. . , . .

2006
:

 1(091)
87.1
946

. . , . . : .
: 2 . / . . -. , 2006. 1: . 98 .
ISBN 5-94356-427-6

I. ..

, ,
.
,
,
.

II. ...

12

III. V .....

38

IV. ..

62

90

90

..

93

10.01.223
(-1227.2005.6)

- . , . . .

. . , . . ,
, ,
, 2006

, 2006
ISBN 5-94356-427-6

I.

, . ,
, , , , ( ) , . ,
, ,
, ,
. , . , ,
, 1.
? , .
, , , 2.
, , , , . ,
, . ,
. , ,
. .
,
, ,
. .
, , , , .
1

Heraclitus, fr. 18 DK (11 Marc.) ap. Clement, Strom. 2.17.4 Sthlin. .

. . .
2
. , , Makin (1988).

. , ,
,
( ),
. , Doxographi
graeci, 1879 ., , , . ( ) , () ( ),
.
( ), , , . ,
, , ,
, . , Vetusta placita, , . .

, .
Doxogpahi
graeci
(Placita), ,
(Eclogae physicae). , -, Historia philosopha, ,
. , , , , , , ,
-, ,
. (Graecarum affectionum curatio), , ,
.

, . , , , - ( ), 5

 , () , 3.

,
1903 .
, 4.
, , ,
. , Freeman (1948),
. , ,
(KRS) . ,
successio, ,
-, . ,
, .
, ,
,
, . ,

,
, .
,
. ,
. ,
,
. 3
4

, (I 1744;
II 117; VIII 5177; 8284; IX 160 ).
1937 . 6-
( )
, -
. , . . . , : Poetarum Philosophorum Fragmenta (Berlin,
1901). , ( ).

,
, ,
. ,
, . , . ,
, , , .
, , (
), ,
, ,
, , . , ,
. , (, ), () ( ),
.
, . ,
. ,
. ,
.

,
, , . , ,
, ,
.

, ,
, .
:
(MansfeldRunia 1996). , , ,
, .

, ,
,
, , , ,
, , .

.
, ,
, , , , . , , , . .
. ,
, .
, ,
.
,
,
. ,
.
,
. . 570 . . .
,
. ,
, ,
. , , ,
.
, ,
: . , , (
), , ,
. , , . , -

. (),
, ,
. ,
.
, , ,
. ,
, .
, . , , .
, , , .
VIV . . . , ,
, . V
. . .
, .
.
,
.
, , , , , ,
( , , , ,
.),
350
250 . . ., ,
( ,
).
. . .
. , ,
- .
( 2002)

 . . , . . , , , . .
.
,
,
. . ( 1990), ,
. . . ,
,
, , . .. ,
.
, (KRS). ,
.
, . , , .
(West 1983). ,
.
, , ,
, .
. . (1951,
. . .: 2000). , , , . . . . . .

.

10

(2005).
,
(Burkert 1972), , (2002).
.
,
, .
, , ,
.

.

,
-. KRS. . . , .

11

II. .

G. S. Kirk,
J. E. Raven, M. Schofield, The Pre-Socratic Philosophers, Cambridge, 1983
(p. 214238). . . ,
.

1. . , X. 600 b (DK 14, 10): ,

, , ,
, , , [] , , [ ], [ ]
-
?
2. . , 530 d (DK 47 B 1): ,
, : ;
, , , .
, , , ,
, . ? ? ,
: ,
(Cornford),
(Weisheit und Wissenschaft) (
,
(Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism, Cambridge, Mass., 1972)). ,
. , .

, , ( ) . ,
, . ( ,
, Burnet (1930), 83
n. 1.) , ,

, .


5.
, , ,
. , , , ( ., , Ross,
(1951), chs. IXXVI.
.
,
- ,
( 2005, .
23 5). .
, , ,
. . , .
(, , X,
248309).
, . ,
, , , .
5

12

. : (2005).

13


.
6. ,
, . , ,
;
( ),
( ) 7.
, , .
. , ,
350250 . . .,
, : ,
, ( ).
,
,
.
, .
(1)
3. 16 (40 DK), , IX, 1: , , , , : ,
, .
4. 17 (129 DK), , VIII, 6:
, , 6

Josephus contra Apionem I, 163 (DK 14, 18). , , , ,

. , (Alex. fort. 328a) (Galen, Plac.
Hipp. et Plat. 459M), (VIII, 6): . DK 14, 18
19).
-
(bo, 1965).

14

. - : , ,
, ,
.
5. , IV, 95 (DK 14, 2): [IV, 94: ,
]. ,
,
, [ , ] : , , . , . - ,
[], , ,
[sofisth>v]: . [ ], [ ]
[ ],
, , ,
, ,
, , .
6. , . 4, I, 120 (DK 37 B 4):
,
,
, :
.
. 4
, (. . 35 DK: , (filoso>fouv), ).
, . , , : , (3).
4, iJstori>h, , , , ? , ,
(. , . 35)?
(. 5) .
, . , , , , , ,
15

 , . ,
, , . , ,
(, VI, 94). ,
- - ,
. , , ,
.
, , 6
4. , ,
,
. 5 ( ), (
).
,
, :
7. , . 129, , , 30:
, :
, ,
,
. ,
, .
, , , ,
, , . ,
, . ,
.
,
. ,

. . 8, . . ,
(. . . ) 9, , , , 10.
,
, .

, ,
, .
(2)
8. , . 7 (6 G.P., 6 D.). , VIII, 36
(DK 21 B 7): [] , :
...
, , :
, , , .
, :
! !
, .
9. , II, 123:
. : [.
] , [
] . , , [ ] , [] .
,
. , .
, , ,
, . , , :
, 8

Wright (1891), 257f

. . : (. 129 ).
10
(1994), 31.
9

16

17

 (The Pre-Socratic Philosophers I, 104). ,

. , , . .
, -
(, , ), , ,
. .
. 8 9, 6
, ,
, yuch>. ,
yuch>, , . ,
, , .
6 ,
. ,

.
(3)
10. . , 1, 131 (. II, . 81, 11 St.) (DK 36
B 2; 15): ,
[ ]. . .
11. , II, 81: [ : ]
(DK 14, 1): . . .
.
: . :
(o]rgia)
. , , (iJero<v
lo>gov). [ : RVS]: . [ ] [ ], ,
: . .
. . ,
(.
18

, 953954, , 103032, ,
364). ,
, , ,
. ,
10 ,
11.
11 ,
,
. , , . , , ,
,
(teletai>), , , ,
. , -, , ,
, , ,
.
, . ,
,
. ,
( ), ,
. ,
. , ,
.
,
. , , (sw|>zetai: sw~ma)
, (, , 400 bc).
, (, , 363 ).
, (, , 952, ,
11

, VIII, 8 (ej>nia poih>santa ajnenegkei~n eijv JOrfe>a). ,

, , ,
. (, . .), ,
, ,
.

19

, 1032, , 782 ). . ,
, ,
. ,
12.
. , . .
,
, , , 13,
.
:
, , , ,
14.
. , , , ,
- . ,
. , , ; , .
, , , , 15.
, .
. , , . 16. , , Hieros Logos , -

17. 18, , . , 19.

, 20.
, , , , ,
Hieros Logos , . -.
21.
, ,
, ,
, ,
. . ,
, , . ,
, , ,
, 22.
, . . , , .
17

. Burkert (1982).
DK 15; DK 17. . . . .
14
. 17 . = 129. ,
. . Burkert (1972), 130f.
15
West (1983), p. 9.
16
. : , ,
Triagmoi, (Call. . 449).
, , , (Ath. 468c, v. 1. Epigenes).
Triagmoi. (Linforth 1958, 114 ff), , .

, , 1.131 = . 222 Kern; 15 DK.

, , , 5.49 ( = . 33 )
, . . :
, Triagmoi, . , ,
, Triagmoi, , . -, Triagmoi.
18
( )
. , JHrodi>kou Prodi>kou (
), , . (Suda s.v. jOrfeu<v Kamarinai~ov), , -, .
19
267, (Burkert 1972, 105 n. 40).
20
,
, (. 297298).
21
. West (1983), 715.
22
, , 5. 49,3 50,1.

