IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW MEXICO
ANTHONY J. TRUJILLO,
JENNIFER K. TRUJILLO, and
RICK LOPEZ,
Petitioners,
vs.
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS FOR THE
COUNTY OF BERNALILLO,
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS FOR THE
COUNTY OF SAN MIGUEL,
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS FOR THE
COUNTY OF SANTA FE,
BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS FOR THE
COUNTY OF VALENCIA, and
THE HONORABLE SUSANA MARTINEZ,
in her official capacity as Governor of the
State of New Mexico,
Respondent.
EMERGENCY VERIFIED PETITION FOR A WRIT OF MANDAMUS
Petitioners Anthony J. Trujillo, Jennifer K. Trujillo, and Rick Lopez
respectfully request that this Court issue an emergency writ of mandamus to the
Boards of Commissioners for the County of Bernalillo, County of San Miguel,
County of Santa Fe, and County of Valencia to compel them to exercise their
nondiscretionary statutory duty of convening emergency meetings of their boards
of county commissioners to fill the vacancy for Senate District 39. In thealternative, Petitioners respectfully request that the Court compel Respondent
Governor Martinez to appoint the senator for Senate District 39 from the list of
names submitted by boards of county commissioners from the County of Lincoln
and County of Torrance, as these counties have swiftly and appropriately acted to
fill the vacancy in accordance with NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2)(a).
PARTIES AND JURISDICTION
1. Petitioners Anthony J. Trujillo and Jennifer K. Trujillo are married
and residents of the County of Santa Fe. Petitioner Anthony J. Trujillo is a
registered Democrat in Senate District 39, and Petitioner Jennifer K, Trujillo is a
registered Republican in Senate District 39. Petitioners have three children that
attend school in Senate District 39,
2. Petitioner Rick Lopez resides in Torrance County at 8643 Highway
55, Tajique, New Mexico 87106, and he is a registered vote as a Republican in
Senate District 39.
3. Pursuant to NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2)(a) (2015), Respondents
Board of Commissioners for the County of Bernalillo, Board of Commissioners for
County of San Miguel, Board of Commissioners for County of Santa Fe, and
Board of Commissioners for County of Valencia (collectively hereinafter,
“Respondents Boards of Commissioners”) are required submit one name to the
governor if'a vacancy occurs in the office of senator for any reason.4, Respondent, the Honorable Susana Martinez, in her capacity as
Governor of the State of New Mexico, is required to appoint a senator to fill a
vacancy from the list of names submitted to her by Respondents Boards of
Commissioners in accordance with NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2)(b) (2015).
5. This Court has original jurisdiction over petitions for writ of
mandamus pursuant to the N.M. Const, Art. VI, § 3 and NMSA 1978, § 44-2-1, et
seq. Mandamus is the proper remedy to compel an official act by a state officer, as,
to which the officer has no discretion. See City of Santa Rosa v. Jaramillo, 1973-
NMSC-119, 7, 85 NM. 747, 517 P.2d 69; see also, e.g,, New Energy Econ, Inc.
y. Martinez, 2011-NMSC-006, $f 21-23, 149 N.M. 207.
6. Petitioners have standing to seek relief from this Court because they
will be harmed by Respondents’ failure to immediately appoint a senator to fill a
vacancy for Senate District 39.
7. Mandamus is appropriate because there is no plain, speedy or
adequate remedy at law available to Petitioners. See, e.g,, State ex. rel, King v.
Lyons, 2011-NMSC-0004, § 26, 149 N.M. 330; see also State ex rel. Pilot Dev.
Northwest v. State Health Planning & Dev. Bureau, 1985-NMCA-050, § 32, 102
N.M. 791, 701 P.2d 390.RELEVANT FACTS AND BACKGRO!
8 On March 14, 2015, Senator Phil Griego resigned from his position as,
Senator for Senate District 39 in the New Mexico Legislature.
9. The First Session of the 52 Legislature of the State of New Mexico
is currently in session and will adjoum at noon on March 21, 2015. Critical
legislation remains pending before the New Mexico Legislature, including
financial legislation dealing with the state budget and capital outlay that will
directly impacts the residents of Senate District 39.
10. The voters in Senate District 39 are currently unrepresented during the
First Session of the 52™ Legislature of the State of New Mexico.
11. Petitioners are registered voters in Senate District 39.
12. Without representation for Senate District 39, Petitioners are
unrepresented in the New Mexico Senate.
13, _ Petitioners have three children that attend school in Senate District 39,
and without representation in the New Mexico Senate, Petitioners have no voice in
how their children’s school is funded.
