Вы находитесь на странице: 1из 37

...

·1-

,_ .

...... .... . . '-"-T

~'~"""'I!"'"_~~rr~

'., I'

BaAHII BQnO~apCICHH

'.

.' ,

'.

:.1

<' .

. '\.

, ,

"1 "J: »,". .: : ...

; . ), :-:'. '. ~'.:'" .:;: .. (.~-~ i:-;'~:'

• : •• 1 ..... '1 ~':~:~.:

- "';o'L, '~-:..

.. !. - "'~" ":",~:

... !:::., -: ,'!j:;.:;. :

.·.x ....

'. _. ~~I' t:

I. '0:" ... j."

.... 11.11'·' . - - ... - ... . '':: .

i' .

.. ~ ::.

!J.. i ~_I.

,~- I

' .... 1. I

Coset» ·:1·.·· a-II':· :·8' ,O····.····K·,-·"·:·-a~;' .. e

. _ .. , i. .. .. 1'1 ..

. - .. - . -

I'~ '.

1; •• ·.-

'.~.

.. ' ... ~~:.' .. ~.~ .. ~ ..

-,.'

. ~ .. \. _

-, _ ,.~

- 'i_ •

--=..:.~-:.~

..

- 'r.--'

~ -'.

,

or 06BIIIHeH141i1 B HapyweHlt1l11

npasan nopcxsoro ABvt)KeHL4R

.'-.

.. r I ....

.. ,_ ....

"

, -,

, ' .

. ',

_ 'fi"1 -.1. ... ~ ...

' .. ,-01:'.

_~ .

. .

....

. ,

• 1

, ..

'.: . I·...... I·~.r_

r-

.1.- !'P'

. -

'I'

,

_, .

r '

......

K:HeB 2,0'01,2"

\

_~

.. :,'.

..

1

. ,

.s

'.'

.~' , ..

.~

'-., .:'''-

..... ~.:--~--:.,

• .' ".' 'i.

..

__.

, .

..... I ..

~n.,!.~ .. <.~ ~ ,::.:. ' .

~~ .- ..

.....

." '. . - Y,UK 34·3.34·6.2

_ :.- .

. ~B"K" 3"9'''' 8:-' 0" 8;

. ",. . .', u ...•.•. ,:, ,', ,; ... "'.' c<,

" . "

:"'. " .. ' B,68,

t: -, -..:, r-". .. ••

I - .' ~

- I - ...

~., '. I

- . ,

". .

. . . .

, . .

.. .

.' . ... ' .

• - •• I .,

«:AaB.OKA'T'J

06' f..ijHaHHf.i~aJlBOKaTiB

. Bono,..,pCb •• i 8a,. •• Jleo '~i,,.o ....

~

r , ,aASOKaT< ~ '.

C~dlLO,I.U'80 M 1'01,8 Bill Ul .... l 1. 1900 p:'

,. .. ..,/ /(pUMinaAbHi; aiJMiHicmpamU8Hi 1M tfU8iAblli cnpoau ~ ,

../ nTn B'u AlYUDLJ'J..J'('J m'a' ,0; 6', '''. ." ., , ,,'"'' , .

I • ,".,' ;u;,j",~ I" .~. tw~~'t'~~ "', ~a'opo'Ha elGCnAyamaijll, mpaflCtW,pmHUX

I, 3aco618~ AtOjICAUBtCmb ,Haoalf.HJl mepMiHoBo-i KlpuiJUttHOj'i)onOJIJJeU

;~ '. ~'HIl Micqi noiJii 3 yiAiWciRlUUt yeoiJu 1ttlnoiJaJlbUJe8~eH,H.1l ~npll8u

,:;>., -,/ AemoPcbKtnpaoa ma in. :;,... . r ••.

~.'. j

_.

. . I

. .

. .

:. :.. • 1:-. • .~~ .

.... ,J .

I •

.' . .:1,.'. .

Y'KpalHa" :~1004',.M~ KMlB,' LJepIB'O"'Oa,pMiM.~bKa, 35 ' .. ".

_ ,_, T'e,D. (044,) 2,2'1-!4'9,~,. MI06. 'Ten'.f2~37'~,3j'85, .

. - . . . -

__ _ _.J1 _ ! 1

, ..

,

" '1

.; .

"

• • • • .. ' .' - ',' I', .. fi.

. . ..... ". .~ .. '. .,{:. ~ :,~~.

.' ... : ..

. . .' ' .. "~ .~/¥

. . . ': '. ': .. -i-'¥

- . . ~

.'. . .",

'3

..

.. 1,: ~'~:

.' .' ~*

. :. i:.

. ~ ;:\

.';'~?(

.' I I I,

I '.~

... '. - " .,.~.

. ". , .. j:.-

.. ,.I. 'i- ~!.

. i"!-"--(

,I0I0, • :::Z:i:i:::r: ~ _

.. 'L "Y-

. <i

" -

. .;".. .' .

. ."

·-r.i,:

• " ~.. -!P. -_._ -EEiiii£T.

.'~.

,~, -.. .. "'_.' _'. .

.,~

. .

: '. ;,

',,','

. . /

".- ,~

'. ~~r~f

..... ~

:~':"~ .. d

'F 'J(_:

'~$

. ~:

. . '.'

. '<fi '~'.;:

• .. I,rtt"

· ._.,'.

.. ~ -

. , ..... ~

. ,.,- -,?~~.-- .~.{

, · .. c· .. .- --~.;.

r .. ~ 'II

1 .' L~"

.. ~

. __ , - ~. ~. . .

• ", -'j .

.. 'I,"

. " ..

,I" I ••

II I, ~ • '.

