You are on page 1of 269

 

 

1
‫ ‬
‫  
 ‬
‫ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ ● ــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــــ‬
‫  ‬

‫‪2‬‬
PeaceII

3
2003   


© Rashid Shaz 2003
 ‫ا  اد
ظ‬
ISBN 81 87856 10 6

(Peace India International)       : 


(Milli Publications)
    : 
Milli Times Building
Abul Fazl Enclave, Jamia Nagar
New Delhi-110025
INDIA
Tel: +91-11-26325499, 26926246
Fax: +91-11-26323053
Email: militime@deI3.vsnl.net.in
www.peaceindia.com

4




11
  +  •

49 Personal Narrative of a Pilgrimage to  :   •


   "
  " Medina and Meccah
R.F. Burton 


75 Palgrave's The Personal Narrative of a  :   •


!" Year's Journey through Central and Eastern Arabia
W.G. , ' 
' *
 "#!
$ %&' (
) *) 
Palgrave

107 
 & "$ .  " Arabia Deserta  :-    •
C.M. Doughty

141  %)0" Seven Pillars of Wisdom  :/   •


T.E. Lawrence  
 
 
 "$

169 The Heart of Arabia & Arabia of the  :   •


 
' 2 "1
 $ %&'
$ %&' !" Wahhabis
St. J.B. Philby

5
207 "
 "    •

 

6
ÉΟŠÏm§9$# Ç⎯≈uΗ÷q§9$# «!$# ÉΟó¡Î0

〈 ∩⊇⊆⊄∪ 5ΟŠÉ)tGó¡•Β :Þ≡uÅÀ 4’n<Î) â™!$t±o„ ⎯tΒ “ωöκu‰ 4 Ü>Ìøóyϑø9$#uρ ä−Îô³pRùQ$# °!...®

(142 :2 )

〈 ∩®∪ Wξ‹Ï.uρ çνõ‹ÏƒªB$$sù uθèδ ωÎ) tµ≈s9Î) Iω É>ÌøópRùQ$#uρ É−Îô³yϑø9$# >§‘ ®

(9 :73 
)
‫ـــــــــــــــــــــــــ ● ـــــــــــــــــــــــــ‬

7
8

 
     
   
  $& ' . #   $   % " ,! ""   
 $+ "  
 -/0   *  )  ( &  )
   $+ 2% / 3
"    -12 ) " &  # 
5  ,+" 50 $ 5 6 5/7   4'#   )& " ,  
 
*&" "  89 "2  : " $ / ;<  *5" $+)2 " , "
>    ' .:  =   $+ 1 "  5/7  
" A -7   /"   @ 3 "    ?   ' +
 4C /   
 3"  +   " & " ?- A  B 6
D"   E 2 : $%(  @" ,) *  $"=     3+C "
-1"  E F "1" , #" F
  G 1 +  8) +  6 H+
* "' $+ J 3 E'1 8) + I  #" %(  &  2%:
8'  "&" $  2  " $%(   ."-" :"    
; I   # -1 6"   )     3 # 6 +
 N: 4&'  A  )1 L   $M " . "' & :)2
 : "1) $ $+  /@ ,+ : & "  & " $+  +9@ 8) A $"
"     " 4 D  O  4<  L) .)1 $+)
.  6 P &
3$%S( & $ R ;1: 8) )#  # +  Q   4" 
S $) .)" $%( )1  :/ " ): $+1 8@ ! ":"
S" S:< " $  T "6 +:  : = $  
9
        


  ,
( *
  #  . ! "# $% &' ()*  + -.
270 .
   5. 6 23*4 23   .1 (1 &  ! "# '0
*80 * = .( 9 . = 6 (1 ;  <
9
:3 (80 
# '7
,&  ! >!? !  =@  3 A %' 1 &# %B. 0 3C<
(80 ,F*   .%3 ;  . % ' D  E* (B9 > %31 F* '0
E*% % ? (   & ( :G (  ( 1 
  >4
,Philby  # 0
 0 9 H6 6 ( (   D 0 B1  ,D 
.( * 0 1' ' # (1 I # %C
D ( L
 :4 ')1 +K *3 () J 1
 ( 91 "@ '7
&-#   ' 1 ;  'N   > (  ! MD1 L
' E* %
O#9 O3    = J. 6@B &- (1  .  ; 0
( ') ( + ')  ; (
  90  (1 O "  .% :
,(3 ;7 P! F%3< ,+## ! =7 (1 $ &- +  .' '
@#
#. %#9 +>
 3 ' + #)  6BQ
  ;7 93?
 (1 ,O ' < ( 9  ; (1 %B3 (1 &- 0 37B:1 '7 .

' #C (1 , C3# '' $ R    ;    0 P
.3 99 ( $:  >!  0 O3 P#: <  ( >! * 0
3'?   ,@ (7 '%  ( '  + ( +  
"# ( # "? C3 ( ' (93  331 <? , 3  ;#:
9
"#
: T
 %# > ' >& + S    ( R39 ,%7 7
( #. (!   I'3 ( * ( # &3 "# 2< 6@01   (9  .%7
=3. ("  0 S  (#@B  ,
- @ 0 %'1 '1 ( %31 "#
' I .: +) ') .I  %  ( # " % # (:G O 0 V "% :
  (K P< 0 ''1 < , ( W
B#: W>1 0 
9 0 60
10

      !" " #
     
(   )* +,  -    "  $/0$1 2 .$ % & !'
< +0/ $:;$0 9)*   ," 

 " 45 6$  $ 3 
=$#  $* =1
 >$ ?
 @=  A  .$; 5 1;,  0
!  1B
 .+)" $/1& $ 1 %-$!" @)!  + 9&  " < ; $ &
.C<" >$ ?$ 0  1& " @ # 9) 6   0 9$
.$:#G  A ,; @#0
 F :   F D$& ,; E /

 

  ,2003 

11
 


.
            
,"  )*& 
+" ! "#    $  
 %&" '
     / 3 " 4" %  .12 1   $ -/ 0%
 0% ,
+ 9* " 0% +:  6  7+#" 8  ,5' 
/ " +  3>   <=" . ; 
+   

  )C + # % B @ ;*A    2= ? 
.  "C  3/ DC     EFG 9*" ,

)*&    ,


  =  "  : 9 + 
     2
 %   .
 )H 8
C/ 2 ,D  ; " 
H -  . "  8  $ ;& ; D H/ J
B; ;I*A
1) H
3>  3 $ =" /  )*& "  

,";H
 $"/" "; 2/" L "+ 2* F  ,;-/   K  1'
" ?3 2&   : # % 2=  .H
 " M*
,+#"/  L  2/ 7  -/ L   D A / I N  ' 
;- .9* "  H
  O+ 
+#"/ A E    J

- +  PN ** 3 H 8   


  + 
'   )*& $ "  
 =   .
C  H
D& ?Burton  2 -/  Q   ' C  + 
12
  Philby 
 ,Lawrence   ,Doughty  ,Polgrave
 " # ( )   !
,  
     
  
2 %&   
" ' *+ -.  /00 1  , $ 
  
 :  ;. ,5
  #6 # 7& 8
*  9 .3$    $ 

. 1  > "= ?@3
 & -    )    <
  6 = 
" " 
+* "
  @*+ " 1,( " . 3   
 =# ; 3  "
 &  8  
" " BCD E#    
" .&A6
.F <#

J  , I+     E H"   "


" "" % $& . 1 
 I+ =   -  5&= % $&  "  K% C L"
 D
 $D ?6 !N >5 N < $& E  %
&M K(" ' *+) "
 *    ;. . #2 
" 'C      , O 9
 #2  ,(*+ + ) " ' *+
8$
  N ND < $&
$
  !

" ' *+    3 '& P3 ! A   N   K3
  "
" "" Q
3$  -. '62 
   . $ ?@3  

-  C     'A <# R&= 8 3   9


 K .
5 >+  *+ -   @ !6
*   ;. K
" ' *+  TA S*+
  &" 1
 T   5  
  .
" " *
=
."
" ""  !C  &  *+D    % $& F 

<# D   1     R&= <  A .
. U  6 J   ' AD  @  -  
" ' *+ !
Cambridge History of English  V 
 A;   <  =

.10 (1985 ) "


  " Orientalism Edward W. Said   1

13
          
 Literature
(   & '% "!  "! " #"$
"# % ,      
 $1  - "   "( / (% '% 
 0 ( " ")* +  2.  
 " 
09 &6 86"  5 8 .  - "67# -"2 3 24  (  &5
   &5 = "=#5  ,
 / 7 "4(  6 :; "  " ( <  
9 %  ?*   2@ *% A
 / 7 6 7#>  
.


B"
 #"+    ? "=   /  5 
"  *
#"+  "  FE39 -+2 " 5 . D  E CB"6 9 1 

"
 *  "(% - #(  ,*+# 6 B9   "!" # G ( B
 % "!% H "!
 <
 B"
  9 #
 E .
 B"
 D 2 " 
2 "
  ("  ."2 "= 9 "= B "%"*$ I   I - % A- 
09 % ."6   H" "9 (  K  E 6 "**" B 09
F #"+ E"2  - +  " 2 
 B"
 "# B   
0* 2 "(
 B"
 2 NMN   : ,E B B"
 9 D * "+
.
" 9 "(
 B"
 <

 2  9
 B"
 6 DO"4 #"+    1 "* 6E 5
" "9 P $  " " (  $( 2  0(1 ( " 9 O"* &5 # 
"#"+ 
 B"
  
 #"( 46 D"   * F"#$1% .QR 6  (

"#      ! ()  
   
 2

' * + , -. /  0  & * 1 2 + , /  3  # &$% !
1% !  .2   2  4. !5 16   7 $% ". 
<  0; ! .0 6  90   ! !   :6#    
.1953 - &240? /14? . 2 =>% ". 0 

14
     ! " " 
.       

    ,   - /  !% &  '(   )*  # +#$
3 )   - 1 ‘’   ! % #2  . 0 ) 1 
 9:  23  ( ( 84 5 $  ( 67$  -   
,@0 #;   
   <   ! - ) = > 
? / 5 8
2    B : ) =   : :% 
4  : 5 97 3 5&3 #
.%  '5 -

: 


:   @   14   '-"  
" ! C( 
+    
D  #5 )E F0  F&      + : G%
,   
  # / 5 8  H F & I3 ?3 '- ? 
% % 3 : 89:5 B  G - J   '- #   I ! K
: 1 '( 9: !     5
. 5 )  N M  ) : 5  L4
)  N   P
87% 3 >: N O  +4    3 7 - O 3
3  . 0 G;= : $ ) 03 4
!Q2  +7  9115 2 # +)5
 5
3 !R 89 B7
3 B  9:    3    13 
 2  3 G1 : $ #
:
)    :- I:  F0     >:- D  !4 5 :  5  F0 
: - 5 4
 2:5 !%:   2 
<5 % 3 ( +!C
!4@7$ 1-( I: :0 + 5$& S:5( 
)  ; I H
.  
 TI3 #%1 3 :1 /5 =  +) ?$  S 3 5$& M 

  3 % :  ?  + UG1 '- @4 !5 B 5   


. $0 
8  G% - B&3 # @ : I + ) F0  '- # + 
: 1 9 2 !4 C
+2 :5 #4 
   V @:- %< 5  S:3 P

$0  - 97 - :    G% #2  8$N 


7 - :   (

15
      
       !"  
.
01
(2 3 ,
 -/ '() * + +
 

 .#$% &%
.4%

4 5 6% 
  7 53  " )  89 #%)     "
 :" ;%3 )  
$ 4!  9 5 < 2 +1= $ 

8?% " 2 ;= 8?5 "!  . 2 82 > 8? "  # ! #1 )
6 8?="  D% A <83
 8?
> ?=3B -C 8?2 @  ':"
  " G  '21  "! <8? 8?$%)  ? ! )  B F>  E2
' 2! E2   > A >   8?$%)  #% ($  $ 7 "
 7 53 -2 ) 89 .13 ) H  E2! 6 ) +( 
 =

!   # 1> J
) H* 1= :) E2 -2 8? 1> >   2
8?$  )  (
2 # 1> J
) H*  = 4$ # 1> J
) H* K% 
E2= =! %G  5 M(    
 *3
2 ./ 8 C
– G   .!2  
4 !> N  ?%     E
) 
'  !  7 53 )  3 
 *3 & 4% P 1  O 1
 
?!  ':" :   6=2 <B! *3     8? ) # "  6
  > ?=%  Niebuhr  % Burkhardt 
?"  "  B

 #%)  =   
> K%  % < 
1= "    
. 


Q?=3) -C >   2 -2 8?


 "  7 53  A
82 > 8?5 () 8? 1)  
 8?2 
4 2 " 3C 
Q  K%"= %" %  2 82 6 1%R  ! ;%? . 2
Q "Q :  S  () ;%3 .8 R 4 2 G=  
Q%" +Q 1 ?%" -) #%B  2 82 4 H*Marco Polo

16
Lodovico
 
     
 
 

 .  
   !  "# $%  Piettro della 
   di Varthema
  
 .(
 )*+ ,   -  
'  /0 12 !
 .&'
6   3 7-     0 /0 "&3 )4 /0 )
# 
 !
5'
.-  ;'  ":& " 0 8
0
 '
 +

( 1)
)  
#   0 8
0& 
< =' '> 3 ? #
 - Herodotus !  
> )
  - (
 
3> "#
 , 
-    
# @

  .  (
 Pliny & Strabo
/>
A> " &3  0 =B% @6 "# ! 
 C+  
6>  
2# D!  /> 0 =B% >
E4> 2
 % !
,&
A- 
2  (
 8,> > ! 
 3.2 26
  <0
A7
%>  F5
GB  (  
* @ - H
6  ' 7
<  "=B% )
3" 5'
.& ?0&

J'  -   , @ 2 "


I%" Geography @
 
DI !
,&  ! 
 7& ' />
AK 0 =B% Strabo -
 >   3 - "# 
 &  ,= 
 !

" : ( ?
4
J '
 ."
% 6  2% : 
 
-  5I 8% 

 D8A

> ,7
 0 N
  &
A &  )' />
AK =B% )'

 " The History of Herodotus George Rawlinson   3

.187185 (1943   ) " 


) "   " The Geography of Strabo H.L. Jones     4

.347   ! (1930

17
. 
     

     ! "  


  Pliny     
' '( )*+  -  /
+ 0
,#$
#  %  & 
-
!   $1 22 *3 )% 4   # 5  6 3 
78 % &-     9 :6   ;< = 6 3* .
. >- >  ( ? @ 71 ?

3 A% )% 5 " 7   


 B"  %
Arabia and the C  James A. Montgomery  -  CD B-
# #'' %   B"   A"B"  % &-" Bible
7%  % HD ID   -  .- FG H5 G' H5 C*  
 3 P3 7 CG;  ."7M % 
NO' N+" (20 :13) :%I 1'  )"
D .(2 :3 D) "...MMQ M RMO5S!N MFMTG M5MN6 HN5 O)7 N M>O'N- ON6" :B"
 U" 6&  )78 %   B"     >I )/%
. -  C

 + HD ID    6 ' ; G G;     - +
7%- % &-  0
V6 V' "   .%   ! 
>/ >6  ?% .)' * -   3*  A   / G
 #-

P*632 )5    6 H
A- 0
 37  W   
 GX F6   )' 7$  7 5  '%  " >
$
    ' B   C(5 )' H'  % .'"  
. " ; '  :&- " ' H5 )' @ P" I
' D 7 HD ' 3 1  I5 V I5 0 " 7I
>D - 6 .75&   = ; )'X F; I+ 3*  6 . 

18
 
            
*+& ,+- +./ 0." %  ! & '&  ( ! "!# $
5
."5 ,  ...$ 2 3& 0.  ,,

0+
 +   6#7  ! . & $%  *  87 9
*
  # $ ;<   5!   %  $!= (*: 

AB +? ;+
 C+% D    & 0- .. >  ?# - 
@ !
.+. *!  0.=& 9 
2# 0 # $ = $
 $ ?  $

,+
! ,+
  C '&  &  .*
  38 !  *:   & 
E#.#  -  *: &  .5 -& 0 *
 "!# : D 
.,D   F @ -& ,  E#& 0G $

+2?" E  .# C H   & .#   9  $.
+ F $%-& # ,B   "F  ,." $ E# = ("-

1
.$+ +  & C+% EB# -
 0 I#   J C% 0
.. .# 7 >F D 0    & & 2%

  ("*: 0" Islam and the West $


! E# 
C% F2  < &  K L. & C Norman Daniel ,  
F
 K&   M &  N0 0.      = , 
   ($  M%  0   & OH2? ;#  ,$
#7 .   .,!  ,"$" /=% 0G $B2? $#
$!?   <  0 $%"  #  -< & – E#% C% - – P2?
< ,# 0   0 .=  R....D#?# &  # Q% .
, ,E# C% 0  
#%  & S9# 0 ."F:  # & #
 7

  " The Arabs and Medieval Europe Norman Daniel  
 5

.56 (1975 ) " 

19
:
 
   ! " .   
 

+ , !
  * $ 
 + ,#$  
% & ' ' ( )
'-!#$ -$ + /
!
!) 01 2+ 3 *& + * $ 

- 8- 7-!$ + !4-5   5 & 3  '6 
$ 
(
"
9   ; <
  7
 = 0
;  ; 1  
5+   ) '&
/6

3$    
'A
'   .>?+ ';%  6 @
 0';%  7 %
- -
C  - '-  3*?
!  .&
; !B
 *
-&
-;% 3$  3
& ?=   8'/ ?
3 
;!+ =) 0<
 
3-!
5- ' 'A
; 
   '  3D%6  ) . @
 
)
-$ .E1/ EF ED
!  '
 % 8@%; $!* '/G !+  +
 <
& %
6
.%  5  
   ,
;! +   =
H  2+ 

'
;! 7 0  &
H;5 I +  5 @6  3/ 
3
-
 ,3
- ,
-$    &   ' J '/;! 
KW. 
- -*   3 I+
 L 5 K
? $ 1 ! & 0'
J

% @
$ "%  O
! +"  J  C 
M  LSouthern
- '- + 
- 0
I  
 & .
+ 5  DP%+ 7/?+ 2 "@6
-  =- ! ,John of Segovia !
&%- -% K-$ @ L D
*
K- ) KC* K!+ 0Jean Germain 
% % 0Nicholas of Cusa
-% -& M-  B & @6 
! LAeneas Silvius (Pius II) (!
I

" " The Crescent and the Rose Samuel Chew   
: 6

.469539 (  )

20
:7    
 

         ! #   $ %  & "
 /
)
     0 +#  -.' ,'( ) &  
 *
  34 %  5 6# %  7 80   #9 % ."  1  
:; & #    .
   & 

<=>     !7 ?#9  6 @   9 ! 


(0  C
7   / *D   9@ *7 B 9   %  A9 !
F  G0  /
; D  /H E0 C
7 =   ( .%(E0 1
#9 % –  !
3     0  I J   I K  (0  
+ 9  .A(    %  &*   K   L!
(     B

! H /
G   E (  + 9  %  0  8 5 .% 
 M E *
,&( *   1 -E  5H , !7    L '(  1
34 1    # B *
 1 N ...   ' 1 ,L3&*
    5H ,;  N ; 1    6# 
  H % B/E   '( %
8
. L
-     J % 9I   H 0 9#  

(E LE  G%
  ( O9> " )( A@ %     #9
%*  )  ;1 <P  % .P#
  
  "  & /   &1

Western Views of Islam in the Middle RW. Southern  


 7

(1962 ! #  ) "



 
  

" Ages
92 91$
Western Views of Islam in the Middle RW. Southern $ $
 8

(1962 ! #  ) "



 
  

" Ages
92 91$

21
(Bibliotheque Orientale) 
Barthelemy d'Herbelot 
: " 
"

 

  
 !# $ %  & # ' * 
,+
 '  - %/ - 0 12 /   .# '+
 + 
1 *'3 1 4 1 15 %+
 6  2   &
9
...
'4 1 6 1& + 6  +7

++ 8   9 *;<  *7 + ' 14    &
10
. 1 = 1 
#    1 1 >

?3@ A  
  0 * 0 B$ C D E  
.
&+C   
 F $0 +
G  
 
*= 1 

+ J2  1 ..."%E  "  +' D E $
*  ?H 9I+
B 9 0+ %E   / ,*+%& ,*#&   F Dante

 " Bibliotheque Orientale Barthelemy d'Herbelot 


 9

.66 65       ! 645 /2 " 

* !  * 1)
* % +  +  , -* 0 ' %( #$
! % & 10

A  "5) 3 4!( " Alphonsus King of Arragon   2


 0) 6 , 4) ) +  %    " Christian Tum'd Turk
) !' 3 ) ! 9
! ,     8!
* . 7
7  ; 
* 3:  8  , #  ' ! 0 ! 6
6& ?7) %  <! 
! =,   %(  = 
* (>      
27 !7 4! %  5 % <  @!  ,
*
 " , "

* "3; <"
!   "4!() "  B <(! =! 
 .#0+ A
  9 -!' #$
! D) (+@  36 9 <)  C7 %
Mahu "0 "  3  E , E, " 3  "
*     :6 < 
.(Muhammed) ( , ) Mohet "0 " ) Mahound " !0 " 1 ,; '

22
  
     
          
" !"# $
"#  %
&  '
 '&  (  ) (* +,*
'"6 4 .
"  -./ 0  1#2  2 -  -3 $' 4  &
<
"= >" 
& ."'(). 9
: ;"  7

 1*  2 (
!*" '"( 2 !3  .  ? 2 ,,6 @ 
A6 B'
 B'3 (
C <
  #= 2 @  != ( D .!=) %3, -&
F
 C <  ,   (  =
  <#  , > .  !
11
"(    H
  3   #*  !2 .G   +
 '= 
.
 ' =, G '  

      $ < = '  / '/ %



& -& -.(
'", '#" '
  ' 
  
 %,   / '
 <( (

"@( @ 4  


   % I( ,' ' ' = %
*  $'(

-&
@
)(
@J* ( 
 
@3  
 
&  $G & BD  
K" !"= %)" ,'# '  
 2  3 !
& $9#  
#=    $G. '& %
(
*  ! 4.
 ! 2  ,'( 
=
<"#3 -&" B- B/ -L "/ 9"  2 '
)2 ,' '( )/
12
  -L $ / '
 <( ( 
  '
  . 

9"( @ 4 $

  -

& 2 ' K/  !) >#4
  %
  #= <#J 3      <
& C  = @ <J # .
 M
:'( (

"
* "3 '"
  ' * * 
2 O  1#* > 
& 

.69 68 


    11

.   :      12

23
 
     
 !"# ,  

$%  $% &%' ()* + ' -  '  !.  $'/
 01
23%3 %3 24%5 !%.  67  89 # ' :) # 93'
%
A%.< .(#  ' 
 '4 ; $< )=9 $<9' >'' -?
%' ,$%  $9' B C D  E" -9 
' F) '

$%=' < .''    B0G 3 ,.3 ' ' ' $93 B0 $
4%' %1 %9  %' 94  ' :=.  H - ? $3' ' :  ' ; 

13
...$. '  I49' A< A49 4

A% A*  ? *) A< H A $96 -3) >   ' $##
F)% - A.< . CJ  
 K3 $L ' 3 !6 - 3
9 -3 -93 ,4 < A< "' $ 4 >' "  ? :< 3
A*)%  ? 69    M ' >) ' .$ $ 
 A<
 $6 :  ; ) A< 4N  O'  ? '  '3 ,? $ '
-? #< ,  ' .2#'  ? 
I? 
P ' .4 P
14
. A< =  "S D9 ' A  " :$ '

( 2)

Burton % Lane % %' $ 


A< !'
>)   /
$%L 3 % A%< 6  : 3 F) "  " 3 ' '

The History of the Decline and Fall of the


Edward Gibbon   13

(1855
 ) "         "
Roman Empire
.289/6

" " The Arabs and the English


Sari J. Nasir     14

.7
(1979
)

24
    "

 "    .
   
  
"  ,
# *+! .
)
 $ %&   ' ( 
!#  
23 4"  *11  ,!  *! Henry Torrens -/  0/   "


15
*! , 6 5! 6 7  ".1!
( 5& 1 - -/ 5& 3   (
%9  : 3 *  3;
# %( 8/    06   4

=> 
!<? @6 *; 34 *! 8(# 5<  
    .1
( *! )( )" *!  /4 8(# @
  A  .)
)1
 "

 "  , B9/ :  .") ) 1 
(;9
#
  2  =  )9 1  :+   1841C1839  
5& 3" Manners and Customs of Modern Egyptians ,+D  (
16
: / )(
FG
   E  .") ( (
 $  ( E4 : (   : 6 *! ,4 (   4" :,
MN
##  2 E/K < */ L  6 $ */K  $ *! I
<<J
17
 :(+/$ 531    $4 "  <   O0 E
 2+<4


  " The Book of the 1001 Nights Henry Torrens   15

.3 1 (1838  ) "




 " The Thousand and One Nights Edward W. Lane     16

.868 /3 (18411839  ) "


 




 
  ! #     $  %&' * &  +,

!! 5 67  1


-0  1! 
&  +   23
4  0  +2,-
Studies Nazia Mukhlis * &  :3 . !  &  8 9  # &
4
;
< &  ! +-" in the Social Background to the Arabian Nights
.( 1968  )
74 
=,  +-   >, 5 ?
!6 "
 

 ) "!   " Modern Egyptians Edward W. Lane     17

.3 (1963

25
% ! " #  $ 
   
      
%0 -(%
'( !($)( *
 +( ( !,( -.(( 
 /# &#
2 : # .3 -/2 $ 3$4 +5   +6( !75 8 
 1(2(
3%( 8 > ?  ?@  6 &  =:  < $ ;3(6 (  ( ( :
. ( 5 $

%?# 'B6 06 3 -/2  @ (     ( !.A
 5   (  D2  : E  6F ! A  '  ;30 
  CB0$
 %:( !354  4 D(  
 <.A  ?= ' :" :+(  >
! (0(
18
,F%A : % 4 '0 !",B2: I4:    7(  &# 4J = $
%  1.% K( %L %C @ .A  ( .<  +A:  (/ 2# ,B2) I4)
3% -%/2 +(%
?= '= -  70M 3 -/2 $ (@
-%/2 % 3(() 7 6      C $(   6  ,2 >
( .'BM(
* D@  CB5 A06:( 3/ 2M +)  5:"   6 7  $ 3
."'  ( 5

-/2  3@4 KN 7@( 6$:    6F   7 6 7,2


O%2( 7%$4 %?( !CB4 ? K $ : >
!  ( K
K%  - (2( 76   32 76( 
: &#  
$ .? ?5 (
K 6 D@  B$ !-,. 3N ) 5(  D$  # :?( +(  6 ! (  K

K   6 7(5  .A:  : '


 ((: E (  6 : K. ((:
%5(  7 6 /2  # &
 ?( !-( C  !3N $ 3P ?
+
': Q   = #" :+(  K 6 !35 -:  0
( .
+(@( +6 I (: -,) 1(  ,/2( !+( (    +2  I4

.267  
 18

26
   
    ! " # $# ( 

19
.",  + #  ' ) *  .. %$&

1 " Modern Egyptians 1$ *12 1 )  0


/ 
8 ,2 :, 637  ) 5 0!  – 
4# 
  )   " 3 
1  ? @1  –  0&  – ) *2 .9;<  0 =$ >  /;<  
12 ./1A# #    /2B   <   $ $ A<  %,
 B$  # ! "EA#"
 D – $  A= C<; *2 – 03  0$
;  /2+   )  ' )  $G 0!=$ H  .2< 0 *2 F 
0 L$ # /$$ K
 $!  IB& 0; 3; % C  J$ =B"
)1  *2   
B&   B! HL$ M$  H / ,F$ & 0 
20
B1 *2 "  "  N ". )  *$ =$
&B$ ' ) $ , / 
21
1 O
1 0
P
 &2 .;  ,,#   O
  $#  O
.%; ;,

S" :@1 0 #$ ER Q  !  2  2


8   
22
1 
1 P
 ."  1; 
C,$ 
; S C;?  4# K
#
   $
 S 2A $ N 8# 8 "
 2A   & *Q
23
/1  1 2? ,2 /# *  ? )
 P
 ". 0
' ) *2
24
01$ – 0=
$" :8L  > 0+$ P    S ,  + RBA 

.379 " 
" 19

.257 
  20

.296 295 


  21

.305 
  22

.228 
  23

.   24

27
$
& $%      
!" # # –    

25
,12 '3 4" $1  # 0  #" *
+ $ $ ,-/   #  ."'

(
.4 6 $& # 7"8 # #
52 $1   

%<%
  ! *; 21 4" & "#
: #
9"  ! # # $3

>  ! # ?3 4" 2


4  ' 8 '- @/ @! ;  A ,;&9/ 4"

! '21 # ' '  # '21 B&  A
.'  752 # ' 6
:,
%  !   Cromer

*'&%
'%& #9 F<%  E' 
 !E D 
"
26
".$198  
 ,! ,/

 $&" *'" '"%:


G$ @ 2 ,: 
 "#"
"
!" # ,!  %
#9 '+  4" #!  " * +  '  7  1
! A   0&   % 
27
."  ,!  ,5   #
 #  * %  $1/  $!

 '+  7H 7
9 $ "'&
'& B"  ! # '2 >  %
Vathek 3 &
.1 4& ,: 
 ;  "#
: #
9"  ! 1"
 '"%: # 7"
>%& "#" '2 > 9 Beckford 
/!  !& "05""
28
.$&  ,: 4  7
9 4 ? #I  +  '+ *$1 

#:: 4" Robert Hay J >


  ;& J "#" + 4%&

.221   
25

 1908 (  ) "  


" Modern Egypt Lord Cromer 
   26

.538 /2  

.567   
27


      

 
!#  $     %  &
28

.'*+ '   

 

&, '  - 0 1  
#

28
            
1893   
"$'"  -+ ' / .#% ( )* 
+ , - # "$'" !"# $%
!3 $1+  4
## 1 5$ #1 6  4
# / % 1 ## 23" :2 0#1
29
!4 Kabbani /    ."8%#  07  1 * 50'+ 24
# 0%
    ;< $2%  $' #9 5$2%     $9
 -#
30
."24 /,  56  ( 4
" 1 #+ #41 /

+  5 Sir Richard Burton  # # ' !3 = #
$ 
 6(%4 / > 
 $? /  @- * #' $ 
 4  
 # -1B 5$'%  B /   0 ' 0
 !3  # 0*%  .9'A
-1 D+9# 5 # $,< '
 2, ' / .62 $C4'4
:Kathryn Tidrick )#

#4% #  -1 !D


 $C  $ C A '  
, 4 4 
 1 #C  F  4
  .E B $ 1'  '1 6(%
I *3 H 3 2'     # $C  I3 5%B 0#  + D+  *
31
./ A J  ; ' -  <4 +

F+#  2 0


4 , / 
#4 K* * / A   % 
.(

1# 4 5"$4 $4 L"  6% $%# $%+ )  #
  # 1

.39 (1978 ) "     


" Edward W. Lane Leila Ahmed   29

      " Europe's Myth of Orient Rana Kabbani    30

.45 (1986 ) "


$ !) "!  #" Heart-Beguiling Araby Kathryn Tidrick  ! 31

.66 (1981

29
1704 ) Gallend         

$- .  /0   1 $"+
, '*" %

& $"# !"    (1717
4353
3'6 7 
! 8
9 /* :3 ; < *= 213

 4" 
%
6 Jonathan Scott 31 >3    1 $2
Henry A3 &2  453 @13 $" 3 ?3 " " 
3

-3 $ -33 ?3" BC Edward W. Lane 
 3
 303 Torrents
32
?B!  90 $
 F3 9 3
   +E3 ."B
 83 93 A 
.G *3 ;H' * <!3, H3 $<-   
  

 
 30 
1  F! ?35 + 3 
, 

3I  90
! L <!3, M2 < 3
 3    .+B
- K,  J?35 3
$+
, +* < F, N3
! +*%   .<3 <6 3   
 3>
."
- 3
* 3I ,
* '  J
33
 L "* +, %  7,9 1
E   +E …5-Q ?
* F' 3" :;H  
5- 453 +O3
0 $3
,  M
E * 6 4-
:
, $3,I 1 <
3B!

."R < E ,

$
 
 :

O /*
 5 <-   %1
3

, #!  90 $'3 S
 :1
+ L,  +E :3
.< 3!3
< +21 3 
 "B3 3  E"  4B  3
  *3 .T  <
 MO0 +E3 $"8 '3 ?  < 3U +B AV
" +
1 T 
B! J3
  /0 L
! >
, 53  90 $?1 M2 3 
3 

.  /0 @ &U
 3 $LB # O +B 8

 
 N3

The Devil Drives: A Life of Sir Richard


Fawn M. Brodie    32

.301
(1986
)
"         :  " Burton

30
33
."  
  


  !# $ 


 %&         
./0  *   +    , ,     - * *   ' ()
7 178 10  (, 2* 2# 34 /! 5       6# *
:=   <#( .  (, $4 :( 5; 1#   ,-* ,
7 7   +  * '>= $#  04  # *#   1#
@A 5 , /    *( B .04       ?   =
(7, 7   % ;  8 64   ;  1# # #
1#   $# 2 !  .C B D( 1# ! 5 # 6 '  #
:*( *   6*, :(

= /< 6(0 *0 '


3=  = - F 6# :( /=;"
 7( B  >0 .6 6  5 *, D  B   =A  /,
 (7 :=7 /7   ' /! ?A 6 ,  ( 
/*7 7 '7A * :=A
, <(  -* 2,  
 7<#  ,  (
B / '(H 18       1# G=
34
".  4

/7 7  /7 I(7 3   1# 04   @  



:J <4

7( K7 / (7   1!A +* L=    04 "

.306  
 33

A Plain and Literal Translation of the Richard F. Burton   34

       " Arabian Nights Entertainments


.6  /1  1986&1984 (  ) ! # $ % " 

31
  ! " # .           
 
35
". :, - 
"+& " '()  $% &

1 " 2 3$ $%


45( 2      " 0% "
#/
: 6 & " !"

 6 7 '& -/2   8  9( +  $   7"
 > &  & ' ...;& "< +   = '& 9 ,
/96 C !< DE( A .@ 6 A7 2 B A
( ?( 
+1$ 3 1$ 1(
  + 2 F$6  "  0 "  ...
36
."$ +& $  /+  +  H G+&<

+?  HIA   E6 / J  9( 3; +62 +  7 


4 M A $   4 (I ,# N& 7
0; .2  L#/  K&
2 1;  #1 9 ( 3&  ( ?  " :I D 
 1  1 7" : 1 0; ."/# 2 +5  I   ( 
 "2 A  I (  M& (&  , $& A &  HI
.42! +& '2 ,"

9AB/
J&(  (+ +" ( + "& "2   

 1 1 


P5    $% ( )  8Q 6&(
/ 1M
!1 &? 4   &?
9   $
  /
:"J&(" ( 3+$  ( "& 4 +
"K$A DE(  ?

7 .J&( ?( # #  D ,    ,/  & 7

.212   
35

.296 "  

" 36

32
37
.""      
 

, , *+%   


! #$ % % &'( )$ 
.#('% % 0 1 23 !4  2   #$ % -/$

,% %,  4% &  


%  ( % 5 %  
,  7 , &   81
0
%9  % :-  4%  !2% 6 
, % 8,;  0<  1 => 2#$
(% 
 !0   & $
,
 $ ?% !-- %  
@ < # 
!  > 2 (%
38
. A%

!$,1% ,    0%


 #% B% +% 
  %
9 .C, ,% D &,E 6, 0  4% ! :% % B 59
, /(9 %   $1% 2#% F
0% 1% A 7
:G
  0%
 #%  8    . 0$7 +% )-

, !,%  % 2/ $ # % > ( % '


:?
!, , "  %"
 % !%
 %  2 % (0% #0%
! %  % 7 I% %9 & (  ! 1 ) @$% 1' 6#1 %
I,% ,
 J K1 2/0 &# @ 89 > &@ # F% 
39
.0 %

, &,% ,B 7 I *0  $ FA 0% %0% I(3  
:)>% 1#     .- $1% % )-  G$  %

.234 /2  


     37

.235 234 /4  


 38

.227 /4   39

33
 
      
    
  ...
# #$ !%  &'(') *+ " 
    !
#3 4 .'- / 0  1
-/ &'- . $
 ! &%
 ,( 
1# % 03 ')+  -)   1-
$ ! 5 61$75  )( 8!% 
40
.
!  0 ,
 *
. /( 9:     )

.# #/+ ;)( <= (


 % > *! ? 
$ @7 /% "
% 1)(/C $ ,  0 "3 "D 
+ @)- % "A " A
 5 " 

.
E 
. "  " ) ;/ ,$ F3
*!
=

   $  ) 1) !) 1/  1 G


 A % !%
 #  " 0 H $ 
%D > ? ' $
-4 . & ? '
1(
  
> 1)' 1  1) 1(/ '$ .
3    1 .
1.# #/ A

I 
3 )+ 1/%
 ,/5 G-)  1
41
.1( 1/%! 4 ! $  " J

7  1
=
I  .  "3 8
-+ 4
. " 8
E " 
 +
J# 
7 " <= (
 8
3  / "+ (+ % 1! A 
0  1/ 1
7 &' )+ ;K ;
  
- 14
$= 
 "+
.(% 4  $ '$ 
L    "3 F3
'/ M
) 3

# 1)#- #' "# & "1) 1) A3" )+ " 


 ) " ;
> "3 &I

1#
E 1#K
 #( 1
 
() 1/ '. 
- J $ (/ '/3 05 N

1#O "3 /(# 1 ' /O &'/3 
 "+ F
= , (
 .1
 
()
. " P / !% 
  (. " &C "3 F3
$
/0 8!% )+ + &%

.17
/1   40

.31 30
/1
 ,   41

34
( 3)

             


 
   
./    *- +, *  (
 )   %&
'  ! "# $

2      1  $
, -  0  !    # 1
-  +  
+, ( #   ' 3,  0 
 
  5
  $
6
  .)  3 
% 7+, 
6, :) ;  % 7,8-  7
9  /
 +

.&  # 
6
<
# <  6,  
0 3   
  =
#6
6 + .7 
6 ) ; 
7!-#     #  79! 3, 3 ? 
 @ *  (1
    >  
7C  7,
+0 3, B  ;  (
>-  D
.>  
  A :3 ' B6#
.8  E*

 )6 F B Sir John Mandeville B,


   
6
F*  
 I!+
H  F*  ("$8 " Travels 7
6 3, 6* ()  

H5,
&*
.#" )    7 ( # %  +  3, # 9- 
!  7
42
   
6 
 J 
 # %
  +  
 $
6
  .".  #
."B 5 ' L ' M@
'" B
? K 3, )    !, ("   )  "

#
 =
' F*  William Lithgow 0 
 N - 1612 
 3  39,
:)   D  ! 7, N F*  7

$
6 , ('
   J; )# ()  )     7PMQ )# 
(9  0 #&
' (     (
+    1

. " ( 

 " Mandeville's Travels Sir John Mandeville  


  42

.47/1
(1953 ) "

35
43
...
 
 
      

! " ! #! !" $!


!" !%&
#!' ( ) *"
!
+" ,- / 0

 *1 "  Bartholomew Plaisted
2

   1750 /
-
( )  " 
, *  (
""
4 5!
5 ' 4) "  " " ) 6" 
 */ 7 *
  4"
44
!"
$!
   ."...< 0 / ;" 8/ +&0 * 99: -
Laverent ,

4 ;"/ "  " =  >
/ -   (& ;"/
! , 
*  1664 / & 
? 7
*
 
d'Arvieux
;!0 
4  .>
/ "  ( ) A-   0 @ ;"
;- 2
"
45
 4) "&! ,! =  B
$" " " , 5 *
" >  , 

  
D  >
" , 7/ > 4" :; 
( ) ,' 0 
,-
!" >

/

8%   *' "  0    " " 4 ;/ 4

The Total Discourse of the Rare Adventures William Lithgow   43

and Painful Peregrinations of Long Nineteen Years Travels from


Scotland to the Most Famous Kingdoms in Europe, Asia and Africa
  
    ! #  $     
   
 "
 2 #% ,26501 .(1906 ,-) ,"* '   ,%  &'  (! )
.1632
A Journal from Busserah to ,Bartholomew Plaisted -% & % 44

#% Aleppo In Douglas Carruthers, ed., The Desert Route to India


.1757 &' 5 !
4 73370 12834901 (1929 ,
)
The Chevalier d'Arvieus's Travel's in Laurent D’Arvieus '  6   45

0 9
;   ": #  9 8 71 &' '  %
 -7 " Arabia the Desert
,
) M. de la Roque ) 5 6  0 "' &' 7 " Voyage en Palestine
.201 ,(1718

36
."  


