14 (494) 2012

336.763

*
. . ,
, ,


E-mail: NBerzon@mail. ru
. . ,


E-mail: D. Doroshin@gmail. com

,
,
.

. .
,
.
: , , , , , , ,
.

.
,
,
.
* -
.

, ,
.
. , 1952.

, .


.
,
.

.
,
.

21


, .

, .

.
(H. Markowits) Portfolio Selection, Journal of Finance 1952.

,

.

, . ,

. -
.

.


,
.

. . 1964. .

(Capital Asset Pricing
Model, CAPM). ( ) CAPM
. (1962.), .
(1965.) . .
:
1) ,
;
2) () ,
.
,
:
rp rf  p (rm  rf ), 
r
,
r
p m
;

rf ;

p .
22

14 (494) 2012
p :
cov(rp , rm )

(1)
p =
.
m 2

.
.
. (Michael C. Jensen)
The Performance of Mutual Funds in the Period
1945-64, Journal of Finance
1968., , .
CAPM:
p = rp rp = rp [rf + (rm rf ) p ].
,
.

. ,
( ) .
,
.
(M2).
. (Franko Modigliani)
Risk-adjusted performance: how to measure
it and why, Journal of
Portfolio Management 1997.


:

M 2 = (rp rf )( m ) + rf ,
p
p, m
, .
,
, .
. ,
,
. ,
,
.
.



.
. The Sharp Ratio, The Journal of Portfolio Management
1994.
:

;

.

,
:
;
.


:
rp rf
Sr =
,
p
rp ;

rf (risk free rate);

p .
, .
,

.
,
.
, , ,
.

, . ,
, ..
,
, .
,
, . , -

14 (494) 2012
,
. ,
,

.
,
, .
,
.
( )
. ,
, ,
.
, .

. (Jack Treynor) How to Rate
Management of Investment Funds,
Harvard Business Review,
,
.


:
rp rf
Tr =
,
p
rp ;

rf ;

p ,
(1).

, .

, , ,
.
. ,
,
.

, . ,
.
23

14 (494) 2012

,

.
,
.
. ,


. , .
, , ,
.
,
,
,
, ..
, .
,
,

. 1994.
. (F. Sortino) . (L. Price)
Performance Measurement in a Downside Risk
Framework Journal of Investing ,
.
.
.
,
,
.
,

, ,
,
.
:
T

n
p

min( R

p ,t

MAR,0) 2

,
T
Rp,t p t;
=

24

t =1

MAR (minimum acceptable return)

.
:
rp MAR
SOr =
.
np

.
.
1.
, ,
MAR ( , ).

,
,
, . ,
, ,


.
2. ,

. ,

,

.
. . , . ,

,
.
,
.

,

.

.

14 (494) 2012

, ,
. 1718 . .
,

- , . , . ,
.

,
, - .
, , , .
Rux-Cbonds.
, - .
01.01.2002 01.06.2008.
, ,
Rux-Cbonds ,
.
, .. 01.01.2002.
( ,
), ( Rux-Cbonds), , ..
- .
01.06.2008. ,

. - . ,
:
,
1 .;
2 .;
.
3 . ..


- .
. 1.
,
. 1 ,
,



( 

, 
16 .), 
,





,
,




. ,

. 1.

25

14 (494) 2012

. ,

,
,
.
, S&P,
10-

.

2010., 83
. ,

.
. 2, 3.
. 2
,
.

10 , (. 3).
,


.

.
,

49%29%9%11%32%52%






1
.
. 2.

1
,
, .
,

, ( )
100%.
. 2 3
,
.
,
17%10%2%5%13%21%28% .




1
. 3. 10- .

1
26

14 (494) 2012

:
n

As =

(r r )
i

,
n3
ri ;
r
;

n ;

.

:
i =1

= 2x .
,
( )
,
. ( )
,
.

. :
As 0, 25 ;
0, 25 < As 0,5 ;
As > 0,5 .
,

, .
,

,
.
:
n

Ek =

(r r )
i

3.
n 4

:
,

.
. , :
|k| <0,2 ,
|k| = 0,20,3 ,
|k| = 0,30,6 ,
i =1

|k| = 0,61,0 ,
|k| > 1 .

,
.
, S&P, 10-
. 1.
. 1 , .
.
, ,
,
.
(1,21) ,
, .

.
.

: ,
, . ,
, 1,88, ,

,
.
,
,
.
,
(0,40),
, ,
1

- - - - -
,% ,%

20,21
11,32
0,40

7,60
5,35
1,21

0,34
1,88

27

14 (494) 2012

,


(0,34).
,
,
,
.


.
, ,

.
,

30- .
, 30- , 1928.,
1. 30-
19281957., 19291958.
.. 19282010.
53 .

30 (. 4), ,

,
, . ,
.
: (), ,
, ,
,
.

, .

, 2010.
.
,
, ,

.
,

,
, 30 (. 5).

. 2, 3,
.




(. 2).

(1,09),
(0,25).
2% 10% 8% 6% 4% 2% 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 12% 14% 16% 18% 20%
1
,
4.
30-
,

28

14 (494) 2012

. 2000. . (Michael Stutzer)

A Portfolio Performance
Index,
,

.
,
,

,
. 5. . 30

.
,
2


. 30-
,

- - - -
- -

,% ,%
,

1,24
12,62
0,22
1,09
.
2,72
5,31
1,71 0,25
, . .
, .
30 ,
, . , ,
.
, , 0

1 T rpt
I
=
max

log

p
T e ,

t =1

(0,22). rp = rp MAR;
.
-

, ,
. ,
(1,71).
-
:
Str = sign(rp ) 2 I p ,
.
sign(rp ) rp .

