Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 305

#3(99)2014

1991 ., 6

...


: , ,
, ( ), ,
, ( ), ,
, , ,
: (), (),
(-), (), (-,
-), (), (), (),
(-), ( , ),
(), (), (),
(), (),
(), (-)





E-mail : logosjournal@gmx.com
: http://www.logosjournal.ru
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/logosjournal
Twitter: https://twitter.com/logos_journal
7746739 23.09.2011
44761
ISSN 0869-5377



16+

, 2014
http://www.iep.ru/

. 142300, ., .,
., 1. 1000 .

1 .
21 .
33 . .

, ,

41
67
95
145

.
.
. , ()
.
1920.

165 . -

181
191
209
223

.
. , , ,
. :
. : ,

231 . .
1993
243 . :
:

265 . :

279 . ?
289 . , :

295 . ,
299 .

[99] 2014 

. ,
,
, -, . ,
-,


, .
: Kongresni trg 12,
1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.
E-mail: szizek@yahoo.com.
: , , ,
, , , , , ,
, .
,
,

.
. ,

. ,
,
. ,
,
, ,
.
.

HEGEL ON MARRIAGE
Slavoj iek. PhD, Visiting Professor at
anumber of American universities (Columbia
University, Princeton University, New School
for Social Research, New York University,
University of Michigan), Senior Researcher at
the Institute of Sociology of the University of
Ljubljana, Slovenia.
Address: Kongresni trg 12,
1000 Ljubljana, Slovenia.
E-mail: szizek@yahoo.com.
Keywords: Hegel, Rousseau, Freud, Mozart,
Philosophy of Right, Cos fan tutte, New
Heloise, marriage, love, sex, communism.
The scandalous theory of marriage in Hegels
Philosophy of Right ethically prefers prearranged marriage over marriages out of attraction and love. Mozarts opera Cos fan tutte
seems to be a good example in defense of this
point of viewthe object of sexual passion is
replaceable. At first, the Rousseau novel New
Heloise also has the same claim. But an unexpected return of love passion for the storys
main character in the end does not seem to fit
into Hegels account. Even so, it is enough to
turn the perspective around to see how after
passing through the painful sublation destined to cure one of love passion, that this
passion emerges as such in its pure form.
After sacrificing everything for passion, there
is a need to renounce passion itselfand yet
the passion persists.


1


, , : .
. , , , : , , ,
,
.. ,
, ,
/, . ,
, ,
.
(becoming-cultural) , , ,
-
. : , () : iekS. Hegel on Marriage//
e-flux. URL : http://www.e-flux.com/journal/hegel-on-marriage/.

[99] 2014

, , /,
. ;
. ( .) , ,
, , .

( ),
: 1. , / ,
, : , () . , , ,

,
, .
,
( ),
.


, , . ,
, (
), (163).

1. : ... // ... . .,
1934. .VII .

, , :
,
(
), , 2.
,
. ,
,
, .
: , , ,
, .
, , . .
, ,
,
, , ,
, ,
,
2. ,
:
, , ,
; , ,
(168).

[99] 2014

. , , , ,
, ,
. <> , , , ,
,
,
, , , (164, ).


, ,
,
. <>
,
(164, ).

, , (rechtlich sittliche) ; , ,
(161, ). ,
, , , (161).
,
, ; , , :


,,
;
,

, , (164).

.
, ,
,
. ,
, ( ).
, , , , , ; , ,
( ). :

, , , .

, , ,
, , .
,

, ,
, , ,
; , ,
(162).

, ,
. , . 6

[99] 2014


,
( ); , , ,
. ,
( ) ,
:
, ,
,
, , ,
; ,

, ,
. , , , , ,
(162).

, :
,


,
.

, , ,
, ; ,
. - , ,
. , ,
, . .
:
(
, ,

, ,
, ); ,
, , :
, , (163, ). <> ,
, , ; ,
,
, , ,
(163).

?3 , , , :
(, , ),
. : ?
/ , , . ,
: - ? . , ,
,
, . ,
Cosi: .
3. ,
: SimonitiJ. Vrtnica bi pod drugim imenom disala drugace//
Problemi. 2010. 12 ( ).

[99] 2014

COSI FAN TUT TE 4

,
.
, . ,
XIX , , .
, :
(1) , , ; , , ; (2) , , ,
; ,
; (3)
, ,
.
, 30 1790,
, Cos. , : , . ,
-
(, , ,
- , ..). : , 5. , , ,
, ,
- . Cos ,
4. (.). . .
5. SaidE. Cos fan tutte// Lettre international. Winter 1997. Vol.39. P.6970.

,
, ?
Cos , , : , .
, , / ,
,
. ,
.
Cos
: ,
, , , ! Cos . ,
: , , ,
. , , Cos , . Cos
;
,
. ( ), Cos . ? Cos , , ,
, , , ,
. , , , . : , ,
; , :
, . ,
.
10

[99] 2014

, , () , , / /, ,- . . , , :
? , , , , , , .. :
, ,
. :
, / . , . , ?
, , . , , , .
, . (
):
, .
ready-made , . ,
,
, ,
, ,
, . : ,
- ,
( ,
-). .
, ,
,

11

, , , ; ,
, . , : ,

, , . , , 6.

, . ( ,
) , ( :
, , ..).
( ), .

, -
, . ,
. ,
. ,
, .
, .
-, . . , ,
-.
: -
, , .
6.
(Alenka Zupani), .

12

[99] 2014

,
. , ,
. - , , . , ; .
,
, . ,
. .
, . .
, , .
-,
. , , , , , .
, , :
- , . , .
, , , . (
,
?
: , .) .
,
. ,
. , ,
- , . ? ,

13

:
,
, ,
, . ,

,
.
, , -
,
,
, . , : ,
, , . -, , ,
. ,
, : , . , ,
-.

,
. ,
, . , ,
-, , , .
: .
, .
14

[99] 2014


, ,
, , ,
7.

, , ,
( ) . ,
, , ,
? ,
( ,
) ( , )
, Aufhebung, ,
?
:
, , , ? ( VI,
VIII) ? , (, ), , , ,
, ce dgot du
bien-tre8, : ,
. : ,
. 7. SpeightA. Hegel, Literature and the Problem of Agency. Cambridge: Cambridge
University Press, 2001. P.9192.
8. (.). . .

15

, , ?9
?
,
, ,
, - - , , ? ( ) , ,
. ,
, ,
.
: / , ,
-- --. , , : ,
Versagung, , . ( ) , , eppur si muove10,
.
.
, , () ,
, ,
. -
: / -
, , , - ,
, .
, ,
9. . : DarntonR. The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes from the French
Cultural History. N.Y.: Basic Books, 1999. P.286.
10. - (.). . .

16

[99] 2014

:
.
( , ),
-, , .
. , , , /,
. ,
,
:
.

: -, , ,
, , , , . , , . .
, , , :
, , , .

, , , .
- .
, , . ,

17

, ,
.
, , ,
,
. , .
, ; -
, .
, .
, , , - - ,
? : ? ,
-, ,
, : , , ,
, , , ,
. , , . (
.)
,
( , ; 18

[99] 2014

;
),
- . ,
, .
.
( , ) , , ,
.
( /;
, /), ,
, ,

.
, , , ? - ,
, , . .
, ,
, , . , - .
(
) : ,
. ,
, -, .
, ,
Aufhebung,

?

19

,
, , , , . ,
. ,
, , , , .
, , ,
, ,
.
REFERENCES
DarntonR.The Great Cat Massacre and Other Episodes from the French Cultural History,
New York, Basic Books, 1999.
HegelG.W.F.Filosofiia prava [Grundlinien der Philosophie des Rechts]. Sochineniia
[Works], Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo politicheskoi literatury, 1984,
vol.7.
SaidE.Cos fan tutte. Lettre international, Winter 1997, vol.39.
SimonitiJ.Vrtnica bi pod drugim imenom disala drugace [That which we call a rose
by any other name would smell as sweet]. Problemi, 2010, no.12.
SpeightA.Hegel, Literature and the Problem of Agency, Cambridge, Cambridge
University Press, 2001.

20

[99] 2014

.
, -.
: 197198, -,
, 18.
E-mail: smulansky@gmail.com.
: ,
, , .

ON IEKS METHOD
Alexander Smulyansky. PhD in Philosophy, facilitator at the Lacan Literacy
seminar.
Address: 18A Bolshoy prospect Petrogradskaya side, 197198 Saint Petersburg, Russia.
E-mail: smulansky@gmail.com.
Keywords: texts of Slavoj iek, university
discourse, primary source analysis, the
problem of representation, utterance act.

In the philosophical tradition at academic


- institutions there is a distinct division
between original texts and secondary
, sources which one can use to improve their
- understanding of the classics. In contem. porary philosophy such a division proves
- problematic. Separating creators from
. - lectors masks a deep latent connection
between two fields as far as philosophical
, interpretations have already been antici , - pated in original conceptions. Slavoj ieks
- unusual style accomplishes a task of pre, , venting this ticklish situation. But his
, method is not a perfect solution to this
. - question. In many respects, his last works
, failed to avoid ambiguity. This concerns the
- book Less than nothing especially.
.
.

,,
, .


21

,
. ,
,
. , ,
-, .
, . ,
.
, , , ,
.
, ,
, , .
,
. ,
, , .
, ,
. , , , 22

[99] 2014


, , .
,
, . ,
, .
, ,
. ,
, , .
, ,
. . , , . ,
, ,
, , .
,
, , .
, . , . , ,
. , . ,
,

23

,
.
.
, .
, .

.
, , ,
, , ,
. , , . , ,
, . .

, , .
- , , ,
, , ,
.
,
. , , , - . ,
, ,
. , 24

[99] 2014

, ( -
) , ,
,
. , ,
,
, . ,
. , , , ,
, , .
, flood ,
, ,
. , -
,
- . ,
, , , , , . , ,
(
, ,,
)
, .
, ,
-
. , . , , ,

25

. , . ( ,
) , , ,
,
.
, , : , , -
. , , .
, ,
, ( ),
.
, ,
, , . , , , -
,
- , , . ,
,
, , ,
.

,
,
, , ,
.
, holocaust discourse
,
26

[99] 2014


.
, , , . ,
.
, , .
. : ,
, ,
.
, , ? , , : , , , :
, , , ,
?

, , :
?
, ,
.

.
, , , , , ,
, ,
,
.
, -

27

, , , . ,
, ,
,
, - .
, rush,
, ,
.
, :
, , (enunciated content) ,
(subjective position of
enunciation).

, . ,
enunciation ,
. , , , , , ? , ,
. , .
. , , - ,
,
,
. , . , , ,
. , ,
28

[99] 2014

, , , .
: ,
, ,
, , .
, ,
, .
, , holocaust movie.
,
. , , , , ,
,
, .
. ,
, , , , ?
idea fix.
, , , ,
, ,
. ,
, .
,
. , ,
, ,

29

. ,
, , ,
.

,
.
. , ,
, , , .

, .
, , ,
, , . ,

, ,

. ,
, , , : ,
, , .
, , ,
, , . , . ,
.
,
, , ,
.
, , ,
30

[99] 2014

, . , , ,
, .
, ,
,
.
, , , ,
.
, ,
,
, , - .
, , . ,
, , , ,
.
, , .
. , , , , ,
( , ,
,
, ), , , .
,

, .

31

.
, .
, , - , ,
.
, , , .
, gap, ,
. , , . ( , , ,
: , appearance ;

, ) , , ,
, ,
, .
, , , ,
, , ,
, 1. , ,
- ,

. , , : ?
1. Should not God as the absolute Subject be precisely the one for whom the
enunciated and its enunciation totally overlap, so that whatever we intimately
know has already been confessed to him?

32

[99] 2014

. ,

.Ru. : 127006, ,
. , 20.
E-mail: yulimelamed@yandex.ru.
: , , , , , ,
.
:


.
,
.
.
.
.
,
,

.

THREE MOST NOTORIOUS


SUICIDES IN HISTORY.
SocratesKirillov
Malevich
Yulia Melamed. Director of documentaries, Gazeta.Ru columnist.
Address: 20 Malaya Dmitrovka str.,
127006 Moscow, Russia.
E-mail: yulimelamed@yandex.ru.
Keywords: Socrates, Kirillov, Kasimir
Malevich, Dostoevsky, Kharms, suicide, The Black Square.
The author deconstructs three rhyming plots in world history: the death
of Socratesthe suicide of Alexey
Kirillov in The PossessedThe
Black Square of Malevich. She
claims that in all the three episodes
a logical suicide has taken place.
An act became a notorious statement.
An act of self-sacrifice found its subject matter. The Death of the Author
became part of its logic. The author
also argues that Socrates moved
towards death deliberately, and we
are thus able to call his execution a
suicide.


33

, , , ,
: , , , . , . .
!
. , , , . - : , ,
! ( ). . , , :
, . , , , , . . :
,
, , ,
, .

, , , , - . (
: ,
?) 34

[99] 2014

. , . . ,
.
, , ()
, , , . , .
,
.
( ,
), :
! .
-? ; , ?
.
. !

,
. , ? ?

,
, . , , , , , ,
?..
- ,
, , .
, , .
. . .
, . , , ,
. , ,
.
. .

35

, . . .
. .
:
. .

, , ,
. . .
. , , , , , .
. , ( ) . .
, ,
, , .
.
, . ?
:
, ,
, . ,
.

, .
, , . . ,
- .
( ,
, , - ,
, , ),
36

[99] 2014

. .
, . , -,
, , , , , .
? : . .
.
, ,
. 399 .. . . , . . , . , .
, . 501 . .
, , , , , .
. (, ),
?
.
.
( ). .
, . , / ( ) , , , .
, all-inclusive.
.
. .
, ?
.
.
- , . - . , .

37

. . . ,
. . . .
, . .
, . . , . , , .
?
: , , , , .
, , ,
, , , , ,
, , .
.
.
,
, .
: ,
, , , . ,
.
, , , . ! ! .
. , ,
, :
,
, , , . ,,
, , ( ,
1876).

! !.. .
1876:

,
,

38

[99] 2014

, ,
, .

. ! . . ? .

: , , , .
, : .
, . ,
( ) ( )!
( )
(). (), (
) . . .
? , .
. ,
.
, , , .
. , ,
.
--: , .
( ).
.
. XIX.
( ). , ,
. , , . .
. , , , , , .

39

XX , .
.
, .
- . -
,
(, , ), (, ): ( ), . ,
. , , . ? .
, , :
, ,
. : ? . ? , ,
. , ? .
, . ,
.
, .
. ,
.
.
.
, , .
!

40

[99] 2014

.
,


.
: ,
., 8/2, . 312.
E-mail: ann.ganzha@gmail.com.
:
, , ,
.


.



.

- ,
,
,

,

.


:
,


.

THEMATIZATION OF TIME IN
SOVIET MASS SONG
Anna Ganzha. PhD in Philosophy,
Associate Professor at the School of Cul
tural Studies of the National Research
University Higher School of Economics.
Address: Room 312, 8/2 Maly Tryokh
svyatitelsky Pereulok, 109028
Moscow, Russia.
E-mail: ann.ganzha@gmail.com.
Keywords: soviet mass song, temporality,
universalism, memory models.
The ideal type of Soviet man, presented
in popular musical genres, is character
ized by radical novelty and constitutive
universalism, which is illustrated using
the material of Soviet songs about time,
understood not simply as a thematically
distinct genre. The history of the Soviet
as such can be read as the story of the
rise and intensification of reflection of
collective engagement into temporal cog
nition. In the period under review, from
the late twenties to the mid-sixties, you
receive a lot of songs, somehow fixing the
course of time: here we thematize not
just subjective experience of immersion
into an unordered medium of temporal
ity, but the presence of a sustainable and
rational order, to which this medium is
submitted.


41


(1958). , , -
,
, , , , , , . ,,
,
. .
, ,
.

? , ,
. , ,
, -


, 2013.

42

[99] 2014

. , ,
.
,
,, .
- , .
- , ,
, ,
. , -, : , , ,
. , .
.
, ,
, , , , ,
;
per se. : , , ,
, .
,
- ,
,
: , , , , , .

,

43

.
. <> , ( , , 1978)

. , ,

, .
.
. . , ,
(1929) . ,
, , , - : , ! , ! ,

:
,
.
: , - , , ,
.
: , ,
. , ,

.
, , , .
, ,
,
.
44

[99] 2014

,
, :
. <>
. <>
;
. . (
, , , .) <> . .
, , , . <> , , .
, , 1.

. , ,

, . , , ,
, . , , , . , , . - ,
. -,
, , .
, , , , ,,
1. . // .
. . .: , 1996.
.180182.

45

. - . ,
. -
( 1934) ( , !),
, - . ,
, .
, , ,
, .
,

. ,
, , . : , - .
, , , ,
, , :
, , ? ,
, ! (
, 1949). : ,
! , !
(
, 1951).

. , ,
:
, , , .
, ,
( , !, 1970).
, , , - , 46

[99] 2014

:
( , 1965). , ,
, , .
,
,
, ,
. , , . , .
, , . , , ,
, ,
. ,
,
.
, , : , . , , .
, . .
, .
, , : . , , .
. , , , ! ( , 1934);
,
(
, 1956); -, -,

47

-, - (
-,
1969); , , , , (
, 1964);
; , ,
( 31 1965); -, - . -,
- - ( -, 1976);
( , 1955);
. , .
! (
, 1979); , , , , , ;
. , , ( ).
, (
, ) - - ,
. , , ; , ; , ;
: .
, , , -, , - , , -
. , . , , ,
, .
48

[99] 2014

.
, , ,
, , , .
. , , . ,
, (1953)
- .
:
,
,

.
?
? ;
,
, .
,
,
, ,
, , .
, , ,
,

.
,
, ,
, .
, ,
,
, ,
.

, ,
! .
, . , ,
.

49

- , - , .
, , , ,
-, -.
, . ,
, , , , ,
,
, . - , , , , ,
. ,
-
, , . ,
, ,
, .
? , , . ,
,
, ! , , . ,
, , , -
, , , . , ,
, , .
- .
50

[99] 2014

, , ,
- .
, ,, .
, , ; ,
, , (!), .
,
, ,
,

. ,
, . ,
.
, .
,
( ), :
. , , , , ,, .

,
,
. , - -
, -. -: , ,

51

, -
, , , , , .


, .
, ,
, , - ,
,
, .
.
,
.
- ,


, .

. ,
( 1943
,
; ,
, , .; ;
) :
, ,
,
,
.

52

[99] 2014

, , ,
, ,
, ,
, , , .

, , , , 1980, : ,
, . ,
, : , , ,, , . , ,
: , (
,
1962) , , ( , 1962 - ; 10 : ! , ,
! , , !).
? (

, , 1958: , ! , . , ,
, ?).
, (1950):
, ,
, .
, ,
. , ,
,
, , . , , , ,

53

. ,
- ,

, .

. ,
- 19401950,
: . (
), ( ) ( ). - .
: , .
, , . :
, ,
, , .
, . ! :
, , , , , . -. , ,
. .
,
, . ?
, ,
,
. , , , 16- . : ,
. ,
( ). 54

[99] 2014

, , , , . :
, , . , , .
,
( ),
:
, ()
, ,
.
, -
. : , - , , .
, , . ,
, , .
, ,
. , , 1957. : , , ,
. . , , .
, ,
, , , ,
, .

55


, , , ( )
, , .
. ,
. ,

(1964). -,
,
. , (
, 1950). , , ? ? ( , 1958).
, ,
(
, 1962). ,
! , , ( , !
1960). : ,
, , ,
.
, ,
, ,,
. , . , ,
, . ,
: ,
,
.
,
,
56

[99] 2014

. . ,
, . , ,
.
. - , :
, (
, 1960).
, , ,
. ,

, .
.
, .
.

( , ),
, ( , ,
, ).

.
, , ,
. , . (1932)
. . , ( , 1926) ,
,
. [: ],
! (
, 1931) , .

57

(1949):
, !
(1957): , ,
,
. : ,
<> , (
, 1958).
:
, ( , 1954). ,
: ,
<> , , ! , (
, 1970).
, ,
, .
, , -, ;
, : , ! , ,
! (
, 1935). ,
, (
, 1960), ,
, , , , ? : , , ,
, , , (
, 1962).
, ,
( ), 58

[99] 2014

, ,
. ,
,
(
, 1941), , ,
, . , ,
, ( , ! , 1959),
(
, 1953), (
, 1960).
: ( , 1948), , , (
, 1944; ,
1964). , ( , 1950) , , -, ,
, , ,
.
( , 1958) , ( , 1960).
, , , ; .
( , 1960). , , , ,

59

( - ),
, , , (
, 1961). , ( ). , , , , , , .
- , . ,
( ) . , , 1964.
- : , ; . ,
; ,
, .
, :
, .
. -, ,
: ,
; .
,
1973, :
, , ,
(1926)
- , , , ,
! . (
,
60

[99] 2014

; .) ,

(1970): ,
. , , , ! ,
: ! (
, ! , , 1950 1960); ( , 1956); (
, 1962).
,
, ,
- , ,
. , .
,
, ,
: ( ) (
,
, :
), (, ,
, -
; , ,
,
,, , ,
).
, ( , ! ! ! ,
1947);

61

( ! ! , 1960; , , ! , , , ,
!
, 1962); ,
( !
,
!
, 1962).
,
. , 1960, , , .
- . : , - ; ,
, , ,
, , . , , ,

, . , : -
, , , , ,
,

. ( 62

[99] 2014

, ) , ,
. ( , , ,
,
1913.)
homo soveticus
;
, .
1965, , , , , . , ! (1932)
.
(1929) . , -
!
.
, , - .
; ,
2. , - . :
( , !)
1930, . :
, , ,
: , , ,
2. .: .. // .. . .:
, 2010. .283.

