THIS PAGE INTENTIONALLY LEFT BLANK

www.islamic-studies.info

5......................................................................................
7......................................................................................
7 .........................................................................................
7 .................................................................................................................
8 ........................................................................................................................

8 ........................................

Paradox

"!

(Ignorito Elanchi: Fallacies of Irrelevance)& % $

8 ............................................................................................ (Argument from Ignorance)() # '1

2
9 ............................................................. (Ad verecundiam: Appeal to authority) 6 # /134 5,-./0 *+'2
10 ......................................................................................................... (Ad Hominem)7 # '3
12 ........................................................ (Argumentum ad Populum: The Appeal to Emotion)809 # '4
13 ................................................................................. (Ad ridiculum: Appeal to ridicule) # ;:'5
13 ........................................................................... (Ad Misericordiam: The Appeal to Pity)< # '6
14 ........................................................................................................... (Red Herring) @A =>?'7
15 ........................................................................................... (Denying the Antecedent)8CD B '8
15 ............................................................................................................ (Non Sequitur)EF
16 ...................................................................................................... I J HG

16 .................................................... (Fallacies of Presumption)

'9

& % $'10

M K> L

16 .................................................................................................... (False cause/Effect)N

'1

17 ................................................................................................ (Complex Question) 8) Q OP'2

17 .............................................................. (Accident Fallacy: Sweeping Generalization)S R

'3

18 .................................................................................................. (Circular Reasoning) "

'5

www.islamic-studies.info
19 .......................................................... (Petitio Principi: Begging the Question) $ V UD T

'6

19 .............................................................................................. (Straw Man Fallacy)X W

'7

19 ........................................................................................................... (Ad Nauseam)UD Y'8

20 ..............................................................................................

20 ............................................................................................................... (Equivocation)[ Z'1

20 ..................................................................................................... (Self Defeating Claims)\]'2
21 ...................................................................................................................... 2. Category Error
21 ......................................................................... (Biased/Unrepresetative Sample)
b _`a ^'3
22 .................................................................. (Slothful Induction/Appeal to Coincidence) e d c '4
22 .................................................................. (Fallacy of Composition and Division) ih fg

'5

23 ................................................................................................................ Perfectionist fallacy'6

www.islamic-studies.info

'j pqrs t uv r w xjyzv{|r} ~ bjklmn o

) ^ s 0Mv{|v{|r} ~ jF
'
' z

) ^ ' |jF

ji j Z b

jFyz D- bz(Argument))

r
M

j b ' -^

MKMz80

M n 'jF z K

z0 CM ) K jFi b F0

bFz) ^

' n 'jVM 'j z

M v j

K n

K M= M

0M M M

v
Dn -

4 z=
M)
) r

!!! M
|
n K
"

) v i )%'C r& ' & ( " Z 80 v

r# $
K

0M jij ) E)*+ ,-M. v /rv /

3 z44 5

1 z 2

M)

-M

'67UD89

b=M0/> yz ^ r:8~ 80n + y< ibz:;

bK H VA F yG ME ABC0Dr$ ? v@ b()" 'j
|

www.islamic-studies.info

KL8M N O)MP IJ ^n

c r z
'RS TrU zJQ N

[Mn i _/

Z KW rKJ Mt jiXY bVrK

_`'azihb zbDn Mk n
|d

z\]boH^lmv j

jef g hi &r(Fallacies) K

oH^ lm

n ' ijkl

Mz c

Fe) ^j < i

v% p "q rs

&r: 0/ 'je)o bK

bje)o bK t

c j z/ l

yM : y

)m

K 6 <

Gr

Muv"t

" zi 'r8 8( Bwx

'j { s e ) | j i | j i " z K | y
'} +v / ~jK
MIntroduction to Logic)

Carl Cohen

Mz 8

Irving M.Copi

MM Mj{E w Bw r Logical Fallacious )

" )
Bo.Bennett

zj0) ^0Mzv r rh j '

v{ 0 " v j r ' pqrMS M " "tr

,|' C

26/05/2015

www.islamic-studies.info

(FALLACIES)
J MoA

'F

) n G

) ^ j| r u r"j"/
'

) rK 'i r

jiv@ rb

MK

s r ^r z# n M | 'jF Ab
K 8 G

' eM) { r +jK

j ^# n 'j
y ibj^v y i&M# jes

'

IC80
i i

v iF-yzihbs 'j^K Kv -

s +j^k j^Kv | i j^# n |

# 80 z rK?y M K K iz
|

|j

j zv@ ] b K
'

jF) Paradox VM '^ jF)

|

www.islamic-studies.info

'jF

jF ^

"!