20

21

12
13

12. . , I, 62 (DK 14, 8): ,

, , , [. 11 Wehrli], [ , . 17 Ross] [FGrHist 115 F 72], ,
[FGrHist 84 F 29], .
, , .
13. , I, 118=, . 14 Wehrli (DK
14, 8): ,
[, . 7 1] .
14. . , 9 = , . 16 Wehrli (DK 14, 8): , , , ,
,
,
.
15. . , 248 (DK 14, 16): ,
, ; , : ,
, . ; , , . , , , , , ,
,
, , ,
. (249) ; , . , , , .

, ,
, ,
, ,
( , VIII 79). , , ( , VIII 46; , , 251).
,
, (,
, 197).
.
, , , .
.
, 540532 522 . . . ( : , ; .,
, , , 1119).
,
, .
, , (, III 125, 131132). ,
, , , .
500450 . . . ( , ,
), (, II
39; Walbank ad loc.). ,

:

22

23

, .
(1)

16. . , 249251 (DK 14, 16):

,
.
[] , , .
, , , [] ,
: ; - . (250) [] ,
.
: - ( !) -
. []
, ,
[], , , .
[] , .
. (251) , ,
. ,
, .
(2)

, ,
(
; ,
), [ ], , , [ ]
.
, [ ] ,
[ ] ,
, :
.
17 ( , . .) 18 ( , )
, .
. , sophos,
. , ,

[, ,
] (J.S. Morrison, CQ 6 (1956) 144145). ,
, , .
- (Burkert 1972, 115).
, hetaireia, :

17. (Iustinus ap. Pomp. Trog. Hist. Phil.

Epit. XX, 4, 12; 58): (.. )
. , , [
], . , .
,
, .
, , . , .
18. . , 18 = , . 33 Wehrli
(DK 14, 8a): , , .

19. (Timaeus fr. 13a Jacoby),

(Schol. In Plat. Phaedr. 279c): : , , , ,
, . : :
koina< ta< tw~n fi>lwn ( ).
20. (Iustinus ap. Pomp. Trog. Hist. phil.
epit. XX, 4, 14): , , ,
, () .

24

25

 sune>dria, ( ) (II 39, 1), ,

( 20)
. hetaireiai

, , ,
, .
koina< ta< tw~n fi>lon ( )
,
(, , 233237 = . 31
Wehrli; ., ., , 127, 239 hetaireiai :
1. , , (tw~n hJlikiwte>wn Her.);
2. , , , (eijv eJtairei>an ejmbalei~n eJauto>n Plut.): spoudai< eJtaireiw~n ejp ajrca>v Plat. ;
3. (. eJtairei>av limh>n Soph.) Eur. 23
, thiasos, : ; , , (Mousw~n Arph.; hJli>kwn
Eur.).
(2002).
. . , ,
,
, - . ,
. . . ,
-, ,
,
24.

23
24

- , . . .
(2002), 5152.

26

, ,
hetaireiai - .
,
. ,
(DK 14, 14).
21. . , 254255. (254)
, ,
,
. ,
, , ,
, , . ,
, , .
( ),
,
. , , (255) , , ,
. , , , ,
, , , . ,
. , , , , ,
, , . , , ,
: ,
, ,
.
22. , XII, 9, 2 ( ?):
[=] , . (3) , ,
.
, . (4)
, 27

 . . .
,
. (5) [300 .], [100 .] , . (6) , , , ,
. , . (10, 1)

, , . , []
.
2122
, . , ,
. , ,
. , , .
,
. ,
, ,
.
, , .
, . , ,
, - . ,

, . , ,
.

28

23. . , 5. 986 29 [=24 3] (DK 14, 7):
[?] .
. , 6=. , . 1 Ross: , ,
: , !
. . , - , , , ,
.
. , II, 26=. : , .
24. . , 5. 986 29 [=24 3] (DK 14, 7):
[?] .
. , 6=. , . 1 Ross: , , <
. > [ ]
: -
. , , [] , .
, , . 23
24 , . ,
,
, , , , ,
, , , . , , , , ,
( IV, 15; Burkert 1972, 147).
. ,

, ,
29

 ,

- 25.

,
. , , acusmata ().

. symbola (, ) , , , ,
, . , ,
.
, , , , (.: Suda s.v.=DK 58 C 6;
3, 6). , , ,
, .
(1)
25. , VIII, 34= (DK 58 C 3).
, . 195 Rose=. 5 Ross: , [] , ,
, * * * [
), , , ,
, , (
). , - .
[. 305 Kock], : , . ,
25

Dodds (1951), ch. V;

Lewis (1971).
. West
(1983), 45; (1998).

30

, , ,
; ,
. , ,
,
. (35) ,
[ ] [],
, , , . , , [ ] , [],
, .
( , )
,
, , .
( , )
, .
, , : ,
, .
, . 25
, (. VIII, 19=, . 194,
,
).
, , , , ,
. (DK 14, 9; 58e) , .
(2)
26. . , 42 (DK 58 C 6):
, : , . . ; , . . [ ]
; , . .
, . :
, . . ; , . . ; , , . ., ,
.
31

 ( , ) , , , , , , . , ,
26, (, , , ), :
.
(3)
27. . , 82 (DK 58 C 4): :
?. . ., ?. . .,
. ?. . .:
? .
? , . .
, .
?. . ., , :
? .
? .
, .
? .
? .
? .
? ().
?
.
, , .
.
, , ,
, ,
.
26

,
, , (, , 21; DK 58 C 6).

32

, ...?,
27. tetractys, . .
, . , , , :
,
(. ) 28. , , (, 616b617; .
449 ). , , , , .
, . ,
;
, , , . , , , , (, , )
(fr. 9 Heinze, Porph., in Ptol. 30, 2).

, (fr. 90
Wehrli; 108d = DK 18, 12). , , :
28. , De vita pyth., 87-88, , :
, ,
.
, .
27

. (Aristoxenus fr. 15 Wehrli,

VIII, 8 (DK 14, 3)).
, , (Burkert 1972,
113114; . 25).
28
. , , VII, 9495.

33

 , , ,
.
Iamblichus, Comm. math. sc. pp. 76, 1677, 2 Festa:
, , , ,
, , , , , ,
.
( )
,
, (,
), , . , , .
,
, .
,
, ,
.
. (1) ,
( , VII, 9495),
, ,
. (2)
.
(3) -
(,
: , 115, ,
II, 1, 9 .; . Burkert 1972, 375377).
, . , ,
, , , ,

34

(, ).
, .
(4)
29. . , 41 (DK 58 C 2): - [] ;
[] [ , . 196 .=. 6
Ross]. , , <>,
, , , , , ,
.
30. . , IV, 17 (DK 58 C 2):
, ; , , ,
.
31. . , 11. 94 b 33 (DK 58 C 1):
, , [ ] .
,
. . 2931 (
27 ),
(. , , 85),
. (
), . , ,
, , , . , ,
,
(.
480482, , ., 1988, . 108).
,
476 . . .:

35

32. , Olympians II, 5677 (. . . ):

,
.

, ,
;
,

;

, .
,
,
,
.
;
,
,
.

,

, ,
.

: -, , , , , , , [], , ,
[] , , , [], [. ]
. , ,
, .
. 33 ( ) , ,
,
( ), , , (cf. Aristotle fr. 192, DK 14, 7; VIII,
15) (cf. Eudemus ap. Simpl. in Phys.
732, 30, DK 58 B 34). ,
, -
. , .
, , , .
,
.

.
, . . 32 2931 , , : (1)
; (2) (, ), (3) ,

, , , (.
, 523 b).
33. . , 19 = , . 33 Wehrli
(DK 14, 8a): ,
, . 36

37

III.

G. S. Kirk,
J. E. Raven, M. Schofield, The Presocratic Philosophers, Cambridge, 1983
(p. 322350). . . ,
.

, ,
, . .
. , - . ,
,
.

