8

se

He,Qenl-1

cpespan~. KOTOpble MAC

rH6 e>KerO,QHO npOBO,Ql-1T ,QJl~ npose,Qe-

HOCTI-1 CBOero Bbi60pa , npo~BJl~IOT He M9Hb W

l-1HTepec K C06b1Tl-1~M .

Hl-1~ CBOI-1X Meponpl-1~Tl-1~ B CaHaTOpl-11-1

Haw >KypHan HeO.QHOKpaTHO OTMeYan ,

BaCl-11lb9BCKl-1~ , no npasy ~Bll~IOTC~

s nocne.QHI-1e ro.Qbl, nposo.Ql-1Mbl~ s BaCl-11lbE-

6ecnp9l.\9.Q9HTHbiM ,QJl~ OT9Y9CTB9HHOrO npo-

so

cpeCCl-10HaJlbHOrO C006ll.\9CTBa B nnaHe l-1Hcp0p-

san s ropa3.QO 6onbWYIO opraHl-13al.ll-10H

Mal.\l-10HHO~ HaCblll.\9HHOCTl-1 l-1 , COOTB9TCTB9HHO ,

cy6cTaHl.\l-110 s nnaHe cpopMbl 1-1 co.~:~ep>K aH

C9Ml-1Hap onepaTOpOB

3B01ll0l.\l-10H l-1

BHl-1MaHl-1~ co cTopoHbl cnel.ll-1aJll-1CTOB . KcTaTl-1 ,

np1-1pacTa~ . Hanpl-1Mep , Kny6oM KpyTble

npe,QCTaBl-1T91l~Ml-1 KOMnaHl-11.1, paCCMaTpl-1BaiO-

pl-11lbl , CeMl-1HapOM no nOBbiW9Hl-110 KB aJ'I

ll.\l-1X ,QaHHYIO TeXHOJlOrl-110 KaK 6y.QYll.\YIO csoero

cpl-1Kal.\l-1l-1, MHOrOYl-1CJleHHbiMl-1 COBell.\aH l-1~

6l-13Heca 1-1 >KenaiOll.\l-19 yKpenl-1TbC~ s npaBl-11lb-

no sonpocaM pa3pa6oTKl-1 HOpMaTl-1BHO-Tex

6_

~eCKOill ,QOKyMeHTaU,ItH1 V1 U,eH006pa30BaHV1fl B

no.QoTpacn 11.
Ha~aBWVIiiiCfl

2015

r . cTan xopowVIM no.Q-

TBep:>K.QeHV!eM OTMe~eHHOill TeH,QeHU,V1V1 . npV1 ~eM , B OCHOBe nO,Q06HOrO pO,Qa BbiBO,QOB ne:>KaT

He TOnbKO

nVI~Hble Bne~ameHV!fl ,

HO V1 MHeHVIfl

y~aCTHVIKOB MeponpV1flTV111i , He3aBV1CV1MbiX 3KC-

nepTOB V1 opraHV13aTOpOB .

YYE5HbiE CEMV1HAPbl:
>KEnAfOl_WV1X MEHbWE
HE CTAnO!
KaK

HeO.QHOKpaTHO

OTMe~anocb

y~e6Hble cpespanbCKVIe ceMV1Hapb1

paHee,

MAC

rH6

OTnVI~aiOTCfl TOnbKO Ka~eCTBOM npe,QnaraeMOIIi

nporpaMMbl ,

KBanV1cpV1Kau,V1elli

npeno.QaBaTe-

nelll , 6ecnpV1CTpaCTHOCTbiO 3K3aMeHaU,V10HHbiX

ou,eHoK. 0HV1 flBnfliOTCfl no aHanor1111 c 6V1p:>KeBbiMV1 cpbiO~epcaMVI csoero po.Qa V1H.QV1KaTopaMV1 aKTV1BHOCTV1 pOCCV111iCKV1X npocpV1nbHbiX KOMnaHV!i/1 B ce3oHe HacTynaiOLl.lero ro,Qa.
Ba:>KHOCTb ,QaHHoro noKa3aTenfl MHoroKpaTHO B03paCTaeT BO BpeMfl cepbe3HbiX 3KOHOMV1 ~eCKV1X