           Carsten Niebuhr    
Travels ill Arabia *+  +, )
! !    # $ % &'(
$+% , 3  &  ( $ 1792 
  2 "$ % &'( 01 -/"
+ +#6 ) !    7 8% 56-6 )-4 $ % &'( /
   +;  %+; 7%    .3% $!9:    / 7%    3 
<+  -+(4  )& / $ *  =1 $>! $' *6  
 %;   
A2 $  .% / $ % &'( 6 $ ( &/ ? # @( ) 
2 01 C( 6 .-   / $6    B  ( / *  6
+8/ F+ 7+% G;+ 
$% D  0
 ,% 6 5-E 7
+6 J + =  %  %       C  . / H!I %  
,L  ( ' 2  #6  6" : #6 )  * /  &    $%  & %
 2  
*, /
)"$  7 B   
* %   ,& 
46
.   D  $ % &'(

:L+   % C( 6 / & $> 


*, /
  8/=
+ & +#     # C   N )$/  6 8/ $ % & C"
@ , 0/    *##/  2      '/ D %6 .
47
?N %6    
' 6 )- $/ 6  C(  %  )O '
: )C   0
-4 *P   ,L # .  % $% % D % 
+ + ?
6 -4  A  # .$%; 
> 7% $   F%;

  
     ! : 
          46

."'( )*  +  


,- .  
   " :# $% 39"
Explorers Victor Vengeance  ,-  , Zahra Freeth $ 01 ( 2 47

.86" (1978   ) "*  1  " of Arabia

37
!  " :  
  
          
'(
*-& $  % #+ # '(,  # $ % # &  # ' '(& )* #
./- 0-1 '(2 
& #3 # * '$3 # % ( 45 6
  % # $

2 *;- # - - < ."#& # 5 6  &  7 '(, 8   & 
) -3% $-3 B -  < , C3 =  $ '>&? #  $  @ A

48
.> )F1  '(
 * E 5 D  C3 )1
 6 '$3 &

-  F3  / DF


 '(& 4 4
3   G + & & )*
+H / #I +J  5 K+; LG / :  (  6
 G+;   5
#
49
<-  L- ,
 'O  LN M  &  #3 C 
   ? *; 

-  'O . 2 O   (  # *;   #   * B45 6 *;
6- <-&
 61   $  / # P   "#& #&  #* #* " $   $*
B-45 R-  6 $2 & #  ./ ' 
 C3 F
#    $  C
Q&

#&-
& ' 6  Q5 Q$S $ #  /( 6  &
 # P $ . *
K-
B- #,  6   8 $ #3 $ /+ $*" :6(? R; L ,
B8 &
50
$$G- / 6   ; ".Q$  K G (
  # (  *   G

       !  "    "  
   48

-  $& %!' ./ )#   $%&' (  )* %+  )! ' , 
 6 !/* " :%  $0 )  ,12* 
 3 $4-   ! 5!
.7 + 48 */* 61 7'9 ;)!! , 1 <
)  10 >  4*  $? 4/ ) % 4/*    ( @ ,* * 5 ( 49

%/ % 9     &-! /   1& $% 11 A     *
Travels in $Carsten Niebuhr  !/  :) .%'2 3 B %! C 

$) John Pinkerton !  )  ! $"   D) ,E " Arabia
.144H /10H) (73)  / $1811
.145H >/   50

38
!           " : 
     
/!  ' 01+ ! . & * '  + -&' *+,+& () '    #$%& 
51
"...
3+   2&  +$1

+  =&  +*  <&   ;    6 7' +& 89 1+ .5*
+A ! #B !C) D  E&' + ?   @ &  1 + A8 A 9 ,,
+!A  ' B' ! .A F
   & + /+A   5+ B  +
! " ."    + &" ++ .*& A + .F    = +,+
 +!& A+ H A' 6 . C  G' E&) *   + $ ;   ' @&' '
0!& +!A ?LK   ."=J   & +' +A   I H =J
N+ +&+ .;  A&& +1 5 
& +&1 + A' 9 AM) +C   = 
O' P  + +  .,  ;39 ;   Q   , P5* ? 
! .7 +&& * < A
R #+3 A ' =C 5  " A E& 
."S  =& 7 +M ' * <

T M  +,    7,+& *  +  8 '   +& 


+
N+ ! +&    .;   @    5* +  & +) M  
=! , U &  
K +&, + V ;, I     8 ;    ? 
! +!& ;   7' 6 .B C)   V + 7 B   
!A9" Decline and Fall 7& ;    Q   =+M   8
."3+ +

!&  AH       +& A =+   =+M  +

! "   # $#   


            51

&' ' ()  +


*     ,-  / 0$   1 .     %
.1425
16  . 2   ( 3( 4

39
  
       ! "#  "$
)
 *% + # ) , +  . % & '' $(
. 
 -( +/' $ 01  % - 2 +$ 
 3#' 4 ,5 6''7  - 8, 
9 %  : # # ;

, # 4@ ?"&"" &"% 8, 
# + = >$ / +$ %"
 
"/ >$ ) ( + =,  "$ + "- ''7 +$ ) ? 'A A"
:+- 2, &-

 #"  #C$ +' "- ? "$ +  &$" 8, :'7 +5"
) % & :" *#  4% 2 8
4  :" ?D%
?: "F  ?&""$ * C"" >5 )- 4! ?&
 & >E/ ? ''
+ ""% 1' 3# ?#1 + AG # " ?#1 >5  "%
52
."" $" , I$ 4$ 3
 J4K! + 6+' H

''M 4% % + +% H "- L - )F9 # +
N9 A1 > +  0' " 6-  ; >$  + ?  -
  N#  ? 9 +7 A1 OP" I! 0! + 4 # (5 ? #' ) +
0/" 4  , )! N# + - " !  #5 L/ ."1 L " ""
, 3E ?$ +! + - + "- "#$ % & 4F'Q 0%
:)! *-F I 4 

?"-   $ "% ) R"% #' )    +' +" +5
+# ?4A 0  +G +'  +, +'  D% S# >$ ' A1 8,
'' + T- 6 #- "-    "A% #
9 4G
  *% + ""% 45 NCU%V  ? - "#$ 4 )' + M + 1

.122   
52

40
  ! 
" #       
      
 ( )  * &   $% + ,
" -  /0 1 .$ 
 %  & '&
53
.-  " 2 

 
   
       
31 4 #  $& "  # ( 
 
  ! "
#
$

953;1 3<& =
1 >3;  ?@ 8 " & & 4 1" :,  56  
 4  4 2   2 
1  $&  !" : /A B "$@ 4
54
".8 * BF !( B"  8*E +  ( G &F    E CD  B2

?& 2(    @  4  & $;)E  )H I &+ B!


8 3 *G3 '3 I3 
3" BF   J2 G 56 8 * 
B 3@  2 2 $& $  &1 2( $ J 2 ( /" &  2  .5@ 
3& H !  $& * 4 0 1 ! B @  2    + &
:& H $ @  $ *  !@5 J E1 L * ( & B .K
- '% E

(  ,   !   8<& ( 5&    ( & H BM *N
 > 3*  83 3 1 G E3 $! !(  $ @  L*& 2E G  & 
 3&& K3
 5&3 ,
" ( O @ + (  @  4  & H
55
.LP&   & 

$  5@  8 ( & 2 >T  2 U@ S8  $<& J& 2 QR  J1
/3*&  !  $@ A ( J  ;)E ;  J  2(  * 
0 G " ;  ;)E U@& $ + 1 .  06 >G& F< 

.124   
53

.125   
54

.143   
55

41
 
     
        

. 
 


  $  %&   %' ( & ) *+  


# ! "
1 "2 3 4  5 ,- /0 "  -   " !
  ! 
 89!  :  .*  ' 6 37! 
! %&  
    %& : %
 
! ? >$ 
05 & ' %0 (  3;<5 =
 
 A $ & (   
 !   54 @7 ! : ! 6
B*  >$ 9- 
 - 3; ' C&! 3 D E
7  
! @'

     ‫   ا ت  ا ن ا‬4   3     
 E;!  $0 6G  H 0 < 1
  ;  ( " 8"0

56
".5

Jean Louis 1  C * 7 D I !  )"0&

! J .   *  B 37! (   >$ Burkhardt
  K2A I :"0 9  3!  
! @' 
* >  1 
 *      B*  - %' (7$ L B&*
+ M& 
 
 E
7 #
 
' @' ,African Association of London 
 )5 "5+
1817  05 %0  "05    B*  *' 0-5     
Notes on the  "(  B* )5 12" Travels in Arabia  0 -

 1829  05  " 7    1$ " Bedouins and Wahabys

A Series of Adventures in the Course of a Voyage ,Eyles Irwin   56

 

 
" up the Red Sea on the Coasts of Arabia and Egypt
#56! ,(1780 ,) ,"
     
    
.57

42
.  1830


 !"# $    

    
1 2  "

$" )! , - / % & '#   ($ )
 * +
57
7& + 2 7 +!   +  "4 
 + 56 -7  + 7& 3

$
58
+2 < = >  .: 1  ; < $  % 89 
59
2B  2
 ".5<  -  " 1@ ( A! &   - 
,(9
)28 - 2# +2 ; C5 +5
  +!   +  
   
. 5 # (  A % 9

2 @2 %C5 E5


 D9 +  : A 4   9 )8
A2F + +2 ="2 9#      !"# -   C< 
*#29 ) ! +  %# H C + #$ G$ E +& @& 35
2B  =74  $  B +&" :)B )B )9#    $ 
K ,2/ (L2M! (L 2M$  +  A 9  % $ K +4  K J"# =74
60
2A +2   ".) H #    D9# 7& N $2F 7 ,#
".O C" B "

=# + 
%$ $6  +!"  $ : A (9 
 H; )& :$ +!" +  &  < - O O$  =O
DQ2! AB29  N$  *7A  8 B9 5 P : %/

  
        57

Notes on the Bedouins and Wahabys ,J.L. Burkhardt  .. 58

.18! ,(1830 , ) "      "


.193! #$
% !  59

.104! - 
/ ,
  & '& *+   60

43
61
     
       .   

& '(   $%        !  
"#      
#5 5 5  '  651 23 4 # $,  - / ' 0- " " )*
62
5 5 5:   *8 9 *  $,    ,
.'6 ;

<5 5 =  3#


 
:>    3%  

5*@ 5 5$   ?   3# %  4    =%
0B5* 4",    ; .A  &   
%


5 =5 C-   0  


(   "  4-  ) &  C- #
. #& =   ,    #

'5   F % E0 9D    4   @   0


,'5 '56: 9I '* &%  0-    ? G#
%H#
  =H '6% C " *   &  " '    ': J
5 '  ?L .9I C- $  '6   = & ? K  ' $?

  =@ 4 ? < "# &  % M % & H  N
.$O $F9H

'5  
5@?I
H  % J Chateaubriand  # 
N5    4 1814 & (1811) Itineraire de Paris en Jerusalem
4F  *%  N .%H# ; :  : M# & 9 N 
U5 N V  * /9 3%    "9  < " :M S&R 1 
5@ 5:  5* 5& /%6 # 0" : W?H..G- 3 3

.106   
61

.105   
62

44
63
.    
       " ..

     ! #  $% &'( &)* &+  ,-  /0
1 2 23 4* 5 )6   %  7 &( &+  , /  ( *0
 * -    /8 9% :   % $ ;( <% =- 8 >
.& %? @8 > &5  /A B 6# ,-

12: !2  Lady Hester Stanhope  3  B 5


  B & #  ! &  *% >)   (  , *% /  (  
230 !2 236 ! '  E  .&D  3D   ( 3: $
?A   F G   9   D  9 ? H 6 30 B )8
:& # @   ! 0  5: 0 &0 0 &%*  0

JK 2   2/  #H0 &  -    90    
'23 '6 6 $: 3#D%   35 0 L > *0 3 3 >
64
.3  

$25 0 %? 0   &/ ? A 3 ) ! 8 3 


.& %  0   & 8 &68 8

!2%  M * ? =- Benjamin Disraeli !' ?  6
M *  ? 6 1847 % Tancred   M *  & 1831N 1830
  P # O(/  Q( 0 : &(D ,-  0 &  # O(/ O3

Travels in Greece, Palestine, F.R. de Chateaubriand 


  63

,   " Egypt and Barbary, during the years 1806 and 1807
.272# (1814,!) ,"1807 1806      ,
.40# ,*  +- ,! & '  
$ % 64

45
.  
      
          !"# 

  &    +  ,# + ))  )* $# % & ' (##
/03  4  56 ,#   !0-1# 
-#  #2    #-  ' /%
"+ 56 ;6 !% ! 9" 9 % #
$,3  --
7 * 8+ 4 
.Tancred  # + -
<  =, %

@ A Alexander Kinglake ?0 %  -%& & 56 >1 
 @#&  Eothen   A# 1834 !   > ) 56 
 +
B#3% "# 2 7" !-  % + #,  .0
 7& + 7%
#- $#) 7  % E ".2 5 >#, D #- " -C > 
.7   2 2   #%


 

"
 " The Crescent and the Cross  
#
! 
$ 
% " :! 
      Eliot Warburton   
(1846) The Romance and Realities of Eastern Travel "&'
(
./1
( 3 4 5   6 -+ , # - ' . / 0 12!
,'
( =  &'!" :,9 <%  2! 8&' #! 1, ,9    ;
#
! @+ 12 65"- %,  , # 4  > ( ?  1, -%  &.
8- 
1
 4=@ %,  A /1 +  <6   ?  1  
4
+ D  ?  = ( 1+ 4! 4' 49B . C!  DE  F.!

 " 
 #
! 1
 .D1 + #
G . ! -'  % D=  ; 12! 4 (
?
2 @
  2 +5 = .!1  ( ,5 #! , 4, +. "
.4. /F+ > F+ ? $ 1+ #! 1+  C !

 " The Crescent and the Cross Eliot Warburton  
65

.1846    14 ,(1859 ,  ) ," 

46
 
     
   
  

$     *.  !


"  " #$$% &'(  ) *+   , -)
/ 3 2   +2% / "  "
   $ "%  01% /
*. 
  %
%
  $5 6 
 4
  , -) 
 ("$5 , "  "  . " 9 (   :;
$  ,/ $% 7)
$= ("$5 +  "  " >  $ >9(  , 4 ("$ &'
% 
." +$
?" 4 @+ 1
= 9$    $5 4 +  -4

='%  @1 E
  
 C 
  D 
 *$  A5B0 
/  
+
  A $%
1'
  

 
0 *
2  ='    A5B0  % " + # 0 >5
 ? 10 %  A/( ?"
, D
     " 1.
 +"+ F' *  >  
" % /
D 10 %"  % /+ G   " @1   H  , -) /   A%  
4$J
   ,
)
 7
A 

&'  B ,-  K $
66
4 E&
."K  " / 7
A  ? 1
5
%   K"  

  ?  (   ?M
%
( C$     *+ L10  % /+
. ?
&= /  % N$  /+
7

/

 )+

@ S   $  P KP % Q+3R   O


E ( , &  %
/ /& L)5 ,!9
 ,( K0 "  C  W.S. Blunt + 7.
+ 
,
& 
9  $4    K  T /=  C9  + C
%  +)
67
C >=9 + " U
"= &   >4'
." 
 + ) 0)
% = 
 /$= *+  " :$J ' ?  U
 $  K% #  4$J
 ?" # 
"% %
  +M0   ' ?$ &% K H4$W >
 
"%

.95
 ,  66

.91
 ,   67

47
68

         ! "  
   
 &  '    ( )* #  $% & 
".. / .# " +, & )% -

 - ." 2  + 3!  .4%      1 ( !
69
* /
4
*# &)   ( ) ."  5  6 
+,#/1 * +,  % +  +7  ,&) 1 6 8  9/
.
 :1
*# ) ;) !<   +7 %

(4)

; % ,% %


  /%  /%
)  % .=> !7 +)
;% / :% ?  
@, / ! 3=>A - B % *   C
 :%   C #   ;7>% +% ) .+ 5  :1 =>A :1
 
?!%   1965 + * Morris Bishop   D  :%  ) :%  
70
 +G  . F ; %  % - E# 1 4 %   - )
:
4- =  .,   :% % +  1 ,
  ; % * ,   
 %J @%% + 3! C.F. Jones => 1   7 ;7>% I!
#KLM 1 ; %  "  4  ) :%
  *  4 %
J   %"
D%7   %  4 =A / * #  - :'
> 7 
Vinienue Mylne  *    !,   .Richard Hakluyt

.92 (1907 
) ,"    " Secret History W.S. Blunt   
68

.237   


 69

Travel Literature and the Evolution of Percy G. Adams 


    70

'* +    35 ,(&&  ) ,"     !#  $


%" Novel
.$& '*  * ,- /
0  1

48
  
               (1965)
#Prevost $* #Lesage  ! "  #$%   &  '
.Bernardin de Saint-Pierre * $  * #Diderot $
History of the "/012   -" * E.A. Baker *  + 
0 4 1 $%   & 3  "/012   -" English Novel
"/ 6 + 78 " The Road to Xanadu   5 .  /012
:/  ! (1927) John Livingstone Lowes /9 1  1
 $< ; 9+    &    Coleridge   ; + 4
.*=   > ? @A  * ! 

  :1 $9  ;D   Percy Adams /B * C
 Thomas Curley   F   ,  4!   9+    & 
Samuel Johnson and the Age of !* (1976 )  $4  
   0 * G%!  6 + "   4  1 4" Travel
Journey to the Western Islands of  "F%" Rasselas :> 4
   ;D 1977   ."*I  % /1 6 + 0 " Scotland
William 1* 0 44  &=    $%   &  
71
#I1  78  < $%   &    "  6  #Spengemann
$  &%8  :1  : K<J L*4  9+ ,<J    
     Lionel Casson   & ;D 1974   .*=
Curiosity and :Christian Zacher </  <B  ,  4! 

Adventurous Muse: The Poetics of William Spengemann  


 71

"      , " American Fiction, 1789-1900
.(1977 ,   , ) (1900 – 1789)

49
Pilgrimage: The Literature of Discovery in Fourteenth Century
"        : 
 " England
  & & $ '# (  ) *
  +!!  %  ! #$
+" -- *-! " Pleasurable Instruction ,  #$ Charles Batten
-5  . -3  #$ %!  0&!1 *
  2 ) (1978)
Abroad: British Literary Travelling Between tile Wars  
9! 8 Paul Fussel  ‫ ! " ل‬0&! *
  :67"
. ;< #$ *
 * 8& --

 !"       


 
    
  
)  *+   

   !" &! '$

( 
# .# $ %&


 /GLrnlaine Bree %  - / Michel Butor    ,
#
2  3 4 5 /0  1
   & / Donald Keene 
1" The Ambiguous Voyage: Mode or Genre 75  # 32 .
6

= .<-  1   $ 3 1  % ;
  "2  $ :79
/"7+$   ( 6 4&!  13> ?  2 $$    1"  (
!&-
$ 1 1  (  
6   $
2   @&
72
4&! 2
#2 @& A  / A$ # 2  
6 1  &  
.
   
 A= '$ 2 =6

Mosaic 8 ,"     " Travel and Wandering


M. Butor    72

The Ambiguous Voyage:


B.G. Bree   
161 ,(1974) "8 "
(1968) Genre1 1 $ # ,"$ #  ! :   " Mode or Genre
World Within Walls: Japanese Literature of ,Keene % &96 – 87
1600 +$  -   !$. :*$  *  '" the Pre-Modern 1600-1867
.(1977 ,*$ ) "1867

50
 
           
  Chaucer !" # $ %& '  ()!* " +, -!* ./&
+,
!  01 Higden # / Wycliffe 0  Gower
:$ -  $  .2  3" 4 5 6 ، Mandeville $ - 
73
Clare /   $  ."9-;) . 3;< 2  3" " "
."#*  "
 .%? .>A @?
=>  ? 4   #, Howard

)  
  B  C DA D 
  ./& ? 
 " Ferdinand Count Fathom 3 9 4 .>! C!
G  .$ +? 3  2!* 3" # (1748) .? Smollett 
Travel in the Ancient World 9  4 Lionel Casson #! $ 
# . ."

 . "  H !  .? 4; $ # ".  . 4
"
# !* 3   , ) #* # !*   +?   $ 6
3B J! K/  + K  & .. $ # +? # 5 
  Varthema    Marco Polo   $D # ) 

Vespucci 4"
 !  Columbus L
  Niccolo Conti 4

W.B. # 4      .Benzoni 4  Pigafetta   

;  3 ! #  .> " B "? #D # 4  # Carnochan


.9; 2>  . $ -! - )= MK ,"
B*

4
 3 O"* P $5! #  
 #? N  
Melchisedec  -  M! "  Hakluyt  / $D N Q (.> 
B $
" .> $ - " . Prevost !-   Thevenot

M.C. 
   :
 ,"


  " Mandeville’s Travels   73

.120 119 (1967 ,   : ) Seymour

51
. 
     

Peter ! "#    $#% "&' 


    
   

3
 "/  ".-/01
/ 2/" () *
+
& # Wilding
"/' 9:"
"
 ' , %&' *
+
& # 456
  7 
;/
/ 9 * < 
& =' %%
 * >+
& ='   
 /? @" " / 2/ @ & 9 * A 
& =' John Cabot

 &
 G ."&

 7F  -?B C1 DE 9Dom de Castro
> ?
 ' 
 -GH
  ""  ' F  *
+ * <?
Sherely = /* /+K+ 7 L ,7" "  # I? J% @E John Smith
G ""2/ E/ =' 9%?  &% A ' M 2  ? 7  F 6
E
=/ "
" #  N"6 @E Dumpier " I+ 2 & C1 E
 ?

   ,;  >K+ 1 I  @E , '*?G  ;K "& ;
A?/ /&
 C  @E " =' 6F  " Baron Lahontan
G
;&% 

E I  -GH O26 C 1' 9 ? #2 ? ' D"# #
P  : 7" " I* =' I  "  0 * J"  *  95# 
. :

/  
 & &   (&#  "6 ;K  "
 QI #6 P "" 
 " #? 7 + +" # @ = 
   .:    
E
;/#1 /# @ = IB   ‫ ا ر ا ا  أو ا‬5:F  B
A/6    J F 2 & = ; DE I+  , #1  & &
@E ;"  E 9#+B C1 "*?K .
   6 = ;K  O26
7E ) 7" "# " Tour ( =' " ? @E Defoe 5 " 9 %?B ""

;/ "/6 .Camden
" 5 = Britannia  %  J 1 7 :"


52
       (1961
1753) Peter Kalm   
  !"   !" #$ % &' .    
&*' -*+  , &' -$  -/! ' 01 23 % + 
.45 "

6*% "4  "$ , 3 74  -8/     9


*" Voyages of Sir John Mandeville *' :0%% , 2" ,%
*, 3 :0*%4 0%% &' &/ ?= >0, ,! (1356) "<  $
74
." 0@   %  0+ 0%% "

  B$C ,!"   %  !" #$ % 4 #
," -8/   4 8     D/  E :& <
Relation 0@ 0+ ?C + & Mme d' Aulnoy F F   
Francois $ $' :(1691) "0$ 0"de Voyage d'Espagne
Nouveau Voyage d'Italie 0    !  + F8 Mission
Voyage et avantures de Francois / " % "G H 0"
I F  D8 :(1707) " $' 1 " Leguat
L0' 3 K$ 0  " $  J"  F8 Gatien de Courtilz
Captain Singilton   < H,!  M+ % .08 $ 23
H 0" A New Voyage round the World  (1720) "$ "
(1729) "F  " Robert Dury's Journal D8 :" 
+  K% Q4 &'  -8/ %% F8 N O P  .0%4 E 2"

The Joseph W. Bennett


   "
" Mandeville  74

,
) ,"
     " Rediscovery of Sir John Mandeville
.(1954

53
75
.  
 
      Journal des Savilnts

     


 !"  # $%  & !  
  1
  &- / 0  '() ) *+ $% , * 
    1 2
 " 3    & ! 4
  2Benzoni (
 5  2Varthema 
# 2Marco Polo 

2Ulrich Schmidt  6  2Hans Stade + 5 % 2Cartier
*    7    (# .Sherleys5 2Pinto  
.,# 54 : 3 
 %25  5   28+" &  4
/     Prevost +8  !"  ;  <% ;  
)+ 
 !  <%  "& ?" Histoire des Voyages =,
3 0 
4 $  2 &-  @& ),  /  4  0 
.A-" "

 CD # '!"  ;  <% ;<  A-" " B) 4
!  @ ,3  (+ 8 E F<  1663 $ / # & Chapelain
H H,I +  $ ".- )  (8,) !" " &
76
  ), 
0  ( Mandeville 8  /  - 2& !

Captain The Voyages and Adventures of    



    
75

  (1757 , ) "         " John Holmesby
Critical Review  $
 !#  
,

 "  
" London Chronicle 
 . . / 0* '402-395+* ,(1757) ,Critical Review % '"
" %&
2 

 " The Imaginary Voyage in Prose Fiction :% '**  1
.( 1941 ) Philip Cove 0 

& "
3 

254 56 , 76

54
Earl of         .  
  
' ( ) * & "!#$% " Characteristics  Shaftesbury
77
The " 23  32
 2 Mary Days 0   ,
1  +,-* /
,3 '  ..."#  $
 34 ( :1#( "Accomplished Rake
Robert D. Mayo 2  ,2  2( .",-*  6 / 5
  " The English Novel in the Magazines   (181581740)
+23 @ ,-*2 /2  ?4 @ " &1 =>  - ",-; 01;<
2 A2 !$2( ,,-*  ,  '@ AB 3  , 
78
."$ 
 , D

G2 21 @   H ,-* /E 0; F ? 34
 ,-* /E 0 , *  J* I$  E A ? 3
I 2 G5  1;  L * ,;   ,3  &1 KA(  
021;< ,A  1 Sir William Temple  1  M 
1
,-* /      H%  $% ,-* / ,  
2? Samuel Johnson 2; $ L     .L1 !%
2 2D * 3 (  ,-* /  A %1  ;
2   2    ."* & 1*" Voyage to Abyssinia Lobo
2 2 3A  Relation du Voyage d'Espagne ،Mme d' Aulnoy
> -  3  , 
" :Percy Adams 0  
 (1691)

"   " Criticism and Aesthetics


Sigworth  : 77

.185
184 (1800 – 1660)
The English Novel in the Magazines 1740-
Robert D. Mayo    78

&  &' :$  %) "1815 !# 1740        " 1815
.408
61 ,( 1962 ,$  % *+ ,

55
.
    
"
 

"  
 

    


!# $  % &
'  $

. 
) 
*+ &
 

 ,$ -# /0,  % 10 . (
 , 

)1
)   2 
   ( ,$  
% 7 - ( /  0 8 2  7' 4 &
/ 
567
/  ,94' -
*  
 #
 # :0 ; ,0  % Hakluyt
) " A New Voyage Around the World  % =% Defoe <
 (
/ A" :> ? :2 >( 1
 . 
) 

"

-
". ,
-B   2  !1
 (
  4
) 

567 ,/2
/+
)  &
/ /


 # /C
.:' , BD < *2 E
% F+
 /,  % /

F 2  :7  G4 


)
&


/ B% / %
1 &   +  :%
E 7 /7  % .2%
-  /  H0 
/

   :0 C 2 : 2
H
7 / /  % , A F ,
 
% 10 (  G& / $<
/ 7 -2  
;  ) F/2  / &

:0 /+  %  ( >+
-7  =
/D /B
5 1
9
(  ,  %
 < 

567 # # .) C
#  K / :0 $
(
. G2 2 1 2
,  =2 E
 ,  % :0  %

 
,=20 ,+
0
)
L7 1 

567 # 0
*C 7 ,  F:


L  

)$
&( BD
:0   ,  %
/( :0  #B + D%  - %
 ,( / - :
11
  
M


- ( :0 11
 5 0 / N
$ .  ; &( 7 /
5 1

.:0 &
/ / G5 2 
L7 ,
  /

56
 
                
     Howell  ! Taylor   Coryat   

Mark  '  James Jarves #& $ #$  % "   
Charles  (  #   Bayard Taylor     Twain
  
"  . 
 #) *$ + %  Dudley Warner
 (1840)   "-  /   " Two Years Before the Mast Dana
 1846   Taylor    " 2 / ! " Taylor's Views A-Foot
 $ (&   / ( " Parisian with a Donkey in the Cevennes
.4 5!   2 #
6" (1879)   Jarves #& $ "3

/  (:   -3  "   (   (&  


789
Voyage au bout de la & ,:;  ! 
# < 
"9  $ 
 %8 &  - - (& (! < Celine   ">> -" nuit
 -# -9: Robinson  :  % (  ?#$ (& , "
   $ ."@ !" Herzog *  (& -# - Bellow   : 
. 
*  "    *    " B5 V.S. Naipaul  A+ (&
 9"  <-   C$5 C&  - 8 D9      
-   B  /  E9 D9  .-88  A   
Sterne     2 6" (&    -  (3 "   4
F  
 
/G
H     (& Smollete 
   I-  - "  /  -G% 9 5 J% (" (3 " 
#$L  6   " < 3     (3& I 2 J  / K 
 
.-2 -#" N  C C M:2   2 -  "


%:  (  -" H - O5! (&  
  -!2 

57
"# $ %       !  
   
,& "  '(    )*  +   ,!!   - #!  .! -)
0"(1  2   % , .3 % 4  )   #
#    5
 :  -*  ! 6 4 6 7 7 0 - # 
 - 8  9 !
The Frank Manuel
"  <"   .87 7(  !  
     . #" Eighteenth Century Confronts the Gods
" " .  <"A "! 3 -. .  %   . @) (1959) "$
79
"  8:  .  %B $ C C  D!  E:   
Terra Incognita  <A Philological Quarterly  5#  
1 %" ,.  7
# %   .
. F :  @) 
,A"I " G J" -" 0( 6 .<A    H! #  G 
%B  ,AI & . !      :# :2! 
%"B  " !   : - K  %  3! 7( !  
.6 ( 6+. ,AI  !

- L2( K %B  ,AI -!      
, 
.     + ,&!
.   ! ,  !
. M!1
, -2)    2 0 #  .!  N 
.   M
% G  #. O 2  7! G # -B I 5 6 ! -
 # # - B  # 7 4  5     -  <A 

A Cycle of Cathy: The Chinese Vogue in England Appleton  79

  :
" during the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
Le Mirage  ( 1951) " 
         ! #
," 
  ! ! !  $" Russe en France an XVIII siecle
.(1951) Albert Lortholary %
 &

58
!  
  
        
  
 


   "   # $%& '( )*+   "+
.



01 '0/ 02 
  34 
 52  "6 78 , -/
"0 0* 0
 $
4( $  -  2 9
/ ": "
,  4

0,* 304
' < ,
/ ": "
, "( 
*4  
 
4 %
@
 " A  '> ,, @
1 4 " , + =>?   


0:+ 0'*4  "* @


 "
 '4 " +  ( " )+ 2 %
0 /02 A 0 
 $&C 52   
 "D ,B - . 
. ,&

 *4 #
? 52    )  < '( A?   4
0+ 0 0*+  ,> E ' F  5
4* " 
 #
+>
? @+
0+ "0 
+ 9  )  " - ."
/ "
,
? 
* E

@0+ 3  % @
 
? B+ 
? +
  
 G

)0 &( @
01 H  % " ? 
 4 - )  B
 " =
'/
A 0 ./ H  9*
1  JG/ " ,, ) / >
 I  4 

 A: =@
1
? 9*
 9  "
, "( %K 
 '>
B0 =% @
  -  
1 34& " I$4 
 3 A 8
.
  " '


59
" 

  " 
PERSONAL NARRATIVE OF A PILGRIMAGE
TO AL-MEDINA AND MECCAH
R.F. BURTON ‫ر
رد ا ن‬
18901821

    
    
 
   !"# $ 
'(  ) %!
  &  
-. *  * !! /1853 *+ ,
. " ! (  , 0  !
2. 3( ( )!4 ! ! !

    , 0  * 
+ 9" - !+ 5 + -+ 674 !
,  "!! !( +4 ! .":
‫ر
رد ن‬ 7
! +  !   ;" "
, 0    
9! " <  ;" ="!  
* < ="! /1818 *+ 2. (7 !" )  >! "  ? 
C *  , Dr. G.A. Wallin! - 2 . @A"
 *  !

2. .! <  ("! /1848E1845   # 2. D <
  6 *  F&G  H 4 4 ( (("! .!   2. (
! "! . +!     I< A I#$! *  !4
  <
J
> 7  .!#    *!   5
(4 !  ( K 2. *  
,.L! ,
(J *!+! , A '(? 2. H +! , L *+! ,H  ! "

60
Personal
 
 !   . 
 
 " Narrative of a Pilgrimage to AI-Madinah and Meccah
'  &  ( ) ' *+ , $ $ .1855 #$ %  & "   
'$ * )  -/ ' 01 %2 '  31  40 %5   '6
.#0 ' 08 *69 '$ :/)  ' ;6 -  ,0 %5 


<  $ ;6 , !1 ) 05  0 %5 '  #9 ) 
  $     ') 0
1 =   '  0 > $ */
> 1  '1 ?-  #
) @ 4 -    '> 1 05
B
1!  21  *A  ,21 05   ; 9 '  #  0
4H 2 I5 G@ : 1 F8A
) G # ;6 405 ' DE #C '
J)  , 1 2 > #0 =A1  2
 ? C) .F-0
 #  9 69
1844 #$    . !
9 ) ) :/&  > '8
1(  / A !K $ > ' 0
5  >
-9L 31
 /  *  -/ ' =A1  .Sindh  1  Napier  1
' C   1  ') Mirza AbdulJah of Bushire H  M $
Scinde; or the 9 ' '$
5 C)  .- *69 '$  0
Sindh, and the Races that "' H  )  1" Unhappy Valley
",  2 H ' 1  G$&  1" Inhabit the Valley of the Indus
)  , 5&
5$ '$  & % 2 '  3$) N 41851 #$
'69 ') + 4Q  *8 '$ ) 3$)  ,(  '>&  %
%5   #8 * 6/ ')  2  !L ' 9+ ' 
8$    R ?) %  K  .2 # '  %2
 G8 # 0
1852 #$  .01 %2
 G81 2 ) '  8$ N B A %!
96 
*62 #8 5) ' '    >5 05 #$ $   '   

61
       
 

   ! ,
 

* + "- 

. /  " & 
'( $

)" 
" #$% 
'() "  "1 0" , 
 
 
  -
" 
" 0+  
.1
   * + "-  - 1

34  ")  


 
*!  
'( 04
5
" 6 
7

"
 " . 8
9 "   " 
 
*! "
3 : +  

 " "  =" , "


 
;-    *! < 
= 1
 " ." @   
 A B * +
. :/ %  " :" * +  ) 
1D"   ' +    

E

* + / C +  " 
 ":
8
1  
'()  .+
 , 
 
 
  04 
.  
 +   4 &. : 

'()  ") "  9 -/ (    


 
  F
"
F"  " /  
0
H( & "   ; 0 )(  :
 C G

$
'() ) 
+ + I   *! 6  H( 7 " &"
" 9"

 
 
*!  
 0
( .6
E
" 5
")G
 F+$ 
06:"
 -/ B I8  " . )
   ,F     @44   
4 0J% " .F 
+  
( 
  0"+
F" G
+ 
" 
 

9 /G
7
"
 
'5
" 1/  

E
;
7
 
I
)D" ,
G   
 
   
"

(
%   

. :/ "1   'L /1


H( *! ; ,H) " 

"  K

 % .-/ .


 "  0B 
* + – "  + 7

 0"
.4%"  
 
 " .+"" @44  
"   OMN !
.6
 :   *!
. :   ! , 
  
"  0B 
* +"
K:-
#  "  " "B  H( D" ,: 
 ":
8 ")
62
"  #$ %& ! ,    
    

*  *  #    ""+ 
  $ "- .' ! ( )
#
/   Anthropology     Physical Anthropology
) #1 " 851 2 1 # 67 # # * $# ) 0 1 2 345
: "   < ""+ 3%  #$ */#  ' 3(  # 9  :;-
 < ' >/ , 9 ' =4#  $ # ! "-  " *## *
.$; ?  '
 $  @A# 3+ 

 - *A4A ' *;? >1 3 ;? :    $ %   "-
C # ) A  !1 ?;  "  ) ."*$#" "*"# " "?#" )%
<$  / # * 6   
 "  C/ 0   !1
D A !?; # .*  @ ' # 3 *"$ ' 3 !? ;
!
 !?; " # < % 3? ?# ' 3 9# = ;? ) 
2"  !?; # .?# )  /# + 2# 5 !?; >? ,* $ ) @ 
)"    ,4 ) 3#% ,"# !? ! *+ *+- #  !#+

 !?; #) *  * 1 !?; !  . ## 3 # 3 # 
 < % # *  3 ,2 ' @%  #  ! (+  !?;
+ "  4?;  I?5 "- 
 ' *# @G? H *; #
+ D A 4?; >? .
 )  # ) 3    D" + ) A 
A ,2   '
 #  *  ! !1 C # +
 
J  *% @? !?; 6% )  0 .@# *"# ' # 3
.*  # 6 @# " @# @4? # C " *;$  )  *"# 35" " #

!?; % ) "*"# " # + 2# 5 !?; ) A C " 


2"  !?; # *"# *"# ) 3;/# "#  K+ :  3   >?
=4# + 9/ +
 !?; #/ #  )    3   D" +

63
, 
   


 

 
   . 
 
 $   #&     '# 
  !"$% !" !" # 
  )     . (%
   '
) * * 
 +  '
  5  ,- / # 
0 '
/"1 /"  &  
 23 4
  ( 

3 &
 3 "8  9 9
  :  ;$- 5)< 92 (-)    3
= !4 >     '  8   9  
3 ."  : %   
   ?   9#) . 9 

( > 4> 9  " >

&2 
@  .#
( "
 >
 8* <   /
@ * ' &2 

&  A / 3  )  ) 


 A / ) >   ) (# 
'
.
'
 B ? C  @83   #1 < D"

  ' D E ) G"#
" 
   4   E ' 3 

# ,
 +$3           .
 +$3 H   <  

3 .D  / ) 0) $ " 8 5J 9 
 
"
 #
? I > />
@ 8 $ D   "- >8   )   
 

./ 3  

  9 0)

=2 +
*< 3 
 98      )  D 
- #
98  ) 2K
 L )   9  /> 
# !0) 3 
   $ " #
? M%
  E  B  
8 ,0) / 

2" N D # + 8 #& 8 ! -?  2  4   


3 .#

. < )  O !"CJ
  % +" ":  )

64
 
 

,     


       
 
+  *( , % & % '( ) %
     !" # $
% 2 % '  3& 40  1  ! +. / - -$ # $
.61   &  ; 5$ 6 # $ 7 $   8/9  4 :
./ : %A 6 (anthropology) = !    / >  7
 :  1 C D$ !$ # $ B8 >$  . 9  61 
.0 C
 17 # $   ) 'F  B&  49 - 
9 E  # $

%/ 1,  H
% # $ : #( A !  (  GD $
/  &9 J ./ 0D .  :    I7 ./
     : 0&   F .(. $ G &  ) jingoism
.0&/ K : LK= . :  M8  4 &  

A Plain and Literal Translation of the ،Richard F. Burton   1

Arabian Nights' Entertainments Now Entitled The Book of The


Thousand Nights and a Night with Introduction, Explanatory Notes on
the Manners And Customs of Moslem Men And A Terminal Essay upon
   
    
 

" The History of the Nights

!  ,   # () '%


% #$%& 
!  

   

1* #&  /0


 ,-.   ,"

  + '%
 *
7   18351/25 ,(185541882) ,(Burton Club For Private Subscribers)
'1?  1 
0>
  9  '1= ;< :

  9 #8 (
.+ 

65
 
 
 

   
      
!)
#%&  ' (%&   Thomas Assad !"# $      

.
 * "+
!!,

-%&
 -!!&   !/   # 0 12, 3 4 5
!:
;* #  <  -!!&

& 7+ 8*

9  # ,*

   / >? !/   # !: * (
7*& Anne Treneer  = 7
 &  -!"
> !/ 2.@,
 <"
& !/ # *
 :

.99 1935 
 ,"
 " Charles M. Doughty ,Ann Treneer   2

66
        
        
$ $ +$ #   $ %& '  (   $ )* 
 " .! " 
'! 1 ,  2  ,"  !"  , -     +$ /'$ . "  

 "      5$ 6" 7 4 
 ( & !  ,2    3 4 
-   1< &  ! ,! " 1;! "8 9   3 4  :" "
% " $ "   "  :  => 4" 7  :" "   <  *  :! "
;    ? $ /> '$   $   @ (>  !"  /" "
/" "  "   '  (4  '$   (8 9 3 >  5  A 4$
.4   * 
  :8> A    :B C ( 2  $ D

 
 
*   5 *  E4
 &    $  A
 $ A, /4  ;  
  , ) ,4      %" F" @% 4
.H I" 4@  H&" 7 !4
$ + J >  '4   "G  5  54 
;   ,   "  6   4 " 5A   (*4"   54  

.>>  4  ; )  
" F" ,  C$ (> F" @    4 
 LI $
4" !" A   B & 51  54   K /2   =8
F" @% 4  -   C  E4"    5!< ! " . 
'  ? )    B     < '> M  "$ F "  4 
3
P;" &   $ '>  O '4 "  )* 
 "  "4  ;B "
.4  
  

>  5 >4  2 !   /  D 5 >4  E4  *  EB
 "! >  C$ +"  
*   K ,4 "
E4  

Achmed Abdullah and Compton T.  


      3

  " "Richard Francis Burton" Dreamers of Empire ,Pakenham


.58 ,1929 ,   ,"  



67
    .  
 
        
  !  4."%& ' ( )   ' :
  !  #$" :
    
230  * +(,  -     /0 %& )   !    1) 
! '0! " :' 2
6 ! 7& 
 4   !   5 
< =9 3 
= <> ' %  2 * +>6 ! ,
 8   9 8
 ? @86 %A /9
 
B ! 0 1)  2  -8 ) 
5
1B 9(D&  0     
  1)  ." < C
    D>  ,& E F   G3 ,B &  
 
.40&

10  A )0


 
 A -     /? 
First Footsteps   7*
8
  
 * H 0*

$!  -E 8 6IJ  " ! G 6  * D" in East Africa
: ' .K3

L  )   ,( 8 -3 )  98  ! 1  -(% &"
3 M-3%
% %  - ."B 6
 ) -(* 1) ',  = 2%A
 ) -3%
% % #? !  - ( , 7&  !  =   
2E 7&   9  < N -B6 0    ?   ,8 
    ) -3%
% %  -  2 O 6 7& 2 $40 2B
3 F  2 4  2G 3  2%*  P6 73E -)> % 
 - 3A B N>  ,  -H  .#E 150 7& '9 < G 1)
 %  -3%
% %   .#8 %   30  ! +
% '=6

.17 16 ,1 ,"" Life 4

.32 ,1 ,"" Life 5

68
          ,       

 $
% !  &'(   .! "  #   $ 
)* + - / 01     2*+ " 3 ) 4  5

 10 8/ ) /  -1  # / )   2 6 7
; .) :  " ,$ 9*   " &'( '   &  7 
+    <! = ) ) 8 = >/ ( )    +
 ; %  ,)( 4  7  $ $
? ,7 ) <7
7 @
   A  6B  ,  ."  6  2 7  -  ,8

 ; 24'    ;    ; 3 C' 2+ 10  D >) /
10 / !    = $
 D ' 10 !  .   ; 
6
.5' =

@   ;  = $


 /  E )    F
3 % H% .+ $   ) G + ) B  H    
B  3   K " : F 8 C  $ ,C  );
"   "D ; '  4 '    2"D  ,7  , /
7 = L      H*# / H  )   M7 ."(
31 Richard Cobden    " '0  5' 2) )(
D  " 5 /  23N  B  '      H 3 
*  E7* 0< <7 '  H ) + H   O 2P C
7
." )  $' 3 7  31

First Footsteps in East Africa or An ,Richard F. Burton    6

 ,"
           " Exploration of Harar
.1856 %   .31$30# ,  ! ,(1894 ,) ,
.116$113# /1#0 ,"-/ " Life * + '
&  7

69
,  
       

    

%  )*# )+
' ( '
 ! " # $%& %
 %
  
 
 1 & #
 
 
#. " :).  / +  
#  
*# %-# %
# -

Draco's Code 3  # . )+  .  7
& ,/ +  &#2 % 3  456
  < ) 3  
 ; 2 . 8." #   8 /
& !  ! 
#
 3 2 -
 = " :' . 7
& ,-= / +  
# -
 '5&
>5@ A2 '5& ! %

   < )
 #   >
  ?#
3 # % 
 6#. '
( # 3
2 %
D2 "! 
 7&
B C<  9."  
)
 # 
 >
 ?
2  ,
#@ 5 &2 /
- ! %3  , &
10
$F 2 C<  3 , E<
2 #D .">5@ %6 ! '5& ! 7&=

 / 6. )= F
2 

"  
#@ G + ' %H 
 7&


  C.  %
  !  3 
  7
& ."  & $ 3 '3
> ! >3 % -# "D  3 ! I  C 2 F2   ,-= / +
 C D  3   .%
# -
 %
- J %
K! L  )
 3 8
 3 .% & I.  )  %
  %
 82  3 )  
)  D
; 2 F
 3  ,
3# = %
#
- = >! %  3#


,%
 >
  32 . ! &  %
  I   ! 
#@ IH+ >
:'
7
& $" (=  !  . (32 A#" >D 
 ?  
 3 

 ,>   K %


& %
- @ #2 3 2  # ! 
"

Personal Narrative of a Pilgrimage to ,Richard F. Burton    8

(MDCCCXCIII ,) ,   "   


 " AI-Medina and Meccah
."%  "  ! #  $   .49 , 
.231 /2* &'  9

. ' +'   -$ 0 .268 ,&'  10

70
   
 
   . 
    