14, Upon information and belief, Senator Phil Griego had capital outlay
money included in legislation designated for the school that Petitioners” children
attend, and without representation for Senate District 39, such funding is in
jeopardy.15. Upon information and belief, Respondent Governor Martinez has
formally requested that Respondents Boards of Commissioners hold emergency
meetings to submit one name to Governor Martinez in order to fill the vacancy for
Senate District 39 by 5:00 p.m. on Sunday, March 15, 2015, in order to ensure
representation during this critical final week of the legislative session. See Exhibit
A. Respondents Boards of Commissioners failed to meet this request by
Respondent Governor Martinez.
16. Upon information and belief, the vast majority of legislation that will
reach the desk of Respondent Governor Martinez. for consideration will be
discussed and decided upon by the New Mexico Legislature during this final week
of the First Session of the 52 Legislature of the State of New Mexico. Thus, the
residents of Senate District 39 will be unrepresented during this critical time frame.
17. Respondent Governor Martinez. intended on appointment a
replacement for Senate District 39 by Monday, March 16, 2015, in order to have
representation for the residents of Senate District 39 when the Senate resumed
business on that day. See Exhibit A. Thus, a swift appointment to Senate District
39 would have afforded residents of Senate District 39 full representation during
the final week of the First Session of the 52™ Legislature of the State of New
Mexico.18. Upon information and belief, each day counts during a legislative
session, and this is especially true during the final week of a session.
19. Upon information and belief, two Boards of Commissioners within
Senate District 39, namely, the Board of Commissioners for the County of
Torrance and the Board of Commissioners for the County of Lincoln, have held
emergency meetings and submitted one name to Governor Martinez in order to fill
the vacancy for Senate District 39.
20. Upon information and belief, Respondents Boards of Commissioners
have delayed appointing a replacement for Senate District 39, thereby resulting in
Petitioners and other residents of Senate District 39 lacking representation during a
time when their critical issues are being considered.
ARGUMENT
Petitioners have the right to be represented by a senator during the First
Session of the 52” Legislature of the State of New Mexico. The New Mexico
Constitution at Article 2, Section 2 states: “All political power is vested in and
derived from the people: all government of right originates with the people, is
founded upon their will and is instituted solely for their good.” In order to exercise
this political power in the legislative branch of government, the people of the State
of New Mexico elect senators and representatives. See, e.g., N.M. Const. Art. VII,§ 1. Currently, Petitioners are unrepresented in the New Mexico Senate due to a
vacancy in Senate District 39.
Senate District 39 is situated in six counties consisting of the County of
Bernalillo, the County of Lincoln, County of San Miguel, County of Santa Fe,
County of Torrance, and County of Valencia. See NMSA 1978, § 2-8E-1 (2015)
(“Senate district thirty-nine is composed of Bernalillo county precinct 551; Lincoln
county precinets 1, 3 through 6, 14, 16, 19 and 21; San Miguel county precincts 13,
16 and 18 through 24; Santa Fe county precincts 12, 14, 17, 62, 70, 72, 80 and 88;
Torrance county precincts I through 4, 7 through 12, 14 and 16; and Valencia
county precincts 30 and 38.”). Since Senate District 39 is situated in two or more
counties, the two-step process for filling a vacancy consists of: (1) “...the board of
county commissioners of each county in the senate district shall submit one name
to the governor...”, and (2) “the governor shall appoint the senator to fill the
vacancy from the list of names so submitted...”. NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2).
Upon information and belief, the boards of county commissioners for the
County of Lincoln and County of Torrance have convened emergency meetings
pursuant to NMSA 1978, Section 10-15-1(F) and submitted one name to
Respondent Governor Martinez in accordance with NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-
4(B)(2)(a). Meanwhile, four other Respondents Boards of Commissioners havefailed to convene emergency meetings at this point in time in order to fill the
vacaney for Senate District 39.
Petitioners maintain that Respondents Boards of Commissioners should be
compelled to exercise their nondiscretionary statutory duty of convening
emergency meetings to fill the vacancy for Senate District 39 under NMSA 1978,
§ 2-8D-4(B)(2). The failure to immediately do so will result in Petitioners being
unrepresented during the most critical week of the First Session of the 52!
Legislature of the State of New Mexico.
In this case, to fulfill that most important duty under NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-
4(B)(2), Petitioners maintain that an emergency meeting of the boards of county
commissioners is required under NMSA 1978, § 10-15-1(F). Emergency meetings
of the boards of county commissioners are appropriate if...unforeseen
circumstances that, ifnot addressed immediately by the public body, will likely
result in injury or damage to persons or property or substantial financial loss to the
public body.” id. Petitioners will likely be injured because they have no
representation in the New Mexico Senate, and the failure to timely act will likely
result in the people of Senate District 39 incurring financial losses.