Cna,QOB , KOTOpble, K CO:>KaneHVIIO, npOVIC-

TaK B

2009

r. KOnVI~ecTBO y~aCTHVIKOB ce -

MV!Hapos no cpasHeHVIIO c npe.Qbi.QYLl.lVIM ro,QOM

XO,QflT B nocne.QHV1e ,QeCflTV1neTV1fl c perynflpHolli

npaKTV1~eCKV1 He V13MeHV1nOCb, a B

nepV10,QV1~HOCTbiO .

3acpV1KCV1pOBaH He60nbWOII\ pOCT, ~TO n03BO -

Pe% VI.QeT o npecnosyTOII! U,V1cppe -

2015

r . 6bln

KOnVI -

nfleT Bblpa3V1Tb OCTOpO:>KHbllli OnTV1MV13M OTHO -

~ecTBe npe,QnpV1flTV111\, ,QenerV1pOBaBWV1X CBOVIX

CVITenbHO nepcneKTVIB nO,QOTpacnVI . XOTfl Ha,QO

npe.QcTaBVITenelll B BacVInbeBCKVIill .

nOHVIMaTb,

no~eMy 3TO Ba:>KHO 3HaTb , HeCMOTpfl Ha TO ,

~TO ,QaneKO V1.QYLl.lV1X BbiBO,QOB ,QaHHbllli noKa3a-

CTBO

noKa3aTenb

KOMnaHV111\,

oTpa:>~<aeT

HaMepeHH~X

KOnVI~e

npO,QOn:>KaTb

(11n11 Ha~aTb BHOBb) 3KCnnyaTV1pOBaTb TeXHVI KY V1 TeXHOnOrVIIO rH6 , HaMepeHHbiX yKpe nVITb Ka,Qpbl .

3,QeCb

KniO~eBbiM

CnOBOM

cne-

KaK o6bf!CHV1nV1 Hawelll pe.QaKU,V1V1 B ,D,V!peK41111 no npose,QeHVIIO y~e6HbiX ceMV!Hapos

Tenb He no3BOnfleT C.QenaTb?

,[J,aHHbllli

~TO

,QyeT C~V!TaTb OCTOpO:>KHbllli .

MAC

rH6, nO,Q06HOrO po,Qa aKTVIBHOCTb pOCCV1iiiCKV1X

KOMnaHV!II\ MO:>KeT 6b1Tb CBfl3aHa C BnV1flHV1eM
.QBYX OCHOBHbiX cpaKTOpOB :
Hapfl.QY c ce30HHbiM cna,QOM pa6o~elll aKTV1BHOCTV1 Kp113V1C , Bblpa3V1BWV1111Cfl B COKpall.leHV1V1

10

3aKa30B, o6yCflOBL-1fl n05lBf19HL-19 CB060AHOro

speMeHL-1 >> B pe)KL-1Me npOL-13BOACTBeHHO~ A95lrenbHOCTL-1 KOMnaHL-1~ . 3Ta B03MO)KHOCTb L-1CnOflb3Y9TC5l Af15l yKpenneHL-15l npocpeCCL-10HaJlbHOf O
ypoBH5l KonneKTL-1BOB, B TOM '-IL-1Cfle nocpeACTBOM
6ypeHL-15l L-1 nOBbiW9HL-15l KBaJlL-1cpL-1Kal..IL-1L-1 .
HeL-1369)f(Hbl~ pOCT KOHKypeHl..IL-11-1 B ycnOBL-15lX CnaAa 3KOHOML-1KL-1 norpe6yeT CHL-1)K9HL-15l L-13A9P)K9K L-1 , COOTB9TCTB9HHO, pOCTa 3cpcpeKTL-1BHOCTL-1 pa60Tbl npocpL-1flbHbiX npeAnpL-15lTL-1~ (06
3TOM C9fOAH5l He fOBOpL-1T TOflbKO f19HL-1Bbl~).
B 3TOM cnyLtae ponb KBanL-1cpL-1Kal..IL-1L-1 pa6oLtero nepcoHana 1-1 VITP Bblpacraer MHoroKparHo!
no)Kany~ . s 3TOM nnaHe nyLtwee peweHL-1e
pyKoBOAL-1Tef15l KOMnaHL-11-1 - Aener1-1posaH1-1e
CBOL-1X npeACTaBL-1T9f19~ B 8aCL-1flb9BCKL-1~ >> !