 - /
*01 &+
 ,!" ! !#$ %&
' % ()    *
11
."/ # 2  
'  
-

 4* 
 
 
 4   5 0  
 )
12
."
- 7'   0 #" 6#  

$ *

4!#$  
 
  *
 1 7 "9) )
" ( ( 8 
2 
  ;" <)
 ( 8 9  . 

:   ( 
, >
&) '
 
    ?*) =  # 2  =
  
*) 4()  2 '  ) % 2) 7# * 4() @ A
 4 %   B
.
# " * 5 (
@8 4
 (     C@ 2 D  %  %
( ./%- D 
* % <*# % % *) 

 *-
  # 4
* (" 5  
 8  ,
&)
E *  F
 

13
# 5 F* ,5#G < % ."
 / *# #)   !"

  .4*& <(   2)   < /
$ H*# 2  
 
$
:
  =0)  4()I   %

<   H*#  ,


K  8"'  K#  '   !" "
% E
 @* @ 2 : H
; /&   , <  5 % G &
  ' N ,"#
 * L
D# M
  =B 8 ( M ,H
-
 (  )# 2  O D
'  ) 8  M
 P  
 ;

.24 23
/1 ,"  " Nights 11

.
  12

.148 147
/1 ," " Pilgrimage 13

71
14
.   
 


$%  &   # # ,         ! "


    # .' +" %"   
 - '  " /0 " ") *" '  "
* ,1 2 3 # " !- 4  5 67    8 97  " :; 
,  *! , ?   =  " :  %; .<9 " %=! 5 <  
 B 5 6; * <9  * C ,*" "  = -  @A *" * 
& "  +8   "  ?  9  " : 8 %; ."<9 " %8 *

15
 5E C 9 ." ! ' 25  !  ;  D  !
.  -  "E 
 -  ! F  "E " 67

G !7 "-   -  "E '   " 5  "  
!
   +8     G "      H I/J 6*- ! "!
M  " @  5 @" ; % @" L- KD " " 6  " 
16
, ' !"  -  N  ."*!" ) " +"  <9 ,"
G   !
  =   O '  "  " &  @!   *- 6-
17
 " G !7    "   ; - ;    .   P5  %0 "
18
"  ! +" " " 2
 ; /9  ,P  "   =*

.259 258
/1  
14

The Gold Mines of Midian and The ,Richard F. Burton   15

,  )  !# "        " Ruined Midianite Cities
 " Gold Mines  $ %
 &   '  * 155 154
(1878
."
.256
/2 "+- 0-" 16

.255
/2  
17

.30
/1 "1 #2 " Footsteps 18

72

    "   
 Professor Palmar
19
."   !#$

  *+ %  *+ %& '   %&  $


 (  )
2 $ 3
$# - #  4 5
& - # ($$ /0 1,& , 
 $
  #$* ,, * 7 8 ,)
& - #   2 ./6 7 6
:= 4 1 SparZheim% *$
< Gall  ; , *  $:
)

D #$
 A    5 B 2 C   7 @   ?@ 0
1F #$  %*$$  
  1%F <$  %E$G & %*$$ H 2 1%
&< ,&  %E 
 1)  @ E @     @$ .* %E2 E % 
I
20
.
6  # $  15) ; J $ % 
=2


< %E $ -   
  ,,2  ,)
< %E   KL )
@@"  (*$  
 5B  
I ,) - @$  1:
#
1,#6 1%
$L  ($$  %E   $
   ."
  ,

.# ,: B ,,*
<  @$$ /6 - =  A    17 )
 
&<  L0 ,
$  / HG
EK 2 D$
$& $
   
MG !<$ $
 0  1
&< !#$ N
  =2 ,)  2
 :

 
&< 0 =  ; * / 5$2 .O
&< 
& !#$ ,=
 2 ,
:$
 = .
= ;  ,< 5*$ 1
6 1P 
 17< 3
&$
2 H)
&<   0 ,
 /$ /$$ : ;&<
&< , $  0"
21

; :<  L 0 HGQ ) ; $


 E ."
&< *) <$ ,<< <

.157156  ," 
" Goldmines 19

.80  /2 " " Pilgrimage 20

.
    ! #
$%&' .82  /2    21

73

   
        .  


'(   #) *+
 ,  .  
!"  #  $% &
     .12   + 3#   /( '(  '  - /
0

, 
 " "
  5 $% &   41 # 
   ,%

%+ )  9: $% 70    
 " 8 (
   

  #  
: > # ( %
  " :&" ( 3  ; - 3# ;  *  .9
 4 : ' " ?2 & 1
 @  &1

"
3#(   
: A"4

B
 ' %
 3#
0
 #  :  A-  B '( 
 
 $% 7)1

 C" @ 8  A    & 9 # # " > 
:
)  EB
   @ 8  ." 
  : D8   +  
A3
 ? #( 3 &: 
 A"3 5 A  B  D%" #(" A- F 
.->  $% "H '( ?" " " $% )C & ) G

I  $C -"  '( 3#%>  


 J     @ 
22
3#
K  &
 ) : C L4" $ 
9 ,  > . 
# 
@ 
 , $CM B % 2 3> ,3# % -"
 .@
 B
K : *
D% $C - 
> 4 A B
 % 3# : AB+
70 %> 9


23
N
 ."3# :: $C 4C ,3:# 4  4 - 3# 
/%

@% $C "( &#


- ( 3 
 +; 7(   O , "% G 3"
:&" ( A  :


 " 9

> 
 %
 4   
 9)F :"
% %" N P *
$% % 3#  )C , 
# ? '(  : ,I  I%
$ #> ' 
  9  ,  D" '(   > 8


.  , ,   


   
     22

.156 /1 "  " Pilgrimage 23

74
, ! "# #$%# " .     
     
%  "* #+) - /' (0 #  / ," #
)* ,&' ( #
 5$ 6 % 1  # ,  %4/ 1  2
  3 ( 0 1
  7#8# *  " #  "# 9 : 6 " # 2 /#  ' 5!
, 9#   ;<   !
=  %    25! ! *
24
."6 + ?= ># ' , + 1 '   %/ (0 "

#  ."$= E#" A B C# 3D6 #'


* # 2" -
 # < 0+B= C# 3D6 :  F% A  ,   $ *  
/ # "* A  2-# 4 "  '   2 +  %=
+  ,1>I!  A 1 " A # "# !H # * 2C G# 06  ' 1
25
"  .A HHKL * 69J 5 C# ' " ' 1 ,A -
# 2   *  "     = E C# 3D6 #
N 2" $  "# "#  6= &% # 6 2M ")C  
, 
= !* "0 "6  ,"# C# 3D6 "' 7) " :
26
.""C 4  "6 2M * 5%# P Q+  &  F%

2F R06 "'  = 2-# 0 >!# "# R A# " 

= E% A    %! 3 %! " 5) G# 2 *  F'
6
# ' <  $ "' " Q .")   ""  E% 4 <
0' 6 A*  $ 6 H "'
= "U F  1 (0 " H ( ")

= N%   ' 2 "# ?/  $  06 "" : .)#  A/ %

.190   
24

.192 /1   


25

.194 /1   


26

75
27
            ." 
   
   ( #'  %(     . #$ % & ' ! 
3  ./0 1 #$  2'     )  )* +'  , -'
:, 5  ) 4* -' 

, .7 = ( ) 8,   9; 1 ,7 5 #4 8,   9; 6
&    %(  ,$  & 0* ,?
 , ' ,9 * %  $  >$
,6 .%@    A @  %  ,%  #$ # %  , ' #$ & 
:EFC   G $ ,=    8  8, B@2 ,1  C  ( 0( ?D
G $ ,  &! #$ #J   @ ?D ,6 "!%0 7 H ,#"
28
"!) 1 D ) )6" :2 56 '   K  

?
( ,9 L ?0" :   4 0   J 9;   @ 
!K =NL1 6 E
0" 
 2 @ ?@ M@( ,  ;C! &
,= 4@  (" )  )$ ,    
  (     ." 2
.  2 = !    &1( 56   )(  ,"FK 56 = O MC  1D

  *  1 1 
$ .  /  '  

  0 /
 ,  N 0 '2 ,1 6" :&
 )$ +#  ( 0 )  
0" %    2   ."P
 5 C
    N  , * (
 K %L %   .#  * 0  ?0 )    ,"Q0
 !   0F    6 ( , ) 0 G   R ( #$  D
F

$ ,'2 ,1 '   . )D 
$6 2 56  S; G  9 

.18
/1  
27

.
       !" 110
, 
28

76
29
 ."          " :   
  
 ! #    $% &  #  '   ()  *)
, 1 2  345 6" /- 0  & - " +,  +,-
2 ' 3!   #8# ) *   .- ! 7  4
?! ,    .3   +; <& ;!=    97
30
= < B +A   .") 0 1) @ , *A)   +;&)" / -
() <= 6"% ,' ,C   "  ; ,  - !  
   7 D # ! () - ) =    () <&  7 * 
31
."# /  #    , ,  + E  ) , "  /

!   F 6"9C     " D )   ;=4 6- !


32
 6 1! <&    ! /,; 6(I H ! .  '1 @1 & G7
# ,# 6@  , 631 0   6 &  #8# <& /!  
' / ! 6"!=  !/  "! 1!  9" :  +,    .,  
,) 9 )" :  1 , B=      4 !
33
 ,& @ B 6K97  <L   -%  1! -% ."'
#)  .7 <& K9 /1 M8# ! 1%4 /  = <&   ,L $8
,  ( ! ! 
 
#  '  ! ( =-  N M = O17 (
/ &  )  F  K9 N1 ! 6-% - ! 3 ) &
.G      ,  ) $1% & .1!

.113   
29

.114   
30

.89   
31

.
     ! ,"
"       "
"  32

.148%147 /1$ ,"# " Pilgrimage 33

77
 
   
  
 
 
  
0 :$%&' (  )" * +  ,- /" .   !  "#
 1-, -# /" ' 23   4 5 *46

0
4 
2

" *0 %0  8
 /"  ,- .7 /" 
0 ?   ."  ' => 
) *6 ; <! 7
,1
   !>7 
" : 4  @ A,- ( 5  4
7 )!  E  -0 "!D * 1)6 6  6   
34

  ! ."0, E)
#4 0 4  
 1
4 , >76 -
0 6  G 36   
 7 F>
. )' !+ 
*0 " " 4 * 3

/" H> 8(4 5 / 4 1 


?4 /"  4,
4-  4   8, /! 6 * ?&  7 .F> #
1 0 & 8
 
 7 (-7 J!+)  ?!
 46
  
   
 ."0 >6 +  " F> 0 -
:  
        

( 17 8 


LM 2' "!F>" / '
35
.  ; P  NL0 
, O6 

#$ # % & – ! "    –          


:   # '    

 3  +  * +   




.176   
34

.22 /2   


35

78

         
  

.     ! "#  


    

.(( *+) &


 '  $ %  
  

*  -%     $  


36
!  /-' 0          

2 34 5!
 2 6*  3 
 278  9! 
 :

:+ 3


/- 3$ ! 0 = ! 3* >! ?


 ' 
  @  8"
"! A+  B

*4 .D >   %   6


 9 4 C
- ! 
 :

3 
% E   
 E 
! 3% C 
- > 7 
 ! 3 F  %! + * .D ' /8 ! 
C! ' F # *
37
 - 

 E 34 E
    * 5!
 ! 2" :D 
$=
 D ' />G % 34 F  '7  34 * / 5
%  
38
." 
' 9 C
  ! 6
  H7  

:/ %   34 % I  


 * 3 @  !  >
 ! >
8  % - @3 C!
-K  J% -  #"
40 39
M3 G 2 34 E
! -- 5!

-K ! L   /' !-

.  36

.23  /1 "  


 " Pilgrimage 37

.3  /2   38

.298  /1   39

79
            
      
  
41
." $  " &  !' ( ")! "   ! " #$  " % 

  " -!/0 , 1!2 34  ! 4 1!567  "! + ,
" "+!   9 :!  ;!)+ 8 7!    :!  " 8! < .!)+  ( 8+ 
# -+ #   ! # " )+ =! >
 -$  .8 8$ -$
"  #!$  8$ $, #  9 8$ :+ 
 & 1/ 17 "

 :$   ( ?! "7  1!+  #!@  "! $ 0 . 5 
#!@  ! "+   #!  1!,$& 1  " 8!  ! >
   +
42
."1!! #,0 %!  ;!A) ; %$  /, 3 

"D  1/" + !    ($   #  (B 1!B C/! !
G  #!$ 1+ ( 1!   #  " "! $  ,
E7+ 1!) !6
 :    &  @   " !? ( -   + 1!,$& : 4 
 #  E0 "I7 + 0 .1!   #!$  " H6 "+  1A! 1/ "
=  "+   !9 :  #B  "+9  -09 /,  5 " :JA0 5
43
!)+  "! E, + ." 8 0! " " "!+   5  6! ;!$, !
  :I$  
 1     #/ 4! 8 $ 5  #9 "0 ",
.1/7 #5 C 4! & "  
 " ?& 8 & ,+   B 

1+ ,   H >


  L /, 1!!  !)I " "! ,
!?, 8 "+ 
  M !  <  " 8!  .L ($   # 

.
        !
#$% &' "
  "   40

.365*, /1* +"(  ) " Pilgrimage 41

.91*, /2* +-$01 2, 42

.175*, +-$01 2, 43

80
" ! .         
 
  $/- '- $   #$%& '(  )* " +   '
, $
44
 '-, $4  50& ( .0 0* 
"  )0 12 3*+
$   ! * " !  $ !  6 $ 3 
45
 ( )* 7    3   ' 8 2 ( #70 '
' 3  ! .!9 2/ 1 6 )* '9* ' 3:  ;< 
* >  ( ' 3* * 3 =  =* ,  
46
.'* 
* ' $  

?  @( 


  ( #&  39 60A (" 1  
 B
 3-!  0 .'0  3! B
   C '-!  ;2/ 
I4    30  ( .
 "-" EFGF ,1 $
 ,B
 J% '
 J<  ?  K0 ,B
 19=/ '
'  ' '  > 4& ( .  3( B  = C-
,$%& J-  #J0 &, ,'L J " ,
 1 :  '0
47

 9" ,'
3 '>  9   < )*  ."'L $,=
 3 , MEFE ( .J   )* 1:
 
0    
 8
 N: 4& '*
 )*   ,:   , '+*< ;4  0 5*
: :%  '&, '!-  3  ."'2 $0

9 2 :$  
 ! ;2/ 
 ...  @, 0"
"Q  9 2*" ",  0   !*, ,$! 74 , 74  " "Q 

.90   
44

.92   
45

.293   
46

.59 /1   


47

81
"  
  ,   "
"    "

  ($ % &'         ! #


)#' *  +   ' -. / 0' 1'  ( 2 03 %45
) 3 9
3 !+ :   +  : ! ' ;' # .
+. * ' 67 
'    -< 63 =+ .>   3?     0
48
.A# @3' 

" :
+
+ B* ) A 4:C + '   ( #


> : ,  
+ ) 0 ' E3  @3  
49
2 ( '     ." %: F7 G  ) H3 ' 3
%5  I #   %? 63  ,-:?  @A$(   +  +
I' 1  ,I(5  *:'
# ,-I# #  ,A
' A%  6 
.B* J %< #   @ I K  =* ,
# 6  
.. +  + /3'  0+  ' ) B:  ( '  + $(   3 1*
@.'   ,/ 4 %:J ,/  , : % <   1 0  
$( N *] L M: 
 :+
5  @>+   ,K7.
' 2 @$ 
' J  ,B: ) + @.+  : # ' I &?  :   :
 J )  +  1 .[
 : 6$ 
< : * B( @$O  
.   K  "  3? 34> I 2   
3 2  " ,0  

 !4 5   % , -( 


> 6+    #

' *)
U:S3 G T
 > .

  %  (Q ' @ )  + 

.61   
48

.   49

82

      
.   

   ( 


 * . $  %  ! &')  )
 , ! "#  ,
1 $  2 3 4 % – /0   .- ! "#  ,  + 

) 6*+  .0 7  8' 9 :) 6)/   
*;
6 5
   . )  1 4005100  =)  3< 1 !
6:  "C1" ?*9% 6*+ *9
  1) 8)@ A0 ,>%   
50
.%   6  <'
!
 ,D1 E , 

 1

) G
 A0 ,* D  F   2'  8' 

8)@ 6! , 1  G1  8)@ 6! ,&  *+


*)0 G1
EC  H  EC G1 3I & 1 G) .&*  @ )#
 .K#/ L10 1 89> J0)#    92 1   %
F*)    0
&9)  -
6; M+ % 0< 3 ) 1
*+ ."0  8' #  )C0 8* G # "  
 
220 D
6+ + + -
 , DH1 8'  0 + 814 -!0 6;
D0   # " :C$  9 9* *+ =)  , 6: + <
O' ,L   8' ' 31 ) 6  ,D1)  )    0)
 4   ) K 2' L> 9
*+ :#0* C  2#
 H*1 4
51
."%2)

*9
 I &9) 6 )I    8' )  
6; *+

) Q .  " " + PC%# 2) 6 -
 ,E  <'
 6
-*+
: 1 R 6' J:*; /
6)9  J   
<0) !
 

) 
 . 1 0   0 ,S   ,D0 E   *+ R

. 
50

.252  /2  


51

83
  
   ,"
    "  
  
 ()  *# +- +  . !#  $% & ' ,
 
 
,2/ / 2 / 34 0 " +  *+  1 " *# (# 0 "* /  /"
+   )  + 5 6 7 89  )! : +  &

;<#
>
  / ? -# @ 8 A *# * B 8C" . 4 =
52
E  
$# + *
F$# ."2-7
 2# '    D= *# 69 ,@ #
53
 4 9 +D J)! *# 
 IG/ >% E+# +

H G -/ 8C / &#
;+ ++
 ;  K % - 6   C  D= *# ; &? , /
M/6 +D .*  +D $  (F
 L/ - +D 7 , / G -/
& + 8%4  ,/ A 
 8? & N
2F  () L/" *# *

/ 89 P$% + 


 .C CD 27%  O! H )9 
! 
B J)!
."O) * # # !  89 + 


D () * 7%  *  6
4

+ %
 * *9 ."7 N *  E " C CD 2#   *
+- +D
 ! O)  
 *# *
;  , + !# + 7 D #  !#
* &   % 8/ + 4 C$ 7 + *  !# M .: D :  E=
Q
;# &# B  !# *
D 3  34- *
   .-< # *
*#  + J)!  ."" 8  +  
 + M/6  .4 - E 
,
 89 &)$F I2 * 
# 7  ) + RC
+ I
  ? M
D4/ ' +$ 
:4/   ,
 89 &
*+  & *+  &

* C  -$  < * +$  * /C E<-  #  < S- 4 &/-

.   89 7# - + J)! *# *


;  . 
- 8/

.232   
52

.       53

84
.  
              
  " :-$ &   /  :!" #$ %& '()  *+
 , 
+
   +  7 ' 8 & 56
,  34$ + %  , 1   
@ 8  -,A+ ,;6 + < =$ >   ' 8 , $?" : 9
A+ , #$   B  *+ - " CD  $? 54."  + < /
<D) 5 F %& F  ?   /  .
+ E ) 6  
: E  & < & 4,  

,D &   > ,& 5G)   6 F*


*   /+
K  3G & ( ,+) , +  , & #$" :GH5
  
.">   <  E < , + ?  ,<   +  ,M $ & L  
& H  @, 
 , ,"!=,+"   5  /" : H5  5 ' 
<,? ,,   D $ ," : H5 B5  ,  5 
9 .5
+ !"#/  P %?   + ! , 4,  
,
 + $ @ ,   O 
 $)
9 ,& -$ %&   / "!
  P ,P  , Q/ ,,?" : H5
55
. 5 =$  R 5 6  ,9 3 F* *

9   !   +   D ,-$ 


 %&
, /   " " ,B6 =/ O M ,'G)"
 ,5 ,&D6
D ,>  , + 3 
 <D " .
 & , ,8
 S   H6 ?" :/  ."8 )  ,&G) ,@6D , 
< %, E F  F48 ' 1  T  ,9  3$)K T   ,&  
1 <, E? ,H6 #$
 #/ ,
 ."
G M  =,    , 

.232 /2
" " Pilgrimage 54

.    55

85
      
  " :  , 

 )* +  ! # $%  & ' '% #   (  
0 &   1  # %  23! 4*   5  % - ./ 
56
."     3

7 8 9   %-   


 % 
    0
:  , 8 ;  '%
 < !  = # .  %


-  >  :"/%( "  ""   -= %
  > 
3! @  %# - AB  0 C  , -; . ( 
 ? 
D= #      &     < ! = EC  F& #
57
. + 0  ! '%#   ,%   %

.%%  9 -# 4>H   %-    G # &<0 %<
  ,I/ A *  ;       ?  @%! 1 9 %- 4
?  1   4 . )+
 +
 # A   )%-  ; 0  
  C . .  %  &   .!   <% & -;
?  >  J# 1C 
/ 4 4K ,I  -  ! %
   
 %  ? B AG
  !  * ( %#   
 *
?  %  , = 9   %- 0 ,.   %- >" . % &

."4 0     %" 
 M - , )*L )

4 ,
 '(-  !N % I # %  7 0  %( 
%<
%   '  &  % ,  <= # F   # )* J/! 9/ %-

/   #    P ! =  %%#     ,  O%  ? +

.  56

.238 
  57

86
   ,
              .
)* + -/ (/    "(  $%" "$%&
'"  
!  "
  ,24   0 $ %   0 1/ 2   3 $%0" :$%0
0  ! 67  (8 9 2   ;7  2/  ,5)    () 
58
/ $%     0 !  ; =  >&  ."/ < 
4   1! 1 $%@3 0  ? '0 .$%
  ? 9&
 / ?  ? '0" :?C  D' ' AB $%0 ? ! ,/!
 
59
."C ;  C?
 C 27/ , $ -     $+ ,&  

;7  $
  ;7  ?3  %E   ?    
 F0 GC? (@3H /   .E  > 7 $%0   !  !
/  ? ! ,9   <6&  =
  10 .I'      
        ? '0 7 = .

 2*  
60
KL  $%!/  ? ! .8   "
" ""   C J
(I N !  %  2  (  6 $%0 ? !0" :M-    
61
O $% E ! ."M&  2/  D7  6 1 ? ,$!  I' 
.D   *! $% / E&  %
 9O C D@) 

 P  <0 '  (


  % )   L%/ &) 
 &
 6/ Q .$%      )  C "   + C 2 
)   -/   9  ' " G2  C ?C 
 =/ G3 
  0 C GR>0 ! S 7 )'  2?/  ,$@/8 >C /

.17   
58

.19   
59

. ! 
#$ % &' 
'  " " ""
    
  60

.20 /2! "( '" Pilgrimage 61

87
    "       .  
 
0 1% + ,#$%&'  (&% % )    *     % +,- ."!
62
.   2 34     %  5$

: -  .   6   - 7819


% %  %
 
9: , # ;-
1%
%  )1  5$1 59%  % +
9 # 
%%  +@  ? ,: > 6%  <  =-
@  ! : : >:  ,"A , @ 6 !B" ,: '* ? % ' 6%
% '    :"  % D .8 C: A% ' 3- 
#9  .
9  #& #EF  #9     :  ."9 ' #
   G,  6& 
 4 6 3-E %  ; C  , 
#& + % : E % 6 )&%
F 6  ,
* C (:  " :
  H
C&'  #9 .")9  4;  
 ,,  ' 6% )9
;  ;  "  6  #  5$ ,E  )-J   54  %
6% $2 ( -  =-
- ;  L &  ." K  E 
-B: 6%- 6% ( % N ,  M " :#   6  (  - (,C
6 ( %  #- # ,6   O  +$2 P % + - A2
63
."...

?  6  + ? !& ,B  4    % )  )%9 +

 : P  Q1&


:  4  * C  .;   
  
% 0 1 +- K  3  5: !&    .!  - !$1 Q

    !  "


  .  

   
   62

-  .  +  Fielding ) *


,Pope (

,Addison 
#  $% 
&'
.Coffee House Politicians ,Rape of the Lock ,Spectator
.3070 /101 $") *" Pilgrimage 63

88
      !" . 
   
-) ) &' )
( $%" :- &     *+)   , )
( $% &'  .#
&' " " : &'    4) #   , ."0' 1 %  1 23
& 8 % " +) "  1  " 1 %  1 23 -7 ,- 5  5
!,< = .*<   , 
 ,%  ; % ,    9
:))> ? 7 &=  <   +) "    

 )  & 23 0= # ) 27 1  ...@3  ,"
@B,  E (  "  ,"0,AB ' CD  & 3+ ,' 
" )% 1) ,J KE ') ,(0 '  H )7) F' 1) ,1A
64
."; , 3'

L , #  03 -J    "   0,) " , =
3  )% 7     M  L+, .@B D 23 < -3)
: " 23   P  % @+ ,O)> B D  - J L  -3' N 

 2,)   ! ...15 +8   8   23 #B>
.)  23 #B>  @ &>)  & P    ' #>  , 
#, 3  0 "C '"  Q  = 0 +,8 #,P " % %
%  -)   3 &' H +% &,<  &+ 0)>  D &% %
0+B+ # -  1,  0  ) 23 3>  @3  R !, .- )
% .P5  1  , L) *' 3 ! 0, 0,AB %   " ,@%
&( , D 0  <  A  ' '  (, @,) ,3
 .& % & =   D -3P  &, , , D P,  LA   7
J"  (C  8) %  .0= A  #   8 " % ,S

.314   
64

89
     ..."
  ,
   ,
    "  
 -/ 0 ' .$% & ' ( )*  +*   !#
5  1 -
# + 2 3 (   4*  1 0  #
6#'    
  
       ,
 *
65
.%07

(  ?   9: ;  < = 9>  - 8 2  


66
. # ( 9*5  @'  4    0


! >-0 + 8 )* -/ 2!%   B "A 


" + 
( 
 9E ,"
 
 D" ( "/ > "  - 2' 2 C@
 C"F
" D#  .-=   #  + 8   4?
>0  $ G 4  '  9(  ,
 - 
 &@(/ 0
2' ' C+ 9:  - 9 4    4 H
I ! ? ,: 
: 
 C   4L  
 K# J%# -

&'#/ 2> O M(  !E= >0  9 N*  -"
D>- - 2... 0 "" *5 2 C...$
 )* -#  %> +/
.*%  0-  - P: ,J<
' %   
(  #  *  

4   * 
  C"!D ? T0'" :Q( 4#- -# R# 
-# V! ,
 !  ( .2/  -? R# * +/
>  J9 MN
."V/ 
( ' 2/ -
X  9( ,"-  W" :>

.  65

 " The Jew, Jypsy and El-Islam ,   .     
 66

' +$ -'/ " :


$ #%&  '  '&() ' (* ,1898 ,# ,"
 !
# 1$ 2&  !   $ $ 1('3  &  ' 4  , #%& 0 #$
.340; ." 89 / ' ' $ )  #'$ ,7$ 8* ' $ 5'6 

90
        
 

    

,0
1  0 % - .# $%& '
  %  ()*  +, #- .)
- 
! " 

" %   %)3 1 ! )  (4 % 



& %) !  "
4 ) 04!   .
  ) . #   3   )  5! %)3   6 
5 0; " % # 
 "5  #  7 
! 8  %    9:
5 ?
 
# 4) @+

>* 
  #  <= (
)  !
#- -) 
%? 0 ! A)
.; 9) B
? 64- #
1 " %
! .
>*
67
.%+  #  
17  .
C )  6  1    D E "
5 5 !  ) = ! ? ., 
FG 0 . 
3
% # H4. (
?
  .()*  95 *  ? A. J
.., @ # 
 "5  I
! E!

+  
1 A
1 + +, 
- 63 # .K 
 
;
68
)3 9 3 #- #  @! 6K !  8 93  0K )3 .6  + =
%) ?  L 
.; L #- C.,   -8 % )4 8M N
.G


.! ), 4
5 0* <%  C  E $%& #- D$;
G
* ) %  % ? )
. ' ) 
3? 
1!  0, ,0
1  0 % -
69
#, ! %  84 " 0* - #  63 6 L3

5 , 4! O!

) # O!  )4 " %  =K ! )  4! O!  )4 9)4 @ ?
70

.! L  3 Q
 95 ."
.-
, )

4. C #-
K ! 0)
.
>* 
-    $%& "  - !
4 RK # 


3 ! ,#  ) 
K
3 
 ! )%! @
 ) ! )3

.306 /1
" " Pilgrimage 67

.322
   68

.          !  #$  69

.298 /1
" " Pilgrimage 70

91

    
   
   
 

71
&'     (  ) ) *  !   " # $  %
-  4-. 
  ) 3! "
 
  2)" + , -. / ! 0
  5 ) -6  4 4 $  ) $ " ) 
" 


2 - /   ) 9
 
  2) 
: ; 7  9  ) -) ( ."7
.
  =  0+
 !
' ' = 7" >?) @  ,/ ! /
,

"
6 *D "'  ) A) ) B )  C @ A: - 
.4 $
 3-:   - 0 + E A) .4 ) -6  ,) -
,) :$:     *D  )
6 'G  H 0  ) -  .FC
; .) ,) :7 3 ."
 
  2)" /    "B
" %-     
+ 4   ,26 " " A) ) * "
 
  2)" +   
J
(?  7  ,- * 'C -       0(
/  ,  2 0( + .% 
  0  ,'? + ,(
K  2E ) ED ,"B
" %- 26      *D "
 
  2)"
- /   D  -= $- $" -  .;
"  + - ,, ? ,-D +
,  "B
" %- + E *: ,- + / ! % 0 &' 7)
F -  ) J) "+ .L. * $    
   ! /' 
 
 % / /  .   + ) * 5"'
  H? /  + 5-.
5$ J /4-+ $ E  .  *  " / ) 5 E  %( *  E
72
E'E )   J) ( .L.  "
  ) /   E /
 / , + $" " E ) 9 B  * 9

 !
 

Three Victorian Travellers: Burton, Blunt, ،Thomas J. Assad   71

.38 1964   ," ,  , 


   
    
" Doughty
.108 /1 " " Footsteps 72

92
   ! "# ,        
   
  0 +( +1  .  .  $  %&'     ()  *+-
9: - 9:# 6 (+ *5 * 7 85 " *
2  3  1    *45
.07  < # 85 8  
8;   

  $ @  85 ? 7 ">  + " 6" 85   !  


 5    ! @ C *" D *+(  ' ;5 A  B$  +1 C  
8$  E) F 5 
%
  (  C   85 3 % FG)" GH   
I   1!  A "  (  *  1  * 7 !  ,6$5 8  
* ; "     (   C   85 J  K#' 31! 85 "  3G.
C   85 *+ -! ( 8  1  3L  2"   I 7 .  
85 *J  (   -.) $ N+( *
  ; O  M3 ;  I   ( 
"+(" 8  O .  $   7 )  0(  *5 ( ! 1 "  +
G
2( '  *" ( 85  . C;G  8' 6 (  1 8$   % 1
85 *#  -"! !   "# ."8  G  1! !" ( + 85)   
" 85    O *! %
,  . C    1!  K  ' 3 ) 
">  + " 6"  C 1 I 85 .8;   8   " + K R 1 GS
.   C$  C +; U  "C   J" T . K#' !   "#

 5"  C    0! 7   (  C   + 45 $. #' +1


,   J  $  %&' +1 *+  , $ C  85 *J E)
   G 85 *J *+" #' 27 8R  ,87 (  8  *7  "& 8"
V 2 ,6$5 *$+ "  2"   (  C   85  N   
. ;  
*L  27  +$ ' 8  '. 3  $  5 K  2" 2( ! 85  !
.

93
 
"     
   "
THE NARRATIVE OF A YEAR'S JOURNEY
THROUGH CENTRAL AND EASTERN ARABIA
W.G. P ALGRAVE ‫و م
رد اف‬
1888-1826

   
   , 
       
    !" #$% William Gifford Palgrave 
  

)( $% * 


   ,1862 (  
 & '& 
0) 1 ''+ 2' 34 5 .+ !-  .   '&  $
The Personal Narrative of a Year's Journey Through )

) )
 &) ( (  + $" Central and Eastern Arabia
.+   ; < !"   ; & ; : '  (1865) ( "7
"
 $ 
 * ( 2= >; 34 5
 .7'+ ! 
) 34) .  ; 5  !" A? 7.1 :1 2 (  ?( "@ &
7
@$ !" B( A?( : 
4 ; ,% ''+  B B
  :
4)* !" 'C D' (  '" ( 5 ' !" 0 + & .
)  )"
 
 1 :&% !" .*' 0  :  0
 
 ( Sir Roderick Murchison  3   E+
34  ? % D+$  + ! $ :$ F D&  '

94
       !  .   
     
# $%    & !&   '( !
) $ T.E. Lawrence " 
  ! 2
  3/
- %   !
" :*+ ,-/ /   , 0
1
."4  
 ,
- !4 5
 $" 

Francis %     "-  7 ,%    /    


 0 " The Golden Treasury 5
 8 %9  Turner Palgrave
 
  /-
 &   %   !
  .   +4 ; ,")
; %    8  ,  >? .1846 4 8 < ;  (=
, ! 4 @& 4 &  $1849 4 "   !
 ,   
?

Society of A- &     ? $, 5  ; 4 '> , -  8 <
 /     - ;C D- 1848 4  .'-- B# ; "Jesus"

 E  B# ,Frere William Gifford Palgrave %  
! '0 C#DF  1853 4    ; - ? ."  -+  !4- 
. * 4-  G- J 7  !  H  & I   & ,G- 
4- G ,(- 2  ( K ! ( !L M   * A  
,  ,   ;#/  & %   ! ! & .!  0N  
,    4 8     G*  O ?
5-  & I   & ;
7  )+4 !
 $1856 4  !

, -  P !
 ., 74= " A

T.E. Lawrence: Seven ,Stephen Ely Tabachnic   


   1

.31#! 1981   "    :" Pillars of Wisdom


 ' ()  * & +  -  % %   1918 % $   % & 2

 2 $ % 1   1 . / ,&.
 ,  , &
  9 %8 , 45 &6 + 7  ,   +
1  3  
.    =2> 9 ; <! ;  
1

95
  :Abbé ] M. 'Abbe Michel Sohail 
   .  
     ! " # $% &
 ' (  % ' 
203/ 
 &   * / 0  1%$  +,  -%) #  *['%)
9 '; -% # ,#% 6 ! 7 $  %/ #  % 4%  45
&  &   &  / 0  ')=  ' 1< & %

&  9% $   1860   #", '>  % > %$) , .9%
  % '  #6%$ '! ?%@   >=  .> #%  & 
%B % # ,  *A%  > 69 %! " % &  .& 
C0D   1%$   >< . / 0  &  ' 
,
 '$ " .   & 9  ;  '  &%@
A% 4%   1%$   *#%+   6 B
0=  & % %$ &
';  '%" -%9$  '("   >   E  '), @ F6 G% %  
."I  '" $"

.$ %/ !  / 0  ?> ,  +,  -  0= 1%$ #(! 
',%) 4% Pere Sebastien Fouillot # &  %  J!% , 
  '%" -%9$  '
$      33  '  -%, *'   '( (
," ?  $ 5 # % % =B 1%$  , *J%=! '  & . $D "/
3
."# + M %; &! $  *L ' %
$ &K  #9 *-$
>)    $! & '%) '     ;  % " ><
 1%$ * % %%  * ( &   .% =   ')  '
 F>
 N% 6%  @  E%/  ( &    &! 1%$ ';%) #
'   '%) I ;  = *'%;  '%" -%9$ &  

1972  ,"


 
 
" Palgrave of Arabia Mea Allen   3

.148

96
             . 

  %   &$ ' ( )* + -  /( " #$ , !
64  7  8 9 ' .& % 01 2 ' ( 34 5%
?  ; <(  !   => 9 .7 $ -9% 6  :

/2  6  "@ < A  %  8 9 ? A 
  @   ( B 9 A  #$ '  < ' 2  (
.2  +4       6  #$<  C 4  < - 
.:% &$ 6! 7      9  

6< '   < %   D@  ! B  E)   B < +
" 9 E)   <   ?( ' .>  !9 2 6D%  
1861 + ' ?   G> G)F # '  9 . F - >  
8   >  ! 5 6 2% * < 9 .4@   )
 !   F H "  , > 6   '@ F , !  
4 I -(   <  !   ' 7   F . (
% G I  J #$ .E)   !> 9  (  !1 
<* '<" , 4K 8 ' " : 8 ' " <  !   5 7 
8   +9 4A"%  NOP4 8 ! 5 & > M > )* B 
9! 7  < '% >< :  ' .B 4 %   (  Q
/2 ,  < ' :  64 < ,   <   
.   < ' '   & #$ 74 99% *  5

Explorers ,Zahra Freeth & Victor Winstone   


   4

.157 ,1978  "  " of Arabia

97
‫  
  ‬
‫       ‬
‫  "! ‪# $% & %‬‬
‫‪  ,*%  '() *+ -. ,‬‬
‫ ‪) *  0&   . *%‬‬
‫ ‪ 23" 4"   1‬‬
‫ ‪,""& 7  5   6‬‬
‫‪ .   4  ** &  $"8‬‬
‫ " &"  **   ‪ 9‬‬

‫‪  + -‬‬ ‫‪$% ;  .% . 6 1 : #‬‬
‫ "   "‪   ,*%  <.‬‬
‫  ‪ ="* - 0  = .$ # ! 9 <*" 5(1*" 1 8‬‬
‫"&‪"&  %" 6 *  ;   .>?" (&"  "& :‬‬

‫ر   و ا ة ا


  و‬

‫‪98‬‬
         
      
: &  '( )*+ , $%  "#   .!   
 3      4 ,    /0 1 # .$   - $  
 $- $   -     15 ! 3 6  '&7 $8+
(     = < ; 9& 6     ,$ 539 .$
.$&9 @0%6 ,&  )* 3  &7   ,  5> ? 

A* B#* ,C  7 90 D 9  9 6  7   (


,*+  *  @ 5  $ 5!  8 A&D  $- E$
5> ?  "# E 9 $ G      EF   
F * J  "#  E3&9 9  I  5  H   $ !
5
.$C

:$  H& KD    7 ; 9&


8 ,$8+& + 

,*6 * *9 < * * < *9  + ,"# '( $ 
$* $*+&D ! * '&7 M8  6  N! .   I! L 
( * *  ,$* 6 O '&7  @! $ 539  $
6
.$ I $6  H&I  * A! $O7 H

:
     

*7 5*! $!!8 $& H & '&7  8!  !  7 MD

Personal Narrative of a Year's Journey W.G. Palgrave


    5

         " Through Central and Eastern Arabia
.7 /1 ,1865 , , ,"
.6 /1  ! 6

99
    .       

 , &% 
   ,  !"# $%
)* )# )    ,  '( '
 4 3"  , 
  )1 2 /0 ) -  
+
7
5%  67 0   ' 89: ; 6

 2 


    2 32 ' !"#" ,/02 802
   2  )> ."   %= $    >

 '2 4  +  !" )%  2 +7 A@0 7 ?  
A1864 )  F  2  B !"# $  8
 C DE
.:I G= 32 2 /= 2 7 4 H2 /2 $ "# G  4 
=  ? :   )  )   J ; = @B2
  "# !% % .   )K
L   4 
  ) 42 C
)    H  4 M  C     )#2
% 3"  ? N = E ?  !
  ; .1865
O  GB B:= 4
   4> # 4B%  67 8

.4   ?
2 ) )9E  


 B  AM9B = H 67  


  B !"# J
  8
  . 
     B:= 4
 
) 4 8B " "  41 " GB" : $
32 # A)9E $  42 Q"   . 
 67 
 .)= 9  $  ? %2  4%9 9:  4R 3"
B 2 ."8
"    9:   ': 8B H B

.2 1   
7

100
  
           
 
,%  * ,% + "## "
$  %& '( )* !

   !0 . 0   12 34 , 54 6% ,-#. /  "
 "## "%0 '* " =%"  9% 60+ :' ; 
 8
9%
 

? ! 8# ;# -


  ( .   -> "## 


 %  
  " "#  
 2 ." 9@ " " 

 .1 "
+ ,) " 60+ "1 "%   60+  +
" $. ) "   6 6% B+
  *  (  0
"% + "0
 "# "#  
 C41 ,! .8#( "#  B!   
 + 
  0 # ."* 92  " > ( "1
>$ %      (  >! 6D 0% " %" "  
;#  + ;  0
    . + 8
  1( !

   "  1  +  
 . +   ,$    +
F  >!# 6D !>    E& B*
 )* "# ,>%
.B0% 5  ,  - 6D 

,! ( 0 G>#  ( 9 + ,* H   "0% C41 -


,$   ."0 " -#D B14     "* =!  * 8 9  H$-+
,    
 -  "1 "% % H 0* 8  "# H% 
 ( ( (    *  & 54 "># E( 
+ '(
H "1 "> . ( '( E    .+ ,I 1 1 "
+
3  >   ( " . " 60+ 9! 9% "## 9!
"1 "> . ( 0 E( K 6*  .1   J@ % #
D + 34  -#. L4  ( / & ." . " 1( ' ?-=% !
,-#. B*  $ N   D + 34 M%
 ,-#. 1 1

101
% $  .       !  "#    
 
1 ! . % %# &%'( )* & " +!'   ,- +/# 0
 %) + %5 3/ ( 5! 6/) +     2 !3
% % % % < ;       - #5   &9/: # (8#
"%#,  "%/!  # 0 @ "#, # )3 # 6! ? " :+
1!% 8. % %# &/ 6# "(/( +/  5 ! A  3/
% %  9/:   !" 2(5 ( +     2 !3
9
."B C( ( (&9/: ) # ( '"   "   &5!

E%!   &!5 #3 3( +     1! 5 "#D
%5!3 G %<(# " < ""9,# ,<#  "  F<( )D "(,/" )* &9/:
&9%/: &%'( 6 2/  &9/: !#   2 !3 1! .
'%/ )%3 !( "#' " #   " (  +   !%H,  #  C( 
03%/ % K / 5 J  C'(" :3
 ,3/ (  "#5 I% !
0%3   D # 03 0(  5(  0 C'( #  0/  &9/: 2/
10
!# "/( (# .M!' 0 < '/ E!/ "!' 8!L )3 C
:"/   <(' 
! '/  !5 

%3(  %  
,- 8 <'  "# ! 5 & &9/: &/ K &/ C
* ;  # " 0 5   *   ' &!  &@ 2#' &C#  !  !-N
11
.2/ * O!<

.363   
8

.465   
9

.376   
10

.377   
11

102
              
 
   " &' & !%  ( )! & $     ! " # $%
12
" 2. 4  .1 2, -%   %  . / 0  *$+
;   (   < 9 6 7! ! %8     '" :

13
."