63

! -, -! -, ! ( ). ,
. (
: .)
. ,
( ),
. , . ,
. , , .
,
.

: ,
, , , , . ,
, ;

, . , , ,
,
,
. , .
( ).
: , ,
, , , , , 64

[99] 2014

.
, ,
.

.
, ,
:
,
,

, . .

1960
-:
, ,
; - , , .
.
. , ; ,
, , . ,
, - .
- , .
, , ,

65

, .
, , - . (
- , , , ,
,
..) :
, ; ,
.
, ,
,
- , - ,
. ,
: , , ,
. ,
, , ,
! .
.
, .
REFERENCES
BenjaminW. Moscow. Proizvedenie iskusstva v epokhu ego tekhnicheskoi vosproizvodimosti.
Izbrannye esse [The Work of Art in the Age of Mechanical Reproduction. Selected
essays], Moscow, Medium, 1996.
GladilinA.T. Ulitsa generalov [Street of generals]. Mech Tamerlana [Tamerlanes
sword], Moscow, RIPOL klassik, 2010.

66

[99] 2014

. ,

-
.
: 109651, ,
. , 9, . 2.
E-mail: hamster-70@mail.ru.
: , ,
, , .

.
, ,
, (docta ignorantia).
,
. ,
-,
, .
, ,
. ,
, .
,

,
.

ALEX ANDER VVEDENSKYS


ANTINOMY OF TIME
Tatyana Rezvikh. PhD in Philosophy,
Associate Professor at the Department of
Advanced Further Education of
the St.Tikhons Ortodox University.
Address: Bldg2, 9 Ilovayskaya str.,
109651 Moscow, Russia.
E-mail: hamster-70@mail.ru.
Keywords: time, eternity, consciousness,
duration, antinomy.
The problem of time is an essential topic in
Vvedenskys work. The uniqueness of the
poets approach to the problem of time follows the tradition of learned ignorance
(docta ignorantia). Time appears as a fundamental ontological characteristic, and
misunderstanding of time becomes the key
to misunderstanding all that exists. The
modern language created by OBERIU poets
can and has to open up the essence of time,
but its disclosure becomes its final misunderstanding. Seeking to leave the essence of
time undefined, the poet exhibits opposite
approaches to it, formulating antinomy.
Time is fluid and fractional, real and illusory, finite and infinite. Vvedensky offers
several different ladders to the concept of
time in order to finally reject all theses and
antithesises and to come closer to broad
misunderstanding. Thus, connecting antinomy does not bring about an understanding
of time, and time remains essentially
incomprehensible.


67

..
1. ,
, ,
., ., ., .., .
2.
,
. ,

1. ..
..// Russian Literature. 1978. VI -4; .. : . .. .: , 2002; . . .//
. ,
100- .. .: , 2004; .. . //
; . , . . // ; ..
, . ..
// ; . ..// ; . .// .
2. . // . 1991. 11; .-. . .: , 1995;
.. .//
. , 1998. .10; .. .: vs. // . : . . 2011. 2 (10); .-.
(
)// .-. . : . .:
, 2011.

68

[99] 2014

.., 1918
..3. 1922 1923
4,
.. ...
,
, , .
,
5. XIXXX ,
,
.
6.
,
,
. 14
1922, ,
:
,
, ,
. ,
, , ,
, .
[]
7
8.

,
. ,
3. , : ., .,
., ., .: , : 2 ./ . . ... .: , 2000. .1. .8.
4. .: . .1.
5. .. //
. 1913. .117; . .
. .: .., 1918;
. // . 1922. 3.
6. .., .., .., .., .., .., ..,
.., . .., .., ... .:
// . ., 1910. .V . .121156.
7. : .
8. . .252. .2. . . 933. .55.

69

9
.
19201930
( 19331934)
. ,
.

,
.
,
,
, , .
,
. , (1931)
:


, , 10.

( 1932 1933)
,
11. :
, , ,
, . . (1) ,
- ,
,
. (2)
,
.
.
, , -
,
,
9. . . . . . : 2 ./ .
.., ... .: , 2002. .1.
.23. , , , , ,
.
10. . / . .. .: , , 1999. .201.
11. . . . .: 2 ./ . . . ., .
. ., . . .: , 1993. .2. .83.

.

70

[99] 2014

,
,
12.

..:
,
, , ,
, , ( )13.
,
(docta ignorantia), ,

.
,
, .
,
, ,
. ,
, .

:

.
. .
, , ,
.
,
.
. ,
, ,
. . 14.

, ,
,
, ,
12. . .79.
13. .. . .: , 1996. .89.
14. . . . .2. .80.

71

15.

16.
,
,
.
,
. ,
, <>17.
, , .
, , 18.
: ,
, , (
)19. ,

, ,

.
, .
: ,
, ,
-
,
20.
,
.
,
21,
15. . : .. - // .., .
. .: , 2000.
16. . . 229a 25// . .: 4 ./ . ...
.: , 19751984. .3. .150.
17. .. . 1933 1934// .. / ., . , . ... .: , 1999. .50.
18. . . . .2. .78.
19. . / . . ., ., .
.. .: , 2003. .99.
20. . . / . ... : , 1999. .740.
21. . .742.

72

[99] 2014

.
, ; ,

.
, ,
,
.
, .

, .
:
,

22. ,
.
,

, ,
, .
,
, .
,
.

, , ,
. ,
23. ,
24
, ,
.
(1929).
. 1929
(;
) ()
( , ).
,
, :
22. . .757.
23. . . . .2. .83.
24. . .84.

73


.

25.

,
, .

26.

:
,
, ,
, , ,
27.

,
, , ,
- 28. , ,

,
.

,
. ,
, , .
,
,
, . . ? . ?
. . 8
, 10 .
. . . 29.
30. ,
25. . . .136.
26. .
27. . . . .2. .77.
28. . .81.
29. . .2. .78.
30. .

74

[99] 2014

,
.
, ,

- , - -.
, .


:
, .
31. , ,
,
(, , ,
).

. , .

, .
, ,
. , , ,
, ,
32.

(1927),
33. ,
, :
.
, . , .
. 34.
,
. ,
, , .

, - . ,
31. .
32. . .2. .81.
33. . / . ... .: Ad Marginem, 1997.
.349.
34. . . . .2. .81.

75

; ,
.
: ,
.

, ,
. ,
:
. .
, .
. ,

- , (
,
), ,
. . . :
( )35.

, , ,
, . ,
,
. , ,
.
: (1) ,
; (2) .
: ,

,
,
, :
. :
, , , .
,

35. . . . .2. .8081.

76

[99] 2014

36.
( ), , .

(1929).
,
.
- .
,
, -
.

.

,
37.

38. ,

( )
( ).
.
:
? - .
, , 39.
,
. .
, , , ,
: , , , ,
. :
40.


: .
,
36. . / . . . .., ..,
. . .., ... .: , 2010.
.207.
37. , . .1. .494.
38. .: , , , < >// . .I .
39. .. . .255, 245.
40. . .245.

77

: ,
, . , , ,
, ,
, 41.

,
,
42. ,
- .
.
. , ,
43.
, :
,
.
.

, - , ,
, . ,
. , ,
.
. (1941). ,
, , ,
, .

, , (19311932).
, ( , )
( , ).
, -,
, ,
. .
. .
. .
, ,
, ,
41. , . .2. .54.
42. . . . .: , 1995.
43. . . . .2. .80.

78

[99] 2014

. .
. 44.

,
, , .
:



( ).

, , :
. :
. . .
45. , :
, ,
-, ,
. (
).
(), .
, .
, ,
. :
. ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
( ).

.


( ).


44. . .85.
45. . .78.

79




( , 19291930).

, , , .
.
.


,
. ( , ,
), ( ),
, ,
, .


( ).


. , ,
. , :
, (
), ,/
( ).
,
,
.
,
.
.
.
( ).

: / , , ,
, -
. .
, : , /
( ),
80

[99] 2014

/ ( ).
,
( ) .
, .


(19311934), ,
.

:


.

,
.

, ,
(
):
.
,
.

,
. , ,
:

, , .


:

,
,

,
, , .

81

: , ,
, , .
:

.

.


, ,
, . ,
, ().
,
, , :


,
.



.

,
:



,
( ).

(), ,
, ,
( , ), .

, ,
:

.
,
.

.

82

[99] 2014

:


.


,

,

.


:

.

, ,
. , ,
( ). ,
: /
/ (
). /
( , ).
( )46.
:
,
,
.

, ,
: ,
, .

:
,
,
,
, .

46. (19331934).

83

,
, .
,
, :
.





,

.

?

,
, :
,
,

.

, .
, :
,

,
;



.

.
,
, - , - , , ,
. 47:
,

.
47. . . . .2. .81.

84

[99] 2014

,
.


,
, ,
. (1930
1931) ,
-
. , ,
, ,
,
48 . , ,
49.
.
: . : .
, ,
, , .
: . :
. ,
:
, , , ,
, .
, .
, ,
(. 103).

, , , .
.
, , , :
.
,
, :



48. . .80.
49. .

85



(, 1928).








( , 1930).


:







50.

: . : .
: . :
. ,
, ,
, ,
. ,
, .
: . :
. : ()
(). : . :
. :
. : . :
.
.
: . :
. , ,
, . : .
: -. .
50. , , .

86

[99] 2014

: . :
. .
(
). .
.: ,
, : , ,
(. 8:5). , ,
, , , .
: - (
). : .
: (1)
-
; (2) ;
(3) ,
,
, .
(1932?)
(
) (
).
,

.
( )
, , .

. :
, ,
, , ,
.
.
:
.
.
,
, .

:

.

87


.
(19361937)
, , .
:
, , .

.

.
, (
)
,
.
, .
(, , )
, . ,
,
, .

.
, .
( -
, , ,
, , )
, , , ,
, , :
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .

,
, .
,
,
,
88

[99] 2014

. .
. , .
()51.
(1938)
,
- , ,
, .
1 82 .
. :
, .

.
,

.
: .

,
.

, , :
.
. ,
,
(. (19601970)),
,
: ,
, ,
docta ignorantia, , , , 52.
,
53. .
. ..

, 54.
51. , . .1. .222.
52. . .46.
53. . .335.
54. . .770.

89

, , ,
, . .,
, , ,

( 1 2 (1934),
(1934), (1937)),
, :
,
,
, ,
,
. , ,
,
,
55.

,
,
56.
,
,
( 57),
, . ,
(1936)
. ,
, , , .
, . , (
, ), :
. ,
, ,
- , .
?
? , .
, ,
. 58.
55. .
. .1//
1310. : . 1999. 3 (9). .92.
56. . . . . .2. .56.
57. , . .1. .231.
58. . .614.

90

[99] 2014

,
,
.
, . 11 1944
:
, <>.
.
. :
59. ,
() ,
. , , . ,

, , .
, ,
,
60.
, , , (
).
,
, ,
. ,
,
,
, , -

,61 ,
,
.
,
: , ,
:
;
, , 62. , .
, , ..63.
59. . . .189. .: . .220.
60. , . .1. .610.
61. . .: 6 ..: , 19631966. .3. .581.
62. . // . .: 2 ..: ,
19791980. .1. .76.
63. .. . // ..

91

,
,
.
,
.
,
, .

, . ,
:


,
.




( , ).



, ,
. ,
,
.
REFERENCES
Sborishche druzei, ostavlennykh sudboiu: A.Vvedensky, L.Lipawski, Ia. Druskin,
D.Kharms, N.Oleynikov: Chinari v tekstakh, dokumentakh i issledovaniiakh: v 2 t.
[Bunch of friends destiny abandoned: A.Vvedensky, L.Lipawski, Ia. Druskin,
D.Kharms, N.Oleynikov. Chinari in the texts, documents and studies: in 2
vols] (ed. V.N.Sazhin), Moscow, Ladomir, 2000, vol.1.
Aristotel. The Physics. Sochineniia: v 4 t. [Works in 4 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 1981, vol.3.
Askoldov S.A.Soznanie kak tseloe. Psikhologicheskoe poniatie lichnosti [Consciousness as
a whole. Psychological concept of personality], Moscow, Tovarishchestvo tipografii A.I.Mamontova, 1918.
Askoldov S.A.Vremia i ego preodolenie [Time and its negotiation]. Mysl, 1922, no.3.

. .: 2 ..: , .: , 1999. .1.


.139140.

92

[99] 2014

Askoldov S.A.Vremia i ego religioznyi smysl [Time and its religious meaning]. Voprosy filosofii i psikhologii [Questions of Philosophy and Psychology], 1913, vol.117.
BergsonH. Tvorcheskaia evoliutsiia. Materiia i pamiat [Lvolution cratrice. Matire
et mmoire] (trans. B.S.Bychkovskii), Minsk, Kharvest, 1999.
BulgakovS.N. Svet Nevechernii. Sozertsaniia i umozreniia [Unfading Light. Contemplation and speculation]. Pervoobraz i obraz. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Foretype and type.
Works in 2 vols], Moscow, Iskusstvo, Saint Petersburg, INAPRESS , 1999, vol.1.
Druskin Ia. O schastlivoi zhizni. 1933 iiul 1934 [On happy life. 1933 July 1934].
Dnevniki [Diaries] (ed. L.S.Druskina), Moscow, Akademicheskii proekt, 1999.
FlorenskyP. Analiz prostranstvennosti i vremeni v khudozhestvenno-izobrazitelnykh
proizvedeniiakh [Analysis of spacetime in the visual works]. Stati i issledovaniia po istorii i filosofii iskusstva i arkheologii [Articles and research on the history
and philosophy of art and archeology], Moscow, Mysl, 2000.
FrankS. Russkoe mirovozzrenie [Russian worldview], Saint Petersburg, Nauka, 1996.
HeideggerM. Bytie i vremia [Sein und Zeit] (trans. V.V.Bibikhin), Moscow, Ad Marginem, 1997.
JaccardJ.-Ph. Daniil Kharms i konets russkogo avangarda [Daniil Harms et la fin de
lavant-garde russe], Moscow, Akademicheskii proekt, 1995.
JaccardJ.-Ph. Krizis tekuchesti v kontse Serebrianogo veka (OLeonide Lipavskom
i ego pokolenii) [Crisis of fluidity at the end of the Silver Age (OnLeonid
Lipawsky and his generation)]. Literatura kak takovaia. Ot Nabokova k Pushkinu: Izbrannye raboty o russkoi slovesnosti [Literature as such. From Nabokov
to Pushkin: Selected works on Russian literature], Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2011.
KantI. Sochineniia: v 6 t. [Works in 6 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 19631966, vol.3.
KharmsD. Dnei katybr [Katybr of days] (ed. M.Meilakh), Moscow, Kaienna, Gileia, 1999.
KharmsD. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii. Zapisnye knizhki. Dnevnik: v 2 kn. [Complete
Works. Notebooks. Diary: in 2 vols] (eds J.-Ph.Jaccard, V.N.Sazhin), Saint Petersburg, Akademicheskii proekt, 2002, vol.1.
KharmsD. Sluchai i veshchi [Cases and things] (eds A.Dmitrenko, V.Erl), Saint Petersburg, Vita Nova, 2003.
KierkegaardS. Strakh i trepet [Fear and Trembling] (eds S.A.Isaev, I.A.Ebanoidze),
Moscow, Kulturnaia revoliutsiia, 2010.
KobrinskiiA. Poetika OBERIU v kontekste russkogo literaturnogo avangarda. Ch.1
[Poetics of OBERIU in the context of Russian literary avant-garde]. Uchenye zapiski Moskovskogo kulturologicheskogo litseia 1310. Seriia: Filologiia [Proceedings of the Moscow Lyceum of cultural studies no.1310. Series: Philology], 1999,
no.3 (9).
KobrinskiiA. Sistema organizatsii prostranstva v poeme Aleksandra Vvedenskogo
Krugom vozmozhno Bog [System of organization of space in the poem of Alexander Vvedensky Perhaps God is All Around]. Teatr [Theater], 1991, no.11.
KolevatykhG. Poetika vremeni u V.Khlebnikova i A.Vvedenskogo [Poetics of time of
V.Khlebnikov and A Vvedensky]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander Vvedensky and Russian Avant-garde. Proceedings of the international scientific conference devoted to the 100th anniversary of
the birth of A.Vvedensky], Saint Petersburg, PT s SPGUDT , 2004.
KuvshinovF. Motiv muzyki v tvorchestve A.I.Vvedenskogo [Music motif in the work
of A.I.Vvedensky]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander Vvedensky and Russian avant-garde. Proceedings of the in-

93

ternational scientific conference devoted to the 100th anniversary of the birth of


A.Vvedensky], Saint Petersburg, PT s SPGUDT , 2004.
LucarelliG. G. Oglianis, mir mertsaet. A.Vvedensky i kinematograficheskoe izobrazhenie razdroblennosti vremeni [Look back, the world twinkls. A.Vvedensky and cinematic representation of fragmentation of time]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander Vvedensky and
Russian avant-garde. Proceedings of the international scientific conference devoted to the 100th anniversary of the birth of A.Vvedensky], Saint Petersburg,
PT s SPGUDT , 2004.
LucarelliG.G. Aleksandr Vvedensky. Samoubiistvo kak begstvo k Bogu [Aleksandr Vvedensky. Suicide as a flight to God]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander Vvedensky and Russian avantgarde. Proceedings of the international scientific conference devoted to the 100th
anniversary of the birth of A.Vvedensky], Saint Petersburg, PT s SPGUDT , 2004.
Nicholas of Cusa. Ob uchenom neznanii [On Learned Ignorance]. Sochineniia: v 2 t.
[Works in 2 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 19791980, vol.1.
RevzinaO. G. Kachestvennaia i funktsionalnaia kharakteristika vremeni v poezii
A.I.Vvedenskogo [Qualitative and functional characteristics of the time in poetry of A.I.Vvedensky]. Russian Literature, 1978, vol.VI , no.4.
SaboB. Gost na kone A.Vvedenskogo [Guest on a horse by A.Vvedensky]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard. Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander
Vvedensky and Russian avant-garde. Proceedings of the international scientific
conference devoted to the 100th anniversary of the birth of A.Vvedensky], Saint
Petersburg, PT s SPGUDT , 2004.
ShevchenkoE.S. Elka u Ivanovykh A.Vvedenskogo: buffonnoe vs. tragediinoe
[A.Vvedenskys New Years Eve at Ivanovs: buffoon vs. tragic]. Vestnik Samarskoi gumanitarnoi akademii. Seriia: Filosofiia. Filologiia [Bulletin of the Samara Academy of Humanities. Series: Philosophy. Philology], 2011, no.2 (10).
Spor o pragmatizme [Debates on the Pragmatism]. Russkaia mysl [Russian thought],
1910, vol.V , pp.121156.
TillichP. Izbrannoe. Teologiia kultury [Selected Works. Theology of Culture], Moscow, Iurist, 1995.
Tokarev D.V. Kurs na khudshee: Absurd kak kategoriia teksta u D.Kharmsa i S.Bekketa [Course on worst: Absurd as a category of text in D.Kharms and S.Beckett],
Moscow, Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie, 2002.
Valieva Iu.M. Iazykovaia kartina mira u A.Vvedenskogo [A. Vvedenskys linguistic
worldimage]. Filologicheskie zapiski [Philological notes], Voronezh, 1998, iss.10.
VeststeinV.G. Absurd, smert i Bog. Neskolko zamechanii o pese A.I.Vvedenskogo
Elka u Ivanovykh [Absurd, death and God. Some remarks on the Alexander Vvedenskys play New Years Eve at Ivanovs]. Aleksandr Vvedensky i russkii avangard.
Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii, posviashchennoi 100-letiiu so dnia
rozhdeniia A.Vvedenskogo [Alexander Vvedensky and Russian avant-garde. Proceedings of the international scientific conference devoted to the 100th anniversary of the birth of A.Vvedensky], Saint Petersburg, PTs SPGUDT, 2004.
VvedenskyA.Polnoe sobranie proizvedenii: v 2 t. [Complete works in 2 vols] (eds
M.Meilakh, Vl.Erl), Moscow, Gileia, 1993, vol.2.

94

[99] 2014

,
()

.


.
: 125252, ,
. , 21.
E-mail: vladnik65@mail.ru.
: ,
, , ,
, , ,
.


,
(
)
,
.

:
,
.

.,

,
:
() ().
,

,
,
.