(i)
34. . , 61 D (DK 44 15): [:] , , [= ], ? [:] , . [:] .
, 61 : [:] , ,
, [= ],
: . .
35. , VIII, 46 (DK 44 A 4): , [. 19 Wehrli], , , ,

, . 29.
36. , IX, 38 (DK 44 A 2): 30 , [. 470 , 460 ] .
34 ,
399 . . . , , ,
, . 35
34, ,
. 36 , . 3436, ( ,
460457 . . .) ,
, ( 470 . . .).
.
(ii)
37. , VIII, 8485 (DK 44 A 1): , . . [. . .]
, (ajna>gkh)
. , (
, ).
. [. 25 FHG] , , , , ,
. ,
[] ,
, .

29

30

38

, ;
, , ,
VIII, 84 (DK 44 A 4). ,
,
.
( ), , VI . . . (, 2.130 (DK 68 B 4), Burkert 1972, 229 n. 51).

39

 , , (
), , . ,
- . .
( , , ). , ,
, , , , , , , (. VIII, 6, DK
14, 19; 199, DK 14, 17; Burkert
1972, 223225). 37 ,
;
(59 ).
, , .
, .

31. . , ()
44 , ()
, , ,
, fusiologi>a ,
, , ,
(Lore, 298). (., , Philip (1966), 3233, 121122; Vogel (1970), 3334, 8485; Barnes
(1989), II, 88, 9293).
. .
(iii)
38. , VIII, 85 [. 1] (DK 44 B 1): []
<> , : [~ ] []: .

39. , I, 21, 7 (. 187, 14 W.) (DK 44 B 2):

:
, , []. . ,
, [] ,
[], , , ,
[]. , [] : , , , ,
, ,
, , .
40. . . , 7, 24 Pist. (DK 44 B 3):
, , ,
.
38, , ,
, . 39 32. , : () , (), -,
. , (),
. ()
, , ,
, , ,
(
), . ,
38 ( , , ).
non sequitur. .
, - ,
, . ,
, (). (Barnes (1989), II, 8587) , ( , 32

31

C. Huffman
.

40

;
. (ap. [Arist.] M.X.G. 979a 11 f.). , .

41

 ), (, ,
, ),
. , ( ). ,
, ( ..) , 51.
, ,
37.
(iv)
41. , 1,21, 7b (. I, . 188, 5 W.) (DK 44 B 4): ,
, , , .
42. , I, 21, 7 (1,188, 9) (DK 44 B 5): : , , . , [?]
33.
41 , ,
. ,
, ,
, . , , , (
)
34. ,
.
(v)
43. , I, 21, 7 d (I, 188, 14; , , 9. . 252, 17 Jan) (DK 44 B 6): 33

42 : ,
5, 986 17 (44 ad fin.); 41 . , in Met. 40, 12 (, . 230).
34
Nussbaum (1979), 6466, 8193, , 3942 .

42

. (ejstw>) , , , . ,
, , ,
, : []. (ajrcai>)
,
, [ ] ,
. , ,
, .
43 . , , .
, , ( ), , :
. , ,
,
. , - ( ) , .
(vi)
, ,
: .
,
, , , . , , , , ,
.. , .
.
,
(. 3843), , 43

 , .
(45), , , ( )
.
, ,
() ,
(52). . ,
, .

.
35.
. , 5. 986 13 (DK 58 B 5): , . . ,
[] []
[.. 4 ]. ,
, (ajrch>)
, (pa>qh kai< e[xeiv),
[ ] ,
[] , (a]peiron),
(to< e[n) [] (
); [] [, ],
, , [=].

44. . , 5. 985 b 23 (DK 58 B 4): [= ?]

, , , ,
(ajrcai>) .
[] , , , (oJmoiw>mata) [] , (, , ), , -
(pa>qov) , - [],
, , [ ] , ,
[- ] ,
, , ,
[]
, , .
[=], , (pa>qh)
[~] , ,
[ ] . - , ,
. , , : [], , ,
,

, , , , , ( 987 31, 293 20, 342 b

30). ,
36.
, , , . . , -
440 . . ., , , , (. 1078 b 19, DK 58 B 4).
44 . , ,
,
, (
1225 30, DK 44 B 16). , , 44 3843 ,
. . -

44

45

35

36

(in . 41, 1; DK 58 B 4)
.
,
, aujto<v ej>fa ( VIII, 46; Jambl. Comm.
math. sc. p. 77, 2224). , .

 42 , 3843
( , , ). 45
, 43 37.
45
(
1092 b 26ff.; DK 58 B 27), 39 43 . , . 42 , ; , (, 52 5658; 987 9ff; DK 58 B 8),
, . 3843. , , .
44 ,
. , ,

. , ,
, (, ) , .
44 ,
,
. ,
. 52, 3843,
. 44

,
. ( ,
;
). (
,
,

45. . , 6. 1080 b 16 (DK 58 B 9): [, ] , , [ ]; , , . ,

[=, ]; , , [] ,
(e[n), , , .
46. . , 8, 1083 b 8 (DK 58 B 10): [], ,
, [], [] , . ,
[ ], .
[], , .
, [, ] , -
[] . ?
[ ]. ; ,
(qewrh>mata) , .38

37

38

(., , , 26, 2; DK 44
A 24); 429 (Ecl. 1, 21 7d cont., DK 44 B 6).
3839 43.

46

..: , . 230 ap. Alex. in Met. 38, 16).

, , ,
.
.
( ),
. ( 1 10;
, ).

, ,
,
. . Ross (1924), liiilvii.

47

 , , 44,
,
. ,
, ,
(., , Furley (1967), I, ch. 3). . 45
, 47
, ,
.
, ,
, . 4547:
47. . , N 5, 1092 b 8 (DK 45, 3): [
].
,
(o]roi) ( , ,
, ; ,
, , , , , [] , [ ] )
, ?
, V . ., ,
, , , (. 51).

48. , VIII, 12: , ,
( -);
:
, ,
.
49. . , , I, 44, . 419, 15 Friedl. (DK 58 B 20):
( , , ). ,
, . . [] , , [] .
48

50. , I, 32, 377, 9 Fr. (DK 58 B 21): ( ,

,
[] ) . 379, 2: ,
[ ] . , :
, .
, , , D , . . , , , , .. ,
, .. . ,
.
.

, . ,
(49) ,
50,
(Schol. Eucl. 273, 3; 13). , ,
(. Ptolemaeus Harm. 1,
13, DK 47 A 16, Boethius De mus. III, II, DK 47 A 19).
, , -,
.

. ,
(Schol. Eucl. 417, 12 ff., , 246
.; DK 18, 4), ,
49

 (. Burkert 1972, 455465; Philip (1966), . 2).

, ,
(. . 48). , ,
, 3, 4, 5, . , , (. Burkert 1972, 427
430).
(. 1968, . II).
44 39 , .
, . ,
,
(Eucl. p. 65, 3ff.) 40. , . . ,
, . 44.
(, ap. Alex. in Met. 39, 8), , 2 + 3 = 5.

:
51. . , 4. 202 b 36 (DK 58 B 28): , , ,
39

40

. ,
(Burkert 1972, 412414) , ,
.
. W. A. Heidel, The Pythagoreans and Greek Mathematics, FurleyAllen
1975, I, 350ff.; Burkert 1972, ch. VI.
, ,
(. 409412).

50

, . , : , .
. 51,
( kai< cwri>v,
). , ,
.

, , .
1, .
2 . 1 , 2, ,
. (. . 52
).
( ) ( ).
,
, , . ,
,
(Simpl. in Phys. 455,20 456,15). , ,
, .
, . 51,
44, 3842 5758, (
) .

51


52. . , 5. 986 22 (DK 58 B 5):
[-]
, [: ]:










, , [. DK 24 3], ,
: [ ],
, 41. ,
[] ,
, , ,
-: -, -, -, -. , [], [ ],
, . , ,
, , [] .
[ ] []
, , , ,
[ ] , , , [] [ ].
,
, , 41

: kai< ga<r ejge>neto

th<n hJliki>an jAlkmai>wn ejpi< ge>ronti Puqago>ra|, ajpefh>nato de< ktl. [? ], . , (Ross, ad loc.) , b , ,
, .