-yz b IJ# "!

j ir

'jF z M#

bn i'jF=$

'j ?/
M

0s"$n

j bM 'j]v n

i ' +j&+ '+jF

'j# "r ] i j A

8) M

jyzb]UDb + r u#

j "! n ij$b

'j z # D KK 'j]

' " # F"! r

(Ignorito Elanchi: Fallacies of Irrelevance)
(Fallacies of

&%$

&% r + K & % r -(Argument) )

) &%0r-)

j#

M UD

v z: UDF ' Relevance)

A=>? a zFjF

xb rv z:

" j is'xr bjFe $ r 8 '

'i x' y H

' j

(Argument from Ignorance) ()# '

'j

X ^X

www.islamic-studies.info

'jer j ^X

"Absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence"

'j8b_ ?%b_ ?% 8
y bVM y^b80jFib 'j
M z
" M b

DjF|

$ i

' |U 80

' z^ +K^

z] ir

80 H 'jF^) b ) ' "! b iv +az^

'j{ 80v $ir ) b

-M8 M

' eb

M ?

' ? jA 0M

b
|

H g8 Mi jF

N M80 X b J r

jb8b80j" z
'{

i+-r (Physics)8

i 'j ? b
8

M(Medical Science)

(Ad verecundiam: Appeal to authority)

2
6 # 1 34 5 ,- . /0*+'
'j X"! bA
'j

M8 MD
'j

|i

Mz#
M

jF

2
6 # 134 5,-./0*+

| 'jFe

)v

(

9 (& ,
|

www.islamic-studies.info

) jFr

+ v + /y z"

'K v

v br
170

^ 0|M

j ^ 0|

|'!" ! Q

) i n

b j#C$ % &g'Zb ( )* 'j+wb8,b

-C K +j. / 8,b j

0 Pr +1n 2M3
i+

False

vC

M'|

" / j

As e4 &%'F
'{Authority

'Anonymous Authority

+Dj i
(Ad Hominem) 7 # ' 5

8 Z

Mz

/ () M v6 jv &%$7#

%w Z K ) M j 8Fi j z= 7
is'j
'j" zM: ; yz&/ 9
' >b$j" z = <

e+j >b?@ 9 80 < Q>0'j ) 9<

<

j" zMK>b c" zM&/ jFir

<x r80 b" zMb&/ 'j&%0rDM980

'j
|

10

www.islamic-studies.info

'A" B C#
(Abusive)7

8 Z'A

'jX "! bA
'j80KD
'

zbA
X"
!

M
' v j Gv j zb 'j {vE F v
'jFv/ HIb z "J d KvK j& JL

e#

j eM z 7 #

'{ rN]MCM8O r

8CDKv u

MKvK80ij& JL

'j

'j^v j Gv /)i+ zb
S80 B # 'jF|
Mz 80

KPQR

M r# O'TzU 7 8 Z z=>?

j'z z^r
Y Q

v /$

B v% 8) M 8WX 8 Z Vw

| 'FrU/xb ?j ? Vv

u 8 v M

+" 8

-& ~ K jZ 0M[ \

M 8 l [ \ Y |' z=

yzM ] \ |K zt

' ` + |yC 80 B_ 8 K ^)
(Circumstantial)

a 'B

11

www.islamic-studies.info

'jX"! bA
'j bbA
'
jF z

X"
!

X"
!

B # DM 'jn 7# i

f bg

S pc0'jd xrv Bw v jKe bb

B

' n 'jFe UDb

f jF

bw bn v jr ]ib '-h i rjkqGKvw bMlj]b<

'-h i rjKvw bMl 'jmC

(Argumentum ad Populum: The Appeal to Emotion) 8 09 # ' n

'j
'j

80 z# "t (
i 0

bqn s'jFzr 8s

X"
!

c A

o ies :09

X]MBv

M p80 ji Pr809#
iS pc0'zt r809M

' ) ur juMKv wM
'yI Jx
ji

K KOjFe#

b) i 'zr
e i j
MK }
|

i Bandwagon Approach

z 80 y^ b ) 'j
v e c~'jF

c~Aj|s'j

v {v j
12

www.islamic-studies.info

80 y r"'j r" mH~A

v ?

|'j

'j&~AMK } #
8 0M K

j] [

rz

C j z bi (Elite Class) D8 0

Snob Approach

C b s'jF#
'-C

M 8 0KDKD jFe 0

8 r bKv
M809#

yz )o b V | j (Best Selling) 54 5 V i z r V D
*

jFe b

K 8 R

'-

'j^ki+M
8a LM#

KRG K

Appealing to Emotion

'ae809Mr ^:rQ
(Ad ridiculum: Appeal to ridicule) # : '

b# UD

Mz r# bDb# M

i z b iM
)

s'

