Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 127




     

    
 



         
  

  
 
    

  

    





   
     

  
  


!  


" !  


 

  

      


             


  
  
  
!
  


   
 "
 

 # $ "   $
   
 
 
%
 &
    

    
 '
  &" 
   '

   
     

  
  


!  


" !  


(  )  

 *
 
+  )'

  
 "
 *  
 
 +   ,   *  
 
+
    #-

"%   "
$ 
 
 
) ) 
"
$   

    !  "  !  

.        
      - $



*
 
+   

  
 

"

-
 "

! ) ) 

 

 




 /"

.  000

(       
'

,  * 1$1)
  
+

    !  "  !   #$


"  ) 
 $ "
 



    , 













$

*    

 

  


 " +2

   
 $ *     +





 /  
   
 " " 
    

 -
   
"


    
     

  
  
  

           
   
  



        
     



   


  0
0 0 $ " 
       
       $ 
 
" 
  
 

  

  
 
    

  

 -  
 

    !  "  !   #$



    
  
  

      



  
    
   
  


    



   



     

   


  0
3  
 )" ,


" $ )   "
 -  
  -
  

   -
4"   - 
 


 "
)   )

 
  -
 "
  )    

  
 "   "

 
   
     $  
 "   "
000

%  &   


3

.   
 
 
      $   
  
  



5 
"
 
"
--  
 
   
   


3 




 --

" 

$

    




    
 

  


 " 

 

 / 

$

-
"

! 

#$"     $"   


   "
  %

( , $ "   
   $

 6 "
 

'  ()*  ' 

 
   # 00 

  "
 %
   $    1
-  $

" 
  " 
   $ )      

 

    / - $"   #1 


%

00 71    
 "
 
  )  $
8"  "
  
" , 
  "
    1
-   $

9
 
 ! 1   
  
5  "
  .  -
  
$
-
"

 






 

 

  .    

  


1-

  

-
  /"


"   "  " 
    
      '
#  $ %
 , 
    :
000

'  ,   !  #',!$



  
   ) 

"
  )    
"
 

)   5  "
$   
5
 "
   5
  



"  8" 

"





 


)

$




$) 


 " 

 

    
  
 
    
)

   "




 
 


$ "
 "

   

     $ 
"
  $



#;%

  )


"
 -

  

1
0

1
0

1
0

11
00
1
0

1
0

1
0

1
0

11
00

11
00
1
0

 ',!  '  (


   
"
2    
"

 9  5   


 "   
   $    
  "
$   

3 



   )

 ! 6 00    


 
<  
   
 " )
   
 

$
 
 
6 5
 "
    
 
 
- 
$
  

1
0

1
0
1
0

1
1
0

1
0

1
0

2
1
0

  $
  


11
00

11
00

3
1
0

 

1
0

 ) ) -  
 " 6
    6$
  8"  
)  
 "   "
    

',! !  - .  /  - '( ! 



            
$
       
    


01 ( 


         

  

  
 $    9      

3







 

- 


  

)



  





    

3 

      
    9=
 "
 0   

    
 
- 
   )      ) - 
        

  






       
  " )   /  
 "
$

         -
   

#      

 
$ %

      


  " 
 
  *
 
+   

 "   
 
0 ( 
 '

 ',! #$
   $   "  9
  

  "
$   

 9   
 
 6

"
$  "     
) #
"% 

 6) ,

 

)
 $  
 
 . 

>)  )   $
)  9'

>)   
  
 
  1   "
 '

   


  '

(  )  , ) )   "'

2
. !
" 

.  "


   !1
!  
   
  

>

        
   
  

 
 
  

  

"



 

"
11 1


 
 



  

9

. 




:"

1$





  
9 1?


  




   .   3 
&-  


  -
 

 




)
  

    ) 

X4
X2
X6

X1

X3

3

/ 


 "

*
1$ +
  5 

    
     

X5

       
   

$ 
< 

         
           

 
 





  

  

!


  

  *
+  ) " 
 


  

x1

xi

x2

N
xN

      
-  -
  2 0 0    

   




   $)  
  
   $

 
- 

    



    





     


.

(
 
!-    
 #%  

 
   $ -
  

) 
 "

 

#)  

   
 " %

  "  
!-   $)
 < 



 


 -" 


 
 $
 
   





@ 
#""% 1  !         

 

 

8"
" 
 "

      

            

 1 

0 0       
   
 

      

 
 )
  
 

   $

3 
       5  

    
)

   




   


  

   0

    )






3  5     $ 


 "



   

 


%    

    $  
   
 " )

     
400




  


 

 

  

  
pdf of Beta(1,)
5

0
0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1


4(( ( !          