%!$  // =  %8 %> ? % $  % ' 


/
 ( $  ) 4  ?!
&' -%!$ %8 B   A%A  " @ (
 $   E ! C! )  C, F  9C!  D * 7 A
14
@H "G A' )' A" ;  $ ? % $  % *   / (  1  ."
* ."+  0! > F$ !D  >  H % " ) 7   !  "
  !8 "G A' )' A" I / "' 9 72 )/ ( < H  H
1 2 K8 6 !8 *! 9(/ % )' $ A' % J $ , H!  F
:/ 9; D

  8 G 8 (  %%8  L 7 @ ( !< (/ C  !8


% )<   8 % "  ? 8 %!$  8  !8 6 *! 9)" 
 ! 6 $ 91 2, !#  9 "  % 8H ;% ;/
M2 J   A !8  ! % 9/8  ;+ N   96 

8
%> "G A' )' A" ;% 
 -" P " .*  *!  O @ (
)   +
' 96 ! 6 ) $ @ (  ' Q J" ! " *( 
ST   "H! ,ST   *> N ,-% G 72 * D  "8H ;%"  ";/ ;%"

.440
   Edward Gibbon   12

.14 /2      Narrative 13

.364 /1     14

103
15
.   
   
    
     
 

% $ "# !  


   
 
   
  
7  (6 "5 24
 23  -+ 1
0 & -/0" :*+ & () '&
'Sic volo, sic jubeo, stet pro (
 
  # -+ 1
0 ."8/
 #&" !& 0 "=  %<" ; 9/ 5/0 0 ratione voluntas'
."%>4

(03 < 97  ;7?  9& 4  %


 (< %  
 
5 85)"  B 85 4  A3 @7 /  & '2
40  (07 < 24

"# %< :8E 6  ;   85 % D 4 ."@7  ( ( ( 85 , &
%7  = 2  $F  % 0 85
&" 85) E 6 8/  7 7
< H "/
 < 85/70 ;7 ;7  ;? 8# 0 - 7 9/ 85 '85 G7 ) !0
16
!I00  ; ;4  
 56 " "# %&   
 %& ."8/

/
 7  7+ 7  / (
" '

 2   .-K  -J   /
8! % (0 " 5 M0  2+ (  85 L7  H   (0J  77 0 %&
!& H4/
  ( 
 %
 (<  
 + ."(
 (0&
 
 %70/
% D  . 
 ( !& 70
 '8/ ( !& E0E 'H !
 (
85
/ %  24
 (07/  %&0 %
 (< 5 8/ 0 ;7  ;7/ 
.(0 7 @7 <   85I 97 %/

N/ N  1  7  ( 2 +   = %I %


 740
"N# %IN '@7 O/ ( 
0 B" 84/ % 4  (0 " = 84 %I 8K D
%< .7 70N  "5 (0  (! 0& 87 H # 24
 2) @"# 56 84/

.365   
15

.366   
16

104
    "  "      

17
# ) ( ( ( ' #'  &  . $ % # !   
!   2 1 ,/0  - ,  $ % , +
* *$ " "
( 5 # 43# * # ) "2 " -  $ $ ,  ,3
$
18
.+6

#( 9
 18  2 #  # , ! 78 
1>(  ."#!  ) ) =   # " #< - :;   
C (D 9#   B3<  @A0   =#
#? +   !
0 *D8 D0 F  )E D8 $ %  # 9 *D 1! *#
9=(#
  0' GA0 : #D< - #!  .D8 -  $
,( ( H0 97
2   8 0! 9 H0 $  5 # ! # +!
(  " 94/G3 1   #% $ 1; 9D !> $ % D3 1; 9
." ! <   " 94/G3   0K  $ 1; J" ! < 9#I

1( 1(  + :' 1 "1 # " D!  ! # 18 !   L
'    # 98  4A ."1   ,/0  <%" + 
(  92 (  (3 ! 0 , ! +  ! 5 2 4A  3/ <
,D/D ! 1 #8!  # #! H #3 5 " ! L . #  5  #
,!   , 9   !  )#! 1 1  0 ,0#N  , 
19
."A +# % +P O%

C + 1 !  *3/0! < *8D 4/! 1/DQ    # <

.367   
17

.   18

.368   
19

105
    
  "  "
 .
 +  
 ' ()* #' . %&   !# $
:$ -/0 ,

9 80      ! 4470 2(6 5 3-40 2$ ( 1 


  $ )=
4 '  0< ,  )  ;4
?9@      & 4 4= 5   2$ $ >
E6
D .C0) 4 6* > B4 <  A/ (6 0  '
 9' 2 4 ' %F #@0 4 26 !) , ' 4  &
94 2G
 4) 5 4) 

/4 4 * 0 (6 #'
20
.*0 ? H* D) 4 D)  ) >;  ; ' E  , 4

J
)* ' !I  )  "6* >-4D" #4 5 =4  6
  04 M0  )L 10 ) .! / @ K) 6# ?$ !;4
9 OG ' HN0 #;  )  9   5 9  >40 E6  ) !
 E ! 4) H)) 3* H0 !;4 0)*  
 .; 0&
&
!# ! #4) MP
  
  '    2* ! ' #  4)
4 10
 .(6  M'  5  H6 !' 2 5 04 '

9  5 ;4 5   04 M0 ?' G6  ' E  6  ) 0
 K 404 ' Q"
4 " 5 ,
  % K
 5  "
"
79   ,' %
  B K)  B0  4)S0 R*' :(6
."4  ,0 )$

 R4 5 !0 M "   4 0  5 10 K
9 !9   ) .7R%  =4    0 #' ."4  0

.
  
  
   
.369  , 
20

106
          "  :   
  
 ""
(+ * )   (     &'  $%! .
! ! #
  3,  ' 1 2)+ 1' 0 * $  ), !  /  - ,
21
  "&    " 6,7489 *, 0  ,5  ."4,  ,
.  /

 @ )1,'  (  % ) ?%= ) = 1>   <


 ; 
C9 ( B   
* ) @  1  ?%=  A (  %
(  % <
 D'  ,'    ,'; 

, ) .   ) C
9
) )'?  )4' (  %
     H G  F #49,  EA +
?%= 
(  % (
A! D' >L J K, .G ?%I      
J  
9 
C
4  M" * / ' 
(  % ) = <
 <D
 " ) P% Q9
, O'  @ ...(1N  2'! *D!   ' J 
O(   R
, O'     "* ) %'= '   %'= ) *
('" ( '   P' ) ?%= (  %   <?,9 ,"J2, J4,
M 1> @ .",   ( '  5 4,  5, &
   V  @ 5 M  (   )   '  ?%=  <
 '
)    W,  ( '  ( M "  @ FG  D5 )   $  ?%=
 ( ?%I )! D5 ) J  M )'  X'  5,%
: +> 1

1  3,  4,  ),  ' )   )   (  %....


   /#  V  P  %% 4+ , ' )   D 
9N *' 
 .(   ,  ,5 4 
1 ;  1' , / 

.372   
21

107
      
     ,     
  
22
...   ) '()  & %#$ "  !   

.21 5$   67 4&5$ 23 01 -/  + " $  * 
": 8$ 4=  2 <; ": -59 4&5$ 8  251   $ +
: 5   ? >* 4* < (  0&    "* <0&

/" :F  ; 0 "E0 D C$ 5( 0:" : A


:G $ H) 0* ""  )   " :>5 <"*  G  F 
=   "EF  ":  )$    C$  * " *
>5*  :JK <0    G  F  / !* " :;
"ELM C$ : * " :>5+ <"$  9 >*  9 ($ 
4D ;" ; ": '*" ;"  N "$ +   " >5+
."G HD+ *  " 0* * <2+ $ F($ >$) K" :O
1+

0* =  25 $ N  :  -59   -/ ?  4&5$ P
.2   $( G $ 2  &$ (   2$: ( Q : 0(
2 $ -/ (5 2 8 -59 2$: 2* -/ ? ;" 4&5$ $9 +
.2R / :   5  /   - 8=  


 & : , N$ +  * 2$( 7&  4&5$ 2 1 2 8  >*


4&5$ 59 + .2$( 7&  8$:" KA P  2$: 2* 0 > 5(
$ 2 0 ( ;" Carsten Niebuhr $  * N5 '9 4+ 
= -59 8    9 ;" ,>
 9 $*  2* '"8 F(
8&  ": C$ $ .2$: 2* 2 =9 F -/ C:" + *   2K
2* 9 OK$ 4&5$ C* S$= ,2* '": 9 K* K* 2(  

.
  
  
.373  , 
22

108
.
  

   ,  


   ,  
$  , $" &) '( &
$%   # !!" 
! 3$ 11 21 *   0 .(müas)  *+ 

;+ &) + + :! 56  7
) 8" 9 $" &) 
 4

< 11 ! ;+ &) '( =  11  "<   $"
? EG D $ EF< 8" ,B(C " "A " :? >6 $ .  
   7? IF""      &
" 1  H D""
"A " :? >6 J
 ,E  $"  ' $ ."6 3B

23
 ' . 6" D<  E  $ M  K1L <4 3! 
   " O  $ N  #$ J
 ? 
 + ) IK:?
."D<  +   (P  ' ?

 $" 6  


 4Q IK
$ 1   0
1  1  ?6 "1 :? $" D ,     R M
?   O ." B?  $1 =1 3"  3R 
B ? ,=? B1"L  $   + J
 &
A )  "
 R"( ,"Q! K "  < M 3< ?) $ $  1
 $%  A  D+%$ E E $  &
I?" 3$ A D? 
24

 + "K1  1  S  1   
 ? ."
&) DP   A  " E) IK:? '  A '4)    

P T 3      3 R ,J6   1 A 

.75‫ ـ‬/2‫ ـ‬، ‫ا


ر‬ 23

.245   
24

109
         

 
 ()  * " "'+ ,'- /" 0 &' $ $% ."" 
!
&"  5 $
4'" " "-" 0 
3   1- * 2 +
 $% $*
25
."890 6
:  7 5 6

"<*
 6$" (  "' " '; '
 $% &' 0 )
5> 
 3*  ?*0 4> "+ ' -"'
 " 3  3 =""
 4> A* -'  "
$ @ 0 $"  ?*0 &' 5 ."(+
 2;"
&'   $,  +  $' $% .C- 0 0 &< ?B3

$ ."EB"0 "$ "*"$ "3 "%D9 6" (* $ "  :$$'
"
6 ; $$"  1$$  F 
 5 6$% "'  0 &'
  * E"9$ F 

0  G'*
"  ?* 1+3' B+' 5  "

&' & $% . 5
 4 *3 + ") 16
 "$+ * 2<*
?*0 &' 80 $% ".:$$'
 (+
" :" % 6   "' 
 "% 8 A* J" ,"'+ 6"   @ 6$, "'  "-' 
26
'0 &3  ." '+ J*  - 9 $-
 6B"  
27
5 <' (,B '0 =" L"(+
 "K   "!G
$9>" &'
5> " 5 N '
 3
*
 89 "' M*0 A 1 B
:- *  $0 -' &' $
 $% .'$    6"' +% A

28
$% ."""' (D 4P !* 0  B0 -9 : O  A
* 0"
"
 3' 6 *
  ;  6
 $
",  ""' 5> ( *

.147   
25

.244   
26

.83   
27

151   
28

110
:     
 
 

(
  & '
 '
  ,
  !"  #$  %...
5  43
/ 1 2    0  + * -/ ' ,*  )
*;
< '0/ 9 $
 $0 8  5) (
  4
 7
$ 1  6
29
." @" "?" -/ 
) 
 $
 -/  ) #=

! 2
 2 4'
  '  
 !
  ,"&;A" &$/ &  A
B2 E$ /
 3 2 D &$/
 ."7=A C" 
B ' !
GA .1
D
 $  2  =< ' " F) 
)< ! "

 4 
;

< ! <  4  E=B ;   H
B 2 &$/ I2
30
GKL * &$/ '" A 4" $" 
/ J/; 2 J A 4
. 
B ' K  
 
 ; =B 2
B
  "
BM/

G 
 $ '  
B 0F A !

 < 
 ,
   
3G  *  4   
B '/ J
 ' -/ &$/ - 2 A .N
"
G G$  &C;/ CL 9 
 F 
 E
2
 N0
 '
A !A
31
2 &G$/ IG .G"@
 -< 
$ N
A< 7
$ -/ N
) -< &
!G  ' 4  0
  &$/ 2 '9 4'  &A A 
B 0F
O0 '
 =B
 .
6
 /  A  H/ C

  4"
B "
GA .G  = +
 N

6 
 O0 =B , 2  J/; '
8(
G / ( 4$ *
$0 5 /

6C '
 * %  E=B   & P
GB G NDG (< ' ( #= 
 0
D &$/ E
 4E

 Q


.156   
29

.157   
30

.195   
31

111
:           .
  

& +! *
  ' () &#$"% "  
!    
 
 6   " (  23   4!)   , '- / 0
+ ()
  #  3 "
"  * 0"   &*"
    8
 , 4  
26 $ * ; < +
6= 
 !3 4 > -; -  0 <? -+ @ 
32
.+  

6- 46 2;
- -  BA!
"    3+  2
3
26   6   6+
" 2;-  2;! ,  4  *3 ,

."4 2;
 3

++ D    3 @> &  D8    C->


,G  F3 

 '   
 &  D8 C->    DE
@
@ 4>  CJ 4" I < + H () "  +
" 
 
6J K6 M" &K
  -!+ L /  - K->  3) .  +
263 @6
-    3  3 .; K
+ 2 +  D  DN -
33
> 6 6 6 O)  .'   F> F  "
 3 & 
?+6 I ,* J P - 43  4  () >   AL" F+ P
8"
?+
34
.";?0 @  @L0- D @-3

+6
 )6 6
 "I   0 &  D8  K
  4$"
+6 K 3 2 3    4 &L  C  -  K   . 
.6" 2;-3 >  2;
  C    >  
 '- > &  4$
H 4
,6;  + C0- 2
 B2$+Q FC -  /) @ ;0   8N  3

.215   
32

.217   
33

.248   
34

112
."! #   "         
 
2  1 /0 !-    +, & !* ( ) ' &  %& $
5 # 8#-,$" 70 6 - 5 !  + 3  0  /4,  5  
35
!# 
'-    < &  ,+   $ ." 9 :  ; 
.( < + 7& >)
 :  = 

!#* <  <)+ ( ' & /+, : / ),  , !*   $
!#, =#+ =#- =&@   + ?+, ?  (  (+
C  * 3*  B ( - /, <  ?  !* ( (A+ & 1+
E-     $ .D  & -   !* (+ A' 5 3, $ +  5),
5# +  )'  G F F D  +* @+ 51@+  -  * 3
!* < -&   C I  /A$     H    ( 
36
.  5  /: " -   C" 6   H   &  - E-9 F

J#  * 3 ( K   ( L,, 5 ?  !* ,$0 :
5# #'   I  5&   + E&,  5, -& 3 < <
: ) ) % -& 3 1M 7&,   < -& 7& C$

(@# + ,1  ( 1 % +    7&9 ( G


  O 3-
J   O  C (  (
  M L',  + F , E@  , 
3, + E PA-& . -  7, C !  ? )    ! < ( 
<
  (  <E &  '  ' L',    9   7

51*  51*, 7& 51  : : (   E    !* + ,
."<H

.151   
35

.373   
36

113
  
   
    
    
"    ! "# # # $  %& ' ( 
 ) $ !  
, . 0  (/ 1  # ,
#   ./ +
 ,-
6  ! ) 
78 ! ( 9: #0 /  0  /   4( / 5&  #23
!  +; <   
   =) >  "/  8 /    #
@
  8#3 4$ A8      ( 
 0 ,  ! .; :
.
/  
 
!   (  

! 7 >  @     % 5! 1# 


! /  
)
 " 1 0 ! E# (  D& . 0  C1  B  
!  6.> G #  "    1#     1F 7  E. 90#
(  ./   ,3 #23 A8 @ "  7 ; ! 5HI 
 

."  #  

6"  + "7 " <  ! '1> ; ( ( , 18 
 =) > 7  / . ;$ #1 

    18 )
  ,
/ / E A) ! 7 ( 9 . # J- ! : 

 A) ; 
  4/ / 3 K / 
! /  
) .  
  #
 ) .L
 00 J 0 / ! 8#
   .(
:7 18 . " M

 ;#  % 
 #. 8 ! A8   A     7 8 
 & 9 4 # < ## # 8+ & , !#   #(3 8   (&%
/ . A  7  18 ! 5
#8 4(  # <  ! J   0#
37
.
 0 ! #

.       .109


 / 1
   Narrative 37

114
      
    
  
38
:   !
"# $% &   & 

$ !3 * 5 &123- 4# 0,./    - '() *#" + ,


  $   8     2 +3 *#" ...+  6 5   2 
= $    ! $ 3  <5 $); 9 ) .
 4#
?(23 $&! &   *#" 5 2 > .  &!  5     
$&/( *
" $ 23  %  ! *# . (3  @   2. #"
 8    2  *.  2  $ 2 B  C D  >A) 
39
.&  E  D 

 " 2)D 5   FD 9 & 


 +3 + # "
3 3 '  9B * 2  ! )  .!
 ! # 23
G   2 
 *  5 )   3   $
= 0  %32
 4 !3  .  &  E   5  H)
 D  4# .)   !" !  @#     "
 (" (
L&   K2  B5" J "    4#  %/
   ."& 3
 'D  = ! ' ? 5 K F  @# H)D 4#  %2 A 
."E *  >(23 - ? 5

5 & " +8  N & "  6 & N 6  ! M
 D  2  E 5 93 O #" !
2  $ "  /
!
3  9  4 $=      .* B  * A  #
:6  5 D !   

.99 98  /2 , 


38

. !"
# $ 
   
.99  , 
39

115
!"           
   
  -. * , +  &*+   !)   # (
   & ' &% #$%
3 "  4 ...* 1        0  ! '  /   ,!

 :' !%   !0  8!93   7!  506  *     0
70 -  0 $  >$ =4    /  3 ...;3  ! 8! < 
* !A / #$% *   # ( !@ +   0  ,? 
 &%!$
40
.$) ' #$%  &3 B  !  C +  !  B

"   +* 3 # ( , +      & ' F0 # ( E!3$ !D


   890 3  !     #$% / 8!   !")G 
 .8! AD #$%    -    $0  *   8!  /)< 
  & " -  D  I  +* " &0    H E!3$
:"&3K F<  EL  0$" # ( &3'

. !N  *  0 #$% $% 1$"      !A  )  


8% ,!D    ! /4 /A #$%  *  C$" F!   
0  *   )'  0 .8! 0   %!    #$%
41
. !'        & H  0  & O3   /

 * %  P%  0 F!       80 " ( E!3$ 


 0   1L' % R?D    ,* H ( 8! L H  "!LQ P0
 03   ! '  $   &$  8!/"  1    !   .) 
3  !/ !A  ) /3  8  % =    H 7) 73! S
1"    # ( )( N' "D  /3 % *!L 0  ! 

.248  /1 / 


40

.286   


41

116
42
 "       
  
 
'#%&  $%& #  !    

 
.
 

% $!0 12&" /  ,&(   )  *  +, (


#7 82&      % , % 64 ' ,34 )5 
 
 ,"64% 9 : 3; <  =9 > ?# ( @ & % A9 >7
6 : =;  '  ,
C 3 D  ' "
 "
  B 
$  .@0     ' @E F   :E )& 
."#  
K7 > >%  @2 J4 J" I 7%   ;H
2 GE;
 
7 I 7% 3%( *  
 JLE GE; >9 M 49 
)7&  
 4   O% 
%5  5
 9":J Macaualy

 '  # $ M I4    6 ; ;  
G%  9 ."0 <(  JLE
  ( JL!2 ' 
7 

%
7"  'L <! >7 M %&% I 7% ' P P%, 
43
."$ Q


%; J(  '
%; !0  % (  I 7% A 
I % @ )!  A :E %  ) 4   2 G H
 9    '  M S%" 'R
% E 2
R @& J! ;
I 7% E ,"S    > M    0 H7  C 9 'C
 ';     > '   C #  )   'L    '#

.23  /2 / 


42

.24 22   


43

117
44
. 
  

!" " #              


"  " )"*% #* )  &' ( $
  %      
3 2% 203 '   10* 0  & */  , 0 -/ , #+ +
 '     ."  9 !  * 8  70 " 0 !5 #%4
  "= :>?" 2= 1   !0 #+   % ' &1   +% ;<9 :0
+*C B     * A 9 3
 7 !< @ 10* !  .04   > =
E< +  ( !  :D 1 A"  ? &' )*% 2:  . 0 # B@
     #9  &"+ =%   =  ;! G !0 #  &F( 
1"0* I9B . 0 A9 < % -   G   H  =  

45
 " 0  &1  :9  !  / <  H , = * -    
"
 ."  F 40 = :9  !   !      /(
K/= !" :   0 * $    10* I9B &!< !  )*% &1
9
O""P !"  *"*  /   ! N  =%   * !M  L 0 
R 8"C" "  C*  #Q   %=   10* 0  ."%
)9"3 &4" "+ *% 
%    "R B@ @ B" F% @ 10* ! ."#
K"  #/   "" I
*      2>  , S  *  #
46
.K/=  

 1    0  +   9 8     M + @


"A*   #      2 " 10* ! . /   *  +* !0
B " , = !*/ +I   / : =   &/ 3C  C #+*

.25   
44

.183 182 /  


45

.168   
46

118
  
          ." 
  
*)  (!

'   &% 
$% !#  
   

, 12  ' 0 /


.% +,$  -
  
3: " 85)9 6/ +
 / 7   
 !, , 6/ 3 45 "3%"
47
.0!  =)*>  *  +  ";<

  


        


1), 6 69
1
5 ? :% " :
"! #$  "! ! 


48
E)*  %
. CD  6 69
1
5 ?<
AB
 6/ @ %
2 F2   $*# 6/ ? %  % &% =))9
=) %  
  ) )
."A   H  " ? 
 7 :" '" +

1
@
)* 4 *  > 6 *
 % & 6< I2 % 9

C
)*
  )# & 7
J , 9
 ;
6   *
 I 5 
6 K (2 (-  % F2 L   K 
. A  -
  &%

   
 
 $*#
9
   ,
 &% @
;  '
:6  I2

I2  57 
1 5 59  / 6/ I2 I 9 M L! " $?, +
."O A" : 
  % 1 N -  69 / ? 

9 H
($?, % +/

P  
CD H 7"  % 1 ."
' 2
 '
 % 5
"
."1
5 ?<  859

 5  (57" ($?,   


 
  &% , % 6  D

.197   
47

.7   
48

119
49
.
   ! #    ."    

, ")  0 /  - ,+ *+" )


 (  ! &' $%
 < ;1 
: " /  6 7 8 69 53 + 34 2 1  !
@10 ! )=+ ! ? <0 : ! >7+ 6= 6%= )3 !  6'3 !  
!   5 : 2 +  69 ;1 )5  >A :1 2  < ...... 
50
69  ) +9 )3+'3 I ."CD EF 2 6 &DEGEEEHEF 6'  C  B0
.+19 69  )+ &'  : 

>E+ J; 0 J  <9 72 K  0  7!" 7  < 
)! +!  : *'L C   :'L! &+  <+ :  .7: < >
E> E )E+ M! /   (+  )+ 5 !=! (+ AA
<E= E NK " 2I 6I 2" <=  M (L 7! <= <+K! ! %!
ME  P    : '0  < ! :1 &+ :5I  1O <  :  .(A 
.'+  :1 L   ! + : 6' !   :1+ 2 )   )+ 
E E E0' 5 :1=Q )1 :1' !  :1 !   2 

:E0 C 7Q   C   B0  51!  <; 5
2I 6I 2" 61! :5 0  :1 I O )L=1  : *1  P0 R
51
.":3 : S P' "

+9 (L )L 


6 = 8 :59 &L 
! &' ,
T 6  @0   53 &' 51 @0 : ) +9 
3    .$0L
:E +  69 B0 1 ! #  " :J= )+ 61 @0 B 1   >

.11   
49

.   50

.12 11 /  


51

120
52
"    
       
   

- * +( *, * )  (& '   $%& # ! 
.!*'& *  */   #*  0$/  1/ 2/, !& 0'
 */ * *  34 5
617  0$  89 $ 7  034
 .")( / 77 :9'  ;% 8  !9 8< 5
$
*(> *  7 .   4 ?%   0? (>  4 ) '  # <'
3* */ *4 B*! 0+( 34  A " $ 7 61@  )7
C*%* . , C**& !
+( 89     7  ,  # <'  ."5

 * 0 *  * G!9   F /  4  , H/ ./ E F  1
- $@
& 0M  4 H/ N  5  $(K 5? ," :$I J $9' $ K
0E '*  4 +'  4 O $
    ."1  H/  A  5 
$ '* $(K $/ +4 !  '   A@"  , # (
*   #' 0  4  P &   4  $  (
I?  0/
53
.Q  4  HR/ (  +(7

$?*
$% # . ,$1'K +(?  4 $7/ , 5
, &
 $* 7 N * / A 4  7 , ? ."+ " $ &  6$@
 7
S   4 & + /' M 0$ BM !
 (< (
   '  
7 *' *7 *?   7 : % ?& ,&  +' *T  <
  7
+* ,*    0B  & $7 / $? 9 )   R .  M ,$9/ 7 M
P * +* " /  /M S  $4& ' + /' 7    %,
*6? # )7 ."6$R  7
  7
A & ,-  6   & +(?R NI

.  52

.253 
  53

121

        ! #  $" : 

& &  & - () *&+ ,& #& %&' ,% !
8&9 &5 &456 7 *1 2 -3  #+ $ 0
 0'54.".
. - *- .

5 - "2<"  #1 ;5  2 - $ 0


 #1
&5 " " = ?  
. # - 2<   ;!-> =1
 C1$ 0
 # ;  = B- 1A      .5 @
& &- &1 %&@ C&1 *&1 #3
 ;3 .5 C@1 
,&
- C 5"   5   = $ 0
 D155."C 
 .A 5 =  ."A> *-
=  0@  0
 @
& .= & & &1-  ' 8 "
0
 D1    *
H & &1A. G >"
F  1 C *   "9  # E B1
* '    -@ C$ 2 -  2<  0
  ."1> 
  = ? C
1  C -  ;* . 2.  5  1 
& ;9< # ;3 - 5 ..  9< -   ?   = 
K&&&1@ & '- " :CA "!-3 B" B B- ;J I=
&
5 , 1& C
=  '-> CA B5 "C- $ G
 1 5 ,7   )
:
     , 5     

&&&&19-   1+5 4&& 1 1> #


&&1 H * & I& &&& 16 1&1D
&&&19   & L    5 1

.140   
54

.  
 !  
   .126 ,  
55

122
‫  
  ‬ ‫ 

   ‬
‫   ‬ ‫   
 ‬

&   ‪#$ %‬‬ ‫   "! ‬
‫
"!‪ # %‬‬ ‫‪(# ' (
 ) #‬‬

 ‪! . *  -‬‬ ‫
 
( * ‪+,‬‬
‫‪
 (#  &/  $‬‬ ‫  !
"! ‪
#‬‬
‫‪
 1
2#  )#‬‬ ‫‪- 
  0
!   #‬‬


‪$ 
 4‬‬ ‫
‪
 3
%‬‬
‫
 ‪ 2#
9‬‬ ‫‪6$
 78$  " 5‬‬
‫‪  <  2 $ 2#‬‬ ‫
‪;  )
$ : 3‬‬
‫>    
‪$‬‬ ‫ ‪= 7 (
  -‬‬
‫<

@ &‬ ‫ ?
 
 
 ;‬

; ;) ‪ 2‬‬ ‫  ‪ 
 A* (#‬‬
‫
 =  ‬ ‫"!‪(#$  2 $*B 
%‬‬
‫‪
2  )% 5‬‬ ‫
"
  ‪
  * 4‬‬
‫‪ 
1
%$ 
#3‬أــــــــ‬ ‫‪( :  2? 
$‬‬

 ‪ ( (#‬‬ ‫  ‪( ; $  -‬‬

‪ ($* ($*B #‬‬ ‫ ‪
 5 B‬‬

&  ‪ 3 2#‬‬ ‫&  ‪ " 2#‬‬

!
 ‪ C  (#‬‬ ‫ 
  
  ‪(#$‬‬
‫‪   2‬‬ ‫‪A $   )1$‬‬
‫‪56‬‬
‫(  
‪C‬‬ ‫
!‪: (6$  (#‬‬


 ‪.228 227  /‬‬ ‫‪56‬‬

‫‪123‬‬
 !   
          

.&()
  * #+ ! &  '   # $% &    "
.$0(  / !  # 
   
 , -    )

&( (7 +(" 4 ,( 5 #+ !  # # 23 +    1

57
( > "0 =>?  4/ -3  ,   ; *
."89,:
2( 8( 4/
 $
0  @
   ; 0    ?; " #+ *
!)  ,/:  -3 =/ 
.89,: B
 7+ 
 -/ A


C(D
,5( C  
 -3 
,@ 5 #+




58
."E "   8!

 (
-/ "G
  
 
 F     5



( -(/ "4
* 4
 #+ H=
, H  42  / ; 50" G
 42
K/?  ( 
  G
 &)

.$ 4,? 8I 8 / 
J

(!+ ,40 ;


 4, ; # G
  7
," :7  >  (  
4( =* 5  = ,,/+ @  5; K ? ,$0 4  M4)
59
H$(   8 N G
 / 4E    N
 ,E  #+
."

G
(  " (    +

. 4*  ;  8 5


,O $2
4 0( 4+)(  (
(   #  # E  #+ = (P((Q,
? 
 /" :5 8! 3 "G
 5 R 8    "4+

(3 B(E 5(/ & 3 
  ,)  #+ G
 7


60
." 

 * 5 #+ 5 S 0, F!+ ,4 ; 5


.  57

.229 /
   58

.263 
   59

.262 /
   60

124
            
 
%% *% %) %  ' %   %' () #$ %& ,   !" 
 #%&  2 3+  ) .% + -. ' / % %$  0)/
9 +   2 3+ / 78  6 /  4 3+   42  +5 '
 2 3+ '2   .
 9 +  .;% <  :4   / / 82 
 
#/ 0( 4>% .=   (' <) 62
  
 < + 
4% 9  63+ /  $% @ 3 ,"@2-/ ' 63+ +/"  % -  63+ ()
61
. @% A%4& 

43% %$ <%B   C! () D! E$ 0( % ( 
 )   -'F D 2    GB  0/ &  %  ) 4 / 0>
C @% @ % () (%  I ) / IJ   @H$ /  

B / L" K54 @ =  C! @ 8% @/ 0& 4 #4 .%%(F  42
-  %4 @HM% 
#@%   ,6/ 3%-  6%2  # %

# % ()   3 #2- B 3+ / 9 %+F  :
N2 4% 
 2
F ) %)   B %/ () ( #2- 0%4%  :  #2- %2 O/
62
. :%4 
F

D 2%. N2  4 2 %&  4" 3+ / 0( P%


,B   4  %F 4/  $  @ % () @ ( Q3  2
. )F 63+  +%L %. 2 ,<  *  ) ,.   ) ,< 2
:-  Q/ K"&  %   - " 6 2/  2 ) N 4 C %

 2 ,+  2  )/ 3% $   >% GB %  4 (


 4 @    $ A( C ( 
 ,%$ EF  A34   @

.263  / 


61

.272  / 


62

125

 


,
,
  
      
#%  ( #% &$  '   $ " #$  #%    ! 

0123 24 #
 

 &-   .


  / % # + " )*
63
.&$5(   .
   

(  : ;$5 ( - 5 8/9"    (* 4(


 7*  

) ?
@$*5 (
  #  >  &  < & $  $= &(    

C
.B$
 (
*
 (
( B<9 A < >
( 5  2 :;$ &*
 2
E ); 5 #  ( ) *   
D > 
$5 (
 (   7*
B E # 8/9"  B$( C
 %" :( ( .(* )
  (  F;$
 5 B &  :> #  AI (3 & 5 " ( ' I
  &
$* ' I

64
."&
 


" ;

-J
  $<   ($ #% ? 
1 !> 7* )( (J

+
- 
 5 ( .B- K 9 &<$ B 8 J * )$  -
* )$ #   B  &  ! '$5 .
,&J &$ ( B B$<  
#  !1 F <$ B<3 >; B 5 7<" 5 & < 'J/ #  8 J
5 M  L> #  )* )J
 B 5 $ ,* :> &  )$
O
( 
 5 
  . 
   #    & D< N  #   
5 5 & 
&;$ 
* &
1 B 8 J *  $ ,P
(1
B A&  Q  *$ '$5 % !$ R 7* (*$  &*
.FD( 
* $% 
      F9S &<$ B  5 B &$5 #  ;-
F 9    +T  ? B  T &  )<J '  C B$%" :8 J

.273  / 


63

. 
 64

126
65
."           , 


, *') ( 
 +- ! #  $% # &'   #() $!   
6 )! * 4(  !
 1 5 01%  ( 2 '3 /)(   )  
;
! ) ,: + .  ' *  9 #'  8 7 -  ,7 
!( => ?  ,   ! 4
 6(   *  ) #'   # 7 <
) $ ! )
!   @ **!A #' 6 !
 1 5 1 7
 6)> ?%
 7  D) %   6#') *>%  *  ?5! BCB $! B
 !
 #F $! * #' 1% '' .9    * *E
,!*' 1 $% # &'G ! 4 : +  6 )  7  ;
!!
 * 4  )!' * .$ % $%' # )> ?% ) ,H'
)!   )A  ! > D  8 * )     !I    *!
. 8  )G *( $(  

;
! ) 1) (K! & 9 8  ( %( 4( )J $!  )
 ! * )%' 2 A B &-9 !8  B #' 6) ) !
  *
 #' L% 
66
#' L%  =  .
9 L%9 * 4( ?  ! 1A! M  

L%   ) 5 :   &-9 '  !8  ,)
   %9 $! * 
= 4 $! <  .  * 4( * '  
 *  #' 6 * *! A

A D) +- ! 7)
 7) '
 1 ! )! N' * 4( L% 
67
*' 75  #' ,
  
  P  
 4( O ) *  ) &  6 !

. -)! 7 8

.303  / 


65

  ! 

  ,         
  66

. -
&0  $ 1  2 *+ #
$%  &

$ %# '( ) " #$ $#
.268  /2  ,*   % Narrative 67

127
,        
         

/
 " :
-
# * + )$% & ' ( 
!"
#      
:!12 3* 45 )"-0

9 ;3 <*$  0 ,80 " 5


 67 ("3 ((0 5
(3 ?@A5 # #

 $* 35 ,8 (   =>8 *  67(3
EF D2#$  0* BC0 9  B3 $  0 9  5
 53 $ #$3
"
 72< (( 3 ,'3$ $* & ,C
  
 E( G*5 %$ -
3 +
,735 ' ,#
  >  !I5$ =5$  =$ ! # 753 
# H15$
C+ #0 , 5 C+  0 ,H> -"53 $ * C3 72 J3 
'$I
  $  $ "3
 9 -  9    * /  ! ,

? $ J3  -5* C $# M* = BL< 
$  < ,+%  K
<$3 $  O? ?P  * G    /
 N =/3 7 H 78 
*
9  ("3   + )C$Q $  C+ &$#$ EF F & )<(5 $  % /3
68
.;*  '5 R (5

( *5 7
"  )/
 Q 7I 
I -      J
$ 
C3 '( HD8  ? 0 ( 7< )5 7< ($  7* 
F
,F< & .-0   M*  75% 5 C+ < F   $ JP
,=#3 =53 7 ? J
$    ? B$  %$ ! "   7
.78D F< C+ !"5  T 3  9F % <

$  '/ C+  J


$ J03* )03 5
 7I 
I
.*
 72D 7* & =*5  ($ 9F 0 7$ E
 (0 $ 71# < =*5

  7*   F
 )C$
+   
!$ ((8 F< C+ J
$ * (

.70  /1 / 


68

128
:  !" # 
   .      


 ,  - /0 ,+" & * '  () ,$ %" & ##
!" () !" 6 +7# ,13 %0# 4 51 ,+!1  
 20!
; 95 ;   - < #  ## ) - < ,-# 2#9 8#!
#
 +9 ,1) !"  @ >#" ?  >#" !5 <  <4 ,5  += ,
.
"  !" =  0  B'C D   .# A)1 8= ,8
#

 #  G


? !" 
0!
 'E F #@
  += 
"" K .%
  %5! IJ 'FK L<D 2#0 2# H)
OJ K ,+1)  2# 1 N
!" 2# # = # ,"' 
" !1

   0!
#=Q .D  +=  > =  0  0!
P
OF D   ,%)1 +E13 %F
@  +1)   0  #0

 ## 1 !" J7 + S+ += OJ !


 +(  ,+!" $) AR
A! 
 %
  H
  ?
0!
#0 #@ .N# +   += J5 
S!1 S2V S+1< U 222S
 %!  T H
 
2#0
'K !" %@ %#" 8( %0  - 13 " 
-#0   D
69
=1  2##  H1  +T !"  0!
 ."  <Q O#

#
 H@"  ,"1< +#" % "   9  + <4 ,13 '-K 1
J-  0!
P .  <  2#)1<  +E1 9
+  "
W"K & 21 +#@ !" =  = < 1X W" '= !" 1 OJ W 
:%  2V A= W  J-  1 '9 < N ,
  "2F"
  
5
A#1 %! 2) +
Y" Z  ,'F    # #"
 %FV
 %)  8J- 
[F  7  '7 < OJ 0 +7# U# 

.128  / 


69

129
70
."  
 

% &% '%    !#$


,     
+ 3 & %  * .2  1(  (  ()(* +-$  / 0-$
1 (%" 5% $ % % % 6 ,(%  (4%3 5 (  % +( 
%* %  ,1%7%%%8%9 2% (  1 (% $ " :+* ,"1%7%%8%9
?(3 ,  % <  * &  =* > ( + '; % ' ... 
71
.  ( + ( ,2(A @ 

%  C ,2  2   B$ 2  3/ 0   (  


1%   % &  ) E+   ) 1D  =   % ( 3 # 0
2%)" ( 3
( &;
()
B  ,2D($ 2  ')I "F  )G  H"
 ')6" :( HD D ( (  +  K( 
L6 ."1 ( J*
3 2(> = AD ( ';" 4-O(> N# 2> ')AD  E"  3  M 
72
K(%
() +(D  (    +O(>   ."  ')$6 O(3 +
% +O(> ? G ,() ()  
2  2    K3 2  1 P  =
1% =%(  I ' < N  ,=O(   D( (  ,  , ($
3%  ')
L6 ,23(  2(Q R( 
')
& ') 6 G ) E"+  F "
2%  ') % +%>
   +D!  3 L(" : '(  
73
."' ;  (S%

%$ % +O3     '-3T


 B ,1(QT ?*3 ( 

.28 /2 / 
 70

.245 / 
 71

.3 / 
 72

.15 / 
 73

130

   ! "#$ % .
       
  / -0
1  20+ -0 -  .   & %  ' ( ") *+,
0   , 9- 6 7,
8  5  3
 4 4
: + > -
 6  + "=  ! ,4 - ;  20+ :
74
."*) + 5  ... ") , 1 -+
1A )"

-0,
B- 1 20+ 1   (- (BC  1: 
)1 E  -0
1
F, - ' 2 9 3 4D 7- 


1 F *) + 20+ G+ -  ." 1  " = *0 2, ,
8
"-  5  '  -  -  !" : 0 -H 
%F  , -
75
." 1  0 -H  ' 3 4D 53

)1 ,
0  !  I%- 5  3,A   - 20+  - *)
- -  .; ) 3,A -= ,  
0  1 J-
0
+0  1 4A %K0 --E +0"  ! (B , % 20+
F ! %
D  +0 + BL 53- -0  ."3,A A -E H
! E  9  +  = % (BC -7=  , - 3,A
% D +, -! ,
 M+N   - -  F  -= 
76
8 ( *1
# /  )!   ; 'F,  D  9,=
  ) 1   --  ! %, ) - 6  ( . %
"7B - 8,+8 + ) 4/H1  D " OC J)1  D %
.  C  "5/-  D 4L" 1) % 8B ) 1 

.133  / 


74

.185  / 


75

" # $
%&' 

  
  
 
  ! .446  , 
76

. 

131
 ! "#   
      
  
 (12 ) "./ ( "  *   +,  "#   ( $%&) '$%&
$*#) Southampton)6* 4)* * 56 7)6 ")8)
%, ,"(  * " :%&  * )6 $# **;  .Birmingham
8 @ A*266  6> "*/ " "?     .$# =*
6> :, "
77
.*C * "D*56 E *# *  */ *#6 :6    B 

.446  / 


77

132
 
" 
"
ARABIA DESERTA
C.M DOUGHTY 

1926-1843

Arabia    T.E. Lawrence   


 
       
  
!"  "  " Deserta
  &         
    #  $%  1."  
  123
 + - 
' () &  /0 ,  ' ()    * 
)  78 9: +/   # .42 ) 56   
 
+    # > 
 
) &%
 =
 '
  ;0 <  ;
? ) :@
;0 ;  A
B:   +C =(

  3    D  =1888
;   =... 
&  
2G @" :/ ? (
 E  + 2 ,
2." - 0 & ;  & * 
 =&(  ,8 =& :6  +C =' ) / *

+   ' () 5 ;  0  ,  *    


/ 
 90H2
  .  
+ @ ) ,";  62" +  0  /0 =  
   IDJKJ2JL
"  "   () +/  . ;0     @H 56 ?E 
! #-
6/ 
 G
M -) 
  = 2   *  M -) 
6 9:
;0 /

0

 A

 : *:
 ;      @ . 
@


;0 E!     6 &H


 N   2 ,5* / ;0  N 
 C 
 P0 5 0 2O 9H
 ' %  * & 
 . 56 6


133
          
     
   .
       %&  '( ," #  $  !  .  
     /  )  01  !  ," # - .) *+ 

 .34  '5    &&6 *#    " # 4    2)
1
."   0  %9 :;  <"  ! "  16% "  7%
3 #      9  "  16% "  = > ," # : 
2
."
 @   !    $   ;=     ! " '?
 1D 0#C  '( & " :&   #
A      &   
 #  =     ' 9   
 ' &  ' 9   E6D
   !   F G4 '   0#C  ."9 5 " #  A 5 *4 
 HI   F  0#C ."  16% "   
(    
 "  K  .
( J (  3%     %4)  <
 "*4   " ! 0       "#  =  "  "  ' 9
.
&    & 

5     1 :   L( 1) *  # 


  "  7
 !  )   5 ."  16% "  3 + = 
& .    A A  A        &  ' ( - ' M=
:A      &  

 9 4% =  6 ';  6   ND %9 


.3= ')  1 ! =   &  :  1) 

Charles M.      