THE MIRROR, THE CLOCK AND


PHILOSOPHY (OFTECHNOLOGY)
Vladimir Nikitaev. Expert of the
Centre for International Industrial
Cooperation in the Russian Federation.
Address: 21b Kuusinen str.,
Moscow 125252, Russia.
E-mail: vladnik65@mail.ru.
Keywords: philosophy of technology,
ontology, schema, Neo-Platonism, magic
of things, power, organ projections, ana
lytical psychology.
This article is devoted to the role of tech
nology in European culture and philoso
phy, namely an application of mirror and
clock (automaton) images and operating
principles in the capacity of interpreta
tion, reflection and ontology schemata.
The scope of the analysis covers a wide
range of cultural history from antiquity
to the early 20th century, from daily life
to great philosophical doctrines. The ori
gin of the philosophy of technology is
considered in detail, especially Ernst
Kapps conception of organ projections.
This conception combines both funda
mental schemata: mechanical (clock)
and catoptric (mirror). On the one hand,
the conception has produced an impor
tant effect on modern culture, but on the
other hand it hid some socially signifi
cant issues which need to be considered
carefully.


95

.
1

() , ,

f(x). .
; , , , , .
() ()

(-) .
. ,
,
.

, - , , , 1. ., ., ., . . .:
, 1925. .117.

96

[99] 2014

sui generis.
, ,
, , , ,
.
2 ,
- XVII .
,
, , , ,
.
-
3, ,
.

Homo faber making-tools animal, , , . ,
, - ,
. ,

. , , ,
. , , ,
, .
2.

.
3. .. : , , ,
. .: , 2011.

97


(18551942) XVIII XIX
,
(18081896).
,
, Grundlinien einer
Philosophie der Technik (1877). (40 , , The Philosophy of Manufactures),
,
4, .
,
. , ()
,
. , , , 5. ,
, ,
, (, ),
6. Homo ex machina
7 :
4. .. // . 2013. 3. .6879.
5. .. XIX . .: .., 1898; . . .II . . .,
1912; .. :
XIX XX . .: , 2009. C.1112.
6. . : // . 2006.
11. .145156.
7. .. Homo ex machina ( .
)// . 2010. 1. .2250.

98

[99] 2014

, , , , , Deus ex machina,
8.

()
/ , , , , 9.
,
10. - , , ,

,
. , , , ,
, , , , 11

. () : , - .
, ( ). , , , , ,
: , , , ,
--, .. ,
,
.
8. . : . Homo mensura: // . .: , 1989. .398399.
9. .. : . .: --, 2003.
10. .: . . .: , 1995. .107112.
11. .-.Corpus. .: Ad marginem, 1999. C.236.

99

:
,

( ), XIX , :
Maja, , , , . magus (),
magia (), magic (), image (), imagination () , ,
12.


, , ()
. , ,
,
( ) (1891). , , (
13), , ,
.

14. , ( , ) 15. ,
. ,
12. .. . .: . , 1876. C.27.
13. .. . .: , 2000.
C.182, 254, 291.
14. ., .: .. . ., 2006.
15. .. : . .: , 1983. C.186187.

1 00

[99] 2014

, , ,
. , , 16. ,
17.
, , ,
( , ), 18. ,
,
, , .
, ( ) () 19. ,
,
. .

, (),
().
, , (/)
; 20. , ,

, : ( ) .
, , ();
, 16. - . . .: , 2006. C.287304.
17. . .356358.
18. ., .: . , ..
// . .5. 1997. C.200203.
19. . . .596d.
20. Enn II .4, 5. . : . : 7 ./ . .., ... .: - , 2004.

101

, , ,
, 21.
, :
, , . 22.

:
, (,
) ( ), ( ) .
:
( ), () .
:
, (. . .),
, , - , , ;
, , , , 23.

, , 24, sui generis.


,
.

: -
. , : ,
21. Enn II .4, 5.
22. Enn IV .3, 9.
23. Enn III .6, 7.
24. .. - // . 1978. 1. .155156.

1 02

[99] 2014

, , ,
25. , (, ), 26.
.
-, doctor universalis (1128
1203), XII
XV, , , , , . , (Speculum
Scripturae), (speculum naturae) (speculum creaturae); ,
(speculum rationis, sensuabilitis et carnis); (specul providentiae), (specula
circumspectionis) (specula cautelae). :
, (per triplex
speculam pervenis ad triplex specular) ,
27.

, ,
.
/
(14011464). ,

28, , , ,
25. // . , , , , IXIV . .: , 1996. .21.
26. ., .: - .. .; .., .. .
.; .. . // AKADHMEIA . . ., 2000. .3. .192214; .. . .
27. .. C.208209.
28. . .: 2 ..: , 19791980. .1. .64.

103

,
29.
, , ,
, . / ()
complicatio/ explicatio,
. , ,
30;
( ) :
, ,
, - , , , , ,
31, , :
.
, 32

, , ( ) , ,
, .,
, ,
, ,, , 33. (specularis)
, 34,
35.


. , 29. . . . .1. .101.
30. . .106.
31. ( ) , , (.: - . . . .2835).
32. . . . .1. .325326.
33. . .2. .67.
34. . .50.
35. . .1. .404.

1 04

[99] 2014

() ( ), ( ) .
:

, , :
, , ,
, ,
.
,
( ),
36.

: ,
( ) sui generis. () , ,
, 37,
,
, , 38. ,
(machines) , 39. ,
, ,
,
( ), 40.
,
- .
XVIII, ,
, ,
, ,
36. .-. .: 4 ..: , 1982. T.1. C.428. . .273.
37. . .416, 424.
38. . C.275.
39. . C.276.
40. . C.428.

105

, 41.
( ), perpetuum
mobile, , , ( ) , 42.
, , :
, ,
, , , . <>
. , ,
, ,
, 43.

, specular,
44. , ,
, :
. ,
.
, , : , , ,, ,
, . ,
, ( ) , ,
45 ( . . .).
41. .-. . . T.1. C.515.
42. . C.430432.
43. . . : - , 1997.
C.9.
44. .: , ,
, (- C.. . .211).
45. ... . .1. . .:
, 1974. C.265.

1 06

[99] 2014

Opus magnum
(1818) 30 / , : ,
, ,
, 46 ..
, ( )
. , ,
, , : , .. , , ,
, , , , .
, ,
. ,
, (), , , ,
. , , , , 47.

. , , , ( )48;
, , ,
49.

46. . .: 6 .M.: TEPPA ; , 19992001. T.1. C.151, 160,


166, 217.
47. . .: 2 ..: , 1995. .2. .75, 171.
48. ., . . .: , 19551981. .23. .62, 68.
49. . .82.

107

, ,
, XVXVII
. , , , . , ,
, , ,
, .
,
():
, , ,
,
, ,
. <> , ,
, ; , ,
, , 50.

XVIII , , 51.
XVII, 52. , ,
. , . 50. - C.. . .208209.
51. . . . .: Ad Marginem, 1999.
C.292306, 317330.
52. - C.. . .229231, 238.

1 08

[99] 2014

,
,

. , ,
, , , , 53.
, civilitate (
XVI ), civilisation civiliser XVIII ,
ancien rgime 54. , -
()
politesse polic . , , ,
.
, ,

( ),
sui generis / ;
.
; , ,
, .
53. , -: , , , , , . ,
(- C. . . .238).
.
54. . .
. 2 .., .: . , 2001. T.1. C.9597, 111113.

109

,
, , , /, .

:
, , , . ,
, ,
, . : , : , 55.
,
.
56, , , .
, , . , ( , ),
. (. 1400), , , ,
, , , , . ,
XIV. . , 57.
55. . : . : , .
: - -, 2002. .75.
56. . C.56.
57. . C.5154.

1 10

[99] 2014

, ,

, ( ) .
, .
XIII XIV,
, , , , , XV.
,
, , 58. , () :
59. XVIII

-

: Time is money ( , 1748).
( )
,
, 60.
. ,

, , . , 1370
V , ; 61.
58. .. . .:
, 1982. .144.
59. . .192193.
60. .. . . .166, 174175.
61. . . . .5556.

111

XV , , , , .
,
(, 1542 ,
). XVI XVII
62.
XVI
, , . .
( ), , . , ,
, XVII
, , ,
, ,
. , , ,
.. , .
, : , , , 63.
, XVII
XVIII . 1863,
,
, :
, XVIII
(
) . ,
62. .. . . .173, 180.
63. . .173.

1 12

[99] 2014

64.

, ,
65. , ,
66. ,
, , , 67. , , ,
68. ,
, .

,
: , ,
.
, , ,
() ,
. ,
, . , (timetables)
, , 69.
64. ., . . T.30. C.263.
65. MumfordL. Technics and civilization. L.: Harcourt, Brace & Company, 1934. P.14.
66. Ibid. P.12.
67. . . . .: , 2001.
.345348.
68. . .350, 357.
69. .. , // . 2013. 7. .9961003.

113


mchina, . , .., :
(1), , ( ); (2) ,
, , ; (3) . , , ,
;
, .
, , , ,
, , , . , ,
, - ,
70.
, - , , (, ),
71.
(I ..) : , (

), .72
, (III
..). , , 73.
,
XIIIXIV , , , 70. . . .: , 1995. C.91, 92.
71. . . .; .: , 1934; Huffman C.A. Archytas of
Tarentum. Pythagorean, Philosopher and Mathematician King. Cambridge:
Cambridge University Press, 2005. P.7683.
72. . . . .6162, 6567.
73. . .182, 188197.

1 14

[99] 2014

, .
(15001585), , , ,
V ( )
, ,
, 1800 . ,
. , , ( );
74. XVIII , , , - ,
, 75.
1550
1650 :
(. . .)
, , 76.

: , ,
, .
, 77.

, , : , 74. . . .: . .-. -, 1933.
.1. C.126128.
75. .. . . .2. .:
, 2004. C.158162.
76. The Clockwork universe: German clocks and automata, 15501650/ K.Maurice,
O.Mayr (eds). N.Y.: Neale Watson Academic Publications, 1980. P.IX .
77. ., .: . .: 2 ..: , 1989. .1. C.282, 345, 484; .2.
.210, 575.

115

, ,
78.
, , , , . 1747 -
( ,
,
) , , , .
, , , , ,
. ,
:
, .
, .
, ,
, , , ;
,
- 79.

, , XVIII ,
, , . ,
, 80.
78. .-.. T.1. C.321, 371.
79. .. -// .. . .: , 1976.
.236.
80. . . . .: , 1988. C.438, 482, 503, 508, 515.

1 16

[99] 2014

,
?
? , ? , ,
(, XVIIXVIII ). , ,
,
: , , , .
perpetuum mobile ,
.

(deus sive natura): , , , . ,
, ,
Perpetuum mobile. <> , , , 81.


,
(. . 1460)82. ,

. (1614
1672), ,
, , ,
( ), , , 83. ,
, , -
81. . // . . . .:
, 1995. .483484.
82. - . ( ). .: , 1980. C.3539.
83. . C.42, 4952, 256.

117

(, , ,
(1686), ).
perpetuum mobile
,
12401251. , ( ,
, ) 84, , .
, (,
), 85, 86
.
, perpetuum mobile,
, , 60 XVIII ,
, ,
, ( )87.
,
,
88.
, perpetuum mobile, , . ,
primum mobile , . 84. , , :
,
, , , ,

(. : . .256).
85. . . . .156157, 173174.
86. . .260264.
87. - .. . .172188.
88. . .189203.

1 18

[99] 2014

: ,,
89.
VS

, ,
() 90 , - , . ,

XVIII91. , ,
.
, , : (1) , : ,
; (2) ,
. XVIII
XIX ( ), , , ,
, , 89. , , XVII
.
, , . , , , , ,
, , ,
(. : .. . .: , 1988. C.66).
90. , , ; , , .
91. XVIII
, ,
, . (- .. . .132140).

119

92. , ,
,
, . - ,
, , ,
- (, ).

. ,
, - , , - , . , -
, .
,
.
, .
: ,
/
, . ,
.
, , , ;
.
93,
94.
92. . .280283, 354; .. :
// . 2006. 3. .1937.
93. , , - : , , -

1 20

[99] 2014

;
, , .
, , (1719),
, 95, , , ,
,
96. ,
( -, ,
). - , 97. , , XVI
, , , ,
98. -
, , ,
.
, ,
. XVIII, , ,
, ( .
(. ..)// . . 2012. .6.2. .411412).
94. .. . . .: , 2002. C.113.
95. . // . 2010. 1. .207.
96. .., .. . .: -, 1998.
.113.
97. .
( .. . . .1559).
98. . .142.

121

. , ,
, , . , ,
, ,
, , , :
, (), 99.
, , ;
, . , -100 , ,
( ),
, .

, 1818101;
.
( ,
)

,
, , ( ). , ( ),
Homo sapiens,
99. . . . .4849.
100. - .. . .383395.
101. - , , : ,
, ,, ,
. , .

1 22

[99] 2014

Homo faber. , , : ?102


,
.
(1877)
.
,
- , ,
103. ,
, , :
,
,
, , , , , ,
, .
. ,
, ,
;
, ,

,
, , ,
, , 104.

,
,
(organische Vorbilder),
102. .. .: 4 ..: , 2000. .3 (1). .377.
103. ., ., ., . . . .23.
104. . .2324.

123

,
. ,
, , , .
, .

, ,
, .. 105
.
, 1855 (Principles of psychology) .
, , , , , , 106.
, . ?
()?
, ?
,
107.
, . .
105. , . (17981857), -, , (18201903) .
,
( ), .
106. ., ., ., . . . .39.
107. .

1 24

[99] 2014

, , ,
, , ..
,
.
, , . , , :
,
, ,
; , :
, 108.

(18271897) (1880),
, ( ) . , .
. ( ),
XIX .
:
. : , 109,
110. , , ; :
108. . C.124.
109. ., .: ., ., ., . . . .124.
110. . .25.

125

projicere , , . ,
. , ,
, , , (objicere)111.

:
: ,
112.

, ,
, :
113 (,
: ). :

, .
,
114.

, , , ( , , ..
). , , ,
, , ,
.
, , .. .
111. ., ., ., . . . .37.
112. .
113. . C.118.
114. .. . . .421.

1 26

[99] 2014

,
, . , , .
, XX, .

? , , , 115. ,
( , ).
, , ,
. , , , ,
, 116. ,
( ) - , .
, , , ( ), , , 117.
,
, , , 118.
, , ,
,
. ,
, , 115. .
116. .. . . .383.
117. ., ., ., . . . .2324.
118. . C.101.

127

, , .

( ,
119),
. ,
, , , ( ) (17891869). , ,
/120. ,
, , , , 121.
- , , , . , (
) , , ,
, ,
, , . (
) 122,
, , ; , , ; ,
, ..123 ,

(1869)
119. . . . .2. .34.
120. .. //
, , XIIIXIX .
.: , 1999. .716717.
121. .. . // , , .723, 730.
122. . . . .1. .105.
123. . .2. .216.

1 28

[99] 2014

, , .
,
,
. , , ,
, ,
, 124.
,
, (,
).
, .
, ,
,
, .
, , , , ,
, 125. , , , ( ), 126.

, , par excellence.
?
, , ? , , ,
124. . Homo mensura: // . .: , 1989. .398.
125. . . . .75.
126. . .76.

129

, , ? (18811963), ,
, , (, ) , ,
, ,
.
, ,

?..
, . , , :

, ,
, . , ,

127.

. :

,
, , , ; ,
, 128.

, :
, , 129.

127. . . . .402.
128. . .403.
129. .

1 30

[99] 2014

, , ( ), ,
, ,
, sui generis.
, , ,
,
,
XIX , , .
, , ( I, 129-).
. ,
, 130; , , . , , ; ,
. ? (, )131. , (, , ).

,
,
, . ,
;
, [
] . ,
, ,
, , 132.

,
. ,
, ,
, , ( )
130. Enn IV .3, 21, 26.
131. . 22, 23.
132. Enn IV .3, 10.

131

( ). : , 133.
, , , , , .
():
: , , , , ,
134.


, , .
: , ,
(); , , , (), (), () .
(
, 135), , (, ) ,
(). ,
, , ,
, , , ,
136. , ,
, , ( ) ,
.
,
per se, . , : , 133. Enn IV .4, 10.
134. Enn IV .3, 23.
135. Enn, IV .3, 22.
136. EnnI .1, 9.

1 32

[99] 2014

, , ,
, , , :
, , , , -
, 137.

, , par excellence138,
, 139. , ,
, , . : Homo sapiens Homo faber, , , .
?
, , , , -
. , [] ,
, ,
.
, .
, 140

, ,
Homo sapiens Homo faber , .
:
( , ).
, , ,
, ,
137. EnnI .1, 3.
138. . 8.
139. .. : . .: - , 2005.
C.158, 175180.
140. Enn IV .3, 31.

133

, ( , ).
, , ,
141. , /, ,
, ( , , ).
,
, , , , .
, ,
, , 142.
,
, . , , ,
() ; ( ), ,
.
Homo faber ( ) Homo sapiens, , . ,
,
( , ); : , , . ,
[] 143.
:

, , ,,
; 141. , (. .
. .2. C.225).
142. . .1. .122123.
143. . .135.

1 34

[99] 2014

,
homo homini lupus144.

:
, ,
, .
, 145.

, , , , , .
, , ,
( ),

,
. , , ( ).
, , , ,
, , , . ,
, 146.
, , , , , ,
,
147 (.
). , ,
, ,
corpus, , -

144. . .137.
145. . .142.
146. . .1. C.299; T.2. C.500501; T.3. C.455.
147. . .3. C.255.

135

148. , ,
.. , ,

, .
,
, ,
(,
, ) ,
, ()
.
, ,
, ; ( , ) 149 . , ,
150,
,
( ) an
sich 151 . , ,
, (
). , ,
/, : , 152, 148. .
149. ,
: , .
150. .. // .. . .: , 2002.
.19.
151. . .3. .59, 64.
152. . . . .: ,
2009. C.18, 311.

1 36

[99] 2014

153, 154 .. ,
,
, , 155. , , , , ,
, , ( )
() 156.
,
,
, ; . ,
1946
an sich ( ) . , . , ,
, , ( ),
, , , ,
157. , an sich
.
, , , ( ,
). (das Selbst)
, 158. , 153. . . . .:
, 1997. C.100.
154. .. C.3842.
155. . // .. . .: , 1991. .209.
156. . // .. . .:
, 1993.
157. . C.5961, 69, 78; . // .. . .: , 1991.
.9899.
158. . . . .40.

137


. , :
, ,
, ;
, 159.

, ,
. , ,
, , : complexio
oppositorum ( ), . ( ) ,
,
( ) .
:
( ), lumen naturalle ,
, ,, 160.
, Homo faber Homo sapiens (), , . : , 161, ?
imago
Dei , ( , )162. ().
, , ,
, ,
159. .. . .: , 2008. C.44.
160. ., .: . . . .103104.
161. .. .215.
162. . . C.44, 4983.

1 38

[99] 2014

163.
, ( Lapis Philosophorum) (, , , , ),
.
( . . .) , , , 164.

, ,

, :
, .
,
(), , .., 165. , , , ,
, . perpetuum mobile166. .
, , , ;
( ) ( ). , , , , ,
. , .
, ,
imago Dei, ,
, , , .

-
,
163. . .44.
164. . .263.
165. . C.4345.
166. . // .. . .: ,
1991. .174179; .: .. //
. URL : http://www.topos.ru/veer/56/14.htm.

139

an sich, , ,
, , 167. .
;
(). , , ,
: , , , .
, , ,
. ,
, -
, 168.

, , ( ) . , ,
, . 169 .
, , : , ,
170.
,
, ,
. ,
, , 167. .. C.4562.
168. . . C.33.
169. . . . .64, 96, 176181.
170. .. C.216.

1 40

[99] 2014


- . 1928


171. , .

;
, ,
, .
() , , - , , ,
, , .
-, , ,
. , , , -
,
. , , , .
, , , . , .
? , ,
,
, par excellence.
, , .
()
?
171. . .221222.

141

, ( ,
) , - ;
, .
, ?
? ,
, ?
, , .
REFERENCES
Akhutin A.V. Poniatie priroda v antichnosti i v Novoe vremia [The concept of nature in
antiquity and in modern age], Moscow, Nauka, 1988.
Aristotelev korpus. Mekhanicheskie problemy [The Mechanical Problems in the Corpus
of Aristotle] (trans. A.I.Shchetnikov). . Filosofskoe antikovedenie i klassicheskaia traditsiia [The philosophical study of antiquity and the Classical Tradition], 2012, vol.6.2.
BaudrillardJ. Sistema veshchei [Le systme des objets], Moscow, Rudomino, 1995.
BeckT. Ocherki po istorii mashinostroeniia [Beitrage zur Geschiclite des Maschinenbaues],
Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe tekhniko-teoreticheskoe izdatelstvo, 1933.
ChulkovO.A. Zhivye zerkala. Mifologiia i metafizika otrazhennogo obraza [Living
mirror. Mythology and metaphysics of the reflected image]. AKADHMEIA . Materialy i issledovaniia po istorii platonizma [AKADHMEIA . Materials and research on
the history of Platonism], Saint Petersburg, 2000, iss.3, pp.192214.
DescartesR. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works in 2 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 1989, vol.1.
DielsH. Antichnaia tekhnika [Antike Technik], Moscow, Leningrad, GTTI , 1934.
EliasN. O protsesse tsivilizatsii. Sotsiogeneticheskie i psikhogeneticheskie issledovaniia: v
2t. [ber den Proze der Zivilisation. Soziogenetische und psychogenetische Untersuchungen. Zwei Bnde]. Saint Petersburg, Universitetskaia kniga, 2001, vol.1.
Engelmeier P.K.Filosofiia tekhniki. Vypusk II . Sovremennaia filosofiia [Philosophy of Technology. Issue II . Modern philosophy], Moscow, Tovarishchestvo Skoropechatni
A.A.Levenson, 1912.
Engelmeier P.K. Tekhnicheskii itog XIX veka [Technical result of the 19th century] Tipografiia K.A.Kaznacheeva, 1898.
FeuerbachL. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works in 2 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 1995, vol.2.
Florensky P.A. Sochineniia: v 4 t. [Works in 4 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 2000, vol.3 (1).
FoucaultM. Nadzirat i nakazyvat. Rozhdenie tiurmy [Surveiller et punir: Naissance de
la Prison], Moscow, Ad Marginem, 1999.
Frazer J.G. Zolotaia vetv: Issledovanie magii i religii [The Golden Bough: a Study in Magic and Religion], Moscow, Politizdat, 1983.
GellerL. Organoproektsiia: v poiskakh ochelovechennogo mira [Organoproektsiya:
in search of a humanized world]. Zvezda, 2006, no.11, pp.145156.
Germetizm, magiia, naturfilosofiia v evropeiskoi kulture XIIIXIX vv. [Hermeticism, magic, natural philosophy in European culture of XIIIXIX centuries], Moscow, Kanon, 1999.