52

44, .
-
, , , 42.

, , ,
. . 44, ,
. ,
. 51,
, . ,
,
, , 43.

55. , I, 21, 8 (. I, . 189, 17 W.) (DK 44 B 7): , , ().

56. . , N 3, 1091 12 (DK 58 B 26): , ,
. : , , (croia>), , , (a]peiron)
(pe>rav).
57. . , 6. 213 b 22 (DK 58 B 30): ,
42

43

52 ,
, , , ,
: 53. , . 1, VIII, 83 (DK 24 B
1): , , , : , ,
(safh>neia) [] ,

. 54. , 5, 1106b29 (DK 58 B 7):

, ,
.

53

 [=] []
(a]peiron), [] , (fu>seiv),
[]. , [, ]
(fu>siv).
58. , I, 18, I c, . I, . 156 W (DK 58 B 30):
[. 201 Ross=. 11 Ross] ,
, [ ], [=]
, , .
, 56 ,
, . 44, , , .
, , 55, ,
, , 56. ,
, (. 43 ,
),
56, 45. (. 5758)
, 44.
, .
, 44

59. . ,
18, 8. . 31 (DK 44 A 27): ,
[ ] , , ,
. : , , ; , , . . , . , - ,
, , . ,
[], , , , , ,
.
.
, , ,
[~ ]. , , , .

54

(. Philip, Pythagoras, 68
70, 9395; C. H. Kahn, Pythagorean philosophy before Plato in The Presocratics, ed. A. P. D. Mourelatos (Garden City, N.Y., 1974), 183184).
; 5759 (
), , 45.
.
,
(, ) ,
. ,

:
.

(i)
60. . , 13. 293 18 (DK 58 B 37): , [] . . .
, , : , , ,
,
. , ,
, , ,
- . [. . .] (293 b 1)
45

, , , -, , , , , (. Guthrie 1978, I, 239282).

54 (. 43).
, , 1028b16, 1090b5, DK 58 B 2324 (
, ., , Cherniss 1944, 132ff., Burkert 1972, 4243), , 4094, , , X, 281, [.] , . 84, 10, DK 44 A 13
( , .
Burkert 1972, 6671).

55

 . ,
, , , ,
, []
. , , ,
.
61. (), II, 7, 7 ( )
(DK 44 A 16): , [, ] ,
() , ,
, , . ,
,
. ,
: , , , ,
(), ,
.
60 ,
, , 60.
,
? , ,
, . , , , (, , ).
, , .
, , ,
46, , ,
46

62. , II, 20, 12 ( ) (DK 44 A 19):

, , ,
, , : ,
, . , , , , .

56

, , , . , (. 42), ,
,
47.
(ii)
63. . , 9. 290 b 12 (DK 58 B 35): , , []
, , , [ ]
, . ,
: , [ ],
, [ ],
, , -
, ,
,
! , , [], , , (sumfwni>ai), , ,
, .
, , ,
: .
, , , , .

47

, , (
II, 20, 13, DK 31 A 56). ,
( II, 29, 4, DK 58 B 36; : I, 8, 6 9, DK 59 A 42, II, 29, 7, DK 59
A 77).
, , , ,
; (, 9847, , in Phys. 23, 33,
DK 18, 7). , , ,

.

57

(ii)
63
.
( ,
). ,
, , .

(i)
64. . , 2. 404 16 (DK 58 B 40): , : [] ,
, . [] ,
, .
65. . , 4. 407 b 27 (DK 44 A 23):
. . . , (kra~siv) ,
.
66. . 88d () .
, , .
64 (
, ),
. 65 ,
48. ,
, , , , .
,
(. 44). 66 .

48

67. . , 2. 405 29 (DK 24 A 12):

[, , ] ,
-, : , ,
. [= ] , : , ,
.
68. (), IV, 2, 2 ( ) (DK 24 A 12):
[ ] (fu>siv), . ,
.
69. -. , 17, 3. 916 33 (DK 24 B
2): , , .
, ,
, (. 64). 68 ,
,
,
(. 67). , , , .
, , , . , (. , 245246, , ).
69 . , , , , , , .
( ), . ,
, 6768, .

, 66 (. 33)
, - .

58

59


70. . . , 137 (DK 58 D 2): , . , ,
(oJmili>a) . ,
; ,
, , .
, , - ,
, , - ,
. , , .
(ku>riov) , , []
, , , ,
, .
71. . , 175 (DK 58 D 3):
, . ,
, , , ,
, . (176) , [] [],

.
72. . , 62 (DK 44 B 15):
, , ,
, .
, , ,
: , , .

32) , . , , ,
.

, (, ) 44, , , , .

( , ).
, , , .
. - , , : , , .
.
,
.
, ,
, .

7071, , (. Stobaeus, Anth. IV, 25, 45 IV, I, 40, DK 58 D 4).

, (, ,
), ,
. . (. 33).
, . 72 ( .
60

61

III.
(
): Dominic J. OMeara, Pythagoras Revived. Mathematics
and Philosophy in Late Antiquity. Oxford, 1990, p. 129.

.
, ,
, , . , , , , . (), ,
,
,
. , , (
), , .
:
. , ,
, ,
. ,
, . , .
.

49.
, , , 49

. Blumenthal (1981); ,
, (, ) , ,
.

62

.
, ,
, ,
, , .
529 50, . , ,
.
, , . , , - 51.
, ( ) ,
. . . , , , , ,
,
. ,
: , , , , ,
.
, 52.

. ,
, 50

. Blumenthal (1978).
. Sorabji (1983), (1987); Sambursky (1962).
52
. P. Hadot (1968), Smith (1974);
, ,
: . Steel
(1978), 1213; Gersh (1978), 78.
51

63


, , , 53.

. , , (Dillon 1973)
, ,
(Larsen 1972). ,
.
, , .

, , . ,
,
, (
) 54. , , , .
, , ,
. ,
. .
, ,
. ,
.
,

.
, ,
.
,

( I).
53
54

. (Praechter 1910), (1932); Steel (1978), 12.

. Praechter (1910), 173; Harder (1926), xvi ff.; Burkert (1972), 98; Szlezk
(1979), 35.

64

,
( II). ,
VVII, .
( III).
. , ( IV), ,
, .

,
( V), ( VI)
( VIIX). ,
,
,
, ,
.
, , , , -,
,
, .
, . ,
, ,
.
,
.
.
, , ,
, 55. ,
55

, , , ., , Lewy (1956), Saffrey (1984), Shaw

(1985).

65

, , ,
,

. , .
. -, ,
,
,

. , ,
,

.

:
, , ,
.
,
, . . , ,
.
,
, ,
: 1. ; 2. (, , , ) ( ).
1.

1. . .

. . , . , : ? ,
? ?
,
, , ?
,
? ?
- ?
, , ,
, 56.

,
57
, . ; ;
,
, , 58. , 59. ,
, ,
, . ,
, . .

57

. Numenius, Fragments, p. 7; Dillon (1977), 362.

. Leemans (1937), Test. nos. 1820, Lewy (1956), 503 n. 23; , (Porphyry, Vit.
Plot. 17, 16).
59
, . 1 a, 1 b, 1 c, 4 b, 24, 29, 52 ( , . Waszink [1964], 11, 25).
58

56

., , Burkert (1961); Drrie (1963); Armstrong (1967), 90106 (Merlan); Dillon (1977), ch. 7. . Burkert (1972), 53; Cherniss (1976),
1645, 1701; Dillon (1977), 115 ff. . Schwyzer (1983). . nn. 8, 46, 52 .

66

67

 , 60.
,
(. 2428).
, . 61.
. -, . ,
, (. 25, 27). , , (. 24, 37 .), , (. 24,
1836). (
, ), , (. . 24, 3336). ,


62. , ,
.
,
.
?
, , (. . 24, 6264),
, .

. ,
, ,
, , ,
,
63.
,
. , , , ,
,
, 64. . . ,
, 65. ,
, 66. ,
,
, , , , ,
,
, .
63

Waszink (1966), 379; O'Meara (1975), ch. 1.