CTAH.QAPT,, >K,QET BTOPA5l

PE.QAKL(V15l
6eccnopHo, OAHL-1M L-13 Ha1-16onee aKryanbHbiX C06biTL-1~ B LtepeAe cpeBpaJlbCKL-1X MeponpL-15lTL-1~ MAC rH6 crano cosell.laHL-1e no sonpocaM
AaflbHe~wero pa3BL-1TL-15l HOpMaTL-1BHo-rexHL-1 LtecKo~ AOKyMeHTal..IL-11-1 - AKryanL-13al..IL-15l CTO
HOCTPOL/12. 27. 17-2011 ''
B pa6ore coBell.laHL-15! npL-1H5lflL-1 yLtacr~-1e : AnnaTOs C.H. (P06T, CPO Hn OnC >> ), 6pe~A6ypA A.Vl ., KasepL-1H C.E. , MaTBL-1eHKO P.H.
(MAC rH6) , M1-1pxanees A.A. (rK <<IOHVIPYC ),
Canaxos P.P. (<l>L-1f1L-1an rH6 CPO Hn ,,onc ,, ),
WeKyAOB E.B. (<l>L-1f1L-1afl OAO l...IHV1V1C << HVll...l
,, ToHHenL-1 1-1 MerpononL-1TeHbl >> ), a raK)Ke p5lA
Cn9l..IL-1aJlL-1CTOB C 60flbWL-1M npaKTL-1'-19CKL-1M OnbiTOM 3KCnnyaTal..IL-1L-1 T9XHL-1KL-1 L-1 T9XHOf10fL-1L-1 rH6
B 6ecrpaHW9~HOM CTpOL-1T9flbCTB9 nOA39MHbiX
KOMMYHL-1Kal..IL-1~ pa3flL-1'-IHOro Ha3HaLteHL-15l.
B AeKa6pe 201 0 r. peweHL-1eM cosera Hal..IL-10HaJlbHoro 06b9AL-1H9HL-15l CTpO L-1T9f19~ (npo-