1 42

[99] 2014

Gorokhov V.G. Tekhnika i kultura: vozniknovenie filosofii tekhniki i teorii tekhnicheskogo tvorchestva v Rossii i Germanii v kontse XIX nachale XX stoletiia [Technology and culture: the
emergence of the philosophy of technology and technical creativity theory in Russia
and Germany in the late XIX early XX century], Moscow, Logos, 2009.
Gorokhov V.G., Rozin V.M. Vvedenie v filosofiiu tekhniki [Introduction to the philosophy
of technology], Moscow, INFRA -M, 1998.
HeckethornC. Tainye obshchestva vsekh vekov i vsekh stran [The Secret Societies of All
Ages and Countries], Saint Petersburg, Tipografiia Akhmatovoi, 1876.
Hegel G.W.F. Entsiklopediia filosofskikh nauk. Nauka logiki [Die Enzyklopdie der philosophischen Wissenschaften. Wissenschaft der Logik], Moscow, Mysl, 1974.
Huffman C.A. Archytas of Tarentum. Pythagorean, Philosopher and Mathematician King,
Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005.
HuningA. Homo mensura: liudi eto ikh tekhnika tekhnika prisushcha cheloveku
[Homo Mensura: Human beings are their technology technology is human].
Filosofiia tekhniki v FRG [Philosophy of Technology in West Germany], Moscow,
Progress, 1989.
JungC.G. Arkhaichnyi chelovek [Archaic human]. Problemy dushi nashego vremeni [The
problems of soul in our time], Moscow, Progress, 1993.
Jung C.G. Eon. Issledovaniia o simvolike samosti [Aion: Researches into the Phenomenology of the Self], Moscow, Akademicheskii proekt, 2009.
Jung C.G. O prirode psikhe [On the Nature of the Psyche], Moscow, Reflbuk, 2002.
JungC.G. Ob arkhetipakh kollektivnogo bessoznatelnogo [On the archetypes of collective
unconscious]. Arkhetip i simvol [Archetype and Symbol], Moscow, Renessans, 1991.
JungC.G. Problema dushi sovremennogo cheloveka [Modern Man in Search of a Soul].
Arkhetip i simvol [Archetype and Symbol], Moscow, Renessans, 1991.
Jung C.G. Psikhologiia i alkhimiia [Psychology and Alchemy], Moscow, AST , 2008.
JungC.G. Psikhologiia i religiia [Psychology and Religion]. Arkhetip i simvol [Archetype
and Symbol], Moscow, Renessans, 1991.
Jnger F.G. Sovershenstvo tekhniki. Mashina i sobstvennost [Perfektion der Technik. Maschine und Eigentum], Saint Petersburg, Vladimir Dal, 2002.
KappE., CunowH., NoirL., EspinasA. Rol orudiia v razvitii cheloveka [Role of a tool
in the development of human], Leningrad, Priboi, 1925.
KardashV.E. Taina tantsuiushchikh starushek: zerkala i avtomaty v romanticheskoi
literature i Sorochinskaia iarmarka Gogolia [Mystery of dancing old ladies, mirror and machines in romantic literature and Gogols Sorochynsky Fair]. Russkaia literatura, 2006, no.3, pp.1937.
La MettrieJ.O. Chelovek-mashina [LHomme Machine]. Sochineniia [Works], Moscow,
Mysl, 1976.
Le GoffJ. Drugoe Srednevekove [Pour un autre Moyen ge,], Ekaterinburg, Izdatelstvo
Uralskogo universiteta, 2002.
Leibniz G.W. Sochineniia: v 4 t. [Works in 4 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 1982, vol.1.
MarxK., EngelsF. Sochineniia: v 50 t. [Works in 50 vols], Moscow, Gospolitizdat, 1955
1981, vol.23.
MauriceK., O.MayrO., eds. The Clockwork universe: German clocks and automata, 1550
1650, New York, Neale Watson Academic Publications, 1980.
McLuhan M.Ponimanie Media: Vneshnie rasshireniia cheloveka [Understanding Media:
The Extensions of Man], Moscow, Kanon-press-Ts, 2003.
Melchior-Bonnet S.Istoriia zerkala [Histoire du miroir], Moscow, NLO , 2006.
MumfordL. Mif mashiny. Tekhnika i razvitie chelovechestva [The Myth of the Machine.
Technics and Human Development], Moscow, Logos, 2001.
MumfordL. Technics and civilization, London, Harcourt, Brace & Company, 1934.
NancyJ.-L. Corpus, Moscow, Ad Marginem, 1999.

143

Nicholas of Kues. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works in 2 vols], Moscow, Mysl, 19791980.


NikitaevV.V. Marks, infrastruktura sotsialnogo vremeni i genezis zheleznogo cheloveka [Marx, the infrastructure of social time and genesis of the iron man]. Filosofiia i kultura [Philosophy and Culture], 2013, no.7, pp.9961003.
NikitaevV.V. Ot filosofii tekhniki k filosofii inzhenerii [From the philosophy of technology to the philosophy of engineering]. Voprosy filosofii [Problems of Philosophy], 2013, no.3, pp.6879.
Ord-Hume A.Vechnoe dvizhenie (istoriia odnoi naviazchivoi idei) [Perpetual Motion: History of an Obsession], Moscow, Znanie, 1980.
Pipunyrov V.N. Istoriia chasov s drevneishikh vremen do nashikh dnei [History of timekeeping devices from ancient times to our days], Moscow, Nauka, 1982.
Plato. Gosudarstvo [The Republic]. Sobranie sochinenii: v 4 t. [Collected works in 4 vols],
Moscow, Mysl, 19901994, vol.3.
Plotinus. Enneady: v 7 t. [Eneads in 7 vols] (trans. T.G.Sidash, R.V.Svetlov), Saint Petersburg, Izdatelstvo Olega Abyshko, 2004.
PodorogaV.A. Homo ex machina (Avangard i ego mashiny. Estetika novoi formy) [Avantgarde and his machines. Aesthetics of new form]. Logos. Filosofsko-literaturnyi zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2010, no.1 (74), pp.2250.
RaunigG. Abstraktnye mashiny [Abstract machines]. Logos. Filosofsko-literaturnyi zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2010, no.1 (74), pp.207215.
Rist J.M. Plotin: put k realnosti [Plotinus: Road to Reality], Saint Petersburg, Izdatelstvo
Olega Abyshko, 2005.
Romanenko Iu. M, ChulkovO.A. Metafora i simvol v kulturnom obrashchenii [Metaphor and symbol in the cultural use]. Metafizicheskie issledovaniia [Metaphysical
studies], 1997, iss.5.
RortyR. Filosofiia i zerkalo prirody [Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature], Novosibirsk,
Izdatelstvo NGU , 1997.
Rozin V.M. Vvedenie v skhemologiiu: Skhemy v filosofii, kulture, nauke, proektirovanii [Introduction to the study of schemes: schemes in philosophy, culture, science, engineering], Moscow, Librokom, 2011.
SamuelsA. Iung i postiungiantsy [Jung and the Post-Jungians], Moscow, CheRo, 1997.
SchopenhauerA. Sochineniia: v 6 t. [Works in 6 vols], Moscow, TEPPA , Respublika, 1999
2001, vol.1.
Sheipak A.A. Istoriia nauki i tekhniki. Materialy i tekhnologii [History of science and technology. Materials and Technologies], Moscow, MGIU , 2004, vol.2.
ShevchenkoV.V. Vechnyi dvigatel [ontinuously operating machine]. Elektronnyi
almanakh Veer budushchnostei [Electronic almanac Fan of futurity]. Available
at: http://www.topos.ru/veer/56/14.htm.
Shichalin Iu.A. Tretii vid u Platona i materiia-zerkalo u Plotina [The third type of
Plato and matter-mirror of Plotinus]. Vestnik drevnei istorii [Journal of Ancient
History], 1978, no.1.
Sinkevich V.A. Fenomen zerkala v istorii kultury [The phenomenon of mirrors in the history of culture], Saint Petersburg, 2006.
SpenglerO. Chelovek i tekhnika [Man and Technology]. Kulturologiia. XX vek. Antologiia [Cultural Studies. 20th century. Anthology], Moscow, Iurist, 1995.
Voltaire. Filosofskie sochineniia [Fhilosophical writings], Moscow, Nauka, 1988.
YatesF. Dzhordano Bruno i germeticheskaia traditsiia [Giordano Bruno and the hermeti
tradition], Moscow, NLO , 2000.
Znanie za predelami nauki. Mistitsizm, germetizm, astrologiia, alkhimiia, magiia v
intellektualnykh traditsiiakh IXIV vv. [Knowledge outside of science. Mysticism,
hermeticism, astrology, alchemy, magic in the intellectual traditions of IXIV centuries], Moscow, Respublika, 1996.

1 44

[99] 2014


1920

.
,



....
: 410000, ,
. , 10, . 12.
E-mail: oshindina@yandex.ru.
: , ,
, , ,
, , ,
, .


1920, . ..
,
, 1924
1922
.
-
( ), , ,
.

ART AND SCIENCE DISCOURSES OF


THE 1920 S. Tynyanov and the Image
of Man of Letters within the
Artistic Universe of Konstantin
Vaginov
Olga Shindina. PhD in Philology, Assistant Professor at the Department of Philosophy of Culture and Culture Studies of the
Saratov State University.
Address: Bldg12, 10 Volskaya str.,
410028 Saratov, Russia.
E-mail: oshindina@yandex.ru.
Keywords: Vaginov, Tynyanov, Shklovsky,
Luntz, Mandelstam, Blok, Russian formalism, man of letters, discourse, thing.
The article is dedicated to the mutual influence of scientific and artistic discourses of
the 1920s on each other, using the example
of the works of K.Vaginov and Y.Tynyanov.
Vaginovs participation in forming Tynyanovs theory of unity and narrowness of
the rhymes line and of rhythm as a constructive factor are emphasized in this article. The ideas of this theory were stated in
Tynyanovs Problems of Poetical Language
of 1924 and were anticipated by the poetical
conception of the main hero of Vaginovs
story The Cloister of Apollo, Our God. The
article compares formal characteristics of
these authors understandings of the images
of a man of letters (Bloks subtext), of literature, of a thing, and of the motives
behind philological and literary work.


145

, -, . ,
-. ,
. , ,
, 1, , 2.
: , , . , ;
, 3.

1. .:
.. //
Russian Literature. 1997. Vol.XLII . No.3/4. .349378.
2. : . / . ..;
. . ..// :
. : , 1990. .271277.
3. .. // .. .: 2 ..:
, 1990. .2. / . . ., ., . .. .178.

1 46

[99] 2014


: , 19211922, 1922
;

.
, . (1927),
, : 4. : ; , ,
5.
, () 6, ; , ,
,
, , .

, :
, (121). 4. .. // .. . . . / .
.., .., .., . .., .
.., . .., ... .: , 1999. .146.
.
.
5. .. . . .179.
6. .

147

(1929),
, : , . 7.
,
( :
,
(463)), , , . , ( ), , (
, (1929)).
(-, )
. - :
,
8.
,
, . , ,
, 9. , 7. [ ] . // :
/ . ... .: ,
2000. .73.
8. .: XX roman clef . . (
-) ( . . // :
. : , 1986. .176).
9. .. // ..

1 48

[99] 2014

, 1924, 1922 :
, ,
(438).
, ,

,
, ,
(
). , , , , ,
, . ,
, ,
,
10.
,
11.
, , ,
.

, 12. . . .: , 1965. .125.
10. . .92.
11. , , ,
. .; .: .. .. . . . . . . , 2010.
12. . ( .. .
// . .857. , 1989.
.4042).

149


, , ,
, 1931
. ,
: , .
. , . ( ),
, : ,
13.

,

, : , , (439).
, : ,
(79). , : , , , , ,
, , (28). , -

13. . ( ). , // .. / ., . , . . .. .: ,
2012. .303.

1 50

[99] 2014

14;
:

(
1924. ..) , , ,
, , , . ,
15.

,
,
:

.
, , , ,
!.. ,
. , . , .
. , ,
.
. .
, ,
, . ,
, , ! . ? 14.
18.. ( . .
.: .. . .: //
: - - : 90- : / . . ..,
... ... : , 2011.
.183191).
15. .. // .. . .: 8 ..: , 19801983. .7. .389.
.,
, :
( .. : . .: ,
1988).

151

. 16

,
84- . ( 1921): : . <> : .
,
; 17. , . ,

, .
., :
, ..18. , 5 = 100,
: . ? .
. . ?19
: ,
, . ,
20. 16. .. . .461.
17. .. // .. .: 2 ./ ., .
. .. .:
, 1955. .2. .347.
18. .. , , // .. . . . .: , 1977.
.462.
19. . : .
20. . , ,
, 1923 Zoo.

1 52

[99] 2014

. ., 21.
, , :
, - ; , . (
) , ,

,
XX, , , , , .
,
22, , ,
. , , .
/,
, . ,
, , ,
, ;
: (. Zoo. , // . / . ., . ., .. .:
, 2002. .302).
21. .. // .. .
. .421.
22. .: .
// :
/ . ., ., ... Trento: Universit degli
Studi di Trento, 1995. .145152; ..
// Russian Literature. 2002.
Vol. LIII . No.4. .451469.

153

, : , , ..,
, .
, 23. ,
- , ,
, 24, , . ,
(
1919); , , , .
. , , , 1924
, , , 22
, , ( ) 25.
:
..

, .
, , ,
23. ., 1929 : , : -, , , , , , .
, , , , (.
// . .72).
24. , !, .: .. :
. .: , 2012. .42 .
25. .. , , // .. .
. .149.

1 54

[99] 2014


() . , ,
, , , , . 26.


:
.
. , ; , , ,
: , , , 27.


. Zoo.
, :
!28 29 30.
. , 1923 1926 ,
31. (1922)32.

26. .. : . . . .: , 1982. .14.
27. . -// ./ . ... .: , 1983. .171.
28. . Zoo. , // .
.294.
29. . .293.
30. -
.: .. . . .1617.
31. .. .. ( )//
: / .
. ... : , 1988. .73.
32.

155

, ; : , (39).
, : , ,
, , . , . , . (40). ,
33, : , (40). ,
, . ,
-, ,
, 1920
34, - 35.

,
,
(1931) - ,
, , ( ) .: . . . .205 .
33. , ., : ,
, . ,
. ,
. ! , ! ( ..
// .. .: 2 ..2. . .92).
34. .. // ..
/ . .., . .., .., . .., ... .: , 1979. .7180.
35. .. // . 1993. 2. .7089.

1 56

[99] 2014

. , ,

1920 1930 ,
36.
, ( 37), , , .
, , , ,
( ) . , ,
, - 36. MorsonG.S., EmersonC. Michail Bachtin: Creation of a Prosaics. Stanford, CA :
Stanford UP , 1990.
37. , .
., 1920 ,
,
(.: . Homo Creator Homo Faber Homo Spectator ( . .)// Russian Literature. 1999. Vol.XLVI .
No.2. P.185206), .: .
. (1923)
;
, , ,
(1928), . ,
, , , ,
() () .: .. .// . .748.
. . . , 1987. .177.

157

. , , , ,
, 38,

, , , . :
, , (214)
,
. , .
, , , (22).
,
, , , , , ( , ).
, , 39;
(1933).
, , 38. , ( ) :
.. // .. :
(19141933)/ . .., .., . .., . . ... .:
, 1990. .5872; ..
// .. . . . / . ., . . .. .: , 1986. .50, 57, 63.
39. .. ( )// .. : . .: - , 2003. .64.

1 58

[99] 2014

40,
.
:
( ), ,
( )41.

, , ,
, -42.
. , , ,
,
( ), ,
, ,
43.
,
, , ,
, :
, , , ,
40. .: .. : // :
. : , 1990. .181182.
41. . .190191. . , . (. // . 1991. 11.
.12).
42. .. // . 1991. 11. .177.
43. .. // .. : / . .., ... .: ,
1987. .428436. ( ) , , .: . . . .174188.

159

. , . ,
, , ,
,
- ,
, , , ,
,
.
,
,
, . 1926 44
, .

45, ,
46. 47, .
,
,
,
.
, , ,
, , 48 .
44. .. // ..
: . .426427.
45. .. .. ( ). .73.
46. .. . . .195.
47. . .55.
48. .
(. // .

1 60

[99] 2014

(
),
, .
, ( ).

,
, 49, ,
, -50. 51

: , , , , 52.
( ), (.229234).

.: . . . .119.
49. : , . <> (. // . .60).
50. ..
// . 1991. 11. .161171; . ..
.
51. , . 1909
: (..
. // .. . .:
7 ..: , 19731975/ . . .. ., . . .. ., . .
... .6. .160175).
52. .. //
Russian Literature. 1993. Vol.XXXIV . No.2. P.219239.

161

), ( ), ,
. ,
,
, , , , , .
REFERENCES
AleksandrovA. Neokonchennye dramaticheskie proizvedeniia Daniila Kharmsa [Unfinished dramatic works of Daniil Kharms]. Teatr [Theatre], 1991, no.11.
Baak VanJ. Zametki ob obraze mira u Vaginova [Notes about the Vaginovs image of
the world]. Vtoraia proza: Russkaia proza dvadtsatykh-tridtsatykh godov XX veka
[Second Prose: Russian prose of the 1920s1930s] (eds V.Veststein, D.Ritstsi,
T.V.Tsivian), Trento, Universit degli Studi di Trento, 1995.
BakhtinM.M. Avtor i geroi v esteticheskoi deiatelnosti [Author and Hero in Aesthetic Activity]. Estetika slovesnogo tvorchestva [Aesthetics of verbal actitivity] (eds
S.G.Bocharov, G.S.Bernshtein, L.V.Deriugina, S.S.Averintsev), Moscow, Iskusstvo, 1979, pp.7180.
BlokA.A. O naznachenii poeta [On the destination of the poet]. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works
in 2 vols] (ed. V.Orlov), Moscow, Gosudarstvennoe izdatelstvo khudozhestvennoi literatury, 1955, vol.2.
BocharovS.G. Ob odnom razgovore i vokrug nego [Of a conversation and around it].
Novoe literaturnoe obozrenie [New Literary Observer], 1993, no.2, pp.7089.
BryusovV.Ya. Literaturnaia zhizn Frantsii. Nauchnaia poeziia [Literary life in France.
Scientific poetry]. Sobranie sochinenii: v 7 t. [Collected works in 7 vols] (ed.
P.G.Antokolskii), Moscow, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 19731975, vol.6,
pp.160175).
Bukhshtab B. Vaginov (eds G.G.Shapovala, A.G.Gerasimova). Tynyanovskii sbornik:
Chetvertye Tynyanovskie chteniia [Tynyanov Collection: Fourth Tynyanov reading], Riga, Zinatne, 1990, pp.271277.
ChudakovaM.O. Kommentarii k state Zhurnal, kritik, chitatel i pisatel [Comments
on the article Magazine, critic, writer and reader]. In: Tynyanov Yu. N.Poetika.
Istoriia literatury. Kino [Poetics. The history of literature. Cinema], Moscow, Nauka, 1977.
ChuzhakN. Literatura zhiznestroeniia [Construction of life literature]. Literatura fakta: Pervyi sbornik materialov rabotnikov LEF a [Literature of fact: The first collection of materials of LEF s workers] (ed. N.F.Chuzhak), Moscow, Zakharov, 2000.
EikhenbaumB. Kak sdelana Shinel Gogolia [How Gogols Overcoat Was Made].
O proze. O poezii. Sb. statei [On prose. On Poetry. Collection of articles] (ed.
O.Eikhenbaum), Leningrad, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 1986.
EikhenbaumB. Literaturnyi byt [Literary Mores]. O literature: Raboty raznykh let [On literature: selected papers] (eds O.B.Eikhenbaum, E.A.Toddes), Moscow, Sovetskii
pisatel, 1987, pp.428436.