. , (Or. 26, 310, 415). dia>stasiv
(. , , 24, 41; 25, 86 104).
62
. oJmo>noia oJmodoxi>a (,
432 , 433 ), metabolh>, polupragmosu>nh sta>siv .

(. 24, 34 politei>aajlhqei~ ), (. , 372 6).

. , , . 53, 61, 2027. ,

/ ..
. , ,

( . 53, 61, 13, ,
. 48, 58, 21). . Burkert (1972), 95.
64
. 24 a; . O'Meara (1976).
65
. 24, p 11 paralu>ontev ( ) . 4 a, 245
paraluo>menon ( ). . 24, 723 oJ>lov dj ejx oJ>lou
eJautou~ metati>qetai> te kai< ajntimetati>qetai oujdamw~v () 380 d 5e 1, , .
6, 1112, (. O'Meara
[1976], 125). . Puech (1934), 767.
66
(76), (. 27, 11)
(. 3, 11). . palina>gretov . 25, 31 ( ) . 3,
5 ( ).

68

69

60
61

 ,
, , : .
, 67 ,

( ), ( ) , . (. 24, 6870). ,
68. ,
, , ,
, 69.
? ! (. 24, 70). , ,

, .. , .
( 6).
:

(. 24, 7379). , , 70. ;
.
67
68
69

70

cwri>zein, . 24, 68: , (cwrismo>v) .

(kainotomi>a); . . 24, 301; 28, 1415.
. 24, 6768 ( . 52).
, ,
(, ; . , 1920 . 1). .
. . 24, 7779; 52, 24 (
. 7, 57).

70

, . , , , , , ,
, 71. . ,
72. , , .
, , ? () ,

? , , ,
73.
, , , . . 14, .
16 , ,
. ,
?
, - ? ,
( ,
) 74.
. : , (. 1 ,
4). (. 2, 2023) ,
(572 d .) , ,
, .
71

. Festugire (195054), I 2026; Drrie (1955), 328329; (1973a), 99 .;

Waszink (1966), 4748; Aubenque (1962), 7172; P. Hadot (1987), 23 .
72
. . 1 a; 1 b, 58; 8, 913; 30, 56; Waszink (1966), 46. ejpikalei~sqai, . . 35, 16.
73
. Whittaker (1967), 200201.
74
. . 2 . 22.

71

 , ,
, ,
( ) (
, , ), ?
, ? 2
. (. 11, 15; 52, 6)
, (. 52, 5).
(. 39) , , , .
,
75?
? , ,
, , , , , , 76.
2.

(. , . 7). ,
,
, ,
, , 79.
,
,
80.
, . , .
.
(sofi>a), ,
, ,
(1, 52, 19).
79

( ) 77
: ,
,
78.
.
(. , . 2)
,
75

(Burkert 1972); . Krmer (1964), 63 ff. (.
. .
(347274 ..). ., 2005, . 23. . .)
76
. . 2, 2223. ,
ti> ejsti to< o}n (loc. cit.; fr. 3, 1), (Met. 1);
,
: . O'Meara (1976).
77
. D'Ooge et al. (1926), 712. (1969) 196
, . Tarn (1974), 113.
78
. I. Hadot (1984), 6569.

72

80

, VII, ,
( Tannery [1885a], 181
182). Oppermann (1928)
. (De dec.), , , , -,
, , , -,
VII .
, () In Nic. (= On Pyth. IV) , Intro. arith. ( anon. Theol. arith. 1, 1018 Iambl. In Nic. 11, 15
24; , anon. Theol. arith. 3, 27 Nicom. Intro. arith. 111,
17; 113, 26). , , , . , , Nicom. Intro. arith. (. 83, 46 )
Iambl. In Nic. ,
On Pyth. VII (, .3) , anon. Theol. arith. , , anon. Theol. arith., , On Pyth. VII.
. D'Ooge, 7987, . Tarn (1974).
, , Burkert
(1972), 98 .

73

(3, 94, 5) (27 d), ,

(. 7), , . .
, , , 81. , , . ,
, . , , , ,
.

82, , .
.
, . , ,
.
,
, ,
(7,
2129, 4). ,

, . , , , ( )
() (). 12, 69, , .
, , ,
, , .
, ,
,
. -

: ,
, (),
. ,
. , ,
, ,
; 83.
. (2, 2123, 5) , , ,
, , , , , . ,
. , ( ), 84. , , , . . ,
,
, , ,
.
, () . , , , , , ,
(ijdiw>mata) 85.
86. , :
, , , .
87. ,

(), , ,
. ,
83

.
Levin (1975), 46 .
82
. anon. Theol. arith. 56, 1315.

. anon. Theol. arith. 44, 713 (= Nicomachus; . D'Ooge, 85 n. 5).

D'Ooge, 9495.
85
Anon. Theol. arith. 20, 1521, 4 (= Nicomachus; . D'Ooge, 8687,
E 20, 1); 44, 813.
86
Anon. Theol. arith. 3, 111; 21, 18; 23, 46.
87
. Intro. arith. 12, 18; 9, 1015; 114, 1718.

74

75

81

84

, . ,
()
, , ( ,
).
-, (12, 614) 88. ? , , ,
, , , , , ?

. , ,
.
.

,
, , . , ,
89 , (66, 12),
, ,
, 90. ,
, 91.

. ,
.

, .
(65, 816) . , 92.
,
. ,
, ;
, 93.

.
, . ,
94 :
( , ),
.
, , 95 .
, , -, ,
,
.
96,
,
, 92

, D'Ooge, 9899 (
, In Nic. I 12, 58), Bertier (1978), 2122.
89
. D'Ooge, 225 n. 1.
90
Intro. arith. 65, 17 ff. to< eijv ta< fusika< tau~ta ( , (D'Ooge), fusiologi>a 64, 2325) suntei~non qew>rhma. , Vit. Pyth. 45, 1415,
pro<v polla< diatei~non fusika< suntele>smata, ( 45, 4).
91
. 64, 2365; 8; 114, 49 . ( ).

65, 912 ( to< th~v yuch~v.kosmhtiko>n eujtakthqh>sontai);

.anon. Theol. arith. 35, 1536, 1 (= Nicomachus; . D'Ooge, 85 n. 4).
93
Theol.
arith. , anon. Theol. arith. 37, 1 .
94
Anon. Prol. in Nic. 76, 2024 (, Tannery, xiii, ; prolegomena,
); , In Nic. I 1, 12.
95
. , . 24. Intro. arith. 122, 20123, 3
Theol. arith. (= Photius, Bibl. III 47, 145 a 67).
96

, (e]fodov, 64, 2324) .

76

77

88


97. . ,
, ,
, ,
( )
,
, , , .
? ? , , . , , : I
, II 98. : - , - , , , . , , 99. .
, , ,
97

Bibl. III 4142, 143 a; 142 b 43

: , ,
, ; . Hgg (1975), 160161.
98
,
; . Nicomachus in anon. Theol. arith. 27, 1015;
80, 10; Theon, Exp. 99, 1719; Anatolius, De dec. 29, 78.
, ., , Anatolius, De dec., Theon, Exp. 99, 17-106, 11,
(-) ( ; . anon. Theol. arith. 74, 10 .).
(-) . . Tannery (1885a), 182
189; Delatte (1915), 233234; Robbins (1921); Staehle (1931), 1517, 1975;
Mansfeld (1971), 157159; Thesleff (1965), 164166; , . 52.
99

. ,
(Delatte 1915, 139) ,
(143 2224, 142 b 2526).

78

,
, , , .
(142 b 35 .) , , (ijdia>zousanposo>thta) . (ajnaforh>), , , (142
b 22 .). , , ,
: 1)
( ,
), 2) , .
,
, ,
. . ,
(1, 42, 17). :
(1, 68);
, , , (1, 9 .; 3, 2 .); 100. ,
,
(3, 1 .), , (4, 12; 4, 912).
. , ,
( ),
101. , 100

2, 1819. ,
; . Burkert (1972), 98, , . 24.
101
, . ,
, . 48, 58, 21 .,

79

 ,
, .

