Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 354

-

 

 


   



  !

2015

       
      

,6%1
     


        
  5D     






       
       




,6%1


  
ZZZNPERRNUX





,  
    ,     !?...,      
    
  .   
 .   , 

  ",   "        
 . #  $ ? % 
      , 
   . &'-   $  
!

(  ) 

 

   

     
              
       
     

      

      
     

 
  
  

      


 








     
     
  


*  +.#.

 

   

     

     

     



 /   



  





     
    
      
     
" 

        
    

   
      
     


0 #.#.
675$780SOXV

 

   

       



      
      

     

     #    

    
#.       
 
 

"

 
     
     
    
 











    



 #.1 2.#


3 (.4.      
     
 ,,,
   ,    
1
.
   ,,,     ,   
 
5    #.6


*  0.#."



 

   

           
     
    
 ;,,, 
     

      



 


     

 
       




     
5D"
      
       
     
     
     





   



;,,,



4  (.6 %<=$17,125266,&$   
         Mercati S.G ,DFREL
%XOJDULDH DUFKLHSLVFRSL RSXVFXOD &ROOHFWDQHD E\]DQWLQD %DUL
9RO,3

 

   

  





 


  


      
5D

"      
     
     
     


     

"
      



     
     
       




6    &'-        R1a   ,


  *.    


 

   

 ,      IV . .$.


   / "$ .

       

        
    



"
&'-          "    

     

        
      
    

"
   





    

 
    
    



 

   





      
     

     




       

   
     
      


     


    
     
      

      

     
     
  


,,,,


'   %.%."





 

   


     
      
       
     
       
   +RPR VDSLHQV 
     
     
,,,,


      
     


     


    
     
    

    
      
    

      


      
      




 

   






      



    
    



     

<
   
<









Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\PXWDWLRQUDWHVDQGVRPHKLVWRULFDO
HYLGHQFHV ZULWWHQ LQ <FKURPRVRPH , %DVLF SULQFLSOHV DQG WKH
PHWKRG-*HQHWLF*HQHDORJ\9RO3Rozhanskii
I.L., Klyosov A.A. 0XWDWLRQ 5DWH &RQVWDQWV LQ '1$ *HQHDORJ\
<&KURPRVRPH $GYDQFHVLQ$QWKURSRORJ\9RO1R
3



 

   

    
      
        
      
      
     
      
       
  
613 6LQJOH
1XFOHRWLGH 3RO\PRUSKLVP    
 

 
 


    675 6KRUW 7DQGHP
5HSHDWV 

 












     
        
<



 

   


      



'<6 
 $*$7   
*7**7&77&7$&77*7*7&$$7$&$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7
$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$*$7$7*7$7
*7&7777&7$7*$*$&$7$&&7&$777777**$&77*$*77&

     
     
      
'<67&7*
   
7&7$

7$7$7777$&$&$77777***&&&7*&$7777**7$&&&&$7$$
7$7$77&7$7&7$7&7*7&7*7&7*7&7*7&7*7&7*7&7*
7&7*7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7$
7&7$7&7$7&7$7&7*7&7$7&7$7&7$7&$7&7$7&7$7&7
77&&77*777&7*$*7$7$&$&$77*&$$7*7777&$7777$&7*
7&$&

     







6RUHQVRQ0ROHFXODU*HQHDORJ\)RXQGDWLRQ85/KWWSZZZVPJI
RUJ\FKURPRVRPHPDUNHUBGHWDLOVMVS["PDUNHU



 

   

8 /  /                   ,
     /         &'.8 /        / $      
/ &'      /  

 
       
       



       
       
 

       

    






 

   

       


    

     

       



       








       

        

      

      


KWWSUDRUJLUDND]Y[OVKWWSUDRUJ
$ )UHH 3XEOLF 6HUYLFH IURP )DPLO\ 7UHH '1$ 85/ KWWSZZZ
\VHDUFKRUJKWWSZZZVPJIRUJSDJHV\GDWDEDVHMVS[
)DPLO\ 7UHH '1$ 85/ KWWSZZZIDPLO\WUHHGQDFRP
SX EO LF  5D< + D SORJ U RX S G HI D X OW  D V S["V H F W LR Q \ U H V X OW V 
KW W SZ Z ZID P L O\ W U H H G Q D F RP SX EO LF 5D GHIDX OW D V S["
VHFWLRQ \UHVXOWV
Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5H([DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD
7KHRU\DQGWKH2ULJLQRI(XURSHRLGV &DXFDVRLGV LQ/LJKWRI'1$
*HQHDORJ\  $GYDQFHVLQ$QWKURSRORJ\1R3
85/KWWSG[GRLRUJDD



 

   









 
      

 
  
 
 
 
     
     




      

     







 


Rozhanskii I.L., Klyosov A.A. +DSORJURXS 5D ,WV 6XEFODGHV DQG


%UDQFKHV LQ (XURSH GXULQJ WKH /DVW  <HDUV $GYDQFHV LQ
$QWKURSRORJ\913



 

   

613       
       
        
   5D=   
5D
 = 
        
     

      


      


    

       
     
     
     
       

     

      
       


    
      
     
        

  




 

   

    



     

       
  


     


    




    
<

   
        

     

      
      


       
     
      



'9 #.#.    < 






 

   


 
     
<




      
      
    
<
       
<    
  <    







     
     


      
     


     
       
  



    



 

   

    



<




<
 
 <   
    
       
      
      
      

     
     
 

         
<
        
<     

   

 675 
 613 
    
         
 <    
    
     
-



 

   


           
      



       

     
    
        
 5D   
      

    
$5D
 
 5D

     
<      






     
5D
Homo sapiens
        

      5D
  5E  
"



 

   

      


 5E

      
  5D5E
  
5E




"
         
      
       

     


      
   
<

<




Klyosov A. A., Rozhanskii I.L., Ryabchenko L.E.5H([DPLQLQJWKH


2XWRI$IULFD 7KHRU\ DQG WKH 2ULJLQ RI (XURSHRLGV &DXFDVRLGV 
3DUW613V+DSORJURXSVDQG+DSORW\SHVLQWKH<&KURPRVRPHRI
&KLPSDQ]HHDQG+XPDQV$GYDQFHVLQ$QWKURSRORJ\9RO
1R3



 

   

      
  


       











      




     
 <   

    
       
       

 675  6KRUW 7DQGHP 5HSHDWV  

      
*D


  





 

   



5D=



5D/
,,,






 5D//


    5D0 
   

     
  
 


   
5D0      
     
      
 
 



 

   

      
     
    

      5D 
     
      
     


      
     
   
         
5D
  
   
      


  








     


     




 

   

      
     
      
      
    


       
  
      
      

       
         
    
     





       



      

      

     
    
*DD 
     





 

   

  
 
       

        



*
*DD

 
 *DE       


     



 *DD 


&
        

      
*DD*D
      

       

    
       
  5D=  
 
 5D0



 

   





     

        
      

      
       
     




     



     

     
     
     5E

     
         



       
      

-       



Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\3



 

   




      

      
       
 



  
       
  

"




  "  

 
       
      

<



     
         


     
       



 

   




     613   
     
    
      






      


     
     




       
        
      




  


 
       



,QWHUQDWLRQDO6RFLHW\RI*HQHWLF*HQHDORJ\85/KWWSZZZLVRJJ
RUJWUHH,62**B+DSJUS$KWPO



 

   



 
 
* 

 -       

-
-
       
/

 //E
/1

      
1
 
,
     
       
      
     
     ,  ,
5D5E

     
    4  5   

5D5E
    5D 
5E







 

   

     


       
     

 5E0 





    
       
    
 5

   
        
     

    

     






     


    
     


,QWHUQDWLRQDO6RFLHW\RI*HQHWLF*HQHDORJ\85/KWWSZZZLVRJJ
RUJWUHH,62**B<'1$7UHH7UXQNKWPO



 

   



      
      



      




     


    
     
     
       


         





      
    

   
    
 
     
      
     


Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\3



 

   

        

       
  
      
 
 
    
        
     

     










     

     
      


     



5D


       


Klyosov A.A. '1$*HQHDORJ\3



 

   



0 / 1.
  


 

  
 

   R1a1  

 
   
   
.

2008

2008

2009

2009

2009

2009

2010

26
44
58
255
98
110
148

- ,

178 4400550 , . 1, . 400477 (2008)


326 4825550 , .1, . 947957 (2008)
423 4725520 J. Genetic Genealogy,
5, P. 186216 (2009)
1320 4475460 , . 2, . 232251 (2009)
711 4700500 J. Genetic Genealogy,
5, . 186216 (2009)
804 4750500 J. Genetic Genealogy, 5, 186216
(2009)
1037 4500470 , 76, 634651 (2001)
2023 4475460
2748 4475470

2013

647

2059 4700480

      
    
       
       




        

 



 

   


       





   5D  


      

 &,   68  


R1a   6-   < . , : 15 12 25
11 1113.1         



 

   

     
         

     
      


  
         
       
       


    

       
  
     








        

    
<



        

  <  



 

   











        

     

  



     
       
        
        
        
    
        





       




 

   

        


 




       


      

    
   
      

      
      








      
       
        
   


     
    
        
     
     



 

   







""



 

   




      



         

      
Homo sapiens
 
       
    

"
       
 "   

Homo sapiens
 
 

     

    

      
       
     
     
      




 

   








      

    
      




    

        
     
 
 

     

      
    

 
   




     
    


Thompson R.7KHRULHVRI(WKQLFLW\$&ULWLFDO$SSUDLVDO1HZ<RUN




 

   


     
     

      






      
    
     
      






    
        
      


       
   

     
     
 
      
    


5/ .*.
      




 

   





      





    
     



      


    


     



    
      

Homo erectus    


     Homo
sapiens



      



 

   

         



       
    



 
 
     

' 
    
       
     

     

       
    
    
       1DWXUH 
     
    
    
      
       
      


     
      
  



Cann R.L., Stoneking M., Wilson A.C. 0LWRFKRQGULDO '1$ DQG


KXPDQHYROXWLRQ1DWXUH9ROS



 

   

     
     
     

      
      

       
    
      



     
    
 

 


    

        
        
    
       
      

    







KWWSZZZVFLUSRUJMRXUQDODD
0RGHUQ +XPDQ $QFHVWU\ DW WKH 3HULSKHULHV $ 7HVW RI WKH
5HSODFHPHQW 7KHRU\  :ROSRII 0+ >HW DO@ 6FLHQFH  9RO
3
Bednarik R.G. $IULFDQ (YH +RD[ RU +\SRWKHVLV" $GY
$QWKURSRORJ\9RO1R3



 

   






"
    "     
"

. (1987)


      
       



 

<
      
      
 
      
 
     
 


     

       
       






 

   



      
    
       
       
        

     

     
      

      




        



        




     
     

      
      
     

        
       




 

   

    








      
     



 
      









 
     

    


Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5H([DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


7KHRU\DQGWKH2ULJLQRI(XURSHRLGV &DXFDVRLGV LQ/LJKWRI'1$
*HQHDORJ\$GYDQFHVLQ$QWKURSRORJ\9RO1R3
85/KWWSG[GRLRUJDD



 

   


  







     
        
     

 
        


"

       

      
   
 
  
      
     
