Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 1210

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

Introduction

SectionOne

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

INTRODUCTION

SectionOneof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJuly1,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employeesofsubscribingcompaniesandtheirsubsidiaries,asdefinedabove,untilJuly1,2016.
Similarly,allsectionsofthesurveyaresorestrictedforthreeyearsfromtheirdatesofissue.
Failuretopreventunauthorizeddisclosurebeforethesedateswillresultinlegalactionagainst
thesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEE SPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

1.INTRODUCTION................................................................................................................11
Contents........................................................................................................................12
Scope.............................................................................................................................12
Sourcesandmethods...................................................................................................13
ProductCategoryDescriptions..................................................................................15
Fragarances...................................................................................................................15
Haircareproducts.........................................................................................................16
Makeup.........................................................................................................................19
Oralcareproducts......................................................................................................111
Skincareproducts.......................................................................................................113
Othertoiletries............................................................................................................115

2.EXECUTIVESUMMARY......................................................................................................21
Personalcarethrivesoninnovationsinfusedwithbettertechnologies
andomnimediamarketingstrategies..........................................................................21
Retaillandscape..........................................................................................................212
Structureoftheindustry.............................................................................................219
Outlook.......................................................................................................................223
Appraisalandopportunityassessment......................................................................226

3.INDUSTRYANALYSIS
TheMarket...............................................................................................................31
Countryoverview..........................................................................................................31
Cosmeticsandtoiletriesoverallperformance..............................................................31
Growth..........................................................................................................................32
Unitvolume...................................................................................................................38
Retailvalueandtrademargins...................................................................................310
Companies..............................................................................................................313
Structureoftheindustry.............................................................................................313
Growth........................................................................................................................318
Companydevelopments.............................................................................................320
ConsumerResearch.................................................................................................327
Haircare......................................................................................................................327
Skincare......................................................................................................................332
Fragrances...................................................................................................................338
Oralcareproducts......................................................................................................340
Othertoiletries............................................................................................................341

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

3.INDUSTRYANALYSIS(Continued)
RetailDistribution...................................................................................................361
Outletdefinitions........................................................................................................361
Salesbyretailoutlet...................................................................................................363
PrivatelabelActivity...............................................................................................371
MarketingActivity...................................................................................................377
Traceablemediaexpenditures...................................................................................377
Promotions..................................................................................................................387
Outlook...................................................................................................................389
Growthtrends.............................................................................................................389
Basecase(mostlikely)unitanddollarforecaststo2017..........................................390
KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel
fortheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesMarket.........................................................397
Methodology...............................................................................................................397
Industrylevelfactors..................................................................................................397
Macroeconomicfactors..............................................................................................399
Overallcosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry...................................................................399
Fragrances.................................................................................................................3100
Haircareproducts.....................................................................................................3101
Makeupproducts......................................................................................................3101
Oralcareproducts....................................................................................................3102
Skincareproducts.....................................................................................................3103
Othertoiletries..........................................................................................................3103

4.PRODUCTS
4A.Introduction.............................................................................................................4A1
Reportcontents..........................................................................................................4A1
Restatedsalesestimates.............................................................................................4A2
Productcategorydescriptions....................................................................................4A3
Fragrances...................................................................................................................4A3
Haircareproducts.......................................................................................................4A4
Makeup.......................................................................................................................4A7
Oralcareproducts......................................................................................................4A9
Skincareproducts.....................................................................................................4A11
Othertoiletries..........................................................................................................4A13

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4B.TheMarket...............................................................................................................4B1
Totalsales...................................................................................................................4B1
Growth........................................................................................................................4B1
4C.Fragrances................................................................................................................4C1
Introduction................................................................................................................4C1
Manufacturerssales...................................................................................................4C1
Retailsales..................................................................................................................4C3
Competition................................................................................................................4C3
Retaildistribution.......................................................................................................4C4
Outlook.......................................................................................................................4C5
FragrancesforMen.................................................................................................4C9
Categoryperformance................................................................................................4C9
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4C15
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4C19
Competition..............................................................................................................4C19
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4C22
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4C23
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4C25
FragrancesforWomen..........................................................................................4C27
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4C27
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4C34
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4C40
Competition..............................................................................................................4C41
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4C44
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4C45
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4C48
4D.HairCareProducts...................................................................................................4D1
Introduction................................................................................................................4D1
Manufacturerssales...................................................................................................4D1
Retailsales..................................................................................................................4D2
Competition................................................................................................................4D3
Retaildistribution.......................................................................................................4D6
Outlook.......................................................................................................................4D7

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4D.HairCareProducts(Continued)
Conditioners..........................................................................................................4D11
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4D11
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4D14
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4D18
Competition..............................................................................................................4D19
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4D22
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4D22
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4D24
EthnicHairCareProducts......................................................................................4D27
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4D27
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4D31
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4D34
Competition..............................................................................................................4D35
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4D37
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4D38
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4D39
HairColoringProducts..........................................................................................4D41
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4D41
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4D43
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4D46
Competition..............................................................................................................4D47
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4D49
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4D50
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4D51
HairStylingProductsandSprays...........................................................................4D55
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4D55
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4D58
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4D60
Competition..............................................................................................................4D62
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4D64
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4D64
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4D66

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4D.HairCareProducts(Continued)
Shampoos.............................................................................................................4D69
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4D69
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4D72
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4D77
Competition..............................................................................................................4D77
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4D81
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4D82
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4D83
4E.Makeup....................................................................................................................4E1
Introduction................................................................................................................4E1
Manufacturerssales...................................................................................................4E1
Retailsales..................................................................................................................4E3
Competition................................................................................................................4E3
Retaildistribution.......................................................................................................4E7
Promotion...................................................................................................................4E8
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4E10
EyeMakeup..........................................................................................................4E13
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4E13
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4E16
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4E19
Competition..............................................................................................................4E20
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4E22
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4E23
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4E25
FaceMakeup.........................................................................................................4E27
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4E27
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4E30
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4E32
Competition..............................................................................................................4E32
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4E36
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4E36
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4E38

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4E.Makeup(Continued)
NailPolishes..........................................................................................................4E55
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4E55
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4E57
Competition..............................................................................................................4E59
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4E61
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4E61
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4E63
4F.OralCareProducts....................................................................................................4F1
Introduction................................................................................................................4F1
Manufacturerssales...................................................................................................4F1
Retailsales..................................................................................................................4F2
Competition................................................................................................................4F3
Retaildistribution.......................................................................................................4F5
Outlook.......................................................................................................................4F6
DentureProducts...................................................................................................4F11
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F11
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F12
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4F14
Competition..............................................................................................................4F15
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F17
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F17
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F18
LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments..........................................................................4F21
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F21
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F22
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4F24
Competition..............................................................................................................4F25
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F27
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F28
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F29

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4F.OralCareProducts(Continued)
Mouthwashes........................................................................................................4F31
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F31
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F32
Competition..............................................................................................................4F34
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F35
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F36
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F37
Toothbrushes.........................................................................................................4F39
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F39
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F40
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4F42
Competition..............................................................................................................4F43
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F45
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F45
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F46
Toothpastes...........................................................................................................4F49
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F49
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F50
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4F53
Competition..............................................................................................................4F55
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F57
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F57
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F59
ToothWhiteningProducts.....................................................................................4F63
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4F63
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4F64
Competition..............................................................................................................4F66
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4F67
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4F68
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4F69

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4G.SkinCareProducts...................................................................................................4G1
Introduction................................................................................................................4G1
Manufacturerssales...................................................................................................4G1
Retailsales..................................................................................................................4G3
Competition................................................................................................................4G3
Retaildistribution.......................................................................................................4G7
Outlook.......................................................................................................................4G7
BabyCareProducts...............................................................................................4G11
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4G11
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4G13
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4G16
Competition..............................................................................................................4G18
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4G20
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4G20
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4G21
FacialTreatments..................................................................................................4G23
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4G23
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4G28
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4G35
Competition..............................................................................................................4G37
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4G44
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4G44
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4G48
HandandBodyLotions.........................................................................................4G53
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4G53
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4G56
Competition..............................................................................................................4G60
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4G65
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4G65
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4G69
SkinCareProductsforMen...................................................................................4G73
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4G73
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4G74
Competition..............................................................................................................4G78
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4G80
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4G80
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4G82

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4G.SkinCareProducts(Continued)
SunCareProducts.................................................................................................4G85
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4G85
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4G87
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4G94
Competition..............................................................................................................4G99
Privatelabel...........................................................................................................4G103
Retaildistribution..................................................................................................4G103
Marketingactivity..................................................................................................4G104
Outlook..................................................................................................................4G107
4H.OtherToiletries........................................................................................................4H1
Introduction................................................................................................................4H1
ManufacturersSales..................................................................................................4H1
RetailSales..................................................................................................................4H3
Competition................................................................................................................4H3
RetailDistribution.......................................................................................................4H9
Outlook.......................................................................................................................4H9
DeodorantsandAntiperspirants...........................................................................4H13
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4H13
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4H15
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4H19
Competition..............................................................................................................4H20
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4H24
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4H25
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4H28
Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches........................................................................4H31
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4H31
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4H32
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4H36
Competition..............................................................................................................4H37
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4H39
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4H40
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4H42

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4.PRODUCTS(Continued)
4H.OtherToiletries(Continued)
PersonalCleansingProducts.................................................................................4H45
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4H45
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4H49
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4H56
Competition..............................................................................................................4H67
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4H71
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4H72
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4H74
ShavingProducts...................................................................................................4H77
Categoryperformance..............................................................................................4H77
Categorydevelopment.............................................................................................4H79
Categorysegmentation.............................................................................................4H81
Competition..............................................................................................................4H84
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4H87
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4H87
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4H89

5.MAJORCOMPANIES
Introduction..............................................................................................................51
Overview...................................................................................................................53
Totalsales.....................................................................................................................53
Growth..........................................................................................................................54
Alticor(Amway)........................................................................................................57
Companyoverview.......................................................................................................57
Corporatesalesandprofits...........................................................................................59
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................510
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................511
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................511
Outlook.......................................................................................................................512
Avon.......................................................................................................................515
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................518
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................518
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................520
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................522
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................524
Outlook.......................................................................................................................525

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Beiersdorf...................................................................................................................529
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................530
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................530
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................531
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................534
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................535
Outlook.......................................................................................................................537
Chanel.....................................................................................................................541
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................542
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................542
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................542
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................545
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................545
Outlook.......................................................................................................................546
Church&Dwight.....................................................................................................549
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................550
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................550
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................551
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................553
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................554
Outlook.......................................................................................................................555
Clarins.....................................................................................................................557
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................558
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................558
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................559
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................561
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................561
Outlook.......................................................................................................................562
TheCloroxCompany...............................................................................................565
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................566
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................566
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................567
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................570
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................571
Outlook.......................................................................................................................572

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
ColgatePalmolive...................................................................................................575
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................576
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................577
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................578
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................580
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................582
Outlook.......................................................................................................................583
Combe.....................................................................................................................587
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................587
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................588
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................588
Recentdevelopments.................................................................................................590
Marketingactivity.......................................................................................................590
Outlook.......................................................................................................................591
Coty........................................................................................................................593
Companyoverview.....................................................................................................597
Corporatesalesandprofits.........................................................................................598
Cosmeticsandtoiletries..............................................................................................599
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5101
Newproducts............................................................................................................5102
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5103
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5105
ElizabethArden.....................................................................................................5107
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5109
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5110
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5111
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5113
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5113
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5114
EnergizerHoldings.................................................................................................5119
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5119
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5120
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5121
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5124
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5124
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5126

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
EsteLauder.........................................................................................................5129
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5133
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5134
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5136
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5140
Notablenewproducts..............................................................................................5141
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5144
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5149
GlaxoSmithKline....................................................................................................5155
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5156
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5157
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5157
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5159
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5160
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5162
GuthyRenker........................................................................................................5165
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5165
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5166
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5166
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5168
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5168
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5170
HelenofTroy........................................................................................................5173
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5174
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5175
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5176
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5178
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5178
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5180
Johnson&Johnson...............................................................................................5183
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5185
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5186
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5187
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5193
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5195
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5198

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Kao........................................................................................................................5203
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5204
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5205
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5206
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5208
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5209
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5210
LimitedBrands......................................................................................................5213
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5215
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5215
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5216
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5220
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5222
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5223
LOral..................................................................................................................5227
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5233
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5234
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5235
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5243
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5248
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5252
LVMH....................................................................................................................5257
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5259
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5259
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5260
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5262
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5263
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5264
MaryKay...............................................................................................................5267
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5268
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5269
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5269
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5271
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5272
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5273

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Merck....................................................................................................................5275
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5275
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5276
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5277
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5278
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5279
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5280
Procter&Gamble.................................................................................................5283
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5287
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5288
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5289
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5299
Notablenewproducts..............................................................................................5300
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5302
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5308
Revlon...................................................................................................................5313
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5314
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5315
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5316
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5319
Notablenewproducts..............................................................................................5319
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5320
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5321
Sanofi....................................................................................................................5325
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5325
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5326
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5327
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5328
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5329
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5330
Shiseido................................................................................................................5333
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5334
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5335
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5336
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5338
Newproducts............................................................................................................5339
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5339
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5340

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

5.MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Unilever................................................................................................................5345
Companyoverview...................................................................................................5347
Corporatesalesandprofits.......................................................................................5348
Cosmeticsandtoiletries............................................................................................5349
Recentdevelopments...............................................................................................5354
Managementchanges..............................................................................................5355
Newproducts............................................................................................................5355
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................5358
Outlook.....................................................................................................................5362

6.MINORCOMPANIES..........................................................................................................61
Abercrombie&Fitch.....................................................................................................65
AlsGroupe...................................................................................................................66
AllianceBoots................................................................................................................66
AmorepacificCorporation.............................................................................................68
AnthonyBrands............................................................................................................69
Arbonne......................................................................................................................610
AstralBrands...............................................................................................................611
AtlanticCoastMediaGroup........................................................................................612
AubreyOrganics..........................................................................................................612
BarcforMen...............................................................................................................613
Beauticontrol(TupperwareBrands)...........................................................................614
Beekman1802............................................................................................................615
Blistex..........................................................................................................................615
BlowPro......................................................................................................................616
BlueQ..........................................................................................................................617
BonneBell...................................................................................................................617
BradBiophotonic........................................................................................................618
ByTerry.......................................................................................................................619
CamilleBeckman.........................................................................................................619
CargoCosmetics..........................................................................................................620
CarmaLaboratories.....................................................................................................621
CarolsDaughter.........................................................................................................622
Cartier.........................................................................................................................622
CCAIndustries.............................................................................................................623

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

6.MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
CellexCInternational.................................................................................................624
Chrysallis.....................................................................................................................625
TheColomerGroup.....................................................................................................625
CorSilverSkincare.......................................................................................................626
CosrichGroup.............................................................................................................627
DanaClassicFragrances..............................................................................................627
DeadSeaLaboratories................................................................................................628
DeborahLippmann.....................................................................................................629
DemeterFragranceLibrary.........................................................................................629
Dermalogica................................................................................................................630
DermovivaSkinEssentials...........................................................................................631
Devacurl......................................................................................................................632
Dr.BronnersMagicAllOne.......................................................................................632
Dr.Fresh......................................................................................................................633
Dr.HauschkaSkinCare...............................................................................................634
E.L.F.Cosmetics...........................................................................................................634
EquitiumGroup...........................................................................................................635
EOSProducts...............................................................................................................636
ErnoLaszlo..................................................................................................................637
E.T.Browne.................................................................................................................637
Euroitalia.....................................................................................................................638
ExpanscienceLaboratories.........................................................................................639
FaceStockholm...........................................................................................................640
FalicFashionGroup.....................................................................................................640
Focus21......................................................................................................................641
FreemanBeauty..........................................................................................................642
Fresh............................................................................................................................642
FruitoftheEarth.........................................................................................................643
FusionBrands..............................................................................................................644
GaldermaLaboratories...............................................................................................644
TheGap.......................................................................................................................645
GiovanniOrganicCosmetics.......................................................................................646
GoSmile......................................................................................................................646
GraceChoi...................................................................................................................647
HairRules....................................................................................................................648

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

6.MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
HamptonSun..............................................................................................................648
HerbalifeInternational................................................................................................649
HermsInternationalGroup.......................................................................................649
HouseofCreed............................................................................................................650
InterfashionCosmetics...............................................................................................650
Interparfums...............................................................................................................651
InspiredBeautyBrands...............................................................................................652
IredaleMineralCosmetics..........................................................................................652
ITCosmetics................................................................................................................653
J.Strickland.................................................................................................................654
JafraCosmeticsInternational.....................................................................................655
J.M.Products...............................................................................................................655
JoeyNewYork.............................................................................................................656
JohnPaulMitchellSystems.........................................................................................656
JohnsonPublishingCompany.....................................................................................657
JonathanProduct........................................................................................................658
JosieMaranCosmetics................................................................................................659
JuiceBeauty................................................................................................................659
KissProducts...............................................................................................................660
KissMyFace................................................................................................................661
KosAmerica..............................................................................................................662
Laqa&Co....................................................................................................................663
LavanilaLaboratories..................................................................................................663
LOccitane....................................................................................................................664
LoracCosmetics..........................................................................................................665
LushFreshHandmadeCosmetics...............................................................................666
LusterProducts...........................................................................................................666
MarkwinsInternational..............................................................................................667
Matriskin.....................................................................................................................668
MerleNorman.............................................................................................................669
MissJessies................................................................................................................670
Murad..........................................................................................................................670
Naturopathica.............................................................................................................672
NewHarmonySoap....................................................................................................672
NotYourMother's......................................................................................................673

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

6.MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
NuSkinEnterprises.....................................................................................................674
Nyx..............................................................................................................................674
Orlane..........................................................................................................................675
OrlyInternational........................................................................................................676
OsmiaOrganics...........................................................................................................677
Ouidad(JHPartners)...................................................................................................677
Palladio........................................................................................................................678
ParfumsDeCoeur.......................................................................................................678
PerioProducts.............................................................................................................679
PerriconeMD..............................................................................................................680
PierreFabreGroup.....................................................................................................681
PrestigeCosmetics......................................................................................................682
PrimalElements..........................................................................................................683
PrMinerals................................................................................................................683
Pure&Basic................................................................................................................684
Rahua..........................................................................................................................685
ReckittBenckiser.........................................................................................................685
RenCleanSkincare......................................................................................................686
RohtoPharmaceutical.................................................................................................687
RosebudPerfumeCompany.......................................................................................688
ShakleeCorporation...................................................................................................688
SisleyCosmetics..........................................................................................................689
SmellBent...................................................................................................................690
SteinerLeisure............................................................................................................690
SueIsmiel&Daughters...............................................................................................691
SundayRiley................................................................................................................692
Sunstar........................................................................................................................692
Tarte............................................................................................................................693
TatasNaturalAlchemy...............................................................................................693
TedGibson..................................................................................................................694
TooFacedCosmetics..................................................................................................695
UniversityMedical......................................................................................................695
Urth.............................................................................................................................696
ValeantPharmaceuticals............................................................................................697
VapourBeauty............................................................................................................698

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

6.MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
TheVillageCompany..................................................................................................698
VincentLongo.............................................................................................................699
VogueInternational..................................................................................................6100
WeiEast....................................................................................................................6101
Weleda......................................................................................................................6101
YesTo........................................................................................................................6102
YvesRocher...............................................................................................................6103

7.ADVERTISING
Introduction....................................................................................................................71
Scope.............................................................................................................................71
Source...........................................................................................................................71
Format...........................................................................................................................71
TheProducts...................................................................................................................77
Introduction..................................................................................................................77
Babycareproducts.......................................................................................................77
Conditioners..................................................................................................................77
Dentureproducts..........................................................................................................78
Deodorantsandantiperspirants...................................................................................78
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches................................................................................78
Ethnichaircareproducts..............................................................................................79
Eyemakeup...................................................................................................................79
Facemakeup.................................................................................................................79
Facialtreatments........................................................................................................710
Fragrancesformen.....................................................................................................710
Fragrancesforwomen................................................................................................710
Haircareproductsmultiproduct............................................................................711
Haircoloringproducts................................................................................................711
Hairstylingproductsandsprays.................................................................................711
Handandbodylotions................................................................................................712
Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments...............................................................................712
Lipsticksandlipglosses...............................................................................................712
Mouthwashes.............................................................................................................713
Nailpolishes................................................................................................................713

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

7.ADVERTISING(Continued)
TheProducts(Continued)
Personalcleansingproducts.......................................................................................713
Shampoos....................................................................................................................714
Shavingproducts.........................................................................................................714
Skincareproductsformen.........................................................................................714
Suncareproducts.......................................................................................................715
Toothbrushes..............................................................................................................715
Toothpastes................................................................................................................715
Toothwhiteningproducts..........................................................................................716
Othercosmeticsandtoiletries....................................................................................716
MajorCompanies..........................................................................................................717
Introduction................................................................................................................717
Alticor..........................................................................................................................717
Avon............................................................................................................................717
Beiersdorf....................................................................................................................718
Chanel.........................................................................................................................718
Church&Dwight.........................................................................................................718
Clarins..........................................................................................................................719
ColgatePalmolive.......................................................................................................719
Combe.........................................................................................................................719
Coty.............................................................................................................................720
ElizabethArden...........................................................................................................720
EnergizerHoldings......................................................................................................720
EsteLauder................................................................................................................721
GlaxoSmithKline..........................................................................................................721
GuthyRenker..............................................................................................................721
HelenofTroy...............................................................................................................722
Henkel.........................................................................................................................722
Johnson&Johnson.....................................................................................................722
Kao..............................................................................................................................723
LimitedBrands............................................................................................................723
LOral.........................................................................................................................724
LVMH...........................................................................................................................724
MaryKay.....................................................................................................................724
Merck..........................................................................................................................725

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

7.ADVERTISING(Continued)
MajorCompanies(Continued)
Procter&Gamble.......................................................................................................725
Revlon.........................................................................................................................726
Sanofi..........................................................................................................................726
Shiseido.......................................................................................................................727
TheCloroxCompany...................................................................................................727
Unilever.......................................................................................................................728

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

INTRODUCTION

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAwithbaseyear2012isKline&Companysthirtyfirstannualstudy
ofthisindustry,precededbyperiodicreportsconductedsince1963.Thereportisbasedona
variety of information, with primary methods comprising more than 300 interviews with
industry executives from manufacturers and/or marketers, retailers and distributors, raw
material suppliers, trade associations, and government agencies, among other sources.
Informationobtainedfromtheseunstructuredinterviewsisthenassessedandanalyzedbyour
cosmeticsandtoiletriesconsultantswithavarietyofothersources,includingdatafromannual
reports, 10Ks, and other financial reports; trade literature; product literature and price lists;
andinformationfromstorevisits.

FullreportsubscriberstoCosmetics&ToiletriesUSAreceiveonedayofconsultationtimewith
their subscription to the study. The actual report is presented in five sections: Executive
Summary; Industry Analysis; The Products; Major Companies; and Advertising. The study
provides data and analysis, including market size and growth, brand and company shares,
trends,newproductactivity,traceablemediaexpenditures,andstrategicanalyses,inaddition
tootherinformation.

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAisoneofmanymulticlientreportsofferedbyKline&Companythat
coverthepersonalcareindustry.Otherselectedreportsandthoseunderconsiderationinclude:

BeautyRetailing
MulticulturalBeautyandGrooming
HomeFragrances
NaturalPersonalCare
PersonalCareCompetitorCostStructures
ProfessionalSkinCare
SalonHairCare

As an international consulting firm, Kline also conducts proprietary projects on an individual


client basis for leading cosmetic and toiletry marketers. Proprietary assignments include
acquisition analyses, new business assessments, strategic analyses, competitive intelligence,
andfinancialanalyses,amongothers.

WeinvitereadersofCosmetics&ToiletriesUSAtocontactuswithanyquestions,andtoadvise
usofanyomissionsorpossiblecorrections,whichwewilladdressimmediatelyorinthe2012
reportedition.

CarrieMellage
LenkaContreras
Director,ConsumerProductsPractice
VicePresident
KlineMarketResearch
KlineMarketResearch
9734353412
9734353407
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com
Lenka.Contreras@klinegroup.com

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

12

Introduction

CONTENTS

The data contained in this report provide information on the entire U.S. cosmetics and
toiletriesindustrythroughconsumeroutletsforthecalendaryear2012.
Suchsectionsalsooccasionallycoverdevelopmentsfor2013.
The information in the report presents a comprehensive overview of the industry,
includingdataonproductsandcompanies,organizedforreadyreference,asfollows:
Executive Summary: This topline document highlights key activities and noteworthy
strategictrendsandissuesthatoccurin2012.
IndustryAnalysis:Thissectionanalyzestheprincipalfeaturesoftheoverallbusiness,its
products,companies,andpracticesin2012.
TheProducts:Thissectiongivesthoroughmarketprofilesof26productcategoriesof
theindustryfor2012.
Major Companies: Profiled here are the principal companies with U.S. cosmetic and
toiletry sales exceeding $99million, providing extensive business summaries of 30
majorsuppliersfor2012.
Minor Companies: Every other year this report publishes summaries of about 150
minorcompaniesintheindustry.This2012editiondoescontaintheminorprofiles
andtheywillbepublishedagaininthe2014edition.
Advertising: This section analyzes traceable media expenditures by category and
companyin2012.

Anoveralltableofcontentsisalsoincludedattheendofthissection.

SCOPE

Thisreportfocusessolelyonproductssoldthroughdomesticconsumeroutlets,including
thosemarketedviadirectsalesfromcompaniessuchasAvonandMaryKay,inadditionto
nontraditionaloutletssuchasspecialtyretailers.
Marketdatareferexclusivelytosalesthroughthesechannels.
Importandmailordersalesareincluded,butsalestoinstitutionssuchashospitalsand
nursinghomes,themilitary,andexportsareexcluded.Alsodutyfreestoressalesare
notincluded.

All market sales data are given in manufacturers or factory dollarsthat is, the prices
receivedbymanufacturersbeforewholesaleandretailmarkups.
All companies selling branded products are considered manufacturers in this report,
regardlessofwhethertheyhavemanufacturingfacilitiesoftheirownorsellproducts
madebyothercompanies.

Percentagetotalsoncertaintablesmaynotalwaysaddupduetorounding.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Introduction

SOURCESANDMETHODS

Data have been obtained through research and analysis of the industry conducted from
July2012throughJune2013.
The report information is obtained through over 300 interviews of executives in the
industry itself, retailers, raw material suppliers, trade associations, and government
agencies.
In addition to the interviews, the report includes an analysis of annual reports and
otherfinancialreportsfromcompanies,aswellasareviewoftrade,press,andother
secondaryinformation,andstorechecksofretailoutlets.

Alldataonmarketsizeandbrandshareshavebeendeterminedfromathoroughanalysisof
severalsourcesofinformation.
Statistics on market size are believed to be accurate for products with sales of
$15millionormore,probablywithin10%ofthetruevalue.
Forsmallermarkets,theaccuracyissubstantiallyless,probablywithin25%ofthetrue
value.
Dataonbrandsharesalsovaryaccordingtothesizeofthemarkets,althoughaccuracy
isroughlythesamefortheproducts.

The data presented in this report are believed to be sufficiently accurate for preliminary
marketplanning.
Morespecificanddetailedstudies,however,shouldbeconductedbeforeprojectsthat
requiresubstantialbusinessdecisionsareundertaken.
Kline& Company is pleased to assist clients on such projects through our custom
consultationcapabilities,realizedthroughover50yearsofexperienceconsultingtothe
cosmeticandtoiletryindustry.

Advertising expenditures are based on Kline& Companys analysis of ad spending data


sourcedprimarilyfromKantarMediaandPublishersInformationBureau,whocopyrightthis
service.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

13

14

Introduction

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Introduction

PRODUCTCATEGORYDESCRIPTIONS

FRAGRANCES

Fragrancesformen

Therearemanyformsofliquidfragranceproductsformen:
Eau de toilettes are diluted alcoholic solutions of perfumes, and eau de parfums
containfragrancesinmoreconcentratedforms.
Colognes contain more concentrated solutions of essential oils than aftershaves and
thereforeleavealongerlastingfragrance.Theyareusedtofreshentheskinandimpart
amasculinescent,frequentlyaftershavingorshowering.
Aftershaves, available in a variety of products, are lower in fragrance concentration
thancolognes.Aftershavesarebasicallyfragranceproductsthatalsosootheandheal
razornicksandconditionandinvigoratetheskinaftershaving.Productsareavailable
asliquids,lotions,andgels.

Ancillaryproductsareusuallyfeaturedaslineextensionsoftheliquidfragranceandinclude
fragrancedsoaps,deodorantsandantiperspirantsscentedwithabrandedmensfragrance,
fragrancedtalcumpowders,skincareproducts,andhaircareproducts.

ToiletryproductsfrommasstoiletrybrandssuchasOldSpice,GilletteSeries,andBrutare
notcoveredinthisanalysis.
Salesforliquidfragranceproductsforthesebrandsareincludedhere.

Bodysprays,suchasAxe,arenotincludedinthisanalysis.
Thesebrandsarecoveredinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory.

Fragrancesforwomen

Womens fragrance products include perfumes, toilet waters, colognes, deocolognes, and
bodysplashes.
Perfumescontainfragrancesinrelativelyconcentratedforms.
Toiletwatersaredilutedalcoholicsolutionsofperfumes.
Colognes are similar to toilet waters but historically contain less fragrance; however,
many of todays colognes are concentrated and contain more perfume oil than toilet
watersdo.
Deocolognes are low in perfume concentration and are applied through an aerosol
spray.
Bodysplashesandmistsarethelowestinfragranceconcentration.
Solids are available in pressed powder or soft solid form and typically come in
compacts,pots,orsticks.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

15

16

Introduction

Ancillaryproductssuchasdustingpowders,bodylotions,andbathadditives,whicharepart
ofafragranceline,arecoveredinthisprofileaswellasintheirrespectivecategoriesinthis
report.

Unisexfragrances,suchasCKOne,arecoveredinthiscategory.

HAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Allhaircareproductsalesreportedareforathomeuseonly.
Forprofessionaluse(backbarsales),refertoKlinesSalonHairCarereportseries.

Conditioners

Conditioners are used to moisturize and treat the hair and are generally available in a
varietyofformulasdesignedfornormal,dry,oily,andothertypesofhair.
Formulasmayalsobedesignedforhairtextureorendresult,suchascurly,straight,or
volumizing.
Morerecently,productsarebeingintroducedtoprovideotherbenefits,suchascolor
protectionorshineenhancement.

Mostconditionersareinstantproductsthatareappliedtothehairafterwashingandare
leftonthehairforonetothreeminutesbeforerinsing.

Alsoincludedaretherapeuticconditioners,whichareformulatedtoprovidemoreintensive
treatmenttothehair.
Suchproductsarealsooftencalledconditioningtreatmentsordeepconditioners.
Productsareoftenusedtotreathairthatisdamageproneorexcessivelydry.
Therapeutic or deep conditioning products are typically left on the hair for 5 to 20
minutesbeforerinsing.
Someproductsrequirenorinsing.
Somedeepconditioningproductsareavailableinsingleusepackets.

Inadditiontosalesgeneratedbymassbrands,ourcategorydefinitionandmarketsizedata
include:
SalonbrandssuchasMatrix(LOral);theseproductsderivethemajorityoftheirsales
from salons, although some volume is also generated from sales in mass outlets and
throughtheInternet.
Minor sales of conditioners also come from direct sales companies such as Avon,
prestigecompaniessuchasEsteLauder,andspecialtymarketerssuchasBath&Body
Works(LimitedBrands).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

Introduction

Combination products that contain both shampoo and conditioner are included in the
shampooscategory.

Ethnichaircareproducts

Ethnic hair care products are specially designed to be effective for AfricanAmerican hair;
thefivemaintypesaredescribedbelow.

Relaxerkits(alsocalledperms)aredesignedtoremovecurlfromthehair,eithertotallyor
partially.

Styling aids serve a variety of functions and include products designed to counteract the
drynessproducedfromarelaxer.
Theseproductsholdthehairinplace,aswellaslubricatethescalp,preventdamage,
conditionandmoisturizethehair,andalloweasierstyling.
Suchproductsincludepressingaids,settinglotions,andhairtonics,aswellasspritzes,
gels,andmoussesthatarespeciallyformulatedforethnichair.

Dresses and lotions are typically petrolatumbased and are designed to add a wavy
appearancetothehairorholditinaparticularstyle.
Productsincludehairdressingconditioners,pomades,andtemporarywaveproducts.
Thissegmentincludesproductsspeciallyformulatedformensgrooming.

Curlmaintenanceproductsenhanceormaintainthecurlproducedbyacurlingproduct.
These products hold the hair in place as wellas lubricate the scalp, prevent damage,
andconditionandmoisturizethehair.
Such products include curl moisturizers, curl activators and restorers, combout
conditioners,curlmoisturizingsprays,andoilsheens.

Curl/wave kits are designed to add curl and body to the hair, help it set better and hold
longer.

Sales of other consumer products positioned specifically for ethnic consumers, such as
shampoos,conditioners,andhaircolorants,arealsoincludedinthiscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

17

18

Introduction

Haircoloringproducts

Haircoloringproductsaredesignedtocolorhair,eithertemporarilyorpermanently.There
arebasicallyfivetypesofhaircoloringproducts:
Permanentdyesprovidelongtermcolortohairandlastuntilnewhairgrowsout.
Semipermanent dyes highlight naturally colored hair or color gray hair without
bleachingaction.Theyaretypicallyappliedasshampooandremainonthehairthrough
severalwashings.
Permanentdemipermanentdyesprovideuptosixweeksofsheerhaircolortoblend
away gray hair without ammonia and without changing the natural color of the hair.
Productisleftinthehairforapproximatelyfiveminutes.
Special effects include lighteners, frosting products, and highlighting kits that are
usuallyappliedtoselectstrandsofhair.
Temporary colorants include rinses, shampoos, mousses, and gels that produce a
cosmetic change in the shade of hair and can be easily removed in one or more
shampoos.Theseproductsdonotpenetratethehairshaftandarenotasharmfulas
othercoloringproducts.

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Thehairstylingproductscategorycoversavarietyofproductsforcontrollingandenhancing
theappearanceofbothmensandwomenshair,includingthefollowing:
Styling gels are used to style and hold hair in place. Gels are applied after hair is
washedandareleftonthehairwhileitisbeingsetorstyled.
Stylingmoussesperformthesamefunctionasgelsbutalsoprovidebodytothehair.
Productsareavailableasaerosolfoamsandareappliedtoeitherwetordryhair.
Spritzesandotherheavystylingspraysarehighlevelresinfixatives,typicallyappliedto
either wet or damp hair to aid in the styling or sculpting of the hair. Such products
produce greater hold and stiffness and generally result in a less natural look than
traditionalaerosolhairsprays.
Stylinglotionsarewaterorwater/alcoholliquid,gellikeformulasavailableinbottlesor
tubes. A glaze is a variety of lotion that usually imparts more shine and hold than a
lotion.
Hair volumizers and thickeners give hair volume and an overall thicker, fuller
appearance.
Treatmentsimprovethehairsoverallmanageability.Productusagenormallyrequires
anextrastepinadditiontoroutinecleansingandconditioningofhair.Usageofthese
products has proliferated recently to include generaltreatment products as well as
onesthataregearedtowardspecifichairtypes,suchasdamaged,fine,orcolortreated
hair.
Retexturizingproductsmakecoarseorfrizzyhairsmoothand,insomecases,straight.
Shine enhancers are mists or serums that add shine to hair. Many of these products
alsocontainsunprotectioningredients.
Mens grooming products help men maintain a certain hairstyle. These products are
typicallyformulatedastonicsandcreams.
Stylingproductsinotherforms,suchaspomades,putty,waxes,sticks,andpastes,are
also included in this category. These product forms generally provide control, shine,
andareusedfrequentlyfortexturedeffects.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

Introduction

Hairspraysareusuallyappliedafterstylingthehairtohelpholditinplace.
Sprays are available in varying degrees of holding power, in scented or unscented
formulations,andinaerosolorpumpcontainers.

Shampoos

Shampoosareusedtocleansethehairandscalpandareavailableinavarietyofformulas.
Someshampoosaredesignedtoworkbestonnormal,dry,oroilyhair.
Others are developed for certain hair colors such as blonde, brunette or redhead, to
helpprotectandenhancecolor.
Antidandruffformulationshelpcontrolflakyscalp.
Someproductsmaycontainconditionersorshineagentsandmayalsobecalledtwo
inoneorthreeinoneproducts.
Childrensproductsareespeciallygentle.

MAKEUP

Eyemakeup

Eyemakeupconsistsofthefollowingproducts:
Eyeshadow,whichisusedontheeyelidorundertheeyebrowtogivetheappearance
of a shadow, is available in such forms of sticks, cakes, liquids, pencils, or brushons,
andinavarietyofcolorsandattributes.
Mascara is used on eyelashes to darken, color, and/or thicken. Mascaras that are
colorlessorsheertintedarealsoincluded.
Otherproductsincludeeyebrowproducts,whichareusedtodarkenandadddefinition
to eyebrows; eyeliners, which are used to line or darken the eyelid; and eye lining
pencils,whichareusedtoaddcoloraboveand/orbelowtheeyelid.

Productssuchasartificialeyelashes,tweezers,andotherimplementsarenotincluded.
Eyemakeupremoversarecoveredinthemiscellaneousproductscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

19

110

Introduction

Facemakeup

Facemakeupisappliedtothefacetocreatesmoothandpolishedlook.
Products covered in this section are makeup bases, face powders, blushers, and
concealers.
Makeup bases or foundations are applied to the face before other makeup products
such as powders and blushers. Twoinone products that can be applied dry like a
powder or wet like a base are also included in this category. Bases are available in
different textural finishes including lotions, creams, cakes, gels, aerosols, sticks, or
mousses, and in medicated or hypoallergenic formulations. Some products like
concealersmorethoroughlycoverskinimperfections.
Facepowdersareformulatedtolightlycoverthefaceorothermakeuptoimpartsubtle
color, provide an even appearance, and help control shine and oil. Products are
traditionallyavailableinpressedcakeorloosepowderforms.
Blushers are applied to the face to add color, usually after a concealer and makeup
base has been applied. Products are available in several forms, the most common of
whichisbrushonpowder.Otherformsincludecream,gel,liquid,stick,pencil,bronzer,
andmousse.
Coversticksandconcealersarealsoincludedinthiscategory.
Concealersformulatedtotreatskinrelatedproblemsarenotcoveredinthissection.

Lipsticksandlipglosses

Lipsticksandlipglossescolor,moisturize,addshine,protectthelips,andcanalsoalterthe
apparentshapeofthelips.
Lipsticks are soft solids that are most typically applied in stick form but are also
availableincompactsandlargepencils.
Lip glosses, which range from liquids to very soft solids, are sold in small jars, pots,
compacts,tubes,androlloncontainers.
Liplinersaretypicallyusedtooutlinethelipstogivethemgreaterdefinition.

Lipbalmsandjelliesareanalyzedseparatelyaspartoftheoralcareproductsclass.

Nailpolishes

Nailpolishesincludethreesubcategories:
Enamels, which gives color and gloss to the fingernails and strengthen them against
breaking.Productscomeinvariousshadesandcolors.
Basecoats,whichareapplieddirectlyonthenailbeforeenamel.Ridgefillersareatype
ofbasecoatthatisspeciallydesignedtoensurethatthenailsurfaceiscoatedevenly.
Topcoats,whichareappliedafterpolishing,tosealtheenamelandprovideprotection
againstchipping.
Multifunctionalproductswhichincorporatealloftheabovebenefitsarealsoincluded.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

Introduction

Topcoatsandbasecoatsmaybeusedalonebutaremorecommonlyusedinadditiontonail
enamel.
Some clear coats are positioned as threeinone coats for use before and after nail
polish,orevenalone.

Nail hardeners are products specifically formulated to provide added durability. Nail
hardenersthatcontaincolorandthosethatarepositionedasbasecoatsareincludedinthe
nailpolishescategory.

Thiscategorydoesnotincludeartificialnails,nailtreatments,nailpolishremovers,orany
nailcareimplements.

ORALCAREPRODUCTS

Dentureproducts

Cleansers are available in tablet, cream, gel, powder, and crystal forms and are used to
removefoodanddebrisfromdentures.

Adhesivesareavailableascreams,powders,liquids,andstripsandaredesignedtosecure
denturesinplace.

Denturelinersandcushionsarenotincludedaspartofthisanalysis.

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Lipbalmsprotectthelipsagainstchappingduringcoldweatheranddryinginwarmweather.
Products are available in natural, fruit, and other flavors, and with such benefits as
sunscreenandaddedvitamins.
LipbalmsmarketedbysuchsuncarebrandsasBananaBoatrepresentminorsalesand
areincludedintheSunCareProductssectionofthisreport.
Lip balm brands that contain SPF such as ChapStick and Blistex are included in this
category.

Lipjelliesalsopreventchappinganddryingandaresimplyamoreconvenientlypackaged
methodofapplyingpetroleumjellytothelips.
Traditionalpetroleumjelly,whichisnotspecificallypackagedasalipcareproduct,is
not included in this category but is profiled in the miscellaneous products section of
thisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

111

112

Introduction

Liptreatmentsconditionlips,smoothmouthlines,controlslipsticksmudgingandbleeding,
andgivelipsafullerappearance.Thisincludeslipplumpers.

Lip balm products that are marketed exclusively as ultratherapeutic products, such as
CamphoPhenique,Herpecin,andTanac,arenotcoveredinthisreportbutarediscussedin
NonprescriptionDrugsUSA.

Products where color is the primary benefit are covered in the lipsticks and lip glosses
categoryofthisreport.

Mouthwashes

Mouthwashes,gargles,andrinsesareliquidproductsthatareusedtocleansethemouth,
fortifyteeth,andfreshenbreath.
In some cases, mouthwashes are also used to help treat or prevent sore throats and
coldsaswellascavities,plaque,andgumdisorders.
Mouthwashes, gargles, and rinses are generally positioned as breathfreshening,
antibacterial,orantiplaque,andsomearealsofluoridetreatments.
Breathfreshenerssuchassprays,arenotcoveredinthisreport.

Toothbrushes

Toothbrushesareusedtoapplytoothpastes,gels,anddentalcreamsforcleaning,polishing,
andwhiteningteeth,aswellascleansingthemouth.

Toothbrushescomeinavarietyofshapes,sizes,anddesigns.
Thecategory,however,isbroadlyclassifiedintotwosegments:childrenandadults.
Thechildrenssegmentcoverstoothbrushesdesignedforyouth,children,andtoddlers.
Thisreportincludesmanualandbatterypoweredbrushes.

Electrictoothbrushesarenotcoveredinthisreport.

Toothpastes

Toothpastesareusedtoclean,polish,andwhitentheteeth,aswellascleansethemouth,
sweetenthebreath,andreduceincidenceoftoothdecayandgumproblems.
Products are available primarily as pastes and gels, but are also sold as powders and
liquiddrops.

Toothwhiteningproducts

Toothwhiteningproductsareappliedtotheteethtoobtainalightershade.
Products are available primarily as whitening strips, brushon gels, and moldable
mouthpiecesortrays.

Thisreportcoversproductsforathomeuseonly.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

Introduction

SKINCAREPRODUCTS

Babycareproducts

Babycareproductsaredesignedtosoothe,protect,andhealthetenderskinofinfantsand
youngchildren,particularlyskinthatisirritatedfromdiaperrashandchafing.

Thissegmentincludesbabybath,lotions,oils,andpowders.Excludedarebabyshampoos
anddiaperrashcreams.

Theseproductsarealsooftenusedbyadultsasbathoils,skinmoisturizers,skinsoothers,
andforeyemakeupremoval.

Facialtreatments

Facialtreatmentsperformvariousfunctionsand,whilesomeoverlapexists,mostproducts
aregroupedintooneofthefollowingsegments:
Moisturizers and treatments keep skin soft, firm, smooth, and often claim to protect
skin and reduce signs of aging. Such treatments as eye creams, serums, and acne
productsarealsoincludedhere.
Thecleanserssegmentconsistsofcleansers,masques,porestrips,andfacialcleansing
cloths.Cleansingcreams,lotions,gels,andbarscleansetheskinandremovemakeup.
Masquesaredesignedtocleanse,firm,purify,ormoisturizethefacebyexfoliatingskin,
absorbing oil, or providing moisturizing benefits, and are typically worn for several
minutes or overnight. Pore strips are designed to cleanse clogged pores and remove
blackheads by applying and removing a bandagelike strip. Facial cleansing cloths,
wipes, and towelettes are designed to cleanse the skin and remove makeup with or
withouttheuseofwater.
Acneaidsarecreamsandlotionsforcontrolofmildinfections,orotherskinblemishes.
Astringentsandtonersstimulatetheskin,helpremoveexcessoil,andcanalsoreduce
appearanceofporesize.
Makeupremoversarenowincludedasfacialtreatmentsinthisreport,whereasin2010
editionandpreviouslyitwasinmiscellaneousproducts.

Oilblottersandfacialtissuesthatdonotcontainacleansingagentarenotincludedinthis
report.

Handandbodylotions

Handandbodycreams,lotions,andtreatmentsaredesignedtopreservethenaturalbeauty,
youthfulfeel,andappearanceofskinandtoprotectagainstenvironmentalharm.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

113

114

Introduction

Productsareformulatedtosmoothandlubricate,moisturize,sootheandpreventdryness,
relievechapping,protectagainstexternaldamage,andsometimesexfoliate.

Included are such specialty body treatments as skinfirming products, body masques, and
relatedproducts.

Fragrancelineextensionsofbodylotionsarealsoincluded.

Footcareproductsincludesmoothinglotionsandcreams,deodorizers,powders,exfoliating
scrubs,andwashesarealsoincluded.
Athletes foot products, fungicidal products, and corn and callus removers are not
included in this report but are discussed in Klines companion report Nonprescription
DrugsUSA.
Specialtyfootinsertsarealsoexcludedfromthisreport.

Skincareproductsformen

Skin care products for men include moisturizers, night creams, antiaging products, facial
and body cleansers, hand and body lotions, replenishing eye creams, exfoliating scrubs,
facialmasques,andaftersportstreatmentsmarketedspecificallytomen.

Thefollowingproductsarenotincludedinthiscategorybutarereportedintheirrespective
sectionsofthisreport:shavingcreamsandgels,personalcleansingproducts,deodorants,
andaftershaves.

Although men often use allpurpose or womens skin care products, such usage is not
includedhere.

Suncareproducts

Fivetypesofsuncareproductsareincludedhere,manyofwhichareavailableascreams,
gels,foams,lotions,oils,sprays,andsticks:
SuntanningproductswithSPF5andunder,whichpromotetanningoftheskinunder
sunlight.
Sunscreens with SPF6 to SPF14 and sunblocks with SPF15 and over, which can
eliminateupto99%ofthesunsultraviolet(UV)radiationandthuspreventburningor
prolongtanning.
Sunless tanning products, which represent two types of products: products that tan
withoutexposingtheskintothesun,andproductsthatalsocontainsunscreen.
Aftersun products, which often contain aloe vera and are designed to soothe and
moisturize sun exposed skin. Lip balms marketed by such sun care brands as Banana
Boat are included in the aftersun and other products segment of this category. Lip
balmbrandslikeChapStickandBlistexthatcontainSPFarereportedintheLipBalms,
Jellies,andtreatmentsproductcategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

Introduction

SPFisthestandardmeasurementofasunscreenscapacitytoprotectagainstUVrays.
TheSPFnumberreferstotheeffectivenessofsuncarepreparationsinprotectingthe
skinfromtheharmfuleffectsofthesunsUVradiation.
ThewavelengthsoftheUVraysemittedbythesunlongalpha(UVA)raysandshort
beta(UVB)raysaffecttheskindifferently.

Facialmoisturizers,bodymoisturizers,makeup,andotherproductsthatareratedwithan
SPF but for which sun protection is considered a secondary benefit are included in their
respectiveproductcategorieswithinthisstudy.

OTHERTOILETRIES

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

Antiperspirantsaredesignedtoeitherinhibitorstoptheflowofperspirationandmayalso
preventodor.

Deodorantssuppressbacterialdecompositionthatcausesodor.

Deodorantsandantiperspirantsareofferedinmanyproductforms.
Solid sticks have an antiperspirant active powder suspended in a wax matrix and are
twistedupandappliedonusersskin;therearetwomaintypesofsolidsticks.Regular
solidsticksweretheoriginalsolidstickintroduced.Invisiblesolidsticksorsheersolids
aresolidstickswithasofterfeel.
Softsolidextrudablesextrudecreamysolidthroughmeshdome.
Gelsareeitherclearoropaqueandusuallyassociatedwithwetandcooling,butalsoa
morestickyandslipperyfeel.
Rollons are one of the original modern forms of antiperspirant delivery; aqueous
solutionsarerolloutontousersskinviaarollingball.
Aerosolsaresprayedontousersunderarmorotherareasofthebody.

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

Depilatoriesaredesignedtoremoveunwantedhairandareanalternativetoshaving.
Most depilatories contain an alkaline chemical that causes the hair shaft to separate
fromtheskinsothehaircanbewipedaway.
Theseproductsareofferedingels,creams,lotions,rollons,mousses,andaerosols.
Theseproductsareeffectiveforaboutsevendays.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

115

116

Introduction

Waxesareappliedtounwantedhairandpeeledoff,removinghairdowntotheroot,not
justattheskinssurface.
Theseproductsareavailableinhotandcoldvarieties.
Someofthenewerwaxescontainsugar,whichissaidtohelptheremovalprocess.
Typically,theseproductsareeffectiveforthreetoeightweeksbeforeregrowthoccurs.

Bleachesareproductsthatfadehairratherthanremoveit.
Theseproductsaremostcommonlyusedinthefacialarea.
Theseproductsaretypicallyeffectivefortwotothreeweeks.

Not included in category sales are buffer products or epilettes, which are a more
mechanicalmeansofhairremoval/sloughing.
Otherminorproductformsarealsoavailable,suchaspaste,rockorcrystal,andwipe
ontowellettes.

Alsoexcludedareprofessionaluseproducts.

Personalcleansingproducts

Personalcleansingproductsaredividedintosixproducttypes:
Bar soaps include traditional commodity soaps such as deodorant, moisturing, and
complexion soaps as well as specialty soaps such as highly fragranced and novelty
soaps.
Bodywashesaretypicallyforuseovertheentirebodyandareusedexclusivelyinthe
shower,inplaceofbarsoaps.

Pricepointsarehigherthancommoditybar,liquid,andsomelowerpricedspecialtysoaps.

Thissegmentdoesnotincludebathandshowergels;suchproductsarecoveredintheBath
Additivessegmentofthisreport.
Liquid soaps are usually available in pump packaging and often contain moisturizing
andconditioningagents.

Mostmanufacturersofferrefills.

Mechanicshandsoapsorwaterlesshandcleanersareexcludedfromthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

Introduction

Liquid gels for use over the entire body, in the bath or shower, are covered in the Bath
Additivessectionofthisreport.
Antibacterialhandgelsorhandsanitizersaredesignedtofightoffgermsonthehands
withoutsoap,water,ortowelsinapproximately15seconds.
Most contain a bitter agent that has been added to discourage ingestion by pets or
children.
Bathadditivestypicallyofferthefollowingbenefits:
Softenwaterforgentleskincare.
Moisturize,sootheandsmoothskin.
Impartfragrancetowaterandapleasantatmospherearoundthebath.
Offertargetedaromachology/aromatherapeuticbenefits,suchasstressreduction.
Productsareofferedinthefollowingforms:
Bath liquids, grains, cream baths, cubes, salts, crystals, tablets, sachets, and mousses
areformulatedtoeithercreatefoamunderrunningbathwaterordissolveinthebath
tosoftenandperfumethewater.
Productsaretypicallysegmentedtoappealtoadults,teens,orchildren.
Bath and shower oils and gels are an extension of bubble baths, offering a high
moisturizingbenefitandleavingskinfeelingsoftandsmooth.
Fragrancebathadditivesaregenerallyincludedinpopularfragrancelines.
The bath additives section covers adult and childrens bath additives. Infant bath
additivesarediscussedseparatelyinthebabycarecategoryofthisreport.

Shavingproducts

Shavingproductsincludeshavingcreamsandsoapsandpreshavelotions.
Shaving creams and soaps, available in scented and unscented forms, are used to
softenthebeardbeforeshavingwitharazor.
Aerosol types, including foams and gels, are by far the most popular, but some
brushlessshavingproducts,lathercreams,andsoapsarestillsold.

Preshavelotionsareusedtocoatthebeardandlubricatetheskinbeforeshaving.

Razorsareexcluded.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

117

118

Introduction

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

ExecutiveSummary

SectionTwo

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

EXECUTIVESUMMARY

SectionTwoof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJuly1,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employeesofsubscribingcompaniesandtheirsubsidiaries,asdefinedabove,untilJuly1,2016.
Similarly,allsectionsofthesurveyaresorestrictedforthreeyearsfromtheirdatesofissue.
Failuretopreventunauthorizeddisclosurebeforethesedateswillresultinlegalactionagainst
thesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

EXECUTIVESUMMARY..........................................................................................................21
Personalcarethrivesoninnovationsinfusedwithbettertechnologies
andomnimediamarketingstrategies.............................................................................21
Retaillandscape.............................................................................................................212
Structureoftheindustry................................................................................................219
Outlook..........................................................................................................................223
Appraisalandopportunityassessment.........................................................................226

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

EXECUTIVESUMMARY

PERSONALCARETHRIVESONINNOVATIONSINFUSEDWITHBETTERTECHNOLOGIES
ANDOMNIMEDIAMARKETINGSTRATEGIES

Improving economy supported by several innovative product launches, an increase in


traceable media expenditures (TME) and promotional activities, and moderatetoheavy
acquisition activity support the overall growth of the cosmetics and toiletries market in
2012.
Manufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesgrow3.4%to$40.4billionin2012.
Other factors attributing to the growth of the cosmetics and toiletries market in the
United States include marketers introducing products with better technologies, rising
consumer confidence with the recovering economy, an increase in promotional
activities,andacontinualshifttowardsnaturalproducts.
Consumerssplurgeonproductsthatcanhelpthemlookbetter,stayyoungerlooking,
andofferspecificbenefitssuitingtheirneeds.
Additionally,manyofthecategoriesthatareshowingsubstantialgrowthsuchasfacial
treatments are growing because of products marketed as a way to stave off or
eliminatemedicalprocedureslikeinjectionsandcosmeticsurgery.
Since2007,saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.1%.

Figure21:ManufacturersSalesintheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustry,2007to2012
$Billion
45
39.0

40
36.4

36.6

36.3

2007

2008

2009

40.4

37.3

35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0
2010

2011

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

2012

22

ExecutiveSummary

Consumers continue to spend on products that claim to provide multiple benefits and
professionallikeresultsin2012.
Consumers are spending on valueadded cosmetics and toiletries products, especially
onproductswhichoffermultiplebenefitsandmeettheirspecificrequirements.
However,atrendobservedisthatsomeconsumerritualsinvolvemoreproducts,such
asserums.
Consumersoptforproductsofferingprofessionalresultsathome,especiallyinproduct
classes,suchasskincareandhaircare.
Mass marketers continue to bridge the gaps within luxury products by introducing
masstige products with technological advancements and multiple benefits, but the
luxurytradeclassgrowsthefastest,followedbyspecialty.
The frequency at which women consumers visit salons is increasing compared to the
previousfewyears,supportingthegrowthofprofessionalhaircareproducts.

Recoveringeconomyaidssalesofthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
Consumers are open to spending more, yet conservatively, on products that are
technicallyadvanced,offermultibenefits,andprovidevaluefortheirmoney.
Theluxuryconsumersreturnstronglyin2012,tradingbackuptoluxuryproductsfrom
massbrands,andshoppingindepartmentstoresmorefrequently.
Thespecialtystoreschannelperformswellin2012,supportedbyincreasingsalesfrom
vertically integrated retailers such as Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret, along
withgrowthfromcosmeticspecialtystores,suchasSephoraandUlta.

Mostmarketersincreasetheiradvertisingbudgetin2012tosupporttheirbrands.
Newproductlaunchesareaggressivelysupportedbymediaexpenditures.
Total TME spending on the cosmetics and toiletries market for 2012 increases by
approximately16%.
MarketersspendingthehighestTMEin2012areL'Oral,Procter&Gamble,Unilever,
andEsteLauder.
Thetopfivemarketersspendapproximately66%ofthetotalTMEspendin2012.
FacialtreatmentscategoryreceivesthehighestTMEof$1.3billionin2012,followedby
shampooswithaTMEof$446million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

23

ExecutiveSummary

Socialmediacontinuestogainprominenceincommunicatingcloselywithconsumers,and
social media sites such as Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, Pinterest, and YouTube are used by
mostmarketerstoestablishaconnectionwithconsumers,especiallytheyoungeraudience.
The marketers prominently provide information on new product launches and other
product offers on their respective social media pages. For example, Maybellines
Facebookpageoffersbeautytipstoitssubscribersinordertokeepthemupdatedwith
thelatesttrendsandlaunchesunderthebrand.
PresenceonthesocialnetworkingwebsitessuchasFacebookbecomesaneconomical
meanstostayintouchwithexistingandpotentialcustomers.
In 2012, Maybelline celebrates 1 million fans for its Facebook page, Sensational
Maybelline.
YouTube is considered a powerful marketing tool due to its ability to captivate the
consumers attention through videos, which are more appealing than static pictures
and words. Videos that manage to go viral, inspiring multiple forwards from
consumerstotheirfriends,drumupsignificantpublicityforbrands.Increasingly,most
leadingbrandshavetheirindividualYouTubechanneltoconnectwiththeirconsumers.
Overall,socialmediaisusedasatooltoadvertisenewproductactivity,sharefeedback,
establishapersonalconnectionwithconsumers,andgatherinstantconsumeropinion
aboutproductofferings.

Figure22:FactorsAffectingtheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustry,2012

Naturally
positioned
products
Increasinguseof
smartphones
drives
interactionwith
brands

Innovative
productswith
better
technologies

Stable
Growth

Increasein
marketingand
promotional
activities

Risingconsumer
confidence

Products
providing
better/
professional
results

Multibenefit
productsthrive

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

24

ExecutiveSummary

Consumersareincreasinglyseekingvaluebasedpersonalcareproducts.
However,theyareopentospendingonproductsthatcanaddresstheirspecificneeds.
Thisisevidentbytheincreasingsalesinthedepartmentandspecialtystores.
A mix of products at different price points keeps the pressure on different retail
channels to consistently innovate to retain their consumers. This eventually leads to
better shopping experience for consumers either in terms of competitive pricing or
betterproductquality.
The other channels, such as food stores and drug stores, also increase their product
portfoliotomaintaintheirsalesgrowth.
Marketers use an increasing number of retail channels and marketing tools to reach
consumers.

Productinnovationsbackedupwithsciencebasedtechnologiessupportthegrowthofthe
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Products with technological advancements primarily in the skin care product class
support the sales of the cosmetics and toiletries industry in 2012. Further, products
thatspantwoormorecategoriesarepopular.
Products with multibenefits across categories including skin care, hair care, and oral
caredrivethevaluesalesoftheindustryin2012.
Naturalandorganicproductscontinuetobeindemand.Tomeetthegrowingdemand
fromconsumers,marketersalsoinnovateandlaunchadvancednaturalproducts.

Marketerscontinuetoevolvewithinnovativemarketingstrategiesinordertosupporttheir
salesovertheforecastperiod.
In 2012, LOral launches a femalecentric Xbox application to keep its female
consumers engaged with its brands. The new application Next Level offers product
articles,howtovideos,andlatestbeautystylesandtrendsbasedonLOralsbrandsin
theUnitedStates.

Facial treatments continues to be the leading category in the cosmetics and toiletries
industryin2012,contributingto16.4%ofthetotalsales.
ThefacialtreatmentsmarketintheUnitedStateshasanotheryearofstronggrowth,
up4.5%during2012.
Consumers continue to invest in themselves by spending money on products and
devicestokeepagingatbay.
The highest percentage growth occurred among products in the luxury trade class,
followed by those in the professional trade class, indicating consumers further
willingnesstospendonthemselvesandtotradeuptomorepremiumproducts.
Newproductstypicallycreateexcitementinthefacialtreatmentarenaandoneofthe
bigproductstoriesduring2012isthegrowthofBBcreams,thatareessentiallyhybrid
productsthatblurthedistinctionbetweenskincareandfacemakeup.Forpurposesof
thisreport,theyarecategorizedasfacialtreatments,andnotasmakeup.
Technologybackedwithclaims,suchasvisibleresults,isoneofbiggrowthdriversof
facialtreatmentsduringtheyear.
Productsthatinteractwithskincells,eithertoactivategenesorcorrectflawsandthat
offernoticeableresultshelptostimulatesales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

ExecutiveSummary

Theuseofmultipleserumsonthefaceisalsoagrowingtrend.Thesenewgeneration
serumstypicallycontaineitherdryoils,hyaluronicacid,orotheracids,andarelightin
textureforfastabsorptionsothattheycanbelayeredunderotherserums.Examples
of these serums launched in 2012 include Ferulic Acid + Retinol Brightening Solution
from Dr. Dennis Gross, Body Shop Nutriganics Drops of Youth, and Este Lauders
PerfectionistCP+Rserum.
BB Creams, also known as beauty balms, blemish balms, or beauty benefit creams,
surfacedintheUnitedStatesinlate2011.Theseproductsexplodeonthescenein2012,
withmostmajorfacialtreatmentandmakeupmarketerslaunchingtheirownversion
oftheseproductsduringtheyear.
During 2012, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) continues to look at the
marketing claims of facial treatment products, especially those making claims of
biologicallyenhancedbenefits.
An increasing number of beauty specialty retailers launch their own facial treatment
linesinthepasttwoyears.Thesearenotlinesthatmimicnationallyadvertisedbrands,
butrathercontainaproprietarymixofingredientsgearedtotheneedsoftheretailers
customerbase.
Sephora started the trend with the launch of the Sephora Collection in early 2011
which is sold at all Sephora and Sephora within JCP locations. The ingredient theme
running through the line is a proprietary plantderived ingredient that the company
claimsismoreeffectivethannationallyadvertisedbrands.
UltalaunchedUltaSkincareinmid2012,afteranunsuccessfulattemptatitsownfacial
treatmentproductsafewyearsprior.Theingredientstoryofthislineisaproprietary
complexcalledAdvancedProtectionFactor+,saidtocombatfreeradicals.

In2012,multibenefitproductsthatprovideprofessionalresultsathomecontinuetogain
attention.
Thetrendofprofessionalresultsathomethatemergedin2010,continuedinto2012
as women upgrade their facial treatment regimen to peels and more expensive at
hometreatmentsinlieuofvisitingaprofessional.
RoCs Retinol Correxion Max Wrinkle Resurfacing System is a twostep system that
renews the look and feel of skin and claims to be clinically proven to be up to four
timesmoreeffectivethanaseriesofdermatologicalpeels.
Although, antiaging products continue to garner the most attention in 2012, multi
benefitproductsthatworktoeliminateandreducesignsofaging,suchasfinelinesand
wrinkles, lighten and brighten skin, provide a smooth appearance, and reduce dark
spotsdrivesalesofthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
BB creams function as hybrid products that offer both facial treatment and cosmetic
properties, by offering treatment benefits, sun protection, and other attributes
dependingontheproduct,allwiththegoalofperfectskin.Somebrandsoffermultiple
shades,whileothersofferoneshadethatisappropriatetomostskintones.
Some of the most notable BB cream launches during the year include entries from
BobbiBrown,EsteLauder,Smashbox,LOralParis,Garnier,andLancme.
Inlate2012andearly2013,CCorcolorcorrectioncreamsbegintoappearontheU.S.
market,andthereareexpectationsthatDDordailydefensecreamsmightalsoemerge
in2013and2014.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

25

26

ExecutiveSummary

Antiaging sun care products, providing the dual function of sun protection and cell
repair,arealsoanothersoughtaftersegmentofproducts.
Face makeup products with multiple skin care benefits such as antiaging and
moisturizingdrivethesalesin2012.
Severalleadingmarketerslaunchmultibenefitproductsin2012.
In the hair styling category, Unilever launches TRESemm Platinum Strength Heat
ProtectSpraythatfortifiesandstrengthenshair.
Inthelipbalmscategory,MargaritavillelaunchesFloridaysMoisturizingLipBalmwith
SPF50thatprovidesmoisturizationbenefitsaswellassunprotection.
Intheshampooscategory,Procter&GamblelaunchesPanteneAgeDefyshampoothat
works together to help hair act up to 10 years younger by thickening existing hair
strands.
Kaolaunchescolorprotectionandcolorenhancementhaircareproductsin2012.
Inthemouthwashescategory,ColgatePalmoliveexpandsitsOpticWhiteportfoliowith
anewRefreshingMintmouthwashthatclaimstoeffectivelywhitenteethandprotect
againstfuturestains.
In the toothpastes category, several leading marketers including ColgatePalmolive,
Procter&Gamble,andGlaxoSmithKlineintroducemultibenefittoothpastes.

In2012,productsinfusedwithnaturalingredientscontinuetoperformwell,supportedby
severalnaturallypositionedproductlaunches.
Growingpublicconcernaboutsyntheticingredients,suchastriclosanandparabensare
drivingthesalesofnaturalproducts.
Consumersarebecomingmoreawareandeducatedabouttheingredientsinpersonal
careproducts.
Consumers incorporate the trend of health and wellness in their spending patterns,
and shift to natural products for their personal care needs, as they contain minimal
levelsofsyntheticcompounds.
Suchproductsaregenerallypricedhigherthanregularbrandsandhelptheindustryto
growitsoverallsalesvalue.
Natural and organic products are becoming more mainstream, with their availability
spreadinginallchannels.
Marketers are introducing natural products in niche and growing segments, such as
mensskincareandethnichaircare.
Several leading marketers including LOral and Procter & Gamble launch naturally
positionedproductsacrosscategoriestosupporttheiroverallsales.
In the oral care product class, Hello Products, based out of New Jersey, introduces a
newlinecalled99%naturaloralcareproductsincludingtoothpastes,mouthwashes,
andbreathfreshenersunderthebrandnameHello.
Inthehaircareproductclass,LOralintroducesEverCremelinethatclaimstocontain
naturalbotanicalsandisfreefromparabens.
LOralalsointroducesseveralnaturallypositionedproductsundertheGarnierFructis
andLOralParislinesin2012.
However,thetrendofusingnaturalingredientsincosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsis
slowly reaching its maturity as natural or naturally positioned products find their
presenceinalmostallproductclassesandevenbrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

ExecutiveSummary

Some of the causes of less than exceptional growth include increasing FDA scrutiny on
productclaimsandmarketersfocusoninternationalmarkets.
Ongoing factors such as a competitive environment, a mature economy, and
globalization have forced most of the leading marketers to expand their business
outsidetheboundariesoftheUnitedStatestomaintaintheirprofitmargins.
Domestic marketers in the industry have a significant interest in expanding their
businessesinternationally.
Marketerscontinuetofocusonexpandingtheirbusinessesintheemergingcountries
including Brazil, Russia, India, and China where the growth for the industry is higher
thanintheUnitedStates.
ThemarketsinAsiapromiselargesalesvolumesforglobalmarketersintheindustry.
Highly populated countries such as India and China can be great prospects for
expansion in the beauty industry as the standard of living in these countries is on a
sharprise.
This has been a major reason for U.S.based global companies to focus more on
developingtheiroperationsintheemergingAsianmarkets.Manyoftheglobalplayers
have been shifting focus and resources outside the United States, thereby reducing
supportfortheirbrandsinthiscountry.

The 26 product categories analyzed in Cosmetics& Toiletries USA are grouped into six
productclasses,asfollows:
Fragrances
Haircareproducts
Makeupproducts
Oralcareproducts
Othertoiletries
Skincareproducts

Skin care continues to be the largest product class in 2012, representing 25.8% of sales,
marginallyupfrom25.6%ofsalesin2011.

Themakeupproductclassisthesecondleadingproductclass,representing19.0%oftotal
dollarsalesin2012.

Dollar sales for the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries industry advance 3.4% in 2012 to
$40,372million,upfrom$39,026millionin2011.

Alltheproductclassesregisterasalesgrowthabove1.0%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

27

28

ExecutiveSummary

Figure23:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductClass,2012

Fragrances,9.5%
Skincare,25.8%

Oralcare,10.5%

Othertoiletries,
16.4%
Makeup,19.0%
Haircare,18.8%

Makeupregistersthehighestgrowthrateof4.3%in2012.
Eyemakeupandfacemakeupcategoriesprimarilysupportthegrowthofthemakeup
productclassin2012.
Both face makeup and eye makeup collectively represent 75.5% of total makeup
productclasssalesin2012.
Growth of the eye makeup category is fueled by new product launches that include
productswithmultiplebenefitsandnewbrushtechnology.
Themostdramaticgrowthcomesfromeyelinerandeyebrowproductsaswomenstrive
for eyes that communicate sex appeal, with dramatic eyeliner and accentuated
eyebrows.
All face makeup product types contribute to the categorys growth. The luxury class
outperforms all other classes. Complexion products continue to be an important
componentinawomensmakeupregimenastheystriveforaflawlessfinish.
Nail polishes is the smallest makeup category, though continues to be the fastest
growingcategory,upby17.4%from$564millionin2011to$662millionin2012.Nail
polishesrepresent8.6%oftotalsalesin2012,upfroma7.0%sharein2011.
Thenailpolishboomcontinuesasmarketersprovideabundantinnovativetechnologies
with products for consumers to imitate salon effects in a costeffective manner at
home.Theassortmentofnailcolorsandthosewithuniquefinishesandtexturesfrom
geltocaviartovelvetandsequinnailscontinuetoaddfreshnesstothecategory.
Lipsticksandlipglossesrepresent18.0%oftotalmakeupsalesin2012,upslightlyfrom
17.6%oftotalmakeupsalesin2011.
Lipsticks perform better than lip glosses and lip liners due to fashion trends, and the
new formulas available on the market. Longwearing lipsticks that go on sheer with
buildablepigmentsarepopular.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

ExecutiveSummary

Skincareisthesecondfastestgrowingproductclassin2012,withsalesimprovingby4.1%
to$10,433million,upfrom$10,021millionin2011.
Sun care products and skin care products for men post the highest growth in the
productclassin2012.
Facial treatments primarily contribute to the growth of the skin careproduct class in
2012. Antiaging remains the major thrust of the facial treatments category. While
serums in facial treatment products have been popular for the past few years, 2012
seesthelaunchofserumsspecificallyfortheeyearea,tobeusedwithaneyecream.
Facial treatment marketers are getting bolder about touting product benefits, which
getsnoticedbytheFDA.
Allthecategoriesintheskincareproductclasspostgrowthofmorethan1.0%in2012.
Hand and body lotions enriched with antiaging benefits continue to be a prominent
trend.
The availability of hand and body lotions in a variety of exotic fragrances is a
significantlygrowingtrend.
Thesuncarecategorysgrowthisdrivenbyanincreasingawarenessamongconsumers
about the harmful effects of the skins exposure to the suns rays. Other factors
contributingtothesuncarecategorysgrowthincludenewproductactivity,packaging
and labeling changes, and innovative reformulations. The category is hampered by
increasing SPF properties in other categories, such as face makeup and facial
treatments.
Mensfacialskincarerepresentsahighgrowthopportunityformarketers.
ThepracticallyflatbirthrateintheUnitedStateshasadetrimentaleffectonthebaby
careproductscategoryssales,yetnaturalproductsdoparticularlywell.

Ofthe26categoriesanalyzedinthisstudy,24categoriesexperiencesalesgrowthin2012.
Thecategoriesthatdeclinearehaircoloringproductsandtoothwhiteningproducts.

Figure24:TheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustrysGrowthRates,2002to2012
Change,%
5%

4%

3%

2%

1%

0%

1%

2%
2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

2011

2012

29

210

ExecutiveSummary

Figure25:TheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustrysGrowthRatesbyProductClass,2011to2012
$Million
14,000
Change,
4.1%

12,000

10,433

10,000

10,021
Change,
2.9%

Change,
4.3%

7,341

Change,
3.0%

7,610

7,657

8,000

7,393

6,412

6,602
Change,
1.6%

6,000
4,000

Change,
3.9%

4,184 4,252

3,675 3,818

Oralcare

Fragrances

2,000
0
Skincare

Makeup

Haircare
2011

Other
toiletries
2012

Figure26:HistoricalandCurrentGrowthRatesoftheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductClass,2011to
2012
CAGR,%
5%
4.3%

4.1%

4%

3%

3.9%
3.8%

3.0%

2.9%
2.7%
2.5%

2%
1.6%
1.2%

1.2%

1%
0.4%

0%
Skincare

Makeup

Haircare

Othertoiletries

2011

Oralcare

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

Fragrances

211

ExecutiveSummary

Ethnichaircareproducts

Handandbodylotions

Lipsticksandlipglosses

Babycare

Toothpastes

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Dentureproducts

2.1

1.9

1.8

1.8

1.7

1.3

1.3

Fragrancesformen
3.6

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

Facemakeup
3.7

2.1

Fragrancesforwomen
4.0

Toothbrushes

Facialtreatments
4.5

2.2

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments
4.8

Mouthwashes

Conditioners
4.8

2.2

Shampoos
4.8

Shavingproducts

Suncareproducts
6.5

3.0

Skincareproductsformen
9.7

Personalcleansingproducts

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
13.2

3.0

Nailpolishes
17.4

Eyemakeup

Haircoloringproducts
(0.5)

Change, %

3.4

Toothwhiteningproducts
(5.6)

Figure27:TheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustrysGrowthRatebyCategory,2011to2012

Industry Average

Thenailpolishescategorypoststhehighestgrowthin2012,asithassince2010.In2012,it
isupby17.4%,from%564millionin2011to$662millionin2012.
Thenailpolishboomcontinuesasmarketersprovideabundantinnovativetechnologies,
with products for consumers to imitate salon effects in a costeffective manner at
home.
Theassortmentofnailcolorsandthosewithuniquefinishesandtexturesfromgelto
caviartovelvetandsequinnailscontinuetoaddfreshnesstothecategory.
Geltechnologyisoneofthemaindriversinnailpolishesin2012,atrendwhichbegan
intheprofessionalchannelandhasmigratedtoconsumers.Itisthenewstandard,and
thelongwearthatgeltechnologydeliversisverypopular.

Depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category posts the secondhighest growth of 13.2% in
2012.
Olays exceptional growth in 2012 is the primary reason for the categorys healthy
growth.
Factorssuchasnewproductactivity,formulationimprovements,andinnovationdrive
thecategorysgrowthin2012.
Thereisanincreasingtrendtowardsdoityourself(DIY)athomehairremovalproducts
thatgiveresultsalmostsimilartoasalonservice.
Depilatory products in the form of inshower products and hairremoving sprays, are
gainingprominenceinthecategoryduetotheconvenienceofusingtheseproducts.
Consumersareincreasinglyshiftingtowardstheuseofnewerwaxproductsduetothe
advancedtechnologyusedandtheeaseofconvenientapplicationincomparisontothe
previouslydifficulttousewaxproducts.
Products that have ease of application and provide results in less time are proving
moresuccessfulinthemarket.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

212

ExecutiveSummary

Theskincareproductsformencategoryexperiencessignificantgrowthof9.7%in2012.
Prestige marketers, such as Este Lauder, Anthony Brands, and Jack Black introduce
new and innovative product offerings to reach out to the male consumers who are
increasinglybecomingconsciousoftheusageofproductstoimprovetheirappearance.
Marketers have an opportunity to expand in the mens facial skin care segment with
relevant product offerings on antiaging, sun protection, and moisturizing; however,
products that perform well offer multiple benefits in one package, as men prefer a
minimalistroutine.

Thesuncarecategoryisthefourthfastestgrowingcategoryin2012,upby6.5%.
In 2012, sprayon formats, lightweight nongreasy formulas, antiaging benefits,
moisturizingformulas,andmakeupapplicationformatscontinuetogarnerconsumers
attention.
With the new FDA rules and regulations on the broad spectrum coverage, marketers
arelookingatwaysofincreasingtheircompetitivenessinthemarket.
FDAsfinalregulationsforoverthecounter(OTC)sunscreenproductscomeintoeffect
fromJune2012.However,toavertanyshortageoftheseproductsinthemarket,the
FDA extends the compliance dates for testing and labeling of these products to
December17th,2012forlargerbrands,andtoDecember2013forproductswithsales
oflessthan$25,000peryear.
According to the FDAs new regulations, companies manufacturing sun care products
willhavetopasstheUVAandUVBprotectiontestinordertoclaimBroadSpectrum
protectiononitslabel.

RETAILLANDSCAPE

Mass merchandisers continue to be the most preferred retail channel for cosmetics and
toiletries, with total sales advancing 3.5% to reach $12,404 million in 2012, up from
$11,981millionin2011.
Mass merchandisers represent 30.7% of total industrys sales in 2012, constant from
2011levels.
Astheeconomycontinuestorecover,consumersseekvaluefortheirmoneyandseek
outletsofferingthebestprices.
Budgetbrandshelpfuelthegrowthinthemassmerchandiserchannel.
Themassmerchandiserretailchannelcomprisingbigboxretailers,warehouseclubs,
and dollar storesis increasingly viewed as a destination for stocking up on
commoditytype items, such as personal cleansing products, shampoos, and
deodorants.
Marketerscontinuetoevolvewaysinwhichwomencanobtaintheperfectshadevia
virtual online consultants, matching department store brand shades to products in
theirmassline.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

ExecutiveSummary

Privatelabel products, a growing segment in the cosmetics and toiletries market is


predominantly present in mass merchandisers. The increasing popularity of these
privatelabelproductsaidsinthechannelsgrowth.
Additionally,thereisagrowingtrendofmassmerchandiserslaunchingtheirownline
ofprivatelabelproducts.In2012,WalgreensintroducestheOlogylineofproducts.
Mass merchandisers frequently launch promotional campaigns and offer discounts of
variouskinds,whichdrivetheirsalessubstantiallytohigherlevels.
The circulars, which promote a variety of product categories, including cosmetic and
toiletryproducts,aredistributedinstores,weekendnewspapers,andsometimesalong
withotherflyersatlocalsupermarketsanddrugchains.
Mass merchandisers also focus on natural products, which fascinate both the
marketers and consumers. Mass merchandisers continue to include private labels for
naturalpersonalcareproductsinordertocatchmoreattentionfromtheconsumers.

Drug stores follow as the secondleading retail channel for cosmetics and toiletries in the
UnitedStates,withsalesat$7,276millionin2012,up1.8%from$7,149millionin2011.
The share of distribution for drug stores decreases nominally from 18.3% in 2011 to
18.0%in2012.
Drugstorescontinuetooffereconomicalpricedproductsandprivatelabelproducts.
Drug stores continue to lose sales to mass merchandisers and department stores as
thesestoresstartsellingbudgetbrands,whilerevampingandextendingshelfspaceto
morebrands.
Drugstoreretailerscontinuetodiversifytheirproductofferingswithaddedemphasis
onthefrontendtobettercompetewithotherretailchannelsthatencroachtheirturf,
suchasmassmerchandisersandwarehouseclubs.
Drug stores continue to offer loyalty programs and promotional coupons, in order to
enticeshopperswiththebestdeals.
Drugstoresaimatbroadeningthespectrumoftheproductsthattheyoffer,inorderto
havemoreconsumers,andenhancetheirconnectivitywiththem.
Drugstoresareincludingprivatelabelsinasmanyrangesofproductsaspossible,along
withenhancingservicesfromsalespersonnel.
Acquisitions are one of the ways for the major drug chains to grow and have been
responsible for major door expansion of Walgreens since 2005. Small regional chains
arepickedupbybothWalgreensandCVStofillinholesintheirnationalcoverage.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

213

214

ExecutiveSummary

Department stores are the thirdleading retail channel for cosmetics and toiletries, with
salesat$5,417millionin2012,up5.0%from$5,157millionin2011.
The share of sales from department stores increases from 13.2% of sales in 2011 to
13.4%in2012.
Department stores continue to be the most soughtafter shopping destination, as
personalconsultationisakeycomponentfortrialandpurchase.
Many women continue to seek brands that are only found in department stores for
theirlipstickpurchases.
Department store sales are cannibalized as some shoppers purchase from the e
commercesitesofdepartmentstores,whicharecapturedintheInternetsalesofthe
directchannel.
Departmentstoresprovideloyaltyprogramstobuildandstrengthentheirrelationship
with the consumers, by taking initiatives to enhance their communication with
consumers.
Departmentstoresfocusonofferinghighlyadvancedproductsinfusedwithadvanced
technology,soastoexpandtheirconsumerbase.
Consumersarewillingtospendonluxuryandpremiummakeup,facialtreatments,and
fragranceproducts,afterbeingfrugalduetorecessioninthelastfewyears.

FoodstoresarethefourthleadingretailchannelforcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnited
States,withsalesup1.3%toreach$5,217millionin2012,upfrom$5,149millionin2011.
Thedistributionshareforfoodstorescontinuetoslidefrom13.2%in2011to12.9%in
2012.
Foodstorescontinuetodisplayincompetencewhencomparedtomassmerchandisers
and department stores, because mass merchandisers and department stores offer a
widerrangeofproductsatcompetitiveprices.
Food stores, however, focus on natural ingredientbased products that have gained
prominenceinthemarket.Astheseproductsfascinatebothmarketersandconsumers,
thelossofsalestootherchannelsiscompensatedtoaconsiderableextent.
Some food store chains call for thirdparty certification on all personal care and
cosmeticsthatareclaimedtobeorganic.
Ascosmeticandtoiletriesmarketersofferanevergrowingnumberoflineextensions,
foodoutletsoftenfindthemselvesshortofspacetoofferalltheavailableproducts.
Food stores also make an attempt to modify their merchandising layouts in order to
bettersellbeautyproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

ExecutiveSummary

The direct sales channel registers sales at $4,499 million in 2012, up 6.7% from
$4,217millionin2011.
Thedirectsaleschannelaccountsfor11.1%oftheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
in2012,upfrom10.8%in2011.
Thedirectchannelincreasesduetoonlinesalesfrombothbrickandmortarretailers,
suchasspecialtyanddepartmentstores,andtheInternetonlyretailers.
Ecommercecaterstothehighestgrowthofthedirectchannelssales.Theelimination
ofshippingchargesformostbeautypurchasesoveracertainminimum,coupledwith
shoppersfeelingmorecomfortablemakingonlinebeautypurchases,contributestothe
fastgrowthofthissubchannel.
DirectsalesoverallareimpededbyAvonsfailuretokeepupwiththeoverallmarkets
growth.CompaniessuchasAvonrelymostlyondirectsalesrepresentatives,anddue
totheirconsistentpoorperformance,theoverallchannelsuffersfromdeclinein2012.
Offers,suchasfreeshippingandsamples,apartfromsmartphoneapplicationsenhance
thegrowthofecommerceandenabletheconsumerstocomparisonshopquickly.
Persontoperson sales continue to dominate as the largest subclass of the direct
channel,despiteadeclineinmarketshare.
Direct sales channels continue to bank on their personalized services which enable
themtoexpandinspiteofmasscompetition.

Specialty stores register increasing sales of $4,228million in 2012, up 8.2% from


$3,906millionin2011.
Thespecialtystoresaccountfor10.5%oftheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket,up
from10.0%in2011.
Growth in this channel is driven by a large number of new store openings, more
apparel chains with sizeable store counts, knowledgeable sales associates, good
customer service, an easy ability to shop across product lines, and a more fun
environmentthananyotherchannel.
The specialty stores channel grows because of increasing sales from vertically
integrated retailers, such as Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret, along with
growthfromcosmeticspecialtystores,suchasSephoraandUlta.
Cosmeticspecialtystores,includingUltaandSephora,growduetotheirwideproduct
assortments,promotions,opensellenvironment,andloyaltyprograms.
Specialty stores, such as Ulta and Sephora, continue to attract more customers by
openingnewdoorsregularlyandofferingacontinuallywiderassortmentofbrands.
An increasing number of specialty stores continue to introduce their own facial
treatmentlinesinthemarket.
The products offered by the specialty stores contain a proprietary mixture of
ingredientsmeanttofulfilltheneedsoftheretailerscustomerbase.
Furthermore,specialtystoresnowalsofocusondifferentiatingthemselvesfromtheir
competition,byofferingexclusiveorlicensedlines.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

215

216

ExecutiveSummary

The professional channel represents 3.3% of the total industrys sales in 2012, decreasing
from3.8%in2011.
Theprofessionaloutletschannelregisterssalesat$1,331millionin2012,downby9.3%
from$1,467millionin2011.
The increasing popularity of products promising professional results at home
contributestothedeclineofthechannelssalesin2012.
Moreover, consumers continue to opt for doityourself (DIY) solutions across
categoriesincluding,haircoloringproducts,nailpolishes,anddepilatories,waxes,and
bleaches.
Althoughtheeconomyisgettingbetter,consumersfrequencyofvisitingprofessional
outletsremainslowcontributingtothedeclineoftheshareofthechannelin2012.
As a result of the sluggish professional channels performance, some professional
brand marketers are broadening their distribution to include the Internet, specialty
stores,andotherchannelsinordertostaycompetitive.

AmoreindepthanalysisofcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesbyretailoutletisprovidedinKline
&CompanysreportBeautyRetailingUSA.
Thisstudyreviewsandassessesthechallengesthatmarketersmustovercomeinorder
tobesuccessfulandcompetitiveinthedynamicretailenvironment.

Figure28:CosmeticsandToiletriesSalesintheUnitedStatesbyChannel,2011and2012

2011

2012

Professional
outlets,3.8%

Professional
outlets,3.3%

Mass
merchandisers,
30.7%

Specialtystores,
10.0%

Specialtystores,
10.5%

Directsales,
10.8%

Directsales,
11.1%

Mass
merchandisers,
30.7%

Drugstores,
18.0%

Drugstores,
18.3%
Foodstores,
13.2%

Foodstores,
12.9%

Department
stores,13.2%

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

Department
stores,13.4%

217

ExecutiveSummary

Figure29:RetailChannelEvolutionintheUnitedStates,2002and2012

2002

Rank

2012

Massmerchandisers

Massmerchandisers

Foodstores

Drugstores

Drugstores

Departmentstores

Departmentstores

Foodstores

Specialtystores

Directsales

Directsales

Specialtystores

Salons

Salons

Table21:GrowthRatesandKeyTrendsforCosmeticsandToiletriesbyCategory,2012
Category

Changeinsales,
%,20112012

Primarygrowthdriversand/ortrends

FRAGRANCES

3.6

Thesuccessofthefragrancescategoryistiedverycloselytotheholidaysellingseason.
CategorygrowthcontinuestobedrivenbyfirmlyentrenchedbrandssuchasLOralsAcquadi
GiandChanelsBleucontinuingtothrive,andbytheexpansionofreputablefranchisessuch
asProcter&GamblesGucciandDolce&Gabbana.

4.0

Salesgrowtoreachalmostprerecessionlevels.Categorygrowthcontinuestobedrivenby
classicssuchasChanelsCocoMademoiselle,ChanelNo.5,andChance;alongwiththe
expansionofpopularfranchisessuchasElizabethArdensJuicy,andCotysMarcJacobs.Several
newcelebrityscentlaunchesin2012aretargetedatyoungerconsumers,attractingsomeof
themtothefragrancecounterforthefirsttime.Thetrendtowardsmorenaturalpersonalcare
productscouldbeoneofthefactorsstiflingrealgrowthinthefragrancecategory.

Conditioners

4.8

Conditionersthatofferextrabenefitsapartfrommoisturizationperformwellinthecategory.
Conditionersthatcatertotheneedsofvarioushairconcerns,suchasthinning,volumeboost,
andhairtypescontinuetoperformwellin2012.Conditionersthatofferextrabenefits,suchas
protectionfromhaircolorandfrizzprotection,supportthecategorysgrowth.Natural
formulationshavebecomeanorm.

Ethnichaircare
products

2.1

Naturallypositionedproductssupportthecategorysgrowthasethnicconsumersincreasingly
chooseproductsthatcontainnaturalandorganicingredients.IngredientssourcedfromAfrica
playanimportantroleinthecategorysgrowth.

Fragrancesformen

Fragrancesfor
women

HAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Haircoloring
products
Hairstyling
productsandsprays

Shampoos

(0.5)

Astheeconomyrecoversconsumersaremovingbacktoprofessionalhaircoloringservices,
causingdeclineofathomehaircoloring.However,productswithnewformulations,suchas
hairfoamsboostsales.

1.3

Hairstylingproductswithnewformulationsandnewformssupportthecategorysgrowth.Hair
stylingproductsthatcontainnaturalandorganicingredientsremainaprominenttrend,helping
thecategoryssales.Multibenefitproductsgrow.

4.8

Marketersincorporatingmorefunctionalbenefits,suchasfrizzprotectionandantiaging
performwell.Shampoosthatprovideprotectionforcoloredhairandcolorenhancementfor
haircontributetogrowth,asdothosethatcatertospecificconcerns,suchasthinning,and
dandruff

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

218

ExecutiveSummary

Table21:GrowthRatesandKeyTrendsforCosmeticsandToiletriesbyCategory,2012
Category

Changeinsales,
%,20112012

Primarygrowthdriversand/ortrends

MAKEUPPRODUCTS
Eyemakeup

3.4

Growthisfuelledbynewlaunchesthatincludemultiplebenefitsandnewmascarabrush
technology.Themostdramaticgrowthcomesfromeyelinerandeyebrowproducts.The
plethoraofnewandimprovedmascarasaddexcitement.

Facemakeup

3.7

Newlaunchesinfoundationsaswellassolidperformanceofconcealersarethedrivingfactors
behindthegrowth.Complexionproductsareanimportantcomponentinwomensmakeup
regimenastheystriveforaflawlessfinish.

Nailpolishes

17.4

Thenailpolishboomcontinuesasmarketersprovideabundantinnovativetechnologieswith
productsforconsumerstoimitatesaloneffectsinacosteffectivemannerathome.Gel
technologyisoneofthemaindriversinnailpolishin2012.

1.8

Lowgrowthduetolacklustersalesinlipglossandlipliner.Helpingtofuelsalesproductsthat
toutlonglastingcolorandaddedfunctionality,suchasmoisturizingand/orSPFbenefits,along
withattractivepackaging.Formulasthatarehybridsoflipsticks,gloss,andstainsareatthe
forefront.

Dentureproducts

1.3

ThegrowingnumberofdenturewearersintheUnitedStatessupportsthecategoryslimited
growth,becauseoftheagingpopulation..Thedentalaccessoriesmarketcontinuestogrow,as
denturecleansersexpandtheirscopefromdenturesonly.

Lipbalms,jellies,
andtreatments

4.8

Lipbalmsthatprovideprotectionagainstsun,tintedlipbalms,andlipbalmswhichprovide
othertreatmentbenefitsperformwell.

Mouthwashes

2.2

Mouthwashesthatoffermultiplebenefits,suchasteethstrengthening,helpingrebuildenamel,
andpreventingcavitiessupportgrowthin2012.Amongthese,whiteningmouthwashes
performbest.

Toothbrushes

2.2

Increasingmediasupportwithnewproductinnovationsdrivethesalesoftoothbrushesin
2012,andmostoftheleadingmarketersextendtheirproductlines.

Toothpastes

1.7

Toothpastesthatprovidemultibenefitsincludingbattlingtoothsensitivity,teethwhitening,
andpreventingplaquesupportthecategorysgrowth.

Lipsticksandlip
glosses
ORALCARE

Toothwhitening
products

(5.6)

Thecategoryfacesintensecompetitionfrommultibenefittoothpastesandthemouthwashes
category.Limitednewproductactivityfromseveralleadingplayersresultsinsalesdecline.

Babycareproducts

1.8

Thecategoryhasminimalnewproductactivityin2012.Thekeyreasonbehindthemoderate
growthisthealmostflatbirthrateintheUnitedStates.Naturalandorganicproductsarethe
primaryfactorboostingsales.

Facialtreatments

4.5

Withanemphasisonyouth,thedefinitionofantiagingmovesbeyondwrinkleminimization
andskinfirming,toincludebrightening,eveningskintone,andprovidingradiance.Thetrendof
professionalresultsathomethatcontinuesinto2012.

Handandbody
lotions

1.9

Handandbodylotionsofferingtherapeuticbenefitscontributetothecategoryssales.Hand
andbodylotionsenrichedwithantiagingbenefitsareaprominenttrend.

Skincareproducts
formen

9.7

Prestigemarketers,suchasEsteLauder,AnthonyBrands,andJackBlackintroducenewand
innovativeproductofferingstoreachouttothemaleconsumerswhoareincreasingly
becomingconsciousoftheusageofproductstoimprovetheirappearance.

Suncareproducts

6.5

Thecategorysisdrivenbyincreasingawarenessamongconsumersabouttheharmfuleffects
oftheskinsexposuretothesunsrays.Otherfactorscontributingtogrowthincludepackaging
andlabellingchanges,andinnovativereformulations.

2.1

Growthinthematurecategoryisprimarilydrivenbynewproductintroductions,
reformulations,andpackagingchanges.Clinicalstrengthproductscontinuetobeanother
drivingfactorforthecategorysgrowth.

SKINCARE

OTHERTOILETRIES
Deodorantsand
antiperspirants
Depilatories,waxes,
andbleaches

13.2

TheexceptionalperformanceofOlayspursoverallcategory.Productsthathaveeaseof
applicationandprovideresultsinlesstimearesuccessful.

Personalcleansing
products

3.0

Categorygrowthisledbythestrongperformanceofthebodywashesandliquidhandsoaps
segments.Furthergrowthisoffsetbythegoodperformanceofprivatelabelproducts.

Shavingproducts

3.0

Shavinggelsandcreamscontinuetogainmarketshareoverfoams.Marketersdevelopnew
productsforwomen.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

ExecutiveSummary

STRUCTUREOFTHEINDUSTRY

Thetoptencosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketersrepresent61.9%oftotalsalesin2012,with
nineofthetenmarketerssalesestimatedatmorethanthe$1billionmark.
Procter& Gamble continues to be the undisputed industry leader by a wide margin,
representing14.4%ofthetotalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin2012.
LOralretainsitssecondposition,with11.3%oftotalindustrysalesin2012.
Unilevercontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketer,with8.8%ofindustrysalesin2012.
EsteLauderfollowsUnileveratfourthplacewitha6.7%share.
Johnson&Johnsons5.0%shareputsitinfifthplace.

Ofthetop29companies,fivemarketersregisterasalesdecline,and24companiesregister
salesgainsin2012.
GuthyRenker, one of the worlds largest direct response television marketing
companies,registersthehighestgrowthat19.6%in2012,withsalesat$737million,up
from$616millionin2011.
Chanelpoststhesecondhighestgrowthof10.6%in2012.
The Clorox Company, having one of the largest natural personal care brands, posts
growthof8.9%in2012.

Figure210:TheU.S.ManufacturersSalesoftheFiveLeadingMarketersofCosmeticsandToiletries,2012

Procter&Gamble

5,883

L'Oral

4,551

Unilever

3,546

EsteLauder

2,722

Johnson&Johnson

2,020

1,000

2,000

3,000

4,000

5,000

$Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6,000

7,000

219

220

ExecutiveSummary

In2002,thefivelargestcompaniescontrolled45.9%ofthemarket.
Thisfiguregrewto46.8%in2007andpresentlystandsat46.2%in2012.
Thecompetitivelandscapehaschangedslightlyoverthepastdecade.
Procter&Gamblecontinuestobetheleadingmarketerinthecosmeticsandtoiletries
industry in 2012. The marketer is among the top five in all the six product classes
profiledin2012.
LOralisthesecondleadingmarketerinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryin2012.
Itcontinuestoleadthemakeupproductclassandisthesecondleadingcompanyinthe
hair care class. The marketer acquires Urban Decay specialty makeup brand in the
UnitedStates.
Unilever continues to be the thirdleading marketer in the cosmetics and toiletries
industryin2012.Unileveristheleadingmarketerintheothertoiletriesproductclass.
EsteLauderremainsatfourthplacein2012,withastrongpresenceinthefragrances,
makeup,andskincareproductclasses.
Johnson& Johnson maintains its fifth place, with its strong presence in oral careand
skincare.

Severalmergersandacquisitionscontinuetosupportthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustrys
growth.
For example, L'Oral acquires Urban Decay specialty makeup brand in the United
States.
BrynwoodPartnersinvestmentfirmmakesaslewofacquisitionsin2012:Coast,White
Rain,LALooks,DepSport,ZeroFrizz,ThickerFullerHair,Soft&Dri,andPure&Natural.
Valeant Pharmaceuticals acquires Ambi from Johnson & Johnson in December 2012,
andObagiinApril2013.
Dr.FreshacquirestheReachbrandofmanualtoothbrushesfromJohnson&Johnson.
MarkwinsInternationalacquiresPhysiciansFormulafor$75million.

Figure211:MarketShareoftheFiveLeadingMarketersofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2002,
2007,and2012
%Marketshare
50%
45.9%

46.8%

46.2%

2007

2012

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
2002

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

ExecutiveSummary

Figure212:HistoricalRankingoftheLeadingU.S.MarketersofCosmeticsandToiletries,2002,2007,and2012
Rank

2002

2007

2012

Procter&Gamble

Procter&Gamble

Procter&Gamble

L'Oral

L'Oral

L'Oral

Unilever

EsteLauder

Unilever

EsteLauder

Unilever

EsteLauder

LimitedBrands

Johnson&Johnson

Johnson&Johnson

ColgatePalmolive

LimitedBrands

LimitedBrands

Avon

ColgatePalmolive

ColgatePalmolive

Johnson&Johnson

Avon

Coty

MaryKay

MaryKay

MaryKay

10

Revlon

Coty

Avon

Oneofthemarketleadersin2002(Revlon)isnolongeramongthetop10companies,asit
lostsignificantshareovertheyears.
However,itsCEOhasstatedhisintentiontomakethecompanyaformidableplayerin
thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryonceagain.

Procter&GambleremainstheclearleaderintheU.S.personalcaremarket.Boththrough
acquisitionandorganicgrowth,thisleadershiphassolidifiedoverthelastdecade.
However,2012provestobeoneofitsmostchallengingyears,asProcter&Gamble's
categoryleading brands have lost their footing in several categories including
shampoos,toothpastes,andcolorcosmetics.
There are a number of factors causing Procter & Gamble to lose ground to its major
competitors in the United States. The main reason appears to be the companys $10
billion cost saving plan announced in February 2012 which has left some of its
brands lacking necessary marketing support, particularly in light of its competitors
increasingtheirownpromotionalactivities.
Furthermore, Procter & Gambles cost cutting on R&D has affected its rate of new
productintroductionsandabilitytokeepupwiththerapidlychangingmarketplace.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

221

222

ExecutiveSummary

LOral is the secondlargest marketer, behind Procter & Gamble, in the cosmetics and
toiletriesindustryintheUnitedStatesin2012.
LOralcontinuestosolidifyitspositioninthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustrythrough
strategic acquisitions, increasing new product launches, and stronger advertising
support.
InNovember2012,LOralacquiresUrbanDecayspecialtymakeupbrandintheUnited
Statesforapproximately$350million,andthecompanyboostsitssalesthroughoutthe
yearwithahighnumberoflaunchesacrossallitscategories.
LOralhasthelargestTME,withaspendingof$1,448millionin2012,up10.4%from
$1,312millionin2011.Thecompanyaccountsfor23.0%oftotalindustryTMEin2012.

Unileverbecomesthethirdlargestmarketerinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryinthe
United States in 2012, up from fourth position in 2007, through successful product
launchesandincreasingadvertisingsupport.
Unilever augments its management team by appointing employees based on their
experience,skills,backgrounds,knowledge,andinsights.
Product introductions with impactful innovations are also a key growth driver for
Unilever in the personal care industry. The companys EVP of North America Gina
BoswellhaspubliclystatedthatUnileverspastlaunchandleavesyndromehasbeen
rectified,andthatnowitiscommittedtothoroughlysupportingitsproductlaunches.
Under her leadership Unilever made two major U.S. launches in 2012: Simple in
February,andClearinMay.

Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestobethefifthlargestmarketerinthecosmeticsandtoiletries
industry in the United States in 2012, experiences more problems, primarily in the baby
carecategorywhereithashistoricallyenjoyedanimmenselyfavorablebrandimage.
In 2012, Johnson & Johnson recalls its Johnsons Baby Shampoo and discontinues its
AveenosOrganicHarvestlineofproductsonaccountofinclusionofharmfulchemicals.
Johnson&JohnsonsOrganicHarvestlineofshampoolosesitsUSDANOPcertification
on account of the fact that its products contain ingredients that are not on the
nationallyapprovedlistoforganicingredients.

Coty becomes the eighthlargest marketer in the cosmetics and toiletries industry in the
UnitedStatesin2012,upfromtenthpositionin2007.
IncreasingnewproductactivityandTMEsupportthegrowthofthemarketer.
InJune2012,Cotyfilestogopublic,afteritswithdrawalfromAvonstakeoveroffer.
InSeptember2012,CotydecidestoputasideitsplansofitsIPO,postponingitto2013.
The decision to delay the IPO is taken in order to give the newly appointed CEO
MicheleScannaviniconsiderabletimetoadjusttohisrole.
In June 2013, Coty finally is offered on the New York Stock Exchange under symbol
COTY,at$17.50pershare.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

ExecutiveSummary

AvonscosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsintheUnitedStatescontinuetodeclineinarow
for five years as the marketer faces problems such as defection and low morale of sales
associates.
Several other factors, such as business restructuring, decline in the total number of
active representatives, warning from the FDA regarding few variants of the Anew
product line, and talks of a possible buyout of the company contribute to the sales
declineforAvon.
InOctober2012,AvoncatchestheFoodandDrugAdministrations(FDAs)attentionfor
havinginfringedguidelinesregardingfivedifferentproductsofitsAnewrange.
FDA claims that some of its products have uses that apparently cause them to be
classifiedasdrugs.Asaresult,FDAasksAvontorectifytheviolations.
InJanuary2013,AvonannouncestheclosureofitsdistributionfacilitiesinAtlanta,GA
andPasadena,CAasameasuretocutcosts.
In February 2013, Avon declares its fourthquarter losses deepen as a result of
restructuringinitiatives.

OUTLOOK

Thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryisforecasttowitnessmoderategrowthof3.0%during
theforecastperiod,2012to2017.
DollarsalesareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof3.0%toreach$46.8billionin2017.
Unitvolumeisexpectedtocontinuetofallbehinddollargrowth,ataCAGRof2.0%to
10.9billionpackagesin2017,upfrom9.9billionpackagesin2012.

Forecast models that project sales performance, given either an economic boom or
recessionoverthenextfiveyears,appearintheFutureViewchapteroftheIndustryAnalysis
section.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

223

224

ExecutiveSummary

Figure213:ProjectedUnitandDollarSalesoftheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustry,2012to2017
50,000

46,829.0

45,000
40,372.0

40,000
35,000
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
9,887.5

10,000

10,924.7

5,000
0
Unitsales

Forecastsales
2012

2017

Figure214:ProjectedDollarSalesoftheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesIndustrybyProductClass,2012to2017

$Million
14,000
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
Skincare

Makeup

Haircare
2012

Other
toiletries

Oralcare

2017

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

Fragrances

ExecutiveSummary

Skin care and makeup are expected to be fastest growing product classes, with sales
growingataforecastCAGRof4.5%and3.8%,respectively,through2017.
Skincareisexpectedtoremaintheleadingproductclassintermsofdollarsales.
New and improved product formulations, innovations in the form of packaging, and
attentionseeking marketing and promotional activities, including the popularity of
social media network channels and the growing acceptance towards mobile media
includingQRcodes,areexpectedtosupportthegrowthoftheskincareproductclass.
Skincareproductsofferingadditionalbenefits,suchasantiaging,naturalformulations,
andtherapeuticofferings,areexpectedtodrivesalesintheproductclass.
Suncareproductsandskincareproductsformenareexpectedtocontributestrongly
towards the skin care products growth, with an estimated CAGR of 7.1% and 5.4%,
respectively,through2017.
AstheU.S.populationincreasinglymakesitahabitofusingsunscreenregularly,dueto
consistent warnings about the dangers of sun exposure, the category is expected
benefitgreatly.
Growth of the sun care products category will be driven by new product activity,
improvedformulations,innovations,andanincreaseinthepricepointsoftheproducts.
Mensskincareproductsarealsoexpectedtoperformbetterintheforecastyears,as
productsformenofferingcosmeticbenefits,suchasconcealersandtintedmoisturizers,
already available in the market, are likely to attract the attention of the male
consumers.

Inthemakeuptradeclass,thenailpolishescategoryisprojectedtoaccelerateataCAGRof
9.0%,thehighestintheproductclass,followedbyeyemakeupwhichisforecasttogrowat
aCAGRof4.0%.
Growthofthemakeupproductclasswillbesupportedbyanincreaseintheadvertising
andpromotionaleffortsofthemarketers,includingthosethathavenotadvertisedin
thepast.
It is anticipated that marketers with skin care brands will continue to introduce
scientificallyadvancedingredientsintomakeupproducts,especiallythoseproductsin
thefacemakeupcategory.

Hair care products are forecast to post a moderate growth of 2.1% during the forecast
periodsupportedbyinnovativeproductlaunches.
Shampoos and conditioners are expected to drive the sales of the hair care product
classinthenextfiveyears.
Haircareproductswithimprovedformulationsandinnovativepackagingareexpected
tosupportthegrowthoftheproductclass.
Shampoos are likely to experience the most growth over the next five years, with a
CAGRof3.1%,closelyfollowedbyconditionersataCAGRof2.5%.
Shampoosandconditionerswithnewandimprovedformulationsareexpectedtodrive
thecategoriesgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Moreover, products that cater to specific hair problems and hair types will perform
wellandalsodriveupdollarsales.
Haircoloringproductsareexpectedtoseetheleastgrowthintheforecastperiod,with
aCAGRof0.4%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

225

226

ExecutiveSummary

TheoralcareproductclassisforecasttogrowataCAGRof1.2%duringtheforecastperiod.
Toothpastes,mouthwashes,andtoothbrushes,thethreelargestcategoriesintheoral
careproductsclass,withacollectiveshareof77%willdrivetheoverallmarketssales
withaCAGRof1.2%.
Salesoftoothwhiteningproductswillcontinuetodeclineduringtheforecastperiodat
a negative CAGR of 0.5%, as the whitening benefits of other oral care products
proliferate.
Multibenefitproductsacrossallthecategorieswilldrivethesalesoforalcareproduct
classinthenextfiveyears.
Several leading marketers, including Procter & Gamble and ColgatePalmolive, are
expected to launch more innovative products to support the oral care product class
growth.

SalesoffragrancesareprojectedtoincreaseataCAGRof3.2%throughtheforecastperiod.
Theproductclassisstilllargelydependentonholidaysalesandforeigntourists,bothof
whicharenotenoughtosubstantiallygrowthecategory.
Whilenewproductshelpcreatesomeexcitementintheindustry,mostofthegrowth
comesfromestablishedscentsandfranchises.
Furthermore,habitsarechanging,andconsumersdonotusefragranceseveryday.
Until the fragrance industry develops more natural scents, containing less synthetic
ingredients that are less likely to interact with the bodys endocrine and hormonal
functioning,fragranceswillnotbeusedbyalargenumberofpeople.
FragrancesforwomenisexpectedtogrowataCAGRof3.5%whilefragrancesformen
ataCAGRof2.5%.

TheothertoiletriesproductclassisforecasttogrowataCAGRof1.7%through2017.
Additional benefits in products, such as moisturizing, cleansing, antiaging, and
vitamins,willhelpinmaintainingconsumerinterestinthecategory.
The highest growth is forecast to come from the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches
categoryandpersonalcleansingproductswithaCAGRof3.7%and1.9%,respectively,
althoughallothercategoriesgrowthisforecastbetween1.0and2.0%.

APPRAISALANDOPPORTUNITYASSESSMENT

Thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryisforecasttopostmoderategrowthof3.0%overthe
next five years supported by various factors including innovations, natural products,
mergersandacquisitions,andanincreaseinmediaspending.
High income consumers are expected to stay fairly unscathed during the forecast
period,therebysupportingthesalesintheluxuryandspecialtytradeclasses.
Competition between trade classes is expected to intensify, with each trying to
outperform the other with respect to innovation, marketing strategies, and distinct
productofferings.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

ExecutiveSummary

Figure215:FactorsAffectingtheU.S.CosmeticsandToiletriesMarket,2012to2017

Positivefactors

Negativefactors

Fragrancestoremainchallenged
Stricterlegislationonclaimsand

Innovativeproductforms,product
designs,anddeliverysystems

Naturallypositionedpersonalcareto

ingredients

Consumercautiousnesson

generatecuriosity

spending

Multibenefitandspecialized
productstoremainstrong

Mergersandacquisitions Industry
consolidation

Moderate

Industryconsolidation
Falteringperformanceofpersonto

Growth

NeglectingtheU.S.marketsinfavor

personsalessubchannel
ofhighergrowthmarkets

Increaseinpromotionaland
innovativemarketingactivities

Demandforantiagingproductsto
remainstrong,acrossmany
categories

Luxuryandspecialtychannelswill
seeincreaseintraffic

Keepingtheconsumersgluedwithcontinualinnovationtheonlymantratocombat
thestiffcompetitioninthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket

Innovations and technological advancements in terms of products, packaging, and


formulations are expected to support the forecast growth of the cosmetics and toiletries
industryintheUnitedStates.
Exciting new products armed with innovative properties across categories will create
interest,andthisnewnesshelpstopropeltrialofnewproductsandincreasesales.
Innovation backed by science will continue to be the main impetus over the forecast
period.
Innovation can be seen in different areas, such as packaging changes, product
reformulations,moreintensifiedresearchanddevelopment,adaptingtothenewFDA
rulesandregulations,andtheuseofnewconceptsandtechnologytobringfreshness
inthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Further innovation can also arise from a few other sources, such as a fresh business
model, improved distribution, innovative marketing strategies, and interdisciplinary
innovation.
The thriving success of online sales and infomercials, countered by downturns in the
UnitedStatesofthedoortodoordirectsalesmethod,indicateopportunitiesinnewer
distributionchannelspoweredbytechnology.
With the onset of natural products in the market, marketers have another area to
exploreandinnovatewithproductofferings.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

227

228

ExecutiveSummary

Naturalpersonalcaremarketwillcontinuetogrow,eventuallynearing
thematurephaseduringtheforecastperiod

Thenaturallypositionedproductsareexpectedtodrivesalesofthecosmeticsandtoiletries
industryintheUnitedStatesovertheforecastperiod.
Increasingawarenessamongconsumersregardingharshchemicalswilldrivethesales
ofnaturalproducts.
Consumerswillcontinuetolookforproductsthatcontainnaturalingredients,suchas
herbalandfloralextracts.
Truly natural products will be in great demand, but naturalinspired brands will also
continuetoflourishthroughtheforecastperiod.
Somecompaniesrecognizethepotentialinthenaturalpersonalcaremarketandare
increasingtheirfocusonthegrowingsegmentsinthenaturalpersonalcareindustryby
introducingnewproductsandfurtherexploringnewproductcategories.Thelaunchof
manynewproductsintothenaturalpersonalcaredomainkeepstheinterestofmany
consumersintactinthemarket.
Severalretailchannelsincludingmassmerchandisers,drugstores,andfoodstoresare
expectedtooffermoreshelfspacetonaturalproducts.
Theprofessionalskincaresegmentislikelytobethenextfrontforthenaturaltrendto
hit,andislikelytogainmomentumwitheachyearduringtheforecastperiod.
However, the growth of the natural products is likely to slow down during the latter
halfoftheforecastperiod,butstillretainhighergrowththantheoverallindustry.

Specializedproductssuchasmultibenefitsandgenderspecificproducts
auniquewaytobedistinctandgainsales

Productsthatoffermultibenefitsacrosscategoriesareprojectedtoperformwelloverthe
nextfiveyears.
Afewoftheleadingproductclasses,suchasskincareandmakeup,willincludenew
concepts and technology, such as the use of peptides, stem cell technology, aerosol
pump sprays, nongreasy products, and DNAcustomized formulations in its product
portfoliotobringinnovativescientificdevelopmentstothemarket.
Antiaging products will continue to be the bestperforming products in the skincare
and makeup product classes. The use of better technology and newly developed
ingredientswilldriveupthepricepointsofsuchproducts.
Additional benefits, such as smooth makeup finish, sun protection, and achieving
professionalresultsathomewillmaintainthegrowthratewhilethepricesincrease,to
maintaindollargrowth.
Ingredients such as UV protectors, vitamins, and fruit and botanical extracts will be
increasinglyusedinmakeupandskincareproductformulations.
The mens segment is expected to experience resurgence, providing a great
opportunityformarketerstointroducenewinnovativeproductsandgainsales.
Theyoungergenerationisopeninguptotheuseofmaleorientedproducts.
Moreover, increased awareness about male grooming backed by aggressive TME
activities are likely to see an increase in the penetration rate of men using products
specific to men as they open up to the idea of going beyond the regular shaveand
cleanseregime.
Productsformenofferingcosmeticbenefits,suchasconcealersandtintedmoisturizers,
willbeanotherareaformarketerstoattracttheattentionofthemaleconsumers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

ExecutiveSummary

Mergers,acquisitions,anddivestituresleadtoashiftingcompetitivelandscape

Manydealsareannouncedthrough2012andthislevelofconfidenceandactivityinM&A
continues to pace into 2013, as exemplified below. Such mergers allow companies to
expandtheirproductreachanddistribution.
Ithasbecomeevidentthatsomeprivateequityfirmsarebecomingspecializedinthe
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry,buyingbrandsorcompanies,andutilizingformidable
expertise in finance, marketing, and distribution to compete with the stalwart
manufacturingfirms.Thistrendisgainingmomentumandisexpectedtocontinueinto
theforecastperiod.
The privateequity firms employ aggressive strategies of either acquiring brands with
known names but that have received weak support from the parent company, or
sometimesbuildingbrandsfromscratch.
In 2012, Yellow Wood Partners, a private equity firm acquires Parfums de Coeur, a
previouslyprivatelyheldcompany,foranundisclosedsum.ThecompanyalsobuysIlex
Consumer Product Group in December 2012, which includes Calgon and The Healing
Garden.Thistypeofactivitywillcontinuethroughtheforecastperiod.
ValeantPharmaceuticalsisexpectedtorapidlyincreaseitspresenceincosmeticsand
toiletries over the forecast period, starting with a dynamic 2012. The company has
purchased15companiessince2010.InDecember2012itacquiresMedicis,whichhas
theRestylanebrandofinjectiblefillers,for$2.65billion,aswellasAmbiSkinCarefrom
Johnson & Johnson. Valeant acquires Obagi Medical Products in April 2013 for
$417million, and Bausch & Lomb in May 2013 for $8.7 billion. While the latter
companyisnotpresentinthebeautyindustry,itillustratesValeantspurchasingpower
andseriousfocusonmajoracquisitions.

Increasemediaexpendituresandinnovativemarketingstrategies
theobviousstepstogainsalesandstayafloatinthecompletion

Several leading marketers are likely to increase traceable media expenditures (TME) to
supportnewproductintroductionsandexistingproductportfolio.
Mostmarketerswillcontinuetoallocatethemajorityoftheirmediaexpendituresfor
theirnewproductlaunches.
Television and print media will continue to be the most preferred channel of
advertisingbymarketersovertheforecastperiod.
Most of the leading marketers will continue to evolve their marketing techniques
duringtheforecastperiodandadapttechniquestotherapidlydevelopingsocialdigital
market place, and offer consumers a more personalized and dynamic approach. This
willallowthemarketerstoreducetheiradvertisingexpenditureswhileimprovingthe
shoppingexperienceforconsumers,bothonlineandatthecounter.
Severalmajormultinationalcompanies,includingEsteLauderandProcter&Gamble,
will emphasize on digital and television advertising in order to reach and attract
consumersfromthemassmarket.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

229

230

ExecutiveSummary

Additionally,theevolutionofthedigitalmediaintherecentyearswillallowmarketers
toreachouttoawidersetofconsumersforconsiderablyfewerdollars,comparedwith
traditionaladvertisingmethods.
Digitalmedia,andparticularlysocialmedia,willcontinueplayaprominentroleinthe
marketingandpromotionalstrategyformostofthecompanies,andthemarketerswill
introducenewsocialmediaandecommercecampaignsforalmosteachofitsbeauty
brands.
MostoftheleadingcompanieswillutilizesocialmediasitessuchasFacebook,Tumblr,
YouTube,Pinterest,andTwittertoengagewithconsumersandpromotetheirproducts,
orwhicheversitesthatbecomesmorepopularintheforecastperiod.
Duringthecourseoftheforecastperiodending2017,EsteLauderisexpectedtodrive
its HighTouch services to new digital heights. This will help the company to connect
with the consumers in a more personal manner beyond expectations in order to
benefititssalesgrowth.
In2012,LOrallaunchesafemalecentricXboxapplicationtokeepfemaleconsumers
engaged with its brands. These types of interdisciplinary innovations are to be
expectedinthefuture.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

IndustryAnalysis

SectionThree

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

IndustryAnalysis

SectionThreeof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJune15,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employees of subscribing companies and their subsidiaries, as defined above, until
June15,2016. Similarly, all sections of the survey are so restricted for three years from their
datesofissue.Failuretopreventunauthorizeddisclosurebeforethesedateswillresultinlegal
actionagainstthesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

THEMARKET........................................................................................................................31
Countryoverview.............................................................................................................31
Cosmeticsandtoiletriesoverallperformance.................................................................31
Growth.............................................................................................................................32
Unitvolume......................................................................................................................38
Retailvalueandtrademargins......................................................................................310

COMPANIES........................................................................................................................313
Structureoftheindustry................................................................................................313
Growth...........................................................................................................................318
Companydevelopments................................................................................................320

CONSUMERRESEARCH.......................................................................................................327
Haircare.........................................................................................................................327
Skincare.........................................................................................................................332
Fragrances......................................................................................................................338
Oralcareproducts.........................................................................................................340
Othertoiletries...............................................................................................................341

RETAILDISTRIBUTION.........................................................................................................361
Outletdefinitions...........................................................................................................361
Salesbyretailoutlet......................................................................................................363

PRIVATELABELACTIVITY....................................................................................................371

MARKETINGACTIVITY........................................................................................................377
Traceablemediaexpenditures......................................................................................377
Promotions.....................................................................................................................387

OUTLOOK...........................................................................................................................389
Growthtrends................................................................................................................389
Basecase(mostlikely)unitanddollarforecaststo2017.............................................390

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY, INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

KLINESFUTUREVIEWSCENARIOFORECASTINGMODEL
FORTHEU.S.COSMETICSANDTOILETRIESMARKET.........................................................397
Methodology..................................................................................................................397
Industrylevelfactors.....................................................................................................397
Macroeconomicfactors.................................................................................................399
Overallcosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry......................................................................399
Fragrances....................................................................................................................3100
Haircareproducts........................................................................................................3101
Makeupproducts.........................................................................................................3101
Oralcareproducts.......................................................................................................3102
Skincareproducts........................................................................................................3103
Othertoiletries.............................................................................................................3103

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

THEMARKET

COUNTRYOVERVIEW

The United States has a territory of approximately 9.8million sq km and more than
313millioninhabitants.
Itisthelargestandmostpowerfuleconomyintheworld.

Table31:KeyStatisticsfortheUnitedStates
Characteristic

Value

Geographicsize

9.8millionsqkm

Population

313.1million

Populationgrowth

0.9%

Grossdomesticproduct

$15.7trillion

GDPgrowth

2.2%

Inflationrate

SOURCE:CIAWorldFactbook2012.

2.0%

The United States is a constitutionbased federal republic consisting of 50 states and one
districtcapital,WashingtonD.C.
Thecountryhasamultipartypoliticalsystemwithdemocraticelections.

TheUnitedStatesstillenjoysapowerfulandtechnologicallyadvancedeconomy.
The Federal Reserve maintains an easy monetary policy in spite of the economy
operatingbellowsitspotential.
The U.S dollar maintains its position in spite of the European turmoil and weaker
growthrateinthedevelopingcountries.
Oil prices weaken considerably on account of concerns relating to the Iranian Oil
embargo.
Thejobgrowthrateisgoodataround175,000permonth.
Housing has become highly affordable and reasonably priced and it is estimated that
there is soon going to be an undersupply, which will help many industries such as
constructionreturntostronggrowth.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIESOVERALLPERFORMANCE

SalesofthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketintheUnitedStatesreach$40.4billionin2012,
increasingat3.4%from$39.0billionin2011.
Theindustryhasgrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.1%since2007.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

32

TheMarket

Table32:IndustrySalesGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletriesin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

36,363

2008

36,643

0.8

2009

36,337

(0.8)

2010

37,321

2.7

2011

39,026

4.6

2012

40,372

3.4

rRestated.

Manufacturers sales for the individual product categories range from $163 million for
depilatories,waxes,andbleachesto$6,645millionforfacialtreatmentsin2012.

GROWTH

Rising consumer confidence, significant promotional activity, multibenefit products,


technological advancements, and innovative marketing and promotional strategies help
industrysalesreboundin2012.
Skincarecontinuestobethelargestproductclassduring2012,withashareof25.8%
ofthemarket.Thetopthreeproductclassesaccountforalmosttwothirdsofthetotal
industrysales.
Themakeupproductsclasspoststhehighestgrowthat4.3%,followedbytheskincare
productclassat4.1%.

Salesofskincareproductsgrow4.1%to$10,433millionin2012,upfrom$10,021millionin
2011.
Antiagingremainsthemajorthrustofthefacialtreatmentscategory.
While serums in facialtreatment products have been popular for thepast few years,
2012 sees the launch of serums specifically for the eye area to be used with an eye
cream.
Facial treatment marketers are getting bolder about touting product benefits, which
getsnoticedbytheFDA.
Hand and body lotions enriched with antiaging benefits continue to be a prominent
trend.
The availability of hand and body lotions in a variety of exotic fragrances is a
significantlygrowingtrend.
Thesuncarecategorysgrowthisdrivenbyanincreasingawarenessamongconsumers
abouttheharmfuleffectsoftheskinsexposuretothesunrays.Mensfacialskincare
representsahighgrowthopportunityformarketers.
ThepracticallyflatbirthrateintheUnitedStateshasadetrimentaleffectonthebaby
careproductscategoryssales,butnaturalproductsdoparticularlywell.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

TheMarket

Salesofthemakeupproductclassreach$7,657millionatthemanufacturerslevelin2012,
up4.3%from$7,341millionin2011.
In the eye makeup category, the most dramatic growth comes from eyeliner and
eyebrow products as women strive for eyes that communicate sex appeal, with
dramaticeyelinerandaccentuatedeyebrows.
In2012,growthinthefacemakeupcategoryisdrivenbythepositiveperformanceof
all the competing product types within the category. The luxury trade class
outperformsallothertradeclasses.Complexionproductscontinuetobeanimportant
componentinwomensmakeupregimenastheystriveforaflawlessfinish.
Concealers grow the fastest in 2012 compared to other face products. There is
excitement in the category with new launches featuring new formulas and/or
applicators. Liquid foundations continue to be popular in 2012 after several years of
powdermineralsattheforefront.Whippedormousseformulasinfoundationsmakea
comebackin2012.
Lipsticksperformbetterthanlipglossesandlipliners,mostlyduetofashiontrendsand
thenewformulasavailableinthemarket.
Inthenailpolishescategory,newcolorscontinuetogatherattentionin2012asmost
marketersexpandtheircolorassortment.

Manufacturers sales of hair care products are $7,610million in 2012, up 2.9% from
$7,393millionin2011.
Shampoosthatpromotescalphealthgarnerattentionin2012.
Shampoos that provide protection for colored hair and colorenhancement for hair
contributetotheproductclassgrowth.
Productcustomizationisanimportantproducttrendintheconditionerscategory.
In 2012, professional hair coloring products gain more popularity over athome hair
coloringproducts,asmoreconsumersvisitsalons.
Ethnic hair care products that cater to specific hair types and hair concerns, such as
frizzandcurl,controlperformwellinthecategory.
Hair styling products with improved product forms, such as gels, sprays, hard/soft
waxes,andpomadesininnovativepackaginghelpinthecategorysgrowth.

Manufacturerssalesoftheothertoiletriesproductclassareestimatedat$6,602millionin
2012,up3.0%from$6,412millionin2011.
Availabilityofpersonalcleansingproductsinavarietyofforms,suchasbarsoaps,body
washes,andbathadditivesgivesconsumersawidearrayofoptionstochoosefrom.
Clinicalstrengthantiperspirantsanddeodorantscontinuetobeamainstayin2012.
Procter&GamblesOlaydoesexceptionallywellin2012inthedepilatories,waxes,and
bleachesmarket.
The shaving products category continues to be dominated by mass marketers, but
specialty brand Art of Shaving proliferates through a rapid increase of its vertically
integratedmalegroomingsalons.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

33

34

TheMarket

Manufacturers sales of oral care products are up 1.6% from $4,184 million in 2011 to
$4,252millionin2012.
Multibenefittoothpastescontinuetosupportthesalesgainofthecategoryin2012.
Thetoothpastescategoryseesnewentrantstothemarketin2012.
Mouthwashesthatoffermultiplebenefits,suchasteethstrengthening,helpingrebuild
enamel,andpreventingcavities,supportthegrowthofthecategoryin2012.
Salesinthedentureproductscategoryarealsosupportedbytheagingpopulation,who
needtoreplacelostteeth.
Sales for the lip balms, jellies, and treatments category increase because consumers
purchase new innovative lip balm products that provide multiple benefits, such as
antioxidantsandsunprotection.
Thetoothwhiteningcategoryisbecomingmatureandfacesintensecompetitionfrom
multibenefit toothpastes and the mouthwashes category, thereby leading to a sales
declinein2012.

Total manufacturers sales of fragrances grow by 3.9% from $3,675million in 2011 to


$3,818millionin2012,withincreasesacrossboththemensandwomenscategories.
Sales of fragrances for women increase by 4.0% to $2,717million, while sales of
fragrancesformenincreaseby3.6%to$1,101millionin2012.
Thegrowthofthewomensfragrancescategorycontinuestobedependentonholiday
sales.
Additionally,anincreaseinforeigntouristswhousefragrancesonaregularbasisfindit
lessexpensivetopurchaseintheUnitedStatesthanintheirhomeland,alsohelpsgrow
thecategoryssales.
Thefragrancesformencategorycontinuestoexhibitlowgrowthin2012.Salesgrow
3.6%duringtheyear,from$1,063millionin2011to$1,101millionin2012.
The fragrances for men category struggles most in 2012, affected by Superstorm
Sandyandothercalamities.Thesuccessofthefragrancescategoryistiedveryclosely
totheholidaysellingseason,andsincetumultuouseventsoccurredinthelastquarter,
salesweregreatlyhamperedupuntilafewdaysbeforeChristmas.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TheMarket

Table33:U.S.DollarSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategory,2007to2012
Productcategory
SKINCAREPRODUCTS
Facialtreatments
Handandbodylotions
Suncareproducts
Babycareproducts
Skincareproductsformen
Totalr
MAKEUPPRODUCTS
Facemakeup
Eyemakeup
Lipsticksandlipglosses
Nailpolishes
Totalr
HAIRCAREPRODUCTS
Shampoos
Hairstylingproductsandsprays
Conditioners
Haircoloringproducts
Ethnichaircareproducts
Totalr
OTHERTOILETRIES
Personalcleansingproducts
Deodorantsandantiperspirants
Shavingproducts
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Totalr
ORALCAREPRODUCTS
Toothpastes
Mouthwashes
Toothbrushes
Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments
Dentureproducts
Toothwhiteningproducts
Totalr
FRAGRANCES
Fragrancesforwomen
Fragrancesformen
Total
TOTALr

rRestated.

2007

2008

5,763
2,160
769
286
143
9,121

2,507
2,133
1,397
305
6,342

2,311
1,713
1,561
1,277
316
7,178

3,473
1,869
345
136
5,823

5,928
2,172
844
278
151
9,373

2,537
2,200
1,311
307
6,355

2,307
1,695
1,561
1,291
304
7,159

3,558
1,915
336
139
5,948

1,622
735
726
337
320
273
4,013

2,706
1,180
3,886
36,363

1,693
779
730
351
320
281
4,154

2,546
1,108
3,654
36,643

$Million
2009
2010
2011
2012

5,860
6,091
6,360
6,645
2,192
2,208
2,240
2,283
860
933
984
1,048
278
278
283
288
146
143
154
169
9,336
9,653 10,021 10,433

2,549
2,655
2,804
2,909
2,304
2,431
2,621
2,709
1,252
1,248
1,352
1,377
341
406
564
662
6,446
6,740
7,341
7,657

2,276
2,361
2,501
2,620
1,632
1,650
1,658
1,680
1,497
1,525
1,578
1,653
1,257
1,280
1,323
1,317
314
328
333
340
6,976
7,144
7,393
7,610

3,686
3,792
3,907
4,026
1,911
1,942
1,999
2,040
341
348
362
373
138
135
144
163
6,076
6,217
6,412
6,602
1,682
761
725
342
319
285
4,114

2,379
1,010
3,389
36,337

1,668
759
718
347
320
287
4,099

2,444
1,024
3,468
37,321

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

1,719
782
725
357
314
287
4,184

2,612
1,063
3,675
39,026

1,749
799
741
374
318
271
4,252

2,717
1,101
3,818
40,372

35

36

TheMarket

Table34:CategorieswithDollarGrowthGreaterthantheIndustry
Average,2012
Productcategory

Change,%

Nailpolishes

17.4

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

13.2

Skincareproductsformen

9.7

Suncareproducts

6.5

Shampoos

4.8

Conditioners

4.8

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

4.8

Facialtreatments

4.5

Fragrancesforwomen

4.0

Facemakeup

3.7

Fragrancesformen

3.6

Table35:U.S.ManufacturersDollarSalesandGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProduct
Category,2011and2012

$Million

Productcategory

2011

2012

Change,%

Facialtreatments

6,360

6,645

4.5

Personalcleansingproducts

3,907

4,026

3.0

Facemakeup

2,804

2,909

3.7

Fragrancesforwomen

2,612

2,717

4.0

Eyemakeup

2,621

2,709

3.4

Shampoos

2,501

2,620

4.8

Handandbodylotions

2,240

2,283

1.9

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

1,999

2,040

2.1

Toothpastes

1,719

1,749

1.7

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,658

1,680

1.3

Conditioners

1,578

1,653

4.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,352

1,377

1.8

Haircoloringproducts

1,323

1,317

(0.5)

Fragrancesformen

1,063

1,101

3.6

Suncareproducts

984

1,048

6.5

Mouthwashes

782

799

2.2

Toothbrushes

725

741

2.2

Nailpolishes

564

662

17.4

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

TheMarket

Table35:U.S.ManufacturersDollarSalesandGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProduct
Category,2011and2012

$Million

Productcategory

2011

2012

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

357

374

4.8

Shavingproducts

362

373

3.0

Ethnichaircareproducts

333

340

2.1

Dentureproducts

314

318

1.3

Babycareproducts

283

288

1.8

Toothwhiteningproducts

287

271

(5.6)

Skincareproductsformen

154

169

9.7

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

144

163

13.2

39,026

40,372

3.4

Totalr

rRestated.

Change,%

Table36:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategoryAccordingto
ChangeinValue,2011and2012

$Million

Productcategory

2011

2012

Nailpolishes

564

662

17.4

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

144

163

13.2

Skincareproductsformen

154

169

9.7

Suncareproducts

984

1,048

6.5

Shampoos

2,501

2,620

4.8

Conditioners

1,578

1,653

4.8

357

374

4.8

Facialtreatments

6,360

6,645

4.5

Fragrancesforwomen

2,612

2,717

4.0

Facemakeup

2,804

2,909

3.7

Fragrancesformen

1,063

1,101

3.6

Eyemakeup

2,621

2,709

3.4

Personalcleansingproducts

3,907

4,026

3.0

Shavingproducts

362

373

3.0

Mouthwashes

782

799

2.2

Toothbrushes

725

741

2.2

1,999

2,040

2.1

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Change,%

37

38

TheMarket

Table36:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategoryAccordingto
ChangeinValue,2011and2012

$Million

Productcategory

2011

2012

333

340

2.1

Handandbodylotions

2,240

2,283

1.9

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,352

1,377

1.8

283

288

1.8

Toothpastes

1,719

1,749

1.7

Hairstylingproductsandspraysr

1,658

1,680

1.3

314

318

1.3

1,323

1,317

(0.5)

287

271

(5.6)

39,026

40,372

3.4

Ethnichaircareproducts

Babycareproducts

Dentureproducts
Haircoloringproducts
Toothwhiteningproducts
Totalr

Change,%

rRestated.

The nail polishes category is the fastest growing category in the cosmetics and toiletries
marketin2012withagrowthof17.4%.
Thedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoryisthesecondfastestgrowingcategory
withagrowthof13.2%.
In2012,onlyfourofthe26categoriespostagrowthhigherthan5.0%,whiletheother
10categoriespostagrowthbetween1.0%and3.0%.
Tencategorieswitnessagrowthbetween3.0%and5.0%.

Haircoloringproductsandtoothwhiteningproductsarethetwoproductcategorieswhich
experiencesalesdeclinesin2012.

UNITVOLUME

In2012,unitsalesincreaseby2.6%from9,639.3millionpackagesin2011to9,887.5million
packages.

Amongthe26productcategoriesprofiledinthisstudy,24productcategoriesregisterunit
growthin2012.
Theremainingtwocategories,haircoloringandtoothwhiteningproducts,experience
adeclinein2012.

Thenailpolishesandthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoriesregisterdoubledigit
growthinunitvolumein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

TheMarket

Personal cleansing products remains the leading category in terms of unit volume at
1,663millionpackages,or16.8%oftheindustrystotalunitvolume,in2012.
Toothpastes, deodorants and antiperspirants, shampoos, facial treatment products,
hair styling products and sprays, and eye makeup are the other categories that have
largeunitvolumes.

Table37:UnitSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyGrowth,2011and2012

Millionpackages

Productcategory

2011

2012

Change,%

Nailpolishes

202.2

234.6

16.0

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

29.4

33.2

12.9

Skincareproductsformen

17.3

18.9

9.3

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

154.6

165.0

6.7

Suncareproducts

230.6

244.8

6.2

Facemakeup

405.2

421.4

4.0

Conditioners

426.5

443.0

3.9

Shampoos

713.5

741.0

3.9

Fragrancesforwomen

155.0

160.0

3.2

Dentureproducts

85.4

88.0

3.0

Shavingproducts

232.0

238.3

2.7

Facialtreatments

655.2

670.0

2.3

1,629.0

1,663.0

2.1

Eyemakeup

514.7

524.9

2.0

Mouthwashes

188.5

192.0

1.9

81.2

82.6

1.7

Handandbodylotions

506.1

514.2

1.6

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

877.7

891.2

1.5

97.8

99.3

1.5

Toothpastes

990.5

1,005.0

1.5

Toothbrushes

344.3

349.0

1.4

Lipsticksandlipglosses

235.1

237.5

1.0

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

523.5

528.7

1.0

99.4

99.9

0.5

227.3

225.0

(1.0)

17.4

17.0

(2.3)

9,639.3

9,887.5

2.6

Personalcleansingproducts

Babycareproducts

Ethnichaircareproducts

Fragrancesformen
Haircoloringproducts
Toothwhiteningproducts
Totalr

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

39

310

TheMarket

Table38:UnitSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesasaPercentageofTotal,2012
Productcategory

Millionpackages

%Oftotal

Personalcleansingproducts

1,663.0

16.8

Toothpastes

1,005.0

10.2

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

891.2

9.0

Shampoos

741.0

7.5

Facialtreatments

670.0

6.8

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

528.7

5.3

Eyemakeup

524.9

5.3

Handandbodylotions

514.2

5.2

Conditioners

443.0

4.5

Facemakeup

421.4

4.3

Toothbrushes

349.0

3.5

Suncareproducts

244.8

2.5

Shavingproducts

238.3

2.4

Lipsticksandlipglosses

237.5

2.4

Nailpolishes

234.6

2.4

Haircoloringproducts

225.0

2.3

Mouthwashes

192.0

1.9

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

165.0

1.7

Fragrancesforwomen

160.0

1.6

Fragrancesformen

99.9

1.0

Ethnichaircareproducts

99.3

1.0

Dentureproducts

88.0

0.9

Babycare

82.6

0.8

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

33.2

0.3

Skincareproductsformen

18.9

0.2

Toothwhiteningproducts

17.0

0.2

9,887.5

100.0

Total

RETAILVALUEANDTRADEMARGINS

Total retail sales in the cosmetics and toiletries business are valued at approximately
$60.1billionin2012.
Theaveragetrademarginforthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryis32.8%.
TrademarginsarediscussedindetailintheRetailChannelssectionofthischapter.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

TheMarket

Among the 26 product categories covered in this study, eight categories have an average
trademarginhigherthantheindustryaverageof32.8%.
Facialtreatmentscontinuetohavethehighestaveragetrademarginof38.9%in2012.
Toothbrushescontinuetohavethelowestaverageretailmarginof18.3%.

Table39:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategory,RankedbyTradeMargin,2012

$Million

Productcategory

Manufacturerssales

Facialtreatments

6,645

10,870.6

38.9

Fragrancesforwomen

2,717

4,362.6

37.7

Fragrancesformen

1,101

1,730.5

36.4

169

265.0

36.2

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,377

2,119.3

35.0

Facemakeup

2,909

4,469.9

34.9

Eyemakeup

2,709

4,122.2

34.3

Conditioners

1,653

2,470.7

33.1

Handandbodylotions

2,283

3,389.2

32.6

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

2,481.1

32.3

Suncareproducts

1,048

1,545.0

32.2

Shampoos

2,620

3,843.6

31.8

Personalcleansingproducts

4,026

5,871.8

31.4

Nailpolishes

662

958.4

30.9

Shavingproducts

373

538.2

30.7

Babycareproducts

288

412.3

30.1

Ethnichaircareproducts

340

486.0

30.0

2,040

2,836.0

28.1

Dentureproducts

318

441.3

27.9

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

163

222.7

26.8

Toothwhiteningproducts

271

359.3

24.6

Mouthwashes

799

1,035.4

22.8

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

374

481.5

22.3

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

1,677.7

21.5

Toothpastes

1,749

2,161.9

19.1

741

907.4

18.3

40,372

60,059.6

32.8

Skincareproductsformen

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

Toothbrushes
Total

Retailsales

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Trademargin,%

311

312

TheMarket

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

COMPANIES

STRUCTUREOFTHEINDUSTRY

The cosmetics and toiletries industry is very competitive, with over 1,000 companies
manufacturingandmarketingmorethan20,000brandsinthe26majorproductcategories
coveredinthisreport.

The top 10 cosmetics and toiletries marketers represent 61.9% of total industry sales in
2012.
Nineoutof10ofthesemarketerscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareestimatedatmore
than$1billioneach.
Procter& Gamble continues to be the undisputed market leader, representing 14.4%
oftotalU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin2012.
LOralretainsitssecondposition,with11.3%oftotalindustrysalesin2012.
Unilever continues to be the third leading marketer in the cosmetics and toiletries
market,with8.8%ofindustrysalesin2012.
Este Lauder follows in the fourth position, with 6.7% of the total cosmetics and
toiletriesmarketsales.
Infifthposition,Johnson&Johnsonscontributes5.0%ofthecosmeticsandtoiletries
industrysalesin2012.

Table310:ManufacturersSalesoftheTop10CosmeticsandToiletries
CompaniesintheUnitedStates,2012
Rank
Company

$Million

2011

2012

Procter&Gamble

5,824

L'Oral

4,551

Unilever

3,546

EsteLauder

2,722

Johnson&Johnson

2,020

LimitedBrands

1,785

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

Coty

1,086

MaryKay

1,063

948

10

10

Allother

16,282

Total

40,372

Avon

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

314

Companies

Procter& Gamble has maintained a strong presence in the industry and retains its top
position in the cosmetics and toiletries market over the years. The company has a strong
presenceacrossallmajorproductclasses.
Procter& Gamble is among the top five marketers in each of the six product classes
profiledin2012.
LOral is the leading marketer in the makeup products class and the second leading
marketer in the hair care product class. The marketer continues to focus on major
industrytrendstoensuredemandforitsproducts.
Unilever is the leading marketer in the other toiletries product class in 2012. The
companybenefitsfromitsloyalconsumerbaseinthemassmarket.
Este Lauder is the secondleading marketer in the skin care and makeup product
classesin2012.
Johnson& Johnson is the leading marketer in the skin care product class, and the
companyalsoenjoysdominanceintheoralcareproductclass.
In 2012, sales of Avon decline due to various factors, such as business restructuring,
declineinthetotalnumberofactiverepresentatives,warningfromtheFDAregarding
fewvariantsoftheAnewproductline,andtalksofapossiblebuyoutofthecompany.

Mostoftheleading29majorcompaniesinthisreporthaveaglobalpresence.
Formostofthecompanies,theU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesmarketaccountsfor
averysmallportionoftheirglobalsales.
Marketers such as Unilever, ColgatePalmolive, and Procter & Gamble are global
players in consumerpackaged goods and have sales coming from many countries
aroundtheglobe.
Beiersdorf, Clarins, GlaxoSmithKline, Henkel, LVMH, Shiseido, and Kao are all
headquarteredoutsidetheU.S.market.WhilesalesfromEuropecontinuetoregistera
majorportionoftotalsalesforBeiersdorfandHenkel,LVMHnowhastherestofAsia
(besidesJapan)asitslargestmarket,followedbytheUnitedStatesandthenEurope.
Companies such as GlaxoSmithKline, Merck, and Sanofi generate a majority of sales
fromtheirpharmaceuticalbusiness.
CombeandRevlonsU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesaccountformorethan50.0%of
the companys total sales in 2012. Mary Kay follows in the third place, with the U.S
cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesaccountingfor35.4%ofthemarketerstotalglobalsales.
Onlyfivecompaniesearnlessthan3.0%oftheircosmeticsandtoiletriesrevenuesfrom
theU.S.region.TheseareMerck,GlaxoSmithKline,Sanofi,LVMH,andAlticor.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

Companies

Table311:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesfor
LeadingCompanies,2012
Company

$Million

Procter&Gamble

5,824

L'Oral

4,551

Unilever

3,546

EsteLauder

2,722

Johnson&Johnson

2,020

LimitedBrands

1,785

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

Coty

1,086

MaryKay

1,063

Avon

948

Revlon

814

GuthyRenker

737

Henkel

635

Shiseido

542

Kao

525

Chanel

461

GlaxoSmithKline

407

EnergizerHoldings

396

Beiersdorf

344

LVMH

337

Church&Dwight

313

ElizabethArden

290

Merck

209

Sanofi

197

Alticor

176

TheCloroxCompany

172

Clarins

171

Combe

157

HelenofTroy

147

Allother

8,304

Total

40,372

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

315

316

Companies

Table312:EstimatedU.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletriestoTotalSalesforLeadingCompanies,
2012
$Million
U.S.cosmeticsand
toiletriessales

Company

157

220

71.4

Revlon

814

1,426

57.1

MaryKay

1,063

3,000

35.4

EsteLauder

2,722

9,714

28.0

737

2,600

28.3

1,086

4,611

23.6

290

1,238

23.4

LimitedBrands

1,785

10,459

17.1

L'Oral

4,551

28,869

15.8

Chanel

461

3,100

14.9

HelenofTroy

147

1,182

12.4

Church&Dwight

313

2,922

10.7

Clarins

171

1,671

10.2

Avon

948

10,717

8.8

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

17,085

8.7

EnergizerHoldings

396

4,567

8.7

Procter&Gamble

5,824

83,680

7.0

Unilever

3,546

51,324

6.9

Shiseido

542

8,553

6.3

Beiersdorf

344

7,762

4.4

Kao

525

15,243

3.4

TheCloroxCompany

172

5,468

3.1

Henkel

635

21,218

3.0

2,020

67,224

3.0

Alticor

176

11,300

1.6

GlaxoSmithKline

407

41,887

1.0

LVMH

337

36,117

0.9

Sanofi

197

44,913

0.4

Merck

209

47,267

0.4

32,068

543,474

5.9

Coty
ElizabethArden

Johnson&Johnson

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

%Oftotalsales

Combe

GuthyRenker

Totalsales

317

Companies

Table313:ManufacturersSalesofMajorProductClassesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesby
MajorCompany,2012
$Million
Company

Makeup

Haircare

Othertoiletries

Oralcare

Fragrances

Total

Alticor

82

94

176

Avon

316

317

17

92

202

948

Beiersdorf

265

60

16

344

79

138

244

461

Chanel
Church&Dwight

111

202

313

92

27

51

171

ColgatePalmolive

636

851

1,493

Combe

127

20

157

Coty

58

415

72

541

1,086

ElizabethArden

52

23

215

290

230

166

396

1,112

1,158

170

12

262

2,722

406

407

GuthyRenker

526

42

169

737

HelenofTroy

85

47

147

Henkel

67

565

635

1,210

99

171

131

409

2,020

Kao

273

195

57

525

LimitedBrands

582

94

33

409

15

652

1,785

L'Oral

814

1,814

1,508

16

397

4,551

LVMH

69

155

113

337

MaryKay

550

431

11

17

54

1,063

Merck

209

209

Procter&Gamble

637

723

1,612

1,186

1,357

309

5,824

Revlon

601

152

52

814

Sanofi

76

51

66

197

114

363

26

39

542

68

37

58

172

323

1,311

1,892

14

3,546

7,752

6,494

5,703

5,563

3,437

3,119

32,068

Clarins

EnergizerHoldings
EsteLauder
GlaxoSmithKline

Johnson&Johnson

Shiseido
TheCloroxCompany
Unilever
Total

Skincare

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

318

Companies

Makeup products remains the strongest product class among the leading 29 companies,
representing84.8%ofthecompaniestotalindustrysalesin2012.
Othertoiletriesisthesecondstrongestproductclass,representing84.3%oftotalsales
in2012forthetop29companies.
The skin care product class has the least penetration from the major 29 companies,
witha74.3%penetrationin2012.

Table314:ManufacturersSalesbyProductClassofMajorCompanies,2012

Productclass

$Million

Top29companies

Total

%Majorcompaniestototal

Makeup

6,494

7,657

84.8

Othertoiletries

5,563

6,602

84.3

Oralcare

3,437

4,252

80.8

Fragrances

3,119

3,818

81.7

Haircare

5,703

7,610

74.9

Skincare

7752

10,433

74.3

32,068

40,372

79.4

Total

GROWTH

Manufacturers sales of the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market grow 3.4% to
approximately$40.4billionin2012,upfrom$39.0billionin2011.
Consumers continue to be valueoriented, but are recently willing to pay more for
productsthatcanofferspecificbenefits.

Outofthetop29companiesprofiledinthisreport,fivemarketersregisterasalesdecline,
andtheremaining24companiesregisterasalesgainin2012.
GuthyRenker, a leading direct response television marketing company, registers the
highestgrowthat19.6%in2012,withsalesat$737millionin2012from$616millionin
2011.Itscostsareknowntobeexorbitantlyhighduetopayingcelebrityendorsersand
producingandairinginfomercials.
Chanel,aprestigecompany,registersthesecondhighestgrowthat10.6%,withsales
at $461million in 2012 up from $417 million in 2011. Chanels classic perfumes are
amongthebestperformersinthecategory.
LVMH shows the thirdhighest growth at 9.8% in 2012 to reach $337 million in 2012
from$307millionin2011.LVMHsbrandsofmakeupandperfumes,includingChristian
Dior,ridethewaveofsuccessintheluxurytradeclass.
TheCloroxCompanyandMerckaretiedinthefourthpositionwithagrowthof8.9%in
2011. Cloroxs Burts Bees is becoming an industry standard for accessibly priced
naturalproducts.
Amongthemajor29companies,16companiesregistersalesgrowthgreaterthanthe
industryaverageof3.4%in2012.
Helen of Troy records the highest decline among the top 29 companies, with sales
declining8.1%from$160millionin2012to$147millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

Companies

Table315:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletrieswithPercentageGrowthforLeading
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

2012

GuthyRenker

616

737

19.6

Chanel

417

461

10.6

LVMH

307

337

9.8

TheCloroxCompany

158

172

8.9

Merck

192

209

8.9

Alticor

164

176

7.3

Clarins

160

171

6.9

EsteLauder

2,569

2,722

6.0

L'Oral

4,304

4,551

5.7

LimitedBrands

1,706

1,785

4.6

EnergizerHoldings

379

396

4.5

ColgatePalmolive

1,431

1,493

4.3

504

525

4.2

3,406

3,546

4.1

392

407

3.8

1,048

1,086

3.6

Shiseido

527

542

2.8

Beiersdorf

335

344

2.7

1,979

2,020

2.1

154

157

1.9

1,047

1,063

1.5

Revlon

802

814

1.5

Sanofi

194

197

1.5

Henkel

626

635

1.4

5,898

5,824

(1.3)

321

313

(2.5)

1,014

948

(6.5)

ElizabethArden

313

290

(7.3)

HelenofTroy

160

147

(8.1)

7,903

8,304

5.1

39,026

40,372

3.4

Kao
Unilever
GlaxoSmithKline
Coty

Johnson&Johnson
Combe
MaryKay

Procter&Gamble
Church&Dwight
Avon

Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Change,%

319

320

Companies

COMPANYDEVELOPMENTS

Someofthekeydevelopmentsfromthetop29companiesareasfollows.
Thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustrycontinuestoconsolidate,therebymakingitmore
difficultforsmallermarketerstooperateindependently.
The acquisition of smaller companies by global corporations opens new doors and
greater investment in research and development for smaller companies, which are
oftenfacedwithlimitedfinancialresources,andhelpthembringnewandinnovative
productstoconsumers.
The year 2012 sees a flurry of merger and acquisition deals globally, with the United
Statesnoexception.

In2012,marketersfindthemselvesembroiledinlegalcomplaintsandlawsuits.
Este Lauders MAC Cosmetics wins a $90 million judgment against Chinese cyber
squatters selling counterfeit MAC beauty products. The lawsuit was filed against
TingtingChen,LimeiWeng,andZhangGuithe,andotherswhooperated112websites
including, themaccosmetics.com, mac2wholesale.com, maccosmeticworld.com,
wholesalemacmakeup.com, and cheapmakeuppick.com.The judge ordered for any
fundsfoundsinthepaypalaccountattachedtotheinfringingsitestobegiventoEste
Lauder. Additionally, third party providers such as online businesstobusiness selling
platforms,backendserviceproviders,searchengines,webdesigners,internetservice
providers, domain name registrars, and shippers to stop all services to the Chinese
cybersquatters.
In 2012, Christiansen Davis Bullock, a Texasbased firm files a complaint against
Unileverwithrespecttoafalse,deceptive,andmisleadingclaiminconnectionwiththe
Suave Professional Keratin Infusion 30 Day Smoothing Kit. Unilever discontinues the
productandrecalleditfromtheretailstores.
In2012,MaryKaytakesluxurydesigner,MichaelKorstocourtforbreachofcontract
and trademark infringement. According to Mary Kay, Michael Kors has registered a
cosmetics line with the same trademark initials as itself. The first filing with the U.S.
Patent and Trademark Office includes the MK with a circle around the letter while
thesecondfilingincludesMichaelKorsonthebottomborderofthecircle.According
toMaryKay,theagreementstatesthatMichaelKorscannotuseMKallbyitself,orin
closeproximitytoMichaelKorsorinrelationwithanyproductswhatsoever.
In June 2012, Revlon settles its dispute with shareholder Fidelity Management &
Researchregardingaclassactionlawsuitrelatedtoashareexchangeofferfrom2009.
In August 2012, Procter & Gamble files a complaint to the NAD (National Advertising
Division)intheUnitedStatesagainstColgatePalmoliveregardingtheusageofcertain
claimsforitsOpticWhiterangeoforalcareproducts.TheNADhassuggestedColgate
Palmolive to stop advertising some claims for its whitening toothpastes including
Samewhiteningingredientasstrips.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

Companies

InSeptember2012,FDAwarnsLOraloverclaimsforantiagingproductsbyissuinga
warninglettertothecompany.Intheletter,FDAclaimsthat11ofthecompanysskin
care products can be classified as drugs as they serve the purpose of changing the
structureoranyfunctionofthehumanbody.Theseproductsinclude:GenifiqueYouth
Activating Concentrate, Genifique Eye Youth Activating Eye Concentrate, Genifique
CreamSerumYouthActivatingCreamSerum,GenifiqueRepairYouthActivatingNight
Cream,AbsoluePreciousCellsAdvancedRegeneratingandReconstructingCreamSPF
15 Sunscreen, Absolue Eye Precious Cells Advanced Regenerating and Reconstructing
Eye Cream, Absolue Night Precious Cells Advanced Regenerating and Reconstructing
NightCream,andRenergieMicroliftEyeR.A.R.EIntenseRepositioningEyeLetter.

In 2012, a number of marketers merge and acquire other brands or companies to


strengthentheirpositioninthemarket.
In 2012, Unilever integrates two acquisitions, Kalina, the Russian Personal Care
Company, and Alberto Culver, the global hair and skin care company. Unilever has
acquired a controlling stake in Kalina for approximately 500 millon. The acquisition
willhelpUnileverboostitspersonalcarebusinessinfastgrowingdevelopingmarkets.
Alsoin2012,HighRidgeBrands,aportfoliocompanyofBrynwoodPartners,acquires
theglobalrightstotheCoastpersonalcleansingproducts,aHenkelbrand.Inaddition,
BrynwoodPartnerspicksupWhiteRain,LALooks,DepSport,ZeroFrizz,ThickerFuller
Hair,Soft&Dri,andPure&Naturalbrandsin2012.
ElizabethArden acquires the CurveFragrance franchise from Fifth & Pacific(formerly
knownasLizClaiborne)foranundisclosedprice.
InMarch2012,Procter&GambleacquiresNewChapterInc.foranundisclosedsum.
NewChapterisaTexasbasedvitaminandsupplementcompany.
In April 2012, Coty proposes to acquire Avon. In May 2012, Avon turns down Cotys
proposalforitsacquisition.
InMay2012,ElizabethArdenacquiresgloballicensesandcontainsassetsassociatedto
the Ed Hardy, True Religion, and BCBG Max Azria fragrance brands from New Wave
Fragrancesforanundisclosedprice.
In June 2012, Elizabeth Arden acquires global permits to the Justin Bieber and Nicki
MinajfragrancebrandsfromGiveBackBrandsforanundisclosedprice.
Revlon acquires brands Pure Ice nail enamel and Bon Bons color cosmetics from Bari
Cosmetics in July 2012. Terms of the transaction are not disclosed; however, Revlon
uses$22millionofborrowingsunderits2011RevolvingCreditFacility,alongwithcash
onhandtofundtheacquisition.
Yellow Wood Partners acquires Parfum de Coeur perfume house in September 2012.
Parfums de Coeur markets Body Fantasies, Designer Imposters, and Bod Man
fragrancesinfood,drugandmasschannels.
In October 2012, Church & Dwight announces that it has completed its previously
announced acquisition of Avid Health for USD 650 million. Avid Health markets
nutritionalsupplements,mostlyinthegummyformat.
In October 2012, LOral USA signs an agreement to acquire Emiliani Enterprises
extendingitscoverageofAmericanhairsalons.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

321

322

Companies

InOctober2012,LOralacquirestheVoguemakeupbrandinColombia.
InOctober2012,ColgatePalmoliveandOmronHealthcareenterabroadcooperation
agreementtomarketanddeveloporalcareproductsincludingelectrictoothbrushes.
InNovember2012,LOralacquiresUrbanDecay,specialtymakeupbrandintheU.S.
forapproximately$350million.
InDecember2012,Beiersdorfacquirestheremaining50%ofsharesandvotingrightsin
EBC EczacbaBeiersdorf Kozmetik rnler Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S (Turkey) for 29
million($37million).Atthetimeofacquisition,Beiersdorfpaysafixedcomponentof
25million($32million)incashandacontingentpurchasepricepayableattheoffset
offiscal2014ifcertainperformanceindicatorsaremetin2013.
In December 2012, Galderma, a pharmaceutical company formed as a joint venture
betweenNestleandLOral,acquiresSpirig,aleadingcompanyintheproductionand
developmentofdermatologicalproducts.
ValeantPharmaceuticalsacquiresAmbiSkincarefromJohnson&JohnsoninDecember
2012,andthenObagiMedicalinApril2013.
ItisannouncedinDecember2012thatMarkwinsInternationalhasacquiredPhysicians
FormulaHoldings,for$75.0million.
AlsoinDecember,Dr.FreshacquirestheReachbrandoftoothbrushesfromJohnson&
Johnson.

Afewmarketersdivesttheirbrandsorbusinessesinanattempttoincreasetheircashflow
andfocusonmoreimportantbusinesses.
In May 2012, Procter& Gamble (P&G) divests its snacks business to The Kellogg
Company for $2.7 billion in an allcash transaction. The Kellogg Company is a
multinationalfoodmanufacturingcompanybasedinBattleCreek,MI.Asaresultofthis
change,thePetCarebusinessisnowincludedintheFabricandHomeCaresegment.
ThedivestituremarksProcter&Gamblesexitfromthefoodandbeveragebusiness.
InJuly,2012,UnileverentersintoadefinitiveagreementtoselltoConAgraFoodsits
North American frozen meal business, the brands Bertolli and P.F. Changs. The total
cashconsiderationforthedealis$265million.ThedivestitureiscompletedinAugust,
2012.
In2012,Henkelssubsidiary,theDialCorporation,divestsitsPure&Naturalbrand.The
Pure&NaturalbrandisacquiredbyGoldenSun,asubsidiaryofBrynwoodPartners.
In July 2012, LOral completes the sale of its home care business from the Cadum
GrouptoEauEcarlateSASforanundisclosedsum.
InJuly2012,Sanofiannouncestheexecutionofanagreementaccordingtowhichitwill
divestitsdirectandindirectstakeofaround19.3%intheYvesRocherGroup.
In July 2012, LOral completes the sale of its home care business from the Cadum
GrouptoEauEcarlateSASforanundisclosedsum.
In October 2012, Sanofi and BristolMyers Squibb coannounce the restructuring of
theirlongtermalliancefollowingthelossofexclusivityofPlavixandAvapro/Avalidein
manymajormarkets.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

Companies

The year witnesses marketers milestones, major strategic planning shifts, increase in
infrastructural facilities, partnerships and license agreements, associations with
organizations,sustainableandphilanthropicinitiatives,andothernews.
InJanuary2012,Burt'sBeesofficiallylaunchesanewnaturalbrand,namedGd,under
different categories, including shampoos, conditioners, body washes, body butter,
bodylotion,andhandwashes.Itisaimedatayoungerdemographicdifferentthanits
flagshipbrandBurtsBees.
In January 2012, LOral announces the launch of a website in the United States,
designedtoinspireandempowergirlstopursuecareersinscienceandtechnology.
In February 2012, Procter & Gamble announces its $10 billion productivity and cost
saving plan to decrease costs in areas like supply chain, research and development,
marketingandoverheadexpenses.
In2012,Procter&Gamblecelebratesits175thanniversary.
InFebruary2012,BeiersdorflaunchesEucerinSkinInstitute,anintegratedconceptthat
consistsofscientificskindiagnosisaswellaspersonalconsultationandindividualskin
treatment.
In March 2012, Amway teams with University of Michigan to harness exclusive
patented technology in its skin care products that counters common side effects of
retinolforimprovedresults.
InMarch2012,LOralinauguratesitsGlobalHairResearchCenterinParisSaintOuen,
France.This100millionfacility,builton25,000squaremeterspace,employees500
people.Thiscenterwillbetheheadofaglobalnetworkofsixregionalcenters,andthe
headquartersforthecompanysinternationaldepartmentsofhaircolor,haircareand
hairstyling.
In May 2012, LVMH teams up with the European Commission to promote best
environmentalbehaviorsintheframeworkofGreenWeek2012.
InSeptember2012,ColgatePalmoliveannouncesthatitsagencypartnersY&R,MEC,
VML, Wunderman and GHG are joining forces to create a single operating unit to
engagewithconsumersinrealtimeacrossalltouchpointsandtodriveefficiencies.
InSeptember2012,ElizabethArdenannouncesinvestmentinRedDoorSpaHoldings.
In November 2012, LOral announces major expansion of Kentucky Manufacturing
Plant. The proposed plant expansion includes renovations to the existing plant, new
constructionandthepurchaseofnewequipment.
In June 2012, Shiseido announces a plan to strengthen its U.S. corporate,
manufacturing,anddistributionoperations.Thecompanyannouncesthatitwillalign
theU.S.finance,legal,andhumanresourcesfunctionsofitspremierconsumerbrands;
includingBareEscentuals,BeautePrestigeInternationalUSA,Nars,andShiseidointoan
unified,sharedservicesplatform.In2012,Johnson&JohnsonrecallsitsJohnsonsBaby
ShampooanddiscontinuesitsAveenosorganicHarvestlineofproductsonaccountof
inclusionofharmfulchemicals.
EnergizerHoldingsgetsheatfromreportsoffiveconsumersinNorthAmericacatching
fire from using its Banana Boat UltraMist sunscreens near sparks or flame. It recalls
over20formulationsfromthemarket,blamingthedeliverysystem.Nolawsuitshave
beenfiledasofyet.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

323

324

Companies

Johnson&JohnsonsOrganicHarvestlineofshampoolosesitsUSDANationalOrganic
Program (NOP) certification on account of the fact that the products contain
ingredientsthatarenotonthenationallyapprovedlistoforganicingredients.
BurtsBeespartnerswithPreserve,asustainableconsumergoodscompany,todevelop
arecyclablesolutionforitsBurtsBeesLipBalm,TintedLipBalm,LipShimmerTubes,
andBurtsBeesplasticcapsin2012.Thepartnershipisaimedatdivertingplasticfrom
landfills in order to provide material to develop packaging for new products such as
Preservetoothbrushesandrazors.
In2012,EsteLauderentersintoalicenseagreementwithAmericanluxurysportswear
brand, Tony Burch and Milanbased fashion company Marni. These additions will
strengthen the marketers Aramis and Designer Fragrances (ADF) portfolio of brands.
ThelicensingagreementgivesEsteLauderexclusiveglobalrightstomarketfragrances
under the Ermenegildo Zegna Group, as well as develop new product lines in the
groomingsegment.
In2012,HelenofTroyentersintoanagreementtopurchase84acresoflandinOlive
BranchinMississippi.Thelandwillbeusedforthepurposeofconstructinga1.3million
square foot distribution center. The distribution center is expected to cost an
approximate$37millionandwillbeoperationalfromthethirdquarterof2014.
Burts Bees enters into a license agreement with childrens brand builder Ayablu In
2012.
Currently Burts Bees range of baby care products include body washes, bar soaps,
moisturizers, ointments and care, and sun care products. This move sees the brands
expansion into multiple categories including home and lifestyle. The line debuts with
newbornessentialsthatincludeapparel,accessories,bathlinens,andgiftsets
The company debuts this range of products through select Target stores and the
retailerswebsite,target.com.During2012,thecompanygraduallyexpandeditsrange
ofproductstobeavailableatbuybuybabyretailoutletsandBabiesRUs.com.BurtsBees
hasalsolaunchedaportaldedicatedtoitsnewlineofproductsatburtsbeesbaby.com.

In2012,Avoncontinuestofacemanychallenges.
InquiriesaremadeintoallegationsofbriberybythecompanysemployeesinChinaand
othercountries.
InMarch2012,Cotymakesanunsolicited$10billionoffertoacquireAvon,asitplans
toutilizeAvonsstrongsalesforceinemergingmarkets.
InApril2012,AvonrejectsCotys$10billionofferforatakeover.
The$23.25persharebidwasputata20%premiumtoAvonsrecentstockprice.Avon
responded that the valuation was too low, and that Cotys nonbinding bid did not
presentarealoffer.
InMay2012,afterCotysbiddies,sharesofAvonplungeon9.7%.
In October 2012, Avon catches FDAs attention for having infringed guidelines
regardingfivedifferentproductsofitsAnewrange.
FDA claims that its products Anew Clinical Advanced Wrinkle Corrector, Anew
Reversalist Night Renewal Cream, Anew Reversalist Renewal Serum, Anew Clinical
Thermafirm Face Lifting Cream and Solutions Liquid Bra Toning Gel have uses that
apparentlycausethemtobeclassifiedasdrugs.Asaresultofthis,FDAasksAvonto
rectify the violations, while Avon pledges its commitment to abide by the laws and
regulations.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

Companies

Avon outlines initial steps to costcutting, two of which include, global headcount
reductionofapproximately1500positions,anditsexitfromSouthKoreaandVietnam.
InJanuary2013,AvonannouncestheclosureofitsdistributionfacilitiesinAtlanta,GA
andPasadena,CAasameasuretocutcosts.
In February 2013, Avon declares its fourth quarter 2012 losses deepen as a result of
restructuringinitiatives.
In March 2013, Avon completes its refinancing activities by closing public offering of
$1.5billioninnotes.
Avoninvestsonnewpackagingsystems.
In November 2012, Avon announces a decline in quarterly dividend from $0.23 per
shareto$0.06pershare,forthefourthquarterdividendpaidinDecember2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

325

326

Companies

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

CONSUMERRESEARCH

Consumer research has been conducted via an online survey among 305 residents of the
UnitedStatesinMay2013.
Thepurposeoftheresearchistounderstandtheusagepatternsofcertaincosmetics
and toiletries categories, where these products are bought, and what attitudes the
respondentshaveaboutusingandbuyingcosmeticsandtoiletriesproducts.
ThesamplewasselectedtomatchthepopulationoftheUnitedStatesintermsofrace,
ethnicgroup,andagebreakdownoftheU.S.population.
Thesamplewasalmostexactlysplitevenlybymalesandfemales
PleasenotethatKlinepurposefullydidnotattempttosurveyanyoneunder15orover
69yearsofage,forvariousreasons.

HAIRCARE

Usage

Table316:UsageofHairCareProductsbyAge
Age,%
1519

2029

3039

4049

5059

6069

%Ofall
responses

2in1shampooandconditioner

21

18

21

15

16

37

Shampoo

20

19

20

19

13

88

Conditioner

10

22

21

19

17

11

69

Hairstylinggel

10

16

25

21

19

34

Hairstylingcream

22

28

24

10

16

Hairstylingpomadeorwax

24

37

18

11

12

Hairspray

19

25

21

17

13

36

Hairstylingmousse

21

33

17

14

20

Inhomehaircolor/dye/greycoverage

13

28

24

19

11

25

Thinninghairprep/hairregrowthproduct

14

43

29

10

Damagecontrolproducts

25

31

18

13

23

Scalp/dandruffcontrolproducts

21

24

21

16

10

29

Insalonhaircolor/dye/greycoverage

35

30

13

Otherhaircareproducts

10

28

16

24

12

10

16

Noneoftheabove

14

14

29

29

14

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

328

ConsumerResearch

Figure31:UsageofHairCareProductsbyGender
2in1shampooandconditioner
Conditioner
Damagecontrolproducts
Hairspray
Hairstylingcream
Hairstylinggel
Hairstylingmousse
Hairstylingpomadeorwax
Inhomehaircolor/dye/greycoverage
Insalonhaircolor/dye/greycoverage
Scalp/dandruffcontrolproducts
Shampoo
Thinninghairprep/hairregrowthproduct
Otherhaircareproducts
Noneoftheabove
0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%
Female

60%

70%

Male

80%

90% 100%

In the United States, hair care products such as hair regrowth products, 2in1 shampoos
and conditioners, dandruff control products, and hair styling gels are the most popular
amongmen.
Women use mostly hair care products like damage control products, hair gels, hair
sprays,haircoloringproducts,andhairstylingcreams.Eachoftheseproductsareused
byatleast30%ofwomen.
Shampoos, conditioners, hair styling gels, and hair sprays are the hair care products
thatareusedmostbyHispanics.
Accordingtothesurvey,12%ofwomengettheirhairdyedinsalons,while37%usein
homehaircolor.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

ConsumerResearch

Retaildistribution

Table317:RetailDistributionofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStates

Male

Female

Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme

83

17

Massmerchandisers

41

59

Discountdepartmentstores

56

44

Upscaledepartmentstores

88

13

Traditionaldepartmentstores

71

29

Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands

27

73

Storeswhichonlycarryonebrand

33

67

Warehouseclub

54

46

Drugstores

47

51

Food/grocerystores

48

52

Dollarstore

43

57

HomeshoppingTVchannels

80

20

Internet/Online/mobilephone

29

71

Persontopersonsales

38

63

Catalog/mailorder

50

50

Spa/salon

36

64

Other/don'tknow

83

17

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

329

330

ConsumerResearch

Figure32:ChannelsShoppedforHairCareProducts
Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme
Catalog/mailorder
Traditionaldepartmentstores
Discountdepartmentstores
Dollarstore
Drugstores
Food/grocerystores
HomeshoppingTVchannels
Internet/online/mobilephone
Merchandisers
Persontopersonsales
Spa/salon
Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands
Storeswhichonlycarryonebrand
Upscaledepartmentstores
Warehouseclub
Other/don'tknow
0%
1519

2029

10%
3039

20%

30%

4049

40%
5059

50%
6069

60%

70%

80%

Consumerswhousuallydonotshopforhaircareproductsaremalesagedbetween15and
19years.

Internet/mobile shopping is more popular among people whose age is in the range of 20
and29years,at41%,whilespecialtystoreschannelisfavoredbyconsumersagedbetween
40and49.

Discountdepartmentstores,upscaledepartmentstores,andtraditionaldepartmentstores
areusedthemostbyconsumersbetweentheagesof30and39.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

ConsumerResearch

Figure33:ShiftsinChannelsShoppedforHairCareProducts
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Ipurchasehaircare
productsfomspecialty
stores

Ipurchasehaircare
Ipurchasehaircare
productsfromdirectsales productsfromdepartment
stores

Ipurchasehaircare
productsfromsalonsor
spas

Moreofteninthepast12months

Lessoftenthaninpreviousyears

Aboutthesameaspreviousyears

Notsure/don'tknow

Haircareconcerns

Table318:HairCareConcernsbyGender
%
Gender

Male

Female

%Oftotalresponses

Oilyhair

50

50

25

Thinninghairorhairloss

62

38

31

Dryhair

30

70

22

Frizzyhair

92

23

Dandruff

71

29

26

Itchyscalp

58

42

20

Greyhair

47

53

32

Fine,limphair

23

77

19

Howtostyleitwell

27

73

24

Hairtoothick

24

76

12

Hairtoocurly

36

64

Coarsehair

16

84

Noneoftheabove

67

33

Other

50

50

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

331

332

ConsumerResearch

Whilehaircareconcernsamongmenaredandruff,hairlossorthinningofhair,anditchy
scalp, women worry about frizzy hair, coarse hair, fine limp hair, dry hair, and on how to
styletheirhair.
Ofthetotalrespondentswhostatedstylingtheirhairwellasaconcern,31%ofthem
areagedbetween30and39,followedcloselybypeopleaged2029.
Grayhair,oilyhair,hairloss,anddandruffarethemajorhairconcernsamongHispanics
intheUnitedStates.

SKINCARE

Usage

Table319:UsageofSkinCareProductsbyAgeGroup
%
1519

3039

4049

6069

%Ofall
responses

27

23

19

15

52

Facialscruborexfoliator

20

29

23

14

39

Toner/astringent

19

31

21

21

16

Facialmoisturizer

23

25

19

15

13

45

BBcreamortintedmoisturizer

32

35

12

11

Eyetreatment

11

23

21

32

11

17

Acnetreatment

23

33

21

15

26

Oilcontrollingtreatment/antishineproduct

36

31

10

17

14

Facialsunscreen

18

27

26

14

10

34

Darkspotcorrector/skinbrightener(anti
discoloration,antidarkspot/markproduct)

17

20

34

17

13

Facialselftanningorsunlesstanningproducts

23

46

23

Bodycreams/lotions

20

24

19

19

10

59

Otherfacialskincareproducts

16

24

16

22

18

18

10

10

18

29

27

17

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

5059

Facialcleanserorwash

Noneoftheabove

2029

ConsumerResearch

Figure34:UsageofSkinCareProductsbyGender

Acnetreatment
BBcreamortintedmoisturizer
Bodycreams/lotions
Darkspotcorrector/skinbrightenera
Eyetreatment
Facialcleanserorwash
Facialmoisturizer
Facialscruborexfoliator
Facialselftanningorsunlesstanningproducts
Facialsunscreen
Oilcontrollingtreatment/antishineproduct
Toner/astringent
Otherfacialskincareproducts
Noneoftheabove
0%

10%

20%

30%

40%
Female

a Includesantidiscoloration,antidarkspot/markproduct.

50%

60%

70%

80%

Male

IntheUnitedStates,skincareproductsusedbymorethanhalfofthepopulationarefacial
cleansersandbodylotions.
Facialsunscreenandscrubareusedbyover30%ofthepeople,andacnetreatmentis
usedbyalmost26%.
Acnetreatmentproductsareusedalmostequallybybothmenandwomen.
Body creams and lotions, facial moisturizers, facial cleansers, facial scrubs, and facial
sunscreensareafewskincareproductsthataremostusedbyHispanics.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

333

334

ConsumerResearch

Retaildistribution

Table320:RetaildistributionofskincareproductsintheUnitedStates
%
Male

Female

%Oftotal
responses

90

10

Massmerchandisers

36

64

61

Discountdepartmentstores

67

33

Upscaledepartmentstores

44

56

Traditionaldepartmentstores

38

62

Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands

25

75

Warehouseclub

43

57

Drugstores

43

57

40

Food/grocerystores

49

51

27

Dollarstore

41

59

14

HomeshoppingTVchannels

40

60

Internet/online/mobilephone

24

76

10

Persontopersonsales

20

80

12

Catalog/mailorder

60

40

Doctorsoffice

33

67

Spaorsalon

50

50

Storesthatcarryonlyonebrand

31

69

11

Other/don'tknow

75

25

Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

ConsumerResearch

Figure35:ChannelsShoppedforSkinCareProductsbyAge
Catalog/mailorder
Departmentstores
Discountdepartmentstores
Dollarstore
Drugstores
Food/grocerystores
HomeshoppingTVchannels
Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme
Internet/online/mobilephone
Massmerchandisers
Persontopersonsales,suchasAvonorArbonne
Spa/salon
Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands
Storeswhichonlycarryonebrand
Upscaledepartmentstores
Warehouseclub
Other/don'tknow
0%
1519

2029

10%

20%

3039

30%
4049

40%
5059

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

6069

Mass merchandisers and drug stores are the most used channels to purchase skin care
productsbyconsumersagedbetween20and29years.

Internetoronlineshoppingforthecategoryisusedby11%ofconsumersaged20and29,
whichishigherthananyotheragegroup.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

335

336

ConsumerResearch

Figure36:ShiftsinChannelsShoppedforSkinCareProducts
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
Ipurchaseskincare
productsfomspecialty
stores

Ipurchaseskincare
Ipurchaseskincare
Ipurchaseskincare
productsfromdirectsales productsfromdepartment productsfromsalons,spas
stores
ordoctor'soffice

Moreofteninthepast12months

Lessoftenthaninpreviousyears

Aboutthesameaspreviousyears

Notsure/don'tknow

Skincareconcerns

Table321:SkinCareConcernsbyGender
%
Linesorwrinkles
Unevenskintoneorhyperpigmentation
DarkSpots
Postacnemarksorscars
Acne/blemishes
Eyepuffinessorbagsundereyes
Largepores
Brokencapillaries/spiderveins
Drypatches
Scars
Saggingfacialskin
Rosacea
Darkcirclesundereyes
Oilyskin
Ingrownhairs
Irritation/redness
Sundamage
Noneofthese

Male
35
33
47
28
44
37
34
19
32
58
41
31
29
44
52
45
49
77

Female
65
67
53
72
56
64
66
81
68
43
59
69
71
56
48
55
51
23

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

%Ofallresponses
41
18
26
19
31
31
23
8
21
14
12
6
26
28
10
11
17
11

337

ConsumerResearch

Figure37:SkinCareConcernsbyAge

Acne/blemishes
Brokencapillaries/spiderveins
Darkcirclesundereyes
DarkSpots
Drypatches
Eyepuffinessorbagsundereyes
Ingrownhairs
Irritation/redness
Largepores
Linesorwrinkles
Oilyskin
Postacnemarksorscars
Rosacea
Saggingfacialskin
Scars
Sundamage
Unevenskintoneorhyperpigmentation
Noneofthese
0%

10%

20%
1519

30%
2029

40%
3039

50%
4049

60%
5059

70%

80%

90%

6069

Linesorwrinklesisbyfarthebiggestskincareconcernwomen,followedbypuffyeyes,dark
circles,andacnearethemajorskincareproblemsamongwomenintheUnitedStates.
Consumersbetweentheagesof20and29areconcernedmostaboutbyproblemslike
acneorblemishes,oilyskin,acnescars,andlargeporeswhilethoseagedbetween40
and49worryaboutwrinkles,puffyeyes,anddarkspots.
AccordingtotheHispanicrespondentsinthesurvey,majorskincareconcernsinclude
oily skin, dark spots, eye puffiness, and wrinkles. Nearly 7% of the Hispanics worry
aboutspiderveinsandsaggingfacialskinwhilealmost5%ofthemareconcernedwith
ingrownhairs.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

338

ConsumerResearch

FRAGRANCES

Usage

Table322:UsageofFragranceProductsbyAge

Age

%
Perfumeorcologne

Aftershave

Otherfragrances

Noneoftheabove

1519

10

10

2029

23

15

19

16

3039

21

16

25

13

4049

18

23

18

24

5059

20

23

21

16

6069

10

20

21

Total

100

100

100

100

65

27

22

20

%Ofallresponses

In the United States, perfumes are more popular among people aged 20 and 29 years,
followedbyconsumersbetweentheagesof30and39.
Foraftershaveproducts,thehighestusageisatiebetweenmentheagesof40and49,
and 50 and 59, with each age group contributing to 23% of the total of aftershave
productsusage.

Compared to men, women in the United States utilize perfumes or colognes to a greater
extent.
Accordingtothesurvey,thehighestusageofperfumesisbywomen(71%)followedby
men(59%).
Theclaimtonotuseanyfragranceatallissplitequallybygender,atabout20%ofmen
and20%ofwomensayingtheyusenoneoftheabovefragrances.

Nearly 82% of the Hispanic respondents use perfumes or colognes while 41% of them
employaftershave.
Approximately8%oftheHispanicsdonotutilizeanykindoffragranceproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

ConsumerResearch

Retaildistribution

Table323:RetailDistributionofFragrancesintheUnitedStates

%
Male

Female

Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme

56

44

%Oftotalresponses
4

Massmerchandisers

54

46

40

Discountdepartmentstores

53

47

14

Upscaledepartmentstores

72

28

Traditionaldepartmentstores

53

47

25

Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands

23

77

11

Storeswhichonlycarryonebrand

15

85

11

Warehouseclub

73

27

Drugstores

68

32

18

Food/grocerystores

71

29

Dollarstore

65

35

HomeshoppingTVchannels

33

67

Internet/online/mobilephone

50

50

11

Persontopersonsales

42

58

Dutyfree(airport,inflight,etc.)

67

33

Catalog/mailorder

29

71

Other/don'tknow

25

75

Figure38:ChannelsShoppedforFragrancesbyAge
Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme
Catalog/mailorder
Traditionaldepartmentstores
Discountdepartmentstores
Dollarstore
Drugstores
DutyFree(airport,inflight,etc.)
Food/grocerystores
Storeswhichonlycarryonebrand
HomeshoppingTVchannels
Internet/online/mobilephone
Merchandisers
Persontopersonsales
Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands
Upscaledepartmentstores
Warehouseclub
Other/don'tknow
0%
1519

2029

5%

10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40% 45% 50%

3039

4049

5059

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6069

339

340

ConsumerResearch

Approximately67%ofthepeoplewhoshopforfragrancesinhomeshoppingchannelsand
44%oftheminupscaledepartmentstoresareagedbetween50and59years.

Menshopatwarehouseclubsforfragrancesmuchmorethanwomendo.

Internetoronlineordersareemployedbypeopleintheagegroupsof40and49,followed
byconsumersaged20and29years.

ORALCAREPRODUCTS

Table324:UsageofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStates

%
Mouthwash

Whiteningproductsstrips,trays,etc.
(notincludingtoothpasteormouthwash
withwhiteningproperties)

Noneofthe
above

1519

17

2029

21

23

14

3039

19

22

14

4049

21

19

19

5059

19

23

13

6069

12

23

Total

100

100

100

79

34

16

Age

%Ofallresponses

IntheUnitedStates,oralcareproductssuchasmouthwashesandteethwhiteningproducts
areusemorebymenthanwomen.

Approximately55%ofthepeoplewhoemployteethwhiteningproductsaremenwhile45%
ofthemarewomen.

AmongtheHispanics,nearly86%ofthetotalrespondentsusemouthwasheswhilearound
2%ofthemdonotemploythementionedoralcareproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

341

ConsumerResearch

OTHERTOILETRIES

Usage

Table325:UsageofToiletriesProductsbyAge

%
Bar
soap

Bodywashor
showergel

Deodorant
antiperspirant
stick/rollon/
underarmspray

Deodorant
bodysprayor
fragrancespray

1519

16

2029

17

24

20

25

20

21

3039

18

20

17

22

20

23

4049

21

19

20

16

22

18

5059

19

18

20

16

20

16

6069

17

10

14

12

13

Total

100

100

100

100

100

100

67

75

92

31

62

64

Age

%Ofallresponses

Shaving
creamorgel

Other
toiletries

Figure39:UsageofToiletriesProductsbyGender

Barsoap

Bodywashorshowergel

Deodorantandantiperspirantstick/rollon/underarmspray

Deodorantandbodysprayorfragrancespray

Shavingcreamorgel

Othertoiletries

0%

10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%
Female

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Male

342

ConsumerResearch

IntheUnitedStates,barsoapsareusedequallybymenandwomen,whilebodywashesare
usedmorebywomen.

Of the total population, 92% use the more traditional stick/rollon or underarm spray
deodorants,while31%usebodyspray.

Only47%ofwomensaytheyuseshavingcreamorgel.

AmongtheHispanics,nearly90%ofthemutilizeantiperspirantrollonorunderarmspray
whilearound33%employbodysprays.
Barsoapsarepreferredtobodywashesandalmost58%ofthemuseothertoiletries.

Retaildistribution

Table326:RetailDistributionofOtherToiletries
%
Gender

Male

Female

%Ofalltotals

Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme

86

14

Massmerchandisers

46

54

74

Discountdepartmentstores

63

37

Upscaledepartmentstores

100

Traditionaldepartmentstores

67

33

Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands

24

76

Warehouseclubs

52

48

20

Drugstores

50

50

48

Food/grocerystores

50

50

48

Dollarstore

51

49

21

HomeshoppingTVchannels

60

40

Internet/online/mobilephone

30

70

Persontopersonsales

32

68

Catalog/mailorder

50

50

Other/dontknow

75

25

Storesthatcarryonlyonebrand

23

77

13

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

ConsumerResearch

Figure310:ChannelsShoppedforToiletriesbyAge

Idon'tshopfortheseproducts,someoneelsebuysthemforme
Catalog/mailorder
Traditionaldepartmentstores
Discountdepartmentstores
Dollarstore
Drugstores
Food/grocerystores
HomeshoppingTVchannels
Internet/online/mobilephone
Merchandisers
Persontopersonsales
Specialtybeauty/cosmeticstoreswhichcarryseveralbrands
Storesthatcarryonlyonebrand
Upscaledepartmentstores
Warehouseclub
Other/don'tknow
0%
1519

2029

10%
3039

20%

30%

4049

40%
5059

50%
6069

60%

70%

80%

Nearly 71% of the consumers aged between 15 and 19 years do not shop for toiletries
products.

Consumers between the ages of 2029, 3039, and 4049, each account for 21% of total
purchasesmadeinmassmerchandiserstores.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

343

344

ConsumerResearch

Figure311:ShiftsinChannelsShoppedforToiletries
70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Ipurchaseshowergelfomspecialty
stores

Ipurchaseshowergelfromdirect
sales

Ipurchaseshowergelfrom
departmentstores

Moreofteninthepast12monthsthanpreviously

Lessoftenthaninpreviousyears

Aboutthesameaspreviousyears

Notsureordon'tknow

GroomingattitudesintheUnitedStates

Figure312:IdontreallycareaboutmyappearancebyAge
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

6069

ConsumerResearch

IntheUnitedStates,only4%ofthemenstronglyagreethattheyarenotconcernedabout
their appearance, while no woman strongly agrees about not being concerned about her
looks.
Nearly 56% of the Caucasian people and almost 67% of African Americans strongly
disagreetheywouldconsiderhavingplasticsurgery.
Approximately 34% of the women and 23% of the men slightly agree that they are
apprehensiveabouttheirfacelookingolder.
AmongtheHispanicpopulationintheUnitedStates,almost23%ofthembelievethat
onlycleansingisnecessarytotakecareoftheirskin.
Closeto51%oftherespondentswhostrictlyconsidermoisturizingasanimportantskin
careregimeliebetweentheagesof30and39.
Only5%oftheconsumersagedbetween20and29areloyaltotheirbrandswhereas
almost 23% of people between the ages of 60 and 69 strongly refuse to experiment
withdifferentbrands.
About 50% of the African Americans, 36% of the Asians, and 23% of Caucasian
Americansstronglyagreetotakeprideintakingcareoftheirskin.
Almost 29% of men and 19% of women in the United States somewhat agree to be
unawareofthelatestskincareadvanceswhile30%ofthemenand36%ofthewomen
neitheragreenotdisagree.
Natural or organic products are increasingly being favored by people of different age
groups. Approximately 14% of consumers aged between 15 and 19, 23% of people
aged between 20 and 29, and 25% of consumers between the ages of 30 and 39
strongly agree to use natural products. Close to 17% of the Hispanics wish to utilize
productswithnaturalororganicingredients.

Approximately29%ofthoseconsumerswhoseincomeliesbetweentherangeof$125,000
to $149,999 and 27% of persons with an income range of $150,000 to $199,999 would
considerundergoingnoninvasiveproceduressuchasBotox.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

345

346

ConsumerResearch

AttitudesinbuyinggroomingproductsintheUnitedStates

Figure313:IenjoytryingnewbeautyorgroomingproductsbyAge
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Nearly36%ofCaucasianAmericans,35%ofAfricanAmericans,7%ofAsians,50%ofNative
Americans,and11%ofpeoplewithmixedracialbackgroundintheUnitedStatessomewhat
agreetoenjoytestingnewgroomingproducts.
About52%ofthewomensomewhatagreetooftenshopatnearbystoreswhileonly
3% of them strongly disagree. Among the men, 40% of them agree toshop at stores
nearbywhile7%ofthemstronglydisagree.
Consumersbetweentheagesof60and69(36%)and15and19(33%)donotspenda
lot of money on buying grooming products for personal use. Only 17% of consumers
with an income range between $100,000 and $124,999 agree to spend a lot on
groomingproductswhilenearly22%ofthemdisagree.
While59%ofthewomenintheUnitedStatesstronglydisagreethatafamilymember
purchasesgroomingproductsforthem,only30%ofthemenstronglydisagreeforthe
same.
Approximately 24% of the Hispanics strongly agree while another 40% of them
somewhatagreetoshopforbeautyproductswhileshoppingforotherproducts.
Closeto50%oftheNativeAmericansand21%oftheAsiansstronglyagreetolookout
forimprovedorlatestbeautyproductswhileonly11%oftheCaucasiansand6%ofthe
AfricanAmericansdothesame.
Only 5% of the men and 4% of women strongly agree to spending large amounts of
moneyongroomingproducts,while11%ofthemenand10%ofthewomensomewhat
agree.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

ConsumerResearch

Nearly 43% of consumers between the ages of 40 and 49 believe that higher priced
groomingproductsareofahigherqualitythanlowerpricedproductswhileonly11%of
them strongly consider this to be false. Close to 71% of Asians in the United States
considerhigherpricedproductstobeofahigherquality.
Almost 44% of the women and 34% of the men somewhat agree that they purchase
mostoftheirgroomingproductswhentherearedealsorpromotionswhileonly2%of
themenand1%ofthewomenstronglydisagree.

Figure314:IwouldconsiderhavingplasticsurgerybyGender
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Male

Female

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure315:IwouldconsiderhavingplasticsurgerybyAge
100%
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6069

347

348

ConsumerResearch

Figure316:IamconcernedaboutmyfacelookingolderbyRace
100%

90%

80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
White/Caucasian

Black/AfricanAmerican

Stronglyagree

AsianorPacificIslander

Somewhatagree

NativeAmericanor
AlaskanNative

Neitheragreenordisagree

Mixedracialbackground

Somewhatdisagree

Other

Stronglydisagree

Figure317:CleansingisreallyallyouneedtotakecareofyourskinbyGender
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Male

Female

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

ConsumerResearch

Figure318:CleansingisreallyallyouneedtotakecareofyourskinbyAge
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure319:MoisturizingisanimportantaspectofskincarebyGender
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Male

Female

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

349

350

ConsumerResearch

Figure320:MoisturizingisanimportantaspectofskincarebyAge
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure321:IliketotrydifferentbrandsofbeautyorgroomingproductsImnotthatbrandloyalbyAge
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

6069

351

ConsumerResearch

Figure322:IliketotrydifferentbrandsofbeautyorgroomingproductsImnotthatbrandloyalbyRace
70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
White/Caucasian

Black/AfricanAmerican

Stronglyagree

AsianorPacificIslander

Somewhatagree

NativeAmericanor
AlaskanNative

Neitheragreenordisagree

Mixedracialbackground

Somewhatdisagree

Other

Stronglydisagree

Figure323:ItakeprideincaringformyskinbyAge
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6069

352

ConsumerResearch

Figure324:ItakeprideincaringformyskinbyRace
100%

90%

80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
White/Caucasian

Black/AfricanAmerican

Stronglyagree

AsianorPacificIslander

Somewhatagree

NativeAmericanor
AlaskanNative

Neitheragreenordisagree

Mixedracialbackground

Somewhatdisagree

Other

Stronglydisagree

Figure325:ItrytokeepupwiththelatestskincareadvancesbyIncome
80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to $125,000to $150,000to $200,000or Refuseto
$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow
Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

Stronglydisagree

ConsumerResearch

Figure326:IliketousenaturalororganicproductsbyAge
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure327:IliketousenaturalororganicproductsbyIncome

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to $125,000to $150,000to $200,000or Refuseto
$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow
Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Stronglydisagree

353

354

ConsumerResearch

Figure328:IwouldconsiderhavingnoninvasiveprocedureslikeBotoxbyAge
90%
80%
70%
60%
50%
40%
30%
20%
10%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure329:IwouldconsiderhavingnoninvasiveprocedureslikeBotoxbyIncome
80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to $125,000to $150,000to $200,000or Refuseto
$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow
Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

Stronglydisagree

ConsumerResearch

Figure330:IenjoytryingnewbeautyorgroomingproductsbyGender
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Male

Female

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure331:IrarelygoshoppingbyIncome
80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Under
$15,000

$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to$125,000to$150,000to$200,000or Refuseto


$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Stronglydisagree

355

356

ConsumerResearch

Figure332:InormallyonlygoshoppingatstoresnearmebyAge
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

6069

Neitheragreenordisagree

Figure333:Ispendalotofmoneyonbeauty/grooming/toiletriesforpersonalusebyrace
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
White/Caucasian

Black/AfricanAmerican

Stronglyagree

AsianorPacificIslander

Somewhatagree

NativeAmericanor
AlaskanNative

Neitheragreenordisagree

Mixedracialbackground

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

Stronglydisagree

Other

357

ConsumerResearch

Figure334:Itendtohaveafamilymemberpurchasemybeauty/grooming/toiletriesproductsbyrace
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
White/Caucasian

Black/AfricanAmerican

Stronglyagree

AsianorPacificIslander

Somewhatagree

NativeAmericanor
AlaskanNative

Neitheragreenordisagree

Mixedracialbackground

Somewhatdisagree

Other

Stronglydisagree

Figure335:I'malwaysonthelookoutfornewandimprovedbeauty/grooming/toiletriesproductsbyAge
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
1519

2029

3039

4049

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

5059

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6069

358

ConsumerResearch

Figure336:I'malwaysonthelookoutfornewandimprovedbeauty/grooming/toiletriesproductsbyIncome
80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Under
$15,000

$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to$125,000to$150,000to$200,000or Refuseto


$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Figure337:Idon'tlikespendingalotofmoneyonbeauty/grooming/toiletriesproductsbyIncome
80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Under
$15,000

$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to$125,000to$150,000to$200,000or Refuseto


$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

Stronglydisagree

359

ConsumerResearch

Figure338:Higherpricedbeauty/grooming/toiletriesproductsaregenerallyofhigherqualitythanlower
pricedproductsbyIncome
60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Under
$15,000

$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to$125,000to$150,000to$200,000or Refuseto


$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Figure339:ItendtomakemostofmypurchaseswhentherearedealsorpromotionsbyGender
50%
45%
40%
35%
30%
25%
20%
15%
10%
5%
0%
Male

Female

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Somewhatdisagree

Stronglydisagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

360

ConsumerResearch

Figure340:ItendtomakemostofmypurchaseswhentherearedealsorpromotionsbyIncome

80%

70%

60%

50%

40%

30%

20%

10%

0%
Under
$15,000

$15,000to $35,000to $45,000to $55,000to $75,000to $100,000to$125,000to$150,000to$200,000or Refuseto


$34,999
$44,999
$54,999
$74,999
$99,999
$124,999 $149,999 $199,999
more
answeror
don'tknow

Stronglyagree

Somewhatagree

Neitheragreenordisagree

Somewhatdisagree

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

Stronglydisagree

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

OUTLETDEFINITIONS

Cosmetics and toiletries are sold through a wide variety of purchase channels, with the
primaryretailoutletsfortheindustryshownbelow:
Departmentstores
Directsales
Drugoutlets
Foodstores
Massmerchandisers
Professionaloutlets
Specialtystores

In terms of total sales volume, mass merchandiser outlets continue to be the most
importantpurchasechannelforcosmeticsandtoiletries.
Consumersshopatmassmerchandiseroutletsforvaluesavings,convenientlocations,
andawidevarietyofstockkeepingunits(SKUs)frommostoftheproductcategories.
Therearethreemaintypesofmassmerchandiseroutlets:bigboxretailers(Walmart,
Target, and Kmart), general merchandise stores (dollar stores, such as Dollar General
andFamilyDollarStores),andwarehouseclubs(SamsClubandCostco).

Drugstoreoutletsaccountforaconsiderableportionofsalesacrossallproductcategories.
Therearethreesubclassesofdrugstores,asfollows:
Chaindrugstores,includingretailerssuchasWalgreens,RiteAid,andCVS.
Independentsfocusmostlyonprescriptiondrugsandothermedicines.
Deepdiscountdrugstoresconsistofafewregionalretailers.

Foodstoresremainanimportantchannel,especiallyfortheallfamilyproductcategories.
Food outlets can be divided into traditional supermarkets, super stores, food/drug
combinationstores,supercenters/combostores,andconveniencestores.

Departmentstorescanbedividedintothreeclasses,asfollows:
Lowerenddepartmentstores,suchasKohls,J.C.Penney,andSears.
Traditionaldepartmentstores,includingMacysandDillards.
Specialtydepartmentstores,suchasNeimanMarcusandSaksFifthAvenue.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

362

RetailDistribution

Direct selling also plays a significant role in the selling of cosmetics and toiletries. This
channelconsistsoffiveprimarysubclasses:
PersontopersonmarketerslikeAvonandMaryKay.
HomeshoppingchannelssuchastheHomeShoppingNetworkandQVC.
Infomercials,whichrepresentaneducational/entertainmentformatwhereconsumers
canorderproductsdirectlyfromthemanufacturerviaatollfreetelephonenumber.
Ecommerce,includingbrandwebsites,multibrandsitessuchasGloss.comandretailer
sites.
Nonelectronic vehicles, which consist of catalogs, direct mail order, and direct
responseprints.

Specialty stores have become a significant purchase channel for cosmetics and toiletries
lately.Thefourmainsubclassesareasfollows:
Verticallyintegratedstores,suchasBath&BodyWorks.
Cosmeticspecialtyshops,suchasSephora,Ulta,andPureBeauty.
Beautysupplystores,suchasSallyBeautyandmanysmallindependents.
Apparelspecialtystores,suchasGapandBananaRepublic.

Professionaloutletsincludesalons,spas,anddoctorsoffices.
Of these purchase channels, salons are the most important, with purchases coming
mainlyfromhaircaresalonsandfromskincaresalons.KlinesSalonHairCarereport
coversthehaircaresegmentmorethoroughly.
Spas and medical care provider offices are an important channel for the skin care
marketandareassessedinmoredetailinKlinesreportProfessionalSkinCare.
ThisCosmetics&ToiletriesUSAstudyreportsonlythesalesofproductspurchasedfor
takehomebyconsumers.Ourprofessionalstudiesreportsalesofthoseproductsused
bytheprofessionalsaswell,knownasbackbarsales.

Other purchase channels for cosmetics and toiletries include health clubs, kiosks, hotel
stores,andgiftshops.
Travelretailordutyfreeshopsaretheonlyconsumeroutletsnotcoveredinthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

RetailDistribution

SALESBYRETAILOUTLET

Mass merchandisers continue to be the most preferred retail channel for cosmetics and
toiletries, with total sales advancing 3.5% to reach $12,404 million in 2012, from
$11,981millionin2011.
Mass merchandisers represent 30.7% of total industry sales in 2012, constant from
2011levels.
Massmerchandiserscontinuetoexpandtheirrangeofproductsbymakingavailableto
consumers not just the necessities, but a range of premium products at high price
points.
Themassmerchandiserretailchannelbigboxretailers,warehouseclubs,anddollar
storesis increasingly viewed as a destination for stocking up on commoditytype
items,suchaspersonalcleansingproducts,shampoos,anddeodorants.
Salesfromwarehouseclubscontinuetogrowin2012.
Massmerchandisershavealsoincreasinglystartedtostockuponnaturalpersonalcare
productswhichareindemandbytheconsumers,therebydrivingthesalesupforthe
retailchannel.
Privatelabel products, a growing segment in the cosmetics and toiletries market, is
predominantlypresentinmassmerchandisers,andtheincreasingpopularityofthese
privatelabelproductsaidsinthegrowthofthechannel.
Additionally,thereisagrowingtrendofmassmerchandiserslaunchingtheirownline
of privatelabel products. In November 2012, Walgreens introduces the Ology line of
personalcareandhomeproductssupposedlyfreeofharmfulchemicals.
The promotional offers organized by mass merchandisers, such as discounts, are
instrumentalindrivingsales.
In2012,Targetdecidestogomoreupscaleinitsbeautydepartmentinordertoattract
more highend brands. As part of this effort, in July 2012, Target launches a "beauty
concierge" test program in 32 stores around the Chicago area. Concierges, available
approximately 40 hours per week, stroll the beauty department with iPads, mirrors,
and product samples to provide unbiased expertise and guidance to shoppers in the
retailer's beauty department. By the end of 2013, Target plans to have 190 stores
offeringthisservice.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

363

364

RetailDistribution

Drug stores follow as the second leading retail channel for cosmetics and toiletries in the
UnitedStates,withsalesat$7,276millionin2012,up1.8%from$7,149millionin2011.
The share of distribution for drug stores decreases nominally from 18.3% in 2011 to
18.0%in2012.
Drugstoreretailerscontinuetodiversifytheirproductofferingswithaddedemphasis
onthefrontendtobettercompetewithotherretailchannelsthatareencroachingon
theirturfsuchasmassmerchandisersandwarehouseclubs.
Acquisitions are one of the ways for the major drug chains to grow and have been
responsible for the major door expansion of Walgreens since 2005. Small regional
chainsarebeingpickedupbybothWalgreensandCVStofillinholesintheirnational
coverage.
Privatelabelandexclusivecosmeticandtoiletryproductsarestronginthedrugstores
channel, with some retailers such as CVS having very established privatelabel
programsthatmimicthelargestsellingbrandstowhichtheyareverysimilarinactive
ingredients and packaging. In contrast, Walgreens offers many exclusive and hard to
findbrands.
Manyofthechainsdevotemorefloorspacetopersonalcareandexpandtheirproduct
andbrandassortment.
Weeklyflyersfromthethreemajorchainsallhighlightcosmeticandtoiletryitemson
promotion.
Loyaltyprogramsandinstoreeventshelpengagethebeautycustomer.

Department stores are the thirdleading retail channel for cosmetics and toiletries, with
salesat$5,417millionin2012,up5.0%from$5,157millionin2011.
The share of sales from department stores increases from 13.2% of sales in 2011 to
13.4%in2012.
Departmentstoresremainchallengedasadestinationforbeautyproductsintheface
of growing sales from specialty stores, direct merchants, and mass merchandisers
expandingtheirselection.
Department store sales are cannibalized as some shoppers purchase from the e
commercesitesofdepartmentstores,whicharecapturedintheInternetportionofthe
directchannel.
Departmentstoreretailersworktobetterengageandcommunicatewiththeirbeauty
consumersbymorefrequentcommunicationviaoptinemails,morebeautyspacein
thecatalogsandmoremailingsdevotedexclusivelytobeauty,andgreateruseofsocial
mediatoengageconsumers.
Departmentstoresmodifytheirbeautydepartmentstoofferamoremodernshopping
environmentandbecomemorepertinenttobeautyshoppers.
Afraid to be stuck with unsold merchandise as experienced during the recession in
2008and2009,departmentstoresasawholecutbackonproductinventory.
Furthersalesinthedepartmentstoresareoffsetbythegoodperformanceofthemass
andspecialtystoreretailers.
Massretailersenhancetheirproductassortmentwithawidervarietyofupscalelines,
andtheadditionofsalesassociatesinmanycases.
Beauty specialty store retailers, such as Sephora and Ulta, continue to chip away at
department store sales, with the ability to more easily shop across brands with
knowledgeablesalesassistanceandinafunenvironment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

RetailDistribution

FoodstoresarethefourthleadingretailchannelforcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnited
States,withsalesup1.3%toreachat$5,217millionin2012,upfrom$5,149millionin2011.
Thedistributionshareforfoodstoresslidesfrom13.2%in2011to12.9%in2012.
Food outlets face increased competition from other channels encroaching upon their
share,sofoodstoresfeellotsofpressureanddonotplaceapriorityoncosmeticsand
toiletries.
While some retailers keep all the mainstream and natural personal care products
together,anincreasingnumberofstoresplacetheirnaturalpersonalcareproductsina
dedicatedarea,alongwithnaturalandorganicpackagedfood.
As cosmetic and toiletry marketers offer an evergrowing number of line extensions,
foodoutletsoftenfindthemselvesshortofspacetoofferalltheavailableproducts.
Privatelabelcosmeticsandtoiletriesaretypicallyevidentincommoditytypesegments.
Shampoos,handandbodylotions,liquidsoaps,andsuncareproductsarethetypical
productlabelofferings.

The direct sales channel registers sales at $4,499 million in 2012, up 6.7% from
$4,217millionin2011.
Thedirectsaleschannelaccountsfor11.1%oftheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
in2012,upfrom10.8%in2011.
Highestgrowthfortheentirechannelemergesfromtheecommercesubchannel.The
elimination of shipping charges for most beauty purchases over a certain minimum,
coupled with shoppers feeling more comfortable making online beauty purchases,
contributestothefastgrowthofthissubchannel.
Additionally,theeaseofpurchasealongwiththelureoffreesamples,andtheabilityto
order24/7fromacomputer,smartphone,ortablet,alongwiththeeasyabilitytoprice
checkproducts,furtherhelpstogrowsalesintheecommercesubchannel.
Home shopping networks, such as QVC and HSN, which have now begun to
merchandise mainstream brands, help the retail channel experience robust sales in
2012.
Printedmaterialsthatincludedirectresponse,catalogs,consumermagazines,remits,
andbillinginsertsareusedascommunicationsvehiclesforinformationpurposesand
helpdrivepurchaseinothersubchannels,mostlyinecommerce.
Persontoperson sales continues to dominate as the largest subclass of the direct
channel,despiteadeclineinmarketshare.
Oneofthebiggestchallengesfacingcompaniesthatfollowthepersontopersonsales
modelisrecruitingandretainingsalesassociates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

365

366

RetailDistribution

Specialty stores register increasing sales of $4,228million in 2012, up 8.2%, from


$3,906millionin2011.
Thespecialtystoresaccountfor10.5%oftheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket,up
from10.0%in2011.
Specialty stores continue to revolutionize the merchandising of cosmetic and toiletry
productsandarecarefullymonitoredand,manytimesmimicked,byotherchannels.
Growth in this channel is driven by a large number of new store openings, more
apparel chains with sizeable store counts, knowledgeable sales associates, good
customer service, an easy ability to shop across product lines, and a more fun
environmentthananyotherchannel.
Attractive price points offered by specialty retailers such as Bath & Body Works and
VictoriasSecretBeautyhelpgrowthischannel.
SpecialtystoressuchasSephoraandUltabenefitfromtheopensellenvironmentand
availabilityofnichebrandsalongsidemajoronesincosmeticspecialtystores.
In 2012, Sephora launches Fragrance Flight Bars at some of its locations. Fragrance
FlightBarsisestablishedsoshoppersarenotinfluencedbycelebrityendorsementsor
productpackaging.
Ultalaunchesanewloyaltyprogramin2012calledULTAmateRewardsprogram,which
willeventuallyreplaceTheClubatUlta.Thenewprogramrollsouttothecentralregion
oftheUnitedStates,withmoreareasaddedin2013.

Sales through professional outlets decrease 9.3% to $1,331million in 2012 from


$1,467millionduring2011.
Thesaleschannelaccountsfor3.3%oftheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012,
downfrom3.8%in2011.
The increasing popularity of professional results at home products contribute to the
declineofthechannelsalesin2012.
Moreover, consumers continue to opt for doityourself (DIY) solutions across
categoriesincluding,haircoloringproducts,nailpolishes,anddepilatories,waxes,and
bleaches.
Althoughtheeconomyisgettingbetter,consumersfrequencyofvisitingprofessional
outlets remains low contributing to the decline of the share of the channel in 2012.
Salonvisitsaregraduallygettingmorefrequentbutarenotuptoprerecessionlevels.
As a result, some professional brand marketers are broadening their distribution to
includetheInternet,specialtystores,andotherchannelsinordertostaycompetitive.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

RetailDistribution

Table327:ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012
$Million
Retailoutlet

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

11,981

12,404

30.7

30.7

3.5

Drugstores

7,149

7,276

18.3

18.0

1.8

Departmentstores

5,157

5,417

13.2

13.4

5.0

Foodstores

5,149

5,217

13.2

12.9

1.3

Directsales

4,217

4,499

10.8

11.1

6.7

Specialtystores

3,906

4,228

10.0

10.5

8.2

Professionaloutlets

1,467

1,331

3.8

3.3

(9.3)

39,026

40,372

100.0

100.0

3.4

Massmerchandisers

Total

Theaveragemarginacrossallretailoutletsforcosmeticsandtoiletriesis34.3%in2012.

Professional outlets displace department stores to represent the largest margin at 50.0%,
muchhigherthantheindustryaverage.
Thechannelsellsproductsatfullpriceascomparedtootherchannelsofdistribution
whichtendtohavesomekindofapromotionalofferonmostofthetime.
Lowmarketingactivityofsalonproductscontributetothehighretailmargin

Thedirectsalesanddepartmentstoreschannelsalsoposthighmarginsat43.9%and38.0%,
respectively.
The direct sales channel has limited administrative and operational expenditures in
comparisontootherchannelsandhencemaintainahighmargin.
Department stores high margin is as a result of the minimal discounts offered on its
products.

Margins for drug stores, food stores, and mass merchandisers fall below the industry
average.
The drug stores, food stores, and mass merchandisers offer a variety of have huge
promotionaloffersintheformofpurchasewithpurchaseoffers,anddiscountcoupons
overandabovethemanufacturerspromotionalschemes.
Massmerchandisers,apopularretailchannelwiththemassconsumers,hasthelowest
averagemarginduetoincreasingcompetitionandpricingpressuresexperiencedfrom
otherretailchannels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

367

368

RetailDistribution

Table328:AverageMarginforMajorRetailOutletsintheUnited
States,2012
Retailoutlet
Professionaloutlets
Directsales
Departmentstores
Specialtystores
INDUSTRYAVERAGE
Drugstores
Foodstores
Massmerchandisers

Averagemargin,%
50.0
43.9
38.0
37.0
34.3
30.0
30.0
28.8

Additional details about retail channels can be found in Klines Beauty Retailing report
series.

Table329:PercentageofSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyTypeofRetailOutlet,2012
%Oftotalmanufacturersdollars
Mass
merchandisers

Drug
stores

Department
stores

Food
stores

Babycareproducts

48

27

21

100

Conditioners

39

18

20

16

100

Dentureproducts

39

29

32

100

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

47

20

24

100

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

42

46

10

100

Ethnichaircareproducts

27

20

45

100

Eyemakeup

29

19

26

14

100

Facemakeup

24

18

30

16

10

100

Facialtreatments

14

16

25

30

100

Fragrancesformen

19

11

37

16

16

100

Fragrancesforwomen

12

34

12

35

100

Haircoloringproducts

39

39

18

100

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

36

19

18

22

100

Handandbodylotions

28

18

11

33

100

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

33

27

20

11

100

Lipsticksandlipglosses

19

25

24

18

11

100

Mouthwashes

46

25

29

100

Nailpolishes

37

39

100

Personalcleansingproducts

43

10

27

12

100

Shampoos

41

13

23

11

100

Shavingproducts

41

25

26

100

Skincareproductsformen

18

15

49

12

100

Suncareproducts

42

30

12

100

Toothwhiteningproducts

49

28

19

100

Toothbrushes

46

22

31

100

Toothpastes

44

18

37

100

Weightedaverage

31

18

13

13

11

11

100

Productcategory

Direct
sales

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

Specialty
stores

Professional
outlets

Total

369

RetailDistribution

Table330:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesbyTypeofRetailOutlet,2012
$Million
Productcategory

Mass
merchandisers

Drug
stores

Department
stores

Food
stores

Direct
sales

Specialty
stores

Professional
outlets

Total

Babycareproducts

138

78

60

288

Conditioners

645

298

17

331

50

66

264

1,653

Dentureproducts

124

92

102

318

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

959

408

82

490

61

41

2,040

68

75

16

163

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Ethnichaircareproducts

92

68

24

153

340

Eyemakeup

786

515

704

108

379

244

2,709

Facemakeup

698

524

873

58

465

291

29

2,909

Facialtreatments

930

1063

1661

133

1994

532

332

6,645

Fragrancesformen

209

121

407

11

176

176

1,101

Fragrancesforwomen

326

163

924

27

326

951

2717

Haircoloringproducts

514

514

237

53

1,317

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

605

319

17

302

34

34

370

1680

Handandbodylotions

639

411

114

114

251

753

23

2,283

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

123

101

75

26

41

374

Lipsticksandlipglosses

262

344

330

41

248

151

1,377

Mouthwashes

368

200

232

799

Nailpolishes

245

258

26

20

53

53

662

Personalcleansingproducts

1731

403

81

1087

282

483

4,026

Shampoos

1074

341

26

603

157

131

288

2,620

153

93

15

97

373

Shavingproducts
Skincareproductsformen

30

25

83

20

169

Suncareproducts

440

314

63

126

63

52

1,048

Toothwhiteningproducts

133

76

51

271

Toothbrushes

341

163

230

741

Toothpastes

770

315

647

17

1,749

12,403

7,281

5,433

5,227

4,583

4,268

1,331

40,372

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

370

RetailDistribution

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

PRIVATELABELACTIVITY

Privatelabelproductsaredefinedinthisreportasproductsmarketedashousebrandsor
storebrands,aswellasgenericproducts.
Forthepurposeofthisstudy,productsfromretailerssuchasBath&BodyWorksand
TheGaparenotconsideredprivatelabelbrands,butspecialtybrands.

Although privatelabel product penetration in the cosmetics and toiletries industry is


marginal,theyslowlyandgraduallyimprovetheirmarketshare.
Theprivatelabelproductsrepresenta3.2%ofthetotalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin
2012, flat from 2011 percentage. Sales of private label grow 3.1% to reach
$1,300millionin2012,upfrom$1,261millionin2011.
Privatelabel products have a significant presence in the baby care products,
mouthwashes,toothbrushes,andsuncareproductscategoriesin2012.
The national, wellrecognized brands still dominate the various categories in the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Sales of privatelabel products in some product categories are too negligible to be
consideredforanalysisinthisstudy.

Thepersonalcleansingproductscategoryholdsthetoppositioninprivatelabelsales.
Privatelabel sales in the personal cleansing products category total $338million in
2012,accountingfor26.0%ofthetotalsegmentsales.
Mouthwashesrepresent10.4%oftotalprivatelabelsales,or$135millionin2012.
Facialtreatmentsaccountfor9.8%oftotalprivatelabelsales,or$127millionin2012.
In2012,privatelabelsuncareproductsregistersalesof$122million,or9.4%oftotal
personalcareprivatelabelsales.

Thesaleofprivatelabelproductsasapercentageofcategorysalesaveragestobe3.2%.
In nine product categories, sales of privatelabel products are above or equivalent to
theindustryaverage.
Baby care products continue to be the leading category in privatelabel sales as a
percentage of the entire category, accounting for 18.8% of category sales in the U.S.
marketin2012.
Salesofprivatelabelbrandsinthemouthwashescategoryaccountfor16.9%oftotal
mouthwashsalesin2012.
Privatelabelsalesin10categoriesrepresentlessthan1.0%ofthetotalcategorysales.
Four out of these 10 categories have virtually no privatelabel sales at all. These
categories include hair styling products and sprays, hair coloring products, skin care
productsformen,andethnichaircareproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

372

PrivatelabelActivity

Retailersutilizeprivatelabelproductsasoneofthemeanstodifferentiatethemselvesfrom
otherretailersinthemarket.
In addition to differentiating themselves from the others in the market, the retailers
countonprivatelabelproductstoboostprofitabilityandimproveconsumerloyalty.
Most of the retail stores offer private label programs in order to compete with the
nationalbrandsthatarebackedbyagoodadvertisingsupport.
Furthermore,retailersbenefitfromthesaleofprivatelabelproductsduetothehigh
profitmargin on these products in comparison to those on nationally advertised
brands.
Retailers are increasingly supporting the sales of privatelabel products by providing
them prime shelf space. Other promotional initiatives include instore campaigns,
rewardcards,andnewspaperpromotions.
To help better understand the consumers needs and choices, privatelabel
manufacturersworkcloselywithretailersinordertodevelopproductsthatappealto
themasses.

Privatelabel products are now achieving mainstream status as retailers narrow down the
price and quality gaps that once differentiated the privatelabel products from national
brands.
The initial wave of privatelabel products focused on copying the national branded
products and making them available at a low price points, especially during the
recession.However,thenotionhaschangednowwithretailersdevelopinginnovative
products and packaging that helps the retailers differentiate their products from the
othersavailableinthemarket.
Privatelabel products are more prominently present in the personal hygiene
categoriesthanthecosmeticcategories.
In 2012, personal cleansing products, mouthwashes, facial treatments, and sun care
productsrepresentthelargestsalesamongotherprivatelabelproductcategories.

In2012,thegrowthofprivatelabelproductsdipsbelowtheindustrygrowthrateof3.6%.
Thelipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategoryrecordsthehighestgrowthrateinthe
privatelabel segment in 2012, with sales up 22.2% from $9 million in 2011 to
$11millionin2012.
The eye makeup and nail polishes categories follow as the secondfastest growing
categoriesinthesegmentwith14.3%growthforeachofthem.However,theseareall
fromsmallbasesalesfigures.

In2012,privatelabelmakesitspresencefeltinthemakeupproducts.
Privatelabel products are now available in the eye makeup, lipsticks and lip glosses,
facemakeup,andnailpolishescategories.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

PrivatelabelActivity

Table331:U.S.SalesofPrivatelabelCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategory,2012
Productcategory

$Million

Personalcleansingproducts

338

26.0

Mouthwashes

135

10.4

Facialtreatments

127

9.8

Suncareproducts

122

9.4

Handandbodylotions

109

8.4

Toothbrushes

101

7.8

Shampoos

82

6.3

Babycareproducts

54

4.2

Conditioners

41

3.2

Fragrancesforwomen

37

2.8

Dentureproducts

26

2.0

Eyemakeup

24

1.8

Facemakeup

22

1.7

Toothwhiteningproducts

16

1.2

Toothpastes

15

1.2

Shavingproducts

14

1.1

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

11

0.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

10

0.8

Nailpolishes

0.6

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

0.2

Fragrancesformen

0.2

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

0.2

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Haircoloringproducts

Skincareproductsformen

Ethnichaircareproducts

1,300

100.0

Total

%Oftotalprivatelabelsales

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

373

374

PrivatelabelActivity

Table332:U.S.SalesofPrivatelabelCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategoryasaPercentageof
CategorySales,2012
$Million
Products

Privatelabel

Babycareproducts

%Privatelabeltocategorytotal

54

288

18.8

Mouthwashes

135

799

16.9

Toothbrushes

101

741

13.6

Suncareproducts

122

1,048

11.6

Personalcleansingproducts

338

4,026

8.4

Dentureproducts

26

318

8.2

Toothwhiteningproducts

16

271

5.9

109

2,283

4.8

Shavingproducts

14

373

3.8

Shampoos

82

2,620

3.1

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

11

374

2.9

Conditioners

41

1,653

2.5

127

6,645

1.9

163

1.8

37

2,717

1.4

Nailpolishes

662

1.2

Eyemakeup

24

2,709

0.9

Toothpastes

15

1,749

0.9

Facemakeup

22

2,909

0.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

10

1,377

0.7

Fragrancesformen

1,101

0.3

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2,040

0.1

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

Skincareproductsformen

169

Ethnichaircareproducts

340

1,300

40,372

3.2

Handandbodylotions

Facialtreatments
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Fragrancesforwomen

Total

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

PrivatelabelActivity

Table333:U.S.SalesofPrivatelabelCosmeticsandToiletriesbyProductCategory,Rankedby
ChangeinValue,2011and2012
$Million
Category

2011

2012

Change,%

11

22.2

Eyemakeup

21

24

14.3

Nailpolishes

14.3

Lipsticksandlipglosses

10

11.1

Facemakeup

20

22

10.0

Shavingproducts

13

14

7.7

Toothbrushes

94

101

7.4

Toothpastes

14

15

7.1

Toothwhiteningproducts

15

16

6.7

120

127

5.8

35

37

5.7

Mouthwashes

129

135

4.7

Suncareproducts

117

122

4.3

Babycareproducts

52

54

3.8

330

338

2.4

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

Fragrancesformen

109

109

26

26

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Haircoloringproducts

Skincareproductsformen

Ethnichaircareproducts

Conditioners

43

41

(4.7)

Shampoos

90

82

(8.9)

1,261

1,300

3.1

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Facialtreatments
Fragrancesforwomen

Personalcleansingproducts

Handandbodylotions
Deodorantsandantiperspirants
Dentureproducts

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

375

376

PrivatelabelActivity

Privatelabelproductswillcontinuetoperformwellthroughtheforecastperiodfrom2012
to2017.
Privatelabelisexpectedtoincreaseitsmarketshareduringtheforecastperiodending,
2017.
Private labels will continue to provide stiff competition to branded products by
launching products with improved quality and at competitive prices. However, mass
retailers will continue to offer privatelabel brands that mimic the bestselling
nationallyadvertisedonesduetotheattractivemargins.
Privatelabel products enriched with natural ingredients and a naturallypositioned
imagewillwitnessexpansioninthecomingfiveyears.
Pricing for privatelabelproducts will also grow during the next fiveyears, but would
stillbeacostsavingalternativecomparedwithnationalbrands.
Reinforcingtheperceptionofimprovedquality,retailersareexpectedtocreatemulti
tiered privatelabel products in the cosmetics and toiletries market. These multi
layeredprivatelabelproductsareexpectedtoattractdifferentconsumerssegments.
Retailers will look to expand the distribution network for their privatelabel products
beyondtheirownstorenetworksandarelikelytosupporttheirproductofferingswith
improvedpromotionalsupport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A76

MARKETINGACTIVITY

TRACEABLEMEDIAEXPENDITURES

Traceable media expenditures (TME) in the cosmetic and toiletry market are recorded at
$6,305millionin2012.
TotalTMEspendingonthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketfor2012increases2.7%.
Televisionremainstobethemostpreferredmediumofadvertisingformostmarketers,
followedbymagazines.
Marketers spend approximately 50% of the entire TME on television advertisements
andapproximately45%onprintmediain2012.
TMEaresourcedfromKontarMedia.

Thefiveleadingproductcategoriesaccountfor48.3% oftotaladvertisingexpendituresin
2012.
Facial treatments, the leading category in dollar sales, continue to have the largest
advertising spending, with a TME of $1,334 million in 2012, up 9.3% from
$1,221millionin2011.
Shampoos is the secondmost advertised category, representing 7.3% of the total
mediaspending,withaTMEof$446millionin2012
Face makeup continues to be the thirdlargest category with respect to advertising
expendituresin2012.TheTMEforthecategoryin2012is$438million,upmarginally
by1.6%from$431millionin2011.
Skin care products for men and ethnic hair care products are the smallest categories
with respect to promotional spending, with a TME of $19 million and $1 million,
respectively.

The 29 leading marketers profiled in this report represent $5,750 million in TME, or
approximately91.2%ofthetotalindustryTME,in2012.
Thetopfivemarketersaccountfor63.7%oftotalindustryTMEin2012.
LOralhasthelargestTME,withaspendingof$1,448millionin2012,up10.4%from
$1,312millionin2011.Thecompanyaccountsfor23.0%oftotalindustryTMEin2012.
Procter&GambleisthesecondlargestadvertiserwithaTMEof$1,217millionin2012,
down18.3%from$1,490millionin2011.
Unilever, the third largest advertiser, spends a TME of $522million, accounting for
8.3%ofthetotalindustryTMEin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

378

MarketingActivity

In 2012, 10 categoriesTME as a percentage of the category sales are above the industry
averageof15.6%.
NailpolishesaccountforthelargestTMEasaproportionofthecategorystotalsalesin
2012.
TheTMEinthenailpolishescategoryrepresents36.3%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin
2012.
In2012,theTMEfordepilatories,waxes,andbleachesare$57million,oraccountfor
35.0%ofthecategorystotalsales.
Sales of tooth whitening products total $271million, while the categorys TME is at
$79millionin2012. Therefore,thepercentageofTMEtothetotalcategoryssalesis
29.2%.
TheethnichaircareproductscategoryhastheleastpercentageofTMEasaproportion
tothecategoryssalesat0.3%.

In 2012, 15 of the leading 29 companies have a TME as a percentage of sales above the
industryaverageof15.6%.
GuthyRenker registers the highest percentage of spending to sales proportion, at
41.2%during2012.
GlaxoSmithKline is the secondleading marketer, which records a TME representing
31.9%ofthecompanyssalesinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
LOralisinaclosethirdposition,withtheTMEaccountingfor31.8%ofthecompanys
sales.

Mostofthemarketersincreasetheiradvertisingbudgetinordertosupportsalesgrowthfor
theirbrandsin2012.
Marketersutilizedifferentmarketingmediatopromotetheirproductsfortheirvarious
portfoliosofbrands.
There is an evolution of nontraditional media, such as social media, the Internet,
YouTube, and mobile marketing, but these are complementary to the traditional
advertisingmedia,whichcontinuestobeimportant.
Most companies have started to launch campaigns that encompass both traditional
andnewmediatogainaccesstoawiderrangeofconsumersandexposeproductsto
morepeople.
Companies are increasingly starting to advertise on the Internet because it is an
effective platform to share product information and create awareness among
consumers,duetoitswideoutreachandeasyaccessofinformation.
Mostofthemarketersgenerallysupporttheirnewproductintroductionswithaheavy
advertising expenditure. These promotions are in the form of print and television
advertisements,samples,socialmedia,sweepstakes,andinstoremarketing.
Other promotional tools adopted by marketers include the use of Internet, coupons,
mobilecommerce,andlaunchevents.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A78

MarketingActivity

Table334:ProductCategoriesRankedbyTraceableMediaExpenditures,2012
Category

$Million

Facialtreatments

1,334

21.2

Shampoos

446

7.1

Facemakeup

438

6.9

Eyemakeup

379

6.0

Toothpastes

338

5.4

Fragrancesforwomen

325

5.2

Othercosmeticsandtoiletries

322

5.1

Handandbodylotions

297

4.7

Haircoloringproducts

297

4.7

Lipsticksandlipglosses

277

4.4

Haircareproductsmultiproduct

255

4.0

Nailpolishes

240

3.8

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

224

3.6

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

165

2.6

Personalcleansingproducts

154

2.4

Fragrancesformen

135

2.1

Conditioners

119

1.9

Mouthwashes

105

1.7

Suncareproducts

80

1.3

Toothwhiteningproducts

79

1.3

Dentureproducts

61

1.0

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

57

0.9

Babycareproducts

55

0.9

Toothbrushes

42

0.7

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

33

0.5

Shavingproducts

31

0.5

Skincareproductsformen

16

0.3

6,305

100.0

Ethnichaircareproducts
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

%Oftotal

379

380

MarketingActivity

Table335:LeadingCosmeticandToiletryCompaniesRankedbyTraceableMedia
Expenditures,2012
Company

$Million

%Oftotal

L'Oral

1,448

23.0

Procter&Gamble

1,217

19.3

Unilever

522

8.3

Johnson&Johnson

440

7.0

EsteLauder

386

6.1

GuthyRenker

304

4.8

Coty

283

4.5

Revlon

161

2.6

Kao

131

2.1

GlaxoSmithKline

130

2.1

ColgatePalmolive

110

1.7

LVMH

90

1.4

Chanel

87

1.4

Church&Dwight

66

1.0

ElizabethArden

57

0.9

Shiseido

52

0.8

Sanofi

51

0.8

Combe

39

0.6

EnergizerHoldings

33

0.5

Clarins

27

0.4

Beiersdorf

26

0.4

MaryKay

18

0.3

Merck

18

0.3

Avon

13

0.2

Alticor

12

0.2

HelenofTroy

12

0.2

TheCloroxCompany

10

0.2

Henkel

0.1

LimitedBrandsa

555

8.8

6,305

100.0

Allother
Total

aTMEdatanegligible.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A80

MarketingActivity

Table336:TraceableMediaExpendituresofCosmeticandToiletryProductCategoriesRankedby
PercentageofSales,2012

Traceablemediaexpenditures
U.S.salesofcosmetics
andtoiletries,$million

Category

$Million

%Ofsales

Nailpolishes

662

240

36.3

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

163

57

35.0

Toothwhiteningproducts

271

79

29.2

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

297

22.6

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,377

277

20.1

Facialtreatments

6,645

1,334

20.1

Toothpastes

1,749

338

19.3

Dentureproducts

318

61

19.2

Babycareproducts

288

55

19.1

Shampoos

2,620

446

17.0

Facemakeup

2,909

438

15.1

Eyemakeup

2,709

379

14.0

799

105

13.1

Handandbodylotions

2,283

297

13.0

Fragrancesformen

1,101

135

12.3

Fragrancesforwomen

2,717

325

12.0

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2,040

224

11.0

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

165

9.8

Skincareproductsformen

169

16

9.5

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

374

33

8.8

Shavingproducts

373

31

8.3

Suncareproducts

1,048

80

7.6

Conditioners

1,653

119

7.2

741

42

5.7

4,026

154

3.8

340

0.3

Othercosmeticsandtoiletries

322

Haircareproductsmultiproduct

255

6,305

15.6

Mouthwashes

Toothbrushes
Personalcleansingproducts
Ethnichaircareproducts

Total
40,372

aSalesincludedinvariouscategories.
bAdjustedtoexcludehaircaremultiproducttoavoiddoublecounting.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

381

382

MarketingActivity

Table337:TraceableMediaExpendituresofLeadingCosmeticandToiletryCompaniesRanked
byPercentageofIndustrySales,2012

U.S.salesofcosmeticsand
toiletries,$million

Company

$Million

%Ofsales

GuthyRenker

737

304

41.2

GlaxoSmithKline

407

130

31.9

4,551

1,448

31.8

337

90

26.7

1,086

283

26.1

Sanofi

197

51

25.9

Kao

525

131

25.0

Combe

157

39

24.8

2,020

440

21.8

313

66

21.1

5,824

1,217

20.9

Revlon

814

161

19.8

ElizabethArden

290

57

19.7

Chanel

461

87

18.9

Clarins

171

27

15.8

Unilever

3,546

522

14.7

EsteLauder

2,722

386

14.2

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

110

7.4

Shiseido

542

52

9.6

Merck

209

18

8.6

EnergizerHoldings

396

33

8.3

HelenofTroy

147

12

8.2

Beiersdorf

344

26

7.6

Alticor

176

12

6.8

TheCloroxCompany

172

10

5.8

1,063

18

1.7

Avon

948

13

1.4

Henkel

635

1.1

LimitedBrandsa

1,785

Allother

8,304

555

6.7

40,372

6,305

15.6

L'Oral
LVMH
Coty

Johnson&Johnson
Church&Dwight
Procter&Gamble

MaryKay

Total

aTMEdatanegligible.

Traceablemediaexpenditures

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A82

MarketingActivity

Television advertising is the most commonly used form of advertising for cosmetic and
toiletryproductsduetoitsabilitytocoverawideaudience,oramorespecifictargetgroup,
asrequired.
Differentkindsoftelevisionchannelsincludenetworktelevision,cabletelevision,and
syndicatedtelevision.
Companiesalsousedifferentprintmediasuchasmagazines,newspapers,andjournals
toreachouttoconsumerswiththeiradvertisements.
Advertisingintheprintmediaiscomparativelycheaperthanadvertisingontelevision.
Different types of magazines include Sunday magazines, local magazines, womens
service magazines, fashion magazines, and magazines for specific groups, such as
Hispanicmagazines.
Increasingly, companies are also using nontraditional media, such as the Internet,
social media sites, and mobile phones to advertise their product lines. Such media is
used in addition to the traditional advertising and to reach out to a wider set of
consumers.
In2012,marketerscontinuetoengagecelebritiestoendorsetheirbrandsforprintand
televisionadvertisements.
Largeproductclassessuchasskincare,makeup,andhaircarewidelypromotetheuse
ofcelebritiestoendorsetheirnewproductlinesortheirbestsellingproductsbythis
mean.
ThecelebritiesengagedbymarketerincludepopularfilmandTVpersonalities,models,
andsportspersonsandathletes.
Therearefewmarketerswhousereallifepeopletopromotetheirproductsinorderto
giveconsumersamorerealfeelandjustifythebenefitsoftheirproducts.

The Internet has emerged as an extremely important medium to promote cosmetic and
toiletryproducts.
The medium is convenient, cost effective, accurate, and allows marketers to inform
peopleabouttheirbrands,productbenefits,andinnovationsonaregularbasis.
The medium of the Internet allows cosmetic and toiletry marketers to expand their
reachbeyondgeographicbarriersandcanbeaccessedvirtuallyfromanycornerofthe
worldthatoffersInternetaccess.
Manyretailersandmarketersofferspecialwebonlypromotionstohelpdrivesales.In
addition,samplesandgiftwithpurchase(GWP)aremoreoftenofferedonlinethanin
theactualretaillocation.
The Internet is increasingly used as a medium of crossmarketing a brand across
different media. Increasingly, most brands websites have links to their presence on
socialmediasitessuchasFacebook,Twitter,YouTube,Pinterest,andblogs.
TheInternetmediumofferstheconvenienceofathomeshopping,enablingconsumers
toshopfortheirbeautyneedsattheirowntimeandconvenience.
A brands website acts as a medium to convey the message to its consumers about
what the brand is all about and why consumers should be reposing their trust in the
brand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

383

384

MarketingActivity

Mostbrandwebsitesrequestconsumerstosignupwiththem,andonceregistered;the
member is entitled to receive a newsletter and access to special offers, samples,
coupons, various events, sweepstakes, giveaways, and insider information on a
monthlybasis.
Besides convenience, most brand websites also have customer service links or the
optionofspeakingtocustomerserviceexecutivestoanswertheconsumersproduct
relatedqueries.
Increasingly,websitesaddvaluebyfeaturingtips,funapplications,games,andquizzes
toentertaincustomers,therebystrengtheninginterestandloyaltyforthebrand.

Social media is emerging as an effective means to reach the end customer, both
independentlyandasacomplementtotraditionalcommunicationchannels.
It enables companies to reach out to their consumers and learn about their brand
experience,aswellasgetinsightsabouttheirbrandsfromthesecustomers.
TwoofthemostprominentplatformsinsocialmediaareFacebookandTwitter,both
ofwhichhaveseenexponentialgrowthintheirimportanceastoolsofcommunication.
Othersocialmediaplatformsincludepicturesharingsites,suchasFlickrandPinterest,
other microblog platforms, such as Tumblr, and a host of similar forums, such as
LinkedIn.
Agrowingnumberofcompaniesusesocialmediatosharedetailsaboutnewproduct
introductions, coupons, sweepstakes, special offers, events, details about social
initiatives, as well as to use it as an open platform to communicate with their
consumers through live chats, and share valuable consumer insights, opinions, and
experiences.
Facebook is being used by companies and brands to update information on brands,
announce new campaigns, new product launches, and details about coming events.
Facebookprovidesthemechanismforacompanyorbrandtoforwardblogpostsand
reviewstoitsconsumers.
Twitter is considered to be a direct forum for discussions, with more immediate
responsestocustomerenquiries.
Social media is increasingly being used to produce viral content in order to gain
attentionandattractnaturallinks,whichhelpstoreceivespontaneousresults.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A84

MarketingActivity

Directmarketingisatraditionalmarketingmethoddirectedatconsumers,previouslyusing
the postal service, but now also utilize email, advertising circulars, brochures/catalogs,
postcards,andnewsletters.
Italsoincludesanyproductsthataresolddirectlytoconsumers,whichinthepersonal
care industry would include persontoperson brands such as Mary Kay and Avon;
infomercial brands, such as Proactiv and Sheer Cover; and brands that are sold on
homeshoppingchannels,suchasQVCandHSN.
Themainadvantageofdirectmarketingisthatbrandsusethismarketingtechniqueto
offer a personalized approach to their customers, thereby making the consumer feel
importantanduniquefromthemasses.
Brochures/catalogs are the ideal way to introduce a company and its collection of
products and services to potential customers. Marketers often make the cover of a
brochure/catalogattractive,withacatchycoverline,inordertoattractthecustomer
toreadthroughitratherthanjustignoreit.Theinsideofthefrontandthebackcover
generallyconsistsofthecompanysprofileandcontactinformation.Thebackpageof
thebrochureandcataloggenerallyfeaturesthebrandsbestsellers,thelatestlaunch,
oravaluedealinthecaseofcosmeticcompanies.Theinsidepagesofabrochureand
catalog typically features the complete collection of products and services offered by
the company. This specific channel of direct marketing is most popular with direct
marketerssuchasMaryKay,Alticor,andAvon.
Direct Response television (DRTV) is a popular direct marketing medium adopted by
cosmeticandtoiletrybrandsthatdoesnotfocusonthetraditionaladvertisingmedia.
DRTVhasbecomeaglobalphenomenon,withQVCandHSNbeingtheoutrightleaders.
For example, GuthyRenkers principal marketing activities involve the production of
infomercialsandhalfhourtelevisionprogramsthatmarketvariousbrands.
Insert media is another direct marketing medium adopted by beauty brands that
involvesinsertingmarketingmessagesaboutnewproductlaunches,events,coupons,
and samples in newspapers, magazines, and catalogs. As an example, the Mary Kay
LookBookcatalogcontainstwofoilwrappedsamplesofnewproducts.
Beautyretailersstillusecatalogsthatgomostlytoeitherchargeaccountcustomers,or
membersoftheirloyaltyprograms.Departmentstores,suchasLord&Taylor,Macys,
and Nordstrom, include cosmetic and beauty items as part of their regular catalog
mailings.SephoraregularlymailscatalogstomembersofitsBeautyInsiderprogram.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

385

386

MarketingActivity

Samplesarealsousedbybrandsas amediumtoattractconsumersto trytheirproducts,


generate curiosity about a product, and gauge the consumers reaction to a new product
launch.
Samplesaregivenoutbybeautybrandssothatcustomerscantrytheproductbefore
makingapurchase.
Samplinginformationisalsodistributedintheformofnewspaperandmagazineinserts.
Another method of distribution is by including samples with any other cosmetic or
toiletry products purchased. This is often applicable for both instore and online
purchases.
The use of social media, such as Facebook and Twitter, is gaining prominence as
channelstodisseminateinformationaboutproductsamplestoconsumers.
Samplingisoftenakeymarketingstrategyforpromotingbrandsinretailstores.Luxury
brandsespeciallyutilizesampling.
Blogsarealsobeingusedasachanneltoshareinformationaboutproductsamples.

Coupons are one of the most popular and common means of product promotions in the
cosmeticandtoiletryindustry,formassmarketproducts.
Couponsarenotonlyusedtoattractconsumersbuttostrengthenbrandloyalty,which
isrequiredtosustainsalesinthefaceoffiercecompetition.
Consumersusediscountcouponstotestnewproductsandforbrandcomparison.
Coupons were initially offered mainly through the mail and as inserts in weekend
newspaperscommonlyknownasfreestandinginserts(FSI).
However, with the constant evolution in the cosmetic and toiletry industry, coupons
are now available through various avenues, such as the brands website, a retailers
website,socialmediasites,andevenonmobilephones.
Luxurybrandsoftenrelyonpricepromotionaloffersinsteadofcoupons.Intheprestige
arena, giftwithpurchase (GWP) or purchase with purchase (PWP), along with
promotional offers of a free product with a purchase becomes the main price
promotional tool, and is an extremely important marketing method for promoting
luxuryproducts.
Afewmarketers,suchasProcter&Gamble,hostaweekendnewspapercouponinsert
several times a year, which includes coupons for several of its brands including Olay,
Pantene,andCrest.ThisweekendnewspaperinsertallowsProcter&Gambletooffer
extravaluetoitsconsumersandhelpgainadditionalexposureforitsbrands.
Coupons are increasingly offered through mobile phones to attract consumers,
especiallyyoungadults.
With the rapid advent of online purchasing, coupon codes are also published online,
whichthebuyerneedstoenterwhilemakingthepurchaseandconsumersareallowed
toenjoytherelatedbenefitfromthecouponcode.
In order to make the offer more attractive, buyers of beauty brands online are also
offeredfreeshippingoftheirproducts,especiallywhenacertainminimumamountis
met. For example, Este Lauder offers free shipping with beauty purchases over a
certain amount as an incentive to encourage purchase. However, at times, Este
Lauderoffersfreeshippingforallonlineorders,withnominimumamountrequired.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A86

MarketingActivity

TMEisonlyanapproximatemeasureofconsumeradvertisingcosts.
Itdoesnotincludecostsofinternaladvertisingdepartmentsoradagenciesfees,which
are often large, and charges for creative and production costs, which can also be
substantial.
As a partial offset to these costs, however, large advertisers can get substantial
quantity discounts that are not included in tabulations of media expenditures,
particularlyfortelevision.
Such discounts give large manufacturers a considerable advantage over smaller
competitors.
Discounts usually apply to yearly contracts for substantial purchases; for instance, a
standard 25% discount for television at nonprime time and a 12% discount for
magazines.
Smallerdiscountsaregivenforcontractsofshorterlengthorforlesserpurchases.

PROMOTIONS

Cosmeticandtoiletrycompaniesalsorelyonconsumerpromotionto:
Educatecustomersaboutnewproductlaunches
Encouragetrialsbyconsumers
Boostsalesforatemporaryperiod
Encourageupsellingorcrosssellingofproducts
Enhancecompetitivepositionduringpricewarperiods
Offerconsumersthevaluetheyareexpecting

Traditionalpromotionsinclude:
Coupons
Bandpackingoftwoproducts
Specialbonussizedpackages
Sampling
Trial/travelsizes
GWPorPWPpromotions

Other promotional vehicles include rebates and sweepstakes, especially for highvolume
commodity items like shampoos, deodorants and antiperspirants, personal cleansing
products,andtoothpastes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

387

388

MarketingActivity

Otherpromotionaleffortsattempttoboostconsumerawarenessandbrandimage.
Offering indirect discounts through free packs is a popular means of marketers to
promotesalesofbrandsthataredeclining.
Companiesemployinstorevisualaids,aimedatpromotingnewproductlaunchesand
toattractcustomersnearthepointofsale.
Specialeventsponsorshipsaredesignedtoboostbrandawarenessandarefrequently
supportedwithfreeproductsampledistributions.
Pointofpurchase displays and various other merchandising materials are also used
extensivelytoencourageimpulsivepurchasing.
Manymanufacturersofferatollfreetelephonenumberthatcanbeusedbyconsumers
tocallforinformation,productliterature,andsamples,ortoorderproducts.

Trade promotion support for cosmetics and toiletries is still driven by deal funding,
includingtypicaloffinvoicedealsandotherdiscountsandfinancialincentives.

Performancesupportforadvertisinganddisplayallowancesalsoremainssubstantial.

Further details on promotional efforts are provided in section four: The Products, and
sectionfive:MajorCompaniesofthisreport.
DetailsonTMEareprovidedinsectionseven:Advertising.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A88

OUTLOOK

GROWTHTRENDS

Thecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketprospersin2012duetoimprovingeconomicconditions,
technologicallyinnovativeproductintroductions,anincreaseinmediaexpenditure,aheavy
acquisitionactivity,andarisingdisposableincomeinthehandsofconsumers.
The improving economy has a desirable effect on the sales of the cosmetic and
toiletries industry. There is an increase in the disposable income available to
consumers; however, they are still mindful of their spending patterns due in part to
lingering unemployment. Highend consumers are less affected and continue to
purchase premium beauty products. This helps trade channels such as department
storesandspecialtystoresregistersalesgains.
Segments such as antiaging facial treatments continue to gain popularity among
consumers seeking to postpone or eliminate professional procedures like injected
fillersandcosmeticsurgery.
Technologicaladvancementisofimportanceinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryin
ordertoattracttheattentionoftheconsumersbyofferingthemnewandmoreresults
orientedproducts.
Mass marketers will continue to retain their leading position in the market with the
introduction of products that offer results similar to luxury products while being
availableatalowerpricepoint,asthemajorityofthepopulationshopsinmassoutlets.
Sales of natural products will continue to pick up as consumers increasingly opt for
naturalandorganicproducts.

Table338:CompoundAverageGrowthRateoftheCosmeticsandToiletriesMarket,
2007to2017
Million

CAGR,%

Year

Dollars

Packages

Dollars

2007

36,263

9,578.9

2012

40,372

9,887.5

2.1

0.6

2017

46,829

10,924.7

3.0

2.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Packages

390

Outlook

During the forecast period ending 2017, growth in the unit volume will grow slower than
dollarsalesgrowthwhichisgoingtobelargelybackedbythegrowthofproductsoffering
multiplebenefitsandavailableatpremiumprices.
Theluxury,specialty,andprofessionalchannelsareexpectedtohaveagrowthhigher
thanthemasschannelduringtheforecastperiod,resultinginhighervaluegrowthand
relativelylowervolumegrowth.

BASECASE(MOSTLIKELY)UNITANDDOLLARFORECASTSTO2017

Overallgrowth

Manufacturers sales in the cosmetics and toiletries market are forecast to advance to
$46.8billionby2017,increasingatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.0%.

Unitgrowth

Total unit volume in the cosmetics and toiletries market is projected to reach
10,924.7million packages by 2017, growing at a CAGR of 2.0% from 9,887.5million
packagesin2012.

Nineofthe26categoriesareexpectedtohaveunitgrowthhigherthantheaverage.

Table339:UnitGrowthForecastfortheNineFastestGrowing
Categories,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Nailpolishes

8.0

Suncareproducts

6.4

Skincareproductsformen

5.3

Eyemakeup

4.4

Facialtreatments

4.2

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

3.5

Shampoos

2.2

Facemakeup

2.0

Fragrancesforwomen

2.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A90

Outlook

Table340:UnitSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProductCategory,in
OrderofSize,2012and2017
Millionpackages
Productcategory

2012

CAGR,%

Personalcleansingproducts

1,663.0

1,797.0

1.6

Toothpastes

1,005.0

1,046.0

0.8

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

891.2

925.9

0.8

Shampoos

741.0

826.0

2.2

Facialtreatments

670.0

823.0

4.2

Eyemakeup

524.9

650.8

4.4

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

528.7

555.2

1.0

Handandbodylotions

514.2

552.0

1.4

Conditioners

443.0

480.0

1.6

Facemakeup

421.4

465.3

2.0

Toothbrushes

349.0

366.0

1.0

Nailpolishes

234.6

344.7

8.0

Suncareproducts

244.8

334.0

6.4

Lipsticksandlipglosses

237.5

256.0

1.5

Shavingproducts

238.3

253.0

1.2

Haircoloringproducts

225.0

230.0

0.4

Mouthwashes

192.0

203.0

1.1

Fragrancesforwomen

160.0

177.0

2.0

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

165.0

175.0

1.2

Ethnichaircareproducts

99.3

105.8

1.3

Fragrancesformen

99.9

104.0

0.8

Dentureproducts

88.0

89.0

0.2

Babycareproducts

82.6

86.0

0.8

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

33.2

39.5

3.5

Skincareproductsformen

18.9

24.5

5.3

Toothwhiteningproducts

17.0

16.0

(1.2)

9,887.5

10,924.7

2.0

Total

2017

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

391

392

Outlook

Table341:UnitSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesRankedby
ForecastRateofGrowth,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Nailpolishes

8.0

Suncareproducts

6.4

Skincareproductsformen

5.3

Eyemakeup

4.4

Facialtreatments

4.2

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

3.5

Shampoos

2.2

Facemakeup

2.0

Fragrancesforwomen

2.0

Personalcleansingproducts

1.6

Conditioners

1.6

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1.5

Handandbodylotions

1.4

Ethnichaircareproducts

1.3

Shavingproducts

1.2

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

1.2

Mouthwashes

1.1

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1.0

Toothbrushes

1.0

Toothpastes

0.8

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

0.8

Fragrancesformen

0.8

Babycareproducts

0.8

Haircoloringproducts

0.4

Dentureproducts

0.2

Toothwhiteningproducts

(1.2)

Total

2.0

The tooth whitening products category is the only category to witness a decline in unit
volumeduringtheforecastperiodwithanannualratedeclineof1.2%through2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A92

Outlook

Dollargrowth

Manufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesareprojectedtoreach$46,829millionby
2017,upataCAGRof3.0%from$40,372millionin2012.

Intotal,25ofthe26categoriesareexpectedtoincreaseindollarsalesthrough2017.
Nailpolishesandsuncareproductsareexpectedtoachievethehighestgrowthamong
allthecategoriesataCAGRof9.0%and7.1%,respectively,through2017.

TheU.S.economyisexpectedtoimproveoverthenextfiveyearstoexperiencemoderate
growth.Thiswillresultinthefollowing:
Consumersarelikelytoincreasetheirspendingonnewandinnovativeproductsthat
offermultifunctionalbenefitssuchassunprotection,antiaging,makeupeffects,and
acne reduction benefits. Consequently, the industry is also expected to have many
multicategoricalproducts.
Productsofferingprofessionalresultsathomewillcontinuetobeamainstayandare
expectedtogainattentionduringtheforecastperiod.Antiagingproductsarelikelyto
add in extra benefits including skin lightening, brightening complexions, evening out
skintones,andlighteningdarkspots.
Marketersareexpectedtointroducesimilarmultibeneficialproductsacrossalltrade
classestowidentheirportfolio.

Nailpolishisthefastestgrowingcategoryinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryin2012
andisexpectedtomaintainitsrhythmofstrongperformancethroughtheforecastperiod.
Thebroadselectionofnailshadesandtexturesisexpectedtoinciteconsumerstowear
andrepurchaseoftenasawayofselfexpression.
Other innovations that are likely to drive growth include newer versions of current
trendsthatincludetexturednails,magneticnailpolish,andglitternailpolish.
Innovations in formulas especially in the gel nail segment are also expected to drive
salesinthefuture.
Someconsumerswillcontinuetoremainsensibleabouttheamountofmoneyspenton
salonvisitsandwillcontinuetoseekoutwaystoobtainthesalonlookwhiledoingtheir
ownnails.
Hence,consumersarelikelytoincreasetheirspendingonretailproductstoattainthe
professionalresultsonceobtainedonlythroughsalons.
Gelbasednailpolishesandkitsareanticipatedtogrowasmoremarketerslaunchsuch
products.Thesepolishesandsystemscarryahigherpricepointandwillcontributeto
theoveralldollargrowthforthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

393

394

Outlook

Suncareproductsisforecasttobethesecondfastestgrowingcategoryduringthenextfive
years,growingataCAGRof7.1%.
Consumersapprehensionsofdevelopingskincancerasaresultoftoomuchexposure
tothesunwillensureincreasingdemandforsuncareproducts.
TheintroductionoftheFDAslongawaitedsunscreenmonographwillinducenewness
inthecategory.
Naturalandorganicformulationswillcontinuetogainattentioninthecategory,while
itwillremaindifficulttocreatetrulynaturalsunscreenproducts.
Thesuntanningsegmentisexpectedtocontinueitsdeclineduringtheforecastperiod.
The category is expected to witness an increase in the prices of the products due to
newandimprovedproductformulationsinaccordancewiththenewFDAregulations.
Theblurbetweentheskincareandsuncareproductsisexpectedtohaveadetrimental
effectonthesuncarecategorysgrowthduringtheforecastperiod.
Privatelabelproductswillcontinuetogrowthrough2017,butnotatthefastrateof
recentyears.

Skincareproductsformenwillprosperthrough2017.
Thecategoryhasstrongpotentialforbothvalueandvolumegrowthinthefuture.
As marketers continue to innovate and spread awareness about mens skin care
products,theproportionofmenbuyingtheseproductsislikelytoincreasegradually,
with male consumers feeling less awkward buying skin care products, as opposed to
theearlierpracticeofusingproductsoftheirfemalefamilymembers.
Thereisopportunityintheantiagingsegmentwithagrowingdemandfrommenaged
30yearsandolderforproductsofferingantiagingbenefits.
Productsformenofferingcosmeticbenefits,suchasconcealersandtintedmoisturizers,
already available in the market, will be another area for marketers to attract the
attentionofthemaleconsumers.
Although prestige marketers shall continue to hold most of the market share in the
category,marketshareformassbrandsareexpectedtogrowfasterthantheprestige
brandsduringtheforecastperiod.

FacialtreatmentsareforecasttogrowatahealthyCAGRof5.0%inthecomingfiveyears.
The emphasis on looking good and keeping aging at bay will continue during the
forecastperiod,eveniftheUnitedStatesentersperiodsofeconomicuncertainty.
The definition of antiaging will continue to evolve and will include a myriad of
attributesinadditiontowrinklereductionandfirming,suchasbrightening,luminosity,
andradiance.
Facialtreatmentproductswillbeusedbothasasubstitutetocosmeticproceduresand
asanadjuncttothem,withthecommongoaloflookingasyoungaspossible.
Innovation backed by science will continue to be the main impetus to growing this
productcategory.
The FDA is expected to be more involved in examining the claims of facial treatment
brands.
Morenaturalingredientsarelikelytobeusedinfacialtreatmentproductsduringthe
forecastperiod.
Luxuryfacialtreatmentproductsareexpectedtoexhibitthemostgrowthoverthenext
fiveyearsandareexpectedtobecomethelargesttradeclass.Moreconsumerswillbe
willingtotradeuptowhattheyperceiveasbetterproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A94

Outlook

Duringtheforecastperiod,salesofthetoothwhiteningproductscategoryareexpectedto
decline.
Thesalesforthecategoryareprojectedtodeclineatacompoundannualrateof0.5%.
The tooth whitening category growth will be limited by stiff competition from
whiteningtoothpastesandmouthwashes.Usageoftheseproducts,increasinglymulti
benefit, is more affordable and convenient than the purchase of a separate tooth
whiteningproduct.
Twoothercategoriesareexpectedtounderperformduringtheforecastperiodwitha
CAGR of less that 1.0%. These categories include hair coloring products and denture
products.

Table342:DollarSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProductCategory,in
theOrderofSize,2012and2017
Dollarsales
Productcategory

2012

2017

Facialtreatments

6,645

8,482

5.0

Personalcleansingproducts

4,026

4,424

1.9

Facemakeup

2,909

3,372

3.0

Eyemakeup

2,709

3,296

4.0

Fragrancesforwomen

2,717

3,231

3.5

Shampoos

2,620

3,050

3.1

Handandbodylotions

2,283

2,500

1.8

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2,040

2,160

1.1

Conditioners

1,653

1,870

2.5

Toothpastes

1,749

1,856

1.2

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

1,802

1.4

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,377

1,553

2.4

Suncareproducts

1,048

1,480

7.1

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

1,345

0.4

Fragrancesformen

1,101

1,244

2.5

Nailpolishes

662

1,019

9.0

Mouthwashes

799

856

1.4

Toothbrushes

741

802

1.6

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

374

410

1.9

Shavingproducts

373

402

1.5

Ethnichaircareproducts

340

371

1.8

Dentureproducts

318

322

0.3

Babycareproducts

288

303

1.0

Toothwhiteningproducts

271

264

(0.5)

Skincareproductsformen

169

220

5.4

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

163

195

3.7

40,372

46,829

3.0

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

CAGR,%

395

396

Outlook

Table343:DollarSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProduct
Category,RankedbyForecastRateofGrowth,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Nailpolishes

9.0

Suncareproducts

7.1

Skincareproductsformen

5.4

Facialtreatments

5.0

Eyemakeup

4.0

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

3.7

Fragrancesforwomen

3.5

Shampoos

3.1

Facemakeup

3.0

Conditioners

2.5

Fragrancesformen

2.5

Lipsticksandlipglosses

2.4

Personalcleansingproducts

1.9

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

1.9

Handandbodylotions

1.8

Ethnichaircareproducts

1.8

Toothbrushes

1.6

Shavingproducts

1.5

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1.4

Mouthwashes

1.4

Toothpastes

1.2

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

1.1

Babycareproducts

1.0

Haircoloringproducts

0.4

Dentureproducts

0.3

Toothwhiteningproducts

(0.5)

Total

3.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A96

KLINESFUTUREVIEWSCENARIOFORECASTINGMODELFORTHEU.S.
COSMETICSANDTOILETRIESMARKET

METHODOLOGY

Three different sales scenarios reflecting total market growth through 2017 have been
developedbasedonKline&CompanysFutureViewForecastingMethodology.
Thethreegrowthscenariosbasecase,optimisticcase,andpessimisticcaseforecast
sales and growth rates for each product category and the entire market annually
through2017.

FutureViewForecastingMethodologycombinestheanalysisofindustryrelatedfactorsand
macroeconomicfactorstoarriveatthethreeforecastscenarios.
At the industry level, the three forecasts incorporate microeconomic analysis of
industrydevelopments,interviewswithindustryexperts,andKlinesexpertjudgment.
Industrydevelopmentsassessedincludetechnologicalchanges,productintroductions,
marketingandadvertisingexpenses,andchangesinconsumertastesandpreferences.
ThemacroeconomicanalysistakesintoaccounttheroleoffactorssuchasGDP,energy
pricesanddisposablepersonalincomesinshapingfuturecosmeticsandtoiletriessales.

INDUSTRYLEVELFACTORS

Manyoftheluxuryconsumershavetradedup,backtotheluxurybrands,whileacertain
segmentstillremainsskepticaloftheeconomicsituation.
Thissegmentofthepopulationplaysitsafebystickingtomassproducts,oratthemost
upgradingtotheuseofmasstigebrandsuntiltheeconomyrecoverscompletely.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

398

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

Underthebestcasescenario,thecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketwouldreturntoahealthy
growth.
Marketersaregoingtocontinuetoemphasizeontechnologicaladvancementsinorder
todrawconsumersattentionandenticethemtospendmoremoney.
Marketers are expected to increase their advertising budget significantly in the years
that follow to support the introduction of new products, and positively affect sales
growthinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Social media will continue to be a prominent medium adopted by marketers to
communicatewithconsumers.Facebook,Twitter,andYouTubeareusedbyalmostall
theleadingmarketerstoestablishaninstantconnectionwiththeconsumers,especially
the young audience. This young audience matures and spends more on brands they
follow.
Ecommerce will gain momentum and is likely to be a big growth driver for the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryduetotheeaseofpurchaseofproducts.
Thenaturalmovementwillcontinuetobeabiggrowthdriverasconsumersrealizethe
disadvantagesofusingharshchemicalsusedinproductsandtheneedformaintaining
ahealthylifestyle.

Accordingtotheworstcasescenario,thenegativefactorsthatinfluencethemarketduring
therecessionof2009and2010willgainstrengthduringtheforecastperiod.
Consumersbecomevalueconsciousandoptforfamilysizedeconomicalproducts,and
buyonlynecessities.Also,tocutcoststheywoulduseonlyoneproductperfunction
insteadofusingdifferentbrandedproductsservingthesamepurpose.
The luxury trade class will decline as consumers look to cut corners. Consumers will
tradedowntousingmassbrandedproducts,therebycreatingalowersalesvolumefor
luxury brands sold primarily through departmental stores. The emergence of the
masstige segment further puts pressure on the department stores, but the dollar
valueofsuchproductslowersasthemarketisfloodedwiththem.
Privatelabelproductswillgainsalesduetotheiravailabilityatpricepointlowerthan
thatofferedbynationalbrands.
Marketerswouldreducetheiradvertisingexpenses,whichmightresultinsalesdecline
forafewmarketers.
MarketerswillbelesslikelytoinnovateastheR&Dexpendituredeclines,resultingin
lessernewproductlaunchesperyear.
Mature categories such as personal cleansing products, hand and body lotions,
antiperspirants and deodorants, denture products, and baby care categories will
experiencedifficultieswithdownwardpricepressures.

Thesmallercompanieswillcontinuetolacktheadvertisingbudgetandfinancialbackingto
competedirectlywiththelargemarketers,suchasProcter&Gamble,LOral,andUnilever,
therebyhintingataclosure,merger,orbeingopenforacquisition.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A98

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

MACROECONOMICFACTORS

Underthebestcasescenario,theeconomyrecuperatesfasterthantheexpectedtimeframe.
The global economy stabilizes and helps strengthen the U.S. economy without any
externalpressure.
Another pivotal factor that will contribute to the economic recovery is the
manufacturingindustry,whichwillhelpcombattheproblemofrecession.
Consumers will gain confidence in spending and further help improve the economy.
Luxury consumers, who had traded down during unfortunate times, will go back to
purchasingluxuryproductswithapremiumprice.
The initiatives taken by the federal government, including various fiscal stimulus
packages,willstrengthentheeconomicactivity.

The worst case scenario expects the economy is most likely to remain vulnerable to the
economicdownturn.
Theglobaleconomyislikelytobeaffectedandslowdownduetothedebtcrisisinthe
Europeancountries.
ThereisapossibilityoftheU.S.economyplungingintorecessionagain,iftheeconomy
undergoesanymajorsetbacks.
The continued situation around unemployment will have a detrimental effect on the
consumersconfidencetherebylimitingtheirdesiretospend.
Consumers will minimize their discretionary spending, as they experience a loss of
disposablepersonalincome.
The real estate sector would waver again, and more foreclosures and lower home
valueswillplungethenationintoadelayedrecovery.
Major marketers limit their spending across the board, and mergers and acquisitions
activitycomestoagradualhalt.

OVERALLCOSMETICSANDTOILETRIESINDUSTRY

Undertheoptimisticscenario,themarketforcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesis
projected to grow at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 4.4% to reach
$49,976millionin2017.

The pessimistic scenario forecasts industry sales to reach $40,880million in 2017, up at a


CAGRof0.3%from$40,372millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

399

3100

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

Figure341:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforCosmeticsandToiletriesIndustrySalesintheUnitedStates,2012
to2017
$Million
60,000
Bestcase,CAGR,4.4%

50,000

Basecase,CAGR,3.0%

40,000

Worstcase,CAGR,0.3%

30,000
20,000
10,000
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$40,372Million

FRAGRANCES

Sales in the fragrances product class are projected to grow at a CAGR of 4.2% under the
optimisticscenario,reaching$4,700millionin2017.

Thepessimisticscenarioprojectsanegativeannualrateof0.7%forfragrancesduringthe
forecastperiod.
Saleswilldeclineto$3,690millionin2017,downfrom$3,818millionin2012.

Figure342:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforFragranceSalesintheUnitedStates,2012to2017
$Million
5,000
Bestcase,CAGR,4.2%

4,500

Basecase,CAGR,3.2%

4,000

Worstcase,CAGR,(0.7)%

3,500
3,000
2,500
2,000
1,500
1,000
500
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$3,818Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A100

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

HAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Hair care products are projected to grow at a healthy CAGR of 3.8% during the forecast
periodundertheoptimisticscenario.
Saleswillgrowfrom$7,610millionin2012to$9,150millionin2017.

Thepessimisticscenarioprojectssalestototal$7,730millionataCAGR0.3%.

Figure343:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforHairCareProductSalesintheUnitedStates,2012to2017
$Million
10,000
Bestcase,CAGR,3.8%

9,000
8,000

Basecase,CAGR,2.1%

7,000

Worstcase,CAGR,0.3%

6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$7,610Million

MAKEUPPRODUCTS

MakeupproductsareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof5.8%duringtheforecastperiodunder
theoptimisticscenario.
Saleswillgrowfrom$7,657millionin2012to$10,128millionin2017.

Thepessimisticscenarioprojectssalestototal$7,780millionataCAGRof0.3%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

3101

3102

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

Figure344:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforMakeupProductSalesintheUnitedStates,2012to2017
$Million
12,000
Bestcase,CAGR,5.8%

10,000
Basecase,CAGR,3.8%

8,000

Worstcase,CAGR,0.3%

6,000
4,000
2,000
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$7,657Million

ORALCAREPRODUCTS

Undertheoptimisticscenario,oralcaresalesareprojectedtoincreaseataCAGRof2.7%to
reach$4,856millionin2017,upfrom$4,252millionin2012.

Underthepessimisticscenario,salesintheoralcareproductclasswillreach$4,230million
in2017atanegativeannualrateof0.1%from$4,252millionin2012.

Figure345:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforOralCareProductSalesintheUnitedStates,2012to2017
$Million
6,000
Bestcase,CAGR,2.7%

5,000

Basecase,CAGR,1.2%

4,000
Worstcase,CAGR,(0.1)%

3,000
2,000
1,000
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$4,252Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A102

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

SKINCAREPRODUCTS

Under the optimistic scenario, sales of skin care products are projected to advance at a
CAGRof5.6%toreach$13,680millionby2017.

ThepessimisticscenarioforecastssalestoadvanceataCAGRof1.0%fortheproductclass
toreach$10,950millionby2017.

Figure346:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforSkinCareProductSalesintheUnitedStates,2012to2017
$Million
16,000
Bestcase,CAGR,5.6%

14,000
Basecase,CAGR,4.5%

12,000
Worstcase,CAGR,1.0%

10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
0
2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

NOTE:Currentsales=$10,433Million

OTHERTOILETRIES

Intheoptimisticscenario,othertoiletriesareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof2.5%toreach
$7,462millionin2017.

Underthepessimisticscenario,salesofothertoiletriesareexpectedtodeclineanannual
rateof0.3%toreach$6,500millionin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

3103

3104

KlinesFutureViewScenarioForecastingModel

Figure347:FutureViewScenarioForecastsforOtherToiletryProductSalesintheUnitedStates,2011to2016
$Million
7,600
Bestcase,CAGR,2.5%

7,400
7,200

Basecase,CAGR,1.7%

7,000
6,800
6,600

Worstcase,CAGR,(0.3%)

6,400
6,200
6,000
5,800
5,600
2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

NOTE:Currentsales=$6,602Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A104

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

TheProducts

SectionFour

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

TheProducts

SectionFourof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJune1,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employees of subscribing companies and their subsidiaries, as defined above, until
June1,2016. Similarly, all sections of the survey are so restricted for three years from their
datesofissue.Failuretopreventunauthorizeddisclosurebeforethesedateswillresultinlegal
actionagainstthesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

4A.INTRODUCTION............................................................................................................4A1
Reportcontents.............................................................................................................4A1
Restatedsalesestimates................................................................................................4A2
Productcategorydescriptions.......................................................................................4A3
Fragrances......................................................................................................................4A3
Haircareproducts..........................................................................................................4A4
Makeup..........................................................................................................................4A7
Oralcareproducts.........................................................................................................4A9
Skincareproducts........................................................................................................4A11
Othertoiletries.............................................................................................................4A13

4B.THEMARKET.................................................................................................................4B1
Totalsales......................................................................................................................4B1
Growth...........................................................................................................................4B1

4C.FRAGRANCES................................................................................................................4C1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4C1
Manufacturerssales......................................................................................................4C1
Retailsales.....................................................................................................................4C3
Competition...................................................................................................................4C3
Retaildistribution..........................................................................................................4C4
Outlook..........................................................................................................................4C5
FragrancesforMen.......................................................................................................4C9
Categoryperformance...................................................................................................4C9
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4C15
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4C19
Competition.................................................................................................................4C19
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4C22
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4C23
Outlook........................................................................................................................4C25
FragrancesforWomen................................................................................................4C27
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4C27
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4C34
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4C40
Competition.................................................................................................................4C41
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4C44
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4C45
Outlook........................................................................................................................4C48

REPRODUCTION ORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4D.HAIRCAREPRODUCTS..................................................................................................4D1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4D1
Manufacturerssales......................................................................................................4D1
Retailsales.....................................................................................................................4D2
Competition...................................................................................................................4D3
Retaildistribution..........................................................................................................4D6
Outlook..........................................................................................................................4D7
Conditioners...............................................................................................................4D11
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4D11
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4D14
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4D18
Competition.................................................................................................................4D19
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4D22
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4D22
Outlook........................................................................................................................4D24
EthnicHairCareProducts............................................................................................4D27
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4D27
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4D31
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4D34
Competition.................................................................................................................4D35
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4D37
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4D38
Outlook........................................................................................................................4D39
HairColoringProducts................................................................................................4D41
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4D41
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4D43
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4D46
Competition.................................................................................................................4D47
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4D49
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4D50
Outlook........................................................................................................................4D51
HairStylingProductsandSprays.................................................................................4D55
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4D55
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4D58
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4D60
Competition.................................................................................................................4D62
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4D64
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4D64
Outlook........................................................................................................................4D66

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4D.HAIRCAREPRODUCTS(Continued)
Shampoos...................................................................................................................4D69
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4D69
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4D72
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4D77
Competition.................................................................................................................4D77
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4D81
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4D82
Outlook........................................................................................................................4D83

4E.MAKEUP.......................................................................................................................4E1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4E1
Manufacturerssales......................................................................................................4E1
Retailsales.....................................................................................................................4E3
Competition...................................................................................................................4E3
Retaildistribution..........................................................................................................4E7
Promotion......................................................................................................................4E8
Outlook........................................................................................................................4E10
EyeMakeup................................................................................................................4E13
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4E13
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4E16
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4E19
Competition.................................................................................................................4E20
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4E22
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4E23
Outlook........................................................................................................................4E25
FaceMakeup..............................................................................................................4E27
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4E27
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4E30
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4E32
Competition.................................................................................................................4E32
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4E36
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4E36
Outlook........................................................................................................................4E38

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4E.MAKEUP(Continued)
NailPolishes...............................................................................................................4E55
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4E55
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4E57
Competition.................................................................................................................4E59
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4E61
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4E61
Outlook........................................................................................................................4E63

4F.ORALCAREPRODUCTS..................................................................................................4F1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4F1
Manufacturerssales......................................................................................................4F1
Retailsales.....................................................................................................................4F2
Competition...................................................................................................................4F3
Retaildistribution..........................................................................................................4F5
Outlook..........................................................................................................................4F6
DentureProducts.........................................................................................................4F11
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F11
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F12
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4F14
Competition.................................................................................................................4F15
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F17
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F17
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F18
LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments...............................................................................4F21
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F21
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F22
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4F24
Competition.................................................................................................................4F25
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F27
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F28
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F29
Mouthwashes..............................................................................................................4F31
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F31
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F32
Competition.................................................................................................................4F34
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F35
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F36
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F37

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4F.ORALCAREPRODUCTS(Continued)
Toothbrushes...............................................................................................................4F39
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F39
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F40
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4F42
Competition.................................................................................................................4F43
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F45
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F45
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F46
Toothpastes.................................................................................................................4F49
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F49
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F50
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4F53
Competition.................................................................................................................4F55
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F57
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F57
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F59
ToothWhiteningProducts...........................................................................................4F63
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4F63
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4F64
Competition.................................................................................................................4F66
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4F67
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4F68
Outlook........................................................................................................................4F69

4G.SKINCAREPRODUCTS..................................................................................................4G1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4G1
Manufacturerssales......................................................................................................4G1
Retailsales.....................................................................................................................4G3
Competition...................................................................................................................4G3
Retaildistribution..........................................................................................................4G7
Outlook..........................................................................................................................4G7

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4G.SKINCAREPRODUCTS(Continued)
BabyCareProducts.....................................................................................................4G11
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4G11
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4G13
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4G16
Competition.................................................................................................................4G18
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4G20
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4G20
Outlook........................................................................................................................4G21
FacialTreatments.......................................................................................................4G23
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4G23
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4G28
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4G35
Competition.................................................................................................................4G37
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4G44
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4G44
Outlook........................................................................................................................4G48
HandandBodyLotions...............................................................................................4G53
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4G53
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4G56
Competition.................................................................................................................4G60
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4G65
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4G65
Outlook........................................................................................................................4G69
SkinCareProductsforMen.........................................................................................4G73
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4G73
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4G74
Competition.................................................................................................................4G78
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4G80
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4G80
Outlook........................................................................................................................4G82
SunCareProducts.......................................................................................................4G85
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4G85
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4G87
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4G94
Competition.................................................................................................................4G99
Privatelabel..............................................................................................................4G103
Retaildistribution.....................................................................................................4G103
Marketingactivity.....................................................................................................4G104
Outlook.....................................................................................................................4G107

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4H.OTHERTOILETRIES........................................................................................................4H1
Introduction...................................................................................................................4H1
ManufacturersSales.....................................................................................................4H1
RetailSales.....................................................................................................................4H3
Competition...................................................................................................................4H3
RetailDistribution..........................................................................................................4H9
Outlook..........................................................................................................................4H9
DeodorantsandAntiperspirants.................................................................................4H13
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4H13
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4H15
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4H19
Competition.................................................................................................................4H20
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4H24
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4H25
Outlook........................................................................................................................4H28
Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches..............................................................................4H31
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4H31
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4H32
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4H36
Competition.................................................................................................................4H37
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4H39
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4H40
Outlook........................................................................................................................4H42
PersonalCleansingProducts.......................................................................................4H45
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4H45
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4H49
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4H56
Competition.................................................................................................................4H67
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4H71
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4H72
Outlook........................................................................................................................4H74

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

4H.OTHERTOILETRIES(Continued)
ShavingProducts........................................................................................................4H77
Categoryperformance.................................................................................................4H77
Categorydevelopment................................................................................................4H79
Categorysegmentation................................................................................................4H81
Competition.................................................................................................................4H84
Retaildistribution........................................................................................................4H87
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................4H87
Outlook........................................................................................................................4H89

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

4A.INTRODUCTION

REPORTCONTENTS

The Products section presents market profiles of 26 major cosmetic and toiletry categories.
These analyses summarize important market activity for each category in a brief, concise
fashion.Datapresentedareestimatesofaccuracylevelsthataresatisfactoryforscreeningand
planningpurposes.Therefore,whenmorepreciseinformationisrequired,asinthedecisionto
launch a new product or brand, more detailed studiesthose specifically designed for the
particularcaseshouldbeundertaken.