TOKOfl NQ22 or 05.12.2011 r .) no cornacosaH L-110

c annaparoM Hal..IL-10HaflbHoro o6b9AL-1H9H L-1s:
npoeKTL-1pOBLl.IL-1KOB (nL-1CbMO 1-1cx. N2 10n1211 o.,.
07.11 .2011 r .) snepBble yrsep)KA9H 1-1 BBeAeH e
A9~CTBL-1e CTO HOCTPOL/1 2.27.17-2011 << OcsoeHL-1e noA3eMHoro npocrpaHcrsa. npoKnaAKa
nOA39MHbiX L-1H)KeHepHbiX KOMMYHL-1Kal..IL-1~ MeTOAOM ropL-130HTaJlbHOfO HanpaBf19HHOrO 6ypeHL-15l >> .
3a 6onee LteM 3-L-1 roAa , npoweAWL-1X c 3Toro speMeHL-1 , CTaHAapr 6blfl npL-1H5lT B KaLtecre.e
o65l3aTeflbHoro AOKyMeHTa Af15l npL-1MeHeH
npaKTL-1'-teCKL-1 sceML-1 B9AYLl.IL-1ML-1 CPO PoccL-1i4cKo~ <l>eAepal..IL-11-1. 0H CTaJl HaCTOflbHO~ KHL-1 f03aKa3'-tL-1KOB, npoeKTL-1p0Bll.IL-1KOB L-1 nOAP5lA'-tL-1KOE
rH6 , Ha ero OCHOBe pa3pa6oTaHbl L-1 ycnew
3KCnnyaTL-1pyiOTC5l Ha npaKTL-1K9 yLte6Hbl9 np<r
rpaMMbl no noArOTOBKe oneparopos KOMnne COB rH6 L-1 nOBbiW9HL-15l KBaJlL-1cpL-1Kal..IL-1L-1 VIT?
npeAnpL-15lTL-1~ , ocyll.leCTBf15liOLl.IL-1X npoeKTL-1posaHL-1e L-1 6eCTpaHW9~H09 CTpOL-1T9flbCTBO nOA39
HbiX KOMMYHL-1Kal..IL-1~ pa3flL-1'-IHOrO Ha3Ha'-19HL-15l
T9XHOflOfL-1L-1 rH6.
0AHaKO, 3a 3TL-1 fOAbl npaKTL-1'-t9CKOrO np
MeHeHL-15l CraHAapra, onpeAeflL-1flL-1Cb HeKOT
pble acneKTbl , rpe6yi0Ll.IL-1e 6onee WL-1pOKO pacKpbiTL-15l P5lAa pa3Aenos AOKyMeHTa , AeTaflL-13al..IL-1L-1 H9KOT0pb1X ero nOf10)K9HL-1~ , KOppe TL-1pOBKL-1 npL-1f10)K9HL-1~ L-1 T.n.
B MAC rH6 nocrynaiOT KOHKp9THbl9 3anpoCbl OT npeAnpL-15lTL-1~ CTpOL-1T9flbHOrO KOMnfleKca
c npocb6aML-1 o AOpa6orKe AOKyMeHra 1-1 npru-;TL-1'-teCKL-1 aKTYaJlbHbl9 np9Af10)K9HL-15l 0 KOppe TL-1pOBKe rex L-1f1L-1 L-1HbiX ero nono)KeHL-1~ .
8 3TO~ CB5l3L-1 B paMKaX 5-ro 9)K9roAHO ~
C9ML-1Hapa nOBbiW9HL-15l KBaflL-1cpL-1Kal..ll-11-1 V1 ...
npeAnpl-15lTL-1~ ,
3KCnnyaTI-1PYIOLl.IL-1X
TeXHI-1
rH6 . 2 cpespan5l 2015 r . s ropoAe Ka3aHb

~~

cTof!nocb nepsoe pa6oYee coBell.laHltle asTOpcKoro KonneKTlt1Ba 1-oro ocplt1l.\lt1anbHOro lt13.QaHlt1fl CTO HOCTPOII12.27.17-2011 c nosecTKO~
.QHfl : AKTyanlt13al.\lt1fl ocplt1l.\lt1anbHOro lt13.QaHlt1fl
CTO HOCTPOIII 2.27.17-2011 c yYeTOM 3aMeYaHlt1~ lt1 npe,QnO>KeHltl~ cne4lt1anlt1CTOB rH6 ,
nocTynlt1BWlt1X s npo4ecce ero npaKTlt1YecKoro
nplt1MeHeHlt1fl .
no ltlTOraM COBell.laHltlfl 6binO nplt1Hf!TO peweHltle 0 He06XO,Qlt1MOCTlt1 BHeCeHltlfl B ,QOKyMeHT 4enoro pfl.Qa yToYHeHltl~ TeXHlt1YecKoro
111 opraHlt13al.\lt10HHoro xapaKTepa. CTaH.QapT>>
>KAeT BTOpafl pe,QaKL\ltlfl.
Hosbl~ .QOKyMeHT AOn>KeH 6b1Tb nonHOCTbiO
rOTOB K 01 .09.2015 r .!
KaK B cnyYae c (( nepso~ pe,QaKL\ltle~
CTaH,QapTa , pa6oTa Ha,Q ero COBepweHCTBOsaHltleM npo~,QeT MaKClt1ManbHO OTKpbiTO C ,QeTanbHbiM o6cy>K.QeHlt1eM scex npltlnaraeMbiX
nono>KeHltl~ .

