: ,

: ,
:
:
: E
: 1115M014
E-mail: takseisithikh@gmail.com
: , 2015-2016
: , ,
:
: : Derrida Benjamin

1. : Derrida Benjamin;
) Derrida
Derrida -,
/ ,
1989 Drucilla Cornell Cardozo
Law School, Deconstruction and the Possibility of Justice [
]. , Benjamin
.
, , Derrida
(
):
[Je dois] ( dois, devoir; I must; I should; I ought
to; I have to;),
[force] .
: , , ,
, (Derrida, 2015: 14-15) -
, .
, ,
, . -
- - [...]

(.: 15-16)
Derrida , ,
:

 ,
, ,
(.: 17)
enforce the law,
, :
, a priori, ,
enforced, (.: 17-18)
.
, .
, ,
, , . , Derrida :
, , ,
, ,

(.: 22).
, ,
: [ ] to enforce the law,
,
, .
, [langage] [langue],
incipit : (.: 29).
O Derrida Pascal Montaigne,
-:
Pascal : [ ,
enforced. ,
]. .
, . .
. , , -,
- (.: 31).
, , Montaigne , , . ,
. .
, . - [credit]
.
- . ,
. [acte de foi] .
(.: 34).
Derrida :
, ,
1,
[croyance]. , Derrida, , - ,
, ,
. - ,
, Derrida , Pascal
Montaigne, . ,
1

. Derrida, 2015: 192.

 , ,
[] [] ,
:
, , , .
, , , .
, . . (.: 40)
, - ,
, ()
. , , Derrida, , - (. )
(.: 54):

, - .
, ( ,
,
. , , ,
,
, , ; (.: 55).
, ,
2,
Derrida , []
(, , , ,
), , ,
, , -
(.: 57-58)
, Derrida, ,
- , , ,
. , Derrida, , :
1. : 3 (.: 61 .)
( ) , ,
.
2. :

-
Marx :
.
, ,
.
,
, , , ,
, ,
,
. par excellence
, , (Marx, 1978: 27-28).
3

,
, -.

 (), ,
. .
.
(., 64 .).
-
, [ide
de la justice infinite], , ,
- , , , ,
. -
Pascal-,
, , , ,
, , [raison]
[rationalite] .
- -- . .
/ . / .
, ,
, ,
[discours] ,
, : (.: 68-69).
3. :
/ ,
. , (. 71 .)
Derrida, ,
, , ,
.
,
-
, , ,
,
, , ..
.
. ,
, : (.: 77)
,
/ , Derrida Benjamin.

) Derrida Benjamin
Derrida, Benjamin
, (.: 97):
1) , (die rechtsetzende Gewalt)
, , ,
2) () ( , rechtsvernichtend) . Derrida
, Benjamin,
() ( ) .

3) (Gerechtigkeit) (Macht)
.
Derrida Benjamin
Benjamin.
, Derrida , ,
, , -,
Benjamin .
,
: , ,
Benjamin
, ,
, (.: 85) Derrida
. , -
. -,
. ,
( Benjamin) ,
(.: 118). , Derrida ,
Benjamin, , ,
:
[est relevee, aufgehoben]. Aufhebung [] - , rechtsetzende [], ,
, .
, ,
. - , -
, : , ,
- . ,
, , , ,
Benjamin (.: 130).
(.:133).
Derrida ,
-, . Benjamin, , ,
Derrida, , , ,
, ()
( ) ,
. Benjamin, Derrida,
,
(
),
.
, ,
. ,
(.: 146-149, Derrida).
, Benjamin , , ,
, , ,
(.: 155, Derrida). Derrida
,
,
:
,
Aufklarung [] , , ,

 . , ,
, (
Benjamin) ,
(.: 154-155).
Derrida, Benjamin , ,
, ,
, ,
Staatsgewalt, , .
,
Schmitt , (.:
164-165). , Benjamin
,
, (.: 165).
, , ,
, .
, , ,
,
, , (.: 168). ,
, Derrida
Benjamin: (1926-1927) Benjamin

(.: 184)
. , ,
(Aufklarung, , , , ,
)
, ,
(.: 185-186)
, Derrida Benjamin,
- Derrida, :
Zur Kritik der Gewalt [representation]
[representation]
. , (
) , 1921, -Aufklarung
[fait surface] [surfer]
1920 1930. Carl Schmitt- Benjamin
- (.: 84)
Benjamin, 1921,
,
,
(.: 86)
, -, ,
;

.
, ,
, - ,
, . ,

 Benjamin, , - .

