
14
251
SUMMARY
Stability of social justice perceptions in public

opinion (by Luidmila Khakhulina). This article
analyzes the dynamics of the ideas of justice and
injustice in the distribution of public goods in the
last 20 years housing, health, education and etc.
The paper also discusses how changed peoples
perceptions of fair and unfair social mechanisms
of economic resources redistribution and which
of them dominated in public views- hard work,
education and skills or social networks.
The results showed that, despite the dramatic
social transformations of the 1990s, peoples ideas
on these issues have not changed significantly
over the 20 year period. Our society is in a state of
uncertainty the old Soviet principles can no
longer relate to the market economy, and new
market principles are not working effectively in
social meaning. Hard work does not guarantee
an achievement of high welfare, and hence the
population again supports the principles of public
distribution and continues to regard it as more
justice then defective market economy.
Public Perceptions of Fairness and Efficiency
in the Health Care Systems of Different Countries
(ISSP 2011) (by Olga Karaeva). This study provides
an analysis of the micro-level estimates and public
expectations of two key characteristics of healthcare
systems justice and effectiveness. Due to the
historically different principles of organization of
health care systems, we will be primarily interested in
the way how people percept justice and effectiveness
in countries with similar levels of economic
development and similar models of healthcare system.
We investigate the differences between 5 groups of
countries: the post-socialist, Scandinavian, Western
developed countries, countries with market models of
health and emerging economies and Russia.
Empirical data is comparative survey
International Social Survey Program (ISSP) on
the topic of Health and Healthcare conducted in
29 countries in 2011.
252
The results show neither fully public nor do

market-oriented models not achieve effectiveness in
healthcare. Optimum result in terms of economic,
social and medical efficacy observed among the
welfare states France, Germany and Belgium.
However, the more efficient healthcare system
(public satisfaction, the level of corruption, quality
of medicine service etc.) is the more unjust in public
opinion.
Despite the common preference among all
countries have equal access to unlimited free health
care, in models with market healthcare population
more satisfied with the health system functioning.
Thus, the market principle of medical services are
not always in conflict with the moral, cultural norms
of society, which suggests that at a certain balance
of social and economic factors marketization of art
can produce a positive result.
The perception of prices by the patients as
the key point in medicine marketisation (case of
Moscow dental market (by Elena Berdysheva). The
article sheds light to the social conventions which
maintain the marketization of healthcare services.
The market of dental services is used as an example
of a market for socially contested goods goods
which are highly essential for individuals and at the
same time closely related to such sacred entities as
human life, death, body, intimate relationships and
so on.
The data of the 23 in-depth interviews with
Muscovites, who have recently visited commercial
dental clinic, point out three possible scenarios of
dental services price perception: a script of hidden
price, a script of price as a communicative issue
and a script of suspicious price. Activation of this
or that price perception script in concrete clinicdoctor-patient interaction depends on the way
apatient comes to the clinic: by recommendation,
by insurance program or from the street. The
latter in its turn correlates with the type of clinic
available to patients in Moscow dental market.
12 (117) 2014
The author suggests to speak about two types

ofdental clinics with professional approach and
with mass production approach to the patient.
The main boarder between them lay in the
context of the worthiness each patient has for the
clinic. Clinics with professional approach recruit
new patients through the social networks of the
patients already treated while mass production
approach clinics populate their chairs through the
contacts with insurance companies. The particular
interest for the study is the scenario of a suspicious
price which exposes two layers of doubts patients
have in relation to the commercialized medicine.
The first layer is concerned to the values and
motives expected by patients on behalf of doctors
and personal in the private clinic. The second
appeals to the legitimacy of money prices
for dental services as such. Doubts about the
professional integrity of a doctor will be dissolved,
if the experience of undergoing dental treatment
is perceived in terms of service to the patients
and medical profession, and not in the categories
of providing market services. Doubts related to
money prices for commercial dental services
are rather mythological. On the one hand they
are driven by suspicion to the market format of
providing medical services which partly replaces
budget dentistry and partly continue to compete
with it. On the other hand patients suspect that
commercial dental services are overpriced due
to the uncertainty of quality of a medical service
provided in the circumstances of information
asymmetry between a patient and a doctor and
strongly dependent on human factor.
Social expulsion of migrants from the Russian
society: law and practice (by Anna Morgunova).
Russian discourses on migration skip many aspects
of social impact of the migration process: the most
influential social actors have not yet been presented
as a subject to study yet. The aim of this article is to
uncover emerging informal practices of interaction
with migrants in Russian society and state
system. Analyzing resources of various actors and
emerging social institutions, author comes to the
conclusion about the formation of the institutional
preconditions of social exclusion of this group.
How Contract Workers Find Clients and
Companies Choose Freelancers: An Empirical
Analysis of Self-Employment in Contemporary
Russia (by Maxim Markin and Elena Nazarbaeva).
The study concerns the process of business partners
selection in the relationships of freelancers and

