Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
EDUC 4202
a1630608
A guide to promoting
a positive learning
environment
Contents
Page No.
Contents Page
Introduction
2-3
Preventative Actions
Theorists:
Strategies
5-9
Supportive Actions
Theorists:
10
Gordon, Skinner, Piaget and Vygotsky
Strategies
10
11-14
Corrective Actions
Theorists:
15
Dreikurs & Cassell, Farruggio, Gordons
Model of Discipline and Rogers Four Rs
Strategies
15-16
17-21
Conclusion
22
References
23-24
Appendices
Appendix 1
25
Appendix 2
26
Appendix 3
27
Appendix 4
28
Appendix 5
29
Appendix 6
30
Appendix 7
31
Appendix 8
32
Introduction
McInerney and McInerney (2002, pg. 248) argue that high academic achievement and prosocial
behaviour are positively related in schools where a positive learning environment is present, and
where students perceive that their teachers both care for and are committed to them.
This handbook focusses on preventive, supportive and corrective actions that promote a positive
learning environment. The Quality Outcomes, Teaching and Learning Model (see Fig. 1) infers that
the personal, social, emotional and moral world of a child affects their academic world, and thus
needs to be considered in order to maximise learning (Killen 2006, pg. 32-33; Snowman et al. 2009,
pg. 64).
Figure 1: The Quality Outcomes Teaching and Learning (QQTL) model is supported by Snowman et al.s (2009,
pg. 64) belief that the personal, social, emotional and moral world of a child affects their academic world (Killen
2006, pg. 32).
Preventative Actions
Preventative discipline refers to actions that maintain motivation and attention. Charles (2002, p.
236) argues that most misbehaviour can be prevented if you treat students sensitively, provide an
interesting curriculum and use a helpful teaching style. This involves:
Making curriculum lessons and topics enjoyable and worthwhile
Being mindful of students needs (i.e. Maslows hierarchy of childrens needs)
Being considerate, respectful, understanding and helpful towards students and encourage
them to reciprocate
Forming a mutual understanding about appropriate classroom behaviour
Teaching students about good manners, how to use them and how they benefit the
classroom environment
(Charles 2002, pg. 236).
Theorists:
Charles (2002, pg. 236) argues that preventative discipline involves being mindful of students needs
for security, hope, acceptance, dignity, power, enjoyment and competence. Maslows hierarchy of
childrens needs (1943, Fig. 2), can be implemented in the school-setting in order to conceptualise
the different levels (or types) of childrens needs and how they can be satisfied. Charles (2002, pg.
241) suggests that when students needs are met, they become less inclined to misbehave or
outsmart their teachers.
Strategies
1. Language
It is important to understand and vary the use of characteristics of language (i.e. eye contact),
direct instruction, whole-class interactive learning, exposition, explanation, questions and
discussion (Cohen, Manion & Morrison 2004, pg. 229-246). Types of language have different
functions and uses within the classroom (i.e. regulative or instructional language).
The ability to swap between language types will allow you to:
Productively engage with the students (i.e. regulative language)
Enable the students to gain the knowledge and skills required (i.e. instructional language)
Enables you to cope with the demands of ordinary living (i.e. everyday language)
Stimulate and deepen student learning (i.e. specialised language)
Figure 3: Amy demonstrates waiting for silent to promote a positive learning environment in her
classroom (SchoolsWorld 2012).
4. Phrases
A well-chosen phrase such as, Looking at me and listening please, can also promote a positive
learning environment if used consistently. Cowley (2006, pg. 39) suggests:
Avoid shouting over students
Repeat the phrase several times over
Pausing briefly to gauge the students response
5. The Choice
Cowley (2006, pg. 41) states that children have two choices: do as the teacher asks, or accept
the consequences of refusal to comply. Killen (2006, pg. 26) refers to this element as student
direction. This strategy provides students with a platform to consider and change their negative
behaviour and avoid negative consequences in the future. It places responsibility on the student
for their own actions, which promotes a sense of ownership and their commitment to it (Brady
& Scully 2005, pg. 59).