· .. I

. .... .' . p-fl

•. ,' •• j' . · .... r~

. h-;_:H~

.{

. 'I ~ ·1 '.,..

~~~~~f!~~ .....

. - ,,_.

. ,""

I '. .:' .> .~;r

' .. -"':'~:,. ~ :~,: ~. ~. ' - .... .. ..' . .-"

... : ~~i~~.l§:i:. ~ .' "J-14

_ Texa OTBeTCTBeHHOCTH38 napymenaa ruui '_'·O.D,H8 K3 ca.MhlX «6onbHblX» N. . .:' ~~

.. aCTO OOcy.>K,ll.aeMblX MeJIQJY Bq.lJ.HTeJlHMH. Ii onsrr TiI.KOro «He<POPMaJIbHOro» o(j~·· ,"

lUeHHH. H aonpoca, 3weaeMbie 8STOPY 3THX crpox BOJlHTenHMH·t npHwen,iuMMH' ,

a81OpH,ll,HlIeCKOA KOHCYJIbT3ll,HeA, It CHTY3Il.HH, nOq'fHKaJKAbIH pal B03HKKad.uHe·· . ~:~

npa Bea,eHHH AeJl, y6e}K,ltaIOT: H aaKOH(WiTeJlbCTDO, pery.RHpYlOlUee ccj)epy- IJ.O~ ; .~

poxaoro .lI.BH>K-eHHH, It co6CTBeHHO Ilpanaaa He «pa60T3IOT» TaK, KaK MdrJln6b1. ' .~

«l1c,K8>K'.eH'JfH H ne,perHrJ'bI» npoacxoaar xauie sccro He :8, nOJlb3Y BOltHTeJ)a~ .

~pHqHHa npocra - 38KJ1lOqa.eTCH OHa B TOM, 'ITO 60JlbllJlHHCTBO yqaCTHHKOB Jl.B,:HJK~HHRH xaome COTPYAHHKH rA'H He YMetoT' npaaansuo IIp':HMeHH,Th, HO'PMbI

38KOHOBH nJlll. I

KO,Hf!'lfHO, ,CjOJ1bWHH'CTBO BOA,HT,e'JleA ,M H:Hc:neKT'Op, 'OB lJHTaJlH: ,nnn' H MO'nrr B:' <

, ryr. "-\I ','''r/'''''-

CJlyqae ocrpoa Heo6x'OAH:MOCTH, n',p,Hn:o,MHHTb COOTSeT"CTBYJOw.ae CJlyqa,1Q nO'Ji'O-

,)KeH,H:R -- :UJIH pa.3b1CK8Tb HX B H3,BJ1:e'QeH,HOH 83, KapM8H8 6po,wlOpe,. npUq'eM.O,H:H coaepuieuno ,H.C,KpeM He 'Cq"HT,a,IOT" 'ITO sroro AOCT8TOl.fHO He TOJlbKO' JlJ.lH ytB,eplK'''; 1 .u.eH"fI: «SI 3H81O Ilpaaana!» - HO H }l,lIlR TOro, 1JTOt>bI HX "paM,eHHTb. Me>KAY T,eM", HeT H,H'q'er-o 6o.ne.e A8neK,oro OT HC,TH'Hb1~ Ilpanaaa 'MaJlO He T'OJl.b,K,O npO'II,H'"" 'TaT:b, :HO A8>KC B'blyqHT'b H8H3YCTb. '4T06bI sepuo npHMeH,HT,b ax ,HOPMbI H apry .. MeH'T'HpOB8H,HO sa"'llHlU8Tb,CSI aa HI ocaoae HY>KHO HSyqH'TbCSI' 3H8JlH'3Hpo:aa,T,b

".

,Ka,KHe npasa H,MeeT COTpyAHHK r AVI,. 'O'CTBHOB,HB,[UM:U 3BTO,M06H,J1b?' MOIK,eT'

nH '" 6

BO)lHTeJlb aaununarsca 'OT He,O';OCHOS8,HHblX Q,60HJleHH:r.t B ynpaaneaaa

Tpa'H,cnopTH~,M CpeJtCTBO:M B He,Tpe3BO:M 'CO'C.TO~IHHH·,. npeaumeuaa 'C:K'O,P'OCTH, Hapy~eHHM npaBHJI npoeaaa nepexpecrxos H neweXQ.D,HMX nepexonon? ,KaK. BQ.C.IlpenH,T-Cl"BOB,8'T.b HenpaBOM'e,pHOMY 3an,peTY 3KcnnyaT.a.~H" ,3BTOM'OtJH.JlH :no TeXHHqeCKOMY 'CO'CTOflH:HfO?

OrB'e-T,M ,H8 3TH Ii :M:HO.rHe. npyrae aonpocu npeanaraer 80TOP 9TO:H KHHrH.

•. I ~ . I •

• ~.... : r .. .: .. 'I

.' .

\., .

..;~

, '

... -. :._ ...

" ..

,

I! •

• i"t1"r? I

-..... - ~ - - .-..

. . -.. ..

. '

.... :.;... .~, ...... . .

. ~

r'n' 11"'88[--' '4

I ';,'. ['" I' • ;,1

-, .~, - - 1 "-?'-

'» - ....

~: J'- -i . I ••

,,:' I I -,

: .

,· •• ::·· •. :;··'0····,

, . - '. ~- -. - -, . - - . -

• , ' F 0( • • l' • - ~ ':

:, :. , ""'.~ ~ . l

I).. • -. r

~ ....

• II··

• I : .~. "i ...... ..:. _.. : ~ :'1 .-.:..._.

... .-:l-..... I

.. i .1;·

__ ' ,I~ _11--

.. _::-1

i \!!..:_ I ¥

I

.;; .. ,.,.'1Il

..... \...

.: II ~, -

, . . .

,

~ . -: r: ~. .. .j

. '

,: "; ",,:':: :.:'/; "C· ..\".;1

I ~"... •• • -. :til!

I.. I:"·": Ej'· .\~ •• ! ..... ' .. ~~.I I :·r~.

. '.!- ~ ~ ,~::,!;;.;,f . . , . '.'

l '- ..._ , '.. !",'., \', .• ~-;. .' . ~

• I - ~..~. Jo •• _ •••• -: .... -... • ~

, :-~I .... ·,!' ·' ,'.~'-:'_ . . . . . ' ....

. 'f ~~ r';.' ~. • .... .1,' "C '

• I ..... ~ ••• ~ .. r.~ II. ~.. .~I..· !II.... :. . -

. ,. .... . J

. "HiMetfuo· TaKC6TP¥AHHK rAM 9(iil1JHOOCTaHaBJIHBaeTTpaH~0" -; '. -:" :1

Cpe.o.CTBO. -BnpotaeM,-,cnoc06M6lKeT fiUTh H HULIM (aanpaaep, ;ne\~~:"; <~ .. ' ." ..•..• ?:

K, . 'or' '0": 'S' ~p.a.J'II'ie-)~~·-y. 'CT'-' "'8' 80· .' 'IBe')- 1'\JT,'l-o [0- iT' ,9~,oro He Me'H:R:'eTCll -'~ <, ;~~ '.', ;{~~.~;' ,~ .. ~~:_. "-..}

' .. __ .-V" ·cn~ n:- _, - .. " ,--.n -",'I' 'W'JJ.~IU '_'I oJ 'I , .' ' .. '''' . '.- oj .~? . '_" _\:.:!~~,<~~.~/_'.;:'" .:' .. /

.,. Beccnopao, lJoo.,WlUmfiCII. CtUHtulg 06 OCtlUJlW8.e.,ot:1 •• _.;:····_·· .'. "i

06JlSGII.. B03MC»KHOt' erooCT3HUJtHsalOT He All" OIPopMJleilu H_~", : ,; .'. .::

, .. = .... - -:: ••

... ~ ........ .):. . ... ,

"M:H~R, a C 'APyroA IltlJtWO" aanpaaep, 'Y,Ka38Tb, HS' 'HeHcn,pa8\HoCT:b·,"He-,.~: ~ '. ~r t ":' .':;,

~opmo~- cPeJl.CTBs(cnymeHHDeKOJIeCO H r.n.) HJI.H n~~~J~~,' . "!

enepe.u.n )lopora S3KpMT8 Mil '.ABIDKeHHA ••. OJlH8KOB8lKUO '388'11(,.11)14, .• . '. /

Po -:.._. •

QTO: :M"QiKeT' ~~n:[pOH.'CX!QJlHTb AMbWe ~ " .~, .;~~~ '. '. 'I' . r :' I Y, •

:.:. ·n--:: 2"~ I Il nny" 'C',"T' a aa en· fJ;,B~ a: e T·· nepe .. q"! e H" b·· n·O'['I(\IMeH7·:0'B'. K~n"p,.~~t.g.'_fn .. ~:~riIO , ..

, . ~ It_ ..... ~:. 1'111'1".',.""." ,-,..,." ,~.Irr,.'J ., .. ., ._V;-:III\II ~~.uU,n

98R HNeTI) npH'ee6e BOJtHTeJlb. 3TO - BO]J.HTeJlbCKOe YAoetO.e,eH¥e.:·'·

• IL .. • • ......... • 1:';

C .. 'TaJI,'O HOlM K :'Ut!M,Y, 'pe!rHCT,paU'HO'"HHllI,e J10'KYMe:H'T'~ :H8. T'p\2lHC:n~'flIT:H.e ~

cpeJl,CTBO, a "PH OTcyTCTBHHCo6cTBeHH:HKa-BpeMelf~:A perIlU, .. QHO:H,H'blH T,aJlO·H HJlH'-£,suAeTeJlbCT:OO ,0· npaae 'CO'.BMeCTHoi· 'Co:Q~T:~;eHHoeTR. ECJiH.~·' S:8,KliW'1e,H ,AOr-O:B[Op _ CT,pa:xoB,aH~H'H,. '~paHtUJHc,~ail' ,OTB.e,,·C1:seH:HOCT:ilr, 'BoflliTelI,b JlOn>K.'e'H' HMer,b npa ':ceOe H '&f.£)· .: ·,~oM,e· roro, II ycraaoaneanux aBKOHOM c.nyqaHX HE!·o6XQAt!lMO. u.e1lt .1!I.y~

rue .o.OKYMeH'TW (nyresueaacru, p,OKYMeHl'bI HI rpya, ~p~ruMMe

:A'8 cneucaruaau, corna C'O[B,3H He: na p[a,~:M,le:Llle.'I;iHYIO peuBMy,:.·J a~~l.Y MBpwpyra If pacnacanae .D.BH>KeHHH If r.n.) nepelJHClliITbaJJ.~<;b.,'DCe

/

.. , -..:'

,(

... I" .

I· • •• J

. J

• ._ • • • .. • I •

-.; • ; I

·1 ' ...

. , .

-:'I •

~ .

;.' ...

I _ .

I. !

1-,;. •

,

. ~ .

,

. .

'-:- '. ~ . ,

01., ..

. ~.

1 • ;

" .

< '

•• I .... r· ...•

~ -

-'Ii •• I,:.:' • .1

. !

. . ,

. ~ .

r

.. ~

.,;

' ...

-:' . }_

·l

~.

-,

I· ...... -... • ,... •• ..

" .

I i i

~I

_

i!

'.(

: .• i

•••• -: , •• _, ~ ""<,,, •• ~",. .:: "~7 'i~'P' '!- \\ .;:' ,~ .: " ;-. C>;i

'; .r:', - , >':: ;:<;:/::\,~,;;_~:.i·:-i

. . _ '-i' ~. ~ _L r-:» • ~.'

. . . '. ,_.;.~: ". "': .:~f ,'~~. ~ '.'

, .' 7")· _,;"._.~ ':":\'~';~~.:. '.' .:-

".: .'. ,;:: (?: :''';\',. .:

. ~ ~ ., , .. :-,., ........ ,.

------.!JI!IIII!I!!!I!!!!!!II!IIiiIiIiiiiiiii-~IIIiiIIIIII!III~IIIII!I!!!II!II~ ...... _~~~~-II!!!IJ!I!I!!!III!!!I!I!!!II!II!I!IIJIIIIII!I~!IIIII!IIIIIIII~~-IIII!I!i!·!IiIIII·- --.!~. ','_ .;",=:':' ·.~~.~fl,_.'··~~·':

~- ~.. _ _I .. - .1'"-· - . . . 1 ,..... . -- - - __ .-r.~ .. . . - -.:. :~ ... : -, i: .... _: "--I·~ ~1oI,.~r~

. . '':_~ " "~:' <:» .. ~j:-!I~:..;-"I£ ,'. :l~

• ~ : ".. •• I •• I-.~· ~ \ • 1 •

MMeNno? (reM 6onee~. qTO,COr:~~CHO ~.~B» n*.!_~ n~~OAHT~~:~,::~',":j-~~:~:~

HMee'T npaso «(38.aTb. n.p.HfJ·8t;IY OCT8H:OBKH". npo8ep.KR~·'.;" ·oc~,'PT.pf.l\· ;~:~,_.~ .... i .: rpaacnopraoro cpep,cT~a.iJ.~HOCTHPlM JlHUOM, ••• a T3lOKe' eno 4J~f.tI:P:~:~-;~,: ~;: ":

Jnno H }J.OJUKHOCTh»,.) lit, C~iM'~TbCH HB,-n,.,? cr.1135lK!l.Da~«:O-; .J4f:i',j <_' LtHH·». K,aK np'a~BHJl~9i: '~tnOHH,B" . liTO HMeet- 'ieJlo C lJ.eJl,a'Ble·K~6·Mi':'-:·;:··~::"'····· .;':

... '. ,}_.l'~ .. :r..l_"- .. [J .,.~.. '. : ·.1' . ! .: ;-- ~,,:').L.o.?~":--'""~"'" -.

paa6H,p'alOlUHMCR11i.·g,aKOHax" 'H,Hc:oeKTQP c caaoro H,Bll,ana Ha:6it~p,aeT' :.\",/~.,' .. '," ..

. QI '< .. ' -' . . " . ' _ , ': '_'~'!:< ... ~ _.' . "-:.,'~!'" ~.

COBe'eM Ap-vrO,H r·OIf(pa3,rOBo~pil. "~. _. , , .. ':.' ..... _>,:.,. ".i;/.".,,::, .. .;' '<.

_ J~.. . .. ~ [ _ -. _ r .. '"_ .::- .. i :- ~JJ.-::t . ..":-...... .

KeT',8TH. C,Hir\laI.(HSJ~,~ ,,(j,8~a comp I~:' ··y,:rDuu" MUAU,IJU.U o,cmafl,o.,tuili><::~<·~·~~/-i;···;'·::i~·'~:~

. 'I' • J ~ ....,. _ "'l- ... '" ... ~ • '% '~~~

mpancnopmuoe cpedcmeo B CO()TB~T~TBHH C 0.2.4 nnll- ;3TOJ:1J~" :l'~i,1

cy' TU, poa aaiJen:Jlt:(J-HUJi /lo(Ju.mellJl, (asacmo -u nacca1lC~'_8'·:~-:.:.:':~~: .. :~'~~~ ~'S:I~'~

, ~~ ~t,- .... ,. .\"~). ~-4'"

. KaK nOKa33ijo shlwe, 'c'orpY}J,HHKH' MRnHl;\MHHMeIOT npaao npo~t~·< '~~;-:~')~!t

,!lOKY" ,MeH'TbI (:_Y,"C.xBHf;U3HTb, JlHt[HO'Ctb)' Tonb,KO' «nou noiiosne _" ", ,_,. .~,.~,~'~ .',', ':'t?'~r

- -, • • !' L J: r • ...:: • roy' .'1"'" -. rf. ... 1

8',e.·~,~Ule,Hu,u n:p~~ aljlo,Ha,p.~.'lUi-e'''".':u4,·.»_ (. IJ m.:~,. ,U ljap,.',y.weH,uu ._.'" . ~;.' :: .'. .. ~.

r: :1' . :~~."f:5t;.!-:~~':'.\~:;··.,;:.·:~~~<~t.~:··.~ .. ,

npecmytUeHuu).,9mo - OCH-0841tUJl OIiR saiJep:JICaItUJl.' . :::\~i,}~~

,M,o,rpeHHbI. 'e 3~KO:HOJlar,enbCTB'O,M .YKp',~HIi,bI·~ 3. Me p>K. '_ ~aH,He .~:. "1 ".: .: ~~_;.'. "~ .. ~ . ':~~

, ' ., .' _' ':-B

TOIJ,bKt? ltO£.T,a~eHHe. B opraa M;HJlHLt":U,~ ,B~n.b eCJ1H BOl(HTenb.n· " .. ~~:"."'.' .:'. ~':~;~

aa 06'hSlCQ:eHMB C ,l(H,CneKTOpOM IlRTbMIi"Yl\ TOT 3aJlep>KaJl. ero·'B~~:~'· _ ... ' .. :

~ -- .... ; _ .... ~j~' .,..,.. '.' "

na aro Bpe'M,SJ'+~. Bbl~J.~HIiJl nHq:HOCT~b (YAOCTO'Bep'eHHle ,H3' ,MeeT,e" lt9.~~~'f.t~~.~~-::; ,: .. :. :,.' :.;"

,n,RTb B ornenenae H'e3a'l.eM').,~ COCT',a'D.HJl MM'HH:,n'pOTo,K·o,n B CJI~ae,,~Ha~~~-: .. :::.-,~~' :v~' '. '.f·7

. - - .. ~ J: -~ ~.~ ,,'C.~Hi\~{f· .

llleHlUI-H OTnyCTHJI~.~' KaK BH,!J.HO,- «OCT3HOBKa» TpaHcno~ji~iti.-_'- :_:_::<'

[ . : ~ ': ~ .. ; ~.-~~ ~~:~:~. ~ .. -: :~ ., ;~-:

cpencrsa r~po~:c.XQ)]J:i:T B rex CaM,bIX .. cnyqaSlx, xoropuc rIO. at\,l<9r~~'~ __ '+:>~!?<' .;: j'-:' . ~.,

. . ." . = . ' . ". ~.?"~,, t,.,-:,v'1" '.' .. :.,.~

IOT·C·H ,O.CH'O,BaHHe;M ,NIH 3cmep>KaHHft. Bonee 'Toro: BOAHTeJJb·,,·. ~::ri)p.lft:e,;;",>< "~'::, .<'~."~

OCTaH,O~lIfJlH, BbI"YlI<D.eH-HaXOp.H~bC~. aa MeCTe, r)le aTO np9"~~<}-,,···':,_,{·_;~j 'CTonbK'O~ 'Bp,e'MeHH" )CK,onb,KIO _Heo6x,OAHM,Q aacnexropy .' AII:R B'b{,3~8e.8.HIi\' "::'.' "' .. _~, :.' ~

_ .. , -::.' ". i.. " '..... . " '. .; , <;~ .~ • :- .• {_: \ .: : . ". .".. .:

J1WI uocra (npoaepxa )J.OKYMeH.TO~)~ COCTa BJleHHH npOTOK.0JI8 'o.()~~~,<:;~: .: _, . J ':~

HflCTpaTHBHOM npaaonapyuienaa MT.n. To ecrs on 3a.nep,)l(aH t(a·~~::- .: .·· .::~

, '. , . '. . . ' , '.' ,:, ~·~·?r.,.'" .,' .' . . .1.

,M:ecre!O ,)1, no. OT'H'O'Ul~~~.1O K :He~y corpynnnx MHllHUH,H np~:Ha_"~)J~~ .... > ... ~~

, . r ":'HAA"" ~

:H:MeH:H'~,"Tle A~:H'CT,BHH" llJIH ccaepuieaas KOTOPblX no ,~aKOHY ,~Me~',~~Q:~,~,.·'. ' ,,:~

BO 3an;epiK8Tb rpa)KJl8HHHa. TSKHM o6pa30M, 1aK Ha$l;JBae,l(ag~~~~a-.· ~. ,4 H'O:BKa ,;rp:l-aH,cnop-,THoro cpeacraa: H no 'O'CHOS8Hf:lAM,. 'H:· no cymuoCrH' ' .~~

• 1 .... :i' .., . .... ~.... "I!tt -

jtRCT.B~A COTPYAHHKa MHJlHijUH coenanaer c nouarRel!.! sap,e: >':~~-;;:: '~. '. . .':

_ COfJlRC(10 n.5 cr. I I 3aKona«OMMJIHUHW», aaiJep3iC '.' .·.·jfJ.~41: . ,;

. '~i

HU.fUl~M;O"'.HLO~.mfJll'''ico n"o. Q,(l.p,eiJeAeHHbtM ,aCH"08~~,UJM.I), " .. B ... ,;~bJlH",;': te~ . . ~

r· .01,[ I . . 1 '. .:.

JI,HM U3 YJ(,BI38HH'blX ,9Jl;e,Cb 'O~CHO,BaH~~A nOAXOAHT TOlU:~~O, '~OA031?'~tH~H:e. ,a, :~

npecTyDJIeHHK anacoeepmeaae MMHHHCTpaTHBHOf'O, .np.§\BOJjap~~HA. 1':j

Bonee 'TO ro. " Il.I 11.2 cT,.2:6,2 Ko.A'O: npejlylcM,a'TpH,B~aer nepeseascay- .1

ltaeB,Kor,a.a 8JlMHHHCTpsTHBHoe 3Mep>K3HHe npoH3BQ.lJ.HTCSL QPf,a:aaMM ';

B:HYT,peH:H·:uX ,AeJ1,"TaK .B:OT,· T:8M qepHbl:M no OeJI~lMy,'~~3:blBa,e,TeHvf:~9!O" B

lfHCJle nposero, Is'a,iJe,n,.a,Hu,e np'ou38ot1u,mc~r_ IIpu· · '!1ap'YfIM!f:''!!U

_ y'. '.. ... ..... "1:. r-

,Up'a,8UA {JOpo3IC'H~a'':l,iJau.eHUA~ To ecrs, 'no eyra, '·HMee:r-C,H'_ J:1,pa:Moe

i .

YK8,3,8H,He, ~,'T-O np:HIfYAH'T:eJlb,:H,oe H,aX,Q>IS)leHHe BO)]}fT'¥ij :8 Y,K.a~a"H,~'QM·.CO·

'Tpy~HH'KOM· rAl1. :Me(;Te c. ,UeJJhlO O,QJop,MJ1eHH,H' T~lK~oro tla,pylU,e,~H,fI: K~K

pa3 :H npencraanset CO~,O;IO 3a)le,p,ma,HHe, .. < ~ . " _ '~"'., ,:' ~ -. ': .

s- : ; .... 1:. , .. ~ .....

,.

: . .

. • , .•••. ,. ~ 'Jf1i. r • .... ~:~.;~'foi;'<I'';::X"':. ·."r;;.i

. ..

.. . ~ 9:, .. , ';~:.;- ::;:.:/.~ll: /

'. , ,;",' _r' "; " ,'. ' , ~;.;..:<,'.,>:,;,#~y~,

- ~- • _. ._.. -- -- - - • • 1·· ... ' ..... :.I1..) ... .r-~ .... ·,I:...I: I'

. ... .. . ~ .. . . ... : ~ '.>: .::.~~. ~I ,; .::~.,.=". .. : ... ;:.~:.~ .; ; ... :<.

Jllftuh' OnOCPeJlOB3HHOe OTHO~~.tlK ;3SKOHY «0 MHJlHllHU» ,e~~':~~,1,;,,~:i'~)j», B8:?J(HOO o6CTmITeJIbctaO~> 13 :n~~O.IHbfX nonO}l(eHlfJlX 3aKOHa:'«Q~~r::~~;;i'i:,~:{; , .: ceRMR H3MeHeHHH H aolii~Jtidi,8 ~~.~» qeTKO }'K33aHO '(ri~2.~~~8::\~YX',;,:~::

. «38KOHbI H Hable Hop.t.iflHbleaKTbI,'~HTbJe ao Bcrynneinlfr'.~~':"~?~i:,'::: 3TOro 3aKoMa ,_icf~TB,,'qacTH ' 'He' QPeTHBopeqam.eA_'I(oHcTi"" •• f''if>;':>,;

YKpaH~bJH 3T~K3aKOHY». 3~eCb~:~b,ae TOJIbKO 0 CT8POft'~Kt5:'~~$,?i:;~'" Yf1KHOJ4lotkhl~el'3aKOf.Jax, peryjf~Bmuinoc TaK WI" HHaqe'3arv.'t~f~t''J:E:;'t'J rue '~08~"'~kOHOM c~ephl. n()ro~:nOnO>KeHHH' 3aKOHa<d),~~"'.+;'-?5P~

. .., .; .:"." , 't" '&."~J ,.. . . ..' ~ -, : .{ .... :..' = , .. ~::~~ .. ':";.":"J.~:i,~/

~Hii», :n5!~'9HOMY peryJlMpOBaBwHe,'~B qg'CTHOCTM, BOn-POCbI OctK~~~~,::~~r 'il~

B·Hec,~ltH,EiM H3MeHeHHH· B Ynl( CJ1:~trUeT np 'H3·88T'1) yrpaTHBUlHMH·:' c.~~L~~·~:~·:~~?J~J.:.:.:~~~~~

, , .. >" .. : ,'. r - • • • ~ , • •• • •••••• ~·.~~'~·f.> ... : .. , ....... 1.1.: ..... 0;. .... ~JI

• ". •• • • I '. • •• 1 .. ',A ..... J • ~ J' .~ :,. " . I ,. .. ', m ::--:i"'

Ha~,~·ni>a;lttHKe. K 3TOA CH1Y8UH:H ·AOJI>KHbJ np.HMe.HflTbcSI "M·eHH(r~:·;CJ_1f:.:::(~::.,::~~'· : .... :; -', ;~:;~;~,

Y~nk.~'er~ H3MeHeHHOA~ HOSOH\Pea3IW.HH.' ", , ., "·;t.,;'::~~,~~'fi~j:;:\:~;},':~,,;,;'

,:' , l(akOBbi *e:npaBHJla TaK~' otMoTpa, ,YCT8HOBJIeHHble a~{~' ~ ;~~~~1~~~~

. .. U"~ ... : . . ./ , ..... ,.~; ~:h\ '~''" .~ . ..! ."<_; •• : •• : •• /:=:. .:~ ':.~

JUlKlIJIea YIl.1,,, . , .. -, ~... .:0 .. ~. . . . .". . :.. ., .~.·-:~"~·:Jt-ii~; ~ .. \ .. :.>';':~"".'\~ ' .

. --. ' • " •. j .• :. 'i . . . , . ~ . .. , .. , ,.. .. ~: \ ~.~';:.:,~~;~~~ . : .. ;: .;/ .•. ." .'. ':. ;:~i

" ,npe>K,lJ,e':BCe~~iCQrJfacHo'C1'~19O-YnK, UCMomp npoBoiJu~~"!jf:J?::~. ';':.'c'

CAe B086g:JfCiJeRWI.:,yaiJAoBHtJUJ iJeAa.' I1CKJIlOlJeBHe - HeoTJi()~',!,:)} -.. .'\;,

• _.' - •• • ..'. • • ." • • ~"""" ..... I..}.' ~ • ~.I' .... '. /.t:J ..

ocaorp Mec1a npoffcmecTBHfI' ("orAl' ~Bb36y>lijlBeTCJl nOCJltfJl~~~~::"~::,<" ::'~;

):te"HHH TaKorO·:·O;CMPTp.a·'HeMeAneHHo!)~:~A;aToMo6Hnb MO>K'e16,biT:b~OP~F:~~':·: .. ., -. <:.~ ... :.:~{J}

. . . . .. -=~.... .. j\'J~II.' 'I r .... ,,-" ',(,.r

TOM,f)CMOrpa t.feCTa npoMcWeCT'BHSI~;,ec;:llH OR cfJHryPHpOPSM B KaI(6~:1<';'.',' ,,:!~

, . . .. . , . ')' , .. , " $t,

.n~~JleHHH (yroH, .)lTn:: e 1K,e·p,r'~a'M:H·· ·MH nocTp,8A8BWH·~H :H :iT: ~:~:.: l)·~~~~··;~:;};.:;:.·~~:·;·~· ~ :. : : :-:~ .. ~,

': ;~,CneJI.OBa:renldiO, ~tIMI."ue Bos6y-_iJeHHozo !lZ.OA08"oaD':~~.~':'i::,;:" ,,> ?:~

• ••• r • • •• I '. I' •• '\~ ... "'""I I"I.~' ''\.. • .. _ •

cocm.ilsllUlem ' me caM we '~3tiItOiJHliie OCHOBQIIWl» ~ UPH ':~~'o.p..r,~,'~ ';':~'(7f,:

, MO>Kef' ocyttleCTBJI$l~LC"OCMOTp~1paHcnopTHoro cpe.nC't$a.H~~'~'!f;;': ',1;":['. ',,' ~oA O€~'TBeTH& sonpoe o npmJ.Jf:UlXOCMOTpa -e,D,HHCTBeHHtlH ;>:l!~P"':. :,":; J .;

• L' • •• •• ,I J .. , . I • • .' t ,.f.." (~~. J • • _ • •

.. :. MO>KeT Cq.HTaTbC;R ·~aoBtle·'Bo;p·-;·HT,en:bHY:M.. ... .:_~ .... : .. ' ... ~; .. ~.: ·:-->:~·:/}·';~·t·.~·.:·.>·. . ... :/

, .. .. t. .. .. J!." " ,.. . .. .• .. ' .. ~':,. '.".,'. , .

. ,·'· .. 60J1,ee··TorO,. Co'rna'b·Hoql'4',eT .. 190··YfIKYKpaHHbJ,.o~o~p·~.·:.:·.::-,: ...... ,.::':

W4";"UItOZ(J "8Aade".W,i_'AU&Ji(~' T8K08b1M RBJlfleTCH If 'Tpa,F"::rio;~'~'· . ,;' , CPeJteTBO) np0t.i88Q'QiI,tiiCA "'0116"0 no nocma'JjDBAB!'tUO\CYih~<'~}l,~' '.,,:"'

" , H 3T() eme aea •. 1WKe apaMl(8X yronoeaoro .m.eiJaoCM()TP;~~~,~ '" '"

.• np9JiJ3BOAHtbl.leJiK)60iicOTPY)J.HHK MHJlHlJ,HH. a CJI~OBaTe.n~,~';.~:?~ 8,OAtTBe'KOT0J:,oro:IiaX,-O.ll,HTC,H;aeJIO. HJlH >ICe TOT, KTO AeAC1B~r.:.(f.'ot~~ ,'; )1enhR~My':napyqeHHI6CJ1eAOBaTenSl, (:)TO - nHCb~eHH~,i,:i~,~,T;. ','

H.elOw.HA dc06YIo npOo.ecCYMbH}'1O tPoPMY). COTPYJlHHK"~{()Cf~~, .', , , *~6UJHA, 3BTojaOr»Lnl; H8: J(opore, rasnx npou,eCCYaJJbHblX :np~B H ~HO-,' ':,'

. .. ~~. . '. . • . ! ..,' . _.. . • . . . _.

.. MOqH·A'He H.Me'eTi~···_'''· ... ( ~ ... ;:: ~.: '. . .<: .'. : '~ .. -.' ':' .:.

, ' ,'" 113: npaBlfjs: 0: He06XOJJ)fMOCTH cy~6I:1oronoCTa»~e'u:.HSI' ~'_'€Je::. · ~

.' " "'M&Tpa >KHJiY!HJlH anero BJI·alleHHH nnua ecru HCK.1lK)lfeM~H: 6e$,: ltOeTa~ :

. ' HOSneRHH , q',nbHTSKOH OCMOTP )l.onyCKaeTCA B HeOTiOO~HhIX, ,~~~.',

, '" ,"eoo ... 9TO He'O()XO.ll.HM.t"-JI,TIH cnaceaas )KHSHn nlo.lleA wt>l, npa npecJfEU{(f~

B~HHIii ~HU., no;u;oa,peBiuoUJ.HXCSI B COBepweHHFI npecty~e~H •. Hanpe-

, i.tep,: 'Mb>K'eT6wTb'npHSHaH 3aKoHHblM 'OCMOTP:,~BT~MOf)D;lUI:t ~aAep~a,H.Horo· H,P'H:·· npeCJIeA003HHH· ero BOAHTeJl9lt ~ COB,epWH~UJ~ro zrrn. B KOTOPOM norHMH HJlH nOCTpa,D,aJII-t JiIOJUf, H'nW1'aIO~rOCR'

.,.. ...

, .. : ... .;. ... ;:_ 'n •..

• ) ~~.~.~ ~ .... ~I

'.. -.. .

I''''''''' r ... ',

~ ~

"0.

. .,



,

"

. n

', ,

.. .

~.

,<

:)j ,

~. .

... .

5:::·::·:·<J\:.·::~ .. ;><. :·':i·: ' .. : .

',. ~'iL< .(:~, "~I . .-.J .' • : ••••

.. .L:JI ~J".-. "'"r'. ..' g-

o; ~'}f..' . ~_, :.' -: . . ". .J.' .

:·:'.lj.:·}/;:;:,·~.f~,; :'~~ .;,.: ': ~.',: . ,J)

"J.'ifi." I;"r ~ • ~:: i I I,' • i '. ...

II :. ...... - •• ' ~""'_'-~~""""'_~~~_IiiiIIIiIIIiIiII!!I!!!I!!!I!!I~"""'~II!iI!I!!!!I!II_""""""'~iI!!I!!I!!IIII!_I!I!IIIIIIIIIII_1IIIiiIIiI!!IIi

.. ' ..... =. ':-t~' .. : .': :"'. ~ ."

':':- /r~~·;~:-t";··. ''I''~'.:: :;: ..... ",,: '. . .' :

;~~,>;r:4)~7~c::Kpb1TbCSl. TOll ao rax >KeOCNIOTp 6e3 cy.ne6HOfO nocr3HQBJ1eHHH nony~·,.·.:.··.:r(;.~·::~::,·",· ~ .':--" ¢,KB.eTC.fI c n,HC.bM:eH.H·o,ro cor J1:a.CHH· BJlMeJ1bua H:MyuteC~rBa~.

~::~:';.:'.~::".:: :.: ... ~:~ ... : .' He rpeoyercs noeraaoaneaae cY~,b": If B TOM cnylJ'8.e, ecna QCM:a,Tp'H}~:.:' ' . ~.~'.' .' B,ae:T'CH .Mecro n,PQ'H~cw:ecTBHH B )KHJ1be· HJI'H HH:OM ,sn:aaeHHH cornacao 38 ..

~.~:'. :: .. ;, .' :HBneHHIO Ma.A~b·ua ·.H:MYm~'C,TBa HJlM C'OO,6ll.\eHHiO 0 cosepmenaa no 'c. -OTHOllleHHIO K HeMY npeCTyDJIeHHH, a raose npa HeB03MO}KHOCTH- nQJJJY~

.'~ .:.'_ .' .' lIHTb cOlrnac~~ .OT':J1H:U.a P,PIH Heo6xo.LlH~ .. OCTH cponuoro OCMOTpa ~e:CTa C]:j':<:' npoucwecrsIUI.,8TO MO>KeT OTHOCHTbCJI KCHlYaUHHM, xorna aBTOMO~ .:::::,\;~t,,-, tlHJIh 'caM - nBJI",eTCH MeCTOM npOHcmeCTBHJI (YKPMeH, orodpaa y sna- .

";~,:~< ."''; Jl,eJ1bl{a wig 1;\ .~~M, .. It:npHMepy; OOHapyJKeH rpyn), .

...... i ,»> Bo sce ".i!' •

", .: . , ''.' BCex ':~MbHblX . ~afD( npoBeJle,HH'e OCMorpa_ Oea nocraHOBJ1'eHH'R

.' t.y~H -. ~o.ECJlH)Ke· 08 -aee-raxa 6b1J1npOB~eH, pe~y.m,mamM

.' : . '. - mattoZQ~' He M021Jtft UCtlo.llb30BOmbCJI. 8 Ka'IeCm8e iJolUlsa-

: . tneIl6Ctn8, mair;:~al(,_olUl nOlJgqetfbt nesaxosso (em. 62 KOHCmumylfUu

YtcpaUllbt). Tep&;:'~'7 Kor.n.a«oCMOTp:& HMeeT npH3HaKu 06b1cKa" npeJKAe ecero+- BCKp~'KaI<liX~nuOOnoMeuJ(e~HH IUIH xp3HHJ1HlJJ.. B T.lI. 6arIDKIiH~ xa ,~H l<Y3q,Ba, aBTe~:o6JUlH::··.A: npaeo ·A.uqa, hpoBOOIlU¥Z'O OOblC" (CAe-

. iJoBatn.ellJl ),. ·.t);"gpbliJam';>- '. '.' ',: . .... . ,~"_. ,,-:. UIUl .llIf6re xpalUlAu'tq'a (UIlU'~

. mpeV08amb all'lOaOom,~bqa) s088U"aem mOAblW npu npoee-

.. iJeHU" ltUJJC08a C.lJ'eiJctlweI(M20' iJeiJemtJUJllClJl(, OObte'" 3m npslMO npe-

nyCM01peH:O q .. 2~:·cr",l83?·mK~ ·l1:M:e~Ho>n'J .~ xapaKTep~Qe .. Q!nHHM·~: OO'bJ:C~, OT OCMOTj>! KaK"11lK09(lro, Anoel<WfbK}' npa (jPOBe.netiHH OCMOrpa (Mil Hi_blX -- [Jp';~c~hHblXAel,-rmK~'~Paoo ~oBaT~lIoMH·HHbIM.n~~~

I • _ I. • -t. •

HbI'M J1l:Jl\8M'''3aKOHOM He"ppeAocr_&11S1:ercl1~"TO ,H AeJl8Th 910" B COOTBeTCTBHH

co CT.,19 KOHCTIrryIJ.HH YKpaHHbI,-OHH He HMelOTnpaaa. . _

-, Ha <PoHe' BbiweYKa33FlHOro _ M!O>KHO ,lJ.IDKe He ynoMHH3Tb 0 TOM. liTO

UK ·OCM'OTP~·. T,aK H OOblCK 40mKHbI . npOHaBO;lHTb~CH B' onpeneneauoa npoueceyansaoa nopanxe ... "Io.eersc yq,acr'H,e,M nOHHTblX,.C COC,T8BJ1eHHeM ,npOTOcKona. ',R: T·.n·~ .. ECJ]"H .. ~,r=H 'Tpe,6o:Ba.~:H.R He C,O,6nlOl(a,IOTCJI. - «OC-

• • I •

. M:~TP» .Hon.RereS( H'e3aK~HHY~MIt . '. .

/' Pa3YMee'TCH, ,nQl{qHa:m'bCsr: C,bTPYJUfH:g3M' 'MHn.HUHH" eCJJH O'H'H HBH:O

npeauuraror 'C.BO" nOJ1HO'Mo'~'H·Jl,·Bo.nHT,enb·,H·e o6SJ.3aH:~ 0 lJeM H:Meer nOJ],~ noe npaso aaaaars. A e,CJ1" 310 ne B6~bU"1:eJ10 _ne.HcT'B¥t:H H. H3 nero co ...

/ . .

.. '.'

cr8BnHlOT IlPOT'OKOJI'" 3~. orsaa npenocrasars rpaacnopraoe C,peJlCTBO

)]JIH' ocxorpa (a TO ,R ,3Mep~,B,aIOT)" B n,pOT'OK.OJle :B.rp·acJ>e,M.H n:O'HC·H'e~ HHM MO>KUO .c.u.e.naTb COoTBetas}'JolllYJO 38nHCb. Hanpnuep: <~.OCKQJ1~- -, !SY ~T ,PdeH~', IIo,r" ' ..... -' _ ' .. " ' .OTK·, :." MTL O,a,ra>K.H:HK a.BTOMQOH'n:H NIH OCMO'T·p,a

- -~

naxo .1nH~Cfl B· H,e,M oeme":, T'a,KH'e Ae:H·CTBiffi:-mt1mfOfClrHen'OCM'orpOP4:., a

__ m •• • ... --_-- ~ -- ••• -- -'-"',83' ~ . ...;.....,. .. _ .

. 06blC~QM.~, 'T~K,~ npSlM:o~h:pe': ~.CM:O'Tp'eHb]: q~2~cL.10eJn1C' OObiC~H:BJ1Her-·

"--CSlHe33KOHHb1M, ·T.R. npOBop.HTCSI 6es B~6y>K)l.eH~H yroJlOBI:IOrO Jl;eJI8, . 6e3, no'c,T~HOBne,HHH cyn,b"~ oes npncyrcrnus n'OHHTW, oes' cocraaneaas nporoxoaa, Ha YKa38.HHoM .. OC,HO'B,3 .. HH,H CQHT'aro lI,eH:cT'BHH C,QT'PY)l,f.lHK.O·B

MHJ1HIl.HH H:e aa KO'H:H:blMH », . .

: • I ... ',

..... '

. .. , ,: (: . / .

~-~~~~I!!!!!!IIiIIIiI~~~~~~~_IIIIII!MlIIIIii~~~~ .. Ii:I.: .•.. ' ;::,-:

" .. ' ....

. . H erne. n.Q~e BHeceHHSlH3MeHeHHH B,I\OAn M~.BO.D.HTe.neM HHH,~ . '.:'.';.'::_ '?,. cneKTopo~ lJaCTO a03HHK3IOT cnopu 0 TOM, MO>Ke.rnH 6L1Tl~ H3bSlTO 'npH, '.: • '<',':;' O(jlopMJJeRHH HapyweHHH BO.ll,HTeJIbCKOe YJ1._ocrobepeHHe. XQTH H3 KoAIl . ./ .

HopMa, AaB3BW3R COTpy)lHHKY rAM T3Koe "pallo, .~HT3,TeM He MeHee,' ..

no)];o!611~SJ np3,KTHKa npo)l;onlKaeT cyw,eCTBOBaTb, npa~.~pacnpocTpaHH ~ ._

~T,~!~.O~I~ sa TE! Hapyme,H:HH" 3a,. K91op~.e MO~~:r. ()bqq,.Haa:HaqeH'O B3b1CKa'" ~

. ",,' ·lme:s·BA,ZI.e JlHlll~HUH npasa ynpaanHTb TpatlC;~~'pnl~Hcp~CTBa,MH.·

,!. '.' . . H sceeu HUl[ero, .HO, noxa J{MO f!y.ll.OM (It¥]}a,CClfptpeHO H H3K338-, :

-". .HHe· He BbI,HeceH'o, ,HalJH,H'aeTCH' «'HepB.oTpe,riKa»l\,i~;~'Ho nanp H'Mep ... ',~. ~ :I,.~'.

l :it" ( , ' .. -, ~ .. ;po/"' "J' ~ . '. ",.,' ,'. ' .. I ." I , ~ .':" /"

npOMeB3Tb p;enCTBHeTaJlOHa . a 38 MeCJIU, KaKnpaliw.O;M1~ neno pac-

cxorpert, H'e -: enesa .)_. A ' , ,,-, ", ':-' < .: .. ,'~"<."~:::"~;~' .. :?-·r~,Ji:I,. I,: . , ' .. ,'." ..... ,;.:~.(

' ' ..' y. . aWT'. '. '. ecnH BO.lJ.HT~]?eI(Qe ,y,4Qet9.}J~peHHe HOBoro -

. oepasna, TOOP" era. H3'bHTHlila.BTOMaTHfJee~· Tep.-Rtil~"\;:ijo~UO~HOCTb ynpannan, aBTOMotlHJIeM3a rpamm,eH (a:9a.3TYc~p.Y.:·lP.RaCJr.HKIuUIHa~

.. , . :~ero. Ml)l8, ,BOOO:lJ_(e. He'p'a.co'p' oc,Tp:a.HfI~'TC· ,0')· ":..' '. . ~f'!<~~<:~)¥"'_" .' .

. .__ ~"J~ . . .' . )",;.. FI .. " . , 01;) •

.- .. nocn~ .BHeceHUHH3MeHeHHiis ~OAnpYKOB6~_!~I).ll.:BblQYCTU.';1]0 nesro opO.ll.e MeTO~qeCKHX peKOMelf;llal.QlijJ;W:ff.'~~c~libpOB ,K3.KHM pa~OTaTb B HOBblX yCJIOB~SIX. H~SlTHeadpWrt~;:'~YA()CTOBepeHHH _

o6oc- ·HOBL.1IBaeTca B ~!Tn M rio~" - .' J 5 :(~ ,: ... ,_ " .. " ,:"-, ~'~-fi.'.r7\i.~: \, , . _- . .

, - ~ ,~ ,. '~~ I. ' '" .' JI.U : 'A' ,~~MeHTe .. ~T., ·:.~-.~:·.~~:~~;~;~~:;~~{~.)P·OlKHO'M AAtf-

~efJ}I.I:I~.~).' Ilpasoaepao ·no a~o?· . " . , ... ' _·~~~,:~.(~>,·:·t~ t'" . "'~::" .. ~<:~'_.:~:,:.:'~.:.' .: :~.' ....

.lleHcTBHTeJibHo, q~ 13 CT,15 sroro ,3a'Kdti~~o/p)fT ~~~Ko'f'~03~~>K-

H ... ... ~ . .'~', v . '. ~ ..

HOCTH~ oaaecsaanexo He Bee 'TElK n'pOCTO·:···~'· :.-- ~""'~' ..:'. .

Compyonulal rAB OUlU6~~tw c.u,,';:1iJ1iI, .mo 3izlC~H «0 - iJop03/CIWM OSU3ICeHUU» aenocpeiJcmse.HlIOiJtIeI!I: U~'/npQ80 uabuuunb

80.;l... ~m· ·s 1I""""'''e .. ,;J . .' . . .. . ., u.' . ~:.' . if:" .'Y • . -'.

~... UK ,.~"~,,",,.' yuocmosepelUle:., ~.IU"y~6.:·Ne (J,~lJJlLItol f)mom aa,ICOH

CaM no ce6e He ooiJep:JICum npolI,eCCYiUlbHblx·HiliiM,D0380J1fJlOIiJ.Hx 80- 06w.e H3.bIMaTb KaKHe-JIHOO npe,n.MeTbl (H OnpeJl~BIoU(l1X nopasoxraxoro

. ~~THSr). B eJI}"Iae a.AMHHuc:rpaTU8HOro npO,~~BQa.C1'Ba.TaKHenpaBHJJa yc~ T3HOBJIeHbJ H~KJIlOqMTenbHo RoAll. YKa3aHNa.JI.~e HOPM8 ;38KOHa'pa3peM uraer TOJihKO «He B03Bpa~Tb.~ YJJ:oCT0~peaJf.~t~ A ,H31»1TO OH'O' ';AOJUKHO ('jblTh -p3Hhwe HB COOTBeTCT.BHH C npoueccY~~~li1npaBHJlaMH, yeranoaJ1'e',Hll'blMRJJPyrH:M 3a.KOH'OMt, Ta,lttIM aaxoH"i4t~~_'·~Q>iJ,g~e,clUl3tiiw, 00 He-

ollBHelo epeueua 6btJ1. KoAH,1fJJ ntJCAelJ_~elftlll ~ ueeo "U3MeH.eNUii. " npaea U3bLMatnb 8oiJumeJlbC1UJey(JoClfl.sepeHUtn:ompgiJItUICu FtfH 60JlbUU! He uuetom. Ai<OJIh He MOryr it:3'hm-L,·TO~'CJle.@BaTe.ahHOt He MO~ >KeT 6bITb pelJg 0 nOCJIe.ayIOmeM ooaBPaTe'IIlI~:l:Ie~gBpaTe: HeJIb3SI BepHYTh HJlH se nepnyts TO" qTO He 3aOHpaJ1'"~! .taK.HM·:~o6p-- aao,M;·.·6e3, HO,p.~·'M: iroAn,.

. . . . _ . . I"" ,

n03"BOJ1H:Kl1.l1(HX. H3bI'M:a,Tb BOAHreJl~KOe YA~cr.o~epe,HH:e'~. C.OOTBeTCTBYW,D¥1f1

lJ8CTb 3aKOHa «0 .D;OPO)f(llOM P,BIDKeHHH»: 'ijlaKTHiJe~I(H repser CHJIY. ..

EMU BO,ltHTe.nLcKoe Y)l.OCTOBepeH(te ':BC~~";TalUl "3bIMaWT, BO.lUlTeJ1b UMeeT nOJlHOe npaao aupasars uecornacaecsraa 8 npOTOKOJIe 06 a,n.,M:H'HHcT'pa'TH'B~HO'M npaaonapyurcasa, a notp,~ '0: ,o6,~OBaT'b, (8. 10,M q:,HC'''' J1'e " B cy~e) 'AeHCT'BH,SI aacnesropa, K·9·TOlp~ii: npoasaen lI3Lo,BTue, B xasecrae ,J];(}JJ>KHO'CT'Horo nHIUit

nOC'Ae 88MaXa· 3ICB3A·UM ...

... ..:..:. -.r __ . : ..::._ .

• _'. : 'I •• : ••••• _

.k._." _,'. ~ .. ~: .... _~~ .... '" ,.: "....,....___,-:.- ...... ~.I,. ...... .x ... ,........... '." ..

..

• ',' • I " •

" .....

- .:--."' -' .' .'~.' .. ,\.::" .. ,:--

Po.

", . '.' :1.". ~4. .. ~1! .~ ... _' .....

. . '" ''i'-''

. . 1·.' v ·::-: .

•• p'

~ ,I • I

" . -.'

. ' . : ....

.", • :-.~ .. I":

I :I. ....... _ ....

. , . "). ~ ft ~':- ' '.... -'.

d" ; !r.e" .'

• .:. '.-. I~ ~. I·... •

i.. I.. .1'" I.

• r-. ,~·tL.!vi.: t", •.... -

.. L 1~'l'L ~ .'

....... I ..... {

" " I

.' " .

I:' ... ',

J •

I .y:~,.~ ~ .. ~

, . {.. : \~; ~~j ... ". : ...

• .. .. ~ ...._"... .. ".:.; t ~ • I ~ I

. • • .. 'p. ... -, 11:. ~ ." I J .. 1"1 I

.. '. : " • " ... II. I ... ' ... I.. • I ' .. ~ f·.2 ~. .... I ':. • "1" :- .....

• " • ... - • :. • .''1' I., .. • I ... • I .." . I .. I . I I

• • • r!' • "I • '!I.' '"A" ![": I ~ J • ~ II

.. " - OJJ.HHM 83 caMbiX. cepseaaax, 80 B· to- H{e BpeMq. II ~: pachpocT~ , -p,aHeli·HWX,.;Ha:~Y··We'HHH run; Bbl~BnfteMbiX. sa ;_,~ri~6~·.!~nUU.R

. ,F, ~ :1 . .. ~~ , , 'V-' 1~~~\.lAk" J . .

. rAM, fI~,.eTCSI .ynpaanenae TpaHcnopTHbiM ·.¢P~eTaoMtB~,~_AHBK

,onlbSlHeH·HU. ,.. ," ..... "', '," ~ -' "' ... ;'\ -, ~ ~ .' .. '_'., ~::}."

I r- -ol'~" - -. I Il[,,' . '. I .. II • ~~ ... - .. ~ I '~;I:"I ,,'~. ....I:·~,! .. l\. ':'

., .. ,,:Ho.. Bf;JIJiSliTb lfapynreHHe ~ Mano., Hy~oo·ew.e JlOK8aa~, 'Iffo;OHt

~MeJ(O Mecro~ n03TOMy BoiJumeJl.IO NY.NO xopOJilo.,,"am&.:f'tifC iN-. .

'- _ . '. .~ j"

c~~ee6Jl '6 maltou, cumyaqaut fl.mo6b1 sa""lIIfUJJf) eBO"" tiP«Bit · . '.

•• • I I •

- ,

HapYUleH~H,e.KOtopPiX H.8JlReTCH· OqeHb :p,ac·npocTp,a'8eJllf;~'M. ,'. :,,~'''' :.

.. ·He.,xoqy 6bJT.~ aesepao nO·HHT·blM: HM B· KoeM CJI~ae~'~H,e co·o~p,·10C{b. orC:raHBaT.~:T()1IKYSpeHHR, qTO' «nssaoe» Bo>fUteHtte' ~~j(~eH~JiOp~ ~an·.bH,oe .. a,~ ~ TeMa 'oTJJi!JlbH'O:rO- pasrosopa, "8-:blXOllR:lltero sa. -np-e)ieJtbI 3ToitKHHrH~ '{ 3aMeqy nHWb, '{TO 80 MHorHX CTpaHaX~:B .a~Mo6BnbHOM O~H(.>:~<eH"·H;KyJl3 60nee paasarux a .UM·B:HJJ·H.,30B8·H_H.blX, 'cyUie~cTByeT; aeKaR:·~pua: Jt,O .Gnpe.u.en.ehHoro yp08HSI COAepX<8HHR anXOfOJ1fI BKpOBH ynpaBII:S(Tb aSTt;lM1otlHneM MO,)KHO, cesnne ero ~! y>Ke-n~:p,a'BoH,apyw'e·H·H:e . .) ,MbI.c·eAlJac-rOBopHM O,ApyrOM': 0 CJlOH<HBW·e.'H'CR y·tI:aIC.8 crpane IJpalC{H· Ke,Op" KOTOpoA, ~OJlHTenb, 3anQl103peHHbJil (HeM)Kllo~cnpaBeNlHBO ~1t1l~ HeT) B «n:bH,~o·,M· BO>KAeHp·H», n'OTepR~T M.'accy~ BpeM1eKH H noaseprDeTCR yHIf3HTM&f1oii- ~JJ.HarHOCTHlJeCKoii» npou~e. M ;A8>Ke ecna 011 OKa*.eTCfI a6COlJIOTH'~ r·pe,3pJolM.; H::H ncrepsnaoro Bp:e'MeHH, .HH Y·H:H>Kle·

HH:R~ e"!y HHKT'O HHKaK 1-1 H·HKOrA.8 ae xosmescapyer.

, .

. ;

.. ,

, ..

y.

'" .

, 1:

. -

"

-: .

C t· .

-

,;a,

"

)..

r ,

-,

<. J

, I

r

.J

. L.:r~

, I J;

..

. . ..

. 'r

... .' ,

"

3alJgeMCR?

.. -

. '.

"" I

-

" .""

":,\;/:'~.":~ ~:':~;Er<'~ ., ... .

', ~': ~~~'~.': '~. ': ~'.';'" - '~. :~. \ '.

.' _.. , »: . »> .: : ,: .

• ".' -:."":../-. :·._f ">:~ / .... :~ :

· - .}.:.~ '.<~. ~":'.~ ... '. /~. ~ .

· :, ~.:.: ' .. ' ...... ":.'" 14 .

":.;~~~i.:.,\~:::' <-. ..

· .. -_\.1: ,.:: •. ,:';\' .. _ ..... :.~-_'~. '. -

/"'1' { ... : .... ~.~.:<~;~,~'-~ .\:,':~~:~.' .. ·r-peTHA cnocod Ji.oKa3b1BaHHH - '3T::Q M,ei!uquHc,,'oe oCBuilemeAb'-

• ,- • r ...... -, ~ ~"l" ..... .. _. r

. ': .. ' <.,"::;::.':~ .. ':. <~·~~.'"tII(J,O'B,a,HU,e na coCm·Q,II.HUe ORbIlHeHU .. ,3a,KJllOqe'HHe cneuaanac-

• :':'.. '" _\:' ,,\'\ .' ~ :.: v , "r" .: ,.. .. __. ~. ~ •. " ~ '-, . I : =r: _ .. . .. •. s - ~. . _ ,

e , :-'." .>::,:~>;.,.:~. TO'~~~M~'KOB, ):l8B8eMoe np'H T8KOM O'C~'B;HJleTenbCTB'OBaHHH, ,_ 3TO

_ .' .. :.: .;;:. AOita3BTe.1IbCTBO, '{TO BO.D.HTWb .neHCTBHTeJ1b~b 1IeTp-e3B. .

· '.' ':'·;"i ~."tOJl ~ .. ' ·o:.·oe~ tna6bi'fifx;HTH TaKO~ OCB~';teJI~BOBaHlte, BOAH~ " , .. , >, tenia (nb~H~My "JlHTpe3BOM.Y)lA~OAHTCH tep~'3aatf'lrie.n~oe spe.: -. ::: .... ~~. 'H -HHK,3KHX B:03p,IDK,eH'H~Aj'cOT:PYnHHKH rAA· He npHHHM,a,lfJT.t,,<OHH

".- '~,-:. ". " ' na n,~2·~5 '·n#D-.-ll' _'IiI, n~~~MaTpHBa,ln. ~rluii o6,Sls,aHH.OCT·b·BO·~.Lt_··Te~

'-~'. "- i-: , • ;, ~ f!...~.~ , a.:;~I.!L,.n,. . W'

~;;i~, . ;n~. DO TpeOOB3HHIOCOTPYAHHKa MM,HIJ.8H npoRTH Me.lI.HlJ,HHCKHH OCMQTP ..

.... :(:1 '; ti"'" , - , , ,

~:<.J;:'~: .. , ~A_{)np·elllMeH.H·JI COCTOR.HHH.:O~~lhH:tI,eHHH, :BJJHHHHJl' HapK.o'TMqeC,K~KX HRH

. TQKCHlJeCKHX Bew,eCTB. H RanoMHJ!am 0 TOM, -rrnno cr.130 l<,9Ae~ca. 06

• < ~ ..' -. •

w. ~.. ' • .:' ,'~MH'~H'cT,pa,T,HBHblX npa:BoHa,pymeHH.RX npeJl,ycMorpeH,8 ·O~.:H,aK'oBaH Of.- ~

.:' .: s, :::.:.: -: ,~·,·~; .. ·.:&e'TCTB,eH'HoCTb K,aK ,33 .y·np,~a'Bn~HH·e-TpaHcn,op·THblM cp'- eJ(CTBOM·.8 H'e1:pe3-. " .. :~

•• I • ,. • -..''',. rio I I _I'" •

;;. ' JIlOM '. COCTORHHH, . T8K,. H,' sa YKJlOaeHHe;. O,T , ,Me)l.HU~UJc~oro ..

. . OCB~~T·enbCTBOBaHHH"... .!:.~.~. '~'., ~.~;. ~,:"", ... '.:~ .z: ... _ . ~ j" /~. ,.' ~. i, - .""

, . IT' ' " .. ,.' '._.. 1 ..• .:' .' '-I,!

. OJIY'l8,etcfl" 'Ir,o 'BOt(HTe,JI1O H~ oc:ra'BIIHIpT .B,wOO·pa;:_ '~"' .":- .~:: '.;'" .. ":_' -. :;.. t.'

.. Hil CllMOM iJ . . . jf1!... ,'. ,.. , .~. _.' : -, L~' :..... . I. .: ~'.' .

.. ' '.~ .. ~~ - "'... e.lle _8_bt~O e_cm~... .'." ~T~~: .. ~-'. -' " 'i - <. ,_!' ' .

. : o~- OCHOBa:H H3 ' .• 3 cm·.-2_, ·.:·'~,oH·cm.um,.g~-:,t4i\-~S!JC.~·.au~,w·"::KoHCTH~. . ~~

~ - .. ~

TYlUI,H ~'Me,·e.T BblCWY'K) IOPH,n,H'lJe,e.KYIO, CllJlW ·i,.~~·rocYAapCTBet I:fOpMbI. ~~~~.

I I oi... - _-

, eeex ,a8K'OHOB H HH&lX 'Hop·M.a'THBH.YX ·aKTOB. AO]JJKQ'w CO'OTBeTC,TBOB'8Tb

• • • F' ill.. 'II

eH~, B TO >K'e B,peM.H ORa HBJlfleTCH . .lJ..OKYMeHTO'JW'rip~.M~~9' ~'eH~CT'BHH, '''·0

ecn, MO)KeT npHMeHH'T.'bCH nenocpencrsenao I.t '·T~.,.':·"JIij<~H~M. OT80- w·eHH'HM.). Ta·M ·Y·K838·H.'O: «HIJ 0AM:H: qenO'BeK ,~e3 ¢r.p·,e>o~oAno,ro co- .

~ 'it - Jt -'.' p ., TJJ! ~ !!MElI_ . - 11 7!IiIi '-

rJJ·,a'C.H~ He _.·'-·.-~_:~~T. 'bl'Tb :p.'O·".'.B'e_.(7· ": .. _ija .. ,:' ~HblM·,:,~~,"~Aii[{Hack~tlM·HJJH·

~M _ • ~ •

'RHhlM on.blTaM)}., . . . , .. ~. ,\.~~ ."'! .f." .~. ", ..

~ ........... ...-. ..... __ .. 1II!!Ii!!IiIiIi......... '1 • • .••• I ...',.. I ".

'. 'YO eCT:b :M'eAHQHHCKoe OC"BHAe'T'enb!CT:BOBa'HQ~e'?'J nO\'CYl>H neaa, , aTO

uensrex caasrx MeJJ.Hll.HHCKltX onuron. 4TO J:lMeHHO CJI~eT,C~ltr~Tb OnbJTO~ c TOlJKH apeuaa KOH CTHTYWlH? Hit; ca.~a KOHCTHT)'li._1f1l f; 'ill.

. u ' ~ ". '

Ae:HCTl3YIOlll.ee .aaKOHO)JlBrenbCTB,Q He ~,ae'T serxero; nO~HH.T~O:rO· H:.B TO'

>Ke 8,peMft Bceo6beMJllOut~ro· onpeneneaaa sroro ;npH"HTHH, KOTop"'Qe. Obi MO.rJIO CT3_T:I:l opH,eHTHpOM, K3'K :n.,p:HMeHSI'Tb :B.~we·ll.pH·BeAeHHYJO·' HOpMy KOHCTHTYUHH. nO.9TOMY npnnercs BblseCTH ~90J1Pe.D.~eHHe

-.

caaocroarensao. .. : : : ..

HaHOOJlee ,6JI'U,3KOe onpeneneaae ,)l3eT 3,3KO:H YK·p.a:l:Jallt'«O·.H,a~:Hoii u' .HaVil:H.O-Tex·HHlfe,'C,KOH: AeHTenbHQC,TH»'~ 'C,PfnaCHO CT.J., 9TQro ·3aK:OH,3,

I ~I~- ~........ • I'" •

• ' . .n.' _ _, ~ _.-!!: j! 4:-=' ~ ..... _ - .... ~ ........ , "I!l f.... 'to

npHKn'ajlHble HayqHble HCcn:eJ(OS8HHSI _. 310 l:IayqH8H ~ H~yqH1.: .: »rexaase-

• . . _ . .'. ,..... d~· .\ ""t:S". ,",,~ .

C.KaSI . AeH:TenbHiOCTb,' .. Hanp.aBJIeHHa:RL" 8·a· "n!onyqe'HHe, ··r Ht;l10,Jlb30BaHR,e ... "-~

. _ ~

A .. U - .

. 3·~aHH·tt MH ,npaKTHq·eCKHX 'l.l.eneH i t ' +'. . ..... ' ~ ~ . : :-,' . . . .f

. ·nOHHTHO, lITO 'BCStKaH ,lI;eSnenbHOCTb,' KaK- nponecc; cocroar H3 OT-'

':AeJlbFtbiX lleHCTBHA •.. no OT'HOtlJ'eHHtO K .JleflTeJ16Hoc;rH,. KOTQpaH HOCHT H,8- 3sallHe' HCCJrep.OBIHKH' (nd-YKpSHHCKH - -,-. '40CJIiJ;vKeHHH) T8KHMH ()1'Jl~bHbI~HAeH~~HR~H SlBJ1HIOTCH dfthlThl (jocl.UlH J: C'APyn,A CTOPOHbI,:' .,.

B 'HeKOT,opblX CJJyq.aRx onur MO>KeT npOBOAHTbCR H3OJ1.HpOB8HHO, Korns 8.

\

•• II I

7F

. _ S.ML2

t .

, • -.~ "",%~T'"' ~:; __ ":" :~:.!.-., .... I. ~ ••

.' I' •

• - ~"I! '\ I... v:

. ,. - ..... -.. . 1

. ~, . .. . - . .

.'

., ,

.,

.J

, . , ,

. Fsaea 2 ..

,3aayeMCR?

I:: ...... -:... ... .. .. _'.J .'

.. '}'\i;::t::.?:Js. ~, . .

. <. J ... :~ "!' -'. 'Mg"' F . - . ) . . . I •

, .. : .. ~ .. '.~~/r~.~~:.::,~, .. I(·::;:.)"~ ._$ ~ ~. I £& I III .' . - - i. 4r ~ ~ I P I £UIIIr'.1 ~', t -

, •• _, -....... -( ,~, • < ;. ••

;.~Jl~.:f~'.'i:;'~·;~~.SAWBaer Q asponopr] lUI" nonp ocrv He .>KleJla~T, TO HH'C.ne\KTOp aOJl""-··

. I;.: .. ~" .. " ........ :r:-:":'~:I:r OJ 1:+ ... ... L~ ... ~ iol '.

',. ~},:,~'~~~~'~~~. OOCTaBHTb . npOTOKQJI 06 M.MHHH~ll~~~B~o" npasoHapywe.Ii..~.·:·:_";>'::'l'~_:~:~HeHHH OT Me)ll4I.lHHCKOfl)iDCBH,U,eTeJI~OBaHHH -. 06paTHM BHD~U;l.~ '\.:, .< .: ~~ .. ·:~~~:y;(~e.:~ti ¥.oAl1.npeogcM·o'!J#¥!"a~f}m8,em.·f!!ni;fell~fIIJ·cm&· ,UMeItHO 3Q· .Y""

• ~ .. , •• :\ II. .... I~,!~~ r·~ ..

~~ ... ': .:-. - .. .. .. /·:~.~··~·IfO_"eltue' om o[cB'uaemllil;"'f.·Bo;"aH~SI~ ~ . _() ~Oap,a3YM·e64,em

.' . ". '-. ·"'-<~<CQBepUleH.Ue c amoil qeA •• ~.r£UX-Au60' iJdt.mtluu. .: - . . . .' _ . . -:-:: ,~:,:.:-~,:.;: J{.nJ13aIWiTbi ~~HX H~~ ~~reJlb M~~~,nH~Tb B nporo'.<, .:.;,i:;I·::' .. :,:., .. ;. xoae (~HJJH aa OTJI.enbHQM ~JlH:CTet., ;,;~:.gl¥eltlfrJ~ B g·POT.-o.Jtone, 'lJ_T'O O,6Dflc,-

.. I. • • • • I:' I I'i.... ...... _.