(   
 " $
 



                '

             


- 

 "  

  $  
     
<   

$      
  -
  


 
 $   "   $ 
   -
      
  
) 

   
 $  
 


400

$
 "

  

  




 8"   )

 

 



3    '(
 

 " 
  -
  )

      

 
 
           







 
 









)  



  0

0 0  
 " $





  



 )

  


$

  


)



   


  
 
 



3 %  '  (


 
- 
   "
 
 !  $

"
 $
  
 "

         


     $
  "
1 5 
   
 "

3    5  "


 

     
)

 

       





    


 
 
   )
) ,-

"    
 
<  $ $
  "
#$
 %






"  


 

  

$




"



 31 3 


400

$
&" "


  )  





   

  -
 


 

   

  &"



 31 3  #$


"
  !  "       
  $
 
  "
 


 "


  5     $    


  $
 



"
 

 "
   -    "  -
 

    










              
    



 31 3  #$


 
)  
   5  " 
   "


)



 





 

   

   5  
  $       $
  5  "
 
 $)0 

      

  
    
   



 8"   $  " 
 

    "   $



  





   

 "



 31 3  #$

xi





 

  
    


%   31 3 


       ! "  # "$  % &$
'( 

    

   
 


3  $ 

$

   

  1 5 2 00 )  "  /"


A -
 1 

 $
 &" "
 
 ,    





9   
 
   




 



      

   

  
  
 )  #""% "  ) " 
 
   $  "
         

  -        $   
 
 
2
 

  $   8"  
   

%   31 3  #$


G0

   
         


 
 



  
    

 

xi

  )   

5 
9


 "  #$

 

 A

 
 - 
 "  #$
$""

%

 ,

$"    2 

>) -
 -
  $    
 
- 

400 "    



  

)  &

 
0 &-

 ) ! ) ) 

   )  "


    
     

 
 " 1
    /" 
 
 "  $
  "
2

 /"  $

    



 

    !  %

0 0

$
 



# 

"  5 



3  '    31 3 


>)  


"

  "





1-


 


$ "
 '

  




 

 
. 

 




 


-


00

  

   


   
 
 



# 00 9 %    " . 

#     
  -
 %  

3


  


 

 

 

"
 


 


-

 
 
 .  
-



.( &   )4   !  "


    !   )   &$ '( 



 5  "    5  "
 



 *

 ! 

   +       )

  5     

  
             
 -
    "
   -
 
(   
 " $   -







  '

    < 

 5  
 " '


    " 
 "

  $  -
 '

 )    $ ) 
   

  

   $ 
*< +'
 )     * "
 +  '

3   
2  , 
   
   $
  :
   $ - )



4   !  " ) %  (


 * 
  +         ,$  
 5   5   8" $ . 
  -
  

    

     

    5   5   8" $   

  

3 





- )  






  !   

!  : 
  $   !

2 (11)

...



 %  ( #$


( ) -    $
" $
 

(     














 )









    

 




  





"

             

      




   



 

     

 

"



  

     5   
   "



.   3  ,  


G0

k
k
0

xi



6 %  (


 )  

@ 
 

  5  $  -
 
  
   ) 



        -
    

 )   )   /  "  


- $

&
  )
   8"

 $)


) 
 " $
 
  

 

) -
 ) "  
-    

 

3



 


 !1

 


)

 

# 8" %

   

   )   

    !1
!  
 "

$





  
 





 !1
! 


 "

 



#)  
-   *

  5 

$  -
 +
$

   - %



  5 
( ) -  ) 1 5   $  


   "
2 )  "
 


   "
'

0 0 " 

   '


" 

   

  2

) 

  
 "
$ - 


"

  2

 

 

 
 )

$ 
 "
 $
 
   "
'

(

 "



         


 
)


   '

 





  

 "

  
  " #    %'

 )
   ")
    

"  
 
 000

   ! 
  
 
    

  -
   
 5   $"  
)
   




-  
    
   
  -
  
  -



    "  $"        $  "


  
   
 
-   " $  
 -    



   / 

.  ! 
"  ) )    
 "   $"  

&" 
   
-  )   

  
 #$
$"  

 %

 $  &" 


 " $
 5  1   
 " 2 0 0
$
  5    $ -" 



    )  !     5      )   

#"  -
 $"  %

7
-,  
      "         $"

)    
 "  $"  6 &" 
 


 )    
 "    "
000

    ! 
  "
  $"  $
 "      -


3 5  1   


 "  )

 5   5     $

"  
 "    

 

(   "
  6
       ) ) 
   

 
   
 "   )    - 



    ! 
    

  
       
  

          
  
  
  
   

   

  
  
#     

 
 !      !   # 
  
 !       !  

     
   
 
#  

 !       ! 



   !       ! 

#B%

 
   $     

  
 
 
 
   
  
      
    
   
 


A5

A2

A3

A1
A4



 !       ! 
"  ) 
$


0

$
  
   
     

(   


 '


 5  
 )     
 
   " #$
  
  

   
 

  2    $
 
%

  
" $
-     
"    

  
   
   )  
   

  "

  ) - #$
 
$  00  
- ;CCD%

    $    

   

"  

          $  





 


,     %  (


    $
" $
   $  
  
  -
  $

   

!  # ) - 




 !    ! 

% !        & 
  !
 