In particular, the First Session of the 52" Legislature of the State of New
Mexico is currently in session and will adjourn at noon on March 21, 2015.
Critical legislation remains pending before the New Mexico Legislature, includingfinancial legislation dealing with the state budget and capital outlay. For example,
when dealing with capital outlay, each Senator will need to prioritize and advocate
for projects within their districts based on the total money assigned to each
Senator, and the residents of Senate District 39 will miss out on this opportunity.
Arguably, capital outlay has the most direct impact on local communities within a
particular Senate district. Unless Respondents swiftly act to fill the vacancy in
Senate District 39, Petitioners will not have a voice to represent them when the
final decisions are made on such critical legislation.
Furthermore, Petitioners Anthony and Jennifer Trujillo have three children
that attend school in Senate District 39, and without representation in the New
Mexico Senate, Petitioners Anthony and Jennifer Trujillo have no advocate in the
New Mexico Senate to assist them with how their children’s school is funded.
Likewise, upon information and belief, Senator Phil Griego had capital outlay
money included in legislation designated for the school that children of Petitioners
Anthony and Jennifer Trajillo attend, and without representation for Senate District
39, such funding is in jeopardy.
Accordingly, Petitioners respectfully request that the Court compel
Respondents Boards of Commissioners to convene emergency meetings to fill the
vacancy for Senate District 39 prior to the adjoumment of the First Session of the
52 Legislature of the State of New Mexico. The primary obligation of alegislator in a representative democracy is to serve and respond to his or her
constituency. See, ¢.g., Williams v. U.S., 71 F.3d 502, 507 (5"* Cir. 1995). In fact,
legislators in a representative democracy are expected to vigorously represent the
concerns of their constituents. See, e.g., Sokaogon Chippewa Community (Mole
Lake Band of Lake Superior Chippewa) v. Babbit, 929 F. Supp. 1165, 1173 (W.D.
Wis. 1996). Petitioners and the residents of Senate District 39 will be deprived of
their right to vigorous representation if'a timely appointment to Senate District 39
is not made.
In the alternative, Petitioners respectfully request that the Court compel
Respondent Governor Martinez to appoint the senator for Senate District 39 from
the list of names submitted by boards of county commissioners for the County of
Lincoln and County of Torrance, as these counties of swiftly and appropriately
acted to fill the vacancy in accordance with NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2)(a).
Respondents Boards of Commissioners should not be allowed to unduly delay the
process for filling the vacancy in Senate District 39, especially since the New
Mexico Legislature is currently in session. Although NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-
4(B)(2)(a) does not contain a time frame for a board of county commissioners of
each county in the senate district to submit one name to Respondent Governor
Martinez, Petitioners maintain boards of county commissioners are required to
immediately act in order to ensure that the people of Senate District 39, including
10Petitioners, have representation during the First Session of the 52™ Legislature of
the State of New Mexico. Accordingly, Respondent Governor Martinez. should be
allowed to appoint a person for Senate District 39 from the list of names currently
submitted. Under the circumstances, NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2) trumps any
Open Meetings Act concerns because there is ample time now for the Respondent
Commissions to act on an emergency basis.
CONCLUSION
For the reasons set forth herein, Petitioners respectfully request that this,
Court issue an emergency writ of mandamus to the Boards of Commissioners for
the County of Bernalillo, County of San Miguel, County of Santa Fe, and County
of Valencia to compel them to exercise their nondiscretionary statutory duty of
convening emergency meetings of their boards of county commissioners to fill the
vacancy for Senate District 39 prior to the adjournment of the First Session of the
52™ Legislature of the State of New Mexico under NMSA 1978, § 2-8D-4(B)(2).