Productcategoriesaregroupedintosixmajorproductclassesfragrances,haircareproducts,
makeup products, oral care products, skin care products, and other toiletriesand are listed
alphabetically within each product class. Each category of the 2012 report contains the
followinginformation:

Category performance. Reports the categorys sales performance at the manufacturer,


retail,andunitlevels.
Categorydevelopment.Asummaryofkeytrends,developments,andnewproductactivities
thataffectedthecategory.
Categorysegmentation.Whereapplicable,ananalysisofthecompanyssalessegmentedby
tradeclass,producttype,and/orproductform.
Competition.Theapproximatebreakdownofmanufacturerssalesorbrandsharesthrough
consumeroutletsindollarsbybrandandrelateddiscussionofperformanceduringtheyear.
Includesprivatelabelactivity.
Retail distribution. The approximate percentages of dollar sales sold by major types of
outlets.
Marketing activity. A description of various promotional vehicles employed by major
marketers.Traceablemediaexpenditures(TME)arepresentedinChapter7ofthisstudy.
Outlook.AfiveyearforecastofmanufacturerssalesofthecategorythroughU.S.consumer
outlets, estimated on the same basis as the market data for the base year. Forecasts are
made in units and in constant dollars. The forecasts are based on our interviews with
suppliersinthemarket,pastgrowthpatterns,trendsinthemarket,thelikelihoodofnew
productintroductions,andchangesinpopulation,disposableincome,andconsumertastes,
amongotherfactors.

Percentagetotalsoncertaintablesmaynotalwaysaddduetorounding.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Introduction

RESTATEDSALESESTIMATES

Certainproductcategoryandbrandsalesestimatesinthiseditionofthereportreflectvalues
thathavebeenrevisedorrestatedfromthepreviousedition.Theserestatementsarearesult
ofadditionaltimedevotedtothecompleteandaccurateresearchingofsalesestimatesandthe
inclusionofotherdistributionchannelswithbroaderproductrepresentation.Theultimategoal
is to quantify the cosmetics and toiletries industry in an accurate, complete, and logical
manner,capturingallU.S.consumerpurchases.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Introduction

PRODUCTCATEGORYDESCRIPTIONS

FRAGRANCES

Fragrancesformen

Therearemanyformsofliquidfragranceproductsformen:
Eau de toilettes are diluted alcoholic solutions of perfumes, and eau de parfums
containfragrancesinmoreconcentratedforms.
Colognes contain more concentrated solutions of essential oils than aftershaves and
thereforeleavealongerlastingfragrance.Theyareusedtofreshentheskinandimpart
amasculinescent,frequentlyaftershavingorshowering.
Aftershaves, available in a variety of products, are lower in fragrance concentration
thancolognes.Aftershavesarebasicallyfragranceproductsthatalsosootheandheal
razornicksandconditionandinvigoratetheskinaftershaving.Productsareavailable
asliquids,lotions,andgels.

Ancillaryproductsareusuallyfeaturedaslineextensionsoftheliquidfragranceandinclude
fragrancedsoaps,deodorantsandantiperspirantsscentedwithabrandedmensfragrance,
fragrancedtalcumpowders,skincareproducts,andhaircareproducts.

ToiletryproductsfrommasstoiletrybrandssuchasOldSpice,GilletteSeries,andBrutare
notcoveredinthisanalysis.
Salesforliquidfragranceproductsforthesebrandsareincludedhere.

Bodysprays,suchasAxe,arenotincludedinthisanalysis.
Thesebrandsarecoveredinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory.

Fragrancesforwomen

Womens fragrance products include perfumes, toilet waters, colognes, deocolognes, and
bodysplashes.
Perfumescontainfragrancesinrelativelyconcentratedforms.
Toiletwatersaredilutedalcoholicsolutionsofperfumes.
Colognes are similar to toilet waters but historically contain less fragrance; however,
many of todays colognes are concentrated and contain more perfume oil than toilet
watersdo.
Deocolognes are low in perfume concentration and are applied through an aerosol
spray.
Bodysplashesandmistsarethelowestinfragranceconcentration.
Solids are available in pressed powder or soft solid form and typically come in
compacts,pots,orsticks.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A3

4A4

Introduction

Ancillaryproductssuchasdustingpowders,bodylotions,andbathadditives,whicharepart
ofafragranceline,arecoveredinthisprofileaswellasintheirrespectivecategoriesinthis
report.

Unisexfragrances,suchasCKOne,arecoveredinthiscategory.

HAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Allhaircareproductsalesreportedareforathomeuseonly.
Forprofessionaluse(backbarsales),refertoKlinesSalonHairCarereportseries.

Conditioners

Conditioners are used to moisturize and treat the hair and are generally available in a
varietyofformulasdesignedfornormal,dry,oily,andothertypesofhair.
Formulasmayalsobedesignedforhairtextureorendresult,suchascurly,straight,or
volumizing.
Morerecently,productsarebeingintroducedtoprovideotherbenefits,suchascolor
protectionorshineenhancement.

Mostconditionersareinstantproductsthatareappliedtothehairafterwashingandare
leftonthehairforonetothreeminutesbeforerinsing.

Alsoincludedaretherapeuticconditioners,whichareformulatedtoprovidemoreintensive
treatmenttothehair.
Suchproductsarealsooftencalledconditioningtreatmentsordeepconditioners.
Productsareoftenusedtotreathairthatisdamageproneorexcessivelydry.
Therapeutic or deep conditioning products are typically left on the hair for 5 to 20
minutesbeforerinsing.
Someproductsrequirenorinsing.
Somedeepconditioningproductsareavailableinsingleusepackets.

Inadditiontosalesgeneratedbymassbrands,ourcategorydefinitionandmarketsizedata
include:
SalonbrandssuchasMatrix(LOral);theseproductsderivethemajorityoftheirsales
from salons, although some volume is also generated from sales in mass outlets and
throughtheInternet.
Minor sales of conditioners also come from direct sales companies such as Avon,
prestigecompaniessuchasEsteLauder,andspecialtymarketerssuchasBath&Body
Works(LimitedBrands).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Introduction

Combination products that contain both shampoo and conditioner are included in the
shampooscategory.

Ethnichaircareproducts

Ethnic hair care products are specially designed to be effective for AfricanAmerican hair;
thefivemaintypesaredescribedbelow.

Relaxerkits(alsocalledperms)aredesignedtoremovecurlfromthehair,eithertotallyor
partially.

Styling aids serve a variety of functions and include products designed to counteract the
drynessproducedfromarelaxer.
Theseproductsholdthehairinplace,aswellaslubricatethescalp,preventdamage,
conditionandmoisturizethehair,andalloweasierstyling.
Suchproductsincludepressingaids,settinglotions,andhairtonics,aswellasspritzes,
gels,andmoussesthatarespeciallyformulatedforethnichair.

Dresses and lotions are typically petrolatumbased and are designed to add a wavy
appearancetothehairorholditinaparticularstyle.
Productsincludehairdressingconditioners,pomades,andtemporarywaveproducts.
Thissegmentincludesproductsspeciallyformulatedformensgrooming.

Curlmaintenanceproductsenhanceormaintainthecurlproducedbyacurlingproduct.
These products hold the hair in place as wellas lubricate the scalp, prevent damage,
andconditionandmoisturizethehair.
Such products include curl moisturizers, curl activators and restorers, combout
conditioners,curlmoisturizingsprays,andoilsheens.

Curl/wave kits are designed to add curl and body to the hair, help it set better and hold
longer.

Sales of other consumer products positioned specifically for ethnic consumers, such as
shampoos,conditioners,andhaircolorants,arealsoincludedinthiscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A5

4A6

Introduction

Haircoloringproducts

Haircoloringproductsaredesignedtocolorhair,eithertemporarilyorpermanently.There
arebasicallyfivetypesofhaircoloringproducts:
Permanentdyesprovidelongtermcolortohairandlastuntilnewhairgrowsout.
Semipermanent dyes highlight naturally colored hair or color gray hair without
bleachingaction.Theyaretypicallyappliedasshampooandremainonthehairthrough
severalwashings.
Permanentdemipermanentdyesprovideuptosixweeksofsheerhaircolortoblend
away gray hair without ammonia and without changing the natural color of the hair.
Productisleftinthehairforapproximatelyfiveminutes.
Special effects include lighteners, frosting products, and highlighting kits that are
usuallyappliedtoselectstrandsofhair.
Temporary colorants include rinses, shampoos, mousses, and gels that produce a
cosmetic change in the shade of hair and can be easily removed in one or more
shampoos.Theseproductsdonotpenetratethehairshaftandarenotasharmfulas
othercoloringproducts.

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Thehairstylingproductscategorycoversavarietyofproductsforcontrollingandenhancing
theappearanceofbothmensandwomenshair,includingthefollowing:
Styling gels are used to style and hold hair in place. Gels are applied after hair is
washedandareleftonthehairwhileitisbeingsetorstyled.
Stylingmoussesperformthesamefunctionasgelsbutalsoprovidebodytothehair.
Productsareavailableasaerosolfoamsandareappliedtoeitherwetordryhair.
Spritzesandotherheavystylingspraysarehighlevelresinfixatives,typicallyappliedto
either wet or damp hair to aid in the styling or sculpting of the hair. Such products
produce greater hold and stiffness and generally result in a less natural look than
traditionalaerosolhairsprays.
Stylinglotionsarewaterorwater/alcoholliquid,gellikeformulasavailableinbottlesor
tubes. A glaze is a variety of lotion that usually imparts more shine and hold than a
lotion.
Hair volumizers and thickeners give hair volume and an overall thicker, fuller
appearance.
Treatmentsimprovethehairsoverallmanageability.Productusagenormallyrequires
anextrastepinadditiontoroutinecleansingandconditioningofhair.Usageofthese
products has proliferated recently to include generaltreatment products as well as
onesthataregearedtowardspecifichairtypes,suchasdamaged,fine,orcolortreated
hair.
Retexturizingproductsmakecoarseorfrizzyhairsmoothand,insomecases,straight.
Shine enhancers are mists or serums that add shine to hair. Many of these products
alsocontainsunprotectioningredients.
Mens grooming products help men maintain a certain hairstyle. These products are
typicallyformulatedastonicsandcreams.
Stylingproductsinotherforms,suchaspomades,putty,waxes,sticks,andpastes,are
also included in this category. These product forms generally provide control, shine,
andareusedfrequentlyfortexturedeffects.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

Introduction

Hairspraysareusuallyappliedafterstylingthehairtohelpholditinplace.
Sprays are available in varying degrees of holding power, in scented or unscented
formulations,andinaerosolorpumpcontainers.

Shampoos

Shampoosareusedtocleansethehairandscalpandareavailableinavarietyofformulas.
Someshampoosaredesignedtoworkbestonnormal,dry,oroilyhair.
Others are developed for certain hair colors such as blonde, brunette or redhead, to
helpprotectandenhancecolor.
Antidandruffformulationshelpcontrolflakyscalp.
Someproductsmaycontainconditionersorshineagentsandmayalsobecalledtwo
inoneorthreeinoneproducts.
Childrensproductsareespeciallygentle.

MAKEUP

Eyemakeup

Eyemakeupconsistsofthefollowingproducts:
Eyeshadow,whichisusedontheeyelidorundertheeyebrowtogivetheappearance
of a shadow, is available in such forms of sticks, cakes, liquids, pencils, or brushons,
andinavarietyofcolorsandattributes.
Mascara is used on eyelashes to darken, color, and/or thicken. Mascaras that are
colorlessorsheertintedarealsoincluded.
Otherproductsincludeeyebrowproducts,whichareusedtodarkenandadddefinition
to eyebrows; eyeliners, which are used to line or darken the eyelid; and eye lining
pencils,whichareusedtoaddcoloraboveand/orbelowtheeyelid.

Productssuchasartificialeyelashes,tweezers,andotherimplementsarenotincluded.
Eyemakeupremoversarecoveredinthemiscellaneousproductscategory.

Facemakeup

Facemakeupisappliedtothefacetocreatesmoothandpolishedlook.
Products covered in this section are makeup bases, face powders, blushers, and
concealers.
Makeup bases or foundations are applied to the face before other makeup products
such as powders and blushers. Twoinone products that can be applied dry like a
powder or wet like a base are also included in this category. Bases are available in
different textural finishes including lotions, creams, cakes, gels, aerosols, sticks, or
mousses, and in medicated or hypoallergenic formulations. Some products like
concealersmorethoroughlycoverskinimperfections.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A7

4A8

Introduction

Facepowdersareformulatedtolightlycoverthefaceorothermakeuptoimpartsubtle
color, provide an even appearance, and help control shine and oil. Products are
traditionallyavailableinpressedcakeorloosepowderforms.
Blushers are applied to the face to add color, usually after a concealer and makeup
base has been applied. Products are available in several forms, the most common of
whichisbrushonpowder.Otherformsincludecream,gel,liquid,stick,pencil,bronzer,
andmousse.
Coversticksandconcealersarealsoincludedinthiscategory.
Concealersformulatedtotreatskinrelatedproblemsarenotcoveredinthissection.

Lipsticksandlipglosses

Lipsticksandlipglossescolor,moisturize,addshine,protectthelips,andcanalsoalterthe
apparentshapeofthelips.
Lipsticks are soft solids that are most typically applied in stick form but are also
availableincompactsandlargepencils.
Lip glosses, which range from liquids to very soft solids, are sold in small jars, pots,
compacts,tubes,androlloncontainers.
Liplinersaretypicallyusedtooutlinethelipstogivethemgreaterdefinition.

Lipbalmsandjelliesareanalyzedseparatelyaspartoftheoralcareproductsclass.

Nailpolishes

Nailpolishesincludethreesubcategories:
Enamels, which gives color and gloss to the fingernails and strengthen them against
breaking.Productscomeinvariousshadesandcolors.
Basecoats,whichareapplieddirectlyonthenailbeforeenamel.Ridgefillersareatype
ofbasecoatthatisspeciallydesignedtoensurethatthenailsurfaceiscoatedevenly.
Topcoats,whichareappliedafterpolishing,tosealtheenamelandprovideprotection
againstchipping.
Multifunctionalproductswhichincorporatealloftheabovebenefitsarealsoincluded.

Topcoatsandbasecoatsmaybeusedalonebutaremorecommonlyusedinadditiontonail
enamel.
Some clear coats are positioned as threeinone coats for use before and after nail
polish,orevenalone.

Nail hardeners are products specifically formulated to provide added durability. Nail
hardenersthatcontaincolorandthosethatarepositionedasbasecoatsareincludedinthe
nailpolishescategory.

Thiscategorydoesnotincludeartificialnails,nailtreatments,nailpolishremovers,orany
nailcareimplements.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

Introduction

ORALCAREPRODUCTS

Dentureproducts

Cleansers are available in tablet, cream, gel, powder, and crystal forms and are used to
removefoodanddebrisfromdentures.

Adhesivesareavailableascreams,powders,liquids,andstripsandaredesignedtosecure
denturesinplace.

Denturelinersandcushionsarenotincludedaspartofthisanalysis.

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Lipbalmsprotectthelipsagainstchappingduringcoldweatheranddryinginwarmweather.
Products are available in natural, fruit, and other flavors, and with such benefits as
sunscreenandaddedvitamins.
LipbalmsmarketedbysuchsuncarebrandsasBananaBoatrepresentminorsalesand
areincludedintheSunCareProductssectionofthisreport.
Lip balm brands that contain SPF such as ChapStick and Blistex are included in this
category.

Lipjelliesalsopreventchappinganddryingandaresimplyamoreconvenientlypackaged
methodofapplyingpetroleumjellytothelips.
Traditionalpetroleumjelly,whichisnotspecificallypackagedasalipcareproduct,is
not included in this category but is profiled in the miscellaneous products section of
thisreport.

Liptreatmentsconditionlips,smoothmouthlines,controlslipsticksmudgingandbleeding,
andgivelipsafullerappearance.Thisincludeslipplumpers.

Lip balm products that are marketed exclusively as ultratherapeutic products, such as
CamphoPhenique,Herpecin,andTanac,arenotcoveredinthisreportbutarediscussedin
NonprescriptionDrugsUSA.

Products where color is the primary benefit are covered in the lipsticks and lip glosses
categoryofthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A9

4A10

Introduction

Mouthwashes

Mouthwashes,gargles,andrinsesareliquidproductsthatareusedtocleansethemouth,
fortifyteeth,andfreshenbreath.
In some cases, mouthwashes are also used to help treat or prevent sore throats and
coldsaswellascavities,plaque,andgumdisorders.
Mouthwashes, gargles, and rinses are generally positioned as breathfreshening,
antibacterial,orantiplaque,andsomearealsofluoridetreatments.
Breathfreshenerssuchassprays,arenotcoveredinthisreport.

Toothbrushes

Toothbrushesareusedtoapplytoothpastes,gels,anddentalcreamsforcleaning,polishing,
andwhiteningteeth,aswellascleansingthemouth.

Toothbrushescomeinavarietyofshapes,sizes,anddesigns.
Thecategory,however,isbroadlyclassifiedintotwosegments:childrenandadults.
Thechildrenssegmentcoverstoothbrushesdesignedforyouth,children,andtoddlers.
Thisreportincludesmanualandbatterypoweredbrushes.

Electrictoothbrushesarenotcoveredinthisreport.

Toothpastes

Toothpastesareusedtoclean,polish,andwhitentheteeth,aswellascleansethemouth,
sweetenthebreath,andreduceincidenceoftoothdecayandgumproblems.
Products are available primarily as pastes and gels, but are also sold as powders and
liquiddrops.

Toothwhiteningproducts

Toothwhiteningproductsareappliedtotheteethtoobtainalightershade.
Products are available primarily as whitening strips, brushon gels, and moldable
mouthpiecesortrays.

Thisreportcoversproductsforathomeuseonly.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

Introduction

SKINCAREPRODUCTS

Babycareproducts

Babycareproductsaredesignedtosoothe,protect,andhealthetenderskinofinfantsand
youngchildren,particularlyskinthatisirritatedfromdiaperrashandchafing.

Thissegmentincludesbabybath,lotions,oils,andpowders.Excludedarebabyshampoos
anddiaperrashcreams.

Theseproductsarealsooftenusedbyadultsasbathoils,skinmoisturizers,skinsoothers,
andforeyemakeupremoval.

Facialtreatments

Facialtreatmentsperformvariousfunctionsand,whilesomeoverlapexists,mostproducts
aregroupedintooneofthefollowingsegments:
Moisturizers and treatments keep skin soft, firm, smooth, and often claim to protect
skin and reduce signs of aging. Such treatments as eye creams, serums, and acne
productsarealsoincludedhere.
Thecleanserssegmentconsistsofcleansers,masques,porestrips,andfacialcleansing
cloths.Cleansingcreams,lotions,gels,andbarscleansetheskinandremovemakeup.
Masquesaredesignedtocleanse,firm,purify,ormoisturizethefacebyexfoliatingskin,
absorbing oil, or providing moisturizing benefits, and are typically worn for several
minutes or overnight. Pore strips are designed to cleanse clogged pores and remove
blackheads by applying and removing a bandagelike strip. Facial cleansing cloths,
wipes, and towelettes are designed to cleanse the skin and remove makeup with or
withouttheuseofwater.
Acneaidsarecreamsandlotionsforcontrolofmildinfections,orotherskinblemishes.
Astringentsandtonersstimulatetheskin,helpremoveexcessoil,andcanalsoreduce
appearanceofporesize.
Makeupremoversarenowincludedasfacialtreatmentsinthisreport,whereasin2010
editionandpreviouslyitwasinmiscellaneousproducts.

Oilblottersandfacialtissuesthatdonotcontainacleansingagentarenotincludedinthis
report.

Handandbodylotions

Handandbodycreams,lotions,andtreatmentsaredesignedtopreservethenaturalbeauty,
youthfulfeel,andappearanceofskinandtoprotectagainstenvironmentalharm.

Productsareformulatedtosmoothandlubricate,moisturize,sootheandpreventdryness,
relievechapping,protectagainstexternaldamage,andsometimesexfoliate.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A11

4A12

Introduction

Included are such specialty body treatments as skinfirming products, body masques, and
relatedproducts.

Fragrancelineextensionsofbodylotionsarealsoincluded.

Footcareproductsincludesmoothinglotionsandcreams,deodorizers,powders,exfoliating
scrubs,andwashesarealsoincluded.
Athletes foot products, fungicidal products, and corn and callus removers are not
included in this report but are discussed in Klines companion report Nonprescription
DrugsUSA.
Specialtyfootinsertsarealsoexcludedfromthisreport.

Skincareproductsformen

Skin care products for men include moisturizers, night creams, antiaging products, facial
and body cleansers, hand and body lotions, replenishing eye creams, exfoliating scrubs,
facialmasques,andaftersportstreatmentsmarketedspecificallytomen.

Thefollowingproductsarenotincludedinthiscategorybutarereportedintheirrespective
sectionsofthisreport:shavingcreamsandgels,personalcleansingproducts,deodorants,
andaftershaves.

Although men often use allpurpose or womens skin care products, such usage is not
includedhere.

Suncareproducts

Fivetypesofsuncareproductsareincludedhere,manyofwhichareavailableascreams,
gels,foams,lotions,oils,sprays,andsticks:
SuntanningproductswithSPF5andunder,whichpromotetanningoftheskinunder
sunlight.
Sunscreens with SPF6 to SPF14 and sunblocks with SPF15 and over, which can
eliminateupto99%ofthesunsultraviolet(UV)radiationandthuspreventburningor
prolongtanning.
Sunless tanning products, which represent two types of products: products that tan
withoutexposingtheskintothesun,andproductsthatalsocontainsunscreen.
Aftersun products, which often contain aloe vera and are designed to soothe and
moisturize sun exposed skin. Lip balms marketed by such sun care brands as Banana
Boat are included in the aftersun and other products segment of this category. Lip
balmbrandslikeChapStickandBlistexthatcontainSPFarereportedintheLipBalms,
Jellies,andtreatmentsproductcategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

Introduction

SPFisthestandardmeasurementofasunscreenscapacitytoprotectagainstUVrays.
TheSPFnumberreferstotheeffectivenessofsuncarepreparationsinprotectingthe
skinfromtheharmfuleffectsofthesunsUVradiation.
ThewavelengthsoftheUVraysemittedbythesunlongalpha(UVA)raysandshort
beta(UVB)raysaffecttheskindifferently.

Facialmoisturizers,bodymoisturizers,makeup,andotherproductsthatareratedwithan
SPF but for which sun protection is considered a secondary benefit are included in their
respectiveproductcategorieswithinthisstudy.

OTHERTOILETRIES

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

Antiperspirantsaredesignedtoeitherinhibitorstoptheflowofperspirationandmayalso
preventodor.

Deodorantssuppressbacterialdecompositionthatcausesodor.

Deodorantsandantiperspirantsareofferedinmanyproductforms.
Solid sticks have an antiperspirant active powder suspended in a wax matrix and are
twistedupandappliedonusersskin;therearetwomaintypesofsolidsticks.Regular
solidsticksweretheoriginalsolidstickintroduced.Invisiblesolidsticksorsheersolids
aresolidstickswithasofterfeel.
Softsolidextrudablesextrudecreamysolidthroughmeshdome.
Gelsareeitherclearoropaqueandusuallyassociatedwithwetandcooling,butalsoa
morestickyandslipperyfeel.
Rollons are one of the original modern forms of antiperspirant delivery; aqueous
solutionsarerolloutontousersskinviaarollingball.
Aerosolsaresprayedontousersunderarmorotherareasofthebody.

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

Depilatoriesaredesignedtoremoveunwantedhairandareanalternativetoshaving.
Most depilatories contain an alkaline chemical that causes the hair shaft to separate
fromtheskinsothehaircanbewipedaway.
Theseproductsareofferedingels,creams,lotions,rollons,mousses,andaerosols.
Theseproductsareeffectiveforaboutsevendays.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A13

4A14

Introduction

Waxesareappliedtounwantedhairandpeeledoff,removinghairdowntotheroot,not
justattheskinssurface.
Theseproductsareavailableinhotandcoldvarieties.
Someofthenewerwaxescontainsugar,whichissaidtohelptheremovalprocess.
Typically,theseproductsareeffectiveforthreetoeightweeksbeforeregrowthoccurs.

Bleachesareproductsthatfadehairratherthanremoveit.
Theseproductsaremostcommonlyusedinthefacialarea.
Theseproductsaretypicallyeffectivefortwotothreeweeks.

Not included in category sales are buffer products or epilettes, which are a more
mechanicalmeansofhairremoval/sloughing.
Otherminorproductformsarealsoavailable,suchaspaste,rockorcrystal,andwipe
ontowellettes.

Alsoexcludedareprofessionaluseproducts.

Personalcleansingproducts

Personalcleansingproductsaredividedintosixproducttypes:
Bar soaps include traditional commodity soaps such as deodorant, moisturing, and
complexion soaps as well as specialty soaps such as highly fragranced and novelty
soaps.
Bodywashesaretypicallyforuseovertheentirebodyandareusedexclusivelyinthe
shower,inplaceofbarsoaps.

Pricepointsarehigherthancommoditybar,liquid,andsomelowerpricedspecialtysoaps.

Thissegmentdoesnotincludebathandshowergels;suchproductsarecoveredintheBath
Additivessegmentofthisreport.
Liquid soaps are usually available in pump packaging and often contain moisturizing
andconditioningagents.

Mostmanufacturersofferrefills.

Mechanicshandsoapsorwaterlesshandcleanersareexcludedfromthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

Introduction

Liquid gels for use over the entire body, in the bath or shower, are covered in the Bath
Additivessectionofthisreport.
Antibacterialhandgelsorhandsanitizersaredesignedtofightoffgermsonthehands
withoutsoap,water,ortowelsinapproximately15seconds.
Most contain a bitter agent that has been added to discourage ingestion by pets or
children.
Bathadditivestypicallyofferthefollowingbenefits:
Softenwaterforgentleskincare.
Moisturize,sootheandsmoothskin.
Impartfragrancetowaterandapleasantatmospherearoundthebath.
Offertargetedaromachology/aromatherapeuticbenefits,suchasstressreduction.
Productsareofferedinthefollowingforms:
Bath liquids, grains, cream baths, cubes, salts, crystals, tablets, sachets, and mousses
areformulatedtoeithercreatefoamunderrunningbathwaterordissolveinthebath
tosoftenandperfumethewater.
Productsaretypicallysegmentedtoappealtoadults,teens,orchildren.
Bath and shower oils and gels are an extension of bubble baths, offering a high
moisturizingbenefitandleavingskinfeelingsoftandsmooth.
Fragrancebathadditivesaregenerallyincludedinpopularfragrancelines.
The bath additives section covers adult and childrens bath additives. Infant bath
additivesarediscussedseparatelyinthebabycarecategoryofthisreport.

Shavingproducts

Shavingproductsincludeshavingcreamsandsoapsandpreshavelotions.
Shaving creams and soaps, available in scented and unscented forms, are used to
softenthebeardbeforeshavingwitharazor.
Aerosol types, including foams and gels, are by far the most popular, but some
brushlessshavingproducts,lathercreams,andsoapsarestillsold.

Preshavelotionsareusedtocoatthebeardandlubricatetheskinbeforeshaving.

Razorsareexcluded.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A15

4A16

Introduction

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

4B.THEMARKET

TOTALSALES

Sales of personal care products in the United States further advance in 2012 to reach
$40.3billion,upby3.4%from$39.0billionin2011.
Sales of individual product categories range from approximately $6.6 billion for facial
treatmentsto$163millionfordepilatories,waxes,andbleaches.

The six leading product categoriesfacial treatments, personal cleansing products, face
makeup,eyemakeup,fragrancesforwomen,andshampoosaccountformorethanhalfof
totalmarketsalesatthemanufacturerslevelin2012.

GROWTH

Themarketregistersagrowthof3.4%insalesin2012.
Leading companies continue to introduce new products with improved technologies,
supportingtheoverallgrowthofthepersonalcareindustryintheUnitedStatesin2012.
Other factors that support the growth include; aggressive promotional activities and
innovationsintermsofbothproductandpackaging.

Twentyfour product categories display growth while only two register a decline in sales
during2012.
Nailpolishescategorycontinuestopostthehighestgrowthin2012,upby17.4%.
Eight other product categoriesfacial treatments, fragrances for women, shampoos,
conditioners, sun care products, lip balms, jellies, and treatments, skin care products
formen,anddepilatories,waxes,andbleachesregistergainsof4.0%ormore.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4B2

TheMarket

Table4B1:ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProduct
Category,2011and2012
$Million
Productcategory

2011

2012

Change,%

Facialtreatments

6,360

6,645

4.5

Personalcleansingproductsr

3,907

4,026

3.0

Facemakeupr

2,804

2,909

3.7

Fragrancesforwomen

2,612

2,717

4.0

Eyemakeupr

2,621

2,709

3.4

Shampoosr

2,501

2,620

4.8

Handandbodylotionsr

2,240

2,283

1.9

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

1,999

2,040

2.1

Toothpastes

1,719

1,749

1.7

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,658

1,680

1.3

Conditionersr

1,578

1,653

4.8

Lipsticksandlipglossesr

1,352

1,377

1.8

Haircoloringproductsr

1,323

1,317

(0.5)

Fragrancesformen

1,063

1,101

3.6

Suncareproductsr

984

1,048

6.5

Mouthwashes

782

799

2.2

Toothbrushes

725

741

2.2

Nailpolishesr

564

662

17.4

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentsr

357

374

4.8

Shavingproducts

362

373

3.0

Ethnichaircareproductsr

333

340

2.1

Dentureproducts

314

318

1.3

Babycareproducts

283

288

1.8

Toothwhiteningproducts

287

271

(5.6)

Skincareproductsformenr

154

169

9.7

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

144

163

13.2

39,026

40,372

3.4

Totalr

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

4C.FRAGRANCES

INTRODUCTION

Included in this section are womens fragrances, which includes perfumes, toilet waters,
bodysplashes,colognes,andbodymistsandmensfragrances,whichincludesaftershaves,
colognes,andbodysplashes.
Allancillaryfragranceproductsarealsoincluded.

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Total manufacturers sales of fragrances grow by 3.9% from $3,675million in 2011 to


$3,818millionin2012,withincreasesacrossboththemensandwomenscategories.
Sales of fragrances for women increase by 4.0% to $2,717million, while sales of
fragrancesformenincreaseby3.6%to$1,101millionin2012.
Fragrancesforwomenaccountfor71.2%oftotalsales,whilefragrancesformenmake
upthebalance.

Figure4C1:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesintheUnitedStates,2012

Fragrancesfor
women,71.2%

Fragrancesfor
men,28.8%

Total:$3,818Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C2

Fragrances

Historicalsales

Saleshavedeclinedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of0.4%from$3,886million
in2007to$3,818millionin2012.

Table4C1:HistoricalSalesofFragrancesintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

3,886

2008

3,654

(6.0)

2009

3,389

(7.2)

2010

3,468

2.3

2011

3,675

6.0

2012

3,818

3.9

Salesbyproducttype

Liquid products, including colognes, perfumes, aftershaves, and body mists and splashes,
accountfor90.6%oftotalfragrancesalesin2012,up3.9%from2011.

Ancillaryproducts,suchasbodylotions,bathadditives,andperfumeddeodorants,account
for9.4%oftotalsales.
Ancillaryproductsgrowasvaluesetsgrowinpopularity.

Table4C2:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

Producttype
Liquidproducts
Ancillaryproducts
Total

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

3,329

3,458

90.6

90.6

3.9

346

360

9.4

9.4

4.0

3,675

3,818

100.0

100.0

3.9

Salesbytradeclass

Theluxurytradeclassaccountsforthelargestportionoffragrancesales,witha61.6%share
in2012,upfroma60.7%sharein2011.

The specialty trade class continues to grow, reaching a share of 21.3% in 2012, up from
20.8%in2011.

Themassanddirecttradeclassescontinuetolosesharein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Fragrances

Table4C3:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

$Million

Tradeclass

Womens

Luxury

1,582

769

2,351

61.6

Specialty

739

73

812

21.3

Mass

198

170

368

9.6

Direct

198

89

287

7.5

2,717

1,101

3,818

100.0

Total

Mens

Total

%Oftotal

RETAILSALES

Retailsalesoffragrancesareestimatedat$6,093million,upfrom$5,859millionin2011.

COMPETITION

Eachoftheninelargestcompaniesgeneratesmorethan$100millioninfragrancesalesand
togetheraccountformorethanthreequartersoftotaldollarvolumein2012.

Table4C4:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesintheUnitedStatesbyCategoryandCompany,2012

$Million

Company

Womens

Total

%Oftotal

LimitedBrands

639

13

652

17.1

Coty

345

196

541

14.2

LOral

181

216

397

10.4

Procter&Gamble

134

175

309

8.1

EsteLauder

238

24

262

6.9

Chanel

181

63

244

6.4

ElizabethArden

188

27

215

5.6

Avon

146

56

202

5.3

LVMH

96

17

113

3.0

569

314

883

23.1

2,717

1,101

3,818

100.0

Allother
Total

Mens

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C3

4C4

Fragrances

LimitedBrandsremainsinfirstplaceandgainsshareasthelargestmarketeroffragrances,
increasingtoa17.1%sharein2012,upfroma16.8%shareofthetotalfragrancesmarketin
2011.
The company is the leading marketer of womens fragrances, competing with brands
from Bath& Body Works, Victorias Secret, and Pink. Sales of its mens fragrances
remainlow.
Sales grow due to the regular launch of new and different scents coupled with
promotionalpricingandappealingmarketing.

Cotyremainsinsecondplacewithashareof14.2%in2012,upfrom13.9%in2011.
Thecompanyrankssecondinsalesinbothmensandwomensfragrances.

During2012,LOralcontinuestoberankedthirdwitha10.4%share,unchangedfromthe
prioryear.
In 2012,thecompanyranksfirstinthesales ofmensfragrancesandtiedforfifthin
womensfragrances.

Procter&Gambleremainsinfourthpositionwithsalesof$309millionandan8.1%share.
The company ranks third in the sales of mens fragrances and eighth in womens
fragrances.

EsteLauderremainsinfifthplacewithtotalsalesof$262million,downfrom$273million
in2011.
Itssharedropsto6.9%in2012,from7.4%in2011.
The company ranks third in the sales of womens fragrances and seventh in mens
fragrances.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Department stores maintain their position as the leading retail outlet for the sales of
fragrancesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Fragrances

Table4C5:RetailDistributionofFragrancesintheUnitedStates,2012

Retailoutlet

%Ofmanufacturersdollars
Womens

Mens

Weightedaverage

Departmentstores

34

37

35

Specialtystores

35

16

30

Massmerchandisers

12

19

14

Directsales

12

16

13

Drugstores

11

Foodstores

100

100

100

Total

OUTLOOK

Sales for the total fragrances industryexperience growth for the third year in a row after
severalyearsofsoftsales.
The industry is still largely dependent on holiday sales and foreign tourists, both of
whicharenotenoughtosubstantiallygrowthecategory.
Whilenewproductshelpcreatesomeexcitementintheindustry,mostofthegrowth
comesfromestablishedscentsandfranchises.

Thefragrancesindustryfacesmanychallengeswhichstiflerobustgrowth.
A reduced demand for fragrances as gifts due to competition from other products
rangingfromconsumerelectronicstogiftcards.
Concern about the healthfulness of fragrances regarding asthma, allergies, and the
potentialtobeahormonedisrupter.
Lackofcompatibilitywiththegrowingtrendofnaturalpersonalcareproducts.
The prohibition of fragrances in work environments mandated by companies or
requestedbycoworkers.
Amorecausalworkenvironmentwithlessdressupopportunities.

The fragrances industry needs to take steps to become more pertinent with consumers
duringtheforecastperiod.
The industry needs to work towards more natural scents that are wellsuited to a
naturallifestyle,containinglesssyntheticingredientsandthatarelesslikelytointeract
withthebodysendocrineandhormonalfunctioning.
Researchers should look to develop scents that offer beneficial properties to
consumerssuchasloweringbloodpressure,elevatingmood,orprovidingmoreenergy.
To help lessen confusion on the part of the consumer, there needs to be more
distinctionbetweenscents.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C5

4C6

Fragrances

Classicsanddesignerscentswillremainpopularthroughtheforecastperiod.
Celebrityscentswillserveasalaunchpadtogetyoungerconsumersinterestedinthe
category.
Marketersneedtoreassesstheirproductofferingstobesuretheyaretrulydifferent,
insteadofjustservingtoconfusetheconsumer.
Marketers need to further review their distribution strategies, as the offering of
prestigescentsinmasschannels,continuestohurtbrandequity,asithasfornearlya
decade.

Marketers need to better engage consumers to help cement a better relationship with
purchasers.
The marketing methods utilized during the forecast period need to be carefully
examinedonthebasisofbrand.
Marketersneedtotellmorestoriesaboutthereasonforthescentandwhatitstands
for.
Samplingisbecomingmorevitalthanever.
Workingwithretailerstodevelopspecialeventscanhelpencouragetrialofproducts.
Promotionalendeavorsshouldtakeplacethroughouttheyearandnotjustaroundgift
givingtime.
Engaging consumers through social media will become an important medium,
especiallyasreadershipofmagazinesdeclines.

SalesoffragrancesareprojectedtoincreaseataCAGRof3.2%,reaching$4,475millionby
2017from$3,818millionin2012.

Table4C6:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFragrancesintheUnitedStatesby
Category,2012and2017

$Million

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Fragrancesforwomen

2,717

3,231

3.5

Fragrancesformen

1,101

1,244

2.5

Total

3,818

4,475

3.2

Unitvolumeisexpectedtoincreaseduetotheavailabilityofsmallersizedproducts.
Packagesareexpectedtoreach281millionin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

Fragrances

Table4C7:ForecastUnitVolumeofFragrancesintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,
2012and2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Fragrancesforwomen

160

177

2.0

Fragrancesformen

100

104

0.8

Total

260

281

1.6

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C7

4C8

Fragrances

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

FRAGRANCESFORMEN

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Thefragrancesformencategorycontinuestoexhibitlowgrowthin2012.
Salesgrow3.6%duringtheyear,from$1,063millionin2011to$1,101millionin2012.

Sales of fragrances for men have declined at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
1.4%from$1,180millionin2007to$1,101millionin2012.

Table4C8:HistoricalSalesofFragrancesforMenin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,180

2008

1,108

(6.5)

2009

1,010

(8.8)

2010

1,024

1.4

2011

1,063

3.8

2012

1,101

3.6

Unitsales

Unitsalesoffragrancesformenincrease1.5%to99.9millionfrom99.4millionin2011.

Retailsales

Sales of fragrances for men at the retail level total $1,731million for 2012, up 3.7% from
$1,669millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C10

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

LUXURY
AcquadiGi

L'Oral

50

53

6.9

6.9

4.7

4.8

Bleu

Chanel

42

45

5.8

5.9

4.0

4.1

GucciGuiltyPourHomme

Procter&Gamble

40

42

5.5

5.5

3.8

3.8

ArmaniCode

L'Oral

24

24

3.3

3.1

2.3

2.2

LightBluePourHomme

Procter&Gamble

23

22

3.2

2.9

2.2

2.0

PoloBleu

L'Oral

21

21

2.9

2.7

2.0

1.9

TheOneForMen

Procter&Gamble

23

21

3.2

2.7

2.2

1.9

Polo

L'Oral

14

15

1.9

2.0

1.3

1.4

L'HommeYvesSaint
Laurent

L'Oral

13

14

1.8

1.8

1.2

1.3

PoloBlack

L'Oral

13

13

1.8

1.7

1.2

1.2

EternityForMen

Coty

13

13

1.8

1.7

1.2

1.2

LeMale

Shiseido

13

13

1.8

1.7

1.2

1.2

ObsessionforMen

Coty

12

12

1.7

1.6

1.1

1.1

EuphoriaMen

Coty

11

12

1.5

1.6

1.0

1.1

Legend

InterParfums

12

1.6

1.1

CoolWater

Coty

11

11

1.5

1.4

1.0

1.0

TheOneSport

Procter&Gamble

11

1.4

1.0

GucciByGucci

Procter&Gamble

13

10

1.8

1.3

1.2

0.9

EternityAqua

Coty

10

1.2

1.3

0.8

0.9

Chrome

Clarins

10

1.2

1.3

0.8

0.9

DrakkarNoir

L'Oral

1.1

1.2

0.8

0.8

VersacePourHomme

EuroItaly

1.1

1.2

0.8

0.8

1Million

Coty

1.2

0.8

LaNuitdeL'Homme

L'Oral

1.2

1.0

0.8

0.7

Aramis

EsteLauder

1.1

1.0

0.8

0.7

VersaceManEauFraiche

EuroItaly

1.0

1.0

0.7

0.7

L'HommeLibre

L'Oral

0.7

1.0

0.5

0.7

L'Eaud'IsseyPour
Homme

Shiseido

1.0

0.9

0.7

0.6

EauLacosteBlanc

Procter&Gamble

0.6

0.9

0.4

0.6

BigPony1

L'Oral

1.0

0.8

0.7

0.5

Dolce&Gabbana

Procter&Gamble

0.8

0.7

0.6

0.5

BigPony3

L'Oral

0.8

0.7

0.6

0.5

PoloDoubleBlack

L'Oral

0.7

0.7

0.5

0.5

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

4C11

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
BurberryTouchforMen

InterParfums

0.7

0.7

0.5

0.5

BurberryBritforMen

InterParfums

0.7

0.7

0.5

0.5

TerreD'Hermes

Hermes

0.6

0.7

0.4

0.5

CurveForMen

ElizabethArden

0.8

0.5

0.6

0.4

Coach

EsteLauder

0.8

0.5

0.6

0.4

NauticaVoyage

Coty

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

ArmaniCodeSport

L'Oral

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

BigPony4

L'Oral

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

BigPony2

L'Oral

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

LacosteEssential

Procter&Gamble

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

PradaMan

Coty

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.4

EuphoriaMenIntense

Coty

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.4

PlatinumEgoiste

Chanel

0.4

0.5

0.3

0.4

VinceCamuto

Procter&Gamble

0.5

0.4

Spicebomb

L'Oral

0.5

0.4

IsseyPourHommeSport

Shiseido

0.5

0.4

ConnectedKennethCole
Reaction

Coty

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.3

GuessSeductiveHomme

Coty

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.3

TheOneGentleman

Procter&Gamble

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.3

EdHardyLove&Luck

ElizabethArden

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.3

KennethColeReaction

Coty

0.6

0.4

0.4

0.3

Pi

LVMH

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

AllureHommeSport

Chanel

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

Fahrenheit

LVMH

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

PleasuresforMen

EsteLauder

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

LacosteEssentialSport

Procter&Gamble

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

AllureHomme

Chanel

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

Artisian

Shiseido

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

BvlgariMan

Chanel

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

EckoBlue

ParluxFragrances

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

PradeAmberPour
Homme

Coty

0.3

0.4

0.2

0.3

Encounter

Coty

0.4

0.3

AllureHommeExtreme

Chanel

0.4

0.3

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C12

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
P.S.

ElizabethArden

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

CKFree

Coty

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

Play

LVMH

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

KennethColeNewYork
Black

Coty

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

TrueReligion

ElizabethArden

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

PoloSport

L'Oral

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Coty

212CarolinaHerrera

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

GucciPourHommeII

Procter&Gamble

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

JohnVarvatos

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

HappyforMen

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

TomFordForMen

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Joop!

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

JohnVarvatosStar

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

AngelMen

Clarins

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.2

EdHardyVillian

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.2

TomFordNoir

EsteLauder

0.3

0.2

OnlytheBrave

L'Oral

0.4

0.1

0.3

0.1

DieselFuelForLifeFor
Him

L'Oral

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

UsherHe

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

EdHardyHearts&
Daggers

ElizabethArden
Fragrances

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

PoloExplorer

L'Oral

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

Tommy

EsteLauder

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

KennethColeRSVP

Coty

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

DrifterforMen

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

HanaeMoriforMen

InternationalCosmetics
&Perfumes

0.3

0.1

0.2

0.1

TheBeat

InterParfums

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

EdHardyMen

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

TommyBahama

GeminiCosmetics

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Bang

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

NauticaOcean

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

CurveCrush

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

4C13

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
MarcJacobsMen

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

DirtyEnglish

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

VeraWangMen

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

IzodForMen

GeminiCosmetics

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Allother

L'Oral

14

14

1.9

1.8

1.3

1.3

Allother

Coty

10

1.4

1.2

0.9

0.8

Allother

LVMH

1.2

1.2

0.8

0.8

Allother

Procter&Gamble

0.8

0.8

0.6

0.5

Allother

ElizabethArden

0.4

0.3

0.3

0.2

Allother

EsteLauder

0.7

0.3

0.5

0.2

Allother

Chanel

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Allother

Clarins

0.1

0.3

0.1

0.2

Allother

InterParfums

0.3

0.2

Allother

65

74

9.0

9.6

6.1

6.7

725

769

100.0

100.0

68.2

69.8

Total
MASS
OldSpice

Procter&Gamble

25

25

14.1

14.7

2.4

2.3

Stetson

Coty

17

17

9.6

10.0

1.6

1.5

Adidas

Coty

15

16

8.5

9.4

1.4

1.5

McGraw

Coty

13

12

7.3

7.1

1.2

1.1

GilletteSeries

Procter&Gamble

10

10

5.6

5.9

0.9

0.9

Bod

YellowWoodPartners

10

5.1

5.9

0.8

0.9

JovanMuskForMen

Coty

5.1

4.7

0.8

0.7

Brut

HelenofTroy

PlayboyForHim

Coty

SkinBracer

4.5

4.7

0.8

0.7

11

6.2

4.1

1.0

0.6

ColgatePalmolive

2.3

2.4

0.4

0.4

AquaVelva

Combe

2.3

2.4

0.4

0.4

DavidBeckham

Coty

2.8

2.4

0.5

0.4

NiveaforMen

Beiersdorf

1.7

1.8

0.3

0.3

AntonioBanderas

Coty

1.7

1.8

0.3

0.3

PreferredStock

Coty

1.7

1.2

0.3

0.2

HalstonMen'sFragrance

ElizabethArden

1.1

1.2

0.2

0.2

EnglishLeather

DanaClassicFragrances

1.1

1.2

0.2

0.2

Afta

ColgatePalmolive

1.1

1.2

0.2

0.2

PierreCardin

FiveStarFragrances

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C14

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

MASS(Continued)
Canoe

DanaClassicFragrances

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

BritishSterling

DanaClassicFragrances

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

Gravity

Coty

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

MuskForMen

Coty

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

1.7

1.8

0.3

0.3

3.4

4.1

0.6

0.6

18

16

10.2

9.4

1.7

1.5

177

170

100.0

100.0

16.7

15.4

Privatelabel
Allother

Coty

Allother

Total
DIRECT
UnpluggedforMen

Avon

10

11.2

0.9

VelocityforHim

MaryKay

9.8

10.1

0.8

0.8

MesmerizeforMen

Avon

8.7

9.0

0.8

0.7

BlackSuede

Avon

6.5

6.7

0.6

0.5

MKHighIntensity

MaryKay

6.5

6.7

0.6

0.5

Domain

MaryKay

6.5

6.7

0.6

0.5

DerekJeterDrivenBlack

Avon

6.5

5.6

0.6

0.5

MuskMarine

Avon

4.5

0.4

MuskFire

Avon

4.5

0.4

WildCountry

Avon

4.3

4.5

0.4

0.4

Ironman

Avon

4.3

4.5

0.4

0.4

DerekJeterDriven

Avon

2.2

2.2

0.2

0.2

PatrickDemsey2

Avon

4.3

1.1

0.4

0.1

PatrickDemsey
Unscripted

Avon

4.3

1.1

0.4

0.1

ChristianLacroixNoir

Avon

3.3

1.1

0.3

0.1

Turn4XT

Avon

3.3

1.1

0.3

0.1

Tribute

MaryKay

1.1

1.1

0.1

0.1

HerveLegerHomme

Avon

2.2

0.2

DerekJeterDrivenSport

Avon

2.2

0.2

DerekJeterDrivenFresh

Avon

2.2

0.2

DerekJeterDrivenWarm

Avon

2.2

0.2

Allother

Avon

6.5

5.6

0.6

0.5

12

11

13.0

12.4

1.1

1.0

92

89

100.0

100.0

8.7

8.1

Allother
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

4C15

FragrancesforMen

Table4C9:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

27

29

39.1

39.7

2.5

2.6

SPECIALTY
Abercrombie&Fitch

Abercrombie&Fitch

Honor

Express

11.6

12.3

0.8

0.8

VerySexyforHim

LimitedBrands

11.6

9.6

0.8

0.6

BananaRepublic

TheGap

8.7

9.6

0.6

0.6

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

8.7

8.2

0.6

0.5

AmericanEagle

AmericanEagle

4.3

4.1

0.3

0.3

11

12

15.9

16.4

1.0

1.1

Total

69

73

100.0

100.0

6.5

6.6

TOTAL

1,063

1,101

100.0

100.0

Allother

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Thefragrancesformencategorystrugglesmostin2012,affectedbyeconomicuncertainty,
SuperstormSandy,andthesenselessmassshootingofinnocentAmericans.
Thesuccessofthefragrancescategoryistiedverycloselytotheholidaysellingseason,
andsincetheaboveeventsoccurredinthelastquarter,thisgreatlyhamperssales,up
untilafewdaysbeforeChristmas.
Withoutrobustgrowth,thecategorydoesnotappeartoberebounding,butratherjust
slowlymovingbacktolevelsseenbeforetherecession.
The luxury trade class displayed the highest growth, up 6.1%, followed by specialty
tradeclassadvancingat5.8%.

Althoughsalesoffragrancesformenhavegrownyearlysince2010,itdoesnotindicatethat
Americanmenarewearingmorefragrances.
Muchofthefragrancepurchasedisbyinternationaltouristswholikescentsandwho
frequent the U.S. shopping venues looking for clothes and fragrances that are more
attractivelypricedthanintheirhomecountries.
Withthetrendtowardstelecommutingandmorecasualworkenvironments,menare
notdressinguponadailybasisastheydidseveraldecadesago.
Concernaboutworkmateswhoaresensitivetofragrance,alongwiththecontroversy
aboutthepotentialoffragrancesashormoneandendocrinedisrupters,contributeto
hamperingrealsalesgrowth.
Fragrancedoesnotappeartobeadailyusegroomingproductnecessityamongmost
men,butratherreservedforspecialoccasions.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C16

FragrancesforMen

Category growth continues to be driven by firmlyentrenched brands, such as LOrals


Acqua di Gi and Chanels Bleu continuing to thrive, and by the expansion of reputable
franchises,suchasProcter&GamblesGucciandDolce&Gabbana.
Asseenoverthepastfewyears,classicsandbrandsfromestablishedmarketersexhibit
themostvitality.
Edgybrandsandthosewithacelebrityalignmentmightbepopularoneyearandfall
out of the fashion the next. Therefore, most fragrance marketers are careful and
developallianceswithmainstreamaccessoryorfashionbrands.

Newlauncheshelpgrowthefragrancesformencategory.
InterParfums Montblanc Legend was the bestperforming mens fragrance launch of
2012,andisgearedtoyoungmen.ThescentisreminiscentofAbercrombiesFierceto
somefragranceexperts.
Procter & Gambles Dolce & Gabbana The One franchise was extended with a third
fragranceTheOneSport,whichisalighterandfresherversionoftheoriginal.
SpicebombisthemaleequivalentofViktor&RolfsFlowerbombfragrancefromLOral,
andthedistinctivepackaginglookslikeahandgrenade.

Nichescentsalsohelptogrowthefragrancesformencategory.
Scentsfrommarketers,suchasAcquaduParma,CliveChristian,ByKilian,Houbigant,
Bond No. 9, and Amouage create excitement in the industry and offer a point of
differentiation.
These scents have price points as high as several hundred dollars, based on their
ingredientcompositionandlongevity.
Theallureofthesenichescentsisthatfewpeoplewearthesescents,duetotheirhigh
priceandlimiteddistribution,andthereforeofferadistinctiveopportunityforamanto
smelldifferentlyfromhiscolleagues.
While collectively these scents are estimated at 5% to 8% of the total fragrances for
menmarketintheluxurytradeclass,eachofthesescentsindividuallyhassmallsales
andarenottrackedindividuallyinthisreport.
Nichescentsaretypicallynotlargeenoughinvolumeforthelargecompaniestooffer,
especially with their select distribution to very high end boutiques and department
stores,suchasNeimanMarcus,BergdorfGoodman,andBarneys.

Flankers,lineextensions,andmigrationofscentstosecondarychannelscontributetothe
declineinthebrandsequity.
Marketers continue to add flankers and line extensions to offer newness to the
consumer, but when new introductions are made, the main brand typically exhibits
decliningsales.During2012,Procter&GamblesTheOneForMendeclinesnearly9%
withthelaunchofTheOneSport.
Theindustryalsoutilizesapracticewherebyaluxuryscentisofferedforsaleinmass
channels,dilutingthebrandsequity.Thismaybeintentionallydonebymarketersto
helpgrowsales,ormaybetheresultofdivertedgoods.
Thesepracticesmakethebrandspositioningmurkyanderodethebrandsequity.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

FragrancesforMen

Eventhoughthefragrancesformencategoryhasgrownyearlysince2010,severalfactors
continuetostiflesubstantialgrowth.
Many workplaces frown upon the use of fragrance due to headache and allergic
reactions.
Youngermencontinuetousescentedgroomingproductsinlieuoffragrance.
More telecommuting and casual work environments lower the opportunities to wear
fragrance.
Concernabouttheeffectsoffragranceproductsonhormonesandendocrinefunction
leadssomementoabandondailyuseoftheseproducts.
Confusionamongconsumersaboutthevariousbrandsandlineextensions,leadsmany
to either purchase only the more wellknown brands, or even abandon the category
entirely.
Frustration on the part of consumers due to the lack of differentiation among scents
alsoleadstolessofapriorityonpurchasing.

A movement to ban the wearing of fragrances in the workplace is gaining awareness in


someareasoftheUnitedStatesandbeyond,whichcouldnegativelyimpactthecategorys
futuresales.
InDecember2012,legislationintroducedinNewHampshirepreventsstateemployees
who have contact with members of the public from wearing fragrances during the
workday.
Private employers and other government agencies in the United States and Canada,
suchasthecityofDetroit,MI;Portland,OR,andtheU.S.CensusBureau,havebanned
thewearingoffragranceattheirworkplace.
In Europe, there is a movement to ban fragrances that include certain ingredients
includingthetopsellingChanelNo.5,whichissaidtoincludeatreemossextractthat
cansetoffallergicreactions.
Most personal care products are required to display their ingredient composition on
thepackage,withonlyafewexceptions.Fragranceformulationsareconsideredtrade
secretsandareexemptfromtheingredientrequirementdisclosure,butthereisapush
by various advocacy groups to make it mandatory to have their ingredients made
public.

Giftsoffragrancesarenotheldinthesameesteemasdecadesago.
Menareoptingforelectronics,suchastablets,games,andgadgets,pushingfragrances
tothebackseatasoneofthemostwantedgifts.
Withanemphasisonvalue,giftshopperscanpurchaseseveralitemsonsales,whereas
fragrancesaretypicallysoldatfullprice.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C17

4C18

FragrancesforMen

M&Aactivity

A number of new licensing agreements and corporate developments are signed or take
effectduring2012,withmoreannouncedfor2013.
AlfredDunhillannouncesthatitisswitchinglicensingpartnerseffectiveApril2013to
InterParfumsina10yeardealfromProcter&Gamble.
InterParfumsacquiresthefragrancelicenseofKarlLagerfieldinearly2012fromCoty.
InterParfumslosesthefragrancelicenseofBurberryasBurberrytakesownershipofits
ownfragrancelicenseasof2013.
Kenneth Cole signs a licensing deal with Parlux effective January 2013 after 10 years
withCoty.
Coty, which has distributed Puigs fragrances in North America for the past six years,
willceasedoingsowhenthelicenseexpiresonJune30,2013.
Clarins Fragrance Group will begin to distribute Puigs fragrances in North America
effectiveJuly1,2013.
ElizabethArdenacquirestheglobalfragrancelicensesofEdHardy,TrueReligion,and
BCBGMaxAzriafromNewWaveFragrancesinmid2012.ElizabethArdenalsoacquires
thefragrancelicensesofJustinBieberandNickiMinajfromGiveBackBrandsLLC.
Yellow Wood Partners acquires Parums de Coeur, Ltd a privatelyheld firm for an
undisclosedamountinfall2012.

Notablenewproducts

Table4C10:SelectNewFragrancesforMenIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Avon

JonBonJovi

Chanel

Chanel

Coty

CalvinKlein

Coty

PacoRabanne

ElizabethArden

EdHardy

EsteLauder

TomFord

Interparfums

Montblanc

LOral

Viktor&Rolf

Procter&Gamble

Dolce&
Gabbana

Procter&Gamble

VinceCamuto

Shiseido

IsseyMiyake

Description
UnpluggedforMen,acollaborationbetweenAvonandJonBonJovi,awoody,floral,and
muskyscent
AllureHommeExtreme,thenewestextensionintheAllureline,includesmuskyshades,
tartspices,aromaticfreshness,andwoodyaccords
Encounter,thenewestCalvinKleinscent,openswithmandarin,cardamom,andrum,
alongwithpepper,jasmine,patchouli,andcognac.
OneMillionintroducedintheUnitedStatesincludesnotesofgrapefruit,redorange,
mint,rose,cinnamon,spices,leather,wood,patchouli,andamber
VillianopenswithnotesofItalianBergamotandFrenchlavenderalongwithmasculine
spicesandEgyptianbasilandwildsage
TomFordNoirhastopnotesofbergamot,verbena,caraway,pinkpepper,andviolet
ThefirstmalescentfromMontblancwithcontrastingnotesthatevokestrengthand
tenderness,traditionandmodernity.Thefougrescentstopnotesincludelavender,
bergamot,coumarin,verbena,andpineappleleaves
Spicebomblookslikeahandgrenadeandcontainsnotesofchili,saffron,leather,
tobacco,andvetiver,alongwithbergamot,grapefruit,elemi,andpepper
TheOnefranchiseisextendedwithTheOneSport,thethirdfragranceintheline.Thisis
lighterandfresherthantheotherscentsinthefranchiseandopenswithaquaticnotes
androsemaryalongwithcardamomandsequoiawood.
Inablackbottlewiththefamilycrest,thisfragranceopenswithItalianbergamot,
mandarin,andblackpepper
IsseyPourHommeSport,sporteditionofhisnamesakefragranceopenswithseveral
citrusnotes

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

FragrancesforMen

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Liquidproductsaccountfor91.0%ofthetotalmensfragrancesalesin2012,downslightly
from91.1%in2011.

Table4C11:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal
Producttype
2011
2012

2011
2012
Liquidproductsa
968
1,002

91.1
91.0
Ancillaryproducts
95
99

8.9
9.0
Total
1,063
1,101

100.0
100.0

aIncludescologne,eaudeparfum,eaudetoilette,andaftershave.

Change,%
3.5
4.2
3.6

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4C12:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforMenintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012
$Million
%Oftotal
Company
2011
2012
2011
2012
LOral
214
216
20.1
19.6
Coty
195
196
18.3
17.8
Procter&Gamble
164
175
15.4
15.9
Chanel
56
63
5.3
5.7
Avon
58
56
5.5
5.1
Abercrombie&Fitch
27
29
2.5
2.6
Shiseido
23
27
2.2
2.5
ElizabethArdena
34
27
3.2
2.5
EsteLauder
29
24
2.7
2.2
InterParfums
13
23
1.2
2.1
MaryKay
22
22
2.1
2.0
LVMH
18
17
1.7
1.5
EuroItaly
15
17
1.4
1.5
Clarins
11
14
1.0
1.3
LimitedBrands
14
13
1.3
1.2
Allother
170
182

16.0
16.5
Total
1,063
1,101
100.0
100.0

aElizabethArdenpurchasesthefragrancebrandsofNewWaveduring2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Change,%
0.9
0.5
6.7
12.5
(3.4)
7.4
17.4
(20.6)
(17.2)
76.9

(5.6)
13.3
27.3
(7.1)
7.1
3.6

4C19

4C20

FragrancesforMen

The top three companiesLOral, Coty, and Procter & Gambletogether account for
53.3%oftotalcategorysales,downslightlyfrom53.8%in2011.

LOralmaintainsthetopspotastheleadingmarketeroffragrancesformenwitha19.6%
share.
Salesgrow0.9%or$2millionto$216millionbasedonthestrengthoffragrances,such
asAcquadiGi,ArmaniCode,andthePolofranchise.
Sixofthetop10scentsbelongtoLOral.
The companys Acqua di Gi continues to be the leader among male fragrances with
$53millioninsales,$8millionaheadofsecondplacedChanelsBleu.
ArmaniCoderanksfourth,andPoloBlueremainsinsixthposition.
LOralcontinuestorelyonitsassociationwithclassicdesignersforitsscentsincluding
Giorgio Armani, Ralph Lauren, Yves Saint Laurent, and Viktor and Rolf, and growth is
experiencedduring2012becausemostoftheclassicsperformwell.
Theluxurytradeclassistheonlytradeclassinwhichthecompanycompetes.However,
whensomeofitsproductsdoendupinmassretailers,itistypicallyduetodiversion
ratherthananintentionaleffortbythecompany.
ThemajorlaunchoftheyearistheViktorandRolfsSpicebomb,withsalesof$4million
during2012.

Cotyremainsinsecondplace,withsalesadvancing$1millionor0.5%during2012.
Share drops from 18.3% to 17.8%, while sales increase from $195 million to
$196million.
Cotys biggest decline is from sluggishness in Kenneth Cole scents, a franchise which
Cotylosesasoflate2012.
ManyofCotysmajorscentshaveeitherrelativelyflatorslightlyupwardsales,suchas
EternityforMen0.0%,Euphora9.1%,andEternityAqua11.1%
Encounteristhemajorlaunchoftheyearwithsalesreaching$3million.
Unlikemanyothermarketersthatcompeteineithertheluxuryorthemasstradeclass,
Cotyisactiveinboth.
ManyofCotysmassscentsexperienceflatordecliningsales,suchasStetson,McGraw,
andPlayboy.
Since2006,inadditiontoitsownbrands,CotydistributesanumberofPuigsbrandsin
North America, including Prada, Nina Ricci, Carolina Herrera, Antonio Banderas, and
Paco Rabanne, which are reflected in Cotys total sales. However, Coty will cease to
distributethePuigfragranceswhenthelicenseexpiresonJune30,2013.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

FragrancesforMen

Rounding out the top three marketers is Procter& Gamble with sales increasing 6.7%,
whichisagreatergrowthratethanLOralorCoty.
Salesgrowfrom$164millionin2011to$175millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble owes its fragrance success to its two highend European fashion
house licenses Dolce & Gabbana and Gucci in contrast to both LOral and Coty
thatalignwithmidtierfashionbrandsandcelebrities.
GucciGuiltyPourHommeisthethirdleadingmensfragrance,andcontinuestogrow,
up5%to$42million.
Dolce&GabbanastopscentsLightBluePourHommeisinfifthplace,whileTheOne
dropstoseventhplace,duetothelaunchofTheOneSportwhichobtains$11millionin
salesinjustafewmonths.
In2012,Procter&GamblelaunchesitsfirstscentwithdesignerVinceCamuto.
The company also competes in the mass market with its lower end, but long
established Old Spice, the leading mass brand, and the Gillette Series, both of which
are more aligned to shaving than fine fragrances, and both of which have a loyal
customerbase.

In a distant fourth place and nudging Avon out of this spot is Chanel, with sales growing
12.5%during2012.
Sales reach $63 million; however, sales are more than $100 million behind the third
rankedmarketer.
ChanelssalesincreasebasedonthesuccessofBleu,whichcontinuestogrow.

Bybrand

LOrals Acqua di Gi continues to lead the categorys sales and grows faster than the
industryaverage.
Salesreach$53millionin2012,agrowthof6.0%from$50millionintheprioryear.
Thebrandsshareoftheluxurytradeclassremainsflatat6.9%,whileshareofthetotal
mensfragrancemarketgrowsfrom4.7%to4.8%during2012.

ChanelsBleuisfirmlyentrenchedinsecondplaceinitssecondfullyearoncounter.
Salesare$45million,up7.1%from$42millionin2011.
Bleusshareoftheluxuryfragrancemarketgrowsslightlyfrom5.8%to5.9%whilethe
brandsshareofthetotalmensfragrancemarketgrowsfrom4.0%to4.1%.

Remaining in third place is Procter & Gambles Gucci Guilty Pour Homme, with sales
growing5.0%duringtheyear.
Salesreach$42million,upfrom$40millionduringitsfirstyearoncounter.
Thisscentmaintainsa5.5%shareoftheluxurymensmarket,anda3.8%shareofthe
totalfragrancemarket.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C21

4C22

FragrancesforMen

Abercrombie&FitchsFierce,remainsinfourthplacewithsalesgrowingfrom$27millionin
2011to$29millionin2012.
Fierceistheleadingapparelretailerbrand.
Salesarestrongasthisscentispopularamongmaleteenagers(andthewomenthey
encounter).DuetothepopularityofthisscentamongtheAbercrombie&Fitchmale
customers,theretailerscentsthestorewithFierceandhasfansblowingthefragrance
outsidethestoretoenticeothercustomers.

Procter&GamblesOldSpiceisthemassleaderandranksfifthintotalcategoryssales.
Salesremainflatat$25million.
While this brand is more aligned with shaving than with fine fragrance, the viral
advertising and video campaigns for its body wash products help grow its fragrance
sales.
The brand accounts for 14.7% of the mens mass market for scents, up from 14.1%
during2011.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Department stores remain the favored channel for the purchase of fragrances for men at
37%,downslightlyfrom2011levels.
Specialtystoresanddirectsales,bothexperiencegainsofonesharepointduringthe
year.
Thedirectchannelincreasesduetoonlinesalesfrombothbrickandmortarretailers,
suchasspecialtyanddepartmentstores,andInternetonlyretailers.
Cosmetic specialty stores, including Ulta and Sephora, grow as a shopping venue for
fragranceduetotheirwideproductassortments,promotions,andloyaltyprograms.

Table4C13:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforMeninthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Departmentstores

38

37

Massmerchandisers

20

19

Directsales

15

16

Specialtystores

15

16

Drugstores

11

11

Foodstores

100

100

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

FragrancesforMen

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Discountsandspecialpromotionsareofferedbymarketersandretailersinallclassesofthe
tradetohelppromotethefragrancesformencategory.
Consumerpromotionformensfragrancesincludespricerelatedprograms,sampling,
gifts,anddifferentinstoreactivities.
Sampling is particularly important for all trade classes and is becoming increasingly
importantasconsumerswanttotryaproductbeforetheybuyit.
Marketers also look at alternative promotional methods, including targeted event
sponsorships,samplingatdifferentvenues,andinteractivecampaignstohelpincrease
theexposureoftheirbrands.
Mostofthemajormarketersutilizesocialmediaandvideostopromotetheirscents.

Toreachyoungerandmoretechnologicallysavvyconsumers,brandsareusingtheInternet
andsocialmedia.
Brands reallocate their marketing budgets to include online advertising and viral
Internetcampaigns.
Blogger outreach is becoming a more important component of a brands marketing
effort with dissemination of product samples and literature to fashion and beauty
bloggers.
ManyfragrancebrandshaveFacebookpages,whereconsumerscanlikethebrandand
findoutthelatestnewproductsandpromotionalactivitiesofthebrand.

Giftwithpurchase (GWP) and purchasewithpurchase (PWP) offers are the domain of


luxurybrandsinthedepartmentstorechannelsandareprimepurchasedrivers.
Luxury marketers also employ sampling, giftsets with ancillary products which offer
great value as compared to purchasing these products individually, sample vials,
fragrancecards,andcatalogblowincardstostimulatesales.
Luxurybrandsalsoplacegreatemphasisandfocusoninstorepromotions.Marketers
oftenpartnerwithkeyretailersforadvertisingeffortsorinstoreevents.
In addition to GWP and PWP promotions, free samples are sometimes offered at a
luxurycounterinadepartmentstore,orwhenpurchasingonline.
Additionally,whenpurchasesaremadedirectlyorfromluxuryretailers,freeshipping
with beauty purchases over a certain amount is offered as a way to encourage
purchase.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C23

4C24

FragrancesforMen

Sampling is increasing in popularity, with scented strips in magazines and store catalogs,
scented blotter cards distributed at retail stores, and fragrance vials attached to cards or
distributedinretailstores.
Sampling is very important for the purchase of luxury fragrance and is a marketing
methodutilizedbydepartmentstoresandbeautyspecialtystores.Moststoresinthese
channelscanmakesamplevialsuponrequestforconsumerstotry.
These retailers also sometimes have premade samples and scent strips which they
obtaindirectlyfromthemanufacturer.
Sephoratypicallyoffersasamplersetduringtheholidayseasonandcontinuestosellit
until stocks run out. As in the past, the sampler set works on the same premise of
buyingoneofthesets,tryingallthesamples,choosingthescentpreferred,andthen
redeeming the enclosed gift certificate for a free fullsize bottle of the preferred
fragrance.

Continuinginpopularity,availableyearround,andgearedtocostconsciousconsumers,are
valueandgiftsets.
Thesesetsareattractivetoconsumersbecauseofthehighlevelofvaluetheyoffer,as
thereisgreatsavingsinpurchasingtheseproductsasaset,whencomparedtobuying
eachoneontheirown.
AtMacys,athreepiecefitsetwithavalueof$139.50isavailablefor$78.00fromPolo
Bleuthatincludesaneaudetoilette,anaftershave,andadeodorant.
Valueandgiftsetscanalsoincludearelatedproductthatisnotfragrancerelatedto
target the audience. At Macys, a complimentary duffle bag is available with the
purchaseofanylargesprayfromtheGivenchymensfragrancecollection.

Specialty retailers increasingly utilize many of the same marketing methods to encourage
salesasdepartmentstores.
Marketingmethodsinthischannelincludepromotions,instoresamplinganddisplays,
directtoconsumermailings,email,andmorerecentlysocialmedia.
A tactic utilized by several specialty retailers is the placement of fragrance samplers
along with fragrances near the checkout counters to encourage pointofpurchase
impulsepurchases.
Ulta frequently runs promotions to encourage the purchase of fragrances whereby
consumersreceiveawiderangeofgiftsthatchangeperiodically,suchasanovernight
bag,withaminimumamountspentonafragrancepurchase.
Afragrancealongwitharangeofancillaryproductsinamaleorientedtoteorshaving
bag,issometimespromotedbyspecialtyretailers.
Forexample,atUlta,afreedufflebagisavailablewithanylargespraypurchasefrom
CalvinKlein.
CustomersatUltaalsoreceiveafreetoiletrybagwithaBurberryTouchforMentravel
spray and after shave balm with the purchase of any largesized Burberry mens
fragrance.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

FragrancesforMen

Mass marketers utilize gift sets, coupons, and price discounts mostly promoted in their
weeklyflyerstohelpsellfragrancesformen.
Limitedsamplingisavailableinthischannel.
During theholidayselling season, mass merchandisers and drug chains typicallyoffer
promotionalpricingonthesaleofmensfragrances.

Direct marketers use their sales consultants and websites to promote new fragrances;
however,themarketingoffragrancesformenisnotthemainpriorityofmostdirectsales
companies.
Avon typically promotes new fragrances on the cover of its brochures at the time of
theirlaunch.
Scentstripsareoftenfeaturedincatalogs.
Otherpromotionalvehiclesincludemediaadvertising,discounts,andGWPoffers.

Intensemarketingeffortsincludingmediaadvertisements,sampling,anonlinecomponent,
social media, and other promotions including contests are typically used for both new
launchesandalsoclassicfragrances.
ForCalvinKleinsEncounterscent,actorAlexanderSkarsgardfromthetelevisionseries
True Blood along with model Lara Stone appear in print and broadcast advertising,
displayingthetensionanddesireinanencounterbetweenamanandwoman.
MontblancLegendisintroducedwithablackandwhiteadvertisingcampaignfeaturing
malemodelSimonClark.

Traceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs)formensfragrancesare$134.6millionin2012,down
from$204.9millionin2011.
LOral is the leader with TME at $63.5 million in 2012, down from $76.2million in
2011.
Procter&Gamblehasadvertisingexpendituresof$7.2million,downconsiderablyfrom
$33.4millionin2011.
CotyhasaTMEof$15.7million,downfrom$25.6millionin2011.
Fragrances for men are sometimes copromoted with their female versions, but this
jointadvertisingismostlycapturedinthewomenscategory.
DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

Slow growth is expected in the fragrances for mens category, as various challenges will
stymiesubstantialgrowth.
Despitegainsinthreeofthepastfiveyears,categorysalesarestillbelowprerecession
levelsandwillstruggletomoveforward,asfragrancesarenolongerthedailygrooming
necessityusedbymen.
Theuseoffragranceswillcontinuetobeoccasiondriven,ratherthanuseddaily.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C25

4C26

FragrancesforMen

Substantialgrowthinthiscategoryisreliantonanumberofoutsidefactors.
Theriseintelecommutingallowsworkerstodressmorecasually.
Thelowerlevelofformalityintheworkplaceascomparedtopriorgenerations.
Policies,bothofficialandunofficial,restrictingtheusefragranceintheworkplace
The trend towards the use of natural products which runs contrary to what most
fragrancesonthemarketareformulatingwith.
Theuseofotherscentedproductsforfragrantpurposesincludingscentedbodysprays,
deodorants,bodymists,andairproducts.

Thecategorywillbedominatedbyclassics;howevernewentrantsareexpectedtosucceed
iftheyoffersomethingnewandexciting.
FirstyearsalesofMontblancLegendandTheOneSportpostgoodresults.
Offering a scent that is unique and different to its audience can help a brand thrive
alongwithacomprehensivemarketingprogramandadequatesampling.

Challengeswillcontinuetoplaguethefragrancesformencategoryoverthenextfiveyears.
Consumersneedtobecomemorefamiliarwiththestorybehindthebrandandmore
intimatewithwhatthebrandstandsfor.
Brands need to become innovative in their interactions with consumers to better
engagewiththem.

Sales of fragrances for men are projected to grow at a low CAGR of 2.5% to total
$1,244millionin2017,upfrom$1,101millionin2012.

Table4C14:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforMenby
ProductTypeintheUnitedStates,2012and2017

$Million

Producttype

2012

Liquidproducts
Ancillaryproducts
Total

2017

CAGR,%

1,002

1,134

2.5

99

110

2.1

1,101

1,244

2.5

Unit sales are projected to increase slightly from 99.9million packages in 2012 to
104.0millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

The fragrances for women category advances, up 4% in 2012, for the third year in a row,
afterexperiencingbigdeclinesinboth2008and2009.
Sales reach $2,717million, up 4.0% from $2,612million in 2011, and finally exceed
salesof2007.

Saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of0.1%since2007.

Table4C15:HistoricalSalesofFragrancesforWomen
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012

Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

2,706

2008

2,546

(5.9)

2009

2,379

(6.6)

2010

2,444

2.7

2011

2,612

6.9

2012

2,717

4.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C28

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

LUXURY
CocoMademoiselle

Chanel

52

58

3.5

3.7

2.0

2.1

ChanelNo.5

Chanel

44

48

2.9

3.0

1.7

1.8

Dolce&GabbanaLightBlue

Procter&Gamble

44

43

2.9

2.7

1.7

1.6

Beautiful

EsteLauder

37

37

2.5

2.3

1.4

1.4

VivaLaJuicy

ElizabethArden

27

30

1.8

1.9

1.0

1.1

Angel

Clarins

25

27

1.7

1.7

1.0

1.0

Viktor&RolfFlowerbomb

L'Oral

22

27

1.5

1.7

0.8

1.0

CashmereMist

EsteLauder

25

26

1.7

1.6

1.0

1.0

J'adore

LVMH

22

26

1.5

1.6

0.8

1.0

Euphoria

Coty

24

23

1.6

1.5

0.9

0.8

Pleasures

EsteLauder

20

23

1.3

1.5

0.8

0.8

ChanceEauTendre

Chanel

18

20

1.2

1.3

0.7

0.7

Romance

L'Oral

20

20

1.3

1.3

0.8

0.7

Happy

EsteLauder

18

18

1.2

1.1

0.7

0.7

WhiteDiamonds

ElizabethArden

19

18

1.3

1.1

0.7

0.7

JimmyChoo

InterParfums

17

0.3

1.1

0.2

0.6

Chance

Chanel

15

16

1.0

1.0

0.6

0.6

DaisyEauSoFresh

Coty

15

15

1.0

0.9

0.6

0.6

GucciGuilty

Procter&Gamble

22

15

1.5

0.9

0.8

0.6

Philosophy

Coty

15

15

1.0

0.9

0.6

0.6

Trsor

L'Oral

17

15

1.1

0.9

0.7

0.6

AcquadiGioia

L'Oral

15

14

1.0

0.9

0.6

0.5

DaisyMarcJacobs

Coty

13

14

0.9

0.9

0.5

0.5

Dolce&GabbanaTheOne

Procter&Gamble

17

14

1.1

0.9

0.7

0.5

Girlfriend

ElizabethArden

14

0.9

0.5

LaVieEstBelle

L'Oral

14

0.9

0.5

MarcJacobsDot

Coty

14

0.9

0.5

CoachPoppy

EsteLauder

18

13

1.2

0.8

0.7

0.5

Eternity

Coty

13

13

0.9

0.8

0.5

0.5

Wonderstruck

ElizabethArden

24

13

1.6

0.8

0.9

0.5

BrightCrystal

EuroItaly

11

12

0.7

0.8

0.4

0.4

CKOne

Coty

11

12

0.7

0.8

0.4

0.4

PradaCandy

Coty

12

0.3

0.8

0.2

0.4

Shalimar

LVMH

12

12

0.8

0.8

0.5

0.4

AromaticsElixir

EsteLauder

11

11

0.7

0.7

0.4

0.4

ChanceEauFraiche

Chanel

10

11

0.7

0.7

0.4

0.4

Fame

Coty

11

0.7

0.4

Opium

L'Oral

12

11

0.8

0.7

0.5

0.4

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

4C29

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
PinkFriday

ElizabethArden

SensuousNude

EsteLauder

11

0.7

0.4

10

11

0.7

0.7

0.4

0.4

TruthorDare

Coty

BurberryBody

InterParfums

11

0.7

0.4

10

10

0.7

0.6

0.4

0.4

Coco

Chanel

10

10

0.7

0.6

0.4

0.4

GucciPremiere

Procter&Gamble

RedDoor

ElizabethArden

10

0.6

0.4

11

10

0.7

0.6

0.4

0.4

Someday

ElizabethArden

35

10

2.3

0.6

1.3

0.4

BondNo.9Classics
Chloe

BondNo.9

0.5

0.6

0.3

0.3

Coty

0.5

0.6

0.3

0.3

MissDiorCherie

LVMH

0.6

0.6

0.3

0.3

WonderstruckEnchanted

ElizabethArden

0.6

0.3

YouthDew

EsteLauder

0.6

0.6

0.3

0.3

BurberryBrit

InterParfums

0.5

0.5

0.3

0.3

CocoNoir

Chanel

0.5

0.3

JuicyCouture

ElizabethArden

0.6

0.5

0.3

0.3

Obsession

Coty

0.5

0.5

0.3

0.3

VeryIrresistible

LVMH

0.5

0.5

0.3

0.3

Alien

Clarins

0.4

0.4

0.2

0.3

Allure

Chanel

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

ArmaniCodeforWomen

L'Oral

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

BeDelicious

EsteLauder

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

CoachPoppyFlower

EsteLauder

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

FanDiFendi

LVMH

0.4

0.4

0.2

0.3

JoMalone

EsteLauder

0.4

0.4

0.2

0.3

L'Eaud'Issey

Shiseido

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

Lovestruck

Coty

0.4

0.4

0.2

0.3

Miracle

L'Oral

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

Oh,Lola!MarcJacobs

Coty

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

Sensuous

EsteLauder

10

0.7

0.4

0.4

0.3

VeraWangPrincess

Coty

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

WhiteLinen

EsteLauder

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.3

CoachSignature

EsteLauder

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

FlorabyGucci

Procter&Gamble

0.5

0.4

0.3

0.2

Knowing

EsteLauder

0.4

0.4

0.2

0.2

BCBGMaxAzria

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

EdHardyBornWild

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

EdHardyWomen

ElizabethArden

11

0.7

0.3

0.4

0.2

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C30

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
ForbiddenEuphoria

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

HappyHeart

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Heat

Coty

0.6

0.3

0.3

0.2

HeatRush

Coty

10

0.7

0.3

0.4

0.2

Hypnose

L'Oral

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.2

LoveChloe

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

MichaelbyMichaelKors

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

NarcisoRodriguez

Shiseido

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Pulse

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Ralph

L'Oral

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.2

Reb'lFleur

ParluxFragrances

13

0.9

0.3

0.5

0.2

BigPony2

L'Oral

0.3

0.1

CoutureCouture

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Este

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Fancy

ParluxFragrances

0.5

0.3

0.3

0.1

FancyLove

ParluxFragrances

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

FlorabyGucciEauFraiche

Procter&Gamble

0.2

0.3

0.1

0.1

Glowing

Coty

0.3

0.1

HanaeMori

International
Cosmetics&Perfumes

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Inspire

Procter&Gamble

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Lola

Coty

0.6

0.3

0.3

0.1

LuckyYou

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Oscar

L'Oral

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

PradaInfusionD'Iris

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Pretty

ElizabethArden

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Pure

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

TheBeat

InterParfums

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

TrsorInLove

L'Oral

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

VeraWang

Coty

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.1

Villain

ElizabethArden

0.2

0.3

0.1

0.1

Amarige

LVMH

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Boucheron

L'Oral

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

CKBeauty

Coty

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

CoolWaterWoman

Coty

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

FantasyBritneySpears

ElizabethArden

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

GucciByGucci

Procter&Gamble

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Hearts&Daggers

ElizabethArden

0.6

0.2

0.3

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

4C31

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
L'AirDuTemps

Coty

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Lovely

Coty

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

MarcJacobs

Coty

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

ParisHilton

ParluxFragrances

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

Queen

ParluxFragrances

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

VeryIrresistibleIntense

LVMH

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Womanity

Clarins

0.1

0.2

0.1

0.1

BabyPhatGoddess

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

BeautifulLove

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Believe

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

BeyondParadise

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

ByNight

Procter&Gamble

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

CircusFantasy

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Eat,Pray,Love

LVMH

0.2

0.1

0.1

0.1

EdHardyLove&Luck

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Eva

FalicFashionGroup

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Forever

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Fresh

LVMH

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

GlowbyJLo

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

GucciEnvyMe

Procter&Gamble

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

GuessbyMarciano

Coty

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

JessicaMcClintock

J.McClintock

0.2

0.1

0.1

0.1

LollipopBling

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Organza

LVMH

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

PalomaPicasso

L'Oral

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Peace,Love,&Juicy

ElizabethArden

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

PleasuresDelight

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

PleasuresExotic

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

PureWhiteLinen

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

SalvatoreFerragamo

FerragamoParfums

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

TommyGirl

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

TrsorMidnightRose

L'Oral

0.2

0.1

0.1

0.1

UnforgivableWoman

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

VeryHollywoodMichaelKors

EsteLauder

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

BurberryLondon

InterParfums

0.1

0.1

BurberrySportforWomen

InterParfums

0.1

0.1

EaudeCartier

ParfumsCartier

0.1

0.1

FairyDust

ParluxFragrances

0.1

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C32

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

LUXURY(Continued)
Allother

Chanel

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Allother

EsteLauder

0.6

0.6

0.3

0.3

Allother

ElizabethArden

12

12

0.8

0.8

0.5

0.4

Allother

LVMH

21

22

1.4

1.4

0.8

0.8

Allother

Procter&Gamble

26

27

1.7

1.7

1.0

1.0

Allother

L'Oral

26

27

1.7

1.7

1.0

1.0

Allother

Coty

29

30

1.9

1.9

1.1

1.1

156

170

10.4

10.7

6.0

6.3

1,505

1,582

100.0

100.0

57.6

58.2

Allother

Total
SPECIALTY
Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

248

260

35.7

35.2

9.5

9.6

VSFantasies

LimitedBrands

100

105

14.4

14.2

3.8

3.9

DreamAngels

LimitedBrands

95

100

13.7

13.5

3.6

3.7

Bombshell

LimitedBrands

50

53

7.2

7.2

1.9

2.0

Pink

LimitedBrands

25

27

3.6

3.7

1.0

1.0

Angel

LimitedBrands

24

26

3.5

3.5

0.9

1.0

Gorgeous

LimitedBrands

24

26

3.5

3.5

0.9

1.0

Abercrombie&Fitch

Abercrombie&Fitch

19

20

2.7

2.7

0.7

0.7

Gap

TheGap

17

16

2.4

2.2

0.7

0.6

VerySexyforHer

LimitedBrands

14

15

2.0

2.0

0.5

0.6

BananaRepublic

TheGap

10

12

1.4

1.6

0.4

0.4

Incredible

LimitedBrands

TheBodyShop

L'Oral

Rapture

10

1.4

0.4

10

10

1.4

1.4

0.4

0.4

LimitedBrands

0.9

0.8

0.2

0.2

SexyLittleThings

LimitedBrands

0.9

0.8

0.2

0.2

AmericanEagle

AmericanEagle

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Bebe

Bebe

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Crabtree&Evelyn

Crabtree&Evelyn

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.1

HenriBendel

LimitedBrands

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Allother

LimitedBrands

Allother

Total

1.0

0.3

0.3

0.1

31

33

4.5

4.5

1.2

1.2

695

739

100.0

100.0

26.6

27.2

MASS
HalleBerry

Coty

12

12

5.8

6.1

0.5

0.4

JovanMusk

Coty

12

12

5.8

6.1

0.5

0.4

CalgonBodyMists

Coty

10

4.4

5.1

0.3

0.4

DoveBodyMists

Unilever

4.4

4.5

0.3

0.3

CelineDion

Coty

4.4

4.0

0.3

0.3

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

4C33

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

MASS(Continued)
BodyFantasies

YellowWoodPartners

3.9

3.5

0.3

0.3

FaithHill

Coty

2.9

3.0

0.2

0.2

DegreeBodyMists

Unilever

2.4

2.5

0.2

0.2

SecretBodyMists

Procter&Gamble

1.5

2.0

0.1

0.1

Shania

Coty

1.9

2.0

0.2

0.1

WhiteShoulders

ElizabethArden

1.9

2.0

0.2

0.1

Chantilly

DanaClassic
Fragrances

1.9

1.5

0.2

0.1

JeanNat

Revlon

1.9

1.5

0.2

0.1

Tabu

DanaClassic
Fragrances

1.5

1.5

0.1

0.1

AntonioBanderas

Coty

1.5

1.0

0.1

0.1

LadyStetson

Coty

1.0

1.0

0.1

0.1

Love'sBabySoft

DanaClassic
Fragrances

1.5

1.0

0.1

0.1

VanillaFields

Coty

1.5

1.0

0.1

0.1

WildMusk

Coty

1.5

1.0

0.1

0.1

WindSong

YellowWoodPartners

1.5

1.0

0.1

0.1

AdidasMovesforHer

Coty

1.0

0.5

0.1

Charlie

Revlon

1.0

0.5

0.1

Ciara

Revlon

0.5

0.5

Primo!

YellowWoodPartners

1.0

0.5

0.1

Privatelabel

Privatelabel

35

37

17.0

18.7

1.3

1.4

Allother

Coty

16

14

7.8

7.1

0.6

0.5

39

41

18.9

20.7

1.5

1.5

206

198

100.0

100.0

7.9

7.3

Allother

Total

DIRECT
UnpluggedforHer

Avon

16

8.1

0.6

OutspokenIntensebyFergie

Avon

14

15

6.8

7.6

0.5

0.6

OutspokenbyFergie

Avon

12

13

5.8

6.6

0.5

0.5

Imari

Avon

11

11

5.3

5.6

0.4

0.4

EternalMagic

Avon

10

10

4.9

5.1

0.4

0.4

MyLife

Carol'sDaughter

10

3.9

5.1

0.3

0.4

Today

Avon

10

10

4.9

5.1

0.4

0.4

FarAway

Avon

3.9

4.0

0.3

0.3

ImariSeduction

Avon

3.9

4.0

0.3

0.3

RareGold

Avon

3.9

4.0

0.3

0.3

RareDiamonds

Avon

3.4

3.5

0.3

0.3

Haiku

Avon

2.9

3.0

0.2

0.2

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C34

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C16:Manufacturers'SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

DIRECT(Continued)
ThinkingofYou

MaryKay

2.4

3.0

0.2

0.2

Mark

Avon

2.9

2.5

0.2

0.2

StepIntoSexy

Avon

1.9

2.5

0.2

0.2

Tomorrow

Avon

2.4

2.5

0.2

0.2

BelaBelara

MaryKay

1.9

2.0

0.2

0.1

ExpressionsbyReeseWitherspoon

Avon

14

6.8

1.5

0.5

0.1

Journey

MaryKay

1.5

1.5

0.1

0.1

Velocity

MaryKay

1.5

1.5

0.1

0.1

Affection

MaryKay

2.4

1.0

0.2

0.1

Always

Avon

1.9

1.0

0.2

0.1

Belara

MaryKay

1.0

1.0

0.1

0.1

Candid

Avon

0.5

0.5

HerveLegerFemme

Avon

2.9

0.5

0.2

Allother

Avon

22

12

10.7

6.1

0.8

0.4

Allother

MaryKay

12

12

5.8

6.1

0.5

0.4

10

3.9

5.1

0.3

0.4

206

198

100.0

100.0

2,612

2,717

Allother
Total
TOTAL

7.9

7.3

100.0

100.0

Unitsales

Unitsalesoffragrancesforwomenincreasefrom155.0millionpackagesin2011,up3.2%
to160millionpackagesin2012.

Retailsales

Salesattheretaillevelareestimatedat$4,363millionin2012,upfrom$4,191millionin
2011.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Forthethirdyearinarow,thefragrancesforwomencategorygrowscomparedtotheprior
year.
Salesfor2012grow4.0%andarethehighestsince2007.
Unitsalesmoveupwards,growing3.2%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

FragrancesforWomen

The fragrances for women category is trending upward, but sales have just reached pre
recessionlevels.
Growthof4.0%fortheyearisbehindthegrowthof6.9%during2011.
The category is negatively affected by the uncertain economy, the devastation by
Superstorm Sandy in the Northeast, along with the senseless shootings of innocent
Americans,whichhelpedstifletheholidayspirit.
Thegrowthofthefragrancescategorycontinuestobedependentonholidaysales.
Additionally,anincreaseinforeigntouristswhousefragrancesonaregularbasisfindit
lessexpensivetopurchaseintheUnitedStatesthanintheirhomeland,alsohelpsgrow
thecategoryssales.
Thespecialtytradeclassexperiencesthehighestgrowthrate,up6.3%,followedbythe
luxurytradeclassat5.1%.
Boththemassandthedirecttradeclassesobservedecliningsales.

The categorys growth continues to be driven by classics, such as Chanels Coco


Mademoiselle, Chanel No.5, and Chance; along with the expansion of popular franchises,
suchasElizabethArdensJuicyandCotysMarcJacobs.
Classicsandbrandsfromestablishedmarketersandfranchises,exhibitthemostvigor.

As in 2011, several new celebrity scents launched in 2012 are targeted at younger
consumersattractingsomeofthemtothefragrancecounterforthefirsttime.
These new celebrity scents include Elizabeth Ardens Justin Beibers Girlfriend, Nicki
MinajsPinkFridayandTaylorSwiftsWonderstruckEnchanted;andCotysLadyGagas
Fame;andMadonnasTruthorDare.

Attheoppositeextreme,nichescentsalsohelptogrowthefragrancesforwomencategory.
Scents from marketers, such as By Kilian, Maison Frances Kurkdjian, Houbigant Paris,
Creed, and Bond No. 9, create excitement in the industry and offer a point of
differentiation.
These scents are priced as high as several hundred dollars, based on their ingredient
compositionandtheirstayingpower.
The appeal of niche scents is that these scents are not meant for the masses due to
their high price and limited distribution, and therefore offer a distinctive opportunity
forapersontosmelldifferentfromtheircolleaguesandfriends.
While collectively these scents are estimated to account for about 5% of the total
fragrancesforwomenmarketintheluxurytradeclass,eachofthesescentsindividually
hassmallsalesandisnottrackedinthisreport.
Nichescentsaretypicallynotlargeenoughinvolumeforthelargecompaniestooffer,
especiallywiththeirselectdistributiontohighendboutiquesanddepartmentstores,
suchasNeimanMarcus,BergdorfGoodman,andBarneys.
Highend retailers are interested in these scents as they carry a higher margin than
mainstream brands, and allow them to carry a different assortment of scents from
thosefoundindepartmentstores.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C35

4C36

FragrancesforWomen

Growthinthefragrancesforwomencategoryoccursinthefollowingareas:
Both, the luxury trades class and the specialty trade class experience aboveaverage
growthat5.1%and6.3%,respectively.
The other trade classes of mass and direct experience declines in 2012. Avon is
responsibleforthedeclineinthedirecttradeclass.
Classicsandbrandsfromestablishedhousesexperiencethemostgrowthduring2012.
New celebrity scents targeting younger female consumers create some energy in the
category.
Majorbeautycompaniesalignwithfashiondesignersoraccessoryhousestodevelop
newscents.

Thetrendtowardsmorenaturalpersonalcareproductscouldbeoneofthefactorsstifling
realgrowthinthefragrancescategory.
The media reports the possibility of harmful ingredients in fragrance products which
couldaffectthehormonesandtheendocrinesystem.
Few fine fragrances contain all natural ingredients; most fragrances include synthetic
ingredients.
Furthermore, all personal care products are required to display their ingredient
composition on the package, with only a few exceptions. Fragrance formulations are
considered trade secrets and are exempt from disclosure; hence, there is a push by
variousadvocacygroupstomakeitmandatorytohavetheseingredientsmadepublic.
Instead body sprays, scented body washes, and hand and body lotions, and even air
products, such as candles and room scents, are utilized as a replacement for fine
fragrances.

Inaddition,thereareanumberofotherfactorsthatcontributetothelackofrobustgrowth
inthefragranceindustry.
Fragrancesaresavedforspecialoccasionsratherthandailyuse,reducingoverallusage.
This decline in usage can partly be attributed to the more casual workplaces where
employees do not get dressed up as much as in the past, coupled with more people
workingfromhomeonaregularbasis.
Inacontinuingtrend,consumersnolongerownawidearrayoffragrances,butrather
juststicktoone,orafewsignaturescents.

A further challenge to the industry is the movement to ban the wearing of fragrances at
workplaces, which is gaining awareness in some areas of the United States, negatively
affectingthecategorysfuturesales.
InDecember2012,NewHampshireintroducesalegislationbarringstateemployeesin
contactwithmembersofthepublicfromwearingfragrancesduringtheworkday.
Private employers and other government agencies in the United States and Canada
haveimplementedbansonthewearingoffragranceintheworkplace,suchasthecity
ofDetroit,MI;Portland,OR,andattheU.S.CensusBureau.
In Europe, there is a movement to ban fragrances that include certain ingredients
includingthetopsellingChanelNo.5whichissaidtoincludeatreemossthatcanset
offallergicreactions.AsimilarmovementcouldpotentiallyspreadtotheUnitedStates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

FragrancesforWomen

Flankers,lineextensions,andmigrationofscentstosecondarychannelscontributetothe
declineinbrandequityandposeanothersetofchallengestotheindustry.
Marketerscontinuetolaunchflankers,whichcapitalizeonthemasterscent,butata
slower pace than in the past. The main issue with flankers is that when attention is
placedonthenewintroduction,themainbrandtypicallyexhibitsdecliningsales.
Procter&GamblesGucciGuiltydeclinesnearly32%duringtheyear,withthelaunchof
GucciPremiere.
Coty and Elizabeth Arden offer luxury scents in mass channels after it has been on
counterforafewmonths.
Sometimesthisisintentionallydonebymarketerstohelpgrowsales,oristheresultof
divertedgoods,butineithercase,thesepracticesconfuseandfrustratetheconsumer,
contributingtotheerosionofthebrandsequity.

Another challenge is that the retail environment for fragrances continues to evolve, as
consumersareincreasinglyvalueconscious.
Retailersstarttheholidaysellingseasonearly,andofferpromotionalpricingonholiday
items from as early as October. However, most of the promotional pricing does not
applytofragranceandbeautyitems.
Giftwithpurchase (GWP) and purchasewithpurchase (PWP) are powerful luxury
beauty goods drivers, and consumers typically plan their purchase around these
offeringswhichoccursonlyalimitednumberoftimesduringtheyear.
Celebrityfragrances,launchedintheluxurytradeclass,areofferedforsaleinthemass
channelsforashortperiodoftime,typicallyatlowerpricepoints,enticingconsumers
towaitforthepricetobereduced.
In a growing trend, giftcard purchases are increasing as they offer the receiver the
opportunitytoactuallypickoutthegifttheywant.
Consumers often prefer todo their holiday shopping online, which is not suitable for
fragrancepurchasing.

Fragrancesforwomenpackagingcontinuestobecomemoreinnovativeandhelpscreatean
urgetobuyatthepointofpurchase.
While the classic scents are in classic type bottles, many of the newer scents have
interestingbottledesignstohelpcreateabuzz.LancmesLaVieEstBelleaimstobea
classicandishousedinaredesignedversionofa1949classicbottle.
MarcJacobsDotresemblesaredandblackladybug.
NickiMinajsPinkFridayisacaricatureofherselfandfeaturesabustwithagoldface,
pinkwig,andhergoldnameplatenecklace.
Justin Beibers Girlfriend is a purple heartshaped bottle housed inside a pink and
purpleslinkytypecasing.
Black packaging is popular among some new launches during 2012 including Lady
GagasFame,MadonnasTruthorDare,andChanelsNoir.
JenniferLopezsGlowingsbottlelightsupandglowsfor15secondsafterspraying.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C37

4C38

FragrancesforWomen

Newfragranceformscontinuetoremainpopular.
Following a trends that has been popular for several years, rollerballs still have high
momentum among young consumers due to their lower price points and ability to
storeinthepurseorworkdesk.Somebrandsalsoofferrollerballcollections,suchas
MarcJacobsthatoffersarollerballtrioofitstopsellingscents.
Some brands offer spray pens which are the same size as the rollerball but with a
sprayheadinsteadofarollontipintheircollection.JuicyCoutureoffersaspraypen
collectionofthreescents.
Packaging that includes charms as rings, pendants, and other items helps to keep
interest high among the younger, more costconscious consumers. Sample size
collectionscontinuetobepopular.
Smallsizesappropriatefortravelandsamplesizecollection,suchascoffretscontinue
tobepopularandappealtoconsumersduetothevaluepricingandvarietyofscents.
Viktor&RolfsFlowerbombcomesinatravelduo,andChloesscentsareavailableasa
miniatureduo.

Toolsandeventsareutilizedtohelpconsumersnarrowdownfragrancepurchases.
Itisnotknownyethowsuccessfulthesetoolsreallyare,butmanyareofferedtohelp
guidetheconsumertothescentthatmightbeappropriateforthem.
Retailers,bothinstoreandonline,includingMacys,Nordstrom,Sephora,andBath&
Body Works offer fragrance finder tools to help consumers discover their fragrance
personalityandthescentmostappropriateforthem.
SephoralaunchesFragranceFlightBarsatsomeofitslocationsduring2012,whichare
basedoffitsSensoriumlimitedengagementmultiscentsoryexperienceshowcasedat
one Manhattan location during 2011. These Fragrance Flight Bars allow customers to
checkoutscentsbasedontheir"impressions,"ratherthanbytraditionalfragranceThe
scents are in unbranded containers and are classified asAddictive, Playful, Casual or
Chicallowingpeopletoexperiencehoweachfragrancemakesthemfeel.Inthehope
thatfragrancepurchasingwillbeaneasierandmorerewardingexperience.
Sniffapalooza invites perfume enthusiasts, representatives from fragrance houses,
journalists, authors, and celebrities from around the world to various events that
includeworkshopsandpreviewsofnewlauncheswithperfumers.
Specialeventsfromretailersoccurseveraltimesduringtheyeartoacquaintconsumers
withnewscentsandoffersamplestopotentialcustomers.NordstromhostsaBeauty
Trend show that travels across the country, and a fragrance event that acquaints
consumers with new scents and other products. In 2012, Bath & Body Works hosts
AmericasFavoriteFragranceevent.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

FragrancesforWomen

Retailerscontinuetobeselectiveaboutthescentstheycarry,astheyareafraidofbeingleft
withunsoldinventoryasexperiencedwhentherecessionfirststarted.
Departmentandspecialtystorestypicallyplayitsafewithclassicscentsandonlyadd
newfragrancesfromsuccessfulbrandsorfranchises.Highenddepartmentstoresstay
awayfromcelebrityscentsasthesequicklymigratetomassretailers.
Department and specialty stores carefully monitor their fragrance inventory and are
frequentlyoutofstockonthemostindemandscents.
The department store channel reduces the number of sales associates, driving the
consumertoshopfromotherchannels.

M&Aactivity

A number of new licensing agreements and corporate developments are signed or take
effectduring2012,withmoreannouncedfor2013.
AlfredDunhillannouncesthatitisswitchinglicensingpartnerseffectiveApril2013,to
InterParfumsina10yeardealfromProcter&Gamble.
InterParfumshastwomajorlicensechangesduringtheyear.
ItacquiresthefragrancelicenseofKarlLagerfieldinearly2012fromCoty.
InterParfumslosesthefragrancelicenseofBurberry,asthecompanytakesownership
ofitsownfragrancelicenseasof2013.
Kenneth Cole signs a licensing deal with Parlux effective January 2013, after 10 years
withCoty.
CotywhichhasdistributedPuigsfragrancesinNorthAmericaforthepastsixyearswill
ceasedoingsowhenthelicenseexpiresonJune30,2013.
Inlate2012,CotysignssingerKatyPerryforanewlineoffragrancestobedeveloped
andmarketedbyCoty.
ClarinsFragranceGroupwilldistributePuigsfragrancesinNorthAmericaeffectiveJuly
1,2013.
Elizabeth Arden acquires the global fragrance licenses of Ed Hardy, True Religion, and
BCBGMaxAzriafromNewWaveFragrancesinmid2012.Italsoacquiresthefragrance
licensesofJustinBieberandNickiMinajfromGiveBackBrands,LLC.
YellowWoodPartnersacquiresParumsdeCoeur,Ltdinfall2012.

Notablenewproducts

Thereareanumberofnotablenewlaunchesthathaveconsiderablesalesduring2012and
addexcitementtothecategoryandinclude:
LaVieEstBelle(LOral)$14million
Girlfriend(ElizabethArden)$14million
MarcJacobsDot(Coty)$14million
Fame(Coty)$11million
PinkFriday(ElizabethArden)$11million
TruthorDare(Coty)$11million
GucciPremiere(Procter&Gamble)$10million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C39

4C40

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C17:SelectNewFragrancesforWomenIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Avon

JonBonJovi

UnpluggedforHerisacollaborationbetweenAvonandJonBonJoviofferingfloral
orientalcompositionstartingwithgourmetnotesofplumandcitrus

Chanel

CocoNoir

ChanelsnewscentwithtopnotesofgrapefruitandCalabrianbergamotfollowed
byaheartofrose,narcissus,rosegeraniumleaf,andjasmine

Coty

HalleBerry

Closerisconsideredamodernfemininefloralthatopenswithaccordsofozone,
wildraspberry,andwaterlily

Coty

JenniferLopez

Glowingisawoodyfloralwithtopnotesofbergamot,mandarin,andcypressina
bottlethatlightsupandglowsfor15secondsafterused

Coty

LadyGaga

LadyGagasdebutscent,Fameisbuiltonthreemainaccords:darkaccord,sensual
accord,andlightaccord.ThedarkaccordincludespoisonousflowerBelladonna
andincense.Scentspraysonblackandturnsclearontheskin,andishousedina
blackbottle

Coty

Madonna

TruthorDareisMadonnasfirstscentandisdescribedasbeingbothlightanddark,
openingwithnotesofgardenia,creamytuberose,andneroli

Coty

MarcJacobs

Dotisfloralfruity,surroundedwithexoticnotesofcoconutandwrappedinsoft
vanillainaladybuginspiredbottle

ElizabethArden

JustinBeiber

GirlfriendisJustinBeiberssecondscentandisgearedtohisadolescentfanbase.
Topnotesincludemandarin,blackberry,pear,andstrawberry

ElizabethArden

NickiMinaj

FirstfragrancefromNickiMinajPinkFridayisnamedafterherfirstalbumofthe
samename,isafloralmuskcontainingnotesofpinkflowerpetals,creamyvanilla,
musk,andwoods.ThefragranceishousedinabustshapedbottleofMinaj
completewithapinkwig

ElizabethArden

TaylorSwift

WonderstruckEnchantedisthesecondfragrance,presentedasaflankerfromthe
youngpopcountrysingerTaylorSwift.Scentisanorientalgourmandthatopens
withnotesofwildberries,pinkpoppy,andpassionfruit.Asintheoriginal,the
bottleisadornedwithdanglingcharms

EsteLauder

DonnaKaren

Womanhastopnotesofsandalwoodandorangeblossom

LOral

Lancme

LaVieEstBellereportedlytookthreeyearstoformulatewithIrisasthekey
ingredientsurroundedbyorangeblossomsandjasmine.Theflaconisaredesigned
versionofaclassicLancmebottlefrom1949

LOral

RalphLauren

BigPonyforHeristhefourfragrancefemalecounterpartofthemenscollection
witheachscentnumberedfromonetofourandhousedinclearbottleswhich
showthebrightlycoloredjuice

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

Newscentsduring2012include:CashmereGlow,ForeverRed,andLoveLoveLove

LimitedBrands

VictoriasSecret

Incredible,namedafterthelingerielaunchofthesamename,isafloralfruityscent
withtopnotesofwhitepeachcombinedwithpearandlotusaccords

Procter&Gamble

Gucci

GucciPremiereissaidtobeinspiredbygownsfromtheGucciPremierecouture
collectionwithtopnotesofbergamotandorangeblossom

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Allproductcategoriesexperienceincrease,inlinewiththetotalmarket.
The largest dollar volume increase is in the perfumes, toilet waters, and colognes
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C18:SalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

$Million

Producttype

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

1,943

2,021

74.4

74.4

4.0

418

435

16.0

16.0

4.1

2,361

2,456

90.4

90.4

4.0

251

261

9.6

9.6

4.0

2,612

2,717

100.0

100.0

4.0

LIQUIDPRODUCTS
Perfumes,toiletwaters,andcolognes
Bodymistsandsplashes
Total
ANCILLARYPRODUCTS
TOTAL

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4C19:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012
$Million
Company

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

LimitedBrands

602

639

23.0

23.5

6.1

Coty

315

345

12.1

12.7

9.5

EsteLauder

244

238

9.3

8.8

(2.5)

ElizabethArdena

201

188

7.7

6.9

(6.5)

LOral

167

181

6.4

6.7

8.4

Chanel

159

181

6.1

6.7

13.8

Avon

156

146

6.0

5.4

(6.4)

Procter&Gamble

133

134

5.9

4.9

0.8

LVMH

91

96

3.5

3.5

5.5

MaryKay

34

32

1.3

1.2

(5.9)

Clarins

33

37

1.3

1.4

12.1

InterParfums

28

41

1.1

1.5

46.4

TheGap

27

28

1.0

1.0

3.7

Parlux

34

20

1.3

0.7

(41.2)

Abercrombie&Fitch

19

20

0.7

0.7

5.3

335

391

12.8

14.4

16.7

Allother

Change,%

Total
2,612
2,717
100.0
100.0
4.0

aElizabethArdenpurchasesthefragrancebrandsofNewWaveFragrancesandGiveBackBrands
during2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C41

4C42

FragrancesforWomen

LimitedBrandscontinuestobetheleaderasthelargestmarketeroffragrancesforwomen,
witha23.5%shareduring2012,upfrom23.0%in2011.
Salesgrow6.1%duringtheyearfrom$602millionin2011to$639millionin2012.
All divisions of Limited Brands contribute to the companys growth as Bath & Body
Works,VictoriasSecret,andPinkexperiencegainsin2011.
New scents launched on a regular basis at favorable price points, along with
promotionalpricingonmultiplepurchasesistheprimestrategyforthesebrands.
Thesemiannualsalesprovidesignificantdiscountsonproductstomovemerchandise,
andmakewayfornewitemsisthekeypromotionaleventoftheyear.
NewscentsfromBath&BodyWorksduringtheyearincludeCashmereGlow,Forever
Red,andLoveLoveLove.
Bath & Body Work repackages its body splashes and relaunches them as fragrance
mistsinearly2012.
The major womens fragrance launch for Victorias Secret is Incredible, launched at
approximatelythesametimeasthebraofthesamename.
Both Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret experience enormous success in the
fragrances for women category, after having tried to capture the fragrances for men
categorytonoavail.

Cotyisthesecondleadingmarketer,commanding12.7%oftotalsalesin2012andgrowing
by9.5%from2011.
Coty continues to compete in both the luxury and mass trade classes with an
assortmentofcelebrityanddesignerscentsandworkstobecomeaglobalfragrance
leader.
The company scouts hot celebrities and develops scents under their names.
Celebrities that offer debut scents with Coty during 2012 include Lady Gaga and
Madonna.
Aside from the debut of Lady Gagas Fame and Madonnas Truth or Dare, the only
othermajorfemalefragrancelaunchesoftheyearareMarcJacobsDotandJennifer
LopezGlowing.
Coty launches a series of new scents in early 2013 including Guess Girl and See by
Chloe.
The only major mass launch for Coty during 2012 is an extension of the Halle Berry
franchise,Closer.

EsteLauderremainsinthirdplacewiththreeofthetop11luxuryfragrances.
Thecompanyhasan8.8%categoryshare,downfrom9.3%in2011,assalesdip2.5%
duringtheyear.
Beautifulssalesareflatfrom2011,whileCashmereMistandPleasureshaveincreasing
sales.Thesethreearethecompanyslargestfragrancebrands.
Asidefromscentsunderthemajorbeautybrands,suchasEsteLauderandClinique,
the company works to put together a portfolio of designer brands including Donna
Karan, Coach, Michael Kors, Tommy Hilfiger, and more recently Ermenegildo Zegna,
ToryBurch,andMarni.ThecompanyacquiredthefragrancefranchisesforZenga,Burch,
andMarniinlate2011,andishandledbytheAramisandDesignerFragrancesdivision
ofEsteLauder.
TheDonnaKaranfranchiseisextendedin2012withthefalllaunchofWoman.
InitialscentsfromZengaandMarnilaunchinearly2013,andanewCoachscentcalled
LovelaunchesintimeforValentinesDay.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

FragrancesforWomen

ElizabethArdenmovesintofourthplacewiththeacquisitionoffragrancebrandsfromNew
WaveFragrancesandGiveBackBrands.
Via these acquisitions Elizabeth Arden acquires the global fragrance licenses of Ed
Hardy,TrueReligionandBCBGMaxAzriafromNewWaveFragrancesinmid2012.The
companyalsoacquiresthefragrancelicensesofJustinBieberandNickiMinajfromGive
BackBrands,LLC.
These acquisitions help Elizabeth Arden achieve a 6.9% share in the fragrances for
womencategory.However,overallsalesdeclineby6.5%.
Salesdropfrom$201millionin2011to$188millionin2012.
SalesdeclineduetothesoftnessinthenewlyacquiredEdHardyfranchise,alongwitha
salesdropofthefirstJustinBeiberscent,andweaknesswiththesecondscent.
ThemajornewscentfromElizabethArdenduring2012isNickiMinajsPinkFridayand
JustinBeibersGirlfriend.

LOraldropstofifthplacewith6.7%shareandsalesup8.4%to$181million.
ThebiglaunchoftheyearisLaVieEstBellewhichachievessalesof$14millionwith
justafewmonthsoncounter.
Viktor & Rolf Flowerbomb continues to grow with an increasing distribution as this
scentjoinsthetop10withjustafewyearsoncounter.
TheonlyothermajorlaunchduringtheyearisthefemaleversionsoftheRalphLauren
Polocollection;however,thesedidnotperformaswellastheirmalecounterparts.

Bybrand

Bath&BodyWorks(LimitedBrands)remainstheleadingbrandinthecategory,withsales
up4.8%from$248millionin2011to$260millionin2012.
The brand holds a 35.2% share of the specialty segment and a 9.6% share of the
category.
New fragrances added to its portfolio in 2012 include Cashmere Glow, Forever Red,
andLoveLoveLove.
Since2009,Bath&BodyWorkshasaddedhighendscentscomposedofseveralnotes
toitsportfolio,suchasCashmereGlow,ForeverRed,andLoveLoveLovelaunchedin
2012However,thebrandstilloffersseveralofitsclassicscents,wherethenameofthe
scentisdescriptiveofthefragrancenotes,suchasCountryAppleandCitrusMelon.
Bath&BodyWorksfragrancesaretypicallysomeofthelowestpricedscentsfoundat
theshoppingmallandthesefavorablepricepointsalongwithfrequentpromotionsand
twosemiannualsaleshelpgrowthebrand.
Promotionsareimportantforthesuccessofthisbrandwhichareofferedyearround
andincludebuythreegettwofreeandbuythreegetthreefreeoffers.
Additionally, the special online fragrance exclusive promotions are offered on the
brandswebsite.
Smallsizescentsalongwithtravelsizeversionsofnewreleasesaresoldnearthecash
registertoencouragetrialandimpulsepurchasing.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C43

4C44

FragrancesforWomen

VS Fantasies (Limited Brands), formerly Victorias Secrets Garden, is the secondlargest


brand in the category, with a 5.0% increase in sales from $100million in 2011 to
$105millionin2012.
VS Fantasies accounts for 14.2% of the specialty trade class and 3.9% of overall
fragrancessales.
Newscentsareaddedtotheline,andunderperformingonesarediscontinued.
Thecollectioncontinuestodowellduetoitsattractivepricepointsandregularlyoffers
promotionsofthreefor$24.00,orfivefor$30.00.

TheDreamAngelsmasterfranchisefromVictoriasSecret(LimitedBrands),ranksthirdwith
salesof$100million,up5.3%from$95millionin2011.
Thecompanyworkstopromoteitsnewerscents,suchasIncrediblelaunchedin2012.

ChanelsCocoMademoiselleranksfourthandistheleaderintheluxurysegment.
Salesgrow11.5%in2012to$58million.
The brand is supported with magazine and television advertising, along with online
supportduringtheholidaypurchasingperiod.
A new broadcast advertising campaign premieres in 2012 featuring actress Keira
KnightleyridingthroughParisonamotorcycle.

In fifth place is another Victorias Secret scent Bombshell, which grows 6.0% during its
secondfullyearinstores.
Salesgrowfrom$50millionin2011to$53millionin2012.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Specialtystorescontinuetogrowandmaintainthetopspotastheleadingchannelforthe
purchaseoffragrancesforwomen.
The specialty stores channel grows because of increasing sales from vertically
integrated retailers, such as Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret, along with
growthfromcosmeticspecialtystores,suchasSephoraandUlta.
Departmentstorestrailspecialtystoresbyonesharepoint,increasingshareslightlyas
consumersreturntodepartmentstores.
However, retail share for mass merchandisers and drug stores drop slightly as
consumersreturntohighendretailersforthepurchaseoffragrances.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

FragrancesforWomen

Table4C20:ManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforWomenintheUnited
StatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Specialtystores

34

35

Departmentstores

33

34

Massmerchandisers

14

12

Directsales

11

12

Drugstores

Foodstores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Price and gift promotions along with sampling and instore activities are the main ways
womensfragrancesaremarketedacrossallretailchannels.
Samplingremainsimportantforalltradeclasses.

New launches typically receive heavy promotional backing generally consisting of media
advertisements,sampling,anonlinecomponent,andotherpromotionsincludingcontests.
Socialmediaisnowincludedasoneofthemarketingtoolsutilized,inadditiontoevent
sponsorshipsandsampledissemination.

TheInternetandsocialmediaconstituteanincreasingportionofbrandsmarketingefforts,
asthesearelessexpensivewaystoconnectwithconsumerswhencomparedtotraditional
advertising.
The Internet also provides tools that consumers can use in the scent purchasing
process,suchasfragrancefindertypetoolsbasedonconsumersresponsestoasetof
questions.
The utilization of social media is seen as a way for brands to connect with younger
consumers.
Over the past few years blogger outreach is used by an increasing percent of beauty
brandswherebytheyprovidefashionandbeautybloggersinformationandsamplesof
new products so that the recipients can blog about these and help create additional
buzz.
YouTubevideoscontinuetobeusedtocomplementabrandsmarketingstrategyand
servetwo majorpurposes:thefirstistocommunicatethestoryaboutthescentand
secondlytoprovideanoutletforbroadcastingvideos,advertisingthescent.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C45

4C46

FragrancesforWomen

Inapracticethatisunchangedforoveradecade,prestigemarketerscontinuetoprovide
samples and offer promotional programs, such as valuepriced gift sets, catalog blowins,
fragrancestrips,GWPoffers,andPWPoffers.
Sampleshelpconsumerstryabrandbeforemakinganinvestment.
Commonsamplingmethodsincludefragrancevialsattachedtocards,scentedstripsin
magazines,andscentedblottercardsorribbonsdistributedatretailstores.
Specialtyretailersanddepartmentstoresofferseveraldifferentwaysforconsumersto
sampleascent.Somebrandsprovideretailersreadymadevialscontainingthescent.
Someretailershavetheabilitytofillthelittlevialswithascentuponrequest.
Sephoracontinuestooffersamplersetswheretheconsumercantryoutvariousscents
and then redeem the enclosed gift certificate for a fullsized bottle of the preferred
scent.

Giftsetsareincreasinginpopularityandserveasapromotionalitemonacontinualbasis.
Thesesetstypicallycontaineitheravarietyoffragranceminiatures,orafragranceand
ancillaryproducts.
Thesesetsarepopularduetotheiremphasisonvalueandthefactthattheytypically
costlessthaniftheindividualcomponentsarepurchasedseparately.
Severalbrandsdevelopgiftsetsoffragranceminiaturesthatarebundledtogetherand
appealtoconsumersdesireforvariety.

Department stores and specialty retailers rely on promotions, instore sampling and
displays,directtoconsumermailings,andemailtohelpspursales.
Strategicplacementoffragrancesinthestoresoftenattractsconsumerswhoarenot
specificallylookingtomakeafragrancepurchase,andaresometimesdoublyexposed
tothesamefragranceinastore.
Thesetwochannelsalsoofferspecialgiftsets,somemadeespeciallyforwomenthat
include the fragrances and ancillary products usually contained in a tote bag or
cosmeticcase.
Departmentandspecialtystoresalsoofferatotebagfilledwithfragrancesamplesasa
giftwithaminimumpurchase.
Inapracticeunchangedfordecades,thedepartmentstoreschannelemploysspritzer
people that spray a chosen scent on blotter paper for the consumer to test. Some
providesafetypinsoraribbonontheblotterpapersothattheconsumercanactually
wearthescentforawhiletomakesuretheylikeitbeforemakingapurchase.
Macys attempts to increase its fragrance sales during 2012 with an advertising
campaignthatpromotestheretailerasthefragranceauthority.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

FragrancesforWomen

LeadingspecialtyretailbrandBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretmakegreatuseof
positioning fragrance offerings in more than one location in a store, especially near the
checkoutcounters.
Victorias Secret and Bath & Body Works offer several of their scents in smaller sizes
nearthecheckoutcountersforimpulsepurchasing.
Victorias Secret promotes its products using a number of promotional activities,
including two semiannual sales in June and January; several GWPs and PWPs
throughout the year; and directmailing campaigns announcing new products and
offers.VictoriasSecretregularlyofferspromotionaldealsonitsvaluepricedFantasies
line.
Bath&BodyWorksregularlysendsoutoffersviaemailordirectmailtoconsumersin
itsdatabaseofferingpricediscountsonmultiplepurchases.Buythreegettwofreeand
buythreegetthreefree promotions are fairly common throughout the year.
Additionally,theretailersometimesofferssamplesofupcomingfragranceproducts,at
introductorypricesof$1.00or$2.00.

Sephora and Ulta increase their share of the fragrances market through a number of
endeavorswhicharepromotedinstore,ontheirwebsites,andthroughmailers.
Boththeseretailersofferloyaltyprogramswherebyconsumersreceiverewardspoints
basedonpurchasevolumes,whichareredeemableforvariousproductsandperks.
Sephora provides five free fragrance samples with any online fragrance purchase of
$25.00 or more. The retailer also offers a selection of fragrance promotion gifts
preparedinconjunctionwiththebrands.Forexample,aCliniquetoteisavailablewith
thepurchaseofselectfragrancesfromthebrand.
Ulta regularly mails scheduled brochures that highlight promotions to encourage the
purchaseoffragrances.Consumersreceivegifts,suchasatotebag,aninsulatedcooler,
candlesticks,orevenarobewiththepurchaseoffragrances,valuedaboveacertain
amount.

Drugchainsandmassmerchandiserspromotefragranceswithpromotionaldiscounts,such
asgiftsetsandpricediscounts,intheirflyers.
CVS,RiteAid,andWalgreensofferloyaltyprogramswherepointsareearnedbasedon
purchaseswhichcanberedeemedforfuturepurchases.
During2012,Walgreenspromotes4,000BalanceRewardspointswiththepurchaseof
selectscents.
Targetflyersin2012frequentlypromotedesignerandcelebrityfragrancesat15%off.

Sales associates and catalogs are used by persontoperson direct marketers to promote
newfragrances.
Avon typically promotes new fragrances on the cover of its brochures at the time of
theirlaunch.
Scentstripsareoftenfeaturedinitscatalogs.
Otherpromotionalvehiclesincludemediaadvertising,discounts,andGWPoffers.
MaryKayshowcasesitsfragrancesinitsLookBook.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C47

4C48

FragrancesforWomen

Examplesofsomeluxuryfragrancepromotionsduring2012includethefollowing:
BradPittfrontsanewprintandbroadcastcampaignforChanelsNo.5andistheonly
malespokespersonsforafemalescent.
AnewbroadcastadvertisementforChanelsCocoMademoisellefeaturesactressKeira
KnightleyridingthroughParisonamotorcycle.
LadyGagasFamedebutswithaprintcampaignimagefeaturingthesingernudewith
muchsmallerscalemenstrategicallyplaced,crawlingupherbody.Gagaalsolaunches
atwittercampaignaboutthescent.However,Fameislessinnovativethanexpected.
Gucci launches the Premiere scent with a broadcast and print campaign featuring
actressBlakeLively.
The launch of Nicki Minaj Pink Friday includes an extensive digital and social media
campaign,alongwithprintandbroadcastadvertisementsaroundtheholidays.
LancmesLaVieEstBelledebutswithanadvertisingcampaignfeaturingactressJulia
Roberts.
An increasing number of brands include YouTube videos of their advertisements on
theirwebsite.

Totalmediaexpenditures(TMEs)forwomensfragrancesdeclinein2012to$324.5million,
downfrom$392.5millionin2011.
Magazinesaccountfornearly70%ofthetotaladvertisingspend.
LVMH is the leading advertiser with TME of $59.6 million during 2012 for its JAdore
andMissDiorCheriebrands.
Cotyfollowsinsecondplacewithadvertisingexpendituresof$50.8million,downfrom
$75.0millionin2011.
Chanel follows in third place with $44.9 million in advertising expenditures, followed
closelybyProcter&Gambleat$40.9million.

DetailsonTMEareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

Low to moderate growth is forecast during the next five years as the industry has many
hurdlestoovercome.
Evenbeforetherecessionstartedin2008,theindustryexperienceddecliningsalesdue
tolowerdemand.
Considerablechallengescontinuetoplaguetheindustrywhichneedstobeovercome
forsubstantialgrowthtobeexperienced.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

FragrancesforWomen

Challengesnegativelyaffectingthefragrancesforwomencategoryareexpectedtoremain
fairlyconsistentoverthenextfiveyearscontinuingtoimpederealgrowthandinclude:
Lackofcompatibilitywiththegrowingtrendofnaturalpersonalcareproducts.
Increasing concern that fragrances can cause hormone disruptions, asthma, or other
unpleasantsideeffects.
The prohibition of fragrances in work environments mandated by companies or
requestedbycoworkers.
Amorecausalworkenvironmentwithfewerdressupopportunities.
A reduced demand for fragrances as gifts due to competition from other products
rangingfromconsumerelectronicstogiftcards.

Thefollowingisexpectedtooccurduringtheforecastperiod:
In lieu of becoming completely natural, companies are expected to take steps to
eliminateunnecessaryingredientsandincludemorenaturalones.
Companieswillworktobecomemoresustainablebyimprovingtheirenergyefficiency,
loweringtheiremissions,andofferingmoreecofriendlypackaging.
Anincreasingnumberofbrandsmayofferrefillabledecorativeflaconsasawaytobe
moreenvironmentallysensitive.
Theclassicscentswillremainstrongandcontinuetogrowastheyareviewedasthe
safe choice for many consumers that are keeping fewer fragrances than in previous
decades.
Companies,suchasCotyandElizabethArdenwillcontinuetoalignwithcelebritiesand
willbecomemorecautiousaboutthecelebritiesthattheychoose.
Coty and LOral are expected to continue their alignment with fashion designers,
whileEsteLauderwillaimhigherduetolicenseagreementswithhighendandniche
designers.
Whilenewnessdrivesthecategory,marketerswilllikelybemorecautiousofwhatthey
bringtomarketbecauseofthehighcostinvolvedinlaunchinganewscent.
Nichescents,costinginexcessof$100.00andwithlimiteddistributionareexpectedto
show the most growth over the forecast period because they provide the consumers
theopportunitytosmelldifferentthantherestoftheirfriends.

Someoftheissuesthatwilllikelyaffectthefragrancesforwomencategoryoverthenext
fiveyearsinclude:
New forms of fragrances in small sizes and at lower price points are expected to
increaseinpopularity,suchasfragrancepens,inadditiontorollerballs.
Companies and brands will likely offer collections of small coffrets of their scents to
help keep consumers loyal to their company and/or brand, while still satisfying
consumersneedforvariety.
Fragrances will likely multitask by providing some additional advantages beyond just
impartingascent,possiblyahealthbenefit,suchashelpingtolowerbloodpressure,
improvingsinuscongestion,oroverallrelaxation.
Consumers will still be interested in value during the forecast period and fragrances
needtocommunicatetheirvalue,whichgoesbeyondprice.
Fragranceswilllikelyremainchallengedasadesiredgiftofchoice.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4C49

4C50

FragrancesforWomen

Reaching the consumer and grabbing their attention will require the use of a
comprehensivemarketingapproach.
Innovative print and broadcast advertising, possibly with the use of celebrities or a
brandspokespersonwillremainthecoreeffortutilizedbybrands.
YouTube videos of the broadcast advertisements, along with additional videos that
helpchannelthespiritoftheproductwillbeincludedonthebrandswebsite.
Cooperative advertising with retailers in newspapers, magazines, and in department
stores and specialty stores brochures are expected to continue during the forecast
period.
Samplingeffortswillcontinuetobeofextremeimportanceandcouldeventakenew
forms,suchasaflashdrivethatemitsascent.
Consumers will likely check out reviews, blogs, and social media before purchasing a
new scent, and brands will need to plan for blogger outreach and social media
engagement.

Specialty and department stores are forecast to remain the leading channels for the
purchaseoffragrances.
Ecommercewillincreaseinpopularityforthereplenishmentoffragrancesandalsofor
giftgiving.
Toolsandapplicationsprovidedbymarketersandretailersareexpectedtomakethe
sellingoffragranceseasier.

Sales are projected to increase at a CAGR of 3.5% to $3,231million by 2017 from


$2,717millionin2012.

Table4C21:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFragrancesforWomenin
theUnitedStatesbyProductType,2012and2017

$Million

Producttype

2012

Liquidproducts
Ancillaryproducts
Total

2017

CAGR,%

2,456

2,917

3.5

261

314

3.8

2,717

3,231

3.5

UnitvolumeisforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof2.0%to177millionpackagesin2017,from
160millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

4D.HAIRCAREPRODUCTS

INTRODUCTION

Included in the hair care market are products used for cleansing, conditioning, styling,
coloring,andgroominghair.

Productcategoriesincludedareasfollows:
Conditioners
Ethnichaircareproducts
Haircoloringproducts
Hairstylingproductsandsprays
Shampoos

Hairpermingproductsarenolongerincludedinthisreport.

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Manufacturers sales of hair care products are $7,610million in 2012, up 2.9% from
$7,393millionin2011.

Shampoos is the largest category in the product class, accounting for 34.4% share of the
totalhaircaresales.
Salesoftheshampooscategorytotal$2,620millionin2012.

Hairstylingproducts,thesecondlargestcategory,accountsfor22.1%ofthetotalhaircare
class.
Salesforthecategoryare$1,680millionin2012.

Conditioners, with sales at $1,653million in 2012, is the thirdlargest category in the


productclass,constituting21.7%ofthetotalproductclasssales.

Sales of hair care products have advanced at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
1.2%between2007and2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D2

HairCareProducts

Table4D1:ManufacturersSalesofHairCareProductsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007r

7,178

2008r

7,159

(0.3)

2009r

6,976

(2.6)

2010r

7,144

2.4

2011r

7,393

3.5

2012

7,610

2.9

rRestated.

Figure4D1:ManufacturersSalesofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012

Ethnichaircare
products,4%

Shampoos,34%

Haircoloring
products,17%

Hairstylingproducts
andsprays,22%

Conditioners,22%
Total:$7,610Million
NOTE:Totalsmaynotaddduetorounding.

RETAILSALES

In 2012, retail sales of hair care products total $10,959million, up 3.1% from
$10,625millionin2011.

Salesbytradeclass

Masscontinuestobethelargesttradeclass,representing80.3%oftotalhaircaresalesin
2012.
Professional brands follow in a distant second place with 16.1% of sales, while the
directsalestradeclassrepresents2.6%sharefortheyear.
Specialty and luxury trade classes account for 0.6% and 0.4% of total hair care sales,
respectively,in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

4D3

HairCareProducts

Table4D2:ManufacturersSalesofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

$Million

Hair
styling

Conditioners

Hair
coloring

Ethnic
haircare

Total

%Of
total

2,077

1,138

1,236

1,317

340

6,108

80.3

Professional

369

503

356

1,228

16.1

Direct

132

28

37

197

2.6

Specialty

27

16

49

0.6

Luxury

15

28

0.4

2,620

1,680

1,653

1,317

340

7,610

100.0

Tradeclass
Mass

Total

Shampoos

COMPETITION

Thethreeleadingmarketers,Procter&Gamble,LOral,andUnilever,accountfor58.2%of
theproductclass.

Table4D3:ManufacturersSalesofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategoryandCompany,2012

$Million

Company

Shampoos

Hair
styling

Conditioners

Hair
coloring

Ethnichair
care

Total

%Of
total

Procter&Gamble

736

222

327

308

19

1,612

21.2

LOral

287

227

253

646

95

1,508

19.8

Unilever

546

364

362

39

1,311

17.2

39

77

41

38

195

2.6

113

57

171

2.2

EsteLauder

56

65

49

170

2.2

GuthyRenker

112

26

31

169

2.2

57

56

43

156

2.0

152

152

2.0

674

643

490

173

186

2,166

28.5

2,620

1,680

1,653

1,317

340

7,610

100.0

Kao
Johnson&Johnson

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems
Revlon
Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D4

HairCareProducts

Procter&Gambleisthelargesthaircaremarketer,withsalesof$1,612million,accounting
for21.2%oftotalhaircaresalesin2012.
Sales of the marketer decline 0.8% from $1,625million in 2011 to $1,612million in
2012.
Procter&Gamblehasitspresenceinallhaircarecategories.
Limitednewproductactivity,adecreaseinthemarketingandadvertisingsupportfor
itsbrands,andadecreaseincouponingactivitycontributetothemarketersdeclinein
theoverallhaircareproductclassin2012.
Procter&GambledecreasesitsTMEsignificantlyby21.7%,from$301.3millionin2011
to$236.0millionin2012.
The company is the leading marketer in the shampoos category and is the second
leading marketer in the conditioners and hair coloring categories. It has a share of
28.1%oftheoverallsalesoftheshampooscategory.Salesforthecompanygrow3.4%
from$712millionin2011to$736millionin2012.Thecompanymarketsninebrandsin
the shampoos category, including the top two brands, Pantene ProV and Head &
Shoulders,andthefifthlargestbrand,HerbalEssences.
Head & Shoulders becomes the leader in the shampoos category in 2012, displacing
Pantene ProV. Head & Shoulders sales grow 9.0%, from $244 million in 2011 to
$266million in 2012. The brands growth is driven by improved marketing and
promotionalactivitiesinthecategory.Procter&Gamblelaunchesvariouscampaignsto
supportthesalesofthebrandinthecategory.ThemarketersignssoccerplayerLionel
Messi as its spokesperson to promote its Head & Shoulders brand. New product
launches and the success of natural products support the growth of Herbal Essences
brandintheshampooscategoryin2012.
Procter & Gamble is the secondleading marketer in the conditioners category,
constituting 19.8% of the total category sales. Sales for the company grow 0.9%, up
from$324millionin2011to$327millionin2012.PanteneProVmaintainsitsposition
asthetopbrandintheconditionerscategorywithacategoryshareof13.3%.Salesfor
thebranddecline1.2%from$167millionin2011to$165millionin2012.Limitednew
productactivityandpromotionalactivitiescontributetothebrandssalesdeclineinthe
conditionerscategoryin2012.HerbalEssencesisthesecondlargestbrandforProcter
&Gambleintheconditionerscategory,withsalesat$98millionin2012.
Procter&Gambleisthesecondleadingmarketerinthehaircoloringproductscategory,
withsalesat$308millionin2012,down9.7%from$341millionin2011.Themarketer
discontinues several brands in 2011, such as Clairol Hydrience, Clairol Men's Choice,
andClairolUltress,contributingtothesalesdeclinein2012.
Procter & Gamble is the third leading marketer in the hair styling products category,
withsalesdecreasing2.2%to$222millionin2012from$227millionin2011.Limited
newproductactivityandadecreaseinmarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributes
tothemarketersdeclineinthehairstylingproductscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

HairCareProducts

LOral, with a share of 19.8% in the product class, is the secondlargest marketer in hair
care.
Sales for the company are down slightly by 0.1% from $1,509million in 2011 to
$1,508millionin2012.
LOral is the leading marketer in the hair coloring products and ethnic hair care
productscategories.
In hair coloring products, LOral accounts for an estimated 49.1% of the categorys
sales in 2012. Sales decline 0.3% from $648million in 2011 to $646million in 2012.
LOrals product offering in hair coloring mainly comprises permanent hair colors.
LOral Preference, L'Oral Excellence, and Garnier Nutrisse are the three leading
brands,and2012marksthelaunchofafewdistincthaircolorlines,includingGarnier
Olia.
AlthoughtheshareofLOralintheoverallethnichaircareproductscategorydeclines
from 29.1% in 2011 to 27.9% in 2012, the company maintains its reigning position in
the category. Sales of the company decline by2.1%, from $97 million in 2011 to $95
millionin2012.In2012,LorealintroducesDarkandLovelyAuNaturaleantibreakage
maintenanceandstylingline,alongwithafewotherproductintroductionstooffsetits
salesdecline.
LOral maintains its position as the secondleading marketer in the hair styling
products category, with a share of 13.5% of the category sales, down from 13.8% in
2011.Salesforthemarketerdecline0.9%from$229millionin2011to$227millionin
2012. The decrease in marketing and promotional activities contributes to the sales
declineforLOralinthehairstylingproductscategoryin2012.
LOraldecreasesitsTMEspendbyapproximately20.3%,from$60.5millionin2011to
$48.2millionin2012.
GarnierFructisistheleadinghairstylingbrandofthecompany,andthesecondlargest
inthecategory.Itssalesare$88millionin2012,down2.4%from$84millionin2011.
LOralistheleadingmarketerintheprofessionaltradeclass,withRedkentheleading
brand,followedbyMatrixinthirdposition.
Themarketeroccupies21.8%oftheprofessionaltradeclass,upfrom21.2%in2011.
LOralisthethirdlargestmarketerintheshampooscategorywitha10.9%share;the
companys sales grow 0.7% from $284 million in 2011 to $286 million in 2012. The
company offers 10 brands in the shampoos category. Garnier Fructis is the leading
brandfromLOral,andsalesdecline1.4%,from$136millionin2011to$134millionin
2012.Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
LOralisalsoplacedthirdintheconditionerscategorywithashareof15.3%.Salesfor
themarketergrow1.2%from$250millionin2011to$253millionin2012.Thelargest
brandfromLOralisGarnierFructis,whichhasashareof7.0%ofthetotalcategory
sales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D5

4D6

HairCareProducts

Unileveristhethirdlargestmarketerofhaircareproducts,withtotalsalesat$1,311million
in2012,up4.3%from$1,257millionin2011.
The marketers sales growth is primarily supported by its significant launch of Clear
shampoos and conditioners in 2012, including a range focused on scalp therapy and
totalrepair.
Themarketerhasapresenceinfourofthefivehaircarecategories,withtheexception
ofthehaircoloringproductscategory.
Unilever,thesecondrankedmarketerintheshampooscategory,hasacategoryshare
of20.8%.Thecompanyssalesgrow4.4%from$523millionin2011to$546millionin
2012. Suave continues to be the leading brand of Unilever and is the thirdlargest
brand in the category. Sales of the brand are up 3.8%, from $186 million in 2011 to
$193million in 2012. New product activity and increased marketing contribute to
Suavesperformanceinthecategory.
In the conditioners category, sales for the marketer grow 7.7% from $336 million in
2011 to $362 million in 2012. Unilever primarily benefits with the launch of a new
brand,Clearconditionersin2012.TheClearbrandhassalesof$27millionin2012,as
thebrandbenefitsfromitsscalptherapyrangeofconditioners.Thelargestbrandfrom
Unilever is Suave, which has a category share of 6.5% in 2012. Sales for Suave grow
4.9% from $103million in 2011 to $108 million in 2012. New product launches and
economicallypricedproductscontributetoSuavesgrowth.
Unilever continues to be the leading marketer in the hair styling products and
conditionerscategoryin2012.SalesforUnilevergrow1.4%from$359millionin2011
to$364millionin2012inthehairstylingproductscategory.TRESemmistheleading
brandofthecompany,withsalesat$124millionin2012,up7.8%from$115millionin
2011. Thegrowthofthebrandissupportedbyseveralnewproductintroductionsby
Unileverin2012.
Unileveristhesecondleadingmarketerintheethnichaircareproductscategorywith
ashareof11.5%in2012.Salesforthecompanyremainflatat$39millionin2012,the
same as 2011. Lack of technological advancements and limited new product activity
account for stagnant sales for Unilever in 2012. Limited distribution channels, with
beauty supply stores accounting for the majority, offset the growth of the marketer.
Soft & Beautiful is the leading brand for Unilever, accounting for 4.1% of the total
categorysalesin2012,downfrom4.5%in2011.Thebrandssalesdecline$1million
from$15millionin2011to$14millionin2012.Soft&Beautifulhasapresenceinthe
relaxerkitsandstylingaidssegments.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandisers,themostpreferredchannelofretaildistribution,accountsfor39.4%
shareofthehaircaremarketin2012.
Drug stores and food stores follow with market shares of 20.9% and 19.8%,
respectively.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

HairCareProducts

Table4D4:RetailDistributionofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012

%Ofmanufacturersdollars
Shampoos

Hair
styling

Conditioners

Hair
coloring

Ethnichair
care

Massmerchandisers

41

36

39

39

27

39.4

Drugstores

13

19

18

39

20

20.9

Foodstores

23

18

20

18

19.8

Salons

11

22

16

12.2

Specialtystoresa

45

5.4

Direct

1.9

Departmentstores

0.3

Total
100

aIncludesbeautysupplystores.

100

100

100

100

100.0

Retailoutlet

Weighted
average

OUTLOOK

Sales of hair care products are projected to grow at a moderate rate of 2.1% during the
forecastperiodfrom2012to2017.
Shampoos and conditioners are expected to drive the sales of the hair care product
classinthenextfiveyears.
Haircareproductswithimprovedformulationsandinnovativepackagingareexpected
tosupportthegrowthoftheproductclass.

Shampoos, the largest category in the hair care product class, is expected to experience
steady growth of 3.1% over the forecast period despite its relatively mature stage in the
UnitedStates.
Shampoosthatprotectthescalpshealthandenhanceshineareexpectedtoperform
wellinthefuture.
Shampoosthatcatertospecifichairproblemsandhairtypesareexpectedtosupport
thecategoryssales.
Marketers will constantly incorporate additional hair care benefits, such as frizz
protectionandcolorprotectionintotheirproducts.
Naturalshampoosornaturallypositionedshampoosthatwillnotcausedamagetothe
hairarelikelytohavegooddemandinthefuture.
Mens shampoos will continue to grow over the forecast period, supported by new
productlaunchesandanincreasingdemandforsuchproducts.
Marketersconsiderthissegmenttohaveahugepotential,andasaresult,companies
such as Unilever and Procter & Gamble are including mens care products in their
prioritylists.
Aggressive and innovative product promotions are expected to be among the key
driversforthecategorysgrowth.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D7

4D8

HairCareProducts

Hair styling products and sprays, the second largest category in hair care, is expected to
growmoderatelyby1.4%overthenextfiveyears.
Manufacturers will continue to introduce hair styling products with multibenefits to
supportthecategorygrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Hairstylingproductsthatoffermultibenefitsforcoloredandtreatedhairarelikelyto
dowellduringtheforecastperiod.
Hairstylingproductsthatwillprotecthairscalpshealthareexpectedtoperformbetter.
Marketersareexpectedtointroduceproductstargetedtomen,asthemenssegment
isexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
Sales of professional hair styling products are expected to grow moderately over the
forecastperiod.

Sales of conditioners are expected post steady growth of 2.5% over the forecast period,
2012to2017.
New product activity and considerable promotional and marketing activities are
expectedtobetheprimegrowthdriversforthesalesgrowthofthecategory.
The continuous growth in the aging population will likely drive the need for
conditionersasthemoistureandshineinhairdeclineswithage.
Research and development efforts from the leading marketers will result in the
introductionofnewandinnovativeproductsinthecategory.
The majority of marketers are expected to launch innovative products that cater to
specifichairproblemsincludingthinningandvolumeboostthatwillperformwellover
theforecastperiod.
Conditionersthatofferextrabenefits,suchassunandscalpprotection,areexpected
toperformwell.
Colorprotectingandcolorenhancingconditionersareprojectedtogrowatahealthy
rateduringtheforecastperiod.
Thegrowingnumberofconsumerswhocolortheirhairareexpectedcontributetothe
growthofcolorprotectionconditioners.
Productsformulatedwithnaturalingredientsarelikelytoemergeasagrowingniche
duringtheforecastperiod.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

HairCareProducts

Thehaircoloringcategoryisexpectedtoexperienceamoderategrowthof0.4%overthe
forecastperiod.
Agingconsumerswillcontinuetolookforcoloringproductsthathavethemainbenefit
ofcoveringgrayhair.
The aging population or consumers in the 35 to 65 age group will be the leading
consumer segment for the category and are likely to drive the sales growth of
permanenthaircolorproducts.
Permanenthaircolorswillcontinuetobetheleadingsegmentinthecategory,asthey
arethemostsuitableproductstocompletegraycoverage.
Youngconsumerswhoconsiderhaircolorasafashionstatementwillalsocontinueto
supportthecategorygrowth.
Productswithimprovedformulationssuchasfoambasedandcreambasedhaircolors
willcontinuetogainpopularityovertheforecastperiod.
Ongoing active research and development activities will result in improvements in
productquality.
Hair coloring products are expected to incorporate a number of additional benefits,
includingthenourishmentofhairandprotectionfromthesun.
Themenshaircoloringsegmentwillcontinuetoshowgrowthovertheforecastperiod,
supportedbynewproductlaunchesandinnovationsinthecategory.

The ethnic hair care category is estimated grow moderately by 1.8% over the forecast
period.
TheethnicpopulationisprojectedtogrowfasterthantheoverallAmericanpopulation
supportingtheoverallcategorygrowth.
Products that cater to specific hair concerns such as curl control, protection against
breakage,andvarioushairtypesareexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
Ethnichaircareproductsthatarepositionedasnaturalorcontainnaturalingredients
areexpectedtogrowsignificantlyovertheforecastperiod.
Consumersarelikelytocontinueseekproductsthatcontainnaturalingredients,such
astiareflower(softens,purifyiesandsoothes)andfloralextracts.
Relaxerkitsareexpectedtoleadthecategoryshareovertheforecastperiod.
Consistent with trends in the general market, African American men are increasingly
focusedongrooming.
However,thecategoryisexpectedtofacecompetitionfromgeneralhaircarebrands
thathavehaircolorsandhairstylingproductwhichareattractivetoethnicconsumers,
especiallyamongtheyoungerpopulation.

Sales of the hair care products class are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 2.1% to reach
$8,438millionin2017from$7,610millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D9

4D10

HairCareProducts

Table4D5:ForecastManufacturersSalesofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesby
Category,2012and2017

$Million

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Shampoos

2,620

3,050

3.1

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

1,802

1.4

Conditioners

1,653

1,870

2.5

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

1,345

0.4

340

371

1.8

7,610

8,438

2.1

Ethnichaircareproducts
Total

UnitsalesareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof1.5%from2,037millionpackagesin2012to
2,197millionpackagesin2017.

Table4D6:ForecastUnitSalesofHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,
2012and2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Shampoos

741

826

2.2

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

529

555

1.0

Conditioners

443

480

1.6

Haircoloringproducts

225

230

0.4

99

106

1.4

2,037

2,197

1.5

Ethnichaircareproducts
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

CONDITIONERS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

In 2012, manufacturers sales of conditioners grow 4.8% to reach $1,653million, up from


$1,578millionin2011.
The category has grown at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 1.2% between
2007and2012.

Table4D7:HistoricalSalesofConditionersintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

1,561

2008

1,561

2009

1,497

(4.1)

2010

1,525

1.9

2011

1,578

3.5

2012

1,653

4.8

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit sales in the category grow marginally by 3.7% from 427million packages in 2011 to
443millionpackagesin2012.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofconditionerstotal$2,470.7millionin2012,up4.8%from$2,356.7millionin
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D12

Conditioners

Table4D8:ManufacturersSalesofConditionersintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

PanteneProVr

Procter&Gamble

167

165

14.1

13.3

10.6

10.0

GarnierFructisr

L'Oral

116

115

9.8

9.3

7.4

7.0

Suave

Unilever

103

108

8.7

8.7

6.5

6.5

TRESemmr

Unilever

109

107

9.2

8.7

6.9

6.5

HerbalEssencesr

Procter&Gamble

96

98

8.1

7.9

6.1

5.9

Dove

Unilever

68

66

5.7

5.3

4.3

4.0

Aussie

Procter&Gamble

45

48

3.8

3.9

2.9

2.9

Organixr

VogueInternational

24

38

2.0

3.1

1.5

2.3

Nexxus

Unilever

36

37

3.0

3.0

2.3

2.2

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

31

32

2.6

2.6

2.0

1.9

AlbertoVO5r

BrynwoodPartners

28

29

2.4

2.3

1.8

1.8

Clear

Unilever

27

2.2

EverPurer

L'Oral

17

18

1.4

1.5

1.1

1.1

Aveenor

Johnson&Johnson

15

16

1.3

1.3

1.0

1.0

BrilliantBrunette

Kao

15

15

1.3

1.2

1.0

0.9

Infusium23

HelenofTroy

17

14

1.4

1.1

1.1

0.8

Finesse

Lornamead

13

12

1.1

1.0

0.8

0.7

VivePror

L'Oral

14

11

1.2

0.9

0.9

0.7

Johnson's

Johnson&Johnson

0.8

0.7

0.6

0.5

Fekkai

Procter&Gamble

0.7

0.7

0.5

0.5

EverSleek

L'Oral

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.5

EverStrong

L'Oral

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

WhiteRain

BrynwoodPartners

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.3

EverCreme

L'Oral

0.4

0.3

Burt'sBees

TheCloroxCompany

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

RadiantRedr

Kao

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.2

Freeman

FreemanBeauty

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.1

Jhirmack

InspiredBeauty
Brands

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

L'OralKids

L'Oral

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Got2B

Henkel

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Condition

HelenofTroy

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Sunsilka

Unilever

0.3

0.2

43

41

3.6

3.3

2.7

2.5

MASS

Privatelabel

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

1.6

4D13

Conditioners

Table4D8:ManufacturersSalesofConditionersintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

Allother

Allother

148

156

12.5

12.6

9.4

9.4

Allother

KaoUSA

23

23

1.9

1.9

1.5

1.4

Allother

Henkel

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

1,187

1,236

100.0

100.0

75.2

74.8

MASS(Continued)

Total
PROFESSIONAL
Matrix

L'Oral

43

44

12.3

12.4

2.7

2.7

PaulMitchell

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems

42

43

12.0

12.1

2.7

2.6

Aveda

EsteLauder

32

33

9.2

9.3

2.0

2.0

Redken

L'Oral

29

30

8.3

8.4

1.8

1.8

Nioxin

NioxinResearch
Laboratories

27

30

7.7

8.4

1.7

1.8

TIGI

Unilever

17

17

4.9

4.8

1.1

1.0

BumbleandBumble

EsteLauder

13

14

3.7

3.9

0.8

0.8

Pureology

L'Oral

13

13

3.7

3.7

0.8

0.8

Joico

Shiseido

10

11

2.9

3.1

0.6

0.7

Alterna

TSGConsumer
Partners

2.0

2.2

0.4

0.5

Sebastian

Procter&Gamble

2.3

2.0

0.5

0.4

108

106

30.9

29.8

6.8

6.4

349

356

100.0

100.0

22.1

21.5

15

31

78.9

83.8

1.0

1.9

10.5

5.4

0.1

0.1

10.5

10.8

0.1

0.2

19

37

100.0

100.0

1.2

2.2

25.0

25.0

0.1

0.1

75.0

75.0

0.4

0.4

100.0

100.0

0.5

0.5

Allother

Total
DIRECT
Wen

GuthyRenker

Avon

Avon

Allother

Total
LUXURY
Origins

EsteLauder

Allother

Total

SPECIALITY
Victoria'sSecret

LimitedBrands

33.3

31.3

0.3

0.3

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

20.0

18.8

0.2

0.2

Crabtree&Evelyn

Crabtree&Evelyn

6.7

6.3

0.1

0.1

40.0

43.8

0.4

0.4

15

16

100.0

100.0

1.0

1.0

1,578

1,653

100.0

100.0

Allother

Total
TOTAL

aDiscontinued.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D14

Conditioners

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Salesofconditionersgrowby4.8%in2012.
Theconditionersmarketcontinuestofollowtheshampoosmarketcloselyintermsof
markettrendsandcharacteristics.
Thebranding,positioning,anddistributionofconditionerstendtobethesameasthe
correspondingshampoobrands.
However,conditionersoftenfollowshampoos,andareslightlybehindshampooswhen
itcomestomarketpenetration.
Conditionersmarginallylagbehindshampoosintermsofmarketpenetrationandreach.

Conditionerswithimprovedformulationssupportthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Conditioners that offer extra benefits apart from moisturization perform well in the
category.
Alongwithmoisturizingthehair,consumersexpectconditionerstoofferotherbenefits,
suchasaddingvolume,enhancingshine,andprotectingcolor.
In 2012, John Paul Mitchell Systems introduces Full Circle leavein treatment that
claimstodetangle,cleanse,andtamefrizzallatonce.
Most of the larger brands in the category offer specialized products as per the
consumershairconcerns.
Leading brands, such as Pantene, Suave, and Garnier have separate product lines for
colorprotection,controllingfrizz,volumizing,andstrengthening.
The socalled cleansing conditioners are reported in the shampoos category, since
theyreplaceshampoos.

Menspecificconditionerscontinuetoperformwellin2012.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Procter & Gamble launch men
specificconditionersin2012.
Unilever launches a new line of Clear Men range of conditioners in 2012 and also
extendsitsSuaveforMenandAxelineofconditionerswithnewvariants.
Procter & Gamble also extends its Head & Shoulders line of conditioners with new
variantstargetedatmen.

Product customization continues to be an important product trend among hair care


products.
Conditionersthatcatertotheneedsofvarioushairconcerns,suchasthinning,volume
boost,andhairtypescontinuetoperformwellin2012.
Marketers also launch conditioners for specific hair types to support the categorys
growth.
In2012,Procter&GamblelaunchesPanteneProVDailyMoistureRenewalconditioner
suitableforboththickandmediumhair.
In 2012, L'Oral launches Garnier Fructis Triple Nutrition Cream conditioner that is
suitablefordryanddamagedhair.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

Conditioners

Several leading marketers including Unilever and Procter & Gamble launch new range of
conditionerssupportingtheoverallgrowthofthecategory.
Unilever introduces its new Clear range of conditioners in early 2012. The range
includesscalptherapyandtotalcareconditioners.
L'Oral launches a new range of EverCreme shampoos and conditioners in 2012,
supportingthecategorysgrowth.

Conditionerswithmultiplebenefitsperformwellinthecategory.
Conditioners that offer extra benefits, such as protection from hair color, frizz
protectionsupportthecategorysgrowth.
ThesuccessofLOralsEverSleekandEverCreme,sulfatefreerangeofconditionersin
2012,willpromptothermarketerstolaunchsimilarproducts.
In 2012, Kao launches Color Care range of conditioners that claims to protect color
underitsGoldwellbrand.

Natural formulations have become a norm in the category, with most marketers either
introducing a complete new range of naturallypositioned products or reformulating their
existinglinestoincludenaturalingredients.
Many leading marketers, such as Vogue International and Procter & Gamble launch
productswithmorenaturalingredientsin2012.
Naturallypositioned brands, such as Organix, perform well in 2012; the sales of
Organixgrowby58.3%,from$24millionin2011to$38millionin2012.
In 2012, Vogue International launches Organix Shea Butter and Argan Oil conditioner
andOrganixAustralianTeatreeConditioner.
Procter & Gamble launches Herbal Essences Long Term Relationship natural
conditionerin2012.
However, most of these products contain a mix of some natural with primarily
syntheticingredients.

Theprofessionalconditionerscategoryexperiencesmoderategrowthof2.0%in2012.
Consumers in the United States increase their salon visits in 2012, supporting the
categorysgrowth.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D15

4D16

Conditioners

Notablenewproducts

Table4D9:SelectNewConditionersIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Aesop

BlackLabel

Volumizingconditionercontainsbothblendedbotanicaloilsandvegetable
andsyntheticproteins

AloxxiInternational

Aloxxi

ColorCareVolumizingandStrengtheningconditionerprovidesvolume,
strength,andcolorprotectionthroughitsspecialAppleCellStem
Technology

EsteLauder

BumbleandBumble

ColorMindedconditionerisinfusedwithdualpolymertechnologythatis
designedtomakehairimpermeabletowater,reducingbothcolorwashout
andfading

HainCelestialGroup

QueenHelene

SilkyTwirlsconditionercontains17aminoacids,plusvitaminsA,B,C,Dand
K,thepresenceofwhich,deliverssmoothinghydrationtothecurlsand
twirls

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems

PaulMitchell

FullCircleleaveintreatmentisdesignedtodetangle,cleanse,andtame
frizzallatonce

Johnson&Johnson

Aveeno

PureRenewalconditionerrefresheshairwithoutwaterforaclean,healthy
lookbetweenwashes

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

CleanReplenishingconditionergentlycleansesanditsmoistureenriched
formulapenetratesdrydamagedstrandstomakehairmoreresilient

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

TripleMoistureDailyDeepconditionercontainsnaturallyderivedextracts
thatpenetrateandmoisturizehairstrand,therebyprovidingsmoothness
andsoftness

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

TripleRenewalWeightlessconditionerisinfusedwithablendofamino
acids,vitamins,andnaturallyderivedproteins

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

CleanVolumeconditionergentlycleansesandaddsbodytoflatlifelesshair,
leavingnobuildup

Kao

Goldwell

ExtraRichconditioner,withitsuniqueformulawithpomegranateessence
providesminimalcolorfading

LOral

EverCreme

Nourishingconditionerinfusedwithomega3and6thathelpsrestore
moisture;containsnaturalbotanicalsandisfreefromparabens

LOral

GarnierFructis

TripleNutritionconditionerfortifiesandinfusesnutrientsforsilkyhair,full
oflife

LOral

GarnierFructis

PureCleanFortifyingconditionerbooststhehealthofhairandscalp,andis
thefirstbiodegradableformulafromFructis

LOral

LOralParis

AdvancedHairCareTotalRepair5Restoringconditionerhelpsrepairfive
visiblesignsofdamagedhair:splitends,weakness,roughness,dullness,and
dehydration

LOral

LOralParis

TripleResistReinforcingconditionerinstantlyhelpsnourishhairfromroot
tocoretotip,therebystrengtheninghair

LOral

LOralParis

SmoothIntensepolishingconditionersoftenshairinstantlyandcombats
symptomsofroughtextures,leavinghairsmooth

LOral

Matrix

BlondeCareconditionercontainsanexoticblendofchamomileand
panthenolthatcleansesanddetangleshairforanenhancedbrilliantshine,
withoutaddingweighttothehair

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

Conditioners

Table4D9:SelectNewConditionersIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

Procter&Gamble

Head&Shoulders

DamageRescueconditionernourishesdamagedhairandrelievesdryscalp
bylockinginmoisturetherebymaintainingahealthymoisturebarrier

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

ProVBeautifulLengthsconditionerfortifieshairagainstdamagethatleads
tobreakage,therebyincreasingthelengthofeachhairstrand

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

ProVMoistureRenewalconditionerisspeciallyformulatedtonurturethe
hairslipidlayerensuringmaximummoistureretentioninanaturaland
healthyway

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

PanteneAdvancedandKeratinRepairconditionerfeaturesadvanced
technologytohelprestoresmoothnesstoextremelydamagedhair,while
preventingfurtherdamage

Unilever

Axe

Apollo2in1shampooandconditionercombinescrispfruitandacreamy
background,therebyrenderingauniquemasculinefragrancetohair

Unilever

Clear

TotalCareNourishingDailyconditioner,withitsadvancedcomplexof
vitaminsandnutrientsgentlycleansesandhelpsrestorethescalpsnatural
moisturebalance

Unilever

Clear

Damage&ColorRepairDailyNourishingconditioner,cleansesgentlyand
hasadvancedcolorsafeformulathatprovidesprotectionfromdaily
damage

Unilever

Clear

VolumizingRootBoostconditionerprovidesspecialnourishingandallday
volumefromroottotip

Unilever

Clear

StrongLengthsDailyConditionercontainsarichstrengtheningserumto
nurtureandprotecthairfrombreakage

Unilever

Clear

MoisturizingDryScalpconditionercontainsanextrarichformulathat
nourishesdryscalpandhairtorestorenaturalmoisturebalance

Unilever

Clear

FrizzControlconditionerhasagentlenourishingformulainfusedwitha
smoothingcomplex,provides24hourfrizzcontrol

Unilever

Clear

UltraSheaconditionercontainsaformulainfusedwithNutritium10TM
MoistureLock,sheabutter,andnaturaloilsthatquenchesdrynessand
locksinmoisture

Unilever

Nexxus

FrizzDefyconditionercontainsMoroccanarganoilandcoconutextract,
thathelpcreatesmoothstylesandcontrolfrizzallday

Unilever

TRESemm

SplitRemedyconditionerconditionsandmoisturizeshairstrandwhile
bindingupto80%ofsplitends

Unilever

Suave

DailyclarifyingconditionerisapHbalancedconditioner,thatlightly
nourisheshairaftershampoo,andissuitableforbothnormalaswellasoily
hair

VogueInternational

Organix

KeratinOilconditioner,fightssplitendsandstrengthensandrestoreshair
beauty

VogueInternational

Organix

CitrusMintconditionerthickensandtexturizeshairwhilestimulatingscalp
withfreshnessofcitrusextracts

VogueInternational

Organix

MoroccanArganOilconditionerisfreefromsulfatesandparabens,andisa
blendofMoroccanarganoil,vitaminE,andantioxidants

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D17

4D18

Conditioners

M&Aactivity

In 2012, Brynwood Partners acquires the brand White Rain from Sun Products for an
undisclosedamount.
WhiteRainissoldinthetopthreecategoriesofthehaircareproductclass:shampoos,
conditioners,andhairstylingproducts.
ThisdealisexpectedtostrengthenthepositionofBrynwoodPartnersinthehaircare
productclass.

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbytradeclass

The mass trade class continues to be the leading retail channel in 2012, accounting for
74.8%ofthecategorysalesin2012.
Productsinthespecialtyandluxurytradeclassesremainflatduringtheyear.

Table4D10:ManufacturersSalesofConditionersintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2011and2012

Tradeclass

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

1,187

1,236

75.2

74.8

4.1

349

356

22.1

21.5

2.0

Direct

19

37

1.2

2.2

94.7

Specialty

15

16

1.0

1.0

6.7

0.5

0.5

1,578

1,653

100.0

100.0

4.8

Professional

Luxury
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

2011

Mass

$Million

Change,%

Conditioners

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4D11:ManufacturersSalesofConditionersintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Unilever

336

362

21.3

21.9

7.7

Procter&Gamble

324

327

20.5

19.8

0.9

LOral

250

253

15.8

15.3

1.2

Johnson&Johnson

55

57

3.5

3.4

3.6

EsteLauder

47

49

3.0

3.0

4.3

JohnPaulMitchellSystems

42

43

2.7

2.6

2.4

Kao

41

41

2.6

2.5

VogueInternational

24

38

1.5

2.3

58.3

Privatelabel

43

41

2.7

2.5

(4.7)

416

442

26.4

26.7

6.3

1,578

1,653

100.0

100.0

4.8

Allother
Total

Unilever,theleadingmarketer,hasashareof21.9%ofthecategoryssalesin2012,slightly
upfrom21.3%in2011.
Salesforthemarketergrow7.7%from$336millionin2011to$362millionin2012.
Unileverprimarilybenefitswiththelaunchofanewbrand,Clearconditionersin2012.
Clear has sales of $27 million in 2012, as the brand benefits from its scalp therapy
rangeofconditioners.
ThelargestbrandfromUnileverisSuave,whichhasacategoryshareof6.5%in2012.
Sales for Suave grow 4.9% from $103million in 2011 to $108million in 2012. New
product launches and its economically priced products contribute to the brands
growth.
TRESemm,thesecondlargestbrandforUnilever,hasanoverallshareof6.5%in2012.
SalesofTRESemmdeclineby1.8%,from$109millionin2011to$107millionin2012.
Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
Dove,thethirdlargestbrandforUnilever,hasacategoryshareof4.0%in2012.
Salesforthebranddeclineby2.9%,from$68millionin2011to$66millionin2012.
Minimaladvertisingsupportcontributestothebrandsdeclineinthecategory.
Unilevers youthcentric brand Sunsilk is discontinued in 2012. Diminishing consumer
interestinthebrandresultsinthediscontinuationofthebrand.
The only professional brand marketed by Unilever in the category is TIGI, with the
brandssalesflatat$17million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D19

4D20

Conditioners

In 2012, the secondleading marketer, Procter& Gamble, has a share of 19.8% in the
categoryssales.
Salesforthecompanygrow0.9%,upfrom$324millionin2011to$327millionin2012.
PanteneProVmaintainsitspositionasthetopbrandinthecategorywithacategory
share of 10.0%. Sales for the brand decline 1.2% from $167million in 2011 to
$165millionin2012.
Limitednewproductactivity,lackofdifferentiation,andlimitedpromotionalactivities
contributetothebrandssalesdeclinein2012.
The only significant launches under the Pantene ProV brand in 2012 are Advanced
KeratinconditionerandAgeDefyconditioner.
HerbalEssences,thesecondlargestbrandforProcter&Gamble,hasacategoryshare
of5.9%in2012.
It is the fifthlargest brand in the category. Sales for the brand are up 2.1% from
$96millionin2011to$98millionin2012.
New product activity from the brand and its natural products line contribute to the
brandsgrowthinthecategory.Thecompanylaunchesarangeofnaturalconditioners
includingHoneyImStrongconditionerandLongTermRelationshipnaturalconditioner
undertheHerbalEssencesbrand.
SalesforAussiegrow6.7%from$45millionin2011to$48millionin2012.
Better promotional activities, such as instore marketing contribute to the brands
growthinthecategory.
Intheprofessionaltradeclass,Procter&Gamblehasasegmentshareof2.0%in2012;
SebastianistheonlybrandmarketedbyProcter&Gambleintheprofessionalsegment.
SalesforSebastiandeclineby$1millionto$7millionin2012.

LOralisplacedthirdinthecategorywithashareof15.3%.Salesforthemarketergrow
1.2%from$250millionin2011to$253millionin2012.
ThelargestbrandfromLOralisGarnierFructis,whichhasashareof7.0%ofthetotal
categoryssales.
Garnier Fructis is the secondlargest brand in the category. Sales for Garnier Fructis
declineby0.9%from$116millionin2011to$115millionin2012.
Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
TheonlysignificantlaunchundertheGarnierFructisbrandisPureCleanconditioner.
EverPure,thelineofsulfatefreeconditionersintroducedin2011,continuestoperform
wellforLOralin2012.
Thebrandgrowsby5.9%from$17millionin2011to$18millionin2012.
ThesuccessofEverPureandEverSleekandthegrowingconsumerconcernaboutharsh
chemicalsusedinhaircareproductspromptsLOraltolaunchafourthlineofsulfate
freeproducts.Thenewline,EverCreme,hassalesof$5millionduringitsfirstyearof
introductionin2012.
Vive Pro, the variant under the LOral Paris umbrella, continues to witness sales
decline in 2012. Sales for the brand shrink from $14million in 2011 to $11million in
2012.
Salessufferduetolimitedpromotionalspendingandlackofnewproductactivityfrom
thebrandin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

Conditioners

LOralistheleadingmarketerintheprofessionaltradeclasswithashareof24.7%in2012.
The company markets the top professional conditioner brand Matrix. Sales for the
brandgrow2.3%from$43millionin2011to$44millionin2012.
SalesforRedkengrowby$1millionto$30millionin2012.Newconditionersunderthe
DiamondOilandAllSoftlineareaddedtoRedkensofferingsin2012.
The sales of the brand Pureology, offering color protection products, remain flat at
$13millionin2012.

Johnson&Johnsonisthefourthleadingmarketerinthecategory,withacategoryshareof
3.4%in2012.
Themarketersellsthreebrandsinthecategory:Neutrogena,Aveeno,andJohnson's.
The marketer launches several new products under both, Aveeno and Neutrogena
brandsthatsupportthemarketerssalesgrowthinthecategory.
Salesforthecompanygrowby3.6%from$55millionin2011to$57millionin2012.
Neutrogena,thelargestbrandforJohnson&Johnson,hasacategoryshareof1.9%in
2012.
The sales of the brand grow by $1 million from $31 million in 2011 to $32 million in
2012.
ThelaunchofNeutrogenaTGelrangeofconditionerssupportsthebrandsgrowthin
2012.
ThesalesofAveenogrowby6.7%,from$15millionin2011to$16millionin2012.

EsteLauder,withacategoryshareof3.0%,isinfifthplaceinthecategory.Thecompany
operatesintheprofessionalconditionersandluxuryconditionerssegment.
Salesforthecompanygrowfrom$47millionin2011to$49millionin2012,registering
agrowthof4.3%.
ThemarketerbenefitsfromthelaunchofAvedaInvatirangeofconditionersthatclaim
toreducehairloss.
The marketer sells two brands in the professional segment: Aveda and Bumble and
bumble.
OriginsistheonlybrandmarketedbyEsteLauderintheluxurysegment.
SalesofAvedagrowby$1millionfrom$32millionin2011to$33millionin2012.
Bumble and bumble, the other professional brand of Este Lauder, grows 7.7% from
$13millionin2011to$14millionin2012.

Privatelabel

Sales of the privatelabel conditioners decline by 4.7% from $43million in 2011 to


$41millionin2012.
As the economy recovers, consumers in the United States switch back to national
brands,contributingtothesalesdeclineofprivatelabelproductsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D21

4D22

Conditioners

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandiserscontinuetoleadthecategory,with39%ofthecategoryssales.
Drug stores maintain their share as the channel increases its offering of economical
pricedproductsandprivatelabelproducts.

Table4D12:ManufacturersSalesofConditionersintheUnitedStates
byRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

Massmerchandisers

40

39

Foodstores

21

20

Drugstores

18

18

Professionaloutlets

17

16

Specialtystores

Directsales

Departmentstores

100

100

Total

2012

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Marketers advertise both shampoos and conditioners together as part of their hair care
lines.
Marketing and promotional activity is the key driver for the conditioners category in
theUnitedStates.
Promotional campaigns usually include television and print advertising, along with
couponing.

Print and broadcast media advertising continue to be the primary mode for marketing
conditionerbrands.
Marketersadvertisetheirnewproductsextensivelyontelevision,innewspapers,and
inmagazines.
Fashion magazines and womens magazines, such as Allure and InStyle, are the main
avenuesforprintbasedadvertisingforconditioners.
Marketers promote the entire hair care product lines including hair styling,
conditioners,andhaircoloring.
LOraladvertisesitsEverCremebrandwiththeclaimsulfatefreemoisturesystem.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

Conditioners

Marketers primarily advertise product benefits through the media to keep consumers
interestengaged.
TelevisioncommercialsforNexxusFrizzProtectionlineclaims,smoothensupto100%
ofroughnessandreduces90%frizz.

Discount coupons and pricebased promotions continue to remain the key tool for
marketers.
Discountsareofferedonnewproductstoencouragetrial.
Marketersalsousediscountsinanattempttorevivebrandsfacingasalesslowdown.
Discountsareofferedthroughcouponsdistributedviafreestandinginserts(FSIs),print
advertisements,andtheInternet.
Coupons in $1.00 and $2.00 denominations are offered by all the leading marketers
includingUnileverandProcter&Gamble.
Marketers also provide discounts and buyonegetone free promotions for brands
whosesalesaredeclininginordertokeepuptheirshare.
Marketers also provide free samples to promote the sales of their underperforming
brands.

Marketers continue to use the Internet as one of the major sources for advertising their
brands.
Social media sites, such as Facebook, Pinterest, and Twitter, are widely used by
marketersforpromotinghaircareproducts.
Newlaunchesandproductinformationisprovidedbymostofthemarketersthrough
theirrespectiveFacebookpageandthroughothersocialmediasites.
Marketers also provide discount coupons on their websites. For example, Dove and
Garnierprovidediscountcouponsontheirindividualwebsites.
Thewebsitesalsoprovidehairtipsandsuggestionsfordifferenthairproblems.
Major brands websites communicate product benefits and other unique features of
eachlineandvariant.

In 2012, traceable media expenditures (TME) specifically for conditioners total


$118.8million,upsignificantlyfrom$41.0millionin2011.
LOral has the highest media spending in the category in 2012. LOrals advertising
spendingonpromotingitsconditionersis$40.7million.
Approximately,62%or$25.4millionisspentonpromotingitsGarnierFructisline.
Unileverhasthesecondhighestmediaspendinginthecategory.Unileversadvertising
spending on promoting its conditioners is $12.6million. Approximately, 55.8% or
$7.6millionisspentonpromotingitsDovebrand.
Procter&Gamble,thesecondleadingmarketerinthecategory,spends$2.6millionin
2012,adeclineby51.9%from$5.4millionin2011.

DetailsonTMEfor2012areprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D23

4D24

Conditioners

OUTLOOK

Salesofconditionersareexpectedtogrowsteadilyovertheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
SalesofconditionersatthemanufacturerslevelareforecasttogrowataCAGRof2.5%
duringtheforecastperiod.
New product activity and considerable promotional and marketing activities are
expectedtobetheprimegrowthdriversforthesalesgrowthofthecategory.
The continuous growth in the aging population will likely drive the need for
conditionersasthemoistureandshineinthehairdeclineswithage.

Productinnovationwillcontinuetodrivethecategoryssalesovertheforecastperiod.
Research and development efforts from the leading marketers will result in the
introductionofnewandinnovativeproducts.
Majority of the marketers are expected to launch innovative products that cater to
specifichairproblemsincludingthinningandvolumeboostthatwillperformwellover
theforecastperiod.
Conditionersthatcatertospecifichairproblemsandhairtypesareexpectedtosupport
thecategoryssales.
Conditionersthatofferextrabenefits,suchassunprotectionandscalpprotectionare
expectedtoperformwell.Marketersareexpectedtolaunchsuchproductsinorderto
increasetheirmarketshareinthecategory.

Consumersfromcertaindemographicswillcontributetothecategorysgrowth.
Thegrowingproportionofbabyboomersislikelytoresultinincreasedconsumptionof
hairconditioningproducts,sinceagingdiminishesthenaturalmoisturecontentofhair,
resultingintheneedformoisturizationthroughconditioningagents.

Products targeted at men are expected to increase, resulting in an increase in the


contributionofmaleconsumerstothecategorysgrowth.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Procter & Gamble will continue to
launch menspecific shampoos and conditioners to support the growth of mens care
conditionersovertheforecastperiod.

Colorprotectingandcolorenhancingconditionersareprojectedtogrowatahealthyrate
duringtheforecastperiod.
Consumerswhocolortheirhairareexpectedtoincrease,contributingtothegrowthof
colorprotectionconditioners.
Technological innovations will make the conditioners more effective in protecting
coloredhairandenhancingthecoloredeffect.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

Conditioners

Marketers are expected to incorporate more natural ingredients in their products, as


consumerschoosenaturallypositionedproducts.
Productsformulatedwithnaturalingredientsarelikelytoemergeasagrowingniche
duringtheforecastperiod.
Growing fears of the potential harm caused by chemical ingredients will encourage
consumerstopurchaseproductswithnaturalingredients.
Chemical agents, such as sulfates and parabens will be increasingly eliminated from
product formulations in view of the widely publicized potential harm associated with
theseingredients.

Marketers are expected to increase their marketing and promotional activities over the
forecastperiod.
Marketers are expected to continue supporting new products with aggressive and
innovativeadvertisingcampaigns.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Procter & Gamble are expected to
increase their TME spending to support their respective brands over the forecast
period.
Newproductactivityandpromotionsareexpectedtobetheprimegrowthdriversin
themasstradeclass.

ManufacturerssalesareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof2.5%to$1,870millionby2017,
upfrom$1,653millionin2012.

Unit volume sales are projected to increase at a CAGR of 1.5%, growing from 443million
packagesin2012to480millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D25

4D26

Conditioners

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesofethnichaircareproductsgrow2.1%in2012,from$333millionin
2011to$340millionin2012.

Thecategoryssalesgrowatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of1.5%since2007.

Table4D13:HistoricalSalesofEthnicHairCareProducts
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

316

2008

305

(3.5)

2009

314

3.0

2010

328

4.5

2011

333

1.5

2012

340

2.1

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unitsalesinthecategoryadvance1.5%,from97.8millionpackagesin2011to99.3million
packagesin2012.

Retailsales

Retail sales of ethnic hair care products are estimated at $486.0million in 2012, up 2.1%
from$475.9millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D28

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D14:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Producttype/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

RELAXERKITS
Dark&Lovely

L'Oral

18

16

17.5

16.0

5.4

4.7

SoftsheenOptimumCare

L'Oral

16

15

15.5

15.0

4.8

4.4

Soft&Beautiful

Unilever

10

9.7

9.0

3.0

2.6

OrganicRootStimulator

DermovivaSkin
Essentials

6.8

8.0

2.1

2.4

JustForMe

Unilever

7.8

8.0

2.4

2.4

GentleTreatment

JohnsonProducts

6.8

7.0

2.1

2.1

PinkOil

LusterProducts

5.8

5.0

1.8

1.5

LusterSCurl

LusterProducts

4.9

4.0

1.5

1.2

AfricanPride

StrengthofNature

3.9

4.0

1.2

1.2

UltraSheen

JohnsonProducts

3.9

4.0

1.2

1.2

CrmeofNature

Colomer

1.9

3.0

0.6

0.9

Realistic

Colomer

1.9

2.0

0.6

0.6

PCJ

LusterProducts

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

BeautifulBeginnings

L'Oral

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

Fabulaxer

Colomer

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

TCB

Unilever

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

Motions

Unilever

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

10

8.7

10.0

2.7

2.9

103

100

100.0

100.0

30.9

29.4

Allother
Total

STYLINGAIDS
PinkOil

LusterProducts

11.8

11.3

2.4

2.4

Dark&Lovely

L'Oral

10.3

9.9

2.1

2.1

Ampro

Ampro

7.4

9.9

1.5

2.1

Isoplus

MurraysWorldwide

8.8

8.5

1.8

1.8

Soft&Beautiful

Unilever

7.4

7.0

1.5

1.5

LetsJam

L'Oral

5.9

5.6

1.2

1.2

PanteneProV

Procter&Gamble

5.9

5.6

1.2

1.2

SoftsheenOptimumCare

L'Oral

4.4

4.2

0.9

0.9

BB

BronnerBrothers

2.9

2.8

0.6

0.6

Realistic

Colomer

2.9

2.8

0.6

0.6

Smooth'NShine

Henkel

2.9

2.8

0.6

0.6

TCB

Unilever

2.9

2.8

0.6

0.6

LeKairCholesterol

ScientificResearch

1.5

1.4

0.3

0.3

Motions

Unilever

1.5

1.4

0.3

0.3

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

4D29

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D14:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftradeclass

Producttype/brand

Company

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

1.5

1.4

0.3

0.3

15

16

22.1

22.5

4.5

4.7

68

71

100.0

100.0

20.4

20.9

Dark&Lovely

L'Oral

22

23

41.5

41.1

6.6

6.8

Textures&Tones

Procter&Gamble

11

11

20.8

19.6

3.3

3.2

Bigen

HoyuAmerica

13.2

14.3

2.1

2.4

CrmeofNature

Colomer

7.5

7.1

1.2

1.2

Dark&Natural

L'Oral

7.5

7.1

1.2

1.2

9.4

10.7

1.5

1.8

53

56

100.0

100.0

15.9

16.5

2011

%Oftotal

STYLINGAIDS(Continued)
Parnevu

MurraysWorldwide

Allother
Total

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS

Allother
Total

HAIRDRESSESANDLOTIONS
OrganicRootStimulator

DermovivaSkin
Essentials

12.5

13.7

1.8

2.1

PinkOil

LusterProducts

10.4

9.8

1.5

1.5

BlueMagic

J.Strickland

6.3

7.8

0.9

1.2

BB

BronnerBrothers

6.3

5.9

0.9

0.9

SoftsheenOptimumCare

L'Oral

6.3

5.9

0.9

0.9

AfricanPride

StrengthofNature

6.3

5.9

0.9

0.9

AllWays

Colomer

6.3

5.9

0.9

0.9

TCB

Unilever

6.3

5.9

0.9

0.9

Isoplus

MurraysWorldwide

4.2

3.9

0.6

0.6

Murrays

MurraysWorldwide

4.2

3.9

0.6

0.6

UltraSheen

JohnsonProducts

4.2

3.9

0.6

0.6

SoftsheenOptimumOil
Therapy

L'Oral

4.2

3.9

0.6

0.6

RoyalCrown

J.Strickland

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

CombThru

Unilever

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

Dax

ImperialDax

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

SoftsheenBreakthru

L'Oral

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

Motions

Unilever

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

12.5

13.7

1.8

2.1

48

51

100.0

100.0

14.4

15.0

Allother
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D30

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D14:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Producttype/brand

Company

2011

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

SHAMPOOSANDCONDITIONERS
CrmeofNature

Colomer

16.7

18.9

1.8

2.1

PanteneProV

Procter&Gamble

16.7

10.8

1.8

1.2

OrganicRootStimulator

DermovivaSkin
Essentials

8.3

8.1

0.9

0.9

SoftsheenOptimumCare

L'Oral

8.3

8.1

0.9

0.9

PinkOil

LusterProducts

5.6

5.4

0.6

0.6

QueenHelene

QueenHelene

5.6

5.4

0.6

0.6

SoftsheenBreakthru

L'Oral

5.6

5.4

0.6

0.6

Dark&Lovely

L'Oral

5.6

5.4

0.6

0.6

Isoplus

MurraysWorldwide

5.6

5.4

0.6

0.6

LeKairCholesterol

ScientificResearch

2.8

2.7

0.3

0.3

TCB

Unilever

2.8

2.7

0.3

0.3

Motions

Unilever

2.8

5.4

0.3

0.6

13.9

16.2

1.5

1.8

36

37

100.0

100.0

10.8

10.9

Allother
Total

CURL/WAVEMAINTENANCEPRODUCTS
CareFreeCurl/CareFree
CurlGold

L'Oral

29.4

29.4

1.5

1.5

LusterSCurlWave
Nouveau

LusterProducts

17.6

17.6

0.9

0.9

Dark&Natural

L'Oral

11.8

11.8

0.6

0.6

Lustrasilk

InspiredBeautyBrands

11.8

11.8

0.6

0.6

LongAid

KeystoneLaboratories

5.9

5.9

0.3

0.3

TCB

Unilever

5.9

5.9

0.3

0.3

WorldofCurls

J.Strickland

5.9

5.9

0.3

0.3

11.8

11.8

0.6

0.6

17

17

100.0

100.0

5.1

5.0

Allother
Total

CURL/WAVEKITS
CombThru

Unilever

18.8

18.8

0.9

0.9

LusterSCurl

LusterProducts

12.5

12.5

0.6

0.6

SportinWave

L'Oral

12.5

12.5

0.6

0.6

Duke

Johnson&Johnson

6.3

6.3

0.3

0.3

Total

100.0

100.0

2.4

2.4

TOTAL

333

340

100.0

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

EthnicHairCareProducts

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Salesofethnichaircareproductsgrow2.1%in2012.
SeveralleadingmarketersincludingL'OralandUnileverlaunchanewrangeofethnic
haircareproducts,therebysupportingthecategorysgrowth.
Naturallypositionedproductssupportthegrowthofthecategoryasethnicconsumers
increasinglychooseproductsthatcontainnaturalandorganicingredients.

In2012,productsthatcatertospecifichairtypesandhairconcerns,suchasfrizzandcurl,
controlperformwellinthecategory.
Severalleadingmarketers,suchasColomerandUnileverlaunchproductsthatsuitdry
hairandcurlyhairtosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Afewmarketerslaunchproductswithinnovativeformulationsthatcatertotheneeds
oftheethnicconsumers,supportingthecategorysgrowth.
ColomerlaunchesStrengthofNatureBeautifulTexturesthatisintendedforconsumers
withcurlyhairandisalsoclaimedtocontrolfrizz.
Este Lauder launches Aveda Curl Controller that contains organic babassu oil which
smoothesandelongatestightcurlswhilefightingfrizzandconditioninghair.

Ethnic hair care products that are naturallypositioned continue to perform well in the
category.
Incorporationofnaturalandorganicproductsintheethnichaircareproductscategory
continuestogainmomentum.
Several ethnic hair care marketers, such as Carols Daughter and Colomer launch
products with natural ingredients or enhance their existing products with natural
ingredientstosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Naturallypositionedbrands,suchasCrmeofNatureperformwellin2012,andsales
ofthebrandgrowby16.7%,from$12millionin2011to$14millionin2012.
Also, increased awareness and dissatisfaction regarding synthetic chemicalbased
products on the hair, helps ethnic hair consumers shift to the use of natural and
organicproducts.
Moreover,ithasbeenobservedthatnaturallytreatedhairrequireslessmaintenance
thansyntheticchemicallytreatedhair.
FragilephysicalpropertiesofAfricanAmericanhairisanotherimportantreasonforthe
marketerstofocusonnaturalingredients.
In 2012, Carols Daughter introduces Manoi Oil Sacred Strengthening Serum that
containsMonoiOil;asacredTahitianblendoftheTiareGardeniaFlowerandCoprah
CoconutOil,whchclaimstostrengthenhair.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D31

4D32

EthnicHairCareProducts

IngredientssourcedfromAfricacontinuetoplayanimportantroleinthecategorysgrowth,
duetotheirprovenefficacyandtraditionalusageamongtheAfricanpopulation.
Shea butter, shea oil, and other herbal ingredients of African origin are increasingly
beingincorporatedinproductsaimedatAfricanAmericanconsumers.
Othercommonlyusedingredientsincludealoe,honey,sheaoil,oliveoil,coconutoil,
andavocado.
In 2012, SheaMoisture introduces its Three Butters line of products that contain
ingredientsincludingshea,mango,andavocadobutters.

Therelaxerkitssegmentssalescontinuetodeclinein2012.
AlthoughrelaxershavebeenatthetopoftheAfricanAmericanhairindustryformany
years,2007witnessedabeginningtotheend,withconstantlydecliningsalesofrelaxer
kits.
The socalled naturalista trend primarily contributes to the segments decline in the
category.Thetermappliestopeoplewhoseeknaturalproductsandwhoshunrelaxers
becauseoftheintrinsicharshchemicalformulationsthatallowrelaxerstowork.

Increasingavailabilityofethnichaircareproductsthroughthemasschannelpromotesthe
categorysgrowthin2012.
Mass merchandisers offer premium ethnic hair care brands along with traditional
brands supporting the categorys growth. A few premium variants available at mass
outletsincludeJaneCarterSolutionandMissJessiesCurlsline.
Consumers choose to shop in mass outlets due to the availability of ethnic hair care
productsateconomicalprices.

Notablenewproducts

Table4D15:SelectNewEthnicHairCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

AfricanPride

StrengthofNature

BeautifulTexturesconditionshairfromtiptoroot,whilereducingfrizz

CarolsDaughter

MonoiOil

SacredStrengtheningSerumreversesandpreventsdamageto
distressedhaircausedbyheatstyling,colortreating,orchemical
straightening

DermovivaSkin
Essentials

OrganicRoot
Stimulator

Moisturizinghairlotionprotectshairfromhighheat,restoresthe
hairsnaturalmoisturebalance,andstraightensit

DermovivaSkin
Essentials

OrganicRoot
Stimulator

OliveOilBuiltInProtectionisanolyerelaxertoalleviatetheitching
andburningthatsometimesoccurduringtherelaxerprocess

EsteLauder

Aveda

BeCurlyCurlControllerconditionsandreducesfrizz.Itscontains
babassuoil,softeninglocks

EsteLauder

Aveda

BeCurlyCurlEnhancingHairSpray,infusedwithorganicaloeand
wheatprotein

InspiredBeauty
BrandsInc

Lustrasilk

MoistureMaxHydrateTherapyconditionerreconstructs,strengthens,
andprotectsthehairstrand,whilemaintainingmoisturebalance

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D15:SelectNewEthnicHairCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

InspiredBeauty
BrandsInc

Lustrasilk

MoistureMaxLeaveInMoisturisingConditioningsprayconditions,
strengthens,andrepairshair

LusterProducts

PinkOil

PinkGlossercontains10naturalingredientsthathelpnourishhairand
addsbrilliantshinetothehair

LusterProducts

PinkOil

PinkStylingShaperpreventshairfromstyledamaging,while
protectinghairfromexcessiveheatstyling

LOral

DarkandLovely

AuNaturaleantibreakagemaintenanceandstylinglineisinfusedwith
mangooilandbamboomilk,nourishmentforallcurltypes

LOral

DarkandNatural

5MinutePermanentHaircolorlocksincolorandleaveshairsoft

LOral

DarkandLovely

HealthyGloss5MoistureHairCrmeinfuseshairwithsupremeshine
andreplenisheshairandscalpwithmoisture

LOral

DarkandLovely

FadeResistantRichConditioningColor,containsmoistureseal
technology,enhancestheconditioningpower

Procter&Gamble

Pantene

TrulyNaturalshampooprovidesmoisture,shine,andhealthtoeach
hairstrand

Procter&Gamble

Pantene

TrulyNaturalconditioneraddsmoistureandhealthtoeachhairstrand

Procter&Gamble

Pantene

TrulyNaturalShineSerumaddsmoisturetohairanditskeyingredient
arganoiladdslonglastingshine

SheaMoisture

ThreeButters

ThreeButtersUtilityShampoo,includesshea,mangoandavocado
butterstoprovidehydration

SheaMoisture

ThreeButters

ThreeButtersUtilityScalpConditionerenhancessmoothnessand
refinesskinstexture

SheaMoisture

ThreeButters

ThreeButtersUtilityGelMoussesmoothesandhydrateshair,while
addinghold

Unilever

Motions

MoisturizingCleansercontainssheabutter,coconut,andavocadooils

Unilever

Motions

SmoothingConditionersoftensandnourisheseventhemost
unmanageablecurls,infusedwithingredientssheabutter,coconut,
andavocadooils

Unilever

Motions

RadiatingGlossprovidesanaturalandevenluster,containsshea
butter

Unilever

Motions

DefineMyCurlsisarichgelthatenhancesmoisturetodeliverthe
ultimatesoft,separatedcurls

Unilever

Motions

HydratemyCurlshydratesandlightlydefinescurls,whilereducing
frizz

Unilever

Motions

DeepConditioningMasquecontainssheabutter

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D33

4D34

EthnicHairCareProducts

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Relaxerkitsisthelargestsegmentinthecategory,accountingfor29.4%ofthecategorys
sales,downfrom30.9%in2011.
Segmentsalesdecline2.9%from$103millionin2011to$100millionin2012.
Despite the growing reluctance to use products with a high proportion of chemicals,
relaxerkitsremainthelargestsegmentinthecategory,asthevastmajorityofAfrican
Americanwomenconsiderrelaxersindispensable.

Styling aids, with a share of 20.9% in 2012, up from 20.4% in 2011, is the secondlargest
segmentinthecategory.
Salesinthesegmentadvanceto$71millionin2012,up4.4%from$68millionin2011.
Thesegmentholdsitsownevenasgeneralmarketstylingproductsincreasinglytarget
ethnicconsumers.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and L'Oral introduce new styling
productstosupportthesegmentsgrowthinthecategory.
In2012,UnileverlaunchesalineofMotionsstylingproductsincludingDefineMyCurls
andHydrateMyCurls.

Haircoloringproducts,withashareof16.5%,isthethirdlargestsegmentinthecategory.
Salesgrow5.7%from$53millionin2011to$56millionin2012.
Ethnic consumers with the primary purpose of gray coverage, continues to drive
segmentgrowth.
Ethnicteenagersandmenareincreasinglydriventohaircolors,followingthefashion
trends.

Hairdressesandlotionssegmentadvancesto$51millionin2012,up6.3%from$48million
in2011.
The segment constitutes 15.0% of the total category sales in 2012, up from 14.4% in
2011.

Sales of shampoos and conditioners grow 2.8% to reach $37million in 2012, up from
$36millionin2011.
Thesegmentaccountsfor10.9%oftheoverallcategorysalesin2012,upfrom10.8%in
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D16:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Relaxerkits

103

100

30.9

29.4

(2.9)

Stylingaids

68

71

20.4

20.9

4.4

Haircoloringproducts

53

56

15.9

16.5

5.7

Hairdressesandlotions

48

51

14.4

15.0

6.3

Shampoosandconditioners

36

37

10.8

10.9

2.8

Curl/wavemaintenanceproducts

17

17

5.1

5.0

2.4

2.4

333

340

100.0

100.0

2.1

Curl/wavekits
Total

COMPETITION

Table4D17:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

$Million

Company

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

LOral

97

95

29.1

27.9

(2.1)

Unilever

39

39

11.7

11.5

LusterProducts

32

30

9.6

8.8

(6.3)

Colomer

20

22

6.0

6.5

10.0

Procter&Gamble

21

19

6.3

5.6

(9.5)

DermovivaSkinEssentials

16

18

4.8

5.3

12.5

JohnsonProducts

13

13

3.9

3.8

MurraysWorldwide

13

13

3.9

3.8

HoyuAmerica

2.1

2.4

14.3

StrengthofNature

2.1

2.1

J.Strickland

1.5

1.8

20.0

63

70

18.9

20.6

11.1

333

340

100.0

100.0

2.1

Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D35

4D36

EthnicHairCareProducts

LOralcontinuestobetheleadingmarketerinthecategory,withanoverallcategoryshare
of27.9%in2012,downfrom29.1%in2011.
Salesofthecompanydecline2.1%,from$97millionin2011to$95millionin2012.
Lackofsignificantmarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributestothesalesdecline
forthemarketerin2012.
In 2012, LOral introduces Dark and Lovely Au Naturale antibreakage maintenance
andstylingline,alongwithafewotherproductintroductionstooffsetitssalesdecline.
LOralsupportsitsbrandswithaninsignificanttraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)of
amere$0.2millionin2012.
Dark & Lovely is the leading brand in the market accounting for 14.1% of the overall
categoryssalesin2012,downfrom14.7%in2011.
Salesforthebranddeclinefrom$49millionin2011toreach$48millionin2012.
Dark&Lovelyistheleadingbrandinhaircoloringproducts,relaxerkits,whileinstyling
itisthesecondleadingbrand.
Lackofmarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributestothebrandssalesdeclinein
2012.
OptimumCareisthesecondleadingbrandforLOralwithanoverallcategoryshareof
6.6%in2012,downfrom6.2%in2011.
Salesofthebranddecline4.5%from$22millionin2011to$21millionin2012.

Unileveristhesecondleadingmarketerinthecategorywithashareof11.5%in2012.
Salesforthecompanyremainflatat$39millionin2012,thesameasin2011.
Lackoftechnologicaladvancementsandlimitednewproductactivityaccountforsales
decline for Unilever in 2012. Limited distribution channels, with beauty supply stores
accountingforthemajority,offsetthegrowthofthemarketer.
Soft & Beautiful is the leading brand for Unilever, accounting for 4.1% of the total
categoryssalesin2012,downfrom4.5%in2011.
Thebrandssalesdecline$1millionfrom$15millionin2011to$14millionin2012.
Soft&Beautifulhaspresenceintherelaxerkitsandthestylingaidssegments.
Lackofmarketingandpromotionalactivitieslimitsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory
in2012.
JustForMeandTCBaretiedforsecondplace,withsalesat$8millioneachin2012.
JustForMeisabrandespeciallyformulatedforchildrenintheagegroupof514years.
TCBisaneconomicalhaircarebranddesignedespeciallyforAfricanAmericanwomen.
SalesoftheMotionsbrandgrowby$1million,from$4millionin2011to$5millionin
2012.Anincreasingnewproductactivitysupportsthebrandsgrowthin2012.Unilever
launchesarangeofMotionsNaturallyYouproductsincludingshampoos,conditioners,
andstylingaidsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

EthnicHairCareProducts

LusterProducts,thethirdplacedmarketer,hasanoverallcategoryshareof8.8%in2012,
downfrom9.6%in2011.
Salesforthecompanydecline6.3%from$32millionin2011to$30millionin2012.
Lackofnewproductactivityandmarketingcontributetothemarketerssalesdecline
inthecategory.
Pink Oil is the leading brand with sales at $20million in 2012, down 4.8% from
$21millionin2011.
SalesofLusterSCurl,thesecondleadingbrandofLusterProducts,decline10.0%from
$10millionin2011to$9millionin2012.

Colomer regains its position as the fourthleading marketer in the category, displacing
Procter&Gamble.
Salesofthecompanyadvance10.0%toreach$22millionin2012,from$20millionin
2011.
Increasingnewproductactivitysupportsthemarketerssalesgrowthinthecategoryin
2012.
CrmeofNatureistheleadingbrandwithsalesof$14millionin2012,up16.7%from
$12millionin2011.
Positive performance and an increasing acceptance of natural products support the
brandsgrowthin2012.
In2012,themarketerlaunchesArganOilrangeofnaturalethnichairproductsacross
varioussegmentsincludingstylingaids,shampoos,conditioners,andhaircoloring.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In2012,beautysupplystoreslosedistributionby2.2%toaccountfor45%ofthetotalretail
sales.
Beautysupplystorescontinuetobetheleadingretailchannelin2012.

The share of mass merchandisers as a retail outlet for ethnic hair care products remains
constantat27%.
The increase in the share of mass merchandisers is a result of the increased sales of
ethnic hair care products from such stores due to the availability of products at
economicalprices.

Theretaildistributionproportionbetweendrugstores,andprofessionaloutletsremainsthe
samein2012,asseenin2011.
Foodstoresshareincreasesto7%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D37

4D38

EthnicHairCareProducts

Table4D18:ManufacturersSalesofEthnicHairCareProductsintheUnited
StatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

Beautysupplystores

46

45

Massmerchandisers

27

27

Drugstores

20

20

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

100

100

Total

2012

MARKETINGACTIVITY

TotalTMEforethnichaircarereducesdrasticallyfrom2011.ThetotalTMEinthecategory
isestimatedatamere$1.1millionin2012,comparedto$2.9millionin2011.

Pricebased promotions and discount coupons continue to be an important means of


promotingsalesofethnichaircareproducts.
Marketers continue to attract consumers through pricebased promotions, as this is
oneofthekeyfactorswhichinfluenceconsumerstotrynewproducts.
Discount coupons are distributed through magazines, the Internet, and freestanding
inserts(FSIs).
Coupons in $1.00 and $2.00 denominations are offered by all the leading marketers
includingLOralandUnilever.

Marketersrelyontelevisionandprintmediatopromoteethnichaircareproducts.
Advertisements for ethnic hair care products are featured in magazines and on
televisionprogramswithastrongfollowingamongAfricanAmericans.
AfricanAmericancelebritiesarecommonlyfeaturedinthepromotioncampaigns.
Bria Murphy, actress and model, continues to be the brand ambassador for the
SoftsheenCarson brand. Bria Murphy features in various media advertisements
includingtelevisionandprint.

In2012,WeAreOnyxlaunchesanonlinebeautyplatform,weareonyx.com,establishedto
catertotheneedsofethnicconsumersonpersonalcarebeauty.
WeAreOnyx.com website touts itself as an online video platform that lets ethnic
consumerslearnfrombeautyexpertswholooklikethem(AfricanAmericans),shopfor
recommended products directly from the video page, and sample everything before
theymakepurchases.
Memberspayafeeof$20/monthfortheeducationandsamples.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

EthnicHairCareProducts

Marketerspromoteethnichaircareproductsthroughsocialmedianetworksitesincluding
FacebookandPinterest.
New product information and promotional offers are presented by all the leading
brandsincludingSoftsheenCarsonthroughtheirrespectivepagesonFacebook.

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreportandinthedatabase.

OUTLOOK

Theethnichaircarecategoryisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthovertheforecastperiod,
2012to2017.
ThecategoryisexpectedtogrowataCAGRof1.8%overtheforecastperiod.
TheethnicpopulationisprojectedtogrowfasterthantheoverallAmericanpopulation
supportingtheoverallcategorysgrowth.

Productinnovationwilldrivethecategoryssalesovertheforecastperiod.
Products that cater to specific hair concerns, such as curl control, protection against
breakage,andvarioushairtypesareexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
Marketers are expected to incorporate additional hair care benefits, such as frizz
protection and curl control into their products to support their respective market
shares.

Ethnichaircareproductsthatarepositionedasnaturalorcontainnaturalingredientsare
expectedtogrowsignificantlyovertheforecastperiod.
Consumers are likely to continue seeking products that contain natural ingredients,
suchastiareflower(softens,purifies,andsoothes)andfloralextracts.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Luster Products are expected to
eliminatechemicalagents,suchassulfatesandparabensfromtheirproducts.

Relaxerkitsareexpectedtoleadthecategorysshareovertheforecastperiod.
Relaxerkitsareexpectedtoretainitspositionastheleadingsegmentinthecategory.
However,relaxerkitsareexpectedtoexperiencesalesdeclineovertheforecastperiod,
duetothegrowingawarenessabouttheuseofharmfulchemicalsusedinrelaxerkits
totreathair.
The segments growth can rebound if the leading marketers introduce products with
innovativeformulationsovertheforecastperiod.
RelaxerkitscontinuetobeanintegralpartofmanyAfricanAmericanconsumershair
regimenandwilltakeawhiletotransitiontootherproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D39

4D40

EthnicHairCareProducts

Consistent with trends in the general market, AfricanAmerican men are increasingly
focusedongrooming.
Anumberofmenareoptingforlongerhairstyles,suchascornrowsandbraids,which
requirestylingaids.
Mens hair coloring products are also expected to grow in sales during the forecast
period.
Foamhaircolors,whichcontinuetodowellintheoverallmarketin2012,willlikelybe
formulatedforAfricanAmericanhair,drivingsalesinthissegment.

However,thecategoryisexpectedtofacecompetitionfromgeneralhaircarebrandsthat
have hair colors and hair styling product which are attractive to ethnic consumers,
especiallyamongtheyoungerpopulation.
Thecategorysgrowthwillbelimitedwiththepopularityofwigsandhairextensionsin
theUnitedStates.

Sales at the manufacturers level are projected to increase at a CAGR of 1.8% from
$340millionin2012to$371millionin2017.

Unit volume is projected to increase at aCAGR of 1.3% over the forecast period to reach
105.8millionpackagesin2017,upfrom99.3millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesforthehaircoloringproductscategorydeclinemarginallyby0.5%to
$1,317millionin2012,downfrom$1,323millionin2011.

Since2007,thecategoryssaleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of
0.6%.

Table4D19:HistoricalSalesofHairColoringProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

1,277

2008

1,291

1.1

2009

1,257

(2.6)

2010

1,280

1.8

2011

1,323

3.4

2012

1,317

(0.5)

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unitsalesinthecategorydeclineby0.9%from227millionpackagesin2011to225million
packagesin2012.

Retailsales

Retail sales of hair coloring products total $1,677.7million in 2012, down 0.5% from
$1,686.7millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D42

HairColoringProducts

Table4D20:ManufacturersSalesofHairColoringProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompanyand
Brand,2011and2012

$Million

Company/brand

Producttype

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

LORAL
L'OralExcellenceCrme

Permanent

146

152

11.0

11.5

Preference

Permanent

153

151

11.6

11.5

GarnierNutrisse

Permanent

92

97

7.0

7.4

Fria

Permanent

78

73

5.9

5.5

NaturalMatch

Permanent

23

21

1.7

1.6

L'OralCouleurExperte

Specialeffects

22

21

1.7

1.6

ColourRays

Permanent

17

17

1.3

1.3

PreferenceLesBlondissimes

Permanent

15

13

1.1

1.0

HiLightStyliste

Permanent

13

13

1.0

1.0

Frost&Design

Lightener

0.6

0.6

ToneRefiner

Lightener

0.6

0.6

Garnier100%Colora

Permanent

0.2

70

72

5.3

5.5

648

646

49.0

49.1

ClairolNice'NEasyb

Permanent

142

130

10.7

9.9

ClairolNaturalInstincts

Semipermanent

75

67

5.7

5.1

NiceNEasyColorBlendFoam

Permanent

35

37

2.6

2.8

BalsamColor

Semipermanent

0.5

0.5

Frost'NTip

Lightener

0.5

0.5

ClairolLovingCarea

Semipermanent

0.6

ClairolHydriencea

Permanent

0.3

ClairolMen'sChoicea

Haircolorformen

0.2

ClairolTouchofSuna

Lightener

0.2

ClairolUltressa

Permanent

0.1

58

62

4.4

4.7

341

308

25.8

23.4

RevlonColorsilk

Permanent

130

135

9.8

10.3

Frost&Glow

Lightener

0.4

0.4

Allother

12

12

0.9

0.9

Total

147

152

11.1

11.5

Allother
Total
PROCTER&GAMBLE

Allother
Total
REVLON

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

HairColoringProducts

Table4D20:ManufacturersSalesofHairColoringProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompanyand
Brand,2011and2012

Company/brand

Producttype

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

COMBE
JustforMenc

Haircolorformen

110

115

8.3

8.7

GrecianFormula

Haircolorformen

0.6

0.5

Total

118

122

8.9

9.3

26

38

2.0

2.9

15

23

1.1

1.7

0.5

0.5

22

22

1.7

1.7

1,323

1,317

100.0

100.0

KAO
JohnFriedaPrecisionFoamColour
DEVELOPLUS

Permanent

Developlus

Semipermanent

SANOFI
SunIn

Specialeffects

ALLOTHER

TOTAL

aDiscontinued.
bIncludesPerfect10.
cIncludesJustForMenTouchofGray.
rRestated.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Salesforthehaircoloringcategorydeclinesmarginallyin2012.
As the economy continues to recover in 2012, consumers are moving back to
professional hair coloring services, attributing to the decline of the athome hair
coloringcategory.
Mostconsumersvisitsalonsforhaircoloringasitlastsforalongerperiodcomparedto
theathomehaircoloringproducts.
New product activity continues to be sluggish in 2012, with very few product lines
beingintroducedduringtheyear.

Productswithnewformulations,suchashairfoamscontinuetogrowin2012.
Foamformulationsinhaircoloringproductsremainasignificanttrend,whichbeganin
2011.
Advantages,suchasdripfreeformat,100%graycoverage,longlasting,andconvenient
application,increasethedemandforfoamhaircolors.
Severalleadingmarketers,suchasKaoandLOral,launchmorenewfoambasedhair
coloringproducts.
Afewofthekeyvariantsintroducedinthissegmentin2012includeGarnierNutrisse
NourishingcolorfoambyLOralandSammyFatcolorfoambyHoyuAmerica.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D43

4D44

HairColoringProducts

In2012,professionalhaircoloringproductsgainmorepopularityoverathomehaircoloring
products,asmoreconsumersvisitsalons.
With the economic recovery in 2012, women are increasing their frequency of salon
visitsforroottouchuporhaircolor.
Womenconsumersareincreasingthefrequencyoftheirsalonvisitsfromprioryears,
supportingthegrowthofprofessionalhaircoloringproducts.

Thehaircoloringproductscategoryalsobenefitsfromfavorabledemographicandproduct
trends.
The baby boomers population who need to cover graying hair continues to grow in
2012.
Increasingavailabilityofathomehaircoloringproductsencouragesmorepeopletotry
them.
The fashionforward younger consumers continue to experiment with their looks by
changingtheirhaircolor.

Haircoloringmarketerscontinuetoincorporatenaturalingredientsintheirnewproducts.
Haircoloringproductsthatarefreefromchemicals,suchasammoniacontinuetogrow
inthecategory.
Ammonia, a key ingredient present in most permanent hair colors available in the
market,isaharshchemicalwhichhelpsopenupthesurfaceofthehairstrandtoallow
thehaircolortopenetratethrough.
In2012,RevlonlaunchesanammoniafreeLuxuriousColorsilkButtercreamNourishing
PermanentCreamColor.

Kaocontinuestogrowsignificantly,postinganincreaseof46.2%in2012,afteritsmarket
entryin2011withitsnewfoambasedhaircolors.
Themarketercontinuestoaddmoreshadestoitsfoambasedcolorsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

HairColoringProducts

Notablenewproducts

Table4D21:SelectNewHairColoringProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Combe

JustForMen

TheAutostophaircolorisatechnologybreakthrough,involving
thedyeandthehydrogenperoxidealreadymixedinasingle
tubewithascrewedoncomb.Theeffectofthecolordoesnot
getdarkerthanitshouldirrespectiveofthetimeperiodfor
whichitiskepton.Itcomesinareadytouseconvertibletube
andcolorshairin10minutes.Itcomesinfivepermanentshades

Developlus

Splat

SplatHairColorisavailableasoneapplicationkitthatincludes
color,bleach,andperoxide.Itformsaprotectiveshieldthat
preventsthecolorfromwashingout

HoyuAmerica

Sammy

FatFoamisnondripwhippedfoamthatwrapshairstrands
leavingevencoloredhair.Itisavailablein10shadesandeachkit
containscolorpowder,basesolution,gloves,shampoo,
conditioner,mixingshaker,andinstructions

Kao

JohnFrieda

ThemarketeraddsmoreshadestoitsPrecisionFoamColor,
permanenthaircolor,availablein30shades

L'Oral

Fria

FriaWildOmbreisanathomehaircoloringproductthatclaims
togivemultishadeeffectswithonepackage.Itisavailablein
shades,suchasmediumtodarkbrown;darkblondetolight
brown;andlighttomediumblonde.Thepatentedbrush
applicatorallowsquickandpreciseapplication

L'Oral

GarnierNutrisse

Theproductisammoniafreeandcontainsbambooextract
whichreinforcesthehair'sprotectivecuticlelayerwhilecoloring

L'Oral

Preference

Thepermanenthaircolorisoptimizedwithfadedefying
conditionersthatkeephairsilkyandhealthyfromroottotip.
Theproductconcealsgrayhairandisavailablein37shades
rangingfromdarkblondetodarkbrown

L'Oral

GarnierOlia

Theproductisavailablein23shadesanduses60%oilblendwith
naturalfloweroilsinthecolorant.Thisoilbasedformulaincites
colorantstopenetratedeepintohairforlongerlastingcolor

RevlonColorsilk

LuxuriousColorSilkButtercreamisanammoniafree,permanent
athomehaircolorthatisavailablein13shades.Theformula
preventsoversaturationofdyetoattainuniformcolor
throughout

Revlon

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D45

4D46

HairColoringProducts

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Permanenthaircolorcontinuestobethelargestproducttype,accountingfor68.3%ofthe
categoryssalesin2012.
Manufacturerssalesfortheproducttypegrow0.8%,upfrom$893millionin2011to
$900millionin2012.
Female consumers above 30 years of age mostly use permanent hair colors to cover
theirgrayhair.
Introduction of new permanent hair colors by several leading marketers including
LOralsupportthesalesgrowthofthesegmentin2012.

Salesofsemipermanenthaircolorsdecline18.0%,from$89millionin2011to$73million
in2012.
Theshareofsemipermanenthaircolorsintheoverallhaircoloringcategorydeclines
to5.5%in2012,downfrom6.7%in2011.
Thedeclineisseenasyoungerconsumersmovetowardsproductsthatprovidespecial
effectswhiletheolderconsumersgravitatetowardspermanentcolors.
Anumberofsemipermanentlines,suchasClairolLovingCarehavebeendiscontinued,
andnonewonesareintroduced.

Salesofhaircolorformenadvance7.4%,upfrom$121millionin2011to$130millionin
2012.
Thehaircolorformensegmentaccountsfor9.9%ofthesalesinthecategoryin2012,
upfrom9.1%in2011.
Sales of Combe, the leading marketer for mens hair color, grow at 3.4% to reach
$122millionin2012,upfrom$118millionin2011.Itsdominantpositioninthemens
haircolorsegmentisgrowing,asisitsbrandequity.
OthermajormarketersinthesegmentincludeProcter&GambleandLOral,butthey
trailCombesignificantly.
Furthergrowthinthesegmentisoffsetbyminimalnewproductactivityanddearthof
innovations.

Sales of the special effects segment post a decline of 3.6% to reach $27million in 2012,
from$28millionin2011.
Thenichesegmentaccountsforamere2.1%shareoftheoverallcategorysalesin2012,
thesameasin2011.
Limited new product activity and discontinuation of Procter & Gambles Herbal
Essenceslinein2011contributestothesalesdeclineinthesegmentin2012.

Sales of lighteners continue to decline reaching $27million in 2012, down 10.0%, from
$30millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

HairColoringProducts

Table4D22:ManufacturersSalesofHairColoringProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012

$Million

Producttype

2011

2012

893

900

Semipermanent

89

Haircolorformen

2011

2012

67.5

68.3

0.8

73

6.7

5.5

(18.0)

121

130

9.1

9.9

7.4

Specialeffects

28

27

2.1

2.1

(3.6)

Lighteners

30

27

2.3

2.1

(10.0)

162

160

12.2

12.1

(1.2)

1,323

1,317

100.0

100.0

(0.5)

Permanent

Allother
Total

%Oftotal

Change,%

COMPETITION

Table4D23:ManufacturersSalesofHairColoringProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

Company

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

LOral

648

646

49.0

49.1

(0.3)

Procter&Gamble

341

308

25.8

23.4

(9.7)

Revlon

147

152

11.1

11.5

3.4

Combe

118

122

8.9

9.3

3.4

69

89

5.2

6.8

29.0

1,323

1,317

100.0

100.0

Allother
Total

(0.5)

In2012,LOralcontinuestobetheleadingmarketerinthecategory.
LOralaccountsforanestimated49.1%ofthecategoryssalesin2012.
Salesdeclinemarginallyby0.3%from$648millionin2011to$646millionin2012.
LOraldecreasesitsmarketingactivitycontributingtoitssalesdeclinein2012.
ThemarketerallocatesTMEofapproximately$164.8millionin2012,down11.4%from
$186.1millionin2011.
LOralsproductofferingsmainlycomprisepermanenthaircolors.
LOral Preference, L'Oral Excellence, and Garnier Nutrisse are the three leading
brandsofthecompany.
Sales of LOrals leading brand, L'Oral Excellence Crme, post a growth of 4.1% in
2012 and Garnier Nutrisse experiences growth of 5.4%, whereas L'Oral Preference
declines1.3%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D47

4D48

HairColoringProducts

ThemarketersupportsthesalesgrowthofL'OralExcellenceCrmeswithanincrease
inpromotionalactivity(TME)in2012.
The marketer allocates a TME of approximately $32.7 million in 2012, up from
$21.2millionin2011topromotetheL'OralExcellenceCrme.
Garnier Nutrisse enjoys a growth of 5.4% in 2012, with sales reaching $97million in
2012,upfrom$92millionin2011.
Sales of Garnier Nutrisse are supported by the launch of Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing
HairColorFoamin2012.
In spite of new product activity and significant TME support of $18million in 2012,
salesofFriadeclineto$73millionin2012,down6.4%from$78millionin2011.
NaturalColorMatchexperiencesadeclineof8.7%to$21millionin2012,downfrom
$23millionin2011.
In 2012, sales of Couleur Experte decline by 4.5%, from $22 million in 2011 to
$21millionin2012.
SalesofColourRaysremainstagnantat$17millionin2012,sameas2011levels.
Preference Les Blondissimes, a line targeting blonde consumers, declines further to
$13millionin2012,down13.3%from$15millionin2011.
Smallerlighteninghaircolorlines,Frost&DesignandToneRefiner,remaindormantin
2012at$8millioneach.
A few distinct hair color lines, such as Superior Preference and Wild Ombre, are
launchedin2012.

Sales of Procter & Gamble, the secondleading marketer, decline to $308million in 2012,
down9.7%from$341millionin2011.
Procter % Gambles overall share in the categorys sales fall from 25.8% in 2011 to
23.4%in2012,duetothedeclineinthesalesofClairolNiceNEasyandClairolNatural
Instinctslines.
Limitednewproductactivityalsocontributestothemarketersdeclineinthecategory.
Salesdeclineforthemarketerinthecategorycanalsobeattributedtothesignificant
decreaseinthemarketingactivity.Procter&GamblesTMEforhaircoloringproducts
declines significantly by 32.2% in 2012, down from $82.3 million in 2011 to
$55.7millionin2012.
ClairolNiceNEasyColorBlendFoamistheonlybrandtoexperiencegrowthin2012;
thebrandgrowsby5.7%,from$35millionin2011to$37millionin2012.
Thesuccessoffoambasedcolorantssupportsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
ThesalesofthebrandarealsosupportedbyaTMEofalmost$21millionin2012.
Nice N Easy drops by 8.5% while Natural Instincts declines by 10.7% to $130million
and$67million,respectively,in2012.
Balsam Color manages to maintain its sales at $6million in 2012, for the second
consecutiveyear.
FrostNTipssalesdeclineby14.3%,from$7millionin2011to$6millionin2012.
Themarketerdiscontinuesseveralproductsin2011,contributingtothesalesdeclinein
2012.
Some of the brands that were discontinued by the marketer in 2011 include Loving
Care,ClairolHydrience,ClairolMen'sChoice,ClairolTouchofSun,andClairolUltress.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

HairColoringProducts

Revlonpostsamoderategrowthof3.4%toreach$152millionin2012,from$147millionin
2011.
The leading brand, Revlon Colorsilk, posts a healthy growth of 3.8%. Sales advance
from $130million in 2011 to $135million in 2012. However, further growth of the
marketerisrestrictedbynegligibleTME.
TheExtensionoftheColorsilkrangecontributestothemarketersgrowthin2012.
RevlonintroducestheLuxuriousColorsilkButtercreamlinein2012.Theproductlineis
apermanenthaircolorlinethaterasesgrayhair.Theproductisammoniafreeandis
availablein13shades.

Combe, the leading marketer of mens hair coloring products, posts a growth of 3.4% in
2012.
Manufacturers sales for the company increase to $122million in 2012 from
$118millionin2011.
Themarketerholdsmorethan85.0%marketshareofthemenshaircoloringsegment.
TheintroductionofJustForMenAutostoplinesupportsthegrowthofthemarketerin
2012,withthemarketerallocatingapproximately$22.1millioninTMEforthebrand.
TheJustforMenbrandhassolidbrandequityandiswellpositionedinthemarketplace.
However, Grecian Formula fails to perform well in 2012 showing a 12.5% decline in
salesfrom$8millionin2011to$7millionin2012.
GrecianFormulaisatreatmentforgrayhairwhichrequiresapplicationeverydayfor
the first two weeks. The complexity of everyday application and slow results over a
period of two weeks dissuades consumers from using the product, and they shift to
moreconvenientandfasterresultorientedproducts.

Developlus sales grow significantly by 53.3%, from $15 million in 2011 to $23 million in
2012.
Thecompanyoffersthreesemipermanenthaircolorbrandsinthecategory:Splat(also
inwashablehaircolorsinvividcolorslikepink,purpleandblue),Satin(withaloevera
base), Xora (avocado oil base and magnetically charged color molecules). Another
brand,ColorOops,isahaircolorremover,whichisnotcoveredinthisstudy.
Themarketerhasamarketshareof1.7%inthehaircoloringcategoryin2012,upfrom
1.1%in2011.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Theretaildistributionforhaircoloringproductsremainspracticallyunchangedin2012,in
syncwith2011.
Mass merchandisers and drug stores tie in the first place as the leading retail
distributionchannelsforhaircolor.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D49

4D50

HairColoringProducts

Table4D24:ManufacturersSalesofHairColoringProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

39

39

Drugstores

39

39

Foodstores

18

18

100

100

Specialtystores
Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

In2012,promotionalactivitiesforhaircoloringproductsincludetelevision,electronicand
printmediaadvertisements,couponing,andretailactivities.
Television advertising remains the leading promotional method in the category,
followedbyonlineadvertisements.

Pricebased promotions and media advertisements are also an important means of


promotingsalesofhaircoloringproducts.
Pricebasedpromotionthroughcouponsisanimportantmeansofenticingconsumers
topurchasehaircolors.
Discountcouponsaredistributedthroughmagazinesandfreestandinginserts(FSIs).
Coupons in $1.00 and $2.00 denominations are offered by all the leading marketers
includingLOralandProcter&Gamble.

Dedicatedbrandwebsitesareemergingasanimportantmediumtopromotehaircoloring
products.
Brandwebsitesofhaircoloringproducts,suchasGarnierandClairolfeatureadviceon
haircoloringandhelpthevisitorschoosetherightshadeofhaircolor.

The Internet is also one of the major sources of advertising marketers use for promoting
theirrespectivebrands.
Social media sites, such as Facebook and Twitter, are widely used by marketers for
advertisingtheirproducts.
Many of the new launches and product information is provided by the marketers
throughtheirrespectivepagesonFacebook.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

HairColoringProducts

In 2012, TME for hair coloring products total $296.5million, down 14.6% from
$347.3millionin2011.
Marketersspendabout61.0%ofTMEor$180.3millionontelevisionadvertisementsin
2012,followedbymagazinesat$107.8million.

LOralcontinuestobetheleadingmarketerintermsofadvertisingexpendituresaswellas
category sales, with a TME of $164.1million in 2012, down 11.8% from $186.1million in
2011.
The company spends approximately 64.2% or $105.8million on television
advertisementsin2012.
ATMEof$32.7millionisallocatedtopromoteL'OralExcellenceCrme.
GarnierNutrissesadvertisementexpenditurein2012totals$53.8million.

Procter & Gambles media spend on the hair coloring category in 2012 is $55.7million,
downsignificantlyby32.2%,from$82.3millionin2011.
The company spends approximately 59.6% or $33.2 million on television
advertisementsfollowedbymagazineadvertisementswith$21.7million.
NiceNEasyhairfoamgarnersalionsshareoftheTMEat$20.4million.
TheClairolNaturalInstinctslineissupportedwith$13.0million.

Combe,whichspecializesinmenshaircolor,spends$33.1millionpromotingitsbrandsin
2012,down25.0%from$26.4millionin2011.
The marketer allocates almost 91.5% or $30.3 million of its TME through television
advertisements.
Just For Men Autostop, launched in 2012, garners a lions share of the TME at
$22.1million.

FurtherdetailsonTMEcanbefoundintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

The hair coloring category is expected to experience moderate growth over the forecast
period.
Thecategoryisexpectedtogrowby0.7%duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.

Theagingpopulationwillcontributetothecategorysgrowthinthefuture.
Agingconsumerswillcontinuetoseekcoloringproductsthathavethemainbenefitof
coveringgrayhair.
The aging population or consumers in the 35to65 age group will be the leading
consumer segment for the category and are likely to drive the sales growth of
permanenthaircoloringproducts.
Permanenthaircolorswillcontinuetobetheleadingsegmentinthecategory,asthey
arethemostsuitableproductsforcompletegraycoverage.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D51

4D52

HairColoringProducts

Several leading manufacturers, such as LOral and Procter & Gamble, are expected to
supportthecategorysgrowthwithnewproductintroductions.
New products are expected to have improved formulations and colors, following the
markettrend.

Young consumers who consider hair color as a fashion statement will also continue to
supportthecategorysgrowth.
Brighthuesincoloringproductsappealtoyoungerconsumersandwillcontinuetobe
popularduringtheforecastperiod.

Innovationswithimprovedformulationsinthehaircoloringproductsareexpectedtorevive
thecategorysgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Productswithimprovedformulations,suchasfoambasedandcreambasedhaircolors
willcontinuetogainpopularityovertheforecastperiod.
Marketerslaunchingnewfoambasedproductsarealsoexpectedtoexperiencegrowth
through2017.Thefoamcoloringproductsarelessmessywithaconvenientapplicator
andareavailableinadripfreeformula,andareincreasinglypreferredbyconsumers.
Foambasedproductsthatarefreefromammoniaandchemicalswillbethepreferred
haircoloringproducts.
New marketers are also expected to enter the foambased hair colors segment, with
otherevolvingformulations,therebysupportingthecategorysgrowththrough2017.
Foreaseofapplication,haircoloringproductsarelikelytohaveimprovisedfeaturesin
factors,suchasapplicationmethod,applicationtime,andformulationconsistency.

Ongoingactiveresearchanddevelopmentactivitieswillresultinimprovementsinproduct
quality.
Hair coloring products are expected to incorporate a number of additional benefits,
includingnourishmentofhairandsunprotection.
Antiaging properties are likely to emerge as an important additional benefit of hair
coloringproducts.
Marketersareexpectedtolaunchhaircoloringproductswithaddedbenefits,suchas
nourishing,glossy,andsleeklook.

Consumerswillcontinuetolookforhaircoloringproductsthatcontainnaturalingredients,
suchasherbalandfloralextract.
Naturalhaircoloringproductsthatwillnotcausedamagetothehairarelikelytohave
gooddemandinthefuture.
Negativeimpactofammoniahaircolorsisexpectedtomakeconsumersshifttonatural
products.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

HairColoringProducts

The mens hair coloring segment will continue to show growth over the forecast period,
supportedbynewproductlaunchesandinnovations.
The leading marketer in the segment, Combe will continue to do well through the
forecastperiod.
The category is expected to revive with the launch of new products with innovative
formulations,suchasJustForMenAutostopline,whichisatechnologybreakthrough
involvingthedyeandthehydrogenperoxidebeingalreadymixedinasingletubewith
ascrewedoncomb,tosupportthecategorysgrowth.

Manufacturers sales of the category are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 0.7% to


$1,363millionin2017,upfrom$1,317millionin2012.
However, as the economy recovers, consumers are expected to shift to professional
haircoloringproducts,limitingthecategorysgrowth.

Unit sales are projected to grow at a CAGR of 0.4%, from 225million units in 2012 to
230millionunitsin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D53

4D54

HairColoringProducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesofhairstylingproductsandspraysadvanceto$1,680millionin2012,
up1.3%from$1,658millionin2011.
Saleshavedeclinedatcompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of0.4%from2007.

Table4D25:HistoricalSalesofHairStylingProductsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

2007

1,713

2008

1,695

(1.1)

2009

1,632

(3.7)

2010

1,650

1.1

2011

1,658

0.5

1,680

1.3

2012

rRestated.

Change,%

Unitsales

Unit sales in the category grow 1.0% to 528.7million packages in 2012, up from
523.5millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retail sales of hair styling products total $2,481.1million in 2012, up 1.7% from
$2,440.7millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D56

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Table4D26:ManufacturersSalesofHairStylingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

TRESemm

Unilever

115

GarnierFructis

L'Oral

PanteneProV

%Oftradeclass

2012

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

124

10.2

10.9

6.9

7.4

84

82

7.4

7.2

5.1

4.9

Procter&Gamble

70

61

6.2

5.4

4.2

3.6

Suave

Unilever

60

59

5.3

5.2

3.6

3.5

FrizzEase

Kao

56

58

4.9

5.1

3.4

3.5

HerbalEssences

Procter&Gamble

53

56

4.7

4.9

3.2

3.3

Aussie

Procter&Gamble

56

55

4.9

4.8

3.4

3.3

Got2B

Henkel

51

52

4.5

4.6

3.1

3.1

StudioLine

L'Oral

39

35

3.4

3.1

2.4

2.1

Nexxus

Unilever

32

32

2.8

2.8

1.9

1.9

Axe

Unilever

26

27

2.3

2.4

1.6

1.6

WhiteRain

BrynwoodPartners

12

14

1.1

1.2

0.7

0.8

SalonGrafix

ContinentalFragrances

14

13

1.2

1.1

0.8

0.8

JohnFrieda

KaoUSA

12

12

1.1

1.1

0.7

0.7

Organix

VogueInternational

12

0.6

1.1

0.4

0.7

L.A.Looks

BrynwoodPartners

13

11

1.1

1.0

0.8

0.7

Consort

Unilever

12

11

1.1

1.0

0.7

0.7

Dove

Unilever

11

11

1.0

1.0

0.7

0.7

AquaNet

Lornamead

10

10

0.9

0.9

0.6

0.6

AlbertoVO5

BrynwoodPartners

0.7

0.6

0.5

0.4

Dep

BrynwoodPartners

0.7

0.5

0.5

0.4

FX

VogueInternational

0.6

0.5

0.4

0.4

Brylcreem

Combe

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.3

SheerBlonde

Kao

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.3

Finesse

Lornamead

0.4

0.4

0.3

0.2

Hask

InspiredBeautyBrands

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.2

Condition

HelenofTroy

0.4

0.3

0.2

0.2

Vitalis

HelenofTroy

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

Fekkai

Procter&Gamble

0.2

0.3

0.1

0.2

FinalNet

HelenofTroy

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

SalonStyle

InspiredBeautyBrands

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Protein29

TheStephanCompany

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Allother

Unilever

54

52

4.8

4.6

3.3

3.1

Allother

Henkel

0.7

0.7

0.5

0.5

MASS

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

4D57

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Table4D26:ManufacturersSalesofHairStylingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

%Oftradeclass

2012

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

MASS(Continued)
Allother

SunProducts

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Allother

Kao

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

278

290

24.5

25.5

16.8

17.3

1,133

1,138

100.0

100.0

68.3

67.7

11.4

11.7

3.4

3.5

11.2

11.1

3.4

3.3

Allother

Total
PROFESSIONAL
Redken

L'Oral

57

59

PaulMitchell

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems

56

56

Matrix

L'Oral

49

51

9.8

10.1

3.0

3.0

TIGI

Unilever

49

48

9.8

9.5

3.0

2.9

Aveda

EsteLauder

37

37

7.4

7.4

2.2

2.2

Sebastian

Procter&Gamble

35

34

7.0

6.8

2.1

2.0

Bumbleandbumble

EsteLauder

27

28

5.4

5.6

1.6

1.7

AmericanCrew

Colomer

21

22

4.2

4.4

1.3

1.3

Nioxin

Procter&Gamble

11

13

2.2

2.6

0.7

0.8

Alterna

TSG

1.2

1.4

0.4

0.4

152

148

30.4

29.4

9.2

8.8

500

503

100.0

100.0

30.2

29.9

12

26

85.7

92.9

0.7

1.6

Allother

Total

DIRECT
Wen
Allother

GuthyRenker

Total

14.3

7.1

0.1

0.1

14

28

100.0

100.0

0.8

1.7

83.3

83.3

0.3

0.3

16.7

16.7

0.1

0.1

100.0

100.0

0.4

0.4

100.0

100.0

0.3

0.3

1,658

1,680

100.0

100.0

SPECIALTY
Victoria'sSecret
Allother

LimitedBrands

Total
LUXURY
Allother

TOTAL

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D58

HairStylingProductsandSprays

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Hair styling products with new formulations and new forms continue to support the
categorysgrowthin2012.
Hair styling products with improved product forms, such as gels, sprays, hard/soft
waxes,andpomadesininnovativepackaginghelpinthecategorysgrowth.
Moreover, innovative product forms, such as styling putty and pomades, better
product functions, such as volumizers and thickeners, packaging, and colors support
thecategoryssales.
In 2012, L'Oral launches a line of styling putty products under the Garnier Fructis
brand;thekeyvariantsincludeCleanSleekPowerPutty,SufferHairPowerPutty,and
MessMakerPowerPutty.

Hairstylingproductsthatcontainnaturalandorganicingredientsremainaprominenttrend
in2012,helpinginthecategoryssalesgrow.
Hairstylingproductsaregettingcommonlyformulatedwithnaturalingredients,such
asbotanicalingredients,fruitextracts,andnaturaloils.
Several leading marketers, including L'Oral and Unilever, introduce products with
naturalformulationstosupporttheirsalesinthecategory.
In2012,L'OrallaunchesEverStylerangeofhairstylingproductsthatcontainnatural
ingredientsincludingbotanicalextracts,andtheproductlineisfreefromalcoholand
parabens.
Growing awareness about the benefits of using natural ingredients and support from
marketers in the form of new product activity, makes consumer pick hair styling
products that are free from synthetic chemical ingredients to protect their hair from
furtherdamage.

Multibenefithairstylingproductscontinuetoexperiencesalesgrowthin2012.
Hair styling products that offer multibenefits including protection for colored and
heattreatedhairsupportthecategorysgrowth.
In 2012, Unilever launches TRESemm Platinum Strength Heat Protect Spray that
fortifiesandstrengthenshair.
Productsextendingnourishingpropertiesareindemandfromconsumers.

Sales for the professional segment of hair styling products and sprays grow marginally in
2012.
Salesgrowby0.6%,from$500millionin2011to$503millionin2012.
Consumersareincreasingtheirsalonvisitscomparedtothepreviousyears.
However, consumers still remain watchful about the number of trips made to salons
fortheirhairstylingneeds.Furthermore,consumersseekouthairstylesthatareeasy
tohandleanddoesnotrequirefrequentsalontrips.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Technologicaladvancementsinotherhaircareproductcategories,suchasshampoosand
conditioners,offsetfurthergrowthinthecategory.
Afewshampoosandconditionerproducts,suchasvolumeandshineenhancing,affect
thegrowthofthehairstylingproductscategory.Asaresultofthis,volumeandshine
enhancingproductsinthecategoryareaffected.

TheincreasingagingpopulationintheUnitedStateslimitsthecategorysgrowth.
It is estimated that there are approximately 43 million baby boomers in the United
Statesin2012.
The elderly segment of the population does not consider hair styling products to be
important, as against the younger population. This is partly because younger
consumershaveacomparativelyhigherpropensitytomakestylestatementsandkeep
upwiththefashiontrends.
Thebabyboomerpopulationpreferstouselowpricedhairstylingproducts,ornone,
therebyaffectingthecategoryssalesvolumeandgrowth.

Notablenewproducts

Table4D27:SelectNewHairStylingProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Henkel

Got2B

TheGluedSpikingFreezespraycreateslonglastingstyle

Henkel

Got2B

TheKinkyCurlingMoussecreatescurlswithoutfrizz

Henkel

Got2B

TheGluedExtremeMoussecontainsaweightlessformulato
createmaximumvolumeattheroots

LOral

GarnierFructis

TheSpikeExplosionPowerGelcontainstaurineandcitrus
complex

LOral

GarnierFructis

TheDisorderhairgelcontainsnaturalingredientsincludingcitrus

LOral

GarnierFructis

TheCleanSleekPowerGelandPuttyprovidesultraslick,wet
shinelookforanyhairstylewith24hourhold

LOral

GarnierFructis

TheSufferHairPowerPuttycontainsnaturalingredients
includingcitrusandlemonextracts

LOral

GarnierFructis

TheMessMakerPowerGelandPowerPuttycontainsalight
formula

LOral

LOralParisEverStyle

CurlActivatingMoussecontainsaweightlessformula,natural
ingredients,andisfreefromalcoholandparabens

LOral

LOralParisEverStyle

CurlDefiningGelcontainsnaturalingredientsandisfreefrom
alcoholandparabens

LOral

LOralParisEverStyle

VolumeRootLiftingsprayis100%freefromdryingalcoholsand
containsnaturalingredients

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D59

4D60

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Table4D27:SelectNewHairStylingProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Unilever

Axe

TheGravityDefyingDustgelcontainhumidityresistantformula

Unilever

Axe

ExtremeSpikeUpHoldSpraykeepsthespikesfortheentireday

Unilever

TRESemm

ThePlatinumStrengthHeatProtectSprayfortifiesand
strengthenshair

Unilever

TRESemm

KeratinSmoothHeatProtectionShineSprayhelpsshieldhair
fromthedamagingeffectsofheatstyling

Unilever

TRESemm

KeratinSmoothInfusingSmoothSerumhelpseliminatefrizzand
Illuminatesshine

Unilever

TRESemm

The24HourBodyhairspraycontainsasalonqualityformulathat
resistshumidityandfightsfrizz

Unilever

TRESemm

TheNourishingRitualsRejuvenatingMasquecontainsdeadsea
minerals

VogueInternational Organix

SmoothHydrationArganOil&SheaButterCurlEnhancingYogurt
smoothesandhydratesthickunrulycurlswithitsnongreasy,
hydratingformula

VogueInternational Organix

ThickandFullBiotin,CollagenRootBoostSpraycontains
proVitaminB7biotinwhichaddsextravolumetothehair

VogueInternational Organix

MoroccanSeaSaltSpraycontainsweightlessleaveinsurfmist
withtexturizingseasalt

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Sales of hair sprays and spritzes grow 1.7% to reach $609million in 2012. The segment
accountsfor36.3%ofthecategoryssales,upfrom36.1%in2011.
Hair sprays, with innovative formulations and packaging designs, drive the segments
salesin2012.
UnileversTRESemmbenefitsfromitsnewPlatinumStrengthHeatProtectSpray.
Promotionalsupportintheformofadvertisementsforhairsprayssustainsthegrowth.

Gels experience a modest growth of 0.3% to reach $385million in 2012, up from


$384millionin2011.
Gelscontribute22.9%,downslightlyfrom23.2%ofthecategoryssalesin2011.
Thewidevarietyavailableingelsandmoussescontinuestocontributetotheirgrowth.
LOrallaunchesGarnierFructisSpikeExplosionPowerGelandUnileverlaunchesAxe
GravityDefyingDustgelin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

HairStylingProductsandSprays

SalesforMoussesgrowslightlyby0.7%in2012from$153millionin2011to$154millionin
2012.
Newproductintroductions,suchasKinkyCurlingmousseandExtremeGluedmousse
supportthesegmentsperformancein2012.

Sales of treatments, volumizing products, and shine enhancers gain moderately, as they
haveacceptancefromconsumersoverawiderangeofages,fromthoseintheirearly20sto
thoseintheir50s.

Aswiththeentirecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry,mensproductscontinuetoexperience
growth.
Mens products have a small sales base and its sales are estimated at $57million in
2012.
Salesareup1.8%from$56millionin2011.
Unilever with its Axe brand is the key marketer selling men specific hair styling
productsinthecategory.

Table4D28:ManufacturersSalesofHairStylingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012
$Million
Producttype

2011

2012

2012

Change,%

Spraysandspritzes

599

609

36.1

36.3

1.7

Gels

384

385

23.2

22.9

0.3

Mousses

153

154

9.2

9.2

0.7

Lotions,pomades,andglazes

118

119

7.1

7.1

0.8

Treatments

100

102

6.0

6.1

2.0

Retexturizingproducts

96

98

5.8

5.8

2.1

Shineenhancers

84

86

5.1

5.1

2.4

Hairvolumizersandthickeners

68

70

4.1

4.2

2.9

Mensgroomingproducts

56

57

3.4

3.4

1.8

1,658

1,680

100.0

100.0

1.3

Total

%Oftotal
2011

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D61

4D62

HairStylingProductsandSprays

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4D29:ManufacturersSalesofHairStylingProductsandSpraysintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Unilever

359

364

21.7

21.7

1.4

L'Oral

229

227

13.8

13.5

(0.9)

Procter&Gamble

227

222

13.7

13.2

(2.2)

Kao

75

77

4.5

4.6

2.7

EsteLauder

64

65

3.9

3.9

1.6

Henkel

59

60

3.6

3.6

1.7

JohnPaulMitchellSystems

56

56

3.4

3.3

589

609

35.5

36.3

3.4

1,658

1,680

100.0

100.0

1.3

Allother
Total

Unilevercontinuestobetheleadingmarketerinthehairstylingproductscategoryin2012.
Unilevers share remains at 21.7% of the categorys sales in 2012, unchanged from
2011.
SalesforUnilevergrow1.4%from$359millionin2011to$364millionin2012.
Thegrowthofthemarketerissupportedbynewproductactivityinthecategory.
Unilever launches several new products including, TRESemm Body Hair Spray, Axe
GravityDefyingDustgel,andAxeSpikedUpSpray.
TRESemmistheleadingbrandofthecompany,withsalesat$124millionin2012,up
7.8%from$115millionin2011.Thegrowthofthebrandissupportedbyseveralnew
product introductions by Unilever in 2012. Some of the key launches under the
TRESemmbrandincludePlatinumStrengthDeepConditioningtreatmentandKeratin
SmoothHeatProtectionShineSpray.
The secondleading brand of the marketer, Suaves sales decline by 1.7% in 2012 to
reach $59million from $60million in 2011. The brands biggest strength, economical
pricing,doesnotbenefitSuaveinthecategory.Inthehairstylingcategory,consumers
increasingly purchase products with better performance, keeping pricing as a
secondary factor. Furthermore, negligible traceable media expenditure (TME)
allocationatlessthanamillionandincreasingcompetitionfromotherleadingbrands
offsetsitssalesprospectin2012.
Limitednewproductactivityalsorestrictsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
SalesoftheAxebrandgrow3.8%from$26millionin2011to$27millionin2012.
In 2012, Unilever supports the brands sales with new product launches: Spiked Up
LookSpikingGlueandSpikedUpLookExtremeHoldingSpray.
Sales of Nexxus and Dove remain stagnant at $32million and $11 million in 2012,
respectively.
SalesofConsortdeclineby$1millionin2012to$11million,from$12millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

HairStylingProductsandSprays

LOral is the secondleading marketer in the category with a category share of 13.5%,
downfrom13.8%in2011.
Salesforthemarketerdecline0.9%from$229millionin2011to$227millionin2012.
Decreaseinthemarketingandpromotionalactivitiescontributetothesalesdeclinein
2012.LOraldecreasesitsTMEspendbyapproximately35.7%,from$60.5millionin
2011to$38.9millionin2012.
GarnierFructisistheleadingbrandofthecompany,withsalesat$82millionin2012,
down2.4%from$84millionin2011.
Despiteawiderangeofproductofferingsandwellestablishedpositioning,thebrand
declinesin2012.
Thebrandssalesdeclinein2012duetoadecreaseinmarketingactivities.
LOral is the leading marketer in the professional trade class in the category, with
RedkenastheleadingbrandfollowedbyMatrixinthirdposition.
Themarketeroccupies21.8%oftheprofessionaltradeclass,upfrom21.2%in2011.

Procter&Gamblecontinuestobeinthethirdpositioninthehairstylingproductscategory.
Salesofthemarketerdecrease2.2%to$222millionin2012from$227millionin2011.
Limited new product activity and a decrease in the marketing and promotional
activitiescontributetothesalesdeclineforthemarketerinthecategory.
Procter&GambledecreasesitsTMEsignificantlyby50.0%,from$55.4millionin2011
to$27.7millionin2012.
Pantene ProV, the largest brand of the marketer in the category, remains the third
leadingbrandinthemasstradeclass.Salesofthebranddeclineto$61millionin2012,
down 12.9% from $70million in 2011. Limited new product activity and substantial
decrease in promotional activities offset the brands growth in 2012. The marketer
significantly decreases its TME support for the Pantene ProV brand in 2012 from
$34.6millionin2011to$10.1millionin2012.
SalesofHerbalEssencesgrowby5.7%to$56millionin2012,upfrom$53millionin
2011. Increasing promotional and marketing activity supports the brands growth in
2012.Procter&Gamblesupportsthebrandwithapproximately$6.8millioninTMEin
2012,upfrom$0.5millionin2011.
SalesofProcter&GamblesAussiedeclineby$1millionto$55millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble is present in the professional trade class with its Sebastian and
Nioxinbrands.In2012,themarketeroccupies9.4%oftheprofessionaltradeclass,up
from9.2%in2011.Sebastianisthesixthleadingbrandintheprofessionaltradeclass
with sales at $34million, down 2.9% from $35million in 2011. Procter & Gambles
other professional brand, Nioxin experiences growth in 2012. The brand grows by
18.2%from$11millionin2011to$13millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D63

4D64

HairStylingProductsandSprays

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In 2012, mass merchandisers continue to be the leading retail channel for hair styling
products.
Massmerchandisersaccountfor36.0%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,unchanged
from2011.
Astheeconomycontinuestorecover,consumersseekvaluefortheirmoneyandseek
outletsofferingthebestprices.
Professional outlets continue to be the secondleading retail channel for hair styling
productswithacategoryshareof22.0%,unchangedfrom2011.

Table4D30:ManufacturersSalesofHairStylingProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

36

37

Professionaloutlets

22

22

Drugstores

19

19

Foodstores

19

18

Specialtystores

Direct

Departmentstores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Televisionadvertisements,electronicandprintmediaadvertisements,couponing,andretail
activities are the prominent channels that marketers utilize to advertise their hair styling
products.
Print advertising, mainly magazines, remains the leading promotional method in the
category,followedbytelevisionadvertisements.
Marketersdeployprintadvertisementsastheycandisplaythewholearrayofproducts
offeredineachproductline.
Printadvertisementsalsofeaturevarioushairstylesachievedbyusingtheproducts.
Television advertising focuses on products targeted at younger consumers, and
marketerstrytoattractconsumerswithappealingaudiovisualelements.
Printadvertisingcontinuestobethemostutilizedchannelaccountingfor$80.7million
inTMEin2012,followedbytelevisionadvertisingwith$66.3million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Couponsremainanimportantpromotionalmediumformarketersinthecategory.
Couponsaredistributedthroughfreestandinginserts(FSIs)inmagazinesandweekend
newspapers.
Marketers often attempt to entice consumers to try new products with coupons.
Couponsrangefrom$1.00toashighas$3.00,dependingonthepriceoftheproduct.
Marketers,suchasUnileverandProcter&Gambleoffercouponsworth$1.00ontheir
websitesfortheirhairstylingproducts.
In addition to FSIs, the leading marketers also promote their brands through
downloadablecouponsontheirwebsites.

Most major marketers including Unilever and L'Oral utilize social media and videos to
promotetheirscents.
To reach younger and more technologically savvy consumers, brands are using the
Internetandsocialmedia.
Themarketersusesocialmediasites,suchasFacebookandTwittertoshareupdated
informationonproducts,launches,andcoupons.

Several leading marketers provide hair styling tips and other product benefits on their
websites.
Unilever, through its TRESemm brand website provides hair styling tips and hair
stylingnewstoengageconsumerswiththelateststylingtrends.
L'Oral,throughitsGarnierwebsite,suggestssuitablehairstylesforaconsumerbased
ontheirhairtype.

Marketers in the hair styling category promote products based on two factors: target
consumergroupsandthevarietyofproductsoffered.
Hair spraysare the most predominantly advertised hair styling product in magazines,
suchasGlamour,Allure,andCosmopolitan.
Television advertisements are the most preferred for styling products that target
youngerconsumers.
Hairspraysareadvertisedasapartoftheirhaircarelinesthatfeatureshampoosand
conditioners.
Due to the variety in styling products available, promotions are through exclusive
campaignspromotingtherangeofstylingproductsunderabrand.

Hair styling products receive a TME of $164.9 million in 2012, down 30.3% from
$236.6millionin2011.
Print advertising remains the most favored mode of advertising hair styling products,
accountingfor48.9%or$80.7millionofTMEin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D65

4D66

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Unilever is the leading advertiser with a TME of $39.2 million in 2012, down from
$55.7millionin2011.
DoveStyleCarerangeisthehighestadvertisedhairstylingvariantfromUnilever,with
aTMEsupportofover$17.6millionin2012.
Dove gets a TME support of $22.5 million or 57.3% of the marketers advertising
expenditurein2012.
Axe receives only $5.4 million or 13.7% of the marketers advertising expenditure in
2012.

In 2012, LOral is the second largest advertiser in the category, with a TME of almost
$38.9million,downfrom$60.5millionin2011.
TheTMEisspreadmainlybetweentelevisionandmagazinesadvertisements.
Television and magazine advertising collectively account for more than 92% or
$35.8millionofTMEin2012.
LOral Paris EverStyle variant receives the singlelargest TME support at almost
$11.4millionin2012.
GarnierFructisStyleSleekFinish,astylingsprayvariant,garnersalmost$10.2millionin
TMEin2012,spreadacrossmagazinesandtheInternet.

Procter&GambleisthethirdleadingadvertiserinthecategorywithaTMEof$27.7million
in2012,downfrom$55.4millionin2011.
The marketer drops its TME significantly by 50.0%, from $55.4 million in 2011 to
$27.7millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble allocates $13.7 million or 49.4% of its TME through television
advertisements followed by $11.7 million or 42.2% of its TME through magazine
advertisements.
PanteneProVlinereceivesatotalTMEsupportofapproximately$10.1millionin2012,
spreadprimarilyacrosstelevisionandmagazineadvertising.TheTMEsupportforthe
branddecreasesby70.8%in2012from$34.6millionin2011.

FurtherdetailsonTMEcanbefoundintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport,aswellasin
thedatabase.

OUTLOOK

The category is forecast to grow at a moderate rate of 1.4% during the forecast period,
2012to2017.

Hair styling products with better formulations and innovative packaging will perform well
throughtheforecastperiod.
Manufacturersofhairstylingproductswillcontinuetoincorporatenewformulations
totheirexistingproductsaswellasnewproductstosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Severalleadingmanufacturers,suchasUnileverandL'Oral,areexpectedtoupgrade
theirproductpackagingwithnewdesignstoattracttheirtargetaudiences.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

HairStylingProductsandSprays

Manufacturers will continue to introduce hair styling products with multibenefits to


supportthecategorysgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Hairstylingproductsthatoffermultibenefitsforcoloredandtreatedhairarelikelyto
dowellduringtheforecastperiod.
Hairstylingproductsthatwillprotecthairscalphealthareexpectedtoperformbetter.
As consumers increasingly want to protect their hair from the harmful UV rays,
manufacturersareexpectedtolaunchsuncarehairstylingproductsovertheforecast
period.

Marketers are expected to introduce products targeted at men, as the mens segment is
expectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Henkel introduce menspecific hair
productsin2012andareexpectedtocontinueintroducingmoremalecentricproducts
duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Marketers are expected to develop products that cater to mens needs including
masculineformats,fragrances,andpackaging.

Manufacturerswillcontinuetoincorporatenaturalingredientsintheirproductstosupport
thecategorysgrowththrough2017.
With increasing awareness about the harmful chemicals contained in hair styling
products, consumers have become mindful of the products they use and would
increasinglyoptfornaturalandorganicproductsoverregularhairstylingproducts.

The sales of professional hair styling products are expected to grow moderately over the
forecastperiod.
As the economy recovers, consumers are likely to take home more products from
salons,supportingthecategorysgrowthintheprofessionalchannel.
Higher price points of professional brands as compared with mass brands would add
moresalesvaluetothecategory.

Sales of hair styling products are projected to increase at a CAGR of 1.4% to reach
$1,802millionin2017,upfrom$1,680millionin2012.

Unit volume of the category is forecast to increase at a CAGR of 1.0% over the forecast
periodtoreach555.2millionpackagesin2017,upfrom528.7millionpackagesin2012.\

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D67

4D68

HairStylingProductsandSprays

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

SHAMPOOS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturers sales in the category grow 4.8% from $2,501million in 2011 to


$2,620millionin2012.
Saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.5%from2007.

Table4D31:HistoricalSalesofShampoosintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

2,311

2008

2,307

(0.2)

2009

2,276

(1.3)

2010

2,361

3.7

2011

2,501

5.9

2,620

4.8

2012

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit sales in the category grow 3.8% from 714million packages in 2011 to 741million
packagesin2012.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofshampoostoconsumersareestimatedat$3,843.6millionin2012,up4.9%,
from$3,665.2millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D70

Shampoos

Table4D32:ManufacturersSalesofShampoosintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

MASS
Head&Shoulders

Procter&Gamble

244

266

12.1

12.8

9.8

10.2

PanteneProVr

Procter&Gamble

259

255

12.8

12.3

10.4

9.7

Suave

Unilever

186

193

9.2

9.3

7.4

7.4

GarnierFructisr

L'Oral

136

134

6.7

6.5

5.4

5.1

HerbalEssencesr

Procter&Gamble

130

132

6.4

6.4

5.2

5.0

TRESemmr

Unilever

120

117

5.9

5.6

4.8

4.5

Dove

Unilever

76

72

3.8

3.5

3.0

2.7

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

53

54

2.6

2.6

2.1

2.1

PertPlusr

HelenofTroy

55

50

2.7

2.4

2.2

1.9

Aussie

Procter&Gamble

46

48

2.3

2.3

1.8

1.8

AlbertoVO5r

BrynwoodPartners

44

45

2.2

2.2

1.8

1.7

Organixr

VogueInternational

29

45

1.4

2.2

1.2

1.7

Nexxus

Unilever

40

41

2.0

2.0

1.6

1.6

Axer

Unilever

44

40

2.2

1.9

1.8

1.5

SelsunBlue

Sanofi

36

36

1.8

1.7

1.4

1.4

Johnson'sBaby/Kids

Johnson&Johnson

37

35

1.8

1.7

1.5

1.3

SuaveforMen

Unilever

34

33

1.7

1.6

1.4

1.3

Clear

Unilever

30

1.4

1.1

EverPurer

L'Oral

18

19

0.9

0.9

0.7

0.7

Aveenor

Johnson&Johnson

17

19

0.8

0.9

0.7

0.7

SheerBlonder

Kao

17

17

0.8

0.8

0.7

0.6

Gillette

Procter&Gamble

16

17

0.8

0.8

0.6

0.6

Finesser

Lornamead

17

16

0.8

0.8

0.7

0.6

BrilliantBrunette

Kao

14

14

0.7

0.7

0.6

0.5

VivePror

L'Oral

16

13

0.8

0.6

0.6

0.5

Infusium23

HelenofTroy

14

12

0.7

0.6

0.6

0.5

Fekkai

Procter&Gamble

10

12

0.5

0.6

0.4

0.5

EverSleek

L'Oral

10

10

0.5

0.5

0.4

0.4

WhiteRain

BrynwoodPartners

11

0.5

0.4

0.4

0.3

EverStrongr

L'Oral

0.4

0.4

0.4

0.3

Prell

PrestigeBrands

0.3

0.4

0.3

0.3

SelsunBlueNaturals

Sanofi

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

EverCreme

L'Oral

0.3

0.3

RootAwakening

Kao

0.4

0.3

0.4

0.2

L'OralKidsr

L'Oral

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

NizoralADr

Johnson&Johnson

0.3

0.2

0.2

0.2

Burt'sBeesr

TheCloroxCompany

0.1

0.2

0.1

0.2

Denorexr

PrestigeBrands

0.2

0.2

0.2

0.2

RadiantRed

Kao

0.2

0.1

0.2

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

4D71

Shampoos

Table4D32:ManufacturersSalesofShampoosintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

MASS(Continued)
Jhirmack

InspiredBeautyBrands

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Ultraswim

Sanofi

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Freeman

FreemanBeauty

Got2B

Henkel

Sunsilk

Unilever

0.1

0.1

Allother

Henkel

90

82

4.5

3.9

3.6

3.1

Privatelabel

Allother
Total

134

147

6.6

7.1

5.4

5.6

2,108

2,077

100.0

100.0

80.7

79.3

PROFESSIONAL
PaulMitchell

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems

57

57

15.7

15.4

2.3

2.2

Matrix

L'Oral

46

47

12.7

12.7

1.8

1.8

Aveda

EsteLauder

33

34

9.1

9.2

1.3

1.3

Redken

L'Oral

29

30

8.0

8.1

1.2

1.1

Nioxin

NioxinResearch
Laboratories

27

29

7.4

7.9

1.1

1.1

TIGI

Unilever

20

20

5.5

5.4

0.8

0.8

Bumbleandbumble

EsteLauder

17

18

4.7

4.9

0.7

0.7

Pureology

L'Oral

14

13

3.9

3.5

0.6

0.5

Joico

Shiseido

2.5

2.4

0.4

0.3

Alterna

TSG

1.9

2.2

0.3

0.3

Sebastian

Procter&Gamble

1.9

1.6

0.3

0.2

Zotos

Shiseido

1.7

1.6

0.2

0.2

Allother

Total

91

92

25.1

24.9

3.6

3.5

363

369

100.0

100.0

14.5

14.1

DIRECT
Wen

GuthyRenker

60

112

74.1

84.8

2.4

4.3

Avon

Avon

17

15

21.0

11.4

0.7

0.6

4.9

3.8

0.2

0.2

81

132

100.0

100.0

3.2

5.0

Allother

Total
SPECIALITY
Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

12

13

50.0

48.1

0.5

0.5

Victoria'sSecret

LimitedBrands

29.2

25.9

0.3

0.3

Crabtree&Evelyn

Crabtree&Evelyn

4.2

3.7

16.7

22.2

0.2

0.2

24

27

100.0

100

1.0

1.0

Allother

Total
LUXURY
Origins

EsteLauder

26.7

26.7

0.2

0.2

11

11

73.3

73.3

0.4

0.4

100.0

0.6

0.6

100.0

100.0

Allother
Total

15

15

TOTAL

2,501

2,620

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D72

Shampoos

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Salesofshampoosgrow4.8%in2012.
Several leading marketers including L'Oral and Unilever launch new range of
shampoos,supportingthecategorysgrowth.
Antidandruffshampooscontinuetoseegoodgrowthin2012.
Brands, such as Head & Shoulders (Procter & Gamble) grows 9.0% and jumps to the
leading spot in the category; the growth of the brand is significantly higher than the
categorysgrowthof4.8%.

Shampoosthatpromotescalphealthgarnerattentionin2012.
Marketers that introduce scalp care products perform well in 2012, supporting the
overallcategorysgrowth.
For example, Unilever benefits from the introduction of its scalp therapy range of
shampoosunderitsClearbrandin2012.
The range includes Scalp Therapy Lengths Nourishing shampoo, Complete Care Anti
dandruffshampoo,andUltraSheaCleansingshampoo.
TheClearbrandhassalesof$30millioninitsfirstyearoflaunch.

Shampoosthatoffermultiplebenefitssupportthecategorysgrowth.
Consumers are looking for functional benefits in their shampoos beyond the basic
cleansingandnourishingproperties.
Marketers incorporating more functional benefits, such as frizz protection and anti
agingperformwellinthecategoryin2012.
Unilever launches Nexxus Frizz Defy Frizz Protection shampoo in 2012 that contains
frizzdefyingtechnologyandMorroccanarganoil.
In2012,Procter&GamblelaunchesPanteneAgeDefyshampoothatworkstogetherto
helphairactupto10yearsyoungerbythickeningexistinghairstrands.

Shampoos that provide protection for colored hair and colorenhancement for hair
contributetothecategorysgrowth.
Thegrowingnumberofconsumerswhocolortheirhairsupportsthegrowthofcolor
protectionshampoos.
SeveralleadingmarketersincludingKaoandL'Orallaunchcolorprotectionandcolor
enhancementshampoossupportingthecategorysgrowth.
KaolaunchesitsColorCarerangeofshampoosunderitsGoldwellbrandin2012.

Shampoosthatcatertotheneedsofvarioushairconcerns,suchasthinning,volumeboost,
andhairtypescontinuetoperformwellin2012.
In 2012, Pantene ProV (Procter & Gamble) introduces the Pantene ProV Daily
MoistureRenewal,whichissuitableforbothmediumandthickhairtypes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

Shampoos

Marketers continue to incorporate natural ingredients in their hair care products as


consumersseekproductsthatarefreefromchemicalingredients,suchassulfate.
Several leading marketers, such asVogue International and Procter & Gamble launch
products with natural ingredients or enhance their existing products with natural
ingredientstosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Naturallypositioned brands, such as Organix perform well in 2012, with sales
increasingat55.2%from$29millionin2011to$45millionin2012.
VogueInternationalandTheCloroxCompanylaunchtheirrangeofnaturalshampoos,
which contain natural ingredients claimed to be beneficial for consumers with hair
problemsincludingthinninghair.VogueInternationallaunchestheKeratinOilrangeof
shampoos.

Increasing new product activity in the category contributes to the sales growth in the
categoryin2012.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and Procter & Gamble launch their new
rangeofshampoosin2012.
UnileverintroducesitsnewClearrangeofshampoosinearly2012.Therangeincludes
scalptherapyandtotalcareshampoos.
Procter & Gamble extends its Head & Shoulders line of antidandruff shampoos with
newvariantsincludingClinicalStrengthantidandruffshampoo.

Significantmarketingsupportandpromotionalactivitiesalsosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and L'Oral support their brands with
hugetraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)inordertogrowtheirmarketsharesinthe
category.
In 2012, TME for shampoos total $446.3million, up significantly by 27.0% from
$351.3millionin2011.

Menspecific hair care products continue to gain importance in 2012, supported by new
productlaunches.
Several leading marketers including Unilever and L'Oral launch products targeted at
menin2012.
UnileverlaunchesClearMenrangeofshampoosin2012.
Unilever also extends its Suave for Men range with new variants, such as Suave for
Men Deep Cleansing shampoo. L'Oral extends its Redken for Men range with new
variants.

Theprofessionalshampooscategoryexperiencesmoderategrowthof2.1%in2012.
Astheeconomyrecovers,consumersareslowlyincreasingtheirsalonvisits.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D73

4D74

Shampoos

Thesalesofshampoosinthedirecttradechannelpostsignificantgrowthof63.0%in2012,
supportedbythestrongperformanceofthebrand.
Salesgrowfrom$81millionin2011to$132millionin2012.
Wenpostssignificantgrowthof86.7%inthecategory,upfrom$60millionin2011to
$112millionin2012.
Wen is positioned as a fiveinone product, replacing shampoos, daily conditioner,
detangler, deep conditioner, and leavein conditioner supporting its growth in the
category.

Notablenewproducts

Table4D33:SelectNewShampoosIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Aesop

BlackLabel

Calmingshampoocontainsblendedbotanicaloils,vegetable,andsynthetic
proteins

EsteLauder

Bumble&Bumble

ColorMindedshampooisinfusedwithdualpolymertechnologythatis
designedtomakehairimpermeabletowater,reducingbothcolorwashout
andfading

HainCelestialGroup

QueenHelene

SoftTwirlsshampoocontains17aminoacids,plusvitaminsA,B,C,DandK,
thepresenceofwhichdeliverssmoothinghydrationtocurls

JohnPaulMitchell
Systems

PaulMitchell

SpringLoadedDetanglingshampoodetangles,cleanses,andconditionsallat
once

Johnson&Johnson

Aveeno

PureRenewalshampoorefresheshairwithoutwaterforacleanandhealthy
lookbetweenwashes

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

CleanReplenishingshampoogentlycleanseshairanditsmoistureenriched
formulaprovidesalldaymoisturization

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

TripleMoistureCreamLathershampoocontainsthreenaturallyderived
extractsthatpenetratetofightdrynessonallthreedimensionsofthehair
strand,asidefromcombatingfrizz

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

TripleRenewalVolumeBoostingshampooisinfusedwithaminoacids,
vitamins,andnaturallyderivedproteins

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

AntiResidueshampooisatreatmentthatinstantlycleanseshair,rendering
thestrandscleanandresiduefree

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

Cleanvolumeshampoogentlycleansesandaddsbodytoflatandlifeless
hair

Kao

Goldwell

FadeStopshampoo,withitsuniqueFadeStopformulawithpomegranate
essencepreventsminimalcolorfading

LOral

LOralParis

TotalRepair5Restoringshampoohelpsrepairfivevisiblesignsofdamaged
hairsplitends,weakness,roughness,dullness,anddehydration

LOral

LOralParis

TripleResistReinforcingshampooinstantlyhelpsnourishhairfromrootto
coretotip,therebystrengtheninghair

LOral

LOralParis

SmoothIntensePolishingshampoosoftenshairandcombatssymptomsof
roughtextures,leavinghairsmooth

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

Shampoos

Table4D33:SelectNewShampoosIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

LOral

GarnierFructis

GarnierFructisPureCleanshampoobooststhehealthofhairandscalp,and
containsabiodegradableformulafromFructis

LOral

Matrix

BlondeCareshampoocontainsablendofchamomileandpanthenol

LOral

EverCreme

TheIntenseNourishingshampoocontainsnaturalbotanicalsandisfree
fromsulfatesandparabens

M&MCosmetics

Sofnfree

NothingButClarifyingShampoocontainsvariouscombinationsofoilsfrom
sheabutter,coconut,jojoba,soyabean,wheatgerm,teatreeoil,vitaminE,
keratin,andnaturallyderivedfragrances

NaturesGate

NaturesGate

BabySoothingshampoo&washcleansesfinehairandsoothesdelicateskin
withmildherbs,infusedwithbabybotanicalsincludingjojobaoil,sweet
almond,andvegetableglycerin

Procter&Gamble

HerbalEssences

TheHoneyImStrongshampooisinfusedwithhoney

Procter&Gamble

Head&Shoulders

TheClinicalStrengthAntidandruffshampoohelpspreventitching,scaling,
irritation,andrednessassociatedwithseborrheicdermatitisanddandruff

Procter&Gamble

Head&Shoulders

DamageRescueDandruffshampoonourishesdamagedhairandhelps
relievedryscalp

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

PanteneAdvancedandKeratinRepairshampoofeaturesadvanced
technologytohelprestoresmoothnessofextremelydamagedhair,while
preventingfurtherdamageatthekeratinlevel

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

TheDailyMoistureRenewalshampoocleansandprovidesanallday
moisturizationtothehair

Procter&Gamble

PanteneProV

PanteneAgeDefyshampooisclaimedtohelphairactupto10years
youngerbythickeningexistinghairstrands

TheCloroxCompany

BurtsBees

BabyBeeshampoocontainsnaturalplantbasedcleansingcomplexin
combinationwithsweetorangeandlemonoilstocreateanourishing
formulathatleavesbabyhairandskinsilkysoft

TheQuantumBeauty
Company

LeeStafford

BleachBlondeshampoocontainsproblondecomplexthathelpskeephair
clean,andkeepsblondehairbright,fresh,andhealthy

Unilever

Axe

Apollo2in1shampooandconditionerhasfruitscentthatthecompany
claimsisuniqueandmasculine

Unilever

Dove

TheDamageSolutionsColorCareshampoocleansandconditionscolor
treatedhair

Unilever

Clear

ScalpTherapyStrongLengthsNourishingshampoocontainsstrengthening
serumandisformulatedwithNutrium10,amoisturecomplexofvitamins
andnutrients

Unilever

Clear

ScalpandHairTherapyCompleteCareAntiDandruffshampoonourishes
deeplyandhelpseliminatedandruffsymptoms,leavingthescalphealthy

Unilever

Clear

ScalpandHairTherapyUltraSheaCleanseandNourishShampooisenriched
withsheabutterandnaturaloilsthathelpslockmoistureintodryscalpsand
leaveshairstrongandbeautiful

Unilever

Clear

ScalpandHairTherapyTotalCareNourishingShampoocontains10
nutrientsandvitaminsthatnourishesscalpforstrong,beautifulhair

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D75

4D76

Shampoos

Table4D33:SelectNewShampoosIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Unilever

Clear

ScalpandHairTherapyDamage&ColorRepairNourishingShampoois
speciallyformulatedtonourishthescalpdeeply,creatingtheright
foundationforstrong,beautifulhair

Unilever

Clear

ScalpandHairTherapyFrizzControlNourishingShampooprovidefrizz
controlandnourishesthehair

Unilever

ClearMen

ScalpTherapy2in1AntiDandruffShampoocontainsGinseng,mint,andtea
tree

Unilever

ClearMen

ScalpTherapyDailyStrongandFullAntiDandruffShampoocontainsBio
Nutrium10,ablendof10nutrientsandbotanicalactivestonourishdeeply

Unilever

ClearMen

ScalpTherapyClean&RefreshAntiDandruffDailyShampoohelpseliminate
dandruffsymptomsatthesourcewithpyrithionezinc

Unilever

ClearMen

ScalpTherapyCoolSportMintAntiDandruffDailyShampoocontainsnatural
mintandCleansesscalpandhair,leavinganextracoolingsensation

Unilever

ClearMen

ScalpTherapy2In1DryScalpHydrationAntiDandruffShampoogently
cleansesandconditionstoleavehairmanageablewithadeepclean
sensation

Unilever

Suave

DailyclarifyingshampooisapHbalancedshampoo,thathasnewformula
forlongerlastingfragranceandissuitableforbothnormalaswellasoily
hair

Unilever

TRESemm

TheSplitRemedyshampoocontainsamoisturizingformulathatgently
cleansesandstrengthenshair

VogueInternational

Organix

MoroccanArganOilshampooisfreeofsulfatesandparabens,penetrates
hairshaftrestoringshineandsoftnesswhilestrengthening

VogueInternational

Organix

KeratinOilshampoofightssplitendsandflyaways,whilestrengtheninghair
andrestoringitsbeauty

VogueInternational

Organix

CitrusMintshampoothickensandtexturizeshairwhilestimulatingscalp

M&Aactivity

In 2012, Brynwood Partners acquires the brand White Rain from Sun Products for an
undisclosedprice.
White Rainis sold in the topthreecategories in the hair care product class including
shampoos,conditioners,andhairstylingproducts.
ThisdealisexpectedtostrengthenthepositionofBrynwoodPartnersinthehaircare
productclass.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A76

Shampoos

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbytradeclass

Thecategoryisdominatedbymassproducts,whichaccountfor79.3%oftheoverallsalesin
2012.
Specialtyandluxuryarethesmallesttradeclasses,accountingfor1.0%and0.6%ofthe
categoryssales,respectively,in2012.
Sales in the direct trade class grow significantly by 63.0% in 2012, mainly driven by
GuthyRenkersbrandWen,salesofwhichgrow86.7%in2012.

Table4D34:ManufacturersSalesofShampoosintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2011and2012

Tradeclass
Massmerchandisers
Professionaloutlets
Directsales
Specialtystores
Luxurystores
Total

$Million
2011
2012
2,018
2,077
363
369
81
132
24
27
15
15
2,501
2,620

%Oftotal
2011
2012
80.7
79.3
14.5
14.1
3.2
5.0
1.0
1.0
0.6
0.6
100.0
100.0

Change,%
2.9
1.7
63.0
12.5

4.8

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4D35:ManufacturersSalesofShampoosintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

Company
Procter&Gamble
Unilever
LOral
Johnson&Johnson
GuthyRenker
HelenofTroy
JohnPaulMitchellSystems
EsteLauder
BrynwoodPartners
Sanofi
VogueInternational
Privatelabel
Allother
Total

$Million
2011
2012
712
736
523
546
284
287
113
113
60
112
69
62
57
57
54
56
55
53
45
45
29
45
90
82
410
426
2,501
2,620

%Oftotal
2011
2012
28.5
28.1
20.9
20.8
11.4
11.0
4.5
4.3
2.4
4.3
2.8
2.4
2.3
2.2
2.2
2.1
2.2
2.0
1.8
1.7
1.2
1.7
3.6
3.1
16.4
16.3
100.0
100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Change,%
3.4
4.4
1.1

86.7
(10.1)

3.7
(3.6)

55.2
(8.9)
3.9
4.8

4D77

4D78

Shampoos

Procter&Gamblecontinuestobetheleadingmarketerintheshampooscategoryin2012.
Salesofthemarketergrow3.4%in2012from$712millionin2011to$736millionin
2012.
Procter&Gamblehasa28.1%marketshareoftheoverallcategoryssalesin2012.
The company markets seven brands in the category, including the top two brands
PanteneProVandHead&Shoulders.
Head&Shouldersbecomesthecategoryleaderin2012,displacingPanteneProV.
Head&Shoulderssalesgrow9.0%,from$244millionin2011to$266millionin2012.
Thebrandsgrowthisdrivenbyimprovedmarketingandpromotionalactivitiesinthe
category.
Procter & Gamble launches various campaigns to support the sales of its Head &
Shouldersbrandinthecategory.Themarketersigns soccerplayerLionelMessiasits
spokespersontopromoteitsHead&Shouldersbrand.
Consumers seek products which provide further functional benefits as compared to
regularshampoos,contributingtoHead&Shouldersgrowth.
PanteneProV,thesecondleadingbrandinthecategory,hasacategoryshareof9.7%
in2012,downfrom10.4%in2011.
Sales for the brand decline by $4million to $255million in 2012, down from
$259millionin2011.
Pantene ProV has limited new product activity in 2012 compared to 2011, when
Procter&GambleaddedanumberofproductstothePanteneProVline.

Head&ShouldersfromProcter&Gambleholdsthefirstpositionwith10.2%shareinthe
category.
Head&Shouldersdominatestheantidandruffsegmentofshampoos.
Consumers seek products which provide further functional benefits as compared to
regularshampoos,contributingtoHead&Shouldersgrowth.
Head&ShouldersaddsaClinicalStrengthantidandruffshampootoitslinein2012.

In2012,thesalesofHerbalEssencesfromProcter&Gamblegrowmarginallyby1.5%,from
$130millionin2011to$132millionin2012.
HerbalEssencesisthefifthlargestbrandintheentireshampooscategory.
Newproductlaunchesandthesuccessofnaturalproductssupportthebrandsgrowth
in2012.
The marketer introduces Herbal Essences Honey Im Strong line of strengthening
shampoosin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A78

Shampoos

SalesforProcter&Gamblesothermassbrandsshowadecentperformancein2012.
Aussieexperienceshealthygrowth,withsalesincreasing4.3%from$46millionin2011
to $48million in 2012. Strong promotional activities and new product formulations
contributetothebrandsoverallperformance.Thesuccessofnaturalproductssupport
thebrandsgrowth,asAussiesproductscontainAustralianWildPeachandAustralian
KangarooPawFlowerextracts.
Gillettesshampoosalesgrow6.3%in2012from$16millionin2011to$17millionin
2012.Bettermarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributestothebrandsgrowth.The
marketer allocates approximately $5.1 million to promote the brand in 2012, up
significantlyfrom$0.5millionin2011.

Procter&Gamblemarketsoneprofessionalbrandinthecategory,Sebastian.
SalesofSebastiandecline14.3%from$7millionin2011to$6millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble is struggling to make Sebastian products appealing to its target
youngerconsumersegment

Unilever, the secondleading marketer in the category, has a 20.8% category share. The
salesofthecompanygrow4.4%,from$523millionin2011to$546millionin2012.
SuavecontinuestobetheleadingbrandofUnilever;andisthethirdlargestbrandin
thecategory.Salesofthebrandareup3.8%,from$186millionin2011to$193million
in2012.NewproductactivityandincreasedmarketingcontributetotheSuavebrands
performanceinthecategory.UnileverlaunchesSuaveProfessionalMoroccanInfusion
range of shampoos to support its growth in the category. However, sales for Suaves
mensvariant,SuaveforMen,declinemoderatelyby2.9%from$34millionin2011to
$33millionin2012.
ThesecondlargestbrandfromUnileverisTRESemm.Thebrandssalesdecline2.5%
from $120million in 2011 to $117million in 2012. Limited promotional activities
contributetothebrandssalesdeclineinthecategory.
Dove,thethirdlargestbrandfromUnilever,declines5.3%from$76millionin2011to
$72millionin2012.Limitednewproductactivitycontributestothebrandsdeclinein
2012.TheonlysignificantproductlaunchfromDovein2012isDamageSolutionsColor
CareShampoo.
Unileverlaunchesanewbrand,Clearinthecategoryin2012.Thebrandexperiences
sales of $30 million in its first year of launch. Significant marketing and promotional
activity supports the brands performance in the category. The marketer allocates
approximately$58.5milliontopromoteitsClearbrandin2012.
UnileverdiscontinuesitsSunsilkbrandin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D79

4D80

Shampoos

LOralisthethirdlargestmarketerinthecategorywitha11.0%share;thecompanyssales
grow1.1%from$284millionin2011to$287millionin2012.
Thecompanyoffers10brandsinthecategory.
Garnier Fructis is the leading brand from LOral, and sales decline 1.4%, from
$136millionin2011to$134millionin2012.Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthe
brandsgrowthinthecategory.
ThesalesofEverPuregrow3.3%,from$18millionin2011to$19millionin2012.The
successofsulfatefreeshampoossupportthebrandssalesinthecategory.
ViveProfromLOralcontinuestodeclinein2012;salesforthebranddecline18.8%,
from $16million in 2011 to $13million in 2012. Limited distribution and lack of new
productactivityaffectsthebrandsperformance.
LOralsuccessfullylaunchesEverCremein2012,acleansingconditionerorrather
a conditioning shampoo that doesnt foam to compete with Wen brand. Sales are
approximately$7millioninitsfirstyear.
LOral markets two professional hair care brands: Matrix and Redken. Matrix
witnessesa2.2%growthin2012,withthebrandssalesincreasingfrom$46millionin
2011 to $47million in 2012. The brands growth is supported by new product
introductionin2012.LOrallaunchesanewBlondeCareshampooundertheMatrix
brand in 2012. Redken grows 3.4% from $29million in 2011 to $30million in 2012.
RedkenlaunchesAllSoftandBlondeGlamshampoosin2012.

Johnson&Johnson,thefourthrankedmarketer,hasa4.3%shareinthecategoryssales.
Salesforthecompanyareflatat$113millionin2012,sameas2011levels.
Thecompanyoffersfourbrandsinthecategory.
Neutrogena,theleadingbrandfromJohnson&Johnson,grows1.9%from$53million
in2011to$54millionin2012.
Significant product launches under Neutrogena in 2012 are Clean Replenishing
shampooandTripleMoistureCreamLathershampoo.
Johnson'sBaby/Kidsbrandexperiencesadeclineof5.4%,from$37millionin2011to
$35millionin2012.
Sluggishsalesinthechildrensandbabieshaircaresegmentnegativelyaffectthesales
oftheJohnson'sBaby/Kidsline.

The sales of Wen (GuthyRenker) shampoos grow 86.7%, up from $60million in 2011 to
$112millionin2012.
ThecategoryshareofWengrowsfrom2.4%in2011to4.3%in2012.
Themarketercontinuestobenefitfromdirectlypresentingthebenefitsofitsproducts
toconsumersviainfomercials.
Moreover, Wen is positioned as a fiveinone product, replacing shampoos, daily
conditioner, detanglers, deep conditioner, and leavein conditioner. These factors
contributetoitshighprice.
ValuesalesarehighbecauseWencleansingconditionercostsabout$40.00abottle,and
the instructions mention that one must use a great deal more of the product than a
normalshampoo.Peopleorderingtheproductareautomaticallyenrolledinamonthly
subscription, with monthly charges made to their credit cards and product shipped
outmonthly.
WhileWenfacesrisingcompetitionfromLOralEverCremecleansingconditionerand
others,thegrowthisstillformidable.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A80

Shampoos

Naturallypositionedproductsalsoseegoodgrowthinthecategory.
Organix, a naturallypositioned brand from Vogue International, grows 55.2% from
$29millionin2011to$45millionin2012.
Betterperformanceofnaturalproductscontributetothebrandsgrowthin2012.
VogueInternationalextendsitsOrganixbrandwithArganOilSheaButtershampooand
ThickeningCitrusMintshampooin2012.

Privatelabel

Salesofprivatelabelproductsdecline8.9%from$90millionin2011to$82millionin2012.
ArecoveringeconomyintheUnitedStatescontributetothesalesdipforprivatelabel
productsasconsumerstradeuptonationalbrandswithbetterbenefits.
Thetechnologicaladvancementsandspecializedingredientsintheheavilyresearched
nationalbrandsrendercompetitionfromplainerprivatelabelproductslessenticing.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandiserscontinuetoleadthecategoryastheleadingretaildistributionchannel,
witha41%shareofthecategoryssales.
Drugstoressharedeclinesfrom14%in2011to13%in2012.
However, food stores experience a decline of 100 basis points as consumers
increasinglyvisitmassmerchandisers.
The direct channel grows from 4% in 2011 to 6% in 2012, supported by the positive
performanceoftheWenbrand.

Table4D36:ManufacturersSalesofShampoosintheUnited
StatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

39

41

Foodstores

24

23

Drugstores

14

13

Professionaloutlets

13

11

Specialtystores

Directsales

Departmentstores

100

100

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D81

4D82

Shampoos

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Aggressivemarketingandpromotionalactivityisthebiggestgrowthdriverforarelatively
matureshampooscategory.

Television and print media continue to be the most preferred channel for advertising of
shampooproducts.
Several leading marketers including Procter & Gamble and Unilever promote their
leadingbrandsthroughtelevisionandmagazines.
Marketersbundletheirentirehaircareproductlineincludinghairstyling,conditioners,
andhaircoloringasacompleteproductset.

Discountcouponsandpricebasedpromotionsarealsoimportantmeansofpromotingthe
salesofshampoos.
Discount coupons are distributed through magazines, the Internet, and freestanding
inserts(FSIs).
Coupons in $1.00 and $2.00 denominations are offered by all the leading marketers
includingLOralandProcter&Gamble.
Marketers continue to attract consumers through pricebased promotions, as this is
oneofthekeyfactorswhichinfluenceconsumerstotrynewproducts.
Marketers also provide discounts and buyonegetonefree promotions for brands
whosesalesaredeclininginordertokeepuptheirshare.
Several leading marketers, such as Unilever and Procter & Gamble provide cash nd
discountcouponsthroughtheirwebsitetosupportthesalesfortheirrespectivebrands.

Marketersprovidefreesamplestosupportthesalesoftheirnewproductsaswellastheir
underperformingproducts.
Marketers provide free samples on new product launches in order to encourage
consumerstotrythem.
Procter&GambledistributesitsnewTRESemmSplitRemedyshampoosin2012.

MarketerscontinuetorelyontheInternetandsocialmediasites,suchasFacebook,Tumblr,
Pinterest,andTwitter,topromoteandadvertisetheirproducts.
Presence on the social networking websites is an economical means to stay in touch
withexistingandpotentialcustomers.
New product information and promotional offers are presented by all the leading
brandsthroughtheirrespectivepagesonFacebook.

Brandwebsitesareemergingasanimportantmediumtopromoteshampoos.
Thebrandwebsitesprovidehairtipsandsuggestionsfordifferenthairproblems.
Major brands websites communicate product benefits and other unique features of
eachlineandvariant.
Marketers websites also provide contests to encourage consumer involvement with
thebrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A82

Shampoos

Marketerslaunchdifferentpromotioncampaignstopromotetheirbrands.
Head&ShoulderslaunchesacampaignstarringsoccerplayerLionelMessi,appearing
inaseriesoftelevisionadvertisementsdesignedspecificallytoreachHispanicmalesin
theUnitedStates.

In 2012, TME for shampoos total $446.3million, up significantly by 27.0% from


$351.3millionin2011.
Marketersspendalmost67.4%ofTMEontelevisionor$301.0millionin2012,followed
bymagazineswith$127.3million.
MarketleaderProcter&GamblesTMEfor2012is$156.3million,downby0.5%,from
$157.1millionin2011.
ThePanteneProVbrandgarners$82.2millionoftheTMEin2012.ThePanteneProV
MoistureRenewallineisallocatedaTMEof$33.5millionin2012.
TheantidandruffbrandHead&Shouldersgarners$60.2millionoftheTME.

Secondleadingmarketer,UnileverhasaTMEof$103.3millionin2012,upsignificantlyby
94.9%from$53.0millionin2011.
Themarketersignificantlyspends$55.4milliontopromoteitsClearbrandin2012.
In2012,TMEforUnileversleadingbrandSuaveare$19.4millionandTRESemmhasa
TMEof$11.6million.
Approximately$78.3millionor75.7%ofthetotalTMEisspentontelevisionadvertising,
followedbymagazineadvertisingwith$19.2million.

Thirdleading marketer LOrals media spending on promoting its shampoo brands is


$51.4millionin2012,downfrom$70.7millionin2011.
GarnierFructis,LOralsleadingbrand,hasaTMEof$51.1million.
The marketer allocates approximately 71.5% or $36.7 million on television
advertisementsfollowedbymagazineadvertisementswithaTMEof$14.0million.

DetailedinformationonTMEinthecategoryisprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthis
report.

OUTLOOK

SalesoftheshampooscategoryareexpectedtogrowataCAGRof3.1%overtheforecast
period,2012to2017.
ThecategorycontinuestogrowdespiteitsrelativelymaturestageintheUnitedStates.

Shampoos with new and improved formulations are expected to drive the categorys
growthovertheforecastperiod.
Shampoos that protect the scalp health and enhance shine are expected to perform
wellinthefuture.
Marketers launching shampoos with improved formulations are expected to
experiencegrowththrough2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4D83

4D84

Shampoos

Productinnovationwillcontinuetodrivethecategoryssalesovertheforecastperiod.
Shampoosthatcatertospecifichairproblemsandhairtypesareexpectedtosupport
thecategoryssales.
Marketers will constantly incorporate additional hair care benefits, such as frizz
protectionandcolorprotectionintotheirproducts.

Shampoosthatcontainnaturalingredientsareexpectedtodrivethecategoryssales.
Consumerswillcontinuetolookforshampoosthatcontainnaturalingredients,suchas
herbalandfloralextracts.
Several leading marketers, such as Unilever and L'Oral are expected to eliminate
chemicalagents,suchassulfatesandparabensfromtheirproducts.
The success of L'Orals newer lines, such as EverPure and EverCreme (sulphatefree
ranges)willpromptothermarketerstooffersimilarproducts.
Naturalshampoosornaturallypositionedshampoosthatwillnotcausedamagetothe
hairarelikelytohavegooddemandinthefuture.

Mensshampooswillcontinuetogrowovertheforeastperiod,supportedbynewproduct
launchesandanincreasingdemandforsuchproducts.
Marketersconsiderthissegmenttohaveahugepotential,andasaresult,companies,
such as Unilever and Procter & Gamble are including mens care products in their
prioritylist.
UnileverlaunchestheClearMenrangeofshampoosand conditionersin2012,which
maybetheonlyrealthreattoHead&Shouldersdominance.
Procter&GamblealsolaunchesmensshampoosundertheHead&Shouldersbrand.

Aggressiveandinnovativeproductpromotionsareexpectedtobeamongthekeydriversfor
thecategorysgrowth.
Marketers will continue to exploit the Internet and its growing reach to increase the
onlineproportionofproductpromotion.
Onlinesocialmediawillcontinuetogainstrengthasproductpromotionandadvertising
tools.
Asthevolumeofonlineshoppingincreases,marketersareincreasinglylikelytoplace
theirproductsonlinetobuildtheirmarketshares.
Marketerswillencourageonlineshoppingbyprovidingdiscountsandfreesamplesfor
productsthatarepurchasedonline.

ManufacturerssalesareexpectedtoincreaseataCAGRof3.1%to$3,050millionby2017,
upfrom$2,620millionin2012.

Unit volume sales are forecast to increase at a CAGR of 2.2% growing from 741million
packagesin2012to826millionpackagesby2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A84

4E.MAKEUP

INTRODUCTION

Makeup products are applied to the face, eyes, and lips to impart color, to highlight and
accentuate,andtocoverblemishesorotherimpuritiesoftheskin.

Includedinthisproductclassarethefollowingcategories:
Eyemakeup
Facemakeup
Lipsticksandlipglosses
Nailpolishes

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Themakeupproductclassisdrivenbythestrongperformanceofthefacemakeupandnail
polishescategoriesin2012.
The nail polishes category is the fastestgrowing product category in 2012, growing
17.4%toreach$662millionin2012,upfrom$564millionin2011.
Face makeup grows 3.7% to reach $2,909 million in 2012, up from $2,804 million in
2011andcontributesthemostdollarstothemakeupproductclass.

Totalsales

Salesofthemakeupproductclassreach$7,657millionatthemanufacturerslevelin2012,
up4.3%from$7,341millionin2011.
Facemakeup,thelargestmakeupcategory,accountsfor38.0%oftotalsalesin2012.
Eye makeup follows as the secondleading makeup category with 35.4% of total
makeupproductclasssales,downslightlyfroma35.7%in2011.
Both,facemakeupandeyemakeupcollectivelyrepresent73.4%ofthetotalmakeup
productclasssalesin2012.
Lipsticksandlipglossesrepresent18.0%oftotalmakeupsalesin2012,downslightly
from18.4%oftotalmakeupsalesin2011.
Nail polishes is the smallest makeup category, though continues to be the fastest
growing,up17.4%.Nailpolishesrepresent8.6%oftotalsalesin2012,upfroma7.7%
sharein2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE &COMPANY,INC.

4E2

Makeup

Historicalsales

Since2007,makeupsaleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of4.3%
to$7,657millionin2012.

Table4E1:HistoricalSalesofMakeupintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

6,342

2008

6,355

0.2

2009

6,446

1.4

2010

6,740

4.6

2011

7,341

8.9

2012

7,657

4.3

Salesbytradeclass

Massbrandsrepresent49.0%ofallmakeupsalesin2012.Thetradeclassgrowsby4.3%for
theyear,onparwiththetotalmarketgrowthof4.3%.
Salesofluxurybrandsfollowinsecondposition,with32.7%ofthetotalmakeupsales,
surpassingthetotalmarketgrowthandgrowingthefastest,up7.7%in2012.
The direct trade class is the thirdlargest, but declines by 2.1% to $1,169 million in
manufacturerssalesin2012.Avon,thesecondlargestdirectmarketer,contributesto
thedecline.

Figure4E1:ManufacturersSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStates,2012

Facemakeup,
38.0%

Nailpolishes,
8.6%

Lipsticksandlip
glosses,18.0%

Eyemakeup,
35.4%
Total:$7,657Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Makeup

Table4E2:ManufacturersSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

Tradeclass

$Million
Face
makeup

Eye
makeup

Lipsticksand
lipglosses

Nail
polishes

Total

%Oftotal

Mass

1,224

1,405

538

585

3,752

49.0

Luxury

1,087

884

494

38

2,503

32.7

Direct

538

356

246

29

1,169

15.3

Specialty

49

58

93

10

210

2.7

Professional

11

23

0.3

2,909

2,709

1,377

662

7,657

100.0

Total

RETAILSALES

Retail sales of makeup products are estimated at $11,670 million in 2012, up 4.4% from
$11,182millionin2011.

COMPETITION

Thetopfivemarketersinthemakeupproductclassrepresent62%oftotalmakeupsalesin
2012,downfrom64%in2011.
The topfive companies generate more than $250million in sales in 2012, much less
thanthe$400milliontheycontributedin2011.
LOralcontributestwothirdsofthenewdollarsin2012 withthemostcoming from
Maybelline,LOralParis,andtheEssiebrands.

LOralistheleadingmarketerinthemakeupproductclassin2012.
Salestotal$1,814millionin2012,up10.5%from$1,641millionin2011.
LOrals share of the total makeup product class is 23.7% in 2012, up from 22.3% in
2011.
LOralhasasignificantpresenceinmostoftheproductcategoriesinthesegmentand
increasesitspresenceinthenailpolishescategoryin2012.
LOralprofitsfromitsstrongdistributionmodelthatisrootedinthemassandluxury
tradeclasses.
LOrals Maybelline is the leading brand in the makeup product class, with sales at
$782millionin2012,up8.8%from$719millionin2011.
LOral Paris is the thirdleading makeup brand in 2012, behind Covergirl, with sales
reaching $558million in 2012, up 6.9% from $522million in 2011. Eye makeup is the
largestproductcategoryforthebrand,with47.7%ofthetotalsales.
LancmeisthethirdleadingbrandintheluxurytradeclassbehindMACandClinique
withsalesof$281millionin2012,up5.2%from$267millionin2011.Lancmesshare
ofthetotalmarketis3.7%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E3

4E4

Makeup

Table4E3:ManufacturersSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,Company,andMajor
Brand,2012

$Million
Face
makeup

Company/brand
LORAL

Eye
makeup

Lipsticksand
lipglosses

Total

Maybelline

235

446

91

10

782

LOralParis

188

266

83

21

558

Lancme

117

128

32

281

26

40

22

88

68

68

YSLBeaute

11

10

30

Dermablend

584

890

236

104

1,814

MAC

173

140

88

405

Clinique

196

105

47

352

EsteLauder

115

49

29

198

BobbiBrown

44

30

32

106

SmashboxBeauty

12

19

11

42

Origins

18

14

39

Aveda

16

565

354

226

13

1,158

328

290

103

723

REVLON

Revlon

105

133

123

48

409

Almay

58

71

129

Sinful

34

34

PureIce

25

25

Bari/BonBons

163

204

126

108

601

UrbanDecay
Essie

Total
ESTELAUDER

Totala
PROCTER&GAMBLE
Covergirl

Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Nail
polishes

Makeup

Table4E3:ManufacturersSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,Company,andMajor
Brand,2012

$Million
Face
makeup

Eye
makeup

Lipsticksand
lipglosses

178

141

110

431

210

218

Rimmel

26

57

26

113

NYCNewYorkColor

14

18

10

42

OPI

21

21

Nicole

19

19

Coty

Total

49

75

27

264

415

192

61

18

271

Nars

17

15

14

46

Shiseido

28

46

237

85

41

363

805

670

508

169

2,152

662

7,657

Company/brand
MARYKAY
SallyHansen

SHISEIDO
BareEscentuals

Total
ALLOTHER

TOTAL
2,909
2,709
1,377

aTotalnolongerincludesBeautyBank,whichisnowincludedinAllOther.

Nail
polishes

Total

Este Lauder is the secondleading makeup marketer with a 15.1% share of the makeup
market,andtotalsalesof$1,158millionin2012.
Thecompanysurpassesoverallmarketgrowthwith6.5%growthin2012.
The company continues to be the leading marketer within the luxury trade class in
2012,accountingfor46.2%ofsegmentsales.
The companys MAC and Clinique brands are the leaders in the luxury segment and
importantbrandsforthemarketerastheyrepresent65.4%ofcompanyssalesin2012.
The face and eye makeup categories represent 79.4% of the companys sales, with a
totalofsevenbrandsinthemakeupluxurytradeclassin2012.
Clinique is the leading brand in face makeup within the luxury class with an 18.0%
share.
MACisthe leadingmarketerinthelipsticksandlipglosses categorywithintheluxury
trade class, with sales of $88 million in 2012. MAC has a category share of 17.8% in
2012.
MACdoublesitsnailpolishesbusinessin2012reaching$4millioninsalesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E5

4E6

Makeup

Procter&Gamble continues to be the thirdlargest makeup marketer in 2012 with its


Covergirlbrand.
Sales total $723 million in 2012, down 4.1% from $754million in 2011. Procter &
Gamble represents 9.4% of total category sales in 2012, down from 10.3% of total
makeupsalesin2011.
Procter & Gamble is the largest marketer in the face makeup category with sales of
$328millionin2012,down2.1%from$335millionin2011.
Face makeup represents the largest category for the brand with 45.4% of Covergirls
totalmakeupsalesin2012.
Procter&Gamblerankssecondintheeyemakeupcategory,withsalesof$290million
in2012,down4.6%from$304millionin2011.

Revlon is the fourthleading marketer in the makeup product class, with sales at $601
millionin2012,up1.5%from$592millionin2011.
Revlonrepresents7.8%oftotalmakeupsalesin2012downslightlyfrom8.1%in2011.
TheRevlonbrandhasa16.0%shareofthemasstradeclassin2012.
Eyemakeupistheleadingcategoryforthebrand,accountingfor32.5%ofthebrands
makeupsalesin2012.
Revlonisthefourthleadingeyemakeupmarketerin2012,with4.9%ofthecategorys
salesin2012.
Almayssalesdecline3.0%to$129millionin2012from$133millionin2011.
Revlonisthefourthlargestbrandinthelipsticksandlipglossescategorywithsalesof
$123millionin2012,down1.6%from$125millionin2011.
RevlonacquirestheBonBonsandPureIcebrandsfromBariCosmeticsin2012,which
combinedcontribute$29millioninsalestothecompany.

MaryKayremainsinthefifthposition,witha5.6%shareofthetotalmakeupsales.
Salesgrow4.4%from$413millionin2011to$431millionin2012.
Facemakeupandeyemakeuprepresent74.0%ofthemarketerssales.
MaryKaylimitsthenumberofSKUsofnailpolishessoldtotwowhichvarybyseason
and/orholiday.

Cotyisthesixthleadingmarketerinthemakeupcategoryin2012.
Salesgrow1.0%in2012to$415million,upfrom$411millionin2011.
NailpolishisthemostimportantcategorytoCotyasitrepresents63.6%ofitsmakeup
sales,or$264million.
The Sally Hansen brand represents 52.5% of the marketers sales in 2012. The brand
declines8.0%in2012withsalesof$218million.Thebranddoesnotprovideenough
productormarketingnewnesstogrowsalesfrom2011.
Cotysnailpolishesmarketsharedeclinesfrom56.6%in2011to45.2%in2012.Coty
faces stiff competition with its plethora of new launches in the mass and specialty
tradeclasses.
Rimmel is the secondleading brand in Cotys portfolio behind Sally Hansen. Rimmel
sales reach $113 million in 2012, up 11.9% from $101 million in 2011. Rimmel
represents27.2%ofCotysalesin2012.
EyemakeupistheleadingcategoryfortheRimmelbrandwithsalesof$57millionin
2012,up9.6%from2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

Makeup

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Themassmerchandiserchannelrepresents26%ofmakeupsalesandcontinuestobethe
leadingchannelformakeupproductsin2012.
Nailpolishesarethefastestgrowingcategoryin2012.Lipsticksandlipglossesdecline
inthemasstradeclass.
Budgetbrands,suchasEyesLipsFace,Rimmel,andWetnWild,helpfuelthegrowthin
thechannel.

Department stores rank a close second with a 25% share as consumers seek personal
attentionandproducttrial.
Allcategoriesoutperformedthetotalmarketgrowthof4.3%.
Nailpolishesgrowthefastest,up25.8%in2012.

Drugstoresanddirectsalesaccountfor21%and15%oftotalmakeupsales,respectively,in
2012.
Drugstoresloseonesharepointtomassmerchandisersasmanydollarstoresbeginto
sell budget makeup brands and mass merchandiser stores revamp and extend shelf
spacetomorebrands.
CVSclosesallofitsBeauty360locationsin2012.
DirectsalesoverallareimpededbyAvonsfailuretokeepupwiththeoverallmarkets
growth.

Table4E4:RetailDistributionofMakeupintheUnitedStates,2012

Face
makeup

Eye
makeup

Lipsticksandlip
glosses

Nail
polishes

Weighted
average

Massmerchandisers

24

29

19.0

37

26

Departmentstores

30

26

24

25

Drugstores

18

19

25

39

21

Directsales

16

14

18

15

Specialtystores

10

11

10

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

0.5

100

100

100

100

100

Retailoutlet

Total

%Ofmanufacturersdollars

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E7

4E8

Makeup

PROMOTION

Themakeupproductclasscontinuestobestronglyadvertisedin2012,andthepromotional
activitiesvarybytradeclass.
Themarketingmixforallmarketersincludesocialmediamarketing,suchasFacebook,
Twitter,YouTube,Pinterest,andTumblr.
Blogsonthebrandswebsitecontinuetobepopularandhelpconsumersfindcoupons,
dates when stores offer giftwithpurchase (GWP) promotions, as well as dates when
brandswillholdpromotionsthatofferdiscountshippingorfreesamples.
Online subscription on company websites, such as glossybox.com, julepmaven.com,
and curlbox.com, are making inroads whereby for a monthly fee, the subscriber will
receivetrialsamplesofbeautyproducts.

Traceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs)fortheproductclassreach$1,320millionin2012,up
16.5%from$1,133millionin2011.
The top three advertisers in the product classLOral, Procter & Gamble, and
Revlonaccount for approximately 75% of total advertising dollars for the entire
makeupproductclass.
LOral continues to be the leading advertiser in the product class with TME of
$605.3millionin2012,up10.9%from$546.0millionin2011.
LOralsMaybellineistheleadingadvertisedbrandin2012,with$320.6millioninTME,
up6.7%from$300.4millionin2011or53.0%ofLOralstotaladvertisingdollars.
LOral Paris is the secondlargest advertised brand by the marketer in 2012, with
$222.8million,up14.3%from$194.9millionin2011.
Procter & Gamble is the secondleading advertiser in the product class with TME of
$224.6millionin2012,down44.9%from$325.5millionin2011.
Procter&GamblesflagshipbrandCovergirlaccountsfor96.0%ofthemarketerstotal
advertisingspendingin2012,whiletheremainingisusedtosupporttheluxurybrand
Dolce&Gabbana.
Revlon follows as the thirdleading advertiser in the product class with TME of
$147.0million in 2012, up 7.1% from $137.2million in 2011. Revlons flagship brand
Revlonreceivesabout81%oftheTMEin2012.
Massbrandscharacteristicallyrelyonprintandtelevisionmedia,anddiscountcoupons
eitheratinstoredisplaysorinprintviamagazinesandwebsites.
Leading mass brands are often supported by celebrity endorsements. For example,
CoverGirlusessingersPinkandJanelleMonaeandactressSofiaVergara.
Mostlargemassretailerstypicallyrunpromotionsofferingmakeupproductsatbuy
onegetonefreeorbuyonegetonehalfpricetostimulatemultiplepurchases.
Theleadingmassbrands,suchas Maybelline,LOral,andRevlon,pushcoupons and
discountstosmartphones.
Mass marketers use their own websites to duplicate the role of the beauty
representative found in department stores to help consumers match products with
theirskintypeandorshade.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

Makeup

4E9

Sales personnel at beauty counters continue to be critical in selling luxury brands within
department stores promoting products by way of education and free samples. Marketers
partnerwithstorestoprovideinstoreactivitiestodrawconsumerstotheircounters.
Retailersareincreasinglycarvingoutspacetoshowcasesingleitemsacrossallbrands,
nearthecashregistertogetconsumerstoeithertrynewproductsintrialand/ortravel
sizes.
Retailers, such as Sephora, use end caps that change monthly in their stores to
showcasefavoriteand/orhotitems.
Marketers continue to use giftwithpurchase (GWP) and purchasewithpurchase
(PWP)promotionsasincentivestopurchase.
Marketersusesocialmediasitestopromotenewproductsandinstoreevents.
Thepromotionalactivitymainlycentersonbringingconsumerstothebeautycounters,
wheresalespersonnelofferfreemakeovers,consultations,andsamples.
Most luxury brands websites offer free shipping on orders above $50.00; however,
Este Lauder offers free shipping and returns, and Clinique offers freestandard
shipping. Some marketers, such as Bobbi Brown, offer free returns on foundation,
concealer,andpowder.
Este Lauder is the leading marketer in the luxury trade class with a TME of
$97.9millionin2012,up42.7%from$68.6millionin2011.
CliniquereceivesthemostTMEfromthemarketeranduses$61.8milliontopromote
itsproductsin2012.Itisalsotheonlyleadingluxurybrandthatadvertisesontelevision,
usingapproximately20%ofitstotalTMEallotmentfromthemarketer.
Lancme is the secondlargest advertised brand in the luxury trade class with
$28.6millioninTMEin2012,followedbytheEsteLauderwith$23.4million,andBare
Escentualswith$18.5million.

Table4E5:ExamplesofCouponingActivityofMakeupintheUnitedStates,2012
Company/division

Brand

Promotion

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

Pickthreesamplesofconcealer,mascara,orBBcreamandfree
shippingwithminimum$65.00purchase.Freereturnson
foundation,concealer,orpowder

LOral

LOralParis

$1.00offonanyLOralParisproduct

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

$3.00offwhenyoupurchasetwoCovergirlnailproducts

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

Save$2.00withthepurchaseofPeoplemagazineandany
CovergirlOutlastlipcolor

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

$2.00offontwo24HRmascaraand/orOutlastlipcolor

Revlon

Revlon

$3.50offonanyRevlonpurchaseof$10.00ormore

Revlon

Revlon

Save$2.00onanyRevlonPhotoReadyFaceProduct

Shiseido

Nars

20%offonatotalorderfortwodaysstartingCyberMonday

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E10

Makeup

OUTLOOK

Thegrowthoftheproductclassislikelytobesupportedbyincreasesintheadvertisingand
promotional efforts of the marketers, including those that declined in advertising dollars
spentin2012.
Additionally, smaller niche brands and budget brands are expected to increase their
advertisingbudgetsduringtheforecastperiod.
Newnessintheproductclasswillcontinuetodrivesalesaswellaspriceincreasesthat
arewarrantedthroughnewingredients,packaging,andtechnologyacrosstradeclasses.
It is anticipated that marketers with skin care brands will continue to introduce
scientificallyadvancedingredientsintomakeupproducts,especiallythoseproductsin
thefacemakeupcategory.
Trendsettingproductsfoundfirstintheluxurytradeclassislikelytotrickledownto
masswherebudgetbrandssuchasEyeLipsFace,Rimmel,andWetnWildarelikelyto
capitalize.
Promotion through tutorials of products on marketers websites and/or packaging is
expectedtocontinue,asconsumersarelikelytoseekouttheirfavoritecelebritylook
orprofessionalmakeupartistlookwithoutalwayshavingtogotoacounterorexpert.
Natural products are still underdeveloped but provide great potential for marketers
withsuchheritage,whilespecialtystorescontinuetopromotethesebrands.

Face makeup categorys sales are predicted to remain on par with the overall makeup
marketgrowthataCAGRof3.8%through2017.
Foundationsandprimersthatofferskincarebenefitsareexpectedtodrivesalesboth
inunitsanddollars.However,somesaleswillbecannibalizedbythegrowingpopularity
ofbeautybalms.
However, as women strive for complexion perfection, primers and concealers are
expectedtosupportnewsales.
Finishing products that help keep products in place are anticipated to grow in
popularityasmoremarketerslaunchsuchproducts.
Liquidandcreamfoundationsareanticipatedtobeattheforefrontattheexpenseof
mineralpowders.
Asconsumerscontinuetoreachforcomplexionperfection,withproductsthatcontain
beneficialornaturalskincareingredientsandareweightlesswhilematchingskintone,
isexpectedtogrowatahealthyrate.
Inadditiontofoundations,primersandconcealerswillbesoughtafter.
Consumer confidence is expected to improve and sales are expected to increase
especiallyamonghigherpricedbrandsasconsumerstradebacktotheirtrustedbrands
ofthepastorfindnewbrandsthatoffersomethingdifferent.
Shadematchingisexpectedtoplayacriticalroleinobtainingandkeepingconsumers
especiallyamongmassmarketers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

Makeup

SalesintheeyemakeupcategoryareanticipatedtogrowataCAGRof3.1%through2017.
Marketers are expected to add new limited or seasonal collections to their lines to
createexcitementandaddincrementalsalesthroughouttheyear.
Thetrendofwearingmultipleshadesoneyelidsisjustbeginningandislikelytospur
saleswithinthecategory.Also,layingshimmerorglittereyeshadowisanticipatedto
growsales.
Marketers are likely to continue to launch new and improved formulas within eye
shadowsandmascaras.
Mascarasthatpromotelashlengththroughtheuseofmorefibersorwithproductsto
fillinthegapsbetweenlashesareexpectedtofuelsalesinthecategory.
ThecategorywilllikelyseeanincreaseinadvertisingduringtheforecastperiodasTME
declinesforthecategoryin2012.

Lipsticksandlipglossescategoryssalesareexpectedtobetheslowest,growingataCAGR
of2.4%duringtheforecastperiodthrough2017.
Itisanticipatedthatwomenwillpurchasemultiplelipproductstocapturetheirmood
ortimeofthedayandislikelytospursales.
It is likely that lip liners will remain relatively flat unless a new trend or innovative
technologytakesholdduringtheforecastperiod.
Bold,redlipsarelikelytoremainpopularandarepredictedtostay.
Natural brands are anticipated to grow as they improve shades and formulas and
increasepromotion.ThenewestbrandisObsessiveCompulsiveCosmeticswithacult
favorite,LipTar.
Multifunctionallipproducts,suchasthosethataredualtipped,stainononesideand
moistureorglossontheother,arelikelytocontinuetodrivesales.
More attractive packaging is anticipated because consumers consider lip products a
beneficialaccessory.

The nail polishes categorys sales are projected to outpace the overall market growth of
9.0%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Enthusiasm in the category is anticipated as marketers continue to launch innovative
shades,textures,anddifferenttypesofnailart.
Thebroadrangeofexcitingnewhuesisexpectedtoprovokeconsumerstowearand
repurchaseoftentosuittheirfashionpalette.
Gelbased formulations are here to stay and it is anticipated that marketers will
increasingly advertise gellike products as well as doityourself (DIY) gel products.
These products are expected to drive retail prices and sales volumes, as more
consumersadoptgelpolishesathome.
Itisalsoanticipatedthatnewinnovationsingeltechnology,suchaseasyremovalgel
polishislikelytofuelsalesthroughtheforecastperiod.
Brandsthathavenotfollowedthenailcrazearepredictedtolaunchandadvertisenew
products.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E11

4E12

Makeup

Sales for the makeup product class are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 3.8% to reach
$9,241millionby2017,upfrom$7,657millionin2012.

UnitsalesareexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof4.2%through2017toreach1,740million
packages,upfrom1,418millionpackagesin2012.

Table4E6:ForecastManufacturersSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStatesby
Category,2012to2017

$Million

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Facemakeup

2,909

3,509

3.8

Eyemakeup

2,709

3,160

3.1

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,377

1,553

2.4

662

1,019

9.0

7,657

9,241

3.8

Nailpolishes
Total

Table4E7:ForecastUnitSalesofMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,2012to2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Eyemakeup

524.9

650.8

4.4

Facemakeup

421.4

488.5

2.5

Lipsticksandlipglosses

237.5

256.0

1.5

Nailpolishes

234.6

344.7

8.0

1,418.4

1,740.0

4.2

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

EYEMAKEUP

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Salesincreaseatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of4.9%since2007.

Table4E8:HistoricalSalesofEyeMakeupintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

2,133

2008

2,200

3.1

2009

2,304

4.7

2010

2,431

5.5

2011

2,621

7.8

2012

2,709

3.4

Manufacturerssalesintheeyemakeupcategorygrowby3.4%toreach$2,709millionin
2012,upfrom$2,621millionin2011.
Eye makeup is the secondleading makeup category in 2012, with 35.4% of the total
salesfortheproductclass.

Mascarascontinuetoaccountformajorityofthesaleswithinthecategory.
Mascarasaretheleadingsegmentintheeyemakeupcategory,with51.0%oftotaleye
makeupsalesin2012.
Mascarasgrowby3.4%toreach$1,383millioninmanufacturerssales.
Growthofthecategoryisfueledbynewproductlaunchesthatincludeproductswith
multiplebenefitsandnewbrushtechnology.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E14

EyeMakeup

Table4E9:ManufacturersSalesofEyeMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Tradeclass/brand

Company

MASS

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass

2011

2011

2012

Maybelline

LOral

422

446

30.7

31.7

16.1

16.5

Covergirlr

Procter&Gamble

304

290

22.1

20.6

11.6

10.7

LOralParisr

LOral

257

266

18.7

18.9

9.8

9.8

Revlon

Revlon

133

133

9.7

9.5

5.1

4.9

Almay

Revlon

74

71

5.4

5.1

2.8

2.6

Rimmelr

Coty

52

57

3.8

4.1

2.0

2.1

Wet'N'Wild

Markwins

30

32

2.2

2.3

1.1

1.2

PhysiciansFormula

PhysiciansFormula

23

25

1.7

1.8

0.9

0.9

NYCNewYorkColor

Coty

15

18

1.1

1.3

0.6

0.7

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

15

15

1.1

0.9

0.6

0.6

TSGConsumerPartners

EyesLipsFace

10

13

0.7

0.6

0.4

0.5

Prestige

PrestigeCosmetics

0.6

0.6

0.3

0.3

BonneBell

BonneBell

30

30

2.2

2.1

1.1

1.1

100.0

100.0

Allother
Total

1,374

1,405

52.4

51.9

LUXURY

MAC

EsteLauder

134

140

16.2

15.8

5.1

5.2

Lancme

L'Oral

122

128

14.8

14.5

4.7

4.7

Clinique

EsteLauder

100

105

12.1

11.9

3.8

3.9

Chanel

Chanel

49

50

5.9

5.7

1.9

1.8

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

48

49

5.8

5.5

1.8

1.8

Benefit

LVMH

30

40

3.6

4.5

1.1

1.5

BobbiBrown

EsteLauder

29

30

3.5

3.4

1.1

1.1

ChristianDior

LVMH

26

29

3.1

3.3

1.0

1.1

SmashboxBeauty

SmashboxBeauty
Cosmetics

18

19

2.2

2.1

0.7

0.7

LauraMercier

Amway

18

19

2.2

2.1

0.7

0.7

Nars

Shiseido

14

15

1.7

1.7

0.5

0.6

TrishMcEvoy

TrishMcEvoy

13

14

1.6

1.6

0.5

0.5

Shiseido

Shiseido

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

Origins

EsteLauder

0.7

0.8

0.2

0.3

FashionFair

JohnsonPublishing

0.7

0.7

0.2

0.2

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

0.7

0.6

0.2

0.2

Clarins

Clarins

0.6

0.5

0.2

0.2

Stila

Stila

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.1

152

161

18.4

18.2

5.8

5.9

826

884

100.0

100.0

31.5

32.6

Allotherr
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

2012

%Oftotal

4E15

EyeMakeup

Table4E9:ManufacturersSalesofEyeMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Tradeclass/brand

Company

DIRECTSALES

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

132

141

36.7

39.6

5.0

5.2

MaryKay

MaryKay

Avon

Avon

95

88

26.4

24.7

3.6

3.2

BareEscentuals

Shiseido

61

61

16.9

17.1

2.3

2.3

Mark

Avon

13

12

3.6

3.4

0.5

0.4

Artistry

Alticor

1.1

1.1

0.2

0.1

VictoriaJackson

VictoriaJackson
Cosmetics

2.5

0.6

0.3

0.1

46

48

12.8

13.5

1.8

1.8

360

356

100.0

100.0

13.7

13.1

22

22

40.0

37.9

0.8

0.8

Allother
Total
SPECIALTY
VictoriasSecret

LimitedBrands

Privatelabel

21

24

38.2

41.4

0.8

0.9

Allother

12

12

21.8

20.7

0.5

0.4

55

58

100.0

100.0

2.2

2.0

66.7

66.7

0.2

0.1

33.3

33.3

0.1

0.1

100.0

100.0

0.2

0.2

100.0

100.0

Total
PROFESSIONAL
Aveda

EsteLauder

Allother

Total

TOTAL

2,709

2,621

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit sales of eye makeup products grow 2.0% to reach 525million packages in 2012, up
from515millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesoftheeyemakeupcategoryareestimatedat$4,122millionin 2012, up3.4%


from$3,987millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E16

EyeMakeup

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Growthofthecategorycontinueswiththesmokyeyestrendasthedriver,butisenhanced
in2012withboldeyebrows.
Themostdramaticgrowthcomesfromeyelinerandeyebrowproductsaswomenstrive
for eyes that communicate sex appeal, with dramatic eyeliner and accentuated
eyebrows.
Eyeshadowsalesarerelativelyflatasbothsalesinthemassandluxurytradeclasses
declinein2012.

Eyeshadowsalesdeclineto$677millionin2012from$681millionin2011.
Eye shadow formats are released by many brands from trios to quads to multiple
colored palettes. Some marketers, such as Smashbox Cosmetics use palettes to
enhancespecificeyecolorstotaketheguessworkoutofthemindoftheconsumer.
Thebreadthofeyeshadowshadesisvastin2012.Shadesrangefromnudestodeep,
richcolors,tometallicandglitterinallcolorsoftherainbow.UrbanDecaycontinuesto
doverywellwithitsNakedpalettefranchises
Severalmarketersprovideeyeshadowpalettestoencouragewomentoplayandhave
fun with color. Consumers also enjoy the value proposition that multiple shadows
provide.
Palettes have a downside for marketers, as consumers are less likely to purchase
severalsingleeyeshadows.
Similar to the wet/dry foundations, many of the brands eye shadow assortments
include eye shadow powders that can go on dry for a subtle look, but that can be
moistenedtogooncreamyforlongerlasting,deeperpigments.
Additionally, creamy eye shadows in pots like MACs Pro Longwear Paint Pot that
provide high pigment in a creamy texture but dry to a powder are also seen from
severalmarketers.Inthemassmarket,MaybellinelaunchesColorTattoo24hrCream
GelShadow.
Multitonedeyesareatrendasareshadowswithhintsofsparkleorshimmer.
Bakedpowderscontinuetobepopular,asmarketersembossbeautifuldesignsonthe
eyeshadow.Auniqueuseofthebakedeyeshadowandmarketingconnectionisfrom
Chantecaille, which embosses elephants in its eye shadow palettes of rich, earthy
metallicshadeswhilesupportingaWildlifeTrustthroughproceedsfromsales.
In addition to paint pots, marketers use creamy formulas in the form of crayons or
liquids, such as Cliniques Chubby Stick Shadow Tint for Eyes and Lid Smoothie
Antioxidant8hourEyeColourandRevlonsColorstaySmokyShadowStick.
New applications are seen as well, such as Bare Minerals Whipped Velvet Longwear
Eyecolorthatgoesongoldandbuffsouttoabrilliantbluehue.
Primersareincludedinsomepalettes,suchasAlmaysWakeUpEyeShadow+Primer
product.
Tutorials on how to doityourself (DIY) are being used by marketers. For example,
Lorac includes a sticker to put on the mirror with instructions on ways to achieve a
certaineyelook.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

EyeMakeup

Mascaraisthepreferredsegmentthatmostwomendonotgowithout.Mostwomenseek
longer,fuller,anddefinedlashes.
Theplethoraofnewandimprovedmascarascontinuestoaddexcitementandgrowth
tothecategory.
In addition to volume and definition, dualpurpose mascaras that include eyelash
primersandadditivefibersarelaunched.
Falselashesareeasilyavailablefrommostmarketers.Althoughmostwomenarenot
comfortableapplyingfalselashesthemselves,thefalselasheslookappealstothem,in
partduetosingersAdeleandKatiePerrywhoareknownforwearingfalselashes.This
trendmakeswayformarketerstolaunchmascarasthattoutafalselashlookorthat
have fibers in their formula to achieve the look. New products include MACs False
Lashesmascara,andTooFacedBetterThanFalseLashesmascara.
The rods, wipers, brushes, tubes, and formulas are all changing constantly with new
shapes and colors. Marketers use pictures of their different brush technology to
showcasethedifferencesbetweentheirproductsandthedifferentlooksoflashesthat
canbeachieved.
Mascarastoutinghighglossareattheforefront.
Primers are also used as part of the application either as a separate product or as
doubleendedmascarabrush.
Buzzwords in marketing mascaras in 2012 include lash extensions, fiber extensions,
extreme,mega,mouse,gel,collageninfused,impact,antismudge,andmultiplying.

Eyelinersandeyebrowproductsarethefastestgrowingsegmentineyemakeupin2012.
Geleyelinercontinuestobepopularasconsumersfinditeasytousesinceitglideson
smoothlyandiseasilysmudgedforthesmokyeyelook.
Liquideyelinerisbecomingmoremainstreamasmarketersmaketheproducteasyto
use.
Glittereyelinerispopularin2012toachieveasparklylook.
Nomattertheshape,theboldeyebrowslookisatrendin2012.
Thereareaplethoraofnewproductlaunchesintheeyebrowsegmentin2012.
BenefitCosmeticsdeclaresApril1622astheNationalBrowWeek.Thebrandhasmore
than400browbarsacrosstheUnitedStates.
MACdedicatesanentirecounterinitsfreestandingstoresforbrowproductsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E17

4E18

EyeMakeup

Notablenewproducts

Table4E10:SelectNewEyeMakeupProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Amway

LauraMercier

EyeColorfeaturingnewbakedtechnologyinsixshades

Amway

LauraMercier

CaviarStickeyecolorpencilthatoffersanewtechniquetoenhancethe
smokyeyelook

Chanel

Chanel

LesQuatreOmbresDeChanelacombinationof4eyeshadows

Chanel

Chanel

CrayonSourcilsEyebrowPencil

Coty

Rimmel

LashAcceleratorEndlessmascara

Coty

Rimmel

ScandaleyesWaterproofKohleyeliner

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

LimitedEditionEyeShadowPaletteCollections

EsteLauder

Clinique

ChubbyStickShadowTint

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

PureColorStayOnShadowPaint

EsteLauder

MAC

FalseLashesmascara

EsteLauder

SmashboxCosmetics

PhotoOpEyeEnhancingPaletteforblue,brown,andhazeleyes

Lorac

Lorac

ProPalette16eyeshadowsamixofmatteandsparklingcolorsthatcanbe
appliedwetordry

LOral

LOral

Infallible24HREyeShadow

LOral

LOral

ColourRicheeyeshadow

LOral

LOral

VoluminousPowerVolume24HRMascara

LOral

LOral

VoluminousFalseFiberLashesmascara

LOral

LOral

TelescopicShockingExtensionsmascara

LOral

LOral

MagicDeCreaseEyelidPrimer

LOral

LOral

TelescopicShockingExtensionsmascara

LOral

Lancme

HypnoseStarMascaradualactionbrushhasaflatsideforoptimizing
productdepositatthelashlinewhiletheroundedsideseparates,defines,
andlengthens

LOral

Maybelline

VolumExpresstheMegaPlushMascara

LOral

Maybelline

DefineABroweyebrowpencil

LOral

Maybelline

EyeStudioMasterShapeBrowPencil

LOral

UrbanDecay

SmokedEyeshadowPalette

LVMH

Dior

DiorShowExtasemascara

Markwins

WetNWild

MegaImpactmascara

MaryKay

MaryKay

LashLoveWaterproofmascara

Revlon

Revlon

SmokyShadowStick

Revlon

Revlon

PhotoreadyPrimer,Shadow+Sparkleeyeshadow

Shiseido

Nars

EyelinerStylofelttipliquideyeliner

Shiseido

Nars

LargerThanLifeLongWearEyeliner

Stila

Stila

Stila5EyeshadowPalette

TooFaced
Cosmetics

TooFacedCosmetics

3WayLashingLiningToolAtripletiplashemphasizingtoolthatfillsin
spacesbetweenlashes

TooFaced
Cosmetics

TooFacedCosmetics

BetterThanFalseLashesmascara

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

EyeMakeup

M&Aactivity

LOral acquires Urban Decay from Castanea Partners, Inc., a private equity firm in
November2012.
The financial details of the acquisition are not disclosed, but are estimated to be as
highas$350million.

Revlon acquires brands Pure Ice nail enamel and Bon Bons color cosmetics from Bari
CosmeticsinJuly2012.
Terms of the transaction are not disclosed; however, Revlon uses $22 million of
borrowings under its 2011 Revolving Credit Facility, along with cashonhand to fund
theacquisition.

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Table4E11:SalesofEyeMakeupProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and
2012

Producttype

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

1,337

1,382

51.0

51.0

3.4

Eyeshadowsr

681

677

26.0

25.0

(0.6)

Allothera,r

603

650

23.0

24.0

7.8

Total
2,621
2,709

aIncludeseyelinersandeyebrowproducts.
rRestated.

100.0

100.0

3.4

Mascarasr

2011

2012

Change,%

Mascarasrepresentthemajorityoftheeyemakeupcategorywitha51.0%sharein2012.
Salesforthesegmenttotal$1,382millionin2012,up3.4%from$1,337millionin2011.
Newproductactivityfuelsthegrowthinthecategory.Someofthemarketersdriving
the growth include Maybelline, Covergirl, Rimmel, Clinique, Lancme, MAC, and
Benefit.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E19

4E20

EyeMakeup

Eyeshadowisthesecondleadingsegmentintheeyemakeupcategory,with25.0%ofeye
makeupsalesin2012.
Eyeshadowsdeclineslightlyin2012.Itisdebatableifpalettesalescannibalizethesales
of single eye shadow purchase, which holds higher price point overall than if one
breaksdownthepriceofshadowsinapalette.
Another trend that is a likely contributor to fewer purchases of eye shadow is the
smoky eye look where consumers use heavy eyeliner and mascara with just one eye
shadow.
Theforecastto2017showseyeshadowincreasing,asfashionwilldictatemorecolor
intotheeyeshadowregimens,withmultiplecolorsofeyeshadowsoneyelids,aswell
asabitofsparkle.

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4E12:ManufacturersSalesofEyeMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

LOralr

841

890

32.1

32.9

5.8

EsteLaudera

339

354

12.9

13.1

4.4

Procter&Gambler

304

290

11.6

10.7

(4.6)

Revlon

207

204

7.9

7.5

(1.4)

MaryKay

132

141

5.0

5.2

6.8

Avon

108

100

4.1

3.7

(7.4)

Shiseido

83

85

3.2

3.1

2.4

Allother

607

645

23.2

23.8

6.3

Total
2,621
2,709

100.0
100.0

aDoesnotincludesalesofBeautyBank,whichisnowincludedinAllother.
rRestated.

3.4

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

EyeMakeup

LOralistheleadingeyemakeupmarketerin2012withsalesof$890million,up5.8%from
$841millionin2011.
LOral increases its share slightly as the company outperforms the overall market
growthforthecategory.
LOral is the leading advertiser in the eye makeup category with traceable media
expenditure(TME)of$204.2millionin2012,sameasin2011.
Maybelline is the largest advertised brand from LOral in 2012, with TME of
$133.4million,up8.5%from$122.9millionin2011.
LOralParisissupportedwith$59.2millioninadvertisingdollarsin2012.TMEdeclines
8.1%in2012comparedtothelevelofsupportreceivedin2011.
All of LOrals brands contribute to the companys growth as all outpace the overall
marketgrowthof3.4%.MaybellineandLOralPariscontributethemostdollars,while
Urban Decay and YSL Beaute experience doubledigit gains of 29.0% and 11.1%,
respectively.
Maybellineistheleadingbrandintheeyemakeupcategoryandoutpacesthemarket,
growing5.7%toreach$446millionin2012,upfrom$422in2011.
Lancmessaleswith4.9%growthreach$128millionin2012,upfrom$122millionin
2011.
GrowthoftheMaybellinebrandcomesfromitsmascaralaunches,eyebrowcollection,
andeyeshadows.Eyelinersalesforthebrandareflatin2012.
MaybellineexpandsitsshareoftheeyebrowsegmentwithitsEyeStudioMasterShape
Brow Pencil and DefineABrow product. Maybelline also has success with its Volum
ExpresstheMegaPlushandIllegalLengthfiberextensionmascaras.Salesgaincomes
fromitsColorTattoo24hrCreamGelShadow.
Lancmes growth comes from many products within the eye shadow, mascara and
eyebrows segments. Known for its mascaras, Hypnose Star and Hypnose Doll lashes
contributetothebrandssuccessinthesegment.
UrbanDecayssalessoarduetothepopularityofitsNakedeyeshadowpalettes.

SalesofEsteLaudergrowby4.4%to$354millionin2012from$339millionin2011.
Este Lauder moves into second position in the eye makeup category with 13.1% of
categoryssalesin2012.
MACandCliniqueareEsteLaudersleadingbrands,withsalesat$140million,up4.5%
and$105million,up5.0%,respectively,in2012.
MACandCliniquecollectivelyrepresent63%ofEsteLauderstotaleyemakeupsales
in2012.
MACsgrowthisrecognizedbythesuccessofseveralnewproductsacrossthecategory
includingFalseLashesmascara,PaintPots,EyeBrows,aswellasseveraleyeliners.
Cliniques growth comes from its new Chubby Stick Shadow Tint, the existing Lid
SmoothieAntioxidant8HourEyeColor,aswellasthenewHighImpactmascara.
TheEsteLauderbrandgrowsonly2.1%in2012toreach$49millioninsales.Growthis
attributed partly to its newest mascaras Sumptuous Extreme Waterproof and
SumptuousTwoToneEyeOpeningmascara,andthelaunchofPureColorPaintPots.
EsteLaudersTMEfor2012is$12.7million,upfrom$3.7millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E21

4E22

EyeMakeup

Procter & Gamble moves down to the third position in the category as sales slide down
4.6%in2012to$290millionfrom$304millionin2011.
Themarketersshareofthecategoryalsodeclinesfrom11.6%in2011to10.7%in2012.
ThenewlaunchesinmascarathatincludetheLashBlastfranchiseperformwellforthe
Covergirlbrandbutsalesdonotexceedthefalloutfromtheeyeshadowandeyeliner
sales decline. The brand does not compete in the eyebrow category, which fuels
growthformanymarketersin2012.
Despite having an impressive cast of megastar spokesmodels including singers Taylor
SwiftandPink,Covergirldoesnothavecomparablenewproductlaunchestopromote
in 2012. However, the marketer appears to be rectifying the situation with new
productsreleasesinearly2013.
Procter & Gamble is the secondleading advertiser in the category with TME of
$74.2millionin2012,down27%from$101.6millioninTMEin2011.Twothirdsofthe
TMEsupportthebrandsmascaraproducts.

Revlonranksfourthin2012,with7.5%ofthecategoryssales.
Salesforthemarketerare$204millionin2012,adeclineof1.4%from$207millionin
2011.ThemarketershrinksitsTMEfrom$52.2millionin2011to$31.5millionin2012.
TheRevlonbrandssalesare$133millionin2012,flatfrom2011.
Revlonsbestperformingsegmentiseyeshadowsin2012.
TME to support the eye shadow business is approximately $8 million in 2012. The
mascarabusinessissupportedwithapproximately$9.5millioninTMEin2012.
Almayssalesdecline4.1%from2011withsalesof$71millionin2012.
Almayissupportedwith$11.6millioninTMEfortheeyeshadowsegment,inparticular,
products within the Intense IColor franchise, and, $1.8 million in TME is used to
supportitsAlmayOneCoatGetUp&Growmascara.

MaryKayisthefifthleadingeyemakeupmarketerwithacategoryshareof5.2%andsales
of$141millionin2012,up6.8%.
Mary Kays growth is recognized due to several successful launches including its lash
primerandbrowbuilder,creameyeshadowpots,andLashLoveWaterproofmascara.
The waterproof version is added in 2012 as an extension of the successful launch of
LashLovein2011.
Additionally, the gel eyeliner, although not new, performs well in the second half of
2012.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Department stores and specialty stores gain at the expense of drug stores, as consumers
seek out makeup artist lines and luxury brands on one end of the spectrum and budget
brands,suchasEyesLipsFace,Rimmel,andWetNWildbrandsatmassmerchandisers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

EyeMakeup

Table4E13:ManufacturersSalesofEyeMakeupinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

29

29

Departmentstores

25

26

Drugstores

20

19

Directsales

15

14

Specialtystores

Foodstores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Massbrandscontinuetouseheavyadvertising,pricingdiscounts,andcouponstopromote
products.
The leading mass brands, such as Maybelline, LOral, and Revlon, offer discount
coupons,andcontinuetopushcouponsanddiscountstosmartphonesthroughtheir
retailpartnerships.
MostmarketersarenowusingsocialmediasitesincludingFacebook,Twitter,YouTube,
Pinterest, and Tumblr to promote their brands and expand awareness among
consumers.
Massmarketerswebsitesfeaturehowtosectionssothatbuyerscanobtainthelookon
themodelintheadvertisement.

Thetopmassbrandsareoftenbackedbycelebrityendorsements.
TheadvertisingcampaignforCovergirlusesactress,SofiaVergaraforitsLashBlast24
hr mascara. Covergirl also uses singer Taylor Swift for its Lash Blast Volume mascara
andforitsEyeEnhancersandPerfectPointPlusLinerproducts.
AlmaycontinuestouseactressKateHudsoninitsadvertisements.
BothLOralandRevlonusesupermodelsfortheireyemakeupadvertisements.

Table4E14:CouponingActivityforEyeMakeupintheUnitedStates,2012
Company/division

Brand

Promotion

LOral

LOralParis

Buyonegetonehalfoff

LOral

Maybelline

Save$2.00withthepurchaseofPeoplemagazineand
VolumExpresstheMegaPlushMascara

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

$2.00offontwo24HRmascaraand/orOutlastlipcolor

Shiseido

Nars

20%offontotalorderfortwodaysstartingCyberMonday

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E23

4E24

EyeMakeup

Luxury brands in the eye makeup category trust sales personnel at beauty counters to
promote products by way of makeup application and free trial. Retailers typically use in
storeactivitiestodrawconsumerstocounters.
Promotionalactivityisusuallyservedthroughgiftwithpurchase(GWP)andpurchase
withpurchase (PWP) promotions as key incentives to purchase, although marketers
continuetoincreasesamplingeffortsatcounterandonlinetominimizeGWPevents.
Moretraditionaladvertisingisseenfromthosewhorarelyorneveradvertisedbefore
includingBobbiBrown, whosigned actress,KatieHolmestobeitsfirst evercelebrity
spokesperson.OthersincludeChantecaille,Nars,andMAC.
Retailers and marketers are using applications in smart phones and sending emails
directlytoconsumerstopromotetheirproductsandspecialevents.
Most luxury brands websites offer free shipping on orders above $50.00; however,
Este Lauder offers free shipping and returns, and Clinique offers free standard
shipping.BobbiBrownoffersfreereturnsonfoundation,concealers,andpowders.
Many marketers are participating in friends and family events with 20% off coupons
that in the past have usually been used for stores fashion items excluding beauty
products.
Marketersareincreasingtheirsamplingeffortsespeciallywithonlineorders.

Direct marketerscontinue to rely on sales consultants to promote their products,but are


increasinglyutilizingothervehiclesincludingprintandtelevisionadvertising.
Mary Kay is one of the leading direct marketers whose success in 2012 can be
attributedtosalesrepresentativesholdingpartiestopromoteratherthansellingone
toone.
VictoriaJacksonisnolongersoldonGuthyRenkerswebsiteorontelevision.
Avon continues to falter, as key executives struggle to get the U.S business back on
track.

TMEsforthecategorydecrease9.5%to$378.5millionin2012from$418.4millionin2011.
Massbrandsmakeupapproximately85%ofTMEin2012.
LOralhasthehighestTMEintheeyemakeupcategory,with$204.2millionin2012,
flatfrom2011.
Procter&Gamble,thesecondlargestadvertiserinthecategorywithonlyitsCovergirl
brand,hasadvertisingexpendituresof$74.2millionin2012,downfrom$101.6million
in2011.
Revlon,adistantthird,decreasesitsTMEto$31.5millionin2012,from$52.2millionin
2011.

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreportandonthedatabase.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

EyeMakeup

OUTLOOK

Sales of the eye makeup category are expected to grow reasonably through 2017, and
continueasthesecondlargestmakeupcategory.
The category will see an uptick in television media spending although it decreases in
2012.
Eyemakeupwillcontinuetoseemorepromotionalmarketingviasocialmediaoutlets
byallmarketers.
Addedbenefitstoeyeshadowsandmascaraswilllikelycontinue.
Budgetbrandsinthemassmarketareforecasttocapitalizeonsuccessfullaunchesin
theluxuryspacebybringingfreshnesstothemassmarket.

Mascaraswillcontinuetobethemostsoughtaftereyemakeupproductbyconsumers.
Mascara is a staple and each one offers something different whether thickening,
curling,orlengtheningandisforeseentogrow.
From fashion runways to Grammy winner Adele, the quest for long, thick, and full
lasheswillnotfadeamongwomen.
Thebrushandfibertechnologywillreignfrom2012andthroughtheforecastperiod.
Marketerswillcontinuetoinnovateonthebrushtechnology,withenhancedproduct
formulations,whichmayincludebenefits,suchaslashbuilding,eyelashtreatments,or
primerstodrivesalesanddemandahigherpricepointeveninthemasstradeclass.
Additionally,productsthatincorporatebenefits,suchashairgrowth,orinnovativeskin
care ingredients are likely to foster new growth. Further benefits, such as quicker
dryingtimeandheat/smearresistant,arelikelytocontributetosalesgrowth.

Eye shadow products are forecast to grow almost as fast as mascaras, as women
increasinglyexperimentandaddmorecolortotheirwardrobeofeyeshadows.
Creamy, creaseresistant, long lasting, easytoapply shadows are expected as more
marketersaddtotheirproductlines.Thissingleshadowproductisprojectedtodrive
sales during the forecast period. Also applications, such tubes, sticks, or pots, are
expectedtoincreaseinpopularity.
Marketersareexpectedtolaunchnew,limitededitioneyeshadowcollectionstoadd
incrementalsalesthroughouttheyearandtocreateexcitement.
Eye shadow palettes are forecast to continue to be popular as consumers enjoy the
value proposition, and as marketers include other benefittype products, such as
primers,whichareanticipatedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.
Newformulationsand deliverymechanismswillcontinuetofuelsales intheeyeliner
segment.
Newshadesincludingglittereyelinersarepredictedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.
New technology and new shades are expected to continue to drive sales in the
eyebrowcategory,aswellascapturemoreconsumersastheyaddeyebrowmakeupto
theirregimen.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E25

4E26

EyeMakeup

Salesofeyemakeupareexpectedtogrowat aCAGRof3.1%,reaching$3,160millionby
2017,upfrom$2,709millionin2012.

Table4E15:ForecastManufacturersSalesofEyeMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2012to2017

$Million

Producttype

2012

2017

Mascaras

1,382

1,615

Eyeshadows

677

Allothera

650

%Oftotal

2012

2017

CAGR,%

51.0

51.1

3.2

783

25.0

24.8

3.0

762

24.0

24.1

3.2

Total
2,709
3,160

aIncludeseyelinersandeyebrowproducts.

100.0

100.0

3.1

Duringtheforecastperiod,unitsalesofeyemakeupproductsareexpectedtoincreaseata
CAGRof4.4%from524.9millionpackagesin2012to650.8millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

FACEMAKEUP

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Category sales for face makeup grow 3.7% in 2012 to reach $2,909 million at the
manufacturerslevel,whichisslowerthanthe5.6%growthexhibitedin2011.
Facemakeupisthelargestmakeupcategory,with38.0%ofthetotalmakeupproduct
classsalesin2012.

Saleshaveincreasedatcompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.0%since2007.

Table4E16:HistoricalSalesofFaceMakeupinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

2,507

2008

2,537

1.2

2009

2,549

0.4

2010

2,655

4.2

2011

2,804

5.6

2012

2,909

3.7

Mass products contribute to most sales within the face makeup category in 2012, with
42.1%oftotalcategoryssales.Themasstradeclass,up3.3%,barelymaintainspacewith
thetotalcategorysgrowthof3.7%in2012.
Theluxurytradeclassfollowsasthesecondleadingtradeclassin2012,with37.4%of
totalfacemakeupsales.Theluxurytradeclassgrows7.5%toreachto$1,087millionin
2012, from $1,011million in 2011. Sales outpace all major trade classes as makeup
artistbrandsandhigherendbrandsoutperformthetradeclassgrowth.
Directsalesisthethirdlargesttradeclasswithsalesestimatedat$538millionin2012,
down 2.4% from $551 million in 2011. Mary Kay is the largest brand to perform
positivelyinthistradeclassin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E28

FaceMakeup

Makeupbases,thelargestsegment,continuetocontributetotheoverallcategorysgrowth,
withsalesreaching$2,042millionin2012,up4.0%from$1,960millionin2011.

Newlaunchesinfoundationsaswellasanotheryearofaboveoverallcategorygrowthfor
concealersarethedrivingfactorbehindthegrowthinfacemakeupsales.Concealersales
areup6.8%fueledmostlybyluxurybrandsandlesswithinthemasstradeclass.
Topluxurybrands,includingbutnotlimitedto,MAC,Clinique,BobbiBrownCosmetics,
and Laura Mercier, drive growth in the luxury class, while top mass brands, such as
LOral, Maybelline, and budget brand Eyes Lips Face all grow concealer sales
dramatically.

Table4E17:ManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

Tradeclass/brand

Company

$Million

MASS

2011

2012

%Oftradeclass

2011

%Oftotal
2011

2012

Covergirl

Procter&Gamble

335

328

28.3

26.8

11.9

11.3

Maybelline

LOral

208

235

17.6

19.2

7.4

8.1

LOralParis

LOral

175

188

14.8

15.4

6.2

6.5

Revlon

Revlon

107

105

9.0

8.6

3.8

3.6

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

72

75

6.1

6.1

2.6

2.6

PhysiciansFormula

PhysiciansFormula

61

62

5.1

5.1

2.2

2.1

Almay

Revlon

59

58

5.1

5.1

2.2

2.1

Wet'N'Wildr

Markwins

24

28

2.0

2.3

0.9

1.0

Rimmel

Coty

25

26

2.1

2.1

0.9

0.9

NYCNewYorkColorr

Coty

13

14

1.1

1.1

0.5

0.5

EyesLipFace

TSGConsumer
Partners

10

0.5

0.8

0.2

0.3

SallyHansen

Coty

0.6

0.6

0.2

0.2

89

86

7.5

7.0

3.2

3.0

100.0

100.0

42.3

42.1

Allother

Totalr

1,185

1,224

LUXURY

Clinique

EsteLauder

185

196

18.3

18.0

6.6

6.7

MAC

EsteLauder

158

173

15.6

15.9

5.6

5.9

Lancme

LOral

112

117

11.1

10.8

4.2

4.2

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

113

115

11.2

10.6

4.0

4.0

Chanel

Chanel

42

46

4.2

4.2

1.5

1.6

BobbiBrown

EsteLauder

40

44

4.0

4.0

1.4

1.5

LauraMercier

Alticor

33

37

3.3

3.4

1.2

1.3

BeneFit

LVMH

30

32

3.0

2.9

1.1

1.1

Shiseido

Shiseido

26

28

2.6

2.6

0.9

1.0

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

2012

4E29

FaceMakeup

Table4E17:ManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Tradeclass/brand

Company

LUXURY(Continued)

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

ChristianDior

LVMH

21

23

2.1

2.1

0.7

0.8

FashionFair

JohnsonPublishing

20

20

2.0

1.8

0.7

0.7

Clarins

Clarins

18

19

1.8

1.7

0.6

0.6

Origins

EsteLauder

17

18

1.7

1.7

0.6

0.6

Nars

Shiseido

14

17

1.4

1.6

0.5

0.6

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

14

14

1.4

1.4

0.5

0.5

TrishMcEvoy

TrishMcEvoy

12

13

1.2

1.2

0.4

0.4

SmashboxBeauty

SmashBoxBeauty
Cosmetics

11

12

1.1

1.1

0.4

0.4

Dermablend

LOral

0.7

0.6

0.2

0.2

Prescriptivesa

EsteLauder

111

119

11.0

10.9

5.6

5.9

1,011

1,087

100.0

100.0

36.1

37.4

Allotherr
Totalr
DIRECTSALES

BareEscentuals

Shiseido

199

192

36.1

35.7

7.1

6.6

MaryKay

MaryKay

166

178

30.1

33.1

5.9

6.1

Avon

Avon

97

91

17.6

16.9

3.5

3.1

SheerCover

GuthyRenker

40

39

7.3

7.2

1.4

1.3

Artistry

Alticor

13

13

2.4

2.4

0.5

0.4

Mark

Avon

13

11

2.4

2.2

0.5

0.4

VictoriaJackson

VictoriaJackson
Cosmetics

13

2.4

2.2

0.5

0.1

10

10

1.8

1.9

0.4

0.3

551

538

100.0

100.0

19.7

18.5

Allother
Total
SPECIALTY

VictoriasSecret

LimitedBrands

14

14

29.9

28.6

0.5

0.5

MerleNormanr

MerleNorman

8.3

8.2

0.1

0.1

Privatelabelr

20

22

42.6

44.9

0.7

0.8

Allotherr

19.2

18.4

0.3

0.3

47

49

100.0

100.0

1.7

1.7

70.0

63.6

0.3

0.3

30.0

36.4

0.1

0.1

100.0

0.4

0.4

100.0

100.0

Totalr
PROFESSIONAL
Aveda

EsteLauder

Allother

Total

10

11

TOTALr

2,804

2,909

100.0

aDiscontinued.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E30

FaceMakeup

Unitsales

Unitvolumeinthecategorygrowsto421.4millionpackagesin2012,upfrom405.2million
packagesin2011.
Unitsgrowsimilartoretailvolume.

Retailsales

Retail sales of the face makeup category are estimated at $4,470million, up 3.7% from
$4,309millionin2011.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

All face makeup product types contribute to the growth of the category. The luxury class
outperforms all other classes. Complexion products continue to be an important
componentinwomensmakeupregimenastheystriveforaflawlessfinish.
Marketersareusingwords,suchasnudeornakedtoconveythemessageofdelivering
thatflawlessfinish.Benefitlaunchesafoundationproductwithjustthatinthename,
HelloFlawlessOxygenWow.
Liquid foundations continue to be popular in 2012 after several years of powder
minerals at the forefront. Whipped or mousse formulas in foundations make a
comebackin2012.
Mostmarketersincludeaprimerintheirproductmixtoobtainlongerlastingandeven
application,fuelingadditionalsales.
Sunprotectionandantiagingbenefitsinmakeupbasesandpowdersareexpectedin
2012asmostmarketersincorporatethebenefitsorSPFfactorintheproductsname.
Forexample,LOralsVisibleLiftRepairAbsoluteAgeReversingFoundationSPF16.
Concealers grow the fastest in 2012 compared to other face products. There is
excitement in the category with new launches featuring new formulas and/or
applicators. Examples are LOrals True Match Crayon Concealer and YSL Beautes
ToucheEclatRadiantTouch.
Shadematchingprogramsamongmassmarketerscontributetothegrowthinthetrade
class. Luxury brands touted the sheer number of shades in their respective lines to
accommodateallskintones.
Blushersarealsodoingverywellcomparedtoprioryearsasbrandscomeoutwithnew
formats including variation of creams, sticks, liquid, and new and improved powder
formulas. Luxury brands such as Benefit launch lip and cheek kits, while other luxury
brands update their pressed blushers with beautiful designs pressed in powder. It is
expectedthatmorebrandswillusedesignsintheirpressedblushcompactstotempt
womenintobuyingbeautifulblushers.Luminousandsheerarewordsmarketersuseto
describethenewblushers.
The recurring theme or buzzwords used by all brands include flawless perfection,
weightlessandbreathable,lightweightandfresh,aswellascomfortableandhydrating.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

FaceMakeup

Notablenewproducts

Table4E18:SelectNewFaceMakeupProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Clarins

Clarins

EverlastingCompactFoundationSPF15.Awetanddrytexturewhichissaid
toprovideaflawlessfinishandlasts15hours

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

LongWearEvenFinishCompactFoundation

EsteLauder

Clinique

PoreRefiningSolutionsInstantPerfectingMakeup

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

DoubleWearStayInPlacePowder

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

DoubleWearStayInPlaceConcealerSPF10

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

PureColorSensuousRouge

EsteLauder

MAC

MineralizeBlush&Highlighter

EsteLauder

MAC

MatchmasterFoundationSPF15

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

HealthySkinBrighteningEyePerfectorconcealer

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

ShineControlPrimer

Johnson&Johnson

Neutrogena

ShineControlMakeup

LOral

Lancme

TeintIdoleUltra24Hfoundation

LOral

Lancme

TranslucenceMattifyingSilkyPressedPowder

LOral

LOralParis

VisibleLiftSerumAbsoluteConcealer

LOral

LOralParis

VisibleLiftRepairAbsoluteAgeReversingFoundationSPF16

LOral

LOralParis

TrueMatchLumiHealthyLuminousMakeup

LOral

LOralParis

TrueMatchSuperBlendableMakeup

LOral

LOralParis

TrueMatchCrayonConcealer

LOral

Maybelline

DreamBouncyBlush

LOral

Maybelline

NudeAirfoamMakeup

LOral

UrbanDecay

NakedSkinWeightlessUltraDefinitionLiquidMakeup

LOral

YSLBeaute

LeTeintToucheclatfoundation

LOral

YSLBeaute

ToucheclatRadiantTouchconcealer

LVMH

ChristianDior

DiorskinNudefoundation

LVMH

MakeUpForEver

HDComplexionStarterKit

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

Covergirl&OlayPressedPowder

Revlon

Revlon

NearlyNakedFoundation

Revlon

Revlon

PhotoreadyAirbrushMousseMakeup

Revlon

Revlon

ColorstayWhippedCremeMakeup

Shiseido

BareEscentuals

ReadySPF20Foundation

Shiseido

BareEscentuals

CorrectingConcealer

TarteCosmetics

TarteCosmetics

MaracujaFoundation

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E31

4E32

FaceMakeup

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Makeupbasescontinuetobethelargestsegmentinthefacemakeupcategorywith4.0%
growthin2012.
The segments growth can be attributed to consumers continued demand for
complexionperfection,aswellasmarketersnewlaunchesinprimers,makeupbases,
andconcealers,toachievethislook.
Facepowder,althoughthesmallestoftheproducttypes,growsthefastestin2012,up
5.1%.Thisisfueledbynewlauncheswithneworimprovedformulations,marketingof
newskincarebenefits,orclaimsforflawlessorvelvetyfinish.

Table4E19:ManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

Producttype
Makeupbases
Blushers
Facepowders
Totalr

rRestated.

$Million
2011
2012
1,773
1,844
462
476
451
474
2,804
2,909

%Oftotal
2011
2012
63.0
63.4
16.5
16.4
16.1
16.3
100.0
100.0

Change,%
4.0
3.0
5.1
3.7

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4E20:ManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

Company
LOralr
EsteLauder
Procter&Gamble
Shiseido
MaryKay
Revlon
Avon
Allotherr
Totalr

rRestated.

$Million
2011
2012
529
584
531
565
335
328
239
237
166
178
166
163
110
103
222
228
2,804
2,909

%Oftotal
2011
2012
18.9
20.1
18.9
19.4
11.9
11.3
8.5
8.1
5.9
6.1
5.9
5.6
3.9
3.5
7.9
7.8
100.0
100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

Change,%
10.4
6.4
(2.1)
(0.8)
7.2
(1.8)
(6.4)
2.7
3.7

FaceMakeup

LOraltakesthetopspotawayfromEsteLauderin2012with20.1%oftotalcategorys
salesin2012.
Sales for LOral grow 10.4% to reach $584million in 2012, up from $529million in
2011. Sales for the company now include sales from Urban Decay, a brand the
companyacquiresfromprivateequityfirmCastaneaPartnersinNovember2012.
LOralsupportsitsfacemakeupbrandsbyincreasingitsadvertisingexpensesby9.4%
to$195.2million,upfrom$178.3millionin2011.
LOralcompetesinthefacemakeupcategorywithLOralParis,Maybelline,Lancme,
UrbandDecay,YSLBeaute,andDermablendbrands.WiththeexceptionofDermablend,
allbrandscontributetothegrowthofthecompany.
Thecompanysmassbrands,MaybellineandLOralParisanditsnewlyacquiredbrand,
UrbanDecay,drivethemajorityofgrowthin2012withdollargainsof13.0%,7.4%,and
52.9%,respectively.
Maybellinecontinuestobetheleadingbrandforthecompanyin2012,with salesof
$235million,upfrom$208millionin2011.
Maybellinesgrowthisdrivenbyallfacemakeupcategories.Concealersalesisfollowed
by makeup bases, and blush sales. New launches, such as Instant Age Rewind Eraser
Dark Spot Concealer + Treatment, Dream Nude Airfoam makeup, and Dream Bouncy
blushfuelgrowth.
LOralsupportsMaybellinesDreamlineofproductswithapproximately$65millionin
traceablemediaexpenditures(TME)in2012.
LOral supports Maybellines Instant Age Rewind line of face products with
approximately$84millioninTMEin2012.
LOral reduces its advertising for its Maybelline Fit Me line from $63 million in TME
duringitslaunchin2011to$7.5millionin2012.
SalesofLOralParisareestimatedat$188millionin2012,up7.4%from$175million
in2011.
LOralParisgrowthisachievedbynewlaunchactivitiesespeciallyinthemakeupbase
categoryasarangeofnewproductshitshelvesin2012.Theseproductsarewithinthe
TrueMatchandVisibleLiftproductlines.
TME for the LOral Paris brand increases in 2012 to $91 million, same as in 2010.
However, TME had dipped in 2011 to $75 million. Approximately, 88% of the dollars
aresplitbetweenpromotingtheTrueMatchandVisibleliftmakeuplinesandcloseto
10%spentontheMagicLumilineoffaceproducts.
TheluxurybrandLancmeachievessalesof$117million,up7.4%from$112millionin
2011. Sales increase due to continuing success of existing products, and to a lessor
extentnewlaunches.Lancmeissupportedwithapproximately$11.5millioninTMEin
2012, up 10% from 2011. These dollars are in support of Teint Idole Ultra 24H
foundation,TeintMiraclefoundation,andlesssoonBlushSubtil.
TheluxurybrandsYSLBeauteandGiorgioArmaniMaestroaresupportedbyclosetoa
halfamilliondollarseach,tosupporttheTouceEclatandliquidfoundationproducts
respectively.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E33

4E34

FaceMakeup

Este Lauder moves down to second position in the face makeup category in 2012 even
thoughthecompanyincreasesitscategorysharefrom18.9%in2011to19.4%in2012.
SalesofEsteLaudertotal$565millionin2012,up6.4%from$531millionin2011.
TheEsteLauderCompaniesInc.increasesitsadvertisingexpensesto$53.7millionin
2012, up from $34.1million in 2011. Close to 95% of advertising dollars is used to
support its Clinique and Este Lauder brands. Products specifically supported include
CliniquesEvenBetterandStayMatteOilFreefoundationandEsteLaudersDouble
WearandInvisiblefoundationlines.Lessthan1%ofadvertisingexpenditureisusedto
supporttheAerinline,whichincludesblushandlipstick.
Withtheexceptionofthenamesakebrand,EsteLauder,thecompanysluxurybrands
outperformthemarket.Productlaunchesforthebrandin2012arenotenoughtofuel
brandsalesbeyondthe1.8%growth.
The companys two leading brandsMAC and Cliniqueaccount for 65.3% of Este
Lauderstotalfacemakeupsalesin2012.
Thetopperformingbrandsinthecompanysportfolioin2012includeMAC,up9.5%;
Bobbi Brown, up 10.0%; and Smashbox Beauty, up 9.1%. Advertising supports Bobbi
BrownsfoundationandconcealerkitandSmashboxsCameraReadyFoundationand
PhotoFinishFoundationPrimer.
Thenamesakebrand,EsteLauder,hasaninnovativemarketingcampaigncobranding
with the television show, Madmen, to promote a collection including limited edition
lipstickandcrmerouge.Thebrandsupportedthecollectionwithhalfmilliondollarsin
advertising.
In 2012, sales for Aveda and BeautyBank brands remain flat. BeautyBank, sold
exclusivelyatKohls,withbrandsincludingFlirtandAmericanBeautyfacecompetition
fromnewbrand,VeraWang,thatentersKohlsin2012,andElle,whichisalsosoldat
Kohls.

Procter&Gambleisthethirdleadingmarketerinthefacemakeupcategory,withsalesat
$328millionin2012,down2.1%from$335millionin2011.
Procter&GamblecompetesinthemasstradeclasswithitsCovergirlbrandandwithits
Dolce & Gabbana line within the luxury trade class. Dolce & Gabbanas sales are not
itemizedinthisreport.
Covergirlscategorysharedeclinesslightlyfrom11.9%in2011to11.3%ofsalesin2012,
assalesdeclineacrossallproductcategoriesexceptpowder,whichisfueledbyanew
product,Covergirl&OlayPressedPowder.
In 2012, Procter & Gamble decreases its advertising budget by 8% down to
$87.1million.Approximately68%ofTMEisusedtopromoteCovergirlandOlaySimply
AgelessandToneRehab2in1foundationproducts.CovergirlCleanMakeupandTru
Blendfoundationissupportedbycloseto$24millioninadvertising.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

FaceMakeup

Shiseidoisthefourthleadingfacemakeupmarketerin2012.
Itscategorysharedeclinesfrom8.5%in2011to8.1%in2012.
Salestotal$237millionin2012,downslightlyfrom$239millionin2011.
TheBareEscentualsbrandcontributes$192millioninsalestothecompanyin2012,
butsalesdecline3.5%assalesdipacrossallcategories.
Shiseido increases its TME by 59% for its Bare Escentuals Bare Minerals brand to
approximately $13.2million in 2012. Onequarter of this is used to promote the new
launch of Ready foundation. The namesake brand does not receive TME in 2012;
however,thecompanysotherluxurybrand,CleDePeauBeaute,receivescloseto2%
ofthecompanysTME.
Bare Escentuals launches a new cream foundation, Ready SPF 20 and a correcting
concealer,butsalesarenotenoughtocompensateforthedropinsalesfromexisting
productsinthecategory.
Nars, the makeup artist brand, outperforms other brands within Shiseidos portfolio,
with sales reaching $17million in 2012, up 21.4% from $14million in 2011. Sales are
drivenbythebrandsblushandbronzingpowder.
The Shiseido brand outpaces the overall market performance, up 7.7% to reach
$28million in sales in 2012, up from $26 million in 2011. The brand introduces new
foundationsandlimitededitioncompactpowder.

Mary Kay is the fifthleading marketer in the face makeup category in 2012. In 2011, the
companytiedwithRevlonforfifthplace.
MaryKayssalesreach$178millionin2012,up7.2%from$166millionin2011.Sales
continue to flourish from the companys 2011 launch of Time Wise Luminous and
Mattefoundations.
Revlonisthesixthleadingmarketerinthefacemakeupcategory.
The Revlon brands sales are estimated to be $107million in 2012, down 1.9% from
2011.
RevlonalsocompetesinthemassmarketwithitsAlmaybrand.
Almays sales decline from $59 million in 2011 to $58 million in 2012. Almays sales
declineacrossallcategoriesin2012.
TMEdecreases13%to$44.9millionin2012forboththeRevlonandtheAlmaybrands.
Justover$14millionoftheTMEisusedtopromoteAlmaysSmartShadeandWakeUp
foundations. The Revlon brands TME promotes its Colorstay Foundations (whipped
andliquid),AgeDefyingwithDNAAdvantagefoundation,andPhotoreadyfoundations
(whippedandliquid).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E35

4E36

FaceMakeup

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Department stores continue to be the most soughtafter shopping destination for face
makeup as personal consultation and shade matching is a key component for trial and
purchase.
Marketers of mass brands continue to evolve ways in which women can obtain the
perfectshadeviavirtualonlineconsultants,matchingdepartmentstorebrandshades
toproductsintheirmassline.
Some marketers provide free returns on face makeup products when purchased
throughtheInternet.
Specialty stores, such as Ulta and Sephora, continue to obtain more customers with
expandeddistribution.

Table4E21:ManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStates
byRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Departmentstores

30

30

Massmerchandisers

24

24

Drugstores

19

18

Directsales

16

15

Specialtystores

10

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Advertisingandpromotionforfacemakeupproductsvarybytradeclass.
Socialmediamarketingisnowpartofthemarketingmixforallmarketers,nomatter
wheretheproductissold.
ConsumerscanfollowtheirfavoritebrandviaFaceBook,Twitter,and/orTumblr.
Most marketers also have a link on their brands website to YouTube, as well as
Pinterest.Consumerscanwatchhowtovideosandfindthelatesttrendscomealiveby
watching the brands makeup artists applying product to the brands spokesmodels.
ConsumerscanusePinteresttosharethelatestlooksand/orproducts.
Marketers are also using loyalty programs in order to obtain information about their
customersandtotrackpurchasesasawaytogetimmediatefeedbackfromtheirmost
loyalfans.
Blogs continue to be popular both for makeup enthusiasts to share new products,
review products, share coupons, giftwithpurchase (GWP) programs, and Internet
shippingpromotions.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

FaceMakeup

Massbrandstypicallyrelyontheprintandtelevisionmedia,coupons,instoredisplays,and
pricediscounts.
TMEformassbrandsareestimatedtobeapproximately$335millionin2012withjust
underhalfallocatedtotelevision.
Promotional activities for mass brands commonly include pricing discounts and
couponseitherfromthemanufacturerinweeklynewspapersoratlocalretailstores.
Many mass marketers ask the consumer to sign up to its club in order to receive
couponsviaitswebsite.
Mostmassretailersinthedrugstoreandmassmerchandiserchannelsfrequentlyrun
promotionsofferingmakeupproductsatbuyonegetonefreeorbuyonegetone
halfoff.
Fashionmagazinesareoneofthepreferredformsofadvertisingforthefacemakeup
category.Magazinesarealsousedtoprovidesamplesofnewproductsforconsumers
totry.
Brands,suchasCovergirl,usetheirwebsitetohelpmatchfoundationshades.Visitors
can choose a department store brand and the site will provide the Covergirl product
thatmatchesthatproduct.LOrealParisusesavirtualconsultationtotakethevisitor
step by step to provide the right product color and texture for her skin type and
solutionneed.
Procter&GambleusesseveralmediapersonalitiestopromoteitsCovergirlbrand.The
latestspokespeopleincludesingersJanelleMonaeandPink.

Luxury brands typically use instore activities to promote products. However, 2012 sees
muchmoreadvertisingthroughfashionmagazines.
Special events, free makeovers, and consultations continue to be the mainstay for
bringingconsumerstothebeautycountersindepartmentstores.
Retailerscontinuetocarveoutspacetoshowcasesingleitemsacrossallbrandsnear
thecashregistertogetvisitorstoeithertrynewproductsinalargesamplesizeorto
purchaseitemsacrossbrandsthattheymayuseonthego.
RetailerssuchasSephorauseendcapsthatchangemonthlyintheirstorestoshowcase
favoriteand/orhotitems.
Luxurybrandsspend$104millioninTMEin2012.Thesplitisapproximately60%40%,
withthemajorityusedinprintandtheremainderontelevision.
GWPandpurchasewithpurchase(PWP)promotionscontinuetobeusedthroughout
theyeartoshowcasetopsellersandtoprovideasamplingvehiclefornewproductsas
wellasdrawwomentothecounter.
Luxury marketers offer some form of discount or free shipping with a minimum
purchasemadeonthecompanyswebsite.Marketersareincreasinglyluringwomento
buyandreceivefreesampleswhentheyorderonline.
In addition to social media, specialty marketers typically use instore displays, and
activitiestodriveconsumerstoselfservedisplays.
Directmarketerscontinuetorelyontheirsalesrepresentatives,socialmediasites,and
catalogstopromoteproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E37

4E38

FaceMakeup

Table4E22:SelectExamplesofCouponingActivityforFaceMakeupintheUnitedStates,2012
Company/division

Brand

Promotion

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

Pickthreesamplesofconcealer,mascara,orBBcreamandfree
shippingwithminimum$65purchase.Freereturnson
foundation,concealer,orpowder.

LOral

LOralParis

$1.00offonanyLOralproduct

LOral

LOralParis

TrueMatchLumifoundationfeaturedinPeoplemagazinethat
teamsupwithamazon.com.Ifyoupurchaseandturninthe
receiptofafeaturedproduct,amazon.comwouldsendouta
$10.00giftcardtothepurchaser

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

Save$1.00onanyCovergirlproduct

Revlon

Revlon

Save$2.00onanyRevlonPhotoReadyFaceProduct

TheTMEforthefacemakeupcategoryincreasesby1.5%,reaching$437.5millionin2012,
upfrom$430.9millionin2011.
LOral is the leading advertiser in the face makeup category with TME of
$195.2millionin2012,up9.4%from$178.3millionin2011.
Procter&GamblefollowsinsecondplacewithaTMEof$87.1million,down8%from
$95millionin2011.
LuxurymarketerEsteLaudermovesaboveRevlontothirdplace.Itsupportsitsface
makeupbrandswithTMEof$53.7million,up57%from$34.1millionin2011.
Revlonisnowthefourthleadingadvertiser,withTMEof$44.9million,down8%from
$51.8millionin2011.

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreportandonthedatabase.

OUTLOOK

Sales of the face makeup category are anticipated to grow at a reasonable rate through
2017 based in part because beauty balms (tracked in facial treatments) are expected to
erodesomefoundationsalesacrossalltradeclasses,whileconcealersandprimersarelikely
tospursales.
Foundationswithmultipleskincarebenefits,aswellasbreathablefeelwilllikelydrive
sales,alongwithnewtechnologyinproductforms.
Mineral powder foundation must tout new benefits, formulas, or ingredients to
reignitethesegment.
As beauty balms currently do no mask all imperfections, it is expected that the
continuationofnewconcealerformatsandformulationswillhelpdrivegrowth.
Shadematchinginthemasstradeclassisforecasttobeprincipaltothehealthofthe
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

FaceMakeup

As consumers continue to seek complexion perfection with products that contain


beneficialornaturalskincareingredientsandareweightlesswhilematchingskintone,
thecategoryisexpectedtogrowatahealthyrate.
Inadditiontofoundation,itisexpectedthatadditionalproducts,suchasprimersand
concealerswillbesoughtafter.
It is anticipated that growth will come from two ends of the price spectrum: from
budgetbrands,suchasEyesLipsFace,toluxuryandmakeupartistbrands.
Budgetbrandsareexpectedtolaunchsophisticatedmakeupartisttypeproducts,such
asprimersduringtheforecastperiod.
Additionally, budget brands are marketing hightech ingredients in their packaging to
lure consumers to switch brands, and are expected to continue through the forecast
period.
As consumer confidence improves, consumers are expected to trade up to higher
priced products, as well as make multiple purchases instead of settling for one most
neededproduct.
MarketersareforecasttoincreaseTMEtosupporttheirbrands,aftercuttingwayback
duringtherecessionaryyears.
Massmarketersareexpectedtocontinuewithlargeadvertisingbudgetsandtheuseof
celebrity spokespersons to promote products. Moreover, brands which did not
advertise much or at all in the past have started to increase their print advertising.
ThesebrandsincludeMAC,LauraMercier,andBobbiBrown.BobbiBrown,forthefirst
time,hasacelebrityspokespersoninactressKatieHolmes.
Highlighting powders and sheer blushes are expected as more marketers outside the
nichebrandswillfollowsuittogetconsumersexcitedabouttheblushsegmentagain.
Face powders that provide additional benefits beyond setting makeup or reducing
shineareexpectedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.Itisexpectedthatpowderswith
light reflection or hydration benefits will help drive sales. Bronzers are expected to
drive sales as marketers extend the shade range and continue to showcase pressed
powdersinprismordesignformatstoobtainshelfappeal.
New blushes with skin care benefits and that are sheer are expected to drive sales.
New innovations in blushes are expected as well, such as those that aid with
hyperpigmentationorcontainhydratingproperties.
Marketers are expected to provide new variations to the traditional pressed powder
blushinforms,suchaswhippedcream,sticks,andliquidtints.Packagingofblushesis
expectedtonotonlybefunctionalbuttobepretty.
Socialmediasiteswillcontinuetohelpdrivesalesasconsumersshareproductreviews,
which can help new brands or products go viral. Video sites will also provide
customerswithtutorialsinordertoachievetheirdesiredlook.

Sales of the face makeup category are forecast to advance at a CAGR of 3.8% to
$3,509millionin2017,upfrom$2,909millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E39

4E40

FaceMakeup

Table4E23:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFaceMakeupintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2012to2017

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2012

2017

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Makeupbases

2,042

2,484

70.2

70.8

4.0

Facepowders

445

536

15.3

15.3

3.8

Blushers

422

489

14.5

13.9

3.0

2,909

3,509

100.0

100.0

3.8

Total

UnitsalesareexpectedtogrowataCAGRof2.5%from421.4millionpackagesin2012to
488.5millionpackagesby2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Categorysalesforlipsticksandlipglossesareclosetotheir2007levels,havingdeclinedata
negativecompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of0.3%since2007.

Table4E24:HistoricalSalesofLipsticksandLipGlosses
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,397

2008

1,311

(6.2)

2009

1,252

(4.5)

2010

1,248

(0.3)

2011

1,352

8.3

2012

1,377

1.8

Manufacturerssalesofthelipsticksandlipglossescategorygrowslowlyat1.8%in2012to
reach$1,377million.
Theslowgrowthrateisduetolacklustersalesinthelipglossandliplinersegments.
Overall,thelipsticksegmentperformswell.
Thebrandsintheluxuryclassfarebetterthanmassbrandsbothinlipstickandlipliner
sales.
Helpingtofuelsalesoflipsticksareinnovativeproductsthattoutlonglastingcolorand
added functionality, such as moisturizing and/or SPF benefits, along with attractive
packaging.
Nourishingingredients,suchasomega3andvitaminEorproductsenrichedwithargan
oiltoconditionandsoftenlips,arehighlightedinthemarketingmaterials.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E42

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Lipsticks and lip glosses remain an essential category within the makeup products class,
representing 18.0% of the total makeup in 2012, remaining relatively flat from 18.4% of
totalmakeupsalesin2011.
Saleswithinthemasstradeclassdecline2.2%to$538millionin2012.
Themassmarketcontributes39.1%ofsalestothecategory.
LOralisleadingmassmarketerwithbrandsMaybellineandLOralParis.Maybelline
representscloseto17%ofsalestothetradeclassandgrows7.1%in2012.
SalesfortheLOralParisbranddecline5.7%in2012despitenumerouslaunchesand
advertising. LOral Paris is one of the few mass brands that perform well in the lip
glosssegmentwithitsColourRichelipgloss,alongwithbrands,NYColorandRimmel.
It is likely that sales from LOral Paris new Caresse lipstick and Caresse Wet Shine
StainbyColourRichewillfuelsalesin2013.
Maybelline grows 7.1% in 2012, fueled by lipsticks including the Color Sensational
Vividslipstickline.Thebrandslipglossandliplinersalesareflatin2012.
LeadingbrandsRevlonandCovergirlbothdeclineinsalesin2012.SalesfromRevlons
launchofJustBittenKissableBalmStainarenotenoughtocompensatedeclinesinits
Colorstaylipsticklinein2012.CovergirlslaunchofBlastFlipstickBlendableDuolipstick
salesperformwellin2012butisnotenoughtooffsetsteepdeclineswithinitslipgloss
segment.

Manufacturerssalesintheluxurytradeclassgrowby8.1%toreach$494millionin2012,
contributing35.9%tothecategoryssales.TopbrandsincludingMAC,Clinique,andChanel
bringinthemostdollarstofuelgrowthin2012.
MACssignaturelipstickcontinuestoperformwell,asdoesitsnewlaunchesofSheen
Supremelipstick,ProLongwearLipPencil,andProLongwearLipglass.
CliniqueslaunchofChubbyStickspropelssalesforthebrand.
ThelaunchofRougeCocoShinelipstickdrivessalesfortheChanelbrand.

Salesinthespecialtysegmentremainflatin2012with$93millioninsales.
TheVictoriasSecretbrand,whichmakesup62.4%ofthetradeclass,declinesslightly
by1.7%in2012.
Privatelabel brands contribute close to 11% of sales to the specialty segment with
$10millionin2012,up11.1%from2011.TheseincludeUltaandSephorastorebrand
lipsticksandlipglosses.

Direct sales, which represent 17.9% of the categorys sales, are flat in 2012 with sales of
$246million.
MaryKayistheonlytopbrandtogrowsalesforthetradeclass.
AvoncontinuestofalterintheU.S.market,duetomajorchangesintopmanagement
andthefactthattheycontinuetoloseU.S.salesrepresentatives.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

4E43

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Table4E25:ManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

Tradeclass/brand

Company

MASS

Revlon

Revlon

125

123

22.7

22.9

9.2

8.9

Covergirl

Procter&Gamble

114

103

20.7

19.1

8.4

7.5

Maybelliner

L'Oral

85

91

15.5

16.9

6.3

6.6

L'OralParis

L'Oral

88

83

16.0

15.4

6.5

6.0

Rimmelr

Coty

19

26

3.5

4.8

1.4

1.9

Wet'N'Wildr

Markwins

22

25

4.0

4.6

1.6

1.8

BonneBell

BonneBell

20

18

3.6

3.3

1.5

1.3

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

13

2.4

1.7

1.0

0.7

EyesLipsFace

TSGConsumerPartners

1.5

1.3

0.6

0.5

Bari/BonBons/LoveMyLIps

Revlon

0.7

0.5

0.3

0.2

Prestige

PrestigeCosmetics

0.5

0.4

0.2

0.1

SallyHansen/NYC

Coty

Allother

$Million

%Oftradeclass

2011

2012

2011

2012

%Oftotal

2011

2012

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

48

47

8.7

8.7

3.6

3.4

100.0

100.0

Total

550

538

40.7

39.1

LUXURY

MAC

EsteLauder

80

88

17.5

17.8

5.9

6.4

Clinique

EsteLauder

43

47

9.4

9.5

3.2

3.4

Chanel

Chanel

32

35

7.0

7.1

2.4

2.5

Lancme

L'Oral

31

32

6.8

6.5

2.3

2.3

BobbiBrown

EsteLauder

30

32

6.6

6.5

2.2

2.3

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

28

29

6.1

5.9

2.1

2.1

UrbanDecay

L'Oral

20

22

4.4

4.5

1.5

1.6

ChristianDior

LVMH

14

15

3.1

3.0

1.0

1.1

Origins

EsteLauder

13

14

2.8

2.8

1.0

1.0

Nars

Shiseido

12

14

2.6

2.8

0.9

1.0

SmashboxBeauty

SmashboxBeauty
Cosmetics

10

11

2.2

2.2

0.7

0.8

LauraMercier

Amway

10

1.8

2.0

0.6

0.7

FashionFair

JohnsonPublishing

1.9

1.8

0.7

0.7

Shiseido

Shiseido

1.8

1.8

0.6

0.7

TrishMcEvoy

TrishMcEvoy

1.8

1.8

0.6

0.7

Benefit

LVMH

1.5

1.6

0.5

0.6

YSLBeaute

L'Oral

1.5

1.6

0.5

0.6

Stila

Stila

0.9

1.0

0.3

0.4

Clarins

Clarins

0.9

0.8

0.3

0.3

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

0.9

0.8

0.3

0.3

85

89

18.6

18.0

6.3

6.5

457

494

100.0

100.0

33.8

35.9

Allotherr
Totalr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E44

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Table4E25:ManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

Tradeclass/brand

Company

$Million

DIRECTSALES

MaryKay

MaryKay

Avon

Avon

BareEscentuals
Artistry

%Oftradeclass

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

107

110

43.5

44.7

7.9

8.0

85

85

34.6

34.6

6.3

6.2

Shiseido

18

18

7.3

7.3

1.3

1.3

Amway

11

11

4.5

4.5

0.8

0.8

Mark

Avon

10

4.1

3.7

0.7

0.7

VictoriaJackson

VictoriaJacksonCosmetics

1.2

0.4

0.2

0.1

12

12

4.9

4.9

0.9

0.9

246

246

100.0

100.0

18.2

17.9

Allother

2012

Total

SPECIALTY

VictoriasSecret

LimitedBrands

59

58

63.4

62.4

4.4

4.2

MerleNorman

MerleNorman

7.5

7.5

0.5

0.5

Privatelabel

10

9.7

10.8

0.7

0.7

Allother

18

18

19.4

19.4

1.3

1.3

100.0

100.0

Totalr

93

93

6.9

6.8

PROFESSIONAL

Aveda

EsteLauder

83.3

83.3

0.4

0.4

Allother

16.7

16.7

0.1

0.1

Total

100.0

100.0

0.4

0.4

TOTALr

1,352

1,377

100.0

100.0

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit volume sales of the lipsticks and lip glosses category increase 1.0% to 238million
packagesin2012,upfrom235millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesoflipsticksandlipglossestotalapproximately$2,119millionin2012,up2.4%
from$2,069millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

LipsticksandLipGlosses

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Lipsticksperformbetterthanlipglossesandliplinersmostduetofashiontrends,andthe
newformulasavailableonthemarket.
Formulasthatarehybridsoflipsticks,gloss,andstainsareattheforefront.
Longwearinglipsticksthatgoonsheerwithbuildablepigmentsarepopular.
Lipsticks that allow consumers to experiment to create their own look is seen in
advertisements,suchasCovergirlsBlastFlipstickthathascreamycolorononeendand
shimmerycolorontheflipside,withthebenefitofbuildablecolor,theintensityof
whichcanbecontrolledbytheconsumer.
Marketing descriptors of lip products in 2012, includes words such as velvet, deep,
plush, rich, concentrate, vibrant, luminous, sheer, nourishing, luxurious, lightweight,
stain,soft,liquid,intense,andcreamy.LOralParistapsintotheseastheyadvertise
Caresse Wet Shine Stain as a lip color that has it all: lipstain power, touch of shine,
hydratingcomfort,andfreshcolors.
True reds play an important role in 2012 to balance out sultry eyes and even
complexion.
Seasonalityplaysaroleintextureasmarketersshowdeep,rich,velvetytexturesforfall
in crimson, blackest purples, and deepmulled wine colors. And, for spring/summer,
colorsrangefromnudestopalepinksandtotheotherendofthespectrumtoneon.

Allthetopbrandsintheluxurytradeclassperformwellintheproductcategory.
MACcontributesthemostdollarstothetradeclass.Thesecondlargestcontributoris
CliniquewithitsChubbySticklaunch.
Makeupartistbrandsoverallleadthewaywiththehighestgrowth,up10.8%insales
combined.
Traditionalbrands,suchasLancmeandEsteLauderalsoperformwellwithLAbsolu
RougefromLancmeandEsteLaudersPureColorLipstick.

Lipglosssalesdeclinein2012.
Overall, consumers seem to be gravitating toward the new lipsticks as marketers
update thelongstanding tube to slimmer tubes that contain a formula that has high
shine.
Theluxuryclassfaresbetterthanthemasstradeclassduetomanynewlaunchesinthe
segmentfromtopbrandsincludingMAC,Chanel,andBobbiBrown.

Lip liners are up slightly in 2012. Once again, the luxury brands perform better than the
massbrandsin2012.
Higher price points in the luxury market play a significant role in driving sales in the
segment.
Luxury brands that help drive growth in the category include Chanel, Nars, Dior, YSL
Beaute,andUrbanDecay.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E45

4E46

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Notablenewproducts

Table4E26:SelectNewLipsticksandLipGlossesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Amway

LauraMercier

CrmeSmoothLipColor

Avon

Avon

ShineAttractLipstick

Chanel

Chanel

CocoRougeCocoShine

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

HighShimmerLipGloss

EsteLauder

Clinique

ChubbyStickMoisturizingLipColorBalm

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

PureColorLipstick

EsteLauder

MAC

ProLongwearLipPencil

EsteLauder

SmashboxCosmetics

BeLegendaryLipstick

LOral

Lancme

RougeinLove

LOral

LOralParis

ColorRichBalm

LOral

LOralParis

ColourCaressebyColourRichelipstick

LOral

LOralParis

ColourCaresseWetShineStainbyColourRichelipgloss

LOral

LOralParis

InfallibleLeGloss8hour

LOral

Maybelline

ColorsensationalVividslipstick

LOral

Maybelline

SuperStay10hrStainGloss

LOral

YSLBeaute

RougePurCoutureVenisaLevers

LVMH

Benefit

UltraPlushLipgloss

LVMH

Dior

DiorAddictLipGlow

LVMH

Sephora

PantoneUniverseLipLusterLipstick

ObsessiveCompulsive
Cosmetics

ObsessiveCompulsive
Cosmetics

LipTar

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

BlastFlipstickBlendableLipDuo

Revlon

Revlon

ColorburstLipButter

Revlon

Revlon

JustBittenKissableBalmStain

Shiseido

Nars

VelvetGlossLipPencil,abutterylipformula,intheformofa
pencilthatprovidesaglossyfinish

Tarte

Tarte

GlamazonPurePerformance12hourlipstick

M&Aactivity

RevlonInc.acquiresbrandsPureIcenailenamelbrand,andBonBonscolorcosmeticsfrom
BariCosmeticsinJuly2012.
Terms of the transaction are not disclosed; however, Revlon uses $22 million of
borrowings under its 2011 Revolving Credit Facility, along with cash on hand to fund
theacquisition.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

LipsticksandLipGlosses

LOral acquires Urban Decay from Castanea Partners, Inc., a private equity firm in
November,2012.Thefinancialdetailsoftheacquisitionisnotdisclosedbutisestimatedto
beashighas$350million.

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Lipsticks are the leading segment in the category, with 70.0% of category sales, reaching
$964millionin2012.
Lipsticksarethefastestgrowingsegment,up3.3%in2012attheexpenseoflipglosses,
asmanylaunchesincludelipstickswithhighshineinslimstickforms.
New packaging in slim cases, fat pencils, and beautiful cases contribute to the
excitementinthelipstickcategory.
Lip liners fare much better in the luxury trade class in 2012 compared to the mass
market.
Lip glosses are up slightly due to higher priced brands in the luxury space while the
segmentfaltersinthemasstradeclass.

Table4E27:ManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012

Producttype

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Lipsticksa

933

964

69.0

70.0

3.3

Lipglosses

311

303

23.0

22.0

(2.6)

Lipliners

108

110

8.0

8.0

1.9

Total
1,352
1,377

aIncludesmultiusesticksandlargepencils.

100.0

100.0

1.8

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E47

4E48

LipsticksandLipGlosses

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4E28:ManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

LOralr

231

236

EsteLauderr

209

Revlonr

2011

2012

Change,%

17.1

17.1

2.2

226

15.5

16.4

8.1

129

126

9.5

9.2

(2.3)

MaryKay

107

110

7.9

8.0

2.8

Procter&Gamble

114

103

8.4

7.5

(9.6)

95

94

7.0

6.8

(1.1)

164

167

34.6

35.0

1.8

1,352

1,377

100.0

100.0

1.8

Avon
Allother
Total

rRestated.

%Oftotal

LOral is the leading marketer in the lipsticks and lip glosses category in 2012. Category
salesforthecompanytotal$236millionin2012,up2.2%from$231millionin2011.
LOralrepresents17.1%ofthecategoryssalesin2012,unchangedfrom2011.
LOral is the leading advertiser, spending $130.8 million in traceable media
expenditures(TME).
LOral competes in the category with its mass brands, LOral Paris and Maybelline,
anditsluxurybrands,Lancme,YSLBeaute,andUrbanDecay.Allbrandscontributeto
the growth of the company in 2012, except LOral Paris. Maybelline adds the most
dollars,whileitsnamesakebranddeclines5.7%in2012.SalesofLOralParisColour
RicheandColourCaresselineofproductsperformwellandaresupportedwithTMEof
$25 million. However, LOral Paris does not fare well with its Infallible lipstick line
despitespending$19millioninTMEin2012.
Salesofthecompanysmassbrandsareuponly0.6%in2012,reaching$174millionin
sales.
Maybellineperformsverywellin2012,withsalesincreasing7.1%toreach$91million
in2012,upfrom$85millionin2011.Thebrandisontrendwithnewlaunchesin2012.
The brand capitalizes on what interests women, the gloss that stays on, and high
pigment lipsticks that stays on and feels creamy. Maybelline launches two new
products: Super Stay 10hour Stain Gloss and Colorsensational Vivids lipsticks. The
launchoftheseproductsissupportedwithcloseto$78millioninTME.
Sales of LOrals luxury brands grow 6.9% in 2012 to reach $62 million from
$58million.BothLancmeandYSLBeautehavesuccessfullaunchesinRougeinLove
andRougePurCoutureVenisaLevers,respectively.Bothproductsaresupportedwith
closeto$9millioninTME.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Este Lauder Companies is the secondleading marketer in the lipsticks and lip glosses
category,withsalesat$226million,increasing8.1%from$209millionin2011.
EsteLauder,asacompany,holdsacategoryshareof16.4%in2012,upfrom15.5%in
2011.
AllEsteLaudersbrandsgrowin2012.
The companys leading brand, MAC, contributes the most dollars, up 10.0% to reach
$88 million in 2012. MAC launches several new products in this category. Its original
lipstickprovidesadditionaldollarstothebrandssales.
MACallocatesmostofitsadvertisingbudgetof$3.7million,whichisup20%from2011,
to promote its lipsticks and nail polishes using multiplepage print advertisements.
MAC receives editorial pieces for its Marilyn Monroe collection of 29 items including
lipstick.
Clinique is the secondleading brand for the company in the luxury trade class with
salesat$47millionin2012,up9%from$43millionin2011.
TheCliniquebrandissupportedwithcloseto$24millioninTMEin2012.Over90%of
theTMEisusedtopromoteitsChubbyStickproduct.
TheBobbiBrownbrandisup6.7%in2012,reaching$32millioninsalesmostlikelydue
toshadeextensionsacrossalllipproductsandincreasedadvertising.Thebrandsigns
onactressKatieHolmesasitsfirstcelebrityspokesperson.However,salesdeclinefrom
itsdoubledigitgrowthbetween2010and2011.
GrowthofOriginsisup7.7%,totaling$14millionin2012,upfrom$13millionin2011.
The brand capitalizes on trends with a variety of lip products in formats that
consumers desire, such as liquid, chubby pencils, and a nourishing lipstick with its
FlowerFusionproduct.
Este Lauder decreases advertising for its namesake brand in 2012, and uses that
allocatedtopromoteitsPureColorlipstick.

Revlonremainsinthirdplaceinthelipsticksandlipglossescategory,despitea2.3%sales
declinein2012.Companysalesare$126millionin2012,downfrom$129millionin2011.
Revlonhasa9.2%categoryshareofsalesin2012.
Revlon competes in the mass lip category with its Revlon and Bari brands. Although
RevloncompeteswiththeAlmaybrandinothermakeupcategories,Almaynolonger
participatesinthelipcategory.
SalesoftheRevlonbrandslideprimarilyduetothedipinlipglosssalesforthebrand.
Itsliplinerandlipsticksegmentsarerelativelyflat.
The decline in sales, however, is not due to the lack of advertising support from the
company,asthebudgetincreasesover40%to$33millioninTMEin2012comparedto
$23millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E49

4E50

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Mary Kay jumps up a rank to become the fourthleading category marketer with 8.0% of
categorysalesin2012,surpassingProcter&Gamble.
Mary Kay is the leading directselling brand in the category, with sales reaching
$110million in 2012, up 2.8% from 2011. This is notable, as the company did not
launchitsnewTrueDimensionlipstickuntillatein2012.Theproductisontrendasitis
toutedasasheer,yetbuildablelipcolorinaluxuriousslimlinepackage.

Procter&Gambledropsdownaranktobecomethefifthleadingmarketerinthelipsticks
andlipglossescategory,withsalesof$103millionin2012,down9.6%from$114millionin
2011.
Themarketeraccountsfor7.5%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,downfrom8.4%
in2011.
TheCovergirlbrand,thesecondleadingbrandinthecategory,istheonlybrandthat
Procter&GamblehasintheU.S.massmakeupmarket.
Manufacturers sales are estimated at $103million in 2012, down 9.6% from
$114millionin2011.
ThecompanydiscontinueditsMaxFactorbrandinearly2010;however,thebrandis
stillsoldinternationally.
Covergirlcompetesinthelipstickandlipglosssegments.Thebrandseesalargedropin
salesamongitslipglossproducts.
Procter & Gamble is the secondlargest advertiser in the category, supporting its
Covergirl brand with $55 million in 2012, down from $78.5 million in TME in 2011.
Television advertising represents about 37% of the brands TME. The remainder is
spentonprintadvertising.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Drugstorescontinuetobetheleadingretailchannel;however,theyloseonesharepointto
massmerchandisersin2012.
Department stores remain in second position, as many women continue to seek the
brandsthatareonlyfoundindepartmentstoresfortheirlipstickpurchases.

Table4E29:ManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Drugstores

26

25

Departmentstores

24

24

Massmerchandisers

18

19

Directsales

18

18

Specialtystores

11

11

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

100

100

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

LipsticksandLipGlosses

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Theadvertisingandpromotionalactivitiesinthecategoryvarybytradeclass.
Approximately $277 million of TME is used to promote brands and products in the
categoryin2012.Ofthat,78%or$217millionisusedtopromotebrandsandproducts
inthemasstradeclass.
Socialmediamarketingisnowanintegralpartofthemarketingmixforallmarketers,
nomatterwheretheproductissold.
Most brand websites include videos to showcase products on models, as well as
tutorials so that consumers can get the look at home. Websites also include links to
sites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,Pinterest,andTumblr.
Blogs, message boards, and reviews on brand websites have increased tremendously
andconsumershavealotofinformationabouttheproductsbeforetheytryand/orbuy
them.
Blogscontinuetoproliferateandareapopularmeansforconsumerstofindcoupons,
dates,andstoreswheregiftwithpurchase(GWP)promotionswillbeheld,aswellas
brandsholdingpromotionsthatofferdiscountshipping.
Massbrandstypicallyrelyonprintandtelevisionmedia,andinstoredisplaycoupons.
Mass retailers in the drug store and mass merchandiser channels frequently use
promotionsofferingmakeupproductsatbuyonegetonefreeorbuyonegetone
halfpricetoencourageadditionalpurchases.

Luxury brands in the lipsticks and lip glosses category rely on editorials, celebrity
endorsements,andinstoreactivitiestopromoteproducts.Companieswithluxurybrands
supportthemwith$55millioninTME.
Veryfewluxurybrandsadvertiseproductsinthiscategoryontelevision.However,in
2012,bothCliniqueandDiorsupporttheirbrandsontelevision.
The promotional activity is generally focused on GWP or purchasewithpurchase
(PWP).Departmentstorescontinuetousethisvehicletobringpotentialcustomersto
thecounter,whilespecialtystoresletconsumerspicksamplestotakehometotrynew
products.
Indepartmentstores,onceconsumersareatthecounter,salespersonnelwillprovide
a makeover, speak of new products, and sometimes, provide the customer with
samplestotakehome.
ChanelandDiorremainpopular,especiallyinthiscategory,asitisarelativelylowcost
for a consumer to experience these brands without the expense of investing in the
brandsiconicfashionlines.

Direct marketers rely mostly on their sales consultants including parties, catalogs, price
discounts,GWPoffers,andsamplingtoachievesales.
Directbrandsrepresent5%oftheTMEforthecategoryin2012.Avonspendscloseto
$1 million in 2012 to promote its Shine Attract lipstick, while Mary Kay spends over
$4millioninTMEtopromoteitsNourishinePlusLipGloss.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E51

4E52

LipsticksandLipGlosses

Leading marketers, including Procter& Gamble, LOral, and Este Lauder, feature many
celebrityspokespersonstoadvertisetheirbrandsandproducts.
Procter & Gambles Covergirl brand features Sofia Vergara for its new Blast Flipstick
lipstick.
LOral Paris runs a series of fivepage print advertising showcasing products in all
makeupsegments.AdvertisementsfeaturemodelsBarbaraPalvinandDoutzenKroes,
andsingerGwenStefani.
MAC uses singer Beth Ditto for its advertisements. MAC also employs a fivepage
magazineadvertisementtoshowcasebothlipsandnailsthatmatch.

LOral is the largest advertiser in the category with combined expenditures for all its
brandsat$130.8millionin2012,aslightdeclinefromthe$134.2millionspentin2011.
LOralspends$60millionontelevisionandover$71millioninprintadvertising.

Maybellineisthehighestadvertisedbrandin2012with$78millioninTME.
LOralParisfollowsasthesecondlargestadvertisedbrandforLOralinthecategory
withTMEof$44.1millionin2012,downfrom$49.8millionin2011.
Procter & Gamble is the third largest advertiser, using $57.1 million to promote the
Covergirlbrandanditsproducts.

Revlon is the fourthlargest advertiser with TME at $32.9 million in 2012, up from
$23.2millionin2011.RevlonusesactressEmmaStonetopromoteitslaunchofJustBitten
KissableBalmStain.

Table4E30:SelectExamplesofCouponingActivityforLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStates,2012

Company

Brand

Promotion

Coty

Rimmel

$2.00offonanyRimmelLipProductatWalmart

LOral

LOralParis

$1.00offonanyLOralParisproduct

LOral

Maybelline

Save$2.00withthepurchaseofPeoplemagazineandMaybelline
Sensationallipcolor

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

Save$2.00withthepurchaseofPeoplemagazineandanyCovergirl
Outlastlipcolor

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

$2.00offwiththepurchaseoftwoCovergirl24HRMascaraand/or
CovergirlOutlastLipColor

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

LipsticksandLipGlosses

OUTLOOK

Sales of the lipsticks and lip glosses category are anticipated to pick up over the forecast
periodthrough2017ataCAGRof2.4%.
Itislikelythatmarketerswillimprovelipglossformulationstobelesstackywithlonger
wearwiththeuseofstaintechnologyinordertobringwomenbacktothesegment.
It is predicted that lip liners sales will remain relatively flat. Although lip glosses are
expectedtogrowonly1%duringtheforecastperiod,thesegmentssaleswillneedto
risehigherinordertogetbacktopositiveresultsfirst.
During the forecast period, it is anticipated that women will purchase multiple lip
productstocapturetheirmoodsandtotransitionfromdaytonighttimelooks.Kline&
Companyexpectstoseemoreglamourinmakeupasconsumeroptimismrises.
Bold,redlipsarelikelytoremainpopularandarepredictedtostay.
Naturalbrandsarepredictedtogrowastheyimproveshadesandformulas.Retailers
and magazine editorials are more often featuring brands, such as Burts Bees, Josie
Maran,andObsessiveCompulsiveCosmetics.
Trends in lipsticks that are likely to continue and drive newness and growth include
longwearingcolorthatarehighinpigmentandhavetheappearanceofliquid,lacquer,
orhighshine.
Although intense colors will continue to be popular, it is anticipated that a trend for
young,moisturizednudelipswillrunasaparalleltrendoverthenextfewyears.
Products containing natural, moisturizing ingredients, such as but not limited to
maracujaoiland/orargonoilsareexpectedtofuelsalesinthecategory.

Marketerswillcontinuetolaunchnewandimprovedproductswithinnovativeingredients,
improvedapplicators,andpackagingtoinspirewomentopurchase.
Prettyanduniquepackaging,suchasTarteswoodenlipstickpackage,isanticipatedto
becomemoreprevalent,ascasesforlipstickproductscontinuetobeanaccessoryina
womenspurse.
Primers,nowpartofthefacemakeupregimen,maybecomeapartofthelipregimen
forimprovedliptextureandtoensurelongwear.Thesetypeofnewbenefitswilllikely
drivegrowthaspricesincrease.
Ontheotherhand,massmarketers,especiallybudgetbrands,suchasEyesLipsFace
and Rimmel are forecast to promote antiaging benefits similar to luxury brands in
ordertokeepcustomersfromtradingbackuptothebrandsthattheyleftduringthe
recessionperiod.
Marketers that have not used traditional advertising in the past will likely increase
advertising budgets to include magazine advertising, revamping of brand websites,
and/ortheuseofsocialmediaasawaytopromotetheirbrandsandproducts.
Collectionsand/orlimitededitionproductsarepredictedtocontinueasawaytokeep
consumersexcitedaboutthebrandandaswaytospuradditionalproductsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E53

4E54

LipsticksandLipGlosses

SalesareexpectedtoforecastataCAGRof2.4%,reaching$1,553millionby2017,upfrom
$1,377millionin2012.

Table4E31:ForecastManufacturersSalesofLipsticksandLipGlossesintheUnitedStatesby
ProductType,2012to2017

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2012

2017

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Lipsticksa

964

1,118

70.0

72.0

3.0

Lipglosses

303

319

22.0

20.5

1.0

Lipliners

110

116

8.0

7.5

1.1

Total
1,377
1,553

aIncludesmultiusesticksandlargepencils.

100.0

100.0

2.4

Unit volume is forecast to grow at a CAGR of 1.5% from 238 million packages in 2012 to
reach256millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

NAILPOLISHES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Sales of the nail polishes category grow 17.4% to reach $662million in 2012, up from
$564millionin2011.
Nail polishes is the fastestgrowing category in the entire cosmetics and toiletries
industryin2012andhasbeensince2010.

Manufacturers sales increase at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 16.8% since
2007.

Table4E32:HistoricalSalesofNailPolishesintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
305
307
341
406
564
662

Change,%

0.8
10.8
19.1
39.1
17.4

The nail polish boom continues as marketers provide abundant innovative technologies
withproductsforconsumerstoimitatesaloneffectsinacosteffectivemannerathome.
Theassortmentofnailcolorsandthosewithuniquefinishesandtexturesfromgelto
caviartovelvetandsequinnailscontinuetoaddfreshnesstothecategory.
3D, nail art, and nail appliques offer additional ways to decorate nails with ease
(however,onlythepolishistrackedinthisstudy).
Geltechnologyisoneofthemaindriversinnailpolishin2012.Itisthenewstandard,
andtheunparallellongwearthatgeltechnologydeliversiscatchingonwithconsumers.
OnesuchmarketernewtothegelpolishsegmentisHautePolish,whichoffersaone
stepgelnailpolishsystem.
Matching lips and nails, is gaining some popularity among marketers including MAC,
whichbringsbackatrendfromdecadesago.
Because of the low cost of nail polishes they are an impulse purchase and used to
createandexpressonesownstyleorupdateoneswardrobe.
Luxurybrandsoutperformmassbrand,althoughfromamuchsmallerbase,up25.8%
reaching$39millionin2012from$31millionin2011.Beautybrands,suchasMACand
Lancmedoubletheirnailpolishbusinessin2012.
Massmarketsalesgrowby20.2%in2012toreach$584million.Twothirdsofthetop
massbrandsshowsignificantgrowthin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4E56

NailPolishes

Table4E33:ManufacturersSalesofNailPolishesintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

%Oftradeclass

Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

$Million
2012

2011

2012

2011

%Oftotal
2012

SallyHansenr

Coty

229

210

47.1

36.0

40.6

31.7

Essie

LOral

31

68

6.4

11.6

5.5

10.3

Revlon

Revlon

38

48

7.8

8.2

6.7

7.3

Sinful

Revlon

26

34

5.3

5.8

4.6

5.1

WetNWild

Markwins

20

34

4.1

5.8

4.6

5.1

PureIce

Revlon

22

25

4.5

4.3

3.9

3.8

LOralParis

LOral

21

0.4

3.6

0.4

3.2

OPIr

Coty

19

21

3.9

3.6

3.4

3.2

Nicoler

Coty

12

19

2.5

3.3

2.1

2.9

NYCNewYorkColor

Coty

10

10

2.1

1.7

1.8

1.5

Maybelline

LOral

10

0.8

1.7

0.7

1.5

Orly

OrlyInternational

1.9

1.5

1.6

1.4

Rimmelr

Coty

1.0

0.7

0.9

0.6

CoverGirl

Procter&Gamble

0.2

0.3

0.2

0.3

Bari/BonBons

BariCosmetics

0.8

0.2

0.7

0.2

HardCandy

FalicGroup

3.2

2.6

0.2

0.2

53

67

11.1

11.6

9.6

10.3

486

584

100.0

100.0

86.2

88.2

MASS

Allotherr
Total

LUXURY
ChristianDior

LVMH

19.4

20.5

1.1

1.2

Chanel

Chanel

22.6

17.9

1.2

1.1

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

9.7

12.8

0.5

0.8

Clinique

EsteLauder

9.7

10.3

0.5

0.6

MAC

EsteLauder

6.5

10.3

0.4

0.6

Lancme

LOral

6.5

10.3

0.4

0.6

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

4.9

10.3

0.4

BobbiBrown

EsteLauder

16.1

15.4

0.7

0.8

31

39

100.0

100.0

5.5

5.9

Allotherr

Total

DIRECT

Avon

Avon

MaryKay
Mark

20

18

54.1

62.1

3.5

2.7

MaryKay

21.6

6.9

1.4

0.3

Avon

5.4

6.9

0.4

0.3

18.9

24.1

1.2

1.1

37

29

100.0

100.0

6.6

4.4

10.0

70.0

80.0

1.2

1.2

Allother
Total

SPECIALTY
VictoriasSecret

LimitedBrands

Privatelabel

Allother

Total

TOTAL

20.0

20.0

0.4

0.3

10

10

100.0

100.0

1.8

1.5

564

662

100.0

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

NailPolishes

Unitsales

Unitsalesofnailpolishesgrow16.0%to235millionpackagesin2012,upfrom202million
packagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofnailpolishesincrease17.3%from$817millionin2011to$958millionin2012.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Newcolorscontinuein2012asmostmarketersexpandtheircolorassortment.
Fall colors feature metallic and sparkle as well as colors in cranberry, deep purples,
ruby reds, blue denim, grays, greens, and black, while spring comes with mango,
tangerine,lime,Caribbeanwatercolors,lavender,andpalebabypinks.
Thereseemstobenoendinsightinthemarketofinimitablefinishesonecancreate,
suchasvelvet,rubber,leather,lace,metal,crackle,andglitter.
Atthesametime,theFrenchmanicurewithahintofsparkleaddedtotheendofthe
nail is popular among those who do not want to be too outlandish, but provides a
personaltouch.
Defineyourownstyleistheunderlyingthemein2012.

Retailers,suchasCVSwithNuance,aregettingintothecategoryandthebrandissupported
bySalmaHayekasitsspokesperson.Thebrandlaunchedwith30shades.
CVSalsoputsupkiosksinstorestoserveasaplatformtoshowcasenewproducts.

CotyregeneratesitsOPIbrandconstantlybycreatinglimitededitioncolorcollectionsthat
tie into current trends in movies or television, to bring excitement and draw young
consumerstothebrand.
ForexampleandnotlimitedtoMariahCareycollectionof8chartsmashingshades
inspiredbytheicon,avintageMinnieMousecollection,KardashianKolorwithKendall
&Kylie,anAmazingSpidermancollection,andaJamesBondcollectionforthemovie,
Skyfall.

Maybelline creates a fashion element in its advertisements for its new ColorShow nail
polishes.
Somethemesseenin2012includedenimsheavymetalandrunwayhotshades.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE &COMPANY,INC.

4E57

4E58

NailPolishes

M&Aactivity

RevlonInc.acquiresPureIcenailenamelandBonBonscolorcosmeticsfromBariCosmetics
inJuly,2012.
Terms of the transaction are not disclosed; however, Revlon uses $22 million of
borrowings under its 2011 Revolving Credit Facility, along with cash on hand to fund
theacquisition.

LOral acquires Urban Decay from Castanea Partners, Inc., a privateequity firm in
November2012.
Thefinancialdetailsoftheacquisitionarenotdisclosed,butestimatedtobeashighas
$350million.

Notablenewproducts

Table4E34:SelectNewNailPolishesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

Coty

SallyHansen

NewCompleteSalonManicure

Coty

SallyHansen

New&ImprovedDiamondStrengthNoChipNailColor

Coty

SallyHansen

MagneticNailColor3Dnailartinseconds

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

PureColorVividShinenailpolish

LOral

Essie

Stylenomicsnailpolish

LOral

Essie

LuxEffectsfivemultidimensionaltopcoats

LOral

Essie

Mirrormetallicshades

LOral

LOrealParis

ColourRichenailpolish

LOral

Maybelline

ColorShownailpolish

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

OutlastStayBrilliantNailGloss

Revlon

Revlon

Brilliantnailpolish

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

NailPolishes

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4E35:ManufacturersSalesofNailPolishesintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

Cotyr

275

264

Revlona

90

LOral

%Oftotal
2011

2012

Change,%

48.8

39.9

(4.0)

108

15.9

16.3

20.0

40

104

7.1

15.7

160.0

Markwins

20

34

3.5

5.1

70.0

Avon

22

20

3.9

3.0

(9.1)

EsteLauder

13

1.4

1.9

62.5

OrlyInternational

1.6

1.4

LVMH

1.1

1.2

33.3

Chanel

1.2

1.1

MaryKay

1.4

0.3

(75.0)

Allother

79

93

15.1

15.3

18.8

564

662

100.0

100.0

17.4

Total

aIncludesPureIcesales.
rRestated.

Cotyremainsthedominantnailpolishmarketerin2012witha39.9%shareofthecategory.
Coty competes in the nail polish arena with brands, Sally Hansen, OPI, OPI Nicole,
Rimmel,andNYCNewYorkColor.
Salesforthecompanydeclineby4%in2012to$264millionduetostiffcompetitionin
thecategoryandlackofnewlaunchesfromtheSallyHansenbrand.
OPIandOPINicolecontributethemostdollarstothecompany,butarenotenoughto
offsetthedeclinesornominalgrowthfromtheotherbrandsinthecompanysportfolio.
Nail polishes is the prime category for the marketer, accounting for 64% of its total
makeupsalesin2012.
Sally Hansens sales decline 8.3% in 2012 to $210 million, down from $229 million in
2011.Thebrandaccountsfor79.5%ofCotysnailpolishsalesin2012.SallyHansenhas
two new and improved product launches and the Magnetic nail launch in 2012.
However,thebrandfacescompetitionfromallmarketersinthemassmarket.
TheNicolebrandgrowsby$7milliondollarsin2012.Totalsalesare$19millionin2012,
up58.3%from2011.
SalesofRimmeldecline20.0%to$4millionin2012,downfrom$5millionin2011as
thebrandfocusesitseffortselsewhere.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE &COMPANY,INC.

4E59

4E60

NailPolishes

Cotyssalonbrand,OPIreaches$21millionin2012,up10.5%from$19millionin2011.
OPIs sales growth is attributed to the fact that its polishes do not contain
formaldehyde,dibutylphthalate,ortoluene,gainingacceptancefromconsumerswho
areconcernedaboutthechemicalsusedinmanynailpolishes.
OPI is available in salons, as well as at Sephora, Ulta, JC Penney, and Pure Beauty
retailers (This report covers only products sold for consumers to take home. For
detailed information on professional nail polishes sales, please refer to Kline &
CompanysProfessionalNailCare:GlobalMarketBrief.)

Revlonisthesecondlargestmarketerinnailpolishesandsurpassesoverallmarketgrowth..
Revlonssalesreach$108millioninmanufacturerssalesin2012,up20.0%from2011.
Nailpolishesrepresent18.0%ofRevlonstotalmakeupsales.
RevlonacquiresBonBonsandPureIcefromBariCosmeticsin2012.
PureIcesalesreach$25millionin2012,up13.6%from$22millionin2011.
Sinfulssalesreach$34millionin2012,up30.8%from$26millionin2011.
Revlons share of the category increases to 16.3% in 2012, up from 15.9% in 2011
primarilyduetoitsnewlaunchactivity.
RevlonincreasesitsTMEby57.1%to$19.8millionin2012from$12.6millioninTMEin
2011.OverhalftheexpendituresupportstheColorstaynailpolishline.

LOral retains its position as the thirdlargest nail polish marketer, with sales of
$104millionin2012,up160%from$40millionin2011.
LOralcompetesinnailpolisheswithitsLOralParis,Maybelline,Essie,Lancme,and
YSLBeautebrands.
SalesoftheEssiebrandincreasefrom$31millionin2011to$68millionin2012and
contributethemostdollarsforthecompany.
Essie continues to expand its shade selection to sustain its popularity among
consumersseekingthelatestfashionhues.
Since the acquisition of Essie by LOral in 2011, the brand continues to expand its
distribution.Thebrandissoldindrugstores,massmerchandisersincludingTargetand
Walmart,departmentstores,andspecialtystores,suchasUltaandSephora.
LOral Paris sales grow the most on a percentage basis from $2 million in 2011 to
$21millionin2012.ItssuccesscomesfromthelaunchoftheColourRichenailpolish
line.
Maybellinemorethandoublesitsnailpolishbusinessin2012reaching$10millionin
sales,upfrom$4millionin2011.MaybellinessuccesscomesfromthelaunchofColor
Shownailpolish.
Lancme doubles its nail polish business in 2012 with sales of $4 million, up from
$2millionin2011anddoesnotadvertise.Thebrandssuccesscomesfromthelaunch
ofLeVernisandVernisinLovenailpolishes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

NailPolishes

MarkwinsWetNWildmovesupasthefourthlargestbrandinthenailpolishescategory
in2012.
Salesareup70.0%in2012toreach$34million,upfrom$20millionin2011.
Thebrandsphilosophyisbasedonfashion,fun,andaffordability.
Thebrandperformsverywellbecausenailpolishisahighimpulsepurchaseproduct,
andthebrandspricepointof$1.99makesiteasyforconsumerstobuy.

Avonslidestothefifthpositionwithdecliningsalesof9.1%in2012.
SalesforAvonareapproximately$22millionin2012,downfrom$20millionin2011.
Avon does not perform well in the nail polishes category because the company as
wholeisstrugglingintheUnitedStatesandthebrandfacesstiffcompetitionfromthe
massmarket.
Avonaccountsforthemajorityofnailpolishessaleswithinthedirectchannelholding
a62.1%sharein2012.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Drugstores andmassmerchandisersmaintaina75% shareofthe overallsalesinthenail


polishescategory.

Table4E36:ManufacturersSalesofNailPolishesintheUnitedStates
byRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Drugstores

38

39

Massmerchandisers

37

37

Directsales

Specialtystores

Departmentstores

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Cotyspends$104milliononitsnailpolishbrands.Traceablemediaexpenditures(TME)for
Cotysnailpolishesareupfrom$63.0millionin2011.Thisfigureincludesspendingforthe
companysSallyHansen,OPI,andNicolebrands.
Magazines are the primary medium used to promote the companys brands and
products.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE &COMPANY,INC.

4E61

4E62

NailPolishes

The Sally Hansen namesake brand is supported with $46.5 million in TME in 2012. About
onethirdoftheexpendituresupportstheSalonEffectsfranchise.
OPI Products receive TME of $43.2 million in 2012, up from $25.3 million in 2011.
About40%oftheTMEsupportsthebrandsGelcolorline.
OPINicoleissupportedwith$13.8millioninTMEin2012.
AllofCotysbrands,andespeciallyOPINicoleuseseasonaland/orlimitededitioncolor
collectionsasawaytomotivateconsumerstodrivesalesandrepurchaseoften.
Coupons are regularly made available in magazines, online, as well as on retailer
shelves.
CotyincreasinglypromotesitsSallyHansenbrandthroughsocialmediasites,suchas
Facebook,Twitter,Pinterestandoffershowtotutorialsonthebrandswebsiteandon
YouTube.
SallyHansenfeaturesanIlovenailartcontesttowincashprizesandatriptoNew
York on its website to promote its products. Viewers can vote through the brands
websiteorthroughPinterestandTwitter.

LOralsupportsitsbrandswith$70.4millioninTMEin2012.
LOralParislaunchofColourRichenailpolishesissupportedby$42.5millioninTME
in2012.
Essieispromotedonsocialwebsites,suchasFacebook,andonecansignuptofollow
thebrandonTwitter.
Essiedoesnotpromoteitsproductswithcoupons.
Essiereceives$30.2millioninTMEtosupportthebrand.Approximately$4.4millionof
theexpenditureisusedtosupportitsLuxeffectslinein2012.
Maybelline receives $17.7 million in TME to support the launch of Color Show nail
polish.

Promotionalvehiclesformassbrandslargelyincludepricediscountsandcoupons.
National mass retailers regularly run promotions offering nail products at buyone
getonefreeorbuyonegetonehalfpricetoinspireadditionalpurchases.
Social media, brand websites, and advertising in womens fashion magazines are the
main marketing means for the nail polishes category. Magazines feature tips from
celebritystylistsonhowtogetthelooksofstars,suchasKatyPerryandBeyonc.
OPIrefreshesitslinebycobrandingorpromotinglimitededitionshades.Forexample,
OPI launched new shades inspired by Bond for the new Skyfall movie and a Vintage
MinnieMousecollection,aswellasinspiredcolorsbysingerMariahCareyandanother
bytheKardashiansisters,KendallandKylie.
RevlonusesactressHalleBerrytoadvertiseitsColorstaynailpolish.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

NailPolishes

Table4E37:SelectExamplesofCouponingActivityforNailPolishesintheUnitedStates,2012
Company/division

Brand

Promotion

Coty

SallyHansen

$5.00offonSalonGelPolishStarterKit

Coty

SallyHansen

$2.00offonanySallyHansennailtreatmentproductwhenyou
buyanySallyHansennailpolish

Procter&Gamble

Covergirl

$3.00offwhenyoupurchasetwoCovergirlnailproducts

Revlon

Revlon

$3.50offonanyRevlonpurchaseof$10.00ormore

Sales representatives and catalogs are used to promote nail polishes through the direct
saleschannelin2012.

OUTLOOK

Thebroadselectionofnailshadesandtexturesisexpectedtoinciteconsumerstowearand
repurchaseoftenasawayofselfexpression.
Other innovations that are likely to drive growth include newer versions of current
trendsthatincludetexturednails,magneticnailpolish,andglitternailpolish.
Innovations in formulas especially in the gel nail segment are also expected to drive
salesinthefuture.
Consumerswillcontinuetoremainsensibleabouttheamountofmoneyspentonsalon
visitsandwillcontinuetoseekoutwaystoobtainthesalonlookwhiledoingtheirown
nails.
Hence,consumersarelikelytoincreasetheirspendingonretailproductstoattainthe
professionalresultsonceobtainedonlythroughsalons.
Gelbasednailpolishesandkitsareanticipatedtogrowasmoremarketerslaunchsuch
products.Thesepolishesandsystemscarryahigherpricepointandwillcontributeto
theoveralldollargrowthforthecategory.
Two brands at either end of the spectrum, Sally Hansen and Chanel, are expected to
launchnewproductstostimulategrowthnotseenin2012.
It is anticipated that marketers will advertise and promote their nail polishes heavily
duringtheforecastperiod.

SalesofnailpolishesareforecasttogrowataCAGRof9.0%toreach$1,019millionin2017,
upfrom$662millionin2012.

UnitsalesarepredictedtogrowataCAGRof8.0%toreach345millionpackagesin2017,
upfrom235millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE &COMPANY,INC.

4E63

4E64

NailPolishes

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

4F.ORALCAREPRODUCTS

INTRODUCTION

Oralcareproductscleanseandsoothethemouth,gums,teeth,andlips.Productsincluded
inthissectionare:
Dentureproducts
Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments
Mouthwashes
Toothbrushes(manualandbatteryoperated)
Toothpastes
Toothwhiteningproducts

Thisreport excludesoralcaremedications,dentalfloss,electrictoothbrushes,andbreath
fresheners.

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Manufacturers sales of oral care products are up 1.6% from $4,184 million in 2011 to
$4,252millionin2012.
Toothpastesrepresentthelargestcategorywith41.1%oftotaloralcaresales.

Figure4F1:ManufacturersSalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012
Toothwhitening
products,6%
Denture
products,8%
Toothpastes,41%

Lipbalms,jellies,
andtreatments,9%

Toothbrushes,17%

Mouthwashes,19%
Total:$4,252Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F2

OralCareProducts

Since2007,saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of1.2%.

Table4F1:HistoricalSalesofOralCareProductsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

4,013

2008r

4,154

3.5

2009r

4,114

(1.0)

2010r

4,099

(0.4)

2011r

4,184

2.1

2012

rRestated.

4,252

1.6

Salesbytradeclass

Table4F2:ManufacturersSalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

$Million

Tradeclass

Tooth
pastes

Mass

Mouth
washes

Tooth
brushes

Lipbalms,jellies,
andtreatments

Denture
products

Toothwhitening
products

Total

%Of
total

1,749

799

741

303

318

257

4,167

98.0

Specialty

35

12

47

1.1

Direct

24

26

0.6

Luxury
Total

12

12

0.3

1,749

799

741

374

318

271

4,252

100.0

RETAILSALES

Salesofalloralcareproductsareestimatedat$5,386.8millionattheretaillevelin2012,an
increaseof1.9%from$5,288.8millionin2011.

The top five major marketers competing in the oral care products class control
$3,225millionor75.8%oftheproductclasssalesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

4F3

OralCareProducts

COMPETITION

Table4F3:ManufacturersSalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategoryandCompany,2012

$Million
Tooth
pastes

Mouth
washes

Tooth
brushes

Procter&Gamble

628

187

244

ColgatePalmolive

659

12

180

Company

Johnson&Johnson

Lipbalms,jellies,
andtreatments

Denture
products

Toothwhitening
products

98

200

1,357

31.9

851

20.0

Total

%Of
total

29

354

18

409

9.6

GlaxoSmithKline

242

21

125

406

9.5

Church&Dwight

154

45

202

4.8

Pfizer

79

79

1.9

Sanofi

66

66

1.6

TheCloroxCompany

58

58

1.4

Dr.Fresh

57

57

1.3

Blistex

49

49

1.2

PrestigeBrands
Allother
Total

40

40

0.9

37

159

206

170

55

51

678

15.9

1,749

799

741

374

318

271

4,252

100.0

Procter& Gamble remains the largest marketer of oral care products in 2012, with total
salesof$1,357million,downby2.9%from$1,398millionin2011.
Procter& Gamble contributes 31.9% to the oral care products category share,
comparedto33.4%sharein2011.
Thecompanycompetesinfiveofthesixcategories,notparticipatinginthelipbalms,
jellies,andtreatmentscategory.
Some of the key factors that contribute to the marketers decline in the oral care
marketin2012includelimitednewproductactivity,adecreaseincouponingactivity,
andadecreaseinthemarketingandadvertisingsupportforitsbrands.
Procter&GambledecreasesitsTMEtosupportitsbrandsintheoralcareproductclass
significantlyby21.6%from$269.3millionin2011to$211.2millionin2012.
Procter&Gambleistheleadingmarketeroftoothbrushesandtoothwhitenersandis
thesecondleadingmarketeroftoothpastes,mouthwashes,anddentureproducts.
The company is the leading marketer of tooth whitening products, with a significant
lead over other marketers in the category. Sales for the marketer in the tooth
whiteningcategorydeclineby5.7%from$212millionin2011to$200millionin2012.
Higherpricepointscomparedtocompetitorsresultsinsalesdeclineforthemarketerin
thecategory.
Procter&Gamblemaintainsitsleadershipintoothbrushes,itssecondlargestproduct
category.Salesdecreaseby4.3%,from$255millionin2011to$244millionin2012for
themarketerinthetoothbrushescategory.
Procter & Gamble, well known for its product innovations, experiences lesser
innovations and new product activity in 2012 limiting the marketers growth in the
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F4

OralCareProducts

ThecompanylosesitsgroundtoColgatePalmolivein2012tobecomethesecondleadingin
thetoothpastescategory.
Salesofthecompanydeclineby2.9%from$647millionin2011to$628millionin2012.
Procter & Gambles increase in price for its products in 2012 is also a major factor
contributingtoitssalesdeclineinthecategory.

ColgatePalmolive is the secondlargest marketer in the oral care market, with sales of
$851millionin2012,up6.0%from$803millionin2011.
ColgatePalmoliveholds20.0%shareoftheclassin2012,upfrom19.2%in2011.
The company competes in the three largest product categories in the oral care
products class: toothpastes, mouthwashes, and toothbrushes. ColgatePalmolive
focusesonthetoothbrushesandtoothpastescategories,withover98%ofitstotaloral
caresalescontributedbythesetwocategories.
The company replaces Procter & Gamble to become the leading marketer in the
toothpastescategoryin2012.
ThemarketerprimarilybenefitsfromthesuccessofitsOpticWhiterangeoforalcare
productsin2012.
Thenewtrendwhiteninghelpsthecompanygrowitssalesin2012 andstrengthen
ColgatePalmolivespositionintheoralcaremarket.
Salesoftoothpastes,accountingfor77.4%ofthecompanystotalsalesintheoralcare
market,increaseby5.9%in2012.
Thecompanyregisters8.4%growthinthetoothbrushescategory.
The success of the Colgate Optic White range of oral care products, which includes
toothbrushes,contributesdirectlytothecompanysgrowth.

In2012,Johnson&Johnsonremainsthethirdlargestmarketerintheoralcaremarketwith
salesof$409million,up1.0%from$405millionin2011.
Thecompanyholds9.6%shareoftheclassin2012,slightlydownfrom9.7%in2011.
The company participates in four of the six categories including mouthwashes,
toothpastes,toothwhiteningproducts,andlipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategories
intheoralcaremarket;however,86.5%ofitstotalsalescomefromthemouthwashes
segment.SalesofJohnson&Johnsoninthemouthwashescategorygrowby1.1%,from
$350millionin2011to$354millionin2012.
Johnson& Johnsons Listerine is still the undisputed leader in the mouthwashes
categorywith44.3%ofthetotalcategorysales.
In the mouthwashes category, Listerines sales grow 1.2% from $336 million to
$340million in 2012. Growth of the Listerine brand is supported by the strong
performanceofitsalcoholfreevariantsListerineZeroandTotalCare.
ThemarketersellsitsReachbrandofmanualtoothbrushestoDr.Freshin2012foran
undisclosedamount.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

OralCareProducts

GlaxoSmithKline is in fourth place, with total sales increasing 4.9% from $387million in
2011to$406millionin2012.
GlaxoSmithKline participates in five categories in the oral care products market, not
participating in the lip balms, jellies, and treatments category. The company has a
majorpresenceinthedentureproductsandtoothpastescategories,contributingabout
90.4%ofthecompanystotalsalesintheoralcaremarket.
GlaxoSmithKline is the leading marketer of denture products and the thirdleading
marketeroftoothpastes.
In 2012, GlaxoSmithKlines sales in the denture products category increase 7.8% to
$125million from $116 million in 2011. The companys growth in the category is
supported by introduction of a new adhesive, Poligrip for Partials. The marketer
removes zinc from its Poligrip brands to promote its sales in 2012 as zinc in denture
productsisexpectedtoleadtohypocupremia,hyperzincemia,orneuropathy(damage
isanervedisorder).

Church&Dwightholdsthefifthpositionintheoralcaremarket,contributing$202million
insales,down3.8%from$210millionin2011.
The company competes in the toothpastes, toothbrushes, and tooth whitening
products categories, with a very small presence in the tooth whitening products
category.
Thecompanysmarketsharedeclinesto4.8%ofthetotalproductclasssalesin2012
from5.0%in2011.Themarketsharedeclineisdrivenprimarilyduetotheslidingsales
inthetoothbrushescategory.
Lack of new product activity and a decrease in marketing activity limits Church&
Dwightssalesintheoralcareproductclass.
ToothpastesarethestrongestcategoryforChurch&Dwight,accountingfor76.2%of
thecompanystotaloralcaresales.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Mass merchandisers are the leading retail channel for oral care products in 2012, with
43.7%ofsales.
Foodstoresranksecond,with31.4%ofthesalesshare.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F5

4F6

OralCareProducts

Table4F4:SalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2012

Retailoutlet

%Ofmanufacturerssales
Denture
products

Lipbalms

Mouth
washes

Tooth
whitening

Tooth
brushes

Tooth
pastes

Weighted
average

Massmerchandisers

39

33

46

49

46

44

43.7

Foodstores

32

20

29

19

31

37

31.4

Drugstores

29

27

25

28

22

18

22.3

Specialtystores

11

1.6

Directsales

0.6

Professionaloutlets

0.2

Departmentstores
Total

0.2

100

100

100

100

100

100

100.0

OUTLOOK

The oral care market is mature and will experience moderate growth of 1.2% over the
forecastperiod.
Toothpastes,mouthwashes,andtoothbrushes,thethreelargestcategoriesintheoral
careproductsclasswithacollectiveshareof77.4%,willdrivetheoverallmarket.
Multibenefitproductsacrossallthecategorieswilldrivethesalesoforalcareproduct
classinthenextfiveyears.
Several leading marketers, including Procter & Gamble and ColgatePalmolive, are
expectedtolaunchmoreinnovativeproductstosupportthegrowth.

The largest category in the oral care product class, toothpastes is expected to experience
slowandsteadygrowthof1.2%overtheforecastperiod,2012to2017,supportedbynew
productlaunches.
Marketers are expected to introduce more innovative or multibenefit products to
supporttheirsalesgrowth.
Companies are also expected to launch products pertaining to specific oral care
problemsincludingsensitiveteeth,protectionagainstplaque,anddrymouth.
Marketersareexpectedtocontinuewithstrongpromotionalsupportfortheirbrands
overtheforecastperiod.
New manufacturers, such as Hello Products, Kiss My Face, and other niche personal
careandcosmeticcompanies,areexpectedtolaunchinnovativenewproductsinthe
category,givingconsumersmorealternatives.
Traditional product options are expected to decline as companies turn to better
technologieswithimprovedformulations,multibenefitproductintroductionstogrow
marketshare.
Productstargetingagegroupsincludingchildrenandteensareexpectedtoexperience
growth, as marketers such as Procter & Gamble and Sunstar Americas continue to
launchsuchproductsinthecategory.
Toothpastes are used bya vast majority of adults and children to maintain good oral
health,makingitsmarketpenetrationhigh.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

OralCareProducts

The mouthwashes category, second largest in oral care, is mature and will experience
relativelylowsalesgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.
Salesforthecategoryareexpectedtogrowby1.4%overthenextfiveyears.
Mouthwashesthatoffermultibenefitssuchasteethwhitening,protectionagainstbad
breath,andenamelprotectionareexpectedtosupportthecategorygrowthoverthe
forecastperiod.
Mouthwashes that are positioned to provide better results such as killing germs are
expectedtoseegrowthovertheforecastperiod.
New product innovations with better formulas will cater to the growth of
mouthwashesintheforecastperiod.
Better promotional and advertisements support for the mouthwashes category will
supportthesalesgrowthofthecategory.
Privatelabel products with continuous improvements in quality and pricing are
expectedtopostsalesgrowthinthecategoryovertheforecastedperiod.
However, the mouthwashes category will continue to face stiff competition from
toothpasteswithallinonebenefits.

Salesoftoothbrushesareexpectedtogrowataslowbutsteadyrateof1.6%overthenext
fiveyears.
Products with better technology and lower price are expected to grow over the
forecastperiod.
Marketerswillcontinuetolaunchnewandcreativeproductswithmultiplebenefits,to
keeppacewiththegrowthinconsumerdemandandexpectations.
Themanualsegmentwillexperiencegreatergrowthinthechildrenssegmentandless
intheadultsegment,drivenmainlybyinnovations,andbettermarketingstrategies.
Products that are designed for specific problems, including gum massage, plaque
removal,anddeepcleaningareexpectedtoseegrowth.
Marketers are expected to increase their marketing activity to support the category
salesovertheforecastperiod.
Factorsincludinglowpriceandnewproductlauncheswillsupportthesalesofprivate
labelproductsovertheforecastperiod.

Thelipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategoryisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof1.9%
overtheforecastperiod.
As the presence of lip care products increase across distribution channels, especially
massmerchandisers,thecategoryssalesarelikelytoincrease.
Sales of highpriced lip balms with additional benefits such as antiaging are likely to
increaseandsupportthecategorysgrowth.
Marketersarelikelytoadoptnewstrategiessuchaspackageinnovationsandtrialsizes
toattractnewcustomers.
New product introductions, particularly focused on products that improve lip quality,
willdriveconsumerinterest.
Tinted lip balms are likely to witness sales increase as they compete directly against
lipsticksandlipglosses
However,otherfactorswillhindergreaterexpansion,includingchangingfashions,the
continued inability of marketers to target older consumers, and continued consumer
belttightening.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F7

4F8

OralCareProducts

Sales for denture products are expected to grow moderately by 0.3% over the forecast
periodsupportedbyacontinuousincreaseintheaverageageofAmericans
An aging population and new product innovations are expected to drive the sales of
dentureproductsovertheforecastperiod.
With growth in the dental accessories category, cleansing brands may also see
moderategrowthifthemarketerscanpositioncleansingproductsforuseinthisarea.
However, sales in the category will be limited by certain factors, including the wider
useofpermanentimplantsandimprovementinoralcare.

Thematuringtoothwhiteningproductscategoryisexpectedtodeclinemarginallyby0.5%
overtheforecastperiod.
The tooth whitening category growth will be limited by stiff competition from
whiteningtoothpastesandmouthwashes.
The continual introduction of new toothpastes and mouthwashes with claims of
whiteningwillcontinuetoposestrongcompetitiontothetoothwhiteningproducts.
However,otherfactorsthatwillhelpdrivethe salesofthecategoryinclude;product
innovations, introduction of products in new formats such as gels and pens, and
whiteningproductsthatwilloffermultibenefitssuchasprotectionagainstenamelor
gums.

SalesoforalcareproductsareforecasttogrowataCAGRof1.2%,from$4,252millionin
2012to$4,510millionin2017.

Unit sales of oral care products are forecast to rise at a rounded CAGR of 0.9% from
1,816millionunitsin2012to1,895millionunitsin2017.

Table4F5:ForecastManufacturersSalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStatesby
Category,2012to2017

$Million

Category

2012

Toothpastes

2017
1,856

1.2

Mouthwashes

799

856

1.4

Toothbrushes

741

802

1.6

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

374

410

1.9

Dentureproducts

318

322

0.3

Toothwhiteningproducts

271

264

(0.5)

4,252

4,510

1.2

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

CAGR,%

1,749

Total

OralCareProducts

Table4F6:ForecastUnitSalesofOralCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,2012to
2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

Toothpastes

CAGR,%

1,005

1,046

0.8

Toothbrushes

349

366

1.0

Mouthwashes

192

203

1.1

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

165

175

1.2

Dentureproducts

88

89

0.2

Toothwhiteningproducts

17

16

(1.2)

1,816

1,895

0.9

Total

2017

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F9

4F10

OralCareProducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

DENTUREPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

In2012,salesfordentureproductsintheUnitedStatesgrow1.3%to$318million,upfrom
$314millionin2011.

Since2007,totalsalesofdentureproductshavecontractedatacompoundannualgrowth
rate(CAGR)ofadeclining0.1%peryear.

Table4F7:HistoricalSalesofDentureProductsintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

320

2008

320

2009

319

(0.3)

2010

320

0.3

2011

314

(1.9)

2012

318

1.3

Unitsales

Unit sales of denture products grow by 0.8% to about 88million units in 2012, up from
85millionin2011.

Retailsales

In 2012, retail sales of denture products are approximately $441.3million in the United
States,up1.2%from$436millionin2011.
Dentureadhesivesaccountfor$277million,whiledenturecleanserscontributeabout
$165milliontothetotalretailsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F12

DentureProducts

Table4F8:ManufacturersSalesofDentureProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTypeandBrand,2011and2012

Producttype/brand

Company

%Ofproducttype

2011

$Million
2012

2011

2012

2011

%Oftotal
2012

DENTUREADHESIVES
Fixodent

Procter&Gamble

99

96

51.0

48.2

31.5

30.2

PoliGripa

GlaxoSmithKline

65

74

33.5

37.2

20.7

23.3

SeaBond

Combe

20

20

10.3

10.1

6.4

6.3

Wernets

GlaxoSmithKline

1.5

1.5

1.0

0.9

Effergrip

PrestigeBrands

1.0

0.5

0.6

0.3

Privatelabel

1.5

1.5

1.0

0.9

Allother

1.0

1.0

0.6

0.6

194

199

100.0

100.0

61.8

62.6

Total

DENTURECLEANSERS
Polidentb

GlaxoSmithKline

25

25

20.8

21.0

8.0

7.9

Efferdent

PrestigeBrands

26

23

21.7

19.3

8.3

7.2

PolidentOvernight

GlaxoSmithKline

16

16

13.3

13.4

5.1

5.0

EfferdentPlusc

PrestigeBrands

11

12

9.2

10.1

3.5

3.8

SmokersPolident

GlaxoSmithKline

2.5

2.5

1.0

0.9

DentuCrme/Gel/Foam

GlaxoSmithKline

2.5

2.5

1.0

0.9

Fixodent

Procter&Gamble

3.3

1.7

1.3

0.6

FreshNBrite

RevivePersonal
Products

1.7

1.7

0.6

0.6

EfferdentPowerCleanCrystals

PrestigeBrands

1.7

0.6

EfferdentPM

PrestigeBrands

0.8

1.7

0.3

0.6

PolidentforPartials

GlaxoSmithKline

0.8

0.8

0.3

0.3

Privatelabel

23

23

19.2

19.3

7.3

7.2

Allother

4.2

4.2

1.6

1.6

100.0

38.2

37.4

100.0

100.0

Total

120

119

100.0

TOTAL

314

318

aIncludesSuperPoliGrip,PoliGripUltraFresh,PoliGripFree,andSuperPoliGripComfortSealStrips.
bIncludesPolidentPowderandPolidentFreshCleanse.
cIncludesListerineFreshEfferdentPlusandEfferdentPlusWithFreshBurstListerineMouthwash.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Thedentureproductscategoryismaturewithlimitednewproductactivityin2012.
Sales grow marginally by 1.3%, supported by new product introductions by leading
marketersincludingPrestigeBrandsandGlaxoSmithKline.
PrestigeBrandslaunchesanewproduct,EfferdentPowerCleanCrystalsinearly2012.
GlaxoSmithKlinelaunchesanewdentureadhesive,PoligripforPartials.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

DentureProducts

The growing number of denture wearers in the United States supports the categorys
growth.
Itisestimatedthatthereareapproximatelymorethan35milliondenturewearersin
theUnitedStatesin2012.

Salesofthecategoryarealsosupportedbytheagingpopulation,whoneedtoreplacelost
teeth.
The U.S. population continues to age, with approximately 43million persons aged 65
andolderasof2012.

GrowthisinhibitedbythefactthattoothlessnessintheUnitedStatesisafadingproblem,
andmostbabyboomersarepredictedtoretainmajorityoftheirteeththeirentirelives.
Improved toothbrushes, toothpastes, and broader use of professional services
contributetothisphenomenon.
Expandedinsurancecoveragefordentalservicesandanincreasedfocusonhealthand
wellnessforseniorsalsocontributetobetterdentalhygiene.
With the recent advances in dental technology, most consumers opt for permanent
implants.Therearealsopredictionsthatadultstemcellswillbeusedtoregenerateor
grownewteethwithinthenextdecade.

However, the dental accessories market continues to grow, as denture cleansers expand
theirscopefromdenturesonly,toencompassthisbroadercategory.

Notablenewproducts

Table4F9:SelectNewDentureProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

GlaxoSmithKline

Poligrip

PoligripSeal&Protectadhesivestabilizespartialproblemsand
reducespotentialproblemsinthefuture

PrestigeBrands

Efferdent

EfferdentPowerCleanCrystalsdenturecleanserreducesplaque
buildupandremovesfoodparticlesthatcancausegumirritation.
Helpsremovetoughstainsfromhardtoreachplaces

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F13

4F14

DentureProducts

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Denture adhesives is the larger segment in the category and accounts for roughly 63% of
totalcategorysales,whiledenturecleansersrepresenttheremaining37%.
Salesofdentureadhesivesareupslightlyin2012by2.6%,from$194millionin2011to
$199millionin2012.
Thesalesofdenturecleansersaredownslightlyby0.8%in2012,from$120millionin
2011to$119millionin2012.
Fixodentdentureadhesivescontinuetoloseshare,withsalesdownover3%in2012,
resulting from a decrease in the promotional and advertising support for the brand.
Thebrandremainstheleaderinadhesiveproductsatjustunder50%ofthesegment
sales.
PoliGripistheonlybrandtogrowin2012,withsalesupbyalmost14%.Thebrandalso
gainsmarketshareduetothedropinFixodentssalesin2012.Introductionofanew
variant, Poligrip for Partials without Zinc, in the denture adhesives segment supports
thesalesgrowthofPoligripin2012.
Denture products containing zinc gained wide publicity in 2011 for causing
hypocupremia,hyperzincemia,andneuropathy(damagetothenerves).
Denturecleansersalesdeclineslightlyduringtheyear.GlaxoSmithKlinesPolidentand
PrestigeBrandsEfferdentremainthelargestplayers.
Intermsofindividualbrands,Polidentsbrandssalesremainflatin2012,butsalesfor
the Efferdents brands grow slightly by 2.6%, supported by the launch of Efferdent
PowerCleanCrystalsinearly2012.

Table4F10:ManufacturersSalesofDentureProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,
2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Dentureadhesives

194

199

61.8

62.6

2.6

Denturecleansers

120

119

38.2

37.4

(0.8)

Total

314

318

100.0

100.0

1.3

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

DentureProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4F11:ManufacturersSalesofDentureProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompanyand
Segment,2011and2012

$Million

Company/segment

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Adhesives

68

77

21.7

24.2

Cleansers

48

48

15.3

15.1

116

125

36.9

39.3

Adhesives

99

96

31.5

30.2

Cleansers

1.3

0.6

103

98

32.8

30.8

Cleansers

38

39

12.1

12.3

Adhesives

0.6

0.3

40

40

12.7

12.6

20

20

6.4

6.3

0.6

0.6

Cleansers

28

28

8.9

8.8

Adhesives

1.6

1.6

Total

33

33

10.5

10.4

TOTAL

314

318

100.0

100.0

GLAXOSMITHKLINE

Total
PROCTER&GAMBLE

Total
PRESTIGEBRANDS

Total
COMBE
Adhesives
REVIVEPERSONALPRODUCTS
Cleansers
ALLOTHER

GlaxoSmithKlineandProcter&Gambleremainthecategoryleaders,collectivelyaccounting
forover70%ofcategorysalesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F15

4F16

DentureProducts

In2012, salesforthecategoryleaderGlaxoSmithKlineincrease7.8%to$125millionfrom
$116millionin2011.
GlaxoSmithKlineconstitutes39.3%ofthemarketsharein2012,upfrom36.9%in2011.
GlaxoSmithKline is the secondleading marketer of denture adhesives, behind
Procter& Gamble, capturing almost onequarter of the categorys market share in
2012.Thecompanysdentureadhesivessalesrisebynearly$9millionduringtheyear.
The companys growth in the denture adhesives segment is supported by the
introductionofanewadhesive,PoligripforPartials.
ThemarketerremoveszincfromitsPoligripbrandstopromoteitssalesin2012aszinc
indentureproductsisfoundtocausehealthproblems.
Dentureadhesivesaccountforabout62%ofthecompanysdentureproductsales.
GlaxoSmithKline continues to be the leading marketer of denture cleansers in 2012,
withover40%segmentshare.Polidentisthetopbrandinthesegment.

Procter&Gamblessalesdropby$5millionto$98millionin2012.
FixodentistheonlybrandmarketedbyProcter&Gambleinthecategory.
Thecompanystotalmarketsharedecreasesslightlyto30.8%in2012,from32.8%in
2011.
Procter& Gamble decreases its advertising and promotional support for its Fixodent
brandin2012,leadingtothesalesdecline.
Lack of new product activity also offsets the growth of the brand in the category in
2012.
Fixodent, the top brand in the denture adhesives segment, drops by 4.9% in 2012 to
$96million.

Prestige Brands maintains its sales unchanged in the category, at $40million in 2012, the
sameasin2011.
Efferdentisamajorplayerinthedenturecleanserssegment.In2012,salesgrow2.6%
to $39million from $38million in 2011, supported by the success of its new launch,
EfferdentPowerCleanCrystalsinearly2012.
The sales of Effergrip decline by $1million in 2012. Effergrip is a small brand in the
dentureadhesivessegment.

Privatelabel

Privatelabel products contribute to sales of $26million or 8.2% of the categorys sales in


2012,withsalesbeingthesameasin2011.
Privatelabelproductsareprominentinthedenturecleanserssegmentwith19.3%or
approximately onefifth the share of the segments sales in 2012. Privatelabel sales
rank third, following GlaxoSmithKlines Polident and Prestige Brands Efferdent in the
denturecleanserssegment.
Inthedentureadhesivessegment,privatelabelproductsaccountforjust$3millionin
sales,capturing1.5%marketsharein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

DentureProducts

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

As in 2011, mass merchandisers remain the most important distribution channel for
dentureproductsin2012.
Massmerchandisersarethemostsignificantdistributionchannelwith39%ofsales.
Sharesoffoodstoresanddrugstoresarealsounchangedat32%and29%,respectively,
in2012.

Table4F12:ManufacturersSalesofDentureProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

39

39

Foodstores

32

32

Drugstores

29

29

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

GlaxoSmithKlineremainstheleadingadvertiserinthedenturescategoryin2012withmore
than$18.9millionintraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)foritsproducts.
ThecompanymarketsfourbrandsinthecategoryincludingPoliGrip,Polident,Dentu
Crme, and Wernets. In 2012, PoliGrip receives almost TME of $12.8 million, and
Polidentreceives$6.1millionTME.
Thecompanyallocatesitsentireadvertisingbudgettotelevision,withnoneallocated
totheprintmedia.
Themarketeralsooffersdiscountcouponsof$1.00onitsPolidentandPoligripbrands.
However, GlaxoSmithKlines 2012 spending is 9.1% lower than its 2011 TME of
$20.8million.

CombehasthesecondlargestTMEinthecategory.
TMEforitsSeaBonddentureadhesiveproductisabout$3.8millionin2012,downby
24.0%from$5millionin2011.
In 2012, the company spends its total advertising budget on television, with none
allocatedtotheprintmedia.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F17

4F18

DentureProducts

Procter&GambleranksthirdinTMEin2012,allocating$1.5millioninTMEtoFixodent.
Television advertisements remain the most preferred promotional method for the
marketerinthecategory.
Procter&Gambles2012advertisingspendisalmost77%lowerthanits2011TMEof
$6.5million.
Virtually, all of the marketing budget is spent on television advertisements and
syndicatedpromotions.
Themarketeralsooffersdiscountcouponsof$1.00onitsFixodentbrand.

TMEbybrandareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

Sales for denture products are expected to grow marginally by 0.3%, over the forecast
periodsupportedbyacontinuousincreaseintheaverageageofAmericans.

Agingpopulationandnewproductinnovationsareexpectedtodrivethesalesofdenture
productsovertheforecastperiod.
The U.S. population continues to age, with approximately 43million persons aged 65
andolderasof2012.
Estimates show that the aged population is expected to almost double, to
approximately90millionby2050.
Irrespective of the limited new product activity, line extensions and reformulations
continuetobeintroduced,retainingconsumersinterestinthecategory.
With growth in the dental accessories category, cleansing brands may also see
moderategrowthifthemarketerscanpositioncleansingproductsforuseinthisarea.

Limited privatelabel activity in the category is expected to help the growth of branded
productsinthecategoryovertheforecastperiod.
Privatelabel products have not been able to establish a significant foothold in the
category and, therefore, do not exert significant downward pressure on dollar sales.
Thistrendisexpectedtocontinue.
Wideruseofpermanentimplantsandimprovementinoralcareismostlikelytolimit
thecategoryssalesduringthenextfiveyears.
Toavoidthehassleslinkedwithdentures,consumersareoptingfordentalimplants.
Expandedprofessionalservices,suchasrootcanals,havebecomeincreasinglypopular
amongconsumersastheseserviceshelppreserveoralhealth.
Advancements in dentistry, along with improved oral hygiene, will help people
preservetheirnaturalteeth.
Newtoothpastes,toothbrushes,andotherproductshelpconsumerstakebettercareof
theirteethathome.
The above factors will affect the demand for denture products and as a result prices
areexpectedtoslowlydecline.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

DentureProducts

SalesofdentureproductsareforecasttogrowataCAGRof0.3%from$318millionin2012
to$322millionin2017.

Unit volume is expected to grow at a CAGR of 0.2%, from 88million packages in 2012 to
approximately89millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F19

4F20

DentureProducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Salesoflipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentsatthemanufacturerslevelincreaseby4.8%from
$357millionin2011to$374millionin2012.
Since2007,manufacturerssalesoflipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentshaveincreasedat
acompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.1%peryear.

Table4F13:HistoricalSalesofLipBalms,Jellies,and
TreatmentsintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

337

2008

351

4.2

2009

342

(2.6)

2010

347

1.5

2011

357

2.9

2012

374

4.8

Unitsales

Unitsalesoflipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentsincreasefrom159millionpackagesin2011to
165millionpackagesin2012,up3.8%.

Retailsales

Retailsalesoflipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentsareup5.8%,totaling$482millionin2012
from$455millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F22

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

Table4F14:ManufacturersSalesofLipBalms,Jellies,andTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,
2011and2012

$Million

Brand

Company

Chapstick

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Pfizer

82

79

23.0

21.1

BurtsBees

TheCloroxCompany

53

58

14.8

15.5

Blistex

Blistex

52

49

14.6

13.1

Carmex

CarmaLaboratories

31

31

8.7

8.3

EOS

EOSProducts

19

2.5

5.1

MaryKay

MaryKay

17

17

4.8

4.5

Nivea

Beiersdorf

14

16

3.9

4.3

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

14

15

3.9

4.0

LipFusion

FusionBeauty

14

12

3.9

3.2

Mentholatum

RothoPharmaceutical

10

10

2.8

2.7

Neosporin

Johnson&Johnson

2.2

1.6

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

1.7

1.6

VaselineLipTherapy

Unilever

1.7

1.6

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

1.1

1.6

Clinique

EsteLauder

1.4

1.3

Avon

Avon

1.4

1.1

Lancme

L'Oral

0.6

0.5

MAC

EsteLauder

0.6

0.5

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

Privatelabel

11

2.5

2.9

Allother

13

19

3.6

5.1

357

374

100.0

100.0

Total

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Salesincreaseaslipcareproductsaredevelopedasanauxiliarytothesuncareregime.
Sales for the category increase because consumers purchase newinnovative lip balm
productsthatprovidemultiplebenefits,suchasantioxidantsandsunprotection.
Lip balms that provide protection against sun, tinted lip balms, and lip balms which
provide other treatment benefits perform well. Marketers such as Margaritaville and
Rohto Pharmaceuticals introduce lip balms with sun protection benefits for their
respectivebrandsin2012.
MarketerssuchasEOSProducts,TheCloroxCompany,andBeiersdorfofferlipbalms
thatcarrySPFratings,claimUVprotection,andfeatureantioxidantactivityin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

In2012,severalmarketersintroducenewproductsinthecategory,thatstimulatesales.
BurtsBees(Clorox),Blistex(Blistex),andNivea(Beiersdorf)productlinesexpandwith
theintroductionofnewvariantsin2012.BeiersdorflaunchesNiveaLipButtersinfour
flavors,Blistexenhancesitslipbalmportfoliowiththeadditionoftwonewproducts
MoistureMeltandSimpleandSensitivewhilethreenewshadesareaddedtoBurts
BeesLipShimmercollection.
EOS Products lip balms, especially Smooth Sphere, are gaining popularity among
women consumers. In 2012, the company launches a limited edition Alice in
Wonderlandcollectionwhichincludesathreepackcollection.
People increasingly buy products that comprises natural or organic ingredients. For
example, Burts Bees expands its lip balm product portfolio with the introduction of
UltraMoisturizingLipTreatmentwithKokumButter,whichdoesnotincludeparabens
phthalatesorpetrochemicals.

Sales of lip care products are expected to increase in winter, when consumers need to
protecttheirlipsfromharshconditionsandtorepairthechappingthatcanresultfromthe
weather,andfromcoldandflu.

This categorys products do not have an identifiable shelf space with retailers. They are
mostlyexhibitedinthecough/coldsectionsoratthefrontend/registers.
Most lip care products continue to be displayed in the cough/cold sections or at the
frontend/registers.
In some instances, dueto the brands popularity, the lip balm products are placed in
othersections.Niveaslipproductsarealsosoldwithinthehandandbodysectionsand
Burts Bees lip balms are offered alongside the companys other products in the
personalcareaisle.

Lipsticksandlipglossescompetewiththecategorysproductsataminorlevel.
Aminorsectionofsalesforthelipbalmproductsisoffsetbytheincreasingpresenceof
moisturizingingredientsinthelipsticksandlipglossesformulations.
Lipsticksandlipglossesenhancetheappearanceoflips,whilelipbalmismoreoften
usedasanalterativeproduct.
However,mostwomencontinuetousebothlipbalmsandtintedproductsfordifferent
purposes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F23

4F24

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

Notablenewproducts

Table4F15:SelectNewLipBalms,Jellies,andTreatmentsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Beiersdorf

Nivea

BeiersdorfintroducesNiveaLipbutterbalmsinjarformatsthatis
availableinfourdifferentflavors:RaspberryRoseKiss,Caramel
CreamKiss,VanillaandMacadamiaKiss,andSmoothKiss

Blistex

Blistex

Blistexenhancesitslipbalmcategoryportfoliowithtwonew
products:MoistureMeltthatprovidesmoisturizationandlong
lastingresistancetodrynessandSimpleandSensitivewithno
addeddyesorfragrances

BodyDrench

LipDrench

Infusedwithbeeswaxcomplexandisavailableinsixflavors,
relieveschappedlipsandprotectsitfromfreeradicals

CarmaLaboratories

Carmex

OrangeflavoredCarmexcreamylipconditioner,infusedwith13
moisturizersincludingcocoabutter.Anothervariant;Carmex
ultramoisturizinglipbalminpomegranateflavor

BurtsBees

BurtsBeesintroducesUltraMoisturizingLipTreatmentwith
KokumButter,whichhelpssootheandrestorelips.Thebrand
addsthreenewshadestoitsLipShimmercollection:cherry,
plum,andstrawberry

EOSProducts

EOS

EOSlauncheslimitededitioncollectioninthreeflavors:
WatermelonWonderland,SweetVanillaNonsense,and
BlueberryPotion.ItalsoinstallsPomegranateRaspberrySmooth
SphereLipBalmasapermanentflavor

Margaritaville

ParrotHead

FloridaysMoisturizingLipBalmwithSPF50.Thealoehydrating
complex500formulaisenrichedwithjojoba,avocado,cocoa
butter,andvitaminEtosootheandnourishlips

Rohto
Pharmaceuticals

Softlips

FournewvariantsSoftlipsJackFrostinglipbalm,Softlips
peppermintsticklipbalm,SoftlipsMarshmallowGhost,and
SoftlipsGlossprovidesunprotection

TheCloroxCompany

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

The stick form of lip balms, jellies, and treatments continues to dominate the majority of
thecategoryssalesin2012.
In 2012, sales of products in sticks grow with the introduction of several new Burts
BeesandEOSproducts.
Niveaintroducesnewlipbutterswhichareavailableinjarformatsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

Table4F16:ManufacturersSalesofLipBalms,Jellies,andTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesby
ProductType,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Sticks

242

251

67.8

67.1

3.7

Tubes

73

73

20.4

19.5

Jars

36

37

10.1

9.9

2.8

13

1.7

3.5

116.7

357

374

100.0

100.0

4.8

Allothera
Total

aIncludesspheres.

COMPETITION

Bybrand

Chapstick(Pfizer)persistsastheleadingbrandinthecategoryin2012.
The brands sales slide 3.7% to $79 million in 2012 from $82 million in 2011. Market
share of the brand declines as consumers increasingly buy natural products. The
company has not introduced any new lip balm products in 2011 and 2012. Pfizers
latest product launch in the category was in 2010, when the marketer introduced its
UltraSmoothlineinfourflavors.
Itconstitutes21.1%ofthetotalmarketin2012,downfromitspreviousyearsshareof
23.0%.
In2012,themarketershiftsitsadvertisementspendingfromtelevisiontomagazines;
andcontinuestousetheradioandtheInternetdisplaysasaddedmedia.
Pfizeristhethirdleadingadvertiserinthecategory,withaTMEof$5millionin2012.

BurtsBees(TheCloroxCompany)remainsaheadofBlistexandisthesecondlargestbrand
in2012.
Manufacturers sales increase 9.4% to $58 million in 2012 from $53 million in 2011.
Burts Bees products benefit as demand shifts from syntheticbased and petroleum
basedlipproductstothoseproductswhicharemorenatural.
Market share rises to 15.5% in 2012 from 14.8% in 2011. The Clorox Company
apportions$2.6millionintraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)in2012,ofwhich99.1%
isspentonmagazineadvertising.
Thebrandpromotesviaprintadvertisementsandsocialmedianetwork.In2012,the
companyinitiatesBurtsBeeslipbalmnaturalchampioncontest,inwhichpeopleenter
the contest by posting a photo of themselves with the brands lip balm. The winner
receives a three day trip including airfare, hotel, and ground transportation to Burts
BeesHeadquartersinDurham,privateconcerttickets,four$150.00spavouchers,and
$500.00ofBurtsBeesproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F25

4F26

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

BurtsBeesFacebookfanbasetouches1millionin2012,upsignificantlyfrom560,000
in2011.
The company increased its distribution channels through specialty natural retailers,
massretailers,anddepartmentstoresin2011,whichcontinuestoaidinincreasingthe
brandssalesin2012.

In2012,Blistex(Blistex)isthethirdleadingbrandinthecategory,regardlessofadeclinein
itssalesby5.8%to$49millionin2012from$52millionin2011.
The brands market share has dropped to 13.1% in 2012 from 14.6% in 2011. Share
gains by other brands, such as EOS, Burts Bees, and Nivea, cut down the brands
marketposition.
The marketer attempts to catch up with its rivals by introducing more products that
containnaturalingredients.
Thebrandlaunchestwonewproductsin2012:MoistureMeltandSimpleandSensitive.
Moisture Melt is a hydrating lip balm with shea butter softbeads in a base of aloe
Vera;andSimpleandSensitive,ahypoallergenicformulawithcocoabutter,jojobaoil,
andsunflowerseedoilthatmoisturizessensitivelipswithoutcausinganyirritation.
Blistexformatsincludesticks,tubes,andjars.
BlistexistheleadingadvertiserinthecategorywithaTMEof$9.4millionin2012,up
from$3.7millionin2011.Themarketerapportions$5.0millionor52.6%ofthetotal
TMEtoprintmediaand$4.0millionor42.5%oftotalTMEtothetelevisionadvertisting.

Carmex (Carma Laboratories) is the fourthlargest brand in the category with its market
shareat8.3%in2012,downfrom8.7%in2011.
Thebrandssalesfor2012areestimatedat$31million,thesameasits2011levels.
In spite of being one of the leading players in the lip care segment, Carmex has an
insignificantamountallocatedasmediaexpenditures.Thislimitsthegrowthprospect
forthebrand.
ThebrandintroducesorangeflavoredCarmexcreamylipconditionerandpomegranate
flavoredCarmexultramoisturizinglipbalmin2012.
Carmexlipbalmsareavailableintube,jar,andstickformats.

NewcomerEOSProductsjumpstofifthpositioninthelipbalmcategory,withsalesforEOS
lipbalmsgrowing111.1%in2012,to$19millionfrom$9millionin2011.
Sales for the EOS smooth sphere lip balm continue to increase with its agressive
marketingtacticsdesignedin2011.
The brand creates awareness by advertising in magazines, such as Marie Claire, OK!,
andCosmopolitanandbymaximizingtheproductsvisualimpactonshelf.
Innovativeproductformsandpackaging,whichisthemaindifferentiatingstrategyof
themarketer,resultsinsalesincrease.
EOSlipbalmproductscommandamarketshareof5.1%in2012,upfrom2.5%in2011.
The lip care products are made of natural and organic ingredients, which are
increasinglyindemand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

The marketer apportions TME of $8.5 million and has the second largest spending of
mediaexpenditurein2012.Printmedia,socialnetworks,andsamplingarethefavored
modesofpromotingitsproducts.
In2012,BeiersdorfedgesoutBath&BodyWorks,anditsNiveassalesareestimatedat
seventhposition,justafterMaryKay.Thebrandssalesriseto$16millionin2012from
$14millionin2011,anincreaseof14.3%.
Niveaslowerpricingoflipcareproductsanditsbrandimageboostitsgrowth.
Niveasmarketshareinthecategoryincreasesfrom3.9%in2011to4.3%in2012.
Thebrandoccupiesthefourthpositioninthecategoryintermsofmediaexpenditure,
with the most popular medium being print advertisements. The marketer spends
$4.1milliontopromoteitsNiveabrandinmagazines.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Mass merchandisers and drug stores remain the key distribution channels for lip balms,
jellies,andtreatmentsin2012.

Table4F17:ManufacturersSalesofLipBalms,Jellies,and
TreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012
%Oftotal
Retailoutlet

2011

Massmerchandisers

32

33

Drugstores

27

27

Foodstores

20

20

Specialtystores

11

11

Directsales

Departmentstores

100

100

Total

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F27

4F28

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Promotionoflipbalmscontinuestoremainstrongin2012.
Print advertisements represent the most important channel of advertising for this
category, followed by television. Marketers spend $26.8 million or 81.2% of the total
TMEinprintmediaand$4.0millionor12.1%oftotalTMEintelevisionadvertising.
Specialvaluepacksandofferscontinuetobeutilizedaspopularmarketingstrategies.
In2012,BlistexandCarmexoffercouponsworth$0.65and$0.30,respectively.In2012,
Beiersdorfreports1millionfansonitsFacebookandextendscoupons,afterwatchinga
shortNiveavideo,forafreeNivealipbalm.
Mostmarketerspromotetheirbrandsonsocialmedia,suchasFacebook,Twitter,and
YouTube, since this media has a wider reach and is more personal in nature. New
product launches, latest discounts and offers, and other events are advertised in this
media.

TotalTMEforthelipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategoryincreasetonearly$33millionin
2012,upfrom$27millionin2011.
BlistexincreasesitsTMEallocationby46.9%in2012,to$9.4millionfrom$6.4million
in2011.
EOS Products allocates about $8.4million in advertisement spending, up 75.0% from
$4.8millionin2011.
Pfizer,thecategoryleaderwithitstopbrandChapstick,spends$5.0millionin2012,up
51.5%from$3.3millionin2011.
TheCloroxCompanyspends$2.6milliontoadvertiseitsBurtsBeesbrandcompeting
inthelipbalmcategory.Themarketerallocates99.7%ofitstotalTMEtosupportitsLip
Shimmercollection.
Carmex, in spite of being one of the major brands in the category, invests only
$1.2millioninTMEduring2012,downfrom$1.7millionin2011.

Blistexisthelargestspenderonadvertisinginthiscategoryin2012.
Thecompanyallocates52.6%ofthetotalTMEor$5.0milliontotheprintmedia.Romance
isthekeycomponentofadvertisinginmagazines,thatfeatureslogans,suchasLipService
isagoodthingandBecausefourstarProtectionisn'tenoughforfivestarmoments.
Thesecondmostpopularmediumofadvertisementistelevision.TaglinessuchasDiscover
Bliss.DiscoverBlistex.areemployedtoinduceconsumerinterest.Blistexspends42.5%of
totalTMEor$4.0milliontopromoteitslipbalmproductsinthismedium.
BlistexwebsitehasasectioncalledLipTipswhicheducatesconsumersaboutcommonlip
problems,offerstipsonlipcare,andfeatureslipquizzes.

EOSProductsisthesecondlargestmediaspenderonadvertisinginthecategoryin2012.
The company spends $8.4 million or 99.1% of its TME on magazine advetisements. In
magazineadvertisements,theproductsaremadetoresembleobjectsineverydaylife,such
asabasketofapples,eggsinnests,andberriesinblenders.
The marketer actively promotes its brand on social networking sites. EOS Facebook page
allows consumers to learn of new product introductions, the latest deals and offers
availableatvariousstores,andotherevents.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

Pfizer, the thirdlargest spender on advertising in this category in 2012, increases its
advertisingexpendituresfromthepreviousyear.Themarketerspends$5.0millioninTME
in2012,up13.6%from$4.4millionspentin2011.
In 2012, Pfizer focuses its advertising spend primarily on magazines (76.1%), radio
(11.7%),andpointofpurchasedisplays(11.2%).

Beiersdorf spends $4.1 million to promote its Aquaphor and Nivea lip care brands. The
marketeradvertisesitslipcarebrandbyhostingconteststhroughthesocialmedia.
In 2012, Beiersdorf promotes its Nivea lip brand through its Kiss of the Year contest,
where fans can share their love story on Facebook and win an opportunity to
participateintheNewYearsEvekissonNiveaKissStageinTimesSquare.Thecouple
with the most public votes wins an all expenses paid trip to New York City to meet
NiveaambassadorsMarioLopezandCourtneyMazza,twoVIPticketstotheNewYears
Eve party at Hard Rock Caf, and a feature in the U.S. Weekly magazine which
highlightstheirnewyearskiss.

Details on TME by brand are included in the Advertising section of this report and in the
database.

OUTLOOK

Thelipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategoryisforecasttogrowataCAGRof1.9%inthe
fiveyearforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Brandawarenessislikelytoincreaseascompaniesraisetheirpromotionalbudget.
As the presence of lip care products increase across distribution channels, especially
massmerchandisers,thecategoryssalesarelikelytoincrease.
Salesofhighpricedlipbalmswithadditionalbenefits,suchasantiagingarelikelyto
increaseandsupportthecategorysgrowth.
Inthelipbalm,jellies,andtreatmentscategory,thetopsixmarketersholdacombined
marketshareofalmost68.0%in2012.Duetobroadpromotionalmeasurestakenby
thesecompanies,privatelabelproductswillnotbemajorcompetitorsinthelipbalm
productscategory.
Marketers are likely to adopt new strategies, such as package innovations and trial
sizestoattractnewcustomers.

Newproductinnovationswithincreasedfeatureswillinduceconsumerinterest.
Thereisanincreasingdemandforlipproductsthatprovidelipplumping,antioxidant,
andsunprotectionbenefitsapartfromsolelymoisturizingthelips.
Tinted lip balms are likely to witness sales increase as they compete directly against
lipsticksandlipglosses.
Risingconsumerawarenessaboutthebenefitsofnaturalandorganicproductswillhelp
increasethesalesofsuchproducts.
Manufacturersstrivetowardsteenagersremainingloyaltotheirbrandandcontinuing
theuseoftheirlipcareproducts,sincelipcareproductsaremostlyusedbyteenagers
toagreatextent.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F29

4F30

LipBalms,Jellies,andTreatments

However,somefactorsrestraingrowthofthelipbalmcategory.
Warmerclimateintheregioncouldimpactthesales.Demandforlipbalms,jellies,and
treatmentproductsaregreaterduringthecoldclimatethanatothertimesoftheyear.
As stronger and brighter lip colors become popular, women will increasingly select
lipsticksovertintedlipbalms.

Sales are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 1.9% to reach $410 million in 2017, up from
$374millionin2012.

Unit sales of the lip balm category are expected to increase at a CAGR of 1.2% from
165millionpackagesin2012to$175millionpackagesin2017.
Unit sales grow slower than dollar sales as the premiumpriced products are
increasinglybecomingpopular.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

MOUTHWASHES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesofmouthwashesincrease2.2%in2012astheeconomycontinuesto
recoverandnewproductformulationsoffermultipurposeproductstomeetmanyneeds.

Since 2007, sales of mouthwashes increase at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
1.7%peryeartoreach$799millionin2012.

Table4F18:HistoricalSalesofMouthwashesintheUnitedStates,
2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

735

2008

779

6.0

2009

761

(2.3)

2010

759

(0.3)

2011

782

3.0

2012

799

2.2

Unitsales

Unitsalesofmouthwashesgrow2.0%in2012to192.0millionpackagesfrom188.5million
packagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofmouthwashestotal$1,035.4millionin2012,up2.6%from$1,009.2millionin
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F32

Mouthwashes

Table4F19:ManufacturersSalesofMouthwashesintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Brand

Company

2011

2012

Listerine

Johnson&Johnson

336

340

Crest

Procter&Gamble

105

Scope

Procter&Gamble

Act

%Oftotal
2011

2012

43.0

42.6

110

13.4

13.8

75

76

9.6

9.5

Sanofi

63

66

8.1

8.3

Biotene

GlaxoSmithKline

19

21

2.4

2.6

TomsofMaine

ColgatePalmolive

12

12

1.5

1.5

Plax

Johnson&Johnson

10

10

1.3

1.3

TheraBreath

CaliforniaBreathClinic

0.8

0.8

Lavoris

CharlesFloraConsumerProducts

0.3

0.3

Cepacol

ReckittBenckiser

0.3

0.3

Listermint

Johnson&Johnson

0.3

0.3

Rembrandt

Johnson&Johnson

0.3

0.3

OralB

Procter&Gamble

0.1

0.1

Targona

GlaxoSmithKline

0.3

Viadenta

ColgatePalmolive

0.3

Fluorigarda

ColgatePalmolive

0.1

Privatelabel

129

135

16.5

16.9

Allother

13

14

1.7

1.8

782

799

100.0

100.0

Total

aDiscontinued.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Themultibenefitmouthwashessupportthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Mouthwashesthatoffermultiplebenefits,suchasteethstrengthening,helpingrebuild
enamel,andpreventingcavitiessupportthegrowthofthecategoryin2012.ActTotal
Care is one of those products which gained from providing multibenefits including
teethstrengtheningandbreathfreshening.
Products that provide added benefits are important to consumers as these products
drivegrowthintheoralcareproductclass.
Among the multibenefit products, whitening mouthwashes see good growth as
consumersareincreasinglyturningtowhiteningoralcareproducts.
The sales of mouthwashes are also supported by consumers turning to easy, instant
solutionsforpreventingbadbreathandkillinggerms.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

Mouthwashes

Listerine(Johnson&Johnson),thelargestbrandinthecategory,seesbetterresultsfromits
variant Listerine Zero, which is alcoholfree and provides protection against bad breath,
therebykillinggerms.
SecondleadingbrandCrest(Procter&Gamble)seesgrowthof4.8%in2012,andleads
the field by focusing on the tween segment. Crest continues to invest in its Crest
ProHealthCompleteproductsduringtheyear.ProHealthisthefirstevercollectionfor
kids aged 8 to 12 years, with flavors and packaging designed just for them. This line
includestheAnticavityFluorideRinse.
AlthoughtheCrestProHealthvariantreceivesalotofcomplaintsthatitturnstheteeth
yellow, the brand still benefits from the launch of Crest 3D White mouthwash range
whichfeatureswhiteningasitsmainbenefit.

Thecategorysgrowthisalsosupportedbysmallbrandsthatcontinuetopostlowgrowth.
Act(Sanofi)whichfeaturesanalcoholfreeformulahasan8.3%share.
TomsofMaine(ColgatePalmolive)isanaturallypositionedproductwitha1.5%share.
TheraBreath(CaliforniaBreathClinic),whichspecificallyaddresseshalitosis,hasa0.8%
marketshare.
Rembrandt(Johnson&Johnson)isawhiteningproductwith0.3%share.

Notablenewproducts

Table4F20:SelectNewMouthwashesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

OpticWhiteportfoliohasexpandedwithnewRefreshingMintmouthwash
andAnticavitySparklingMinttoothpaste,claimstoeffectivelywhiten
teethandprotectagainstfuturestains

Johnson&Johnson

Listerine

TotalCareZeroinFreshMintvariant,preventscavities,restoresenamel,
strengthensteeth,preventsbadbreath,andcleansthewholemouth

Johnson&Johnson

Listerine

Ultracleanmouthwashcontainsantitartaringredientforcleaner,brighter
teeth,clinicallyproventoremoveplaqueandkillgerms.Itisavailablein
twovariants:ArcticFreshandFreshCitrus

Procter&Gamble

Crest

Crest3DWhiteArcticFreshIcyCoolMintOralRinseisinfusedwithatriple
actionformulathatwhitensteethbyremovingsurfacestains,helpsprotect
againsttheformationofnewstains,andfreshensbreath

Procter&Gamble

Crest

CrestProHealthClinicalAntiplaquerinse,offersprotectionfromplaque
andgingivitis,clinicallyproventoreduceplaqueandhelppreventplaque
regrowth,andclinicallyproventohelppreventandreversegingivitis

Procter&Gamble

Scope

Outlastmouthwashinfusedwithoutlasttechnologythatbindstightlyto
selectreceptorsinthemouth,creatingacool,refreshingsensationthat
lastslonger

Sanofi

Act

TotalCareinfusedwithnaturalbotanicalsthataregentleonsoremouths,
alcoholfree,andstrengthenstheteeth.Itisavailableintwovariants:Mild
MintandTropicalBreeze

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F33

4F34

Mouthwashes

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4F21:ManufacturersSalesofMouthwashesintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Johnson&Johnson

350

354

44.8

44.3

1.1

Procter&Gamble

181

187

23.1

23.4

3.3

Sanofi

63

66

8.1

8.3

4.8

GlaxoSmithKline

21

21

2.7

2.6

ColgatePalmolive

15

12

1.9

1.5

(20.0)

Allother

152

159

21.4

21.4

2.4

Total

782

799

100.0

100.0

2.2

Johnson&Johnsonremainstheleadingmarketerinthecategoryin2012,withtotalsalesof
$354 million, up 1.1% from $350 million in 2011. In 2012, the market share decreases to
44.3%,downfrom44.8%in2011.
Listerineisthecompanyslargestmouthwashbrandandisalsothepreeminentleader
inthiscategory.
Listerines sales grow 1.2% from $336 million to $340 million in 2012. Growth of the
Listerine brand is supported by the strong performance of its alcoholfree variants:
ListerineZeroandTotalCare.
The company continues to stress on the importance of using Listerine twice a day in
ordertohave24hourprotection.
IncreasedmarketingandnewproductactivitysupportthesalesoftheListerinebrand
in2012.
SalesofPlaxremainat$10millioneachin2011and2012duetoalackofpromotional
supportandexcitementforthebrand.
Sales of Listermint and Rembrandt remain low at a rounded $2 million each in 2012,
sameas2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

Mouthwashes

Procter&Gambleisthesecondlargestmarketerinthiscategorywith23.4%share,upfrom
23.1%in2011.
Crest,thesecondlargestbrandinthecategory,experiencesasalesincreaseof4.8%in
2012withtheintroductionoftwonewproducts:CrestProHealthClinicalAntiPlaque
RinseandScopeOutlastmouthwash.
Crestsmarketshareincreasesfrom13.4%in2011to13.8%in2012.
The new Crest 3D Whitening range includes Arctic Fresh Rinse and Glamorous White
Rinse that help boost brand sales. Also, the cross marketing with the OralB
toothbrusheshelpsbroadenawarenessanddemandforthebrand.
Scope rises 1.3% in 2012, benefiting from new branding and packaging in 2012, with
salesreaching$76millionin2012from$75millionin2011.
ScopeOutlastmouthwash,introducedin2012,booststhebrandssaleswithitsstrong
performance.

Sanofiisthethirdleadingmarketerwith8.3%marketshare,upfrom8.1%in2011.
Salesincrease4.8%from$63millionin2011to$66millionin2012.
ThesalesgrowthforSanofiissupportedbyitsnewlaunchActtotalcare.
Productsformulatedforchildrenarebecomingincreasinglypopularwithparentsasa
meanstoboth,ensurehigherproductsafetyforchildrenandencouragechildrentouse
theproduct.ActsAnticavityKidsrinseforchildrenispopularamongconsumers.

Privatelabel

Themarketshareforprivatelabelproductsincreasesto16.9%in2012,upfrom16.5%in
2011.
Salesgrow4.7%to$135millionin2012,from$129millionin2011.
Privatelabel products have the secondlargest share of the market after Johnson &
JohnsonsListerine.
Improvedformulations,lowerpricepoints,multiplebenefits,andimprovedpackaging
contributetothesalesofprivatelabels.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In2012,theshareofretaildistributionofmassmerchandisers,foodstores,anddrugstores
remainsflatwith2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F35

4F36

Mouthwashes

Table4F22:ManufacturersSalesofMouthwashesintheUnitedStates
byRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

46

46

Foodstores

29

29

Drugstores

25

25

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

In 2012, promotional activity for mouthwashes focuses heavily on television commercials


andmediaadvertisinginmagazines,withlimitedfocusonInternetdisplayadvertisements.

Johnson & Johnson is the leading advertiser with traceable media expenditures (TME) of
$55.9millionin2012,downby21.6%from$71.3millionin2011.
About threefourths of the companys advertising spend is allocated to television
commercials,withmostoftheremainingquarterspentonmagazineadvertisements.
All of the companys advertising support is allocated to the Listerine brand, with no
spendingonminorbrandsListermint,Plax,andRembrandt.
The company offers discounts coupons ranging from $1.00 to $2.00 on Listerines
websitetopromotethesalesofitsproducts.
The Listerine brands website also provides tips for maintaining a clean and healthy
mouth.

Procter&Gambleisthesecondlargestadvertiserformouthwashes,spending$22.0million
in2012.
TMEaredividedprimarilybetweentwobrandsCrestProHealthandScopebothof
whichhavenewproductlaunchesin2012.
Procter & Gamble allocates approximately $17.2 million to promote its Crest Pro
Healthbrand,andtheremaining$4.8millionisallocatedtotheScopebrand.
Advertising spend is primarily allocated to magazines and television commercials in
2012.Thecompanyallocates$18.0millionofitsTMEonmagazineadvertisementsand
$1.3millionontelevisionadvertising.

SanofiranksaclosethirdinTME,spending$23.6millionin2012.
Almostallofthecompanysadvertisingspendisallocatedtotelevisioncommercials.
About threefourths of advertising expenditures go to support Act Total Care Dry
Mouthformula,withaboutonefourthcollectivelygoingtoActAnticavityKidsFluoride
RinseandActRestoringMouthwash.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

Mouthwashes

4F37

Advertising increasingly differentiates products based on the ability to deliver added


benefits.

DetailsonTMEbybrandareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

The mouthwashes category is mature and, over the next five years, will experience
relativelylowsalesgrowth.

This category will continue to face stiff competition from toothpastes with allinone
benefits.
Toothpastes are increasingly incorporating mouthwash properties in product
formulationstherebygivingintensecompetitiontothecategory.

Mouthwashesthatoffermultibenefitsareexpectedtosupportthecategorysgrowthover
theforecastperiod.
Mouthwashesthatoffermultiplebenefits,suchasteethwhitening,protectionagainst
bad breath, and enamel protection are expected to see good sales growth over the
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Multibenefit mouthwashes are more attractive to consumers as they are more
convenientandaffordablethanthealternativeofhavingtopurchasemultipleproduct
types.
However,themouthwashescategoryisnotconsideredasanecessity,ascomparedto
toothpastesandtoothbrushes.Whenfacedwithbudgetaryconstraints,consumerswill
morereadilyspendontoothpastes.

Productsthatarepositionedtoprovidebetterresults,suchaskillinggerms,areexpectedto
seegrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Increasingawarenessamongconsumersregardingoralhygienewillalsoboostthesales
ofmultibenefitmouthwashes.
However, if marketers do not support their brands with adequate TME, then further
growthofthecategoryislikelytoberestricted.

Newproductinnovationswithbetterformulaswillcatertothegrowthofmouthwashesin
theforecastperiod.
Better promotional and advertisements support for the mouthwashes category will
supportthesalesgrowthofthecategory.
Companywebsiteswillcontinuetopromoteproductsinexcitingmultimediaformatsto
enticeteensandyoungerconsumers.
MarketersareexpectedtousetheInternetandsocialmediaonalargerscaletoreach
youngerandmoretechnologicallysavvyconsumersinthefuture.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F38

Mouthwashes

There are certain problems related to aging that result from increased medication that
include dry mouth and bad breath; these factors present opportunities for new product
innovationandbrandpromotion.
Toothpastesareincreasinglyincorporatingmouthwashesinproductformulations.
Dry mouth will continue to plague consumers, as a result of aging and higher use of
medicationwithadversesideeffects.
Marketers have been unable to convert a large numbers of consumers who do not
currentlyusemouthwashproductsintoregularusers,whichhaslimitedthecategorys
growth.

Furthermore,theyoungersegmentsofthepopulation,suchaschildren,representagrowth
opportunity,andsomebrands,suchasAct(Sanofi)arepursuingthissegmentaggressively.
Agespecific oral care sales will continue to experience strong growth, as marketers
refreshtheirbrandswithnewofferingsbasedonspecificneeds
Marketers, such as Procter & Gamble and Sanofi are expected to launch products
specific to tweens (aged 8 to 12), such as Crest ProHealth For Me Anticavity
mouthwash,whichwillsupportsalesovertheforecastperiod.

Privatelabelproductswithcontinuousimprovementsinqualityandpricingareexpectedto
postsalesgrowthinthecategoryovertheforecastedperiod.
Retailersarealsoexpectedtoallocatemoreshelfspacetosupportthesalesofprivate
labelproductsovertheforecastperiod.
Increasingsalesoflowerpricedprivatelabelproductswillweakendollarsales.
Therecoveringeconomywillexertbothpositiveandnegativeeffectsonprivatelabel
products.

Companies will continue to leverage their total oral hygiene portfolio of crosscategory
productstobothretailersandconsumerswithcoordinatedlaunchesandpromotions.

Manufacturers sales of mouthwashes are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 1.4% to reach


approximately$856millionin2017,upfrom$799millionin2012.

UnitsalesareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof1.1%from192.0millionpackagesin2012to
about203.0millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

TOOTHBRUSHES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesoftoothbrushesgrow2.2%in2012to$741millionfrom$725million
in2011.

Since2007,salesoftoothbrusheshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of0.4%peryear.

Table4F23:HistoricalSalesofToothbrushesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

726

2008

730

0.6

2009

725

(0.7)

2010

718

(1.0)

2011

725

1.0

2012

741

2.2

Unitsales

In2012,unitsalesoftoothbrushesgrow1.5%to349millionpackagesfrom344millionin
2011.

Retailsales

Retail sales of toothbrushes total $907.4million in 2012, up 2.2% from $888.2million in


2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F40

Toothbrushes

Table4F24:ManufacturersSalesofToothbrushesintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Brand

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

OralB

Procter&Gamble

215

204

29.7

27.5

Colgate

ColgatePalmolive

139

152

19.2

20.5

Reach

Dr.Fresh

45

49

6.2

6.6

Arm&HammerSpinBrush(Battery)

Church&Dwight

48

45

6.6

6.1

OralB(Battery)

Procter&Gamble

29

29

4.0

3.9

Colgate(Battery)

ColgatePalmolive

27

28

3.7

3.8

ButlerGum

Sunstar

24

26

3.3

3.5

Crest

Procter&Gamble

11

11

1.5

1.5

Aquafresh

GlaxoSmithKline

1.2

1.2

Dr.Fresh

Dr.Fresh

1.0

1.1

Privatelabel

94

101

13.0

13.6

Allother

77

79

10.6

10.7

725

741

100.0

100.0

Total

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

The toothbrushes category remains mature, since the product is considered a commodity
withhighhouseholdpenetration.
Toothbrusheswithbetterdesigns,features,andbenefitsdrivethesalesofthecategory
in 2012. For example, Procter & Gamble launches OralB ProHealth Clinical ProFlex
toothbrushthatremovesplaquefromtheteeth.
Improvingeconomicconditionsalsoaidinthesalesgrowthoftoothbrushesin2012.
Consumers are trying new manual toothbrushes with better features and are not
tradingupforinnovativetoothbrushes,astheyarequiteexpensive.Forexample,New
musicaltoothbrushespricedbetween$12.00and$15.00arelaunchedin2012,butare
notdoingwellduetotheirhighprices,suchasBrushBuddiesJustinBiebersinging
toothbrushwhichsellsforabout$15.00.
Premiumpricedproducts,includingsomebatteryoperatedbrushes,seesalesdecline.

Differentoralcareproducttypesbeingofferedasabundledpackagebyleadingmarketers
including Procter & Gamble and ColgatePalmolive support the categorys growth by
keepingconsumersloyaltotheirbrands.
Procter&GambleoffersitsCrestbrandasanoralcarepackagetoconsumers;thispack
includesatoothpaste,toothbrush,andmouthwash.
Similarly, ColgatePalmolive offers its Colgate brand as an oral care package that
containsitstoothbrush,toothpaste,andmouthwash.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

Toothbrushes

Increasingmediasupportwithnewproductinnovationsdrivethesalesoftoothbrushesin
2012,andmostoftheleadingmarketerscontinuetoextendtheirproductlines.
Procter & Gamble extends its new product line for tweens (children aged 8 to 12),
featuringOralBPulsarProHealthForMeVibratingToothbrush.
ColgatePalmolivelaunchestheMaxFreshtoothbrush.
SunstarintroducesStarWarsLineofgumtoothbrushesforchildren.

M&Aactivity

In December 2012, Dr. Fresh completes the acquisition of its Reach brand manual
toothbrushesfromJohnson&Johnsonforanundisclosedprice.
Withtheacquisition,Dr.Freshbecomesthethirdleadingmarketerinthetoothbrushes
category.
TheacquisitiondoesnotincludeReachbrandflossorotherinterdentalproducts.

Notablenewproducts

Table4F25:SelectNewToothbrushesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

BrushBuddies

JustinBieber

JustinBiebersingingtoothbrushfeaturestwobuttons,eachof
whichwillplayasongfromthepopstarfortwominutes,sothatit
encourageskidstobrushformoretime

Church&Dwight

Arm&Hammer
ToothTunes

ToothTunesisamanualtoothbrushthatplayspopular
commercialmusicfortwominutestoencourageproperbrushing

ColgatePalmolive

ColgateOpticWhite

ColgateWispOpticWhitetoothbrushcontainsbothwhitening
cupsandpolishingbristles

ColgatePalmolive

ColgateMaxFresh

ColgateMaxFreshtoothbrush,withitsmultiheight,multiangle
bristlespenetratedeeplybetweentheteethtoblastawayplaque

ColgatePalmolive

ColgateMaxWhite

ColgateMaxWhitetoothbrushgentlyremovesstainswithits
uniquepolishingstarandspeciallydesignedbristles

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

Colgate360ActiflexSonicPowertoothbrushcombinesunique
flexibleactionwiththepowerofsonicvibrationstocleanaround
andinbetweenteeth

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate360Optic
White

Colgate360OpticWhitePowertoothbrushpolishesawaysurface
stainsandcleanshardtoreachplaces

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

Colgate360WholeMouthCleantoothbrush,withmorebacteria
removingnubs,removesover96%morebacteria

Procter&Gamble

OralB

OralBextendsitslineofProHealthforMelinewithaSensitive
Cleanrechargeablepowertoothbrushthatprovidesagentle
brushingexperiencetokids

Procter&Gamble

OralB

OralBadvantagePlustoothbrush,withouterangledbristlesthat
massages,stimulates,andcleansgumlineeffectivelyforwhiter
teeth

Sunstar

StarWarsLine

MovieinspiredGUMtoothbrushesforchildren

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F41

4F42

Toothbrushes

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbysegment

In 2012, sales distribution between the adults and childrens toothbrushes segment
continuetoshifttowardchildrensproducts.
Theadultssegmentcontributesheavilytotoothbrushsalesinthecategory.

Table4F26:ManufacturersSalesofToothbrushesintheUnitedStatesbySegment,2011and
2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Segment

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Adults

615

626

84.8

84.5

1.8

Children

110

115

15.2

15.5

4.5

Total

725

741

100.0

100.0

2.2

Introductionofnewproductsandbetterpromotionalactivitysupportthesalesgrowthof
childrenstoothbrushesin2012.
Mostoftheleadingmarketers,suchasProcter&GambleandDr.Freshconsiderage
segmentation as a major growth avenue, with childoriented products gaining more
popularity.
Increasingadvertisingandpromotionalsupportalsocatertothegrowthofchildrens
toothbrushes.
Kidsproductsaredevelopedforsmallermouthsandhands,aswellasdevelopingteeth.
Product design, advertising, and packaging are kid friendly, which tends to increase
usage.
Procter&GamblecontinuestosupportitsCrestProHealthproductlinefortweensin
2012.
Dr.FreshintroducesnewFireflyHelloKittytoothbrushesforchildren.

Batterypowered toothbrushes continue to experience growth, supported by the


introductionoflowcostprivatelabelofferingsatTargetandWalmart.Thelowpricepoints
encouragebuyerstoswitchfrommanualtoothbrushestobatteryoperatedones.
Batterypowered products, such as Colgate and OralB continue to receive strong
promotionalsupportfrommanufacturers.
OralBsbatterypoweredtoothbrushsalesremainstablein2012.
Colgates battery toothbrushes sales grow by 3.7%, from $27 million in 2011 to
$28millionin2012.
Arm & Hammers SpinBrush is the most affected by privatelabel introductions, with
salesdecliningin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

Toothbrushes

Manualtoothbrushessalesincreasemarginally,offsetbythedeclineinOralBssalesinthe
category.
Procter&GamblesmanualOralBtoothbrushsalesdeclineby5.1%in2012,duetothe
lackofnewproductintroductionsanddecreaseinmarketingactivity.
ColgatePalmolivesColgatetoothbrushesincreaseby9.4%,duetothesuccessofthe
newlylaunchedColgateOpticWhitein2011,whichcontainsbothwhiteningcupsand
polishingbristles.

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4F27:ManufacturersSalesofToothbrushesintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

Procter&Gamble

255

244

ColgatePalmolive

166

Dr.Fresh

%Oftotal
2011

2012

Change,%

35.2

32.9

(4.3)

180

22.9

24.3

8.4

52

57

7.2

7.7

9.6

Church&Dwight

48

45

6.6

6.1

(6.3)

Sunstar

24

26

3.3

3.5

8.3

1.2

1.2

Allother

171

180

23.6

24.3

5.3

Total

725

741

100.0

100.0

2.2

GlaxoSmithKline

In 2012, Procter& Gamble continues to be the largest marketer in this category,


representingalmostonethirdofthecategorystotalsales.
However,thecompanysmarketsharedropsfrom35.2%in2011to32.9%in2012,as
overallsalesdecreaseby4.3%,from$255millionin2011to$244millionin2012.
ThesalesgrowthisoffsetwiththedeclineinitsleadingbrandOralB.Thebrandssales
declineduetodecreaseinmarketingactivity,suchasdiscountsandcouponsin2012.
Increasing competition from ColgatePalmolive in the toothbrushes category also
hampersthegrowthforProcter&Gamblein2012.
Procter&Gamble,wellknownforitsproductinnovations,investslessinR&Dandnew
productactivityin2012,limitingthemarketerssuccessinthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F43

4F44

Toothbrushes

OralB continues to bethe largestbrand in this categorywith a decrease in market share


from33.7%in2011to31.4%in2012.
Thedeclineisdrivenbymanualtoothbrushes,whichdecline5.1%from$215millionin
2011 to $204million in 2012. Battery toothbrushes, a much smaller segment, see
stablesalesat$29millioneachin2011and2012.
Limited new product introductions and marketing activities, such as discounts and
coupons,restrictthegrowthoftheOralBmanualtoothbrushesin2012.
Increaseinpricepointsoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.

In2012,ColgatePalmoliveremainsthecategoryssecondlargestmarketer.
Thecompanyssalesincrease8.4%to$180millionin2012from$166millionin2011.
ColgatePalmolivesmarketsharealsoincreasesfrom22.9%in2011to24.3%in2012.
Growth is seen primarily in manual toothbrushes which gain slightly in market share,
from19.2%in2011to20.5%in2012.
Salesofitsbatteryoperatedtoothbrushesalsogrowby3.7%,from$27millionin2011
to$28millionin2012.
The success of Colgates Optic White range of oral care products, which includes
toothbrushes,contributesdirectlytothecompanysgrowth.

Dr. Fresh becomes the thirdlargest marketer in 2012, replacing Church& Dwight in the
category.
Dr.FreshacquirestheReachbrandofmanualtoothbrushesfromJohnson&Johnsonin
2012,therebymakingDr.Freshthethirdleadingmarketerinthecategory.
Dr. Fresh, headquartered in Los Angeles, CA, offers over 250 personal care products
andmarketssomeoftheleadingoralcarebrandsincludingDr.Fresh,Firefly,Binaca,
andDr.Kens.
Thecompanyssalesincrease9.6%,from$52millionin2011to$57millionin2012.
ThecompanysgrowthissupportedbystrongsalesfromitsReachbrand,whichgrows
8.9%from$45millionin2011to$49millionin2012.
ThesuccessofReachTotalCareline,launchedin2011,supportsthebrandsgrowthin
2012.
The other smaller brand, Dr. Fresh also sees growth of $1 million in 2012 to reach
$8million,upfrom$7millionin2011.

Church& Dwight, the thirdleading marketer in the category in 2011, drops to the fourth
positionin2012.
Thecompanysmarketsharedecreasesfrom6.6%in2011to6.1%in2012,withsales
droppingfrom$48millionto$45million.
Arm & Hammers SpinBrush, the largest batterypowered toothbrush brand in the
category,dropsto$45millionin2012from$48millionin2011.Theintroductionofa
privatelabel brand, similar in design and functionality of the SpinBrush, but priced
significantlylower,istheprimarycauseforthedrop.
Church& Dwight discontinues all Mentadent toothbrushes except one, significantly
paringthebrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

Toothbrushes

Sunstar becomes the fifthlargest marketer in the category, replacing Johnson& Johnson,
whichsellsitsonlybrand,ReachtoDr.Freshin2012.
GUMistheonlybrandthecompanymarketsinthiscategory.
Manufacturerssalesofthebrandgrowfrom$24millionin2011to$26millionin2012.
Growth of the brand is supported by the improved performance of its new line of
manualandpowertoothbrushesfeaturingcharactersandlightsabersfromStarWars.

Privatelabel

In 2012, privatelabel products improve their already significant position in the


toothbrushescategory,withagrowthof7.4%.
Privatelabelproductssalesincreasefrom$94millionin2011to$101millionin2012,
withthemarketsharegrowingfrom13.0%in2011to13.6%in2012.
Inthecurrenteconomicclimate,manufacturersandretailersrespondtotheincreasein
demandwithmorestorebrandproducts.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandisersremainthekeydistributionchannelfortoothbrushesin2012,withits
sharenearlyremainingflatwith2011.

Table4F28:ManufacturersSalesofToothbrushesintheUnited
StatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

46

46

Foodstores

32

31

Drugstores

22

22

100

100

Specialtystoresa
Total

aIncludesairport/hotelgiftshops.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

In 2012, television advertisements and freestanding inserts (FSIs) remain important for
marketersinthetoothbrushescategory.
FSIscontaincouponswithvaluesthatrangefrom$0.50to$1.00.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F45

4F46

Toothbrushes

Procter&Gambleistheleadingadvertiserinthecategoryin2012with$21.6millionspent
intotaltraceablemediaexpenditures(TME),upsignificantlyfrom$18.3millionin2011.
Approximately, $20.7million in TME is allocated to OralB regular toothbrushes and
$20.8millioninTMEisallocatedtoOralBbatterytoothbrushes.
Procter&Gamblepromotesitstoothbrusheswithabout$54.6ofitsTMEontelevision
advertisements,followedby38.9%onInternetpromotions,and6%onmagazines.

Church& Dwight is the secondleading advertiser in the category, with 2012 TME of
$15.6millionforSpinBrush.
SpinBrushpromotionsthroughmagazinesandFSIsaccountforaboutonehalfoftotal
advertisingspend.Televisioncommercials(42.1%)andInternetdisplayadvertisements
(3.4%)accountfortheremainingpromotionalexpenditures.

Dr. Freshs $1.7million advertising spend in 2012 is almost completely allocated to the
promotionofitsReachTotalCaretoothbrushes.
TMEsarespentalmostexclusivelyonmagazineadvertisements.
Furthermore, the company mounts a number of social mediabased initiatives to
supportitsFireflytoothbrushes.
In2012,Dr.FreshteamsupwithDavidDeVore,the9yearoldstaroftheviralYouTube
video"DavidAfterDentist,"topromotegoodoralcarehabitsinchildren.

DataonTMEaredetailedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreportandinthedatabase.

OUTLOOK

Salesoftoothbrushesareexpectedtogrowataslowbutsteadyrateof1.6%,overthenext
fiveyears.

Innovative product launches and strong marketing support will help drive the growth of
salesinthecategory.
Products with better technology and lower prices are expected to grow over the
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
The manual toothbrushes segment will experience greater growth in the childrens
segment and less in the adult segment, driven mainly by innovations, and better
marketingstrategies.
Marketers will continue to launch new and creative products with multiple benefits,
such as plaque removal, breath freshening, or gum massage to keep pace with the
growthinconsumerdemandandexpectations.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

Toothbrushes

Toothbrushes that cater to specific oral care needs will perform better over the forecast
period.
Products that are designed for specific problems, including gum massage, plaque
removal,anddeepcleaningareexpectedtoseegrowth.
Childrensproductswillcontinuetoexpand,asparentsincreasinglyselecttoothbrushes
designedspecificallyforchildrenoradolescents.

Marketersareexpectedtoincreasetheirmarketingactivitytosupportthecategoryssales
overtheforecastperiod.
SeveralleadingtoothbrushmarketersincludingProcter&Gamble,ColgatePalmolive,
and Dr. Fresh will continue to offer coupons including online and print coupons to
supporttheirrespectivesalesinthecategory.
Toothbrushmanufacturerswillcontinuetoinvestinadvertisingandspecialpromotions,
thereby reminding consumers of the importance of using the right tools to maintain
goodoralhealth.

Factors, including low prices and new product launches will support the sales of private
labelproductsovertheforecastperiod.
As privatelabel manufacturers offer greater variety, costconscious consumers will
increasinglypurchasestorebrands.
However,privatelabelproductswillconstraindollargrowth,butwillsupporttheunit
salesgrowth.

Sales are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 1.6% to reach $802million in 2017, up from
$741millionin2012.

Unit sales of toothbrushes are forecast to increase at a CAGR of 1.0%, from a rounded
349millionpackagesin2012toalmost366millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F47

4F48

Toothbrushes

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

TOOTHPASTES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

In2012,salesfortoothpastesincrease1.7%to$1,749millionfrom$1,719millionin2011.

Dollar sales of toothpastes have increased at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
1.5%peryearsince2007.

Table4F29:HistoricalSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStates,
2011to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,622

2008

1,693

4.4

2009

1,682

(0.6)

2010

1,668

(0.8)

2011

1,719

3.1

2012

1,749

1.7

Unitsales

Unitsalesoftoothpastesareapproximately1,005millionpackagesin2012,up1.4%from
991millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Salesoftoothpastesareroundedat$2,162millionattheretaillevelin2012,up2.0%from
$2,119millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F50

Toothpastes

Table4F30:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

$Million

Brand

Company

Crest

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Procter&Gamble

637

618

37.1

35.3

Colgate

ColgatePalmolive

569

605

33.1

34.6

Sensodyne

GlaxoSmithKline

132

149

7.7

8.5

Arm&Hammer

Church&Dwight

82

83

4.8

4.7

Aquafresh

GlaxoSmithKline

84

80

4.9

4.6

Tom'sofMaine

ColgatePalmolive

46

48

2.7

2.7

Rembrandt

Johnson&Johnson

21

22

1.2

1.3

Aim

Church&Dwight

19

19

1.1

1.1

Orajel

Church&Dwight

17

16

1.0

0.9

Mentadent

Church&Dwight

14

12

0.8

0.7

CloseUp

Church&Dwight

14

13

0.8

0.7

Biotene

GlaxoSmithKline

13

13

0.8

0.7

Pepsodent

Church&Dwight

12

11

0.7

0.6

OralB

Procter&Gamble

0.5

0.5

Plus+White

CCAIndustries

0.4

0.5

Listerine

Johnson&Johnson

0.4

0.4

UltraBrite

ColgatePalmolive

0.4

0.3

Gleem

Procter&Gamble

0.1

0.1

CrestKids

Procter&Gamble

0.1

0.1

Privatelabel

14

15

0.8

0.9

Allother

14

14

0.8

0.8

1,719

1,749

100.0

100.0

Total

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Toothpastesareconsideredacommoditywithhighhouseholdpenetrationandthecategory
remainsmaturein2012.
Overall,saleshavebeenmoderatelygrowingforthepastseveralyears.
Gainsforseveralleadingbrands,suchasColgateandSensodyne,aremainlyattributed
tonewproductlaunchesandheavypromotionalsupport.
Companiesloseandgainsharetoothercompetitors,butthereislimitednetexpansion
ofthecategory.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolive overtakes Procter& Gamble for the leadership position in
thetoothpastescategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

Toothpastes

Severalleadingmarketerscontinuetolaunchnewproductsin2012,therebysupportingthe
moderatesalesgrowthofthecategory.
ColgatePalmolive extends its Colgate Optic range with Enamel White variant, and
Colgate Max White line of professionally inspired daily toothpastes, and Toms of
MaineBotanicallyBrightwhiteningtoothpaste.
TheColgateOpticWhitetoothpasteisinfusedwithsodiummonofluorophosphate,an
activewhiteningingredient,andtherangeincludesSparklingMint,CoolMildMint,and
EnamelWhitevariants.
Procter&GambleintroducesCrestProHealthClinicalPlaqueControlToothpasteand
Crest3DWhiteGlamorousWhiteToothpaste.

Multibenefittoothpastescontinuetosupportthesalesgainofthecategoryin2012.
Toothpastes that provide multibenefits including battling tooth sensitivity, teeth
whitening,andpreventingplaquesupportthecategorysgrowth.
Amongthemultibenefittoothpastes,whiteningtoothpastesseegoodgrowthin2012,
supportedbythelaunchofnewwhiteningproductsincludingColgateOpticWhiteand
Crest3DWhitetoothpastes.
Toothpastes that provide therapeutic and sensitivity benefits, such as Sensodyne
Pronamelforsensitiveteethwitnessdoubledigitgrowthin2012.
Consumers who suffer from sensitive teeth are estimated to account for about one
quarteroftheU.S.population.

Consumerscontinuetoseekvalueforproducts.
Consumersprefermultibenefitproductsastheymoreattractiveandaffordablethan
havingtopurchasemultipleproducttypes.
Toothpastes that offer multibenefits including cavity protection, whitening, and/or
numbingeffectsforsensitiveteetharemoredesirable.
Premiumpricedproductsmustdemonstrateexcellentresultstostaycompetitive.
Consumers continue to increasingly utilize coupons and take advantage of special
promotions.

Thecategorycontinuestoseenewmarketersenterthemarketin2012.
Hello Products, based out of New Jersey, introduces a new line called 99% natural
oralcareproductsincludingtoothpastes,mouthwashes,andbreathfreshenersunder
the brand name Hello. Hello toothpaste offers benefits, such as strengthens and
whitens teeth, and reduces the effects of acid erosion and tartar buildup. The
toothpastegentlyandsafelypolishesstainsofftheteeth,andhelpspreventcavities.
The marketer launches the new oral care line to cater to consumers looking for
toothpasteswithnaturalingredients.

Privatelabelproductsareunabletoestablishasolidfoothold,duetostrongbrandloyaltyin
thecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F51

4F52

Toothpastes

Notablenewproducts

Table4F31:SelectNewToothpastesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Church&Dwight

Arm&Hammer

Arm&HammerAdvancedWhiteBakingSoda&PeroxideFreshMinttoothpasteis
specificallyformulatedwithrefineddentalgradebakingsodatopreventnewstain
buildupinteeth.Besidesdeepcleaning,italsocontrolstartarandremovesplaque

Church&Dwight

Arm&Hammer

TheOrajelsensitivetoothpastecontainsalowabrasionformulathatisgentleron
theenamel,alsoprovidesrelieffrompainfultoothandnervesensitivity

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

ColgateMaxFreshCoolCrystalsMinttoothpasteisafluoridetoothpastethathelps
tofreshenbreath,fightscavity,andwhitensteeth

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

ColgateMaxFreshNightToothpastecontainszincwhichhelpstopreventgerm
buildupatnight

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

ColgateMaxwithMouthwashBeadsTinglingMinttoothpastehasdissolvablemini
mouthwashbeadsthatcleansthemouth,helpsfightgerms,andpreventscavities

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

ColgateOpticEnamelWhitetoothpastecontainsthesamewhiteningingredientas
whiteningstripsforwhiterteethinoneweekandfortifiesenamelforstrongwhite
teeth.

ColgatePalmolive

Colgate

ColgateMaxWhiteLiquidToothpasteprotectsagainstcavities.Thetoothpastehas
sodiumfluorideastheactiveingredient

ColgatePalmolive

TomsofMaine

BotanicallyBrightwhiteningtoothpasteissodiumlaurylsulfatefreeandfluoride
freetoothpastewhichisformulatedwithablendofbotanicalsthathelptowhiten
teethnaturally.Itisavailableintwoflavors:Spearmintwithaloeandchamomile
andpeppermintwithxylitolandpropolis

Dr.Fresh

Dr.Fresh

FireflyFluorideFoamtoothpastehasalight,foamyformulathatflushesout
bacteriaandgetstohardtoreachspots,specificallydesignedforchildrenwho
wearbraces

GlaxoSmithKline

Sensodyne

SensodynePronamelGentleWhiteningtoothpasteissugarfreeanticavity
toothpasteforsensitiveteethtoprotectagainstthegrowingproblemofacidwear.
Itprotectsteethagainstaciderosion,hardensenamel,andwhitensteeth

GlaxoSmithKline

Mentadent

MentadentAdvancedWhiteningRefreshingMinttoothpasteclaimstowhitenteeth
insevendays.Italsoaidsinremovingplaqueandpreventstartarbuildupbeforeit
forms

HelloProducts

Hello

Thetoothpastecontainsfluoride,whichisknowntohelppreventcavities.Itisfree
fromreportedlyharmfulingredientsincludingtriclosan

Johnson&Johnson

Rembrandt

RembrandtGentleWhitetoothpasteisspecificallydesignedforpeopleproneto
cankersores.Theproducthelpswhitenteethandstrengthenstoothenamel
withoutsodiumlaurylsulfate(SLS),whichhasbeenreportedtocauseirritation

KissMyFace

KissMyFace

TheTripleActiontoothpastecontainsxylitolandteatreeextractstohelpfight
cavitiesanditisfreefromsodiumlaurylsulfate,parabens,andartificialflavorsand
colors

KissMyFace

KissMyFace

TheWhiteningAnticavitytoothpastecontainsorganicaloeveratohealandsoothe;
Teatreetocleanseandactasanantiseptic;andIcelandMoss,anaturalwhitening
agent

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

Toothpastes

Table4F31:SelectNewToothpastesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Procter&Gamble

Crest

CrestProHealthClinicalPlaqueControltoothpastehasaformulathatprotects
teethagainstplaque,gingivitis,cavities,andtoothsensitivity.Thistriclosanfree
toothpastealsohelpswhitenteethandpreventsplaquefromreoccurring

Procter&Gamble

Crest

CrestCompleteMultiBenefitExtraWhite+ScopeOutlastLastingMinttoothpaste
whitensteethbyremovingsurfacestainsandhelpsprotectagainstcavitiesand
tartars

Procter&Gamble

Crest

Crest3DWhiteAdvancedVividEnamelRenewaltoothpaste,ananticavity
toothpastewithsodiumfluorideasitsactiveingredient.Theproductisforpeople
agedoversixyears

Procter&Gamble

Crest

CrestProHealthClinicalGumProtectionInvigoratingCleanMinttoothpaste,ifused
formorethanfourweekshelpsreversegingivitisandimprovegumhealth.Italso
protectsfromteethsensitivity,cavities,plaque,andbadbreath

Procter&Gamble

Crest

TheCrest3DWhiteGlamorousWhitetoothpasteismadewithaformulathat
removessurfacestainsandsurroundsteethwithteethwhiteningagentsto
brightenthem

SunstarAmericas

GUM

GUMCrayolaSqueezeAColortoothpasteproductisavailableinavarietypackof
childsizetubesinthreeflavors:MelonBlast,BlueberryBurst,andJazzyApple.Itis
safetobeusedbychildrenagedabovetwoyears.Eachtubehasasmallnozzlethat
spreadsoutathinlineofpasteacrossthebrushtoencouragekidstobecreative
andusemultiplestripseverytimetheybrush

Vitacare

ChiaMint

ChiaMinttoothpasteincludesvitaminsA,C,D,Eandcalciumwhichhelptoheal,
protect,andstrengthengumsandteeth.TheproductsaresweetenedwithXylitol
andmarketedasglutenandfluoridefreeandsafeforpregnantwomen

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Whitening toothpastes remain the largest segment, increasing 1.6% in sales in 2012 as
many leading marketers, such as Procter & Gamble and ColgatePalmolive introduce new
productswithwhiteningbenefits.

Salesofmultibenefittoothpastescontinuetogainpopularitywith1.3%increaseinsales.

Specialtyproductsseestronggrowthin2012,withsalesincreasingby5.3%,andsharerising
to10.2%,upfrom9.8%in2011.
StronggrowthbytheSensodyneRepair&Protectbrandcontributessignificantlytothe
increaseinsales.

GrowthbytheArm&Hammerbrandboostsbakingsodaandperoxidetoothpastessalesin
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F53

4F54

Toothpastes

Salesoftraditionaltoothpastesincreasemarginallyby0.5%,supportedbysalesofnatural
products.

Childrenstoothpastescontinuetoshownoticeablegrowth,with3.3%increaseinsales.

Table4F32:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Whiteners

623

633

36.2

36.2

1.6

Multibenefit

468

474

27.2

27.1

1.3

Traditionala

201

202

11.7

11.5

0.5

Specialtyb

169

178

9.8

10.2

5.3

Tartarcontrol

86

86

5.0

4.9

Childrens

92

95

5.4

5.4

3.3

Bakingsodaandperoxide

69

70

4.0

4.0

1.4

Bakingsodac

11

11

0.6

0.6

Total
1,719
1,749

100.0

aIncludesregular,cavity,breathfreshening,natural,andvaluebrands.
bIncludessensitiveteethandgumcarevarieties.
cIncludesoriginalandtartarcontrolvarieties.

100.0

1.7

Salesbyproductform

The distribution of sales between pastes and gels is stable in 2012, with minor changes
comparedto2011.

Table4F33:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStatesbyProductForm,2011
and2012

Productform

2011

Paste
Gel
Total

$Million

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

946

968

55.0

55.3

2.3

773

781

45.0

44.7

1.0

1,719

1,749

100.0

100.0

1.7

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

Change,%

Toothpastes

Salesbypackagetype

Table4F34:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStatesbyPackageType,2011and2012

$Million

Packagetype

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

1,263

1,287

73.5

73.6

1.9

356

360

20.7

20.6

1.1

Total

1,619

1,647

94.2

94.2

1.7

PUMP

95

97

5.5

5.5

2.1

0.3

0.3

1,719

1,749

100.0

100.0

1.7

TUBE
Conventional
Standup

ALLOTHER
TOTAL

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4F35:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

Company

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

ColgatePalmolive

622

659

36.2

37.7

5.9

Procter&Gamble

647

628

37.6

35.9

(2.9)

GlaxoSmithKline

229

242

13.3

13.8

5.7

Church&Dwight

158

154

9.2

8.8

(2.5)

63

66

3.7

3.8

4.8

1,719

1,749

100.0

100.0

1.7

Allother
Total

In 2012, ColgatePalmolive overtakes Procter& Gamble for the leadership position in the
toothpastes market with 37.7% share, based on the strong performance of the Colgate
OpticWhitebrand.

ColgatePalmolivecontinuestoexperiencestrongsalesgains.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolives sales increase by 5.9%, up from $622 million in 2011 to
$659millionin2012.
Themarketshareofthecompanyincreasesfrom36.2%in2011to37.7%in2012.
ThestronggrowthofthemarketerisprimarilysupportedbythesuccessoftheColgate
OpticWhitebrandin2012.
The whitening toothpaste trend helps the brand grow its sales in 2012 and helps
strengthenColgatePalmolivespositioninthetoothpastescategory.
Newproductintroductions,suchasColgateOpticEnamelWhitewithformulationsfor
whiteningandsensitiveteethboostthecompanysperformancein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F55

4F56

Toothpastes

Procter&Gambleexperiencessalesdeclinein2012andthemarketerslidestothesecond
positioninthetoothpastescategory.
Sales of the company decline by 2.9%, from $647 million in 2011 to $628 million in
2012.
Themarketshareofthecompanyalsoslidesfrom37.6%in2011to35.9%in2012.
SalesofCrest,thecompanyslargestmasterbrandinthecategory,declineby3.0%to
$618millionin2012from$637millionin2011.
Thebrandssalesdeclineisinlinewiththedecreaseinthemarketingandadvertising
supportforitsbrandsin2012.
The marketer decreases the marketing support for the Crest brand significantly by
50.4%from$143.9millionin2011to$71.4millionin2012.
Procter&Gamblesincreaseinthepriceforitsproductsin2012isalsoamajorfactor
contributingtoitssalesdeclineinthecategory.
Decrease in couponing activity by the marketer in 2012 also limits the growth of the
companyinthecategory.
Limitednewproductactivityalsolimitsthegrowthofthemarketerin2012.
However, some of the key launches in 2012 by Procter & Gamble include Crest Pro
Health Clinical Plaque Control toothpaste and Crest 3D White Glamorous White
toothpaste.

GlaxoSmithKline remains the thirdleading marketer in the category with a 13.8% market
sharein2012,upfrom13.3%in2011.
Totalsalesofthemarketergrowby5.7%to$242millionin2012,upfrom$229million
in2011.
Growth in sales for GlaxoSmithkline is supported by Sensodyne, which experiences
stronggrowthandseesitsshareincreasefrom7.7%in2011to8.5%in2012.
SalesoftheSensodynebrandgrow12.9%,upfrom$132millionin2011to$149million
in2012.
The launch of Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening toothpaste and Sensodyne
Sensitivetoothpastesupportsthebrandsgrowthin2012.
Aquafresh, the next largest brand for the company, has a decrease in sales from
$84million in 2011 to $80million in 2012. The lack of new product activity and a
decreaseinmarketingactivitylimitsitssalesin2012.
Thebrandnowholdsamarketshareof4.6%in2012,downfrom4.9%in2011.
Biotene, a much smaller brand used to treat excessive tartar, dry mouth, and oral
irritations,remainsflatatjust$13millionin2012.
In2012,GlaxoSmithKlinelaunchesnewproductsundertheSensodynebrand.
The marketer supports its new launch, Sensodyne Pronamel with traceable media
expenditure(TME)of$19.5millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

Toothpastes

Church& Dwight remains in fourth place with an 8.8% market share, down from 9.2% in
2011.
Totalsalesin2012are$154million,comparedto$158millionin2011.
Arm&Hammer,thecompanysleadingbrand,hasa4.7%marketshare.Salesareupby
1.2%to$83millionin2012from$82millionin2011.
TheintroductionofmultibenefittoothpasteundertheArm&Hammerbrandsupports
thebrandsgrowthin2012.
During2012,Church&DwightlaunchestwosignificantnewproductsundertheArm&
Hammerbrandinthetoothpastescategory:AdvancedWhiteBakingSoda&Peroxide
FreshMinttoothpasteandOrajelSensitivetoothpaste.

Sales of privatelabel products grow 7.1% in 2012 to $15million, up from $14million in


2011.
Theprivatelabelscategorysharegrowsslightlyfrom0.8%in2011to0.9%in2012,but
furthergrowthisoffsetbytheincreasingcompetitionfromnationalbrands.
However, with heavy promotions and new product launches from national brands
includingColgate,Crest,andSensodyne,consumerssticktobrandedproducts.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In2012,foodstoresandmassmerchandisersremaintheprimarydistributionchannelsfor
toothpastes,withtheproportionofsalesthrougheachoutletunchangedfrom2011.

Table4F36:ManufacturersSalesofToothpastesintheUnitedStates
byRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

Massmerchandisers

44

44

Foodstores

37

37

Drugstores

18

18

100

100

Specialtystoresa
Total

aIncludesairport/hotelgiftshops.

2012

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Advertisementsandpromotionalactivityremainimportantinthetoothpastescategory.
Marketerscontinuetosupportnewproductswithextensiveadvertisingcampaigns.
Themarketingandpromotionalactivityalsodrivesthesalesforbothexistingandnew
products.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F57

4F58

Toothpastes

Feature advertising, displays instore, and temporary price reductions (TPR) are the three
typesofpromotionsfoundtypicallyinthecategory.
Couponsremainanimportantpromotionalmediumformanufacturers,asmanyoffer
couponsof$0.50to$3.00offonpremiumbrands.
Leading marketers including ColgatePalmolive, GlaxoSmithKline, and Procter &
Gambleofferdiscountcouponstosupporttheirsales.

Television advertising continues to be the main media of advertising followed by print


media.
Televisionadvertisingaccountsforalmost80%ofallTMEin2012.
Printmediapromotionsthroughadvertisementsinmagazinesaccountfor16%ofthe
advertisingexpenditures.
Internetdisplayadvertisingisincreasinginusage,accountingfor3%ofmediaspend.

TotalTMEspentbymarketersonthetoothpastescategoryis$338.3millionin2012,down
by6.1%,from$360.3millionin2011.
ColgatePalmolive is the largest advertiser in the category in 2012, with TME of
$104.3million in 2012, up from $81.7 million in 2011 to support several major new
productsandallocatesmorethanonethirdofitsTMEtosupportitsOpticWhitebrand.
GlaxoSmithKline invests $100.2million in TME in its brands in 2012, allocating three
quartersofthebudgettopromoteSensodyne.
Procter & Gamble decreases its TME support significantly by 39.5%, from
$107.5millionin2011to$87.0millionin2012.
Church&Dwightallocates$39.7millionin2012,withthreequarterssupportingArm&
HammerSensitiveWhitening.

ColgatePalmolive is the largest advertiser in the category with total TME of more than
$103.4millionin2012.
ColgatePalmoliveswhiteningbrandsreceiveonehalfofTMEsin2012,withatotalof
$56.6millionspent.
ThemarketerspendsaboutonethirdofitsTMEtosupportitsOpticWhitebrand.
ColgatePalmolive also offers discount coupons ranging $1.00 to $3.00 on its website
andmagazines.
ColgatePalmolive partners with Jeannie Mai, fashion expert, actress, and television
personality,topromoteitsOpticWhitebrandwiththetaglineGettheperfectsmile.
ColgateOpticWhitecontinuestobesupportedbyanintegratedmarketingcampaign,
includingbothdirectinstoreandoutofstoresupport.
ColgatePalmolive demonstrates methods to combine digital and outdoor advertising
to maximize impact with its Smile campaign. ColgatePalmolive uses a dedicated
Facebookpagewhereusersareencouragedtouploadpicturesofthemsmiling.These
arethenturnedintolargecollageposterswhichcanbeseeninsupermarkets,shopping
malls,andotherpointofsalelocations.
ColgatePalmolive also provides various applications that can be downloaded on
mobile phones, including Colgate Smile Capsule, Colgate Smile Sign, and MaxWhite
iPhoneApplication.
ColgateOpticWhitetoothpasteisalsosupportedbyanintegratedmarketingcampaign,
includingboth,directinstoreandoutofstoresupport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

Toothpastes

GlaxoSmithKlinefocusesitspromotionalactivitiesonSensodyne.
In2012,thecompanyallocatesabout$77.2millioninTMEtoSensodyne.Sensodyneis
mainly advertised through television advertisements, with almost 95% of the brands
advertising budget spent on television promotions. Magazine and Internet
advertisementsarealsoused.
TMEof$23.0millionareallocatedforAquafreshtoothpastein2012.

Procter&GambledecreasesitsTMEsignificantlyby39.5%from$143.9millionin2011to
$87.0millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble also decreases its couponing and discounting activity in 2012. For
example, in 2011, Procter & Gamble offered coupons worth $3.00, but in 2012 the
marketerofferscouponsworth$1.00onlyandforaverylimitedperiod.

CrestProHealthlineoftoothpastescontinuetogetextensivemediasupportin2012,with
TMEof$51.1million.
CrestCompleteandCrestwhiteningproducts(Crest3DWhiteandCrestExtraWhite)
splitmostoftheremaining$29.0millionTME,mostofwhichisallocatedtotelevision
advertising.
Procter&GamblesCrest3DteamsupwithGenArtandFashionDesignerWhitneyPort
topromotetheimportanceofhavingaglamorouswhitesmile.
Procter & Gambles brand Crest launches a new advertising campaign that allows
consumerstofindproductsnearbyorbuythemonlinethroughaniPhoneapplication.
ThecampaignispartofabroadermarketinginitiativetopromoteanewlineofCrest
andOralBproductsthatfightplaque.

Data on TME by brand are included in the Advertising section of this report and in the
database.

OUTLOOK

The category is expected to experience slow and steady growth over the forecast period
supportedbynewproductlaunches.

Product innovation will continue to drive the categorys sales growth over the forecast
period.
Marketers are expected to introduce more innovative or multibenefit products to
supporttheirsalesgrowth.
Companies are also expected to launch products pertaining to specific oral care
problemsincludingsensitiveteeth,protectionagainstplaque,anddrymouth.
Singlebenefitproductoptions,suchasdedicatedwhiteningtoothpastes,areexpected
todecline,asconsumersincreasinglyexpectaplethoraofbenefitsfromeachproduct.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F59

4F60

Toothpastes

Marketersareexpectedtocontinuetoprovidestrongpromotionalsupportfortheirbrands
overtheforecastperiod.
The increasing promotional support from the marketers will also maintain brand
awareness.
Privatelabel sales are expected to remain flat or decline due to strong marketing
supportbytheleadingmarketersinthecategory.

New manufacturers, such as Hello Products, Kiss My Face, and other niche personal care
andcosmeticcompanies,areexpectedtolaunchinterestingnewproductsinthecategory,
givingconsumersmorealternatives.
Natural products are not perceived to be critical in this category, however, will
continuetohavemodestgrowthaspenetrationslowlyincreases.
Growing public concern about synthetic ingredients, such as triclosan, will also spur
growthinnaturaltoothpastes.
Traditional product options are expected to decline as companies turn to better
technologies with improved formulations and multibenefit product introductions to
growmarketshare.

Productstargetingspecificagegroups,includingchildren,tweens,andteens,areexpected
to experience growth, as marketers, such as Procter & Gamble and Sunstar Americas
continuetolaunchsuchproductsinthecategory.
Someofthetoothpastesforchildrenlaunchedin2012includeGUMCrayolaSqueeze
AColor toothpaste by Sunstar Americas and Firefly Fluoride Foam toothpaste by Dr.
Fresh.
Companieswillcontinuetointroduceproductswithnewlicensedcharacters.
Productsfortweensandteenswillbepromotedheavilyoncompanywebsites.
Thespecificrequirementsoftheagingpopulation,andthehealthissuesthatmayarise
from increased medication, such as dry mouth, is likely to offer opportunities for
innovationandpromotion.

The recovering economy in the United States is expected to turn consumers towards
brandedproductsthatofferbothproductandvaluebenefits.
Consumers will continue to seek products that offer better benefits rather than
purchasepremiumpricedproducts.
However,inordertosavemoney,manyconsumersaregivingupwhiteningproducts
andmouthwashesinfavoroftoothpastesthatofferthesebenefits.

Companies will continue to leverage their total oral hygiene portfolio of crosscategory
productstobothretailersandconsumers,includingcoordinatedlaunchesandanextension
betweentoothpastes,toothbrushes,andmouthwashes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

Toothpastes

Toothpastesareusedbyvastmajorityofadultsandchildrentomaintaingoodoralhealth,
makingitsmarketpenetrationhigh.
Newuserswillmostlycomefrompopulationgrowth.

Sales are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 1.2% to reach $1,856million in 2017, up from
$1,749millionin2012.

Unit sales of toothpastes are forecast to increase at a CAGR of 0.8% from 1,005million
packagesin2012to1,046millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F61

4F62

Toothpastes

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesoftoothwhiteningproductsdecline5.6%,from$287millionin2011
to$271millionin2012.

Since2007,manufacturerssalesoftoothwhiteningproductshavedeclinedatacompound
annualgrowthrate(CAGR)of0.2%.

Table4F37:HistoricalSalesofToothWhiteningProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

273

2008

281

2.9

2009

285

1.4

2010

287

0.7

2011

287

2012

271

(5.6)

Unitsales

Unitsalesoftoothwhiteningproductsareapproximately17millionpackagesin2012,down
5.6%from18millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retail sales of tooth whitening products are estimated at $359million in 2012, down by
5.8%from$381millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F64

ToothWhiteningProducts

Table4F38:ManufacturersSalesofToothWhiteningProductsintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Brand

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

CrestWhitestrips

Procter&Gamble

212

200

73.9

73.8

GoSmile

GoSmile

12

12

4.2

4.4

Aquafresh

GlaxoSmithKline

12

4.2

3.3

LusterPremiumWhite

Dentovations

2.8

3.3

Rembrandt

Johnson&Johnson

2.4

3.0

Plus+White

CCAIndustries

1.7

1.5

Arm&HammerWhiteningBooster

Church&Dwight

1.4

1.1

KlearActionWhiteningLight

ThaneInternational

0.7

0.7

Dr.Georges

M&MInnovations

0.3

0.4

NaturalWhite

NaturalWhite

0.3

0.4

Listerinea

Johnson&Johnson

0.7

Privatelabel

15

16

5.2

5.9

Allother

2.1

2.2

287

271

100.0

100.0

Total

aDiscontinuedin2012.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

The tooth whitening category is fairly mature and faces intense competition from multi
benefit toothpastes and the mouthwashes category, thereby leading to sales decline in
2012.
Increasing competition from oral care products, such as whitening toothpastes and
mouthwashesresultsinadeclineinsalesinthetoothwhiteningcategoryin2012.
Consumerscontinueto buytoothpastesandmouthwasheswithwhiteningproperties
astheyaremoreaffordablethanhavingtopurchasemultipleproducts.

Despite the economy recovering, consumers do not consider whitening strips to be as


essential as toothpastes, and the challenge for the marketers of whitening strips is to
providemultiplebenefitstoensurepurchase.
Consumerscontinuetoincreasinglyseekvalueforproductsinthecategory.
Premiumpricedproductsmustdemonstrateexcellentresults.
Consumersincreasinglyutilizecouponsandtakeadvantageofspecialpromotions.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

ToothWhiteningProducts

Limited new product activity from several leading players results in sales decline in the
toothwhiteningcategoryin2012.
Procter&GambleintroducesCrest3DWhiteIntensiveProfessionalEffectsWhitestrips
thatclaimstoprovideprofessionalresultsinsevendays.
CCAIndustriesintroducesPlusWhiteOneStepwhiteninggelthatclaimstowhitenthe
teethinfiveminutes.

Declineinsalesofseveralleadingmarketers,suchasProcter&Gamble,GlaxoSmithKline,
andJohnson&Johnson,limitsthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Increasingcompetitionfromotheroralcareproductsthatusewhiteningagentsintheir
productstoprovideaddedvalue,limitsthecategorysgrowth.

Toothwhiteningstrips,rinses,andpensremainpopularinthecategory,comparedtothe
oldertrayform.

Notablenewproducts

Table4F39:SelectNewToothWhiteningProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

CCAIndustries

PlusWhite

PlusWhite5MinuteStainGuardrinseisformulatedwithPVP
(Polyvinylpyrrolidone),anonabrasivestainliftingpolymerthathelps
captureandremovestainsanddebrisfromtheteethssurface

CCAIndustries

PlusWhite

PlusWhite5MinutePremierSpeedWhiteningGelgentlyliftsaway
stainsandreducesteethyellowing

GoSmile

GoSmile

TheTouchSmileWhiteningPengivesbrighterandwhiterteethinless
thantwodays;alsosuitableforconsumerswithsensitiveteeth

Procter&Gamble

Crest

Crest3DWhiteIntensiveProfessionalEffectsWhitestripsusesashine
technologythatclaimstoremoveupto90%ofsurfacestainsinfive
days

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F65

4F66

ToothWhiteningProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4F40:ManufacturersSalesofToothWhiteningProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

Procter&Gamble

212

200

GoSmile

12

GlaxoSmithKline

2011

2012

73.9

73.8

12

4.2

4.4

12

4.2

3.3

(25.0)

Dentovations

2.8

3.3

12.5

Johnson&Johnson

3.1

3.0

(11.1)

CCAIndustries

1.7

1.5

(20.0)

Church&Dwight

1.4

1.1

(25.0)

25

26

8.7

9.6

4.0

287

271

100.0

100.0

Allother
Total

%Oftotal

Change,%
(5.7)

(5.6)

Procter&Gambleremainstheleaderinthecategory,withaslight decreaseinitsmarket
sharefrom73.9%in2011to73.8%in2012.
Collective sales for the marketer decline by 5.7%, from $212million in 2011 to
$200millionin2012.
Crestcontinuestobethemainbrandthecompanymarketsinthecategory.
Despiteanincreaseintraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)in2012,Procter&Gamble
experiencessalesdeclineduetolimitednewproductactivity.
Higher price points compared to its competitors also results in sales decline for the
marketerinthecategory.
In2012,Procter&GambleintroducesCrest3DWhiteGlamorousWhitetoothpasteand
Crest3DWhiteIntensiveProfessionalEffectsWhitestrips.

Go Smile is the secondlargest marketer in the category in 2012, moving ahead of


GlaxoSmithKlinewhichseesasteepdeclineinthecategory.
GoSmilescategoryshareincreasesfrom4.2%in2011to4.4%in2012,withthelaunch
ofGoSmilewhiteningpeninMay,2012.
Thewhiteningpenisamultiusebrushpenthatwhitensteethandalsominimizesteeth
sensitivity.Itistobeusedtwiceadayfortwoweeks.Ittargetspeoplewhodoforget
tousewhiteningproductsathomeandinsteadwanttousethemonthego.
GoSmileisaprestigebrandcarryingrelativelyhighpricesof$35.00to$120.00.
Theproductsareprimarilydistributedthroughcosmeticspecialtystores,suchasUlta
andSephora.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

ToothWhiteningProducts

GlaxoSmithKline,whichtiedwithGoSmileforsecondplaceinthecategoryin2011,dropsto
thethirdplacein2012.Thecompanyexperiencesadeclineinitsmarketsharefrom4.2%in
2011to3.3%in2012.
Sales of Aquafresh White Trays drop sharply by 25.0% from $12million in 2011 to
$9millionin2012.
GlaxoSmithKline entered the category in 2007, but has not been able to significantly
buildsales.Itstrayformathasnotbeenaspopularwithconsumersastheeasytouse
andlessintrusivestrips.
The trays have not performed well as they are uncomfortable to fit and moreover,
cause a lot of inconvenience compared to whitening gels which are easy to use. The
marketerhasnotlaunchedanyotherformsinthecategory.

Johnson&Johnsondropstofifthplacein2012,experiencingadeclineinmarketsharefrom
3.1%in2011to3.0%in2012.
Listerine was discontinued from the market in 2011, leading to the sales decline for
Johnson&Johnsoninthecategory.
ThediscontinuationofListerineWhiteningproductscan,tosomeextent,beaccounted
for by the lawsuit for patent infringement filed against the company in 2008 by
Procter&Gamble.
ThelawsuitprohibitedJohnson&JohnsonandMcNeilPPCfrommaking,selling,and/or
importing any products that infringes on Procter& Gambles patents for tooth
whiteningproducts.In2011,thecompanystoppeddistributingitswhiteningstrips.
The companys other brand, Rembrandt, has sales grow by 14.3%, from $7million in
2011 to $8million in 2012. The brands growth is supported by an increase in
promotionalactivityin2012.

Privatelabel

Privatelabelproductshold5.9%ofthemarketshareinthiscategory,upfrom5.2%in2011.
Privatelabel sales increase from $15million in 2011 to $16million in 2012, as
consumersseektokeepdownexpenses.
Lowerpricepoints,improvedformulations,andimprovedpackagingcontributetothe
growthofprivatelabelssales.
Entrants,suchasCVSJusttheBasicsprivatelabeltoothwhiteningproducts,stimulate
growthasthiscategorymatures.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In2012,theproportionofsalesthroughretaildistributionremainsflat.
Mass merchandisers continue to account for almost onehalf of the sales in the
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F67

4F68

ToothWhiteningProducts

Table4F41:ManufacturersSalesofToothWhiteningProducts
intheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

49

49

Drugstores

28

28

Foodstores

19

19

Professional

Specialtystores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Televisionadvertisements,electronicandprintmediaadvertisements,couponing,andretail
activitiesarethechannelsthatmarketersprefertoadvertisetheirtoothwhiteningproducts.
Television advertising remains the leading promotional method in the category,
followedbytheInternet.

Marketers in the category promote their products through electronic and print media
advertisements.
Televisionadvertisementsarethemostcommonpromotionalmeans,withmorethan
75%ofthetotalmediaexpenditureinthecategoryin2012.
Internetpromotionsconstituteabout10%ofmediaexpenditure,andabout6%isspent
onmagazineadvertisements.
Couponsremainanimportantpromotionalmediumformanufacturersinthecategory.
Couponsrangefrom$1.00toashighas$10.00,dependingonthepriceoftheproduct.
Couponsarefrequentlyusedbecauseoftherelativelyhighpricepointsoftheproducts
inthecategory.
Marketers, such as Procter & Gamble, offer coupons worth $10.00 on their websites
fortheirtoothwhiteningproducts.
Marketersoftenattempttoenticeconsumerstotrynewproductswithcoupons.
In addition to freestanding inserts (FSIs), the leading marketers also promote their
brandsthroughdownloadablecouponsontheirwebsites.

Marketersalsousesocialmediatofurtherengagetheirconsumers.
Increasingly,mostbrandswebsiteshavelinkstotheirpresenceonsocialmediasites,
suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.
Severalleadingmarketers,suchas Procter&GambleandGlaxoSmithKline,usesocial
mediatosharedetailsaboutnewproductintroductions,coupons,sweepstakes,special
offers,events,anddetailsaboutsocialinitiatives.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

ToothWhiteningProducts

TMEdedicatedfortoothwhiteningproducts,exclusiveoftoothpastes,growby80.1%,up
from$43.8millionin2011to$78.9millionin2012.
Procter& Gamble spends $53.7million promoting Crest tooth whitening products
during2012,reboundingfromaTMEof$40.2millionin2011,andremainsbyfarthe
topadvertiserinthetoothwhiteningcategory.
Johnson& Johnson increases media support to its Rembrandt tooth whiteners from
$2.8millionin2011to$8.4millionin2012.
GlaxoSmithKlineshowsnoTMEonAquafreshwhiteningproductsin2012.

DetailsonTMEsareavailableintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreportandinthedatabase.

OUTLOOK

The mature tooth whitening products category is expected to decline marginally over the
forecastperiod.

The tooth whitening category growth will be limited by stiff competition from whitening
toothpastesandmouthwashes.
Usageoftheseproducts,increasinglymultibenefit,ismoreaffordableandconvenient
thanthepurchaseofaseparatetoothwhiteningproduct.
The introduction of new toothpastes and mouthwashes with claims of whitening will
continuetoposestrongcompetitiontotoothwhiteningproducts.

Marketers and retailers are expected to increase promotional activities and new product
introductionstosupportthegrowthoftoothwhiteningproductsovertheforecastperiod,
2012to2017.
There is a dire need for marketers to innovate and regularly introduce new tooth
whiteningproducts,whichthenneedstobeaggressivelysupportedthroughmarketing
andpromotionalefforts.
Betterpromotionalactivitiesandmorevisibilityofsuchproductsinretailchannelswill
alsohelpincreasesalesoftoothwhiteningproducts.
Continuedadvertisingwillalsohelpkeepbrandedproductsrelevantforconsumers.

Innovationsinthecategorywilldrivetheproductsalesovertheforecastperiod.
Innovations in product formats, such as gels and pens, are expected to support the
categorysgrowth.
Tooth whitening products with safe formulations, without causing damage to the
enamel,areexpectedtorevivesomeinterestinthecategory.
Tooth whitening products that will offer multibenefits, such as protection against
enamelorgumsareexpectedtopostgrowthinthecategory.
Newproductlaunchesbytopmanufacturers,suchasProcter&GambleandGoSmile,

arelikelytosupporttheoverallgrowthinthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4F69

4F70

ToothWhiteningProducts

Onthegowhiteningproductsthatcanbecarriedanywhereandprovideinstantresultsare
expectedtosupportthecategorysgrowthduringtheforecastperiod.

ManufacturerssalesareexpectedtodeclineataCAGRof0.5%from$271millionin2012
to$264millionin2017.

Unit sales of tooth whitening products are forecast to decline at a CAGR of 1.2% from
17millionpackagesin2012toalmost16millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

4G.SKINCAREPRODUCTS

INTRODUCTION

Skincareproductscleanse,moisturize,tone,protect,andotherwisecarefortheskin.

Includedinthissectionare:
Babycareproducts
Facialtreatments
Handandbodylotions
Skincareproductsformen
Suncareproducts

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Salesofskincareproductsgrow4.1%to$10,433millionin2012,upfrom$10,021millionin
2011.
The skin care product class continues to be dominated by the facial treatments
category,representing$6,645millioninsales,or63.7%oftotalskincaresalesin2012.

Figure4G1:ManufacturersSalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012

Skincareproducts
formen,2%
Babycare
products,3%

Facialtreatments,
64%

Suncare
products,10%

Handandbody
lotions,22%

Total:$10,433Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G2

SkinCareProducts

Historicalsales

Since 2007, sales of skin care products have grown at a compound annual growth rate
(CAGR)of2.7%to$10,433millionin2012.

Table4G1:HistoricalSalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

9,121

2008

9,373

2.8

2009

9,336

(0.4)

2010

9,653

3.4

2011

10,021

3.8

2012

10,433

4.1

Salesbytradeclass

Themassandluxurytradeclassescollectivelyrepresentabouttwothirdsofthetotalskin
caresalesin2012.
Themasstradeclasscontinuestobethelargesttradeclass,representing45.9%oftotal
skincaresalesin2012.
Theluxurysalestradeclassisatadistantsecond,accountingfor22.5%ofthetotalskin
careproductclasssalesin2012.
Thedirecttradeclassisinthirdplacewith17.0%ofsalesin2012.
The specialty trade class accounts for 7.6% of the total product class sales, while the
professionaltradeclassrepresents6.9%ofthetotalskincaresalesin2012.

Table4G2:Manufacturers'SalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

Facial
treatments

Handand
body
lotions

Suncare
products

Babycare
products

Skincare
products
formen

Total

%Of
total

Mass

2,247

1,303

888

285

68

4,791

45.9

Luxury

2,120

74

74

84

2,352

22.5

Direct

1,482

236

52

1,770

17.0

Specialty

97

646

34

17

797

7.6

Professional

699

24

723

6.9

6,645

2,283

1,048

288

169

10,433

100.0

Tradeclass

Total

$Million

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

4G3

SkinCareProducts

RETAILSALES

Retail sales of skin care products grow 4.3% to a rounded $16,482million in 2012 from a
rounded$15,810millionin2011.

COMPETITION

Table4G3:ManufacturersSalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategoryandCompany,2012

Millionsofmanufacturersdollars
Facial
treatments

Handand
bodylotions

Suncare
products

Skincare
productsformen

Total

%Of
total

596

217

189

185

23

1,210

11.6

1,023

26

29

34

1,112

10.7

L'Oral

709

38

53

14

814

7.8

Procter&Gamble

609

20

637

6.1

17

542

18

582

5.6

MaryKay

449

95

550

5.3

GuthyRenker

526

526

5.0

Unilever

119

198

323

3.1

Avon

206

82

28

316

3.0

Kao

65

208

273

2.6

Allother

2,326

857

725

103

79

4,640

39.2

Total

6,645

2,283

1,048

288

169

10,433

100.0

Company
Johnson&Johnson
EsteLauder

LimitedBrands

Babycare
products

Thetop10companiesaccountfor$6,343millioninsalesor60.8%oftotalskincaresalesin
2012.
Thetopsevencompaniesremainunchangedfrom2011.
Unilever moves up to become the eighthleading marketer in the skin care products
classdisplacingAvontotheninthposition.
In 2012, sales of Avon decline due to various factors, such business restructuring,
declineinthetotalnumberofactiverepresentatives,warningfromtheFDAregarding
fewvariantsoftheAnewproductline,andtalksofapossiblebuyoutofthecompany.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G4

SkinCareProducts

Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestobetheleadingmarketerintheskincareproductclassin
2012.
Salesofthemarketeradvance3.2%to$1,210millionin2012,upfrom$1,173millionin
2011.
Johnson&Johnsonrepresents11.6%oftotalskincaresalesin2012,marginallydown
from11.7%in2011.
Facialtreatmentscontinuetobetheleadingproductcategoryforthemarketer,with
salesat$596millionor49.3%ofthemarketerstotalskincaresalesin2012.
Johnson&JohnsonsNeutrogenaisthesecondlargestbrandinthemasssegmentwith
$347millioninmanufacturerssalesin2012,up5.2%from$330millionin2011.
OneofthemajorgrowthcatalystsforNeutrogenaistheNaturalslinewhichissaidto
be97%naturallyderivedandcontainsantioxidants.Thelineisextendedin2012with
MultiVitaminNourishingMoisturizer,whichisadailylotionthatreplenishesessential
nutrients.
In 2012, Neutrogena extends its acne line with the launchof AllInOne Acne Control
Treatment, which the company promotes as a multifunction product that is able to
fadethelookofacnescarswhilecontrollingpresentandpreventingfuturebreakouts.
Johnson & Johnson is the secondlargest marketer in the hand and body lotions
category, with sales at $217million in 2012, up 4.8% from $207 million in 2011. The
marketercompetesinthecategorywithitsAveeno,Neutrogena,Lubriderm,Johnsons,
andRoCbrands.
The marketers growth in the hand and body lotions category is due to the natural
positioning of its Aveeno brand and the formulation change of the Lubriderm line of
productsinlate2011,whichbecomevisiblein2012.
In the sun care category, Johnson & Johnson slides to become the thirdleading
marketer with sales at $189million in 2012, up 6.2% from $178million in 2011.
Johnson & Johnson is represented by two major brands in the category: Neutrogena
andAveeno.
Following a decline in 2011, Aveeno recuperates its sales in the sun care products
category in 2012 with the launch of its new Protect + Hydrate line of products
comprisingthreeSKUs.
Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestoleadthebabycareproductscategoryinspiteofsales
declineof1.1%from$187millionin2011to$185millionin2012.
Johnson&Johnsonhasbeeninthenewsfortheinclusionofunwantedformaldehydes
in its baby care products. The company has made claims to remove these
formaldehydes from its baby care products and the No More Tear Baby Shampoo by
2013.
Johnson&Johnsonsmoderategrowthinthebabycareproductscategoryisaffected
by the negative media coverage it has been receiving in the past few years with its
product recalls. Such news leads to a negative image about the brand among
consumers,therebyaffectingitssales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

SkinCareProducts

Este Lauder retains its position as the secondlargest marketer in the skin care product
class,withsalesat$1,112millionin2012,up8.5%from$1,025millionin2011.
EsteLauderrepresents10.7%oftotalskincaresalesin2012,upfrom10.2%oftotal
skincaresalesin2011.
EsteLauderistheleadingmarketerinthefacialtreatmentscategoryacrossalltrade
classeswithsalesat$1,023millionor15.4%oftotalfacialtreatmentssalesin2012.
EsteLaudersCliniquecontinuestobethelargestluxurybrandwithnearly22%share
ofthetotalluxuryfacialtreatmentsales.Salesgrow4.6%from$438millionin2011to
$458millionin2012.
WhileCliniqueiscertainlythecategorysleader,sevenpercentagepointsaheadofits
closest competitor, the brand continues to grow sales at a healthy rate, with some
market share lost during the year as other brands play catchup by introducing
products similar to those introduced by Clinique such as BB Creams and dark spot
correctors.
In2012,thesalesofthemarketeraredrivenbynewproductlaunchesduringtheyear
including Este Lauders Advanced Time Zone Age Reversing Wrinkle Crme, Este
LaudersPerfectionist[CP&R]WrinkleLifting/FirmingSerum,EsteLaudersReNutriv
ReCreationFaceCrmeandNightSerum,EsteLaudersReNutrivEyeBalmandNight
SerumforEyesandDayWearBBCrme,CliniquesDarkCircleCorrector,andCliniques
SkinFortifyingHydrator
In the skin care products for men category, Clinique Skin Supplies for Men is the
secondlargest brand with sales at $19million in 2012, an increase of 5.6% from
$18millionin2011.GrowthofthebrandissupportedbytheintroductionoftheAnti
FatigueCoolingEyeGelandtheDarkSpotCorrectorin2012.

LOralremainsthethirdleadingmarketerintheskincareproductclassin2012,withsales
at$814million,up7.7%from$756millionin2011.
LOralrepresents7.8%oftotalskincaresalesin2012,upfrom7.5%in2011.
LOralderives87.1%ofitstotalskincaresalesfromfacialtreatmentsproductsin2012.
LOralParisisthethirdlargestmassbrandinthefacialtreatmentscategorywithsales
of the brand up 3.2% to $227million in 2012, from $220million in the prior year.
Growthin2012isduetotheintroductionofproductsincludingYouthCodeBBCream
Illuminator,YouthCodeFoamingGelCleanser,andRevitaLiftTriplePower.
LOralsLancmeremainsthethirdlargestbrandintheluxurysegment,withsalesof
$243millionin2012,up5.7%from$230millionin2011.Salescontinuetogrowdueto
thesuccessofVisionnaireAdvancedSkinCorrector,whichmadeitsdebutin2011and
Gnifiquewhichwaslaunchedin2010.
Inthesuncarecategory,manufacturerssalesofLOralgrowatanaggressiverateof
12.8%to$53millionin2012,upfrom$47millionin2011.TheintroductionofLOrals
SublimeSunisthekeyreasonbehindthestronggrowthofthecompanyin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G5

4G6

SkinCareProducts

Procter&Gambleisthefourthleadingmarketerintheskincareproductclass,withsalesat
$637millionin2012,down3.8%from$662millionin2011.
Procter&Gamblesshareintheskincareproductclassdeclinesfrom6.6%in2011to
6.1%in2012.
The marketer derives 95.6% of its total skin care sales from the facial treatments
categorywithsalesat$609millionin2012.
Procter& Gambles Olay remains the largest mass brand, accounting for slightly over
onequarteroftradeclasssalesinthefacialtreatmentsproductsclass.
Olayssalesinthefacialtreatmentsproductsdecline3.9%atthemanufacturerslevel,
from $593million in 2011 to $570million in 2012. A number of factors contribute to
Olayssoftsalesduring2012,includingincreasedcompetitionatmultiplepricepoints,
extensive marketing campaigns from competing brands, consumers trading up to
luxury products, mass private labels that mimic many of Olays product lines, and a
changeinretailerplanograms.
Procter & Gamble is one of the largest personal care advertisers and invests $125.3
millionsupportingtheOlaybrandduring2012,downfrom$197.3millionin2011.

