Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 5

RUNNINGHeader:ETHICALANDLEGALCONSIDERATIONS1

EthicalandLegalConsideration
NicoleKalwa
Rasmussen

AuthorNote:
NicoleKalwa,MedicalLawandEthics,RasmussenUniversity.
Thisisapaperaboutacourtcaseaboutthatdealtwithsurrogacy.Iwillprovideevidencealong
withanalysisandmyopinionsaboutthecourtcase.

EthicalandLegalConsiderations

EthicalandLegalConsiderations
SurrogacyCourtCase
HelenBeasley,26yearsold,fromBritainwasleftpregnantwithtwins.Shewasnotable
toaffordtotakecareofthetwinsalongwithhersevenyearoldson.Thesituationthatleft
Beasleypregnantwasasurrogacycontractthatsoonwasbroken.HelenBeasleyfoundCharles
BermanandMarthaWheeleronlineandwantedtohelpthemoutbecausetheywerenotableto
havekids.Beasleycommunicatedwiththecoupleviaemail.ThecoupleofferedBeasley
$20,000forcarryingthebaby.OncethecouplefoundoutBeasleywaspregnantwithtwinsthey
wereshocked.Courtdocumentsindicatethatthecontractshesignedcalledforhertoabortany
additionalfetusesifshehadmultiplefertilization,...(CNN2001).Although,Beasleywasnot
thelegalparentorguardianofthetwinsshewascarryingsheopposedofabortingoneofthe
children.Beasleytoldthecoupleshewaspregnantwithtwinswhenshewas8weeks,however,
thecoupledidnotmentionanythingaboutanabortionuntilshewas13weekspregnant.The
threehadorallyagreedthatanyabortionwouldoccurbefore12weeksofgestation(LosAngeles
Times2001).ThecoupletoldBeasleytohaveanabortionwithoneofthebabiesuntilshewas
thirteenweekspregnantwhichwastoolateandtoofaralonginthepregnancy.Thecouple
decidedtoterminatethecontractandsueBeasley....reimbursethem$80,000inexpenses,
sayingshebroketheircontract(LosAngelesTimes2001).Beasleywaspregnantwithtwins,
gettingsuedandnotbeingabletofindafamilyforthetwinsbecauseshewasnotthelegal
guardian.

EthicalandLegalConsiderations

My

ThoughtsOnTheCase
HelenBeasleywasleftwithtwinsandhersevenyearoldsontotakecarewhichwas
difficultforherbecausesheisasinglemother.Whenthey'reborn,whathappenstothem?"
shetoldtheSanFranciscoChronicle."Ican'thavethem(CNN2001).Beasleyisnotthelegal
guardianbutshouldbecomethelegalguardianbecauseshejustwantsthebestforthebabies
knowingshewillnotbeabletoprovideforthemandknowingWheelerandBermanarenot
acceptingofhavingtwins.Beasleyjustwantsthechildrentoliveahappylifewithacaring
family."Theydidn'twanttwobabies.Theywantedonebabyandthat'sit,"TheresaErickson,a
SanDiegoattorney,saidearlierthisweek."WhenHelensaidshewouldn'treduce,theysaid,
'Well,weonlywantedone.Wedon'twanttoseparatethem,soyoufigureoutwhatyou'regoing
todowiththetwobabies'"(CNN2001).Beasleywasleftinahorriblesituationbecausethe
couplewasclearonwantingonechildbutleftBeasleytodecideonwhatshouldbedone.
BeasleyshouldalsogetmoneyfromWheelerandBermanbecausetheyleftherinadifficult
situationandwillnothelpher.
InordertoavoidthesituationWheelerandBermanshouldhavegonetoasurrogacy
clinicsotheprocesswouldhavebeenthoughtfullyprocessed.Also,Beasleyshouldhavebeen
carefulwithwhatthecontractsaysbecauseshedidbreakitbynotgoingthroughwhatwas
stated.BermanandWheelerdidnotwanttoseparatethetwinsbutwantedoneofthemaborted
whichmakesnosensebecausethebabytwinwouldhavebeenseparatedeitherway.Berman
andWheelerarelegalguardiansoftheunborntwinssotheyshouldfindafamilythatwillaccept
thetwinsandbeabletoprovideforthem.AnotherwayBerman,Wheeler,andBeasleycould

EthicalandLegalConsiderations

haveavoidedthissituationisBermanandWheelercouldhaveadoptedababy.Itwouldhave
beenalongwaitbutbetterthantogothroughcourts.

Reference

Glionna,J.M.(2001,August11).TwinsRejected,SurrogateBirthMotherSues.RetrievedMay
31,2016,from<
http://articles.latimes.com/2001/aug/11/local/me33076
>

Surrogatesuesparentsoverunborntwins.(2001,August13).RetrievedMay31,2016,from
<
http://edition.cnn.com/2001/US/08/11/surrogate.twins/
>

EthicalandLegalConsiderations

Вам также может понравиться