their clients. As this process looks like an empirical

realization of the model of perfect competition
social ties and institutions are expected to play
unimportant role. Nevertheless the findings
demonstrate that the relationships of freelancers
and their clients are socially embedded. This
embeddedness reduces uncertainty and prevents
opportunism in the field of self-employment.
The research is based on the empirical data
collected at the beginning of the 2010th. More
than 1200 managers of different companies were
questioned in 2010 and more than 7000 contract
workers filled in a questionnaire in 2011 at the website Freelance.ru.
Although price, quantity and quality are very
important for both companies and freelancers
recommendations and previous experience of
making business with each other also play a key role
in the process of contractors selection. Social ties
and institutions make business partners behavior
predictable and that is why market actors do not rely
only on the forces of competition.
Current status and problems of Russian
secondary vocational education (by Diana
Migunova). The article contains analysis of the main
problems of secondary vocational education, as well
as its current status, which is tracked in Monitoring
of education markets and organizations (MEMO),
initiated by the Ministry of Education and Science
of the Russian Federation jointly with the Institute
for Statistical Studies and Economics of Knowledge,
National Research University- Higher School of
Economics. Among problems faced by the system
of secondary vocational education in Russia there
are: diminution in the demand of population and
enterprises for this type of education, the reduction
in funding and degradation of the material-technical
base of educational institutions, declining progress
of skilled students and teachers.
Beyond the Nation-State: Indirect impact
of Nationalist Movements on Public Opinion in
Belarus and Ukraine (by Marharyta Fabrykant).
The goal of the paper is to broaden Hrochs
theory of three-stage development of nationalist
movements in smaller European nations using the
recent historical experience of two very different
Eastern European states. According to Hroch, each
national(ist) movement in country that did not
gain independent statehood prior to the nineteenth
century originates as a discovery of a nation
by academic intellectuals (Phase A), gains initial
support among educated professionals (Phase
12 (117) 2014
253
B), and progresses towards a full-fledged mass

movement (Phase C) culminating in the eventual
gain of independence. This scheme apparently
captures key turns in Central European nationalist
movements in the nineteenth century, but is much
less easily reconciled with later Eastern European
experience (Martin, 2001). In particular, Hrochs
theory at the first glance offers little explanation
of the post-Communist Ukraine and Belarus,
where independent nation-states emerged, at least
initially, due the general dissolution of the Soviet
Union, and not to the national liberation struggle.
The Ukrainian nationalist movement, instead of
widening the circle of its supporters nationwide,
caused polarization of alternative versions of
Ukrainian national identity and, instead of winning
on its own at the Phase C, went through a succession
of uneasy alliances with not primarily nationalist
forces. The Belarusian nationalist movement failed
to attract the popular interest and transformed
itself into a small coterie relatively isolated from
other movements. A possible explanation is that
Hrochs scheme reflects long-term direct effects
of nationalist movements, but not short-term
indirect hidden effects those irrelevant to the
goals of nationalist movements. In the Ukrainian
case, the main indirect impact of the nationalist
movements lies in forming mass notions about the
form and style of social activism, irrespectively of
its nationalist content, while in Belarus nationalists
covertly influenced the content of popular discourse
about national issue, including the views of selfproclaimed
anti-nationalists.
Metaphorically
speaking, the ABC of nationalism offered by Hroch
accurately interprets the signs of history, but, for
a comprehensive understanding of nationalist
movements, a different layer of theory is required to
read between the lines.
Belarusian Maidan: is it possible? (by Sergej
Nikolyuk). The article presents the analysis of the
possible prerequisites and conditions which could
conduce wide protest activities of mass political
processes. Basing on the survey data of IISEPS poll,
the author analyses the main question: are there
conditions for the formation of a revolutionary
situation in Belarus today.
Belarusian respond to the Ukrainian challenge
(by Sergej Nikolyuk). Subsequent to the results of
December poll of Institute of Socio-Economic
and Political Studies (iiseps) in Belarus, the
positive trend of public sentiment changed to the
negative. However, more recent studies of public
254
opinion (since 24 March by 2 April) showed that