1 62

[99] 2014

EikhenbaumB. O prostykh veshchakh i azbuchnykh istinakh [On the simple things


and truisms]. O literature: Raboty raznykh let [On literature: selected papers] (eds
O.B.Eikhenbaum, E.A.Toddes), Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel, 1987, pp.426427.
GinzburgL. Tynianov-uchenyi [Tynyanov the scientist]. Vospominaniia o Yu. Tynyanove
[Memories of Yu. Tynyanov] (ed. V.A.Kaverin), Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel, 1983.
IablokovE. Homo Creator Homo Faber Homo Spectator (Tema masterstva u
A.Platonova i M.Bulgakova) [Homo Creator Homo Faber Homo Spectator
(Theme of mastery by A.Platonov and M.Bulgakov)]. Russian Literature, 1999,
vol.XLVI , no.2, pp.185206.
Ivanov Vyach.V. Ob evoliutsionnom podkhode k kulture [On evolutionary approach to
culture]. Tynyanovskii sbornik: Vtorye Tynyanovskie chteniia [Tynyanov Collection:
Second Tynyanov reading], Riga, Zinatne, 1986.
Kaverin V.A. Literator: Dnevniki i pisma [Writer: Diaries and Letters], Moscow, Sovetskii
pisatel, 1988.
KaverinV.A. Osveshchennye okna [Illuminated windows]. Sobranie sochinenii: v 8 t. [Collected works in 8 vols], Moscow, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 19801983, vol.7.
Kaverin V.A. Vechernii den: Pisma. Vstrechi. Portrety [Evening Day: Letters. Meetings.
Portraits], Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel, 1982.
KostandiO.G. Stilisticheskie printsipy rannei prozy V.Kaverina [Stylistic principles of
early V.Kaverins prose]. Uchenye zapiski Tartuskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Proceedings of Tartu State University], 1987, iss.748 (Actual problems of the
theory and history of Russian literature. Works on Russian and Slavic Philology. Literature).
Lef. Vmesto postskriptuma [Lef. Instead of postscript]. Literatura fakta: Pervyi sbornik
materialov rabotnikov LEF a [Literature of fact: The first collection of materials of
LEF s workers] (ed. N.F.Chuzhak), Moscow, Zakharov, 2000.
Levchenko J.S. Drugaia nauka: russkie formalisty v poiskakh biografii [Other science: Russian formalists in search of biography], Moscow, Vysshaia shkola ekonomiki, 2012.
MalakhovS. Lirika kak orudie klassovoi borby (okrainikh flangakh v neproletarskoi
poezii Leningrada). Doklad, chitannyi v Leningradskom otdelenii SSP na diskussii o tvorcheskom metode poezii [Poetry as an instrument of class struggle (onthe
extreme flanks of the non-proletarian poetry in Leningrad). Report on the Leningrad branch of the Soviet Union of Writers. Debate about the creative method of
poetry]. In: VaginovK.K. Pesnia slov [Song of words] (ed. A.Gerasimova), Moscow, OGI , 2012.
MandelstamO. Chetvertaia proza [Fourth Prose]. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works in 2 vols]
(eds S.Averintsev, P.Nerler), Moscow, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 1990, vol.2.
MandelstamO. O prirode slova [On the nature of word]. Sochineniia: v 2 t. [Works in 2 vols]
(eds S.Averintsev, P.Nerler), Moscow, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 1990, vol.2.
MeilakhM.B. Shkap i kolpak: fragment oberiutskoi poetiki [Cupboard and cap: fragment
of OBERIU poetics]. Tynyanovskii sbornik: Chetvertye Tynyanovskie chteniia [Tynyanov Collection: Fourth Tynyanov reading], Riga, Zinatne, 1990.
MeilakhM.B. Zametki o teatre oberiutov [Notes about the OBERIU theater]. Teatr [Theatre], 1991, no.11.
MorsonG.S., EmersonC. Michail Bachtin: Creation of a Prosaics, Stanford, CA , Stanford
University Press, 1990.
Nikolskaia T. L. K.K.Vaginov (Kanva biografii i tvorchestva) [K. K.Vaginov (Outline of
biography and work]. Chetvertye Tynianovskie chteniia: Tezisy dokladov i materialy
dlia obsuzhdeniia [Fourth Tynyanov reading: Abstracts of papers and discussion
papers] (ed. M.O.Chudakova), Riga, Zinatne, 1988.

163

ShindinaO.V. K interpretatsii romana Vaginova Kozlinaia pesn [On the interpretation


of the Vaginovs Goat Song]. Russian Literature, 1993, vol.XXXIV , no.2, pp.219239.
ShindinaO.V. O nekotorykh soderzhatelnykh osobennostiakh romana Vaginova Garpagoniana [On some substantial aspects of Vaginovs Harpagoniana]. Russian
Literature, 2002, vol. LIII , no.4, pp.451469.
ShindinaO.V. Obraz slova v kontekste khudozhestvennogo mira Vaginova [Image of the
word in the context of the Vaginovs art world]. Russian Literature, 1997, vol.XLII ,
no.3/4, pp.349378.
ShindinaO.V. Teatralizatsiia povestvovaniia v romane Vaginova Kozlinaia pesn [The
theatricalization of narrative in the Vaginovs Goat Song]. Teatr [Theater], 1991,
no.11, pp.161171.
Shindina O.V. Tvorchestvo K.K.Vaginova kak metatekst. PhD Thesis, Saratov, 2010.
ShindinaO.V. V.Kaverin i K.Vaginov: metatekstualnye poiski [V.Kaverin and K.Vaginov: metatextual searches]. Serapionovy bratia: filosofsko-esteticheskie i kulturnoistoricheskie aspekty: K 90-letiiu obrazovaniia literaturnoi gruppy: Materialy mezhdunarodnoi nauchnoi konferentsii (pod red. Konovalovoi, I.V.Tkachevoi). Gosudarstvennyi muzei K.A.Fedina [The Serapion Brothers: philosophical, aesthetic,
cultural, historical aspects. On the 90th anniversary of the literary group: Proceedings of the International Conference (eds Konovalova, I.V.Tkacheva), State Museum of K.A.Fedin], Saratov, Orion, 2011, pp.183191.
ShklovskyV. Iskusstvo kak priem [Art as Technique]. Gamburgskii schet: Stati vospominaniia esse (19141933) [Hamburg reckoning: Articles Memories Essays (1914
1933)] (eds A.Iu. Galushkina, A.P.Chudakova), Sovetskii pisatel, 1990, pp.5872.
ShklovskyV. K tekhnike vnesiuzhetnoi prozy [To the technique of prose without a storyline]. Literatura fakta: Pervyi sbornik materialov rabotnikov LEF a [Literature of
fact: The first collection of materials of LEF s workers] (ed. N.F.Chuzhak), Moscow, Zakharov, 2000, pp.229234.
ShklovskyV. Zoo. Pisma ne o liubvi, ili Tretia Eloiza [Zoo, or Letters Not About Love].
Eshche nichego ne konchilos [Nothing is over yet] (eds A.Galushkin, V.Nekhotin), Moscow, Propaganda, 2002.
ToddesE.A. Kommentarii k state Mnimyi Pushkin [Comments on the article The
Imaginary Pushkin]. In: Tynyanov Yu. N.Problema stikhotvornogo iazyka. Stati
[The problem of poetic language. Articles], Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel, 1965.
ToporovV.N. Peterburg i Peterburgskii tekst russkoi literatury (Vvedenie v temu) [Petersburg and the Petersburg Text of Russian Literature (Introduction to the topic)]. Peterburgskii tekst russkoi literatury: Izbrannye trudy [Petersburg Text of Russian Literature: Selected Works], Saint Petersburg, Iskusstvo-SP b, 2003.
ToporovV.N. Stikhi Ivana Ignatova. Predstavlenie chitateliu [Poetry of Ivan Ignatov. Presentation to the reader]. Uchenye zapiski Tartuskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta
[Proceedings of Tartu State University], 1989, iss.857, pp.4042.
TretyakovS. Biografiia veshchi [Biography of thing]. Literatura fakta: Pervyi sbornik materialov rabotnikov LEF a [Literature of fact: The first collection of materials of LEF s
workers] (ed. N.F.Chuzhak), Moscow, Zakharov, 2000.
Tynyanov Yu. N.Zhurnal, kritik, chitatel i pisatel [Magazine, critic, writer and reader].
Problema stikhotvornogo iazyka. Stati [The problem of poetic language. Articles],
Moscow, Sovetskii pisatel, 1965.
VaginovK.K. Kozlinaia pesn [Goat Song]. Polnoe sobranie sochinenii v proze [Complete
collection of prose writings] (eds A.I.Vaginova, T.L.Nikolskaia, V.I.Erl), Saint
Petersburg, Akademicheskii proekt, 1999.

1 64

[99] 2014

-
-

, DIDROS PHILOSOPHICAL AND


, ARTISTIC MYSTIFICATION IN
- JACQUES THE FATALIST
Natalia Pakhsarian. Doctor of
....
Philology, Professor of Philology at the
: 119991, , -1, - Department of Philology of the Moscow
, .27, . 1. State University.
E-mail: npakhsarian@gmail.com. Address: 271 Lomonosovsky prospekt,
: , - GSP -1, 119991 Moscow, Russia.
, , , - E-mail: npakhsarian@gmail.com.
, ,
, .

, .
-
- ,
, , - .

, ,
.
-
, ,
.

Keywords: Diderot, mystification, illusion, play, ambiguity, infinity, fragmentarity, irony.


This article deals with the notion and
the function of mystification in philosophy and in literature. The author analyzes the novel-dialogue Jacques the
Fatalist by Diderot, in which different
types of mystification are represented.
We examine narrative mystification,
fable mystification, philosophical mystification, among others. We look at the
similarities and differences between the
poetics of Diderots novel with Don
Quixote by Cervantes, Cleveland by
Prevost, Mariannas Life by Marivaux
and Tristram Shandy by Stern in the
aspect of literary game. We have concluded that Diderots ambiguous text is
at once philosophical and fictional and
combines seriousness with play, realism
with illusion, and integrity with fragmentarity.


165

: , ,
,
1, .
, .
; , - , .
, , : ,
( , ) , , , , , 2,
.

1. .: // Philosophydic.Ru. URL : http://


www.philosophydic.ru/mistifikaciya.
2. , .: .,
. . . .: , 2002; JeanneretJ. Laffaire Sokal ou la
querelle des impostures. P.: PUF , 1998.

1 66

[99] 2014

, , , .
. (1930) 3, .. (1979)
, , 4.

:
,
5. , , (
) , 6. , , , XIX (, .,
./ .), ,
. 7,

. ,
, ( . . .)
3. . . .: , 2009. .67.
4. .. ..
( )//
. .: , 1979. .XXXIV .
5. GalimskaM. ( )// Polilog. Studia Neofilologiczne. 2013. No.3. P.6575.
6. ., .: / . .., ... .: , 1987. .222.
7. ., .: .. - . . . . . ., 1992; JeandillouJ.-F.
Esthtique de la mystification. Tactique et stratgie littraires. P.: Minuit, 1994.

167

8, , ,
. ...
, ,
, , /, /, / ..

, , , , , . XVIII
:
(,
, , , ,
, , III, ), ,

.
, , .
, , , ,
, , ..
, - , (, , ,
) (, , ,
), ,
8. .. . . . . . . , 2006. .8.

1 68

[99] 2014

,
, ; , , .-.9. ,
, (faire-croire), , (laisser-croire)10, .

. 201111. , , , .
1760,
: , ..
, , , . , , ,
., - .

., - (philosophie narrative) ,
- ,
(
), - ( , , )12. ,
, ,
, XVIII . 9. JeandillouJ.-F.Op. cit. P.191.
10. Ibid. P.23.
11. ChartierP. Vies de Diderot. Portrait du philosophe en mystificateur. Vol.13. P.:
Hermann, 2012. , -, La Mystification djoue.
12. DufloC. Les aventures de Sophie. La philosophie dans le roman au XVIII sicle.
P.: CNRS Editions, 2013. P.255.

169

, (17311739).
. (
, ;
, , , ,
). -
,
-, 13, , : 14
, , .-. ,
-, .
-,
. , , 1762 . , .
. : , , , .15, ,
, ,
.

( ) , , , , .
, - , (), .
13. ., , (DufloC. Op.
cit. P.263).
14. Ibid. P.265.
15. ChartierP. Op. cit. Vol.3. P.197.

1 70

[99] 2014

, , 16. - , ,
: , , ,
17.
, , , ,
, ,
, 18. - , - , 19 . , .,
,
, . - : -
, . , 1724,
. - , ( , .-.),
( ) , , , ,
: .
,
, (
), , , , , , ,
. .
., , .
16. Salkin-Sbirolt L.Les paradoxes comiques de Jacques le fataliste// Recherches sur
Diderot et sur lEncyclopdie. 1987. No.3. P.24.
17. Ibid. P.17.
18. .. : .// .
. .34. . .: - , 2008. .173.
19. ChartierP. Op. cit. Vol.3. P.236.

171

;
,
- .
- , , . - ( ) .
,
, ,
, , . , .,
20. -
, , , ,
, ..
, , - , ..

, romans inachevs.
, . , . ,
, .
,
. , ,
, -.
, , roman inachev. , , . , .
. ( , ,
)
20. ChartierP. Op. cit. Vol.3. P.240.

1 72

[99] 2014

. , :
, (,
, ,
, , , , ); , ; , ,
-.
-. ., , 21.

- ,
. , - (roman quichotis), , - . ,
,
22. , , , ( , ; ),

. , , . , -
, . , ( ), , ,
. ,
, , -, ,
21. CronkN. Jacques le fataliste et son matre: un roman quichotis// Recherches sur
Diderot et sur lEncyclopdie. 1997. No.23. P.6378. , , .: Tran-Gervat Y.-M. Humour
servantique et roman parodique: rflexions sur le rire et le roman au XVIII sicle,
partir du cas de Tristram Shandy// Etudes franaises. 2011. Vol.47. No.2. P.64.
22. CronkN. Op. cit. P.73.

173

.
- . , , , .
, , 1760 (17601765,
),
, -23, , . XVIII:
- , , , , , .

, , , ( 1737 ). - , ,
.
, (
), . :
, ; , ,
-.
( -),
, ( , )
.
- , .
, ,
23. Richard-Pauchet O.Diderot inventeur du marivaudage?// Recherches sur Diderot
et sur lEncyclopdie. 2012. No.47. P.167185.

1 74

[99] 2014

24. , , ( ,
, . - , , 25). , ,
, -. , , (, ,
), - -. , - , , ,
.- 26:
? , . ? ? ? . ?
, : .
, , 27.

,
,
(
, ,
, , ,
, ,
() , ..).
, . ,
( , ),
24. FredmanA.G. Diderot and Sterne. N.Y.: Columbia university press, 1955.
25. Bandry-Scubbi A.Sterne, limitateur imit// Bulletin de la socit dtudes angloamricainesdes XVII et XVIII sicles. 1991. No.32. P.6777.
26. Salkin-Sbirolt L.Op. cit. P.46.
27. . -// . . . - . .: , 1973. .259. .

175

, . ,
( ).

, . : , ,
(471) , , . , ,
, , ,
, , , .
, -
, . , XVIII ,, , , .
, , . , ,
, , : , , , (,
, ;
),
, ,
, , . , ,
; , ,
, . ,
, , -: , , ..
1 76

[99] 2014

( )
( , , - ).
. -
: , , , ,
,
(, , , , , ,
), , . ,
, ,
,
, , , ,
. , .
,
(, , , , ) .. ,
, /, , /
.
, ,
, : ,
. ,
, ( ? , ), :
, : (472). .., :

,
-, , , , ;

177

, : , ,
,
28.

, .29,
, ; - -, ,
( ) , , .
, ,
, :
,
.
.
: , , ,

. , ,
, ,
, .-.: , -,
,
30.
, - ,
, , , 28. .. . .: + , 2009. .71.
29. CronkN. Op. cit. P.74.
30. JeandillouJ.-F. Op. cit. P.175.

1 78

[99] 2014

( , , , , ,
, , ), , , , , ,
, ,
.
REFERENCES
Bandry-Scubbi A.Sterne, limitateur imit. Bulletin de la socit dtudes angloamricainesdes XVII et XVIII sicles, 1991, no.32, pp.6777.
ChartierP. Vies de Diderot. Portrait du philosophe en mystificateur, vols 13, Paris,
Hermann, 2012.
CronkN. Jacques le fataliste et son matre: un roman quichotis. Recherches sur Diderot
et sur lEncyclopdie, 1997, no.23, pp.6378.
DiderotD. Zhak-fatalist [Jacques le fataliste]. Monakhinia. Plemiannik Ramo. Zhakfatalist i ego khoziain [La Religieuse. Le Neveu de Rameau. Jacques le fataliste et
son matre], Moscow, Khudozhestvennaia literatura, 1973.
Dlugach T.B. Deni Didro [Denis Diderot], Moscow, Kanon+, ROOI Reabilitatsiia,
2009.
DufloC. Les aventures de Sophie. La philosophie dans le roman au XVIII sicle, Paris,
CNRS Editions, 2013.
Fredman A.G. Diderot and Sterne, New York, Columbia University Press, 1955.
GalimskaM. Mistifikatsiia kak literaturnoe iavlenie (Cherubina de Gabriak) [Hoax as
a literary phenomenon (Cherubina de Gabriak)]. Polilog. Studia Neofilologiczne,
2013, no.3, pp.6575.
JeandillouJ.-F. Esthtique de la mystification. Tactique et stratgie littraires, Paris,
Minuit, 1994.
JeanneretJ. Laffaire Sokal ou la querelle des impostures, Paris, PUF , 1998.
KhitrovA.V. Materiia i smysl: igroterapiia L.Sterna [Matter and meaning. L.Sterne:
the treatment by the game]. Filosofskii vek. Almanakh [Philosophical Age.
Almanac], Saint Petersburg, Sankt-Peterburgskii tsentr istorii idei, 2008, iss.34
(Chelovek v filosofii Prosveshcheniia [Man in the philosophy of Enlightenment]).
Kholneva M.A. Osobennosti khudozhestvennoi mistifikatsii v romane Dzhona Faulza
Volkhv [Specific character of the art hoax in the J.Fowles The Magus]. PhD
Thesis, Nizhnii Novgorod, 2006.
LannE. Literaturnaia mistifikatsiia [Literary hoax], Moscow, Librokom, 2009.
Literaturnyi entsiklopedicheskii slovar [Encyclopedic Dictionary of Literary] (eds
V.M.Kozhevnikov, P.A.Nikolaev), Moscow, Sovetskaia entsiklopediia, 1987.
Mistifikatsiia [Hoax]. Filosofskii slovar Philosophydic.Ru [Philosophical Dictionary
Philosophydic.Ru]. Available at: http://www.philosophydic.ru/mistifikaciya.
Popova I.L. Literaturnaia mistifikatsiia v istoriko-funktsionalnom aspekte [Literary hoax
in the historical and functional aspects]. PhD Thesis, Moscow, 1992.

179

Richard-Pauchet O. Diderot inventeur du marivaudage? Recherches sur Diderot et sur


lEncyclopdie, 2012, no.47, pp.167185.
Salkin-Sbirolt L.Les paradoxes comiques de Jacques le fataliste. Recherches sur Diderot
et sur lEncyclopdie, 1987, no.3.
SmirnovI.P. O poddelkakh A.I.Sulakadzevym drevnerusskikh pamiatnikov (mesto
mistifikatsii v istorii kultury) [On the A.I.Sulakadzevs forgery of Old Russian
documents (place of hoaxes in history of culture)]. Trudy Otdela drevnerusskoi
literatury [Proceedings of the Department of Old Russian Literature], Leningrad,
Nauka, 1979, vol.XXXIV .
SokalA., BricmontJ. Intellektualnye ulovki. Kritika filosofii postmoderna [Impostures
intellectuelles], Moscow, Dom intellektualnoi knigi, 2002.
Tran-Gervat Y.-M. Humour servantique et roman parodique: rflexions sur le rire et
le roman au XVIII sicle, partir du cas de Tristram Shandy. Etudes franaises,
2011, vol.47, no.2.

1 80

[99] 2014

.

....
: 119991, , -1, , 27, . 4.
E-mail: nishukov@gmail.com.
: , , , .

(Modern sports),
: .

,
,


, .


.

THE CONCEPT OF SPORTS


Vladimir Nishukov. Postgraduate
student at the Lomonosov Moscow
State University.
Address: 274 Lomonosovsky prospekt, GSP -1, 119991 Moscow, Russia.
E-mail: nishukov@gmail.com.
Keywords: sociology of philosophy,
philosophy of sports, post-sports,
Allen Guttmann.
The article is dedicated to the analysis
of the definition of contemporary
sports, introduced by Allen Guttmann
in his book From Ritual To Record:
The Nature Of Modern Sports. Guttmans definition tends to be the basis
for the development of a wider concept of post-sports, which is based on
the principle of family resemblance.
The article also looks at the problem
of forming a corpus of literature dedicated to the topic of the philosophy of
sports.


181

. .
. , , , . - . ,
,

. , ,
: , . ,
.

. . , , , , , XVIII, .
,
, . ,
, . -

1 82

[99] 2014

. , , 1
, .
2, .
, . , : 3
. , , , : ,
. .
, .
( , )
4. , , , .