no npOCb6e pa3pa60TYlt1KOB HOBOrO ,QOKyMeHTa (coCTas pa6oye~ rpynnbl npaKTlt1YeCKlt1

He lt13MeHlt1ncfl) Mbl nplt13blsaeM scex 3alt1HTepecosaHHbiX cnel.llt1anlt1CTOB no,QOTpacnltl Hanpaslt1Tb CBOltl npe,Qno>KeHltlfl 111 3aMeYaHlt1fl B
a,Qpec MAC rH6 . no,Qp06HOCTlt1 Ha ca~Te www.
masgnb.ru
V1 ell.le O,QHa HOBOCTb, KaCaiOLl.laf!Cfl BOnpoca pa3pa60TKlt1 HOpMaTlt1BHO -TeXHlt1YeCKO~ ,[10KyMeHTal.\ltlltl.
B nnaH pa60Tbl TK-465 Ha 2015-2016 rr .
nonan CBO,Q npasltln en nO,Q3eMHble ltlH )I(eHepHble KOMMYHlt1Kal.\lt1lt1 . npoKna,QKa ro plt130HTanbHbiM HanpasneHHbiM 6ypeHlt1eM
HaYlt1HaeTcfl aKTltlBHaf! pa6oTa no cosepweHcTsosaHlt110 ,QaHHoro .QOKyMeHTa. 0Ha TaK>Ke
npO~,QeT B MaKClt1ManbHO OTKpbiTOM pe>Klt1Me .
Bee >KenaiOLl.lltle MoryT BbiCKa3aTb cso111 npe.Q-

no>KeHltlfl , HanpaBltlB lt1X B a,Qpec MAC rH6

(www.masgnb .ru) .

nEPBbit/1 OTPACnEBOt/1!
Hltl B KOeM cnyyae He XOTenOCb 6bl 06lt1,QeTb
opraHlt13aTopos ,QsyxHe,QenbH.o ro cnel.\lt1anlt13lt1posaHHoro Mapacj:>oHa B BacltlnbescKOM, 1t1n1t1
nonbiTaTbCfl Bbi.QaTb MHeHltle pe,QaKL\lt1lt1 >KypHana
3a 06beKTlt1BHYIO Ol.\eHKY npowe,QWltlX C06b1Tlt1~.
Ho caMbiM 3anOMlt1HaiOLl.llt1MCfl co6biTlt1eM
3Tlt1X .QHe~ cTano npose,QeHltle nepsoro B pocCltl~CKO~ lt1CTOplt1lt1 rH6 OTpacnesoro ceMlt1Hapa,
lt1Mei0Ll.lero ocplt1l.\lt1anbHOe Ha3saHlt1e BcepocClt1~CKlt1~ ceMlt1Hap " TexHonorltlf! roplt130HTanbHoro HanpasneHHoro 6ypeHlt1fl KaK ltlHCTpyMeHT
nplt1sneYeHlt1fl ,QononHlt1TenbHbiX .QOXO.QOB .Qnfl
npe,Qnplt1f1Tlt1~ BKX .
6e3yCnOBHO, ltlHTepec K yYaCTlt110 B ,QaHHOM
Meponplt1f!Tlt1lt1 B 3HaYlt1TenbHO~ CTeneHltl nOAOrpesanCf! aBTOplt1TeToM opraHlt13aTOpos - Me>K.QyHapo.QHO~ ACCOL\lt1al.\lt1e~ roplt130HTanbHOro
HanpasneHHoro 6ypeHlt1fl (MAC rH6) 1t1 POCCV1li!CKOIII AcCOL\lt1al.\lt1e~ BO.QOCHa6>KeHlt1fl 111
BO,QOOTBeAeHltlfl (PABB).