, ,
102,
,
(. 4445), .
, , ,
, , , ,
103.
,
. ? , , ,

; , , . ,
, 104.
, , ,
, ,
: , , ,
, .
, , , , ,
didaskali>av ca>rin, , , .
, ..
,
.
.
102
ajriqmw~| dej te pa>nt' ejpe>oken; . Delatte (1915), 1415.
103
, (, 143 39, 143 b 23, 144
4) , .
104
. , 142 b 3237; 143 a 10.

80

. , ,
.
, .
? ? , , , ,
,
, . , , ,
105. , ,
, -, ,
, ,
, .
3.
, 106. ,
, , 107. , , , ,
, , .
(245
105

,
, (. anon. Theol. arith. 57,
2158, 7; 32, 1112), . ,

.
106
Eunapius, Vit. soph. 363;
(Quaest. Hom. ad Il. 281, 2; . :
Schraeder, 347348).
107
, , II 726, 69;
; ;
(59, 1).

81

), ,
, 270 108. : 109 . ,
, ,
,
.
, ,
, ,
, , , .

, ,

, . , (Hultsch) , . , (to< ejpisthmoniko>n) , ,
, 110.
, ,
, ,
. , (279, 2022).
-
, ,
.

.
,
.
108

. Dillon (1973), 79; Larsen (1972), 3738; I. Hadot (1984, 257258;

, 56.
109
, ,
. . ., , ., 2002, . 434, . 2.
. .
110
Excerpta 277, 814.

82

,
(eijkazontev, oJmoiou~ntev) .
, , , , , 111. ,
. ,

, ?

, (2 . .), ,
, 112,
.
(33, 13 .; 36, 28 .; 40, 1
. 14 .), , .
. ,
.
, , ( ) . , ,
113, -
. ( )
.
4.
, . ,

111

29, 1922 (. Theon, Exp. 100, 46).

, 2728 ( , ).
113
; . , 50.
112

83

. ,
, 114. - .
115. . 116. ,
, 117. ,
, .

. , , ,
, 118. ,
. , . , . .
, , . , ,
119.
. ,
.

, , , 120 (ajpori>a), (110, 17). , , , :

, , 121.
. 122, ,
:
?
? () ? ()
?
? ?
, ? 123
,
. . , ,
, 124. , , ,
, .
, , .
(Op. sel. 57, 1724),
, , -

114

. (Beutler 1953), 278301 (

. ).

.
115
Eunapius, Vit. soph. 363; . Dillon (1973), 1011.
116
Stobaeus, Anth. III 579, 6580, 1.
117
Dillon (1973), 10, Saffrey (1971), ,
.
118
. Porphyry, Opuscula, 47; . A. Segonds Vit.
Pyth., 162197.
119
4647, 57, 2258, 20; . Segonds , 162168.

84

120

wJdi>nantev: (, Symp. 206 1).

. Wolff (), 4243; Bidez (1913), 17 . . O'Meara
(1959), 2931. ,
, , , .
122
Porphyry, Ep. ad An., Sodano, xviii.
123
22, 1123, 3 (= Iamblichus, De myst. 260, 410);
.
124
(De myst. 96, 510) ,
filoso>fwv ma~llon kai< logikw~v.
121

85

 125 , . , , :
, . , ,
, , , , , .
.

. (
) , . ( , , ), ,
,
.
, ,
() , : , .
,
.

, 126. ,
,
127. ,
, , .
,
, ,
. ,
, , -

. ,
, . :

, , ! 128 ( ,
(I 72) ). ,
129, , , , , IV ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
130.
,
, .
, , . , : (. 47, 58, 1219). (I . 29, 64),
(II . 36,102). , ,
, , ,
.
. (Drrie 1955)
, . ,
,
. ,
128

Orpheus (68, 1), Homer (78, 1516); 71, 17

(. 77, 22).
126
. , I 2529 ed. Bouffartigue et Patillon (:
?).
127
I . 15, 3, 55; . 18, 1 19, 1, 56.

I . 3032; 46. ,
,
(I . 48 .).
129
I . 36; (I . 15).
130
III , .

86

87

125

 ,
131: 132
133;
(23, 1 .); (7, 3235); , ,
, ,
, ,
134. , , ,
,
,
(14, 810). ,
. ,
,

135.
131

De abst. I . 2728; II . 4952, 114116; I 33; II 48

49 ed. Bouffartigue et Patillon ( ).
132
Vit. Plot. 2, 5 (
, De abst. IV, Opuscula 264, 20
.).
133
Vit. Plot. 8, 20 . ( prosoch> De abst. I . 39; I 3435 ed.
Bouffartigue et Pataillon).
134
Vit. Plot. 23, 201 (.
). ,
, , ,
, .
135
() , . , (Vit. Plot. 3, 2427). . L.
Brisson et al. (1982), 254256. ,
. (II
. X, 28 .) , (xx, 53). . (1984), 101136, ,
, .

, , .

88

H. G. Liddell, R. Scott, H. S. Jones, R. McKenzie, A Greek-English

Lexicon (Oxford, 1996), G. W. H. Lampe, A Patristic Greek Lexicon (Oxford, 1968) Lewis and Short, A Latin Dictionary (Oxford, 1987).

. . , .
,
.
CAG
DK
Dox. Gr.
LSJ
KRS
RE
SVF
TLG

Commentaria in Aristotelem Graeca, Berlin, 1870 ff

Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker, ed. H. Diels, W. Kranz,
Berlin, 19601961
H. Diels (ed.), Doxographi Graeci
Liddell H. G., Scott R., Jones H. S., McKenzie R. A GreekEnglish Lexicon. Oxford, 1996.
Kirk G. S., Raven J. E., Schofield M. The Presocratic Philosophers. Cambridge, 1983
Pauly, Wissowa, Kroll, Realencyclopdie der classischen
Altertumswissenschaft
Stoicorum veterum fragmenta, ed. H. von Arnim, Leipzig,
1905-24
Thesaurus Linguae Graecae,

.
. Solignac (1958), 124126, 129137, ,
.

89


1. ( )
, . .. -, ., 1988.
, 4- ., ., 197684.
: , , ,. ., . .
. . , ., 1970.
, , , . . . , ., 1986.
, 4- ., ., 199094.
, . . : ,
, , .
. . , ., 1986.
, 2- ., . . . , .,
1976.
. . 1: , . . . , .,
1989.
, . . . . , . 1998.
. 1: (1998). . 2(1): . (1999). . 2(2): . (2002).
, , . . . , ., 1995.
, , . .
.. . ., , 2002.
(-), . :
. . , : , . 2,
., 1988.
2. .

Anatolius, De decade, ed. J. L. Heiberg, Congrs international d'histoire
compare, Ve section, Paris 1900, 2741 (repr. Nendeln 1972), transl. P.
Tannery, 4257.
Excerpta, ed. F. Hultsch, Heronis Alexandrini geometricorum et stereometricorum reliquiae, Berlin 1864, 27680.
Anonymous Prolegomena to Platonic Philosophy, ed. L. G. Westerink, Amsterdam 1962.