. ,
, ,
( ,
), -
- , , , ,
( ).
,
[destruction] Destruktion. ,
,
. (.:
186-187)
Derrida . Benjamin,
- ,
, ,
// , ,
Schmitt Heidegger,
. ,
, ,
Derrida, , , Benjamin
,
, , , ,
, . ,
-, ,
- ,
,
- Benjamin Derrida.

) Derrida Benjamin = Derrida Benjamin

Derrida Benjamin
, .
, Derrida
,
Benjamin ,
.
Benjamin
, -
. (
) ,
- , , ,
, 4. , ,
.
,
.
, ,
4

-, . Derrida, 2015: 213, 52.

 Derrida,
. -
, , , ,
, : -
. , , .
, ,
, ,
, .
, ,
- , Derrida Benjamin
.
Derrida , , . ,
, Benjamin.

, ,
,
, ,
. , ,
, (-) , -
(-), , Tractatus Wittgenstein,
Benjamin ,
- . ,
, , ,
Derrida . ,
Derrida Benjamin,
/
- Benjamin ,
, , .
Benjamin, ,
() .
Benjamin Derrida,
- Benjamin
, Derrida Benjamin, 1989,
, ,
. ,
- .
, , , Derrida ,
, ,
. Derrida
, ,
Seattle, ,
- , ,
Derrida, .
:
, ,

( :
1917, , , , - .. ..). ,

 . (Derrida, 1996: 7071).

, ,
, - ,
.
[] , ,
. ,
. , ,
[sans pouvoir].
[ ]. . []
: .
, [] (.: 276)
Derrida Benjamin ;
Derrida Benjamin,
,
- . Derrida Benjamin Derrida
Benjamin, .
, , Derrida Benjamin,
4 ,
:
1. , , .
2. .
3.
.
4.
.

2.
)
Ted Lewellen, 99% 2 3
, , , ,
(Lewellen, 2003: 44).
.
,
.
,
. ,
() .
,
.
Pierre Clastres,
, . Clastres,
,

 ) , )

) ( , ,
, - ). ( .
). , -
.
, .
, ( .
). ,
, , .
, . (Clastres,
1992: 35-36).
. ,
, , (.: 37).
, , ., , ,
(.: 38). ,
. , , , ,
, , (.: 38).
- , . ,
, ( )
( , ) , ,
. .
,
. ,
, , (.:
47). , .
, , ,

, .
, Clastres, ,
, .
,
, , ,
, , (.: 49-50).
, ,
. leaders ,
: , ,
,
(.: 48). , ,
.
, , , Derrida,
, .
, ,
(.: 164-166):
, ,
,
.
, , ,
(.: 168)

 Clastres, ,
, .
,
, ,
(.: 181, 226-235).
, , , ,
, Benjamin
Derrida . ,
, , ,
, .
, Clastres
,
, .
, . , ,
, , , , , .
. , ,
, 5 ,
Derrida, :
. , ,
: , , .
, , , . , . ,
, ,
(), ,
.
, , .
, , , .
, , : , .
, , : .
,
, :
. (.: 196-197).
Clastres Claude Levi-Strauss,
.
, 1938 Nambikwara -
, . ,
, .
: ,
[] , .
,
, []
. .
,
.
.
.
: .
. , ,
5


. ,
[]
[]
.
, []
; ,

. (Levi-Strauss, 2007: 274, 276,277). Levi-Strauss
, Rousseau
,
: ,
, ,
.
.

: ,
(.: 281). Levi-Strauss, Clastres,
-,
.
, Clastres, Andrea Staid,
, :
chefferie , ,
. , , chefferie,
,
(Staid, 2016: 44).
, , ,
(.: 40). Staid
(.: 43) (, ,
. , .
. , .
),
(.: 33-34), , ,
(.: 30).
,

, Staid (.: 30), (.:
29), (.: 26) .
Aidan Southall 5 : )
, )
)
) ) ,
, .
, , ,
,
-,
, .
:Kung Bushmen , Siriono Nambikuara Indians ,
Murngin Tiwi , Kwakiutl , Nuer Sudan Turkana
, Kalinga Ifugao , Plateau Tonga Zambia, Siane Star Mountain peoples New
Guinea. -,
, ,

, , , ,
(Southall, 1968).
. ,
,
,
, ()
.
, ed Lewellen , ,
(bands), (tribes) (chiefdoms) ,
(Lewellen, 2003: 20-21).
!Kung Bushmen (), Pugmies (), Inuit (, ), Shoshone
(..), (-) .
Kpelle ( ), Yanomano (, ), Nuer
() Cheyenne (..), (-) Iroquois (..) Oaxaca
Valley (). , Hawaii,
Kwakiutl (), Tikopia (), Dagurs (),
Ashanti, Benin, Dahomy Skotish Highlanders.
,
.