the optimism of the Belarusians has increased.
According to the author of the recent article, such
an increase in positive attitudes was formed because
of the policy influence: in the eyes of electorate
the value of present policy, which is based on
maintaining stability, increases because of the
Ukrainian chaos.
Euromaidan. Before and After the victory (by
Vladimir Paniotto). Events which are associated
with Euromaidan can be divided into several main
phases: the beginning of the protests; beating
the protesters and changing the motivation of
the protests; the radicalization of the Maidan,
skirmishes with police, first victims; execution of
the Maidan; victory of the Maidan; after the victory.
This unique social phenomenon is not comparable
to any other form of mass activity, neither in massscale nor on activity level of participants. This
article contains step analysis of the events of the
period autumn 2013- spring 2014.
Protest and self-organization (by Alexej
Levinson). Post-Soviet popular political culture
looks as a culture of obedience to authorities or
indifference to them. The instances of protest are
very rear. The article is based on the description
and analysis of three cases of strong or ever strongest
protest movements/actions in Post-Soviet space.
The ability of the participants to switch from the
protest negative actions to the positive tasks of self
organization and self regulation is a specific and
unexpected feature of the above political culture of
protest. The case studies of the miners mass strike in
Kuzbass mining area of Russia, famous Maidan
in Kiev (Ukraine) and Bolotnaya in Moscow are
analyzed using the interviews with participants and
authors observations.
OccupyAbay protest street camp in Moscow
in May 2012 through the eyes of its participants. (by
Denis Volkov). The paper is based on the series of
interviews with the activists who started the protest
street camp, created, managed and transformed the
supporting structures of the camp such as kitchen,
informational block, security newspaper,
assembly and others. The author is concerned
with the prerequisites of the camp, social profile
of if its participants (political and civic activists,
journalists, VIP-s, and general participants), rapid
evolution of its structures, the ideas and motives
that the activists had (including tough competition
between leftists and liberals), as well as with
12 (117) 2014
the results of the protest events in Moscow between

May 6th and the end of the month, 2012.
Soviet competition with capitalism in the fate
of Tatiana Zaslavskaya (by Alexander Nikulin).
The article includes the analyzes the history of
competition between Soviet and the West, which
is associated with the scientific heritage of Tatyana
Zaslavskaya, in particular economic-statistical
comparison of development of agriculture in USSR
and United States in early 1960s and problems of
slowing economic growth and strengthening of the
socio-political stagnation of the early 1980s.
The issues of the evolution of the relationships

of political power and scientific research were
examined through the life stories of scientists,
scientific organizations and mass media and the
transformation of public opinion in the USSR.
The article includes formulation of the problem of
professional and moral succession in post-Soviet
society relating to understanding and resolving
issues of existence of Soviet society, the years of
Thaw, stagnation and Perestroika, which were
embodied in the intellectual heritage of Tatyana
Zaslavskaya.
12 (117) 2014
255

2014
_____ (1, 2, 3, 4 )
: . .
1 250 . ( 10% )
* _____ ( 10%)
: . .
_________ ______________
40703810100010000119 - () . .
. 30101810700000000501 044583501 7705466756
: (-)
:
:
:
(e-mail)
( )
, , : 109012, ,
. , . 17, adele@levada.ru

( PDF).
165 ( 18%).
, , . (499) 755-40-39 adele@levada.ru
SUBSCRIPTION
Foreign readers may subscribe for the e-version of our magazine via e-mail adele@levada.ru
One year subscription costs 25
256
12 (117) 2014

"Вестник общественного мнения" № 1-2 (117) за 2014 год

Загружено:

Сведения о документе

Авторское право

Доступные форматы

Поделиться этим документом

Поделиться или встроить документ

Параметры публикации

Этот документ был вам полезен?

Это неприемлемый материал?

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

"Вестник общественного мнения" № 1-2 (117) за 2014 год

Загружено:

Авторское право:

Доступные форматы

. .

The Russian Public Opinion Herald

PROBLEMS OF MODERN RUSSIAN SOCIETY

Public Perceptions of Fairness and Efficiency in the Health Care

The perception of prices by the patients as the key point in medicine

How Contract Workers Find Clients and Companies Choose Freelancers:

Belarusian Maidan: is it possible? (by Sergej Nikolyuk)

Belarusian respond to the Ukrainian challenge (by Sergej Nikolyuk)

Euromaidan. Before and After the victory (by Vladimir Paniotto)

Protest and self-organization (by Alexej Levinson)

OccupyAbay protest street camp in Moscow in May 2012 through

IN HONOUR OF TATIANA ZASLAVSKAYA

Authors of the issue

* 1, 3-6, 8 2008 . N=2100, 2009 - N=1600.

14. (), 2008 . = 100%

15. (), 2008 . = 100%

1996 : , , , 1989 (. 2). 1998

2006 2008 2011 2012 2013

Homo sacer. . .: , 2011, .220.

StoreyJ., SalamanG., PlatmanK. Living with Entrerprise in an Enterprise

1990 2000 2005 2010 2011 2012

2603 2703 2905 2850 2925 2981

2603 2589 2688 2586 2665 2725

2270 2361 2591 2126 2082 2087 1982,1

2013 . // , 1, 2004. . 266.

Halfin, I. From Darkness to Light: Class, Consciousness, and Salvation

Subtelny, O. Ukraine: a history. University of Toronto Press. 2009.

3,5 ( ), 1960. 3,75

Stability of social justice perceptions in public

The results show neither fully public nor do

The author suggests to speak about two types

their clients. As this process looks like an empirical

B), and progresses towards a full-fledged mass

opinion (since 24 March by 2 April) showed that

the results of the protest events in Moscow between

The issues of the evolution of the relationships

Вам также может понравиться