Page 1 of 16 JABALPUR, JABAL YU JA No. LL64,/2% x BENCH Original Application No.1164 of 2011 Jabalpur, this 7: HON’GLE SHRI suSTICE Dy HON'BLE SHRI G.P.SINGHAL, ADMINISTRA 1. Gaya Pr Aged about Residency, J. Roud, Bhopal 4¢ 2. Sajay Gandhi, S/o Shri M.C. R/o B-291 A. MIRENDRA MISHRA, J BAL. Patel Gandhi, Aged about 41 years, R/o Telephone Exchange Campus, Choda Choupati, Dhar (MP) 454001 3, Mukesh Kulshreshtha, S/o Shri Rajendra Prakash, aged about 40 years, Vaishnavi Eni 4. Nand La! Singh, S/o Shri 10 204, ©, Vigyan Nagar, Indore (MP) Singh, Aged about 41 years, R/o Plot No.1464, Vijay Nagar, Jabalpuc (MP} 4 5. Jitendra Kumar Verma, S/o L Aged about 41 years, Rio G70, Behind Jain Mandir, Gar 6. Ms, Shilcha Pandey, D/o Aged about 45 years, R/o 270 : Jabalpur 482004 (MP 7. DK. Pate e Glory, 8-8 E: mu, S/o Shri R. Aged about 43 years, Near Orion School, £ Bhopal 462039 (M.P.) 9. Man Mohan Vyas, 8/0 Aged about 42 years, R/o P-36, Phase I, BHEL, Bhopal 32002 Late B.P. Verma anjeevani Nagar, a, Jabalpur-482008 (MP} bri H.P.S. Chaudhury nand Nagar, Adharial, ; S/o Shri RL, Patel, aged about 40 years 8, Bhopal-462039 (Mi en 8. Sha: Extension, i RC. Vyas, Rishipuram, 462021 (MP) 10. Qutubuddin Tikiwala,-S/o Shri Saifuddin Tikiwala, aged about 42 years, R/o 52, Saifee Mohalla, K.D. Gate, Ujjain - 456 006 (MP) (By Advocate: Shri Vijay 1: ve he 114: day of December, 2012 UDICIAL MEMBER VE MEMBER puiicantsPawe Lot 16 O* No.1164/2011 CENTRAL ADMINI: RATIVE (RIBUNAL, JABALYUR BENCH JABALPUR Originat Application No.1164 of 2011 Jabalpur, this Tuesday, the 110 day of December, 2012 HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DHIRENDRA MISHRA, JUDICIAL MEMBER, HOW DLE SHId G.P.SINGHAL, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER 1. Gaya Pra tcl, S/o Shri B.L. Patel Lovilcants Aged about 44 years, R/o 8-251 A. Minal Residency, J.K. Koad, Bhopal 46:00) 2. Sajay Gandhi, S/o Shri M.C. Gandhi, Aged about 41 years, R/o Telephone Exchange Campus, Ghoda Choupati, Dhar (MP) 454601 2, Mukesh Kulshreshtha, 8/0 Shri Rajendra Prakash, aged about 40 years, R/o 204, Vaishnavi Enclave, Vigyan Nagar, Indore (MP) 452001 4. Nand La! Singh, $/o Shri B.N. Singh, Aged about 41 years, R/o Plot No.1464 Vijay Nagar, Jabalpur (MP} 4820¢ 5. Jitendra Kumar Verma, S/o Late B.P. Verma Aged about 41 years, Ro 670, Sanjeevani Nagar, Behind Jain Mandir, Garha, Jabalpur-422008 (MP) & Ms. Shilha Pandey, D/o Shri H.P.8. Chau¢hury Aged about 45 years, R/o 270 Anand Nagar, Adharial, Jabalpur 482004 (MPj 7. D.K. Patel, $/o Shri RL. Patel, aged about 40 year: R/oY-7, Fortune Glory, E-8 Extension, Bhopal-dG 8. Mukesh Sharma, 8/o Shri R.S. Sharma, Aged about 43 y Near Orion School, Bawadiakala, Guimos Bhopal 162039 (M.P,) 9. Man Mohan Vyas, S/o Shri R.C. Vyas, Aged about 42 years, K/o P-36, Rishipuram, Phase 1, BHEL, Bhopat ~ 462021 (MP) 10. Qutubuddin Tikiwala, $/o Shri Saifuddin Fikiwala, aged about 42 years, R/o 52, Saifee Mohalla, K.D. Gate, Ujjain - 456 006 (MP) (By Advocate: Shri Vijay24 No.1 64/2012 VY JABALPUR Originaé Application No. 1164 of 2011 Yabalpur, this Thesday, the 116 day af Decent HON ULP SHRI JUSTICE DuMREND IA MISHRA, SUD CAL MEMBER HOWBLD SHIRE G.P.SINGHAL, ADMINISTRA’ UH tenutbon 1. Gaya Prasid Pret, 8/0 Shri 13.L, Pat ’ Aged about 44 years, Ryo f Residency, JK. Koad, Bhopal asuoy 2. Sajay Gandhi, $/o Shri M.C. Gandhi, Aged about 41 years, R/o Telephone Exchange Campus, Choda Chougati, Dhar (MP) 454001 2, Mukesh Kulehreshtha, 8/0 Shri Rajendra Prakash, aged about 40 years, R/o 204, bnavi Enclave, Vigyan tager, Indure (MP) 4. Mandl Lai Singh, S/o Shri Aged about 4} yc 70, Sanjeevari Nagar, A, Jabedpuir-482008 [MP] 5. Jitendes Kamar