Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 2

NewsPrompt2

StudentStacyCarolwillbetakentoadisciplinaryhearingonApril10toberemovedand
takentothealternativeschooluntilshechoosestoremoveherlipjewelry.
Idontunderstandwhythedistrictwontdropthis,saysCarol,whodefendsherbody
modificationwithreligion.Ihaveneverbeensuspended.Infact,Ihaveneverhadareferral.I
amastraightAstudent.Ijustwanttogetbacktoclass.
Carolcontinuestoexplainhowhermotherandherselfcametothereligion.
MymotherandIjoinedthechurchoverthewinterbreak,Carolcontinues.Wehad
beensearchingforachurchsincewemovedtoLeaguetownlastyear.Wemeetattheminister's
housewithaboutsevento10memberseachSunday.
LareinaCarol,Stacysmother,issupportingherdaughterduringthistime.
IwasgratefulwhentheACLUagreedtohelpus,saysLareina.Thepiercingispartof
Stacysreligion.Mydaughterwantstogotoclass,butshealsodoesntwantherFirst
Amendmentrightstrampled.IaskedStacyifshewantedtobackdownandtakeoutthelip
jewelry,butshebelievesinourchurchandinourfreedom.Shewantstostandupforherself
andforthat,Iamproud.
OthersbelievethatTheChurchofBodyModificationdoesnotqualifyasatruereligion
andthattheFirstAmendmentdoesnotprotectthem.
PeoplecryFirstAmendmentviolationsallofthetime,saysJettRamirez,a
constitutionallawyer.Freedomofreligionisabigone.Justbecauseafewpeoplegettogether
andcallthemselvesachurchdoesnotmeantheyareachurchintheeyesofthelaw.Heck,In
AustraliathereisamovementforaJedichurch.Doesthatmeanwehavetoallowallteenage
boystowearJediKnightrobesandcarrylightsaberstoschool?Theschooldistrictshouldhold
itsground.Ibelievethecourtswillseetheabsurdityinthis.
Carolcontinuestoexplainwhatshebelievesandwhyshebelievesitisnotaproblem.
Wedontworshipatattooedgodoranythinglikethat,Carolsays,defendingherbelief
intheChurchofBodyModification.Ourspiritualitycomesthroughwhatwechosetodoto
ourselves.Throughbodymodification,wecanchangehowweseeourselvesandtheworld
aroundus.Noteverymemberhasafacialpiercing.Youchoosehowyouwanttoexpressyour
faith.
ParkerGordon,superintendentoftheschooldistrict,explainsanddefendsthedress
codethedistrictputintoplacein2009.
Whenwecreatedthisdresscodein2009,thedistrictsoughtinputfromstudents,faculty
andcommunitymembers,saysGordon.Together,wedesignedaplanthatwasappropriate
forourdistrict.Facialjewelrydidnotmakethecut.Wehaveadresscodetohaveorderand
disciplineinourschools.Imaginewhatourschoolswouldbelikeifweallowedstudentstowear
whatevertheyliked.Wealsowantourstudentstounderstandexpectationsindress.Employers
havedresscodes.Wearemodelingthebusinessworldwithourexpectations.
SoniaStephens,anACLUlawyer,defendsStacyandhercase.
Stacyhasasolidcase,Stephensclaims.Itisinthebestinterestoftheschooldistrict
toallowherareligiousexemptionfromthedresscode.Acourtcasewouldbecostlyand

lengthy.Thedistrictdoesnthavemuchtostandonsinceitalreadyhastworeligious
exemptionsonfile.Itwillbehardpressedtodefendthatinacourt.
AminaShakuriisastudentwhohasreceivedareligiousdresscodeexemptionfor
wearingherhijabatschool.
IdontthinkyoucancomparetheMuslimreligiontotheChurchofBodyModification,
saysAmina.Wehavearichandlonghistory.TherearemorethanabillionMuslimsworldwide.
Ourbeliefsaredocumented.IdonthaveaproblemwithStacyslippiercing,butcomparingher
lippiercingtomyhijabisabsurd.
TheministerofStacyschurchdeclinedtocommentonthematter.
Thedisciplinaryhearingwillhappentomorrowwiththeschooldistrict.TheAmericanCivil
LibertiesUnionsaystheywillsupportStacyandpursuehercaseincourtifsheloseswiththe
schooldistrict.

Вам также может понравиться