BMECTO nPEJ:lV1CnOBV171
Ocplt1l.\lt1anbHoe Ha3saHlt1e ceMlt1Hapa no3BOnfleT C,QenaTb BbiBO,Q 0 TOM , YTO peanlt13al.\lt1fl
pa6oye~ nporpaMMbl .QOn>KHa yKna,QbiBaTbCfl
B pycno MHOrOYlt1CneHHbiX apryMeHTOB , 060CHOBbiBaiOLl.lltlX 3cpcpeKTlt1BHOCTb BHeApeHltlfl
B npaKTltlKY CTpOlt1TenbCTBa TeXHOnOrlt1lt1 rH6 .
Ho noYeMy np111 3TOM Meponplt1f!Tlt1e nonyYltlno
100%-HyiO oTpacnesy10 HanpasneHHOCTb?
06 3TOM Mbl nonpoclt1nlt1 paccKa3aTb npe3lt1.QeHTa MAC rH6 A.V1 . 6pe~,Q6yp,Qa .
B HaCTOflll.lee BpeMfl Ha pOCCltl~CKOM pbiHKe rH6 OTYeTnltlBO npocne>Klt1BaeTCfl TeH,QeHL\ltlfl

12

- - -- -

cTpyKTypHoro nepepacnpe.QeneH~t~H KOMnaH~t~~

H5lnC51 TeXHitiKO~, a

y'iaCTHitll..l 8 nOnb3Y OTpacne8biX npe,Qnp1t151Tit1~,

KaK nplt1H51TO r080plt1Tb , no Mepe 803MO)t(Ho-

3KCnnyaT1t1PYIOLl.llt1X TeXHitiKY lt1 TeXHOnOrltiiO

rH6.

TeXHOnOrlt151 8He,Qp51nac

CTe~ .

Aa8a~Te 8epHeMC51 np~t~MepHo Ha nHTHa.Q-

Cero.QHH Henb351 cKa3aTb, 'iTO 3TOT n po-

I..IaTb neT Ha3a.Q. BHe.QpeH~t~e TexHonor~t~ltl Ha'i~t~

l..lecc nonHOCTbiO

Hanocb c nocTeneHHoro cpopM~t~po8aHit151 pbiHKa

3aMe,QfleHitle Hanltii..IO. V1 3TO He C8513aHO C 8 0 3-

3HTY31t1aCT08, niO,Qe~ 8 He3Ha'ilt1TenbHO~ CTe-

,Qe~CT81t1eM 8HeWHit1X cpaKTOp08 : 8 'iaCTHOC

neHitl C8513aHHbiX lt!MeHHO C Tpy6onp080,QHbiM

8nlt151Hit151 3KOnOrltl'ieCKOrO Kp1t131t1Ca .

3a8epw~t~ncH,

HO ero pe3 KO

AaHHbl~ pe3ynbTaT MO)t(HO paccMaTp~t~8 a

CTp01t1TenbCT80M . nocTeneHHO pbiHOK 3anon-

t::

KaK ltiTOr HaCblll.leHit151 onpe,QeneHHO~ Hit!W ~

3a nocne,QHitle

15 neT.

Mbl He nep8bl~ ro.Q Ha6niO.QaeM 3a Te

KaK 8

nocne,QH~t~e

np~t~XO.Qit!T

ro.Qbl

l..lltlan~t~31t1po8aHHbl~

KOMnaHitl~:

8peMH c ne-

80,QOKaH aJlOE

8 o6nacTit1 npoKna.QKitl ltiH)t(eHepHbiX ceTe ~ . ra3opacnpe.Qen~t~TenbHbiX opraH~t~3al..llt1~ 8 cepe

ra3~t~cp~t~Kal..llt11t1 111 T ..Q.

KOHKypeHTHble npe1t1MYLl.leCT8a TaKitiX KO naHitl~ 3anO)t(eHbl 8 OCH08e lt!X npOit1380,QCT8et-o-

HO~ ,QeHTenbHOCTitl .