Limited Brands retains its position as the fifthleading marketer in the skin care products
class,with5.6%oftotalskincaresalesin2012.
The companys sales in the product class total $582million in 2012, up 3.0% from
$565millionin2011.
LimitedBrandsgenerates93.1%ofitsskincaresalesfromthehandandbodylotions
categoryin2012.
LimitedBrandsrepresents23.7%shareoftotalhandandbodylotionscategoryssales
in 2012, up from a 23.3% share of the total categorys sales in 2011. Growth for the
marketer is supported by new product introductions and packaging changes to its
existinglineofproducts.
Bath&BodyWorksSignatureCollectionisoneofthebestsellingproductlinesforthe
company.
In 2012, the brand introduces the Pink Chiffon Body Lotion, Cashmere Glow Body
Lotion, Paris Amour Body Lotion, Paris Amour Triple Moisture Body Cream, and the
ForeverRedBodyLotion.
Also in 2012, the marketer brings about packaging changes to its Sweet Cinnamon
Pumpkinlineofproductscomprisingabodylotionandamoisturebodycream;Twilight
Woods line of products comprising a body lotion, moisture body cream, and body
butter; and Brown Sugar & Fig line of products comprising a body Lotion and a
moisturebodycream.
TheForeverRedproductlineisapremiumlineandisretailedatahigherprice.
In2012,VictoriasSecretssalesadvanceduetotheintroductionoflimitededitionskin
careproductsandapackagingchangeforitsPinklineofbodylotionsandbodybutters.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

SkinCareProducts

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

The direct sales channel is the leading distribution channel in the skin care product class
representing22.1%ofthetotalproductclasssalesin2012.
Mass merchandisers is the secondlargest distribution channel generating
approximately21%ofskincaresalesin2012.
Department stores and drug stores account for 18.4% and 18.1% of the skin care
sales,respectively,in2012.

Table4G4:RetailDistributionofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012

Retailoutlet

Facial
treatments
30
14
25
16
8
2
5
100

%Ofmanufacturersdollars
Handand
Suncare
Babycare
bodylotions
products
products
11
6
1
28
42
48
5
6
1
18
30
27
33
5
2
5
12
21
1

100
100
100

Directsales
Massmerchandisers
Departmentstores
Drugstores
Specialtystores
Foodstores
Professionaloutletsa
Total

aIncludesmedicalcareproviders,spas,andsalons.

Skincareproducts
formen
3
18
49
15
12
3

100

Weighted
average
22.1
20.8
18.4
18.1
13.0
4.2
3.4
100.0

OUTLOOK

Sales of the skin care product class are expected to grow at a CAGR of 4.5% from
$10,433millionin2012to$12,985millionin2017.
Growth of the category is expected to be fueled by the introduction of new and
innovativeproductsbackedbygoodresearchanddevelopmentfrommarketers.
New and improved product formulations, innovations in the form of packaging, and
attentionseeking marketing and promotional activities, including the popularity of
social media network channels and the growing acceptance towards mobile media
includingQRcodes,areexpectedtosupportthegrowthoftheskincareproductclass.
Skincareproductsofferingadditionalbenefits,suchasantiaging,naturalformulations,
andtherapeuticofferings,areexpectedtodrivesalesintheproductclass.
Majorityofthegrowthwillcomefromthefacialtreatments,thesuncareproducts,and
theskincareproductsformencategories.
Privatelabel products will continue to perform well across all skin care categories
except the facial treatments category where consumers choose wellestablished
brandedproductsoverprivatelabelproducts.
Consumersperceiveprivatelabelproductsasqualityproductsavailableatlowerprices
than products of national brands. Additionally, private label receives support from
retailersduetothehighmarginofprofitsearnedbytheseretailers.
Marketersarelikelytoinnovatewithpackagingformatsincategoriessuchassuncare
productsandfacialtreatments.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G7

4G8

SkinCareProducts

Thefacialtreatmentscategoryisexpectedtoshowstronggrowthboth,invalueandvolume,
duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Innovation backed by science will continue to be the main impetus to growing this
productcategory.
The definition of antiaging will continue to evolve and will include a myriad of
attributesinadditiontowrinklereductionandfirmingsuchasbrightening,luminosity,
andradiance.
Luxury facial treatmentproducts are anticipated to exhibit the most growth over the
next five years and are expected to become the largest trade class. More consumers
willbewillingtotradeuptowhattheyperceiveasbetterproducts.
Morenaturalingredientsarelikelytobeusedinfacialtreatmentproductsduringthe
forecastperiod.
Moisturizers/treatmentswillshowthemostgrowth.
Fadecreamsandwhiteningproductswillexperienceslightdeclineduringtheforecast
period, as most benefits offered by these products are being included in moisturizer
andtreatmentproducts.
The prevalence of acne along with unique facial cleansers that allow for better
absorptionofmoisturizersandtreatmentproducts,willkeepthesetwoproducttypes
growing.

Manufacturers sales of the hand and body lotions category are expected to grow
moderately.
Natural and organic products are expected to be the driving force behind the
categorysgrowthduringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Marketersareexpectedtoadoptinnovativemarketingtechniquesinordertopromote
theirproducts.
The consistent rise of the baby boomer population across the United States will
facilitatemarketersinexpandingtheirproductlineswithantiagingproperties.
Themassanddirectsaleschannelsarelikelytogrowduringtheforecastperiod.
Private label is expected to expand their product portfolio by offering good quality
multifunctionalproductsataffordableprices.
However,handandbodylotionsisamaturecategorywithahighlevelofcompetition
amongtheexistingbrandsandpresentsalimitedscopeforinnovation.

ThesuncareproductscategoryisexpectedtogrowataCAGRof7.2%duringtheforecast
period,2012to2017.
The introduction of the FDAs longawaited sunscreen monograph in late 2012 is
expectedtostimulatenewinterestinthecategory.
Naturalandorganicformulationswillcontinuetogainattentioninthecategory.
Research and development will continue to play a key role for the category as
marketers will look to innovate with product formulations, establish patented
technologies, add multifunctional benefits, and increasing the level of protection
againsttheUVraysforitsproducts.
Thesuntanningsegmentisexpectedtocontinueitsdeclineduringtheforecastperiod.
However,theblurbetweentheskincareandsuncareproductsisexpectedtohavea
detrimentaleffectonthesuncarecategorysgrowthinthefiveyearforecastperiod.
Privatelabelproductswillcontinuetogrowthrough2017,butnotatthefastrateof
recentyears.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

SkinCareProducts

Manufacturers sales of the baby care category are expected to grow at a CAGR of 1.0%
through2017.
The primary reason behind the marginal CAGR for the baby care products category
wouldbethestagnanttodecliningbirthrateintheUnitedStates.
Natural and organic products will continue to be the primary reason behind the
categorysgrowth.
Privatelabelproductsareexpectedtopostahealthygrowthastheytryandcompete
withwellestablishednationalbrands.

Manufacturers sales in the mens skin care products category are expected to grow at a
CAGRof5.4%duringtheforecastperiod.
Currentdevelopmentsintheformofgrowingdemandforantiaging,natural,andsun
careproductsaretestimonytothefactthatthecategoryhasstronggrowthpotential.
Moreover, increased awareness about male grooming backed by aggressive TME
activities are likely to see an increase in the penetration rate of men using products
specific to men as they open up to the idea of going beyond the regular shaveand
cleanseregimen.
Productsformenofferingcosmeticbenefits,suchasconcealersandtintedmoisturizers,
already available in the market, will be another area for marketers to attract the
attentionofthemaleconsumers.
The skin care products for men category provides marketers an opportunity to shift
theirattentionfromthesaturatedfemalecentriccategories.
The marketing expenditure is expected to increase over the next five years, with
marketers concentrating more on promoting the mens skin care brands than the
femalecentricbrands.
Althoughprestigemarketersshallcontinuetoholdmajorityofthemarketshareinthe
category, market share for mass marketers are expected to grow faster than the
prestigebrandsduringtheforecastperiod.

ManufacturerssalesofskincareproductsareprojectedtoadvanceataCAGRof4.5%to
reach$12,985millionby2017,upfrom$10,433millionin2012.

Table4G5:ForecastManufacturersSalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStatesby
Category,2012and2017

$Million

Category

2012

2017

Facialtreatments

6,645

8,482

5.0

Handandbodylotions

2,283

2,500

1.8

Suncareproducts

1,048

1,480

7.2

Babycareproducts

288

303

1.0

Skincareproductsformen

169

220

5.4

10,433

12,985

4.5

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

CAGR,%

4G9

4G10

SkinCareProducts

Unit volume of skin care products are projected to grow at a CAGR of 3.6% to
1,827.3millionpackagesby2017,upfrom1,530.5millionpackagesin2012.

Table4G6:ForecastUnitSalesofSkinCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCategory,
2012and2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

670.0

823.0

4.2

Handandbodylotions

514.2

552.0

1.4

Suncareproducts

244.8

341.8

6.9

Babycareproducts

82.6

86.0

0.8

Skincareproductsformen

18.9

24.5

5.3

1,530.5

1,827.3

3.6

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

BABYCAREPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesforthebabycareproductscategoryshowamarginalgrowthof1.8%
during2012.
Salesadvanceto$288millionin2012,upfrom$283millionin2011.

Sales of the baby care products category have grown at a marginal compound annual
growthrate(CAGR)of0.1%from$286millionin2007to$288millionin2012.

Table4G7:HistoricalSalesofBabyCareProductsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

286

2008

278

(2.8)

2009

278

2010r

278

2011

283

1.8

2012

288

1.8

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit sales of baby care products advance 1.7% to 82.6million packages in 2012, from
81.2millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofbabycareproductstotalarounded$412millionin2012,up1.7%fromabout
$405millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G12

BabyCareProducts

Table4G8:ManufacturersSalesofBabyCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

Product/type/brand

Company

$Million
2011

2012

%Ofsegment

2011

2012

%Oftotal

BABYBATHADDITIVES

2011

2012

Johnsons

Johnson&Johnson

60

57

57.7

53.8

21.2

19.8

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

15

16

14.4

15.1

5.3

5.6

BabyMagic

Naterra

5.8

5.7

2.1

2.1

CaliforniaBaby

CaliforniaBaby

3.8

3.8

1.4

1.4

BurtsBees

TheCloroxCompany

1.9

2.8

0.7

1.0

Mustela

ExpanscienceLaboratories
dbaMustela

1.0

0.9

0.4

0.3

Privatelabel

10

8.7

9.4

3.2

3.5

Allother

6.7

8.5

2.5

3.1

104

106

100.0

100.0

36.7

36.8

Total

BABYLOTIONS
Johnsons

Johnson&Johnson

40

39

53.3

50.0

14.1

13.5

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

11

12

14.7

15.4

3.9

4.2

BurtsBees

TheCloroxCompany

6.7

6.4

1.8

1.7

BabyMagic

Naterra

4.0

3.8

1.1

1.0

CaliforniaBaby

CaliforniaBaby

4.0

3.8

1.1

1.0

Mustela

ExpanscienceLaboratories
dbaMustela

1.3

2.6

0.4

0.7

Privatelabel

10.7

11.5

2.8

3.1

Allother

5.3

6.4

1.4

1.7

75

78

100.0

100.0

26.5

27.1

37

37

61.7

61.7

13.1

12.8

Total

BABYPOWDERS
Johnsons

Johnson&Johnson

BabyGoldBond

Sanofi

3.3

3.3

0.7

0.7

Caldasene

HeritageProducts

1.7

1.7

0.4

0.3

Privatelabel

17

17

28.3

28.3

6.0

5.9

Allother

5.0

5.0

1.1

1.0

100.0

100.0

21.2

20.8

Total

60

60

BABYOILS

Johnsons

Johnson&Johnson

24

24

54.5

54.5

8.5

8.3

BurtsBees

TheCloroxCompany

2.3

2.3

0.4

0.3

Privatelabel

18

18

40.9

40.9

6.4

6.3

Allother

2.3

2.3

0.4

0.3

100.0

15.5

15.3

100.0

100.0

Total

44

44

TOTAL

283

288

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

BabyCareProducts

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

The category witnesses minimal activity in 2012 as a result of which manufacturers sales
advancebyamoderate1.8%during2012insyncwiththe2011levels.
Thekeyreasonbehindthecategorysmoderategrowthisthealmostflatbirthratein
theUnitedStates.
Furthermore, a rising trend towards the use of natural and organic products helps
elevatethecategorysgrowthto1.8%in2012.

Natural and organic products continue to be the primary factor behind the categorys
growth.
Mothers are becoming more ecofriendly and green in their approach, and are
increasinglydemandingproductsthatareformulatedwithnaturalingredientsforuse
ontheirbabysdelicateskin.
Burts Bees, a popular naturallypositioned brand, continues to perform well with its
growingproductrangeandexpandingdistributionnetwork.
Although offering similar benefits and result as regular baby care products, these
naturalandorganicproductsareavailableatahigherpricepointthannormalproducts.
Notably,consumersarewillingtopaytheextrapriceforthesenaturalproductssince
they not want any kind of risk or harm to their babys sensitive skin. However, the
trend for organic products is more prominent among affluent parents who have the
purchasingcapacitytobuypremiumpricednaturalproducts.

ThepracticallyflatbirthrateintheUnitedStateshasadetrimentaleffectonthecategorys
sales.
The birth rate in the United States in 2012 is estimated at 13.7 births per 1,000
populationascomparedto13.8birthsper1,000populationin2011.
Factorscontributingtothisdecliningbirthratearehighincidenceofawarenessamong
citizens through the various awareness programs including those on teen pregnancy
andtherisingcostoflivingandeducation.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G13

4G14

BabyCareProducts

SPFformulatedproductsisanemergingandrapidlygrowingsegmentwithinthebabycare
productscategorywithanincreasingnumberofnewproductstargetedtowardsbabies.
Withgrowingawarenessabouttheharmfuleffectsofthesun,mothersareincreasingly
becomingprotectiveoftheirbabiesskin,whichisthinner,moredelicate,andsensitive
thananadultsskin.
Baby lotions containing an SPF factor are formulated with ingredients that are mild,
gentle,andsafeforthebabyssensitiveskin,andalsoachievetheprimaryfunctionof
providingUVprotectionsimultaneously.
A few leading sun care brands, such as Coppertone, Banana Boat, and Neutrogena,
offersuncareproductlinesexclusivelydedicatedtobabiesandkids.In2012,Johnson
& Johnson introduces a new Aveeno variant, the Baby Natural Protection Lotion
Sunscreen with broad spectrum SPF 50. However, sales for these products are not
includedinthebabycareproductsprofile.
Another rising trend is the availability of these sun care products for babies in spray
formats,makingitconvenientformotherstoapplytheseontheirrestlesstoddlerswith
ease.

Unlikeothercategories,thebabycareproductscategoryisnotledasmuchbyinnovation,
butratherbytrustandthepositioningofabrandinthemarket.
The baby care category, low on true innovation, depends upon the extension of
productlines,emergenceofnaturalandorganicproductlines,andintroductionofsun
careproductsforanincreaseinsales.
Consumerloyaltyisanimportantfactorinthiscategory.

Therehasbeenasurgeformultifunctionalproducts.
Marketers, such as California Baby, Burts Bees, and Baby Magic, offer products with
twoormoreadvantagesinasingleproduct.
A common example of this popular trend is seen in the multifunctional products
offeringshampooandbodywashbenefitsinasingleproduct.
In2012,NatureGateintroducestheBabySoothingShampoo&Wash.
Thereareafewbrandsinthemarket,suchasMonkeySeaMonkeyDoothatoffer3in
1productswithabenefitofashampoo,conditioner,andbodywash,allinoneproduct.

Thereisanupswingtowardsthepremiumbabyskincarebrandsasconsumersarelikelyto
tradeuptopremiumproductsforspecificresults.
Thepremiumbabyskincaresegmentprimarilycomprisesnaturalandorganicbrands
whichhaveshownasignificantgrowthinthepastfiveyears.
SomeofthesehighendbrandsincludeHonestCompany,LalabeeBathworks,Dr.Robin,
MDMoms,LoveMeBabyMe,Episencial,andCaliforniaBaby.
These premium baby care brands use a variety of natural and organic ingredients in
theirproductformulations,suchasLoveMeBabyMeusesorganicaloeandchamomile
inafewofitsproducts;MDMomsusesgingerrootextractinitswipesand;Lavanila
usesNonijuiceasakeyingredientinitsproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

BabyCareProducts

Privatelabelproductsdomoderatelywellin2012.
Retailers,suchasWalgreens,introducetheirownlineofbabycareproductswhichare
availableatapricelesserthanthosebeingofferedbythenationalbrands.
A tradedown activity is visible in only certain segments, such as baby wipes and
diapers,whichdonotfallwithinthescopeofthisstudy.

Notablenewproducts

Table4G9:SelectNewBabyCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012

Company

Brand

Description

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

AllNaturalShampoo&BodyWashUnscented/FragranceFree2in1isa
hypoallergenic,tearfree,andfragrancefreehairandbodycleanser.Suitablefor
newbornbabies,infusedwithaloeleafextractandoliveoil

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

AllNaturalLotionisaneverydaygentleandmoisturizinglotionwhichisenriched
withaloeleafextractandoliveoil.ItisavailableinCherryAromaandUnscented
Fragrance

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

AllNaturalShampoo,Bodywash&Conditioner:CherryAroma3in1isa
hypoallergenic,tearfree,andfragrancefreeshampoo,conditioner,andbodywash.
Itisenrichedwithaloeleafextractandoliveoil,andcontainsanallnaturalcherry
aromascent

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

MonkeySea
MonkeyDoo

CherryConditionerisanallnaturalgentleandmoisturizingbabyconditionerthatis
freeofharshchemicals,andisenrichedwithgentlealoeleafextract,andoliveoil.It
issuitableforkidswithallergies,dryskin,eczema,andsensitiveskin

Naterra

BabyMagic

DryScalpTherapyBabyShampooisinfusedwithteatreeoilandmallowrootto
helpsootheandrelievedryscalpandcradlecap.Itisdermatologicallytestedand
hypoallergenic

Naterra

BabyMagic

DrySkinTherapyMoisturizingCreamenrichedwithsheabutterandalmondoilfor
analldaymoisturizingexperiencefordryskin.Itisvitaminenhanced,
hypoallergenic,anddermatologicallytested

SureSource

Natures
Gate

BabySoothingShampoo&Washisenrichedwithablendofexclusivebotanicals
includingchamomile,orangeflower,calendula,jojobaoil,sweetalmond,apricot
kerneloils,andvegetableglycerintogiveacleansingexperiencetothehairanda
soothingexperiencetothebabysdelicateskin

Walgreens

Ology

SoothingAromaTherapyBabyLotionLavender&Chamomilemoisturizes,softens,
andconditionsbabysskinwhileprotectingitfromdryness.Itisfreeofparabens,
silicones,dyes,phthalates,oranimalbyproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G15

4G16

BabyCareProducts

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Table4G10:ManufacturersSalesofBabyCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProduct
Type,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Babybathadditives

104

106

36.7

36.8

1.9

Babylotions

75

78

26.5

27.1

4.0

Babypowders

60

60

21.2

20.8

Babyoils

44

44

15.5

15.3

283

288

100.0

100.0

1.8

Total

Change,%

Babybathadditives

Babybathadditivescontinuetobethelargestsegmentinthecategory,representing36.8%
oftheentirebabycarecategoryssalesin2012.
Baby bath additives sales total $106million in 2012, up moderately by 1.9% from
$104millionin2011.
Growthinthecategoryisdrivenbytherisingtrendamongmanufacturerstointroduce
multifunctional products offering 2in1 functions and 3in1 functions. Common
examplesofsuchproductsincludeshampooandbodywashproductsorbubblebath
andbodywashproductsorshampoo,conditioner,andbodywashproducts.
A few popular multifunctional offerings in this segment include the California Baby
Overtired & Cranky Shampoo & Bodywash, California Baby Calendula Shampoo &
Bodywash,BurtsBeesBabyBeeShampoo&Wash,AveenoBabyWashandShampoo,
andJohnsonsBabyBubbleBath&Wash.

Johnsons (Johnson & Johnson) continues to be the leading baby bath additives brand in
2012.
In spite of a 5.0% sales decline from $60 million in 2011 to $57 million in 2012, the
brand continues to maintain its lead in the segment. Repeated press releases about
JohnsonsBabysPureandGentleShampoocontainingtracesofformaldehyde,suchas
carcinogenand1,4dioxaneproductshasadetrimentaleffectonthecompanyssalesin
2012.
ThecompanyclaimsthatitwillmakeamendstotheformulationofJohnsonsBabys
PureandGentleShampoobytheendof2013.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

BabyCareProducts

AveenoandBurtsBeesaretheonlybrandstopostagrowthinthesegmentin2012.
Burts Bees is one of the few brands in the category to show a growth of 50.0%,
because of the small sales base of the brand in the segment. Sales increase from
$2millionin2011to$3millionin2012duetoitsexpandingretaildistributionnetwork.
Aveenopostsa6.7%growthwithmanufacturerssalesat$16millionin2012,upfrom
$15millionin2011.
Thepopularityofinnovativemultifunctionalproductsintheformof2in1and3in1
products adds to the sales gain for these brands and also, makes this segment a
dynamiconeinthebabycareproductscategory.

Babylotions

Babylotionscontinuetobethesecondlargestsegmentinthebabycareproductscategory
in2012,withsalesat$78million,up4.0%from$75millionin2011.
Johnsons Baby maintains its leading position in the segment, but, fails to perform in
2012withasalesdeclineof2.5%.
However,Aveeno,anotherJohnson&Johnsonbrand,performswell,withagrowthof
9.1%toreach$12millionin2012,from$11millionin2011.Inspiteofaproductrecall
of more than 2,000 tubes of its Baby Calming Comfort Lotion in 2012, the company
manages to show a healthy growth due to its established name in the market as a
manufacturerofnaturallypositionedbabycareproducts.
Sales of the specialty brand Mustela also advance 100.0% from $1 million in 2011 to
$2million in 2012 albeit from a small base. Growth is due to its expanding distribution
networkinSaks,Nordstrom,Ulta,sephora.com,andentryintoTargetinearly2012.
Privatelabel products also show good growth of 12.5% from $8 million in 2011 to
$9millionin2012duetochangingconsumerbehaviorsandperspectives.

Babypowders

Thebabypowderssegmentssalesremainflatat$60millionin2012.
The segment continues to stagnate due to absence of new or innovative product
activityinthesegment.
Sales of private label also remain dormant in this particular segment in spite of their
availabilityatcheaperpricesincomparisontonationalbrands.

Babyoils

Manufacturerssalesofbabyoilsarestagnantin2012at$44million.
JohnsonsBabycontinuestoremaintheleadingbrandinthebabyoilssegment,with
salesat$24millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Salesofprivatelabelproductsremainsluggishat$18millionin2012.
Babyoilsisadecliningsegmentinthebabycareproductscategoryasitcontinuesto
losemarketshare.Thesegmenthasnotseenanynewproductactivitysince20102011.
Moreover,marketershaveverylimitedproductofferingsinthissegment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G17

4G18

BabyCareProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4G11:ManufacturersSalesofBabyCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,
2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

Johnson&Johnson

187

185

Naterra

TheCloroxCompany
CaliforniaBaby

2011

2012

66.1

64.2

3.2

3.1

2.8

3.1

2.5

2.4

Privatelabel

52

54

18.4

18.8

Allother

20

24

7.1

8.3

283

288

100.0

100.0

Total

%Oftotal

Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestoleadthebabycareproductscategoryin2012.
In2012,thecompanysmanufacturerssalesdeclineby1.1%from$187millionin2011
to$185million.
Johnson&Johnsonhasbeeninthenewsfortheinclusionofunwantedformaldehydes
in its baby care products. The company has made claims to remove these
formaldehydes from its baby care products and the No More Tear Baby Shampoo by
2013.
JohnsonsBabycontinuestodominatethecategorywithsalesat$157millionin2012,
down 2.5% from $161 million in 2011. The declining sales is attributed to the lack of
newproductactivity,dearthofinnovation,andthenegativemedianewssurrounding
itsproductrecallsin2012.
JohnsonsBabypostsdecliningsalesinthebabybathandbabylotionssegmentsand
stagnantsalesinthebabyoilsandbabypowderssegments.
Johnson&Johnsonsotherbrandinthecategory,Aveeno,showssalesgrowthof7.7%,
from$26millionin2011to$28millionin2012.Thehealthygrowthisattributedtoits
goodperformanceinboththebabybathandbabylotionssegments,throughwhichit
competesinthebabycareproductscategory.
AveenosOrganicHarvestline,launchedin2011,comprisingthreeSKUsisdiscontinued
in 2012 on account of losing its U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA ) NOP
certification status as a result of the products containing an ingredient in their
formulationthatisnotonUSDAsNationalList.AlthoughtheOrganicHarvestlineisnot
availableonthecompanysofficialwebsite,itcanfoundoncertainonlineportalsand
ontheshelvesofafewretailers.
In August 2012, Aveeno makes a voluntary recall of its baby Calming Comfort Lotion
after the FDAs tests on a sample product showed exceeded specified quantities of
commonbacteria.However,theproductwasrelaunchedin2012afterprecautionary
measuresweretakenbythecompany.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

BabyCareProducts

NaterraandTheCloroxCompanyaretiedforthesecondpositioninthebabycareproducts
categoryin2012.
SalesforNaterraremainstagnantat$9millionin2012;however,TheCloroxCompany
postsagrowthof12.5%toreach$9millionin2012,upfrom$8millionin2011.
ThemarketshareforNaterradeclinesfrom3.2%in2011to3.1%ofthetotalcategorys
salesin2012.
Ontheotherhand,themarketshareforTheCloroxCompanyadvancesfrom2.8%in
2011to3.1%in2012.
TheCloroxCompanysbrand,BurtsBeesintroducesitsnewlineofbabycareproducts
known as Burts Bees Baby in 2012 and also has an exclusive website for the entire
baby care range of products and accessories. This step helped the brand gain more
mediacoveragein2012therebybringingaboutmoreawarenessamongconsumers.
The positioning of Burts Bees products as containing natural and organic ingredients
andanexpandingdistributionnetworkalsoaidsinthecompanysgrowth.

SalesofCaliforniaBabyremainflatat$7millionin2012.
Sales for the brand increase marginally, but are not visible due to rounding and the
salesbeingfromasmallbase.
The company introduces a number of dual packs and kits for its already existing
productsin2012.

Sales of privatelabel products advance 3.8% in 2012 to $54million in 2012, up from


$52millionin2011.
Retailersaremakingconsciouseffortstoimprovethequalityandpackagingofprivate
label products and introduce innovative products in order to compete with the
established national brands. Also, retailers continue to place these privatelabel
productsrightnexttothebrandedproductsforconsumerstomakecomparisons,such
aspackaging,formulations,andthepricing.
Privatelabel products are increasingly being associated with quality and efficacy,
therebydrivinggrowth.
However,thereisastillacertainsectionofthesocietywhoprefersnationalbranded
productsoverprivatelabelproducts.

Table4G12:ManufacturersSalesofPrivatelabelBabyCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012

Producttype

$Million
Privatelabel

Totalproducttype

Oils

18

44

40.9

Powders

17

60

28.3

Bath

10

106

9.4

78

11.5

54

288

18.8

Lotions
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

%Oftotalproducttype

4G19

4G20

BabyCareProducts

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

In2012,massmerchandisersretaintheleadingpositionasthepreferredretaildistribution
channel,comprising48.0%oftotalretailsalesin2012,up1.0%from47.0%in2011.
Followinginthesecondpositionaredrugstores,whichcontributeto27.0%ofthetotal
sales,inlinewiththe2011levels.
Foodstorescontinuetocontributeto21.0%ofthetotalsalesin2012.

Table4G13:ManufacturersSalesofBabyCareProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

49

48

Drugstores

27

27

Foodstores

21

21

Specialtystores

Directstores

Departmentstores

Total
100
100

aIncludesdepartmentstores,specialtystores,toystores,andthe
Internet.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Johnson & Johnson is the leading advertiser in the category, with traceable media
expenditure(TME)at$31.4millionin2012,downfrom$31.9millionin2011.
Ofthis58.6%ofTME,or$18.4millionisallocatedtomagazineadvertisingandtherest
isallocatedacrosstheInternetandtelevisionmedia.
In 2012, Johnson & Johnson launches its website, safteyandcarecommitment.com,
whichinformsconsumersaboutthesafeuseandqualityofingredientsandaboutany
traceofchemicalsusedinitsproductformulations.Thewebsitewillbeupdatedwith
consumer feedback, new regulations, scientific developments, and information on
Johnson&Johnsonspolicies.
Themarketerofferscouponswith$1.00offonitsJohnsonsHeadToToeBodyWash.
Johnsons website established a platform encouraging moms to share their funny
storiesandadvice.
The brand also utilizes its website to provide useful and necessary information from
healthcareprofessionalsandexpertstonewmoms.
JohnsonsFacebookpageoffersadviceandtipstohandlevariousbabyproblems.
The marketer promotes its products in this page by advertising numerous discounts
thatcanbeavailedbytheconsumers.
Thecompanyswebsiteisalsoutilizedtopromotecouponsandspecialoffers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

BabyCareProducts

Popular promotional instruments include magazine advertising, television advertising,


onlinepromotions,sampledistributions,andinstorepromotions.
Socialmediapromotionisthemostfavorablemediumsincethemarketercaninteract
withtheconsumersonapersonalbasis.
Babycenter.com, a subsidiary of Johnson & Johnson, offers online education to new
parents.

Privatelabel brands, including those of Walgreens, CVS, and Walmart, promote their
productsbyofferingfreeshipping.

TMEinthetotalcategoryisapproximately$55millionin2012,up41.0%from$39millionin
2011.
Johnson & Johnson has the highest advertising expenditures in the category with its
TMEof$31.4millionin2012,down1.6%from$31.9millionin2011.
Johnsons, the leading brand in the category, receives the majority of TME, at
$14millionin2012,withJohnsonsBabylotionsreceivinganindividualTMEallocation
of$3.9million.
Naterra spends a negligible ($142,000) in TME for its baby lotion and baby powder
products.
Social network sites and magazines are the most popular promotional media for the
productcategory.

DetailsonTMEforthecategoryareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

Manufacturers sales of the baby care category are expected to post a marginal CAGR of
1.0%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
TheprimaryreasonbehindthemarginalCAGRforthebabycareproductscategoryis
thestagnanttodecliningbirthrateintheUnitedStates.
Natural and organic products will continue to be the primary reason behind the
categorysgrowth.
Privatelabelproductsareexpectedtopostahealthygrowthastheytryandcompete
withwellestablishednationalbrands.

The biggest driver for the category during the next five years would be the natural and
organicproducts.
Naturallypositioned brands, such as Aveeno, Burts Bees, and California Baby, will
continuetoproliferateasparentscontinuetospendonnaturalproducts.
Moreover,thisisanaddedopportunityfornewbrandstoenterthenaturalpositioned
segment,orforexistingnaturalbrandstoexpandintothebabycarecategoryandbe
successful.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G21

4G22

BabyCareProducts

Johnson & Johnson, the pioneer in baby care products, will maintain its leading position
through2017.
Thecompanywillcontinuetomaintainitsleadingpositiondespitethenegativemedia
newssurroundingtherecallofitsJohnsonsBabyShampooandthediscontinuationof
AveenosOrganicHarvestlineofproductsonaccountofinclusionofharmfulchemicals.
Johnson&Johnsonwillcontinuetoenjoyafavorablebrandimagebecauseofitslong
historyinbabycareintheUnitedStates.Manyconsumerswillnotbepersuadedfrom
buyingitssignaturebrandortheAveenobrand.Therefore,thecompanyisprojectedto
recuperate from these setbacks during the forecast period, by reformulating and
employingaggressivemarketingtechniquestorepairitsreputation.

Privatelabel products are anticipated to grow its sales moderately during the forecast
period.
Inspiteoftheprivatelabelmarketersattempttointroduceandformulateitsproducts
asclosely/identicalaspossibletothoseofnationalbrands,growthwillbelimitedasa
certainsectionofconsumerswouldstillchoosenationalbrandsoverprivatelabels.
Themoderatelypricedprivatelabelcanonlydosomuchtoattractdemand.However,
privatelabelisexpectedtoincreasepricesslightlyinordertomeettherisingpricesof
therawmaterialsused.
Retailers, such as Walgreens, increasingly allocate more shelf space to privatelabel
productstoallowconsumerstomakedirectcomparisonswithnationalbrands.

TheSPFformulatedbabycarelotionsareexpectedtoperformwelloverthenextfiveyears.
Marketers will continue to introduce baby care lotions formulated with varying SPF
levels to give a wider variety of product offering to consumers to select from to suit
theirneeds.
The increasing education and awareness of sun exposure will make parents adopt
safety precautions for their babies by safeguarding their skin with SPFformulated
lotions.

ManufacturerssalesofbabycareproductsareanticipatedtogrowataCAGRof1.0%from
$288millionin2012to$303millionin2017.

UnitvolumeisexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof0.8%to86.0millionpackagesin2017,up
from82.6millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

FACIALTREATMENTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

The facial treatments market in the United States has another year of strong growth, up
4.5%during2012.
Sales are higher than they have been since 2007. The categorys sales reach
$6,645millionin2012,upfrom$6,360millionin2011.
Inthewakeofanuncertaineconomyandaloomingfiscalcliff,coupledwitha super
stormthatseverelyaffectedandprovidedgreathardshiptotheNewYorkmetropolitan
area, and other tragedies, consumers continue to invest on themselves by spending
moneyonproductsanddevicestokeepagingatbay.
The highest percentage growth occurred among products in the luxury trade class,
followed by the professional trade class, indicating consumers further willingness to
spendonthemselvesandtotradeuptomorepremiumproducts.
Pricepointsamongmassproductsalsoincreaseduetomoretechnologicallyadvanced
ingredientsandvisibleresults.
Thequesttostayyoungerlookingisthemajorthrustforconsumerstoinvestinfacial
antiaging products by helping staveoff cosmetic surgery and procedures. Among
those who have already undergone such procedures, the use of facial treatment
productsfunctionsasanadjuncttohelpextendthelifeoftheseprocedures.
Duetoconcernsaboutfinancialissues,manyconsumersratevalueveryhighly.Value
continues to take many forms and can include the quality of a product, the type of
sales support that it provides, or even the bundling of products into kits that offer a
discountedpricecomparedtopurchasingeachoftheproductsseparately.
Products that offer visual results, such as lightening and brightening help propel the
categorysgrowth,andmovethewholeantiagingspectrumpastwrinklereductionand
firming.
Newproductstypicallycreateexcitementinthefacialtreatmentarenaandoneofthe
bigproductstoriesduring2012isthegrowthofBBcreams,thatareessentiallyhybrid
productsthatblurthedistinctionbetweenskincareandfacemakeup.Forthepurpose
ofthisreport,theyarecategorizedasfacialtreatments,andnotasmakeup.

Salesforfacialtreatmentsshowasteadyincreasesince2010,growing4.5%in2012,which
ismorethananyyearsince2007.
Since2007,manufacturerssalesincreaseatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of
2.9%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G24

FacialTreatments

Table4G14:HistoricalSalesofFacialTreatmentsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

5,762

2008

5,923

2.8

2009

5,860

(1.1)

2010

6,091

3.9

2011

6,360

4.4

2012

6,645

4.5

Table4G15:Manufacturers'SalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and
2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

MASS

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

Olay

Procter&Gamble

593

570

27.3

25.4

9.3

8.6

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

330

347

15.2

15.4

5.2

5.2

L'Oral

L'Oral

220

227

10.1

10.1

3.5

3.4

Clean&Clear

Johnson&Johnson

108

111

5.0

4.9

1.7

1.7

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

84

81

3.9

3.6

1.3

1.2

Garnier

L'Oral

61

76

2.8

3.4

1.0

1.1

Pond's

Unilever

62

63

2.9

2.8

1.0

0.9

Biore

Kao

54

58

2.5

2.6

0.8

0.9

RoC

Johnson&Johnson

52

52

2.4

2.3

0.8

0.8

Clearasil

ReckittBenckiser

52

49

2.4

2.2

0.8

0.7

Cetaphil

GaldermaLaboratories

46

47

2.1

2.1

0.7

0.7

AcneFree

ValeantPharmaceuticals

32

30

1.5

1.3

0.5

0.5

St.Ives

Unilever

29

29

1.3

1.3

0.5

0.4

Burt'sBees

TheCloroxCompany

27

29

1.2

1.3

0.4

0.4

LaRochePosay

L'Oral

22

27

1.0

1.2

0.3

0.4

Noxzema

Unilever

17

17

0.8

0.8

0.3

0.3

Oxy

RothoPharmaceutical

16

16

0.7

0.7

0.3

0.2

Eucerin

Beiersdorf

11

11

0.5

0.5

0.2

0.2

Simple

Unilever

10

0.4

0.2

PhysiciansFormulaa

Markwins

10

0.4

0.2

CeraVe

ValeantPharmaceuticals

10

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.2

Dr.LewinnbyKinerase

ValeantPharmaceuticals

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

%Oftotal

4G25

FacialTreatments

Table4G15:Manufacturers'SalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and
2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

MASS(Continued)

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

Maybelline

L'Oral

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.1

DermaSilk

BiotechInternational

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Lumene

LumeneOy

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Avne

PierreFabre

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

Jergens

Kao

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

SeaBreeze

HelenofTroy

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

Palmer's

E.T.Browne

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

StriDex

Blistex

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

Phisoderm

RothoPharmaceutical

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Vichy

L'Oral

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Purpose

Johnson&Johnson

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

FaceLift

UniversityMedical

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Almay

Revlon

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Ambib

ValeantPharmaceuticals

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Boots

AllianceBoots

0.1

0.2

0.1

Esoterica

Medicis

0.1

0.1

Porcelana

Henkel

0.1

0.1

Zapzyt

Waltman

0.1

0.1

Privatelabel

120

127

5.5

5.6

1.9

1.9

Allother

127

143

5.9

6.4

2.0

2.2

2,171

2,247

100.0

100.0

34.1

33.8

Total
LUXURY

Clinique

EsteLauder

438

458

22.3

21.6

6.9

6.9

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

291

322

14.8

15.2

4.6

4.8

Lancme

L'Oral

230

243

11.7

11.5

3.6

3.7

Shiseido

Shiseido

98

104

5.0

4.9

1.5

1.6

LaMer

EsteLauder

75

94

3.8

4.4

1.2

1.4

PerriconeMD

PerriconeMD

79

84

4.0

4.0

1.2

1.3

Chanel

Chanel

70

77

3.6

3.6

1.1

1.2

Clarins

Clarins

68

71

3.5

3.3

1.1

1.1

StrivectinSD

Chrysallis

43

54

2.2

2.5

0.7

0.8

Kiehl's

L'Oral

44

52

2.2

2.5

0.7

0.8

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

51

50

2.6

2.4

0.8

0.8

Origins

EsteLauder

42

50

2.1

2.4

0.7

0.8

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G26

FacialTreatments

Table4G15:Manufacturers'SalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and
2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

MASS(Continued)

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

Philosophy

Coty

48

46

2.4

2.2

0.8

0.7

LaPrairie

Beiersdorf

35

37

1.8

1.7

0.6

0.6

BobbiBrown

EsteLauder

29

32

1.5

1.5

0.5

0.5

ChristianDior

LVMH

27

32

1.4

1.5

0.4

0.5

DDF

Procter&Gamble

31

28

1.6

1.3

0.5

0.4

LauraMercier

Alticor

24

28

1.2

1.3

0.4

0.4

MAC

EsteLauder

19

22

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

PeterThomasRoth

PeterThomasRothLabs

20

22

1.0

1.0

0.3

0.3

Dr.DennisGross
Skincare

Dr.DennisGrossSkincare

15

18

0.8

0.8

0.2

0.3

Guerlain

LVMH

16

17

0.8

0.8

0.3

0.3

Bliss

SteinerLeisure

16

16

0.8

0.8

0.3

0.2

BeneFit

LVMH

14

14

0.7

0.7

0.2

0.2

Dr.BrandtSkincare

Dr.BrandtSkincare

12

12

0.6

0.6

0.2

0.2

FashionFair

JohnsonPublishing

11

10

0.6

0.5

0.2

0.2

SKII

Procter&Gamble

10

0.4

0.5

0.1

0.2

Borghese

Borghese

0.5

0.4

0.1

0.1

BeautyBank

EsteLauder

0.4

0.4

0.1

0.1

OrlaneB21

Orlane

0.4

0.3

0.1

0.1

ErnoLaszlo

CharlesDenton

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

JosieMaran

JosieMaran

0.2

0.3

0.0

0.1

KateSomerville

KateSomerville

0.1

0.3

0.0

0.1

Givenchy

LVMH

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Kinerase

ValeantPharmaceuticals

11

0.6

0.2

0.2

0.1

Freeze24/7

Freeze24/7

0.1

Prescriptives

EsteLauder

0.1

Allother

Total

52

65

2.7

3.1

0.8

1.0

1,960

2,120

100.0

100.0

30.8

31.9

DIRECTc

MaryKay

MaryKay

451

449

30.8

30.3

7.1

6.8

ProActiv

GuthyRenker

353

389

24.1

26.2

5.6

5.9

Avon

Avon

217

202

14.8

13.6

3.4

3.0

MeaningfulBeauty

GuthyRenker

65

82

4.4

5.5

1.0

1.2

Artistry

Alticor

53

54

3.6

3.6

0.8

0.8

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

%Oftotal

4G27

FacialTreatments

Table4G15:Manufacturers'SalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and
2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

MASS(Continued)

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

Hydroxatone

AtlanticCoastMediaGroup

65

52

4.4

3.5

1.0

0.8

Jafra

JafraCosmeticsInternational

39

38

2.7

2.6

0.6

0.6

Arbonne

Arbonne

29

29

2.0

2.0

0.5

0.4

BeautiControl

Tupperware

30

29

2.1

2.0

0.5

0.4

PrincipalSecret

GuthyRenker

26

26

1.8

1.8

0.4

0.4

NuSkin

NuSkin

24

25

1.6

1.7

0.4

0.4

Allother

GuthyRenker

21

13

1.4

0.9

0.3

0.2

XOut

GuthyRenker

10

0.7

0.2

Rodan&Fields

Rodan&Fields

0.5

0.5

0.1

0.1

YouthfulEssence

GuthyRenker

11

0.8

0.4

0.2

0.1

Mark

Avon

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

Pola

Pola

0.3

0.3

0.1

0.1

MaxClarity

GlaxoSmithKline

0.3

0.1

0.1

57

61

3.9

4.1

0.9

0.9

1,463

1,482

100.0

100.0

23.0

22.3

Allother

Total
PROFESSIONALd

Obagi

ObagiMedicalProducts

89

94

13.4

13.4

1.4

1.4

Skinceuticals

L'Oral

57

61

8.6

8.7

0.9

0.9

Dermalogica

Dermalogica

53

51

8.0

7.3

0.8

0.8

SkinMedicar

SkinMedica

43

51

6.5

7.3

0.7

0.8

Aveda

EsteLauder

35

36

5.3

5.2

0.6

0.5

Murad

Murad

34

35

5.1

5.0

0.5

0.5

JanMarini

JanMarini

19

20

2.9

2.9

0.3

0.3

336

351

50.5

50.2

5.3

5.3

666

699

100.0

100.0

10.5

10.5

Allother

Total
SPECIALTY

MerleNorman

MerleNorman

30

29

30.0

29.9

0.5

0.4

PatriciaWexlerM.D.

LimitedBrands

20

17

20.0

17.5

0.3

0.3

L'Occitane

L'Occitane

11

12

11.0

12.4

0.2

0.2

TheBodyShop

L'Oral

9.0

9.3

0.1

0.1

30

30

30.0

30.9

0.5

0.5

100

97

100.0

100.0

Allother
Total

TOTAL
6,360
6,645

aMarkwinsacquiresPhysiciansFormulain2012.
bValeantPharmaceuticalsacquiresAmbifromJohnson&Johnsoninlate2012.
cIncludeshomeshopping,infomercial,andotherdirectsalesbrands.
dRefertoKline&Company'sProfessionalSkinCareUSA,2010reportforfurtherdetails.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

1.6

1.5

100.0

100.0

4G28

FacialTreatments

Unitsales

Unit sales of facial treatments in 2012 increase to 670million packages, up 2.3% from
655millionpackagesintheprioryear.
Unitsalesofmassbrands,whichconstitute60.7%oftotalunitsales,increaseby2.0%
to407millionpackages,whichislowerthanthedollarvolumeincreaseof3.6%.Thisis
duetopricepointsofmassproductsinchingupwards.
Luxurybrandsunitsalescontinuetoexperiencethehighestgrowth,up6.7%,dueto
thedollarsalesgrowthofthesebrands,alongwiththeslightdecreasesinproductsize
alongwithincreasesinpricepoints.
Unitsalesareweakinthespecialtyanddirecttradeclasses.

Table4G16:UnitSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2011and2012

Millionpackages

%Oftotal

Tradeclass

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Mass

399

407

60.9

60.7

2.0

Direct

139

140

21.2

20.9

0.7

Luxury

89

95

13.6

14.2

6.7

Professional

17

18

2.6

2.7

5.9

Specialty

11

10

1.7

1.5

(9.1)

655

670

100.0

100.0

2.3

Total

Retailsales

Retail sales of facial treatments are estimated at $10,871million in 2012, up 4.7% from
$10,387millionin2011.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Antiagingremainsthemajorthrustofthefacialtreatmentscategory.
With an emphasis on looking younger, the definition of antiaging moves beyond
wrinkleminimizationandskinfirming,toincludeahostofproductsthatbrightenand
evenskintoneandprovideradiance.
While the antiaging theme remains virtually unchanged from 2011, some new and
moreeffectiveingredients,alongwithsomenewproductformshavebeendeveloped.
Oils,onceconsideredundesirableasacauseoffacialblemishes,havemadetheirway
intoavarietyoffacialtreatmentproductstoravereviews.
Retinols, once considered quite harsh for delicate skin, are now formulated for
gentlenesswhileincreasingineffectiveness.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

FacialTreatments

The use of an increasing number of facial treatment products on a daily basis provides
incrementalsalesforthecategory.
While serums in facialtreatment products have been popular for thepast few years,
2012 sees the launch of serums specifically for the eye area, to be used with an eye
cream.
Eyeserumlaunchesaretypicallyextensionsoffacialtreatmentlines,suchasCliniques
Even Better Eyes Dark Circle Corrector, Este Lauders Advanced Night Repair eye
serum, and Lancmes Genifique Yeux LightPearl EyeIlluminating Youth Activating
Concentrate.
Theuseofmultipleserumsonthefaceisalsoagrowingtrend.Thesenewgeneration
serumstypicallycontaineitherdryoils,hyaluronicacid,orotheracids,andarelightin
textureforfastabsorptionsothattheycanbelayeredunderotherserums.Examples
launched during 2012 include Ferulic Acid + Retinol Brightening Solution from Dr.
DennisGross,BodyShopNutriganicsDropsofYouth,andEsteLaudersPerfectionist
CP+Rserum.
Other product types that create interest during 2012 include masks, peels, and oils,
whichwhilestillsmall,aregearedforgrowth.

Exciting new products armed with innovative properties create interest in the facial
treatmentscategory,andthisnewnesshelpstopropeltrialandincreasesales.
BB Creams, also known as beauty balms, blemish balms, or beauty benefit creams,
begantosurfaceintheUnitedStatesinlate2011withfewlaunches.Theseproducts
explodeonthescenein2012,withmostmajorfacialtreatmentandmakeupmarketers
launchingtheirownversionoftheseproductsduringtheyear.
BB creams function as hybrid products that offer both facial treatment and cosmetic
properties,offeringtreatmentbenefits,sunprotection,andotherattributesdepending
ontheproduct,allwiththegoalofaperfectskin.Somebrandsoffermultipleshades,
whileothersofferoneshadethatisappropriatetomostskintones.
Some of the most notable BB cream launches during the year include entries from
BobbiBrown,EsteLauder,Smashbox,LOralParis,Garnier,andLancme.

The trend of professional results athome that emerged in 2010, continues into 2012 as
women upgrade their facial treatment regimen to peels and more expensive athome
treatmentsinlieuofvisitingaprofessional.
RoCs Retinol Correxion Max Wrinkle Resurfacing System is a twostep system that
renewsthelookandfeeloftheskinandclaimstobeclinicallyproventobeuptofour
timesmoreeffectivethanaseriesofdermatologicalpeels.
GarniersSkinRenewalDarkSpotOvernightPeelisaglycolicpeelthatcanbeusedas
an overnight treatment to fade dark spots, even skin tones, brighten skin, and refine
thetextureofskin.
La RochePosays Redermic antiaging formula claims to combat wrinkles inspired by
dermatologistsapproachtoplump,fill,andhydrate.
AreformulatedversionofOlaysRegeneristMicroSculptingCreamclaimstoreverse10
yearsofwrinklesinfourweeksbyacceleratingskinturnover.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G29

4G30

FacialTreatments

With an uncertain economy, consumers remain valueoriented, with the description of


valuemeaningdifferentthingsdependingontheperson.
Thecharacterizationofvaluecontinuestoevolveandincludesfactorsthatcontribute
tothedecisiontopurchaseaparticularitemorregimen.
Tosome,valuecanincludethebenefittothemobtainedwithpurchasinginaparticular
channelorretailer.Forexample,whetherapersonreceivesadiscount,freesamples,
orsalesassistanceisofvaryingimportancetodifferentindividuals.
Toothers,valuecanmeantheingredientsintheproducts,themannerinwhichthey
aresourced,thesustainabilitypracticesofacompany,orotherfactors.
Additionally, value can also include the ability to purchase a kit or bundled regimen
thatoffersalowerpricethanifeachproductispurchasedseparately.

Consumers are getting more savvy about their facial treatment purchases and conduct
extensiveresearchbeforemakingapurchase.
Themoreseriousfacialtreatmentpurchaserdoesnotmakeapurchasearmedwithout
adequate information, often using a smartphone at the pointofpurchase to check
pricesorproductreviews.
Consumersrefertoproductreviews,blogs,Facebook,andahostofothersocialmedia
optionstomakesurethattheyhaveselectedtheappropriateproductsfortheirfacial
concerns.

Facial treatment marketers are getting bolder about touting product benefits, which gets
noticedbytheFDA.
During 2012, the FDA continues to look at the marketing claims of facial treatment
products,especiallythosemakingclaimsofbiologicallyenhancedbenefits.
The FDA objects to claims such as rebuilds collagen, boosts the activity of genes,
damagedcellsrepairthemselves,etc.
In fall 2012, the FDA sends warning letters to companies such as Avon and Lancme
citingobjectionablemarketingclaims.
The impact and the steps taken by the FDA on such marketing claims, remains
unknown in early 2013. It is evident that marketers in the near future will need to
substantiatetheirclaims.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

FacialTreatments

Anincreasingnumberofbeautyspecialtyretailersarelaunchingtheirownfacialtreatment
linesinthepasttwoyears.
These are not lines that mimic nationally advertised brands, but rather contain a
proprietarymixofingredientsgearedtotheneedsoftheretailerscustomerbase.
Sephora started the trend with the launch of the Sephora Collection in early 2011
whichissoldatallSephoraandSephorawithinJCPlocations.Theingredientinthese
linesisaproprietaryplantderivedingredientthatthecompanyclaimsismoreeffective
thannationallyadvertisedbrands.
UltalaunchesUltaSkincareinmid2012,afterapreviouslyunsuccessfulattemptatits
ownfacialtreatmentproducts.Theingredientstoryofthislineisaproprietarycomplex
calledAdvancedProtectionFactor+,saidtocombatfreeradicals.
Alsoinmid2012,the37storeBluemercurychainlaunchesM61,whichisanantiaging
linebasedonnaturalingredientswithscientificallyprovenresults.
In addition to the retailers own lines, beauty suppliers also search out exclusive or
licensedlinestocarrytohelpdifferentiatethemselvesfromtheircompetition.
PleaserefertoKline&CompanysBeautyRetailingUSA2012,formoreinformationon
privatelabelandexclusivebrandsacrossvariousbeautycategories.

Distributionstrategiescontinuetoexpandbeyondthecorechannelforabrand.
Theuseofecommerceandhomeshoppingnetworksisbecomingmorewidespread.
MajordepartmentstorebrandsincludingClinique,EsteLauder,andLancmetest
selling at cosmetic specialty stores, such as Sephora and Ulta. These tests are being
conductedatselectlocations.
Homeshoppingnetworksincreaseinpopularityasawaytolaunchnewproducts.
Sampledisseminationprogramsviaservices,suchasNewBeautyTestTube,Birchbox,
andBeautyfix,provideproductsfortrialtothesubscribers.

M&AActivity

ValeantPharmaceuticalsacquiresanumberofskincarebrandsduring2012andintoearly
2013.
In mid2012 the company acquires the Acne Free brand from University Medical for
approximately$64million.
Latein2012,itannouncestheacquisitionofAmbiSkinCarefromJohnson&Johnson
foranundisclosedsum.
Inearly2013,ValeantannouncesitsintenttopurchaseObajiMedicalproductsthrough
apurchaseofallitsoutstandingcommonstockforapproximately$344million.

Markwins International acquires the skin care and cosmetic brand Physicians Formula for
$75millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G31

4G32

FacialTreatments

Notablenewproducts

Table4G17:SelectNewFacialTreatmentsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Avon

Avon

AnewClinicalProLineEraserwithpatentedAF33(AminoFill33)claimstoworklike
potentantiagents.AHA,retinol,andinjectablecollagenreducethelookofdeep
wrinklesinoneweek

Avon

Avon

Genicslineisextendedwithaneyecream

Beiersdorf

LaPrairie

SkinCaviarLiquidLiftissaidtoliftandfirmtheskinstructure,protectandrestore
epidermalstemcellfunction,preventtheappearanceanddeepeningoflinesand
wrinkles

Beiersdorf

LaPrairie

CellularPowerComplex,whichincludesingredients,suchasSwisssnowalgaeand
tissueguidancematrix,issaidtofueldefenseandstimulatetheskinsnaturalrepair
processes.Productincludesginsengrootextract,horsetailextract,andglycoproteins,
saidtohelpstimulatetheskinsrenewalprocesswhilemoisturizingandenergizing
skin.Theformulaalsoincludespanthenolandsodiumhyaluronateformoisturizing
properties

Chrysallis

Strivectin

EVGetEvenSpotRepairisaconcentratedspottreatmentclinicallyproventovisibly
diminishstubbornspotsatthesourceforclearer,brighter,youngerlookingskin

Clarins

Clarins

SuperRestorativeTotalEyeConcentrateisatripleactionserumfortheeyeareathat
lifts,depuffs,andreplenishes

CloroxCompany

BurtsBees

IntenseHydrationisanewlinecomposedofCreamCleanser,DayCream,Night
Cream,TreatmentMask,andEyeCreamdevelopedtoprovideintensehydration.
ClarySage,abotanicalthatsurvivesinharshenvironmentsduetoitsabilitytoretain
moisture,istheinspirationbehindtheline

Dr.DennisGross
Skincare

Dr.DennisGross
Skincare

FerulicAcid+RetinolBrighteningSolutionclaimstoeffectivelysoftentheappearance
oflines,wrinkles,andenlargedporeswhilecounteractingdryness,redness,and
irritation.Developedwith2%activeretinolcomplex,thisovernighttimerelease
formulapromotesradiancebystimulatingcellrenewalandrevivingdullskin

Dr.DennisGross
Skincare

Dr.DennisGross
Skincare

ClarifyingColloidalSulfurMaskisanacnetreatmentthatclarifiestheskinby
absorbingexcessoilandacnecausingbacteriaovernight;rinsesoffinthemorning

E.T.Browne

Palmers

Twonewproductsareadded:CocoaButterFormulaEventoneBBcreamandCocoa
ButterFormulaEventonedarkspotcorrector.Bothproductsclaimtoincludeaskin
toneenhancingcomplex

EsteLauder

BobbiBrown

BBCreamcombinesmoisturizer,treatment,sunprotectionfactor,andlightmakeupin
oneproduct

EsteLauder

Clinique

EvenBetterEyesDarkCircleCorrectorisalightweight,oilfreehydratingeyeserum
claimedtobeclinicallyproventovisiblylightendarkcirclesby30%in12weeks.Skin
strengtheningingredientsmakeskinlesstransparent.Coolingmassagetipbreaksup
puffs.Sheeropticsinstantlybrightensallskintypes,fromfairtodark.

EsteLauder

Clinique

MoistureSurgeIntenseSkinFortifyingHydratorisacreamgelthatprovidesmaximum
hydrationplusabarriertostrengthenandrepairtheskin

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

AdvancedNightRepairlineisextendedwithaneyeserumtosmoothpuffinessand
firmtheeyearea

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

AdvancedTimeZoneAgeReversingLine/WrinkleCrmeclaimstohelprewindthe
visiblesignsofaginginjustfivedays

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

DayWearBBCrmefightsagainstenvironmentalhazardswhileprotectingtheskin

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

FacialTreatments

Table4G17:SelectNewFacialTreatmentsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

Perfectionist[CP+R]WrinkleLifting/FirmingSerumclaimstocorrect,prevent,and
repairskinbycreatingavirtual"forcefield"againstlinesandwrinklesby
superchargingnaturalcollagenbuildingpower

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

ReNutrivlineisextendedwithtwosetsofproductduos:ReCreationFaceCrmeand
NightSerum,andEyeBalmandNightSerumforEyes.Thesehighendproductsare
superchargedwithanewingredientsourcedfromthedeepwaterbeneathAntarctic
glacierscalledGlacialBioExtract

EsteLauder

Origins

MegabrightSkinToneCorrectingSerumclaimstobeclinicallyproventohelpreduce
theappearanceofdarkspotsinfourweekswhileinstantlyleavingskinbrighterand
moreradiant

EsteLauder

Origins

MakeaDifferencePlusRejuvenatingMoisturizerisarejuvenatingmoisturizerfortified
withRoseofJerichoplus,abreakthroughLycheeandWatermelonhydrasustain
complexwhichquenchesdeeptohelprepairthenaturalmoisturedeficiencyindry,
dehydratedskin.Clinicallyproventoinstantlyboostskin'smoisturereservoirtokeep
ithydratedandrejuvenatedallday

EsteLauder

Smashbox

CameraReadyBBcreamcontainsanoilcontrolformulationwithemollientsand
opticalpearlpigmentstoprovidehydrationandreducefinelinesandwrinklesafter
onlyfourweeks.Containssunprotectionandcomesinmultipleshades

GuthyRenker

XOut

Anewacnelineconsistingofawashindeliverysystemwithbenzoylperoxide(8.5%)
andmicrobeadstohelpexfoliatedeadskincells

Johnson&
Johnson

Aveeno

PositivelyAgelessCorrectingTintedMoisturizerisformulatedwithNaturalShiitake
ComplexandvitaminC,tohydrateandnourishfacialskin,tohelpvisiblyreducethe
appearanceoffinelinesandskindiscolorations

Johnson&
Johnson

CleanandClear

AdvantageOilAbsorbingTreatmentisdesignedforuseinplaceofaregular
moisturizer.Thisoilfreeacneformulacontainssalicylicacidtotreatbreakouts
withoutcloggingpores

Johnson&
Johnson

Neutrogena

AllInOneAcneControlTreatmentnoticeablyfadesthelookofpastacnemarks,
clearspresentbreakouts,andhelpspreventfutureacne

Johnson&
Johnson

Neutrogena

Naturalslineisextendedwithmultivitaminnourishingmoisturizer,adailylotionthat
replenishesessentialnutrients.Thecompanyclaimsthatthelineis97%naturally
derivedandcontainsantioxidants

Johnson&
Johnson

Neutrogena

UltraGentleDailyCleanserisanewcleanserformulatedforsensitiveskin

Johnson&
Johnson

RoC

RetinolCorrexionMaxWrinkleResurfacingSystemisatwostepsystemthatrenews
thelookandfeeloftheskinandclaimstobeclinicallyproventobeuptofourtimes
moreeffectivethanaseriesofdermatologicalpeels

Kao

Biore

CombinationSkinBalancingCleanserisanewcleanserforskinthatisacombination
ofdry,oilyandnormal.

LOral

BodyShop

NutriganicsDropsofYouthisayouthenhancingconcentratewithplantstemcell
technologytoenhancesurfaceskinrenewalforsmoother,healthierskin

LOral

Garnier

GarnierSkinRenewalDarkSpotOvernightPeelisaglycolicpeelthatcanbeusedasan
overnighttreatmenttofadedarkspots,evenskintones,brightenskin,andrefinethe
skinstexture

LOral

Garnier

SkinRenewMiracleSkinPerfectorBBCreamevenstone,brightenscomplexion,
renewsradiance,delivers24hourhydration,providesSPF15UVAandUVBprotection

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G33

4G34

FacialTreatments

Table4G17:SelectNewFacialTreatmentsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

LOral

Kiehls

ClearlyCorrectiveDarkSportSolutioncontainsvitaminC,whitebirch,andpeonyto
diminishnumberandintensityofdarkspots

LOral

LOralParis

YouthCodeBBCreamIlluminatorclaimstoeven,illuminate,perfect,correct,and
moisturizeinonestep.YouthCodeFoamingGelcleanserisanewcleanseraddedto
theYouthCodeline

LOral

LOralParis

RevitaLiftTriplePowerisafacialtreatmentcollectionwhichthecompanysays
containsthehighestlevelsofLOralsproprietaryProXylane,whichisanaturally
derived,biodegradablemolecule,extractedfromthebeechwoodplant.This
ingredientissaidtoenhancecollagenproduction.Designedtoaddressthree
dimensionsofagingwrinkles,lossoffacialvolumeandfirmnessthelineis
comprisesaDay/NightCream,Serum,andEyeTreatment

LOral

Lancme

AbsoluLExtraitisaregeneratingelixirthatclaimstorevealfirmer,moreelastic,more
radiantskin.Eachjarhasupto2millionrosenativecells

LOral

Lancme

GenifiqueYeuxLightPearlEyeIlluminatingYouthActivatingConcentratecontainsa
uniquerotatingandmassagingapplicatortoreacheventhemostinaccessibleeye
areaswith360degreeeyecontourapplication

LOral

Lancme

RnergieMultiLiftActionclaimstoshieldskinwithbroadspectrumSPF15and
restoresskinsyouthfulenergy.Addressingkeyagingconcerns,itlifts,firms,and
smoothensinfourweeks

LOral

LaRochePosay

Redermicantiagingformulaclaimstocombatwrinkles,inspiredbydermatologists
approachtoplump,fill,andhydrate

LOral

Maybelline

DreamFreshBBCreamprovideseightskinbenefitsforinstantskinperfection

LVMH

ChristianDior

OneEssentialMaskisaserumtomaskformulatoeliminatetoxinsandprovide
intensiverepair.Theproductcanbeappliedlightlyasleaveonserum,ormoreheavily
asamasktoberemovedin15minutes.

LVMH

ChristianDior

HydraLifeBBCreamisoneuniversalshadecombiningthemoisturizingandprotective
powersofaskincareproductwiththeimmediatecomplexionenhancingandeven
toningpropertiesofafoundation

MaryKay

MaryKay

TimewiseRepairVoluFirmLiftingSerumhelpsfirmandliftskinwhilerestoring
youthfulvolumeandvibrancysoskinappearstighterandlifted.Thisserumclaimsto
influencetheproductionofCollagenVII,minimizingdamagetotheproteinsinthe
dermalepidermaljunctionwhichcancausewrinkles

Markwins

Physicians
Formula

SkinCareMoistureBalancelineclaimstoprovideinstanthydration,foryounger
lookingandbalancedskinwithlesstightness,moreradiance,andmoistureretention
properties

Markwins

Physicians
Formula

SkinCareSensitivityandRednesslinecontainsMediACalm,aningredientthatclaims
todeliverantiirritantandsoothingpropertiestoreducerednesscausedbyexternal
irritation.Theingredientportulacaimprovestheappearanceofblotchinessoften
causedbypoormicrocirculationandhelpsstrengthendelicateskin

Markwins

Physicians
Formula

SkinCareAginglinetargetsthevisibleeffectsofchronologicalagingwhichoccurover
timeandphotoagingfromsunandenvironmentaldamage.Theseproductshelpto
preventandcorrectthemostcommonsignsofskinaging:theappearanceoffine
lines,deepwrinkles,andthelossoffirmnessandmoisture

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

FacialTreatments

Table4G17:SelectNewFacialTreatmentsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Procter&
Gamble

Olay

ProXSpotFightingTreatmentissaidtoreducetheappearanceofdarkspotswith
hydrationtoimproveoverallskinforamoreeventoneandmicroexfoliationto
removedullnessforbrighterskin

Procter&
Gamble

Olay

TotalEffectsCCToneCorrectingLinetreatssevensignsofaging,whilealsoproviding
immediatecolorcorrectionwithtintedformulasthatincludeUVprotectionortone
correctionovertime.Themultipleinstantandlongtermbenefitsclaimtoleaveskin
eventonedwiththereducedappearanceofdiscoloration,finelines,andwrinkles

Procter&
Gamble

Olay

RegeneristMicroSculptingCreamReformulationclaimstoreverse10yearsof
wrinklesinfourweeks.Helpsaccelerateskinturnover

Shiseido

BareEscentuals

BareMineralsMultiWrinkleRepairclaimstoworkonmultiplelayersoftheskinto
diminishforeheadwrinkles,browfurrows,laughlines,andcrowsfeet

Shiseido

Shiseido

WhiteLucentIntensiveSpotTargetingSerumisabrighteningserumcreatedto
diminishstubborndarkspotsin10daysandpreventfuturepigmentationfrom
appearing

Unilever

Ponds

LuminousCleanCreamCleansercontainswhitekaolinclay,anaturalmineralknown
toactlikeamagnettodrawoutdeepdwellingimpurities,andmoisturizing
ingredients,suchasglycerintohelpleaveskinsoftandsmooth

Simple

AfacialtreatmentlinenewtotheUnitedStatescontainingnodyes,artificial
perfumes,orharshirritantsandishypoallergenic,noncomedogenic,andpH
balanced.Linecontainscleansers,wipes,moisturizers,andproductsforusearound
theeyearea

Unilever

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbytradeclass

Luxuryandprofessionalaretheonlytradeclassestodisplayaboveaveragegrowthduring
2012.
Theluxurytradeclassexperiencesthehighestgrowthof8.2%,asconsumersinvestin
theirfacialtreatmentregimensandlayeronanincreasingnumberofproducts.
The professional trade class grows 5.0%, with growth coming from brands, such as
Obagi,Skinceuticals,andSkinMedica.

Themasstradeclassgrows3.6%asmassbrandshoponthemultiproductbandwagon,and
offerahostofserumsandotherproductsthatencouragelayering.
Thedirecttradeclassgrowsjust1.3%,pulled downbysoftnessfrom Avonand Mary
Kay.
Thespecialtytradeclasscontinuestoexperiencedeclinesduring2012,down3.0%or
$3millionfromaverysmallbase.ThedeclineismostlyduetoamovementbyBath&
BodyWorksawayfromitsPatriciaWexlerMDlinetofocusonitsbathandbodylines.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G35

4G36

FacialTreatments

Table4G18:ManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2011
and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Tradeclass

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Mass

2,170

2,248

34.1

33.8

3.6

Luxury

1,960

2,120

30.8

31.9

8.2

Direct

1,463

1,482

23.0

22.3

1.3

Professional

666

699

10.5

10.5

5.0

Specialty

100

97

1.6

1.5

(3.0)

6,359

6,646

100.0

100.0

4.5

Total

Salesbyproducttype

Themoisturizersandtreatmentssegmentexperiencesthemostgrowth,withanincreaseof
approximately$178millionduring2011,a5.0%increase.
While skin brightening and dark spot lighteners continue as the major antiaging
themesduringtheyear,BBcreamsalsocontributetosalesgrowth.
Sales also grow with the launch of multiple products in the brands regimen that
encouragelayeringwiththemultipleuseofserums.
In2012,serumsspecificallyfortheeyeareagainpopularity.

Salesofcleansersgrowaheadoftheaverage,at4.7%to$1,935million.
Consumersarebecomingmoreawareoftheneedforpropercleansingandexfoliation
inorderformoisturizersandtreatmentstoworkatoptimumlevels.

Acneaidsalsogrowslightlyfasterthanaverage,attherateof4.6%duringtheyear.
SolidgainsareexperiencedfromProactiventriesfromothermarketers.
Growth comes from new launches, such as Olay ProX Acne, along with healthy
increasesfromrevampedProactiv.
Whitening products and fade creams both experience declines as many of the
propertiesofferedbytheseproductsarenowincludedasbenefitsinmoisturizersand
treatments,suchaswhiteningandbrightening.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

FacialTreatments

Table4G19:ManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

$Million

Producttype

2011

Moisturizers/treatments

3,546

Cleansersa

2012

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

3,724

55.8

56.0

5.0

1,849

1,935

29.1

29.1

4.7

Acneaids

614

642

9.7

9.7

4.6

Astringents/toners

129

127

2.0

1.9

(1.6)

Whiteningproducts

101

99

1.6

1.5

(2.0)

Makeupremovers

99

99

1.5

1.5

Fadecreams

21

20

0.3

0.3

(4.8)

Total
6,359
6,646

100.0
100.0

aIncludescleansers,masks,porestrips,facialtowelettes,andathometreatmentkits.

4.5

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Thetopfourcompaniesrepresent44.2%oftotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfrom44.1%in
2011.
Salesforthesefourcompaniesincreaseacombined5.0%,whichisabovetheoverall
categorysgrowthof4.5%.

EsteLauderisthecategoryleaderwitha15.4%share.
ItdominatestheluxurysegmentwithitsCliniqueandEsteLauderbrands.
Thecompanyssalesinthecategorygrow8.9%during2012,approximatelytwicethe
industryaverageof4.4%.

LOralholdssecondplacewithavarietyofluxuryandmassbrands.
Salesarestrong,up7.9%anda10.7%shareofthemarket.

Procter&Gambleholdsthirdplacewiththemasssegmentleader,Olay.
Procter & Gamble is the only one among the topfive facial treatment marketers to
experiencesluggishsalesduring2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G37

4G38

FacialTreatments

Table4G20:ManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

Company

$Million
2011

2012

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

EsteLauder

939

1,023

14.8

15.4

8.9

LOral

657

709

10.3

10.7

7.9

Procter&Gamble

633

609

9.9

9.1

(3.8)

Johnson&Johnsonr

579

596

9.1

9.0

2.9

GuthyRenker

476

526

7.5

7.9

10.5

MaryKay

451

449

7.1

6.8

(0.4)

Avon

222

206

3.5

3.1

(7.2)

Allother

2,402

2,528

37.8

38.0

5.2

Total

rRestated.

6,359

6,646

100.0

100.0

4.5

Bybrand

Massbrands

Procter&GamblesOlayremainsthelargestmassbrand,accountingforslightlyoverone
quarteroftradeclasssales.
Thebrandssalesdecline3.9%atthemanufacturerslevel,from$593millionin2011to
$570millionin2012.Thebrandalsodeclinedin2010.
A number of factors contribute to Olays soft sales during 2012, including increased
competition at multiple price points, extensive marketing campaigns from competing
brands,consumerstradinguptoluxuryproducts,massprivatelabelthatmimicsmany
ofOlaysproductlines,andachangeinretailerplanograms.
Thebrandhaslostouttonewerinnovationsbycompetitors,suchasLOralandEste
Lauder.
Olay takes some major steps to become more innovative in late 2012 with the
reformulationofitsRegeneristlinetoofferfasterandmorevisibleresults.
The ProX franchise suffers as the price points for this mass line are comparable to
someentrylevelluxurybrands.Infact,theProXlineisthefirstmasslinetobreakthe
$25.00 price barrier,and open up the door for other mass brands to try as well. The
ProX line is extended with a Spot Fighting Treatment toreduce dark spots and even
outskintone.
During 2012, the company works to develop a new line that launches in early 2013
gearedforyoungerconsumers,andwithlowerpricepoints,calledOlayFreshEffects.
Procter & Gamble is one of the largest personal care advertisers and invests
$125.3million supporting the Olay brand during 2012, down from $197.3million in
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

FacialTreatments

Johnson& Johnsons Neutrogena is the secondlargest brand in the mass segment with
$347millioninmanufacturerssalesin2012,up5.2%from$330millionin2011.
OneofthemajorgrowthcatalystsforNeutrogenaistheNaturalslinewhichissaidto
be97%naturallyderivedandcontainsantioxidants.Thelineisextendedin2012with
MultiVitaminNourishingMoisturizerwhichisadailylotionthatreplenishesessential
nutrients.
In 2012, Neutrogena extends its acne line with the launchof AllInOne Acne Control
Treatment which the company promotes as a multifunction product that is able to
fadeawayacnescarswhilecontrollingpresentandpreventingfuturebreakouts.
Advertising expenditures for Neutrogenas facial treatment brands are approximately
$14.0millionduring2012,adramaticdeclinefrom$88.3millionduring2011.

LOralParisfromLOralremainsthethirdlargestmassbrandinthecategory.
Manufacturers sales of LOral Paris increase 3.2% to $227million in 2012, up from
$220millionin2011.
Two new products are launched under the Youth Code line. Youth Code BB Cream
illuminatorisoneofthefirstmassBBcreams;andYouthCodeFoamingGelCleanser.
RevitaLiftlineisextendedwiththelaunchofTriplePower,alineofconcentratedfacial
treatmentproducts,targetedtorepairandfightwrinkles.Thecompanyclaimsthatthe
TriplePowerrangecontainsthehighestlevelsofthecompanysproprietaryProXylane,
which is a molecule extracted from the beechwood plant, said to enhance collagen
production. The Triple Power range has the highest price points among any of the
productsintheLOralParisportfolio,andisthefirstmassbrandtodirectlycompete
withOlayspremiumpricedProX.
Advertising expenditures for facial treatment products from LOral Paris are
approximately $25.0 million during 2012, down considerably from $129.1million
during2011.

There are several other fastgrowing mass brands that deserve special mention, a few of
thesebeingLOralsbrands.
Garnier grows 24.6% during 2012 due to the continual launch of innovative new
products which include Sin Renewal Dark Spot Overnight Peel which is an overnight
treatment to fade dark spots and even skin tones, and Skin Renew Miracle Skin
PerfectorBBCream.
TwomorebrandsfromLOral,LaRochePosayandVichy,eachgrowgreaterthan20%
duetosignificantlyexpandeddistribution.
ValeantPharmaceuticalsgainsinthemassfacialtreatmentareawiththerevampingof
CeraVe, the expanding awareness of Dr. Lewinn by Kinerase, and the late 2012
purchaseofAmbifromJohnson&Johnson.
Unilever brings its 50 year old Simple brand to the United States, which is aimed at
sensitive skin and is reported to be the leading facial treatment brand in the United
Kingdom.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G39

4G40

FacialTreatments

Luxurybrands

Este Lauders Clinique continues to be the largest luxury brand with nearly 22% of total
luxuryfacialtreatmentsalesshare.
Salesofthebrandatthemanufacturerslevelgrowby4.6%from$438millionin2011
to$458millionin2012.
While Clinique is certainly the leader in the luxury category, seven percentage points
ahead of its closest competitor, sales continue to grow at a healthy rate. The brand
losessomemarketshareduringtheyearasotherbrandsplaycatchupbyintroducing
products similar to those previously introduced by Clinique, such as BB Creams and
darkspotcorrectors.
The Even Better line is expanded with a Dark Circle Corrector for the eyes and the
MoistureSurgelinelaunchesanIntenseSkinFortifyingHydrator.
Traceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs)forCliniqueare$55.3millionin2012,downfrom
$64.1millionin2011.

Este Lauders flagship brand Este Lauder is the secondlargest brand in the luxury
segmentwith$322millioninsalesin2012,up10.7%from$291millionin2011.
Severalnewproductlaunchesduringtheyearareallextensionsofitsexistinglines.
DayWearisextendedwiththelaunchofaBBCrme.
TimeZoneisextendedwithAdvancedTimeZoneAgeReversingWrinkleCrmewhich
thecompanyclaimscanrewindthevisiblesignsofaginginfivedays.
The Perfectionist line is extended with Perfectionist [CP&R] Wrinkle Lifting/Firming
Serumwhichclaimstocorrect,prevent,andrepairskinbycreatingavirtualforcefield
againstlinesandwrinklesbyacceleratingnaturalcollagenbuildingpower.
TheReNutrivlineisextendedwithtwosetsofproductduos:ReCreationFaceCrme
and Night Serum, and Eye Balm and Night Serum for Eyes. Both of these products
contain Glacial BioExtract, a new ingredient from the water beneath the Antarctic
glaciers.
TMEs for Este Lauder facial treatments are $47.7 million in 2012, up from
$44.5millionin2011.

LOrals Lancme remains the thirdlargest brand in the luxury segment, with sales of
$243millionin2012,up5.7%from$230millionin2011.
Sales continue to grow due to the success of Visionnaire Advanced Skin Corrector,
whichmadeitsdebutin2011andGnifiquewhichlaunchedin2010.
The Gnifique line is extended with the launch of Gnifique Yeux LightPearl
Illuminating Youth Activating Concentrate, made specifically for the eyes with a
rotatingandmassagingapplicator.
TheRnergielineexpandswithaMultiLiftActionproductthatlifts,firms,smoothens,
andprotects.
TheAbsolulineisextendedwithLExtraitaregeneratingproductcontainingrosenative
cellstohelprevealfirm,moreelastic,andradiantskin.
TMEsforLancmeareapproximately$33.7millionin2012,downfrom$39.8millionin
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

FacialTreatments

Otherluxurybrandsshowingsizeablegrowthduringtheyearinclude,EsteLaudersLaMer
andOriginsandLOralsKiehls.
Expanding distribution, along with new product launches help each of these brands
growdoubledigitsduring2012.

Directbrands

Mary Kay continues to be the largest directselling brand of facial treatments products,
commandingover30%oftotaltradeclasssales.
The brands sales decline by $2 million to $449 million in 2012 as the company
strugglestomaintainanactivesalesforce.
DirectsalesistheonlybusinessmodelthatMaryKayfollows,utilizingrepresentatives
that can run their own business and conduct parties, classes, and oneonone
consultations.Mostoftheindependentrepresentativesalsohavetheirownwebsites,
and many customers choose to purchase directly from their website. During 2012,
several articles about Mary Kay are published in magazines, such as Forbes and
BusinessWeekthatindicatedifficultiesinmaintainingitsdirectsalesforce.
MaryKaytypicallydoesnotlaunchmanynewproductsinayear,yettheTimewiseline
isextendedin2012withRepairVoluFirmListingSerumsaidtohelpfirmandliftskin.
Mary Kay spends little on advertising and promotional dollars to support its facial
treatmentbrands,relyingonitssalesconsultantsandcatalogstopromotethebrand.

Proactiv (GuthyRenker) is the secondlargest brand in the segment, with $389million in


manufacturerssalesin2012,up10.2%from$353millionin2011.
Despite the sales increase, its business model of utilizing infomercials with celebrity
endorserscoulddraintheprofitabilityofthebrand,duetothehighcostofpurchasing
media, costs associated with infomercial production, and the cost of compensating
celebrities.
Sales grow due to several reasons including a number of new and young celebrity
endorsers, such as actresses Kaley Cuoco, Julianne Hough, and Naya Rivera; positive
endorsementsasbestacneproductbyseveralmagazines,lowintroductoryprice,and
withthebrandmakingmostofitsmoneyonreplenishment.
While no new products are launched during the year, the brand offers a cleansing
brushasagift.
ThebrandlosesseveralcompetitorssuchasMaxClarity,whichisdiscontinuedduring
theyear,causingthesecustomerstoseekoutotherbrandssuchasProactiv.

Avon is the thirdlargest directselling brand in the category with $202million in


manufacturerssalesin2012,down6.9%from$217millionin2011.
Thecompanystruggleswithitswellpublicizedproblemsofattractingandmaintaining
salesassociatesintheUnitedStates,andthecompanydevotesmuchofitsenergiesto
expandinginotherregionsoftheworld.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G41

4G42

FacialTreatments

MajorfacialtreatmentlaunchoftheyearisanadditiontotheAnewClinicallinecalledPro
LineEraserwhichthecompanycomparestoinjectablecollagenandretinolstoreducethe
appearanceofdeepwrinklesinoneweek.
TheGenicslineisextendedinMarch2012withaneyecream.
Thecompanyspendsamere$2.2millionduring2012,downfrom$8.1millionduring
2011toadvertiseitsvariousfacialtreatmentproducts.

Professionalbrands

Obagi(ObagiMedicalProducts)isthelargestprofessionalskincarebrandinthecategory,
withsalesof$94millionin2012,up5.6%from$89millionin2011.
Growthisdrivenprimarilybytheincreaseinthenumberofaccountsandanumberof
marketinginitiativesthatareconductedtoincreasebrandawarenesstoreachoutto
both,physiciansandtheirpatients.
Oneofthemajornewlaunchesfor2012isElastidermEyeCompleteComplexSerum.

SkinCeuticals (LOral) is the secondlargest brand in this trade class with manufacturers
salesof$61millionin2012,up7.0%from$57millionin2011.
The brand continues to enjoy healthy growth in the medical care provider sector,
particularly in medical spas. In the spa sector, the brand strengthens its partnerships
withcoreaccounts,helpingitmaintainsalesinthechannel.
In2012,itlaunchesaloyaltyprogramdestinedfortopmedicalaccounts,designedto
helpgrowthebusiness.

Dermalogica(Dermalogica)isthethirdleadingbrandintheprofessionalsegmentwithsales
of$51million,downfrom$53millionduringtheprioryear.
Thebrandhasshownsalesdeclineoverthepastseveralyearsasaresultofthepoor
performance of the overall spas and salons channel and the loss of accounts due to
brandconsolidationindayspas.

FourthrankedSkinMedica(SkinMedica)showsthebiggestincreaseinsales,up18.6%from
$43millionin2011to$51millionin2012.
The marketers various loyalty programs and growing sales force helps the brand to
collaboratecloserwithaccountsandstrengthenitspartnerships.

AdetailedoverviewofprofessionalbrandsisdiscussedinKline&CompanysProfessional
SkinCare:UnitedStatesreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

FacialTreatments

Privatelabel

Privatelabel sales continue to grow in 2011, as a way for retailers to differentiate


themselvesfromtheircompetition.
Amongmassbrands,privatelabelfacialtreatmentsexperiencegrowthof5.8%during
2012.
To compete with nationally advertised brands, most major mass chain stores offer
privatelabelprogramsthatvarybyretailer.
The profit margin of privatelabel brands is higher than that of nationally advertised
brands,enablingtheretailertomakemoreprofiteventhoughprivatelabelbrandsare
usuallycheaper.

CVScontinuestohaveoneofthemostwellestablishedprivatelabelprogramsinthefacial
treatmentsarea.
These privatelabel products mimic the leading facial treatment brands in active
ingredientsandpackagingandsitadjacenttothesenationallyadvertisedbrandsonthe
shelf.
CVSinparticularoffersproductsthatarecomparabletothevarioussubbrandsofOlay,
LOral,Neutrogena,Aveeno,andRoC.
DrugstorecompetitorsWalgreensandRiteAiddonotoffertheextensiveprivatelabel
offeringsthatCVSprovides.
Not only are the major retailers increasing shelf space for privatelabel products, but
areofferingextraincentivesinpricingandpromotiontoencouragepurchase.
Specialty retailer Sephora offers the Sephora Collection as a standalone brand
including facial treatments since 2011, and Ulta adds facial treatment products to its
UltaSkincarelinein2012.

Another evolving trend is the establishment of exclusive, captive brands, and licensed
brands.
Insomecases,retailerscommissionexclusivebrandsdirectlyfromamanufacturer.
Sometimes a retailer seeks out an established foreign brand for exclusivity in the
UnitedStates.
Alternatively, some U.S. direct marketers look to make arrangements with other
channelsfordistributionexpansion.
Sometimesthearrangementisexclusivebychannel,wherebythebrandisexclusiveto
one retailer in the drug channel and to another retailer in the mass merchandiser
channel.
Since agreements between retailers and vendor are negotiated, it is possible that
exclusivityinachannelcouldalsoberestrictedtoaspecifiedperiodoftime.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G43

4G44

FacialTreatments

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Direct sales and specialty stores show slight increases in market share in the retailing of
facialtreatmentproducts.
Direct sales are driven by online sales from brickandmortar retailers, pure online
retailers,andalsoomeshoppingretailers.
Specialty retailer sales are driven by cosmetic specialty stores, such as Sephora and
Ulta.

Table4G21:ManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnited
StatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Directsales

29

30

Departmentstores

25

25

Drugstores

16

16

Massmerchandisers

14

14

Specialtystores

Salonsandspas

Physicianoffices

Foodstores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Masspromotion

Print advertisements and coupons are the major means through which facial treatment
productsarepromotedtoconsumers.
Coupons typically consist of national $1.00 and $2.00off coupons as freestanding
inserts(FSIs)inweekendnewspapers.
Retailersalsopromotethebestsellingbrandsintheirweeklycirculars,sometimesto
match the availability of FSI coupons for the brand, offering greater savings to the
consumer.
Some brands and companies also offer rebates on the purchase of multiple products
fromtheirproductlineup.
Printadvertisementstypicallyappearinwomensfashionandservicepublications.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

FacialTreatments

Mostmassmarketersnowutilizesocialmediatofurtherengagetheirconsumers.
MostmarketershaveaFacebookpage,andencourageconsumerstoselectlikeuson
Facebook,sothattheycanengageinadialogwiththebrandandotherpeoplewho
havelikedit.
Twitter is used by facial brands to rapidly share updated information on products,
launches,andcoupons.

Someofthecouponingactivitybyleadingmassmarketersincludesthefollowing:
Simplesave$2.00ononeSimpleproduct
RoCsave$3.00onanyRoCproduct
Aveenosave$2.00onanytwoAveenoproducts
Olaysave$5.00onanyProXregimen
Pondssave$1.00onanyPondscleansingproduct

ThemassfacialtreatmentbrandwiththelargestmeasuredtotalmediaexpendituresisOlay
at$125.3millionin2012,downfrom$197.3millionin2011.
OthermassfacialtreatmentbrandswithsizablemediaexpendituresincludeGarnierat
$34.6million,Aveenoat$27.6million,LOralParisat$25.0million,andNeutrogena
with$14.0million.

Massretailersplanspecialeventsandpromotions,sometimesinconjunctionwithproduct
companiestoencouragepurchase.
WalgreensoffersaninstoreeventseveraltimesayearcalledSaturDatewithBeauty,
where beauty advisors educate consumers with samples on products appropriate for
them.
In fall 2012, Target holds its first multicultural makeup and beauty event geared
specificallytotheneedsofethnicconsumers.

Luxurypromotion

Unchanged for decades, consumer promotion for luxury brands mainly consists of
advertising,sampling,giftwithpurchase(GWP),purchasewithpurchase(PWP)offers,and
instoreactivities.
Advertisingistypicallyinnationalfashionmagazines,suchasVogue,Glamour,andElle.
Luxurybrandsalsoplacegreatemphasisandfocusoninstorepromotions.Marketers
oftenpartnerwithkeyretailersforadvertisingeffortsorinstoreevents.
In addition to GWP and PWP promotions, free samples are sometimes given for
stoppingataluxurycounterinadepartmentstore,orwhenpurchasingonline.
Additionally,manyoftheluxurymarketerswhenpurchasingdirectly,alongwithluxury
retailersofferfreeshippingwithbeautypurchasesoveracertainamounttoencourage
sales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G45

4G46

FacialTreatments

Mostluxurymarketersnowutilizesocialmediatofurtherengagetheirconsumers.
Most marketers have Facebook pages, encouraging consumers to click like us on
Facebook,soastoengageinadialogwiththebrandandalsowithotherpeoplethat
havelikedthem.
Twitterisbeingusedbyfacialbrandstorapidlyshareupdatedinformationonproducts,
launches,andcoupons.

Clinique,theluxurysegmentsmarketleader,reliesprimarilyonGWPorPWPtopromote
itsbrand.
Makeup cases that are either generic or from a designer, such Tracy Reese or Trina
Turk,arecommonlyincludedaspartofCliniquesGWPorPWPpromotionsatleading
departmentstores.Insidethesemakeupcasesareanarrayofsomelongstandingand
somenewproductsfortheconsumertotry,typicallyofferedwithapurchaseof$28.00
ormore.
If purchasing directly from Cliniques website, the brand typically offers samples, or
evenatwoweeksupplyofaparticularproductwithacertainminimumpurchasemade.
Thewebsitealsohighlightsanyongoingofferoftheday.
Purchases through Cliniques website receive free shipping every day, no matter the
valueofthepurchase.
During2012,CliniqueoffersatwoweeksupplyofRepairwearLaserFocusatcounter
with no purchase necessary, to encourage trial. After a return consultation, another
twoweek supply is issued, so that the consumer will have four weeks to try out the
product.
CliniquemaintainstheInsidersClub,whichcustomerscanjoinafterenteringtheire
mail address on the brands website. The Insiders Club provides customers with an
insidescooponCliniquesproducts,freetreats,andotherinformationexclusiveonlyto
themembersoftheclub.

ForitsEsteLauderbrand,EsteLauderreliesprimarilyonGWPandPWPpromotions,and
alsohasawiderangeofotherpromotionalefforts.
EsteLauderoffersfreeshippingwithbeautypurchasesoveracertainamountas an
incentivetoencouragepurchase.
Este Lauder offers free samples of perfume, mascara, or facial product with every
onlineorder.
During 2012, Este Lauder holds a monthly sweepstakes in which the grand prize
winnerreceivesa$350.00shoppingvoucher.Consumersenterthepromotionbyfilling
outaformonthebrandswebsite,withnopurchaserequired.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

FacialTreatments

LOrals leading luxury brand, Lancme, offers various incentives to encourage purchase,
withGWPandPWPasthemainpromotion.
Anypurchaseof$60.00ormoremadedirectlyfromLancmeswebsiteiseligiblefora
freegiftcomprisingamakeupcasealongwithseveralsamplesizeproducts.
Freeshippingisavailableonordersof$49.00ormore.
EmailsignupisavailableatLancmeswebsitetoreceiveemailsaboutnewproducts
andtrends.
ConsumerscancreateanaccountdirectlythroughLancmeswebsitethatwillentitle
the consumer to preview and shop for new products before its retail launch, receive
deluxesampleofferswhichareofalargersizethantheminisamplestypicallyprovided,
andalsosavetoaWishlist.
The brand offers various instore events in conjunction with major retail partners to
providepersonalizedconsultationsandintroducenewproducts.

The major luxury facial treatment marketers support their brands with advertising
campaignsinfashionandwomensservicepublications,alongwithtelevisionspots.
Luxury brands receiving the most advertising expenditures include Clinique at
$55.3million,EsteLauderwith$47.7million,andLancmewith$33.7million.

Directpromotion

Persontoperson direct marketers use company brochures, websites, and their sales
associatesforproductpromotion.
Salesforceincentiveprogramsaremostcommonlyused.
Other promotional efforts by direct marketers mainly include sampling and price
promotions.

Theleadingdirectmarketers,includingAvonandMaryKay,havetoolsontheirwebsitethat
allowaninterestedpartytofindasalesconsultantintheirarea.
MaryKayswebsitehasaPersonalBeautyProfilerthathelpsconsumersdecidewhich
facialtreatmentproductswouldbebestforthem.Thiswebsitealsoincludesthebrand
catalog,alinktoitsFacebookpage,aswellasaYouTubevideoaboutthebrandandits
products.
MostofMaryKayssalesassociateshavetheirownwebsitepage,tokeepintouchwith
theirconsumersviafrequentemails.
To help entice consumers, Mary Kays sales associates frequently hold product
demonstrationgatheringswhereparticipantsaregivenafreeproduct,suchasfullsize
lipglossoradollarcredittowardspurchasing.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G47

4G48

FacialTreatments

Avonsignsonpopularcelebritiesforitsproductandcollectionlaunches,andfeaturesthese
celebritiesinitscatalogs.
Avon regularly promotes various products in its catalogs and on its website with
discountedprices.
While not part of themeasuredmediaexpenditures, Avons brochures are central to
thepromotionofthebrand,andserveinlieuofafulladvertisingcampaign.
SomeofAvonstraditionaladvertisinginthepasthasbeenmorerecruitmentoriented,
asawaytosecurenewsalesassociatesthanpromotingactualproducts.
AvonalsowidelypublicizesitsannualWalkforBreastCanceranditsprogramstofight
domesticviolence.

GuthyRenkercontinuestopromoteProactivthroughinfomercialsandadvertising.
Popularcelebrityspokesmodels,suchactressesKaleyCuoco,JulianneHaugh,andNaya
Riveraareusedintelevisionspots,digitalmedia,andpromotionsduring2012.
Free gifts are offered with the purchase of a Proactiv starter kit, and free shipping is
alwaysoffered.
The brand continues to run directresponse advertisements in FSIs of weekend
newspapersthroughoutthecountry,encouragingprospectivecustomerstoeithermail
inacouponorcalltopurchasetheProactivsystem.
TheProactivkiosksinmajormallsaroundthecountryalsocontinuetoevolvefroma
mannedkiosktoavendingmachine.
Measured advertising expenditures for Proactiv are $304.2 million during 2012, up
from$247.3millionduring2011.

OUTLOOK

The emphasis on looking good and keeping aging at bay will continue during the forecast
period,eveniftheUnitedStatesentersperiodsofeconomicuncertainty.
The definition of antiaging will continue to evolve and will include a myriad of
attributesinadditiontowrinklereductionandfirming,suchasbrightening,luminosity,
andradiance.
Facialtreatmentproductswillbeusedbothasasubstitutetocosmeticproceduresand
asanadjuncttothem,withthecommongoaloflookingasyoungaspossible.

Innovationbackedbysciencewillcontinuetobethemainimpetustogrowingthisproduct
category.
Consumerswillcontinuetotrythelatestproductsavailableinthehopeoffindingtheir
fountainofyouthinabottleorjar.
The use of multiple layers of products including serums, treatment products, and
moisturizerswillbecomethenormratherthananexception.
Products will target prevention and correction of common issues relative to facial
concerns.
Facial treatment marketers will work to offer benefits that claim to mimic those of
injectables,offermusclerelaxingproperties,suchasBotox,andplumpskinlikefillers,
suchasRestylaneandJuvederm.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

FacialTreatments

Due to the success of BB creams from Asia, the United States will likely see an influx of
popularproductsfromotherareasoftheworld.
In late 2012 and early 2013, CC or color correction creams also from Asia begin to
appearontheU.S.market,andthereareexpectationsthatDDordailydefensecreams
mightalsoemergein2013and2014.
OilsfromnutsandtreesendemictovariousregionsinAfrica,arealsoexpectedtobe
usedmorecommonlyinthefuture.

TheFDAisexpectedtobemoreinvolvedinexaminingtheclaimsoffacialtreatmentbrands.
Severalbrands,suchasLancmehavealreadycomeunderscrutinyforsomeoftheir
claims,anditisexpectedthattheFDAwillprovidemoreoversightinthisareaduring
theforecastperiod.
Beforeandaftervisualstodemonstratetheresultsthatmaybeobtainedwiththeuse
of a products will be more readily available on the companys literature, with
disclaimersthatresultsmaynotbetypical.

More natural ingredients are likely to be used in facial treatment products during the
forecastperiod.
Fromoilstoplants,toingredientsfromthesea,thesenaturalingredientswillformthe
coreoffacialtreatmentproducts.
Stem cells from fruits and plants will likely increase in popularity in facial treatment
products.
Elimination of unnecessary ingredients and extra packaging will occur as facial
treatmentmarketersaimtobemoreenvironmentallyfriendly.

Marketerswillcontinuetolookbeyondtheircorechannelofdistributionforsales.
Drug chains and massmerchandisers willcontinue to look for higherend brandsand
willlikelyfindwillingparticipants.
Retailers, such as Sephora and Ulta will continue to court luxury department store
brands get them to test expanding their channel of distributionHome shopping
channelsandtheInternetareexpectedtoincreaseinpopularitywithluxurybrands.

Luxuryfacialtreatmentproductsareexpectedtoexhibitthemostgrowthoverthenextfive
yearsandareexpectedtobecomethelargesttradeclass.Moreconsumerswillbewillingto
tradeuptowhattheyperceiveasbetterproducts.
This trade class is expected to grow at a CAGR of 8.8%, compared to the category
averageof5.0%.
Antiagingwillcontinuetobethemajorpowerofthetradeclass,andtheuseofbetter
ingredientswilldriveuppricepoints.
Consumerswillviewthepurchasingoffacialtreatmentproductsasaninvestment,and
willbeenthusiastictoinvestintheseproductsprovidedthattheyseeresults.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G49

4G50

FacialTreatments

Massfacialtreatmentproductswillcontinuetoaccountforthesecondlargesttradeclass.
The mass trade class is expected to grow at a CAGR of 6.0%, which is ahead of the
industryaverageof5.0%.
Antiagingwillcontinuetobethemajorthemeofnewproducts.
Pricesofmassbrandswilllikelyincrease,duetomoretechnicallyadvancedingredients,
puttinghighendmassbrandsnotfarbehindthecostofentrylevelluxurybrands.
Mass retailers will continue to offer privatelabel brands that mimic the bestselling
nationallyadvertisedones,duetotheirattractivemargins.
Additionally, mass retailers will continue to seek out exclusive brands that are not
foundinallretailers,tohelppositionthemselvesasdestinations.Onesuchexampleis
WalgreenswhichinvestsinproductsfromAllianceBoots,suchastheBootsNo.7line
during2012.

ThedirecttradeclasswilllikelysufferthelargestdeclineataprojectedCAGRof2.0%.
Thistradeclasswillcontinuetoexperiencedecliningsalesduetochallengesfromboth,
AvonandMaryKaytorecruitandmaintaingoodqualitysalesassociates.
It is expected that infomercial marketer GuthyRenker will explore the selling of its
products in channels other than infomercials due to the increasing production costs
associatedwithitscurrentmodel.

Facial treatments are expected to grow at a CAGR of 5.0% over the forecast period,
reaching$8,482millionby2017.
Moisturizers/treatmentswillshowthemostgrowth,ataforecastCAGRof5.4%.
Fadecreamsandwhiteningproductswillexperienceslightdeclinesduringtheforecast
period as benefits offered by these products are increasingly being included in
moisturizerandtreatmentproducts.
The prevalence of acne treatments along with unique facial cleansers that allow for
betterabsorptionofmoisturizersandtreatmentproducts,willkeepthesetwoproduct
typesgrowingatthecategorysaverageof5.0%

Table4G22:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsintheUnited
StatesbyProductType,2012and2017

$Million

Producttype

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Moisturizers/treatments

3,724

4,834

5.4

Cleansers

1,935

2486

5.0

Acneaids

642

819

5.0

Astringents/toners

127

127

Whiteningproducts

99

98

(0.2)

Makeupremovers

99

99

Fadecreams

20

19

(1.0)

6,645

8,482

5.0

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

FacialTreatments

Table4G23:ForecastManufacturersSalesofFacialTreatmentsinthe
UnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012and2017

$Million

Tradeclass

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Mass

2,248

3,008

6.0

Luxury

2,120

3,232

8.8

Direct

1,482

1,340

(2.0)

699

810

3.0

97

92

(1.0)

6,645

8,482

5.0

Professional
Specialty
Total

Unit volume is forecast to grow at a CAGR of 4.2% over the forecast period, reaching
823millionpackagesby2017,upfrom670millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G51

4G52

FacialTreatments

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Salesofhandandbodylotionsatthemanufacturerslevelgrow1.9%to$2,283millionin
2012,upfrom$2,240millionin2011.

Salesinthehandandbodylotionscategoryhavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate
(CAGR)of1.1%from$2,160millionin2007to$2,283millionin2012.

Table4G24:HistoricalSalesofHandandBodyLotionsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

2,160

2008

2,172

0.6

2009

2,192

0.9

2010

2,208

0.7

2011

2,240

1.4

2012

2,283

1.9

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unit sales of hand and body lotions advance 1.6% to 514.2million packages in 2012, up
from506.1millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retail sales of hand and body lotions total $3,389 million in 2012, up 1.8% from
$3,331millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G54

HandandBodyLotions

Table4G25:ManufacturersSalesofHandandBodyLotionsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Mass

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

Jergensr

Kao

149

162

12.0

12.8

6.7

7.1

Aveenor

Johnson&Johnson

112

120

9.1

9.5

5.0

5.3

VaselineIntensiveCare

Unilever

114

108

9.2

8.6

5.1

4.7

Nivear

Beiersdorf

94

94

7.6

7.5

4.2

4.1

Eucerinr

Beiersdorf

82

85

6.6

6.7

3.7

3.7

GoldBond

Sanofi

63

64

5.1

5.1

2.8

2.8

Lubridermr

Johnson&Johnson

60

63

4.9

5.0

2.7

2.8

Cetaphilr

GaldermaLaboratories

53

54

4.3

4.3

2.4

2.4

Suaver

Unilever

54

52

4.4

4.1

2.4

2.3

Palmer'sr

E.T.Browne

44

48

3.6

3.8

2.0

2.1

Curelr

Kao

47

46

3.8

3.6

2.1

2.0

St.Ives

Unilever

32

32

2.6

2.5

1.4

1.4

Burt'sBees

TheCloroxCompany

29

30

2.3

2.4

1.3

1.3

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

26

25

2.1

2.0

1.2

1.1

Aquaphor

Beiersdorf

21

22

1.7

1.7

0.9

1.0

Olay

Procter&Gamble

22

20

1.8

1.6

1.0

0.9

Johnson's

Johnson&Johnson

0.7

0.7

0.4

0.4

Keri

Novartis

0.6

0.6

0.4

0.4

AvalonOrganics

TheHainCelestialGroup

0.6

0.6

0.3

0.3

Dove

Unilever

0.6

0.5

0.3

0.3

Sebamed

PhysicianLaboratories

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

JasonNaturalProducts

TheHainCelestialGroup

0.3

0.3

0.2

0.2

DirtyGirl/BlueQ

BlueQ

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

L'Oral

L'Oral

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

FruitoftheEarthr

FruitoftheEarth

0.1

0.1

TheHealingGarden

IlexCapitalGroup

0.1

0.1

EOS

EOSProducts

0.1

0.1

Privatelabelr

109

109

8.8

8.6

4.9

4.8

Allotherr

78

82

6.3

6.5

3.5

3.6

1,237

1,261

100.0

100.0

55.2

55.2

Totalr
Specialty
Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

409

425

66.8

67.0

18.3

18.6

Victoria'sSecretGarden

LimitedBrands

102

105

16.7

16.6

4.6

4.6

TheBodyShop

L'Oral

33

34

5.4

5.4

1.5

1.5

L'Occitane

L'Occitane

13

13

2.1

2.1

0.6

0.6

CamilleBeckman

CamilleBeckman

10

10

1.6

1.6

0.4

0.4

Crabtree&Evelyn

Crabtree&Evelyn

1.0

1.1

0.3

0.3

CaswellMassey

CaswellMassey

0.7

0.8

0.2

0.2

Allother

Total

35

35

5.7

5.5

1.6

1.5

612

634

100.0

100.0

27.3

27.8

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

4G55

HandandBodyLotions

Table4G25:ManufacturersSalesofHandandBodyLotionsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012
$Million
Tradeclass/brand

Company

2011

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS(Continued)

%Oftradeclass

2012

2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

Direct
MaryKay

MaryKay

93

95

39.9

41.5

4.2

4.2

Avon

Avon

75

70

32.2

30.6

3.3

3.1

Arbonne

Arbonne

35

35

15.0

15.3

1.6

1.5

Mark

Avon

2.6

2.2

0.3

0.2

Allother

Total

24

24

10.3

10.5

1.1

1.1

233

229

100.0

100.0

10.4

10.0

Luxury
Philosophy

Coty

10

11

13.7

14.9

0.4

0.5

Origins

EsteLauder

10

10

13.7

13.5

0.4

0.4

Clinique

EsteLauder

11.0

10.8

0.4

0.4

Bliss

SteinerLeisure

11.0

10.8

0.4

0.4

Clarins

Clarins

4.1

4.1

0.1

0.1

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

4.1

4.1

0.1

0.1

BeneFit

LVMH

4.1

2.7

0.1

0.1

Chanel

Chanel

2.7

2.7

0.1

0.1

ElizabethArden

ElizabethArden

2.7

2.7

0.1

0.1

Lancme

L'Oral

2.7

2.7

0.1

0.1

Shiseido

Shiseido

Allother

Total

2.7

2.7

0.1

0.1

20

21

27.4

28.4

0.9

0.9

73

74

100.0

100.0

3.3

3.2

20.8

20.8

0.2

0.2

19

19

79.2

79.2

0.8

0.8

24

24

100.0

100.0

1.1

1.1

16

16

38.1

38.1

0.7

0.7

7.1

7.1

0.1

0.1

Professional
Aveda

EsteLauder

Allother
Total

FOOTCAREPRODUCTS
Mass
Dr.Scholl's

Merck

FreemanBareFoot

FreemanBeauty

JohnsonsOdorEaters

Blistex

7.1

4.8

0.1

0.1

GoldBond

Sanofi

4.8

4.8

0.1

0.1

SallyHansen

Coty

2.4

2.4

0.0

0.0

17

18

40.5

42.9

0.8

0.8

42

42

100.0

100.0

1.9

1.8

11

12

100.0

100.0

0.5

0.5

2,240

2,283

Allother

Total

Specialty
Bath&BodyWorks
Direct
Footworks
TOTAL

LimitedBrands

Avon

100.0

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

100.0

0.4

0.3

100.0

100.0

4G56

HandandBodyLotions

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Naturalandorganicproductscontinuetoprosper,drivingthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Marketers, such as Johnson & Johnson, Kao, and The Clorox Company increasingly
introduce naturallyinspired hand and body lotion variants infused with different
naturalingredients,asthedemandforsuchproductsincreases.
In comparison to the conventional mass products, natural products demand higher
prices, which many consumers are willing to pay, thereby driving sales growth in the
category.
Mostofthenaturalproductofferingsinthecategoryarenaturallyinspiredandcontain
lowerproportionofsyntheticchemicalsincomparisontotheconventionalproductsin
thecategory.However,mosthandandbodylotionsarenottrulynatural.
A few naturallypositioned hand and body lotions available in the market include St.
IvessNaturallyIndulgentAdvancedBodyMoisturizers,AveenosPositivelyNourishing
Calming Body Lotion, Jergens Soothing Aloe Refreshing Moisturizer, and Burts Bees
NaturallyNourishingMilk&HoneyBodyLotion.
In 2012, Sensible Organics introduces the Nourish Organic Body Butter and Nourish
Organic Body Lotion and E. T Browne introduces the Palmers Cocoa Butter Formula
DailyCalmingLotionandPalmersCocoaButterFormulaHydratingGelLotion.
Mosthandandbodylotionsinthecategoryareinfusedwithcommonlyusednatural
ingredients, such as milk, honey, shea butter, cocoa butter, aloe, oatmeal, jojoba oil,
coconutoil,cucumber,vitaminA,andvitaminE.

Handandbodylotionsofferingtherapeuticbenefitscontributetothecategoryssales.
Products claiming to provide moisturizing and nourishing benefits continue to gain
acceptanceinthemarket.
Consumersincreasinglybuyhandandbodylotionsthatoffernourishing,hydrating,and
moisturizingproperties.
NiveasExtendedMoistureLotionenrichedwithProVitaminB5providesrelieftodry
skinforupto48hours.
Johnson&JohnsonsNeutrogenaMoistureWrapLotionclaimstomoisturizetheskin
deeply,andproviderelievefromdry,dull,andflakyskin.
Curelclaimsthatitslineofhandandbodylotionstobedermatologistrecommended
and formulated to moisturize and heal dry skin. Curels line of body lotions includes
nineSKUs.
Cetaphils Restoraderm Skin Restoring Moisturizer rebuilds the skins moisture,
replenishestheskinsnaturallipids,andsoothesdry,itching,andirritatedskin.
In2012,KaointroducestheJergensCremaDeepConditioningOatmeal,JergensCrema
SoothingAloeVera,andJergensCremaHydratingCoconutMilk.
Handandbodylotionsenrichedwithsunprotectionfactor(SPF)isanotherrisingtrend
in the market, with many consumers opting for multifunctional products providing a
varietyofbenefits.
SomeofthehandandbodylotionsofferingSPFbenefitsincludeJergensNaturalGlow
and Protect Daily Moisturizer with SPF 20, Eucerins Daily Protection SPF 15
MoisturizingBodyLotion,LubridermsDailyMoistureLotionwithBroadSpectrumSPF
15,PalmersCocoaButterFormulaSPF15BodyLotion,andVaselinesAloeFreshBody
LotionwithSPF15.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

HandandBodyLotions

Handandbodylotionsenrichedwithantiagingbenefitscontinuestobeaprominenttrend.
Marketers focus on the development of hand and body lotions, enriching them with
antiagingproperties,asthebabyboomerpopulationintheUnitedStatesincreases.
Hand and body lotions equipped with antiaging benefits that help reduce the
appearanceofaging,andfirmsandupliftstheskintokeeptheskinlookingyoungand
tight,gainprominenceinthemarket.
Jergens Natural Glow and Firming Daily Moisturizer not only provide a gradual
darkeningofskincolorbutalsofirmerskinwithimprovedskinelasticity,andnotably
reducedappearanceofcellulite.
Beiersdorfs Nivea Skin Firming Body Lotion with Q10 Plus is formulated with Co
enzyme Q10 Complex to firm and tighten skin. The company claims that results are
visibleinaslittleastwoweeks.
E.T. Browne asserts that its Palmers Cocoa Butter Formula Massage Lotion infused
withablendofcocoabutter,vitaminE,sheaButter,andBioCElaste,helpsreducethe
appearanceofstretchmarks.
Aveeno claims its Positively Ageless Skin Strengthening Hand Cream, enriched with
activenaturalssouthernwood,givesstronger,moreresilient,andyoungerlookingskin.
DovesProAgeCreamOilBodyLotionisamultifunctionalproductofferingthebenefits
ofenhancedcellturnover,hydration,andsunprotection,allinoneproduct.

Theavailabilityofhandandbodylotionsina variety of exotic fragrances is a significantly


growingtrend.
Marketersareincreasinglyintroducinghandandbodylotionsinanarrayoffragrances
toappealtoawidersectionofconsumersandalsoexpandtheirproductportfolio.
AvalonOrganicshandandbodylotionsareavailableinOlive&GrapeSeed,Grapefruit
&Geranium,Lavender,Lemon,Peppermint,Rosemary,andYlangYlangvariants.
SuaveNaturalsoffershandandbodylotionsinWildCherryBlossom,LavenderVanilla,
MangoMandarin,SweetPea&Violet,andEverlastingSunshinealternatives.
However,marketershavenowalsobeguntointroducefragrancefreeformulations.
AfewofthefragrancefreehandandbodylotionsavailableinthemarketareCurels
Intensive Healing Cream Daily FragranceFree Cream and Mary Kays FragranceFree
SatinHandsCream.
In2012,KaointroducestheJergensDailyMoistureFragranceFreeDrySkinLotion.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G57

4G58

HandandBodyLotions

Seasonalitydeterminesthedemandforthetypeofhandandbodylotions.
During winters, consumers choose to use hand and body lotions enriched with
ingredientsofferingextramoisturizingandhydratingbenefitssoastoprovidereliefto
extra dry skin while during summers consumers use hand and body lotions with a
lightweightfeelandofferingagradualtannedlook.
Some of the commonly used hand and body lotions during winters include Jergens
CremaDeepConditioningOatmealandEucerinsIntensiveRepairVeryDrySkinLotion,
whilethehandandbodylotionsfavoredinsummersincludeEucerinsProtectionSPF
15MoisturizingBodyLotion,Crabtree&EvelynsTaroccoOrange,Eucalyptus&Sages
Skin Refreshing Body Lotion, and Bath & Body Works Wild Citrus Sunflower Body
Lotion.
Also,handandbodylotionsavailableingelformatsareincreasinglypopular,withafew
variants available in the market including Palmers new Cocoa Butter Formula
Hydrating Gel Lotion, Niveas Express Hydrating Gel, and Vaselines Aloe Fresh
HydratingBodyGel.

Salesofprivatelabelproductsremainstablein2012.
Privatelabel hand and body lotions are associated with decent quality products
providingefficaciousresults.
Also,privatelabelproductsaresupportedbyanaggressivepushfromretailers,suchas
Walmart, Walgreens, and Target, who are allocating good amount of shelf space at
strategiclocationsforeasyvisibilitytoconsumers.
Manyconsumerswhohadtradeddowntoprivatelabelproductsduringtherecession,
continue to use them in spite of the economic recovery. This is due to their past
experienceofprivatelabelproductsprovidingthemresultssimilartothoseofnational
brandsatamuchlowerprice.
Privatelabel products offer more value for money with a difference of 30.0%35.0%
betweentheirpricesandthoseofnationalmassbrands.

Foot care products continue to remain a niche segment in the hand and body lotions
categorywithsalesin2012stagnantat$61million,flatfrom2011.
Footcareproductsaccountfor2.7%ofthecategoryssalesin2012.
Mercks Dr.Scholls retains its lead in the segment, with sales at $16million in 2012,
samefrom2011levels.
Sales in the segment remain stagnant due to a lack of new product activity and
innovation. Moreover, limited number of marketers compete in the segment with
limitedproductofferings.
A few variants available in this segment include Curels Foot Therapy Cream and
PalmersCocoaButterFormulaFootMagic.
Additionally,thenegligibletraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)allocatedbymarketers
forthesegmenthasadverseeffectonthecategoryssales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

HandandBodyLotions

Notablenewproducts

Table4G26:SelectNewHandandBodyLotionsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Beiersdorf

Eucerin

ProfessionalRepairExtremelyDrySkinLotionisinfusedwithceramide3andglucoglycerol,retain
moisture,andpreventsfurtherdryness

TheCloroxCompany

BurtsBees

UltimateCareHandCreamisclinicallyproventomoisturizeextremelydryskin.Theformulaisenriched
withbaobaboil,watermelonseedoil,andnaturalfruitacidcomplex

TheCloroxCompany

BurtsBees

UltimateCareBodyLotionisclinicallyproventoleavedryskinmoisturized,nourished,and
conditioned.Itcontainspumpkinseedoilandgreenteaextracts

TheCloroxCompany

Gd

RedRubyGroovyNaturalBodyLotionsoftensskin,hasnoparabens,phthalatesorpetrochemicalsand,
hasthescentofgrapefruitandwildthyme

TheCloroxCompany

Gd

PearanormalActivityNaturalBodyLotionsoftensskinheadtotoe,hasnoparabens,phthalates,or
petrochemicals,hasascentofpearandacaiberry,andisenrichedwithsheabutter

TheCloroxCompany

Gd

OrangePetaloozaNaturalBodyLotionisenrichedwithsheabutterthathydratestheskinandgets
absorbedquickly,hasnoparabens,phthalates,orpetrochemicals,hasascentofbloodorangeand
hyacinthleaves

TheCloroxCompany

Gd

FloralCherrynovaNaturalBodyLotionprovidesnourishmenttotheskin,hasnoparabens,phthalates,
orpetrochemicals,hasascentofcherryblossomsandalmondmilk

TheCloroxCompany

Gd

VanillaFlameNaturalBodyLotionprovidesmoisturizingpropertiestotheskin,hasnoparabens,
phthalates,orpetrochemicals,hasascentofvanillaandricemilk

E.TBrowne

Palmers

CocoaButterFormulaDailyCalmingLotionwithablendofcocoabutter,glycerin,urea,soy,andoat
providesrelieftoirritatedskin,helpsretainmoisture,exfoliatesdryandflakypatches,andchamomile
andlavenderextractsprovidesoothingbenefits

E.TBrowne

Palmers

CocoaButterFormulaHydratingGelLotionisalightweightmoisturizerintheformofgel,infusedwith
cocoabutter,vitaminE,aloe,andcucumberextract

Kao

Jergens

NaturalGlowandProtectisabodymoisturizer,providesUVA/UVBprotection(SPF20),availablefor
twoskintones:fairtomedium,andmediumtotan.

Kao

Jergens

DailyMoistureDrySkinLotionisanodorlessdailymoisturizer,thatrevitalizesskinwithmoisturizer,
antioxidant,andvitaminE.Itisavailablefortwoskintones:fairtomedium,andmediumtotan

Kao

Jergens

CremaDeepConditioningOatmealBodyMoisturizer,containsoatmealformulathatprovideshealing
andsoothingpropertiestoreplenishtheskin

Kao

Jergens

CremaSoothingAloeVeraBodyMoisturizer,enrichedwithaloevera,vitaminEandB5

Kao

Jergens

CremaHydratingCoconutMilkBodyMoisturizer,lightweightformulawithcoconutmilk

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

SecretBombshellItalianIrisBodyLotionisalimitededitionbodylotionfromtheCiaoBellafragrance
collectionwithtopnotesofItalianiris,whitepoppy,andorris

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

VerySexyItalianMandarinBodyLotionisalimitededitionbodylotionfromtheCiaoBellafragrance
collectionwithtopnotesofItalianmandarin,bergamot,andcoconutmilk

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

VSFantasiesDeepsofteningBodyButterisarestorativebodybutterenrichedwithsheabutter,cocoa
butter,andvitaminE.Itisavailableinthreevariant:LusciousCrush,CitrusDream,andLemonEscape

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

VSFantasiesUltramoisturizingHandandBodyCreamisanintensivehandandbodycreamenriched
withavocadoandsweetalmondoilsandhoneyfora24hourmoisturizingexperience.Itisavailablein
threevariant:LusciousCrush,CitrusDream,andLemonEscape

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

VSFantasiesHydratingBodyLotionisafastabsorbingbodylotionenrichedwithextractsofaloe,oat,
andgrapeseedandvitaminEandC.Itisavailableinthreevariant:LusciousCrush,CitrusDream,and
LemonEscape

LimitedBrands

Victorias
Secret

ItalianBergamotBodyLotionisalimitededitionbodylotionfromtheCiaoBellafragrancecollection
withtopnotesofItalianbergamot,waterbreeze,andspringdaffodils

SensibleOrganics

Nourish
Organic

NourishOrganicBodyButterisenrichedwithsheabutter,coconutoil,oliveoil,vitaminE,and
antioxidants,andminimizessignsofaging

SensibleOrganics

Nourish
Organic

NourishOrganicBodyLotionisenrichedwithaloe,proteins,acai,essentialoils,andvitaminE,claimsto
improveskinelasticity

TheCloroxCompany

BurtsBees

IntenseHydrationDayLotionisanoncomedogenicdaylotionthathydratesdryskinandhelpsreduce
finelinesandwrinkles.Itisinfusedwithclarysage

Valeant
Pharmaceuticals

CeraVe

SARenewingLotionislightweight,fragrancefreebodymoisturizerthathydratesskin.Itisenriched
withnaturalingredients,suchasglycerin,mineraloil,ceramides,andvitaminD.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G59

4G60

HandandBodyLotions

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4G27:ManufacturersSalesofHandandBodyLotionsintheUnitedStatesby
Company,2011and2012

$Million
2011

2012

2011

2012

LimitedBrands

522

542

23.3

23.7

Johnson&Johnsonr

207

217

9.2

9.5

Kaor

196

208

8.8

9.1

Beiersdorfr

197

201

8.8

8.8

Unileverr

207

198

9.2

8.7

MaryKay

93

95

4.2

4.2

Avon

89

82

4.0

3.6

Sanofi

65

66

2.9

2.9

GaldermaLaboratoriesr

53

54

2.4

2.4

E.T.Browner

44

48

2.0

2.1

LOral

38

38

1.7

1.7

Arbonne

35

35

1.6

1.5

TheCloroxCompany

29

30

1.3

1.3

EsteLauder

26

26

1.2

1.1

Procter&Gamble

22

20

1.0

0.9

Merck

16

16

0.7

0.7

Privatelabelr

109

109

4.9

4.8

Allotherr

292

298

13.0

13.1

2,240

2,283

100.0

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

%Oftotal

Company

Totalr

rRestated.

HandandBodyLotions

LimitedBrandsistheleadingcompanyinthehandandbodylotionscategorywitha3.8%
growthin2012.
Sales grow from $522 million in 2011 to $542 million in 2012 supported by new
productintroductionsandpackagingchangestoitsexitinglineofproducts.
LimitedBrandsrepresents23.7%shareofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfroma
23.3%shareoftotalcategoryssalesin2011.
ThecompanyisrepresentedbyBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretbrandsinthe
category.
Bath&BodyWorkssalesadvance4.0%from$420millionin2011to$437millionin
2012.
Bath & Body Works product offerings in the category include body lotions, body
creams,bodybutters,footlotionsandcreams,andhandlotionsandcreams.
Bath&BodyWorksSignatureCollectionisoneofthebestsellingproductlinesforthe
company.
Other popular product ranges for the brand include Forever Red, Paris Amour, and
CashmereGlow.
The Forever Red product line is a premium line and therefore is retailed at a higher
price.
In 2012, the brand introduces the Pink Chiffon Body Lotion, Cashmere Glow Body
Lotion, Paris Amour Body Lotion, Paris Amour Triple Moisture Body Cream, and the
ForeverRedBodyLotion.
Also in 2012, the marketer brings about packaging changes to its Sweet Cinnamon
Pumpkinlineofproductscomprisingabodylotionandamoisturebodycream;Twilight
Woods line of products comprising a body lotion, moisture body cream, and body
butter and; Brown Sugar & Fig line of products comprising a body Lotion and a
moisturebodycream.
As a part of its 2012 Holiday Traditions, the brand introduces the Vanilla Bean Noel
LotionandFrostedSnowberryBodyLotionforalimitedtimeperiod.
VictoriasSecretssalesadvance2.9%from$102millionin2011to$105millionin2012.
In2012,VictoriasSecretintroduceslimitededitionoftheSecretBombshellItalianIris
BodyLotion,ItalianBergamotBodyLotion,andVerySexyItalianMandarinLotion.Also
new to 2012 are a number of Victorias Secrets Fantasies variants with exotic
fragrances.In2012,thePinklineofbodylotionsandbodybuttersundergoapackaging
changetogivethelineofproductsamorelivelyandfreshlook.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G61

4G62

HandandBodyLotions

Johnson&Johnsonisthesecondlargestmarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategory,
withsalesat$217millionin2012.
Salesgrow4.8%from$207millionin2011.
Johnson&Johnsonsmarketsharegrowsfrom9.2%in2011to9.5%in2012.
The marketer competes in the category with its Aveeno, Neutrogena, Lubriderm,
Johnsons,andRoCbrands.
Aveenoisthelargestbrandforthemarketerinthecategorywithsalesat$120million
in2012,up7.1%from$112millionin2011.Aveenosnaturalpositioninginthemarket
istheprimaryreasonbehindthebrandsgrowthasmoreconsumerschoosenaturally
positionedhandandbodylotionsovertheconventionalhandandbodylotions.
Aveenorepresents55.3%ofthemarketerstotalsalesinthecategoryin2012.
Thebrandclaimstoenrichitsproductformulationswithactivenaturalingredients.
Some of the commonly found natural ingredients in Aveenos hand and body lotions
include blueberry, goji berries, grapefruit, rosemary, vanilla, cocoa butter, and shea
butter.
The marketers secondlargest brand in the category is Lubriderm, with sales at
$63millionin2012,up5.0%from$60millionin2011.Thegrowthin2012isdrivenby
theformulationchangesthatthemarketerintroducestoitsLubridermlineinlate2011,
effectsofwhichbecomeprominentinits2012sales.
The brand represents a 29.0% share in Johnson & Johnsons hand and body lotions
salesinthecategory.
Lubridermpositionsitselfasadermatologistdevelopedbrandwithfourproductlines:
DailyMoisture,AdvancedTherapy,IntenseSkinRepair,andSoothingRelief.
Sales of Johnson & Johnsons thirdleading brand, Neutrogena, decline 3.8% from
$26millionin2011to$25millionin2012.Neutrogenassalesdeclineasaresultofthe
lack of new and innovative product activity from the brand in the category in 2012.
Additionally,thebrandsofferingsinthecategoryareverylimitedincomparisontothe
other brands offerings. The more successful competitors continuously evolve their
brandsandoffernewandinnovativeproductswithadditionalbenefitsandfragrances
tokeepconsumersengaged.
As a result of the sales decline in 2012, Neutrogenas share in Johnson & Johnsons
sales in the hand and body lotions category decline from 12.6% in 2011 to 11.5% in
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

HandandBodyLotions

Kaocontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketerinthecategorywithsalesat$208millionin
2012.
Salesgrow6.1%from$196million2011.
Kaosmarketshareinthehandandbodylotionscategoryadvancesfrom8.8%ofthe
totalcategoryssalesin2011,to9.1%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012.
KaoisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsJergensandCurelbrands.
Jergensisthelargestmassbrandinthehandandbodylotionscategory,accountingfor
7.1%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfrom6.7%in2011.
Salesforthebrandadvance8.7%from$149millionin2011to$162millionin2012.
The good performance of the newlyintroduced Jergens Crema line comprising three
variants: Crema DeepConditioning Oatmeal Body Lotion, Crema Soothing Aloe Vera
BodyLotion,andCremaHydratingCoconutMilkaidsinthebrandsgrowth.
JergenslineofproductsinthehandandbodylotionscategorycomprisesNaturalGlow,
DailyMoisturizers,andCrema.
Alsoin2012,themarketerchangesthepackagingofitsNaturalGlowlineofproducts
withnewproductintroductions,includingtheNaturalGlowandProtectandtheDaily
Moisture Dry Skin Lotion, each including two variants for different skin tones: fair to
mediumandmediumtotan.
SalesofCureldeclinein2012to$46million,down2.1%from$47millionin2011.
Inadditiontobodylotions,Curelalsooffershandandfootcareproductsintheformof
Hand&CuticleTherapyandFootTherapy,respectively.

Beiersdorfisthefourthleadingmarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategorywithsales
reaching$201millionin2012.
Manufacturerssalesadvance2.0%to$210millionin2012,from$196millionin2011.
BeiersdorfispresentinthecategorywithitsNivea,Eucerin,andAquaphorbrands.
Niveaistheleadingbrandforthemarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategorywith
salesat$94millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Niveas product offerings include lotions, hand creams, and gels/serums with a wide
selectionofproductsforthelotionssegment.
EucerinisthenextbiggestbrandforBeiersdorfinthecategory,postinga3.7%growth
toreach$85millionin2012from$82millionin2011.
In 2012, Eucerin undergoes packaging changes for its hand and body lotions by
streamlining the design for each product. A texture scale design is added to the
packagingthatshowsiftheproductisrich,lightweight,orfallsbetweenthetwo.
Additionally,theproductnamesarechangedtomakeiteasierforconsumerstoclearly
identifywhattheproducthastooffer.Thisproductnamechangeismadefor11SKUs
inthehandandbodylotionscategory.
SalesofAquaphorincreaseto$22millionin2012,up4.8%from$21millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G63

4G64

HandandBodyLotions

Unileveristhefifthleadingmarketerinthecategorywithdecliningsalesin2012.
Thecompanyssalesdecline4.3%from$207millionin2011to$198millionin2012.
ThemarketerisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsVaseline,Suave,Dove,andSt.Ives
brands.
Unileveraccountsfor8.7%shareofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,downfrom9.2%
in2011.
Sales of Vaseline continue to declines in 2012 with sales at $108 million, down 5.3%
from$114millionin2011.
VaselineisbackedbyTMEof$41millionin2012,upfrom$28.4millionin2011.The
VaselineIntensiveMoisturelineisthemostadvertisedrangeofproductsforthebrand
with a TME allocation of approximately $20 million in 2012. However, the lack of
freshness in its product portfolio, negligible innovation, and increasing competition
fromotherbrandsresultinsalesdeclineforVaselinein2012.
Suaveisthesecondleadingbrandforthemarketerin2012withsalesat$52million,
down3.7%from$54millionin2011.Despitetheextensionofitshandandbodylotions
lineofproducts,thebrandisnotabletopostgrowthin2012.
SuaveintroducestheEverlastingSunshinefragrancetoitsalreadyexistingbodylotion
productlinein2012.
SalesofSt.Ivesremainstagnantat$32millionin2012,from2011levels.
SalesofDovecontinuetodeclineat14.3%from$7millionin2011to$6millionin2012.
AdeclineinsalesofDoveisduetonegligiblenewproductactivityandnoinnovations
orformulationchangesforthebrandin2012.
Dovehasalimitedpenetrationinthecategorywithonlyfourproducts.

Privatelabel

In 2012, manufacturers sales of privatelabel products remain stagnant at $109 million


from2011levels.
Themarketshareofprivatelabeldeclinesto4.8%ofthecategoryssalesin2012from
4.9% in 2011, although the overall categorys sales grow. The recovering economy
allowsconsumerstoshiftbacktonationalbrands,therebyrestrictingsalesgrowthof
privatelabelproductsin2012.
However,privatelabelproductsreceivesupportfromretailersduetothehighmargin
ofprofitsearnedbythemascomparedtothosefromwellestablishednationalbrands.
Few privatelabel products available in the market include Walgreens Cocoa Butter,
Walgreens Intensive Healing Moisturizing Lotion, CVS Healthy Hands Hand and Nail
Care Lotion, CVS Fragrance Free Lotion Advanced Healing, and Sephoras Collection
HeadtoToeHydrator.
Massmerchandiserscontinuallyexpandtheirexistingproductlineswithhandandbody
lotions offering advanced benefits, such as antiaging, sun care, and therapeutic
benefits.
SomeofthealreadyavailableproductsinthemarketincludeCVSHealingSkinTherapy
Lotion, Rite Aids Renewal Daily Moisturizer Positively Glowing with SPF 15, and
WalgreensMoistureRecoveryLotionFragranceFree.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

HandandBodyLotions

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Specialty stores continue to be the largest retail distribution outlet in the hand and body
lotions category, representing 33% of the total categorys sales in 2012, flat from 2011
levels.
Massmerchandisersarethesecondbiggestretailoutletwitha28%shareofthetotal
categoryssalesin2012,upfroma27%sharein2011.
In2012,theshareofdirectsalesdeclinesto11%from12%in2011,primarilydueto
thepoorperformanceofthedirectmarketer,Avon.

Table4G28:ManufacturersSalesofHandandBodyLotionsin
theUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Specialtystores

33

33

Massmerchandisers

27

28

Drugstores

18

18

Directsales

12

11

Departmentstores

Foodstores

Professionaloutlets

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Overall

In2012,TMEforhandandbodylotionstotal$297.1million,up14.1%from$260.4million
in2011.
In2012,magazineadvertisingovertakestelevisionadvertisementsasthemostutilized
mediumofadvertisingamongmarketers.Marketersspend42.6%or$126.6ofthetotal
categorys TME on magazine advertisements in 2012, followed by 33.9% or
$60.0millionofthetotalcategorysTMEontelevisionadvertising.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G65

4G66

HandandBodyLotions

Kaoisthelargestadvertiserinthecategory,withatotalTMEof$61.2millionin2012,up
18.1%from$51.8millionin2011.
Kao allocates $35.3million and $26.0 million to its Jergens and Curel brands,
respectively.
Jergens Ultra Healing is the most advertised product line from Jergens, with a TME
allocation of $12.3million in 2012. Majority of this expenditure is on television and
magazineadvertisements.

Johnson&Johnsonretainsitspositionasthesecondlargestadvertiserinthecategorywith
aTMEof$49.9millionin2012,down1.2%from$50.5millionin2011.
MajorityoftheTMEor$41.4millionisapportionedtowardsprintmediain2012.The
companyallocates$8.1milliontowardsmagazineadvertisements.
The company promotes its brands competing in the category through television
commercials and fullpage advertisements in popular beauty publications, such as
Glamour,Lucky,andBeautyFashion.
In2012,Johnson&Johnsonallocates$41.0millioninTMEtopromoteAveenosDaily
MoisturizingBodyLotion.

Beiersdorfcontinuestobethethirdleadingadvertiserinthecategory.
ThecompanyallocatesaTMEof$33.4millionin2012,up5.0%from$31.9millionin
2011.
In 2012, Beiersdorf spends $17.5million on its Nivea brand, with $12.4million being
allocatedtotelevisionmedia.
Beiersdorf allocates approximately $16million for its Eucerin brand in 2012, with an
equaldivisionbetweentheprintandtelevisionmedia.

Massbrands

Traditionalmarketingtechniquescontinuetobethemostpopularwiththemassmarketers
in2012.
Advertising, discounts, couponing, sampling, shelf displays, and consumer outreach
programsareafewtoolsthatmarketerscontinuetousetoincreasesales.

Magazine and television advertisements are the most heavily employed marketing media
forhandandbodylotions.
In 2012, Unilever endorses its Vaseline brand with nearly $41million in TME, with
54.9%at$22.5millionspentonmagazineadvertisements.
In 2012, Vaseline Intensive Care Rescue line is allocated a total TME of $20.1million,
spreadmainlyacrosstelevisionandtheInternetmedia.
In2012,KaosTMEexpenditureforitsJergensbrandis$35.3millionwithmajorityofit
beingspentonmagazineadvertisements.
JergensUltraHealingproductlineisthemostadvertisedproductlineforJergenswith
aTMEallocationof$12.3millionin2012.
In 2012, Beiersdorf apportions $17.5million as the advertising budget for its Nivea
brandwith70.9%oftheTMEspentontelevisionadvertisements.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

HandandBodyLotions

Coupons of several denominations are offered by marketers in an attempt to entice


consumerstopurchasetheirproducts.
Coupons,whichareusuallyprintedordigital,makeproductsavailabletoconsumersat
a price lower than the regular market price. This induces consumers to splurge on
products.
Mass brands, such as Aveeno, Neutrogena, and Nivea use brochures to extend the
valueoftheproductsandincreasethepopularityofbrands,throughadvertisementsin
Sundaynewspapers.Mostbrands,suchasEucerin,Nivea,andJergensoffervouchers
throughmagazines,websites,andQRcodesonmobiles.Thishelpsmarketerstokeep
theirloyalconsumersinformedoftheirlatestoffersandnewproductlaunches.
In 2012, Eucerin offers coupons worth $1.50 on its hand and body products, Nivea
offerscouponsworth$2.00ononeNiveahandandbodylotionproduct,andJergens
offers a coupon worth $1.00 on one Jergens Skin Care Lotion. Social media sites and
Sundayfreestandinginserts(FSIs)arethemostfavoredmediatoadvertisesuchoffers.

Companies also utilize their brands websites to promote products and to communicate
withconsumers.
Throughtheirwebsites,marketersupdateinformationabouttheirbrandsbyproviding
detailedinformationandproductbenefits.
The Internet is progressively being used as a crossmarketing medium to promote a
brands presence across different media. A popular trend followed by almost all
companies is to link the brands websites with their social media pages, such as
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTube.
Moreover, recently many brands have started to enter the popularly growing social
mediachannelPinterest.
Most brands offer consumers an opportunity to win rewards by answering a few
questionsabouttheirbrands.Forexample,consumerscanavailrewardsbyanswering
afewquestionsaboutJergens(Kao).Thebrandswebsitealsoallowsconsumerstosign
up for the Jergens newsletters, which provides consumers with latest information on
thebrandshappeningsanddiscountsandoffers.
Doveswebsitealsoallowsconsumerstosignupforsuchnewsletterstherebyhelping
the brand communicate its latest promotions and offers. Doves website also offers
specialbeautyadvicesandtipstoitsaudience.Thebrandswebsitealsointeractswith
itsconsumersthroughvideos,quizzes,andgames.
Dove spreads awareness about the SelfEsteem Weekend and its other social
initiativesthroughthesocialmissiontabonitswebsite.Italsomakesavailableonits
website,discountcouponsandallowsconsumerstoregisterfortheDovenewsletter,
alsoknownastheDoveInsider.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G67

4G68

HandandBodyLotions

Socialmediaisoneofthefastestgrowingmediausedbymarketerstopromotetheirbrands.
In majority of the cases, brands have their own social networking page or account which
contains information on the brands happenings and information on the brands newly
launchedandbestsellingproducts.
Leadingmarketers,suchassuchasUnilever,Kao,Johnson&Johnson,andBeiersdorf
extensively use social media channels, such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube, to
promotetheirbrandsandproducts.Thisprovidesconsumersaplatformtodiscussand
sharetheirexperiences,reviewproducts,andaskqueriesfrombrandexperts.
These social networking pages/accounts inform consumers about new product
introductions, events, special offers, discounts, coupons, sweepstakes, and other
companyinitiatives.
Consumers can post their queries on these sites and await a response from the
company. Marketers also utilize these pages to educate consumers through live chat
experienceswithindustryexpertsandcelebrities.
Additionally, social media allows marketers to directly communicate with consumers
thereby allowing companies to understand the dynamics of the market and create
productsthatcatertotheconsumersneeds.

Luxurybrands

Instorepromotions,directmailings,andatcountersamplingaretheprimarypromotional
toolsadoptedbyluxurymarketers.
Marketing activities, such as merchandising endeavors, pointofpurchase advertising,
sales assistance, displays, sampling, and price promotions, taking place inside a retail
environmentarecategorizedasinstoremarketing.
Departmentstoresusuallyemploysuperiorcustomerservice,specialevents,andgift
withpurchase(GWP)optionstopromotetheirbrands.
ThefundamentalpromotionaltoolsutilizedintraditionaldepartmentstoresareGWP
and purchasewithpurchase (PWP). Purchases are typically high during such
promotionalperiodssinceconsumersareawareofsuchoffers.
Salespersonsgenerallyundergoindepthtrainingaboutsuchluxuryproductssoasto
educateconsumersaboutsuchoffers.Luxurymarketersalsopromotetheirbrandsin
retailers catalogs and conduct various promotional activities that help set up direct
contactwithconsumers.

Specialtybrands

Specialtyretailersofferavisuallystimulatingenvironmentalongwithknowledgeablesales
associates,pricepromotions,andaconstantflowofnewproductstopersuadeconsumers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

HandandBodyLotions

Instore promotions that sport huge discounts are popular among specialty marketers.
LimitedBrandsusuallyadvertisesitsBath&BodyWorksbrandbyprovidingoffers,suchas
buytwoandgetonefreeandbuythreeandgetthreefreepromotionsonselectproducts.
Bath & Body Works helps clear its stock of goods through its two semiannual sales
heldinJanuaryandJune.Thesesalespavewayforthebrandslatestlineofproducts.
Thebrandalsoprovidescoupons,suchasa$10.00offonpurchaseofproductsworth
$30.00 and discounts, such as 20.0% off on entire purchase or buy four products for
$15.00orsixfor$20.00.
Specialtybrandsusuallyrenderdiscountsashugeas80.0%onselectproductsduring
theholidayseason.
Instore demos prove to be an effective marketing tool and relationship builder for
associates.Brands,suchasBath&BodyWorks,stayclearfromtelevisionandmagazine
advertisingandoftenutilizeinstoredemonstrationssincetheyhaveamorepersonal
touch. Window displays is another commonly used promotional tool utilized by
specialtybrands.Specialtybrandsalsooffertesterstoconsumerstotrynewproducts.
TheBath&BodyWorkswebsitecontainsalistofallproductsalongwithaspecialtab
for all the products on sale. The brand offers discounts on some of its products
throughouttheyear.Freeshippingonpurchasesabove$50.00isanotherpromotional
toolwhichisoftenusedbythemarketer,especiallyduringtheholidayseasonof2012.

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

Manufacturerssalesofhandandbodylotionsareforecasttopostapositivegrowthwitha
CAGRof1.8%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Handandbodylotionsisamaturecategorywithhighlevelofcompetitionamongthe
existingbrandsandpresentslimitedscopeforinnovation.
Marketersintroductionofnewproductsofferingadditionalbenefits,suchasantiaging,
sun care, therapeutic, and natural formulations will help achieve a moderate growth
forthecategoryandmaintainconsumersinterest.
Privatelabelproductsarelikelytogrowtheirsalesduringthenextfiveyears.
Private label is expected to expand their product portfolio by offering good quality
multifunctionalproductsataffordableprices.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G69

4G70

HandandBodyLotions

Natural and organic products are expected to be the driving force behind the categorys
growthduringtheforecastperiodending2017.
The natural and organic products segment will continue to perform well during the
nextfiveyearsasconsumersbecomemoreconsciousofwhattheyapplyontheirskin.
Oncetheproductefficacyisproven,consumersarelikelytotradeupforthesehigher
priced naturallypositioned products, thereby supporting the overall growth of the
category.
Marketersnotpresentinthenaturalssegmentwithproductofferings,areexpectedto
makeanattempttoenterthisprofitmakingsegment.
Smallmassmarketerswithlimitedfinancialsupportarealsoexpectedtoencashupon
this opportunity by offering naturallypositioned products, although with lesser and
morecommonlyavailablenaturalingredients,suchasaloevera,coconutoil,almondoil,
oliveoil,honey,andsheabutter.

Innovation will be of key importance to the category during the forecast period, 2012 to
2017.
Productinnovationwillplayamajorroleinthecategorysgrowth.
Innovation could be in the form of new product activity, packaging changes, and
improvedformulationsincludingtechnologicaladvancements.
Unlessmarketerscontinuetoinnovate,thecategoryislikelytostagnate.
Marketers are expected to innovate with the packaging formats of their products
duringtheforecastperiodbymakingtheirformulationsavailableinformatsthatallow
convenientandeasyapplicationoftheproducts.

Marketersareexpectedtoadoptinnovativemarketingtechniquesinordertopromotetheir
products.
Establishedmassmarketerswillcontinuetoallocatesignificantamountofadvertising
expenditurestopromotetheirrespectivebrands.
Majority of the marketers are already present on social media networks, such as
FacebookandTwitter,withmanyexpandingtheiroutreachtoYouTubeandPinterest.
Marketers can widen their marketing approach by educating consumers on the
benefitsoftheingredientsusedintheproductsandadvisingthemonthebestsuitable
handandbodylotionfortheirskintypebasedontheproductformulation.
Samples, coupons, giveaways, and contests will continue to be a major part of mass
brandsmarketingstrategy.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

HandandBodyLotions

The consistent rise of the baby boomer population across the United States will facilitate
marketersinexpandingtheirproductlineswithantiagingproperties.
Antiagingisalreadyanestablishedtrendinthethefacialtreatmentscategoryandis
expectedtohaveamajorimpactinthehandandbodylotionscategory.
Consumers pose an increased awareness of their overall appearance and would not
only want antiaging products for their face but for their entire body, for a uniform
youngerlookingappearance.
Hand and body lotions with antiaging properties will present the marketers an
opportunitytobargainforhigherpricesfortheseproducts,astheywouldoffermuch
morethanregularmoisturizingandhydratingbenefits.
Overthenextfiveyears,theproductformulationsarelikelytoincludeantioxidantsand
SPFasincreasedexposureoftheskintoUltraVioletAlfa(UVA)andUltraVioletBeta
(UVB)raysisakeyreasonbehindprematureaging.

Themassanddirectsaleschannelsarelikelytogrowduringtheforecastperiod.
Natural product offerings from mass merchandisers will add to the sales of the mass
channel.
Since the category is a valuedriven category, consumers seek valueadded products
availableatareasonableprice.
Moreover,privatelabelproductsavailableinmassmerchandiserswilladdtothesales
ofthedistributionchannel.
Over the course of the next five years, the direct sales channel is expected to gain
momentum as the ecommerce trend gains popularity among consumers with many
marketersallowingconsumerstobuyfromtheirowncompanyswebsitethangotoa
retailerswebsite.

Privatelabelisexpectedtoproliferateoverthenextfiveyears.
Privatelabel products, available at retailers, which gathered popularity during the
recession,arelikelytobewellacceptedbyconsumersduringtheforecastperiod.
Thelowpricedprivatelabelproductswillbeassociatedwithqualityproductofferings
providingresultssimilartothoseofferedbynationalbrandsandatalowerpricepoint
ascomparedtonationalbrandsproducts.
Overthenextfiveyears,retailersareexpectedtointroducehandandbodylotionswith
multibenefitsgivingstiffcompetitiontonationalbrands.

Sales of hand and body lotions are forecast to increase at a CAGR of 1.8% from
$2,283millionin2012to$2,500millionin2017.

Unit volume is expected to advance to 552.0million packages by 2017, up at a CAGR of


1.4%from514.2millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G71

4G72

HandandBodyLotions

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesfortheskincareproductsformenscategorypostahealthygrowthof
9.7%from$154millionin2011to$169millionin2012.

Since2007,thecategoryssaleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of
3.4%.

Table4G29:HistoricalSalesofSkinCareProductsfor
MenintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

143

2008

151

5.6

2009

146

(3.3)

2010

143

(2.1)

2011

154

7.7

2012

169

9.7

rRestated.

Unitsales

The categorys unit sales grow at 9.2% from 17.3million packages in 2011 to 18.9million
packagesin2012.

Retailsales

Salesattheretailleveltotal$265millionin2012,up9.5%from$242millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G74

SkinCareProductsforMen

Table4G30:ManufacturersSalesofSkinCareProductsforMenintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,2011and2012

Brand

Company

NeutrogenaMen

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Johnson&Johnson

22

23

14.3

13.6

CliniqueSkinSuppliesforMen

EsteLauder

18

19

11.7

11.2

NiveaForMen

Beiersdorf

14

14

9.1

8.3

AnthonyLogisticsForMen

AnthonyBrands

10

11

6.5

6.5

JackBlack

JackBlack

10

11

6.5

6.5

LabSeriesSkincareForMen

EsteLauder

10

11

6.5

6.5

Kiehl's

LOral

4.5

4.1

TheArtOfShaving

Procter&Gamble

3.2

3.6

Vaseline

Unilever

3.2

3.6

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

3.2

3.0

ClarinsMen

Clarins

3.2

3.0

Zirh

TPRHoldings

3.2

3.0

LOralMensExpert

LOral

2.6

2.4

Origins

EsteLauder

2.6

2.4

LancmeMen

LOral

1.9

1.8

Gillette

Procter&Gamble

1.3

1.2

LaPrairie

Beiersdorf

0.6

0.6

24

32

15.6

18.9

154

169

100.0

100.0

Allotherr
Totalr

rRestated.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Manufacturers sales in the skin care products for mens category grow 9.7% to reach
$169millionin2012.
Growthisdrivenbythepositiveperformanceofmarketersinthecategory,especially
prestigebrands,suchasAnthonyLogisticsForMen,LabSeriesSkincareForMen,Jack
Black,andCliniqueSkinSuppliesforMen.
Prestige marketers, such as Este Lauder, Anthony Brands, and Jack Black introduce
new and innovative product offerings to reach out to the male consumers who are
increasinglybecomingconsciousoftheusageofproductstoimprovetheirappearance.
Established marketers including Este Lauder, Johnson & Johnson, Beiersdorf, and
Procter&Gamblehavestartedtopayincreasedemphasisondevelopingtheirmens
skincareproductlinesasthedemandformensskincareproductsrisesamongmenof
allagegroups.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

SkinCareProductsforMen

Mensfacialskincarerepresentsahugeopportunityformarketers.
Marketers have an opportunity to expand in the mens facial skin care segment with
relevant product offerings on antiaging, sun protection, and moisturizing; however,
the challenge involves getting them interested in these products, as men only use
productstargetingbasiccleaningandmoisturizing.
Since mens skin texture varies from that of women, marketers have to work to
educatemen,andurgethemtouseskincareproductsdesignedspecificallyformenin
ordertoachievepositiveresults.
Throughtheirwebsites,marketerseducatethemaleconsumeronthecorrectusageof
products.
Additionally, with the availability of a wide array of product offerings targeting
differentbodyareaswithuniquebenefits,marketersaretryingtoconveytothemale
consumersthattherearedifferentproductsforthebodyandface,andthetwoshould
notbeusedinterchangeably.

Thecategorybenefitsfromthestrongperformanceofprestigebrands.
Prestige marketers dominate the category, accounting for almost 50% of the total
categoryssalesin2012.
PrestigebrandsincludingLabSeriesSkincareForMen,JackBlack,CliniqueSkinSupplies
for Men, and Origins continue to innovate with the introduction of new products to
attractmaleconsumers.
Thehighperformingsegmentsintheskincareproductsformencategoryincludefacial
moisturizers,eyetreatments,andantiagingcreams.Prestigemarketersofferingsuch
productsincludeLabSeriesSkincareForMen,CliniquesSkinSuppliesforMen,Clarins
Men,andAnthonyLogisticsForMen.
Moreover, there has been an emergence of new prestige mens skin care marketers
which not only drive growth for the segment but also educate men on the way they
perceive grooming. In 2012, J. Paul Skin Care For Men enters the market with the
GuardFaceandBodyLotion.

In2012,massmarketerscontinuetopenetratetheskincareproductsformenscategory.
Themarketshareofthemassmarketersincreasesfrom39.6%in2011to40.2%in2012.
Johnson & Johnsons Neutrogena Men continues to be the leading brand in the
categorywiththesalesof$23millionin2012.
Vaseline grows 20.0% albeit from a small base of $5 million in 2011 to $6 million in
2012.
Mass brands recording constant sales in 2012 include Nivea For Men, L'Oral Men's
Expert, and Gillette. A few other smaller mass brands in the market include Dove
Men+Care,Menscience,Palmers,andGoldBond.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G75

4G76

SkinCareProductsforMen

Thereisagrowingshifttowardsthenaturallypositionedproducts.
Marketers are increasingly enriching their products with natural ingredients to gain
sales, get better acceptance among consumers, and as a means of differentiating
themselvesfromothermarketers.
In 2012, Ultra Balm introduces the Ultra Handy Man, a product that is enriched with
aloevera,lanolin,andvitaminAandE.
Jack Black launches the Dry Erase UltraCalming Face Cream with Hydromanil, ginger
root,andvitaminCandEin2012.
There is a growing awareness among many consumers of the possible harm from a
numberofcommonlyusedsyntheticingredients.
Asaresult,moreconsumersarebuyingproductsformulatedwithsubstantialamount
of natural ingredients that are free of parabens, formaldehydes, dyes, and added
fragrances.

Productsofferingantiagingandsuncarebenefitsaregainingpopularitywithmen.
Mensskincareproductsofferingantiagingpropertiesareincreasinglygainingdemand
inthemarketasmaleconsumersbecomeparticularoftheirlooksandwishtomaintain
theiryouthfulappearance.
AfewoftheantiagingvariantsavailableinthemarketincludeKiehlsFacialFuelAnti
WrinkleCream,NeutrogenasMensAgeFighterFaceMoisturizerwithsunscreenSPF
15,LabSeriesSkincareForMensAgeRescueEyeTherapy,JackBlacksProteinBooster
EyeRescue,andKiehlsFacialFuelTransformerAgeCorrectingMoistureGelforMen.
Furthermore,mensskincareproductswithsunprotectionalsogainpopularity.
Some of the variants available are Neutrogena Mens Triple Protect Face Lotion with
sunscreenSPF20,AnthonyLogisticsForMensMintandWhiteTeaAdvancedFormula
LipBalmSPF25,andJackBlacksDoubleDutyMoisturizerSPF20.

Progressively retailers are also taking initiatives to cater to the growing desire of men for
skincareproducts.
In 2012, Macys in Philadelphia opens a mens grooming zone on its beauty selling
floor. The area carries highend mens skin care brands, such as Jack Black, Shiseido
Men,andLabSeriesSkincareForMen.
Ulta and CVS already have similar spaces for men with Ulta offering male grooming
boutiquesinsideitsstoresandCVSofferingGuyAisleswithallmalefocusedproducts
displayedinasingleaisle.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A76

SkinCareProductsforMen

Setsandkitscontinuetogarnerattentionin2012,leadingtohighersalesformarketers.
Marketersareincreasinglyintroducingsetsandkits,whichincludesmallsizedproduct
offerings packed together, as a means of attracting men towards a single pack that
shalltakecareoftheirentireregime.
This is a strategy adopted by marketers to lure men who are new to using skin care
products and do not know how to navigate through choices of products available,
therebymakingtheessentialsofaskincareregimeavailabletotheminonepackage.
They have the added benefit of being offered at a lower price than when bought
individually.
Also, through these sets and kits, the consumer can judge the efficacy of these
productsontheirskinwithoutspendingmoreforlargebottles,onlytorealizelaterthat
theyarenotsatisfiedwiththeresults.
AnthonyLogisticsFor MenoffersaFaceKitcomprisingGlycolicFacialCleanser,Deep
PoreCleansingClay,AllPurposeFacialMoisturizer,andFacialScrub.
Lab Series Skincare For Men has a number of kits and sets in its line of products
including Skincare Simplified Kit, Blemishes/Breakouts Solutions Kit, Age Rescue Kit,
andMAXLSLuxurySolutionKit.

Notablenewproducts

Table4G31:SelectNewSkinCareProductsforMenIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

EsteLauder

CliniqueSkin
SuppliesforMen

DarkSpotCorrectorisapowerfulserumformensskinthathelpsreducethe
appearanceofdarkspots,acnescars,andsunspotsonallkindsofskintypesand
tones.Helpsreduceingrownhairandresultsstartbecomingvisibleinaslessas
fourweeks

EsteLauder

CliniqueSkin
SuppliesforMen

AntiFatigueCoolingEyeGelisarollongelthatgivesinstantresultswithrespect
torevitalizing,hydrating,andbrighteningtiredeyes.Itisalsoclaimedtoreduce
puffinessanddarkcirclesaroundtheeyes

EsteLauder

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

MAXLSDailyRenewingCleanserisaMoleculeAgeLessComplexthatcombines
withtheoxygenationactionthatwashesawayimpuritieswithoutaffectingthe
skinsnaturalPHbalance

EsteLauder

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

MAXLSSkinRechargingWaterLotionisaweightlesshydratinglotionthatis
formulatedwithMoleculeAgeLessComplexcomprisingAquatrontechnologyto
removeold,dead,anddullskinwithoutaffectingtheskinsnaturalPHbalance

EsteLauder

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

MAXLSLightMoistureLotion,formulatedwithSirtuintechnologyandMolecular
AgeLessComplex,isalightweightdailymoisturizingtreatmentthatpreventsand
repairssignsofaging

EsteLauder

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

InstantSkinBoosterisformulatedwithFirmaboostComplextotightenanduplift
theskinontheoutsideandstrengthentheskinsnaturalcollageninternally

EsteLauder

Origins

SaveTheMalesisamultibenefitoilfreelotionthatkeepstheskinhealthyand
hydrated.Itisenrichedwithnaturalingredients,suchascarrotprotein,Chinese
wolfberry,mangosteenextract,andwhitebirch

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G77

4G78

SkinCareProductsforMen

Table4G31:SelectNewSkinCareProductsforMenIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

JackBlack

JackBlack

DryEraseUltraCalmingFaceCreamisenrichedwithhydromanil,gingerroot,and
vitaminCandEintheformofanongreasycreamtoprovideinstantandlong
lastingmoisturizingfordryskin.Italsocalmsirritatedskinandhelpsreducethe
redness

JackBlack

JackBlack

TurboBodyBarScrubbingSoapisenrichedwithnaturalbluelotus,ginkgobiloba,
murumuru,sheabutter,andnaturallavarockwhichhelpscrubawayandexfoliate
thebodytogivesmoothandsuppleskin

JackBlack

JackBlack

CoolMoistureBodyLotionisalightweightandquickpenetratinglotioninfused
withsoyprotein,vitaminE,andjojobafornourishingandhydratingskin

JackBlack

JackBlack

IntenseTherapyLipBalmSPF25Mango&Mandarinisenrichedwithskin
conditionersandantioxidantstosoothedryandchappedlipswhileofferingbroad
spectrumSPF25protection

JackBlack

JackBlack

IntenseTherapyLipBalmSPF25SheaButter&VitaminEisenrichedwithskin
conditionersandantioxidantstosoothedryandchappedlipswhileofferingbroad
spectrumSPF25protection

J.PaulSkinCare
ForMen

J.Paul

GuardFace&BodyLotionisenrichedwithvitaminEandaloeveraandSPF20for
protectionagainstUVA/UVBsunrayswhileprovidingantiagingprotection

Johnson&
Johnson

NeutrogenaMen

SkinClearingAcneWashisanoilfreegentleformulawhichcleansesdeepporesto
minimizebreakoutsandingrownhairandpreventnewonesfromappearing

LimitedBrands

Bath&BodyWorks

ParisForMenBodyLotionisenrichedwithjojobaoil,sheabutter,andvitaminEto
defendtheskinagainstdrynessandkeepitlookinghealthyandsupple.Itsscentis
ablendofwhitewood,orangezest,andmusk

LimitedBrands

Bath&BodyWorks

ParisForMen2in1Hair&BodyWashsexclusiveformulagivesafastrinsingand
richlatherexperienceforanallovercleanexperience.Itsscentisablendofwhite
wood,orangezest,andmusk

LimitedBrands

Bath&BodyWorks

DarkAmberForMenBodyLotionisenrichedwithjojobaoil,sheabutter,and
vitaminEtodefendtheskinagainstdrynessandkeepitlookinghealthyand
supple.Itsscentisablendofbergamotandwarmamber

LimitedBrands

Bath&BodyWorks

DarkAmberForMen2in1HairandBodyWashsexclusiveformulagivesafast
rinsingandrichlatherexperienceforanallovercleanexperience.Itsscentisa
blendofbergamotandwarmamber

COMPETITION

Bybrand

Neutrogena Men (Johnson& Johnson) is the largest mens skin care brand with
manufacturerssalesat$23millionin2012,up4.5%from$22millionin2011.
The brands growth is mainly attributed to the sale from its facial treatments,
specificallyitsfacewashesandfacialtreatmentscontainingSPFbenefits.
Neutrogena Men competes in the category through four product lines including
NeutrogenaMen,RazorDefense,SensitiveSkin,andSkinClearing.
Thebrandsfurthergrowthin2012hasbeenoffsetbythelackofnewandinnovative
productactivity.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A78

SkinCareProductsforMen

EsteLaudersCliniqueSkinSuppliesforMenisthesecondlargestbrandinthecategory,
withsalesat$19millionin2012,anincreaseof5.6%from$18millionin2011.
Thebrandsmarketshareinthecategorydeclinesfrom11.7%in2011to11.2%in2012.
GrowthforthebrandissupportedbytheintroductionoftheAntiFatigueCoolingEye
GelandtheDarkSpotCorrectorin2012.
Furthersalesgainforthebrandisoffsetbythelimitedproductofferingsofthebrand
for younger consumers, who are an important market segment for the entire
categorysgrowth.

Nivea For Men (Beiersdorf) continues to be the thirdleading brand, with sales remaining
constantat$14millionin2012from2011levels.
The brand remains stagnant in 2012 as there is no new product activity or change in
formulationsforitsproducts.
Thebrandstraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)in2012areamere$1.9million.

Tied in the fourth place are three brands: Lab Series Skincare For Men, Anthony Logistics
ForMen,andJackBlack.
Allthreebrandsgrowapproximately10.0%from$10millionin2011to$11millionin
2012.
LabSeriesSkincareForMensgrowthisprimarilyduetoitsnewandinnovativeproduct
launchesincludingtheInstantSkinBooster,BBTintedMoisturizerbroadSpectrumSPF
35,MAXLSDailyRenewingCleanser,MAXLSLightMoistureLotion,andMAXLSSkin
RechargingWaterLotion.
SomeofLabSeriesSkincareForMensbestsellingproductsaretheMultiActionFace
Wash, MultiAction Face Wash Limited Edition, Daily Moisture Defense Lotion Broad
SpectrumSPF15,InvigoratingFaceScrub,AgeRescueFaceLotion,andOilControlFace
Wash.
Anthony Logistics For Mens bestsellers include Glycolic Facial Cleanser, Facial
MoisturizerSPF15,ContinuousMoistureEyeCream,andFacialScrub.
JackBlackperformswellin2012asitsproducts,althoughmalespecific,arebeingused
bywomenincreasinglyduetotheprovenefficaciousresults.
JackBlackcompetesintheskincareproductsformenscategoryundertheantiaging,
moisturizers,andcleanserssegments.
JackBlacksbestsellingproductsincludeIntenseTherapyLipBalmSPF25,PureClean
DailyFacialCleanser,AllOverWashforFace,Hair&Body,FaceBuffEnergizingScrub,
Cool Moisture Body Lotion, Industrial Strength Hand Healer, and DoubleDuty Face
MoisturizerSPF20.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G79

4G80

SkinCareProductsforMen

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Departmentstorescontinuetobetheleadingdistributionchannelintheskincareproducts
formencategoryaccountingfor49%ofthetotalsales,constantfrom2011levels.
Althoughmassmarketersdowellin2012,thepercentageshareofmassmerchandisers
remainsconstantat18%in2011and2012.
The number of men purchasing skin care products over the Internet increases.
However,itisnotsufficienttoraisethedirectchannelsshareinthecategory.
Theotherthreeretailsaleschannelsdrugstores,specialtystores,andfoodstores
donotexperienceasignificantchangeinthesharepercentagein2012.

Table4G32:ManufacturersSalesofSkinCareProductsforMen
intheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Departmentstores

49

49

Massmerchandisers

18

18

Drugstores

15

15

Specialtystores

12

12

Foodstores

Directsales

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The key aim of the brands in this category is to build greater engagement with the male
consumers.
Gymnasiums and lounges are popular places targeted by marketers to promote their
products.
Some male consumers are not comfortable shopping for grooming products. To
encourage purchase, marketers adopt the strategy of building menspecific areas for
theprivacyandcomfortofthemaleconsumers,wheretheycantryouttheproductsat
ease.
However,marketersalsotryandattracttheattentionofyoungmaleconsumerswho
are often more comfortable using mens products as compared to the older
generations.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A80

SkinCareProductsforMen

Instorepromotionisalsocommon,especiallyinpartnershipwithmasterbrands.
Instore events are organized by marketers, such as Anthony Logistics For Men, to
share information with male consumers about the products available, provide
educationonproductbenefits,andinducepurchase.
Sampling is also as an effective means to get men to try a product and encourage
buying.

Manymarketerstargetwomentopromotethepurchaseofskincareproductsformenasit
is the women who make purchases for most men. Women also have higher engagement
withhealthandbeautyproducts.
Marketers are tapping this line of approach by promoting male products cobranded
withtherelatedfemaleproducts,tocapturetheattentionofthefemaleconsumers.
Marketers such as Nivea and LOral with a presence in both the male and female
categories, often merchandise male products with the female products to encourage
purchasebyfemaleconsumers.

In 2012, Unilever promotes its Dove Men+Care line through the Journey to Comfort
campaign.
UndertheJourneytoComfortcampaign,thecompanyteamsupwithbasketballstars,
ShaquilleONeal,SteveNash,andMichiganStateUniversityHeadCoach,TomIzzo.The
campaign gives sports fans a glimpse into their professional and personal lives, by
sharing unique stories and events that changed their lives, lessons learnt from their
familyandcoaches,andstrugglesenduredtoachievetheirgoalsintheformofvideos.
DoveMen+CareFacebookpageinitiatestheShaqsBigExcuseFacebookapplication,
whichallowsfanstosendcustomizedmessagestoacquaintancesandfriends.
Dove Men+Care also collaborates with Viggle, an application, which allow fans who
checkintoNCAAbasketballgameswithinViggle,withachancetoearnextrapointsby
watchingtheJourneytoComfortvideos.

LOral promotes the Kiehls brand in the United States by providing complimentary
shippingandthreesamplesonordersabove$50.00.

Television advertising continues to account for a major part of the marketing spend
representing72.3%or$11.5millionofthetotalTMEinthecategoryin2012.
In order to encourage more men to indulge in skin care products, most marketers
collaboratewithsportspersonsandathletestopromotetheirbrandssincemenhavea
specialaffinitytowardssports.
Marketers opt for social media platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter to promote
deals and offers, however, most marketers find it risky to depend on social media
completelywhilesubsequentlycuttingbackontelevisionadvertising.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G81

4G82

SkinCareProductsforMen

In2012,TMEfortheskincareproductsformencategorytotalsapproximately$15.9million,
anincreaseof245.7%from$4.6millionin2011.
Marketersspend72.3%oftheTMEontelevisionadvertising.
Johnson&JohnsonhasthehighestTMEinthecategoryatapproximately$10millionin
2012.Johnson&JohnsonsentireTMEisallocatedtoitsLubridermbrandin2012.
Beiersdorf is the secondlargest marketer with a TME of $1.9 million in 2012. It
allocatesmajorityofitsTMEtotheExpressAbsorptionBodyMoisturizer.

DetailedinformationonTMEinthecategoryisprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthis
report.

OUTLOOK

Manufacturerssalesinthemensskincareproductscategoryareexpectedtogrowduring
the forecast period ending 2017. The category has strong potential for both value and
volumegrowthinthefuture.
Current developments in the form of growing demand for antiaging, natural and sun
careproductsaretestimonytothefactthatthecategoryhasstronggrowthpotential.
Theleadingmarketersofthebeautyindustry,Procter&Gamble,Unilever,EsteLauder,
Beiersdorf, LOral, and Johnson & Johnson have taken steps in the form of new and
innovativeproductlaunchesandincreasedmarketingsupporttoincreasetheirpresence
inthecategorybybringingawarenessamongconsumers.
Moreover, increased awareness about male grooming backed by aggressive TME
activities are likely to see an increase in the penetration rate of men using products
specific to men as they open up to the idea of going beyond the regular shaveand
cleanseregime.

Duringtheforecastperiodending2017,thereisanincreasedlikelihoodofmenofallage
groupspurchasingmensskincareproducts.
As marketers continue to innovate and spread awareness about mens skin care
products, the proportion of men buying these products is likely to increase gradually
with the male consumers feeling less awkward to go out and buy male specific
products, as opposed to the earlier practice of using products of their female family
members.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A82

SkinCareProductsforMen

WiththegrowingbabyboomerpopulationintheUnitedStates,theforecastperiodending
2017shallwitnessagrowingdemandforantiagingproducts.
Thereisastrongopportunityintheantiagingsegmentwithagrowingdemandfrom
menaged30yearsandolderforproductsofferingantiagingbenefits.
Similartowomen,menarealsoexpectedtoseekantiagingsolutionstohelpfightsigns
ofaginginordertolookasyoungandpresentableaswomenoftheirage.
The younger generation of men is also likely to use these antiaging benefits in the
anticipationthattheearlyuseoftheseproductsmightdelaytheagingprocedure.

Products for men offering cosmetic benefits, such as concealers and tinted moisturizers,
alreadyavailableinthemarketwillbeanotherareaformarketerstoattracttheattentionof
themaleconsumers.
These cosmetic beneficial products have recently entered the market, the success of
which is yet to be seen. There is a likelihood of a change in the landscape provided
theseproductsreceivesuccessfromconsumers.

The skin care products for men category provides marketers an opportunity to shift their
attentionfromthesaturatedfemalecentriccategories.
Marketershaveroomtoinnovatewithnewandinnovativeproductsandformulations
intheantiagingandSPFformulatedhandandbodylotionssegments.
Also, marketers have the opportunity to expand their products lines with naturally
formulatedproducts.
Also,thereisanopportunityforestablishedmarketerstoforayintothecategorywith
new brands and for new startup companies to enter the cosmetics and toiletries
industrywithproductofferingsintheskincareproductsformencategory.

Marketingwillplayapivotalroleinpromotingmarketersproductofferings.
The marketing expenditure is expected to increase over the next five years, with
marketers concentrating more on promoting the mens skin care brands than the
femalecentricbrands.
Television advertising will continue to be the key area of TME expenditure for
marketers followed by magazines, as visual marketing endorsed by celebrities has
proventobethemosteffectivemarketingmediaovertheyears.
Social media in the form of Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Pinterest, and digital
marketingthroughmobilemarketingwillbetheothermarketingmediumsadoptedby
marketersduringthecourseofthenextfiveyears.

Prestigemarketersareexpectedtocontinuetodominatethecategorythrough2017.
Althoughprestigemarketersshallcontinuetoholdmajorityofthemarketshareinthe
category, market share for mass marketers are expected to grow faster than the
prestigebrandsduringtheforecastperiod.
Themasssegmentinthecategoryislikelytowitnessnewentrantsintheformofnew
malespecific marketers and femalecentric marketers expanding their outreach to
introducemenspecificproductlines.
NeutrogenaMenisexpectedtobethelargestbrandinthecategorywithothermass
brandsenteringthetop10brandsintermsofsalesinthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G83

4G84

SkinCareProductsforMen

Sales of skin care products for men are forecast to advance at a CAGR of 5.4% to
$220millionin2017,upfrom$169millionin2012.

UnitvolumeisexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof5.2%from18.9millionpackagesin2012to
24.5millionpackagesby2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A84

SUNCAREPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturerssalesinthesuncareproductscategoryadvance6.5%in2012.
Categorysalesgrowfrom$984millionin2011to$1,048millionin2012.

Since 2007, manufacturers sales for the category have grown at a compound annual
growthrate(CAGR)of6.4%,from$769millionin2007to$1,048millionin2012.

Table4G33:HistoricalSalesofSunCareProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

769

2008

844

9.8

2009

860

1.9

2010

933

8.5

2011

984

5.5

2012

1,048

6.5

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unitsalesinthesuncareproductscategorygrow6.2%from230.6millionpackagesin2011
to244.8millionpackagesin2012.

Retailsales

Retail sales of the category are estimated at $1,545million in 2012, up 6.9% from
$1,446millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G86

SunCareProducts

Table4G34:ManufacturersSalesofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClassandBrand,2011and2012

Tradeclass/brand

Company

MASS

$Million
2011

2012

%Oftradeclass

2011

%Oftotal
2011

2012

BananaBoat

EnergizerHoldings

168

179

20.3

20.2

17.1

17.1

Coppertone

Merck

159

173

19.2

19.5

16.2

16.5

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

158

169

19.1

19.0

16.1

16.1

HawaiianTropic

EnergizerHoldings

49

51

5.9

5.7

5.0

4.9

LOralParis

LOral

24

28

2.9

3.2

2.4

2.7

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

20

20

2.4

2.3

2.0

1.9

CoppertoneWaterBabies

Merck

16

19

1.9

2.1

1.6

1.8

OceanPotion

Sun&SkinCareResearch

13

14

1.6

1.6

1.3

1.3

AustralianGold

AustralianGold

12

13

1.4

1.5

1.2

1.2

LOralParis

LaRochePosay

11

13

1.3

1.5

1.1

1.2

NoAdr

Sun&SkinCareResearch

10

11

1.2

1.2

1.0

1.0

Bullfrog

Sanofi

1.0

0.9

0.8

0.8

FruitoftheEarth

FruitoftheEarth

0.6

0.6

0.5

0.5

PanamaJack

PanamaJackProducts

0.4

0.5

0.3

0.4

BaindeSoleil

Merck

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Sea&Ski

RadiantTechnologies

0.1

0.1

0.1

0.1

Privatelabel

Privatelabel

117

122

14.1

13.7

11.9

11.6

53

57

6.4

6.4

5.4

5.4

828

888

100.0

100.0

84.1

84.7

Allotherr

Totalr

LUXURY

Clarins

Clarins

13

13

18.3

17.6

1.3

1.2

Clinique

EsteLauder

12

12

16.9

16.2

1.2

1.1

Lancme

LOral

12

12

16.9

16.2

1.2

1.1

Origins

EsteLauder

11.3

12.2

0.8

0.9

EsteLauder

EsteLauder

11.3

10.8

0.8

0.8

Shiseido

Shiseido

9.9

10.8

0.7

0.8

11

12

15.5

16.2

1.1

1.1

100.0

100.0

Allother

Total

71

74

7.2

7.1

DIRECT

29

28

55.8

53.8

2.9

2.7

11.5

11.5

0.6

0.6

17

18

32.7

34.6

1.7

1.7

52

52

100.0

100.0

5.3

5.0

LimitedBrands

18

18

54.5

52.9

1.8

1.7

Avon

Avon

MaryKay

MaryKay

Allother
Total
SPECIALTY
Bath&BodyWorks

Allother

15

16

45.5

47.1

1.5

1.5

Total

33

34

100.0

100.0

3.4

3.2

TOTAL

984

1,048

100.0

100.0

100.0

100.0

rrestated.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A86

2012

SunCareProducts

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Manufacturerssalesinthesuncareproductscategorygrow6.5%from$984millionin2011
to$1,048millionin2012.
Thecategorysgrowthisdrivenbyincreasingawarenessamongconsumersaboutthe
harmfuleffectsoftheskinsexposuretothesunsrays.
Other factors contributing to the categorys growth include new product activity,
packaging and labeling changes, innovative reformulations, and good performance of
privatelabelproducts.

Rising awareness among consumers about the harmful effects of the UV rays helps boost
thecategoryssalesin2012.
Consumersarebecomingincreasinglyawareandeducatedaboutthepotentialdangers
ofsunexposure.
SkincancerisanevergrowingconcernamongthepeopleintheUnitedStatessincethe
majorityofthepopulationcomprisesfairskinnedpeoplewhoaremoresusceptibleto
skin cancer than darkskinned people. Also, people living in geographies around the
equator,suchasCalifornia,Texas,andFloridaarepronetomoresundamagedueto
thedirectraysofthesun.
Organizations,suchastheSkinCancerFoundation,thePersonalCareProductsCouncil,
the American Association of Dermatologists, and manufacturers, such as Johnson &
Johnson, Energizer Holdings, and Merck play an instrumental role in educating
consumersaboutthehazardsoftheskinsoverexposuretothesunsrays.
In2012,theSkinCancerFoundationorganizedthethirdannualeventANighttheStars
ShineOninNewYorktofightagainstskincancer.Theproceedsfromtheeventbenefit
theTheSkinCancerFoundationsresearchandeducationinitiatives.
Marketers,suchasMerck,EnergizerHoldings,Johnson&Johnson,andSun&SkinCare
Research also undertake the help of the increasingly popular social media network
channels, such as Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube, to spread awareness among
consumers.
Sunscreen application remains one of the most important preventative measures
againstsunburn,photoaging,andskincancer.
Many consumers are not aware of the amount of product that is necessary to be
applied, and in most cases, are likely to underdose than overdose the amount of
product applied, thereby making their skin susceptible to sun exposure unknowingly
andincreasingtheriskpotentialofskincancer.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G87

4G88

SunCareProducts

Packagingisofutmostimportancetosuncareproductsmarketers,becauseofthevolatile
natureoftheproductformulations.
With the evolution of the sun care market, marketers are introducing complex
formulationsthatrequireinnovativepackagingsolutionsincludingairlesspacks,foams,
sprays,anddispensertubes.
Packaging suppliers also face challenges as there is a growing demand for high SPF
formulated products and the higher the SPF in a formulation, the more vicious the
formulaisandgreateristhechallengetodispenseiteffectively.
Sincesuncareproductsarechemicallyaggressive,itisverydifficulttomaintaintheir
packagingandkeepthempackagedforalongerdurationoftime
Marketers are mindful of the fact that packaging of sun care products should be
designed in a manner which allows for easy dispensing of thick formulations and is
convenienttoapply.
Moreover, people often pack sun care products for travel, and therefore marketers
needtomaketheseproductsavailableinleakproofformats.
Companies,suchasEnergizerHoldings,Merck,Sun&SkinCareResearch,andLOral
areincreasinglyshiftingtowardsusingairlessdispensersinordertoextendshelflifeof
theproductbyenhancingformulaprotectionfromexposuretoair.
These airless dispensers are available in allplastic packaging which implies easy
recyclability.Thesprayonapplicationiseasier,moreconvenient,andlessmessythan
thetubeapplicationasitismoreprecisewiththeapplication.
Although sprayon sun care products are popular, there are rising concerns among
consumers about the dangers associated with the inhaling of the nano particles that
are released when these products are sprayed. However, companies, such as The
HonestCompany,AubreyOrganics,BaboBotanicals,andCaliforniaBabyhavestarted
offeringnanofreesuncareproducts.
Furthermore,aerosolsunscreenshavethedangerofcatchingfire,asevidencedinthe
productrecalloftheContinuousSpraylinefromBananaBoatinOctober2012.InNorth
America,in2012,atleastfivepeoplecatchfireafterapplyingtheproductwhenneara
flameorsparks.
Anotherconcernwithsprayonsuncareproductsisthatconsumersdonotuseenough
ofittoprovideenoughprotectionagainstthesun.
Althoughstillanichesegment,thereisrisingtrendamongmarketerstointroducesun
careproductsinupsidedownbottleswhichareknowntoenhancedispensabilityasthe
can does not have to be positioned at a particular angle while spraying the product.
Also,theyareconsideredtobemoreecofriendlyalternativestotopclosurebottles.
CoppertonesnewSportProSeriespackagingincludesaspraycanwithabagonvalve
packagingtechnologywhichseparatesthepropellantfromtheproductwithaMoritz
twisttolockactuator.
Bag on valves feature a 360 degrees continuous spray that does not allow any
duplication of the traditional sunscreen dispensing methods while the twisttolock
actuatorspermitasecurelockingfeatureforsafeportabilityoftheproducts.
However, consumers wary of the health dangers associated with the spray
formulationsareoptingforfoambasedproducts.
Suncareproductsinstickformats,isanotherpackagingformatgainingprominence.It
ismainlyusedforbabies.
Marketersincreasinglyintroducesuncareproductsforchildrenwithbrightandcolorful
packagingthatisappealingandattractivetochildren.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A88

SunCareProducts

Each of Sunbows sun care products for children is designed with a different
Nickelodeoncharacteretchedonit.
Hawaiian Tropic presents its Silk Hydration Lotion Sunscreen, formulated with silk
ribbons,inclearbottlesforconsumerstoseethedualribbonformula.
As the industry shifts towards a more ecofriendly environment, there has been a
growingdemandforproductsfeaturingsugarcanebasedpolyethylenepackaging.
Inearly2012,Johnson&Johnsonintroducestheuseofsugarcanebasedpolyethylene
initspackagingwhichcontains60%bioplasticand40%recycledmaterialpackagingfor
itsSundownsuncareline.

ManystatesintheUnitedStatesareaimingtokeepteenagersawayfromindoortanning.
AsubstantialpopulationintheUnitedStatesmakesuseoftanningboothsinspiteof
warningsfrompublichealthagenciesabouttheirpotentialincausingskincancer.
AccordingtotheSkinCancerFoundation,researchshowsthatexposuretoUVradiation
fromartificialtanningmediumshasanincreasedeffectontheriskofmelanoma,the
mostdangerousformofskincancer.
California, Idaho, and Maryland in the United States have banned minors from using
indoortanning.
A proposal similar to the one above is being carefully considered in Arizona,
Connecticut, Florida, Iowa, Illinois, Michigan, Minnesota, North Carolina, New Jersey,
New York, Ohio, Oklahoma, Pennsylvania, Rhode Island, Washington, Vermont, and
WestVirginia.

Natural and organic products continue to gather momentum in the sun care products
category.
Increasing awareness about the inclusion of harmful chemicals contained in personal
care products makes many consumers opt for natural and organic products over
regularsuncareproducts.
Marketers,suchasJohnson&Johnsonareincreasinglyintroducingnaturalingredients
intheirproductschemicalformulationsinanattempttoenticeconsumerstopurchase.
Thereisagrowinginterestamongresearchanddevelopmentscientiststoresearchon
the ability of plants, algae, microorganisms, and coral that produce ingredients to
provideprotectionfromtheharmfuleffectsofthesun.
Therehavebeenprovenresultsfromscientistsacrosstheworldonnaturalingredients,
such as broccoli extracts, totara and manuka tree extracts, jojoba byproducts,
cordyceps fungus extracts, and turmeric to provide ultraviolet filters and protect the
skinfromsundamage.
In 2012, Energizer Holdings introduces the Banana Boat Natural Reflect Sunscreen
Lotion SPF 50+, Banana Boat Natural Reflect Kids Sunscreen Lotion SPF 50+, and
NaturalReflectbabySunscreenLotionSPF50+.
Yogurt is a key ingredient in Korres Sunscreen Face Cream Yoghurt. Yogurt contains
proteinsandlactosetokeeptheskincoolandsoft,helpsrelievesunburn,andincrease
themoisturelevelsintheskin.However,itisnotyetofferedintheUnitedStates.
Currently, there is no 100% natural sunscreen formulations that exists in the market,
and the closest approach to manufacturing a natural sunscreen is to use as many
naturalingredientsaspossible.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G89

4G90

SunCareProducts

Suncareproductsmaketheirwayontoshelvesmuchinadvanceofthesummerseason.
With growing awareness, sun care products have begun to make their way to the
shelvesofretailersasearlyasspring.
However,theplacementofthesuncareproductsvariesaccordingtotheseason,with
mostbeingplacedateyelevelbesidefacialtreatmentproductsduringthesummerand
onlowershelvesduringwinter.
Althoughsuncareproductsareavailablethroughouttheyearatretailers,newproduct
introductionsfromcompaniesisprimarilywitnessedduringspring.

Marketersintroduceproductswithspecificbenefitsfordifferentsectionsofthesociety.
With the new U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) rules and regulations on the
broad spectrum coverage, marketers are looking at ways of increasing their
competitivenessinthemarket.
Marketers,suchasMerckandEnergizerHoldings,introduceproductlinestargetinga
specific section of consumers, such as athletes, babies, children, and the aging
consumers.
In2012,Merckintroducestwoproductlines:theBananaBoatSportsProSeriesandthe
Banana Boat Wet n Clear line. The former line is specially designed for athletes who
undergo heavy sweating while the latter is a transparent, waterresistant, and
moisturizinglinethatbenefitschildren.

Marketersdiversifytheirproductofferingsasconsumersseekmultibeneficialproducts.
Manyconsumersbuymultifunctionalproductsthatinadditiontoprovidingprotection
against the sun provide benefits, such as skin lightening, antiaging, and make a
suitablebaseforcosmetics.
The BB creams, popular in 2012, are categorized as facial treatments, and many of
these are replacing womens sunscreens in daily usage. Moreover, consumers are on
thesearchforanSPFcreamforthefacethatislightweightandhasarefreshingfeeling
withoutleavingtheskinfeelingheavyorgreasy.
Marketers are also increasingly introducing primers with an SPF factor. Although
womenuseprimersandmakeuptocovertheirskinimperfections,thedailyexposure
tothesunandenvironmentalfactorscanfurtheraggravatetheproblem.
In 2012, LOral introduces the La Roche Posay Anthelios 50 AntiAging Primer with
Sunscreen.
Lipbalms,lipsticks,andlipglossescontaininganSPFfactor,isanotherpopulartrend,
asconsumersrealizetheimportanceofprotectingtheirlipsfromthedamagingsuns
rays.Theseproductsarecoveredintheirrespectivecategories.
In2012,afewlipbalmswithSPFformulationsareintroducedincludingAquaphorsLip
Repair+Protect,JackBlacksIntenseTherapyLipBalmSPF25,Chapfix,andSebamed
LipDefensewithSPF30.
Blurring of skin care products boundaries offset further growth in the sun care
productscategory.
Withtherisingdemandformultifunctionalproducts,marketershavebeguntolookto
sun protection as an advantage to be added to their multifunctional products
comprisingotherbenefitsaswell.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A90

SunCareProducts

These multifunctional skin care products include benefits, such as antiaging,


moisturizingandnourishing,skinwhitening,andsuncareprotection.However,theSPF
factor in these products is much more diluted than a core sunscreen product and
thereforealotmorequantityisrequiredtobeappliedontheskininordertoprevent
damage from the suns harmful rays. Also, consumers do not have a tendency of
reapplyingtheseproductsandtherefore,remainsusceptibletoskindamage.

The rapidly growing mens skin care market also makes provisions for sun care products
specificallydesignedformen.
The mens skin care market which continues to grow significantly during 2012 also
offerssuncareproductsspecificallydesignedforthecoarseandroughskinofmen.
AfewvariantsinthiscategoryincludeAnthonyLogisticsforMensOilFreeFacialLotion
SPF15,JackBlacksIntenseTherapyLipBalmSPF25,MaryKaysMoisturizerSunscreen
BroadSpectrumSPF25,CliniqueforMensAgeDefenseHydratorBroadSpectrumSPF
15, Lab Series BB Tinted Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 35, and Neutrogena For
MensTripleProtectFaceLotionwithSunscreenSPF20.

FDAsnewregulations,passedinmid2011,finallycomeintoeffect.
FDAsfinalregulationsforoverthecountersunscreenproductscomeintoeffectfrom
June18th,2012.However,toavertanyshortageoftheseproductsinthemarket,the
FDA extends the compliance dates for testing and labeling of these products to
December17th,2012forlargerbrands,andtoDecember2013forproductswithsales
oflessthan$25,000peryear.
According to the FDAs new regulations, companies manufacturing sun care products
willhavetopasstheUVAandUVBprotectiontestinordertoclaimBroadSpectrum
protectiononthelabel.
Previously, the rules for sun care products were only concerned with sunburn
preventionwhichismainlycausedbyUVBradiation,whichiswheretheSPFvaluation
isimportant.However,marketersdonottakeintoconsiderationUVAradiation,which
istheprimaryreasonforearlysignsofagingandskincancer.
Furthermore, under the law, marketers can only claim to reduce the signs of early
agingandtheriskofskincancerwithsuncareproductswithabroadspectrumSPF15
valueorhigherandwhenusedasperthedirectionsprovided.
Marketers sunscreen products with SPF values between 2 and 14 or not labeled as
broadspectrumarerequiredtowarnconsumerswithSkinCancer/SkinAgingAlert:
Spending time in the sun increases your risk to skin cancer and early skin aging. This
product has been shown only to help prevent sunburn, not skin cancer or early skin
agingastheyareonlyknowntoprovideprotectionagainstasunburn.
Companies can no longer make use of terms, such as, waterproof, sweat proof,
sunblock,andalldayprotection.InsteadtheFDAallowstheuseofwaterresistant
(40minutes)orwaterresistant(80minutes)dependingontheefficacyoftheproduct.
Manufacturerscannotclaimtheirsuncareproductstoprovideinstantprotectionon
applicationorprotectionformorethantwohourswithoutreapplication.
Itisrequiredofsunscreenproductstohaveadrugfactsinformationboxontheback
orthesideoftheproductpackaging,givingdetailedinformationabouttheproducts
ingredients.
TheFDAspropositionofcappingtheSPFvaluesonsunscreenproductstoSPF50isstill
aworkinprogresssincetherehasstillbeennoconclusiveevidenceabouttheefficacy
ofsuncareproductswithhighSPFvaluesincomparisontothosewithalowerSPF.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G91

4G92

SunCareProducts

Salesofprivatelabelproductsgrow,butatalowerratesince2007.
Rising awareness about the criticalimportanceof good sun protection contributes to
thestrengthofnationalbrands.
Product pricing continues to be the key factor for some consumers, thereby exerting
pressureonthesalesvalueofnationalbrands.
Privatelabel products offer high profit margins to retailers and, hence, are heavily
backedbyretailersthemselves.

Notablenewproducts

Table4G35:SelectNewSunCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Ahava

Ahava

AfterSunBodyLotionisafaceandbodybalmthatisenrichedwithAhavaspatentedOsmoter,
minerals,vitamins,andnaturalmoisturizers

AustralianGold

AustralianGold

SheerCoverageContinuousSprayisformulatedwithInvisiDrytechnologythatquicklygets
absorbedbytheskinwithoutgivingastickyfeelingandbroadspectrumsunscreenprotection
thatisavailableinasprayformat.ItisanoilfreeformulawiththeAustralianGoldsignature
fragranceandiswaterresistantforupto80minutes.ItisavailableinSPF15andSPF30variants.

AustralianGold

AustralianGold

SheerCoverageFacesSPF45isformulatedwithnonoilyInvisiDrytechnologythatprovidesthe
facewithbroadspectrumsunscreenprotection.Itisdermatologicallytestedandisinfusedwith
theAustralianGoldsignaturefragranceandiswaterresistantforupto80minutes

AustralianGold

AustralianGold

SPF45SheerCoverageFaceswithSelfTannerisformulatedwithnonoilyInvisiDrytechnology
thatprovidesanaturalgoldenglowwhileprovidingbroadspectrumsunscreenprotection.Itis
dermatologicallytestedandisinfusedwiththeAustralianGoldsignaturefragranceandiswater
resistantforupto80minutes

AustralianGold

AustralianGold

SoothingAloeGelisinfusedwithvitaminAandE,andgreentea.Italsocontainsthenative
AustralianAcaciaextractswhichprovideantioxidantbenefitsandisinfusedwiththeAustralian
Goldsignaturefragrance

BananaBoat

SportPerformanceCoolzoneUltraMistContinuousSpraySunscreenprovidesbroadspectrum
UVAandUVprotectionandwaterresistanceforupto80minutes.ItisrecommendedbyTheSkin
CancerFoundationandisavailableinSPF30andSPF50variants.ThisisoneContinuousSpray
productnotrecalledin2012.

Energizer
Holdings

BananaBoat

NaturalReflectSunscreenLotionSPF50+isformulatedwithnaturallysourcedmineralsuncreeen
activesandzincoxideforUVAandUVBprotection.Itisoxybenzoneandparabenfree,gentleon
sensitiveskin,dermatologisttested,hasbeenproveneffectiveagainstsunburn,waterresistant
upto80minutes,andisrecommendedbyTheSkinCancerFoundation.Comesinvariantsfor
adults,babies,andkids

Energizer
Holdings

HawaiianTropic

SilkHydrationClearMistSprayoffersbroadspectrumUVAandUVBprotectionaccompaniedby
12hoursofmoisturization.Itisformulatedwithskinnourishingantioxidants,andis
recommendedbytheSkinCancerFoundation.ItisavailableinSPF15andSPF30variants

Energizer
Holdings

HawaiianTropic

SilkHydrationLotionSunscreenprovidesUVAandUVBprotectionand12hourmoisturization.It
isformulatedwithhydratingsilkribbonsforacontinuousinsunmoisture,nourishing
antioxidants,exoticbotanicals,andatropicalfragrance;andisavailableinSPF12,SPF30,and
SPF50variants

Aveeno

Protect+HydrateLotionSunscreenwithBroadSpectrumisacombinationofEnviroguard
TechnologyandActiveNaturalsOattoprovideUVAandUVBsunprotectionItisoilfree,non
comedogenic,sweatandwaterresistantforupto80minutes,andisavailableinSPF30,SPF50,
andSPF70variants

LaRochePosay

AntheliosUltraLightSunscreenLotionSpraywithCellOxShieldusesacombinationofpatented
sunfiltersandpowerfulantioxidantstoprotecttheskinevenatthecellularlevel.Itcomeswitha
360degreespraythatallowsforcontrolledapplicationoftheproduct,andoffersUVAandUVB
protection,availableinSPF30andSPF60variants

Energizer
Holdings

Johnson&
Johnson

LOral

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A92

SunCareProducts

Table4G35:SelectNewSunCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

LOral

LaRochePosay

Anthelios50TintedMineralUltraLightSunscreenFluidwithCellOxShield,offersUVAandUVB
protection(PFA21andSPF50).Itisa100%mineralformula,hasauniversaltinttechnologyfor
allskintones,andisclinicallyproven,fragrancefree,parabenfree,andwaterresistantforupto
40minutes

LOral

LaRochePosay

Anthelios50AntiAgingPrimerwithSunscreenoffersUVAandUVBprotection,andisinfused
withpowerfulantioxidantsforcorrectionofagingandtopreventthedailyagingcausedbysun
exposure

LOral

LOralParis

SublimeSunAdvancedSunscreenSPF50+LiquidSilkSunshieldforFacehasanexclusivepatented
UVfiltersystemwithaluxurioussheerformula.Infusedwithantioxidants,suchasvitaminEand
whitegrape

LOral

LOralParis

SublimeSunAdvancedSunscreenLotionsexclusivepatentedUVfiltersystemprovidessun
protectionwithaluxurioussheerformula,infusedwithantioxidants,suchasvitaminEandwhite
grapeItisavailableinSPF30andSPF50+variants

LOral

LOralParis

SublimeSunAdvancedSunscreenCrystalClearMistsexclusivepatentedUVfiltersystem
providessunprotectionwithaluxurioussheerformula.Infusedwithantioxidants,suchasvitamin
Eandwhitegrape,itisavailableinSPF30andSPF50+variants

LOral

LOralParis

SublimeSunAdvancedSunscreenSPF30HydraLotionSpraysexclusivepatentedUVfiltersystem
providessunprotectionwithaluxurioussheerformula.Infusedwithantioxidants,suchasvitamin
Eandwhitegrape

LOral

Vichy

CapitalSoleilSPF30LuxuriousProtectiveOilprovidesUVAandUVBprotection.Itis100%
transparentandisenrichedwithNaturalWhiteGrapeseedOilandvitaminE

Merck

Coppertone

SportProSeriesContinuousSpraySunscreenisformulatedwithDuraFlextechnologythat
providesUVAandUVBprotectionandiswaterresistantfor80minutes.Itisappropriateforacne
proneskin,andisavailableinSPF15,SPF30,andSPF50variants

Merck

Coppertone

WetnClearContinuousSpraySPF30providesUVAandUVBprotectionandiswaterresistantfor
upto80minutes.ItisdermatologicallytestedandisavailableinSPF30andSPF45+variants

Merck

Coppertone

WetnClearKidsContinuousSpraySPF45+providesUVAandUVBprotectionandiswater
resistantforupto80minutes

PanamaJack

PanamaJack
Products

AcceleratorSprayGelFullSunwithInstantBronzerisaninstantbronzerwithnosunscreenand
comesinabottlethatspraysfromallangles

PanamaJack

PanamaJack
Products

SunscreenSprayGelwithInstantBronzerisenrichedwithaloeandvitaminEandcomesina
bottlethatspraysfromallangles.ItisavailableinSPF4andSPF8variants

PanamaJack

PanamaJack
Products

SunscreenSprayGelisenrichedwithmoisturizersandthespraybottleworksatanyangle.Itis
availableinSPF15,SPF30,andSPF50variants

Sanofi

BullFrog

MosquitoCoastSPF30ContinuousSprayprovidesa2in1protectionagainstthesunandinsects,
andlastsupto8hours

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

FloridaysMoisturizingSunscreenisenrichedwithaloehydratingcomplex300,olivesqualane,
andvitaminAandEforUVAandUVBprotection.Itiswaterresistantforupto80minutesandis
availableinSPF30andSPF50variants

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

FloridaysFaceisanultralightsunscreenthatisenrichedwithaloehydratingcomplex500,olive
squalane,andvitaminAandEforUVAandUVBprotection.ItcontainsH2Omelonskinaging
defenseandiswaterresistantforupto80minutes

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

FinsUpDryFeelSunscreenLotionwithWetSkinTechnologyiswaterresistantforupto80
minutes.Itisformulatedwithaloehydratingcomplex200andvitaminAandE,isfragrancefree,
andisavailableinSPF15andSPF30variants

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

FinsUpDrySunscreenSpraywithWetSkinTechnologyisasunscreenlotion,infusedwithaloe
hydratingcomplex200andvitaminAandE,fragrancefree,andisavailableinSPF15,SPF30,and
SPF50variants

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

ParakeetKidsHypoallergenicSunscreenForKidsSPF50isenrichedwithaloehydratingcomplex
200andvitaminAandE,andiswaterresistantforupto80minutes.Itisavailableinalotionand
sprayformat

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G93

4G94

SunCareProducts

Table4G35:SelectNewSunCareProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

LicenseToChillIntensiveMoisturizingRepairLotionisenrichedwithH2OMelonskinaging
defense,aloehydratingcomplex1000,olivesqualane,andvitaminsA,CandE

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

LicenseToChillCoolingAloeGelenrichedwithaloehydratingcomplex

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

DedicatedToSunshineTanningOilSPF6withaloehydratingcomplex2000isarichblendof
tropicalbotanicalsincludingborage,hemp,brazilnut,andavocado

Sun&SkinCare
Research

Margaritaville
ParrotHead

DedicatedToSunshineTanEnhancerSPF8or15isanoilfreesprayongelwithaloehydrating
complex400,arichblendofbotanicalextractsincludingcalendula,chamomile,comfrey,and
carrotandantioxidants.

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Sunblockscontinuetodominatethesuncareproductscategory.

Table4G36:ManufacturersSalesofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011and2012

$Million

Producttype

2011

Sunblocks(SPF15andover)r

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

594

648

60.4

61.8

9.1

Sunlesstanningproductsr

145

154

14.7

14.7

6.2

Sunscreens(SPF6toSPF14)r

114

118

11.6

11.3

3.5

Suntanningproducts(SPF5andunder)r

89

84

9.0

8.0

(5.6)

Aftersunandotherproductsr

42

44

4.3

4.2

4.8

984

1,048

100.0

100.0

6.5

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A94

2012

Totalr

rRestated.

SunCareProducts

Sunblocks(SPF15andover)

Sunblocksretaintheirdominanceinthesuncareproductscategoryin2012,withsalesat
$648million.
Manufacturerssalesadvance9.1%from$594millionin2011to$648millionin2012.
Newandinnovativeproductintroductionsandlineextensionsarethekeyreasonsfor
thehealthygrowthofthesegment.
In 2012, leading marketers, such as Energizer Holdings and Merck introduce new
technologicallyadvancedsunblockproductstotheiralreadyrobustproductofferings.
In2012,EnergizerHoldingsintroducestheHawaiianTropicSilkHydrationproductline
and Banana Boat Natural Reflect and Sport Performance Coolzone products while
MerckintroducestheCoppertoneSportsProSeriesandWetNClearrangeofproducts.
Consumers commonly believe that the higher the SPF value of a product, the more
protectiontheyprovideagainstthesun.However,theFDAhasproposedtolimit the
valueofSPFonsuncareproductstoSPF50,asthereisnosignificantdatatoprovethat
productswithSPFvaluesgreaterthan50offerbetterprotectionthanproductswithan
SPF50.
MarketersdemandhigherpricesforhigherSPFvaluedproducts.
Sunblocks have begun to gain preferential shelf space at retailers with most being
placedrightnexttofacialtreatmentproductsduringspringandsummer.
PrivatelabelproductsintroducehighSPFproductofferingsinanattempttocompete
with established national brands. However, the luxury brands are yet to explore the
segmentwiththeintroductionofhighSPFfactorproductofferings.
Since2007,salesofthesegmenthaveadvancedataCAGRof9.7%to$648million.

Table4G37:HistoricalManufacturersSalesofthe
SunblocksSegmentofSunCareProductsintheUnited
States,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

408

2008

460

12.7

2009

478

3.9

2010

533

11.5

2011

594

11.4

2012

648

9.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G95

4G96

SunCareProducts

Sunlesstanningproducts

Manufacturerssalesofthesunlesstanningproductssegmentgrow6.2%in2012.
Salesadvancetoreach$154millionin2012,up6.2%from$145millionin2011.
Thesegmentcontinuestogainsalesduetoconsumerschoosingmoresunlesstanning
productsoversuntanningproducts.
AfewvariantsinthesegmentincludeHawaiianTropicsT2MaxIndoorTanningLotion,
Coppertones Gradual Tan Moisturizing Lotion, Banana Boats Summer Color Self
TanningMist,NeutrogenasBuildaTanGradualSunlessLotion,andLOrealsSublime
BronzeSelfTanningGel.

Since2007,saleshaveadvancedataCAGRof5.7%toreach$154millionin2012.

Table4G38:HistoricalManufacturersSalesofthe
SunlesstanningProductsSegmentofSunCareProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

117

2008

131

12.0

2009

128

(2.3)

2010

140

9.4

2011

145

3.6

2012

154

6.2

rRestated.

Sunscreens(SPF6toSPF14)

Salesinthesunscreenssegmentadvance3.5%to$118millionin2012,from$114millionin
2011.
Althoughthesegmentpostsagrowthin2012,itcontinuestoloseshareinthesuncare
productscategory.
TheraceamongmarketerstointroducesuncareproductswithavaluehigherthanSPF
50,continues,therebyaffectingthesegmentsgrowthin2012.
A few variants in this segment include Hawaiian Tropics new Silk Hydration Lotion
Sunscreen SPF 12, Coppertones Continuous Spray SPF 10, and Panama Jacks
SunscreenOilSPF8.
A few leading brands, such as Banana Boat, Neutrogena, and LOral do not offer
productsinthissegment.

Since2007,saleshavegrownataCAGRof1.6%toreach$118millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A96

SunCareProducts

Table4G39:HistoricalManufacturersSalesoftheSunscreens
SegmentofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

109

2008

112

2.8

2009

112

2010

115

2.7

2011

114

(0.9)

2012

118

3.5

rRestated.

Suntanningproducts(SPF5andunder)

The suntanning products segment continues to decline in 2012 with sales sliding to $84
millionin2012,down5.6%from$89millionin2011.
Therehasbeenashiftinthepreferencesofconsumersfromsuntanningproductsto
sunlesstanningproducts.
Growing awareness among consumers about the hazardous effects of the suns
harmful rays on the skin results in the shift of consumers to indoor sunlesstanning
products.
Moreover, suntanning products require the skin to be exposed to the sun after
application which can lead to signs of aging, wrinkles, freckles, blisters, skin
discoloration,andinafewcases,couldevenleadtoskincancer.
Some variants in this segment include Panama Jacks Spray Gel with Bronzer SPF 4,
Coppertones Continuous Spray SPF 4 Sunscreen, Hawaiian Tropics Tanning Crme
LotionSPF2,andBananaBoatsDeepTanningDryOilSPF4ContinuousClearSpray.

SalesofsuntanningproductshavedeclinedataCAGRof2.8%to$84millionsince2007.

Table4G40:HistoricalManufacturersSalesoftheSuntanningProducts
SegmentofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

97

2008

101

4.1

2009

101

2010

101

2011

89

(11.9)

2012

84

(5.6)

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G97

4G98

SunCareProducts

Aftersunandotherproducts

Manufacturerssalesfortheaftersunsegmentpostagrowthof4.8%from$42millionin
2011to$44millionin2012.
Although the segment advances in 2012, it continues to lose share in the entire sun
careproductscategory.
Withgrowingawarenessabouttheharmfuleffectsofthesunsrays,manyconsumers
aremindfulofprotectingtheirskinandtherefore,takepreventivemeasuresnotonly
before going out in the sun but also with aftersun products, resulting in a growing
demandforsuchproducts.
AfewproductsavailableinthesegmentincludeHawaiianTropicsSilkHydrationAfter
Sun Lotion, Banana Boats Coolzone After Sun Aloe Gel with Lidocaine, and Panama
JacksGreenIceAloeGel.
However,leadingmarketers,suchasLOralandEsteLauderdonotfindapresencein
thisnichesegment.

Since2007,saleshaveadvancedataCAGRof3.0%to$44millionin2012.

Table4G41:HistoricalManufacturersSalesoftheAftersun
andtheOtherProductsSegmentofSunCareProductsinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

38

2008

40

5.3

2009

41

2.5

2010

44

7.3

2011

42

(4.5)

2012

44

4.8

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A98

SunCareProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4G42:ManufacturersSalesofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

EnergizerHoldings

217

230

Merck

176

Johnson&Johnson

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Changeinvalue,%

22.1

21.9

6.0

193

17.9

18.4

9.7

178

189

18.1

18.0

6.2

LOral

47

53

4.8

5.1

12.8

Sun&SkinCareResearchr

23

25

2.3

2.4

8.7

Privatelabelr

117

122

11.9

11.6

4.3

Allotherr

226

236

23.0

22.5

4.4

Totalr

rRestated.

984

1,048

100.0

100.0

6.5

EnergizerHoldingscontinuestobetheleadingmarketerinthesuncareproductscategory
in2012.
Manufacturerssalesofthemarketeradvancetoreach$230millionin2012,up6.0%
from$217millionin2011.
The marketers share in the entire category declines from 22.1% in 2011 to 21.9% in
2012.
EnergizerHoldingsmarksitspresenceinthecategorywithtwo ofitsbrands:Banana
BoatandHawaiianTropic.

BananaBoatdominatesthesuncareproductscategoryin2012,withsalesat$179million.
Manufacturers sales advance to $179million in 2012, up 6.5%, from $168million in
2011.
Thebrandmaintainsitsmarketshareinthecategory,accountingfor17.1%ofthetotal
categoryssalesin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
BananaBoatisalsotheleadingbrandinthemasstradeclass,accountingfor20.2%of
thetotaltradeclassshare.
Growth for the brand in 2012 is attributed to its new product introductions, brand
loyaltyfromconsumers,andincreasedemphasisonmarketingactivities.
The brands offerings include sunblocks, sunscreens, suntanning products, sunless
tanning, and aftersun and other products. However, its dominance is in the rapidly
growingandpopularsunblockssegment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G99

4G100

SunCareProducts

Most of the products introduced in 2012 contain high SPF formulations in order to
meetthegrowingdemand.
In 2012, Energizer Holdings introduces Banana Boat Sport Performance Coolzone
UltraMist Continuous Spray Sunscreen SPF 50, Banana Boat Sport Performance
Coolzone UltraMist Continuous Spray Sunscreen SPF 30, Banana Boat Coolzone After
Sun Aloe Gel with Lidocaine, Banana Boat Natural Reflect Sunscreen Lotion SPF 50+,
BananaBoatNaturalReflectKidsSunscreenLotionSPF50+,andBananaBoatNatural
ReflectBabySunscreenLotionSPF50+.
The popularity of sun care products for kids and babies induces the marketer to
introduceSKUsintheNaturalReflectlineforadults,kids,andbabiesalike.
BananaBoatoffersanarrayofproductsforkidsandbabiesinlotionandsprayformats.
AfewofthevariantsavailableincludetheKidsSPF110ContinuousClearSpray,Baby
TearFree SPF 50 Continuous Lotion Spray, Natural Reflect Kids Sunscreen Lotion SPF
50+, Baby SPF 100 Lotion, Kids SPF 50 Sunscreen Stick, and Kids SPF 50 Pump Lotion
FamilySize.
In October 2012, the brand voluntary withdraws 23 of its continuous spray products
whichareidentifiedtobeathreatduetothepotentialriskoftheproductsignitingon
theskin,whencomingincontactwithanignitingsourceiftheproducthasnotdried
offcompletely.
The products withdrawn include Ultra Mist Sport 15 Spray, Ultra Mist Sport SPF 30
Spray, Sport 30 Bonus Continuous Spray, Ultra Mist Ultra Defense SPF 30, Ultra Mist
UltraDefenseSPF30Bonus,FamilySizeSport30UltraMist,UltraMistSportSPF50,
UltraDefenseUltraMistSPF50,UltraDefense50BonusContinuousSpray,UltraMist
KidsSPF50Clear,Sport50BonusContinuousSpray,UltraMistSportPerformanceSPF
50+ Spray, Ultra Mist Ultra Defense 85 Spray, Ultra Mist Sport 85 Spray, Kids SPF 85
Spray,BonusUltraDefenseSPF85UltraMist,BonusSportSPF85UltraMist,SportSPF
30 Spray Twin Pack, Sport SPF 50 Spray Twin Pack, Sport 30 Ultra Mist 2 Pack with
Lotion&Lip,SportSPF30UltraMistwithSportLipBalm,Sport30UltraMist,andSport
SPF50UltraMist3Pack.
The company cites the reason behind the potential risk to be the product delivery
systemorthesizeofthevalve,whichdispensesmorethantheregularsuncarespray
and therefore takes longer to dry in comparison to other continuous sprays in the
market.
Manyofthebrandstanningoilsareenrichedwithnaturalingredients,suchascocoa
seed butter, banana fruit extract, carrot root extract, banana oil, grape seed oil, and
carrotandcoconutoil.TheDeepTanningSPF8Lotionwithgreenteaisenrichedwith
antioxidants.
A few of the brands aftersun and lip products are formulated with aloe vera and
vitaminEtoreplenishtheskinsmoistureandsoothesundamagedskin.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A100

SunCareProducts

4G101

HawaiianTropic,theotherbrandofEnergizerHoldingswithwhichitcompetesinthesun
careproductscategory,continuestobethefourthleadingmassbrandinthecategory,with
salesat$51millionin2012.
HawaiianTropicpostsa4.1%growthwithsalesadvancingfrom$49millionin2011to
$51millionin2012.
Hawaiian Tropics growth in 2012 is accredited to the marketers introduction of the
highlyanticipatedSilkHydrationrangeofproductsandincreasedmarketingexposure
withitsfirsteverproductlinelaunchattheMercedesBenzFashionWeek.In2012,the
companyreceivesaTMEof$6.1million,withmostor$5.9millionbeingallocatedto
promotetheSilkHydrationproductline.
The Silk Hydration line comprises six SKUs: Silk Hydration After Sun Lotion, Silk
Hydration Clear Mist Spray SPF 15, Silk Hydration Clear Mist Spray SPF 30, Silk
Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 12, Silk Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 30, and Silk
Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 50. The variants are enriched with hydrating silk
ribbons.

MerckdisplacesJohnson&Johnsontobecomethesecondleadingmarketerinthecategory
withsalesat$193millionin2012.
Thecompanyexperiencesahealthygrowthof9.7%from$176millionin2011.In2012,
Merckscategoryshareincreasesfrom17.9%in2011to18.4%in2012.
The companys growth in 2012 is due to the introduction of two new product lines:
SportsProSeriesdesignedforathletesandsportspersons,andWetnCleardesigned
forbabies.
TheCoppertoneWaterBabiesbranddoesexceptionallywellwithagrowthof18.8%to
postsalesat$19millionin2012,upfrom$16millionin2011.
As the awareness about the dangers of the UV rays among consumers increases,
parentsaretakingprecautionarymeasurestosafeguardtheirbabiesandkidsskin,as
aresultofwhichthekidsandbabiessegmentgarnersincreasedattention.
CoppertoneWaterBabies,apediatricianrecommendedbrand,offersproducts,suchas
QuickCoverLotionSpraySPF50Sunscreen,LotionSPF100+Sunscreen,FoamingLotion
SPF75+Sunscreen,andStickSPF55Sunscreen.

Johnson & Johnson slides down to become the thirdleading marketer in the sun care
productscategoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalestotal$189millionin2012,up6.2%from$178millionin2011.
Thecompanysshareslidebyamere0.1%from18.1%in2011to18.0%in2012.
Johnson & Johnson is represented by two major brands in the category: Neutrogena
andAveeno.
Neutrogenaisthethirdleadingbrandinthecategorywithsalesat$169millionin2012.
Thebrandshowsahealthygrowthof7.0%from$158millionin2011.
Thebrandsgrowthin2012ismainlyattributedtoitsexpandingdistributionnetwork,
good reputation in the market, and increasing marketing support from the parent
company,Johnson&Johnson.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G102

SunCareProducts

Thecompanyslatestproductline,theWetSkinlinecomprisingsixSKUs,launchedin
2011continuestodowellin2012.
The brand also offers an array of multifunctional products offering benefits, such as
antiaging, moisturizing, and makeup. A few such products include Age DefenseAnti
Oxidant Moisturizer SPF 20, Healthy Skin AntiWrinkle Cream with sunscreen SPF 15,
Healthy Defense Daily Moisturizer with sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 50Sensitive
Skin,andVisibleEvenDailyMoisturizerBroadSpectrumSPF30.
Neutrogena also offers sun care moisturizers designed specifically for men. These
include Neutrogena Mens Triple Protect Face Lotion with sunscreen SPF 20,
NeutrogenaMensSensitiveSkinOilFreeMoisturewithsunscreenBroadSpectrumSPF
30,andNeutrogenaMensAgeFighterfaceMoisturizerwithSunscreenSPF15.
Johnson&Johnsonsotherbrandinthecategory,Aveeno,recordsalesat$20millionin
2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Followingadeclinein2011,Aveenorecuperatesitssalesin2012withthelaunchofits
newProtect+Hydratelineofproducts.
TheProtect+HydrateproductlinecomprisesthreeSKUs:LotionSunscreenwithBroad
SpectrumSPF30,LotionSunscreenwithBroadSpectrumSPF50,andLotionSunscreen
withBroadSpectrumSPF70.

ManufacturerssalesofLOralgrowatanaggressiverateof12.8%to$53millionin2012,
upfrom$47millionin2011.
TheintroductionofLOralsSublimeSunisthekeyreasonbehindthestronggrowthof
thecompany.
The Sublime Sun product comprises six SKUs including Advanced Sunscreen SPF 50+
Liquid Silk Sunshield for Face, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 50+ Lotion, Advanced
Sunscreen SPF 30 Lotion, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 50+ Crystal Clear Mist, Advanced
Sunscreen SPF 30 Crystal Clear Mist, and Advanced Sunscreen SPF 30 Hydra Lotion
Spray.
The line is supported with a traceable media expenditure (TME) of $14.5 million in
2012.
In2012,LOralintroducesfournewSKUsforitsLaRochePosaybrand:Anthelios30
Ultra Light Sunscreen Lotion Spray, Anthelios 60 Ultra Light Sunscreen Lotion Spray,
Anthelios 50 Tinted Mineral Ultra Light Sunscreen Fluid, and Anthelios 50 AntiAging
PrimerwithSunscreen.
A new product, Capital Soleil SPF 30 Luxurious Protective Oil, is added to Vichy
Laboratoriesexistinglineofproductsin2012.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A102

SunCareProducts

Sun&SkinCareResearchsmanufacturerssalesadvance8.7%from$23millionin2011to
$25millionin2012.
The company is represented in the category by its No Ad, Ocean Potion, and
MargaritavilleParrotHeadbrands.
NoAdgrows10.0%to$11millionin2012,upfrom$10millionin2011.
ThemanufacturerssalesforOceanPotiongrow7.7%torecordsalesat$14millionin
2012,upfrom$13millionin2011.
In 2012, the company introduces its Margaritaville Parrot Head brand comprising 10
products:FloridaysMoisturizingSunscreen,FloridaysFace,FinsUpDryFeelSunscreen
Lotion, Fins Up Dry Sunscreen Spray, Parakeet Kids Hypoallergenic Sunscreen Lotions
ForKidsSPF50,ParakeetKidsHypoallergenicSunscreenSprayForKidsSPF50,License
ToChillIntensiveMoisturizingRepairLotion,LicenseToChillCoolingAloeGelenriched
withaloehydratingComplex,DedicatedToSunshineTanningOilSPF6,andDedicated
ToSunshineTanEnhancerSPF8.

PRIVATELABEL

Privatelabelsalesofsuncareproductshavepositivegrowthin2012.
Salesincrease4.3%from$117millionin2011to$122millionin2012.
Althoughthepopularityofprivatelabelwasdrivenbytherecession,itremainspopular
withsomeconsumerswhoarecontentwiththequalityandefficacyoftheseproducts.
There is still a section of the society who does not wish to splurge on these kinds of
products,thereby,optingforlessexpensiveprivatelabelproducts.
Moreover,overaperiodoftime,privatelabelproductshavebecomewidelyavailable
acrossmostmassdistributionchannels.Suchproductsoccupyprominentshelfspace,
right next to established brands, thereby making it easier for consumers to make a
comparisonwithrespecttoprices,packaging,formulations,andingredients.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Mass merchandisers retain the leading position as the preferred retail channel of
distribution.
Massmerchandisersconstitute42%oftotalretailsales,constantfrom2011levels.
Drugstoresremainalmoststableinsecondposition,accountingfor30%oftotalretail
sales.Thereisaslightdecreasenotshownbecauseofrounding.
Food stores continue to be in the thirdleading position with a contribution of 12%
towardsthetotalcategorysalesin2012.
Shareofthedirectsaleschannelsinthecategoryreducesslightlyin2012dueto the
decliningandstagnantsalesofdirectsalescompanies,suchasAvonandMaryKay.
Ontheotherhand,shareofdepartmentstorestowardsthecategoryssalesincreases
from5%in2011to6%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G103

4G104

SunCareProducts

Table4G43:ManufacturersSalesofSunCareProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

42

42

Drugstores

30

30

Foodstores

12

12

Departmentstores

Directsales

Specialtystores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

TMEforthesuncareproductscategorydeclines2.5%to$79.5millionin2012from$81.5
millionin2011.
Television advertisement is the most popular advertising medium of the category,
followedbymagazineadvertising.Collectively,theyrepresentalmost75%ofthetotal
suncareproductcategorysTMEin2012.
In 2012, expenditures on television and magazine advertisements account to $46.1
millionand$27.7million,respectively.

Marketers in the sun care products category organize events to create awareness about
theharmfuleffectsofprolongedexposuretotheUVraysontheskin,theintroductionof
newproducts,andextensionofexistingproductlinesamongconsumers.
Neutrogena teams up with actress Gabrielle Union to advise and advocate people to
makeskincancerpreventionapartoftheirdailyroutine.Skincancerisatypeofcancer
thatispreventableandNeutrogenaistryingtoeducateconsumersaboutthecommon
sunprotectionmyths,andspreadawarenessthatskincanceroccursirrespectiveofa
personscolor.
In 2012, Hawaiian Tropic sponsors the Mercedes Benz Fashion Week Swim 2013
Collectionsrunwaytopromoteitslatestrangeofsuncareproducts,theSilkHydration
line.
Following its annual tradition since 2008, The Skin Cancer Foundations Road To
Healthy Skin Tour which is presented by Aveeno and Rite Aid in conjunction makes
approximately85stopsacross27statesduringtheperiod,MarchthroughSeptember.
Aveeno uses this Tour to highlight its Be An Active Natural Fund which has been
established with the aim of inspiring people and organizations to realize the spirit
behindActiveNatural.Duringtheyear,Aveenoissaidtoaward$300,000ingrantsto
theSkinCancerFoundationandindividualswhoseeffortsbringaboutchangesinone
andtheworldaroundthem.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A104

SunCareProducts

LOral holds a press event in 2012 at its headquarters in New York to educate
consumersthatpeopleofcolorarenotimmunetomelanomaandotherskindiseases
assunexposurerisksaffectsalltypesofskincolors.
In2012,BananaBoatcollaborateswithChipGanassiRacingTeamsforthe2012IZOD
IndyCarSeriesracingseason.Accordingtothepartnership,twotimeIndianapolis500
winnerDarioFranchittidrivesaBananaBoatbrandthemedcarintheseasonopening
GrandPrixofSt.Petersburg.FranchittiadornstheBananaBoatbrandlogoonhisfire
suitthroughoutthe2012season.Thebrandalsohostsaneventtracksidewherebyfans
can come to the Banana Boat CoolZone Sunscreen Pit Stop and use new sunscreens,
playgames,andreceiveproductsasgiveaways.

Sponsorshipactivityhelpsdrivegrowthinthesuncarecategory.
Theprimarygoalofthesesponsorshipactivitiesincludepromotingnewproductsand
lineextensionsfromestablishedandstartupcompanies,educateconsumersaboutthe
attributesoftheproducts,andgatherretailplatformsforpromotionalactivities.
Marketersemploybroadertacticsofincludingthemeparks,NASCARteams,andother
activitieswhereconsumersspendaconsiderableamountoftimeinthesun.
Coppertone uses its partnership with Six Flags to promote the Sports Pro Series and
Wet N Clear product lines. The partnership provides the brand a platform and an
environmenttocommunicatetochildrenandadultstheimportanceofprotectingtheir
skinfromthesunsrayswhiletheyareoutdoors.

Sun care marketers continue to focus on social media activation efforts, to spread
awarenessaboutthebrandsandnewproductintroductions.
Socialnetworksites,suchasFacebookandTwitterareoftenutilizedtopublicizenew
productintroductions.
ActivebrandsonFacebookincludeBananaBoat,Coppertone,andNeutrogena.
In2012,CoppertoneholdsacontestonitsFacebookpagetofindthenextLittleMiss
Coppertoneinanefforttogivethebrandsadvertisingcampaignanewandmodern
lookbyrekindlinginterestinthelittlegirlandthedogaCoppertonesymbolsince1953.
ThecontestispromotedinanumberofwaysincludinganadvertisementinthePeople
magazine for the Coppertone Ultra Guard sunscreen spray that is portrayed with a
scratchandsnifffeaturewhichreleasesthetrademarkCoppertonescent.
HawaiianTropicactivatestheMercedesBenzFashionWeekSwimthrough,aFacebook
promotionthatallowsparticipantstowinatriptotheevent.
Banana Boat promotes the Chip Ganassi Racing with a branded Facebook tab that
offerstipsonmusicandoutdoorgearfromDarioFranchittiandJamieMcMurray.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G105

4G106

SunCareProducts

Suncaremarketerslookforretailpromotionalplatformsandonsitesalesrightstopromote
theirbrandsandproductlines.
CoppertoneactivatesSixFlagswithinstantredeemablecouponsthatofferconsumers
$40.00discountonpassesforparticipatingthemeparks.
Panama Jack acquires the sales rights on its partnerships with Hersheypark and
SeaWorldParks&Entertainment.

Afewleadingmarketers,suchasEnergizerHoldings,Merck,andJohnson&Johnson,adopt
marketing techniques, such as special offers including giveaways, sweepstakes, and
discountcoupons.
BananaBoats101DaysofSummerinitiativeisdesignedtogetfamiliesoutdoorsto
play. Each time a parent takes the Banana Boats Facebook pledge to play with their
kidsoutdoors,thecompanydonatesabottleofsunscreen(upto10,000bottles)tothe
Hole in the Wall Gang, a camp founded by Paul Newman for children coping with
cancerandseriousillnesses.
Most of the leading sun care brands offer discounts and coupons to promote their
brands.

Johnson&Johnsonremainstheleadingadvertiserinthesuncareproductscategoryin2012
inspiteofasteepdeclineinitsmediaspending.
The companys entire TME is estimated at $20.2 million in 2012, down 37.4% from
$32.1millionin2011.
Television and magazine advertisements are the preferred marketing mediums
adoptedbythecompany.
Johnson&Johnsonallocates56.4%ofthetotalTMEtotelevisionadvertisementsand
39.1%ofthetotalTMEonmagazineadvertisements.
The companys entire TME is allocated to its Neutrogena brand with the advertising
expendituredeclining20.0%fromapproximately$25millionin2012toapproximately
$20millionin2012..
Neutrogenas Ultra Sheer sun block receives most of the brands TME in 2012, at
$10.5million.

EnergizerHoldingsretainsitspositionasthesecondlargestadvertiserinthecategorywith
aTMEof$19.5millionin2012.
ThemarketerincreasesitsTMEby8.3%from$18millionin2011.
Thecompanyallocates$13.4milliontopromoteitsBananaBoatbrand.BananaBoat
Coolzonesprayreceivesthehighestadvertisingspend,at$6.7million.
Thecompanysotherbrand,HawaiianTropic,isallocatedaTMEof$6.1millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A106

SunCareProducts

4G107

MerckisthethirdlargestadvertiserinthecategorywithTMEof$17.6millionin2012.
Coppertone, the companys popular sun care brand receives the entire amount
allocatedasTME.
The marketer apportions $7.4 million to promote the Coppertone Wet n Clear Spray
and$6.4milliontopublicizeCoppertonesSportProSeries.

DetailsonTMEareprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

The sun care products category is expected to post strong growth during the forecast
period,2012to2017.
Consumersapprehensionsofdevelopingskincancerasaresultoftoomuchexposure
tothesunwillensureincreasingdemandforsuncareproducts.
The introduction of the FDAs longawaited sunscreen monograph, will stimulate the
categoryintheforecastperiod.
Growth of the sun care products category will be driven by new product activity,
improvedformulations,innovations,andanincreaseinthepricepointsoftheproducts.
Mediareportsandarticlespublishedbyagencies,suchastheSkinCareFoundationand
marketersaboutpropersuncarewillallowthecategorytoaddnewconsumerseach
year.

TheintroductionoftheFDAslongawaitedsunscreenmonographwillinducenewinterest
inthecategoryduringtheforecastperiodthrough2017.
Newregulationsonproductlabelingandformulationshavebeenforcedintoeffectin
December2012,andarelikelytoleadtoeffectivechangesduringthecomingyears.
TheFDAisexpectedtocomeupwithadecisionfortheproposedruleoflimitingthe
SPFto50,therebychangingthewayconsumersperceivehigherSPFproducts,andalso
altering the product offerings of marketers. This would require marketers to
reformulatesomeoftheirproductofferingstobringdowntheleveloftheirSPFclaims.
Itwouldalsocauseconfusioninthemarketplaceassomeconsumerswouldsearchin
vainforhigherSPFproducts,therebydelayingpurchases.
Theabovewouldeventuallyhelpincreaseconsumerconfidenceinpurchasingsuncare
products,afterthechangesarebetterunderstoodbyconsumers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G108

SunCareProducts

Naturalandorganicformulationswillcontinuetogainattentioninthecategory.
Organicproductshavealreadycreatedabuzzacrossallmajorproductcategories,and
thesuncareproductcategoryisnoexception.
Gradually,marketerswillintroducesuncarelinesformulatedwithnaturalingredients,
eliminatingsomeperceivedharmfulchemicalsfromtheirregularsuncareformulations.
These natural products will continue to command higher prices in comparison to the
regularchemicallyformulatedsuncareproductsandthereby,contributetotheoverall
categorysvaluegrowth.
Thesuncareproducts,however,cannotguaranteea100%naturalformulationasthe
complexity of the formulations makes it necessary for the manufacturers to include
syntheticchemicalingredients.
Future success of natural sun care products will depend on the ability of the
manufacturerstodevelopanddiscovervariednaturalandorganicingredientsforsun
careproducts.

Thesuntanningsegmentisexpectedtocontinueitsdeclineduringtheforecastperiod.
Thereisalwaysalargeconsumerbasefortanningproducts;however,consumersare
expectedtoshifttothesaferoptionofindoortanningorresorttotheuseofsunless
tanningproducts,withoutactuallyexposingonesskintothesun.
Sunlesstanning products and spraytanning products will continue to gain popularity
through2017.

Marketers are expected to continue to support their product lines with significant
promotionalandadvertisingsupport.
Marketerswillnotletgooftheopportunityofincreasingawarenesstowardskincancer
andskinprotection.
Efforts will be directed towards increasing awareness on skin cancer and skin
protectionandonfollowingaproperskincareregimen.
There will be an increase in the number of public health campaigns organized by
variousorganizationsandcompaniestoincreaseconsumerawarenessaboutsuncare
protectionandthevariousproductsavailableinthemarket.

Innovationswillallowthecategorytogarnergoodsalesduringtheforecastperiodending
2017.
Research and development will continue to play a key role for the category as
marketers will look to innovate with product formulations, establish patented
technologies,addmultifunctionalbenefits,andincreasethelevelofprotectionagainst
theUVraysforitsproducts.
Thedemandforsuncareproductsofferingantiaging,skinnourishing,brightening,and
whiteningbenefitswillcontinuetogrow.
MarketersareexpectedtointroducesuncareproductswithhighSPFwithappropriate
cosmeticpropertiesandtextures.Theseproductswillapparentlydemandhigherprices
fromconsumersallowingforthecategorysdollarsalestogrow.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A108

SunCareProducts

The category is expected to witness an increase in the prices of the products due to new
andimprovedproductformulationsinaccordancewiththenewFDAregulations.
Marketers are expected to demand higher prices for their sun care products due to
improved formulations, use of advanced technology, and availability in convenient
formats.
Thepricesoftherawmaterialsareexpectedtograduallyincreaseinthenextfiveyears.

The blur between the skin care and sun care products is expected to have a detrimental
effectonthesuncarecategorysgrowthduringtheforecastperiod.
SPFisbecomingthenorminalmostallskincareandmakeupformulations.
Thereisalikelihoodofshiftindemandfromcoresuncareproductstoskincareand
makeupproductsofferingaSPFadvantagewhichprovidemultiplebenefitsinasingle
product.
Additionally, the skin care and sun care products are expected to merge in the
followingyearsmakingitdifficultforbrandshavingapresenceinboththecategories
to balance their sales between the two categories of products without having a
negativeeffectontheother.
Suncaremarketersarefacedwiththerisingchallengeofconvincingconsumerstouse
coresunscreensratherthanproductsofferingmultibenefits,suchasfoundationsand
primersthathavenowbeguntoofferasunprotectionfactor.

Privatelabelproductswillcontinuetogrowthrough2017,butnotatthefastrateofrecent
years.
Inordertomatchuptothelevelsofthenationalbrands,privatelabelmarketerswill
continuetoinnovateandspendincreasedcapitalontheresearchanddevelopmentof
products.
Thereisapossibilityofprivatelabelproductstoalsointroducenaturalandorganicsun
careproductssoastogivestiffcompetitiontowellestablishednationalbrands.

Manufacturers sales of sun care products are forecast to grow at a CAGR of 7.1% from
$1,048millionin2012to$1,480millionin2017.
Thesunblocksegmentwillbethekeydriverfortheentirecategoryssalesgrowth.

UnitvolumeisprojectedtoadvanceataCAGRof6.4%to334.0millionpackagesin2017,up
from244.8millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4G109

4G110

SunCareProducts

Table4G44:ForecastManufacturersSalesofSunCareProductsintheUnitedStates,2012
to2017

$Million

Producttype

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Sunblocks(SPF15andover)

648

955

8.1

Sunlesstanningproducts

154

221

7.5

Sunscreens(SPF6toSPF14)

118

152

5.2

Suntanningproducts(SPF5andunder)

84

81

(0.7)

Aftersunandotherproducts

44

71

10.0

1,048

1,480

7.1

Total

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A110

4H.OTHERTOILETRIES

INTRODUCTION

Includedinthissectionarethefollowingproducts,whicharenotcategorizedinanyother
sectionofthisreport:
Deodorantsandantiperspirants
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Personalcleansingproducts
Shavingproducts

Thepersonalcleansingproductscategorycoversbarsoaps(bothcommodityandspecialty),
bathadditives,liquidsoaps,bodywashes,andantibacterialhandgels.
Thebathadditivessectioncoversbothchildrensandadultbathadditives.Infantbath
additivesarediscussedseparatelyinthebabycareproductscategory.
The shaving products category includes shaving gels, creams, and preshaves only,
excludingrazors.

MANUFACTURERSSALES

Manufacturerssalesoftheothertoiletriesproductclassareestimatedat$6,602millionin
2012,up3.0%from$6,412millionin2011.
Personal cleansing products continues to be the leading product category in the
productclass,withsalesat$4,026millionor61.0%oftotalproductclasssalesin2012.
Deodorants and antiperspirants follow as the secondlargest product category,
accountingfor30.9%oftotalproductclasssalesin2012.
Collectively, the top two product categories represent almost 92% of total product
classsalesin2012,downmarginallyfrom92.1%oftotalproductclasssalesin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H2

OtherToiletries
Figure4H1:ManufacturersSalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2012
Depilatories,
waxes,and
bleaches,2.5%

Personalcleansing
products,61.0%

Shavingproducts,
5.6%

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants,
30.9%
Total:$6,602 Million
NOTE:Totalsmaynotaddupduetorounding.

Historicalsales

Since 2007, sales in the other toiletries product class have grown at a compound annual
growthrate(CAGR)of2.5%toreach$6,602millionin2012.

Table4H1:HistoricalSalesofOtherToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

5,823

2008

5,948

2.1

2009

6,076

2.2

2010

6,217

2.3

2011

6,412

3.1

2012

6,602

3.0

Salesbytradeclass

Themasstradeclasscontinuestobethelargesttradeclassintheothertoiletriesproduct
classin2012.
Themasstradeclassrepresentsbulkofthetradeclasssalesat89.8%in2012.
Thespecialtytradeclassfollowsinthedistantsecondplacewith7.6%ofsalesin2012.
The direct trade class is the thirdleading trade class representing 1.8% share of the
salesin2012.
The luxury trade class accounts for 0.8% of the total product class sales, while the
professionaltradeclasshasnegligiblepresenceintheproductclasssalesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

4H3

OtherToiletries

Table4H2:Manufacturers'SalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyTradeClass,2012

$Million

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

Depilatories,waxes,
andbleaches

Personal
cleansing
products

Shaving
products

Total

%Of
total

2,029

163

3,396

340

5,928

89.8

493

11

504

7.6

Direct

11

102

118

1.8

Luxury

35

17

52

0.8

Professional

2,040

163

4,026

373

6,602

100.0

Tradeclass
Mass
Specialty

Total

RETAILSALES

Total retail sales of the other toiletries product class are estimated at a rounded
$9,469millionin2012,up3.0%fromarounded$9,191millionin2011.

COMPETITION

Table4H3:ManufacturersSalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyCategoryandCompany,2012

$Million

Company

Personalcleansing
products

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

Shaving
products

Depilatories,waxes,
andbleaches

Total

%Of
total

Unilever

1,134

755

1,892

28.7

Procter&Gamble

385

687

95

19

1,186

18.0

ColgatePalmolive

464

172

636

9.6

Henkel

430

135

565

8.6

LimitedBrands

409

409

6.2

EnergizerHoldings

166

166

2.5

Johnson&Johnson

115

16

131

2.0

66

45

111

1.7

BrynwoodPartners

88

94

1.4

Avon

81

11

92

1.4

920

208

93

99

1,320

20.0

4,026

2,040

373

163

6,602

100.0

Church&Dwight

Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H4

OtherToiletries

The top five marketers in the other toiletries product classUnilever, Procter& Gamble,
ColgatePalmolive, Henkel, and Limited Brandsrepresent over 71.0% share of the other
toiletriesproductsclasssalesin2012.
ThetoptwomarketersUnileverandProcter&Gambleregistersalesofmorethan
$1,000millioneachin2012,whileColgatePalmoliveandHenkelatthethirdandfourth
position,respectively,registersalesofmorethan$500millioneach.

Unilever continues to be the leading marketer in the other toiletries product class, with
salesat$1,892millionin2012.
Salesgrow4.6%from$1,809millionin2011.
Unilevers share in the other toiletries product class increases from 28.2% of total
product class sales in 2011, to 28.7% of total product class sales in 2012. The
marketersgrowthintheproductclassisduetoitsgoodperformanceinthepersonal
cleansingproductsanddeodorantsandantiperspirantscategories.
Unilever continues to be the largest marketer of personal cleansing products with
28.2% of the total categorys sales in 2012. Sales of the marketer grow 4.0% to
$1,134millionin2012,from$1,090millionin2011.
Unilevercontinuestodominatethebarsoapsandthebodywashessegmentsin2012,
withadistinctlead.
Bar soaps is the largest segment for the marketer, representing 52.2% of Unilevers
totalcategorysalesin2012.
Bodywashes,thesecondleadingsegmentforthemarketer,accountsfor47.4%ofthe
marketerssalesin2012.
Sales for the marketer are supported by a varied product portfolio, moderate new
product introductions, and a considerable Traceable Media Expenditure (TME) of
$85.2millionin2012.
Doveistheleadingbrandforthemarketerwithsalesup5.9%to$680millionin2012,
from$642millionin2011.
Dove continues to hold leadership positions in the bar soaps and body washes
segments.
DoveisallocatedaTMEof$64.5millionin2012.
Unilever also continues to be the leading marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirants category in 2012. The marketers sales total $755million in 2012, up
5.4%from$716millionin2011.
Thecompanysmarketshareinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryincreases
from35.8%in2011to37.0%in2012.
UnileverspresenceinthecategoryisthroughitsDegree,Dove,Axe,andSuavebrands.
Degree is the leading brand for Unilever and the secondleading brand in the
deodorantsandantiperspirantscategorywithsalesadvancing4.3%to$265millionin
2012,upfrom$254millionin2011.
The brand represents 35.1% share of the marketers sales in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategory.
The brand sustains its growth with its loyal consumer base and product offerings for
both,menandwomen.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

OtherToiletries

In 2012, sales of Degree are supported by the expansion of the womens Expert
Protection, Clinical Protection, and Nature Effects Invisible Solids product lines with
theLinenDry,CottonFresh,andAbsorbentSeaSaltsvariants,respectively.
In 2012, the marketer also revolutionizes its Degree Men Adrenaline Series with
motionsense technology. The technology is composed of motionactivated micro
capsules that provide extra protection to combat extra sweat and odor. The Degree
Men Adrenaline Series with motionsense technology comprises variants including
Adventure,Extreme,Everest,SportDefense,andV12.
In2012,UnilevertakesamajorstepbyintroducingtheAxeAnarchy,thefirstfragrance
in the brands history targeting both men and women. The body spray is allocated a
TME of $22.9million in 2012, the highest for the brand among any of its deodorants
andantiperspirantsin2012.TheAxeAnarchyForHerisalimitededitionproduct,with
the marketer waiting to see the response that the market has for the brands first
femaleorientedproduct.

Procter& Gamble remains the secondlargest marketer of other toiletries, with


$1,186millioninsalesduring2012,up2.1%from$1,162millionin2011.
Procter& Gambles share in the product class declines marginally from 18.1% of the
totalproductclasssalesin2011to18.0%oftotalproductclasssalesin2012.Procter&
Gambles growth in the other toiletries product class is mainly due to good
performance of the Olay brand in the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches and the
shaving products categories. However, the marketers share in the product class
declines marginally as a result of the stable sales in the large personal cleansing
product category and a marginal growth in the deodorants and antiperspirants
category.
Thedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryisthelargestcategoryforthemarketerin
theothertoiletriesproductclassin2012.Themarketerexperiencesamarginalgrowth
of0.7%toreach$687millionin2012,upfrom$682millionin2011.
Thecompanysshareinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryfallsfrom34.1%
in2011to33.7%in2012.
Procter & Gamble is present in the category with its Secret, Old Spice, and Gillette
brands.
Secret continues to be the leading brand for the marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategoryin2012.Manufacturerssalesofthebrandareupmarginally
by0.6%tototal$350millionin2012,upfrom$348millionin2011.Secretscategory
share declines marginally by 20 basis points to 17.2% in 2012, from 17.4% of total
categoryssalesin2011.
Procter&GamblesTMEsupportforSecretincreases4.5%from$39.9millionin2011
to $41.7million in 2012, with Secret Clinical Strength and Secret Outlast being
allocated the maximum TME at $18.8million and $22.5million, respectively. In 2012,
the marketer introduces the Secret Outlast in Invisible Solid, Clear Gel, and Smooth
Solid variants. To promote the Secret Outlast Collection, Procter & Gamble partners
withJenniPulos,atelevisionpersonalityandactress,tohelpconsumersconquertheir
hecticworkscheduleswhiletheproductprovidesthemwith48hourodorprotection.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H5

4H6

OtherToiletries

SalesofProcter&Gambleinthepersonalcleansingproductscategoryremainstableat
$385millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Bodywashesisthelargestsegmentforthemarketerinthepersonalcleansingproducts
category in 2012, and is the secondleading marketer in the body washes segment,
accounting for 18.5% of the segments sales in 2012. The marketers sales in the
segmenttotal$251millionin2012,up3.3%from$243millionin2011.
Procter&Gambleisthethirdlargestmarketerinthebarsoapssegment,representing
33.5% of the marketers sales in 2012, down from 35.1% in 2011. The decline in the
marketers share in the segment is due to the poor performance of Olay, Ivory, and
Safeguard.
The marketers decline in sales in the bar soaps segment is because TME declines
approximately 70.0% from $114.1million in 2011, to $40.0million in 2012. The
marketer experiences a considerable decline in sales for its Old Spice and Gillette
brands.
Procter&Gamblecontinuestobethesecondleadingmarketerintheshavingproducts
category in 2012. Manufacturers sales reach $95million in 2012, up 4.4% from
$91millionin2011.
Themarketshareforthecompanyintheshavingproductscategoryincreasesto25.5%
in2012,upfrom25.1%in2011duetotherapidlyexpandingTheArtofShavingbrand.
Procter&Gamblesleadingbrand,Gilletteexperiencesa2.4%growthfrom$82million
in2011to$84millionin2012.
In early 2012, the marketer introduces the Gillette Fusion ProGlide Clear Shave Gel.
Furthergrowthforthebrandisoffsetbyincreasingcompetitionfromotherbrandsin
themarketincludingSchick,Edge,andNiveaforMen.
Procter & Gambles Olay records an enormous growth at 375.0% in the depilatories,
waxes, and bleaches category in 2012. Manufacturers sales for the brand advance
from$4millionin2011to$19millionin2012.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfromamere2.8%in2011to11.7%in2012.
In 2012, the marketer introduces the Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo for
Medium to Coarse Hair after the success of the initial launch of the Smooth Finish
FacialHairRemovalDuoforFinetoMediumHairin2011.
SalesforOlaybenefitsfromastrongdistributionmodelanditsproductsareavailable
acrossallmajorretailmasschannelssuchasWalmart,Walgreens,andCVS/Pharmacy.
The brand has a higher price point than competing products because of the trusted
Olayname,whichalsocontributestothesteepdollarincreaseinsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

OtherToiletries

ColgatePalmolivecontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketerintheothertoiletriesproduct
classwithsalesat$636millionin2012,up2.3%from$622millionin2011.
The marketer represents 9.6% of total product class sales in 2012, down marginally
from9.7%oftotalproductclasssalesin2011.
Personal cleansing products is the largest category for the marketer in the other
toiletries product class in 2012. The marketer is the secondleading marketer in the
category,with11.5%ofthetotalpersonalcleansingproductscategoryssalesin2012,
flat from 2011 levels. Sales total $464million in 2012, up 3.6% from $448million in
2011.
ColgatePalmolive is the leading marketer in the liquid soaps segment and fourth
largestmarketerinthebodywashesandbarsoapssegmentsduring2012.
Theliquidsoapssegmentrepresents46.3%ofthetotalmarketerssalesinthepersonal
cleansing products category in 2012. Sales of the marketer in the segment increase
2.9%from$209millionin2011to$215millionin2012.
Growthofthemarketerisdrivenbynewproductintroductionsandgoodperformance
intheliquidsoapssegmentin2012.
The bar soaps segment of the marketer witnesses the highest growth in sales during
2012.Salesadvance8.5%to$127millionin2012,upfrom$117millionin2011.
Sales of the marketer in the body washes segment remain stable at $122million in
2012,flatfrom2011levels.
ColgatePalmoliveisthethirdleadingmarketerinthedeodorantsandantiperspirants
category in 2012. Manufacturers sales decline 1.1% to $172million in 2012, from
$174millionin2011.Themarketeraccountsfor8.4%oftotalcategoryssalesin2012,
downfrom8.7%in2011.Themarketersshareinthecategoryhasbeendecliningsince
2011.
ColgatePalmolive is represented in the category by Speed Stick, Lady Speed Stick,
TomsofMaine,andTeenSpirit.
Sales of Speed Stick, the flagship brand of the marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategorydecline1.0%from$97millionin2011to$96millionin2012.
The brands sales decline in spite of the launch of the new product line Speed Stick
Power in 2012. The product line contains four variants in the solid form and two
variantsinthegelform.Tolaunchtheproductline,themarketerinitiatestheHandle
It campaign on twitter, inviting consumers to share their uncomfortable, funny, and
embarrassingmomentstransformedintoaYouTubevideo,withtelevisionactorDanny
Pudiasthenarrator.DannyPudialsoprovidesconsumerswithsomeadviceonafewof
thecommonlyincurredHandleItmoments.
ThebrandssalesfurtherdeclineduetoalowTMEof$4.1millionin2012.Majorityof
the brands TME at $4.0million is allocated towards the advertisement of the newly
launchedSpeedStickPowerproductline.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H7

4H8

OtherToiletries

Henkelisthefourthleadingmarketerintheothertoiletriesmarketwithsales$565million
in2012,up1.4%from$557millionin2011.
Henkel accounts for 8.6% of total product class sales in 2012, down marginally from
8.7%ofthetotalproductclasssalesin2011.
Personal cleansing products is the largest category for Henkel in the other toiletries
productclassin2012.Henkelisthethirdleadingmarketerinthecategoryin2012.The
marketers sales advance 2.1% in 2012, from $421million in 2011 to $430million in
2012.
Henkel is the secondleading marketer in the bar soaps and liquid soaps segments,
thirdleadingmarketerinthebodywashessegment,andthefourthleadingmarketerin
theantibacterialhandgelssegment.
Bar soaps is the biggest segment for the marketer accounting for 45.1% of the
companys total sales in 2012, though sales in the segment decline 2.9% from
$198millionin2011to$194millionin2012.
Thelackofnewproductintroduction,packagingchange,orformulationchangehasa
negativeimpactonthesalesofthecompanyinthebarsoapssegment.
BodywashesisthesecondleadingsegmentforHenkel,up2.2%to$142millionin2012
from$139millionin2011.
In 2012, the marketer introduces the Dial Gold Antibacterial Round The Clock Odor
ProtectionDeodorizingBodyWashandtheHelloKittyMoisturizingBodyWash.
Intheliquidsoapssegment,salesofHenkeltotal$92millionin2012,up13.3%from
$81million in 2011. Growth of the brand in 2012 is attributed to the introduction of
newproducts,suchasNaturalTangerine&GuavaMoisturizingLiquidHandSoapand
HelloKittyAntibacterialFoamingHandWash.
In2012,DialisallocatedaTMEof$2.9millionwhileTonereceivesaTMEof$55,800.
In2012,HenkelsTonepartnerswithcountrysingerKerryPicklertopromotethenew
ToneFruitPeelBodyWash.
Deodorantsandantiperspirantsisthesecondlargestcategoryforthemarketerinthe
product class. Henkel is the fourthlargest marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirants category, with sales at $135million in 2012, a decline of 0.7% from
$136millionin2011.
Henkelscategorysharedeclinesfrom6.8%oftotalcategoryssalesin2011to6.6%in
2012.Henkelcompetesinthecategorywithlargemarketers,suchasProcter&Gamble,
Unilever,andColgatePalmolive,whoenjoyagoodTMEsupport,brandloyalty,anda
widerdistributionnetworkincomparisontoHenkel.
Henkel is represented in the deodorants and antiperspirants category with the Right
GuardandDryIdeabrands,whileitdivestsitsSoft&DribrandtoBrynwoodPartnersin
April2012.
RightGuardisHenkelsleadingbrandinthecategorywithsalesat$108millionin2012
flatfrom2011levels.NewproductactivityforRightGuardin2012includesthelaunch
of the Sport Triathlon Clear Gel Antiperspirant and Deodorant. The TME support for
RightGuardisamere$2.1millionin2012.ThisisaninsignificantTMEincomparisonto
theTMEofotherbrandsavailableinthemarketwhichencashuponthisopportunityto
promotetheirproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

OtherToiletries

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandisersaretheprimaryretailoutletintheothertoiletriesproductclasswitha
44.1%shareofsalesin2012.
Foodstoresfollowatadistantsecond,accountingfor25.6%oftotalproductclasssales,
followedbydrugstoresat14.8%ofthetotalproductclasssalesin2012.
Department stores are the smallest retail outlet in the other toiletries product class,
representing2.7%oftheproductclasssalesin2012.

Table4H4:SalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2012

%Ofmanufacturersdollars
Deodorants

Depilatories

Personal
cleansing

Shaving
products

Weighted
average

Massmerchandisers

47

42

43

41

44.1

Foodstores

24

10

27

26

25.6

Drugstores

20

46

10

25

14.8

Specialtystores

12

8.1

Directsales

5.4

Departmentstores

2.7

100

100

100

100

100.0

Retailoutlet

Total

OUTLOOK

Sales of the other toiletries product class is likely to grow moderately at a CAGR of 1.7%
duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Growthwillbedrivenbythemoderateperformanceofthematurepersonalcleansing
productscategoryandthegrowingdepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategory.
Marketers are expected to continue to create innovative marketing and promotional
strategiestokeepconsumersinterestedandengaged.Additionally,marketersarealso
goingtostepuptheiradvertisingexpendituresinthematurecategories.
Multifunctionalproductofferingscontainingbenefitsinadditiontothebasiccleansing
andmoisturizingfunctionswillcontinuetogainpopularitywiththemasses.
Marketers will continue to segregate their products to make them specific to gender
andagegroupsinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory.
In the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category, Olay is expected to expand its
presencebyventuringintothewaxesandbleachessegments.
Thewelltodomalepopulationisexpectedtotradeuptousingprestigeskincareand
shavingproducts.
There is a likely surge in mens skin care products offering cosmetic benefits such as
concealersandtintedmoisturizers
Malecentricshavingbrandsareexpectedtointroduceorexpandtheirexistingfemale

productlines.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H9

4H10

OtherToiletries

SalesofthepersonalcleansingproductscategoryareforecasttoadvanceataCAGRof1.9%
duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Theslowgrowthofthecategorywillbesupportedbytheintroductionofnewproducts
across the various segments. Marketers can look to innovate with their products by
offering benefits in addition to the regular cleansing. Added benefits to the personal
cleansing products could be in the form of moisturizing, exfoliating, antiaging, odor
protection,andtheadditionofvitamins.
Otherfactorscontributingtothegrowthofthecategoryinvolvepackaginganddesign
changes,changeinformulationsofexistingproductlines,andthemarketerseffortsto
increasinglyintroducenaturallyformulatedproducts.
Thecategoryisinamaturephaseandlimitedinnovationfrommarketerswilldampen
thegrowthofthecategoryduringtheforecastperiod.
Thebodywashessegmentisexpectedtomaintainitspositionasthelargestsegmentin
the personal cleansing products category. Body washes providing multipurpose
functions,suchasshampoosandfacewashes,willcontinuetogainpopularityamong
menduringthenextfiveyears.
Liquidsoapsareexpectedtocontinuetogrowatamoderaterateasconsumersprefer
the use of liquid soaps over bar soaps to wash hands. Additionally, many consumers
shift from the use of antibacterial hand gels towards liquid soaps with the option of
usingantibacterialhandgelsonlywhenonthegointheabsenceofwater.
Sales in the antibacterial hand gels segment are expected to stabilize in the forecast
period as there is still a certain section of consumers who are concerned about their
health and hygiene habits and will continue to use hand gels for protection.
Additionally, marketers are expected to make efforts to educate consumers about
maintainingpersonalhygieneandtheimportanceofusingantibacterialhandgels.

Salesforthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryareexpectedtogrowataslowpace
of1.2%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Clinicalstrengthproductswillcontinuetocontributetothecategorysvaluegrowth.
Marketers are expected to expand their product ranges with innovative products,
reformulating their existing line of products, and bring packaging changes to their
existinglineofproductsinordertokeepthecategoryalive.
However, further growth in the category is offset by a few factors, such as mature
phase of the category, limited scope for innovation, and a restricted growth in
population.
Additionally,thereislittlescopeformarketerstoexpandduetothehighpenetration
rateoftheirbrandsintheexistingretailchannels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

OtherToiletries

Theshavingproductscategoryisexpectedtoshowamoderategrowthof1.5%duringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Growth during the forecast period is most likely the direct result of changing habits
amongmentowardstheirpersonalgroomingastheybecomemoreconsciousoftheir
appearance.
Newandinnovativeproductlaunches,changingformulations,andimprovedpackaging
isexpectedtogarnerfurthergrowthinthecategorythrough2017.
Marketers will continue to undertake efforts to differentiate their brands from the
others available in the market by giving their brands a premium positioning in the
market,eventhosesoldinmasschannels.
Prestigemarketersareexpectedtogainmarketshareinthefuture.

Thedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoryisexpectedtowitnessmoderategrowthof
3.7%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Olayisexpectedtocontinuetogrowitssalesbyexpandingitslineofproducts.Further,
Olayisexpectedtoforayintoothersegments,suchaswaxesandbleachesduringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
The marketers ability to innovate with products and make them available in
convenienteasytousepackagingformatswilldrivesalesinthecategory.
Depilatory products formulated with natural ingredients will continue to gain
popularity,withmarketersincreasinglyintroducingsuchproducts.
However, inadequate marketing support from marketers for their new products and
theexistingproductportfolioisexpectedtorestrictfurthergrowthinthecategory.
Competitionfromalternatehairremovaltreatments,suchassalonservices,laserhair
removaltreatments,andathomehairremovaldeviceswillalsohinderthecategorys
growthduringtheforecastperiod.

ManufacturerssalesofothertoiletriesareprojectedtoadvanceataCAGRof1.7%toreach
$7,181millionby2017,upfrom$6,602millionin2012.

Table4H5:ForecastManufacturersSalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProduct
Category,2012to2017

$Million

Category

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Personalcleansingproducts

4,026

4,424

1.9

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2,040

2,160

1.2

Shavingproducts

373

402

1.5

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

163

195

3.7

6,602

7,181

1.7

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H11

4H12

OtherToiletries

UnitvolumeisexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof1.3%toreach3,015.4millionpackagesby
2017,upfrom2,825.7millionpackagesin2012.

Table4H6:ForecastUnitSalesofOtherToiletriesintheUnitedStatesbyProductCategory,2012to
2017

Millionpackages

Category

2012

Personalcleansingproducts

1,663

2017
1,797

CAGR,%
1.6

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

891.2

925.9

0.8

Shavingproducts

238.3

253.0

1.2

33.2

39.5

3.5

2,825.7

3,015.4

1.3

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturers sales of the deodorants and antiperspirants category grow 2.1% from
$1,999millionin2011to$2,040millionin2012.
Initsstateofmaturity,thecategorystrugglestopostgoodgrowth.

Sales for the category have grown at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 1.8% to
reach$2,040millionin2012.

Table4H7:HistoricalSalesofDeodorantsand
AntiperspirantsintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,869

2008

1,915

2.5

2009

1,911

(0.2)

2010

1,942

1.6

2011

1,999

2.9

2012

2,040

2.1

Unitsales

Unitsalesadvance1.5%to891.2millionpackagesin2012,upfrom877.7millionpackages
in2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesofthecategoryincrease2.1%to$2,836millionin2012,upfrom$2,779million
in2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H14

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Table4H8:ManufacturersSalesofDeodorantsandAntiperspirantsintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,
2011and2012

$Million

Brand

Company

2011

2012

Secret

Procter&Gamble

348

350

17.4

17.2

Degree

Unilever

254

265

12.7

13.0

OldSpice

Procter&Gamble

258

263

12.9

12.9

Dove

Unilever

183

209

9.2

10.2

Axe

Unilever

206

207

10.3

10.1

RightGuard

Henkel

108

108

5.4

5.3

SpeedStickr

ColgatePalmolive

97

96

4.9

4.7

Gillette

Procter&Gamble

76

74

3.8

3.6

Suave

Unilever

73

74

3.7

3.6

LadySpeedStick

SpeedStick

53

51

2.7

2.5

Ban

Kao

52

51

2.6

2.5

Arrid

Church&Dwight

45

43

2.3

2.1

LadyMitchumr

Revlon

35

33

1.8

1.6

Sure

InnovativeBrands

35

33

1.8

1.6

DryIdea

Henkel

28

27

1.4

1.3

Arm&Hammer

Church&Dwight

23

23

1.2

1.1

Tom'sofMaine

ColgatePalmolive

21

22

1.1

1.1

Mitchumr

Revlon

17

19

0.9

0.9

Brut

HelenofTroy

14

14

0.7

0.7

Avon

Avon

11

11

0.6

0.5

Soft&Dri

BrynwoodPartners

0.3

0.3

Adidas

Coty

0.2

0.2

TeenSpirit

ColgatePalmolive

0.2

0.1

Lady'sChoice

Church&Dwight

0.1

2011

2012

Privatelabel

0.1

0.1

Allotherr

47

51

2.4

2.5

1,999

2,040

100.0

100.0

Total

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

%Oftotal

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Growthinthematureddeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryisprimarilydrivenbynew
productintroductions,reformulations,andpackagingchanges.
Thecategorydoesnotwitnessanynewbreakinginnovationsin2012.
Marketers introduce products to its already existing line of products in the form of a
varietyoffragrances,therebyexpandingtheirproductlines.
Manyofthenewproductsaimtoprovideodorandwetnessprotectionforaminimum
of24hours.
In 2012, Henkel introduces the Right Guard Sport Triathlon Clear Gel Antiperspirant
and Deodorant which provides odor and wetness protection for 48 hours; Coty
introduces the Adidas Action 3 Control which provides 24hour antiodor and anti
whitening protection and is available in three variants: Fresh, Control, and Intensive
and; Unilevers Dove Clear Tone Skin Renew Deodorant which provides 24hour odor
and wetness protection with availability in three variants: Skin Renew Invisible Solid,
SheerTouchInvisibleSolid,andClinicalProtectionSkinRenew.
Few marketers reformulate their already existing product lines or introduce new
productslineswithimprovedtechnology.
In2012,UnileverreformulatesitsAdrenalineSeriesofdeodorantsandantiperspirants
withmotionSensetechnologywhichprovidesextraprotectiontofightbodyodorand
sweat.
In 2012, Procter & Gamble introduces the Secret Outlast Collection with Dual Action
Odor Technology and Coty introduces the Adidas Body Sprays with CoolTech
Technology.
However, the deodorants and antiperspirants market does not witness any new
innovationsintheformofproductdelivery,withmarketersstickingtotheoldformats
ofrollons,sticks,gels,softsolids,andaerosols.
Marketersareincreasinglyintroducingbodyspraysinthemistsprayformat.
CotysAdidasintroducestheDeodorantBodySprayinthreevariants:DeepEnergy,Ice
Dive,andPureGamein2012.Thesebodyspraysareavailablewithacapfreeactuator
whichallowsforconvenientapplicationoftheproductswithoutconsumershavingto
openthecapofthebodyspraytoapplytheproduct.
Marketersalsolookatupgradingtheproductpackagingofitsexistinglineofproducts
inanattempttoprovideanewandfreshlooktotheirproducts.
In2012,OldSpicechangesthepackagingforitsRedZoneandFreshCollectioninorder
tobringaboutmanufacturingefficiencies.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H15

4H16

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Clinicalstrengthproductscontinuetobeanotherdrivingfactorforthecategorysgrowthin
2012.
Clinical strength products demand higher prices in comparison to their conventional
counterparts due to the innovative technology involved in manufacturing these
products.
Clinical strength products are mainly bought by consumers experiencing heavy
sweatingorthosewhoareoutintheheatforlongdurationsoftime.
These products provide a simple and convenient solution to consumers to deal with
such embarrassing issues. It is estimated thatonly 2% of the population suffers from
hyperhidrosis, or extreme sweating, but one study found that many more people
believethattheysweatexcessively.Thisisthetargetmarketforsuchproducts.
Afewofthevariantsavailableinthemarketinclude:SecretClinicalStrengthPowder
Protection, Dove Clinical Protection Antiperspirant/Deodorant Rebalance, Degree
Clinical Strength Fresh Energy, and Suave Clinical Protection Prosolid Everlasting
Sunshine.
Other brands, such as Gillette, Degree, Arrid, and Sure also offer clinical strength
products.
In2012,UnileverintroducestheDegreeClinicalProtectionCottonFreshvariant.
These clinical strength products are formulated with active ingredients, such as
aluminumzirconiumcompounds,thathelpcontrolsweating.
However, there is still room for development with a number of brands, such as Ban,
Axe, and Right Guard still not offering clinical strength products in their range of
deodorantsandantiperspirants.

Marketerscontinuetosegregatetheirproductstomakethemspecifictogenderandage
groups.
Genderspecific product lines help marketers expand their offerings with different
fragrancestargetingdifferentgendersandprovidingconsumerswithawiderchoiceof
products.
ColgatePalmolive, Unilever, and Revlon offer separate deodorant and antiperspirant
productlinesformenandwomenwithSpeedStick,DoveMen+Care,andMitchumfor
men, respectively, and Lady Speed Stick, Dove, and Lady Mitchum for women,
respectively.
Marketers also provide different product offerings for adults and teens in order to
meettheirspecificrequirements.
Unilevers Axe is targeted towards the young male consumers while Colgate
PalmolivesTeenSpiritistargetedtowardsteenagegirls.
However, most marketers target the younger audience, who remain the primary
consumerswithinthecategory.
Since2010,OldSpicehasworkedtofreshenupitsbrandimageinthemarketwitha
changeinpackagingandthewayitmarketsitsproducts,inordertoappealtoawider
base of consumers. It especially targets the young male consumers thereby helping
driveupthebrandssales.
BrandssuchasAxe,Adidas,andTeenSpirittargettheyoungeraudience.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Therapidlygrowingmalegroomingmarkethasapositiveeffectonthecategoryssales.
Therehasbeenanincreaseinthedemandfordeodorantsandantiperspirantstargeted
towardsmen,asmenbecomemoreconsciousoftheirgroominghabits.
The malecentric deodorants and antiperspirants availablein the market includeAxe,
Adidas,DoveMen+Care,OldSpice,Mitchum,andSpeedStick.
In 2012, Unilever introduces the Axe Anarchy For Him, ColgatePalmolive introduces
theSpeedStickPowerrangeofproducts,and CotyintroducesthreeSKUseachtoits
AxeDeodorantBodySprays,andAction3ControlAntiperspirants.

Also, adding to the categorys growth is innovation in the form of marketing and
promotionalsupport.
Marketerscreateinnovativemarketingandpromotionalstrategiestokeepconsumers
interestedandengagedintheotherwisematurecategory.
Axeenjoysimmensepopularitywithyoungconsumersanddirectsitsmarketingefforts
totargetyoungadultmaleswhoareitscoreconsumers.Itsadvertisingcampaignshave
areputationofbeingmodern,irreverent,andrisqu.
Procter & Gambles Old Spice, a malecentric brand, is known for its popular viral
campaignswhichareahitwiththemassessincetheyinvolvetheconsumersbecoming
apartoftheinteractiveadvertising.

Thecategorycontinuestobedominatedbywellestablishednationalbrands.
Privatelabelhasaminisculepresenceinthecategory,representingamere0.1%ofthe
totalcategoryssalesin2012.
The limited presence of privatelabel products in the category is because most
consumersconsideritasanintegralpartoftheirpersonalhygieneregimenandprefer
wellestablishedbrandsoverprivatelabelproducts.
Moreover, private label finds it challenging to compete with established national
brandsduetolackofinnovativeproductofferingsandpaucityoffundstosupporttheir
lineofproductswithagoodmarketingstrategy.
Additionally, the cost of producing deodorants and antiperspirants is relatively
expensive and therefore the margin difference between privatelabel products and
brandedproductsislowercomparedtoothercategories.Thismakestheprivatelabel
categorylessattractiveforretailers.

M&Aactivity

Brynwood Partners subsidiary Golden Sun acquires Soft & Dri deodorant brand from
Henkel. Based in Santa Clarita, CA, Golden Sun is whollyowned by Brynwood Partners.
Termsandconditionsofthetransaction,whichclosesonApril1,2012,arenotdisclosed.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H17

4H18

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Notablenewproducts

Table4H9:SelectNewDeodorantsandAntiperspirantsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Arbonne
International

Arbonne

PureMintDeodorantisaluminumfree,andinfusedwithmintandextractsfromwhite
tea,ginger,lemongrass,sage,andteatreetofightbadodor

ColgatePalmolive

SpeedStick

SpeedStickPoweroffersbothantiperspirantanddeodorantbenefits,availableinfour
scents:Fresh,Unscented,UltimateSport,andenergySpurgeinsolidformatsandin
twoscentsinthegelformat:FreshandUltimateSport

ColgatePalmolive

Tomsof
Maine

MensLongLastingWideStickDeodorantcontainsaluminumandpropyleneglycol
freedeodorantstickscontainodorfightingbotanicalhopsandzincricinoleate
availablein100%naturalfragrances,areclinicallyproventoprovide24hourodor
protection.Itisavailableintwovariants:CleanConfidenceandMountainSpring

ColgatePalmolive

Tomsof
Maine

NaturallyDryAntiperspirantStickisclaimedtobemadeofnaturallyderived
ingredientsandclinicallyproventokeepfreshanddry.ItisavailableinNatural
PowderandUnscented/FragranceFreevariants

Coty

Adidas

DeodorantbodyspraysareinfusedwithCooltechtechnologyfor24hourfreshness.It
comeswithacapfreeactuator,developedforathletesandisavailableinthreescents:
DeepEnergy,IceDive,andPureGame

Coty

Adidas

Action3Controlisa24hourantiodorandantiwhiteningantiperspirantwithDryMax
Systemthathasbeenespeciallydesignedforathletes.Itisavailableinthreescents:
Fresh,Control,andIntensive(24hourplusprotection)

Creed

Creed

MillesimeImperialDeodorantisanalcoholandaluminiumfreedeodorantforallday
longprotection.Itretailsfor$65.00,over10timesmorethanthemassmarket
deodorants

FrenchTransit

Crystal

RockDeodorantStickpromisestonaturallyeliminateodorcausingbacteriawith100%
mineralsaltcomponentswithouttheuseofaluminums,parabensandchemicals

FrenchTransit

Crystal

RockDeodorantStickcombinesodorkillingnaturalmineralsaltswith100%natural
fragrancestoprovide24hourprotection

Henkel

RightGuard

SportTriathlonClearGelAntiperspirantandDeodorantprovides48hoursofodorand
wetnessprotection

Kao

Ban

SimplyCleanInvisibleSolidcontainsfloralandambernotesforalonglastingscent

Procter&Gamble

Secret

SecretOutlastwithDualActionOdorTechnologyprovidesfreshnessthatlastsupto48
hours.Italsominimizesodorcausingbacteriaandisavailableininvisiblesolid,clear
gel,andsmoothsolidformats

TCCDInternational

GeoDeo

NaturalDeodorantPlushelpsremovedailybuildupoftoxinsandimpuritieswith
DetoxComplex

Unilever

Axe

AnarchyForHimhasAxessignaturefragrancecomprisingfreshandfruitynotesand
notesofsandalwoodandamber

Unilever

Axe

AnarchyForHerisacombinationofappleandblackberrynotesatthetop,softflorals
attheheart,andabaseofsandalwood,amber,andvanilla

Unilever

Degree

ExpertProtectionLinenDrywithMotionsensetechnologyisinfusedwithafloral
greenscenttoprovidefreshness

Unilever

Degree

ClinicalProtectionCottonFreshwithMotionsensetechnologyisinfusedwiththe
fragranceofwhiterosepetalsandjasmineandoffersodorprotectionthroughoutthe
day

Unilever

Degree

NatureEffectsInvisibleSolidAbsorbentSeaSaltisablendofginger,mint,andteafor
longlastingprotection

Dove

ClearToneSkinRenewDeodorantprovides24hourodorandwetnessprotection,
helpsreducedarkmarks,provideanevenskintone,anddesignednottoleavewhite
marks.ItisavailableasSkinRenewInvisibleSolid,SheerTouchInvisibleSolid,and
ClinicalProtectionSkinRenew

Unilever

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Invisible solid sticks continue to be the largest product type in the segment in 2012 with
$943million in sales; a distant lead from the secondlargest product type, regular solid
sticks.
Salesforinvisiblesolidsticksareup3.2%from$914millionin2011.
Invisiblesolidsticksrepresent46.2%oftotalcategorysalesin2012,upfrom45.7%in
2011.
Growthinthesegmentisfueledbytheconsumersdesireforproductswith nowhite
residuebenefitsandtheintroductionofnewvariantsbyafewcompanies.
In2012,UnileverintroducestheDoveClearToneSkinRenewDeodorantinSkinRenew
InvisibleSolidandSheerTouchInvisibleSolidvariants.

Regularsolidstickisthedistantsecondleadingsegmentinthecategoryin2012.
Salesforregularsolidsticksgrow2.3%to$444millionin2012,upfrom$434millionin
2011.
They account for 21.8% of total category sales in 2012, marginally up from 21.7% in
2011.
Regularsolidstickscontinuetogainmarketshareduetotheirlowpricepointandthe
repeatpurchaseofsuchproductsbythepriceconsciousconsumers.
However,furthergrowthoftheproducttypeisoffsetbythemessyresidueleftbehind,
andtherapidrateatwhichtheseproductsfinish.

Salesofaerosolsandrollonsdeclineduetothedecreasingdemand.
Salesforaerosolsdecline1.5%whilesalesforrollonsdecline3.1%in2012.
Sales of aerosols are affected by the perception that aerosols are bad for the
environmentandtheconsumerspreferenceforstickdeodorants.