 
 " 8" -"  $   )
  '  
)
   "
$
  $     8"        
)

 

"    



 
   "   
 

  $  

 #);%

  5  " $  $
  
  

 "


 



 



 5  $  
   
 '

    !1
! 
   "
E
 
 
"   
  
- 2  $) $
   
 $ 
 "  
   
 " # "
 ;CCF%



%  31 3 


 "
    
  



  
 
   ) 



0 0 ,   
- 

( "  
   
    "  

 
  

     

  
"    ! 

/"   5  "
 

3      ! )   


   
  "
 



    !  31 3 
G0

xi

  $ 
    
    
    "        


3 ( ! 


3    
  
   $  
 

  
 "

G0

     

)  

G0

xi
xi



3 ( ! 

 #$
   $
"

%

 

!          & 



 !     !
 

      8"   $ 


  
   $  
- 



 0

3 $
"   

  

  

   
  
   $  
-   )

0

 - 

 0

 

  

3  /"  9=
 "
   E

0 0   
  -

   "

)

  $ 

 

 9=
 "



5       !  31


     
"
  
  
"
 
     !1
! 

 
1
 



   $

     !1
! 

 

3'3'      !  31
  
$  + !
 % &$  . '(  . 
#/  

7   

    



400    
"
  

)
" "

   

       $  


"
'
 ) "

   "
 

-

#  % 
 
)

."

       ) ) "

)  5  "
2

 /  
     -
   "  )



'  .

(

    

         #      %
 

 /"   
"
    
 !   /"  "" "
! 
    
$
)
 $
" $
    $
&

  

#   /"  %

$ 
 
 
  
 $
    

  
 
- 
          $ 
        

3 )  -
   


 "  
    
 




4 " 3'3' 4(  


  &

  , ) $  

  /"  $
  &

)   "  -          

 
1>  # %

&

   ) "


 
 
 # 4 
G H
"
2  %

1
 
 #&
G  
 2 I G  %
) 
" $    -
 1  /" 



       ! 
 #/   &$ .
 )

3
"    !1
! 

 



 5   -"

    



3  

   $
 #    



 ! )  



 

  

  


  
 
" 




" $

) 
 "  $ 
  $
  9   $


 (   #   

  , - 

-
 
      




.

(
    ! #%  .

$
 $  
!-  



   

        

$


      




      #   
$

$

$


  



   

$  $ )





 

 
     



      #   

$
  




  5 
    " $
#  15 % -
   $


&-   
    

  

  
 
 

 $

% $




 5  < 
  

  
@

%

' &

%   

 
   
 
  $

     $  


  -

$

 
  

#0 0   $  %



  5   ! 31


 .  0112

3




 "   
"    !1
! 

  #  




"  %


   $
8"  $
  /" 9 "
   
$

$

)

 
 
    

(    

(   



$ 
' 
' 
 



) 

$ '  
-
  
 
   )


)  * %  +&   * %    +&  * %,&   * % ,&


01  !.  31

 

 

; 


D #  % 


)$ ((3 (4   4

5 4   /  

6   / $ $ )$   711 (   

5  # 

+ 3   $ 83   4 

10

20

30

40

50

10

20

30

40

50

Dimension

Dimension

 / 

400
1200

200
5

 

800

500

700

1000

Heldout log likelihood

VDP
CDP
TDP

300

Time in seconds

1500 2200 3200 4700

01  !.  31

/ * 4   (      / 4 
9+ $ )+ #

*+ #5

 (

    

)+   $ ( #

 (

"$ 4 $:   $ / $

(   (4   

%  5  

! 7;;0

3 

$
 "
$   

   #
 % 

2

" !


   $  
 

   
 -

-   
 !

  ! #;CJF% )  

    

 
  




 )
 
 $ 


  




)
-    



  -    
  

 

 $"  0

%  5  

#$

! 7;;0

3  

       

  



  

)    
  
   " 
/    --  
$

   
 " ,  /"    $

  
"
 


 

    -
  #   

 
 "

 
%

   

  
 "

3       $


&

  



0  %      !  31

 6  .  0112

" .   )      


 -


 
 $

 
"   
 "  ) 
1

 

 ) ,-    , 
   $

,








 


" )  "

 

$



'
)



 

  , -
   6 "     
 
<  "   $

 "    
$   
 
  

3


-







 

) 

#""%

  

5 





 
  -"   <  #
 % ! 
 " !
     
" )  ,  
-  $






) "   $


 2

"    !
   
  

 " 
  ! 



4
>   

  
     ) " ! ) "
 $  

5   
!-  



* 3 (


 

3


 
 
!
    


 

   60 0   $    




"  $  $
$ )

  " " 

 

    $ " 

 
 $ 
!
 #$
   -"%

&-    $    #"  -"%

{A, a}
{B, b}
{C, c}

  " 
 

 

3   "
  
  



* 3 ( #$


A

{A, a}
{B, b}
{C, c}

3     "
-
 "  

 / 



 0  0 /  0  0

#"  >
1( 
 8"
"%

         "
   
  

." )   
  $

'


   
  "
  
 "



!%  * 3 


<  ,$  .  011=

  
"
 

          ) 
" 
   # 
 $  "-  
 " %


- 
$
 $      $ &
    #BKKB%

+





7@

17A2

1=A1

7?