90

Anonymous, [Iamblichi] Theologoumena arithmeticae, ed. V. de Falco,

Leipzig 1922.
Atticus, Fragments, ed., transl. E. des Places, Paris 1977.
Chaldaean Oracles, ed., transl. E. des Places, Paris 1971.
Domninus, Manual of Introductory Arithmetic, ed. J. Boissonade, Anecdota
graeca IV, Paris 1832 (repr. Hildesheim 1962), 413-29 (transl.: cf. Tannery [1906]).
Eunapius, Vitae Sophistarum, in Philostratus and Eunapius The Lives of the
Sophists, ed., transl. W. Wright, London 1922.
Eusebius, Historia ecclesiastica, ed. E. Schwartz, Leipzig 1908.
Hierocles, In Aureum Pythagoreorum carmen commentarius, ed. F. Khler,
Stuttgart 1974 (transl.: cf. Khler [1983]).
Iamblichus, De mysteriis, ed. G. Parthey, Berlin 1857 (repr. Amsterdam
1965) (transl.: des Places [1966]).
Fragments: Commentaries on Plato: cf. Dillon (1973); Commentaries
on Aristotle: cf. Larsen (1972); De anima: cf. Stobaeus; Letters: cf. Stobaeus.
On Pythagoreanism:
Book I. De Vita Pythagorica (= Vit. Pyth.), ed. L. Deubner (1937), repr.
Stuttgart 1975 (transl.: cf. von Albrecht [1963], Montoneri [1973]);
Book II. Protrepticus (= Pr.), ed. L. Pistelli (1888), repr. Stuttgart 1967
(transl. Schnberger [1984], des Places [1986]);
Book III. De communi mathematica scientia (= Comm.), ed. N. Festa
(1891), repr. Stuttgart 1975;
Book IV. In Nicomachi Arithmeticam introductionem (= In Nic.), ed. H.
Pistelli (1894), repr. Stuttgart 1975.
Lydus, De mensibus, ed. R. Wnsch, Leipzig 1898.
Marinus, Commentarius in Euclidis data, in Euclidis Opera omnia, ed. I.
Heiberg and H. Menge, vol. VI, Leipzig 1896.
Vita Procli, ed. J. Boissonade, Leipzig 1814, repr. Amsterdam 1966
(transl.: cf. Masullo [1985]).
Maximus of Tyre, Orationes (Philosophumena), ed. H. Hobein, Leipzig
1910.
Nicomachus, Introductio arithmetica, ed. R. Hoche, Leipzig 1866 (transl.:
cf. D'Ooge [1926], Bertier [1978]).
Manuale harmonicum, ed. K. von Jan, Musici scriptores graeci, Leipzig 1895, repr. Hildesheim 1962, 23765.
Numenius, Fragments, ed., transl. E. des Places, Paris 1973.
Philoponus, In Aristotelis Physica commentaria, ed. H. Vitelli (CAG XVI
XVII), Berlin 1888.
In De anima, ed. M. Hayduck (CAG XV), Berlin 1897.
91

 In Nicomachum, ed. R. Hoche, Program Wesel 18647.

Photius, Bibliotheca, ed., transl. R. Henry, Paris 195977.
Plotinus, Enneads, ed. P. Henry, H. R. Schwyzer, Bruxelles-Paris-Leiden
1951-73 (transl.: cf. Armstrong [1966 ff.]).
Plutarch, De procreatione animae, ed., transl. H. Cherniss, Plutarch's
Moralia XIII 1, Cambridge, Mass. 1976.
Porphyry, De abstinentia, ed., transl. J. Bouffartigue and M. Patillon, Paris
19779.
De philosophia ex oraculis haurienda, ed. G. Wolff, Berlin 1856, repr.
Hildesheim 1962.
Epistula ad Anebo, ed. A. R. Sodano, Porfirio Lettera ad Anebo,
Naples 1958.
Opuscula Selecta, ed. A. Nauck, Leipzig 1886, repr. Hildesheim 1963.
Quaestiones Homericae ad Iliadem, ed. H. Schraeder, Leipzig 18802.
Vie de Pythagore, Lettre Marcella, ed., transl. E. des Places, avec
Appendice d'A.-Ph. Segonds, Paris 1982.
Vita Plotini, edited at head of Plotinus' Enneads.
Proclus, Commentary on the First Alcibiades of Plato, ed. L. G. Westerink,
Amsterdam 1954 (transl.: cf. O'Neill [1965], Segonds [19856]).
Commentaria in Parmenidem, in Proclus, Opera inedita, ed. V. Cousin, Paris 1864 (transl.: cf. Morrow and Dillon [1987]).
(?) Commentary on the Pythagorean Golden Verses (Extracts made by
Ibn at-Tayyib), ed. transl. N. Linley, Buffalo 1984.
Institutio Physica, ed., transl. A. Ritzenfeld, Leipzig 1912.
Hypotyposis astronomicarum positionum, ed. C. Manitius, Leipzig
1909.
In Platonis Cratylum commentaria, ed. G. Pasquali, Leipzig 1908.
In Platonis Rempublicam, ed. W. Kroll, Leipzig 1899 (transl.: cf. Festugire [1970]).
In Platonis Timaeum, ed. E. Diehl, Leipzig 1903 (transl.: cf. Festugire
[19668]).
In Primum Euclidis Elementorum librum commentarii, ed. G. Friedlein, Leipzig 1873, repr. 1967 (transl.: cf. Morrow [1970]).
The Elements of Theology, ed., transl. E. R. Dodds, 2nd edn., Oxford
1963.
Thologie Platonicienne, ed., transl. H.-D. Saffrey and L. G. Westerink, Paris 1968 ff.
Tria opuscula (De providentia, libertate, malo) ed. H. Boese, Berlin
1960 (transl.: cf. Erler [1978], [1980]).
Michael Psellus, Philosophica minora, ed. J. M. Duffy, D. J. O'Meara, vol.
II, ed. D. J. O'Meara, Leipzig 1989.
92

Simplicius, In De anima, ed. M. Hayduck (CAG XI), Berlin 1882.

In De caelo, ed. I. Heiberg (CAG VII), Berlin 1894.
In Categorias, ed. C. Kalbfleisch (CAG VIII), Berlin 1907.
In Aristotelis Physicorum libros, ed. H. Diels (CAG IX-X), Berlin
1882-95.
Stobaeus, Anthologium, ed. C. Wachsmuth-O. Hense, Berlin 18841912.
Stoicorum veterum fragmenta, ed. H. von Arnim, Leipzig 1905-24, repr.
Stuttgart 1978.
Syrianus, In Hermogenem, ed. H. Rabe, Leipzig 1892.
In Metaphysica commentaria, ed. W. Kroll (CAG VI), Berlin 1902.
Themistius, In Aristotelis Physica Paraphrasis, ed. H. Schenke (CAG V 2),
Berlin 1900.
Theon, Progymnasmata, ed. L. Spengel, Rhetores graeci, vol. II, Leipzig
1854.
Theon of Smyrna , Expositio rerum mathematicarum ad legendum Platonem
utilium, ed. E. Hiller, Leipzig 1878 (transl.: cf. Dupuis [1892]).
Timaeus Locrus, De natura mundi et animae, ed. W. Marg, Leiden 1972.

--, . . (1959). :
, , ., .
, . (2003). . ., .
, . (2005). . ., .
, . . (2000), , ., .
, . . (1994). , . ., .
, .. (2002). . .,
.
, . . (1990). , , 3233, . 300324.
, . . (1990), (. 530 . 430 . . .),
., .
, . (1961). . ., .
, . (1968), , , .
, . . (1979), . , ., .
(2002): , . . , , . . , , . . , , . .,
, .

93

, .. (1998). . , ., .
, .. (2001). : . , .,
.
, . . (1997). , , .
, . . (2001). : . :
, , , . 1940.
, . . (2005). .
. , , .
, . (2005). , . . . . , .
, . (1998), : , ,
.
Armstrong, A. H. (1967). Ed., The Cambridge History of Later Greek and
Early Medieval Philosophy, Cambridge.
Aubenque, P. (1962). Le Probleme de l'tre chez Aristote, Paris.
Barnes, J. (1989). The Presocratic Philosophers, Routledge.
Bertier, J. (1978). Nicomaque de Grase Introduction arithmtique, Paris.
Beutler, R. (1953). 'Porphyrios', RE 22, 1, 275313.
Bidez, J. (1913). Vie de Porphyre, Ghent, repr. Hildesheim 1964.
Blumenthal, H. J. (1978). '529 and its sequel: What happened to the Academy', Byzantion 48, 36985.
(1981). 'Plotinus in Later Platonism', in Neoplatonism and Early Christian Thought, ed. H. J. Blumenthal and R. Markus, London, 21222.
Brisson, L., et al. (1982). Porphyre: la vie de Plotin, Paris.
Burkert, W. (1972). Lore and Science in Ancient Pythagoreanism, translated
by E. Minar, Cambridge, Mass.
Burkert, W. (1982). Craft versus sect: the problem of Orphics and Pythagoreans, Jewish and Christian Self-definition, ed. Ben Meyer and
P. Sanders, London, SCM Press.
(1961). 'Hellenistische Pseudopythagorica', Philologus 105, 1643, 226
46.
Burnet, J. (1930). Early Greek Philosophy, London, A & C Black Ltd.
Cherniss, H. (1944). Aristotles Criticism of Plato and the Academy, I, Baltimore.
Cherniss, H. (1976). Cf. Plutarch, De procreatione animae.
Cornford, F. M. (1935). Platos Theory of Knowledge, London.
Diels, H. (1901). Poetarum Philosophorum Fragmenta, Berlin.