T.E. Lawrence   
 1

.(  ,) " " Arabia Deserta  Doughty


" Mr. Doughty's Travels in Arabia  Richard F. Burton      2

.48 47 $ (1888 , 28) ,"  ! # 

134
 ! "#$ 
        


...)$  #& % & 
 
# '(&

: 

    

)2 ,"/ 0#"   , *+$ * ...% *) % *+


* ) '$$ ,6$ *+  73 8$+0 )9 33) *5 3$#4
 $)  $(  ;< % .8: 6 ! '  *# *)
4 ?) ?  @ >&+$ * *05 
+ $ ,3 ;;< =
 )
& =$ *+ ,8) ( ? =$ 7 ,3 =$ @ 

.A(

0< F, E  . B $ C *# 3 D0$ 


 >&+$  *+
* 60+5 8$+ 3$ % H( ? A)2 G 8   ; ,
2

"$ *+ ' 7


  7$ 65 % .  33)  G 2$ *
+...H( ? G D  *+ " :IB% 6 6$;< )  C  (
) $  *+ ."8$+  D$$+ !+ G0#
(0;$ * "+
( 6

." $#;$ % G0# 6$$+ 3" :% 6
 
 (; 3  +   

0( *  K L & E4 33) C *#  G3 D ,
I   "!<$ 4
2
2<&  ( ? < ($ 6

   $ 8#$ * "+ ( 82($ " 6$0)  $
* ) + *  0)  $ % A C $ D
&$$ 3 .3;

,0
 :0 3
$ * *+$ * : C   .8$+0 M9  C 
 * ,?  6!
  * ,6 * "% 60($ $ 
  ?) ) *

135
3
.          ,     

* #$ % & ' ( %)  Walt Taylor !  " 
  1
! )  0  %+ . ! ' #$ %-  +/   +-
1%  &  &! #!4     &/   .3%  %)- 0 #$ &2
( 6$ %   %2 . +- +  +- ! &  5*!
$ &! 3% +
%2 .1%  &  &! #$ &2 
    5' *!
8 ! 3%  &!7
5' (  , 29
 +- ! +- ! )  0 + )+  %
! % 5%;  " :'
; *!
$  +  < =  
3 5'  ,D.G. Hogarth 0 / ? %% #$ & %2 ." *!
8
:@AB 2 , 6

-+ 9 " +- (6;" &  "%! 6  5<    % 


&
+ D"%! =' +  
-%  B & +7 %6 $ 06 . ;
5  ;- ! <+  D %  4    &-  6+  
+ 
 % 4 D! ( 3 - '   D"+   +/ :' D *!
8
4
.:' " +$ #!4 %  5% "


.%+ ) ; + , +- ! + -  ='  


;
! %+ %2
%
4 )  "% - F- );;  
 " 6 ;  ! E ' %+

   ,"  " Arabia Deserta Charles M. Doughty  
 3

Arabia    ! 
 #$ % &  .95  1 .(1936 ,) ,  , 
.+- '*  % "  " Deserta
(1935 ) ," 
" Charles M. Doughty ,Anne Treneer    /  4

.392

136
  . 
                5.
(!  )! *  , &! ,'  ,&   "  #$ %  !
 #! 3 . 1 0  2  1 0$ / 
 " + -"
  !   . 4
   !    / ! &
!   3 6."8 4 #) 4 '" 6 !  "6  7"  
  7."4  ;<!" : 7 %6 1 " & 9 '" 7 -
   4=3 #! %7  )    >& ? @ !
7 " "E" - &A 
 B " C   ?  D .    6"
. ;   ' - 

  /  $ 0? -  F( 6 D +"  0@ "  G8
-!   I6 "  ! /J? K   .3  "&" H
3 Sprenger 8 8 L" 8.I
  3 %D    #$
 N'& " : / " =" -"   ?!  # 
28 +  L D  "8 D  4"   ! -" ? $)

Travels in Arabia Deserta: Stephen Ely Tabachnick   


  5

&  ,#$ %  ,"! :   


" Themes
.(1981 , ' )
SPE Tract "& &  -" Doughty's English ,Walt Taylor    * + 6

.1/ No. LI (Oxford MD CCCCXXXIX)


.270 – 262/ 1/   Arabia Deserta
.349/ /2/   Arabia Deserta
 & 4   $83 4 9 !! 6 ; & 7& 8 , 56   1  23 4" 7

&! ." '@ AA& B ,> ! ?&3 =*$& 4 .2 ! =* . & <65 ;
.264/ /1/ B 
&) "& " The Life of CM. Doughty D.G. Hogarth #5 . .C& 8

.115/ (1928

137
9
."  


$ #
      
 ! , 

  
10
 , -'  +! ( /! %
0 %& 
'  
 () *)+
7! , 5 !! 5
$! 6
 ) " )' 12 3' $ 1  
'4
(0! ,6
 3  ; /! 6! ,:+ /! 9 12 3!  1   ,
8!
11

8 

@ :+ 9=> 5 ! /?
+   / "< 5 ;8 
2     /! 7)! (?  5+! ( /! A
8 5
 B@  .A
:($

 
? D !'   !$ &E? ? D E 
 > /!  ' $' *$ ! ;
8 * )' ;)8  ;>!  (8 F
>
D' E ? !  E /' 
? : G&E  !  H 5I 7
+ 5
-
 3 ( E /! (+  ! >!  !  .  3  /! ! J /!I
! :G&E 9
 3? 2 J 7 /  ! 7 + 3!   6)!
-! /  
5
- 2 D
 3  (0! D!E 9 ?   ) 2   2 + 
12
K7 + ! 7
+

/?" :* 
 L :($  / 
  
 D 
   
 E !'  * @!   
 () @ 4 7)!  #"KD?
/! J   ! " "5
-!   " ;>! -!
 ./' 7 /! J 
I 7&8
7
+ 5
-" /? /  ,! * M
 ( E /' 7 2 "

$  /!?

.115  , 


9

.272  /1 


10

.264  , 


11

.1  , 
12

138
   
 
. 
   
   "
$( /
* 01 2" :! # $ % &
'( $  )* +  ,-
2 7 5  
 67 83   )
89;

,
# $
3
  $  
 >1? 9 1 ,- %@- 8<
 % = +
#
,)(
13
$
) 
 
" ."!  $
( $ *
,'# 6!

B2#
 B) 1
# $ 6) )# ,- A ,1 9  0; 
#

$ D)%  
8*  -  %   5 8$
3 $( $#* 
) C
14
 )* $ 3 ." E)
)* % 
7 F2  B(
8
 %  8 >* 1 $
 ,2( +(   $ D   D 
,)( H)> ( >* +7 (
> D2;  )* G( 
. )

B; D) 67 % - 8 Tabachnick 6 


3  8

,"" 3 D2;
15
. I !>* $(

 ,- D)1


3 
 9)#   J%
 +7 $ *K J% 6

D 67 %

.0# 
 D2; &
0
 D2; # $  D


.L )* 2 ,- D2 M  ( D2; 0# 
 $( E1 3% ,=
 =3
% D # ,)* * % # M E1 ,)1 3 J D A1

1 (" :67 $( 
3
.+
 D* ( D2; $( B(% 3 % ; #
D2; 1@ $ D ,
 ' $ 93(
 J>2  81

2# % $

0 ( $ +> 7 Q)N( O P2 
." )A D1
 E
) ,1  # $
&3  &
 +7 C $  6
"R& ,- #1  " :H1 D#
$

,= 
   %  )* 1
.B)2 S;
  )* %

.  13

.369 /2 ,
   14

.70 
 ,Stephen Ely Tabachink   
15

139
   
! . 
     
   
" # $ % &'  ( $ )!* + ' ! % !
.$)  1"0" ,-  

3  
 4 ! 5  6 $ %
 $* -6 $7 ,%
 3 ! ; :; 3 $ &  $* ! $= ,3 89 :; <!*'
4  5  6 ? 5  -6 $ @ . ( >-6 $ ! 
: 3  "  ! " .B!*   6 & C; ,B!* -6 A!
>-6   E $-   4  * <  '! 1B!* -6 )  "
." $ '! % $ 0   ,)  C 1F 8" $ 497
.B!* $ *  3 !  B3   ! ! !6 +G!
 E &  $* $ %!   $* ,   5 8 *) &!  :!

16
$H -6 .& 
! * ! '! * :  3 0
( $ *
 3 3   " :" 5 >
 " I
,$  :   3  GA !
17
$ ) $ Tollog ! 5 I
! E ."""
 &  , ! C <-
:" ! $* & * .,- :;   ! ,<  "  ,  3 B
18
J) CH! :  %  ."
   6 ,  $" :! $  
893 % 3 89 5" 
*  4); $* $ ?" : @
   '! B   3 ) .BM     "L* :; KC
., '    9; $ B  &""


  $ 3 89 :; ! 


 4 5  A 3!

.496 /2 




Arabia Deserta 16

.381 ,  
17

.600 /1   


18

140
 . 
 
         
  ! "#  $  %   & ' () *+  %, &!$  (#'
19

   .( - 
/  (+ ("  0#  & ' 1# 2 3 
Aelius 8 # 8  (   ,
  )   05 , / 4 / 456
(+ ;

 .  & ' (     0#  (!9:  Gallus
()=  %#  & ' + 2 =" ,( =  /5 = ("  0#  <
., !=+  * 
 %  6   ,8=    05

>)  ("  5? & '  ; 1 (+@  >) 
A) % 
/$ /)# ()" & ' B/ (=  C%, & ' ,%
   .456 ( ()=

6 F' (  ' ( / (6 ) ("  0#  & ' ,%  D+ 6 E ./"@
.  %, ;
45  (  ( G B,6 >   D 

 /
HI 
:  =
  = 
$ - -
) HWalt Taylor !   ,Treneer  H Barker Fairley  )
)   /"9 "  0# (! 9 +
6 E HHogarth E, 3#
:  #  &!$ (   (+  
6
KF .D-  J: 
 (#
"!  (* = (   = B+ H$5  #  &!$  H!
.4$5 4 = "("  1 "  ) /5$   ("  0# 

 ,/ ' 2


6 - ;  C%,
$ ()  !" &!$   -
 ! / :
      ./"9
  %, ()# &!$ 456
#9 8   , >#  C%, . + ) >#  M"
:+ 6 &!$
0# ( =  ()# " Die Alte Geography Arbiens " Alios Sprenger
   56 ,4 - ("  0# 
$ ( !$ (+ , ,(1875) "" 

.415  /1  


19

141
Arabien und die Arber Seit Hundert Albrecht Zehme 
 ,(1875)     " 
   " Johren
 - / '0    .  !# $ % &'* +
.1 % - !' / 2 3# ' 4 56 7 -'

; 82! 1872   8# 9: ; 3 3 -' 7
  A# ,?@ ' < /= ;#  >1874 8&  .

& !9! /7 -  1875   . /= ; 2 -6  -2 
-' - /   >8 2  #  7 ,82  ;&
" :3@  ' A. Sprenger2& /= 6B  .B$ ;6# 
  /7 -  < - E ."8 0 D DB 2  -'
-F 4B 7 ,8 /= ;@6  ,"/ - " / @62  D#=
K6 /  H-' 5@ >!I -   J -
 / @62 G2
- 7 @  ,2 4  M@2 B -  4!# ' .L#
; %#  @  -' 7 ."#" !I 4   3 -'
;' 3$ : 2 @  -' ' , $ N&'*  O9
." 8#"

9:  /= R2 ;2F ,# -'  -F P6B @  Q& @
Q #F' ;
S /= ;2 Q&  P6B @ *  5 .-# -
>  - J# .## 32: 8  3' ? ;2 D  >  L2
3 & ;10 " T 2 " Elements of Geography '  
 5 &  $ '  4# ;10 8S <  ,Lyell
*= >@@# /= 3 #    - /= 3 >?@ ' 8

142
20

   !"# $ %
& '    
, 
 
!"# 3 4 5 ,() *+ *(% -(/ * 0( 1 2 2 .  &
.  &   6

&/ " $ 2 *5


%  4  6  3
&# 7
8 * 
.
2 
   & * %6   & 6  /" $ %
+
) * % 
9%6 :;  & &
 4   < 2 A
 4 "
(  (@" 
 6 (2)  " < $+ *2
 2
" *5
(
" 6  
9" 2% 6   B2
 (  4 ,"A  2" B(/

/
( * E 9&  - :0(& 7/ * *& E 9& '1 C D &
21
2 % %
(% (@  " * 4 ."(A) 28  2 E 9&  * ( G 9 &

J( 2 .     * '  H6( ((  I  $G( (  B &
   6 (2@ -  0( )  2   & &  H  Tabachnick  )

-  ( B

  K&2 4 ( )  .
2( 6  9 (
3 4 A 22
  2 " 9 (
6 (/""Dawn in Britain 
 6 B ) &
0( 
6 22 $N 4 H  ()   .  &
L  * 42 M!@ *   *
(O9 * 
 A 9   %
P  " * $N (9" Adam Cast Forth
4 "*&Q M2( 6" Man soul 
 6 ( ) 26  4 6H42  *
22
.R' 2 L%)  *2    %  E S   -  $ 
L   * Q

2 .2@6 B 


  ,*  6 "
(  (@" 3 (@ 2
 ,
(  B( ' 4 ( 2 4 2#  * T2# +!+ 2@/

Agnostic "   "       . .   


20

.!# $%    & ' ( )% * +  ,# Humanitarian
.159-0 /2- !# /0 Arabia Deserta 21

.33-0 ! 0 2'!  3 22

143
  ,
  
  , ,    
   
 
&' (  )*+- /0  1# $%  .          !" 
78 - /5 %  9
 :
  /0  : .
  -  23 4  56 
.$ / & 56  -  ;< " 1 :5 
 9 9 -0 (   

 
  1     #   * =      

9  ,  "
?5      " 0/ ,""5 " 56  =  
."%9 B
9   ?'-3" @
  ?=   A  

:%  $ / &    4 )0/ C-  CD  '/0   


   ;     :-  ,  " :
-  /0  =  .
-- 
    2  ,E 9 F/  ?-  #  
8     ?-
/0  !//HD ."
  4 =  E 9 " G 4- -"  @   # 
 
 4      E  8  /0    ;  /0   I'; 
    - 4   
 ! D   7 +  D- .KJ  ,4 K5KLK , J
 ;';  /0  ?5  .1 1  *   * M9 "  M
 5" 9
/D8  ?5  ,"O KN"  4" B"/0 B%  8 CD    8 I ; 

KJ; M   4 = 9 .(S6 )   Q    P8  /D8 # 4= 

8 :-  /0  9 , 8 ;  8 :


-  "/0  S%    
 B  B  /0  # E   .$ / &     B -  
  4  #Q E   8  /0  9 .-  "-  
!2' 
 --      8  M  /0  U2 .% 8 'D  #9 
/0  9 .&     --     /D ,;  4 "    '

V :   5 7/ A 8  ;  /0  # AV "   DV
.8 
 V 

144
     
 

 
          
$% &   !  "
 #  !  
 
  
 .
2$ .(+0) () !' !* +$ !  -$ # ,$' 
! ) $0 2 $06 !7   . ! 
 $34 5 
 
< ' "
 $0  !    .:$ $ 0  "; 
7$ 8 9
! 7  
'    .A* 6 = >$4 ? :@ "; 
$ 

 $0
: = -5 
 C  
  $0 !  "
 $0 < !    *B
8=
4  
 $D 5  = E$ .$4' $6 

.! 6 -$
 
 $6 :$@  &$  
 = = ,: ";

"$6 &$" (
5 !F ,Barker Fairley $ $5$ >$5*  (
=7' (D$ 
 7 C  B
,:$5 &@  7 "; 8$)
 )
!5 
";     !5 C  >*B  .$6 :$@  :$%  


145
"" 
  
   , 
    
#$ %% & ' (! ) *%+     -    . ,  !
!$% 5# + # / 2% # 6 .$  /   '0 10 *$% 2
 3$
*. 1 8
  &    # 
 2%  . ,7  & /
<  <= ; :/ 2% # 6 ,$! (
* 9
#8  
23
.? *$ ; >? 6 ? &

= A$  B  2% ,"$! @" 7 * 



3B  D   ,+ C D0 .+:  &0 $! (  (
8 ,/ %$ A?:' EA  21 79 7!6 =C F  # 
 . C ,7 !6 =C
B    G!$ 7"
 6+ 21.
 "    3$8/    = 2C D:/ +  . ."*  #A ' HI:
0
 &0 K=
  ...J  21 G= H%$ 21:6
  A6 %  L  21 7 =C 321!  2C+ M 3
/ 21A
EA  21!  6! <= B
N      3!J  $  !6
.":  % "*$N$" #  <(O # )=  21AP$ 21! .  
Q:  ." +6 . ! <= , +  . . *. &
  B  
* $ S$/ B E +$ <  * 0 0" :>?
  :
   # B 
@
*'  #?: ; *! 3Q: * $ A$  A$ O E +$ ,2
S$  !6 .  28 & =C ."Q: <(0 # * 1$ K%  ; $!
) $  ; jingoism  6 &0 / S!$
# 
 ; A $
The Clouds "   :" The Cliffs   : ,!6 *$

7
&  . '0 ."A$
+" The Dawn in Britain "7%"

Charles M. Doughty: A Critical Study Barker Fairley   23

.58 (1927 ) ,"  : .


 "

146
 !# $%        " 
"
!# 0 $12 3& 4%  .- .'   &# ' ()  (% *+ ,
(5 0  6& . - ! .' 70# ' 8% 9 ,  
.# < .  . 5 ; !# ! !2 +  , 7+ !
$( % !  $A @  ! 3 ,'? ? $! " .= (5>   !%
!# B < >E 5 = (5 F (& ,"!#   7 BC D+
24
G   ."(5+# ! !%   9  - 8 '" +,
, -  -2+ = $+, ! > 0) D G  ! ) ! !
 B ? 20"  L83+ 20 " :(5 H' I5 )? 83 J
D "L5 (># 3# LB  20 6' ;% ! (!0+ 5#) ( D0 L5
20 ,)+O 83+  ,)+O )# 0 20" : H'  - F >
= % ,+ % 02" +5 *E (5&  (& .")+O 8 0 8 
# L5  20 8% I# ! !D  4)? ! 20 !   !0
!# ! 3# .0)< )+O 5+% 5  = *  !, ,(>#
25
."(% ( !2 (0 )+O

 (50 E>, !  !'%   ! < ! 
.# QB> (  ! ,- ; (5E , # %  8
>  %
(% 0 T S J# $4 . %O =&  R8= .> C 

!% !2 D+ U 5 D $0 T )+O ;%  -<
.   B> ( $(D+ ! E?  D  0)  (5#
26
20 !# 3, ,BH) 
 # "4%3" J I !# (< .. V 

.318 /1 




Arabia Deserta 24

.526 525 /2 ,  


25

.56 /1   


26

147
     "   "   

  
!  # $  %
 &&' #    &   () .    
- 4 " 2 
# 3 " *+ %! ,-  *$ / 0 * * 1

 ; < !,  = 5 !, 6' %!   7    8 9, :2
.%        &  > >

 & / -C   . AB  


 ,  7?   78
5  E
 * ,'' ; 7!  D " +  
 7' -&   28
)G ,"...
  - *> 
  ,  <'   -"  7! ; ,"F
?I 0  !I ! 0G 7 .F 5 : ) AF  H 7! !I 
0* 
&  0=    7&
< , AF %
 " :E!> E ?+ *>
9 6 G 7 E *! ) 4 "%' K & 6> # ' 
 " D   
27
." 8 6 G * 9I  2

D  ) E & N ,


 ( ) ' I - /,-   I  
O
 >  <3 
  %
/>   
 * .%
 8 9
9 6 G 4   O  + P ,  + 4   C . ; ,-  '
,- 7? 6 G C  , AF 
   6>  * >  = 7>
P < *C 5 .9  O '  P  6> ' Q8   9, 7

28
AF .  D ! ! R <  O2 /&   3)
0:  5  %  .'  3  75  3    * 
5 "   !! & AF  2&  #     

.101   
27

.387   
28

148
29
." 
         

*     !#$ %  &'# ( &) 


$   
  +3 4" : $ ,#( * , #-  /# 01  * .+# 
30
# 8< < ," 0  7   ,54#6 0   1  7 4 89 ;*
  0* +1  !#$ #> #6  *
4# 
#  = 54#6
) 0 8 A !#$ B4  ,?@  0#   4 '
3   *
%> C  D> # 0 C* ,0 * *    6 C* 4 +#  C 1
.5@ %1 4 E %1 04 F @ C* < &

 1 5 0 #

,+#  *  F  # E7A * 5#G E#7H '#8 1 CI#
* 0 8*  4 .C< 4 0  # ( J  81 J#   081 H
#I
K8
#6 D   77  A1  * C$" $  K
  #Q8 1 )G  4)
8  G3 #KI 77
GLOLLM LN 
31
5  F  8* 0  * +#*1 @ .(R<A SL8A +>A8 1 
4 C<Q* # C<#84 ,"8#8 !UV" :K@ 0   C<   E81 5
32
 A84 +# K
8 4 C<1 04   8* ."08 * X :K@  
#4 ".1 D8 
8A Y#  Z ,581 8#81 :K@    08 #6 &'$
  ,#1 #6[ 
8A 4 #41 1 88  ,8  #Q8" K@ G  0*
33
,  4" 0A 4 ."RD# 1" 08 * #  G 4 KN @ ."!8@
."8  +@ 4

.379  /2 , 


29

.174 173  /1  


30

.145   


31

.191   


32

.63 62  /2 , 


33

149
 
      , 

 
   
.

!   "


#    $%  & &
 '
 

5
 6" :123
( , 0   ! ,(  )% !*+ )% )-+ "+/
& 0  &
 5 !5
*   8 *&  % 6+ , 0 - 7 &  
=++ " >
?<"  + ' ." 5 ; <" 5+*+
3  
B  C D+-  + ,  (0)
 < 
  
34
I H
(<& 
 (+ .""EB &  0-& F *- + < 
%& 
G
*-6 ( F

   
   3
-  +#  & "% F ++
! , <  8 7
 L+ & ,$   K2-J D  + 0
8
35
.%+$ MF 

) >+ .N 


 +  >
?< +  O
 G+
+?(++ 
<&
  
<&  +  E D (+ B P+%   Q

: + R%
 !   +% & ;
  ?-
 , 
%
 +%
36


1
&+ ."
*-  +* -+ > & =- ,0 16
 D 6 ,5
 ; 0
&"
 
-  + ."-  +< "*   8 & 5 +S- +

0 +- 58" :+# +
  
8  +< >
5 -&  )+

  
< >
+ "!+< 8 -&
 ,; 
-" ... !=$ 0 F ,;+ 6 ,T
+<
37
+ ."+ 5 +< R8 +<
 ! ; & +" :3
( 0#+ I% 
"O I+U  I 6+ 5S 2 +<" $ >& + M& ,
#  

.161
/1  
34

.365
 
35

.507
 
36

.588
 
37

150
  ! "
 # . 
       
,+!  &
 /0  & "1 " , $ % &$' (  ) ! *+

38
5

  "
 ." 23 0 /  ' (  4+ & $ & 1

:5  /2 7 &  ( 0 "+ 6  "1 


8    
$ 9  ; &
 4% <  "1  2
,$   >    *  ,&$ ;  &  
 1 , + "1  =8
$ +
8 ; 7 0#  @&+ A$ ,$ ? "1 51  8   "1 $ 1
!  E F
9 .4 3  5B C 0
"
 (  ! D  
 ,5$

B
1 %   +
"
 D  , 8$
"
 & 3 ! ($ ,
39
." <# 

 H  & ($   , "1 ($ /1  /B /=G8  
40
<1 H  7 @583 /B J1 9  .< % 5  I B ($ 7
41
"1" :/2 A$ #
 ! H @"&2 "   $ &K8 1 B
, 5  L  
3  > C
H; 5 ,/9 L " 
&F$ L3
 C% ) ( +B &$  ) "1 +BM  / < 

"
$   
42
."5  " "  ;E ,( 2
8

    @7    "


 &  $ '
 )  
  /'
 51B &8 /B (  $
 N 9  @
$ '

.586   
38

.520   
39

.230 /2 ,  


40

.131   
41

.40   
42

151
 ."
"            
  
$%&   '& ( )  *+ , - /0 1 "
"  ! #!
43
.  ' 5 8 5 3  9 0 !1 "! 6 0 4 13 ) 5
 23"
; 4 1 ! $(  ! .$  ! 8%  9 !  :3
.$ '  ) $<< 9 #2

5'   = 6 )( 6   &   4!3  ! 
 ; $ 1 B .8  @  @ A  ( $ ! ,<  $
>
$ %<  ' .=3 6 ! $0 ' C1 )(  8% #2 ;3 1 )
 8&  8  D '  ," % " <   6<  
:2 E 3 F    

!  #3  . +
& < 6 ,=3  + !> !3 #3 
  , !> ! 4! , D  6 < !> !! ,'1&  !>
,!; !  !1 I , D !>  H $6 )' H6 F B !<
JD9 ' K !3 0  
-% .=  C  4 D !>
44
./ !3 K( J 

, < < 8< @ 3 6 0 H < L9 3 M!  M



1 M6 < 43 /( $>< 3    *  % 8  3 *1 B H+
  0 " ::-DB   #   4!>  $
 .  = 6  

I6  1 6 1 ,9 $D'  23  : 4! N8 =B  % 1 $3

.635
1  
43

    !"  #  $% & $%   ,548
 
44

.)* $ +-&/ 0 1 ' (&

152
45
."(   ) 
         , 

$%&       !     #  $        


5  $*  1 !2  % %3 4
0'*  
%+  -  /& 
 B @A>?>><=   $     $;6    :6 7 & $8 $# 9
:#%  *  
$ %  $%   #"  E    D C7
46
." B G B
 $ & $  &" : 3 *     8 B * F
-   $ *  $F * & !   F    H8    2
."$   '* " -  
I%9

C$G
  $2  $*  $ &     'G 
I%9  D 2
7=   B
-  2 $*6  %9 - &   2 C7G  *   
> K$F 6  M   2   L " K     " :' % C  :6
D ."$&  : 3 P#  : 3 $
G3 C$F     NO +F 1&  G ! 
& % > B6= B 9 - PF3 L+6 -B  Q%    
 C$   $   $ % $6 2   @=R $6  B  $F 
C 6%6 E G+   C1 F  $& %      DS
47
.6    : 3 %
5%  PM  $ = $ 

T%   9  D  0 G 


I%9  &3  D 
- &9    C'*  
/8      N  & 6%  D E

.508   
45

Achmed Abdullah and Compton T.  .  


  
 46

   " 'Richard Francis Burton', Dreamers of Empir ,Pakenham


.57 ,(1929 ,#) " 
! 
 "
.407 406 /2& ,$ %  Arabia Deserta 47

153
   
     ,
      
:%
 & "#$ !


0* "
123 4#1 ,!&
.-/ "- + "
%( )  *
"
,819 7  *
 ,  "

 7 4#
#$ 6  , (5

>3 2 ,72    <&
"- 81

=    !8(* .2 
C8@
#& A 65


B    # ( *7?  4#

, @ 6E  "#$ .+
77 4E3 8F(
"- D9
  D
48
.G 
  7(-

  .+     I7 "- "  85+ A  #




: 
 #5
!& "- 6 "
BJ
 5( /E

%( "-  5
8#
%#K B1 "
3  "
(
%(  3 ""
L3  
8+&
2E
L7 2  "- *F .#
 C85B@
>2

4
( *#& N+ ,
 B  B L 7 M - - ,* 
857  G @ # ( ,*  "-   "
3 #$ ) 8+#7 

4 
 ( ,B72 8( (   C
O2  *#&7 O C8O+E

8  *- "
BJ
  , / #
 3   87+
8&#(-  .-
J
 @
BJ(
I  / ,#$ "- 8 MP 

2O# 8 2
*&  6 O#   ,

"- B  6 O# "
8@7
!&
 J  (
>+&

8F
?
"9
7# 8-  I- "
Q
 C 
25  * -
M 
49
.*O 3 G 
>
#
B "&  *7?

8 


 8(#(# " :/#$ @7  
 4@$ 657# 1

.517
/1  
48

.521 520
 
49

154
    
   " 
 " 
 "
) *  
  *+" :)
#   %&  '( %&  %&$# !#
./
&0&1 + 
$ 2 3$ *
 + ,'# & * ,
 
 %&8&3&9  ;
< 2 45= > ? , 
 6
  7 ,45
,45  '
= < )  " :B    !A
  3 (
 ."
 DEF G*B 32 H *
 ) 2  + ,6  C
 
# < #
:JKB+ IK 5  ."3 I

 LB< )3+ 6+ K ,


# I52  ,' < A


* N M *( < :M *> 
 2 45 ?  45= < 35 # +> 
 =?
   52 
 
O <  >  4
   I
3
50
."45= <

2 < "


# I52 "  ") " "
" 6
 .3 !
. 3" '
1 B I=
  .4KN  E  )$# .PN
I+= I( # I+= 6
P H I 7 *  *# + '" > Q"

  45   


 *
R2 %& .=? I(
P
,  H L T <  U
 51." S( O
 IO
   N
L5  ,    52 4KV   N
1 T5  *  , 33 #
 HO 3#
=  JK3+   2< ,<
I3 HBE 5 ,
 3
.+ E+   
2 W?   ) 52.!
  *  
  5
* <  *E2<  '
+ I< .  " :T < 2 4 * *O
53
."=7 6 ! *P

.  50

.63 
  51

.92 
  52

.99 
  53

155


156
 
           ! "
  
 #
 
 $% &  '( )#% *+% ,
".
 

.
  *-  /+ *


 * 

157
 
       !# $  "
". %& ' ( ( # ) *
.&+ '    ,-  *# , )/ ,(  

158
& #$% " !    
 

 
 
 
  
 
3  4

0 56% ,! .",-.
,% /

0 (& %)  (
'  ) '
,!" :5. , ;   &  
 # %
& 7 ,% 8  4 98 0 : 
54
."...=.   . , ) =.  >/%

,

,% =B
&  
 > ' ,?
% 5 3  5/ 5@  >A %$
:#%  6- I ,J K G# H/ # C
#.  6D
E% 5 C  #/0 5F@ 

#H
5? 
3I 
"/ K 
#L
;/ ,$ 3  % 5%M L !"
55

.
&B 
PI$
30 N  % ,  ,$ ," I K/ N% 

,% 6$ ,/ % 5 %" R %  5% Q% " ! I 7 5 ,% / &  Q
56
",J
30 $  N C
C ,!" :PA ."=C  ,. % S ,, A@
=IJ
T%B N $" :9
8
J C L
BM  6D
TC , K #..
&@ B $


56 %
N U$  9
I
, $ ,5 %
"/ T$ 9 B
,% 

0 @ #J? 
 .%
#?
 @ I% #I$
N
B
30 N $ ,T%B
=
 I /$
57
",
 " 0 #6 6 =% 
@  6D
= 8 5/ . % ."#%.

58
0 ,5/ >' ? "
@ #%
5 
5" #I
% @ #A%
, K
@  % #' @ ;$B &! "  G&$
! @ V #
 6$ , 
 ( 
59
., 6L
50  % "/ # M$  6D
30 " !  B %% 

#7 ,% =8 @ )W%



'
 &J C 
@ 5/ X  ,W$% 

.406 /2
 54

.106 /1
 55

.115 ,
 56

.107 ,
 57

.504
 58

.96 95
 59

159
  
          
 
 )*  +'" -$ ,(   & ' 
% #$ . ! " 
.2 34  4
5$ ,2   0 $ 1    '" ,/
' 2'" 9  8)  -  5   67 5%  "
:  ;<=) $  $ :% "

/2 0 $
A B   @) 
 <% ,
$"   -..."
D 64 /- " C  5%
- ,+4  % 8@
- "  
34   $ ) E'  - "  - .  6$
C   
< JKL  MJ)< $ 0 N@ (H '  (  7 
 4  !
 E /
" /O 5%     5 ,; 
 MJ$ ,B" N 1 $
60
..../

.352
/2  
60

160

   

      

161
 
   

  &' . 


       !" # $ %

162
 
     
( 
 
 
 
 )
.1919 

163
.1945   

 
    

    


    
  
*,  -"* ) :#$%& '$(  
    !  "  
7* 1    ' 6*% 01 *2 3 4 5 & 61."   . ,
:
 '$(

,"   6*   ; '* ..." 7*   %89 ......


 
1 6   3  "   *,  ...5* =& ' 5=>=9=?2 @   &
3 4    ) ..." *2    '"  A 9   ) ...5 4

.372   
61

164
 
   ,       
   
62
.!!

)*+ )-  /01 2 3*  !( # $% & ' 
#" #- & 2 78  #
 
$  /9 .43  56 2 6 
63
 "A " 6 @
$   :<0=8 4;> 6 ( ,   4;' "6'
7 
 /0D 4$ $ C B   , * * #'
.)+8  6

H G * F ) * 7E !( 2 /   /9 6
4'   J' 8 2  :3 G4-  9   I /!
> @
& 2
!'" #  - ! M 2 L   4' ' 4')  @8
64

$ 2 Q-  2 I > .("#'O -
 N 
65
2 M-  
$  / ." F* " ' C 2 @  2 5 $
C R3  >; * 8 3  ' 3  2 F* > /  6&>
/!
  4 56  H ) 3 G/
 3 ! SQ6  D 56 M 6" :8
66
 ."'  /! I3  />  
> #' G  /!
>  
67
."C-  U $"  T E   6 2

4;> 2 3 ' '   8 2 )  


$   8

.379 378   


62

.380   
63

.390   
64

.418   
65

.378   
66

.388   
67

165
    
  
! "   . 
  
01  "  /' +' -" :  ) '
 (& %
 ,#
$
68
$' ;5 9

  8  ."6 
 1  7 5- 42 3
5 6'! ,
 </ 9!  ) "$1 '
 #  #!   
 
!
69
 #+' #!1 7 
 
! 3  1 <5 9! > ."#
 =! " 1
 B/ ' , A!' #!1 1     1'  
 
/
'  ?>@ # 
+   D
    C !  " :8/ ; "-   +
 
# $ G 2  +   ; 
H
 ...8A! %! F "   +E
70
"....
! 8 J  <  ! '' $1 I  


 / 7' $ 1    E ! )  1 ' A'
1 G  M
 1 > ,  $1 IL! '
2  ;'
K (3

 2) #
 ) 
' '   .2 0 '  9! ,

:( - B  
"  E ! '

#
 ( 9' ,OP  2+N #
$ ( (52 
  
4%1 , J # Q) 2/  KP  2 L/   
 ,!
8/ ; 
F   71I#
+   " :%1 S+1>  H' + R

(K/ (5+ ' 
 1 F- S  
 2 R
 S
   ' 1 L' 

.441   
68

.484   
69

.   70

! 

   

       "" .630 ,  
71

/& 012 3 
4" :)
( *& ' +- .

' # !
$
 % 
& 
/*&  *&;- <!  
&6 ... 7&  8# 97&
 &  
5
  6
."&  ,@& ,@ - , ?  , ,&5 , 
,< > ,= ,&6 "

166
72
."
   
     
   

*-  '+  ,*      )( ( '& %!# $
."45( 45  
#
 32# -2" 0 # 12- + % 
 /
> ? 2 ! @' =3< ;   : 7 
( 
67 8 9
:B   A<-(

3(-# F 
 8 ,*6 *-  7 ; #
2  ,3 DE
*
 ...45*+  #  ,  3( 2#  ;#

( ( %>2


  E G
'    > =J 7(  #   ...>2#E H* H6   3I (
73
...K/ (  ( F   >-  G7 #/ >(

=J8 7 :

B  <
*# L' = E*  6<    D 2

 +
3I NF 8 M (' 9 .9< 9<  2
* ;E* 
-#  L " 3 #2" 3
9 ="2 >O6*   3
*"
. >
2#E (P


    R
 / ## 2#E #&# Q8 1
( 9 9
; 37 3#   #  
 IS ;+ >#7 45 3< 1E
>## " #B /" >
/#  '65M5T 8 ; 3< 78   =3< 9 #
74
" 2# 2
8" :W
 7# V7 ( =>#/ U9 3(#   # > ;
: 9 =" R9 >#-
R9  >   3(#" U<8 ## >  3< >#*  
Q2* >
 1' 3  *8 >2 (   ( =3< 3
#  

.94 93   


72

.131 /1   


73

.206   
74

167
75
."

!#       


,
        
76
&$ /0-
()
 
**  +- ' $% &$ ' 
7*$ 6 *
( !#  *# 3
*  45*
." " 2
 
1% + 

/0  4 '        3


* 8* 3#
,   7
 ' 3# &
 #;  < ,
( 9 +'
  #:
 % 1 
.   = >    !;  ? 3
*

A1 ( * 4: $


 * 4:  
 @ *' 1-  
1
 
*
F 9 7* GH' DE ( DE$% 4- =  *:C , $'   B
1-* F 
B  I   DE
   1-* ' 7$

*
 
H 
4%
.'  2*:$ / *   * <
: ,"+*( 3
 = >
#"
, 7H% +'
#  ...&(

 G<J   (B 4- =  "  GH@'
77
1  4- =  
  45*
." *B < * 
 
( + 
.
*  7*$ + (  8* 
 < ,()

 1     , ( *JK L( &$ @  *JK  


!*   

6O 4: 7   4: 


% 1
 4- = 
  
*JN  * *M
 L  DE( ' &$   4- =   1
  1 A4H()   4

."( ' *J

*
  ;
,"* 6 * $ "  :
% < L *B 2#; 1J
A*%B * $ *
 #; &$  *J
*  

'* '
B 

.207   
75

.208   
76

.373   
77

168


 !" #"$ 
 
   
   

 .  )$ ,
  -
%$  
 #+$ "$)
$ * % 
 &'
( 
/  54 " 1
0
 4- / 0 123$ $
%$ 
 
&$   $ ,;# 8 

  :%$ 
9 +  8$ " .$4$ .
6
"0"

%$ 
"
?. 30  ( " >;#   6#
" :5!' 2*. 


   
?  #$0 %.  ,
?  #$0 & B 8$ &30 $ @ A
G (   H$F !; # B $" :*

&$ D @ 1 A   $C 8
)"
6#  ?$" J$ ; #
1$
"  I$ 8# .J$  J$ $
%$ 

78
I5@

L ,; 
;$@ 
9
-
 %'  0$ KG@. . 
6
*
A
79
,; 
$" $ 4 0*
$"!0,
6
"
A M
"-
 N)J$ 

80
$"!0,
"
A *$ $
O 
" ,"))" 80C
" &3. 9
G@$ 1
81
20$ "# "$
Q"$ "" R# %*
$$0S
1.  Q"$  " P$ " 1 0"

" & $ U  . T . . 
"" $ !@ /+  ; $" :5!' $" 0"
!@ "
,(H *
) 9
*
9. T
9 + V"0  ; 
" &  !N .
8
6$ 

/0  V$40$  ,;$ T


$
!#

1. 1!@
+$ # &4$ G$#
82
% " N$  +"
" 6@ &
. "# "!&$" 
R$  $
8
83
."!(&
 ) N . .
&$ YM$T. 6@" &3# "'"

.524
/2  
78

.18
 
79

.99
/1  
80

.101
 
81

.108
 
82

.341
/2  
83

169
         "
    "  
+& * &  ,&&
'"   
!# # $%
&'(  & )
2
#  
 % +-.( & &&
' ( & /'
01   ! "
 & 7 8  *9 /&  #
3  &4 5 &
6
7 < &# ,  ;
 
0 (  & :  & *"  
>   ! & +!  & , =  (
%
 & & $.
?@ ( ' =  ,  
-&   /9  >0  
1
/0 (   1!! 

  > * &  & !
:
 

/ # &  B 8 CD 6  . E  > @ 5  &


  ,(1@.
6! =8 )
I & / GH ! F    ( C/0 /!
   0  & & ) B O  8 C+.( N3 MHL
 8 7 +P @ 7&&# 7
  ( = P % && H 7D $&&  
H
.&   / ! H R  S0& Q0
-&&' @ !(   4 1
>&0  =8
& Q4( 
 '
  /0 =8 ( 1&   +&# Q4 !
, 6! 9 &( ,> & & V  ?& 81 $& B T# 1) *U
  +)&) # Q ( X  & &2 8 9 !7&  ) + T
< 9 .

  /0 .  +
%  # ( .' !( (GH)
* 8  &  #2 *U X1   ! ( ,
&  & 10 R@&
  ? (* -8  /'F  ( $&6  %  &  1 
84
./.&

& <-  Z 6 > 


&!  ! >: ! " : #   + !

.406   
84

170
       ,(  ,  ,
 )   
"   ."( '*  %   &  $ "#  !  )  
97 787
56   3 2 -3 - 4  " -
- /    0  -1 % 
< "  -  "   5
 ; : - ' * : -3 2 " 5#
-@   3  = "   ?! = "- >  -" <= /  = 6
- C  $ ,-3 -  A 2@ B     ."'   "  -
$ "  -; G .
46  /D  * E *  -6F -   $ 2 % 
06  2% '=  @ B  " - -H I
 ,-   5   
85
* " .6  H 3  $ DH   ?  $ - 97  H 
-  =" ,"5 *" -   H 2@ B /  = 6 -   " "  =
86
."  63 
?#H ? !  I -  #

J - 2
K = 7 "   5  "  'L   3 " ! 

* - !  6  =J 7 0B J " ?M"  3 " "  1
  J 5 -> H
@   L@ & * . I;  G 
"      - $; ,0 #   /3   1 J  3 " " 4
I
 
OM%  ! !  H   J3 NA  I
'=  
:6 " *  A M* " P! =J I
5/ 6 ,  

-  3 2; :<= I


!B &  2 7 * ! "     I;
-   3 2 21 R K! 
-   23 -  2  ,
  '3 ! -1 RH - 2H * ! K3 'K $ '3 "  !
"   2 K
" ?@ ?$AJ ! !B 'MH H < S
$ 2 < 6 , (!?  ) &# 5%1   I
 /A ,2J M*

.142 141
 /1
,  85

.124
   86

171
!   :            

87
.&   %   ,# $  " "

/  *  &0 "* ,-   & %"($ $ ) *   " + ' 


-  " :   "  2"     12 3*" "/ & -45 *
- & ,- 9 - & 5 0   ; "* -   8 7     * -4 "
 "82 7 # $  " !    ;  ,<    & -   
-  @ &  & A %"*" "  *  3 * %=7    > " ?"$
DE -  % 7" > C > "& #2  ;  2 "  4 &""  9B
/ ,4"(" / * "% &"  !    , 7 0F - A
 4  * I ,"H 3 &  " 4'  4 7 -4 ' %G"     $ + 2""
88
."  >' 

 7    "/ %  >" ' J 7 3 ! "  " < "
" 3  *=    7LMK*  ! 7 C .& +" 7 !
OI "  - D5 7  B - N  " 4 $  "  4/F 3 !
A +& %G5 7 " >   Q0  I " 7  ! 4N P *
:"A& I" M  % > 7 4N

 ; 2 7 , >" &  %    ) & R0  !  