# :

K 6iCie< !jCkib

'|

(Ad Misericordiam: The Appeal to Pity) < # '

'j

f bX

'j< A

'jvE_A

13

www.islamic-studies.info

v F j F < < r
+ Br v

M z vE _ Z M #

< #

ir bz v An s'
'_< # i+_ v_/

i MKzz

q"

+ irK ++ UD K

< # i z B rz K - z r +z

<

" /

ji z< M# 'KvE_ - # i
i b UDb n
k f bvE`

|'|j KC _ n i !

-_ Z
i

(Red Herring) @A =>?'

K 'j

'jFzXUD A

'jFzYUDn B

'jFU/ w XUD

Ur zD M

U 80 ) 'j^yz" s'jFer cb

i'jFe ^z
'j =byz !
' b c++b" = ' z
'j" zd M M%

je bi| J e j" ziik <

|

14

www.islamic-studies.info

jFi Mz UDb j tu quoque 8 Jn

jF<i i pc 'M z
' @

ZK @ ! s'K
(Denying the Antecedent) 8CD B '

/) 0 ?

jF + s K ) M pc

j ?+j/ | 'jD|+jK S
jF r" x%/)bn

jD|+jK S

s'j

'j+j ?/ |
'F&r FzMb

Non Sequitur) EF

'

' ?)

' eX"!

-MY"!

'j

X"
!

s'xr-bF ) i
'jH v

+ 0Mw) v

'j QM D " c|jk^ Q

y z

+jy8r8

'j z 8H

'{

8 ) 'j Kj er8 b
z/ K

ey 8 J

'j# 0M =E r
|

| z '|
sy8

{^yz) i' %
15

www.islamic-studies.info

j z: 8BK h

I J HG

&% $ '

r xI J H &%$

v MK+ J
'

80iD KDMC/ yz# i

80

(Argument from age/Genetic Fallacy)'j

8~# '{ +C80i y p80

v z

Appeal to Force)

(Fallacies of Presumption)

MK> L

(False cause/Effect) N

'

' A

' 0MA0B

'jAbB
) jF zQ b(Cause & Effects) N 0M8a

jv

2jFi: + jF2r(Cold)" s'Fx 0M

iv 2rlz|Q 'j Ni'j" N
i'j{ N 2 {N

i+ 2r +TrKD

' _/vP/
' ? r C

0 MK

jF 'jz8M (Anaximander) y r iM

16

www.islamic-studies.info

'jeMzr i

b b v +

/)v xb

bbn r

Q' v /$

g K xj" z80i-

i8

iM

'I

'_K$b n

Complex Question) 8) Q OP '

jF Q+ jFe Q n M

jF 8 J

cir vE_s'xrbjFKe
^ j

L b z Q

Li Q j ^

|
'

'FM
False

8) Q

i) jFe
'

jb

K+ J K Q

M = K j ) e s

jF z/ (Gray)% jFz)o bn r v
j z/

(Neutral)

8
'Dilemma

% n 'jF

MKv

!z

'5

(Accident Fallacy: Sweeping Generalization) S R

i S pc0'z) Bw n jF S
s' Bwv j
'jvEh 8?
' x 'b

'jvE

b% |x'j

17

www.islamic-studies.info

bJ Mz w i

(Converse Accident)

O'j8 J!

) i" # r i Mz/ #$

'n
i

z %

j
'-8/ X' 'j()r jFX'
'-+, - w

K&

.K/9r " * |

'

(Circular Reasoning) "

UD

"!

jv

MK> L (Circular Reasoning Fallacy)

) ^ 0 is'{ D1 z280 jF z

"

M
j
<

'j8b M

'8b ik 9
'j ?

ji n
'j|3rM j |) $ i
'{45 = 0 bij3 <
k9
'j <

18

www.islamic-studies.info

'

(Petitio Principi: Begging the Question) $VUD T

O'jF # r F zQ r b 6 j
v $V UD T
2
71 584 98. j
n r y K i'yzw zUD - yz80
8 z ):| r$s'jFe# r jF"!
iz = ZMK>

iz<r (Meditation) ; P
'

i @jis" B : { + u'j<?w$80i
+=

2 b):|jEz

'ji'jFM=

v C):| n
U E 3
'j

') vBMj ^

:FVKMK D
y 0r '8 8 z

80
M

_`j1 U
=

'j

'

(Straw Man Fallacy) X W

'jFzX"!