Delatte, A. (1915). tudes sur la littrature pythagoricienne, Paris.

Dillon, J. M. (1973). Iamblichi Chalcidensis in Platonis dialogos commentariorum fragmenta, Leiden.
(1977). The Middle Platonists, London.
Drrie, H. (1955). 'Ammonios, der Lehrer Plotins', Hermes 83, 43977 =
Platonica minora 32449.
(1963). 'Der nachklassische Pythagoreismus', RE 24, 26877.
(1973a). 'Platons Reisen zu fernen Vlkern', Romanitas et Christianitas
(Festschrift J. H. Waszink), ed. W. den Boer et al., Amsterdam, 99118.
D'Ooge, M. L., et al. (1926). Nicomachus of Gerasa: Introduction to Arithmetic, New York. et al.
Festugire, A. J. (19504). La Rvlation d'Herms Trismgiste, Paris.
Freeman, K. (1948). Ancilla to the Presocratic Philosophers, Oxford.
Furley, D.J. (1967). Two Studies in the Greek Atomists, Princeton.
Furley, D. J. R., Allen, E. (1975). Studies in Presocratic Philosophy, London.
Guthrie, W. K. S. (1978). A History of Greek Philosophy, Cambridge.
Gersh, S. (1978). From Iamblichus to Eriugena, Leiden.
Hadot, I. (1984). Arts libraux et philosophie dans la pense antique, Paris.
Hadot, P. (1968). Porphyre et Victorinus, Paris.
(1987). 'Thologie, exgse, rvlation, criture, dans la philosophie
grecque', Les Rgles de l'interprtation, ed. M. Tardieu, Paris, 1334
Hgg, T. (1975). Photios als Vermittler antiker Literatur, Uppsala.
Harder R. (1926). Ocellus Lucanus, Berlin.
Heidel, W. A. The Pythagoreans and Greek Mathematics
Huffman, C. (1993). Philolaus of Croton: Pythagorean and Presocratic.
Cambridge.
Huffman, C. (2005). Archytas of Tarentum. Pythagorean, Philosopher and
Mathematician King. Cambridge.
Kahn, C. H. Pythagorean philosophy before Plato in The Presocratics, ed.
A. P. D. Mourelatos (Garden City, N.Y., 1974)
Krmer, H. J. (1964). Der Ursprung der Geistmetaphysik, Amsterdam.
Larsen, B. D. (1972). Jamblique de Chalcis. Exgte et philosophe, Aarhus.
Leemans, E. A. (1937). Studie over den wijsgeer Numenius van Apamea,
Brussels.
Levin, F. (1975). The Harmonics of Nicomachus and the Pythagorean Tradition, University Park, Pa.
Lewy, H. (1956). Chaldaean Oracles and Theurgy, Cairo; new edn. Paris
1978.
Lewis, M. (1971). Ecstatic Religion, Harmondsworth.

94

95

Makin, S. (1988). How can we find out what ancient philosophers said?
Phronesis 33, 121132.
Mansfeld, W. (1972). Timaeus Loerus: De natura mundi et animae, Leiden.
Mansfeld, J., Runia, D. (1996). Aetiana: The Method and Intellectual Context of a Doxographer. Vol. I (The Sources). Leiden.
Nussbaum, M. C. (1979). Eleatic Conventionalism and Philolaus on the
Conditions of Thought, HSCP 83.
O'Meara, D. J. (1975). Structures hirarchiques dans la pense de Plotin,
Leiden.
(1976). 'Being in Numenius and Plotinus', Phronesis 21, 1209.
OMeara, D. J. (1990). Pythagoras Revived. Mathematics and Philosophy in
Late Antiquity. Oxford.
O'Meara, J. (1959). Porphyry's Philosophy from Oracles in Augustine, Paris.
Oppermann, H. (1929). Review of Anonymous [Iamblichi] Theologoumena
arithmeticae, ed. de Falco, Gnomon 5, 54558.
Philip, J. A. (1966). Pythagoras and Early Pythagoreanism, Toronto.
Praechter, K. (1910). 'Richtungen und Schulen im Neuplatonismus', Genethliakon fr C. Robert, Berlin, 10556, = Kleine Schriften, 165216.
(1932) 'Syrianos', RE II, 8, 172875.
Puech, H.-C. (1934). 'Numnius d'Apame et les thologies orientales au
second sicle', Mlanges Bidez, Brussels, 74578.
Robbins, F. E. (1921). 'The Tradition of Greek Arithmology', Classical Philology 16, 97123.
Ross, W. D. (1924). Aristotles Metaphysics, Oxford.
Ross, W. D. (1951). Platos Theory of Ideas, Oxford.
Saffrey, H. D. (1971). 'Abamon, pseudonyme de Jamblique', Philomathes
(Festschrift P. Merlan), ed. R. Palmer, R. Hamerton-Kelly, The Hague,
22739.
(1984). 'La Thurgie comme phnomne culturel chez les
noplatoniciens (IVeVe sicles)', KOINNIA 8, 16171.
Sambursky, S. (1962). The Physical World of Late Antiquity, London.
Schwyzer, H.-R. (1983). Ammonius Sakkas der Lehrer Plotins, RheinischWestfalische Akad. der Wiss., Geisteswiss. Vortrge G 260.
Segonds, A. (19856). Ed., transl., Proclus sur le premier Alcibiade de
Platon, Paris.
(1987). 'Philosophie et astronomie chez Proclus', Proclus et son
influence, 15977.
Shaw, G. (1985). 'Theurgy: Rituals of Unification in the Neoplatonism of
Iamblichus', Traditio 41, 128.
Smith, A. (1974). Porphyry's Place in the Neoplatonic Tradition, The
Hague.
96

Solignac, A. (1958). 'Doxographies et manuels dans la formation

philosophique de saint Augustin', Recherches augustiniennes 1, 11348.
Sorabji, R. (1983). Time Creation and the Continuum. Theories in Antiquity
and the Early Middle Ages, London.
(1987). Ed., Philoponus and the Rejection of Aristotelian Science, London.
Staehle, K. (1931). Die Zahlenmystik bei Philon von Alexandria, Leipzig
and Berlin.
Steel, C. (1978). The Changing Self. A Study on the Soul in Later Neoplatonism: Iamblichus, Damascius and Priscianus, Brussels.
Szlezk, T. (1979). Platon und Aristoteles in der Nuslehre Plotins, Basle
and Stuttgart.
Tannery, P. (1885a). 'Sur l'Arithmtique Pythagoricienne', Mmoires
scientifiques II, 179201.
Tarn, L. (1974). 'Nicomachus of Gerasa', Dictionary of Scientific Biography 10, 11214.
Thesleff, H. (1961). An Introduction to the Pythagorean Writings of the Hellenistic Period, bo.
(1965). The Pythagorean Texts of the Hellenistic Period, bo.
Vogel, C. J. de (1966). Pythagoras and Early Pythagoreanism, Assen.
Vogel, C. J. de. (1970). Philosophia I, Assen.
Waszink, J. H. (1964). Studien zum Timaioskommentar des Calcidius I, Leiden.
(1966). 'Porphyrios und Numenios', Porphyre, VanduvresGeneva, 35
83.
West, M. L. (1983). The Orphic Poems, Oxford.
Whittaker, J. (1967). 'Moses Atticizing', Phoenix 21, 196201.
Wright, M. R. (1981). Empedocles: The Extant Fragments, New Haven.

,
.

10.10.2006.
60x84 1/16. .
. . . 6,8. . . . 5,7. 100 .
- ,
630090, -90, . , 2.
. 471