Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
50:122-132, 2010
ASET, Missouri
INTRODUCTION
Landau-Kleffner Syndrome (LKS). also known as Aphasia-Convulsion Syndrome
or Acquired Epileptiform Aphasia, is a rare childhood neurological disorder. LKS is
characterized by a sudden or gradual inability to understand or express language
Received: December 10. 2009. Accepted for publication: February 8. 2010.
722
LKS
123
(aphasia) and an abnormal EEG with myoclonus and brief absence-like attacks. LKS
affects Broca's area and Wernicke's area, which are the parts of ihe bruin that control
speech and comprehension respectively. The first manifestation of the language
problem is often word deafness or auditory verbal agnosia, including lack of recognition of familiar noises such as whistles, bells, barking of a dog. or a ringing phone.
The appearance of this syndrome occurs during a critical period of language acquisition. Speech production is affected just as badly as or even worse than language
comprehension.
WHO GETS LKS?
This rare syndrome usually occurs in children between the ages of 3 and 9 years.
with a mean age of 5 to 7 years. However, symptom onset has been described in
patients as young as 18 months and in those as old as 13 years. In LKS there is a
slight male predominance of an approximately 2:1 ratio and about 12% of patients
have a family history of epilepsy. The prevalence of LKS is I per 1000 children
(Chiolalo et al. 2003).
CLINICAL MANIFESTATIONS
The first manifestation is language deterioration which commonly occurs over
weeks or months, but acute onset after a seizure has also been described (Sotero
de Menezes 2007). Parents report that the child develops agnosia or word deafness
and the child no longer responds to commands, even with raised voices. Auditory
agnosia, or receptive dysfunction, is the dominant manifestation in the early stages of
this syndrome. Some parents or doctors assume at first that the child has lost his/her
hearing. The condition sometimes deteriorates until total unresponsiveness and
impaired speech or mutism is reached. Some patients first develop some type of
language disturbance prior to acquired aphasia. Verbal expression is marked by a
gradual increased in misarticulation. usage of wrong words, or the wrong combination of words and fluent jargon. The child may express himself with a sign language
system, gestures, or writing which may be relatively preserved.
The changes in the patient's speech with this syndrome may be due to disruptions
of the normal connections ora reaction of the speech area of the brain to the continuous epileptiform discharges. However, the severity of the aphasia does not always go
hand and hand with the degree of EEG abnormality (Sotero de Menezes 2007).
Some affected children have seizures and some do not: therefore, this syndrome
is also sometimes misdiagnosed as pervasive developmental disorder, hearing
impairment, learning disability, auditory/verba I processing disorder, attention dellcil
disorder, mental retardation, childhood schizophrenia, or emotional/behavioral
problems (NINDS 2008).
124
LKS
The child may develop neuropsychological symptoms and the child's intelligent
quotient (I.Q.) tnay be adversely affected. Hyperactivity and decreased attention
span are common in LKS. Behavioral disturbances are seen in as many as 78% of the
patients (Sotero de Menezes 2007). Although behavior patterns are secondary to the
language impairtiient. some patients may have complex, bizarre, and aggressive
behaviors which include hyperactivity, excitability, psychosis, and attention deftcit.
These conditions may become so severe that the child cannot function normally.
The aggression and rage tnay be so protninent that the parents may take the child to
a psychiatric service rather than a neurological service.
LKS
125
CAUSES of LKS
As is the case with matiy types of epilepsies and epileptic syndromes, the etiology
of LKS is still unknown. LKS may be as.sociated with underlying problems in
the speech area of the cerebral cortex, caused by subacuie bitemporal encephalitis,
congenital malformations, cysts, or brain tumors (Sotero de Menezes 2007). Other
etiologies include a genetic predisposition, toxoplasmosis. neurocysticercosis,
temporal astrocytoma. lempotal ganglioglioma, hemophilus influen/ac meningitis,
subacute sclerosing panencephalitis. inllammatory demyelinating disease, and
abnormal zinc metabolism (Pearl et al. 2001 ). There is a single report that depicts
LKS in a child wiih neurocysticercosis (Pellock et al. 2001 J.
126
LKS
FIG. 1. EEG of a 9-year-old female with history of language regression. EEG sample
shows generalized 2 Hz spike and wave activity during non-rapid eye movement
(non-REM) sleep; electrographic status epilepticus during sleep (ESES). Timebase = 1
second indicated by black thick horizontal line.
William Landau and Frank Kleffner (1957) were die first to suggest that a correlation
between paroxysmal discharges and language deterioration existed, and reported five
children with acquired aphasia associated with a convulsive di.sorder. These children
exhibited "normal acquisition of speech" followed by aphasia, seizures, and EEG
abtiormalities. Over 200 cases have been reported since 1957 (Pellock et al. 2001 ).