 >"G T0 !  * >" $ 3 -4" D&  * ,"  S  $
-  @ 2" & ,  & *  " * 7 3& ;4 3 7 >$  S
U <*G 7 %  ' & R/  U N A& %   G" 7  
D P * , 4  $ / "   J  - $ >    UN   &"" , 0

.187
/2  
87

.68
 
88

172
 
  !  " # ,   ... 

  ( !&  +%& '   &  $ ("& )*  %$
89
.-/

5 %&456 ( *  +"' $ " 2 01' 0   &
" 0 <= ,% % $ + 0&;" ('< 5 (&7 89 : ! %'
90
#/ 5 %1  &=  &> ?  5 %&456 &/ +"2& ($'
@! 21     & A ) &< " &/ " +0=' &
'< =B  &/ ?  & %< C= D<   "  + 0<
:% $  %&456 (   / < (;

&=... &<  &/  " & ,%' C&F % C %&456
"    $'! 9 ,$  D< < && #G& )%A &/  > %&456
=9 ; '" %&456  +%= C!& D=H $='  $' " , 
C&=H" '" > )'! -  J5/ $/ <   %I= = ,"&
< ,&   &$ 0
= $  2 %&456 19 1 C&G  ,C 
  K  07 0 0 & #H= $!  $& %&456 +  $='!
91
. 0! (' -'  $'! L 21 

M ( (& L ,=' <  ( 


& (  -&
,8&! C&  $  %&456 & '< " +# &"'=  # >'  (7
   % "& *"" :$ #   $/ D< $' #> 
 ?= #! ! " +O1= $ D< ''  < #! & N
&G #  *

.103 101  /1 , 


89

.222   


90

.272   


91

173
92
& ' ()* + %  !#$  ."...
    

9:, 0, 8 0$6 07  ,, ,  -* /, 0' (12 3+ 4')
6'
7 & .?2 @ ('&> 3& <& =) (&, "7;$ 12 "
.0'' E$ @&& $9 CD$   ,B  4,$ A# 4*

 4,$ 0H '*&:I 3+  0'' 0H; 8  @H;  F* & ' G'
:& ' * . $ / 2  ,$D  -)& $B , ) G$&1$
'')&  ) 421  4 *9 E7  M(  K L+ 07$  0+
$ @#: !#9, /  M'2 0$ O+ 67, 07& 0# ME12 '')& 0$ NI' ? 2
93
."G' !;) " ')

 P$ 0: *; >& )  @&7  & ' 7


0: 67 F* G$ MQ 7#$ *  4 )9 0: ) 421#
> Q$$  D)&$  =) @: & ' ', ' .'; 0 E
I Q 7 /  8 ,P ' ,A#* " :@:  N6$ ,@&7 0$ 3
94
M, 0(&$  4) 8#& ."O)$1 (& I $ **  @, I+ ,#*&$
@#: 6 /  '; 0 ( G&$& & 7) 4* 0: $&  @& E 
 /     " 0$ NI' "$" N# :' + A ($ @7# & '
95
S# 3#: C9I G " '; 0 0, & ' R ,8 3+ ND+ ,"AH&  A 
( G&$& & A $# # 3#: '; 0 6 .T P $ :; M")
:') 7 > 07 & ' '$ 0$ '; 0 @ U $ U:, M*& A97

.274   
92

.277   
93

.561   
94

.591   
95

174
96
 !     ."  
        "
-/0 1 #
, ( )  *%+ &' % %    #$
  0 3$8   *  % ,)  - 7 % ,+2 34  &'$5
.3+ 90 *


-$5 )= 325 !:   3;$ 


* <   3%
97
- .@+5 % % %% >?  >! 9% 3% 1 
3? 3) 3? % D   5  < D ?% C AB% 4%
98
 -%%   +5 F G 3
  HB -$5   ,"E "
-  F$ "G" 35 % %  .58  <  7$5  ;+5
 < 5 E  %   -$5    F I J 4% ,3%+ @0
B
 F  % $ L%  % .  I$ 3% 90 KB2
 9 +%
% $ % $ % M ,"30 3
 9" 
."3 
"  -%

G 34%   +' * 


 ;  -2 N  %
 H? 3%;0    2  -%
 / % <% % >-;
 >-'+
) I    - #%
 3$0$0 $4  O? <  3
B 
9 * 3% 3    1   .5 -   PQ%
 % 9(+ 7  2%  G ,34 R% 32;? 34% *+ 
 
 /  F S A   -%
 % .G -2+G - A0
 0 < 7;5  -=% ,*%G  2+ U" :-% H &'  

.32
/2  
96

     
 ,"  "  Tamar " "           97

.#$   ! 
.539
/1 % & 
98

175
#$% &' (  ! "          
 
99
2 3
 ! 4 1 / 0 , !  !- ." ) ( & * )
$% !6 .   !$ 4
 7  89 (   4  ! 45 ! 6
. = 0= !=> &  &- :
? ::
8  &- 6 ;5 06 ( 
" : =  ! 6 6     &-   !6 ! ! 4@ !5 A  
100
."!0  ( 3 D  ?
 ! E9 ! !( B

 5- #$% ( G )
4
-  
$ 2F , !    #$% )
#D A$ 06 $% ! HB ,8
3 -   3 0 
H   ! ,
3 ;5 , ! 6 ( 0  #$%   (  D@, #$% ;5 A 
66 3 
5 &  3 ( ?9@  ; B A  J1 .3 
5 & 
, !  , L " .

K ' * D  !5  % ?9@ $%
  %- @ : 5  $6 G, ( (
9   5 @ !6 ! (
!  4 5 (   #$% #9  ; !6  .
 ! #9 ; B :
!  ! 6 $B 5 M 9 
 ( M, 4 ? 
5 (
D
@ 3  ,
0O5  %" : " ,% ! 26 2  N "  D " , !
101
#:  ! HB ,  ( & 3  ! @ 4   0' ;5 ."...!?,
" &  P 
5" :   $ !5 ,48
, !  ! 26 0 O
! ! 6
3%  !      06 
5  3  8 O

 Q=
6 Q=
,
102
."0  ;5 0=" M= 
5  3 ;
 % M
 !   #)  

0
 (  &) %- A  @ M"
D1 " !6

% ; B

.26
/2  
99

.27
 
100

.510
 
101

.618
/1  
102

176

   
  
        .
 
'&( )  "
 %&""  !" #  .    

+2 3
,    "  .(- 0&)    ,  -  + *
&4  ( (  5 *  6 72) 3 8 
(  9 &
,   
.', ) 72)  (

  <  6 


(
+   ,50 2& 
, 7: 2& '  
& @ ?&  > <    2, +  , '52, & 
(
6 3% =
'    > 
  B* 7: 2& % 6 0) A( 0) A, 
'5 
 ,<D0 '5   
   C " . , *  
(
50

   F , (8 < '2E6 5  F %( '
*D GB
  
103

= )
0 ,4
 !   2 ." ,  &( 2
H C
 0 7:     "    ,
, 7: <    
:(D  2

J( 
A 2 ,
* 4 72) HC
  0 * H= ! ' 
&( 2 H
  0  K6 ,H= 
 *  , * @K

 B*  ! %( 


,   
  ... 6"  C ... &2 

  (  6
 ) !  ?& ( 9 F
 0 A* 
  !
% L  

104
.)  , * 

! D .2N %( 


25 6 72) O4  L: A  
, 6 0
(
 ',   56 7& 5   ! F P0 Q 6     
  '&(   0 )  ,R* ?   K ,4&=  (D

.71
/2  
103

.76
 
104

177

  
    
 . 
  
*  .  
  ! "# $  %&  '(  )

-/$ )
 " $ "1#  #  " )
-/0 +
$  ,& "

, 2
  "
3  "! 2 4 " +  +
$   .+ 
 
 $ >, /<# )=  .73 8& 9 :
; "
6   " %& )6
$ @ 7 3 7# !  '  73 "
? $ 71   ! ' 
7  ,  +

  "
?
  7 + $ .
A  ,&4
  D , C &4 1?
B .  ,&4 $ 3
? & 9

  )4#
71
 ) ? G "  4  )4#     %
4  "" :)
105
.+ 
  "$ D %& "
0 "  "   H
 # 

+
$ 
     ,&4 $  J B ?  ') # "I 
 )4# )
 3 $   '+  ,&4 ? K3
 L  ? 71  /
NL
 ,&4 ?   " '!  D
  " 7 # M ,
-/ 
.+ 
 ! 
?M 7B$  "I  ? ! !  
 &

 O  L
 ,&4 ?  ) ; )  "$ )
 8# ?
L ,! ,?  +

 ,&4  7  "I $ ND 0  D?  "
 &4

 ) ) 8& L    %&" :


 L   D?  
 PB
106

 
" .  "S  " L
 8 $  # 7 QR/  "  $
&4 
 ? !   
 !
;  M
1#  $ # # "$ 3 D!?
107
) " + %$ ."U 2 
 !! &4 $  ...)
1J " "
O  /  $V ) H / "
#" DR# $ .( 

!  

.107   
105

.81   
106

.110   
107

178
    !        " "  
,
* +- $/  ' () !    &%   # $% 
.
2 
  3 4 # 5 # 
6 /  )/ . 0 !  1 #
108
  : 
# . 
   %7  4 8 ( ( 9  )//
+- B;/ +/ >  ?@  
  A 
  !; <-  ;=
109
" ;  %" 0/
+- +/  <@% +/    * %C .*
+(  F? ""  * 
  
" :+/   * D    

110
."8 : ; 4 *

  1 *  9  #G 0%  +- $/     H  #


'  +?; 9  /    0-  
 ,     ;=
+- #7 : ;G  8 ( +- 8  4 /- +- 
  ,8>  8 ( ( 8 /
111
  ." K A" 0    
-   J F IJ<- .8 A/
  + %  : */#I   +- F <G; 
+/ $#  
112
." </  "   

0   +- .%*    )  ( # H=  L 4  8 ( A/

  6%@/ M@% +/  * ,$/
  4  @% +- :/  ( 
:/
 0  +/     0G/  +( D
   5=* #  0#
!4 = +/? 4    0 N   = * " : * 2 
N 
 K  <G  D4 ; &? +- D / ' : ;G '#    ...

.117   
108

.120   
109

.126   
110

.83   
111

.91   
112

179
113
      
     
 ". 

.)*!+ - %  / ((' "#$ #%&"  ! ,

5% 6 "-4 0 5 "  % 2  3  % 2 0!1% 


 6% =7
 & "/% ;7 < %" 9 ) :  "7 8&"
!4   )3 64 B ,A
 @( ?9 7 =: 6 =
7! 7  )" : 
 % B 6   6 5!  E"5&7%  CD /   %
114
B H 6 < B ?9 ."$ F% 6 /%% 6% $G 5DG " 9

%7   6%


H   .5%  3 8: %% $G   F%
)
 B  9 2    =: * 5%   B 6 I" /4!%   / 1
   J" 7  "D% 0& )7   ?
 A% /
115
/%!C 7
4 ,"7 =:  8:  6   6% 
! = 7
:6  H  ./ I C&  5DG     %C

7   ) / B ?9 EA 
 57 F   6%
B  )I ...
  )  0*    6C ,
 1 / % 7  ) F )  ) %

)
 6 H   ./K
B  L7 / 1 7  AK
 E- 
B AK

116
.@( 
A ) %4
&

 57 6 H B M4 %!  )$7 J – 6%



B
4
=D 6 / & 7  )  )   ,&1% 7  
 
%! 6% 7% ;7 F  .3  = H! / 5% ) 6%

.485   
113

.40   
    114

.68 2     Arabia Deserta 115

.29 28   


     116

180
 
           
 !

,"-."! +"! /0 "!" ,"&'"! "! ( 


'"! ) *+" "# $
6"4 5"! /0 " 12  3!"

: 9  ," 0"! )!/"!"  9 : ) 9 , 0 "! 7 "!  8!/"!
! 3  ! ? @ 0 
A /0  0"! "! 
B :;<=!
!'  !
:
 " CDE "! ."! " 
9 <"!    "0"! : D;'B!
9 $ # 3  0"! "! 2 0 "! 9: -:  !
9 . F
# < 9:  ' "
!
0 <! 
 
" 9 " H ,4;    9 +!
:  9 40
# ! ?  @ 3: .)A 3!
  "! F   

./ 3 3" 9 : 0"!  ,I:   "! B!

181
  
"  
 "
SEVEN PILLARS OF WISDOM
T.E. LAWRENCE    
1963-1888

       "   " 


    
() , + *       !  #
$ %&   '  ()
. 0 () 1 . & #
()  -  ()     - ./  
   () 4 ,    6
 #
45   3 
 
 !
 ,1921    96
 .
 %# : ,7 - ()   
? 6# %#.@    > % 6= < ,1922  ()  ; () * 
7
< . B93 
 6 A ( 3 > %# : .1926  %&
-.!  FG   .
 () E  > #  CD   0  
 , ! (#  - J7  <D I H ()   3 > +- CD

 5 .1 .   E>   E
-3# K> 6
 () ;
 6=
  ;
. L7 - () M  ) L -.      1 
 " O) 6 H=&  N&9 C:  , L?, 
 7
& % ,     ! ?, 
 D   ( " 
.-    : K B- K P.! %=&
Q: !    <  4#Q 7 - () 
 :5 %


182
     
   
        
# ,"   "     !
Storrs' mission $ %& " ' (
234 /01 .- ) ') *  $ +)
9 5(8 / 67 -  & ( 5")+
")+ 234 7 < -&; 4    :3
( $ ')  " : 4 (8 = 8
 # ,@ '%+ +7 - A
+ 
B8 '   /  
) -%#
     1." 8 2 %7  63
"+ 7"
 " % "=0 "  234 
  

7 7 " :/  !% C + 5"" &
  &  F )  G
7 7 ,D ; D E%  %&7 7 ,  "7 97
2
.""   (4 H IJ8) D+ - )   7   %& 63  &H
   7   5"   $ - G *+ - 1 / H (  3
( # # 5"    -% 1 (1% E -1%&  /  C+  ' "
4  
%  ;  )%    3 <  " H B G *  7  / ( %
D ) ," 8  G" L   7 <7 5
% (+  +% "+ K  "  
  -   63  +  4   /  7 ."* 8  G" D $ ,""4$  G"
87 6  
% ,"  "  ) (8) M  8 /G 7 -
%    

"
 
 " Seven Pillars of Wisdom T. E. Lawrence 
. . 1

.68  (1986 . 
)
.23   
 2

183
          
     
!#  $ % &' (  ) ()  *)   &+$ ," :  
 5 (6 3.") 2 %  + !/ 3 ( ', -% ,- ./0  +
. 5 7 33     +
. + , ;  -  8- 9)  &    /  -)
? ;$   <+ -   + '$ 8- 9)  ,- =+ >
% @- -  ( -   + ,  0   $   + +$
D 9' 3%   A5 -   - * ,-  ;B C
  ,+ !5  E%  + ,   8 ,,- -   

( I  J +$ K, + H>;F & G =+  "+ 3  0 !"
% +  3 ,- ?() L5--3 >5 0  * ;F  ,-
."+ 3  0 !" &0 $ *0
,6   % %   !$  "+ 3  0 !"  MJ
-  *; 6 # D .N $ -/ ' .E%  $
7 ! % *0 9,* 8- O 6- , F   + !/* 33
!/ 9, ; 93 ( 5$ '$ # Ronald Storrs#3 -
?, , + !#  $ F 8- !# F   - .0-  
<'5 P M$* Q/  E P  - ?5 ,/N/ '-    M$
Q/   L5- - ,  R$3 8- + -/   #  !/*
  0 3 ;   3 /N/ Q/   ;
8;    .6,3  ,+ * 96     & + 0
SP 8- , M <0 ,#-
 (6 - 8- ) # M
  3 *+   3' -+  <0 D  $3  

.92  68   


3

184
    
 , 
     

 

+$ -
' . / #$
%& ' '(
)*
+) "     !
 +$ 4/
#/
) "  2
3 
%%
0&  
1/)
'$
 ,5  '/ 6/ &* . 73 #//  8/ 9
8$ 3
&  

2/ 8/ 9
2
> +$ '(
#/
!  ") 
: ; <  = /

8$
8$/ 4@  &5$  "'9/ 8$ 
83
 ? )3 - */  


 @   
6 !%

0*) 4
#/
9 "3

"#$
. 5 <C & " 9
#/
  
B "&  % 9 
A

3/) '   # 9


A23 '  6  A9 , < $/ # 3
'D

 9
 ! $9
A*
 ; <  $F
/ #$
 . 3 8
HIJ  , )<
@/3G/ 9/ A9
%& @< , / 9
#9
 -/
.# 9
'
; < 8( 8)< 8  ,8$ +  )*
0*) #$
'$ . 

8K $ L  D  ,5 "'I9
!  ,9
!  ,  (
K*  ) > M)
N 
& &3 ) 8)< ': .7 3 8*<  -/
A23
8 1/) !%

/  
#: ' $ , 3 
: & O 
#$ > & 
 
/<  "PK/ * 9 8
 /G  
>@@<
Secret 6/$  8 @ 8)<$ ) 5 /: 6
3 ' ,8 %
6 
9

% ,8 $9
6$$ ' .5 >$ "8 
>J G " Despatches
 "P/ (
2 ' 4@ !%
3

& ) ' '29 6DR
6  ) .  ' /
89*
6// '$ .  S )*/  
#: '$
D2
6  62 I< ' ! $9

' 5  )3
8<   '$
.= &  8
 /: 83/  S  
3
/ 9

'  /$   8/ 3
) #  8   + 
8D +) @9

185
      
         
'  ) *!+ " 
  $# $% &  $' ( ! "#
,'( & ' -! &.  .  / - .0 1 2
*3  
  ! 2     1.0 / ( 
."4<  . ) %( 9: 3;' 1-.0 8" 1% ! 63 ,) 4  
/ 1 ? 8 2 "# "  -  >%  '   :
.#(   -+(  
   ! @ A# (  
D
E 3: C. .
 1.0 1  "" : B8(   .!
 !  9H <G! 0 9: 2 ! !( 6( ,>  .( !: .$#( F3 !
3+ 9  .  2! 9: 1-!  ( .( "
 I 2  " 
 2
.0 *3  
   & 1 1-!  1-  ! 
 > ! M ,HK )  1L 9  G?  J 
./
:  N' !( 9
,".
>!" - C!    !(  . 9:  9 OE (  
/ .% !( 9 -H ,"/
 <.  3" ,".  & " " .. "
O0 2   1L .     8 ,
 %   
 !: .<
2 9 2% >% 3' ! HK8 9 $.%   $ . 5 
2 P
 . 9 !.  2 / 1 E+  .! ,&   9 CH F(
Q3+ 2  : .
 /  9: .  $K! 1-.
 1-(  1
  63 % 2 ,+R /  Q.K    ( )" $#( &.
2   ! ( ! , ."....T 2 .  9 ,  R S .
.%  ! C '.  63   8 9 BG."  6  K 3+ . < 

.41   
4

.     


         5

186
  !"#
" 
         
  
/ " *+ ,$ !" - $ ) # " !" & ' ($  6."$
 (   :;
<  , :;
34 56 3 76" 89  , ( ,!2  ,!  ,! 0
7
."""   "
  @ 
2"  5  76$+ ?< $ ) # " &= >" +
>B !(  E" *+ *
- D + <# "< A
0  BC @#
 * "< A
0 #( A<   *F4   A
- + ,   0"
, "
( 
( + E - "   A
 0  A<" " !+ "
G#
:!B
!$&0 A< < #
"< !$ & "I $4 !B ,$+ A
" 8 "0 
$" 4
  ! "  " )
C
0 B
(J " ! ( + A  ' < " #
A
0 + !<B !"  <  '< #  ""  ( " "0 )C  ,)(
73M0" ,$+  # E
" ,&<   !
'
C <" L(4 + K"!
  
,#  #   (  # " ,# A < "  *F4 B  A  !< " / >+

 
 ,   # "< ( " ,A
0 ) B"
"5 *  # A
" >BC
>" ,$+ >"C 8."' 
I "  " !9" !<-I  " N <- + *<(
, + @0 ,P" ,A< " " )B A<O+ AC<
"I 8C '   4 
$

."I 2 >" "  

.97 96 "



" Seven Pillars of Wisdom 6

.582   
7

.125   
8

187
.(1 ) 
   

188
.(2 ) 
   
,  , "       
   

*/ # ,!# $ % &  ' () *$ $ + - .(-  , 
'5 * " 
.  3 '    *  2 ,$ 1 $ ,"* 0
: 7$$ ;# $< 9."*
8 9& )) 7$ 8  - +  
 ,6$ 6   

.126 125   


9

189
 !"#  
  
  
     

%1# 20 -/0 %
.!%
 -
 +  ,+
 * & ' () !$  !%
 20 8  )  .4
 -  5$  !  !62 + 7 32
4 0 5
 5< +%%)
 # !; 
 105
 2  :% 0 9  0 4 
 ,$ ; =0  5
 2 %  %2 ( %   ' 1#% 0
-2 !)
  0  >'

  0 !
%
 !2'  ?$%  @ /  $
4
 5$ ! 
 + 
 ) 5$ !C'
 1
  %%
 -%  5
 !
 5< AB<
  $   %  52 !'%
 !%
 1D"
  -2 .9  %"
 $ ! 
 + 
 4 E 5$ !12 821 !  !/  %$ !;2

?    5
 !
 F .! E 0 !
/  
 ,+  @%0  0
 60 1
 I)  J%   1
 +# HC +# "  1
 1)
.!) !# !   /  9
B C"0 %# "11- 

 C2 ) <  $ 6 5
 8#
 L 4
 5$ K2 
% 
 <
 K 5$   $ 0 < 9
B 5$ 4
 .9  
 'M 
+% 
 N 62  C   @ / 2; 
  
 5$ !1%
 E -2
 $  8 )
 A%
 @   $  
!
  5$ !O
?  C2 " % %%< - 
 &% F 5$ .  %" 2;  +%2
@" 
    %
."12
 5$  
  2; 
  
BF  
- ')
 L ? 1
 %    5$ 2
 L ?  = 
5
 %
  ! 
 + /
@"$  =B
 ,)  / ,!

;D"
 +P; -   $ ;" ,9  ? -"C
 -)$ %# .52%


.127   
10

.181   
11

.571   
12

190
            
 
) * ,() &   ,&#  ' " :" "#  "$ ,!
13
".)
 " #    01" -! / ($ -  (  +  &
67 /  # " "5  2  "$ 34    &  
14
0<  "  6  &  "# +#)   ";  * 8!9
& ? 
#! ,#   1 .&  ' "$   =>  
"$ " )
0 A1 6!  (1 B , #  -7@ -   (7#
D$  & B A4" &C!  &  0   . 6  &  -! & 
0  "G7    - "1 B A A &*F  E  ,""0
 A "0  &1 "7H
0 #  & & 6! ,4H '   
8 &0 "= H   (1 & I-=J  #  -! <  " 
15
.6   & KB "# L6 
    
0 A* ;9 7 #  *  M) 0 6
&1" *#  !=   34  -#  L)  60 P NO  & 

1 &    


0 N'! N6 4 ) -  = &  34   1
( P I #   36  (C  & ; 4 &1 / R ."Q  #
A0) & & 
 *2  #$  -#  O)J / C () &
& -=J  #  -!   H1 R A71 ; 6  +1681
& 6 
0  S Q &1 & &6
0 8   )

.683   
13

.332   
14

.572   
15

.241   
16

191
        .         
 
!" #$ %&  !$ '  (  '  ' )*$  +  $
    
' !  3 $  ) ' '   '  / / " , - /   0&1
17
789 0 ' 7 & ,
     1-'    5  ! 4"
: #$ 4:8 1- ( 7
 :!$ / #$ <$  / 7 < '! < '=' +  $
  !
 ! 7 41  %&   (/  - <>? (@' A >  '   B
C 7  ...D   ' :   :> $ ' ?= 4:$*  C
4$*  :C' $'?/ ' 4 
  E1&  9
 - 1    /
 <   ($  4'     $ <     9 ( 8>' , &
18
.     9 ((* 5    <  
*& *) C %5  A !$ :@'  $
  5 
?
:>  * =   $
   / 5  F/  4 ! *  '  >?  
 ?=  ,'C '  < ?' , '! HI$ 4< !   " 1G  >=

K 7 %'   :87  $  !      E / 7 : J / B9 ,"<


!    , ' C!/ , & ' L'?/ :/ B9 , B -' 0 J? 7  $
0&1 :7 ?@  4$  0 G>=9 */  :! = K ' ,E $7 :C$/
.:! ) >? - ( 7 J  L'?/ $ %' !  < 
'   M $ $  < '=   $
  :' +  ) ' 
 9 0"'/   :/ B9 4!   0"'/  / 87 7 4  ' :'/
 $ / '  5'   / ( E 4!  ,  ' / 5'' )*$ 
! 4N$  O  7  * ! !  G7 + ( / 4'   J (C$ 

.102   
17

.   18

192
       
 , 
      

" 
 ) *! &!   ! ! ' % "( ,!!"!" #
 $%
 $ %!
5 4 3
 1
!  + – !
 !+
    -!.  /0 12 
 * 
19
."! ! :
  #+/  -!. " 6 2 '    ! 782 $ %
C( @A  !
B #!   >?  ! <!

=2 ) /0
C( 
 
  "!  2 <
  ( E' *! 7 
 D
<!
 2 H5 <. 
+! 2  C 2 G! 2 C( :
F ) ,@A
5 I @ !!!
 ! 8  * 
 ! + "( 6>?"( >? !
 + !
' >? + &
 7! – 0 
L  :/ – ".
" KJ0 !"!  7)
(
!2 "!  <!
   +!  "!" C( "  M!
 ' "  7"" 
.!'%A (. ! C "!  5 + C( 0 < '  !  &
!E+ +(  
20
.*% C(

N I O  $ ! + "( '"  7%.  ! <!


 <
F )
+ C !  7E!2 C(  7E!
 # ) !
N '    $ % 
2!  :2   7E! I O
!B! + ,!!!
' M'  78H ' !( +P!
+!  75" 7 $) :/ C! 70/  G! $E 1
2
2  G C(
$)  5 7 %
! !'
!
!  5 <! + $ ,&! ) &! 2 &! ) &! !
C %
 3  M( M!O 7'" " :3
 $ "! ,!%
 7!  ." 
$!'" R'  C *
  D
  %
)  ! !
!D
 C( &  !( +
7! 02  !=  $!( 
 "' ) ."7   2
+5 C( $%
 
+ :/ . %  /0
 C( *
!B 3( &
 #
 ! C( *!. 

.101   
19

.75 73   


20

193
21
."  
     !
!# $ %&  
  "
!(&
12 34  0! / % & $ '( )
$ *+ ,-!/& !
$ ,  %9!  5! 5
 ! 6& 7 (8  .2  % 5
?<! 6 '8 < !  >3  = 0 =6 '
 %  !

0
< !;3
%  4 , C 3 '( = ( =B   %& 6 !&
,@*/  3 A  %  &
%& A8 .
>3  5
 !E
2! 56 !6  D *    5 %
22
.%!

%!F %   0& G %  H IJ  %  % J
K
  !# H ,
  =
 6 F  %    504 

%8 ,
0 5! !
L * 6 !
FC %& -&! & '  ,0 3 % K!
 6 A 50!
!E"   !$&  ,J '(
. * ,5 08 % 
23
%   =!L
."% *! % M
;  ( 'C %  
,  =)  % 
% ( *#$ *   < 
M3
< 
 !  %& '  ,6 %( '/ 
. F8 53  &  (6) %    M99   !8 3&
2   0 !
* K "5 5 (&" % !/4 M ;6 P$

'( Q! /"
"%B /" G 6 '( *& % %& 53! ,P!6 )( '8 
 
>3 '( = ( =B    !;3 6 % '( 6  $! ! *8 
."%
 
G   ,! >3  G6 J 
3
 !# K! !& ,  !
>3  B "   !;3 %
 ' %8" :J '(  "5" !3 

."G 5 ! % '(& ! >3  5 ! 3
A & %  ,  !
!! 3& % %
3& % %
  A  

6 %&  
 % K! J
P6 %& !&  .5  F 
 *  F P6 '  5F 5! * 

.334 332   


21

.172   
22

.548   
23

194
 '&( .!" #$ %&          ,

 
24
."**4  54  #$ ( 2* - 3
 1" 0" )* +-
 
& :  – "1
9 " 67  " 8   267 
,>  2*7 =
3 ( 4 "1
9 " .<3  
- );   154
5  +* AB;C A*  ,- A- 5 @ " :8 +

7    #
."  79" D    >* 2* .""3*  1& =
&3 + + 2#9$ - ,1  +* ,C C7*" +"4 2*
25
&" 'B;- )* &  ."E  
 %
 = ,2 
- &3 +

*6 F1 1& &      ;& =( > 1
9 B7  * 3
26
."... 2  "B &  #7
*   
 4 *  ."GH: GH3 GH" 1  A+  6 *
"
%J ,6(    
3  & +  I  1 +   5
+ ( 6(  - .
J  3   5 $  *D 3  6(
J GHK" 5 +*  ."+4 * ( +4 "4 +
&   + "  +*" 1 

& "337 =C +- & "*  "0 5* +
 &( ,"" 

27
." +  
>L ,+4 E"* - 'B3 '67" 6( = + 6  ( 1  -
& +*O !69 - 1 N( ,  1D * $ 6(  #0 ."M )
@ ,+4 ( >7O  GH: ,"C )(" H 6( 0 4 &( ."
 ( :
1  ( +J 2* - .   4  Q P + 

.595   
24

.228   
25

.179   
26

.   27

195

      "   "  
 
    
28
.
     

,   )  *+ (
% &' #  $  !

3  ' 12 3 ./ 0
/ 
,  - + *
$5  +
  1 )" :893  5
 7 453 6   
 19 $  + @  ." >
$
?5 = 1 ) ,/ ;%
DD #E 3 C)9  + ' 8   C   #

B- ) !  A6 1 7
 '  A  A6 C2* $  ; ? $ 
8 ?
 *  3 C 
2
%9
3 1
 3 . 3 F %D A 
 / ; /  % )
A6 CI 
 ? 6     +
G  $ % ) 1) H 3
 %  ) 9* 6  9   H J%) $ #
  )  
.- DD
 #  (' C? @ 1 '
8  8) +H D  6
M  L D  . ? $ 8H  $ K
 C *= F3  ) $ !
 N 'H -  )   A6 C  ' F 
 F   H! $ 
  @
:5 ) 'H  ;' K2  .1*+
+  ...-   -  ) CJ% #%
+ ('
% 4
 *  H6 8H  1HO 1) A K9 )%   : ) $  

 $ * ,  $  P #2@ '6 . 5 1   %  


Q > 
 1!% 'H $ :G%  P    R A Q? A 
29
.  M #  ,(

T 
  6 *+   # %  
S * 15@ )

.  28

.230 
  29

196
! " ,  ,
       

  

 2
.% %  -. / 0 )( *& + 
  ( '#  #$ ! % &
46 
'!" $ 3 0 # ! # 02&0 # 4 5  % #"
:% -6 $ &4&7 $6
4 ,< 0= < <
>2? 8 09 '# 02&0 # 4  2 ;  
4  # $6    &0 4 %& $
'! >2? @&   5 -6

 ...80"0  & ="  B4 ( = ,# 02&0 5  5A
E-  B4 ( #0$ 90 
 ,9 0 0 %  %C4 5 2& D$
80 :< & 0 ? B&2 % 7 0 %
  # -6  2  #7 -0 5 
8 09 %2 , &  ! ' 0 'G  ,7!? #!" 
 '80 <
,F= 4
30
.H 4 H92 +< " 4  F % 2 2
'#2 I0 7 0  $ @&0 4 
   ; 
<92  #0 4 - @& 4 4 ' &  # '#0? '#!" '8
L0 + 0 % & #" $0 0 % . 2& 0J < & 7  % K
# $ % &
 H " M
  #2 
$
04  # $ 5 -6 D$
.+< %9 52 7- % 2M0 40  2( 
 $6 @= .#0J0 #
 I
0 '# $ 5 -6& %   $      B&- (

  6 9 P!Q 7O  I& " " N  $    4K0
4 #2 /F= 
# 0   @F 89  S"#$" #042 0" 4 # 2

'%0J 2 & '% & %"7  + 4 0 #&20 /F= 
 .@? 80
$ " '# 4 #0 < 0 2 9 0  TF "20" $6 
 2
4 #
$0  .#97 # 4 #A& 9 0 #0 # I # $ +<A  &- 
%! ,% ! %0<7 04 46 =K0 /2 = % ,% 4&0 %  C 

.  30

197
31
#  !    ."          

, , - %
 #/   0()
 ()*+& & +&
$ %&
' #&
32
, $ 8
  4()
67$ 2  $  % #&3 5
 41 2
23
 &   9
$ #
% :2 *   :-  ; $ 
/ /3
"
5  $" 
/& :
 /3 9& - (
+
/ >$ ) ;  <*+
 <; @ +
 ."&  27" 9$  - "  

7 5"
%C
 (;
$ #& )   

+
/ 
2A 
 B 
; *
.
+
/   D2 % 

;&
  <5  EC /3 2 2/ $ >
@ 
:
 $ 4:
 I,/ / 
2 
H  >2/ 8
 9/ 47F :
 G-  >
% :2
 
, ,E  .
J2/ :
  2 /
 
 & 2 <5
967 >2/ 9
 .< / K  #-& <  :  #3 % 9B  >2/ :

-7
 4"M
* <7 ,& 3   ,<; @ 3 ,D
 <" %  

 E
>2/ .
5 
 9J    *
 
 / $ 
2 
:P  /  $ O*   % - 4
3 :+
 N+ G7 &
/+ 8

 O$ 4 < :&
/+ % #57 $ 4>3/ 2 >$ , 

,3// @
 >2/ 2 P .>2
$ 2 P  >2/ #
, . 2$  
- 4- , / $ &/ () & @
 0
67$ ' 4
& ' 4
2 (J
3 @

5  42
/ 5
' 4-/ J 
  :&
/+ 2$ R
 @

S-, E :F 
,  &
/+ 4,25  9& 9  49  J P 4
E&/
33
.


.45   
31

.56   
32

.39   
33

198

    

      
 
, 
 ( *) +
 "% (  .# $%  &' (  )  $ ! " 
06     . 234 5 23
( 23
'" 0 $1&(  +- !' /)
7 % !8 15 
  
/41 ( 9    : ;  
:-  $ ,> /&1 , !% " -
" 0   + .<1  ' 9

*  7F E"C D / $% 23  @A' "  B ) "
/5 ") 4
  ) " I"- ,: H
: B':
( , : : A6
4 $% F " /)6 , J> F !' ,  4 7F  6 .'" 7 
" /) . 5  8 $ AD  ( !% " /) F" "1   6 .K'
J> " $ " 1"  I
,1) (  " E/
 ( +' ,  %
34
.! /

/L $) % ) ,: " A 7 /8" <& L I  ( J %
 ,! A6 , " M
 "6 N% > .!% " 11 /- " $% +"

Q4 0 P 5 /)F


  )O 6 .+
 ( 8O J(   !  )"
7F 11 )1  " 
 ' " 
4!R " 4" 1 $% )"
F (
" (   B .B5( ' " "   : ' "  
. !% 
C 8' " ,
% P! K'
( "  ! 7" > 3   (  ,> 9"
0 I4  4 S
4( !  - F " "" " 06  
*) ' .
( 0 T 
) 8O >

  3 - )  - )
, #'" M ( )% ( *)   ' I " $"  " >5 7 (
 M  "1" 14 ) .
 B -  )%  ) ""
*4 J>
I  
 
 
 ) M O
 !A 06 /"  )   ( S& 


.36   
34

199
: 
   
       !" #$ # % &      ...
-  ,* #   +   ,
 ' ( '  ) #& *  

 
 %  / 0$ +    1 )   ...
 
35
.
 +  #$
!+ 70& / # * 2 & 34 
 5  06 + 1 
7" 4 )4  ;6   4 !+ < 1  ."#$ 9 #  -"
>4" 
5 ,1 4  # & ; 6 !
5
 ' = ,   7" +  4
?Allah "/" *0 ."@# /  '    6 70& #2 
5 ?"5  ! 
* # + A 0 B(+ (+" ?)   2 A# ?God *0  74
.@  #+
 !   * 2  – "C%
E ?  4 #& /  >4   F  
  1+ < D 
!  " & IJH + ,"   & !  & ' 5(" " !   G-    ! +  
:< '% L 4   .* #  AK $" L %  * 
#% !L H ## ' $  !  ,  ( IJ(#  IJ %  )4  #%
...!  756 )6 7" *  !   A ?*%5  D< 4F  #$ ! $ ! 04
J * 04 * 2 0 AN5 !  ?# 0$    A  7" @ A #%
36
.*   &  / * # & J    

'+   ""   ?"# 0$    A "  & #  !+ < 1 
  F  *$# @ A  #% ?* # 'E *4  + ."-  4 + 
? ."   0% +   4 7  *
4
#"  3 ?* 4 ?* "
* 0% ) !%  + B0  # !+ 70& )    -4F < 
N+ #%

.39   
35

.40 39   


36

200
!  " #    
  
 
 . 
 


()* ! !) ' +
 , -
!# + 
/  .$ %
& '

.0
$ .5
! 0 - 0   1 2 ( ) 0  ! 1 2
!&...
 ;  0 :)
8 0  9 # $ 6   0
# 67
 0 
! !? C   ,0  =) '
>% ! ?@? $  A  <  9
=) '
! 

& $  8
6  9
$,  < 9  ' 
& (
 C'# 8) ?@?

.  # # 8E ! F@ ,  
   @
    D $-


& 2 H# I& 6  9 
 
CG 8  + 
!# 0 
! K*   9
 
>% ! K  .-
!    ")"
 9
 '

& "C
E"  $#  6
,
  9
 '

$-

& 8
! 
% C 9 E .$@ 
M 
& L87#  
37
.  # # 8 >'    
 ,  @
 ,   D
 !# I& N 0 ,! )  +# !  H#  0@9D 
& 2 + 
!G

  9
 
H7 8 + 
   .! 9

 9G  

! H     ),  ,H2@   ,
H   ), 
  
  
 ,
8 + 
  ,O*#  ! $ 
+ 
 ,Beckford 7 
Vathek  8 C
   . -
1'
F7 9" + 
  P# 8
 6 
 ,
8 *9

    #
8G 9
!# + 
  .
   '
$
! 
)9 6"I9
38
87 < E'
$ 
>% 8   ! ! 9
C,   
9

6"Q 0
 0" ! 0 1 E# FI ;' K > 
8I C7

.37   
37

.     38

201
       "   ." 

"  
) * +  -  /0   .  %&'  (  ,  !# $
3 4 * !5     6 '  7 .'1  2/
:%  89 : / ! 

BA  A /@ >?< !<   3 4 %# = (   ...
 B # . / C   3 D ?    ? !#   # / %A
- C B$ 57F  * /5 : ,   ECA  %# ! 9
5 B G  %# ' / F *5( = B   :  G# >? A /
! %# /& 2  !7   DC B AC &  %/ :  HC 
39
. K %# H A J&' IA  IA 
3 *4 : %# B /    ' B / 
 ECA  A
% ! H N -" % 6   ,( C 6C ) '/  
N :/ %# !/&@ < ,/  %# AC(   B J  ! / 
40
."%/& !  !/ %# 6/ 5   
:  ."%5 6   7" B: 5  B O#  : :
. J? J $ / P + DC BG %# DC 6 : " !4 !
:  < HC 
)5 G :    6 5( $ *4 57 ECA  
C4 .J !     5 EC!   .D/ G  %# A 7 
: B  
5( B$  C'F *4 ! A  A ,! <
41
.OP

.28 "

" Seven Pillars of Wisdom 39

. 
 40

.28   
41

202
  
  
   
"    


34 2-
.% & ' ( )* & +, 
- ./ 

0
"!#$
 7 5 6$#*  3 
 
2 2 % 2
2
  
42
."2  (@
 0, A)  
  > <=89 :;"
)%
D #7  E%+  % %7  @
 0,   
C

* $8% <= 0 <=%I


 J  2- 9$  
 FGH2 &
..
9 2* 
%-
0,  $# N
I
  H
M=L   
  K 
.8
 &#
. 2 <=*
  '    P ,F0'
FQ & F
  )* @
I
  

# 2 
2  2 &%  9  % 2 F 56  
* >2 %
!
Q 5  C
5 !
Q 22%# 
D 0  8
,
.9 %#
9 K @ & ! * ! A 2* !
Q A 5A R;A >2M

4
52'  &#
&* & !9+ F
9 .PS5 2*
. Q% 
.5
Q C2
>0,   F &
.T .& / & $# 5#8#9   ..9 5
Q 5
  9$ >2M

4  ,  -  
/
 ,.9 5%# &# 9+  *
D 0
# & $  3U  
2   9 I-  - 2* 9
43
2 
9 2* &" :&   
 >2M

4 0
, ,
. #
Q 3 )9
,#
Q  /7 8% 
S S  E K E2' 2* C# E%  


# & :P
U 2 9$ >2M

4 #* ."<=% I
5 ; )2 2' 0
5 % 
 G=4 * F#" 5  
5$
&# 5
Q# 
Q W
  
2 2
."F,Q  
9U 22 3$I$ 5
A  Q7 

 $ *#$   $  * FU F !9" ,2 - 
2
F

.  42

.285 
  43

203
44
."


!         " 


  "  

 #$ ( *   +,  %& .( % ' )   #$ %& $'
   -    / 01 &  2 # ( * 3 4   5 ) 
 
  7 6 
 
$ 8 9 :&  -& .+6
* %& <  =1 > 0;* %& 4 8   .   :5  /
     3 :-;   :   -& , 0 
& :5
? 
(   A/ '=   #$ 3   * 
 '! 3 4  0 - .:
  ,  " .B 
 ,  %&    ,Takuri >  %
' 
 ."
F6? F ? :   ,DE: $  , 
?   C  :
0 
 :?   % 0 ? I* 3 : 7 0G
H   ,? 0 :
.: J  $ # ):
= 0#    * .
> %& $ -& )   #$ %&    K? K 4  $ *
%&  5 -& ,  .  I
:
'  $ * 5 ,6, L =1
.: M? N$
.6:
 :  F5J  '3 ,+   - >/ 0 
*  7  
 :  7 . 1? :-   5     O 3   -& 
 /:
?
 :RES$ 0$  :
=P :
  > Q& ) -   
=1 + $ ( *     %6
J   T Q& ,A/    6 .  -
  ( * '! 01   : %& +;  F:  ) - =1 
45
. U *       +  :  4  $ -& .: 

!   