       
1DWXUH




(DUO\ GLVSHUVDO RI PRGHUQ KXPDQV LQ (XURSH DQG LPSOLFDWLRQV IRU
1HDQGHUWKDOEHKDYLRXU%HQD]]L6>HWDO@1DWXUH9RO3
7KHHDUOLHVWHYLGHQFHIRUDQDWRPLFDOO\PRGHUQKXPDQVLQ
1RUWK:HVWHUQ(XURSH+LJKDP7>HWDO@1DWXUH9RO
3
  
         

 



 

   


     
        
       
       

   
     
"





     

     



      
 
       


    
     
      

     




      
        



 

   






  

    



     
    
    
     
     
     
        
 "     
   "   

       
      





5E


5E    "   
       


+XPDQ<FKURPRVRPHKDSORJURXS59DSDWHUQDOJHQHWLFUHFRUG
RIHDUO\PLG+RORFHQHWUDQV6DKDUDQFRQQHFWLRQVDQGWKHVSUHDGRI
&KDGLFODQJXDJHV&UXFLDQL)>HWDO@(XU-+XPDQ*HQHW
9RO3



 

   


"     
      

         
        

"


      
        <       "     #<  
  
<  
   
       
     
  




      


    
5D  5E         










Hayden E.C.$IULFDQJHQHVWUDFNHGEDFN1DWXUH9RO
3
$QFLHQW ZHVW (XUDVLDQ DQFHVWU\ LQ VRXWKHUQ DQG HDVWHUQ $IULFD 
3LFNUHOO -. >HW DO@  3URF 1DWO $FDG 6FL 86 (DUO\ (GLWLRQ
85/ZZZSQDVRUJFJLGRLSQDV
Cann R.L. Stoneking M., Wilson A.C. 0LWRFKRQGULDO '1$ DQG
KXPDQHYROXWLRQ3
Atkinson Q.D. 3KRQHPLF GLYHUVLW\ VXSSRUWV D VHULDO IRXQGHU HIIHFW
PRGHORIODQJXDJHH[SDQVLRQIURP$IULFD6FLHQFH9RO
3
Klyosov A. A., Rozhanskii I. L.5H([DPLQLQJWKH2XWRI$IULFD
7KHRU\3



 

   


      
 "     5D 
5E     " 

   
       
      
        
      
"

        
       
       
       





      

   










Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5H([DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


7KHRU\ 3  .O\RVRY $$ $QFLHQW KLVWRU\ RI WKH $UELQV
EHDUHUVRIKDSORJURXS5EIURP&HQWUDO$VLDWR(XURSHWR
\HDUVEHIRUHSUHVHQW$GY$QWKURSRO9RO3
Hellenthal G., Auton A., Falush D.,QIHUULQJKXPDQFRORQL]DWLRQ
KLVWRU\XVLQJDFRS\LQJPRGHO3/26*HQHWLFVH
Campbell M.C., Tishkoff S.A. 7KH HYROXWLRQ RI KXPDQ JHQHWLF QG
SKHQRW\SLF YDULDWLRQ LQ $IULFD &XUUHQW %LRORJ\  9RO 
55



 

   

        


    
       





 &  $/      .        
Y-  ,      
"   .1   <-

   160 .. .,    -
(   6  0) 646 .. .   
   <    #00  #0 ( 
          A1b   
),      
  



Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5H([DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


7KHRU\3



 

   

      


      

      







     
    
        
      

     
 
     
      


     







        
    
      
         



 

   

      
        
     

     
       
      

           
   
   
   
   


 
     
     
    
        

















<FKURPRVRPH VHTXHQFH YDULDWLRQ DQG WKH KLVWRU\ RI KXPDQ


SRSXODWLRQV8QGHUKLOO3$>HWDO@1DWXUH*HQHWLFV9RO
3
Forster P. ,FH $JHV DQG WKH PLWRFKRQGULDO '1$ FKURQRORJ\ RI
KXPDQ GLVSHUVDOV D UHYLHZ 3KLO 7UDQV 5 6RF /RQG % 
3
5HFHQWVSUHDGRID<FKURPRVRPDOOLQHDJHLQ1RUWKHUQ&KLQDDQG
0RQJROLD ;XH < >HW DO@ $PHULFDQ - +XPDQ *HQHW 
9RO3
Carrigan D., Hammer M.F. 5HFRQVWUXFWLQJ KXPDQ RULJLQV LQ WKH
JHQRPLFHUD1DWXUH5HYLHZV9RO3
5HYHDOLQJWKHSUHKLVWRULFVHWWOHPHQWRI$XVWUDOLDE\<FKURPRVRPH
DQGPW'1$DQDO\VLV+XGMDVKRY*>HWDO@3URF1DWLRQDO$FDG
6FL869RO3
,ELG
Chiaroni J., Underhill P.A., Cavalli-Sforza L. / <FKURPRVRPH
GLYHUVLW\KXPDQH[SDQVLRQGULIWDQGFXOWXUDOHYROXWLRQ3URF1DWO
$FDG6FL869RO3
Campbell M.C., Tishkoff S.A. 7KH HYROXWLRQ RI KXPDQ JHQHWLF QG
SKHQRW\SLFYDULDWLRQ
Hayden E.C.2SFLW3



 

   

)&UXFLDQL






?
      
    

"
   
      
      
       

     





      
         

      

Homo sapiens
Homo
sapiens




$UHYLVHGURRWIRUWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPDOSK\ORJHQHWLFWUHHWKH
RULJLQRISDWULOLQHDOGLYHUVLW\LQ$IULFD&UXFLDQL)>HWDO@$PHU
-+XPDQ*HQHW9RO3



 

   

      

     

     
      



       


      
       
<  
  





        
        




         


     

        







 

   



       
     
<


        
    







"

      

     

     
 




"
     
   <   
     
     
     


      



 

   


    
     
   $EEE  
      
  
$


     
      
           
$E$E$E
       


     
 
       

 
   $D $E $D $D $DD
$DE 
      
 
 
  
 
      

 


     


      



 

   

\  ($/ )   


 #.8  
  -  

   $/     
   "  ,  /,  
60 ( - .3).8   "   (
    5,5   . .)   
  # (     
  6  0);  /   
     , $  < 
 $/,      / 
2832  . .5   60     <         
$/  /:     ^ A0-T^ A1
^ A1b ^BT.* A0-T, A1  A1b  #<   .+ $/  ,      < / ,     
 #< <   



 

   

      



     
<     
     
      
 Homo neanderthalensis 
       
       
      
Homo


    $  

0R


 
 
   


     

     

E

     $E 
E%7
    
     
E



 

   


        
E
       
  
 
 
        
$E 
       
<$E$D
$E$E 
 %7
     
5D5E,,1F

 

$7$
$E

    

7$$E




      
       

       

$E      
    





 

   


 


      





$7$$E
       
         
      
   <  
$D$E
       




      
       
      

$E
     
      


     
$E
$EEE0


Hayden E.C.2SFLW3$QFLHQWZHVW(XUDVLDQDQFHVWU\LQ
VRXWKHUQDQGHDVWHUQ$IULFD



 

   

     
        
     
           

    

  
      
      

     
    
    < 

$EEE


     


      
      




     
$




)DPLO\ 7UHH '1$ 85/ KWWSVZZZIDPLO\WUHHGQDFRPSXEOLF


+DSORJURXSB$GHIDXOWDVS["VHFWLRQ \UHVXOWV
Klyosov A.A. 7KH VORZHVW  PDUNHU KDSORW\SH SDQHO RXW RI WKH
 PDUNHU SDQHO  DQG WKHLU PXWDWLRQ UDWH FRQVWDQWV HPSOR\HG IRU
FDOFXODWLRQV WLPHVSDQV WR WKH PRVW DQFLHQW FRPPRQ DQFHVWRUV
3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH 5XVVLDQ $FDGHP\ RI '1$ *HQHDORJ\ ,661
 9RO3



 

   



      

 
      
      
       
      

       
    


      







$EEE
      
       
       

          








,ELG Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI


$IULFDWKHRU\3
Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\PXWDWLRQUDWHV3Klyosov
A.A.$QFLHQWKLVWRU\RIWKH$UELQV3
$Q $IULFDQ $PHULFDQ SDWHUQDO OLQHDJH DGGV DQ H[WUHPHO\ $QFLHQW
URRW WR WKH KXPDQ \ FKURPRVRPH SK\ORJHQHWLF WUHH  0HQGH] )/
>HWDO@$P-+XP*HQHW9RO3



 

   

       
      





        
    5D  5E 


 5E0
 5D=

    5E  5D  

     5  



      



      
"

 
'<6
 


$IULFDQVLQ<RUNVKLUH"7KHGHHSHVWURRWLQJFODGHRIWKH<SK\ORJHQ\
ZLWKLQ DQ (QJOLVK JHQHDORJ\  .LQJ 7( >HW DO@(XU - +XPDQ
*HQHW9RO3



 

   



     $EEE 




        
     








    
        
       $GYDQFHV LQ
$QWKURSRORJ\    
     

      

     
    

  


     



Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L 5H([DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


7KHRU\3



 

   







      
       

      





 
      

      






       





,
     
      


+XPDQ (YROXWLRQDU\ *HQHWLFV  -REOLQJ +ROOR[ +XUOHV


.LYLVLOG7\OHU6PLWK



 

   

   

    
    
&RPSOHWH VHSDUDWLRQ RI $IULFDQ DQG QRQ$IULFDQ
OLQHDJHV    <  
     

 &RPSOHWH
VHSDUDWLRQRI$IULFDQDQGQRQ$IULFDQOLQHDJHV 
     

        
   <  < 





      


"

"
    

     
    

      



 ;,;
      




 

   


      
     
      


     

     




    
    
     
    
      



  < ,    
      


      
       

     
     







( #.      




 

   


    
     
    
    

UXRWVL

UXV



 
      

$GYDQFHV LQ $QWKURSRORJ\     
      

        


    
        
<     
      
     
       
 
 
 
 
       

        
     


Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


WKHRU\3



 

   

        


  
     
     


(1987)
, (1991)


 

       

  
      
       
          
        
 
       





     
       
      


      




Cann R.L., Stoneking M., Wilson A.C. 0LWRFKRQGULDO '1$ DQG


KXPDQHYROXWLRQ3
$IULFDQSRSXODWLRQVDQGWKHHYROXWLRQRIKXPDQPLWRFKRQGULDO'1$
9LJLODQW/>HWDO@6FLHQFH9RO3



 

   

     

    

   "   

"
       



  
        



        




      
     

       

     

     
     
 

  
       





 

   

(SNP)- ,

56FR]]DUL  
       
      
     
     
  <   
      
     

        

5



     
 
   <  
       
    $7  
      
$E  F

       
  


$E99
     
  
       
       


0ROHFXODUGLVVHFWLRQRIWKHEDVDOFODGHVLQWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPH
SK\ORJHQHWLFWUHH6FR]]DUL5>HWDO@3/R621(1R
H



 

   

&        ,


   R.Scozzari .(2012).8      / (SNP, Single Nucleotide
Polymorphism,    ),     
  .6 ,  "        #,    < .6     ,    ,   
 6,   
  < .*  
  , 50, , 
 ,  19 &'- ,  < 


0ROHFXODUGLVVHFWLRQRIWKHEDVDOFODGHVLQWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPH
SK\ORJHQHWLFWUHH



 

   

9

 $DFF   

    E  
      
      
 $EF
9/
 $ED9     $EE0 
 
$EEE0


 E     
56FR]]DUL
  

       
     
      

       
      
 






         

      




,ELG



 

   

     
      
 

     
     

       
     
      
<     
     
 
 
         
 $E


 E 





       
     



E$

      

       
;<=:





 

   


56FR]]DUL  

     
    
       
       
       

       


     
 
     
      

 
     
<
     
  
<
 

    
     
   








KWWSZZZLVRJJRUJWUHH,62**B+DSJUS$KWPO
Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD
WKHRU\3
0ROHFXODUGLVVHFWLRQRIWKHEDVDOFODGHVLQWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPH
SK\ORJHQHWLFWUHH



 

   

5       <   (    )  <  (       50   
   60   ).2        2012 .,       
2012 . 2   ,   < 
 
      
   < ,   <  &'- 
50 (    )    < .8    
   <    <  (  ),   ,  
    <  
<   "    160 .. .

