Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Date: 11-01-2015
Topic Selected:
Topic 3: What does the research say about advantages and disadvantages of distance
education?
1. LITERATURE REVIEW:
What does the literature/research say about this issue/topic? By using NAU
Library or Online Search engines, conduct a literature review.
You need to include 5 different sources (book, journal article, web article
etc.) in your review. Try to use current sources as much as possible.
You don't need to evaluate your sources (if the sources are trustworthy,
weather the author has a bias or not)
Historyofthedistanceeducationcanbetracedbacktolate1800s.Itstarted
inEuropefromusingpostalmailsystembydeliveringmaterialstostudents
andgettingtheirassignmentsandhomeworkbackagainwithmailsystem.It
developedfromusingradiosystem,TVbroadcasting,vhsvideolessonsto
nowadaysonlinelearning,elearning.Distanceeducationisaneducation
thatteachingoccursseparatedbytimeandspace.Bydevelopmentof
technologypopularityDistanceeducationalsoincreasing.Togivean
exampleisonlineeducations,openuniversities,teleconferencingandetc.
Withgettingmorepopular,distanceeducationhasbothadvantagesand
disadvantages.IfoundthisarticleonNAUsEBSCOdatabaseandinthis
articleC.DMaddux,J.ETaylor,D.LJohnson(2001)believethat,abilityto
reachlearnersinremotelocations,flexiblehours,workandlearninaplace
theylikeaspotentialadvantagesofdistanceeducation.Asdisadvantageof
distanceeducationtheybelievelackofattentiontoeducationalquality
controlissues.
Inanotherwebsite,IfoundarticlenamedAdvantagesanddisadvantagesof
DistanceLearning.AccordingtothisarticleAdvantagesarestatedas:
1. NoCommuting
2. Attendfromanywhereanytime
3. Gainextraknowledge
4. Selfpacedlearning
5. Accessibility
AndasDisadvantagesoflearning:
1. CostlyandComplextechnology
2. Advanceplanning
3. Hiddencosts
4. Noimmediatefeedback
5. SocialIsolation
OntheonlineeducationalmagazinestudyMagazine,Ifoundanarticleabout
ProsandConsofDistanceLearning.Inthisarticleconvenience,flexibility,
less Interruption of daily life, affordability as advantages of distance
learning.AndIsolation,indirectcontactwithprofessors,lackofthecollege
spirit, limited course options as disadvantages of distance learning. In
anotheracademicJournal,Fender,D.L.(1999)statesadvantagesofdistance
educationas:
1. Improvedaccesstoeducation
2. Knowledgeandskillsbeinglearnedcanbeapplieddirectlytostudents
currentjob
3. Convenienceandflexibility.
Disadvantagesofdistanceeducation:
1. SocialInteraction
2. Feedback
MylastbutnotleastarticlereviewisfromperiodicalTechDirectionsbyC.
Zirkle,(2002).C.ZirklestatesadvantagesofDistancelearningas:Noneed
toattendclassoncampus,noscheduledtime,andwebbaseddelivery,less
interaction and less discipline problems. And, disadvantages of Distance
learningas:
Isolation from other learners, frustration caused by poorly flowing
communication,andconfusionasaresultofunclearfeedback.
2. REFLECTION:
What is your personal opinion on this issue? Do you agree with the
research? If you agree or disagree, please explain why?
Provide examples/experiences regarding this issue from school
perspective or If you are not working in a school, from your profession. Be
specific with your examples. You can mention software/hardware names,
Reflection:
IagreewithmostoftheopinionsstatedinthearticlesIfoundintermsof
advantagesanddisadvantagesofDistanceeducation.Asyoucanseefrom
thearticlereviews,mostoftheadvantagesanddisadvantagesstatedonthose
articlesareprettymuchcommon.MostofthearticlesIfounddidnot
mentionedaboutInternetandtechnologyavailabilityasdisadvantageandfor
methatisoneoftheimportantone.Formyopinionadvantagesand
disadvantagesoftheonlineeducationarefollows:
AdvantagesofDistanceEducation:
+FlexibilityofTime
+NoCommuting
+MoreOptionstochoose
+Cost
+LearningandWorking
+InvolvesMultimediaActivities
DisadvantagesofDistanceEducation:
+NoInteractionwithteacherandPeersorLackofFacetofaceinteraction
+LackofCompetition
+Formatofthelessoncannotbesuitableforeveryone
+InternetandTechnologyAvailability
+Timecommitmentforparents
TheschoolIamworkingistraditionalsmallcharterschool,andmyschool
isnotappropriatetoofferonlineeducation.ButourHighschoolstudentsare
takingonlineclassesfromstatecommunitycollegesandIseesome
advantagesanddisadvantagesfromtheirexperience.IfIwanttogive
example,NocommutingasanadvantageandInternetandTechnology
availabilityattheirhomecanbedisadvantageforsomestudents,butsince
theyaretakingthosecoursesatschooltheyareabletouseinternetand
computersatschooltocompletetheironlineclasses.
IfIamgoingtogiveanyonlineclassesinfutureIthinkIwillmakecourses
accordingtotheadvantagesanddisadvantagesIlearnedfromthisarticle
reviewresearch.
3. REFERENCES:
References:
Maddux,C.1.,EwingTaylor,J.,&Johnson,D.L.(2002).TheLightand
DarkSidesofDistanceEducation.ComputersInTheSchools,19(3/4),17.
AdvantagesandDisadvantagesofDistanceLearning.(2015,March30).
RetrievedNovember1,2015.
Staff,E.(2014,April15).DistanceLearningProsandCons|STUDY
Magazine.RetrievedNovember1,2015.
Fender,D.L.(1999).DistanceEducation.ProfessionalSafety,44(10),26.
Zirkle,C.(2002).DistanceEducationandtheTradeandIndustryEducator.
TechDirections,62(4),32.