Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
researchthatwasrelevanttomyhypothesis.Specifically,inthispaperIworkedon
formattingandintroducinggraphsandtables,aswellasincorporatingthecommunication
ImadewithAndyregardingtheimportanceofastructuredphysicaleducationprogramin
promotingMVPA(intheconclusionssection)
Iarrivedatmycoreideasbyestablishtheconnectionwithenergyimbalancetobarriers
tophysicalactivity.Onepotentialbarriercouldbethegeneraltrendofnotplaying
outdoors,butratherbeingsedentaryindoors.Ithoughtaboutwhatspecificallyprevents
outdoorplay,andIcametotheconclusionthattheoutdoorenvironment,specifically
neighborhoodsafety,mightplayasignificantrole.
Ihopethisdraftexceedsexpectationswiththedevelopmentofthethesis,anda
strongabilitytosummarizetheresultsfromresearcharticles.PotentiallyIfell
belowthemarkinprovidinghighqualityofevidenceformyconclusions.
However,muchofthedataregardingthistopicisobservational.ThebestIcould
dowastolookforsystematicreviewstoincreasethelevelofevidence.Iwas
abletoincludesomeRCTintheinterventionssectionofmypaper
Iproofreadeachsectionindividuallytoseeifmythoughtswerewellconnectedan
organized,andthenreadthepaperoncethroughasawhole.
OtherthingstokeepinmindwhilereadingthisdraftisthatItrulyappreciateall
ofthewaysinwhichDr.Duffytaughtustothinkanalytically,andtousethe
resourcesavailabletous.Goingintoa20+pagepaperseemedintimidating,but
bytakingitslowandonedraftatatimetheundertakingwasdoable!
IvowthatIdidnotplagiarize.TheeffortsItookinavoidingplagiarisminthis
paperincludeproperparaphrasingandcitationofallthesourcesIutilizedfor
data.
Allison Burke
Writing for Community Nutrition
Introduction
The increasing rate of childhood obesity in the U.S. and around the
world is a significant public health concern. According to analysis of data
from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, the rates of
childhood obesity have doubled over the last 30 years (Ogden CL et al.
2014). Moreover, the prevalence of childhood obesity is greater in lowincome families according to the Pediatric Nutrition Surveillance System
findings in 2010 (Dalenius K 2010). According to this data, there was a 14.5%
prevalence of childhood obesity when the family income was between 51
and 100% of the federal poverty level, compared to 11.8% prevalence in
families whose income was between 151 and 185% of the federal poverty
level. The World Health Organization reports statistics retrieved from the
Final Report of the Commission on Ending Childhood Obesity of 2016. These
statistics state that childhood obesity rates are rapidly increasing,
specifically in low income and urban areas (World Health Organization 2015).
Many factors contribute to the childhood obesity pandemic or a chronic
imbalance between dietary intake and energy output, specifically physical
activity.
Figure 1
The above table corresponds to the amount of time (low, medium, high) spent outdoors and
variables including BMI, % obese, and level of MVPA and is separated based on gender.
Outdoor play environment and greater access to green space and play
equipment associates with greater MVPA among young children according to
an observational study (Nicaise, V et al 2011). This involved 51 preschoolers
in southern California. Researchers examined levels of unstructured outdoor
play. Unstructured outdoor play was any time spent outdoors during the
school day in which adult supervisors were not instructing or guiding the
children to partake in a particular activity. The researchers followed this
cohort of students and tracked their level of MVPA during 204 observation
periods that corresponded to the preschool recess. From the analysis,
geographical and social environment played a significant role in engaging
preschoolers in MVPA. Researchers compared level of activity between a
cement amphitheater playground and an open green-space park area.
Children were between 3.4 and 4.9 times more likely to engage in physical
activity when using green space. In addition, the researchers found that
children were more likely to engage in physical activity if they were either
alone or with one other child. Lastly, researchers noticed a relationship
between weight status and level of activity. Overweight children were 3.2
times less likely to engage in MVPA than their healthy weight counterparts.
Consistently, a systematic review of 28 studies aimed to determine the
level of evidence in the relationship between access to outdoor playtime and
physical activity, fitness and sedentary behavior. Many of the previous
studies had only been observational; therefore pooling and comparing results
from different studies strengthen the relationship between these variables at
establishing a more concrete relationship between outdoor play and physical
activity, cardiorespiratory fitness, musculoskeletal fitness, and sedentary
behavior (Gray, C et al. 2015).