     


      "  
     
"






0ROHFXODUGLVVHFWLRQRIWKHEDVDOFODGHVLQWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPH
SK\ORJHQHWLFWUHH
Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD
WKHRU\3



 

   

&  $/             


   #00,      "    2012. 
   2013.       
 Y-  ,   
   "   .1   <- ( A1b  "  </)

   160 .. .,    -
(     6  0) 646 .. .

    
56FR]]DUL  

""


      


 1DWXUH 

"


Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD


WKHRU\3



 

   

     
       
      
  5 6FR]]DUL      


    5 6FR]]DUL
        
 $E       
      
      
 $       


  

      

         


       
      




ED


       
     







 

   


  $EE0   
       

      


       
       










"
         

     
<  "  





       




)&UXFLDQL  


$UHYLVHGURRWIRUWKHKXPDQ<FKURPRVRPDOSK\ORJHQHWLFWUHHWKH
RULJLQRISDWULOLQHDOGLYHUVLW\LQ$IULFD



 

   


"
     < 



56FR]]DUL  

<
E $ 


     
       
        



     
      



    
      
     
   
     
     
      



(SNP)





 

   

        
<
    
 613 6LQJOH 1XFOHRWLGH 3RO\PRUSKLVP   
       
      
< 
<
    

   
      

        
 E 
 
 
       

     


      


      

     
      






      0ER
 



 

   

$)$)$)$)$)$)$)////
//////////
//////////
//////////
//////////
////////


     

 <

      
      
      
      
   
<    
      
< 


        

      
   <  

        
       
       
       
        



      
 



 

   


$)/////////
//////////
//////////
//


///////////
//////////
/////////9
99999999999
999999999







//////////
///39999999




     

$E 
   9    
 





 

   

///////////
///00000365<
999999999



$E  
        
      
 


 
      


       
Homo
sapiens
      

%7F




        
"
      
"



       


$ &RSHUQLFDQ UHDVVHVVPHQW RI WKH KXPDQ PLWRFKRQGULDO '1$


WUHHIURPLWVURRW%HKDU'0>HWDO@$PHU-+XP*HQHW9RO
3



 

   

      
    
   /    
//  
    
/       
     


   
 

   /   

   <   
/

<
"

/
       
/


     
 /      
  //  
  /    
     
<
  
  




 

   

5    &' ,


  /   
 &'  / ()  &'    ().
6       RNRS  RSRS  
     <      /     <     .   &.4  . 1        
  
 <     ()
/ /  <   L0 (  ),  /     &'


,ELG



 

   





    

       
      











     

     











    
.ROE$:


1DWXUH



 

   


     
       


    
      
     
     

     
     

,          
       
 
,,

,,,
,9
9
9,

     
       
     

     
     

     
      


Kolb A.W., Ane C., Brandt C.R.8VLQJ+69JHQRPHSK\ORJHQHWLFV


WRWUDFNSDVWKXPDQPLJUDWLRQV3/R62QH  H85/
GRLMRXUQDOSRQH



 

   

    
    
       

     
    
 VXSSRUWVWKHRXWRI$IULFDWKHRU\RIKXPDQ
HYROXWLRQ        

    


     




         
    
    



       
       
 9,       


        
9

      

        
      
      ,9




 

   

\  ,     


"     HSV-1    

   " ,      
Kolb,A.W.. ,  ,    ,    <:  I %/5  # 
(" 17  *,   5$, 5 \ /,
5w#),  2 6  # (', x
 ',
{ ,  | [Cw#]),  III, IV, V  VI  <  (  ' )


       
,9,,, 
     


Kolb A.W., Ane C., Brandt C.R.8VLQJ+69JHQRPHSK\ORJHQHWLFV


WRWUDFNSDVWKXPDQPLJUDWLRQV



 

   

    

      
    
,,,


       



      
    
     
 ",
  <      ,    &  6, ', { ,
'      ,     %  # ,      ,         

   
"
     
  "   , 
     ,      ,       " ( #<. #.)      
 
 






KWWSJXDUGLDQOYFRPKHUSHVVLPSOH[YLUXVFRQUPVRXW
RIDIULFDPLJUDWLRQRIDQFLHQWKXPDQV
KWWSZZZVFLQHZVFRPJHQHWLFVVFLHQFHKHUSHVYLUXVRXWRI
DIULFDWKHRU\KWPO



 

   


      
      


      




       
        
       
    
       

      
    





       

    






     
    

      
  



 

   


     

    

      







     

        


     




       






     
     

       
      
     
      



 

   

     

     

       
+69+69
 
 

          





    






      
    

    
    
    


    
     
         


 



 

   




   
    
      


       


 


 



 
     



       
       

     
     
       
        
     
          


    
   




 

   

         
    


        
       




    
      
       
    
  3URWVFK    
 
      
        
         
       
          





      


    

$U$U
      





KW W SZ Z ZW KHJ X D UG LD QFRP VFLHQFH IHEVFLHQFH


VFLHQFHQHZV
KWWSDUFKLYHDUFKDHRORJ\RUJQHZVEULHIVLQVLGHUKWPO



 

   

        
     



    





       
    *ULQH )( 

2PR
.LELVK 
 2PR 
    
+HUWR      
      



+RIPH\U









Bednarik R.G.$IULFDQ(YHKRD[RUK\SRWKHVLV"3
 /DWH 3OHLVWRFHQH KXPDQ VNXOO IURP +RIPH\U 6RXWK $IULFD DQG
PRGHUQKXPDQRULJLQV*ULQH)(>HWDO@6FLHQFH9RO
35HFRQVWUXFWLRQRIWKHODWH3OHLVWRFHQHKXPDQVNXOOIURP
+RIPH\U6RXWK$IULFD3
Rightmire G.P. 0LGGOH DQG ODWHU 3OHLVWRFHQH KLPLQLQV LQ $IULFD
DQG6RXWKZHVW$VLD3URF1DWO$FDG6FL869RO3

/DWH 3OHLVWRFHQH KXPDQ VNXOO IURP +RIPH\U 6RXWK $IULFD DQG
PRGHUQKXPDQRULJLQVRightmire G.P.0LGGOHDQGODWHU3OHLVWRFHQH
KLPLQLQVLQ$IULFDDQG6RXWKZHVW$VLD3Tattersall I.
+XPDQRULJLQVRXWRI$IULFD3URF1DWO$FDG6FL869RO
3



 

   

    
   Herto,      8/ ,  Klasies River  x
 #<  Skhul/
Qafzeh  ,          / .      ,
     35000. .   
       <


      










      

          
      

       ( 
   .      
            /  #<,   /
5 5  







5LJKWPLUH*30LGGOHDQGODWHU3OHLVWRFHQHKLPLQLQVLQ$IULFDDQG
6RXWKZHVW$VLD
*HQHWLF HYLGHQFH IRU DUFKDLF DGPL[WXUH LQ $IULFD  +DPPHU
0) >HW DO@ 3URF 1DWO $FDG 6FL 86  85/ GRL
SQDV
Hammer M. +XPDQ K\EULGV 6FLHQWLF $PHULFDQ 0D\  3




 

   

     







       





         

      
 0&5     
        


       
     


     
       







     




 

   





      
    
    



<
         


      
        
      
 
         
      





"
      
 


      
     
      



 

   

      
 

 


    
     

    
     
     


      

     
     
      
       
        


 


   
      



    
    


     
<      



 

   

       
     

     



<"
    

    





  
%70
%0
&70
'(0
'0
(0
&)3
&0
)0

\     Y- 


    60   5  F


      
'(&) 
 &)
)
       
      



 

   

  
        
  
0
)=
&76
0
3
&DD=
&DD=
9 
9
E
&E3
&ED.
&E=
&F0
&F0
&FD3
&FE3
&G0
&0
&D0
&E/
&E3
&E0
&ED
3
&G3
&H0
&H=
&HD0
&HE=
HE)
HE&76
&H&76
&H.
&I,06-67
&    5   
  (      )



 

   


  
     
     

      

 E 
    
      
       
  
      
     


       
      
      


      

)
*6
      
* 
,

-
    1  
    
4
5

      
/



 

   

      

    
$                 
   

)0
*0
+0
,-./
,-0
,0
-0
.0
/7/
/0
70
. [/7 0
03
120
10
20
30
40
50
60
\     Y-   
 .10   F   S  0

    

        
     
  



 

   

      
 
      

  

      
    
      

     
     

       






     
 

       
     

      






   
        





 

   

  
    
      




       

       


    


      

    
     
    
       
          
      
    
  

     

     



     
    


Cooper A., Stringer C.B.'LGWKH'HQLVRYDQVFURVV:DOODFHVOLQH"


6FLHQFH9RO3Gibbons A.(OXVLYH'HQLVRYDQV
VLJKWHGLQROGHVWKXPDQ'1$6FLHQFH9RO3



 

   

     
      




    
     
    
      
        

      
     
     
      
     
     ,,, 

     
  
     



         



 
    


 


6" / 2.4.     







 

   

     
     



      
     
     










      
  



     


       




      






1  #.8
 , 

Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. 5HH[DPLQLQJ WKH 2XW RI $IULFD
WKHRU\3



 

   

          
        
 '(     
 '     ' 
         
     
    
      
        
     

  '(  
))

 )    
      
       
  *   ,-.   


     
<
    
       
        
      


        




*+,-.

