Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
Ms.BethBridges
ChairwomanoftheBoard
LubbockChamberofCommerce
1500Broadway,Suite101
Lubbock,TX79401
DearMs.Bridges:
WeunderstandthatthemissionoftheChamberistostrengthen,promoteandserveitsmemberbusinesses,
andhavesupportedtheChamberinthepastbecauseofthisbeneficialservice.However,wewereextremely
disappointedtofindthatourlocalChamberisoneofnineorganizationsjoiningthesuitagainsttheDepartment
ofLaborFiduciaryRule.Wecanonlyassumethatthedecisionwasmadewithoutasolidunderstandingofthe
issuesinvolved.
Toillustrate,theChamberopinesinitscomplaint:
ManyoftheLubbockChambersmemberssponsor401(k)sandotherretirementplansfortheir
employeesandwillnegativelybeaffectedbytheRule.AnumberoftheLubbockChambersmembers
arefinancialservicesprovidersandinsurancecompanieswhowillincursignificantcomplianceandother
costsasaresultoftheRulesexpansionoffiduciarystatus.Asaresult,theLubbockChambers
memberseffortstoprovidecompetentandaffordablefinancialproductsandservicestoconsumerswill
beharmed
Infact,wewouldpointoutthat401(k)plansarealreadysubjecttothefiduciarystandardsofERISAandarenot
impactedbythisRule.Inaddition,thereisabsolutelynothingintheRulethatwillaffectmemberseffortsto
providefinancialproductsandservicestoconsumers.TheRuleonlyappliestoadvice,nottothesaleof
product.
ThenewDOLFiduciaryRulerequiresadvicetobefromafiduciary,andinthebestinterestofretirement
investors.Undertheoldretirementrules,somebrokersandinsuranceagentseventhoughtheycall
themselvesadvisorsandtheirfirmsadvertisethattheyprovideadviceareabletoescapefiduciaryduty.
Investorswhobelievetheyaregettingbonafideadviceintheirbestinterestmaynotbe.
Underthenewrule,investoraccesstoadvicewillincrease,notdecrease.Often,investorswhodonotworkwith
afiduciaryonlygetasalespitchfrequentlyfortheproductsthatpaytherepresentativeandtheirfirmthe
most.Asalespitchisnotadvice.Infact,undertheSecuritiesExchangeActof1934,brokersmaynotprovide
substantiveadvice.
Firmsandfiduciaryinvestmentadvisorswhohavetheprivilegeofworkinginthebestinterestofretirement
investorswillearnreasonablecompensationinsteadofhighcompensationthatoftencomesattheexpenseof
theinvestorsnestegg.Sufficeittosay,weconsiderplacingtheinterestsofbusinessesaheadoftheconsumer
(andourclients)tobeunconscionable.
Thousandsoffiduciariesalreadyserveretirementinvestorsandplans.Thereare11,400RegisteredInvestment
Adviser(RIA)firmsservingasfiduciariestomorethan30millioninvestors,acrossalltypesandsizesofaccounts.
RIAsmanageoradviseon$67Trillioninassetsandemploy750,000individuals.Weknowthefiduciarymodel
works.Itisworkable,itisprofitable,itissustainableanditisinthebestinterestoftheinvestor.
TheDOLconsideredthousandsofcommentsovermorethansixyears,andincorporatedmanysubstantive
suggestionsintotherule.DOLheldhundredsofmeetingsandcallswithstakeholders,testifiedbeforeCongress,
andheardtestimonyfromallwhorequestedtotestify.
Ifthelawsuitsprevail,highcommissionsandhiddenpaymentswouldcontinuetobeharvestedfromthesavings
ofhardworkingAmericansinvestingforretirement,andwouldflowtobanks,brokerdealers,mutualfundsand
insurancecompanies.TheFiduciaryRulesimplyrequiresthatrecommendationstoretirementinvestorsbein
theirbestinterest.
Theissueisnottheformofcompensation.TheDepartmentofLaborachievedaremarkablebalanceinits
FiduciaryRule,increasinginvestorprotectionswhileallowingtraditionalbrokeragecompensationmodelsto
continue.Many,ifnotmostbrokers,wouldbepleasedtobeheldtoafiduciarystandard.
TheDOLFiduciaryRuleisenormouslybeneficialtomillionsofAmericanswhoworkandsacrificetosavefortheir
ownretirement.Asanation,weoughttobeencouragingretirementsecurityandthebestoutcomesforhard
workingretirementinvestors.WebelievethattheChamberwouldagreethatretirementinvestorsdeserve
nothingless,andwearethussurprisedbyyoursupportofthislawsuit.
Intheinterim,unlessanduntiltheChamberwithdrawsfromparticipationinthisanticonsumersuit,please
acceptourresignationfromtheChamber.Ifyouareinterested,wecanbecontactedat(806)7477995,and
wouldbehappytodiscusstheseissueswithyouingreaterdepth.
Respectfully,
HaroldEvensky,CFP,Chairman
JohnSalter,CFP,PhD,Partner
KatieSalter,CPA,Partner
AnneBednarz,CFP
ClayRanck,CFP
Evensky&Katz/FoldesFinancial
CC: AdamD.YoungLocalNewsEditor,AvalancheJournal
JeffKlotzmanNewsDirector,KJTV34
RussPoteetNewsDirector,KLBKTV/KAMCTV
ErikBreonNewsDirector,KCBDTV