1711

7=
7@



 $

7?
7
02
B

>,









17=7

17B=

1==1

17@1

1021

17?1

1011

1=21

17A1

17@2

1@2@

1772

1070

12AA

1070

1712

10BA

11??

17=2

1===

11;0



    


 



*    %  3 (


 *

+ #  .    $  
%        ) 

 
 

  
  -
  
 
-   )  
 

  

"
 
 
-   )   !
  8"  

9
    6  $
   8"  $ 

     #
)% 
$   
   
"  $
!   .  
 

3 

  
$      $"  
 
 $   

 
 "
*+



$

8"   

 -

)

 

"


  #  $   %
 

. 

  ,

"

$




  

$

1

-" #
 "
 $ ",
$
  $
8" 1 -" %

3 /  ( ! 
 
( $ $ "
   
  
   #*
 $
 
 +%

400 " &"   

    1

x2 j

x1j

" ! 

) 



xmj



  

" !  $   , )


! -
 ) 
)   *
  
+ #0 0 *+%

*    %  4 


3 .  "   - )  
 

  $
  " 
  -
 




  -
  

x2 j

x1j

&-  -
   .   $
 
  $
 



xmj


 6 


    $
  $  
" )" 

"       
"

*    3 (


     

xij

48"-  

x1j

x2 j

xmj



3 '  ( ! 


 
(  "    )  ) - "
  "
  
  '
)  
' )  
'

"
 

(  


     





            

z1j

z 2j

z mj

x1j

x 2j

xmj

' '

( $ )  , ! ) 

'

  
 
 .  
      " 8"  000



4 &    4  )4    


  
   
   $
  
"  ! 

  " 
 



G0

Gi

ij

xij

9
     
 

 
   "


0 0     
" )



)

 

  $
     


"6  
  $ "
E

      )


! )    
 
    $ #   %
   
 
   000 1#



*        ! 
)$ .    011=

(   - 
"    

  "






L    
 



*        ! 
)$ .    011=

(   - 
"    

3 5  

3

  



 $

  "






L    
 


 "   
    9

  $ 2 

$

$2 

    

$



  "
 #
 %  
 " 6  $



)

 $
   

0 0 /"    
 -  $  .  

E



*        !  31
H

G0

Gi

ij

x ij

  

 

  

 






   



 %  ( ,  


 

  $ 





 

























 




   











 

 
 



'  ,     #', $



   
 " 

    
 " 
H

G0
H

Gi

ij

ij
x ij
x ij

'  ,     #', $


14 18
13
11 11= 1

16
15
12 12= 2

17

13= 1

22
21 21= 3

26
24
23 22= 1

25

23= 3

3536
32
31 31= 1

34
33 32= 2

3   
" 


  
$

 

28
27 24= 1

 

)  " "   "

  
"
 

3
   



)  " "   "


$




   "

3 5
 "
         $
   $
   
 "
  $
  : 6 "
 
$
      )   

"


  
$
     


   

"


 *!  !
>9 
    $  

 $
 )
!

    !1
! 

  $  
   
 








 

3 >9  5     $ 
"    

 

  )   !  

 -
 
 
"








 

3     
   -

"    ) 
  $
"
 #,  )   $  >9%

        ! 

$  0111


 #  )  
 
  "
   % )
" )

   !           -


 



"

4- 

 
, 
 

  "
 -    5    
 6)       !         
-
  

 
$

)

0 0  








    ""

 


  
 

 

5    !  



      



 
   
   #0 0        $
 
-
  %

(      $ 9  -


    $"  $  -




01
 9 # 4 
7   & $  BKK;%
    !  
  





  &" 
     

 9 #




 H
"
  
BKKF%

!   -    5
  :  4
$

         4  '


    !   
 
$ 




 

)1)

 

" 1)

 !

$

 

'

 
 



 "     $    



     3 
  $  
$  7;;?
$($55   #/  7;;B

* 
 
 + 

$
    $     "

 


 
       
 
  

$   
    $
 "  
 
  6
 
 
    


  



    *
/   "+   $
8"    



  
  "   .    

           #) ,


 
   
   
6 
 
6  )   5   ) -
 " ! )
"

 "   " )  ) ! $ ) " %


  


  

" $"



 
 


 

 
 
  



01  !  , ( 


*     0110

"  )  ,
 
"  9   # 00 -
1
 %
   9 )  9 )  9

  "


$ 
 
 
 $    


5 

 5

0  
0  
    



      -  $ 
-
     -  

         5   

  #   
%   0   0 
 ! $"  
3  $  $
 #$ %  

$
 
 
  # : 
$  
 %2  
 "   
" 
 

)

  -
 #"  
 %








/      4 #/4$ 3 


 % .  011@

! 
  