. , , 5 ,
. ,
.
1. .
2. .: . : // . 2006.
3 (54). .147158. .: . // . 2013. 5 (95).
.4360.
3. .: GuttmannA. From Ritual to Record: The Nature of Modern Sports. N.Y.:
Columbia University Press, 1978.
4. . // . 2009. 6 (73). .147187; .
, , // . 2013. 5 (95).
.142.
5. .URL : https://www.amherst.edu/aboutamherst/magazine/issues/2010winter/
guttmann.

183

, 50 , . . ,
, , , , , , soccer football .
, , : ? :
, . (), (),
. , ,
,
.
. .
, . , , , ,
, :
(modern sports) , .

: , , ,
, ,
, .
. , ,
1 84

[99] 2014

,
. , ,
, , , , , , .. ,
. ,
.

. , , ( ,
6), ,
, :
1. , XVIII, . , .
2. , ,
. , ( , , , ), : , -, .

, , .
(.1).
,
, . , 6. . // . 2009. 6 (73). .188.

185

Modern
Sports

. 1 .

, , , .
( , ),
, .
, (.1).
, , , , . , ,
,
, .
:
7
. -, , , ,
. , 8 ,
, 7. . . .
8. MacAloon J. Are Olympic athletes professionals? Cultural categories and social
control in US sport// The Business of Professional Sports/ P.Staudohar, J.Mangan
(eds). Urbana; Chicago: University of Illinois Press, 1991. P.264297.

1 86

[99] 2014

1 .

: . // . 2009. 1(73). .187.

, , . , ,
. , 9 :
, .
, , ,
,
, .
, , , 10.

, (, , , , , ,
..), -
.
. 9. Philosophic Inquiry in Sport. 2nd ed. / MorganW.J., MeierK.V. (eds). Champaign,
IL : Human Kinetics, 1995. P.377389.
10. . . .148.

187

. 11 ,
, , .
. 12 , , , , . ,
, fair play,
.
,
. , ,
. , ,
, (, , )
(, , ),
. ,
, , . , , 13 14, ,

.
,
, . -,
11. SuitsB. The elements of sport// The Philosophy of Sport: a Collection of Original
Essays/ R.Ousterhoudt (ed.). Springfield, IL : CharlesC.Thomas, 1973. P.4864.
12. DAgostino F.The ethos of games// Journal of Philosophy of Sport. 1981. Vol.VIII .
P.718; Lehman. Can cheaters play the game?// Journal of Philosophy of Sport.
1981. Vol.VIII . P.4146.
13. KretchmarS. On beautiful games// Journal of Philosophy of Sport. 1989. Vol.XVI .
P.3443.
14. MeierK.V.Triad trickery: playing with sports and games// Journal of Philosophy
of Sport. 1988. Vol.XV . P.1130.

1 88

[99] 2014

, ,
. -, , , , . .
.
,

,
, Homo Ludens
, , . , . ,
, : , , ., -.
, ,
, (
). , , , , , , .
. . ,
play games. ,
,
.
.

, . ,
(Games and Empires),
(Sports and American Art from Benjamin West to Andy Warhol),
: (Japanese Sports: A History),
.

189

REFERENCES
DAgostino F.The ethos of games. Journal of Philosophy of Sport, 1981, vol.VIII , pp.718.
EcoU.Boltovnia o sporte [Faith in Fakes: Travels in Hyperreality]. Logos. Filosofskoliteraturnyi zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2009, no.6 (73).
GuttmannA.From Ritual to Record: The Nature of Modern Sports, New York, Columbia
University Press, 1978.
GuttmannA.Protestantizm, kapitalizm, sovremennyi sport [Capitalism, Protestantism
and modern sport]. Logos. Filosofsko-literaturnyi zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical
and Literary Journal], 2013, no.5 (95), pp.142.
Guttmann.Ot rituala k rekordu [From Ritual to Record]. Logos. Filosofsko-literaturnyi
zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2009, no.6 (73), pp.147187.
Kildiushov O.Sport kak delo filosofii [Sport as a matter of philosophy]. Logos.
Filosofsko-literaturnyi zhurnal [Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2013,
no.5 (95), pp.4360.
KretchmarS.On beautiful games. Journal of Philosophy of Sport, 1989, vol.XVI ,
pp.3443.
Lehman .Can cheaters play the game? Journal of Philosophy of Sport, 1981, vol.VIII ,
pp.4146.
MacAloon J.Are Olympic athletes professionals? Cultural categories and social control
in US sport. The Business of Professional Sports (eds P.Staudohar, J.Mangan),
Urbana, Chicago, University of Illinois Press, 1991, pp.264297.
MeierK.V.Triad trickery: playing with sports and games. Journal of Philosophy of Sport,
1988, vol.XV , pp.1130.
MorganW.Filosofiia sporta: istoricheskii i kontseptualnyi obzor i otsenka ee
budushchego [The Philosophy of Sport: A Historical and Conceptual Overview
and a Conjecture Regarding Its Future]. Logos. Filosofsko-literaturnyi zhurnal
[Logos. Philosophical and Literary Journal], 2006, no.3 (54), pp.147158.
MorganW.J., MeierK.V., eds. Philosophical Inquiry in Sport, Champaign, IL , Human
Kinetics, 1995.
SuitsB.The elements of sport. The Philosophy of Sport: a Collection of Original Essays (ed.
R.Ousterhoudt), Springfield, IL , CharlesC.Thomas, 1973, pp.4864.

1 90

[99] 2014

, , ,

. ,

.
().
: P.O.Box 5000,
Amherst, MA 010025000, USA .
E-mail: aguttmann@amherst.edu.
: , ,
,
, Homo Ludens.
,


:
,



.
,

, , , .

PLAY, GAMES, CONTESTS,


SPORTS
Allen Guttmann. PhD in American Studies, EmilyC.Jordan Folger
Professor of English and American
Studies, Emeritus.
Address: P.O.Box 5000, Amherst,
MA 010025000, USA .
E-mail: aguttmann@amherst.edu.
Keywords: play, games. contests,
sports, Modern sports, philosophy of
sports, Homo Ludens.
The text is the first and also the most
fundamental chapter of Allen Guttmanns work From Ritual To
Record: The Nature Of Modern
Sports, in which the author develops
the research optics for the Modern
sports study. It is compared with
both the corporal and the contest
practices of the past. Guttmann
offers an original paradigm, describing the logical relationship between
the concepts of play, games, contests,
sports. His research aims to answer
the basic questions of ontology of
sport.


191

:
, , .
.
, . , , - . ,
. , . , . , . , 1.

, , . ,
, , . , ,
: GuttmannA.
Play, Games, Contests, Sports// GuttmannA. From Ritual to Record. The Nature
of Modern Sport. N.Y.: Columbia University Press, 1978. P.114.
1. BannisterR. The Four Minute Mile. N.Y.: Dodd, Mead, 1957. P.1112.

1 92

[99] 2014

, .
, , , , .
, ,, , .
, ,
.
6 1954,
, . , , ,
(Great Britains
Amateur Athletic Union, AAU), , , (International Amateur Athletic
Federation), . . ,
. , . , ,
. . , , .
, , , , ,
1954.
, . ,
, . ? ,
. , , . . ,
.
. .
,

193

,
,
, 1500 (0,93 ). , .
6 1954 . . 3:59:4.
, , ,
, ,
.


.
,
. , - ,
, .
,
, , (play, games, contests, sports).
, . , , ,
, 2.
. ,
, . , , . .
, , ,
, , . ,
, , ,
. 2. DiemC. Wesen und Lehre des Sports. B.; Fr.a.M.: Weidmannsche Verlags
Buchhandlung, 1949. P.10.

1 94

[99] 2014

. .
, ,
. , ,
, ,
: , 3.
. , , ,
, .
, .
Homo Ludens, . , , Deus Ludens4.
( ) (play) (games).
:
, . . - ,
? ,

, .
, , ;
. , . , : , /, , , . .
, .

3. AsheA., DefordF. Arthur Ashe. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1975. P.46.


4. .: FinkE. Oase des Glcks. Munich: Karl Alber, 1957; Idem. Spiel als Weltsym
bol. Stuttgart: Kohlhammer, 1966; Miller D.L. Gods and Games. N.Y.: World Pu
blishing Co., 1969.

195

, . . ,
, . .
, :
,
, ,
,
( ), ,
( )5.


, , , , , , .
?
, . , . , , ,

. , .
, , --6 ,
/. , , ,
, , , . ,
.
, .
, kemari,
5. SuitsB. The Elements of Sport// The Philosophy of Sport/ R.G.Osterhoudt (ed.).
Springfield, IL : CharlesC.Thomas, 1973. P.55. . : Idem. What Is a
Game?// Philosophy of Science. June 1967. 34. P.148156.
6. Ring Around the Rosie . . .

1 96

[99] 2014

, . , . ,
, , , , 7. . :
. 8. ,
kemari.
.
athlos () athlon ().
, , , , , , , - . .
,
. , , , ,
, .
(.1). :
. , , ,
( , ,
).

mo Ludens :
. ,
9. ()
. , , . ,
. 1119
7. .: Mathys F.K. Kultischer Fuball in Japan// Olympisches Feuer. April 1959.
6. P.1213.
8. YoudJ. Notes on Kickball in Micronesia// Journal of American Folklore. 1961.
74. P.64.
9. HuizingaJ. Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play Element in Culture. L.: Temple
Smith, 1970. P.98.

197

.1.

, 1240 10. , , , ? ,
, , ,
, . , , . . Homo Ludens :
,
, , ,
, 11.

, ,
, , , , , , .
, , ,
: ,
10. Jusserand J.J. Les Sports et jeux dexercice dans lancienne France. P.: Plon, 1901.
P.58.
11. CailloisR. Les Jeux et les hommes. P.: Callimard, 1958. P.32.

1 98

[99] 2014

12.
,
.
, , , , Sports Illustrated, . , - , .
, . , II,
, ,
.
13.
, protagoniste daction14,
15.
, .
, , .
, ,
, , 16. .
, (1976)
, , . :
, 17.
. , ,
. , .
, . (.2) , ?
12. : LoyJ. The Nature of
Sport: A Definitional Effort// Quest Monograph. May 1968. 10. P.115.
13. .: FinleyM.I., PleketH.W. The Olympic Games: The First Thousand Years.
N.Y.: Viking Press, 1976. P.3132.
14. (.). . .
15. .: GrittiJ. Sport a la une. P.: Armand Colin, 1975. P.114.
16. .: Gabriel R.H. Introduction// KroutJ.A. Annals of American Sport. New
Haven: Yale University Press, 1929. P.3.
17. Michener J.A. Sports in America. N.Y.: Random House, 1976. P.62.

199

()

()

.2. , , ,

., - , (1) ,
;
(2) , ; (3) 18. , - , ,
19. .
, .
18. .: Roberts J.M., Arth M.J., Bush R.R. Games in Culture// American Anthro
pologist. 1959. 61. P.597605; RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B. Child Train
ing and Game Involvement// Ethnology. 1962. 1. P.166185; Roberts J.M.,
Sutton-SmithB., KendonA. Strategy in Games and Folk Tales// Journal of Social
Psychology. 1963. 61. P.185199; Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M., KozelkaR.M.
Game Involvement in Adults// Journal of Social Psychology. 1963. 60. P.1530;
Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M. Rubrics of Competitive Behavior// Journal of
Genetic Psychology. 1964. 105. P.1337; RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B.CrossCultural Correlates of Games of Chance// Behavior Science Notes. 1966. 1.
P.131144; Sutton-Smith B.The Sporting Balance // Soziologie des Sports /
R.Albonico, K.Pfister-Binz (eds). Basel: Birkhauser, 1971. P.10513; Sutton-Smith
B., Roberts J.M. The Cross-Cultural and Psychological Study of Games// Inter
national Review for the Sociology of Sport. 1971. 6. P.7987; Sutton-SmithB.
Games, the Socialization of Conflict// SW . 1973. 3. P.4146; Sutton-SmithB.
Play as Adaptive Potentiation// SW . 1975. 5. P.103118; Ball D.W. The Scal
ing of Gaming// Pacific Sociological Review. July 1972. 15. P.277294; Idem.
What the Action Is// Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior. 1972. 2. P.121
143; Idem. Control versus Complexity// Pacific Sociological Review. 1974. 17.
P.167184.
19. .
: EichbergH. Spielverhalten und Relationsgesellschaft in West Sumatra//
Stadion. 1976. 1. P.1315.

2 00

[99] 2014

, -
, - , - , , , , ..
, , , 20.

. ,
, , , ,
, ,
.
. ,
(1924) . - , , , , ,
- 21. .
:

( ), ( , ), ( )22.
20. RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B.Child Training and Game Involvement// Sport,
Culture and Society/ J.W.Loy, G.S.Kenyon (eds). N.Y.: Macmillan, 1969. P.124.
21. Ibid. P.128.
22. Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M. The Cross-Cultural and Psychological Study of
Games. P.86.

201

:
, , , ,
, , , 23. ,
.
,
-. , .
. paideia ludus , (paideia) (ludus).
,
paideia ludus. : (1) , alea;
(2) , agon; (3) ; (4) ,
, ilinx.
, paideia, ,
, , , . , ludens, ,
, . ,
, ,, ,
: , , 24. ,
.
- ,

. :
, ,
, ilinx. , ,
, , , , ,
, , agon alea, 23. Ibidem.
24. CailloisR. Op. cit. P.142.

2 02

[99] 2014

.
25.

, -
, , .
, , , , , , agon alea.
.
, , ,
. . -
, , ,
.
, , ,
, , .
, . , , . , - 4
5 , .
. , , .
, .
,
(play) , : , ?
, . , . ,

. ,
25. Ibid. P.169170.

203

(1968) ( ) 26. -- .

.
?
.
, , , ,
.
, ,
: , , . ,
, , , .
, , .
, .
, .
, . , , , ,
. , , . , . . :
, , , ,
26. .: LoweB. The Aesthetics of Sport// Quest Monograph. 1971. 16. P.13
17; Idem. A Theoretical Rationale for Investigation into the Relationship of Sport
and Aesthetics// International Review for the Sociology of Sport. 1973. Vol.8.
1. P.95101; Idem. The Beauty of Sport. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice-Hall, 1977;
Keenan F.W. The Athletic Contest as a Tragic Form of Art// The Philosophy
of Sport/ R.G.Osterhoudt (ed.). Springfield, Illinois: CharlesC.Thomas, 1973.
P.309326; MitchellR. Sport as Experience// Quest Monograph. 1975. 24.
P.2833; Readings in the Aesthetics of Sport/ H. T.A.Whiting, D.W.Masterson
(eds). L.: Lepus Books, 1974.

2 04

[99] 2014

: (to play or
to display)27.
,
,
. , , . -,
. , , ,
, 28. ,
,
.
.
. ,
, ,
, , .
.

, , , ,
, . Homo Ludens
, ,
29. :

, , , ,
.
27. Ingham A.G., Smith M.D. Social Implications of the Interaction between
Spectators and Athletes// Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews. 1974. 2. P.202.
: Stone G.P. American
Sports Play and Dis-Play// Chicago Review. 9. 1955. 3. P.83100.
.: LaschC. The Corruption of Sports// New
York Review of Books. April 28, 1977. 24. P.2430.
28. BarthesR. Mythologies. P.: Editions du Seuil, 1970. P.17. .: Stone G.P.,
Oldenburg R.A. Wrestling// Motivations in Play, Games and Sports/ R.Slovenko,
J.A.Knight (eds). Springfield, IL : CharlesC.Thomas, 1967. P.503532.
29. HuizingaJ. Op. cit. P.32.

205

, , 30.

, , ().
?
, , , .
,
. ! . ,
. , . ,
- ?

,
: .
, , , . ,
, . , ,
, .
, ,
. , ,
. , . .
, 31.
30. CailloisR. Op. cit. P.37.
31. : Ingham A.G., Loy J.W. The Structure of Ludic Action// International Review for
the Sociology of Sport. 9. 1974. 1. P.2360.

2 06

[99] 2014

, ,
, . , , . -
,
, , -
. , ,
, (
), , . , .
REFERENCES
AsheA., DefordF. Arthur Ashe, Boston, Houghton Mifflin, 1975.
BallD. Control versus Complexity. Pacific Sociological Review, 1974, no.17, pp.167184.
BallD.W. The Scaling of Gaming. Pacific Sociological Review, July 1972, no.15,
pp.277294.
BallD. What the Action Is. Journal for the Theory of Social Behavior, 1972, no.2,
pp.121143.
BannisterR. The Four Minute Mile, New York, Dodd, Mead, 1957.
BarthesR. Mythologies, Paris, Seuil, 1970.
CailloisR. Les Jeux et les homes, Paris, Callimard, 1958.
DiemC. Wesen und Lehre des Sports, Berlin, Frankfurt am Main, Weidmannsche
Verlagsbuchhandlung, 1949.
EichbergH. Spielverhalten und Relationsgesellschaft in West Sumatra. Stadion, 1976,
no.1, pp.1315.
FinkE. Oase des Glcks, Munich, Karl Alber, 1957.
FinkE. Spiel als Weltsymbol, Stuttgart, Kohlhammer, 1966.
FinleyM.I., PleketH.W. The Olympic Games: The First Thousand Years, New York,
Viking Press, 1976.
GabrielR.H. Introduction. In: KroutJ.A. Annals of American Sport, New Haven, Yale
University Press, 1929.
GrittiJ. Sport a la une, Paris, Armand Colin, 1975.
GuttmannA. Play, Games, Contests, Sports. From Ritual to Record. The Nature of
Modern Sport, New York, Columbia University Press, 1978, pp.114.
HuizingaJ. Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play Element in Culture, London, Temple Smith,
1970.
InghamA.G., LoyJ.W. The Structure of Ludic Action. International Review for the
Sociology of Sport, 9, 1974, no.1, pp.2360.
InghamA.G., SmithM.D. Social Implications of the Interaction between Spectators
and Athletes. Exercise and Sport Sciences Reviews, 1974, no.2.
Jusserand J.J. Les Sports et jeux dexercice dans lancienne France, Paris, Plon, 1901.
KeenanF.W. The Athletic Contest as a Tragic Form of Art. The Philosophy of Sport
(ed. R.G.Osterhoudt), Springfield, Illinois, CharlesC.Thomas, 1973, pp.309326.

207

LaschC. The Corruption of Sports. New York Review of Books, April 28, 1977, no.24,
pp.2430.
LoweB. A Theoretical Rationale for Investigation into the Relationship of Sport
and Aesthetics. International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 1973, vol.8, no.1,
pp.95101.
LoweB. The Aesthetics of Sport. Quest Monograph, 1971, no.16, pp.1317.
LoweB. The Beauty of Sport, Englewood Cliffs, Prentice-Hall, 1977.
LoyJ. The Nature of Sport: A Definitional Effort. Quest Monograph, May 1968, no.10,
pp.115.
MathysF.K. Kultischer Fuball in Japan. Olympisches Feuer, April 1959, no.6.
Michener J.A. Sports in America, New York, Random House, 1976.
Miller D.L. Gods and Games, New York, World Publishing Co., 1969.
MitchellR. Sport as Experience. Quest Monograph, 1975, no.24, pp.2833.
RobertsJ.M., ArthM.J., BushR.R. Games in Culture. American Anthropologist, 1959,
no.61, pp.597605.
RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B.Child Training and Game Involvement. Ethnology, 1962,
no.1, pp.166185.
RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B.Child Training and Game Involvement. Sport, Culture
and Society (eds J.W.Loy, G.S.Kenyon), New York, Macmillan, 1969.
RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B.Cross-Cultural Correlates of Games of Chance. Behavior
Science Notes, 1966, no.1, pp.131144.
RobertsJ.M., Sutton-Smith B., KendonA. Strategy in Games and Folk Tales. Journal
of Social Psychology, 1963, no.61, pp.185199.
StoneG.P. American Sports Play and Dis-Play. Chicago Review, 1955, vol.9, no.3,
pp.83100.
Stone G.P., Oldenburg R.A. Wrestling. Motivations in Play, Games and Sports (eds
R.Slovenko, J.A.Knight), Springfield, IL , CharlesC.Thomas, 1967, pp.503532.
SuitsB. The Elements of Sport. The Philosophy of Sport (ed. R.G.Osterhoudt),
Springfield, IL , CharlesC.Thomas, 1973.
SuitsB. What Is a Game? Philosophy of Science, June 1967, no.34, pp.148156.
Sutton-Smith B.Games, the Socialization of Conflict. Sportswissenschaft, 1973, no.3,
pp.4146.
Sutton-Smith B.Play as Adaptive Potentiation. Sportswissenschaft, 1975, no.5, pp.103118.
Sutton-Smith B.The Sporting Balance. Soziologie des Sports (eds R.Albonico, K.PfisterBinz), Basel, Birkhauser, 1971, pp.105113.
Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M. Rubrics of Competitive Behavior. Journal of Genetic
Psychology, 1964, no.105, pp.1337.
Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M. The Cross-Cultural and Psychological Study of Games.
International Review for the Sociology of Sport, 1971, no.6, pp.7987.
Sutton-Smith B., RobertsJ.M., KozelkaR.M. Game Involvement in Adults. Journal of
Social Psychology, 1963, no.60, pp.1530.
WhitingH.T. A., MastersonD.W., eds. Readings in the Aesthetics of Sport, London,
Lepus Books, 1974.
YoudJ. Notes on Kickball in Micronesia. Journal of American Folklore, 1961, no.74.