     *   




 

   

  




      

       

      


,-.
,-
,-
,-
      , , 
 
 
--

-
 
*- 
 . /7 / 7  6 . [/7    
/7

        

      
12
       
   1     
   1 
      

           
1




 

   


1F 

       


 1F     
      
 
  
12
        

    
12
        
4
55
      

 
        
  4   

.,-.
)
     
*,- 

     
      

    


7KHROGHVWGLUHFWO\GDWHGKXPDQUHPDLQVLQ6LEHULD$06&DJH
RIWDOXVERQHIURPWKH%DLJDUDORFDOLW\:HVW6LEHULDQ3ODLQ.X]PLQ
<9>HWDO@-+XPDQ(YROXWLRQ



 

   

      

4
        
      
      

,QGLDQ6FKRRO 
4
    


4

 5      
5  5 

 55D5E
       
      


5D
     

      5D

 5E    
       

       
5E

       
     
5  




 

   

 
     
     
      
     
 

5E $  
5E

5E 
      
     
       
5E 
      

 


5E5D



5D


R1a
& "   R1a  
 20 .. .   '
     


   *DQVX  %RQDQ
'RQJ[LDQJ  6DOD     /LDRQLQJ 
+XL 



 

   

 5D0       


     




'<6 



























Bittles A.H, Black M.L, Wang W.3K\VLFDODQWKURSRORJ\DQGHWKQLFLW\


LQ$VLDWKHWUDQVLWLRQIURPDQWKURSRORJ\WRJHQRPHEDVHGVWXGLHV
-3K\V$QWKURSRORJ\



 

   










 






5D

     
      
 5D    
 

5D

     


5D


    
         
      
      

      



 

   

,,

     
5D
       



=
 5D       




  
 5D  =    





 
  
        
      
      
 5D       



7KH ,QGLDQ RULJLQ RI SDWHUQDO KDSORJURXS 5D  VXEVWDQWLDWHV WKH
DXWRFKWKRQRXVRULJLQRI%UDKPLQVDQGWKHFDVWHV\VWHP6KDUPD6
>HWDO@-RXUQDORI+XPDQ*HQHWLFV9RO3

,QGLJHQRXV DQG IRUHLJQ <FKURPRVRPHV FKDUDFWHUL]H WKH /LQJD\DW
DQG9RNNDOLJDSRSXODWLRQVRI6RXWKZHVW,QGLD&KHQQDNULVKQDLDK
6>HWDO@*HQHLQWKHSUHVVSDJHV




 

   



 

 

5D=


5D

   5D   
     / 
        
/
/


         

 /    <
      
      
 
/

   5D   

=
      
       
Rozhanskii I.L., Klyosov A.A. +DSORJURXS 5D ,WV 6XEFODGHV DQG
%UDQFKHVLQ(XURSH3

3RSXODWLRQ GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI 6RXWKHUQ ,QGLDQ PDOH OLQHDJHV
FRUUHODWHVZLWKDJULFXOWXUDOH[SDQVLRQVSUHGDWLQJWKHFDVWHV\VWHP
$UXQ.XPDU*3>HWDO@3/262QH9RO1RH
85/GRLMRXUQDOSRQH




 

   



     
 1DLNURG$QGK3DUGKDQ 

       




        
      
     
5D      

       
 


     
5D




       
         

   5D   



     
  5D      


'9 #.#.
5D





 

   

    
5D         
 5D      





     
5D
/XRED'HQJ
    5D



5D




     
 
      
 
     
      
         
    5D  

      
5D
<FKURPRVRPH2+DSORJURXS'LYHUVLW\LQ6LQR7LEHWDQ3RSXODWLRQV
5HYHDOV7ZR0LJUDWLRQ5RXWHVLQWRWKH(DVWHUQ+LPDOD\DV.DQJ/
>HWDO@$QQDOVRI+XPDQ*HQHWLFV85/GRLM
[

'9 #.#.5D1
      





 

   


      

5D



5D
         

        

     
     
5D  



5D


     
       
      
5D
    



    5D  
      
0VDLGLH6  


'9 #.#.5D


*HQHWLFGLYHUVLW\RQWKH&RPRURV,VODQGVVKRZVHDUO\VHDIDULQJDV
PDMRU GHWHUPLQDQW RI KXPDQ ELRFXOWXUDO HYROXWLRQ LQ WKH :HVWHUQ
,QGLDQ2FHDQ0VDLGLH6>HWDO@(XU-+XP*HQHW9RO
3



 

   


     

  








5D

      
5D
      
5D
 



 


    5D 
         
        


 

    
 




 

   

   



        
       



5D

     
5D

      

      
5D

 
"       
      5D 
   
5D
    <  
      


'9 #.#.5EE
   $ 3UHGRPLQDQWO\ 1HROLWKLF 2ULJLQ
IRU (XURSHDQ 3DWHUQDO /LQHDJHV 3DWULFLD %DODUHVTXH HW DO 3/R6
%LRORJ\ YRO  -DQXDU\  RQOLQH SXEOLFDWLRQ  
 ,661 


*  0.6.,   6.6.    
  Gray R.D., Atkinson Q.D. /DQJXDJHWUHH
GLYHUJHQFH WLPHV VXSSRUW WKH $QDWROLDQ WKHRU\ RI ,QGR(XURSHDQ
RULJLQ 1DWXUH  9RO  3  85/ GRL
QDWXUH

Boric D., Price T.D. 6WURQWLXP LVRWRSHV GRFXPHQW JUHDWHU KXPDQ
PRELOLW\ DW WKH VWDUW RI WKH %DONDQ 1HROLWKLF 3URFHHGLQJV RI WKH
1DWLRQDO$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHVRIWKH86$9RO3
GRLSQDV



 

   

     5 

     < 

       
        

$!*

5D        

5D




5D/
 !&      
5D
      
      
5D/
        


      
5D
 
     

5
      <
      
       




KWWSZZZQFELQOPQLKJRY613VQSBUHIFJL"UV 



 

   


7!&

5D

        


     
5D
/03)/03)/03)
/03)

     
 613 6LQJOH 1XFOHRWLGH 3RO\PRUSKLVP  

/
)7'1$ )DPLO\7UHH'1$ 

  3)
 

"




     
       








KWWSZZZQFELQOPQLKJRY613VQSBUHIFJL"UV 
KWWSZZZLVRJJRUJWUHH,62**B+DSJUS5KWPO



 

   



       
    5D 
5E



    
5D
 
        





5D 
     

  5D    
      
5E  


 

 


 

5D
$QFLHQW'1$UHYHDOVNH\VWDJHVLQWKHIRUPDWLRQRI&HQWUDO(XURSHDQ
PLWRFKRQGULDOJHQHWLFGLYHUVLW\%UDQGW*>HWDO@6FLHQFH
9RO3

$QFLHQW'1$UHYHDOVNH\VWDJHV3




 

   

  <   
 
      5D


       

      
      

,,,

     


         
      
       
      



     
     (E9
*D3 ,0 ,0 5D0  5D0 
       
     
       
     

,D0
      


$QFLHQW '1$ VWURQWLXP LVRWRSHV DQG RVWHRORJLFDO DQDO\VHV VKHG


OLJKW RQ VRFLDO DQG NLQVKLS RUJDQL]DWLRQ RI WKH /DWHU 6WRQH $JH 
+DDN:>HWDO@3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH1DWLRQDO$FDGHP\RI6FLHQFHV
RI WKH 8QLWHG 6WDWHV RI $PHULFD  9RO  3 
GRLSQDV



 

   



 ,D0     



(E9

        


  ,0    
*D


       
      
 *DE 
         
    





      ,,,  
"


         
     
    
5E


 5D     
       



 

   

      
       
5D=5D/
      


<
    =  /  


5DD00 
5DD0
5DDE=
5DDE= 
5DDED=
5DDED= 
5DDE= 
5DDED/= 

\       R1a


Y-       III    .$.,           8       R1a-M17 (
 R1a-M198),
""         
   ,     
R1a-Z283,  -   R1a-Z93.   
     /   
 Z280    L342.2 (
 Z94)

    =
       
 / 
      
     
     
       



 

   

  


=/


   -  


 R1a-Z93-L342.2. $  
 ,        , "    L342.2.'   "    L342.2,    
 
  .0 -      Z93,  ,      L342.2.      " 
  R1a-L342.2-Z2124-Z2122-M582,  
        
(   19-)       *  -8"-2- .'     
RozhanskiiI.L., KlyosovA.A. (2012)

   5D/   
     



Rozhanskii I.L., Klyosov A.A. +DSORJURXS 5D ,WV 6XEFODGHV DQG


%UDQFKHVLQ(XURSH3



 

   

       
 

    ,,,    
5D

      

     
==



    
    5D=
       
  


    
       
    
       





  



       
        




 

   

   /      R1a-Z280   . 


        
 ,   /     
  /  - , ,  ,
 -,  -   - .'      RozhanskiiI.L.,
KlyosovA.A. (2012)




  5D  

5D

       

       
      


,ELG3



 

   

     
5D
5D
    
       5D



      

5D
 


 
       
 
      







 
 
     - *  / 7

         
     

/

      
      
    



 

   


 5D F     
     
   
5D
5D  
      
         




    
      
        

  
5DDE= 
5DDED/= 
5DDED/ 

5DDEDD< 
5DDED= 

5DDEDD= 
5DDEDE= 

5DDEDE)0 
5DDEDED&76=
5DDEDEE)
5DDEDE< 
 

\       R1a-Z93


Y-  .%     4900. .
      (Z93  L342.2),    
4050. .      L657  Z2124, 
   "   Y7 ( L657)  
       Z2124



 

   

 / 


 / 

       
<      


/ 
/
 =
     
      




     
     
       
  5D     
<


     


      
        
      
       


       




 

   

  Equus caballus gmelini   



         

        
   Equus caballus silvaticus


     


;,;



      

     

     
 5D 
       
       





R1a-Z93-L342.2


    


6  0.       

  



 

   

    /
5D

/

/
    
    
      
     


  
      
5D/

    
    
          
/

    5D/ 
       
=

       
      
       


         


      

5D




 

   

    

=/



&  128   R1a-L342.2 


67-   < .*        /       R  U,  ,       

      

    
   

       
      
      



 

   



 




      
 /     


/

    
       
  
      /

     

/

     
/
      
5D/
      
      
      
 /      


    

     /
     




 

   

   ;9,  ;,;    
     
  
     
    
     
   
 
     
       
    
     
      
5D/


      
      
      
 










 
 < 
     
    <
     
      



 

   

   
'<6        


      '<6 
         
        
       
     
      
     

 

     



/






        
 
  

/ 
      
 
 
 





 

   

;,




    



       






         





      
         
         

       

     
5D/
      



     

          



 

   

     / 
      
 
 


/

 
 
 
/
/


 
        
 
 
  

       
      

      




 

   





     
     
     
     


      

      
     
     

    






     












 

   



   


"

    

     


6    

,9
  
     
  \    
     



     

# "
   




  
    



 
 



 

   

  


#   6 


, 6
 \  

    
      


      










 

   

    
       ,4OLE 
 KWWSZZZLTOLEUX   
     
   
    
     
 
,          
 
      $ 
     






   8 ,
6-1    & -& / ,       #
     
     

    
    
             
4    ()  5 , /  
 1 - " 
,  
8  5)
   






 




 

   

   
     
    
   
      
      

     
,,



"      



    




      

     
   
        
   
       
       


     
    
       








 

   

    
     
   



    


    
     
     ,, 

       






   
      
   
   
    0
  ,  &.#.' , 
  ,  /   <  ,    "   

     

      
   "  
   



'  &.#.




 

   

     


   6-1 
 "  /  << //,      
      
     
  , / ,     , "      
   
      
    
      
   



     
     
  







    

 

    
       
        




 

   

   
       
  



     
    


      


    
      
      




    
    
       

     
    
     





      

    






 

   



      


       

     


     

      
     





     
      
    
      
       

      






     
"    


5<  6.#.



 

   



     
      

     


"


     
     
      



     
    

     

        
        
      
,,,,,,,,,,
,,,

     





5<  .%.


5  '.6.       


  %..




 

   

      /  < /  "             
   %   /   
     
      
      
       
       
       



 / ( ,     )  ,        
 ,   ,    
    
   
    ;9,,,;9,   
     
  -      <          
    


     

   " " 
  

   
*   %.6.     


  %..








 

   

     
     
     
       
     
   
   

     
       
   
     
 
     
       
      
      
     

       
    
     
   
     
   

    
       

    
"
      
            
    "  


)  *.4.







 

   

     

     
   "  
    /
    
;9,,,;9,
      

 "
      
    
      
      
      
     








    

      

    


)  *.4.


'   %.%.     


  .6.    
       





 

   

    


 
  -       

 $  

     
    
     
       


    
     

      


              -  








     

      

      

  %.., '   5.6.   
  






 

   

    

       
    
      



       
    


    
      

   
      
      


      
       
"     
     



  
      

        


 


(  #.2.