Table 2
Table 3
Table 4
outdoor time associated with a lower amount of time per day spent being
sedentary. However, the third table in this series indicates a low quality of
evidence. Only two studies were included, and there was a high risk of bias.
The studies in this review were all observational, and therefore cannot
provide a high-quality level of evidence in relating the variables. However,
benefits of the study included that most used objectives measures such as
pedometers, accelerometers and GPS, to report levels of activity.
In summary of this section, across all publications, researchers have
found that more time spent outdoors is associated with increased time being
active, however some studies have concluded that the environment has to
be conducive to physical activity. This presents a challenge to children living
in urban socioeconomic areas as they may lack neighborhood security and
access to appropriate green space and play equipment to promote activity.
Increasing Physical Activity is Associated with Decreases in
Childrens BMI
The next question to consider is whether increases in physical activity
has an effect on the body composition and adiposity of children. The
following studies were found using PubMed including search terms Physical
Activity Child/Children/Childhood Obesity Body Composition and
BMI.
An observational study of a cohort of 2810 preschoolers in the Head
Start program found that providing access to outdoor physical activity during
the school day decreased the childs risk of developing obesity by 42% and
on average reduced total BMI by 0.18 points. (Ansari, A. et al 2015). Data
were gathered from 3-4 year old children who were enrolled in the Head Start
program, a government-funded preschool program for socioeconomically
disadvantaged children. The researchers stratified for initial BMI at the
beginning of the year, time spent outdoors at home, and neighborhood
safety. The preschool teachers were asked to categorize the time their class
spent outdoor within five-minute intervals. The childrens heights and
weights were taken four times throughout the year (twice during each term).
Overall, the researchers found that for every 1 minute increase in time spent
outdoors was associated in a 1% decrease in risk of becoming obese
indicated by an odds ratio (OR= 0.99). As shown in table 5, children who
had high levels of outdoor play had an overall decrease of 0.18 BMI points
more than children who had low levels of outdoor play at school. Children
who experienced the largest reduction in BMI based high levels of outdoor
play at school were those who were obese at the beginning of the school
year, those who lived in unsafe neighborhoods, and those who were less
active at home.
used pedometers throughout the school day to track total physical activity
and moderate to vigorous activity. In comparing the group means, Total PA
and MVPA was higher in boys than in girl participants and on average higher
in younger participants. Total physical activity was not significantly
associated with BMI z-scores across all children. However, healthy weight
children had higher significantly higher rates of MVPA than did the obese
children independent of age or sex (p value <0.001). While healthy weight
children also had higher rates of MVPA than overweight children, the data
wasn't statistically significant (p value = 0.18). The above findings suggest
an increased need for interventions specifically targeting young girls to
increase levels of physical activity. However, this was another observational
study and therefore cannot establish a cause and effect relationship on its
own. As another limitation, this study looked primarily at rurally located
children and this does not take into consideration the different resources and
disadvantages that are presented to children living in urban areas.
The previous two studies only established a correlation between
physical activity and BMI. In comparison, a nonrandomized control trial
examined if a causal relationship existed between physical activity and BMI
(Li, X. et al 2014). Specifically, the trial sought to determine the effectiveness
of physical activity interventions in the school setting in decreasing BMI. A
sample of 921 children between 7 and 15 were allocated to control and
intervention groups. The intervention group received a 12-week program of
physical education, afterschool physical activities, and home physical
activities as well as education on overall health for both participants and
their parents. The control group maintained their usual daily health practices.
Researchers assessed BMI, skinfolds, and duration of moderate to vigorous
physical activity, and blood glucose levels at the start and end of the 12week program. After the 12-week program, the intervention group had a
0.43 kg/m2 smaller average BMI than the control group. There were also
significantly larger decreases in skinfolds as well as fasting blood glucose
levels. In addition, the intervention group had longer average duration of
study used data from the ABCD longitudinal cohort. Socioeconomic status
was determined using status scores set by the Social and Cultural Plan
Bureau, and neighborhood safety was ranked using the Dutch Housing
Questionnaire. The study included other questions regarding prenatal and
postnatal health. Researchers used a mixed linear regression model to
interpret the relationship between the neighborhood environment and child
adiposity. Overall, the maternal health characteristics were a stronger
indicator for children's adiposity than socioeconomic status or neighborhood
safety.