2 08

[99] 2014

. , -.
: 1 Saxon Dr., Alfred,
NY 14802, USA .
E-mail: westacott@alfred.edu.
: , ,
, ,
, ,
.

.
,
. ,
,
, . , ,
.



, ,
,
.
, .

THE ETHOS OF FOOTBALL:


GALAHAD VS ODYSSEUS
Emrys Westacott. PhD in Philosophy,
Professor of Philosophy at Alfred University in Western New York.
Address: 1 Saxon Dr., Alfred,
NY 14802, USA .
E-mail: westacott@alfred.edu.
Keywords: ethics, sport, sportsmanship,
fair play, honour code, fouls, cheating.
The article discusses the principles of fair
play in contemporary sports and seeks to
define the concept of cheating. The
author points out two moral positions,
the Odyssian attitude and the Galahadian attitude. The first assumes that
sport is not possible without a certain
amount of cheating, as athletes and
coaches only care about results, and not
about how they are achieved. The second,
in contrast, insists on strict observance
of the rules of fair play. Based on examples from the history of various championships and on discussions of the most
famous cases of cheating and judicial
errors, the author insists that sports
would become much more attractive to
viewers the Galahadian position characterized the dominant mode of action.
However, the author does not believe that
the Galahadian attitude should be
extended to other areas of life.


209


2010
.
1:1, . , . ,
1. , . ,
.
. , , , . . ,
.
, .

: WestacottE. Galahad Versus Odysseus: The Clash Between Honor Codes and Strategic Thinking in Sport and Beyond// Philosophy Now. MayJune 2012. 90. P.2025.
.
1. , , . , ( ) ,

, , . . FIFA, , ,
. . .

2 10

[99] 2014

, . , ,
. ,
, .

. , , , . , , , .
. ? , ? ,
? , ( ),
, ?

. . ,
. , , , -
. ,
.
.

. ,
, .
, , . , ,
.
, . , , , , .

211

?
,
: ,
?
, . , .
, , ,
. ,
, . .
-, , ,
. ,
?
, . , ! , , , , , , (),
, .
. ? .
-, , , . .
, ,
,
- .
, , , . , ,
. ,
, , ,
, , . , , ,
.
, , . , .
, 2 12

[99] 2014

,
, , . - ;
, (good fouls).
, ,
, ,
. , , , ,
, ,
, .
, .
, , .
.
.
-, . , ,
, .
,
, . , ,
.
-, . -, , , , . , ,
, . , . ,

(sportsmanship) .
. , ? ,
.

213

.
:
. ? , . .
? ,
, :
? ,
. , .
, .
,
. ,
,
. , ,, , , ,
, .
, , , ,
, , , .
, ,
. , ,
,
, ,
,
. ,
. , , . ,
, , , . , ,
,
2 14

[99] 2014

. , ,
, , , . ( , , , , ,
.) , , , -. , .
, , , .
, , , , , . ,
, , (Winning isnt
everything its the only thing), ,
, . (, : ,
!
.) ,
. , , ,
- .

? ,
? ,
. , , , . ,
. , , , . , .
,
. , ,
, .
, , , .

215

, ,
,

. , , , . , , ?
, ,, .
, ,
, , , ,
.

, . , .
,
,
: ? ,
2008 , , .
, , .
, , , , .
( ,
). , , , . ,
, , . ,
, ,
.
, ( !), 2 16

[99] 2014

. 2005 . .
, , . , , , .

. 2001
, , .
. ,
,
, . .
,
. , , ,
.

,
. , , ,
2010.
, .
, . .
. , , , ,
( !), .
,
, 88% .
.
; . ,

217

, , : .
, , , , (
) .
? . , , . , ,
, .
, , ,

, ,
.
2010
( )
.
.
, , , .
,
, . ,
, , .
,
. 4:1.
:
, . , , (), ,
, ().

, . ,
, . . ,
, , , .
, , .
. , , -
2 18

[99] 2014

: , .
, ?
. , ,
.
, , . , ,
.
, , ,, ,
2:2. . .
,
, .
, ,, , .
, : ? , , , ,
.
: . , . , ,
.
. ,
, , , .

. , ,
, , : ?

219

: ? , , , - .
:
,
?
, 2006, ,
.
200 ., ,
100 , , , .
20. , 10.
. .
, . , , .
,
. ,
- , ,
. Pew Research Center,
2010, .
, , , , , . , .
-, . .

. , : .
,
! !, . - ,
2 20

[99] 2014

.
,
.
. , .
, ,
: , ,
. , ,
, . , , ,
. ,
, .
, .
: ? , , , ,
. , , , , , , . , ,
. , ,
, , , , , . ,
, , , .
,
, ,
,
,
, .

221

. ,
. - ,
. , , , . - , , ,
, , , ,
, . , ,
, , .
, ,
, .

2 22

[99] 2014

.
,


....
: 117312, ,
. 60- , 7/2.
E-mail: eumenius@gmail.com.
: , ,
, .

.
,
,
.



,

.

DOPING IN SPORTS: History,


Limits, Perspectives
Evgeny Kulikov. PhD in Biology,
Senior Fellow at the Institute of
Microbiology, Russian Academy of
Science.
Address: 7/2 60th Anniversary of
October Prospect, 117312 Moscow,
Russia.
E-mail: eumenius@gmail.com.
Keywords: doping, chemical doping,
muscle growth stimulation, biological doping.
Doping in sports is a serious challenge for modern medicine. New
kinds of doping, as a result of current advances in the area of human
molecular biology, poses a new set of
questions to scientists. To understand the possible future development of doping practices, we must
address history of the issue and
imagine how humanity might face
the new challenges of the age.


223


. ,
.
,
,
.
,

.
,
, , . ,
1. XIX
. ,
,
,
.
.
XX,

, ,
, ,

, 23 2013

...
XXI .
1. . . , , , , , , , .

2 24

[99] 2014

.
,
,
.

. ..

.
,
, 2 ( )
,
. , ,
, . , . .

, .

.

,
.
,
.

. ,
,

. ,

1944, ,
, , .
,
,
.

.
,
,
2. , (. -), , ; (
).

225

, ,

.
,
.
: ,
, ..
1950.
( .)
1930, ,
. , , .
, ( ..)
, .
.
,
. , , , ,
. 1930 .
,
1954
,
. ,
, , ,
. ,
, -
:
, .
.
( )
,
. 1947
,
.

, .
, 3,
3. . , ,

2 26

[99] 2014

.
,
,
, .
,
.
,
.
,
. ,
, .
,

.

.
, .
:
,
,
.
: ,
.
,
- .
,
. ,
, 15
100%- .
,
,
, .
,
, ,

.. :
, , , , , .
, , .
1970 (3).

227


.
.

.
. , ,
,
.
,
,
.

. ,
,
,
. ,
:
,
(
).
,
,
,
.
. , 1
2 .
, ,
..
,
.
, .
,
, ,
, ,
, .
: ,
. ,
, ,
- ,
,
.
.
2 28

[99] 2014

.
,
,
. ,
:
.
.
,
,
.

. ,
,
,
.
, , ,
. (,
)
.

, . ( ,

, , ,
.
,
. ,

, .)
,
,
.

,

.
,
,
.
,
, 15 ?
,
.

229

.
,
.


. ,
,
. , ,
-,
.
, ,
. (


, , .)
, ,
. ,
, ,
,

.

2 30

[99] 2014

1993

. ,

-.
: 1 Gatterstrae,
CH -9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland.
E-mail: ulrich.schmid@unisg.ch.
: , , , ,
.
.
-
,
, ,

,
.
, ,
, .

,
.


, ,
.

POLITICAL RELIGION IN RUSSIA.


The Constitution 1993 as a Holy
Scripture
Ulrich Schmid. PhD in Slavic Philology,
Professor of Russian Studies at the University of St. Gallen.
Address: 1 Gatterstrae,
CH -9000 St. Gallen, Switzerland.
E-mail: ulrich.schmid@unisg.ch.
Keywords: consitution, political religion,
inauguration, law, culture.
The article examines the discursive status
of the constitution in the Russian political
system. Starting from Ernst-Wolfgang
Bckenfrdes affirmation that the liberal
state is not able to guarantee its own premises, it is argued that many contemporary
states use political ceremonies in order to
veil this paradox. A case in point is the
inaugurational oath of office in the USA ,
which usually is taken on the bible. In Russia, the president takes his oath on a special copy of the Russian constitution which
functions as a kind of a Holy Scripture.
Generally, the constitution plays an important role in Russia not only in the legal system, but also in the political religion that
reassures the social legitimacy of Putins
power.


231

1976 - ,

:
, , . , . ,
, , , .
,
, ,
( )
, 1.


.

. , , ,
.
.
1. BckenfrdeE.-W.Staat, Gesellschaft, Freiheit. Fr.a.M., 1976. S.60.

2 32

[99] 2014


. , . , ,
, , , , . , , .
1939 .
, , 1936 - 2. , -
.
, .
10 - , ,
. ,

.
:
, , : , ,
3.


. ,
, , . 1 2. VoegelinE. Die politischen Religionen. Stockholm, 1939; Idem. Der autoritre
Staat. Wien, 1936.
3. Miller R.F. Geist und Gesicht des Bolschewismus. Darstellung und Kritik des
kulturellen Lebens in Sowjet-Ruland. Zrich, 1926. S.1.

233

.
. , , , : ,
: ,
, ,
.
, . , ,
,
.
A
, 11 .
, -., ,
. ,
, 4.

.
.
, . , ,
, 5.
4. GentileE. Gods Democracy. American Religion after September 11. Westport,
2008. P.139148.
5. LindquistG., HandelmanD. The Long Past Foregrounding the Short
Present Prologue and Introduction// Religion, Politics, and Globalization:
Anthropological Approaches/ G.Lindquist, D.Handelman (eds). N.Y., 2011.
P.168, 48.

2 34

[99] 2014

, 2009. , 1861. ,
( -, ). , 20 2009 , , ,
, . ,
, .
, 6. ,

. , .
. , .
. . ,
, . , .
, , .
, ,
1996
7.
, -
. 6. AndrewsJ. Barack Obama and Leadership: 10 Reasons the 44th President
Squandered Unprecedented Goodwill. Washington, 2012. P.126.
7. .URL : www.legis.ru/misc/doc/1810/.

235


.
. , .
, .

.
, ,
. .
- :
8.
,
. , 1964
. , , , , , . ,
9.

, . : , ,
, 10. , 8. Von SteinsdorffS. Die Verfassungsgenese der Zweiten Russischen und der Fnften
Franzsischen Republik im Vergleich// Zeitschrift fr Parlamentsfragen. 1995.
Bd.26. S.486504.
9. Zorgbibe Ch. De Gaulle, Mitterrand et lesprit de la Constitution. P., 1994.
10. SakwaR. The Crisis of Russian Democracy: The Dual State, Factionalism, and the
Medvedev Succession. Cambridge, 2011.

2 36

[99] 2014

.
, . o ,
,
.
-
. 1994
12, , . , . 2000 . 2005
.
(28), (3)
(7)11.
, , , .
, ; ;
. , , ,

.
, ,
,
. , ,
. . , 11. .URL : www.consultant.ru/document/cons_doc_LAW _153949/.

237

762 ,
. ,
, . 21 1993
, , . , .
,
. 6 . , ,
. 1993
, .
12. .8390 .
, , 13. .80 :
1. .
2. ,
.
, ,
14.
, . 12. Ahdieh R.B. Russias Constitutional Revolution. Legal Consciousness and the
Transition to Democracy, 19851996. University Park, 1997. P.5673.
13. Scheppele K.L. We forgot about the ditches: Russian Constitutional Impatience
and the Challenge of Terrorism// Drake Law Review. 20042005. Vol.53. P.963
1027, 995.
14. .URL : http://www.constitution.ru/10003000/100030006.htm.

2 38

[99] 2014

. -
15. , , , .
, ,
- 16.
. .84 .
,
,
. . 14 .
. 1982 . . 1980

:
(
) , , .. (
) . !
: (,
- ). : . : , ,
: , ( ), , ... <>

15. Scheppele K.L. A Comparative View of the Chief Justices Role. Guardians of the
Constitution: Constitutional Court Presidents and the Struggle for the Rule of
Law in Post-Soviet Europe// University of Pennsylvania Law Review. 20052006.
Vol.154. P.17561851, 1767.
16. Ibid. P.1835.

239

, (
), .
?17


, . ,
.
. . ,
,
, , , .

.
. . ,
, . ,
.
, 6 2012 . ,
: , .

18. , , .
, , ,
.
17. .. a ( : ). ., 1994. .7677.
18. : // .
6.2.2012. URL : http://www.kommersant.ru/doc/1866753.

2 40

[99] 2014

, , . , .
.
, , 20
12 2013.
(. . 89). , , , , ,

. , ()
, ,
,
.
REFERENCES
Ahdieh R.B.Russias Constitutional Revolution. Legal Consciousness and the Transition to
Democracy, 19851996, University Park, Pennsylvania State University Press, 1997.
AndrewsJ. Barack Obama and Leadership: 10 Reasons the 44th President Squandered Unprecedented Goodwill, Washington, Steward Publishing, 2012.
BckenfrdeE.-W. Staat, Gesellschaft, Freiheit, Frankfurt am Main, 1976.
Buzgalin A.V. Belaia vorona (poslednii god zhizni T sK KPSS : vzgliad iznutri) [White crow
(AnInside Look at the last year of life of the Central Committee of the CPSU )],
Moscow, Ekonomicheskaia demokratiia, 1994.
GentileE. Gods Democracy. American Religion after September 11, Westport, Praeger,
2008.
LindquistG., HandelmanD. The Long Past Foregrounding the Short Present Prologue and Introduction. Religion, Politics, and Globalization: Anthropological Approaches (eds G.Lindquist, D.Handelman), New York, Berghahn Books, 2011.
Miller R.F. Geist und Gesicht des Bolschewismus. Darstellung und Kritik des kulturellen
Lebens in Sowjet-Ruland, Zrich, Amalthea, 1926.
PutinV.V. Demokratiia i kachestvo gosudarstva [Democracy and the quality of
state]. Kommersant, February 06, 2012. Available at: http://www.kommersant.
ru/doc/1866753.
SakwaR. The Crisis of Russian Democracy: The Dual State, Factionalism, and the Medvedev Succession, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2011.
ScheppeleK.L. We forgot about the ditches: Russian Constitutional Impatience and
the Challenge of Terrorism. Drake Law Review, 20042005, vol.53.

241

ScheppeleK.L. A Comparative View of the Chief Justices Role. Guardians of the Constitution: Constitutional Court Presidents and the Struggle for the Rule of Law in
Post-Soviet Europe. University of Pennsylvania Law Review, 20052006, vol.154.
VoegelinE. Der autoritre Staat, Wien, Springer, 1936.
VoegelinE. Die politischen Religionen, Stockholm, Bermann Fischer, 1939.
Von SteinsdorffS. Die Verfassungsgenese der Zweiten Russischen und der Fnften
Franzsischen Republik im Vergleich. Zeitschrift fr Parlamentsfragen, 1995,
vol.26, pp.486504.
Zorgbibe Ch. De Gaulle, Mitterrand et lesprit de la Constitution, Paris, Hachette, 1994.

2 42

[99] 2014

.
, ,



....
: 119991, ,
, 1, .1314.
E-mail: s9895929@yandex.ru.
: , ,
,
,
.


- .
1993,


,



.

THE RUSSIAN CONSTITUTION:


From Crisis to Development
Sergei Shakhray. Doctor of Legal
Sciences, Professor, Prorector and
Dean of Higher School of Public
Audit Moscow State University.
Address: Bldg 1314, 1 Leninskiye
Gory, Moscow 119991, Russia.
E-mail: s9895929@yandex.ru.
Keywords: Constitution of Russia,
state and law, transformation processes, change management, contemporary Russian history.
The article is devoted to new
approaches to understanding the role
of the Basic Law as a tool for managing large-scale social transformations.
The author, who was one of the architects of the 1993 Constitution of Russia, reveals the aspects of functional
organization and goals of this document, evaluates the results of the
practical implementation of constitutional models and demonstrates yet
unrevealed creative possibilities of
the current Basic Law.


243

, (. constitutio ) , , . ,
,
,
, .. , ,
,
, ,
.
:
, , ,
;

,
.
- ,
- ,
.
, , .

2 44

[99] 2014

, , , , .
, , , . ,
.
1980 1990 .
, .

1993 ,
1978 .
. , , , .
1970, - , , .
, ,
. ,
. .
, , . , , .
- , .

245

(1988), (1989). (1989), 1990 .


, , .

1978 ( 1977)
. - - , -
, ,

. ,
, .
,
, .
27
1989, 1.
,
. , , ,
12 1993 .

,
. 1993
1. 27 1989 ( ) // . 1989. 44.
. 1303; 27 1989 // . 1989. 44. . 1305.

2 46

[99] 2014

,
, , , .
, 12 1993

:
, - ,
, ,
.
, 12
1993, .
1989
1991. 1978 , , .
, , , . ,

. ,
, ,
. , 1990 , , . ,
, ,
.

1991 12 1993.
,
.

247



,
.
,
.
1978,
, , .
, 1988 1977 1989 .
. 1068 , 900 , 168 - .
, ,
. , ,
, ,

: .
(16 22
1990 ) 16
1991 . 29 1991
,
,
. 102 .
.
. ,
2 48

[99] 2014

,
1989 , .
, , .
, , , , , ,
. ,

.
1990 2.

, .
12 1990 1 3.
; ; ,
,
, -
4.
24 1991
,
. ,
2. .: 16 1990 381 ( ) // . 1990. 3. . 25.
3. 12 1990
22-I //
. 1990. 2. . 22.
4. .: 15 1990 4231 ( ) // . 1990. 29. . 395.

249

.
, ,


5. -
.
, ,
, , , , ,
, , () , ,
.
, , , :
. ,
()
.
1921 1991
.
,
. , 1 1991 6.
24 1991 . ,

5. .: 24 1991 1096-I // . 1991. 17. . 510;


24 1991 1098-I //
. 1991. 17. . 512.
6. .: . 14 1 1991 1827-I ( ) //
. 1991. 45. . 1497.

2 50

[99] 2014

7.
,
8.
25 1991, 19 00 , .. , .
.
, , .
. , V 2 1991
9.

.
- , , , , , .
,
, .
7. ,
.
8. 25 1991 2094-I
// . 1992. 2. . 62.
9. 2 1991
18371 // . 1992. 13.
.268271.

251

(, ) .

, ,
,
.
, .
,
.
1991 1992
400 , . , , .
. , ,
,
.
. , .
, , , - . , , ,

. , , ,
, .
, , , .
2 52

[99] 2014

,
,
. , , (, , ).
1978
, .
,
, .
,
, , ,
10.
-, .
, .
.
, 1993
. . , , 25 1993 ---.
:

58,7% , ;
10. .: .. : . .: , 2003. .84.

253

- .. 53,0%
, ;
49,5% , 31,7%
, ;

67,2%
, 43,1% ,
.
,
, ,
11.
1993 , .
, ,
, . . ,
- .., .. , , 12.

- . , .
11. .. : 19921993. .: ,
1995. .328; .. : 2 ..: ,
1994. .1. .120121.
12. -2000: (19851999). .:
, 2000. .1. . .231; ., ., . .
.: - , 1996. .308.

2 54

[99] 2014

,
.
,
, , ,
, .

19921993 .


.
, , , ,
, . ,
.
29 1993

13.
29 1993 .. , ,
, . 14.
, , ,
, .
13. 29 1993 4907-I //
. 1993. 19. . 696.
14. . .., ..//
. 30.4.1993.

255

12 1993 .. 15, 5 .
1993
.

,
;
, , , , , -; ; , , , ,
, 16. ,

,
, , , , , . 760 .
5
1993 . ,
,
. .

,

.
15. 12 1993 660
//
. 1993. 20. . 1757.
16. 20 1993 718 // . 1993. 21. . 1903.

2 56

[99] 2014

12 1993, .
50 .
,
, 30
.
. 1993
.
, . , ,

1993 .
.
1993 ,
, . ,
, .
1993
-
. - ,
.
.
, -
,

257

. .
,
.
,
.
.
,
12 1993 (
)
,
17.
12 1993 , .
, , ,
.

20
1993. 32 937.
630, 58,4% ,
. , .
25 1993 .

.

, , : 17. 15 1993 1633


// .
1993. 42. . 3995.

2 58

[99] 2014

.
, , (. 2).
. , , , . ,

, ( ).
,
. .1 . 15 : , .
, ,
.
,
, .
, , ,
,
18.
1990 ,

, ,
19.
,

18. .: .. . .: , 2005.
19. 31 1995 8 //
. 1995. 247. 28.

259

20. .
, .
, ,
.
, . , .
.
, , . , .
, ,
,
, . , . ,
.
, ,
.
.
.

.
20. . 4 ,

, , , .

2 60

[99] 2014


.
, , .


.
, , ,
..
,

.
, , . ,
,

.
?

20 . ,

. , . .
,
. , , ,
, .
-,
.
-,
. ,

261

,
,
.