 

   

    




        

      


  -  

1RRUVPDUNNX.DDVDQPDNL/DXNDDLHODYHVL 
 
 
 
    -


,


         

    

 


"

    


  %.., '   5.6.






  %.., '   5.6.




 

   



     

     
    
  
   



    
     


       


      
    
       

     

    
    
    



    
     
     

      







 

   


     

     

   
    



   -
  
     
      
      

    
     



      500\
$  $   ,   - / ,.. "         



    

       




 -

    






 

   

 
       

     

      
   

1-                  
      


   <    
   NHQRWiSKLRQ   

       


       


      




      
      








  %.., '   5.6.


' (.\.      




 

   


      





2-        
       


3-  


4-  

       
      



5-       



     

      



0" #.#., *" 5.8."




8 6.{.



  %.., '   5.6.





  %.., '   5.6



 

   

6-  







7-      

      
      
     

           
 
     , 
    




     

;,;

      
       

       
     

     
  

    




'" x.\.      





 

   

      
     
    ;9,    

    

;9,,
;9




    

"      



99,,,

,,

     
    
     
      
      


   

;9,,;9,  -  
   <      

     



 

   




    
          

      
       
       

      
   
         
   
      
 
     


      
     
    
    
    
.-mietmit miat
kuankiwen.
kukwemchu
suwoswanana



 
  
 

*  0.6.,   6.6.


*  0.6.,   6.6.





 

   

      

     
     
      

  
/  /







     
      
      
  
    



     
     

      
      

'
 8.(.


|      



        

  





 

   

     

        

      
     



     
   
     
      

    
      

      
  



1   
 
 


| x.5.
          




 

   



     
     
<
      






6   ( R1a)   


     
 , 
  



 

   

 (  ),


    (  ),  /   (        
 ).0 
       
R1a  *   (+),  "   , 
 4600 . .,        ( &   6, 2    .$.),       (      & ,
56004300 . .,   43 . .$.,       5  ',   
 ,      
    (2 . .$.)  
*  # (        
    ,  
.+   $  ,  
R1b,  $
 
      
     ,        ,    $ 
  1 - ",  "    
 )

      

$QFLHQW'1$VWURQWLXPLVRWRSHVDQGRVWHRORJLFDODQDO\VHVVKHGOLJKW
RQVRFLDODQGNLQVKLSRUJDQL]DWLRQRIWKHODWHU6WRQH$JH+DDN:>HW
DO@3URF1DWO$FDG6FL869RO3

{ %.6

   85/ KWWSZZZGLVVHUFDWFRPFRQWHQW
VNRWRYRGFKHVNRHQDVHOHQLHVHYHUR]DSDGQRJRSULFKHUQRPRU\D
HSRNKLUDQQHJRPHWDOODL[]]WE73U4)M

KWWSFKHFKHQRUJDUFKLYHV

'  6.&..
9,,
85/KWWSVLEURUXUHDGLQJGRF

KWWSZZZFXOWXUDOVFKRROUXLQGH[OHV3DJHKWP

&
 6.2., 0  4.*.   

   85/ KWWSZZZEURQ]DOLEQDURGUXGGHU]KDYLQB
WLKRQRYKWPO

*" #.%.     
    
         85/ KWWS
ZZZGLVVHUFDWFRPFRQWHQWSRJUHEDOQ\LREU\DGNURWRYVNRL
N X OW X U \W LSRORJ L\DSRJ UHEDO QRLSU D N W L N LSR PDW H U LD OD P
PRJLOQLNL[]]WDE2.SL.




 

   


      
    
      
      
         
    



     
 
       

   
      
      
       
     











         
      





'9 #.#.




 

   

)   
  R1a (/ )
  4600. .      *   (+).8
     , 
 , /  





<
      

   
<
       


  
<     
       

        
     


$QFLHQW'1$VWURQWLXPLVRWRSHV3



 

   





     
       





      






     


R1a, , 4600 ..
     
      

        
     
     
    5D   
          




   5D   


$QFLHQW'1$VWURQWLXPLVRWRSHV3



 

   






      


 5D 


    5D  

 5D 



 
     
       

       
       

        
    
     
    
          
       
     


         
 



 

   


5D

    



R1a, , ,
3800-3400 2800-1900 ..

5D


      5D   




5

     
5D  
 5D 

       
     
       
  5D     

 5D 


$QFLHQW'1$SURYLGHVQHZLQVLJKWLQWRWKHKLVWRU\RIVRXWK6LEHULDQ
.XUJDQSHRSOH.H\VHU&>HWDO@+XP*HQHW9RO3




 

   

   (  /) 


   ,           &' .6 ,  $  )         ,
      / ,    

     

     

     


      
     
        
         






,ELG



 

   

>& [& @



      


      
5D







      
        








 
 




      
    


'9 #.#.5D//




 

   



   613   
5D//
5D/
= 
 5D     


       
     

       
        




6 
  ||.
(/    Klyosov A.A., Mironova%.#.2013)


Klyosov A.A., Mironova E.A $ '1$ *HQHDORJ\ 6ROXWLRQ WR


WKH 3X]]OH RI $QFLHQW /RRN$OLNH &HUDPLFV DFURVV WKH :RUOG
$GYDQFHVLQ$QWKURSRORJ\9RO1R3



 

   

       
 
 



       


      4 ,


  



 

   

  5D    

      
       





    /  
       
       
      
/




       



R1a, , - ,
40003800 ..
  


5D
  
/L&

     
     


(YLGHQFH WKDW D :HVW(DVW DGPL[HG SRSXODWLRQ OLYHG LQ WKH 7DULP


%DVLQDVHDUO\DVWKHHDUO\%URQ]H$JH/L&>HWDO@%0&%LRORJ\
GRL



 

   

1   0      


0  ,       
  R1a

      



       
    
5D

  5D    



/L&


        
5D

     



 

   

5D


     
5D/
      
    
     
       
         





R1a,
-
    
       
 .H\VHU
7UDFTXL &         



       
    
       


     

5D


Keyser-Tracqui C., Crubezy E., Ludes B.1XFOHDUDQGPLWRFKRQGULDO


'1$DQDO\VLVRID\HDUROGQHFURSROLVLQWKH(J\LQ*RO9DOOH\
RI0RQJROLD$P-+XP*HQHW9RO3



 

   

 5D 

 
    
 
     

 5D 

     
 

 y

      
5D

    5D  
      

     
      
 .LP .       
   F   


   #
      
       

 
      

     

      
 

$ :HVWHUQ (XUDVLDQ PDOH LV IRXQG LQ \HDUROG HOLWH ;LRQJQX
FHPHWHU\ LQ 1RUWKHDVW 0RQJROLD  .LP . >HW DO@ $PHU - 3K\V
$QWKURSRO9RO3



 

   

      
<    5D 
    8H 
       
8
         

5D
5D
    
       
   .DQDOMRUGHQ   
  
    8H  

 8 
       






5D
*

G2a,
- , 6015-6260 ..
     
     

$QFLHQW KXPDQ JHQRPHV VXJJHVW WKUHH DQFHVWUDO SRSXODWLRQV IRU
SUHVHQWGD\(XURSHDQV/D]DULGLV,>HWDO@6XSSOHPHQWDO0DWHULDO
'HFHPEHUELR5[LYRQOLQH'RL

$QFLHQW'1$IURP(XURSHDQHDUO\1HROLWKLFIDUPHUVUHYHDOVWKHLU
1HDU(DVWHUQDIQLWLHV+DDN:>HWDO@3/26%LRORJ\  
HGRLMRXUQDOSELR




 

   




      
      
     
    <  
      
 *D    
 :      
<) [*+,-. 
)
*+,-.
       
  )      




++99.7-
 :1D 

 78DD 
     


    
      


*D
    
         


'9 #.#.    
 +DDNHW
DO   3/26 %LRORJ\ 1RYHPEHU    




 

   

          
       
    *D 



*D
 
       

"




5E

      

  
        

     
     5D  
*D
E
 ,       
,E
     
       


        
  ,DE   


'9 #.#.


Klyosov A.A.$QFLHQWKLVWRU\RIWKH$UELQV3



 

   

     





       
       
,

     
  *D  

       



G2a I2a
, 5000 ..
/DFDQ0  
      


,D
*D
 

 
;;;
,D 
'9 #.#.     
  ,D   
3

$QFLHQW '1$ UHYHDOV PDOH GLIIXVLRQ WKURXJK WKH 1HROLWKLF
0HGLWHUUDQHDQURXWH/DFDQ0>HWDO@3URF1DWO$FDG6FL86
9RO3




 

   

    
     
  ,D   
       
     
  

,D 

    
 
      



       
      
,D
      
      
   ,DE   


  ,D    
     
5E

      


     
    *D  

      




 

   

;;
*D3 


       
        
       
*D3
*DFD3
        
 


;;
*D 


  
      
   

      

      


 

5E

G2a E1b -
, 7000 ..
    /DFDQ 0     
    
      
*D



 

   

(E9    
*D

;;
*D 



        
     

      
      
         
        

 *D   

      


   
*D

   (E 
 9      


       
 5E    
     
     
    


$QFLHQW '1$ VXJJHVWV WKH OHDGLQJ UROH SOD\HG E\ PHQ LQ WKH
1HROLWKLFGLVVHPLQDWLRQ/DFDQ0>HWDO@3URF1DWO$FDG6FL
869RO3



 

   




5E



(E9
   

      
 
(E9

     



   9  



        
(E9


9

(E9 





'LVFXVVLRQV 7KH PXWDWLRQ UDWH FRQVWDQWV LQ '1$ JHQHDORJ\ DQG


UHODWHGLVVXHV




 

   



 
(E9 

&  67-    


E1b-V13.8   193 ,     
%



 (E9 

    

   

     



 

   

     
     




    
        






, tzi the Iceman,


G2a,
, 4550 ..

  

      
     

*DE*D
         


&RPSOHWHPLWRFKRQGULDOJHQRPHVHTXHQFHRIWKH7\UROHDQ,FHPDQ
(UPLQL/>HWDO@&XUU%LRO9RO3$UHYLVHG
WLPHVFDOH IRU KXPDQ HYROXWLRQ EDVHG RQ DQFLHQW PLWRFKRQGULDO
JHQRPHV  )X 4 >HW DO@ &XUU %LRO  9RO  3  7KH
PXVFXORVNHOHWDO DEQRUPDOLWLHV RI WKH 6LPLODXQ ,FHPDQ g7=, 
FOXHV WR FKURQLF SDLQ DQG SRVVLEOH WUHDWPHQWV  .HDQ :) >HW DO@
,QDPPRSKDUPDFRORJ\9RO3Pntener A.G., Moss
S.2W]LWKH,FHPDQDQGKLVOHDWKHUFORWKHV&KLPLD $XUDX 
9RO32OLYLHUL&>HWDO@&KDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIQXFOHRWLGH
PLVLQFRUSRUDWLRQ SDWWHUQV LQ WKH LFHPDQV PLWRFKRQGULDO '1$
3/26 2QH     H GRL MRXWQDOSRQH
)LQHFKDUDFWHUL]DWLRQRIWKH,FHPDQVPW'1$KDSORJURXS5ROOR)
>HWDO@$P-3K\V$QWKURSRO9RO3



 

   


*D



      


(3333-3323 ..),
R1b

      
      
     
  
    
     
    

     L*(1($ 
    


 


5ED
5ED
  
  
5ED


'9 #.#.  