When Using The Choice in the Classroom:
State the behaviour you require
Make clear the positive benefits or doing as you ask
Make clear the consequences of refusing to comply
Give the student a short time to consider his or her decision
If the student does not comply, apply the sanctions you have specified and revert to
corrective strategies
(Cowley, 2006, pg. 41).
Figure 4: Michelle demonstrates the need for structure, planning and preparation in order to promote a
positive learning environment (SchoolsWorld 2012).
7
9. Engagement
Genuine interest in both the content and activity of learning underpins effective engagement in
the classroom (Brady & Scully 2005, pg. 45). To achieve this, teachers must build on existing
knowledge, demonstrate good knowledge of the curriculum, show creativity and flexibility,
establish expectations about learning and acknowledge students hierarchy of needs (i.e.
Maslows hierarchy of needs, Fig. 2) (Brady & Scully 2005, pg. 46-49).
Strategies to Engage Students within the Classroom include:
Surprises (i.e. sing a song, make a controversial statement, appear as a fictitious character)
Review prior learning (i.e. give a class quiz or reflective summary
Scaffolding (i.e. students can interpret new experiences in terms of pre-existing structures
thereby better making sense of it)
Model behaviour (i.e. enrich content by teacher enthusiasm and communication of positive
expectations)
Establish relevance of learning (i.e. use recent real-life events)
Motivational cues (i.e. use rewards in the form of preferred activities that still aid learning)
(Brady and Scully 2005, pg. 54-59).
Figure 5: Phillip demonstrates the need for engaging activities to connect students to content, such as
Macbeth, in order to promote a positive learning environment (SchoolsWorld 2012).
Supportive Actions
Supportive actions refer to minimising management problems through pre-emptive and effective
classroom management (Charles 2002, pg. 236). It is natural for students to, at some stage, become
restive and engage in misbehaviour, thus such actions have a place in our classroom. Charles (2002,
pg. 236-237) states that supportive discipline involves:
Showing interest in the students work, ask cheerful questions and give constructive
feedback
Learning to catch students eyes and send private signals such as head shakes
Using physical proximity
Helping students when they get stuck with hints or suggestions
Setting small learning challenges
Restructuring or changing the activity if students find the work too difficult
Theorists:
Gordons humanistic approach (1974) and Skinners theory on positive reinforcement, encourage
the creation of warm supportive relationships between teachers and students, where the teacher is
sensitive, accepting and non-critical (McInerney & McInerney 2002, pg. 263). Gordons approach
implies that positive learning environments are achieved through minimal control and authoritative
methods, where the goal is to understand why students behave the way they do. This is closely
supported by Piaget and Vygotsky, whose research place an importance on understanding key
developmental milestones in a childs life, and the role of social and cultural influences on a childs
cognitive development. Piaget and Vygotskys philosophies promote positive learning in the
classroom by accepting the influence of both theories and highlight the need for teachers to observe
their students carefully and match their learning experiences with their cognitive development (see
Appendix 4 for applying Piaget and Vygotskys theory in the classroom) (Krause, Bochner and
Duchesne 2003, pg. 67).
10
Strategies
1. Praise and Supporting Students Progress
Supporting or scaffolding student learning can be achieved through praise and positive
reinforcement at an individual level (i.e. whisper technique) or in front of the whole class,
ensuring that the positive comment is personalised by using their name (Brady & Scully 2005, pg.
60).
Examples of Praise:
Thank you for keeping your hands to yourself [name]
[Name], you are doing a great job at working quietly
Excellent job at taking turns in group discussions [name]
Thank-you for contributing your ideas [name]
[Name], excellent work, its good to see you are staying on task
An example of using praise to promote a positive learning environment is seen in Praise and
Preparation, where teacher Amy demonstrates the power of positive praise and reinforcement,
consistent with Gordons humanistic approach and Skinners theory on positive reinforcement
(see Appendix 1).
2. Cues
Cowley (2006, pg. 40) discusses the use of cues within the classroom, stating that the idea
behind using cues is to cue the children into the behaviour you do want, rather than letting them
behave incorrectly first and then having to use disciplinary action. Examples include smiles,
winks and nods (Charles 2002, pg. 240).