  -
  6
  

     


  -
  
  "  

     

 
  -
  
 )
 

    

   
 
 

  $ 
    "  -
  ) 
"
  $ "   -
  )  " 



   1
4  

$    

   
- 



topic


 6

  $ 

000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
topic 1
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
11
00
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
00
11
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
topic simplex
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x 111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
word simplex
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x 111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x 111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
x
x111111111111111111111
x
000000000000000000000
x
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
21
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
0
0
1
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
0
1
0
1
000000000000000000000
111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
0
1
0
1
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
topic 3
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111
00000000000000000000000000000
11111111111111111111111111111

  
     
  "             6 "  
 "
-
 

 
"       
   
 "    



 &
   /4
    $  -  !   "
$   -  $

$       2  ) " 9   '

 

   *"
 +6 "
  
 ,    

 
 " 

"

 
)
 )   " 

0 0    "    ) "


  
  
) -


 

"
  
  6 
 " 

) )    $
   "   
 $
 
 " 

3      " $


 

  
   
 

0 0  >9 -   
   $    "
$   $

#    
 %

 (  *     4 / " 


3 >9 $
 !    $
 


 "
$  -  $ 




    - 
 $
 
 

  "
   
"  

  "
  

3  
   8" " $"
00  ) 

" 

 #)   
 $
   
 "      

%
00  
!-   ) "  !


&5! '  4  #7899:;;7$



   $
   $

-      

""
"
#$
#%
&
%$
$
'(
)$


   
 "

  
 -  
 
   -
   
"
 
  
  
 
   

-

  
  

     "
  #-
)
   -  "
%
 >9  "    -
  
"
 #* +%   
  
)    
)   
       

3 

   
" ) $ "     #%    


    

*+
*, +
*

 +

 

  
 >9 $
   
   >9 $
   
  !    $ >9

G0

G0

G0

G1

G2

Gj

Gj

Gj

Gj

Gj

Gj

Gj

Gj

ji

ji

ji

ji

ji

ji

ji

ji

xji

xji
nj

VS Training
documents

xji
nj

VS Test
documents

*+

xji
nj

Additional training
documents

VS Training
documents

*, +

xji

xji

xji
nj

nj
VS Test
documents

nj
Additional training
documents

xji
nj

VS Training
documents

nj
VS Test
documents

*

 +


, 
Average perplexity over NIPS sections of 3 models
6000
5500

Relationship to LT, AA, and AP


5000

none, no other section


flat, additional section
hierarchical, additional section

LT
AA
AP

4500

Perplexity

Perplexity

5000
4500
4000

4000

3500

3500
3000
3000
2500
0

 $

20
40
60
Number of VS training documents

80

2500
0

20
40
60
Number of VS training documents

80

-
 
  $     "  - 
    " 

$
     
  $
M :
  0

"
-  ) 

-
  -
 
     
D
" 0



-
 
  $     "  - 3    9

 " 
 -  "  >9   -
  -
D
" 0

   
3  


)     
  

 )   
     
 





3




  
 
 
 
  

 
 



  
  

  
 
 


 
 
   


 
 
 


 

 
 


 
 
 

" 

  
  
  
 $ 
 
  
 
  

  

  
 
 
 
  
 "



 
" 
#


   
 
 
 
  

 

 
 
  # 
  # 
 
 
 
 

9

9



 
 
 
  

!


 

  
 

  
 
"
 

!

 

 
  
# 

  
 
 



  
 

 
 
 
  

 
  
 
%!



 
 
  

 
  
 


 "

"
 


 
 
# 
  
"
  
 
 
#  
" 


  
#
 
 

 

 
 

*  3 " 3 


z1

z2

zT

x1

x2

xT

3  
!-  6   -
  $  "
 
 
) $  
  
     $ "

1 1   
  

  $
  $   

3 * 5   
!-  + #>%6 > )  " "  
"
$   #.  &
  " BKKB%

*        !  *33
  
$
)
  
 "     6   
 "

>6)  >9 $
 )
!

 > 

- )      $ "
 6 "
  $

  -" $  * "

  +

(  )  
   >9  
 *
+  )   
 $  "

  
  
    2   

   
"
 

z0

z1

z2

zT

x1

x2

xT

4   


Perplexity on test sentences of Alice
45
ML
MAP
VB
VBm

40

Perplexity

35
30
25
20
15
10
5
0

10
15
20
Number of hidden states

25

30

9
  $      ! $
  ) 

,

"

 - 

*     3 


3   "    
*L+6    $   
- 
   " 

 

     
 <      
#>$ BKKK%
   )
 *

 +  

  "    .   

...

...

...

...

',!%  *     3 


   011=

...

...

...

...