 

   

    5ED  
 "     
       
        


50   
;;




)  <  0   


 



'9 #.#.      





 

   

     
     

5ED
      

"

      

    >     
   @       
         
       
 5ED     
    






    
5ED

      " 


        

    
   ;9,,,  


      
;9,,,,


Klyosov A.A.$QFLHQWKLVWRU\RIWKH$UELQV3



 

   

,,,,,,
,,,
        
   ,      
,
 ,  ;9,,,  
,
,,

,

 ;9,,,     

 
,,   ,   ,   ,,, 
 ,,,      
 
     ,,     
      
 
    
      
;;;,,        
        
       
       

     
     

        
      
5ED


    
      



 

   




       

    
      
        

   5ED  




     


R1b, , 47004500 ..
/HH(-  


  
  5E    


      
         

       
<5E
5E
    
    


(PHUJLQJJHQHWLFSDWWHUQVRIWKH(XURSHDQ1HROLWKLFSHUVSHFWLYHV
IURPDODWH1HROLWKLF%HOO%HDNHUEXULDOVLWHLQ*HUPDQ\/HH(-
>HWDO@$PHU-3K\V$QWKURSRO9RO3



 

   


         R1b   
     3    .$.)
        3 . .$.,    4800 
,  8 .+         $  ,
  R1b,  8  ,
      5  #<

     5E  

<      


     

     
       



 

   

,.7D8H8D:D
  +    
      

5D
          
5E



I2a, R1a, R1b, , 3000-2700 ..


     


6FKLO])

      
,DE/
5D5E8
     


  ,D   
    
 5D      
,D

 ,DE 


5D



Schilz F. 0ROHNXODUJHQHWLVFKH 9HUZDQGWVFKDIWVDQDO\VHQ DP


SUlKLVWRULVFKHQ6NHOHWWNROOHNWLYGHU/LFKWHQVWHLQK|KOH'LVVHUWDWLRQ
*|WWLQJHQ



 

   

 5D 

5E
 5E8 


    
     

 ,DE
 5D
 5E8 

     



   
     

       


I2a, , 7200 ..

      
       


    



$QFLHQW KXPDQ JHQRPHV VXJJHVW WKUHH DQFHVWUDO SRSXODWLRQV IRU


SUHVHQWGD\(XURSHDQV/D]DULGLV,>HWDO@6XSSOHPHQWDO0DWHULDO
'HFHPEHUELR5[LYRQOLQH'RL



 

   

      
,DE
      
,
   ,-     
<
, , ,D,D
,DE
 ,DD    ,DE  


,DE,DE,DE  

,0
,0
,0
,D/
,D3
,DD/
,DE0/
,DE0
,DE/
,DE/
,DED/

&    I( ).1       
/, I2a1b-M423.5 

     L147.2,     
  6  %   */  
 8   ,     
   ,
"  2300. .0   
/,

" 7200 . .      

  ,
       



,ELG



 

   



,,-
      

,

     
    
      
       

,,
5D5E

      



      
    

 
 
8ED


      
       8
  


       
         
  85/ KWWSDQWURSRJHQH]UX]YHQR
VLQJOH






 

   

5D
    5E    


8
  
    -  1D  9  

     8 

-9


       


,,


I, , 7 . ..
     
       




      


     
;<


 


$QFLHQW KXPDQ JHQRPHV VXJJHVW WKUHH DQFHVWUDO SRSXODWLRQV IRU


SUHVHQWGD\(XURSHDQV



 

   

 
      
     
;<  
 
  

<


 ,       
,        
 , ,D ,DE ,DED  

,,D,D,DD


,0
,0
,0
,D/
,D3
,DD/
,DD/
,DE0/
,DE0
,DE/
,DE/
,DED/
,D/

&    I,      


 </  -          ( , w/.)      $ ,          .#
 ,      </   I,   , I*,     

   .'  , $  ,    
    ,    I2,   



 

   


, 
      ,  

,,
,DE


     


     ,   
  

    
88H  8D
 8D8DG  
8ED

R, , 24 . ..

        
        

    
       
5DJKDYDQ0  


<
58


8SSHU3DODHROLWKLF6LEHULDQJHQRPHUHYHDOVGXDODQFHVWU\RI1DWLYH
$PHULFDQV  5DJKDYDQ 0 >HW DO@ 1DWXUH  GRL
QDWXUH

,ELG




 

   





54  
       

       
     
4 

 

     





5D5E

Balter M. $QFLHQW '1$ OLQNV 1DWLYH $PHULFDQV ZLWK (XURSH


6FLHQFH9RO3

Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\PXWDWLRQUDWHV3Klyosov
A.A., Rozhanskii I.L.+DSORJURXS5DDVWKH3URWR,QGR(XURSHDQV
DQGWKHOHJHQGDU\$U\DQVDVZLWQHVVHGE\WKH'1$RIWKHLUFXUUHQW
GHVFHQGDQWV $GYDQFHV LQ $QWKURSRORJ\  9RO  1R 3
Klyosov A.A$QFLHQWKLVWRU\RIWKH$UELQV3




 

   




   
     
        


"

     








  "     
"
     


      

     


      
        
        



 

   



     
       

4

     

      
      



"



;


    
;,,

     


      
      

        


"
     
      
      



 

   

     
        




     
      
      
       

      










       

"




     

   5D    

5D






 

   

( 
 
     .

    
     
      

     





      

      
     
        
     
        
      
    



 

   

& 12-    126  ( . 8    PijpeJ. .
8     







-
      


,QGLDQ RFHDQ FURVVURDGV +XPDQ JHQHWLF RULJLQ DQG SRSXODWLRQ


VWUXFWXUHLQWKH0DOGLYHV3LMSH->HWDO@$PHU-3K\V$QWKURSRO
9RO3



 

   

       
      
      5D 

       
 

      

    -     
       
        
      


<
5+/


5  
        



 
 
     
         



Klyosov A.A. 5D= VXEFODGH DPRQJ 'UDYLGLDQ SRSXODWLRQV LQ


,QGLD3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH$FDGHP\RI'1$*HQHDORJ\9RO
 1R  3  Klyosov A.A $XWRFKWRQRXV DQG ,QGR
(XURSHDQKDSORW\SHVRIWKH5DKDSORJURXSLQWKH6RXWKRI,QGLD
&RPPHQWVWRWKHDUWLFOHE\56SHQFHU:HOOV>HWDO@3RSXODWLRQ
GLIIHUHQWLDWLRQ RI 6RXWKHUQ ,QGLDQ PDOH OLQHDJHV  3/26 RQH
1RYHPEHU3URFHHGLQJVRIWKH$FDGHP\RI'1$*HQHDORJ\
9RO1R3



 

   




       




      
/


+

    + 
     
       


   5D    


      
5D

  




        
      
      
 
 



 

   


 


,

5D"

 

  
5D




      


     

     
5D
       
 
 


5D
   =   
  

  



Rozhanskii I.L., Klyosov A.A. +DSORJURXS 5D ,WV VXEFODGHV DQG


EUDQFKHVLQ(XURSH3



 

   

 
 

5D


     



        

5D

5D
 



     
      
     
 5D    




      
      
         
    

Klyosov A.A., Rozhanskii I.L. +DSORJURXS 5D DV WKH 3URWR ,QGR
(XURSHDQV3

)DPLO\ 7UHH '1$ 85/ KWWSVZZZIDPLO\WUHHGQDFRPSXEOLF
LQGLDGHIDXOWDVS["VHFWLRQ \UHVXOWV




 

   






6  6415  

        


      6 5< >
 @   
      
;,,, < - / 
     
     
      
       

< 
       

     
 
    






4  (.6.





 

   

     
"
     
    

      
     

      



      
     
    
     
   
     








   

    
    

     
     
      


4"  #..


       




 

   

9
,          
      


    
    

      
[
     


     
       
    
    
    
      
     
      
   

    
      
        



      

      





4"  #..






 

   





"






       

    
     
      
    
 
     



       




     




      
5  '.6.       







 

   



 
 
   5      ?'       ,   
    ,       ? (     -    
(    R1a) "  
 ,  ,  4
 6"

       

 
 5D





       


     





1DWXUH
      +DOI
RIDOO5XVVLDQPDOHVKDYHD<FKURPRVRPHOLQNHGWRWKH
KLVWRULFDO$U\DSHRSOHRI,UDQ 


&  .6.




 
      




 

   

  <   
 
    


0 / 2.
 



      


  
, 
, ,  , 
 
 (%) [   .. ,
.. !  
 "  

      
]

250-500
1086

R1a
45,0
50,8

R1a-Z280
16,2
15,5
R1a-CE
9,1
12,1
R1a-NEA2
8,1
11,8
R1a-BC
2,0
8,1
R1a-WS
9,6
3,3
I2a1b
13,0
17,9
N1c1
7,5
10,1
I1
3,5
5,6
R1b1a2
7,5
5,3
E1b1b1
5,5
3,8
J2
7,0
2,3
G2a
2,5
1,4
J1
1,0
0,7
I2a2
1,0
0,6

6,5
1,5

545

825

1100

256

47,9

55,1

22,0

35,1

21,5
6,0
10,8
6,4
3,2
11,7
14,3
9,5
4,8
2,9
2,9
1,8
0,9
0,2
2,9

21,1
9,4
1,7
5,7
17,2
6,4
5,8
7,5
12,6
2,7
3,6
1,3
0,2
2,2
2,4

22,0

37,8
0,4
5,5
7,9
10,7
6,2
2,7
1,1
1,5
4,2

13,6
5,0
7,2
7,9
1,4
3,5
46,5
5,5
3,9
0,8
1,6
1,2
0,0
1,2
0,8

1     R1a: CE /  -, WS   , NEA2    (Z280+, Z92+),  
 2350300  , BC -, Z280  
  .5       
FTDNA.   R1a            IRAKAZ, 
 3126  R1a   67   .    /,   R1a   ,
    www.eupedia.com/europe/european_y-dna_haplogroups.shtml



1DWXUH
'9 #.#.



 

   

     
"
     

"
    5D 

      
5D

      
1
     
     
,

          

          
     
       
,
         



  ,  ,    

5D1
       
5D1
   1    
     
  1    



KWWSVZZZIDPLO\WUHHGQDFRPSXEOLF 15XVVLD
'1$3URMHFWGHIDXOWDVS["VHFWLRQ \UHVXOWV



 

   





5D
    ,5$.$=   
      

1

5D

      


      
   1  
       
    
5D  





      
15D

    
15D


        
     




KWWSUDRUJ



 

   

    


&   R1a (  )


 N (),    797 67-   ,
   568  R1a  229 N.&
  /    , $  /<
 
           .0        

     ,    ,   
     $    N1,
N1a,       ()   N1b, 
20  (   9%     N),
  91%   N1c1 (  "  ).0    R1a 
  ,
$        , , , -  /  
,   

     
1 
 
5D




 

   

    
15D"
     
     
      
     

  
      
    
       
 


     5D 
    

 >OQ  @      
       
       
        
    

"
5D=




       

1



Klyosov A.A.'1$*HQHDORJ\PXWDWLRQUDWHVDQGVRPHKLVWRULFDO
HYLGHQFHV ZULWWHQ LQ <FKURPRVRPH , %DVLF SULQFLSOHV DQG WKH
PHWKRG-*HQHWLF*HQHDORJ\9RO3



 

   


>OQ  @ 

1

       
     
   




      
      
       




     







        
       

  6.6.    $FWD
(WKQRJUDSKLFD+XQJDULFD%XGDSHVW7

     
         
 

 
      
      





 

   

    
        

 5D    
     


]
] 
     " 
 





 

   



      
        
  
       
     
       
     



      




         

   
      ,  

      
    

       


,9,9  
       

        5  



 

   

    
  
  
     
      
   5    
 
  
      



           
   



      


  
      
    
      

      
     




     


0 8..
2" .
 