Table4H10:ManufacturersSalesofDeodorantsandAntiperspirantsintheUnitedStatesbyProduct
Type,2011and2012

Producttype

$Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Changeinvalue,%

Invisiblesolidstick

914

943

45.7

46.2

3.2

Regularsolidstick

434

444

21.7

21.8

2.3

Gels

208

210

10.4

10.3

1.0

Softsolidextrudable

203

208

10.2

10.2

2.5

Aerosol

134

132

6.7

6.5

(1.5)

Rollon

97

94

4.9

4.6

(3.1)

0.5

0.4

1,999

2,040

100.0

100.0

2.1

Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H19

4H20

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4H11:ManufacturersSalesofDeodorantsandAntiperspirantsintheUnitedStatesby
Company,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Company

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Unilever

716

755

35.8

37.0

5.4

Procter&Gamble

682

687

34.1

33.7

0.7

ColgatePalmolive

174

172

8.7

8.4

(1.1)

Henkel

136

135

6.8

6.6

(0.7)

Church&Dwight

69

66

3.5

3.2

(4.3)

Revlonr

52

52

2.6

2.5

Kao

52

51

2.6

2.5

(1.9)

118

122

5.9

6.0

3.4

1,999

2,040

100.0

100.0

2.1

Allother
Total

Unilever continues to be the leading marketer in the deodorants and antiperspirants


categoryin2012.
Themarketerssalestotal$755millionin2012,up5.4%from$716millionin2011.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfrom35.8%in2011to37.0%in2012.
UnileverspresenceinthecategoryisthroughitsDegree,Dove,Axe,andSuavebrands.
Degree is the leading brand for Unilever and the secondleading brand in the
deodorantsandantiperspirantscategorywithsalesadvancing4.3%to$265millionin
2012,upfrom$254millionin2011.
The brand represents 35.1% share of the marketers sales in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategory.
The brand sustains its growth with its loyal consumer base and product offerings for
bothmenandwomen.
In 2012, sales of the Degree brand are supported by the expansion of the womens
ExpertProtection,ClinicalProtection,andNatureEffectsInvisibleSolidsproductlines
withtheLinenDry,CottonFresh,andAbsorbentSeaSaltsvariants,respectively.
In 2012, the marketer also revolutionizes its Degree Men Adrenaline Series with
Motionsense technology. The technology is composed of motionactivated micro
capsules that provide extra protection to combat extra sweat and odor. The Degree
Men Adrenaline Series with Motionsense technology comprises variants including
Adventure,Extreme,Everest,SportDefence,andV12.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

DoveadvancestobecomethesecondlargestbrandforUnileverinthecategory.The
brandgrows14.2%toreach$209millionin2012,upfrom$183millionin2011.Dove
hasbeenpostinggoodgrowthsince2011.
Doveoffersdeodorantsandantiperspirantsforbothmenandwomen.
In2012,UnileverintroducestheDoveClearToneSkinRenew(forwomen)proclaiming
thatitsformula,enrichedwithcalendulaandsunflowerseedextracts,helpsaccelerate
the skins renewal process, provides 48hour odor and wetness protection, reduces
darkmarks,andprovidesanevenskintone.
Dovesgrowthin2012issupportedbygoodadvertisingexpenditureof$49.8millionin
2012. Doves new Clear Tone Skin Renew Deodorant is allocated traceable media
expenditures (TME) of $14.7 million while the Dove Go Sleeveless line of products is
allocatedaTMEof$15.9million.
DoveMen+Caresmarketingprimarilyrevolvesaroundsportspersonalitiesandsports.
DoveMen+CareisthetitlesponsoroftheDad2.0Summit.Thesummithasaseriesof
eventswherebyapanelofspeakerspresentanumberofissuespertainingtothelives
of men including the importance of fatherhood in their life. The brand offers male
consumersthechancetohavealivediscussionwithformerprofessionalfootballstar,
DougFlutiebyloggingontothebrandsFacebookpagein2012.
Dove Men+Care also organizes a number of contests, such as the Fan Bowl Photo
Challengewiththeluckyparticipantsgettinganopportunitytowinprizesthroughout
theNCAAFootballSeason.
Axe,thethirdlargestbrandforthecompanygrows0.5%from$206millionin2011to
$207millionin2012.
In2012,UnilevertakesamajorstepbyintroducingtheAxeAnarchy,thefirstfragrance
in the brands history targeting both men and women. The body spray is allocated a
TMEof$22.9millionin2012,thehighestforthebrandamonganyofitsdeodorants
andantiperspirantsin2012.TheAxeAnarchyForHerisalimitededitionproduct,with
the marketer waiting to see the response that the market has for the brands first
femaleorientedproduct.
Axe has been advertising its product benefits as giving men the edge in the mating
game.However,withthelaunchoftheAxeAnarchyproduct,themarketerseemsto
bechangingthebrandsimagewiththeAxeAnarchysadvertisementfeaturingaman
and a woman walking towards each other passionately while the world collapses
aroundthem,usingthetaglineUnleashthechaos.NewAxeAnarchyforhimandfor
her. This campaign now suggests that men and women are equally involved in the
courting process. The marketer launches a teaser campaign called Axe: Anarchy is
Comingwhichinvolvesagraphicnovelwithconsumerssuggestionsincorporatedand
somebeingdepictedinacomicroleplay.Thetelevisionadvertisementcampaignstarts
early2012withsupportfromdigitalandoutdooractivity.
Suave, Unilevers smallest brand, records sales at $74 million in 2012, up 1.4% from
$73million in 2011. The brand accounts for 9.8% of the marketers share in the
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H21

4H22

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Procter & Gamble is the secondleading marketer in the deodorants and antiperspirants
categoryin2012.
Themarketerexperiencesamarginalgrowthof0.7%toreach$687millionin2012,up
from$682millionin2011.
Thecompanysshareinthecategoryfallsfrom34.1%in2011to33.7%in2012.
Procter & Gamble is present in the category with its Secret, Old Spice, and Gillette
brands.
Secret continues to be the leading brand for the marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategoryin2012.Manufacturerssalesofthebrandareupmarginally
by0.6%tototal$350millionin2012,upfrom$348millionin2011.Secretscategory
share declines marginally by 20 basis points to 17.2% in 2012, from 17.4% of total
categorysalesin2011.
Procter&GamblesTMEsupportforSecretincreases4.5%from$39.9millionin2011
to $41.7 million in 2012, with Secret Clinical Strength and Secret Outlast being
allocatedthemaximumTMEat$18.8millionand$22.5million,respectively.In2012,
the marketer introduces the Secret Outlast in Invisible Solid, Clear Gel, and Smooth
Solid variants. To promote the Secret Outlast Collection, Procter & Gamble partners
withJenniPulos,atelevisionpersonalityandactresstohelpconsumersconquertheir
hecticworkscheduleswhiletheproductprovidesthemwith48hourodorprotection.
Old Spice, the marketers secondleading brand in the category posts sales at
$263million in 2012, up 1.9% from $258million in 2011. Old Spice, a malecentric
brand, has changed its approach which now involves reaching out to men of all age
groups, thereby helping improve its brand image as against its previous approach
which targeted only the older and mature men. The brand benefits from its loyal
consumerbaseasaresultofitslongpresenceinthecategory.
In2012,thebrandhasanotherviralhitwithitsMuscleMusicPlayervideofeaturing
formerNFLplayerTerryCrewswhocontrolsavarietyofinstrumentssimultaneouslyby
flexing his forearms, biceps, abs, deltoids, and quads. The advertisement acts as a
musicmaker game, involving interaction from consumers who have the ability to
controlCrewsbodyandinstruments.Oncethevideofinishes,theyhavetheoptionof
recordingit.ThebrandsvideoontheYouTubechannelisaninstanthitduringitsinitial
launchandcontinuestogainalotofhitsonYouTube.
Another marketing campaign of Old Spice features NFL star Greg Jennings promoting
theChampionDeodorantinaseriesofsevencommercialsthatgoliveduringtheNFL
2012season.
SalesforGillettedecline2.6%to$74millionin2012, downfrom$76millionin2011.
ThecategoryshareofGillettedeodorantsdeclines0.2%from3.8%in2011to3.6%in
2012. Gillettes sales decline are a result of the lack of newness from the brand with
respecttoproducts,changeinformulations,orpackagingchanges.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

ColgatePalmolive is the thirdleading marketer in the deodorants and antiperspirants


categoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalesdecline1.1%to$172millionin2012,downfrom$174millionin
2011.
Themarketeraccountsfor8.4%oftotalcategoryssales,downfrom8.7%in2011.The
marketersshareinthecategoryhasbeendecliningsince2011.
ColgatePalmolive is represented in the category by Speed Stick, Lady Speed Stick,
TomsofMaine,andTeenSpirit.
SalesofSpeedStick,theflagshipbrandofthemarketer,decline1.0%from$97million
in2011to$96millionin2012.Thebrandssalesdeclineinspiteofthelaunchofthe
newproductlineSpeedStickPowerin2012.Theproductlinecontainsfourvariantsin
the solid form and two variants in the gel form. To launch the product line, the
marketerinitiatestheHandleItcampaignontwitter,invitingconsumerstosharetheir
uncomfortable,funny,andembarrassingmomentstransformedintoaYouTubevideo,
withtelevisionactorDannyPudiasthenarrator.DannyPudialsoprovidesconsumers
withsomeadviceonafewofthecommonlyincurredHandleItmoments.
ThebrandssalesfurtherdeclineduetoalowTMEof$4.1millionin2012.Majorityof
the brands TME at $4.0 million is allocated towards the advertisement of the newly
launchedSpeedStickPowerproductline.
Lady Speed Stick is the secondlargest brand for the marketer with sales down 3.8%
from$53millionin2011to$51millionin2012.Salesforthebranddeclineduetothe
absence of new product activity, negligible TME, and an increasing competition from
otherfemaleorienteddeodorantsandantiperspirantsbrands.
In2012,LadySpeedStickistheofficialsponsoroftheWomensHalfMarathonheldat
St.Petersburg,FL.Theeventencourageshealthandfitnessamongwomen.
Toms of Maine, the thirdleading brand for ColgatePalmolive registers a growth of
4.8%toreach$22millionin2012,upfrom$21millionin2011.Thebrandaccountsfor
1.1%oftotalcategorysalesin2012,stagnantfrom2011.
TomsofMainesgrowthin2012isattributedtothebrandspositioninginthemarket
as a producer of aluminumfree deodorants since aluminum has been linked as a
reason for breast cancer. Additionally, the brands expansion into mainstream retail
outletsaddstoitssalesin2012.However,furthergrowthofthebrandisoffsetbythe
premiumpricingofthebrandsdeodorantsandantiperspirantsastheyareretailedfor
approximatelytwicethepriceoftheirregularcounterparts.
In 2012, the company introduces the Toms Of Maine Mens Long Lasting Wide Stick
DeodorantinCleanConfidenceandMountainSpringvariants,andtheTomsofMaine
NaturallyDryAntiperspirantStickintheNaturalPowderandUnscented/Fragrancefree
variants.
In 2012, the brand partners with TerraCycle, an organization that works towards
eliminating waste by providing solutions and systems to companies, to launch the
TomsofMaineNaturalCareBrigadewhichenablesconsumerstokeeppackagingfrom
TomsofMaineproductsoutoflandfills.Asacontinuationofits50StatesforGood
program,thebrandannouncesyetanother$150,000asapartoftheprojectfunding.
The winning projects, which have been voted for by the public, include initiatives
around reforestation, environmental dance programs, free dental care, and a
friendshipnetwork.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H23

4H24

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Henkelisthefourthlargestmarketerinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory,with
salesat$135millionin2012.
Salesdecline0.7%from$136millionin2011.
Henkelscategorysharedeclinesfrom6.8%oftotalcategorysalesin2011to6.6%of
total category sales in 2012. Henkel competes in the category with large marketers,
such as Procter & Gamble, Unilever, and ColgatePalmolive, who enjoy a good TME
support,brandloyalty,andawiderdistributionnetworkincomparisontoHenkel.
HenkelisrepresentedinthecategorywiththeRightGuardandDryIdeabrands,whileit
divestsitsSoft&DribrandtoBrynwoodPartnersinApril2012.
RightGuardisHenkelsleadingbrandinthecategorywithsalesat$108millionin2012
flatfrom2011levels.NewproductactivityforRightGuardin2012includesthelaunch
of the Sport Triathlon Clear Gel Antiperspirant and Deodorant. The TME support for
RightGuardisamere$2.1millionin2012.ThisisaninsignificantTMEincomparisonto
theTMEofotherbrandsavailableinthemarketwhoencashuponthisopportunityto
promotetheirproducts.

Privatelabel

Privatelabelwitha0.1%categoryshare,havenegligiblepresenceinthecategory.
Privatelabel products have experienced difficulties penetrating the category due to
their inability to offer consumers an array of product offerings, thereby failing to
competewiththewiderangeofproductsofferedbyestablishedmarketers.
Moreover, consumers prefer to use deodorants and antiperspirants of established
marketersfortheirpersonalhygieneneeds,therebymakingitdifficultforprivatelabel
productstomakeinroadsinthecategory.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Mass merchandisers continue to be the leading retail channel for deodorants and
antiperspirantsin2012,with47.0%oftotalcategoryssales,unchangedfrom2011levels.
Foodstoresloseoutonthepercentagesharein2012withadeclineof100basispoints
tocontribute24.0%ofthetotalcategoryssales
Drug stores sustain their share at 20.0% of the categorys sales in 2012. The retail
channelusesmethods,suchasspecialdiscountsandoffers,inhousetelevisionspots,
advertising, and instore promotions to assist in sales increase of deodorants and
antiperspirantsintheiroutlets.
Thepercentageshareofdirectsalesimprovesto3.0%in2012,upfrom2.0%in2011
on account of the popularity of ecommerce sites and the company websites for the
purchaseofdeodorantsandantiperspirants.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Table4H12:ManufacturersSalesofDeodorantsandAntiperspirantsin
theUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

47

47

Foodstores

25

24

Drugstores

20

20

Departmentstores

Directsales

Specialtystores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Deodorantsandantiperspirantsareprimarilymarketedthroughthreechannels.
Televisionandmagazineadvertisementscontinuetobethepreferredmarketingmedia
amongstmarketers.Duetothecompetitivenatureofthemarketandthedominance
ofmassbrandsinthecategory,mostmarketersadopttraditionaladvertisingforawide
outreach. A few of the preferred magazines include Allure, Vogue, Glamour, In Style,
CosmoGirl,MensFitness,andMensHealth.
The second mostpreferred promotional channel includes promotions, samples, price
discount,coupons,andfreestandinginserts(FSIs).
Thethirdandthenewestchannelgainingpopularityistheuseofsocialmediaonthe
Internet, comprising sites, such as Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Pinterest for
marketerstopromotetheirproducts.

The category is dominated by a few large marketers who rely on discount coupons and
promotionalofferstomarkettheirproducts.
Discountcouponscontinuetobeanimportantpromotionaltoolutilizedbymarketers
tomaintaintheirsales.
Marketersusecouponstosupportnewproductintroductionsandpromotebrandsales.
These coupons, available in various denominations depending on the brand, are
offeredthroughmagazines,FSIs,theInternet,andretailstores.
Consumersutilizediscountcouponstogainpricereductionsonnewproductsandfora
chancetotrynewproductsanddifferentiatethemwiththeexistingones.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H25

4H26

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

Table4H13:SelectCouponingActivitiesofDeodorantsandAntiperspirants,2012
Company/division

Brand

Promotion

Henkel

RightGuard

Thecouponisfor$3.00offonanytwoTotalDefense5
antiperspirantordeodorant

Procter&Gamble

OldSpice

Freeshipping,15%offonOldSpicedeodorantproducts,anda
couponworth$2.00

Unilever

Axe

$1.00offonanyAxedeodorantorantiperspirant

Unilever

Degree

$2.00offonanyoneDegreeclinicalproductand$0.75offon
anyoneDegreeproduct

Unilever

Suave

$0.50offonanySuavedeodorant

Onlinepromotionscontinuetogainprominenceasmarketersincreasinglyadoptthesetools
topromotetheirproducts.
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTube,remainthemostsoughtaftersocialmediachannels
utilizedbymarketersduetotheirpopularitywithconsumers.
Advertisements of brands, such as Axe, Old Spice, and Gillette, are present across
variouschannels,includingseveralsocialmedianetworkingsites,suchasFacebookand
Twitter,andonlinestreamingmediasites,suchasYouTube.
Brands also use their websites as good promotional tools by offering consumers fun
and interactive activities, such as multimedia games, applications, new product
information,andvideosharing.
Brandloyal consumers wanting to know about the latest offers and new product
activityfromthebrandalsohavetheoptionofsigningupforthebrandsnewsletter.

Malecentricbrandscontinuetoassociatethemselveswithpopularsportspersonalitiesand
sports.
Unilevers Degree Women deodorant teams up with Erin Andrews, a sports
broadcaster,tocelebrate"UnapologeticallyStrong"womenwhoarenotafraidtotest
their limits and are willing to push boundaries. Erin Andrews shares her personal
challenges and victory stories on Facebook and helps encourage others to face
challenges.Thecompanyalsoprovideswomenanopportunitytowin$5,000byvisiting
theDegreeFacebookpage.
Procter&GamblesGillettelaunchesMyCityisMyGymcampaignthaturgesmento
puttotesttheirGillettesOdorShieldantiperspirant/deodorantbytakingtheirexercise
regime outdoors. The company partners with three professional athletes hockey
playerPatrickSharp;formerfootballstarDhaniJones;andfootballlegendJerryRice
topromoteitsGillettebrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

TMEofthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategorytotals$224.1millionin2012,up2.1%
from$219.5millionin2011.
Unilever continues to be the leading advertiser in the category with TME of
$134.6millionin2012,up11.4%from$120.8millionin2011.
Procter&GamblesTMEdeclines20.5%in2012to$69.9million,from$88.0millionin
2012.

Unilevers Degree brand is the most advertised brand within the marketers portfolio of
deodorantsandantiperspirantsin2012.
Degreereceivesadvertisingsupportof$56.9millionin2012.
Dovereceivesthesecondhighestadvertisingexpenditureat$49.8millionin2012.The
combinedTMEofDoveGoSleevelessandDoveClearTonetotals$30.7million.
Unilever further reduces the advertising expenses of its Axe brand in 2012 to
$27.9million,adeclineof1.1%from$28.2millionin2011.
Withanallocationof72.1%ofthetotalTME,televisionadvertisementsarethemost
importantmeansofadvertisingadoptedbythemarketer.

Procter& Gamble continues to be the secondleading advertiser in the deodorants and


antiperspirantscategoryin2012.
ThemarketersTMEin2012amountsto$69.9million,down20.5%from$88.0million
in2011.
Secret,themarketersleadingbrand,receivesaTMEsupportof$41.7millionin2012.
Thisisanincreaseof4.5%from$39.9millionin2011.
The Secret Outlast Collection receives the maximum TME among the Secret line of
productswithexpendituresat$22.5millionin2012.
Televisionisthemostpreferredadvertisingmediumadoptedbythebrand.Television
advertisementsaccountfor61.7%ofthetotalTME.
Thesecondleadingadvertisingmediumforthemarketerismagazineadvertisements,
accountingfor22.6%ofthetotalTME.
In2012,Procter&GamblereducesitsadvertisingexpenditureonInternetadvertising
to$10.2millionin2012,down43.0%from$17.9millionin2011.
The company partners with Jenni Pulos, a television personality, actress, rapper, and
executiveassistant,topromoteitslatestlineofproducts,theSecretOutlastCollection.
In2012,Procter&GamblesetsuptheGangUpforGoodhubatmeanstinks.comin
the honor of National Bullying Prevention Month. The website offers a NiceAdvice
section, whereby girls all over the country share their experiences, encourage other
girls,andprovideexamplesofhowtheyvesuccessfullyGangedUpForGood.
In the second year of the Mean Stinks program, the brand partnerswith music artist
DemiLovatoandencouragesgirlstobeapartofthemovementthatattemptstobring
an end to mean behavior. The girls participating in this program are expected to
promote the Mean Stinks pinky swears by painting their nails blue to support peace
andsolidarity.
ThecompanypromotesitsOldSpicebrandwithamusicalhitMuscleMusic,avideo
whichfeaturesTerryCrews,aformerNFLplayer.Whenthevideofinishes,viewerscan
devloptheirownmusicbymovingCrewsmuscleswiththeirkeyboard.Eachkeystroke
flexesamuscleonCrewsbodytohitaninstrument.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H27

4H28

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

OUTLOOK

Salesforthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryareexpectedtogrowataslowpace
of1.2%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Clinicalstrengthproductswillcontinuetocontributetothecategorysvaluegrowth.
Marketers are expected to expand their product ranges with innovative products,
continue to reformulate their existing line of products, and bring about packaging
changestotheirexistinglineofproductsinordertokeepthecategoryalive.
However, further growth in the category is offset by a few factors, such as mature
phase of the category, limited scope for innovation, and a restricted growth in
population.
Additionally,thereislittlescopeformarketerstoexpandduetothehighpenetration
rateoftheirbrandsintheexistingretailchannels.

Clinical strength products will continue to contribute to the categorys sales during the
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Clinical strength deodorants and antiperspirants, which are better equipped to fight
odorandprovideprotectionagainstwetnessareexpectedtohelpspurthecategorys
growth.
Sincetheseclinicalstrengthproductsarenewtothecategoryandarewellperceived
bytheconsumers,marketersarelikelytocontinuetoemphasizeontheirdevelopment
by trying to innovate with fragranced variants, offering consumers a wider base of
productstochoosefrom.
Furthermore, the availability of these clinical strength products at premium price
pointswillaidinthevaluegrowthinthecategory.

Newproductactivityandinnovationwillcontinuetobolstergrowthinthecategory.
Marketers are expected to introduce new products with improved formulations and
advancedtechnologytodifferentiatetheirproductsfromothermarketers.
The aluminumfree deodorants and antiperspirants are expected to perform well
during the forecast period as consumers become more conscious of the purported
dangersoftheingredient.
Products offering odor and wetness protection for longer hours will be the primary
areasoflookoutforconsumers.
Innovative and fresh fragrances will help marketers diversify their product variants
targetingawiderconsumerbase,therebyaidinggrowthofthecategory.
Marketersarealsoexpectedtoexperimentwithnewandinventivedeliveryforms,and
creativeandattractivepackagingfortheirproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

With the presence of large marketers, such as Procter & Gamble, Unilever, Colgate
Palmolive, and Kao, the marketing and promotional spending are expected to remain at
highlevels.
Companies are likely to support their new product introductions with high media
expenditurestoensurevisibilityoftheirproductsinthemarket.
In order to differentiate their products from the others available in the market,
marketers are expected to launch creative and innovative marketing strategies to
gatherconsumersattentiontherebyhelpingthebrandsgrowth.

Changeinthepopulationdemographicswillalsodeterminethecategorysgrowth.
Withanincreasingtrendamongmentowardspersonalgroominghabits,thedemand
fordeodorantsandantiperspirantsislikelytogoupduringtheforecastperiodending
2017.
Additionally,theyoungmaleconsumerswhoaremoreopentotryingoutnewproduct
offerings of the various brands available in the market are likely to spend higher
proportionsontheirpersonalgroomingneeds.
In an attempt to target the tweens (812 year olds), marketers are expected to
introduceproductlineswithcolorfulandattractivepackagingprimarilytargetedtothe
particularneedsoftweens.

Growth in the deodorants and antiperspirants category is expected to be driven by the


introductionofmorenaturalandorganicproductsduringtheforecastperiod.
Marketers will increasingly introduce natural components in their products to drive
growth.
Natural products are preferred by consumers who have sensitive skin and higher
environmentalawareness.
Suchproductswiththeirpremiumpricepointswillgarnervaluegrowthinthecategory.
Marketers are expected to pay increased emphasis on the development of Natural
productsthatofferodorandwetnessprotection.

Sales of the deodorants and antiperspirants category are projected to grow at a CAGR of
1.1%toreach$2,160millionby2017,upfrom$2,040millionin2012.

UnitsalesofdeodorantsandantiperspirantsareforecasttogrowataCAGRof0.8%from
891.2millionpackagesin2012to925.9millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H29

4H30

DeodorantsandAntiperspirants

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturers sales for the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category post a growth of
13.2%to$163millionin2012,upfrom$144millionin2011.

Since 2007, the sales of the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category have grown at a
compoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.4%from$136millionin2007to$163millionin
2012.

Table4H14:HistoricalSalesofDepilatories,Waxes,and
BleachesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

2007

136

2008

139

2.2

2009

138

(0.7)

2010r

135

(2.2)

2011

144

6.7

163

13.2

2012

rRestated.

Change,%

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H32

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Table4H15:ManufacturersSalesofDepilatories,Waxes,andBleachesintheUnitedStatesbyBrand,
2011and2012

$Million

Brand

Company

SallyHansen

Coty

Nair

2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

45

46

31.3

28.2

Church&Dwight

42

45

29.2

27.6

Veet

ReckittBenckiser

25

26

17.4

16.0

Olay

Procter&Gamble

19

2.8

11.7

Nad's

SueIsmiel&Daughters

10

6.9

4.9

HairOff/BikiniZone

CCAIndustries

2.8

2.5

Jolen

JolenCrmeBleachCorp.

2.1

1.8

Magic

LOral

1.4

1.2

ArdellSurgi

AmericanInternational

0.7

0.6

Privatelabel

2.1

1.8

Allother

3.5

3.7

144

163

100.0

100.0

Total

Unitsales

Unitsalesofthedepilatories,bleaches,andwaxescategoryadvance12.9%to33.2million
unitsin2012,upfrom29.4millionunitsin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalestotal$222.7millionin2012,up13.6%from$196millionin2011.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Thedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoryexhibitsastellargrowthof13.2%toreach
$163millionin2012,upfrom$144millionin2011.
Olays exceptional growth in 2012 is the primary reason for the categorys healthy
growth.
Factorssuchasnewproductactivity,formulationimprovements,andinnovationdrive
thecategorysgrowthin2012.
Thereisanincreasingtrendtowardsdoityourself(DIY)athomehairremovalproducts
thatgiveresultsalmostsimilartoasalonservice.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Newandinnovativeproductactivityin2012aidsgrowthinthecategory.
AllthemajormarketersinthecategoryincludingProcter&Gamble,ReckittBenckiser,
Coty,andChurch&Dwightintroducenewproductsin2012.
Coty,thelargestcontributortothecategoryssales,introducestheSallyHansenSimply
SmoothHairRemoverCrmeandSallyHansenZeroBumpsBikiniSprayvariants.
Church&DwightintroducestheNairBrazilianSpaClayproductlinecomprisingtheNair
BrazilianSpaClayBodyCream,NairBrazilianSpaClayRollOnWax,andNairBrazilian
SpaClayFaceCream.
NadsinnovativeNoseWaxforMen&Womenisafirstofitskinddepilatoryfornose
hairremoval.TheproductcomeswithapatentpendingSafetipapplicator.
ReckittBenckiserin2012introducestheVeetHighPrecisionFacialWax,enrichedwith
almondoilandaloeVeratoremoveunwantedhairindelicateareas,suchastheupper
lip,chin,andeyebrows.Itcomesinaprecisiontubeapplicatorwhichcontrolstheflow
ofthewax.
Marketers increasingly introduce their products in innovative and easytouse
packagingformatstomakeiteasyforconsumers.

Procter & Gambles Olay does exceptionally well in 2012 in the depilatories, waxes, and
bleachesmarket.
Olaysgiganticincreaseisthekeyreasonbehindthecategoryshealthygrowth.
Inlate2011,Procter&Gambleenteredthefacialdepilatoriessegment,withthelaunch
of its Olay Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo for Fine to Medium Hair, which it
supportedbyatraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)of$11.5millioninitslaunchyear,
whichhelpedthesalesofthebrandtakeoff.
In2012,themarketerexpandsOlaysofferingsinthedepilatories,waxes,andbleaches
market with the introduction of the Olay Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo for
MediumtoCoarseHair,avariantoftheoriginalOlaySmoothFinishFacialHairRemoval
DuoforFinetoMediumHair.
Olays Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo for Medium to Coarse Hair is well
accepted by the consumers. The growth of the product is due to good marketing
support, with a TME of $30.1 million in 2012, primarily in the form of television and
magazineadvertisements.
Also positioning these products alongside other Olay skin care products in many
retailersbooststhepurchaseofdepilatoriesbywomenwhotraditionallydonotshop
forsuchproducts.

Depilatoriescontinuetobetheleadingsegmentinthecategory.
Theeaseofuseascomparedtothetraditionalwaxproductsleadstotheirsuccess.
Depilatory products in the form of inshower products and hairremoving sprays are
gainingprominenceinthecategoryduetotheconvenienceofusingtheseproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H33

4H34

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Waxescontinuetodowellin2012.
Consumers are increasingly shifting towards the use of wax products due to the
advanced technology used behind these products and the ease of convenient
applicationincomparisontothetraditional,difficulttoapplywaxproducts.
Many consumers choose cold wax over hot wax products; however, the hot wax
segmentisgrowingnoticeablyin2012.
The cold wax segments major performer is the easytouse wax strips, making it
convenient for consumers to use these products thereby saving them the bother of
warminganddealingwithhotwax.
A few variants in the cold wax segment include Veets ReadytoUse Wax Strip Hair
Remover available in Bikini, Underarms & Face and Leg & Body variants, Nads Body
Wax Strips available in Normal Skin, Dry Skin, and Sensitive Skin variants, and Sally
HansenshairRemoverWaxStripKitsavailableforBodyandFace.
Although wax products are time consuming, they often give smoother and longer
lastingresultsthandepilatories.
Moreover,thewaxproductsavailableinthemarketcomeinaneasytoapplyformat,
makingitlessmessyandmoreconvenientfortheconsumers.Someoftheseproducts
availableinthemarketincludeNairsMilk&HoneyRollOnWax,VeetsPrecisionFacial
WaxHairRemover,andNadsNoseWaxforMenandWomen.

Productsthatareeasytoapplyandprovideresultsinlesstimeareprovingmoresuccessful
inthemarket.
Nads Nose Wax For Men and Women comes with a Safetip applicator that makes it
easyforproductapplication.
SallyHansensZeroBumpsBikiniSpraycomesinasprayformatthatcanbetargeted
towardshardtoreachareas.
Nairs Brazilian Spa Clay RollOn Wax requires the wax to be heated and rolled on to
skinforhairfreeskin.Additionally,therollonapplicatorisclaimedtobeeasytouse
andmessfree.
NairsBrazilianSpaClayFaceCreamcomeswithahandsfreeprecisiontipapplicator
thatissaidtoprovideresultsinaslessasfiveminutes.

Hairremovalproductsenrichedwithnaturalingredientsarebecomingmorecommonwith
themarketers.
Ingredients,suchasaloeVera,almondoil,chamomile,honey,andvitaminEaresome
ofthemostcommonlyfoundnaturalingredientsinhairremovalproducts.
Consumers seek hair removal products with natural ingredients with the hope of
evadingtheburningandirritationsensationscausedbyproductsthatareformulated
withharshsyntheticchemicals.
Theseorganicproductsarenotonlyusedbyconsumerswithsensitiveskinbutothers
aswell.
NairsBrazilianSpaClaylineofproductsisenrichedwithmangobutter,acaiberry,and
mineralrichclay.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Furthergrowthinthecategoryisoffsetbyanumberoffactors.
With the recovering economy, consumers have started visiting salons for a more
relaxingexperienceandprofessionalresults.
The higher income segment of the society continues to visit salons for their hair
removalregimenratherthanusingcheaperalternativesofDIYdepilatories,waxes,and
bleaches.
Alternate hair removal treatments, such as laser treatments, guaranteeing close to
permanenthairremovalresultsalsohindersthecategorysgrowth.Theseservicesare
becoming less expensive due to increased competition and technological
advancements.
Themarketforathomebeautydevicesofferingelectronicallyenableddevicesforuse
intheconvenienceofthecustomershomealsorestrictsfurthergrowthinthecategory.

Notablenewproducts

Table4H16:SelectNewDepilatories,Waxes,andBleachesIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

Church&Dwight

Nair

BrazilianSpaClayBodyCreamisenrichedwithmangobutter,acaiberry,mineralrich
clay.InfusedwiththeShowerPowerTechnologywhichhelpspreventthecreamfrom
rinsingoffwhileintheshower.Additionally,theconvenientpumpandspongemakes
theapplicationandthehairremovalprocesseasyandhandsfree

Church&Dwight

Nair

BrazilianSpaClayRollOnWaxisinfusedwithmangobutter,acaiberry,andmineral
richclay.Itcomeswitharollonapplicatorforamessfreeapplication

Church&Dwight

Nair

BrazilianSpaClayFaceCreamisenrichedwithmangobutter,acaiberry,andmineral
richclaytogivesmoothhairfreeskinwithinaslittleasfiveminutes,dermatologically
tested

Coty

SallyHansen

SimplySmoothHairRemoverCrmeisawaterresistanthairremovalcrmethat
staysonintheshower,formulatedwithodorlesstechnology,givesresultsinjust
threeminutes,andresultslastuptosixdays

SallyHansen

ZeroBumpsBikiniSpraysoothesandeliminatesbumpsandirritationassociatedwith
hairremoval,preventsingrownhair.Itisenrichedwithaloeandorangeflower
whichprovidemoisturizationbenefits,andisavailableinsprayformatwhichprovides
convenientapplication

Olay

SmoothFinishFacialHairRemovalDuoMediumtoCoarseHair.Gentletwostep
systemthatremovesunwantedfacialhair,theskinguardingbalmactsasaprotective
barrieragainstthedirectcontactofthehairremovalcream,whilethecream
removestheunwantedhair

Veet

HighPrecisionFacialWaxisspeciallyformulatedwaxtoremoveunwantedhairin
delicateareas,suchaseyebrows,upperlip,andchin,enrichedwithalmondoiland
aloeveratomoisturizetheskin.Easytousetubeprecisionapplicatorcontrolsthe
flowofthewax

Nads

NoseWaxForMen&Womenisenrichedwithchamomileandaloeextractsto
quickly,easily,andeffectivelyremoveunwantednosehair,blackheadsandcleanse
poresfromthenosesurface.ComeswithaSafetipapplicatorandcanbeusedby
bothmenandwomen

Coty

Procter&Gamble

ReckittBenckiser

SueIsmiel&
Daughters

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H35

4H36

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Depilatoriesretainsitsleadasthelargestsegmentinthecategory,constituting63.8%ofthe
marketsharein2012.
Salesofdepilatoriesgrow16.9%in2012toreach$104millionfrom$89millionin2011.
Thesegmentscategoryshareadvancesfrom61.8%oftotalcategorysalesin2011to
63.8%in2012.
Cotys Sally Hansen and Church & Dwights Nair brands continue to dominate the
segmentwithavarietyofproductofferings.
Olays Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo, available in two variants, is the key
reasonbehindtheexceptionalperformanceofthissegmentin2012.
Moreover,constantnewproductactivityinthesegmentfromleadingmarketers,such
asCoty,Church&Dwight,andReckittBenckiseraddtothecategoryssalesin2012.

Waxes is the secondlargest segment in the category, accounting for 32.5% of the total
categoryssalesin2012.
In2012,waxeslosemarketsharefrom34.0%in2011to32.5%in2012;however,the
segmentssalesincrease8.2%from$49millioninto$53millionin2012.
Therecontinuestobemoredemandforcoldwaxesthanhotwaxes;however,thehot
waxessubsegmentgrowsrapidlyin2012aswell.
Coldwaxesaccountforapproximately59%ofthesegmentssales,whiletheremaining
41%comefromthehotwaxes.
In2012,thenewproductsintroducedinthewaxessegmentincludeNairsBrazilianSpa
ClayRollOnWax,VeetsHighPrecisionFacialWax,andNadsNoseWaxforMenand
Women.

Bleaches,thesmallestsegmentinthecategory,represents3.7%ofthetotalcategoryssales
in2012,downfrom4.2%in2011.
Manufacturerssalesforthesegmentremainflatat$6millionin2012from2011levels.
Althoughthesegmentssalesremainstagnant,itsmarketsharedeclinesin2012,due
tothegrowingsalesinthedepilatoriesandthewaxessegments.
Since the segment does not witness any new or innovative activity from marketers,
suchasJolenwhospecializeinsuchproductofferings,thesegmentstagnates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Table4H17:ManufacturersSalesofDepilatories,Waxes,andBleachesintheUnitedStatesby
ProductType,2011and2012

Product

$Million
2011

%Oftotal

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Depilatories

89

104

61.8

63.8

16.9

Waxes

49

53

34.0

32.5

8.2

4.2

3.7

144

163

100.0

100.0

13.2

Bleaches
Total

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Cotys Sally Hansen continues to dominate the category with 28.2% of the total market
sharein2012,adeclinefrom31.3%in2011.
Manufacturers sales for the brand advance 2.2% from $45million in 2011 to
$46millionin2012.
Thebrandsgrowthin2012isduetonewproductactivity.Thecompanyintroducesthe
SallyHansenSimplySmoothHairRemoverCrmeawaterresistantformulaformess
free hair removal inshower and the Sally Hansen Zero Bumps Bikini Sprayenriched
withwitchhazel,aloe,andsoyextracttokeepskinsoftandpreventingrownhair.
SallyHansencompetesinallthethreesegmentsofthecategory:depilatories,waxes,
andbleaches.
ThemarketersofferinginthebleachessegmentislimitedtoonlytwoSKUs.
Thecompanyconcentratessolelyonitslineoffemalehairremovalproductsafterthe
discontinuationofitsmenshairremovallineofproductsin2011.
In2012,thecompanylaunchestheGetBareDoubleDareprogramallowingfansto
enterthesweepstakesonSallyHansensFacebookpagewithachancetowinaniPad
and $2,000. The program is designed to promote Sally Hansen's Hair Remover Wax
StripKitforFace,thenewZeroBumpsBikiniSpray,andthenewSimplySmoothHair
Remover.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H37

4H38

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Church&DwightsNairisthesecondlargestbrandinthecategory,withsalesat$45million
in2012,up7.1%from42millionin2011.
Nairsmarketsharereducesfrom29.2%in2011to27.6%in2012.
Thekeyreasonforthemarketershealthygrowthin2012isaccreditedtothelaunchof
itsBrazilianSpaClaylineofproducts.ThelinecomprisesBrazilianSpaClayBodyCream,
BrazilianSpaClayRollOnWax,andBrazilianSpaClayFaceCream.
Nairsportfolioofproductsforwomenincludesinshowerproducts,waxes,andcreams
and gels. These products are available in different variants with some especially
designedasasensitiveformula.
NairsproductofferingsformenarelimitedtotheNairforMenSpray,InShowerNair
ForMen,andNairForMenBodyCreamsincedepilatoriesisanichesegmentforthe
maleconsumers.
Meningeneralarenotloyaltoadepilatorybrandandtendtopickupanythingthat
would catch their attention first. In many cases, men trade down to privatelabel
depilatoryproductsduetothelowerpricedoption.

ReckittBenckisersVeetpostsa4.0%growthin2012toreach$26millionin2012,upfrom
$25millionin2011.
Veet is distantly placed as the thirdlargest marketer in the depilatories, waxes, and
bleachescategory.
Veetsmarketsharedeclinesfrom17.4%in2011to16.0%in2012.
The marketers growth in 2012 is the result of the good performanceof its SprayOn
Cream Hair Remover Sensitive Formula with Aloe Vera & Vitamin E, Spray On Cream
Hair Remover with Essential Oils, and ReadytoUse wax Strips Hair Remover Legs &
Body,andtheintroductionoftheHighPrecisionFacialWaxproduct.

Olay(Procter&Gamble)recordsanenormousgrowthat375.0%in2012.
Manufacturerssalesforthebrandadvancefrom$4millionin2011to$19millionin
2012.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfromamere2.8%in2011to11.7%in2012.
Olays offering in the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category consists of a single
product, the Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo. Currently, the Smooth Finish
FacialHairRemovalDuoisavailableintwovariants:oneforfinetomediumhairand
theotherformediumtocoarsehair.
The Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo for Medium to Coarse Hair is, however,
launchedin2012afterthesuccessoftheinitiallaunchoftheSmoothFinishFacialHair
RemovalDuoforFinetoMediumHairin2011.
SalesforOlaybenefitsfromastrongdistributionmodelanditsproductsareavailable
acrossallmajorretailmasschannels,suchasWalmart,Walgreens,andCVS/Pharmacy.
The brand has a higher price point than competing products, because of the trusted
Olayname.Thisalsocontributestothesteepdollarincreaseinsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Nads(SueIsmiel&Daughters)salesdecline20.0%in2012.
The companys sales decline to $8 million in 2012, down 20.0% from $10 million in
2011.
Nadsmarketsharedeclines200basispointsfrom6.9%in2011to4.9%in2012.
Nadsoffersproductsforbothmenandwomen.
Inspiteofthelaunchofafirstofitskind,NoseWaxforMenandWomeninthemarket
in2012,thecompanyfailstorecuperateitsoverallsales.
Additionally,Nadslowemphasisonmarketing,withaminimalTMEof$1million,aids
itsdeclinein2012.
The brands decline in sales is also a result of the increasing competition from other
leadingbrandsandespeciallytheentryofOlayinthemarket.

Privatelabelproductssalesremainflatat$3millionin2012,fromthe2011levels.
Theseproductsaccountfor1.8%shareofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,downfrom
2.1%in2011.
Of all the segments in the category, consumers most often purchase privatelabel
bleaches,sincebleachingisarelativelypainfreemethodandtheriskfactorisminimal.
However, many consumers are wary of using less expensive and lowquality private
label depilatories and waxes due to the fear of a bad experience with respect to
discomfort,pain,andirritationassideeffects.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Theshareofretailoutletsinthecategoryundergoesminorchangesin2012.
Drug stores continue to be the leading retail outlet in the category with a 46.0%
contributionfollowedbymassmerchandisers.
Massmerchandisers,inthesecondlead,accountsfor43.0%ofthetotalretailsalesin
2012, up from 42.0% in 2011. The enormous growth of Olay, which is mainly
distributedthroughmassmerchandisers,isthekeyreasonbehindtheincreaseinthe
shareofthedistributionchannel.
Foodstoresisthethirdlargestretailchannelforthecategoryrepresenting8.0%ofthe
totalcategoryssales,flatfrom2011levels.
The sales proportion of the direct sales retail channel declines from 3.0% in 2011 to
2.0%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H39

4H40

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Table4H18:ManufacturersSalesofDepilatories,Waxes,and
BleachesintheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Drugstores

46

46

Massmerchandisers

42

42

Foodstores

10

Directsales

Specialtystores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

TMEforthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoryisestimatedtogrowat36.7%from
$42millionin2011,to$57.4millionin2012.

Procter & Gamble is the leading marketer in TME, with an advertising expenditure at
$30.1millionin2012.
The marketer entered the category in 2011 with Olays Smooth Finish Facial Hair
RemovalDuo.
Procter&Gamblespends$15.8milliononmagazineadvertisementsand$12.9million
ontelevisionadvertisements.
Olayspresenceonsocialmedianetworks,suchasFacebook,helpsspreadawareness
aboutitsproductsthatcompeteinthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategory.
OlayswebsitealsopromotestheSmoothFinishFacialHairRemovalDuobyeducating
consumersabouthairremovalfactsandmythsandbyprovidingvideosandarticlesby
professionalestheticians.
Consumersinterestedinreceivingregularupdatesaboutthebrandshappeninginthe
formofspecialoffers,events,sweepstakes,giveaways,andinsiderinformationcanjoin
theOlayClubthroughthebrandswebsite.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

ReckittBenckisersupportsitsVeetlinewithaTMEof$5.8millionin2012.
Themarketersexpenditureontelevisionadvertisementsare$4.2millionin2012.
Magazineexpendituresfollowcloselyat$1.6million.
VeetsReadytoUseWaxStripsreceiveaTMEof$4.6millionin2012.
Veetoffersdiscountcouponsworth$2.00onitswebsite.
The brands website sports the Veet EMail Club that provides tips, offers, and
informationaboutitsproductstoitsmembers.
Reckitt Benckiser also utilizes social media networks, such as Facebook, Twitter, and
YouTube to spread awareness and gain a medium of personal communication with
consumers.
YouTubefeaturesnumeroushowtodovideosaidingconsumersinproductusage.
In2012,thecompanypartnerswithCherylBurke,acelebrityballroomdancingproand
televisionpersonality,topublicizeitsReadytoUseWaxStripsforFaceandBodyand
theHighPrecisionFacialWax.

Church&DwightsTMEdecreasesto$4.5millionin2012from$7.4millionin2011,down
39.6%.
Majority of its TME, $2.9million, is spent on television advertisements. Television
advertisementexpendituresaccountfor64.4%ofthetotalTME.
Themarketeralsospends$2.2milliononmagazineadvertisements.
The Nair Brazilian Spa Clay hair removal line receives most of the brands TME at
approximately$3.0millionin2012.
Nairs website offers a discount coupon of $3.00 on the purchase of any two Nair
products.
The website offers writeups on the advantages of using athome Nair hair removal
productsasagainstvisitingsalons,guidetoobtainingbeautifulskin,andotheruseful
informationontheuseofproducts.
Nairs men and women products are classified separately on its website, making it
easierforconsumerstotracetheproductappropriateforthem.

DetailsonTMEbybrandareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H41

4H42

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

OUTLOOK

Thedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategoryisexpectedtowitnessmoderategrowthof
3.7%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Olayisexpectedtocontinuetogrowitssalesbyexpandingitslineofproducts.Further,
Olayisexpectedtoforayintoothersegments,suchaswaxesandbleachesduringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Marketers ability to innovate with products and make them available in convenient
easytousepackagingformatswilldrivesalesinthecategory.
Depilatory products formulated with natural ingredients will continue to gain
popularity,withmarketersincreasinglyintroducingsuchproducts.
However, inadequate marketing support from marketers for their new products and
theexistingproductportfolioisexpectedtorestrictfurthergrowthinthecategory.
Competitionfromalternatehairremovaltreatments,suchassalonservices,laserhair
removaltreatments,andathomehairremovaldeviceswillalsohinderthecategorys
growthduringtheforecastperiod.

Marketerswillhavetoinnovatewithproductsforthecategorytopostgrowth.
Innovationsintheformofnewandimprovedformulations,attractivepackaging,easy
touseformats,andnaturalingredientswillplayanimportantroleintheoverallsales
growthofthecategory.
Inshower products and sprays are popular among consumers and with the
introductionofvariants,moresuccessisexpectedinthissegment.
Asmenbecomemoreconsciousoftheirgroomingneeds,andbegintoestablishaskin
careregimen,morearelikelytostartusinghairremovalproducts.However,onlythe
depilatoriesandwaxessegmentswouldapplytothemaleconsumers,withmajorityof
themchoosingdepilatoriesoverwaxesduetothepainfactorinvolvedwiththewaxing
procedure.
Marketers interested in venturing into the mens segment will have contradictory
examplestogainalearningexperiencefromwiththefailureofSallyHansenforMen
andthesuccessofNairsShowerPowerforMen.
SallyHansenforMenwasunsuccessfulincompletehairremoval,exceptthemaximum
strength version which also burnt the consumers skin. However, Nairs product has
had more success due to its more effective formula and pleasant smell than the
competitorsproducts.

Olayislikelytopostahealthygrowththrough2017.
Thebrandisexpectedtolaunchmorevariantstoitsexistinglineofproductsoverthe
nextfiveyears.
There is a likelihood that the brand will venture into other segments, such as waxes
andbleachesinanattempttocompetewithotherbrandsinthecategoryandtryand
capturegoodmarketshare.
The marketer will continue to have good marketing support for its new product
introductionswithprintandtelevisionadvertisementsasthemainmediums.Also,Olay
couldpossiblysignacelebritytoendorseitsproductsinthecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

Marketers will be required to increase marketing expenditures to support their evolving


productportfoliosandgeneratedemand.
Marketers might be influenced by Procter & Gamble to follow the kind of marketing
supportitgivestheOlaybrand.
However, all marketers are unable to provide large marketing support for the
depilatories,waxes,andbleachescategory.
Companieswouldincreasinglyresorttousinglessexpensiveandvirtualsocialmedia,
suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube,whicharehighlypopularamongthemasses.

Similar to the other categories in the cosmetics and toiletries industry, marketers are
expectedtoinnovatewithnaturalandorganicproductstosupporttheirsalesincrease.
As consumers gain awareness about the adverse effects of the synthetic chemicals
used in products, they make a shift towards the use of products formulated with
naturalandorganicingredients.
Some of the commonly found natural ingredients in depilatories and bleaches
formulationsincludealoevera,cocoabutter,almondoil,andvitaminE.
Cotys Sally Hansen, Church & Dwights Nair, and Reckitt Benckisers Veet already
possess products that are formulated with natural ingredients and are expected to
expandtheirproductlinesoverthefiveyearforecastperiod.

Manufacturers sales in the category are expected to increase at a CAGR of 3.7% from
$163millionin2012toarounded$195millionin2017.

UnitvolumeisprojectedtogrowataCAGRof3.5%from33.2millionpackagesin2012to
39.5millionpackagesin2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H43

4H44

Depilatories,Waxes,andBleaches

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

In 2012, the personal cleansing products category displays an overall growth of 3.0% to
reach$4,026millioninsalesatmanufacturerslevel,upfrom$3,907millionin2011.
The body washes segment continues to be the major contributor to the categorys
growth,postingthehighestgrowthat3.4%in2012.
The body washes segment dominates the personal cleansing products category with
thesegmentssalesat$1,354millionin2012,upfrom1,310millionin2011.
Growthoftheliquidsoapssegmentisduetotheaddedbenefitsintheseproductsas
comparedtobarsoaps.

Table4H19:HistoricalSalesofPersonalCleansingProducts
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

3,473

2008

3,558

2.4

2009

3,686

3.6

2010

3,792

2.9

2011

3,907

3.0

2012

4,026

3.0

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H46

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H20:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

Producttype/brand

Company

$Million

BODYWASHES

Dove

Unilever

202

214

15.4

15.8

5.2

5.3

Suaver

Unilever

129

133

9.8

9.8

3.3

3.3

Dialr

Henkel

116

118

8.9

8.7

3.0

2.9

Olay

Procter&Gamble

101

110

7.7

8.1

2.6

2.7

OldSpicer

Procter&Gamble

104

105

7.9

7.8

2.7

2.6

Softsoap

ColgatePalmolive

87

89

6.6

6.6

2.2

2.2

Axe

Unilever

80

79

6.1

5.8

2.0

2.0

Caressr

Unilever

61

69

4.7

5.1

1.6

1.7

Nivea

Beiersdorf

43

44

3.3

3.2

1.1

1.1

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

40

38

3.1

2.8

1.0

0.9

St.Ives

Unilever

38

36

2.9

2.7

1.0

0.9

IrishSpringr

ColgatePalmolive

35

33

2.7

2.4

0.9

0.8

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

25

29

1.9

2.1

0.6

0.7

Toner

Henkel

23

24

1.8

1.8

0.6

0.6

Gillette

Procter&Gamble

24

20

1.8

1.5

0.6

0.5

Ivory

Procter&Gamble

14

16

1.1

1.2

0.4

0.4

WhiteRainr

BrynwoodPartners

14

15

1.1

1.1

0.4

0.4

Zestr

BrynwoodPartners

12

13

0.9

1.0

0.3

0.3

Lever2000

Unilever

0.7

0.5

0.2

0.2

Adidas

Coty

0.5

0.4

0.2

0.1

GoldBond

Sanofi

0.4

0.3

0.1

0.1

Coast

BrynwoodPartners

0.1

0.1

Johnson's

Johnson&Johnson

0.1

0.1

89

95

6.8

7.0

2.3

2.4

2011

Privatelabelr

Allother

2012

%Ofsegment

2011

%Oftotal

2011

2012

51

54

3.9

4.0

1.3

1.3

Totalr

1,310

1,354

100.0

100.0

33.5

33.6

BARSOAPS

Dove

Unilever

440

466

35.5

36.8

11.3

11.6

Dial

Henkel

188

184

15.2

14.5

4.8

4.6

IrishSpring

ColgatePalmolive

106

110

8.6

8.7

2.7

2.7

Caressr

Unilever

68

68

5.5

5.4

1.7

1.7

Olay

Procter&Gamble

63

60

5.1

4.7

1.6

1.5

Lever2000

Unilever

59

58

4.8

4.6

1.5

1.4

Ivory

Procter&Gamble

53

51

4.3

4.0

1.4

1.3

Zest

BrynwoodPartners

41

46

3.3

3.6

1.0

1.1

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

18

19

1.5

1.5

0.5

0.5

Safeguard

Procter&Gamble

17

16

1.4

1.3

0.4

0.4

L'Occitane

L'Occitane

13

14

1.0

1.1

0.3

0.3

(Continued(

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

2012

4H47

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H20:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

Producttype/brand

Company

$Million

BARSOAPS(Continued)

Coast
Palmoliver
Tone

Henkel

Yardleyr

Lornamead

PrimalElements

2011

2012

%Ofsegment
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

BrynwoodPartners

11

12

0.9

0.9

0.3

0.3

ColgatePalmolive

12

0.6

0.9

0.2

0.3

10

10

0.8

0.8

0.3

0.2

0.7

0.7

0.2

0.2

PrimalElements

0.7

0.7

0.2

0.2

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

0.6

0.6

0.2

0.2

Jergens

Kao

0.6

0.4

0.2

0.1

Tom'sofMaine

ColgatePalmolive

0.3

0.4

0.1

0.1

Avon

Avon

0.2

0.2

0.1

0.1

Basis

Beiersdorf

0.2

0.2

0.1

Camay

Procter&Gamble

0.2

0.2

0.1

Neutrogenar

Johnson&Johnson

0.2

0.1

0.1

Lava

WD40

0.2

0.1

Pure&Natural

BrynwoodPartners

0.1

Privatelabel

23

24

1.9

1.9

0.6

0.6

Allother

72

75

5.8

5.9

1.8

1.9

Totalr

1,239

1,268

100.0

100.0

31.7

31.5

BATHADDITIVES

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

197

212

31.8

33.2

5.0

5.3

Avon

Avon

87

78

14.0

12.2

2.2

1.9

VictoriasSecretGarden

LimitedBrands

49

50

7.9

7.8

1.3

1.2

BurtsBees

TheCloroxCompany

35

37

5.6

5.8

0.9

0.9

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

25

26

4.0

4.1

0.6

0.6

Philosophy

Coty

14

15

2.3

2.4

0.4

0.4

TheBodyShop

L'Oral

14

14

2.3

2.2

0.4

0.3

Neutrogena

Johnson&Johnson

13

13

2.1

2.0

0.3

0.3

VillageNaturals

MinnetonkaBrands

1.5

1.4

0.2

0.2

L'Occitane

L'Occitane

1.1

1.4

0.2

0.2

Origins

EsteLauder

1.1

1.3

0.2

0.2

Dr.Teals

Dr.TealsTherapeutic
Solutions

1.1

1.3

0.2

0.2

Crabtree&Evelyn

Crabtree&Evelyn

1.3

1.3

0.2

0.2

MaryKay

MaryKay

1.1

1.1

0.2

0.2

Lander

GrandBrands

1.1

1.1

0.2

0.2

Bliss

SteinerLeisure

1.0

1.1

0.2

0.2

BlueQ

BlueQ

1.1

0.9

0.2

0.1

TheHealingGarden

YellowWoodPartners

0.8

0.8

0.1

0.1

Cosrich

Cosrich

0.8

0.6

0.1

0.1

(Continued(

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H48

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H20:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

Producttype/brand

Company

$Million
2011

2012

%Ofsegment
2011

2012

%Oftotal
2011

2012

BATHADDITIVES(Coyinued)
Calgon

YellowWoodPartners

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

Vitabath

RichBrands

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

VaselineIntensiveCare

Unilever

0.6

0.6

0.1

0.1

MZB

MZBPersonalCare

0.5

0.5

0.1

0.1

KidCare

CosmeticEssence

0.3

0.3

0.1

Privatelabel

22

23

3.5

3.6

0.6

0.6

Allother

72

75

11.6

11.8

1.8

1.9

620

638

100.0

100.0

15.9

15.8

Total

LIQUIDSOAPS

Softsoap

ColgatePalmolive

Dialr

209

215

35.5

34.9

5.3

5.3

Henkel

81

92

13.8

14.9

2.1

2.3

Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

78

84

13.3

13.6

2.0

2.1

Method

Method

23

28

3.9

4.5

0.6

0.7

Ivoryr

Procter&Gamble

0.9

0.6

0.1

0.1

Jergens

Kao

0.2

0.2

Kandoo

Procter&Gamble

0.3

0.2

0.1

Johnson'sBaby

Johnson&Johnson

0.2

Privatelabelr

145

146

24.7

23.7

3.7

3.6

Allother

43

45

7.3

7.3

1.1

1.1

588

616

100.0

100.0

15.0

15.3

Totalr

ANTIBACTERIALHANDGELS
Bath&BodyWorks

LimitedBrands

41

44

27.3

29.3

1.0

1.1

Purell

GojoIndustries

39

40

26.0

26.7

1.0

1.0

GermX

ViJohnLaboratories

5.3

4.0

0.2

0.1

Dial

Henkel

2.0

1.3

0.1

Privatelabelr

51

50

34.0

33.3

1.3

1.2

Allother

5.3

5.3

0.2

0.2

Totalr

150

150

100.0

100.0

3.8

3.7

TOTALr

3,907

4,026

100.0

100.0

rRestated.

Unitsales

Unitsalesofthepersonalcleansingproductsadvance2.8%from1,617millionpackagesin
2011to1,663millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H21:UnitSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductSegment,2012

Millionpackages

%Oftotalunits

Segment

2011

2012

2011

2012

Changeinvolume,%

Barsoapsr

788

806

48.7

48.5

2.3

Bodywashesr

434

448

26.8

26.9

3.2

Liquidsoapsr

205

215

12.7

12.9

4.9

Bathadditives

122

125

7.5

7.5

2.5

67

67

4.1

4.0

1,617

1,663

100.0

100.0

2.8

Antibacterialhandgelsr
Totalr

rRestated.

Retailsales

Retail sales of the personal cleansing products category grow 3.1% to $5,871.8million in
2012,upfrom$5,694.7millionin2011.

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Thepersonalcleansingproductscategory,althoughinamaturephase,continuestogrowin
2012.
Availabilityofpersonalcleansingproductsinavarietyofforms,suchasbarsoaps,body
washes,andbathadditivesgivesconsumersawidearrayofoptionstochoosefrom.
Salesofthebodywashesandliquidsoapssegmentsincreasesignificantly,whilesales
ofbathadditivesandbarsoapsincreasemoderately.
Salesoftheantibacterialhandgelssegmentremainstagnantin2012.
Brandloyaltyislowasconsumersdecisionsareruledbythepriceoftheproducts.
Further growth of the category is offset by the good performance of privatelabel
products,makingavailabletoconsumersgoodqualityproductsatlowprices.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H49

4H50

PersonalCleansingProducts

Categorygrowthcontinuestobedrivenbythestrongperformanceofthebodywashesand
liquidhandsoapssegments.
Manymarketerscontinuetointroducebodywashesinavarietyoffragrances.
In 2012, Lornamead introduces Yardley Skin indulgence Lavender & Rosemary Skin
SoothingBath&ShowerGel,ColgatePalmoliveintroducestheSoftsoapCitrusSplash&
Berry Fusion Moisturizing Body Wash, CaswellMassey introduces the Fig & bamboo
FoamingBodyWash,UnileverintroducestheCaressEndlessKissSilkeningBodyWash,
andSuaveEverlastingSunshine.
Also in 2012, The Clorox Company launches the Gd range of products comprising,
among other products body washes in an array of five fragrances: Red Ruby Groovy,
PeranormalActivity,OrangePetalooza,FloralCherrynova,andVanillaFlame.
Thecategorysgrowthisalsodrivenbythegoodperformanceofnaturallypositioned
body wash formulations comprising greater proportions of natural or organic
ingredientsincomparisontotheconventionalbodywashes.
AfewofthenaturallypositionedbodywashesavailableinthemarketincludeStIves
DeepMoistureTripleButtersCreamyCoconutenrichedwithjojoba,Shea,andcoconut
butter; andBurts Bees Naturally Nourishing Milk & Shea Butter Body Wash enriched
withsafflowerseedoleosomes.
In2012,LornameadintroducestheSkinIndulgenceSeaMineralsSkinSmoothingBath
&ShowerGelwhichisenrichedwithseakelpandnaturalexfoliants.
Growth in the liquid soaps segment is driven by a number of new launches in 2012.
ColgatePalmoliveintroducestheSoftsoapPamperedHandsCoconutLimeLiquidHand
Soap and Henkel introduces the Dial Natural Tangerine & Guava Moisturizing Liquid
HandSoap.

Although sales of bar soaps grow in 2012, further growth of the segment is negatively
affectedbythegrowingpopularityofbodywashes.
Acertainproportion of thepopulationprefersbarsoapsoverthehigherpricedbody
washestherebydrivingsalesforthebarsoapssegmentin2012.
A few of the new variants introduced in 2012 include Aubrey Rosas Mosqueta
LuxuriousBathBar,CaswellMasseysVerbenaandLavenderBarSoaps,andYardleys
SkinIndulgenceMango&CreamBodyButterCleansingBar.
However, further growth in the bar soaps segment is negatively affected by the
marketers inability to continually innovate with product offerings in the segment to
preventshiftingtobodywashes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

PersonalCleansingProducts

The category continues to witness fierce competition with respect to pricing of products
andattainingbrandloyaltyamongconsumers.
Brand loyalty continues to be a major area of concern for marketers in the personal
cleansing products category as consumers increasingly change their preference for
brandsbasedontheproductpricing
Thelowpricedprivatelabelproductsposeathreattotheproductsmanufacturedby
wellestablished national brands as consumers continue to be pricesensitive while
purchasingpersonalcleansingproducts.
Additionally, privatelabel manufacturers expand their personal cleansing range of
productsbymakingthemavailableinavarietyoffragrancesandofferingmoisturizing
benefits,inlinewiththeestablishedmarketers,therebymakingiteasierforconsumers
totradedowntothelessexpensiveprivatelabelproducts.
Overall,thecategorycontinuestobecompetitive,withmarketerscontendingforbrand
loyalty from consumers in terms of pricing, marketing, packaging, and new product
offerings.

In an attempt to innovate, marketers increasingly introduce genderspecific personal


cleansingproducts.
Marketerslookatvariousmeanstoenticeconsumerstowardstheirproductofferings,
one of them being the introduction of separate personal cleansing products for men
andwomen.
Thepersonalcleansingproductsdesignedforwomenaremilderthanthosedesigned
for men and are generally available in a variety of fragrances. Marketers infuse the
personal cleansing products targeted towards women with floral fragrances,
moisturizingbenefits,andnaturalingredients.
While the personal cleansing products designed for men have more masculine
fragrances, some are formulated with technology that helps fight odor, and in some
cases provide multifunctional benefits, such as acting as a shampoo, face wash, and
bodywashsimultaneously.
Leading brands, such as Axe, Adidas, Irish Spring, Old Spice, Dove Men+Care, and
Gillettearetargetedtowardsmen.
Withrespecttomalespecificproducts,bodywashesgrowinpopularity.
In2012,UnileverintroducestheDoveMen+CareCleanDefenseBody&FaceWashand
Fresh Awake Body & Face Wash. Doves range of Body & Face Wash are formulated
withMicromoistureTechnologythatisclinicallyproventofightskindryness.
Alsoin2012,CotysAdidasintroducestheAdidasHair&Body3,arangeofproducts
that provides tripleaction results by cleansing and refreshing the skin while
conditioningthehair.Therangeofproductsisavailableinthreevariants:AfterSport,
ExtraFresh,andActiveStart.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H51

4H52

PersonalCleansingProducts

Salesintheantibacterialhandgelssegmentremainconstantin2012.
Sales in the segment stagnate as consumers become less preoccupied with
antibacterialgel,comparedtothesegmentssurgein2009and2010duetothescare
oftheH1N1flu.Thedormantsalesinthesegmentisattributedtothecurrentdearthof
pandemics.
Antibacterialhandgels maketheskindryduetothealcoholcontent, contributingto
theslowingsalesinthesegment.
Furthermore, concerns about triclosan, the main ingredient in many of the products,
havenotabatedandthereforenegativelyaffectthesegmentssales.

Thetrendtowardsnaturallypositionedproductscontinuestogathermomentum.
Naturallyformulated products gain acceptance as consumers increasingly become
health conscious and try and incorporate the trend of health and wellness in their
personalhygieneregimen.
These naturallyformulated personal cleansing products contain lower levels of
synthetic ingredients as compared to the conventional personal cleansing products
availableinthemarket.

Duetothematurephasethatthecategoryisin,innovationplaysasignificantroleforthe
categorysgrowth.
Innovation in the form of substance, texture, fragrance, packaging, and added value
willhelpdrivesalesinthepersonalcleansingproducts.
Productofferingscontainingbenefitsinadditiontothebasiccleansingandmoisturizing
functionshasbecomeatrendinthemarket.Consumershavebecomeusedtothebasic
functions and expect more benefits from personal cleansing products in the form of
skinnourishment,improvedskinhealth,andbeautyenhancement.
Fragrancescontinuestoplayasignificantroleinthegrowingsalesofthecategorydue
tothemarketersinitiativestoexpandtheirpersonalcleansingrangeofproductswith
variantsincreativeandexoticfragrances.Someareespeciallydesignedforeachseason.
During the spring and summer seasons, marketers introduce floral and refreshing
fragranced personal cleansing products while during autumn and winter, personal
cleansingproductswithspicierorheavierfragrancesareintroduced.
Bath & Body Works spring and summer body washes collection includes Wild Citrus
SunflowerShowerGel,WildPeachPoppiesShowerGel,CarriedAwayShowerGel,and
CoconutLimeBreezeShowerGelwhileitsbodywashessuitedforuseduringautumn
andwinterincludeSensualAmberShowerGel,SweetCinnamonPumpkinShowerGel,
CashmereGlowShowerGel,andTwilightWoodsShowerGel.
Marketers also regularly change the packaging of their product lines to make them
more attractive and give them a fresh appearance. This helps develop curiosity and
leadspeopletobuycertainproducts.
Moreover,marketersalsobringaboutchangestotheformulationsoftheirexistingline
ofproductbyenrichingthemwithmoreadvancedtechnologyorsuperioringredients
toprovidemoreefficaciousresultsinlessertime.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

PersonalCleansingProducts

Sales of privatelabel products continue to grow during 2012, driven by a wide variety of
productsavailableatlowpriceofferings.
Privatelabelproductsareperceivedasgoodqualityproducts,backedbyanaggressive
pushfromretailers.
Retailers support privatelabel products by giving them prime shelf space next to
establishedbrandsproducts.
Additionally, private labels work in close contact with the retailers and develop
products based on the feedback they receive from the retailers, who are able to
provideatruepictureabouttheneedsanddemandsofconsumers.
Despitetheeconomicrecovery,consumerscontinuetobepricesensitiveforproducts
thatsatisfytheirbasicneeds.

M&Aactivity

In2012,BrynwoodPartners,throughitsportfoliocompaniesacquiresbrandsacrossthethe
entirecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket.
Brynwood Partners through its portfolio company, Golden Sun acquires the Pure &
Natural brand from The Dial Corporation, a subsidiary of Henkel. Pure & Naturals
rangeofproductsincludeliquidhandsoapsandbodywashes.
BrynwoodPartnersthroughitsportfoliocompanyHighRidgeBrandsacquirestheCoast
personalcleansingbrand.
Coastwaslaunchedin1975anditsproductsareofferedunderthebarsoapsandbody
washessegments.
Brynwood Partners through its portfolio company High Ridge Brands acquires the
WhiteRainbrandfromSunProducts.
White Rain was launched by Gillette in 1952. White Rain offers a diverse range of
productsincludingshampoos,conditioners,bodywashes,andhairstylingproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H53

4H54

PersonalCleansingProducts

Notablenewproducts

Table4H22:SelectNewPersonalCleansingProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

AubreyOrganics

Aubrey

RosaMosquetaLuxuriousBathBarisinfusedwithorganicrosamosquetaoilandborageoil

CaswellMassey

CaswellMassey

Fi&BambooCollectioncomprisesafoamingbodywashandbarsoap.Theproductsareenrichedwitha
blendofmarulaoil,mirabellaplumoil,andedelweissandswisswatercressextracts

CaswellMassey

CaswellMassey

LavenderBarSoapisformulatedwithlatheringvegetablebaseandperfumegradeoilstocleansetheskin
withoutleavingitdry

CaswellMassey

CaswellMassey

VerbenaBarSoap,formulatedwithlatheringvegetablebase,cleansestheskinwithoutleavingtheskin
dry

Colgate
Palmolive

Softsoap

Scensationsisalimitededitionlineofbodywasheswhichareinfusedwithseasonalfruitscentsand
moisturizingingredientstokeeptheskinhydrated.ItisavailableinJasmineOasisandLemonadeBerry
Splash

Colgate
Palmolive

Softsoap

CitrusSplash&BerryFusionMoisturizingBodyWashisenrichedwithamoisturizingformula,energizing
fragrance,andberryextracts

Colgate
Palmolive

Softsoap

PamperedHandsCoconutLimeLiquidHandSoapisenrichedwithmoisturizingingredientstocleansethe
handsandisavailableincoconutandrefreshinglimescent

Colgate
Palmolive

Softsoap

AntibacterialHandSoapwithMoisturizersisclinicallyproventoeliminate99.9%ofbacteriawhileleaving
theskinmoisturized.Itisavailableintwoscents:CrispCleanandFreshCitrus

Colgate
Palmolive

IrishSpring

Clear&FreshSkinBodyWashenrichedwithsalicyclicacidclaimstotreatandhelppreventbody
breakouts

Colgate
Palmolive

IrishSpring

DeepActionScrubBodyWashinfusedwithcelticrocksaltexfoliatestheskintogivecleanskin

Coty

Adidas

Hair&Body3ShowerGelcleansesandhydratesthebodyandface,conditionshair.Itisavailableinthree
variant:AfterSport,ExtraFresh,andActiveStart

Dr.Teals
Therapeutic
Solutions

Dr.Teals

MilkBathisablendofrealmilkproteinandvitaminA,D,andEforamoisturizingspalikeexperience.Itis
availableintwoforms:foamingliquidMilkBathandpowderedMilkBath

Dr.Teals
Therapeutic
Solutions

Dr.Teals

EpsomSaltFootScrubisacombinationofEpsomSaltandTeaTreeOiltoexfoliateandnourishthefeets
skin

Henkel

Dial

HelloKittyisfreshandfruitylineofpersonalcleansingproductscomprisingMoisturizingBodyWash,
AntibacterialFoamingHandWash,BarSoap,andMoisturizingHandSanitizer

Henkel

Dial

GoldAntibacterialRoundTheClockOdorProtectionDeodorizingBodyWashprovidesodorprotection
RoundTheClock

Henkel

Dial

NaturalsTangerine&GuavaMoisturizingLiquidHandSoapisinfusedwithingredientsthatare
hypoallergenicand94%naturallyderived

Henkel

Tone

FruitPeelBodyWashisacombinationofsunkissedapple,kiwi,citrus,andAlphaHydroxyAcidsthat
exfoliatetheskintowashawaydullskin

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

PinkChiffonShowerGelisafeminineblendofsparklingredpear,vanillaorchid,andwhippedchiffon
muskfragrancesenrichedwithvitaminE,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblier
experience.Itisavailableinatravelsizeaswell

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

PinkChiffonPocketbacSanitizingHandGelispocketsizedgermkillerenrichedwithTahitianpalmmilkto
givethehandsaconditioningfeel.Itisscentedwithsparklingredpear,vanillaorchid,andwhipped
chiffonmusk

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

CashmereGlowShowerGelisablendofgoldenpeach,shimmeringvanilla,andcashmeremusk
fragrancesenrichedwithvitaminE,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblier
experience

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H22:SelectNewPersonalCleansingProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

CashmereGlowGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystalswhichexfoliatesandconditionswiththe
apricotandsweetalmondoils.Itsfragranceisablendofgoldenpeach,shimmeringvanilla,andcashmere
muskandcomesinaeasytousesqueezetube

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ParisAmourCreamyBodyWashisenrichedwithTripleMoistureComplexofmilkproteins,ricebranoil,
berryextracts,andsheabutterforahydratingwash.Itsfragranceisablendoffrenchtulips,apple
blossoms,andpinkchampagne

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ParisAmourBubbleBathisavitaminenrichedbubblebathwithafragranceblendoffrenchtulips,apple
blossoms,andpinkchampagne

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ParisAmourGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystalswhichexfoliatesandconditionswithapricotand
sweetalmondoils.Itsfragranceisablendoffrenchtulips,appleblossoms,andpinkchampagne

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ParisAmourShowerGelisablendoffrenchtulips,appleblossoms,andpinkchampagnefragrances
enrichedwithvitaminE,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblierexperience.Itis
availableinatravelsizeaswell

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ParisAmourPocketbacSanitizingHandGelispocketsizedgermkillerenrichedwithTahitianpalmmilkto
givethehandsaconditioningfeel.Itisscentedwithfrenchtulips,appleblossoms,andpinkchampagne

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ForeverRedGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystalswhichexfoliatesandconditionswiththeapricot
andsweetalmondoils.Itsfragranceisablendofpomegranate,redosmanthus,andvanillarum

LimitedBrands

Bath&Body
Works

ForeverRedShowerGelisablendofpomegranate,redosmanthus,andvanillarumenrichedwithvitamin
E,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblierexperience

Lornamead

Yardley

SkinIndulgenceLavender&RosemarySkinSoothingBath&ShowerGelisablendoflavenderoiland
rosemaryextractthatwashesawaydirtleavingtheskinsoftandsmooth

Lornamead

Yardley

SkinIndulgenceMango&CreamBodyButterCleansingBarisblendofmango,avocado,andolivebutter
whichproducesfoaminglathertogiveanenergizedexperience.

Lornamead

Yardley

SkinIndulgenceMango&LilySkinSofteningBath&ShowerGelisablendofmangobutterandcalendula
extracttogivetheskinaclean,fresh,andhydratedappearance

Lornamead

Yardley

SkinIndulgenceSeaMineralsisinfusedwithseakelpandnaturalexfoliantsandafreshbergamotand
limescenttomoisturize,exfoliate,andgivetheskinatonedlook.Itisavailableintwovariants:Scrub&
SmoothBathBarandSkinSmoothingBath&ShowerGel

Procter&
Gamble

Gillette

OdorShieldAllDayCleanBodyWashisformulatedtofightodorandwetnessinadditiontothebasic
cleansingfunction

TheClorox
Company

Gd

NaturalBodyWashwithitsfrothyfoamisavailableinfivevariants:RedRubyGroovy,PearnormalActivity,
OrangePetalooza,FloralCherrynova,andVanillaFlame

Unilever

Caress

EndlessKissSilkeningBodyWashisenrichedwithmoisturebeadsandcontainsthescentofVanillaand
Sandalwood

Unilever

Caress

PassionateSpellFineFragranceElixirBodyWashisinfusedwiththescentofpassionfruitandfieryorange
rosetoleavealingeringfragrance

Unilever

Caress

SheerTwilightFineFragranceElixirBodyWashisscentedwithblackorchidandjuniperoil

Unilever

DoveMen+Care

CleanDefenseBody&FaceWashwithMicromoistureTechnologygetsactivatedonceincontactwiththe
skintoremoveoilbuildupandmaintaintheskinsmoisturelevels

Unilever

DoveMen+Care

FreshAwakeBody&FaceWashwithMicromoistureTechnologygetsactivatedonceincontactwiththe
skinandisclinicallyproventofightskindryness

Unilever

Suave

EverlastingSunshineBodyWashisenrichedwithvitaminEandthescentofpassionflowerandvanilla

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H55

4H56

PersonalCleansingProducts

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Overall

Body washes is the largest product type, representing onethird of the categorys sales in
2012.
Bar soaps is the secondlargest product type, accounting for 31.5% of the personal
cleansingproductscategorysalesin2012.
Liquidsoapsandbodywashesrecordthehighestgainsof4.8%and3.4%,respectively.
Salesofantibacterialhandgelsremainstagnantat$150million,flatfrom2011levels.

Table4H23:ManufacturersSalesandGrowthofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesby
ProductType,2011and2012
$Million

%Oftotal

Producttype

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Bodywashesr

1,310

1,354

33.5

33.6

3.4

Barsoapsr

1,239

1,268

31.7

31.5

2.3

Bathadditives

620

638

15.9

15.8

2.9

Liquidsoapsr

588

616

15.0

15.3

4.8

Antibacterialhandgelsr

150

150

3.8

3.7

3,907

4,026

100.0

100.0

3.0

Totalr

rRestated.

Bodywashes

Since 2007, sales of the body washes segment have grown at a CAGR of 6.0% to
$1,354millionin2012.

Table4H24:HistoricalSalesofBodyWashesProducts
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

1,011

2008

1,057

4.5

2009

1,096

3.7

2010

1,225

11.8

2011

1,310

6.9

2012

1,354

3.4

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

PersonalCleansingProducts

In2012,salesofbodywashescontinuetoregisterasalesincrease.
Sales of body washes advance 3.4% to reach $1,354million in 2012, up from
$1,310millionin2011.
Bodywashescontinuetobethekeydriverbehindthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Bodywashesaccountfor33.6%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfrom33.5%in
2011.
The body washes segment which had stirred up sales in 2010 and 2011 due to
improved formulations, affordable prices, and adding newness to the category, slow
downin2012asthemarketbecomesfullypenetrated.Manyconsumersnowusebody
washesinconjunctionwithbarsoapsasapartoftheirdailypersonalcleansingregimen.
Marketers continue to introduce body washes enriched with natural ingredients with
moisturizingandcleansingformulations.
Marketers emphasize the use of natural and organic ingredients in their product
labelingandformulationstodrivegrowthinthematurecategory.
New and innovative products are introduced which not only focus on providing
cleansingbenefitsbutotheradditionalbenefits,suchasmoisturizingandexfoliation.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolive introduces the Irish Spring Deep Action Scrub Body Wash
enrichedwithcelticrockwhichhelpsexfoliatetheskin.
There are a variety of body washes available in the market that provide moisturizing
and exfoliating benefits with the presence of natural ingredients. A few examples of
theseincludeBurtsBeesradianceExfoliatingBodyWash,St.IvesHydratingVitaminE
Body Wash, Doves Deep Moisture Body Wash with NutriumMoisture, and Doves
TouchofHoneyDewHydratingShowerGel.
Mainstreambrandscontinuetoexpandtheirrangeofproductlinestointroducemale
centricbodywashesformulatedwithadvancedtechnology.Thisaidsthemainstream
brands to add some dynamism to the category thereby helping drive the categorys
sales.SomeofthecommonlyavailablemalecentricbrandsinthesegmentincludeAxe,
DoveMen+Care,Gillette,IrishSpring,andOldSpice.
In2012,HenkelintroducestheDialGoldAntibacterialRoundTheClockOdorProtection
DeodorizingBodyWash.
Marketers introduce multifunctional body washes which also serve the purpose of a
face wash, shampoo, and even as a bath additive. These products gain increasing
demand,especiallyfrommaleconsumers.
The trend among marketers to continue to innovate with fragrances in the body
washessegmentgainspopularityasmarketersaimtoreachouttoawidersectionof
thesocietywiththeirdiverserangeofvariants.In2012,LornameadintroducestheSkin
Indulgence Lavender & Rosemary Skin Soothing Bath & Shower Gel, Skin Indulgence
Mango&LilySkinSofteningBath&ShowerGel,andSkinIndulgenceSeaMineralsSkin
SmoothingBath&ShowerGel.
Thebodywashessegmentprovidesanopportunityformarketerstoinnovatewiththe
packaging by changing the shape and size of the bottles with creative and colorful
graphicsonthelabel,toattractattention.Marketersalsousepackagingasameansto
differentiatebetweentheirvariousproductlines.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H57

4H58

PersonalCleansingProducts

Theliquidformatofthebodywashesgivethemanedgeoverthetraditionalbarsoaps
duetotheconvenientformatandhygienicuseofbodywashes.Barsoapsareexposed
toenvironmentalfactors,suchasair,water,dust,andgermswhilebodywashesstay
more hygienic, packaged in bottles with either a pump disposer or a nozzle for the
contentstobesqueezedout.
Marketersbenefitfromconsumerstradinguptobodywashesfrombarsoapsdueto
thebodywasheshighpricepoints.
ThesegmentattractsasubstantialamountofthemarketersTME,helpingitmaintain
consumersinterestandinducespurchasing.

Unilevercontinuestobethelargestmarketerinthebodywashessegmentin2012.
Thecompanyssalesinthebodywashessegmentgrow3.7%to$538millionin2012,
upfrom$519millionin2011.
Unilevers segment share increases marginally to 39.7% in 2012, up from 39.6% of
segmentsalesin2011.
Unilever markets its Dove, Suave, Axe, Caress, St. Ives, and Lever 2000 brands in the
segment.
The marketers growth is driven by the good performance of its Dove, Suave, and
Caressbrands,andalsonewproductactivityin2012.
DoveisUnileversflagshipbrandandalsotheleadingbrandinthecategory,withsales
at$214millionin2012,up5.9%from$202millionin2011.Doverepresents39.8%of
Unileverstotalbodywashessalesin2012.
Dovesgrowthin2012isattributedtothesignificantTMEfromUnilever.Themarketer
allocatesaTMEof$63milliontothebrandin2012.
The Dove Deep Moisture Body Wash receives the maximum TME at $41.6 million in
2012. The Dove Deep Moisture Body Wash is enriched with a proprietary ingredient
NutriumMoisture, which claims to provide effective moisturization, to nourish skin
deepdown.
TheDoveVisibleCarelineofbodywashesreceivesaTMEof$13.9millionin2012.The
line has two variants: Visible Care Replenishing Crme Body Wash and Visible Care
ToningCrmeBodyWash.
Dove also benefits from its Men+Care line of products which claim to contain one
fourthmoisturizinglotion.
In 2012, Dove Men+Cares line of body and face washes is launched with two more
variants,FreshAwakeandCleanDefense.
SuaveisthesecondleadingbrandforUnilever,withsalesat$133millionin2012,up
3.1%from$129millionin2011.
Sales growth for the brand is aided by its natural positioning in the market with
variants available in nine different fragrances, the newest addition being Everlasting
Sunshine,a2012launch.Furthergrowthisduetoitsbrandloyaltyamongconsumers
anditseasyavailabilityacrossdifferentretailoutlets.
Sales of Axe, the thirdlargest brand for the company, decline 1.3% to $79 million in
2012 from $80million in 2011. The brand represents 5.8% of body washes sales in
2012,downfrom6.1%ofsegmentsalesin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

PersonalCleansingProducts

In 2012, Unilever unleashes an online advertisement campaign for its Axe brand that
urgescollegestudentstoshowerwithafriendoranattractivestrangerinanattempt
toconservewater.Themarketercoinsthetermshowerpoolingforitscampaign.The
Showerpoolingcampaignencouragessustainablelivingroutinewithatouchoffuntoit.
The marketer introduces a few videos, with some featuring brand ambassador and
actress, Nicki Reed as the narrator. The brand also distributes 7,000 waterefficient
DeltashowerheadswithH20KinteticTechnologyduringitscampustouranddonates
$100,000 to the Alliance for Water Efficiency, a nonprofit organization dedicated to
theefficientandsustainableuseofwater.
In 2012, sales of Caress advance 13.1% to reach $69 million in 2012, up from
$61millionin2011.
In 2012, Caress Body Washes receive a TME of $4.3 million. The brand allocates
$2.9milliontowardsthepromotionofthenewEndlessKissSilkeningBodyWashand
thenewPassionateSpellFineFragranceElixirBodyWash.
In 2012, Caress teams up with celebrity and style experts, June Ambrose and Lilliana
Vazquez, to start a campaign called "Caress Fabulistas. The "Caress Fabulistas help
women find and flaunt the seasons fashion trends by providing them beauty secrets
and style tips that inspire women to look good. Women also get a chance to have a
look at the behindthescenes happenings of the Caress Fabulistas on the brands
Facebook page. The brand also persuades women to upload a picture of themselves
flauntingaFabulistalooktogetachancetowinadailygiftcertificate.

SalesofProcter&Gamble,thesecondlargestmarketerinthebodywashessegment,are
$251millionin2012,up3.3%from$243millionin2011.
Themarketersshareinthecategoryremainsstableat18.5%in2012,constant from
2011levels.
Procter& Gamble is wellpositioned in the segment with its leading brands Olay and
OldSpice.TheotherminorofferingsincludeGilletteandIvory.
Olayistheleadingbrandforthemarketerinthebodywashessegmentin2012,with
salesat$110million,up8.9%from$101millionin2011.Olayisamasstigebrandand
manyconsumerswhoarewillingtotradeupfromthebasicmassbrandsbutnotallthe
waytoluxurybrands,preferOlaysproducts.
InspiteofOlaysmoreexpensivepositioningofitsbodywashesincomparisontothe
productsofothermassbrands,thebrandperformswell.
SalesofOldSpiceadvance1.0%to$105millionin2012,upfrom$104millionin2011.

Barsoaps

Since2007,salesofthebarsoapssegmentgrowatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of0.4%toreach$1,268millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H59

4H60

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H25:HistoricalSalesofBarSoapsProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

1,242

2008

1,258

1.3

2009

1,272

1.1

2010

1,229

(3.4)

2011

1,239

0.8

2012

1,268

2.3

rRestated.

Bar soaps continues to be the secondlargest segment in the personal cleansing products
categoryin2012.
Salesofthesegmenttotal$1,268millionin2012,up2.3%from$1,239millionin2011.
Barsoapsrepresent31.5%ofthecategorysalesin2012,marginallydownfrom31.7%
ofcategorysalesin2011;unitsalesofbarsoapsaccountsforalittlelessthanhalfof
thetotalcategorysvolumesalesin2012.
The bar soaps segment comprises the highest number of brands competing in the
category.
The segment is challenged with stiff competition from alternative products in the
category, such as body washes. More consumers are trading up to the body washes
and bath additives for a better bathing experience and to gain advantage from the
multifunctionalbenefitsoftheseproducts,whichactasashampoo,bodywashandin
somecasesformen,asafacewashtoo.
Since bar soaps are commodity products, they experience stiff competition to retain
theirsales.
Additionally, the mature segment is challenged by the limited scope for innovation.
There is not much that marketers are doing in this segment except expand their
product lines with variants in fragrances and infusing them with beneficial natural
ingredients, such as vitamins, moisturizers, antibacterial components, botanicals, and
othervalueaddedingredients.
A few of the vitaminenriched bar soaps available in the market include Dial Natural
RadianceandToneCocoaButterBathBar.
Barsoapsareperceivedbymanyconsumersasproductsusedforbasiccleansingneeds,
leading to consumers shifting to less expensive privatelabel products which offer
similarbenefits.
Moreover, marketers utilize promotional tools, such as multipack offers, to promote
thesalesoftheirbarsoaps,therebyresultinginthedeclineinrevenueperunit.
However, further decline in sales in the segment is counterbalanced by the
introductionofthenaturallypositionedproductswhichhaveagrowingreputationof
beinggentleontheskinandsuitableforbuyerswithsensitiveskin.
Also,asegmentofconsumersarestillloyaltousingbarsoapsfortheirdailypersonal
hygieneregimen.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

PersonalCleansingProducts

Unilevercontinuestobetheleadingmarketerofbarsoaps,aheadofProcter&Gambleand
Henkel.
Salesadvance4.4%toreach$592millionin2012,upfrom$567millionin2011.
Inthebarsoapssegment,UnilevermarketsitsDove,Lever2000,andCaressbrands.
Unileversshareinthesegmentadvancestoaccountfor46.7%oftotalsegmentsales
in2012,up from45.8%in 2011.Theshareofthemarketerinthecategoryimproves
duetothepositiveperformanceofDove.
Doveremainstheleadingbrandinthebarsoapssegment,withsalesat$466millionin
2012,up5.9%from$440millionin2011.Thebrandsshareinthesegmentimproves
from35.5%ofthetotalsegmentssalesin2011to36.8%in2012.
Unilever continues to support Dove with a traceable media expenditures (TME) of
$21millionin2012.
Thebrandalsobenefitsfromitsloyalconsumerbasein2012.
Furthermore,Dovespromiseofusing1/4proportionasmoisturizingcreaminitsbar
soapshelpsdrivesalesforthemarketer.ThisgivesconsumersasatisfactionthatDove
barsoapsnotonlyprovidecleansingbenefitsbutalsonourishandmoisturizetheskin
simultaneously.
Dove also benefits from its Men+Care line of products which claim to contain one
fourthmoisturizinglotionandareavailableasbodywashesandbodybars.
Dove claims that its body and face wash variants are infused with Micromoisture
Technology that helps prevent skin dryness by replenishing the moisture levels. The
micromoistureioninthebodyandfacewashvariantsgetactivatedontheformation
oflatherandpreventanydiscomfortduetowoundandcuts.
In2012,DoveMen+Careslineofbodyandfacewashesisextendedbytheintroduction
oftwomorevariants:FreshAwakeandCleanDefense.
Doves Beauty Bar receives a TME of $18.3 million while Dove Men+Care Bar Soaps
receiveaTMEof$2.7millionin2012.
Sales of Caress, the companys secondleading brand, remain stagnant in 2012 at
$68million,flatfrom2011levels.
In2012,CaressMoisturizingBodyBarsreceiveanegligibleTME.
In 2012, sales of Lever 2000 decline 1.7% from $59 million in 2011 to $58 million in
2012.Lever2000hasnoTMEin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H61

4H62

PersonalCleansingProducts

Withsalesat$194millionin2012,Henkelisthedistantsecondleadingmarketerinthebar
soapssegment.
SalesofHenkelbarsoapsdecline2.5%from$198millionin2011.
The marketers share in the segments sales decline from 16.0% in 2011 to 15.3% in
2012.
In 2012, Henkel divests its brand Coast to Brynwood Partners subsidiary High Ridge
Brands,therebynegativelyaffectingitsmarketshare.ThesaleofCoastcontributesto
Henkelsdecliningsalesinthissegment.
HenkelispresentinthebarsoapssegmentwithitsDialandTonebrands.
Dial is the marketers flagship brand, with sales at $184million in 2012, down 2.1%
from $188million in 2011. Dial represents 94.8% of Henkels total bar soaps sales in
2012.
SalesofToneremainflatat$10millionin2012,from2011levels.
The lack of new product activity, product innovation, and insufficient advertising
support to its bar soaps segment makes it difficult for the marketer to register sales
growthin2012.

Procter&Gambleisthethirdlargestmarketerinthebarsoapssegmentwith10.2%oftotal
barsoapssalesin2012,downfrom10.9%in2011.
Sales of Procter & Gamble bar soaps decline 4.4% from $135million in 2011 to
$129millionin2012.
Procter&Gamblecompeteswithfourbrandsinthesegment:Olay,Ivory,Safeguard,
andCamay.
Olay is Procter & Gambles flagship brand in the bar soaps segment, with its sales
declining4.8%from$63millionin2011to$60millionin2012.Thebrandssalesinthe
segmentdeclineasaresultofthelackofthebrandsabilitytointroducenewproducts
orinnovatewithformulations.SalesofIvorydecline3.8%in2012to$51million,from
$53millionin2011.
Safeguard, the thirdlargest brand for the company in the bar soaps segment, also
postsdecliningsalesat$16millionin2012,down5.9%from$17millionin2011.
SalesofCamayremainstagnantat$2millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.

Bathadditives

Since2007,historicalsalesofthebathadditivessegmenthavegrownataCAGRof2.0%to
$638millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H26:HistoricalSalesofBathAdditivesProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007r

579

2008r

586

1.2

2009r

589

0.5

2010r

598

1.5

2011

620

3.7

2012

638

2.9

rRestated.

The personal cleansing products category covers only adult and childrens bath additives.
Infantbathadditivesarecoveredseparatelyinthebabycarecategoryofthisreport.

Salesofthesegmentadvance2.9%to$638millionin2012,upfrom$620millionin2011.
ThecategoryisdominatedbyLimitedBrands,withsalesat$262millionin2012.Sales
advance 6.5% from $246million in 2011. Limited Brands represents 41.1% of total
segmentssalesin2012,upfrom39.7%oftotalsegmentsalesin2011.
AvonandJohnson&Johnsonfollowasthesecondandthirdleadingmarketersinthe
segment, respectively. Avons sales total $78million in 2012, declining 10.3% from
$87millionin2011.Johnson&Johnsonssalestotal$39millionin2012,up2.6%from
$38millionin2011.
Bathadditivesareaneconomicalalternativetotheexpensiveservicesatprofessional
spas. As consumers shift towards more doityourself (DIY) options, bath additives
claimingtoprovideathomealternativesareahitamongthem.
Further growth in the segment is offset due to limited new product activity in the
segment.

Liquidsoaps

Since2007,salesofliquidsoapshavegrownataCAGRof2.8%to$616millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H63

4H64

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H27:HistoricalSalesofLiquidSoapsProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

536

2008

544

1.5

2009

570

4.8

2010

565

(0.9)

2011

588

4.1

2012

616

4.8

rRestated.

Salesofliquidsoapsgrowsignificantlyto$616millionin2012,up4.8%from$588millionin
2011.
Liquid soaps represent 15.3% of total category sales in 2012, up from 15.0% of total
categoryssalesin2011.
Ashiftindemandfrombarsoapstoliquidsoaps,isevidentbythehighsalesgrowthof
thesegment.
Thedesireformorehygienichandsoapleadsconsumerstooptforliquidsoapsover
barsoapsforhandwashing.
Furthermore, the liquid soap has the advantage over bar soap of not leaving soap
residueinasoapdish,sothereisnocleanuprequiredwhileusingtheliquidformat.
The promise of moisturizing benefits, exotic or seasonal scents, and attractive
packagingalsocontributetothegrowthofthissegment.

ColgatePalmoliveistheleadingmarketerofliquidsoapsin2012,withsalesat$215million.
ColgatePalmolivessegmentsharedeclinesfrom35.5%ofthetotalsegmentssalesin
2011to34.9%in2012.
ColgatePalmolive competes with its Softsoap brand, the leading brand in the liquid
soapssegment.
Sales of the brand advance 2.9% from $209million in 2011 to reach $215million in
2012.
Newproductactivityandbrandloyaltyfromconsumersplaysanimportantroleinthe
brandsgrowthin2012.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolive introduces the Softsoap Pampered Hands Coconut Lime
LiquidHandSoapandthelineofAntibacterialHandSoapwithMoisturizersavailablein
twovariants:CrispCleanandFreshCitrus.
ColgatePalmolivesupportsitsSoftsoapbrandwithaTMEof$281,600in2012,upfrom
172,700in2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

PersonalCleansingProducts

Henkelregainsitspositionasthesecondleadingmarketerintheliquidsoapssegmentwith
salesadvancingsignificantlytodisplaceLimitedBrands.
Salesincrease13.6%to$92millionin2012,upfrom$81millionin2011.
Henkel represents 14.9% of the total segment sales in 2012, up from 13.8% of the
segmentsharein2011.
HenkelspresenceinthesegmentisthroughitsDialbrand.
SalesofDialin2012aredrivenbytheintroductionoftheNaturalsTangerine&Guava
Moisturizing Liquid Hand Soap and the Hello Kitty line of products comprising an
AntibacterialFoamingHandWash.
FurthersalesgrowthforDialisrestrictedduetolimitedadvertisingsupportin2012.

LimitedBrandsisthethirdleadingmarketerinthesegmentin2012.
Salesgrow7.7%to$84millionin2012,upfrom$78millionin2011.
LimitedBrandsaccountsfor13.6%ofsegmentsalesin2012,upfrom13.3%ofsegment
salesin2011.
LimitedBrandsloyalconsumerbaseaidsinthegrowthofBath&BodyWorksin2012.
Strategically designed marketing campaigns, attractive bright colored packaging with
trendy names, strong promotions, and availability of many variants in product lines
contributetothesuccessfulperformanceofthebrandin2012.

Sales of privatelabel products grow a mere 0.7% to $146million in 2012, up from


$145millionin2011.
Privatelabel products continue to gain distribution in 2012 across different retail
outletstosupporttheirmarginalsalesgrowth.
However, growth is offset as consumers are no longer purchasing privatelabel liquid
soapsinthemagnitudethattheywereduringtherecession.

Antibacterialhandgels

Since2007,salesoftheantibacterialhandgelssegmenthavegrownataCAGRof14.0%to
$150millionin2012.

Table4H28:HistoricalSalesofAntibacterialHandGel
ProductsintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

2007

78

2008

86

10.3

2009

137

59.3

2010

164

19.7

2011

150

(8.5)

2012

rRestated.

150

Change,%

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H65

4H66

PersonalCleansingProducts

Sales in the antibacterial hand gels segment remain stagnant at $150 million in 2012,
constantfrom2011levels.
Antibacterial hand gels represent 3.7% of total categorys sales in 2012, down from
3.8%in2011.
Consumers benefits from the convenience of not needing water to wash their hands
whileonthego.
Thesegmentsgrowthin2009and2010hadbeendrivenbythehighlevelsofconcern
about health pandemics and epidemics. However, when such phenomena subside
periodically,itcanbeexpectedthatsaleswillstabilizeatmoresustainablelevels.
Theincidenceofswinefluhadsparkedthesignificantriseinthesalesofantibacterial
handgelsin2009and2010.
However,withnosuchthreatlurkingaround,saleshavebeennegativelyaffected.
Additionally, consumers are also challenged by the dryness caused to the skin upon
usageoftheseantibacterialhandgelswhichcontainalcoholincertainproportions.This
has led consumers to adopt the traditional means of using liquid hand soaps or bar
soapstokeeptheirhandsclean.

LimitedBrands,withitsBath&BodyWorksbrand,istheleadingmarketerinthesegmentin
2012.
Salestotal$44million,up7.3%from$41millionin2011.
LimitedBrandsrepresents29.3%ofsegmentssalesin2012,upfrom27.3%in2011.
Themarketersgrowthinthesegmentissupportedbythepositiveperformanceofthe
pocketbacs sanitizing hand gels range available in a variety of fragrances, such as
BerrySangria,FreshPickedTangerines,Bubblegum,andAlohaOrchid.

WithitsPurellbrand,GojoIndustriesisthesecondlargestmarketerinthesegment.
SalesofPurelltotal$40millionin2012,up2.6%from$39millionin2011.
Purellaccountsfor26.7%ofthesegmentssalesin2012,upfrom26.0%in2011.
In2012,GojoIndustriesreleasesacorporatestatementdeclaringthatnoneofitshand
sanitizerscontaintriclosan.
In2012,GojoIndustriesintroducesthePurellAdvancedHandSanitizerclaimingthatits
productismoreeffectivethananyotherhandsanitizerinthemarketasitistheonly
product in the market to meet the FDA germ kill requirements with a single 1.2 ml
dispense.
The brand receives a TME of $3.4 million in 2012, up from $1.1 million in 2011. The
marketerssanitizersareavailableasgels,foam,orwipes.

Privatelabelproductssalesdecline2.0%to$50millionin2012,downfrom$51millionin
2011.
Privatelabel products represent 33.3% of the segments sales in 2012, down from
34.0%in2011.Privatelabelsalescontinuetodominatethesegmentin2012.
Thesalesoftheseproductscontinuetodeclinein2012afterthehighgrowthin2009
and2010asaresultoftheH1N1virusscare.
Demand reduces in 2012, as many consumers forego the use of these products on a
regularbasis.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

PersonalCleansingProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4H29:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbySegment
andCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Segment/company

2011

ANTIBACTERIALHANDGELS

2012

%Ofsegment

2011

2012

LimitedBrands

41

44

27.3

29.3

GojoIndustries

39

40

26.0

26.7

ViJohnLaboratories

5.3

4.0

Henkel

2.0

1.3

51

50

34.0

33.3

5.3

5.3

150

150

100.0

100.0

BARSOAPS

Unileverr

567

592

45.8

46.7

Henkelr

198

194

16.0

15.3

Procter&Gamble

135

129

10.9

10.2

ColgatePalmoliver

117

127

9.4

10.0

23

24

1.9

1.9

199

202

16.1

15.9

1,239

1,268

100.0

100.0

Unileverr

519

538

39.6

39.7

Procter&Gambler

243

251

18.5

18.5

Henkelr

139

142

10.6

10.5

ColgatePalmoliver

122

122

9.3

9.0

89

95

6.8

7.0

198

206

15.1

15.2

1,310

1,354

100.0

100.0

BATHADDITIVES

LimitedBrands

246

262

39.7

41.1

Avon

87

78

14.0

12.2

Johnson&Johnson

38

39

6.1

6.1

Privatelabel
Allotherr
Totalr

Privatelabel
Allotherr
Totalr
BODYWASHES

Privatelabel
Allotherr
Totalr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H67

4H68

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H29:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnitedStatesbySegment
andCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Segment/company

2011

2012

2011

TheCloroxCompany

35

37

5.6

5.8

Privatelabel

22

23

3.5

3.6

Allother

192

199

31.0

31.2

Total

620

638

100.0

100.0

209

215

35.5

34.9

Henkelr

81

92

13.8

14.9

LimitedBrands

78

84

13.3

13.6

145

146

24.7

23.7

75

79

12.8

12.8

588

616

100.0

100.0

1,090

1,134

27.9

28.2

ColgatePalmoliver

448

464

11.5

11.5

Henkelr

421

430

10.8

10.7

LimitedBrands

383

409

9.8

10.2

Procter&Gambler

385

385

9.9

9.6

Johnson&Johnsonr

115

115

2.9

2.9

Privatelabel

330

338

8.4

8.4

Allother

735

751

18.8

18.7

3,907

4,026

100.0

100.0

BATHADDITIVES(Continued)

LIQUIDSOAPS
ColgatePalmolive

Privatelabel
Allotherr
Totalr
COMPANYTOTALS
Unileverr

Total

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

%Ofsegment

2012

PersonalCleansingProducts

Unilevercontinuestobethelargestmarketerofpersonalcleansingproductswith28.2%of
thetotalcategoryssalesin2012.
Salesofthemarketergrow4.0%to$1,134millionin2012,from$1,090millionin2011.
Themarketerimprovesitscategorysharefrom27.9%oftotalcategorysalesin2011to
28.2%in2012.
Unilevercontinuestodominatethebarsoapsandthebodywashessegmentsin2012,
withadistinctlead.
Bar soaps is the largest segment for the marketer representing 52.2% of Unilevers
totalcategorysalesin2012.
Bodywashes,thesecondleadingsegmentforthemarketer,accountsfor47.4%ofthe
marketerssalesin2012.
Sales for the marketer is supported by a varied product portfolio, moderate new
productintroductions,andaconsiderableTMEof$85.2millionin2012.
Doveistheleadingbrandforthemarketerwithsalesup5.9%to$680millionin2012,
from$642millionin2011.
Dove continues to hold leadership positions in the bar soaps and body washes
segments.
Growthofthebrandissupportedbynewproductsintroductionsin2012,especiallyin
thebodywashessegment.
TheDovemensline,DoveMen+Careconnectswellwiththemaleconsumerandaids
inthebrandsgrowthin2012.
Dovealsoenjoysaloyalcustomerbaseandgoodadvertisingsupportin2012.
DoveisallocatedaTMEof$64.5millionin2012.

ColgatePalmoliveisthedistantsecondleadingmarketerinthecategory,with11.5%ofthe
totalcategoryssalesin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Salestotal$464millionin2012,up3.6%from$448millionin2011.
Themarketercompetesintheliquidsoaps,barsoaps,andbodywashessegments.
ThemarketerisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsSoftsoap,IrishSpring,Palmolive,
andTomsofMainebrands.
ColgatePalmolive is the leading marketer in the liquid soaps segment and fourth
largestmarketerinthebodywashesandbarsoapssegmentsduring2012.
Theliquidsoapssegmentrepresents46.3%ofthetotalmarketerssalesinthepersonal
cleansing products category in 2012. Sales of the marketer in the segment increase
2.9%from$209millionin2011to$215millionin2012.
Growthofthemarketerisdrivenbynewproductintroductionsandgoodperformance
intheliquidsoapssegmentin2012.
The bar soaps segment of the marketer witnesses the highest growth in sales during
2012.Salesadvance8.5%to$127millionin2012,upfrom$117millionin2011.
Sales of the marketer in the body washes segment remain stable at $122 million in
2012,flatfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H69

4H70

PersonalCleansingProducts

Henkelisthethirdleadingmarketerinthecategoryin2012.
Themarketerssalesadvance2.1%in2012,from$421millionin2011to$430million
in2012.
HenkelisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsDialandTonebrands.
Henkel is the secondleading marketer in the bar soaps and liquid soaps segments,
thirdleadingmarketerinthebodywashessegment,andthefourthleadingmarketerin
theantibacterialhandgelssegment.
Bar soaps is the biggest segment for the marketer accounting for 45.1% of the
companys total sales in 2012, though sales in the segment decline 2.9% from
$198millionin2011to$194millionin2012.
Thelackofnewproductintroduction,packagingchange,orformulationchangehasa
negativeimpactonthesalesofthecompanyinthebarsoapssegment.
BodywashesisthesecondleadingsegmentforHenkel,up2.2%to$142millionin2012
from$139millionin2011.
In 2012, the marketer introduces the Dial Gold Antibacterial Round The Clock Odor
ProtectionDeodorizingBodyWashandtheHelloKittyMoisturizingBodyWash.
Intheliquidsoapssegment,salesofHenkelamountto$92millionin2012,up13.3%
from$81millionin2011.Growthofthebrandin2012isattributedtotheintroduction
of new products, such as Natural Tangerine & Guava Moisturizing Liquid Hand Soap
andHelloKittyAntibacterialFoamingHandWash.
In2012,DialisallocatedaTMEof$2.9millionwhileTonereceivesaTMEof$55,800.
In2012,HenkelsTonebrandpartnerswithcountrysingerKerryPicklertopromotethe
newToneFruitPeelBodyWash.

BehindHenkelinthefourthleadingpositionisLimitedBrandswithsalesat$409millionin
2012,up6.8%from$383millionin2011.
MarketshareofLimitedBrandsimprovesfrom9.8%ofthecategoryssalesin2011to
10.2%in2012.
Limited Brands is the leading marketer in the bath additives segment, with sales at
$262millionin2012,up6.5%from$246millionin2011.
LimitedBrandsfindspresenceinthebathadditivessegmentwithBath&BodyWorks
andVictoriasSecretGardenbrands.
LimitedBrandsisalsotheleadingmarketerintheantibacterialhandgelssegmentwith
salesat$44millionin2012,up7.3%from$41millionin2011.
ThemarketerispresentinthesegmentwithitsBath&BodyWorksbrand.
Limited Brands slides down to become the thirdleading marketer in the liquid soaps
segment, accounting for 20.5% of the marketers sales in 2012, marginally up from
20.4%in2011.
Duetostableeconomicconditions,thepurchasingcapacityinthehandsofconsumers
improves,resultinginmanyconsumersgoingbacktousinghighendspecialtyproducts
ofbrands,suchasBath&BodyWorks.
In2012,themarketersintroducesarangeofproductsforitsBath&BodyWorksbrand
including Pink Chiffon Pocketbac Sanitizing Hand Gel, Pink Chiffon Shower Gel,
CashmereGlowShowerGel,CashmereGlowGoldenSugarScrub,ParisAmourCreamy
Body Wash, Paris Amour Bubble Bath, Paris Amour Golden Sugar Scrub, Paris Amour
ShowerGel,PocketbacSanitizingHandGel,ForeverRedShowerGel,andForeverRed
GoldenSugarScrub.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

PersonalCleansingProducts

In 2012, sales of Procter & Gamble remain stable at $385 million in 2012, flat from 2011
levels.
The marketer is present in the category with its Olay, Old Spice, Ivory, Gillette,
Safeguard,Camay,andKandoobrands.
Bodywashesisthelargestsegmentforthemarketerin2012,andisthesecondleading
marketerinthebodywashessegment,accountingfor18.5%ofthesegmentssalesin
2012. The marketers sales in the segment total $251 million in 2012, up 3.3% from
$243millionin2011.
Procter&Gambleisthethirdlargestmarketerinthebarsoapssegment,representing
33.5%ofthemarketerssalesin2012,downfrom35.1%ofthemarketerssalesin2011.
Thedeclineinthemarketersshareinthesegmentisduetothepoorperformanceof
Olay,Ivory,andSafeguard.
The marketers decline in sales in the bar soaps segment is because TME declines
approximately 70.0% from $114.1 million in 2011, to $40.0million in 2012. The
marketer experiences a considerable decline in sales for its Old Spice and Gillette
brands.

Privatelabel

Salesofprivatelabelproductsadvance2.4%in2012.
Salestotal$338millionin2012,upfrom$330millionin2011.
Privatelabel products register high growth in segments such as body washes, bath
additives,andbarsoaps.
Thegrowthofprivatelabelproductsinspiteoftheeconomicrecoveryisanindication
ofconsumersincreasingconfidenceinthequalityoflowpricedproducts.
Liquid soaps and body washes are the top two competing segments for privatelabel
products,collectivelyrepresenting71.3%oftheirproductsalesinthecategoryin2012,
upfrom70.9%oftheirproductsalesin2011.
Overtheyears,privatelabelshavebeenabletoimprovethequalityoftheirofferings
andgainarespectableplaceinconsumersopinion.
Additionally, support from the retailers has had an influential impact on the sales
growthofprivatelabelproductsinthecategory.
Overallprivatelabelproductsrepresent8.4%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,flat
from2011levels.

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Mass merchandisers continue to dominate the category, with 43% of total retail sales in
2012,similartotheircategorysharein2011.
Massmerchandisersareabletomaintaintheirshareinthecategoryonthebasisofthe
competitivepricesthattheyoffertobuyers.This,incombination,withawidevariety
ofproductofferingsunderasingleroofmakesmassmerchandisersapopularshopping
spotforpersonalcleansingproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H71

4H72

PersonalCleansingProducts

Drugstoresarealsopopularoutletstopurchasepersonalcleansingproductsandareableto
maintaintheirshareinthecategoryin2012.
The leading drug store chains continue to offer heavy promotions and improve the
shoppingenvironmentforamorepleasantretailexperience.

Privatelabelproductsseeapushfrommassmerchandisersanddrugstores,withprivate
labelproductsbeingplacednexttobrandsoftheestablishedmarketers.
Forexample,CVShasitsownprivatelabelbodywashes,includingtheCVSRefreshing
BodyWashandCVSMoisture&RefreshingBodyWash.

Table4H30:ManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansing
ProductsintheUnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

43

43

Foodstores

27

27

Specialtystores

12

12

Drugstores

10

10

Directsales

Departmentstores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Unilever and Procter & Gamble continue to dominate the personal cleansing products
categoryin2012.
Print media, electronic media, sampling, and coupons are the most popular
promotionaltoolsadoptedbymarketersinthecategory.
Since majority of the personal cleansing products are mass offerings, the two most
popularchannelsofadvertisingadoptedbymarketersaremagazinesandtelevision.
Magazines represent $54.4 million or 45.2% of the total categorys TME while
television advertisements represent $50.6million or 43.2% of total category TME in
2012.
TheInternetaccountsfor$4.8millionor4.0%ofthetotalcategorysTMEin2012.
MarketersareprogressivelyutilizingtheInternetandmobilemarketingasameansto
promote their brands by sharing news about new products and latest offers. These
channels allow the marketers to build a resonance with consumers. Typically such
channels also allow additional activities, such as games, quizzes, and multimedia
applications,todrawcustomers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

PersonalCleansingProducts

UnileverovertakesProcter&Gambletobecometheleadingadvertiserinthecategory,in
2012.
TheTMEofthemarketerisat$85.2million,representing70.8%ofthetotalcategorys
TME in 2012. Unilever spends $46.9 million or 55.0% of its total TME on television
advertising.
Dove, the leading brand of the marketer, accounts for 91.1% of the marketers total
TMEin2012.WithaTMEallocationof$41.6millionor48.8%ofthecompanystotal
TME,theDoveDeepMoisturebodywashisallocatedthehighestTMEin2012.
The marketer comes out with the Dove Truth Files game where consumers are
supposedtoputtheirbarsoapandbodywashtotestforachancetowingiftcardsand
cashprizes.
Axes personal cleansing products receive a TME of $2.4 million in 2012, down
aggressivelyfrom$9.5millionin2011.Axeispromotedinmagazinesandthecompany
allocates$2.0millionor83.3%ofthebrandstotalTMEtomagazineadvertising.
In2012,UnileveradvertisesitsAxebrandinacontroversialonlinecampaignthaturges
college students to conserve water by showering with a friend or an attractive
stranger,aconceptthatthemarketertermsshowerpooling.
In 2012, Axe teams up with supermodel Kate Upton and profootball player Jason
PierrePaul to promote its newly launched Axe Sport Blast 2in1 shower gel and
shampoo.KateUptonandJasonPierrePaulhosttheAxeSportBlastCombineHouse,a
competitivepartyspacewherethetwosquareoffinaseriesofchallenges.
In addition to television and magazine advertisements, social media also plays an
important role in promoting the marketers offers, discount coupons, or any new
productsintroductions.

Procter & Gamble slides to become the secondleading advertiser in the category with a
TMEallocationof$11.6millionin2012.
The marketers TME declines 70.0% from $114.1 million in 2011, to $40.0million in
2012.
The company apportions $10.6 million or 91.4% of the marketers total TME on
magazineadvertisements.
In2012,Procter&GambleintroducestheMyCityisMyGymcampaigntopromote
its Gillette brand. The campaign encourages men to take their exercise routine
outdoorsandcleansethemselveswithGillettesOdorShieldBodyWash.Themarketer
claimsthatthisbodywasheliminatesodorinsteadofmaskingit.Gillettepartnerswith
three professional athleteshockey player Patrick Sharp, Dhani Jones, a former
footballstar,andJerryRice,afootballlegendtopromoteitsproducts.
Olayswebsitepromotesitspersonalcleansingproductsbyinformingconsumersabout
the various offers and providing details on ways to attain the companys products at
lowerprices.Olayalsoprovidesfreeshippingonpurchasesabove$25.00.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H73

4H74

PersonalCleansingProducts

TME in the personal cleansing products category declines drastically to $154.0 million in
2012,down45.3%from$281.4millionin2011.
Magazines surpass television to become the most preferred medium of advertising
usedinthepersonalcleansingproductscategory.Magazineadvertisementrepresents
$54.4millionor45.2%ofthecategorystotaladvertisingdollarsin2012.
Television advertising slips to the second position with a TME allocation of
$50.8millionor43.2%oftotalcategorysTMEin2012.
Procter & Gamble cuts down its advertising expenditure in 2012 to $11.6 million. Its
TMErepresents9.7%ofthetotalcategory.
Beiersdorf emerges as the thirdleading advertiser in 2012, replacing Johnson &
Johnson.BeiersdorfpromotesitsNiveabrandwithaTMEof$5.9millionin2012.The
companyallocates$5.2milliontoadvertiseitsNiveaTouchOfbodywash.

In 2012, Henkel spends $3.5 million on TME to promote its brands that compete in the
personalcleansingproductscategory.Themarketerspends$2.6millionor74.3%ofitstotal
TMEexpenditureinthecategorytopromotetheDialTripleMoistureBodyWash.
In2012,HenkelpartnerswithSpartanRaceseriestopromoteitsDialforMenbrand.
SpartanRacehostsobstaclecourseracesthroughmudandtrailstotestonesresilience,
strength,stamina,anddecisionmakingskills.ThecompanysuppliesDialforMenbody
washattheshowerstationstowashawaythetoilsofthecourse.
Henkel for its Tone brand teams up with country singer Kellie Pickler to promote its
TheToneTurnitUp!Seriesin2012.ConsumersareinvitedtokeepupwithPicklervia
Facebook through personal blog posts, and a live Facebook chat. Fans also have the
chancetoparticipateincontestgiveaways,includingagrandprizeofanallexpenses
paidtriptoNashvilletomeetthecountrysinger.

DetailsonTMEsbybrandareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

OUTLOOK

SalesofthepersonalcleansingproductscategoryareforecasttoadvanceataCAGRof1.9%
duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Thecategoryisinamaturephaseandlimitedinnovationfrommarketerswilldampen
thegrowthofthecategoryduringtheforecastperiod.
There is fierce competition within the category, and individual companies will
experiencegrowthbytakingsharefromothermarketersinthecategory.
The slow growth of the category will, however, be supported by the introduction of
newproductsacrossthevarioussegments.Marketerscanlooktoinnovatewiththeir
productsbyofferingbenefitsinadditiontotheregularcleansing.Addedbenefitstothe
personalcleansingproductscouldbeintheformofmoisturizing,exfoliating,antiaging,
odorprotection,andadditionofvitamins.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

PersonalCleansingProducts

Other factors contributing to the growth of the category during the forecast period
involvepackaginganddesignchanges,changeinformulationsofexistingproductlines,
andthemarketerseffortstoincreasinglyintroducenaturallyformulatedproducts.
Few marketers experience a gradual phaseout of their brands from the bar soaps
segmentduetothelackofgrowthoffered.Thesemarketersareexpectedtoshifttheir
focus on the growing body washes segment, which offers a huge potential for
innovationandgrowthduringthenextfiveyears.
Marketers will continue to make efforts to differentiate their products from others
availableinthemarketsoastoprovideexclusivity.
Body washes providing multipurpose functions, such as shampoos and face washes,
willcontinuetogainpopularityamongmenduringthenextfiveyears.
Thebodywashessegmentisexpectedtomaintainitspositionasthelargestsegmentin
thepersonalcleansingproductsduringthecourseofthenextfiveyears.
Malecentric brands are expected to gain share in the personal cleansing products
category as the male grooming market booms. Marketers are also likely to render
increased marketing efforts targeted towards the malespecific brandsin the form of
traditionalmarketingmedia,suchastelevisionandmagazineadvertisements,thereby
gainingsomeloyaltyfromthem.
Liquidsoapsareexpectedtocontinuetogrowatamoderaterateasconsumersprefer
the use of liquid soaps over bar soaps to wash hands. Additionally, many consumers
shift from the use of antibacterial hand gels towards liquid soaps with the option of
usingantibacterialhandgelsonlywhenonthegointheabsenceofwater.
Sales in the antibacterial hand gels segment are expected to stabilize in the forecast
period
as there is still a certain section of consumers who are concerned about their health
and hygiene habits and will continue to use hand gels for protection. Additionally,
marketers are expected to make efforts to educate consumers about maintaining
personalhygieneandtheimportanceofusingantibacterialhandgels.
Thereisalwaysthenecessityforcleaninghandsonthegointheabsenceofwater,the
core function of antibacterial hand gels. Marketers are open to innovating in the
segment the form of new formulations. Formulations could be designed in a manner
suchthattheycauselessdrynesstotheskinuponusage.
Privatelabelwillcontinuetoperformduringtheforecastperiodduetotheirimproved
qualityofofferings,availabilityatalowprice,andsubstantialbackingfromretailers.
Marketersareexpectedtoinnovatewiththeirmarketingcampaignstolureconsumers
into purchasing products in this mature category and also attain the loyalty of
consumers towards their brands. Marketers in the category are expected to use the
popularsocialmedianetworkstomarkettheirproducts.

SalesofthecategoryareexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof1.9%to$4,424millionin2017,
upfrom$4,026millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H75

4H76

PersonalCleansingProducts

Table4H31:ForecastManufacturersSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbySegment,2012to2017

$Million

Segment

2012

2017

CAGR,%

Antibacterialhandgels

150

160

1.3

Bodywashes

1,354

1,589

3.3

Liquidsoaps

616

665

1.5

Bathadditives

638

660

0.7

Barsoaps

1,268

1,350

1.3

Total

4,026

4,424

1.9

UnitsalesinthecategorywillgrowataCAGRof1.6%to1,797.0millionpackagesin2017,
upfrom1,663millionpackagesin2012.

Table4H32:ForecastUnitSalesofPersonalCleansingProductsintheUnited
StatesbySegment,2012to2017

Millionpackages

Segment

2012

2017

CAGR,%

67

70

0.9

Bodywashes

449

520

3.0

Liquidsoaps

215

228

1.2

Bathadditives

126

129

0.5

Barsoaps

806

850

1.1

1,663

1,797

1.6

Antibacterialhandgels

Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A76

SHAVINGPRODUCTS

CATEGORYPERFORMANCE

Manufacturerssales

Manufacturers sales of the shaving products category advance 3.0% during 2012 to
$373million,upfrom$362millionin2011.

Sales of the shaving products category have grown at a compound annual growth rate
(CAGR)of1.6%from$345millionin2007to$373millionin2012.

Table4H33:HistoricalSalesofShavingProducts
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

345

2008

336

(2.6)

2009

341

1.5

2010

348

2.1

2011

362

4.0

2012

373

3.0

Unitsales

Unit sales of shaving products grow 2.7% to 238.3million packages in 2012, up from
232.0millionpackagesin2011.

Retailsales

Retailsalesgrow3.1%toarounded$538millionin2012,upfromarounded$522millionin
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H78

ShavingProducts

Table4H34:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductTypeandBrand,2011and2012

Producttype/brand

Company

$Million
2011

SHAVINGCREAMS

2012

%Ofsegment

2011

%Oftotal

2011

2012

EnergizerHoldings

83

85

23.5

23.4

22.9

22.8

Gillette

Procter&Gamble

82

84

23.2

23.1

22.7

22.5

Edge

EnergizerHoldings

75

77

21.2

21.2

20.7

20.6

Barbasol

PerioProducts

18

18

5.1

4.9

5.0

4.8

NiveaForMen

Beiersdorf

14

14

4.0

3.8

3.9

3.8

Aveeno

Johnson&Johnson

11

10

3.1

2.7

3.0

2.7

TheArtofShavingr

Procter&Gamble

10

2.3

2.7

2.2

2.7

EOS

EOSProducts

1.7

2.2

1.7

2.1

NeutrogenaMen

Johnson&Johnson

1.7

1.6

1.7

1.6

AnthonyLogisticsForMen

AnthonyBrands

1.7

1.4

1.7

1.3

Schick

EnergizerHoldings

1.1

1.1

1.1

1.1

MaryKay

MaryKay

1.1

1.1

1.1

1.1

JackBlackr

JackBlack

0.8

0.8

0.8

0.8

Noxzema

Unilever

0.8

0.8

0.8

0.8

CliniqueSuppliesforMen

EsteLauder

0.6

0.5

0.6

0.5

Zirh

TPRHoldings

0.6

0.5

0.6

0.5

OldSpice

Procter&Gamble

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

KingofShaves

KMIInternational

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

LabSeriesSkincareForMen

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

ClarinsMen

Clarins

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

Origins

EsteLauder

0.3

0.3

0.3

0.3

Privatelabelr

11

12

3.1

3.3

3.0

3.2

Allother

10

12

2.8

3.3

2.8

3.2

353

364

100.0

100.0

97.5

97.6

Total

PRESHAVES

LectricShave

Combe

Allother

66.7

66.7

1.7

1.6

22.2

22.2

0.6

0.5

11.1

11.1

0.3

0.3

Total

100.0

100.0

2.5

2.4

TOTAL

362

373

100.0

100.0

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A78

Skintimate

Privatelabel

2012

ShavingProducts

CATEGORYDEVELOPMENT

Markettrends

Theshavingproductscategory,categorizedbyestablishedmassmarketers,isinamature
phase.
In2012,thecategoryshowsmoderategrowthof3.0%.
With the average growth of large established marketers, such as Energizer Holdings,
Procter&Gamble,Johnson&Johnson,andBeiersdorf,thecategorywitnesseslimited
new product activity and innovation from these marketers thereby restricting the
categorysgrowth.
The category continues to be dominated by mass brands, with a limited presence of
prestigebrands.

Theshavingproductscategorycontinuestobedominatedbymassmarketers.
Many consumers choose mass shaving products to get the desired results instead of
indulginginmoreexpensiveprestigeproducts.
Although several prestige brands, such as Jack Black, Clinique, Zirh, Origins, and Lab
SeriesSkincareForMencompeteinthecategory,theyfinditchallengingtocompete
withthemassbrands.
Prestige marketers use elegant packaging and provide customer service assistance.
However, the majority of male consumers have not taken to this and continue to
choose costeffective mass shaving products over the expensive shaving products of
prestigemarketers.

Diversificationofproductsinfluencesthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Shavinggelsandcreamscontinuetogainmarketshareinthecategory.
Marketers, such as Energizer Holdings and Procter & Gamble introduce shaving gels
and creams enriched with moisturizing benefits that provide prevention from rashes
andirritation.Growthoftheaerosolbasedfoamsislowonaccountoftheseproducts
offering limited benefits to the skin and the perceived negative effect on the
environment.
Marketersdiversifytheirrangeofshavinggelsandcreamsbyofferingvariantsenriched
withnaturalingredients,suchasaloe,antioxidants,andfragrances.
In2012,EOSProductsintroducestheEOS24hourMoisturizingShaveCreamenriched
with natural conditioning oils, shea butter, antioxidants, and vitamins C and E; and
EsteLauderintroducestheOriginsBladeRunnerenrichedwithkukuinutoil,soyabean
oil,andotherplantprotectors.
Also, shaving products infused with natural ingredients allow marketers to position
themathigherprices.
Marketers are also increasingly introducing shaving products targeted towards men
with sensitive skin, which is prone to irritations and allergy. Gillettes shave gels for
men with sensitive and irritationprone skin include Gillette Fusion ProGlide Irritation
DefenseShaveGel,GilletteFusionHydraGelPureandSensitiveShaveGel,andGilllette
FusionProGlideSensitiveShaveGel.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H79

4H80

ShavingProducts

Changingfashiontrendsanddemographylimitsfurthergrowthinthecategory.
Thecurrentfashiontrendofsportinganunshavenlookwithmenkeepingstubbleshas
anunfavorableeffectonthecategorysgrowthin2012.
Also,manyworkplacesallowmentokeepanunshavenlookasapartoftheirformal
appearance, and the high unemployment rate coupled with higher levels of
telecommutingfurtherreducestheneedtoshaveasoften.
Moreover,thegrowingagingpopulationintheUnitedStateshasanundesirableeffect
onthecategorysgrowthasretiredmendonotneedtoshaveasoftenasyoungmen.

Womencentricproductscontinuetogainfootholdinthecategory.
Duetolackofinnovationinthemalesegment,themalecentricmarketersattemptto
developnewlineofshavingproductsforwomenorexpandtheirexistinglineoffemale
shavingproducts.
In 2012, sales for Skintimate, a femalecentric and the leading brand in the shaving
productscategorygrow2.4%.
Gillette, a previously malecentric brand, offers the Gillette Venus Satin Care line of
productscomprisingshavinggelsforwomen.TheSatinCarelinecomprisesshavinggels
availableindifferentfragrances,suchasAlluringAvocado,LavenderKiss,FloralPassion,
andPassionFruitandalsofordifferenttypesofskin.
However,productinnovationsandtechnologicaladvancementsintheformofsprays,
andinshowerdepilatorieshaveanadverseeffectonthesalesoftheshavingproducts
inthefemalesegment,therebymoderatingthegrowthofthissegment.
Additionally shaving is a more tedious process involving the purchase of razors and
shavinggelsorcreams,whilepurchaseofdepilatoriesrequiresthepurchaseofasingle
packcontainingallthenecessaryitemsforeasyhairremoval.

Thereisarisingtrendforthelaunchofspalikebarbershops/salons.
The Art of Shaving through its barber shops/salons offers traditional barber services
andaromatherapyskinservices,withshavingspecialistsalsoprovidingmaleconsumers
guidanceongroomingandproductselection.
Whiletheproductsusedwithinthesalonsbytheprofessionalsarenottrackedinthis
study,theproductssoldfortakehomeuseareincluded.Oftenafteragoodexperience
inthebarbershopsalon,menbuysomeproductstouseathome.
Anotherexample,TheBoardroomSalonforMenoffersamyriadofgroomingservices
includingshaving.ThesalonisknowntouseTheArtofShavingproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A80

ShavingProducts

Notablenewproducts

Table4H35:SelectNewShavingProductsIntroducedintheUnitedStatesin2012
Company

Brand

Description

EnergizerHoldings

Schick

HydroSkinProtectShaveGelenrichedwithingredientsincludingvitaminEandaloe,
andhelpsprotecttheskin

EOSProducts

EOS

MoisturizingShaveCreamenrichedwithnaturalconditioningoils,sheabutter,
antioxidants,andvitaminsCandE

EsteLauder

Origins

BladeRunnerenrichedwithkukuinutoil,soyabeanoil,andotherplantprotectors.Its
fragranceisablendofcoriander,Australianeucalyptus,Frenchpeppermint,andother
naturalrevivers

Procter&Gamble

Gillette

FusionProGlideClearShaveGelisanonfoamingshavegelwithamasculinefragrance

CATEGORYSEGMENTATION

Salesbyproducttype

Shavingcreamsandgels

Table4H36:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

332

2008

323

(2.7)

2009

330

2.2

2010

339

2.7

2011

353

4.1

2012

364

3.1

Theshavingcreamsandgelscontinuetobethekeydriverbehindthecategorysgrowthin
2012.

Marketers are increasingly introducing creams and gels formulated with benefits, such as
moisturizing,irritationreduction,suitableforsensitiveskin,andeffectiveskincare.
Althoughsalesofshavingfoamsremainstagnantat$76millionin2012,theircategory
sharedeclinesfrom21.5%in2011to20.9%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H81

4H82

ShavingProducts

Table4H37:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyProductType,2011
and2012

$Million

Producttype

2011

2012

Creamsandgels

273

284

76
4

Foams
Allothera

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Changeinvalue,%

77.3

78.0

4.0

76

21.5

20.9

1.1

1.1

Total
353
364

100

aIncludesmugsoap,tubes,andoils,amongothers.

100

3.1

Preshaves

Thesalesofthepreshavessegmentremainsstagnantin2012at$9millionfrom2011levels.
Combes Lectric Shave is the largest brand in the category with sales constant at
$6millionin2012from2011levels.Themarketerrepresents66.7%ofthesalesinthe
preshavesegmentin2012.
The market has very limited offerings in this segment. Moreover, companies neither
introducenew,attractiveandinnovativeproductsnortakeinitiativestopromotethe
segmentamongthemaleconsumers.
Thereareveryfewbrands,suchasTheArtofShavingandLectricShavewhocompete
inthiscategory.

Table4H38:ManufacturersSalesofPreshaveProductsin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012

Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

13

2008

13

2009

11

(15.4)

2010

(18.2)

2011

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A82

ShavingProducts

Salesbysegment

Shavingcreamsandgelscontinuetodominatewith78%oftheproducttypesalesin2012.
The share of womens shaving products advances to reach 30.2% in 2012, up from
29.7%in2011.
Growth in the womens product type segment is driven by the introduction of EOS
ProductsMoisturizingShaveCream.
EOSisgrowingfastwitha33.3%growthin2012from$6millionin2011to$8millionin
2012.
Also, womens shaving products constitute added advantages including moisturizing,
vitamins,andaloe,whichmakethemanattractivechoiceforfemalebuyers.
Furthergrowthinthewomensshavingproductssegmentisoffsetbythepresenceof
depilatories in the market and also due to some women choosing mens shaving
productsoverwomens.
However,theshareofmensshavinggelsandcreamsdeclinesto69.8%in2012from
70.3%in2011duetothegoodperformaceofwomensshavinggelsandcreams.

Table4H39:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsintheUnitedStatesbySegment,2011
and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Segment

2011

2012

2011

2012

Changeinvalue,%

Mens

248

254

70.3

69.8

2.4

Womens

105

110

29.7

30.2

4.8

Total

353

364

100.0

100.0

3.1

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H83

4H84

ShavingProducts

COMPETITION

Bycompany

Table4H40:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsintheUnitedStatesbyCompany,2011and2012

$Million

Company

2011

2012

EnergizerHoldings

162

166

Procter&Gambler

91

PerioProducts

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

44.8

44.5

2.5

95

25.1

25.5

4.4

18

18

5.0

4.8

Johnson&Johnson

17

16

4.7

4.3

Beiersdorf

14

14

3.9

3.8

EOSProducts

1.7

2.1

33.3

Combe

1.7

1.6

AnthonyBrands

1.7

1.3

EsteLauder

1.1

1.1

Privatelabel

13

14

3.6

3.8

7.7

Allotherr

25

27

6.9

7.2

8.0

Total

rRestated.

362

373

100.0

100.0

3.0

(5.9)

(16.7)

EnergizerHoldingscontinuestobe theleadingmarketerintheshavingproductscategory
withsalesat$166millionin2012.
Salesadvance2.5%from$162millionin2011.
Themarketerscategorysharedeclinesfrom44.8%in2011to44.5%in2012.
EnergizerHoldingshasapresenceinthecategorywithitsSkintimate,Edge,andSchick
brands.
Skintimate, the flagship brand of Energizer Holdings, leads the category with sales at
$85millionin2012,up2.4%from$83millionin2011.Thebrandrepresents22.8%of
thecategoryssalesin2012.
Skintimate, a femalecentric brand, continues to grow as the future prospect for
shaving products for women brightens. The brand is also the largest female shaving
brandinthecategory.
In 2012, Skintimates Lotionized Shave Crme undergoes a packaging makeover. The
product comes in a new colorful packaging that gives it a feminine touch. The
moisturizingshavingcreamisenrichedwitholivebutter,soy,vitaminE,andaloevera.
Skintimates Lotionized Shave Crme is available in three variants: Sensitive Skin
Formula,DrySkinFormula,andBabySoftFormula.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A84

ShavingProducts

Edgeisthesecondleadingbrandforthemarketerin2012withsalesat$77million,up
2.7% from $75million in 2011. Although the sales for Edge increase in 2012 but its
marketsharedeclinesslightlyfrom20.7%in2011to20.6%in2012.
In2012,EdgeutilizesitsFacebook pagetopromoteitsproductsthrougha varietyof
sweepstakesincludingtheEdgeEndowmentSweepswherebyparticipantsgetachance
to win $10,000 daily and over 250 weekly cash prizes and the Team Edge
SweepstakeswhichrequiresparticipantstovotefortheUFCrisingstarinordertowina
tripfortwotoLasVegastoseealiveUFCevent.
Additionally in 2012, the marketer introduces special edition Team Edge cans
containingtheUFCfightersfacesetchedonthepackaging.
Schicks sales remain stagnant at $4million in 2012 from 2011 sales. In spite of the
SchickHydroSkinProtectShaveGellaunch,thesalesofthecompanyremainstagnant
in2012.

Procter&Gamblecontinuestobethesecondleadingmarketerinthecategoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalesreach$95millionin2012,up4.4%from$91millionin2011.
Themarketshareforthecompanyincreasesto25.5%in2012,upfrom25.1%in2011
duetotherapidlyexpandingTheArtofShavingbrand.
Procter&Gamblesleadingbrand,Gilletteexperiencesa2.4%growthfrom$82million
in2011to$84millionin2012.
In early 2012, the marketer introduces the Gillette Fusion ProGlide Clear Shave Gel.
Furthergrowthforthebrandisoffsetbyncreasingcompetitionfromotherbrandsin
themarketincludingSchick,Edge,andNiveaforMen.
Themarketerssecondleadingbrand,TheArtofShavingwitnessesagrowthof25.0%
to$10millionin2012,upfrom$8millionin2011.
SinceProcter&GamblesacquisitionofTheArtofShavingbrandin2009,thebrandhas
been the fastestgrowing brand for Procter & Gamble in the beauty and grooming
division. The brands retail presence, which was once confined to department stores,
witnesses growing retail expansion to standalone stores, mass merchandisers, and
selectsalonsafteritsacquisitionbyProcter&Gamble.
Also, the number of The Art of Shaving stores has more than doubled since its
acquisitionwithamajorityofstoreshavingabarbershopinsidethemtopampermen
withatraditionalshavingexperience.Thebrandhasitsownretailstoresinabout80
locationsacrosstheUnitedStates.
SalesofOldSpice,themarketersthirdbrandinthecategory,remainat$1millionin
2012,constantfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H85

4H86

ShavingProducts

PerioProductscontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketerinthecategoryin2012.
Salesremainat$18millionin2012,flatfrom2011.
The categorys share of Perio Products declines from 5.0% of total category sales in
2011to4.8%oftotalcategorysalesin2012.
The marketers TME allocation of $2.6million to its Barbasol brand helps retain the
salesofthebranddespitenonewproductintroductionsin2012.
In2012,Barbasolsignsafiveyearagreementtobecometheofficialjerseypartnerof
ColumbusCrewOhiosMajorLeagueSoccerClub.Moreover,thebrandalsosupports
the Crew Soccer Foundation: an organization that uses soccer as a tool to provide
education,fielddevelopment,andahealthylifestyletotheyouth.
Also in 2012, the marketer teams up with professional snowboarder Louie Vito to
promotetheBarbasolArcticChillwithMentholShavingCream.

Johnson&Johnsonretainsitspositionasthefourthlargestplayerintheshavingproducts
categoryin2012.
The companys sales decline 5.9% to $16million in 2012, down from $17million in
2011.
ThemarketerisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsAveenoandNeutrogenabrands.
SalesofAveeno,Johnson&Johnsonsleadingbrandintheshavingproductscategory,
decline9.1%to$10millionin2012,downfrom$11millionin2011.
Neutrogena Men is the other brand of the marketer with which it competes in the
category.In2012,thebrandssalesremainconstantat$6millionfrom2011levels.

EOS Products posts a growth of 33.3% to reach $8million in 2012, up from $6million in
2011.
Introduction of the EOS 24hour Moisturizing Shave Cream in 2012 aids in the
marketers growth. The product is enriched with conditioning oils, shea butter,
antioxidants,vitaminCandE.Thecompanyclaimsitsproductprovidesacloseshave,
preventsrazorbumps,andprovidesnourishmentfor24hours.
Thecompanybenefitsfromitsexistenceintheemergingwomensshavingsegment.
FurthergrowthofthebrandisduetotheTMEsupportof$3.5millionin2012.Majority
oftheadvertisingexpendituresin2012isonmagazineadvertisements.
The marketer promotes its shaving products at consumer events and trade shows by
providingconsumerswithproductsamples.

Privatelabel products steadily gain share in the market accounting for 3.8% of the total
categoryssalesin2012,upfrom3.6%in2011.
Growth of privatelabel products is supported by the increasing confidence among
consumersaboutthequalityofproducts.
Moreover,privatelabelproductsbenefitfromthepriceadvantagetheyhaveoverthe
nationalbrands,negativelyaffectingtheirsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A86

ShavingProducts

RETAILDISTRIBUTION

Massmerchandiserscontinuetodominatethecategory,with41.0%oftotalretailsalesin
2012,similartotheircategorysharein2011.
Due to the widespread usage of shaving creams, mass merchandisers are convenient
andappropriateoutletstofindtheseproducts.

Foodstoresareabletomaintaintheircategorysharein2012at26.0%.

Theshareofdepartmentstoresremainsconstantat4.0%.
Thecategoryshareofdirectsalesremainsat2.0%.Thereisincreasingpopularityofe
commercesalesespeciallyamongmen,whilepersontopersonsalesdrag,keepingthe
averagelow."

Table4H41:ManufacturersSalesofShavingProductsinthe
UnitedStatesbyRetailOutlet,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Retailoutlet

2011

2012

Massmerchandisers

41

41

Foodstores

26

26

Drugstores

25

25

Departmentstores

Directsales

Specialtystores

100

100

Total

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Gillettepartnerswith25ambassadorsworldwideforitsGetStartedcampaign.
Thecampaignhelpsitsambassadorstogivebacktotheirrespectiveorganizationsand
communities,whichgroomedthemtotheircurrentpositioninlife.
GilletteandRyanLochte,worldchampionswimmer,donate$25,000toDaytonaBeach
SpeedSwimmingtheswimmingclubthathelpedgiveLochteastarttohisswimming
career.
Gillette also partners with sport personalities, such as Tyson Gay (USA, track), Roger
Federer(Switzerland,tennis),andSirChrisHoy(GreatBritain,cycling).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H87

4H88

ShavingProducts

Edge Shave Gel promotes its products by advocating consumers to enter the Edge
Endowment sweepstakes for a chance to win $10,000 by letting the brand know how
$10,000wouldhelpgettheiredge.

TheArtofShavingbrandteamsupwithMovember,aglobalmenshealthcharity,tofight
cancerthataffectsmen.
The participants raise awareness and funds for mens health, especially prostate and
testicularcancer.
The Art of Shaving encourages people to participate in Movember's 6th annual U.S.
fundraisingevent.
Thebrandurgesmembersoftheir"brotherhoodofshaving"toparticipateintheevent
byassuringtomatchtheteamdonationsupto$25,000.
In 2012, The Art of Shaving invites all registered MoBros to a complimentary
MovemberHotTowelShaveavailableatthebrand'sBarberSpalocations.

Afewofthepopularpromotionaltoolsutilizedbymarketersincludepricediscounts,FSIs,
coupons,instorepromotions,andconsumerevents.
Marketersusetheproductspackagingtosharepromotionrelatedinformation.
Marketersorganizeproductsamplingandconsumereventstointroducenewproducts
andinduceconsumerstobuytheproduct.
EnergizerHoldingsoffersprintablecouponsfortheSkintimatebrandwhichatdifferent
time frames allows the customers to avail $1.00, $1.50, and $2.00 off on every
purchase.

In 2012, TME for the shaving products category total $30.6million, down 15.0% from
$36.0millionin2011.
In 2012, marketers spend 42.2% of the total TME or $12.9 million on magazine
advertisements and 35.3% of the total TME, or $10.8million on television
advertisements,.

Market leader, Energizer Holdings TME for 2012 is $12.5million, down 27.3% from
$17.2millionin2011.
Themarketerspends$8.1millionontelevisionadvertisementsin2012.
Print advertisements account for $2.3million of the companys TME in support of its
brands.
Edgealonegarners$9.5millionor76%ofthemarketersTMEin2012.

Procter & Gamble spends $4.4 million as TME to promote its brands competing in the
shavingproductscategoryin2012,up10.0%from$4millionin2011.

In2012,PerioProductsovertakesProcter&Gamblesmediaexpenditure.
ThecompanyhasaTMEof$9.0millionin2012,down20.4%from$11.3millionin2011.
ThemarketershighestTMEisforitsPureSilkbrandwithaTMEof$6.4millionin2012.
In2012,themarketerspends$2.6millionasTMEforitsBarbasolbrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A88

ShavingProducts

DetailedinformationonTMEinthecategoryisprovidedintheAdvertisingsectionofthis
report.

OUTLOOK

Theshavingproductscategoryisexpectedtoshowamoderategrowthof1.5%duringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Growth during the forecast period is most likely the direct result of changing habits
amongmentowardstheirpersonalgroomingastheybecomemoreconsciousoftheir
appearance.
Newandinnovativeproductlaunches,changingformulations,andimprovedpackaging
isexpectedtogarnerfurthergrowthinthecategorythrough2017.
Marketers will continue to undertake efforts to differentiate their brands from the
others available in the market by giving their brands a premium positioning in the
market,eventhosesoldinmasschannels.
Prestigemarketersareexpectedtogainmarketshareinthefuture.

Marketersareexpectedtocontinuetodiversifytheirproductofferings.
Innovationwillplayamajorroleinthecategorysgrowthduringthenextfiveyears.
Shavingproductsenrichedwithskincarebenefitsareexpectedtogainpopularitydue
to their dual function of providing a smooth shaving experience with moisturizing
benefits.
Theseshavingproductsinfusedwithmoisturizingbenefitsareexpectedtobeenriched
with commonly used natural ingredients, such as aloe, vitamin A and E, shea butter,
cocoabutter,milk,andhoney.

With the rapidly developing male grooming market, a large proportion of the welltodo
malepopulationisexpectedtotradeuptousingprestigeshavingproductsasapartoftheir
dailyroutine.
Althoughtheshavingproductscategoryisdominatedbymassmarketers,theprestige
marketersarelikelytogainshareduringtheforecastperiodending2017.
Prestigemarketersareexpectedtointroduceinnovativeandmultifunctionalproducts
for male consumers, giving them skin care benefits in addition to the basic shaving
advantage.

The female segment in the category shall continue to gain marketers attention and post
growthinthenextfiveyears.
Malecentricshavingbrandsareexpectedtointroduceorexpandtheiralreadyexisiting
femaleproductlineswithinthecategoryinanattempttoappealtoabroadersection
ofthesociety.
Availability of variants in different fragrances for women will be a key driver for the
growthofthefemalecentricshavingproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4H89

4H90

ShavingProducts

Furthergrowthinthesegmentwillbeoffsetbyalternativetreatmentsandservices,suchas
depilatories,salonwaxes,lasers,andelectrolysis,andthegrowingathomebeautydevices
market.

SalesofthecategoryareexpectedtoadvanceataCAGRof1.5%to$402millionin2017,up
from$373millionin2012.

UnitsalesinthecategorywillgrowataCAGRof1.2%to253millionpackagesin2017,up
from238.3millionpackagesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A90

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

MinorCompanies

SectionSix

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

MinorCompanies

SectionSixof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeApril1,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employees of subscribing companies and their subsidiaries, as defined above, until April 1,
2016.Similarly,allsectionsofthesurveyaresorestrictedforthreeyearsfromtheirdatesof
issue. Failure to prevent unauthorized disclosure before these dates will result in legal action
againstthesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

MINORCOMPANIES.............................................................................................................61
Abercrombie&Fitch......................................................................................................65
AlsGroupe....................................................................................................................66
AllianceBoots.................................................................................................................66
AmorepacificCorporation..............................................................................................68
AnthonyBrands..............................................................................................................69
Arbonne........................................................................................................................610
AstralBrands................................................................................................................611
AtlanticCoastMediaGroup.........................................................................................612
AubreyOrganics...........................................................................................................612
BarcforMen.................................................................................................................613
Beauticontrol(TupperwareBrands).............................................................................614
Beekman1802..............................................................................................................615
Blistex...........................................................................................................................615
BlowPro.......................................................................................................................616
BlueQ...........................................................................................................................617
BonneBell.....................................................................................................................617
BradBiophotonic..........................................................................................................618
ByTerry.........................................................................................................................619
CamilleBeckman..........................................................................................................619
CargoCosmetics...........................................................................................................620
CarmaLaboratories......................................................................................................621
CarolsDaughter...........................................................................................................622
Cartier...........................................................................................................................622
CCAIndustries..............................................................................................................623
CellexCInternational...................................................................................................624
Chrysallis.......................................................................................................................625
TheColomerGroup......................................................................................................625
CorSilverSkincare........................................................................................................626
CosrichGroup...............................................................................................................627
DanaClassicFragrances...............................................................................................627
DeadSeaLaboratories..................................................................................................628
DeborahLippmann.......................................................................................................629
DemeterFragranceLibrary..........................................................................................629
Dermalogica..................................................................................................................630
DermovivaSkinEssentials............................................................................................631

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Devacurl........................................................................................................................632
Dr.BronnersMagicAllOne.........................................................................................632
Dr.Fresh.......................................................................................................................633
Dr.HauschkaSkinCare.................................................................................................634
E.L.F.Cosmetics............................................................................................................634
EquitiumGroup............................................................................................................635
EOSProducts................................................................................................................636
ErnoLaszlo....................................................................................................................637
E.T.Browne...................................................................................................................637
Euroitalia.......................................................................................................................638
ExpanscienceLaboratories...........................................................................................639
FaceStockholm.............................................................................................................640
FalicFashionGroup......................................................................................................640
Focus21........................................................................................................................641
FreemanBeauty...........................................................................................................642
Fresh.............................................................................................................................642
FruitoftheEarth..........................................................................................................643
FusionBrands...............................................................................................................644
GaldermaLaboratories.................................................................................................644
TheGap.........................................................................................................................645
GiovanniOrganicCosmetics.........................................................................................646
GoSmile........................................................................................................................646
GraceChoi....................................................................................................................647
HairRules......................................................................................................................648
HamptonSun................................................................................................................648
HerbalifeInternational.................................................................................................649
HermsInternationalGroup........................................................................................649
HouseofCreed.............................................................................................................650
InterfashionCosmetics.................................................................................................650
Interparfums.................................................................................................................651
InspiredBeautyBrands................................................................................................652
IredaleMineralCosmetics............................................................................................652
ITCosmetics..................................................................................................................653
J.Strickland...................................................................................................................654
JafraCosmeticsInternational.......................................................................................655

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
J.M.Products................................................................................................................655
JoeyNewYork..............................................................................................................656
JohnPaulMitchellSystems..........................................................................................656
JohnsonPublishingCompany.......................................................................................657
JonathanProduct.........................................................................................................658
JosieMaranCosmetics.................................................................................................659
JuiceBeauty..................................................................................................................659
KissProducts.................................................................................................................660
KissMyFace.................................................................................................................661
KosAmerica................................................................................................................662
Laqa&Co......................................................................................................................663
LavanilaLaboratories...................................................................................................663
LOccitane.....................................................................................................................664
LoracCosmetics............................................................................................................665
LushFreshHandmadeCosmetics.................................................................................666
LusterProducts.............................................................................................................666
MarkwinsInternational................................................................................................667
Matriskin.......................................................................................................................668
MerleNorman..............................................................................................................669
MissJessies..................................................................................................................670
Murad...........................................................................................................................670
Naturopathica...............................................................................................................672
NewHarmonySoap......................................................................................................672
NotYourMother's........................................................................................................673
NuSkinEnterprises.......................................................................................................674
Nyx................................................................................................................................674
Orlane...........................................................................................................................675
OrlyInternational.........................................................................................................676
OsmiaOrganics.............................................................................................................677
Ouidad(JHPartners)....................................................................................................677
Palladio.........................................................................................................................678
ParfumsDeCoeur.........................................................................................................678
PerioProducts..............................................................................................................679
PerriconeMD................................................................................................................680
PierreFabreGroup.......................................................................................................681

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MINORCOMPANIES(Continued)
PrestigeCosmetics.......................................................................................................682
PrimalElements............................................................................................................683
PrMinerals.................................................................................................................683
Pure&Basic..................................................................................................................684
Rahua............................................................................................................................685
ReckittBenckiser..........................................................................................................685
RenCleanSkincare.......................................................................................................686
RohtoPharmaceutical..................................................................................................687
RosebudPerfumeCompany.........................................................................................688
ShakleeCorporation.....................................................................................................688
SisleyCosmetics............................................................................................................689
SmellBent.....................................................................................................................690
SteinerLeisure..............................................................................................................690
SueIsmiel&Daughters................................................................................................691
SundayRiley.................................................................................................................692
Sunstar..........................................................................................................................692
Tarte.............................................................................................................................693
TatasNaturalAlchemy................................................................................................693
TedGibson....................................................................................................................694
TooFacedCosmetics....................................................................................................695
UniversityMedical........................................................................................................695
Urth...............................................................................................................................696
ValeantPharmaceuticals..............................................................................................697
VapourBeauty..............................................................................................................698
TheVillageCompany....................................................................................................698
VincentLongo...............................................................................................................699
VogueInternational....................................................................................................6100
WeiEast......................................................................................................................6101
Weleda........................................................................................................................6101
YesTo..........................................................................................................................6102
YvesRocher................................................................................................................6103

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

MINORCOMPANIES

Table61:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesforSelect
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

MarkwinsInternational

180

216

JohnPaulMitchellSystems

155

156

LOccitane

88

94

GaldermaLaboratories

86

92

PerriconeMD

79

84

ReckittBenckiser

79

80

YvesRocher

68

73

Arbonne

64

67

VogueInternational

60

63

Dr.Fresh

57

58

ValeantPharmaceuticals

61

57

AtlanticCoastMediaGroup

70

55

Dermalogica

51

53

Blistex

55

52

InterParfums

41

48

Abercrombie&Fitch

46

47

JohnsonPublishingCompany

46

47

Chrysallis

43

43

LushFreshHandmadeCosmetics

41

43

TheColomerGroup

41

42

J.M.Products

39

40

MerleNormanCosmetics

41

40

JafraCosmeticsInternational

38

38

Murad

34

35

TheGap

33

35

E.T.Browne

33

34

LusterProducts

33

34

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

2012

62

MinorCompanies

Table61:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesforSelect
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

CarmaLaboratories

33

33

AstralBrands

32

32

Beauticontrol

30

32

TooFacedCosmetics

30

32

E.L.F.Cosmetics

24

32

RohtoPharmaceutical

31

31

SteinerLeisure

30

31

YesTo

29

31

ShakleeCorporation

30

30

AllianceBoots

29

29

KissMyFace

27

29

EosProducts

16

29

NuSkinEnterprises

24

25

HerbalifeInternational

23

25

SunstarInc

24

24

Dr.HauschkaSkinCare

23

24

DeadSeaLaboratories

22

24

CarolsDaughter

23

23

ParfumsdeCoeur

22

23

IredaleMineralCosmetics

22

22

Dr.Bronner's

19

20

PerioProducts

18

20

BonneBell

21

19

AubreyOrganics

18

19

CellexCInternational

18

18

JoeyNewYork

16

18

AlsGroupe

17

17

AnthonyBrands

16

17

CCAIndustries

16

17

Euroitalia

15

17

Ouidad

14

15

PierreFabreGroup

14

15

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

2012

MinorCompanies

Table61:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesforSelect
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

2012

FusionBrands

14

14

Amorepacific

12

14

Cartier

12

13

EquitiumGroup

12

13

JosieMaranCosmetics

12

13

DanaClassicFragrances

14

12

GoSmile

12

12

InterfashionCosmetics

12

12

CargoCosmetics

11

12

KissProducts

11

12

TheVillageCompany

11

11

Fresh

10

11

HouseofCreed

10

11

SisleyCosmetics

10

11

Weleda

10

11

InspiredBeautyBrands

11

10

PrestigeCosmetics

11

10

CamilleBeckman

10

10

SueIsmiel&Daughters

10

10

GiovanniOrganicCosmetics

10

PrimalElements

10

DemeterFragranceLibrary

DermovivaSkinEssentials

FreemanBeautyLabs

HermesInternationalGroup

OrlyInternational

Pure&Basic

Orlane

FaceStockholm

Focus21

WeiEast

ErnoLaszlo

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

63

64

MinorCompanies

Table61:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesforSelect
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

2012

FruitoftheEarth

J.Strickland

LavanilaLaboratories

LoracCosmetics

RenCleanSkincare

BlowPro

Cosrich

BlueQ

ByTerry

CorSilverSkincare

RosebudPerfumeCompany

HamptonSun

PurMinerals

Nyx

Tarte

UniversityMedicalProducts

SmellBent

FalicFashionGroup

JuiceBeauty

MissJessies

TatasNaturalAlchemy

Urth

DeborahLippmann

BradBiophotonic

ExpanscienceLaboratories

KoseAmerica

TedGibson

ITCosmetics

Naturopathica

SundayRiley

VincentLongo

HairRules

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

MinorCompanies

Table61:U.S.ManufacturersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesforSelect
Companies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

2012

NotYourMothers

VapourBeauty

BarcForMen

Beekman1802

Devacurl

GraceChoi

JonathanProduct

Laqa&Co

Matriskin

NewHarmonySoap

OsmiaOrganics

Palladio

Rahua

aNegligible.

ABERCROMBIE&FITCH

Abercrombie & Fitch was founded by David T. Abercrombie and Ezra Fitch in 1892. It went
publicin1996.ThecompanyisheadquarteredinNewAlbany.Abercrombie&Fitchisaspecialty
retailerofcasualapparelandaccessoriesforyoungmen,women,andkids.Thecompanysells
itsproductsundertheAbercrombie&Fitch,AbercrombieKids,GillyHicks,andHollisterbrands.
Asof2012,thecompanyemploysapproximately8,500people.

In2012,thecompanyoperates1,050storesinNorthAmerica,Europe,andAsia.Thecompany
operates 942 stores in the United States comprising 279 Abercrombie & Fitch stores, 154
Abercrombiestores,491Hollisterstores,and18GillyHicksstores.Internationally,thecompany
operates 107 stores: 15 Abercrombie & Fitch stores, five Abercrombie stores, 84 Hollister
stores, and 3 Gilly Hicks stores. The company primarily promotes its products through its
website. The company operates stores and directtoconsumer operations, offering personal
careproducts,sleepwear,andathomeproductsforwomenundertheGillyHicksbrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

65

66

MinorCompanies

The company sells only fragrances in the cosmetics and toiletries industry, and its brands
includeFierceCologne,A&F1892(formen);8,andWakely(forwomen).Theapproximateretail
pricefortheirproductsisbetween$40.00and$85.00.FierceCologneand8areconsideredto
bethesignaturescentsofthecompanyandarethemostheavilypromotedbrands.Perfume41
forwomenisnolongerbeingsoldbyAbercrombie&Fitchin2012,butthecompanywillnot
confirmitsdiscontinuation.NoTMEforAbercrombie&Fitchsbrandsareevidentin2012.

Theglobalsalesofthecompanyareestimatedat$4.1billionin2012.Manufacturerssalesin
theU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketforthecompanyare$47millionin2012,up2.2%from
$46millionin2011.

ALSGROUPE

In1969,PatrickAlsfoundedPhytosolbaLaboratories,whichwasrenamedastheAlsGroupe
in1999.ThecompanysheadquartersisinParis,France.Thegrouphasestablishedsubsidiaries
in nine countries including the United States, Germany, the United Kingdom, and Italy. The
companys American subsidiary was established in New York in 1989. Als Groupe employs
approximately920peopleworldwide,with30employeeslocatedatitsU.S.office.

The company manufactures and markets fragrances, hair care, and skin care products under
thebrandnamesPhyto,PhytoSpecific,SecretProfessional,Kydra,Lierac,Caron,andDucastel.
In the United States, the company markets the Phyto and PhytoSpecific brands of hair care,
Lierac brand of skin care products, and Caron fragrances. The hair care brands Phyto and
PhytoSpecific are sold through highend salons and over 900 retail stores, including Sephora,
Bloomingdales, and Bergdorf Goodman. Caron fragrances are sold in around 50 department
storesandselectindependentspecialtystores.ThedepartmentstoresthatsellCaronproducts
includeSaksFifthAvenue,Nordstrom,BergdorfGoodman, HenriBendel,andBloomingdales.
Products from the group are also sold through drug store chains, such as Rite Aid, CVS
Pharmacy,DuaneReade,andBrooksPharmacy.

CorporatesalesforAlsGroupegrow7.3%from$254millionin2011to$273millionin2012.
TheU.S.manufacturerslevelsalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesareestimatedataflat$17million
in2012.AlsGroupehasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

ALLIANCEBOOTS

AllianceBootsisaleadingmanufacturer,distributor,andretailerofhealthcare,pharmaceutical,
and consumer products worldwide. Named originally The Boots Company at the time of
foundingin1849,thecompanychangeditsnametoAllianceBootsinJuly2006.Thecompany
developsanddistributesmedicines,toiletries,skincareproducts,makeup,fragrances,andbaby
nutrition,aswellaspharmacyanddispensingservices.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

MinorCompanies

Alliance Boots headquarters is located in the United Kingdom. The companys two core
businessactivitiesarehealthandbeautyretailing,andpharmaceuticalwholesaling.In2012,it
distributes medicines and other healthcare products to approximately 170,000 pharmacies,
doctors, health centers, and hospitals from over 370 pharmaceutical wholesale distribution
centersin25countries,includingassociatesandjointventures.In2012,AllianceBootsoperates
3,330healthandbeautyretailstoresin11countries,ofwhichover3,200haveapharmacy.

Alliance Boots operates in 25 countries including the United Kingdom, the United States,
France, Italy, the Netherlands, Germany, and Russia. Alliance Boots is a privatelyowned
companyandemploysover116,000peopleworldwide.

BootsRetailUSAoperatesasasubsidiaryofAllianceBootsintheUnitedStates.Thecompany
entered the U.S. market in 2004 by selling some of its makeup, skin care, and other beauty
products.AllianceBootsproductsareavailablewithretailers,suchasTarget,CVS,andShoppers
DrugMart.Asof2012, BootsproductsaresoldintheUnitedStatesinallTargetstores,over
450 CVS pharmacies, and over 650 Shoppers Drug Mart locations. The company employs
approximately30peopleintheUnitedStates.

Bootsmarketssixbrandsofcosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsinover670SKUs.BootsNo.7is
the leading brand for the company, with products in the makeup, skin care, and toiletries
productclasses.Botanicsisalineofplantbasedproductsthatincludesmakeup,skincare,and
hair care products. Time Dimensions is the companys antiaging product line. Boots Expert
solveseverydayskinconcerns.BootsOriginalBeautyFormulaoffersproductsintheskincare
and bath and body category. The Hawaiian Islands, Mediterranean, and Amazon Forest
Productsarearangeofhypoallergenicanddermatologicallytestedproductscreatedusingonly
organicingredients.

InApril2012,AllianceBootslauchesanewproductunderitsNo7brand,Lift&LuminateDay&
NightSerumforwomenaged45andabove.Itissaidtobeclinicallyprovenandhelpstofade
agespotsandvisiblyliftskintoreducetheappearanceofdeeperlinesandwrinkles.Alliance
BootspromotesitsproductsthroughvarioussocialmediasiteslikeFacebookandPinterest.It
spendslessthan$100,000inTMEintheUnitedStates.

As of September 2012, Walgreen Co., owns a 45% equity interest in Alliance Boots GmbH.
AllianceBootssetsupanewcompanyWalgreensBootsAllianceDevelopmentGmbH,jointly
ownedwithWalgreen.ThecompanyisbasedinBerne,Switzerland.AllianceBootswillaccount
foritsinterestasajointventure.

ManufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforthecompanyintheUnitedStatesareflatat
$29million,sameasin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

67

68

MinorCompanies

AMOREPACIFICCORPORATION

AmorepacificCorporationisaKoreabasedchemicalandcosmeticscompany.Thecompanyis
headquartered in Yongsangu Seoul, South Korea. Amorepacific was founded by SungHwan
Suh.Amorepacifichasbeenamanufacturerofcosmeticssincethe1930s.

AmorepacificenteredtheUnitedStatesin2003.Althoughthecompanyprovidesitsofferings
under many categoriescosmetic products; skin care products; makeup products; fragrances
for men and women; personal care products, and health care productsit has restricted
presenceintheUnitedStateswithonlyskincareandmakeupproducts.In2008,Amorepacific
introduced its first makeup product, Time Response Skin Renewal Foundation in the United
States.SomeofthecommoningredientsusedinAmorepacificskincareproductsincludegreen
tea,bamboosap,andredginseng.

Time Response is the companys biggest line in the United States, however the Treatment
Enzyme Peel, which is said to help brighten and even skin tone while giving a smooth
complexion,isthebestsellingproduct.

In 2012, the companys introductions in the facial treatments category includes the new
advanced Time Response Intensive Skin Renewal Ampoule, a fourweek skin enhancement
system,theFutureResponseAgeDefenseCreme,anantiagingcreamthatfightssignsofaging
andrestorestheskinsabilitytoregeneratecellsforayouthfulexperience,theLuminousEffect
Brightening Serum formulated with Asian botanicals to help reduce signs of age spots and
hyperpigmentation for a flawless and luminous complexion, and the Luminous Effect
Brightening Masquemicrofiber material masque that provides immediate skin brightening
effect.Additionally,thecompanylaunchestheLimitedEditionHolidayTimeResponseFlawless
SkinSet,LimitedEditionMoistureBound,andFutureResponseHolidaySet.

Amorepacific is active on social networking platforms, such as Facebook and Twitter to


promoteandmarketitsproductsandatthesametimebuildsapersonalrelationshipwithits
consumers. The brand also relies on PR activities to spread the word around on its latest
happenings,whichincludewriteupsinmagazines,suchasAllure,OKMagazine,Pregnancyand
Newborn,NewBeauty,andMarieClaire.Giveawaysanddeals,suchasluxuriousspagetaways
are also another attractive marketing medium adopted by the brand. The brand organizes a
numberofinstorebeautyeventsatretailers,suchasNeimanMarcusandBergdorfGoodman.
The company has a minimal TME of $0.9 million, with all of it attributed towards magazine
advertisements.

Amorepacific skin care products are available at select Neiman Marcus, Nordstrom, Sephora,
Bergdorf Goodman, Holt Renfrew, and Cosbar stores, as well as Amorepacific Beauty Gallery
andSpainSOHOandNYC.In2012,thecompanyexpandsitsdistributionnetworkinNeiman
Marcus and Sephora stores and penetrates into the online channel. Amorepacific has highly
trained sales representatives for instore sales and creates events to give consumers a good
experience.ThecompanyprovidestheBeautyCreatorservicewherebysalesrepresentatives
perform demonstrations on skin hygiene and skin care regimens and build relationships with
prospectconsumers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

MinorCompanies

U.S. manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries for the company are estimated at
$14millionin2012,up16.7%from$12millionin2011.

ANTHONYBRANDS

The New York Citybased Anthony Brands was established by Anthony Sosnick in 1998. In
October2000,thecompanylauncheditsretaildistributionof30productsdesignedspecifically
for male grooming. Today, the company specializes in the research and development of
personalcarebrandsspecificallytargetingtheneedsofboth,menand,morerecently,women.
The company offers over 100 SKUs with brands, such as Anthony Logistics for Men, Action,
Anthony For Little Men, and Shaveworks The Cool Fix. Anthony Logistics for Men is the
companysleadingbrand.

The marketers products are distributed in about 2,000 retail doors across the United States.
StoresthatsellthecompanysproductsincludeNordstrom,Bath&BodyWorks,Sephora,Ulta,
and C.O. Bigelow. Internationally, the company is present in over 28 countries. Products are
alsosoldonlinethroughthecompanyswebsite.

Anthony Brands promotes its products primarily through sampling, instore events, and
editorialplacements.Themarketerpromotesitsproductsthroughsocialnetworkingwebsites,
such as Facebook and Twitter. The option of online chat on its website is also available.
AnthonyforMenalsorunsaweblogthatpromotesvisibilityofitsproductsthroughdiscussions
on mens fashion and grooming trends. The company apportions an insignificant amount of
TMEin2012.

Among the bestselling products is a parabenfree Glycolic Facial Cleanser with aloe vera for
soothingbenefits,glycolicacidtoeaseawayfinelines,vitaminsA,C,andEforskinnourishing,
aswellasashavecreamdesignedforallskintypes.

Someofthenewproductsintroducedin2012includeBlueChamomilehairandbodycleansing
gelwhichhelpstocleans,hydrate,andconditiontheskin,andincludesingrediantslikeglycerin,
aloe vera, wheat protein, and revitalizing chamomile; Instant Fix Oil Control, which helps to
instantlyabsorbexcessgreaseoncontactandkeepshineatbayallday.Italsohelpstoreduce
the appearance of pores. For 2013, the company is getting ready to launch a new brand
focusedontheskincareneedsformenandwomencalledGrandmaStelles.

The marketer offers free shipping on any order exceeding$50.00. The company also does its
promotional and marketing activities through social websites like YouTube, Twitter, and
Facebook. Complementary deluxe samples with every purchase are also offered by the
company.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

69

610

MinorCompanies

Manufacturers sales of U.S. cosmetics and toiletries for the company are estimated at
$17million in 2012, up 6.3% from $16 million in 2011 and mainly driven by new product
launches.

ARBONNE

ArbonneInternational,LLC,basedinIrvine,CA,isadirectsellingcompanythatmanufactures
anddistributescosmeticsandtoiletries,aswellasnutritionalsupplements.Thecompanyisa
formersubsidiaryofLevlad,LLC.

Thecompanywasfoundedin1975inSwitzerlandbyPeterMorckandagroupofleadingbio
chemists,biologists,andherbalists.ArbonnebeganitsdistributionintheUnitedStatesin1980
andsellsonline,aswellasthroughitsnetworkofindependentsalesconsultants.

NaturalProductsGroup,theformerownerofArbonneInternationalandLevlad,LLC,filedfor
Chapter11bankruptcyattheUnitedStatesBankruptcyCourt,inDelaware,inearly2010.The
currentownersofArbonneInternationalaretheformercreditorsoftheArbonneandNatural
Productsgroup,whichincludescompanieslikeGECapital.Inthebankruptcyprocess,Natural
ProductsGroupexchanged85%ofitsequitywithitsbanks,includingGECapital,for80%ofits
debt.

Arbonnes products include shampoos, conditioners, premium facial cleansers, moisturizers,


antiaging sun care products, and baby skin care products along with detoxification,
aromatherapy, weight loss, and nutrition products. Arbonne is also positioned as a natural
brandanditsproductsarepricedhigherthanmostotherdirectsalesproductsaswellasmany
othernaturalproducts.

Arbonnes products are shared across the world through its network of independent
consultants. The company also offers products through its online shop,
www.arbonne.com/shop_online/shopOnline.asp. Its products are marketed through the
independent sales consultants rather than through traditional advertising. Arbonne allocates
$319,200inTMEin2012.

Thecompanylaunchesitsseasonal 2012HolidayCollection,whichincludes16newproducts.
These products include Mandarin Pomegranate Hair and Body Care, the Comet Cosmetic
Collection, and a limited edition Arbonne The Angel Signature Fragrance. Arbonne promotes
throughsocialanddigitalmediasiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.

Arbonne also launches three personal care products in 2012: Pure Mint Deodorant, an
aluminiumfree deodorant; Pure Mint Mouthwash, which is alcoholfree; and Pure Mint
Toothpaste,aflouridefreetoothpaste.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

MinorCompanies

HeatherChastainisappointedSeniorVicePresidentandChiefSalesOfficer.AsofSeptember
2012, Chastain, a recognized direct sales industry executive, oversees Arbonnes sales
organization. Other news regarding the company is that in the summer of 2012, another
Executive National Vice President (ENVP) leaves the company. This is the highest position
Arbonneconsultantscanachieve,andthethreepeoplewhohaveachievedthispositionhave
allleftthecompany.Thisindicatesproblemsinthestructureforthehighestleadershiplevelsof
Arbonneandforitslongtermgrowthpotential.

SalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforArbonneatthemanufacturerslevelintheUnitedStates
reach $67million in 2012, up 4.7% from $64 million in 2011, supported by new product
launchesandanincreaseinthenumberofconsultantssellingitsproducts.

ASTRALBRANDS

Astral Brands, founded in 1978, was formerly known as Aloette Cosmetics. In 2005, the
company changed its name. The company operates two subsidiaries: Astral Health& Beauty
and Astral Foods. Astral Brands manufactures and markets beauty care and food products in
theUnitedStates,Canada,Australia,theUnitedKingdom,Japan,andtheRussianFederation.
AstralBrandsisheadquarteredinAtlanta,GAwithanadditionallocationinBaltimore,MD.As
of2012,AstralBrandsemploysapproximately330peopleinitstwofacilitiesinAtlanta,GA,and
Baltimore,MD.

The company offers cosmetics and skin care products under three major brands: Aloette,
Cosmedix,andPrMinerals.Aloette,thecompanysflagshipbrand,offersskincare,makeup,
and bath and body products through the direct sales channel. Aloette's aloe verabased skin
careproductsandcosmeticsaresoldmainlythroughhomepartiesheldbyAloette'sdirectsales
network.Thebrandhasmorethan10,000consultantsinaprroximately40franchisesacrossthe
UnitedStatesandCanada.Aloetteswebsitealsooffersproductsforsaleonline.Aloettesskin
care line focuses on botanicalbased facial treatment products, offering antiaging products,
moisturizers,exfoliants,andacneproducts.

Cosmedix is a dermatologybacked professional skin care brand marketed by Astral Health&


Beauty. They are a line of premium skin care products sold only at professional spas. Pr
Mineralsisabrandofmakeupandskincareproductsformulatedwithmineralingredientsand
sells well through Ulta stores nationwide, and is also offered in Dillards and Trade Secret
stores.Allthreebrandsarealsosoldonlineandontelevisionshoppingchannelswhichinclude
QVC.In2012,thecompanydoesnothaveanyevidentTMEforitsproducts.

In 2012, Astral Brands introduces Super Shot, a multipurpose cosmeceutical booster that the
company claims enhances the performance of everyday skin care and cosmetic products. All
thenewproductlauchesarepromotedthroughvarioussocialnetworkingsiteswhichinclude
FacebookandTwitter.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

611

612

MinorCompanies

In2012,thereareafewmanagementchangesforthecompanywhichincludeRobertCohen,
AstralHealth&Beautysfounderandchairmanoftheboardnowmadetheexecutivechairman.
StephenMerrickistheCFO,EricAllenisthevicepresidentofoperations,TammyBlytheisthe
vicepresidentofsalesandtrainingforPrMinerals,andTishaThompsonispromotedandis
the vice president of brand marketing for Pr Minerals. Manufacturers sales in the United
StatesforAstralBrandsareestimatedtototal$32millionin2012,evenwith2011levels.

ATLANTICCOASTMEDIAGROUP

AtlanticCoastMediaGroup,headquarteredinNewJersey,wasfoundedin2005bytwodirect
response marketing professionals, Andrew Surwilo and Thomas Shipley. Atlantic Coast Media
Group is one of the prominent national and multichannel personal care products marketers,
withakeyfocusonimprovingthepersonalandlifestyleneedsofbabyboomers.

Thecompanyhasnutraceuticalandcosmeceuticalproductsavailableinthehealthandbeauty
marketplace,andworksinthepersonalcareandsupplementindustry,underbrands,suchas
Hydroxatone, Hydrolyze, Celtrixa, Declatone, Luminique, Instant Effect, Besotone, and
Venacura.

ThemarketerlaunchesKeraniqueHairRegrowthKitin2012,anewantiagingsolutiontotreat
femalehairthinning,hairloss,andtoaddresstherootcauseofissuesassociatedwiththeaging
ofhair.

Atlantic Coast Media Group enjoys a significant brand recall due to its longterm association
withover3,000televisionandradiostationsacrosstheUnitedStates,aswellasthrough500
major newspapers and magazines. It promotes through social media sites, such as Facebook,
withquizzesandotherchancestowinfreeproducts.NoTMEforthecompanysproductsare
evidentin2012.

The companys manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States for 2012
areestimatedat$55million,down21.4%from$70millionin2011.Thedropismainlydueto
Hydroxatonespoorperformancefromitslossofdistribution,keypeopleleavingthecompany,
andalargenumberofconsumercomplaintsoffraudulentcreditcardcharges.

AUBREYORGANICS

Tampa,FLbasedAubreyOrganicsisamarketerofcosmeticsandpersonalcareproductsbased
onnaturalingredients.Thecompanywasfoundedin1967byAubreyHampton.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

MinorCompanies

Aubrey Organics markets a wide range of products spanning across the skin care, hair care,
makeup, and fragrance product classes. The companys products are formulated with 100%
natural products and are sold under the companys flagship brand, Aubrey Organics. The
companyhasover200productsandissoldinmorethan4,500retailersworldwide.

Aubrey Organics was one of the first personal care companies to be certified as an organic
processor according to the standards set by the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA). The
company has obtained organic certification by two other certifying bodies in the United
States:NaturalProductsAssociation(NPA)andQualityAssuranceInternational(QAI).BDIH,the
associationofGermanmarketersofpharmaceuticalsandpersonalcareproducts,alsocertifies
thecompanysproductsasorganic.

In 2012, the company launches new products in the skin care and hair care product classes.
Under the skin care product class the company launches Natural Sun suncreens which offers
threekindsofsunprotection:Sundeflectingmineralsformingaprotectivebarrierthatkeeps
UVA/UVB rays off the skin; antioxidants prevent free radical damage; and botanical
moisturizersprotectskinfromthedryingeffectsofthesun.In2012,thecompanyalsolaunches
twonewadditionstoitslineofscentedwomen'sshavingcreams:CrmedelaShavewithwhite
teaandcitrusfragrance,andCrmedelaShavepomegranatefragrance.Underthehaircare
product class, the company launches two new fragrances under its range of GPB Glycogen
Protein Balancing shampoos: GPB rosemary peppermint shampoo and conditioner and GPB
lavenderYlangYlangshampooandconditioner.

AubreyOrganicssellsitsproducts onlinethroughdedicatedwebsiteintheUnitedStates,the
United Kingdom, Japan, and Russia. It also distributes its products through retailers, such as
PacificHealthFoods,WholeFoods,VitaminShoppe,HealthNuts,andSunHarvest.

Aubrey Organics conducts its promotional and marketing activities through various social
networking sites like Facebook and Twitter. The all natural product range is advertised on
Facebook.Italsospendsalittlemorethan$600,000onmagazineadvertising.AubreyOrganics
allocatesTMEof$1.1millionin2012.

AubreyOrganicsU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesareestimatedat$19millionin2012,up
5.5%from$18millionin2011,mainlydrivenbynewproductlaunches.

BARCFORMEN

BarcforMenisaspeciallyformulatedlineofskincareproductsformen.Itwasfoundedin2005
and is located in New York, NY. The companys products are alcoholfree, oilfree, and
fragrancefreeandworkonallskintypesandskintones.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

613

614

MinorCompanies

BarcforMenmarketsshavingcreamsandpostshavelotions.Itsproductsaredevelopedunder
two brand namesBump Down and Cutting Up. Bump Down is a facial repair treatment to
reduceingrownhairandirritationcausedduetoshaving.Italsohealsoldbumpsandprevents
new ones from coming up. The product has to be applied immediately after shaving. Bump
Downisavailableintwosizes1.7fl.oz.and3.4fl.oz.andasatripackwhichisasetofthree
1.7ounceproducts. Cutting Up is a shaving cream that softens hair to ensure smooth shave
andpreventsshavebumps.Itisavailableintwosizes:2fl.oz.and6fl.oz.Nonewvariantswere
introducedin2012.

BarcforMenbrandsarepromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeTwitterandFacebook.Products
areavailableatselectstores,spas,boutiques,andpharmaciesintheNewYorkCityarea.

Corporatesalesofthecompanyareestimatedtobeunder$1millionflatfrom2011levels.

BEAUTICONTROL(TUPPERWAREBRANDS)

BeautiControl is one of the subsidiaries of Tupperware Brands Corporation that markets


cosmeticsandotherpersonalcareproducts.BeautiControlisadirectmarketerheadquartered
in Carrollton, TX. The companys products are sold through over 140,000 independent
consultants intheUnitedStates,PuertoRico,andCanada. Asof 2012, thecompanyemploys
700personnelwithabout325employeeslocatedinthecompanysheadquarters.

BeautiControl markets products across skin care, makeup, fragrances, and the personal
cleansingproductclasses.AntiagingproductsformasignificantportionofBeautiControlsskin
care offerings. The latest among the companys product introductions in 2012 include Dark
Brown sugar collection,which includes body wash, instant manicure, and body creme; and
Regeneration Tight Firm & Fill Extreme Eye Complex, which helps to conceal fine lines and
wrinklesaroundtheeyesin15minutes.

Besidesrelyingonitssalesconsultantstomarketitsproductsdirectly,thecompanyconducts
its promotion and marketing through various social media sites which include Facebook,
Twitter, Tumblr, YouTube, Printerest, and Instagram. It does not do traditional advertising in
2012.BeautiControlalsohasapartnershipwithWomenHelpingOthers(WHO)foundation,that
supports communityfocused charities that serve the overlooked needs of women, children,
andfamilies.

Totalcompanyssalesareapproximately$87millionin2012.ManufacturerslevelsalesinU.S.
cosmetics and toiletries are $32 million in 2012, up 6.7% from $30 million in 2011, mainly
drivenbythepromotionalactivitiesandnewproductlaunches.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

MinorCompanies

BEEKMAN1802

JoshKilmerPurcellandBrentRidgefoundedBeekman1802in2008.BasedinSharonSprings,
NY,thetwofoundersincludedaneighboringfarmerandhisdairygoatsintheirBeekmanfarm
and started producing cheese and soaps. The company now markets beauty products, food
items, stationery, linens, and a few other products. The skin care products are all made with
goatsmilk,thatthecompanyclaimsmoisturizesandbeautifiesskin.

Thecompanysproductportfolioincludesskincareproducts,suchasmoisturizers,bodysoaps,
and body washes; and oral care products namely, lip balms. Beekman 1802 Tub of Butter
launchedin2012hasmoisturizingbenefitsofsheabutterandgoatsmilk.Itisavailableinfour
scents:spring,summer,autumn,andwinter.ThecompanyalsolaunchesLumpofKohl,adetox
treatment that uses bamboo charcoal to remove impurities and chemicals from the skin and
puregoatsmilktomoisturizetheskinandkeeptheskinspHbalance.Beekman1802Stickof
Butter Simply is a moisturizing lip balm. The companys bar soap, named Beekman 1802, is
availablein12variants,eachnamedafterdifferentmonthsoftheyearandarepromotedfor
useontheface,body,andevenhair.TheSignatureTwoBarBagshavetwosoapsinaclothbag,
promotedasagiftitem.Beekman1802alsomarketsfoursoapsnamedafterthefourseasons
of the year. Beekman 1802 MilkShake is a milk bath made of goats milk available in four
variantsspring,summer,autumn,andwinter.

ProductsarepromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,Pinterest,Twitter,Google+,and
Tumblrandinpopularmagazines,suchasVogue,MarieClaire,Lucky,andElle.Beekman1802
productsareavailableatHenriBendelFifthAvenueandinanumberofboutiquesintheUnited
States. Internationally, the company sells to countries like Norway, Denmark, England, China,
andAustralia.

Beekman1802employsoneparttimeandthreefulltimeemployees.Thecompanyisexpected
to be growing rapidly and total sales are estimated to be under $1 million in 2012. Beauty
products contribute to around 60% of the domestic sales. Increasing awareness and
introductionofnewproductsaremajorfactorscontributingtosalesgrowthofthecompany.

BLISTEX

Blistex,Inc.,foundedin1947,primarilydevelopsandmarketslipcareproducts.Thecompanyis
headquartered in Oak Brook, IL, where it conducts its research and development and
manufacturingoperations.ThecompanyisbestknownforitsBlistexliptreatmentproducts.

Blistex also markets other personal care and healthcare brands, such as StriDex acne
treatments, Ivarest poison ivy itch relievers, KankA oral pain relievers, Glysomed hand and
bodyproducts,andFoillemedicatedfirstaidointment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

615

616

MinorCompanies

Blistex offers a wide range of lip care products including ointments, balms, and medicated
products. Some of the products under Blistex include Simple Essentials, Natural Cooling
Comfort,DCT(DailyConditioningTreatment),FiveStarLipProtection,CompleteMoisture,and
LipInfusion.

In 2012, Blistex launches two new products: Moisture Melt, a superhydrating lip balm with
moisturizing softbeads; and Simple and Sensitive that moisturizes the most sensitive lips
withoutirritation.

Blistexsellsitsproductsthroughsupermarkets,foodstores,dollarstores,anddrugandbeauty
stores,includingKroger,Ulta,Target,Walmart,RiteAid,CVS,Walgreens,DollarGeneral,Dollar
Tree,drugstore.com,andamazon.com.

Blistexadvertisesthroughcabletelevision,magazines,storepromotions,andthe Internet.As
Internetmarketinggainspopularity,likemostothernationalbrands,Blistexhasitspresenceon
Facebook. Blistex Facebook page is used to discuss new products, receive feedback about
them, and display pictures of the variants. The companys website has a special section, Lip
Tips,whichtalksaboutcommonlipproblems,suchaslipdrynessandchapping,sundamage,
andaging.Italsolistssometipstoensuregoodhealthoflips.TotalTMEforBlistexslipbalm
productsareapproximately$7.6billionin2012.

AsofJune2012,Blistexemploysapproximately200people.

The manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the Unites States for Blistex are
estimated at $52 million in 2012, down 5.5% from $55 million in 2011. Sales for its lip balm
productsareerodedbysteepcompetitionfromEOS,Nivea,andBurtsBees,whicharepursuing
aggressivemarketingtactics.

BLOWPRO

BlowProwasfoundedin2005bythreefriendswhoenvisionedandcreatedasalonthatwould
provide hair blowdry (often referred to as blowout) services exclusively. The company first
openeditsdoorstoManhattansMeatpackingDistrictbyofferingsignatureblowoutservices.
Blow Pro is headquartered in New York. In 2008, the company launched the Blowpro line, a
uniquelineofproductsdesignedtogivebetterblowdryresults.

BlowProsproductsarefreeofsulfates,parabens,andsodiumchlorideandarecompliantwith
keratin treatment. Blow Pro offers three line of products: Clean + Nourish, Prep + Style, and
Finish+Refresh.Theproductrangeincludesshampoos,conditioners,andhairstylingproducts.
BlowProsproductsfindmentioninleadingmagazines,suchasSelf,Health,Latina,OK,Modern
Salon, American Salon, Beauty Launchpad, and InStyle. The company does not allocate any
evident TME in 2012. Blow Pro also holds customized parties, such as bachelorettes, bridal
showers,andweddingdaybeautywherebyconsumerscanselectfromtheirrangeofservices,
suchasblowouts,manicures,andquickfixmakeup.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

MinorCompanies

BlowProslineismadeavailablethroughspecialtyretailers,suchasUlta,professionalsalons,
onlineretailerssuchasamazon.com,andthecompanyswebsite.In2012,BlowProsproducts
debutatselectNordstromlocations.

SalesofBlowProintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketatthemanufacturersleveltotal
$6millionin2012,constantfromthesalesin2011.

BLUEQ

Established in 1988, Blue Q Corporation is a marketer of personal care products and is


headquartered in Pittsfield, MA. In addition to personal care products, the company markets
items,suchasbreathsprays,carairfresheners,homeaccessories,andcandy.Thecompanys
productsarenotedfortheireyecatchingpackaging,retrostylebranding,andquirkynames.

The leading cosmetics and toiletries brands from Blue Q are Dirty Girl, Miso Pretty, Mental
Case, and Wash Away Your Sins. The companys new product activity in 2012 is focused on
general merchandise, candy, and gift items. In 2012, some of the latest additions to the
companyscosmeticsandtoiletriesportfolioareMeOmLipbalm,MeOmHandcream,MeOm
bodywash,LipShitlipbalmpeachlavenderandLipShitlipbalmasianpearmint.

Thecompanysellsitsproductsonlinethroughitswebsiteandalsothroughover1,500stores
across the United States including Ulta, Urban Outfitters, Papyrus, C.O. Bigelow, Rickys, and
WholeFoods.Itdoesnotadvertiseandreliesonwordofmouthpublicitygeneratedduetothe
productsquirkybranding.

TheU.S.manufacturerslevelsalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforthecompanyareestimatedto
at$5millionin2012,sameas2011levels.

BONNEBELL

BonneBellisaprivatecompanyfoundedbyJesseBellin1927inLakewood,OH.Thecompany
manufacturesandmarketscolorcosmeticsgearedtowardsteensandpreteens.BonneBellhas
approximately150employees.Productsaresoldundertwobrands;BonneBellandSmackers.
BonneBellisdesignedforolderteens,featuringmoresophisticatedpackagingandafulllineof
bronzers, lip glosses, and eye makeup. Smackers wide variety of flavored lip glosses targets
youngerteensandpreteens.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

617

618

MinorCompanies

The company sells various cosmetic products including bronzers, eye shadow, eyeliner,
mascara, lip color, and lip gloss. Bonne Bell sells its products through supermarkets, drug
stores, beauty retailers, and specialty shops, as well as online. The company promotes its
products through editorial mention in magazines, such as Justine, Teen Vogue, Glamour and
Elle.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

UrbanchicLipGlossclaimstomoisturizeandconditionthelips.
Undercover Concealer, oilfree concealer to camouflage dark, undereye circles, redness,
blemishes,andmore.Itcomesinthreeshades:WarmBeige,NaturalBeige,andIvoryBeige.
Lipblush moisturizes and conditions the lips, and also provides a delicate shine. It is
availableinsixsoothingflavorsincluding,PeacefulPeach,CheerfulCherry,PassionateFruit,
SereneStrawberry,Pomegranate,andVanillaChai.

TheU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforthecompanytotal$19millionin2012,downfrom
$21millionin2011.BonneBellhasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.Besidesnotinvestingin
advertising, the company has internal conflicts in upper management that are preventing a
solidgrowthstrategyfrombeingimplemented.

BRADBIOPHOTONIC

BradHunterfoundedBradBiophotonicin2010asaregenerativeskincaresystemformenand
women.Thecompanysproductsaredevelopedusingbiofermentedingredientswhichactivate
collagen and elastin. Biofermentation means stimulating living cells with ultraviolet light, and
thebottlesarevioletcoloredglass,whichblocksUVlightandkeepstheactiveingredientsalive
until dispersed onto the skin. Brad Biophotonics products claim to promote skin health and
provideantiagingbenefitstoskin.ThecompanyislocatedinLosAngeles,CA,andwasinitially
createdasacustomprojecttoreducedamagedonetotheskinduetotheharsheffectsofair
travel.

BradBiophotonicsproductportfoliomarkets15SKUsofcleanser,mist,creams,andtreatment
products.Itsgelcleanserscontainingablendoffermentedacidsandplantinfusionsstimulate
theskinsrenewalprocessanditsultrapeelprovidesmulticellularexfoliationwhiledeeply
hydratingskin.Theantiagingproductcontainsproteinsandpeptidestorestorefirmnessand
elasticityofskinanditsessentialelixirsincreasethedensityofskinandofferantioxidant
defense.SomeofBradBiophotonicbrandsincludeUniversalCleansingGel,UltraElastinfirming
cream,UltraPeelexfoliatinggel(thecoreproduct),EssentialElixirPoreTightening,UltraWhite
IntensiveLightening,SeriousComfortBodyCream,UniversalShave,andTransformingBodyOil.
Nonewproductshavebeenintroducedin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

MinorCompanies

Brandsarepromotedinsocialnetworkingsites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.Brad
BiophotonicsskincareproductsareavailableatitsflagshipstoreinLosAngeles,selectretail
stores,andthroughonlineretailers,suchasdermstore.comandmyskin.com.Domesticsalesof
thecompanyareestimatedat$2millionin2012,aslightincreaseoverjustunder$2millionin
2011.Thecompanyhasplanstolaunchthroughhomeshoppingchannelsintheinternational
markets.

BYTERRY

Aftercollaboratingasamakeupartistwithpeoplefromtheworldoffashionandbeautyfor20
years, Terry launched her own signature label, By Terry in 1998. Located in Paris, France, By
Terry develops and markets face makeup products like foundations, concealers, bronzers,
powders, blush, and primers; lipsticks and lip glosses; and eye makeup products, such as eye
shadow,mascara,eyeliner;andnaillacquers.Thebrandsdifferentiatorcomesfromadvanced
packaging for the delivery of the product, such as click pens, as well as rare pigments for
specialcolorload.

Brands promoted by the company include Nectar Opulent (Intense YouthReviving Cream),
EclatDeTeint(ColorSkinEnhancer),SheerExpert(FluidFoundation),TouchExpertAdvanced
(MultiCorrective Concealer Brush), Crayon Onctueux (Multicare Lip Definer), and Terrybly
collection which includes foundations, lipsticks, lip liners, and eye pencils. In 2012, By Terry
launches Haute Parfumerie which included five fragrances Flagrant Dlice, Rve Opulent,
PartiPris, Lumire d'Epices, and Ombre Mercure. The company also launches its Hyaluronic
HydraprimerandHyaluronicHydrapowderin2012.

Products are promoted through social network sites like Facebook and Twitter. By Terrys
productsareavailableatselectretailstoreslikeBarneysNY,ArchApothecary,SpaceNK,Four
SeasonsProducts,andSephora.

Thecompanyemploysastaffofaround30people.Thesalesfor2011and2012areestimated
at$5million.

CAMILLEBECKMAN

HeadquateredinEagle,ID,CamilleBeckmanisaprivatecompanyestablishedin1986bySusan
CamilleBeckmanRoghani.Thecompanycelebratedits25thanniversaryin2011.Thecompany
marketsitsproductsintheUnitedStates,Canada,SouthPacific,Europe,theMiddleEast,and
Asia.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

619

620

MinorCompanies

The company manufactures a range of personal care products which include bath and body
products, hand lotions and creams, fragrances, and facial treatment products. The jars and
bottles are decorated with the companys signature trademark, the tiny handtied satin
rosebud.

Some of the companys bestknown brands include Midnight Monarch, Lime Leaves, and
Tuscan Honey. The bestselling products of the company are its Glycerin Soap and Coronet
Cream. The Glycerin Soap helps in retaining the skins moisture and the Coronet Cream is a
handcream.

Thecompanysdistributionnetworkisstrongwithindependentretailers;primarilygiftshops,
boutiques, and local drug stores. It retails its products through wholesalers who have a
storefront business. The products are sold online, and are also promoted on Facebook and
other social networking sites. In 2012, no TME have been reported for Camille Beckham
products.

ManufacturerslevelsalesintheUnitedStatesforCamilleBeckhamfor2012total$10million,
evenwith2011salesduetothelackofnewproductlaunches.

CARGOCOSMETICS

BasedinToronto,Canada,CargoCosmeticsisaCanadiancosmeticscompanythatwasfounded
in 1996 by Hana Zalzal. The companys line of cosmetics was developed by top professional
artists. In 1998, Cargo Cosmetics was introduced in the United States and is now available
worldwide.Cargoproductsaresoldinmorethan1,400storesacross11countries.

Cargos product offerings include makeup products comprising face makeup, eye makeup,
lipsticksandlipglossesaswellasmakeupbrushes(notincludedinthisstudy).

CargoCosmeticsisaprofessionalbrandandpopularwithsomeHollywoodcelebrities.Sincethe
company works so closely with the professional makeup artist community, the company has
startedaspecialProArtistProgramwherebymembersareentitledtoreceivea40%discount
onCargoproductspurchaseddirectlyfromtheCargoCosmeticswebsite.

New products introductions in 2012 include the Cargo Lip Gloss moisturizing, highshine,
longwearinglipglossthatisavailablein14shades;andCargoColorstickoilfree,creamcolor
stickthatblendswitheyes,cheeks,andlipstogiveanaturallookandisavailableinfiveshades.
Furthermorein2012,thecompanylaunchestheSpringKitcomprisinglipglossinFresno,Beach
BlushCoralBeach,EyeShadowDuo,TripleActionMascara,andaSpringMakeupbag.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

MinorCompanies

CargoCosmeticsissoldthroughouttheUnitedStatesatmajorretailersincludingSephorainside
JCPenny department stores, Ulta, QVC, and Macy's Impulse Beauty. The company does not
advertiseitsproductsdirectlybutthroughPRarticlesinleadingfashionandbeautymagazines
includingFlareandEssence.Thecompanyscosmeticsareusedbymakeupartistsonanumber
of popular television shows, such as AmericanIdol and The Big Bang Theory, and in movies,
suchasAliceinWonderland,IronMan2,andInsidious.Thecompanyhasavoidedtraditional
advertising and instead appointed celebrities including Denise Richards and Courtney Cox to
designlipsticksandengageinsocialmediacampaigns.CargoCosmeticshasnoTMEin2012.

In 2012, TPR Holdings purchases a controlling interest in Cargo Cosmetics. TPR Holdings is a
NYCbasedinvestorandoperatorofbeautyandconsumergoods.HanaZalzalwillcontinueto
remainwithCargoCosmeticsasthecreativedirector.

Cargo Cosmetics sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
$12millionin2012,up9.1%from$11millionin2011.

CARMALABORATORIES

Carma Laboratories is a private company headquartered in Franklin, WI. It was founded by


Alfred Woelbing in 1937 and has a total of 100 employees as of 2012. Carma Laboratories
competesintheU.Scosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryundertheoralcareandskincareproduct
classes.Itenteredtheskincareproductclassintheyear2010byintroducingCarmexHealing
CreamandCarmexHydratingLotion.

The new products introduced during 2012 include the Carmex Pomegranate Ultra Smooth lip
balminfusedwithninemoisturizers;andCarmexlipconditioner,anaturalorangeflavorinfused
with13moisturizerstokeeplipshydrated.Thecompanysproductsareretailedthroughmany
stores,includingAlbertsons,CVS,DuaneReade,DollarGeneral,FamilyDollar,FredMeyer,HE
B, Kmart, Kroger, Rite Aid, Safeway, Sams Club, Walmart, Walgreens, Target, and Pathmark.
Advertisingisalsoanintegralpartofthecompanysagenda.Thecompanykeepsitscustomers
informedaboutitsproductsthroughtelevision,magazines,andspecialevents.

Carma Laboratories spends an estimated $7.3 million as TME in 2012. The company offers
couponsandalsopromotesitsproductsthroughsocialwebsiteslikeFacebookandTwitter.

CarmaLaboratoriesU.Scosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareflatat$33millionin2012,sameas
2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

621

622

MinorCompanies

CAROLSDAUGHTER

Carols Daughter is a line of natural beauty products which was designed by Lisa Price. The
company was founded in 1993 and is headquartered in Brooklyn, NY. It employs about 50
peopleasof2012.InvestorsofthecompanyincludepeoplelikeWillSmith,JadaPinkett,JayZ,
MaryJBlige,JimmyLovine,TommyMottola,andThalia.

The companys personal care products portfolio comprises hair care products, skin care,
personalcleansing,andfragrancestargetingAfricanAmericans.

In2012,thecompanyintroducesnewproductswhichincludeAaiClarifyingExfoliatingToner,
Aai Hydrating Foam Cleanser, Aai Hydrating Exfoliating Toner under the skin care product
class,andHairMilk4PieceStarterKitandTransitioning123underthehaircareproductclass.

The products of the company are retailed through nine of its own stores, as well as various
salonsandotherretailers,suchasSephoraandMacys.Productsarealsosoldonlineandthe
company offers complimentary shipping on any order. Carols Daughter allocates a TME of
$902,700in2012.

ManufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforthecompanyintheUnitedStatesin2012
and2011areconstantat$23million.

CARTIER

Cartier was founded in 1847 by Louis Francois Cartier and is headquartered in Paris, France.
CartierisownedbytheVendomeGroup,asubsidiaryoftheSwissgroup,CompagnieFinanciere
Richemont. The company has a worldwide presence with products being retailed across all
continentsanditsotherbrandsincludePiaget,IWC,AlfredDunhill,andVanCleef&Arpels.The
headquartersofCartierNorthAmericaareinNewYork,NY.

Cartier manufactures jewelry, watches, leather goods, apparel, accessories, hand and body
lotions,personalcleansingproducts,shavingproducts,andfragrancesandancillariesformen
and women. The company also offers pens, lighters, scarves, eyewear, decorative pieces,
clocks,cufflinks,andbirthdaygifts.Themajorityofthecompanyssalesaregeneratedfromits
jewelryandwatchesbusiness.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

MinorCompanies

In 2012, Cartier revamps its classic Dclaration to introduce Dclaration d'un Soir a new
fragranceformenwhichreprisesthecoldspicesoftheoriginalfragranceandlaunchestheEau
de Cartier Essence de Bois a fresh woody fragrance with oud wood with additional notes of
yuzu,bergamot,violetleaves,violetflower,lavender,musk,patchouli,andambergris.

In 2011, Cartier expanded its worldwide network of boutiques and specialized retailers. The
companys products are distributed through a network of approximately 300 boutiques. In
2011, boutiques were upgraded with the closure of selected boutiques and the opening of
better and larger flagship retail stores. Cartier products are retailed at stores including
Nordstrom,Sephora,Macys,andSaksFifthAvenue

Macys offers a variety of bonus offers to consumers on Cartiers fragrances for men and
women,handandbodylotions,andpersonalcleansingproducts,suchasacomplimentaryfive
piece gift set on the purchase of Cartiers Dclaration d'un Soir, free gift with purchase on
Cartiers Declaration Toning Bath & Shower Gel, and free gift with purchase of a Cartier
Declaration After Shave Lotion. Cartier spends under $100,000 in TME in 2012, 67% on
magazine advertising for its womens fragrance Baiser Vole, and the remainder on magazine
advertisingforitsmensfragranceDclaration.

Cartiers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at $13million in
2012,up8.3%from$12millionin2011.

CCAINDUSTRIES

CCAIndustries,foundedin1983,isheadquarteredinEastRutherford,NJ.Itisapubliclytraded
companyandmarketspersonalcareandhealthproductsundervariousbrandnames,primarily
in the United States and Canada. The products are manufactured by contract manufacturers
andaremarketedunderlicenseagreements.Itemploysaround140employeesasofOctober
2012.

CCA Industries brands comprise Plus+White toothpastes and teeth whitening kits, Sudden
Change range of antiaging skin care products, Nutra Nail manicure products, Bikini Zone
depilatoryandafterhairremovalproducts,GelPerfect5Minutecolorgel,SolarSensesuncare
products, vanillabased fragrances called Cherry Vanilla, Hair Off depilatories, Wash N Curl
shampoos, Scar Zone scar management, and firstaid products, IPR3 products for foot care,
andmensaftershaveproductcalledShaveZone.

The company sells and markets its products through warehouse clubs, drug stores, mass
merchandisers,foodstoresaswellasthroughonlineportals.Someoftheretailstoresthrough
whichthecompanysellsitsproductsareA&P,Albertsons,CVSPharmacy,DiscountDrugmart,
Duane Reade, Food City, Food Lion, Publix, Rite Aid, Safeway, Shop Rite, SuperValu, Target,
Ulta,Walgreens,andWalmart.Amazon.com,drugStore.com,andWalgreens.comaresomeof
the online portals for shopping CCAs products alongwith the companys own online portal,
shop.CCAIndustries.com. CCA creates and/or oversees formulations with independent
contractorsformanufacturingitsproductsbasedoncompanyspecifications.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

623

624

MinorCompanies

ThecompanylaunchesNutraNailGelPerfect,Plus+White5MinutePremierWhiteningSystem,
Plus+WhiteSuperWhitetoothpaste,SuddenEyeUnderEyetreatment,EyeBoutiqueShadow
Shields,andCherryVanillaBodyMistin2012.Itpromotesthroughsocialmediawebsiteslike
FacebookandTwitter.TMEforCCAIndustriesproductsareestimatedat$1.8millionin2012.

JonathanRothschildisappointedasadirectoronAugust16,2012,replacingJamesMastrian,
whoresignedasthedirectorofthecompanyasofAugust15,2012.

CCAIndustriescorporaterevenuesareestimatedatapproximately$50millionin2011,down
2.0% from $51million in 2010. The companys cosmetics and toiletries sales in the United
Statesincreaseby6.3%from$16millionin2011to$17millionin2012,basedonnewproduct
activities.

CELLEXCINTERNATIONAL

CellexC International is a privatelyowned Canadian company headquartered in Toronto,


Canada,foundedin1990.Itisamanufacturer,distributor,andretailerofcosmeticformulations
containingvitaminC.ThecompanyhasaningredientCellexCComplex,withpatentedformulae
used widely in its products. The companys product lines include, sun care, antiaging, and
productsformotherandchild.Thecompanyemploysabout50staffmembersasof2012.

Thecompanyoffersawiderangeoffacialtreatmentsandsuncareproducts.Someofthefacial
treatment products include cleansers (foaming gels, creams, and cleansing milk); antiaging
products(oilfreemoisturizers,skintighteningcream,eyecontours,serums,andskinhydration
complexes); exfoliators and masks (skin toning masks and clear complexion masks). The sun
careproductsmarketedbythecompanyincludesuncareSPF30+,sunscreenlotions,andUV
moisturizers.

The companys products are sold in about 40 countries. In the United States, CellexC
International sells its products through distributors, dermatologists, and aestheticians. The
company further markets its products through the Internet, pharmacies, and some specialty
stores,suchasSephora.

In2012,thecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesatthemanufacturerslevelintheUnited
Statesareat$18million,unvaryingfrom2011sales.NoTMEforCellexCsbrandsareevident
in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

MinorCompanies

CHRYSALLIS

Chrysallis is a management group with a mission of driving growth and development of fast
movingbrandsinthehealthandbeautyindustry.Itsparentcompany,CattertonPartners,isa
privateequityfundmanagingmorethan$2billiondollars,withfocusexclusivelyonconsumer
products.ThecompanyisheadquarteredinNewYork.

SomeofthebrandsdevelopedbythecompanyincludeFrdricFekkai(soldin2008),Niadyne
Nia24,andtheCanyonRanchYourTransformationskincarecollection.Someofthepersonal
careproductscurrentlymarketedbyChrysallisareStriVectinandNia24.StriVectinwasbought
by Chrysallis in 2009, and although positioned as a clinical brand, it is sold across multiple
channelswithretailersincludingCostco,Ulta,andBeauty360.CattertonPartners,alongwith
Chrysallis,nowoverseethedaytodaymanagementofthePoutCosmeticsbusinessaswell.

ManufacturerssalesintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketforChrysallisareestimatedat
$43millionin2012,sameasin2011.ChrysallishasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

THECOLOMERGROUP

ColomerUSAisheadquarteredinJacksonville,FL.ItisasubsidiaryoftheSpanishcompany,The
ColomerGroup.ThecompanywasfoundedbyJoseColomerin1923.Asof2012,thecompany
employsapproximately950people.TheColomerGroupsparentCVCCapitalPartnershasthe
company(ColomerGroup)upforsalesince2011,andCVCCapitalPartnersintendstosellits
haircareandskincarebrands.

Thecompanysproductofferingsincludeshampoos,conditioners,gels,lotions,hotfills,perms,
relaxers, masks, scrubs, nail care, bath salts and crystals, treatment skin care, and nail care
products.ThecompanymanufacturesproductsinSpain,Italy,Mexico,andtheUnitedStates(in
Florida).Itproducesavarietyofhaircareformulasspecializinginethnicconcerns,fromcolorto
stylingandtreatmentproducts,andmarketedtoAfricanAmericanandHispanicconsumers.

ThebrandsmarketedbythecompanyincludeRouxhaircareproducts,AmericanCrewmens
skinandhaircareproducts,andCrmeofNaturemulticulturalhaircareproducts.Professional
brands marketed by the company are D Fi, Creative Nail Design (CND), and Equave. The
companyprimarilysellsitsproductsthroughprofessionalchannelsincludingsalonsandbeauty
supply stores, and the professionaluse sales are not included in the scope of this report.
Colomers ethnic products are also distributed through mass outlets. The success of CND
Shellachasbroughtabroughtalotofimitationsintothenailcarecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

625

626

MinorCompanies

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

CrmeofNaturewithArganOilTreatmentisinfusedwithArganOil,andtheproductclaims
torepairdry,damagedhair,strengthenandpreventhairbreakage.
Moisture&ShineShampoo,infusedwithArganOilfromMorocco,helpshairtodetangle,
soften,andboostshine.
IntensiveConditioningTreatmentclaimstoleavehairsoft,silky,andrestoreshine.
Strength & Shine LeaveIn Conditioner infused with Argan Oil from Morocco, claims to
revitalizechemicallytreatedhairfrominsideout.

The Colomer Groups global sales are estimated at $435 million in 2012. The companys U.S.
salesoftakehomeproductsareestimatedat$42millionin2012,upfrom$41millionin2011.
The Colomer Group supports its brands with TME of $2.2 million in 2012. The company
allocates its TME majorly on two categories; nail care and hair care. The nail care category
receives$1.0millionTMEandhaircarecategoryreceives$1.2millionTMEin2012.

CORSILVERSKINCARE

CorSilverSkincarewasfoundedin2008byJenniferMcKinley.McKinleysfascinationwiththe
patentedformulaofnanosilverwithsilicaledtotheformationofthecompany.Thesilverin
Corproductsstopsthebacteriafromtransferringoxygenthroughthecellwallswhilethesilica
helpstheskinabsorbtheingredientsofCor.Corwasthereforelaunchedinpartnershipwitha
scientistinKorea.Corproductsarecomposedofpatentedsilversilicacompound,knownforits
antibacterialproperties,tohelpclearskin,andasanantiagingagent.Corsproductofferings
can be classified under personal cleansing products, hand and body lotions, and facial
treatments.

In2012,thecompanylaunchestheCorSilverCalmingMask,whichusesthehealingproperties
ofBentoniteClay,colloidaloatmeal,seawhipfromcoral,andpurealoefordetoxificationand
purification of the skin; Cor Silver Enzyme Maskformulated with papaya, antioxidants,
vitamins,flavonoids,andcaroteneshelpsremovedeadskincellsandgiveamoreglowingand
youthful skin; and Cor Silver Hydrating Mask formulated with ricefermented sake, black tea,
oats, wheat amino acids, and pink grapefruit for a smooth and luminous skin with skin
lighteningproperties.

CorproductsareusedbymanycelebritiesincludingRashidaJones,JenniferGarner,TyraBanks,
andChristinaHendricks.Thecompanyfeaturesinmagazinesincluding Esquire,WWDBeauty,
Essence, Bazaar, Glamour, and Health Beauty Life. The companys website features a 20%
discount on all Cor products. Social media networking sites, such as Facebook, Twitter, and
PinterestarealsoimportantpromotionalmediaforCor.Thecompanydoesnotapportionany
significantamountofTMEin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

MinorCompanies

Corisretailedthroughspasandsalons,retailersFredSegal,BeautyCollection,GoddessWithin,
IllusionsofBeauty,Palmetto,andPowderRoom.Thecompanysproductsarealsoavailablefor
purchaseonthecompanyswebsiteandskinstore.com.

In 2012, sales of Cor Silver Skincare in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market at the
manufacturerslevelareestimatedat$5millionin2012,constantfromsalesin2011.

COSRICHGROUP

Cosrich Group is a subsidiary of the international firm PMC Group, which manufactures and
distributes children's bath products including shampoos, conditioners, cleansers, and bath
bubbles. The company also markets play cosmetics. Cosrich Group is a private company with
headquartersinBloomfield,NJ.Thereareatotalofover50employeesinthecompany.

Cosrich Group markets its products through its MeToo brand. The company owns licenses of
publishers, such as Hasbro and DC comics and some toy manufacturers. The companys
products feature characters including Batman, Superman, Hello Kitty, My Little Pony,
StrawberryShortcake,andBobtheBuilder,amongothers.

Thecompanysdistributesitsproductsnationwide,throughsupermarketsandspecialtystores
andalsothroughmassmerchandisingstoreslikeKmart,Target,ToysRUs,andWalmart.The
U.S. manufacturers level sales for the company are estimated at $6million in 2012, up from
$5millionin2011.NoTMEforCosrichGroupsbrandsareevidentin2012.

DANACLASSICFRAGRANCES

DanaClassicFragranceswasestablishedinSpainin1932.HeadquarteredinDeerfieldBeach,FL,
the company employs about 330 people. The company offers a wide range of mens and
women's fragrances for all types of consumers. Dana Classic Fragrances manufactures and
distributes over 50 classic brands, among which the classic 1970s womens scents include
Love's Baby Soft, Navy, Toujours Moi, Tabu, and Chantilly. Aside from the classic fragrance
brands, others marketed by the company include Black Lace, British Sterling, California For
Men,CaliforniaForWomen,Canoe,Chantilly,EnglishLeather,EnglishLeatherBlack,Forbidden,
HeavenSent,LovesBerrySweet,LovesSugarKiss,NavyForMen,NavyForWomen,andNo
Limit.DanaClassicFragrancesintroduces20Caratsfragrancein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

627

628

MinorCompanies

Dana Classic Fragrances is owned by Patriarch Partners, a private equity firm whose founder
and CEO is Lynn Tilton. With a specialty in turning around ailing U.S. companies, Patriarch
Partners has majority holdings in over 40 companies in diverse industries: aerospace,
automotive,engineering,andtechnologyaswellasconsumerproducts.Itsothercosmeticsand
toiletriesbrandsareStilaCosmeticsandJaneCosmetics.

Thecompanysellsitsproductsonlineandthroughmajordrugstoresandmassmarketretailers,
such as Walmart, CVS,Rite Aid,and Longs Drugs. The companys products are also marketed
throughvariousdepartmentstores,suchasSears.

TheU.S.manufacturerslevelsalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforDanaClassicFragrancesare
estimatedat$12millionin2012,downfrom$14millionin2011.Thecompanyhasnegligible
TMErecordedin2012.

DEADSEALABORATORIES

DeadSeaLaboratoriesisaprivatecompanyfoundedbyZivaGiladin1988andisheadquartered
in Holon, Israel. The company manufactures and distributes skin care products made of mud
andmineralbasedcompoundsfromtheDeadSea.Thecompanysmainmanufacturingplantis
basedoutofMitzpeShalem,onthewestbankofPalestine.Thecompanyemploysabout200
peopleandsellsitsproductsinover30countriesworldwide.

ThecompanymarketstheAhavabrandofskincareproductsincludinghandcream,footcream,
facial cleanser, body milk, facial nourishing cream, facial moisturizer, and face makeup,
moisturizingshowercreamandbodycream.Italsohasasmallrangeofmakeupproducts.

In2011,ElanaDrellSzyfer,formerSeniorVicePresidentofGlobalMarketingforEsteLauder,
wasappointedgeneralmanagerofAhavaNorthAmerica.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

HopeBlossomsBathSaltclaimstocontain100%naturalDeadSeasaltcrystalswithhealthy
minerals.Itclaimstorelaxmusclesandjointsandleavestheskinfeelingsoft,smooth,and
refreshinglyhydrated.
ComfortingCreamprovidestotalrelieffromsensitiveskinandcanbeusedeverydayorfor
occasionalflareups.
FirmingBodyCream:Thissilky,nourishingbodycreamhelpsskinrecoverlostfirmnessand
supportssaggingwhileimprovingtoneandelasticity.
Extreme Firming Eye Cream claims to reduce wrinkles, enhance firmness, and provide
protectionandintensemoisturetothefragileskinaroundtheeyeareaforamoreyouthful,
wellrestedappearance.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

MinorCompanies

Avahas products are distributed in more than 30 countries through department stores,
perfumeries, and chain outlets. The company also has flagship stores in Israel, Germany,
Hungary, the Philippines, and Singapore. In the United States, Avahas products are retailed
through stores like Nordstrom, Bloomingdales, and Lord & Taylor. It also has an online
shopping portal which contributes to a large part of the sales in the company. The company
promotesitsproductsthroughmagazines,suchasNewBeauty,NaturalHealth,andSheen.

Mostofthecompanysrevenueisdrivenfromexportsandtheglobalsalesofthecompanyare
estimated at approximately $160 million in 2012. The U.S. manufacturers sales total
approximately $24 million in 2012, up from $22 million in 2011. No TME for Dead Sea
Laboratoriesbrandsareevidentin2012.

DEBORAHLIPPMANN

DeborahLippmannisarenownedmanicuristandaninnovativeentrepreneurwhocreatedher
nailbrand,DeborahLippmann.BasedinNewYork,NY,thecompanywasestablishedin1999.
Her nail collection features over 45 longwearing nail lacquers and a few nail, hand, and feet
treatments. Deborah Lippmann's nail polishes have been worn by some Hollywood stars like
Kate Winslet, Resse Witherspoon, Renee Zellweger, and Penelope Cruz. Passion for nail art
enablestheentrepreneurtobuildherclientele.

In 2012, Deborah Lippmann launches colors with names, such as Candy Shop, Mermaids
Dream, Steal My Kisses, Swagga Like Us, Sugar Daddy, Private Dancer, Rock This Town, Shes
AlwaysaWomen,PuttinontheRitz,andBadThings.Theyear2012alsomarksthelaunchof
Lip and Nail Duets of Love Notes and My Touch My Kiss. Deborah Lippmanns hand and foot
treatments include Rich Girl hand cream, Get Off callus softener, Soul Mission foot scrub,
CuticleRemover,andCuticleOil.

DeborahLippmannsproductsarepromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,and
YouTube,andthroughonlineblogs.Productsareavailableathighenddepartmentstores,such
asNeimanMarcus,Nordstrom,BarneysNewYork,Lord&Taylor,andBloomingdale's.TheU.S.
manufacturers sales of the company are estimated at $3 million in 2012, up by 50% from
$2millionin2011.

DEMETERFRAGRANCELIBRARY

DemeterFragranceLibraryisheadquarteredinGreatNeck,NY,andwasincorporatedbyJohn
Demeter.Establishedin2002,thecompanyemploysabout25peopleasof2012.Itmarketsa
totalofabout250productSKUsunderdifferentproducttypes,suchascolognesprays,shower
gels,bathandbodyproducts,bodylotions,andbodysplashes,positionedasnatural.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

629

630

MinorCompanies

All Demeter Fragrance Library products are either made entirely by hand, or semi
automatically,insmallbatches.Thecompanyclaimsnottoaddoruseanyartificialcolors,and
itsfragrancesarecompletelynatural.AlthoughDemeterFragraceLibraryClassicfragrancesare
all natural, the company does use some synthetic ingredients in some fragrances. The
ingredientsinthefragrancesareatleast95%derivedfromnaturalandsustainablesources,and
usenoartificialcolororPhthalatesorparabens.

DemeterFragranceLibraryfragrancesincludeVanillaCakeBatter,PureSoap,Dirt,GreenTea,
and Rain. Some of the most popular fragrances of Demeter Fragrance Library include Snow,
Grass,andWetGarden.

The company sells its products through various retail stores like Walgreens, Exit 9, Dollys
Vintage, and Rickys Sobe. Demeter Fragrance Library promotes its products through various
socialnetworkingsiteslikeFacebookandTwitter.NoTMEforthecompanyhavebeenreported
in2012.

DemeterFragranceLibraryssalesintheU.S.marketforcosmeticsandtoiletriesareestimated
at$9millionin2012,fixedat2011levels.

DERMALOGICA

Dermalogica is a privatelyheld company, which was founded by Jane Wurwand in 1986. It is


headquarteredinCarson,CA,andhasaworkforceofapproximately1,000people,ofwhich700
are located in the United States. The companys products, all manufactured in the United
States, are distributed in over 60 countries, including the United Kingdom, Ireland, Germany,
andCanada.Dermalogicahasapproximately120skincareproducts,thebulkofwhicharefor
takehomeinsteadofprofessionaluse.Therangeincludesavarietyoffacecare,bodycare,and
suncareproducts,amongothers.Thebrandalsooffersmalegroomingproducts,severalhair
careproducts,andamakeupfoundation.

Dermalogicas skin care range is segmented into a variety of product lines designed to treat
specificskinconditionsandincludescleansers,toners,exfoliants,andcreams,aswellasmore
specializedproducts,suchasacneandundereyetreatment.TheseincludeAgeSmarttotreat
aging signs, Chromawhite to treat hyperpigmentation, Ultracalming to treat hypersensitivity,
and Medibac to treat acne. Each line also has its own product kits. The product range also
includesaseriesofboosterswhich,whenappliedbeforeapplyinganotherDermalogicaproduct
ontheskin,providesanadditionalbenefitontheskin.ThefourboostersareGentleSoothing
Booster, Skin Hydrating Booster, Extra Firming Booster, and Skin Renewal Booster. The
companyalsooffersseveralhaircareproductsandamakeupfoundation.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

MinorCompanies

631

Dermalogicasproductsaresoldonline,inUltaandBluemercury,andthroughmanysalonsand
spas. It generates approximately 75% of its sales through the spas and salons channel. The
brandhasapproximately5,000activeaccountsamongwhichmostaredayspas,fulltimehair
salons,andnailsalons.Itsproductsarefoundinapproximately1,500retailoutlets,themajority
of which also offer treatment services. Growth is driven mainly by popular promotions,
especiallywithnewproductkits,andthegoodperformanceofsomeofitsretailpartners,such
asUltaandBluemercury.Thecompanyprovidessamplesofhaircare,makeup,skincareand
fragranceproductspairedwithanexclusiveissueofAlluremagazine.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012,someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

AgeSmartSkinPerfectPrimerSPF30claimstosmoothenfinelines,brighten,andprimefor
flawlessskin.
Solar Defense Booster SPF 50 is said to be formulated without artificial fragrances and
colors.
Exfoliating Body Scrub contains papaya enzymes, skinsoftening rice bran, and pulverized
olive,figanddateseedstosmoothenroughspots.
ConcealingSpotTreatment,atintedspottreatmentthathelpsconcealandclearbreakouts
uponcontact.

Global sales of the company are estimated at $130 million in 2012. The U.S. manufacturers
levelsalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforthecompanyareestimatedat$53millionin2012,up
3.8%from$51millionin2011.DermalogicahasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

DERMOVIVASKINESSENTIALS

DermovivaSkinEssentialswasestablishedin2005andisasubsidiaryofDaburIndia.In2010,
the company acquired Namaste Laboratories and its three subsidiary companiesHair
Rejuvenation & Revitalization Nigeria, Healing Hair Laboratories International, and Urban
LaboratoriesInternationalfor$100million.NamasteLaboratoriesisaleadingethnichaircare
productscompanybasednearChicago,ILwithoperationsinNorthAmerica,Europe,theMiddle
East, and Africa. It claims to offer holistic remedies that condition and renew hair, skin, and
body.

Through Namaste Laboratories, the company markets products targeted at healthconscious


multiculturalconsumers.Itsportfoliooffershaircare,skincare,andothertoiletriesproducts.
ItsmostpopularlineisnaturalhaircareproductswiththebrandnameOrganicRootStimulator.
Productsaredirectedattreatinghairconcerns,suchashairloss,thinningofhair,damagedhair,
anddryanditchyscalp.OrganicRootStimulatoruseshairstrengtheningagentsfoundinplants
to formulate its products. The brands hair care product formulations contain beta carotene,
vitaminE,horsetail,andaminoacidstoaddstrengthtofragileanddamagedhair.Dermoviva
SkinEssentialsalsomarketssoapsthataddressspecificconcernsoftheconsumers.Antiaging
soaps,moisturizingsoaps,andfairnesssoapsaresomeofitsproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

632

MinorCompanies

The company promotes its brands on its website, online blogs, social networking sites like
FacebookandYouTube,andbyprovidingdiscountcoupons.IntheUnitedStates,productsare
availableat8,000storesincludingmassmerchandiserslikeWalmart,Target,andKmart,drug
stores such as Walgreens and CVS, and other food and health stores. The products are also
retailedthroughindependentbeautyandbarbersupplyretailers.

The U.S. manufacturers sales of Dermoviva Skin Essentials for the years 2012 and 2011 are
estimatedat$9million.

DEVACURL

DevaCurl is a privatelyheld company founded in 2001 by Lorraine Massey. It has a complete


collectionofproductsforacurlylifestyle.Theproductsusehealthyoilsandbotanicalextracts,
suchasoliveoil,lavenderextracts,andwheatproteintocleanse,hydrate,andlockinmoisture
incurlyhair.

DevaCurls product portfolio consists of hair care brands to cleanse, hydrate, and style curly
hair.BrandsforcleansingandhydratingincludeDevaCurlLowPoo,DevaCurlNoPoo,DevaCare
LowPoo, DevaCare NoPoo, DevaCurl One Condition, and DevaCare One Condition. Styling
brands include DevaCurl Light Defining Gel, DevaCurl Set It Free, DevaCurl Styling Cream,
DevaCurl Spray Gel, DevaCurl Mister Right, DevaCurl SetUp & Above, and DevaCurl
MirrorCurls.

DevaCurlsbrandsarealsopromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,Pinterest,Twitter,
and YouTube. In the United States, products are available in specialty stores like Ulta and in
variousbeautysupplystores,salons,andspas.

DomesticsalesofDevacurlareestimatedatunder$1millionin2012,thesameas2011levels.

DR.BRONNERSMAGICALLONE

Dr. Bronner's Magic AllOne was established in 1948 by Emanuel Bronner. The company is
headquarteredinEscondido,CA,andisamanufacturerandmarketerofnaturalpersonalcare
products.Themarketerhasabout40employeesintheUnitedStates.Thecompanyclaimsthat
its range of personal care products is of the highest quality and conform to the standards of
environmentalawarenessandsocialresponsibility.Thecompanysclassicliquidsoapsandbar
soaps are certified organic under the United States Department of Agricultures (USDA)
NationalProgram.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

MinorCompanies

Some of its products include classic liquid and bar soaps, organic hand and body soaps, hair
conditioning rinse and crme, organic lip balms, organic body balms, organic lotions, organic
shaving gels, and organic hand sanitizers. Dr. Bronner's Magic AllOne products are mainly
distributedthroughmassmerchandisersandnaturalfoodstores.Theproductsareavailableat
Walmart, Whole Foods, Target, Walgreens, Rite Aid, and Longs Drugs. The online shopping
portalisanotherwayofsellingthecompanysproductsthroughitsownwebsite.

The company promotes its products through Facebook and Twitter and also offers 15%
discountonselectedproducts.ThecompanydoesnotallocateanyevidentamountofTMEin
2012.Dr.BronnersU.S.salesatthemanufacturerslevelare$20millionin2012,up5.3%from
$19millionin2011,drivenbypromotionalactivitieslikediscountsofferdbythecompany.

DR.FRESH

Establishedin1998,Dr.FreshisheadquarteredinLosAngeles,CA.Ithasdistributionfacilitiesin
about 35 countries worldwide with major locations in the United Kingdom and China. As of
2012,thecompanyemploysatotalof93peopleworldwideandoffersover250personalcare
products.Dr.FreshhasmanufacturingfacilitiesintheUnitedStates,China,andIndia.

The companys products are designed for both children and adults, and are sold under the
brandnamesofDr.FreshDailies,Dr.FreshTravelKits,Binaca,Firefly,Dr.Kens,andTek.The
companyalsoownslicensesofCloseUp,Peanuts,Marvel,Barbie,HotWheels,andHelloKitty.
Dr. Freshs product offerings include toothbrushes, travel kit dental floss, and denture care
products.

In April 2012, Dr. Fresh enteres into a new licensing agreement as the exclusive U.S.
manufacturerandmarketerofAngryBirds,abrandedoralcareproduct.InDecember2012,Dr.
FreshacquirestheReachbrandoftoothbrushesfromJohnson&Johnson.

The companys products are available at most mass merchandizing stores like CVS, Kmart,
Kroger, Safeway, Target, and Walmart. Products are also sold through food stores and drug
stores. Dr. Freshs new product activity is promoted through social networking sites like
YouTube.In2012,thereisnoevidentallocationofTMEforDr.Freshsproducts.

Dr.FreshssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesareestimatedat$58millionin
2012, up 1.8% from $57 million in 2010 and 2011 (both years figures include the Reach
toothbrushessales).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

633

634

MinorCompanies

DR.HAUSCHKASKINCARE

Establishedin1967andheadquarteredinEckwalden,Germany,Dr.HauschkaSkinCarehasa
rangeofprofessionallypositionednaturalskincare,haircare,bodycare,andmakeupproducts.
Itsproductsareproduced,manufactured,andmarketedbyWALAHeilmittelGmbH,aprivately
heldGermanhomeopathicpharmaceuticalscompany.

Dr.HauschkaSkinCareproductsaredevelopedusingnatural,ecological,certifiedorganic,and
sciencebased ingredients. Dr. Hauschka Skin Cares product range comprises 150 SKUs,
developed to treat skin conditions, such as mature skin, sensitive skin, normal, oily, a
combination of oily and normal, and dry skin. Dr. Hauschka also provides skin consultation
servicesandoffersitsproductsonline.

IntheUnitedStates,Dr.HauschkaSkinCareproductsareavailableinsalons,spas,naturalfood
stores,supermarkets,andhealthfoodstores.Someofthemainretaildestinationstobuythe
companys products are Whole Foods, Westerly Natural Market, Steven Alan, C.O. Bigelow,
PugetConsumerCoOp,andAnthropologie.

The company offers 20% discount on some introdcutory and travel kits. The company also
offers free shipping on any order exceeding $50.00. It also conducts its promotional and
marketing activities through social websites like YouTube, Twitter, and Facebook. Consumers
can also view skin care and makeup tips on YouTube. Dr. Hauschka Skin Care apportions a
minisculeamountofTMEin2012.Itspendslessthan$3,000onlocalmagazineadvertising.

The U.S. sales of Dr. Hauschka Skin Care cosmetics and toiletries in 2012 are estimated at
$24million,up4.3%from$23millionin2011.

E.L.F.COSMETICS

E.L.F. Cosmetics (Eyes Lips Face) was launched in 2004 by Joey Shamah and ScottVincent
Borba.The companyisbasedinNewYork,NY andmarketsanddistributesitsproductsin16
countries outside the United States, including the United Kingdom, Germany, Columbia,
Australia,SaudiArabia,CzechRepublic,Bahrain,Spain,andFrance.E.L.F.Cosmeticsoffersaline
ofprofessionalmakeuptoolsandmakeupproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

MinorCompanies

Thecompanymarkets67SKUsofmakeupproductsandskincareproducts,suchasfoundation,
concealer, bronzer, powder, blush, shimmer, tinted moisturizer, cleanser, moisturizer, eye
shadow,eyeliner,mascara,primers,lipsticks,lipgloss,lipliners,andnailpolish.SomeofE.L.F.
CosmeticsproductsincludeFlawlessFinishFoundation,TranslucentMatifyingPowder,Tinted
Moisturizer SPF 20, Baked Bronzer, Matte Eyeshadow, Kohl Eyeliner, Mascara Primer, High
Definition Undereye Setting Powder, Luscious Liquid Lipstick, Shimmer Lip Gloss, and Matte
Finisher Clear Nail Polish. In 2012, the company launches LongLasting Lustrous Eyeshadow,
Jumbo Lip Gloss Stick, Jumbo Eyeshadow Stick, Daily Moisture Stick, Contouring Blush &
BronzingCream,HDBlush(fivecolors),BakedEyeshadow,MaximumCoverageConcealerOil
Free, Pressed Mineral Eyeshadow, Baked Blush, Baked Bronzer, Defining Mascara, Lip
Exfoliator,andVolumizingMascara.

Brands are promoted extensively on social network sites like Facebook, Pinterest, YouTube,
Twitter, and Google+ and by providing educational videos to its consumers. E.L.F. Cosmetics
productsareavailableatmassmerchandisestoreslikeWalmart,Target,andKmart;drugstores
like CVS, Rite Aid, and Walgreens; grocery stores such as H.E.B.; and online retailers like
amazon.com,dermstore.com,drugstore.com,andeyeslipsface.com.

Thisprivatelyheldcompanyhasastaffofaround30people.Corporatesalesofthecompany
areintherangeof$75millionand$85million.In2012,theU.S.manufacturerssalesofE.L.F.
Cosmeticsareestimatedtogrowby33.3%to$32millionfrom$24millionin2011.Salesgrowth
is supported by increased distribution channels and by the introduction of various new
products.

EQUITIUMGROUP

TheEquitiumGroupisaMiamibasedinvestmentfirmfocusedontheluxury,fashion,beauty,
health, and personal care industries. In 2007, the company acquired CaswellMassey, the
Edison,NewJerseybasedpurveyorofluxurypersonalgroomingproducts.CaswellMasseywas
foundedin1752inNewport,RIasDr.HuntersDispensary.Thecompanyproduceshighquality
groomingproductsincludingsoaps,lotions,fragrances,andotherpersonalcareitems.

CaswellMasseys product offerings include approximately 1,100 SKUs comprising bath and
body products, fragrances, facial treatments, and other toiletries. CaswellMasseys range of
brandsincludeDr.HuntersOriginalRemedies,Patyka,LuckyTiger,ClausPorto,ColonelConk,
Dr.Sharp,GiannaRose,IreneHirose,Me!Bath,MusgoReal,Roger&Gallet,andNaturopathica.

In 2011, Lorell Marketing Group collaborated with CaswellMassey to release the companys
first directtoconsumer catalog for the Gianna Rose brand, a luxury collection of beautifully
moldedbarsoapsandbathaccessories.ThecataloghelpedexpandtheGiannaRoseaudience,
increaseproductawareness,andhelpconsumersdiscovernewproducts.In2011,thecompany
also partnered with the Google catalog application for the iPad. The application allows users
access to a diverse group of catalogs, makeawish list or collage of favorite products, post
itemsonFacebookoremailtofriendsandfamily,andviewbehindthescenesphotoshoots,
videos,andtutorials.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

635

636

MinorCompanies

In 2012, the company introduces a variety of products including Pure Frost a limited edition
fragrance; the Botanicals Collection, available in three fragrances: Fig & Bamboo, Vetiver &
Cardamom, and Coriander & Mandarin; the Lavender line of products comprising an eau de
toilette, bar soap, body butter, body lotion, hand and body wash, hand cream, and talc. In
2012,thecompanyalsoreformulatesitsShavingEssentialsline.

The companys distribution network includes standalone retail stores, department stores,
onlineshoppingportal,andthenewlyintroducedcatalogs.

Sustainabilityisveryimportanttothecompanyandthereforeallitssoapsarevegetablebased
andbiodegradable.Thecompanyalsousesbiodegradableorrecyclablepackaging.In2012,the
companysgivesamakeovertoitsproductspackaging.IthasnoTMEin2012.

The U.S. sales of cosmetics and toiletries for CaswellMassey products are estimated at
$13millionin2012,up8.3%from$12millionin2011.

EOSPRODUCTS

EOSProducts,whichstandsforEvolutionofSmooth,cameintobeingin2008withthelaunchof
itsUltraMoisturizingShaveCream.ThecompanyisheadquarteredinNewYorkandspecializes
innatural,innovative,andstylishlypackagedproductsthataretargetedtowardswomen.

EOSProductsofferingsnowincludelipbalms,jellies,andtreatments,handandbodylotions,
and shaving products. The EOS lip balms are the bestsellers for the company. The lip balm
smoothsphereandthehandlotionareuniquelypackedinsphereshapedcontainersthathave
an almost velvety touch on the outside. The company claims the EOS Smooth Spheres to be
100%NaturalandpackedwithvitaminEandSheaButter.EOSlipbalmsarecertifiedorganicby
theU.S.departmentofAgriculture(USDA).

InSeptember2012,EOSlaunchestheAliceinWonderlandLimitedEditionsetwhichincludes
threeflavoredlipbalmsincludingBlueberryPotion,SweetVanillaNonsense,andWatermelon
Wonderland. These lip balms come with a Mickey Mouse shaped indentation for the fingers.
Alsoin2012,thecompanyintroducesthePomegranateRaspberryflavoredLipBalm.

EOS finds mention in articles in popular fashion and beauty magazines including Brides,
Womens Health, Lucky, Teen Vogue, Star, OK!, Seventeen, and Cosmopolitan. It also
aggressivelyadvertisesinprintmedia,referringtoitsproductsscentsasflavors.

EOSProductshasachievedbroaddistributioninarelativelyshorttime.Thebrandisavailableat
mass merchandisers such as Walmart, Target, and Costco; drug stores including CVS,
Walgreens, RiteAid, and Duane Reade; online retailers, such as drugstore.com, soap.com,
amazon.com,andthecompanyswebsite.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

MinorCompanies

Sales for EOS Products in 2011 totaled $16 million. In 2012, the company shows a growth of
81.3%toreach$29million.Growthin2012issupportedbyaninordinatelyhighTMEof$17.7
million.ThelaunchoftheAliceinWonderlandLimitedEdition,rapidlyexpandingdistribution,
andthegoodperformanceofthelipbalmswhoseuniqueshapesstandoutonretailshelves
aidsinthecompanysgrowth.

ERNOLASZLO

In 1927, Erno Laszlo was founded by a Hungarian dermatologist and cosmetic businessman
namedErnoLaszlo.HeadquarteredatNewYork,NY,thecompanyprovidesdermatologicalskin
care products. In February 2011, RBS Special Opportunities Fund managed by RBS Equity
FinancebackedCharlesDentonintheacquisitionofErnoLaszlo.CharlesDentonisanEnglish
entrepreneurwhohasheldthepositionofchiefexecutiveinseveralbusinessenterprises.

Erno Laszlos product portfolio includes various skin care products, such as facial cleansers,
toners,moisturizers,antiaging,serums,masks,exfoliators,handcare,andbodycare.Products
aresegregatedonthebasisoftheskintype,concern,andcategory.Thecompanyalsoprovides
treatmentsforfacewrinkles,finelines,lackoffirmness,acne,stressedskin,skindiscoloration,
sun protection, and facial redness. In 2012, Erno Laszlo launches The Hollywood Collection, a
limitededitioncollectionofcustomblendedskincareformulations.TheHollywoodCollection
includes five productsInstant Eye Repair, Intensive Porcelain Veil, Morning Beauty Rescue,
RefreshMoistureInfusion,andVelvetNightCream.

Erno Laszlo promotes its products on social networking sites, such as Facebook, Twitter,
Google+, and YouTube and in magazines, such as Allure, Vanity Fair, Marie Claire, Harpers
Bazaar,People,andGlamour.Theproductsareavailableathighenddepartmentstores,such
asSaksFifthAvenue,Nordstrom,NeimanMarcus,andBergdorfGoodman.

Thecompanyssalesareestimatedtogrowby14.3%to$8millionin2012,upfrom$7millionin
2011.Salesgrowthissupportedbytheintroductionofnewproducts.

E.T.BROWNE

Establishedin1971,E.T.BrowneDrugCompanyisheadquarteredinEnglewoodCliffs,NJ,andis
amanufacturerandmarketerofpersonalcareproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

637

638

MinorCompanies

Many of E.T. Brownes products are sold under the brand name Palmers. Palmers sells five
differentnaturalbasedskincareandhaircarelinesunderthenamesofCocoaButterFormula,
Shea Butter Formula, Olive Oil Formula, Olive Butter Formula, and Coconut Oil Formula.
However, E.T. Brownes ethnic hair care products are sold under the brand name Black &
Beautiful.

In2011,thecompanyhasaddedfournewproductstoitslineofPalmersCocoaButterFormula
SkinCareproductswhichincludePalmersCocoaButterFormulagentleexfoliatingfacialscrub,
PalmersCocoaButterFormulalotion,andPalmersCocoaButterFormulatummybutter.

Thecompanysproductsareretailedthroughfood,drug,andmassmerchandisersnationwide,
includingWalmart,Target,DuaneReade,Walgreens,andCVS.In2012,alargeportionofthe
companysTMEatalmost$15millonisattributedtotheCocoaButterformulaline.Overall,
in 2012, the marketer spends a TME of $18.8 million, spread primarily across television and
magazineadvertising.

Thecompanyconductsalotofpromotionalandmarketingactivitiesthorughsocialnetworking
siteswhichincludeFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.ThecompanypromotesitsCocoaButter
Formula lip care and skin care range on its Facebook page. The company also promotes its
prodcutsthroughcoupons.

E.T. Brownes U.S. sales of cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at $34 million in 2012, up
3.0% from $33million in 2011, mainly driven by the increased promotional and marketing
activities.

EUROITALIA

Euroitaliawasfoundedin1978byGiovanniSgariboldiandsoonbecamealeadingplayerinthe
market for selective fragrances and makeup. The company is headquartered in Milan, Italy.
Euroitalia and its subsidiary Giver Profumi, have the license to manufacture and distribute
Versace and Moschino beauty products in the United States. Versace Profumi is the U.S.
subsidiaryofthecompany,locatedinNewYork.

Euroitalia is known to have specialized expertise in designing, manufacturing, retailing, and


distributing luxury fragrances, makeup, and skin care products. The company employs
approximately20employeesintheUnitedStatesasof2012.Euroitaliahasworldwidepresence
throughqualifiedsubsidiariesanddistributors.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

MinorCompanies

AfewofEuroitaliasbrandsincludeVersace,JohnRichmond,andMoschino.In2012,Euroitalia
introduces fragrances, such as the Viva Rock John Diamond, Yellow Diamonds, and Versace
Vanitas.In2012,thecompanysTMEamountstoapproximately$9million,withmajorityofit
being attributed towards magazine advertisements. Majority of the TME expenditure for the
company in 2012 is allocated to the Versace Bright Crystal and Versace Yellow Diamond
fragrances. The Versace Yellow Diamonds print advertisement features Australian model,
AbbeyLeeKershaw.

The marketing activities for these brands is mainly through print advertisements in leading
fashion and beauty magazines, such as Allure, Cosmpolitan, Glamour, and Vanity Fair and
television advertisements The company has a wellconnected distribution network in the
UnitedStates.Theproductsareretailedinover700doors,includingsomespecialtystores,such
asMacys,SephoraUlta,andNordstrom.

Domestic manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries are $17million in 2012, up 13.3%
from$15millionin2011.

EXPANSCIENCELABORATORIES

Expanscience Laboratories was founded by Paul Berthom and Claude Guillon in 1950 and is
headquarteredinCourbevoie,France.ItoperatesasasubsidiaryofLaboratoriesExpanscience.
The company manufactures and distributes its products under the brand Mustela. It has
subsidiaries in Spain, Portugal, Italy, Belgium, Switzerland, Poland, Mexico, and the United
States. Its brand Mustela is sold in about 40 countries through its own subsidiaries and
distributorcompanies.Thecompanyhasabout12employeesintheUnitedStatesanditsoffice
islocatedinNewYork.

The company provides dermocosmetic products for babies, for pregnant women, and young
mothers.TheproductrangeundertheMustelabrandincludes,Bbdesignedforthehygiene,
bathing, changing, and skin protection of babies; DermoPediatrics skin care products
dedicated to caring for skin problems of newborns, babies, and children; 9 Months a line
createdtotakecareofskinbothduringpregnancyandaftergivingbirth;andSunprotection
sunprotectionfornewborns,babies,andchildren.

The companys product offering includes norinse cleansing fluids, facial cleansing cloths,
alcoholfreefragrancesprays,ultraprotectivefaceandbodylotions,moisturizingandsoftening
bodylotions,massageoils,nourishingandmoisturizingbalmforlipsandcheeks,soaps,dermo
cleansing gels, soapfree cleansers for hair and body, foam shampoos for newborns, baby
shampoos, cleansing milks, cleansing and soothing wipes, vitamin barrier creams, and sun
protectioncreams.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

639

640

MinorCompanies

The company sells its products through retailers, such as Sephora, Ulta, Skinstore, and
Dermstore. In 2012, manufacturers sales of the company in the U.S cosmetics and toiletries
marketareestimatedtobestagnantatrounded$2million,upfromthe2011salesofslightly
lessthan$2million.NoTMEforExpanscienceLaboratoriesbrandsareevidentin2012.

FACESTOCKHOLM

FACE Stockholm is a marketer and distributor of skin care products, makeup products, and
accessories, and is headquartered at Hudson, NY. The company is owned and operated by a
motherdaughter duo, Gun Nowak and Martina Arfwidson. The companys first shop was
openedin1982andwasanimmediatesuccess.FACEStockholmsproductsareavailableatover
50 locations globally. The companys product offerings include products for lips, eyes, face,
nails,skincare,andbodycare,aswellasbrushesandtools,bagsandcases,andeyewear.Some
oftheproductsofferedbyFACEStockholmareSkimrande,HealingFeet,BambooWalnutScrub,
NailSaver,AgelessToner,PerfectPrimer,andAloeVeraIntenseMoistureCream.

The company launches three liquid foundations in 2012: Ageless Foundation, Fresh Face
Foundation, and Mineral Foundation for all skin types. FACE Stockholm also launches Gldje
lipstick.ItalsolaunchesanewrangeofnailpolishincollaborationwithJ.Crew,amultibrand
specialty retailer of mens and womens clothing in the United States: Vibrant Flame, Neon
Sunset, Tulle Time, and Pinched Cheeks. It promotes through social and digital media like
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTubeinformingaboutnewproductlaunches,andprovidingdetails
onbenefitsandusageofitsproducts.ThereisnoevidentallocationofTMEbythecompanyin
2012.

FACEStockholmsproductsareavailableincompanyownedshopsintheUnitedStates(there
are three, all located in New York state), Sweden, Norway, and Finland, as well as through
different retail outlets and salons across the United States, the United Kingdom, Ukraine,
Sweden,Spain,SanMarino,Norway,theNetherlands,Italy,Germany,France,Canada,Belgium,
andAustria.Eachofitsstoreshasaprofessionaltogivemakeupadvicetoitsconsumers.

FACE Stockholms sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States remain constant at
$8millionin2011and2012.

FALICFASHIONGROUP

Falic Fashion Group was started by three brothersSimon, Jerome, and Leon Falicand the
company is headquartered in Hollywood, FL. Falic Fashion Group operates as a subsidiary of
DutyFreeAmericas,thelargestdutyfreeretailstoreoperatorinNorthAmerica.Thecompanys
regionalofficeisinPanama,anditoperatesacrossLatinAmerica.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

MinorCompanies

Thecompanyisonlyintofragrancesitdevelopsanddistributesfragrancesworldwide.Some
ofthefragrancesonofferare:PerryEllisforMen,PerryEllisNight,PerryEllisforWomen,Eva
by Eva Longoria, Dy and Dyamante by Daddy Yankee, as well as the fragrance from Jennifer
Aniston.ThePerryEllisfragrancefranchisewasacquiredbythecompanyinJanuary2007.

Asizeableamountofthecompanysrevenuecomesfromthedutyfreestores,whichisoutof
the scope of this study. The products are also sold across specialty stores, such as Sephora;
departmentsstoresNordstrom,Dillards,Macys,andPerfumania,aswellasWalmart.

Thecompanysdistributionnetworkcomprisesover120dutyfreeshopsinmajorinternational
airports like Boston, Chicago, New York, Washington, and Miami, as well as international
gateways. It promotes through social and digital media like Facebook and YouTube. The
companydoesnotallocateanyTMEin2012.

FalicGroupssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesareestimatedremainfixedat
$3millionin2011and2012.

FOCUS21

Focus21wascreatedin1980byhairstylists,cosmologists,andchemiststosolvehairandskin
care related problems. Soon after its establishment as a salon brand, Richard Ravid acquired
Focus21in1997.ItislocatedinRoyalOak,MI.Thecompanymarketshaircare,skincare,and
nailcareproducts.

Focus21shairproductsincludeFocus21SplashFinishingSpray,Focus21SplashSculptingFirm
Gel, Focus 21 Panasea Emergency Hair Repairing Formula, Focus 21 Panasea Hair Repair
DetanglingShampoo,Focus21JojobaShampoo,Focus21SeaplasmaDesigningGel,andFocus
21SeaplasmaHairBoosterPlus+.SomeofitsnaillaminateproductsincludeLiquidGlassNail
Laminate,NoMoreChipsNailLaminate,andNoMoreWrapsNailLaminate.Nonewproducts
arelaunchedin2012.

Focus 21s brands are available with online retailers like amazon.com, ebay.com, and
drugstore.comandatselectretailstoreslikeUltaandSears.Thebrandsarepromotedthrough
brochures.

Focus 21 employs a staff of approximately 70 people. Domestic sales of the company are
estimatedfor2012and2011areapproximatedat$8million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

641

642

MinorCompanies

FREEMANBEAUTY

Freeman Beauty Labs was founded in 1976 and is based in Beverly Hills, CA. It operates as a
subsidiary of pH Beauty Labs, Inc. It provides a range of skin care products, hand and body
lotions,footcareproducts,andhaircareproducts.

ThecompanysskincareproductsaresoldundertheproductlinesFeelingBeautiful,VitaK
Professional,andEclos.BareFoot,BareFootRepair,BareHands,FeelingBeautiful,andC.Booth
areofferedunderFreemansbodycaresegment.Thecompanyshaircareproductsportfolio
comprises shampoos, conditioners, and hair styling products under Papaya, Pssssst, and Ellin
Lavarbrands.SomeofthebestsellingFreemanproductsarebarefootpeppermintandplum
footscrub,Psssstinstantdryshampoo,FeelingBeautifulavocadoandoatmealfacialclaymask,
andFeelingBeautifulmintandlemonfacialclaymask.

Freeman launched its new website in 2011 that tries to convey a youthful, accessible, and
modern image. The companys products are sold at its online stores as well as through drug
stores,foodstores,andmassmerchandisers.Walgreens,Target,CVS,andWalmartaresomeof
theleadingretailchainswhichmarketFreemanproducts.In2012,noTMEforFreemanBeauty
productsareobservable.

FreemanBeautyLabssalesintheUnitedStatesforcosmeticsandtoiletriesremainalmostflat
for2011and2012,andareestimatedat$9million.

FRESH

Freshwasfoundedin1991byLevGlazmanandAlinaRoytberg.Theprivatelyheldcompanyis
headquarteredinNewYorkCity,NY.FreshpartneredwithLVMHin2000gainingadvantageof
LVMHsvaluableexperienceinresearchanddevelopmentandexpertiseintheprestigemarket.

Today,outsideofitsownstores,Freshproductsaresoldacrosstheglobeanditsproductrange
in the United States includes fragrances, skin care products, hair care products, makeup
products,othertoiletries,andproductsforthehome.

In 2012, Fresh celebrates its 21st Birthday with the launch of a R. Nicholsdesigned limited
edition collection of Oval Soap Series and Stationery Set. The collection has been inspired by
three fresh scents including Patchouli, Sugar, and, Hesperides Grapefruit. Additionally, the
brand is giving out a complimentary Mini Sugar Lip Treatment Advanced Therapy with online
orders above $100. Also in 2012, the company introduces Sugar Berry Tinted Lip Treatment
Sunscreen SPF 15 which moisturizes, protects, and soothes lips while leaving a berry tint;
Seaberry Restorative Body Cream Tube hydrating and nourishing cream to soothe irritation;
SakeBathMini,withacompositionofmorethan38%sake;RoseHydratingGelCream,adaily
moisturizer that provides 24hour moisturization and protects against pollution; Peony
WhiteningEssence,adailyformulathathelpscorrectunevenskintoneandhyperpigmentation
and;RoseCleansingFoam,adailycleanserthathydratesandrejuvenatesskin.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

MinorCompanies

Freshholdsinstoreeventsregularly.FreshoffersaReFreshClientRewardsProgramwherein
clientsearnsrewardsforevery$100spentataFreshretailstore.Upon$500ofexpenditure,
clients are entitled to receive a $50 gift card. Presence on social media networks, such as
Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest are of significance to Fresh in promoting its products. Fresh
products are also featured on the home shopping network, QVC. The company does not
allocateanysignificantamountofTMEin2012.

Fresh products are sold at independent outlets across Boston, New York, Los Angeles, San
Francisco,LasVegas,andDallas.Thebrandisalsopresentatotherretailers,suchasSephora,
Kiss & Makeup, Barneys New York, Blue mercury, CO Bigelow, and Neiman Marcus. Fresh
productsareavailableforpurchaseonlineonthecompanyswebsiteaswell.

Sales for Fresh in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market at the manufacturers level total
$11millionin2012,up10.0%from$10millionin2011.

FRUITOFTHEEARTH

FruitoftheEarthwasfoundedbytheMcCurryandMichellfamiliesin1980.Itisheadquartered
inFortWorth,TX.Thecompanyisamanufacturerandmarketerofpersonalcareproductsand
health care products. The products are formulated based on the beneficial qualities of aloe
vera. Fruit of the Earth also offers three variants of dietary supplements which are based on
aloeverajuice.

Thecompanymanufacturesabout64SKUsofskincareproducts.Itprovidesfacialtreatments
that include moisturizer, cleanser, scrub, face mask, face serum, face crme, eye crme, and
skin care oil. The companys sun care products include general protection, dark tanning, full
spectrum continuous spray, and aftersun products for babies and kids. Its sunless tanning
productsofferlight,medium,anddarktanningcreams.Thecompanyslatestproductsinclude
vitaminEdailydefensemoisturizerandvitaminEalmonddailyscrubthatwereintroducedin
2010.

FruitoftheEarthpromotesitsproductsonsocialnetworksites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,and
YouTube. Theproductsareavailableatdrug,food,andmassmerchandiserstoreslikeKmart,
Shopko, CVS, Albertsons, Walgreens, Meijer, Family Dollar, HEB, Fred Meyer, Dollar General,
Safeway,RiteAid,andWalmart.

Fruit of the Earth has 75 employees as of 2012. Sales of the company are estimated at $7
millionin2012,evenwiththe2011sales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

643

644

MinorCompanies

FUSIONBRANDS

Fusion Brands was established in 2003 and is based in Ottawa, Canada. Fusion Brands
manufactures and markets makeup and fragrance products. The companys products include
lotions, shower gels, lip color, lip liner, antiwrinkle moisturizers, and foundations. Its brands
includeCleanPerfume,FusionBeauty,andScentology.

FusionBrandshas16fragranceSKUs, ofwhich11arespecificallyforwomen.Thecompanys
FusionBeautybrandoffersfacialskincareandmakeupproductsundertheproductlinesSkin
Fusion,LipFusion,GlowFusion,LiftFusion,andLashFusion.

ThecompanysproductsaredistributedintheUnitedStates,Canada,Japan,Korea,Singapore,
Taiwan,Denmark,Finland,Holland,Norway,Sweden,andinEurope(dutyfreestores).

The Clean Perfume and Skin Fusion brands are distributed through department stores and
specialty stores, such as Nordstrom, Bloomingdales, Ulta, Sephora, Macys, and Saks Fifth
Avenue. Skin Fusion is also sold on the Internet and television through avenues, such as the
ShoppingChannel,HomeShoppingNetworks,andskinstore.com.Scentologyproductsaresold
exclusivelyatthemassmerchandiserTarget.

SomeoftheprominentprodcutsincludeStimuLashFusion,anintensivenightconditioninglash
enhancer treatment; PrimeResults, an antiwrinkle primer value set, and IllumiFill, line filling
luminizer.

Fusion Brands promotes its prodcuts through social websites which include Facebook and
Twitter.Italsogivescomplementaryfreegiftwithpurchasesthatexcced$60.00ormore,and
alsohasaschemeoffreeshippingforanyorderexceeding$50.00ormore.NosignificantTME
havebeenreportedbythecompanyin2012.

TheU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforFusionBrandsareflatatapproximately$14million
in2012,sameasthe2011levels.

GALDERMALABORATORIES

Formed as a joint venture between LOral and Nestle in 1981, to become a prominent
dermatology company, Galderma Laboratories, the Switzerlandbased company, is the
developerandmarketerofdermatologyproductsmeanttoprovidetherapeutic,corrective,and
aesthetic solutions. Galderma Laboratories is headquartered in Fort Worth, TX. The company
hasresearchanddevelopmentfacilitiesintheUnitedStates,Japan,France,andSweden.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

MinorCompanies

Thecompanyoffersawiderangeofproducts,fromskincaretotopicaltreatmentsformajor
dermatological conditions. It addresses a number of skin conditions, which include acne,
dermatitis,melasma,rosacea,andpsoriasis.Inthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry,Galderma
LaboratoriescompetesinfacialtreatmentsandhandandbodylotionswithitsCetaphilbrand.

Cetaphil is retailed through food stores, drug stores, and mass merchandisers in the United
States. Cetaphil is primarily promoted through recommendations from doctors and
dermatologists.ThecompanyallocatesnegligibleamountsonTMEin2012.

In2012,CetaphillaunchesCetaphilDermaControlproducts,alineforacneproneskin.Anew
product,CetaphilMoisturizingCream,isavailableatWalgreens,beginningSeptember2012.

GaldermassalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesreach$92millionin2012,up
7.0%from$86millionin2011basedonnewproductlaunches,aswellasonitscorporatesocial
initiatives,whichhelpsinbrandrecall.

THEGAP

The Gap is a global specialty apparel company started in 1969. It is headquartered in San
Francisco, CA. The company offers personal care products, apparel, and accessories for men,
women,andchildren.Ithasmorethan132,000employeesworldwide.

The company sells its products under five brands including Gap, Old Navy, Banana Republic,
Piperlime,andAthleta.Thecompanyhasover3,263storesglobally,ofwhich3,036storesare
companyoperated and the rest are franchise store locations. The Gap stores operate in the
United States, Canada, the United Kingdom, France, Ireland, Japan, China, and Italy. In early
2012, it opens a new store in South Africa. The Gap operates under two segments: Stores,
whichincludetheoperationsoftheretailstoresforGap,OldNavy,andBananaRepublicand
Direct, which includes the operations for its online brands, both domestic and international.
Thecompanysproductsareavailableonlinetocustomersinover90countriesthroughitsown
website.

The company markets personal care products under an agreement with Inter Parfums Inc.
Womens fragrances from Banana Republic include W, Alabaster, Malachite, Jade, and
Rosewood.BananaRepublicsmensfragrancesareBlackWalnut,Slate,Classic,andCordovan.
Fragrance lines for Gap include Gap Bath+Body, Gap Body, and G7 for Men and Individuals.
Banana Republic and Gap offer ancillary skin care and body care products for their fragrance
brands. The company promotes its products through directmail initiatives, circulars, and
couponprograms.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

645

646

MinorCompanies

TheU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesare$35millionin2012,upfrom$33millionin2011.
Thecompanyspends$1.8millionTMEtosupportitsbrandsin2012anditallocatestheentire
TMEtosupportitsBananaRepublicbrand.

GIOVANNIORGANICCOSMETICS

GiovanniOrganicCosmeticswasfoundedbyArthurGiovanniandisheadquarteredinBeverly
Hills,CA.Thiscompanydevelopsanorganiclineofskincareproductsformenandwomen.It
usesapatentedGiovanniPureOrganicTechnologythatincorporatesvitamins,herbs,minerals,
proteins,nutrients,andessentialoils.

GiovanniOrganicCosmeticsmanufacturesandmarketsaround63SKUsthatcatertohaircare,
personal cleansing, and skin care products. Its hair care products include shampoos,
conditioners, hair styling products, and hair repair treatments, while skin care includes body
lotions,facialcleanser,scrubs,moisturizer,andfacemask.Thecompanyalsooffersbodywash,
liquid soaps, body bars, body scrubs in the personal cleansing product class. The company
markets these products under brand names, such as Four Elements, Four Dreams, D:tox
System,Colorflage,2chic,andMagnetic.In2012,GiovanniOrganicCosmeticsintroducesanew
line called Wellness System with a Scalp Serum, and Conditioning & Styling Elixir. The 2chic
brand introduces eight variants which includes shampoos, conditioner, blow out styling mist,
flatironstylingmist,stylingelixir,hairandbodypotion,bodywash,andbodylotion.

Giovanni Organic Cosmetics advertises its products in popular magazines, such as Good
Housekeeping,People,Cosmopolitan,Allure,Health,andLucky.Productsarealsopromotedon
socialnetworkingsites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.GiovanniOrganicCosmetics
products are available in mass merchandiser stores, Target and Walmart, drug stores such as
CVS,foodstoressuchasKroger,WholeFoods,andFredMeyer,aswellasUlta.

Giovanni Organic Cosmetics is a privately owned company and employs 56 people. Sales are
estimatedtogrowat11.1%to$10millionin2012from$9millionin2011.

GOSMILE

GoSmilewasfoundedin2002bydentistJonathanLevine.In2008,JHPartners,aSanFrancisco,
CAbasedprivateequityfirmacquiredGoSmile.Aftertheacquisition,theheadquartersofGo
SmileshiftedfromNewYork,NYtoBerkley,CA.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

MinorCompanies

Go Smile provides whitening light systems, teeth whitening pens, prewhitening gels,
toothpastes, and whitening ampoules. Based on Kline & Companys categorization, these
products can be divided into tooth whitening products and toothpastes. The company has a
workforceofapproximately50employeesasof2012.

ProductsareofferedunderWhitenYourTeethandKeepYourTeethWhiteregimens.The
company also offers sets and kits. Go Smiles products are distributed through retail stores,
online retailers, dental offices, and spas. Go Smile products are available in over 300 outlets
includingBliss,BeautyBrands,Bluemercury,Nordstrom,SaksFifthAvenue,andUlta.

Go Smile is present on social networking sites, such as Facebook and Twitter and offers a
numberofonlinediscountsandvaluedealsonthesesites.GoSmiledoesnotadvertiseitsown
products,butSephoradoesinvestminimallyinTMEforthebrand.

Sales for the company in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries are $12million in 2012, flat from
2011.

GRACECHOI

GraceChoidebutsherbeautyskincarelineinmid2012.Sheisanentrepreneur,basedinNew
YorkCityandBostonwhoinventedmedicaldevicespreviously.Herinterestinskincarebegan
asaresearcheratWeillCornellMedicalCollege.GraceChoiwasinspiredbyKoreanBBcreams
tocreateherownBBandCCcreams.

Shelaunchesherallinonemediumtofullcoverageantiaging,sunblock,darkspotrepair,oil
control,andskinsmoothingproduct.GraceChoiPorcelainSkinBBCreamisavailableinadewy
or matte finish. The mineralbased cream provides a natural looking coverage while it treats
and conditions skin throughout the day. It is the first BB cream to be offered in 10 different
shades,suchasneutral,lightpink,mediumpink,lightolive,mediumolive,deepolive,medium
yellow, and dark yellow. The product can be obtained from the companys website, even
thoughinfall2012thereisawaitlisttofulfillorders.GraceChoiCCCreamwillbelaunchedin
early2013.

Domesticsalesofthecompanyareestimatedatlessthan$1millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

647

648

MinorCompanies

HAIRRULES

Hair Rules was founded in 2008 by Anthony Dickey and Kara Young Georgiopolous. The
companyisbasedinNewYork,NY,andofferssalonpositionedhairproducts.Itoffersarange
ofhydratingcleansers,conditioners,andstylingaidstohairtypesdefinedaskinky,curly,and
wavy. Hair Rules product portfolio consists of hair care products, such as shampoos,
conditioners, styling, and finishing hair products. Some of its brands include Aloe Grapefruit
Purifying Shampoo, Quench Conditioner, Blow Out Your Kinks, Curly Whip, Wavy Mousse,
VolumizingHairSpray,andHydratingFinishingCream.ThecompanyintroducesLiftVolumizing
Shampoo, Blow It All Out (straight styling for all textures), and a 4Piece Trial Set for kinky,
curly,andwavyhairin2012.

BrandsarepromotedonsocialnetworkingsiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,YouTube,andGoogle+.
Onlineblogsandtestimonialspublicizetheeffectivenessoftheproducts.IntheUnitedStates,
HairRulesproductsareavailableinTarget,Walgreens,andvarioussalons.Corporatesalesof
thecompanyareexpectedtogrowby11.1%in2012to$1millionfrom$900,000in2011.

HAMPTONSUN

Hampton Sun is a private company founded by Salvatore and Grant in the year 2005. The
companymanufacturesanddistributesacompletelineofluxurysuntanningproductsdesigned
especially for individuals who enjoy the sun. The company is headquartered in New York.
Aside from sun care products, the company sells skin care products and fragrances under
HamptonSunandPrivetBloombrands.

All of the companys products are made with natural and organic oils, vitamins A through E,
Aloe,andpowerfulantioxidants.

In2012,thecompanylaunchesSPF8BronzeContinuousMistSunscreen,whichisclaimedto
offer the highest quality sun protection with a new hypoallergenic and oilfree formula
containingalightamountofitssignaturescent.

ThecompanysellsitsproductsthroughvariousretailersincludingBeautyBar,BlinkBeach,Blue
mercury, Hhbeauty, and Saks. It also markets its products through resorts, cruise ships, and
specialtyretailerSephora.

HamptonSunssalesintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketareestimatedat$5millionin
2012,upfrom$4millionin2011.HamptonSunhasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

MinorCompanies

HERBALIFEINTERNATIONAL

Herbalife International was founded by Mark Hughes in 1980 and is headquartered in Los
Angeles, CA. The company manufactures and distributes nutrition, weightmanagement, and
skin care products globally. It employs around 5,100 employees worldwide. The company
distributes its products in 84 countries through a network of approximately 2.7 million
independentdistributors.

AllproductsaremarketedundertheHerbalifebrandname.Personalcareproductsmarketed
by the company include skin care, bath and body, fragrances, and hair care products. The
companyoffersthreelinesoffacialtreatments:NourifusionSkinEssentials,RadiantC,andSkin
Activator.TheHerbalAloelineoffershandandbodylotions,personalcleansingproducts,and
haircareproducts.Fragrancesareofferedinfourlines:Heart,Soul,Man,andWoman.

Total sales for Herbalife International are $4,154 million in 2012, up from $3,454 million in
2011. The U.S. manufacturers level sales of cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at
$25million in 2012, up from $23 million in 2011. Herbalife International has negligible TME
recordedin2012.

HERMSINTERNATIONALGROUP

Herms International Group was founded in 1837 by Thierry Herms and is based in Paris,
France. The companymanufactures and markets highfashion clothing and accessories. It has
14productdivisionsconsistingofleather,scarves,men'swear,women'sfashion,ties,watches,
perfume, stationery, footwear, decorative arts, enamel, gloves, tableware, and jewelry.
ParfumsHerms,itssubsidiaryintheUnitedStates,islocatedinNewYork,NY.Thiscompany
markets,distributes,andretailsluxurygoodsinNorthAmerica.

Thecompanyspersonalcareportfolioconsistsoffragranceproducts,theearliestofwhichwas
launchedin1951,EaudHerms.ItsnicheHermssencecollectionconsistsof10fragrancesthat
can be used by both men and women, including Rose Ikebana, Vtiver Tonka, and Ambre
Narguil. The company markets another eight unisex fragrances, including the Voyage
d'Herms, Eau de Pamplemousse Rose, Eau de Gentiane Blanche, and Jardin sur le Toit.
Furthermore, the Herms International Group develops nine fragrances for women and four
fragrancesformen.In2012,thecompanyintroducestwofragrancesforbothmenandwomen:
LAmbredesMerveillesandVoyagedHermsEaudeParfum.

Herms International Group promotes its products on social network sites like Facebook,
Google+, and YouTube. In the United States, products are distributed through 300 highend
department stores, such as Neiman Marcus and Nordstrom, in addition to 23 standalone
Hermsboutiques.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

649

650

MinorCompanies

Herms International Group has 9,526 employees at the end of June 2012. Estimated U.S.
manufacturers sales for cosmetics and toiletries in 2012 are $9 million, tantamount to 2011
sales.

HOUSEOFCREED

HeadquarteredinParis,France,HouseofCreedisaprivatelyownedluxuryfragrancecompany.
The company was founded by James Henry Creed in 1760 as a perfume boutique in London,
andsincethen,leadershiphasbeenpassedfromfathertosonforsixgenerations.Thecurrent
headofthecompanyisOlivierCreed,tobesucceededbyhisson,ErwinCreed.Themarketer
claims that their fragrances are hand made using natural essences. New Yorkbased
InternationalCosmetics&PerfumesdistributesCreedproductsintheUnitedStates.

Creedscollectioncomprisesfragrancesformenandwomen,handandbodylotions,personal
cleansingproducts,antiperspirantsanddeodorants,homefragrances,andcandles.Someofthe
popular brands from the company include Jasmal, Irisia, Orange Spice, Royal English Leather,
RoyalScottishLavender,andOriginalVetiver.

In2012,thecompanyintroducesluxurybodyproductsincludingabathandshowergel,large
handmilledsoap,aftershavebalm,andanonalcoholicdeodorantfortheMillesimeImperial
fragrance. In 2012, the company launches a product line the Acqua Fiorentina, The Encore
whichincludesafragranceforwomen,bathandshowergel,triplemilledsoap,nourishingbody
lotion,andnonalcoholicdeodorant.In2012,Aventus,oneofthemostpopularfragrancesof
Creed, also introduces its own line of luxury products comprising a shower gel, handmilled
soap,aftershavebalm,andanonalcoholicdeodorant(retailingfor$65).

Creed fragrances are retailed through Creed boutiques, the companys website, and luxury
retailers including Bergdorf Goodman, Neiman Marcus, Saks Fifth Avenue, select Nordstrom
andBloomingdaleslocations,VonMaur,Halls,andHoltRenfrew.TheHouseofCreeddoesnot
advertise,relyinginsteadonwordofmouthandeditorialplacement.

The U.S. manufacturers sales of House of Creed fragrances grow 10.0% from $10 million in
2011to$11millionin2012.

INTERFASHIONCOSMETICS

Founded in 1986, Interfashion Cosmetics specializes in the manufacturing, designing,


marketing, and distribution of color cosmetics in the domestic as well as the international
markets. The company is headquartered in Teterboro, NJ, and its color cosmetics range is
marketed by its wholly owned subsidiary, Pantina Cosmetics. A significant portion of
Interfashion Cosmetics revenues are generated from privatelabel manufacturing. The
company has been making privatelabel makeup, skin care products, bath and body care
products,andhaircareproductsforhighendbeautycompaniesforover25years.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

MinorCompanies

Thecompanyhasastrongdistributionnetworkwithproductsbeingavailablenationwideacross
5,000 stores. Some of the selected retailers include CVS Duane Reade, Albertsons, Rite Aid,
Safeway,andWalgreens.

Sales of cosmetics and toiletries at the manufacturers level are estimated at approximately
$12millionin2012,constantfrom2011.TherearenoreportedTMEduring2012.

INTERPARFUMS

InterParfums, headquartered in New York, develops, manufactures and distributes perfumes,


cosmetics,andpersonalcareproducts.Itholdsanexclusiveinternationallicenseforpremium
fragrance and cosmetics brands, such as Burberry, Paul Smith, Montblanc, Boucheron, S.T.
Dupont,JimmyChoo,andVanCleef&Arpels.InterParfumsalsoownsNickelS.A.,amensskin
care company based in France, and Lanvin Perfumes. The company produces personal care
products for the mass market through an exclusive agreement with Anna Sui, Gap, Banana
Republic,BrooksBrothers,bebe,BetseyJohnson,NineWest,andLaneBryantbrands.

ThecompanysluxuryfragranceproductsareproducedandmarketedbyitsFrenchsubsidiary,
InterParfums, S.A. The companys U.S. operations cover mass market and specialty retail
products. InterParfums fragrance products are distributed through department stores and
specialtystores.Thecompanyentereda13yearworldwidelicenseagreementwithLaMaison
Repetto, in December 2011, for creating, developing, and distributing fragrances under the
Repettobrand,startingJanuary1,2012.Thefirstfragrancelineisexpectedtobelaunchedin
2013 by InterParfums SA. InterParfums announces the disagreement on the final terms on a
new operating model for the fragrance and beauty business between its subsidiary,
InterParfumsSAandBurberry,inJuly2012,andBurberrywillbuyoutthelicenserightstotake
effectMarch2013.

InterParfums wins the Best Fragrance Award for Anthropologie 1922 Lily Sanguine Eau de
Parfum,atthe40thAnnualFiFiAwards,intheSpecialtyBrandWomenscategory,inMay2012
atAliceTullyHallinNewYorkCitysLincolnCenter.

Thecompanylaunchesseveralnewproductsin2012:LoveFurybyNineWest,WildBloomVert
from Banana Republic, Gap Established 1969, Miss Madison by Brooks Brothers, Wishes &
Dreams from bebe, a new mens scent called Wild Blue from Banana Republic, and Anna Sui
fragrances, such as Dolly Girl, Flight of Fancy, Forbidden Affair, and Live Your Dream. It
promotes through social media websites like Facebook by informing about new product
launches,andprovidingreviewsaboutitsvariousproducts.InterParfumsallocates$14.1million
in TME for 2012. Its global corporate sales reach $654.1million in 2012, up 6.3% from
$615.2millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

651

652

MinorCompanies

ThemanufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforInterParfumsintheUnitedStatesare
estimated at $48million in 2012, up 17.0% from $41 million in 2011 based on new product
launchesandwidedistributionofretailbrands.Someofitsbrandsarenotreportedhere,such
asBananaRepublic,whichiscountedunderGapssales.

INSPIREDBEAUTYBRANDS

Alleghany Pharmacal is a private company and is headquartered in Great Neck, NY. The
company has changed its name to Inspired Beauty Brands in 2012. It manufactures and
distributes hair care products across the United States. The company employs around 25
employeesasofOctober2012.

Thecompanymarketsmainstreamhaircarebrands,suchasHask,PureShine,SalonStyle,and
Jhirmackandethnichaircarebrands,suchasLustrasilkandVigorol,positionedtoreachvarious
demographics and professional markets, as well as OTC retail categories. Products marketed
underthesebrandsincludeshampoos,conditioners,hairstylingproducts,andethnichaircare
products. Bulk of the companys sales is through its mainstream products. The companys
products are sold across the United States through retail outlets, including food stores, drug
stores, and mass merchandisers, such as Walmart, Walgreens, Kmart, and Rite Aid. The
companyalsosellstobeautysupplydistributors.

Thecompanyfollowsthestrategyofacquiringsmall,decliningbrandsandturningthemaround
throughrightpositioning,marketing,anddistributionsupport.Noneofitsleadingbrandsbeing
marketedcurrentlywereoriginallylaunchedbyInspiredBeautyBrands.

InspiredBeautyBrandshasnoproductlaunchesin2012.Itpromotesitsbrandsthroughsocial
media sites like Facebook and Twitter by informing about new product launches, and adding
reviewsaboutitsvariousproducts.ThecompanyspendsanegligibleamountonTMEin2012.

Manufacturers sales for cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at $10 million in 2012, down
9.1%from$11millionin2011drivenbythelackofmarketingactivitiesandtheabsenceofnew
productlaunches.

IREDALEMINERALCOSMETICS

Iredale Mineral Cosmetics is a private company founded by Jane Iredale in 1994 and is
headquartered in Great Barrington, MA. The company manufactures and distributes makeup
products.JaneIredaleisthecurrentpresidentofthecompanyandhasabout135employees.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

MinorCompanies

The company offers mineralbased makeup products in all four makeup product categories
coveredinthisstudy(face,eye,nail,andlip).Leadingmakeuplinesofferedbythecompanyare
Pure Pressed powders, Dream Tint foundations, Purelash mascaras, and Pure Moist lipsticks
and lip glosses. The companys face makeup product line includes mineral foundations,
concealers,blushandbronzerproducts;eyemakeupincludeseyeshadow,eyeliners,eyebrow
makeupandmascara;productsforlipscompriselipcrayons,balms,exfoliators,definers,colors,
andplumpers.Thecompanyalsoprovidessunscreensandlipbalmsformen.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

Zap&HideBlemishConcealer,thedualendedconcealerstickconcealsandcalmsbreakouts
usingantibacterialandantiinflammatoryingredientsliketeatreeleafoil,chamomile,and
psoraleacorylifoliaextract.
PowderMeSPFDrySunscreencontainstitaniumdioxideandnaturalclaydriedinthesun
andisfreeofcontaminantsandatmosphericpollutants.