~~~~~.>: ... ,/ ... , 1"~eHH~ npanaraercs ~ S'TOT 8.~pHaar~.)ije~n;(le1Jl9qT"·~bHe.e, QOTOMY

"I,":,' •• " ,oJ'-:- _ • \. r J ~ • 'til .. I. ... Jf' •

::;f:~;·.·.:." - .. ,·,·-qT10 saaeraee, er.o ·rpYtlHee «n'po;ny~rHiTb~[, :3~H~t:'Q~:H~.btIC ,MaT~p'~aJJA,MH

'·k 1 .;. -.' _ . .ReJla) TaK'Oe O(jbHCH-,e· .H.'He.· «-,0.'.·' 'ml M' 1";~U··-"~~"~-U·I!~n[:~(J-. [0, c·~IJ,~e,meAfjC· """0,"

, ~ • ,'" • - .....' ,_, I li~V! ~"f'Mi'~~~&f (, ~"Y'. . ;,.-

. . " , _. .,~ He gICllOIlRIOCb, a om"fl3bl;(ltUOC6, Plf4AU.3!JA ceoe II.PlI.:.o.;

: <: ' .. -: ifP"-O_ npedOCDlaSJleH1tDe «. 30 em .. ~8:~l<I»wlllJl!ll.lHfUu f;-spaulI"'*'; .'. :""-:OPII 310M, B CJI}"Iae HaJIHqliR K8KHX-JIHtiio npUlJHu (lIa"tI)Iep,.9no~-'

.. - . HHe'B asponopr), 0" roXGe M()>KHO Y~~'l"f:yB ~,.~u~~Jt". eHe "t'FO He

-, . . ·o6.B3aTeJl~aO H, 00 OoJrbWOMy cqery, IOpiU1H,eQIORl~$tllqe»OO:He fH~"

.: ¢T; ,H·cnoJJ.heHH·e :non.o,)Ke.~HH - KQHCT:~~HH -Ya'pH;H·bI'-~$ .,~_.(1y[~~O'BiIe·HO ., ' H'JfKaKBMIf· npHQHH8,MH. Ba)KHhItJ Sl8lIHtrcH, t~.ijt~HIJe'III1H,H~e~

. . MIlKe ~P.HTeJUJ nOllBepr3TbCfJ Oflt,lTaM. . ."~/'~; ':,v~<,,;:', .~;;~, < ';'.' " :. ~ ".' .

-. , .. ·nOBTOpHM:: DOJI.SI BOJ].H·TeJl8 .. :H8. [OTKaa~ ·(rr· 'QCJMdr'enbCr~Q_a:tfflfl .,

. ' • .' ~ .. ...... 'I. .

AQJ[JKH,a, 6WTb qeTK·Q B.bJ:pa>K,eH8 B-nO.HCH1eHl·QlIX K:IJP9!Q""'lY O{l_tf.:HHw

. c'rpaTIf.8HOM npaB,oHapyweH~H'1 '; ~11 [06:"3;@.TeJlbft'Q:·~/~t~'PQ·;BQHtAa·r-QC,R

• .,.. \ •• I' ......... "~1 ..

CCbLnK8.MH aa KbHKpeTH.ble KOHCTHryUHOQH·bJe •. H0·p_'M,~' :~··.·8jJgJ.lQTM'BH.OM

. " . ~ ',' r'·· I , ' _

CJJytI'ae OOaH'TeJllO Hen[OCpeAc'rS1eHJI'O BiCYJle CiYAef·:)t:py.~ _~IJ_Sarr:b, 'Iro

OR ue«yicJIOHHJJCft» OT OCBIfJ(.eTenbCTBOB8nHSlt.a:10l~1l~,;~i;u(oH"C1'inyu.HoHHble .npaea, 3anHCb, CAenaHHCUl8QlWre-n~;CO;Iclree.ti~ppyq; HQ~KM·eH.QQ np H o"'O·pMneH.HH: «H,apYlUeHHH»,:UK pas ,M JJM~etcaTaK1~~

, 't' .I' ..

jtO.K:a.aaTeJlbCT:BOM'- H ~ 'TOMY >Ke CBHAeT[eJlbCT~y~.T, _q~o~ "O.H H,e;:~<abI~~

I - I

~ CT3ThlO ~f(oH,eT.H1)'UHH cneUHMhHO ~k· CYllY~~ ';(~ero M'MorH'~ 'CYJlbH[, ..

noasruo, ae .llt06.RT),. a 3.Han (H, cxopee scero llqe'~e"~.)~el.,B MQMe'HT 'COCT8BJleHHA' nporoxoaa, [9TO '06b11JHOcp.aayIJ .• e:~~~e~:HeT,~r'~QlUeHHe, K ~ He·;q co' CTOpOH.b! acex AOn>KHOCTHbI·X ,nHU ~ 'fleAI, CY~tr ··,.ITO,t):bl npU3H,8'fb BOAHTeJI:R B,HHOBHbI.M, npaaerca noATH H8;.npHMoe 'Hapyw,e'HKe

Ko.H"CTHtyU,HHn~ . .. . ~ -~, :,

.' Bo BCHKOM cnyqae, tlOl103ICeHue 8oiJumeJlII, :fJ;,e on"Jjlle""e iJOIC43all[O' rtg,,,,eM _ M.eiluquN.CICO[tO . o6BuiJelm:eJtflc·",S,OtIIlHUIl,.

6. .~ . ) ~ .

·,gue"m. If.e'CPtJi(J~HeH·H.O xY3ICeU!i '. . .. . I_~_; .. ~:~.~·.·.;Ii-·::·· ,.< >. ,':,t r .r~, _

'CnleuyeT Y'I'HT:blB8Tb BOT euie q'TO~ lJacTo n.pH ·BW"~eH~H" aerpessux B·OAHT.ene·A COTPYAH L··.KH rAH CTaB'RT HX [aBTO.M0(5Rn,~ H8. WTp's4>nn,Ofltart .. ~, onnara «y·cnyr~· ~~OTOpOH npespamaerca $ lIe~t~" B·pOAe ,Ao·no'JI. ~H-,

T[eJlbH'O:rO :HaKa3a"'UH~ .". .

ECTeCTseHHo, TaKOH BM «H8K3aaHltft» AeifCTBy..oo...uM SaKOHO.ll:8-

, .- ....

'TenbCTaOM He npeJJIYCMOT,peH •. 0 po HCXQAIiT" ,.; "0 err"', aaJJftSblSaHHe

, ..

r-

. .:',..

.' •• _.-:", _. "r

. . ' ... - .' ...

,

. ,.

. §

. .. '.: ~

. ._..."

':"~::~~\~~~L~';::';}:: . >, j

~ .. ,.~' ~'."~'. '<':'-.... J 8

:;. ·;j~L:;:;.{..·::\·,>L ~ .'

• ,.-~··- .• ~~f .' - ... ::.~.:s~~ ... ~" ~" ... --~---_--iIiiiiIIiiIIIII ..-.!"""''''''_'''''''~ __ II!!I!!I!!!!!iI _ _''''''-

· .. ;""' .. ~(.~~\ ,,' ':\-':-'~.>~' < ':"~ '. I .', . . ... ., • ..

':: ,0/t~f. ~ ··r~' ... : .: HCXO.l(R 83 3TOro, un BHOBb npaasroe, HB crapoe saIWH"Oame.tlb-

· .~ <> .~.~ ;':' :::" "etIJ~o; npeiJYCMaml'tusalOmee IUJICIi!JtJltUe UAU 83blCICaNl.te B. BUiJe

"L ••• ,.,'r.:' , .. ' r...,~· .,. .. . . .

"'I~"t ·!'~t . sli.npema S4HUMamfl ollpeiJeAeH'lUiIe iJOJl3ICHOCmU UJJU' 3aHU~

":;.~~·1~!: <'·'···r~"'·".:··:~\:., '. ,.,.'. .. :- .. :-., •.. -~"'." -".: .t·-·· '- _, .. : _.,."':.-::

... .: .: >' ', ,~ .... : MIl,m6CR onpeiJelt,elf.,IWAv4_BllmeA&.8ocm.fJl(J! (8. TOM QHCJ1le H n'H:rne'Hu"e

:, . ':: \ ~ .. <. .ppaB3 ynpaaaan, TpaHCfl(lNRblMH. Cpe.il,CTB3MJI), I#!' coomeemcmeqem ., .... ".: '1(oHcmumytfuu YicpaUlI.bI' .'.;6 smail "ac"u,~;"1 M03ICem npuue.' ' .. : .: ';;' ~m&CJI. H60T3KaH Mepa 1iii.K.a38tJoS,g,;IIH 3,lJ.MHHUCTpatHBHoro B3b1CKa·

.' I • .

.>.!.,» t HUH npH.MO ·n:p·OTHBo:pelJHT KOHCT,tI~L\HH •. -;' ·t .' 4 •• ~''','~" - •

\; ;-:\.'.. . .:' '. .Mo>Ker OblTb, c~T·I·43 KOH~eTH~.,R ·co"e:p~·~.T·· KaKHe~JlH60 UCKJJ.f()'qe-·

p-'I'.-.. . _.. .. ._ I["~~~ '\' ...~.. t

.~~:> , , .:" H.HSi? Kacareasno H36p·aHHSI n·p·.·~+eceHH !.'HJIH- in~Ae"HTeJlbH'OCTH HC-

"r • ~, E' ....... ' < ~}~..... . •

< .. ' .' . · ~JllO···elfRH B HeR aer, Bot 83, y·'·era';G"BJJeH.Horo.+~~,3J ,9To·i'c~TaTb:H sanp era

II!' • • ~.~. -E' :to.... .0,.; ~.'" -,...cr ..f ... + .......... '..*= . I ~ •.

. .: : _. ~., J:I~'Hcnonb30BaHHe npHH}')l.HTenllHoro TPYJt8, HCKJI.Q'IeHHR. ecrb: TaKOBblM

-", ~ • 'oil • ;. _ ._. I • =-- _ ;i;. .. ~I ' . •

': .. , _"'::'.' ". ¥ ~ ..... '.: .. ·C'JaTa·eTCH BoeHHaH Hn" aJibie- .. p···.···H· -8:tt"H- ·D1H· a:; :~CI c:nvMl4~, ··p~·8·' 6:·0····· T' ··a··· BI...··'·ni ,0' 1 "H-.'·H-'"

· .. _>. '. , . . .'-'-' _ . .._ . _.' . ,~, D ',' .. '1 ;J II. .. uQ,. I ~. '~ .• '" . t' . .Dl '''I .

-. . -, .. "eM3S1 no npUfOBOPY 'MIt t>eiiieHHlO CY.ll3- H"tdC n9&TOMy H~ rooQ~

. . ~tI1" - ~ #.... "I'~' ~ ~ '1+ ,.or .'.

pHTb - 0 HeKOH,cT~TY:LlH·OHHo·e·TH, ~ Ta:KH,X···~ B·HAOB· ": H:aKas8HHH, - K3-K

Hc:npaB.HT'eJlb.Hble 'HlIH o6·:~eC.TBel:l.HbI,e pa"o.QTiI'~·1 . ~ .. ~ ;: .~\).'~:~: .~.~,,~. i_ ~' .. " .,'~

. ,O:p"a.BO Bbl6,opa npopeccan :HJJH ,P-:oAaiAeJlTeJI~bHOeT·:H.a~BI1ReT.C:R·6e.~c,-

1 't' ' 4 - . ~~ ~J'

JlOBHblM H He MQ>KeT uapyurarecs UB TIp" KaKRX o(!ieronTeJlbCTB3X. ;llame ..-

\ -. .

.. n·pH.rO'Bopo·M. ~H. nO'CT,aHOBJI~J.leH~M, '~A8~ "B'blSOiCHM'blMH, ,Ka3anO'C~b' :Ob], , '.

ri \' aa OCHOaaHHH 38KOH3. OrpaHIPIHTL Ccpepy ~BbI&pa)pY.lJ.OBQIl Aeite.Rb:" ';;_

, . . .:~. . HOCT'_., nOBTO'pHMCfI U' oC.o60 rtWllJet:'KHe.M., .He." MO)f(eT i~H:e '::HMeeT np:, asa ~~

• • ~ _... .' '" _ '"," • of' .... ~_oIr_,j"_ 'I- .......... ~~~- .. .; ~,- •• T .. .:.. ....... d'oI\ _, " •• -- ---~.. -. j.

,n8>Ke. CYA H A3>Ke "PH BblHeceHH:H nparoeopa no, yronOJ3:HOMY A'ij:fty, ~Heli.'" .. ~

rosopa y>Ke onpyrax cnyq3S1X (Kor)I,B pessaner ,00 8)J,MHHHCTnaT'HBHOH:

It' .1

O,T:seTCTBe.HH,'OCT"ff .):, 'Ii . . ~ "_ , • ~ '., .' , I >. . :" 1.' . , .' :"

. ~ .

'. KCT3T:H :rOB'opa, .. nO"CJJ,eAHH.H BblBOA pacnpocrpaaaerca >,H H'a OJIY'-I'aH n:HlUeH'H'H npasa ynpaansrs rpaHcnbprHblMH :~PeACTBa.MH·BOJUfTeUleii lfa~ cmux aBTOMd6HJIeH. BeJJ,b, ao-nepaux, rasoe JlHWeHHe yw.eMJISleTo'uX B103MO>KHO'CTb, B OYJlYl1leM. H3Me·HHT.b',.npoq,eCCHIO H ynpaanars ,aBTO.M'O- 6HileM no H8HM}'(KOHCTHlYI..J.HH npeaocraanaer HMeRHO npaso Bbl60pa

u

~pynoBO.H Jl.eBTeJlhHOCTH, a He T'OJlbKO C'OXpaHe"HSJ-Y1K~ cyme c BYIO.lueH).

A BO-BTOPbIX, aiJecb nanuuo U HaplJUleHUe npaea CI)t}CllUJeHII.OCmU; . _'. Ta,K, cornacno CT'~41 KOHCTHTYUHH,. 'Ka>KllblR H.MeeT .n:p.a·BO BIIMer:b, nOJl'b;30B8'TbCH H pacnopascan-cs CBoeH Co6C.TBeHHOCTb:lO •. Ilpa '3TOM'

npaso qa'CT'H.o:A: 'CO()CTB,eHH.OCT·H JIBJJHeTCH HepyrnH·MblM.: , ... :. . ,

RUUl"e'Hlue npaea .Y np a 8AR. m» mpancnopmlttAM cpedCmfjoM npeoemaennem co 60 10 OAR, e20 eoticmeeusuxa nuusenue -803- M.03IC!Jioc.mu nosseoeamec» ,C80'UM ,UMYUf)e'cm8·0,M~ 9TO-, K8K MbI BHA~HM~ TalOK'e njpOTHB,OpeqHT KO·HCTHTYlI.HH.- ~ .

:.' Ilpaaynareasaoe O·T1fY·>Kll.e·HHe 'HM'ymecTs8 MO)K:eT' npH'Me'HHT'bCR. !OJIbKQ B HCKJIlOlIHTeJIbH&lX cnyuaax B CBR3H.COOw.eCTBeHHoH·Heo6.· XOJJ.HM·OCTb:Kl, ,3 ero .KOH4JH·CKaUHH npaaeaae eft n,o peuieamo cy.Aa(.CM~ c.T.41 11.4· KOHCTH'TYUHH YKpaHH.bI·). STOT nepeseas,

n,oA"IepKHeM ocooo, HB,nHeTCSI' H.C:KnWlJHT,enbHbI.M" .no3ToMY ace

....... • ''I

~ I

. ~

.. 1:

I :' ..

, I .

.. : ~"

... L.

"I, .

I ." -:. ~-. ... -_. '.' .. • ... ""-:. • •• •

. ',:":-.~~. --"~,~' 0:'''';:.':''.,: .l~~~;~'i\i;;[~:_;:

.. ' . . . ."

, I~, ~

..

r; • 'I: .

.. ...

, ,

. ...

" ...,' .I·u

. "'. . I' ". . e • '110

....

. .

. '.. .... ....

. ,

.... r •

,

• • " .. 'I •

. .

'.

• I '! . ~ . . ..

-, ~. ". '. .. . ~

. ,

,

: . j

,I' .:

.. '.

::. .:.

,

. .'.

, . ,

._ '.....,: '1' .:. . .. '-. .~'.

.... .'

'- , .. : .

r i! I

I ......... •

.' .

.;~

,-

, .

. . ~

.) . .

, .

. .. , ...

• r ~- •

.•

, '.

-

.' ,

... I •

,

_ ..

. .

, .

'.

_'. i

, "

""T •• _ J

..

. .r-.

. ,

"',- ..... .

. ,

,



. .:

I

,..... J ~

, ,

I ', ..

._

.. :- . "·i

. .: . ._

•••• 1"1

., -~. _ ........ -_.

. -

,

- ) ..

. ,

..

. -'

.. :. J ~.

.. -. -.

. ...

I" 1 I'" ..

,.:.. ••• 1.

·.aKpec

•-~

.



- • I •

1 ,. l"", .... ..: ~ .. "I •••

I" .

. . ~... .: ~.

, .

• s;-~

_. .' - L

• a •.• ift"' .

-~.

/":;~ . (-'

. - \ ) .' , -:,

. . .• : ... ~ .. :~ --!-: -~

- •• I

~~

,

.. :; ... ~ _. 0 .. · .. ':.

~.

".11

#'~' . ~. ~ ~.t.~;:

••• • ... 111 ..

H. ' - . - . 1.'.'"

,:M'eHHO B 9T'HX :MecTax :npO~CXOAflT' H-,aH!OOll,ee O)f(eCTot,U~!H9h1e~ RUH~'

<PnHKTbI Me>l(Dy'DOAUTeJIftM.A H COTPYAHHKaMH' fAI1, 3Jl.eebCOCTalWllleTCSJ' l:Ian6MbWee~OJlHqeCTBO Dpo-rOKOJlOB 0' HapyweHHSIX nJlJJ., npH~M;IUI . I[C01lcpnHJtTOB, -KaK npaeano, o,tJ.HOl'HnHbI: 06BHReHHe CO CTOPOHhl"- HH~

enexropa B TOM, qTO BO,!J,H'Tenb npoexan peryJlJipyeMhlA nepexpccrox aa aanpemalOUJ;Hii CHrHaJI~ coanan nOMexy BOAHTeJliO, HMelOw,eMY npeaay- ... . l1leCTBO, H3 Hepeil')'JIupyeMOM, HJlH He npony'CTHJt nemexonoaaa sepery-

nHpye:~QM' nepexone. .

Ha*l:H'eM:- C nepson CHty8IUfH'. /

3AeCb~BO cpasy oroaopnrsca: BOJJ,HTeJlH, KOHelfUO, 'He cssrae.

, H<> BC~ ~~ >KHTb,KaK npasano, XOTRT. nOTOMY cnyq.SH OTKPOBE!HHOro npoesaa "8 KpaCH~H BC1peqa~TCSl HeqaCTO, .A3. II cnopHOHT3K3S1 CHTYa'~ W.,I HlUISleTCR JleAKO. KOH<fJ.nUKTblB03HHK~IOT BTex·CJIYIf8RX, xorna 'BQAH'Tenb, npoeaxaer nepespecros nocne nepe:Kn:lOqeHH,H.: 'aeneaoro caraaaa H8 >KeJlTbdi (Kp3CHbI.A) ~JIH nOJUllJH COOTseTCTSYIOw.ero carna-

lUrt. :pe,ryJ1HpOBtnHKO,tA~ .

Me1K,llyTeM, B C8MHX rum eers PM nOJlo>KemiA, xoropae BOJlUTeJ1b

M'O)KeT ,Hc,non,b30B,irr:b lUlH: caoea saunrru.

~. \ ~--' .~ ... :-·.~.~nepBblX,. S onpesesenuu nepel€pecmK.a(n.l.JO 1IJIJ!J"em-

.... I ''0 gtuJStl~bl eeo zpaHuqbt: ,3TO - H311aJ10 3aKpyrJleH~A xpaea npoes,.. )KHX q,aCTeH. KpOMe roro, COrJlaCHO n.IS.8 n.u.n, 6oiJume.llb,

, "

I

.. :- .

..:: .. '-

..

,~ .....

I.. :.

. . - \.,

..

, ~

·.r.

. .

. .. .

I. ...

. ,

• •• 1 •• _ lll'"

.. .

8bzeXatlWU~ nanepettptlCR1.01t ua paap6malOU4Uu. etUH.tuII;.····.·~·4J', t~f~;lmiID1~:.42<

zea IIWeX4tnb 8 HaMe'lelllliJM HanpaSJl.eIl.UUltes. . ....

~tulUUlQ, C8em()fjJ.opa lUJil!J.aiJe (38 BC,UJOqeHOeM ~ae8

TaM CTOn.JlHiH.HH). _!<. :,....: . . ;; . .,._ :' f'~";:~'fc~~~~=

. .,al0 .3H8t1HT, IfTO·eCJIU·,BOJl,HreJlb, BbleSX<aIOI1\RR aa nepe aD!lT'.lln~m"';':'.~~ M·en-IJI H3MeHeUfle~ OI1IfHana cseroeopa; KOrp,a era rpa neno pTuoo:i

eTBO xora 6&r flea"aqHTeJl~HO· BblexaJlO 88 ysaerox .a.~porH:fIje npoe3>Kcil qaefH "MeeT aaxpyraeaae, OR OOHsan npOJ.l;omKau:·" <-., ~.:.fiF

:e~e.3 nepexpecrox, Bonee roro: B()Jf.HTeJ1H, xoropue as'·· :._'.,...,.; ... ~ .... 'IIft1"H,

H81J8Tb ,IlBflmeUHe .HS ,p~3peWalOw.HR{,Dilm HRX) cHrHM, ··--·""'~_1Ibl1l.lL..

OTBeT.CTBHflC n.16.5fUUJ.t ycrynHTbeMY AOpory!, .: ;':;:''' Uli),;I .. ~.~Jj! -:-0"-""' ,,.,. '.-

.. re~ep:b BOUGMHHMt xaspaooraior 'COTpy.u,HHKH [AM, q,HKC* ,.. pymeHHB nOAoOHoro ~oAa. OHH~ KaK opa.BHJlO, pacnOJlaralO. . ..

,. pe1<peCTI<:t'M .aY>K'f',,8M, OCT8H8MRB81OT BO.D.HTeJI-eA, H3pYlIl" •... I"T; ','rJtU,~t¥:_~ HX MIImiK1D, npalJ~a npoea,u,a 51'QrO nepeKpeCTK3. TaKoH Met_ ... , ....... '-,=.-...: ~~,':.~~r TbI JlMJle~TCI B 9TOB 'C:H1YIUH'H.e,cTecTBeHH'L'IM H'O H'- M'e' e',- o·nuH,~,-j~ '·n···,.r'!\'~~a~.}

. ""I .,.DI. " ' , ,,' ., W.I' ' D

10K: 'Ha~~Aflw.~~cs'. · .. S8, HeCKOJlbKO . .u;eCRTKOB ' .. MetP~~~'~ ...... ""--,.j'o_.,"",.

~poTHBOnOJlO1KBfnl.rpaUHULI .nepespecrxa HHcneKTOp· ~~~~'H: ',! ~ I_"~rr.:.

. . QP~CTO He ".MeeT B09M~HC'I;10CTH TO'l80 onie.nmb " , . ,. ~._-.__._~~~~.

_. eft ' 'bH'O :,' De oe ,cpeJ].CT,B.O B

:;;;:':==~=~"bJlGn",seMYtO ·n,'H,HH·}o , TRa,.( :

BHIO). 3TOMY npe .' . M, r- ••

M .'H,HC,:neKTOp ,~D:bray>KAeH O'CM,8rp:HS8Tb n,pOT'H': t!~~~:p~

:~,e,ro: rpa'BH1UY nepexpecraa. .'\ . . , ~". , .