*HWLFD

#  6..




 

   







        
       


     
       
     

     
        >
@
      





      






      
"
KWWSZZZDEDHYDUXGH\DWHOLBQDXNLDEDHYBYDVLOLMBLYDQRYLFK
LVWRUL\DLQGH[KWP

#  6..

 .        





 

   







< 


 9 
     

9,



       




    
     
     

       

       

    
      
       
     


# 6.8.


# 6.8.     




 

   

    


     " 
    

      

            "   
   >@
       



     
       

    
  
     

      

       
    
    

      
       
     
     
\ 6.8.     



+  &..





 

   


       9,
,,  

     
    

        
    
   
   
     
      
 
      

      

       
      

       
6 
          ,  
        ,  (     ),  ,
    > @    






      
"



( #.



 

   


     



      



     

       
"
     
       
 
       
     
       
5D

 
 

      
 
 
       


     5D 

        
       
     

 



 

   


 

     

   
    
       
       
      
       



5D  

       

    


5D

     
       




5D  

 

     
       
5D



 

   

      

 5D 

     

          
       
5D

,,


"


5D
       

     
    5D= 
  

      
     
5D//  
     

5D/  
 (XODX 

5D

$QFLHQW '1$ 6WURQWLXP LVRWRSHV DQG RVWHRORJLFDO DQDO\VHV
3

,ELG




 

   



 
;       

 

5D 


5D
      

 5D 

       
    

      









  
     
5D







 

   

 5D 

     
        
      
        
  

5D

  
       
       



   
>@  


     


       
5D
5D

  

     
       


     


7KH ,QGLDQ RULJLQ RI SDWHUQDO KDSORJURXS 5D  VXEVWDQWLDWHV 3






 

   

     


5D










=  
      

  

       
"

















































      
/
  

       
   5D//  
      
5D




 

   

  
      





 
 







5D/




 5D     
      





      

     
      

        




 

   

"
       


5D
     

      

5D"
     
    

5D




 ,,,9
    9,     



    
 
 


    
    
0LWRFKRQGULDO'1$DQG<FKURPRVRPHYDULDWLRQSURYLGHVHYLGHQFH
IRU D UHFHQW FRPPRQ DQFHVWU\ EHWZHHQ 1DWLYH $PHULFDQV DQG
LQGLJHQRXV$OWDLDQV'XOLN0&>HWDO@$PHU-+XPDQ*HQHWLFV
'2,DMKJ

7UDFLQJWKHRULJLQRIWKH(DVW:HVWSRSXODWLRQDGPL[WXUHLQWKH$OWDL
UHJLRQ &HQWUDO$VLD *RQ]DOH]5XL]0>HWDO@3/262QH
9RO3H




 

   

      5D
      
5D
      
41
    5E
      

5D

    5D 
  


5D
$&'*
5D


$&'*
       

     5D
     
     
5D
 
 

     
     
   



'9 #.#.   5D    



3



 

   

&  75   R1a  #


 17-   < .6      (57, 68, 70, 71, 74),  (60, 61, 62)  -

(57).
     :  
(66, 67, 69, 73, 75)    (63).
  
 " :    (64, 65),   (72), -

(8, 51,59).1    -




      

     


       


    






 

   

5D



&  257   R1a 


    ( 12    \/)
 17-   < .   
Ar32  Ar38       [Roewer, 2008]
(    
   ) "  ,
       .(  
   ,  ,  
   
 


'9 #.#.     "







 

   

     
       
  
    

      


 


  


     

;,




5D 

     

  

 
  


Rozhanskii I.L., Klyosov A.A. +DSORJURXS 5D LWV VXEFODGHV DQG


EUDQFKHV LQ (XURSH GXULQJ WKH ODVW  \HDUV $GY $QWKURSRO
9RO1R3



 

   

        

     

     
        

      

       
        

     
 
 



      


    

 
 

 

 
>@

 



 

   

     / 


 / 

       


 


 



 
 
 


      


 
   
 
 



     





 

   

    
      
       
<
      
     
 $&'* 
 +9-87. 
    
       
      
      
    

      
5D

     
     


        

     
5D
      
     


      



       
     




 

   



  

   
    
    
 
 
        

     
 

   
      
 
 
       
       


    




      

      

     

    
        
     




 

   

 
   
 


     
    
     
     


      
   
    
 
       
      

   

5D

     
      
5D
    
     



 5D    
        
 







 

   

  
       
      



     
      





 

   




     
    

      


       
     


      

        





    






     

    




 

   


     

      
     
     
      
     
    
    

     
      
      




      

      




     




      





| x.5.





 

   

     
    
    
   






   




 
 
        
   
      
        

    

  

 
   
    





     
       



 

   


;,;
    
     
    
      



   
  
   

 
    



    
    
       

      
      
   
      

      

      
     

     



4 0.5.>@
      




 

   

      
   
    
         
       

  ,  
  
  "

5   /   



   8, x )  5  ( ).
#  /:0.5.4.



 

   

5   /  


 
   , x )  5  (
, IIIIV. .$.) #  /:0.5.4.

 
 
" 
   
   
 
    

     
 
 



 

   

      

 



5   /   



 \  , x
 8 (  ,
VIV. .$.).#  /:0.5.4.


     5   
 ;9 
     




 

   




5   /  


 
 \  , x
 8 (  ,
VIV. .$.) #  /:0.5.4.

    

>@

   
   <   /  









 

   

5   /   


  '   (XV.) #  /:
0.5.4,%.6.6.


      
     
       
    
    


      


 



 .  



 

   

      
     



     

       
      
  
       


 

      
       
      
/    , 
, /       
   #     
      




   

      
     


'  .6.



8  '  &
.   *. .



* -*
  *.%.
,,



 

   



     
    
"    
    

     
    
5D       
5E
        
 


     
  



       

     
   


{       
  


   

    
   
   
         
     
   



 

   








      

     



#   (.0., 8  6.#., 5  .\. 

      '" x.\.,
8  6.#., \ 2.6. 
      
      
 
  ,      
> @     
8  6.#., 5.6.
,

8  6.#., 5.6.



&  6.#. 
 

5  '..



6/ +.4.
 5.6. 
5   6.#.

\ 
#.6.





 

   






    

       
        
     

        
5E

     
5



       
      



    


,

   ,,   
& / *.\.        
# 6.8.   
,,,
  

& / *.\.

8  8.&.      ,,  






 

   

&
    

      ,, 
,,
      




     
    
      
  
      
      
   
 

    
     
    




     



w  #.6.



 



6/ +.4.


8  6.#.       
   
&   6..




 

   

      




      


 
5E
5D


       


       
    
        
   
      
    

9,,,9,,,

    
      

     
        


     




6/ +.4.
# 6.8., *  ..   




 

   

        





      



       
       
    
 %RQDQ 'RQJ[LDQJ  6DOD    
   +XL   
    5D0





    

 





      




6/ +.4.



 

   

     
       

     
     
>@



     
 

     
   

    

,,




   
           


      
,,,
     
      
 
         
      



  9,,,


' 5.6.




 

   




     

    

    
      
     

     




 
    
        
     
          
     
     
;,,,
  
     
     

       
       
        
      




' #.#.





 

   


       




      


   

       
     





      

       


     
    
     







 

         
  0RUL 0DVDR .DQ GR 5PD 7KH +DQ '\QDVW\ DQG WKH
5RPDQ(PSLUH 7RN\R3



 

   

       

   
      
     
        
     
      

      


     

     



      

    

      
 



9,9,,


      
     
        


* -*
  *.%.
,,

Hall D.G.E.$KLVWRU\RI6RXWK(DVW$VLD/S
*  2..



 

   

    

       
  9,,9,, 
      
     1   
 
 
     




          
      
   

     
 


\< 5 

       
;;9
     
       
          


  
 6.6.|


Krause W. =XU )UDJH QDFK GHQ QLFKWLQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ 6XEVWUDW
GHV 7RFKDULVFKHQ =HLWVFKULIW IU YHUJOHLFKHQGH 6SUDFKIRUVFKXQJ
DXIGHP*HELHWHGHULQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQ*|WWLQJHQ
%6Lane G.S.7RFKDULDQ,QGR(XURSHDQDQGQRQ
,QGR(XURSHDQ UHODWLRQVKLS  &DUGRQD * +RHQLJVZDOG + 0 DQG
6HQQ$ HG ,QGR(XURSHDQDQG,QGR(XURSHDQV3KLODGHOSKLD
3HQQV\OYDQLD8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

  6.6.
    ,,     
  * 6.    
      8/ 6. 





 

   


    
     

      



    
     
     

    

>@
>@
>@

       


    
    
      


      
       



    ;9,,;9,            <   




' 2.5.675$780
SOXV&

5   .  9,,,





 

   


    ,,  
    


     
     
      
  
,,
    

     

>@

     

        
        




    



       
      


( " #.(.
      


5  &.*.


 .


5   .



 

   

      
      

     
      
    
      
 


  
    
     /-    
/-    /-  /  /-  $
/-    /-    
  >@ /   
      // /-  
        

     
  /    
      


  
>@
 >@    

>@
$
/ 

&  #.6.
1 
.



5  &.*.





 

   

>
@


     



        


      
     


     
      

      
        

  


9


    
      
         
     
       
VLDQRL 
 






 

   


       
 >6WUDE ;, 9,,, @    >7URJ
3URO ;/, ;/,,@    

 


     

  
    
     
        
       
    
    ,9   
       
    >@ 
        
  >@   > @ 
  >@   
  >@     
 >@     
>@  >  @ 
       
  
>@

 

>@>@
 
    


*  0.#."1
.


'  .6. 



 

   


    




      


 
 
     

  

      
  


  



    ,  
       
     
 

      
    
#" '.#., '" *.#. 


      




Pulleyblank E.G. &KLQHVH DQG ,QGR(XURSHDQV -RXUQDO RI 5R\DO
$QWKURSRORJLFDO6RFLHW\SW




 

   

     
      
       
      
      
,



     
    
    
       
  




      
      
      

       

   

  >@      
     >@    >
   @    
     


'  .6.
       
  

  

 


'  .6.






 

   




   
     
    
     
     






9,9

      
    

   

       
>@
       



      
    

    




)  x.#.


,,9






 

   


   
     



   



     
 >  @    
       
>@       
         


  99,    

  

        



#" '.#., '" *.#.




>@

  


        
 
 
  


  
          

  

'  .6.





 

   

       
    
"  - 



    
 


    /   

//
 /  
 $   
/   // 
     
       
$   / /   
 

    
       
      
    
      
    


#" '.#., '" *.#.




4 .{. [ <].


'  .6.

{      






 

   


    

    
     
   /       
     ,,,     

    


   
 
 
 
        




    
      
     
 
    
( 5.%.      
  1
.   
      1
.  





4 .{. [ <].

(         






4 .{. [ <].




 

   


,


    

       
      
      

     

     
      
      
 


 
 
        

     
     
    



    

,
,99

  

>@

'  .6.

4 .{. [ <].