Theproductsareavailableinover50countriesglobally.IntheUnitedStates,IredaleMineral
Cosmeticsdistributesitsproductsthroughaestheticplasticsurgeons,dermatologists,spas,and
salons. The companys website also offers products for online purchase. It advertises its
products through trade and beauty magazines, such as Vogue and Life & Style. The U.S.
manufacturerslevelsalesforIredaleMineralCosmeticsareestimatedataflat$22millionin
2011 and 2012. The company spends $3.9 million TME to support its brands in 2012 and
magazines are the most preferred medium for promotion of the company, accounting for
approximately$3.8million.

ITCOSMETICS

Establishedin2008,ITCosmetics,aprivatelyheldcompany,wasfoundedbyJamieKernLima.
Thecompanyspecializesincolorcosmetics.ThecompanyisheadquateredinJerseyCity,NJ.As
of 2012, the company has over 17 employees. Its product premise relies on the companys
collaborationwithplasticsurgeonstoincludeantiagingtechnologyincolorcosmetics.

The company offers eye, lip, and face makeup, cosmetic brushes, minimal facial treatments,
and one cuticle care pen. The company has a product portfolio of over 45 product SKUs. In
2011, the company wins the Cosmetic Innovator of the Year Award for "Most Innovative
Company"byICMAD.SomeofthemajorbrandsforITCosmeticsincludeByeBye,Vitality,and
HelloLight.

In 2012, IT Cosmetics partners with the American Cancer Societys Look Good, Feel Better
(LGFB)program,whereinforeveryBrowPowerpencilsold,onepencilisdonatedtotheLGFB
program,inordertohelpwomenfacetheeffectsofcancerwithconfidence.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

653

654

MinorCompanies

Someofthenewproductsin2012includeVitalityGlowAntiAgingMatteBronzer,anantiaging
mattebronzerthatdeliversafaceperfectingvitalityglowandairbrusheffect.Itisinfusedwith
antiagingtechnologyandskincaretreatmentforyoungerlookingskin;VitalityLipFlushButter;
and Vitality Lip Flush 4in1 Natural AntiAging Lipstick Stain which takes the place of four
products;lipstick,antiagingconditioninglipbalm,ultrahydratinglipgloss,andlipstain.

The companys products are distributed in the United States, Canada, and Australia. It is
available in various channels which include QVC and Henri Bendel in the United States. The
productscanalsobepurchasedonlinethroughbeauty.com.Thecompanydoesnotallocateany
evidentTMEin2012.

ManufacturerslevelsalesofpersonalcareproductsintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
areestimatedat$2millionin2012up100.0%fromapproximately$1millionin2011,mainly
drivenbynewproductintroductions.

J.STRICKLAND

J. Strickland & Co. was establised in 1936 and is headquartered in Olive Branch, MS. It is a
manufacturerandmarketerofethnicskincareproducts,haircareproducts,andmakeup.The
companyemploysover60peopleintheUnitedStates.

ImportanthaircarebrandsfromthemarketerincludeBlueMagic,AfricanGold,RoyalCrown,
Sulfur8, Magnificent, Queen, and World of Curls. The company also markets the skin care
brands Nadinola and Artra. The bestselling product of the company is the Blue Magic
Conditioner.ThecompanypromotesitsproductsthroughtheInternetandmagazines.

The company also promotes its products through social networking sites like Facebook and
Twitter.SomeoftheonlinemagazineswheretheproductsarepromotedincludeSister2Sister,
Upscale, Today's Black Woman, Sophisticate's Black Hair Styles and Care, and Hype Hair. J.
Strickland allocates $439,300 in TME for 2012. The entire amount is spent on magazine
advertisements.

InMay2012,J.StricklandacquiresNaturesProtein,makerofDOOGROproducts.DOOGROis
apartoftheethnichaircareindustrysince1997,andconsistsofmorethan20productswhich
includehairvitalizers,shampoos,andconditioners.

The company launches two new products in 2012: Five Star medicated nongreasy dandruff
controlhairgroomingandBlueMagicpetroleumjellywithaloeveraandvitaminE.

The distribution for J. Stricklands products is nationwide through food, drug, and mass
merchandisers,includingWalmart,Kroger,andWalgreens,aswellasbeautysupplystores.

Manufacturers level sales of cosmetics and toiletries are at $7 million in 2012, equivalent to
2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

MinorCompanies

JAFRACOSMETICSINTERNATIONAL

Founded by Jan and Frank Day in 1956 in Malibu, CA, Jafra Cosmetics International is a
manufactureranddirectsalesmarketerofbeautyandskincareproductswithoperationsin20
countries around the globe. As of 2012, the privatelyheld company reports that it has more
than555,000consultantsandannualrevenuesinexcessofhalfabillionU.S.dollars.Since2004,
Jafra Cosmetics is a member of the Vorwerk Group, a family enterprise with headquarters in
Wuppertal,Germany.Establishedin1883,Vorwerk&CoKGhasacorebusinessofdirectselling
consumerproducts,representedinover60countriesworldwide.

JafraCosmeticsoffersmorethan700cosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsthatthecompanysays
offeraffordableluxuryandatechnologicallyadvancedandhighperformanceportfolio.Product
collectionsincludeskinandbodycare,colorcosmetics,spaproducts,mensgroomingproducts,
andfragrances.ItssignatureproductlineistheRoyalJellycollection.

In 2011, the company lauched a new skin careproduct under the facial treatments category,
JafraPro,whichhelpswomenmaintainandrecoveryouthfulskinappearanceandisapplicable
forallskintypesandskintones.

In2012,thecompanypartnerswithBeautyBusFoundation,anationalnonprofitorganization,
that provides beauty and grooming services to people with chronic and terminal illness and
theircaregivers.ItdoesnotraditionaladvertisingintheUnitedStates.

TotalmanufacturerssalesforcosmeticsandtoiletriesforJafraCosmeticsintheU.S.cosmetics
andtoiletriesare$38millionin2012,aboutthesameas2011.

J.M.PRODUCTS

J.M. Products is a private company that is coowned and completely managed by Murrays
Worldwide.ItmanufacturesanddistributesethnichaircareproductsintheUnitedStatesand
internationally.ThecompanywasfoundedbyErnestP.Joshua,Sr.in1986,andisbasedinLittle
Rock,AR.Thecompanyhasapproximately110employeesintheUnitedStates.Thecompany
hastwomanufacturingfacilitiesinArkansas,bothlocatedatLittleRockandNorthLittleRock.

J.M.ProductsmarketsitsproductsunderitsbrandsIsoplus,UpTurn,OilofK,andBlackMagic.
The Isoplus brand umbrella has more than 100 SKUs of professional and retail products
includingaerosolhairsprays,shampoos,conditioners,hairrelaxers,stylingaids,andscalpoils.
The company also operates beauty and barber shops, as well as a beauty school to educate
beauticians. The majority of the companys products comprise styling aids. The top selling
productsforthecompanyinclude,MurraysPomade,MurraysBeeswax,IsoplusOilSheen,and
IsoplusNeutralizerShampoo.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

655

656

MinorCompanies

J.M. Products distributes its products through drug stores, such as Rite Aid, CVS, and
Walgreens;massmerchandisers,suchasWalmartandKMart;beautysupplystoreslikeSallys
Beautyandbeautysalons.

The companys manufacturers level sales of cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at
$40millionin2012,anincreaseof2.6%from$39millionin2011.J.M.Productshasnegligible
TMErecordedin2012.

JOEYNEWYORK

Joey New York, Inc., based in Sunny Isles Beach, Florida, was established by Joey Chancisa
skin care expert and the current CEOin 1993. The company manufactures and markets
solutionbasedmakeupandskincareproductsthatarehealthy,effective,andaffordable.

The company designs its products to enhance beauty by using pure and safe exotic natural
ingredients.SomeoftheproductsonofferarePeelOffMasque;LineUpforremovingwrinkles
onfaceandeyes;ShedtheRedforskinredness,andunevenskintoneanddullness;ByeBye
Blackheadstoremoveblackheads,reducelargepores,andtreatacne.

JoeyNewYorklaunchesthefollowingnewproductsin2012:CorrectALineforfaceandeyesin
2012,whichcomprisesthebenefitsoftendergreencoconutwaterandIndianginsengextract
complexforsmoothing,healing,andprotectingskin;KeepItupforaninstantnaturalfacelift;
LineUpforminimizingindividuallinesandlargeporesonfaceandeyes.

Joey New York products are available online at skin Store.com, spalook, dermstore.com, and
beauty.com.ItpromotesthroughsocialanddigitalmedialikeFacebook,Twitter,andYoutube
byinformingaboutnewproductlaunches,andreviewsonitsvariousproducts.NoTMEforthe
companysproductsareevidentfor2012.

The manufacturers sales for cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
approximately $18million in 2012, up 8.6% from $16 million in 2011 based on new product
launches.

JOHNPAULMITCHELLSYSTEMS

John Paul Mitchell, one of the leading privatelyheld companies in the professional hair care
industry, sells its professional products across more than 150,000 beauty salons in nearly 90
countries.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

MinorCompanies

John Paul Mitchell Systems was founded by John Paul DeJoria and the late Paul Mitchell in
1980. The founders wanted to provide luxury hair care at an affordable price and launched
three products: Shampoo One, Shampoo Two, and The Conditioner. The company currently
produces more than 100 products. John Paul DeJoria is the chief executive officer of the
company, whereas, Angus Mitchell, Paul Mitchells son, serves as the companys artistic
director.JohnPaulMitchellSystemsisheadquarteredinBeverlyHills,CA.

JohnPaulMitchellsprofessionalhaircarerangecomprisesPaulMitchell,AwapuhiWildGinger,
TeaTree,ModernElixirs,PaulMitchellProfessionalHairColor,andPaulMitchellProTools.The
companyispresentinthefollowingthreecategories:shampoos,conditioners,andhairstyling
productsandsprays.

In2012,JohnPaulMitchellSystemsisentering2,000selectMarriotthoteldoorsacrossNorth
Americaa first for the company. About 24 million units of four unisex Paul Mitchells Salon
ClassicsproductsaretobemadeavailablethroughfourMarriottbrands:CourtyardbyMarriott,
SpringHillSuitesbyMarriott,ResidenceInnbyMarriott,andTownePlaceSuitesbyMarriott.

Thecompanylaunchestwonewproductlinesin2012:N+colorlineandtheTruthAboutCurls.
N+colorlineofferssevenshades,fromlevels3to9thatguaranteemaximumcoverageandcan
bemixedwithotherPaulMitchelltheColorshades.

TheTruthAboutCurlslineisoutwithfournewproductsSpringLoadedDetanglingShampoo,
Full Circle Leave In Treatment, Ultimate Wave Beachy Texture Cream Gel, and Twirl Around
CrunchFree Curl Definerthat are designed specifically to create frizzfree and humidity
resistantcurls.

JohnPaulMitchellisactiveonsocialmediawebsiteslikeFacebookandTwitterthroughbrand
promotions, showcasing skills on hair styling and cutting techniques, as well as sharing its
success stories. It also relies on marketing through hair stylists to increase sales in salons, its
primarydistributionchannel.In2012,thecompanyallocates$23.5millioninTME.

Total sales for cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at $156million in
2012, up 0.6% from $155 million in 2011, due to new product launches and an expansive
distribution.

JOHNSONPUBLISHINGCOMPANY

HeadquarteredinChicago,IL,JohnsonPublishingCompany,Inc.isaleadingAfricanAmerican
owned publishing firm in the United States. It has an established business in publishing,
cosmetics,televisionproduction,andfashion.Foundedin1942byJohnH.Johnson,thefirmhas
five divisions: Fashion Fair Cosmetics, JPC Consumer Products, Ebony Fashion Fair traveling
fashionshow,Ebonyjetonlinemagazine,andEbonyjetEntertainmentGroup.Thecompanyhas
morethan2,000employees.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

657

658

MinorCompanies

Inadditiontopublishing,thecompanyproducesalineofhaircareproducts(SupremeBeauty)
and cosmetics (Fashion Fair) marketed for AfricanAmerican women. Products offered by the
company include facial treatments, face makeup, eye makeup, and lipsticks and lip glosses.
Many Fashion Fair items are available in fragrancefree versions. Fashion Fair Cosmetics are
soldinaround700storesnationwide,includingMacys,Dillards,andLord&Taylor.

Inaddition totheUnitedStates,productsarealsoavailableinCanada,Africa,theCaribbean,
England, France, and other countries around the world. All manufacturing and packaging
functionsareoutsourcedtocontractors.Thecompanypromotesandsellsitsproductsthrough
itswebsiteanddepartmentstoresincludingMacy's,Lord&Taylor,BonTon,Belk,andDillard's.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012,someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

Grapesicle Lipstick claimed to be uniquely formulated to defy drying and is infused with
vitaminE.
RebelLipstickisinfusedwithvitaminEandconditionsthelips.
Lurelipglossisclaimedtobeformulatedwithauniqueblendofsoothingbotanicalsthat
conditionandmoisturizedelicatelips.
SoColdNailLacquerismadefromchipproofformulathatdriesfastandwillnotfade.

Sales at the manufacturers level for Johnson Publishing Company in the U.S. cosmetics and
toiletries market total $47 million in 2012, up 2.2% from $46 million in 2011. Johnson
Publishing Company spends $1.1 million TME to support its brands in 2012. The company
spendsapproximately90.9%or$1millionofthetotalTMEthroughmagazineadvertisements.

JONATHANPRODUCT

JonathanProductisaluxuryhaircarelinefoundedin2005,inspiredbyprofessionalhairstylists.
It is located in Linthicum Heights, MD, and employs around eight people. Jonathan Products
formulas utilize purified, deionized essential water infused with natural botanicals. The
companyshairproductsaremadeofingredientsfromnaturaloilsandexoticbutters.

JonathanProductmarketshaircareproducts,suchasshampoos,conditioners,andhairstyling
products. The companys hair care collection includes Infinite Volume, Weightless Smooth,
Hydrating, Green RootineNatural, Dirt, and Dry Shampoo. In 2012, Jonathan Product
introduces its Green Rootine Dry Shampoo Brush on Hair Powder in two variants: dark and
light.Thisproductisahairpowderthatcleansesthehairandscalpwithouttheuseofwater.

Products are promoted on social network sites like Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube and in
magazineslikeAllure,Elle,Cosmopolitan,Vogue,People,Lucky,Self,MarieClaire,Vegas,Star,
W, Fashion, Prevention, and InStyle. Jonathan Products brands are available with select
retailers including Ulta and Nordstrom, and through online retailers like dermstore.com,
beautysak.com, folica.com, and beautybar.com. Corporate sales of Jonathan Product are
estimatedatunder$1millionin2012,unvaryingfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

MinorCompanies

JOSIEMARANCOSMETICS

Josie Maran, an actress and an entrepreneur, launched her natural cosmetics products line,
Josie Maran Cosmetics, in 2007. Based in Los Angeles, CA, Josie Maran Cosmetics develops
arganoilbasedskincareandcosmetics.Besidesarganoil,thecompanysproductsarecreated
with other natural ingredients, such as shea butter, olive oil, rosemary oil, papaya extract,
cucumber,flaxseedoil,coconutoil,andavocado.

JosieMaranCosmeticsportfolioconsistsoffacemakeupproductslikefoundation,concealer,
bronzer, powder, and primer; eyemakeup products, such as eye shadow, eye liner, mascara,
andlipsticksandlipglosses.Thecompanyalsomarketshaircareandskincareproducts,suchas
hair mist, hair serum, tanning cream, and body butter. Some of its brands include Argan
MatchmakerSerumfoundation,ArganPressedPowderNatural,ArganMagicMarkerliquideye
liner, GOGO Instant Natural Volume Argan mascara, Argan Natural Volume lip gloss, Argan
Cleansing Oil, Argan Oil Hair Serum, and Argan Sun Protection for the Body. In 2012, the
companyintroducesJosieMaranArganHighGlossLipQuench,ArganHotOilSelfHeatingHair
Treatment, Bohemian Waves Argan Hair Mist, Argan Matchmaker Powder Foundation, and
ArganBrighteningBronzerSunCorrector.

Josie Maran Cosmetics brands are promoted on social network sites like Facebook, Twitter,
YouTube, online blogs, and in magazines like Allure, Audrey, Beauty Biz, Brides, Lucky, Life &
Style, Vanity Fair, Vogue, Natural Health, Glamour, Zink, Whole Living, Teen Vogue, and
Seventeen. Products are available at josiemarancosmetics.com, QVC, sephora.com, and all
Sephoralocations.

The cosmetic company employs around 50 people and its corporate sales are estimated at
$12millionin2011.SalesofJosieMaranCosmeticsareestimatedtogrowby8.3%from2011
to$13millionin2012.

JUICEBEAUTY

Juice Beauty was founded by Karen Behnke in 2004 and is based in San Rafael, CA. The
company offers organic cosmetic, skin care, and hair care products in the Asia Pacific, North
America,andEurope.JuiceBeautyusesingredients,suchasalphalipoicacid,coenzymeQ10,
DMAE,peptides,fatsolubleVitaminC,andessentialfattyacidsinits products. Thecompany
claimstoplaceover100USDAcertifiedorganicingredientsintoa100%certifiedorganicjuice
baseandhasatotalorganiccontentofupto98%ineveryproduct.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

659

660

MinorCompanies

Thecompanysproductportfolioconsistsofskincareproducts,suchascleansers,toners,and
moisturizers, makeup products like foundations, concealers, and lip glosses, and hair care
productsthatincludeshampoosandconditioners.SomeofitsskincareproductsincludeGreen
AppleCleansingGel,BlemishClearingMask,GreenAppleAgeDefySerum,SimplyNourishing
Moisturizer, Green Apple Firming Body Moisturizer, and Exfoliating Cleanser. Juice Beautys
makeup products consist of Irresistible Glow Facial Highlighter, Blemish Clearing Powder,
PerfectingFoundation,CorrectingConcealer,andIlluminatingEyeColor.Thecompanymarkets
fourSKUsinhaircare:BrighteningShampoo,PomSmooth Shampoo,BrighteningConditioner,
andPomSmoothConditioner.

Apart from North America, products are distributed in the Asia Pacific and the European
regions. In the United States, JuiceBeauty products are available in specialty stores including
Ulta, food stores including Whole Foods, at various salons and spas, and online retailers like
amazon.comanddermstore.com.SocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,Tumblr,Pinterest,
andYouTubeandonlineblogsarepopularpromotionalmediautilizedbythecompany.

Corporate and U.S. manufacturers sales of the company are estimated to remain flat at
$5millionand$3million,respectively,in2012.

KISSPRODUCTS

HeadquarteredinPortWashington,NY,KissProductswasfoundedin1989.KissProductsisa
private manufacturer and distributor of professional quality nail products. With growing
popularity, the company expanded its distribution network to drug stores and massmarket
merchandisers,suchasWalgreensandWalmart.Fashionnailsanddecoratedwearnailsare
thecompanyskeyareaoffocusfollowedbywomensfalseeyelashes,cosmetics,haircoloring
products,andhairaccessories.

Kiss launched its second brand, Broadway Nails, to attract the nail care market by making
available to consumers athome salonlike manicures easily and quickly. Kiss and Broadway
Nailsareavailablein96countriesworldwideacrossdiverseretailchannels.

In2012,thecompanylaunchesGradationPolisheswithlayercolorsforafadedstylemanicure,
andEverlastingGelPolishwithhighglossshineforwearuptotwoweeks.TheImpresslinea
fullcoverdesignerstickerthatisnotharmfultothenail,hasbeenthecompanysbestselling
linein2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

MinorCompanies

Kiss Products is advertised in magazines including People, Star, Glamour, Seventeen,


Cosmopolitan, and O Magazine. The company also showcases its products through television
advertisements that appear exclusively on cable channels in latenight time slots, spending a
total of over $17 million in TME 2012. The companys market strategy involves targeting
celebrities to try on their products and make style statements at big functions with bloggers
capturing the information and posting it on their blogs. Actress Nicole Scherzinger is the
spokesperson for the Impress line. As a part of its promotional strategy, the company often
comesoutwithanumberofgiveawaysanddiscounts.Thecompanyswebsiteactsasasource
ofeducationforconsumerswithhowtovideosexplainingtoconsumersthecorrectapproach
toputtingonandtakingoffgluednails.

KissProductsareavailableatmassmarketretailersandbeautysupplylocationsincludingdrug
stores, such as CVS, Duane Reade, Kmart, Meijer, Rite Aid, Target, Ulta, Walgreens, and
Walmart.Manufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriescoveredinthisreportareestimated
at roughly $12million in 2012, up 9.1% from $11million in 2011 (note: excludes nail art and
decals).

KISSMYFACE

KissMyFaceisaprivatelyheldmanufacturerandmarketerofnaturalpersonalcareproducts.
The company is based in Milford, CT, since the time of its inception in 1981 by two friends,
RobertMacleodandSteveByckiewicz.Thebrandwasestablishedona200acrefarminHudson
River Valley, NY. The company has 50 employees worldwide. The brand has close to 30,000
pointsof saleworldwide,includingnearly14,500intheUnitedStates.KissMyFaceproducts
aresoldinatotalof19countriesincludingtheUnitedKingdom,SouthAfrica,Canada,Norway,
Germany,Croatia,HongKong,Guam,Taiwan,andthePhilippines.Theproductsarelargelysold
throughnaturalfoodstores,pharmacies,specialtystores,spas,andsmallgroceryshops.

In the United States, Kiss My Face has products across several categories, with close to 200
different SKUs spanning toiletries, skin care, hair care, and oral care, as well as a few home
fragranceproducts.KissMyFacesskincareproductportfolioincludeshandandbodylotions,
sun care products, childrens skin care, and facial treatments. The company also offers
deodorants, foot scrubs and creams, shave creams, hand soaps, shower gels, mouthwash,
toothpaste,conditionersandshampoos,lipbalms,glosses,andliptints.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

661

662

MinorCompanies

Thecompanycontinuestoextenditslineofproductswithnewlaunches.Thekeylaunchesfor
KissMyFacein2012include:

KissMyFaceTripleActiontoothpaste:Thetoothpastecontainsnaturalingredientsincluding
oliveextracts,Icelandmosesextract,teatreeleafoilandisfreefromSLS(Sodiumlaureth
sulfate).
KissMyFaceNaturalMineralSunscreenSPF40:Thesunscreencontainsanaturalmineral
formulathat helps reduce irritation, fight the signs of aging and provides Broad Spectrum
SPF40protection.
Kiss My Face Sun Spray Lotion SPF 30: This spray is specially formulated with aloe and
antioxidantgreenteatoprotect,moisturizeandsoothetheskin.
KissMyFaceSportLipBalm:Madewithnaturalbeeswax,coconutoil,VitaminEandShea
Butter,thislipbalmwillsoothe,smoothandprotectlipsallday.
Kiss My Face Peace Soap: The soap is formulated with 100% natural ingredients including
olive,coconutandjojobaoils.

IntheUnitedStates,thebrandsellsitsproductsthroughsomelargeretailerslikeWholeFoods
andCVS.KissMyFacesproductsarealsoavailablethroughWalmartandonlineretailers,such
as herbalremedies.com, amazon.com, and drugstore.com. Kiss My Face uses point of sale
materials,theInternet,andprintadvertisingasthepromotionaltoolstomarketandadvertise
itsproducts.Socialnetworkingwebsites,suchasFacebookandtwitter,constituteamajorpart
of the brands Internet promotions. At times, the brand also offers samples and discounts as
consumerpromotions.

Sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States at the manufacturers level are
approximately $29 million in 2012, up from $27 million in 2011. Hand and body lotions, and
facialcareproductsarethebiggestcategoriesforthebrand.

KOSAMERICA

HeadquarteredinJapan,Koswasfoundedin1946byKozaburoKobayashi.KosAmericaisthe
U.S. division of Kos Corporation. Since its inception, the prime focus for Kos has been to
developtechnologicallyadvancedcosmetics.Thecompanygloballyhasabout5,500employees.
Kos Corporation was listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange in 2000 and is also the creator of
AwakeandSekkiseibrands.

Awake,anestablishedbrandinJapan,enteredtheUnitedStatesin1997throughHenriBendel
storesinNewYork.Awakeoffersskincareandbasemakeupproducts.AwakeutilizesJapanese
technology to incorporate natural botanicals into formulations that are suitable for sensitive
skin. Sekkisei, Koss other brand available in the United States, is a formulation of Japanese
andChineseherbalextracts,whichoffersproductsthathydrate,replenish,andbrightenskin.
Sekkisei brand offers three product lines: Sekkisei, Seikisho, and Junkisui. Both, Awake and
SekkiseibrandsareretailedthroughBergdorfGoodmanstoresinNewYork.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

MinorCompanies

To promote its products, Sekkisei holds events where licensed aestheticians use and
demonstrateSekkiseiproducts.In2012,thecompanylaunchesitsglobalwebsite.Sekkiseigives
away two complimentary samples on every online order. The company does not spend on
advertisingthroughbroadcastorprintmedia,butitdoessponsortheStarsonIceskatingshow
in2012,for$56,000.

U.S.manufacturerslevelsalesforKosareestimatedat$2millionin2012,fixedfrom2011.

LAQA&CO

Founded in 2010, Laqa & Co started as a company that develops high gloss nail polishes in a
pen.BasedinNewYork,NY,thecompanyalsomarketsnailpolishandlippencils.Nailpolish
pens are designed for an easytouse, quick, and neat application of the product. The brand
promotesupcomingdesignersbyfeaturingtheirartworkonthepackagingofitsproducts.

The company markets30 SKUs of nail polish, nail polish pen, and lip pencils. Some of its nail
polishbrandsareavailableinamixofcolors,suchasredbrown(Plonk),bluepurple(Blurple),
and greybeige (Fancypants). Its nail polish pen consists of brands like Incestous (lavender),
Birthday Suit (nude), WTF (pink), Toff (navy blue), and Greedy Guts (red).In 2012, Laqa & Co
launches the fat lip pencils in five different shades: Ring of Fire, Wolfman, Bossy Boots,
Lambchop,andFairyblood.

Brands are promoted in online blogs and social network sites like Facebook, Twitter, and
Tumblr.Productsareavailableinretailstores,suchasPlanetBeautyandAnthropologieandat
varioussmallscalestores.Itcanalsobepurchasedonlinethroughwebsiteslikedermstore.com,
asos.com,indigo.com,powderrooms.com,3floz.com,beautyHabit.com,andbglowing.com.

Corporatesalesofthecompanyareestimatedtobeunder$1million,eapproximatelyflatfrom
the2011levels.

LAVANILALABORATORIES

Lavanila was founded by Danille Raynor in 2006. The privatelyowned company is


headquartered in San Francisco, CA. The company got its name Lavanila when Danielle
discovered that the key ingredient in most of her products, Vanilla, is known as Lavanila in
Madagascarwhereitissourcedfrom.Thecompanysbiggestsuccesstodateoccurredin2007,
whentheretailchainSephora,begantocarrythecompanysvanillabasedfragrances.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

663

664

MinorCompanies

Thecompanyhasgrownitsproductofferingquickly,from3productofferingsin2007toover
70 in 2012. Lavanilas product range includes fragrances, deodorants, hand and body lotions,
personal cleansing products, lipsticks and lip glosses, sun care products, and baby care
products. The companys bestseller is the Vanilla Lavender Mini Deodorant. The company
claimsthatitsown100%Healthysealrepresentshealthyingredients,freeofharshchemicals,
scientificallyproventobeeffectiveandsociallyresponsible.

In 2012, the company revamps its website to make the consumers shopping experience
convenient and informative. Through its new website, the company introduces the sample
strategywherebyitcreatesexclusivesamplesetsforitsconsumersbasedontheirneeds.

In2012,Lavanilafeaturesinmagazinesandnewspapers,suchasUSWeekly,InStyle,andMetro
NY. The company has presence on social networking sites including Facebook and Twitter.
Lavanila has its own blog. In 2012, the company conducts a variety of promotional activities
includingafreeLavanilacosmeticbagonpurchasesofabove$40.00,offeringa25%discount
oncyberMonday,choiceoftwofreesampleswithonlinepurchases,buyonegetonefreeon
bodywashesand2in1showershave,andfreeshippingonordersabove$50.00.Lavaniladoes
notreportanysignificantTMEfor2012.

LavanilaproductsareretailedthroughSephora,SephoracountersinsideJCPennystores,QVC,
Kitson, Ebeauty, online retailers such as beautybar.com, drmstore.com, skinstorecom, Urban
Outfitters,QVC,amazon.com,beauty.com,anddiapers.com.

SalesforLavalinaintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketatthemanufacturerslevelin2012
areestimatedat$7million,up16.7%from$6millionin2011.

LOCCITANE

LOccitane is a global manufacturer and retailer of natural and organic ingredientbased


cosmetic personal care products, headquartered at ManosqueenProvence, France. The
companywasfoundedin1976byOlivierBaussan,whopreparedhisfirstnaturalproductswith
essentialoils,andsoldtheminthemarketsofProvence.LOccitanesfirststoreopenedin1978.

The company has three brands in its portfolio: LOccitane, Melvita, and Le Couvent des
Minimes.LOccitaneistheflagshipbrand,andissoldinmorethan90countries,throughmore
than1,900retaillocations,bymeansofavarietyofwholesaleandinhouseretaildistribution
channels.Melvita,aleadingorganicandpersonalcarebrand,hasitsownretailnetwork,andLe
CouventdesMinimesisanaturalingredientbasedbrand,whichisdistributedmainlythrough
wholesalers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

MinorCompanies

AsofMarch31,2012,LOccitanehas2,082retaillocations,anincreasefrom1,828asonMarch
31,2011.Thenumberofownretailstoresstandsat1,053asonMarch31,2012,anetincrease
of 158 stores, adding 80 stores in Asia, 53 in Europe, and 25 in the Americas. The TME for
LOccitaneproductsareabout$769,300in2012.

The company offers a range of products across fragrances, facial treatments, hand and body
lotions,personalcleansingproducts,haircare,andmen.AllLOccitanesproducts,exceptthe
suncarerange,areparabenfree.

SomeofthenewproductlaunchesbyLOccitanein2012areSheaButterHoneWhippedbody
cream,SpringCherryEauDeToilette,ImmortelleBrighteningFoamingcleanser,andImmortelle
BrighteningFaceMist.ThecompanypromotesthroughsocialanddigitalmedialikeFacebook,
Twitter,andYouTube.

Thecompanyscontinuedfocusonitslongtermgrowthstrategyandfurtheracceleratedretail
network and topline helps the manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United
Statesreach$94millionin2012,up5.3%from$88millionin2011.

LORACCOSMETICS

Lorac Cosmetics is a private company founded by Carol Shaw, a makeup artist based in
Hollywood in 1995. It is headquartered in Valencia, CA. The company manufactures and
distributespersonalcareproductsintheUnitedStates.Thecompanyemploysabout20people.

All products are sold under the brand name Lorac. The personal care range consists of color
makeupproductslikelipsticks,lotions,foundations,andeyeshadows,aswellasbathandbody
products.Thebestsellingproductsofthecompanyareitsbronzersandblush.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

EyeCandyeyepencilwithaluxuriousassortmentofvelvetysmooth,richcolorsforavariety
ofenticinglooks.Itisavailableinfourshades:coal,plum,cocoa,andlicorice.
Sweet Temptations lip gloss comes in an assortment of rich colors and is available in six
scentsincludingCandyApple,Butterscotch,CrmeBrule,CottonCandy,FrostedGumdrop,
andSugarPlum.

The companys products are sold through specialty and department stores, such as Sephora,
Macys,andNordstrom.SalesatthemanufacturerslevelintheUnitedStatesareestimatedat
$7millionfor2012,upfrom$6millionin2011.LoracCosmeticshasnegligibleTMErecordedin
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

665

666

MinorCompanies

LUSHFRESHHANDMADECOSMETICS

LushFreshHandmadeCosmeticsisheadquarteredinPoole,DorsetintheUnitedKingdom.Itis
aprivatelyheldcompany,whichwasfoundedbyMarkandMoConstantinein1995.Lushhas
morethan700storesin43countries.Thecompanyalsooperatesfivespas,includingfourinthe
United Kingdom and one in Tokyo, Japan. The manufacturing activities of the company are
spreadinfourcontinents.About950peopleworkwithLushFreshHandmadeCosmeticsinthe
UnitedStates.

Thecompanymanufacturesitsproductsfromfresh,organicfruitandvegetables,essentialoils
and,itclaims,safesynthetics.Theproductsaresaidtocontainlittleornopreservativesand
are made by hand. The company buys ingredients only from companies that do not conduct
tests on animals. The company also uses only vegetarian ingredients to develop its products
andfragrances.

Thecompanymanufactures,distributes,andsellsmorethan400SKUsofpersonalcareitems.
The companys product portfolio includes personal care (soaps, shower gels, bath bombs,
bubblebars);haircare(solidordryshampoosandhairconditioners),andskincare(handand
bodylotionsandfacemasks).Italsoproducesproductslike,"ShowerJellies,"gelatinlikesemi
solid shampoos and body wash; "Toothy Tabs," solid toothpaste tablets; and "Bath Bombs,"
solidballsmadeofsodiumbicarbonate.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012,someofitskeylaunchesinclude,Eyes
Right mascara, Emotional Brilliance Translucent face powder, Charisma Tint/Primer, Feel
YoungerPrimer,andgiftsets.Thecompanypromotesitsproductsthroughitsecommercesite
andcatalog.Lushsellsitsproductsthroughmorethan60specialtystoresinstreetfront,mall,
and airport locations, through print catalogs, mail order, and online. Lush Fresh Handmade
CosmeticshasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

SalesintheUnitedStatesatthemanufacturerslevelareestimatedat$43millionin2012,up
4.9%from$41millionin2011.

LUSTERPRODUCTS

LusterProductswasfoundedbyhairstylistFredLuster,Sr.in1957andiscurrentlymanagedby
hissonJoryLuster.Thecompanymakesprofessionaluseandconsumerpersonalcareproducts
forpeopleofAfricandescent.LusterProducts,headquarteredinChicago,IL,employsover400
peopleworldwide.ThecompanyhasmanufacturingfacilitiesinIllinoisandinternationalbranch
officesinSouthAfricaandtheUnitedKingdom.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

MinorCompanies

The company sells products for men and women sold under several brand names, including
Pink Brand products for women; SCurl products for men; PCJ PrettynSilky & Smooth Roots
children products; YOU unisex products, and Designer Touch products for stylists. Products
offeredbythecompanyincludecosmetics,skincare,haircareproducts,hairstylingirons,hair
stylingtools,humanhair,nailproducts,perfumesformenandwomen,andskincareproducts.

The products are sold nationally and internationally through a dynamic sales force and
numerousretailoutlets.ThecompanysproductsareavailablethroughouttheUnitedStatesin
conveniencestores,food,drug,andmassoutlets,salons,andbeautysupplystores.

Manufacturers level sales in the United States of takehome products are estimated at
$34millionin2012,upfrom$33millionin2011.LusterProductssupportsitsbrandswithTME
of$2.2millionin2012.ThecompanyallocatesitsentireTMEtosupportitsbrandPink.

MARKWINSINTERNATIONAL

Markwins International Corporation was established by Eric Chen, the president and CEO, in
March1984.MarkwinsInternationalmanufacturescosmeticsandbeautycareproductsandis
headquarterednearLosAngeles,CA.Thecompanydistributesitsbeautyproductsinmorethan
85countriesandemploysmorethan150peopleworldwide.Thecompanymarketsmorethan
200 SKUs under its product portfolio. It offers an extensive variety of products, including
products for the eyes, lips, nails, and kits and accessories. The major brands of the company
includeWetNWild,BlackRadiance,Tropez,TheColorInstitute,TheColorWorkshop,TheSpa
Workshop,DisneyPrincess/Fairies/Minnie,Barbie,andMonsterHigh.WetnWildisthemost
recognizedandbestsellingbrandfromthecompany.

In 2012, Markwins International acquires Physicians Formula for $75.0 million or $4.90 per
shareincash.PhysiciansFormula,basedoutofAzusa,CA,develops,markets,anddistributes
cosmetics and skin care products for the mass market channel. The company has 151
employees,anditcompanywasestablishedin1937byDr.FrankCrandall,aneminentallergist,
whocreatedalineofcosmeticsasatokenofloveforhiswifewhohadsensitiveskin.

Markwins International launches a number of cosmetic products in 2012. Some of its major
launchesinclude:

Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow: It is said to beautifully enhance any eye color and
providesalldaycreaseresistance.
ColorIconShimmerSingle:Thissilkysmoothshimmerstaysforhourswithoutanyfallout,
hashighpigmentationandpearldensityformula.
MegaShieldLipColorSPF15:ItcontainsnaturalingredientsVitaminE,avocadooil,andrice
bran oil that moisturize and condition. With SPF 15, lips are protected from harmful UVB
rays.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

667

668

MinorCompanies

JuicyLipBalmSPF15:TheproductisclaimedtoprotectfromharmfulUVBrayswithSPF15.
MegaLast Nail Color: It comes with a fiveday chipresistant formula and is free from
Formaldehyde,Toluene,andPhthalate.

Inaddition,PhysiciansFormulaintroducesanumberofnewproductsin2012,including:

GlowBoostingSeasontoSeasonBronzer
Ultra Smoothing Blush, 2in1 Lash Boosting FeltTip Eyeliner+Serum, Glow & Mood
BoostingBlush
Glow&MoodBoostingBronzer&Blush
Glow&MoodBoostingLipstick
TalcFreeCorrectingBronzer
TalcFreeMineralAirbrushingPressedPowderSPF30
100%NaturalLashBoostingMascara
pHPowderedBlush,pHPowderedBronzer,andpHPowderedLipGloss

In 2012, the company signs a deal with DMV Diedrichs Markenvertrieb to launch the brand,
WetnWildinGermany.Thecollaborationtargetsdrugandmassretailers.IntheUnitedStates,
Markwins products are sold through food, drug, and mass merchandising retailers, such as
Walgreens,Target,CVS,RiteAid,andWalmartinmorethan25,000doors.

The company is expected to invest in advertising through print and electronic media. It
promotesitsproductsthroughpromotionalmaterials,planograms,andretail/customerevents.
MarkwinsInternationalspends$5.1millioninTMEforallitsbrandsin2012.Thefacemakeup
categoryreceivesapproximately70.1%or$3.5millionofthetotalTME,followedbyskincare
categorywith$1.3millionTMEin2012.Approximately,$4.7millionTMEisspentonmagazine
advertisements.

Global corporate sales for the company are estimated at $490 million in 2012. Sales of
cosmetics and toiletries in the United States at the manufacturers level are approximately
$216million in 2012, up 20.0% from $180 million in 2011. Note that these numbers include
PhysiciansFormulaU.S.salesinbothyears.

MATRISKIN

Dr. Pierre Huet opened Laboratoires ESPA in Toulouse, France, in 1995, to produce various
brands, such as Dr. Sebagh, Meaningful Beauty, and Biotec. He thenestablishedhis skin care
line, Matriskin, in 2006. Matriskin products heal skin imperfections, such as wrinkles, marks,
andstains.Asadermatologist,Huetwantedtheresultsofhisproductstobeimmediateandto
persistonalongtermbasis.MatriskinUSA,asubsidiaryofMatriskin,isfoundedin2012andis
locatedinMiami,FL.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

MinorCompanies

Matriskin employs the "2nd Skin" technology which is a combination of two patented
molecules,polysaccharidesandceramides.Theresultofthiscombinationisarangeofproducts
thatthecompanyclaimsacttostrengthentheprotectivefunctionofskincellsandrestructuring
ofalllayers.ThecompanymarketscreamslikeCollagenCream,HighPerformanceCream,and
RetinolCapsules,serums,suchasVitaminCSerum5%,HyaluronicAcidGel2%,and10%DMAE
Serum, masks which include HPR Mask Fibronectol and Mask Osmopeel. Its eye care brands
includeNOPADantipuffinessandEyeLiss.

Matriskins brands are promoted on social network sites like Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr,
Pinterest, and YouTube, and magazines such as Elle, People, InStyle, Ultimate, Cosmopolitan,
and Venue. Venus Paradise is the exclusive distributor of the brand in the United States.
Matriskin products are available at online retailers, such as luckyscent.com, ebay.com, and
scentbar.com.

U.S.manufacturerssalesforMatriskinareestimatedtobeunder$500,000in2012.

MERLENORMAN

Merle Norman Cosmetics, based out of Los Angeles, CA, specializes in developing,
manufacturing, and distributing skin care products and color cosmetics. It was founded by
Merle Norman in 1931. The company is currently owned by Chairman Jack Nethercutt,
Norman's greatnephew. The company relies solely on the franchise business to distribute its
products. Merle Norman products are sold exclusively through approximately 2,000
independently owned and operated retail outlets, called Merle Norman Cosmetic Studios, in
the United States, Canada, Mexico, and the United Arab Emirates. The company also offers
purses,sandals,soycandles,sunglasses,readingglasses,giftcards,andperfumes,inadditionto
itsbeautyproducts.

Merle Normans personal care offerings include makeup, fragrances, skin care products, bath
andbodyproducts,andsuncareproducts.ProductsareallsoldundertheMerleNormanbrand
name.

ThenewproductlaunchesbyMerleNormanin2012include:AntiRednessFoamingCleanserto
dissolvemakeupandimpurities;AntiRednessCreamandAntiRednessPowderthatneutralize
the visible signs of redness under the AntiRedness System line; and Ultimate Firming Neck
Cream. The company promotes through social and digital media like Facebook, Twitter, and
YouTube.MerleNormanspends$1.4millioninTMEforitsbrandsin2012.

The manufacturers sales in the United States for cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at
$40millionin2012,down2.5%from$41millionin2011.Growthissupportedbynewproduct
launches.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

669

670

MinorCompanies

MISSJESSIES

MissJessie'swasfoundedin1997byMikoandTitiBranchandislocatedatNewYork,NY.The
company has established its presence in the hair care industry as an innovator in ethnic hair
careproducts.BesidestheUnitedStatesandCanada,thecompanysproductsareavailablein
countries like the United Kingdom, France, Germany, Netherlands, Bermuda, Belgium, and
Bahamas.AliciaKeys,JossStone,HalleBerry,KeriHilson,Rihanna,andRandyJacksonareafew
celebritieswhouseMissJessiesproducts.

The ethnic hair care company markets shampoos, conditioners, and styling brands like Super
SlipSudsyShampoo,CrmedelaCurlCleansingCrme,CrmedelaCrmeConditioner,Rapid
Recovery treatment, and Super Sweetback Treatment. Its styling creams include Pillow Soft
Curls,QuickCurls,StretchSilkeningCrme,CurlyMeringue,CurlyPudding,andUnscentedCurly
Puddingthataddshinetocurls.BabyButterCremeandCurlyButterCremetreatdryhairwith
theirmoisturizingbenefits.Thecompanyannouncestheopeningofitsfirstpublicsalonlocated
in the SOHO area of New York in 2012. Miss Jessies also launches Pillow Soft Curls, a styling
lotionthatdeliverscurlsquickly.

Miss Jessies brands are promoted online through social networking sites, such as Facebook,
Twitter,andYouTubeandbyprovidingproductsamplestoconsumers.IntheUnitedStates,the
productsareavailableatTarget,CVS,andMeijerstores.

Miss Jessies employs a staff of 15 people. The U.S. manufacturers sales of the company are
estimatedtoremainflatat$3millionin2012aswell.Devotingresourcesfornewsalonsand
havingonlyoneproductlaunchin2012hampersitsgrowth.

MURAD

Murad is a private company founded by dermatologist and pharmacist Dr. Howard Murad in
1989. Murad offers a wide range of skin care and hair care products, as well as dietary
supplements. Murad is headquartered in El Segundo, CA, and its products are sold
internationally in approximately 50 countries including the United Kingdom, Canada, Italy,
Brazil, Japan, Chile, and South Africa. Products are distributed mainly through spas, direct
marketing channels, and specialty stores. The major brands of the company include Acne
Complex, Resurgence, Age Reform, Environmental Shield, Vitalic, Redness Therapy, AgeProof
Suncare,CelluliteSolution,MuradMan,Hybrids,andCleanScene.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

MinorCompanies

The companys skin care line consists of approximately 80 SKUs, including backbar and take
home products. All of Murad's products are formulated with a blend of antiinflammatories,
hydrators,andantioxidantsthatcomefromavarietyoffruits,suchasdurian,gojiberries,and
pomegranates. In the United States, the company markets its skin care products through
infomercials,beautysupplystores(suchasSephoraandUlta),salons,andspas.Thecompany
claimstohavefoundedtheconceptof"InternalSkincare,"orincreasingthebeautyoftheskin
bytakingnutritionalsupplements(salesofwhicharenotincludedinthisreport).

Thecompanycontinuestoextenditslineofproductswithnewlaunches.Thekeylaunchesfor
Muradin2012include:

MuraSol Antioxidant Defense: It comes with an advanced sun care technology that
penetrates the skins top layers to create a protective barrier of free radical neutralizers,
providingawholenewlevelofenvironmentalprotection.
RejuvenatingLiftforNeck&Dcollet:Theproductclaimstorestoreyouthfulsmoothness
andeventone.
Rapid Age Spot & Pigment Lightening Serum: It is free from parabens, synthetic dyes,
petrochemicals, and genetically modified organisms (GMOs). It is said to rapidly lighten
spotsandevenskintone.
Time Release Retinol Concentrate for Deep Wrinkles: Theproduct is specially designed to
effectivelyfocusonthetreatmentofdeepwrinkles.
IntensiveCRadiancePeel:Itisanathomespatreatmentcreatedtoactivelyacceleratethe
turnover of dark, damaged cells. It is free from parabens, synthetic dyes, petrochemicals,
andGMOs.
AgeDiffusing Firming Mask: The product contains a multiactive formula which instantly
tightens,firms,andrevivesdehydratedskin.

The company appoints Beverly Parsons, who joined the company from GuthyRenker in early
2012,aschiefoperatingofficer.

MuradadoptsamultichanneldistributionstrategyintheUnitedStates.Itsproductsaresold
throughspas,physiciansoffices,retailstores,andthedirectsaleschannels.Thecompanysells
its products through more than 2,000 spas and salons across the United States. Murad is
presentinapproximately900retailstores,mostofwhicharecosmeticspecialtystores,suchas
Sephora, Ulta, and Beauty First. In 2011, Murad set up a new franchise system based on its
InclusiveHealthSpaconcept.Itisestimatedthatthereareapproximately10InclusiveHealth
Spasacrossthecountry.Muradhaspartnershipswithalargenumberofthirdpartywebsites
including dermadoctor.com, beauty.com, sephora.com, ulta.com, skincarerx.com, and
skinstore.com, among others. Overall, the direct marketing channels account for more than
onehalfofthebrandssales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

671

672

MinorCompanies

The brand also has a strong presence in direct marketing. It regularly runs a number of
infomercials,suchastheResurgenceinfomercial,whichithasdonetwoyearsinarow.Murad
also has a popular catalog business and ecommerce platform, offered through HSN. Murad
spends $2.8 million in TME for all its brands in 2012. The company allocates approximately
92.8% or $2.6 million of total TME through magazine advertisements. The global sales of the
company are estimated at $118 million in 2012. Manufacturers level sales of cosmetics and
toiletriesintheUnitedStatestotal$35millionin2012,up2.9%fromunder$34millionin2011.

NATUROPATHICA

Naturopathicawasfoundedbyaclinicalestheticianandherbalist,BarbaraClose,in1995.Itis
headquarteredatEastHampton,NY.Thecompanysdifferentiationreliesonclaimingthatits
extractsofenzymesfromfruitslikepumpkin,cherry,fig,andpearprovidenaturalandeffective
personalcareproducts.

Naturopathicas portfolio consists of skin care (facial cleansers, mists, moisturizers, body
lotion), hair care (shampoo, and conditioner), and oral care products (lip balm). Its skin care
brands include Oat facial polish, Chamomile cleansing milk, Lavender Honey balancing mist,
Geranium regenerating serum, and SicilianBergamot body lotion. Clarifying facialwash, Daily
Defense moisturizer, and Soothing shave cream are products exclusively for men. In 2012,
Naturopathica introduces a limited edition of Black Spruce shampoo and Horsetail hair
conditioner. The company also launches Aloe Replenishment Gel, a treatment mask, and
SicilianBergamotShowerGelin2012.

The company uses social network sites like Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and YouTube to
promoteitsbrands.IntheUnitedStates,Naturopathicabrandsareavailableatabout250spas
andsalonsaswellasitsownspainEastHampton,NewYork.

Naturopathica employs a staff of approximately 30 people, most of which work in the spa
services.Thecosmeticsandtoiletriessalesofthecompanyareestimatedat$1millionin2012,
levelwith2011.

NEWHARMONYSOAP

Headquartered in New Harmony, IN, New Harmony Soap was founded in 2012 by Jim and
Stephanie Spann. New Harmony Soap develops bar soaps and bath enhancers composed of
naturalandorganicingredientswhicharedevoidofmanmadeandsyntheticchemicals.Almost
6070%oftheingredientsaresourcedfromoutsidetheUnitedStates.Thecompanysmottois
GetYourSkinOffJunkFood.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

MinorCompanies

NewHarmonysrangeofproductsincludesbarsoaps(bodybarsandfacebars),bathenhancers
(body soak and chlorine removal), skin repair products, sampler packs, gift sets, and
accessories. Their acne soap which is a premium priced product is a bestseller for the
company. In 2012, the company introduces the Red Wine Soap formulated with reggae red
table wine and Honey Wine Soap formulated with camelot mead honey wine, at the 10th
Annual Wabash Valley Wine & Art Festival in Palestine, IL. New Harmony Soaps marketing
activitiesinvolvesFacebookmarketing,PRdistributionsinvolvingjournalsandpublicationsand
regionalmagazines.NoevidentTMEisallocatedbythecompanyfor2012.

Asof2012,thecompanyhasalimiteddistributionnetworkcomprisingofitsbrickandmortar
store in New Harmony, Indiana and its online store on the company website. Its brick and
mortarstoreaccountsfor70%ofthetotalsaleswhiletheonlinesalesrepresenttheremaining
30%.StartingJuly1,2012,thecompanyinitiatesaprogramtosupporttheMt.VernonIndiana
FoodPantrybydonating5%ofallsalesfromnewharmonysoap.comandintheoutletstoreat
NewHarmony,IN.TheprogramcontinuesuntilSeptember30,2012.

SalesforthecompanyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketatthemanufacturerslevel
areestimatedat$150,000in2012.In2013,thecompanyplanstorolloutliquidbodywashes
andestablishawiderwholesaledistributionnetwork.

NOTYOURMOTHER'S

Not Your Mothers was launched in 2010 and the company offers hairstyling products. The
brandsdevelopedbythecompanyhaveuniquepackagingandunconventionalproductnames.

Not Your Mothers hair care portfolio includes products such as Shes A Tease volumizing
hairspray,AllEyesOnMeshape&shinehairspray,MissFreezefreezinghairspray,BeachBabe
texturizing spray, Beat The Heat styling spray, Rise & Shine mist, Kinky Moves curl defining
cream,andGirlPowdervolumizinghairpowder.In2012,thecompanyintroducesWaytoGrow
ShampooandConditioner,whicharesulfatefreeformulations,andKnottytoNicedetangler.

Brands are promoted on social network sites like Facebook, YouTube, Tumblr, Twitter, and
Pinterest In 2012, the company increased its distribution channels and added almost 7,500
retail outlets. Not Your Mothers brands are available in mass merchandiser stores, such as
Walmart and Target, drug stores like CVS and Walgreens, specialty stores, and other retail
stores.Itisalsoavailablewithonlineretailerslikedrugstore.com,soap.com,andamazon.com.

DomesticsalesofNotYourMothersareestimatedat$1millionin2012,anincreaseof11.1%
from2011levelsofabout$900,000.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

673

674

MinorCompanies

NUSKINENTERPRISES

Nu Skin Enterprises is an American multilevel marketing company that sells cosmetics and
nutritionalsupplements.Thecompanywasfoundedin1984inProvo,UT,intheUnitedStates.
The company employees 3,600 people worldwide and operates in 52 international markets
includingAmericas,AsiaPacific,Europe,Africa,andtheMiddleEast.Thecompanymarketsits
products through a sales force of approximately 865,000 active distributors, of which 36,000
aredesignatedasexecutivedistributors.Itdoesnotinvestinanytraditionaladvertisingforits
brands.

The company sells more than 200 products in the personal care and nutritional supplements
categories.InDecember,2011,thecompanyacquiredLifeGenTechnologies,LLC(LifeGen).

NuSkinsproductlinemainlyhasskincareproductswithcustomizedsolutionsandformulated
with botanical ingredients. The companys five different product lines: Core Daily Systems,
Customized Solutions, Total Care, Skin Complements, and ageLOC. Core Daily Systems is
primarilyafacialcarelineandhasfourdifferentlineextensions:Nutricentials,NuSkin180,Tri
PhasicWhite,andNuSkinClearAction.UndertheTotalCareline,thecompanyoffersproduct
categories, such as hand and body lotions, personal cleansing products, mens skin care
products,toothbrushes,toothpastes,mouthwashes,conditioners,andshampoos.

ThecompanydoesnotallocateanysignificantamountofTMEin2012.SalesofNuSkininthe
U.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketareflatat$25millionin2012,up4.2%from$24millionin
2011.

NYX

Nyx is a manufacturer and supplier of cosmetics products and was established in 1999. This
company was founded by Toni Ko and is headquartered in Commerce, CA. The company
marketseyes,face,andlipmakeupproducts.Nyxemploysaround35people.

Nyx markets products in three makeup categories with products, such as eye shadows, eye
shadow base, mascaras, eye pencils, liquid liners, concealers, palettes, lip gloss, lipstick, lip
liners, blushes, bronzers, powders, and liquid makeup. Some of Nyxs brands include Round
lipstick,Jumboeyepencil,MegaShinelipgloss,Slimlippencil,Mattelipstick,LoosePearleye
shadow, Glitter powder, Doll eye mascara, Mosaic powder blush, Twin Cake powder, Stay
MatteButNotFlatliquidfoundation,andTangowithBronzingStixcreambronzer.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

MinorCompanies

In2012,Nyxlaunchesapaletteof32eyeshadows,twobrushes,onebronzer,foureyebrow
powders,threeconcealers,andfourlipglossesinakitcalledWaitingforTonightandalineof
shineandshimmercalledTheGlamCollectionwhichincludeslipglossesandliquideyeliners.
The collection has 22 new colors of eye shadow singles, 11 lip glosses called Glam Lip Gloss
AquaLuxe,and9shadesofGlamLinerAquaLuxe.ThecompanyalsolaunchesTheCurveliquid
eye liner, Be Fierce Palette eye shadow, Be Free Palette eye shadow, Bohemian Chic Nude
Matteeyeshadow,andWickedDreamseyeshadow.

Nyx brands are promoted in magazines and publications like Exude, Beauty Store Business,
HollywoodLife,PaintedLadies,InStyle,Seventeen,WomansWorld,Health,Life&Style,Allure,
Happi,BettyConfidential,Glamour,Nylon,andSelf,throughonlineblogs,andonsocialnetwork
sites,suchasTwitter,Facebook,YouTube,andFormspring.Nyxisavailablewithselectretailers
likeUlta,Nordstrom,Sears,Harmon,andBBB.

Total sales of the company are estimated at $4 million in 2012, about the same as the 2011
levels.

ORLANE

Orlanewasfoundedin 1947byJeandAlbret,amakerofperfumesandeaudetoilette.The
company started with the launch of the fragrance, Ecusson. Between 1947 and 1950, the
company created its first cream containing active ingredients and opened its first beauty
institute. Also, during this period the company introduced informative advertising illustrating
thecrosssectionviewoftheskin.In1966,thecompanyunveileditsHouseofBeautyaspace
for women to interact with beauticians and understand the benefits of the products and the
techniques used. The company is headquartered in Paris, France, while its Research and
ProductionCenterislocatedinOrleans.

In 1985, the company was acquired by the Italian Kelemata Group. The Kelemata Group was
foundedbyapharmacistandisnowrunbythefoundersdaughterRaffallaGiraudi,whoisthe
Managing Director, and his son Gian Luca Giraudi, as CEO. The companys U.S. subsidiary,
OrlaneInc.,wasestablishedin1997andisheadquarteredinNewJersey.

In the United States, Orlane markets fragrances, makeup, and skin care products. Orlanes
productsarepopularduetoitsnaturalformulationsbasedonactiveingredients.TheB21Bio
EnergicAntiAgingComplexisthesignatureingredientofallOrlaneskincareproducts.In2012,
thecompanylaunchestheAntiagingOxygenationSystem.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

675

676

MinorCompanies

In 2012, the company gives free miniatures on all online orders above $150.00 and also two
free samples on every order. For a limited time period, Orlane is giving out a 15ml Thermo
Active Firming Night Cream free on the purchase of ThermoActive Firming Cream or Serum.
Orlane uses Facebook as a social platform to launch its new products, inform consumers of
great deals and discounts, and share testimonials of products. Orlanes products are sold
through over 100 doors, including Neiman Marcus, Bloomingdales, and select independent
outlets.

Manufacturers sales in the United States remain flat at $9 million in 2012, up 12.5% from
$8millionin2011.Therearenotraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)recordedforthiscompany
in2012.

ORLYINTERNATIONAL

Orly International, the personal care products manufacturer, was established in 1975 by Jeff
Pink. Orly makes nail lacquers and assorted nail care items which are used internationally in
salons and spas in more than 65 countries. Jeff Pink created the original French manicure to
complementHollywoodstarletsentireonsetwardrobe.ThecompanyisheadquarteredinLos
Angeles,CA.

Orly International is positioned as a professional and natural products company, the latter
becauseofitsprominentformulationwithnotolueneorformaldehydeinitsnaillacquers.The
use of nonfully synthetic chemical formulations and some natural ingredients is carried
forwardfromthecompanysnailcareproductstotheskin careline,whichtoutsingredients,
suchasaloevera,shea,andcocoabutters,andvitaminsAandE.

The companys product portfolio of cosmetics and toiletries includes nail care and skin care
products.Itoffersarangeofproductsundernaillacquercolors,basecoats,primers,topcoats,
hand and foot lotions, and spa kits. Some of the Orly's nail treatment products include the
OriginalFrenchManicure,FungusMD,andCalciumShield.

OrlysproductsaresoldthroughUltasalons,aswellasthroughbeautysupplystores,suchas
Sally Beauty. The company launches a limitedtime nail color collection in partnership with
WarnerBros.PicturesinlinewiththereleaseofDarkShadowsinMay2012. No TMEforthe
companysproductsareevidentfor2012.

ManufacturerssalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforOrlyInternationalintheUnitedStatesare
almostflatfor2011and2012,estimatedat$9million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A76

MinorCompanies

OSMIAORGANICS

Osmia Organics was founded by Sarah Villafranco in 2010, and is located at Carbondale, CO.
ThestoreisofficiallyopentopublicsinceApril2012.Sarahstartedhercompanyafterspending
six years as a physician in emergency medicine. The company markets natural and organic
productlinesoffragrances,skincare,andoralcareproducts.Organicbotanicalsareingredients
inalltheproducts.

OsmiaOrganicsfeaturesavarietyofhandmadeorganicsoaps,sensuousbodyoils,andnatural
perfumeswithecoconsciouspackaging.Thecompanyalsodevelopsorganicskincareproducts
like cleansers, exfoliants, moisturizers, and serums. Some of its products include Black Clay
Facial Soap, Aspen Walnut Micro Scrub, Active Gel Nutrient Serum, and HoneyMyrrh Lip
Repair.BestsellersofOsmiaOrganicsareLavenderPineSoap,CoffeeMintSoap,HoneyMyrrh
LipRepair,FacialCalibrationSerum,andJuniperFirePerfume.

ProductsaremarketedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,YouTube,Pinterest,andTwitter.
Discountcouponsandsamplesareavailableonline.OsmiaOrganicsproductscanbepurchased
onlinethroughthecompanyswebsite.

Domesticsalesofthecompanyareestimatedtobeunder$1millionin2012.

OUIDAD(JHPARTNERS)

Ouidad started her hair salon in 1984 to cater exclusively for curly hair. It is located in New
York,NY,andSantaMonica,CA.Ouidadhaircarebrandsfeatureafoundationforfrizzfighting
resultsfromtheinsideout.In2007,privateequityfirmJHPartners,acquiredOuidad.Termsof
the deal were not disclosed. The executives of Ouidad stayed except for a change in the
companyCEO.

Ouidad markets ethnic hair care products which include shampoos, conditioners, treatment,
styling,andfinishingproductsfordrydamaged,limpthin,frizzy,andnormalhair,aswellasfor
kids. Some of its products include Climate Control defrizzing shampoo, PlayCurl volumizing
shampoo,CurlQuenchermoisturizingconditioner,SunShieldsun&sportleaveinconditioner,
KRLYKidsPump&Gospraygel,MoistureLockdefine&shinecurlstylinggelcream,ShineGlaze
serum,andStylingMistsetting&holdingspray.In2012,OuidadlaunchesSalonSerieswhich
includes Mediterranean Bay Leaf Exfoliating Hair & Scalp Treatment, Omega3 Replenishing
HairTreatment,andBiotinLightweightReparativeHairSerum.Thiscollectionofhairproducts
provides salon results at home for women with all hair textures and styles and is available
exclusivelyatSephora.ItalsolaunchesCurlCoWash,MoistureLockdefine&shinecurlstyling
gelcream,CurlQuencherhydrafusionintensecurlcream,andClimateControlfrizz&flyaway
fighterin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

677

678

MinorCompanies

Thecompanysbrandsarepromotedthroughtelevisioncommercials,onlineblogs,andsocial
networksites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.Ouidadbrandsareavailableinspecialty
storeslikeUltaandSephoraandatmanysalonsnationwide.Ouidademploysaround40people.
Thecompanyisestimatedtogrowat7.1%to$15millionin2012,upfrom$14millionin2011.
Salesgrowthissupportedbytheintroductionofnewproducts.

PALLADIO

Palladio is a private company based in Hollywood, FL, that markets naturalpositioned


cosmetics.Establishedin1999,thecompanydevelopsproductsmadewithvitamincomplexes
(vitaminsA,C,D&E)andcontainingredientssuchasgreentea,chamomile,ginseng,andaloe
vera.Palladioproductshaveantiagingpropertiesthathelptorepairtheskinselasticity.

Palladios makeup products include face makeup, such as Baked Blush, Herbal Liquid
FoundationTubes,andHerbalLiquidConcealers,eyemakeupincludingEyeLinerPencilandEye
shadowPrimer.Thecompanyalsomarketslipsticksandlipglossesandnailtreatments.Itsskin
care products include facial scrubs, facial cleansers, moisturizers, and antiaging creams. In
2012,thecompanylaunchesanewshadeofitsHerbalLipGlossEleventhGorgeous.

ProductsarepromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,Google+,andYouTube.
The brand is distributed through beauty supply stores, such as Sally Beauty, and specialty
retailers including Ulta. They are also available at online retailers, such as
discountbeautycenter.com,beautynaturals.com,andcherryculture.com.

Palladioemploysastaffofapproximately15people.U.S.manufacturerssalesofPalladioare
estimatedtoremainflatatjustunder$1millionin2012.

PARFUMSDECOEUR

Based out of Darien, CT, Parfums de Coeur was established in 1981 by Mark Laracy. The
company offers mainly fragrances for the mass market. As of 2012, the company employs
about 100 people worldwide. In September 2012, Yellow Wood Partners private equity firm
acquires Parfums de Coeur, previously a privatelyheld company. The terms of the acquistion
arenotmadeavailable.

Parfums de Coeur offers fragrance, deodorant, personal cleansing, and skin care products
includingbodysprays,moisturizinglotions,bodywashproducts,skinoils,colognesprays,and
deodorants. It has seven different product lines: Body Fantasies, Bod Man sprays, Prince
Matchabelli,SkinMusk,DesignerImposters,SexiestFantasies,andBodyFantasiesVampire.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A78

MinorCompanies

In 2012, the company launches two products under the body spray product class: Bod Man
MostWantedandCherryBlossomFantasyscentintheBodyFantasiesline.

Thecompanyoffersitsproductsthroughchaindiscountersanddrugstores,aswellasthrough
itswebsite.ParfumsdeCoeurapportions$2millionofTMEin2012.Itadvertisesitsfragrances
throughtelevision.

TotalsalesforthecompanyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesatthemanufacturerslevelare
estimatedat$23millionin2012,upfrom$22millionin2011.

PERIOPRODUCTS

Perio Products Company, a marketer and distributor of personal care products, is


headquarteredinDublin,OH.Thecompanyhastwomajorpersonalcarebrands:Barbasoland
PureSilk,whichareundertheshavingproductscategory.

Perio Products started as a dental care company, Columbus Dental, in 1903. The company
becameFranklinDentalin1981afterthesuccessofitsSteelefacings,individualreplacement
teethwithgoldorsilverbackings.Thecompanyshifteditsfocusfromdentistrytoshavingafter
itacquiredhairremovalbrands,NuditandHersin1997.

In2001,PerioacquiredBarbasolfromPfizer,whichstrengthenedthecompanyspersonalcare
portfolio.In2003,thecompanysshavingproductsassortmentwasstrengthenedwiththere
launch of Pure Silk, Barbasols sister brand, designed specifically for women. The shaving
productscategorydominatesthepersonalcareofferingsofthecompany.TheBarbasolrangeof
productsincludesshavingcreamsandaftershaveliquidandbalm.Someoftheshavingcreams
includeBarbasolOriginal,BarbasolPacificRush,BarbasolSoothingAloe,andBarbasolSensitive
Skin, whereas, the after shave segment includes Barbasol Pacific Rush, Barbasol Brisk, and
BarbasolPacificRushPremiumaftershavebalm.ThePureSilklineisrestrictedtotheshaving
products category. In 2012, Perio Products launches Barbasol Sensitive Skin shaving cream,
Barbasol Arctic Chill shaving cream, Barbasol Mountain Blast shaving cream, Barbasol Pacific
RushPremiumAfterShavebalm,andPureSilkKiwiBerryBlissshavingcream.

Barbasol signs a fiveyear agreement with Columbus Crew, a major soccer league club, to be
theirofficialjerseypartnerinFebruary2012.BarbsaolsponsorsthePGATour,web.comTour,
and Champions Tour for professional golfers, whereas, Pure Silk sponsors nine LPGA tour
members,suchasKatherineHullKirkandJeongJang.

The companys products are sold in major food stores, drug stores like Walgreens, and mass
merchandisechains,suchasWalmartandTarget.PerioProductsallocates$9millioninTMEfor
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

679

680

MinorCompanies

Manufacturers sales for cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
$20million in 2012, up 11.1% from $18 million in 2011 based on new product launches and
marketingactivities.

PERRICONEMD

Founded in 1998 by renowned dermatologist Dr. Nicholas V. Perricone, Perricone MD is a


private company located in Meriden, CT. TSG Partners, a private equity firm based in San
Francisco,CA,isthemajoritystakeholderinthecompany.Thecompanywaspreviouslycalled
N.V.Perricone,butwasrenamedasPerriconeMDin2008.Itusescontractmanufacturersfor
manufacturingitsproducts.

The company offers skin care products and markets antiaging skin care products, as well as
books, DVDs, and vitamin supplements. Products are formulated with antiaging skin care
ingredientsthatprovideremedytodullskin,antiagingskin,hyperpigmentation,damagedskin,
acne,oilyanddryskin,andsensitiveskin.Thebrandspremiseisbasedonaddressingskinaging
andinflammation.

The companys bestselling products include its Citrus Facial Wash, High Potency Evening
Repair,AdvancedEyeAreaTherapy,andFaceFinishingMoisturizer.

In2012,thecompanylaunchesFormula15,ahighlyadvancedformulationoftheoriginalFace
FirmingActivator,designedtominimizethelength,depth,andwidthofawrinkle,andrestore
skin to its youthful suppleness and glow. It also introduce two skin care products, Acyl
GlutathioneEyeLidSerum,totightenandfirmtheuppereyelidarea,whilesmoothingcreases
andimprovingtheappearanceofrednessanddarkcircles,andVitaminCEster15tohelpboost
collagenproduction,smoothenskintexture,andbrightenitsappearance.

Nationwide distribution is through retail stores, including Sephora, Saks Fifth Avenue,
Nordstrom,NeimanMarcus,Bluemercury,andHenriBendel.Thecompanyhasitsflagshipretail
store at Madison Avenue in New York City and Malibu in California. Products are also sold
through phone and through the companys online shopping portal. Perricone MD promotes
throughsocialanddigitalmedialikeFacebook,Twitter,andYouTubebyprovidinginformation
on new product launches, online deals, explaining beauty techniques, and providing tips on
healthyliving.TheTMEforPerriconeMDareestimatedat$7.1millionin2012.

ThemanufacturessalesforPerriconeMDintheUnitedStatesforcosmeticsandtoiletriesare
estimatedat$84millionin2012,up6.3%from$79millionin2011duetonewproductlaunches
madeintheyear.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A80

MinorCompanies

PIERREFABREGROUP

The Pierre Fabre Group is a pharmaceuticals and cosmetics company based in France. The
companywasfoundedin1961bypharmacist,PierreFabre.Thecompanyhasaglobalpresence
across five continents. Globally, the company has a workforce of 10,000 employees. Pierre
Fabres operations are divided under two segments: DermoCosmetics and Pharmaceutical.
PierreFabreDermoCosmtiqueUSAisawhollyownedsubsidiaryofPierreFabreGroupandis
responsible for marketing and distributing cosmetics and toiletries products in the United
States.ThecompanysU.S.headquartersarelocatedinParsippany,NJ.

The Pierre Fabre Group is represented by Avne, Ren Furterer, A Derma, Ducray, Elancyl,
Galnic, and Klorane cosmetic brands across the world. However, in the United States, the
companyisrepresentedonlybytheAvneandRenFurtererbrands,whichfindpresencein
theskincareandthehaircareproductclasses.

The Avne brand was introduced in 1989. All Avne products are formulated with the Avne
Thermal Spring Water, which the company claims to have a balanced mineral composition.
AlthoughAvneisprimarilyafacialtreatmentsbranditalsooffersbodycareproducts,suncare
products,andskincareproductsformen.Avneproductsareespeciallydesignedtotreatall
types of sensitive skin care concerns, such as skin redness, sensitive and intolerant skin,
dehydratedskin,andalsooffersproductsforwoundcare.In2012,thebrandintroducestheD
Pigment Light, a light formula that is enriched with shinereducing powders and is known to
reduce and prevent dark spots after four weeks. The brands bestselling products include
Thermal Spring Water, Cleanance Gel Soapless Cleanser, Cold Cream Lip Balm, Soothing
MoistureMask,GentleToner,Rtrinal+0.1Cream,andHighProtectionTintedCompactBeige.

AvnesPRactivitiesincludewriteupsinfashionandbeautymagazines,suchas,Allure,InStyle,
People Style Watch, Marie Claire, Essence, O, The Oprah Magazine, New Beauty, TeenVogue,
Town & Country, Self, and Vogue. The brand is also highly active on social media networks
includingFacebook,Twitter,Pinterest,andYouTubewithcontests,giveaways,andtipsofthe
day.

Avnes line of skin care products is available through online retailers, dermstore.com,
drugstore.com, and skinstore.com; massmarket retailers and drug stores including Duane
Reade, Soho Pharmacy, Walgreens, Grove Pharmacy, K&B Cosmetic Beauty, Pure Essentials,
WindsorPharmacy,PasteurPharmacyanddoctorsoffices.

RenFurtererisanaturallyformulatedhaircarebrandthattreatsboththescalpandthehair.
ThelineiscreatedbytheFrenchstylistRenFurtererandismadefrompureessentialoilsand
plantsfromallovertheworld.ThebrandhasbeenapartofthePierreFabreGroupsince1980.
In 2012, Ren Furterer launches the Okara Active Light range comprising a shampoo,
conditioner,andaleaveinfluid.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

681

682

MinorCompanies

RenFurterersproductsarefeaturedinmagazinesincludingAmericanSalon,Allure,InStyle,US
Weekly,BeautyLaunchpad,Cosmopolitan,WholeLiving,USWeekly,andPeople.Thebrandalso
promotes its products on Facebook and Twitter with snapshot uploads of the products being
usedatrunwayevents,suchastheNewYorkFashionWeek.Thebrandholdseventssuchasthe
Ren Furterer Art and Science of Hair dressing event to educate consumers on the latest in
fashion and trends with respect to hairstyles. The company invests very minimally in TME in
2012.

RenFurtererproductsaredistributedthroughhighendsalonsandspas,suchasPatriceVinci
Salon, Roffi Salon & Spa, and department and specialty stores, such as Bloomingdales and
Sephora. The brand is also associated with professional partners who receive exclusive
promotionsandoffers.

Manufacturers sales in the United States are estimated to grow at 7.1% from $14 million in
2011toreach$15millionin2012.

PRESTIGECOSMETICS

Prestige Cosmetics was established in 1987, by two brothers, Jacques and Gabriel Cohen.
Prestige Cosmetics is a privatelyowned comapany that manufactures and markets color
cosmetics.ItsheadquartersandproductionfacilitiesarelocatedinPompanoBeach,FL.As of
2012,thecompanyemploys55workersintheUnitedStates.Itprimarilytargetsconsumersin
theagegroupof25to35years.Thecompanyhasastrongcolorcosmeticsrangeconsistingof
over300productSKUs.

Thecompanysproductofferingsincludelipsticks,lipliners,lipglosses,eyeshadows,eyeliners,
mascaras, powders, blushers, foundations, nail polishes, and makeup brushes. Prestige
CosmeticsoffersmakeupunderthePrestigebrandandunderprivatelabelsforretailers.

PrestigeCosmeticshasastrongdistributionnetwork.Ithaspresenceinnearly12,000retailers
in the U.S. market and 17,000 retail points worldwide. The company markets its products to
drug stores, mass merchandisers, supermarkets, and specialty retailers in the United States.
Outside of the United States, it sells its products to distributors in Australia, Canada, South
America,Europe,andAsia.

The company does its promotion and marketing through various social media sites which
includeFacebookandTwitter.NoevidentamountofTMEisspentbythecompanyin2012.

Mnaufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
$10million in 2012, down by 9.1% from $11 million in 2011. The sales reported here include
onlythePrestigebrand,andexcludesprivatelabelsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A82

MinorCompanies

PRIMALELEMENTS

HeadquarteredinGardenGrove,CA,PrimalElementswasfoundedbyFaithandScottFreeman
in 1993. Primal Elements is a privatelyheld manufacturer, marketer, and retailer of personal
careandhomecareproducts.Thecompanyhasover40employeesandusesamanualprocess
tocreatePrimalElementsHandmadeVegetableGlycerinSoaps.

The company began from a bath, body, and aromatherapy shop in Belmont Shore, CA to
expand its product base to include home and personal fragrances in 1999. The companys
offering falls into personal cleansing products, hand and body lotions, shampoos, fragrances,
andhomefragrancescategories.

In 2012, timed with the U.S. Presidential elections, the company makes limited edition
Republican and Democrat Soaps, featuring each partys political symbol. The company also
makes limited edition bar soaps and candles for special occasions, such as Halloween,
Thanksgiving,BreastCancerAwarenessmonth,andNationalHoneyMonth.Also,in2012,the
companyintroducestheLePinklipglossandFoamingHandwashesavailableinsixfragrances.A
fewofthecompanysbestsellingproductsincludeArielBarSoap,OrangeCantaloupeBarSoap,
andFacetsoftheSeaBarSoap.

AccordingtoPrimalElementsCustomProductsProgram,thecompanywelcomesrequestsfor
soapcustomizationaccordingtocolor,designs,andfragrances.

Primal Elements products are also featured regularly on HSN and beauty magazines, such as
Happi, GQ, and Spa Magazine. The company is socially active on Facebook and Pinterest. It
doesnotinvestintraditionaladvertising.

PrimalElementsproductsareretailedthroughmorethan11,000storesnationwideincluding
highendretailchains,suchasNordstrom;salon,suchasElizabethArdenRedDoor;specialty
storesandgiftshops;andhotelsandspas.Thecompanysproductsarealsoavailablethrough
online retailers, such as drugstore.com, soapmaking.com, rosnersoap.com, and
thesoapopera.com.

Manufacturerssalesofthecompanyinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustrypostagrowthof
11.1%in2012to$10millionfrom$9millionin2011.

PRMINERALS

PrMineralsisalineofcolorcosmeticsthatprovidesskincaretreatmentsatthesametime.
The company was founded in 2002 and is based in Atlanta, GA. Its products claimto nourish
andconditionskinwhileeveningoutskintone.Theproductsofferpurepigmentcolorswhich
suitallskintonesandskintypes.ItoperatesasasubsidiaryofAstralBrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

683

684

MinorCompanies

Pr Minerals products are made using ceretin complex, shea butter, and antioxidants. Pr
Mineralsproductportfoliomarketsmakeupandskincarebrands.Itsmakeupproductsinclude
facemakeuplikeprimers,foundations,powders,eyemakeupsuchaseyeshadows,mascara,
eye pencils, and lipsticks and lip glosses. Some of its makeup products are Universal Marble
Mineral Powders, Pressed Mineral Eye Shadow Singles, and Pout Plumping Lip Gloss. Its skin
careproductsincludecleansers,moisturizers,masques,serums,andbodylotions.Someofits
skincareproductsareLiteBodyButter,MineralMuddMasque,FulvicMineralMist,andTone
Upeyetreatment.In2012,thecompanyintroducesPerfectFitEyeShadowTrios,BalancingAct
OilControlPowder,andarangeof4in1productslike4in1LiquidFoundation,Disappearing
Act4in1Concealer,and4in1MineralTintedMoisturizer.

Social network sites, such as Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, YouTube, and Pinterest are popular
promotional mediums employed by the company to advertise its products. Pr Minerals
brands are available in specialty stores, department stores, and at select drug stores in the
UnitedStates.

Thecompanyhasaround70employeesasitsworkingstaff.DomesticsalesofPrMineralsare
estimatedat$5millionin2012,upby25%from$4millionin2011.Salesgrowthissupported
bytheintroductionofnewproducts.

PURE&BASIC

Pure& Basic is a manufacturer and marketer of natural personal care products, and is
headquarteredinCarson,CA.Thecompanywasfoundedin1971byThomasDionisio.Pure&
Basics production and warehouse facilities are located at Carson, CA, and its products are
distributedintheUnitedStatesandCanada.

Pure& Basic markets personal care, hair care, and skin care products. Its range of products
includehandandbodylotions,bathandbodywash,barsoaps,shampoos,conditioners,hand
soaps,vitaminEoils,anddeodorants.SomeoftheproductsfromPure&BasicincludeHoney
SheaButternaturalbarsoap,CaribbeanHeatbodywash,andGreenClaydeodorantstick.

The company has changed its distribution network over the last few years. Its products are
distributedinover12,000independentretailoutletsincludinghealthfoodstoresandsmallco
operatives in the United States and Canada. Pure & Basic products are sold through online
retailersaswellasthroughretailerslikeTJMaxxandMarshalls.

Thecompanyhasnoproductlaunchesin2012.Itpromotesthroughsocialanddigitalmedialike
Facebook and YouTube, by informing about new product launches, and providing details on
benefitsandusageofitsproducts.ThecompanydoesnotallocateanyTMEin2012.

Pure&Basicssalesin2011and2012remainalmostflat,atapproximately$9million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A84

MinorCompanies

RAHUA

Rahua by Amazon Beauty is a hair treatment collection that combines organic and natural
ingredients with extracts found in the Amazon. Based in New York, NY, the company was
createdbyhairdresserFabianLiguinin2008.AmazonBeautypartnerswiththetribalwomenof
Amazontosourceandprocessessentialoilsinaccordancewiththetraditionalmethods.

ThemainingredientofallhaircareproductsistheoilfromRahuanut.Thecompanyclaimsthat
Rahua oils small molecular structure enables it to penetrate deep into the hairs cortex and
makes the hairs cuticle smooth. The company markets products, such as shampoos,
conditioners,hairmasques,andhairsprays.In2012,RahualaunchesRahuaOmega9HairMask
whichcontainsungurahuaoil,whichissaidtoinjecthairrootswithlifeandshine.

ProductsarepromotedonsocialnetworksiteslikeFacebookandTwitter.Rahuasproductsare
available in highend department stores, such as Barneys New York, retail stores like
Anthropologie, at various spas and salons nationwide, and with online retailers like
beautybar.com,skinstore.com,dermstore.com,betterbeauty.com,andsaffronrouge.com.

Domesticsalesofthecompanyareestimatedatlessthan$1millionin2012,constantat2011
levels.

RECKITTBENCKISER

ReckittBenckiser,headquarteredatBerkshire,theUnitedKingdom,wasformedasaresultof
the 1999 merger between the United Kingdoms Reckitt& Colman and the Dutch group,
Benckiser.IntheUnitedStates,itisheadquarteredinParsippany,NJ.

Reckitt Benckiser groups together brands of a variety of products across different product
segments. It is one of the global leaders in the manufacture and sales of household cleaning
products. The company markets a large collection of OTC and personal care products. The
companys OTC line strengthened after it completed the acquisition of Boots Healthcare
International,aglobalhealthcarecompany,in2006.Thecompanyisalsopresentinthefood
sector,andmarketssauces,crisps,andmustards.

The company has operations in nearly 60 countries and sells its products in more than 180
countries.BartBecht,theCEOofthecompanyfor16years,leftReckittBenckiserinSeptember
2011andwasreplacedbyRakeshKapoor.ThecompanysellstheParaspersonalcarebrandsto
MaricoLtd.,inFebruary2012,afteracquiringitfor$730millioninApril2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

685

686

MinorCompanies

Reckitt Benckiser competes under facial treatments, mouthwashes, personal cleansing


products,anddepilatories,waxesandbleaches.Veet,oneoftheleadingdepilatorybrands,and
Clearasil, the skin care and acne treatment brand dominate the companys personal care
portfolio. Veet was launched in Canada in 1901, and was previously named Neet. It has a
presence in nearly 180 countries and its product range comprises two major products types:
hairremovalcreamsandlotionsandwaxproducts.Inmouthwashes,thecompanymarketsthe
Cepacolbrand.

Productsaresoldnationwidebymajorfood,drugstore,andmassmerchandisechainsincluding
Walmart,Walgreens,andKmart.Itpromotesthroughvarioussocialanddigitalmediawebsites
likeFacebook,Twitter,Linkedin,YouTube,Google+,andWeibo.In2012,thecompanyallocates
aTMEof$3.6millionforitsbrands.

Reckitt Benckisers sales in the United States for cosmetics and toiletries are estimated at
$80million in 2012, up 1.3% from $79 million in 2011 because of the strong brand base and
widedistribution.

RENCLEANSKINCARE

Founded in 2000, Ren is a British skin care company that claims to use hightech plant and
mineral derived bio actives in its product formulations, which are devoid of skinirritating
ingredients. The company was founded by Robert Calcraft and Antony Buck and is
headquarteredinLondon,theUnitedKingdom.However,itsU.S.corporateofficeisincentral
NewJersey.

Rens product offerings are distributed across facial treatments, hand and body lotions, sun
care products, skin care products for men, shaving products, personal cleansing products,
shampoos,andconditioners.Thecompanyalsoofferstravelandgiftsets.

In2012,RenintroducesavarietyofskincareproductsincludingtheKeepYoungandBeautiful
AntiAging Eye Creaman ultra lifting, firming, and replenishing eye cream that reduces the
appearanceoffinelinesandwrinkles;PhotoactiveSunVeilSPF15,atripleactionmicromineral
sunscreenthatdeliversbroadspectrumUVAandUVBprotectionandfightsfreeradicalstogive
aradiantandtonedappearancetotheskin;ClarifyingToningLotion,anexfoliatinglotionsthat
unclogsporesandhelpsremovedeadskinand;BioRetinoidAntiAgingConcentratetoincrease
collagenproductionby24%andreducetheappearanceoffineslinesandwrinklesforafirmer
andradiantskin.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A86

MinorCompanies

Ren skincare products find regular mention in fashion and beauty magazines including Elle,
Stella, Beauty Magazine, So Feminine, The Guardian, Wedding Venues, Natural Health, Bella,
InStyle,Metro,Grazia,andSpaSecrets.Renhasanactivesocialmediapresencewithanofficial
YouTubechannelandpresenceonFacebookandTwitter.In2012,themarketerteamsupwith
Swedishsparetreat,HotelTylsandtogivetwoRenproductloversachancetowinaninclusive
nightstayatthespa.NoTMEforthecompanysproductsareevidentin2012.

IntheUnitedStates,RensproductscanbefoundinSephorastores.In2012,manufacturers
sales for the company are estimated at $7 million, up 16.7% from $6 million in 2011. The
growthin2012isprimarilyattributedtotheintroductionofnewproductstoitsalreadyexisting
productline.Thecompanyhasalsosteppedupitsmarketingin2012.

ROHTOPHARMACEUTICAL

HeaquateredinOsaka,Japan,RohtoPharmaceuticalspecializesindeveloping,manufacturing,
and distributing ophthalmic medicines. The operations are carried out through the following
divisions:SkinCareProducts,EyeCareProducts,OralMedicine,andOther.Thecompanyhasits
business in domestic markets as well as in overseas markets, including Europe, Asia and
America. As of March 31, 2012, the company has 32 subsidiaries and seven associated
companies. Worldwide,the company has 5,347 employees. The Rohto Group has established
23companiesworldwidewithproductsavailabletoconsumersinmorethan130countries.

TheU.S.businessishandledbyitswhollyownedsubsidiary,TheMentholatumCompanyInc.It
specializes in the manufacturing, marketing, and distribution of nonprescription drugs and
consumerhealthcareproducts.ThecompanyisheadquateredinOrchardPark,NY.

Thecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriesrangecomprisesskincareandoralcareproducts.Lip
balms, jellies, and treatment products account for more than 70% of its revenues in this
segment.Inthelipbalmsandjelliescategory,productsareofferedundertheproductnames
SoftlipsandNaturalIce.TheSoftlipsproductrangeconsistsof28productSKUsthatarespread
under seven different lines: Organic Lip glosses with Sun Protection Factor (SPF 10), Lip balm
flavors with SPF 20, Therapeutic Lip conditioners, Tinted Lip Balms with SPF 15, PURE 100%
Natural Organic Lip balm flavors, PURE 100% Natural Specialty Lip Products, and Limited
EditionsSeasonalflavorswithSPF20.

In the skin care segment, the company offers facial treatment lines pHisoderm and Oxy. The
pHisoderm line includes mainly facial cleansers and moisturizers. Under the Oxy line, the
company primarily markets acne products that are specially targeted towards younger
audiences.Thelineisalsoextendedtoincludepersonalcleansingproductsandshavingcreams.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

687

688

MinorCompanies

Distribution is nationwide through major food, drug, and mass merchandise chains, including
CVS, Fred Meyer, Rite Aid, Safeway, Target, Walmart, and Walgreens. Rohto Pharmaceutical
spendsaminoramountofTMEthisyear.Thecompanyconductsonlyonetypeofadvertisingin
2012:atelevisionspotforitspHisodermPH2OEverydayMoisturizer.

Manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
$31millionin2012,flatfrom2011duetothelackofpromotionalactivities.

ROSEBUDPERFUMECOMPANY

The Rosebud Perfume Company was founded in 1895 by George F. Smith. Originally, the
business started out from a drug store that is located across the present Rosebud building
Woodsbro,MD.Dr.SmithcameupwiththeBalsamofRosebudsuponsuggestionsfromfriends
andfamily,whichwaslaterrenamedasRosebudSalve.

The companys product offerings include moisturizing lip balms, jellies, and treatments. Its
balms are available in a variety of flavors and packaged in the conventional balm boxes or
tubes.

The company has a limited distribution network with products available for purchase at
Sephora, Amish Creek, Urban Outfitters, Anthropologic, Terrain, American Apparel, Pharmaca
Integrated Pharmacy, Walgreens New Mexico; and online retailers, such as drugstore.com,
beauty.com, and amazon.com. No significant TME have been reported for the company in
2012.

In 2012, the companys sales in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market are estimated at
$5million,steadyfromthe2011sales.

SHAKLEECORPORATION

Privately held since its inception in 1956, Shaklee Corporation specializes in the manufacture
anddistributionofvitamins,cosmetics,personalcare,andnutritionproducts,aswellasgreen
household cleaners. It manufactures its privatelabel products and markets them through its
website, and sales representatives in the United States, Canada, Mexico, China, Japan,
Malaysia,andTaiwan.

TheU.S.basedfirmisheadquarteredinPleasanton,CA.FoundedbyDr.ForrestC.Shaklee,Sr.,
the company is owned by private equity firms, Ripplewood Holdings and Activated Holdings.
Thepartnershipjointlyholdsmorethan80%ofthecompanystotalshares.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A88

MinorCompanies

IntheUnitedStates,thecompanyhasnearly500employees.Productioniscarriedoutinthe
companysheadquarters,locatedatPleasanton,CA.

The companys personal care business comprises six product lines, which includes Cleanse,
Neutralize, Enfuselle Advanced Skin Care, ProSante Hair Care, Daily Essentials, Beauty
accessories,AdvancedMoisture,SpecificTreatmentsRepair,andBodyCare.

The company does not spend any evident amount of TME in 2012. Manufacturers sales of
cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are at $30 million in 2012, unvarying from 2011
levels.Flatsalesarearesultoflackofnewprodcutactivityfromthecompany.

SISLEYCOSMETICS

Based out of Paris, France, Sisley Cosmetics specializes in the manufacturing, marketing, and
distributionofluxuryhaircare,makeup,fragrances,andskincareproducts.Thecompanyhasa
separatelineformenwhichincludesfragrancesandskincareproducts.Itwasstartedin1976
by Count Hubert dOrnano, and the privatelyowned company is still run by the dOrnano
family.

The U.S. subsidiary, Sisley Cosmetics USA Inc. was started in 2003. The companys U.S.
headquarters are located in New York City, NY. As of 2012, the company has over 4,000
employeesworldwide.IntheUnitedStates,ithasover150personnel.MostofSisleysproducts
are manufactured in France, mainly in its Blois plant, while its Research and Development
laboratoriesarelocatedjustoutsideParis.Thecompanyhasaround30subsidiarycompanies
anddistributionofficesoperatinginnearly80countriesaroundtheworld.

Sisley Cosmetics offers a comprehensive range of personal care products ranging from color
cosmetics to hand and body lotions, hair care, fragrances, facial treatments, and sun care
products.Sisleyoffersover220productSKUs.ItsSisleyaGlobalAntiAgeCreamisoneofthe
most expensive skin care creams on the market, at $475.00 for 1.7 ounces. New products
introducedduring2011areSkinleya,anantiagingliftfoundationandBlackrosecreammask.In
2012,thecompanylaunchestwomoreproductswhichincludesPhytoBlanclighteningserum,
consistingofactivelighteningcomplex,andSisleaConcentrAntiAgeFermetCorps,thefirst
globalantiagingskincareforthebodybySisleyCosmetics.

The company distributes its products through department stores, perfumeries, beauty
institutes,andalimitednumberofpharmacies.SisleyCosmeticsallocatesaTMEof$210,900in
2012. It invests in magazine advertising in the United States in 2012 for it skin care and
cosmeticproducts.

ManufacturerslevelsalesintheUnitedStatesareapproximately$11millionin2012,up10.0%
from $10 million in 2011, mainly driven by the new prodcut launches under the skin care
category.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

689

690

MinorCompanies

SMELLBENT

BrentLeonesio,aformerdesignerforCynthiaVincent(afashiondesigner),startedSmellBent,a
perfumecompany,withacollectionof10scents.BasedinWestHollywood,CA,thecompanys
earliest edition of fragrances was introduced in 2009. Smell Bents perfumes are available in
sprays and oil format. The company combines scent and art and uses childlike graphics for
packaging all perfumes. The company prices its brands at mass rates in order to approach a
broaderaudience.

SmellBentdevelopsaround59SKUsandallproductsarepricedbetween$20.00and$45.00.
Thefragrancesareclassifiedintodifferentcollections,suchasclassiccharacters,leisurecruise,
spray exclusives, vocabulary, limited edition, and sunset people. Bestsellers of the company
includeBollywoodandPrairieNymph.In2012,twocollectionsareintroduced:Vocabularyand
SunsetPeople.TheVocabularycollectionincludesbrandslikedry,floral,green,citrus,woody,
musky,andcompletistandSunsetPeopleincludesbrands,suchasDiscoNap,LadyGogo,Tipsy
SocialBlahBlah,MirrorBall,andWalkofShame.TheSmellBentbrandsarepromotedthrough
social networking sites like Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and YouTube. Online blogs are other
promotional mediums. Fragrances can be ordered at the company website, luckyscents.com,
ebay.com,andscentbar.com.SmellBentisestimatedtogrowat33.3%from$3millionin2011
to$4millionin2012.Salesgrowthissupportedbytheintroductionofmanynewfragrancesin
2012.

STEINERLEISURE

Headquartered in Nassau, the Bahamas, Steiner Leisure Limited is a global provider of spa
servicesandoperations.Thecompanymanufacturesanddistributespremiumskin,body,and
haircareproducts.Itisalsoanaccreditededucator,teachingstudentstheskillsnecessarytobe
a spa professional, including massage, skin care, and spa management. The company has
approximatelyover7,300employeesworldwidein2012.

ThecompanysMaritimeandResortSpadivisionsoperateinover210venuesonlandandat
sea. In November 2011, the company acquired Ideal Image Development, a leader in the
cosmetichealthcarecategoryoflaserhairremovalfor$175million.

The company operates in three reportable segments: Spa Operations, which provides spa
services onboard cruise ships, at hotels, and at spas. It sells its products through six brands
including Elemis, Bliss, Remde, La Thrapie, Mandara Spa, and Mandara. Its product lines
include cleansers, toners, moisturizers, lotions and other skin care products and cleansing
accessories, waxing and other body products, as well as aromatherapy oils, shampoos,
conditioners,andstylingproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A90

MinorCompanies

Thecompanysellsitspersonalcareproductsthroughdepartmentstores,throughotherthird
party retail outlets and distributors, as well as through salons and websites, including
www.timetospa.com, www.blissworld.com, and www.bodyworkmall.com. It also markets its
products through the QVC home shopping television channel. Steiner Education Group
operatesschoolsat30campuseslocatedinArizona,Colorado,Connecticut,Florida,Maryland,
Nevada,Pennsylvania,Utah,andVirginia.Offeringprogramsinmassagetherapyand,insome
cases, skin care, these schools train and qualify spa professionals for health and beauty
positionswithintheSteinerfamilyofcompaniesorotherindustryentities.

Totalcorporatesalesfor2012areapproximately$770million.Salesofcosmeticsandtoiletries
intheUnitedStatesareapproximately$31millionin2012,upfrom$30millionin2011.Steiner
LeisurehasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

SUEISMIEL&DAUGHTERS

Sue Ismiel& Daughters specializes in the manufacturing, marketing, and distribution of hair
removal products, health supplements, and hair treatments products. The company is
headquarteredatBaulkhamHills,NSW,Australia.Thefamilyownedcompanyhasthreebrands:
Aussies Nad, a hair removal product; Wyld, a natural health supplement; and Nitwits, a lice
treatmentproductforhair.

AussiesNadwasestablishedin1992byCEOSueIsmiel.ThecompanysU.S.headquartersare
located at Torrance, CA. Aussies Nad accounts for a large portion of the companys overall
revenues.In2012,AussiesNadcelebratesits20thanniversary.Theproductsaredistributedin
Australia,NewZealand,theUnitedStates,Canada,andtheUnitedKingdom.

The companys personal care offerings comprise naturalinspired hair removal products.
Products are classified under two separate lines, Nad For Men and Nad For Women. In the
mensline,thecompanyoffersproducts,suchashairremovalcreamsandhairremovalstrips.It
alsooffersproducts,suchasIngrowSolutions,acreamwhichhelpstoeliminateingrownhair,
razorburns,andshavingrashes.Hairremovalproductsforwomenincludehairremovalcreams
andhairremovalstripsasitsmainofferings.Alltheproductsfallinthecategoryofdepilatories,
waxes,andbleaches.

In2012,thecompanylaunchesNoseWaxformenandwomenunderitsNadsbrand.

Products are sold through 35,000 retail points including food, drug, and mass merchandising
storesnationwide.SomeoftheselectedretailchainsareTarget,Kmart,CVS,andRiteAid.The
brandisalsosoldthroughinfomercials.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

691

692

MinorCompanies

ThecompanyallocatesaninsignificantamountofTMEin2012.Asidefromprintadvertisingin
magazines,thecompanydoesitspromotionthroughvarioussocialmediasiteswhichinclude
Facebook,TwitterandYouTube.

SalesintheUnitedStatestotal$10millionin2012,constantat2011levels,mainlyduetostiff
competitionin2012.

SUNDAYRILEY

SundayRileyisawomanwholaunchedherownantiagingskincarelinein2009.Thecompany
isheadquarteredinHouston,TX.Alltheproductsaremadebyacombinationofbotanicalsand
biotechnology.ThemainingredientofallproductsisNV5AgelessComplex.Itisablendoffive
NativeAmericanbotanicalsthatprovidecellularhealing,detoxification,andregeneration.

Sunday Rileys skin care product portfolio includes brands, such as Charisma Crme Cleanser,
Stimulant I Perfecting Stem Cell Serum for wrinkles, Good Genes treatment mask, Juno
TransformativeLipidSerumforradiance,Bionicantiagingcream,CashmereSPF30,StartOver
eyecream,BeyondBodyLotion,andBodyLipidSerum.

Sunday Riley promotes its products on social network sites, such as Facebook, Tumblr,
YouTube, and Twitter. The companys brands have nationwide presence in highend
departmentstoreslikeBarneysNewYork,BergdorfGoodman,SpaceNK,specialtystoressuch
asSephora,andonlineretailerslikenordstrom.comanddermstore.com.

ItisestimatedthatSundayRileyemploysfourpeopleanditscorporatesalesfor2011areat$1
million.Salesarerelativelyflatin2012aswell.

SUNSTAR

BasedoutofOsaka,Japan,Sunstarwasfoundedin1946andisapubliclyheldmanufacturerof
oral care, hair care, and skin care products. It also sells health foods, household products,
constructionmaterials,andmaterialsforindustrialuse.

Thecompanyhas3,966employeesworldwideandtotalsalesof$1,141millionin2012.Itsoral
care division accounts for 81% of the total revenues. Sunstar has 22 subsidiary companies
outsideJapan,withtheU.S.headquarterslocatedinChicago,IL.

IntheUnitedStates,thecompanyemploysover200people.SunstarAmericasonlymarketsthe
ButlerGumbrand,underwhichthecompanyofferstoothbrushes,toothpastes,andsomeoral
careaccessoriesandflossproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A92

MinorCompanies

Sunstar Americas distributes nationwide through food, drug, and mass merchandise retailers,
suchasWalmart,RiteAid,andPriceChopper.TheU.S.manufacturerslevelsalesforSunstars
cosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsareestimatedat$24millionin2011and2012.Thecompany
spends$1.8millionTMEtosupportitsbrandsin2012anditallocatesalloftheTMEtosupport
itsButlerGumbrand.ThecompanyallocatestheentireTMEthroughmagazineadvertisements.

TARTE

Tarte was founded in 2000 by Maureen Kelly and is headquartered at New York, NY. The
companydevelopsalineofcosmeticproductswiththepremisethattheyarefreeofsynthetic
ingredientsandnourishtheskin.

The company markets makeup products, such as primers, concealers, foundation, powder,
blush,bronzer,eyeshadow,eyeliner,mascara,lashenhancer,lipstick,lipgloss,liptint,andlip
liner.In2012,Tarteintroducesitssummerandfallcollectionofproducts.TheyincludeCallof
the Wild Amazonian Clay 8shadow collector's palette, Call of the Wild Amazonian Clay liner,
MaracujaMiraclefoundation,AmazonianClay12hourfullcoveragefoundation,Beauty&the
BoxAmazonianclayeyeshadowquad,andBambeautifulAmazonianClayeyeshadowpalette.

Thecompanypromotesitsproductsthroughtelevisioncommercialsandinmagazines,suchas
Allure,Cosmopolitan,Star,USWeekly,People,OK!,Life&Style,Lucky,andMarieClaire,andon
socialnetworkingsiteslikeFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube.Discountandsamplecouponsare
also available on the companys website. The products are available in 200 specialty stores
nationwide,suchasUlta,Sephora,andHenriBendel.

Tarte is a privatelyheld company and employs 17 people as of 2011. Sales are estimated to
remainconstantat$4millionin2012.

TATASNATURALALCHEMY

TataHarperSkincareisthebrandownedandmarketedbyTatasNaturalAlchemy,LLC,which
wasfoundedin2010byTataHarper,withtheaimtoofferwomenarangeofproductsthatare
natural,nontoxic,andofferresults.TataHarperisheadquarteredintheChamplainValleyof
Vermont.

Theproductionandmanufacturingoftheproductstakesplaceatthecompanysheadquarters
in Vermont where many of the essential ingredients are grown. The companys products
offerings include facial treatments, lip balms, jellies, and treatment and aromatherapy
products.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

693

694

MinorCompanies

Tostaytruetoitsnaturalandsustainablegoals,TatasNaturalAlchemymakeseffortstouse
recycledpackagingmaterials,recyclableglassbottles,andtreelesslabels.In2012,thecompany
changesitstaglineforthethirdtimetoTheNextGenerationofBeautyasthecompanyclaims
to formulate its products with unprecedented concentrations of active natural ingredients
between9%and29%perbottle.

In2012,TataHarperreformulatesitsHydratingFloralEssencewithbeetrootextractaddedand
ResurfacingMaskwithanewadvancedformula.

TataHarperSkincarefindspresscoverageinmagazinesincludingMarieClaire,VanityFair,LA
Confidential,HarpersBazaar,Prevention,Latina,Style,NYTimes,LATimes,Lucky,Allure,and
Vogue. The company is socially active on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and YouTube. The
companydoesnotreportanysignificantTMEin2012.

Tata Harper skincare products are available at boutiques, department stores, drug stores,
online retailers, salons, specialty stores, and spa and resorts. Retailers carrying Tata Harper
productsincludeSpaceNK,OrganicAvenue,andBloomingdales.

SalesforthecompanyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketatthemanufacturerslevel
total$3millionin2012,almostflatfrom2011.In2013,thecompanyisexpectedtolaunchan
entirenewlipcarelinecomprisingtheBeTruesheerliptreatment,BeAdoredrosytintedlip
treatment,andBeFiercesheerliptreatment.

TEDGIBSON

Ted Gibson is a celebrity hairstylist who created his line of hair care products. His salons are
locatedinNewYork,NYandFt.Lauderdale,FL.HiscelebrityclientlistincludesAnneHathaway,
Debra Messing, Angelina Jolie, Ashley Greene, Joy Bryant, Zoe Saldana, Emma Watson, and
GabrielleUnion.

TedGibsonshaircareproductportfolioincludesshampooslikeDailycleanse,Claritycolor,and
GlimmeringGoldshampoo,conditioners,suchasDailyNourish,BrazenBrownconditioner,and
CaptivatingCopperconditioner,andstylingproductslikeFixitstylinggel,TameItShineLotion,
andBuildItBlowdryingAgent.

His work has appeared in publications, such as Vogue, Harpers Bazaar, Elle, Marie Claire,
Vanity Fair, People StyleWatch, W, and Allure. Ted Gibson is also the resident hair expert on
TLCsWhatNottoWear.Hisbrandsarepromotedontelevision,socialnetworkingsiteslike
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTube,andthroughonlineblogs.TedGibsonproductsareavailable
throughretailerslikeTarget,Sephora,QVC,beauty.com,beautybar.com,andamazon.com.

CosmeticsandtoiletriesproductssalesofTedGibsonareestimatedat$2millionin2012,same
as2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A94

MinorCompanies

TOOFACEDCOSMETICS

Thecompanywasestablishedin1998byJerrodBlandinoandJeremyJohnson.Itisoneofthe
largestindependentcosmeticscompaniesintheUnitedStates.BasedinIrvine,CA,TooFaced
Cosmeticsdevelopsandmarketsaportfolioofmakeupproductsthatareoftenusedbymakeup
artists and fashion stylists. It serves boutiques and department stores through a network of
global distributors. Apart from the United States and Canada, Too Faced Cosmetics has its
presenceinNorthernEuropeandtheAsiaPacificregion.

Thecompanymarketseyemakeupproducts,suchasbasesandprimers,shadows,glittersand
shimmers,liners,mascaras,andbrows;andlipproductslikelipglosses,lipsticks,plumpers,and
lip pencils. Its face makeup products include concealers, pressed powders, foundations,
blushes, bronzers, and bronzing palettes. In 2012, Too Faced Cosmetics launches The
ConfectionCollectionwhichincludesasetofeyeshadows,lipshades,andbrushes,andLove
SweetLovemakeupcollection.ItalsointroduceseyepaletteslikeShadowBonBons,Glamour
To Go Spun Sugar Edition, and Return of Sexy and mascaras like Better Than False Lashes,
3*WayLashLiningTool,andLashInjection.LaCrmelipstickpricedat$21.00islaunchedin16
shadesin2012.

Thecompanysassociationwithcelebrities,suchasCourtneyLove,Madonna,DrewBarrymore,
FranDrescher,ShannonDougherty,QueenLatifa,andBrookeShieldsprovidesstrongpublicity
to the brand. It also promotes its brands on websites like Facebook, Twitter, Instagram,
Pinterest, and YouTube. In January 2013, the company announces that Francesca Eastwood,
daughterofClintEastwood,isthenewfaceofthebrand.

IntheUnitedStates,productsareavailableinselectspecialtybeautystores,suchasSephora
andUlta,highenddepartmentstoreslikeNordstrom,andatothersmallretailers.

Thecompanyemploysaround50people.TotalsalesofTooFacedCosmeticsareestimatedat
$32million,upby6.6%from$30millionin2011.Salesgrowthissupportedbytheintroduction
ofmanynewproducts.

UNIVERSITYMEDICAL

Universal Medical Pharmaceuticals was founded in 1992 by Raymond Francis. It is


headquartered in Irvine, CA. The company markets and distributes personal care products.
Amongthepersonalcareproducts,itprimarilymarketsskincareproductsformenandwomen.
Themanufacturingandproductionactivitiesareoutsourced.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

695

696

MinorCompanies

Theproductrangecomprisesfourcorebrands:AcneFreeacnetreatments,FaceLiftantiaging
facial treatments, WrinkleMD professional use antiwrinkle treatments, and Body Lift body
firmingskincareproducts.However,thecompanysellsitsAcneFreelinefor$64millioninMay,
2012toValeantPharmaceuticals.

University Medical products are distributed through mass retailers, such as Target and
Walmart; drug stores, such as CVS, Walgreens, and Longs Drugs; food stores including
Albertsons; and cosmetics retailer Ulta. The company has strong distribution in warehouse
stores,CostcoandSamsClub.

Thecompanylaunchesseveralnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

WrinkleMD Eye Starter System claimed to give 15 times greater reduction in the
appearanceofwrinkles.
EyePatchthatclaimstokeeptheskinlookingradiant,smooth,andyouthful.

DomesticmanufacturerslevelsalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheU.S.marketareroughly
$4 million in 2011 and 2012. These figures do not include the sales of Acne Free, due to the
divestiturein2012.UniversalMedicalhasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

URTH

Urth Skin Solutions for Men was founded in 2007 to develop grooming products specific to
men. Urths comprehensive product line comprises facial treatments, hand and body lotions,
and shaving products that are formulated with botanical solutions. The company is
headquarteredinLosAngeles,CA.

Urthsproductofferingsincludearangeoffiveproducts:FaceWashwithWhiteTea&Ginseng
gentle cleanser formulated with herbs, essential oils, antioxidants, and vitamins; Scrub with
GreenTeaandRiceremovesdeadcellsforsofter,smoother,andyoungerlookingskin;Shave
FormulawithGinseng&TeaTreeluxuriouscreamthatminimizesrazorburnsandbumps;Face
Balm with SPF 15 with White Tree and Vitamins provides antioxidant protection to improve
skin tone, texture, and reduce fine lines and wrinkles; and HydraTherapy antioxidant
hydratingtreatmentthatreducestheappearanceoffinelinesandwrinklesandstimulatesthe
production of collagen and elastin. The company claims that its product lines have been
inspiredfromancientAsianingredients.

UrthmarketingactivitiesinvolvesprintadvertisementsandPRwriteupsinmagazines,suchas
Mens Health and Instinct Magazine. Urth video commercials are available for viewing on
YouTube. The companys website offers tips and advice to men for their wellbeing. The
company offers a simple packaging reflecting the products natural botanicalbased
formulations.NosignificantTMEbythecompanyhavebeenreportedfor2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A96

MinorCompanies

Urthproductsareavailableatselectbeautysalons,spas,andhotelsincludingViceroy,HairM,
MenEssentials,DetailsforMen,TheBreakersPalmBeach,andSkinReflections.

SalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesforUrthintheUnitedStatesareestimatedat$3million2012,
almostflatfrom2011.During2013,thecompanyisexpectedtolaunchaclaymask,anunder
eyecream,andabodywash.

VALEANTPHARMACEUTICALS

Headquartered at Bridgewater, NJ, Valeant Pharmaceuticals is a specialty pharmaceutical


company engaged in the development, manufacture, and marketing of pharmaceutical
productsintheareasofneurology,dermatology,andinfectiousdiseases.

Foundedin1960,ValeantPharmaceuticalsmarketsover350brandedproducts.Asof2012,the
company has a work force of 7,500 employees across the globe. In the United States, it has
nearly 575 employees. The companys production facilities are located in four different
countries:Canada,Mexico,Poland,andBrazil.

Valeantoffersconsumerproductsforskinandhaircare,vitamins,painrelief,andtopicalcare,
amongothers.

SomeoftheotherbrandswithinValeant'scosmeticsandtoiletriesbusinessincludeDermaglow
skincareandmakeup,Dr.LeWinnbyKineraseskincare,Dr.Renaudskincare,Kinerase,CeraVe
skin care, Ultra, Dermaveen skin care, O, and Dermadrate skin care. The company acquires
Ambi fade cream from Johnson & Johnson and Acne Free from University Medical in 2012.
ValeantPharmaceuticalsallocates$5.7millionofTMEforitscosmeticsandtoiletriesproducts
in2012.Mostofthisamountisspentonmagazineadvertisements.

Total corporate sales for the company in 2012 are estimated at $3,550 million, up from
$2,460millionin2011and$1,181millionin2010.Ofthe$3,500millionworldwide,theUnited
Statesaccountsfor72.0%andcontributes$2,500millionin2012.

The companys manufacturers level sales in the United States for cosmetics and toiletries
productsareestimatedat$57million,down6.6%from$61millionin2011.Bothyears'sales
includetheacquiredAmbiandAcneFreebrands.InMarch2013,thecompanyannouncesthat
itisacquiringtheoutstandingstockofObagifor$360million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

697

698

MinorCompanies

VAPOURBEAUTY

Eric Sakas, cofounder of Kevyn Aucoin Beauty, Krysia Boinis, a botanical expert, and Kristine
Keheley, an abstract artist founded Vapour Beauty in 2009. The company is located at Taos,
NM.VapourBeautyscosmeticsaremadefromnaturalmineralpigmentssuspendedincertified
organic botanicals that help beautify the skin. Its products contain 70% of certified organic
ingredientsand30%ofvitaminsandminerals.ThecompanyusesLightReflectionTechnology
thatcomplementsdifferentskintonesandhelpstoavailthebenefitsofitsproducts.

VapourBeautysportfolioconsistsof110SKUsofskincareandmakeupproducts.Itsskincare
line consists of Essence Restorative Night Treatment that promotes cell renewal and Clarity
MakeupRemovingCleansingOilthatcleansandprovidesantiagingantioxidantstoprotectthe
skin. In its makeup line, the company markets brands, such as Atmosphere foundation,
Illusionistconcealer,Mesmerizeeyeshimmer,Auramultiuseblush,Solartranslucentbronzer,
Siren lipstick, Elixir lip gloss, and Vernissage 3free nail lacquer. In 2012, Vapour Beauty
launches its Vernissage Nail Lacquers which are available in four shades. Replenish Nail &
CuticleOil,madeofUSDA(U.S.DepartmentofAgriculture)certifiedorganicoilsandbotanicals
includingjojobaoil,reishimushrooms,andpomegranateseedoil,isalsolaunchedin2012.

Vapour Beauty products are promoted on social networking sites like Facebook, Google+,
Twitter, Pinterest, and YouTube, online blogs, and in magazines, such as Bella, Lucky,
Dermascope,Seventeen,OrganicSpa,InStyle,Fashion,Cosmopolitan,People,WWD,Allure,and
Health.Productsareavailableatvapourbeauty.comandselectspecialtyboutiques.

VapourBeautyhasastaffofaround12people.Salesareestimatedtogrowat11.1%toaround
$1millionin2012from$900,000in2011.

THEVILLAGECOMPANY

TheVillageCompanyisamarketeranddistributorofpersonalcareproducts.Thecompanywas
founded in 1993 and was formerly known as Minnetonka Brands. The Village Company is
headquartered in Chaska, MN. In 2008, the company acquires Mr. Bubble, an iconic bubble
bathbrand.

Thecompany'sproductsaresoldthroughretailandonlinestoresunderthebrandnamesMr.
Bubble,SesameStreet,BathShoppe,VillageNaturals,andVillageNaturalsAromatherapy.The
Village Companys product offerings include personal cleansing products, shampoos, foot
essentials,andtherapyproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A98

MinorCompanies

Asapartofits50thbirthdaycelebrations,in2011,thebrandcameoutwithaspecialbirthday
editionpackagingforitsproductsandgaveMr.Bubbles,themascotofthebrand,anewlook.
In2011,thebrandintroducedtheOriginalBubblyBodyWash,anextrabubblingformulathatis
tearfree, hypoallergenic, dermatologist and pediatriciantested, Extra Gentle Body Wash
gentlebodywashthatisdyefreeandfragrancefreeforsensitiveskin;MoisturizingHandSoap,
formulated with aloe, the hypoallergenic, dermatologisttested hand soap for both kids and
adults;andExtraGentleMoisturizingHandSoap,dyefreeandfragrancefreeExtraGentleHand
Soap.

In 2012, the company has not introduced any new products; however, the Therapy brand
undergoes a packaging change with respect to changes in the labeling and bottling. Also in
2012, The Village Naturals Bath Shoppe brings back the original Milk Bath Jug, a curvy jug
packagewithasinglehandleloopwithanewdyefreeformula.

The Village Companys newsletter, The Splash, keeps the consumers updated with the latest
news about the company pertaining to new product launches, exclusive promotions, and
coupons.Thecompanyishighlyactiveonsocialnetworkingsites,suchasFacebookandTwitter.
ItdoesnothaveanyTMEin2012.

Mr.Bubbleshaslaunchedanumberofretrostylecommercialsintheyearspriorto2012which
are available on YouTube. Products are retailed through a number of food, mass, and drug
stores including Walmart, Walgreens, RiteAid, Target, CVS, Duane Reade, Toys R Us, and
Kroger.Theseproductsarealsoavailableonamazon.comanddrugstore.com.

ThecompanyssalesintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketareapproximately$11million
in2012,flatwith2011sales.

VINCENTLONGO

VincentLongolauncheditsrangeofcolorcosmeticsin1995.Itwasfoundedbyawellknown
makeupartist,VincentLongo,andisheadquarteredinNewYork,NY.Thecompanysproducts
gained popularity with the introduction of trendsetting color palettes in the late 1990s. The
founders association with supermodels and celebrities developed a following among
consumers.

VincentLongosproductportfolioincludesprimer,foundation,concealer,powder,eyeshadow,
mascara,eyelinerandpencil,fauxlashes,blush,bronzer,gelstains,lipstick,lipgloss,andlip
pencil. The company launched two new collectionsGalaxy Dream and New Essentialsin
2011 and one new collectionPulsein 2012. The Pulse collection introduces 10 SKUs that
includelippencil,lipstick,gelstains,andeyeshadow.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

699

6100

MinorCompanies

Vincent Longo promotes its products via association with famous people. Some of its clients
include celebrities like Sharon Stone, Sigourney Weaver, Gwyneth Paltrow, Claire Danes,
Courtney Cox, Michelle Williams, Sarah Jessica Parker, Mena Suvari, Molly Sims, Paris Hilton,
Christina Ricci, Sissy Spacek, Jennifer Lopez, Jewel, Celine Dion, Candice Bergen, Bernadette
Peters,CatherineDeneuve,andElizabethHurley.

Vincent Longo products are available at Bloomingdales, Space NK freestanding stores,


Nordstrom, Cosmetic Boutique, Beauty.com, Makeup.com, and at select spas and boutiques
across the United States. The brands are promoted on social network sites like Facebook,
Twitter,andYouTube.

Salesareestimatedat$1millionin2012,thesameasin2011.

VOGUEINTERNATIONAL

VogueInternationalwasstartedbyahairstylist,ToddC.Christopherin1987.Heisthecurrent
presidentandchiefexecutiveofficerofthecompanyandisthesoleshareholder.Thecompany
isheadquarteredinTampaBay,Florida.VogueInternationalInc.marketsanddistributeshair
careandotherpersonalcareproducts.

Thecompanymarketsanddistributesproductsinnearly42countriesworldwide.Allproduction
activities are outsourced. Packaging of products is handled at Vogues 40,000squarefoot
facilitylocatedatanindustrialparkinOldsmar,FL,whichalsoservesasthecompanysglobal
headquarters.Ithas45employeesintheUnitedStates.

Thecompanysmainproductofferingsarehairstylingproducts,shampoos,andconditioners.
The company markets three brands: FX line of hair styling products, Organix collection of
shampoos,conditioners,andstyling/treatmentproducts,andOrganixBath&BodyCollection.

Thecompanylaunchesarangeofnewproductsin2012.Someofthekeylaunchesinclude:

MacadamiaOilDryStylingOilmadewithmacadamiaoilwhichthecompanyclaimsinstantly
hydratesandsmoothesdryhair.
Awapuhi Ginger Shampoo has a moisturizing formula and is infused with Awapuhi Ginger
extracttoinstantlymendandsoftendryhair.
Macadamia Oil Shampoo instantly hydrates and smoothens dry hair while mending split
endsforabrilliantshine.
MoroccanArganOilmakesthehairsmoothandshiny,healthy,andstrongwithitsnatural
ingredients.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A100

MinorCompanies

Voguesproductsaredistributedprimarilythroughthefood,drug,andmasschannels,including
Albertsons,CVS,Kroger,Publix,RiteAid,Safeway,Target,Ulta,Walgreens,Walmart,andWinn
Dixie.Thecompanypromotesitsproductsprimarilythroughtheprintmedia.

ManufacturerslevelsalesintheUnitedStatesareestimatedat$63millionfor2012,upfrom
$60millionin2011.VogueInternationalspends$3.5millionTMEtosupportitsbrandsin2012.
ThecompanyspendsitstotalTMEtosupportitsbrandOrganixin2012.

WEIEAST

WeiEastwasfoundedbyWeiBrianin1999andisbasedinNewtownSquare,PA.Thecompany
combines traditional Chinese herbal medicines to deliver natural skin care treatments. The
company partnered with HSN in 2002. Wei East is a traditional Chinese skin care remedy
companyintheUnitedStates.Itformulatesmanytypesofherbsthatcreateacomplexwhichis
usedinitsproducts.WeiEastproductsareproducedinChina.

Wei Easts portfolio consists of skin care products which include cleansers, toners, serums,
moisturizers, masques, exfoliants, and specialty treatment products. Some of its skin care
products include Chestnut & Black Soy cleansing cream, Sichuan Holly Wrinkle Away Serum,
PomegranateAntiOxidantExfoliatingGrains,andBrightLightsRiceMilkSpotBrightener.The
company also markets makeup products like foundation, powder, concealer, blush, and lip
gloss. Some of them include Enriched Powder Foundation, Chinese Rose Pressed Blush, and
White Olive Tinted Lip Smoother. In 2012, Wei East launches White Lotus Hydrating a day
cream, Sichuan Holly Wrinkle Away Amazing Eyes, Sichuan Holly Wrinkle Away Serum, and
ChinaAgeDelaycollectionthatincludescleansers,toners,masques,moisturizers,andserums.

Products are promoted online through social network sites, such as Facebook, YouTube, and
Twitter. Wei Easts products are available through online retailers, such as weieast.com,
thefind.com,ebay.com,andhsn.com.

The U.S. manufacturers sales of the companyare estimated at $8 million in 2012, about the
sameas2011levels.

WELEDA

Weleda is a privatelyowned global manufacturer, distributor, and retailer of natural and


organic personal care products and pharmaceuticals. The company was founded in 1921 in
Arlesheim,Switzerland.Itisalsothecompanyspresentcorporateheadquarters.Weledawas
firstformedasapharmaceuticalcompanydevelopedbytheDutchmedicaldoctor,ItaWegman
andAustrianphilosopher,Dr.RudolfSteiner,toprovideremediesandbodycarepreparations
totheirpatients.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6101

6102

MinorCompanies

Weledas administrative headquarters and production division is located in Arlesheim,


Switzerland.TheWeledagroupconsistsof20subsidiaries,locatedinfivecontinentsincluding
Europe,Asia,Africa,NorthAmerica,andSouthAmerica.Thetwomostimportantsubsidiaries
are located in Schwbisch Gmnd, Germany, and Huningue, France. The company has three
productionfacilitieslocatedinFrance,Germany,andSwitzerland.

Weledas products are available in 50 countries across five continents with 20 regional
subsidiary companies. As of 2012, the company employs over 2,000 people worldwide.
Weledasproductformulationsaremadeupofalmostallnaturalororganicingredients,which
isanaddedadvantageoveranumberofothernaturalmarketers.

The companys personal care portfolio consists of 200 different products that broadly fall in
categories,suchasbabycare,bodycare,facialcare,haircare,mensskincare,andoralcare
products.

In2012,thecompanylaunchesthreenewbodylotionswhichincludesCitrusrefreshingbody
carefornormalskin,SeaBuckthorn,WildRose,andPomegranate.

WeledasproductsareavailableacrosstheUnitedStatesandCanada.Thecompanysproducts
arealsosoldonline,andalltheproductscanbepurchasedfromtheirwebsite.Weledaoffers
freeshippingonordersover$50.00.Thecompanyapportions$4,900ofTMEin2012.

Weledasglobalsalesofpersonalcareproductsatthemanufacturerslevelare$355millionin
2012, up from $324 million in 2011. The companys sales in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries
marketsareapproximately$11millionin2012,anincreasefrom$10millionin2011,upby10%
mainlydrivenbytheintroductionofnewproductlauches.

YESTO

YesToInc.manufactures,distributes,andmarketsnaturalface,body,andhaircareproducts.
The company was founded in 2006 by Ido Leffler and his business partner, Lance Kalish. It is
headquartered in San Francisco, CA. The companys headquarters and production facilities
weremovedtotheUnitedStatesfromIsraelin2010.Thecompanydistributesproductsin15
countries and employs nearly 30 personnel in the United States and about 70 personnel
worldwide. The companys rapid success in a very short period is mainly due to its unique
formulation,combiningbetacarotenefromorganicfruitsandvegetables,and26mineralsand
traceelementsharvestedfromtheDeadSea.YesTomarketsover65SKUsofnaturalskincare
andhaircareunderfivesubbrands:YesToCarrots,YesToTomatoes,YesToCucumbers,and
Yes To Blueberries, and Yes To Baby Carrots. The companys product categories include
shampoos, conditioners, lip balms and jellies, facial treatments, hand and body lotions, baby
care,andsuncare.Thecompanyemphasizesthatingredientsusedforproductionarenatural,
ecological,andcertifiedorganic.Theingredientsintheproductlinearesourcedfromcertified
organicfarmers.ThekeyingredientsinYesTosproductsarebetacarotene,anaturalformof
VitaminAfoundinorange,yellow,anddarkgreenfruitsandvegetables.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A102

MinorCompanies

The companys products are formulated for normaltodry skin and hair types; sensitive skin
typesandcolortreatedhair;andoily/combinationskintypesandfine/thinhair.Itoffersface
care products, including nourishing, soothing/sensitive, clear skin/acne, and age refresh
products; body care products comprising body moisturizers and washes, hand care products,
and intensive care products; hair care products, which include nourishing products and
soothingproducts;andlipandbabycareproducts.

Thecompanysellsitsproductsonlineandthroughdrug,mass,andgroceryoutletsintheUnited
States;andthroughretailstoresin15othercountries.IntheUnitedStates,thecompanyhas
theentirerangeofproductsstockedatWalgreens.Productsarealsoretailedthroughnational
retailchains,suchasUlta,CVS,DuaneReed,Target,andWholeFoods.Eachofthesechannels
playsanimportantroleinthecompanyscategoryandgrowthstrategy.Thecompanycontinues
toexpanditsdistributionnetworkintheUnitedStatesandEurope.

In the United States, the company considers PR, sampling, instore promotions, and social
medianetworks,suchasFacebookandTwitter,asthekeymarketingchannels.Thecompanys
productsarefeaturedinmagazines,suchasTheOprahMagazine,Lucky,People,Glamour,and
InStyle.

Thecompanylaunchesavarietyofnewproductsin2012.Someofitskeylaunchesinclude:

Yes to Blueberries Deep Wrinkle Night Cream that provides a soothing and intensive
parabenfreehydratingtreatmentforagingskin.
Yes to Blueberries Deep Wrinkle Filler claims to immediately reduce the look of fine lines
andwrinkles,isfreefrompetroleumandparaben.
Yes to Blueberries Softening Facial Exfoliator is formulated with Blueberries to fight the
formationoffreeradicals,andAppletohelprefreshandbrightentheskin'ssurface.
Yes to Carrots AntiFrizz Serum is perfect for frizzy hair types and provides a nourishing
serumtolockinmoistureandshine.
YestoCarrotsLeaveinConditionerclaimstodeliveramixofproteinsandarganoildeep
intothehaircuticleforseriousrestructuringandrejuvenatingbenefits.

The companys sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States are estimated at
$31millionin2012,upfrom$29millionin2011.YesTohasnegligibleTMErecordedin2012.

YVESROCHER

YvesRocher,Inc.,aprivatelyheldmanufacturer,marketer,andretailerofbotanicalbeautyand
wellness products, is headquartered in La Gacilly, France. It was founded in 1956 by Yves
Rocher,andisoneofFrancesleadingmarketersofnaturalpersonalcareproducts.Itisawholly
owned subsidiary of French beautycompany, Yves RocherS.A. The companys manufacturing
facilityislocatedinKilbarryBusinessPark,DublinHill,Ireland.YvesRocherhasitsUnitedStates
headquarters located in Houston, TX. The company distributes 300 million products in more
than 80 countries. The Yves Rocher Group owns seven brands, all focused on women: Yves
Rocher,PetitBateau,Stanhome,DrPierreRicaud,DanielJouvance,Kiotis,andIDParfums.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

6103

6104

MinorCompanies

The company is a global marketer of a broad range of natural personal care products. It
specializesintheskincaresegment,includingproductcategories,suchasfacialtreatmentsand
hand and body lotions. Yves Rocher is also one of the leading marketers of mass market
fragrances across continental Europe. The company further competes in the household
cleaningandhomeimprovementproductscategorywithitsStanhomebrand.

Yves Rochers popular products include Recovery Moisturizer Night 1st Lines, an antiaging
moisturizerthattargetsagingsignswithconcentratedricepeptidesandceramides;Arnica2in
1 Hand & Nail cream; Nourishing Shampoo for dry hair; and Laotian Lotus Flower, an anti
perspirantdeodorantthatgives24hourprotection.

In 2012, Sanofi sells its 19.3% stake in the Yves Rocher Group to Socit Financire des
LaboratoiresdeCosmtologieYvesRocher.TheRocherfamilyisexpectedtocontrolmorethan
95%oftheGroupscapitalafterthisdivestmentofstakebySanofi.Sanofiacquiredastakein
theYvesRocherGroupscapitalin1973anddivestedpartofitsstakeintheearly2000s.Yves
Rocher Group acquires 51% share in Flormar, a Turkish cosmetics company, in 2012, for an
estimated$150million.

Distribution is primarily through direct mail and freestanding independent stores worldwide.
The company generates 60% of its revenues through direct mail orders from sources that
include its catalog, website, and independent beauty consultants. The remaining 40% of its
revenues are generated through its independent freestanding stores. In the United States,
almostonehalfofitssalesaregeneratedthroughdirectmailorders.Itpromotesthroughsocial
media websites like Facebook by informing about new product launches, giving makeup tips,
andprovidingreviewsaboutitsvariousproducts.ThereisnoevidentallocationofTMEforYves
Rochersproductsin2012.

Thecompanylaunchesarangeofnewproductsacrossitsskincare,makeup,fragrances,body
care,andbathandshowerproducttypesin2012,suchasCultureBIOAntiWrinkledaycare,
Culture BIO AntiWrinkle night care, Couleurs Nature High Concentration nail lacquer, Candid
MallowsandVanillaLemonSparklingbodylotion,andLesJardinsDuMondeshowergel.

YvesRochersglobalcorporaterevenueisabout$3billionin2012.ManufacturerssalesofYves
RocherforcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesareestimatedat$73millionin2012,up
7.4% from $68 million in 2011 based on new product launches, and its practice of actively
connectingtocustomersbyprovidingdetailsonitsproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A104

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

MajorCompanies

SectionFive

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

MAJORCOMPANIES

SectionFiveof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJuly1,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employeesofsubscribingcompaniesandtheirsubsidiaries,asdefinedabove,untilJuly1,2016.
Similarly,allsectionsofthesurveyaresorestrictedforthreeyearsfromtheirdatesofissue.
Failuretopreventunauthorizeddisclosurebeforethesedateswillresultinlegalactionagainst
thesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES
Introduction....................................................................................................................51
Overview........................................................................................................................53
Totalsales........................................................................................................................53
Growth.............................................................................................................................54
Alticor(Amway)..............................................................................................................57
Companyoverview..........................................................................................................57
Corporatesalesandprofits..............................................................................................59
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................510
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................511
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................511
Outlook..........................................................................................................................512
Avon.............................................................................................................................515
Companyoverview........................................................................................................518
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................518
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................520
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................522
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................524
Outlook..........................................................................................................................525
Beiersdorf.....................................................................................................................529
Companyoverview........................................................................................................530
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................530
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................531
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................534
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................535
Outlook..........................................................................................................................537
Chanel..........................................................................................................................541
Companyoverview........................................................................................................542
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................542
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................542
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................545
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................545
Outlook..........................................................................................................................546

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Church&Dwight...........................................................................................................549
Companyoverview........................................................................................................550
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................550
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................551
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................553
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................554
Outlook..........................................................................................................................555
Clarins...........................................................................................................................557
Companyoverview........................................................................................................558
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................558
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................559
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................561
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................561
Outlook..........................................................................................................................562
TheCloroxCompany.....................................................................................................565
Companyoverview........................................................................................................566
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................566
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................567
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................570
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................571
Outlook..........................................................................................................................572
ColgatePalmolive.........................................................................................................575
Companyoverview........................................................................................................576
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................577
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................578
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................580
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................582
Outlook..........................................................................................................................583
Combe..........................................................................................................................587
Companyoverview........................................................................................................587
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................588
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................588
Recentdevelopments....................................................................................................590
Marketingactivity..........................................................................................................590
Outlook..........................................................................................................................591

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Coty..............................................................................................................................593
Companyoverview........................................................................................................597
Corporatesalesandprofits............................................................................................598
Cosmeticsandtoiletries.................................................................................................599
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5101
Newproducts...............................................................................................................5102
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5103
Outlook........................................................................................................................5105
ElizabethArden..........................................................................................................5107
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5109
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5110
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5111
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5113
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5113
Outlook........................................................................................................................5114
EnergizerHoldings......................................................................................................5119
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5119
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5120
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5121
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5124
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5124
Outlook........................................................................................................................5126
EsteLauder...............................................................................................................5129
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5133
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5134
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5136
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5140
Notablenewproducts.................................................................................................5141
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5144
Outlook........................................................................................................................5149
GlaxoSmithKline.........................................................................................................5155
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5156
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5157
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5157
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5159
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5160
Outlook........................................................................................................................5162

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
GuthyRenker.............................................................................................................5165
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5165
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5166
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5166
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5168
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5168
Outlook........................................................................................................................5170
HelenofTroy..............................................................................................................5173
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5174
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5175
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5176
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5178
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5178
Outlook........................................................................................................................5180
Johnson&Johnson.....................................................................................................5183
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5185
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5186
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5187
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5193
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5195
Outlook........................................................................................................................5198
Kao.............................................................................................................................5203
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5204
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5205
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5206
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5208
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5209
Outlook........................................................................................................................5210
LimitedBrands............................................................................................................5213
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5215
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5215
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5216
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5220
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5222
Outlook........................................................................................................................5223

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
LOral........................................................................................................................5227
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5233
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5234
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5235
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5243
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5248
Outlook........................................................................................................................5252
LVMH..........................................................................................................................5257
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5259
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5259
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5260
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5262
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5263
Outlook........................................................................................................................5264
MaryKay....................................................................................................................5267
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5268
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5269
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5269
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5271
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5272
Outlook........................................................................................................................5273
Merck.........................................................................................................................5275
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5275
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5276
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5277
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5278
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5279
Outlook........................................................................................................................5280
Procter&Gamble.......................................................................................................5283
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5287
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5288
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5289
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5299
Notablenewproducts.................................................................................................5300
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5302
Outlook........................................................................................................................5308

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES(Continued)
Revlon........................................................................................................................5313
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5314
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5315
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5316
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5319
Notablenewproducts.................................................................................................5319
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5320
Outlook........................................................................................................................5321
Sanofi.........................................................................................................................5325
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5325
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5326
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5327
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5328
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5329
Outlook........................................................................................................................5330
Shiseido......................................................................................................................5333
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5334
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5335
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5336
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5338
Newproducts...............................................................................................................5339
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5339
Outlook........................................................................................................................5340
Unilever......................................................................................................................5345
Companyoverview......................................................................................................5347
Corporatesalesandprofits..........................................................................................5348
Cosmeticsandtoiletries...............................................................................................5349
Recentdevelopments..................................................................................................5354
Managementchanges.................................................................................................5355
Newproducts...............................................................................................................5355
Marketingactivity........................................................................................................5358
Outlook........................................................................................................................5362

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

INTRODUCTION

Thissectionpresentssummariesofpertinentmarketingandfinancialdataonthe29leading
companiesofcosmeticsandtoiletries,allwithannualsalesinexcessof$145million.
Thecompaniesarearrangedalphabetically.
If a subsidiary marketscosmetics and toiletries, it is classified under the name of the
parentcompany.

Foreachmajorcompany,thefollowingdataarepresented:
Overview.Abriefdescriptionofthecompanysmajorbusinessinterests.
Corporate sales and profits. The companys recent overall financial history, including
sales, profits, margin or sales, and when available, returns on stockholders equity.
Return on equity is calculated as the percentage of net profit after taxes to
stockholders equity, equal to book value. Related segment data are included when
available.
Cosmetics and toiletries. A breakdown of the companys divisions and brands that
market cosmetics and toiletries and a discussion of the sales of these products. A
competitiveanalysisofselectedproductsmayalsobeprovided,alongwithadetailed
listofthecompanysbrandsofcosmeticsandtoiletries.
Recent developments. A discussion of activities, such as new product introductions,
acquisitions,divestitures,mergers,managementchanges,andlegalactivity.
Marketingactivity.Adescriptionofvariouspromotionalvehiclesusedbythecompany.
Traceablemediaexpendituresareprovidedinaseparatesectionofthisstudy.
Outlook. A forecast of manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries through U.S.
consumer outlets for five years. The forecast, based primarily on an analysis of the
productsnowofferedbythecompany,isdevelopedbyanalyzingthevariousmarkets
inwhichthecompanycompetes,withsomeadjustmentsbasedonKlinesestimateof
itsmarketingstrengths.Futuresalesestimatesaregiveninbothunits andrealdollar
sales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

52

Introduction

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

OVERVIEW

TOTALSALES

In 2012, consumer sales of cosmetics and toiletries in the United States reach
approximately$40.4billion,upby3.4%from$39.0billionin2011.

The 29 largest companies profiled here capture 79.4% of the industry, valued at
$32.1billion.
The companies vary in size, ranging from Helen of Troy at $147million in sales to
Procter&Gamblessalesof$5,824millionin2012.

The top 10 cosmetics and toiletries marketers represent 61.9% of total industry sales in
2012.
Nineoutof10ofthesemarketerscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareestimatedatmore
than$1billioneach.

Table51:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforLeadingCompanies,2012
Company

$Million

Procter&Gamble

5,824

L'Oral

4,551

Unilever

3,546

EsteLauder

2,722

Johnson&Johnson

2,020

LimitedBrands

1,785

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

Coty

1,086

MaryKay

1,063

Avon

948

Revlon

814

GuthyRenker

737

Henkel

635

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

54

Overview

Table51:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforLeadingCompanies,2012
Company

$Million

Shiseido

542

Kao

525

Chanel

461

GlaxoSmithKline

407

EnergizerHoldings

396

Beiersdorf

344

LVMH

337

Church&Dwight

313

ElizabethArden

290

Merck

209

Sanofi

197

Alticor

176

TheCloroxCompany

172

Clarins

171

Combe

157

HelenofTroy

147

Allother

8,304

Total

40,372

GROWTH

Total manufacturers sales of cosmetics and toiletries increase by 3.4%, or $1,346million


from2011.

The29largestmanufacturersexperienceacombinedincreaseinsalesby3.0%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Overview

Table52:U.S.SalesofCosmeticsandToiletrieswithPercentageGrowthfor
LeadingCompanies,2011and2012
$Million
Company

2011

2012

Change,%

GuthyRenker

616

737

19.6

Chanel

417

461

10.6

LVMH

307

337

9.8

TheCloroxCompany

158

172

8.9

Merck

192

209

8.9

Alticor

164

176

7.3

Clarins

160

171

6.9

EsteLauder

2,569

2,722

6.0

L'Oral

4,304

4,551

5.7

LimitedBrands

1,706

1,785

4.6

EnergizerHoldings

379

396

4.5

ColgatePalmolive

1,431

1,493

4.3

504

525

4.2

3,406

3,546

4.1

392

407

3.8

1,048

1,086

3.6

Shiseido

527

542

2.8

Beiersdorf

335

344

2.7

1,979

2,020

2.1

154

157

1.9

1,047

1,063

1.5

Revlon

802

814

1.5

Sanofi

194

197

1.5

Henkel

626

635

1.4

5,898

5,824

(1.3)

321

313

(2.5)

1,014

948

(6.5)

ElizabethArden

313

290

(7.3)

HelenofTroy

160

147

(8.1)

7,903

8,304

5.1

39,026

40,372

3.4

Kao
Unilever
GlaxoSmithKline
Coty

Johnson&Johnson
Combe
MaryKay

Procter&Gamble
Church&Dwight
Avon

Allother
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

55

56

Overview

Outofthetop29companiesprofiledinthisreport,fivemarketersregisterasalesdecline,
andtheremaining24companiesregisterasalesgainin2012.
GuthyRenker, a leading direct response television marketing company, registers the
highestgrowthat19.6%in2012,withsalesat$737millionin2012from$616millionin
2011.
Chanel,aprestigecompany,registersthesecondhighestgrowthat10.6%,withsales
at$461millionin2012upfrom$417millionin2011.
LVMH shows the thirdhighest growth at 9.8% in 2012 to reach $337 million in 2012
from$307millionin2011.
TheCloroxCompanyandMerckaretiedinthefourthpositionwithagrowthof8.9%in
2011.
Amongthemajor29companies,16companiesregistersalesgrowthgreaterthanthe
industryaverageof3.4%in2012.
Helen of Troy records the highest decline among the top 29 companies, with sales
declining8.1%from$160millionin2012to$147millionin2012.

Five companies register declining sales in 2012, with Avon, Elizabeth Arden, and Helen of
Troydemonstratingthesharpestdeclines.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

ALTICOR(AMWAY)

Table53:AmwaysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

2012

Artistry

53

54

LauraMercier

24

28

Total

77

82

FACEMAKEUP

LauraMercier

33

37

Artistry

13

13

Total

46

50

18

19

22

23

11

11

10

Total

19

21

TOTAL

164

176

EYEMAKEUP
LauraMercier
Artistry
Total
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Artistry
LauraMercier

COMPANYOVERVIEW

BasedoutofAda,MI,Alticorisadirectsellingmarketerofnutrition,wellness,beauty,and
homecareproducts.Thecompanyoperatesthroughthreekeysubsidiaries:
Amway,oneoftheworldsleadingdirectsellingcompaniesofbeautyandhomecare
products.
Access Business Group, a manufacturer and distributor of products worldwide for
Amwayanditscontractcustomers.
AlticorCorporateEnterprises,aholdingcompanyforthecorporationsnondirect
sellingcompanies.ThecompanyoperatesresortmanagementfirmAmwayHotel,
upscalecosmeticsmakerGurwitchProducts(marketerofprestigebeautybrandsLaura
MercierandRevive),andhealthdiagnosticsdeveloperInterleukinGenetics

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

58

Alticor(Amway)

Founded in 1959, the company entered the beauty business with the introduction of the
Amwaygroup.
Alticor USA owns and controls all its manufacturing and distribution facilities
throughouttheworld,includingmanufacturingfacilitiesintheUnitedStatesandChina.
Thecompanyalsooperatesorganicallycertifiedfarmsforgrowingfoodsupplements.It
hasorganicfarmsintheUnitedStates,Mexico,andBrazil,andhasdistributionfacilities
inNorthAmerica,Europe,Asia,andtheMiddleEast.

Thecompanyhasabout20,000employeesworldwide.Inaddition,ithasanindirectsales
staffofmorethan3millionpeople,whichmainlyincludesitsaffiliatesanddistributors.

Alticorhasapresencein80countries.
The company has a strong presence in Asian countries, including China, South Korea,
India,Indonesia,andThailand,Japan,Australia,andNewZealand.

In 2000, the company stopped marketing products in North America under the Amway
brandnameandcalleditselfQuixtar.
However,in2008,inanattempttorevivetheAmwaybrand,itrebrandedQuixtarto
AmwayGlobal,andthenchangeditsnametoAmwayNorthAmericain2010.

TheAmwaynameisretainedforthecompanysglobaldirectsalesbusiness.
Amway, which accounts for the majority of Alticors revenues, manufactures a wide
rangeofproductsincludinghouseholdcleaningandlaundrysupplies,floorwaxes,and
polishes, personal care products (cosmetics, toiletries, and fragrances), vitamins and
nutritional supplements (manufactured by the Nutrilite Products subsidiary), home
technology products, including security and water treatment systems, commercial
productlines,andmensandwomensapparel.

Amways products are marketed directly to consumers through more than 3million
independentdistributorsinmorethan100countriesandterritories.
More than 6,500 durable and nondurable products are sold through a sales catalog
calledPersonalShoppers,aswellasavarietyofservicesandeducationalproducts.
Morethan450productsbeartheAmwaybrandname.
Amwayoperateseightregionaldistributioncentersnationwide.

The company employs about 20,000 worldwide, with roughly onethird located in the
UnitedStates.
Amwayhas25domesticandmorethan50foreignsubsidiaries,withmostengagedin
themarketingofthecompanysproducts.
MorethantwothirdsofAmwayssalescomefromAsia;Chinaisthecompanyslargest
individualmarket.
Since1995,AmwayhasexpandedoperationsintoChina,SouthAfrica,theDominican
Republic,Romania,Venezuela,Scandinavia,Croatia,Namibia,theUkraine,Singapore,
andRussia.

Amways products, as well as nationally branded products, are also sold online through
AlticorsQuixtarsubsidiary.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

Alticor(Amway)

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Alticor is a privately held company and does not divulge its financial information to the
public.
Amway,beingasubsidiaryofAlticor,doesnotdivulgeitssalesinformation.

The total sales for Alticor are estimated at $11.3billion in 2012, an increase of
approximately3.7%fromabout$10.9billionin2011.

Table54:AlticorsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to
2012
Yeara

$Billion

Change,%

2007

7.1

2008

8.2

15.5

2009

8.4

2.4

2010

9.3

10.7

2011

10.9

17.2

2012

11.3

3.7

aYearendingDecember31.

Table55:AlticorsGlobalCorporateSalesbyProduct
Category,2012
Category

%Oftotal

NutritionandWellness

46.0

BeautyandPersonalCare

26.0

HomeCare

22.0

Durables

6.0

Total

100.0

Beautyandpersonalcareproductsgeneratesalesofabout$2.9billion in2012,drivenby
theArtistrybrand.

This is the seventhconsecutive year of growth for the company, which has posted sales
increases12outofthepast13years.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

59

510

Alticor(Amway)

Amwaygrowsineachofthe10marketsforthefirsttimein20yearsin2012.Thesemarkets
includeChina,India,Korea,Malaysia,Russia,Thailand,Taiwan,theUkraine,andtheUnited
States.

Colombia, Italy, Turkey, Mexico, Hong Kong, Venezuela, and Russia post doubledigit
increasesin2012.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Table56:AmwaysCosmeticsandToiletriesSalesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

113

2008

120

6.2

2009

130

8.3

2010

145

11.5

2011

164

13.1

2012

176

7.3

The companys sales of cosmeticsand toiletries in 2012 are estimated at $176million, up


7.3%from$164millionin2011.
Facialtreatmentsisthelargestproductcategoryforthe company,withtotalsalesof
$82millionin2012.Thesalesinthecategorygrow6.5%from$77millionin2011.
Facial treatment products account for 46.6% of the companys total cosmetics and
toiletriessalesin2012.
Themarketersellstwobrandsinthecategory:ArtistryandLauraMercier.
The companys leading brand in the facial treatments category is Artistry, which
accountsforthemajorityoftheskincarebusinessforthecompany.
Amwaymainlyfocusesonantiagingproductsintheskincaresegment.

The companys makeup product class sales account for 53.4% of the companys total
cosmetics and toiletries sales, totaling $94million in 2012, up from $87million in the
previousyear.
LauraMerciercontinuestobetheleadingmakeupbrandforthecompany,withsales
of$66million,up11.9%from$59millionin2011.
Sales of its other makeup products, offered under the Artistry label, remain flat at
$28millionin2012,flatfrom2011.
There are no other major developments for the marketer in the makeup segment
during2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

Alticor(Amway)

Thecompanycontinuestogainmarketshareinthedirectsellingindustryandhasastrong
yearacrossthemap.
Thecompanyskeyproductlinesimprovethecompanyscompetitiveposition.

The concept of global investment in building brands is helping distributors; in return,


makingitiseasierforthemtosellproductsthatconsumersalreadyseekbyname.
The company continues to invest in its global power brands, Artistry and Nutrilite,
whichhelpsitsdistributorsgloballytogenerategoodreturnsbothforthecompanyand
themselves.

TherearesignificantnewproductlaunchesforArtistryin2012.
ThecompanylaunchesArtistryYouthXtendAntiagingcollectionin2012,promotedto
betterservewomenaroundtheglobewhoarestartingtonoticethefirstsignsofaging
and who want to keep their skin looking younger. Other significant launches include,
ArtistryVolumeMascaraandArtistryMenDermasync.
Amway launches Laura Mercier Matte Powder for Skin, featuring new baked
technologyinsixshadesandLauraMercierAmbreVanillaBodyButterandHandCream.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

InJanuary2012,ArtistryfeaturesAustralianactress,TeresaPalmerasthenewglobalface
foritsskincareandcolorcosmetics.

In March 2012, Amway teams up with the University of Michigan to harness exclusive
patentedtechnologyinitsskincareproductsthatcounterscommonsideeffectsofretinol
forimprovedresults.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

With more than 3million distributors globally, Amway promotes its products primarily
throughdistributorsandaffliates.
Thecompanycirculatesamonthlymagazine,theAmagram,throughwhichitprovides
salesliterature,inadditiontotheaudioandvideomaterialsthatitprovidestoitssales
associates.
The marketer also promotes its products though broadcast advertising including
magazines, television, and radio, apart from the product promotions done by
distributors.
TotalTMEsforthecompanyin2012are$12.1million;almost99.1%ofthisisspentto
backthemultiplecategorypromotionsthroughlocalmagazines.
The company also promotes and sells its products through its website that contains
linkstoallofitsdirectresponsebrandsalongwithproductdescriptions.Thesitealso
containstoolstohelpconsumerspurchaseproducts.
The company continues to gain attention by sponsoring charitable and philanthropic
projects. The marketer funds and organizes charity programs in health, education,
environment,arts,andculturalpractices.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

511

512

Alticor(Amway)

Themarketerincreasesitssocialmediapresencetopromoteitsproducts.
Thecompanyincreasesitsfocusonsocialmediamarketingwhichhelpsittoreachout
to a younger generation of independent business owners that sell and distribute the
companysproducts.
New product information and promotional offers are presented by the company
throughitsrespectiveFacebookpage.
Amwaypromotesitsproductsthroughsocialmediasites,suchasPinterest,Facebook,
andTwitter.

Amwayspendsabout78.5%or$9.5millionofTMEinpromotingitsbrandLauraMercierin
2012.
Thebrandisprimarilypromotedthroughlocalmagazines.

OUTLOOK

Amwayscosmeticsandtoiletriesbusinessisforecasttogrowatacompoundannualgrowth
rate(CAGR)of3.5%overthenextfiveyears,2012to2017.
Thecompanyplanstolaunchnewandinnovativeproductsacrosscategoriesthatwill
supportitsgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoincreaseitssalesrepresentativestosupportitssalesin
thefuture.
However, most multilevel marketing companies are not expected to enjoy as high
growth in the forecast period as in the past five years, due to the success of more
moderatelypricedproductsalsosoldthroughdirectchannelssuchastheInternetand
homeshoppingtelevisionchannels.

The facial treatments category is expected to be the largest revenue generator for the
marketerovertheforecastperiod.
The company will launch innovative products in order to support the growth of the
category.
The growing demand for antiaging products is expected to drive the sales of the
category for the marketer over the next five years. Furthermore, Amway is likely to
expand its Artistry brand with new antiaging products to support its growth in the
facialtreatmentscategory.

ThefacemakeupcategoryislikelytopostthehighestgrowthforAmwayovertheforecast
period.
Themarketerplanstolaunchnewproductsunderthecategorytosupportitssales.
Amwayisexpectedtointroducefacemakeupproductswithmultipleskincarebenefits,
alongwithnewtechnologyinproductformstosupportitssales.
Themarketerislikelytoprovidenewvariationstothetraditionalpressedpowderblush
informs,suchaswhippedcream,sticks,andliquidtintsinordertopromoteitssales
overtheforecastperiod.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

Alticor(Amway)

TheflagshipbrandofAmway,Artistrywillcontinuetodrivethesalesofthecompanyover
theforecastperiod.
Thecompanyplanstolaunchnewandinnovativeantiagingproductsunderthisbrand
inthenextfiveyears.
Thecompanyinexpectedtoincreaseitsmediaspendingontheseproductstosupport
sales.

The company sells all its products through direct sales and will continue to do so in the
future,asitisanintegralpartofitssalesmodel.

Alticorwillcontinuetoincreaseitspromotionalandmarketingactivitiesinordertosupport
itsgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.
Themarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitssocialmediapresencetokeepitsconsumers
engagedbyconductingvariouscontestsandcampaigns.

Alticors cosmetics and toiletries sales are projected to increase to $209million by 2017
from$176millionin2012,increasingataCAGRof3.5%.

Table57:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforAmwaybyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facemakeup

4.5

Lipsticksandlipglosses

4.0

COMPANYAVERAGE

3.5

Eyemakeup

3.0

Facialtreatments

2.5

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

513

514

Alticor(Amway)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

AVON

Table58:AvonsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

2012

Avon

217

202

Mark

Total

222

206

OutspokenIntensebyFergie

14

15

OutspokenbyFergie

12

13

Imari

11

11

EternalMagic

10

10

Today

10

10

FarAway

ImariSeduction

RareGold

RareDiamonds

Haiku

Mark

Tomorrow

StepIntoSexy

14

Always

HerveLegerFemme

Candid

UbyUngaroFeverforHer

BondGirl007

InBloom

UbyUngaroforHer

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

ExpressionsbyReeseWitherspoon

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

516

Avon

Table58:AvonsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

ChristianLacroix

ChristianLacroixAbsynthe

11

12

156

146

Avon

97

91

Mark

13

12

Total

110

103

Avon

95

88

Mark

13

12

Total

108

100

Avon

85

85

Mark

10

Total

95

94

75

70

Footworks

Mark

Total

89

82

87

78

90

81

MesmerizeforMen

BlackSuede

DerekJeterDrivenBlack

Ironman

Allother
Total
FACEMAKEUP

EYEMAKEUP

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Avon

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Avonbathadditives
Avonbarsoaps
Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

2012

Avon

Table58:AvonsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORMEN(Continued)

WildCountry

DerekJeterDriven

PatrickDempseyUnscripted

PatrickDempsey2

ChristianLacroixNoir

Turn4XT

DerekJeterDrivenFresh

DerekJeterDrivenSport

DerekJeterDrivenWarm

HerveLegerHomme

Allother

58

56

29

28

Avon

20

18

Mark

Total

22

20

17

15

11

11

Avon

TOTAL

1,014

948

Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Avon
NAILPOLISHES

SHAMPOOS
Avon
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS
Avon
LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
Avon
CONDITIONERS

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

517

518

Avon

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Avon was established in 1886 and employs the direct sales model, mostly by using
independentsalesrepresentatives.
It is a global manufacturer and marketer of cosmetics and toiletries, apparel and
jewelry,andhousewares.
ThecompanyislistedontheNewYorkStockExchangeandisheadquarteredinNew
York.
AsofDecember2012,Avonemploysapproximately39,100employeesworldwide.Of
these, approximately 4,800 are employed in the United States and 34,300 in other
countries.
Avoncurrentlyoperatesitssalesactivitiesin65countriesandterritories,includingthe
UnitedStates,anddistributesitsproductsin43morecountries.
Avonhasmorethan6millionactiveindependentrepresentativesworldwide.
In2012,85%ofthecompanysrevenueisfromoutsidetheUnitedStates.
Avonhasapresenceinsevenglobalregions:LatinAmerica,NorthAmerica,Centraland
EasternEurope,WesternEurope,theMiddleEastandAfrica,AsiaPacific,andChina.

Avonsbusinessisdividedintothreesegments:
Beauty,comprisingfragrances,colorcosmetics,skincare,andpersonalcareproducts
Fashion,includingfashionjewelry,apparel,footwear,watches,andaccessories
Home, comprising housewares, gifts and decorative products, entertainment and
leisureproducts,andchildrensandnutritionalproducts

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

CorporatesalesforAvondecline5.1%from$11,291.6millionin2011to$10,717.1millionin
2012.
Avonsnetprofitstotal$526millionin2011andthecompanypostslossof$38million
in2012.
Saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of1.9%since2007.

Table59:AvonsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million
Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

2007

9,759

533

5.3

140.6

2008

10,508

883

8.2

80.7

2009

10,205

619

6.0

211.9

2010

10,863

595

5.4

35.5

2011

11,292

526

4.6

33.1

2012

10,717

(38)

(0.4)

(3.1)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

Returnonequity

Avon

In the secondquarter of 2012, Avon manages Central and Eastern Europe and Western
Europe, the Middle East, and Africa as a single operating segment. This segment is now
called Europe, the Middle East, and Africa. The company also includes the Dominican
RepublicinLatinAmerica,whilepreviouslyitwasincludedinNorthAmerica.

Intermsofsales,LatinAmericacontinuestobethelargestcontributor,comprising46.6%of
thecompanyscorporatesalesin2012.
Avons2012salesinLatinAmericadeclineby3.3%to$4,994million.

Europe,theMiddleEast,andAfricarepresent27.2%ofthecompanystotalsalesin2012.
Theregionssalesdeclineby6.7%to$2,914millionin2012from$3,123millionin2011.

SalesforthecompanyinNorthAmericadecreaseby7.7%to$1,907millionin2012.
Theregioncontributesto17.8%ofAvonssalesin2012.

AsiaPacificrepresents$902millionor8.4%ofthetotalsalesin2012.

Table510:AvonsSalesbyGeographicalRegion,2011and2012

$Million

Region

2011

2012

LatinAmerica

5,162

4,994

Europe,theMiddleEast,andAfrica

3,123

NorthAmerica
AsiaPacific
Total

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

45.7

46.6

(3.3)

2,914

27.7

27.2

(6.7)

2,065

1,907

18.3

17.8

(7.7)

942

902

8.3

8.4

(4.2)

11,292

10,717

100.0

100.0

(5.1)

BeautycontinuestobeAvonslargestbusinessunit,accountingfor71.3%ofthecompanys
globalsalesin2012,althoughitwitnessesadeclineof5.3%from2011.

Table511:AvonsSalesbyGlobalBusinessUnit,2011and2012
$Million

Productcategory

2011

2012

Beauty

8,068

7,643

Fashion

1,995

Home
Allothera

%Oftotal

2011

2012

71.4

71.3

(5.3)

1,892

17.7

17.7

(5.2)

1,049

1,012

9.3

9.4

(3.5)

180

171

1.6

1.6

(5.0)

100.0

(5.1)

Total
11,292
10,717

100.0

aIncludesshippingandhandlingfeesbilledtosalesrepresentatives.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Change,%

519

520

Avon

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

SalesofAvonscosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsintheUnitedStatesdeclineby6.5%,from
$1,014millionin2011to$948millionin2012.
Since2007,salesdeclineataCAGRof3.5%from$1,134millionin2007to$948million
in2012.
AvonscosmeticsandtoiletriesproductsintheUnitedStatescontinuetodeclineina
rowforfiveyearsasthemarketerfacesproblemssuchasdefectionandlowmoraleof
salesassociates.

Table512:AvonsCosmeticsandToiletriesSales,2007to
2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,134

2008

1,114

(1.8)

2009

1,098

(1.4)

2010

1,077

(1.9)

2011

1,014

(5.8)

2012

948

(6.5)

Facial treatments continues to be Avons largest product category, with $206million in


manufacturerssalesin2012,downby7.2%from$222millionin2011.
Avoncontinuestobethethirdlargestdirectsellingbrandinthecategory.
Thecompanystruggleswithitswellpublicizedproblemsatattractingandmaintaining
salesassociatesintheUnitedStates,andthecompanydevotesmuchofitsenergiesto
expandinginotherregionsoftheworld.
Its major facial treatment launch of the year is an addition to the Anew Clinical line
calledProLineEraser,whichthecompanycomparestoinjectablecollagenandretinols
toreducethelookofdeepwrinklesinoneweek.
TheGenicslineisextendedinMarch2012withaneyecream.

ThesecondlargestcategoryforAvonisfragrancesforwomenin2012.
Thecategoryssalesdropby6.4%,from$156millionin2011to$146millionin2012.
Avon slips to seventh place among manufacturers sales in the category, with a 5.4%
share,downfrom6.0%sharein2011.
Avoncontinuestoalignwithcelebritiesanddesignerstointroduceitsnewfragrances.
TheonlysignificantlaunchbyAvoninthecategoryin2012isUnpluggedforHerunder
theJonBonJovibrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

Avon

FacemakeupcategorysalesofAvonareestimatedat$103millionin2012,down6.4%from
$110millionin2011.
Avonrepresents19.1%oftotaldirecttradeclassfacemakeupsalesin2012,downfrom
20.0%ofsalesin2011.
Increase in competitors promotional and advertising expenses, ready availability of
massproducts,andnewproductintroductionsbymostmarketersmakeitchallenging
fortraditionaldirectmarketerssuchasAvontogrowin2012.

Avonseyemakeupcategorysalesdecrease7.4%from$108millionin2011to$100million
in2012.
The company holds the sixth position in the eye makeup category in 2012, with a
categoryshareof3.7%,downfrom4.1%ofcategorysalesin2011.
Lack of new product activity and limited advertising support contributes to the
marketersdeclineinthecategoryin2012.

Thesalesforthecompanyslipsticksandlipglossescategorydecline1.1%from$95million
in2011to$94millionin2012.
Thecompanymarketstwobrandsunderthecategory:AvonandMark.
Sales of the Avon brand drop by $1million; however, sales of Avon as a company
remainflatinthecategory.

Avons hand and body lotions have a relatively small presence in the cosmetics and
toiletriesindustry.
Categorysalesofthemarketerdropfrom$89millionin2011to$82millionin2012.
Lackofnewproductactivityaffectsthemarketersdeclineinthecategory.
Avon,Mark,andFootworksarethebrandsmarketedinthiscategory.

Thecompanyspersonalcleansingproductscategoryssalestotal$81millionin2012;sales
declineby10.0%from$90millionin2011.
ThecategoryincludesAvonbrandbathadditivesandbarsoaps.
Salesofbathadditivesdeclineby10.3%;however,salesofbarsoapsremainflatinthe
category.

Thefragrancesformencategorydeclinesinsalesfrom$58millionin2011to$56millionin
2012.
Avon slips to the fifth spot in the category with market share of 5.1% in 2012, down
from5.5%in2011.
Limitednewproductactivitycontributestothemarketersdeclineinthecategory.
TheonlysignificantlaunchbyAvoninthecategoryin2012isUnpluggedforMenunder
theJonBonJovibrand.
Avonpromotesitsfragrancesinitsmonthlycatalogsandonitswebsite.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

521

522

Avon

Avons sun care products category sales decline by 3.4% from $29million in 2011 to
$28millionin2012.
ThecompanymarketsonlytheAvonbrandunderthiscategory.

The companys nail polishes category sales decline by 9.1%, from $22million in 2012 to
$20millionin2011.
Avonisthefifthlargestnailpolishmarketerwithacategoryshareof3.0%,downfrom
3.9%in2011.
Avondoesnotfarewellinthenailpolishescategorybecausethecompanyisstruggling
for market share in the United States and the brand faces stiff competition from the
massmarket.
Avon still accounts for the majority of the nail polish sales within the direct channel,
holdinga62.1%sharein2012.

AvonshaircareproductsareallmarketedundertheAvonbrand.
Theshampooscategoryssalesaredown11.8%,from$17millionin2011to$15million
in2012.
Theconditionercategoryssalesareflatat$2millionin2012,flatwith2011levels.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Otherdevelopments

In2012,Avoncontinuestofacemanychallenges.
InquiriesaremadeintoallegationsofbriberybythecompanysemployeesinChinaand
othercountries.
InMarch2012,Cotymakesanunsolicited$10billionoffertoacquireAvon,asitplans
toutilizeAvonsstrongsalesforceinemergingmarkets.
InApril2012,AvonrejectsCotys$10billionofferforatakeover.
The$23.25persharebidwasputata20%premiumtoAvonsrecentstockprice.Avon
responded that the valuation was too low, and that Cotys nonbinding bid did not
presentarealoffer.
InOctober2012,AvoncatchestheFoodandDrugAdministrations(FDAs)attentionfor
havinginfringedguidelinesregardingfivedifferentproductsofitsAnewrange.
FDA claims that its products Anew Clinical Advanced Wrinkle Corrector, Anew
Reversalist Night Renewal Cream, Anew Reversalist Renewal Serum, Anew Clinical
Thermafirm Face Lifting Cream, and Solutions Liquid Bra Toning Gel have uses that
apparentlycausethemtobeclassifiedasdrugs.Asaresult,FDAasksAvontorectify
theviolations,whileAvonpledgesitscommitmenttoabidebythelawsandregulations.
Avon outlines initial steps to costcutting, two of which include global headcount
reductionofapproximately1,500positions,anditsexitfromSouthKoreaandVietnam.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

Avon

InJanuary2013,AvonannouncestheclosureofitsdistributionfacilitiesinAtlanta,GA
andPasadena,CAasameasuretocutcosts.
In February 2013, Avon declares its fourthquarter losses deepen as a result of
restructuringinitiatives.
In March 2013, Avon completes its refinancingactivities, by closing public offering of
$1.5billioninnotes.
In2013,Avoninvestsinnewshrinksleevepackagingsystemsforitslipsticks,eyeliners,
andmascaras,whichresultsincostsavingsforthecompany.

Managementchanges

TherearecertaintoplevelmanagementchangesrecentlyatAvon.
InApril2012,AvonnamesSherilynMcCoyasthenewCEO;shewaspreviouslyworking
asaViceChairmanwithJohnson&Johnson.
In April 2012, the company announces that Douglas Conant is elected to its board of
directors, with immediate effect. Conant, retired last year as President and CEO of
CampbellSoupCo.andistheCEOofDRCLLC.
KimberlyRossjoinsasExecutiveVicePresidentandChiefFinancialOfficer,shecomes
fromtheRoyalAholdgroup.
AvonappointsPatriciaPerezAyalaasChiefMarketingOfficer.
In January 2013, Avon appoints David Powell as Senior Vice President of Business
TransformationandGlobalSupplyChain.
In August 2012, Avon appoints Scott Curm as the Senior Vice President of Human
Resources and Jeff Benjamin as the the Senior Vice President of General Council in
2012.
InApril2013,FredHassanresignsafterfourmonthsofhistenureonBoardofDirectors.

Newproducts

Table513:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyAvonintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Avon

Facialtreatments

AnewClinicalProLineEraserwithpatentedAF33(AminoFill
33)thecompanyclaimsworkslikepotentantiagersAHA,
retinol,andinjectablecollagen,reducingthelookofdeep
wrinklesinoneweek

Avon

Facialtreatments

Genicslineisextendedwithaneyecream

JonBonJovi

Fragrancesformen

UnpluggedforMenisacollaborationbetweenAvonandJon
BonJoviandisawoody,floral,muskyscent

JonBonJovi

Fragrancesforwomen

UnpluggedforHerisacollaborationbetweenAvonandJon
BonJoviandoffersafloralorientalcompositionstartingwith
gourmetnotesofplumandcitrus

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

523

524

Avon

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Avon primarily uses company brochures, websites, and sales associates for product
promotion.
Salesforceincentiveprogramsaremostcommonlyused.
OtherpromotionaleffortsbyAvonmainlyincludesamplingandpricepromotions.
The marketer promotes its brands through its websites and through social media
channelsincludingFacebook,Twitter,Tumblr,Pinterest,andYoutube.
Avon advertises its new product launches and other product promotions on its
Facebookpagetosupportitssales.
Although,themarketerreliesprimarilyonsalesassociatestopromoteitsproducts,itis
alsoincreasinglyutilizingothervehiclesincludingtheprintandtelevisionadvertising.
The marketer has approximately more than 6million active sales representatives
acrosstheglobe,eventhoughthisnumberhasbeendecreasing.

Campaigns, media advertising, print advertisements, discounts, and giftwithpurchase


(GWP)offersaretheotherpromotionaltoolsforAvon.
Avon regularly promotes various products in its catalogs and on its website with
discountedpricestoencouragemultiplepurchases.
While not part of measured mediaexpenditures, Avons brochures are central to the
promotionofthebrand,andserveinlieuofafulladvertisingcampaign.
Infact,someofAvonstraditionaladvertisinginthepasthasbeenmorerecruitment
oriented, as a way to secure new sales associates in contrast to promoting actual
products.

Avonalsoprovidesbeautytipsandguidesonitswebsite.
Thecompanyswebsiteoffersaskincareguidethatincludesrecommendationsbased
onconsumersresponsestoanonlinequiz.
Avonhastoolsonitswebsitethatallowaninterestedpartytofindasalesconsultantin
theirrespectivearea.
Advertisements regarding the companys products can be viewed directly on Avons
website.

Avontypicallypromotesnewfragrancesonitsbrochurecoveratthetimeoftheirlaunch.
Avoncontinuestoprintitsnewcatalogseverytwoweeks,apracticewhichcontinues
tobecriticizedasconfusingtoconsumersandwasteful.
Scentstripsareoftenfeaturedinitscatalogs.
Otherpromotionalvehiclesincludemediaadvertising,discounts,andGWPoffers.
Tohelpenticeconsumers,thesalesassociatesfrequentlyholdproductdemonstration
gatheringswhereparticipantsaregivenafreeproduct,suchasfullsizelipgloss,ora
dollarcredittowardspurchasing.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

Avon

Avonsignsonpopularcelebritiesforitsproductandcollectionlaunches,andfeaturesthese
celebritiesinitscatalogs.
Avons2012brochurefeaturesvariouscelebritiesincludingAleshaDixonandKatyAtlas.
In 2012, the marketer partners with American musician Jon Bon Jovi for its new
Unpluggedlineoffragrances.
AvonalsowidelypublicizesitsannualWalkforBreastCanceranditsprogramstofight
domesticviolence.

Avon spends about $13.0million on traceable media expenditures (TMEs) to support its
brandsin2012,downby11.0%from$14.6millionin2011.
Morethan90%oftheTMEisspentthroughtelevisionandlocalmagazines.
The company promotes its products mainly through television (75.5%), followed by
magazines(14.6%)in2012.
AvonspendsthehighestTMEonpromotingitsfacialtreatmentscategoryin2012.
Thecompanyspendsabout$9.3million,or71.5%ofitsTMEonthefacialtreatments
category, up from nearly $8.1million during 2011. In the facial treatments category,
the company spends about $4.4million on promoting its new launch, Avon Anew
ClinicalProLineEraser,in2012.

OUTLOOK

SalesofAvonarelikelytogrowmarginallyby0.8%overthenextfiveyearsintheUnited
States.
ThecompanywithitsnewCEO,SheriMcCoy,hasnotbeenforthcomingaboutplansto
recuperate.However,somethingshavebeenmadeclear.
The company plans to focus more on field programs to increase its number of
representatives. These initiatives will help strengthen the companys presence in
developingmarketsandalsointhedevelopedmarkets.
The company expects continued challenging financial results within the North
American business, partially as a result of the ongoing impact of field transformation
andredistrictingintheUnitedStates.
Thecompanyhasoutlinedstepstowardsachievingacostsavingtargetof$400million
beforetaxesbytheendof2015.
They also continue to implement an enterprise resource planning (ERP) system on a
worldwide basis, which is expected to improve the efficiency of its supply chain and
financialtransactionprocess.
Thecompanyplanstousevariouspricingandpromotionalmodels,whichareexpected
toprovideadeeperunderstandingofthepricingwithinitsproductporfolios.
Itplanstoincreasethedepthofthemanagementstructure.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

525

526

Avon

Avonislikelytofocusonnewtechnologyandproductinnovationtodeliverfirsttomarket
productsthatprovidevisibleconsumerbenefits.
The company is expected to grow in the facial treatments category supported with
more product launches. The new product introductions are likely to be innovative
products with multifunctional benefits in the forecast period, similar to its Anew
ClinicalProLineEraserproductin2012.
The company strengthens its product presence and offers strong competition to its
competitors by varying the technology it infuses in its products and package design.
Thisalsohelpsthemarketertoincreasethevisibilityoftheitsproducts
Avon is expected to strengthen its position in the facial treatments category with
brandsthatfunctionasahomealternativetodermatologicaltreatments.

Avonplanstofocusonitscorebusinessinordertostabilizesalesovertheforecastperiod.
Asapartoftheplan,themarketerisexpectedtofocusonitsskincare,fragrances,and
makeupproductclassesbylaunchinginnovativeproductsovertheforecastperiodto
supportitssales.

The marketer plans to appoint executives who will effectively manage and develop the
businessforthemarketerovertheforecastperiodasapartofitsrestructuringprogram.
Asapartofthisplan,AvonappointsDavidPowell,whoformerlyworkedforcompanies
such as Johnson & Johnson and Midreef Partners, as the Senior VicePresident of its
businesstransformationandglobalsupplychaindivisions.

Avonwillcontinuetoworkonitscostsavingprograminordertosupportitsgrowthinthe
UnitedStates.
Asapartofthecostsavingprogram,themarketerplanstocut400executivejobsin
2013.
Themarketerislikelytofinishtherestructuringofitsbusinessbyendof2013,which
willhelpthecompanyachievestableresultsovertheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
ThemarketeralsoclosesitsdistributionfacilitiesinNorthAmericaasapartofitscost
savingprogram.
The marketer is expected to pull out its business from some of the underperforming
marketsincludingIrelandandothermarketsinEuropeovertheforecastperiod.

The marketer is expected to launch naturallypositioned products across categories,


especially skin care and makeup, as this segment is projected to perform well over the
forecastperiod.
Avon plans to launch Totally Kissable lipstick that contains natural oils and organic
ingredientsincludingfruitextracts.
The marketer will continue to infuse and reformulate its products with natural
ingredientsinordertosupportitssales.
However,dabblinginthissegmentwillnotstrengthentheAvonbrandbutwillperhaps
muddleit.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

Avon

Avonwillcontinuetotryincreaseitssalesrepresentativesovertheforecastperiodinorder
toboostitsoverallsales.
Avon will likely improve the reward and effort equation for its representatives. The
marketer offers webbased tools for its representatives to help them increase their
sales.
Furthermore, there will be continued efforts to recruit and train representatives. As
with any cosmetics and toiletries marketer, Avon will also depend on new product
launches and reformulation of existing product lines with improved ingredients or
improvedpackagingtosupportitssalesgrowththroughtheforecastperiod.
In the United States, the company also markets its products through consumer
websites.

The marketer will continue to promote its products primarily through its sales
representatives and is expected to adopt other methods of marketing its products, for
example, by initiating specialty boutiques within mass retail stores, or by recruiting
representativesinstoretomarketproducts.
Thecompanyalsoadoptsthepromotionofpackageditemsformarketingitsproducts,
whileprovidingsalesaidstotherepresentativessuchasbrochures,productsamples,
anddemonstrationproducts.

CotyorsomeothercompanyisexpectedtooffertobuyAvonovertheforecastperiod.
IfCotyacquiresAvonduringtheforecastperiod,Avonsstrugglingfragrancebrandsare
likelytobenefitfromthesuccessofCotysfragrancesbrands.
However, Coty would also likely to benefit from Avons successful skin care and
makeuplines.

SalesofAvonareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof0.8%toreach$987millionby2017,up
from$948millionfrom2012.

Table514:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmetics
andToiletriesforAvonbyCategory,2012to2017
Category
Facialtreatments
Eyemakeup
Fragrancesforwomen
Facemakeup
Fragrancesformen
Suncareproducts
COMPANYAVERAGE
Lipsticksandlipglosses
Nailpolishes
Handandbodylotions
Personalcleansingproducts
Shampoos
Conditioners
Deodorantsandantiperspirants
Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

CAGR,%
1.8
1.5
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.5
0.5
0.4
0.4
0.3
0.3
0.2
0.2

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

527

528

Avon

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

BEIERSDORF

Table515:BeiersdorfsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

Nivear

94

94

Eucerin

82

85

Aquaphor

21

22

197

201

LaPrairie

35

37

Eucerin

11

11

Basis

Total

47

49

43

44

45

46

14

16

14

14

15

15

14

14

335

344

Total
FACIALTREATMENTS

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Niveabodywashes
Basisbarsoaps
Total
LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
Nivea
SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN
NiveaforMen
LaPrairie
Total
SHAVINGPRODUCTS
NiveaforMen
FRAGRANCESFORMEN
NiveaforMen
TOTAL

rRestated.

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

530

Beiersdorf

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Beiersdorf AG is a leading international branded goods company in the cosmetics and


toiletries,adhesiveproducts,andmedicalproductsindustries.
Thecompanywasestablishedin1882.
ItsheadquartersislocatedinHamburg,Germany.
Thecompanyemploysapproximately16,605employeesworldwideattheendof2012.

Thecompanysbusinessisdividedintotwobusinesssegments:
Theconsumerbusinesssegmentmanufacturesandmarketsskincareandbeautycare
products.SomeoftheleadingglobalbrandsofferedbythedivisionareNivea,LaPrairie,
andEucerin.Thedivisionalsooffersregionalbrands,suchasLabello,8X4,Hansaplast,
Florena,andSlek.
The Tesa division manufactures and markets selfadhesive systems and product
solutions.Tesahasoperationsinmorethan100countries.

In 2012, the company invests a total of 159million ($204million) in research and


development,down2.5%from163million($210million)in2011.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

CorporatesalesforBeiersdorfreach6,040million($7,762million)in2012,up7.2%from
5,633million($7,239million)in2011.
Saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of1.9%since2007.
The companys net profits grow 74.1% from 259million ($333million) in 2011 to
451million($580million)in2012.

Table516:BeiersdorfsCorporateWorldwideSales,2007to2012

Million

Year

Netsales

Profitsaftertax

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

2007

5,507

442

8.0

21.4

2008

5,971

567

9.5

23.0

2009

5,748

380

6.6

14.4

2010

5,571

326

5.3

11.2

2011

5,633

259

4.5

8.6

2012
6,040

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

451

7.5

13.7

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A30

Beiersdorf

Beiersdorfs consumer business segments sales in 2012 increase 7.5% to 5,048million


($6,488million),upfrom4,696million($6,035million)in2011.
Organicgrowthforthesegmentis4.9%in2012.
Thecontributionoftheconsumersegmenttothetotalcompanyssalesincreasesfrom
83.3%in2011to83.6%in2012.

Table517:BeiersdorfsCorporateWorldwideSalesbyBusinessSegment,
2011and2012

Million

%Oftotal

Businesssegment

2011

2012

2011

2012

Consumer

4,696

5,048

83.3

83.6

937

992

16.7

16.4

5,633

6,040

100.0

100.0

TESA
Total

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

EuropecontinuestobethelargestmarketforBeiersdorfin2012,generatingover56%ofits
revenues,downfromitsshareof59.5%in2011.

Table518:BeiersdorfsCorporateWorldwideSalesbyRegion,2011and2012

Million

%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

2011

2012

Europe

2,792

2,831

59.5

56.1

Africa/Asia/Australia

1,029

1,205

22.0

23.9

875

1,012

18.5

20.0

4,696

5,048

100.0

100.0

Americas
Total

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

BeiersdorfisamongtheleadingmarketersofskincareproductsintheUnitedStates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

531

532

Beiersdorf

Table519:CosmeticsandToiletriesBrandsofBeiersdorfintheUnitedStates,2012
Brand

Product

AQUAPHOR

Handandbodylotions

BASIS

Barsoaps,facialtreatments

EUCERIN

Handandbodylotions,facialtreatments

LAPRAIRIE
CellularPlatinum

Facialtreatments

SkinCaviar

Facialtreatments,handandbodylotions

WhiteCaviarIlluminatingSystme

Facialtreatments

CellularRadiance

Facialtreatments,handandbodylotions

Antiaging

Facialtreatments,handandbodylotions

AdvancedMarineTechnology

Facialtreatments

CellularTreatmentColor

Makeup

SilverRain

Womensfragranceandtoiletries

NIVEA
Nivea

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

NiveaBathCare

Personalcleansingproducts

NiveaBody

Handandbodylotions

NiveaforMen

Skincareproductsformen,fragrancesformen,shaving
products

NiveaSoft

Handandbodylotions

The companys sales in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market grow 2.7% from
$335millionin2011to$344millionin2012.
Since2007,saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.7%.

Table520:HistoricalSalesofBeiersdorfintheU.S.
CosmeticsandToiletriesMarket,2007to2012

Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

287

2008

297

3.5

2009

312

5.1

2010

322

3.2

2011

335

4.0

2012

344

2.7

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A32

Beiersdorf

SkincareisthelargestproductclassforBeiersdorf.
Skincareproductsaccountfor77.0%ofthecompanyssalesintheU.S.cosmeticsand
toiletriesmarketin2012.
SalesforBeiersdorfinthisproductclassincreaseby2.3%toreach$265millionin2012
from$259millionin2011.
Beiersdorfaccountsfor2.5%ofthetotalsalesinthisproductclassin2012.
Beiersdorfs Consumer Business Segment applies for patents for 87 inventions in the
fiscal year 2012. The company launches various new products that include hand and
bodylotions,facialtreatments,andshavingproductsin2012.

The hand and body lotions category is the largest contributor to the companys sales in
2012.
Handandbodylotionsshareinthecompanyssalesdecreasesfrom58.8%in2011to
58.4%in2012.
Beiersdorfssalesinthecategoryincreasefrom$197millionin2011to$201millionin
2012,registeringagrowthof2.0%.
The company markets its Nivea, Eucerin, and Aquaphor brands under this product
category.
Beiersdorf becomes the fourthlargest marketer in the category, displacing Unilever,
contributingto8.8%ofthetotalcategoryssalesintheU.S.marketin2012.
Niveaistheleadingbrandforthemarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategory,with
salesat$94millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Niveas product offerings include lotions, hand creams, and gels/serums with a wide
selectionofproductsforthelotionssegment.
EucerinisthenextbiggestbrandforBeiersdorfinthecategory,postinga3.7%growth
toreach$85millionin2012from$82millionin2011.
In 2012, Eucerin undergoes packaging changes for its hand and body lotions by
streamlining the design for each product. A texture scale design is added to the
packagingthatshowsiftheproductisrich,lightweight,orfallsbetweenthetwo.
Additionally,theproductnamesarechangedtomakeiteasierforconsumerstoclearly
identifywhattheproducthastooffer.Thisproductnamechangeismadefor11SKUs
inthehandandbodylotionscategory.
SalesofAquaphorincreaseto$22millionin2012,up4.8%from$21millionin2011.

The companys secondlargest category, facial treatments, accounts for 14.2% of the
companysoverallsalesin2012;thesharegrowsfrom14.0%in2011.
Sales of the category grow 4.3% in 2012, from $47million in 2011 to $49million in
2012.
Beiersdorfoffersaluxurybrand,LaPrairie,inthefacialtreatmentscategory.

Salesofskincareproductsformenare$15millionin2012,constantfrom2011levels.
Thecompanyisthethirdlargestplayerinthecategory,with8.9%marketsharein2012,
downfrom9.7%in2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

533

534

Beiersdorf

Othertoiletriesisthesecondlargestproductclassandcontributes17.4%tothecompanys
totalsalesintheU.S.marketin2012.
Salesinthisproductclasspostanincreaseof1.7%in2012,from$59millionin2011to
$60millionin2012.
The company participates in the shaving products and personal cleansing products
categories,ofwhichpersonalcleansingproductsistheonlycategorytoshowgrowth.

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentsisthefifthlargestcategoryforthecompanyin2012.
Sales of lip balms, jellies, and treatments grow 14.3% from $14million in 2011 to
$16millionin2012.
Niveasshareinthecategoryincreasesfrom3.9%in2011to4.3%in2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Otherdevelopments

In February 2012, Beiersdorf launches Eucerin Skin Institute, an integrated concept that
consists of scientific skin diagnosis as well as personal consultation and individual skin
treatment.

InDecember2012,Beiersdorfacquirestheremaining50%sharesandvotingrightsinEBC
EczacbaBeiersdorf Kozmetik rnler Sanayi ve Ticaret A.S (Turkey) for 29million
($37million).Atthetimeofacquisition,Beiersdorfpaysafixedcomponentof 25million
($32million)incashandacontingentpurchasepricepayableattheoffsetoffiscal2014if
certainperformanceindicatorsaremetin2013.

Managementchanges

DuringApril2012,StefanF.HeidenreichtakesoverfromThomasB.QuaasasthenewCEO
of the company. Stefan F. Heidenreich has held leading positions in the international
consumerandbrandedgoodsindustryforalmost25years.
InMarch2012,BeiersdorfannouncestheappointmentofJoeOliveriasVicePresident,
SalesandMikeVoadenjoinsBeiersdorfasSeniorDirectorofNationalAccounts.
In October 2012, Sven Jacobsen assumes the role of Vice President Corporate
Communications at Beiersdorf. He had previously served as the head of corporate
communications at the MediaSaturn group, an European electrical and electronics
goodsretailer.
In March 2013, Peter Feld, the board member responsible for the European/North
American region, leaves the company. CEO Stefan Heidenreich assumes Felds duties
untilfurthernotice.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A34

Beiersdorf

Newproducts

Table521:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyBeiersdorfintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Eucerin

Handandbodylotions

ProfessionalRepairExtremelyDrySkinLotionisinfusedwithceramide
3andglucoglycerol,retainsmoisture,andpreventsfurtherdryness

LaPrairie

Facialtreatments

SkinCaviarLiquidLiftissaidtoliftandfirmtheskinstructure,protect
andrestoreepidermalstemcellfunction,preventtheappearanceand
deepeningoflinesandwrinkles

LaPrairie

Facialtreatments

CellularPowerComplex,whichincludesingredientssuchasSwisssnow
algaeandtissueguidancematrix,issaidtofueldefenseandstimulate
theskinsnaturalprocessesforrepair.Productincludesginsengroot
extract,horsetailextract,andglycoproteins,issaidtohelpstimulate
theskinsrenewalprocesswhilemoisturizingandenergizingskin.The
formulaalsoincludespanthenolandsodiumhyaluronatefor
moisturizingproperties

Nivea

Lipbalms,jellies,and
treatments

BeiersdorfintroducesNiveaLipbutterbalmsinjarformatsthatis
availableinfourdifferentflavors:RaspberryRoseKiss,CaramelCream
Kiss,VanillaandMacadamiaKiss,andSmoothKiss

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The companys spending on mediabased advertising and promotions are $26.0million in


2012.
Traceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs)decrease45.1%,from$47.4millionin2011.
Thecompanyutilizesawiderangeofmediatoolstopromoteitsproducts.
The largest part of the media spend are for television spots and magazines, which
togetheraccountfor88.1%ofthetotalTMEofthecompany.
The company spends about 65% of its TME through magazines and almost 23% on
televisionadvertisements.
The company spends 51.5% of its media budget on the promotion of its skin care
brands,NiveaandEucerinin2012.

Inspiteofadeclineinitsadvertisingexpendituresin2012,Beiersdorfcontinuestobethe
thirdleadingadvertiserinthehandandbodylotionscategory.
The company allocates a TME of $33.4million in 2012, up 5.0% from $31.9million in
2011.
In 2012, Beiersdorf spends $17.5million on its Nivea brand, with $12.4million being
allocatedtothetelevisionmedia.
Beiersdorf allocates approximately $16million for its Eucerin brand in 2012, with an
equaldivisionbetweentheprintandtelevisionmedia.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

535

536

Beiersdorf

In May 2012, Aquaphor, a product owned by the Eucerin division of Beiersdorf AG,
announcesthetitlesponsorshipoftheAquaphorNewYorkCityTriathlon.

Coupons of several denominations are offered by Beiersdorf in an attempt to entice


consumerstopurchaseitsproducts.
Coupons,whichareusuallyprintedordigital,makesproductsavailabletoconsumers
atapricelowerthantheregularmarketprice. Thisinducesconsumers tosplurge on
products.
In2012,Eucerinofferscouponsworth$1.50onitshandandbodyproductsandNivea
offerscouponsworth$2.00onNiveahandandbodylotionproducts.Socialmediasites
andSundayfreestandinginserts(FSIs)arethemostfavoredmeanstoadvertisesuch
offers.

Beiersdorf introduces a new logo and design for its Nivea brand in order to significantly
enhancethebrandsrecognition.
The marketer introduces the new logo in May 2012; all Nivea products across the
categorieshavethenewlogoonthem.

While pointofsale displays and advertising are important, store traffic decreases. The
companyincreasesitspresenceonlineinordertocreategreatervisibilityofitsbrandsand
tosupportitsonlinesales.

BeiersdorfextensivelyusessocialmediachannelssuchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube
topromoteitsbrandsandproducts.
Thesechannelsprovideconsumersaplatformtodiscussandsharetheirexperiences,
reviewsproducts,andasktheirqueriestobrandexperts.
These social networking pages/accounts inform consumers about new product
introductions, events, special offers, discounts, coupons, sweepstakes, and other
companyinitiatives.

In2012,NiveapartnerswithGrammyAwardwinningrecordingartistNeYo,televisiontalk
showhostWendyWilliams,andNiveabrandambassadorsBillandGiulianaRancictoextend
itsyearlongNiveamillionmomentsoftouchmovementandcelebrateNationalPDA(Public
DisplaysofAffection)Day.
Aspartofthecelebration,NiveahostsaseriesofeventsinNewYork,LosAngeles,and
nineothercitiesacrossthecountrytoencouragecouplestogetoutintheopenand
showtheiraffectionforoneanother.

In2012,NivealaunchesKissofStyleDesignContestexclusivelyonFacebook.
CharlotteRonson,aleadingfashiondesigner,joinsasthecelebrityjudge.
Through this contest, people will be able to personalize their favorite Nivea lip care
productstomakememorablekissmomentsthatmuchmorespecial.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A36

Beiersdorf

OUTLOOK

Beiersdorfisforecasttopostgrowthof1.8%overtheforecastperiod.

Beiersdorfisexpectedtofocusonproductinnovationoverthenextfiveyears.
Innovation could be in the form of new product activity, packaging changes, and
improvedformulationsincludingtechnologicaladvancements.
Beiersdorfplanstolaunchmenspecificproductsovertheforecastperiodtosupportits
salesgrowth,asproductsformenareexpectedtoperformwell.
Themarketerislikelytofocusonitsskincareproductclassovertheforecastperiod,as
itwillbethehighestrevenuegeneratorforBeiersdorf.

Themarketerisexpectedtomaintainitsforecastgrowthbyintroducinginnovativeproducts
overtheforecastperiod.
Furthermore,Beiersdorfwillcontinuetofocus onitscorecompetencyinskincarein
theU.S.marketthroughbrandssuchasNiveaforMen,Eucerin,andAquaphor,aswell
asitsmainstaybrandNivea.
Beiersdorf will continue to focus on its Nivea brand and the company is expected to
increaseitspromotionalsupportforthebrandoverthenextfiveyears.

Theskincareproductclass,whichisthelargestproductclassforBeiersdorf,willcontinueto
bethemainfocusforthemarketer.
The facial treatments category for Beiersdorf is expected to perform well with the
launchofantiagingproducts.
Consumers are expected to spend more on skin care as they regain their purchasing
capacity.
Other factors that are expected to support the marketers growth in the skin care
product class include innovative packaging formulations, products with improved
technologies,andincreasingpromotionalactivities.

Nevertheless, hand and body lotions will remain the most important category as a
proportionoftotalsalesforthecompanyduringtheforecastperiod.
Nivea,theflagshipbrandofthecompany,willcontinuetodrivesalesforthecompany,
asthebrandoffersalargenumberofvariantsunderitsumbrellainthecategory.
Beiersdorfplanstolaunchinnovativeproductswithimprovedformulationstosupport
thecategorysgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

537

538

Beiersdorf

Beiersdorf is expected to adopt innovative marketing techniques in order to promote its


products.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoprovidesamples,coupons,giveaways,andcontestsasa
partofitsmarketingstrategy.
Over the next few years, Beiersdorf is expected to continue to invest aggressively in
marketing to establish itself as a leader in skin care, especially with its Nivea and
Eucerinbrands.
The marketer plans to make a packaging change for its Nivea products across
categoriesin2013tostrengthenthebrandspresence.
AlltheproductswithnewpackagingwillalsohavethenewNivealogoonthem.
Thecompanyisexpectedtocontinuetospendheavilyonprintandelectronicmediato
promoteandadvertiseitsproducts.
Inspired by the success of its recent social network marketing, the company will
continuetopromoteitselfthroughthischanneltoreachyoungertargets.
In 2012, the marketer launches Kiss of Style Design Contest exclusively on its
Facebookpagetopromoteitsproductsandthemarketerisexpectedtocontinuewith
suchactivitiestoengageconsumerswiththecompanysproducts.

Themarketerplanstoenhanceitsresearchanddevelopmentactivitiesacrosscategoriesto
strengthenitssalesovertheforecastperiod.
In the coming years, the marketer is expected to focus on its research and
developmentactivitiesacrossitssixcorecategories(asdefinedbythecompany):body
washes, sun care products, mens skin care products, skin care products, fragrances,
andshowerproducts.

Thecompanywillcontinuetofocusonenhancingitspresenceintheemergingmarketsover
theforecastperiod.
ThemarketerconstructsanewproductioncenterinSilao,Mexicotomeettherapidly
growingdemandforskincareproductsintheregion.
Beiersdorf will continue to focus on exploring new geographies to support its overall
sales over the next five years. Such endeavors will remove its focus from the U.S.
market.

Themarketerisexpectedtolaunchnaturallypositionedproductstostrengthenitsposition
inthenaturalsegmentovertheforecastperiod.
In 2012, the marketer launches La Prairie Cellular Power Complex in the facial
treatments category. The product contains natural ingredients including ginseng root
extractandhorsetailextract.
The marketer will continue to focus on incorporating more natural ingredients in its
productsacrosscategoriesincludingpersonalcleansingproductsandskincareproduct
categories.

SalesforBeiersdorfscosmeticsandtoiletriesareprojectedtoreach$376millionby2017,
upataCAGRof1.8%from$344millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A38

Beiersdorf

Table522:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforBeiersdorfbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

2.8

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

2.5

Personalcleansingproducts

2.2

Shavingproducts

2.0

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.8

Handandbodylotions

1.5

Fragrancesformen

0.8

Skincareproductsformen

0.1

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

539

540

Beiersdorf

REPRODUCTIONOR DISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A40

CHANEL

Table523:ChanelsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

Category/brand
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN
CocoMademoiselle
ChanelNo.5
ChanceEauTendre
Chance
ChanceEauFraiche
Coco
CocoNoir
Allure
AllureSensuelle
BvlgariPourFemme
ChanelNo.19
Total
FACIALTREATMENTS
Chanel
FRAGRANCESFORMEN
Bleu
PlatinumEgoiste
BvlgariMan
AllureHomme
AllureHommeSport
AllureHommeExtreme
Allother
Total
EYEMAKEUP
Chanel
FACEMAKEUP
Chanel
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Chanel
NAILPOLISHES
Chanel
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Chanel
TOTAL

$Million
2011

2012

52
44
18
15
10
10

7
1
1
1
159

70

42
3
3
3
3

2
56

49

42

58
48
20
16
11
10
8
7
1
1
1
181

77

45
4
3
3
3
3
2
63

50

46

32

35

2
417

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

2
461

542

Chanel

COMPANYOVERVIEW

ChanelS.A.wasfoundedin1909bythelatecouturierCocoChanel.
Chanel is a global manufacturer and supplier of luxury goods, such as readytowear
jewelry,accessories,handbags,fragrances,makeup,andskincareproducts.
ItsheadquartersislocatedinNeuillysurSeine,France.
ItsU.S.administrativeofficeislocatedinNewYork,NY.
Itemploysapproximately3,200employeesworldwide.

Chaneloperatesover310Chanelboutiquesworldwide.
Itincludes128boutiquesintheUnitedStates,94inAsia,70inEurope,10intheMiddle
East,2inSouthAmerica,and6inOceania.
It has its own network of 95 companyowned retail stores and 135 Chanel shopin
shops.
Thesearelocatedinupscaleshoppingdistricts,upscaledepartmentstoresandmalls,
andmajorairports.
IntheUnitedStates,thecompanyoperatesboutiquesinNewYorkCity,BeverlyHills,
Boston,SanFrancisco,Houston,Dallas,BalHarbour,PalmBeach,Chicago,Waikiki,and
Honolulu.

ChanelalsoownsEresandParaffection,twoleadingapparelcompaniesbasedinParis.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Chanelisaprivatelyheldcompanyanddoesnotdiscloseitsfinancialinformationpublicly.

Corporate sales for the company are estimated to increase at a rate of 6.9% from
$2.9billionin2011to$3.1billionin2012.

ThecompanystotalcorporatesalesintheUnitedStatesareestimatedtoincrease9.9%in
2012,upfrom$644millionin2011to$708millionin2012.
IntheUnitedStates,Chanelscosmeticsandskincareproductsaredistributedthrough
855stores,whilefragrancesaresoldthroughapproximately3,500doors.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

The companys U.S. sales in the cosmetics and toiletries market grow by 10.6% from
$417millionin2011to$461millionin2012.
Since 2007, sales for the company have grown at a compound annual growth rate
(CAGR)of6.5%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A42

Chanel

Table524:ChanelsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

336

2008

312

(7.1)

2009

292

(6.4)

2010

346

18.5

2011

417

20.5

2012

461

10.6

The fragrance product class commands 52.9% of the companys total sales in the U.S.
cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
Chanel holds a 6.4% market share in the fragrance class in 2012, increasing
considerablyfrom5.9%in2011.
Salesoftheproductclassgrowfrom$215millionin2011to$244millionin2012,an
increaseof13.5%.

Table525:CosmeticsandToiletriesBrandsofChanelintheUnitedStates,2012
Division/brand
CHANEL
Allure
AllureHomme
AllureHommeSport
AllureSensuelle
AntaeusPourHomme
Bleu
Chance
ChanceEauFraiche
ChanceEauTendre
Chanel
ChanelNo.19
BvlgaripourFemme
ChanelNo.5
ChanelPourMonsieur
ChanelPrecision
Coco
CocoMademoiselle
Egoiste
EgoistePlatinum
LightBluePourHomme
CocoNoir
AllureHommeExtreme

Product
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesformen
Fragrances/toiletriesformen
Fragrancesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesformen
Fragrancesformen
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrancesforwomen
Makeup,nailpolishes,skincareproducts
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrancesformen
Facialtreatments
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesforwomen
Fragrances/toiletriesformen
Fragrances/toiletriesformen
Fragrancesformen
Fragrancesforwomen
Fragrancesformen

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

543

544

Chanel

Thefragrancesforwomenproductcategorygenerates39.3%ofthecompanyssalesinthe
fragrance product class in 2012, mainly driven by the classics such as Chanels Coco
MademoiselleandChanelNo.5brands.
Salesofwomensfragrancesgrowfrom$159millionin2011to$181millionin2012,up
by13.8%.
Chanelmarketsallofitsproductsintheluxurytradeclass,whereitisthethirdlargest
marketer.
Chanelpossesses6.7%marketshareinthewomensfragrancecategoryand11.4%in
theluxurytradeclassofthiscategoryintheU.S.marketin2012.
Coco Mademoiselle continues to be the top brand for the company in this category
with $58million in sales, or 12.6% of the total. Chanels Coco Mademoiselle is the
leaderintheluxurysegmentinthefragrancesforwomenproductcategory.
The brand is supported with magazine and television advertising, along with online
supportduringtheholidaypurchasingtimes.
A new broadcast advertising campaign premieres in 2012 featuring actress Keira
Knightley.

Facial treatments is the secondlargest contributor to the companys cosmetics and


toiletriessales,with16.7%ofthetotalsalesin2012,alsodecreasingitsshareslightlyfrom
16.8%in2011.
Salesincreaseby10.0%,from$70millionin2011to$77millionin2012.
Thecategorybenefitsfromconsumerswillingtospendmoreonluxuryproducts.

Makeupproductsisthesecondlargestproductclassforthecompanyin2012.
It experiences a 6.2% increase in sales, from $130million in 2011 to $138million in
2012.
Eye makeup continues to be the largest makeup category for the company in 2012,
generating 36.2% of the companys cosmetics and toiletries sales in the makeup
productclass.
Salesintheeyemakeupcategorygrowby2.0%in2012.
Chanelisrankedfourthintheluxuryeyemakeupproductcategory,with5.7%market
sharein2012,downfrom5.9%in2011.
Thecompanypostsastronggrowthof9.5%inthefacemakeupcategoryin2012,from
$42millionin2011to$46millionin2012.
Thecompanyranksfourthintheluxuryfacemakeupcategory,with$46millioninsales
in2012anda4.2%marketshare.
The company is ranked third in the luxury lipsticks and lip glosses category with
$35millioninsalesin2012and7.1%marketshareintheproductcategory.
Chanelranksthirdintheluxurynailpolishescategorywithsalesof$7millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A44

Chanel

Fragrancesformencontinuestobeanimportantcategoryin2012.
Salesofmensfragrancesgrows12.5%from$56millionin2011to$63millionin2012.
It is the thirdlargest category for Chanel, increasing its share from 13.4% in 2011 to
13.7%in2012.
The company jumps from fifth position in the category to fourth and increases its
marketsharefrom5.3%in2011to5.7%in2012.
ChanelssalesgrowthinthecategoryisbasedonthesuccessofitsbrandBleu,which
continuestogrow.
Bleusshareofthetotalmensfragrancemarketis4.1%during2012,upfrom4.0%in
2011,andthebrandsshareoftheluxurytradeclassin2012growsto5.9%,from5.8%
in2011.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

TherearenonotablerecentdevelopmentsforChanel.

Newproducts

Table526:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyChanelintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Chanel

Fragrancesformen

AllureHommeExtremeisthenewestextensionintheAllurelineand
includesmuskyshades,tartspices,aromaticfreshness,andwoodyaccords

CocoNoir

Fragrancesfor
women

Chanelsnewscentwithtopnotesofgrapefruit,andCalabrianbergamot
followedbyaheartofrose,narcissus,rosegeraniumleaf,andjasmine

MARKETINGACTIVITY

In2012,Chanelincreasesitsspendingonadvertisingandpromotionalactivities,withTME
of$86.6millioncomparedto$77.8millionin2011,anincreaseof11.3%.
The marketer primarily uses broadcast media, such as television, print, and Internet
advertisements,topromoteitsproducts.
ChaneladvertisesinleadingfashionmagazinessuchasVogue,Redbook,andAllure.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

545

546

Chanel

Chanelspends87.8%ofitsmediabudgetonitsfragrancescategoryin2012,upfrom77.2%
in2011.
In 2012, most of the expenditures, or almost $25 million are allocated to Bleu de
Chanel.
Alargeshareofthe24.4%isspentontheCocoMademoisellebrandin2012.
Almost 59.1% of the total media spending in the category is spent on womens
fragrancesin2012.
ChanelsBleuscentformencontinuestoreceivealotofeditorialmentioninfashion
andmenspublicationsduring2012.
Brad Pitt fronts a new print and broadcast campaign for Chanel No.5 and is the only
malespokespersonforafemalescent.
AnewbroadcastadvertisementforChanelsCocoMademoisellefeaturesactressKeira
KnightleyridingthroughParisonamotorcycle.
Foritsfirstfullyearoncounter,ChanelcontinuestosupportthelaunchofBleuwith
nationalprintadvertisements,televisionadvertisingfromfilmdirectorMartinScorsese,
aYouTubevideo,andanonlinecampaign.

Themarketerutililizesflashretailing(popupstores),openingsalesshopsforashortperiod,
inordertopromotesales.
Themarketeropensthesestoresincitycentersorpopularplaceswhereitcanengage
withconsumersbypromotingitsproducts.

Chanel promotes its products through social media channels including Facebook, Twitter,
andYoutube.
ThemarketeradvertisesitsnewproductsonitsFacebookpagetosupportitssales.

Details on traceable media expenditures (TME) are provided in the Advertising section of
thisreport.

OUTLOOK

Chanelisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof2.5%inthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry
overthenextfiveyears,2012to2017.
Newproductlaunchesacrosscategorieswillcontinuetosupportthemarketersgrowth
overtheforecastperiod.
Themarketerwillcontinuetopartnerwithpopularcelebritiesanddesignerstosupport
itssales.
Consumersareslowlyopentopurchasingluxuryproductsthatwillsupportthesalesof
themarketeroverthenextfiveyears.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A46

Chanel

Thefacialtreatmentscategoryisexpectedtopostthestrongestgrowthof3.5%forChanel
overtheforecastperiod.
Growing demand for antiaging and antiacne products will support the marketers
growthinthecategory.
Newproductlauncheswithbettertechnologiesandclaimsareexpectedtosupportthe
marketersgrowthinthenextfiveyears.
The marketer will continue to look beyond its core channel of distribution for more
sales.
Chanel is expected to support its sales through home shopping channels and the
Internet.
Chanel will continue to focus on this category, considering the increasing consumer
demandinthiscategoryandinclinationtohavegood,healthyskin.

ThemakeupproductclassisexpectedtoperformwellforChanelovertheforecastperiod.
Theeyemakeupandfacemakeupcategoriesareexpectedtobethebestperfomersin
themakeupproductclassoverthenextfiveyears.
Themarketerplanstolaunchnewproductsandimproveitsexistingbrandstosupport
itsales.
Chanelisexpectedtoprovidenewvariationstothetraditionalpressedpowderblushin
forms,suchaswhippedcream,sticks,andliquidtints.
Face powders that provide additional benefits beyond setting makeup or reducing
shineareexpectedtosupportthefacemakeupcategorysgrowth.

Thefragrancesproductclasswillcontinueto bethelargestrevenuegeneratorforChanel
overtheforecastperiod.
Thecorebrandsofthemarketer,BleuandCocoMademoiselle,areexpectedtodrive
thesalesofthemarketer.
The marketer plans to increase its media spend on these brands to support its sales
overthenextfiveyears.
Theseproductsalsohavealoyalconsumerbase,whichwilllikelysupportsales.
Chanel plans to introduce new fragrances and existing products in new forms to
supportitssales.
Thecompanywillcontinuetosignagreementswithcelebrities,designers,artists,and
entertainerstolaunchnewbrandsorpromoteexistingbrandextensions.
The marker will also continue to feature celebrities, such as Brad Pitt and Keira
Knightley,initsadvertisementstopromotethesalesofitsproducts.

Chanelplanstoenternewmarketsandgeographiesovertheforecastperiod.
The company plans to open up more of its companyowned boutiques and shopin
shopstoresinthenextfewyears.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

547

548

Chanel

Chanelwillcontinuetoenhanceitsresearchanddevelopmentactivitiesacrosscategoriesto
supportitssalesoverthenextfiveyears.
Thecompanyplanstopartnerwithexpertsandscientistsinplantbiologytodevelopa
lineofnaturalandorganicingredientsthatcanbeincorporatedintoitsproducts.

Chanelwillcontinuetoincreasethemediaspendingforitsproductsacrosscategoriesover
theforecastperiodtosupportitssales.
Thecompanywillcontinuetoutilizeinnovativetools,suchassocialwebsitesandother
toolsoftheInternet,tocommunicatewithconsumersmoreeffectivelyandquickly.
Chanel will continue to conduct various marketing and promotional campaigns to
attractconsumers.
The marketer is likely to support its new product introductions with high media
expenditurestosupportitssales.

Sales for the company are expected to grow at a CAGR of 2.5% to reach $522million by
2017,upfrom$461millionin2012.

Table527:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletries
forChanelbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

3.5

Facemakeup

2.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.5

Lipsticksandlipglosses

2.0

Eyemakeup

1.5

Nailpolishes

1.0

Fragrancesforwomen

1.0

Fragrancesformen

1.0

Handandbodylotions

0.2

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A48

CHURCH&DWIGHT

Table528:Church&DwightsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and
2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

TOOTHPASTES

2012

Arm&Hammer

82

83

Aim

19

19

Orajel

17

16

Mentadent

14

12

CloseUp

14

13

Pepsodent

12

11

158

154

Arrid

45

43

Arm&Hammer

23

23

69

66

48

45

42

45

321

313

Total
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

LadysChoice
Total
TOOTHBRUSHES
CrestSpinBrush
DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES
Nair
TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS
Arm&HammerWhiteningBooster
TOTAL

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

550

Church&Dwight

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Church&Dwight,foundedin1846,marketsandmanufacturesawiderangeofhousehold,
personalcare,andspecialtyproducts.
ItisheadquarteredinPrinceton,NJ.
AsofDecember31,2012,thecompanyemploys4,354staff.
The company conducts its research and development at its Princeton and Cranbury
facilitiesinNewJersey.
The core focus of the company is on its power brands, Arm & Hammer, Trojan
Condoms,Xtralaundrydetergent,Oxicleanprewashlaundryadditive,Nairdepilatories,
FirstResponsepregnancyandovulationtestkits,Orajeloralanalgesics,andSpinBrush,
abatteryoperatedtoothbrush.

The companys business is divided into three segments: consumer domestic, consumer
international,andspecialtyproducts.
The consumer domestic segment has eight power brands which includes household
and personal care products such as Scrub Free, Kaboom, and Orange Glo cleaning
products, Answer home pregnancy and ovulation test kits, Arrid antiperspirant, and
CloseUpandAimtoothpastes.
Theconsumerinternationalsegmentsellsavarietyofpersonalcareproducts,someof
which are also sold in the domestic product line in international markets of Canada,
France,Australia,theUnitedKingdom,Mexico,Brazil,andChina.
The specialty products segment primarily produces sodium bicarbonate and other
inorganicchemicalsforindustrial,institutional,medical,andfoodapplications.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Church&Dwightssalesincrease6.3%from$2,749millionin2011to$2,922millionin2012.
Netprofitsriseby13.0%to$349.8millionin2012,upfrom$309.6millionin2011.

Table529:Church&DwightsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

2007

2,220.9

169.0

7.6

15.6

2008

2,422.4

195.2

8.1

18.1

2009

2,520.9

243.5

9.7

15.2

2010

2,589.2

270.7

10.5

15.6

2011

2,749.0

309.6

11.2

15.2

2012

2,922.0

349.8

11.9

17.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A50

Returnonequity

Church&Dwight

Since2007,saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of5.6%.
The consumer products segment achieves sales of $2,667.0million in 2012, growing
7.2%from$2,488.2millionin2011.
DollarsalesintheconsumerproductssegmentadvanceataCAGRof6.3%since2007.

Table530:Church&DwightsProductSegmentSales,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Consumer
products

Specialty
products

Total

2007

1,962.4

258.5

2,220.9

2008

2,137.0

285.4

2,422.4

2009

2,275.4

245.5

2010

2,330.1

2011
2012

%Oftotal
Consumer
products

Specialty
products

Total

88.4

11.6

100

88.2

11.8

100

2,520.9

90.3

9.7

100

259.1

2,589.2

90.0

10.0

100

2,488.2

261.1

2,749.3

91.6

9.4

100

2,667.0

254.9

2,921.9

91.3

8.7

100

Domesticsalesofconsumerproductsrepresent74.0%ofthecompanystotalsalesin2012.

Table531:Church&DwightsGlobalSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011to
2012

%Oftotalsales

Businesssegment

2011

2012

Household

47

48

Personalcareproducts

25

26

Total

72

74

CONSUMERINTERNATIONAL

19

17

100

100

CONSUMERDOMESTIC

SPECIALTYPRODUCTS
TOTAL

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

TotalsalesforChurch&Dwightscosmeticsandtoiletriesaredown2.5%to$313millionin
2012from$321millionin2011.
Since2007,saleshavedeclinedataCAGRof2.1%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

551

552

Church&Dwight

Table532:Church&DwightsCosmeticsandToiletries
SalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

347

2008

361

4.0

2009

366

1.4

2010

339

(7.4)

2011

321

(5.3)

2012

313

(2.5)

ThetoothpastescategoryisChurch&Dwightslargestcategory,withsalesof$154million
in2012,downby2.5%from$158millionin2011.
In the toothpastes category, Church& Dwight remains in fourth place with an 8.8%
marketshare,downfrom9.2%in2011.
Lackofnewproductsandpromotionalactivitiescontributestothemarketersdeclinein
thetoothpastescategory.
Arm&Hammer,thecompanysleadingbrand,hasa4.7%marketshare.Salesareupby
1.2%to$83millionin2012from$82millionin2011.
The introduction of multibenefit toothpastes under the Arm & Hammer brand
supportsthemarketersbrandsgrowthin2012.
During2012,Church&DwightlaunchestwosignificantnewproductsundertheArm&
Hammerbrandinthetoothpastescategory:AdvancedWhiteBakingSoda&Peroxide
FreshMinttoothpasteandOrajelSensitivetoothpaste.

Deodorants and antiperspirants are the secondlargest product category for the company
withtotalsalesof$66millionin2012,down4.3%from$69millionin2011.
Thecompanymarketstwokeybrands:ArridandArm&Hammer.
ThemarketerdiscontinuesLady'sChoice,whichcontributestothemarketersdecline
inthecategory.
Arridistheleadingbrandforthecompanywithsalesof$43millionin2012,downby
4.4%from$45millionin2011.
SalesofArm&Hammerremainflatat$23millionin2012,constantwith2011levels.

Church&Dwightsthirdlargestproductcategoryistoothbrushes.
Salesofthecategorydeclineby6.3%in2012to$45millionfrom$48millionin2011.
Thecompanysmarketsharedecreasesfrom6.6%in2011to6.1%in2012.
The introduction of a privatelabel brand, similar in design and functionality to the
SpinBrush,butpricedsignificantlylower,istheprimarycauseforthedrop.
Church & Dwight discontinues all Mentadent toothbrushes except one, significantly
paringthebrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A52

Church&Dwight

Sales of Church & Dwights depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category grow 7.1% from
$42millionin2011to$45millionin2012.
Naircontinuestobethesecondleadingbrandinthecategory,withsalesat$45million
in2012.
Nair accounts for 27.6% of total depilatories, waxes, and bleaches categorys sales in
2012,downfrom29.2%in2011.
Thekeyreasonforthemarketershealthygrowthin2012isaccreditedtothelaunchof
itsBrazilianSpaClaylineofproducts.ThelinecomprisesBrazilianSpaClayBodyCream,
BrazilianSpaClayRollOnWax,andBrazilianSpaClayFaceCream.
Nairsportfolioofproductsforwomenincludesinshowerproducts,waxes,andcreams
and gels. These products are available in different variants with some especially
designedasasensitiveformula.
NairsproductofferingsformenarelimitedtotheNairForMenSpray,InShowerNair
For Men, and Nair For Men Body Cream, since depilatories for men is still a niche
segment.

The sales of Church & Dwights Arm & Hammer brand in the tooth whitening products
categorydeclineby25.0%from$4millionin2011to$3millionin2012.
Toothwhiteningproducts,ingeneral,declinedin2012,mainlyduetocompetitionfrom
whiteningtoothpastesandmouthwashes.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers,alliances,andacquisitions

InOctober2012,Church&DwightannouncesthatithascompleteditsacquisitionofAvid
Health for $650.0 million. Avid Health markets nutritional supplements, mostly in the
gummyformat.

Managementchanges

InFebruary2012,thecompanyannounceschangeswithinitsSpecialtyProductsdivision.
Curt Siverling is promoted to the position of President, Specialty Products Division,
effective March 2012. He was responsible for leading Church & Dwights Specialty
ChemicalsandAnimalNutritionbusinesses,aswellasbeingaboardmemberonthree
jointventurecompanies.
Scott Druker is promoted to the position of Director, Animal Nutrition, assuming
generalmanagerresponsibilitiesofArm&HammersAnimalNutrition.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

553

554

Church&Dwight

Newproducts

Table533:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyChurch&DwightintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Arm&Hammer

Toothpastes

Arm&HammerAdvancedWhiteBakingSoda&PeroxideFreshMint
toothpasteisspecificallyformulatedwithrefineddentalgradebaking
sodatopreventnewstainbuildupinteeth.Apartfromdeepcleaning,
italsocontrolstartarandremovesplaque

Arm&Hammer
ToothTunes

Toothbrushes

ToothTunesisamanualtoothbrushthatplayspopularcommercial
musicfortwominutestoencourageproperbrushing

Nair

Depilatories,
waxes,and
bleaches

BrazilianSpaClayBodyCreamisenrichedwithmangobutter,acai
berry,mineralrichclay.InfusedwiththeShowerPowerTechnology
whichhelpspreventthecreamfromrinsingoffwhileintheshower.
Additionally,theconvenientpumpandspongemakestheapplication
andthehairremovalprocesseasyandhandsfree

Nair

Depilatories,
waxes,and
bleaches

BrazilianSpaClayRollOnWaxisinfusedwithmangobutter,acai
berry,andmineralrichclay.Itcomeswitharollonapplicatorfora
messfreeapplication

Nair

Depilatories,
waxes,and
bleaches

BrazilianSpaClayFaceCreamisenrichedwithmangobutter,acai
berry,andmineralrichclaygivessmoothhairfreeskinwithinaslittle
asfiveminutes,dermatologicallytested

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Church& Dwight spends $65.7 million in advertising and promotional activities in 2012,
down7.9%from$71.3millionin2011.
Various promotional tools used by the company to promote its products include
sampling, couponing, media advertising, temporary price reductions, and other
consumerincentives.
In 2012, Church & Dwight allocates $38.7 million to its Arm & Hammer toothpastes,
withthefundingspreadacrosstelevisionandmagazineadvertisements.
Themarketerallocatesalmost$28.0milliontopromoteitsArm&Hammerwhitening
toothpastein2012.

Church & Dwight promotes SpinBrush mainly through television commercials and
magazines.
Thecompanyspendsabout$15.6milliontopromoteitstoothbrushescategoryin2012.
The company primarily uses television and magazine advertisements to promotes its
toothbrushes.
In the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category, Church & Dwights decreases its
traceablemediaexpenditures(TME)to$6.9millionin2012from$7.4millionin2011,
down6.8%.
Majority of the TME at $4.3million, is spent on television advertisements. Television
advertisementexpendituresaccountfor62.3%ofthetotalTME.
Themarketeralsospends$2.2milliononmagazineadvertisements.
TheNairBrazilianSpaClayhairremovalcreamreceivesmajorportionofthebrands
TMEat$2.4millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A54

Church&Dwight

Church&Dwightoffersdiscountcouponsthroughwebsites,magazines,andnewspapersas
apartofitspromotionalstrategy.
ThecompanysupportsitsNairbrandinthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachesproduct
linewith$8.0millionasTMEin2012.
Nairs website offers a discount coupon of $3.00 on the purchase of any two Nair
products.

Church&DwightsaugmentsitstraditionalmarketingactivitieswithInternetmarketing.
NairswebsiteofferswriteupsontheadvantagesofusingathomeNairhairremoval
productsovervisitingsalons,guidetoobtainingbeautifulskin,andotherinformation
ontheuseofproducts.
Nairs men and women products are classified separately on its website, making it
easierforconsumerstotracetheproductappropriateforthem.
Church&DwightisalsoavailableonsocialmediasitessuchasFacebookandYoutube
forinstantacceptanceamongconsumers.
Themarketeradvertisesitsnewproductsandexistingproductsonthesemediumsto
engageconsumersinterest.

Arm&Hammeruserscanregisterforthebrandsnewsletteronitswebsitebyfillingina
simpleform.
Signing up for the newsletter provides members benefits, such as opportunities to
previewandshopfornewproductsanddiscountsonnewandexistingproducts.

OUTLOOK

ThecompanyssalesatthemanufacturerlevelareforecasttogrowmoderatelyataCAGR
of0.3%overtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Totalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareprojectedtogrowfrom$313millionin2012to
$318millionin2017.

Church&Dwightisexpectedtoregainitszealforintroducingnewerproducts,gainingmore
stanceinallthecategoriesthatitcompetesin.
The company is expected to launch innovative products such as Tooth Tunes battery
operated toothbrushes that claim to come with a proprietary technology that will
deliver music while brushing. This is expected to support the companys overall sales
growthduringtheforecastperiod.
The company is likely to launch innovative products in all its categories, including
toothpastes,toothbrushes,anddepilatories,waxes,andbleaches.
The company will also focus on marketing its key brandsArm & Hammer, Orajel,
SpinBrush,andNairintheforecastperiodtokeepupitsrevenuesintherespective
categories.
Furthermore, Church & Dwight will likely benefit from providing more promotional
supporttoitsproductportfolio.
Newacquisitionsareanotherwaytohelpleveragethestrengthofitsdiverseproduct
portfoliowhichconsistsofpremiumbrandsandvaluebrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

555

556

Church&Dwight

Themarketerplanstoadoptcostsavingprogramsovertheforecastperiodtosupportthe
positivegrowthofthecompany.

The oral care product class will continue to be the largest revenue generator for the
marketerovertheforecastperiod.
Church&Dwightplanstolaunchinnovativeproductswithmultibenefitsunderitsoral
care product categories including toothpastes, toothbrushes, and mouthwashes to
supportitssales.
Moreover, the marketer will continue to increase its TME spend on the oral care
productclasstosupportitssalesovertheforecastperiod.
However, further growth of the marketer in the oralcareproduct class will be offset
duetoitspresenceinthematurecategoriesincludingtoothpastes,toothbrushes,and
mouthwashes.

The two flagship brands, Nair and Arm & Hammer, are expected to generate the highest
revenuesforthecompanyovertheforecastperiod.
Church & Dwight plans to launch innovative products under these brands to support
salesandprovideaggressivepromotionalsupporttotheseproductofferings.
Furthermore,themarketerislikelytointroducemoreproductsspecifictomentocater
tothegrowingdemandofmalegroomingproducts,therebysupportingitssalesgrowth.

Table534:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletriesfor
Church&DwightbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

1.6

COMPANYAVERAGE

0.3

Toothpastes

0.2

Mouthwashes

0.3

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

0.2

Toothwhiteningproducts

0.2

Toothbrushes

0.1

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A56

CLARINS

Table535:ClarinsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

68

71

Angel

25

27

Alien

Womanity

33

37

18

19

Chrome

10

AngelMen

Allother

11

14

13

13

160

171

FACIALTREATMENTS
Clarins
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

Total
FACEMAKEUP
Clarins
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Clarins
SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN
ClarinsMen
EYEMAKEUP
Clarins
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Clarins
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Clarins
SHAVINGPRODUCTS
ClarinsMen
TOTAL

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

558

Clarins

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Clarins is a French cosmetics company headquartered in NeuillysurSeine, France,


specializing in skin care products, makeup, and fragrances. The company was founded in
1954.
The marketer was founded by Jacques CourtinClarins with the development of the
ClarinsInstitutedeBeautinParisin1954.
The companys global distribution network includes 20 subsidiaries, 19,000 retail
venues,andextendedpresenceinnearly150countries.
Clarinsemploysabout6,100employeesworldwidein2012.
Thecompanyisprivatesinceitsdelistingin2008.

Clarinsisdividedintotwobusinesssegments:ClarinsBrandandClarinsFragrancesGroup.
ClarinsBrandincludesthecompanysmakeupandskincareproducts.
TheClarinsFragrancesGroupcomprisesthefragrancebrands,includingThierryMugler,
ModeetPatrimoine,Azzaro,PorscheDesign,andSwarovski.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

The company does not disclose its financial information after it became a private
organizationin2008.

Clarins corporate sales are estimated to increase by 8.2% from 1,135million


($1,458million)in2011to1,228million($1,578million)in2012.
Saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of4.0%since2007.

Table536:ClarinsGlobalSalesofCosmeticsandToiletries,
2007to2012
Year

Million

Change,%

2007

1,008

2008

975

(3.3)

2009

965

(1.0)

2010r

1,045

8.3

2011r

1,135

8.6

2012

1,228

8.2

rRestated.
NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A58

Clarins

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

The companys sales of cosmeticsand toiletries products in the United States increase by
6.9%,from$160millionin2011to$171millionin2012.
SaleshaveincreasedataCAGRof2.3%since2007.

Table537:ClarinsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletries
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

153

2008

146

(4.6)

2009

136

(6.8)

2010

142

4.4

2011

160

12.7

2012

171

6.9

The companys portfolio includes fragrances for men and women, makeup products, and
skincareproducts.

Table538:ClarinsCosmeticsandToiletriesBrandsintheUnitedStates,2012
Brand

Productcategory

Alien

Fragrancesforwomen

Angel

Fragrancesforwomen

AngelMen

Fragrancesformen

Chrome

Fragrancesformen

Clarins

Facialtreatments,fragrances,makeup,handandbodylotions,suncareproducts

ClarinsMen

Skincareproductsformen,deodorants,shampoos,shavingproducts

Womanity

Fragrancesforwomen

Facialtreatmentsarethelargestcategoryforthecompany,accountingfor41.5%ofitstotal
salesinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
Sales of Clarins in the category advance 4.4% to reach $71 million in 2012, up from
$68millionin2011.
Themarketercontinuestoloseshareinthecategorywithadipof1.0%from42.5%in
2011 to 41.5% in 2012. Introduction of new products is the primary reason for the
positivegrowthinthecategory.
In2012,themarketerintroducestheSuperRestorativeTotalEyeConcentrate.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

559

560

Clarins

Thecompanysmarketshareintheoverallfacialtreatmentscategoryremainsat1.1%
in2012,flatfrom2011levels.
The marketer maintains the eighthleading position in the luxury trade class in the
facialtreatmentsproductscategoryin2012.
Clarinsrangeofproductsinthecategoryincludescleansers,toners,facetreatmentoils,
serums,moisturizers,andantiagingproducts.

Womensfragrancesisthesecondlargestproductcategoryforthemarketer,accountingfor
21.6%ofthecompanyssalesin2012.
Sales in the category continue to increase with growth of 12.1% from $33 million in
2011to$37millionin2012.
Angel continues to be the leading brand for Clarins in the fragrances for women
category,withsalesup8.0%from$25millionin2011to$27millionin2012.
Clarinsmarketshareinthefragrancesforwomencategoryisupmarginallyby0.1%to
1.4%in2012,from1.3%in2011.

Facemakeupproductsisthethirdlargestproductcategoryforthecompanywithsalesup
5.6%from$18millionin2011to$19millionin2012.
Sales of the marketer in the face makeup products category represent 11.1% of the
companysentiresalesin2012,downfrom11.3%in2011.
Thecompanysmarketshareinthefacemakeupproductcategoryis0.7%in2012.
In2012,themarketerintroducestheEverlastingCompactFoundationSPF15.

Clarinssalesinthefragrancesformenproductscategorygrow27.3%toreach$14million
in2012,upfrom$11millionin2011.
Salesinthefragrancesformenscategoryrepresent8.2%ofthemarketerstotalsales
in2012.
With sales at $10 million in 2012, up 11.1% from $9 million in 2011, Chrome is the
marketerslargestbrandinthecategoryin2012.
In2012,Clarinshasa1.8%marketshareintheluxurytradeclassofmensfragrances,
upfrom1.5%in2011.

Clarinsalsomarksitspresenceinsixothercategoriesinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
in2012.
Thesecategoriesincludesuncareproducts,skincareproductsformen,eyemakeup,
lipsticksandlipglosses,handandbodylotions,andshavingproducts.
Thesesixcategoriestogetheraccountfor$30millioninsalesor17.5%ofthemarketers
salesin2012.
Shavingproductsisthesmallestcategoryforthemarketerwithsales at$1millionin
2012,flatfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A60

Clarins

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Therearenonotabledevelopmentsin2012.

Partnershipsandagreements

Therearenopartnershipsoragreementsin2012.

Newproducts

Table539:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyClarinsintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Clarins

Facemakeup

EverlastingCompactFoundationSPF15.Awetanddrytexturewhichissaid
toprovideaflawlessfinishandlasts15hours

Clarins

Facialtreatments SuperRestorativeTotalEyeConcentrateisatripleactionserumfortheeye
areathatlifts,depuffs,andreplenishes

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The companys total traceable media expenditures (TME) for cosmetics and toiletries
increase16.7%from$22.8millionin2011to$26.6millionin2012.
Printadvertisementsinleadingandfashionandbeautymagazines,suchasAllure,Elle,
Vogue, Teen Vogue, and Harpers Bazaar, receive the largest TME support at
$21.5millionin2012.Themarketerspends80.8%oftheTMEonprintadvertisements
in2012,followedbytelevisionspots.
TelevisionspotsreceiveaTMEsupportof$4.4millionin2012.
Majority of Clarins TME, at almost 66% of total TME, is allocated to its fragrances
productclass.TheproductclassreceivesaTMEspendingof$17.5millionin2012,up
63.6%from$10.7millionin2011.
ClarinsisallocatedaTMEof$4.9milliononpromotingitsfacialtreatmentproductsin
2012.

ThecompanysleadingbrandintermsofadvertisingexpendituresisThierryMuglersAngel
withaTMEof$10.5millionin2012.

TheClarinswebsiteoffersspecialoffersintheformofdiscountsandalsoallowsconsumers
to sign up for its newsletters to receive special offers and news about new product
introductions.
The website also offers customized suggestions to customers in the form of beauty
advice,applicationmethods,andonlineconsultations.
TheMyFaceBeautyConsultationoptionavailableonthecompanyswebsiteallows
consumerstofindtheiridealbeautyroutinebyansweringafewsimplequestions.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

561

562

Clarins

In 2012, Clarins organizes the Clarins Million Meal Concert for the FEED Foundation at
LincolnCentersAliceTullyHall.
Theconcertisacombinationofpopstarsandcontemporaryclassicalgreatsincluding
John Legend, Natasha Bedingfield, the PS22 Chorus, pianist Christoph Eschenbach,
violist David Aaron Carpenter, conductor Alan Gilbert, and the Salome Chamber
Orchestra.
The former U.S. President Bill Clinton made an appearance during the event, which
aimstoraiseenoughfor1millionschoolmeals,soastoliveuptothedreamofleaving
nochildintheworldwithoutfood.

OUTLOOK

ManufacturerssalesofClarinsareforecasttogrowatahealthyCAGRof3.4%duringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.
Clarins is expected to introduce new innovative products across the cosmetics and
toiletriescategories.Innovationcanbeintheformofimprovedpackaging,extending
productlines,innovativemarketingcampaigns,andadvancedtechnology.
TheTMEforthecompanyisexpectedtocontinuallyincreaseduringthenextfiveyears.
Effortswillalsobedirectedtowardsimprovingthesupplychainefficiencies.

Facial treatments will continue to be the leading product category for Clarins during the
forecastperiod.
The marketer is expected to introduce new products in the skin care product class,
helpingspursalesforthecompany.Itislikelytoregainitspositionastheleadingluxury
suncaremarketerthrough2017.
Antiaging facial treatments will remain a focus segment for Clarins as they gain
popularity with the growing baby boomer population, who become more intent on
preservingtheircomplexion.
Clarinswillcontinuetoformulateitsfacemakeupandfacialtreatmentproductswith
SPFingredients.Thiswillbeakeygrowthdriverforthecompanyintheforecastperiod,
asconsumersbecomeconsciousaboutsunexposureandtheharmfuleffects.

The fragrances product class will be the primary driver behind the healthy growth of the
companyduringtheforecastperiod.
Withimprovedeconomicconditions,consumerswillreturntopurchasingtheirfavorite
premiumpricedfragrances.
Celebrityscentsareexpectedtohavevitalityinthefuture,butthecompanymustbe
moreselectiveinthecelebrityitchooses.
Clarinsisanticipatedtoincreaseitsadvertisingspendingandisexpectedtoengageits
consumers through popular social media networks, such as Facebook, Twitter, and
YouTube.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A62

Clarins

Clarinswillcontinuetodevoteincreasedexpendituretowardsitsresearchanddevelopment
initiatives.
The marketers research team will continue with their global quest to search for
powerfulnaturalactiveingredientstoincludeintheirproductformulationsinorderto
provideconsumersnewandinnovativetechnologicallyadvancedproductsthatdeliver
enhancedresults.

FurthergrowthofthecompanyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketwillberestricted
duetostagnatingperformanceinthehandandbodylotions,shavingproducts,eyemakeup,
andlipsticksandlipglossescategories.
Additionally,limitednewproducts,lackofinnovationintechnology,formulations,and
designs, and limited TME are likely to hamper growth of the company during the
forecastperiod.

ClarinssalesareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof3.4%duringtheforecastperiodendingin
2017toreach$202million,upfrom$171millionin2012.

Table540:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletries
forClarinsbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

4.1

Fragrancesformen

4.0

Fragrancesforwomen

3.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

3.4

Facemakeup

3.0

Skincareproductsformen

3.7

Suncareproducts

1.5

Eyemakeup

Handandbodylotions

Lipsticksandlipglosses

Shavingproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

563

564

Clarins

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A64

THECLOROXCOMPANY

Table541:TheCloroxCompanysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnited
States,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS

BurtsBees

53

58

35

37

29

30

27

29

BurtsBees

SHAMPOOS

158

172

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
BurtsBees
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
BurtsBees
FACIALTREATMENTS
BurtsBees
BABYCAREPRODUCTS

BurtsBeesr
CONDITIONERS
BurtsBeesr
TOTAL

rRestated.

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

566

TheCloroxCompany

COMPANYOVERVIEW

TheCloroxCompany,foundedin1913,isakeyplayerintheconsumerproductsindustry.
ThecompanysheadquartersislocatedinOakland,CA.
Itsemployeeheadcountisapproximately8,400worldwidein2012.
Thecompanymarkets24brandsunderitsproductportfolio.
It offers an extensive variety of products, including: bleach and cleaning products;
home care products; auto care products (glass cleaners, wax, and wipes); cat litter
products (clay, crystals, fresheners, and wipes); charcoal products; food products
(dressings and sauces); water filtration systems; plastic bags, wraps, and containers;
andnaturalpersonalcareproducts.
Italsohasapresenceintheinstitutional,healthcare,andfoodservicemarkets.
Itmanufacturesitsproductsinmorethan24nations,andmarketstheminmorethan
100countries.
Thecompanyoperatesandmarketsproductsacrossfourdistinctsegments:Cleaning,
Household,Lifestyle,andInternational.
The Clorox Company is present in all principal markets, such as North and Central
America,SouthAmerica,Europe,theMiddleEast,Asia,Africa,andAustralasia.
Thecompanyventuredintothepersonalcareproductssegmentwiththeacquisitionof
BurtsBees,aleadingmarketerofnaturalpersonalcareproducts.

Mass merchandisers, grocery stores, and other retail outlets are the companys primary
distributors.
It initiates improved communication about the products ingredients, given that
consumers today want to know what are in products they use in and around their
homes.

Burts Bees is among the fastestgrowing mass market brands in the cosmetics sector in
2012.
The brand experiences growth with added distribution, which includes a designated
BurtsBeesareainretailerssuchasTarget.Themarketerspositioningwithnaturally
formulatedproductsaidsinitsgrowthin2012.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Totalcompanyssalesare$5,468millionin2012,upby4.5%,from$5,231millionfor2011.

Corporatenetprofitsdecreaseby2.5%,from$557millionin2011to$543millionin2012.
Thecompanystotalsalesincreaseatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.4%
from$4,847millionin2007to$5,468millionin2012.

TheCloroxCompanyderivesalmost79%ofitssalesfromtheUnitedStates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A66

TheCloroxCompany

Table542:TheCloroxCompanysGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Yeara

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

2007

4,847

501

10.2

190.1

2008

5,273

461

8.7

(124.6)

2009

5,450

537

9.9

(306.9)

2010

5,234

603

10.9

726.5

2011

5,231

557

10.6

(647.5)

2012

5,468

543

9.9

(402.2)

aFiscalyearendingJune30.

Table543:TheCloroxCompanysGlobalCorporateSalesby
Region,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

TheUnitedStates

78.9

78.9

International

21.1

21.1

100.0

100.0

Total

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

The Clorox Company is represented in the cosmetics and toiletries industry through its
brand,BurtsBees.
BurtsBeeswitnessesahealthygrowthof8.9%in2012.
The marketers product offerings include lip care, lip shimmer, and gloss products;
body care products such as moisturizers, soaps, and natural bath products; hair care
products including shampoos, conditioners, and treatments; natural personal care
products,suchascleansers,toners,eyecrme,exfoliants,complexionmists,footcare,
handsoaps,skincareproductsformen,andtoothpastes.

The Clorox Companys U.S. sales of cosmetics and toiletries grow 8.9% to $172million in
2012,upfrom$158millionin2011.

TheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesofthecompanyhaveincreasedataCAGRof15.1%
from$85millionin2007to$172millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

767

568

TheCloroxCompany

Table544:TheCloroxCompanysCosmeticsandToiletries
SalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Yearr

$Million

Change,%

2007

85

2008

111

30.6

2009

125

12.6

2010

141

12.8

2011

158

12.1

2012

172

8.9

rRestated.

BurtsBeeshasbeenaleadingmarketerinnaturalpersonalcareproductssince1984.
It manufactures more than 250 products in lip care, face care, body care, hair care,
mensskincare,babycare,oralcareproducts,kits,andgifts.
Theproductsprimarilysellinnearly42,000retailoutlets,includingsomeofthemajor
grocery and drug store chains in the United States, the United Kingdom, Ireland,
Canada,HongKong,andTaiwan.
The company increased its distribution channels through specialty natural retailers,
massretailers,anddepartmentstoresin2011,whichcontinuestoaidinincreasingthe
brandssalesin2012.

The Clorox Company remains the secondlargest company in the lip balms, jellies, and
treatmentsproductscategoryin2012.
Manufacturers sales increase 9.4% to $58 million in 2012 from $53 million in 2011.
Burts Bees products benefit as demand shifts from syntheticbased and petroleum
basedlipproductstoproductswhicharemorenatural.
Marketsharerisesto15.5%in2012from14.8%in2011.

The personal cleansing products category is the secondlargest product category for the
companyin2012.
Themarketerssalesinthecategorygrow5.7%from$35millionin2011to$37million
in2012.
Sales of personal cleansing products represent 21.5% of the marketers total sales in
the cosmetics and toiletries market. This is marginally down from 22.2% of the
marketerstotalsalesin2011.
Thecompanyspersonalcleansingproductscategorysportfolioincludesawiderange
ofbodywashes,barsoaps,showerkits,oils,crystals,scrubs,andbubblebathproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A68

TheCloroxCompany

The thirdlargest product category for the company in 2011 is the hand and body lotions
withsalesup3.4%toreach$30millionin2012,upfrom$29millionin2011.
In2012,thecompanyintroducesitsGdlineofproductscomprisingbodylotionsand
bodybutters.
In spite of the introduction of new products, the marketers share in the category
declinesfrom18.4%in2011to17.4%in2012.
In 2012, The Clorox Company updates its Burts Bees hand and body lotions bottles
withtheadditionofconvenientpumpsthathelpdispensetheproductwithease.

Facial treatment is the fourthlargest category for the company in 2012, with sales at
$29million.
Sales of the company in 2012 are up 7.4% from $27 million in 2011. The good
performance of the Burts Bees brand is due to the introduction of the Intense
Hydration line comprising the Cream Cleanser, the Day Cream, the Night Cream, the
TreatmentMask,andtheEyeCream.

The Clorox Company rises to become the secondleading marketer in the baby care
products category (tied with Naterra), with sales at $9 million in in 2012, up 12.5% from
$8millionin2011.
ThemarketshareforTheCloroxCompanyinthebabycareproductscategoryadvances
from2.8%in2011to3.1%in2012.
BurtsBeesintroducesitsnewlineofbabycareproductsknownasBabyBeein2012,
andhasanexclusivewebsiteforitsentirebabycarerangeofproductsandaccessories.
This step helps the brand gain more media coverage in 2012 thereby bringing about
moreawarenessfortheentirebrand.
ThepositioningofBurtsBeesproductsascontainingnaturalandorganicingredients,
with affordable pricing, together with an expanding distribution network also aids in
thecompanysgrowth.

SalesofTheCloroxCompanyinthehaircareproductclassgrow50.0%toreach$9millionin
2012,upfrom$6millionin2011.
Thehaircareproductclasscontributesto5.2%ofthecompanystotalcosmeticsand
toiletriessalesin2012,upfrom3.8%in2011.
Thegrowthofthecompanyinthehaircareproductclassisaresultofthesmallsales
baseofthecompanyineachoftheshampoosandconditionerscategory.
The marketer reformulates its hair care collection with new formulations for its
shampoos and conditioners, making it more naturallyenriched, free of sulfates, and
replacingsyntheticfragranceswithnaturalones.
Thenewshampoosandconditionerscontainmildercleaningagentsorsurfactants,and
addedaminoacidsandjojobaproteintofortifyandprovidelightmoisturizationtothe
hair.
In 2012, the marketer discontinues its Color Keeper Shampoo and Conditioner and
claimsitsnewlyformulatedshampoosandconditionerstobegentleoncoloredhair.
Additionally, this new hair collection is now available inrecyclable bottles (80% post
consumerrecycledcontent).

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

769

570

TheCloroxCompany

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

In January 2012, Burt's Bees officially launchesa new natural brand, Gd, under different
categories, including shampoos, conditioners, body washes, body butter, body lotion, and
handwashes.
SalesofthenewbrandcommencedonlineinDecember2011.
ItisaimedatayoungerdemographicthanitsflagshipbrandBurtsBees.

Alsoin2012,BurtsBeesentersintoalicensingagreementwithAyablu,achildrensproduct
designcompany.
Currently, Burts Bees range of baby care products include body washes, bar soaps,
moisturizers, ointments and care, and sun care products. This move sees the brands
expansion into multiple categories including home and lifestyle. The line debuts with
newbornproductsthatincludeapparel,accessories,bathlinens,andgiftsets.
The company debuts this range of products through select Target stores and the
retailerswebsite,target.com.During2012,thecompanygraduallyexpandeditsrange
ofproductstobeavailableatbuybuybabyretailoutletsandBabiesRUs.com.BurtsBees
hasalsolaunchedaportaldedicatedtoitsnewlineofproductsatburtsbeesbaby.com.

Burts Beespartners with Preserve,a sustainable consumer goods company, to develop a


recyclable solution for its Burts Bees Lip Balm, Tinted Lip Balm, Lip Shimmer Tubes, and
BurtsBeesplasticcaps.
Thepartnershipisaimedatdivertingplasticfromlandfillsinordertoprovidematerial
todeveloppackagingfornewproducts,suchasPreservetoothbrushesandrazors.

Newproducts

Table545:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbytheCloroxCompanyintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

BurtsBees

Facialtreatments

IntenseHydrationisanewlinecomposedofCreamClenser,DayCream,NightCream,
TreatmentMask,andEyeCreamdevelopedtoprovideintensehydration.ClarySage,a
botanicalthatsurvivesinharshenvironmentsduetoitsabilitytoretainmoistureis
theinspirationbehindtheline

BurtsBees

Lipbalms,jellies,
andtreatments

BurtsBeesintroducesUltraMoisturizingLipTreatmentwithKokumButter,which
helpssootheandrestorelips.ThebrandaddsthreenewshadestoitsLipShimmer
collection:cherry,plum,andstrawberry

BurtsBees

Shampoos

BabyBeeshampoocontainsnaturalplantbasedcleansingcomplexincombination
withsweetorangeandlemonoilstocreateanourishingformulathatleavesthe
babyshairandskinsilkysoft

Gd

Personalcleansing
products

NaturalBodyWashcleansestheskinandisavailableinfivefragrances:RedRuby
Groovy,PearnormalActivity,OrangePetalaooza,FloralCherrynova,andVanillaFlame

Gd

Handandbody
lotions

NaturalBodyLotionhydratestheskinandgetsabsorbedquickly,hasnoparabens,
phthalates,orpetrochemicals.Itisavailableinfivefragrances:RedRubyGroovy,
PearnormalActivity,OrangePetalaooza,FloralCherrynova,andVanillaFlame

Gd

Handandbody
lotions

NaturalBodyButtermoisturizesandsoftenstheskin.Itisavailablethesame
fragrancesastheNaturalBodyLotionandNaturalBodyWash,excepttheRedRuby
Groovy

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A70

TheCloroxCompany

MARKETINGACTIVITY

TheCloroxCompanystraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)advancesto$9.5millionin2012,
up58.3%from$6.0millionin2011.
Magazineadvertisingisthemostpreferredmarketingmediaadoptedbythecompany.
Thecompanyspends$7.9millionin2012,up36.2%from$5.8millionin2011.
BurtsBeesreceivesaTMEallocationof$9million,whileGdreceivesaTMEallocation
of$500,000in2012.

The Clorox Company heavily depends on social media networks, such as Facebook and
Twitter(@gudhappens),topromoteitsproductsinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket.
Burts Bees promotes its Gd line of products with 90 seconds of scratchandsniff
animatedvideoonitsFacebookpage.
The company distributes approximately 2.6 million scratchandsniff cards to
consumersthatdirectthemtothevideoonFacebook.
BurtsBeesFacebookfanbasetouches1millionin2012,upsignificantlyfrom560,000
in2011.

Themarketerstrategicallyblendsnewmediawithestablishedtraditionalmarketingmedia
suchasprintandtelevisionadvertising.
To promote its Intense Hydration line of products, Burts Bees uses an interactive
billboardonabusystreetinMinneapolisthatshowsawomansfacewithdryskinthat
is made up of thousands of product coupons. The dry skin flakes or the coupons are
peeledbypassersbytorevealhydratedskinonthemodelsfaceonthebillboard.

BurtsBeesenjoysthereputationofbeingrecognizedasasustainablecompany.
Thecompanysreputationofbeingasustainablecompanynotonlycomesfromitsuse
of natural ingredients in its products but also its waste reduction strategies and
employeeeducationprogram.
Burts Bees campaign in 2012, Wild For Bees, expresses its concern over the Colony
Collapse Disorder (CCD) or the disappearance of bees. The campaign educates
consumers on the importance of bees for pollination by introducing a series of
educationalvideosabouttherolesofdifferentbees.Thecampaignendswiththebrand
askingtheconsumerstogetinvolvedinthecampaignandhelpsavethebees.
The Clorox Company has successfully allowed Burts Bees continue to operate as an
independentsubsidiaryandmaintainsitsprincipleofsustainabilythattheBurtsBees
foundersinstilled.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

771

572

TheCloroxCompany

Thecompanypromotesitsproductsthroughcashcouponsandgiveaways.
TopromoteitsnewIntenseHydrationrangeofproducts,themarketeroffersa$3.00
discountonanyofthefiveproductsintherange.
In 2012, the brand urges its consumers to visit diaper.com to enter a giveaway that
gives three winners a chance to win $100.00 worth of Burts Bees assorted products
includingthoseforMomandBaby.
Alsoin2012,thecompanyinitiatesBurtsBeeslipbalmnaturalchampioncontest,in
whichpeopleenterthecontestbypostingaphotoofthemwiththebrandslipbalm.
Thewinnerreceivesathreedaytripincludingairfare,hotel,andgroundtransportation
to Burts Bees Headquarters in Durham, private concert tickets, four $150.00 spa
vouchers,and$500.00ofBurtsBeesproducts.

ThecompanyusesamarketingstrategydifferentfromtheBurtsBeesbrandtointroduce
itsGdlineofproducts.
The company adopts the scratchandsniff strategy wherein consumers can use the
scentcardtosmelltheproductsfragrances.Thesescentcardsaredistributedthrough
magazinessuchasAllureandLucky.
Additionally, the marketer takes the help of guerrilla street teams to give out
handoutsatsixuniversities.
The company gives a fun image to its Gd brand with youthfriendly names such as
OrangePetalooza,FloralCherryNova,andVanillaFlame.
TheGdbrandisadvertisedwiththetagline:Wherevergdgoes,gdhappens.

OUTLOOK

TheCloroxCompanyisforecasttogrowataCAGRof4.0%duringtheforecastperiod,2012
to2017.
Thecompanywillcontinuetointroducenewandinnovativeproductsoverthenextfive
years.
Burts Bees will continue to enjoy its natural positioning in the market place and
maintain its core values that it had before its acquisition by The Clorox Company.
However, the acquisition benefits the brand with a large advertising expenditure
allocationandawidedistributionnetwork.
ThelaunchoftheGdbrandislikelytoexpandthecompanystargetdemographyand
increasethesalesofthecompanyspersonalcaresegmentintheforecastperiod.

BurtsBeeslineofhaircareandbabycareproductsareexpectedtobethestarperformers
duringtheforecastperiod.
TherepositioningoftheBurtsBeeshaircarelineofproductswithconsumerfriendly
formulas and a new packaging in 2012 helps spur sales of the stagnating line of
products.
Thehaircarelineofproductsisexpectedtogatherfurthersalesintheforecastperiod.
Furthermore,theBurtsBeeslineofbabyproductsareexpectedtogathermomentum
duringtheforecastperiodafterthebrandentersalicensingagreementwithAyablu.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A72

TheCloroxCompany

In the lip balms, jellies, and treatments category, Burts Bees will continue to induce
consumerinterestinthecategoryduetoitsnaturalpositioning.
Thecompanywillcontinuetoinnovateinthecategorybyintroducinglipproductsthat
provide lip plumping, antioxidant, and sun protection benefits apart from solely
moisturizingthelips.
Thecompanywillcontinuetobuilduponthesuccessofitslineoftintedlipbalmswith
theintroductionofnewshades.
Innovationinpackagingdesignsisalsolikelytohaveapositiveimpactonthebrands
salesduetoitsfreshpositioninginthemarket.

Inthepersonalcleansingproductscategory,thecompanyisexpectedtogrowataCAGRof
2.6%throughtheforecastperiodending2017.
ThecompanywilldependonitsgrowingBurtsBeesanditsnewlylaunchedGdbrand
forsuccessinthecategory.
Burts Bees naturally formulated body washes, bar soaps, and bath salts will drive
growthforthebrand.
Ontheotherhand,Gdsfreshlyfragrancedlineofproductswilldrivegrowthforthe
brandwiththeadditionofvariantsandthepossibilityofventuringintobarsoapsand
otherpersonalcleansingsegmentsduringthecourseofthenextfiveyears.

Inanattempttocompetewithothermassmarketers,thecompanyisexpectedtointroduce
multibeneficialskincareproductsunderitsBurtsBeesbrandwhichwillprovidebenefits
additionaltobasicmoisturizationandnourishing,suchasprovidingantiagingbenefits,
acneprevention,suncarebenefits,andanevenskintone.

The ongoing preference among consumers for the increased use of natural products will
likely attract more consumers towards the Burts Bees brand and increase sales for the
companyduringtheforecastperiod.

The company is progressively increasing its advertising expenditures and is likely to


continuethetrendthroughtheforecastperiod.
TheCloroxCompanyhasrecentlyenteredintothetraditionalmediaofadvertisingsuch
as television and print advertisements for its Burts Bees brand and will continue to
emphasizeitseffortsonthemediumduringtheforecastperiod.
Social media will remain an important and integral part of the companys marketing
strategytopromoteitspersonalcarebrands.ThecompanysFacebookpageallowsit
tointeractwithitsconsumersandbuildamorepersonalrelationship.
Thecompanyisalsolikelytoexpanditsfocusondigitalmarketinginthefuture.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

773

574

TheCloroxCompany

The Clorox Company will continue its partnerships and affiliations with organizations to
achievesustainability.
Cloroxincreasesitsleveloftransparencybymovingtowardsintegratedreportingand
expanding its Ingredients Inside Program which discloses the list of ingredients
containedinitscleaninganddisinfectantproductsintheUnitedStatesandCanada.
These initiatives are important for Burts Bees to maintain its image as a naturally
positionedbrand.

ThecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof4.0%from
$172millionin2012to$209millionin2017.

Table:546:ForecastDollarSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesfortheClorox
CompanybyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Shampoos

9.9

Babycareproducts

9.2

Conditioners

8.4

Facialtreatments

5.0

COMPANYAVERAGE

4.0

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

3.2

Personalcleansingproducts

2.6

Handandbodylotions

2.5

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A74

COLGATEPALMOLIVE

Table547:ColgatePalmolivesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

569

605

46

48

622

659

Softsoapliquidsoaps

209

215

IrishSpringbarsoaps

106

110

Softsoapbodywashes

87

89

IrishSpringbodywashesr

35

33

Palmolivebarsoapsr

12

TomsofMaine

448

464

139

152

27

28

166

180

SpeedStick

97

96

LadySpeedStick

53

51

TomsofMaine

21

22

174

172

12

12

TOOTHPASTES
Colgate
TomsofMaine
Ultrabrite
Total
PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

Totalr
TOOTHBRUSHES
Colgate
Colgate(batteryoperated)
Total
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

TeenSpirit
Total
MOUTHWASHES
TomsofMaine
Viadent

(Continued)

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

576

ColgatePalmolive

Table547:ColgatePalmolivesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

Category/brand
MOUTHWASHES(Continued)
Fluorigard
Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN
SkinBracer
Afta
Total
TOTALr

rRestated.

$Million
2011
2012

15
12
4
2
6
1,431

4
2
6
1,493

COMPANYOVERVIEW

ColgatePalmoliveCompany,foundedin1806,togetherwithitssubsidiariesmanufacturesand
marketsconsumerproductsworldwide.
Its product range consists of oral care products, including toothpaste, toothbrushes, and
mouthrinses,aswellaspersonalcleansing,deodorant,andpharmaceuticalproducts.
Thecompanyalsomanufacturesandmarketspetnutritionproductsunderthebrandname
Hills.
AsofDecember31,2012,thecompanyemploysabout37,700peopleworldwideanddoes
businessinmorethan200countries.

ThecompanyhasitsheadquartersandcorporateofficeatParkAvenue,NewYorkCity,NY.The
three manufacturing facilities in the domestic market are located in Morristown, NJ;
Morristown,TN;andCambridge,OH.
Internationally, the company operates approximately 280 properties, of which 76 are
companyowned, in more than 70 countries. Major overseas facilities are located in
Australia,Brazil,China,Colombia,France,Italy,Mexico,Poland,SouthAfrica,Thailand,and
Venezuela.

The companys business is managed in two product segments: Oral, Personal, and Household
care;andPetNutrition.
The Oral, Personal, and Household care segment offers products such as toothpastes,
toothbrushes,oralrinses,dentalfloss,andpharmaceuticalproductsfordentistsandother
oralhealthprofessionals.Thesegmentalsomarketspersonalcareproductssuchasshower
gels, shampoos, conditioners, bar soaps, deodorants and antiperspirants, and liquid hand
soaps. The household cleaning products include dish washing liquids, household cleaners,
oilsoaps,andfabricconditioners.
ThePetNutritionsegmentproducesproductsfordogsandcats.

In2012,thecompanyinvestsatotalof$259millioninresearchanddevelopment,down1.1%
from$262millionin2011.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-76

ColgatePalmolive

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

ColgatePalmolives total sales are up by 2.1% from $16,734million in 2011 to


$17,085millionin2012.

Thecompanysnetprofitsgrow1.7%,from$2,431millionto$2,472millionin2012.

Since2007,thecompanyssaleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of4.4%,whilenetprofitshavegrownataCAGRof7.3%.

Table548:ColgatePalmolivesGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
Netprofits
13,789.7
1,737.4
15,329.9
1,957.2
15,327.0
2,291.0
15,564.0
2,203.0
16,734.0
2,431.0
17,085.0
2,472.0

%
Marginonsales
12.6
12.8
14.9
14.2
14.5
14.5

Returnonequity
76.0
101.8
70.3
77.8
95.6
103.4

Table549:ColgatePalmolivesGlobalSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011
and2012

Segment
Oral,personal,andhouseholdcare
Petnutrition
Total

%Ofsales
2011
2012
87.0
87.4
13.0
12.6
100.0
100.0

Oralcarecontinuestobethelargestproductclassforthecompany,with44%shareduring
2012,upfrom43%in2011.

Table550:ColgatePalmolivesGlobalCorporateSales
byProductClass,2011and2012

Productclass
Oralcare
Homecare
Personalcare
Petnutrition
Total

%Oftotal
2011
43
22
22
13
100

2012
44
21
22
13
100

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

577

578

ColgatePalmolive

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

In 2012, the U.S. sales of ColgatePalmolives cosmetics and toiletries grow from
$1,431millionin2011to$1,493million,upby4.3%.

Since2007,saleshaveincreasedataCAGRof1.6%.

Table551:ManufacturersSalesforColgatePalmolive,
2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,382

2008

1,446

4.6

2009

1,448

0.1

2010

1,420

(1.9)

2011

1,431

0.8

2012

1,493

4.3

ToothpastesremainsColgatePalmoliveslargestcategoryintheoralcareproductsclass.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolive overtakes Procter& Gamble for the leadership position in
the toothpastes category with 37.7% share, based on the strong performance of the
ColgateOpticWhitebrand.
ColgatePalmolivecontinuestoexperiencestrongsalesgains.
In 2012, ColgatePalmolives sales increase by 5.9%, up from $622million in 2011 to
$659millionin2012.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfrom36.2%in2011to37.7%in2012.
ThestronggrowthofthemarketerisprimarilysupportedbythesuccessoftheColgate
OpticWhitebrandin2012.
Newproductintroductions,suchasColgateOpticEnamelWhitewithformulationsfor
whiteningandsensitiveteeth,boostthecompanysperformancein2012.
Colgateistheleadingbrandforthecompanyinthecategory,withsalesof$605million
in2012,up6.3%from$569millionin2011.
The company offers three brands in the category: Colgate, Toms of Maine, and
Ultrabrite.
The whitening toothpaste trend helps the brand grow its sales in 2012 and helps
strengthenColgatePalmolivespositioninthetoothpastescategory.
Toms of Maine, the brand the company purchased in 2006, experiences continued
growthduring2012,attributedtothenaturalbasedactiveingredientsinitstoothpastes.
SalesofUltrabritedeclinesto$6millionin2012from$7millionin2011.
Limited new product activity and promotional support contributes to the decline of
Ultrabritebrandinthetoothpastescategoryin2012.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-78

ColgatePalmolive

PersonalcleansingproductsisColgatePalmolivessecondlargestcategorywithasalestotal
of$464millionin2012,up3.6%from$448millionin2011.
Thecompanydominates11.5%oftotalcategorysalesin2012,downfrom12.0%oftotal
categorysalesin2011.Itisthesecondleadingmarketerinthecategory.
Themarketercompetesintheliquidsoaps,barsoaps,andbodywashessegments.
The marketer is represented in the category with its Softsoap, Irish Spring, Palmolive,
andTomsofMainebrands.
ColgatePalmoliveistheleadingmarketerintheliquidsoapssegmentandfourthlargest
marketerinthebodywashesandbarsoapssegmentsduring2012.
Theliquidsoapssegmentrepresents46.3%ofthetotalmarketerssalesinthepersonal
cleansingproductscategoryin2012.Salesofthemarketerinthesegmentincrease2.9%
from$209millionin2011to$215millionin2012.
Growthofthemarketerisdrivenbynewproductintroductionsandgoodperformance
intheliquidsoapssegmentin2012.
The bar soaps segment of the marketer witnesses the highest growth in sales during
2012.Salesadvance8.5%to$127millionin2012,upfrom$117millionin2011.
Salesofthemarketerinthebodywashessegmentremainstableat$122millionin2012,
flatfrom2011levels.

Deodorants and antiperspirants sales decline by 1.1% in 2012 to $172million from


$174millionin2011.
ThecategoryisthefourthlargestforColgatePalmolive.Thecompanyaccountsfor8.4%
of the total deodorant category sales in 2012, down from 8.7% of the total category
salesin2011.
ColgatePalmoliveisrepresentedinthecategorybySpeedStick,LadySpeedStick,Toms
ofMaine,andTeenSpiritbrands.
The sales of Speed Stick, the flagship brand of the marketer, decline 1.0% from
$97millionin2011to$96millionin2012.
The Speed Stick brands sales decline in spite of the launch of the new product line
SpeedStickPowerin2012.Theproductlinecontainsfourvariantsinthesolidformand
two variants in the gel form. To launch the product line, the marketer initiates the
Handle It campaign on Twitter, inviting consumers to share their uncomfortable,
funny, and embarrassing moments transformed into a YouTube video, with television
actor Danny Pudi as the narrator. Also, Danny Pudi provides consumers with some
adviceonafewofthecommonlyincurredHandleItmoments.
Thebrandfurtherlosesoutonsalesduetoalowtraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)of
$4.1millionin2012.MajorityofthebrandsTMEat$4.0millionisallocatedtowardsthe
advertisementofthenewlylaunchedSpeedStickPowerproductline.
Lady Speed Stick is the secondlargest brand for the marketer with sales down 3.8%
from$53millionin2011to$51millionin2012.Salesforthebranddeclineduetothe
absenceofnewproductactivity,negligibleTME,andincreasingcompetitionfromother
femaleorienteddeodorantsandantiperspirants.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

579

580

ColgatePalmolive

In2012,LadySpeedStickistheofficialsponsoroftheWomensHalfMarathonheldat
St.Petersburg,FL.Theeventencourageshealthandfitnessamongwomen,withmany
participantsjoiningeveryyear.
Toms of Maine, the thirdleading brand for ColgatePalmolive registers a growth of
4.8%toreach$22millionin2012,upfrom$21millionin2011.Thebrandaccountsfor
1.1%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,stagnantfrom2011.
TomsofMainesgrowthin2012isattributedtothebrandspositioninginthemarket
asaproducerofaluminumfreedeodorants,sincealuminumhasbeenlinkedtobreast
cancer,albeitinconclusively.Additionally,thebrandsexpansionintomainstreamretail
outletsaddstoitssalesin2012.However,furthergrowthofthebrandisoffsetbythe
premiumpricingofthebrandsdeodorantsandantiperspirants.
In 2012, the company introduces the Toms Of Maine Mens Long Lasting Wide Stick
DeodorantinCleanConfidenceandMountainSpringvariants,andtheTomsofMaine
NaturallyDryAntiperspirantStickintheNaturalPowderandUnscented/Fragrancefree
variants.
In2012,thebrandpartnerswithTerraCycle,anorganizationthatworkswithcompanies
towards eliminating waste, to launch the Toms of Maine Natural Care Brigade. This
programencouragesconsumerstokeeppackagingfromTomsofMaineproductsoutof
landfills.Asacontinuationofits50StatesforGoodprogram,thebrandannouncesyet
another $150,000 as a part of the project funding. The winning projects, which have
been voted for by the public, include initiatives around reforestation, environmental
danceprograms,freedentalcare,andafriendshipnetwork.

ToothbrushesisthefourthlargestcategoryforColgatePalmolive.
Thecompanyssalesincrease8.4%to$180millionin2012from$166millionin2011.
ColgatePalmolivesmarketsharealsoincreasesfrom22.9%in2011to24.3%in2012.
Growth is seen primarily in manual toothbrushes which gain slightly in market share,
from19.2%in2011to20.5%in2012.
Themarketerlaunchestoothbrusheswithmultibenefitssuchasplaqueremoval,breath
freshening, and gum massage that support its growth in the manual toothbrushes
segment.
Salesofitsbatteryoperatedtoothbrushesalsogrowby3.7%,from$27millionin2011
to$28millionin2012.
The success of ColgatePalmolives Optic White range of oral care products, which
includestoothbrushes,contributesdirectlytothecompanysgrowth.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Managementchanges

TherearenonotablechangesinColgatePalmolivesmanagementin2012.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-80

ColgatePalmolive

Otherdevelopments

InAugust2012,Procter&Gamble filesacomplaintagainstColgatePalmolivetotheNAD
(NationalAdvertisingDivision)intheUnitedStatesregardingtheusageofcertainclaimsfor
itsOpticWhiterangeoforalcareproducts.

The NAD has ordered ColgatePalmolive to stop advertising some claims for its whitening
toothpastesincludingSamewhiteningingredientasstrips.

In September 2012, ColgatePalmolive announces that its agency partners Y&R, MEC,
VML,WundermanandGHGarejoiningforcestocreateasingleoperatingunittoengage
withconsumersinrealtimeacrossalltouchpointsandtodriveefficiencies.

In October 2012, ColgatePalmolive and Omron Healthcare enter a broad cooperation


agreementtomarketanddeveloporalcareproductsincludingelectrictoothbrushes.

Newproducts

Table552:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyColgatePalmoliveintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Colgate

Toothpastes

ColgateMaxFreshCoolCrystalsMinttoothpasteisafluoride
toothpastethathelpstofreshenbreath,fightcavity,andwhiten
teeth

Colgate

Toothpastes

ColgateOpticEnamelWhitetoothpastecontainsthesamewhitening
ingredientaswhiteningstripsforwhiterteethinoneweekand
fortifiesenamelforstrongwhiteteeth

Colgate

Toothpastes

ColgateMaxFreshNightToothpastecontainszincwhichhelps
preventgermbuildupatnight

Colgate

Toothbrushes

ColgateMaxFreshtoothbrush,withitsmultiheight,multiangle
bristlespenetratedeeplybetweentheteethtoblastawayplaque

Colgate

Toothpastes

ColgateMaxwithMouthwashBeadsTinglingMinttoothpastehas
dissolvableminimouthwashbeadsthatcleansthemouth,helpsfight
germs,andpreventscavities

Colgate

Toothpastes

ColgateMaxWhiteLiquidToothpasteprotectsagainstcavities.The
toothpastehassodiumfluorideastheactiveingredient

Colgate

Toothbrushes

ColgateMaxWhitetoothbrushgentlyremovesstainswithitsunique
polishingstarandspeciallydesignedbristles

Colgate360

Toothbrushes

Colgate360WholeMouthCleantoothbrush,withmorebacteria
removingnubs,removesover96%morebacteria

(Continued)

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

581

582

ColgatePalmolive

Table552:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyColgatePalmoliveintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Colgate360Optic
White

Toothbrushes

Colgate360OpticWhitePowertoothbrushpolishesawaysurface
stainsandcleanshardtoreachplaces

ColgateOpticWhite

Toothbrushes

ColgateWispOpticWhitetoothbrushcontainsbothwhiteningcups
andpolishingbristles

Toothpastes

BotanicallyBrightwhiteningtoothpasteissodiumlaurylsulfatefree
andfluoridefreetoothpastewhichisformulatedwithablendof
botanicalsthathelptowhitenteethnaturally.Itisavailableintwo
flavors:Spearmintwithaloeandchamomile,andpeppermintwith
xylitolandpropolis

TomsofMaine

MARKETINGACTIVITY

ColgatePalmolive primarily promotes its products through TPRs (temporary price


reductions),displaysinstore,andbroadcastadvertising.
Themarketersupportsitsproductswithdiscountcoupons.
ColgatePalmolive offers discount coupons ranging between $1.00 and $3.00 on its
websiteandmagazines.

ColgatePalmolivehasTMEsof$110.4millionin2012,up35.1%from$81.7millionin2012.
Approximately$104.3millionor94.5%ofthetotalTMEisallocatedtothetoothpastes
categoryin2012.
Colgates whitening toothpastes receive onehalf of TME in 2012, with a total of
$55.8millionspent.

Broadcast media is ColgatePalmolives preferred medium of advertising to promote its


products.
ColgatePalmoliveusesprintadvertisementsextensively.
Print advertisements for mouthwashes increasingly differentiate products based upon
theabilitytodeliveraddedbenefits.
ColgatePalmolivesbrandTomsofMaineadvertisesitsmouthwasheswiththetagline
stopsbadbreathwithouttheburn.

ColgatePalmolive is the largest advertiser in the toothpastes category, with total TME of
morethan$104.3millionin2012.
ColgatePalmoliveswhiteningbrandsreceiveonehalfofTMEsin2012,withatotalof
$56.6millionspent.
ThemarketerspendsaboutonethirdofitsTMEtosupportitsOpticWhitebrand.
ColgatePalmolivedemonstratesmethodstocombinedigitalandoutdooradvertisingto
maximize impact with its Smile campaign. ColgatePalmolive uses a dedicated
Facebookpagewhereusersareencouragedtouploadpicturesofthemsmiling.These
arethenturnedintolargecollageposterswhichcanbeseeninsupermarkets,shopping
malls,andotherpointofsalelocations.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-82

ColgatePalmolive

ColgatePalmolivealsoprovidesvariousapplicationsthatcanbedownloadedonmobile
phones, including Colgate Smile Capsule, Colgate Smile Sign, and MaxWhite iPhone
Application.
Colgate Optic White toothpaste and toothbrushes are supported by an integrated
marketingcampaign,includingbothdirectinstoreandoutofstoresupport.

ColgatePalmolivepromotesitsproductsthroughvariouscelebritycampaigns.
InFebruary2013,talkshowhostKellyRipasignsonasColgateTotalsspokespersonfor
itsYouCanDoItCampaign.Asapartofthecampaign,KellyRipafeaturesinvarious
television advertisements encouraging consumers to discover the importance of oral
hygieneandhealthymouth.
ColgatePalmolive partners with Jeannie Mai, fashion expert, actress, and television
personality,topromoteitsOpticWhitebrandwiththetaglineGettheperfectsmile.
InNovember2012,ColgatePalmoliveteamsupwiththepopmusicbandOneDirection
tolaunchtheneworalcareline.Aspartofthecompanysrecentcollaboration,Colgate
Palmolive features the band on its products in the United States, to encourage young
peopletotakecareoftheirteeth.

Thecompanyutilizesonlinepromotionsasanimportanttool.
Inthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory,ColgatePalmoliveusestheInternetto
launchitsnewproductsasmostofthemareaimedatyoungcustomers.
The companys website offers the SmileTalk enewsletter for consumers, and also a
varietyofbothfunandeducationalfeaturessuchasSmileSign,whichallowsconsumers
tolearnwhattheirsmilesaysaboutthem.
The company also offers discount coupons to its SmileTalk members. The company
offers discount coupons ranging between $0.75 and $2.00 off on its products to its
SmileTalkmembers.

Consumers can sign up for newsletters on the Toms of Maine website in order to get
updatesonnewproductlaunchesandotherpromotionaloffers.

OUTLOOK

ColgatePalmoliveisforecasttogrowatamoderatepaceof1.5%overthenextfiveyears
2012to2017.
Toothpastesandtoothbrushescategoriesareexpectedtoshowpromisinggrowthover
theforecastperiodsupportedbyproductinnovations.
ColgatePalmolive is expected to generate moderate growth over the next five years,
mainlysupportedbythemarketersleadershipbrandsinthepersonalcaremarket.
The company will continue to gain sales through new product launches and product
innovationsduringtheforecastperiod.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

583

584

ColgatePalmolive

Toothpastes are expected to be the largest revenue generator for the company over the
forecastperiod.
Themarketerisexpectedtomaintainitsleadershippositioninthetoothpastescategory,
supportedbynewproductlauncheswithmultiplebenefitsandenhancedefficiency.
ColgatePalmolive is expected to launch products for specific oral care problems
includingsensitiveteeth,protectionagainstplaque,anddrymouth.
The marketer will also benefit from its global brand names and its international
presence,whichwillhelpincreaseitsprofitabilityandshareholdervalue.
ColgatePalmolivewillcontinuetolaunchstarbrandssuchasOpticWhitetosupportits
leadershippositioninthecategoryandtoincreaseitsmarketshare.

Thepersonalcleansingproductscategoryisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof1.5%over
theforecastperiod.
ColgatePalmoliveisexpectedtolaunchnewproductsacrossvarioussegmentsincluding
bodywashes,barsoaps,andliquidsoapstosupportitssalesinthecategory.
Themarketerwilllikelylooktoinnovatewithitsproductsbyofferingadditionalbenefits
inadditiontotheregularcleansing.Addedbenefitstothepersonalcleansingproducts
could be in the form of moisturizing, exfoliating, antiaging, odor protection, and
additionofvitamins.
ColgatePalmolivewillcontinuetomakeeffortstodifferentiateitsproductsfromothers
availableinthemarketsoastoprovideexclusivity.

Thetoothbrushescategoryisexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
ColgatePalmoliveisexpectedtointroduceproductswithbettertechnologyandlower
pricestosupportitssalesinthecategory.
Themarketerwillcontinuetolaunchnewandcreativeproductswithmultiplebenefits,
such as plaque removal, breath freshening, or gum massage to keep pace with the
growthinconsumerdemandandexpectations.
ColgatePalmolivewillalsooffertoothbrushesthataredesignedforspecificproblems,
includinggummassage,plaqueremoval,anddeepcleaning.
Theintroductionofcomparablypricedbatteryoperatedtoothbrushesbyprivatelabelis
expected to wane down the sales prospect of ColgatePalmolives batteryoperated
toothbrushesandwilloffsetitsgrowthprospect.