In the alternative, Petitioners respectfully request that the Court compel
Respondent Governor Martinez to appoint the senator for Senate District 39 from
the list of names submitted by Boards of County Commissioners from the County
of Lincoln and County of Torrance, as these counties of swifily and appropriately
acted to fill the vacancy.Respectfully submitted,
SCOTT & KIENZLE PA
saul M. Rienzle Ti
P.O. Box 587
Albuquerque, NM_ 87103-0587
Phone: (505) 246-8600
Fax: (505) 246-8682
E-Mail: paul@kienzlelaw.com
Attorney for PetitionersThereby certify that a copy of the foregoing was served
electronically and by first class, U.S. mail
on this 16" day of March, 2015:
Honorable Peggy Carabajal
Valencia County Clerk
P.O. Box 969/444 Luna Avenue
Los Lunas, NM 87031
Honorable Geraldine Salazar
Santa Fe County Clerk
102 Grant Avenue
Santa Fe, NM 87501
Honorable Maggie Toulouse Oliver
Bernalillo County Clerk
One Civic Plaza NW 6" floor
P.O. Box 542
Albuquerque, NM 87103-0541
Honorable Geraldine Gutierrez
San Miguel County Clerk
San Miguel County Administrative Building
2" Floor, 500 West Avenue
Las Vegas, NM 87701Randy M. Autio
Bernalillo County Attorney's Office
520 Lomas Blvd., NW Floor 4
Albuquerque, NM 87102-2118
Phone: (505) 314-0180
Fax: (505) 242-0828
E-Mail: rmautio@bemco.gov
Attorney for Respondent Board of Commissioners
For the County of Bernalillo
Jesus L. Lopez
Jesus L. Lopez Attorney at Law
P.O. Box 2115
Las Vegas, NM 87701-2115
Phone: (505) 425-3730
Fax: (505) 425-0805
E-Mail: fil49@qwestoffice.net
Attomey for Respondent Board of Commissioners
For the County of San Miguel
Gregory S. Shaffer
Santa Fe County Attorney's Office
P.O. Box 276
Santa Fe, NM 87504-0276
Phone: (505) 986-6279
Fax: (505) 986-6362
E gshaffer@)santafecountynm.gov
Attorney for Respondent Board of Commissioners
For the County of Santa FeDavid Matthew Pato
Nance Pato & Stout LLC
P.O. Box 772
Socorro, NM 87801-0772
Phone: (575) 838-0911
Fax: (866) 808-1165
Mail: dave@npslawfirm.com
Attorney for Respondent Board of Commissioners
For the County of Valencia
Jessica Hernandez
Office of the Governor
490 Old Santa Fe Trail
Room 400
Santa Fe, NM 87501
Telephone: (505) 476-2200
E-Mail: jessica.hernandez@state.nm.us
Attorney for Respondent Governor Susana Martinez
Hector H. Balderas
New Mexico Attoiney General
408 Galisteo Street
Villagra Building
Santa Fe, NM 87501
Phone: (505) 827-6000; Fax: (505) 827-5826
Paul M. Kienzle II],STATEMENT OF COMPLIANCE
Pursuant to Rule 12-213(A), (F) & (G), Petitioners counsel states that the
total word count contained in the body of the brief is 2772, with 359 lines, using
Microsoft Office Word, Version 2013.
Paul M. Kienzle II],
Dated: March 16, 2015VERIFICATION
Anthony J. Trujillo, being under oath, states that he is a named Petitioner
herein, that he has read the foregoing Emergency Verified Petition for a Writ of
Mandamus, and that the contents are true and correct to the best of his knowledge
and belief.
Anthonf J. illoVERIFICATION
Jennifer K. Trujillo, being under oath, states that she is a named Petitioner
herein, that she has read the foregoing Emergency Verified Petition for a Writ of
Mandamus, and that the contents are true and correct to the best of her knowledge
~A._)/ 7 (
CVs yO
and belief.VERIFICATION
Rick Lopez, being under oath, states that he is a named Petitioner herein,
that he has read the foregoing Emergency Verified Petition for a Writ of
Mandamus, and that the contents are true and correct to the best of his knowledge
and belief,
Rick LopezState of New Mexico
‘Susana Martinez
Governor
March 14, 2015
Bernalillo County Commission
Chairwoman Maggie Hart
‘One Civic Plaza, NW
Albuquerque, NM 87102
Dear Chairwoman Hart,
Due to the resignation of Senator Phil Griego, a vacancy now exists in the Senate for
District 39, a district that includes portions of your county. There are only seven days
remaining in the 2015 legislative session. It is imperative that the citizens of District 39
maintain representation through the rest of the legislative session.
am requesting that the County Commission invoke its emergency meeting provi
for the purpose of submitting a nomination to fil the vacancy. If an appointment is not
made before the Senate reconvenes on Monday moming, all residents of Senate
District 39 will be unrepresented and your voters will be disenfranchised. This is a
serious issue affecting core constitutional rights of New Mexico residents.
Please send the County's nomination to my office by 5:00 PM tomorrow, Sunday, March
15, 2015. It is my intention to make an appointment by Monday, March 16, 2015. Please
direct any questions to Nick Piatek, Director of Boards & Commissions, at
Nicholas. Piatek@state.nm.us or at 505-476-2235.
Thank you for your prompt attention to this critical issue.
Sincerely yours,
Susana Martinez
EXHIBIT
Governor
SMinjp i A
State Capitol + Room 4oo * Santa Fe,New Mexico 87sor + 505-476-2200 + fax: 505-476-2226