In agreement, the Early Childhood Longitudinal Study identified that
parental perceptions of neighborhood safety can influence whether or not
children are allowed to spend unsupervised periods of time outdoors. In this
student researchers sought to find the effect of parental perceptions of
neighborhood safety in their children's BMI (Datar, A et al 2013). The
researchers found that perceived neighborhood safety did not significantly
influence a child's percent body fat or BMI but did have an impact on time
spent sedentary and physically active. This 9 year long longitudinal study
examined over 19,000 United States children between kindergarten and
eighth grade. Parents were asked to rank the safety of their neighborhood as
"very safe," "somewhat safe" or "not at all safe" during the 9 years. The
parents were interviewed 4 times when their children were in kindergarten,
third grade, fifth grade, and eighth grade. The researchers stratified for
gender, race, maternal education level as well as the level of "urbanicity" of
the neighborhood environment. The researchers asked the parents to specify
if their home was located in an urban area, city, or town.
From the analysis, unsafe neighborhoods significantly increased the
children's time spent sedentary watching TV as shown in Figure 2. Also
shown in figure 2, unsafe neighborhoods significantly decreased the time
spent partaking in physical activity. In addition, neighborhood safety did not
have a significant impact on BMI or % obese as shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3
e dark gray bar indicates children who lived in a neighborhood their parents
thought to be very safe. The light gray bar represents children who lived in
somewhat safe or not at all safe neighborhood
Th
spent outdoors during the school day could have a huge impact on childhood
obesity by providing access to outdoor play. One systematic review and meta
analysis found that by providing children with interventions (which promoted
increased time spent in MVPA) spent 24% of the lesson time engaging in
MVPA compared to children who followed their schools regular physical
education pattern (Ogden, CL 2014). By implementing more effective
strategies during the school day, the school commute, and by providing
afterschool activities, which promote MVPA, the energy imbalance that
contributes to childhood obesity could improve. In addition, by keeping the
socio-ecological model in mind and addressing interpersonal, intrapersonal,
institutional, community, and policy-based interventions through
interventions, the epidemic of childhood obesity may be reversed.
References
Ansari, A., Pettit, K., & Gershoff, E. (2015). Combating obesity in head start: Outdoor play
and change in children's body mass index. Journal of Developmental and Behavioral
Pediatrics : JDBP, 36(8), 605-612. doi:10.1097/DBP.0000000000000215 [doi]
Center for Disease Control. (Aug 27 2015). Childhood obesity facts. Retrieved
from http://www.cdc.gov/healthyschools/obesity/facts.htm
DaleniusK,BorlandE,SmithB,PolhamusB,GrummerStrawnL.PediatricNutritionSurveillance2010Report.
Atlanta:U.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices,CentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention;2012.
Datar, A., Nicosia, N., & Shier, V. (2013). Parent perceptions of neighborhood safety and
children's physical activity, sedentary behavior, and obesity: Evidence from a national
longitudinal study. American Journal of Epidemiology, 177(10), 1065-1073.
doi:10.1093/aje/kws353 [doi]
Gray, C., Gibbons, R., Larouche, R., Sandseter, E. B., Bienenstock, A., Brussoni, M., . . .
Tremblay, M. S. (2015). What is the relationship between outdoor time and physical
activity, sedentary behaviour, and physical fitness in children? A systematic
review. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12(6), 64556474. doi:10.3390/ijerph120606455 [doi]
Gunter, K. B., Nader, P. A., & John, D. H. (2015). Physical activity levels and obesity status of
oregon rural elementary school children. Preventive Medicine Reports, 2, 478-482.
doi:10.1016/j.pmedr.2015.04.014 [doi]
Hrudey, E. J., Kunst, A. E., Stronks, K., & Vrijkotte, T. G. (2015). Do neighborhood
characteristics in amsterdam influence adiposity at preschool age? International Journal
of Environmental Research and Public Health, 12(5), 5561-5580.
doi:10.3390/ijerph120505561 [doi]
Li, X. H., Lin, S., Guo, H., Huang, Y., Wu, L., Zhang, Z., . . . Wang, H. J. (2014). Effectiveness of
a school-based physical activity intervention on obesity in school children: A
nonrandomized controlled trial. BMC Public Health, 14, 1282-2458-14-1282.
doi:10.1186/1471-2458-14-1282 [doi]
Mendoza, J. A., Watson, K., Baranowski, T., Nicklas, T. A., Uscanga, D. K., & Hanfling, M. J.
(2011). The walking school bus and children's physical activity: A pilot cluster