ColgatePalmolive will continue to invest in advertising and special promotions, thereby


remindingconsumersoftheimportanceofmaintaininggoodoralhealth.
The marketer is expected to increase its marketing activity to support its overall sales
overtheforecastperiod.
ColgatePalmoliveisexpectedtoofferdiscountcouponstoattractconsumersandsafe
guarditsmarketshare.
Thecompanywillcontinuetoutilizeinnovativetools,suchassocialwebsitesandother
toolsoftheInternet,tocommunicatewithconsumersmoreeffectivelyandefficiently.
The marketer is likely to indulge in deploying marketing campaigns to keep the
consumersengagedandpromoteitsproducts.
ColgatePalmolive is likely to support its new product introductions with high TME to
ensurevisibilityofitsproductsinthemarket.

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-84

ColgatePalmolive

In order to differentiate its products from the others available in the market, the
marketer isexpected to launch creative and innovative marketing strategies to gather
consumersattentiontherebyhelpingthecompanysgrowth.
Brand loyalty for the companys leading brands is expected to improve and further
augmentthemarketerspositioninthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
The company will focus on increasing its instore promotional activities to support its
salesinthecategoryovertheforecastperiod.

ColgatePalmoliveisexpectedtoincreaseitsspendingoninnovationandresearcheffortsto
introduceinnovativeproductsacrossitsproductcategories.
Innovations in terms of product portfolio, packaging, design, consumer feedback, and
instore activities, which build consumer awareness, will help the company achieve
highersales.
Themarketerwillalsostriveforinnovationtoreduceproductivitycosts,driveefficient
performancelevels,andthisislikelytobeakeytothecompanysoverallsalesgrowth.
ColgatePalmolive is expected to introduce innovative products with the help of the
latest scientific advances, consumer insights, and clinical trials, and will bring
improvementwhereverpossibleacrosstheorganization.
ThenewinnovationswillalsohelptodifferentiateColgatePalmolivesbrandsfromthe
competition.

ColgatePalmolivewillcontinuetofocusonnaturallypositionedproducts.
ColgatePalmolivesTomsofMainebrandisforecasttoexperiencesalesgrowthin2012
asthebrandgainsbyitsnaturalpositioning.
This brand shows progress from 2011 and may continue to support the companys
overallgrowth.

SalesinsmallermarketsforColgatePalmolive,suchasmensfragrancesandmouthwashes,
willcontinuetostagnateduetolackofpromotionalsupport.

SalesforColgatePalmoliveforthenextfiveyearsareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof1.5%
andreach$1,608millionby2017,upfrom$1,493millionin2012.

Table553:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforColgatePalmolivebyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Toothbrushes

2.2

Toothpastes

2.0

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.5

Personalcleansingproducts

1.5

Mouthwashes

0.5

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

0.3

Fragrancesformen

0.2

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

585

586

ColgatePalmolive

REPRODUCTION OR DISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN; SEE SPECIAL NOTICE KLINE & COMPANY, INC.

4A-86

COMBE

Table554:CombesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

110

115

118

122

20

20

154

157

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
JustforMen
GrecianFormula
Total
DENTUREPRODUCTS
SeaBond
SHAVINGPRODUCTS
LectricShave
HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS
Brylcreem
FRAGRANCESFORMEN
AquaVelva
TOTAL

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Combe Inc. is a manufacturer and marketer of OTC pharmaceuticals and personal care
products,particularlymensgroomingproducts.
The familyowned company was founded in 1949 by Ivan D. Combe and is
headquarteredinWhitePlains,NY.
IvanD.CombecreatedClearasilacnemedicationin1951andsoldittoVickChemicalin
1960.
The companys product portfolio includes antiitch, oral care, feminine hygiene, and
mensgroomingproducts.
JustforMenHairColorwasintroducedin1987andisthefirstinstantfullcoveragehair
colorformen.
Itsproductsaresoldin83countries,acrosssixcontinents.
ThecompanymaintainsitsmanufacturingfacilitiesinIllinoisandPuertoRico.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

588

Combe

Thecompanysbrandportfoliofeatures:
MenshaircolorbrandsincludingJustforMen,GrecianFormula,andGrecian5.
OtherproductsincludehairstylingbrandBrylcreem.
TheaftershavebrandAquaVelvaandshavingproductLectricShavearealsomarketed
bythecompany.
SeaBonddentureadhesivesaremarketedinthedenturecarecategory.
Vagisilisthemainbrandofthefemininecarebusiness.

TheBrylcreembrandismarketedbyCombeintheUnitedStates.
In2011,UnilevercompletedthebuyoutofthebrandfromSaraLee,whomarketsthe
brandoverseas.

Combesolditscough/cold,skincare,andfootcarebusinessesin2011.
Under the Foot Care business of Combe, the OdorEaters brand is divested to Blistex
Inc.
The Cough/Cold and Skin Care businesses, consisting of Cepacol, Lanacane, Scalpicin,
LiceMD,andHemoalbrands,aresoldtoReckittBenckiserInc.
ThereasonforthesedivestituresisforCombetoincreaseitsfocusonitsglobalbrands.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Combeisaprivatelyheldcompanyanddoesnotreleasedetailedfinancialdata.
Therefore,onlyestimatesofsalesandprofitsareprovidedforthecompany.

Thecompanyssalesareestimatedat$220millionasof2012,withthebrandJustforMen
accountingforabout52.3%ofcompanystotalsales.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

ThecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesintheUnitedStatesin2012postagrowthof
1.9%toreach$157millionin2012,upfrom$154millionin2011.
Saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.3%since2007.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A88

Combe

589

Table555:CombesCosmeticsandToiletriesSalesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
140
146
146
143
154
157

Change,%

4.3

(2.1)
7.7
1.9

Hair coloring products is the largest category for Combe, contributing 77.7% of the
companystotalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin2012.
Themarketerpostsagrowthof3.4%from$118millionin2011to$122millionin2012.
Combeistheleadingmenshaircoloringmarketer,offeringproductlinesunderitsJust
forMenandGrecianbrands.
TheintroductionofJustforMenAutostoplinesupportsthegrowthofthemarketerin
2012, with the marketer allocating approximately $22.1million in traceable media
expenditure(TME)forthebrand.
TheJustforMenbrandhassolidbrandequityandiswellpositionedinthemarketplace.
TheJustforMenbrandcomprisesJustforMenHaircolor,Mustache&BeardJustfor
Men,JustforMenAutostop,andJustforMenTouchofGray.
GrecianFormulaisagradualhaircolortreatmentforgrayhairthatrequiresapplication
everydayforthefirsttwoweekstogiveresultsinthreeweeks.Theproductisavailable
inthreeeasytouseforms:GrecianLiquid,GrecianCream,andGrecianPlus.
Combeoccupiesamarketshareof9.3%inthehaircoloringcategoryin2012,upfrom
8.9%in2011.

The denture products category is the secondlargest category for Combe, accounting for
12.7%shareofthemarketerssales.
The sales of the marketer in the category are flat at $20million in 2012, same as its
2011levels.
Combeisthefourthleadingmarketerinthedentureproductscategory,accountingfor
6.3%oftheoverallcategoryssalesin2012.
SeaBond is the thirdleading brand in the denture adhesives segment, representing
10.0%ofthesegmentsales.

Combes hair styling products and sprays category contributes to 3.2% of the total
cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesofthecompanyintheUnitedStatesin2012.
Thesalesofthecompanydrop16.7%from$6millionin2011to$5millionin2012.
Brylcreem has been showing a consistent drop in sales for the past four consecutive
years.
Despitebeinganestablishedbrandofmenshairstylingproducts,thebrandislosing
market share to younger brands that are adopting new and innovative products,
attractivepackaging,andmoreaggressivemarketingstrategies.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

590

Combe

Combesshavingproductsaccountfor3.8%ofthetotalsalesin2012.
SalesofLectricShave,themarketerssoleentrantinthecategory,remainstagnantat
$6millionin2012.

The marketers sales in the fragrances for men category remain constant at $4million in
2012,sameasits2011levels.
ThemarketersonlybrandinthemarketisAquaVelva.

ThemarketerprimarilyfocusesonitshaircoloringcategoryintheUnitedStates,whereit
hasacompetitiveadvantage,withanichecarvedoutinmenshaircoloring.
Combeaccountsformorethan85.0%ofthemenshaircoloringsegmentintheUnited
States.
As a result of its intense efforts in maintaining this edge, Combes presence in other
categoriesisnegativelyaffected.
Otherfactorsthatcontributetothesluggishsalesofthemarketerinothercategories
includelackofnewproductactivityandlackofinnovation.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

TherearenonotabledevelopmentsinCombein2012.

Newproducts

Thereislimitednewproductactivityforthemarketerin2012.

ThemarketerexpandsitsJustforMenbrandinthehaircoloringproductscategorywiththe
Autostophaircolorvariant.
Theproductisatechnologybreakthrough,involvingthedyeandthehydrogenperoxide
alreadymixedinasingletubewithascrewedoncomb.
Theeffectofthecolordoesnotgetdarkerthanitshouldirrespectiveofthetimeperiod
forwhichitiskepton.
Itcomesinareadytouseconvertibletube,colorshairin10minutes,andcomesinfive
permanentshades.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Combe spends virtually most of its media expenditure on television advertisements and
magazineadvertisements.
Thecompanyspendsapproximately$38.8millionasTMEfor2012.
Of the total TME of $38.8million in 2012, $35.9million is spent on television
advertisements,andtheremaining$2.7millionisspentonmagazinepromotions.
JustforMenconductsafewadvertisementsperyear,whileGreciandoesnothaveany
televisionadvertisements.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A90

Combe

Combealsooffersdiscountcouponstopromoteitsproducts.
Themarketerofferscouponswithdenominationsof$1.00and$2.00offonitsbrands
includingSeaBondandJustforMen.

Combe uses the Internet as one of the major sources of advertising and promoting its
brands.
The marketer uses social media sites, such as Facebook, Youtube, and Twitter, to
promoteitsproducts.
ThecompanyalsoadvertisesitsproductsonWalmartswebsite.
Themarketeralsoutilizesitsbrandswebsitesasanimportantmediumtopromoteits
products.
JustforMenbrandswebsitefeaturesadviceonhaircoloringandhelpsvisitorschoose
therightshadeofhaircolor.

Combe, which specializes in mens hair color, spends $33.1million promoting its brands
includingJustforMenandGrecianFormulain2012,up25.0%from$26.4millionin2011.
The marketer allocates almost 91.5% or $30.3million of its TME through television
advertisements.
The brand Just for Men is the main brand for the company and thus receives the
maximum TME support, with only a few thousand dollars spent on the other hair
coloringbrands.
Just for Men Autostop, launched in 2012, garners a significant share of the TME at
$22.1million.

OUTLOOK

Combessalesareprojectedtoshowamoderategrowthof1.2%duringtheforecastperiod.
Newproductlaunchesinthehaircoloringproductscategorywilllikelydrivethesales
ofCombeovertheforecastperiod.
Thecompanyplanstofocusonitsflagshipbrands,JustforMenandSeaBond,overthe
nextfiveyears.

The mens hair coloring products category will likely be the largest revenue generator for
Combeovertheforecastperiod.
The marketer is expected to revive with the launch of new products with innovative
formulations,suchasJustforMenAutostopline,whichisatechnologybreakthrough
involvingthedyeandthehydrogenperoxidebeingalreadymixedinasingletubewith
ascrewedoncomb,tosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Haircoloringproductsformencontinuestobeoneofthefastestgrowingsegmentsin
thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Menofalldemographicgroupsaretakingtheinitiativeofusingandbuyinggrooming
products,andhaircolorformenstandstogrow.
The company is taking initiatives to educate its customers about its varied product
ranges.
Itisexpectedthattheresultwouldcreatealoyalcustomerbaseandboostsalesforthe
forecastperiod.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

591

592

Combe

Themarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitsmarketingandpromotionalactivitiestosupportits
salesoverthenextfiveyears.
Thecompanyislikelytospendmoreonpromotingitsexistingproductsandsupportits
newproductintroductionsaswell.
ThemarketerwillcontinuetoallocatemajorityofitsTMEtotheJustforMenbrandin
order to maintain its position as the leading hair coloring brand for men over the
forecastperiod.

However,theshavingproductsandfragrancesformencategoriesforCombeareexpected
todeclineovertheforecastperiod.
LackofnewproductintroductionsandTMEsupportforthecategorieswillcontribute
tothedeclineovertheforecastperiod.
Moreover,themarketerisexpectedtofocusonitscorebrandsJustforMenandSea
Bondoverthenextfiveyears.

Sales are forecast to increase through 2017 at a CAGR of 1.2% to reach $167million, up
from$157millionin2012.

Table556:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforCombebyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Haircoloringproducts

2.0

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.2

Dentureproducts

0.8

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

(4.0)

Shavingproducts

(6.5)

Fragrancesformen

(11.0)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A92

COTY

Table557:CotysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

2012

Euphoria

24

23

DaisyEauSoFresh

15

15

Philosophy

15

15

DaisyMarcJacobs

13

14

14

Eternity

13

13

CKOne

11

12

HalleBerryr

12

12

JovanMuskr

12

12

PradaCandy

12

Fame

11

TruthorDare

11

CalgonBodyMists

10

Chloe

Obsession

CelineDionr

Oh,Lola!MarcJacobs

VeraWangPrincess

Lovestruck

FaithHill

Pulse

10

Heat

LoveChloe

MarkJacobsDot

HeatRush

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

594

Coty

Table557:CotysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

ForbiddenEuphoria

Lola

PradaInfusionD'Iris

Shaniar

VeraWang

Glowing

CKBeauty

CoolWaterWoman

Lovelyr

MarcJacobs

L'AirDuTemps

VanillaFields

BabyPhatGoddess

GuessbyMarciano

GlowbyJLo

LadyStetson

AntonioBanderasforWomen

WildMuskr

AdidasMovesforHer

PlayboyforHer

212CarolinaHerrera

CarolinaHerrera

Emeraude

Exclamation

GuessforWomen

L.A.M.B.

HarajukuLovers

LivebyJenniferLopez

NauticaforWomen

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A94

2012

Coty

Table557:CotysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

2012

Prada

Sand&Sable

Covet

CovetPureBloom

VanillaMusk

29

29

315

345

NAILPOLISHES

SallyHansenr

229

210

OPI/Nicoler

31

40

NYCNewYorkColor

10

10

275

264

Stetson

17

17

AdidasForMenr

15

16

EternityForMen

13

13

ObsessionforMen

12

12

EuphoriaMen

11

12

McGrawr

13

12

CoolWater

11

11

EternityAqua

10

1Million

JovanMuskForMen

PlayboyforHim

11

NauticaVoyage

EuphoriaMenIntense

PradaMen

DavidBeckhamr

Allother
Total

Rimmelr
Totalr
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

595

596

Coty

Table557:CotysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORMEN(Continued)

Encounter

GuessSeductiveHomme

ConnectedKennethColeReaction

KennethColeReaction

AntonioBanderasforMenr

PradaAmberPourHomme

KennethColeNewYorkBlack

PreferredStock

CKFree

212CarolinaHerrera

JOOP!

PradaAmberPourHommeIntense

KennethColeRSVP

Gravity

MuskForMen

Bang

MarcJacobsMen

NauticaOcean

VeraWangMen

DavidoffAdventure

15

16

195

196

Rimmelr

52

57

NYCNewYorkColorr

15

18

Totalr

67

75

Rimmel

25

26

NewYorkColorr

13

14

Allotherr
Totalr
EYEMAKEUP

FACEMAKEUP

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A96

2012

Coty

Table557:CotysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACEMAKEUP(Continued)

2012

SallyHansen

Coty

49

49

48

46

45

46

19

26

20

27

14

15

Totalr
FACIALTREATMENTS
Philosophy
DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES
SallyHansen
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Rimmelr
SallyHansen/Naturistics/NYCr
Totalr
PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Philosophy
Adidasbodywashes
Total
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Philosophy
SallyHansen
Total
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS
Adidas

20

21

10

11

11

12

TOTALr
1,048
1,086

rRestated.

NOTE:"Allother"includessalesofsmallerbrandsthatthecompanyowns.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Foundedin1904inParis,CotyInc.isaleadingmanufacturerofglobalmassmarketaswell
asprestigefragrancesformenandwomen.
ThecompanysheadquartersarelocatedinNewYork,NY.
The company is an operational subsidiary of the German holding company, Joh. A.
Benckiser.
InJune2012,Cotyfilestotakethecompanypublic.
Theglobalemployeecountattheendoffiscalyear2012isabout12,000.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

597

598

Coty

Coty specializes in the production of fragrances, skin care products, other toiletries,
andmakeup.
ThecompanyhassixresearchanddevelopmentfacilitiessituatedintheUnitedStates,
Europe,andChina.
ItalsohasmanufacturingsitesintheUnitedStates,France,theUnitedKingdom,Spain,
andChina.
Cotyhasoperationsin30countries,anditsproductsaresoldinmorethan90markets
worldwide.
Thecompanyhasadopteddistributionchannelsstrategicallytocomplementtheimage
ofitsproductsandbrands.
Itsdistributionpartnersincludeupscaledepartmentstores,specialtyretailers,upscale
perfumeries,pharmacies,massmarketretailers,anddutyfreeshopsatairports.

Thecompanysbrandsarecategorizedintotwomainclasses:
CotyBeauty,aunitofCotyInc.,wasformedin2007inordertomakeasingleplatform
combiningthemassmarketbusinessesoftheAmericas,Europe,andAsia.
The company markets leading mass brands, including Adidas, Aspen, Astor, Beyonc,
Borghese, Celine Dion, Chupa Chups, David and Victoria Beckham, Desperate
Housewives, Esprit, Exclamation, Isabella Rossellini, Jovan, Kate Moss, Kylie Minogue,
MaryKateandAshley,MissSixty,MissSporty,Playboy,PierreCardin,Rimmel,Shania
Twain,Stetson,andVanillaFields.
CotystoptenbrandsAdidas,Chloe,CalvinKlein,MarcJacobs,Playboy,OPI,Davidoff,
Philosophy,SallyHansen,andRimmelareknownaspowerbrandsthatyieldnearly
70%ofthecompanysnetrevenuesinfiscalyear2012.

TheCotyPrestigeunit,adivisionofCoty,wasformedin2006tomarketitsprestigebrands.
The unit has 23 exclusive brands in its portfolio and is distributed in luxury stores
worldwide.
It includes luxury brands such as Balenciaga, Calvin Klein, Cerruti, Chlo, Chopard,
Davidoff, Jennifer Lopez, Jette Joop, Jil Sander, JOOP!, Karl Lagerfeld, Kenneth Cole,
L.A.M.B.fragrancebyGwenStefani,Lancaster,MarcJacobs,Nautica,Nikos,BabyPhat,
PahtFarm,SarahJessicaParker,OPI,VeraWang,andVivienneWestwood.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

TotalsalesforCotygrow12.2%in2012,from$4.1billionin2011to$4.6billionin2012.

Since2007,saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of6.9%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A98

599

Coty

Table558:CotysGlobalCorporateSales,2007to
2012
Yeara

$Billion

Change,%

2007

3.3

14.0

2008

4.0

21.2

2009

3.5

(12.5)

2010

3.6

2.9

2011

4.1

14.0

2012

4.6

12.2

aYearendingonJune30.

Table559:CotysGlobalCorporateSalesby
ProductCategory,2012
Category

%Oftotal

Fragrances

55.4

Colorcosmetics

29.1

Skin,sun,andpersonalcare

15.5

Total

100.0

Thesplitofthecompanystotalrevenuesbyregionisasfollows:
Europe,theMiddleEast,andAfrica(EMEA)continuetobethelargestmarketforthe
company,generating48.6%oftherevenuesforthefirstninemonthsinfiscal2012.
The contribution to corporate sales from the Americas is 40.2% for the first nine
monthsinfiscal2012,a29%increasefromthefirstninemonthsinfiscal2011.
AsiaPacificcontributes11.1%toCotyssalesforthefirstninemonthsinfiscal2012.

Coty Beauty, the mass marketing arm, contributes 49% to Cotys sales, and Coty Prestige
generates51%ofthecompanyssales.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Sales for Cotys U.S. cosmetics and toiletries increase from $1,048million in 2011 to
$1,086millionin2012.
ThecompanyssaleshavegrownatCAGRof3.3%since2007.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5100

Coty

Table560:CotysCosmeticsandToiletries
SalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

923

2008

945

2.4

2009

918

(2.9)

2010

961

4.7

2011

1,048

9.1

2012

1,086

3.6

Cotyisinsecondplaceinthefragrancesproductclasswitha14.2%shareoftotalfragrances
salesin2012.
The company ranks second in both the mens fragrances and womens fragrances
categories.

Coty continues to be the secondleading marketer of fragrances forwomen, commanding


12.7%oftotalcategorysales.
Thecategoryssalesgrowby9.5%in2012,from$315millionin2011to$345millionin
2012.
Thecompanysshareinthecategoryincreasesfrom12.1%in2011to12.7%in2012.
Coty continues to compete in both the luxury and mass trade classes with an
assortmentofcelebrityanddesignerscents.
Euphoria continues to be the leading brand for Coty in the category in 2012. Sales
declineby4.2%,from$24millionin2011to$23millionin2012.
AsidefromthedebutofLadyGagaFameandMadonnaTruthorDare,theonlyother
majorfemalefragrancelaunchesof theyearareMarcJacobsDotandJenniferLopez
Glowing.
Coty launches a series of new scents in early 2013 including Guess Girl and See by
Chloe.
The only major mass launch for Coty during 2012 is an extension of the Halle Berry
franchisecalledCloser.

Cotyisthesecondleadingmarketerinthefragrancesformencategoryin2012.
Cotys sales in the category grow 0.5% from $195 million in 2011 to $196 million in
2012.
Thecompanyscategorysharedeclinesfrom18.3%in2011to17.8%in2012.
Stetson continues to be the leading brand for the company in 2012. The sales of the
brandareflatat$17millionin2012,constantwith2011levels.
CotysbiggestdeclineisfromthesluggishnessinKennethColescentsales,afranchise
whichCotylosesasoflate2012.
ManyofCotysmajorscentshaveeitherrelativelyflatorslightlyupwardsalessuchas
EternityforMen0.0%,Euphora9.1%,andEternityAqua11.1%
Encounteristhemajorlaunchoftheyearwithsalesreaching$3million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A100

Coty

5101

Unlikemanyothermarketersthatcompeteineithertheluxuryorthemasstradeclass,
Cotyisactiveinboth.
ManyofCotysmassscents,suchasStetson,McGraw,andPlayboy,experienceflator
decliningsales.
Since2006,inadditiontoitsownbrands,CotydistributesanumberofPuigsbrandsin
North America, including Prada, Nina Ricci, Carolina Herrera, Antonio Banderas, and
Paco Rabanne, which are reflected in Cotys total sales. However, Coty will cease to
distributePuigfragranceswhenthelicenseexpiresonJune30,2013.

Cotycontinuestobethefifthleadingmarketerinthemakeupproductclassin2012.
Itsmakeupsalestotal$415millionin2012,up1.0%from$411millionin2011.
TheSallyHansenbrandrepresents52.5%ofthemarketersmakeupsalesin2012.The
branddeclines8.0%in2012withsalesof$218million,asitdoesnotprovideenough
newnesstogrowsalesfrom2011.
NailpolishisthemostimportantmakeupcategoryofCotyasitrepresents63.6%ofits
makeupsales,with$264million.
Cotysnailpolishesmarketsharedeclinesfrom56.6%in2011to45.2%in2012.Growth
in the nail polish market overall, is 29.9%. Coty faces stiff competition from the
plethoraofnewlaunchesinthemassandspecialtytradeclasses.
Rimmel is the secondleading brand in Cotys makeup portfolio behind Sally Hansen.
Rimmelsalesreach$113millionin2012,up11.9%from$101millionin2011.Rimmel
represents27.2%ofCotymakeupsalesin2012.
EyemakeupistheleadingcategoryfortheRimmelbrandwithsalesof$57millionin
2012,up9.6%from2011.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Acquisitions

InApril2012,CotyproposestoacquireAvon.
InMay2012,AvonturnsdownCotysproposalforitsacquisition.

In February 2013, Coty and Puig announce not to renew their distribution agreement in
NorthAmerica.

Managementchanges

In July 2012, Coty appoints Michele Scannavini as the new CEO after Brend Beetzs
retirement.
ScannavinihasbeenpresidentofCotyPrestigeformorethan10years.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5102

Coty

In September 2012, Coty announces Jean Mortier as the new Global President of Coty
Prestige.

InNovember2012,CotyannouncesMarcReyasitsnewRegionalVicePresidentforNorth
America.

Licensingagreements

In October 2012, Coty announces its agreement with Karl Lagerfeld to end its existing
fragrancelicense.

Otherdevelopments

InJune2012,Cotyfilestogopublic,afteritswithdrawalfromAvonstakeoveroffer.
Cotyplanstoraiseupto$700millionthroughitsIPO(initialpublicoffering),following
which,itsshareswillbeoffloadedbyallitsexistingshareholders.Thecompanydoes
notrevealthenumberofsharesthatitplanstoofferintheIPO.ThisIPOisexpectedto
open doors to a greater number of investment opportunities, for its German
conglomerateJoh.A.Becker.
InSeptember2012,CotydecidestoputasideitsplansofitsIPO,postponingitto2013.
The decision to delay the IPO is taken in order to give the newly appointed CEO
MicheleScannaviniconsiderabletimetoadjusttohisrole.
June 13, 2013, Coty finally is offered on the New York Stock Exchange under symbol
COTY,at$17.50pershare.

InDecember2012,CotyPrestigeannouncesThomasDutronc,aFrenchGuitarist,astheface
ofthenewCerrutifragranceformen.

NEWPRODUCTS

Table561:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyCotyintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

CalvinKlein

HalleBerry

Category

Description

Fragrancesformen

EncounteristhenewestCalvinKleinscentand
openswithmandarin,cardamom,andrum,
alongwithpepper,jasmine,patchouli,and
cognac

Fragrancesforwomen

Closerisconsideredamodernfemininefloral
thatopenswithaccordsofozone,wild
raspberry,andwaterlily

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A102

Coty

Table561:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyCotyintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Fragrancesforwomen

Glowingisawoodyfloralwithtopnotesof
bergamot,mandarin,andcypressinabottle
thatlightsupandglowsfor15secondswhen
used

Fragrancesforwomen

LadyGagasdebutscent,Fameisbuilton
threemainaccords:darkaccord,sensual
accord,andlightaccord.Thedarkaccord
includespoisonousflowerBelladonnaand
incense.Scentspraysonblackandturnsclear,
andishousedinablackbottle

Madonna

Fragrancesforwomen

TruthorDareisMadonnasfirstscentandis
describedasbeingbothlightanddark,
openingwithnotesofgardenia,creamy
tuberose,andneroli

MarcJacobs

Fragrancesforwomen

Dotisfloralfruity,surroundedwithexotic
notesofcoconutandwrappedinsoftvanillain
aladybuginspiredbottle

PacoRabanne

Fragrancesformen

OneMillioncomestotheUnitedStates.It
includesnotesofgrapefruit,redorange,mint,
rose,cinnamon,spices,leather,wood,
patchouli,andamber

Prada

Eyemakeup

ScandaleyesWaterproofKohleyeliner

Rimmel

Eyemakeup

LashAcceleratorEndlessmascara

SallyHansen

Nailpolishes

NewCompleteSalonManicure

SallyHansen

Nailpolishes

New&ImprovedDiamondStrengthNoChip
NailColor

SallyHansen

Nailpolishes

MagneticNailColor3Dnailartinseconds

JenniferLopez

LadyGaga

MARKETINGACTIVITY
Cotyincreasesitstraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)by15.8%,to$283.3millionin2012
from$244.7millionin2011.
Thecompanyutilizesawiderangeofmediatoolstopromoteitsproducts.
Magazine advertising at $234.9 million continues to be the preferred medium to
promotethecompanysproductsin2012.
Coty spends about 82.9% of its TME on magazines and 16.1% on television
advertisements.
Cotyistheleadingfragrancesadvertiserwith$128.7millionasTMEin2012.
In 2012, TME for womens fragrances decrease 25.1% to $76.4 million, down from
$102millionin2011.
TMEformensfragrancesis$31.7millionin2012,up23.8%from$25.6millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5103

5104

Coty

Coty spends $104 million on its nail polish brands. TME for Cotys nail polishes are up by
65.1%, from $63.0 million in 2011. This figure includes spending for the companys Sally
Hansen,OPI,andNicolebrands.
Magazines are the primary medium used to promote the companys brands and
products.
TheSallyHansenbrandissupportedwith$46.5millioninTMEin2012.Aboutonethird
oftheexpendituresupportstheSalonEffectsfranchise.
OPIProductsreceiveTMEof$43.2millionin2012,upby70.8%,from$25.3millionin
2011.About40%oftheTMEsupportsthebrandsGelcolorline.
OPINicoleissupportedwith$13.8millioninTMEin2012.
All of Cotys brands, especially OPI Nicole, use seasonal and/or limited edition color
collectionsasawaytomotivateconsumerstodrivesalesandrepurchaseoften.
Coupons are regularly made available in magazines, online, as well as on retailer
shelves.
CotyincreasinglypromotesitsSallyHansenbrandthroughsocialmediasites,suchas
Facebook, Twitter, and Pinterest, and offers howto tutorials on the brands website
andonYouTube.
SallyHansenfeaturesanIlovenailartcontesttowincashprizesandatriptoNew
York on its website to promote its products. Viewers can vote through the brands
websiteorthroughPinterestandTwitter.

Promotionalvehiclesformassbrandslargelyincludepricediscountsandcoupons.
OPIrefreshesitslinebycobrandingorpromotinglimitededitionshades.Forexample,
OPI launched new shades inspired by James Bonds new movie Skyfall and a Vintage
MinnieMousecollection,aswellascolorsinspiredbysingerMariahCareyandbythe
Kardashiansisters,KendallandKylie.
Themarketeralsooffersdiscountcouponsonitswebsitetopromoteitsproducts.
The company offers discount coupons of different denominations. For example, Coty
offers $1.00 off on any Sally Hansen nail product and $3.00 off on any Rimmel Stay
MatteFoundation.

Cotycontinuestosigncelebritiestolaunchnewproductsandpromoteexistingbrands.
In January 2012, the company signs Kristen Stewart as the face of its Balenciaga
fragranceforwomen,toberevealedinfall2012.

Themarketerincreasesitspresenceonsocialmediawebsitestopromoteitsproducts.
Coty is increasingly promoting its brands on social websites, such as Facebook,
Pinterest,Twitter,andYouTube,togaininstantacceptanceamongconsumers.

Cotyoffersgiftsetsinordertoattractcostconsciousconsumers.
Coty specializes in giftwithpurchase (GWP) promotion offers to support its sales
growth.
The marketer offers free gifts with a purchase of $50.00 or more for its Philosophy
brandthroughitswebsite.
Cotyoffersgiftsetsandshippingoffersforvariousproductsthroughouttheyearasa
partofitspromotionalactivity.
Consumers can also receive free gifts and offers by signing up for newsletters on its
website.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A104

Coty

Cotyalsodistributesscentedstripsinmagazinesassamplestoattractmorecustomers.

OUTLOOK

Cotyisprojectedtogrowmoderatelyby2.7%overtheforecastperiodfrom2012to2017.
Themarketerislikelytopostpositivegrowthinallthecategoriesthatitcompetesin.
Newproductlauncheswithbettertechnologieswillsupporttheoverallgrowthofthe
marketerinthefuture.
Cotyisalsoexpectedtoincreaseitsmediaspendingovertheforecastperiodtosupport
itssalesgrowth.
Themakeupproductclasswilllikelydrivethesalesofthemarketerovertheforecast
period.

Fragrances, the largest product class for Coty, will continue to be the largest revenue
generatorforthecompanyovertheforecastperiod.
Themarketerisexpectedtooffercollectionsofsmallcoffretsofitsscentstohelpkeep
consumersloyaltothecompanyand/orbrandwhilestillsatisfyingconsumersneedfor
variety.
Theindustryisexpectedtolaunchfragranceswithadditionaladvantagesbeyondjust
impartingascent,possiblyhealthbenefitssuchasloweringbloodpressure,improving
sinuscongestion,andoverallrelaxation.Coty,asamajorfragranceplayer,isexpected
toleadsuchinnovations.
However,thegrowthofCotysfragrancesproductclasswillbelimitedovertheforecast
period,asthelicenseofPuigfragrancesexpiresin2013,andPuigfragranceshavebeen
veryimportanttoCoty.

Themakeupproductclassisforecasttoperformwelloverthenextfiveyears.
NailpolisheswillbethelargestrevenuegeneratorforCotyinthemakeupproductclass
overtheforecastperiod.
Cotyisforecasttopostgrowthinthenailpolishescategorysupportedbynewproduct
launches.
Coty will continue to be the leading marketer in the nail polishes category over the
forecastperiod.
The marketer is expected to launch innovative products such as textured nails,
magneticnailpolish,andglitternailpolishtosupportitssalesgrowth.
Coty will likely increase its marketing and promotional activities in the nail polishes
categorytosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Theeyemakeupcategoryisforecasttopostgrowthof4.0%forCotyoverthenextfive
years.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5105

5106

Coty

Themarketerisexpectedtolaunchinnovativeproductswithmultibenefitssuchas
quickerdryingtimeandheat/smearresistancethatarelikelytocontributetosales
growthoftheeyemakeupcategory.
Coty should also launch limitededition eye shadow collections to add incremental
salesthroughouttheyearandtocreateexcitement.
ThefacemakeupcategorywilllikelypostgoodgrowthforCotyoverthenextfiveyears.
Themarketerwilllikelyintroducefoundationswithmultipleskincarebenefits,aswell
asbreathablefeeltodrivesales,alongwithnewtechnologyinproductforms.
Theproductswithantiagingandsuncarebenefitswilllikelydrivesalesoffacemakeup
productsovertheforecastperiod.
Coty is expected to increase its TME support for its makeup product class over the
forecastperiod.

Cotywillcontinuetoalignwithcelebritiesyetwillbemorecautiousaboutthecelebrities
thatitchooses.
Themarketerisexpectedtosignagreementswithdesigners,artists,andentertainers
tolaunchnewbrandsorforpromotingexistingbrandextensions.
Howeveritsnewstatusasapubliccompanywillforceittobecomemorecautiouswith
itsinvestmentsandthefamouspeopleitalignsitselfwith.

Coty is expected to continue to spend on its advertising and promotional activities in the
fiveyearforecastperiodinordertoattractmorecustomers.
Printmediaandtelevisionadvertisingwillcontinuetobethepreferredmediatoolsfor
Coty.
Engaging consumers through social media will become an important medium,
especiallyasreadershipofmagazinesdeclines.

Cotys cosmetics and toiletries sales are projected to increase at a CAGR of 2.7% to
$1,238millionby2017from$1,086millionin2012.

Table562:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforCotybyCategory,2012to2017
Category
Nailpolishes
Eyemakeup
Facemakeup
Facialtreatments
COMPANYAVERAGE
Lipsticksandlipglosses
Personalcleansingproducts
Fragrancesforwomen
Fragrancesformen
Handandbodylotions
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches
Deodorantsandantiperspirants

CAGR,%
4.2
4.0
3.9
3.0
2.7
2.7
2.2
1.8
1.5
1.5
1.0
1.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A106

ELIZABETHARDEN

Table563:ElizabethArdensSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011
and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

2012

VivaLaJuicy

27

30

WhiteDiamonds

19

18

14

24

13

11

RedDoor

11

10

Someday

35

10

WonderstruckEnchanted

JuicyCouture

BCBGMaxAzria

EdHardyBornWildr

11

CoutureCouture

LuckyYou

Pretty

Villain

WhiteShoulders

FantasyBritneySpears

Hearts&Daggers

Believe

CircusFantasy

EdHardyLove&Luck

Forever

LollipopBling

Girlfriend
Wonderstruck
PinkFriday

EdHardyWomenr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5108

ElizabethArden

Table563:ElizabethArdensSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011
and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

Peace,Love,&Juicy

5thAvenue

CuriousBritneySpears

CurveCrushforWomen

CurveforWomen

Design

GreenTea

LusciousPink

MbyMariah

Mediterranean

UsherShe

UsherUR

WithLoveHilaryDuff

201

188

51

50

CurveForMen

EdHardyLove&Luckr

EdHardyVillianr

HalstonMen'sFragrance

JohnVarvatos

JohnVarvatosStar

P.S.

TrueReligion2

CurveCrush

DirtyEnglish

DrifterforMenr

EdHardyHearts&Daggersr

EdHardyMenr

Totalr
FACIALTREATMENTS
ElizabethArdenr
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A108

2012

ElizabethArden

Table563:ElizabethArdensSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011
and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORMEN(Continued)

2012

UsherHe

Roccawear9X

Allother

34

27

14

14

313

290

Totalr
FACEMAKEUP
ElizabethArden
EYEMAKEUP
ElizabethArden
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
ElizabethArden
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
ElizabethArden
NAILPOLISHES
ElizabethArden
TOTALr

rRestated.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Elizabeth Arden Inc., established in 1910, is one of the largest global prestige beauty
productsmarketers.

The companys portfolio in the cosmetics and toiletries industry comprises prestige
fragrances,skincare,andcosmeticsbrands.

ElizabethArdensprestigefragrancesportfolioisdividedintocelebrityfragrances,lifestyle
fragrances,anddesignerfragrances.
Celebrity fragrances include brands such as Britney Spears, Elizabeth Taylor, Mariah
Carey,TaylorSwift,JustinBieber,NickiMinaj,andUsher.
Lifestyle fragrances include Curve, Giorgio Beverly Hills, P.S. Fine Cologne, and White
Shoulders.
Designer fragrances include Juicy Couture, Kate Spade New York, John Varvatos,
Rocawear,BCBGMaxAzria,AlbertaFerretti,Halston,GeoffreyBeene,AlfredSung,Bob
Mackie,andLucky.
The company also distributes approximately 250 prestige fragrance brands in the
UnitedStatesthroughdistributionagreements.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5109

5110

ElizabethArden

The companys headquarters are located in Miramar, FL while regional administrative


headquartersforthecompanyarelocatedinNewYork,Geneva,andStamford.

Thecompanysellsitsproductsinmorethan100countriesthroughperfumeries,boutiques,
departmentstores,travelretailoutlets,anddutyfreeshops,aswellasontheInternet.

In addition to marketing its own brands, the company also acts as a distributor for other
fragrancemarketers.

Leading retailers for Elizabeth Ardens products include Macys, Dillards, Belk, JCPenney,
Saks, Bloomingdales, Nordstrom, Walmart, Target, Sears, Kohls, Walgreens, CVS, Boots,
Debenhams,Sephora,Marionnaud,Douglas,andWorldDutyFree.AsofAugust2012,the
companyemploysabout2,357fulltimeemployeesacrossalllocations.
It also employs approximately 432 parttime employees in the United States and 17
othercountries.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Corporate sales of Elizabeth Arden increase by 5.3% from $1,175.5 million in 2011 to
$1,238.2millionin2012.

In2012,netprofitsofthecompanytotal$57.4million,up40.0%from$41.0millionin2011.
Since2007,salesofElizabethArdenwitnessacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of
1.9%.

Table564:ElizabethArdensGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million
Yeara

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales,%

2007

1,127.5

37.3

3.3

2008

1,141.1

19.9

1.7

2009

1,070.2

(6.2)

(0.6)

2010

1,103.8

19.5

1.8

2011

1,175.5

41.0

3.5

2012
1,238.2

aFiscalyearendingJune30.

57.4

4.6

Fragrancescommand76.1%ofthecompanystotalsalesworldwidein2012.
Salesincreasefrom$900millionin2011to$942millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A110

ElizabethArden

Table565:ElizabethArdensGlobalCorporateSalesbyProductCategory,2011
and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Category

2011

2012

2011

2012

Fragrances

900.3

941.9

76.0

76.1

Skincare

207.1

226.4

18.0

18.3

Cosmetics

68.1

70.0

6.0

5.6

1175.5

1,238.2

100.0

100.0

Total

TheU.S.marketcontributes58.1%tothecompanysbusinessin2012.

Table566:ElizabethArdensGlobalCorporateSalesbyCountry,2011and2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

2011

2012

UnitedStates

701.6

718.8

59.7

58.1

70.0

71.7

5.9

5.8

403.9

447.6

34.4

36.1

1,175.5

1,238.2

100.0

100.0

UnitedKingdom
Allother
Total

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

ManufacturerssalesforElizabethArdenintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketdecline
7.3%from$313millionin2011to$290millionin2012.
Since2007,saleshavegrownataCAGRof0.8%.

Table567:ElizabethArdensCosmeticsandToiletriesSales
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

279

2008r

298

6.8

2009r

316

6.0

2010r

286

(9.5)

2011r

313

9.4

2012

290

(7.3)

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5111

5112

ElizabethArden

The fragrances product class commands 74.1% of the companys cosmetics and toiletries
salesintheUnitedStatesin2012.
Sales in the fragrances category experience a decrease from $235million in 2011 to
$215millionin2012.
ElizabethArdencaptures5.6%ofthefragrancesproductclasssalesintheUnitedStates
in2012.
Mass retailers, such as Walmart and Target, and chain drug stores, such as CVS and
Walgreens, continue to be the fastestgrowing distribution channels for Elizabeth
Ardenintheluxuryfragrancessegment.

Fragrances for women is the largest product category for the company, accounting for
$188millioninsalesin2012,down6.5%from$201millionin2011.
SalesdeclineduetoweaksalesinthenewlyacquiredEdHardyfranchise,alongwitha
sales drop of the first Justin Beiber scent, and less than expected growth with the
secondscent.
ElizabethArdenmovesintofourthplacewiththeacquisitionoffragrancebrandsfrom
NewWaveFragrancesandGiveBackBrands.
ElizabethArdenacquirestheglobalfragrancelicensesofEdHardy,TrueReligion,and
BCBGMaxAzriafromNewWaveFragrancesinmid2012.Italsoacquiresthefragrance
licensesofJustinBieberandNickiMinajfromGiveBackBrands,LLC.
These acquisitions help Elizabeth Arden achieve a 6.9% share in the fragrances for
womencategory.However,evenincludingthebrandsnewtothestable,overallsales
declineby6.5%.
ThemajornewscentfromElizabethArdenduring2012isNickiMinajPinkFridayand
JustinBeiberGirlfriend.

Facialtreatmentsisthecompanyssecondlargestproductcategory,representing17.2%of
thecompanysU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin2012.
Categorysalesdeclineby2.0%from$51millionin2011to$50millionin2012.
Thecompanyaccountsfor0.8%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012.
Limited promotional support and lack of new product activity offsets the marketers
growthinthecategory.

FragrancesformenisthethirdlargestcategoryforElizabethArden,generating9.3%ofthe
marketerssalesin2012.
Salesdecline20.6%from$34millionin2011to$27millionin2012.
ElizabethArdenisplacedeighthinthemensfragrancescategory,accountingfor2.5%
oftheU.S.mensfragrancessalesin2012.
ThemarketerintroducesEdHardyinthemensfragrancescategoryin2012.

Themakeupproductsclassgenerates7.9%ofthecompanyssalesin2012.
Face makeup, the largest makeup category for the company, registers sales of
$14millionin2012,flatwith2011levels.
Eyemakeupalsoexperiencesflatsalesof$5millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A112

ElizabethArden

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

InMay2012,ElizabethArdenacquiresgloballicensesandcertainassetsassociatedtothe
EdHardy,TrueReligion,andBCBGMaxAzriafragrancebrandsfromNewWaveFragrances
foranundisclosedprice.

In June 2012, the company acquires global permits to the Justin Bieber and Nicki Minaj
fragrancebrandsfromGiveBackBrandsforanundisclosedprice.

In2012,themarketeracquirestheCurveFragrancefranchisefromFifth&Pacific(formerly
knownasLizClaiborne)foranundisclosedprice.

InSeptember2012,ElizabethArdenannouncesinvestmentinRedDoorSpaHoldings.

Newproducts

Table568:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyElizabethArdenin2012
Brand

Category

Description

EdHardy

Fragrancesfor
men

VillianopenswithnotesofItalianBergamotandFrenchlavenderalong
withmasculinespicesandEgyptianbasilandwildsage

JustinBeiber

Fragrancesfor
women

GirlfriendisJustinBeiberssecondscentandisgearedtohisadolescent
fanbase.Topnotesincludemandarin,blackberry,pear,andstrawberry

NickiMinaj

Fragrancesfor
women

FirstfragrancefromNickiMinaj,PinkFriday,namedafterherfirstalbum
ofthesamename,isafloralmuskcontainingnotesofpinkflowerpetals,
creamyvanilla,musk,andwoods.Thefragranceishousedinabottle
shapedbustofMinajcompletewithapinkwig

TaylorSwift

Fragrancesfor
women

WonderstruckEnchantedisthesecondfragrance,presentedasaflanker
fromtheyoungpopcountrysingerTaylorSwift.Scentisanoriental
gourmand,thatopenswithnotesofwildberries,pinkpoppy,andpassion
fruit.Asintheoriginal,thebottleisadornedwithdanglingcharms

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The companys annual spend on mediabased advertising and promotional activities is


$57.0millionin2012,up9.0%,from$52.3millionin2011.
The fragrances product class claims 77.3% of the total traceable media expenditures
(TMEs)in2012.Thedollaradvertisingexpenditureamountsto$44.1million.
Thefragrancesforwomencategoryaccountsfor78.9%ofthetotalmediaspendingby
the marketer in the fragrances product class in 2012, with TME amounting to
$34.8million.
Skin care is the secondmost advertised product class, with TME of $10.7 million in
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5113

5114

ElizabethArden

The company ensures that each of its fragrance, skin care, and cosmetics products are
distinctivelypositionedwithexclusiveadvertisingthemes,logos,andpackaging.
ElizabethArdenutilizesprintmedia,television,andradioadvertising,andpointofsale
merchandising, including displays and sampling, the Internet marketing, and mobile
marketingtoolstopromoteitsbrands.

Thecompanyoffersfreenewsletters,shippingoffers,andbeautyrewardsonfreesignup
onitswebsite.
It also promotes its brands through social networking websites such as Facebook,
MySpace,andTwitter.
Themarketeralsoleveragesnewmarketingmediums,includingmobilemarketingand
socialmediatoengagewithtechnologicallysavvyconsumers.
The company provides free shipping and a gift with a purchase of $40.00 through its
website.

ProductsamplingisanimportantmeansofpromotionforElizabethArdensproducts.
Scented strips in magazines and scented blotter cards distributed in retail stores are
commonwaysforsamplingfragrances.
The company also distributes samples of select antiaging products in department
stores.

Elizabeth Arden encourages giftwithpurchase (GWP), an important promotional activity


forthecompany.
Thesesetstypicallycontaineitheravarietyoffragranceminiatures,orafragranceand
ancillaryproducts.
Thesesetsarepopularduetotheiremphasisonvalueandthefactthattheytypically
costlessthaniftheindividualcomponentsarepurchasedseparately.

Anotherimportantpromotionalactivityusedbythemarketerforitsmakeupandskincare
productsisproductdemonstrationbysalesrepresentativesatinstorecounters.

OUTLOOK

ElizabethArdenisforecasttopostgrowthof1.5%overtheforecastperiod,supportedby
newproductlaunchesacrosscategories.
Thegrowthofthecompanywillbesupportedbynewproductlaunchesacrossskincare,
fragrances,andmakeupcategories.
ThemarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitsTMEspendinordertosupportitsoverallsales
duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A114

ElizabethArden

The marketer repositions its brand globally in 2012 by modernizing its presentation to
appealafreshtowomenbyhonoringthestrongheritageofthebrand.
Thekeyelementsonthebrandsrepositioningincludesimprovedproductformulations,
packaging,andcounterredesign,andthisisexpectedtoaddmoresalesduringthenext
fiveyears.
Alltheproductsunderthebrandwillhaveaunifiedlookgloballytoengageconsumers
interestacrossallmarkets.
The repositioning of the brand includes the introduction of communication that is
designedtoreflectandreinforcethebrandsrevitalized,modernpositioning.
The marketer relaunches its website enhanced with capabilities including delivering
shoppingexcellenceinteractiveplatformforkeepingconsumersengagedandbuilding
brandequity.

Themarketerwillcontinuetofocusonacquiringfragrancebrandsandlicensesofvarious
fragrance brands over the forecast period in order to strengthen its position in the
fragrancesproductclass.
In2012,themarketeracquiresgloballicensesandcertainassetsassociatedtotheEd
Hardy,TrueReligion,andBCBGMaxAzriafragrancebrandsfromNewWaveFragrances.
The acquisition of these brands will strengthen the position of the marketer in the
fragrancesproductclassoverthenextfiveyears.
Elizabeth Ardens market share is also expected to grow in the future with the
expansionofitsfragrancefranchises.

Themarketerisexpectedtoexpanditsdistributionforitsfragrancesbrandsthroughluxury
outletsintheUnitedStatesandEuropein2013tosupportitsgrowth.

Themarketerwillcontinuetofocusonlaunchinginnovativeproductsacrossthecategories
inthefuture.
In2012,thecompanylaunchesanewproduct;BritneySpearsfantasytwist,whichisa
uniquelypackagedduofragrancecontainingbothFantasyandMidnightFantasy,twoof
themostpopularfragranceswithintheBritneySpearsfranchise.
Themarketerwillfocusonthemostsuccessfulfragranceswithintheirrespectivelines
tomaintainsustainablegrowthovertheforecastperiod.

ThefragrancesproductclasswilllikelybethelargestrevenuegeneratorforElizabethArden
overtheforecastperiod.
Themarketerwillcontinuetolaunchmorefragrancesinordertosupportitsgrowthin
thecategory.
ThemarketerplanstolaunchEdHardySkullsandRosesfragrancesforbothmenand
womenin2013tosupportitssales.
ThemarketshareofElizabethArdenintheprestigefragrancescategorygrowin2012
due to the launch of various fragrances, and will continue to grow in the forecast
period.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5115

5116

ElizabethArden

Themarketerwillincreaseitsmediaspendforitsfragrancesovertheforecastperiodin
ordertosupportitsgrowth.
Celebrityfragrancesareexpectedtodrivethesalesofthefragrancesproductclassfor
themarketerinthefuture.
Fragrance brands, such as Britney Spears, Juicy Couture, Curve, Rocawear, and John
Varvatos,areimportantforthemarketer.Itislikelythatnotallofthesewillcontinue
tobewinnersinthecategory.

Thefacialtreatmentscategoryisexpectedtoperformwellforthemarketeroverthenext
fiveyears.
The marketer launches a successful line of skin care products under the Visible
Differencebrandin2012toattractyoungerconsumersthroughanentrypricepointto
supportitssales.
Themarketerwillcontinuetolaunchsuchproductsinthefuture.
GrowingdemandforantiagingproductsintheUnitedStateswillalsocontributetothe
categorysgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.

Themarketerdiscontinuesitsnailpolishesproductsin2012andisexpectedtodiscontinue
itshandandbodylotionscategoryovertheforecastperiod.
Lack of significant activities, including new product launches and TME support to its
brands, will likely contribute to the discontinuation of the hand and body lotions
categoryinthefuture.

The marketer will continue to promote its products through social media channels to
supportitssalesovertheforecastperiod.
Themarketerplanstoexpanditsecommercefunctionalityovertheforecastperiodin
ordertogainadditionalsalesthroughthisplatform.
Expansion of the ecommerce and retail outlet business is part of Elizabeth Ardens
directtoconsumerbusinessinitiative.

Themarketerisexpectedtofocusontheemergingmarketsovertheforecastperiod.
The marketer plans to open an affiliate office in Brazil in 2013 and increase its
resourcesinmarketsincludingRussia,Europe,andtheMiddleEast.

Sales of Elizabeth Ardens cosmetics and toiletries are projected to reach $312million by
2017,growingataCAGRof1.5%from$290millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A116

ElizabethArden

Table569:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthof
CosmeticsandToiletriesforElizabethArdenby
Category,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

2.7

Eyemakeup

2.3

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.5

Facemakeup

1.4

Fragrancesforwomen

1.0

Fragrancesformen

0.5

Lipsticksandlipglosses

Handandbodylotions

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5117

5118

ElizabethArden

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A118

ENERGIZERHOLDINGS

Table570:EnergizerHoldingsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

SUNCAREPRODUCTS

BananaBoat

2012

168

179

49

51

217

230

Skintimate

83

85

Edge

75

77

Schick

Total

162

166

TOTAL

379

396

HawaiianTropic
Total
SHAVINGPRODUCTS

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Energizer Holdings is a global consumer goods company operating in broad categories of


personalcareandhouseholdproducts.
Thecompanywasincorporatedin1999andisheadquarteredinSt.Louis,MO.
ItistradedontheNewYorkStockExchange.
Thecompanyoperatesin49countriesandhasdistributioninmorethan160countries.
EnergizerHoldingsworldwideemployeestotalabout14,800.
As of September 2012, the company employs more than 4,800 people in the United
Statesandapproximately10,000inforeignjurisdictions.
The company is present internationally in North America, the AsiaPacific region, and
SouthandCentralAmerica.
Itisprimarilyaconsumergoodscompanythatoperatesgloballyinthehouseholdand
personal care productscategories.Personal care productscontribute to 54.3% of the
totalsalesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5120

EnergizerHoldings

Thecompanyshouseholdproductsofferitsconsumersarangeofportablepowersolutions
undertheEnergizerandEverydaybrandnames.
Energizer Holdings household product portfolio comprises household batteries,
specialtybatteries,andlightingproducts.
ProductsrangefromlowcostcarbonzincbatteriestolithiumAAandAAAbatteries.
Other products include specialty batteries, Energi To Go chargers, and a complete
lineofbatterypoweredflashlightsandlanterns.

The companys personal care division offers its customers a range of products in the wet
shave,skincare,femininecare,andinfantcareproductcategories.
ThewellestablishedbrandnamesincludeSchickandWilkinsonSwordinthemensand
womensshavingproducts.
Tampons, gloves, and infant feeding products are marketed under the Playtex brand
name.
Sun care products are marketed under the wellknown brands, Banana Boat and
HawaiianTropic.
Underthepersonalcareproductsdivision,thecompanyalsomarketsWetOnesmoist
wipes.

Energizerproductsaresoldworldwidethroughretailoutlets.
Massmerchandisers,warehouseclubs,electronicspecialtystores,departmentstores,
hardware and automotive centers, and military stores, as well as food, drug, and
conveniencestores.
The company operates a number of manufacturing and packaging facilities in 14
countriesinfivecontinents.
Energizers products are marketed to its retailer partners primarily through a sales
forceandalsothroughexclusiveandnonexclusivedistributorsandwholesalers.

InNovember2012,the companysboardofdirectorsapprovesamultirestructuringplan.
Thisplanisformulatedtoamelioratecostcompetitivenessandtodeliverincreasedfinancial
returns.However,theplanisexpectedtocutdowntheglobalworkforceby10%.

Energizerlabels2012astheYearofReturnwithprofitgrowthinpersonalcareafterthe
investmentsthecompanyhadformedin2011.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Total corporate sales for the company decrease by 1.7% from $4,645.7 million in 2011 to
$4,567.2millionin2012.
Corporatenetprofitsincreaseby56.5%from$261.2millionin2011to$408.9million
in2012.
Since 2007, the companys sales have increased at a compound annual growth rate
(CAGR)of6.3%,whilenetprofitshavegrownataCAGRof4.9%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A120

EnergizerHoldings

Table571:EnergizerHoldingsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

2007

3,365.1

321.4

9.6

49.2

2008

4,331.0

329.3

7.6

33.1

2009

3,999.8

297.8

7.4

16.9

2010

4,248.3

403.0

9.5

19.2

2011

4,645.7

261.2

5.6

12.4

2012

4,567.2

408.9

9.0

19.8

NOTE:FiscalyearendingSeptember30.

Table572:EnergizerHoldingsGlobalSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011to2012

%Ofsales

Segment

2011

2012

BatteriesandLightingProducts

47.3

45.7

RazorsandBlades

35.2

37.0

Skincare,femininecare,andinfantcare

17.5

17.3

100.0

100.0

Total

Table573:EnergizerHoldingsGlobalSalesby
Region,2011and2012
%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

TheUnitedStates

50.4

51.6

International

49.6

48.4

100.0

100.0

Total

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

In the cosmetics and toiletries industry, Energizer Holdings competes in two product
categories:suncareproductsandshavingproducts.
SalesofEnergizerHoldingsinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryintheUnitedStates
advanceby4.5%from$379millionin2011to$396millionin2012.
Since2007,salesofEnergizerHoldingshaveincreasedataCAGRof4.8%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5121

5122

EnergizerHoldings

Table574:EnergizerHoldingsCosmeticsandToiletriesSales,
2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

314

2008

324

3.2

2009

324

2010

354

9.3

2011

379

7.1

2012

396

4.5

ThesuncareproductscategorycontinuestobethelargestproductcategoryforEnergizer
Holdingsin2012.
Manufacturerssalesadvance6%toreach$230millionin2012,upfrom$217millionin
2011.
The marketers share in the entire category declines from 22.1% in 2011 to 21.9% in
2012.
Energizer Holdings marks its presence in the category with two brands: Banana Boat
andHawaiianTropic.
Banana Boat dominates the sun care products category in 2012, with sales at
$179million, up 6.5% from $168million in 2011. Growth for the brand in 2012 is
attributed to its new product introductions, brand loyalty from consumers, and
increasedemphasisonmarketingactivities.
Thebrandmaintainsitsmarketshareinthecategory,accountingfor17.1%ofthetotal
suncareproductscategoryssalesin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
BananaBoatsofferingsincludesunblocks,sunscreens,suntanningproducts,sunless
tanning, and aftersun and other products. However, its dominance is in the rapidly
growingandpopularsunblockssegment.
In 2012, Energizer Holdings introduces Banana Boat Sport Performance Coolzone
UltraMist Continuous Spray Sunscreen SPF 50, Banana Boat Sport Performance
Coolzone UltraMist Continuous Spray Sunscreen SPF 30, Banana Boat Coolzone After
Sun Aloe Gel with Lidocaine, Banana Boat Natural Reflect Sunscreen Lotion SPF 50+,
BananaBoatNaturalReflectKidsSunscreenLotionSPF50+,andBananaBoatNatural
ReflectBabySunscreenLotionSPF50+.
In October 2012, the brand voluntary withdraws 23 of its continuous spray products
whichareidentifiedtobeathreatduetothepotentialriskoftheproductsignitingon
the skin, when in contact with an igniting source, and the product has not dried off
completely.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A122

EnergizerHoldings

The products withdrawn include Ultra Mist Sport 15 Spray, Ultra Mist Sport SPF 30
Spray, Sport 30 Bonus Continuous Spray, Ultra Mist Ultra Defense SPF 30, Ultra Mist
UltraDefenseSPF30Bonus,FamilySizeSport30UltraMist,UltraMistSportSPF50,
UltraDefenseUltraMistSPF50,UltraDefense50BonusContinuousSpray,UltraMist
KidsSPF50Clear,Sport50BonusContinuousSpray,UltraMistSportPerformanceSPF
50+ Spray, Ultra Mist Ultra Defense 85 Spray, Ultra Mist Sport 85 Spray, Kids SPF 85
Spray,BonusUltraDefenseSPF85UltraMist,BonusSportSPF85UltraMist,SportSPF
30 Spray Twin Pack, Sport SPF 50 Spray Twin Pack, Sport 30 Ultra Mist 2 Pack with
Lotion&Lip,SportSPF30UltraMistw/SportLipBalm,Sport30UltraMist,andSport
SPF50UltraMist3Pack.
The company cites the reason behind the potential risk to be the product delivery
systemorthesizeofthevalve,whichdispensesmorethantheregularsuncaresprays
and therefore takes longer to dry in comparison to other continuous sprays in the
market.
Hawaiian Tropic, the other brand of Energizer Holdings in the sun care products
category,continuestobethefourthleadingmassbrandinthecategory,withsalesat
$51millionin2012.
HawaiianTropicpostsa4.1%growthwithsalesadvancingfrom$49millionin2011to
$51millionin2012.
Hawaiian Tropics growth in 2012 is accredited to the marketers introduction of the
highlyanticipatedSilkHydrationrangeofproductsandincreasedmarketingexposure
withitsfirstproductlinelaunchattheMercedesBenzFashionWeek.
The Silk Hydration line comprises six SKUs: Silk Hydration After Sun Lotion, Silk
Hydration Clear Mist Spray SPF 15, Silk Hydration Clear Mist Spray SPF 30, Silk
Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 12, Silk Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 30, and Silk
Hydration Lotion Sunscreen SPF 50. The variants are enriched with hydrating silk
ribbons.

EnergizerHoldingsisalsotheleadingmarketerintheshavingproductscategorywithsales
at$166millionin2012.Salesadvance2.5%from$162millionin2011.
Themarketersshareintheshavingproductscategorydeclinesfrom44.8%in2011to
44.5%in2012.
EnergizerHoldingshasapresenceinthecategorywithitsSkintimate,Edge,andSchick
brands.
Skintimate, the flagship brand of Energizer Holdings, leads the category with sales at
$85millionin2012,up2.4%from$83millionin2011.Thebrandrepresents22.8%of
thecategoryssalesin2012.
Skintimate, a femalecentric brand, continues to grow as the future prospect for
shaving products for women brightens. The brand is also the largest female shaving
brandinthecategory.
In 2012, Skintimates Lotionized Shave Crme undergoes a packaging makeover. The
new colorful packaging provides a feminine look. The moisturizing shaving cream is
enrichedwitholivebutter,soy,vitaminE,andaloevera.SkintimatesLotionizedShave
Crmeisavailableinthreevariants:SensitiveSkinFormula,DrySkinFormula,andBaby
SoftFormula.
Edgeisthesecondleadingbrandforthemarketerin2012withsalesat$77million,up
2.7%from$75millionin2011.AlthoughthesalesforEdgeincreasein2012itssharein
theshavingproductsmarketdeclinesslightlyfrom20.7%in2011to20.6%in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5123

5124

EnergizerHoldings

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Acquisitionsanddivestitures

Therearenomajormergersoracquisitionsin2012.

Managementchanges

Therearenomajorchangesinthetopmanagementofthecompanyduring2012.

Newproducts

Table575:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyEnergizerHoldingsintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Suncare
products

SportPerformanceCoolzoneUltraMistContinuousSpraySunscreen
providesbroadspectrumUVAandUVprotectionandwaterresistancefor
upto80minutes.ItisrecommendedbyTheSkinCancerFoundationand
isavailableinSPF30andSPF50variants.Thisproductisnotrecalledin
2012

BananaBoat

Suncare
products

NaturalReflectSunscreenLotionSPF50+isformulatedwithnaturally
sourcedmineralsuncreeenactivesandzincoxideforUVAandUVB
protection.Itisoxybenzoneandparabenfree,gentleonsensitiveskin,
dermartologisttested,hasbeenproveneffectiveagainstsunburn,water
resistantforupto80minutes,andisrecommendedbyTheSkinCancer
Foundation.Comesinvariantsforadults,babies,andkids

HawaiianTropic

Suncare
products

SilkHydrationClearMistSprayoffersbroadspectrumUVAandUVB
protectionaccompaniedby12hoursofmoisturization.Itisformulated
withskinnourishingantioxidants,andisrecommendedbytheSkinCancer
Foundation.ItisavailableinSPF15andSPF30variants

HawaiianTropic

Suncare
products

SilkHydrationLotionSunscreenprovidesUVAandUVBprotectionand12
hourmoisturization.Itisformulatedwithhydratingsilkribbonsfora
continuousinsunmoisture,nourishingantioxidants,exoticbotanicals
andatropicalfragrance;andisavailableinSPF12,SPF30,andSPF50
variants

Schick

Shaving
products

HydroSkinProtectShaveGelenrichedwithingredientsincludingvitamin
Eandaloe,helpsprotecttheskin

BananaBoat

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Energizer Holdings total traceable media expenditures (TMEs) decline 10.1% in 2012 to
$33.0million,downfrom$36.7million.
The company utilizes an array of marketing media such as sampling, couponing, and
advertisementsinmagazinesandontelevision.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A124

EnergizerHoldings

Inthesuncareproductscategory,EnergizerHoldingsTMEtotals$19.5millionin2012.
ThemarketerincreasesitsTMEby8.3%from$18millionin2011.
MagazineadvertisementsreceivethemaximumTMEfromthecompanyat$9.7million
in2012.Thisaccountsfor49.7%ofthecompanystotalTMEinthecategory.
Television advertisements follow, accounting for 34.0% of the companys total TME,
withexpenditureamountingto$6.6millionin2012.
In 2012, the company allocates $13.4 million to promote its Banana Boat brand.
Banana Boat Coolzone spray receives the highest advertising expenditures, at $6.7
million.
Thecompanysotherbrand,HawaiianTropic,isallocatedaTMEof$6.1millionin2012
withmostor$5.9millionbeingallocatedtopromotetheSilkHydrationproductline.

Intheshavingproductscategory,EnergizerHoldingsTMEfor2012is$12.5million,down
27.3%from$17.2millionin2011.
Themarketerspends$8.1millionontelevisionadvertisementsin2012.
Print advertisements account for $2.3million of the companys TME in support of its
brands.
Edgealonegarners$9.5millionor76%ofthemarketersTMEin2012.
SkintimatereceivesaTMEof$2.9millionin2012.

Afewleadingmarketers,suchasEnergizerHoldings,Merck,andJohnson&Johnson,adopt
marketing techniques, such as special offers including giveaways, sweepstakes, and
discountcoupons.
BananaBoats101DaysofSummerinitiativeisdesignedtogetfamiliesoutdoorsto
play.EachtimeaparenttakestheBananaBoatFacebookpledgetoplaywiththeirkids
outdoors,thecompanydonatesabottleofsunscreen(upto10,000bottles)totheHole
intheWallGang,acampfoundedbyPaulNewmanforchildrencopingwithcancerand
seriousillnesses.
In2012,EdgeutilizesitsFacebook pagetopromoteitsproductsthrougha varietyof
sweepstakes including the Edge Endowment Sweeps where participants get a chance
to win $10,000 daily, over 250 weekly cash prizes, and the Team Edge Sweepstakes
whichrequiresparticipantstovotefortheUFCrisingstarinordertowinatripfortwo
toLasVegastoseealiveUFCevent.

Themarketercontinuestoutilizesocialmediaactivationefforts,tospreadawarenessabout
itsbrandsandnewproductintroductions.
In2012,HawaiianTropicactivatestheMercedesBenzFashionWeekSwimthrough,a
Facebookpromotionthatallowsparticipantstowinatriptotheevent.
Banana Boat promotes the Chip Ganassi Racing with a branded Facebook tab that
offers tips on music and outdoor gear from Dario Franchitti and Jamie McMurray in
2012.
Additionally, in 2012, the marketer introduces special edition Team Edge cans
containingtheUFCfightersfacesetchedonthepackaging,whichitpromotesthrough
theFacebookpageofitsEdgebrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5125

5126

EnergizerHoldings

EnergizerHoldingsorganizeseventstobringaboutawarenessabouttheharmfuleffectsof
theskinsexposuretothesun.
In 2012, Hawaiian Tropic sponsors the Mercedes Benz Fashion Week Swim 2013
Collectionsrunwaytopromoteitslatestrangeofsuncareproducts,theSilkHydration
line.
In2012,BananaBoatcollaborateswithChipGanassiRacingTeamsforthe2012IZOD
IndyCar Series racing season. According to the partnership twotime Indianapolis 500
winnerDarioFranchittidrivesaBananaBoatbrandthemedcarintheseasonopening
GrandPrixofSt.Petersburg.FranchittiadornstheBananaBoatbrandlogoonhisfire
suitthroughoutthe2012season.Thebrandalsohostsaneventtracksidewherebyfans
can come to the Banana Boat CoolZone Sunscreen Pit Stop and use new sunscreens,
playgames,andreceiveproductsasgiveaways.

OUTLOOK

EnergizerHoldingsisexpectedtopostahealthygrowthof4.2%duringtheforecastperiod,
ending2017.
Themarketerisexpectedtosupportitsbrandswithanincreasedadvertisingspendand
promotionalsupport.
Thecompanyislikelytostrengthenitspresenceinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
withmergersandacquisitionsduringtheforecastperiod.
The sun care products category will continue to be the key driver for the companys
growthduringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Intheshavingproductscategory,themarketerstwobrands,SkintimateandEdge,will
continuetoshowgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.

Inthesuncareproductscategory,themarketerisexpectedtomaintainitsleadingposition
withitstwobrandsBananaBoatandHawaiianTropic,duringtheforecastperiod2012to
2017.
Energizer Holdings will continue to introduce new and innovative sun care products
andbringabouttechnologicaladvancementstoitsproductsunderitsBananaBoatand
HawaiianTropicbrands.
Consumersapprehensionsofdevelopingskincancerasaresultoftoomuchexposure
tothesunwillensureincreasingdemandforsuncareproducts.

The introduction of the Food and Drug Administrations (FDAs) longawaited sunscreen
monographwillinducenewinterestduringtheforecastperiodthrough2017.
Newregulationsonproductlabelingandformulationshavebeenforcedintoeffectin
December2012,andarelikelytoleadtoeffectivechangesduringthecomingyears.
TheFDAisexpectedtocomeupwithadecisionfortheproposedruleoflimitingthe
SPFto50,therebychangingthewayconsumersperceivehigherSPFproducts,andalso
alteringtheproductofferingsofEnergizerHoldingsbrandsinthecategory.Thiswould
require the marketer to reformulate some of its product offerings to bring down the
leveloftheirSPFclaims.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A126

EnergizerHoldings

Energizer Holdings brands in the shaving products category are likely to show moderate
growthovertheforecastperiod,althoughlowerthanthecompanysaverage.
The marketer is likely to introduce shaving products enriched with commonly used
naturalingredients,suchasaloe,vitaminAandE,sheabutter,cocoabutter,milk,and
honey.
The company is expected to undertake efforts to differentiate its brands from the
othersavailableinthemarket.
The company will continue to support its brands with good TME during the forecast
periodending2017.

SalesofEnergizerHoldingsareprojectedtoreach$487millionby2017,up4.2%annually
from$396millionin2012.

Table576:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforEnergizerHoldingsbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Suncareproducts

5.6

COMPANYAVERAGE

4.2

Shavingproducts

2.2

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5127

5128

EnergizerHoldings

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A128

ESTELAUDER

Table577:EsteLaudersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

Clinique

438

458

EsteLauder

291

322

LaMer

75

94

Origins

42

50

Aveda

35

36

BobbiBrown

29

32

MAC

19

22

BeautyBank

Prescriptives

939

1,023

Clinique

185

196

MAC

158

173

EsteLauder

113

115

BobbiBrown

40

44

Origins

17

18

SmashboxBeauty

11

12

Aveda

Totalr

531

565

MAC

134

140

Clinique

100

105

EsteLauder

48

49

BobbiBrown

29

30

SmashboxBeauty

18

19

FACIALTREATMENTS

Total
FACEMAKEUP

EYEMAKEUP

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5130

Este Lauder

Table577:EsteLaudersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

EYEMAKEUP(Continued)

2012

Origins

Aveda

Totalr

339

354

Beautiful

37

37

CashmereMist

25

26

Pleasures

20

23

Happy

18

18

CoachPoppy

18

13

AromaticsElixir

11

11

SensuousNude

10

11

10

BeDelicious

CoachPoppyFlower

JoMalone

WhiteLinen

CoachSignature

Knowing

HappyHeart

MichaelbyMichaelKors

Este

Pure

BeautifulLove

BeyondParadise

PleasuresDelight

PleasuresExotic

PureWhiteLinen

TommyGirl

UnforgivableWoman

VeryHollywoodMichaelKorsr

BeautifulSheer

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

YouthDew
Sensuous

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A130

Este Lauder

Table577:EsteLaudersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

2011

2012

Calyx

Cinnabar

Intuition

OriginsGingerEssence

PleasuresIntense

RedDeliciousWomen

Spellbound

TuscanyperDonna

244

238

MAC

80

88

Clinique

43

47

BobbiBrown

30

32

EsteLauder

28

29

Origins

13

14

SmashboxBeauty

10

11

Aveda

Totalr

209

226

Aveda

37

37

Bumbleandbumble

27

28

Total

64

65

Aveda

33

34

Bumbleandbumble

17

18

54

56

Aveda

32

33

Bumbleandbumble

13

14

47

49

Total
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

SHAMPOOS

Origins
Total
CONDITIONERS

Origins
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5131

5132

Este Lauder

Table577:EsteLaudersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

CliniqueSkinSuppliesforMen

18

19

LabSeriesSkincareforMen

10

11

32

34

Clinique

12

12

Origins

EsteLauder

28

29

Origins
Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS

Total
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

Origins

10

10

Clinique

Aveda

EsteLauder

26

26

Aramis

Coach

PleasuresforMen

HappyforMen

TomFordForMen

TomFordNoir

Tommy

IamKinga

Mustanga

Allother

29

24

NAILPOLISHES

EsteLauder

Clinique

MAC

Total

13

Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A132

Este Lauder

Table577:EsteLaudersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
Clinique

MAC

EsteLauder

Total

CliniqueSuppliesforMen

LabSeriesSkincareforMen

Origins

Total

2,569

2,722

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Origins
SHAVINGPRODUCTS

TOTALr

aDiscontinued.
rRestated.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

TheEsteLauderCompaniesisoneoftheworldsleadingmanufacturersandmarketersof
luxuryskincare,makeup,fragrance,haircare,andpersonalcareproducts.
Este Lauder was founded in 1946 by Mrs. Este Lauder. The flagship brand, Este
Lauder,waslaunchedwithfourproducts:SuperRichAllPurposeCreme,CremePack,
CleansingOil,andSkinLotion.
The company is listed on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol, EL.
Eventhoughitwentpublicin1995,themajorityofthecompanysstocksarestillheld
bythemembersoftheLauderfamily.
Its headquarters is located in New York, NY. Este Lauder has business activities
operational in 43 countries and territories. As of June, 2012, the company employs
38,500fulltimeemployeesglobally.
The company has approximately 12 manufacturing units in five countries: the United
States,Belgium,Switzerland,theUnitedKingdom,andCanada.
As of June 2012, Este Lauders research & development division employs
approximately500employeesacrossfiveprincipalfacilities:Melville,NY;Blaine,MN;
Oevel,Belgium;Ontario,Canada;andShanghai,China.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5133

5134

Este Lauder

Thecompanyoffersawiderangeofbrands,whichareorganizedintofourclustersbasedon
thedistributionchannelandconsumersegmentation.
Highendprestigebrandsandmakeupartistbrands:EsteLauder,MAC,BobbiBrown,
Prescriptives,LaMer,JoMalone,andTomFordBeauty.
Prestigeskincareandalternativechannels:Clinique,Origins,andOjon.
Fragrance licensing and creative incubator: Aramis and Designer Fragrances, and
BeautyBank.
Salonandpharmacychannel:Aveda,Bumbleandbumble,andDarphin.

Thecompanyhasanumberoflicenseagreementsforfragranceandbeautyproductswith
celebritiesinthefashionworld,includingKiton,TommyHilfiger,DonnaKaran,MichaelKors,
SeanJohn,Missoni,andTomFord.
EsteLaudersellsitsproductsinmorethan150countriesthroughdepartmentstores,
perfumeries, pharmacies, retail stores, travel retail outlets, prestige hair salons and
spas, freestanding company stores, specialty stores, directresponse television, stores
oncruiseships,inflight,dutyfreeshopsinairportsandcities,andtheInternet.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Corporate sales for Este Lauder grow 10.3% to $9,713.6million in 2012 from
$8,810.0millionin2011.
Netprofitsincreaseby22.3%from$700.8millionin2011to$856.9millionin2012.
Netsalesofthecompanyincreaseatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of6.7%
since2007.

Table578:EsteLaudersGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Fiscalyeara

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

2007

7,038.0

449.0

6.4

37.4

2008

7,910.8

473.8

6.0

28.7

2009

7,323.8

218.4

3.0

5.8

2010

7,795.8

478.3

6.1

19.0

2011

8,810.0

700.8

8.0

26.6

2012

9,713.6

856.9

8.8

31.4

NOTE:ThecompanysfiscalyearendsJune30.

The Americas region accounts for 42.2% of the companyssales in 2012, a decline in the
totalsharefrom43.1%in2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A134

Este Lauder

Table579:EsteLaudersGlobalSalesbyRegion,2011and2012

Region
TheAmericas
Europe,theMiddleEast,
andAfrica
AsiaPacific
Returnsassociatedwith
restructuringactivities
Total

$Million
2011
2012
3,796.3
4,101.1

%Oftotal
2011
2012
43.1
42.2

3,257.6

3,603.2

37.0

37.1

10.6

1,760.7

2,011.4

20.0

20.7

14.2

(4.6)

(2.1)

(0.1)

(54.3)

8,810.0

9,713.6

100.0

100.0

10.3

Change,%
8.0

The skin care product class is the leading product class and commands 43.5% of the
companysglobalcorporatesalesin2012,upfrom42.2%sharein2011.

Table580:EsteLaudersGlobalSalesbyProductClass,2011and2012

$Million

Productcategory

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Skincare

3,718.6

4,225.2

42.2

43.5

13.6

Makeup

3,370.8

3,696.8

38.3

38.1

9.7

Fragrance

1,236.0

1,271.0

14.0

13.1

2.8

Haircare

432.3

462.4

4.9

4.8

7.0

Allother

56.9

60.3

0.6

0.6

6.0

Returnsassociatedwith
restructuringactivities

(4.6)

(2.1)

(0.1)

(54.3)

8,810.0

9,713.6

100.0

Total

100.0

10.3

North American department stores, in conjunction with international department stores,


are the biggest retail channel for Este Lauder in 2012, accounting for 54.0% of the
companyssales.

Table581:EsteLaudersGlobalSalesbyDistributionChannel,2012
Distributionchannel

%Ofsales

Internationaldepartmentstores

27

NorthAmericandepartmentstores

27

Perfumeries

13

Travelretail

11

Retailstores

10

Salonsandspas

Allother

Total

100

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5135

5136

Este Lauder

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Thecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesincreaseby6.0%from$2,569millionin2011
to$2,722millionin2012.
SaleshavegrownataCAGRof1.5%since2007.

Table582:EsteLaudersCosmeticsandToiletriesSales,
2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

2,526

2008

2,450

(3.0)

2009

2,332

(4.8)

2010

2,399

2.9

2011

2,569

7.1

2012

2,722

6.0

rRestated.

EsteLauderleadsthefacialtreatmentsproductscategorywitha15.4%marketshare.
ItdominatestheluxurysegmentwithitsCliniqueandEsteLauderbrands.
Thecompanyssalesinthecategorygrow8.9%during2012,approximatelytwicethe
industryaverageof4.4%.
EsteLaudersCliniquecontinuestobethelargestluxurybrand,withnearly22%share
ofthetotalluxuryfacialtreatmentsales.
Salesofthebrandatthemanufacturerslevelgrowby4.6%from$438millionin2011
to$458millionin2012.
WhileCliniqueiscertainlythecategorysluxuryleader,sevenpercentagepointsahead
ofitsclosestcompetitor,andcontinuestogrowsalesatahealthyrate,thebrandloses
somemarketshareduringtheyearasotherbrandscatchupbyintroducingproducts
similar to those previously introduced by Clinique, such as BB Creams and dark spot
correctors.
The Even Better line is expanded with a Dark Circle Corrector for the eyes and the
MoistureSurgelinelaunchesanIntenseSkinFortifyingHydrator.
Este Lauders flagship brand Este Lauder is the secondlargest brand in the luxury
segmentwith$322millioninsalesin2012,up10.7%from$291millionin2011.
Severalnewproductsarelaunchedduringtheyear,whichareallextensionsofexisting
lines.
DayWearisextendedwiththelaunchofaBBCrme.
TimeZoneisextendedwithAdvancedTimeZoneAgeReversingWrinkleCrmewhich
thecompanyclaimscanrewindthevisiblesignsofaginginfivedays.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A136

Este Lauder

The Perfectionist line is extended with Perfectionist [CP&R] Wrinkle Lifting/Firming


Serumwhichclaimstocorrect,prevent,andrepairskinbycreatingavirtualforcefield
againstlinesandwrinklesbyacceleratingnaturalcollagenbuildingpower.
TheReNutrivlineisextendedwithtwosetsofproductduos:ReCreationFaceCrme
and Night Serum, and Eye Balm and Night Serum for Eyes. Both of these products
contain Glacial BioExtract, a new ingredient from the water beneath the Antarctic
glaciers.
Traceable media expenditures (TMEs) for Este Lauder facial treatments are
$47.7millionin2012,upfrom$44.5millionin2011.

EsteLauderasacompanymovesdowntosecondpositioninthefacemakeupcategoryin
2012eventhoughthecompanyincreasesitscategorysharefrom18.7%in2011to19.2%in
2012.
SalesofEsteLaudertotal$558millionin2012,up6.5%from$524millionin2011.
TheEsteLauderCompaniesInc.increasesitsadvertisingexpensesto$53.7millionin
2012, up from $34.1million in 2011. Close to 95% of advertising dollars is used to
support its Clinique and Este Lauder brands. Products specifically supported include
CliniquesEvenBetterandStayMatteOilFreefoundationandEsteLaudersDouble
WearandInvisiblefoundationlines.Lessthan1%ofadvertisingexpenditureisusedto
supporttheAerinline,whichincludesblushandlipstick.
Withtheexceptionofthenamesakebrand,EsteLauder,thecompanysluxurybrands
outperformthemarket.Productlaunchesforthebrandin2012arenotenoughtofuel
brandsalesbeyondthe1.8%growth.
The companys two leading brandsMAC and Cliniqueaccount for 65.3% of Este
Lauderstotalfacemakeupsalesin2012.
Thetopperformingbrandsinthecompanysportfolioin2012includeMAC,up9.5%;
Bobbi Brown, up 10.0%; and Smashbox Beauty, up 9.1%. Advertising supports Bobbi
BrownsfoundationandconcealerkitandSmashboxsCameraReadyFoundationand
PhotoFinishFoundationPrimer.
Thenamesakebrand,EsteLauder,hasaninnovativemarketingcampaigncobranding
with the television show, Madmen, to promote a collection including limited edition
lipstickandcrmerouge.Thebrandsupportsthecollectionwithhalfmilliondollarsin
advertising.
In 2012, sales for Aveda and BeautyBank brands remain flat. BeautyBank, sold
exclusively at Kohls, with brands including Flirt and American Beauty, faces
competitionfromnewbrand,VeraWang,thatentersKohlsin2012,andElle,whichis
alsosoldatKohls.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5137

5138

Este Lauder

In the eye makeup category, the companys third largest, sales of Este Lauder grow by
4.4%to$354millionin2012from$339millionin2011.
EsteLauderisthesecondleadingmarketerintheeyemakeupcategory,with13.1%of
salesin2012.
MACandCliniqueareEsteLaudersleadingbrands,withsalesat$140million,up4.5%
and$105million,up5.0%,respectively,in2012.
MACandCliniquecollectivelyrepresent63%ofEsteLauderstotaleyemakeupsales
in2012.
MACsgrowthisrecognizedbythesuccessofseveralnewproductsacrossthecategory
includingFalseLashesmascara,PaintPots,EyeBrows,aswellasseveraleyeliners.
Cliniques growth comes from its new Chubby Stick Shadow Tint, the existing Lid
SmoothieAntioxidant8HourEyeColor,aswellasthenewHighImpactmascara.
TheEsteLauderbrandgrowsonly2.1%in2012toreach$49millioninsales.Growthis
attributed partly to its newest mascaras Sumptuous Extreme Waterproof and
SumptuousTwoToneEyeOpeningmascara,andthelaunchofPureColorPaintPots.
EsteLaudersTMEfor2012is$12.7million,upfrom$3.7millionin2011.

Inwomensfragrance,EsteLauderremainsinthirdplaceofcompanyranking,byhaving
threeofthetop11luxuryfragrances.
Thecompanyhasan8.8%categoryshare,downfrom9.3%in2011,assalesdip2.5%
duringtheyear.
Beautifulssalesareflatfrom2011,whileCashmereMistandPleasureshaveincreasing
sales.Thesethreearethecompanyslargestfragrancesbrands.
Asidefrom scentsunderthemajor beautybrandssuchas EsteLauderandClinique,
the company works to put together a strong portfolio of designer brands including
Donna Karan, Coach, Michael Kors, Tommy Hilfiger, and more recently Ermenegildo
Zegna,ToryBurch,andMarni.ThecompanyacquiredthefragrancefranchisesforZegna,
Burch,andMarniinlate2011,andishandledbytheAramisandDesignerFragrances
divisionofEsteLauder.
TheDonnaKaranfranchiseisextendedin2012withthefalllaunchofWoman.
InitialscentsfromZegnaandMarni,launchinearly2013,andanewCoachscentcalled
LovelaunchesintimeforValentinesDay.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A138

Este Lauder

Este Lauder Companies is the secondleading marketer in the lipsticks and lip glosses
category,withsalesat$226million,increasing8.1%from$209millionin2011.
EsteLauder,asacompany,holdsacategoryshareof16.4%in2012,upfrom15.5%in
2011.
AllEsteLaudersbrandsgrowin2012.
The companys leading brand, MAC, contributes the most dollars, up 10.0% to reach
$88 million in 2012. MAC launches several new products in this category. Its original
lipstickprovidesadditionaldollarstothebrandssales.
MACallocatesmostofitsadvertisingbudgetof$3.7million,whichisup20%from2011,
to promote its lipsticks and nail polishes using multiplepage print advertisements.
MAC receives editorial pieces for its Marilyn Monroe collection of 29 items including
lipstick.
Clinique is the secondleading brand for the company in the luxury trade class with
salesat$47millionin2012,up9%from$43millionin2011.
TheCliniquebrandissupportedwithcloseto$24millioninTMEin2012.Over90%of
theTMEisusedtopromoteitsChubbyStickproduct.
TheBobbiBrownbrandisup6.7%in2012,reaching$32millioninsales,mainlydueto
shadeextensionsacrossalllipproductsandincreasedadvertising.Thebrandsignson
actressKatieHolmesasitsfirstcelebrityspokesperson.However,salesdeclinefromits
doubledigitgrowthin2011.
Origins is up 7.7%, totaling $14million in 2012 from $13million in 2011. The brand
capitalizes on trends with a variety of lip products in formats that consumers desire,
suchasliquid,chubbypencils,andanourishinglipstickwithitsFlowerFusionproduct.
Este Lauder decreases advertising for its namesake brand in 2012, and uses that
allocatedtopromoteitsPureColorlipstick.

SalesofEsteLauderinthehaircareproductclassgrow3.0%from$165millionin2011to
$170millionin2012.
Hairstylingproductsandspraysisthelargesthaircarecategoryforthemarketerinthe
productclasswithasalesgainof1.6%toreach$65millionin2012,upfrom$64million
in2011.
The company is represented in the hair styling products and sprays category with its
AvedaandBumbleandBumblebrands.
Shampoosisthesecondlargesthaircarecategoryforthemarketerwithsalesin2012
at$56million,up3.7%from$54millionin2011.
The marketers performance in the conditioners category grows 4.3% to reach
$49millionin2012,upfrom$47millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5139

5140

Este Lauder

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergersandacquisitions

Therearenomergersandacquisitionsin2012.

Managementchanges

Thefiscalyear2012seesimportantchangeswithexpansionofrolesofexecutiveswithin
themanagement.
TraceyT.TravisisappointedasExecutiveVicepresidentandChiefFinancialOfficerof
TheEsteLauderCompanies.Travisassumesherpositionfromthe20thAugust,2012
replacingRichardW.Kunes.
Richard W. Kunes is appointed as the Executive Vice President and Senior Advisor to
theChiefExecutiveOfficer.
Thia Breen and Lynne Greene are appointed as Group President at Este Lauder
Companies,effectiveJanuary1,2013.LynneGreene,PresidentoftheCliniquebrand,
takesontheroleastheGroupPresidentofClinique,Origins,Ojon,Aveda,andDarphin.
Thia Breen, who is currently President of North America, will add Canada to her
responsibilities.
JaneLauder,theglobalpresidentandgeneralmanageroftheOriginsandOjonbrands,
nowaddsthebrandDarphintoherrelationshipresponsibilities.
PeterLichtenthal,PresidentofBumbleandBumble,willalsooverseeSmashbox.
John Dempsey, Group President of Este Lauder, will add Bumble and bumble to his
responsibilitiesfromJanuary1,2013.
JamesGagerisappointedSeniorVicePresident,GroupCreativeDirectortooverseeall
thecreativeactivityofMACCosmetics,LaMer,andJoMalone.

Otherdevelopments

EsteLaudersMACCosmeticswinsa$90millionjudgmentagainstChinesecybersquatters
sellingcounterfeitMACbeautyproducts.ThelawsuitwasfiledagainstTingtingChen,Limei
Weng, and Zhang Guithe, and others who operated 112 web sites including,
themaccosmetics.com,
mac2wholesale.com,
maccosmeticworld.com,
wholesalemacmakeup.com,andcheapmakeuppick.com.
ThejudgeorderedthatanyfundsinthePaypalaccountattachedtotheinfringingsites
tobegiventoEsteLauder.Additionally,thirdpartyproviders,suchasonlinebusiness
tobusiness selling platforms, backend service providers, search engines, web
designers,Internetserviceproviders,domainnameregistrars,andshippers,tostopall
servicestotheChinesecybersquatters.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A140

Este Lauder

In 2012, Este Lauder enters into a license agreement with American luxury sportswear
brandTonyBurch,andMilanbasedfashioncompanyMarni.
TheseadditionswillstrengthenthemarketersAramisandDesignerFragrances(ADF)
portfolioofbrands.ThelicensingagreementgivesEsteLauderexclusiveglobalrights
to market fragrances under the Ermenegildo Zegna Group, as well as develop new
productlinesinthegroomingsegment.

NOTABLENEWPRODUCTS

Table583:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyEsteLauderintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

BobbiBrown

Eyemakeup

LimitedEditionEyeShadowPaletteCollections

BobbiBrown

Facemakeup

LongWearEvenFinishCompactFoundation

BobbiBrown

Facemakeup

SkinFoundationMineralMakeupSPF15.Claimstoprovidenatural
finishwithaweightlessfeelandnaturalfinish

BobbiBrown

Facialtreatments

BBCreamcombinesmoisturizer,treatment,SPF,andlightmakeupin
oneproduct

BobbiBrown

Lipsticksandlipglosses

RichLipColorSPF12,reformulatedandlightweight,combines
pigmentswithaclearbasetodeliverpurecolor

BobbiBrown

Lipsticksandlipglosses

HighShimmerLipGlosswithlightcatchingshimmerandlasting,non
stickyshine,madewithfinepearlsandclearpigments

Bumbleandbumble

Conditioners

ColorMindedconditionerisinfusedwithdualpolymertechnology
thatisdesignedtomakehairimpermeabletowater,reducingboth
colorwashoutandfading

Clinique

Eyemakeup

LidSmoothieAntioxidant8HourEyeColor,acreamy,crease
resistanteyecolorin12shades.Featuresametalapplicatorthat
feelscoolontheeyelid.Containsantioxidantsthataresaidtohelp
protecttheskinaroundtheeyearea

Clinique

Eyemakeup

BottomLashMascarawithaspecialbrushfortinytasksanda
formulathatpreventssmears.Canbeusedwithanymascaraontop
lashes

Clinique

Facemakeup

RepairwearLaserFocusAllSmoothMakeupSPF15.Anupdated
formulathatissheerandcontainsRepairwearLaserFocusserum.
Theliquidfoundationisavailablein12shades

Facialtreatments

EvenBetterEyesDarkCircleCorrectorisalightweight,oilfree
hydratingeyeserumclaimedtobeclinicallyproventovisiblylighten
darkcirclesby30%in12weeks.Skinstrengtheningingredientsmake
skinlesstransparent.Coolingmassagetipbreaksuppuffs.Sheer
opticsinstantlybrightensallskintypes,fromfairtodeep

Facialtreatments

CliniqueMoistureSurgeIntenseSkinFortifyingHydratorlaunchedin
late2011,isanoilfree,creamgelhydratorthatkeepsskinplumped
for24hours.Alsohelpstofortifyandrepairskinsmoisturebarrier
withcontinuoususe.AgeDefenseBBCreamSPFisamultifunctional
beautyproductthatprovidesskinprotectionandhelpsbanish
imperfections

Clinique

Clinique

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5141

5142

Este Lauder

Table583:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyEsteLauderintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Clinique

Eyemakeup

ChubbyStickShadowTint

Clinique

Facemakeup

PoreRefiningSolutionsInstantPerfectingMakeup

Clinique

Facialtreatments

EvenBetterEyesDarkCircleCorrectorisalightweight,oilfree
hydratingeyeserumclaimedtobeclinicallyproventovisiblylighten
darkcirclesby30%in12weeks.Skinstrengtheningingredientsmake
skinlesstransparent.Coolingmassagetipbreaksuppuffs.Sheer
opticsinstantlybrightensallskintypes,fromfairtodeep

Clinique

Facialtreatments

MoistureSurgeIntenseSkinFortifyingHydratorisacreamgelthat
providesmaximumhydrationplusabarriertostrengthenandrepair
theskin

Clinique

Lipsticksandlipglosses

ChubbyStickMoisturizingLipColorBalm

CliniqueSkinSupplies
forMen

Skincareproductsfor
men

DarkSpotCorrectorisaserumformensskinthathelpsreducethe
appearanceofdarkspots,acnescars,andsunspotsonallkindsof
skintypesandtones.Helpsreduceingrownhairandresultsstart
becomingvisibleinaslessasfourweeks

DonnaKaren

Fragrancesforwomen

Womanhastopnotesofsandalwoodandorangeblossom

EsteLauder

Eyemakeup

PureColorStayOnShadowPaint

EsteLauder

Facemakeup

DoubleWearStayInPlacePowder

EsteLauder

Facemakeup

DoubleWearStayInPlaceConcealerSPF10

EsteLauder

Facemakeup

PureColorSensuousRouge

EsteLauder

Facialtreatments

AdvancedNightRepairlineisextendedwithaneyeserumtosmooth
puffinessandfirmtheeyearea

EsteLauder

Facialtreatments

AdvancedTimeZoneAgeReversingLine/WrinkleCrmeclaimsto
helprewindthevisiblesignsofaginginjustfivedays

EsteLauder

Facialtreatments

DayWearBBCrmefightsagainstenvironmentalhazardswhile
protectingtheskin

EsteLauder

Facialtreatments

Perfectionist[CP+R]WrinkleLifting/FirmingSerumclaimstocorrect,
prevent,andrepairskinbycreatingavirtual"forcefield"against
linesandwrinklesbysuperchargingnaturalcollagenbuildingpower

EsteLauder

Facialtreatments

ReNutrivlineisextendedwithtwosetsofproductduos:ReCreation
FaceCrmeandNightSerum,andEyeBalmandNightSerumfor
Eyes.Thesehighendproductsaresuperchargedwithanew
ingredientsourcedfromdeepwaterbeneathAntarcticglacierscalled
GlacialBioExtract

EsteLauder

Lipsticksandlipglosses

PureColorLipstick

EsteLauder

Nailpolishes

PureColorVividShinenailpolish

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

Skincareproductsfor
men

MAXLSDailyRenewingCleanserisaMoleculeAgeLessComplexthat
combineswiththeoxygenationactionwashingawayimpurities
withoutaffectingtheskinsnaturalPHbalance

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

Skincareproductsfor
men

MAXLSSkinRechargingWaterLotionisaweightlesshydratinglotion
thatisformulatedwithMoleculeAgeLessComplexcomprising
Aquatrontechnologytoremoveold,dead,anddullskinwithout
affectingtheskinsnaturalPHbalance

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A142

Este Lauder

Table583:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyEsteLauderintheUnitedStatesin2012

Brand

Category

Description

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

Skincareproductsfor
men

MAXLSLightMoistureLotion,formulatedwithSirtuintechnology
andMolecularAgeLessComplex,isalightweightdailymoisturizing
treatmentthatpreventsandrepairssignsofaging

LabSeriesSkincare
ForMen

Skincareproductsfor
men

InstantSkinBoosterisformulatedwithFirmaboostComplexto
tightenanduplifttheskinontheoutsideandstrengthentheskins
naturalcollageninternally

MAC

Eyemakeup

FalseLashesmascara

MAC

Facemakeup

MineralizeBlush&Highlighter

MAC

Facemakeup

MatchmasterFoundationSPF15

MAC

Lipsticksandlipglosses

ProLongwearLipPencil

Origins

Facialtreatments

MegabrightSkinToneCorrectingSerumclaimstobeclinically
proventohelpreducetheappearanceofdarkspotsinfourweeks
whileinstantlyleavingskinbrighterandmoreradiant

Origins

Facialtreatments

MakeaDifferencePlusRejuvenatingMoisturizerisarejuvenating
moisturizerfortifiedwithRoseofJerichoplusabreakthroughLychee
andWatermelonhydrasustaincomplexwhichquenchesdeepto
helprepairthenaturalmoisturedeficiencyindry,dehydratedskin.
Clinicallyproventoinstantlyboostskin'smoisturereservoirtokeepit
hydratedandrejuvenatedallday

Origins

Shavingproducts

BladeRunnerisenrichedwithkukuinutoil,soyabeanoil,andother
plantprotectors.Itsfragranceisablendofcoriander,Australian
eucalyptus,Frenchpeppermint,andothernaturalrevivers

Origins

Skincareproductsfor
men

SaveTheMalesisamultibenefitoilfreelotionthatkeepstheskin
healthyandhydrated.Itisenrichedwithnaturalingredientssuchas
carrotprotein,Chinesewolfberry,mangosteenextract,andwhite
birch

Smashbox

Eyemakeup

PhotoOpEyeEnhancingPaletteforblue,brown,andhazeleyes

SmashboxCosmetics

Facialtreatments

CameraReadyBBcreamcontainsanoilcontrolformulationwith
emollientsandopticalpearlpigmentstoprovidehydrationand
reducefinelinesandwrinklesafteronlyfourweeks.Containssun
protectionandcomesinmultipleshades

SmashboxCosmetics

Lipsticksandlipglosses

BeLegendaryLipstick

TomFord

Fragrancesformen

TomFordNoirhastopnotesofbergamot,verbena,caraway,pink
pepper,andviolet

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5143

5144

Este Lauder

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Este Lauder supports its brands with TMEs of $385.6 million in 2012, up 41.9% from
$271.7millionin2011.
The company supports the launch of its new products with an effective pullpush
marketing mix, composed of a combination of television, print, digital application,
stores,andwebsites.
CliniquereceivesthehighestadvertisingsupportwithaTMEof$135.3millionin2012,
up27.5%from$106.1millionin2011.
Este Lauders flagship brand, Este Lauder, follows close behind with a TME of
$133.5millionin2012,upalmost50%fromapproximately$89millioninTMEin2011.
ThecompanysupportsitsfacialtreatmentswiththehighestTMEof$142.7millionin
2012.ThecategoryreceivedaTMEof$125.2millionin2011.
CliniquesEvenBetterClinicalDarkSpotCorrectorSerumcontinuestoreceivethemost
TMEsupportwith$49.6millionin2012,up50.8%from$32.9millionin2011.Product
advertisements include an impactful use of a spotted egg transitioning to a flawless
finish,illustratingthebenefitsoftheproduct.
Este Lauders Idealist Even Skintone Illuminator Serum receives the secondhighest
TMEat$25.9millionin2012,marginallyupfrom$25.5millionin2011.
In 2012, Clinique airs its first television advertisement to support its Even Better
makeup SPF 15 Foundation. In the same year, Clinique also introduces a television
advertisementforitsChubbyStickMoisturizingLipcolorBalm.
Avedas newest hair care system, Invanti, is supported by the brands first ever
televisioncampaign,whichiswellreceivedbyconsumersandhelpsupliftthesalesof
thecompany.

Este Lauders most favored marketing media include traditional advertising methods, in
theformofprintadvertisementsandtelevisioncommercials.
The marketer conducts a lot of magazine advertisements to promote Este Lauder
products. Advertising is done typically in national fashion magazines such as Vogue,
Glamour,Allure,andElle.
Este Lauders emphasis on digital and television advertising has led the marketer to
expanditsconsumeroutreachandattractconsumersfromthemassmarket,especially
towardsitsClinique,EsteLauder,andMACcosmeticsbrands.
Televisioncommercialscontinuetogainimportanceasoneofthepreferredadvertising
media, with a TME support of $163 million in 2012, up 67.2% from $97.5 million in
2011.
Brands, such as Tom Ford beauty and Smashbox, use the traditional print media to
promotetheirproducts.
ThemajorityofCliniquesadvertisingspendingisdirectedtowardwomensmagazines
through fullpage advertisements. These advertisements highlight the message that
Cliniqueisallergytestedandpositionsitselfas100%fragrancefree.
CliniquestelevisionadvertisementsforitsEvenBetterClinicalhavebeeninstrumental
inattractingmassmarketconsumerstowardstheprestigemarket.
In 2012, the marketer conducts the first national advertising campaign for its color
cosmeticswithacommercialforitsCliniqueChubbyStick.Theadvertisementgoeson
airinMayandlastsuntilfall.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A144

Este Lauder

Este Lauder continues to capitalize on its Internet marketing initiatives as an important


meanstoreachouttoconsumersin2012.
TheCliniquewebsiteofferssamples,orevenatwoweeksupplyofaparticularproduct
which a certain minimum purchase. The website also highlights the ongoing offer of
theday.
Purchases through Cliniques website receive free shipping every day, no matter the
valueofthepurchase.
During2012,CliniqueoffersatwoweeksupplyofRepairwearLaserFocusatcounter
with no purchase necessary, to encourage trial. After a return consultation, another
twoweek supply is issued, so that the consumer will have four weeks to try out the
product.
CliniquemaintainstheInsidersClub,whichcustomerscanjoinafterenteringtheire
mail address on the brands website. The Insiders Club provides customers with an
insidescooponCliniquesproducts,freetreats,andseveralothertreatsexclusiveonly
tothemembersoftheclub.

InstoremarketingisanextremelyimportantmarketingmediumadoptedbyEsteLauder
topromoteitsproducts.
EsteLauderoftenpartnerswithkeyprestigeretailersforitsadvertisingeffortsandin
storeeventstospursales.
The marketers promotional activity within stores generally centers on bringing
consumers to the beauty counters, where sales personnel offer free makeovers,
consultations,andproductsamples.
EsteLaudersupportsitsmakeupproductsthroughcomplimentarymakeoversoffered
inselectretailstores.
In 2012, Emily Schuman, creator of the blog Cupcakes and Cashmere and Este
Lauders guest blogger, stops at Bloomingdales for signing her first book called
Cupcakes and Cashmere: A Guild For DefiningYour Style,Reinventing Your Space and
EntertainingwithEase.ThebooksigningsattractsmanynewandexistingEsteLauder
consumersandhavedoubledthemarketersexpectationsduringeachoftheauthors
appearance.
Alsoin2012,CliniquesassociationwithmodelturnedactivistPetraNemcova,boosts
traffic at department stores such as Bloomingdales where she makes a guest
appearance. The brand also assigns the tag Happy Day to December 14, 2012
wherein, the companys executives assist the beauty advisers at retailers throughout
thedistributionnetwork.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5145

5146

Este Lauder

Este Lauder relies primarily on giftwithpurchase (GWP) and purchasewithpurchase


(PWP) promotions, and also on a wide range of other promotional efforts including
sampling.
Clinique, the luxury segment market leader, relies primarily on GWP and PWP
promotionofferstopromoteitsbrandsandhelpdrivesales.
Makeup cases, either generic or from a designer such Tracy Reese or Trina Turk, are
commonly included as part of Cliniques GWP or PWP promotions at leading
departmentstores.Insidethesemakeupcasesareanarrayoflongstandingandsome
new products for the consumer to try, typically offered with a purchase of $28.00 or
more.
EsteLauderoffersfreeshippingwithbeautypurchasesoveracertainamountas an
incentivetoencouragepurchase.
EsteLauderdistributessamplesofitsproductstoitsconsumers,especiallysamplesof
newproducts.
Commonsamplingmethodsadoptedbythemarketerincludefragrancevialsattached
to cards, scented strips in magazines, and scented blotter cards distributed at retail
stores. Other forms of sampling in stores include deluxe miniatures and scented
ribbons.
Este Lauder offers free samples, a choice of an Este Lauder perfume, mascara, or
facialproduct,witheveryonlineorder.
During 2012, Este Lauder holds a monthly sweepstakes in which the grand prize
winnerreceivesa$350.00shoppingvoucher.Consumersenterthepromotionbyfilling
outaformonthebrandswebsite,withnopurchaserequired.

Socialanddigitalmediaplayaprominentroleinthecompanysmarketingandpromotional
strategy,withthemarketersintroducingnewsocialmediaandecommercecampaignsfor
almosteachofitsbeautybrands.
The marketer uses the increasingly popular social media channels in the form of
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTubetopromoteitsproducts.
In2012,EmilySchumanpostsweeklyonthecompanyswebsitewithcontentfromthe
posts being shared on Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, YouTube, and Instagram. Emily
Schumans stepbystep athome manicure guide on Facebook has gained popularity.
Otherpopularpostsincludevideotutorialsoncreatingametallicsmokyeyelookand
thegildedfademanicure.
In 2012, Este Lauder launches the Bobbi Brown Brings Back: Lip Color whereby
consumers have a chance to vote for one of the 10 discontinued lip shades creating
curiosityamongthebrandsloyalistsandanticipatingpurchase.
Twitterhasbeenanimportantsiteforthemarketer.InApril2012,themarketerstarts
acampaignonTwitterwherebyitusespromotedtweetsandensuresthatitsmessage
staysinthenewsfeedofthetargetedconsumeraudience.
In2012,MACCosmeticsemployeesutilizemicrobloggingsites,suchasTwitter,under
theiraccountnamestointeractwithconsumers.
Smashboxs Lights, Camera, BB! Facebook application educates consumers on the
benefits of the brands latest product introductions and also allows consumers to
featureinitsBBcommercial.
Cliniques Chubby Stick digital campaign on Facebook includes a mixandmatch
concept for lip shades whereby the marketer induces multiple purchases from
consumersbyshowingtheresultswhentwoorthreeChubbyStickarecombined.The
resultcanalsobeemailedtoafriendintheformofadigitalkiss.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A146

Este Lauder

Este Lauder steps up its importance towards digitalization as an important marketing


mediumin2012.
In an attempt to build brand awareness and expand its consumer base, the brand
introduces the digital send a sample application which allows consumers to try the
brandsproductsfreeofcostin2012.

In 2012, the marketer increases the digital pull efforts for its Bobbi Brown brand.
Initiatives include the Bobbi Brown Blog whereby the brands representatives
interactdirectlywiththeconsumerscreatingapersonalrelationshipbetweenthetwo
parties.Theblogbecomesaninstanthitwithconsumersattractingseveralviews.
To promote its Clinique Chubby Stick, the marketer designs a digital campaign
comprisingdigitalmarketingandmarketingthroughtaxitopsandtaxitelevisionswhich
begintoappearinMay.
In 2012, Clinique gives its departmentstore selling space a makeover by creating an
environment for consumers that is free of interference from a salesperson. The
CliniquestoreshaveasignboardreadingCarryaCliniquebrowsingbasketandwell
leaveyoualone.Promiseabovethestackofshoppingbasketswiththeavailabilityof
whitecoatedlabconsultantsatanygivenpointoftime.Cliniquehasswitchedtothe
useofopensellingenvironment.Accordingtothenewprogram,thecompanyinstructs
itssalesconsultantstoloosenupabitwiththeirsalesskillsandjudgecustomersbased
ontheirbodylanguage.CliniquealsooffersanewapproachknownastheServiceAs
youLikeItwherebyconsumerscanopenupdrawersandhelpthemselvestoproducts
without taking any permission. Consumers shopping needs also depends on their
moods and the time they have at their disposal. The brand has also taken into
considerationtheroadblocksthatwerehavinganegativeimpactonthebrandssales,
such as displaying the prices of the products upfront, availability of more mirrors
includingalipstickdisplaywhichismountedonthewallwithamirrorunderneathit,an
array of containers containing cotton swabs and tissues, and different tester wand
typesformascarastocorrespondtothemascarawandsinsidethetubeofaparticular
product.
In 2012, Este Lauder makes the atthecounter experience more meaningful for its
Clinique brand by launching the Experience Bar at its Bloomingdales 59th Street
flagshipstoreinManhattan.TheExpansionBaristhenewestadditiontoCliniquesAs
YouLikeItProgramthatfeaturesseveniPadsthatprovidepersonalanalysisandgives
skin care advice in nine languages. The bar also provides the worlds first musical
testers.ThebarfeaturestheinstallediPadsand11leadingCliniqueproductsmounted
on the wall arranged according to significancebest sellers, dermatological concerns
and solutions, serums, and moisturizers. Above the bar, on the wall are mounted
screensthatflashvideos,images,andinformation.Thetesterunitsaredesignedina
waythatinadditiontodispensingtheproductsample,italsoplaysamusicalinterlude
which signifies the character of the product, when the consumer presses the button.
Consumersfirststepofusingthebarinvolvesansweringninebasicquestionsonthe
iPad through its proprietary software program. The possible combination of answers
can lead to 180,000 possible recommendations with 52 million logic pathways in the
program. Customers can also get a print of their recommendations. Consumers also
havetheoptionofemailingtothemselvesthelistofsuggestions.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5147

5148

Este Lauder

Este Lauder organizes and sponsors events and charity shows and is associated with a
number of campaigns as a means to stay in the limelight with the wealthier segment of
societyanddisplayitsphilanthropicinitiatives.
EveryyearMACCosmeticsusesacelebritytoendorseatrademarkproductforitsViva
GlamCampaign.In2012,ithasselectssingersNickiMinajandRickyMartintopromote
the bubblegumpink lipstick and colorless unisex lip conditioner, respectively. The
unique feature of MACs Viva Glam Campaign making it different from other brands
celebrity endorsements is that all the proceeds from the Viva Glam products are
donated to the MAC AIDS Fund. The print advertisement for the 2012 campaign
features Nicki Minaj crawling on a motorcycle dressed in a pink dress while Ricky
Martinisfeaturedstandingbehindthemotorcycle,weightliftingagiantlipstick.
TheMACAIDSFundandtheVivaGlamCampaignhavecontinuedtoraisemoneyfor
AIDS research, bring about awareness for AIDS prevention, and attract celebrities.
Este Lauder uses the strategy of choosing rock stars, models, and actresses over
doctors and public health officials to bring about awareness for HIV and AIDS
prevention, as consumers are more interested in what these celebrities have to say,
anditmakesamorelastingimpression.
In2012,themarketercelebratesthe20thAnniversaryoftheEsteLauderCompanies'
Breast Cancer Awareness campaign (BCA), which is now active in over 70 countries
worldwide.In20years,theBCAhasraised$35millionforresearchandeducation.The
2012CampaignthemeisCourage.Themarketersbrandshavejoinedtogethertosell
Pink Ribbon products to raise awareness for breast cancer and funds for medical
research.PinkRibbonproductsincludebrandssuchasEsteLauder,Clinique,andLab
Series Skincare for Men, and Bumble and bumble. On October 1st, 2012 the Empire
State Building is illuminated and the day is officially proclaimed as the "The Este
LauderCompaniesBreastCancerAwarenessCampaignDay."Thecompanyencourages
consumerstovisitFacebook.com/BCACampaigntopostamessageandBCAwilldonate
$1 to the Breast Cancer Research Foundation for every milestone of courage posted
throughout October. Another of the marketers social initiatives includes Clinique
association with model Petra Nemcova who has turned into an education advocate
with her Happy Hearts Fund, which assists children affected by natural disasters.
Nemcova survived the 2004 tsunami when she was vacationing in Thailand, but her
fiancwaskilled.Cliniqueorganizesafundraisingeventforthesaleofapproximately
30 million Clinique Happy Heart womans fragrance and Make Someone Happy t
shirts.Cliniquedonates$10.00and$5.00foreverybottleoffragranceandtshirtsold,
respectively.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A148

Este Lauder

SamplingisofextremeimportancetoEsteLaudersoverallmarketingstrategy.
Este Lauder believes in distributing a lot of samples to its consumers, especially
samplesfornewproducts.
EsteLaudersvalueorientedgiftsetscontinuetobeavailableroundtheyear,asthey
appealtotheconsumersdesireforvarietyandvalue.
Common sampling methods for fragrances include fragrance vials attached to cards,
scentedstripsinmagazines,andscentedblottercardsdistributedatretailstores.Other
formsofsamplinginstoresincludedeluxeminiaturesandscentedribbons.
Este Lauder offers samples and free shipping of products for its leading brands
CliniqueandEsteLauderforordersaboveaspecificvalue,suchas$25.00or$35.00.
The brand offers samples from a choice of Este Lauder perfumes, mascara, or facial
productswitheveryonlineorder.

Este Lauders promotional offers are available in the brands newsletter via email on a
regularbasiswithitsregisteredusers.
EsteLaudersnewsletteroffercouponsandongoinginsightsaboutthebrand.
Additionally, the avenues to receive coupons or price rebates have continued to
increaseduringthelasttwotothreeyears.
Este Lauders price promotion offers are available on the brands website, various
retailerswebsites,mobilemarketing,andsocialmediapages.
EsteLauderhasbeenknowntoofferperonlineorderasample,achoiceofanEste
Lauder perfume, mascara, or facial product. Periodically, Este Lauder offers free
shippingforonlineorders,withnominimumamountrequired.

EsteLauderalsointroducesanumberoflimitededitionproductsasapartofitsmarketing
strategytokeeptheconsumersinterestedinitsproducts.
The marketer introduces a multidimensional, limited edition trendcollection for Fall
2012calledtheEsteLauderPureColorVioletUnderground.

OUTLOOK

EsteLauderssalesareforecasttogrowataCAGRof4.2%duringtheforecastperiod.The
companyisexpectedtooutshineitscompetitorsintheprestigemarketduringtheforecast
period,2012to2017.
The combination of innovative products backed by robust marketing is likely to fuel
growthovertheforecastperiod.
The company will focus its efforts on the introduction of a few big and wellplanned
innovativeproductsthatwillhavethedesiredimpactontheconsumers.
Increasedadvertisingexpendituresacrosstelevision,print,anddigitalmediatailoredto
thecustomneedsofeverybrandwillhelpdrivethesalesforthemarketersindividual
brands.EsteLauderisexpectedtoplayonitsstrengthsbyfocusingondevelopingits
biggestbrands,leveragingnewproductlaunches,andevolvingitsHighTouchservices
togainsalesduringthenextfiveyears.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5149

5150

Este Lauder

Thecompanywillcontinuetobenefitfromitsexpandingdistributionchannelandnewtie
upswithretailersinordertoachievehighersalesduringthenextfiveyears.
Este Lauders distribution network comprises a few select retail channels, including
freestanding companyoperated stores, company websites, a few authorizedretailer
websites,storesoncruiseships,directresponsetelevision,andinflightanddutyfree
shops.
The marketer benefits from its selective distribution channel due to the personal
relationshipsharedwiththeretailers.
Travel retail continues to be a good opportunity for the marketers to expand upon.
Withdevelopedairportenvironments,thechannelhasevolvedtobuildtheequityof
thebrandsduringjourneys.
Intheairportenvironment,themarketeroffersHighTouchservicesandeventssuchas
makeupdemonstrations,popupstores,andmultilingualdigitaldisplays.Forexample,
at New Yorks John F. Kennedy International Airport, the marketers advertisements
shiftinlanguagesasthedayprogressescateringtotravelersfromallregions.
BrandssuchasEsteLauder,Clinique,andBobbiBrownBBcreamswerealloriginally
launchedthroughthetravelretailchannel.
Additionally, Este Lauder utilizes alternate distribution channels such as direct
response television and the Internet to expand its operating margins. The companys
webpagesonsocialnetworkingsitesallowsthemarketertoengagewithitscustomers
by informing them about new offers, new products, gift sets, and other relevant
information.Internetorderingwillalsoenhancemarginsbyreducingsellingexpenses
andthereforewillbeanimportantprofitmakingchannelinthefutureaswell.
Otherancillarytools,suchasemailnewslettersincreasebrandawarenessandeducate
consumersaboutthenewandthelatesthappeningsforthemarketer.
Este Lauder will continue to strengthen its distribution network with Sephora and
otherspecialtymultibrandretailers,withthefocusonthedepartmentstorechannel.
In the fall of 2012, the marketer tests its Este Lauder flagship brand at 25 Sephora
doorsinNorthAmerica.
Ecommerce has been a strong promotional channel for Este Lauder and is likely to
gainfurtherimportanceduringthecomingyears.Ecommerceallowsthemarketerto
reach consumers in remote areas where the marketer does not have any brickand
mortaroutlets.
The marketer is also likely to emphasize on the importance of mobile commerce
channelinthecomingyears.
It will continue to launch social media campaigns for its beauty brands and new
products.
The company will also look to capitalize on social media networks to gain consumer
insights. The company will use the information provided by consumers through
feedbacks,productratings,andreviewstoimproveitsproducts,packaging,andtailor
itsmarketingandmerchandisingefforts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A150

Este Lauder

EsteLauderwillcontinuetoinnovateinanattempttoattractmoreconsumersandgain
salesduringtheforecastperiodending2017.
The companys key pillars Este Lauder, Clinique, and MACwill help drive sales
backed by innovative new product introductions, emphasis on developing high
performing skin care products, and engaging television marketing and promotional
tools.
Themarketerisexpectedtosupportitsnewproductintroductionswithdynamicmixof
marketing including engaging advertising, digital, and social media strategies, and
effortstoattractnewandexistingconsumerstoitscounters,eandmcommercesites,
retailers,andstorestodrivesalesacrossvariousproductcategories.
Themarketerisalsolikelytoperformwellduetoincreasingwillingnessandimproving
purchasingpowerofwomen.
EsteLauderislikelytocontinuetocreateconsumerdriveninnovationswiththeaim
ofattractingexistingandnewconsumers.Someoftheconsumerinspiredinnovations
in2012includetheintroductionoftheIdealistCoolingEyeIlluminator,anextensionof
theIdealistEvenSkintoneIlluminatorthathelpsreducetheappearanceofundereye
puffiness and dark circles. Cliniques Moisture Surge Intense Skin Fortifying Hydrator,
meant to provide moisture barrier protection, is well received by consumers. The
AvedaInvatiCollection,tacklingtheproblemofthinninghair,hassuccessfullyhelped
increase the sales in the hair care products class. The MAC Matchmaster SPF 15
FoundationwithShadeIntelligenceTechnologycomprisespatentpendingtranslucent
pigmentstogiveamorepreciseskintone.OriginsextendsuponthesuccessofitsDr.
Andrew Weil for Origins by introducing MegaBright, a serum that addresses the
problemofunevenskintone.
Bumbleandbumblewillcontinuetorelyonthecombiningcreativitywithinnovationto
helpexpanditssalesinthehaircarecategory.

Technologically, the marketer has a very strong year in 2012, with digital content to
communicateandconnectbetterwithconsumers.
Duringthecourseoftheforecastperiodending2017,themarketerisexpectedtodrive
its HighTouch services to new digital heights. This will help the company to connect
withtheconsumersbeyondtheirexpectationsinordertoachievesalesgrowth.
The HighTouch Online Skin Care Guide developed for www.origins.com is another
example of the marketers HighTouch services initiatives. The tool offers consumers
personalizedfeedbackandrecommendationofproductsbasedonskincareconcern.
A similar tool is introduced in 2012 on www.jomalone.com with fragrancecombining
consultations.
MACalsoofferstheseHighTouchservicesintheformofitsMagicMirrorinteractive
station, especially designed for the travelling consumers, acting as a support tool for
themakeupartistinordertoreceiveamorepersonalizedexperience.Theinteractive
application provides product descriptions in various languages and when combined
withamakeupsession,allowsconsumerstoreceiveadigitalphotographoftheirnew
lookwithacustomizedlistofproductsemailedtothem.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5151

5152

Este Lauder

Themarketerwillcontinuetoaccelerateandemphasizeonthedevelopmentandwill
keepitsdigitaltechnologyuptodate.
The company has improved its counter designs, merchandising, and navigation,
incorporateddigitaltechnology,andrefiningtheretailexperiencefortheconsumers.
Cliniques Apple iPad Skin Care Diagnostic application allows consumers to identify
concernsrelatedtotheirskinandrecommendsacustomizedregimeofproductstobe
used.

The facial treatments category is expected to be of utmost importance to the company


duringtheforecastperiod.
Sales for the category are expected to grow at a CAGR of 7.5% during the next five
years.
Este Lauder is expected to keep up the momentum with innovative and
technologically advanced products that not only provide instant gratification but also
longtermbenefits.
EsteLauderclaimsthatitsproductsprovidedermatologicalbenefits,suchasevenskin
toneandblotchiness,andreducesdarkspots.Thiswillcontinuetobeakeytrendfor
themarketersportfolioofproductsandinduceconsumerstopurchasetheseproducts
withthebeliefofprovidingprofessionalresultsathome.
EsteLauderisalsoknowntoenrichitsproductformulationswithrareandhardtofind
biological and natural extracts that give the marketer an extra edge over its
competitorsinthemarket.

The makeup and skin care product classes will continue to drive sales for the company
duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Themarketerwillcontinuetofocusitseffortsondevelopingfacialtreatmentproducts
thatfightsignsofagingandhelpinreducingtheappearanceoffinelinesandwrinkles.
Theuseofmorenaturalandtechnologicallyadvancedformulationswillhelpdrivethe
upthepricepointsoffacialtreatmentsproducts.
Themarketerwillalsocontinuetoimproveitsproductformulationswithmultibenefits,
suchasSPFprotection,reductionofagespots,improvedskintone,andacnesolutions,
initsproducts.
EsteLaudersMACwillpersistwithitsstrategyofintroducinglimitededitionproducts,
togeneratecuriosityandinterestamongconsumerstherebyinducingpurchaseofhigh
pricedproductswhilethestockslast.

EsteLauderwillcontinuetolookouttoexploitstrategicalliances,partnerships,affiliations,
andlicensingwithanattempttobeatitscompetitorsinthemarketwithrespecttoresearch
anddevelopment,distribution,andthirdpartymanufacturing.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A152

Este Lauder

Duringtheforecastperiodending2017,EsteLauderislikelytofocusonthedevelopment
of its business in key product classes, such as skin care, makeup, and fragrances, thereby
havinganegativeimpactonthesalesofitsothersmallerproductclassessuchashaircare
andothertoiletries.

SalesofEsteLauderscosmeticsandtoiletriesareprojectedtoincreaseataCAGRof4.2%
toreach$3,342millionby2017,upfrom$2,722millionin2012.

Table584:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsandToiletriesforEste
LauderbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

6.4

Skincareproductsformen

4.3

COMPANYAVERAGE

4.2

Facemakeup

3.8

Suncareproducts

3.2

Eyemakeup

3.0

Nailpolishes

2.9

Lipsticksandlipglosses

2.8

Shampoos

2.7

Conditioners

2.7

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

2.4

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1.5

Handandbodylotions

0.8

Fragrancesforwomen

0.5

Fragrancesformen

Personalcleansingproducts

Shavingproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5153

5154

Este Lauder

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A154

GLAXOSMITHKLINE

Table585:GlaxoSmithKlinesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012
Category/brand

2011

TOOTHPASTES

2012

Sensodyne

132

149

Aquafresha

84

80

Biotene

13

13

229

242

Poligripbr

65

74

Polidentc

45

45

DentuCreme

Wernets

116

125

Biotene

19

21

Targonr

21

21

12

Total
DENTUREPRODUCTS

Totalr
MOUTHWASHES

Total
TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS
Aquafresh
TOOTHBRUSHES
Aquafresh
FACIALTREATMENTS
MaxClarity

TOTALr
392
407

aIncludesAquafreshExtremeClean,Advanced,Sensitive,ForKids,andRegular:
BakingSodawithPeroxide,BakingSodavariety,andExtraFresh.
bIncludesSuperPoligrip,PoligripUltraFresh,andPoliGripFree.
cIncludesPolidentOvernight,Smokers,ForPartials,andPolidentPowder.
rRestated

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5156

GlaxoSmithKline

COMPANYOVERVIEW

GlaxoSmithKlineisapubliclimitedcompany,establishedin1999.
ThesharesofthecompanyaretradedontheLondonandNewYorkStockExchanges.
TheheadquartersofthecorporationisinLondon,theUnitedKingdom.
ThecompanysthreeprimaryareasofbusinessincludePharmaceuticals,Vaccines,and
ConsumerHealthcare.
Asof2012,thecompanyemploys99,488employeesgloballywithapproximately40%
or38,788employeeslocatedinEurope,36.9%or36,738locatedinEMAP,and17.3%
or17,201locatedintheUnitedStates.
TheU.S.operationsofthecompanyarebasedinPhiladelphia,PA.Asoneoftheleading
pharmaceuticalcompanies,GlaxoSmithKlineexploresbothmedicinesandvaccinesfor
the World Health Organizations three priority diseasesHIV/AIDS, tuberculosis, and
malaria.
GlaxoSmithKlineholds7%oftheworldspharmaceuticalmarket,makingitoneofthe
industrysleaders.

The company has its own offices in more than 115 countries, while its products are
distributedinmorethan150countries.
Its products, particularly pharmaceuticals, are distributed virtually throughout the
entireworld.

Inadditiontothemanufacturingfacilitiesthatthecompanyownsin34countries,itholds
key research and development centers in Belgium, China, the United Kingdom, and the
UnitedStates.
Thecompanyhasanetworkof87manufacturingsitesandresearchanddevelopment
centersintheUnitedKingdom,theUnitedStates,Spain,China,andBelgium.
The companys activities are separated into three business units: Pharmaceuticals,
Vaccines,andConsumerHealthcare.
ConsumerHealthcareisclassifiedintothefollowingproductcategories:totalwellness,
oralcare,nutrition,andskincare.
Popular overthecounter (OTC) brands distributed by the company are Aquafresh,
Sensodyne, Biotene, and Nicorette. Some of GlaxoSmithKlines prescription drugs are
Paxil, Avandia, Advair, and Wellbutrin. The company also markets drinks such as
Horlicks,Lucozade,andRibena.
Consumer Healthcare specializes in the following product categories: OTC medicines,
dentalproducts,smokingcontrolproducts,nutritionalhealthcaredrinks,andskincare.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A156

GlaxoSmithKline

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

GlaxoSmithKlinesrevenueswitnessa3.5%dipto26,431million($41,887million)in2012,
from27,387million($43,403million)in2011.
Its pharmaceuticals and vaccines business unit command 80.7% of GlaxoSmithKlines
totalcorporatesalesin2012,withbusinessworth21,321million($33,789million).
Within the consumer healthcare business, total sales decline 1.6% to 5,110 million
($8,098million)in2012,from5,195million($8,233million)in2011.

Thecompanysnetincomedeclinesby13.1%from5,458million($8,650million)in2011,
to4,744million($7,518million)in2012.

Saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.1%since2007.

Table586:GlaxoSmithKlinesGlobalSales,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales,%

2007

22,716

5,310

23.4

2008

24,352

4,712

19.3

2009

28,368

5,669

20.0

2010

28,392

2,961

10.4

2011

27,387

5,458

19.9

2012

26,431

4,744

17.9

NOTE:$1.00=0.6310.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

GlaxoSmithKlines annual sales in the cosmetics and toiletries industry advances 3.8% to
reach$407millionin2012,upfrom$392millionin2011.

Since2007,GlaxoSmithKlinescosmeticsandtoiletriessaleshavegrownataCAGRof2.0%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5157

5158

GlaxoSmithKline

Table587:GlaxoSmithKlinesSalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

368

2008

376

2.2

2009

368

(2.1)

2010

395

7.3

2011

392

(0.8)

2012

407

3.8

rRestated.

GlaxoSmithKline remains the thirdleading marketer in the toothpastes category with a


13.8%marketsharein2012,upfrom13.3%in2011.
Totalsalesofthemarketergrowby5.7%to$242millionin2012,upfrom$229million
in2011.
Growth in sales for GlaxoSmithkline is supported by Sensodyne, which experiences
stronggrowthandseesitsshareincreasefrom7.7%in2011to8.5%in2012.
SalesoftheSensodynebrandgrow12.9%,upfrom$132millionin2011to$149million
in2012.
The launch of Sensodyne Pronamel Gentle Whitening toothpaste and Sensodyne
Sensitivetoothpastesupportsthebrandsgrowthin2012.
Aquafresh, the next largest brand for the company, has its sales decline from
$84million in 2011 to $80million in 2012. The lack of new product activity and a
decreaseinmarketingactivitylimitsitssalesin2012.
Thebrandnowholdsamarketshareof4.6%in2012,downfrom4.9%in2011.
Biotene, a much smaller brand used to treat excessive tartar, dry mouth, and oral
irritations,remainsflatatjust$13millionin2012.
In2012,GlaxoSmithKlinelaunchesnewproductsundertheSensodynebrand.

GlaxoSmithKline along with Procter & Gamble is the leading marketer in the denture
productscategoryin2012.
In 2012, sales for the category leader GlaxoSmithKline increase 7.8% to $125million
from$116millionin2011.
GlaxoSmithKlineconstitutes39.3%ofthemarketsharein2012,upfrom36.9%in2011.
GlaxoSmithKline is the secondleading marketer of denture adhesives, behind
Procter&Gamble, capturing almost onequarter of the categorys market share in
2012.Thecompanysdentureadhesivessalesrisebynearly$9millionduringtheyear.
The companys growth in the denture adhesives segment is supported by the
introductionofanewadhesive,PoligripforPartials.
ThemarketerremoveszincfromitsPoligripbrandstopromoteitssalesin2012,aszinc
indentureproductsisfoundtocausehealthproblems.
Dentureadhesivesaccountforabout62%ofthecompanysdentureproductsales.
GlaxoSmithKline continues to be the leading marketer of denture cleansers in 2012,
withover40%segmentshare.Polidentisthetopbrandinthesegment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A158

GlaxoSmithKline

GlaxoSmithKlines sales in the mouthwashes category remain constant at $21 million in


2012,flatfrom2011levels.
ThebrandsmarketedwithinthiscategoryincludeBioteneandTargon.
Themarketersmarketshareinthecategorydeclinesmarginallyfrom2.7%in2011to
2.6%in2012.

GlaxoSmithKline,whichtiedwithGoSmileforsecondplaceinthetoothwhiteningproducts
categoryin2011,dropstothethirdplacein2012.Thecompanyexperiencesadeclineinits
marketsharefrom4.2%in2011to3.3%in2012.
Sales of Aquafresh White Trays drop sharply by 25.0% from $12million in 2011 to
$9millionin2012.
GlaxoSmithKline entered the category in 2007, but has not been able to significantly
buildsales.Itstrayformathasnotbeenaspopularwithconsumersastheeasytouse
andlessintrusivestrips.
The trays have not performed well as they are uncomfortable to fit and moreover,
cause a lot of inconvenience compared to whitening gels which are easy to use. The
marketerhasnotlaunchedanyotherformsinthecategory.

Sales of GlaxoSmithKline in the toothbrushes category remains stagnant at $9million in


2012,flatfrom2011levels.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers,alliances,andacquisitions

Nomergersandacquisitionsarereportedin2012.

Managementchanges

InJanuary2012,GlaxoSmithKlineappointsPatrickVallanceasPresidentofPharmaceuticals
R&D.
Priortothis,heservedasSeniorVicePresident,MedicinesDiscoveryandDevelopment.

InJanuary2012,itisannouncedattheAnnualGeneralMeetingthatHansWijers,Chairman
ofHeineken,willjoinGlaxoSmithKlineasNonExecutiveDirector..

InApril2012,LynnElsenhansandJinUlrichareappointedasNonExecutiveDirectors.

SeniorIndependentNonExecutiveDirector,SirRobertWilsonhasagreedtoremainonthe
Boardforanadditionalyearin2012toprovideadviceandexpertise,whilenewmembers
settlein.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5159

5160

GlaxoSmithKline

Newproducts

Table588:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyGlaxoSmithKlineintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Mentadent

Toothpastes

MentadentAdvancedWhiteningRefreshingMinttoothpasteclaimstowhiten
teethinsevendays.Italsoaidsinremovingplaqueandpreventstartar
buildupbeforeitforms

Poligrip

Denture
products

PoligripSeal&Protectadhesivestabilizespartialproblemsandreduces
potentialproblemsinthefuture

Toothpastes

SensodynePronamelGentleWhiteningtoothpaste,sugarfreeanticavity
toothpaste,forsensitiveteethtoprotectagainstthegrowingproblemofacid
wear.Itprotectsteethagainstaciderosion,hardensenamel,andwhitens
teeth

Sensodyne

Otherdevelopments

In late 2011, GlaxoSmithKlines Consumer Healthcare business was restructured into four
categories:Totalwellness,Oralcare,Nutrition,andSkinhealth.
Effectsoftherestructuringarevisiblein2012.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

GlaxoSmithKlines traceable media expenditures (TMEs) in the cosmetics and toiletries


markettotal$130.0millionin2012,down13.3%from$149.9millionin2011.
Thecompanyutilizestraditionalmarketingmedia,suchastelevision,print,andradio;
socialmedialnetworkssuchasFacebookandTwitter;andInternetmarketingthrough
websitestopromoteitsbrands.
Aquafresh,throughitswebsite,offerstipsforattaininghealthyadultteeththroughsub
segmentssuchaswhiterteeth,strongteeth,healthygums,freshbreath,andaskthe
experts.
Aquafreshswebsiteprovidestipsformomsandallowschildrentoplayonlinegames
andthentradethepointsthattheyscoreforgiftssuchascoloringbooksandbrushes.
Aquafreshs website gives consumers an additional advantage of joining their club
whichprovidespersonalizedtips,expertadvice,andsavingandopportunities.
Sensodyne, through its website, educates consumers on acid erosion and sensitivity
problemsencounteredbyconsumers.
Sensodyne also offers discount coupons for its toothpastes and toothbrushes in the
form of a $0.75 off on Sensodyne Toothpastes and $0.50 off on Sensodyne Precision
Toothbrush.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A160

GlaxoSmithKline

GlaxoSmithKline focuses its promotional activities on Sensodyne in the toothpastes


category.
In2012,thecompanyallocatesabout$77.2millioninTMEtoSensodyne.Sensodyneis
mainly advertised through television advertisements, with almost 95% of the brands
advertising budget spent on television promotions. Magazines and the Internet
advertisementsarealsoused.
The marketer supports its new launch, Sensodyne Pronamel with a TME of $19.5
millionin2012.
In2012,TMEof$20.9millionareallocatedforAquafreshtoothpaste.

GlaxoSmithKline remains the leading advertiser in the denture products categoryin 2012,
withmorethan$12.8millioninTMEforitsproducts.
ThecompanymarketsfourbrandsinthecategoryincludingPoliGrip,Polident,Dentu
Crme,andWernets.In2012,PoliGripreceivestheentireTMEof$12.8million,asthe
companydoesnotallocateanyTMEtoitsotherbrands.
Thecompanyallocatesitsentireadvertisingbudgettotelevision,withnoneallocated
totheprintmedia.
Themarketeralsooffersdiscountcouponsof$1.00onitsPolidentandPoligripbrands.
However, GlaxoSmithKlines 2012 spending is 38% lower than its 2011 TME of
$20.8millioninthedentureproductscategory.

GlaxoSmithKlineshowsnoTMEforAquafreshinthetoothwhiteningproductscategoryin
2012.

In2012,GlaxoSmithKlinesupportsitsAquafreshbrandinthetoothbrushescategory,witha
TMEof$2.3million.
GlaxoSmithKline promotes its toothbrushes with about 51% of its TME on television
advertisementsandtheremainingTMEspentonmagazines.

DetailsonTMEareincludedintheAdvertisingsectionofthisreport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5161

5162

GlaxoSmithKline

OUTLOOK

Manufacturers sales of GlaxoSmithKline in the cosmetics and toiletries industry are


expectedtogrowatamoderaterateof1.6%duringtheforecastperiodending2017.
GlaxoSmithKlinewillcontinuetomakeprogressinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket
as it attempts to make a mark in the industry with increasing focus on its oral care
brandssuchasAquafreshandSensodyne.
Growth will be supported by the companys urge to innovate with its portfolio of
products by introducing scientifically advanced products, products with new and
advancedtechnologiesandformulations,andextenditsproductlines.
The marketer is expected to increase spending on innovation and research efforts to
introduceinnovativeoralcareproducts.
GlaxoSmithKlines fully integrated supply chain will allow for greater flexibility and
moreresponsivenessfromthesupplychainduringthecomingyears.
GlaxoSmithKline is expected to continue to increase its media expenditures or
advertisingforitsbrands,overthenextfiveyears.Itwillcontinuetosupportitsnew
productlaunchesintheoralcareproductclasswithinnovativemarketingthroughprint
andtelevisionadvertisements.
GlaxoSmithKlineislikelytoexpandtheoutreachofitsmergerandacquisitionsstrategy
to e toral care categories in order to diversify oral care product technologies and
introducenewproductsinitsconsumerhealthcaredivisiontooffsetthesaturationof
themarketforitstraditionalproducts.
BeingadominantmarketerintheOTCsegment,ithasa strongrelationshipwiththe
retailers and is expected to use it to the advantage of pushing its new products to a
widersectionofthesociety.
Naturallyformulated toothpastes could be a potential area for the marketer to
innovateinandexpanditsoutreachofproductstoavarietyofconsumers.
Sensodyne and Aquafresh are expected to continue to do well in the toothpastes
category due to the ability to offer a range of products targeting various oral care
concernsincludingbattlingtoothsensitivity,teethwhitening,andpreventingplaque.
In spite of the marginally growing denture products category, GlaxoSmithKline
performs well in the category in 2012 and will continue to do so during the forecast
periodprovidedthemarketercontinuestointroducenewproducts.
Inthegrowingbatterypoweredtoothbrushesmarket,themarketerlosesoutonsales
and growth as a result of the incapacity to offer such advanced products and the
absenceofinnovationwithnewvariantsinthecategory.
Unless the marketer innovates with the introduction of new variants in the tooth
whiteningproductscategory,themarketersperformancewillcontinuetodeteriorate.
Themarketerwillcontinuetofacestiffcompetitionfromleadingmarketers,Colgate
Palmolive,Johnson&Johnson,Procter&Gamble,andUnilever.
Sales of MaxClarity facial treatments continue to decline in 2012 and the company
might pull out of the category on account of the regressive sales during the forecast
period.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A162

GlaxoSmithKline

DollarsalesareexpectedtoincreaseataCAGRof1.5%to$439millionby2017from$407
millionin2012.

Table589:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforGlaxoSmithKlinebyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Toothpastes

2.4

Toothbrushes

2.1

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.6

Mouthwashes

0.9

Dentureproducts

0.6

Facialtreatments

Toothwhiteningproducts

(7.8)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5163

5164

GlaxoSmithKline

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A164

GUTHYRENKER

Table590:GuthyRenkersSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

Proactiv

2012

353

389

MeaningfulBeauty

65

82

PrincipalSecret

26

26

10

YouthfulEssence

11

Allother

21

13

476

526

60

112

SheerCover

40

39

VictoriaJackson

13

Total

53

42

15

31

Wen

12

26

TOTAL

616

737

XOut

Total
SHAMPOOS
Wen
FACEMAKEUP

CONDITIONERS
Wen
HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTS

COMPANYOVERVIEW

GuthyRenker is one of the largest televisiondriven direct marketing companies in the


world.
Thecompanywasestablishedin1988byBillGuthyandGregRenker.
ItisheadquarteredatPalmDesert,CA.
IthasadministrativeofficesintheUnitedKingdom,Sweden,Germany,Finland,China,
Japan,Australia,andIndia.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5166

GuthyRenker

Themarketer,inassociationwiththirdpartydistributors,sellsitsproductsincountries
otherthantheonesmentionedabove.
Thecompanyhascloseto825employeesworldwideasof2012.
The company follows a directtoconsumer model with infomercials which entice
consumers to purchase the marketers products at low introductory prices, and a
subscriptionmodel.
Itsdistributionnetworkisspreadacross68countries.
The company pursues marketing opportunities through electronic retailing of various
productsthroughbroadcasttelevision,cableandsatellite,theInternet,telemarketing,
directmail,andretailchannels.
The marketers brands in the beauty business include Proactiv Solution, Wen, X Out,
NaturalAdvantage,MeaningfulBeauty,SheerCover,andPrincipalSecret.
In 2012, the company launches six ecommerce and mobile commerce sites for its
brands, Wen Haircare, X Out, Malibu Pilates, Proactiv, Proactiv+, and Meaningful
Beauty.

GuthyRenkers principal marketing activities involve the production of infomercials, half


hourtelevisionprogramsthatmarketvariousproducts.Italsomarketsitsproductsthrough
shortform,directresponsetelevisionspots,telemarketing,directmail,andalargeInternet
mall.
Thecompanysshowsaretelecastinmorethan60countriesonpopularchannelslike
CNBC,Lifetime,CourtTV,andFX.
Itspecializesinfourproductcategories,whichincludeentertainmentitems,weightloss
andfitness,healthandbeauty,andselfimprovement.
The company also sells GuthyRenker products through thirdparty distributors based
ineachcontinent,formingnewrelationshipseachyear.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

GuthyRenkerisaprivatelyheldcompanyanddoesnotdiscloseitsfinancialinformationto
thepublic.

Estimatedtotalannualsalesforthecompanyin2012are$2.6billion.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Most of the sales of GuthyRenker in the cosmetics and toiletries market are in the facial
treatmentscategory.

GuthyRenkers sales have been growing at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
13.7%since2007.

Thecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesgrowby19.6%toreach$737millionin2012,
upfrom$616millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A166

GuthyRenker

Table591:GuthyRenkersCosmeticsand
ToiletriesSalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year
2007r
2008r
2009r
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
388
422
453
493
616
737

Change,%

8.8
7.3
8.8
24.9
19.6

rRestated.

GuthyRenkersProactivisthesecondlargestbrandinthefacialtreatmentscategory,with
$389millioninmanufacturerssalesin2012,up10.2%from$353millionin2011.
Despite the sales increase, its business model of creating infomercials with celebrity
endorserscoulddraintheprofitabilityofthebrand,duetothehighcostofpurchasing
media, costs associated with infomercial production, and the cost of compensating
celebrities.
Sales grow due to several reasons including a number of new and young celebrity
endorsers, such as actresses Kaley Cuoco, Julianne Hough, and Naya Rivera; positive
endorsements as the best acne product by several magazines, and low introductory
pricehookingnewcustomers.
While no new products are launched during the year, the brand offers a cleansing
brushasagift.
Competing brands, such as MaxClarity, are discontinued during the year, causing
customerstoseekoutotherbrandssuchasProactiv.

Inthehaircareproductclass,salesofGuthyRenkerpostaformidablegrowthof108.8%to
reach$338millionin2012,from$162millionin2011.
ThesalesofWenshampoosgrow86.7%,upfrom$60millionin2011to$112millionin
2012.
Wenscategorysharegrowsfrom2.4%in2011to4.3%in2012.
Themarketercontinuestobenefitfromdirectlypresentingthebenefitsofitsproducts
to consumers via infomercials. Celebrity Alyssa Milano promotes the brand in the
infomercials.
Moreover, Wen is positioned as a fiveinone product, replacing shampoos, daily
conditioner, detanglers, deep conditioner, and leavein conditioner. These factors
contributetoitshighprice.
Value sales are high because Wen cleansing conditioner costs about $40.00 a bottle,
andtheinstructionsmentionthatonemustuseagreatdealmoreoftheproductthan
a normal shampoo. Customers ordering the product are enrolled in a subscription,
with automatic charges made to their credit cards and product shipped to them at
regular intervals. Customers are usually charged $30.00 per month after the initial
purchase.
The sales of GuthyRenker conditioners grow 106.7% to $31million in 2012, from
$15millionin2011.
Inthehairstylingproductsandsprayscategory,salesgrow116.7%from$12millionin
2011to$26millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5167

5168

GuthyRenker

In2012,thefacemakeupcategorydeclines20.8%from$53millionin2011to$42millionin
2012.
In2012,GuthyRenkeradoptstheuseofaMegaAirlessneutralandairlessdispensing
solutionforitsMeaningfulbeautyCindyCrawfordCrmeSerum.
The company claims that this new dispensing solution is vacuumtested inline and
delivers precision amounts, quickpriming, and a 360 degrees operation without any
dripping,clogging,drying,oranykindofcontaminationtotheproduct.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Newproducts

In 2012, GuthyRenker introduces the X Out acne line consisting of a washin delivery
systemwithbenzoylperoxide(8.5%)andmicrobeadstohelpexfoliatethedeadskincell.
ThisproductisuniquetoGuthyRenkerinthatitisnotsoldthroughinfomercials,but
only sold online. Furthermore X Out is targeted specifically at males,and, hence, has
onlyoneproduct.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

GuthyRenker continues to use infomercials and advertising as an important marketing


mediumtopromoteitsbrands,especiallyProactiv.
In 2012, GuthyRenker enters into an agreement with actress Kaley Cuoco to be the
companys newest spokesperson. Kaley Cuoco features in the television advertising
campaignforthemarketerthatcomesonairinthefallof2012.Sheadvertisesforher
favorite Proactiv products including the 3Step System, Mini Maintenance System
TravelKit,RefiningMask,andDailyProtectionPlusSunscreenBroadSpectrum.
Other popular celebrity spokesmodels for the marketer include actresses Julianne
Haugh, and Naya Rivera. These actresses promote the companys products through
televisionspots,digitalmedia,andpromotionsduring2012.
Free gifts are offered with the purchase of a Proactiv starter kit, and free shipping is
alwaysofferedforonlinepurchases.
The brand continues to run directresponse advertisements as freestanding inserts
(FSIs) in weekend newspapers throughout the country, encouraging prospective
customerstoeithermailinacouponorcalltopurchasetheProactivSystem.
TheProactivkiosksinmajormallsaroundthecountryevolvefromamannedkiosktoa
vendingmachine.
Measured advertising expenditures for Proactiv are $304.2million during 2012, up
23.0%from$247.3millionduring2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A168

GuthyRenker

The company also utilizes shortform and Direct Response Television (DRTV) spots to
promoteitsbrands.
GuthyRenkersleadingbrand,Proactiv,usesDRTVasitsprimarymarketingmedium.
ThemarketerusesDRTVinconjunctionwithinfomercialstoprovidebeforeandafter
demonstrations and testimonials, which are difficult to express clearly via traditional
televisionadvertising.

The company increasingly sponsors and host events in an attempt to promote awareness
aboutthecompany.
GuthyRenker sponsors the 2012 Palm Springs Strength & Human Performance Expo,
featuringthreecompetitiveeventsincludingUSAWeightliftingsannual2012American
Open, 2013 World Youth Team Trials, and the Outlaw Open. The Expo features
exhibitors, renowned speakers, demonstrations, and activities pertaining to strength
and extreme human physical performance with keynotes from prominent speakers
suchastwotimeOlympianKendrickFarrisandOlympianandfitnessexpertCaraHeads.
In2012,GuthyRenkersWenpartnerswiththe2012MissAmericaOrganization.Inthe
days that lead up to the 2012 Miss America Pageant, celebrity stylist Chaz Dean and
creatorofWenHairCareinteractswithcontestantsandstylestheirhairshowingthem
varioushairstyles,forthemtoexperiencetheadvantagesofusingthebrandsproducts.
The brand also hosts a live stream conversation with Chaz Dean for fans to get an
insidersperspectiveonthepageant.

GuthyRenker increasingly capitalizes on social media channels such as Facebook and


YouTube.
Unlike other marketers, social media platforms play an important role for Guthy
Renkerduethenatureofthemarketersdirectsellingbusinessmodel.
Themarketerprimarilyusessocialmediaplatformstodevelopapersonalrelationship
with its consumers and fans and provides them a platform to share their product
experiences,reviews,andseekanswers.
In 2012, Proactiv joins the bandwagon of other beauty brands by creating its own
channel on YouTube. The brand promotes its YouTube channel by advertising on its
otherpopularsocialmedianetworkchannel,Facebookbyaskingconsumersandfans
tosubscribetothechannel.ThebrandsYouTubechannelfeaturesinsiderstories,fan
reviews, Proactiv success stories, behindthescenes of advertisement shoots, videos,
andadvertisementsofthebrand.
The brands YouTube channel also allows consumers to chat with Proactiv
representativestoclarifytheirdoubtsontheproduct.
Other social media networks that the marketer uses to promote its products include
FacebookandTwitter.

The companys 60day money back guarantee is very popular with its customers. The
company claims to refund the money within 60 days of receipt, if the consumer is not
completelysatisfiedwiththeproduct.
The companys practice of selling product subscriptions leads to higher sales per
consumer. Purchases of many GuthyRenker products are automatically billed and
shipped monthly after the first purchase, until the customer cancels. The 60day
guarantee also leads to unwanted purchases not being credited back if the customer
doesnotsendtheproductbackwithinthe60days.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5169

5170

GuthyRenker

The company has an extensive website that lists all its directresponse brands along with
theirdescriptions,andprovidesopportunitiestopurchaseproductsonline.
Each individual brands website is structured in a similar fashion to its infomercial,
showcasingbeforeandafterphotos,celebrityendorsers,andcustomertestimonials.
Many of the brands allow consumers to see video clips on its website. They also
provideaweeksscheduleforinfomercialprograms.

OUTLOOK

GuthyRenkerscosmeticsandtoiletriesbusinessisexpectedtogrowatahealthyCAGRof
6.6%duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
GuthyRenkerisforecasttopoststronggrowthinitscosmeticsandtoiletriesbusiness
overtheforecastperiod.
Itsproductsareexpectedtocontinuetoenjoystrongbrandloyaltyduringtheforecast
period;however,thecompanywillfacestrictcompetitionfromothermarketers,direct
andotherwise.
AlthoughGuthyRenkerhasbeenveryinnovativeinitsproductofferingsandbusiness
model,ithaspavedthewayforothercompaniestostepinandcapturemarketshare
withlowerpricedcompetingproducts,therebyrestrictingitsfurthergrowth.
Thecompanyislikelytoincreaseitsadvertisingexpenditureshelpingitgainsalesover
otherdirectmarketerswhohavealimitedadvertisingbudget.However,thehighcost
ofmediafortheinfomercials,theproductioncostsoftheinfomercials,andthecostof
thecelebrityspokesmodelscouldhaveanegativeimpactonthecompanyssalesinthe
furureiftheydonotcontinuetogrowtheirsalesatthedesiredCAGR.
The company is testing other distribution models which may prove to be more
profitable.

Thefacialtreatmentscategorywillremainthehighestrevenuegeneratorforthecompany
duringtheforecastperiod.
In early 2012, the company launches X Out, an antiacne product that claims to fight
acneandbanishexistingpimples.Thecompanywilllikelylaunchmoreacneproductsin
theforecastperiodtosupportitssales,eitherinexistingbrandsorinnewones.This
segmenthasbeensuccessfulforGuthyRenker.
The company is likely to continue to hire celebrities to endorse its products, and to
promote the company, however, on a lower scale than before as it focuses on
promoting and launching its brands through social media channels, banner
advertisements, and retail stores in the future. Its profitability is too low to allow
continuedrelianceoncelebrityendorsedinfomercials.
Thecompanywillcontinuetopromoteitsnewintroductionsacrossvariouscategories
throughinfomercialsandotherdirectresponseadvertisementsinthefuture.
Furthermore,thecompanystestswithsellingthroughretailerswilllikelybeexpanded.
Meaningful Beautys foray into Sephora in JCPenney stores is probably just the
beginningofitsexplorationofdifferentsalesmodels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A170

GuthyRenker

The hair care product class is also projected to post strong growth of 5.2% during the
forecastperiod.
Wenwillcontinuetoattractnewconsumersandretaintheoldonesastheygetlocked
intheirsubscriptionplans.
ThecompanyislikelytoexplorewithmorevariantsintheWenproductlinebyoffering
advancedtechnology,combinedwithnaturalingredients.
Wen is sold in Sephora stores, widening its exposure but reducing the continual
revenuestreamthatthedirectmodelleverages.Thebrandwilllikelybesoldthrough
otherchannelsaswell,duringtheforecastperiod.

Dollarsalesareexpectedtoreachapproximately$1,013millionatthemanufacturerslevel
by2017,upataCAGRof6.6%from$737millionin2012.

Table592:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforGuthyRenkerbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

7.4

COMPANYAVERAGE

6.6

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

6.1

Shampoos

5.3

Conditioners

4.2

Facemakeup

1.4

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5171

5172

GuthyRenker

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A172

HELENOFTROY

Table593:HelenofTroysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

SHAMPOOS

PertPlusr

55

50

Infusium23

14

12

Totalr

69

62

Sure

35

33

Brut

14

14

Total

49

47

17

14

18

15

Condition

Vitalis

FinalNet

Total

SeaBreeze

TOTALr

rRestated.

160

147

DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

CONDITIONERS
Infusium23
Condition
Total
HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

FRAGRANCESFORMEN
Brut
FACIALTREATMENTS

2012

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIAL NOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5174

HelenofTroy

COMPANYOVERVIEW

ThecompanywasincorporatedasHelenofTroyCorporationin1968inTexas;however,in
1994itwasreincorporatedasHelenofTroyLimited.
HeadquarteredinElPaso,TX,HelenofTroyhasofficesandwarehousefacilitiesaround
theworld.
ThecompanyisapubliclimitedcompanyandislistedontheNASDAQundertheticker
symbolHELE.
AsofFebruary,2013,thecompanyemploysapproximately1,458full meemployees
worldwide.Thecompanyalsoemploysparttime,temporary,andseasonalemployees
perthebusinessrequirements.
Thecompanymarketsitsproductsinapproximately80countriesacrosstheworld.

The company has three business segments namely Personal Care, Housewares, and
Healthcare/HomeEnvironment.
The Personal Care segment includes electric hair care, beauty care, and wellness
appliances; grooming tools and accessories; and liquid, solid, and powderbased
personalcareandgroomingproducts.
The Houseware segments range of products include food preparation and storage,
cleaning,organization,andbabyandtoddlercareproducts.
The Healthcare/Home Environment business comprises health care devices, such as
thermometers, blood pressure monitors, humidifiers, and heating pads; small home
appliances, such as air purifiers, portable heaters, fans, and bug zappers; and water
filtrationsystems.

The companys distribution network comprises mass merchandisers, drug stores,


warehouseclubs,catalogs,grocerystores,specialtystores,andecommerceretailers.
In addition to the above, the Personal Care segment also sells extensively through
wholesalersandsupplyretailers.
IntheHealthcare/HomeEnvironmentbusiness,HelenofTroyownstrademarksforits
SoftHeat, Protec, SmartTemp, PUR, Duracraft, Stinger, and Nosquito brands and has
licensedtrademarksforBraun,Vicks,Honeywell,andFebreze.
FortheHealthcare/HomeEnvironmentbusinesssegment,thedistributionnetworkalso
comprisesmedicaldistributorsandhomeimprovementstores.
In the Personal Care segment, the marketer owns trademarks for PRO Beauty Tools,
Karina,HOTTools,GoldNHot,Carel,Comare,ShearTechnology,DCNL,Brut,Infusium
23, Pert Plus, Sure, Ammens, Ogilvie, and Final Net; and has licensed trademarks for
Revlon,VidalSassoon,Dr.Scholls,Scholl,Toni&Guy,BedHead,andSeaBreeze.
FortheHousewaresbusiness,themarketerownstrademarksforitsOXO,GoodGrips,
SoftWorks,OXOSteel,andOXOtotbrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A174

HelenofTroy

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

TotalsalesforHelenofTroyare$1,181.7millionin2012,up52.1%from$777.0millionin
2011.
Thecompanyssaleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of13.2%
since2007.
The company has performed exceptionally well in 2012 as compared to any of the
previousfiveyears.

Table594:HelenofTroysGlobalCorporateSales,
2007to2012
Yeara

$Million

Change,%

2007

634.9

7.6

2008

652.5

2.7

2009

622.7

(4.6)

2010

647.6

3.9

2011

777.0

20.0

2012

1,181.7

52.1

aFiscalyearendingisFebruary.

Thecompanyspersonalcaresegmentcurrentlyoffershaircareproducts,suchasliquidhair
styling products, treatments, shampoos, conditioners; liquid or medicated skin care
products; fragrances; deodorants and antiperspirants; hair care appliances such as curling
irons, straightening irons, hot air brushes, handheld dryers, hard and softbonnet hair
dryers,hairsetters,hairclippersandtrimmers,hairbrushes,hairstylingimplements,and
decorativehairaccessories;facialcareappliances;footcareappliances;andhandheldand
lightedmirrors.

Net sales in the personal care segment marginally increase by 1.1% to $496.6million in
fiscalyear2012,comparedto$491.2millioninfiscalyear2011.

Table595:HelenofTroysGlobalCorporateSalesby
ProductCategory,2012
Category

%Oftotal

Personalcare

42.0

Healthcare/HomeEnvironment

37.9

Housewares

20.1

Total

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5175

5176

HelenofTroy

The U.S. market is the largest sales contributor, with 76.7% of the companys business
comingfromtheregion.

Table596:HelenofTroysGlobalCorporateSalesbyCountry,2011to2012

$Million

%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

UnitedStates

619.4

906.8

79.7

76.7

Europeandother

78.7

155.6

10.1

13.2

Canada

40.7

69.4

5.2

5.9

LatinAmerica

38.2

49.8

4.9

4.2

777.0

1181.7

100.0

100.0

Total

2011

2012

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Sales for Helen of Troy in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries market decline 8.1% from
$160millionin2011to$147millionin2012.

Since2007,salesofHelenofTroyhavebeendecliningatacompoundannualgrowthrate
(CAGR)of6.7%.

Table597:HelenofTroysCosmeticsandToiletries
SalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

208

2008

200

(3.8)

2009

175

(12.5)

2010

168

(4.0)

2011

160

(4.8)

2012

147

(8.1)

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A176

HelenofTroy

Shampoos is the largest product category for the company, accounting for 42.2% of the
companyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesin2012.
Salesoftheshampooscategorydecline10.1%from$69millionin2011to$62million
in2012.
ThecompanyisrepresentedinthecategorybyitsPertPlusandInfusium23brands.
The sales of Pert Plus decline 9.1% to $50million in 2012, down from $55million in
2011.
PertPlusaccountsfor34.0%ofcompanyssalesinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry
intheUnitedStatesin2012.
SalesofInfusium23declineby14.3%,from$14millionin2011to$12millionin2012.
A dearth innew product activity from the company negatively affects the marketers
salesintheshampooscategory.

Deodorants and antiperspirants is the secondlargest category, accounting for 32.0% of


HelenofTroyssalesintheU.Scosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
Thesalesofthecompanyinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategorydecline4.1%
from$49millionin2011to$47millionin2012.
Lackofnewproductactivity,limitedmarketingsupport,andtheabsenceininnovation
haveanegativeimpactonthesalesofthecompanyinthecategory.
ThecompanyisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsSureandBrutbrands.
SalesofSuredeclineby5.7%,from$35millionin2011to$33millionin2012.
However,thesalesofBrutremainstableat$14millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Brutssaleshavebeenstableat$14millionsince2009.

Conditioners are the thirdlargest category for the company, generating 10.2% of the
companyssalesin2012.
Salesofthemarketerinthecategorydecline16.7%to$15millionin2012,downfrom
$18millionin2011.
ThemarketercompetesintheconditionerscategorywithitsInfusium23andCondition
brands.
SalesofInfusium23decline17.6%from$17millionin2011to$14millionin2012.
Infusium 23 represents 93.3% of the marketers sales in the conditioners category in
2012.

Thehairstylingproductsandsprayscategoryisthefourthlargestcategoryforthemarketer
withsalesat$8millionin2012.Salesdecline11.1%from$9millionin2011.
Thecategorygenerates5.4%ofthecompanyssalesin2012,downfrom5.6%in2011.
ConditionandVitalisarethelargestbrandsforthecompanywitheachhavingsalesat
$3millionin2012.
The sales of Vitalis remain stagnant at $3million in 2012, flat from 2011 levels;
howeverthesalesofVitalisdecline25.0%from$4millionin2011to$3millionin2012.

SalesofHelenofTroyinthefragrancesformencategoryremainstableat$8millionin2012,
flatfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5177

5178

HelenofTroy

HelenofTroyssalesinthefacialtreatmentscategorycontinuestoexperienceflatsalesat
$7millionin2012.
Thecompanycompletetheintegrationofitsacquiredbrandsin2011,andwillfocuson
addingnewvariantstoitsexistinglineinthefuture.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers&acquisitions

Therearenoacquisitionsin2012.

Otherdevelopments

Thecompanyhasenteredintoanagreementtopurchase84acresoflandinOliveBranchin
Mississippi.
The land will be used for the purpose of constructing a 1.3million square foot
distributioncenter.
The distribution center is expected to cost an approximate $37million and will be
operationalfromthethirdquarterof2014.

Newproducts

Therearenonotablenewproductlaunchesin2012.

MARKETINGACTIVITY

In 2012, Helen of Troys traceable media expenditures (TME) total $12.1million, up 5.2%
from$11.5millionin2011.
MajorityofthemarketersTMEat$11.3millionisspentonthehaircareproductclass.
Infusium23brandthemostTMEat$6.5millionin2012.
PertPlusreceivesaTMEof$4.8millionin2012.

Magazineadvertisingisthemostpreferredmarketingmediumadoptedbythemarketerto
promoteitsproducts.
Thecompanypromotesitsproductsthroughtrademagazinesandconsumermagazines
suchasLuckyandGlamour.
In 2012, magazine advertisements and television advertisements receive a TME of
approximately$9millionand$2.8million,respectively.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A178

HelenofTroy

Infusium23isthesponsoroftheU.S.SynchronizedSwimmingNationalTeamatthe2012
SummerOlympicsheldinLondon.
The brand is holding sweepstakes on its Facebook page. However, participants are
supposedtoliketheFacebookpageinordertoenterthesweepstakes.TheHonorary
TeamCaptainandaguestwillgetachancetoattendtheduetsynchronizedswimming
event,roundtripticketsfromNewYorksJFKtoLondonsHeathrowAirport,fivenight
stayinLondon,aVIPprizepack,andachancetomeetandgreettheteam.

PertPlusandBrutsponsortheWarriorDashinWindham,NYinAugust,2012.
TheWarriorDashisa5Kracethatteststheparticipantsmentalandphysicalstrength
through grueling obstacles. Pert Plus gives out shampoo samples to the participants,
whoaredirtyfromthemuddypit,tocleanupinthePertPlusSudzZonebeforethey
reachthepostracefestivalarea.

In2012,HelenofTroypromotesitsBrutrangeofproductswithanewcampaignsatirizing
machismo.
The digital and television based campaign, similar to its 2011 campaign is humorous
andistargetedatyoungmen.
The campaign includes two 15second spots showcasing Brut being the Essence of
Man.
Thefirst15secondadvertisementfeaturesamangettingreadyforanightoutwithhis
wifewholeavesthebathroomlookingsliminablackeveningdressandassoonasthe
manspraysontheBrutSplashOn,thewifeemergesasapregnantwomenandsodo
thedaschundandthegoldfish.
ThesecondadvertisementfeaturesamanapplyingtheBrutdeodorantwhilewatching
theweathernewsontelevision.Assoonasthemanappliesthedeodorant,themale
weatherforecasterturnsintoabikinicladblondewoman.
BrutusestheWarriorDashasameanstoshowcasethebrandssloganLetYourMan
Outbygivingparticipantsachancetowinaweekendgetawayworth$1,000.

Socialnetworkingsites,suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube,continuetobeanintegral
partofthemarketersmarketingstrategy.However,themarketerusesanantifeelgood
strategyinthehopetogoviralasOldSpicehas.
Bruts Facebook application, called Mantervention, features a 5minute video in
which a man berates account holders and some of their posts, criticizing them for
participatingonFacebook.
This happens with the help of the profile access feature on Facebook, which allows
everyapplicationtoseekpermissiontohaveaccessto,fromtheaccountholder.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5179

5180

HelenofTroy

OUTLOOK

SalesofHelenofTroyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryisprojectedtodeclineat
aCAGRof2.9%intheforecastperiod,2012to2017.

The company has been investing a great deal in acquiring brands in the industry, and
focusingontheUnitedStatesasaprimarymarket.
HelenofTroycontinuestofocusondevelopingitsbusinessthatfalloutsidethescope
ofthisreportsresearch.Thecompanyisbiginthehaircaremarketwithspecialization
inthehaircareappliancesmarketwhichisnotapartofthisreport.
The company has not done enough to develop and support the sales of its U.S.
cosmeticsandtoiletriesbrands.

Duringtheforecastperiod,theshampooscategorywillcontinuetogeneratethemostsales
forthecompanyintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry.
Inthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory,theSurebrandwillcontinuetodecline
until and unless the marketer makes innovations with new product introductions,
packaginganddesign,andmarketinginitiatives.
However,theBrutbrandwillcontinuetopoststablesalesoverthenextfiveyearsdue
toconsumerloyaltytowardsthebrand.

HelenofTroyshouldemphasizeonitsmarketingstrategytopromoteitsbrandsandnewly
introducedproductsduringtheforecastperiod,ending2017.
Socialmedianetworks,suchasFacebook,Twitter,andYouTube,willcontinuetobean
integral part of the marketers marketing campaign as its target audience incudes
youngconsumerswhoareactiveonsuchmedia.
Additionally social media is of great importance to the marketer due to its limited
marketingbudget.
The company will continue to utilize events and campaigns in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategorytocompetewithothermalecentricbrandssuchasOldSpice,
Axe,andGillette.
Themarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitsadvertisingspendandpromotionalactivitesin
thehaircareproductclass.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A180

HelenofTroy

HelenofTroywillbeabletogathersomegrowthifitseeksoutthefollowingkeythings.
In order to broaden its growth opportunities, the company should seek to acquire
brandsthathaverelevancetothecompanyspersonalcarebusinessinthecosmetics
andtoiletriesindustry.Incaseswhereacquisitionisnotfeasible,thecompanyshould
lookforlicensedbrandswithsubstantialbrandequityinordertocreatesynergieswith
themarketersexistingbrands.
Thecompanyshouldlooktoexpanditsexistinglineofproductswithnew,innovative,
and technologically advanced products that will help drive sales during the forecast
periodending2017.
Expansioninthedistributionnetworkwillalsoaidinthegrowthofthecompanyssales.
The companys strategy of reducing the time difference between developing and
introducing new products to meet the changing needs of the consumers in the fast
evolvingcosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketwillalsohaveapositiveeffectonthesalesof
thecompany.
However, the lack of constructive efforts to support its cosmetics and toiletries sales
willlikelyputadentinthesalesgrowthprospectofthemarketerduringthenextfive
years.

HelenofTroyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareprojectedtodeclineataCAGRof2.9%to
$127millionin2017,downfrom$147millionin2012.

Table598:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforHelenofTroybyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Fragrancesformen

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

(2.2)

Conditioners

(2.8)

COMPANYAVERAGE

(2.9)

Facialtreatments

(3.0)

Shampoos

(3.1)

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

(9.0)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5181

5182

HelenofTroy

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A182

JOHNSON&JOHNSON

Table5107:Johnson&JohnsonsSalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

2012

Neutrogena

330

347

Clean&Clear

108

111

Aveeno

84

81

RoC

52

52

579

596

336

340

10

10

Listermint

Rembrandt

350

354

112

120

Lubridermr

60

63

Neutrogena

26

25

207

217

158

169

20

20

178

189

161

157

26

28

187

185

Purpose
Totalr
MOUTHWASHES
Listerine
Plax

Total
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Aveenor

Johnsons
Totalr
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Neutrogena
Aveeno
Total
BABYCAREPRODUCTS
Johnsons
Aveeno
Total
(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5184

Johnson&Johnson

Table5107:Johnson&JohnsonsSalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

2012

Aveeno

73

71

Neutrogenar

40

43

Johnson'sSoftwash

Johnson'sKids

115

115

Neutrogena

53

54

JohnsonsBaby/KidsShampoo

37

35

Aveenor

17

19

NizoralAD

113

113

72

75

Neutrogena

31

32

Aveenor

15

16

Johnsons

55

57

Rembrandt

21

22

Listeriner

28

29

Totalr
SHAMPOOS

Totalr
FACEMAKEUP
Neutrogena
CONDITIONERS

Totalr
TOOTHPASTES

Totalr
SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

NeutrogenaMen

22

23

Aveeno

Neosporin

Neutrogena

18

18

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS

Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A184

Johnson&Johnson

Table5107:Johnson&JohnsonsSalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

SHAVINGPRODUCTS

2012

11

10

17

16

EYEMAKEUP

Neutrogena

15

15

13

Aveeno
NeutrogenaMen
Total

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Neutrogena
TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS

Rembrandt

ListerineWhitening

Total

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Duke
TOTALr

rRestated.

1,979

2,020

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Johnson&Johnsonisamongtheworldslargestmanufacturersofhealthcareproductsfor
the consumer, pharmaceutical, and professional markets. It is headquartered in New
Brunswick,NJ.
The company operates in 60 countries through 250 operating companies, and its
productsaresoldinvirtuallyallcountries.
Asof2012,thecompanyemploysapproximately117,900people.

Johnson&Johnsonoperatesthroughthreebusinesssegments:
The Consumer segment primarily markets skin care products, hair care products, oral
careproducts,babycareproducts,sanitaryprotectionproducts,woundcareproducts,
andnonprescriptiondrugs.
TheMedicalDevicesandDiagnosticssegmentencompassesabroadrangeofproducts
used by or under the direction of health care professionals, including surgical and
medicalsupplies.
The Pharmaceutical segment distributes prescription drugs for use by health care
professionalsandthegeneralpublic.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5185

5186

Johnson&Johnson

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Johnson& Johnsons corporate sales total grow 3.4% to $67,224million in 2012, up from
$65,030millionin2011.

In2012,Johnson&Johnsonsnetprofitgrows12.2%to$10,853million,from$9,672million
in2011.
In the fourthquarter net profits rise to $2.6 billion from $218 million for the same
period in 2011. In its fourthquarter, Johnson & Johnson includes sales of recently
acquiredcompany,Synthes.
Increaseinsalesofprescriptiondrugsandmedicaldevicesalsoresultinincreaseofnet
profitsforthecompany.

Corporatesalesforthecompanyhaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of1.9%peryearsince2007.

Table5108:Johnson&JohnsonsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

Netprofit

2007

61,095

10,576

2008

63,747

2009

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

17.3

24.4

12,949

20.3

30.5

61,897

12,266

19.8

24.2

2010

61,587

13,334

21.7

23.6

2011

65,030

9,672

14.9

16.9

2012

67,224

10,853

16.1

16.7

The United States continues to be the singlelargest market for Johnson& Johnson, with
sales of $29,830 million in 2012 or 44.4% of sales, up from $28,908 million and 44.4% of
salesin2011.

Internationalsalescontinuetogainshare,andrepresent55.6%ofthecompanystotalsales,
at$37,394millionin2012,upfrom$36,122millionand55.6%in2011.
TheConsumersegmentaccountsfor21.5%ofthetotalsalesin2012.

Table5109:Johnson&JohnsonsGlobalSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011and2012

Segment

$Million

%Ofsales

%Ofoperatingprofit

2011

2012

2011

2012

2011

2012

Medicaldevicesand
diagnostics

25,779

27,426

39.6

40.8

38.3

48.1

Pharmaceutical

24,368

25,351

37.5

37.7

46.5

40.6

Consumer

14,883

14,447

22.9

21.5

15.2

11.3

Total

65,030

67,224

100.0

100.0

100.0

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A186

Johnson&Johnson

SalesforthecompanysConsumersegmentdeclineby2.9%from$14,883millionin2011to
$14,447millionin2012.

Table5110:Johnson&JohnsonsSalesbyConsumerSegment,2007to2012

$Million
Year

Consumer

Allother

2007

14,493

2008

%Oftotal

Total

Consumer

Allother

Total

46,602

61,095

23.7

76.3

100

16,054

47,693

63,747

25.2

74.8

100

2009

15,803

46,094

61,897

25.5

74.5

100

2010

14,590

46,637

61,587

24.3

75.7

100

2011

14,883

50,147

65,030

22.9

77.1

100

2012

14,447

52,777

67,224

21.5

78.5

100

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Johnson&JohnsonsU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesgrowby2.1%to$2,020millionin
2012from$1,979millionin2011.

Johnson&JohnsonssaleshaveincreasedataCAGRof2.1%since2007.

Table5111:Johnson&JohnsonsCosmeticsand
ToiletriesSales,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007r

1,825

2008r

1,885

3.3

2009r

1,901

0.8

2010r

1,945

2.3

2011r

1,979

1.7

2012

2,020

2.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5187

5188

Johnson&Johnson

Johnson&Johnsonslargestproductcategory,facialtreatments,accountsfor29.5%ofthe
companystotalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesfortheyear2012.
Categorysalesareup2.9%from$579millionin2011to$596millionin2012.
Neutrogenaisthecompanysleadingbrandinthecategory.
The brand is the secondlargest brand in the mass segment with $347million in
manufacturerssalesin2012,up5.2%from$330millionin2011.
OneofthemajorgrowthcatalystsforNeutrogenaistheNaturalslinewhichissaidtobe
97% naturallyderived and contains antioxidants. The line is extended in 2012 with
MultiVitamin Nourishing Moisturizer which is a daily lotion that replenishes essential
nutrients.
In 2012, Neutrogena extends its acne line with the launch of AllInOne Acne Control
Treatmentwhichthecompanypromotesasamultifunctionproductthatisabletofade
acnescarswhilecontrollingpresentandpreventingfuturebreakouts.
Advertising expenditures for Neutrogenas facial treatment brands are approximately
$14.0millionduring2012,adramaticdeclinefrom$88.3millionduring2011.

Thecompanysmouthwashescategoryisthesecondlargestforthecompany,contributing
17.5%tothetotalsales.
Johnson&Johnsonremainstheleadingmarketerinthemouthwashescategoryin2012,
withtotalsalesof$354million,up1.1%from$350millionin2011.In2012,themarket
sharedecreasesto44.3%,from44.8%in2011.
Listerineisthecompanyslargestmouthwashbrandandisalsothepreeminentleader
inthiscategory.
Listerines sales grow 1.2% from $336 million to $340 million in 2012. Growth of the
Listerine brand is supported by the strong performance of its alcoholfree variants:
ListerineZeroandTotalCare.
The company continues to stress on the importance of using Listerine twice a day in
ordertohave24hourprotection.
IncreasedmarketingandnewproductactivitysupportthesalesoftheListerinebrandin
2012.
SalesofPlaxremainat$10millioneachin2011and2012duetoalackofpromotional
supportandexcitementforthebrand.
Sales of Listermint and Rembrandt remain low at a rounded $2 million each in 2012,
sameas2011levels.
Hand and body lotions is the thirdlargest product category for Johnson & Johnson,
accountingfor10.7%ofthecompanystotalsales.
Johnson & Johnson is the secondlargest marketer in the hand and body lotions
category,withsalesat$217millionin2012.
Salesgrow4.8%from$207millionin2011.
Johnson&Johnsonsmarketsharegrowsfrom9.2%in2011to9.5%in2012.
The marketer competes in the category with its Aveeno, Neutrogena, Lubriderm,
Johnsons,andRoCbrands.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A188

Johnson&Johnson

Aveenoisthelargestbrandforthemarketerinthecategorywithsalesat$120millionin
2012,up7.1%from$112millionin2011.Aveenosnaturalpositioninginthemarketis
the primary reason behind the brands growth as more consumers choose naturally
positionedhandandbodylotionsovertheconventionalhandandbodylotions.
Aveenorepresents55.3%ofthemarketerstotalsalesinthecategoryin2012.
Thebrandclaimstoenrichitsproductformulationswithactivenaturalingredients.
Some of the commonly found natural ingredients in Aveenos hand and body lotions
include blueberry, goji berries, grapefruit, rosemary, vanilla, cocoa butter, and shea
butter.
The marketers secondlargest brand in the category is Lubriderm, with sales at
$63millionin2012,up5.0%from$60millionin2011.Growthin2012isdrivenbythe
formulation changes that the marketer introduces to its Lubriderm line in late 2011,
effectsofwhichareevidentinits2012sales.
The brand represents a 29.0% category share in Johnson & Johnsons total hand and
bodylotionssales.
Lubridermpositionsitselfasadermatologistdevelopedbrandwithfourproductlines:
DailyMoisture,AdvancedTherapy,IntenseSkinRepair,andSoothingRelief.
Sales of Johnson & Johnsons thirdleading brand, Neutrogena, decline 3.8% from
$26millionin2011to$25millionin2012.Neutrogenassalesdeclineasaresultofthe
lack of new and innovative product activity from the brand in the category in 2012.
Additionally, the brands offerings in the category are limited in comparison to other
brands offerings. The more successful competitors are continuously evolving their
brandstooffernewandinnovativeproductswithadditionalbenefitsandfragrancesin
ordertokeepconsumersengaged.
Asaresultofthesalesdeclinein2012,NeutrogenasshareinJohnson&Johnsonssales
inthehandandbodylotionscategorydeclinefrom12.6%in2011to11.5%in2012.

Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestobethesingledominantmarketerinthebabycareproducts
categoryin2012,withitsJohnsonsBabyandAveenobrands.
In 2012, the manufacturers sales decline by 1.1% from $187 million in 2011 to $185
million.
Johnson&Johnsonhasbeeninthenewsfortheinclusionofunwantedformaldehydes
in its baby care products. The company has made claims to remove these
formaldehydes from its baby care products and the No More Tear Baby Shampoo by
2013.
JohnsonsBabycontinuestodominatethecategorywithsalesat$157millionin2012,
down2.5%from$161millionin2011.Thedecliningsalesisattributedtothelackofnew
product activity, dearth of innovation, and the negative news surrounding its product
recallsin2012.
Johnsons Baby posts declining sales in the baby bath and baby lotions segments and
stagnantsalesinthebabyoilsandbabypowderssegments.
Johnson&Johnsonsotherbrandinthecategory,Aveeno,showssalesgrowthof7.7%,
from$26millionin2011to$28millionin2012.Thehealthygrowthisattributedtoits
goodperformanceinboththebabybathandthebabylotionssegments,throughwhich
itcompetesinthebabycareproductscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5189

5190

Johnson&Johnson

AveenosOrganicHarvestline,launchedin2011,comprisingthreeSKUs,isdiscontinued
in2012onaccountoflosingitsU.S.DepartmentofAgriculture(USDA)NationalOrganic
Program (NOP) certification status as a result of its products containing an ingredient
thatisnotontheUSDAsNationalList.AlthoughtheOrganicHarvestlineisnotavailable
onthecompanysofficialwebsite,itcanstillbefoundoncertainonlineportalsandon
theshelvesofafewretailers.
In August 2012, Aveeno voluntary recalls its baby Calming Comfort Lotion, after the
FDAstestsonasampleproductshowexceededspecifiedquantitiesofcommonbacteria.
However,theproductisrelaunchedin2012afterprecautionarymeasurestakenbythe
company.

Johnson & Johnson slides below Merck to become the thirdleading marketer in the sun
careproductscategoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalestotal$189millionin2012,up6.2%from$178millionin2011.
Thecompanysshareslidebyamere0.1%from18.1%in2011to18.0%in2012.
Johnson&Johnsonisrepresentedbytwomajorbrandsinthecategory:Neutrogenaand
Aveeno.
Neutrogenaisthethirdleadingbrandinthecategorywithsalesat$169millionin2012,
withahealthygrowthof7.0%from$158millionin2011.
Thebrandsgrowthin2012ismainlyattributedtoitsexpandingdistributionnetwork,
good reputation in the market, and increasing marketing support from the parent
company,Johnson&Johnson.
The companys latest product line, the Wet Skin line comprising six SKUs, launched in
2011continuestodowellin2012.
The brand also offers an array of multifunctional products offering benefits such as
antiaging, moisturizing, and makeup. A few such products include Age Defense Anti
Oxidant Moisturizer SPF 20, Healthy Skin AntiWrinkle Cream with sunscreen SPF 15,
HealthyDefenseDailyMoisturizerwithsunscreenBroadSpectrumSPF50SensitiveSkin,
andVisibleEvenDailyMoisturizerBroadSpectrumSPF30.
Neutrogena also offers sun care moisturizers designed specifically for men. These
includeNeutrogenaMenTripleProtectFaceLotionwithsunscreenSPF20,Neutrogena
Men Sensitive Skin OilFree Moisture with sunscreen Broad Spectrum SPF 30, and
NeutrogenaMenAgeFighterfaceMoisturizerwithSunscreenSPF15.
Johnson&Johnsonsotherbrandinthecategory,Aveeno,recordssalesat$20millionin
2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Followingadeclinein2011,Aveenorecuperatesitssalesin2012withthelaunchofits
newProtect+Hydratelineofproducts.
TheProtect+HydrateproductlinecomprisesthreeSKUs:LotionSunscreenwithBroad
SpectrumSPF30,LotionSunscreenwithBroadSpectrumSPF50,andLotionSunscreen
withBroadSpectrumSPF70.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A190

Johnson&Johnson

PersonalcleansingproductsisthesixthlargestcategoryforJohnson&Johnson,accounting
for5.7%ofthecompanystotalsalesin2012.
Categorysalesremainflatat$115millionin2012,constantwith2011levels.
ThecompanysellsAveeno,JohnsonsKids,JohnsonsSoftwash,andNeutrogenabrands
inthecategory.
AveenoisthebiggestbrandforJohnson&Johnsoninthecategoryin2012.
Aveenossalesdecline2.7%,from$73millionin2011to$71millionin2012.
SalesofNeutrogenagrowby7.5%,from$40millionin2011to$43millionin2012.
JohnsonsSoftwashbrandssalesremainflatat$1millionin2012.
ThemarketerdiscontinuesitsJohnson'sKidsbrandinthecategoryin2012.

Johnson & Johnsons shampoos categorys sales are flat at $113 million in 2012, constant
with2011levels.
Johnson&Johnsonisthefourthrankedmarketerintheshampooscategoryandhasa
4.3%shareinthecategoryssales.
Thecompanymarketsfourbrands,Neutrogena,JohnsonsBaby/KidsShampoo,Nizoral
AD,andAveeno,inthecategory.
Neutrogena,theleadingbrandfromJohnson&Johnson,grows1.9%from$53millionin
2011to$54millionin2012.
SignificantproductlaunchesunderNeutrogenain2012areCleanReplenishingshampoo
andTripleMoistureCreamLathershampoo.
Johnson's Baby/Kids brand experiences a decline of 5.4%, from $37 million in 2011 to
$35millionin2012.
Sluggishsalesinthechildrensandbabieshaircaresegmentnegativelyaffectthesales
oftheJohnson'sBaby/Kidslinein2012.

ThemarketersellsonlyonebrandNeutrogenainthefacemakeupcategory.
Salesgrowby4.2%,to$75millionin2012from$72millionin2011.

Thecompanysconditionerscategorygrowinsalesby3.6%from$55millionin2011to$57
millionin2012.
Themarketerdistributesthreebrandsunderthiscategory:Neutrogena,Johnsons,and
Aveeno.
The marketer launches several new products under both, Aveeno and Neutrogena
brandsthatsupportthemarketerssalesgrowthinthecategory.
Neutrogena,thelargestbrandforJohnson&Johnson,hasacategoryshareof1.9%in
2012.
Neutrogenassalesgrowby$1millionfrom$31millionin2011to$32millionin2012.
The launch of Neutrogena TGel range of conditioners supports the brands growth in
2012.
SalesofAveenogrowby6.7%,from$15millionin2011to$16millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5191

5192

Johnson&Johnson

Inthetoothwhiteningproductscategory,Johnson&Johnsondropstofifthplacein2012,
experiencingadeclineinmarketsharefrom3.1%in2011to3.0%in2012.
TheListerinetoothwhiteningbrandwasdiscontinuedfromthemarketin2011,leading
tothesalesdeclineforJohnson&Johnsoninthecategory.
ThediscontinuationofListerineWhiteningproductscan,tosomeextent,beaccounted
forbythelawsuitforpatentinfringementfiledagainstthecompanyin2008byProcter
&Gamble.
ThelawsuitprohibitedJohnson&JohnsonandMcNeilPPCfrommaking,selling,and/or
importing any products that infringes on Procter & Gambles patents for tooth
whiteningproducts.In2011,thecompanystoppeddistributingitswhiteningstrips.
ThecompanysotherbrandRembrandtssalesgrowby14.3%,from$7millionin2011
to $8 million in 2012. The brands growth is supported by an increase in promotional
activityin2012.

Thecompanyoccupiesfifthplaceinthetoothpastescategory.
ThecompanysellsRembrandtandListerinebrandsunderthiscategory.
Theoverallmarketshareremainsflatat1.4%in2012.
Totalcategoryssalesgrow3.6%,from$28millionin2011to$29millionin2012.

Johnson&JohnsonsNeutrogenabrandcontinuestobethelargestmensskincarebrandin
2012,withmanufacturerssalesat$23millionin2012,up4.5%from$22millionin2011.
TheNeutrogenabrandisknownforitsacneandantiagingskinbenefits.
The brands growth is mainly attributed to the sales from its facial treatments,
specificallyitsfacewashesandfacialtreatmentscontainingSPFbenefits.
Neutrogena Men competes in the category through four product lines including
NeutrogenaMen,RazorDefense,SensitiveSkin,andSkinClearing.
Thebrandsfurthergrowthin2012hasbeenoffsetbythelackofnewandinnovative
productactivity.

Sales in Johnson & Johnsons lip balms, jellies, and treatments category remain flat at
$18millionin2012.
Neosporin,Aveeno,andNeutrogenaarethebrandsmarketedunderthecategory.
Allbrandsinthecategory,Neosporin,Neutrogena,andAveenohavesalesof$6million
respectivelyin2012.

Thecompanysshavingproductssalesdecline5.9%from$17millionin2011,to$16million
in2012.
Johnson & Johnson retains its position as the fourthlargest player in the shaving
productscategoryin2012.
The marketer is represented in the category with its Aveeno and Neutrogena Men
brands.
SalesofAveeno,Johnson&Johnsonsleadingbrandintheshavingproductscategory,
decline9.1%to$10millionin2012,downfrom$11millionin2011.
Neutrogena Men is the other brand of the marketer with which it competes in the
category.In2012,thebrandssalesremainconstantat$6millionfrom2011levels.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A192

Johnson&Johnson

Johnson&Johnsonsmakeupproductclasssalesdeclineby14.3%,from$28millionin2011
to$24millionin2012.
ThecategorymarketsonlyonebrandNeutrogena.
Thelipsticksandlipglossescategoryssalesdeclineby30.8%,from$13millionin2011
to$9millionin2012.
Theeyemakeupcategoryssalesremainflatat$15millionin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers,alliances,divestures,andacquisitions

Therehavenotbeenanymajordevelopmentsintermsofacquisitionsduring2012.
InJune2012,Johnson&JohnsonannouncescompletingtheacquisitionofSynthes,fora
totalpurchasepriceof$19.7billionincashandstock.
In March 2013, Johnson & Johnsons Cordis Corporation announces acquisition of
FlexibleStentingSolutionsInc.Itsfinancialtermsare,however,notdisclosed.

Managementchanges

In February 2012, Johnson & Johnson announces Alex Gorsky as Chief Executive Officer,
effectiveApril26,2012.

In September, 2012, Johnson & Johnson recruits Sandra Peterson as Group Worldwide
Chairman. She oversees information technology and the global supply chain, as well as
Johnson&Johnsonsconsumerbusiness.

Otherdevelopments

InAugust2012,JanssenBiotechannouncesgloballicenseanddevelopmentagreementfor
investigationalanticanceragentdaratumumabwithDanishcompanyGenmab.

In 2012, Johnson & Johnson recalls its Johnsons Baby Shampoo and discontinues its
AveenosOrganicHarvestlineofproductsonaccountofinclusionofharmfulchemicals.
Johnson&JohnsonsOrganicHarvestlineofshampoolosesitsUSDANOPcertification
on account of the fact that its products contain ingredients that are not on the
nationallyapprovedlistoforganicingredients.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5193

5194

Johnson&Johnson

Newproducts

Table5112:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyJohnson&JohnsonintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Aveeno

Facial
treatments

PositivelyAgelessCorrectingTintedMoisturizerisformulatedwithnatural
shiitakecomplexandvitaminC,tohydrateandnourishfacialskintohelp
visiblyreducethelookoffinelinesandskindiscolorations

Aveeno

Suncare
products

Protect+HydrateLotionSunscreenwithBroadSpectrumisacombination
ofEnviroguardTechnologyandActiveNaturalsOattoprovideUVAandUVB
sunprotection.Itisoilfree,noncomedogenic,sweatandwaterresistant
forupto80minutes,andisavailableinSPF30,SPF50,andSPF70.

Aveeno

Shampoos

PureRenewalshampoorefresheshairwithoutwaterforacleanand
healthylookbetweenwashes

Aveeno

Conditioners

PureRenewalconditionerrefresheshairwithoutwaterforacleanand
healthylookbetweenwashes

CleanandClear

Facial
treatments

AdvantageOilAbsorbingTreatmentisdesignedforuseinplaceofaregular
moisturizer.Thisoilfreeacneformulacontainssalicylicacidtotreat
breakoutswithoutcloggingpores

Listerine

Mouthwashes

TotalCareZeroinFreshMintvariant,preventscavities,restoresenamel,
strengthensteeth,preventsbadbreath,andcleansthewholemouth

Listerine

Mouthwashes

Ultracleanmouthwashcontainsantitartaringredientforcleaner,brighter
teeth,clinicallyproventoremoveplaqueandkillgerms.Itisavailablein
twovariants:ArcticFreshandFreshCitrus

Neutrogena

Facial
treatments

AllInOneAcneControlTreatmentnoticeablyfadesthelookofpastacne
marks,clearspresentbreakouts,andhelpspreventfutureacne

Neutrogena

Facial
treatments

TheNaturalslineisextendedwithMultiVitaminNourishingMoisturizer,a
dailylotionthatreplenishesessentialnutrients.Thecompanyclaimsitis
97%naturallyderivedandcontainsantioxidants

Neutrogena

Facial
treatments

UltraGentleDailyCleanserisanewcleanserformulatedforsensitiveskin

Neutrogena

Shampoos

CleanReplenishingshampoogentlycleanseshairanditsmoistureenriched
formulaprovidesalldaymoisturization

Neutrogena

Shampoos

TripleMoistureCreamLathershampoocontainsthreenaturallyderived
extractsthatpenetratetofightdrynessonallthreedimensionsofthehair
strand,asidefromcombatingfrizz

Neutrogena

Shampoos

TripleRenewalVolumeBoostingshampooisinfusedwithaminoacids,
vitamins,andnaturallyderivedproteins

Neutrogena

Shampoos

AntiResidueshampooisatreatmentthatinstantlycleanseshair,rendering
thestrandscleanandresiduefree

Neutrogena

Shampoos

Cleanvolumeshampoogentlycleansesandaddsbodytoflatandlifeless
hair

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A194

Johnson&Johnson

Table5112:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyJohnson&JohnsonintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Neutrogena

Conditioners

CleanReplenishingconditionergentlycleansesanditsmoistureenriched
formulapenetratesdrydamagedstrandstomakehairmoreresilient

Neutrogena

Conditioners

TripleMoistureDailyDeepconditionercontainsnaturallyderivedextracts
thatpenetrateandmoisturizehairstrands,therebyprovidingsmoothness
andsoftness

Neutrogena

Conditioners

TripleRenewalWeightlessconditionerisinfusedwithablendofamino
acids,vitamins,andnaturallyderivedproteins

Neutrogena

Conditioners

CleanVolumeconditionergentlycleansesandaddsbodytoflatlifelesshair,
leavingnobuildup

NeutrogenaMen

Skincare
productsfor
men

SkinClearingAcneWashisanoilfreegentleformulawhichcleansesdeep
porestominimizebreakoutsandingrownhairandpreventnewonesfrom
appearing

Rembrandt

Toothpastes

RembrandtGentleWhitetoothpasteisspecificallydesignedforpeople
pronetocankersores.Theproducthelpswhitenteethandstrengthens
toothenamelwithoutsodiumlaurylsulfate(SLS),whichhasbeenreported
tocauseirritation

RoC

Facial
treatments

RetinolCorrexionMaxWrinkleResurfacingSystemisatwostepsystem
thatrenewsthelookandfeelofskinandclaimstobeclinicallyproventobe
uptofourtimesmoreeffectivethanaseriesofdermatologicalpeels

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Johnson&Johnsonusesmultiplewaystopromoteitsproductsincludingbroadcastmedia,
discountcoupons,instorepromotins,andonlinepromotions.
Themarketerpreferstelevisionandmagazineadvertisementstopromoteitsproducts.

The marketer offers discount coupons through magazines, newspapers, and websites as
oneofitskeyconsumerpromotionaltools.
Johnson & Johnson primarily offers discount coupons for its new product launches in
ordertosupportitssales.
Themarketerofferscouponswith$1.00offonitsJohnsonsHeadToToeBodyWash.
The company offers discounts coupons ranging from $1.00 to $2.00 on Listerines
websitetopromotethesalesofitsproducts.
Johnson & Johnson offers coupons worth $1.00 off on Johnson & Johnsons baby oil
products.
Johnson&Johnsonsponsors$1.00and$2.00denominationdiscountcouponsonmost
ofitsbabycareproductsthroughouttheyear.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5195

5196

Johnson&Johnson

Johnson&Johnsonspendsabout$439.8milliononTMEtosupportitsbrandsin2012.
Themarketerdecreasesitsmediaexpendituresby9.7%from$486.9millionin2011.
Thecompanyutilizesawiderangeofmediatoolstopromoteitsproducts.
The largest part of the media spend is for television spots and magazines, which
togetheraccountfor96.8%ofthetotaltraceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs).
The company spends about 64.6% on television advertisements and 32.2% through
magazinesin2012.

Johnson & Johnson continues to be the secondlargest advertiser in the hand and body
lotionscategorywithaTMEof$49.9millionin2012,down1.2%from$50.5millionin2011.
MostoftheTMEor$41.4millionisapportionedtowardstelevisionmediain2012.The
companyallocatesaTMEof$8.1milliontowardsmagazineadvertisements.
The company promotes its brands competing in the category through television
commercials and fullpage advertisements in popular beauty publications, such as
Glamour,Lucky,andBeautyFashion.
In2012,Johnson&Johnsonallocates$41.0millioninTMEtopromoteAveenosDaily
MoisturizingBodyLotion.

Johnson&Johnsonistheleadingadvertiserinthebabycareproductscategory,withTMEat
$31.4millionin2012,downfrom$31.9millionin2011.
Ofthis,58.6%ofTMEor$18.4millionisallocatedtomagazineadvertising,andtherest
isallocatedacrosstheInternetandtelevisionmedia.
Johnsons, the leading brand in the category, receives the majority of TME, at
$27millionin2012,withJohnsonsBabylotionsreceivinganindividualTMEallocation
of$8.9million.

Johnson & Johnson is the leading advertiser in the mouthwashes category with TMEs of
$55.9millionin2012,downby21.6%from$71.3millionin2011.
About threefourth of the companys advertising spend is allocated to television
commercials,andmostoftheremainingquarterspentonmagazineadvertisements.
All of the companys advertising support is allocated to the Listerine brand, with no
spendingonminorbrandsListermint,Plax,andRembrandt.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A196

Johnson&Johnson

The marketer adopts various methods of promotions including instore promotions,


sampling,andonlinepromotions.
In 2012, Johnson & Johnson launches its website, safteyandcarecommitment.com,
which informs consumers about the safe use and quality of ingredients and about
chemicalsusedinitsproductformulations.Thewebsiteistobeupdatedwithconsumer
feedback, new regulations, scientific developments, and information on Johnson &
Johnsonspolicies.
The Johnsons brand website established a platform encouraging moms to share their
funnystoriesandadvice.
The brand also utilizes its website to provide useful and necessary information from
healthcareprofessionalsandexpertstonewmoms.
The marketer displays its entire product range and keeps consumers abreast of new
productsandpromotionalactivitiesonitsFacebookpage.
JohnsonsFacebookpageoffersadviceandtipstohandlevariousbabyproblems.
The marketer promotes its products on this page by advertising numerous discounts
thatcanbeavailedbytheconsumers.
Thecompanyswebsiteisalsoutilizedtopromotecouponsandspecialoffers.
The marketer also utilizes social media sites such as Facebook, Pinterest, Twitter, and
Youtubepredominantlytopromoteitsproducts.
Johnson & Johnson continues to promote its products through its leading online
educationsite,babyCenter.com.
Johnson& Johnson distributes coupons and samples of its products to expectant
mothersthroughthesite.
TheListerinebrandswebsiteprovidestipsformaintainingacleanandhealthymouth.

Product advertisements increasingly differentiate products based on the ability to deliver


addedbenefits.
Johnson & Johnsons brand Listerine teeth whitening products advertisements tout its
ability to whiten teeth and provide deep cleaning. Products feature the #1 Dentist
RecommendedBrandlogoonitspackagingandadvertisements.
Plaxadvertisementsnotethebrandsclinicallyvalidatedefficacy.

InMarch,2013,OralHealthAmerica(OHA)joinshandswithListerinebrandtopromoteoral
healthcareforchildren.
OHAandListerineplantocallallAmericanstotakea21DayChallenge,swooshingwith
ListerineAntiseptictwiceadayfor21days,inordertoimprovetheiroralhealth
For every person who registers for the challenge, Listerine will contribute to OHAs
SmilesAcrossAmericaprogram.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5197

5198

Johnson&Johnson

Brand Ambassadors Emma Roberts, Hayden Panettiere, Miranda Cosgrove, and Sandra
EcheverriateamupwithNeutrogena,tostartthethirdannualWaveForChangecampaign
toencourageteenstohelpbuildbrighterfuturesforchildrenacrossthecountry.
NeutrogenaandGlobalGiving,afundraisingcharity,teamuptoreachagoalof$250,000
throughonlineinitiativestodriveteenstowardsthisnoblecause.
For every video view of the campaign on Neutrogenas Wave for Change website or
NeutrogenasFacebookpage,$1.00willbedonatedtoGlobalGivingtosupporttheU.S.
educationalorganizations.
EmmaRobertshasalsodesignedaWaveforChangetotebagtobegiftedtothosewho
makeapurchaseoftwoNeutrogenafacialskincareproductsatTarget.

InJanuary2013,JenniferAnistonsignsadealtobethenewfaceofAveenoproducts.The
newadvertisementreleasesinFebruary2013.

Aveenospreadsproductawarenessthroughmobileadvertisements.
Theseprintadvertisements,poweredbyShopText,promotethecompanysNourishand
Strengthenlineofshampoosandconditioners.
Thisapproachismeanttohelpclientsgetthemostoutofeveryadvertisementtheyrun.

The company also arranges special events and works together with retailers on special
promotions.
Targetoffersafree$5.00giftcardthatcanbeusedtobuyAveenoproducts.
CVSofferscouponsworth$1.00offonanyoneAveenoBodyCareProduct.

OUTLOOK

Johnson&Johnsonisforecasttopostmoderategrowthof1.5%overtheforecastperiod,
2012to2017.
The company will continue to gain sales through new product launches and product
innovationsduringtheforecastperiod.
Facial treatments and sun care product categories are expected to show good growth
forthemarketerovertheforecastperiodsupportedbyproductinnovations.
Thecompanysnaturalproductlineswilldrivethesalesofthecompanyinthefuture.
However, the recentlysurfaced legislative and imagerelated issues will take time to
resolveandwilllikelyimpedethecompanysomewhatthroughouttheearlypartofthe
forecastperiod,2013and2014.
However, the company is strong, with competencies and brand equity in many areas,
andwillrecuperatewithsomestrategicdeviationsfromitsrecentpaths.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A198

Johnson&Johnson

TheFacialtreatmentscategoryisexpectedtobethelargestrevenuegeneratorforJohnson
&Johnsonovertheforecastperiod.
Johnson & Johnson will likely launch new products with innovative technologies and
multibenefitpropertiestosupportthecategorysgrowth.
Themarketerislikelytointroduceproductsthatwilltargetpreventionandcorrectionof
commonissuesrelativetofacialconcerns.
Growingdemandforantiagingproductsisexpectedtosupportthecategorysgrowthin
thefuture.
Themarketerwillfocusoneliminatingharshchemicalingredientsinitsfacialtreatment
productsinordertosupportitssalesandcapitalizeonthegrowingnaturaltrend.

Thesuncareproductscategoryisforecasttopostthehighestgrowthof3.8%forJohnson&
Johnsonoverthenextfiveyears.
The marketer plans to launch products with multibenefits including antiaging, skin
nourishing, brightening, and makeup to support its sales in the category over the
forecastperiod.
Johnson & Johnson is expected to introduce sun care products with appropriate
cosmeticpropertiesandtextures.Theseproductswillapparentlydemandhigherprices,
permittingthecompanysdollarsalestogrow.
The company will continue to launch men care products in the category as the mens
segmentisprojectedtoperformwell.
Asanimportantcompanyinthepharmaceuticalindustry,Johnson&Johnsonshouldbe
asmuchormorepreparedcomparedtoitscompetitors,tosmoothlyadapttothenew
FDAsunscreenregulations.Thecompanyshouldnotbenegativelyaffectedbythemajor
changesrequiredasitisaccustomedtoworkingunderFDAguidelines.Newregulations
on product labeling and formulations have been forced into effect inDecember 2012,
andarelikelytoleadtoeffectivechangesduringthecomingyears.

The second largest category for Johnson & Johnson, mouthwashes, is forecast to post
moderategrowthof1.0%.
The marketer will continue to increase awareness among consumers regarding oral
hygieneinordertosupportitsoralcaresales.
Johnson&Johnsonisexpectedtointroducemouthwasheswithmultibenefitssuchas
teeth whitening, protection against bad breath, and enamel protection to support its
salesinthecategory.
The marketer is expected to increase its TME spending on the Listerine brand
mouthwashesoverthenextfiveyearstopromoteitssales.
The company is expected to provide more appropriate claims to its products in the
futuretoavoidanylegalissues.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5199

5200

Johnson&Johnson

Themarketerwillcontinuetobethesinglemostdominantplayerinthebbaycareproducts
categoryovertheforecastperiod.
Thecompanywillcontinuetomaintainitsleadingpositiondespitethenegativemedia
coveragesurroundingtherecallofitsJohnsonsBabyShampooandthediscontinuation
ofAveenosOrganicHarvestline.Thecompany,inordertosupportthesalesofitsbaby
care line, plans to remove the formaldehydereleasing preservative from all its baby
productsworldwidetoretainitsmarketshareintheforecastperiod.
Themarketerisexpectedtocontinuallyimproveitsproductassortmentandmakeuse
oftheincreasingdemandfornaturalproducts.
Naturally positioned brands such as Aveeno will continue to proliferate as parents
continuetolookintothewellbeingoftheirbabies.

ThecompanyscorebrandsAveeno,Johnsons,Listerine,andNeutrogenaareexpectedto
driveJohnson&Johnsonssalesoverthenextfiveyears.
Johnson&Johnsonwillcontinuetolaunchseveralnewproductextensionsunderthese
brandstosupportitssalesinthefuture.
The marketer will continue to infuse more natural ingredients into its products to see
highergrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Aveenoislikelytoperformwellacrossallskincarecategories,duetothepopularityof
naturalpositionedproducts.
Neutrogena,backedbyitstechnologyandstrongnewproductactivity,willbethekey
brandforthecompanyinthefacialtreatmentsandsuncarecategories.

Thecompanywillcontinuetoincreaseitsspendingonresearchanddevelopmentactivities
inordertointroduceproductwithbettertechnologies.
Johnson&Johnsonislikelytofocusoninnovations,asitwillbeakeytothecompanys
overallsalesgrowth.
The marketer is expected to launch innovative products based on latest scientific
techniquesandclinicaltrials.

Johnson&Johnsoncontinuestofocusonitssustainabilityprogram,HealthyFutureunder
which it plans to set a series of objectives to strengthen its position in the personal care
marketovertheforecastperiodbyusingsustainablepackaging.
As a part of this program, the company plans to focus on sustainable product
developmentandinnovationsinthecompanysproductportfolio.
Themarketerhassetupawebsite,www.saftetyandcarecommitment.com,inorderto
highlightthebenefitsofitssustainablepackagingbenefits.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A200

Johnson&Johnson

The company will continue to focus on naturallypositioned products, as this segment is


expectedtoperformwellinthefuture.
Johnson&Johnsonplanstoreduceoreliminatechemicalingredients,suchasparabens,
triclosan,anddiethylphthalatefromitsproductsovertheforecastperiod.
The company will likely launch products with more natural ingredients to support its
overallsales.
The marketer also plans to reformulate its entire range of products that contain
harmfulchemicalsbyendof2015.
Someofthechemicalsthatthecompanyplanstoeliminatefromitsproductportfolio
includes;4dioxaneandquaternium15.
The marketer plans to eliminate these chemicals from its leading brands such as
Neutrogena,Aveeno,andClean&Clear.

The marketer plans to enter new segments in order to strengthen its position in the
personalcaremarketovertheforecastperiod.
Johnson&Johnsonplanstocompeteintheantiwrinklearenawiththeformulationof
newdrugsin2013.
WhenthedruggetsapprovalbytheFDA,thecompanyexpectstodisplaycompetency
invariablyinthisarenatosupportitsoverallgrowth.

Johnson&Johnsonisexpectedtoincreaseitsmarketingandpromotionalactivitiesoverthe
forecastperiod.
The marketer will likely increase its TME support for its brands across categories to
supportitssales.
The marketer will continue to support its new product introductions with aggressive
mediaexpenditurestosupportitssales.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoengageconsumersinvariouscontestsandcampaignsin
ordertoeducateconsumersregardingitsproducts.
The company will continue to offer discount coupons and free samples for its new
launchesinordertoattractconsumers.
Televisionandprintadvertisingwillcontinuetobethepreferredchannelsofadvertising
forJohnson&Johnsonoverthenextfiveyears.
The marketer will continue to increase its presence on social media sites such as
Facebook, Twitter, Pinterest, and Youtube to keep the consumers engaged with its
products.

SalesofJohnson&Johnsonscosmeticsandtoiletriesareprojectedtoreach$2,180million
by2017,upbyaCAGRof1.5%from$2,020millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5201

5202

Johnson&Johnson

Table5113:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforJohnson&JohnsonbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Suncareproducts

3.8

Facialtreatments

3.0

Facemakeup

2.5

Eyemakeup

2.4

Shampoos

2.3

Conditioners

2.3

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

2.2

Handandbodylotions

2.2

Skincareproductsformen

2.0

Ethnichaircareproducts

1.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.5

Personalcleansingproducts

1.2

Mouthwashes

1.0

Toothwhiteningproducts

0.8

Babycareproducts

0.6

Lipsticksandlipglosses

0.5

Toothpastes

Shavingproducts

(4.5)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A202

KAO

Table5114:KaosSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

Jergensr

2012

149

162

Curelr

47

46

Totalr

196

208

FrizzEase

56

58

JohnFriedar

12

12

SheerBlonde

Allother

75

77

54

58

61

65

52

51

15

15

Allother

23

23

Totalr

41

41

SheerBlonde

17

17

BrilliantBrunette

14

14

RootAwakening

RadiantRed

44

39

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

Total
FACIALTREATMENTS
Bior
Jergens
Total
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS
Ban
CONDITIONERS
BrilliantBrunette
RadiantRed

SHAMPOOS

Totalr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5204

Kao

Table5114:KaosSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
PrecisionFoamColor
PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Jergens
TOTALr

rRestated.

2012

26

38

504

525

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Kao Corporation, headquartered in Tokyo, Japan, manufactures and markets household


cleaningproducts,industrialproducts,personalcareproducts,foodproducts,andchemical
products.

Thecompanysbusinessisbroadlydividedintotwobusinessdivisions:ConsumerProducts
andChemicals.

TheConsumerProductsDivisionisdividedintothreesubbusinessunitsthatincludeBeauty
Care,HumanHealthCare,andFabricandHomeCare.
TheConsumerProductsDivisionaccountsforthebulkofthecompanystotalsalesand
includesalargevarietyofproducts.
The Beauty Care business comprises prestige cosmetics, premium skin care products,
andpremiumhaircareproducts.
The Human Health Care business includes food and beverage products, sanitary
products,andpersonalhealthproducts.
The Fabric and Home Care business consists of fabric care products and home care
products.

The Chemical Business comprises Oleo chemicals, performance chemicals, and specialty
chemicals.

The companys operations are spread over more than 25 countries, including locations in
Asia,Australia,NorthAmerica,andEurope.
In2012,Kaoemploysabout34,069workersacrossallKaoGroupcompaniesglobally.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A204

Kao

IntheUnitedStates,KaoisheadquarteredinCincinnati,OH.
EffectiveJanuary2012,thecompanyundergoessequentialreorganizationasaresultof
which Kao Brands Company, KPSS, Inc, and KMS Global Marketing LLC have been
combinedandarenowcollectivelyknownasKaoUSA.
KaoUSAmanufacturespersonalcareproductsformenandwomenunderlabelnames
suchasJergens,Curel,SoftSense,Bior,JohnFrieda,andBan.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Kaos worldwide sales increase 2.5% from JPY 1,186.8billion (USD 14.9 billion) in 2011 to
JPY1,216.1billion(USD15.2billion)in2012.

Table5115:KaosGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

Billion

Yeara

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

2007

1,231.8

70.5

5.7

13.1

2008

1,318.5

66.6

5.0

11.7

2009

1,276.3

64.5

5.1

11.5

2010

1,184.3

40.5

3.4

7.3

2011

1,186.8

46.7

3.9

8.5

2012

1,216.1

52.4

4.3

9.8

aFiscalyearendingMarch31oftheyearafter.

NOTE:$1.00=79.78.

Table5116:KaosGlobalCorporateSalesbyProduct
Class,2011and2012

%Oftotal

Productclass

2011

2012

ConsumerProducts

83.3

82.7

ChemicalProducts

19.5

20.4

Eliminationsa

(2.8)

(3.0)

Total
100.0
100.0

aEliminationisintersegmentsalesandinterregional
sales.NetsalesoftheChemicalBusinessinclude
intersegmentsalestotheBeautyCareBusiness,the
HumanHealthCareBusiness,andtheFabricandHome
CareBusiness.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Returnonequity

5205

5206

Kao

KaosdomesticsalesinJapanconstitutethemajorportionofthecompanystotalsalesin
2012.
Salesinthedomesticmarketseizesalessharefromtherestoftheworld.
SalesinNorthAmericaandEuropeaccountfor16.6%oftotalrevenuesin2012,aslight
increasefrom2011levels.
Asia and Oceania account for the remaining 14.3% of Kaos total revenues in 2012, a
sharprisefrom12.8%in2011.

Table5117:KaosGlobalCorporateSalesbyRegion,2011and
2012

%Oftotal

Region

2011

2012

Japan

76.9

76.1

NorthAmericaandEurope

16.2

16.6

AsiaandOceania

12.8

14.3

Eliminations

(5.9)

(7.0)

100.0

100.0

Total

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

KaossalesintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketincrease4.2%toreach$525millionin
2012,upfrom$504millionin2011.Themarketersgrowthisattributedtotheincreasein
salesofthecompanyslargestcategory,handandbodylotions,andthefacialtreatments
category.
Also, Kaos entry into the hair coloring category with the John Frieda Precision Foam
Color in late 2010 continues to boost the marketers sales with the addition of new
shadesin2012.

Since2007,Kaoshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.4%.

Table5118:KaosCosmeticsandToiletriesSalesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007r

466

2008

446

(4.3)

2009r

463

3.8

2010r

468

1.1

2011r

504

7.7

2012

525

4.2

r Restated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A206

Kao

HandandbodylotionscontinuestobethelargestcategoryforKaoin2012.
Themarketeristhethirdleadingmarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategory,with
salesat$208millionin2012.Salesgrow6.1%from$196million2011.
Kaosmarketshareinthehandandbodylotionscategoryadvancesfrom8.8%ofthe
totalcategoryssalesin2011,to9.1%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012.
KaoisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsJergensandCurelbrands.
Jergensisthelargestmassbrandinthehandandbodylotionscategory,accountingfor
7.1%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfrom6.7%in2011.
Salesforthebrandadvance8.7%from$149millionin2011to$162millionin2012.
The good performance of the newlyintroduced Jergens Crema line with three
variantsCremaDeepConditioningOatmealBodyLotion,CremaSoothingAloeVera
BodyLotion,andCremaHydratingCoconutMilkaidsinthebrandsgrowth.
JergenslineofproductsinthehandandbodylotionscategorycomprisesNaturalGlow,
DailyMoisturizers,andCrema.
Alsoin2012,themarketerchangesthepackagingofitsNaturalGlowlineofproducts
withnewproductintroductions,includingtheNaturalGlowandProtectandtheDaily
Moisture Dry Skin Lotion, each including two variants for different skin tones: fair to
mediumandmediumtotan.
SalesofCureldeclinein2012to$46million,down2.1%from$47millionin2011.
Inadditiontobodylotions,Curelalsooffershandandfootcareproductsintheformof
Hand&CuticleTherapyandFootTherapy,respectively.

Kaos sales in the hair care product class increase 4.8% to reach $195million in 2012, up
from$186millionin2011.
Hair styling products and sprays is the secondlargest category for Kao in 2012, with
salesat$77millionin2012,up2.7%from$75millionin2011.
Hairstylingproductsandspraysaccountsfor14.7%ofthecompanystotalsalesinthe
cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012,adeclinefrom14.9%in2011.
KaosgrowthinthecategoryisduetothegoodperformanceoftheFrizzEasebrand
whichpostsagrowthof3.6%.
KaosotherbrandsinthecategoryincludeJohnFriedaandSheerBlonde,salesofwhich
remainconstantin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Conditioners is the fifthlargest category for Kao followed by the shampoos and hair
coloringproductcategories.
Themarketerssalesintheconditionerscategoryremainstableat$41millionin2012,
flatfrom2011levels.
In2012,themarketerintroducestheExtraRichConditioner.
Sales of Kao in the shampoos category decline 11.4% from $44million in 2011 to
$39millionin2012.
The marketers shampoo sales represent 7.4% of its total sales in the U.S. cosmetics
andtoiletriesmarketin2012,adeclinefrom8.7%in2011.
KaointroducestheFadeStopShampooin2012.
Kaossalesinthehaircoloringproductscategorypostanenormousgrowthof46.2%to
reach$38millionin2012,upfrom$26millionin2011.
In2012,themarketercontinuestoaddmoreshadestoitsPrecisionFoamBasedHair
Colorwithwhichitenteredthehaircoloringproductsmarketin2011.Foambasedhair
coloring product formulations remain a significant trend with the advantages of drip
freeformat,100%graycoverage,longlasting,andconvenientapplication.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5207

5208

Kao

FacialtreatmentsisthethirdlargestcategoryforKao,withsalesat$65millionin2012,up
6.6%from$61millionin2011.
In 2012, the share of facial treatments as a proportion of the companys total sales
increasesfrom12.1%in2011to12.4%in2012.
ThemarketerispresentinthecategorywithitsBiorandJergensbrands.
Bior marks a significant presence in the category with sales up 7.4% to reach
$58millionin2012,upfrom$54millionin2011.
In2012,thecompanyintroducestheBiorCombinationSkinBalancingCleanser.
Sales of Jergens in the category remain stable at $7million in 2012, flat from 2011
levels.

Deodorants and antiperspirants is the fourthlargest product category for Kao in the
cosmetics and toiletries market, with sales declining 1.9% from $52million in 2011 to
$51millionin2012.
In2012,deodorantsandantiperspirantsrepresent9.7%ofthemarketerssales,down
0.6%from10.3%ofthemarketerssalesin2011.
Themarketerssalesinthecategorycontinuetodeclineduetothelimitedpenetration
withitsBanbrand.Ithasnonewactivityin2012withtheexceptionoftheintroduction
of the Simply Clean Invisible Solid, which is unable to help the marketer regain its
growthinthecategory.
Furthermore,thedearthofadvertisingexpendituresinsupportofitsBanbrandaddsto
thebrandsdecliningsalesin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers,alliances,andacquisitions

Nomergersandacquisitionstakeplacein2012.

Managementchanges

In June 2012, Michitaka Sawada is appointed to the position of Representative Director,


President,andChiefExecutiveOfficer.
Andrea DeLeon is promoted from Senior Director, Marketing to Vice President,

MarketingforKaosSalondivisionintheUnitedStates.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A208

Kao

Newproducts

Table5119:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyKaoin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Ban

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

SimplyCleanInvisibleSolidcontainsfloralandambernotesforalong
lastingscent

Bior

Facialtreatments CombinationSkinBalancingCleanserisanewcleanserforcombinationskin

Goldwell

Shampoos

FadeStopshampoo,withitsuniqueFadeStopformulawithpomegranate
essencepreventsminimalcolorfading

Goldwell

Conditioners

ExtraRichconditioner,withitsuniqueformulawithpomegranateessence
providesminimalcolorfading

Jergens

Handandbody
lotions

NaturalGlowandProtectisabodymoisturizer,providesUVA/UVB
protection(SPF20),availablefortwoskintones:fairtomediumand
mediumtotan

Jergens

Handandbody
lotions

DailyMoistureDrySkinLotionisanodorlessdailymoisturizer,which
revitalizesskinwithantioxidantandvitaminE.Itisavailablefortwoskin
tones:fairtomediumandmediumtotan

Jergens

Handandbody
lotions

CremaDeepConditioningOatmealBodyMoisturizer,containsoatmeal
formulathatprovideshealingandsoothingpropertiestoreplenishtheskin

Jergens

Handandbody
lotions

CremaSoothingAloeVeraBodyMoisturizerisabodymoisturizerenriched
withaloevera,vitaminE,andvitaminB5

Jergens

Handandbody
lotions

CremaHydratingCoconutMilkBodyMoisturizerisalightweightformula
withcoconutmilk

JohnFrieda

Haircoloring
products

ThemarketeraddsmoreshadestoitsPrecisionFoamColor,permanenthair
color,availablein30shades

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The companys total traceable media expenditures (TME) for cosmetics and toiletries
increase3.1%from$127.4millionin2011to$131.4millionin2012.
Handandbodylotionsisthemarketerslargestadvertisedcategoryin2012,gathering
TMEsupportof$61.2millionin2012,up18.1%from$51.8millionin2011.
Facialtreatmentsreceivesthesecondlargestallocationofmediaexpenditures,witha
TMEof$17millionin2012,up14.1%from$14.9millionin2011.
In 2012, the hair coloring products category for the marketer receives a TME of
$15.8million.
Hair styling products receive a TME allocation of $11.1million in 2012, down 56.8%
from$25.7millionin2011.
JohnFriedaisthemostadvertisedbrandforthemarketer,receivingaTMEsupportof
$47.5millionin2012,downfrom$52.2millionin2011.
Jergens follows as the secondmost advertised brand with an advertising support of
$39.3millionin2012,up17.7%from$33.4millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5209

5210

Kao

Kao is the largest advertiser in the hand and body lotions category, with a total TME of
$61.2millionin2012,up18.1%from$51.8millionin2011.
Kao allocates $35.3million and $26.0million to its Jergens and Curel brands,
respectively.
Jergens Ultra Healing is the most advertised product line from Jergens, with a TME
allocationof$12.3millionin2012.Mostoftheseexpendituresarespentontelevision
andmagazineadvertisements.

Printadvertisementsinmagazinesremainthepreferredpromotionalmedium,followedby
televisionadvertisements.
CommonlyusedmagazinesbyKaoincludeAllure,Vogue,Glamour,InStyle,andCosmo
Girl.
In 2012, Jergens equips its print advertisements with QR codes. The print
advertisements equipped with the QR codes have begun to feature in the November
issueofInStylemagazine.Theadvertisementencouragesconsumerstoscanthemobile
bar codes with their phones to direct them to a web landing page that shows a 30
secondvideoonwomentryingouttheJergensUltraHealingLotion.
Additionally, there is a calltoaction on the page that induces consumers to visit the
JergensFacebookpagewheretheycansubmittheirownstyleideasforachancetobe
featuredintheprintadvertisement.
The marketer uses the QR code strategy to bridge the gap between print and video
advertisements.
Additionally, the marketer uses media advertising, couponing, sampling, and free
standinginserts(FSIs)featuringcouponstopromoteitsproducts.
CouponingremainsanimportantpromotiontoolforKaointhehandandbodylotions
category.

OUTLOOK

Duringtheforecastperiodfrom2012to2017,Kaoisforecasttopostamoderatetohealthy
growthof2.6%.
Themarketerislikelytoexperienceincreasedsalesinskincareandhaircareproducts,
duetothecompanysnewproductintroductions,reformulations,changesinpackaging
and design, and the use of innovative technology. Kao is expected to build on its
marketing strategy to further expand its business in the United States. The company
will continue to increase its media support to further boost sales growth, more so in
thecategoriesinwhichthecompanyhasasizeablepresenceandmarketshare.
One of the companys key aims through the forecast period is to accelerate growth
throughintegratedglobalbusinessoperations.
The marketer will continue to emphasize on the importance and development of
technologyinordertoaddvaluetoitsproductsandincreaseconsumersatisfaction.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A210

Kao

Kaos new matrix management system will shift the focus of the companys innovation
strategy from innovating in product categories to innovating based on consumers
perspective.
ContinuousinnovationwillbeKaosprimarystrategyduringtheforecastperiodwhich
willhavetwophases.
According to its breakthrough innovation phase, ideas for new products will be
developedthatisexpectedtodrivegrowth.
Thestepbystepinnovationphasewillbringaboutsmallandsignificantchangesthat
will help keep the brands relevant in the market place and fresh in the minds of the
consumers.

Kaossalesinthefacialtreatmentsandhandandbodylotionscategoriesareprojectedto
growat3.2%eachduringthenextfiveyears.
Kaosfacialcarebusinessisexpectedtoremainstrongandvibrantduringtheforecast
period.Productsinthissegmentbenefitfromcompetitivepricingandstrongproduct
formulationsofferedundertheBiorandJergensbrands.
For its Bior brand, the marketer is conducting strong rollouts at the local level by
understandingthetargetdemographyineachnation.
The Bior Restage Project, launched in 2010, has been designed for the brands
strategy in the United States. To gain sales in the U.S. facial cleanser market, the
marketerisrethinkingitstargetdemographybyfocusingonwomenintheirtwenties
due to their loyalty towards the brand. Additionally, based on several surveys, the
companyiscarryingoutcommunicationsstrategythatfocusesondigitalmarketing.
Jergens will continue to be the market leader in the hand and body lotions category
provided the marketer continues to innovate with the introduction of new products,
packaging changes, and technological advancements to offer a variety of product
variantsandkeepthemafreshinthemindsoftheconsumers.
Curelshandandbodylotionswillcontinuetogainsalesduetothepositioningofthe
brand as dermatologist recommended and the product offerings of which are
specificallycreatedtomoisturizeandhealdryskin.
ThenewlineextensionstoJergens,thecompanyslargestbrandinthehandandbody
lotionscategory,willfurtherrevivesalesandgainmarketshare.

Thehaircareproductclasswillcontinuetobeanareaofgrowthforthemarketer,witha
projectedmoderategrowthof1.5%duringtheforecastperiod.
TheJohnFriedaPrecisionFoamColor,whichmarkedthemarketersentryinthehair
coloringproductscategoryin2011,islikelytoperformwellduringtheforecastperiod,
with the possibility of the marketer introducing more product lines that induce
excitementandinterestamongconsumersandwidentherangeofproductstochoose
from.
The marketer is expected to introduce more variants in the hair coloring category to
match up with its competitors and offer its consumers a wide range of products to
choosefrom.
Themarketerisalsoexpectedtoshowamoderategrowthinhairstylingproducts,with
moderatedeclineinsalesintheshampoosandconditionerscategories.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5211

5212

Kao

Inthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory,KaosBanisaleadingbrandintherollon
segment and is expected to post stagnant sales until and unless it is refreshed with
formulationchangesandproductintroductions,tokeepabreastofcompetitionandmarket
dynamics.

The marketers performance will continue to decline in the personal cleansing products
categoryasJergensphasesoutofthecategorywithitsbodywashes.
Jergenswillhavelimitedofferingsinthebarsoapssegmentonly.

Kaos dollar sales in the U.S. cosmetics and toiletries industry are projected to grow at a
CAGRof2.2%toreach$586millionby2017,upfrom$525millionin2012.

Table5120:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmetics
andToiletriesforKaobyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Haircoloringproducts

5.6

Facialtreatments

4.2

Handandbodylotions

3.2

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.2

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

2.0

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

Shampoos

(0.5)

Conditioners

(2.0)

Personalcleansingproducts

(19.7)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A212

LIMITEDBRANDS

Table5121:LimitedBrandsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

2012

Bath&BodyWorks

248

260

VSFantasies

100

105

DreamAngelsHeavenly

95

100

Bombshell

50

53

Pink

25

27

Angel

24

26

Gorgeous

24

26

VerySexyforHer

14

15

Incredible

10

Rapture

SexyLittleThings

HenriBendel

BodybyVictoria

ParfumsIntimes

SecretMoments

Supermodel

VSNow

602

639

Bath&BodyWorks

420

437

VictoriasSecretGarden

102

105

Total

522

542

334

359

49

50

383

409

Total
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
Bath&BodyWorks
VictoriasSecretGarden
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5214

LimitedBrands

Table5121:LimitedBrandsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

59

58

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
VictoriasSecret
EYEMAKEUP

VictoriasSecret
SHAMPOOS
Bath&BodyWorks
VictoriasSecret
Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Bath&BodyWorks

22

22

12

13

19

20

18

18

20

17

FACIALTREATMENTS
PatriciaWexlerM.D.
LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
Bath&BodyWorks

14

15

14

14

VerySexyforHim

Bath&BodyWorks

14

13

VictoriasSecret

Bath&BodyWorks

Total

1,706

1,785

FACEMAKEUP
VictoriasSecret
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

Total
CONDITIONERS

SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN
Bath&BodyWorks
HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS
VictoriasSecret
NAILPOLISHES
VictoriasSecret
TOTALr

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A214

LimitedBrands

COMPANYOVERVIEW

LimitedBrands,Inc.,foundedin1963,isbasedinColumbus,OH.
Limited Brands is a leading manufacturer and marketer of apparel, beauty, and
personalcareproducts,andaccessories.
As of February 2013, Limited Brands employs approximately 99,400 associates
worldwide,ofwhich79,800associatesworkparttime.

Limited Brands portfolio includes brands such as Victorias Secret, Victorias Secret Pink,
Bath&BodyWorks,C.O.Bigelow,WhiteBarnCandleCo.,LaSenza,andHenriBendel.

The company has three reportable businesses: Victorias Secret, Bath & Body Works, and
Other.
The Victorias Secret segment incorporates womens lingerie and other apparel,
personalcareproducts,andaccessories.
Bath&BodyWorkshaspersonalcareproductsandhomefragrances.

Limited Brands sells its merchandise through its specialty retail stores, websites, and
catalogs.
The company operates a wide distribution network of more than 2,876 retail stores
nationwideintheUnitedStatesasof2012.
In the United States, the company sells its products through 1,019 Victorias Secret
storesand1,571Bath&BodyWorksstores.
La Senza apparel is available in Canada and 32 other countries around the globe and
hascloseto330stores.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Total sales for Limited Brands increase to $10,459million in 2012, up by 0.9% from
$10,364millionin2011.
However,netprofitsslide11.4%from$850millionin2011to$753millionin2012.
Since2007,salesforLimitedBrandshavegrownatacompoundaveragegrowthrate
(CAGR)of0.6%.

Table5122:LimitedBrandsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Netsales

Netprofit

Marginonsales

2007

10,134

718

7.1

32.4

2008

9,043

220

2.4

11.7

2009

8,632

448

5.2

20.5

2010

9,613

805

8.4

54.5

2011

10,364

850

8.2

620.4

2012

10,459

753

7.2

(74.2)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Returnonequity

5215

5216

LimitedBrands

Victorias Secret, the companys largest division, accounts for $6,574million in sales, or
62.9%ofthecompanyssalesin2012,anincreaseof7.4%from2011sales.
Bath& Body Works registers an increase in sales from $2,674million in 2011 to
$2,902millionin2012.

Table5123:LimitedBrandsGlobalCorporateSalesbyDivision,2011and2012

$Million
Division

2011

2012

VictoriasSecret

6,121

6,574

Bath&BodyWorks

2,674

Allothera

1,569

%Oftotal

2011

2012

Change,%

59.1

62.9

7.4

2,902

25.8

27.7

8.5

983

15.1

9.4

(37.3)

Total
10,364
10,459

100.0
100.0
0.9

aIncludesCorporate,MastGlobal,HenriBendel,andinternationaloperationsincludingLaSenza.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Sales of Limited Brands in the cosmetics and toiletries market grow 4.6% from
$1,706millionin2011to$1,785millionin2012.
Saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.6%since2007.

Table5124:LimitedBrandsCosmeticsandToiletriesSales,2007to
2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

1,568

2008

1,512

(3.6)

2009

1,525

0.9

2010

1,602

5.0

2011

1,706

6.5

2012

1,785

4.6

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A216

LimitedBrands

FragrancesforwomencontinuestobethelargestrevenuegeneratingcategoryforLimited
Brandsinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketin2012.
LimitedBrandsisthelargestmarketerofallfragrancesforwomen,witha23.5%share
during2012,upfrom23.0%in2011.
Salesgrow6.1%duringtheyear,from$602millionin2011to$639millionin2012.
All divisions of Limited Brands contribute to the companys growth as Bath & Body
Works,VictoriasSecret,andPinkexperiencegainsin2011.
New scents launched on a regular basis at favorable price points, along with
promotionalpricingonmultiplepurchasesistheprimestrategyforthesebrands.
Semiannual sales provide significant discounts on products to move merchandise,
makingwayfornewitems.
NewscentsfromBath&BodyWorksduringtheyearincludeCashmereGlow,Forever
Red,andLoveLoveLove.
Bath & Body Works repackages its body splashes and relaunches them as fragrance
mistsinearly2012.
The major womens fragrance launch for Victorias Secret is Incredible, launched at
approximatelythesametimeasthebraofthesamename.
Both Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret experience enormous success in the
fragrances for women category, after having tried to capture the fragrances for men
categorytonoavail.
Bath&BodyWorksremainstheleadingbrandinthecategory,withsalesup4.8%from
$248millionin2011to$260millionin2012.
The brand holds a 35.2% share of the specialty segment and a 9.6% share of the
category.
New fragrances added to its portfolio in 2012 include Cashmere Glow, Forever Red,
andLoveLoveLove.
Since2009,Bath&BodyWorkshasaddedhighendscentscomposedofseveralnotes
toitsportfolio,suchasCashmereGlowandForeverRed,andLoveLoveLovelaunched
in2012.However,thebrandstilloffersseveralofitsclassicscents,wherethenameof
thescentisdescriptiveofthefragrancenotes,suchasCountryAppleandCitrusMelon.
Bath&BodyWorksfragrancesaretypicallysomeofthelowestpricedscentsfoundat
theshoppingmallandthesefavorablepricepointsalongwithfrequentpromotionsand
itssemiannualsaleshelpgrowthebrand.
Promotionsareimportantforthesuccessofthisbrandwhichareofferedyearround
andincludebuythreegettwofreeandbuythreegetthreefreeoffers.
Additionally, the special online fragrance exclusive promotions are offered on the
brandswebsite.
Smallsizescentsalongwithtravelsizeversionsofnewreleasesaresoldnearthecash
registertoencouragetrialandimpulsepurchasing.
VS Fantasies, formerly Victorias Secret Garden, is the secondlargest brand in the
category, with a 5.0% increase in sales from $100million in 2011 to $105million in
2012.
VS Fantasies accounts for 14.2% of the specialty trade class and 3.9% of overall
fragrancessales.
Newscentsareaddedtotheline,andunderperformingonesarediscontinued.
Thecollectioncontinuestodowellduetoitsattractivepricepointsandregularlyoffers
promotionsofthreefor$24.00,orfivefor$30.00.
The Dream Angels Heavenly master franchise from Victorias Secret ranks third with
salesof$100million,up5.3%from$95millionin2011.
Thecompanyworkstopromoteitsnewerscents,suchasIncrediblelaunchedin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5217

5218

LimitedBrands

LimitedBrandsistheleadingcompanyinthehandandbodylotionscategory,witha3.8%
growth in 2012. It is more than twice the size of the next leading company, Johnson &
Johnson.
Sales grow from $522million in 2011 to $542million in 2012 supported by new
productintroductionsandpackagingchangestoitsexistinglineofproducts.
LimitedBrandsrepresents23.7%shareofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,upfroma
23.3%shareoftotalcategoryssalesin2011.
ThecompanyisrepresentedbyBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretbrandsinthe
category.
Bath & Body Works sales advance 4.0% from $420million in 2011 to $437million in
2012.
Bath & Body Works product offerings in the category include body lotions, body
creams,bodybutters,footlotionsandcreams,andhandlotionsandcreams.
Bath&BodyWorksSignatureCollectionisoneofthebestsellingproductlinesforthe
company.
Other popular product ranges for the brand include Forever Red, Paris Amour, and
CashmereGlow.
The Forever Red product line is a premium line and therefore is retailed at a higher
price.
In 2012, the brand introduces the Pink Chiffon Body Lotion, Cashmere Glow Body
Lotion, Paris Amour Body Lotion, Paris Amour Triple Moisture Body Cream, and the
ForeverRedBodyLotion.
Also in 2012, the marketer brings about packaging changes to its Sweet Cinnamon
Pumpkinlineofproductscomprisingabodylotionandamoisturebodycream;Twilight
Woods line of products that include a body lotion, moisture body cream, and body
butter;andBrownSugar&FiglineofproductswithabodyLotionandamoisturebody
cream.
As a part of its 2012 Holiday Traditions, the brand introduces the Vanilla Bean Noel
LotionandFrostedSnowberryBodyLotionforalimitedtimeperiod.
VictoriasSecretssalesadvance2.9%from$102millionin2011to$105millionin2012.
In2012,VictoriasSecretintroduceslimitededitionoftheSecretBombshellItalianIris
BodyLotion,ItalianBergamotBodyLotion,andVerySexyItalianMandarinLotion.Also,
new in 2012 are a number of Victorias Secrets Fantasies variants with exotic
fragrances.In2012,thePinklineofbodylotionsandbodybuttersundergoapackaging
changetogivethelineofproductsamorelivelyandfreshlook.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A218

LimitedBrands

LimitedBrandsisthefourthleadingmarketerinthepersonalcleansingproductscategory
withsalesat$409millionin2012,up6.8%from$383millionin2011.
MarketshareofLimitedBrandsincreasesfrom9.8%ofthecategoryssalesin2011to
10.2%in2012.
Duetostableeconomicconditions,consumerpurchasingcapacityimproves,resulting
inmoredemandforspecialtybrands,suchasBath&BodyWorks
Limited Brands is the leading marketer in the bath additives segment, with sales at
$262millionin2012,up6.5%from$246millionin2011.
Limited Brands has presence in the bath additives segment with Bath & Body Works
andVictoriasSecretGardenbrands.
LimitedBrandsisalsotheleadingmarketerintheantibacterialhandgelssegmentwith
salesat$44millionin2012,up7.3%from$41millionin2011.
ThemarketerispresentinthesegmentwithitsBath&BodyWorksbrand.
Limited Brands slides down to become the thirdleading marketer in the liquid soaps
segment, accounting for 20.5% of the marketers sales in 2012, marginally up from
20.4%in2011.
In2012,themarketerintroducesarangeofproductsforitsBath&BodyWorksbrand
including Pink Chiffon Pocketbac Sanitizing Hand Gel, Pink Chiffon Shower Gel,
CashmereGlowShowerGel,CashmereGlowGoldenSugarScrub,ParisAmourCreamy
Body Wash, Paris Amour Bubble Bath, Paris Amour Golden Sugar Scrub, Paris Amour
ShowerGel,PocketbacSanitizingHandGel,ForeverRedShowerGel,andForeverRed
GoldenSugarScrub.

The companys makeup product class contributes 5.3% to the companys total sales of
cosmeticsandtoiletriesin2012,downfrom5.6%in2011.
Lipsticksandlipglossescapturesthecompanyslargestshareinthetotalsalesinthe
makeup product class in spite of sales decline of 1.7% to $58million in 2012, down
from$59millionin2011.
The eye makeup category is Limited Brands secondlargest makeup category, with
salesof$22millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Limited Brands sales in the face makeup product category remain stagnant at
$14millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Thecompanydiscontinuesitsnailpolishescategoryin2012,withsalesslidingfroma
mere$1millionin2011tonegligiblesalesin2012.

Thefacialtreatmentscategorycontributes1.0%tocompanystotalsalesinthecosmetics
andtoiletriesmarketin2012.
Thecategoryssalesdecline15.0%from$20millionin2011to$17millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5219

5220

LimitedBrands

Limited Brands hair care product class contributes 1.8% to the companys total cosmetics
andtoiletriessalesin2012.
Companysalesgrow3.1%,from$32millionin2011to$33millionin2012.
Shampoos contribute the major chunk of the sales in the hair care product class for
LimitedBrands.Shampoossalesgrow5.3%from$19millionin2011to$20millionin
2012.
Sales of the company in the conditioners category remain stagnant at $8million in
2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Salesinthehairstylingproductscategoryareflatat$5millioninbothyears.

SalesofLimitedBrandsinthelipbalms,jellies,andtreatmentscategorygrow7.1%,from
$14millionin2011to$15millionin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Therearenoimportantdevelopmentsin2012.
InMarch2013,thecompanychangesitsnametoLBrands.

Newproducts

Table5125:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLimitedBrandsintheUnitedStatesin2012
Division/brand

Category

Description

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

PinkChiffonShowerGelisafeminineblendofsparklingredpear,
vanillaorchid,andwhippedchiffonmuskfragrancesenriched
withvitaminE,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,
andbubblierexperience.Itisavailableinatravelsizeaswell

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

PinkChiffonPocketbacSanitizingHandGelispocketsizedgerm
killerenrichedwithTahitianpalmmilktogivethehandsa
conditioningfeel.Itisscentedwithredpear,vanillaorchid,and
whippedchiffonmusk

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

CashmereGlowShowerGelisablendofgoldenpeach,
shimmeringvanilla,andcashmeremuskfragrancesenrichedwith
vitaminE,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,and
bubblierexperience

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

CashmereGlowGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystals
whichexfoliatesandconditionswiththeapricotandsweet
almondoils.Itsfragranceisablendofgoldenpeach,shimmering
vanilla,andcashmeremuskandcomesinaneasytousesqueeze
tube

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ParisAmourCreamyBodyWashisenrichedwithTripleMoisture
Complexofmilkproteins,ricebranoil,berryextracts,andshea
butterforahydratingwash.ItsfragranceisablendofFrench
tulips,appleblossoms,andpinkchampagne

(Continued

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A220

LimitedBrands

Table5125:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLimitedBrandsintheUnitedStatesin2012
Division/brand

Category

Description

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ParisAmourBubbleBathisavitaminenrichedbubblebathwith
afragranceblendofFrenchtulips,appleblossoms,andpink
champagne

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ParisAmourGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystalswhich
exfoliatesandconditionswithapricotandsweetalmondoils.Its
fragranceisablendofFrenchtulips,appleblossoms,andpink
champagne

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ParisAmourShowerGelisablendofFrenchtulips,apple
blossoms,andpinkchampagnefragrancesenrichedwithvitamin
E,aloevera,andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblier
experience.Itisavailableinatravelsizeaswell

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ParisAmourPocketbacSanitizingHandGelispocketsizedgerm
killerenrichedwithTahitianpalmmilktogivethehandsa
conditioningfeel.ItisscentedwithFrenchtulips,apple
blossoms,andpinkchampagne

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ForeverRedGoldenSugarScrubcomprisessugarcrystalswhich
exfoliateandconditionswithapricotandsweetalmondoils.Its
fragranceisablendofpomegranate,redosmanthus,andvanilla
rum

Bath&BodyWorks

Personalcleansing
products

ForeverRedShowerGelisablendofpomegranate,red
osmanthus,andvanillarumenrichedwithvitaminE,aloevera,
andsheabutterforacleaner,softer,andbubblierexperience

Bath&BodyWorks

Fragrancesfor
women

Newscentsduring2012includeCashmereGlow,ForeverRed,
andLoveLoveLove

VictoriasSecret

Fragrancesfor
women

Incredible,namedafterthelingerielaunchofthesamename,is
afloralfruityscentwithtopnotesofwhitepeachcombinedwith
pearandlotusaccords

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

SecretBombshellItalianIrisBodyLotionisalimitededitionbody
lotionfromtheCiaoBellafragrancecollectionwithtopnotesof
Italianiris,whitepoppy,andorris

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

VerySexyItalianMandarinBodyLotionisalimitededitionbody
lotionfromtheCiaoBellafragrancecollectionwithtopnotesof
Italianmandarin,bergamot,andcoconutmilk

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

VSFantasiesDeepsofteningBodyButterisrestorativebody
butterenrichedwithsheabutter,cocoabutter,andvitaminE.It
isavailableinthreevariant:LusciousCrush,CitrusDream,and
LemonEscape

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

VSFantasiesUltramoisturizingHandandBodyCreamisan
intensivehandandbodycreamenrichedwithavocadoand
sweetalmondoilsandhoneyfora24hourmoisturizing
experience.ItisavailableinthreevariantsLusciousCrush,Citrus
Dream,andLemonEscape

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

VSFantasiesHydratingBodyLotionisafastabsorbingbody
lotionenrichedwithextractsofaloe,oat,andgrapeseedand
vitaminEandC.ItisavailableinthreevariantLusciousCrush,
CitrusDream,andLemonEscape

VictoriaSecret

Handandbody
lotions

ItalianBergamotBodyLotionisalimitededitionbodylotionfrom
theCiaoBellafragrancecollectionwithtopnotesofItalian
bergamot,waterbreeze,andspringdaffodils

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5221

5222

LimitedBrands

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Limited Brands offers a visually stimulating environment along with knowledgeable sales
associates,pricepromotions,andaconstantflowofnewproductstoenticeconsumersto
makepurchases.
LimitedBrandscontinuestorelyheavilyonincreasedpromotionalactivitiesandheavy
discounts. Other mediums of advertising include sampling, emails, and direct mail
campaigns.
Limited Brands advertises its product through print advertisements in fashion and
beautymagazines,suchasAllureandGlamour.
Thecompanysinstore promotions throughits variousretailventuresformthemost
importantcomponentofLimitedBrandsproductpromotion.
Promotions,suchasgiftwithpurchase(GWP)andpurchasewithpurchase(PWP),are
offered around the year in Bath& Body Works stores. Buytwogetonefree and
Buythreegettwofreepromotionsarecommonthroughouttheyearinthesestores.
LimitedBrandsisalsoactiveonsocialmediasitessuchasFacebookandTwitter.

LeadingspecialtyretailbrandBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretemploysthetacticof
positioning fragrance offerings in more than one location in a store, especially near the
checkoutcounters.
VictoriasSecretandBath&BodyWorksofferseveralscentsinsmallersizesnearthe
checkoutcountersforimpulsepurchasing.
Victorias Secret promotes its products using a number of promotional activities,
including two semiannual sales in June and January and directmailing campaigns
announcing new products and offers. Victorias Secret regularly offers promotional
dealsonitsvaluepricedFantasiesline.
Bath&BodyWorksregularlysendsoutoffersviaemailordirectmailtoconsumersin
its database offering price discounts on multiple purchases. Additionally, the retailer
sometimes offers samples of upcoming fragrance products, at introductory prices of
$1.00or$2.00.

Instore promotions that sport huge discounts are popular among specialty marketers.
LimitedBrandsusuallyadvertisesitsBath&BodyWorksbrandbyprovidingoffers,suchas
buytwogetonefreeandbuythreegetthreefreepromotionsonselectproducts.
Bath & Body Works helps clear its stock of goods through its two semiannual sales
heldinJanuaryandJune.Thesesalespavewayforthebrandslatestlineofproducts.
Thebrandalsoprovidescoupons,suchasa$10.00offonpurchaseofproductsworth
$30.00anddiscounts,suchas20.0%offontheentirepurchaseorbuyfourproductsfor
$15.00orsixfor$20.00.
Instore demonstrations prove to be an effective marketing tool and relationship
builder for associates. Bath & Body Works stay clear from television and magazine
advertisingandoftenutilizeinstoredemonstrationssincetheyhaveamorepersonal
touch. Window displays is another commonly used promotional tool utilized by the
company.
TheBath&BodyWorkswebsitecontainsalistofallproductsalongwithaspecialtab
for all the products on sale. The brand offers discounts on some of its products
throughouttheyear.Freeshippingonpurchasesabove$50.00isanotherpromotional
toolwhichisoftenusedbythemarketer,especiallyduringtheholidayseasonof2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A222

LimitedBrands

OUTLOOK

Duringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017,thecompanyisforecasttoshowapositivegrowth
of 3.4% in the cosmetics and toiletries business. Its dominance in key categories in the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryisexpectedtoprevail.
With improved conditions in the economy, the marketer is likely to introduce
innovativeproductswithrespecttoadvancedtechnology,packaginganddesignchange,
changeinformulations,andexoticblendoffragrances.
The marketer is expected to command higher prices for these new and innovative
productstomeetthecostofproducingthemduringtheforecastperiod.
The company will continue to introduce new scents throughout the year, along with
giftpackagesandpromotionalpricingformultipleproductspurchased.
Bath&BodyWorkswillcontinuetointroducetravelsizeoptionsforitsvariouslinesof
productsfromitsSignatureCollectionintheformoffragrancemists,bodylotions,and
showergels.
Additionally,LimitedBrandswilloffercustomerstheflexibilitytocarrytheseitemsas
theyare3ounceseach,andmeetairlinecarryonluggagerequirements.Thiswillprove
tobeanadvantageforthecompanyaswell,becauseofthehigherpriceperounceof
product.

The fragrances product class will continue to be the leading product class, with its sales
forecasttogrowataCAGRof3.2%inthefiveyearforecastperiod.
The company is expected to develop new products in the fragrances for women
categorywithdistinctivefeatures.
ThemarketerbenefitsfromthesemiannualsalesheldforitsBath&BodyWorksand
VictoriasSecretbrands,whichbringinextrarevenueduringtheholidayseason.
Thecompanywillcontinuetoinnovateandintroducevariousoptionswithrespectto
sizes,giftpacks,andGWPforconsumerstopurchaseanycombinationtheylike.

The marketer is likely to witness the most growth from the personal cleansing products
categoryduringtheforecastperiod,ending2017.
Bath& Body Works sales will continue to benefit from its loyal customer base and
continual improvement in its product assortment, new scents, and improved
formulations.
ThemarketerislikelytokeepitsBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretbrandsalive
andfreshwithchangesinpackaginganddesignatregularintervals.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoinnovatewithnewfragranceblendsespeciallydesigned
fordifferentseasonsoftheyear.
However, Limited Brands will face competition from mass brands that will try and
emulate the marketers product offerings with respect to fragrances, formulations,
benefits,andpackagingdesigns.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5223

5224

LimitedBrands

HandandbodylotionswillcontinuetobeasignificantcategoryforLimitedBrands.
Bath&BodyWorkssaleswillcontinuetobenefitfromitsloyalcustomerbase.
Limited Brands will continue to introduce hand and body lotions with innovative
fragrance blends for its Bath & Body Works and Victorias Secret brands in order to
offerconsumerawiderselectionofproducts.
The packaging will be refreshed at regular intervals of time to add spark to the
productslabelingdesign,changeintheshapeofbottles,anddispensingformat.
ThecompanyisexpectedtoreceiveincreasedTMEallocationthrough2017.

LimitedBrandsisexpectedtocontinuewithrestrainedmediaexpenditures.
Limited Brands will continue to attract consumers with its aggressive consumer
promotionstoensuresalesgrowth.
Catalogs and instore promotions will continue to be the mainstay of the companys
promotionaleffortsinthefiveyearforecastperiod.
Itwillcontinuetosupportallnewproductlaunchesthroughprintadvertisementsinits
catalogs,andthroughthedistributionofsamplesandGWPoffers.
LimitedBrandssupportsBath&BodyWorksandVictoriasSecretthroughouttheyear
with regular email and direct mail campaigns, largescale sales events, catalogs, and
frequentGWPandPWPoffers.
LimitedBrandswillcontinuetosendoffersviaemailordirectmailtoconsumersinits
databaseofferingpricediscountsonmultiplepurchases.
ThemarketerisincreasinglyusingsocialmediasitessuchasFacebookandTwitterfor
instantaccesstoconsumers.
Tohelpboostsalesfortheendofyearholidays,Bath&BodyWorkswillcontinuewith
itsholidaypromotionsfromOctoberthroughDecember.

TheholidayseasonsandthecompanyssemiannualsalesthatisgenerallyheldeveryJune
andJanuary,whenspecialpricebasedpromotionsareconducted,willcontinuetogenerate
increasedsalesincomparisontotherestoftheyear.
These events will continue to contribute to a significant portion of sales during the
forecastperiod.
Duringthesalesevents,Bath&BodyWorksproductsareofferedatsteeplydiscounted
prices,resultinginhighsalesvolumes.

Themarketerislikelytoshowstagnantgrowthintheconditioners,hairstylingproductsand
sprays,lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments,andskincareproductsformencategoriesdueto
thelackoffocusonthem.
Therehasbeennegligiblenewproductactivityinthesecategoriesandthemarketeris
notexpectedtomakeanygroundbreakinginnovationinthemtospursalesduringthe
forecastperiod.

Sales of Limited Brands cosmetics and toiletries business are projected to increase at a
CAGRof3.4%toreach$2,108millionby2017,upfrom$1,785millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A224

LimitedBrands

Table5126:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforLimitedBrandsbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Personalcleansingproducts

4.7

Handandbodylotions

3.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

3.4

Fragrancesforwomen

3.3

Fragrancesformen

1.5

Facemakeup

1.4

Facialtreatments

1.1

Suncareproducts

1.1

Shampoos

1.0

Eyemakeup

0.9

Conditioners

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Skincareproductsformen

Lipsticksandlipglosses

(1.1)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5225

5226

LimitedBrands

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A226

LORAL

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

EYEMAKEUP

2012

Maybelline

422

446

LOralParisr

257

266

Lancme

122

128

31

40

10

841

890

Lancme

230

243

LOralParis

220

227

Garnier

61

76

Skinceuticals

57

61

Kiehls

44

52

LaRochePosay

22

27

Maybelline

TheBodyShop

Vichy

ShuUemura

657

709

UrbanDecay
YSLBeaute
Totalr
FACIALTREATMENTS

Total
HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS

L'OralExcellenceCrme

146

152

Preference

153

151

GarnierNutrisse

92

97

Fria

78

73

NaturalMatch

23

21

L'OralCouleurExperte

22

21

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5228

LOral

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS(Continued)

ColourRays

17

17

PreferenceLesBlondissimes

15

13

HiLightStyliste

13

13

FrostNDesign

ToneRefiner

70

72

648

646

Maybelline

208

235

LOralParis

175

188

Lancme

112

117

UrbanDecay

17

26

YSLBeaute

10

11

Dermablend

529

584

136

134

Matrix

46

47

Redkenr

29

30

L'OralParisEverPurer

18

19

L'OralParisVivePror

16

13

Pureology

14

13

L'OralParisEverSleek

10

10

L'OralParisEverStrongr

L'OralParisEverCreme

LOralKids

284

287

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
Garnier100%Color
Allother
Total
FACEMAKEUP

Totalr
SHAMPOOS
GarnierFructisr

Totalr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A228

2012

LOral

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

CONDITIONERS

116

115

Matrix

43

44

Redken

29

30

L'OralParisEverPurer

17

18

Pureology

13

13

L'OralParisVivePror

14

11

L'OralParisEverSleek

L'OralParisEverStrong

L'OralParisEverCreme

LOralKids

250

253

Maybelliner

85

91

LOralParis

88

83

Lancmer

31

32

UrbanDecay

20

22

231

236

GarnierFructis

84

82

Redken

57

59

Matrix

49

51

StudioLine

39

35

229

227

GarnierFructisr

Totalr
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

YSLBeaute
Totalr

2012

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

AcquadiGi

50

53

ArmaniCode

24

24

PoloBlue

21

21

Polo

14

15

LHommeYvesSaintLaurent

13

14

PoloBlack

13

13

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5229

5230

LOral

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORMEN(Continued)

DrakkarNoir

LaNuitdeL'Homme

L'HommeLibre

BigPony1

BigPony3

PoloDoubleBlack

ArmaniCodeSport

BigPony2

BigPony4

Spicebomb

PoloSport

OnlytheBrave

DieselFuelforLifeforHim

PoloExplorer

Chaps

14

14

214

216

Allother
Total
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

Viktor&RolfFlowerbomb

22

27

Romance

20

20

Trsor

17

15

AcquadiGiia

15

14

LaVieEstBelle

14

Opium

12

11

TheBodyShop

10

10

ArmaniCodeforWomen

Miracle

Hypnse

Ralph

BigPony2

TrsorInLove

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A230

2012

LOral

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN(Continued)

2012

Oscar

Boucheron

TrsorMidnightRose

PalomaPicasso

AmorAmor

AnasAnas

EmporioArmaniforHer

IdoledArmani

Poeme

Notorious

Stella

Paris

18

19

167

181

31

68

LOralParis

21

Maybelline

10

Lancme

YSLBeaute

40

104

Dark&Lovelyhaircoloringproducts

22

23

Dark&Lovelyrelaxerkits

18

16

OptimumCarerelaxerkits

16

15

Dark&Lovelystylingaids

Dark&Lovelyshampoos

Dark&Naturalhaircoloringproducts

LetsJamstylingaids

Allother
Total
NAILPOLISHES
Essier

Totalr
ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS

CareFreeCurl/CareFreeCurlGoldCurl/wave
maintenanceproducts

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5231

5232

LOral

Table5127:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS(Continued)

2012

OptimumCarehairdressesandlotions

Optimumshampoosandconditioners

OptimumCarestylingaids

SportinWaveCurl/wavekits

Dark&NaturalCurl/wavemaintenanceproducts

OptimumOilTherapyhairdressesandlotions

SoftsheenBreakthrushampoosandconditioners

SoftsheenBreakthruhairdressesandlotions

BeautifulBeginningsrelaxerkits

97

95

LOralParis

24

28

Lancme

12

12

LaRochePosay

11

13

Total

47

53

Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

TheBodyShop

33

34

LOralParis

Lancme

38

38

14

14

Kiehls

LOralMensExpert

Lancmeformen

14

14

Total
PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
TheBodyShopbathadditives
SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

Total
DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES
Magic
LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
Lancme

TOTALr
4,304

rRestated.

NOTE:"Allother"includessalesofsmallerbrandsthatthecompanyowns.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A232

4,551

LOral

COMPANYOVERVIEW

HeadquarteredinParis,France,LOralisoneoftheworldslargestmarketersofcosmetics
andtoiletries.
Thecompanywasfoundedin1909byFrenchchemistEugneSchueller.
LOral operates five development centers, 38 factories, and 18 research centers
worldwide;thecompanyemploysabout72,600peoplein2012.
GlobalfoodandbeverageindustrymajorNestlholdsa29.7%directstakeinLOral.
ThecompanyoperatesintheUnitedStatesthroughitsLOralUSAsubsidiary,basedin
NewYork,NY.

LOralhasaportfolioof27globalbrandsthathaveannualrevenuesof50millionormore.
Productsaresoldinmorethan130countries.
The companys core business is cosmetics and toiletries, encompassing all product
classes.
As of 2012, the company allocates 791 million ($1,017 million) in its research and
innovationbudget,upfrom721million($927million)apportionedin2011.
In2012,LOralregisters611patentsincosmeticsanddermatologicalresearch,slightly
downfrom613patentsin2011.

LOralisorganizedintothreemainbranches.
TheCosmeticsbranch,whichencompassesthehaircare,makeup,fragrances,andskin
carecategories,generatesthemajorityofsales.
TheBodyShop,acquiredbyLOralin2006,operatesasanindependententitywithin
thecompanyandsellsonlyTheBodyShopbrandedproducts.
The Dermatology branch consists of Galderma Laboratories, a joint venture between
LOral and Nestl. Galderma manufactures and markets specialty skin care products
designedtomeettheneedsofdermatologistsandtheirpatients.

LOralsCosmeticsbranchconsistsoffourdivisions.
Consumer Products is the largest division that markets mass skin care and cosmetics
productsunderbrandnamesLOralParis,Garnier,MaybellineNewYork,Softsheen
Carson,andEssie.
LOral Luxury markets premiumpriced products that are sold through department
stores, other luxury retail outlets, and online retailers. This division handles brands
such as Kiehls, Ralph Lauren, Lancme, Yves Saint Laurent, Giorgio Armani, Helena
Rubinstein,andClarisonic.
The companys Professional Products division markets hair care products for take
homeandbackbarsalethroughprofessionalsalons.Brandsmarketedbythisdivision
includeLOralProfessional,Krastase,Redken,andMatrix.
The Active Cosmetics division markets its brands chiefly through drug stores,
pharmacies,dermatologists,andmedispas.Thedivisioncomprisesdermocosmeticskin
carebrands,suchasVichy,LaRochePosay,Innov,Roger&Gallet,andSkinCeuticals.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5233

5234

LOral

LOralestablishesGlobalHairCareResearchCenterin2012.Thisresearchcentreheadssix
regionalresearchandinnovationcenterslocatedinBrazil,China,France,India,Japan,and
theUnitedStates.
Thecompanyinvests100million($129million)tosetupthisresearchCentrebasedat
SaintOuen,Paris.
Global Hair Care Research Centre originates, formulates, and assesses hair coloring,
haircare,andstylingproducts.
The Centre employs 500 personnel that include materials scientists, opticians,
computer scientists, statisticians, metrologists, physicochemists, chemists, and
rheologists.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

LOral continues to grow, as corporate sales increase by 10.4% to reach 22,463 million
($28,869million)infiscalyear2012.
Net profits grow from 2,438 million ($3,133 million) in 2011 to 2,868million
($3,686million)in2012.
Total company sales have grown at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of 5.7%
since2007.

Table5128:LOralsGlobalCorporateSalesandProfits,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofit

Marginonsales,%

2007

17,063

2,658

15.6

2008

17,542

1,951

11.1

2009

17,473

1,795

10.3

2010

19,496

2,242

11.5

2011

20,343

2,438

12.0

2012
22,463

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

2,868

12.8

Table5129:LOralsGlobalSalesbyBranch,2012
Branch

Million

Cosmetics

%Oftotal

20,812

92.7

TheBodyShop

855

3.8

Dermatology

796

3.5

22,463

100.0

Total

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A234

LOral

Table5130:LOralsGlobalSalesbyDivision,
2012
Division

%Oftotal

ConsumerProducts

51.5

LuxuryProducts

26.8

ProfessionalProducts

14.4

ActiveCosmetics

7.3

Total

100.0

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

LOral continues to be the secondlargest marketer, behind Procter & Gamble, in the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryintheUnitedStatesin2012.
LOralfindspresencein18ofthe26productcategoriescoveredinthisstudy.
LOralexperiencesahealthygrowthof5.7%in2012.
Salesgrowfrom$4,304millionin2011to$4,551millionin2012.Saleshavegrownata
CAGRof2.8%since2007.

Table5131:LOralsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletries
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

3,961

2008

3,924

(0.9)

2009

3,897

(0.7)

2010

4,056

4.1

2011

4,304

6.1

2012

4,551

5.7

Eyemakeup,theleadingcategoryforLOral,accountsfor19.6%ofthecompanyssalesin
2012.
LOralistheleadingeyemakeupmarketerin2012withsalesof$890million,up5.8%
from$841millionin2011.
LOral increases its share slightly as the company outperforms the overall market
growthforthecategory.
LOral is the leading advertiser in the eye makeup category with traceable media
expenditure(TME)of$204.2millionin2012,sameasin2011.
Maybelline is the largest advertised brand from LOral in 2012, with TME of $133.4
million,up8.5%from$122.9millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5235

5236

LOral

LOralParisissupportedwith$59.2millioninadvertisingdollarsin2012.TMEdeclines
8.1%in2012comparedtothelevelofsupportthebrandreceivedin2011.
AllofLOralsbrandscontributetothecompanysgrowthastheyoutpacetheoverall
marketgrowthof3.4%.MaybellineandLOralPariscontributethemostdollars,while
Urban Decay and YSL Beaute experience doubledigit gains of 29.0% and 11.1%,
respectively.
Maybellineistheleadingbrandintheeyemakeupcategoryandoutpacesthemarket,
growing5.7%toreach$446millionin2012,upfrom$422in2011.
Lancmessaleswith4.9%growthreach$128millionin2012,upfrom$122millionin
2011.
GrowthofMaybellineisfromthelaunchofitsnewmascaras,eyebrowcollection,and
eyeshadows.Eyelinersalesforthebrandareflatin2012.
MaybellineexpandsitsshareintheeyebrowsegmentwithitsEyeStudioMasterShape
Brow Pencil and DefineABrow product. Maybelline also has success with its Volum
ExpresstheMegaPlushandIllegalLengthfiberextensionmascaras.Salesgaincomes
fromitsColorTattoo24hrCreamGelShadow.
Lancmes growth comes from many products within the eye shadow, mascara, and
eyebrows segments. The brand is known for its mascaras, and in 2012 Hypnose Star
andHypnoseDollLashescontributetoLancmessuccessinthesegment.
UrbanDecayssalessoarduetothepopularityofitsNakedeyeshadowpalettes.

Facial treatments is the secondlargest category for LOral. The category accounts for
15.6%ofthemarketerstotalsalesin2012.
LOralsLancmeremainsthethirdlargestbrandintheluxurysegment,withsalesof
$243millionin2012,up5.7%from$230millionin2011.
Sales continue to grow due to the success of Visionnaire Advanced Skin Corrector,
whichmadeitsdebutin2011,andGnifiquewhichwaslaunchedin2010.
The Gnifique line is extended with the launch of Gnifique Yeux LightPearl
Illuminating Youth Activating Concentrate, made specifically for the eyes with a
rotatingandmassagingapplicator.
TheRnergielineexpandswithaMultiLiftActionproductthatlifts,firms,smoothens,
andprotects.
The Absolue line is extended with LExtrait a regenerating product containing rose
nativecellstohelprevealfirmer,moreelastic,andradiantskin.
Total advertising expenditures for Lancme are approximately $33.7 million in 2012,
downfrom$39.8millionin2011.
LOralParisfromLOralremainsthethirdlargestmassbrandinthecategory.
Manufacturers sales of LOral Paris increase 3.2% to $227million in 2012, up from
$220millionintheprioryear.
TwonewproductslaunchundertheYouthCodeline.YouthCodeBBCreamilluminator
is one of the first mass BB creams. Youth Code is also extended with a foaming gel
cleanser.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A236

LOral

RevitaLiftlineisextendedwiththelaunchofTriplePower,alineofconcentratedfacial
treatmentproducts,targetedtorepairandfightwrinkles.Thecompanyclaimsthatthe
TriplePowerrangecontainsthehighestlevelsofthecompanysproprietaryProXylane,
which is a molecule extracted from the beechwood tree, said to enhance collagen
production.TheTriplePowerrangehasthehighestpricepointsofanyproductsinthe
LOral Paris portfolio, and is the first mass brand to directly compete with Olays
premiumpricedProX.
Advertising expenditures for facial treatment products from LOral Paris are
approximately $25.0 million during 2012, down considerably from $129.1million
during2011.

Haircoloringproducts,themarketersthirdlargestcategoryinthecosmeticsandtoiletries
industry,represents14.2%ofthecompanyssalesin2012.
In 2012, LOral continues to be the leading marketer in the hair coloring products
category.
LOralaccountsforanestimated49.1%ofthecategoryssalesin2012.
Salesdeclinemarginallyby0.3%from$648millionin2011to$646millionin2012.
LOraldecreasesitsmarketingactivity,whichcontributestoitssalesdeclinein2012.
ThemarketerallocatesTMEofapproximately$164.8millionin2012,down11.4%from
$186.1millionin2011.
LOralsproductofferingsmainlycomprisepermanenthaircolors.
LOral Preference, L'Oral Excellence, and Garnier Nutrisse are the three leading
brandsofthecompany.
LOralsleadingbrand,L'OralExcellenceCrme,postsagrowthof4.1%in2012,and
GarnierNutrisseexperiencesgrowthof5.4%, whereasL'OralPreferencedeclinesby
1.3%.
ThemarketersupportsthesalesgrowthofL'OralExcellenceCrmewithanincreasein
TMEin2012.ThemarketerallocatesaTMEofapproximately$32.7millionin2012,up
from$21.2millionin2011topromotetheL'OralExcellenceCrme.
Garnier Nutrisse enjoys a growth of 5.4% in 2012, with sales reaching $97million in
2012,upfrom$92millionin2011.
Sales of Garnier Nutrisse are supported by the launch of Garnier Nutrisse Nourishing
HairColorFoamin2012.
In spite of new product activity and significant TME support of $18million in 2012,
salesofFriadeclineto$73millionin2012,down6.4%from$78millionin2011.
NaturalColorMatchexperiencesadeclineof8.7%to$21millionin2012,downfrom
$23millionin2011.
In 2012, sales of Couleur Experte decline by 4.5%, from $22 million in 2011 to
$21millionin2012.
SalesofColourRaysremainstagnantat$17millionin2012,sameas2011levels.
Preference Les Blondissimes, a line targeting blonde consumers, declines further to
$13millionin2012,down13.3%from$15millionin2011.
Smallerlighteninghaircolorlines,Frost&DesignandToneRefiner,remaindormantin
2012at$8millioneach.
A few distinct hair color lines, such as Superior Preference and Wild Ombre, are
launchedin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5237

5238

LOral

SalesofLOralinthefacemakeupcategorygrow10.4%to$584millionin2012,upfrom
$529millionin2011.
LOral takes the top spot away from Este Lauder in 2012 with 20.1% of total
categoryssalesin2012.
SalesforthecompanyincludesalesfromUrbanDecay,abrandthecompanyacquires
fromprivateequityfirmCastaneaPartnersinNovember2012.
LOralsupportsitsfacemakeupbrandsbyincreasingitsadvertisingexpensesby9.4%
to$195.2million,upfrom$178.3millionin2011.
LOralcompetesinthefacemakeupcategorywithLOralParis,Maybelline,Lancme,
UrbanDecay,YSLBeaute,andDermablendbrands.WiththeexceptionofDermablend,
allbrandscontributetothegrowthofthecompany.
Thecompanysmassbrands,MaybellineandLOralParisanditsnewlyacquiredbrand,
UrbanDecay,drivethemajorityofgrowthin2012withdollargainsof13.0%,7.4%,and
52.9%,respectively.
Maybellinecontinuestobetheleadingbrandforthecompanyin2012,with salesof
$235million,upfrom$208millionin2011.
Maybellinesgrowthisdrivenbyallsegmentsinthefacemakeupcategory.Concealer
salesarefollowedbymakeupbases,andblushsales.NewlaunchesincludeInstantAge
Rewind Eraser Dark Spot Concealer+Treatment, Dream Nude Airfoam makeup, and
DreamBouncyblushfuelgrowth.
LOralsupportsMaybellinesDreamlineofproductswithapproximately$65millionin
TMEin2012.
LOral supports Maybellines Instant Age Rewind line of face products with
approximately$84millioninTMEin2012.
LOral reduces its advertising for its Maybelline Fit Me line from $63 million in TME
duringitslaunchin2011to$7.5millionin2012.
SalesofLOralParisareestimatedat$188millionin2012,up7.4%from$175million
in2011.
LOralParisgrowthisachievedbynewlaunchactivitiesespeciallyinthemakeupbase
categoryasarangeofnewproductshitshelvesin2012.Theseproductsarewithinthe
TrueMatchandVisibleLiftproductlines.
TMEforLOralParisincreasesin2012to$91million,sameasin2010,afteradecline
in2011to$75million.Approximately,88%ofthedollarsaresplitbetweenpromoting
the True Match and Visible lift makeup lines and close to 10% is spent on the Magic
Lumilineoffaceproducts.
TheluxurybrandLancmeachievessalesof$117million,up7.4%from$112millionin
2011.Salesincreaseduetothesuccessofexistingproducts,andtoalesserextentdue
to new launches. Lancme is supported with approximately $11.5 million in TME in
2012, up 10% from 2011. These dollars are in support of Teint Idole Ultra 24H
foundation,TeintMiraclefoundation,andonBlushSubtil.
TheluxurybrandsYSLBeauteandGiorgioArmaniMaestroaresupportedbyclosetoa
halfamilliondollarseach,tosupporttheTouceEclatandliquidfoundationproducts,
respectively.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A238

LOral

Sales of hair styling products for LOral decline 0.9% from $229 million in 2011 to
$227millionin2012.
Despitethedecline,themarketermaintainsitspositionasthesecondleadingmarketer
inthehairstylingproductsandsprayscategorywithashareof13.5%ofthecategory
sales,downfrom13.8%ofthecategorysalesin2011.
Decreaseinthemarketingandpromotionalactivitiescontributetothesalesdeclinein
2012.LOraldecreasesitsTMEspendbyapproximately35.7%,from$60.5millionin
2011to$38.9millionin2012.
GarnierFructisistheleadingbrandofthecompany,withsalesat$82millionin2012,
down2.4%from$84millionin2011.
Despiteawiderangeofproductofferingsandwellestablishedpositioning,thebrand
declinesin2012.
Thebrandssalesdeclinein2012isduetoadecreaseinmarketingactivities.
LOral is the leading marketer in the professional trade class in the category, with
RedkentheleadingbrandandMatrixinthirdposition.
The marketer occupies 21.8% of the professional trade class sales, up from 21.2% in
2011.