Childten who develop seiztires, usually develop generalized or focal motor seizures soon after speech is lost. Seizures can occur in approximately liWc of patients
but usually are infrequent (Pellock et al. 2001). After 10 years of age, only one fifth
of patients continue to have sporadic seizures; by 15 years of age. seizures rarely
persist (Pearl et al. 2001 ). Seizures generally disappear by adulthood.
Partial motor seizures oecur more often during the night. Less frequently the
seizures are generalized tonic-clonic seizures, atypical absence.s. or myoclonicastatic seizures. Cotnplex partial seizures with automatisms are not common. Some
children appear to have worsened language skills during the periods of increased
epileptiform activity.
LKS
127
FIG. 2. EEG of a 5-year-old boy with history of language regression. EEG sample shows
generalized 2 Hz spike and wave activity during non-rapid eye movement (non-REM)
sleep; electrographic status epilepticus during sleep (ESES). Sensitivity = 30 |jV/mm;
timebase = 1 second indicated by black thick horizontal line.
The EEG epileptiform activity varies. Some of the patterns seen arc bilaleral.
independent temporal or temporoparietal spikes; bilateral temporal I to 3 Hz slow
waves; generalized sharp nr slow wave discharges; and multifociil or unilateral
spikes. Background activity is generally normal. Epiteptifbrm activity is activated
mainly by sleep, especially sleep onset. Hyperventilation and pbotic stimulation are
seldom activators of epileptiform activity in LKS.
Since in about 85% of LKS patients the high voltage spike and wave activity
occurs during non-rapid eye movement (non-REM) sleep and decreases in intensity
during REM sleep, long-term EEG monitoring is often necessary to detect this
syndrome.
In the eariy stages of this syndrome, the high voltage epileptiform activity may
appear only when tbe patient is asleep. As the syndrome progresses, the epileptiform
activity may be seen sporadically in the waking state as spike and wave or multifocal
spikes in addition to the continuous spike-wave bursts during sleep.
128
LKS
FIG. 3. This is an EEG record of an 8-year-old female with partial seizures, epileptic aphasia, and language regression. EEG sample shows generalized spike and wave discharges
from 1 to 3 Hz during non-rapid eye movement (non-REM) sleep; electrographic status
epilepticus during sleep (ESES). Timebase = 1 second indicated by black thick horizontal
line.
LKS
129
both temporal lobes during the Interjetai state. HypermetaboHstn has been present
dttring the ictal pattern of continuous spike and wave of slow wave sleep. The hypometabolism in patients with LKS is more prominent in tbe area of the midtemporal
gyrus on the left side of the brain (Sotero de Mene/es 2007).
Magnetocncephalography (MEG) tneasures the tnagnetic variations produced by
the electric currents of the brain. The electrical generators produce a magnetic field
that goes in and out of the scalp around the axis of a vertical dipole. In 1991. Paetau
et ai. demonstrated that MEG shows a vertical dipole in patients with LKS located in
tbe superior surface of the temporal lobe that is two to three cm deep. This type of
dipole may not be detected by an EEG. MEG is not commonly used for LKS because
is not widely available and its high cost.
TREATMENT OPTIONS
Landau-Kleffner Syndrome is very rare and the prognosis varies. There have been
very few clinical trials to study the efficacy of various treatment options. The control
of the seizures is usually not difftcult because the seizures can be successfully treated
with antiepileptic medications. However, these drugs are not often effective against
the language disorder. An improvement in the EEG may not be accompanied by
a change in aphasia. Aphasia cotitinues into adulthood despite the contR)l oi the
seizures. Antiepileptic drugs that have proven effective in controlling the seizures are
latiiotrigine. levetiracetam. valproate. and dia/epain (Hwang et al. 200-'^). Coi1costeroids have also shown efficacy in the suppressioti of seizures, improving the EEG,
and improving language when used in the eariy stages of the syndrome. In a pharmacological study of five cases. Marescaux et al. (1990) observed that soine drugs
were ineffective and even aggravating. Carbamazepine and phenytoin appeated to
increase the duration of spike-wave activity in sleep and phnobarbital intensified the
behavioral problems in patients.
Another treattnent option involves surgery. Temporal lobectotny has been used
to improve language and seizure control. Eor patients who cannot safely undergo a
lobectomy. the alternative procedure is called multiple subpial transections (Morrell
et al. 1998). This involves multiple selective shallow cuts or transections into the
cerebral cortex with minimal injury to vertically oriented cortical columns. These
cuts are done to interrupt the pathways that connect neighboring parts of the brain.
The connecting fibers causing the abnortiial electrical brain activity are severed.
Aside from the possibility of bleeding, major complications are rare and the procedure is generally well-tolerated. Due to the rarity of this disease, the appropriate
timing for this procedure and it.s long-term ramifications are still unknown and being
studied.