,

, () . ,

,
taboo (.: 20 .).
, !Kung Bushmen, , ,
,
,
, ,
.
, . Yanomano,
,
,
.
Kwakiutl , potlatch,
,
-
(.: 24-25).
Georges Balandier, ,
, ,
,
. -
-
.
,
, , .
: ,
, , []
(Balandier, 1990: 69). Balandier

 , ,
, , , , ,
, , , (.: 94
.). ,

, ,
,

, , Balandier . , ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
(.: 111).
Fortes Evans-Pritchard, African Political Systems
,
,
Nuer. Evans-Pritschard Nuer 1930
() - , ,

Nuer (, ). Nuer
, 5.000 30.000-45.000
. Pritschard
, :
T ,
, ,
[] , ,
. A , , ,
. T ,

[]E (
) . , ,
, ,
. , ,
,
, , []
.
, ,
/. T ,
,
. T . E,
, , ,
, , , ,
. ,
,
. O N, , , .
O . A
,
, , , ,

[] , , , ,
. H ,

, , ,
N , (Pritchard, Fortes, 1940-2011/2012: 135 .). O Pritschard
Clastres , - : O N
N .
, ,
N []M
, ,
. H . ,
, , ,
-
, , . A
,
( )
(.: 139).
M ,
,
Nuer. T T N, P. Bohannan,
T , R. Firth. O John Middeton David Tait,
African Political Systems,
Tribes without Rulers. , 1958, (800.000 ), Lugbara
(240.000), Amba (30.000) Konkomba (45.000), Dinka (900.000) Mandari (15.000)
, ,
(Middleton-Tait, 1958: 28). , Dinka,
, ,
. Lugbara ( ),
250.000 , () ,
. , .
, . , ,
, - ,
, ,
(.: 203, Scwarz, Turner, Tuden, 1966: 152).
Kuikuru (.: 73), .
Carib-Speaking Waiwai, . Kuikuru
. -
, , -,
(.: 79).
,
, ,
, (.: 76-77). Kuikuru
, , .
Kuikuru ,
.
. (.
). )
) .
, ,
.
(.: 255)
, ,
.
,

. , ,
. ,
20 20.000 6.000 ,
,
, (Gasey, 2012: 103). Ila,
(Swartz, Turner, Tuden, 1966: 275), , ,
, , .
.
, ,
,
. mosulozhi () mukaindi ().
,
, , .
,
.
- . ,
. Ila, Swat
Pathans (., 275 .)
. . , khan, ,
, .
, .
, , mullahs, ,
. ,
. ,
, , ,
.
.
Pemon, , ,
. Pemon,
18 , 1980 4.000 . ,
, ,
, ,
, .
(, , , , .),
, ,
,
. Pemon
.
, ,
, . Pemon
,
(Thomas, 1982: 1-10). , Pemons
, ,
,
, .
Charles J-H Macdonald (Macdonald: 2009), Palawan
30 . Palawan 45.000
, . T Palawan , ,
, , .

 V.W.Turner, o Kafwana Ndembu

.
.
,
, serous servorum Dei (Turner, 1966: 102-104). Gerard Casey,
, 500 . 1600 . ,
- 500.000 ,
150 , 3000 .

.
. : ) -honour price )
, ) .
,
(Gasey, 2012: 105-107). ,
, ,
.
.
,
: 1) ,
2) 3) 4)
5) 6) : )
, ) )
, . )
) -,

. . , , , , , ,
, , , , , , , , , ,
, , , , , . (, 1997: 209 .).
,
nonviolent conflict management,
. Hopi , o Rotumans , Paliyans
La Paz , Mardu Aborigines , Nubias , Sama
Dilaut , Semaia ,
(Kemp, Fry: 2004).
, .
,
. ,
,

. (.: 160 .) : )
) )
( , . Hopi, Paliyan,
Nubians Mardu) )
, , . )
- ,
) , (, . )
(, , , ,
). ,
.
,

 ,
. Afikpo -
.Oko Elechi Doing Justice without State ,
. A 1902 , Afikpo
,
.
, Afikpo ,
.
-
. , ,
, .
- , Ashanti
Igbo (O.Oko Elechi, 2006: ).
(.: 117 .-.6, 221
.-). , ,

. .
,
. ,
. Afikpo
,
.
.
Afikpo.
, ,
, ,
, .
, ,
.
, .
, -, ,
,
, .
Okpota,
. .
- ,
. , ,
. ,
Afikpo, ,
.
. Afikpo
, .
, , )
. ,
.
,
, , . ,
,
.
, , .
, ,
Ekpuke Essa .