4     
   
"
 

4     -

"
       
 "  )
 #
* +% 
) $
  


        -
"
       " 

 

)  
-     $"


"
    $"

 
)  $

 <     
  )     

31 4 !    *   
True dataset hierarchy

Posterior mode

68

19

18

75

68

19

18

100

67

55

67

11

10

22

27 4

27

26

27

14 11 1

55

35

27 4

27

26

27

14 11 1

100

100

100

54

15

16

12

10

89

11

10

68

67

16

89

16

83

67

10

22

16

17

89

89

50

38

35

69

33

33

21

35

23

16

16

35

35

57

50

39

38

100

100

22

61

100

16

100

39

100

57

16

100

61

12

100

19

16

100

19

67

100

100

45

100

52

83

100

45

68

22

100

54

22

100

35

100

22

Posterior mode

100

100

100

75

True dataset hierarchy

69

33

33

22

21

 *     

 


response ; stimulus ; reinforcement


speech ; reading ; words
action ; social ; self
group ; iq ; intelligence

a ; model ; memory

hippocampus ; growth ; hippocampal


numerals ; catastrophe ; stream
rod ; categorizer ; child

sex ; emotions ; gender


reasoning ; attitude ; consistency

self ; social ; psychology

the ; of ; a

genetic ; scenario ; adaptations

color ; image ; monocular

motion ; visual ; binocular

conditioning ; stress ; behavioral

drug ; food ; brain

 *     



spanning ; heap ; structure


regular ; language ; expression
distance ; s ; points
colors ; dgr ; coloring
the ; of ; a
pages ; hierarchical ; page
building ; block ; which
classification ; metric ; allocation
set ; optimal ; structure

n ; algorithm ; time

quantum ; part ; classical


graphs ; planar ; inference
learning ; learnable ; c
data ; access ; overhead

queries ; classes ; complexity

abstract ; program ; theory


sets ; magic ; predicates

programs ; language ; rules

routing ; adaptive ; routers


closed ; queuing ; asymptotic
traffic ; latency ; total
balancing ; load ; locations
inference ; task ; optimization
class ; have ; property

networks ; network ; routing

online ; task ; decision


availability ; data ; contention
methods ; parsing ; retrieval
circuit ; cache ; verification

system ; model ; performance

zeroknowledge ; argument ; round


that ; time ; problems

proof ; np ; question

nodes ; binary ; average

trees ; tree ; search

shared ; waitfree ; objects


channel ; transmission ; cost
networks ; processors ; those
more ; trees ; derived

n ; processors ; protocol

database ; dependencies ; boolean


recursion ; query ; optimal
subclass ; satisfiability ; by

constraints ; constraint ; algebra

m ; parallel ; d
show ; oblivious ; protection
studied ; makes ; the

n ; log ; functions

temporal ; logic ; exponential


known ; large ; very
compilation ; queries ; online

logic ; knowledge ; systems

automaton ; states ; global

automata ; lower ; bounded

the ; of ; a

! 
  
 

 ! 
    

&-   


$

 

4

    8" $ "   
 

  5    5  
 )     
"   $

    -  $  
 5 -
  



! 46    


  - 0


  "  

- 4  5 
 - 

)

-  -

  -







       

 !  #$
@ 

"
     
 "
! )  

  


 

  5  
 

   
 "    $ 
 "   



"    

   
   
 
 
"    

  $
   
 $ 

(





 $


 "   $




   
   
    $ $

  2   

(

 
   
   $
)
   -
  8" $


 


 $

   
 
 2

      

-  !    "    "" )


  "  "

&   ,(  ! 


+     >C !


    

 

$"   

# 00

"
--


  
 " $" 
$ $
-

-
  

+

 "

( "
(

 

"

 %

8"

 

  








 "

    
 #3%


     
 

"  

   "

 3 :

       "



   +  + +    

 %  "

&





+ 

  =
- 
 

 3 

 "   3 


4  . 1  
  $
)   
<  "
   ! )

! 
   4 
   , $ !

    $ $

    ) 
 

-

 

    -
  1
 

! 4

    

 
 " $  -
  
:


! 4






!

 
   
   
   


6  

9

" 

  


$

 
   #     $

" 9 

 "  

 "    "" )
  "  "

 
 " 1
   "  "  

# 

  9 

 " %

N"  


 
-  )   
-  

 

) 

 " 
  8"  

    <  
% 0117


   "
   $
 
 

&-   

   
 

 5  .
)  

  
-         

" - .
)  



*

 



 $)    

"

 

:  
    <
 $" 
) 

-    
-"

   

     

  

) 
   

    "
$   - 
-"
    

  #"
1!

-
%

 <
 $"    -
  

    "
$  
- $)    #  " %

9
 "
  $ <
 $"       1
  "


.    %  ( ! 
 &$ . 0117

     !1


!   
"  

  

    

( 
      ) "  

  5   $ 



-
  

400 


. 

$+

   5 

        

     

  ! ) $


 
 -"  $   !       

-" 2      


  
"
  
 
< $ 
    - 

3  #BKKD%    
  $  
    
"  
 "   

"
 
  

 
 


  5 


I" )
  ) 
   
 "    "
   . 
 !
 ,  
     $

 ,

 

  2 
1$ 
     

"" 
 

   ) $   


 
 )
    



)

-


  # 00  %

"   " )   



  ! 