             44

.'
&$!$ '( % $  $    "  #$ $
.90) *# $ 45

204
 
    
       
 ! $  !   
   !
 #  
"   
$% &
 $  !' (   
$  )*  +  , - ." 
:( 0 )1  1$ .# /$  !
 9;2 3 # &
 4$ 56  $    7$ 8
...
 ' )  !( 2  $ > =  
( .6  
<
 5 1 2   ! -3  + +  ,(0 )*  ( '= 

+ 
 43 BC &  ,  )1  &C 0   & + B  !=$
5 $   $= 
( . 2 )1   < 6  1  &  
!
)1 
 2  42  0 
 ,   2 D ) (  $ 
- 5   )1 8
!# + 1  !'  !#E #3 E $ 
< ! $F  #  
  < 2 B ,   . 2 ($ #
46
.       !   $=
5 #   !1 6
  !  4 # , $  ( $
  %*  #    !     (    G )1 H#
56   (1 1
 J    $    2  I (  B* ,5
 
1(  4$   ($ . !   8 1$  
2  $
, 1( 4$ 81$   $  K= , ,+   ( !%
  0%  $  ( 
 %
)1 &# 6

,! !% 
8
 5 + M, 8   . * !(6   &$ 2 L 
 !   2  $ B H7  ! H   7 L )1   G

= M   *  1$ 
* N#  # >= 8 # 2 -  $ (2 
5  
= 56   # )1  1$ .>, < (# 1  >#B

. 
46

205
: 
    
( .        ! " #$! % ! &' (
$ ,, - /  -  #( +$ (,' .( ) * #( (* +$
49,3 $    ,12 ((3 45 67 / 8,* $  /  
$ 1  , ; $ * 1 1(  $ < 1 =' >% ? ) # ' .1
47
@1, , #
9 <  ,3 #( 3 $  .;7 3  1,*
* >
C " A3 $3 4! ) 3 1') $ ('   
) >1 
    3 > 
% !/ E,7 1'  ."1 ' D

19 $" :G ( -  8,* E  H,
 .  F * G 7  ( 
3 8,*/ # $ $ ,I (  !
#( ' #  * (
> 4 + $ 1  .,   J 
 ,3  ( ' # (
H9 ( 1* * 
 ;  >% /     K  >?   
48
 #7  E  ,- /   L,, ,( $ ( . 1) $
%95   3 
    #$ (* ( .1 5   
#$ 
H(3 *  
 $" M73 ' 1  #  1 
D7
;J $  #( #7  E  $ ."1  $ H(3 ' F

$ 3 N7 
 83 ,   1 ' 1 G < $ 3 8  
+$ 3" = 1( E , 3 ) +)  . 
  35 1 >

49
./ H !, 7 < M$  ' "3  ... 7 

.103   
47

.   48

 

     !" #$   $  .563   
49

,56 !4 ,$


2$ 3
-& 01&  " :,$ - / +" !& '() * " $
$1! 0;$ <1 7 
$ 3$1! 01&) !$8 8 3
  9  3&!8 ;
3> . 
$   0 =1 ,$1  3"1 016 !
! $
9 9 0> = 



206
    . 

      

) *+ -( %&  '#( ' ,


 
 !"  #
$
!
5 0& $ 78#
.#/ 01# '2 ! 34 0
5 6
>
 - -; ' ! ?; < ="  )%% (95 ! 0(
 !  3
50
6/ 
 C B+ '#( !  -( ."%@ -(  9 A
51
'#( F5 7 E   B  ."A9 $ D -( ! 1 A5 B+" 
:   4  9 '5 -(
 A( ! - : 9 -( ! B +A -%& H1 !=
.   A%1  3 I - ; A9  !+ ! %( .'  H1

 J3 K1 J3 
 $
; !@ ' B+ -(6 A6
3%

M; 8   % L 9 8  8
( . 9 6
 $ 
52
.  8 

 .% KN 8 + L A '6 A6 L  45 0 




 
#   ! P B+ I- 
 O(2 .4  O2 
- ,$ Q &
 C 5% K A E  P I$ % - 
:!
 !% 8 #  % C '31 A( .% 0%1 !3 7 B+
O8 0 5 0 * 
 !  I 8  'A% +A E8 !
 ..."
0 5
 
5 3  6 '2 !; )03 9% !  ! , 5A

  ! "#  


        
'(  )*+    & , !# $      !% $ &
.& !-    ./ ", 0*1% 0 ( ' +#  2
 ) "& $5+ " Arabia Deserta  C.M. Doughty "# .0( ." 50

.27 8 (1936
.5638 91   ،1968 "&  $ %" Seven Pillars of Wisdom 51

.3448 91   52

207
53
 "     " .      
 
 
  ."$  %  
 $ & ' " #"     !  

:  $01 2 + ,   +,, 3/ -( )*   +,
 
8,  , ;    ,$0, 8 *0 : 47 451  6
=05,  
*5  $<  .    00, 8, 8 < 81 =0,
 @ , !   )*!  =0 > $% '<  ?* ; ?=
54
.?** ? 
6D  E,  A
 2   B7 >, C

    8, 87   0 81 ?% F    G
) 7 0  7 .H ,&   65< 
, 6, 
$!  5& 81
.   *  5   6'2 6
5 $,0 1* *  I 3'
 @ J- 
,
 $!* 81 85' 5 7 $   +@ $0
.% K L@ 6 M  H ,& 3 
* L 6  67C  *    A*
N1 #H  3
2  6 C  *01 ,=M L 4* 4
5, 
5 L # 4* J-*,
 B  F , P! )  ;=  O
81 $,0 = "@ A
#5
* .) > 6 6 *  #H  $&   ."4  ,5  ? %
QO *  . 4* %    ,QO  4 4** 6 
=
;1 $  81 ) =,5    ,6 ?* $!   =,5"
$ ,6 &  * 6 *& ?<
67 = 5 K 
  81 !
;< 81 * 800
**  6  ."O $% $, ;5, =,5 
7R , ,* H, , ' G*
@  1 #J-5,  5
5  ,  O, $ *,  . 6& >   *!

.78   
53

.110   
54

208
 
  . 
          ,
.)  *( +- 
   ! "#$ % &  ' (  
.43 0 &-    /(   +0(* 1 )   2* 3 
.)   5( 6    &- )
 70 "
8 9 
.&6( &-  ;  <  0(* 
/ /2  :
  *
>? 223 &2  &-9 ,&0< ;  
&- 9 &
- &-9 =

8 -( 92 # 


 

  , 
? ,* - , 
(
   #  * A#B  @ ( ... @ (
  # 
?9
-  (
 @ : 
2  3 $ C(( &  ? =  +
?9
,5 3     7 7
?  +&-D ;  6  &- (
,&-?(

) 
 ) 5  /2? ,EF
 EF6 EF(
 EF +'(
@ (

55
.7
 --  
 ( ((
 (
  +
9  (?(" ."( *%  ,&6  ,
 J
" >  & 
9   EF
9    L ."K  B    ,)  &
<
 
 - )A  &- ? ,(
 AM<     #=
  &-D  9 &- 2* 9(
  %D% ( +(
 >
8
@  ( N  7
% &- " 3 & .EF
 7
 @%# ! 
(
?9) 3" ?B
 9( # ,&6  (   # &- .>

9 F @2P Q  % F 
 O 0 &- O2 & 
56
.9
-   &-((
(? (
9 * @ R
5( 5? :
 "
9 +$ 5= 
 
#= ,!
  @ 59 * # 
3S  P T9(  &M
 .7(
= 
 C

.106   
55

.110 104   


56

209
          
    

+- /  .#$ !  !% #& ' ( )*  +" ,!"
51916 34  ! Sykes-Picot Treaty " 20"" #$  0 
;)< : .! !9 0 ,   $  ""6 $ 
78
!9 "  
  5"     <- 3  !" #$
5!-*A ;)< 0  3@4 - .=6 >
 $% ? !" * #"@
7@4 ! # C< 8 7 "  )$ 6 ,* ! 7@4  B@ 3  
  % $ ."6 E/  " *2>&@? D  E  ,*
:! ;)$ ;? @   +
.=6 E 4  78 G@ #H ;)$ 4 G/ G 
)< .G""H < B  =@  
!-   E/  0  
* =) 5% G-  ID    ;"  5   @

!" ! !
>  3 .!  !% 4 -

5"  "
-  3<J  ,"20"" #$ 
;4 $ G& 4 !-
5M

B"
G   ,:*L G"  6 5 .% G- !? #& K

7@4 % ? @  4   +" 5%     !%  

,3<  78 ? "N G


- G  5!@ '" O/" G  
 .E
3<D #-  .C? 4 ;)$  ?
 3<%  3<46 
3
 3< G
 )< .E/ %    "  @" $ G  !

7@4 3$  3<@?  A )$ .$)% $4 3&@ @? 
? /
O G  ,O" ; %  O 

 :A ,B   :?
  .3<% 7@4 #  53<@4  5 =/



3 .#
!% ;)$  &% P  $ )$ 5# A8  ? A
5!   5%

210
57
.
!#      "" 
  

  
$  % &  $' $( ) 
 * +   $ ,-
   &
 01  !+ 2 
 3
 4-$ *5 + . + 
/
9*
 + :$ : $  $  ;<
 $"   6
 7 8
58
% &$/ =$   $  =  >& # # ! $+ ."&
0/ =$@    ,$- 8 2  $ =$   ) . 
.; */&$ 5 $ , !$A AB 0/ 5 , 2$  '$  
 

 C &
"  $* $5" 3
 $ 8B 5 +

&" : G* . !
 01 D8B  B  E!/ EB  F B

&82 $  3  0/  ,:5  + J 2 /+ =/1 I$
,  5 $ B K$ B $   0/ $  '( $ ; D5
   :  ,)! B 3 )
* N 
0/ $/ 8L M
2$
59
)
* N 
 9/
$ F3  $ =5    6 ) ." =$ &
  
/ + K=5 OP
 ) 
/1 $8 +   
 ,)! B 3
2   ,/( *" :J$ D*1 +  + ":   /A" : $
  M ,  S :   =$@ 8  ,F Q * ; R 8  J
60
."...+    
 S :  3<
2   5 %- " F*&" 
 3
   5 )Q
$ 5 S1 3 0/ $* + -$ Q =   S5 0/ 7*

.283   
57

.337   
58

.439   
59

.544   
60

211



     
"
 
 "  
$ $ !)  *) 
( ,1927  $ % 
&
' ( $ .!#  !# 
:+-/   01

6 !/  (
&# !#4$5 +) 2  
$    3

.8)#81 8) ,33


 # &# !) 9;3 3  3
.#7
$ )8
&
' !$
:?   <4$ %
6  :(
 <4$ =#1)> 5  2 <
  3

!
 $ ! )
  1  A $ ... %  2  !)  @ 33 
3)
06    )   3$ B#  @  ' 8) B#) C 3) D

B##

<8
* 2  E

 <C !#C -@ #
  C

 (
1  ... F2  ,F   !# 5   ( G$ ,

 . 1
(
 
%
06 <C
+I1 J) I )# (1 ...H

61
.6 

<%$ 3#$   2  L I (
 *) 
E G$ ?
 K
#4$@ !  ' M    
  4 <%  @ &
' 7)
$ F4
"F4) " 8) *
&# +)   !) 03   0=   
 .(
&#
  8 1 
?#  FC H# I (
 !  I' "F/ 6"
 <   !)5 F)   <  !)' .Kinglake ?#1) # ) 

.+- I 8 7 I   
!)
 ,
!4 8)5 
43

 N  ' $ 
43
5% 4)
*) 
E  E  3

! 1 !
O 
E $ 33
!% E  ?I  
With (  5
"(
*) 
" 8%
#
&# ! ) %
B)

The Dichotomy of Self in T. Thomas J. O'Donnell   . 


61

  . .     " E. Lawrence's Seven Pillars of Wisdom
.101+, (1970   !# (& !')."!#$% !&' 
"

212
    " 
 " Lawrence in Arabia
!'
  ! #$ !%&     
 .Lowell Thomas
01 2 3!4 5 !6 3 7! .,- / 
 + ( )*
=> ;<6!- : & 
9
!4  "+& + !89" 

.=:&?  78 @A #%
+ +( 78 C ! B  8 7 !  7 7 7
+" 79 09  "+-A$
=- " D- 7  79 09  3 $
79 ! !!  +  #EA     ! F  "+E ? 
 9 !  !6 #% 78 +  +(8 FE 7  2  G & !6 3 $
+-A$ ,( I J + 7 +9 H 2 H   &  7
3 $ $ 79 $H
* + B +K -9 -  + 
+  7 +   $ )*  +E 2
 I8 + 

-
 >/? 8  >:8 )E8  F8 =>
!8 J7&
:F/: L  L!* & > = 7 
  
=E
6:AH ( N
F !85 +!   L 7
 9 =!8  L  @A
& E )* L! 3 ! >

B
 O& ( )E8 +-A !6 !* 0& 2
$ 7% =E ...
B =>
62
. +/ +E / !8- 5 + !
Arab  
       

, !  "#
$
  %&   "     1971   Bulletin
+ -  )   *!  )  '   !( )   
:  ' 

T.E. Lawrence: Seven Pillars  Stephen Ely Tabachnick  


 62

.78 (1981   ) "     : 


" of Wisdom

213
  !   

   ,     
 "
  0 */ . ) ) '  +  - *$%# &!' !( )#  #
. 567  , .    * ! 2 3 0 4 .  1!  
> ? ' * =; <   8  3 : -  ,9)  8!
4 ! *5  )#  0  >   ,5 >  3  ,. &#
...( ? 8 ! &!' . - 0)   )@+ >#   A -   #
'( * 36 =; . -   =! 0  96E  1  !
'8 ,0?! 9-; FE  0E : ( :  # ,&!' 4  ?
63
.8!   ?  0'  < #
: 3 A#-   !( . G  4 6
: ! 6! 4 @6 I  1#
J6!   : ,56 :! G ( :  ! : 
(i)
..! # 8 # 4!
:   ,J ! 4 3!
 ( 4 #  : : 
(ii)
.4 ! #  LM -; J! K5#
N!    6  : :A! 0+! :    (iii)
.4!%  .#   6!  % 0?  ,  ! 4#!
 . 0? 4 P 0! O? 9 9 : :   (iv)
>'8   : * ! 0!   Q 5 ! J6! N!Q )7
 ,!  5?  R  ,4## ?E 06! =  !( 5!
=%#- 48 5! )! : ...)( !( +%! # , !(
64
.! )! 0# 9  ....  ,<6  

.(
   )    Arab Bulletin 63

.79 78       64

214
   
   Simpson
 Nightly  
 ," #
 $  %$&  "   !    
,. ' /  (% )   &  *# +%
 -    ' (% ) 
0& 1 (  ) 2
3   % ( % &
  '
.( #  4% 
%  9 /
'  (% #7 # 8 !   6
('  :< ; 3 + %  :4 ;4 (%   :4
 2 +9 %
 = 9 '  "
% %  ;2 " Twenty Seven Articles  
)!    !  ?) #  (' @9# +> . #
   
 +' :   
'  >   
 0A  +6 . (% #%
 % ' ; E " :  ?& C 3 .   3  '  B
1 :'#  % ' I@ #
'    H  3  FG7 ;'
65
."..../  '
  *# +=J ;3
 < %#  & #  6

 M 2 K   L@  @ $3  


'   + % A 
  % L@  @ %  C3  @ + 
> N% #    
4 9
 "L  O"
 /& "%   ' : " # C' %
  % :Q
' K"    # +%     ' +CP 
" &  6 ' N#   7 : 3 2   )
 Q M= R% ;'
C3    A$ %    & 
  + 
"9'
1 G   E  ' G  % :Q# S$=  Q   %    
Q   # +  1# 
 7 @ .3 ; N >  & ;
  +I  T ..L 8=   % 1# 
I    1# 

.102  
 65

215
66
. 
 


 
                 ! " # 66

&$!$  *+  " ," -  , # %& '   ($ $   )  %!$
7"#  )4 84 %1925 7" &$ #  )10,  ,  #2  34    5 6 %. /0  
%)  *   # ) 7# :$  &$  9 4  )$ :$0, !$ 
<6 $= >4 &,     + )4 # )$ :$0  ) ;,+  7$ )4 )$  ) ) 
%Heart-Beguiling Araby %Kathryn Tidrick 5$#$ )$' :@! .2$ 9!
.184E %(1981 %C#$ )

216
  
 "   

 
"    " 
  
HEART OF ARABIA & ARABIA OF THE WAHIHABIS
ST. J B PHILBY 

1960-1885


      


        
 
 %&'     ()  "  * $ ! "#   
 () /, 0 
* ! +  ! "#  . 
# :+, -'  
      .
- 2, 1
3   2 :  1 $%&'   
9 2 ;  .5'6 .%     * 7  ! "# " 4
5   1
> .? .@%  A 1  4 > 5'=  < 
  .
 . 
    @B 0 % 5'6  %  BC& , 
D
5'6   E# -#   2 .  

5'6 ; . # 5C
 . %  )  . ! "# '   . % F 1, #
@ .   & 151  ! + 5'6 <!  ., + ,1917    ! "#
 %&'     ()  !  ! .
  HC + -3 . 

The Heart of 2 . ,       H' B@ 2  .0% 2


"# " Arabia of the Wahhabis (1922) " ! "# E%" Arabia

51 
-. 
     
  L $ ! (1928) " 2

217
    
  
       
 &'   "#$ %  1.!
()* % +  , #--/ #' 
 6# #'  # 3) 343 012
 012   712 6
#' , % ( #* 6 712 6#
 012 ()*
 , ,- 
.:-/ # #*+ 
712#  &#* , 
  ;+  # #  
 2 ? #
 #< #= 7 0# 3, . '#
$ 4  # ?A # % /- / > ?#@ & #  '
>, B  2, B @ 3-    1C2 6#  ? # D- ,?# #-=
 % ?/- " :B4C#  @ &  , . @ E #$ ?#
$< * ()* <#    2 300 % 1 # :, ; ,;H

  #  2."... # 7I   #'4   -  7-
J $<   # K# #* 6 #$  )    6/ 7I ()*
E# * #2 ?4< 0#L$ ,  M# % 1915 &#   #  .
# '   # 4   ./ ?  M#  - , <L  , =

.(1928  ) "    " Arabia of the Wahhabis 

 1

.3    


( 1973   ) ,"  !" Philby of Arabia Elizabeth Monroe 
  2

.37#

218
 
 
   
   

  
-

,  . &
'( )  * + ,  !"
# $%
 

*&
*%3 7% 56# 
 /!
 , ,(
&
0+1 234
. 3
  0: )  ;
3  -89 *% !   , Language Board
.1915  #  , , 2<
)  + 0=,   

>1915  #   2;
, 3
  0: ,  ! 2, $:

$% =
 00(
2 + *
0 0 @  .*(
2?  ,  
0
0?
1917

)# , $<+ 1916  # 0:


0# , . 0 =  3
0 # *;
*(

 ,  ! ,A
(
, *(
2?
/ (= )  3 : ,    20( 2? 

 ! 0! . 0 E;F $( 0 $? ,Gertrude Bell $ 0 C  D

3; )  *0D
'(
# 0! . 3, -(
3, 

G 
,

   
) D
* (
-+
# H0+
G
  
 
I
  *1   D
0
0 1 ; ,  0! ./!
 ,
3
.  +   $ ,-+,
0
0& , Cox  C $(  , A+
1917  #    ,
00# $+  - A
D
0
0# $4 , $#  0! . <4 0# 
C
# 
+
;F
0 ( - 
 # 3 / #
 
* + C $ (
*;  3 ,$(
/J  , 2 E2

 
D

#  3 /  .G


 K: , *F, +
*:"
$! (
, K J

 N 0" $=  .*(


2?
 , L D
$+ * 4 2  0
0#
 04 
 0( 
  (
O0+ , W.H.C. Shakespeare 4

 3  ! 
*=
; !
 3 %
0 $@  * 
*+
(

.55   
3

219

        
   .   
  
-)  /0  + *  % &   
' ()  ,  ! "# $
-1 2 ) & 3 4
 5 ()   6
2  4 2 &
:  1909 2 - 95  8- "" " &   % 21  * 1 

  ; 
 5 , 
$    /1 
0 5  
  ) ,  ! "# :0 %  = 3' %  % 
4< * 1
  @# 
60  )  
?  2    + .> 
Hamilton
-)  B & 9  C  
!   Arnold Wilson   A
*  &    ! "# $ % 
DE F ) & %  $=
.
!  >5    )
% 3 
 I5 B H 3  3  % 
G 2
/  
  3   1 G&    ? J4 .  ! "#
KL  H! .   >$$= 
&     ! "# %   -) @ 
5 3"  #) # 8 3    ,  M ?) 3 % 
%
3    + 4."  < K 1#    :# % ' 3 + ,@-
 8- *  < 4   
 0 
)   :# 
  #)
Elizabeth    " 5 .8"# # 8 
#  %   #)
,3& @4  ) / 21 ;& % N 
! = O N Monroe

$  J  ! %   
 ' 
 ) 21  -) 2) 
*$  >P -' % G
 -   >  3 Q   ,$ 
20 1
21  -) &   .( S RN'  8- /   5   #1 &
U5  ) 3  #  2  &    T    ) 

Elizabeth Monroe       1918     


  4

.79    

220

   
  
      , 
. ' ()  & *"  +
-  #  $% &  !"
5  .  /0 '   1' 23 
& 44  3
 
  7 7 83 0
& 914 6&  3 
 
, &<  &4  
  ;
73  ' *'  
 5:
 *1> $'  @# A#

'

 ?
  414 ?)3 = &%>
. = B 1;
3)  " ' () $ " The Heart of Arabia $
 /C

& #;0 ?

   #&  E
 @1#& 0  3  1
0
F
)
 +5 ,  '"  3
3  . ' ()  ' 
, - ' $   ' () &  G%- ,5 * 
The ' - #" /# .$  5 & "   
    & # / " ' () $
3" Threshold of Arabia
9   & ?##; & 4 #" 3 .2 > = H  , =  

 . %  *) & ?
#; I 0 2 # = ?
 
@K @1#"
#" 5 * .5 # J = ?# 94 #"
#" &  & /# .
&< 
&H J & (  5: 
,M  , ' E ,   / E ,L  M & ?
 6
The Holy land ,8; #" 3 .( = ? & 6N  , '"

#" 
 .( , & E ,/ & ?
/#& ,"  J-"
.J = 4 ?
) /#& 6 #" 3 ." E  ?
 8
. 5 (    O%3 B 
 ( 5 A  &  
#" 5 P!Q#R;     4 2) 3 4 #"  6
) . ' () ?0  (0 )  5 ,TPS; & (  #


221
# " .
     !"     
  
,+, -( *  * " !" )($ .(."$ % $    &'
 
6"  ,     )" .45! +2 3$ "! 1 *2 0  "#"
  #9 3$ -
 8 ," 6"  *$ ' 7-(   
.+$ ("  " , 

  
   

222


"    " Arabia of the Wahhabis   

# $% & '   !        


  
*  +( , )   . )    # ( !  
 #1 ! $  ' )  ! .-  ! # )/ 0   0 
4&  0 6 % 0  +3
7 ! ,  23% %3  4(
 
 ,! 9    , ) 3 2 ! #  !3 ) '  3 . 1'8
#$  &  <$% :;   ) ! .3  ' ,0(
  # ( &' ' '  >*
)  3  . )$=  0 ;  
 %
+ , =, @  ) 
.4 0 2 (   2' ?  '3  
%  2$ )      DEAB= 2C . &
 <) ! #  
 !+3  .0+   2'   <$%   F(
0+3
 
  =G $ C
  
 (% F = !) I   4+3 ! $  29 <$% H $ )
04%2 'G 
 I  
0' L ( $ ; # $%    (1918 0%
. ;&3  3&     8 I&&= 

223


 
   
                   
   
'( )*
 + +,( ) - &  $ %     #  !
 "

 ./   #    0  )*      1 2 "- 34  5   6 
-    :      
,8 4 % .#  *   +
, 6 > 6#< 8& - 1;  4   <=          
 "-
+, &@   ;
  B-  C;   
  " ?/ "@  . #   4
"
    F  5." /@  D
 .  E - 
> ...+,  >  @

 .     & 6 > 
    
#  )
(    6HF +G +
    .   ;   6H> @           )H  ) 
K  I   $  + /
 J -   D    1@-  5
> ,  )/
:+ 
 I   L - , MN   $ <    .   .D   * 34  ,  
 0  %> B:     +      )    14& P- > 4"
 2  0 ,
  #     )/ . > B, ,+,* <  ; 
34  & )G-   Q R 4&  )* - #<   @   6." >
.+ "
 1>   J )@

 " Arabia of the Wahhabis St. J. B. Philby  


5

.335   " 


"  " The Heart of Arabia St. J. B. Philby  
6

.181 /1 (1922 


)

224

     
    
 
.%  & ' ( )* + -  !  "#
$ ,
  
 
 /$ 01 2 3 4
  2 /5 +" ( * !
6 7
. ;< 2= : 2* ) 9 )
 "# ( 8

"  * 0B : 2 5  4 * +   ?8 @A
: 1

* 0 "
< "
" C/
 < /* &
#= H59 / F G1 
 0 $ F 
-= 

 F
<  F
* I <# *< 
 H;  / *  H+
7
.*  8 ,J8 # . 1
 B   3 *<
 C;
'M 0 # <
L H * 7  K  2*   ,1  
G 9M   " # 6  1 /= " :0 .   8  9M
2=    /*  N - *#
6 " : M  ? A  ."
*   <
< *  )1 *   O 
6 6 ,  -   ;<
8
."< /* : * ! ) /

& HMP   *<



 /9  A  -6=
 " <  4   :$ R<  MP    Q 
$ 
:18 :$ 4 / G   <;   :$
6 H2  / R
:

 2 )   I6 ,A  P G TU* , SK 0I 9 
$
 M 0M / H/    0M / 0 *  ,I 8 /*  ) !6=
18
6 ,"0) 0 #"
I 8  G1  =
91 ,  &
9W6  = 0/ !  N &V *#"  A !G L 1 /</

.203
/1  
7

.249
/3  
8

225
 ! " # 
      ,       

&    ( &+ "# )
   *     &  ' ( $%&
#  5 2 3 $  4 * (  $  *0# %   *- ./  !  '0 1
9
."$ (6 )

 7(  '0  89 $ $ :;
D E4  $ 3  B "9 $C (  ! /?A?@?

> * "# 05 (


"9 %# ! $ / , (    ,' &+     $ F "9 " )
 # 
10
 I( E4  '"J(> $ 3 H  3   5 ."B(!#   D43 # G  
$   ; 0 ( $9 
   ,)(
 G05" G   &  :& $9
&5 $ !; :& #" : "# * 43 "9 L"&  .GK # 3   2 4 E1
$ P  * $ )"  '0 05 $ '  F13 %  # ' N F )O  
11
."GK # '0Q 23   E1  )&   *
 $ )9  G9 ( *C ( ' (
 O 0%N 0 F , RC ) ( ) 3  )!  "# )#& $ 'O
 "# * $ 3  G )+ TC  $9 .*S# *5 00/ # )! 
)(  "     ? /  *
 $ ? $ 3" U(> ,/(   #
12

/  G  '  . 0(/ "  9  .    ) "9 )S/ 
+(   # &  0%  G 
 $ # (" P >   &  0  #
 5&  BV   $ 
 $ .5  BO 9  , R $  
$ 3  $  .W#; ! .5  0# BV  )%!"  $& 
 43  $ 
)1 39 $ F  )%!"  # $  (  $    "9 $ $ " 
.)  T   .5  S

.132  /1  


9

.60  /3  


10

.56   


11

.251  /2  


12

226
     
 
    
 

 )
*"  %   & '%  $ !"
# 
1   2 3  '4  ' 1 ' /5
 .", -. /. - : &+

'4 ' $'4 6  "7"  8 95  .' *  5-
;+
)7 % . ")7 ;< <"  
/% $" ) #
'7" :  =5 >1 ? >8  3. '" $  / '4
!
 3  >    @5 3. '4 ;+  ? .",  '1 
, C "7" ;+  + >1  3  >8 "  ;A
B5&"
13
 F
"   .>1  ) * *  ,) "7" "7" >5 D
/"
 % ."   )* ;" %  )
1 ! )  $)5 
6C )7 2+  5 ;1 
 )7   'H 3  /. G7C<
>1 H+ ; 18  1 >1 " '% ;+  % -. , # 
!" J+ @8  ,+ !I 1 ;1  '% <  
14
% 5  '%< 3  )A5 &% '% " :G7C< 6& .")7
15
."1 ' LMC8 A1 '%7 * K5 *
)
. O N
 )7 % #  
  
 
$/ ;P G
 G)7 /+  .%
)7 >
 
  A
6 

  K =5-   / '4 9< +1  O
:G7C<
 1 .K 9& A '%+  * /C   
:6& ,")7 ;< C  8   *  1  *
"
;<  ,K 
 =5 ;  ! 5 ,
 '+  G


.252   
13

.253   
14

.454   
15

227
! " #  ,        .
    

 , # 1  /0  "' + - ( *'   ,$%   #& ' ()
9  ) .$%    # # , #) 45 2 345 4678 # / ! #
# / = , 5 /  $% () +- # ; <7 (  # 34:) ,+ -
A;  B 1$/&  +   ?  ,?/6 /@ () 2  >  *'
F  $%  FG 8 ?  .>& * #5 E4 D& D4 45 C/@ ( 
16
.>& H/- # ;   I/ # 7 # 
$5/ () J& 4 ?4 ( # K%!8 L  (  )  8 -
C1$/&  >& ?/= ?5 3 /J F #'M # ?4 (@) C$%  + -
$% () *' (@ >&  7 7 # 45 J-/&  - *'
4 ,/@    - ) 3 /J /@ #'N # &  - () 4 ,/@
 5 P & # (  ) "/  .>&  /0N /!N @! 45 & #'O /J #
$%  + -  - $5/ # S/ # R L / #  / /  R Q
 / ;  K- &  # #  # .6   +' +4  
;U
 +- () $%  -" # #/ 4 C 4 5  ' # /@4
17
5     ' # (  ) S/  ."V(4WX H!& #  # J) 45
$% # (  ) S/ S/!  4 # .#  #  # 9 - K%! 
+- () $%    #  /& , 7/ / = J  ? 7 # 5 JU! 8 # 
K%!8 # / 0 <  ,3   8 2/ #   /!     .

B
7 F  ,J7  / /   $%  ()
 K- ()
34 
 /  $5  # $%  B #  
7  ,$%  () 

.206
/1  
16

.178
/2  
17

228
18
."          
  
  
/  - # 
,  , &! %
& '( ) * % + !  #
$ 

3 + 45 % % 4  ) 


& )$
* , )0 1 2 
$ 0 3+ ) !

  8!
 ! 9!0 ! '
$ !:   1 .6!57 ) ' 4 * ,
)' %+ (;
>  ) ;< ! '$ 8 !, %: %+ ! :  ! '$ &  
&
:AB" :%


8, ) 3( ) !
3! 1 % -! )'' /
 ./
19
   D! ." 
 %
 :8! 5 , 
 :
A:
: ,)
 :
8 
: , %

 ;# - ,  )! %+ ! 57  # E! 57 ) $  % 
 2
'   B ,)  ! '( 3+ 2   , 
,B %+ F: 
! <  2H  "  '  6! G   '( )+!  !  ,
/
$ ! ),
I )  /
 ) 

, 47  ,  ):  !1 ):: 
20
."F 
3
 
3 ) 
&  0 /
 % J
J
 ,
8! 
 K , 3 2' /7 
,  % + HB

 M + 

 
7 !
0  
  ! #  20  .%
& L&#
:  %+ 35
3'!
 % ) '( ! D /
'!
 L' )& 27 F '
 
 & ,
7 ),
$
8* 2' ! 27 N  N
& &
 3>+"
21
K )! 
, %+ !!> ;   N# - ."!$<O B
8# P!
,
   !H
8 !# B & ,  2 %0 '  , L /  " :2$
 +  #
22
, % + !9 4 ."! K" :A
1 4 >  ,8! '
 %+ 1 A!

.179   
18

.46   
19

.   20

.195 /1   


21

.134   
22

229
   
    
  


:
,
   
 !"  #$
 % & 
 ' (
0 2$ */ 0 1! ,#
 + !- .!  

) *+ ( !

,% 5
6
" 78 " ' 2
 '  !
 ,!
 
34 !  

;

< " 7+6
 " =8 - '  4 ( "' (9  (
23
.>+6
 + 0 (   
! 6
% ;! */ 
 / 0
 ,  " A>  6 "( 2"% ' (" :!+0  !%
"8 %' "
!( C   " 

 ,B
" " !

0
 ( %'
D( 8  0 !%+ !8"!  
2$(0 ,
24
( ! 3(
"  
! !% .%$ 
"  =! H ."E!  "/ F6/ G4
25
  7  ' !+0 + H ." 

< !  3 *+ A  #
%
&
 " * 84 .-  I>" 28/ J
-  I>"
 - %  

( ' .4 ,LK! M


D9  ( (" "' 
 !% ' K ( ."4
  3 N
   =
0  ++6   +- =
>! M!


! +(P! N
  =
  3 +( ."J8> O"' 0( "
'
 ( #$ 
 ! * F6 */
 ' H .&
 .D 3 , 

26
."   $% I>" 0 
 DD "   $%

("

.  23

.3  /3
  24

.4    25

.5  /2
  26

230
 
     

 
  
    
 
   .% /  0 (, *
) % ! &
  '(
) *$ 
! "#
:    ; ! *$   . *  ,
* 7
 8#% ,54 1! 2 3#

" ; 
: ?; 
*# @: 3 =  ?5 /
 =  >  <# 
 '
5C 1  ;  8#*  :#=  *
 , " D ! ."B 5A <#
 B#%" 8    
$ #
%  '# F% = " ,, " D :
27
'  
# ( 
 ."@

 * 7*%
HI
# H# H "G
' #   F
* 
 (
: ' : .
J 7= 
*# '

: "B
.. # '  K:# '   0A  1!    ! 
 : :# A
# ,
 '
:# . # ' 1*
 ,  '0L : 
 0
1*
 '  @5 $   .
 
:  O L 7 N# 1*

*;  M
1#   =% >  <I ## 1*
"  % <# P    #%#
# 7 1#  O
# 
 ? K: ; 7= 7  .....7 
F
*
* 3= 2!   
 ?5 ?
 ; '  Q: 
*# <$ 1   0##
28
= 5" :
  <I #
8
H##0    ."=%  * 
#
!$  I %;  ; 
 7
% B# 1*
 # 
 7* S0
"...Q


     *
 
  I  7: '3= ; ;  8 !

H; * N ; $ ,"B 54 (*  ; I


% *I F5  3 = ; 

 ** ;" *5T  : KI 

* ,54 7
* <# 
8#* 
#I ! 


% ;
H; 8
 .";  '  " P  %  U  (* 5
 1  ?5 = ": *I
  V 
% 7 ;  M I  

.6   
27

.7   
28

231
        !"  
  

)*%  "
 +  #
%   & '    ( $#

   "1 ,!", - % % )", . %. /"-

. 23  6 %" )4%


'
5", % #6  . 23
-   <"% 7
"  
 .7"6 . 7" 8"%%  9:
=, /",  
%+ #> 4 9. "6   !
!",
29
. '"1

#>"  ?" @%    . +4    

 9% , "',  A   %  &%   #%  >"
30
   "1 "# ED  ( 7  ,%   D%" : @
 -", +%   !D +: . % !"   . ' 
   . F "  9.F GH, 9:  
", 7
A " :"%I  !  !%" . %% .   : " /-F  
(  J
# =
= ="1  #" <"+ ? E"% " 
31
."#- 9. <"4 &."
KJ  H%
D
#" <"+ !*
#  #" %A  "A( 
= D
& >%% & D
#  "
L+ *  &% :  *
." ' ,#" M" 
 !H ' 5  ?I G*"
 9D%   , >( NO% & '
D% #H # &% 9: &% 
- 7"%
#  "% ?>> ?I  P.+ PH 
#A

.251 250  


29

.14 /2  


30

.15  


31

232
32
 ""  
  
    

  
*& , % )   ( #$ % & # '& (        !
* *%2    ,+) -$. *  /!   01  -  &
:   (/ 6 - %2 - 5 3 & -%2 4
 %
;1;) :&"  )" 72 ) *( *! 89...
:& "" /!    ? @ *  =><0< & *   * -<
33
.72 - A B'& -! & * %2 @%2 * 1 $  3"%2 "
< )
 5A * ' ) *& -% *  ) % -)
 ( $ 
?$  ,! (/  *   2 D   (   2% ) *
* ! 
 G   *& DH *)   - ,F!A ! ) 1E

1'   )   *&
 B =>G 0)   ) ! 
..."  */  *! *&    
 K9&  ?$  ,I < I J!
 L      + F %  
 @9 $ *  
34
".
8 
  N/  'M * *
 (   $
  (
 %  ,
 P *) I - ( 1' . ' O$
/! )/ ! <  ()  . '    ( 
  
R1
 Q    $. /! *)   2%) < *  .$.

 ? ! () & 0< *%


 % - 3  ! 6&  B'& 8
F% *S  62  . ' ( P %  % 0 !
O1 * 9&   ( !
 -ST  ( 3 ' !(D

.262
/2  
32

.220
/3  
33

.
 34

233
     
   !  "#     

! . + - %") " " ,)   "" % &'   $ "#
 - "1 3"1   01 $ . ("
 .  01 $ ..."#

 8 - ; ! ) $ 
 
:  89   8$ 3
7 564 3
)$ = )"1 3"1  <1 = > 6# 8  . 1 6# &1'93 ;#   
8$   >"1 B%  .% 7 9"1 >-@1   1"1 !"  A  &
%?
>"1 D> = 8   -" ) $ %1 )"1  C "1 $  )"1 . "1
  ,3"1 F? 3% 16G1    C "1 $  ) $ E; " %"1
35
1 -  ">"1  H   )" 5 3 "F?"1   )"  3  01 1
B"6  A  & "1 F" !J1 >
01 K H   "1  L % " I" E "
36
. %"1  1' > 1'
   F- "1   > 1 F )%"1
" M1 N ) $ NL "
3 %  %"1 -? )$ ) $ .% N )"1 @1 9  .!H 
 1
  7 ,> 1
H " 
 @1  OP 1    N"1
 )$ N"1 !  ,7"1  )$
"  3 )"1  "1 > "1"  !"3
37
."!$?  H#  ! H1 HI  % "1
=     " % 1906
 )$ F9 >" > 1 11  ) $ Q 
S11 ) $ !3   J1"1 %   R6  - )$ H 1  !
   "# 8    Q  6# & 101 !1   "1 > 1 11"
JC1       > 1   "# E $  -101 !--H
 F"1
1H1 8- $> > 1 8 ; 1'"       ,"

.
   
  
   35

.229$227#/2 !"
  " Heart of Arabia 36

.97# !%&' #( 37

234

      ,
      
   
38
.") "+ 
( ) *& ' "  # $%  ! 
45 6
'  7 3& 1 2"  ) " /& + & & 0(
    8  < 
 +!  
  9  :; 2 8 )(
; & ? @A B:5    
9
  8 >
 )=   ) 
"!
 =   )( 45 
DE+
 C  >
   5 @+!
8 :/ 28 
4  @ )& 
1 @ ! @% FA 
4& ) & )& E "HI&" )( 45 G 

)5: : E
45 / ,)5! )5
 5  ; )( 45 
" J5 

 > " 
@& )5 : ,@ 6&   + & 
/  
K& ,+ & ; "?"
@

  
 F  L+ & K
M K
N; &  !  )& !" /&  
>0% )
 DE"
   

 
 
O /& & 
 &
>" 
  
& P .G
 4 "
 )!8 :5  < 

@  
 @  F @   @& 5 @  ; M  " @
  + &
39
."B  F
     6
 )  ; ,4+" & + & 5Q !
; ,)& + : &
 = !( H+& + & & & ' ; )
@ +
 @  A&   F 1R B  '+ @
+ "( 
 @
  +& ! 9  & 5  '  3  >)%8 '+
M & & ' ; +
 N :5 .  '   9 45 59 
,)    5  45 ! &  )59

 3 1 >9 45  @
: 0%  "= A   '(+ @& 
)5
4& @ I  
< ; L&& 6


/  /   & 

.171
/3  
38

.173
 
39

235
 %       
!"
 #$  ,
 
/  -
 .+ %  !&' % ( '&
 )*   %+ +
51  # /  .32 )*
2 1  #
0"+ '*
.   ,36
 3
+ 5'  %+ +' & 3
 %  +&'

40
.5'9 :  %+ +&'
;  .&' < =
 78##
+6 2& %>+" :
 '
%>+ +' / +  + ?
."35 ! '  35'& " + /
$ +   C" & 2 BA 

F 9 )6  /E 3 D5 8 '+ % =
   8 + (+'
&K F 9 
J C%< J
:G  ' 'H " 5+ & B+
;


O'
/
&
  /
+ HL J
M '  + BM (+- .  N  '
41
1  
1
0+ %+ )>-
 .
"
F 9
 .+K
321 BR#
35 9 " 
Q  1 Q Q B.6
%
 P 6
+
N-' 51 3
> + & 2 A&" + 35&  "A-< )<  &"

42
+/
+    
+ ./
6
< A&<+ -9'H+
B'    M " :
 =
 
Q )* .1+
A&
251  !KS
6

Q ! 35 9 B35  -"' %L & 6 G** N+ '
43

>
P+  8 : M
+ )6 . 
+ 35 B39

Q 
B6
H &M 
9/ BP
;+  /' 
%&
J
=
 S+ 8
44
A> BU + +& )6 .-H
&
A1 T1
#K ) -< 3H*

.6
/2  
40

.367
/3  
41

.        42

.48
/3 "#$% !" " Arabia of the Wahhabis 43

.17
/2  
44

236
#!"        " "    
  
 &  
 $% & $ '& () * +&, -!  .
/ **! %  $, 01 % 2'& '& * - /3
45
91 :       8 8
) $* 7   .45
- " :*  > 7 <- =-  < );  -  /3
* A- 7 - B*7 /B&- 2BC D8E B* 7 FB * * @-%
46
."2B-
47
 H
B' BG + 2B 7 * B - 1&   *& 2
 3 ; JB % *< 4B  I& 1 J *< *B< +K B%
. - I& 7 % 2< B% /% 'M G  I& 7 'L
:  B BG  E B-
DB3< $K 4& *  &  -&  B9 *'   *<
B-B& N*   - < B    J B%   =K 7
**! $K B% H*  * * B% 78 ; % 7  B
1 B B  =  B  2B DB  4& J B @* L
7 21 2*< 2B- IF! * H BG   &* @8 7 N 4B
,  4& @ B% 8 7 , *  *- J JB D 7 7
48
. * B%  4& C  @ B% H 
L

B9 G  F /FB P3B 2B7 %! 1B&  N O8 I  B%

.18   
45

.129 /3   


46

."
      