3. Feedback
Glasgow and Hicks (2003, pg. 95) state that feedback is important for students to help them
assess their mastery of course material and their use of thinking and learning strategies, as well
as connecting their efforts and strategies to their academic outcomes. Written and verbal forms
of feedback are most effective.
11
4. Scaffolding
Scaffolding involves providing students with enough help to complete a task and then gradually
decreasing the help as the student becomes able to work independently (Killen 2006, pg. 8).
5. Physical Proximity
Argued to be a supportive and corrective action, teachers can use physical proximity as a
supportive action before the student goes off task. For example, teachers could closely observe
a disruptive student to redirect attention to the learning.
Figure 7: Nicola demonstrates rewards and positive consequences to promote a positive learning
environment for her class (SchoolsWorld 2012).
12
8. Characteristics of Teachers
Killen (2006, pg. 34) argues that teachers who most effective at using pedagogical practices to
promote a positive learning environment are:
Knowledgeable
Enthusiastic
Confident
Effective at communicating
Committed
Compassionate
Curious
Patient
Persistent
Willing to share and collaborate
Resourceful and inventive
Well-organised
Optimistic
Ethical
These qualities are believed to positively impact classroom motivation, achievement and
engagement.
13
9. Role Play
Eby, Herrell & Jordan (2006, pg. 220) argues that role play can be used to help students explore
and understand the whole range of human feelings that surround any issue, and has many
applications in the cognitive and affective goals of the curriculum. This strategy can used to
resolve dilemmas within the classroom, promote the learning of new behaviours and social
skills and help students discover more productive and responsible ways of behaving.
An example of using role play to promote a positive learning environment is seen in
Underachieving Boys: The Plays The Thing (see below), where teacher Abigail incorporates
role play into an English class to connect the students to the characters and literature (see
Appendix 6).
Figure 8: Abigail demonstrates role play into an English class to promote engagement, self-esteem
and confidence, thus encouraging a positive learning environment for her class (SchoolsWorld 2012).
14
Corrective Actions
Corrective actions refer to responding to common and chronic misbehaviour problems when they
arise (Charles 2002, pg. 237). Through approaching misbehaving students in a well-thought-out and
sensitive manner, poor behaviour can be easily corrected. Corrective discipline involves:
Intervening positively when class agreements are broken
Speaking to disruptive students in a calm and respectful manner without lecturing or
threatening them
Establishing discipline standards and the corrective measures that will be taken for
inappropriate behaviour
Remaining positive and cooperative with classroom rules and expectations
Being consistent with discipline, corrective measures, and classroom rules and expectations
A teachers individual corrective action plan should take into account their own personal needs, the
students needs as well as the educational goals of teaching.
The more strategies that you have at your disposal to achieve control, the more confident you
will feel. When things are going wrong, you will try one approach after another, until you find
something that works for you.
(Cowley, 2006, pg. 36).
Theorist:
Dreikurs and Cassel (1995) argue that consequences to poor behaviour should be logical and should
relate as closely to the behaviour as possible so that students can connect meaning to their decisionmaking. McInerney and McInerney (2002, pg. 256) theorise that following this method teaches
students to foresee the outcome of their behaviour and develop ownership of it. For reoccurring
problem behaviour, fellow theorist In McInerney and McInerney (2002), Farruggio (2002) suggests
that teachers may need to investigate why the behaviour is occurring rather than enforce the
corrective actions, for example if there is a problem occurring at home. Farruggio (2002) states, To
a good teacher, punishment must serve the broader purpose of helping [students] develop maturity
and responsibility (McInerney and McInerney 2002). Gordons model of discipline expands on this,
suggesting that a teachers role in corrective actions should be to critically listen which helps to
understand the real message underlying the behaviour (McInerney & McInerney 2002, pg. 263). In
addition, Rogers (1998) believes that the four Rs should underpin any school or classroom discipline
policy (see. Fig. 4). Verbal and non-verbal strategies can be employed to achieve this within the
classroom.