": ~O.~:b,, __ ·~HaXOAR ',' ,

... s . ~. " ., ~~~~==:::=-c

. B03MO>KHDCTL onPeAe.RUTbMeCTOnWIO>KeH . . . *::i§,; ~. .(~-~~

, . _. ~ .', ~ __ "~ :l.'·,t.·····\··,·,·;-- "'~l

: ,S~C!B,a ~ 't,OIJHee. Ha .S)T,O B CnOp"QH CmySU,HH MOJKH(rYlUlaaT);,: !;:,/>:~>':,~ .~ < ~

. ~I1eKTOpy., As c.nyq:ae, ecna TOT .BCe-TaKH COcr8BJ1ReT n:nOTOKOn'" .;i!:<~~'>'~\l

..: ' .. . .'~Y' .. '" [ 'f'"o' 'o:.~ " r- )\L: . ""~

,SaTb/H3J18'H:Hble 06CT"'-""QH'~JRb~'C'-T--"B'--:a" 8' C·s-o·:e- M 06~,aeHe"H"HH .. ', '.. ."F'J~. :;~<.~, ': .. '/ .'.~:~"~.'<:

. __ _. . _ ,I'~I .' _ ' .' .' .. ' ", ,.un, .' I [,.' . ; I, .,~ , ~ I.·~·' ',~-" Yi .ht~

. ' n03JlH:ee,.KO-fA3,lleJlO ,6YAe'T nepeaano MR ,po ,aCCMOrp' e.m.;Pun~jfi1i~~-' '>; .• ·~·:·~f':~l

. .' ' , _ _. ~3~'i,.f!fi!/~ "'-, 1 '~, i.

. CJJ.e}J.HeM}'ily>KHO· 6yn.eT HarJUlllFlO npo.n,eMOHC!pnpOS8Tb :trOT T_Wc,""H ,." -~~:~j

.. .. __ .. . ... .~. .. c .... . - . . ... -.... . ... ,.....;. <.,~,c· ':':';.;,.c'.,. » ••• ' • - (\\.

. .~b'.IJlH 3Toro eC'f.b. . . ·r" <A'lt:' . .. .; .',

'. §, • .1' ''ii. . , . .• ,_ - - - " iii . ' , . I ~~. ~ , . . I ,."

r"'~;': i .; •• . O~If.O us ,fttlea"CMO,mneHblX , .. FoAD ~"'a8 A:UUll,·' #I"U6 ", • .;..,,,,,?.,~~:,.:,, " <:. ~'.~~:

~ _ -T ,::1' •• .,., At. ·'T . ,....... ;wT .. ~~"R{~V'''rU' ... •

i,.:.::~ .a~MUIlUcmpamuBtw4"ofIJtl.etrtCmfJeHHOCmU, - saA~fM;ltiltJ!-*,,~" ..... .' .•. ' co.

;;l/~I4~c,!,,,a. Hnepep;paCCMOTpeHHCM nena H)'>KHO HSnpUH"I:b'B ewif(~-- . :". !;.; :::

'7;\~e acero 3ap8P0e. a81(:a3HOH ·n01JTOH) X0}J,3T3HCTBO 06 YCTpe&8aUl8~"9· .. ' . . ..... <:

.'~~ '.,_. _.. _ __ r _, l' ,. -"':"" '}'t 1 :: .',-.~

/~::.~t~~O~Be,TCTB:YIOIJlHX PJIV)1{'6 (. H,anp·.H'Mep,t aOpo: ,)I(,H'blX) M!aH:O:B·D'H:H,Or~~·~~tJ' , .. ~~

.;",~ , . . _~I "'4~ . " r '- ~ T'''':ll~J..o.~ ,.

-: ~~1~K'pe"'. :·CTKB C:'VIK'~3a'HHe·W lil'l:iiTJlpU· H" bI' np oeaxax 'qacre'H' roerva hRB'" 1'~4 ,;Fl.' "H" ~, ..

; .~ .... ,:)t~."t -- __ - '" . '. I .. '~ - '-' . ,1- . . l1" U-I,f":1 > ~. '. ' ' I. .' n'\,. ' """ Y""'· J._J - rrru-! " ,Q. ;-<4i:i; ,I·b ~ "

.of'~' • ~ . ," .

}:.:,. )_~~e -... 0, Bbl3OQ'e ,B S8C'eJ.\8H:H'e H:H,cn,eKTOp' a, C01CT,aBKBmerro :B~TrIKosi.'" ~,< .

, . ~ ,... r'~ ~ . >.i" -

"s· . · y - ,

:\. ::\~i: .'. ,S3Ce,[l8HHH eu:y, Dbl3SaHHOMY B Kail.f'eCTBe CBHAereJl5l\,'MO$.HO dy .. "

~~\:' '~T SUlB8Tb sonp ocu. H ,B'T'O"M t{H'CJ1e nonp .OCHT~ ern vi<as.a1'b R.a:'~~e·< ... :'~'

• • 0 • • , ,J ,I -if '1-, '~~ .• + ,

.. ' lui' - " "I \

;'J~',_'"'~ nepexpecrxa MecTO, rAe OH CTOHJI, H MeCTOi\\_r~.j 1I:U~JUIM;.~ ' .

;;,:>, ~lICnOpT'HOe Cpe.nCTBO B .MOMeHT «HapyweHHfI». A· nomM" cj'tlefoM

. "':". :,"} . - ,- :'- . .'. .',

... L· .1 ~ .

\" .

;':'~ ·11fpflKpBcrrucu. nepexodbt ...

.,

I ~. • I •

·1 "·1

. '

. ;.': .. : ' ,-,,;"':: :

...-"' _. I •

•• ..~. .: ... : ~ •• I ••

. . ~ . .

. .

I I .:-.. •

. ...

}

~ii{~~~:~?7~[~F~~'~~-- -: - --~~-','--' " -, ' ~-' .. -

• II -:-:. .. ~ •• ;. .. ) 1",/,:: •

.. , ',' ~ .. ~ .. '... J.:",.:. ': .

.. ::: :;·~:·~·i.t :',~ ./::':' ':':~'-~2'

. ~ '. ,:, ", ,;:0":";;'): . ~.

'.' ~O::·.:0 .' .. , < : ... ;'~.:.:. :._"', At .~~. --- __ ~_~ ........ !J!IIIIII!III!!_!!I!IIIIIIIIII!IIIIII!IJW!II!I_II!I!III!I!II!!~~~-~I!!11!!1!11!1!!!!!!!!I!!!!!!ii- - ~~I!I!!!IIIIIIII!

.. .- '::i~{:' ~.-:-- .. ~.- ~I :-. -'y •• ."

· . .. -: ~"""_. ... e :: •. ~ 4. ":,,;~ '~'... . ;. i.""

90"1 . ., ", - .. ' ,,· L:\ . ",

_' ",~;~ti:':'~~';' ~,~HaqeHHblX aa CXeMe pasaepos, nOnpOCHTb onpeneaun, 'paCCTOSI ~

,": '~'~.~.,'/:;.;..,:.:'::;:.;" "H".'···:~;e···· 'M- ·,-e:wnv ~T/.HM:·H· T·O···· u ·a;M:U:: .... ~r . ". .• •.

: ;. . .' .\ I:," .: > ,>:1'1 .. . . .. .. ~ ;;:;'"""'. .. .... If K,.... ,',!ill -,' , . .

;-:r,: ':~t)~{;':-;:<fIo onury: sro paCCTOSIBIt~ npaKTlIlJ,e~:~IiKorAa He 6bIBaeT'MeHb"

. :: '·':,.c ,,- .. . ' .' .•. - 40 Me1'pOB. A 3I;1aQiu;' acerna MOlKHO' sapoHHTb Y CY.D.bH COMBe,;.

,>,,<, ,\)~:HHe '8 TOM, .'1TO ancnexrcp-aa TaKOM pacCToJflUlu·TOQHO onpeneann, ,.".:,:rt~peceK nil 8BTOMo6JlJlb rppR!W)lepeKpeCTK3\B'MO~BTnepeKJnoqe-

, : ' .: ":~QSI CHl'HaJIa caerooopa. -riP.!, ',TO socnpaarae HHcneKTQPOM'9TOrO

". ': ". :: (j>aKTa (aepaee, U,e.nOH c08oKYri~~llJJ q,aKTOB) eceraa ~BJlfleTCfl cy6DeK ~

~ ,'. .. THB'H' LI' M· a.... 10'0,:) ~',' , ,I " .".' . . 1 r : "

~ . : ". c. ' .... , . !oI' .~'- . I"':E I. . i ... ~ ,

I' .' • : . • -.: .' r" - : ........... I J~ "{'~, 1 • -. ~. • I I··.". •

" . .'.,'.' :"!' A nOCTaHOBJleHHe cy,a.a )l.~ 6a~p()Ba~I$CH HaHCKJllotJOTeJIbHO

" -, ': ' ' "', TOqHblX Jl.8HHhlX. Cor JlaCHO CT;f52:·'K~BCT~H': WKPSHHbI, 068':"fe-

· ',. . HUe (BT.q. H B aapyureuaa flWlllieMo3ICetn 661m&, OC~()BaHO na

,', " ,..~i:~'~ftpeiJnoAOXeHUJlx. M~HC,D,y '~MiyrBep)K,ll,e~Ue ,UH9ne~Topa, QTO ,B "

, '. - .' .: .. :~~.:: ·M·oM,e.;HT' nep eKJIlOlI·eH'HSI caraana CBo6T'o,lj),epa. BQ)ui'reJlb, .,~(Ue '. ae B,blex,an

r • • I po • ~. - -. '. • • • • ~ • • '.' I. _

:.' :": sa, nepexpecrox, ·MomeT HBJUITbCflT~iro'~r.0,nH1J:"b1M'flPe)J.no.noH(e-

. HR···e·'· a ae o«~e·· ··K··T· ··HBH,O·.·.:\ ·HC· THH!OH '. (·J-FIOHSlT.HO·,'.~,· sro 'He; '·OTHO~GHT·'CH. K

_ _ . '''.1,.·. U .0. '. .'. . .n. -'. - . - - ~ .., ~ 7,',.' ,

- .•.... 'CJlyqaJJM, xorna B MOMem nepeKJuolleHiul,B6,aHfeJiL'H8XO)(HnCft 'e ae-

·CKOJlb~·HX =. lJ,eC'RTKax Mer·pOR ~'T·· nepespecrxa' ~ "tyr~ ~8ce ,.'B·MHO ueso-

- . 330M ).. . ., .' , I ... ~ ,', ~~., t' ~ .' ..

'OOY'Ke'HII'blM' rJJ· ..•. ,.'.' • .. . . ~-! ' .' . " I~'"" . ,. '." .

~#*~. ~ 1-,1 " .1 ... II~·"r"'_.I:""I!I"P"

... • ~.. -! .III."r.... •• .. • • ~ '"':T~ ~~ I .... ~~~ ",Itt • •

. '. . SO-J(,ee Toro. . '._ .,..~ -'~ .~:. . _ .... , "," . : I~ -. ' "~':', 'J '", .. ,.,-, ,

"; 8 i In,: npSlMo np¥MaTp"Baet;~~l'r(r.O:a-timeAb~ :iiomo;'

. P~~p'u BlCJttp1fe~~u ~eAmozon~~lIiiAa::C'~'!J.fi"'pa< UA~:-"~~-

nsmu« py"a, peegAup08U4utca He M,,!sem, d),eIII.~~o~um'6 tl ltaiJAe3ICaU{eM seecme mpallcnopmHoe-cpeiJC1JlBO" ~-e$; ~f~eHe-

. '1I.w, II ecmpe It ItOZ 0 mopMOXeHUJI.· t/,Meem-:npas() '_lJ:su,ambCJI iJlMblile npK,Y~OBHH oCJecnetieHHH '6esonaCHpCTH 'J:\BHJK,eiittSl:,.:npn .'

9·T·Oa.jjj· eoaa T· e·:·JI···b·· no C·VTH onpeneaser C8M"'Q\lAeT ,118: B~ T3X'O:M·.·cnyqae

'. ·.,1111 'A. ~ .. "., .... -'J_:' .. , .. : 1-'\.. J~ .... -..........: .,-: :~,- .. ' ~ .. '- r

TOpMO)KeHHe 3KCTpeHHblM unH ReT t MO)KeT .iUf, OR, OCT3HOBHTbCfI oea

'"pUMe HeHHH UMeRHO sxcrpcaaoro TopMomeH Uft (: 9iO. gaBIICIfT _aT _tleJlor~ paaa napaaerpos - xareropaa, Tuna H xa<'p"KTep'HCTHK· TpaHCnoprsoro cpencrsa, ero 3,arpy3KH., COCTOHHHSI nopora H r.n, '.,

. Ho 310 He see, H3 60J]ee ,lleTaJlbHOro 8HaJIH3a HOp~ fI)JJJ. B~TeKa-' er, qTo:,imalCou cumyaquu soiJumeJtb He mOJlbIW'UMeem npaeo, I}O U,IIO ,egmu iJeila. 06J1.84H· . iJa,u~el!u.. .' . / Iln, «:r:» 0.1.2,9' f1JlU BOJl)fT1eJlJO aanpeuiaerca peaxo TOPM03HTb ..

Kpoae O,llHoro-e}UfHCTBeHHOrO cnyqaR - lior)l.a 6e39T0rQ' HeB03MO>KHO

np~oTBpaTHTbJlTn."· ' ":' ',i'~ , .. " , "

, Tioal-oMY B' pHlle c.nyqaeB, xorna caeua cHrna~B cBeTo4>opa (H.nH perynaposutaxa] ·3aCTaeT BO)J.HTeJIft B acnocpencreeuaoa MH30eTH OT rpaHHlJ,LI nepexpeerxa, OR HMeeT 09J)Hoe "pa,SO H~ 3TOT nepexpecrox suexars (a nOTOM B COOTBeTCTBHH C n.t6.S ero n~!<HHyrb). Bo-nepBblX., ARK roro qTOltSbloCTaHOBHT.b rpancnopraoe ~,'CPeACTBO no nepe-. .K·peCTKa, .AonIKHO .Tpe6oB8T.bICH sxcrpeaaoe, pesxoe TOp'M'O.)KeHHe

.-'

.'

,."

I ~

-.

. ',' "'..-- _. .

~ .

". Ilepespecmxu, nepexoou ...

. .

. ,

. .

<; Ew\;:~;,:~,:~:,;:;~tr}:J;~~: "

. - .~ '.'-':.' .... "-";.. ·t -1·.,;. i -:1-; <',~, . .'

::"~~;; };~.;i:;~·~-t:~4!··~:" ,. '

'.--;~-::' ,0"::-,0; \;""ii' .. ~{:L!:>':' "Ail . . ~ .' :.~. =. '. :.~~;'~:\~~'-;.~:; -':1;- .:t_~~

.' •• ~ !.,. .... 1 "\""'."'7":'J' 111,,[,' -. ~ I"',.r.

. . ~""":tr~~>~'~;; ":"';~.~'.'.~"" .~. "~i!J '~""""-~--iiIIiMI!II!!!!!_"_~ ~'_' -IIiiiIIIIIIIIII -11!!111!1!1!!1

., ';·:.)&t:;:~'I~.).:.;.-~.'~7.~: .. ;~:~:~ ... :~-r~: < ~." . FE7 . . _

~~-f(~~·:~;?;tt';£:'~'~llnPl(,. B iJaNH.OiiculIIgaqUtl :/i·.UMeA npaeo npo8DA_am" "\ :·'):",:_::.('!.!jwi1.lI.iRleell.Ue.l{axe 8 CA/rl.ae, '.CAUtJ&i:9fIlO mOpMOXellUe "iJaDe" -···:~·';"·;;:,~:\~~~f-'~·~~·~~:~;~~rJ;}ij~;fj~eC.m,8um6 6,ea ~·,e,od#~·~a· 'epa H' '-u·: ~'4:~~";·i.i.,fte"pecm"a .... am, ·0' O~·;IJO·

. it,' '.' ~. $.: ' ,~'~. upt., "r ... ~ u. , ," ", I'~~r ' ,. " _. . 1IIo!ii!'.J!'"

-,_< '.,_'.-:'>:;';-~~~/~:.,\: HapYUleH.UUlllll. «a~;~t2.9 flJ.ut-'lii~"#lJeJlac" iJpyeaJI 803-

; ·;:·;:"'·,::.>~~ItOCm6 npeiJomBpti~~_.: IfJ'H -c06~"ue. iJpgzUMU80-

. ~ . ,. "um 16 5 "TIn .. 1< '! '. .' 1 4 "'17"

::"~;'>·.I':._,. '.' .', ': .... '. .. : .. >:,:'~.' .' .. :.' ·e/l.RMU n, . '.,.' .I:.~., ,Ii.,._~.~, B coo,m.Bemc.tIJ:_"u c 1l~:' .• ' - ~"'~j

• I.' • I~. I. ,.. • _... •• • ". I ••• '\:," .... •• • • • • ..

;:.i.' .. ":',_ .. ' .. "'.~ npaeo paeCfl.um.bl~~lu)e mopMiJ3ICe1ltl.e S04!lH,oQ cu-

~;;' . ,- .. -, .. : !!,lIa'f,UUM02JlO npusecmu.'itiJ_IllilUJlJettulO C u8yu,u,'caaiJu cis ..

t:;:: ... ';''':.:'.::.'~ .. ·.·:,-.·mo~~.6UAeM,., 'HoamoMY" .c.,,"I/ttt._, .. :.~tll)u· ... oei(~mitlUJl,. ne. nptlc,mo

i- -, "~:, ,'.:' ."~I$,~MepllfXMu, a. eiJuHcmtidito, ciii>"'~P1n(fYI8UfIlMU tnpe6o;::"d':~,":~~ttu:JlM DlUl siJaHHoll iJoPO:llt __ ~c~f!l~tJiJ ClUllYtli4Uu».· r_.....'~~';o;i-~~ ,(,~;',Cne.oyIOw.aH caryanaa - ·3TO aeBbln~HeBfJe'Tpet54~amBr'·ru:w.,yc~~

( .'-', ...... yYllHTbJ(OPOry Jq>yroMy TpaHcnOpTHOMY epeACTsy· HI HeperyJllifPyeMoM'

~':.'~ . . . .i1ep1eKI)eCTKe .. ' '. : . .' ~ ~ .•. '1 < t·. .~.: 1': ,-,~,.:, .' .;' '. ~ . . ,

~:_ . .. '_ •... '" ; .' M3){eCb ~weT OT~HlIaTb: CJJY'I~~rKQfM ,cH~a~~.Adc,Ta~~bHO

;:. , .. Cr8HOBHTCH 8aapHfflma (TO eCThBONlTeIE"~ H~~H,hpeIW}!Die&rBO,

i:< . ,lteAcTBHTenhHO t5w BbI~eH,pe3Ko.TOP"03~/:~N"·.f!iP~poBatb)

~':.- . - . . .. -Ii '

~,,: . -. . or rex, 'K()ra8 peanbHO:~ ,ona'~H'OCTII·.·~RH MH ~f(>":C~3.8(l:::Jle:: uitJI·o~· .. B no-

~',' " ' , 'CJle.llHeM CJiyqae BO)tHTeJlb, o6BHHeHHbI~ Dr .wWe.tHt"llJUl~ - BROJJHe

i·: ""', "'O~eTAOKaBblBaTb CIOIO npaSOTy.-.H.DJIB 9TOi'o,~ctbi\(JClioBalmSJ. -":.> ." }:,' ", ,',:.-Olt. 16~11 u 16 .. 12JlJTJfjpeeAaMtHmupiitO~iiP:;:IwJ".;ifle~80" :' ' ,-,~e:~ npu npoeooe nepeeYAUP1JUt6IX ._"fIH1 .. M',:6ite.UPY+ '

: ,', _' IOmtR na nOlJRmuu,06itaa''1toctnll «gcntli_'~~~'.n.LlO-

-, ,.. . . ~ . ~ .. -}~. ..

, IIM::o!1PeA~HeT3To nOHHTHe raK:' «lpet)OB8.n";K ,yq~~)I,OPO)K-

, 'Jf9,;rQ JJ.BH>Ke"HSI~'He' npO]J.OJDK8Th :HJI·H· .ae Bod_rJ:;' .... He,: He , . '·q(yW.eCT~SlTb HHKakux MaHeBpOB (saHCKJIKl'~~TPe&Il8~"oeao-

, '~T~ ~aHRM8eM}'lO 'nOJlocy .lI.BH>KeHHSI), eCJJl;t;~9'fOMO>Ker .SblH}'.U.H'f.J> . ':.iJ.lWHX ~a~HItKOB JlopO>KHoro )J,BIDKeHHSI ~ IiM~~~I_~lBX"'IlP,eHMYm~BO'~"

H3MeHHTb~HanpaBlleHHe )J,BHmeHHH HnHCKOp:oC'Fh~':,'·- ,.'~ .. ' ..

.. ',:'::"" r~~ c 06~oM.,.·ec~uiJeUCmBUJl soiJum~iI:;'Iie.~-;""'.'~m'

: 1:IUICgeb U3MeNJIlnb·nanpa&4eatle dsu3i£eHUR _C*tJP.tJC1ll~ D'08-" MOM· iIp~e"eHU" ,nolUlmwr« gcmynumb ,OOPP2tJ»· Be MtJaicem'

6"'tn6 u tJe'Ul. . .'. . '. '>~,' .

. . ,:.'. A~qTO Q3,HalfaeT ,~ B,blHYAHTb?···· r , -'.~ .:; '. . ~ • - ~

'":,,O';leBIUUiOt:1ffO MeHSl'th CKOpQCTh HnH MaHeBpKPor$iT~ abl~eHTat yqa~HK'ABmKeHHJiJ AJlJI KOTOporoC03.ASHbI,npenstrCftllie:HJlilonac~ Hot~h~;~JiHalJe FQ OPH, eCJIu OOCT8HOBK3 crana:8sapM¥1t'. ',. .

: ' ... ·.:~RtY8.·UHH, <KO,rAa 'ooae'HOCTH MOiKH~ .H;i6e)i(8tb:·CDoKoAHblM,H:'-~ nnaB~ . . HhI.nf'Ma·HeSp8MB 'HlIII TOpMO)KeHUeM, B03HHKaJOt,:A9BOJlLROpe.zgcO. KaK' .n"'nJIo, 0 4:8b1HylK;neHHocTH» M8HeBpa,HJJH TGpMO>KeHHfI'np"IIXOAHTC9'

. ··r,~~~p·HTb 'f.O~Dt :KotAa·o'H.H· 6b1J1H ,pe3KHM.R, 9Kit,rpe.Habi,MH~· '. '-'

.' ·\' •. A eCJlH'PlMeIOliI,Hff. npeHMYw,ecTBo BO,IUiTMb''O.U3&nCH BliH)'>I<Ae8 . ·.M.eHHTh·peSKoe,.9KCTpeHHoe TOp MO)l(e tute y TO, K8KM:· y>K.e aBaeM,'

" "

_. r....,-..~·7-=-._ .. ~~....iI .'~ .~"~.".. • .'_~ __ ':"_'~ •••• ~.

, . .

r' ~ ..

--roo

,,.

:) "::?~ ij.4 • .J:"

'_ ,

...... ~ ...... , ..... l!." ........... ~ (:.:' ..

.~~~~----~~-IiIIiIIM!II!!I~~-~--IIII!IIM!IIMM Iillillllli........_ ............. ~~~~ :.~::i·}~·~

~~.:~ '., , ..

. . 1 I"'"J ...

3!O 6hU1 EWiHCTBe'HHbJR 'cnOC~:H36eJK8Tb zrrn. B. npOTHBHO.'~;: '--~,_,__, '9.0. caa npleJ1;cTaeT'.Hapyt;U~.T.p'eM:nn, .. :· «r» n. 12~9 nna .. · ". :::,<".~ '~'>:"':''''~'''"'"-''~:f:::.~*~.~i%r~''''"Ii:::

HH8lJe roBOPJl,ecA;':~cmB~tIJ).,.UHotl, "PQMe' ... 0'.":'

,UM,eIOUfUM. npSUM.g,"f",eiJitJ,o BoiJu'In:,eiieM peaICO,z"fJ m·o . I ""'''''',-'' r-, .......

sapUallmj . tipa:uiitopul!TO He tqJoucxoiJu.n.o,. _ ' .. '-,"Ah."·'.·"""'"

HeucnOAHeauumpe6(J8aHUJI ycm,ynumb oopozy HeA63JI; . <-' ... " ...... , ,

npaacp, TOT,; i~_en:npeHMYllteCTBO, TOPM03HJ1 «c nePeriyry~,i: . THlJeCKH . -'1iR~~enOpTHble',.epe.uCTBa ,MornH pa3beXaTb:CjJ>:J:f~;?:":_,oiiIiiIi: .LJf;,' ;(",,~ on,pe~en'¢~H",.·.·'OblJJO JlH .Ha.py.w~eH:H,'e.,nJnJl H' C lfben CTOPOiJ.W,:·· .. ~" ,- '.-',' ,

. ., ' - \

ne, ,HeBI.a)K~O)~·ac.CTOHHHe ._. AeCHTb Me:TpOB asa HnH n . OJ]' ,FM" e-"ma' ~ .;.: .. "(t'-~,,~'" .J<;," .(

. '.' , . : y .. , p;..L' '. ' ',~ :V ~lt~ r;. "l.· .. :i'

'. : ,KaJ(.'~npe;J,eJIHTb, ,OhUlO JUt llTll HeH36e>KHhlM, 6b1J1a JIH:, ",·:,"',_t ..

___". ': ,.~ , '') '.

,on.·a·CHOCTb. ~ _. '.

. .

. '. ··H.JleSJI.bH·hlH ·B~.pHaHT ~. H,a3H,aQeHHe· C .3100 UenblO' sa n~.in.iU'::\;;I\.U

3KcnepTB3bJ. Ii.O STO~ BO-nepBb[7C~ npaKTH1JeCKH HepeanbHo(9 ,.·.·~·~R,: D." r\m.HM~C

. . sa He acer}l8 Ha~nf~qaeTCR.z:ta)l(e no JJ.enaMO npOHcwe.zu.UHX;llTflJ., .. c>.'. ' .' ,y

... BTOPbJX~ M>Ke9Kcnepr naneso He acerna B COCTOHHPiH:'.o.a~&;.:;i',ii~~~:~j:'y,:·!\ . nOJJ.06HblM BonpOC8M xarercpasecxoe ,38KJIIOlJeHHe. npH'leM·~!ri:.~:~~:; ~};;,/:-:f~'\~' . .fI,a 3,KcnepT'OS' ,_ . C/rHW'KOM qaCTO .MH n,aq'·H 3aKJllOlIe.HHH: npo:: oero .. -·H:·· "e' ~~>~~~r~~::r~-.::·.!·; .. ·;}~~J

I [~r. .. ~.I·. ., n~r~.- ..... ~ ~L' ." • ~~

T3eT Heo6xOMMblX' Jl8HHWX, KOTOpbJe MomHO YCTaHoBHTb·-'ifo.n~!~.i;~?L_' ,X~~~:~~

• '.. ~,,,,,"" "1. .... ~~ .(.1 I • "'rt.,.

MeCTe, npOHcweCTBHB HJ1H C nOMOJUb,IO BocnpOH3BeAeHHfro6clj~~~:~%>::f:,:~;:'i:;

06CTO.SlTeJlbCTB,. C.OOblT·H!" .xoropoe OOblQHO :npOBOJlHTCH·. rro Y:roIIQj~:J.t.\<~:~::?~~,·.":':'~<:'~·~ .n.enaM ( a o,tj)0pMJuiswHe.llTncOTpy.D.HHKH rAM sroro.ae ~/latf,~}~~~'~'f"-: ;'::: ,~:':~~ npeJUlqJIO>K,e·H·1f:RX" :KaK M.bI.IIO,MHHM, -HH',Ka,Koe 'o6SHH'eHH,e :OC·HO'S;:QBai~:~.,~,:,:·I'.:,., t.: .. -.:~:

. . . '.' . LL': .~. '.~"; ",' .. i"I···=!J.'I'~: : .... 1· rl,:~ .··~I ..... ~

He M'O'iidJ'et :. · '. : . ., ,;.'! s., . '~".~'~":. ',-: ,'-',. ...... ~ "'1'

, ll!J'\ _- .:11 . '.' .' ; • ~ ~ .' • ." ~~ {. ~. ".1 ~ II'" . • .. ~Y ;~~.~~"". ..':". :~~:.~. ~

~ • .. .... .' ~ i;, • ,1' ok'. 'I. I,. '~'.r'(!" • i,.... .: I.": _~~

.. ,fie sceraa, HOB~HeKOTOPblX CJIytl8HX (xorna CHTYau8Sl60JIee:~ •• ~;::,·::", . _.",',:.:

. HeeSlBH8H), MOli<eT:, ()hlTb JlOCTaTOlfHo H nOSlcHeHHH TOFOl)nlaci'it.8~,.~r>,:·,- :'"~ . lKemtR, KOTopoMy6wna C03)il,aH8 nouexa. HO,corpyJlHUIi;'·tdi·;··:: :'~,~ ,I

. .... .. . . 1 . 1 .i' ... ~ • r _. ',. ~'''''~:':: :'."lI1 ":.' ~ ,': .: .' ".1 I;~

.,ocrBH8BJ1HB8eT .ero ,·~p.aHHe '·petlK,O, ne roeopa Y>Ke.- o .8allJle_ ... ·~·: .. .. t: .. , ·-.~~{.:.i?

. . ecpopMJleHHH AOK)'AleHTOB .. (A cyqeToM roro, qTOt· KaK:nOKM,a"',Q:,.~.~:~:r· ,:.~.,_ :,::':,:.~

. '. ': ocra HO'B Ka:· 'Tp,. 8Hcnop,. raorecp OT;'CTBa ~ 310 .. ,no'c.~vr:Hji<3.~iif'.;~~'~·,H~Ae.·:·.\B."~cQ,Ub~.-:~~ .. -, .. ,\ h;<~:,

. . . ~ , J"',. ~~r··_"" f'~ ~ .<' •. iM«Jfl, .. -.' ". ','< J

." . TeilH ·ff naCC8>KHJ)OlJ, saKOHHOCTb TaKHX JJ,eHCT~HA nOOToo.we_ik:~;~:': .: -: ""<_,--

,., ,M-renlO, He.:·CO,BepWasweMY", HapyweHHH, Boo6me. 'BblrJJni#t1l;·)~a:~;.:. /;',:f

~":' COMBHTe.nbHO~r:noaTOMY qacro, nOKa npe.u.nOJIarae'Ml:.liL""~.:; .. ,,';'

:;.:,,-o6maeTeH C HHCneKTopoM, TOT HHKeM He on03HaH~l:di,KoMY·.:,y~tffl·_ .. "

_.', IfH,J{,Opory,paeTBOpReTCH B ,D.,0PO>KHOM_rIOTOKe. ..'::: .:" ;: .. , ;·;:::_,.,-i:;~. <;6,.<" !( .'.

'Si·. '. 11 BOT 3ll.e~ npeilil.oA4eaeMblU 8UHOBH",tl B c08iJalt4~.II"~_~ . . ' ',' '~);:;:·._'BffPa8e nmnpe6o(Jtlm~: .A iJlc43ICume Mite Ha- ",Ol.fJ,,_.fju·_. .. . .

f'~~' ·tIIiI"fJ3ICiJeH- mopM03umb I H J10KmKHTe; QTO OHBQO(i1U.e lo.P'l~M:-; H'_~ . .. ~.

.. ~~V{:·q.TO,3TIO 'HMea'DO' Sf era "BbI"yJlIfJ1 A nOKB OH 3Tor10 c·a·M .He.c.'Ka38Jl(IIJJH2y:e··:· .'