X"!

'jFz bX" v z

BH

'jFzzG /

:M

n jF 8 J

DM jFz)J80 r

i'

XW

jFz b jFzzI
'
(Ad Nauseam) UD Y '

80iTM)
|

|Q s'jF Mz

/ 0 080n

i
19

www.islamic-studies.info

L) ir |

0M) KM |'j b z

' zv 0 M |Q N ''yjM+ b

S
'

S &r8

N K

(Equivocation) [ Z '
M(EAR)QR bOb s'E [v /rn pc r$ P
2
'U9VW8 mrKXjFr M(MINE)S"T jFr

i' (EVENING)

BwM

0 is' er

j yb (SYRIA)Yn

Z) On jF
j K

= 9

!\[ <
']+

0M

'6H'[r /0v <

(Self Defeating Claims) \]'

s' zH g UD)
i ^ _48 'j" zyz _ 50
'n

M^A

AKD^i) '{ ^

'j` I 8,b 'j +wb 'jF+wb

20

www.islamic-studies.info

b Category Error
v xr bj )Jrc dn
:is'j / e N f Q)g

js

jFb y

i'" r

Kv j'j s 'j hii

hd i yzI0

P"'{ ^ j yeb" l" = kci

'j^:i

m ikci' 8 j

b_`a^ ' 5

(Biased/Unrepresetative Sample)
e# v`a ^

ji

F'j

ei ^o p Mw| K" 0 b
e )o b KwC

vi

KVV

Ni

nrih

q&cis'jF
'jv /w| K

rs

n 'j"Vrs" ci S i

'j"t+n ~ 'ju t+ VKDKD H )D K

j e"! i { u t+Mzvb VBwBwrH j S i

'z) w x p_ H ) j"t+~
c Bw x b j y
'a

HASTY GENERALIZATION n

oN

'jFr(Quantity)
an

E ais

'a j i Statement
'{i) ^ n

21

www.islamic-studies.info

{|

'v j zzv{|rV}~
'jMzv

e d c 'n

(Slothful Induction/Appeal to Coincidence )

0

bP 'j |$r e ijFer# B b-

}v r"{ / n s'jC bM j Fz 80 y
'j~ n

'{^ ci+

K cr mCM 0' mCb 0 ?+

+K i

e r Fz

" z % n r 0

cmC' ++v b| |r e )

|K

<i cHGmCM 0 '_| '6 z i + )

/M
i6

" TM

" : ) K

g v +b/ Gi / MK

"
b " r

'e =z8e 8 G
2

{|k " i 71
0b " <i) cmCM 0
Q u z |'K b () K Q) b Q

) 89
'z

'

(Fallacy of Composition and Division) ih fg

fg
'j ?Xd rsA

'jbArsB

'j ?Xd

22

www.islamic-studies.info

M M

" v j" zMrs80

i jF 8 J

s'j
'j"/a< jK< K"/a
' r$M<

'{ %/)U Bwv br

'j rs" cv j

Gn Mrs80O'j8 J! fg

i ih

'j ?Xd A

'jbYrsA

'j ?Xd

Yrs

s
' K 'j z" K$K
'jK

'j

' K

'K K 'K K

n 2M 8Ov z: b

&G

M!

'

' Perfectionist fallacy

(Ideal)" - MX(Realistic)

(Practical) n

jF 8 J

80 |i qM5n | j M | s' g P
'- q&cz c

23

www.islamic-studies.info

f
<i 0M ih

b :n 6
j

: o

'j+j

'j s : o
'j ? jz ?8b |)
j z / r " j ) r"

(Atheism)

v ?

'r

y^b

' Kij '% KM

H^Uy

8,b

Q ):|,/i ?

'jZM 'j r

8,b

b1
b2

b3
b4

n &gvrv ?

) jz: )| (Process) cM

8,b`

b5

'j `K 8,b <ij8 z

xbuv09 M

rKvKjin b"Jd 1 V

b6

'j
1

+FzrKv F

b7

'
o D v e'j ii - 0MDrVK

b8

j zi) aJ80
|

24

www.islamic-studies.info

'jF n z rX P

i (Aw

0K

K )

MKCn
+jF

b9

Mz8

0M 'KQr C n j 80
'j80C i

j z8r

8 K%K b10
'j b "$n i 8

+j

z e yKKc y~ zr"
'Cr +jz

i'_ "

MK r ]MjFz vE

Z | b11

t+

_/

b12

'j y
' G QM"g ' yMw|

b13

25