15
Figure 4: Rogers (1998) proposed policy framework for rights, rules, responsibilities and relationships.
16
Strategies
1. Non-Verbal Intervention and Teacher Presence
Jones (1987) encourages the use of body language, presence and direct eye-contact to help
students behave responsibly and to focus on their own learning, emphasising non-verbal
discipline (Olsen & Cooper 2001, pg. 44).
Using Body Language as a Corrective Action in the Classroom
Eye contact (sweep the room continually and engage the eyes of individual students)
Physical proximity
Body carriage (hold yourself upright and move assertively)
Facial expressions (very slight shakes of the head, frowns, tight lips and flashing eyes used
instead of verbalisation)
Gestures (palm forward to symbolise stop and finger to lips to symbolise quiet)
Waiting for silence
Planned ignoring
(Olsen & Cooper 2001, pg. 44).
2. Verbal Intervention
Although non-verbal interventions are ideal, verbal interventions are also successful in
correcting poor behaviour (Levin & Nolan 2005, pg. 31). Fig. 5 displays a suggested hierarchy of
verbal interventions that teachers can use as a range of options to consider, and that the
teacher should begin with the intervention at the point on the hierarchy that is likely to correct
the misbehaviour and still allow the student as much control and responsibility as possible (Levin
and Nolan 2005, pg. 33-34).
Using Language as a Corrective Action in the Classroom
Acknowledge correct behaviour at individual and group level (i.e. Excellent work, John!)
Reinforce task instruction
Keep interventions brief and private, and avoid lecturing
Speak to the situation, not the person (i.e. use Interrupting is rude, rather than You
interrupted me, you are rude)
Avoid sarcasm or other demeaning behaviours
(Levin & Nolan 2005, pg. 31-32; Olsen & Cooper 2001, pg. 44).
17
Hints
(Student-Centred)
(Less Confrontational)
(Less Disruption)
(More Disruption)
(More Confrontation)
(Teacher-Centred)
Figure 9: Hierarchy of classroom verbal intervention techniques (Levin & Nolan 2005, pg. 33).
Figure 10: Jenny demonstrates verbal intervention strategies to redirect poor behaviour choices, in
order to promote a positive learning environment (SchoolsWorld 2012).
18
4. Separating Students
If students are encouraging others to participate in poor behaviour students, teachers can
separate those students until they have calmed down. This encourages students to re-direct
their poor behaviour into good behaviour, as well as removing the stimulus that may have been
encouraging it.
5. Whisper Technique
Although the whisper technique can be a supportive action, it can also be used effectively to
correct poor behaviour. It can be used to address off-task, disruptive behaviour, particularly in
situations where students are mature enough to quickly recorrect what they are doing wrong, or
where the teacher does not want to publically address the misbehaviours to avoid escalating the
issue.
An example of using the whisper technique to promote a positive learning environment is seen
in Attention Seekers (below), where teacher Jane demonstrates using whisper voices and
close teaching distances to correct off-task behaviour in a way that does not draw attention
away from teaching the whole class (see Appendix 8).
19
Figure 11: Jane demonstrates the whisper technique to redirect poor behaviour choices, in order to
promote a positive learning environment (SchoolsWorld 2012).
7. Individual Accountability
Keeping students individually accountable for their involvement in learning can help students
gain maturity and responsibility for their actions in life. Methods to encourage this include
asking direct questions or having students record reflections in a diary (McInerney &
McInerney 2002, pg. 261). This can regain the students attention after poor behaviour in a way
that does not publically embarrass the student or escalate into a retaliation.
20
21
Conclusion
Teachers should strive to redirect misbehaviour in a positive and helpful manner, promote trusting
relationships between students and teachers, and guide students to become responsible and selfcontrolled (Charles, 2002). By dividing behavioural management strategies into preventative,
supportive and corrective actions, new teachers can grasp the most effective methods that
specifically target preventing poor choices, those that support student growth in responsible
decision making and those that correct poor behaviour whilst least disrupting the learning of the
whole-class. The strategies discussed in this handbook, together with the theoretical backgrounds
that underpin child development, can facilitate a positive learning environment through scaffolding
skills in problem solving, communication, relationships and interaction, and helping students
construct their own understanding of the world (Charles, 2002).