, ,
. ,
1
Str = S r 2 . ,
.
2

29



.
,

.

.
, ,
.
,
. , ,

, , .
.

, . . , .

, :
As
Ek
2
Sh = Sh 1 +
Sh
Sh ,
24
6

Sh ;

As ;

Ek .
,
, , ,
, .
,

,
.
, ,
.
, ,

.
30

14 (494) 2012
,
,
,
.
, ,
,

, -
.
,
,
.
,

,
,
,
.
2002.
2011.
,
.
:
;
.
80% , , 20% , RUX-Cbonds.
80% 20% .


,
.

.
. 3

.
1 36 .

.

14 (494) 2012

,%

,%
,%



,%

,%
,%

1 .
12 .
24 .

0,074
0,059
0,050
0,148
0,321
0,428
1,331
1,134
1,033
1,875
1,702
1,599
0,176
0,357
0,810
0,095
0,200
0,270
0,141
0,291
0,404

0,262
0,205
0,167
0,229
0,464
0,595
2,217
1,746
1,550
2,602
2,202
1,998
0,212
0,629
1,299
0,142
0,283
0,369
0,197
0,401
0,542

,
.

. , 60
. ,
.

. ,
,
.
.
, 48 .,

.
.

,
,
,
.
,


,
,

36 .

48 .

60 .

0,042
0,508
0,931
1,489
1,891
0,333
0,509

0,026
0,012
0,805
1,063
1,085
1,039
1,663
1,659

0,569
0,821
0,855
1,172

0,133
0,686
1,367
1,811
4,610
0,444
0,671

0,055
0,012
0,868
0,989
1,233
0,988
1,746
1,588

0,639
0,746
0,942
1,087

.

.

,


, .
,
. , .

.
, ,

.
, ,
.
,
,
31



,
,
, .
,
, .

, .

,
.

,
, ,
,
.

, ,
,

.
.


, ,
,
,
.

.
,
,

,
. ,
,
32

14 (494) 2012
.
.

,
. ,
.
,
,
.

1. .., .. -
// . 2010.
. 14. 3.
2. ., .
-
//
. 2007. 5.
3. Ang A., Hordrick R., Xing Y., Zhang X. The
cross-section of volatility and returns. Working paper,
Columbia Business School. 2004
4. Barberis N., Huang M., Santos T. The Center for
Research in Security Prices. Working paper, University
of Chicago, Graduate School of Business. 1999
5. Bollen N.P. and J.A. Busse. On the timing
ability of mutual fund managers // Journal of Finance
2001. 56.
6. Breeden D., Litzenberger R. Prices of statecontingent claims implicit in options prices // Journal
of Business. 1978. 51.
7. Carhart M.M. On persistence in mutual fund
performance // Journal of Finance. 1997.52.
8. Fama E.F. and French K.R. Common risk
factors in the returns on bonds and stocks // Journal of
Financial Economics. 1993. 33.
9. Grobman I., Peresetsky A. 1999. Analysis of
Russian stock market performance at the pre-crisis
period October 1997 August 1998. Working paper,
New Economic School.
10. Gupta F., Prajogi R. and E. Stubbs. 1999.
The information ratio and performance // Journal of
Portfolio Management, Volume 26, Number 1.
11. Harvey C. Time-varying conditional covariances
in tests of asset pricing models. Working paper, Duke
University. 1991.


12. Henriksson R. and Merton R. 1981. On market
timing and investment performance: statistical procedures
for evaluating forecasting skills // Journal of Business. 54.
13. Ibbotson R., Chen P. 2002. Stock Market Returns
in the Long Run: Participating in the Real Economy.
Working paper, Yale School of Management.
14. Jensen M. The Performance of mutual funds
in the period 19451964 // Journal of Finance. 1968.
23.
15. Kahneman D., Tversky A. 1979. Prospect theory:
An analysis of decisions under risk // Econometrica.
1979. 47.
16. Kon S.J. and Jen F.C. 1979. The investment
performance of mutual funds: an empirical investigation
of timing, selectivity and market efficiency // Journal
of Business. 52.
17. Markowitz H. Portfolio Selection // Journal of
Finance. 1952. 1.
18. Michael Stutzer. 2000. A Portfolio Performance
Index // Financial Analysts Journal. 2000. 56.
19. Modigliani F. and Modigliani L. 1997. Riskadjusted performance: how to measure it and why //
Journal of Portfolio Management. 1997. 23.
20. Nardari F., Scruggs J. 2005. Why Does Stock
Market Volatility Change Over Time? A Time-Varying

14 (494) 2012
Variance Decomposition for Stock Returns. Working
paper, Arizona State University.
21. Pezier J & White A 2006. The relative Merits of
Investable Hedge Fund indices and of Funds of Hedge
Funds in Optimal Passive Portfolios.
22. Robertson D., Wright S. 1998. The good news
and the bad news about long-run stock market returns.
Working paper, university of Cambridge.
23. Roll R. 1978. Ambiguity when performance
is measured by the securities market line // Journal of
Finance 33.
24. Sharpe W.F. 1966. Mutual fund performance //
Journal of Business 39.
25. Sharpe W.F. 1994. The Sharpe ratio, Journal
of Portfolio Management, Fall.
26. Sortino F., Price L. 1994. Performance
Measurement in a Downside Risk Framework // Journal
of Investing. 1994.
27. Treynor J.L. 1965. How to rate management
of investment funds // Harvard Business Review 43.
28. Treynor J.L. and F. Black. 1973. How to use
security analysis to improve portfolio selection //
Journal of Business. January.
29. Treynor J. and K. Mazuy. 1966. Can mutual funds
outguess the market? // Harvard Business Review. 44.

33