After seizures are controlled by either antiepileptic tnedications or surgery.
the child may need special assistance with cotiimunication. Some techniques may
130
LKS
include, a one-to-one helper in the classroom to aid with understanding and presenting information, the use of sign language, color coding, visual cues, specialized
computer programs, and, most important, speech language therapy. Patients with
LKS may be able to read and write, therefore, these skills should be used for teaching
and cummunicating with the child whenever possible. The learning of sign language
not only aids in communication with the child, but diminishes anxiety and improves
social skills. The use of sign language does not prevent or delay the recovery of aphasia in patients with LKS. Due to the inability to understand or express language.
children experience frustration. This frustration may lead to disruptive behavior.
The introduction of effective communication and speech therapy can assist in alleviating such negative behavior. Speech therapy should be started early in order to
regain as much language ability as possible.
PROGNOSIS
The prognosis for children affected by LKS has several variables. Outcomes range
from complete recovery after several months or years to permanent severe language
impairment. However, some patients experience improvement with only residual
moderate language deficits. A relationship between the onset of the syndrome
and the ability to regain language has been observed. Since younger children have
not developed sufficient language skills, those four years of age and younger have
demonstrated worse outcomes in language ability. When the onset of LKS is after six
years of age and when speech therapy is started early, the prognosis is improved and
the result of the syndrome is less severe. But the speech and comprehension ability
may not return to normal levels for the age of the child. In some cases remission
and relapse may occur. The prognosis is also dependent on how severe the EEG
disturbances were, how long the epileptiform activity continued, and the location
of the abnormal activity. A long-term study of 11 patients with a mean follow up of
nine years, revealed complete language recovery in only 18.2% of cases and mental
retardation in 63.6% (Peari et al. 2001 ).
The indicators of a favorable prognosis are onset of symptoms after six years of
age and early speech therapy (Pellock et al. 2001 ).
CONCLUSION
Landau-Kleffner Syndrome, characterized by acquired aphasia and an abnormal
EEG pattern of focal or multifocal epileptic discharges during non-REM sleep, is
still considered a rare and idiopathic syndrome. Due to the variations in outcomes,
similarities with autism, manifestations, and progress of the disorder, this syndrome
is sometimes difficult to diagnose and treat. A positive outcome greatly depends
on how early LKS is recognized and treated, but unfortunately a large percent of
childien are left with language deficits.
LKS
131
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would like to thank Walt Banoczi, program director of Neurodiagnostic
Technology of Orange Coast College. Costa Mesa for his guidance, encouragement,
and support in the preparation of this article. His contributions to the field of
Neurodiagnostics and his dedication to the education of future technologists have
proveti to be key factors in the success of the profession.
I would like to extend a thank you to Conrad Szeliga at UCLA Medical Center
Neutophysiology Department for his contribution to this article.
REFERENCES
Arunkumur G. Kotagal P. Rothner D. Localization-related epilepsies. In: Pellock JM, Dodson WE.
Bourgeois B (Edilors). Pediatrit: Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Therapy: Second Editioti. Demos
Medic-al Ptiblishing: 2(){) I. p. 248-ii().
CastronovoV. Oldiini A. Noclurtial seizures. In: BtJikov N. Lee-ChiongTL (EditorsI. Fundamentals
of Sleep Techtiology. Lippincolt Williams & Wilkins: 21H)7. p. .^82-89.
Cliiol'alo N. David P. Breiiibauer C. Ferreira J. Polysomiiography irt the spoctrutn of acquired
epileptiform aphasia. Am J ElectroneurodiagrmsiiL- Teehnol 2lH).l: 43( 1 ): L^-17.
da Silva EA. Chtigani IX'. Mu/ik O, Chiigani HT, Liindaii KlelTner syndrome: tnetabolic
abttormalities iti temporal lohc are a common feature. J Child Netirol 12{8):489-95.
Dreifuss FE, Nord DR Jr. Classillcation of epilepsies in ehildhoud. In: Pellock JM. Dodsnn WE.
Bourgeois B (Editors). Pdiatrie Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Therapy: Second Edition. Demos
Medical Publishing: 2001. p. 77.
Fisch BJ. Fisch and Spehlmann's EEG Primer: Basic Principles of Digital and Analog EEG: Third
Edition. Elsevier; \^99. p. 279-80.
Galanopoulou AS. Vidaurre J. McVicar K. lallaban-Ciil K. Shinnur S, Tuchman R. Moshe
SL. Language and behavioral disturbances associated wilh epilepliform EEGs. Am J
EleclroneurodiagnosticTechnol 2002: 42(4): 181-209.
Glauser TA. Morila DA. Encephalopathic epilepsy alter infancy- In: Pellock JM. Dodson WE.