 , , , , ,
, ,
. ( 15 16 ), Ekpuke Eto,
,
.
, , ,
, .. ,
. , 100 ,
, ,
. .
,
. Afikpo
, .
,
,
. .
.
, ,
.
/. ,
.
. ,
. ,
- , , ,
. ,
.
, ,

.
Afikpo
. 90
, ,
.
(restorative justice) ,
- , ,
.
.
, ,
, .
, - ,
,,
. : (, , , ),
(conflict resolution), (alternative dispute
resolutions), , , (deliberation
democracy) . []
. ,

.

,
(). H
,

,
() ()

)
,
.
, , :
) , .
) , .
) , .
,
6, / Youtube Wikipedia
. ,
,
, (:
2012). ,
, ( ,
, .),
, , , , , , 7
.. ,
- ,
8. ,
,
, , .
, ,

, 9. 29 1871
, ,
, .
, ,
,
. 8
. 15
. 16

. 26
, ,
. 27
,
,
. 28
,
,
6

, . Negri A. Hardt, 2009, De Angelis, 2007, , 2012.

, 2012.
8
. , Sutton, 2003.
9
, . , 2007.
7

 . ,
- ,
.
, ,
, , - .
, ,
.
, , ,
.
, Marx, Engels, Lenin,
, , , -
10.
, -,
,
.
, , ,
.
,
,
Marx, Engels, Lenin , .

)
, ,
Derrida Benjamin, Benjamin, . Derrida
, ,
- ,
, , , . ,
Derrida
. Benjamin, ,
, Derrida ,
,
, . ,
Derrida Benjamin , , ,
, ,
,
.
Derrida Benjamin, ,
, , . Derrida
-11 Montagne,
, -
. Benjamin
() , ,
10

,
, . http://leninreloaded.blogspot.gr/2012/03/blogpost_08.html
11
, Derrida
, (morale). ,
[excedance] [ethique hyperbolique], [ethique]
. [morale] . !.
Derrida, 2015: 278.

 , , ,
() , .
Benjamin, Sittliche verhltnisse
, Moralitt
Kant Sittlichkeit Hegel ,
12. ,
Derrida-Benjamin
, Moralitt Sittlichkeit,
Hegel.
Kant, Moralitt
, ,
(Kant, 1984: 51 .) (Kant, 2004). Sittlichkeit
Sitten, , Kant
,
. Hegel
(Moralitt) (Sittlichkeit)
, - 13-
Hegel,
.
/ , Hegel

- Spinoza . Gilles
Deleuze, Spinoza, (morale)
, / (ethique) : (thique)
. .
. ,
, : ,
, .
, *
. , (morales)
, : , ,
[] (thique)
(Deleuze, 2002: 329 .). Spinoza,
- (.: 300). Hegel

, ,
.

12

http://criticallegalthinking.com/2013/10/11/notes-thought-walter-benjamin-critique-violence/.
: : )
, , ,
) , , ,
, , . , , ,
. ,
:
) , ,
, , ,
. , (Hegel,
: . 70-71, . 33). : ) [] ,
) ,
. - (.
.. 77,: Moralitt) , , ,
: /, (. .. 78: Sittlichkeit).
G.W.Hegel, 2015, .52, -. 487.
13

 , Hegel -
(Hegel, 2005: 443 ),
, Sittlichkeit
- .
,
,
, .
, - , (Moralitt)
,
(Sittlichkeit) Volkgeist. -
,
,
. () ,
,
- Kant
. Hegel
, -, ,
Spinoza,
G. Herder,Friedrich Schlegel, Novalis,
- 14, , ,
, ,

-.
Derrida
Benjamin, Sittlichkeit Moralitt -,
() . Hegel,
( )
,
(Notstaat, Verstandstaat)15, (Vernunftstaat) 16

.
, -
. ( Marx

14

-
, . Ross,
15
. , (. )
(Hegel, 2012: . 183). Hegel: 183,
(. Hegel) .
. , ,
... ,
, , ,
, .
, , (J.P Lefebvre,
P. Machere, 2006: 29).
16
(, 2007: 339 ., 381),
Hegel. ,
.
, , , ,
. Hegel, (Vernunft)
(Verstand) , (. ),
,
-.