Theshampooscategoryrepresents6.3%ofLOralssalesin2012.
LOral is the thirdlargest marketer in the category with an 11.0% share; the
companyssalesgrow1.1%from$284millionin2011to$287millionin2012.
Thecompanyoffers10brandsinthecategory.
Garnier Fructis is the leading brand from LOral, and sales decline 1.4%, from
$136millionin2011to$134millionin2012.Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthe
brandsgrowthinthecategory.
ThesalesofEverPuregrow3.3%,from$18millionin2011to$19millionin2012.The
successofsulfatefreeshampoossupportsthebrandssalesinthecategory.
ViveProfromLOralcontinuestodeclinein2012;salesforthebranddecline18.8%,
from $16million in 2011 to $13million in 2012. Limited distribution and lack of new
productactivityaffectsthebrandsperformance.
LOral markets two professional hair care brands: Matrix and Redken. Matrix
witnessesa2.2%growthin2012,withthebrandssalesincreasingfrom$46millionin
2011 to $47million in 2012. The brands growth is supported by new product
introductionsin2012.LOrallaunchesanewBlondeCareshampooundertheMatrix
brand in 2012. Redken grows 3.4% from $29million in 2011 to $30million in 2012.
RedkenlaunchesAllSoftandBlondeGlamshampoosin2012.

Salesintheconditionerscategoryaccountfor5.6%ofLOralsalesin2012.
LOral is placed third in the category with a share of 15.3%. Sales for the marketer
grow1.2%from$250millionin2011to$253millionin2012.
ThelargestbrandfromLOralisGarnierFructis,whichhasashareof7.0%ofthetotal
categoryssales.
Garnier Fructis is the secondlargest brand in the category. Sales for Garnier Fructis
declineby0.9%from$116millionin2011to$115millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5239

5240

LOral

Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
TheonlysignificantlaunchundertheGarnierFructisbrandisPureCleanconditioner.
EverPure,thelineofsulfatefreeconditionersintroducedin2011,continuestoperform
wellforLOralin2012.
Thebrandgrowsby5.9%from$17millionin2011to$18millionin2012.
ThesuccessofEverPureandEverSleekandthegrowingconsumerconcernaboutharsh
chemicalsusedinhaircareproductspromptsLOraltolaunchafourthlineofsulfate
freeproducts.Thenewline,EverCreme,hassalesof$5millionduringitsfirstyearof
launchin2012.
Vive Pro, the variant under the LOral Paris umbrella, continues to witness sales
decline in 2012. Sales for the brand shrink from $14million in 2011 to $11million in
2012.
Salessufferduetolimitedpromotionalspendingandlackofnewproductactivityfrom
thebrandin2012.
LOralistheleadingmarketerintheprofessionaltradeclass,withashareof24.7%in
2012.
The company markets the top professional conditioner brand Matrix. Sales for the
brandgrow2.3%from$43millionin2011to$44millionin2012.
SalesforRedkengrowby$1millionto$30millionin2012.Newconditionersunderthe
DiamondOilandAllSoftlineareaddedtoRedkensofferingsin2012.
The sales of the brand Pureology, offering color protection products, remain flat at
$13millionin2012.

LOralmaintainsthetopspotastheleadingmarketeroffragrancesformenwitha19.6%
categorysharein2012.
Salesgrow0.9%or$2millionto$216millionbasedonthestrengthoffragrances,such
asAcquadiGi,ArmaniCode,andthePolofranchise.
Sixofthetop10scentsbelongtoLOral.
The companys Acqua di Gi continues to be the leader among male fragrances with
$53millioninsales,$8millionaheadofsecondplacedChanelsBleu.
Salesreach$53millionin2012,agrowthof6.0%from$50millionintheprioryear.
Thebrandsshareoftheluxurytradeclassremainsflatat6.9%,whileshareofthetotal
mensfragrancemarketgrowsfrom4.7%to4.8%during2012.
ArmaniCoderanksfourth,andPoloBlueremainsinsixthposition.
LOralcontinuestorelyonitsassociationwithclassicdesignersforitsscentsincluding
Giorgio Armani, Ralph Lauren, Yves Saint Laurent, and Viktor & Rolf, and growth is
experiencedduring2012becausemostoftheclassicsperformwell.
Theluxurytradeclassistheonlytradeclassinwhichthecompanycompetes.However,
whensomeofitsproductsdoendupinmassretailers,itistypicallyduetodiversion
ratherthananintentionaleffortbythecompany.
The major launch of the year is Viktor & Rolfs Spicebomb, with sales of $4 million
during2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A240

LOral

LOral is the leading marketer in the lipsticks and lip glosses category in 2012. Category
salesforthecompanytotal$236millionin2012,up2.2%from$231millionin2011.
LOralrepresents17.1%ofthecategoryssalesin2012,unchangedfrom2011.
LOralistheleadingadvertiser,withTMEat$130.8millionin2012.
LOral competes in the category with its mass brands, LOral Paris and Maybelline,
anditsluxurybrands,Lancme,YSLBeaute,andUrbanDecay.Allbrandscontributeto
thecompanysgrowthin2012,exceptLOralParis.Maybellineaddsthemostdollars,
whileitsnamesakebranddeclines5.7%in2012.SalesofLOralParisColourRicheand
Colour Caresse line of products perform well and are supported with TME of $25
million.However,LOralParisdoesnotfarewellwithitsInfalliblelipsticklinedespite
spending$19millioninTMEin2012.
Salesofthecompanysmassbrandsareuponly0.6%in2012,achieving$174millionin
sales.
Maybellineperformsverywellin2012,withsalesincreasing7.1%toreach$91million
in2012,upfrom$85millionin2011.Thebrandisontrendwithnewlaunchesin2012.
The brand capitalizes on what interests women, the gloss that stays on, and high
pigment lipsticks that stays on and feels creamy. Maybelline launches two new
products: Super Stay 10hour Stain Gloss and Colorsensational Vivids lipsticks. The
launchoftheseproductsissupportedwithcloseto$78millioninTME.
Sales of LOrals luxury brands grow 6.9% in 2012 to reach $62 million from $58
million.BothLancmeandYSLBeautehavesuccessfullaunchesinRougeinLoveand
RougePurCoutureVenisaLevers,respectively.Bothproductsaresupportedwithclose
to$9millioninTME.

LOraldropstofifthplacewith6.7%shareinthewomensfragrancescategoryin2012.
LOralcontributes4.0%ofitstotalsalesofthecompanyin2012.
ThebiglaunchoftheyearisLaVieEstBellewhichattainssalesof$14millionwithin
justafewmonthsofitslaunch.
Viktor&RolfsFlowerbombcontinuestogrowwithincreasingdistribution,asthisscent
joinsthetop10withjustafewyearsoncounter.
TheonlyothermajorlaunchduringtheyearisthefemaleversionsoftheRalphLauren
Polocollection,however,thesedidnotperformaswellastheirmalecounterparts.

AlthoughtheshareofLOralintheoverallethnichaircareproductscategorydeclinesfrom
29.1%in2011to27.9%in2012,thecompanymaintainsitsreigningpositioninthecategory.
Salesofthecompanydecline2.1%,from$97millionin2011to$95millionin2012.
Lackofsignificantmarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributestothesalesdecline
forthemarketerin2012.
In 2012, LOral introduces Dark and Lovely Au Naturale antibreakage maintenance
andstylingline,alongwithafewotherproductintroductionstooffsetitssalesdecline.
LOralsupportsitsbrandswithaninsignificantTMEofamere$0.2millionin2012.
Dark & Lovely is the leading brand in the market accounting for 14.1% of the overall
categoryssalesin2012,downfrom14.7%in2011.
Salesforthebranddeclinefrom$49millionin2011to$48millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5241

5242

LOral

Dark&Lovelyistheleadingbrandinhaircoloringproducts,relaxerkits,whileinstyling
itisthesecondleadingbrand.
Lackofmarketingandpromotionalactivitycontributestothebrandssalesdeclinein
2012.
OptimumCareisthesecondleadingbrandforLOralwithanoverallcategoryshareof
6.6%in2012,downfrom6.2%in2011.
Salesofthebranddecline4.5%from$22millionin2011to$21millionin2012.

In the sun care products category,sales of LOral grow 12.8% to $53 million in 2012, up
from$47millionin2011.
TheintroductionofLOralsSublimeSunisthekeyreasonbehindthestronggrowthof
thecompany.
TheSublimeSunproductcomprisessixSKUs:AdvancedSunscreenSPF50+LiquidSilk
Sunshield for Face, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 50+ Lotion, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 30
Lotion, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 50+ Crystal Clear Mist, Advanced Sunscreen SPF 30
CrystalClearMist,andAdvancedSunscreenSPF30HydraLotionSpray.
ThelineissupportedwithaTMEof$14.5millionin2012.
Alsoin2012,LOralintroducesfournewSKUsforitsLaRochePosaybrand:Anthelios
30UltraLightSunscreenLotionSpray,Anthelios60UltraLightSunscreenLotionSpray,
Anthelios 50 Tinted Mineral Ultra Light Sunscreen Fluid, and Anthelios 50 AntiAging
PrimerwithSunscreen.
A new product, Capital Soleil SPF 30 Luxurious Protective Oil, is added to Vichys
Laboratoriesexistinglineofproductsin2012.

LOral retains its position as the thirdlargest nail polish marketer, with sales of $104
millionin2012,up160%from$40millionin2011.
LOralcompetesinnailpolisheswithitsLOralParis,Maybelline,Essie,Lancme,and
YSLBeautebrands.
SalesoftheEssiebrandincreasefrom$31millionin2011to$68millionin2012and
contributethemostdollarsforthecompany.
Essie continues to expand its shade selection to sustain its popularity among
consumersseekingthelatestfashionhues.
Since the acquisition of Essie by LOral in 2011, the brand continues to expand its
distribution.Thebrandissoldindrugstores,massmerchandisersincludingTargetand
Walmart,departmentstores,andspecialtystores,suchasUltaandSephora.
LOral Paris sales grow the most on a percentage basis from $2 million in 2011 to
$21millionin2012.ItssuccesscomesfromthelaunchoftheColourRichenailpolish
line.
Maybellinemorethandoublesitsnailpolishbusinessin2012reaching$10millionin
sales,upfrom$4millionin2011.MaybellinessuccesscomesfromthelaunchofColor
Shownailpolish.
Lancme doubles its nail polish business in 2012 with sales of $4 million, up from
$2millionin2011anddoesnotadvertise.Thebrandssuccesscomesfromthelaunch
ofLeVernisandVernisinLovenailpolishes.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A242

LOral

5243

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

M&Aactivity

InJuly2012,LOralcompletesthesaleofitshomecarebusinessfromtheCadumGroupto
EauEcarlateSASforanundisclosedsum.

InOctober2012,LOralUSAsignsanagreementtoacquireEmilianiEnterprisesextending
itscoverageofAmericanhairsalons.

InOctober2012,LOralacquirestheVoguemakeupbrandinColombia.

In November 2012, LOral acquires Urban Decay, specialty makeup brand in the United
Statesforapproximately$350million.

In December 2012, Galderma, a pharmaceutical company formed as a joint venture


between Nestl and LOral, acquires Spirig, a leading company in the production and
developmentofdermatologicalproducts.

Managementchanges

In March 2013, Lindsay Owen Jones resigns from the Board of Directors, and Virginie
MorgonisappointedasanewDirectorbytheBoard.

Otherdevelopments

InMarch2012,LOralinauguratesitsGlobalHairCareResearchCenterinParisSaintOuen,
France.
This100millionfacility,builton25,000squaremeters,employees500people.
This center will be the head of a global network of six research & innovation (R&I)
regionalcenters,andtheheadquartersforthecompanysinternationaldepartmentsof
haircolor,haircare,andhairstyling.

InNovember2012,LOralannouncesmajorexpansioninitsKentuckyManufacturingPlant.
Theproposedplantexpansionincludesrenovationstotheexistingplant,newconstruction,
andthepurchaseofnewequipment.

InJanuary2012,LOralannouncesthelaunchofawebsiteintheUnitedStates,designed
toinspireandempowergirlstopursuecareersinscienceandtechnology.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5244

LOral

In September 2012, FDA warns LOral over claims for antiaging products by issuing a
warninglettertothecompany.
Intheletter,FDAclaimsthat11ofthecompanysskincareproductscanbeclassified
asdrugsastheyservethepurposeofchangingthestructureorfunctionofthehuman
body. These products include: Genifique Youth Activating Concentrate, Genifique Eye
Youth Activating Eye Concentrate, Genifique Cream Serum Youth Activating Cream
Serum, Genifique Repair Youth Activating Night Cream, Absolue Precious Cells
Advanced Regenerating and Reconstructing Cream SPF 15 Sunscreen, Absolue Eye
Precious Cells Advanced Regenerating and Reconstructing Eye Cream, Absolue Night
Precious Cells Advanced Regenerating and Reconstructing Night Cream, and Renergie
MicroliftEyeR.A.R.EIntenseRepositioningEyeLifter

Newproducts

Table5132:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLOralintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

BodyShop

Facialtreatments

NutriganicsDropsofYouthisayouthenhancingconcentratewith
plantstemcelltechnologytoenhancesurfaceskinrenewalfor
smoother,healthierskin

Dark&Lovely

Ethnichaircare
products

AuNaturaleantibreakagemaintenanceandstylinglineisinfused
withmangooilandbamboomilk,nourishmentforallcurltypes

Dark&Natural

Ethnichaircare
products

5MinutePermanentHaircolorlocksincolorandleaveshairsoft

Dark&Lovely

Ethnichaircare
products

HealthyGloss5MoistureHairCrmeinfuseshairwithsupreme
shineandreplenisheshairandscalpwithmoisture

Dark&Lovely

Ethnichaircare
products

FadeResistantRichConditioningColor,containsmoistureseal
technology,enhancestheconditioningpower

Essie

Nailpolishes

Stylenomicsnailpolish

Essie

Nailpolishes

LuxEffectsfivemultidimensionaltopcoats

Essie

Nailpolishes

Mirrormetallicshades

EverCreme

Shampoos

TheIntenseNourishingshampoocontainsnaturalbotanicalsandis
freefromsulfatesandparabens

EverCreme

Conditioners

Nourishingconditionerinfusedwithomega3and6thathelps
restoremoisture;containsnaturalbotanicalsandisfreefrom
parabens

Haircoloring
products

FriaWildOmbreisanathomehaircoloringproductthatclaimsto
givemultishadeeffectswithonepackage.Itisavailableinshades,
suchasmediumtodarkbrown;darkblondetolightbrown;and
lighttomediumblonde.Thepatentedbrushapplicatorallowsquick
andpreciseapplication

Fria

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A244

LOral

Table5132:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLOralintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Garnier

Facialtreatments

GarnierSkinRenewalDarkSpotOvernightPeelisaglycolicpeelthat
canbeusedasanovernighttreatmenttofadedarkspots,evenskin
tones,brightenskin,andrefinetheskinstexture

Garnier

Facialtreatments

SkinRenewMiracleSkinPerfectorBBCreamevenstone,brightens
complexion,renewsradiance,delivers24hourhydration,provides
SPF15UVAandUVBprotection

GarnierFructis

Hairstylingproducts TheSpikeExplosionPowerGelcontainstaurineandcitruscomplex

GarnierFructis

Hairstylingproducts TheDisorderhairgelcontainsnaturalingredientsincludingcitrus

GarnierFructis

Hairstylingproducts

TheCleanSleekPowerGelandPuttyprovidesultraslick,wetshine
lookforanyhairstylewith24hourhold

GarnierFructis

Hairstylingproducts

TheSufferHairPowerPuttycontainsnaturalingredientsincluding
citrusandlemonextracts

GarnierFructis

Hairstylingproducts

TheMessMakerPowerGelandPowerPuttycontainsalight
formula

GarnierFructis

Shampoos

GarnierFructisPureCleanshampoobooststhehealthofthehair
andscalp,andcontainsabiodegradableformulafromFructis

GarnierFructis

Conditioners

TripleNutritionconditionerfortifiesandinfusesnutrientsforsilky
hair,fulloflife

GarnierFructis

Conditioners

PureCleanFortifyingconditionerbooststhehealthofhairand
scalp,andisthefirstbiodegradableformulafromFructis

GarnierNutrisse

Haircoloring
products

Theproductisammoniafreeandcontainsbambooextractwhich
reinforcesthehair'sprotectivecuticlelayerwhilecoloring

GarnierOlia

Haircoloring
products

Theproductisavailablein23shadesanduses60%oilblendwith
naturalfloweroilsinthecolorant.Thisoilbasedformulaincites
colorantstopenetratedeepintohairforlongerlastingcolor

Kiehls

Facialtreatments

ClearlyCorrectiveDarkSportSolutioncontainsvitaminC,white
birch,andpeonytodiminishnumberandintensityofdarkspots

LaRochePosay

Facialtreatments

Redermicantiagingformulaclaimstocombatwrinkles,inspiredby
dermatologistsapproachtoplump,fill,andhydrate

Lancme

Eyemakeup

HypnoseStarMascaradualactionbrushhasaflatsidefor
optimizingproductdepositatthelashlinewhiletheroundedside
separates,defines,andlengthens

Facialtreatments

AbsoluLExtraitisaregeneratingelixirthatclaimstorevealfirmer,
moreelastic,radiantskin.Eachjarhasupto2millionrosenative
cells

Lancme

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5245

5246

LOral

Table5132:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLOralintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Lancme

Facialtreatments

GenifiqueYeuxLightPearlEyeIlluminatingYouthActivating
Concentratecontainsauniquerotatingandmassagingapplicatorto
reacheventhemostinaccessibleeyeareaswith360degreeeye
contourapplication

Lancme

Facialtreatments

RnergieMultiLiftActionclaimstoshieldskinwithbroadspectrum
SPF15andrestoresskinsyouthfulenergy.Addressingkeyaging
concerns,itlifts,firmsandsmoothensinfourweeks

Lancme

Facemakeup

TeintIdoleUltra24HRfoundation

Lancme

Facemakeup

TranslucenceMattifyingSilkyPressedPowder

Lancme

Lipsticks

RougeinLove

Lancme

Fragrancesfor
women

LaVieEstBellereportedlytookthreeyearstoformulatewithIrisas
thekeyingredientsurroundedbyorangeblossomsandjasmine.The
flaconisaredesignedversionofaclassicLancmebottlefrom1949

LOral

Eyemakeup

Infallible24HREyeShadow

LOral

Eyemakeup

ColourRicheeyeshadow

LOral

Eyemakeup

VoluminousPowerVolume24HRMascara

LOral

Eyemakeup

VoluminousFalseFiberLashesmascara

LOral

Eyemakeup

TelescopicShockingExtensionsmascara

LOral

Eyemakeup

MagicDeCreaseEyelidPrimer

LOral

Eyemakeup

TelescopicShockingExtensionsmascara

LOralParis

Facialtreatments

YouthCodeBBCreamIlluminatorclaimstoeven,illuminate,
perfect,correctandmoisturizeinonestep.YouthCodeFoamingGel
cleanserisanewcleanseraddedtotheYouthCodeline

LOralParis

Facialtreatments

RevitaLiftTriplePowerisafacialtreatmentcollectionwhich
containsthehighestlevelsofLOralsproprietaryProXylane,
whichisanaturallyderived,biodegradablemolecule,extracted
fromthebeechwoodplant.Thisingredientissaidtoenhance
collagenproduction.Designedtoaddressthreedimensionsofaging
wrinkles,lossoffacialvolume,andfirmnessthelinecomprises
aDay/NightCream,Serum,andEyeTreatment

LOralParis

Facemakeup

VisibleLiftSerumAbsoluteConcealer

LOralParis

Facemakeup

VisibleLiftRepairAbsoluteAgeReversingFoundationSPF16

LOralParis

Facemakeup

TrueMatchLumiHealthyLuminousMakeup

LOralParis

Facemakeup

TrueMatchSuperBlendableMakeup

LOralParis

Facemakeup

TrueMatchCrayonConcealer

LOralParis

Shampoos

TotalRepair5Restoringshampoohelpsrepairfivevisiblesignsof
damagedhairsplitends,weakness,roughness,dullness,and
dehydration

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A246

LOral

Table5132:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLOralintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

LOralParis

Shampoos

TripleResistReinforcingshampooinstantlyhelpsnourishhairfrom
roottocoretotip,therebystrengtheninghair

LOralParis

Shampoos

SmoothIntensePolishingshampoosoftenshairandcombats
symptomsofroughtextures,leavinghairsmooth

LOralParis

Conditioners

AdvancedHairCareTotalRepair5Restoringconditionerhelps
repairfivevisiblesignsofdamagedhair:splitends,weakness,
roughness,dullness,anddehydration

LOralParis

Conditioners

TripleResistReinforcingconditionerinstantlyhelpsnourishhair
fromroottocoretotip,therebystrengtheninghair

LOralParis

Conditioners

SmoothIntensepolishingconditionersoftenshairinstantlyand
combatssymptomsofroughtextures,leavinghairsmooth

LOralParis

Lipsticks

ColorRichBalm

LOralParis

Lipsticks

ColourCaressebyColourRichelipstick

LOralParis

Lipsticks

ColourCaresseWetShineStainbyColourRichelipgloss

LOralParis

Lipsticks

InfallibleLeGloss8hour

LOralParis

Nailpolishes

ColourRichenailpolish

LOralParis
EverStyle

HairStyling
Products

CurlActivatingMoussecontainsaweightlessformula,natural
ingredients,andisfreefromalcoholandparabens

LOralParis
EverStyle

HairStyling
Products

CurlDefiningGelcontainsnaturalingredientsandisfreefrom
alcoholandparabens

LOralParis
EverStyle

HairStyling
Products

VolumeRootLiftingsprayis100%freefromdryingalcoholsand
containsnaturalingredients

Matrix

Shampoos

BlondeCareshampoocontainsablendofchamomileandpanthenol

Matrix

Conditioners

BlondeCareconditionercontainsanexoticblendofchamomileand
panthenolthatcleansesanddetangleshairforanenhancedbrilliant
shine,withoutaddingweighttothehair

Maybelline

Eyemakeup

VolumExpresstheMegaPlushMascara

Maybelline

Eyemakeup

DefineABroweyebrowpencil

Maybelline

Eyemakeup

EyeStudioMasterShapeBrowPencil

Maybelline

Facialtreatments

DreamFreshBBCreamprovideseightskinbenefitsforinstantskin
perfection

Maybelline

Facemakeup

DreamBouncyBlush

Maybelline

Facemakeup

NudeAirfoamMakeup

Maybelline

Lipsticks

ColorsensationalVividslipstick

Maybelline

Lipsticks

SuperStay10HRStainGloss

Maybelline

Nailpolishes

ColorShownailpolish

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5247

5248

LOral

Table5132:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLOralintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Preference

Haircoloring
products

RalphLauren

Fragrancesfor
women

UrbanDecay
UrbanDecay

Eyemakeup
Facemakeup

Viktor&Rolf

Fragrancesformen

YSLBeaute
YSLBeaute
YSLBeaute

Facemakeup
Facemakeup
Lipsticks

Description
Thepermanenthaircolorisoptimizedwithfadedefying
conditionersthatkeephairsilkyandhealthyfromroottotip.The
productconcealsgrayhairandisavailablein37shadesranging
fromdarkblondetodarkbrown
BigPonyforHeristhe4 fragrancefemalecounterpartofthemens
collectionwitheachscentnumberedfrom1to4andhousedin
clearbottleswhichshowoffthebrightlycoloredjuice
SmokedEyeshadowPalette
NakedSkinWeightlessUltraDefinitionLiquidMakeup
Spicebomblookslikeahandgrenadeandcontainsnotesofchili,
saffron,leather,tobacco,andvetiver,alongwithbergamot,
grapefruit,elemi,andpepper
LeTeintToucheclatfoundation
ToucheclatRadiantTouchconcealer
RougePurCoutureVenisaLevers

MARKETINGACTIVITY

With TME support of $1,448 million, LOral is the secondleading advertiser in the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryin2012.
At$778.2million,magazineisthemostpreferredmarketingmediumadoptedbythe
company.Closebehindaretelevisionadvertisementswithtraceablemediasupportof
$646.4millionin2012.
LOral is the leading advertiser in the face makeup category with TME of $195.2
millionin2012,up9.4%from$178.3millionin2011.
LOralhasthehighestTMEintheeyemakeupcategory,with$204.2millionin2012,
flatfrom2011.
LOralParisreceivesthehighestTMEsupportofapproximately$350millionamongall
LOralsbrands.

LOral continues to market its products through various channels including discount
couponsandcelebritycampaigns.
Growth of the marketer is primarily supported by the aggressive marketing and
promotionalactivitiesundertakenbythemarketer.
LOralusessupermodelsanddesignersforthepromotionofitsmakeupandfragrance
products.
ThemarketersspokesmodelsincludecelebritiessuchasJenniferLopez,EvaLongoria,
GerardButler,AndieMacDowell,andLaetitiaCasta.
Themarketeradoptsvarioustools,suchastheInternetanddiscounts,topromoteits
productsacrosscategories.
Themarketerutilizesthesocialmediasites,suchasTwitter,Pinterest,andFacebook,
topromoteitsproducts.
LOralprimarilypromotesitsnewproductlaunchesandotherproductoffersthrough
thischannel.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A248

LOral

LOraladoptsdiscountcouponsasanimportantmeansofpromotion.
Couponing has gathered significance among brands as a promotional tool in the past
fewyearsduetothesubstantialsavingsitofferstoitsusers.
The company offers discount coupons of denominations ranging from $1.00 to $5.00
offonitsproducts.
It also offers discount coupons, usually in freestanding inserts (FSIs) in weekly
newspapers.
Themarketeralsopushescouponstosmartphonesthroughitsretailpartnerships.
The mobile coupons are offered in order to influence consumers purchase decisions
whiletheyareshoppingatsupermarketsnationwide.
Consumers can obtain coupons either on the companys website or through the
brands newsletter. The companys coupons are also available on various thirdparty
websites.
The marketer primarily offers discount coupons for its newly launched products in
ordertoattractconsumers.

The marketer allocates aggressive media spend to its core brands Maybelline, Garnier,
andLOralParisin2012.
LOral allocates the maximum of its TME to support its LOral Paris brand in 2012;
withapproximately$529million.
The marketer promotes LOral Paris primarily through print and television
advertisements.
LOralParisisadvertisedinpopularfashionmagazinesincludingGlamour,InStyle,and
Elle.
LOraloffersdiscountcouponsonitsLOralParisbrandtopromoteitssales.
TheMaybellinebrandisallocatedwithaTMEofapproximately$341.6millionin2012.
TheGarnierbrandreceives$265.8millionasTMEin2012.
The company promotes its Maybelline brand primarily through popular fashion
magazines,suchasAllure,Vogue,andGlamour.
MaybellinesFacebookpageoffersbeautytipstoitssubscribersinordertokeepthem
updatedwiththelatesttrendsandlaunchesunderthebrand.
ConsumerscansubscribetoMaybellinesnewsletteronitswebsitewhereitprovides
discountcouponsandinformationonitslatestlaunches.
During 2012, Maybelline continues to be the official sponsor for the MercedesBenz
FashionWeek,whichtakesplaceinNewYork,fortheseventhconsecutiveyear.
Maybelline, as the official cosmetics sponsor for the MercedesBenz Fashion Week,
releases an advertising campaign in spring 2012 featuring Jessica White, Shu Pei Qin,
LisallaMontenegro,ChristyTurlington,andEmilyDiDonato.
In2012,MaybellineorganizesDaretoWhisperContesttopromoteitsColorWhisper
line of products in which the first prize winner get $5,000 in cash and the next 300
winnersgetasetofall20ColorWhisperShades.
Maybellineswebsiteoffersmakeuplessonsforamateursandusersdesiringanewlook
bycategorizingthevideosaccordingtomakeupartistandspecificlookforeyes,face,
lips,andnailsgiventheoccasionandthemood.
In2012,MaybellineandGarnierorganizeHolidayGiftSweepstakesinwhichthefirst20
winnersgetachancetoreceiveprizesworth$150.00.
In 2012, Maybelline celebrates one million fans for its Facebook page, Sensational
Maybelline.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5249

5250

LOral

The marketer promotes its leading luxury brand, Lancme, on a large scale in 2012 by
allocating$112.3millionofthecompanystotalTMEin2012.
The company allocates $25.2 million to support its new launch Genifique Yeux Light
Pearl,afacialtreatmentproductin2012.
Lancme offers various incentives to encourage purchase, with giftwithpurchase
(GWP)andpurchasewithpurchase(PWP)asthemainpromotionaltool.
Anypurchaseof$60.00ormoremadedirectlyfromtheLancmewebsiteiseligiblefor
afreegiftcomposedofamakeupcasealongwithseveralsamplesizeproducts.
Freeshippingisavailableonordersof$49.00ormore.
Email signup is available on Lancmes website, to receive emails about new
productsandtrends.
Consumers can create an account directly through the Lancme website that will
entitletheconsumertopreviewandshopfornewproductsearlierthanotherpeople
can, receive deluxe sample offers which are of a larger size than the minisamples
typicallyprovided,andalsosavetoaWishlist.
The brand offers various instore events in conjunction their major retail partners to
providepersonalizedconsultationsandintroducenewproducts.
Lancme partners with Julia Roberts as the spokesperson for its La Vie Est Belle
fragrancein2012.
In2012,thebrandpremiersatelevisionadvertisementwhichfeatures1930scartoon
iconBettyBoop.
In addition, Lancme uses the platform www.makeup.com, a professional website
owned by LOral since 2009. The website features Lancmes presence in different
beautyblogs,whichareoperatedbybeautyexpertsandprofessionalbloggers.
Lancmeconsidersinstoremarketingtobeanextremelyimportantmarketingtoolfor
its brand, as sales associates can provide the necessary guidance for a consumer to
make the correct purchasing decision regarding products. Lancme, like other luxury
brands, is moving to an opensell environment in many department stores, where
customers are able to browse the products alone and are able to ask for sales
assistance, if necessary. These opensell installations invite browsing and enable the
consumerstoplaywiththemakeupthemselvesoraskforassistance,ifneeded.
Lancme offers a users club called My Lancme, which allows consumers to receive
exclusive updates and previews of new products, along with complimentary deluxe
sampleswitheveryorderandGWPoffers.
Lancmeholdsvariousinstoreeventstointeractwithconsumers,providingthemwith
amorepersonalizedconsultation.

Samplingisanimportantmeansofdrawingconsumerstopurchasenewluxuryfragrances
andfacialtreatments.
Scented strips in magazines and sample vials are common methods of sampling
employedbyLOral.
The company also offers smelling strips and blotters to consumers at the pointof
purchase,asameansofencouragingtrial.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A250

LOral

Celebrities associated with beauty and glamour, such as actors and models, are featured
extensively in the promotional campaigns of LOrals skin care, fragrance, hair care, and
makeupcategories.
Thebrandambassadorsfeaturedinthepromotionalcampaignsofantiagingproducts
arechosenbasedontheagegroupofthetargetconsumers.

LOral exploits the growing reach and influence of the Internet as an effective tool for
productpromotion.
Presence on social networking websites such as Facebook, Twitter, Tumblr, and
Pinterest becomes an economical means to stay in touch with existing and potential
customers.
TheleadingbrandsfromLOralincludingGarnier,Lancme,andLOralParishavea
significantpresenceonFacebook.

LOraladoptsinstorepromotionsasamajormeansofpromotionalactivity.
New product launches for the fragrance brands and luxury skin care brands are
accompanied by promotional displays at respective counters of the brands in
departmentstores.
Beautyadvisorsplayanimportantroleinsellingluxuryfragrances.
The company employs knowledgeable beauty advisors, who encourage sampling and
explaintheintricaciesofthefragrancenotestoconsumers.
Giftsintheformofancillaryproductsorsamplepacksareofferedtoattractconsumers
towardsnewproducts.

LOralcontinuestobetheleadingmarketerintermsofadvertisingexpendituresaswellas
categorysalesinthehaircoloringproductscategory,withaTMEof$164.1millionin2012,
althoughdown11.8%from$186.1millionin2011.
The company spends approximately 64.4% or $105.8million on television
advertisementsin2012.
ATMEof$32.7millionisallocatedtopromoteL'OralExcellenceCrme.
GarnierNutrissesadvertisementexpenditurein2012totals$53.8million.

In2012,LOralisthesecondlargestadvertiserinthehairstylingproductscategory,witha
TMEofalmost$38.9million,down35.7%from$60.5millionin2011.
TheTMEisspreadmainlybetweentelevisionandmagazinesadvertisements.
Television and magazine advertising collectively account for more than 92% or
$35.8millionofTMEin2012.
LOral Paris EverStyle variant receives the singlelargest TME support at almost
$11.4millionin2012.
GarnierFructisStyleSleekFinish,astylingsprayvariant,garnersalmost$10.2million
inTMEin2012,spreadacrossmagazinesandtheInternet.

LOralsmediaspendingonpromotingitsshampoosbrandsis$51.4millionin2012,down
from$70.7millionin2011.
GarnierFructis,LOralsleadingbrand,hasaTMEof$51.1million.
The marketer allocates approximately 71.5% or $36.7 million on television
advertisementsfollowedbymagazineadvertisementswithaTMEof$14.0million.
LOralhasthehighestmediaspendingintheconditionerscategoryin2012.LOrals
advertisingspendingonpromotingitsconditionersis$40.7million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5251

5252

LOral

OUTLOOK

LOralisexpectedtopostmoderatetohealthygrowthof2.8%intheUnitedStatesover
theforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Product innovations with better technologies and new formulations are expected to
drivethemarketersgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Makeup, skin care, and fragrances product classes are expected to be the highest
revenuegeneratorsforLOralovertheforecastperiod.
ThemarketerwillcontinuetosupportitsnewproductlauncheswithsignificantTMEin
ordertostrengthenitsposition.
LOral will continue to enhance its research and development activities in order to
continuallyinnovateandensureitssalesgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
LOral is likely to excel continually in product promotion, product innovation, and
distribution, which are crucial success factors for the marketers of cosmetics and
personalcareproducts.
The marketer continues to post significant growth of 7.4% in the luxury segment in
2012,drivenbythesalesfromdepartmentstoresandthehealthyperformanceofthe
facialtreatmentscategory.Thisgrowthcanbeattributedmainlyduetotherecoveryin
theeconomyandthehighendconsumerswillingtospendmoreonluxuryitems.
Themasssegmentalsoshowsagoodgrowthof5.5%in2012,primarilydrivenbythe
good performance of the makeup product categories including face makeup, eye
makeup,andnailpolishes.
Thecorebrandsofthemarketer,LOralParis,Maybelline,Lancme,andGarnierare
expectedtodrivethesalesforLOraloverthenextfiveyears.

LOralwillcontinueto focuson productinnovationsovertheforecastperiodinorderto


maintainitspositioninthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarket.
The company will continue to launch innovative products with better technologies
acrossitsmajorcategoriesincludingfacialtreatments,facemakeup,suncareproducts,
shampoos,andconditionersovertheforecastperiod.
Inthefacialtreatmentscategory,themarketerisexpectedtointroduceproductsthat
willtargetbothpreventionandcorrectionofcommonissuesrelativetofacialconcerns.
Themarketerisalsolikelytoofferbenefitsthatclaimtomimicthoseofinjectableswith
musclerelaxing properties like Botox has, and plumping skin as do fillers such as
RestylaneandJuvedermtoincreaseitssalesinthefacialtreatmentscategory.
LOral continues to utilize premium ingredients and packaging in an effort to
differentiate its brands. Facial treatments will increasingly include highperformance
ingredientsinanattempttoboostproductefficacyandprovidevisibleresults.
Fragranceswillincorporatehighendpackagingasameanstocreateperceivedvaluein
theeyesofconsumers.Thiswilladdslightlytotheproductioncostsforthemarketer
duringtheforecastperiod.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A252

LOral

The marketer will continue to introduce products that are naturally positioned, as the
naturalsegmentisexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecastperiod.
The natural and organic products segment will continue to perform well during the
nextfiveyearsasconsumersbecomemoreconsciousofwhattheyuse.
LOral is expected to infuse more natural ingredients to its new launches as well as
existingproductsinordertosupportitssalesgrowth.
The marketer will continue to focus on eliminating harsh chemicals and ingredients
suchassulfatesandparabensinitsproducts.
The marketer will focus on natural ingredients ranging from oils to plants, to
ingredientsfromthesea,andstemcellsfromfruitsandplants.

Themarketerwillcontinuetofacestiffcompetitionfromtheotherleadingcosmeticsand
toiletriesmarketersovertheforecastperiod.
LOral is placed second in the overall cosmetics and toiletries market in the United
StatesafterProcter&Gamble,anditwillcontinuetobeactiveintheindustryinorder
tomaintainitspositionovertheforecastperiod.
The key competitors for LOral in the industry include Procter& Gamble, Unilever,
Johnson&Johnson,EsteLauder,andLimitedBrands.

TheoperatingmarginsforLOralscosmeticsandtoiletriesdivisionintheUnitedStateswill
continuetogrowoverthenextfiveyears.
The marketer offers its products across various channels including mass, luxury,
professional,andspecialty.
The marketer generates most of its revenues from its two core channels, mass and
luxury,andislikelytocontinuetogetthehighestrevenuesfromthesesegmentsover
theforecastperiod.
LOralgeneratesmostofitssalesfromhighermarginhaircareandmakeupproducts,
whichwillhelpthecompany,maintainitsoperatingmargin.
Furthermore,LOralwillcontinuetoextenditsreachtovariedconsumersegmentsby
offering products across different price points in brands such as LOral Paris and
Lancme.Thiswillhelpthemarketertoaddmoreconsumersinthelongrun,andto
increaseitspresenceacrossmoredistributionchannelsandpricepoints.

LOralislikelytoincreaseitsmediaspendingacrosscategoriestosupportitssalesgrowth
overtheforecastperiod.
The marketer will continue to aggressively support its mass and luxury products that
willcontributetothecompanysgrowth.
Global advertising campaigns featuring actors and models will contribute to the high
visibilityandbrandrecognitionenjoyedbyLOralsmakeupandfragrancebrands.
LOralspendsmorethan31%ofitsnetsales,ormorethan$1.4billion,onTME.
The marketer will continue to support its new product introductions with aggressive
mediaexpenditurestosupportitssales.However,itisexpectedthatthemarketerwill
eventuallytrimitsadvertisingexpensesandkeepitclosertothe19%to20%rangeasa
percentageofnetsalesduringtheforecastperiod.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5253

5254

LOral

Televisionandmediaadvertisingwillremainthemostpreferredchannelforpromoting
itsproductsovertheforecastperiod.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoengageconsumersinvariouscontestsandcampaignsin
ordertoeducateconsumersregardingtheirproducts.
The company will continue to offer discount coupons and free samples for its new
launchesinordertoattractconsumers.
The company will continue to partner with models, actors, and designers in order to
promoteitssalesinthefuture.
ThekeybrandsthatareexpectedtoreceivethehighestTMEsupportbyLOralover
theforecastperiodincludeLOralParis,Maybelline,Lancme,andGarnierFructis.
LOralisexpectedtoadoptinnovativemethodsofmarketingandpromotionsoverthe
forecastperiod.
In2012,themarketerlaunchesafemaletargetedXboxapplicationtokeepthefemale
consumersengagedwithitsbrands.Thesetypesofinterdisciplinaryinnovationsareto
beexpectedinthefuture.
The new application Next Level offers product articles, how to videos, and latest
beautystylesandtrendsbasedonLOralsbrandsintheUnitedStates.

The marketer will focus on enhancing its research and development activities in order to
introduceinnovativeproductstocapturemoremarketshareovertheforecastperiod.
The marketer continues to partner with various scientists in order to introduce
productswithinnovativeingredients.
The marketer is increasingly pushing back boundaries and taking up challenges to
introduceinnovativeproducts.
LOral continues to invest a lot on its research and development activities and has
maintainedacompetitiveedgethisway.Hence,themarketerwillcontinuetoinveston
itsresearchanddevelopmentactivitiesoverthenextfiveyears.
The key innovations by LOral in 2012 include Lancmes Gnifique Yeux Light Pearl
productthatisclaimedtocontainauniquerotatingandmassagingapplicatortoreach
even the most inaccessible eye areas. However, it will need to take care with its
marketingclaimstoavoidincitingtheFDAorotherregulatoryenquiries.
The marketer will continue to launch similar innovative products over the forecast
periodinordertosupportitsoverallsales.
NewlineextensionsareexpectedtohelpLOralregistersalesgrowthandimproveits
marketshareduringtheforecastperiod.

Themarketerplanstoredesignitspersonalcarebrandsovertheforecastperiodtosupport
itssales.
In 2012, the company redesigns its Pureology hair care products with multitasking
bottlesdesignedforsustainablepackaging.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoredesignitsotherbrandswithsustainablepackagingover
thenextfiveyears.
The company plans to redesign its LOral Paris brand with sustainable packaging by
usingenvironmentallyfriendlymaterialsin2013.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A254

LOral

Themarketerwillcontinuetofocusonthedigitalmediainordertogetclosertoconsumers
topromoteitsproducts.
LOralwilllikelycontinuetoincreaseitsinvestmentsondigitalmediabyincreasingits
online presence through social media sites such as Facebook, Youtube, Tumblr, and
Pinterest.
Themarketerwillfocusonthedigitalmediaplatformasitisagreatpromotionaltool
thatwillfurtherstrengthenthepositionofthecompanysbrands.
LOralhasalmost20millionFacebookfansatpresentandthemarketerplanstoutilize
thistopromoteitsproducts.
ThesocialmediachannelwillallowLOraltointeractwithconsumerssoastoidentify
theproductstheyseek.
The marketer displays its new product launches, product offers, and various product
videosonitsFacebookpagetokeeptheconsumersinterestengaged.

LOralisexpectedtomakestrategicacquisitionstofurtherexpandthecompanysproduct
portfolioovertheforecastperiod.
In2012,themarketeracquiresUrbanDecaytofurtherstrengthenitscolorcosmetics
divisionintheUnitedStates.
LOreals CEO JeanPaul Agon announces early in 2013 that he is willing to make an
importantacquisitionin2013tomaintaingrowth.

LOralwillcontinuetoexpanditsdistributionofproductsthroughmassanddrugstoresin
theUnitedStatestosupportitssales.
In 2012, the marketer expands its skin care brands, La RochePosays and Vichys
distributiontomoreWalgreensstoresinordertopromoteitssales.
ThemarketeralsoplanstoopenanewdistributioncenterinDallasin2013.

Duringtheforecastperiod,thecompanyssalesareprojectedtoincreaseataCAGRof2.8%,
from$4,551millionin2012to$5,225millionby2017.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5255

5256

LOral

Table5133:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmetics
andToiletriesforLOralbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Nailpolishes

6.0

Facemakeup

4.5

Eyemakeup

4.2

Suncareproducts

4.0

Facialtreatments

3.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1.7

Shampoos

1.5

Conditioners

1.4

Haircoloringproducts

1.2

Ethnichaircareproducts

1.2

Skincareproductsformen

1.0

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1.0

Fragrancesformen

1.0

Fragrancesforwomen

0.8

Personalcleansingproducts

0.8

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments
Handandbodylotions

(1.0)

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

(10.0)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A256

LVMH

Table5134:LVMHsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

2012

J'adore

22

26

Shalimar

12

12

MissDiorCherie

VeryIrresistible

FanDiFendi

Amarige

VeryIrresistibleIntense

Eat,Pray,Love

Fresh

Organza

AbsolutelyIrresistible

DiorAddict

DiorAddict2

Dune

HypnoticPoison

Poison

PurePoison

Ysatis

Allother

13

14

Total

91

96

Benefit

30

40

ChristianDior

26

29

Total

56

69

EYEMAKEUP

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5258

LVMH

Table5134:LVMHsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

2012

ChristianDior

27

32

Guerlain

16

17

Benefit

14

14

61

67

Benefit

30

32

ChristianDior

21

23

Total

51

55

14

15

21

23

Fahrenheit

Pi

Play

Allother

18

17

NAILPOLISHES

ChristianDior

Givenchy
Total
FACEMAKEUP

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
ChristianDior
Benefit
Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

Total

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Benefit

TOTAL
307
337

NOTE:"Allother"includesthesalesofsmallerbrandsthatthecompany
owns.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A258

LVMH

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Founded in 1987 and headquartered in Paris, France, LVMH is a luxury goods holding
company.
It is the parent of around 60 subcompanies that each manages a small number of
prestigiousbrands.
As of December 31, 2012, the company operates approximately 3,402 stores
worldwideandemploysmorethan97,559employeesglobally.
Thecompanyspecializesinfivedifferentsectors:winesandspirits,fashionandleather
goods,perfumesandcosmetics,watchesandjewelry,andselectiveretailing.

LVMHownsmanypopularluxurybrands,suchasMotetChandon(winesandspirits);Dom
Prignon (wines and spirits); Donna Karan (fashion and leather goods); Givenchy (fashion
andleathergoods);TagHeuer(watchesandjewelry);andZenith(watchesandjewelry).

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

ThetotalcorporatesalesofLVMHincreasefrom23,659million($30,406million)in2011,
to28,103million($36,117million)in2012,upby18.8%.
Net profits increase by 12.8%, from 3,465million ($4,453 million) in 2011, to
3,909million($5,024million)in2012.

Table5135:LVMHsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales,%

2007

16,481

2,331

14.1

2008

17,193

2,318

13.5

2009

17,053

1,973

11.6

2010

20,320

3,319

16.3

2011

23,659

3,465

14.6

2012
28,103

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

3,909

13.9

TheFashionandleathergoodssegmentcontinuestobethelargestbusinessgroupwithin
thecompanyin2012,commanding35.3%ofthetotalcorporatesales.
TheWatchesandjewelrysegmentclearlyoutpacesotherbusinessgroupsintermsof
salesgrowth,asitwitnessesa45.5%increaseduringfiscal2012.
Perfumes and cosmetics witnesses a 13.1% increase in global sales, up from
3,195million($4,106million)in2011to3,613million($4,643million)in2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5259

5260

LVMH

Table5136:LVMHsGlobalCorporateSalesbyBusinessGroup,2011and2012

Million

%Oftotal

Businessgroup

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Fashionandleathergoods

8,712

9,926

36.8

35.3

13.9

Selectiveretailing

6,436

7,879

27.2

28.0

22.4

Winesandspirits

3,524

4,137

14.9

14.7

17.4

Perfumesandcosmetics

3,195

3,613

13.5

12.9

13.1

Watchesandjewelry

1,949

2,836

8.2

10.1

45.5

(157)

(288)

(0.7)

(1.0)

23,659

28,103

100.0

100.0

Allotheractivities
Total

18.8

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

LVMHsellsitsproductsworldwide.
The rest of Asia (except Japan) continues to be the largest market for the company,
followedbytheUnitedStatesandtherestofEurope(excludingFrance).

Table5137:LVMHsGlobalCorporateSalesby
Region,2012
Region

%Ofsales

RestofAsia

28.1

UnitedStates

22.7

RestofEurope

19.4

France

11.1

Japan

8.4

Allother

10.3

Total

100.0

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

LVMHsU.S.salesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesincreaseby9.8%,from$307millionin2011to
$337millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A260

LVMH

Table5138:LVMHsSalesofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

282

2008

279

(1.1)

2009

269

(3.6)

2010

279

3.7

2011

307

10.0

2012

337

9.8

ThewomensfragrancescategorycontinuestobethelargestproductcategoryforLVMH,
commanding28.4%ofthecompanyssales.
Salesincreasefrom$91millionin2011to$96millionin2012.
JadorecontinuestoLVMHsleaderinthecategory,with$26millioninsales,followed
byShalimarwith$12millioninsalesin2012.

Makeupproductsaccountfor 46.0%ofthecompanyssalesin2012intheU.S.cosmetics
andtoiletriesmarket.
Thecontributionincreasesfrom43.6%in2011.
The category commands a 6.2% market share in the U.S. luxury makeup product
segmentin2012,upfrom5.8%in2011.
BenefitandChristianDioraretheleadingmakeupbrandsforthecompany.

Eye makeup is the secondlargest category for the company, with sales of $69million in
2012,upby23.2%from$56millionin2011.
ThecompanybenefitsfromtheloyalcustomerbaseforitsBenefitbrand,supportedby
itsglamorouspackagingandinnovativeformulas.

Facial treatments constitutes the thirdlargest category for the company, with a share of
19.9%ofthecompanyssales.
Salesinthecategoryincreasefrom$61millionin2011to$67millionin2012,up9.8%.
Christian Dior, its largest brand in the category, experiences an increase in sales by
18.5%,from$27millionin2011to$32millionin2012.
Guerlainssalesalsoincreaseby6.3%,from$16millionin2011to$17millionin2012;
however,BenefitandGivenchyrecordflatsalesfrom2011at$14millionand$4million,
respectively,in2012.

Facemakeupsalesforthecompanyincreasefrom$51millionin2011to$55millionin2012.
ThecompanysellsBenefitandChristianDiorbrandsunderthiscategory.

Sales in the lipsticks and lip glosses category increase from $21million in 2011 to
$23millionin2012,upby9.5%.
Improvedsalesofnewnailpolishcolorssupportthecategorysgrowthin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5261

5262

LVMH

LVMHseesadeclineinthemensfragrancescategoryin2012.
Salesdecreasemarginallyfrom$18millionin2011to$17millionin2012.
Lackofnewproductactivityandlimitedtraceablemediaexpenditures(TMEs)leadto
thedeclineinsalesforthecategory.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Managementchanges

In March 2012, LVMH announces the appointment of Sebastian Suhl as Chief Executive
OfficerofGivenchyCouture.

InDecember2012,LVMHannouncestheappointmentofMichaelBurkeasChairmanand
CEOofLouisVuitton.HejoinstheExecutiveCommitteeofLVMH.

Mergersandacquisitions

ThereissignificantactivityontheM&AfrontforLVMHinfiscalyear2012.
InMay2012,LVMHacquirestheentiresharecapitalofLesTanneriesRoux(France),a
leathersupplyingcompany,foranundisclosedamount.
In June 2012, LVMH acquires Arnys (France), a fashion house that makes apparel for
men.Thetermsofthedealarenotdisclosed.
In October 2012, LVMHs Berluti brand acquires the business of Anthony Delos, a
bespokefootwearmanufacturer.Thefinancialtermsarenotdisclosed.

Otherdevelopments

In May 2012, LVMH teams up with the European Commission to promote best
environmentalbehaviorsintheframeworkoftheGreenWeek2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A262

LVMH

Newproducts

Table5139:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyLVMHintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Benefit

Lipsticks

UltraPlushLipgloss

ChristianDior

Facemakeup

DiorskinNudefoundation

ChristianDior

Lipsticks

DiorAddictLipGlow

ChristianDior

Facialtreatments

OneEssentialMaskisaserumtomaskformulatoeliminatetoxins
andprovideintensiverepair

ChristianDior

Facialtreatments

HydraLifeBBCreamisoneuniversalshadethatcombinesthe
moisturizingandprotectivepowersofaskincareproductwith
immediatecomplexionenhancingandeventoningpropertiesofa
foundation

MakeUpForEver

Facemakeup

HDComplexionStarterKit

Sephora

Lipsticks

PantoneUniverseLipLusterLipstick

MARKETINGACTIVITY

LVMHhasaTMEof$89.8millionin2012.
Itincreasesitsmediabudgetby63.0%from$55.1millionin2011.
The company spends approximately $62 million of its total TME through local
magazines.

Thecompanyspendsalmost$65.1millionor72.4%ofitsTMEtosupportitsfragrancesfor
womenproductsin2012.
LVMHspendsthehighestTMEof$50.1milliontosupportitsChristianDiorfragrance
brand.

Themarketerprimarilyadvertisesitsproductsthroughprintadvertisementsinbeautyand
fashionmagazines,suchasVogueandAllure

Themarketerusestheincreasinglypopularsocialmedianetworks,Facebook,Twitter,and
YouTube,topromoteitsproducts.
The marketer primarily advertises its new product launches through its social media
channelstoengageconsumersinterest.

Thecompanyalsopromotesitsproductsbygivingfreesamplestoattractmoreconsumers.
Thesepromotionsincludescentedstripsinmagazinesandsmallsamplesdistributedin
stores.
Intheskincareproductsclass,thecompanyusesspeciallydesignedminiaturesample
packs,whichencourageproducttrial.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5263

5264

LVMH

OUTLOOK

LVMHisforecasttopostmoderategrowthof2.0%overtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
The growth of the marketer will be primarily supported by new product launches
across categories over the next five years and the resilience of the luxury shoppers
budgets.
Increasingmarketingandpromotionalactivitieswillalsocontributetothemarketers
overallgrowth.

The makeup product class and the facial treatments category are expected to post the
highestgrowthovertheforecastperiod.
Thecompanyisexpectedtolaunchnewantiagingproductstosupportitssalesgrowth
inthefacialtreatmentscategoryinthefuture.
Growing demand for antiaging products will drive sales of the facial treatments
categoryovertheforecastperiod.
Thecompanywilllikelylaunchnewandinnovativeproductstosupportthegrowthof
themakeupcategory.

The fragrances product class is projected to be the highest revenue generator for the
companyoverthenextfiveyears.
Thecompanyplanstolaunchmorefragrancesandincreaseitsmediaspendtosupport
thesalesoffragrancesovertheforecastperiod.
Fragrances for women is expected to maintain its leadership in the company in the
future.
ThemarketerplanstofocusonitsDiorfragrancelinesovertheforecastperiod.

The company is expected to increase its media spending during the forecast period to
supportitssales.
The company is likely to spend more on promoting its fragrances product class and
facial treatments category over the forecast period. Furthermore, the company is
expectedtospendmoreonitsnewproductlaunchestosupportitssales.
Magazine advertisements are likely to be the preferred mode of advertising medium
forthemarketer.

The company will likely enter into new markets and new product categories through
mergersandacquisitions,andsigningpartnershipagreements.
Itwillmaintainitsdominanceasthelargestluxuryconglomerateintheworld.

LVMHalsopromotesitsproductsthroughsocialmediachannelsandisexpectedtoincrease
itspresenceinthisplatformtosupportitssalesandattractmoreconsumers.
ThecompanylaunchesitsTwitteraccountLVMHinHyeresinApril2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A264

LVMH

Thecompanywillcontinuetoleverageconsumerinterestinsocialnetworkingsitesand
willstrengthenitspresencebycontinuingtopromoteitsbrandsonsocialsitessuchas
Facebook,Twitter,andYouTube.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5265

5266

LVMH

Themarketermightdiscontinueitshandandbodylotionsproductsovertheforecastperiod
due to the lack of new product extensions, a lack of TME support, and other significant
activitiestosupportthecategory.

Thecompanyscosmeticsandtoiletriessalesareprojectedtoreach$372millionby2017,
growingataCAGRof2.0%,from$337millionin2012.

Table5140:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmetics
andToiletriesforLVMHbyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Eyemakeup

4.0

Facialtreatments

3.0

Facemakeup

2.8

Nailpolishes

2.6

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.0

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1.5

Fragrancesforwomen

0.5

Fragrancesformen

0.3

Handandbodylotions

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A266

MARYKAY

Table5141:MaryKaysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and
2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACIALTREATMENTS

MaryKay

451

449

166

178

132

141

FACEMAKEUP
MaryKay
EYEMAKEUP
MaryKay

2012

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

MaryKay

107

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

110

MaryKay

93

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

95

ThinkingofYou

BelaBelara

Journey

Velocity

Affection

Belara

Allother

12

12

Total

34

32

FRAGRANCESFORMEN

VelocityforHim

Domain

MKHighIntensity

Tribute

22

22

Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5268

MaryKay

Table5141:MaryKaysSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and
2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
MaryKay

17

17

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
MaryKay
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
MaryKay
SHAVINGPRODUCTS
MaryKay
NAILPOLISHES
MaryKay

TOTAL
1,047
1,063

NOTE:Allothersalesincludethesalesofsmallerbrandsthatthecompanyowns.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

MaryKaywasfoundedonSeptember13,1963.
It is one of the largest directselling company of skin care and color cosmetics in the
UnitedStatesandinternationally.
ItisheadquarteredinthetownofAddison,asuburbofDallas,TX.
Mary Kay remains family owned. Mary Kay Ash, the founder, remained active in the
companyuntil1996.HersonRichardRogerswasnamedtheCEOofMaryKayin2001,
theyearofAshsdeath.
ThecompanymarketsallitsproductsprimarilyundertheMaryKaybrandname.
Thecompanysproductsaremanufacturedintwomanufacturingcenters:onenearthe
companysheadquartersinDallas,andtheotherinHangzhou,China.
Itemploysaworkforceofaround4,500peopleglobally.

Mary Kay sells its products through an independent contractor sales force called
IndependentBeautyConsultants.
Thereareabout2.4millionIndependentBeautyConsultantsinmorethan35countries.
TheBeautyConsultantspurchasetheproductsatwholesalepricesfromthecompany.
Theproductsarethensoldtoendusersatretailpricesbytheconsultants.
MaryKayhasmorethan600independentnationalsalesdirectors,whoholdthehighest
rankwithintheindependentsalesforce.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A268

MaryKay

Consultantsvieforawardseachyear,rangingfromjewelrytothecompanystrademark
pinkCadillac(firstawardedin1969).
The company also founded the Mary Kay Ash Charitable Foundation in 1996 to fund
cancerresearchanddomesticviolenceprograms.
MaryKaymarketsmorethan200productsacrossproductcategoriessuchasskincare,
makeup,fragrances,andmensproducts.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

MaryKayisaprivatelyheldcompanyandreleaseslimitedfinancialdata.

Corporate sales are estimated to grow at 2.4% to approximately $3,000million in 2012,


from$2,931millionin2011.
MaryKaysworldwidesaleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of4.9%since2007.

Table5142:MaryKaysGlobalCorporateSales,
2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

2,367

7.0

2008

2,447

3.4

2009

2,494

1.9

2010

2,549

2.2

2011

2,931

15.0

2012

3,000

2.4

Approximately50%ofMaryKayssalesaregeneratedintheUnitedStates.
TheremainingsalesaregeneratedinAsiaPacific,Canada,Mexico,SouthAmerica,and
Europe.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Since2007,U.S.salesforMaryKayscosmeticsandtoiletrieshaveincreasedataCAGRof
0.2%.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5269

5270

MaryKay

Table5143:MaryKaysCosmeticsandToiletries
Sales,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

1,053

2008

1,052

(0.1)

2009

1,042

(1.0)

2010

1,039

(0.3)

2011

1,047

0.8

2012

1,063

1.5

NOTE:Salesincluderetailproductsonly;salesaids
purchasedbyconsultantsforsellingeffortsarenot
included.

MaryKayssalesinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketgrow1.5%toreach$1,063millionin
2012,upfrom$1,047millionin2011.

FacialtreatmentsisthelargestrevenuegeneratingcategoryforMaryKayin2012withsales
declining$2millionto$449millionin2012asthecompanystrugglestomaintainanactive
salesforce.
MaryKaycontinuestobethelargestdirectsellingbrandoffacialtreatmentsproducts,
commandingover30%oftotaltradeclasssales.
DirectsalesistheonlybusinessmodelthatMaryKayfollows,utilizingrepresentatives
that can run their own business and conduct parties, classes, and oneonone
consultations. Most of the independent representatives also have their own websites,
and many customers choose to purchase directly from their website. During 2012,
severalarticlesaboutMaryKayarepublishedinmagazines,suchasForbesandBusiness
Weekthatindicatedifficultiesinmaintainingitsdirectsalesforce.
MaryKaytypicallydoesnotlaunchmanynewproductsinayear,yettheTimewiseline
isextendedin2012withRepairVoluFirmListingSerumsaidtohelpfirmandliftskin.
Mary Kay spends little on advertising and promotional dollars to support its facial
treatmentbrands,relyingonitssalesconsultantsandcatalogstopromotethem.

Thefacemakeupcategoryisthesecondlargestcategoryforthemarketerintermsofsales.
MaryKayssalesreach$178millionin2012,up7.2%from$166millionin2011.Sales
continuetoflourishfromthecompanys2011launchofTimeWiseLuminousandMatte
foundations.
MaryKayisthefifthleadingmarketerinthefacemakeupcategoryin2012.In2011,the
companytiedwithRevlonforfifthplace.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A270

MaryKay

EyemakeupisthethirdlargestcategoryforMaryKaywithsalesat$141millionin2012,up
6.8%.
MaryKayisthefifthleadingeyemakeupmarketerwithacategoryshareof5.2%.
Mary Kays growth is recognized due to several successful launches including its lash
primerandbrowbuilder,creameyeshadowpots,andLashLoveWaterproofmascara.
Thewaterproofversionisaddedin2012asanextensionofthesuccessfullaunchofLash
Lovein2011.
Additionally, the gel eyeliner, although not new, performs well in the second half of
2012.

MaryKayjumpsupto becomethefourthleadingmarketerinthelipsticksandlipglosses
categorywith8.0%categorysalesin2012,surpassingProcter&Gamble.
Mary Kay is the leading directselling brand in the category, with sales reaching
$110millionin2012,up2.8%from2011.Thisisnotable,asthecompanydidnotlaunch
itsnewTrueDimensionlipstickuntillatein2012.Theproductisontrendasitistouted
asasheer,yetbuildablelipcolorinaluxuriousslimlinepackage.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

In2012,MaryKaytakesluxurydesigner,MichaelKorstocourtforbreachofcontractand
trademarkinfringement.
According to Mary Kay, Michael Kors has registered a cosmetics line with the same
trademarkinitialsasitself.
In May 2012, Michael Kors files two unauthorized applications for trademark
registration.
ThefirstfilingwiththeU.S.PatentandTrademarkOfficeincludestheMKwithacircle
aroundtheletterwhilethesecondfilingincludesMichaelKorsonthebottomborder
ofthecircle.
AccordingtoMaryKay,theagreementstatesthatMichaelKorscannotuseMKallby
itself, or in close proximity to Michael Kors or in relation with any products
whatsoever.

Newproducts

Table5144:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyMaryKayintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

MaryKay

Eyemakeup

LashLoveWaterproofmascara

Facialtreatments

TimewiseRepairVoluFirmLiftingSerumsaidtohelp
firmandliftskinwhilerestoringyouthfulvolumeand
vibrancysothattheskinappearstighterandlifted.
Thisserumclaimstoinfluencetheproductionof
CollagenVII,minimizingdamagetotheproteinsin
thedermalepidermaljunctionwhichcancause
wrinkles

MaryKay

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5271

5272

MaryKay

MARKETINGACTIVITY

MaryKaycontinuestorelyonsalesconsultantstopromoteitsproducts,butisincreasingly
utilizingothervehiclesincludingprintandtelevisionadvertising.
MaryKayisoneoftheleadingdirectmarketerswhosesuccessin2012canbeattributed
tosalesrepresentativesholdingpartiestopromoteratherthansellingoneonone.
MaryKayshowcasesitsfragrancesinitsLookBook,itsquarterlycatalog.
Otherpromotionalvehiclesincludemediaadvertising,discounts,andgiftwithpurchase
(GWP)offers.
Some of the GWP offers from the company include a gift with the purchase of Mini
FragranceFreeSatinHandsPamperingSetandtheMiniNouriShinePlusLipGlossSeton
purchasesof$40.00worthofproducts.
MaryKayscatalogsarecentraltothepromotionofthecompany.Itpromotesvarious
productsinitscatalogs.Thecompanyhasalsointroducedtheconceptofecatalogsfor
thebenefitofthetechsavvyconsumers.Thisinitiativealsoactsameansofconserving
environmentbysavingonpaper.

MaryKaysoverallTMEin2012isapproximately$18million,upfrom$2.8millionin2011.
In 2012, Mary Kay allocates $14.1 million towards magazine advertisements while
$3.5millionisallocatedtowardstelevisionadvertisements.
TheTimewiselineofproductsintroducedin2012receivesthemostTMEat$4.2million.

Thecompanytakesadvantageoftechnologytoreachouttoconsumers.
MaryKayusesavarietyofmarketingtoolsincludingpersonalecommercesitestoaid
its independent beauty consultants, ecatalogs, online virtual makeovers, business
managementtoolsformobiledevices,andsocialmedianetworks.
The digital tools give the independent beauty consultants better access to their Mary
Kay business by broadening their reach, strengthening their customer network, and
increasingawarenessabouttheirbusiness.

MaryKayhastoolsonitswebsitethatallowaninterestedpartytofindasalesconsultantin
theirarea.
Mary Kays website has a Personal Beauty Profiler that helps consumers decide which
facialtreatmentproductswouldbebestforthem.Thecompanyswebsitealsoincludes
the brand catalog and a link to its Facebook, Twitter, YouTube, and Pinterest home
pages.MostofMaryKayssalesassociateshavetheirownwebpage,tokeepintouch
withtheirconsumersviafrequentemails.
To help entice consumers, Mary Kays sales associates frequently hold product
demonstrationgatheringswhereparticipantsaregivenafreeproductsuchasfullsize
lipglossordollarcreditforpurchasing.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A272

MaryKay

OUTLOOK

MaryKayscosmeticsandtoiletriesbusinessisprojectedtogrowmoderatelyat1.3%during
theforecastperiod.
Thecompanywillcontinuetotakeinitiativestostrengthenitsdirectsellingnetwork,cut
costs,andexpanditsdistributionnetworkintheforecastperiod.MaryKaywillcontinue
to improve its reward and effort equation for its representatives. The marketer offers
webbasedtoolsforitsrepresentativestohelpthemincreasetheirsales.
Catalogsandecatalogswillcontinuetoplayanintegralroleinaidingrepresentativesto
marketandpromoteitsproductsandthereaftergeneratesales.
The company is expected to strengthen its product presence and offers strong
competitiontoitscompetitorswithnewlaunches.

Thefacemakeupcategoryisexpectedtoshowthehighestgrowthduringthenextfiveyears
followedbytheeyemakeupandfacialtreatmentcategories.Themarketerwillcontinueto
focus its efforts on its new Timewise Repair line of products and introduce products with
multifunctional benefits like antiaging with sun protection or foundation with sun
protection.
MaryKaysgrowthinthefragrancesformen,lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments,personal
cleansingproducts,nailpolishes,shavingproducts,andsuncareproductscategoriesis
expected to stay dormant in the forecast years until the marketer undertakes drastic
measurestorevampitspresenceinthesecategories.
The company will need to increase its efforts on R&D and introduce innovative and
technologicallyadvancednewproductsatregularintervalsaheadofitscompetitors.
The multilevel marketing business model is not expected to thrive in the forecast
period,asmoremoderndirectsellingtacticssuchastheInternetsalescapturemarket
share.

Themarketersexpendituresonmarketingareexpectedtoincreaseintheforecastyears.
Mary Kays newly revolutionized approach of adopting digital media as a means of
promotingitsproductswillaidthecompanysgrowthduringtheforecastperiod,2012
to2017.
Additionally,marketingtoolssuchasthecompanyswebsiteandsocialmedianetworks
willbenefitthecompanyincuttingdownitsmarketingcosts.
Instorepromotionswillbeencouragedtoreachouttothemasses.
Distribution of samples to the masses is also likely to have a positive impact on the
companyssales.

Mary Kays sales are projected to experience a 1.3% CAGR increase to $1,333million by
2017,upfrom$1,063millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5273

5274

MaryKay

Table5145:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmetics
andToiletriesforMaryKaybyCategory,2012to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Facemakeup

2.5

Eyemakeup

1.8

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.3

Facialtreatments

1.1

Lipsticksandlipglosses

0.9

Fragrancesforwomen

0.6

Handandbodylotions

0.4

Fragrancesformen

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

Personalcleansingproducts

Nailpolishes

Shavingproducts

Suncareproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A274

MERCK

Table5146:MercksSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

159

173

16

19

176

193

16

16

192

209

SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Coppertone
CoppertoneWaterBabies
BaindeSoleil
Total
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Dr.Scholls
TOTAL

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Merck&Co.,Inc.isaglobalhealthcarecompanythatdevelops,manufactures,andmarkets
medicines, vaccines, biologic therapies, overthecounter (OTC) remedies, animal health
products,andpersonalcareproducts.
ItisbasedoutofWhitehouseStation,NJ.
Merck was founded in 1891 and employs approximately 83,000 employees globally,
with32,500intheUnitedStatesincludingPuertoRico,asofDecember31,2012.
Thecompanyemploysapproximately13,600peopleinitsresearchteam.

Merckhasthreereportablebusinesssegments:
Pharmaceuticals: The company offers human health pharmaceutical products,
including therapeutic and preventive agents for the treatment of human disorders in
the areas of bone, respiratory, immunology, dermatology, cardiovascular diseases,
diabetes and obesity, infectious diseases, hypertension, heart failure, urology,
bronchospasm,neurosciencesandophthalmology,andoncology.
Animal Health: The company offers antibiotics, antiinflammatory products, vaccines,
products for the treatment of fertility disorders, and parasiticides for cattle, swine,
horses,poultry,dogs,cats,salmon,andfish.
Consumer Health: This segment includes antihistamines, products for constipation,
cold medicines, nasal decongestant sprays, and laxative tablets; foot care products,
which comprise topical antifungal products, and foot and sneaker wetness products;
and sun care products, such as sun care lotions, sprays, dry oils, and lipprotection
products,aswellassunlesstanningandsunburnreliefproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5276

Merck

Thecompanydistributesitssuncareandfootcareproductsthroughwholesale,retaildrug,
foodchainoutlets,massmerchandisers,clubstores,andspecialtychannels.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Mercks sales grow to reach $47,267 million in 2012, down 1.6% from $48,047million in
2011.
Since2007,thecompanyssaleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)
of14.3%.
The companys net profit witnesses a decline from 2011 figures, at $6,299million in
2012.
ThecompanyssalesoutsidetheUnitedStatesareprimarilydonethroughsubsidiaries.

Table5147:MercksGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million

Fiscalyear

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales

Returnonequity

2007

24,198

3,275

13.5

16.5

2008

23,850

7,808

32.7

37.5

2009

27,428

12,899

47.0

21.2

2010

45,987

861

1.9

1.7

2011

48,047

6,392

13.3

11.2

2012

47,267

6,299

13.3

11.9

Table5148:MercksGlobalSalesbyRegion,2011and2012

$Million

Region

2012

2011

2012

UnitedStates

20,495

20,392

42.7

43.1

Europe,MiddleEast,andAfrica

13,782

12,990

28.7

27.5

Japan

4,835

5,102

10.1

10.8

Allother

8,935

8,783

18.6

18.6

48,047

47,267

100.0

100.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A276

%Oftotal

2011

Total

Merck

5277

Table5149:MercksGlobalSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011and2012

$Million

Businesssegment

2011

2012

41,289

40,601

Miscellaneoussegmentsa

5,093

Allotherb

1,666

Pharmaceuticals

%Oftotal

2011

2012

85.9

85.9

6,412

10.6

13.6

254

3.5

0.5

Total
48,047
47,267

100.0

aIncludessegmentssuchasanimalhealthandconsumerhealthcare.
bIncludessalesofdivestedproductsorbusinessandthirdpartymanufacturingsales.

100.0

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Since2007,saleshavegrownataCAGRof2.0%.

Table5150:MercksCosmeticsandToiletries
Sales,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007r

189

2008r

196

3.7

2009

181

(7.7)

2010

185

2.2

2011

192

3.8

2012

209

8.9

rRestated.

The sun care products category is the largest category for Merck in the cosmetics and
toiletries market in 2012 with sales at $193million in 2012, up 9.7% from $176million in
2011.
ThecompanydisplacesJohnson&Johnsontobecomethesecondleadingmarketerin
thesuncareproductscategory.
In2012,Mercksshareinthesuncareproductscategoryincreasesfrom17.9%in2011
to18.4%in2012.
The companys growth in 2012 is due to the introduction of two new product lines:
SportsProSeriesdesignedforathletesandsportspersons,andWetnCleardesigned
forbabies.
TheCoppertoneWaterBabiesbranddoesexceptionallywellwithagrowthof18.8%to
postsalesat$19millionin2012,upfrom$16millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5278

Merck

As the awareness about the dangers of the UV rays among consumers increases,
parentsaretakingprecautionarymeasurestosafeguardtheirbabiesandkidsskin,as
aresultofwhichthekidsandbabiessegmentgarnersincreasedattention.
CoppertoneWaterBabies,apediatricianrecommendedbrand,offersproducts,suchas
QuickCoverLotionSpraySPF50Sunscreen,LotionSPF100+Sunscreen,FoamingLotion
SPF75+Sunscreen,andStickSPF55Sunscreen.

MercksDr.Schollsretainsitsleadinthefootcaresegmentofthehandandbodylotions
category,withsalesat$16millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
Dr.Schollsrepresents38.1%ofthetotalfootcareproductssegmentsalesin2012,flat
from2011levels.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

In2012,MercksettlesalawsuitagainstitsCoppertonelineofsunscreens.
Although Merck initially denied all the allegations, it has decided to make the
settlement in order to avoid the expense and burden of continuing the litigation any
further.
Merck has agreed to stop using the terms sunblock, waterproof, sweatproof, all
day or all day protection on its Coppertone sunscreen products in the U.S. market
afterJune2012.
For the settlement, Merck is required to pay $1.50 for each eligible Coppertone
sunscreen product that was purchased from July 2006 and returned resulting in an
aggregateofanywherebetween$3millionand$10milliondollars.

Alsoin2012,Merckhasbeensuedforaclassactionconsumerfraudlawsuit.
According to the lawsuit, Mercks advertisements for its Coppertone sunscreens are
deceptivelylabeled,advertised,andmarketed.
Theplaintiffsargumentrevolvesaroundthefactthatconsumershavebeenmisledby
promises of the products providing full defense against the ultravioletA (UVA)
radiation,wheninrealitytheseproductsdonotblockallorclosetoalloftheUVArays.
In December 2011, the company had received prior warnings from the National
AdvertisingDivision(NAD)ofBetterBusinessBureauClaimstostopadvertisingclaims
foritssuncareproductswithaSPFof15orhigherwhichprotectsacross100%ofthe
UVA/UVBspectrum.
AlthoughlaterNADwasabletodeterminethatevidenceprovidedby Merckpartially
supportedtheevidence,itdidnotsupporttheclaimtoprovide100%protection.

Mergers,acquisitions,anddivestures

Therearenomergers,acquisitions,anddivestituresin2012.

Managementchanges

Therearenomanagementchangesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A278

Merck

Newproducts

Table5151:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyMerckintheUnitedStates,2012
Brand

Category

Description

Coppertone

Suncareproducts

SportProSeriesContinuousSpraySunscreenisformulatedwithDuraFlex
technologythatprovidesUVAandUVBprotectionandiswaterresistantfor80
minutes.Itisappropriateforacneproneskin,andisavailableinSPF15,SPF30,
andSPF50variants

Coppertone

Suncareproducts

WetnClearContinuousSpraySPF30providesUVAandUVBprotectionandis
waterresistantforupto80minutes.Itisdermatologicallytestedandisavailable
inSPF30andSPF45+variants

Coppertone

Suncareproducts

WetnClearKidsContinuousSpraySPF45+providesUVAandUVBprotectionand
iswaterresistantforupto80minutes

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Mercksupportsitsbrandswithtraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)of$17.7millionin2012,
up22.9%from$14.4millionin2011.
Television advertisement is the most popular advertising medium for the marketer,
followed by magazine advertising. Collectively, they represent almost 96% of the
marketerstotalTMEin2012.
Television and magazines advertisements receive a TME support of $13.4 million and
$3.6million,respectively.
CoppertonereceivesMercksentireTMEallocationin2012.
CoppertonesWetnClearreceivesthemaximumTMEsupportat$7.4millionfollowed
byCoppertonesProSeriesat$6.4millionin2012.

Sponsorshipactivityhelpsdrivegrowthforthemarketerinthesuncareproductscategory
in2012.
Theprimarygoalofthesesponsorshipactivitiesincludepromotingnewproductsand
lineextensionsfromestablishedandstartupcompanies,educateconsumersaboutthe
attributesoftheproducts,andgatherretailplatformsforpromotionalactivities.
Coppertone uses its partnership with Six Flags to promote the Sports Pro Series and
Wet n Clear product lines. The partnership provides the brand a platform and an
environmenttocommunicatetochildrenandadultstheimportanceofprotectingtheir
skinfromthesunsrayswhiletheyareoutdoors.

Merckcontinues to focus on the social media, to spread awareness about its Coppertone
brandandnewproductintroductions.
Socialnetworksites,suchasFacebookandTwitterareoftenutilizedtopublicizenew
productintroductions.
In2012,CoppertoneholdsacontestonitsFacebookpagetofindthenextLittleMiss
Coppertone in an effort to give the brands advertising campaign a new look by
rekindlinginterestinthelittlegirlandthedogaCoppertonesymbolsince1953.The
contest is promoted in a number of ways including an advertisement in the People
magazine for the Coppertone Ultra Guard sunscreen spray that is portrayed with a
scratchandsnifffeaturewhichreleasesthetrademarkCoppertonescent.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5279

5280

Merck

OUTLOOK

Merck is forecast to post a healthy growth during the forecast period, at CAGR of 3.4%
through2017.
The company will continue to grow in line with its fourparty growth strategy that is
focused on: executing its core businesses including its largest markets, core brands,
newly launched brands, and research and development efforts; geographical
expansion; expansion of consumer care and animal health businesses and; managing
costswhileinvestingforthefuture.
Thecompanywillcontinuetoemphasizeonitsresearchanddevelopmentinitiativesto
compete with other marketers with respect to quality control, ability to meet
consumersexpectations,andexpanditsdistributionnetwork.
To meet the evergrowing changing market conditions, the marketer will continue to
enterexternalalliances,jointventures,andlicenses,andstrivestoacquirebusinesses.
The marketers success in the cosmetics and toiletries industry will depend upon its
abilitytopromoteitsnewproducts.

Merck has a strong presence in the sun care products category with its flagship brand,
Coppertone.
The companys largest brand, Coppertone, which has a loyal customer base, will
continuetogathersalesandislikelytoremainasoneofthetopfivemassbrandsinthe
suncareproductscategoryduringtheforecastperiod.
Thecompanyislikelytodiversifyitsproductofferingswiththeintroductionofsuncare
productsexclusivelyforfaceinordertosafeguarditspositioningfromthethreatening
blurbetweentheskincareandsuncareproducts.
Its Coppertone for Water Babies brand will continue to gain sales over the next five
yearswithrisingawarenessamongconsumersabouttheharmfuleffectsoftheUVrays.

AlthoughsalesofMercksDr.Schollsfootcareproductshaveremainedstablein2012,the
brandisprojectedtogrowataCAGRof1.2%duringtheforecastperiod.
There is a rising obese American population with a high possibility of developing
callousedfeetresultinginincreasedsalesofcorn,callus,andwartremovers.
Additionally, with the growing number of people suffering from diabetes, there is a
growingtendencyofthemdevelopingailmentssuchaswartsandcorns.
Furthermore, with the growing number of women adopting the use of tightfitting,
highheeled, and opentoed shoes on a daily basis, there is a likelihood of increased
demandforfootrepairandcomfortingproducts.

However,furthergrowthofthemarketerinthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryisoffsetby
itslimitedpenetrationwithinthesuncareproductsandhandandbodylotionscategories.

Sales of Mercks brands in the cosmetics andtoiletries market are projected to grow at a
CAGRof3.4%,toreach$247millionin2017,upfrom$209millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A280

Merck

Table5152:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthof
CosmeticsandToiletriesforMerckbyCategory,2012
to2017
Category

CAGR,%

Suncareproducts

3.6

COMPANYAVERAGE

3.4

Handandbodylotions

1.2

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5281

5282

Merck

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A282

PROCTER&GAMBLE

Table5153:Procter&GamblesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

SHAMPOOS

2012

Head&Shoulders

244

266

PanteneProVr

259

255

HerbalEssencesr

130

132

Aussie

46

48

Nioxin

27

29

Gillette

16

17

Fekkai

10

12

739

765

Secret

348

350

OldSpice

258

263

76

74

682

687

637

618

OralB

CrestKids

Gleem

647

628

Sebastian
Totalr
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

Gillette
Total
TOOTHPASTES
Crest

Total
FACIALTREATMENTS

Olay

593

570

DDF

31

28

SKII

10

Covergirl

633

609

Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5284

Procter&Gamble

Table5153:Procter&GamblesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

Olay

164

170

OldSpicer

104

105

Ivoryr

72

71

GilletteSeries

24

20

Safeguard

17

16

Camay

Kandoo

385

385

335

328

167

165

HerbalEssencesr

96

98

Aussie

45

48

Nioxin

27

30

Fekkai

Sebastian

351

357

142

130

ClairolNaturalInstincts

75

67

NiceNEasyColorBlendFoam

35

37

BalsamColor

FrostNTip

ClairolHydrience

ClairolLovingCare

ClairolMensChoice

ClairolTouchofSun

ClairolUltress

58

62

341

308

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

Totalr
FACEMAKEUP
Covergirl
CONDITIONERS
PanteneProVr

Totalr
HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
ClairolNiceNEasy

Allother
Total

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A284

Procter&Gamble

Table5153:Procter&GamblesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

304

290

215

204

OralB(Battery)

29

29

Crest

11

11

Total

255

244

PanteneProV

70

61

HerbalEssences

53

56

Aussie

56

55

Sebastian

35

34

Nioxin

11

13

Fekkai

227

222

212

200

EYEMAKEUP
Covergirlr
TOOTHBRUSHES
OralB

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

Total
TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS
CrestWhitestrips
MOUTHWASHES

Crest

105

110

Scope

75

76

OralB

181

187

GucciGuiltyPourHomme

40

42

OldSpice

25

25

LightBluePourHomme

23

22

TheOneForMen

23

21

TheOneSport

11

GilletteSeries

10

10

GuccibyGucci

13

10

EauLacosteBlanc

Dolce&Gabbana

Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5285

5286

Procter&Gamble

Table5153:Procter&GamblesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORMEN(Continued)

2012

LacosteEssential

VinceCamuto

LacosteEssentialSport

TheOneGentleman

GucciPourHommeII

Allother

164

175

Dolce&GabbanaLightBlue

44

43

GucciGuilty

22

15

Dolce&GabbanaTheOne

17

14

GucciGuiltyPremiere

10

FlorabyGucci

FlorabyGucciEauFraiche

Inspire

SecretBodyMists

GuccibyGucci

ByNight

GucciEnvyMe

Dolce&Gabbana

GiorgioForWomen

Joy

LacosteTouchofPink

Red

21

22

133

134

Total
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

Allother
Total
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

Covergirl
MaxFactor
Total
DENTUREPRODUCTS
Fixodentr

114

103

114

103

103

98

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A286

Procter&Gamble

Table5153:Procter&GamblesSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesinthe
UnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

82

84

TheArtofShaving

10

OldSpice

91

95

22

20

SHAVINGPRODUCTS
Gillette

Totalr
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Olay
DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES

Olay

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS

19

Textures&Tones

11

11

PanteneProV

10

Total

21

19

TheArtofShaving

GilletteComplete

Total

SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

NAILPOLISHES

Covergirl

TOTALr
5,952
5,883

rRestated.

NOTE:Allotherincludesalesofsmallerbrandsthatthecompanyowns.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Foundedin1837,Procter&Gambleisaglobalmarketleaderinconsumergoods,suchas
household products, personal care products, food and beverage products, and overthe
counter(OTC)medicines.
Its headquarters is located in Cincinnati, OH. The company celebrates a milestone in
2012withits175thanniversary.
In2012,thecompanysemployeestrengthisapproximately126,000peopleacross80
countries.
Thecompanymarketsmorethan300brandsin180countriesprimarilythroughmass
merchandisers, grocery stores, membership club stores, drug stores, and high
frequencystores.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5287

5288

Procter&Gamble

Other retail outlets where Procter & Gamble products can be found include
departmentstores,perfumeries,pharmacies,salons,andecommercesites.
Thecompanygloballycompetesin38productcategories,withanaveragepresenceof
19categoriesinanygivencountry.
IntheUnitedStates,thecompanycompetesinmorethan35categories.

Procter& Gambles organizational structure comprises its Global Business Units (GBUs),
GlobalOperations,GlobalBusinessServices(GBS),andCorporateFunctions(CF).
The companys GBU is divided into five segments: Beauty, Grooming, Health Care,
FabricCareandHomeCare,andBabyCareandFamilyCare.
The companys Beauty segment comprises antiperspirant and deodorant, cosmetics,
haircare,haircolor,personalcleansing,prestigeproducts,salonprofessional,andskin
care.
The Grooming segment includes blades and razors, electronic hair removal devices,
haircareappliances,andpreandpostshaveproducts.
Procter & Gambles Health Care segment comprises feminine care, gastrointestinal,
incontinence, rapid diagnostics, respiratory, toothbrush, toothpaste, other oral care,
otherpersonalhealthcare,vitamins/minerals/supplements.
TheFabricCareandHomeCaresegmentcomprisesbleachandlaundryadditives,air
care,batteries,dishcare,fabricenhancers,laundrydetergents,petcare,professional,
andsurfacecare.
TheBabyCareandFamilyCaresegmentincludesbabywipes,diapersandpants,paper
towels,tissues,andtoiletpapercategories.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Thecompanyssalesincrease3.2%from$81,104millionin2011to$83,680millionin2012.
Since2007,saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of2.9%.
The companys net earnings see a further dip in 2012, at $10,756million from
$11,797millionin2011.

Table5154:Procter&GamblesGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million
Yeara

Change,%

Netprofits

2007r

71,095

10,340

14.5

15.4

2008r

77,714

12,075

15.5

17.3

2009r

75,295

13,436

17.8

21.2

2010r

77,567

12,736

16.4

20.7

2011r

81,104

11,797

14.5

17.3

10,756

12.9

16.8

2012
83,680

aFiscalyearendingJune30.
rRestatednetsales.

Sales

Profitmargin

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A288

Returnonequity

Procter&Gamble

Table5155:Procter&GamblesSalesbyGlobal
BusinessUnit,2011and2012

%Oftotalsales

Segment

2011

2012

HouseholdCare

67.0

51.0

Beauty&Grooming

33.0

49.0

100.0

100.0

Total

Table5156:Procter&GamblesSalesbyBusinessSegment,2011and2012

$Million

Segment

2011

2012

FabricandHomeCare

26,536

27,254

BabyandFamilyCare

15,606

16,493

Total

45,298

43,747

19,937

20,318

8,245

8,339

HealthCare

12,033

12,421

Total

40,215

41,078

CORPORATE

(1,255)

(1,255)

TOTAL

81,104

83,680

HOUSEHOLDCARE

BEAUTY&GROOMING
Beauty
Grooming

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Procter & Gambles cosmetics and toiletries sales in the U.S. market have declined to
$5,883millionin2012,down1.2%from$5,952millionin2011.
SaleshaveexperiencedaCAGRof1.6%since2007.

Table5157:Procter&GamblesCosmetics&Toiletries
Sales,2007to2012
Yearr

$Million

Change,%

2007

5,428

2008

5,592

3.0

2009

5,617

0.4

2010

5,809

3.4

2011

5,952

2.5

2012

5,883

(1.2)

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5289

5290

Procter&Gamble

Procter&GambleremainstheclearleaderintheU.S.personalcaremarket.Both,through
acquisitionandorganicgrowth,thisleadershiphassolidifiedoverthelastdecade.
However,2012provestobeoneofitsmostchallengingyears,asProcter&Gamble's
categoryleading brands have lost their footing in several categories including
shampoos,toothpastes,andcolorcosmetics.
ThereareanumberoffactorscausingProcter&Gambletolosegroundtoitsmajor
competitorsintheUnitedStates.Themainreasonappearstobethecompanys$10
billion cost saving plan announced in February 2012 which has left some of its
brands lacking necessary marketing support, particularly in light of its competitors
increasingtheirownpromotionalactivities.
Furthermore, Procter & Gambles cost cutting on R&D has affected its rate of new
productintroductionsandabilitytokeepupwiththerapidlychangingmarketplace.

ShampooscontinuetobethelargestcategoryforProcter&Gamblein2012.Itisalsothe
leadingmarketerintheshampooscategoryin2012.
Salesofthemarketergrow3.5%in2012from$739millionin2011to$765millionin
2012.
Procter&Gamblehasa29.2%marketshareoftheoverallcategoryssalesin2012.
The company markets eight brands in the category, including the top two brands
PanteneProVandHead&Shoulders.
Head&Shouldersbecomesthecategoryleaderin2012,displacingPanteneProV.
Head&Shoulderssalesgrow9.0%,from$244millionin2011to$266millionin2012.
Thebrandsgrowthisdrivenbyimprovedmarketingandpromotionalactivitiesinthe
category.Furthermore,until2012therewasalackofseriouscontendersinasegment
that has high demand. Many men and women suffer from dandruff and Head &
Shoulders,asaunisexbrand,solvesthisspecificproblem.
Procter & Gamble launches various campaigns to support the sales of its Head &
Shouldersbrandinthecategory.ThemarketersignssoccerplayerLionelMessiasits
spokespersontopromoteitsHead&Shouldersbrand.
Consumers seek products which provide further functional benefits as compared to
regularshampoos,contributingtoHead&Shouldersgrowth.
PanteneProV,thesecondleadingbrandinthecategory,hasacategoryshareof9.7%
in2012,downfrom10.4%in2011.
Sales for the brand decline by $4million to $255million in 2012, down from
$259millionin2011.
Pantene ProV has limited new product activity in 2012 compared to 2011, when
Procter&GambleaddedanumberofproductstothePanteneProVline.Thebrand
alsosuffersfromlackofdifferentiation.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A290

Procter&Gamble

DeodorantsandantiperspirantsisthesecondlargestsalesgeneratingcategoryforProcter
&Gamble.
The marketer is the secondleading marketer in the category in 2012. Procter &
Gambleexperiencesmarginalgrowthof0.7%toreach$687millionin2012,upfrom
$682millionin2012.
Thecompanysshareinthecategoryfallsfrom34.1%in2011to33.7%in2012.
Procter & Gamble is present in the category with its Secret, Old Spice, and Gillette
brands.
Secret continues to be the leading brand for the marketer in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategoryin2012.Manufacturerssalesofthebrandareupmarginally
by0.6%tototal$350millionin2012,upfrom$348millionin2011.Secretscategory
share declines marginally by 20 basis points to 17.2% in 2012, from 17.4% of total
categorysalesin2011.
Procter&Gamblestraceablemediaexpenditure(TME)supportfortheSecretbrand
increases4.5%from$39.9millionin2011to$41.7millionin2012,withSecretClinical
Strength and Secret Outlast being allocated the most TME at $18.8million and
$22.5million, respectively. In 2012, the marketer introduces the Secret Outlast in
Invisible Solid, Clear Gel, and Smooth Solid variants. To promote the Secret Outlast
Collection, Procter & Gamble partners with Jenni Pulos, a television personality and
actress, to help consumers conquer their hectic work schedules while the product
providesthemwith48hourodorprotection.
Old Spice, the marketers secondleading brand in the category, posts sales of
$263million in 2012, up 1.9% from $258million in 2011. Old Spice, a malecentric
brand, has changed its approach and targets men of all age groups, as the brand
previously targeted only older men, thereby improving its brand image. The brand
benefitsfromitsloyalconsumerbaseasaresultofitslongpresenceinthecategory.
In2012,thebrandhasanotherviralhitwithitsMuscleMusicPlayervideofeaturing
former NFL player Terry Crews who controls a variety of instruments simultaneously
byflexinghisforearms,biceps,abs,deltoids,andquads.Theadvertisementactsasa
musicmaker game, involving interaction with consumers who have the ability to
controlCrewsbodyandinstruments.Oncethevideofinishes,usershavetheoptionof
recording it. The brands video on the YouTube channel is an instant hit during its
initiallaunchandcontinuestogainalotofhitsonYouTube.
AnothermarketingcampaignofOldSpicefeaturesNFLstarGregJenningspromoting
theChampionDeodorantinaseriesofsevencommercialsthatgoliveduringtheNFL
2012season.
SalesforGillettedecline2.6%to$74millionin2012,downfrom$76millionin2011.
ThecategoryshareofGillettedeodorantsdeclines0.2%from3.8%in2011to3.6%in
2012.Gillettessalesdeclinearearesultofthelackofnewnessfromthebrandwith
respecttoproducts,changeinformulations,orpackagingchanges.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5291

5292

Procter&Gamble

Toothpastes is the thirdleading category for Procter& Gamble in the U.S. cosmetics and
toiletriesindustryin2012.
Procter & Gamble experiences sales decline of 2.9% from $647million in 2011 to
$628millionin2012andthemarketerslidestothesecondpositioninthetoothpastes
category.
The companys market share slides from 37.6% in 2011 to 35.9% in 2012. Although
Crest retains its top ranking in the category, Colgate erodes its share aided by the
successofColgate360OpticWhiteandColgate360SensitiveProRelief
SalesofCrest,thecompanyslargestmasterbrandinthecategory,declineby3.0%to
$618millionin2012from$637millionin2011.
Thebrandssalesdeclineisinlinewiththedecreaseinthemarketingandadvertising
supportin2012.
The marketer decreases the marketing support for the Crest brand significantly, by
50.4%from$143.9millionin2011to$71.4millionin2012.
Increase in the prices of Procter & Gambles products in 2012 is also a factor
contributingtosalesdeclineinthecategory.
Decreaseincouponingactivitybythemarketerin2012alsolimitsthegrowthofthe
companystoothpastebrands.
Limitednewproductactivityalsolimitsthegrowthofthemarketerin2012.
However, some of the key launches in 2012 by Procter & Gamble include Crest Pro
Health Clinical Plaque Control toothpaste and Crest 3D White Glamorous White
toothpaste.

Thefourthleadingcategoryforthemarketerin2012isfacialtreatments.
Procter& Gambles Olay remains the largest mass brand in the facial treatments
category,accountingforslightlyoveronequarteroftradeclasssales.
Thebrandssalesdecline3.9%atthemanufacturerslevel,from$593millionin2011
to$570millionin2012.Thebrandalsodeclinedin2010.
A number of factors contribute to Olays soft sales during 2012, including increased
competitionatmultiplepricepoints,extensivemarketingcampaignsfromcompeting
brands,consumerstradinguptoluxuryproducts,massprivatelabelsthatmimicmany
ofOlaysproductlines,andachangeinretailerplanograms.
Thebrandhaslostouttonewerinnovationsbycompetitors,suchasLOralandEste
Lauder.
While most of the prestige brands, such as Clinique and Este Lauder, launch BB
creams,withmanymassbrandsfollowing,Olaydidnottakeadvantageofthismajor
trend of hybrid makeup/skin care creams until late 2012, when it launches a color
correction(CC)cream.
Olay takes some major steps to become more innovative in late 2012 with the
reformulationofitsRegeneristlinetoofferfasterandmorevisibleresults.
The ProX franchise suffers as the price points for this mass line are comparable to
someentrylevelluxurybrands.Infact,theProXlineisthefirstmasslinetobreakthe
$25.00pricebarrier,andopenupthedoorforothermassbrandstotryaswell.The
ProXlineisextendedwithaSpotFightingTreatmenttoreducedarkspotsandeven
outskintone.
During 2012, the company works to develop a new line that launches in early 2013
gearedforyoungerconsumers,andwithlowerpricepoints,calledOlayFreshEffects.
Procter & Gamble is one of the largest personal care advertisers and invests
$125.3million supporting the Olay brand during 2012, down from $197.3million in
2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A292

Procter&Gamble

In 2012, sales of Procter & Gamble in the personal cleansing products category remain
stableat$385millionin2012,flatfrom2011levels.
The marketer is present in the category with its Olay, Old Spice, Ivory, Gillette,
Safeguard,Camay,andKandoobrands.
Body washes is the largest segment for the marketer in 2012, and is the second
leadingmarketerinthebodywashessegment,accountingfor18.5%ofthesegments
salesin2012.Themarketerssalesinthesegmenttotal$251millionin2012,up3.3%
from$243millionin2011.
Procter&Gambleisthethirdlargestmarketerinthebarsoapssegment,representing
33.5% of the marketers sales in 2012, down from 35.1% in 2011. The decline in the
marketers share in the segment is due to the poor performance of Olay, Ivory, and
Safeguard.
The marketers decline in sales in the bar soaps segment is because TME declines
approximately 70.0% from $114.1million in 2011, to $40.0million in 2012. The
marketer experiences a considerable decline in sales for its Old Spice and Gillette
brands.

Procter&Gambleisthethirdleadingmarketerinthefacemakeupcategory,withsalesat
$328millionin2012,down2.1%from$335millionin2011.
Procter&GamblecompetesinthemasstradeclasswithitsCovergirlbrandandwith
itsDolce&Gabbanalinewithintheluxurytradeclass.Dolce&Gabbanassalesarenot
itemizedinthisreport.
Covergirls category share declines slightly from 11.9% in 2011 to 11.3% of sales in
2012,assalesdeclineacrossallproductcategoriesexceptpowder,whichisfueledbya
newproduct,Covergirl&OlayPressedPowder.
Covergirl suffers territory encroachment from competitive new launches including
LOralsTrueMatchSuperBlendableMakeup,RevlonsPhotoreadyAirbrushmousse
makeup,andMaybellinesDreamNudeAirfoammakeup.
Despite having an impressive cast of megastar spokesmodels including Taylor Swift
and Pink, Covergirl simply does not have comparable new product launches to
promote in 2012. However, the company appears to be rectifying the situation with
newproductsalreadylinedupfor2013.
In 2012, Procter & Gamble decreases its advertising budget by 8% down to
$87.1million.Approximately68%ofTMEisusedtopromoteCovergirlandOlaySimply
AgelessandToneRehab2in1foundationproducts.CovergirlsCleanMakeupandTru
Blendfoundationissupportedbycloseto$24millioninadvertising.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5293

5294

Procter&Gamble

In 2012, Procter & Gamble is the secondleading marketer in the conditioners category,
withashareof21.6%inthecategoryssales.
Salesforthecompanygrow1.7%,upfrom$351millionin2011to$357millionin2012.
PanteneProVmaintainsitspositionasthetopbrandinthecategory,withashareof
10.0%.Salesforthebranddecline1.2%,from$167millionin2011to$165millionin
2012.
Limitednewproductactivity,lackofdifferentiation,andlimitedpromotionalactivities
contributetothebrandssalesdeclinein2012.
The only significant launches under the Pantene ProV brand in 2012 are Advanced
KeratinconditionerandAgeDefyconditioner.
HerbalEssences,thesecondlargestbrandforProcter&Gamble,hasacategoryshare
of5.9%in2012.
It is the fifthlargest brand in the category. Sales for the brand are up 2.1% from
$96millionin2011to$98millionin2012.
New product activity from Herbal Essences contributes to the brands growth in the
category.Thecompanylaunchesarangeofnaturalpositionedconditionersincluding
HoneyImStrongconditionerandLongTermRelationshipundertheHerbalEssences
brand.
SalesforAussiegrow6.7%from$45millionin2011to$48millionin2012.
Improvedpromotionalactivities,suchasinstoremarketing,contributetothebrands
growthinthecategory.
Intheprofessionaltradeclass,Procter&Gamblehasasegmentshareof2.0%in2012;
SebastianistheonlybrandmarketedbyProcter&Gambleintheprofessionalsegment.
Sales for Sebastian decline by $1million to $7million in 2012. The brand has been
strugglingtoregainitsedgeasatrendybrand.

Sales of Procter & Gamble, the secondleading marketer in the hair coloring products
category,declineto$308millionin2012,down9.7%from$341millionin2011.
Procter&Gamblesoverallsharein the categorys sales drop from 25.8% in 2011 to
23.4%in2012,duetothedeclineinthesalesofClairolNiceNEasyandClairolNatural
Instinctslines.
Limitednewproductactivityalsocontributestothemarketersdeclineinthecategory.
Salesdeclineforthemarketerinthecategorycanalsobeattributedtothesignificant
decreaseinthemarketingactivity.Procter&GamblesTMEforhaircoloringproducts
declines significantly by 32.2% in 2012, down from $82.3million in 2011 to
$55.7millionin2012.
ClairolNiceNEasyColorBlendFoamistheonlybrandtoexperiencegrowthin2012;
thebrandgrowsby5.7%,from$35millionin2011to$37millionin2012.
Thesuccessoffoambasedcolorantssupportsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
ThesalesofthebrandarealsosupportedbyaTMEofalmost$21millionin2012.
NiceNEasydrops8.5%whileNaturalInstinctsdeclinesby10.7%to$130millionand
$67million,respectively,in2012.
Balsam Color manages to maintain its sales at $6million in 2012, for the second
consecutiveyear.
FrostNTipssalesdeclineby14.3%,from$7millionin2011to$6millionin2012.
Themarketerdiscontinuesseveralproductsin2011,contributingtothesalesdecline
in2012.
Some of the brands that were discontinued by the marketer in 2011 include Loving
Care,ClairolHydrience,ClairolMen'sChoice,ClairolTouchofSun,andClairolUltress,
amongothers.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A294

Procter&Gamble

Procter & Gamble moves down to the third position in the eye makeup category as sales
slidedown4.6%in2012to$290millionfrom$304millionin2011.
The marketers share of the category also declines from 11.6% in 2011 to 10.7% in
2012.
ThenewlaunchesinmascarathatincludetheLashBlastfranchiseperformwellforthe
Covergirlbrand,butsalesdonotexceedthefalloutfromtheeyeshadowandeyeliner
sales decline. The brand does not compete in the eyebrow category, which fuels
growthformanymarketersin2012.
Procter & Gamble is the secondleading advertiser in the category with TME of
$74.2millionin2012,down27%from$101.6millionin2011.TwothirdsoftheTME
supportthebrandsmascaraproducts.

In 2012, Procter& Gamble continues to be the largest marketer in the toothbrushes


category,representingalmostonethirdofthecategorystotalsales.
However,thecompanysmarketsharedropsfrom35.2%in2011to32.9%in2012,as
overallsalesdecreaseby4.3%,from$255millionin2011to$244millionin2012.
Sales growth is offset with the decline in its leading brand OralB. The brands sales
declineduetodecreaseinmarketingactivity,suchasdiscountsandcouponsin2012.
Increasing competition from ColgatePalmolive in the toothbrushes category also
hampersthegrowthforProcter&Gamblein2012.
Procter&Gamble,wellknownforitsproductinnovations,investslessinR&Dandnew
productactivityin2012,limitingthemarketerssuccessinthecategory.
OralB continues to be the largest brand in this category with a decrease in market
sharefrom33.7%in2011to31.4%in2012.
Thedeclineisdrivenbymanualtoothbrushes,whichdecline5.1%from$215millionin
2011 to $204million in 2012. Battery toothbrushes, a much smaller segment, see
stablesalesat$29millioneachin2011and2012.
Limited new product introductions and marketing activities, such as discounts and
coupons,restrictthegrowthoftheOralBmanualtoothbrushesin2012.
Increaseinpricepointsoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.

Procter&Gamblecontinuesretainthethirdpositioninthehairstylingproductscategory.
Salesofthemarketerdecrease2.2%to$222millionin2012from$227millionin2011.
Limited new product activity and a decrease in the marketing and promotional
activitiescontributetothesalesdeclineforthemarketerinthecategory.
Procter&GambledecreasesitsTMEsignificantlyby50.0%,from$55.4millionin2011
to$27.7millionin2012.
PanteneProV,thelargestbrandofthemarketerinthecategory,remainsthethird
leadingbrandinthemasstradeclass.Salesofthebranddeclineto$61millionin2012,
down 12.9% from $70million in 2011. Limited new product activity and substantial
decrease in promotional activities offset the brands growth in 2012. The marketer
significantly decreases its TME support for the Pantene ProV brand in 2012, from
$34.6millionin2011to$10.1millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5295

5296

Procter&Gamble

SalesofHerbalEssencesgrowby5.7%to$56millionin2012,upfrom$53millionin
2011. Increased promotional and marketing activity supports the brands growth in
2012.Procter&Gamblesupportsthebrandwithapproximately$6.8millioninTMEin
2012,upfrom$0.5millionin2011.
SalesofProcter&GamblesAussiedeclineby$1millionto$55millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble is present in the professional trade class with its Sebastian and
Nioxinbrands.In2012,themarketeroccupies9.4%oftheprofessionaltradeclass,up
from9.2%in2011.Sebastianisthesixthleadingbrandintheprofessionaltradeclass
with sales at $34million, down 2.9% from $35million in 2011. Procter & Gambles
other professional brand, Nioxin experiences growth in 2012. The brand grows by
18.2%from$11millionin2011to$13millionin2012.

Procter&Gambleremainstheleaderinthetoothwhiteningproductscategory,withaslight
decreaseinitsmarketsharefrom73.9%in2011to73.8%in2012.
Collective sales for the marketer decline by 5.7%, from $212million in 2011 to
$200millionin2012.
Crestcontinuestobethemainbrandthecompanymarketsinthecategory.
DespiteanincreaseinTMEin2012,Procter&Gambleexperiencessalesdeclinedueto
limitednewproductactivity.
Higher price points compared to its competitors also results in sales decline for the
marketerinthecategory.
In 2012, Procter & Gamble introduces Crest 3D White Glamorous White toothpaste
andCrest3DWhiteIntensiveProfessionalEffectsWhitestrips.

Procter & Gamble is the secondlargest marketer in the mouthwashes category with a
23.4%share,upfrom23.1%in2011.
Crest,thesecondlargestbrandinthecategory,experiencessalesincreaseof4.8%in
2012withtheintroductionoftwonewproducts:CrestProHealthClinicalAntiPlaque
RinseandScopeOutlastmouthwash.
Crestsmarketshareincreasesfrom13.4%in2011to13.8%in2012.
ThenewCrest3DWhiteningrangeincludesArcticFreshRinseandGlamorousWhite
Rinse that help boost brand sales. Also, the cross marketing with the OralB
toothbrusheshelpsbroadenawarenessanddemandforthebrand.
Scopes sales increase 1.3% in 2012, benefiting from new branding and packaging in
2012,withsalesreaching$76millionin2012from$75millionin2011.
ScopeOutlastmouthwash,introducedin2012,booststhebrandssaleswithitsstrong
performance.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A296

Procter&Gamble

Procter& Gamble is the thirdleading marketer in the fragrances for men category, with
salesincreasing6.7%,whichisahighergrowthratethanLOralorCoty.
Salesgrowfrom$164millionin2011to$175millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble owes its fragrance success to its two highend European fashion
houselicensesDolce&GabbanaandGucciincontrasttobothLOralandCotythat
alignwithmidtierfashionbrandsandcelebrities.
GucciGuiltyPourHommeisthethirdleadingmensfragrance,andcontinuestogrow,
up5%to$42millionin2012.
Dolce&GabbanastopscentsLightBluePourHommeisinfifthplace,whileTheOne
dropstoseventhplace,duetothelaunchofTheOneSportwhichobtains$11million
insalesinjustafewmonths.
In2012,Procter&GamblelaunchesitsfirstscentwithdesignerVinceCamuto.
The company also competes in the mass market with its lower end, but long
establishedOldSpice,theleadingmassbrand,andtheGilletteSeries,bothofwhich
are more aligned to shaving than fine fragrances, and both of which have a loyal
customerbase.

SalesofProcter&Gambleslidedowntomakeitthefifthleadingmarketerinthelipsticks
andlipglossescategory,withsalesof$103millionin2012,down9.6%from$114millionin
2011.
Themarketeraccountsfor7.5%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,downfrom8.4%
in2011.
TheCovergirlbrand,thesecondleadingbrandinthecategory,istheonlybrandthat
Procter&GamblehasintheU.S.massmakeupmarket.
Manufacturers sales are estimated at $103million in 2012, down 9.6% from
$114millionin2011.
Covergirl competes in the lipsticks and lip glosses segments. The brand sees a large
dropinsalesamongitslipglossproducts.
Procter & Gamble is the secondlargest advertiser in the category, supporting its
Covergirl brand with $55million in 2012, down from $78.5million in TME in 2011.
Television advertising represents about 37% of the brands TME. The remainder is
spentonprintadvertising.

Inthedentureproductscategory,Procter&Gamblessalesdropby$5millionto$98million
in2012.
FixodentistheonlybrandmarketedbyProcter&Gambleinthecategory.
Thecompanystotalmarketsharedecreasesslightlyto30.8%in2012,from32.8%in
2011.
Procter& Gamble decreases its advertising and promotional support for its Fixodent
brandin2012,leadingtothesalesdecline.
Lack of new product activity also offsets the growth of the brand in the category in
2012.
Fixodent,thetopbrandinthedentureadhesivessegment,dropsby4.9%in2012to
$98million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5297

5298

Procter&Gamble

Procter& Gamble continues to be the secondleading marketer in the shaving products


categoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalesreach$95millionin2012,up4.4%from$91millionin2011.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesto25.5%in2012,upfrom25.1%in2011dueto
therapidlyexpandingTheArtofShavingbrand.
Procter&Gamblesleadingbrand,Gilletteexperiencesa2.4%growthfrom$82million
in2011to$84millionin2012.
In early 2012, the marketer introduces the Gillette Fusion ProGlide Clear Shave Gel.
Furthergrowthforthebrandisoffsetbyincreasingcompetitionfromotherbrandsin
themarketincludingSchick,Edge,andNiveaforMen.
Themarketerssecondleadingbrand,TheArtofShaving,witnessesagrowthof25.0%
to$10millionin2012,upfrom$8millionin2011.
SinceProcter&GamblesacquisitionofTheArtofShaving brandin2009,thebrand
hasbeenthefastestgrowingbrandforProcter&Gambleinthebeautyandgrooming
division.Thebrandsretailpresence,whichwasonceconfinedtodepartmentstores,
witnesses growing retail expansion to standalone stores, mass merchandisers, and
selectsalonsafteritsacquisitionbyProcter&Gamble.
Also, the number of The Art of Shaving stores has more than doubled since its
acquisitionwithmoststoreshavingabarbershopinsidethemtopampermenwitha
traditional shaving experience. The brand has its own retail stores in about 80
locationsacrosstheUnitedStates.
SalesofOldSpice,themarketersthirdbrandinthecategory,remainat$1millionin
2012,flatfrom2011levels.

Procter&GamblesOlayrecordsanenormousgrowthof375.0%inthedepilatories,waxes,
andbleachescategoryin2012.
Manufacturerssalesforthebrandadvancefrom$4millionin2011to$19millionin
2012.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfromamere2.8%in2011to11.7%in2012.
Olays offering in the depilatories, waxes, and bleaches category consists of a single
product, the Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal Duo. Currently, the Smooth Finish
FacialHairRemovalDuoisavailableintwovariants:oneforfinetomediumhairand
theotherformediumtocoarsehair.
TheSmoothFinishFacialHairRemovalDuoforMediumtoCoarseHairislaunchedin
2012 after the successof the initial launch of the Smooth Finish Facial Hair Removal
DuoforFinetoMediumHairin2011.
SalesforOlaybenefitfromastrongdistributionmodelanditsproductsareavailable
acrossallmajorretailmasschannels,suchasWalmart,Walgreens,andCVS/Pharmacy.
The brand has a higher price point than competing products, because of the trusted
Olayname.Thisalsocontributestothesteepdollarincreaseinsales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A298

Procter&Gamble

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

In August 2012, Procter & Gamble files a complaint with the NAD (National Advertising
Division) in the United States against ColgatePalmolive regarding the usage of certain
claims for its Optic White range of oral care products. The NAD has ordered Colgate
Palmolive to stop advertising some claims for its whitening toothpastes including same
whiteningingredientasstrips.
Also in 2012, NAD states that Procter & Gamble uses Photoshop to digitally retouch
theimagesusedinitsprintadvertisementsandmakingsuperiorperformanceclaims
foritsproducts.

Mergers,acquisitions,anddivestures

InFebruary2012,thecompanyannouncesits$10billionproductivityandcostssavingplan
todecreasecostsinareassuchassupplychain,researchanddevelopment,marketing,and
overheadexpenses.

InMarch2012,Procter&GambleacquiresNewChapterInc.foranundisclosedsum.
NewChapterisaTexasbasedvitaminandsupplementcompany.

In May 2012, Procter& Gamble divests its snacks business to The Kellogg Company for
$2.7billion in an allcash transaction. The Kellogg Company is a multinational food
manufacturingcompanybasedinBattleCreek,MI.
As a result of this change, the Pet Care business is now included in the Fabric and
HomeCaresegment.
ThedivestituremarksProcter&Gamblesexitfromthefoodandbeveragebusiness.

Managementchanges

Therearenomanagementchangesin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5299

5300

Procter&Gamble

NOTABLENEWPRODUCTS

Table5158:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyProcter&GambleintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Covergirl

Facemakeup

Covergirl&OlayPressedPowder

Covergirl

Lipsticksandlip
glosses

BlastFlipstickBlendableLipDuo

Covergirl

Nailpolishes

CovergirlOutlastStayBrilliantNailGloss

Crest

Toothpastes

CrestProHealthClinicalPlaqueControltoothpastehasaformula
thatprotectsteethagainstplaque,gingivitis,cavities,andtooth
sensitivity.Thistriclosanfreetoothpastealsohelpswhitenteeth
andpreventsplaquefromreoccurring

Crest

Toothpastes

CrestCompleteMultiBenefitExtraWhite+ScopeOutlastLasting
Minttoothpastewhitensteethbyremovingsurfacestainsand
helpsprotectagainstcavitiesandtartars

Crest

Toothpastes

Crest3DWhiteAdvancedVividEnamelRenewaltoothpaste,an
anticavitytoothpastewithsodiumfluorideasitsactive
ingredient.Theproductisforpeopleagedoversixyears

Crest

Toothpastes

CrestProHealthClinicalGumProtectionInvigoratingCleanMint
toothpaste,ifusedformorethanfourweekshelpsreverse
gingivitisandimprovegumhealth.Italsoprotectsfromteeth
sensitivity,cavities,plaque,andbadbreath

Crest

Toothpastes

TheCrest3DWhiteGlamorousWhitetoothpasteismadewitha
formulathatremovessurfacestainsandsurroundsteethwith
teethwhiteningagentstobrightenthem

Crest

Toothwhitening
products

Crest3DWhiteIntensiveProfessionalEffectsWhitestripsusesa
shinetechnologythatclaimstoremoveupto90%ofsurface
stainsinfivedays

Mouthwashes

Crest3DWhiteArcticFreshIcyCoolMintOralRinseisinfused
withatripleactionformulathatwhitensteethbyremoving
surfacestains,helpsprotectagainsttheformationofnewstains,
andfreshensbreath

Mouthwashes

CrestProHealthClinicalAntiplaquerinse,offersprotectionfrom
plaqueandgingivitis,clinicallyproventoreduceplaqueandhelp
preventplaqueregrowth,andclinicallyproventohelpprevent
andreversegingivitis

Fragrancesformen

TheOnefranchiseisextendedwithTheOneSport,thethird
fragranceintheline.Thisislighterandfresherthantheother
scentsinthefranchiseandopenswithaquaticnotesand
rosemaryalongwithcardamomandsequoiawood

Crest

Crest

Dolce&Gabbana

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A300

Procter&Gamble

Table5158:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyProcter&GambleintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Gillette

Personalcleansing
products

OdorShieldAllDayCleanBodyWashisformulatedtofightodor
andwetnessinadditiontothebasiccleansingfunction

Gillette

Shavingproducts

FusionProGlideClearShaveGelisanonfoamingshavegelwitha
masculinefragrance

Gucci

Fragrancesfor
women

GucciPremiereissaidtobeinspiredbygownsfromtheGucci
Premierecouturecollectionwithtopnotesofbergamotand
orangeblossom

Head&Shoulders

Conditioners

DamageRescueconditionernourishesdamagedhairandrelieves
dryscalpbylockinginmoisturetherebymaintainingahealthy
moisturebarrier

Head&Shoulders

Shampoos

DamageRescueDandruffshampoonourishesdamagedhairand
helpsrelievedryscalp

Head&Shoulders

Shampoos

TheClinicalStrengthAntidandruffshampoohelpsprevent
itching,scaling,irritation,andrednessassociatedwithseborrheic
dermatitisanddandruff

HerbalEssences

Shampoos

TheHoneyImStrongshampooisinfusedwithhoney

Olay

Depilatories,waxes,
andbleaches

SmoothFinishFacialHairRemovalDuoMediumtoCoarseHairis
agentletwostepsystemthatremovesunwantedfacialhair,the
skinguardingbalmactsasaprotectivebarrieragainstthedirect
contactofthehairremovalcream,whilethecreamremoves
unwantedhair

Olay

Facialtreatments

ProXSpotFightingTreatmentissaidtoreducethelookofdark
spotswithhydrationtoimproveoverallskinforamoreeventone
andmicroexfoliationtoremovedullnessforbrighterskin

Facialtreatments

TotalEffectsCCToneCorrectingLinetreatssevensignsofaging,
whileprovidingimmediatecolorcorrectionwithtintedformulas
thatincludeUVprotectionortonecorrectionovertime.The
multipleinstantandlongtermbenefitsclaimtoleaveskineven
tonedwiththereducedappearanceofdiscolorations,finelines,
andwrinkles

Olay

Facialtreatments

RegeneristMicroSculptingCreamReformulationclaimsto
reverse10yearsofwrinklesinfourweeks.Helpsaccelerateskin
turnover

OralB

Toothbrushes

OralBextendsitsProHealthforMelinewithaSensitiveClean
rechargeablepowertoothbrushthatprovidesagentlebrushing
experiencetokids

OralB

Toothbrushes

OralBadvantagePlustoothbrush,withouterangledbristlesthat
massage,stimulate,andcleansgumlineeffectivelyforwhiter
teeth

Pantene

Ethnichaircare
products

TrulyNaturalshampooprovidesmoisture,shine,andhealthto
eachhairstrand

Olay

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5301

5302

Procter&Gamble

Table5158:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyProcter&GambleintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Pantene

Ethnichaircare
products

TrulyNaturalconditioneraddsmoistureandhealthtoeachhair
strand

Pantene

Ethnichaircare
products

TrulyNaturalShineSerumaddsmoisturetohairanditskey
ingredientarganoiladdslonglastingshine

PanteneProV

Conditioners

PanteneProV

Conditioners

PanteneProV

Conditioners

PanteneProV

Shampoos

PanteneProV

Shampoos

PanteneProV

Shampoos

Scope

Mouthwashes

Secret

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

VinceCamuto

Fragrancesformen

PanteneAdvancedandKeratinRepairconditionerfeatures
advancedtechnologytohelprestoresmoothnesstoextremely
damagedhair,whilepreventingfurtherdamage
ProVMoistureRenewalconditionerisspeciallyformulatedto
nurturethehairslipidlayerensuringmaximummoisture
retentioninanaturalandhealthyway
ProVBeautifulLengthsconditionerfortifieshairagainstdamage
thatleadstobreakage,therebyincreasingthelengthofeachhair
strand
PanteneAdvancedandKeratinRepairshampoofeatureadvanced
technologytohelprestoresmoothnessofextremelydamaged
hair,whilepreventingfurtherdamageatthekeratinlevel
TheDailyMoistureRenewalshampoocleansandprovidesanall
daymoisturizationtothehair
PanteneAgeDefyshampooclaimstohelphairactupto10years
youngerbythickeningexistinghairstrands
Outlastmouthwashinfusedwithoutlasttechnologythatbinds
tightlytoselectreceptorsinthemouth,creatingacool,refreshing
sensationthatlastslonger
SecretOutlastwithDualActionOdorTechnologyprovides
freshnessthatlastsupto48hours.Italsominimizesodorcausing
bacteriaandisavailableinInvisibleSolid,ClearGel,andsmooth
Solid
Inablackbottlewiththefamilycrest,thisfragranceopenswith
Italianbergamot,mandarin,andblackpepper

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Procter&GamblesupportsitsbrandswithahugeTMEof$1,216.6millionin2012,down
17.8% from $1,489.8million in 2011. The advertising expenditure is a good mix of media
andcrosschannelpromotionalstrategies.
The majority of Procter & Gambles advertising expenditures are attributed towards
magazineadvertisements,accountingfor50.8%ofthemarketerstotalTMEin2012.
Televisionadvertisementsrepresent42.0%ofthecompanystotalmediasupport.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A302

Procter&Gamble

Procter&Gambleutilizesdifferentmarketingmediatopromoteitsproductsforitsvarious
portfoliosofbrands.
The company continues to engage celebrities to endorse its brands and line of
products for print and television advertisements. The celebrities engaged by the
marketerincludepopularfilmandtelevisionpersonalities,models,andsportspersons
andathletes.
Increasingly,themarketerisutilizingnontraditionalmediasuchastheInternet,social
media sites, and mobile phones to advertise its product lines. Such media is used in
addition to the traditional advertising in order to reach out to a wider section of
consumers.

In2012,Procter&GamblesTMEinthehaircareproductclassamountsto$242.3million.
Procter&GamblesTMEintheshampooscategoryfor2012is$156.3million,downby
0.5%,from$157.1millionin2011.
ThePanteneProVbrandgarners$82.2millionoftheTMEin2012.ThePanteneProV
MoistureRenewallineisallocatedaTMEof$33.5millionin2012.
TheantidandruffbrandHead&Shouldersgarners$60.2millionoftheTME.
Procter&Gamblesmediaspendonthehaircoloringcategoryin2012is$55.7million,
downsignificantlyby32.2%from$82.3millionin2011.
The company spends approximately 59.6%, or $33.2million, on television
advertisementsfollowedbymagazineadvertisementswith$21.7million.
NiceNEasyhairfoamgarnersalionsshareoftheTMEat$20.4million.
TheClairolNaturalInstinctslineissupportedwith$13.0million.
Procter&Gambleisthethirdleadingadvertiserinthehairstylingproductsandsprays
category. The marketer drops its TME significantly by 50.0%, from $55.4million in
2011to$27.7millionin2012.
Procter & Gamble allocates $13.7million or 49.4% of its TME through television
advertisements, followed by $11.7million or 42.2% of its TME through magazine
advertisements.
PanteneProVlinereceivesatotalTMEsupportofapproximately$10.1millionin2012,
spreadprimarilyacrosstelevisionandmagazineadvertising.TheTMEsupportforthe
branddecreasesby70.8%in2012from$34.6millionin2011.
Procter&Gamblespends$53.7millionpromotingitsCresttoothwhiteningproducts
during2012,reboundingfromaTMEof$40.2millionin2011,andremainsbyfarthe
topadvertiserinthetoothwhiteningcategory.
Procter& Gamble, thesecondleading marketer in the conditioners category, spends
$2.6millionin2012,adeclineby51.9%from$5.4millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5303

5304

Procter&Gamble

Procter&GamblesTMEintheoralcareproductclassamountsto$185.8millionin2012.
ThemarketerdecreasesitsTMEsignificantlyby39.5%from$143.9millionin2011to
$87.0millioninthetoothpastescategoryin2012.
Procter & Gamble also decreases its couponing and discounting activity in 2012. For
example, in 2011, Procter & Gamble offered coupons worth $3.00, but in 2012 the
marketerofferscouponsworth$1.00only,andforaverylimitedperiod.
Procter& Gamble spends $53.7million to promote Crest tooth whitening products
during2012,reboundingfromaTMEof$40.2millionin2011,andremainsbyfarthe
topadvertiserinthetoothwhiteningcategory.
Procter & Gamble is the secondlargest advertiser for mouthwashes, spending
$22.0millionin2012.
TMEaredividedprimarilybetweentwobrandsCrestProHealthandScopebothof
whichhavenewproductlaunchesin2012.
Procter & Gamble allocates approximately $17.2million to promote its Crest Pro
Healthbrand,andtheremaining$4.8millionisallocatedtotheScopebrand.
Advertising spend is primarily allocated to magazines and television commercials in
2012.Thecompanyallocates$18.0millionontelevisionadvertisingand$1.3millionof
itsTMEonmagazineadvertisements.
Procter&Gambleistheleadingadvertiserinthetoothbrushescategoryin2012with
$21.6millionspentinTME,upfrom$18.3millionin2011.
Approximately $21million in TME is allocated to OralB regular toothbrushes and
$0.8millioninTMEisallocatedtoOralBbatterytoothbrushes.
Procter& Gamble promotes its toothbrushes with about 54.6% of its TME on
television advertisements, followed by 38.9% on Internet promotions, and 6.0% on
magazines.
Procter& Gamble ranks third in TME in 2012, allocating $1.5million in TME to
Fixodentinthedenturesproductscategory.
Television advertisements remain the most preferred promotional method for the
marketerinthecategory.
Procter&Gambles2012advertisingspendisalmost77%lowerthanits2011TMEof
$6.5million.
Virtually all of the marketing budget is spent on television advertisements and
syndicatedpromotions.
Themarketeralsooffersdiscountcouponsof$1.00onitsFixodentbrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A304

Procter&Gamble

Procter&GamblesTMEintheothertoiletriesproductclassis$116millionin2012.
ThemarketersTMEinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategorydeclines20.5%in
2012to$69.9million,from$88.0millionin2011.
Malecentric brands continue to associate themselves with popular sports
personalities and sports. Procter & Gambles Gillette launches My City is My Gym
campaign that urges men to put to test its Gillette Odor Shield
antiperspirant/deodorant by taking their exercise regime outdoors. The company
partners with three professional athletes hockey player Patrick Sharp; former
footballstarDhaniJones;andfootballlegendJerryRicetopromoteitsGillettebrand.
Procter&Gamblecontinuestobethesecondleadingadvertiserinthedeodorantsand
antiperspirantscategoryin2012.
ThemarketersTMEin2012amountsto$69.9million,down20.5%from$88.0million
in2011.
Secret, the marketers leading brand, receives TME support of $41.7million in 2012.
Thisisanincreaseof4.5%from$39.9millionin2011.
The Secret Outlast Collection receives the maximum TME among the Secret line of
productswithexpendituresat$22.5millionin2012.
Televisionisthemostpreferredadvertisingmediumadoptedbythebrand.Television
advertisementsaccountfor61.7%ofthetotalTME.
Thesecondleadingadvertisingmediumforthemarketerismagazineadvertisements,
accountingfor22.6%ofthetotalTME.
In2012,Procter&GamblereducesitsadvertisingexpenditureonInternetadvertising
to$10.2millionin2012,down43.0%from$17.9millionin2011.
ThecompanypartnerswithJenniPulos,atelevisionpersonality,actress,rapper,and
executiveassistant,topromoteitslatestlineofproducts,theSecretOutlastCollection.
In2012,Procter&GamblesetsuptheGangUpforGoodhubatmeanstinks.comin
the honor of the National Bullying Prevention Month. The website offers an advice
section, whereby girls all over the country share their experiences, encourage other
girls,andprovideexamplesofhowtheyhavesuccessfullyGangedUpForGood.
InthesecondyearoftheMeanStinksprogram,thebrandpartnerswithmusicartist
DemiLovatoandencouragesgirlstobeapartofthemovementthatattemptstobring
an end to mean behavior. The girls participating in this program are expected to
promote the Mean Stinks pinky swears by painting their nails blue to support peace
andsolidarity.
ThecompanypromotesitsOldSpicebrandwithamusicalhitMuscleMusic,avideo
whichfeaturesTerryCrews,aformerNFLplayer.Whenthevideofinishes,viewerscan
develop their own music by moving Crews muscles using the keyboard. Each key
strokeflexesamuscleonCrewsbodytohitaninstrument.
Procter & Gamble is the leading marketer in TMEs in the depilatories, waxes, and
bleachescategory,withadvertisingexpendituresat$30.1millionin2012.
The marketer entered the category in 2011 with Olays Smooth Finish Facial Hair
RemovalDuo.
Procter&Gamblespends$15.8milliononmagazineadvertisementsand$12.9million
ontelevisionadvertisements.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5305

5306

Procter&Gamble

Olayspresenceonsocialmedianetworks,suchasFacebook,helpsspreadawareness
aboutitsproductsthatcompeteinthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategory.
OlayswebsitealsopromotestheSmoothFinishFacialHairRemovalDuobyeducating
consumersabouthairremovalfactsandmythsandbyprovidingvideosandarticlesby
professionalestheticians.
Consumersinterestedinreceivingregularupdatesaboutthebrandsactivitiesinthe
form of special offers, events, sweepstakes, giveaways, and insider information can
jointheOlayClubthroughthebrandswebsite.
Procter & Gamble slides to become the secondleading advertiser in the personal
cleansingproductscategorywithaTMEallocationof$11.6millionin2012.
The marketers TME declines 70.0% from $114.1million in 2011, to $40.0million in
2012.
The company apportions $10.6million or 91.4% of the marketers total TME on
magazineadvertisements.
In2012,Procter&GambleintroducestheMyCityisMyGymcampaigntopromote
its Gillette brand. The campaign encourages men to take their exercise routine
outdoorsandcleansethemselveswithGillettesOdorShieldBodyWash.Themarketer
claimsthatthisbodywasheliminatesodorinsteadofmaskingit.Gillettepartnerswith
three professional athletes hockey player Patrick Sharp, Dhani Jones, a former
footballstar,andJerryRice,afootballlegendtopromoteitsproducts.
Olays website promotes its personal cleansing products by informing consumers
about the various offers and providing details on ways to attain the companys
productsatlowerprices.Olayalsoprovidesfreeshippingonpurchasesabove$25.00.
Procter&Gamblespends$4.4millionasTMEtopromoteitsbrandscompetinginthe
shavingproductscategoryin2012,up10.0%from$4millionin2011.
Gillettepartnerswith25ambassadorsworldwideforitsGetStartedcampaign.
Thecampaignhelpsitsambassadorstogivebacktotheirrespectiveorganizationsand
communities,whichgroomedthemtotheircurrentpositioninlife.
GilletteandRyanLochte,worldchampionswimmer,donate$25,000toDaytonaBeach
Speed Swimming the swimming club that helped give Lochte a start to his
swimmingcareer.
Gillette also partners with sport personalities, such as Tyson Gay (USA, track), Roger
Federer(Switzerland,tennis),andSirChrisHoy(GreatBritain,cycling).
TheArtofShavingbrandteamsupwithMovember,aglobalmenshealthcharity,to
fightcancerthataffectsmen.
Theparticipantsraiseawarenessandfundsformenshealth,especiallyprostateand
testicularcancer.
The Art of Shaving encourages people to participate in Movember's 6th annual U.S.
fundraising event. The brand urges members of their "brotherhood of shaving" to
participateintheeventbyassuringtomatchtheteamdonationsupto$25,000.
In 2012, The Art of Shaving invites all registered MoBros to a complimentary
MovemberHotTowelShaveavailableatthebrand'sBarberSpalocations.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A306

Procter&Gamble

In2012,theadvertisingexpendituresforProcter&Gamblearerecordedat$221.4million
inthefacemakeupcategory.
Procter&GamblesTMEinthefacemakeupcategoryis$87.1million in2012,down
8%from$95millionin2011.
Covergirl uses its website to help consumers match foundation shades. Visitors can
chooseadepartmentstorebrandandthesitewillprovidetheCovergirlproductthat
matchesthatproduct.Procter&Gambleusesseveralmediapersonalitiestopromote
itsCovergirlbrand.ThelatestspokespersonsincludesingersJanelleMonaeandPink.
Procter&Gamble,thesecondlargestadvertiserintheeyemakeupcategorywithonly
itsCovergirlbrand,hasadvertisingexpendituresof$74.2millionin2012,downfrom
$101.6millionin2011.
TheadvertisingcampaignforCovergirlusesactressSofiaVergaraforitsLashBlast24
hrmascaraandforitsnewBlastFlipsticklipstick.CovergirlalsousessingerTaylorSwift
for its Lash Blast Volume mascara and for its Eye Enhancers and Perfect Point Plus
Linerproducts.
Thelipsticksandlipglossescategoryreceives$57.1millioninadvertisingexpenditures
fromProcter&Gamble.

In 2012, Head & Shoulders signs on Argentinian soccer player, Lionel Messi, as an
ambassador for a series of advertisements that are specifically designed for the U.S.
Hispanicmaleaudience.
LionelMessiwillhelppromotetheRefreshforMenlineofproductsthroughtelevision
andonlineadvertisements.
Additionally, Messis fans are able to access statistics and photos of the threetime
FIFAworldplayerthroughthenewlyredesignedFacebooktab,www.HombreMVP.com.

Procter&Gambleistheworldwidepartnerforthe2012LondonOlympicsheldatLondon,
England.
Thecompanysponsors28U.S.OlympicandParalympichopefulsforthe2012London
OlympicsandParalympicGames.
Theseathletesrepresent13ofProcter&Gamblesiconicbrands.
The marketer also announces the launch of the Procter & Gamble Team USA Youth
SportsFundwhichaimsatraising$500,000throughthe2012LondonOlympics.
The fund will aim to aid mothers in raising happy and healthy kids by giving them
broader access to youth sports as a part of Procter & Gambles Thank you, Mom
campaign.Thisisapartofthecompanysglobalefforttoraisemorethan$5millionfor
youthsports.
The marketer, in conjunction with the Olympic and Paralympic athletes, encourages
consumerstohelpthecausebyvisitingtheThankyou,MomFacebookpagetoshow
theirsupportandsharetheirstories.
Furthermore, Procter & Gamble donates $1.00 up to $100,000 to the Procter &
GambleTeamUSAYouthSportsFundforeverylikeonProcter&GamblesThank
you,MomFacebookpage.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5307

5308

Procter&Gamble

TheSuperBowl,apopularsportingeventintheUnitedStates,attractsmillionsofviewers
everyyear.
Onthisday,sportsenthusiastsnotonlywatchthematchwithenthusiasmbutalsothe
advertisements. The company uses this opportunity to premier its latest and most
entertainingadvertisements.

OUTLOOK

Procter&GambleislikelytoremaintheleadingmarketerintheU.S.personalcaremarket
throughtheforecastperiod,eventhough2012hasproventobeoneofitsmostchallenging
yearstodate.
Procter & Gamble, despite a disappointing financial performance in 2012 in the U.S.
personal care market, one of its largest revenue generating regions, the marketer is
expectedtohaveabrightfuturethrough2017.
Procter & Gamble, with its portfolio combining performing and underperforming
brands,hasprominenceinmostproductcategories.
The companys focus will continue to be on the development of its core leadership
brandsandcategories.
The company is taking initiatives to focus on its longterm strategies to increase its
financialstability,eventhoughsomeoftheseactionshavehurtsitsU.S.sales.
The company has implemented three changes including strengthening its core
business,renewingfocusondiscontinuousinnovation,andstartinga$10billioncost
savingprogram.
Therestructuringandfocusonstrongbrandsstrategyimpliesthecompanysshiftfrom
premiumpriced products to a more competitive pricing structure, a strategy that
manyconsumersinthedevelopedmarketsfavorduetotheircompromisedspending
power.
Furthermore,thecompanytakesstepstoimprovetheexecutionacrossthecompany
to overcome macro challenges, manage competitive threats, and attain maximum
benefitsfrominnovation,marketing,andproductivityprograms.
However, the companys growth in the U.S. market will be hampered by the
marketersfocusondevelopingbusinessintheemergingmarkets.
Additionally, Procter & Gamble suffers due to its division of resources among many
diverse categories, whereas its competitors such as LOral and Unilever are at an
advantage, due to their concentration in the beauty and personal care categories
respectively.

Thereareseveralfactorsfavoringthemarketersgrowthoverthenextfiveyears.
The consolidating industry where big companies continue to acquire brands from
smallercompanies,therebycontrollingtheindustry.
The companys new fourpoint plan for innovation which has been designed to help
shape themarketersbusiness especially during challenging economic conditions will

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A308

Procter&Gamble

help the company improve its position in the market. According to the fourpoint
innovationplan,innovationmustbebalanced,communicatevalue,concernallofthe
companysemployees,andconnectwithconsumers.
Procter & Gamble is expected to emphasize on technologically advanced product
formulationsandpackaging.
In the past traditional media has been instrumental in using up the companys
advertisingbudgettoagreatdeal.However,withplansofarevisioninitsmultibillion
dollar advertising budget, the company is expected to use Facebook and Google to
becomemorecosteffective.
The companys partnership with wellknown celebrities for its larger wellknown
brands such as Olay, Covergirl, Gillette, Old Spice, Crest, and Oral B is expected to
increasesalesandthevisibilityofitsbrandsduringtheforecastperiod.
Procter & Gamble will continue to expand its presence into varied channels such as
specialtystores,perfumeries,pharmacies,salons,andecommerce.
In 2012, Procter & Gamble forms a global pledge to invest its resources for the
development of plantbased poly ethylene terephthalate (PET) to be used in the
packagingofitspersonalcareproducts.PET hasanenlargedcarbonfootprintasthe
materialisproducedwithlargeamountsoffossilfuels.Sustainablepracticessuchas
thiswillbecomemoreimportanttoconsumersovertheforecastperiod.
Procter & Gambles beauty business in the U.S. market is geared towards the mass
segment,howeverinthecomingyears,itisanticipatedthatthemarketerwillgrowits
presenceinthepremiumsegmentbeginningwiththeemphasisonitsmasstigebrand,
Olay.

ThefactorscausingProcter&GambletolosegroundintheUnitedStatesin2012willneed
tobereversed,forthecompanytoregainitsfootingintheforecastperiod.
The companys $10 billion costsaving plan announced in February 2012 has left
some of its brands lacking necessary marketing support, particularly in light of its
competitorsincreasingtheirownpromotionalactivities.Thecompanyplanstoreduce
costsbycutting$6billionincostofgoodssold,$3billioninoverhead,and$1billionin
marketing.
Thecompanyisalsolikelytocut1,600jobsasacostcuttingexerciseinthefiveyear
forecastperiod.
The costcutting exercise will work in conjunction with companys new advertising
strategythatisaimedatloweringthecompanysadvertisingexpenditures.
Limited innovations from Procter & Gamble are also responsible for the companys
weakgrowthin2012,whichresultsfromcostcuttinginR&D.
Procter & Gambles current plight dramatically exemplifies how critical both
innovationandpropermarketingsupportaretobesuccessfulinthebeautyindustry.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5309

5310

Procter&Gamble

Procter&GamblehaslostouttoitsmajorcompetitorsintheUnitedStatesin2012.
Competition from big marketers such as Unilever, ColgatePalmolive, and Johnson &
Johnson has gradually eroded Procter & Gambles market share in the skin care and
haircareproductclass.
In2012,Procter&Gamblehasstruggledtomatchupwithitscompetitorsinvolume
growth,asthecompanyshigherpricepositionmakesitvulnerable.Itincreasesprices
of products to recover commodity costs, a move many of its competitors did not
undertake.

Thecompanyspresenceinboththeretailandsalonprofessionalchannelswillhelpthehair
careproductclasstocontinuetobethelargestproductclassforthecompanyduringthe
forecastperiod.
ShampoosandconditionersarelikelytoemergestrongerforProcter&Gambleduring
theforecastperiod.Thecompanysresearchprogramintothehairagingprocessthat
hasresultedinthenewhaircarelinecomprisingashampoo,conditioner,masque,and
thickeningtreatment,tofightthesevensignsofhairfollicledeteriorationisexpected
to be well received by the consumers thereby driving up the sales for the company
through the forecast period. Procter & Gamble claims that its AgeDefy product is
expectedtomakethehairlook10yearsyoungerforwomenintheir40s.
With Pantene losing ground, the companys own Head & Shoulders is capturing its
place. By focusing on problemsolving products, Procter & Gamble is expected to
regainlostground.
SalesofHerbalEssenceswillcontinuetogainfromitsemphasisonproductscontaining
naturalingredients.Newproductactivityfromthebrandin2012includesarangeof
conditioners including Honey Im Strong conditioner and Long Term Relationship
naturalconditioner.
Thesuccessoffoambasedhaircoloringproductswillsupportthecompanysgrowthin
thehaircareproductclass.
Procter & Gamble is expected to try to revive growth in the hair coloring products
category with active new product introductions after the discontinuation of six hair
coloringproductlinesin2011.
The companys presence in the professional trade class through its Sebastian and
Nioxinbrandsisexpectedtostrengthenduringtheforecastperiod,ending2017.Ifit
renewsmarketinginitiativestoreviveSebastian,itcanonceagainbeamuchsought
afterbrand.Nioxinwillsucceedbecauseofitsstrongclinicalpositioningandsolution
forhairlossproblems.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A310

Procter&Gamble

In the other toiletries product class, Procter & Gamble is likely to post a healthy growth
through2017.
In the deodorants and antiperspirants category, Procter & Gamble is expected to
introduce a range of products targeted towards women in order to compete with
othermarketerssuchasColgatePalmolive,Unilever,andRevlon,whoofferseparate
deodorantandantiperspirantproductlinesformenandwomen.Procter&Gambleis
expected to introduce naturallyformulated shaving gels and creams thereby
commandinghigherpricesforsuchproducts.
Olayisexpectedtoperformwellinthedepilatories,waxes,andbleachescategorywith
thelaunchofmorevariantstoits existinglineofproducts.Thereisalikelihoodthat
thebrandwillventureintoothersegments,suchaswaxesandbleachesinanattempt
tocompetewithotherbrandsinthecategoryandtryandcapturegoodmarketshare.
The marketer will continue to provide good marketing support to its new product
introductions with print and television advertisements as the main mediums. Also,
Olaywillsignacelebritytoendorseitsproductsinthecategory,whichwouldsolidify
itsdominance.

Procter & Gamble is poised to take advantage from the opportunities arising from the
growingmalegroomingsegment.
Procter&GambleemphasizesthiswithitsmaleorientedbrandssuchasGilletteand
The Art of Shaving brands, which span various sales channels and appeal to a wide
rangeofconsumers.
Gillette is expected to maintain its longstanding leadership position in the shaving
productscategory.Thebrandbenefitsfromitsdominantglobalpresenceintherazors
category.
The Art of Shaving, a premium mens grooming brand, is likely to continue its
expansionthrough2017.
Bytheendof2012,TheArtofShavingbrandispresentin67retaillocationsincluding
retailerssuchasNordstrom,BloomingdalesNeimanMarcus,BarneysNewYork,Saks
FifthAvenue,HoltRenfrew,andMacys.
The company is planning to strengthen its mens product line as more interest is
generatedamongitsyoungandoldmalecustomers.

As the trend towards naturallypositioned products continues to gather momentum, the


marketer is likely to introduce products enriched with increased concentration of natural
ingredients.
Naturallyformulated products gain acceptance as consumers increasingly become
health conscious and try and incorporate the trend of health and wellness in their
personalhygieneregimen.
These naturallyformulated products contain lower levels of synthetic ingredients as
comparedtotheconventionalproductsavailableinthemarket.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5311

5312

Procter&Gamble

The prestige fragrance category, backed by big brand names such as Gucci, Dolce &
Gabbana,andHugoBosswillcontinuetodowellduringtheforecastperiod.

Procter&GamblessalesintheU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketareforecasttoreach
$6,317millionby2017,upataCAGRof1.4%from$5,883millionin2012.

Table5159:ForecastDollarSalesgrowthofCosmeticsandToiletries
forProcter&GamblebyProductCategory,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

13.0

Skincareproductsformen

10.2

Nailpolishes

8.4

Fragrancesformen

3.7

Shampoos

3.6

Conditioners

3.0

Shavingproducts

3.0

Mouthwashes

1.6

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.4

Toothpastes

1.3

Facialtreatments

1.2

Fragrancesforwomen

1.2

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

1.1

Handandbodylotions

1.0

Toothbrushes

1.0

Haircoloringproducts

0.9

Toothwhiteningproducts

0.9

Personalcleansingproducts

0.8

Eyemakeupproducts

0.7

Facemakeupproducts

0.7

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

0.7

Lipsticksandlipglosses

0.6

Dentureproducts

Ethnichaircareproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A312

REVLON

Table5160:RevlonsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnited
States,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

EYEMAKEUP

2012

Revlon

133

133

Almay

74

71

Total

207

204

Revlon

107

105

Almay

59

58

Total

166

163

130

135

12

12

147

152

125

123

129

126

FACEMAKEUP

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
Colorsilk
Frost&Glow
Allother
Total
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES
Revlon
Bari/BonBons/LoveMyLips
Total
NAILPOLISHES

Revlon

38

48

Sinful

26

34

PureIce

22

25

90

108

Bari/BonBons
Totalr

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5314

Revlon

Table5160:RevlonsSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnited
States,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

LadyMitchumr

35

33

Mitchumr

17

19

Totalr

52

52

JeanNat

Charlie

Ciara

Total

DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

FACIALTREATMENTS
Almay

TOTALr
802
814

rRestated.

NOTE:Allothersalesincludethesalesofsmallerbrandsthatthe
companyowns.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Revlon,foundedbyCharlesRevson,isheadquarteredinNewYork,NY.
ThecompanyisthemajorityownedsubsidiaryofMacAndrewsandForbesHoldings.
Revlon manufactures, markets, and sells a variety of color cosmetics, fragrances,
personalcareproducts,andbeautytools.
Revlons products are sold worldwide in more than 100 countries and are marketed
underthebrandnamesRevlonandAlmay.
TheU.S.marketcontributestoapproximately56%ofthecompanysrevenues.
Thecompanycelebratesits80thanniversaryin2012.

As of December 31, 2012, the company has a worldwide workforce of about 5,100
employees.
Revlonsproductsaresoldinmorethan100countriesacrosssixcontinents.
Its products are sold through prestige and department stores, television shopping
networks,directsaleschannels,specialtystores,theInternet,perfumeries,andother
distributionoutlets.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A314

Revlon

Globally,Revlonsmainavenuesofdistributionaremassmerchandisers,chaindrugstores,
andfoodstores.
Some of its major retailers are CVS, Target, Shoppers Drug Mart, A.S. Watson, and
Boots.
Walmart is Revlons singlelargest retailer, accounting for approximately 22.0% of its
salesin2012.
RevlonsproductsarealsosoldtotheU.S.militaryexchangesandcommissaries.

ThecompanyhasmanufacturingandwarehousingfacilitiesintheUnitedStates,Venezuela,
SouthAfrica,andMexico.
Product manufacturing is also outsourced by the company to thirdparty
manufacturersaroundtheworld.
AsapartofitsSeptember2012program,Revlonclosesitsmanufacturingfacilityin
FranceandMarylandandrestructuresitsFrenchandItalianestablishments.
The restructuring program, that includes cutdown of 250 positions, costs nearly
$24milliontothecompany.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Revlon records a 3.2% increase in sales to reach $1,426.1million in 2012, up from


$1,381.4millionin2011.
Revlonsprofitsfurtherdeclineby4.3%to$51.1millionin2012,from$53.4millionin
2011.Netprofitsdeclineduetotheincreaseinthecostofsales,restructuringcharges,
andlossonearlyextinguishmentofdebt.

Since 2007, corporate sales have increased at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
0.9%.

Table5161:RevlonsGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

$Million
Year

Sales

Netprofit/loss

2007

1,367.1

(16.1)

2008

1,346.8

57.9

2009

1,295.9

48.8

2010

1,321.4

327.3

2011

1,381.4

53.4

2012

1,426.1

51.1

TheUnitedStatescontinuestobeastablemarket,contributingto56.1%ofthecompanys
overallsalesin2012.
TheAsiaPacificregion,whichhascloseto16.8%shareofthenetsales,records2.4%
growthin2012.
Overall,thenetsalesincreaseduetoanincreaseinthesalesofRevloncolorcosmetics:
RevlonColorSilkhaircolorandSinfulColorscolorcosmetics.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5315

5316

Revlon

Table5162:RevlonsGlobalCorporateSalesbyGeographicArea,2011and2012

$Million

Geographicarea

2011

2012

UnitedStates

757.4

799.8

5.6

AsiaPacific

233.4

238.9

2.4

Europe,MiddleEast,andAfrica

208.7

184.4

(11.6)

LatinAmericaandCanada

181.9

203.0

11.6

1,381.4

1,426.1

3.2

Total

Change,%

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Total sales for Revlons cosmetics and toiletries are up 1.5% to $814million in 2012 from
$802millionin2011.

Since2007,saleshavegrownataCAGRof1.4%.

Table5163:RevlonsCosmeticsandToiletriesSalesinthe
UnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

758

2008

759

0.1

2009

752

(0.9)

2010

768

2.1

2011

802

4.4

2012

814

1.5

Makeupproductscontributeto73.8%ofthecompanystotalsalesin2012.
Salesintheproductclassgrowfrom$592millionin2011to$601millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A316

Revlon

Revlonslargestcategory,eyemakeup,accountsfor25.1%ofthecompanystotalcosmetics
andtoiletriessalesintheUnitedStates.
RevlonisthefourthleadingeyemakeupmarketerintheoverallU.S.marketin2012,
with7.5%ofcategorysalesin2012,downfrom7.9%in2011.
The companys sales decline 1.4% to $204million, down from $207million in 2011,
mainlyduetoitsflagshipbrand,Revlon.
ThemarketershrinksitsTMEfrom$52.2millionin2011to$31.5millionin2012.
TheRevlonbrandssalesare$133millionin2012,flatfrom2011.
Revlonsbestperformingsegmentiseyeshadowsin2012.
TME to support the eye shadow business is approximately $8million in 2012. The
mascarabusinessissupportedwithapproximately$9.5millioninTMEin2012.
Almayssalesdecline4.1%from2011withsalesof$71millionin2012.
Almayissupportedwith$11.6millioninTMEforitseyeshadowsegment,inparticular,
products within the Intense IColor franchise, and, $1.8million in TME is used to
supportitsAlmayOneCoatGetUp&Growmascara.

Withsalesof$163millionin2012,facemakeupaccountsfor20.0%ofthecompanystotal
sales.
Categoryssalesdeclineby1.8%,from$166millionin2011.
ThecategorystwomainbrandsareAlmayandRevlon.
Revlonisthesixthleadingmarketerinthefacemakeupcategory.
TheRevlonbrandssalesareestimatedat$105millionin2012,down1.9%from2011.
RevlonalsocompetesinthemassmarketwithitsAlmaybrand.
Almays sales decline from $59million in 2011 to $58million in 2012. Almays sales
declineacrossallcategoriesin2012.
TMEdecreases13%to$44.9millionin2012forboththeRevlonandtheAlmaybrands.
Justover$14millionoftheTMEisusedtopromoteAlmaysSmartShadeandWakeUp
foundations. The Revlon brands TME promotes its Colorstay Foundations (whipped
andliquid),AgeDefyingwithDNAAdvantagefoundation,andPhotoreadyfoundations
(whippedandliquid).

Hair coloring products is Revlons thirdlargest category, accounting for 18.7% of the
companys total sales in 2012. Revlon is also the thirdlargest marketer in the overall
category.
Revlon posts a moderate growth of 3.4% to reach $152million in 2012, from
$147millionin2011.
The leading brand, Revlon Colorsilk, posts a healthy growth of 3.8%. Sales advance
from $130million in 2011 to $135million in 2012. However, further growth of the
marketerisrestrictedbynegligibleTME.
TheextensionoftheColorsilkrangecontributestothemarketersgrowthin2012.
RevlonintroducestheLuxuriousColorsilkButtercreamlinein2012.Theproductlineis
a permanent hair color that erases gray hair. The product is ammoniafree and is
availablein13shades.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5317

5318

Revlon

Revlonssalesinthelipsticksandlipglossescategorydeclineby2.3%,from$129millionin
2011to$126millionin2012.
Revlonscategorysharedecreasesfrom9.5%in2011to9.2%in2012.
Revlon competes in the mass lip category with its Revlon and Bari brands. Although
RevloncompeteswiththeAlmaybrandinothermakeupcategories,Almaynolonger
participatesinthelipcategory.
SalesoftheRevlonbranddecline1.6%to$123millionin2012,downfrom$125million
in2011.
SalesoftheRevlonbranddeclineprimarilyduetothedipinlipglosssalesforthebrand.
Itsliplinerandlipsticksegmentsarerelativelyflat.
Thedeclineinsales,however,isnotattributedtothelackofadvertisingsupportfrom
the company, as the budget increases over 40% to $33million in TME in 2012 from
$23millionin2011.

NailpolishesisthesmallestmakeupcategoryforRevlon,accountingfor13.3%ofRevlons
totalcosmeticsandtoiletriessalesintheUnitedStates.
Revlonisthesecondlargestmarketerinthenailpolishescategoryin2012.
Revlons sales reach $108million in manufacturers sales in 2012, up 20.0% from
$90millionin2011.
Nailpolishesrepresent18.0%ofRevlonstotalmakeupsales.
RevlonacquiresBonBonsandPureIcefromBariCosmeticsin2012.
PureIcessalesreach$25millionin2012,up13.6%from$22millionin2011.
Sinfulssalesreach$34millionin2012,up30.8%from$26millionin2011.
Revlons category share increases to 16.3% in 2012, up from 15.9% in 2011 primarily
duetoitsnewlaunchactivity.
RevlonincreasesitsTMEby57.1%to$19.8millionin2012from$12.6millioninTMEin
2011.OverhalftheexpendituresupportstheColorstaynailpolishline.

Revlonssalesinthedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategoryremainunchangedfromthe
previousyear,recordedat$52millionin2012.
Lackofnewproductactivityoffsetsthemarketersgrowthinthecategoryin2012.
ThecategorystwomainbrandsareMitchumandLadyMitchum.
The sales of the Mitchum brand declines by 5.7%, from $35million in 2011 to
$33millionin2012.
ThesalesforLadyMitchumbrandgrow11.8%from$17millionin2011to$19million
in2012.

SalesinwomensfragrancesforRevlondeclinefrom$7millionin2011to$5millionin2012.
JeanNatcontinuestobeRevlonsbestsellingfragrancebrand.
SalesofJeanNatdeclineby25.0%,from$4millionin2011to$3millionin2012.
Sales of the companys heritage brand Charlie drop from approximately $2million in
2011to$1millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A318

Revlon

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Acquisitionsandmergers

Revlon acquires brands Pure Ice nail enamel and Bon Bons color cosmetics from Bari
CosmeticsinJuly2012.
Terms of the transaction are not disclosed; however, Revlon uses $22million of
borrowings under its 2011 Revolving Credit Facility, along with cashonhand to fund
theacquisition.

Otherdevelopments

InJune2012,RevlonsettlesitsdisputewithshareholderFidelityManagement&Research
regardingaclassactionlawsuitrelatedtoashareexchangeofferfrom2009.

NOTABLENEWPRODUCTS

Table5164:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyRevlonintheUnitedStatesin2012

Brand

Category

Description

Revlon

Eyemakeup

SmokyShadowStick

Revlon

Eyemakeup

PhotoreadyPrimer,Shadow+Sparkleeyeshadow

Revlon

Facemakeup

NearlyNakedFoundation

Revlon

Facemakeup

PhotoreadyAirbrushMousseMakeup

Revlon

Facemakeup

ColorstayWhippedCremeMakeup

RevlonColorsilk

Haircoloringproducts

LuxuriousColorSilkButtercreamisanammoniafree,
permanentathomehaircolorthatisavailablein13
shades.Theformulapreventsoversaturationofdyeto
attainuniformcolorthroughout

Revlon

Lipsticksandlipglosses

ColorburstLipButter

Revlon

Lipsticksandlipglosses

JustBittenKissableBalmStain

Revlon

Nailpolishes

Brilliantnailpolish

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5319

5320

Revlon

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Revlon continues to use heavy advertising, pricing discounts, and coupons to promote
products.
The marketer primarily promotes its products through a variety of promotional tools
including, print, television, and the Internet advertising, as well as pointofsale
merchandisingincludingdisplaysandsamples.
Revlon, for its facial treatment products, runs a fourpage insert in the September
issuesofVogue,Glamour,Allure,andSelfthatincludestipsonskincare,haircare,and
cosmetics.

Revlonsupportsitsbrandswithcelebrityendorsements.
The marketer utilizes famous actresses and models as spokespersons to endorse its
products.
Theendorsementsarethroughtelevisionandtheprintmedia.
Revlon signs actress Emma Stone to promote its launch of Just Bitten Kissable Balm
Stain.

Themarketeroffersdiscountcouponstosupportitsnewlaunches.
Revlon offers discount coupons, usually as freestanding inserts (FSIs) in weekly
newspapers.
Revlonoffers$2.00offonanyRevlonPhotoReadyFaceProduct.

RevlonalsousestheInternetasoneofthemajorsourcesofadvertisingandpromotingits
brands.
The marketer uses social media sites, such as Facebook, Pinterest, and Twitter, to
promoteitsproducts.
The marketer utilizes its brands website as an important medium to promote its
products.Revlonprovidesmakeuptipsandmakeupsolutionsonitswebsite.
Themarketersharesitsnewproductlaunches,otherproductoffers,andcontestsonits
Facebookpagetopromotesales.
Revlon conducts various contests on its website to encourage consumers to buy its
products. For example, the marketer asks consumers to share their favorite makeup
storyonitsFacebookpage,forachancetowinatriptoNewYork.

Revlonspendsabout$161.4millionontraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)tosupportits
brandsin2012,up3.1%from$156.6millionin2011.
Morethan97%oftheTMEisspentthroughtelevisionandlocalmagazines.
The company promotes its products mainly through television (50.9%), followed by
localmagazines(46.3%)in2012.
Revlon is the fourthlargest advertiser in the lipsticks and lip glosses category with a
TMEof$32.9millionin2012,upfrom$23.2millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A320

Revlon

The marketer allocatesTME of $44.9 for its face makeup category in 2012 and the entire
TMEisallocatedtopromoteitsRevlonandAlmayproductlines.
About$17millionoftheTMEisusedtopromotetheRevlonColorstayproductline.
AlmayusesitsTMEforitsSmartShadePowderandFoundationproducts,aswellasfor
itsWakeUpPowderproduct.

OUTLOOK

Revlonisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof2.0%overtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Growth in the cosmetics and toiletries market will be supported by new product
launchesacrosscategoriesoverthenextfiveyears.
AlanT.Ennis,PresidentandCEOofRevlon,intendstorevivethecompanysleadership
positioninthecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustryintheUnitedStates.Inordertotake
Revlon to greater heights, Ennis plans to focus on growing the business and the
companysbrandsbyenhancingtheorganizationalpotentialintheUnitedStates,while
driving Revlon to expand globally. Ennis also says in 2012 that he intends to expand
manufacturing in the United States, moving away from China, because of cost and
qualityissues.

The makeup product class is expected to account for themajority ofthe marketers sales
andislikelytodriveRevlonssalesoverthenextfiveyears.
Eyemakeupisexpectedtobethehighestrevenuegeneratorovertheforecastperiod.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoinnovateonmascarabrushtechnology,withenhanced
productformulations,includingbenefits,suchaslashbuilding,eyelashtreatments,and
primerstodrivesales.
Themarketerisexpectedtointroduceeyemakeupproductsthatincorporatebenefits,
such as hair growth, or innovative skin care ingredients that are likely to foster the
growth.
Revlonisexpectedtolaunchlimitededitioneyeshadowcollectionstoaddincremental
salesthroughouttheyearandtocreateexcitementinthecategory.
Further, the marketer plans to launch eye makeup products with natural ingredients
whichareexpectedtogainmorepopularityinthefuture.
New formulations and delivery mechanisms will continue to fuel sales in the eye
makeupcategory.
Newshadesincludingglittereyelinersarepredictedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.
New technology and new shades are expected to continue to drive sales in the
eyebrowsegment,aswellascapturemoreconsumersastheyaddeyebrowmakeupto
theirregimen.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5321

5322

Revlon

Thefacemakeupcategoryisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof2.5%overtheforecast
period.
Revlon is expected to launch products with new benefits, formulas, or ingredients to
supportitssalesgrowth.
Face powders that provide additional benefits beyond setting makeup or reducing
shineareexpectedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.Itisexpectedthatpowderswith
light reflection or hydration benefits will help drive sales. Bronzers are expected to
drivesales.
The company is expected to incorporate antiaging and antiacne ingredients to
supportsales.
Productswithbetterfeatures,formulations,andpackagingareexpectedtosupportthe
marketersgrowthinthecategory.

Revlonisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthinthehaircoloringproductscategoryoverthe
nextfiveyears.
Revlonplanstolaunchproductswithimprovedformulationsandcolorstosupportits
salesinthecategory.
Productswithimprovedformulations,suchasfoambasedandcreambasedhaircolors
willcontinuetogainpopularityovertheforecastperiod.
Revlon will continue to launch foambased hair colors which are likely to be in good
demandinthefuture.
Themarketerwillcontinuetofocusoneliminatingharshchemicalssuchasammonia
fromitshaircoloringproductstodrivesales.
Revlonwillfocusonincorporatingmultiplebenefits,suchasnourishmentofhairand
sunprotectionovertheforecastperiod.

Over the next five years, Revlon is projected to post moderate growth in the lipsticks
category.
Revlonwillcontinuetolaunchnewandimprovedproductswithinnovativeingredients,
improvedapplicators,andpackagingtoinspirewomentopurchase.
Products containing natural, moisturizing ingredients, such as maracuja oil and/or
argonoilsareexpectedtofuelsalesinthecategory.
Longlasting lipsticks and lip glosses is an area in which the company is likely to
continueintroducingmoreproductvariantsandshowprogressinsales.
Revlonisexpectedtomaintainitsstrongpositioninthemasslipsticksandlipglosses
market.
Revlon plans to launch lipsticks with multibenefits, such as sun protection and
moisturizingbenefits,whichwilllikelydrivethecategoryssales.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A322

Revlon

Revlonwillcontinuetobuildonimprovingitsstrongbrandsbyfocusingoninnovationsand
marketingactivities.
Themarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitspromotionalandmarketingactivitiesoverthe
forecastperiod.
Revlon will likely increase advertising budgets to include magazine advertising,
revamping of brand websites, and the use of social media as a way to promote its
brandsandproducts.

Revlonwilllikelypostgrowthof1.8%inthenailpolishescategoryovertheforecastperiod.
ThemarketeracquiresBonBonsandPureIcefromBariCosmeticsin2012inorderto
increaseitsmarketshareinthecategoryoverthenextfiveyears.
Revlon will likely increase its media spending on these brands to support its overall
sales.
Further benefits, such as quicker drying time and heat/smear resistant, are likely to
contributetosalesgrowth.

Themarketerwillcontinuetoseekopportunitiesforitsexistingbrandsandmakeeffortsto
acquirenewbrandsovertheforecastperiodtomaintainitsstrongposition.
Revlon acquires brands Pure Ice nail enamel and Bon Bons color cosmetics from Bari
CosmeticsinJuly2012.
The marketer is expected to make similar moves over the forecast period to
complementitscorebusiness.
The marketer will also continue to benefit from its competitive pricing and strong
brandloyaltyoverthenextfewyears.

Revlons sales are forecast to increase through 2017 at a CAGR of 2.0% to reach
$899millionin2017,upfrom$814millionin2012.

Table5165:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforRevlonbyProductCategory,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Eyemakeup

2.8

Facemakeup

2.5

Haircoloringproducts

2.2

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.0

Nailpolishes

1.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1.5

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

0.8

Facialtreatments

0.5

Fragrancesforwomen

0.3

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5323

5324

Revlon

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A324

SANOFI

Table5166:SanofisSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnited
States,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

GoldBond

2012

65

66

63

66

SHAMPOOS

SelsunBlue

36

36

SelsunBlueNaturals

UltraSwim

45

45

194

197

MOUTHWASHES
Act

Total
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
BullFrog
HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS
SunIn
PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS
GoldBond
BABYCAREPRODUCTS
BabyGoldBond
TOTAL

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Sanofiisoneofthelargestpharmaceuticalcompaniesintheworld.

ThecompanyisheadquarteredinParis,France.

Operating primarily under two business segmentsPharmaceuticals and Vaccines


the companys principal activities include research, development, production, and
distributionofpharmaceuticalproductsaroundtheworld.

The Pharmaceuticals business segment includes manufacturing, marketing, and


distributionofmedicinesfortherapeuticareasthatincludecardiovascular,thrombosis,
centralnervoussystem,oncology,metabolicdisorders,andinternalmedicine.

The company manufactures, markets, and distributes vaccines used for treating
tetanus, whooping cough, diphtheria, HIV/AIDS, and Hepatitis B, under the Vaccines
businesssegment.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5326

Sanofi

Operatingallovertheworld,Sanofiemploysmorethan111,974peopleworldwideandis
presentinmorethan100countriesin2012.

WiththecompletioninMarch2010oftheacquisitionofChattem,aleadingmarketer
and manufacturer of personal care and health care products, Sanofi entered the
cosmeticsandtoiletriesbusiness.

Based in Chattanooga, TN, Sanofi manufactures and markets overthecounter (OTC)


drugs,toiletries,anddietarysupplements.

Sanofi markets the following brands under its cosmetics and toiletries segment: Act, Bull
Frog,GoldBond,BabyGoldBond,SunIn,IcyHot,Selsun,SelsunBlue,andUltraSwim.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

In 2012, total corporate sales grow 4.7% to 34,947million ($44,913million), from


33,389million($42,911million)in2011.

Net profits in 2012 decrease to 4,967million ($6,383million), down 12.8% from


5,693million($7,317million)in2011.

TheUnitedStatesistheprincipalmarketforthecompany,witha31.1%shareoftotalsales.

TotalU.S.salesforthecompanyare10,873million($13,974million).

OtherimportantmarketsaretheemergingmarketsandWesternEuropeancountries.

The company is currently shifting from established but lesserperforming markets,


suchastheUnitedStatesandWesternEurope,toemergingmarkets.

Since2007,saleshavegrownatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of4.5%peryear,
andnetprofitshavedeclinedataCAGRof1.2%.

Table5167:SanofisGlobalCorporateSalesandProfits,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Profitmargin

Returnonequity

2007

28,052

5,263

18.8

11.8

2008

27,568

3,851

14.0

8.6

2009

29,785

5,265

17.6

10.9

2010

32,367

5,467

16.8

10.3

2011

33,389

5,693

17.1

10.1

2012

34,947

4,967

14.2

8.6

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A326

Sanofi

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Table5168:CosmeticsandToiletriesBrandsofSanofiintheUnitedStates,2012
Brand

Category

Act

Mouthwashes

BabyGoldBond

Babycareproducts

BullFrog

Suncareproducts

GoldBond

Handandbodylotions,footcareproducts,talcumand
dustingpowders,personalcleansingproducts

SelsunBlue

Shampoos

UltraSwim

Shampoos

SunIn

Haircoloringproducts

In2012,salesofSanofiscosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatespostanincreaseof
1.5%,from$194millionin2011to$197million.

Since2007,thecompanyssalesintheindustryhavegrownataCAGRof4.5%.

Table5169:SanofisSalesofCosmeticsandToiletries
intheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

158

2008

179

13.3

2009

176

(1.7)

2010

188

6.8

2011

194

3.2

2012

197

1.5

HandandbodylotionsisthebiggestcategoryforSanofi.

Salesgrowby1.5%,from$65millionin2011to$66millionin2012.

ThecategorysshareinthecompanystotalU.S.cosmeticsandtoiletriessalesis33.5%
in2012.

GoldBond,thecompanysonlybrandinthecategory,rankssixthamongmassbrands
intheoverallhandandbodylotionscategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5327

5328

Sanofi

The companys secondlargest product category, mouthwashes, accounts for 33.5% of its
salesin2012,upfrom32.5%in2011.

Sanoficontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketerinthemouthwashescategory.

Company sales in this category increase by 4.8% in 2012, to $66million from


$63millionin2011.

The company increases its market share from 8.1% in 2011 to 8.3% in 2012 in the
category.

SanofissalesgrowthinthecategoryissupportedbyitsnewlaunchActTotalCare.

Productsformulatedforchildrenarebecomingincreasinglypopularwithparentsasa
meanstobothensuresafetyforchildrenandencouragechildrentousetheproduct.
ActsAnticavityKidsrinseforchildrenispopularamongconsumers.

Theshampoosproductcategoryrepresentsthecompanysthirdlargestcategory.

Salesofshampoosremainflatat$45millionin2012.

ThecompanysellsSelsunBlue,SelsunBlueNaturals,andUltraSwimbrandsunderthis
category.

Themarketshareofthecompanydecreasesfrom1.8%in2011to1.7%in2012inthe
category.

Thesalesofallthreebrandsinthecategoryremainflatin2012.

Lackofnewproductactivityleadstotheflatgrowthforthemarketerinthecategory
in2012.

Thecompanyssuncarebrand,BullFrog,postssalesof$8millionin2012,thesameasin
2011.

Lackofnewproductactivityandpromotionalsupportleadstotheflatgrowthofthe
categoryin2012.

Thesalesofhaircoloringproductsandbabycareproductsremainflatfrom2011salesat
$6millionand$2million,respectively,in2012.

Lackofnewproductactivityandpromotionalsupportleadstotheflatgrowthinboth
categoriesin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergers,alliances,divestures,acquisitions

Thecompanymakesanumberofacquisitionsandasignificantdivestiture.

InJuly2012,Sanofiannouncestheexecutionofanagreement,accordingtowhichit
willdivestitsdirectandindirectstakeofaround19.3%intheYvesRocherGroup.

In October 2012, Sanofi and The Coca Cola Company set up a 5050 partnership to
launchdrinkscarryingwellbeingandbeautyclaims.

In October 2012, Sanofi announces acquiring Genfar SA, a pharmaceuticals


manufacturerbasedinColombia.Thefinancialdetailshavenotyetbeendisclosed.

InJanuary2013,Sanofiannouncescompletingtheacquisitionoftheworldwiderights
totheRolaidsbrandfromMcNeilconsumerhealthcaredivisionofMcNeilPPCInc.

In March 2013, Sanofi sells its only sun care brand, Bull Frog, to Sun & Skin Care
ResearchCompanyforanundisclosedprice.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A328

Sanofi

Otherdevelopments

In October 2012, Sanofi and BristolMyers Squibb coannounce the restructuring of


theirlongtermalliancefollowingthelossofexclusivityofPlavixandAvapro/Avalidein
severalmajormarkets.

InDecember2012,Sanofiagreestopay$109milliontotheU.S.governmenttoresolve
theallegationsofitsviolationagainsttheFalseClaimsActforprovidingfreeunitsofa
kneeinjection,Hyalgan,tophysiciansintheUnitedStates.

Newproducts

Table5170:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbySanofiintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Act

Mouthwashes

TotalCareinfusedwithnaturalbotanicalsthataregentleonsoremouths,
alcoholfree,andstrengthenstheteeth.Itisavailableintwovariants;Mild
MintandTropicalBreeze

BullFrog

Suncare

MosquitoCoastSPF30ContinuousSprayprovidesa2in1protection
againstthesunandinsects,andlastsupto8hours

MARKETINGACTIVITY

Sanofi continues to primarily promote its cosmetics and toiletries through television
advertisements.

In 2012, Sanofi spends approximately $50.8million in traceable media expenditures


(TME)topromoteitsproducts,down26.5%from$69.1millionspentin2011.

The company allocates approximately $47.6million or 93.7% of its entire TME on


televisionadvertising.

ThecompanyspendsthehighestTMEtosupportitsmouthwashescategorywith52.4%or
$26.6million of its total TME, followed by hand and body lotions with 22.6% or
$11.5millionin2012.

Television advertising is the main means of promotion for Sanofi, though radio, the
Internet,andprintadvertisingarealsoemployed.

TherearetelevisioncommercialspromotingSanofismajorbrandsinthepersonalcare
segment.

Mostoftheadvertisementslotsareinsertedduringshowsthatareknowntohavea
largefollowingamongwomenandfamiliesontelevision.

Sanofialsoemploysmethodssuchasdiscounting,primarilythroughcouponing,topromote
itsproducts.

The marketer distributes coupons usually for newlylaunched products in order to


supportthem.

Couponsofdifferentdenominationsaredistributedthroughmagazines,freestanding
inserts(FSIs),theInternet,andretailstores.Forexample:thecompanyoffers$1.00off
on any Bull Frog sun block product and $2.00 off on Gold Bond Ultimate cream or
lotion.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5329

5330

Sanofi

The remainder of the marketers promotional budget is spent on building awareness and
consumerloyaltyforitsbrands.

The company primarily highlights and emphasizes the medicated properties of its
products through media promotions. These are the competitive strengths of its
products.

In order to respond quickly to the changing consumer trends and to support its
growingbrandswhereneededmost,themarketeremploysagreatdealofflexibility,
reallocatingmediaexpenditurebetweenitspersonalcareandhealthcarebrands.

OUTLOOK

Sanofispersonalcaresalesareexpectedtomaintainamoderategrowthof1.5%duringthe
forecastperiod,2012to2017.

Growth will be supported by strong performances of brands such as Act in the


mouthwashescategory,BullFroginthesuncareproductscategory,andGoldBondin
thepersonalcleansingcategory.

Themouthwashescategoryisexpectedtopostthehighestgrowthovertheforecastperiod.

Themarketerisexpectedtolaunchproductsspecifictotweens(aged8to12),which
willsupportitssalesovertheforecastperiod.

In 2012, the marketer allocates the highest TME of $26.6million to support its Act
brandofmouthwashes,andwillcontinuetodosoduringtheforecastperiod.

Sanofiplanstointroduceproductswithnaturalformulationstosupportitsgrowthin
thecategory.

The hand and body lotions category is also expected to perform well over the forecast
period.

Introductionofnewproductsofferingadditionalbenefits,suchasantiaging,suncare,
andtherapeuticwillhelpachieveamoderategrowthforthecategory.

Asnaturalandorganicproductssegmentwillcontinuetoperformwellduringthenext
fiveyears,themarketerisexpectedtolaunchsuchproductsinthecategorytosupport
itsgrowth.

Sanofiplanstodivestitsunderperformingbrandsacrosscategoriesovertheforecastperiod.

In March 2013, Sanofi sells its only sun care brand, Bull Frog, to Sun & Skin Care
ResearchCompanyforanundisclosedprice.

Themarketersintentionsarecleartosellordivestitsunderperformingbrandsinthe
futureandfocusonitscorebrands,asitstreamlinesitsportfolio.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A330

Sanofi

The marketer is expected to increase its marketing and promotional activities over the
forecastperiodtosupportitsgrowth.

Promotionalactivitieswillcontinuetovaryasperthebrandinfocus.Themarketerwill
workoutdifferenttechniquesfordifferentbrands,basingitseffortsonthesizeofthe
brandanditspositioninginthemarket.

The main advertising channel for the marketer over the forecast period will be
televisionadvertising.

ThemarketerislikelytoallocatemajorityofitsTMEtosupportitsActandGoldBond
linesoverthenextfiveyearstosupporttheirgrowthintheirrespectivecategories.

The company is expected to enter new markets and new product categories through
mergersandacquisitions,andsigningpartnershipagreements.

In 2012, Sanofi and The Coca Cola Company set up 5050% partnership to launch
drinkscarryingwellbeingandbeautyclaims.

Productswithcosmeceuticalpropertiesareexpectedtoperformwellovertheforecast
periodandthiswillsupportthemarketersgrowth.

Consumers increasingly seek products with health and beauty claims combined, and
Sanofis step to partner with The Coca Cola Company with these claims will likely
supportthegrowthofthemarketerovertheforecastperiod.

Otherleadingcompaniesinthepersonalcareindustryarealsoexpectedtointroduce
suchcrossindustryproductsasthetrendignitesagain.

Themarketerisexpectedtocontinuetopartnerwithothercompaniestopromoteits
products.

NewproductlaunchesacrosscategorieswillsupportSanofisgrowthinthenextfiveyears.

ThemarketerisexpectedtolaunchnewandinnovativeproductsunderitsGoldBond
andActbrandstosupportitsgrowth.

SanofiwillcontinuetoincreasethenumberofSKUsforitsrespectivecategoriesover
theforecastperiod.ThiswillalsoallowSanofitocommandmoreshelfspaceabetted
bytheincreasingnumberofbrandsinitscosmeticsandtoiletrieslines.

The marketer also has a significant presence in the OTC market space which further
complementsthecompanysstrongrelationshipwithretailers.

Themarketeralsoplanstoincreaseitssocialmediapresenceinordertoengageconsumers
interestovertheforecastperiod.

The marketer is expected to advertise its new products on its Facebook page and
engageconsumerswithvariousconteststosupportitssales.

The Baby Gold Bond brand, the only brand in the baby care products category, might be
phasedoutordiscontinuedbythemarketerovertheforecastperiod.

Lack of new product extensions, stagnant sales for last five years, and lack of TME
support to the category might prompt the marketer to discontinue its product
offeringsinthebabycarecategoryovertheforecastperiod.

SalesofpersonalcareproductsofferedbySanofiareforecasttoincreaseataCAGRof1.5%,
toreach$212millionin2017,upfrom$197millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5331

5332

Sanofi

Table5171:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforSanofibyProductCategory,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Mouthwashes

2.5

Suncareproducts

1.5

COMPANYAVERAGE

1.5

Shampoos

1.3

Handandbodylotions

1.3

Personalcleansingproducts

0.2

Babycareproducts

Haircoloringproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A332

SHISEIDO

Table5172:ShiseidosSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FACEMAKEUP

2012

199

192

Shiseido

26

28

Nars

14

17

Total

239

237

98

104

BareEscentuals

61

61

Nars

14

15

83

85

BareEscentuals

18

18

Nars

12

14

38

41

13

13

LEaudIsseypourHomme

IsseyPourHommeSport

Artisian

23

27

Joico

Zotos

Total

15

15

BareEscentuals

FACIALTREATMENTS
Shiseido
EYEMAKEUP

Shiseido
Total
LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

Shiseido
Total
FRAGRANCESFORMEN
LeMale

Total
SHAMPOOS

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5334

Shiseido

Table5172:ShiseidosSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,
2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

2012

LEaudIssey

NarcisoRodriguez

12

12

10

11

527

542

Total
CONDITIONERS
Joico
SUNCAREPRODUCTS
Shiseido
HANDANDBODYLOTIONS
Shiseido
TOTAL

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Shiseido is the top cosmetics marketer in Japan and is ranked globally among the leading
luxurycosmeticsmarketers.
The company was founded in Tokyo in 1872, originally as a pharmacy. It shifted its
focustocosmeticsin1915.
Shiseido offers products in the makeup, skin care, and hair care product classes.
Additionally,italsomarketsfoodproducts,pharmaceuticals,andfinechemicals.
ThecompanywasformallyincorporatedinJune1927.

ThecompanysheadquartersislocatedinTokyo,Japan.
Itemploysapproximately46,267employeesworldwidein2012.
ThecompanysU.S.subsidiaryShiseidoCosmetics(America)wasfoundedin1965.
Shiseidos primary distribution channels globally are department stores, general
merchandisestores,anddrugstores.
The companys five research and development centers are located in China, Europe,
SoutheastAsia,theUnitedStates,andJapan.
IthasninemanufacturingunitsinJapanand10abroad.
Thecompanyfranchises25,000cosmeticsoutletsinJapan.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A334

Shiseido

Thecompanysbusinessisdividedintothreesegments:DomesticCosmetics,International
Cosmetics,andOthers.
The company manufactures and sells pharmaceuticals for medical use and aesthetic
cosmeticsmaterials.Itisalsoinvolvedinretailclothing,miscellaneousgoods,andthe
restaurantbusiness.
The company owns a French cuisine restaurant in Tokyo called the L'Osier, which
earnedthehighestMichelinratingofthreestars;andTheShiseidoParlour,aWestern
stylerestaurantthatstartedassodafountainin1902.
Shiseidohas97subsidiariesand13associatedcompaniesasofMarch2012.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

The total corporate sales for Shiseido increase from 670,701 million ($8,407 million) in
2011to682,386million($8,553million)in2012,up1.7%.
Thecompanyreportsnetprofitsof14,515million($182million)in2012.

Table5173:ShiseidosGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

2007

694,594

25,293

2008

723,485

2009

Profitmargin

Returnonequity

3.6

6.6

35,460

4.9

9.2

690,256

19,373

2.8

5.4

2010

644,201

33,671

5.2

9.8

2011

670,701

12,791

1.9

3.9

2012

682,386

14,515

2.1

4.9

NOTE:$1.00=79.78.

Thetotalnetsalesofcosmeticsproductsdomesticallycommand51.8%ofShiseidosoverall
salesin2012,adeclineof1.3%from53.4%in2011.
Netsalesofoverseascosmeticswitnessanincreasefrom45.1%to46.8%,from2011to
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5335

5336

Shiseido

Table5174:ShiseidosGlobalSalesbyBusinessDivision,2011and2012

Billion

Division

2011

2012

Domesticcosmeticssales

358.4

353.8

Overseascosmeticssales

302.6

319.7

9.7

8.9

Allothera

%Oftotal

2011

2012

53.4

51.8

45.1

46.8

1.4

1.3

Total
670.7
682.4

100.0

aIncludessalonproducts,pharmaceuticals,healthandbeautyfoods,andfinechemicals.

NOTE:$1.00=79.78.

100.0

Mostofthecompanysbusiness,55.9%,comesfromJapan.
ThesecondlargestcontributorisAsia/Oceania(besidesJapan)with18.3%,followedby
Europe.
TheAmericasaccountfor12.7%ofnetsales.

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

ShiseidostotalsalesincosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnitedStatesincreaseby2.8%,from
$527millionin2011to$542millionin2012.
Since2007,saleshaveincreasedatacompoundannualgrowthrate(CAGR)of3.3%.

Table5175:ShiseidosCosmeticsandToiletriesSalesin
theUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Million

Change,%

2007

460

2008

477

3.7

2009

478

0.2

2010

494

3.3

2011

527

6.7

2012

542

2.8

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A336

Shiseido

Shiseidosleadingproductcategory,facemakeup,contributes43.7%ofthecompanyssales
in2012.
Salesinthecategorydeclineby0.8%from$239millionin2011to$237millionin2012.
Shiseido continues to be the fourthleading company in the face makeup category in
2012.
The Bare Escentuals brand contributes $192million in sales to the company in 2012,
butsalesdecline3.5%asitssalesdipacrossallcategories.
Shiseido increases its TME by 59% for its Bare Escentuals Bare Minerals brand, to
approximately $13.2million in 2012. Onequarter of this is used to promote the new
launch of Ready foundation. The namesake brand does not receive TME in 2012;
however,thecompanysotherluxurybrand,CleDePeauBeaute,receivescloseto2%
ofthecompanysTME.
Bare Escentuals launches a new cream foundation, Ready SPF 20 and a correcting
concealer,butsalesarenotenoughtocompensateforthedropinsalesfromexisting
productsinthecategory.
Nars, the makeup artist brand, outperforms other brands within Shiseidos portfolio,
with sales reaching $17million in 2012, up 21.4% from $14million in 2011. Sales are
drivenbythebrandsblushandbronzingpowder.
The Shiseido brand outpaces the overall market performance, up 7.7% to reach
$28million in sales in 2012, up from $26 million in 2011. The brand introduces new
foundationsandlimitededitioncompactpowder.

Facialtreatmentsaccountsfor19.2%ofthecompanyssalesin2012.
Salesofthecategorygrowfrom$98millionin2011to$104millionin2012,up6.1%.
Facial treatments is the secondlargest category of the company, and the brand
Shiseidoissoldunderthiscategory.

Theeyemakeupcategory,thethirdlargestcategoryinthecompany,accountsfor15.7%of
thecompanysoverallsalesin2012.
Salesofthecategoryincreaseby2.4%from$83millionin2011to$85millionin2012.
ThecompanymarketsBareEscentuals,Nars,andShiseidobrandsunderthiscategory.
Sales of Bare Escentuals remain unchanged from the previous year, at $61 million in
2012.
New product extensions and better traceable media expenditures (TMEs) to support
thebrandgarnerthegrowthoftheBareEscentualssalesin2012.
Narssalesgrowfrom$14millionin2011to$15millionin2012,upby7.1%.
SalesfortheShiseidobrandgrows12.5%,from$8millionin2011to$9millionin2012.

Lipsticksandlipglossesgrowfrom$38millionin2011to$41millionin2012.
Categoryssalesgrowby7.9%in2012.
Newproductlaunchesinthecategorysupportthemarketersgrowthin2012.
In2012,ShisheidolaunchesNarsVelvetGlossLipPencilthatclaimstoprovideaglossy
finish.
TheBareEscentualsbrandcontributes43.9%ofthetotalsalesinthecategoryin2012.
Thesalesofthebrandremainsflatat$18millionin2012,constantwith2011levels.
SalesoftheShiseidobrandgrow12.5%,from$8millionin2011to$9millionin2012.
SalesoftheNarsbrandgrowby16.7%,from$12millionin2011to$14millionin2012.
The growth of Nars brand is supported by new product launches in the category in
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5337

5338

Shiseido

The companys sales for the fragrances product class grow by 11.4%, from $35 million in
2011to$39millionin2012.
Thefragrancesproductclasscontributesto7.2%ofthetotalcompanyssalesin2012.
Lack of TME support in the category leads to the marginal growth of the categorys
sales.
Thefragrancesformencategorygrowsfrom$23millionin2011to$27millionin2012,
upby17.4%.IsseyPourHommeSportlaunchesin2012andcontributestothegrowth.
Thefragrancesforwomencategoryisflatat $12million in2012,constantwith 2011
levels.
Limitednewproductintroductionsandpromotionalactivitiesoffsetthegrowthforthe
marketerintheproductclassin2012.

The hair care product class comprising both shampoos and conditioners collectively
contributes4.8%tothetotalcompanyssalesin2012.
ThecompanysellsJoicoandZotosbrandsunderthesecategories.
SalesofJoicoincreaseby5.3%,from$19millionin2011to$20millionin2012.
SalesofZotosremainflatat$6millionin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

Mergersandacquisitions

NosignificantM&Aactivityisobservedforthecompanyin2012.

Managementchanges

InApril2012,theU.S.subsidiaryofShiseidoannouncestheelevationofPankajGuptatothe
positionofChiefFinancialOfficer.

In June 2012, Shiseido announces a plan to strengthen its U.S. corporate, manufacturing,
anddistributionoperations.
ThecompanyannouncesthatitwillaligntheU.S.finance,legal,andhumanresources
functions of its premier consumer brands including Bare Escentuals, Beaute Prestige
InternationalUSA,Nars,andShiseidointoanunified,sharedservicesplatform.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A338

Shiseido

NEWPRODUCTS

Table5176:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyShiseidointheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

BareEscentuals

Facialtreatments

BaremineralsMultiWrinkleRepairclaimstoworkonmultiplelayersof
theskintodiminishforeheadwrinkles,browfurrows,laughlines,and
crowsfeet

BareEscentuals

Facemakeup

ReadySPF20Foundation

BareEscentuals

Facemakeup

CorrectingConcealer

Nars

Eyemakeup

EyelinerStylofelttipliquideyeliner

Nars

Eyemakeup

LargerThanLifeLongWearEyeliner

Nars

Lipsticks

VelvetGlossLipPencil,abutterylipformula,intheformofapencilthat
providesaglossyfinish

Shiseido

Facialtreatments

WhiteLucentIntensiveSpotTargetingSerumisabrighteningserumto
diminishstubborndarkspotsin10daysandpreventfuture
pigmentationfromappearing

MARKETINGACTIVITY

The companys spending on mediabased advertising and promotions is $52.1 million in


2012.
Thecompanyutilizesawiderangeofmediatoolstopromoteitsproducts.
The largest part of the media spend is for television spots and magazines, which
togetheraccountfor96.9%ofthetotalmediaexpenditures.
The company spends about 48.7% on television advertisements and 48.2% through
magazines.
The company spends 65.0% of its media budget on the promotion of its makeup
productsin2012.

Shiseido helps to promote the Bare Escentuals products with TME of approximately
$32.1millionin2012.

Shiseidooffersdiscountcouponsandfreesamplestopromoteitsproducts.
In2012,themarketeroffersfreesampleofitsnewFutureSolutionEyeRegenerating
CreamwithanUltimateRegeneratingSerumpurchase.
Themarketeralsooffersfreeshippingforproductsboughtthroughitswebsite.
Shiseidooffers20%offonatotalorderfortwodaysstartingCyberMondayforitsNars
products.
The marketer offers discount coupons of denominations ranging from $2.00 to $6.00
onitsBareEscentualsbrand.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5339

5340

Shiseido

While pointofsale displays and advertising are still important, as store traffic decreases,
thecompanyincreasesitspresenceonlineinordertocreategreatervisibilityofitsbrands
andtosupportitsonlinesales.
Shiseido employs the Internet as one of the major sources of advertising and
promotingitsbrands.
The marketer uses social media sites, such as Facebook, Youtube, and Twitter, to
promoteitsproducts.

Thecompanyalsopromotesitsproductsthroughitswebsite.
Themarketerprovidesmakeuptipsandadvicetoconsumersonitswebsite.
The company also provides limitedperiod offers, for example, an Ultimate Cleansing
Oilforfreewiththepurchaseofanytwosuncareproducts.

SalesrepresentativesareanotherimportantsourceforpromotingShiseidosproducts.
The company uses sales representatives as one of the main promotional vehicles for
promotingitsfacemakeupproducts.

ShiseidosBareEscentuals,oneoftheleadingdirectsellingbrands,organizesregularevents
featuringnationalmakeupartistsinpopularmagazinesandinstorepromotionstopromote
itsproducts.
Bare Escentuals products, such as Matte SPF 15 foundation or Original SPF 15
foundation, feature makeup artists in leading fashion magazines, such as Allure and
Seventeen.
Thecompanyalsousesmassretailersanddepartmentstorestopromoteitsproducts.
BareEscentualspromotesitsproductlinethroughQVC.
Besides QVC, infomercials, and company boutiques, Bare Escentuals expands
distribution to department stores and specialty stores including Bloomingdales, Ulta,
andSephora.

OUTLOOK

Shiseidoisexpectedtopostmoderategrowthof3.0%overthetheforecastperiod,2012to
2017.
New product launches with better technology will likely drive the sales for the
marketerintheoverallcosmeticsandtoiletriesmarketintheUnitedStates.
The marketers plan of expanding its business in the United States is expected to
supportitsgrowth.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A340

Shiseido

The largest category for Shiseido, face makeup, is expected to be the highest revenue
generatoroverthenextfiveyears.
Mineral powder foundation must tout new benefits, formulas, or ingredients to
reignitethesegment.
The marketer is also expected to increase its product portfolio with more variants in
thecategoryoverthenextfiveyears.
Shiseido will likely provide new variations to the traditional pressed powder blush in
forms,suchaswhippedcream,sticks,andliquidtints.
Face powders that provide additional benefits beyond setting makeup or reducing
shineareexpectedtogrowduringtheforecastperiod.Itisexpectedthatpowderswith
light reflection or hydration benefits will help drive sales. Bronzers are expected to
drive sales as marketers extend the shade range and continue to showcase pressed
powdersinprismordesignformatstoobtainshelfappeal.
The high growth of the category is not likely to be supported by the Bare Escentuals
brand in the United States, due to intense competition from other brands in the
categoryandoversaturationofmineralmakeup.
TheothermakeupcategoriesforShiseidoarealsoexpectedtoperfromwelloverthe
forecastperiod.
Shiseido is likely to introduce eye makeup products with new technology and new
shadesthatwilldrivethecategoryssales.
The marketer will continue to launch new and improved products with innovative
ingredients,improvedapplicators,andpackaginginordertosupportthegrowthofits
lipsticksandlipglossescategoryinthefuture.

Facial treatments, the secondlargest category for Shiseido, is also expected perform well
overtheforecastperiod.
The marketer is expected to launch facial treatments with multibenefits such as
brightening,luminosity,andradiancetosupportthecategoryssales.
Facialtreatmentswillbeusedbothasasubstitutetocosmeticproceduresandasan
adjuncttothem,withthecommongoaloflookingasyoungaspossible.
The growing demand for antiaging products is expected to drive the sales of the
categoryforthemarketeroverthenextfiveyears.

The company is likely to leverage the aggressive direct marketing strategy that Bare
Escentualspractices.
For instance, Bare Escentuals home shopping and companyowned stores is likely to
provideShiseidoproductsmoreconsumervisibility.
Shiseidos joint product development with Bare Escentuals will further strengthen its
currentproductportfolio.
Thecompanyplanstosellitsotherbrandsthroughdirectmarketingthroughtelevision
togainbettermarketshareinthefuture.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5341

5342

Shiseido

Themarketerisexpectedtoincreaseitsmarketingandpromotionalactivitiestosupportits
salesoverthenextfiveyears.
Thecompanyislikelytospendmoreonpromotingitsexistingandnewproducts.
The Bare Escentuals brand that is present in most categories is expected to get the
highestTMEallocationovertheforecastperiod.
Increasingly,Shiseidoispoisedtoutilizedigitalandsocialmediaasanimportanttool
formarketingitsbrands.

ShiseidoplanstoexpanditsoperationsintheUnitedStatesinordertostrengthenitsglobal
presenceovertheforecastperiod.
The marketer is expected to increase production in its main personal care production
centerintheUnitedStates.
Theincreaseinproductiongivesaclearindicationthatthemarketerisexpectedtopost
stronggrowthovertheforecastperiod.

The marketer will focus on enhancing distribution for its core brands including Bare
Escentuals,Nars,andShiseido.
Themarketerwillcontinuetoincreaseitsproductofferingsthroughmoreretailstores
overtheforecastperiodtosupportitsoverallsales.
The marketer plans to open new distribution centers in the United Sates in order to
supportitssalesbothintheUnitedStatesandgloballyovertheforecastperiod.
Sheseidoisexpectedtoincreaseitsproductofferingsthroughmoredrugstoresoverthe
forecastperiodinordertosupportitsoverallsales.
Promotionsthroughdrugstoresarelikelytoincreaseandthereisthelikelihoodofthe
companyinstallingnewcounterstostrengthenitslineofglobalbrands.

Thecompanyisexpectedtoenterintonewmarketsandnewproductcategoriesthrough
mergersandacquisitionsovertheforecastperiod.
The company is expected to expand its product line and acquire more foreign
companiesthatfitintoitslineofbusiness.

Themarketerislikelytophaseoutitsproductsinthehandandbodylotionscategoryover
the forecast period, through lack of significant activities including new launches or TME
supportforitsbrandsinthecategory.
Moreover, sales in the category have remained stagnant for a few years now,
compellingthemarketertodiscontinueproductsinthiscategory.

The marketer is expected to benefit from naturally positioned products over the forecast
period.
ThecompanylaunchesBaremineralsskincareproductsin2012andislikelytolaunch
similarproductsovertheforecastperiod,expandingfromitsoriginalmineralmakeup
focusintohighergrowthsegments.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A342

Shiseido

ShiseidossalesofcosmeticsandtoiletriesareprojectedtogrowataCAGRof3.0%toreach
$628millionin2017,upfrom$542millionin2012.

Table5177:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforShiseidobyProductCategory,2012to2017

Productcategory

CAGR,%

Facialtreatments

3.5

Facemakeup

3.2

COMPANYAVERAGE

3.0

Eyemakeup

2.8

Lipsticksandlipglosses

2.5

Haircare

2.2

Handandbodylotions

1.0

Fragrancesformen

1.0

Fragrancesforwomen

0.8

Suncareproducts

0.8

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5343

5344

Shiseido

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A344

UNILEVER

Table5178:UnileversSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

Dove

642

680

Caressr

129

137

Suaver

129

133

Axe

80

79

Lever2000r

68

65

St.Ives

38

36

1,090

1,134

Degree

254

265

Dove

183

209

Axe

206

207

Suave

73

74

Total

716

755

Suave

186

193

TRESemmr

120

117

Dove

76

72

Nexxus

40

41

Axer

44

40

SuaveforMen

34

33

30

20

20

Sunsilk

Totalr

523

546

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

VaselineIntensiveCare
Totalr
DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

SHAMPOOS

Clear
TIGI

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSURE FORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5346

Unilever

Table5178:UnileversSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

115

124

Suave

60

59

TIGIr

49

48

Nexxus

32

32

Axe

26

27

Consort

12

11

Dove

11

11

Allother

54

52

359

364

Suave

103

108

TRESemmr

109

107

Dove

68

66

Nexxus

36

37

27

17

17

Sunsilk

Totalr

336

362

Vaseline

114

108

Suaver

54

52

St.Ives

32

32

207

198

Ponds

62

63

St.Ives

29

29

Noxzema

17

17

Simple

10

Totalr

108

119

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS
TRESemm

Totalr
CONDITIONERS

Clear
TIGI

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

Dove
Totalr
FACIALTREATMENTS

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A346

Unilever

Table5178:UnileversSalesofCosmeticsandToiletriesintheUnitedStates,2011and2012

$Million

Category/brand

2011

2012

15

14

JustForMe

TCB

Motions

CombThru

39

39

DoveBodyMists

DegreeBodyMists

14

14

3,406

3,546

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS
Soft&Beautiful

Total
FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

Total
LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS
VaselineLipTherapy
SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN
Vaseline
SHAVINGPRODUCTS
Noxzema
TOTALr

rRestated.

COMPANYOVERVIEW

Unileverisoneoftheworldstopmanufacturersofpackagedconsumergoods.
Thecompanysproductsaresoldworldwideinmorethan190countries.
Thecompanysproductportfolioincludessavoryfoods,dressings,spreads,icecream,
beverages,personalcare,homeproducts,andhomecare.

TheUnileverGroupoperatesunderadualstructure,UnileverNVandUnileverPLC.
Unilever NV is a publiclimited company registered in The Netherlands, and Unilever
PLCisapubliccompanyregisteredinEnglandandWales.
ThecompaniesarelistedontheEuronextAmsterdam,andLondonandNewYorkStock
Exchanges.
Thetwoparentcompaniesoperateasasingleeconomicentity,TheUnileverGroup.
ThegroupoperatesinallthemajorcountriesinEurope,theAmericas,Asia,andAfrica.
Itemploysabout171,000peopleasofDecember31,2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5347

5348

Unilever

Thecompanyisdividedintotwoglobaldivisions,Home&PersonalCareandFoods.
The Home& Personal Care division covers eight product categories: deodorants, hair
care, household care, laundry, mass skin care, oral care, personal wash, and prestige
products.
TheFoodsdivisionaccountsforcategoriessuchassavoryfoodsanddressings,spreads
andcookingproducts,health,wellnessandbeverages,andicecreamandfrozenfoods.
Otheroperationsincludeplantations,plantbreeding,andtextiletrading.

CORPORATESALESANDPROFITS

Thetotalcorporatesalesforthecompanyincreasefrom46,467million($59,719million)in
2011to51,324million($65,961million)in2012,upby10.4%.

Corporate net profits reach 4,948 million ($6,359 million) in 2012, up 7.0% from
4,623million($5,941million)in2011.

Since 2007, Unilevers sales have increased at a compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of
5.0%,andnetprofitshavegrownataCAGRof3.7%.

Table5179:UnileversGlobalCorporateSales,2007to2012

Million

Year

Sales

Netprofits

Marginonsales,%

2007

40,187

4,136

10.3

2008

40,523

5,285

13.0

2009

39,823

3,659

9.2

2010

44,262

4,598

10.4

2011

46,467

4,623

10.0

2012

51,324

4,948

9.6

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.

Withrevenuesof20,357million($26,162million),Asia,Africa,theMiddleEastandRussia
continuetoaccountfornearly40%ofUnileverssalein2012.

North,Central,andSouthAmericascombinedsalesaccountfor33.3%ofUnileverssales,
at17,088million($21,961million)in2012,surpassingEuropeasthesecondlargestregion
forUnileverin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A348

Unilever

Europeposts13,879million($17,837million)insalesin2012,accountingfor27.4%ofthe
companystotalsales.

Table5180:UnileversGlobalSalesbyRegion,2011and2012

Region

Million

%Oftotal

2011

2012

2011

2012

Change,%

Asia/AMET/RUB

17,723

20,357

38.1

39.7

14.9

TheAmericas

15,251

17,088

32.8

33.3

12.0

Europe

13,493

13,879

29.0

27.4

2.9

Total
46,467
51,324

NOTE:$1.00=0.7781.
AMETAfrica,theMiddleEast,andTurkey.
RUBRussia,Ukraine,andBelarus.

100.0

100.0

10.4

COSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

UnilevercontinuestobethethirdleadingmarketerofcosmeticsandtoiletriesintheUnited
States,withalargeportfolioofproductsthatincludeshaircareproducts,skincareproducts,
personal cleansing products, deodorants and antiperspirants, fragrances, and shaving
products.
In 2012, the U.S. sales of Unilevers cosmetics and toiletries total $3,546 million, up
4.1%from$3,406millionin2011.

Since2007,manufacturerssalesofUnileverhavegrownataCAGRof3.3%.

Table5181:UnileversCosmeticsandToiletries
SalesintheUnitedStates,2007to2012
Year

$Millionr

Change,%

2007

3,022

2008

3,037

0.5

2009

3,109

2.4

2010

3,206

3.1

2011

3,406

6.2

2012

3,546

4.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5349

5350

Unilever

The personal cleansing products category continues to be the largest category for the
marketerin2012,withsalesat$1,134millionin2012,up4.0%from$1,090millionin2011.
Unilever continues to be the largest marketer of personal cleansing products, with
28.2%ofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012.Themarketerimprovesitscategoryshare
from27.9%oftotalcategorysalesin2011to28.2%in2012.
Unilevercontinuestodominatethebarsoapsandthebodywashessegmentsin2012,
withadistinctlead.
Bar soaps is the largest segment for the marketer representing 52.2% of Unilevers
totalcategorysalesin2012.Doveremainstheleadingbrandinthebarsoapssegment,
with sales at $466million in 2012, up 5.9% from $440 million in 2011. The brands
share in the segment improves from 35.5% of the total segments sales in 2011 to
36.8%in2012.
Bodywashes,thesecondleadingsegmentforthemarketerinthepersonalcleansing
productscategory,accountsfor47.4%ofthemarketerssalesinthecategoryin2012.
Sales for the marketer are supported by a varied product portfolio, moderate new
product introductions, and a considerable traceable media expenditure (TME) of
$85.2millionin2012.
Doveistheleadingbrandforthemarketerinthepersonalcleansingproductscategory,
withsalesup5.9%to$680millionin2012,from$642millionin2011.
Dove continues to hold leadership positions in the bar soaps and body washes
segments.
Growthofthebrandissupportedbynewproductsintroductionsin2012,especiallyin
thebodywashessegment.
Furthermore,Dovespromiseofusingonefourthproportionasmoisturizingcreamin
itsbarsoapshelpsdrivesalesforthemarketer.Thisgivesconsumersasatisfactionthat
Dovebarsoapsnotonlyprovidecleansingbenefitsbutalsonourishandmoisturizethe
skinsimultaneously.
Dove also benefits from its Men+Care line of products which claim to contain one
fourthmoisturizinglotionandareavailableasbodywashesandbodybars.
Dove claims that its body and face wash variants are infused with Micromoisture
Technology that helps prevent skin dryness by replenishing the moisture levels. The
micromoistureioninthebodyandfacewashvariantsgetactivatedontheformation
oflatherandpreventanydiscomfortduetowoundandcuts.
In 2012, Doves Men+Care line of body and face washes is extended with the
introductionoftwomorevariants:FreshAwakeandCleanDefense.
Dovealsoenjoysaloyalcustomerbaseandgoodadvertisingsupportin2012.
In 2012, sales of Caress personal cleansing products advance 6.2% to reach $137
millionin2012,upfrom$129millionin2011.
Suave is the thirdleading personal cleansing brand for Unilever, with sales at
$133millionin2012,up3.1%from$129millionin2011.
Sales growth for the brand is aided by its affordable pricing and variants available in
ninedifferentfragrances.ThenewestadditionisEverlastingSunshine,a2012launch.
Further growth is due to its brand loyalty among consumers and its easy availability
acrossdifferentretailoutlets.
SalesofAxe,thefourthlargestbrandforthecompany,decline1.3%to$79millionin
2012 from $80million in 2011. The brand represents 5.8% of body washes sales in
2012,downfrom6.1%ofthesegmentssalesin2011.
In2012,salesofLever2000declined4.4%from$68millionin2011to$65millionin
2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A350

Unilever

Unilever continues to be the leading marketer in the deodorants and antiperspirants


categoryin2012.
Themarketerssalestotal$755millionin2012,up5.4%from$716millionin2011.
Thecompanysmarketshareincreasesfrom35.8%in2011to37.0%in2012.
UnileverspresenceinthecategoryisthroughitsDegree,Dove,Axe,andSuavebrands.
Degree is the leading deodorant brand for Unilever and the secondleading brand in
thedeodorantsandantiperspirantscategory,withsalesadvancing4.3%to$265million
in2012,upfrom$254millionin2011.
The brand represents 35.1% share of the marketers sales in the deodorants and
antiperspirantscategory.
Thebrandsustainsitsgrowthbecauseofitsloyalconsumerbaseandproductofferings
forbothmenandwomen.
In 2012, sales of the Degree brand are supported by the expansion of the womens
ExpertProtection,ClinicalProtection,andNatureEffectsInvisibleSolidsproductlines
withtheLinenDry,CottonFresh,andAbsorbentSeaSaltsvariants,respectively.
In 2012, the marketer also upgrades its Degree Men Adrenaline Series with motion
sensetechnology.Thetechnologyiscomposedofmotionactivatedmicrocapsulesthat
provideextraprotectiontocombatsweatandodor.TheDegreeMenAdrenalineSeries
withmotionsensetechnologycomprisesvariantssuchasAdventure,Extreme,Everest,
SportDefence,andV12.
DoveadvancestobecomethesecondlargestbrandforUnileverinthecategory.The
brandgrows14.2%toreach$209millionin2012,upfrom$183millionin2011.Dove
hasbeenpostinggoodgrowthsince2011.
Doveoffersdeodorantsandantiperspirantsforbothmenandwomen.
In2012,UnileverintroducestheDoveClearToneSkinRenew(forwomen)proclaiming
thatitsformula,enrichedwithcalendulaandsunflowerseedextracts,helpsaccelerate
the skins renewal process, provides 48hour odor and wetness protection, reduces
darkmarks,andprovidesanevenskintone.
Axe,thethirdlargestbrandforthecompany,grows0.5%from$206millionin2011to
$207millionin2012.
In2012,UnilevertakesamajorstepbyintroducingAxeAnarchy,thefirstfragrancein
thebrandshistorytargetingbothmenandwomen.ThebodysprayisallocatedaTME
of$22.9millionin2012,thehighestamonganyofUnileversbrandsinthedeodorants
and antiperspirants category in 2012. The Axe Anarchy For Her is a limited edition
product, with the marketer waiting to see the response that the market has for the
brandsfirstfemaleorientedproduct.
Suave, Unilevers smallest deodorant brand, records sales at $74 million in 2012, up
1.4%from$73millionin2011.Thebrandaccountsfor9.8%ofthemarketerssharein
thecategory.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5351

5352

Unilever

Unilever, the secondleading marketer in the shampoos category, has a 20.8% category
share.Thecompanyssalesgrow4.4%,from$523millionin2011to$546millionin2012.
SuavecontinuestobetheleadingbrandofUnileverinthecategory;andisthethird
largest brand in the category overall as well. Sales of the brand are up 3.8%, from
$186million in 2011 to $193million in 2012. New product activity and increased
marketingcontributetoSuavesperformanceinthecategory.UnileverlaunchesSuave
Professional Moroccan Infusion range of shampoos to support its growth in the
category.However,salesforSuavesmensvariant,SuaveforMen,declinemoderately
by2.9%from$34millionin2011to$33millionin2012.
ThesecondlargestbrandfromUnileverisTRESemm.Thebrandssalesdecline2.5%
from $120million in 2011 to $117million in 2012. Limited promotional activities
contributetothebrandssalesdeclineinthecategory.
Dove,thethirdlargestshampoobrandfromUnilever,declines5.3%from$76millionin
2011 to $72 million in 2012. Limited new product activity contributes to the brands
decline in 2012. The only significant product launch from Dove in 2012 is Damage
SolutionsColorCareShampoo.
Unileverlaunchesanewbrand,Clearinthecategoryin2012.Thebrandachievessales
of$30millioninitsfirstyearoflaunch.Significantmarketingandpromotionalactivity
supports the brands performance in the category. The marketer allocates
approximately$55.4milliontopromoteitsClearbrandin2012.
UnileverdiscontinuesitsSunsilkbrandin2012.

Unilever continues to be the leading marketer in the hair styling products and sprays
categoryin2012.
Unilevers share remains at 21.7% of the categorys sales in 2012, unchanged from
2011.
SalesforUnilevergrow1.4%from$359millionin2011to$364millionin2012.
Themarketersgrowthinthecategoryissupportedbynewproductactivity.
Unilever launches several new products including, TRESemm Body Hair Spray, Axe
GravityDefyingDustgel,andAxeSpikedUpSpray.
TRESemmistheleadingbrandofthecompany,withsalesat$124millionin2012,up
7.8%from$115millionin2011.Thegrowthofthebrandissupportedbyseveralnew
product introductions by Unilever in 2012. Some of the key launches under the
TRESemmbrandincludePlatinumStrengthDeepConditioningtreatmentandKeratin
SmoothHeatProtectionShineSpray.
The secondleading brand of the marketer, Suaves sales decline by 1.7% in 2012 to
reach $59million from $60million in 2011. The brands biggest strength, economical
pricing,doesnotbenefitSuaveinthecategory.Inthehairstylingcategory,consumers
increasingly purchase products with better performance, keeping pricing as a
secondary factor. Furthermore, negligible TME allocation at less than a million and
increasingcompetitionfromotherleadingbrandsoffsetsitssalesprospectin2012.
Limitednewproductactivityalsorestrictsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
SalesoftheAxebrandgrow3.8%from$26millionin2011to$27millionin2012.
In 2012, Unilever supports the brands sales with new product launches: Spiked Up
LookSpikingGlueandSpikedUpLookExtremeHoldingSpray.
Sales of Nexxus and Dove remain stagnant at $32million and $11 million in 2012,
respectively.
SalesofConsortdeclineby$1millionin2012to$11million,from$12millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A352

Unilever

Unilever, the leading marketer in the conditioners category, has a 21.9% share of the
categoryssalesin2012,slightlyupfrom21.3%in2011.
Salesforthemarketergrow7.7%from$336millionin2011to$362millionin2012.
UnileverprimarilybenefitswiththelaunchofanewbrandClearin2012.
Clear has sales of $27 million in 2012, as the brand benefits from its scalp therapy
rangeofconditioners.
ThelargestbrandfromUnileverisSuave,withacategoryshareof6.5%in2012.
Sales for Suave grow 4.9% from $103million in 2011 to $108million in 2012. New
productlaunchesandeconomicallypricedproductscontributetothebrandsgrowth.
TRESemm,thesecondlargestbrandforUnilever,hasanoverallshareof6.5%in2012.
SalesofTRESemmdeclineby1.8%from$109millionin2011to$107millionin2012.
Limitednewproductactivityoffsetsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory.
Dove,thethirdlargestbrandforUnilever,hasacategoryshareof4.0%in2012.
Salesforthebranddeclineby2.9%,from$68millionin2011to$66millionin2012.
Minimaladvertisingsupportcontributestothebrandsdeclineinthecategory.
Unilevers youthcentric brand Sunsilk is discontinued in 2012. Diminishing consumer
interestinthebrandresultsinthediscontinuationofthebrand.
The only professional brand marketed by Unilever in the category is TIGI, with the
brandssalesflatat$17million.

Unileveristhefifthleadingmarketerinthehandandbodylotionscategorywithdeclining
salesin2012.
Thecompanyssalesdecline4.3%from$207millionin2011to$198millionin2012.
ThemarketerisrepresentedinthecategorywithitsVaseline,Suave,Dove,andSt.Ives
brands.
Unileveraccountsfor8.7%shareofthetotalcategoryssalesin2012,downfrom9.2%
in2011.
Sales of Vaseline continue to decline in 2012 with sales at $108 million, down 5.3%
from$114millionin2011.
VaselineisbackedbyTMEof$41millionin2012,upfrom$28.4millionin2011.The
VaselineIntensiveMoisturelineisthemostadvertisedrangeofproductsforthebrand
with a TME allocation of approximately $20 million in 2012. However, the lack of
freshness in its product portfolio, negligible innovation, and increasing competition
fromotherbrandsresultinsalesdeclineforVaselinein2012.
Suaveisthesecondleadingbrandforthemarketerin2012withsalesat$52million,
down3.7%from$54millionin2011.Despitetheextensionofitshandandbodylotions
lineofproducts,thebrandisnotabletopostgrowthin2012.
SuaveintroducestheEverlastingSunshinefragrancetoitsalreadyexistingbodylotions
productlinein2012.
SalesofSt.Ivesremainstagnantat$32millionin2012,from2011levels.
SalesofDovecontinuetodeclineat14.3%from$7millionin2011to$6millionin2012.
AdeclineinsalesofDoveisduetonegligiblenewproductactivityandnoinnovations
orformulationchangesforthebrandin2012.
Dovehasalimitedpenetrationinthecategorywithonlyfourproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5353

5354

Unilever

Unilever is the secondleading marketer in the ethnic hair care products category with a
shareof11.5%in2012.
Salesforthecompanyremainflatat$39millionin2012,thesameasin2011.
Lackoftechnologicaladvancementsandlimitednewproductactivityaccountforsales
decline for Unilever in 2012. Limited distribution channels, with beauty supply stores
accountingforthemajority,offsetthemarketersgrowthinthecategory.
Soft & Beautiful is the leading brand for Unilever, accounting for 4.1% of the total
categoryssalesin2012,downfrom4.5%in2011.
Thebrandssalesdecline$1millionfrom$15millionin2011to$14millionin2012.
Soft&Beautifulhaspresenceintherelaxerkitsandthestylingaidssegments.
Lackofmarketingandpromotionalactivitieslimitsthebrandsgrowthinthecategory
in2012.
JustForMeandTCBaretiedforsecondplace,withsalesat$8millioneachin2012.
JustForMeisabrandespeciallyformulatedforchildrenintheagegroupof514years.
TCBisaneconomicalhaircarebranddesignedespeciallyforAfricanAmericanwomen.
SalesoftheMotionsbrandgrowby$1million,from$4millionin2011to$5millionin
2012.
Increasingnewproductactivitysupportsthebrandsgrowthin2012.Unileverlaunches
a range of Motions Naturally You products including shampoos, conditioners, and
stylingaidsin2012.

RECENTDEVELOPMENTS

In2012,UnileverisnamedasthesectorleaderintheDowJonesSustainabilityIndexesfor
the14thconsecutiveyear.

LinkedInhasnamedUnileverasthefifthmostdesirablecompanytoworkforin2012.

TheCatalystOrganizationhasrecognizedUnileverforitsworkondiversity.

Also in 2012, Christiansen Davis Bullock, a Texasbased firm files a complaint against
Unilever with respect to a false, deceptive, and misleading claim in connection with the
SuaveProfessionalKeratinInfusion30DaySmoothingKit.
Unileverdiscontinuestheproductandrecallsitfromallretailstores.

Acquisitionsanddivestitures

In 2012, Unilever integrates two acquisitions, Kalina, the Russian Personal Care Company,
andAlbertoCulver,theglobalhairandskincarecompany.
UnileverhasacquiredacontrollingstakeinKalinaforapproximately500million.
The acquisition will help Unilever boost its personal care business in fastgrowing
developingmarkets.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A354

Unilever

InJuly,2012,UnileverentersintoadefinitiveagreementtosellitsNorthAmericanfrozen
mealbusinesstoConAgraFoods.ThebrandsdivestedareBertollliandP.F.ChangsHome
Menu.
Thetotalcashconsiderationforthedealis$265million.
ThedivestitureiscompletedinAugust2012.
Unilever announces its definitive agreement for the sale of its global Skippy peanut
butterbusinesstoHormelFoodsinJanuary2013.Thetermsofagreementarevalued
at$700million.

MANAGEMENTCHANGES

Thecompanyhasnotmadesignificantchangestoitstopmanagementduring2012.

NEWPRODUCTS

Table5182:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyUnileverintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Axe

Conditioners

Apollo2in1shampooandconditionercombinescrispfruitanda
creamybackground,therebyrenderingauniquemasculinefragrance
tohair

Axe

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

AnarchyForHerisacombinationofappleandblackberrynotesatthe
top,softfloralsattheheart,andabaseofsandalwood,amber,and
vanilla

Axe

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

AnarchyForHimhasAxessignaturefragrancecomprisingfreshand
fruitynotesandnotesofsandalwoodandamber

Axe

Shampoos

Apollo2in1shampooandconditionercombinescrispsparklingfruits,
therebyrenderingauniquemasculinefragrancetohair

Axe

Hairstylingproducts
andsprays

TheGravityDefyingDustgelcontainhumidityresistantformula

Axe

Hairstylingproducts
andsprays

ExtremeSpikeUpHoldSpraykeepsthespikesfortheentireday

Caress

Personalcleansing
products

EndlessKissSilkeningBodyWashisenrichedwithmoisturebeadsand
containsthescentofvanillaandsandalwood

Caress

Personalcleansing
products

PassionateSpellFineFragranceElixirBodyWashisinfusedwiththe
scentofpassionfruitandfieryorangerosetoleavealingering
fragrance

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5355

5356

Unilever

Table5182:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyUnileverintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

Caress

Personalcleansing
products

SheerTwilightFineFragranceElixirBodyWashisaSilkyFragrance
Infusionofblackorchidandjuniperoil

Clear

Conditioners

TotalCareNourishingDailyconditioner,withitsadvancedcomplexof
vitaminsandnutrientsgentlycleansesandhelpsrestorethescalps
naturalmoisturebalance

Clear

Conditioners

Damage&ColorRepairDailyNourishingconditioner,cleansesgently
andhasadvancedcolorsafeformulathatprovidesprotectionfrom
dailydamage

Clear

Conditioners

VolumizingRootBoostconditionerprovidesspecialnourishingandall
dayvolumefromroottotip

Clear

Conditioners

StrongLengthsDailyConditionercontainsarichstrengtheningserum
tonurtureandprotecthairfrombreakage

Clear

Conditioners

MoisturizingDryScalpconditionercontainsanextrarichformulathat
nourishesdryscalpandhairtorestorenaturalmoisturebalance

Clear

Conditioners

FrizzControlconditionerhasagentlenourishingformulainfusedwith
asmoothingcomplex,provides24hourfrizzcontrol

Clear

Conditioners

UltraSheaconditionercontainsaformulainfusedwithNutritium10
TMMoistureLock,sheabutter,andnaturaloilsthatquenchesdryness
andlocksinmoisture

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpTherapyStrongLengthsNourishingshampoocontains
strengtheningserumandisformulatedwithNutrium10,amoisture
complexofvitaminsandnutrients

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpandHairTherapyCompleteCareAntiDandruffshampoo
nourishesdeeplyandhelpseliminatedandruffsymptoms,leavingthe
scalphealthy

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpandHairTherapyUltraSheaCleanseandNourishShampoois
enrichedwithsheabutterandnaturaloilsthathelpslockmoistureinto
dryscalpandleaveshairstrongandbeautiful

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpandHairTherapyTotalCareNourishingShampoocontains10
nutrientsandvitaminsthatnourishesscalpforstrong,beautifulhair

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpandHairTherapyDamage&ColorRepairNourishingShampoois
speciallyformulatedtonourishthescalpdeeply,creatingtheright
foundationforstrong,beautifulhair

Clear

Shampoos

ScalpandHairTherapyFrizzControlNourishingShampooprovidefrizz
controlandnourishesthehair

ClearMen

Shampoos

ScalpTherapy2in1AntiDandruffShampoocontainsginseng,mint,
andteatree

ClearMen

Shampoos

ScalpTherapyDailyStrongandFullAntiDandruffShampoocontains
BioNutrium10,ablendof10nutrientsandbotanicalactivesto
nourishdeeply

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A356

Unilever

Table5182:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyUnileverintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Description

ClearMen

Shampoos

ScalpTherapyClean&RefreshAntiDandruffDailyShampoohelps
eliminatedandruffsymptomsatthesourcewithpyrithionezinc

ClearMen

Shampoos

ScalpTherapyCoolSportMintAntiDandruffDailyShampoocontains
naturalmintandcleansesscalpandhair,leavinganextracooling
sensation

ClearMen

Shampoos

ScalpTherapy2In1DryScalpHydrationAntiDandruffShampoo
gentlycleansesandconditionstoleavehairmanageablewithadeep
cleansensation

Degree

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

ExpertProtectionLinenDrywithMotionsensetechnologyisinfused
withafloralgreenscenttoprovidefreshness

Degree

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

ClinicalProtectionCottonFreshwithMotionsensetechnologyis
infusedwiththefragranceofwhiterosepetalsandjasmineandoffers
odorprotectionthroughouttheday

Degree

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

NatureEffectsInvisibleSolidAbsorbentSeaSaltisablendofginger,
mint,andteaforlonglastingprotection

Dove

Deodorantsand
antiperspirants

ClearToneSkinRenewDeodorantprovides24hourodorandwetness
protection,helpsreducedarkmarks,providesanevenskintone,and
designednottoleavewhitemarks.ItisavailableinSkinRenew
InvisibleSolid,SheerTouchInvisibleSolid,andClinicalProtectionSkin
Renew

DoveMen+Care

Personalcleansing
products

FreshAwakeBody&FaceWashwithMicromoistureTechnologygets
activatedonceincontactwiththeskinandisclinicallyproventofight
skindryness

DoveMen+Care

Personalcleansing
products

CleanDefenseBody&FaceWashwithMicromoistureTechnologygets
activatedonceincontactwiththeskintoremoveoilbuildupand
maintaintheskinsmoisturelevels

Dove

Shampoos

TheDamageSolutionsColorCareshampoocleansandconditionscolor
treatedhair

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

MoisturizingCleansercontainssheabutter,coconut,andavocadooils

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

SmoothingConditionersoftensandnourisheseventhemost
unmanageablecurls,infusedwithingredientssheabutter,coconut,
andavocadooils

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

RadiatingGlossprovidesanaturalandevenluster,containsshea
butter

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

DefineMyCurlsisarichgelthatenhancesmoisturetodeliverthe
ultimatesoft,separatedcurls

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

HydratemyCurlshydratesandlightlydefinescurls,whilereducing
frizz

Motions

Ethnichaircare
products

DeepConditioningMasquecontainssheabutter

(Continued)

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5357

5358

Unilever

Table5182:SelectNewProductsIntroducedbyUnileverintheUnitedStatesin2012
Brand

Category

Nexxus

Conditioners

Ponds

Facialtreatments

Simple

Facialtreatments

Suave

Personalcleansing
products

Suave

Shampoos

Suave

Conditioners

TRESemm

Conditioners

TRESemm

Shampoos

TRESemm
TRESemm
TRESemm
TRESemm
TRESemm

Hairstylingproducts
andsprays
Hairstylingproducts
andsprays
Hairstylingproducts
andsprays
Hairstylingproducts
andsprays
Hairstylingproducts
andsprays

Description
FrizzDefyconditionercontainsMoroccanarganoilandcoconut
extract,thathelpcreatesmoothstylesandcontrolfrizzallday
LuminousCleanCreamCleansercontainswhitekaolinclay,anatural
mineralknowntoactlikeamagnettodrawoutdeepdwelling
impurities,andmoisturizingingredientssuchasglycerintohelpleave
skinsoftandsmooth
AfacialtreatmentlinenewtotheUnitedStatescontainingnodyes,
artificialperfumes,orharshirritantsandishypoallergenic,non
comedogenicandpHbalanced.Linecontainscleansers,wipes,
moisturizers,andproductsforusearoundtheeyearea
EverlastingSunshineBodyWashisenrichedwithvitaminEandthe
scentofpassionflowerandvanilla
DailyclarifyingshampooisapHbalancedshampoo,thathasnew
formulaforlongerlastingfragranceandissuitableforbothnormalas
wellasoilyhair
DailyclarifyingconditionerisapHbalancedconditioner,thatlightly
nourisheshairaftershampoo,andissuitableforbothnormalaswell
asoilyhair
SplitRemedyconditionerconditionsandmoisturizeshairstrandwhile
bindingupto80%ofsplitends
TheSplitRemedyshampoocontainsamoisturizingformulathatgently
cleansesandstrengthenshair
ThePlatinumStrengthHeatProtectSprayfortifiesandstrengthenshair
KeratinSmoothInfusingSmoothSerumhelpseliminatefrizzand
Illuminatesshine
KeratinSmoothInfusingSmoothSerumhelpseliminatefrizzand
Illuminatesshine
The24HourBodyhairspraycontainsasalonqualityformulathat
resistshumidityandfightsfrizz
TheNourishingRitualsRejuvenatingMasquecontainsdeadsea
minerals

MARKETINGACTIVITY

UnileversupportsitsbrandswithagenerousTMEof$522.3millionin2012,up14.0%from
$458.3millionin2011,spreadacrossalladvertisingmediaincludingtelevision,print,cable,
andtheInternet.
Thecompanysinitiativetonegotiateadvertisingandmarketingdealsdonegloballyin
order to customize them for the local regions and countries, helps in achieving
economiesofscale.
Unilever capitalizes on wordofmouth as an important means of communicating the
benefitsofitsproducts.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A358

Unilever

Dove, the marketers leading brand, represents 18.1% of Unilevers total TME at
$94.3millionin2012.
Majorityoftheadvertisingdollars,at$60.1millionor63.7%ofthebrandstotalTMEis
spentontelevisionadvertisements.
Doveswebsiteofferssamplesandcoupons.
Doveswebsitealsoallowsconsumerstosignupforitsnewslettertherebyhelpingthe
brandcommunicateitslatestpromotionsandoffers.Doveswebsitealsooffersspecial
beauty advices and tips to its consumers. The brands website also interacts with its
customersthroughvideos,quizzes,andgames.
Doveaddressestheissueofselfesteem,oneofthebiggestissuesfacedbyadolescent
girls around the world. The Dove Self Esteem Project, which encourages girls and
women to develop a positive relationship with beauty, has been successful in driving
growthforthebrand.
Dove spreads awareness about the SelfEsteem Weekend and its other social
initiatives through the social mission tab on its website. It also offers discount
couponsandallowsconsumerstoregisterfortheDovenewsletter,alsoknownasthe
DoveInsideronitswebsite.
TheDoveDeepMoistureBodyWashreceivesthemostTMEat$41.6millionin2012.
The Dove Deep Moisture Body Wash is enriched with a proprietary ingredient
NutriumMoisture, which claims to provide effective moisturization, to nourish skin
deepdown.
Doves Beauty Bar receives a TME of $18.3 million, while Dove Men+Care Bar Soaps
receiveaTMEof$2.7millionin2012.
DovesnewClearToneSkinRenewDeodorantisallocatedaTMEof$14.7million,while
theDoveGoSleevelesslineofproductsisallocatedaTMEof$15.9million.
DoveMen+Caresmarketingprimarilyrevolvesaroundsportspersonalitiesandsports.
In2012,UnileverpromotesitsDoveMen+CarelinethroughtheJourneytoComfort
campaign.
UndertheJourneytoComfortcampaign,thecompanyteamsupwithbasketballstars
ShaquilleONeal,SteveNash,andMichiganStateUniversityHeadCoach,TomIzzo.The
campaign gives sports fans a glimpse into their professional and personal lives, by
sharing unique stories and events that changed their lives, lessons learnt from their
familyandcoaches,andstrugglesenduredtoachievetheirgoalsintheformofvideos.
DoveMen+CareFacebookpageinitiatestheShaqsBigExcuseFacebookapplication,
whichallowsfanstosendcustomizedmessagestoacquaintancesandfriends.
Dove Men+Care also collaborates with Viggle, an application that allows fans who
checkintoNCAAbasketballgameswithinViggle,withachancetoearnextrapointsby
watchingtheJourneytoComfortvideos.
DoveMen+CareisthetitlesponsoroftheDad2.0Summit.Thesummithasaseriesof
eventswherebyapanelofspeakerspresentanumberofissuespertainingtothelives
of men including the importance of fatherhood. The brand offers men the chance to
havealivediscussionwithformerprofessionalfootballstar,DougFlutiebyloggingon
tothebrandsFacebookpagein2012.
Dove Men+Care also organizes a number of contests, such as the Fan Bowl Photo
Challengewiththeluckyparticipantsgettinganopportunitytowinprizesthroughout
theNCAAFootballSeason.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5359

5360

Unilever

In2012,AxereceivesaTMEofapproximately$72million,withthemajorityofthebrands
TMEat$59.4millionallocatedtowardstelevisionadvertisements.
In 2012, Unilever unleashes an online advertisement campaign for its Axe brand that
urgescollegestudentstoshowerwithafriendoranattractivestrangerinanattempt
toconservewater.Themarketercoinsthetermshowerpoolingforitscampaign.The
Showerpooling campaign encourages sustainable living routine with tongue in cheek.
The marketer introduces a few videos, with some featuring brand ambassador and
actress Nicki Reed as the narrator. The brand also distributes 7,000 waterefficient
DeltashowerheadswithH20KineticTechnologyduringitscampustouranddonates
$100,000 to the Alliance for Water Efficiency, a nonprofit organization dedicated to
theefficientandsustainableuseofwater
Axewasadvertisingitsproductbenefitsasgivingmentheedgeinthematinggame.
However, with the launch of the Axe Anarchy product, the marketer seems to be
changingthebrandsimagewiththeAxeAnarchysadvertisementfeaturingamanand
a woman walking towards each other passionately while the world collapses around
them, using the tag line Unleash the chaos. New Axe Anarchy for him and for her.
Thiscampaignnowsuggeststhatmenandwomenareequallyinvolvedinthecourting
process. The marketer launches a teaser campaign called Axe: Anarchy is Coming
which involves a graphic novel with consumers suggestions incorporated and some
beingdepictedinacomicroleplay.Thetelevisionadvertisementcampaignstartsearly
2012withsupportfromdigitalandoutdooractivity
One of the Axe brands campaigns, called the Axe Lounge, is hosted in Dallas. The
campaign,withitsbaseintheRioRoominDallas,includesperformancesbyGrammy
AwardnomineeCeeLoGreen,DJVice,Diplo,JermaineDupri,andothers.
Alsoleveragingitspresenceintheonlineandmobilemedia,thecompanylaunchesthe
AxeTwistRoulette,whichisabrandedapplicationforApplesiPhoneandiPodtouch.
Furthermore,anewWebbasedwidgetcalledtheAxeSprayaway,whichwheninstalled
ontheuserscomputercanbeusedtoblockunwantedwebcontent.
InordertopromotetheAxeshowerrange,thebrandhasanewtagline,TheCleaner
You Are, The Dirtier You Get and is also introducing a fourpart Web series in
association with Comedy Central Digital. The show has actor/comedian Rob Riggle as
host and pits coed teams against one another in challenges designed to get them as
messyaspossiblewithin90seconds.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A360

Unilever

Unilever overtakes Procter & Gamble to become the leading advertiser in the personal
cleansingproductscategoryin2012.
TheTMEofthemarketerisat$85.2millionwith$46.9millionor55.0%ofitstotalTME
spentontelevisionadvertising.
Dove, the leading brand of the marketer, accounts for 91.1% of the marketers total
TMEin2012.WithaTMEallocationof$41.6millionor48.8%ofthecompanystotal
TME,theDoveDeepMoisturebodywashisallocatedthehighestTMEin2012.
The marketer comes out with the Dove Truth Files game where consumers are
supposedtoputtheirbarsoapandbodywashtotestforachancetowingiftcardsand
cashprizes.
Axes personal cleansing products receive a TME of $2.4 million in 2012, down
aggressivelyfrom$9.5millionin2011.Axeispromotedinmagazinesandthecompany
allocates$2.0millionor83.3%ofthebrandstotalTMEtomagazineadvertising.
In2012,UnileveradvertisesitsAxebrandinacontroversialonlinecampaignthaturges
college students to conserve water by showering with a friend or an attractive
stranger,aconceptthatthemarketertermsshowerpooling.
In2012,AxeteamsupwithmodelKateUptonandprofootballplayerJasonPierrePaul
to promote its newly launched Axe Sport Blast 2in1 shower gel and shampoo. Kate
Upton and Jason PierrePaul host the Axe Sport Blast Combine House, a competitive
partyspacewherethetwosquareoffinaseriesofchallenges.
In addition to television and magazine advertisements, social media also plays an
important role in promoting the marketers offers, discount coupons, or any new
productsintroductions.

Unilever continues to be the leading advertiser in the deodorants and antiperspirants


categorywithTMEof$134.6millionin2012,up11.4%from$120.8millionin2011.
UnileversDegreebrandisthemostadvertisedbrandwithinthemarketersportfolioof
deodorantsandantiperspirantsin2012.
Degreereceivesadvertisingsupportof$56.9millionin2012.
Dovereceivesthesecondhighestadvertisingexpenditureat$49.8millionin2012.The
combinedTMEofDoveGoSleevelessandDoveClearTonetotals$30.7million.
Unilever further reduces the advertising expenses of its Axe brand in 2012 to
$27.9million,adeclineof1.1%from$28.2millionin2011.
Withanallocationof72.1%ofthetotalTME,televisionadvertisementsarethemost
importantmeansofadvertisingadoptedbythemarketer.

Secondleadingmarketerintheshampooscategory,UnileverhasaTMEof$103.3millionin
2012,upsignificantlyby94.9%from$53.0millionin2011.
Themarketersignificantlyspends$55.4milliontopromoteitsClearbrandin2012.
In2012,TMEsforUnileversleadingbrandSuaveare$19.4millionandTRESemmhas
aTMEof$11.6million.
Approximately$78.3millionor75.7%ofthetotalTMEisspentontelevisionadvertising,
followedbymagazineadvertisingwith$19.2million.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5361

5362

Unilever

Unilever is the leading advertiser in the hair styling products category with a TME of
$39.2millionin2012,downfrom$55.7millionin2011.
DoveStyleCarerangeisthehighestadvertisedhairstylingvariantfromUnilever,with
aTMEsupportofover$17.6millionin2012.
Dove receives a TME support of $22.5 million or 57.3% of the marketers advertising
expenditurein2012.
Axe receives only $5.4 million or 13.7% of the marketers advertising expenditure in
2012.

Unilever has the secondhighest media spending in the conditioners category. Unilevers
advertisingspendingonpromotingitsconditionersis$12.6million.
Approximately,55.8%or$7.6millionisspentonpromotingitsDovebrand.

In the hand and body lotions category, Unilever endorses its Vaseline brand with nearly
$41millioninTME,with54.9%at$22.5millionspentonmagazineadvertisements.

UnileverusestheInternettosharenewsaboutitsproducts,educateconsumersaboutits
products, offer coupons, and instantly establish a rapport with the consumers by offering
additionalactivitiessuchasgamesormultimediaapplications.

The marketer also employs the use of social media to interact with consumers, share
information about new products, information about brand ambassadors, and organizes
eventstopromoteitsproductlaunches.
The usage of social media also allows consumers to ask questions and give opinions
aboutaproductthattheyhaverecentlyused.

OUTLOOK

Unileverisexpectedtopostmodestgrowthof2.7%overtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Unileverexperiencesastrongyearin2012,buildingonitsgoodperformancein2011.
Unilever will continue to strengthen its management team by appointing employees
basedontheirexperience,skills,backgrounds,knowledge,andinsights.
Thecompanywillcontinuetostrengthenitsportfolioofbrandsbyperformingstrategic
acquisitionsanddisposingunprofitablebusinesses.
Continuous introductions of impactful innovations will be a key growth driver for
Unileverduringtheforecastperiodending,2017.
The company will continue to make efforts towards transforming Unilever into a
sustainablecompany.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A362

Unilever

Unileverwillcontinuetobenefitfromitsstrongrelationshipwithitsretailers,ensuring
smooth movement of its brands from retail shelves. The marketer benefits from
consumers loyalty to its brands, which will help Unilever increase its sales over the
next five years. Further, Unilevers Onshelf availability measures the product
availabilityontheshelfandensuresthattheproductisavailablewhileconsumersare
shoppinginretailoutlets.
Efforts will be directed toward improving the supply chain efficiencies while keeping
costscompetitive.
Thecompanyisexpectedtotakenaturalproductsseriouslywithsomeofitsbrands
implementingnaturalformulationswhiletakingintoaccountcostandavailability.
The marketer will continue to support its brands with aggressive media and
promotionalactivity.

Thecompanywillcontinuetofocusondevelopingandstrengtheningitsstrongbrands.
Innovationwillbethekeydriverindevelopingthesebrands.
Unilever will also continue to invest in brand equity in order to strengthen the
connectionsbetweenconsumersanditsbrands.
Innovating with superior products that appeal to the consumers would be of prime
importancetothemarketer.
Itwillcontinuetofocusondevelopingitspremiumportfolioofbrandsacrossvarious
personalcarecategories.
It is expected to continue to elevate the brand image of Dove as a supporter of all
women and their self esteem, as evidenced with the continuation of its Real Beauty
campaignin2013.Unileverhiresaforensicsketchartisttodrawwomenbytheirown
descriptions of themselves, and then again by someone elses description. By
comparingthetwodrawings,themessageisyouaremorebeautifulthanyouthink.
Thevideogoesviralwhenitreleased.

Unileverisexpectedtoachievesustainablegrowthduringtheforecastperiod,2012to2017.
Thecompanyisexpectedtoreducegreenhousegasimpactonitsproducts.
Unileverislikelytohalvethewasteassociatedwiththedisposalofitsproducts.
By 2020, the marketer is expected to source 100% of its agricultural raw materials
sustainably.
In2012,UnileverteamsupwithU.S.basedenvironmentalresearchcompanyEarth911
to determine whether or not, the millions of deodorant sticks that are thrown away
each year, can be recycled. The companies also utilize the help of students from 50
schoolsandcollegestocollectuseddeodorantsticksthatcanbetestedforrecycling.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5363

5364

Unilever

The company is expected to strengthen its R&D efforts over the course of the forecast
period.
Unilevers six major laboratories located across the world in conjunction with its
regional center in the United States will help it discover its potential to innovate
through2017.
During the course of the next year, the company will expand manufacturing at its
productionfacilityatRaeford,NC.Theinvestmentintheproductionfacilitywillamount
to $29.9 million and will be developed with the aim of meeting increasing
manufacturingcosts.Theexpansionwillalsoresultinthecreationof21newjobposts.

Unileverwillcontinuetoaccelerateitspresencebywideningitsdistributionnetwork.
Thethreechannelswhichhavedemonstratedgoodgrowthin2012includedrugstores,
ecommerce,andoutofhome.
Thecompanyplanstoexpanditsdistributionnetworkbyincreasinglypartneringwith
retailers.

Unilevers acquisition of AlbertoCulver towards the end of 2010 helps the hair care
businessgrow.
The acquisition has expanded the companys hair care brands portfolio with the
inclusionofrenownedbrandssuchasTRESemm,Simple,andVO5.

Unilevers personal care portfolio, which is focused towards hair care and other toiletries
productclasses,isprojectedtoshowconsiderablegrowthduringtheforecastperiod.
Increasedproductpricing,asaresultoftheaddedbenefitsandadvancedtechnology,
incategorieslikedeodorantsandantiperspirants,skincare,andhaircare,willfurther
aidsalesgrowth.
Unileverwillcontinuetocapitalizeonitsflagshipbrand,Dove,whichbenefitsfromits
strong brand loyalty among the women consumers, seeking moisturizing as a key
benefitinpersonalcareproducts.
Unilever will continue to gain from the strong brand loyalty for its brands which will
benefititinthecomingyears.
However,thelackofnewproductlaunchesorinnovationcanseriouslydampengrowth
prospectsforUnilever.

The personal cleansing category, the strongest category for Unilever, is projected to
continuetodevelopduringtheforecastperiod.
Thecompanyisexpectedtocontinuetostrengthenitsmajorbrandsinthecategory,
Dove,Caress,Axe,andSuave,bywideningthechoiceofproductsavailable,freshenthe
portfolioofproducts,andmeetcompetingmarketersinthecategory.
Innovationinthematurecategoryisofkeyimportanceforthecompanytoattainsales
in the category. Innovation can be in the form of bright, colorful, and attractive
packagingandadditionalbenefitssuchasmoisturizing,whichwillhelpdrivegrowthfor
thecompanyinthefuture.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A364

Unilever

Thematuredeodorantsandantiperspirantscategorywillbeanotherkeypointofsalesfor
thecompanyduringtheforecastperiod.
Dove has done particularly well in 2012, and is likely to continue its healthy growth
through the forecast period, mainly due to the good performance of its Dove
Men+Carelineofproductsthataretargetedtowardsmen.
Axe,anotherleadingbrandforthecompany,willcontinuetogrowanddowellwithits
targetaudiencebeingtheyoungergenerationofmen.
TheintroductionofAnarchyforHerin2012sparksinterestamongwomentotrythe
limitededitionbodyspray.Thecompanyislikelytocomeoutwithalineofbodysprays
anddeodorantsforwomenduringtheforecastperiod.

Unileverisshowingstrongsignsofgainingafootholdinthegrowingmalegroomingmarket.
Thecompanysmalecentricbrands,AxeandDoveMen+Care,aredoingwellin2012
andwillcontinuewiththeirgrowththroughtheforecastperiod.
Vaseline,oneofthefewmassbrandsintheskincareformencategorydominatedby
prestigebrands,willattempttomakeamarkinthecategory.

ThehaircareproductclasswillemergestrongerforUnileverduringtheforecastperiod.
TheacquisitionofAlbertoCulverhassolidifiedthecompanyspositioninthehaircare
productclass.ItwilladdstrengthtoUnileverscurrentproductportfolio.
AlbertCulversbrandsacquiredbyUnileverTRESemmandNexxusaresomeofthe
leadingnamesinthehaircaremarketandwillprovidethecompanywithanextensive
portfolioofproducts.
Thisadvantageislikelytoincreasesalesandmoreinnovativeentriesofnewerproducts
byUnilever.
Salesareexpectedtogrowextensivelyinthehaircareproductclass,asthecompany
providesitsconsumerswithawiderangeofproductscoveringdifferentpricepoints.

ManufacturerssalesforUnileverscosmeticsandtoiletriesareforecasttogrowatCAGRof
2.7%toreach$4,051millionby2017,upfrom$3,546millionin2012.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

5365

5366

Unilever

Table5183:ForecastDollarSalesGrowthofCosmeticsand
ToiletriesforUnileverbyProductCategory,2012to2017
Productcategory

CAGR,%

Skincareproductsformen

5.9

Personalcleansingproducts

3.2

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

3.1

Shampoos

2.9

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2.9

COMPANYAVERAGE

2.7

Facialtreatments

2.6

Conditioners

2.5

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1.5

Fragrancesforwomen

1.4

Handandbodylotions

1.2

Ethnichaircareproducts

0.5

Fragrancesformen

Shavingproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A366

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSA

Advertising

SectionSeven

Cosmetics&ToiletriesUSAContinuingService

ADVERTISING

SectionSevenof

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESUSA

ContinuingService

Thisreportandthesurveyonwhichitisbased
werepreparedunderthedirectionof:

CARRIEMELLAGE
Director,ConsumerProducts
KlineMarketResearch
+19734353412
Carrie.Mellage@klinegroup.com

Copyright2013Kline&Company,Inc.

Circulationofthisreportisrestrictedtoemployeesofsubscribingcompaniesandsubsidiariesin
whichthesecompaniesholdmorethanahalfinterest.Itscontentsmustnotbedisclosedtoany
otherpersonsororganizationsbeforeJune15,2016.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

SPECIALNOTICE

Each company subscribing to COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA Continuing Service, including


thosecompaniessubscribingtosectionsofthesurvey,hasagreedthat,forthreeyearsfromits
dateofissue,theywill:

1. Refrainfromreproducingthisreport,inwholeorinpart,byanymeans.

2. Restrict circulation of this report to its own employees and those of


subsidiaries in which it has more than a half interest, or of parent
organizations which have more than a half interest in the subscribing
company.

3. Takeallreasonableprecautionstopreventthedisclosureofthecontents
ofthisreporttoanyotherpersonsororganizations.

Accordingly, COSMETICS& TOILETRIES USA cannot be reproduced and must be restricted to


employees of subscribing companies and their subsidiaries, as defined above, until June 15,
2016.Similarly,allsectionsofthesurveyaresorestrictedforthreeyearsfromtheirdatesof
issue. Failure to prevent unauthorized disclosure before these dates will result in legal action
againstthesubscriber.

Kline&Company,Inc.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

Servingthe

COSMETICS&TOILETRIESINDUSTRY

throughconsultingservices:

Acquisitionassessments
Competitiveintelligence
Industry/category/brandanalyses
Newbusinessdevelopment
Profitability/financialanalyses
Strategicanalyses

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

TABLEOFCONTENTS

Page

INTRODUCTION....................................................................................................................71
Scope................................................................................................................................71
Source..............................................................................................................................71
Format..............................................................................................................................71

THEPRODUCTS.....................................................................................................................77
Introduction.....................................................................................................................77
Babycareproducts..........................................................................................................77
Conditioners.....................................................................................................................77
Dentureproducts.............................................................................................................78
Deodorantsandantiperspirants......................................................................................78
Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches...................................................................................78
Ethnichaircareproducts.................................................................................................79
Eyemakeup......................................................................................................................79
Facemakeup....................................................................................................................79
Facialtreatments...........................................................................................................710
Fragrancesformen........................................................................................................710
Fragrancesforwomen...................................................................................................710
Haircareproductsmultiproduct...............................................................................711
Haircoloringproducts...................................................................................................711
Hairstylingproductsandsprays....................................................................................711
Handandbodylotions...................................................................................................712
Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments..................................................................................712
Lipsticksandlipglosses..................................................................................................712
Mouthwashes................................................................................................................713
Nailpolishes...................................................................................................................713
Personalcleansingproducts..........................................................................................713
Shampoos.......................................................................................................................714
Shavingproducts............................................................................................................714
Skincareproductsformen............................................................................................714
Suncareproducts..........................................................................................................715
Toothbrushes.................................................................................................................715
Toothpastes...................................................................................................................715
Toothwhiteningproducts.............................................................................................716
Othercosmeticsandtoiletries.......................................................................................716

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

TABLEOFCONTENTS
(Continued)

Page

MAJORCOMPANIES...........................................................................................................717
Introduction...................................................................................................................717
Alticor.............................................................................................................................717
Avon...............................................................................................................................717
Beiersdorf.......................................................................................................................718
Chanel............................................................................................................................718
Church&Dwight............................................................................................................718
Clarins.............................................................................................................................719
ColgatePalmolive..........................................................................................................719
Combe............................................................................................................................719
Coty................................................................................................................................720
ElizabethArden..............................................................................................................720
EnergizerHoldings.........................................................................................................720
EsteLauder...................................................................................................................721
GlaxoSmithKline.............................................................................................................721
GuthyRenker.................................................................................................................721
HelenofTroy..................................................................................................................722
Henkel............................................................................................................................722
Johnson&Johnson........................................................................................................722
Kao.................................................................................................................................723
LimitedBrands...............................................................................................................723
LOral............................................................................................................................724
LVMH..............................................................................................................................724
MaryKay........................................................................................................................724
Merck.............................................................................................................................725
Procter&Gamble..........................................................................................................725
Revlon............................................................................................................................726
Sanofi.............................................................................................................................726
Shiseido..........................................................................................................................727
TheCloroxCompany......................................................................................................727
Unilever..........................................................................................................................728

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

INTRODUCTION

SCOPE

TheAdvertisingsectionofCosmetics&ToiletriesUSAconsistsofmediaspendingdatareported
for product categories and major companies, profiled in sections four and five of this report,
respectively.Asummaryoftraceablemediaexpenditures(TME)andU.S.salesofcosmeticsand
toiletries by company and by category are shown in Table71, Table72, Table73, and
Table74.

SOURCE

AdvertisingexpendituresarebasedonKline&Companysanalysisofadspendingdatasourced
primarily from Kantar Media and Publishers Information Bureau, who copyright this service.
Thefollowingmediaoutletsaretracked:

Television(TVnetwork,spot,cable,syndicated)
Magazines
Outdoor
Newspapers
Radio
Internet

FORMAT

Products

Asixyearsummaryofadspendingandsalesdataisprovidedforthe26cosmeticsandtoiletries
categories,includingaratioofTMEtosales.

Two special advertising analyses are included. The first analysis, hair care products multi
products, details media dollars for complete hair care lines or two or more products. The
other cosmetics and toiletries advertising summary presents media expenditures for those
productsthatcannotbedesignatedtoanyofthe26categoryspecificanalyses.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

12

Introduction

Fragrance advertisements that feature both mens and womens fragrances are reported
mainlyinthefragrancesforwomencategory.

Table71:ProductCategoriesRankedbyTraceableMediaExpenditures,2012
Category

$Million

%Oftotal

1,334

21.2

Shampoos

446

7.1

Facemakeup

438

6.9

Eyemakeup

379

6.0

Toothpastes

338

5.4

Fragrancesforwomen

325

5.2

Othercosmeticsandtoiletries

322

5.1

Handandbodylotions

297

4.7

Haircoloringproducts

297

4.7

Lipsticksandlipglosses

277

4.4

Haircareproductsmultiproduct

255

4.0

Nailpolishes

240

3.8

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

224

3.6

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

165

2.6

Personalcleansingproducts

154

2.4

Fragrancesformen

135

2.1

Conditioners

119

1.9

Mouthwashes

105

1.7

Suncareproducts

80

1.3

Toothwhiteningproducts

79

1.3

Dentureproducts

61

1.0

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

57

0.9

Babycareproducts

55

0.9

Toothbrushes

42

0.7

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

33

0.5

Shavingproducts

31

0.5

Skincareproductsformen

16

0.3

6,305

100.0

Facialtreatments

Ethnichaircareproducts
Total

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A2

Introduction

Table72:LeadingCosmeticandToiletryCompaniesRankedbyTraceableMedia
Expenditures,2012
Company

$Million

L'Oral

1,448

23.0

Procter&Gamble

1,217

19.3

Unilever

522

8.3

Johnson&Johnson

440

7.0

EsteLauder

386

6.1

GuthyRenker

304

4.8

Coty

283

4.5

Revlon

161

2.6

Kao

131

2.1

GlaxoSmithKline

130

2.1

ColgatePalmolive

110

1.7

LVMH

90

1.4

Chanel

87

1.4

Church&Dwight

66

1.0

ElizabethArden

57

0.9

Shiseido

52

0.8

Sanofi

51

0.8

Combe

39

0.6

EnergizerHoldings

33

0.5

Clarins

27

0.4

Beiersdorf

26

0.4

MaryKay

18

0.3

Merck

18

0.3

Avon

13

0.2

Alticor

12

0.2

HelenofTroy

12

0.2

TheCloroxCompany

10

0.2

Henkel

0.1

LimitedBrandsa

555

8.8

6,305

100.0

Allother
Total

aTMEdatanegligible.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

%Oftotal

13

14

Introduction

Table73:TraceableMediaExpendituresofCosmeticandToiletryProductCategoriesRankedby
PercentageofSales,2012

Category

Traceablemediaexpenditures
$Million

$Million

%Ofsales

Nailpolishes

662

240

36.3

Depilatories,waxes,andbleaches

163

57

35.0

Toothwhiteningproducts

271

79

29.2

Haircoloringproducts

1,317

297

22.6

Lipsticksandlipglosses

1,377

277

20.1

Facialtreatments

6,645

1,334

20.1

Toothpastes

1,749

338

19.3

Dentureproducts

318

61

19.2

Babycareproducts

288

55

19.1

Shampoos

2,620

446

17.0

Facemakeup

2,909

438

15.1

Eyemakeup

2,709

379

14.0

799

105

13.1

Handandbodylotions

2,283

297

13.0

Fragrancesformen

1,101

135

12.3

Fragrancesforwomen

2,717

325

12.0

Deodorantsandantiperspirants

2,040

224

11.0

Hairstylingproductsandsprays

1,680

165

9.8

Skincareproductsformen

169

16

9.5

Lipbalms,jellies,andtreatments

374

33

8.8

Shavingproducts

373

31

8.3

Suncareproducts

1,048

80

7.6

Conditioners

1,653

119

7.2

741

42

5.7

4,026

154

3.8

340

0.3

Othercosmeticsandtoiletries

322

Haircareproductsmultiproduct

255

Total
40,372
6,305

aSalesincludedinvariouscategories.
bAdjustedtoexcludehaircaremultiproducttoavoiddoublecounting.

15.6

Mouthwashes

Toothbrushes
Personalcleansingproducts
Ethnichaircareproducts

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A4

Introduction

Table74:TraceableMediaExpendituresofLeadingCosmeticandToiletryCompaniesRankedby
PercentageofSales,2012

Company

Traceablemediaexpenditures

U.S.salesofcosmeticsand
toiletries,$million

$Million

%Ofsales

GuthyRenker

737

304

41.2

GlaxoSmithKline

407

130

31.9

4,551

1,448

31.8

337

90

26.7

1,086

283

26.1

Sanofi

197

51

25.9

Kao

525

131

25.0

Combe

157

39

24.8

2,020

440

21.8

313

66

21.1

5,824

1,217

20.9

Revlon

814

161

19.8

ElizabethArden

290

57

19.7

Chanel

461

87

18.9

Clarins

171

27

15.8

Unilever

3,546

522

14.7

EsteLauder

2,722

386

14.2

ColgatePalmolive

1,493

110

7.4

Shiseido

542

52

9.6

Merck

209

18

8.6

EnergizerHoldings

396

33

8.3

HelenofTroy

147

12

8.2

Beiersdorf

344

26

7.6

Alticor

176

12

6.8

TheCloroxCompany

172

10

5.8

1,063

18

1.7

Avon

948

13

1.4

Henkel

635

1.1

LimitedBrandsa

1,785

Allother

8,304

555

6.7

40,372

6,305

15.6

L'Oral
LVMH
Coty

Johnson&Johnson
Church&Dwight
Procter&Gamble

MaryKay

Total

aTMEdatanegligible.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

15

16

Introduction

Companies

Similar to the product ad spending section, TME and cosmetics and toiletries sales data are
reported here for 2007 through 2012 for 29 major companies. In cases where companies or
brandshavechangedownership,arenewlyformed,orhaverecentlybecomeamajorplayerin
thecosmeticsandtoiletriesindustry,historicaldatamaybelimited.

Unless otherwise stated, acquisitions and divestitures are incorporated into the current year
only.Historicalsalesandtraceablemediaexpendituresgenerallyonlyreflectbrandsownedby
thatcompanyatthetime.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A6

THEPRODUCTS

INTRODUCTION

The following pages provide summaries of ad spending and sales data for the 26 product
categoriesprofiledinthisreport.
Pleasenotethatnumbersinallthetablesbelowarerounded.

BABYCAREPRODUCTS

Table75:TraceableMediaExpendituresforBabyCareProducts,
2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

286

39

13.6

2008

278

3.2

2009

278

29

10.4

2010

278

40

14.4

2011

283

39

13.8

2012

288

55

19.1

CONDITIONERS

Table76:TraceableMediaExpendituresforConditioners,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

1,561

109

7.0

2008

1,561

45

2.9

2009

1,497

44

2.9

2010

1,525

76

5.0

2011

1,578

41

2.6

2012

1,653

119

7.2

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

78

TheProducts

DENTUREPRODUCTS

Table77:TraceableMediaExpendituresforDentureProducts,2007
to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
320
320
319
320
314
318

%TMEofsales
11.6
8.5
11.9
12.5
20.4
19.2

TME
37
27
38
40
64
61

DEODORANTSANDANTIPERSPIRANTS

Table78:TraceableMediaExpendituresforDeodorantsand
Antiperspirants,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
1,869
1,909
1,911
1,942
1,999
2,040

TME
339
295
276
269
220
224

%TMEofsales
18.1
15.5
14.4
13.8
11.0
11.0

DEPILATORIES,WAXES,ANDBLEACHES

Table79:TraceableMediaExpendituresforDepilatories,Waxes,and
Bleaches,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
136
139
138
135
144
163

TME
40
37
22
26
34
57

%TMEofsales
29.4
26.8
15.9
19.4
23.6
35.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A8

TheProducts

ETHNICHAIRCAREPRODUCTS

Table710:TraceableMediaExpendituresforEthnicHairCare
Products,2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
316
305
314
328
333
340

TME
27
23
7
20
6
1

%TMEofsales
8.5
7.5
2.2
6.1
1.8
0.3

rRestated.

EYEMAKEUP

Table711:TraceableMediaExpendituresforEyeMakeupProducts,
2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
2,133
2,200
2,304
2,431
2,621
2,709

TME
198
244
278
348
418
379

%TMEofsales
9.3
11.1
12.1
14.3
15.9
14.0

rRestated.

FACEMAKEUP

Table712:TraceableMediaExpendituresforFaceMakeup
Products,2007to2012

$ Million
Salesr
2,507
2,537
2,549
2,655
2,804
2,909

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

TME
247
317
242
349
431
438

%TMEofsales
9.9
12.5
9.5
13.1
15.4
15.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

79

710

TheProducts

FACIALTREATMENTS

Table713:TraceableMediaExpendituresforFacialTreatments,2007
to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
5,762
5,923
5,859
6,091
6,360
6,645

TME
901
844
854
1,169
1,221
1,334

%TMEofsales
15.6
14.2
14.6
19.2
19.2
20.1

FRAGRANCESFORMEN

Table714:TraceableMediaExpendituresforFragrancesforMen,
2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
1,180
1,108
1,010
1,024
1,063
1,101

TME
199
184
188
176
205
135

%TMEofsales
16.9
16.6
18.6
17.1
19.3
12.3

FRAGRANCESFORWOMEN

Table715:TraceableMediaExpendituresforFragrancesfor
Women,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
2,706
2,546
2,379
2,444
2,612
2,717

TME
401
372
285
467
455
325

%TMEofsales
14.8
14.6
12.0
19.1
17.4
12.0

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A10

TheProducts

HAIRCAREPRODUCTSMULTIPRODUCT

Table716:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHairCareProducts
MultiProduct,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Milliona
Salesr
5,585
5,563
5,405
5,536
5,737
5,953

TME
499
438
109
129
232
255

%TMEofsales
8.9
7.9
2.0
2.3
4.0
4.3

aIncludesconditioners,shampoos,andhairstylingproductsandsprays.
rRestated.

HAIRCOLORINGPRODUCTS

Table717:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHairColoringProducts,
2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
Salesr
1,277
1,291
1,257
1,280
1,323
1,317

TME
277
295
227
293
339
297

%TMEofsales
21.7
22.9
18.1
22.9
25.6
22.6

rRestated.

HAIRSTYLINGPRODUCTSANDSPRAYS

Table718:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHairStylingProducts
andSprays,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
Salesr
1,713
1,695
1,632
1,650
1,658
1,680

TME
186
123
82
184
236
165

%TMEofsales
10.9
7.3
5.0
11.2
14.2
9.8

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

711

712

TheProducts

HANDANDBODYLOTIONS

Table719:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHandandBodyLotions,
2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
Salesr
2,160
2,172
2,192
2,208
2,240
2,283

TME
384
311
267
230
276
297

%TMEofsales
17.8
14.3
12.2
10.4
12.3
13.0

rRestated.

LIPBALMS,JELLIES,ANDTREATMENTS

Table720:TraceableMediaExpendituresforLipBalms,Jellies,and
Treatments,2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
337
351
342
347
357
374

TME
28
34
40
33
27
33

%TMEofsales
8.3
9.7
11.7
9.5
7.6
8.8

rRestated.

LIPSTICKSANDLIPGLOSSES

Table721:TraceableMediaExpendituresforLipsticksandLip
Glosses,2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
1,397
1,311
1,252
1,248
1,352
1,377

TME
236
170
193
217
265
277

%TMEofsales
16.9
13.0
15.4
17.4
19.6
20.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A12

TheProducts

MOUTHWASHES

Table722:TraceableMediaExpendituresforMouthwashes,
2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
Sales
735
779
761
759
782
799

TME
135
17
7
11
145
105

%TMEofsales
18.4
2.2
0.9
1.5
18.5
13.1

rRestated.

NAILPOLISHES

Table723:TraceableMediaExpendituresforNailPolishes,2007to
2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
305
307
341
406
564
662

TME
31
41
46
55
117
240

%TMEofsales
10.2
13.4
13.5
13.5
20.7
36.3

rRestated.

PERSONALCLEANSINGPRODUCTS

Table724:TraceableMediaExpendituresforPersonalCleansing
Products,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$ Million
Salesr
3,473
3,558
3,686
3,792
3,907
4,026

TME
240
314
297
378
281
154

%TMEofsales
6.9
8.8
8.1
10.0
7.2
3.8

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

713

714

TheProducts

SHAMPOOS

Table725:TraceableMediaExpendituresforShampoos,2007to
2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
2,311
2,307
2,276
2,361
2,501
2,620

TME
165
196
422
284
137
446

%TMEofsales
7.1
8.5
18.5
12.0
5.5
17.0

rRestated.

SHAVINGPRODUCTS

Table726:TraceableMediaExpendituresforShavingProducts,
2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
345
336
341
348
362
373

TME
17
25
34
41
57
31

%TMEofsales
4.9
7.4
10.0
11.8
15.7
8.3

rRestated.

SKINCAREPRODUCTSFORMEN

Table727:TraceableMediaExpendituresforSkinCareProductsfor
Men,2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
143
151
146
143
154
169

TME
11
17
69
25
5
16

%TMEofsales
7.7
11.3
47.3
17.5
3.2
9.5

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A14

TheProducts

SUNCAREPRODUCTS

Table728:TraceableMediaExpendituresforSunCareProducts,
2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
769
844
860
933
984
1,048

TME
82
78
73
61
77
80

%TMEofsales
10.7
9.2
8.5
6.5
7.8
7.6

rRestated.

TOOTHBRUSHES

Table729:TraceableMediaExpendituresforToothbrushes,2007to
2012
$ Milliona
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
726
730
725
718
725
741

TME
69
115
49
49
51
42

%TMEofsales
9.5
15.9
6.8
6.8
7.0
5.7

aBatteryoperatedtoothbrushesareexaminedaspartofthisstudy
startingin2007.
rRestated.

TOOTHPASTES

Table730:TraceableMediaExpendituresforToothpastes,2007to2012

$ Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
1,622
1,682
1,678
1,664
1,715
1,749

TME
287
291
139
324
362
338

%TMEofsales
17.7
17.3
8.3
19.5
21.1
19.3

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

715

716

TheProducts

TOOTHWHITENINGPRODUCTS

Table731:TraceableMediaExpendituresforToothWhitening
Products,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

273

148

54.2

2008

281

112

39.9

2009

285

123

43.2

2010

287

70

24.3

2011

287

72

25.1

2012

271

79

29.2

OTHERCOSMETICSANDTOILETRIES

Othercosmeticsandtoiletriesincludemediaexpendituresforthoseproductsthatcannot
bedesignatedtoonespecificcategoryortothemultiproducthaircareanalysis.

TME for other cosmetics and toiletries total approximately $322million in 2012, up from
$293millionin2011.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A16

MAJORCOMPANIES

INTRODUCTION

The following pages provide summaries of ad spending and sales data for the 29 major
companiesprofiledinthisreport.
ThesalescolumnreferstothecompaniescosmeticsandtoiletriessalesintheUnited
States.

ALTICOR

Table732:TraceableMediaExpendituresforAlticor,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

113

2008

120

2009

130

2010

145

0.7

2011

164

11

6.7

2012

176

12

6.8

aHistoricalTMEdatanotavailable.
bTMElessthanamillion.

AVON

Table733:TraceableMediaExpendituresforAvon,2007to2012

Year

$Million
Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007r

1,134

92

8.1

2008r

1,114

58

5.2

2009r

1,098

34

3.1

2010r

1,077

40

3.7

2011

1,014

15

1.5

2012

948

13

1.4

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

718

MajorCompanies

BEIERSDORF

Table734:TraceableMediaExpendituresforBeiersdorf,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

287

109

38.0

2008

297

107

36.0

2009

312

135

43.3

2010

322

61

18.9

2011

335

47

14.0

2012

344

26

7.6

CHANEL

Table735:TraceableMediaExpendituresForChanel,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

336

36

10.7

2008

312

35

11.2

2009

292

34

11.6

2010

346

62

17.9

2011

417

78

18.7

2012

461

87

18.6

CHURCH&DWIGHT

Table736:TraceableMediaExpendituresforChurch&Dwight,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007r

347

42

12.1

2008

361

57

15.8

2009r

366

50

13.7

2010r

339

54

15.9

2011r

321

69

21.5

2012

313

66

21.1

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A18

MajorCompanies

CLARINS

Table737:TraceableMediaExpendituresforClarins,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

153

10

6.5

2008

146

11

7.5

2009

136

3.7

2010

142

5.6

2011

160

23

14.4

2012

171

27

15.8

COLGATEPALMOLIVE

Table738TraceableMediaExpendituresforColgatePalmolive,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

2007

1,382

89

6.4

2008

1,446

115

8.0

2009

1,448

49

3.4

2010

1,420

113

8.0

2011

1,431

87

6.1

1,493

110

7.4

2012

rRestated.

%TMEofsales

COMBE

Table739:TraceableMediaExpendituresforCombe,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

140

43

30.7

2008

146

67

45.9

2009

146

42

28.8

2010

143

41

28.7

2011

154

34

22.1

2012

157

39

24.8

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

719

720

MajorCompanies

COTY

Table740:TraceableMediaExpendituresforCoty,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
923
945
918
961
1,048
1,086

TME
224
168
97
326
245
283

%TMEofsales
24.3
17.8
10.6
33.9
23.4
26.1

rRestated.

ELIZABETHARDEN

Table741:TraceableMediaExpendituresforElizabethArden,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008r
2009r
2010r
2011r
2012r

Sales
279
298
316
286
313
290

TME
46
46
48
53
52
57

%TMEofsales
16.5
15.4
15.2
18.5
16.6
19.7

rRestated.

ENERGIZERHOLDINGS

Table742:TraceableMediaExpendituresforEnergizerHoldings,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
314
324
324
354
379
396

TME
17
16
36
26
37
33

%TMEofsales
5.4
4.9
11.1
7.3
9.8
8.3

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A20

MajorCompanies

ESTELAUDER

Table743:TraceableMediaExpendituresforEsteLauder,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Salesr
2,526
2,450
2,332
2,399
2,569
2,722

%TMEofsales
6.5
4.6
5.1
7.8
10.6
14.2

TME
163
112
118
186
272
386

rRestated.

GLAXOSMITHKLINE

Table744:TraceableMediaExpendituresforGlaxoSmithKline,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
368
376
368
395
392
407

TME
108
107
144
158
150
130

%TMEofsales
29.3
28.5
39.1
40.0
38.3
31.9

rRestated.

GUTHYRENKER

Table745:TraceableMediaExpendituresforGuthyRenker,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Sales
388
422
453
493
616
737

TME
a
a
a
222
260
304

%TMEofsales
a
a
a
45.0
42.2
41.2

aGuthyRenkerwasprofiledforthefirsttimein2010,sohistoricalTMEprior
tothatyearisnotavailable.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

721

722

MajorCompanies

HELENOFTROY

Table746:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHelenofTroy,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Salesr
208
200
175
168
160
147

TME
7
5
10
13
11
12

%TMEofsales
3.4
2.5
5.7
7.7
6.9
8.2

rRestated.

HENKEL

Table747:TraceableMediaExpendituresforHenkel,2007to2012

Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

$Million
Salesr
661
668
671
664
626
635

%TMEofsales
5.6
2.2
2.8
2.9
2.9
1.1

TME
37
15
19
19
18
7

rRestated.

JOHNSON&JOHNSON

Table748:TraceableMediaExpendituresforJohnson&Johnson,2007
to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
1,825
1,885
1,901
1,945
1,979
2,020

TME
576
376
396
415
486
440

%TMEofsales
31.6
19.9
20.8
21.3
24.6
21.8

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A22

MajorCompanies

KAO

Table749:TraceableMediaExpendituresforKao,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007r

466

143

30.7

2008

446

118

26.5

2009r

463

24

5.2

2010r

468

97

20.7

2011r

504

127

25.2

2012

525

131

25.0

rRestated.

LIMITEDBRANDS

Table750:TraceableMediaExpendituresforLimitedBrands,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

1,568

2008

1,512

0.1

2009

1,525

0.1

2010

1,602

2011

1,706

2012

1,785

aLessthan$500,000.
bLessthan0.1%.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

723

724

MajorCompanies

LORAL

Table751:TraceableMediaExpendituresforLOral,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Salesr
3,961
3,924
3,897
4,056
4,304
4,551

TME
750
757
834
1,109
1,312
1,448

%TMEofsales
18.9
19.3
21.4
27.3
30.5
31.8

rRestated.

LVMH

Table752:TraceableMediaExpendituresforLVMH,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
282
279
269
279
307
337

TME
37
33
37
39
55
90

%TMEofsales
13.1
11.8
13.8
14.0
17.9
26.7

MARYKAY

Table753:TraceableMediaExpendituresforMaryKay,2007to2012

$Million
Year
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012

Sales
1,053
1,052
1,042
1,039
1,047
1,063

TME
8
3
7
5
14
18

%TMEofsales
0.8
0.3
0.7
0.5
1.3
1.7

NOTE:Salesincluderetailproductsonly;salesaidspurchasedby
consultantsforsellingeffortsarenotincluded.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A24

MajorCompanies

MERCK

Table754:TraceableMediaExpendituresforMerck,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007r

189

22

11.6

2008r

196

23

11.7

2009

181

22

12.2

2010

185

17

9.2

2011

192

14

7.3

2012

209

18

8.6

rRestated.

PROCTER&GAMBLE

Table755:TraceableMediaExpendituresforProcter&Gamble,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

5,376

1,632

30.4

2008

5,538

1,561

28.2

2009

5,565

1,180

21.2

2010

5,757

1,300

22.6

2011

5,898

1,490

25.3

2012

5,824

1,217

20.9

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

725

726

MajorCompanies

REVLON

Table756:TraceableMediaExpendituresforRevlon,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

758

201

26.5

2008

759

162

21.3

2009

752

153

20.3

2010

768

166

21.6

2011

802

156

19.5

2012

814

161

19.8

rRestated.

SANOFI

Table757:TraceableMediaExpendituresforSanofi,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007r

158

2008r

179

47

26.3

2009r

176

35

19.9

2010

188

44

23.4

2011

194

69

35.6

2012

197

51

25.9

aSanofiisprofiledforthefirsttimein2008,sohistoricalTMEpriorto
thatyearisnotavailable.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A26

MajorCompanies

SHISEIDO

Table758:TraceableMediaExpendituresforShiseido,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Sales

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

460

15

3.3

2008

477

10

2.1

2009

478

1.3

2010

494

1.6

2011

527

33

6.3

2012

542

52

9.6

THECLOROXCOMPANY

Table759:TraceableMediaExpendituresforTheCloroxCompany,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

85

2008

111

15

13.5

2009

125

19

15.2

2010

141

3.5

2011

158

3.8

2012

172

10

5.8

aTheCloroxCompanyisprofiledforthefirsttimein2008,sohistoricalTMEprior
tothatyearisnotavailable.
rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

727

728

MajorCompanies

UNILEVER

Table760:TraceableMediaExpendituresforUnilever,2007to2012

$Million

Year

Salesr

TME

%TMEofsales

2007

3,022

462

15.3

2008

3,037

432

14.2

2009

3,109

464

14.9

2010

3,206

499

15.6

2011

3,406

458

13.4

2012

3,546

522

14.7

rRestated.

REPRODUCTIONORDISCLOSUREFORBIDDEN;SEESPECIALNOTICE KLINE&COMPANY,INC.

4A28

Вам также может понравиться