;C,.~~nHca.;i),.· M~~eT- 6btTh, -O~:Bn~He Mor cnoKollHo'co 'M~Oii,,:p,~3~~~~~':' ... _

'~2;:'~':~!: A npwrop~o3Hn.(ecnH . Boo6w.e npHTOp_M03HJ1· ~ .ilM.bq.R nOrE) ,JJe . .. - .. ' .

:::::,~ B~) no cOBe:pweHHQ JJ;pyfOH npHlfHHe. HanpHMep. Ha:ceKyifAY'~.-rM:" •

/'-;'. :., a~ "DoT!e&fHMo~i: HJlH' 3Jle.KTpoo6oPYJJ:oBBuHe B 'M3wtfue A8JJQ. [~~.P~·.,. '»': . /'.'

• 1 .' •••• •

. . .

~ .. , ...

:.

,.

.' .

'.

. .

: I'

. . ~

~ .

I' ' .. 1

~ .1' • : .) ': •

, .

;, ... : .::·f!(4peICpecmICuJ n~pexoiJbl ...

. . . . .

,

'.

• 1

.'

." .

, .'

I' .' 1 •

1 • ,- •

r ::.' (. :.'~':: ... :'~~.~~';~)J/':~};~;: ~ ". _'.'

~'.. T:.... ": .-!-.. S;. '/ : • Q--' " .

. . ; . --," '.~'._' : .... r'

.~ : I .- I" 'r" •... .I-.::.-":'-."!'

-'--~'. )' i<, ~;' >:<.'~- .

. , .: ..... '.' ~"_:.j..'~./'":: _ ·~26:~·

. ',. "-.1-' . ._ ....... _: •. -'!-"" - : -.--.,. . " "

.. ~ ..... ~ ... ~,~~'.,,-::-"~ ~\ '-': .:

..... ,:-"~.(1:0·~:1' ~-~IIII!I!I!I!!!!I-~IiiiiIiiiIiIIiI~-iIiiiIIiIIIIIIIl!!IIiiiIIiiIiI""""'~"""'~_"""""iIiII!!!I!!!!I!i!I!!!!II!!II!I--I!!II!!iiiiiiII~!!!!!I!II!!!I!IIIIIiiiiIIiIII!I!!!IIIiiiiiiii~

. ;:.. ~ '-:6)- /:.- \.,

. ~ >~~L"' ~.;~ .. ~.:-::-~ >', .": _

\ .;::~~'<it~}_~·;'_·_;EcJlH3TH apryMeHTbI·.n,eHCTBHH He B()3~MenHt 'TO ox, ODRTb >K~HMeI_ - ; ,~". \ .~ ,~::~_:CMblcn omoopaaamb B C80tiX -n'ORClleIJ,UII% Ie npomoIColIY 06 aiJ-

l" .•.. ".·_·)&OCf·iltucm· rna" mUBU

~. ~' '. ).,~~{~~"';~~'~~.,._. ',' 'r _ , ,',' nOM npaSfJ"HapIIWeHUIt. •• ~~~ .::'.. . .

1 " "\;- ~ U' _ - .

J ( ~ .'>.~~', ... ~,,/,~,~~> .~a~··- nOKa,3b1B8'e'T npastasa, ~ 'C-YAb,H OTHO'CflT~. K~ HCCJ1eAOBa,HHIQ :H:/

1 . '1'1 i _. . .. .J"

C .; ., )Il.~HKe .llOK838TeJIbCTBKYJ1.3 ~aTHee H OTBeTCTBeHHee, qeM corpyn-

.' . -, '. 'H'M'KIt rA IA . l.,...·~·~ -<

1', .,: . .'. - .'~ '_ '_ .~ J. .J'\¥J.""Ii' . ., i; !~.": ~ ~ ~ .. ~~.' r t. .:. :. . ,

f'.<~· .. _"·· HaKOHeU" cne)JyIOlll.3R CHTYaiJ<J~;-~.KOTOPYIO Heo6xo.ll;HMO· 3}l.eCb pac-

r'\ ,:.. . ~MOTpeTb, - 310 nonarxa HHcnelrt~pa H8K3aaTb BO.llHTeJlH 321 aapyuie-

}: . '.' .·HHe npaann npoeaaa neUleXO.lU-l&ijt';n~p.exQAOB. . . . .

~~" ." '- .' . ,npH M~JIeihJ]eM nO.l1;OapeHHH 'US ~Ha.pylueHHe BQ.ZI.IfTeJIeM npHOpHTeT8 .: ... ,' , ...... ··,n~UJeXOltOB OOJIbWHHCTBO COTP"VA,HI$O,B .fAH nnaaaer npHMO~'r,a]~:H B

.! ,. _ . Jj "/- i.

j_'. '- .. ::':' ~l\"ll\eHUYIO SlpOCTb. OTHOWeHHe K nQ,D,OOHOMY aapyuieamo OObltlnO 6b1 ~. .

':. . '. . aaer KYna po,ne,e ,>KeCTKH:M, qeM K Ka,KOMY:~J1H60 _npyro'";,,y'· (38 .. H,C,I(JIlOt,I'e:HH"

.' - - eM pS3Be TOJIbKO ynpaBJIeHHR TpaHcnopTRbIM -cpe.l1CTBO'M! BHeTp~3BOM C,OC.TOHH:HH),t' CKJ13J1b1B3,e'TC:R ,Bn:eQ,8TJl'eHH:ej q'TO'-~3aWJiT'H' "HTe·pe~OB' neutexoaa-« O}J,HH"3 BblCUlHX npaopareroa 3BTOHItCneIUnm. Ho He CJIe,uy.., eT-3aObiBSTb:C8MHM CROMM nOJl.BJ1eHneM Ha cBErr.e.nyJK6a fAH'QOH3aH3 · uM'le,H,H'o HanH:lJHIO ,a:B'TOMOOHJIeH Hl~O'pO,)KHOrO )IJi"JKe~H:SI,~ He ·GYAeT HX -'

,M HB,AO,(j'HO'CTb B'T8KOH' crpyKTYpe OTo:aaeT· ca"Ma~110~,cii6e.· . ., .

. ManoToro. C»ryaLUlSIHa HawHX~oporaxnll{~J3a'.'~T~~caMH nemexo_Nd MOIyr C03AasaTb JJIQ6ble nO_MecXHJlBIDKeH_HIO,~T_paHcgopTame yrOJlHo.

Bjeectax, upeaycaorpeauux n.lJJl (rne neuiexonax' npe)lQCTaQ1leHb1 or. pOMHbIe npeaaymecraa, C TOlllCH 3peH0H8STOpa srax CTpo"~.·HeOIlpaB. )laHHO 60J1bUJHe), H B J1.pyrHx MecT3xll rAe BbtXO,lJ" nemeXO)l.OB. HS . ,n,poe3>K)f1O _EJaCT,b ,A:Bn,HeTCH uapyuicuaea nJUl~ a'ro}~n:poHlcxoJIlrr' c nonyC,TII'TenbCTB8 :r~oH·,>K.,e rAH', xoropas netnexonos, l'~OTJI:HqH:e or _JBO,l{HT1e" ...

,JH!H" rio' cyrn ae aaxasuaaer, liTO Obi OH:,H 'H:H CO,T:BQP;HJlH,t.'1 .

.- .. K 3TOMY )l.06SSHM H3JlHqHe B HaWHX PM' npecnoayroro fI.12.3, 06H3blS3mU{e,r,o BOAHTeJ1f1 npH'HHMB'T'b Me:pbI K' ·',CH·H')K"e'HHIO CK'OpOcrH ,Bn'J]O'~rb 11.0 OC,T,3HOBKH HJlH: 'OODe:aZJY, JijI>Ke, eCJl':H C'03AQ~tI(H:A noxexy UJIM onaCHOCTL (rOT >ke neurexon) ca,M HRHO aapyuiaer rf.,lIJ(. Flonysaerca, 'ITO as-sa T8KHX BOT 0e3U8KaSaHHblX Ha.pYWHTeJfE!A .BOJI,MTeJlb BhIHy)Kp,eH pacxoears .)KH3HbIOCBoeH .H caonx naCC3>KHpoB, na H,):q>yru-yqacT-

HHKO~ llBHiKeHHH (HeH3seCTHo, K8KHMH 6yJJYT Doc.r.e.ll.CTBHSl -

3KCTpeHHorO'T'Op'MO>Ke.HHH Hn,H M·aHeBpa'). Taxoe Bne;q,()jTneM:H,e, qTO Ha:M n'~~TalO'T'C\R naaasan, «a3S1QHH» 'CTH~b :Bo,>tU:{e:H:H,H:: orosr 'YBHAe'T:b' neurex'o~" ,M ~BQAHT'enb BlbI~ne:H OCT,a,:H8BJIHB3r,bCH unH 'yBo;t1,,air:HB8ThCfI,1j He-

..... J;~liI~ . r "

a8BHCHMO OT 'To:ro, :HMeeT ,no :npB810 neuiexon n'epe,X'QllH'Tb '8 ,3TOM' MleCTe

npoeaxyio xacrs. A «nyrMoM» CJ1y>KHT COOTBeteTByrow.aH CTa!J'bH Yro.noaaoro K'OAe:Kca" ~:Kap,a!OUtaH sa uapyureaae rum, 3a:~OH'q,HBW,ee'CR aaneceHHeM TeJleCHbIX nOBpe)KJJ.eUU" UJIH c.MepTblO ncrepneamero. npn 3To:NJ. :He3a,BHt~~HMO of n01cne)l.cTB'H',R CB'ORX lleHcTB~H'A neurexon-napyuia-:

~ _ _ _ , . _ '_ Ii _

TeJlb OCTaeTCH OObllfHO 6e3HaKa,gaHHbtM~ . Ilo Kp,aft'He,H' MErpe,t M>Ke

~ .

)

.:.: :.

'. l

T FAQaQ,' 13.

c- - • -

_: .. : .. :-: :,..\ i~~ - :.-:.~~:.\~'.': 1"~:~~'" ~~:~.':'~". . '. -:. ~n.~~'" ,-. ~ I ~~- •• '

• »:e >; ::. :<:-:~'):.,__ ..... ];- ~.:..~:,. _... '. ' .-..."

. ~- . ", .:_~ ~~. - (,-V:"l:-\'''~l''ji"-'~::'''''' -, .. E-', ... •

· t~ .~~. ,~""":(,:v:,. ";..:.'.;:o:,.: ..... ; .. ':.~.: .. - .... _ . . .. .

:,,".: . ~.-t.~ ... ~ .. r , ~ :"'II ~.~I.r"? :r, .',. !i~ . •

.c' ":- ... .:0.:::,. "·"i .. _","11 .:.:i. .... Yllj-.I'~. : .j . '.

II I, .. ':I~·:i.:''' ·•· .. 111YI .. ~.;;..4.:: '-:' . '.-

:~')"~:~~I'I "')-;-i _', .~:~. '<.~'::"",.~:. .i > ,r : • •

• -...: •.• _::'i. •. , "'.)'. _ ·(fI, •

:', ··:_~'J:-:~:I. II : .. ..a-.~~:\ "'-! ...... ~ ':- • •

". -~ .:;.;,'.:··;->-·'~·.:'r·:";~·28' : . .

.. .. ·-t:r....· ..... 'tj.... _....... _, '-;"'_' .

.. ., ... ~ -», ":..\r: >"'"~'I;'-":' . ,'".,::."'i: .

~:, .. :~:<~~~i:ff~\-~~·-~ ~::_"b-! ~. ~ -_ . . _ _ - _ _ c • _ __

. ~,. ';_ .... <~ •... ~ ... )..... ',.~ ~ ._::.-> - ~ '._.'. .

, ..•.. ! J"4'~:i!'~S~4'.:'::·v~ ~ ~ .: - ""-"~.'''' ~ '.: . . - - . .

".j' ,~.l!: .. ._,,~ .... ,-.·t· " .. -.

~\.~~2~?f.t\··~~~~:·fit~Besp, H He cnpaaancanpa 310M C 'y,nr-,aBn'eHHleM~) 11, Ha:KOH~~·.ca·

. 0" .... f, h '~~.' .... ~",_ "- • • . ,If .