 
! 47

.64 /1 "#  $%" The Heart of Arabia 48

237
49

            
    
()#   *       !  "   #  $  %   &  '#
." "    (. +  , -
6 !)  !7  )2 ()# # 54 2  ! 3   1# !)  1 
:. 37 
  "9& # )  "  &2# 5"   8 $' ()# )
   1 ;.   .   # ;   <=
> : ; )" 2     ).
'   .2 )" 2  A *  5"    ? @ "
 " ()# 91 
 2  7 !  -"  : 2   ). C-  1)  B->  *%
' "   "    2  E"= ! ;<   F ! G2  ; " :?
50
   . ! *'    :  !)  H @$  !&#   .,  "  ()#

   %  ? - :  = # "   2 2$. ! 5"    


51
.",&  : I     J   ( 3.      
: & 2 < !  3- 2   I #    !)  #
  .L M     $'   ( = !)  G     K  !  17   
:: 2 ! N-A
()# P 2Q ( R& )2 > 97 . ; - ;)F " ,O .
!% - .  O - = I  ,.  O - & )2 > =" ,  R  J
52
."I %   ).  9 1  & )2 > B ( , 7 ; 6   !%# 5O#
! 2 @$     3    " I #   7 3  # :  #
9 J-   3 " * # #   * # # !     T) (# N7"  1 

.194   
49

.259 /2   


50

.138 /1   


51

.138   
52

238
   
         
  
0 /% &' ( )*+  ,  -   . ! "# $
53
.# 0 4 5 30 . &2  !1 #
  "2  *   (#  ""  "7
?# $ ! !+ !>    =3 " :)*3 5 !+9 :; 
!'  : - B C %  =3   5A ; @  !9 : -
."!-
!
"7 ?# . $  ( !> B  #  "2
54
#  !2   ( # D =#+ 95 E+  " ' : 
:!  #  
5C I- !'  #  H+ G@    C ( F 
(9 > L K$D+L 7  ( " :B  #  C !D+J @ (9
D+" M 7 7>   9 (  +L   F "$ 7 
O+C K0 ( N>  (   -  L   C "!' 9
( # C >  F+  P>J #  GO 9 "(#"   
55
.", (* N>  &2  ( , " :   9  "2Q   ( +
 !+  !- >       = #  
$   O O'  :2 O7 9+   L 9 L 7  &
> !*  2   !;  ! ?- C D !#  
 ! >  L # R =1 )2 ( #  ! (> " :   
."&   L     9 

.139   
53

.214   
54

.2 /3   


55

239
     
    
    
  ' () *+ , # $ %# & 
 # !   ! "   
/ * (00 (1 !2 3  32  -. * '   '
:$ # 7/ 56 56 $21 4 *#    
9   "# ! 8 3 *
+
;  "< = ' ! 4  >
,) $    
 
  & ?    '  < !;  @ !  ' 1"
@" 9 ! &  B"< 4?    2  ' 1  # @' A  
 3'  (> AA  C (  (D !0 3 E # $F 
 (H< >"  (  # &  2  &  ,   4 #
 H   (  0 
   $?   # ,  '  &D
<   (<  /I # E#  J/I 41   $ 2 ,8
(  ) * 3N) ?O E    /K L2    M
:< E (  )) A $N# =
/# $ 0 =" 
! =D P    # "    
 BR)> S L'A @"   ('<  ' A F " J"(< " 
 ( (  D   L) * (; ! D 
, !?   
&8 &' 4  2  (< (8    (  (  !<
56
"...
  (N> (   $<  >U      
 $1+ 4/>  ?O 1 O? ! 0 4   '   ) (8
B  ?   ="   $N8  B =" (8  V/

:4   4?
8  $ #  > ( ( 2   $

.37
/2  
56

240
!" 
      

 (  ) "
* !
&+  # !'*
+
  &
%" : # $  

1# 2* 
1 " : $ /0 !"-& . #* '$,
-$7 %0 ; 96+
$7 8& 0 5 # !*
30$ 4#
  0 4
?, 2? !##
'<
 - =7<
94
+ 1*+ >;,0 
57
." 
# ?, $7 AA BA$@
5  # 5 E 9* 5
7 D* ' -#

 0 # 
4;> 5  !# /<
 4+
3; 7 !/F,
 
 0 8$ $$
,& J;G #   3;
<
!# ',
6 G IH G F+
*

 = " :# K; $7 $ $* !>


  5 *
F+

K$&
6 ?  L0 
'
7& K%  K>   ',

 ; 9 >
6+
N+-&  <

;> 0 G !"M*
$ 

/
 /
  1F$"   9OB
F  "2 <"  
0
58
." - P30   1$
  
  @TSR  8 0 !#' 0  ', !/$ Q&   
5> ! '  " :/
# ;!>
 *
F+
*
5+


'  - U *
,
- 
,
 !"  

5 -# -$&    !     !



 , - E*
3;$ > 0  - & ?0 ' -*   2$  &0 =%
4;> 5-

;V !/
  * !5
 E2 ,
 .$
 ; !N2 0  & F$ *
   !  0 /$ F+ 2
5


57& 5  !"-& G 



QT'" : $ MG  $?
*
0 

.97 96  


57

.18 /1  


58

241
            
    
. !
+ ,) ,& & -,& ,*  ()" # $%
" $&'
2  ) &
 % ,  # #,34 )/3  () *, 1 0 ( +/)
)/ #' 89' (  #+)  &! " : 6)+ ,) ,/+ ' 53 #&
< & ,/>+ -& +/  , +/ = )/  (!/ ;% &  <
)  6) 6 #"  #" :'B) / 5@ () A '  " , ?%
59
." ,  A
/ )< )     ) +/  ) ;,) '/  C=9
 H,& 5@ C3! ,) () G F() 6 D+  ( E  ' 
 *,  +6+ $' %@  ,/ ( 6  ) 6 E&  '  % 
A  ) D+++ ' 2 -& F ) 6 E+" ) $6++    2  
< D,) 0*+" (+ & $=)6 ,+    3 " < ?6
I+ E ) , !"! ' ! =, ) & $,+   &+ ,'3 +<* 
60
.C+   0*)
=,B) /  ', =' J 
"  $&+  C 1 E, ) (
=' E,3 $'"   ,'3 ,  ( )<    ,'3
 3
  & ,) /'+ 3 * 6 +  -& 9' I  ?9'+ E, )
E'  +'1 K'  () 0*+ = $% " ,   "! 3 "*
)  L' ,&   +J  =& ,)+ # ) / I ,& 53
E
 $< 1 + # ='  () L&M +) ) C&! C+ + L
61
 .N* 8  $3 ,6) M@ 
 M %@ FI)
 E

 ! "

.203   
59

.367 /3   


60

.204   
61

242
 
 .   
 
  
  

"# $%%
&'
 !  (
)
 *+,
 -   !
5
 6
 ! 
" $&'
12 *  3  
&+0 !   /
! $"0
 
2  5
%0 ! 
8 $ +
5
 7  $ +

62
 '
12 5   $" 
 *9 -   -
9 9)
.+ *  ;'
 -9)  *
 : !2  +0
 #  -=  9>
 
<

+  
63

 ?
=
 6
A+ :" :/2 -=  #   - ?
=

*9 /2 ->0  -=  3+  


!
! –   6)
! "
2 !  $6) 

"  ?
=
 ! ."9>
3  *=
 >,
  0B " -! ! -= C 
D 2  -
=  8 % 6

$   6) 


*9 *>E +  -  +  $-, 
G H2
*9 ?
=
 ) ! 
6=
5 
F! + 
64
."
I
*9 "-+
:'   $J>I
 3+ "<,
 I
E K + ! 
!
- ?
=
  
2 !" :
J>
3+ LM *  6
N)! 6!
/ 6 + 3+ *-
 ! ". -+> >0

 $""<,
5 *  5
/  > H2
0
"  
- - 
 5
 = + , $ Q
3+ 6
DM  69  OP!!) ! +
5,Q 5

! *
  

6
12- 3 $
K

.219   
62

.19   
63

.248   
64

243
65
  
    .    
  
66
/$ 
 0 1 "
 2" ! + , - *& .)  !" #$ %"& '(
5& 6 7 3 1  4-  3 !
  !" , ( 
 
9 3 & -  !" 1 $   8 7 3 1 8 " *
! : 
 !" (
    9 " ) '( ):" 3 ! 
/  !"    2  #<  9 ;: *0 1 !"  
3 1 6?  9 3 ! "  *'( ="   ;$  > * (
 3 -
  
 1 & " :6" * A  ( ( @ :  3 7
! " 1 F %-E 8" A?  8
 5  7 3 D ! "   ."  
:  ( G  > E 5& !" , ( 
    H 9 3 8 
J F8 3 I+ 1 9 3 : H" 5   :  !" : ) 
67
."8    3 & , :
 3 J F6   A:  E@ '(  :  ! " K
= ! "  *  8  "  
   8( L   '(  ,( 
!" ) "  #? '( A ( 8 : / *   ((
 3 93
( 9 3  ) + ,<" )  '( & 
 * &3  )3  
K .6(   (  8 , : #$  # 83 *(

   !" , ( &" !& !E@ '(  : !" K: )
  ! "
<  :! " M < *"6  ( 8 1 / !$   &" 3 0?
68
!" 
  6 ! "  .  91 A     N !E ;$

.255   
65

.256   
66

.291   
67

.274   
68

244
:    
     
,
-
*$ '+ )*$% '# (
 ! #  
$%&  ' "
  
' ,' ,' :
 % 3
(0 '#+ %  1 0 2  .$/& 

/ &' $ 4%
*& 8 9
('# ./$ 67  #+ ,4 5
&  7? 
('>

'>'= 4* + , -
* ; 7  9 <=
%
*
1# 
/& '#
 + '# 4 & 
# <'/ ! @ A '
 '% B$; 1

69
."%
*  7
'EF6
 '7 4'8$ !'%& 
  
  $+ & ,3 1D

'#+  % < &'%


* / 4H=
IJ*K L +
 
  '7 0 G'>'0
70
5 & & %  
  2'; 4'7
.J 1 #8$ M
 (7' 2N '6
<  4O  
7&  '% 3& '7  +  
P + 4'%
*
$@'&  = 0 :I<'  @ B$; $+ $
(4? 7= 0 #+ %
71
 2';  '7 :$+ 
8
"... 6 3 $; Q & J 
'@
 '@+ '7
'>
 &'%
*    
 -'&  J R+ 2 '% A  0  

2'&6 3$&  -
* 1 1'& S + 6 & '@
('#8$& !8 + '#$K
0 'EF6? 'EF' '7 (
  M'  ) 7& 2
  $+ 
($%
72
.'#&/ -
*& '#8$ 
  0
J 2  '7  2*% 
+ -
* 0" :
8 $+ V&7

A% M'6& 1&  2 


,
;  B0 V@  W'+ ,4'' 8&&

           ! .69


/1  
69

."23 4 1 & + ,-0" :'( )  "# " $ % &


. 6'3    6' = $0 5 "#  ' "  67  8 "9 0 5 60 +6; + 1<$ 70

.94
/1 " >? @<" The Heart of Arabia 71

.   
A B "# 9C0  8  + 1<$ 9   ( 0 <  72

245
73
    .   
    
   
        !"# $% &'
()
*
+ $), 

74
.01
()2   - ,) -
8 51) " 67   # 3   +  $
!% ! 4
=- : 
' =!  9 <
;  (&# '  
5
: 98'7 $% * 
67 # $
!% ?# 90
 ,% >
0<- ? -  
 0 5  @ ' 

$
 67 
 A $%   
  
))  
 + $%
.3 
$%   $%    
9 ) !1
$% 
 31 $% $''  =! 6  *: $
!% ) $!
 9$   B # =!   ')   5  3)%
 
 31 $%  @# ,) !   C ' 
 D! # $
!%
4 G >
 B 9 &
 () 9) %8E  8 F 
*
&E ' <
4 G '# 8:% I$ : &!'! 6H  ! 1  
# &E   9) &
J 5
: 6H 0%  ! ' 
 =-
3A  L
' 
 1 # ,*1 6(! ""  8'7 =! 6
6H 
)' #  #  9
  M
)#  ."0 M%  F   
6  @ ' 
H %- N ) %8E $% !:) 8'J '' 3!
:&)  
'
#  3 $% N +E 3  67 3 
 + $% I$
 )1  *) : 61 $% ...
 <) H D)    1  L

 ) H 3 <% 5  96'7
8
 P 1)     
 - .$8'7  ! 3   ,$  
 1 9 & +) D  )    

 +) =!   3

.140 139 /1


" 
 " The Heart of Arabia 73

.199 /2
  74

246
           
       
-( 
) * +  , '  ! " !  # $ %    &" 
34 54 3 '.   /  0 1 2( 2 *   #+ (
24*"9  
 "+ , '  7! 83 4  #   54 + ,# $
+4/   + /4  9 < ,8  3 : ;"9 -( + 0  1"
 4 #  <  +"4 !2  ,# $ 34   #    ;"9 => ;4*"
75
. /   ?  +
:A.
2*
  ?= 7! -(  8/
F
 ,0 1  7! E1  D  / 9 ?= 7! >"
76
( 0     5I> H4 E  !  E3" 
 ."9 G:  2
2"9 - > # !   J3/  #4     I ,"   < /4  0 
.D F   /  
44  4
 /   ? 33 H   9 F3    L K ( K $ :9 3
 M   E2  2"?: 1* 84   1/  $ "+" H4+   / 
E
 "+ 9 / JH4  23*" N  ,/ 2/ <  ,24*"$
3 '"" O.4  E$  5 M9 " F J  E4  A #" = 5 3
- > H    4  - ";  E  L ( $ +  J1( H   <*" +
77
."$
P +  I   3  ;(9 /4  0
 9  1= 

;/ ;"9 ( !  % F"  < 24  219 2"9 + "     Q
 4( D4   E+  +   > > , 'H4"     2

.105 104
/3  
75

.105
/3  
76

.239
 
77

247
78



  
    
   

.  


 
    !  " 


   

 
 

.
!  $  "#
0   #, +/ "!
 )* " $ '* +
,- #
 "!* !'" :%
)*   ! 5
 6  7 + 3 ! 1
 # 23   !
 4

"   5  16!  8 9; 6  
   ' 6

 8,

' 
!  >9  3* ? 0@ 3 = 1<   

 , 2'
79
." CD ?#* A B
B 5 

 
+  $% E$ !  8   
 )

' G
 
  
$ E
@
/ 8 E$ !  ' ,

4

GC  / "I$   !
 , 
  "
/ >    " H0 @
80
."
  L
8  
 ! ! 


 K, 
! 
4 ! J
A * : 
1 #
 ;*  $ 
   $ C
L+
$ 
$  3* , 8 


 ,G
- H; N, E$ MM ! +
$ 8 "# KD 2' 8 +
,- " ?8 ?, N,/ K'# 5

  
81
."";

 8 L
+, 4
  ,  K, J  8  5%  "
8 $  3* ,

4
 B  8 ;C  
  L
8 
  
K'C 2' 5%  ' .K
!M 
4  ? "#
$+  
" 
   /
P% 6   .,   
 O 8

 8, 2'  8

.24   
78

.23   
79

.   80

.272   
81

248
:$!$% &#!       ! "

 "  
0! ./*" :+)-' ,)*  ! ,('  ! &#!    &'
8    ,56 0 7 /* 5 5   4 2 3   ! "!   
@ 8 " +)-' 

?! ."0$ ;  <!=! ,    )' 97" :+)-'
  ! 0 9" ,*E 5 D F9! BC D 5$ A 
82
."C D
5$@ ( 5' 5  ! ,H)7I 7 FG 4% 5@'! A 7 !
  H)7I   '! .K &=  9 9 J*% 7  ! ,5 !
* 0" J@ L- 8!K ! ! *E= M%  (3 J (   0!
 5G  F/6 K7 0 ?! .A  *' C (!9=7 " = ?
( /  5 8!% 79 N= ( 5EEO (!@ 5 P ! ! (
@7 .=! ! 5$ ,  7 0 5/ 5G 7  ! '! .(=
9 $' 8! ! ,87!K 4  &K 7 !' %  (9= K
(I! .Q!K 8!% ( !@= /! , / 79 ! ! != ( /3 (-'
K7 ,5 8!%  N= &  !@= ( <E ( !  EK! 9
9 (! E! !  = (!!K= /3 !K ! ( / (9
83
G3   (9  /  ( 2 ,!% $ A !$  J= /!*@
8 R ( ! ! I @ 7 A != 8= A 9 *E G (!
( 5 !   !  ( G9  % ( 8!=  *= !" :!E
7 5- (=  5* , 9  ? S!' 5$@ (!/
! 7 ! 57K F%  ! ."!' T 2 ,! 4' 8!  ! ,7

.43   
82

.180 /2   


83

249
84
!
 ."        " :  
  
 # $ !%
& '( )  
 * +'   ,-  /  
-! 37*
01 $ 0% %2   +
-! 3 4#5! 622  
85
6  % 9 , ;#  < (  .$9   1 8  
8  077 !1 
?%@ A   $ '(  ,
9  > 6  
, A ,
 62 
!1 
  B5 6C  , $@ .
 ?7 ,%
86
." 3 <
 $12   "$ 3 $!5 /  /%
 F , A ,D

 7 9E 6%! F9  $ , $@
,     ( .,11 6#  2   7  , ,#%  GA
/7  7 8A G7  < 7 H
0( +!1 
' +, 2  0
5 !1 

(#  $C1 /
2    ,  $C  $@ 8 " , 52 $C 9
(9  (A ,C 1 $C ,, , ?  0!
  $ F(  A ,$C55
A ,G C7 
-!   G7 , $@ ?5  
 I ."$C 9 $1
 65
 ,9  622 F  ,) .$! ' 8  0%    ,
,9 G#A 
 / 2 ,'!1 55 5 $ 
2!  ! 3%
#  625 9 J(9  I 
  .7 6
! , &  65

/
F( 8A *  .$C%  $ 1 @ 5
7 6
! 6%! 
:  6 -
8A 
9( ( 6   J  K 8   9   2"
; ,$C 9E /  ?! / -   !  ?7 ?! <7
,) 05
0-*  $  / ' 3 0
 K# , (9  F* 8 '

.181   
84

.185   
85

.144 /1   


86

250
     ! #"   "  

' &   (%) * + -. /0 (1 - ,1915 $% & 
87
."....)2
 1  7  ) & 4  4 56
 4 18 
9 * # ' %   ,Carlo Guarmani
: : ;
< & 

1 AB ,@   4 8 * 2 *<1 !
* (0 )  %"
*   #) 
...D4  C& ! 2 $  % 8 
&    * 1  % . * 6 %- (1  -. ,/+
(B % & 41    2 * D B *       * (1& ,D D9
88
.D9 ;

& *  &  4   * * )  2 * E 


(2 B * D4  *6 D< * & & 2 B .$4 % 
  1 % F  & . 
$4  %    0 &

G H) & & G ! * ,*2 (2 * % 1 5)
* , 2 * 
& * *9 E 1 I   .< &' E
2"  B :J0 $4 B  * 9 $ ! * -. .   2 *- 
. 
 $4
.
89
@ K (2 H- *  ." 2 * % $% ,*& 4 521 $% K
.;9
D%  6 $ $4
2 D+1 & * *% 0  *.
H8  % & LB % .7 $4  H 2 * (2

.87   
87

.   88

.267 /2   


89

251
"   ,  
           
 
!
%. , *'      +$ -.&   # !  $ % $& '  ($  )
# 1 2 ($' 3 
 -.&     2   .   '/ " ! 
   9  9   ;!  ."9!   : ,5  67 8# / "$ 6"
      1+  =  '   9  <  $     '
.    B  .( *
# ! 2 B   )>? @ # 1 $ ' 9!
H *6 @ $      &     D ) E $1F -G = +1
9!  1+ 9! ($D I=
      '  @7  !  9 
;$  )  67 , $   9    1)  @ ) ! /$  !'
+ & 9*  G&  $    ! '   %/  ' ($) J -.G
 &  !  .  M  9 9!  7 ... 5 " : ! !K  9
90
."  ' @ +$ 5 G$ ! O  ! N + 
 5  !
 * !$  G&   I2   6  !      ' 
$  -.G . "  G /    (  $ ' .2  & :  +9
   O      P 9  O    . G+9  9 $ '
N+  M9 ! I%. B  .; 
 ($ ' @ H *    * ( <
% $&  (    =   Q ,<  Q . *' + " (  
91
."    #< ' GG  "&
 ( ' P+  P     P
,  9  :   (  
!  G$ , M   
G$D  & '    9  <  *
 ' )
9#   ?   ?  P  +1    =  .    @  $
   &   ( ' D/ R 1   9 6"  &    


.82   
90

.191 /3   


91

252
!
 ,   ,      
   . 
 
92
"!(
 0 1)+ 2  3 ! - " & ' ()! *+- & !  / .""#$
:= 7 89/ ": 8 9 27! ' ()!   ; /  ( < /  "(5 )
/ 7  ,? &   & &?) 1!@
 ;+  "! 3+= &
*A !  
3!? 37 B!!?  , # 57 & " / 7  & :
7 
  1)+ * C9 *=A - !
   3!  &
93
.3! D
< ;3) 3 &"    E ;"*   " 3!? 3)( &   /
* F 9    ."-  7$   ) 3!  2 -( ? 3 ' 
:" G  C9 ' ()!  (/
: ;   ? I  2 / ( & H  C9  ;  
+? 9/ &
? .
( & ! ) !? & ?L
 M : B  & JK$
*+
 3!  2 -( !7 !+ C9 Captain G. Forster Sadlier  ?
3@! 7 < #7 ,JKM   = & * C9  ;!  8 A  .(1818
89/
   :E 8  & NG7 
 7 !7 "
$ &
 3MMO
JK$# * ;3( : 8(
 ;' ()! & 9/ 1)+ - .29)  3  / 2
'#  5$  '# 9/ ,! 3 B   & "   P=#$
...& 9 Q7 <E/ . - ,
)! ,$)   ?  C9 # 
&:=:   ! ( 3 "(?L ) '$ 3 3 ? 3  " & $7 
(    
 3$  ! /? 3D!   ...2 "#$ &+ ...+
& 2+  -(@! 5)    3(  ' ()! ! + G( .5 7

! 
&+  + ! 3 ?< "M$T   R& S ( * F 9 ;(
!(

.146
/2  
92

.
    93

253
         !"# .
   
94
.+,% '#(% 
  ')  * %  $ #% !&#$
 7%6  5 16"   "% /% " 0% %   12  3 - 
  -  " '=  .""   8 9 8 :6   ;  &# < $
 3% &    8 % 7%6 @$% 3%" !2%  % > ?$%  < $
 & #$ " 96 ,+(% 7  # 7%6 #  !" % ? 6 7 &A 
'@ #% - #C < $  16   D% 7%6 3 E# < $ 7 E5, %
95
3 *% A
% < $ E5, C# '#  "$$ '#% .9 ' "
.(  "C F1% '% 8A(% ,? 8%% F  3 # , % 3 
< $ G 1 F1% <A%  !&#$ < $ <   F1% !? 8%% - 
32 !8
%   < $ H# #(% ...A    " E% ( 
96
." % < $ 8
 F C #  I >#$ =
*  % " 7 " #  F1% ',J% "  < $% 3 #( 6
,D%1 '=  .C#A %  >  $ # *  &  < $ 8$ #$ 3 2%
N#%     #C "  # :%  ?$  D2 ,KL)M 1  
# $% 6 " 8(  3%  H# #  8( 3% #% 8 D%1 ! %
97
, >  . (% ' 3$ # '%% 12  3)
 3% EC
% 8 
3%" > )% ', 3 3 3% L 2$%  " ? 3 C O$ 7%6 # 9 
> )% 7%6  3 2% P% 3 '#
  &   L " #  3% 5 E(

.151 150/2 
     94

.154 
  95

.156 /2 
  96

." #  !       243 : 97

254
98


 
 ,    ." 
   
% &   ' ()* + - & /!01 ($ $) # $
!
99
3  (!4  5 04 6
 &    7 8 9 ,00 2 $
=  3 "6
<"  
1 2 4  :; (   4 .
 * 4 
  %2 +'
= '* ! >?@ !
* A$
B  !1
( A$ D
2 2 ,5  $ 5  -
* ! 6 "C 92 2 9 "
.   >?@ 4 6
*
/BE4 & !4 #  6
* $'
.6 (4 6  !  ?@' (   D +0  #
FG   
 & 6 FH B   8   
80!  6 ? /BE1 !
,6  F
?  6 I
1 +& ! %1 ) .D ! 6@ ! 6  ;
6
 'J
) :    I
5 04 >' 9 , 4  4 6   4

4  9 F; DE 6 >)


1
FG   !1 2 4 ! :1  4 ."D $
! $! +   +4:1  4
7!  !1 92 #>@ 9  9 >$
1
: 7
 3 4&
 +0 #6
1 2  7E  .F; %  
.$':  %) (  )   E    ' ,
 :
 +?1

9    BE 6 6  ; +    ) /   5%1 K% 
.6  :   )
L@  #
 'J  
    5  +)1
4 6
1  
.B    A  !
5 ,  2  %  !   F; = 
1
4
MN0   6 # (   (B  6  '  A!
2
3 '1  A!  +  5E  (: ) ,   BE
4

 'J
 BE DE /6: O MN&$!
4
1 6   )$ G -4

.26
/1  
98

.251
/2  
99

255

              .
*"  (1930  )   
% &'  " (  . ! " #$
. +, -/ &# 
0
" 12 3   ,  4/ ( &5 6 1
6 1 ' 9$ 6 '  .' &8  7(  4/
 '2  ,/' 68"  =0 ' " >  " ::  
 1 02
C, 5" : @ &"   8A 8'   1 1" B" 8 "
" 44    ,
 6/ & *" 9  ."E0  E' :
,D
:&0  9' 
 E'
&'  ,=
  * :
D C, 5" :F @
 6/ 

5 , -( G ,*
 C/ 0 A'" :
" : @ 3/" ' ."' 61
@'0 " ,0  44  +/" ."5 !' :
 ' &5    "
100
."+
0  0 I  
/' 2 ,=/ =1H 3 

@
 8  ,69LJ   1"
 6/ K  &70 6 1
C4/H 69LJ ,
  .0" &
 ' M , G ' 6/'N  
 &' =/ QL' O 
 "  P'  
 ' I9 
101
, 3 .9
 
 K@, 9 &'"  C
  64' 0 1> E
/  6  
0" 8  -1" ,  60  R9'  '
: 0" 8 L 
&H
.0/ 8 
1>     "
6 -#  M0 ,H$1 C," 6  S &  &0" G , 
" :! 9$ 3
' T05  #  L "H$1 3' 5 & $1 

.286 285
/3  
100

.286
 
101

256
102
"
   
Elizabeth    ! ,      
/0  * + -. )'$     #$ %  &'$ ( )Monroe
&  .9 : - + -' ; <   ; .12 34 56  &+7
:   -(= 
!. ! .  > ? @ !     . 
: 6  ! ( . + B  ( )>$ 6$  > 2 ,A
103
 6 . ? ."5! ! ,#'6 '! 3 9 :  D $"
 > G$ ! H– 9 @ <% E  >4F 9 >F  $ >4
Arabian Jubilee ,"9 +'" Gateway of Islam
 #+7 >  !
!   /K . '!L J I.."54+ B 9 /  (","  "
6  566$ A : -/  >$ 5$   A!M  .- 5$$
:   . O '% . '6  ) agnostic '.  !  =
/ )H' . '. @(   % 5 #'6 E = 6  .(> 
   : G Q .5'       ! )A :
 A!M    R  )>  >4F >F. /2  9 '
7 S   :S. 5

: > $ F >4  . *  .> +
  J D'!  > FQ .' H J 
 S . ,5$ 5  > 
T' :   '  ,5! M ,59 #' ,'$9 ,>'."J
4 R 4" 7 K 'F >. A'. ' .";2$.  =M  5 544
>F  @  <LF' . >= ' )  F 'F .9   "+7 

*!  >+' ' 5=S M >. ,59 +7 @%U. >. )9
5 (&6 . ) #'%   @ ! 9 >F  @ -4  .

.195
/2  
102

.164
 
    103

257
:1930 
15  
     ! "# "!$ , 
    
" % "&  '!($
*+ $% ! -.$ / 
0 1(!2 1
& 34&  # *#
:3$ 1
& ;< "$" 15$8 9# & .5 %6*
 A $ .! "& $ % %  @?5 * "!58 > % # 9= 
104
.B
+ 4 "!! 2< ,*+ "& #& B# B 2 "!!< .  4  *+
:3$ "=& ;< C. 9#$
*# ;= * H($ #   ,(?! ) 3$D
?! B C*E 9!# 
B=%
I*  ;< " ! $ ,*+ C4
$#  88  ;!* .$#  >5
105
. "& 3$5 94 
 < ? *+
( ( 1!6 1 3$ >#$ "*
0 = "=& ! C4
#$# #  *#
."8* L" Baghdad Times 5 "& K! & $
=$ $! * ,J"
3*4
"& 1 * "& 1&  1! 2< , * J" ?= 34M $ "=& 3*D ($
:& 3( "985 5<" Egyptian Gazette $ " "=" Daily Herald
 *$ %N* * '$! 1! ;= "*
0 "(%+ A! ;< A! "!!<
 $ O$8 ? "& * D "& *4 9#$=
 ;< ?# A! *# ,D
*  5 ;< I  *+ P  J!+  *$ > $
E "$$+ "(%+ $! * ;( ?  ! ;= P*4 4 9(%+
4 85 3 ! H* "M 4  - "!<   "!!< .D
* ;=

.169    


   104

.  105

258
106
.  

  
    
 !"
+- ,Donald Robertson #" " 
$" %&  ' ( ) * &
 7"8" ,' 4 " 5    
6  " :"  ,/( ' 0 1
2 #
&
A;?5 *$
4 (
?) 
4) >
? =
6 +- - ;< #  984
107
."('$
- >"(?
 D6   6" 7
6(  /- # C
 '$) )
# " , 4$)  "  =4  " ,5 F G
$ ,E""
7
A;   + - J
" I;< )  "6 (  &"&H

& I'
1$ ?K  6 G
$   '
 F"  4$)  ' "  # 4
/-
1 A  L ?K ;
 7=
 %"= &  & '$ H #
#6
 
 6 =N 5   - L I
M *5 (?H 
1$ 4"=
&6 ()
$ 0 $ 
$" I  >;?O ;< $    #
& -)

4 P
 # " Q

&$) #&    6 G
$  - L" I5 -  2
$
/- 1 Q;<" * /
4 ;R 'A
$  7    7

& 
"6 N
;<" * /
4 D & C " S
  C '1A" # 4$ ,'

& # 6
A # E
 6( "
6 4 SA" '6 6 N A #6 G-  6
 $ #  D6 ';) # " ;  + ,1933 ""  .;<
#""5 T 2
? 
1 F 06(  
A D6 Q  #J 4  4$)
.4 $ G #
 
& $  # $  ?  " ? #-U #)
#
&6"
"     
   G  4 ...4" J

"     " Why I turned Wahhabi St. J.B. Philby  
106

.1930  26     Egyptian Gazette


.170   
  107

259
 !"   #$ % 
  
 
   ,
)!( *+ -  - / 0   & &'   -  & .&'( #$
 4  5 + 3+"  ( 3 - 1 &  #"+ /12 3&"
 < 0  +  - !#-   &8   9:  67   0  )  
108
.#   0  &8   @? =   > #-  
0 >  ,#  #-&  <  < &  & + B:  A 
)
8> #  + *  F> # G 
  = &:     DE$ C
  ,1$ # # -  J-2  - " .$$ 9H 5 #  #-&
109
3 +) 2 + 30>   @ ."
 J-2 + 5 9 + :9(>
:+  59(   + &(-   #& E
)2
 A  -  < <&8 J   MN  8 5+$  L&...

 *'$ 


! $  51'  & &G J =G  #  # 
E&G0+  J2 9 @#  *' N O # E&' *> 5  @&2   
110
.<  9$  #&
#!& #H #1 *+
00  59( "+ -"
N8 P- #& - 
3 - G + A- *>
+& 3!( N @3& E& :  #2  &&$ 3
&( 5$  = 8 #!& # - - @  5 5"2 F & Q >" :5 $
 -  *  T P SJ M$ 5 @  #& =H R   #8:
111
M   "&" ""  +-  & '
(   B'  > T"  &

RCAS "
 " Mecca and Madina St. J.B. Philby  
108

.508 1933   20 Journal


.513  
 109

.517  
 110

.33 1938 !#   $ ! "


     " 111

260
.         

!" # $% & '()*   +    


 
6 $ 7  4
 " !% 5 $ ,"012 / ) '()* -"
= $()* ' 12 : 8; < ) +  4; :   8 & 9
 $ 7 '!1 >     .#7  $%  7   
'()* =  - &)% '()* /  %   8 ?
%(2
 2 =# $% $ 7 -2 =%  $% & . 2" =
:-# %(2 = - @ )
' C  - ) >; B -  7 4
B :-#   
'()* $% F ...D B '()* ' ## $% #%  7 E# $D
,-=% 
4D   ') $  G B H  ? '()*% @=# 8 $% F 
= !/ # 1 &6 -#   72 = $% -9 G  -
 -(#)?  #    8! ? ,$) ' 1 )
J:" J: 2 B ,-  G12 ID E  2  # .()*
 $% %(2 E
!  7 ! ! +  7)%  7)
L=2  4) '!1= '/  @ /  CK  '()*
112
.   '()*   $% -?;M

.'()*    $%  +  ( N!")? >; $1
 ? 4; D  O # F J:H '()P    M% O$1 ) 
#7 '()* B H  /
$% -D  & ?
?B O7 -"  'K/
B $ '  ')# &)  % ; @  B 17 =
 $%  )    OQ2D  !   - R2 
Q2D  !(H  QB $#
 $2 H   
. K/ '()* >/ 1   '!1    ) 

  " Is Islam Ripe for a Caliph? St. J.B. Philby 
 112

.669!# 1938       "  

261


# " !       


  
."  "  - , ) *!+   (  &' (  %"$
2 # -!  -/ %
 - ( 0 -  1  
-


 3 $) #
' 2 ' %$ , -
3 + &) $ # &'
.33 - ! !  ) 
4 30 % %!+ -  
9)   3   &'  -   567 -+ - #8 &)
:  ; # + - ! -+ <(! )!   #+ 6' %9(( 9)
.:  ?  - 9 (! #  5 #> - %  -) 0= 
#) =  3 &) 4@ 3+ $ < 4  >
+ -   )
-! 7 
 + 3 $  4)1  ?= - 933)  %1
! 2  30 $' 3 6  3 A -+ 6' .$ # A 
 # 0  &' 3  $  % + $ # -)
)C = - B33 B33)  : -+ 8 %9)1 <6 (!  -!
.#
  3F 
3 3 6 07 5 E   D1 4 $  !
 #2 42@ @: -  G=  H &'   -
+ 3( %; ?
.- -( 4 3 ) ?  -( @: $ # &' # 30' # - 
) @: -   -!  #2 7 4
 3(
$ - - ?  ; -)   4 6  C 33 -
9 % ;=+ - + $ J    $= 3) A ; -
K I$@F 
.# 3 &) 5 3 # -
# * -L ( # ) - 33   &)
31 3 ! $  "D3 - )" -
# 2 $ #@F -+ ; &' 1+

262

       
        .
. 
  
 
! "# $
!    "  ( 
(  )*   
 '  & %&
"1 23 45 
 !  
 ! 0 
  
 +, -
/ "&*

 ';  
     : $ . 5 ( 8 9 
#6 7 *

   !    
6 =  & .7
 2< 
 *
@ ? & 
6 & ) >< $ 2< 
*  
   
*< '  
  3
2 ! 0 23 B  " ! A#(  3 5( 0  $#6 @



6 !
* +, &   2 0 C 4
* & ( 7 "$6
. 
(
6  5 ! 56 E7
  2( "6 "& ! 5! 0 D 

 7 * G ;(  2< * 5F< < "=   <   &
. ( ( + *
$  
6 6   
 ' +
  &  "  H! %&

*< '  


 "# "&&  
 &
  $ . C 3 5! &F(
F!  (L) 0
&  - (7) 0
 (() :  
*  
   

( ! 
 ( $ . 
6
/ @5  
#M G ;( 
F P 3 !  < 9 
 & 0-
O ! -
! 
&  NA 23
 -
 9 "   F 4 *& 23 %&   F 0F
"  ! . 5 

3  ' -

; +
  4$ $ . 5! & #

< ! ( 
= ; #  
5 C;( 
) # 
 5!( + A#3
23 -
; "= ;! " = 5 < 2<   Q9  
! 5A(
.

  * 7 *
R 5
/ < C< A# 7
  
  -
/  & 0% '
0 
  5 !   5 09 "O 0     $
*

$  2< 0  &  . &
( 
 096 
!(  & %&
263
   !  
   
  
  
&)* + " " # , -     (    %& '
 $ " # 
 (  0 " 12 
/ $ "  &  " ) & . #
"7  "4 %89   : "3 "  ! . 5 (3 41 3
/# (  .!  -  ! &)*  & 8 ;!  ( &
-  
< ! 5 
 "# "  #  #  #3 & /*
  ,3   .  ( @ ? & +1 >
  
"3 *=   &
&    & # "3 &
  "7  "4 <A 3 "!3 " $)7
 5 FG &#  
DE  "3 7#  0  C 8 ## 4 &B
#+3 
43 3 " 0 ( .7  +  # & < 
" 
&
" H1 7#  3 8@ > >)* +1 
    & # "G
" 8@ < ! +#   I#J A  #
)  +1 &     !
.&
 
 A 
" > $+4  3 8@ 
" I KI1 " 0 (
 ) <#  " 5 , + >
 N  L M&
-  -  
 L
 ) &: -  ( @ "    %89 " L .    #3
K  :1 B
 ! 4 .
/4  : & "
 " 5 8 

"  /   (7# :
( @ 
 3   +  )7 : & & 
" < ! -  ."#=  / 89# " N1 &   @   "3
& ,
 < ! " $+7
 *3 %& '
 /B3 :   %89 K:
 B  7 " *3  +  B  !3 & 7 : "3 F#
&  
#8 *
 )  &  #  
 1O P# < . I#=
." : "   3 !+
MB4   7 I 3 "   N! #  +Q1 4
"  /    B  7   : ( @   N! " .3 &B+ 8 L
264
     
      
 .
(  1! *( ! +,-  /0 &( )"!# " $  % & '! 
4!! %565 - 3 !  & %! .(&2 0 -  $ !
9 68 /
( (  "  *,6 /'7! 
! 6 /'-,
0# ;  6$ /!
 < -   1 !  .  : '
  1 ! $ .<@ 8 #! /' 6 ( %!& ?6 / "$ 53 =>;
(&2 B-
A7#   5  2   '  
  / !
 &(
 ( .2,2 - D59 +C9 (  (  ( BC '(
 3  #$ /'$ &&- &!  ! (   ? %B($ ; ! 8
 ': /'C9 C( ./'! /'6C$ & *&    - /  '  C!
   !   - 
 +- 53 @5   " 5 
./ 'C ' !  2 * 53  6 !! ! ( 
3 %C!   
3
- 
70  / H- )E F    /'!
3 G(  -   
"!" +C I$ @!8 - D59 
> *C# D :-, .0 $
( - .%( - ( K (   '! #8  4! 
' C# 
./'
/'&
2M 
 C& $ !   %( 
  L>#M! I 
& K 6 ? $ 1  $ H- *( *! K + /' !6!
."-$ D B ( /'- 6 6  6 $ ! 6
7
%#! % = 6  6 / /'( /' /',6! />C 
)/'$ /'&
 * $  !
     
5 +& B
 "M! /,68   &( .I#  6 ?  66 NF  /2 
$ @   . 1 > *7, "   (> +& 
/70 17@
$      "0 &C 1 6(   6  ?B> 3  
/' % " 0 .- *

!$   % < 66; !6  %'
H- O- 7#! I  ( > ,68 !  6; K& D 6 - 

265
  ! "  
        
0)& 1 ..! -(  #! #$%& '(   )*  +  , 
2  3     #$%& *2 
+ 4 5 6! (!
  4  5   ! ) #1* 8! -6 7 1!
2: ;1  8!  (2 8  ,  *2 . 95
." * !" .!
- &  ,  $?  24 A.@ 
+ >? @      = >(2
* 7  21   5 * .* B    2 "C >(2
." *& ! >(2 2  & )* 5  0) . (  *! 6*
. *! .: ,* #  7  .* 
 1* *  2 >(2   #$%& 
 8 8 ? D
? .
+ *  #!  F* F"     &  E(  
H! , B*  *  95  A
1 A  #$%& ,? >  G)  )
#  F  A (   
+    = >(2 )& .* ( HJ I(
  24* , (2 B* !  F -) 7 8! .:  &
KI5 .
+ *  76 *C G 5  B A(1    
" I 2" "8) *  "  *C 1 5! 8     
B* 92
 H! >(2    -) 7   $? "8) I"  " "
4 =  2 *  (*"  * *2  . ?  ,
8   , !  * " F *   E  L  * **
  G - &   )?  FB  ( "*("  ,(*" I5  .
! , G) B* * 8M #$%&   -) 7 .
+ * !
7 N * .&@ 0)& I4  >? 5  ( = *  )& 5 
.*   6O
F*    0*! ( P ;*5 E *  O 2 &#O ;*15 "
266
!        .         

- ) +/ -0  1 2 3 / ) '(  )* + ,  &"#$%
/ 7  /0   "/  ) 5
 56$ '  ,  &) 4 
80  : )* 8( 9 !  4/* )  .) 3 ( 7 ,6 

  , :      9 ! )/ * ,/<    &"2 >2  
" ;<
.  , :  2/ ?! ,  >;   A  .? @0 
!  2 ,<  
 # 4  2  !0  B  )#! 
##$  "
+;  * D4<  ;< 5   C B #0  &4
.!0  "  E  0 )*   46  
3 )F0G   ,H >; )*H I; 9 5 " < E 
)* 5M! "1 L! +<  , JK ( ."
 5/ ,6 ,/ ) ' 
)* '  <E / 5 0 @ '( -
 3 9 &5 F0G 5 ! 5*H K(
) 5 % ?!/ ! 5*! 5 3 3( - ) &5 ! '

- 
  &<  .4F0G 8 / 4<0 '* "09 9 !0 -
! &' BM &5 ! H &3 ! -M )/  #  5 " <
.?! A 5
 5 0  -*  &- 


 5# , < &-F ;< 3H  )! 4! '( 9
(   < 9 ' 9 EO P  &3 5@6 5  N 500
-;/ )* :Q  )< ' / '  5 Q - P  &  / 5 0  5!/
;<     .0/   !6  )*$   P  &5 0 
3 ) ,    H  3  &)! 4! B6   R/$ '(
;<  S 3(/$0 ) &)! 4!/ 5! '( 9 .  EF 
&>  &)0  ;; ! &- 
 ! '<E , 0 B  )< &?
T     &50 % )* 3  0 )F -<! &-F /$
'( ;< R/$  .0/  4<  /!   &T% &
267
 !" #$              

 
 * +   )  ( ) %&'  
  )4 )2
 0+ .0+ )1 %& 2 , ' -. /
09 : ,2 ' :2  #  %0  -2 -  ' "0*" ( 674 5 
=2 $" >2 )&
 ' '0<   24 *   #0 &' ;0
0+ #& 6 .-. /  @5  0  6 90 )0+ 2 & ?-. /
 %&' $  A1   
  & ?7  2 -',  00 -0+ -
)1 B 1" -  #-0' @ 2  B,   
 
& - #. / 0 =  +  1,  74  #00

2 !  - C 
   2/ -   00
-  CD
.,7   )* 

268