 Hegel17)
, , , , /
.
, , - .
- (), -
,
, , ,
, , Derrida,
-
. , ()
, ,
.
-
; O Benjamin
,
, , , ,
-. Benjamin -,
Kant,
(), -, , - - .
Giorgio Agamben:
, , ,

(..). ,
, ,
. , -
, . ,
, ,
,
(Foucault)
, .
;
'
:
; (
.) ; (
[Vysinsklj] [Pasukanis].) '
. ,, ,
, , ,
, , .
,
.
17

. O Marx Hegel :
, ,
, .
(Marx, ,
1978: 95). Hegel ,
,
- (Marx 1978:36,37) . Marx-Engels
, , ,
. Hegel Marx
, MacGregor,1985: 195 .

 , .
( ) .

, ,
, .
,
, .
,
. , ,
. .
, '
,
' (. Agamben, 2007: 110 .)
, Agamben Benjamin, ( Benjamin
) - .
, , , Derrida,
, , Hegel ,
, .
,
, , . ,

.
- ,
.
Derrida,
,
, .
, ,
, 18.

3.
Derrida Benjamin, . ,
Benjamin ()
.
, Derrida Benjamin,
, , . ,
. Derrida
/- ,
.
. ,
,
.
, ,
18

Derrida
, , 2003.
.
, Derrida, ,
. ,
, -.

 , , ,
( ) .
(stateness) - ,
,
.
, ,
, , / .
,
.
, Elinor Ostrom
: , , .
, ,
. Ostrom 50 15.000
19.
, , , .
:
( ) (
) .
,
(Ostrom, 2012: 84). Ostrom
,

.
-,
, (.: 142):
1. , , .
2. , , ,
, , / , .
3. ,

4. : .
5. .
6.
7. ,

8. , , . ,

Ostrom ,
.
19

Ostrom 1989 5.000

(Ostrom, 2002: 12).
100 , 1000 (.: 99).

 : , , & ,
.& , -, , , ,
, & , , ,
.
, Ostrom 7
,
, ,
.
: ) ) )
) ) )
) ( )
(.: 293).
Ostrom :
, ( ,
( ),
, ,
, . ,
, , ..,
.

.
, ,
Derrida Benjamin. +
-> ,
,
, , .
- , , . - ,
- .

B
Agamben Giorgio, , , , 2007.
Balandier Georges, , , , 1990.
Casey Gerard, Libertarian Anarchy-against the State, Continuum, 2012
Clastres Pierre, , , , 1992.
Deleuze Gilles, , ,
, , 2002.
Derrida Jaques, , -- , , 2015.

Derrida Jaques, - , ,
, , 1996.
De Angelis, Massimo, The Beginning of History: Value Struggles and Global Capital, Pluto Press, 2007.
Elechi O.Oko, Doing Justice without the State-The Afikpo (Ehugbo) Nigeria Model, Routledge, 2006.
Evans-Pritschard E.E, Fortes M., African Political Systems, Oxford University Press-International African Institute,
1940- , , , 2011-2012.
Hegel G.W.F, - , --
, , 2005.
Hegel G.W.F, , -- , ,
2012.
Kant Immanuel, , -- ,
, 2004.
Kant Immanuel, , -- , ,
1984.
Kemp Graham, Fry Douglas P. (edited), Keeping the Peace-Confict resolution and peace societies around the world,
Routledge, 2004.
Lefebvre, J.P, Machere, P., , , , 2006.
Lenin V.I, , , 2012.
Levi-Strauss, Claude, , , , 2007.
Lewellen Ted, Political Anthropology-An Introduction, 3rd Edition, Praeger, 2003.
Marx Karl, , ,
, 1978.
McDonald, Charles J-H, The anthropology of anarchy, School of Social Sciences, Paper Number 53, 2009.
McGregor, David, The Communist Ideal in Hegel and Marx, University of Toronto Press, 1984.
Negri Antonio, Hardt Michael, Commonwealth, Harvard University Press, 2009.
Ostrom Elinor, , , , 2002
Ross Nathan, On Mechanism in Hegels Social and Political Philosophy, Routledge, 2008.
Southall Aidan, Stateless Society, International Encyclopedia of Social Sciences, 1968.
Staid Andrea, , , , 2016
Sutton, Robert P, Communal Utopias and the American Exprerience-Religious Communities 1732-2000, Praeger,
2003.
Swartz Marc J., Turner Victor, Tuden Arthur (edited), Political Anthropology, Aldine Publishing Company, 1966.
Thomas, David John, Order without Government-The society of the Pemon Indians of Venezuela, Illinois Studies of
Anthropology, No.13, 1982.
Turner Victor, The ritual process-structure and anti-structure, Cornel University Press, 1966.

 , , .
, IV- , , 1997.
, , , 2012
, -
, , 2012.
, 1871, , 2007.
, :
;