. -:.:~ .. ":,.:7 .... \.:-?"-',':-;~"'t;""' ... : ~. \ .. - .- __:_ . _. ~ _. _ ,_

~~~!':'::~::t~~,. tJlaBH,oe: B Hapywe,Hile n.,4.13 IllW .neurexcn ae B()3A.epiK~CH

'::~i~:·;,;~~1~~1@f;'q·~p~xoJJ.a yJlHIl,bI; necaorps.ua npH·dJ.tit .• t1HHe narpynsnoro asto-

'·',<'i:.'t~1«t~ii~6~~j rAM, QCHa1UeHHo.ro:~,n~u.cHrHajalt~~. .• . ." .

\-·:::~}J6·.f~2]1J1SK, ;CHT}'a~H: B pe~~l.Tj1Te ~apywe:allih ~.Ho~ecTB3 . nYRwroB : , .• , :-,.::>.:.~,J1)Ul neuiexonoa npOH30wmt:Jf{l ,.B pe3YJlbTaT.t:~ Koroporo O,lJ,HH co-

'H:·,',:.·:':'._i'f". MHJJHLtUH norao, n.pYr~jt.~HJI TIDKenble.TP~~. ·.Ka38JIOCb ( .. ~ ... :~ .: :.~. , .. ·~:i·.:. >·6·bJ·,~. 310 :np,HMo,it nOB01l3ro:ro-~.:~eweuJ1a p :~eJa~W[C:KaTb"H, npHM~eHH'Tb K, ~~~y

.... ,. -, ". . , ~ :So ~"";'!,;.,, _ , _ .

:!.. ' {". •• ..,._ - I' ", I ' •• '~. r .~. • "u

_.::, <'.;':'. ". ,:C1arb~ ¥ro.nOBHoro KOAeKc3, ~~~:i.l'9~~t~P~~MO'fpeH~T3KHe neacrsaa.

:'."; .. ~ ... :: ... ~ '.: ::~XO'T'H:,6b1l1J1H ·r,oro,. IITO'Db] nO'Ka3,atb\nelll90AW~To~e AOJl>:KHbl: He'~TH OT-

,><;'-:~'-: ':'B~ ,~'CT..~eHHOCTb 33 TO qTO~H'R~BQ~tttC, sa :;o~ore .. ; O)J.HaKQ H3 craTbH He

• .' ".1;- \ .t: ,'.- ~'.,iIi ,~ . -" - ".. ,I"'. '. :' . ~. r .. ~ ,

;:"}':?:'~'<~':'~QMOi qTOObJ 3TO KTO-HHOYllb m~lT~iqI."Tb.,:HanPOTHa,·e-'~TQa Cllry·,,:

f<::(\·:~::~.Wul KoppecnOH,lleHT, BCJle.D.,BH,llHM·O, ;38' :CO:rpY~H~M1:I: :M"~~T,unl ,(~ . :_< .. '. - .. (. erarse 'Bblpa>KaeTC,R 6n,arQAap, _ HOCTb sa ·n;O:M,o;~ ·B .Jl'OAr;OTq;QKe ··:M<lTI~:p'~,a.:~,

, . . ~ .

, . .n8·HaqanbHHKY MHJ1HueifcKoH ·j(Jpece~cny)t6b1.l, : (!lf~~aeT.B~n~HblM B

.. ... .. npOHCWeA!.ueH TpareJl.HU ••• BO,ll,HTe.nSI Ilpe~enyeMOr:o 3I!!OM,~6uff! ,Ta.K

.-.~ . . .. . .

Fl D,-',~ :r.li~'-L"I QH,e __ P, - !.' .. - ., .. , _'..~ '~. '.f' .

,t':f"IP.D1 ~ ~ ..... ~' .' .~ ... '. ... :~ .. : .... '>'~" ..

. . ~ TOqK3 apeana aSTopaSTHX CTpOK(HHKOMY,~np()qe",.:e~.He ,fiaR~.3b.1~

aalO): neuiexona aooouie Henb9.RClJm3Th J1O,JJ;~:9.blM' :ytlBeTHHK?M MluKeHHH. XOTH ~b] B. cany roro 06CTOHTenb¢l'Bat:,rrp,~_e He~8a,q~-

reasaoe npoacureeraae C ero ytl2lCTUeM 3aKaJAHB.~'~~,wa~ecefl~~" .. !e~)Ke'TpaBI\taMH, npHtleM, xaxnpaeano, cep:b~H~~ . .>;~\." <: ., '. . .' ....•

. -, •. Ho, .pa3Y.Mee~cR, .MblBblHY*AeHbI 'Ha .llt01l9Fe j>.fK(j\lQ.,crIl9SElTbCSI . AeiicT~w.HM((tlpaBlfJlaMH. To eCTbn~ocf.iJtJl:,[bn.ef.lJ-~M npe ~

.. ' ''I':,&.iI;VI:llle~oc·,T' ·.BO·' ·8 ''1I~BI':I:'''',eH, :HH B yo, -Ka,gaHH:blX I1nJl·f'~~,a8X~~~··:.·- : . '~' , .~ .'~~~~~.. . ......

q,I?lJ .. ~~" , - J_ ~ ~ -~ ,~ I JI- _ _ ~'I.~-;J II I..... ,.

· . ". ',' ".,.' Q.Q.H8KO y cmyaLJ,H.H, Kor.o.a C~TPYAHRKH rN'l ;"~b.~q aalIlYUJ,a ....

: .', . ··IOT:.JlpaBa,newexoA~B, ecn.H 060pOTHaSl'CTOpO""~~MeHHQ:,lWitg,,,U-

· ..... ,.: "~':' gSbl,. paCltpOCll'lpaneHUe ~pa"·mJI'"l·;~~~p"tneAbH020

:', 'iMAl«J8tlluui olJR8aa"ocmu 8oiJutnMllnpfJ.~fI,m,,, :J,~e~()"!':

;:. :tJi,8~H; cooToeTCmeHUQ,; rionbiToK Helo,6oCHOBaHHO,n~e1Jt.tJJQllHf:eJUI

K aAMHHH~pa1'HBHOH: OToeTCTBeHHOCTH. , . . ';i' ;,,; .,' ( :' ... ,"'.

. .' CorJlaCeH:· .CJIyqaerCSI,lfTO BOJJ,HTeJIb Bble3~eT'·.~~fl"~P~Al'P~CIlY'r,RBaa ne~QZlOB KJl3KCQHOM H qyTb JIM He npOAHpaSlCO~C~"03bH~Jt'nO

HblHeAeAcToyroUUlM Il}J}I - 'TO HapyrneHHe (ORoe A~O,q:rb~:BO MHI~('~ . N~£t:ax "Hatie. 'He npoe.ri.ewbt HanpHMep, Ha HeperyJIHpyeltW:X;flep~XOJl8x:

'. :pac.n,:o.nO>KeHHblX B03JIe PblHKOB, rAe JIK),lUI"H,DyT gepe3ft.Gp~,n' CIUOumoM c~~,olO;«npOQY0K,81b newexo.u,OB», O)KlUI.aH·BOiJMO~B~TlI ;~poexa'1,'b B' CO()TBeTCTBHH cJ1lJJ1, au.ecb. MO>KHO R l[ac, H'Jl,Sa, H.TP!l"')~·:· '. '. .

, . )/0' memo soo.Rlue" uunpat/JYlOm II ~:,f?UR',II~U1lX: :lU)aiJa S. .If,OMeam ~npoe~4:nepeJ:oiJa H4 HeM iJeiic".~".,/l.W«J ~.n~UleXQ/4 H.O nepi!Kt)i!u.A Oli ttpU amOM COlleeN. &fH!lID,'':l6Arp;" iJ~U:JICeHUJl,. ~oiJJtCb 8 ~""ux J/lLempax om a8m:-~.6~.II;, ~llmeJtf7 c

.,. . ....' "

nBtlI6lt,o;{JOM,· ... UMetO:im, ·,BO'3MOllC,~oc.mb ,cnol((Rl!J0. ··,P •. aM.:UHg,m.1i~~ t

. ~ r -, . . I I ';~. II" _ r.. ... ..

..

,- : ... ~ .. '

• ..!' - '.;

. . ... .;- :

' .....

It,UI cmPY.D.RIfKa rAM C8Moro'ijJakTa o$ro8peMeHHOro RUO .

nepexoae ()bIBaeT Jl.OCTaTOlfno.:. •• >.... . .

: ... ·H,8, 'C.B,MO'N Ae,J1'e D, ·r.S:KOM.-cJl'yqae ,8 ;A',e,R'CTB'H:RX, BOAH'Te~·,R~, c, ...... " '11~ __ [~)

H,H:R 'IlLUl He'TI H -8TO: H'~e~6,x,oll:HMO nonssrarsca noxasars :O'll: ~' tM •• ;r py, a eMU He y.a.anOCbl'~ OTpa3HTb CBOlfnOSlCHeHHSl'~ np~To.::1 ~DB "~"O"X!i""."_,,,---,,,,,-_,,,, Cor naCHO 'ri.t~.l 'ruut, npHOJll'OKa:HCb It HeperyJI»pye~"

WeXO.ltHoMY llep~xoAY, H3 KO~'OpOM HaXOJJ.fITCSllleWeXOJ(bl~ ~fJ .. !'II ~1I~~~.JIi"1t~~)~:~\!~~ aOA,.'" CH'~3HTb ICKOP'O'CTb~ a, B ·,cnyqae HeoDX,OAUM,oera.· ~;;;'O ~n1a_N~~

, BHTLCf{"lJT06M IIcmynum" tJopozg netuexoiias«, HOIl,: ': M·: n,,, l4J!Wo!§

mes; iJIII' xomopu» 'M03IIiem"6wmtJ cosiiano "pen. ,B'.,al. ".''-'"'''.'-'""'

UIlU onacnocms: i . .. .', . . . .. ;.<.

- -~. - ,B~ 3T'()M]' n:~yjHKT;e· ecrsasa B8>KHblX nO,nO>KeHHSiI. Ha OAI¥O.·~:: ,! ~..r1{1:ru, " '.~:~>~~:."_~~

". - A . . J .. --::.:t

. ,o6'p'aTHJUf SHUM.aHPle. A npyroe COCTOHT B ToOM, qTO~ cOtJl·acH~· . " ,,~>:~';~S~~

. . (J . r . ~ ,·1., ~, ) .. rf , .

B'H;na- M,' o· :~~d3',aHHOCm·6 iJoDUmeAIf.· npe _ n:pUItR,m,6 ':i"a' ',. , .: .. ~~r:~?!~/~<;~·:\ .. Ai·i

' (II: , lI'n ~ ~ _ _ , :I . . ." . 1 ' •• ~ .". r ;»

Bbl.,me· M·'ep· &i" (I·OBlta·tclJ,·em;.ItIOltbICO· moeda, "/cOZOO; ne \., . '.;;~~~:\Y;;:~~~~

.. -' .. ~ - .- if .. (J.. ~ . ...

g3lct! ItfuOiJrJl.RlCJt:'Ha: nepexoite ·8 JflOMeH.m, "oziJa8o(J'~~~I;.f~Sp:~: .. :~~;

'. HeMU Ilpu6A.u3/Cfl,emtJJ'. HOHHK3K He TorJJ.3, xorna nemexo~:~~~:';:;t~;{~~'f~~; , ,. nsr C TP'OTY· apa a MS·.W:tl·H3 Y>Ke H,a.XOJlJfT'C,R npaKTHq,eCK'~ (HJlfl··n-~(t'~~~~:!;':~~··:~/;:~~<·~r~~:~;~

I, . '"' " t"., . . ~.,. .. . .. ... " , .. ~:.i;!-.\, .:. ........ ~ <: , ., '. \ 1 .Ij::_ '~~

.:; Cpl!,n.CTBeHHG) 'H3: Itep~XO)J.e,· H . peSKO OCT3HOBHTb' ee"~{·~·'f.P~i.!~~,~(-~~,·')}/'\

rrp on y' C~T·"r'llT~-b ·-n; eurex 0·' .nIOS . ,nHt),o .sooome H:e:B03MO>KHO,,· J1:"clo.~~n!:C"H_d:X :;:~'.: ·-':;,~:.·~'~:~,;~j~l

' I'J ' \, ~ ~ , ~ . . ..~ ". T". . .i_' • .';' 1't1?:

Bo 'Be'- I:'·K,O':M· ,CJly- ·qae ecna ~B MO,MeHT np'H6J1H>KeHHSI BOAHTeJl~K;;~~:t,.::;.:.::~-\::~,'i.:~

, n. " ....... ........ . . . f. L ',,:.. • .,... .."-. "

... xony neurexonoe sa HeM H'eT - nyrs OTKPblT~ HM~~~O e~e?~'i~~ti~'(;":'::'~ .;'::' .... ) '.' ,'3b1B8Tb HHcneKTOpy (8 nHeaTb B CBOUX 06'bRCHeuuSlX): «B'",~~'tq;l,!~;:;, ':"':;:~;:~:~~

\ ~ - If:'~' ", 1._, '~I ,"-. (0 .• 11-" ~-. . .... " ~ .. ~

: Moero npHon·UlKe'HH,A K· ·n,[ep,ex,o)ly new,eXQAOB H·a 'H,e:M·· ... H,~,·u·BI~Jl~·::::~~::~~~:.~.·.··<.·::~:.:~.·.?:.~

. ew,e ·H3XO){H.ftHCb H~f 'TpOTYape, 'n nOTOMY 06H33f1HOCTJiI nporlji:¢_~;·~',.}\ .. ::'··::;"~

,"' .. HX- -~B-' coo· "'''B'e'T'C· T' BHU' C ·:n"-:· ·1' 8- 1- n'M~: :,;-:' It-· 'e BO-~H:'H·'U no» i> •• I:~ :.. .'. t' ~\' /\ i~~~(~~~i?~:·t.:·:··:····:.· .-'. ~~~

,. '_' '-, . , '. ~~, . ~ , ,~-- ,., , . " ;;,l, 1'\.t,J,1l ~ - ( ''il:~'" : ~. . '.1

JO -, -,. '. ' , - - - • •• l' . A, .~_.,. . . .

'~'; ..... , .. n·'" o~~nyro~ 'UV CHTVS- Jr:ruCl C- KJ)' a- RblB·aeT"CH· 06bIQHO :HBi ,):lOp 1 orax~. il.e~~~~~~~;;\"·?:\.</~:·:~i·':~t~

• , 1- ~_ IjUJ .',J' ....,J..I1 '. ~ ". . , ... . .;(o ... ~. 'J[,t- ... ,~ .' :.'_:y\'": '.o;.~~

.. fl·t~X·' "H-e,CK' n ~'bK' 0- nn;~,o~" c· )~[rtH' .rlDUU;,eHHH B K,IDKt(OM hanpa,:B1IeHH,H" ~<{ilep'~~:·,-·~.··,~<~.~ .Y:~./:~~

,~1. " , -, -- ~,I, -~'.1 ., .,.',1., ~ ~nl.n - . _ . " " .,,r' _: .. '.I .. ~~t, ._ "1' •... . r.

:, . qepKHYTblX» .. nE!W~OAHblM nepeXO,u.OM · ( UeJleC006'pg3HO,;~',~t~~~(~\;:::~,:;~~::\::d

: ·:.OeT3H3BJ1HB3tb taKHN'- 06pa30M MOII(HblH DOTOK TpaHCnopta H~}~~~;;·;<:_'.::.::.:(~ , .. 'lJ'hIX AopOraXtOCT3U:HU. ceiiq:ac «38 K3,llPOM».) BOJl.HTeJJh 'AB~e~~ :'~lf'":~'~:': . ~.<: <;: ::~ . Iip.lt'Mep, nOrpeTheH uOnoce Mil ,l(BH>KeHHSI B Jr,tlHHOM Hanpa~'~·~}Ha."::' .' .. ' ..• ~:< ~: .'; .. nel!SaOM: HOJiOee; TOlfeee, 93 nepeCeKBlOllleM ee ytl8CTKe· nep~01Ql,~~x,,~~r.·,· .' .' : '. :. '.

;"~'.D.Hi'Cfl ne'w~ott.:-BolJ.HTenb npOeS)KSeT nepexo.o.,a 3aDep~OAO:~e:~,~-·: ... iN' :'

.{,~:jlnaBJIHBaeT HHCneKTOp H yrBep)KJlaeT, l[TO 9TOIfY nem(!X~D~~~~., ,' .. ,._:,

.'.\,. . " . ~~, ~.. . ... ~~ l, ..... ~,., ,. . .,' ...

~ ;~"(OIgaaH 'Ci.blJl YCzyrt«Tb AOpory. . : . ,'. " ':, ~':: ': ,.' . '. ..' '

i~~;>;~?!· .. TaK JUf'.9TO?· He 18:1<. BoiJumeAb 86.1t3ICelt ycmyn,u •• f.JP:o~"t:~. - . " ~)YmOJi6"O meAt 1teulexoiJaM, .el/UI KomopMX M.o3ltem;~IiI""" CfJ3iJ.41tO~,> "

• ' ..•. n' . . ~. :: . ~-. '...... ~ \ .. ...:. .. , .. ' :r ..

:~<':'(lIp8lUlmcmBrJeUAU ONu:HOCm&.· .' . . ,"' .. ' ',.- ..... ' ..•. ,' _, "";

:::::: OTKJ:weM n.l..1 0 nn.n U nOCMOTpHM, lJTO:-TaKO~O~g~~~~T~ ~~l

.,< 'ABH)KeHlnl"9Ifo' ~ «H3MeHeHue .n:opO)KHoA 06claH.f1It~II·,;(B':1'eM. 'IRIt'..; , .'." ,

.,.;, Jle" ri(j"BJre~HeABH>Kyw.e rOCH 06'beKTa, np H On HamlO~~~dcH. ;l(i~.O.n,o.~', ',.'

: .... ceABHmeHH.R tpaHcnoprHorocpe.o.CTsB liJln nepeceK81Omero ee). Ifn~:!1 •

-'

~ I , •

I I.. • JL. ..

I ••

!~.~:. ~

"j:. : •

:,:~;.~, ~~ ~:~lJePe'i(fJ,e.cm"u ~ ,nepexoiJbt ..• '.

. '

.~ (

."i .....

..," "', ..

..

J

'. .

.!. ._.. I' :

Ii,. I,

.~ .

,'.1 ", (. "

:.;.}ili:;~;1:~f{~~~l: ... .. .... -,.;

")":'~"J. .... -,' I~':-""""J '.':~~.I, " v-, J. ,-: .

. ~~ .. ~I'. ~ ~.'.~ : .. ~. ~:i.~~~ .: .. ·.·I:"~: .~~~

'.' "": .. ··,·~ .. ~t· ... " ", )~: :

: .~ ... ~·~·::~jt::~~?~~\' .. ·~·:; '::':'~:9':'

••• ~ .. "''01:-':':.'.1;. oJ- _~ / .. "-~.""" 1 .. _

::/:::f~f"~~1i})\·:·.:,:".~\::~~\-~~~~:'~J .. '. -. -----....._ ..... ~11111!!1!11111- ----- ..... ....--- -- iiiiiiiMIIII!ii'''-- -- .... - ... - --~~!!IJiiiiIiIII!I._. -~.__;.~--

;ff~~~r!~~~I:I'IeCKoro COCTOJlHHHTpaHCnOprHQrOCpe.n.CTBa~ yrpOlfS:IWr.uee . ":;:': :·<::.;~~·,>."·;J;~.e,3:0n,aCHOCT·H J:{0p'O>KHOrO .llBHiK[eH·U·f.l ~-H :-.SblHY·>KAalOmee . BOAHTenH

:;:i:-~{j.~&~}l~MeNteHHO CHH3HTb· CKOPOCTh HJ1Hoe~IldBHTbCH· . )~A np·e~srtCT~

'. "'. ."~:';, ~.::<: _.' . ", . .... . _ ~ , '" , .' .. , I . '. ' . _ '._ "~ .!' _'.:' _ ." .: ' -.' _. . ""'111 . ". .- . '.' ',. I. ',

-: :'.: :.:.:.:·;,;~::-:::;:·~~:\~.H'e AJIH ,llBH)Ke·H,H·.SI ~ 910 ~He·.nOJlBH>K.H.bi··H· ·Ot)~:he.KT B npenenax nOJl"Q~,

;, ''', , :r·· ...:s.:( , " ' ... .:- • . -, , ; ..: . -' ". •

: .. : . ":,~,·.·.~::;,~/::?Cbl], . .A·~H)KeHH.ft . TpaHC:nO·p'THO.rO: .:Cp'e):tCTBa· Un:R" 'o't)'1,le,KT, JjlBH·>K,YIllHH·ICn

:t .. , :<~~~nyTHOB npeJJ;enaX9TOH nOJl'O~bI-.~. H BhIUY>KJf.tliOin.HB aOAHTeJl~ ~a,-

.. ~>"S':_::. Be~pHpO,J3aTb HnH CHH1KaTb C150POCTb_.BJMQTb ;llO·OctaHoBKH Tpa~q .. -

J;"· ... _·.::'i:."' .: ";-:' n.OpT'H·O'fO· cpeacrnax I.~ ',' • '. • - •• •••• ' .'1:'" ..

.• ><','; .. :' ··<{aKHM Q()pa30M, e~H 6b1T~ tP6IlMan~at.a~HiT~ Mo>KHO A~K83h1~aTb, ~~_~-':::.;"; :"~TO nOHHTHH npenSlTCTBHH H onaC.HOCTH N1jiABH"~-H~,·B npHHIJ;Hne; He . ~·',~,';·:OTJ{OCm'CH K neiuexonaa - ORM npHMeHHMht:Ton·bJ(O .iLB.O.lUtTeJlS1M

."'>:' :t:P~HCnOpTHblX Cpe.n,CTB" sro COBepmeHHO' H~YCMEiCJl~tfO BbITeKaeT

'., .'. 0 113 C8MHX n}lJI.. H npHMeHHTb ux no auanofOQ: Bpsm:,.JJ1:I yMeCTHO. . .

. ..... . ., .. Ho errb He B-3TOM~ EciIH.lla>Kepa.CnPOCTpa.ititTI:!.~.9THnOHHTHB Ha.

.,. . . nemeXOAOB, nonyqaeTcH, qTO e.CAU .epOJl~OCmb 'If,aeaiJa. am-

; cgmcmBgem, mo U 06J134NHfJCmU >ilpongc"amb' neiuexoda. y BoiJumeA.R nem: Taxaa 06s1S8SHOCTb BO~H"KaeTBTOM;.c:ny~ae,· ~C-· nH neurexoa BblRVwn'e-'H:. 0" C-~·Ta·-'H,o·~:'B·-:·"".ITbC·-··H' 'T::"e- n·p·-·e··v-p,a'T····H·T-,L··n·ep" e X' 0'-')].'" "0'

_' __ '.' ~ I, ~.a.J""~ ..' ,'>' .]",., '_.., '.,_' 1!Io ..... !'. ,-~,~ C .1. '.:, D ',' . -I ',,! ,~, .. -.

pont, IIJJH me K3MeHHTb aartpauacaae ,ltlui*eHHR, MHTOf'O, QTo6b1 H36e>KaTb aaeaaa upoeaacaiouiero :nepexo)J. rpaacnopraoro -cpencrsa. Ilo CYT.H, .. BOJ1.:HT~·b_ npencraer Ha.pywH1en,eM l1:pSBH,n' ronsxo B, .

. .u.ByX cnysasx: eCJUI OH COHJI neurexoaa Hno eCJIu srorneurexon ObJJI n.pH·HYlKAe·H aanepexone YBO,paQH.B,8Tb,C.ft lot a,BT,oM.o6.HnH.:~:···EcnH'}Ke S, -

,

.MO.Me·H·T, npoeaaa 8BTOfd,06'HnH rteurexon cnosonao nepecexan HHYIO

. nonocy H .HH· OJl:HH' H3 yq·,aCTH,HKOB .. AB}I,)KeHHH .ne C0;3A8Ban noxex APY~ ,~O:My~ ner HHK8Koro noaona H8K.aSblB,3'Tb BOAHTeJlH ''''''',8' T·aKo:A (:,0'1)'-

·au.nH TOPM03RTb OH He oWl 06H33H. . ... ' . .

- -. To )Ke caaoexacaerca H. 00S1S8HHOCTH YCTYPHTb .n.oP()ry neurexo-

. MM" 3,aKaH'I'H~8alOll(H',M nepexoa ~Ha ,p,erynup·y·eM,o.M nepe .. xone "·1I.H·. ne-

. pexpecrxe, a' T810Ke neurexonaa, n,'e.p'e.xo'llflI.l\HM; aa nepespecrxe npoeaxyto l{.aC;Th, ·88 .. K'OTO PYIO , B'OAH"renb ncaopaxaeaer .(JIn.~ ,I [61.2 H '. 1,8~~ .. n,]lll).. 3Ta O(i,R38,HHOCT.b· B'03HHKaeT, :TIOJI.bKO ·.B" Icny:.-,q,a!e,·· 'e'cnH.

- - ) , -

n.pon.Dn>KeH·He,ABH>Ke.HHA TpaHcn,opT.Hor~, ·C.PeACTB8 BblHYJtHT ~[]elIleXO- ,

Aa as,MeH·n'r·b· CKOPOCTb H'II"~ H3.npasneHH:e ABH>KeHHH·. (eM I' ,onp~~ne·HH·e. 'OQH,HT.HH «YCTYDHTb AO'p'Ory» .8: n .. ·1 .. 1 0)- ... ECJl]~ .Boat4o;)K.HQ

np·QAo·n3<eHHe ,ABH>K .. eHHR " BOlUlT,en1e.M., H ne:wexOAOM·t:··B .. p~3ynbTaTe KOTop,oro HHJ(TO.·H3. HUX He 6y.a.eT BblHpKAeHIMeHHTb CKOPOCTb HJlH . Hanpaan:t!HHe ABHH(eHIUI, H npit aTOM OHM cnoKoiiHO pa3MHHyTCH (ne ~ w·exoJl ~'a ,Jl.py:rOH· no'n'o'c·e l\.BH>Ke.HHH) - ,o6HI3a:HHO'CTb YIClYnHT,b JlOP'O:-.

ry'fle B'O~.H:,HK,ae~ B·:n·p:HH·UHoe·.. : . .

·Bce. 9TO H,y>KHO!~o,61,:SlCH,wr,b :HHlcneKTopy~ A e .. CIIH np~TOI(jOn: B·ce .~>Ke cocTa~He.TCH· - orpa3HTb CBOro n03HUU:IO, lI[eTKO It C'D ':CCblJlKOH .H8 nyH.K-

~ TbI·n~nJl,. B CBOHX·.nOH,CHeHHH,X. '. , "

,,- ••• ~F .. -.-_·_

-:

. : . " 1:--:--"'"

~ .'.

"

. '

, :

, ..

'1 :'

"

I',' •

.:

I",: t .

~'.

..J. -

. ""' ..

• '. I! ', •• 1

. " :-

. . .

3,u:ecb ecn, TOHKOCTb. l:ho6b1 )toKa3aTb co cronpouears .

HOCTb:lQ· LIl'O BOl{HTenb OblJl' aenpas COTPYJ.lHHKY fA 11, ,(ly)ti]lO,~, '~I' .l~ OO'bHCH~'HHe y neriIex~~,~~TOP'blii 6b1Ji'· BbJ~y>KJJ.~H.« H·3M " .:~"'{ l'::;"~ta~~~~1d

peers H'no aanpanneaae AB:U>KeH':HfI:», QTOObi oCle'Cn,e';lHT.b '! .. ~R~.~t-;Q.~\~~~ 30naC,HOCTb,~ .E'CJlH TaKo·:Boro B .~ene HeT,~ ~O)l(HO CIfHT,3'Tb,.·:,, ".' . ~.1i~i~~~

.lI.OK83aTeJlbCTB ..... . . . . .. -, ';:',:

r ..... npH.pac~M.~t~~~HH.neJIaB CY~~(~:Jlyqllle ~ 3ap8He~j::.·u· .:W,;j::: Wdc&·~~ft~~~.~~

MO>KeT· 3a~BItTb. xOAaTaAcTBo:~ BbJ30Be B cYJJ. COTPY,lJ.HHIU(f; .. ~:~j~!(f'~.~~~~ sasurero IipOTOKOJl.: H 3MaT·b eMY B • sacenaaaa Bonpoc~:~~~ neurexona, npaaa K:OTOPOf<P1KOOI?lObiJIH uapyuiesu 11 pe . :-:' ',~~ ~'<~t"ri'i~3~~~~fB~J£t~ HX .a.eACTBHH, He6biJlo' oTo6pa~o<.:o6DftCHeHl,f(~?» Be)J,b, .... .-...-:- .

~T~269 ;I<OAn/T8KOp neurexon Jl8JIHeTCH norepnesuraa. He~ _Ilnl

. . .'~ . . .'.e;'. - . i.

~H'B ero 'yq,~(~TH8 '8 npouecce, ae yCT,a.:HOBHB· ero Ji .. HqHOC,T'b, C' ffl~'!TiU~~~1~tf;:

rAI1~no cyra, l-iaPYWHJI eronpanal A oanoepeueano - H."-d:"'::&"'-"" 1w.'II.iIl.I.Ir ::'Re~~~!f*j B03MO)KH~M npaaaasaoe paccaorpenae .neJ13 C ou,eHKol1: B~ek·-.t'" .. '!!WII:''It

I ~ • • ' -. "I. • • "", • • : '.' .".:1

'CT'~~S1Te~lb[CTB .n· AOKa3~Tenb'CT.B. . . ;. " '.~

H- '. 1(' . . - .~; - ~ ~

a Bee ·3T··O HY>KH~·.:~o[~.paT.HTb BHHM,a.HHe CyJ]_bH, JlyqweJl.,H·~b. E.IHI;1':I'U ... s ..... - .. ,._.

(B xoaaraacrse ).l1oopaTHTbCa c npocb6oH npexparars A~O(

. . tV ~". - .'. ..' ~. «; ; .• -' .:

cyrcrsnex B Jl.eHCTB:H.~.X BQAHTeJ1'SI cocrasa anMH,HH·C,Tpa~HB:Ho,ro:·.n.c1 t1i7;g,;ts, ",.: .. :,f,

.. _,' ,.... __ ._ ... .' . ,," . .' . ". .' "F ~:'~.ff~'\·i;·: '~~,/I,'~·"'.

BOHapyweHHH; . ',.. " ..... r c »: ... ~~.! '~~'" ,'.

,. . . . . . ,<co . . • . : . ::': •• ':. ::;':,ii,rrtt:t;::~:T>::!:"

. ... .,' '_,;:,.:·:'t:}~j'f:::'~z:~~~;}~~>:,·;·~ ..

• J 'l' . 0< " ,.'./ ;.t .. ~,~ , ;~ ". . - _

. ._ .. , <~,~·::)L:;?~;"<~:,; ..

".. • L ." .' .~ >I-' ., '1:.' " .

, :....: . ,.. ., ;:~~~B}":f,/;>:\

. , ..,. "~ ,- ,: ' f> \. -. "\' .

. . . .,) :~.: ... .:: /; .: .. :: rl .. ; . I '>:', Jt.~:-.~ .

. , - 'j J ., ., -:., .' ,

• ~J: :1'1 .. :.::- .. ,,:',r I! . to" .:. ,-" .. -,' • :

.' . 'i" I' ·"'1': 1 ' ,. '-/..... • ''i : '. I I ' .. I •

... 1 ',.:~·rl~:~': ... I ~"': I -.;: :', :'l~

I,' I ~~ .,., .- 'i il. I,t ... I._":".~~. " I ~: .'II .. ,',

» .:'. •• :,: :':. .;:;i:;.::. . .. > ,,);::;:

. ... . -.. . . \

I; _.'UI... ..~.: •••• ~: •• :. ',.. • ".:' I • ~ •

.... ~, ~ .' ~~'. , . ,

t.~ ,~":' . ';._. ~ :, ,..... ...... J •

" ", t, • - • I::': .!.... '1.;

, ... ~ I" :..;.r., 1 .'0 I •• • .... .,..

• rM ' •• ~'I~ r' t I ~.~ .':'" • ':','

.

r

. .'

..

: '. ,'.';" r, ~"'/':'-,l/:"~. _.~ ..

- .

~. .

". .. ~ ", " .. ~':':: •• .. ~ 1· • -,'

• • • • i"', ',', I L ....

• ... "1.

., ~

. '.

. .

• • ... , I .~ ;.,. ' ... '. ' :. • : ' . '. _o' '. •

'I

-. "l .. ", .;

• , I" .',

' .. '.': "': •.. ~~:. ".

.." 'I •

. .

.... : '

. \\ .:

, .

. . .

. . '.'

J' .

, . '"

: '," ...

. .

. .

.' .

. ' .

.-

.. " .

. .

. . ..

. : . .:':--. '.'~'", :':'-'

J

. I'

......

, '.

, .

, ..., . ;, ~:~.:;.::- . : ... ,;' : ~ .: . .' -~ ;

.

. {..'

' .... ..,:.: ~"_ .. ' '\ ••• " I. - o· .,... ~ 0 • )'.' ~

, "

. ~

I •• " '.'

. .

~ ~ . . .

II;: • ~. .,.:. • "' .. :4.. : ''':1] • I' .

... .( . , . . ~ ~. ~ . -."

'. '."' ~; '. _.. '1"'~

II. .. ..

-.

n"pe.l(p~:cm,"u J. n,epexoiJbl., .•

. . .

..

"-,.-: I

r~.:' ~ ,I • .. I

;;: ,.} . ~

... . ( .

? ·-r~.~;~.~ .. _~.~ :

~} .. "rrl: ...... ".:",;" ... ,~ ..... ,:.:.

... e , r' ..... ,:-"

-:;:'.~ .~,..r--r: .. :.,;

, . ._. .'.""."c"_'_'-

...... ":7'" - .

~:. -- .. _.,.... -::.:. '; '~."'" :.

. .

•• " ••• ..1

.... : :: .. ", .

• • I .. 'I_~;. _ :,.y~"'.::~~': .. :- ~ .. : .. -.

:'- ' ..

, .

·4 . ,,_a' 3a,npe1':_

". 1_ _ .. r' , .

,l.

( .:

I

-.

. .

T()Jlb:K,C) ~;p;HMeHH'Tb UX, H9 M '8 IlPyrHx CJ1,yq'a:RX ,l(eHCT',BOB,aT'b D~:~:reIVJlE,UU

,H"blM ,'06p',a3uaM,~ . _ '., _'~'. _ .

'. - Haaoonee n'p'o.cT'Qil.. ~,~~.ij:aH~' )leHcr»H,e ,SHaK,OB '«,1l;8)H~*t:':1 '1iIIt~:~1 npeuieaos Ii HeKO,Top •• X;':APYrHX (3,.1' -,3.8, 3,.11) uep8e~~~ED~

:Hfl,eT'CSI :H8 T'pa,,~,'~,I;I'OpT'H.bJ,e: ,cpe,ll,cr:03v" npaaanaesca '""j , ,

OOc.nY>KHB8 JOw.ue:rp~>KJ1aH un If npe;!Ulp:HfI'fHH ,KOTO pue np''''''':' ........... '_ Hn,M: H,aXaJlftT'C~ii,iB:, ,AilHHfoa 3Q:He., ,E.c.n.H ,B'O){H ren h, T8Koro:"T I; 'u~jiij·~.~~~~~y;

Horo CpeJlCTaa' OCT8HoMen .sa Ha.1WweHHe Tpe6oBa'iuiA" ·"U1tt:1j·~~H .. ;tj ."~' .. '" ... .;

. , _. - .' t=~;"'")':

xa, . 'OH Jton>:Ke·H. cocnarscs aa M:e'CT'O caoero ,np'O,>KH:,B.· '~~I.i ~.I£~;

pao,oT~ :H T~[J~ ECJJ;,H :q::P',O"Y'O,KOJl .RCe' ,)Ke. COCT3·,BJlR'e'T':CS1· ~.~.:.'U:~ .. "-~ :JI:JII!lI~~ R~·~~'~~:~

CBQH,X ,oO'~,I~lCHeHP~x Ha~3tQ OQCT(lSlT'eJlbCT'B,a H cocaarsca .' 3 npHJlQ1KeHHSJ,j"K fUlll,'KOT:OPbl~M YCTaHOBJIeHO 9TO H '. '~'l ,J o:Jt~lBlrfi ""';l'.':'I"~-";

.. ... .

TO')Ke caxoe.sacaercs npasana a.TOM, xro ):le,H:CTB'He 3HaKa'~<:~' :~1ttf.l~I~~~~~

. , " .: ,- ~

.Kla 3.anp"e,me,Ra'>~. ae- ,p,8!C:il.pOCTpaHH,eTCR na 'TaKen c B,K»~~e,"'~·-:""""'L:."iII·

TaK~~O;Me:TpOM ar.n. IcnytfaeB~~' . , . "

.. I1HO~4S B:03HH,K8IOT :KOH'¢uI~~IqHble· ·C:HryB,.UJIH, xorna . "' ... <.: £lIIjg

,Henp,(t8UA,f:lHO' ,,,,,o4,,gecm 8()'~g ·aei!c,m8tu1 31J4"a. Han:tl~~"~.i;··: .

ObIB,aeT»,lfrO:,JleiicrBH:e.$Ha'" «OCTaHOBK8 sanpenteaa» P4concO""" . ''.It,(J~~·;y.·

'I, , • ~ __ .... "".a , • 'T.' . ,. , (" .

• -!"I.F~'.& T fl~ , . n :~~~:.~ ... ),:;-.

'eTCH TMbKO H'B rycrop _ O'~ JlOpO"rH~, ""fIB KOTOp· OH O:H y_' 'CTa,HOl$lleu.,.).:i.;.~- I : "%·~>rJ:'3

.~ J ~~:.;J- 'i - .... -'-1.1

• • ~ • "".' - .' .. .. • .1,.11" 'I,:'!. ~Io.'.

~a8X, .B04HTenb . .D.OJI)I(eH . YK838Tb ·B CBonK nOSlCH'~HHflX, - ,1lrt)'J~¢T , '. . .'l'l:,:,;{

BlUleR u,a.npyroR cropoae nopora, a He aa TOM,. [IT'O 0603Haqeia~' ", ~IL{,.:;:;:\

... ~.' • • ~ ~ ~ :... • I,. • w'" i l • (. "j'~_' .. 1.~·~=..~:- r~

Ii COCJlaTh'C'R aa.coorsercrayiouree n'MO)K'e:HHe n-nn,.· .: .. ... . ."'''~.~'. :,,:-;::.,,~I·~·:;: ..... ~;~~t·,~.~.~l~~ ;":~~

'. '. - .. ~ O-'c~(j~ '~eM;'--- c~o'oocmHo.iipe3ICUM. (K::'- a' ~ JIna~HiIO~:~~,~~~;':~:~):~>'i~"<\

• ,. - J. --. ,_ - •• ~ - -r- . - ~ Y: .. I~r· ,· ... ~~;:~I·~~~~. -, .... ,

. HHKlI .fA:Ht .,BO'QPYlK:eHflble COOTBeTcTByIO~HMH nptl6QP·a~~:~·'~~yjl~,~\_:::,'_:':1.

.' , . . 'I'\V" ,~ "~'r. . J~~,

r_trv>KOY-' H'Me,HUQ, a 3:0He',JleaCTB~:H '~'HaKOB" orp ,8H',HIIH,eaK>ilf4Qx C,K~~O*i~t~"~,,'~:).;;.·;'~ .):;::·:~;-.r~ ':'.

'""""",~ I '..... ~, . .;~~, .. ',j' '#:. •. > ~, ... - ., ,_ -,

~ .,' 3nreCb"~· CJ1eJlY'· , er 'n,O:M'HH'Tb'O TOM.. QT'O "MeJOIII.Hecn.':Y·','·:HHcrie'K;tO~,r,li~·:i~·~-:;~·~:;~:'\~'~ .';,;)

. . 'J-I\. - . .,. " . .' - .', ,. _. . ]I • -, • " " ~ ,oM..;.:;..:: .. r)i,'..,.~· . ," . .

. . -. - -. ..• -- .'~.:"~i,..II;-"'l .. 4. r~'I" ....." ~J .. 0:11 _ • •

'-P" O':op-- -"'~"SI l.li3MeperH-~-a CK'O'POCTH ,I/'Ca"P' b' e'p"2'M''-'' H"'"· H'M' ··_'p--o~:,n:ct<~tt~i*lr,~~:~~~~~,/ <: ..

:" . I'~. , hi, AlI'." n'" '. _. '" .' ; ~Hn .'.' .' ,'\. U .,' ... ' "!', '.' ',:',.,., .: ' ' r : ~ '. ':v.:\J,~_ .. '....:~.i:· .. :;(~.' .... : "'\'- '.

I~ ,{~I; .. ' ' __ ""'_/ '"" _ .. --."'i!"" "_ __ _ _ l.' u ...... "_ _ .' .- --.. • .... ...._, .... '~" i .. ~.·.CI."IIIII' .... ,._.·' .... L_j. •

• , '. 1. ,. ,#£..' . 7 .~ ... , ~r'~ " ...... --::;.1.:: "',"'$"/'"

IMO,ry~( TOnbK'O 3a""U~K'CU'p~OBaTb' CK'OflOC'Tb on~,oro'~ .. CaM~arO·:Maccil#!4i~;~~~~~:~~~\:,:\~'\.t\>{

" .. l - 0'- ~ -, -.-th. - - _, .-..1'.-. ~'-I, . -.!'~~~l~i'l· .. rr-;: ~ .. r •• r"I'iI ..... ·

_ . F .'. - . '.' i' .;..r ',01 -. ~ i ., , ), . .,. '. "

ri). HJIH C: ' ·-.CTHOrO· t~<'H3, :np.,H'Q,nH>K8,fOWHXCSI o6oeK.T.OS. ,BtJl:~ ·.a*,.t~~~;<:~~,~ t>·;.:y:~>\

.. ',~~ . uAb .. iJsuxee B n.omo"e mp·aHCnOn,m,.a._m.tl ,t1'O"4.~~~~-:; ~/;~~~

,-" -;- ~ -I" -'="" • • .... - - I r '. . ;t~.J' . -.:: oil;""" ~~'~:_"'_"··r .: .• ;- .-I~I~'''!

- • , \ • !' • t I ,... " ("., '} I r

':"',"'.0 U3M,epe",lttl~Jt· .C"'OPIQ,C',tn& npu",aiJA:e",~a~' ',~eIt80, ~.,1~~-."~ ;' .. ~'",:. ~:~~ '-".\ ':~'::-'

.. - ••• .. I I .. ~I. , ,u' .' ':'.:'" I." : .'", I,t- -;'11 .I • i

~Q,~o.no .. Jla>Ke eMU aa npaeope HMeeTCSi-T8HMep, :n:0; ~~~~f'~~O .;;::, - • :;.::.\:;

. .ne, AO,Kaa;a'T,e'JI.iJ:e~rBo,.: ··KTO· M~'O,)K.'eT nO;llTBep.1l'H,Tb, ''1'10 Aa:H,H:.¥\~~~~:a.~~~~IQ'.~.:~·~ .:.': ':'~'~,": ~:'.'~JiHJJb nOnaJlll.3m"YAeHCtBHB_npHoopa H).feRRO 40, 8.H,e 35Iffl~:.~D~'¢~, .. ' ,t' _;'.' :;-r 'Ky-HJJ." Ha3M? (npHCKOpOcTHcBblme: 60 KM/'l T8KHe ,.R-p~.eH~-e" j 'i . k:0,:r'j'-U"Te'p" Ban~', -"bI': 10' s- 'H' ,-:'ail:~a-"'~T:-:- Jl~' '1,~'c':TaH' 'I'HV' M' eWTiJV TP,' a·Hc,nopr,H·,blM:H CP'" ;M~,r.B·~j -.;. -~.--:\ ~'i'"

;'~I~:' P'lII , " '_, -~. _' ".: _'11," ,rv , ,r:l . ~ .. ' '~' rv .' ~,'I.~ , . .' , , I".," "-~ " . "./{ !.~'.:" :<;:~" <" .- ... , ~ ,'.' . :' : t

·:\(::\M'_',I'~ ',u,'3=Me:.pa',e-M-'y,'~n,.' K3K M- 'H,-,H,~H,'·M,:y' M· 'R'e'CSI'T,K,8,MH MeT'p'oB, .. ,)· '-.-",\ ' . ."Jf..-' '~.<' ,,','.~

,{,!.. -.l ,.-,J ,. ". ." - "TI :' if\}' .. ." ". '." _ [ "f-'. , ,_;.!' :' , < ':

.. , ... - .fl - :J , • 'r'

~~;~~":: :' .. Bonee: 'Qro,~· :n'pHOOp JIIlH ,onpe;leneAHH CKOpocrH ~ _9ro-Ha,M~p~~~1~. .'

~~\~:;~~~'p\lff:lon,a·HH',e··. H": ~,o H', 'e' ro- ".:a....,n,~Hbt 6bU11b ,(JO""MeIUllbt~·:tlOiJmseft3J&8~; .

". ~.~~, _. J~ D<l", " ill . ' na..~ .: ,'ClUoij/ikIft;!', _. .' ,:1'Ft "M' ":"''_ ' .. r' -r,::. "",'';:,-,'.

;' :/Jm,II~I,t,'8aO _mnn.ttOa~'ltOammec_"""UulO, ~lqJ,It.~'~~{'K ' .

;. ;"~~" ,,-~"·~,T~'·_ .. ::I.,. ,- .,. .. ". ~ _ . 11._.', : .... _ ... '.-

;:';:'~\~ tpe6oBilQJmM. IiIbI·el,lte sepHeMCSI n03)J,Hee.) Beatl~,q_,~~ .N.t~ .

"; ,~~. ,~tf&,,:,npu6opa He ~ellm IlB/I.1lm"cR ,iJqKfWl,~~

.. ' ~.·.'lflIM ,BUHJJB~11IU rsoiJutneM 8 ,npel1blUleI#LU C"O_~". ,,~;\~~,_, ';,'" "~ ~

.. .: ... - ;>' ., • .. •• ~ II... . __ ' ... .

..

_.-" -, ..-

, . .

. - ~

,

- . li.,t; , '

. ... "'r" . .t,

.. -.- -~~.

~ .

,1iIa-UOB

.

... <, .~.

• ~ l ).)-: : .:

-0·7"-.-

!'I.'" IIII!II IIIII!I '!io <!io

.,','. :", _,,',:Ii~~eJJYeT )lyMaTb, '1TO 8BTOP npasasaer eaAHtif:~ .. eano T3K. ,: ~.:- . P:~~n.,noibleT scero JIUWb 0 TOM, KaK 3aw.Hw.aTbe.H~·:~~.lJ"H.CneKTOp '.~. ._.. :'~'~.~"p~a·e'T, xro B'O)l,HTenb He BblnO,JI.HH'JJ' ,3,~1~p.etl~'~;~- ·IlAJl·:o~rpaH,HlJe,-

" '. '., '.' :·'·.':,·-·~iJfrf" 'YCt3Hoen,eH'H:bI'X ,J{O',P'O)f(HblMH ,3Ha,KaM·:H~ .... , .. ;::~.'. -, '., ... : .. ,,' .'

.•. ,-, _-, -::;~'-'9r'OBopH~CSl cpasy: B cHTyaIJ,HHX, KOr,ll,3UapyweHHe 6bJJIO flB"~/t:-:> If.~~" BpOA~ npoeaaa «non «xapnas>» H8 rJIa-~a8.'coTpy.a.HHKa'rAH, ' ~':.'_'<': .' .'JlO~~~aTb qTq.T~ 6b1SaeT Tpy~HO .. OAH8KO Qaw.e-,:fI,p3H"KiUOT npyree, :,::::"'.' CHtyStUlH ..... enopaue, xorna JIH60 TOJIKOSaTb t_00J:l8HH" H SOBY

;, ': .If.~-.CTBtm: 3HaKaMO~HO no-paaaoxy, JIH60 HHCn~~1'op·:J.le )'lIUThlBtl:" \ . ,er "HCJMI0geHHHH3 ooutero npaaana, yCTaQoB41~eQHbtX C3MH::",1i :, , ,IJJJJl. BblOQIOT CJIY'laH, xorna Ii caMH 3HaKH YCTa~OBileHLI C HapYJ:

..... _ I.UleHHe:~· Tpe.6oBaH·HH~: . J'. . .

. , . .npe>KJl.e ,Bcero:. npe.o,yCMOTpeTb Bee CHTYaUH~, KorOPble MOryl B03H'UKoyTb B 3l'OH c(j)~pe., COBep.weHHO.Hee03M0>K:H&. nOTO~ Ka)K~Y,A. BO)l:H'TeJI.b" leCJ]:H~ KO.H'e'q:HO; He: XOlf'e'T' TP,8THTb ~ JI:ijw,EI"X AeH,er n3wTpa4>Lf,. a 'MaCey apeMeH" - na xO>K,lteHHe no eyJt8_M;(H Ha nOMCK C!6be:3)lOB,' K'Or,lll8 3TO BOB'ce H He nY>K·H'O), ,IlO,Jt>K~",H' BHHMSTeJ1,bH\euw,HM' . O,6PS,3IOM" .H3Y'lf~"Tbt,pa3AeJ]bI np,aSHJI, ,pe:rn,aMe'H:TH,y1O~,H,e npHM'eHe~,

,~H,e .. if, ~lle·R,cr'B,Qe·A6,p·o'>K,H,bI.X 3Ha:K'O,B', ·n ,nlpH,MeH'R~:b~',HX' ':_ K,aamOM ,K,OH'~ I .K,PeT~'o"fi CH'TY~Bf(",~~~ ,M,b! ,me o'c,seT."M ,3Aec.b . "mnoco:(j:W\ ',Ae,HCTBHA ·8

. HaH60nee 'laCTO~8CtpeqaIOLlUIXCfl ,cKryau.HjfX, '1106,1,.; BO,D;HTeJlb Mor He

J ..

,

,

.. ~~ .~::

.,. '1." ,

.'·~l~·;;"":.

. ,t.

; ,J ~;' ~;

! -. ": ,vI" .1-.~ ; .

~

..

t

. f,

, I

... ._

• .r ..

. ~.

,

.... ... , ! ..

. .

~' ,r~a8a ·4. '

.' ,

. '.

.. -. ". .

. I';' ... '

",. . ..

...

'" .

• • >

I ,.' •

" .

, ... .. ..-..

.. .. - . I, .•. ..' .

~. . ..

.. 1,:

' •. : •. ; .. J:. ':...'''~.'' ':-::~?"~" -:;:- . - ~- .' ..... : ... _-.- -. r= -_._ .. -~- •..

~. ',. I .. 11. ~ ,.:- 1 • -t.~ •• -":.~ .. t .... ~" • • • ..' I'. • ........ -:""""-"'r. -'~"'-"-- -'ro_.'Y""'P,!!,"-l,,"" ......... - .. -. .. .......

:~ .•.•.•. :: •. ~ .... ,r,<-.~ .... "'.h .... ..:-::..~~ ,'.' . " . '.' .'

-. it' . -:.., .:' -'1J. ~\I .. ~~ .. ;: "-1: .. '=:"'1..,.. 1*...... . .

··.~·.lt\:~~·ft:f~/~·t;~:r~~S:;·~t~··· . ". .

'. ;. ..... ',' .... ...;.. -", L+ ~ 1~~::k'~ ., r : . '

;'1A.'J::,-:f~ .. "1 '':'r::.~'' "r'~ -. -.,' •

~~~~: :-.' ... .:-. : ... t . ~ -":.:-.-"! '/~ ~ 1., . .

