Rubric for Evaluation11CP Writing Portfolio

Element

Criteria

Points or check

Goal followup
(W2a-f)

Two pieces of evidence for the goal are

selected, relevant to the goal recorded, and all of
this information is provided in a LIST prior to the
paragraph.
Background and reasoning for goal
selected is clearly explained in the paragraph.
Paragraph(s) is/are logically organized,
using appropriate transitions.
Reflection demonstrates understanding of
progress, recognition of remaining challenges.
Conclusion statement provides a
suggestion of goals in the future or continued
challenges.

______/ 10

Punctuation
Errors
(W5)

15 punctuation errors are located and

corrected.
Explanations provided identify the type of
error made as well as the correction.

Complete 5
pts?
Yes/No

Major essay
revision
(W2a-f, 5, 6)

Original draft of writing is included (if not,

-5 point deduction)
Areas of most significant revision are
highlighted on new copy. (W5)
Areas of revision respond to feedback on
initial draft. (W5)
Draft has clearly improved.
Paragraph demonstrates reflection and
revision process undergone through writing
process (W2a-f, W6).

______/10

Personal
Narrative
Draft
(W4, 10)

- Essay is between 400-600 words in length.

- Writer uses some elements of storytelling such
as imagery, dialogue, or other figurative language
to SHOW the events rather than TELL them.
- In addition to telling a story, writer
communicates something about him/herself and
addresses how this quality will translate into the
future (post-HS goals, etc)
- Writer establishes and maintains a positive and
reflective tone.

____/10

Overall

Reflection is at least one page.

_____/10

Reflection
(W2a-f)

Reflection utilizes a strong introduction and

conclusion, demonstrates focus and develops
ideas in a logically organized fashion using
specific examples. Identifies goals moving
forward.

Organization
/
Aesthetics

_____/5
Components appear in order.
Apparent effort has been made to make the
journal appear neat, organized, and readable.

By submitting this work digitally, I certify that all work present in this portfolio is 100% my
own. I understand that this project must be submitted digitally to Google Classroom by 2:20
on Friday June 10.

for Evaluation11CP Writing Portfolio

Element

Criteria

Points or check

Goal followup
(W2a-f)

Two pieces of evidence for the goal are

selected, relevant to the goal recorded, and all of
this information is provided in a LIST prior to the
paragraph.
Background and reasoning for goal
selected is clearly explained in the paragraph.
Paragraph(s) is/are logically organized,
using appropriate transitions.
Reflection demonstrates understanding of
progress, recognition of remaining challenges.
Conclusion statement provides a
suggestion of goals in the future or continued
challenges.

______/ 10

Punctuation
Errors
(W5)

15 punctuation errors are located and

corrected.
Explanations provided identify the type of
error made as well as the correction.

Complete 5
pts?
Yes/No

Major essay
revision
(W2a-f, 5, 6)

Original draft of writing is included (if not,

-5 point deduction)
Areas of most significant revision are
highlighted on new copy. (W5)
Areas of revision respond to feedback on
initial draft. (W5)
Draft has clearly improved.
Paragraph demonstrates reflection and
revision process undergone through writing
process (W2a-f, W6).

______/10

Personal
Narrative
Draft
(W4, 10)

- Essay is between 400-600 words in length.

- Writer uses some elements of storytelling such
as imagery, dialogue, or other figurative language
to SHOW the events rather than TELL them.
- In addition to telling a story, writer
communicates something about him/herself and
addresses how this quality will translate into the
future (post-HS goals, etc)
- Writer establishes and maintains a positive and
reflective tone.

____/10

Overall
Reflection
(W2a-f)

Reflection is at least one page.

Reflection utilizes a strong introduction and
conclusion, demonstrates focus and develops
ideas in a logically organized fashion using
specific examples. Identifies goals moving
forward.

_____/10

Organization
/
Aesthetics

_____/5
Components appear in order.
Apparent effort has been made to make the
journal appear neat, organized, and readable.

By submitting this work digitally, I certify that all work present in this portfolio is 100% my
own. I understand that this project must be submitted digitally to Google Classroom by 2:20
on Friday June 10.