111x apceHane ~t~Me eT

KaK 6oraTbl~ OnbiT, TaK 1t1 60nbWOe KOnltl'ieCTB.:

K8anltlcp1t11..11t1p08aHHbiX cnel..lltlanlt1CT08 , MOLl.IHac:
TeXHitl'ieCKa51 6a3a. V1Hb1Mit1 Cn08aMit1 lt!Mee T
MHOrOe 1113 TOrO, 'iTO y KOMnaHit1~-3HTY31t1aC TOE
KaK npa81t1nO, HeT 8 Hanltl'iltlltl .
C
rltlltl

O,QHO~ CTOpOHbl , 8He,QpeHitle TeXHOn

rH6

8 TaKitiX ycn081t151X npoltiCXO,QitiT

a-

MHOro 6biCTpee lt1 C MeHbWit!Mitl conyTCT8Y

Ll.llt!Mitl lt13,Qep)t(KaMit1 . C ,Qpyro~, cp~t~HaHC0 8 b
noKa3aTen~t~ (8 nep8yl0 o'iepe.Qb , np~t~6b 1Jlt::
.QOCT~t~raiOTCH 6onee 3cpcpeKTit18HO 80 8Cex o~
HOWeH~t~Hx.

;.

F.

'

13

nO,QBOaV1M V1TOIV1
KaK npV1HfiTO eYV1TaTb, nyYWVIM noKa3aTeneM 6onbwei:1 V1Torosoi:1 OL\eHKV1 MeponpV1fiTV1i:1
nOA06HOrO ypOBHfl eny)t(VIT eyxaf! eTaTV1eTV1Ka . Ha oTpaenesoM eeMV1Hape PABB V1 MAC
rH6 npV1eyTeTBOBan 71 ene1...1V1anV1eT B o6naeTV1
BKX V13 49 poeeV1i:1eKV1X perVIOHOB. EenV1 Hano)t(V1Tb 3TV1 1...\Vlcppbl Ha 06l.LIYIO 3KOHOMV1YeeKyiO
eV1Tyai...\V110 B eTpaHe, TO BneYaTneHV!e OT npV1BeAeHHbiX noKa3aTenei:1 yeV1nV1saeTef! MHoroKpaTHO.
lt1eXOAfl V13 MHOrOYVleneHHbiX KOMMeHTapV1es s Kynyapax, V1 yYaeTHV1KV1, V1 opraHV13aTOpbl
AanV1 eaMyiO BbleOKYIO 01...\eHKY npoweAWeMy
OTpaeneBOMY eeMV!Hapy.
HasepHoe, rnaBHbiM V1ToroM eneAyeT eYV1TaTb
npV1HfiTOe PYKOBOAeTBOM MAC rH6 peweHV!e 0
TOM , YTO opraHV13ai...\V1fl nOA06HbiX OTpaeneBbiX
MeponpV1fiTV1i:1 nonyYVIT nOCTOfiHHYIO OeHOBy. nnaHV1pyeTefl, YTO OHV1 6YAYT npOBOAV1Tbef! e)t(erOAHO
npV1MeHV1TenbHO K pa3nV1YHbiM OTpaenf!M 3KOHOMV1KV1.
8 3aKniOYeHV1e, HeeKOnbKO enos 06 OAHOM
HIOaHee, OTMeYeHHbiM MHOrDYV1eneHHbiMV1 ene1...\VlanVleTaMVl, npeAeTaBnfiiOI..LIVIX eTOpOHY opraHV13aTOpOB. MHOrVle npeAeTaBV1TenV1 BOAOKaHanOB V13 pa3nV1YHbiX perVIOHOB He V1MenV1 nonHoro
npeAeTaBneHVlfl 0 TeXHV1Ke V1 TeXHOnOrV1V1 rH6,
He rosopfl o AeTanf!x. Bee 6blnV1 ysepeHbl B o6paTHOM.

MAC
(~
~

ft1D

1AC

~
~

rHo

0AHaKo, AaHHoe o6eTofi.TenbeTso MO)t(eT

eTaTb AOnOnHV1TenbHbiM V1MnynbeOM B nnaHe
AanbHei:1wei:1 3KenaHeV1V1 MeTOAa.