Verma, Aged aboui 41 years, Rio Behind Jain Mandir, Gar 6. Ms. Shikha Pandey, D/o Shri HP, Aged about 45 years, Ryo Jabalpur 482004 (Me 7. DAK. R/oY-7, Atel, S/o Shri RL, Patel, prtune Glory, Bf Exu S. Mukesh i RS, Sharma, Aged about 13 years, 23, Coutortpalm, © Near Ovion School, Bawadiakala, Galmonar, Bhopal 462629 (M1. ste ay 9. Man Molan Vyas, 8/o Shri R.C. Vyas, Aged about 42 years, K/o P-36, Rishipusana, Phase 1, BAIEL, Bhopal ~ 462021 (iP) 10. Qutubuddin Tikiwata, ‘Tikiwala, aged about 42 ye K.D. Gate, Ujjai S/o Shri Saifudein rs, R/e $2, Saifec Mohalla, 456 006 (MPj (By Advouate: Shri Vijay 7 thyPape Vet 36 (0 Mo.LL64/2011 CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, JABA! jABALPUI, Origicat Application No.1164 of 2011 vabalpur, thi ‘Toesday, the 110 day of De aber, 2012 HON ULE SHRI JUSTIC! HOW BLE SUle G.P DIGREND RA MISHRA, J AL, ADMINISTRD CAL MRMBER, 1. Gaya Prasid Pavel, S/o Shri 3.1. Patel Aged abut 44 years, Rio B24! A, sina Residency, J.K. Koad, Bhapal asi Sajay Gandhi, $/o Shri M.C Aged about 41 years, R/o Yeley Exchange Campus, Ghoca Choupati, Dhar (MP) 454601 2. Mukesh Kulshreshtha, S/o Shri Rajendra Prakash, aged about 40 years, R/o 204, Vaishnavi Enelase, Vigyan Nagar, indore (MP) 4. Mand Lat S/o Shri BN. S Aged about 41 years, Ra Plot No.14 Vijay Nagar, Jabalpur (IP) 482002 sh, . ditendea Kamar Vernta, So Lete BP, Verma, Aged about 4i years, Rfo 670, Sanjeevani Nagar, Behind Jain Mandir 2, Jédbalpuir-a&2008 (MP) 6. Ms. Shikha Pandey, D/o Shri H.P.S. Chaychury Aged about 45 years, Ryo 270 Anand Nagur, Adh Jabalpur 482004 (MP 7. DAC Paw, S/o Shei RL, Pate R/o ¥. 7, Fortune Glory, B-8 Ext 8. Mukesh Sharma, 8/ Aged about 43 yes: Near Orion Sckwol, Bawadiakala, Gulmohar, Bhopal 9 (MP) Extensicn, 23 9. Man Mohan Vyas, 3/0 St Aged about 42 years, K/o 2-36, Rishipuran, Phase I, BHEL, Bhopal ~ 46202! (MP] 10. Qutubuddin Tikiwala,-S/o Shri Saifuddin Tikiwala, aged about 42 years, R/v 52, Saifec Mohalla, K.D. Gate, Ujjain ~ 456 006 (MP} (By Advooste: Shri Vijay ath VersuPage 16 of 16 9A No.1104/201! 11.21.2004 cancelling the promotion was quashed by the Annexure ALO wider of che Hon'ble High Court of Ke: dated 91.02.2008. Pacts of the present « se being entirely 2009 © on the finding in that judginent is dillerent from those in he case reposted ine ILR (supra), the reliar srisplaced and (hat judgement is not applicable to the party respondents. ‘Tue creation of the supernum Ny posts whether neccesary or not, whether improper or not does aot affest, just as the promotion of t c respondents in 1981, the Fights of the applicants, ‘The focus of the present O.A., it appe: applicants as on den 8, is not som ruck: on securing the sights of the ing the © hte of the resp 18.0n the basis of aforesaid discussion and following te ‘Tribunals and Hon'ble High Courts of Bombay and Kerala, ‘ve are 0 opinion that the applicants? im for seni Ly over and’aboze Uh respondents and similarly situated persons is without ariy subsiance and they ea not claim service benefits from ihe date of arising vacancy and the service benefits can be claimed only from the date of joining duly. ‘The applicants, who were subsequently appointed towards 25% quota under the departmental competitive examination, are not eniitle:t (9 have their seniority fixed ith retraypecuve effect against the respursie nts who were already promoted Jomed thelr duties on the pranuted pasts even before the promotion orders ef the applicants were issu 2 © othe OA. is accordingly disn 2 . cl, No orcler as to costs. (Se hi end hits tee Judigi a : 6 1 alls eo SO ee 7 Pinip Li Hock Ss Bog TRUE COP! Be one RS. ST EEE elt) elt a ion Te eave, Section Offizer