.f.~ Lt;j'r~' ~ "':; '.~!.~"io".:;"-_: ~ .:..::.~~ ~

'.:-s.S-'.~r' 1- • .1 t ..... '4'"

_'1j~ ~<;o..::_ ; • i ~ ::"'~ , "g' < ~.-

r:t. : ... ~. ~; ~,._ ~ {-,:::.; ..... ,;' ,' . :

... " :~" ·~T. :.~ . .' ... ;1"j. ~ .;.,.. .. ~::.~' .. ' .

> ->:~ ·~·:~~i~·~?:~· .. ~ ... : ... >~~ _ _ ' _ _ _, _ _ . _ . __ __ . . ,

... ~;,";.~ .. 'Y.-:.t.l"."'_\':-:.-_. .. :. . - - -, '- ... _- .

. - -'.1- -.:. ..~ ' ..• ~ -".- . •

·~)3~:5~~1 ~~;~~'~~\~'.' >.:.: ~-;- . ..' _ "_ . . , ' " ... _ ,. ' "

"'i~4:;'t:$~-:'~_;V·iJ~K)Ke clleiJyem «emxoonpedennm» 30a9 iJeucRlfJuJtsanpe-

~'j':ff~?i::~~w.lOlllux 3NaIC08: OHa MO>KeT npocrsp aT:bCH no 6JJH>Ka,H,tu'ero·.,nep.e-

,.IF-,: _,,:,-,' I .. ~ ~I':' ..... _ •. ~!_" •• _ ,: • _'

. ~'''' •• ~ 'rj.' " ~ d' J.:.~ _.' . . . ., ." ". I.f!:. .

. ::':L<\~.::~!~~;;£ft!:~p~~T'~at -"AO r-paHH,UbI .aaeeaeaaoro .. n,YH~ta. 'UII:H 'ublTb onpeaenena

'-\t{j~~:M~~1~');}t6JiHqKOH K caMOMY ~Ha~; 'I1t B CJIyqat;pas~OrJIaCHH C MHcneKTO-

:':',,:;'>}2t);~~t-DnHpaTbCH H8 OpaBH.Jia.i. ...., -' :-'-~-; :-- ·

~,~.~:',';~;>" ·<~ .. '···:~,F-;;.·· ;·.B'OT CHTYa"[JJf,f(,, 8C,Tp'eq~»cft CIlJIOmb 'Hi,nSVl,OM H8 3arop0JJ.HbIX

· .". ". .... · ... w· , . ~- ...

:;'~>{~/,~-;_,·'S~p~ccaX:«6e.n.bUi» 3HaIC «1Ii,i:q,uo If.aceJleHHii~o~ngll''ma>> gcma-

:.. I, :---. I':" : ~. ~ r:-,: ~ , .. ., . -:." . .' . ~ ". . . J . ~ .. , '~..- . . . . . I . .

-;. , -, ~<.~:~.:}{\·;~~·:··"().~AeH.~ .« 8: «ucmou nOJle·»·~~,AO~~ij:a~,8J;I,a-.:aaCTPQe,J.:lFl'~~: _:~~CT,KOB, npa-

: ~ •••• -' I. "." • _' ',:.' • 1 . . ~ .. - "..:1; • I .... '!II '.' • • .... ' •

,~~<. ~>' .. '.~.".' .. '1:.< : .).fbJ:.~IU;HX, ,K nopore, ocra:IO'TCH": COT~:Q" _'.:M~er-po',B (3', 'e'cJ1tH~ : peqb. M~'T 0

~:~;:\~\)-,;:::::-.t,:pyn~QM repone - lJyrb nHHeKMoMeTp~)~::~{j~OP()CT~',n,QHW:fHO; HHKTO t:;':X:~<\~:~~:~~,CHH>i<aeT. I1MeHHo aa;eCb COTPYAHHKH_rAlf~ 8'oO_~eHHbJe. ~PIJ60pOM .

...... ~ .. :. . . .. -:" ~ .. .!IlI . I

. , > -;,~.;.:." :'~'~~ij1lSl: on~PeAeneHHH 'CK,OPOCTH" qa,ICTeHbKO H,aK8s:hi:~BalOt:iI~Q~T,e3I"eH. 3;a' ope'- ': ..

::~,~ ." - ',: ,'(':;~blllIeHHe CKOPOCTH, paspemeaaoaa HaceneHHoM ~KTe.:· -' ..' -: -":: :: .' .', .

'-, ~:", ,:, -CHryaU,HH pacrtpocrpaneaaaa. H, B03NOmH3.sr ~,:~bI ~ TMb~ :n~Wb

.';:- :-- nOTOM)', ' .. TO CaM" BOllHTeJlM He 3HalOT Tpe60BaHBH Il,llll" ,'~O'l'OPbleB

.... :' .:" _.Jla'HHOM CJ1yqa,e ,He Ha C,TopOH.e, H,HCneK~T(Jpa'1!" ~.'~" "::'~\"~.:__:': ,I-,.'~. '.'.'. ~. " ',.: .

· '. -;, '--"- 0·12.4 n}lJl. onpeaeaser.orro JlB"*HHe -cp-:.c~6poe~'~~e()onee - -. ,60 KM/ll oCYUlecTBJlHeTCH B J:laCeneHHblX,':' _:'-"-<:':A nJ~'10-I1}J)l onpe':' -:_. '- ,~Nlem nonsmue nacenenuoeo -tiI/HfCmaVUZt{:- '-8ti,10- sacmpoen» .• '. <\ -, ~ :, : fIMI. meppumopun, OOo3HttrteHltaJl. .o11i8etftcmttglOUfUMu

•••• -- - < ' -ib>PO.HblMtl aH"SflMU... : '.:--. >, ':~'" , '- .

. . I - --, _ , '".. .

' .. ,.' '. - .:'. ' To eCTb 'yqacTo,~K Jlopor,H'" lfTOOhI ClIHT8T,bCH .H,aXQll'$.IlIlHMC:ft ,8 ·,DaCe-

.' . ne,U'"H:9M' :nyHKTe" AM'men OT,Se'1IaTb llJ!,YM' ·TPJelt508.a:KHlI~:M,:. -so-nepsux, ,: , -'. ...O()03;Haq:a'TbIC,H -COOT'Be'T,cTByrom,H,MH ..JlOpO>K,H~M;H' SN.8:K·a:M)I:( Hi .r9'TO 'Tpe' _, . (?Q-B3HHe· OtJbl1fHOBbInOJIHSIeTCSI K a BO- BTOpblX~ tmpox(),D,u't,L no-sa ~ . .¢!t·pO~·HHOii T,epp'HTOpH,H~ B ,onH,caH'Ho,H CHTy'atIHR~·:· 9·~- "',9:bIflOIlH,eHHH

. -v . ~

· . _ ~TCiporo T:pe,6,o,B:a'H!!~ ~"p ~p~.lJ:"' HeT'.. n'OTOMY BO~/_/",.:~Ftb. UM·eem· :no,/I.-,

,:' •... - .... 1fI)e._ .np,Q!!p C'IUmamb, lImo H4XoiJumcR ,au' :npeiJeA4MU·· ",a:cew

. ....-:--. . . .

. ':"' ... < .... ,~ .. ·'~eH"-020' n-g,,.,,,'.ma ,"', , ~eJlOB.~'~e~~~~,q~ .. ~ .... ·e O(j"ft3~'~~~JtHJlep,>lSJ~rl?a~~:CR

.. ... I t" r _.c.-..... ~!1 -...:Ii,.... ~ .. ~I~ -'I"t""+'~' ).IS." •

<~" ':- .. ~ . '~ycTa:HO'BJleHH:oro JIIIS!' H'er,o ~K,O,POCTHOr.~, ,nHMHTa. )~:~~ .. :: .' .'.: :. ',. /

: '. ~'.'- '-- Ker>3TH, psap,en 5npunomeHHH I IlJUlqeT-KOnpeAyCM3tpHBaeT; liTO 31Ul~U: ,5~4,5 u 5.46'(T,~e: .. «'o,eiIbI'e» 3HaKH t<aaqiaJlO H~ceneH~,o·ro·,nyH,K-

·1'a·»' ,M «iCOHeu, Hac,en'eH,Ho,ro· nyHKTa}») O,OIl3lCHbI y~ma~a8"u'B,a,mbCR «Ita: t/J,(J,ICmu"tecICoil. . apanuqe a4cmpoii"u, np.uea·alIOUfeii. " iJ,opo~ ze',».'·,Tt) 3ICe CQ.Mi)I mpe608.anu,e .cooep,~,itmclI U ."fJ',·c,maHo,apm,ax" P,li.Z-l14,upg'H)'uf,UX ,gc,maH'o8ICY iJOPO,.H,fJIX 3Ha,,",B,~ '.:! ~ '. ... .

TI03TOMY, BcnyqaeCOCTaBJleHHSI npOTDKOJIa 3a uapyweHHe B "F-8- ,K,O,H. c,..TyaUH·H' ·'C,K()PO'C~,H,or,o pe,>K,HM,a;, B, 'CB'OHX q(}.i4lc:HeH·JlHx cn:eJJYeT y~~aaT:b'= '«,)la~',H,~B" x~acT,oK Jloporu :H"e n',PQXQ~T' ,,:8:. , H8C1eJle,H'H'OM ' nYHK,Te:,~ T._:K •.. !~PPtl'TOp~,H,H', Korff H ,o'6~'Q~H~,~~:!!a '·,3a~,·,",;()',M>5·i4J5!~- H:e ,flBn,R· ... ercH aacTp<ieHHOHHHe nOJ].na,aaeT no)l. onpe.ll.entmne ~H'aCeneHHQrO nyH'.KT~~',· A·aH',H'~~~,_n"i-·l.l 0.· n,M'i :rpa HHll,a ,3,8¢T':poAl(H: ::fI~al;,Q4H'T'CR 8 He ~

,C,KO~,b·.K:H.>;· .,CQ'T.HR~x~~M;e·T:pOB OT 'y,Ka3a:.HHoro·· .. ~Hakil, FI':~oir. <M,ecr8,··-rAe. Sf

j .'

. ~.

• • ~ .. 10 ......... • •• :· I:~ -.',1" • ~ ~ i"i I.'. ,...... • ••

. . .

-'.

'. : I .. :',-

6b1J1 OCT8HOBn_eH COTPY)J.HHKOM rAtI. 'n03TOMY 3H3K 5.45, 8'S-"·; .m. lll~D:M

cnysae YCTaHOBneH C HapyweoHeM Tpe6oBaHHH: no.m.pa3AeJt~,5.,o,,~a·~~~~~~"'1: )te.n:a 33 .OM H CTaHA,~,p·roB,. B COO'TBe:TCTB,HH C .KOTOPbI,M:H' , ,

meH - 6blTb YCTaHOB.IIeH-' H8 $aKTHQeCKOH rpaaaue SHCT x:b~;~~tt!~Vi~~ npaneratomea K nopere. Ilo YK.aS8H-HbtM .npH1fRH.8M· C~"'Ta'ID '._~-" .;""''110::#

-,~ BHHOBHbI:MB, HapymeltRH nJUl». .r-. ".' .

. . nepell Haq,U:'O·.M paccaorpcnas nena cYJlheH B T,8KUX 'Cny.~ta·,=*x ' ' '..,.,....I'i;~_.:.t_,..-" .... ."",

. : "C,MbICJl ,n01l8Tb, XQAaTaHCTB,o 06 HCTpe6oBaH,HH H3 COOTB " , ',', ·1.:LI.",,~jt~I¥M~:;'

~. _. PO,>KHOH CJly>K'O,bI J].oK}'MeHToB 06 y'c,T,8H,o,BKe AOP0>KHblX ,3,H'a'l.<oii.', ' , BtI~f",:,~ H'oe',M' nonpoonoro MeeTa' "·X ycraaoaxn]. H, pasyaeercs, H :, 'O'~ tIS', ~mfJ~:m~~;~l~~~~

'" " .

>Ke apryaenra, nonpocan neno saxpars 3,0' OTc'yrcTBHeM C9CT~'~ :. "

HHCTpaTHBHoro npauoaapyuicmsa. _ .. ·,;:iU:;-/'" r '.'...._~.,_' .. t_.) ... ·~~'5_~~;-.:_.,

. B'03B.pam:a·RCb K,·c,o,6ICTBe:HHo ,3,a:npe~aIOLUH,M' llOp.O>KHbiM .·S~,,~~: !II..;L&' ... !\ • .'~PJ:_~f~

~ - • • .... I,

HY>K·H·Q, cxaaart. eute 00 ·OitHOM HSneHHH., A HMeHHO - 0 ~ ,,~'g'c.·~·-1.·rn~ ,.:a,tJ2f;·0.

Hb,l,g'iJopo,3ICHbtX 3H_aICax,»:" m'o· e,cmb malta,x, "omoPbl~:':", ........ , .. ; . ....-:'J'

",uMu.Hl1I{·He- np,eay,cM~o",peHbl. - . '.' ' ... __ ." "

.. l.Jaw.e scero Mcmmo Ylm.neTb Ta6.nUQKH K 3H3KY (-UJIM H3mtH.· ,- ,_' "_,, ",', ';,). '

. ,~.. 'iii' .. L·.J l ~ ", ~"" '1-. ..'--:

A E(: .. '. -._. .... < -:. • \~.. " :' ~ " -c-: • .:t

" . MOM 3H3Ke) «ABIOKeHHe sanpeiueao». T8uJIHqKa rJlaCHT, K~OP~M_~~~~::-~;~~:;;~::';'\{i

': «TpaH3HTHOMY H HHoropo.D.HeMY rpaacnopry» "JIM npocro: «"~~I,f~s,!~:~-:'_~,~:,~-/<~

l1JIH, HanpHMep,.3n8K«()CTaHOBKa sanperueaa» cHa6>KeH Ta6JiIf.'f_K~~,-~>;,j;>\~::~;{

«,~'OM,e aBle QMofigJleHu.» (4aJI,ee en ' ,H:He· ,ae " .' . ·~"d;" --".>:··~~-··:·_-.:~:T:~:~:{:~~~~~

, ~ I l! .. _- . . -: " ,.~ '!, . ._,,1 ... - .•.. _.

• PSW~M mn2MblltnH yq~AWHi1). . . " ,'-::-f:!':-)':))~;':;'--"':_'}:,',t,,!:

,,'. , ' ,11 38 Hap'· 'y'uieHlieTpe6oBaHH" T8KHX SHaKOB COTpyJt.HH_K"}~~;:Ji ~,~'>-:;2,

I _ . ,''1 ":-I~'''' 'i'"J ~~ ""'~~""

;.- cnaoun, H p,H)i.OM" nblT8IOT'CH uasasars BO~,HTeJ1eH;, xacte ~,"'~~q~~.~~~';:~~: ~·--:':.:<::~·'i'~~~:~: _~~;

'.' Ka'K 6hJ-' Tb B'" T8K' HX' f'JrVUa'(]'x~' ,,: -- ". - . "., ::>~ :·;-:.:~·:~·:'-'·::·i;;(.~<""~.~·";··.;-~;~::- .'·i :,' .

• ~ . _ , ' " , " ", " . ~ ~ - """,.... 'r. J' ,,,,.11 ... . I . .." :-.~ r { . < 'v . fi,.:: • ". ..". .:.

~:. OTl,leT Ha 3TOTBonpoc'.a.aeT 3aKOH YKp8HHbI «O)J.OP()HU10M~~~'::;;;:.\::>:::~,·.

;: .' ,>K,e.H,UH·»'~ E'C.JlH ,KOH·.KpeTHo,lI.2. CT.41 3aKOH3 YCTaHaBJl"8;~\;:~>l:·:,,'(_:'_;

,I • " ! • A .... k'.I. I' I :;r{l ..... "?

'«BOrlpOChI'Opr~mH3al.'"_H ~BH>KeHHB H ero 6e30naC_HocTH'pery~~~;~:\;,."::~;;'):~;',

':: ,IQTCH -npaBHJJ8MH .lI.OpO>KHOrO ABH>KeHH:H, yrBep}f(JlaeMblM~ KaQ~~;~,: __ :-:::~::;>~ 'TOM M:HI,RHCTp'OB. YK,p,8HHbI »'.1 n OC:Kon,:bKY Bon pOCo 0, ~ TO'M ~ . ~M~.K?1: ',~~~:-' ~, ~.~ ... \r·(·~~~·· upaso HHOfopo.n.lUfe HTpaH3HTHbie TpaHcnopTHbie Cpe,zl.CTBa'AlJ.fII'~~t:ij~.. _.. /', ':( i, CHHa .n.aHHOMytJaCTKe ,ll,OporH, OTHOCHTCR K ccpepe opraHH~all.~ff-,liQ)":- ,_.' . ',' .

\:' -)I(e,RHJI, nOCMorpHM, K3KHMHMeHHO 06pa30,JL T8KHe,- :so~pq~e-lil _'.- .,' -

1/"yperyJlHpos8HbI n.nn ' ' , . ..: " .~:"": ; , ,-:'

.:~:~. '"",: ,:, EenH Mbi _eM,· qTO peryJlHpytOTCA OUR C nOMOIJ.fkIOJ.\0pmKa~" ""~' ...

,~::::,<'3HaKOB, 1.0 HHKaKOro OTKpblTMR He CJ1:~aeM. Ho npH BHH~,e4611()t4" . _' ,;

~:~~>aHanH3e npSBHJI nOHesone npHxo.lnfWb K HHTepecHbiM B~M;M., . -";.' _ ,- ."-'

':'(~<,.>" lleJlo B TOM,"lITo nepe"eHb iJopO:JICHbIX aHa"oB,It!,eiJg~o_mpeH.- .

~.6IX IQUl, Jl.8JUlemCJl :U-~ICJlIO'lUmeA " , " - ." .• HHK3KOH, .o.pyroa" HOPMa.,:, , - i)_:;",TtJBHblif aKT BblcmeA HJ1K paBHoA no OTHomeHHIO K~:JO.PHAfN~c~oji:' ..." ";~ K8.KHX~JI~60 . .u.pYfHXJJPPo)KHbIX SHaKOB TO>Ke He'·BBP,DJIT~ .K~KM~ ,-" ;: yx<~: ycr8HOBHJlH, aonpocbI opraHH38UHH JI.BH>KeHHH K CIj1epe peryn.Hpo~;

,.- - BaBRR" nun "OTHeceHbI HenOCpeACTBeHHO aaKOHOM •. "9TO, 3HaQHT. QTO .

"

I

" . 'f'

. :

t, .

. .

, " -~'" I' ~... :". ·.rJlafla ,4.t,

• I • '.... • '. :. _".~'.' _ -~~ ~

L

~ .. ' Ses'rtQnp:ern,OB U CAeiJo'8

, . -.

. '.~ -;.;- '. ;.:.:.

. :.'.

". . . .

'"

. . . .

~;I:~ ,': ~.".: !c:.: <' .. ~: ')-:" ':. ' .. 1, .

.. .1 •• .1 ..... _ .... L " ••

I.. .

.. ..".., . .. .

I .... " • 1

• ,. !i

.........

. .

, - ';";' !"' F.AJl, liU MeCIlUl. " 14- ._, emu -. He UMelOm npa_ Rpll-

1I1111~~'" ''lRW-mo HOBoe, DJIIl. 1lW':'apeogCMOmpeH.Hoe. 9ro_ Bld ~ ""~'_"_""~I~"'I.~~~~ .. I"Jl3 CT.19 KOHcnrryrum, corJlacHo'IKoWPo,A )l,OJDKHOCTHble .mtLUI

pcraeanux OpraH'OB, BJI'8CTH' 06H3aH'bI~~eR\CTBO',BaTb T,Onb:K'O B npe ..

'_~,":',iII~.,r.i .11...,.:, {" cnOC06aMH, npSlMO~ycraHOMeHHblMH SlKOUOM.' ' ,

< :_.: Teneps -06paT,HMCH ,K paait~inv '7 n'p'HJlO}KeHHlI '1 K tJ'·nIl- KOT'GP~"blH Ta'K

.-" To '.) , .- , -' ,,_,.JtJ ~ , ' - - ~".-+ ... , . -, - -, - ,

iiitm~~~M:,H~blB~erCB «JlopO}l(H~e3HaKH~:'AcaM pa3.llM 7 - ,«TileslliNKH K.!l.O~

~,l' '_ ,w~, ,SDaK,a,M» ~ . · \' t ." ;,,: ' '. . . ._.

~r" ... ., I' ...