  , $    
 
 )
 )
.   $
 

8" )
 

, 
    

  !  )   *8" )
  +  
    $
  

   ! $
8"  -"

'   
 +    +   #$ #$$ "$ #$ 4 
9 !  '$

   

 
   
 $  
" " 
 
 
 
 
 "   "
$        5 '
  
    - $
 
   
 
00  
   
  )  " 

  "
   &"

    #     )     $


8"    %

 -
" $
 ) !  
2 -
" $
>  

  7"  !1  

  1- 
 #.  -0 >
-<13 
%

'   
*@ $
"    1   
   


   $  



 
2     

 )    
)
"   " - 0 3  ) "
  "      ) )
-        " $ .   
 
   8" +
#   G 
 ;COP%0

' 
.      
 
 

5  1  


  

 "   "
   "



 !



)
!

)


 "




#" -  % " "    5  1   


,  "  /" )
 " 
      "

3
      
 
"
   
  2
  
"
E

 
   

 " .   


 
  )
!



*.   
 
  )
!+   &
 

 $"  )   9 .   


 
  )
!

)  "    


  



    !

/


AA)))0 0
!  0 "A

,  
  + 7;A2 3$  5    ( &

   
   * 

   
   

( 7D7;A ,(   

7;B=

 ( ( 

3  / +$ ( $ ((   5

     

0 ?E7720D77B=


 . #$$  '   "   * 

0110 )$  8  $


4

 & +$ ) #  ,   #$$  ' 

 
! "  

    

4  7= ( 2BBD2A= * 



&) 

5 +    *$   "

7;B;

( 4 3  / +$ (

( 5  / 

     

 

BE22AD2?A

 +  
   .  7;B@      4 F
5  $

     

7E@2@D@22

 +
   . 
 & 0112 9   /  / +$ ( 3 

# "   "

7 7E707D7==


 +
 %  G   . 
 & 011@   +$  

% & ' ! ( &

$   

@E;;@D7100

 +
 #$ ) . 
 &   )    .

011= >$ (

   $  *$     ( & )$  , ,     ,$(/
 

      


!

4  7? * 


E
&)



   "   & $ . #

011@

 /        44 

   .

 5 ( C  $$

#  

2;E007D00A

7;;2 5    $   $ $4 5

  

$    )     

=E@@2D@=A

 $ *  
$  , % 7;;?  :( 5  /  
  

#  * 

A@E7B2D7A2

* *     #

#  * 

0110

,(  /   

A; 0E0?2D0A7


*/ +   "HH   7;BA     (   H  


  I
 (H  (   4 )$  (   & 

   H JK 4I


  ) 
+ &

    "  # 
   

011=

 %L9  / (  

$    &          

+       +

     

7;A?

L     5  /  

7=E?ADAB

+       + 7;A?  L $   5 /

  

;; =?2E012D072

5 

  

7=E7D?B

+       + 7;;@ % (

   
+  
  

 5 5  

 

07E071AD07@B
7;B=

)/       (     $ (

  
  "

0E7A@D017

+ > 7;A2 5  (  / $    E *( 
/ $ 

     

7@E7=@0D7===


+ >

7;;=

5  (  /  (  4  4

   ( 

     

00 =E7B?@D7BA?

 
 + 7;;=      $  +$ ( (

&          


 
 +   !

3 

A;E0?AD0BB

7;;2

5  5     /   

$    &          

;1E2BBD2AA

  ! 7;B0 )$ (  $5 / 4   

#!"

$   

+&   
) 

@EABD770

   .

  

7;?=

5(

$4 / 5 

   % &  

@2EA=?DA2?

   ) , 7;B@  5  5 /   ( ( 

  

7E01;D0@1

   ) ,

  

  

7;B=      ( / (  5  

  

0E?72D?0;


   ) , 7;A@ 5  5 

5 3  /    

(      

% GE 

  +  >  ,    ,      # 

0110 " 5H 

& "H4 >   "  . 




 

  M(      4 $  $(   

 #      

01E=0@D==1

  + 7;?@ L $ 5(

   % &     


#/       

$4 / 5   $  

@=E7@A?D7=1@

0110  (   (($ / /   (

5  /   +$ ( 3  

- )&    

$  

$    , )   

77E0A;D@12

#/       


$  , % 0112 5  ( (
  $ +$ ( 3 

$    &          

711E7107D71@2
#$ , #$$ .    "$ " 9 7;;;    5 / +$
3    5  

     

0BE7=@D72A

#$ ,   4  9 

0117  (    /  4  / 5

  3  $  / 3  /   

     

0;E70@@D70?@
#     "$  ,
+$ (

0117

  $ 5 $   $  $

    $      

#   > * *   ! , #


/   /  +$ (

011@

/    44 

$    , )    - )&    

>C % 7;;1 % ( 5 


/ $5 

0AE@22D@BB

     