, . , ,
, ,
.
,
- , . 1980 1990 ,
.
,

, . , . ,
, , ,
, .
. , . , ,
,
.
, , .
,
,
, . 2000
2 62

[99] 2014

53% , 2012 45%21.


,
,
, .
, , .
,
. ,
, : . , . .
.
REFERENCES
Baglai M.V. Konstitutsionnoe pravo Rossiiskoi Federatsii: Uchebnik dlia vuzov [Constitutional law of the Russian Federation: A Textbook for high schools], Moscow,
NORMA , 2003.
Isakov V.B.Gosperevorot: Parlamentskie dnevniki 19921993 [oup detat: Parliamentary diaries of 19921993], Moscow, Paleia, 1995.
Khasbulatov R.I. Velikaia rossiiskaia tragediia [Great Russian tragedy], Moscow, SIMS ,
1994.
Konstitutsiia Rossii: meniat ili ne meniat? [The Russian Constitution: to change or not
to change?]. Press release of the Russian Public Opinion Research Center, 11.12.2012,
no.2186. Available at: http://wciom.ru/?id=459&uid=113463.
Konstitutsiia Rossiiskoi Federatsii. ProektS.S.Alekseeva, S.M.Shakhraia [Constitution of the Russian Federation. The draft of S.S.Alekseev and S.M.Shakhrai].
Izvestiia, April 30.
Konstitutsionnyi vestnik [Constitutional Reporter], 1992, no.13.
Luchin V.O. Entsiklopediia iurista [Encyclopedia of lawyer], Moscow, Iurist, 2005.
Postanovlenie Plenuma Verkhovnogo Suda Rossiiskoi Federatsii ot 31 oktiabria 1995
goda no.8 O nekotorykh voprosakh primeneniia sudami Konstitutsii Rossiiskoi Federatsii pri osushchestvlenii pravosudiia [Resolution of the Plenum of
the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation On several issues of judicial implementation of the Constitution of the Russian Federation, 31.10.1995, no.8].
Rossiiskaia gazeta, December 28, 1995, no.247.

21. - : ?.
11.12.2012. 2186. URL : http://wciom.ru/?id=459&uid=113463.

263

Rossiia2000: Sovremennaia politicheskaia istoriia (19851999 gody) [Russia 2000: Contemporary Political History (19851999)], Moscow, VOPD Dukhovnoe nasledie,
2000.
Sobranie aktov Prezidenta i Pravitelstva RF [Collection of Acts of the President and the
Government of the Russian Federation], 1993, no.20.
Sobranie aktov Prezidenta i Pravitelstva RF [Collection of Acts of the President and the
Government of the Russian Federation], 1993, no.21.
Sobranie aktov Prezidenta i Pravitelstva RF [Collection of Acts of the President and the
Government of the Russian Federation], 1993, no.42.
Vedomosti Sezda narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the Congress of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1990, no.2.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1990, no.3.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1990, no.29.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1991, no.17.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1991, no.45.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1992, no.2.
Vedomosti Soveta narodnykh deputatov i Verkhovnogo Soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the
Council of Peoples Deputies and the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1993, no.19.
Vedomosti Verkhovnogo soveta RSFSR [Bulletin of the Supreme Soviet of the Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic], 1989, no.44.
VerkhovskiiA., PappA., PribylovskiiV. Politicheskii ekstremizm v Rossii [Political extremism in Russia], Moscow, Institut eksperimentalnoi sotsiologii, 1996.

2 64

[99] 2014

. ,
,
.
: 105120, ,
4 ., 1, .3.
E-mail: skavt@yandex.ru.
: ,
, ,
.


.
,

.
,


. , ,

,

, ,
,
,
,
,
.



.

T H E G A R DE N OF RU S SIA N
C U LT U R E . A Historio graphical
Analysis of Contemp orary Utopia
Sergey Kavtaradze. Art and architec
tural historian, lecturer at the Winzavod
Centre for Contemporary Art.
Address: Bldg3, 1 4th Syromyatnichesky
lane, 105120 Moscow, Russia.
E-mail: skavt@yandex.ru.
Keywords: utopia, Russia not Europe, sover
eignty of culture, negative creativity, the
end of postmodernism.
The author examines recent events in the
cultural life in Moscow from a historians
point of view. He draws his analysis from
three sources which have become histori
cal over the course of the past few months.
The sources describe an imaginary picture
of an accurate, proper reality as seen by
agroup of proponents of civilization theo
ries. This picture, in turn, fits into an invar
iant pattern of the etatist utopia that
implies the boundedness of the zone in
which a social project is realized, the exist
ence of a special world within an isolated
historical moment, the urge for quantitative
certainty and total mental control over
being. However, the inability of proponents
of such discourses to create leads them to
the idea of eliminating unwanted elements
in order to let proper culture blossom.


265

. .
.

, , , ,
. , , .
, , , , .

, , , - .
. IX , 9 2014
.., : ,
, , , , 1. -

1. , .,
.: COLTA.RU // Colta.Ru. 9.04.2014. URL : http://www.colta.ru/news/3501.

2 66

[99] 2014

( 1114 2014),
: ,
, .
, ,
. , ,
10
2014. : , ,
, ,
2 . , , ..
. , .
, .
( , ) , . -
,
. , ,
, ,
( -). . : , 3.

, Colta.Ru
.
2. :
// : . 10.04.2014. URL : http://portal-kultura.ru/articles/country/
36886-minkult-preduprezhdaet-sovremennoe-iskusstvo-mozhet-byt-opasnodlya-zdorovya-rossiyan/.
3. .

267

. -, , .
.
, , .
,
, .
-, 4 ( , :
).
, . , , , , ,
, . , , . ?
,
. , 25 2014,
.. : ( ).
. ,

, , ,
, , , , ,
.

. ,
. ,
, .
4. . . . ., 2012.URL : www.olzhas.ru/
pics/File/Podushki.doc.

2 68

[99] 2014

. , .
, ,
, , , 5.

,
, , , , .

( ..) :

. ?
. . , ,
, .
, , ,
, , .
. , . . , , , , , .

, , :
: , .

, , , . ,
: , , , ,,
, , . ,
, 5. .. // YouTube. 31.03.2014.URL :
http://youtu.be/HDMX g3xBeYw.

269

.
, , .
, (, , , ), , , , .

,
, ,
. , .
. (18221885), , . - ,
,
, , , . 1,
, :
, , , ,
, - ,
.

:
3. -
. ,
.

, ,
, , , . , 2 70

[99] 2014

-
. -, , , , ,
. -,
, ,

. ,
. -,

, ,
.
, . . ,
, XIX,
, XXI, -

. ,
.
, , ,
.
, , .
. :
5. -
, , .

- (, .) - , . , ,
. , .

271

, , .
, , .
. , ..
: , ,
, . (
- : , , , , , , ,
, , ; ,
, .) , , , 193
,
, , ,
.
, , , ,

.
, , , .
. , , ,
. -
, ,
,
, . -

,
. , , .
. , XX. , ,

, . 2 72

[99] 2014


. , , , () , (-,
). , ,
. , , .

,
, .
, .
(
, ),
. ,
. ,
, , , . , ,
.
, , . ,
, , , . ,
, , (
).

273

, , . , . , , ,
, , ,
.
,
6.
, ,
. , ?

: , , . , ( ) , .
, . 810 . :
, . , ,
,
, . ,
, , , - :

: , , ,
, 7.

6. : .
// . 1990. 11, 12.
7. :
-

2 74

[99] 2014

, ,
8
, , .
, , , , . ,
. ,
.
,
, . , 9.

- . , , , - ,
. , , , ,
.
. ,
, ,
, , , -
, .
, , ,
, URL : http://www.mgsv.org/article/1774.html.
8.
.: .. //
. ., 1984. .102.
9.

275


. , , , ,
, . ,
.
.
, . , , .
. :

, .

, ,
. :
, , .. , , , . ,
, , , , ,
, -
, !

, , .
, , . ,
. ,
. ,
, . , , , . , ,
, .
2 76

[99] 2014

,
. . . , .
, , ,
.
-, -
. ,
, , , .
, , , , , .
-,
. , . (,
, ,
). .
, . .
.
.
, , .
, ,
. , ? , , , . ,
.
, , , , - . , ,
. , ,
( ),

277

. , , , , , .
REFERENCES
KavtaradzeS. Khronotop kultury stalinizma [The chronotope of culture of Stalinism].
Arkhitektura i stroitelstvo Moskvy [Architecture and Construction in Moscow],
1990, no.11, 12.
Minkult preduprezhdaet: sovremennoe iskusstvo mozhet byt opasno dlia zdorovia
rossiian [Ministry of Culture warns: contemporary art can be dangerous for the
health of Russians]. Gazeta Kultura: Dukhovnoe prostranstvo russkoi Evrazii
[The newspaper Culture: Spiritual Space of Russian Eurasia], April 10, 2014.
Available at: http://portal-kultura.ru/articles/country/36886-minkult-preduprezhdaet-sovremennoe-iskusstvo-mozhet-byt-opasno-dlya-zdorovya-rossiyan/.
PanchenkoD.V. Iambul i Kampanella [Iambulos and Campanella]. Antichnoe nasledie
v kulture Vozrozhdeniia [Ancient heritage in the culture of the Renaissance],
Moscow, Nauka, 1984.
AristarkhovV.V. Vremia pravdy i spravedlivosti [Time of truth and justice]. YouTube,
March 31, 2014. Available at: http://youtu.be/HDMX g3xB eY w.
Programma COLTA.RU na MMOKF otmenena po trebovaniiu Minkulta [Colta.Ru programme of events on Moscow International Open Book Festival canceled on the
demand of the Ministry of Culture]. Colta.Ru, April 9, 2014. Available at: http://
www.colta.ru/news/3501.
Rezoliutsiia Moskovskogo obshchestvennogo foruma Suverenitet kultury: vremia
pravdy i spravedlivosti [Resolution of the Moscow Public Forum Sovereignty of culture: Time of truth and justice]. Moskovskii gorodskoi sovet veteranov
[Moscow City Council of Veterans], April 2, 2014. Available at: http://www.mgsv.
org/article/1774.html.
ZhanaidarovO. Dusha podushki. Pesa dlia detei [Soul of pillows. Piece for children],
Moscow, 2012. Available at: www.olzhas.ru/pics/File/Podushki.doc.

2 78

[99] 2014


?
. .
/ . . .. ...
.: , 2014. 752 .

( ,
)
, ,
,
:
. . , ( , ) ,
, .

,
1.
, , , (70).
, 1. .. :
. . ., 1996. .142154.

, , .

, ,
, , ,
. , -

279


, ,
,
. , , ,


, , :
,
.
, (,
)2,
:

, ,
. , -
- , ,
,
.
,
, , 3.
:
,
2. . , II / . ... .: , 1970. .18.
3. .. //
. 2013. 5. .149160.

280

, , .
,
,

4. ,

5, ,
, :
, , ,
,
II , , , .
4. . / .
.. .: --, 2000.
.998.
: BoureauA. Histoire dun historien: Kantorowicz. P., 1990. P.162167.
5. KunderaM. Les testaments trahis. Essi. P., 1993.
P.269273.

[99] 2014

, , Bltter fr die Kunst,


1927 , , :
6.
1945
,
, ,
, ,
,
,
, .
, !

:
19802000. 7.
6. Ein toleranter Richter aber gleicht lauem
Feuer (KantorowiczE. Kaiser Friedrich der
Zweite. B.: Georg Bondi, 1927. S.247).
, .
7. XIXXX,
,
II ,
, : ..
. II
// . 1996. .211235,
.233234.
.

,
1938 , , :

, , , 8. II
(
, 1930 ), ,
, too-much-ness nimiety9.

-
,
10.

, , ,
, ,
, ,
11.
II
, ,
XIII .
8. , sanctus Fiscus (279), I ,

(558).
9. ., : English Historical Review.
1960. Vol.75. P.295298.
10. Past and Present. 1961. 20. P.2025.
11. Journal of Ecclesiastical History. 1959. Vol.10.
P.105108.

281

:
. , 1980,
.
,
, : ,
,
, .
, , ,
,
. , , , .
, ,
. , , , , .
. (
) . , ,
, , ( ),
.
12.
12. , ,
,

282

,
,
,

,
. comme il faut ,
. ,
, -,
. . . ,
, . ,
.
. ,
- , ,
,
( ). , erudite confusion, , , ,
,
. .

, , , a study, ,
, , .

[99] 2014

13,
- : ? ,
, , , , , , ,
. , ,
,

14.
, ,
?
, ,
, ; , , .

(65): ,
, , , , .
.
,

(!). , 13. ,
, tude, -.
14. . -. ,
.
.: , 1998.

, ,
, , , .
, - ,
,
(573).
, . ,
, :
Quaderni storici 19701980 .
, , , , ,
(135162),
.
, ,
,
, ,
, . , , ,
, , -
, - , : ,
, ,
.
,
-

283

, ,
: ,
, (-)15, .
, , . ,
().
,

,
,

(684745). ,

. ,
: , ,
. , ,
, , XVIXVII ,

, ,
. , ,
, .

15. Logre historien. Autour de Jacques Le Goff/
J.Revel, J.-Cl. Schmitt (dir.). P.: Gallimard, 1998.

284

,
.

,
, .
,
, , .
,
, , ,
. (56) ..
. , ,
,
(377), , bodified16.
,
-,
17.
16. . / . ... .:
, 2006; .. . . .: ,
2009. , , , ,
.
17. Le GoffJ., TruongN. Une histoire du corps au
Moyen ge. P.: Liana Levi, 2003. , , ,
.

[99] 2014

:



, 18.
: , , , ,
, , sacerdotium regnum, ,
.


,
.
, , (
,
) : , , ,
.

?

18. Paravicini BaglianiA. Il corpo del papa. Torino: Giulio Einaudi, 1994. .
: . 1999. .319328.
,
,
,
,
,
Seuil. , .

,
,
,, ,
? , , ?
, :
,
,
,
, ,
. , ,
:

, ,
19.

,
, ,
?
()
,
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
-,
.
, ,
19. . . . C.163.

285


,
, .

, , ,
, . - ,
, , , ,
1938, , .

, , . -
,
, , ,
, , .
, ,
, , .
,
,
. ,
, , ,
-

286

,
,
, ,
. , ,
, .
:
, .
, , ,
,
.


, , , (
. ..),
20.

,
, 1947.

, ,
20. JanzenH. Ottonische Kunst. Mnchen: Mnchner Verlag, 1947. S.162.
, : published under Military Government
Information control Licence No. US -E-173.

[99] 2014

21. , , , , ,

.

(556), ,
.
,
, , , II
, , , ,
,
,
(
) , , ,
21. , ,
,
, , (
? Mitte) (. . .: ; , 2008. .31244),
XX ,
: die Zeit
der Spaltungen schlechthin, die Welt-Zeit ohne
Mitte (SedlmayrH. Die Entstehung der Kathedrale. Zrich, 1959. S.512). .

: .
. XIIXV . .:
, 2013. .I .

XXI .


. ,
, ? , ,
.
,
, ,
.
***

, .
,
:

, ,
. .
, -

287


. . , ,
,
. ,


, ,
, , .
, , , - .
,
, , ,
. , ,
, , .
(
,
,
- ,
.) , , authority power,
auctoritas potestas , ,
. , ,
, effigies, (544). -

288

,
!
, , . , , ,
, . , ,
,
, , - , , , ,
, ,
,
,
, .
,
.
,
, , .
, ,
- , (959). ,
,

,
. , ,
,
, , .

[99] 2014

, :

Roberto Esposito. Living Thought: Origins and Actuality of Italian Philosophy/
Z.Hanafi (trans.). Stanford: Stanford University Press, 2012. 296 p.

: (2010,
2012)
.
.
, , .
,
, ,
, ;
. , ,
, ;
.

. ,
, .
(Communitas:
, 1998),

(Immunitas: ,
2002) (Bios: , 2004).
,
.

, ,
.
, : ,

289


( , ) .


, ( )
.
,
,

.

- XX.


,
,
,
, ..
,
,
. , , :


(255).

,
,
.
.
, ,
(, ), , . , ,
,


. . ,
, ,
, ,
, , ,

. ,

: , ,

. ,
-
communitas, , , ,, - (, ,
Mit-sein -

290

[99] 2014


).
,
,

. , , ,

,
,
,
.
.

,

, ,

.
,

,
. ,
,
, , , .
.
,
( )? ,
?
- -,

,
, ?
,
, .

, :
, ,
, , , . ,
, ,
, ,
(178).

, . ,
, ,

, ,
, .

,
, communitas,

. : ,
,
, -.
Limmanence: une vie (1995),
: -

291

, -,
-22.
, ,


, ,
. , ( ) .
,
, , , , , - , ,
,
,

.
,
. : , ,
?
?
? ? ?
? , ,
- , ? .

22. DeleuzeG. Deux rgimes de foux. Textes et
entretiens 19751995. P.: Minuit, 2003. P.360.

292


. ,
, , , ,

,
. , . ,
, (24).
, , ,
,
,
.
-
, .
:
, ,

,
,

,
,
,

, (54).

, [99] 2014

. ,
, , ,
, .
,
,
, , ,
, ,
( ), .
(218)

,
.
,

. ,
, :

; , , , (233).

, , ,
,
.
-,


, ? , ,
,
- (non-philosophie) ? : ,
(221). , ,
-, , natura
naturans,
? , , ,
, -
( ).

, , , .
, , ,

, ,

.

, ,
,
- , -

293

, - .
; ,
,

.
, ,
,
,
,
, - ,
, . , , , , - , (78).
,
- ,
, - . . , , . , - , ,
- , , - , , . - , , , - . ,
- , ,
, - . .
.

.

, ,

, - ,
(27).
, - , , - ,
. - , ,
? , - , - ,
, , ? , , .
-
,

,

294

[99] 2014

,
.
. .: ;
, 2014. 232 .

, , ,

. ( , )
- ,
.

,
. ,
, : , , soft power,
.
,
, ,
. , ,
..

,

, :
.
, , . ,
(12), , ,

-
( ). ,
-

295

. ,
,

, , .
,
, . ,
.
( , , )

,
?

: , ,
. ,

.
, ,
- , reduction ad absurdum,

. , -

296

/
, , , , ,

,
.
:
, ,
, (59).


, ,

, ,

23.

, , 23. .: ,-,-. 1. .
- . - . - .
2. , . - .
- . - . - . - . - .
- . - . -
(). - ( ,
). - (
; ). -
( ) (
/ .
... ., 2009).

[99] 2014

,
,
. , ,
, .
, .
- , - ,
-

, .
,
,
,
-
. ,
. ,
, -


. .
, 24. 24. ., ., . ,
19351940
, -


? ,
.

, ,
- .
,


, , ,


.
, ,
,
, ,
,
. , : ,
,

,
. ,
. : .. : . ; , 1995.

297


, , ,
, , ,
.


,

,
.
,
,
, - ( , ,
, )

, . ,
. ,
, , ?
? ,

?

(
) (), ()
() (75).

298

, ,
, ,
.
,

. , ,
,
, .
,
, . ,
,
1980
1990 ( :
), 2010 (209)

. ,
.

, ,
, ,
, , .
, -

[99] 2014

, ,

.
, ,
, -

,
.


. : .
.: , 2014. 436 .

:
. .
,
, . , ,
Lurkmore25. , .
;
, ,



(79), ,
, ,
. :
Mad pride26, -- ( 25. .URL: http://lurkmore.to/.
26. .URL : http://madpride.org.uk.

-), .
27
:

.
27. // . URL:
http://antipsychiatry.ru/index.php?i=378.

299



. ,
,
, ,
.
, ,
, .
: , .
,

, , .

:
,
,
,
.
( ) , -,
(9),

300

.
.
,
,
? ,
, . ,

.
: - --.

, , , ,
(371),
,
.
, .
(388), . ,

, - ,
. , -

[99] 2014

:
, ,
. ; ,
[] (385).

, . .
,
. , ,
,

, .

.
, ,

, .
. , ,
(387),

. ,
:
,
,

,
,, ?

,
, .
, , ,
.
, -
,
. ,
,
.


, (300), . ,
,
28.
, , 28. , ,

, . ., .: MatthewsE. Moralist or
Therapist? Foucault and the Critique of Psychiatry// Philosophy, Psychiatry, & Psychology. 1995. Vol.2. 1. P.1930; BrackenP., ThomasP. Postpsychiatry: A New Direction For
Mental Health// British Medical Journal. 2001.
Vol.322. 7288. P.724727.

301


.
,
( ) .

,

.
, . . ,
, (351).
,
. , -.
;

( , ,
).

, .

, . .
,
:
, [],

302

29.

.
,
, , .

,
.


--.

. ,
, ( ),

.
,
, ,

,
(373).


29. ., . -:
. : -
, 2007. .567.

[99] 2014

. .
, , .
,

:
, , 30,
,
,, .

,
,
.
,
:

(375), ,

, , . ,

,
. ,
( ,

- , ).


. - ,
, ,
,
:
, . , , .
; ,
,


;
.. (11).

, ,
. , , ,

. , .

30. Szasz Th. Debunking Antipsychiatry: Laing,


Law, and Largactil// Current Psychology. 2008.
Vol.27. P.89101, 89.

303