Bourgeois B (Editors). Pdiatrie Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Iherapy: Second Edition. Demos
Medical Ptihlishing; 200!. p. 212-1."^.
Greenfield IJ, Geyer JD. Carney PR. Reading EEGs: A Practical Approach. Lippincoti Williams &
Wilkins: 2(K)9. p. 110-M. 151-52.
Hirsh E. Valent; MP. Rudolf G. .SeegmullerC. de Saint Martin A. Macjtifi P, Wioland N. Mel/t.utz
MN. Marescaux C. Arzimanoglou A. Landau KlolVner syndrome is not an eponymie badge of
ignorance. Epilepsy Res :(HXi: 7()(Supp 1 ):S239-S247.
Hwang P. Otsburo H. Riviello JJ Jr. Hohnes Gt.. Age-speeific seizure disorders. In: Holmes GL.
Moshe SL. Jones HR Jr (Editors). Clinical Neurophysiology of Infancy. ChildhoiKl. and
Adolescence. Butlerworth-Heinemann; 2005, p. 24446. 261-66.
Landau WM. Kleffner ER. Syndrome of acquired aphasia with convulsive disorder in children.
Neurology 1957:7:523-30.
Marescaux C. Hirsh E. Finck S. Marquct P. Schlumberger E. Sellai F. Met/-Lul/ MN. Alemhik Y.
Salmon E. Franck G. Landau-Klelncr Syndrome: a pharmacological sttidy of live cases.
Epilepsia IWO; 3l(6):768-77.
Martin KM. Snead OC. ACTH and steroids. In: Pellock JM. Dodson WE. Bourgeois B (Editors).
Pdiatrie Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Therapy: Second Edition. Demos Medical Publishing; 2001.
p. 533-.34.
Mikati MA. Shatuseddine AN. Management of Landau-Kleffner syndmme. Paediatr Drugs 2005;
7(6): 3 77-89.
132
LKS
Morrell F. Whisler WW, Smith MC, Hoeppner TJ. de Toledo-Morrell L. Pierre-Louis SJ.
Kanner AM. Buelow JM. Rislanovic R. Bergeti D. Landau-Kleffner syndrome. Treatment wilh
subpial intracortical transaction. Brain 1993: 118:1529^6.
Mosli SL. Early intervention. In: Engel J Jr (Editor). Surgical Treatment of the Epilepsies: Second
Edition. Raven Press: 1993. p. 128-29,
Myer E, Morion LD. Selected disorders associated with epilepsy. In: Pellock JM. Dodson WE,
Bourgeois B (Editors). Pdiatrie Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Therapy: Second Edition. Demos
Medical Publishing: 2001. p, 269.
National Institute of Neurological Disorders and Stroke, NINDS Landau-Kleffner syndrome
infonnation page. Updated October 17. 20()X. On the Internet at: h[tp://www.ninds.nih,gov/
disorders/landaukletnersyndrome/lundaukleftnersyndrome.htm Accessed Oclober 2009.
Niedermeyer E. Ellen Grass Lecture: Epileptic syndromes: a remarkable citntribution of EEG to
epileptology. Am J EEG Technol 1992; 32( 1 ):3-25.
Niedenneyer E. Epileptic seizure disorders. In: Niedenneyer E, Lopes da Silva F (Editors). Electroencephiiiography: Basic Principles, Clinical Applications, and Related Fields: Fourth edition.
Lippincott. Williams & Wilkins: 1999. p. 534-35,
Nordi DR Jr. Pcdley TA. The use of EEG in the diagnosis of epilepsy in childhood. In: Pellock JM,
Dodson WE. Bt)urgeois B (Editors). Pdiatrie Epilepsy: Diagnosis and Therapy: Second
Edition- Demos Medical Ptiblishing: 2001. p. 125-26.
PaetLiu R. Kajnla M, Korkman M. Hmlinen M. Granstrm ML. Hari R. Landau-KlefFner
Syndrome: epileptic activity in the auditory conex. Neuroreport 1991: 2(4):2()l-04.
Pearl PL. Carranza EJ, Holmes GL. The Landau Kleffner syndrome. Epilepsy Curr 2001 November;
l(2):39-45 and on the Internet at www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC320814Accesses
October 28. 2009.
Sotero de Menezes M. Landau-Kleffner syndrome. March 20. 2(K)7 (updated February 5. 2010).
On the Internet al http://emedicine.medscape.eom/article/l 176568-overview Accessed October
17. 2009.
Tatum WO. Husain AM, Benbadis SR. Kaplan PW. Handbook of EEG Interpretation. Demos
Medical Publishing: 2()O8. p. 146-47.
Yamada T. Meng E. Practical Guide lor Clinical Neurophysiologic Testing: EEG. Lippincott
Williams & Wilkins; 2010, p. 166-67.201-02.