 

 (   /

7AE702;D70;=

&$  >   .  011@ # H $ *$     ( /
( (  3  

    

&$  >   .   0117 #

7@E7077D70@2

 (  $ / :   (

$    &          

;? =2@E7?7D7B@

&$  >   .   0110 ((3 +$ ( (    8 


 3 E ,$    (  / 

  

$    , )    - )& 

77E21AD2@0


&$  >   .   011= *(   $ /  (4   5
   $  (E (  $H  (  (

$    &          

  (    

;;E7B2D7;1

&$  >   '( 


 0111
4 $ 
  *  ((3 +$
 

 :( ( $$ 

&$  >   '( 




    

#  * 

ABE@B7D@;1

0110 +$ ( 4  8   3 

70E;=7D;?@

&$  >   '( 



$ +$ (

0110  3   ((3  :(   /

,    $      

.  ,   % "

011=

@1E0?;D0A@

 (:
4 $
  * (  /

$ +$ ( 3  

$    , )    - )&    

7@ 7E72AD7A0
   .  * 7;B= "     

 "

$    & ("     

@BE7D00

       & $ . #


 H   3 

7;;A

 :( 5 (($ 

    %

7BE02B;D02;?


 

011?

  

% ( 5  44  5   3  / ! 

$       
 !   

7@?E2BAD2;?

4 
 7;;0 , ( / 5     /   

   

01E7000D70@2

  . , 7;;? % ( $$ 5 4 N   (  

  

 

  

0=E;77D;@1

  G 7;A= L   / 5  ( E & + 5 

     

$  , %
( (

,

70 7E@27D@2B
7;;=

     $   C  5 +$

      #

0@EB0BDB=7

$  , % 7;;A *(   $ / 3  / +$ ( 
& +5 +
    , $ + 

# "    

$  , %

   )     )  

( 0@D== ,( 


7;;; +(    ( ( &

   # "      

!  &

 ,  





$  , %  
  7;;A   3  / +$ ( 

$    , )    - )&    

BE00@D0@A

     ! , # 7;;B *     / / 4 3( 


$  ( (

#  * 

A=E?;BDB1?

   " + , $ ! +   ! , *


  

     

7;;0 5     

01E701@D7007

 6 .  +


   . 
 &  (( % ( ( 5
/ $ +$ ( 3  

    , ) !

$($55 ,   #/   

7;;B +$ ( 3  H  



$    &          

;0E?@@D?@;

      , 7;;@  5 (4 (($  N   $ /
 ( E     ( 

 "

0E@=;D@?=

  ,$    ! , #




$    &       

0111 K $    /  

 &  
  & )) 

AAE2;DBA



    ) , 7;;A ((3     /   /   /
  :+$ (

,    $      

        "  #

011=

   ( 5 

0?E0A@D0;B

 $ /      / 

$    & ("       "

??EB@2DB=;

% "


 % / 

!  & . *&)


 )"  # "  % &       " 4  77 (
7;;0

5 3   

&

7;BD077

% "
 0111
4 $ (  $ / +$ ( 3  

$    , )    - )&    

;E0=;D0?2

% "
 0117 +8   ( /      +$ 6   )$ 
"( 171= +(  / , K 45 / ) 

 #    ) * 7;BB +45    (    (  /  


 

#   &             

=BE=;BD272


  .

7;;?

, 4(  / $ :


   $

   ) , ,$(5  ,  


   .  

-  +& "

&

  0
  " 

( 0=2D0?B &   /


$ , >5 *

  . 7;;B )$ :(  :+$   4 /   
  

  
  "

02EA22D;11

  . 0110 *   $ ( )$  "( ?07 +( 
/ , K 45 / */   5

   / ,

  , 

,$
  .

0110 

 :$   #
 4     / (: :

  /  /   4 ( 

,   0
  "  , ) !

77E217D27=
"  *

7;;?
3  /   E & /      & # ! "

"$  ,   ,($ + 

   % * ,&  %  , 

*$(   >
,$   .

7;;=

   4 8  / +$ (

    

=E?@;D?21


)$ G ! . 


 & 
 .    +

(

011= >$ +$

)$  "( ?2@ +(  / , K 45 / */  

5

)   #    


 7;;;  5 /   )$  ( K 45
/ ) 

! , #  
 
5  $

!  

7;;2 :,5 (      / $

     

02E7B?0D7BA1

7;;A 5( (( /  ( 5 (  &

+5 +
    , $ + 

# "    

   )     )  

( 0;@D@1= ,( 

!
 7;;0 >5((   +$ ( 3   )$ 
"( ;0:1@ &   / ,   + ,  +  K 45

!

     


7;;= >$ (   3  

$ ((       5   &    "   ,$ 



 

)   1  "

( @?@D@A? .$ !5




<    ,$  "   . 


 &
(

011= >(5(   4 $ +$

     ,   % & ' !

% GE *


'$  0111 5 ( /   ( ( 

     

0AE2@0D220



Вам также может понравиться