 

   

 

"$      
9,
99,
    
        
    






       
9,
       

    



     
     
       
5   *.8.     


| x.5.     
      
1
.



 . 
  


  

4 .{. [ <].

| x.5.     
 




 

   



     









      



>@>@


        




       
       
       


          
    




4 6.6.
          ,9 




 

   

                  


        
        

     

   




     
      


 
   
      
     

 " 
    


   
       

(" &.%. 
 
9,,; 

 
9,,; 

"-- .







 

   


       
      

     
   
     
     
     



   
    ,   
    

      
      

      


    
  
     










| x.5.     
 

4 .{. [ <].

&< *.







 

   

 " 


  


    
     




>@

       

     
       
        



     
      
      
        
   ,99   
     
;,9   
     

        
 
 $   



4 .{. [ <].


'  .6.



 

   




    
       
     




     

    
     
      
     

     

   
    
      

     
        



      
     
    


*   6.6.


,

#  8.8.      
9,,9,,,

4 .{. [ <].



 

   







    
    





     



    



   
     
       
     
      
      
     

     





'  .6.
% 2.#.    
 5  &.*.




 

   


>@
       
     
     
      
    
      

>@
 
 >@
       
>@

     
     
     
     
      

     

     
    

       
    
      

      




4 .{. [ <].




'  .6.






 

   

    
     






;9,, 

      
      
        
 
'.8 



      
     
    


 
     
      

      


* -*
  *.%.

;;;,9






 
9,,,




 

   

     
      
 
      
    
      

     


  -
 
 ,,,


 ,9       
        
  -   
      
       
      
      


-   
$


'  ..9,
5 #.(.







 

4 .{. [ <].




 

   

$      


    
      


WLQJOLQJ 
   ,   
     
       
,

      

 $ (   .)
 ",  ,  ,  ,  $, , ,  ,  ,  , , , , -, 


    

 
>@



           
>@
>
@
 


8 2.8.     


0 B.C.      


  

4 .{. [ <].





 

   


      

>@

        

    >@    
         


   
     
     


    ,  
        

$     .     
     


      
    

     
      

     

      



'  .6.
4 .{. [ <].








 

   


      


    

    
    
     

    



     

      
       
    





   
    
       
*  2..    


5  &.*.



# 6.8., *  ..   


     
 
 
       





 

   


    






   
     
       
     

     






     


       

        










& / *.\.




 

   

  
     
>@
    
       


   $    
    
 $  ",
 ,  ,  ,  $, , ,  ,
 ,  , , , , -, 
       
  


 -$- 


     


-$
-$

 

-$


4 .{. [ <].




        

  

4 .{. [ <].

0  &..





 

   

    

      
     
9,,,




   
     
     
   
     


      


   
    


    
       

   >@  
      





4 .{. [ <].


* -*
  *.%. 
8  &.(. 
 ,,,

* -*
  *.%.


4 .{. [ <].




 

   

  ().* '.


IXXIII .

  






;,,,

      
     



  6. .



 

   



    
     
      
        

        
       
      
     




     

     


     





  
    





4 .{. [ <].


5  &.*.

* #.#.

 




 

   

    
    
    

9,,,


         
       >
@



;,
       


  




     
        
      
     
      
      
     

      
   
 



4 .{. [ <].








 

   



 
 
;9;9,,,
     
    


  
      
     
     
   
      


 


     





       





*  2..
( #.*.
,;
1
.,;;,,


*HQHWLFSRO\PRUSKLVPRI<FKURPRVRPDO675VLQ.D]DNKDQG
8LJKXU SRSXODWLRQV IURP ;LQMLDQJ  6KDQ : >HW DO@ &KLQD ,QW -
/HJDO0HG-DQXDU\




 

   

& 17-     (121 )   (217 ) 5 / .5 "
  95 ,      
 R1a (   5400-7900  ).5
 5     O3a2c1-M134 
55 ,    
  680220 
.5  7     53,
    1200  .   8  
  
  53,      11  .1       N, J2, G,R1b.1   "  


5D 
 
  
5E

 
2DF0  



 

   



          
        

  
   5D  
5E


5D
5D



       
        

      
      

5D
   5D    
 
5D  



       
 

   
5D




 

   

5D



    
 5D      
  5D   

       
"
   
    5D  

     
     5D

     

   5D    

      
0/
=====0
       
=

     
     
     
5D
      
)7'1$


 
      
 5D       



 

   

5D/

5D       
* *D/   
1
    1F     
 -         5E 
     
    5E0
  5E0
     

 5E      

4  ,-  5  / 
'    

5D
      
  &     
5D 

5D
5D
5D


 
       
      
      >@ 
    
>@>@
>@


'  .6.



 

   

   

         
 8     
> @      >@
>@
>@
     
     






     

      
  
   
       
 ,; 
        




   > @    
       
    
    >@  
>@
>@










 

   



   
       

        


       

>@


      
    
    


     
9;,,,
     
    
    
    



 " #.(.    
     
     " #.(.   
      
     
      
 " #.(.    

;,,
    
" #.(.
    







 

   


    


   
     
   
  >@    
>
@ 
 


()
     
   $   /$     

  
      

       
       
   
      

       "  

" #.(.     

  



4 .{. [ <].

'"  5.*.
 





 

   



#"      
     

$


      
      
      

        
    


     


     
     DVDQD 


    
     

0$

99,



     


4 .{. [ <].


'"  5.*.

4 . {. [ <].

' 5.6.




 

   


WUN
0$
 
 
   /$ 
       
      
9,,9,,,


     
    

      
"  
      
      

      
      

     
       


   
     
   
     

   
  ' 5.6.     


'"  5.*.

5/ 

 




 

   

 

    
      
 
       
  ,,,       

       
     
      



     

       
        


      
    
    



    
 " 
    
#" 


       
    



'"  5.*.
5  &.*.




 

   

    

      
     
     
    

      
    



    
     
     
    
      


    



       
       

     

       
      

       
       







 

   

     
       

        



      
   


      

 

 
      
   
     
       
    
    






     
     







4 . {. [ <].


5  &.*.




 

   


     
       

     


      
      


      



      

      

        





 
         


    
     
 ( & 
     












 

   

  9,            
      
       









     
    

    




       

   


        



     
 


8 '.>@
,&;9,,


4 . {. [ <].







 

   


     
    
     

      
>@     
      
     
     

      
    
     

    

    
     

      
     

       
"
     
     

 
 
   




 
        
     


8 . 2.. *   



 

   


      


    





   
      
     

    
     
      
        
      

       
      
      
"      
       

       
        
      
"


     


*  2..   ZZZ 


4 . {. [ <].

;;,;8  5.#.





 

   







        
    
     


     





()
 0     
      
torutha-gar
    
       
    ;,,,   

  -  




'   4  .    


*  2..85/
KWWSJXPLOHYLFDNXOLFKNLQHW

* 8 .      






 

   

  $      
       
        
      
  '.8.    

      $
     $
  

      
 $
    - 
      
 
       
      


     

 ,     

    
     
     
   
    
        
    


($ - $-


* 8 

 x.


* \.

\< 5 .,9

  6.6.


Pulleyblank E.G. &KLQHVH DQG ,QGR(XURSHDQV -RXUQDO RI WKH
5R\DO$VLDWLF6RFLHW\3



 

   

        
    


    
 ,,,     
$

       
        
     
      
     $
 
   9   

    $
  
 ,,       
      

 
 




,,,


     




     


) x.#.




 

   



-$
 " $
 



    
         
     
'.8. 
     '.8.  
    
          

'.8. 

 '.8. 

       




    
 



     



         


'"  5.*.


4 . {. [ <].



 

   

      



     


     

  
     
     
         
  

  



    
    -              <-<         

     
      





  6.6.
    ,,    
  * 6.    
8/ 6.


Pokorny J. 'LH 6WHOOXQJ GHV 7RFKDULVFKHQ LP .UHLVH GHU
LQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQ%HULFKWHGHV)RUVFKXQJVLQVWLWXWVIU
2VWXQG2ULHQWLQ:LHQ%,,,

* 6.






 

   

   < - 



 / 




    
       
    




      




      
    
     
    
        
     


Krause W.=XU)UDJHQDFKGHQQLFKWLQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6XEVWUDWGHV
7RFKDULVFKHQ =HLWVFKULIW IU YHUJOHLFKHQGH 6SUDFKIRUVFKXQJ DXI
GHP*HELHWHGHULQGRJHUPDQLVFKHQ6SUDFKHQ *|WWLQJHQ %
   /DQH *6 7RFKDULDQ ,QGR(XURSHDQ DQG QRQ
,QGR(XURSHDQUHODWLRQVKLS&DUGRQD*+RHQLJVZDOG+0DQG
6HQQ $ HG  ,QGR(XURSHDQ DQG ,QGR(XURSHDQV 3KLODGHOSKLD 
3HQQV\OYDQLD8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

4   +.


' 2.5.
     




 

   

      
     
   

 

      
5E
5D



 

  
      
 

99,,,,;;
     
 

      
      
      
   
    
    
  miet     mit  miat
kuankiwen
kukwemchu
suwoswanana
5   6.#.     



*  0.6.,   6.6





 

   

   
    
        
 
  
  



VLUVLUNHN 
     
       



 6HUHV       
     
VHULFL

     
     

        



      
 5D        
       
      
 



' 2.5.675$780
SOXV

8  '  &
. .  *. .




 

   



   
      

      

     

     
      
       

>@
>@


        

     
       


      

     


().
    
     
     
 
 

4 . {. [ <].








 

   

      
      5"$   
     
       
       
     
         
        
 / 
 ($ 
 
$  
  
 

$ 
      


 
$ 
 
    

 

  

$   

$  

&

$
  '.8 
-
     
     
 -

 $
      


-
     /     
       
>@
>@

  

"-- .        





 

   

/ # 


5" 

       

      


    
  
 
        

        
     

 "'.8 
 
'.8 

     
      

9,9        
  





  





        
 
 

       
  

6  (.6.






 

   

      



      

>@


    



     
    
    
        


    
      
   ;9,,,   


 
   

% 2 -.

( 6.%       
    
 ( 6.%
      
  
  ( 6.%  
  w  +.6., 8  *.   
( #.*


6  (.6





 

   



    
        
       
     
      
      


'.8 
        
       
        




      

     

  


    
 

         
        
         
* -*
  *.%





  



Grube W.'LH6SUDFKHXQG6FKULIWGHU-XFKHQ/HLS]LJ




 

   

    (11151234).


       
      

     
     




 

   


     
     
   
    
    



      
   
     


     
         


      
        





      


      


      


4  #.#.
       
 
 

2 6.%.




 

   



     


     
    




      





     
     


    
       

      





       







% 2 -.




 

   

   



 


     
       



 
   
    

     
      
       
"
        

     " 




      
"

       

       
"


2 *.*.





 

   

       
     
     
     
    




       
      


      

;,
>
@         >
 @   


     
      
       
      



      




   '   %..   ;,  
 



% 2 -





 

   

   
   

       
      

    











    

         
     
    






8 0.#.      




 

   

       

     

"

"
     
"

  

      


      
    
      



      
       

         
    


      




 

   





       
      


"


      
     
       
<
 
        

     
   <  
     






     
        
       

      
      
    
       
    5D   



 

   

       

     

      






    

     

5D

    
     
        
     
     

5D



      
      
      
      
       

     




 

   




    
        




 

   

 

 

 

 

 


 

 
 
 


















12+ 






  
ZZZNPERRNUX