22
References
Maslow, A 2012, Maslows Hierarchy of Needs, <http://www.abrahammaslow.com/m_motivation/Hierarchy_of_Needs.asp> accessed 27 April 2015.
Brady, L, & Scully, A 2005, Engagement: inclusive classroom management, Pearson Education
Australia, NSW.
Charles, C M 2002, Building classroom discipline, 7th Edn, Pearson Education Inc, New Jersey.
Cohen, L, Manion, L & Morrison, K 2004, A guide to teaching practice, 5th Edn, Taylor and Francis,
London and New York.
Cowley, S 2006, Getting the buggers to behave, Continuum International Publishing Group.
Dreikurs, R & Cassel, P 1995, Discipline without tears, 2nd Edn, New York.
Eby, J, Herrell, A & Jordan, M 2006, Teaching in K-12 schools: a reflective action approach, 4th Edn,
Pearson Education.
Glasgow, N A & Hicks C D 2003, What successful teachers do: research-based classroom strategies
for new and veteran teachers, Corwin Press, California.
Killen, R 2006, Effective teaching strategies: lessons from research and practice, 4th Edn, Thomson.
Krause, K, Bochner, A & Duchesne, S 2003, Educational psychology for learning and teaching,
Thomson
Levin, J & Nolan, J 2005, What every teacher should know about classroom management, Pearson
Education Inc, New Jersey.
McInenery, DM, & McInerney, V 2002, Educational psychology: constructing learning, 4th Edn,
Pearson Education Australia, NSW.
Olsen, P & Cooper, J 2001, Dealing with disruptive students in the classroom, Taylor & Francis Ltd.,
UK.
Porter, L (2000), Student behaviour: theory and practice for teachers, Allen & Unwin, New South
Wales.
Rogers, B 1995, Behaviour management: a whole-school approach, Ashton Scholastic.
Snowman, J, Dobozy, E, Scevak, J, Bryer, F, Bartlett, B & Biehler, R 2009, Psychology applied to
teaching, John Wiley & Sons Australia, Ltd.
23
24
25
Teacher Michelle struggles to plan and prepare what she would like the students to achieve
Multiple students question the activity, suggesting that they are confused about what they
have to do
She improves on this by providing clear instructions and guidelines for what is expected to
be completed during the lesson
Outcome: using specific aims and objectives during the lesson can prevent students from
struggling with or questioning the task
26
Teacher Phillip uses Argument Tennis to engage students with the story of Macbeth. Phillip
successfully engages year nine boys with the literature by:
Creating a debating-style setting
Engaging the students with the content
Dividing the students into two groups and selects a spokesperson to argue their case
Encourages participation
Encourages praise from within the groups (peer to peer support)
Using creativity to teach content that may be perceived as dull
27
28
In this video, two students are continually seeking reassurance and attention from the teacher to
complete their work. The teacher is well aware that they are capable to complete the task on their
own. In response to this, she decides to give a reward or incentive to achieve the desired behaviour.
Nicola decides to:
Reward good behaviour with her attention
Uses a hot and cold notion to show the students when they are doing the correct or
incorrect behaviour
Uses rewards that the students are initiating, for example with wedding photographs and
looking at Nicolas wedding ring
Uses such rewards as positive reinforcers for correct and desired behaviour
29
Teacher Abigail incorporates role play into her English class to engage students with the text.
Techniques include:
Using drama to engage students with the text
Allocating characters to students, which they act and read out in class
Promoting confidence and self-esteem by encouraging performance skills
Satisfying students needs for attention (i.e. fulfilling Maslows hierarchy of childrens needs)
Supporting self-expression through the use of role play
30
31
Teacher Jane uses close teaching distances and whisper voices to re-direct a student who is not
paying attention. By doing this, the poor behaviour is corrected and the attention is not drawn away
from teaching the whole class. The whisper technique is effective in situations where the task has
been set, where students are engaging in off-task behaviour.
32