2:~!,~~ '),. otSHapY>KHM, qTO TaOJlHq,ttai~.()03HaqaIOLQafl, qTO AeHcrBiu~ -K8K~~,

~~~6f':c.,.~~.;,:' , ,'~,iA::t() HO 6b1J1o 3H3Ka pacnpOC1iPaHfteTCRTOJIbKO aa rpansaraae HJJH

~~:\ ' .: " e T,paH'Cno'pTHbie C,pt\lcTBa, B 3TOM' 'paaaene O'T'cyTCTB;yeT~

r),,;~ , " KH 7.5.1 - 7.5.8, 03,arJlaUeHH~e' «BHJJ. rpaacnopmoro cpencr-

It'! . ::>-,' -', ,:"o603HaQaIOT, exopee, KaTerQPHID (MOTOIJ.HKJlbJ, nen(OBble, rpyso-

~~>~''!Y,;~:r~·',:-·· .-,B~e-· aBT'O'MO"~HJI- H H 'T, - n- )" , . '.. . .' . .' ' .

~ ... ~ • .1 r .. ~ • ~ u, . ,- ~... . .'. . .

.. : ~~I .:¥:::. L 1")-.1 p- • • .. • •

;_:(:,>T~:'>""(,,(\ tBKHM. ?6paaOM, HJf'MeCTHbl'e BJlaCTH, HH fAM- He UMBAU npaea

: ~', ,;,', ,. ,::';, 1!'eIlJQaaSAUSamb iJOP03ltHblti. SR.a",' cHa631CeNIt61ii "lie IipeiJgc-. : ':,;'~~::'~: :~'?~'~.":' .~Mp~peH,H,orl HUICalC,tlMU HOt)M,a,ntuBn,blMu,I. a,'·mr"~ ,a~." ":':': ma ,6' :',IiU~ ,u_

~~ t. it",' 1 • • r - -,.., " .".... ,':"" ",,.,JI.,'"

i<";;::::':.::: 4»4 "fl.' meAl '60Aee 'He' U.Metoflt npaea. eocmaennm»

.e,':::,-:i~:-.,:::-:'#p(lmOICliAbI 36 "apYWBltue mpe6osalluiJ:tntlttu% SH:alto~~ ,",,'

:;;;:'~ : ._,';< ,': ,,: Ilpa 'aTOM Ba>KHO npHHHMaTb 80 BHHMa~e, 'lITO _HOpMaTH'BHbJe -, ~:,'~~b:,-/'<"': a~~.y.nOAln,IJYf~e B~UIe, oop~3ylOT qeTKy.ro «8e~tlKa.llb~~: ~QJlla9- .. ; .~; .". :,l1X'. H'O KOHCT,~TY~UH; 06H3·a,HHOCTh rp-ra>KJl,8a:uaa_'(:B 'TOM If:H'C"JI:e H"oJnn:HTe ..

{' .' -.: ., ~ IlL J'~I Ih. -- ' ~....--I..-I< , .., • ' -........' • "~ , -

;,:,;;,' <_> ,:~A.",M~eT ~~tb YCT3HOBJleHH TOJlbKO 3aKOHOM,::;a~~Jtoh»<HocTFIbie ~

'~/: ,', ,~,',~~mfroCYJJ.ap(Yt:Be"HbiX opranos MaeTH'"- oprSHOB'.eCTHoro caao-. ;

. .' ' .. '.:. ,> .. ~~·\Y~"pa\BJlecH,H,H MM'e,IOT npaao Jl,e,HCTB.OS8Tb ronsxo -8 .np e,:-",~q.n' a'~ ,~ .. H-"- en 'OC-O~ ;~I :

.' •.. ' '{~".'L ., ' ~'Ii!1J ,I'i, , "

:, .. :: ':_<~,~M~ RpSlMO ripe.nyCMorpeHHbIMH, 38KOlfOM,: ~.: 19)~ 3a'I(OH' «.0

~:;j ::: ,_,' , ' ~O~n:eM )J.BH>KeHHH» YCTa H asa anaer, lJT()' sOAJiTeli b J1.OJimea -PYKO-~

~~(~:'~: ';' .' .:~~80Bat:J!,Cft rpe60saHHSlMH nnn. H' UMH {lHe,peryJlH'PYIOTCHBo{-

!p;if;,~~.:>-~ ,- /0"' "A-C'bl o~ pc-"r' aaaa - IIU ' .. , -,'- ". - - ' - - . ..1 '~. n"n" '

KJ;:':'~, ,-,,':'~I"','~' ,,~, ••... , 3 ....... HJJ,81f:)KeHHfI, B CBOIO 01.Jepe)(~;~: .1~'onpeaeJUH(}1'i;

:," ","; '",eMlO~~TeJlbHhlii nepeaeus .D.0P0>KHblX SH3KOfi;; r.e. ' YCT3IU1MHsa·

', _ '.", 1O~~'~~08aHHHMU KaKUX ~maKOB .1l0Jl)KHLI -PyKODo;tcTBoeaTbCH ysa-

. " . ,.' c,tR,~K'H, ABH>KeHHA', ,k8,K,H:e ,HMeH'HO SHaKO HB·JlHIOTcH )P·i.~ as,'p, 'eiU~'HHbiMH .

I .. ~ (_. I ...

, , ' Cp@Ji;C,l'B8MH opraaaaanarr H peryJlHpOB8RHfI )J,BHlKeHHsi; :nphQeM1lIH

,: K'KSK,HM'HopMatHsHblM-aKTBM, B TOM qHCne aasurero (ata.OMCTBeH-'

" H~9rHnH M@CYHOrO ypOBHH, npaS,HJJ8 He OTCblJlaH)T,~a C8MH YCTaHaJiJrftBaIOT .Tpe6QB8SHSI K rioBe.a.eHHlO:Y'iac1HHKOB ASH>KeHHSI'U TO, K,8K,HMH 3HaK~a,M,H .OH,O l{OJ))KHbI PYK'O BO)lCT'B osarsca .' . '. : \::' :.; .' '. ~. .

~t -'flo,giro" npa.luie, eCJIH JJ.BJKe'H cyn.r.ecrBYIO"K8K'He.;;JiH()O B~OM- .' 'C!SeHHble 8KTLf" paapeuraieuiae YC-r8H.QB:IQt- he' npe,ayCMorpeHHblX'::'" , fllUl.'38ai'mB' (uadpHMep, CTaH)(apTbI tIJI~' -Be.s,OMCTBellH£ie npHK83bJ

M~Jl,:'a' Ta~~ eOOTBeTCTBYlOlIlHe pilCnOpfl>K6HHR fieC'txblX8JfaCTeR),

, ' H'~6TpYAHHJtH -rAM, JlyqacTHMKU JlBH>Keli,MH 'o(jR~afJhlcp"'"Y·KO'B'OJtCT·BO~';

.". .... .':-.J." .. I I L .. I '

_ , ':, ~~¥I'H_e "MR, 'If'tpe6os8HHHMH n.l1.ll Ht 'SKoaelfUOM'Cl.Je'ie,' a&KOH8.'

", .'I-~..-"

_.. •• ... "I. ,............... " .. :~ _. _~.. olio··

t.,

~' Boaeeroro, caMH TaKMeaKtbl 'HJlH pacnop5J>KeHHSI CJI.e)lyeT'· .. ~ ... ,~......,"'~-"""'" npOTHP'~_'-' I~ ,'-, " I.'O_- 3aKIOHY"",~" ,J,,"-"!I!otl;lOo''''''''

M:eHteHHIO Ha ,npaKTH:,K,e,·. _;,_,~ :.' >" .;;~~ '. '~ ~ ~ . =t-». " < ~.~

/ .. ~ .O).tH8KO Bonpoc Moxuio :riGcT3BHTh II' aeCKMbKO HHalle. ' ", .' ~ , '.' ,;" ,

- a U8 K3KOM~ OCH'OB8HHR MeCTHble BnaCTH7,H:DKOTOPblX na maf&~;~~

~ ~". :·1 . . - I..· .-

~:'; TOB BBO.ll,flT aanperaaaeseaa H8 HX .'fieppwropHIO BO,lJ,UT@eitii3"-' :il' ,!\"'" ;tgJ\.V

.~~~,: roponos> I<~" :!lCmaHo,8AeKue ma"oil «"flenmbt oc'eaJlOc*!-f~.·»:~fJ __ .. r.:o:..

.~ , . . y .I'.~ .

'.;: HocumCR,c,np.llStlMU '1l!AOBelCa? "'-,"'. ":::';~:.:;' ,;: .

~'," ,_, . . . ';., ' .• e~· .~,: ~:.'l~,:'

-,;' " ~ Orser H3 'TOT OOIlPOC Mer Q.2 cr:24 I 'CTHl)'WIH YKp ,'" ~ _',.,,,

:. paHn~Monp~cMa~Ba~:«H~~~e~-M!~O~'~!.::!e,:Tt"~~~~~~~~k~~

. '.' , 'I n, ~~·~.~a·M ;~ "MetCT~_J~P9)K~aH,HH 0. WI" H,~blM rr' DltHlBft

'.'; . 'TQ eCT}) npa ~, ,'" a ,,' ' "a suso-mo

.' " iJopoa,u tUlIl,s"NaCeJleHHbIX'nYHlClllax paspeiuaemcx mO.4f1iPtJ, Ra~~·~,'~£..~

._. " ,aUmeAJIM" np03lC,U6alO,UfuM 8 a,mo"u 3QH'~j UAU meu, '116"';'''' ,". ' ~

nopmsue cpedcmea sapeeucmpupoeatu« aiJecb,' 'npIQiil;;i':·,;;i~t:·.;: ,RpomUBOpe,,1UIl oi/lWMg U8 ~ltetlUlUX "oHcmumyq"o~Ji~).\;~ 10:': ,',; ~ AO:JIC~HUif. He' snaer.ycranoaneeas pasaoro o6b~Ma npaa J3o.!UIT.Q~~:"'i~~>~:\' ,: , . aaBHCHMOCTH OT MeCT8 _np0>KHBaHHR WlH perHcTpallHH TPClHcn~p1',ri:~~-<-:_·,·:;-:->_

CpeACT& H cT.16 3aKOR-~'-YKpaHHbI, «0 )lOPO>KHOM ,ABIDKeHHH».,HaOtJ)Q'{' <:':

/ ' .' _. ..~ ~ ,.!. ." -

,POT, B It, 1 3TO,H crarsa H-QBycMbJ,CJI,e,H·Ho n'pel!Yc:MoT,pe,Ho ,n,p,a,Bo-B6JtHTe,~:.:i :~: ;:~ . .'.~: ...... "':' ,":'

.lUi ynpaanars rpaacnopraua CPeACTBOM aa ysacrxaxnopor; -i~olW:' ::":.i\::'". )l.BIDKeHHe B npaauane He aanpeuteao.To me caaoe npaao yttal;l3$JHi~ ',;,:~',:','~ BaeTCSl H nn. «a'» 0.2.14 n.nn. A ecna y>K BO.lI.HTenb HMeeTT~~tilp~, ',:,', ,~>',,' '" ,BO, '110 xacaerca 9TO' ,JlKl6o.ro BOJUfTeJIS, X'OTb MeCTHoro, .. XOTb laB: ~':_erQ~ ., . ' .: _: .~',:.:':~:~:., :~~:~ A sanper ABH>KeHIIfJ AmI, O.D.HHX H paspeurenae ero AJIHP;pyrnx S.T~ __ ~ -'_,.-" ~,,' >'>-,.

, Jlo>i<eH:HIO HBHO nporasop eIlHT. CnenoaaTeJlbHO, He MOX<eT np_a~HI~~'i.+, <:,,>

• ' . ( "~'I,.~ ~ .. ..:. . . , ~

aarscs HH MeCTH,blM'H ·':M,aCTSlMH. HH [AH, " .:' .. , .: :;!~:' .: \h·:':·~_::~~·"/'."

, KaK}?Ke ro80PHJI~Cb, npo()neMa "aMHOrO WHpeH KacaeTCSI He.ro.I~~)·,f;':/:~,;;~i .

KO _ABH>KeHHSI TpaH:1HTHOro rpaacnopra, He npe.nyCMO'fP¢HHble ,~:.:~ ,~,l~::// TaOJUNKH sacro scrpesarorca us H8WHX noporax H B CO'leT3HHH C .lPY~", ' )';;~fHUR n.OPO>KHblMH3UaKaMH. Ilpescte acero - pa3peWalOUJ,HMHHJlH~~ :_.. -':.'::,'-'_:

. . . . ~ ..

n pe I' I' '8 10 - - ~ - - ' . .)

,: , ,,~. ,,]JJ)fMH CTOS1HKYI . '

" "HanpHMep" 'B KHeBe DOMe :maHHU JlHrLlIOM8THlJeCKHX JlPe.Q,ct8BH - _"

',:' ,~JlbCTB xacro ycr8HoBJIeHbf3H8KH «QCTBHOBKa aanpeuteaa» C Ta6nWf-' "

~:," KOM: «KpOMe 8BTOM06HJIeii.aoCOJIbCTBB». Bosne ~HHHtrJle HaxOJtStT~ .1;:" OCP,HCbI .pHPM, qacro MO>KHO scrperars 3HBKH «CTOSlHKa» c raonHlImH, t' y,K83b1B81OW.eA, sro npenaaaaaseaa OHa TOJIbKO ,lJ,1I:H 8BTOMo6MeH _COOT~

,I ~ .

'~,t, ~BeTCTByID~eH "H,PMbt~ .To )l{e caxoe lI!a,CT,Q ,MO:>KHO ,YS,QAeTb Bt;)3JJe roey-

'; . \ "

/' ~ap!CTB,eHHbI_X yqpe)l(Jle,HHH:.

, .'

" : " fI)JJl HHQerO U9Ao6HOro, pa3YMeeTCH, He npeaycaarpaaasor.

'~,HHCT:B,eHHble, rpaacnopruue cpeacraa H,MelOlllH~ ,~',p,eAYc,MOTpeH~' ,HYIO Ilpaaunaaa Ta6J1HQJ(y, KOTopas pacnpocrpaaser HJIHHe pacnpOCTpaHSIeT aa HUX )leACTBHe 3;HaKOB, - :7TO- MOTOKOJIflC·KH H

,..,tr· -

-

I,

~

• .1,'

I ",

"! •

6.e:~· sanpemoe U CAeOOt!J'

~.

- -_. - -- - . - ... -:"'--'''''--

.. - "'~7·:"_. - -- ~--.~-~. -=--~ .. -..~ .. - ._._..... .... ...

. ,. _' ..

rnaBa 5 O&rOH -

: .. ' ,.

.. '~ ~/ .... +

-,

. \

. ..." .

. .

I . . ..

·-ell.:8 'TO:H

I~ '.' - ~

oe'"

..

.

.', .

......

.....

. " .:

'. ~ v., •

. .

I~ •

, "

, "

, ,

. :';' .... .r~,

:. I "

•• 'I ,I •

I •

. . ' .

. +

.i .

. t. .

., .. , I

",... I" .... ," ....

:.. r •

,,(~ ~... ' .:

,' ....

. , . , .

;'.1',., ' .. '; '\. .

. . ....

. '.

.,

, r

.. ~ i>

I •

, , ,

~ .

y



,

.. -

. . ...

.,

. I

, .

. ~

L "

. '.

..

. ,

-.

v " •

,

. ~

, .

• I ~

.;.I" ....

,',-

• • I ..... '_,' -,

. ., I

.;.::: .: ... ~~.,L· . "' .. :'

: . • .•.. I. '.

, .

• • ;;~ ",..,', ::".: .: .:', I • "I '7'.: ...... ~ ... ;0,.

L • :,.' '.~ I

. .... " .

, Fsaea 4.~

.... " ..

• I ....

.. '

: .:.:_. '! .

. .. y",:' .:.~,"::_::-I .. ~ -r·' -, -~.'-.,'

•• .._ :.' .." ; .,,: I". '. "~.i.' (. . :-:. ..... : ';.

. '

..... ~.. II

.. _

.~ &11·· . ~ .. ~

• --"""IIl"""" ._- - ....... - ,,- -'-" •

~. ~_., .. ...---:....... .. ~:

.M

_... - - ~

-

B'o,A o6QiqHHe)~ Ha 310M :U CAeiJ,em: «acmaueam« 18 CBOIU

JlX: 8,6Je30a Ha 8cm~y~: nOllOell He O&IJIO, a 6tJiJto·' ,~ .. I_"''I

Ita {Jopc1ae, UJH,e,IOUfe~ .llIe: nOJlOCbl 8 mxOOM ' Ilpa paccaorpeaan ~E:Jla CYllOM :uM'e,ei CMbllCJl

, ... • I !II"

o nocanse aanpoea.a COO1:BeTCTBYfO:WYKr. ' . ' e ~ II

•. ;1< . ~ .

lIlHp~Ha npo~a>!<eu.4a'cTH B Mec'if! «H3pYOJeHHSI»? .' :V'~>":~;

. Jtanee coow' $BOry :~~ P.OKa3h1SBTh TaK. np,~ . pnaa npoeslKeA. LlSeTH ~. 1 r:~M:,.' 3, .LU,H-Il-H,H:a 06r'O~HfI'e:Moro. 1r ·,ii naf,iBDrma ...

Cpe;xCTB8 - OKMoZrti;. 06rOHfllOtQero -J,65 M. COrJiaq'Ho·· . a.l~1

( . . ·1 ~~~~ml

· ... ·BOJtHTeJlb caM .. onp,elt'en:H:'eT',; B saB:H:CHMOICTU 01 PHJl8 ycn6BHi~! .

· ·.·:HblH aarepsan, ,n·o"Th~)"lJP'~ pa~CMO'T,peHHH neaa B ICYJJ..e MmK~HO ,lIa~~1I

KHe noRcHeHll~: «}l~04ar.u, .'U'O oe30nacHbu'lHHTepBM. OT~' . . ""'"l'. ... mr~:;-oII:riUoiW'.Ji-.-"'"'-'

.,npaBOfO K,p:aH.o6roaRe:Moro rpancnopraoro cpencrsa CQ .. ;, . ,=wot:l'l;i;'l;

. Me~ o6fOHH~ftlW~f'Ho6roa,H~lI\HM ~ wrb MeHee. I M,'ME!, . . .

Kpa~M'.~oo;ro'~~:iow.ertl"TpaH·c~~OptHoro.cpeJtCTBa·H BGo6pa>Kae ' , - 0;5 M" MPH lOJIpolte np~H-qaCTHll M lJ8CTb.nOp01"H,';.·'!' . It._~

QeHH(iS1 AnSJ.ltBWKeuIfR· BABBeo'" .1t80pSBJlefmH wtipuooiio; ''''''¥.''o.c.!Y_,

llB~Ji()iu:)cl'll .D,8H1KeUHR; H~o.u.R 83 sroro, SI cosepuraa , . '." .

• ~ = -

,B&J'eSAa :HB nonoriv scrp e'JHo:ro ilBH>KeH,Hst,. ,KOTo'poe~,~ B. 1 I ~~t;rfii~.l~nl'iIf;'~~fS~~~i

~. .~ . ~ .

n.I ~ lO'-IlJlll.; He RBJI~eTCR:b6rOHOM; nOM'OMY CqHTa1O,~lItonJ)-~~·BJrlJff(~BlI

aa He "R',a'~y~,,~wan.'t H'a .91O.M OCHOBBHHH ,np'" owy npeK'pBTJITJ)·,a.t,Vl~ .. _,;!Ij . ri:N.;1!ll~J:..,,1

.. I FI_ _! " ..... ..:-. ~

·CTS:H'e·M: I coerasa ~H~Hctp'aTH:BH'Oro npa,BOH:apy,wep'l(tl:)~:~,: ,t01 ...

I I ... [ijI ..... ",,", I, ~ .... '~I

M:O>KH·'O YUS8Tb H B nH'~bMeH'H'OM ,XOll8TB,JlCToe. 0 npeK,p,a~~B~iR· "N n rfiJ" ,~., ... ;:w,_..,._< .. ~

Flpaorcyreraaa B MarepHaJl8X.zr.ena nOSCHeRHH BO.JJ.HTe.h. .. . .... . ",_ . ",,_.,.,-;',;,,' ..

ro rpancnop THoro .ep e;ll:C'fB3, CorJlaCHO KOTOPblM 06rOHHI8_ii,~B"i~;-'~1~~;t~:~,~~

.. . • ... • . L.' .. ' I -r "i:'""';,.-,t.-~.\~ ...... :i. ... ~. ":: f. .-,.' ..... - 0

.a"Q n H'- a- n':_:·:n.·nocy-· scrpe ~',:f~O~ ro ·n~'"·~e'-H'~' Hq' (a HX npaKT·HqeeKH<H"HK~n~'~~tJ0~~.:'"}-;~~-

;;~eT)t';~ AWM~-=~po~r~b ~'POCTO HeqeM. A p83TaK;/~;;tI~~'i.:;··"Cl "-.:,.,r"o.,

. , - . . L·. ':t...I- ;::"'-,1"·,1;:, .", .~

3H8Tb OO,ll.ll'reJJSlBHHolmlitMa HapyweHMH npBBHJI 06roH3 ·neaaBMo~J~~~~,i:~; ..

H\1\IlHO nOMHHTb. lJ'TO OT'BeTCT,BeH.:HOCTb 33 (Jea·OIi2f0llotu. ,()·O"a;~t~~,;~ ..

J "-,I!L'I!o "-' . t, J-~~ h <I~.... • -:lr~.

T3,KHJlH H~alJe, JI~HT sa TOM, KTO .ero coaepmaer, Bee }npUB~'fV:,~-. .' ..

-onp ODf;I·gH~-HA:·.MO: 'PJJT/-1'~'fITb neMCfS,ElHH'bI ~Ton,bKO· ,B~ Tex:CII'dl; .. a:HX,·~H6r •• I1~.';~i.-- .. ~, ~$:~:I ..

v' ~ P~ .. , '" . ...."J.-oiU:g"' ... , ~ ~ '. '_ ,. ~. . ... ~~. t •. Ji_ '.1<' ........ ~~~ ". ".r. " .~ .... : ~y,'!, ... /

B·peayJibT,ne 061"0113 He npOH30llJRO. ECJlI;I OHO nMen()·Me_c~:;:,m1',~-,,,\,~--;,-.~<:>.::;~:;

MY rrpoacnrenurero ayJJYi-'·CKoPee Bcero,:Boc6TaHaMHBaTh"'9iRiiipfiii'+<~' :.'.:>: ::<1

.' tiD MeTQD,aMH. TOJIhKO OnpaB,D,bIB3TbCH, B03MO>KHO, ;6YA~T)'lIte JieKQtIy;i'. ',',:' . .; ::<~j \ ~ .. n03TOMY .aee onWCaHHbte· BbIwe cnocoou a8w.HTbJ,K0taphl'e;'IU'~' " .. ', .:';.0', ;~;J :~ :" '~MOqb' B cnopJ.lWX CHtyau.umc, He )J,M>KHblBCe me CT8UGBti1LCB GeH~k< ',~'. :?:1 F.uHeM MSI roro, qTOOI:d pemarsca na PHCKOB3HHblH -H Heonpa_ilHWR·., .- -,)

"~'.'.~06roHB uaD.e1Kll.e Bbl'HrpSTb KaKYIO'~TO MHHYfY... . .. - :';': .: .. ;' f> ~.J:' . . ' ..

· ..... 'f -i 1 • • _ • • • • _. •

:.- ~ . ;.' .. ,....,\..... .;_: . .:,.. .

· "f _. , , • . .>,

·;"0 •

· .j .• ~ . . . - '~.. . \~ .:., ... 1·~ ~ , . ~'.~.' ~. ... ..

• ~ (. .. .rL_: ...' • ,- I

· i",' ....

......

~; ... ' ': •• ~ •• 1..

:: I:. . I.:". ~ I.

,-t:. •

.. ( : • I

:.' ~:~ • ",:. • vr , -.;

.. .'. . .

.... '. -... . .

',' .. , •• _. ~ ~ ~ • ~ ~ I ~ • • I ....... : . 'r >.. ..._

, ~ • '_ • I • ....' I I:'

J j

: ·1

t . .' ~

~- ;.. ".r. 1,1, -:: .~""

..

.. • - I •

",.

,;.~ .:··.:~·-.I~"· .. ,' "',";." I 1 ~._ ••• "

'I ~..... j"I :,;

I .... r .... .~ ..... •

• ... I'

I I.' , •

~::-':.: .. :Ii" . ,·_I:l.I1 .... ~ . ).J:" • 'I

.' .. , '-. .'

.... ' .. : ' .. ~ ~ I .,' ~

' .. ,' , , .

...:

..

.' . :".

• 'I , ~.. L .' • ,}

.. ',. ,::(,~... '--

. ' ".- .

"S< .: •••

• ~I ..... ~_ .... _~.:II.J. I!~"". ~.

. , ".

. ! .

, . . , .

·1"" . I, .~~ I.· ,

i.. --' ......... .,

t~T .,IJSe,vH. - oeso mO'/tKoe

~ . ..-

,-, _. ,.

~

• • p. ••• ....

• .. t~. ~-. ,..

.. ~. "'I •• .""'1 . :" ..

' ..

. .

¥ .... ~__ _I..~ ..... -r-..---:- -_... .

--- - - _._.

'. ,

....

.. r • J1

r" ."11 ••

i. . , .

. "

H.11H aarpysxa (BblrpY3KH). rpysa, ; BblnOJIHeHHR Tpe6oB8HHH : ~~1.7~_~i+

.AOCTa.8Jle:HHH npeH:My; .' 'eCTal' .'0 ~ ·'ABH·)I(e.HHH, BhlnonHeHHe T' - ...

.pe:ry~Jj.pOBQ.UiKa; C.,H.rH8JlOB.CB,eTocJlopa. H T.,n'~)M' ICOOToe'TlcTBe . :.',: .

. ~ - npexpameuae ,nBlQKeaHS HS BpeMfl 60nee 5 eo HeCBH3aHHblM C noC!UU'oH (BhlCa,D.KOH) qa . ~:~. ~. ~".~_._.. ·.!J,'U'.,;;;c,K'ia!"

, '. eN '. D;~ en(J~~11

np~morymeCTB3: B·JJ,BIDKea.HH, BhlnOJIHeHH~ TpeOOBaHHH'.p: ~ r;r~.';~~

K8" CHf'H3JUlS· CBeT~ih.(ip~a If· .~~',~ ,0.-........ ,j .... ~ . ft.. :' . ' . .:r. :;i

"i . "¥ .'" T · JI. }.. . . '. , . «»

3aqeM 310 HpKHO? '.' .. '~..... ~

£leJIo B TOM, ~TO :H~ :np8KTHKe BCTpeQ310TCH cHryaIi~H,~ . . ,lJ,HTeml HaKa3b1BaIOT, 3aCTOftHKY B, MeCTe; rne ona 3aripem pa3p~w[eHa O·CraHOB}{.~~ YI BOT,3AeCb ancnexrop, COC'T3B·H ~ '. ,'.:'1..1 r,"~

TOK'O,J]., AOJl>K'eH np'eJ(OCTaBHTb ){OK83aTenbCTBa' ,'foro q'. 'TO', ",' """,

.' , .. '.' '.Ii<I,~I.~

'IIJ.eHHe )l;BH>KeHHH»JVIHJIOCb DOJlee :) MHHyr H He 6b1J10··. .'. 9\"1.

norpyaxon-aurpysxojl. .' . "'.' ~

" . f'

PeaJIhHO TaKHe AOKaSaTeJ1bCTBa npeaocrasars npaxr .. ' '. A' ~;'_iU.·;· '-~'p' .. '~c':~iin~ ~..1~~;~

,MO>KHO, 'eCJIH TOn'bKO a_,BT'OMOOHJl'b, He 3·8 sanen no ca,MhIe, -, ·., ",ft',-=- ""Y"';".--'.'

caeroa, BblnaBWUM aenemo aasaa., B crropaux cnYU1HX ~:Q~~, ~~fji~l.~~~

)KeT YKa38TbB CBOHX otJ'bSlCHeHHHX K nporoxony, liTO' · ,.' .' J1.0JUKanaCb MeHee 5 MHuyr H.RU ObJJla CBH3aHa c nOfPY9KoH~.Y *,~ IJ~t~I~.~. (aanpaaep, O,lUlH qeJIOBeK TaCK3J[ KMalUHHe HeCKOJIbkO ."' '.,' '&I!I';''-~:~~'Io..'..\1

TOlJHO.MHTenbHoe speaa), a nOTOMY CTOHHKOH He SlBn~aCb'}l. ~~tSI~1

HYiKHO nOMHHTb H 0 TOM, -rro iJeucmsue 3IiaICO":~' j'O:R"'~ fl'. a

sanpeUfeHa»u «cmoRHtca sanpetueua» pacn<'"'lJ.· ,alia' fllUa~§o~. ~~mOltblCO na my.cmoPDlty 80POlU, na IComopotl OIlU;,' ..' .' ",bl. B enysae npe).l'bHBJleHHSI npeTeH3HH co CTOPOHbl cOTPYJl.RHlCa:, COCT3B.1JeHHH npOTOKOJJ8, BO;lJ.HTeJlb AOJUKeH YK3aaTh B ,CB.OHx nOH1....; ... 11 ::::J,~,FI <-BI'<~.

HX, qTO OCTaHQBltnCH Hi JJ.pyroii CTopOHe nopora, 3 He .Ha:~;r:OA,'·q,o: '. · .. ···(:~ ........ ~1~~.

3HaqeHH 3H8KOM, If COcnBThCH Ha COOTBeTCTBYK>IIl.ee nOJloX£eHHe" .' '.~'1~,( .<"""''''i.'''~''''f""!·

Ilepesen» MBCM, loe sanpetueua ocmanoesa usu.cm '. . "t;W'·\..·$.c$·.::~·L>It-~""!;i"W_Qi.~

~pu8eiJeHHblii 8 OllA, Jl8.11J1emCllIJCICAIO'l.UmeAtillblM. Bo",,~pe} t~~ .. ~·1if.:1"';1 ,.'I:-;O<'I;l«>-:,,=.wT 1'anbHblX cnyqaHx OrpaHHQeH}IJI ua OCT8HOBKY HJIH CJ:OJlHKY lfIO~a.io.~::,'," .".' AHTbCH TMbKO,Cpe.D.CTBaMH pe'YJlHpOBaHHSI Jl.BH>KeHKfl - . .llOpO~HQH~ .. ~'" .

.. 3.H8KaMH HJ)',H pa3MeTKOH . . . . -' ~,;.: .. ' :" .: '._

. . . . . .. ,.. . • .., ,..., ........ ,.' ' ~:, i. _;:

'. Orp3HM'IeHHB, H~ npe)t)'CMOTpeHHble n.LUl.~ MOryl BBO)J.HTbCft r..te"",. · .~'. ,} "j

'., fTHblMH BJI3CTSlMH BCOOTBeTCTBytOllJ,eM nOP.SI,lJ.Ke Ha~TAeJlhHhlX.~8CT~,' .' .- : .' .:,~;

~:I(~X, xoropue H 0003HalJ9lOTCH OpH 3TOM cooTBeTCTBYIGJ.1J,H""U·· ~ "}

·$HaK3MH. Ho OHH se UMBlOm npaea sanpetuam« cmORIl1qJ.: na. . .;,

'meppumopwu onpeoeneunoeo muna UAU, /l.anpUMep, Se30e, .' .. ' , "

,~,poMe oxpa!fJ!..eM~ cmOJlHOIC, s HOff Hoe BpeMJl·c.;,: ;" ;,: ,::". . . . ' s ;~'.:

~, ;I.~ Bee me T3,KJle Kaa.YCbI npoacxonsr H, YBbI, Hepe.4If!?,~' .~CJUI BOA"'-,~;;· .' "\~~

.teJIB npHBJleUlOT K OTBeTCTBeHHo,CTH 33 raKHe «HapyrpeHHSI»", TO '8.,- . : ;

~" . ' " I" . .A',. '. , !

, ~eHX O~'bHCH~HHHX OJ{ )lOJJ>Keu qTMeTlfTb: «OcTaH~~Ka .. ( c!~~Hlqir, ,

~ ~ ." ~~", .,

, .

•• - "'11 ~.. -

.,. ~"I.;-1·.

. - , .

.... .

. .

. '.

. r r

... .

. , .. '/' -'

• \~ ':Jo) '". ~

" ~ .. <r ...

•• &-' ,..1

.111 .iio .... ..,. I

, . ...-....~ ·"-0"

..

:">=-'"'.:." .,~, ...... -.;=::7

... .~. . "" ' .

... /..... ": '_.,' . " '. ~. .' ~ .l- .' i-:> .

• • 1 ';/. - J • • • r

>_ ';". l .. ~ . J .' " • ". _ _ _ u" . . '..' . .

t? -. ...... ".~ ... ~onp?cblt_ CBH~aHBble .. c . oCTaHoBKon::." . CTOSlH~~,4IaCTo HBJlSUOTC~

r~:~~ : '.: .. BpH'IOBOH He.zt.opa3)'MeHlnt Me>K.llY BO)J.HTe.neM ]{ 'Co:rPYARHK8NH rAI-{ B

"lI~,. '-::.-. .. ',.." ,. . . "J

it. "';it'r' .. :~. :.,.-,,: .:.: roponax Hap' y~. -weHne· np,',8BHJl locraH,OBKH H CTO.RHKH"'·g·BJ1HeT'CfI n,o>K,~-nvA.

'It, ;.,;;...~. ". . . ' . ' . . '. - -, ., -... ... J J

ti\<:;,;;~;:.:' .. ::PJlI'IHM 1t3 H3H66J1ee pacnpocTpaHeHubIx HBpyweliBiitfl.lUl ..... ll.eHCTBH~

~~l{f; ... "\ .... ~TeJIb'H, blX~" 'r"'n· .~~ M' 'H' ·'rl',[M··~'blX·- '.: ". . ' .. - , ,<'. '. , ' .

~ :, .';~7.'., .' _ rl. r.l · .,n.·. _.. .. .:" r" .' . .

I~; .,:;::.".' '.'. . .' Ilpaaaa, nocne BHecel!HB 19 .. f4,eHeHHH B KoAn, Yi£OTPYAHHKOB

~>:'" rAH 0't0pe@JI," qo,gWWQSliAp"iw«aa..IIDuepuwe iRaKil Q ~kIQ..

.~~. '.-; «ooeCneqeHHH oq,opM.neHHfI Hap meHMiI», H 0011'0118' npO.6neMbi

I. • s • C'3HmlCb •.... e,n,b H.·,plIbie 3HaKH CHHM3J1H, K8K np~BHJlO,..JtMeHHO C

~~ aBTOM~6IJJleHt npunapKOB3HHblX C HapyweH8eM flJlll~ B pesynsrare

i' . q:ero ananeneu ,0'8 N1HTenbHoe ,BpeMfi 'Tep' ·Jln B03MO,)I(HOCTb' nonsso-

,t r

f BaT beD M3WHHOH. CeHlfac pe'lb H,lJ,eT TOIIbKO OOa}l.MHHHCrpaTHBHOM

i BSblCKaHHH S3 napymeaae fUUl. 3TO, O)J,HaKo, He,aua'lHT, 'ITO,C na-

1 J(OlKeHHeM rasoro BSblCKaHRSI, eCJIH 3TO )J.eJI'i'eTl!SI JlBHo:ouenpaSHJlb-

i 90, H:Y)K·HO corJlaW,aTb,Cft~,.,. .

l /G'.

j .' .a3ICObi.U 80tJumeltb iJoA3ICen «emso 31Ulmb pa3Huqy Me.iJg

o,cma,IWBICOu. U c,m,OJl.,HICOU .. Cor naC·HO n, 1.10 nrr}l.,-,2CT·f;JHQ,BJ<a - ,310

~ . r". £I ..

npeKpaw.eHHe .D,BH>KeHHH rpaacnopruoro CPeJl.CTB8 H3 BpeMH ,; .. , Ie ,'M .'.'

HJIH 6o.riee, ecnn 3TO Heo6xop)fMO JI,.lIH nocaaxa (BblC8Jl.KH) naCCa>KHpOB

: ' . .

r &5. _ C.

• _1-

e-.

, , "

(~' ~ .. :<:. 'y~ .. (!

• • ..• _ • "/ :",).;-t ~":. • ' .. ~ .• :. • ~ .\~ ... oil 1 •

••• ••• ~I. I~ ~r~. I· - ! .... ~. •

• M. 1....." . :. "'I. _. .II • _ •• _. ~;.. Wi! :,.~ I .. V."~ ~J . . .. i

• :. : I··~· .. :"1 .. :.: :: ·: r·~) ';":I'(.~~:I·'" -, _,.:.: .. ~ 1.lll· ::J

" " " •••• • .... ~ ...... • :Jo..' _ ? ~ .. ":-1' !~!~~ ,,'., :,<.~ .. , ",.,. J"~

I ••• :.rl.: ••• r r .. I /~~ • ~ ...• ::_i.: -:~. 1 • ""' ~~(-f~I :·~, • c:;- .:- .1 •• 1 : .-: ..

: _ .. _ . I . .1.: .. r., :: ":.. . ... I.~I .~.... 10· ••• 1.'4i ~ .. i:'.lf4 .. I" ._:"o";;!II'" -.~ (i. ·.1· J. I.... ..

... • •• •• •• .. :--r, _. : .•• J.. • •.• .:~ .. -:: (:.. r. r. ~. . ...... Ii _;.... •• '. 1 I· •

:<.'

. --··r ... , .. .I,~' . .- -. .. 'I .r-. ._ •..• ':-

........ J ~ • .- ••

- .. '

.. '

~ ';;/. ~.,""< .~~:'. .: -' . . .' , .

,-_~~ .. ' cy,meCTBJlHn8Cb ... (U8a,B3TbM'eCTO). BJt8RHOMMeCTen.uJlo,cTae

:;.,;r'llJ:x·"'", . , ,.$ (CToaHKa) He aanpent~fla.3aR:p!emarow.He ee 3"aKR~~aKme

. ' Y.fOT. 4.2 CTAI 3aKon8 YC!f,OJ1i1BJ1HBser: «Bongochllo0:2ra-

'ct '_":,'., . _ ... n· . . .', "~5I'~:~;:::j::~~:~~~ erlaJI()~:e~~~H~~~Bii~~;~i '.'

< ,;:,;;_Jf: ~a.JlHhI». . 03TOMY YCTa~i¥H~e -lUfiiix~jnioo nrpaHHlJeHRA·, ue

. ~R,p~.zwcMo,TpeHHhlx nnJ](, .~'.', JjI ypOBHC H,e orsesaet 'f ' ~

, a8KO'H,a H" cnenoaat I, , "",, .',' OH~ ern; T, ... y ...

:.. ... '_ . ."..,..,._.,__ .. . .' !, ,'!Ii" ., •

~~~J.''''~''''_~;j~:>;, 'I. It'"' 'YK,p·',BHH,bI. ,nO,M"HM'IO' 'TI oro ' '\c'~·-1·~n2~·. ,:-':' ·'O~ Il ,'~i K~ OT'"C:OPDtr,

Iii ~ (0' , • ' , ' '. ~ , , - t - ';1:" ,~ , , ' '" ,. ." \" '" II rl

~~-i' ",~ ,' .. " .,'." ,. ',8TpHB3ercR OTBeTCTBeH' 0_- ~f>'3 •. Jiapy..weHHe 'npaBOJl OCTa '_ .

~BKH~·H.CTOHHKH, YCTSH8SJlIIBaer OTQetcTB~H,H~T'" sa.aapymeaae

:'~'~~""".""""""'a!iII""'" eHHO Il.lUl, SIl~lmY.r.HX na!i3iWlBBWX aUT~ flJlII.,a,!TOD ~Me~,T~hlX

.. anoa . BJI acra. Tpeooaanaa JIM -MHo~',fie,Hapy~eHb[: fIet 91'OM --

_11 ,~f~<', .. ' .. ' "ClIHT3ro c,eoSl He8HHOBHblM B COiBep!W:~RHll'Q"'HHHCTpa-

:." ............ ~.. .~.~.. :,' :'ll:B H oro n:p'8aofra p'ywe H:H:,f(}) " . r - '-r' " • . ~~. ~ :., '. t: - y' .' •

':'-',,<- ". "," :,np~ paCCMOTpeHHB aeaa CYAbe" eJlepyeT.aafiiulTbxo"t.aACrBO 0

; :'::", ,: '. ~p.eJ(paweHHHAena sa orcyrcraaea cocr30a-.8JJ.MHintctpaTHB,U,aroo npa-

;?~~r;,;·~>.~::·:" .,BoHapywe,H:HH, OOO,cHoB,a:s 'ero TeM~" >Ke'}a"p-"~MeHT:aM:H~- .' L • ,- ~

. ~_ \':~Jl~ ..' '. .' ~.J' ~ 1-' "<" . "" ~~, ~" ..,

. :"::"\ . ><> .. : .... ' ': .. ': 'OTAeJIbH,8H rexa, :H "P' :RTOM qp'-'e3B1lJIQa'HHo: .. «l~~~~'~LJ~'j\"liH '» ~ r_a-TOi o mo

,_ , .. ' . I .. , , . . ,- - I ' 0' _. I "_, . ': ~~~a~~un " ',' ,:;:3 I.' " '. -

;:,/;~' .', '. -RIt"a mpaHcnOpmHbIJt cpeiicm« 8 .f1ICUAWK'paiifJ,1ltIJ:. tfrooco6eHHO

:::::":~-',-.,:,,':~KTYMbHO, B .KpynHblx ropoaax, rne 00.n_hWHHeT90alr0'MOO-~eA, npa;(_~. :' ,:~:: H~e>Kaw.1:tX ttaCTHblM' BJlM~bU8Mt He 06eCneqeH~, 'rap.a~a"4H HJUI

." it. _ .. 1:' ' " GXpaJH~Re'Mb1M'H-,~oaHKa'MT'~ .'\ ': .< : >-. , --

-. , c- ' } \' • 0 0 ~ I ,n" l'1,.., . '. ~ . . .' . .:.11:

:.;- J •• < • , .. -' • • ... : ~',~~. • •

~;:::t:" " .. ' ,',.-',_·UpaBAa" peA./tbI rAI1 c U,eJlb.tO,fH8K33£1HHA sa .H;a-PYWeHHe npasan

~~;~:"." ". ~CTO,SI~KH BJ),WleJIbueB 8STOMo6une,R., xp a,H,H'·'~~~:RX. IIX Bf}~,~n:~, .IO¥MO-' B'" Inl~H"i ...

:'-_', , _ .' "' ~ , ," ,- ~NY ~ "-, - ,t !!!.;...i~',

1/;:;.-' ":.,~iH:! p,eAKOCTh~ .Ho }J,OCTBTOllHO pacn:poaTpaHeH~~,sMHeTcR'Jipyroe -

'i;~~/«:,~'HB.1IeHHe: eCJID uaWHHY 06S0pOB8JJ8 WJHH3~&ItG,B,anlf, BLl388fJHLle ~?,~~:. ::. ~'C~lI?YAHHKH M8JlHIJ.HH DbIT810TCRBblCT80H"lb;8: pQ.nHHapyWHTtJIR-'Il.D.Ll,

~~;;~~{~:::/ ',! ~~oro ~oT~neBlUe.,-o, csaaaa: AS Hero; TalGJ~,' 06pa3~M, XOT~' 6bl'

r:"'~~~·~<i. ..' q_CT~ OTBeT,eTBe,H,HOCTH~ '. . ,. . . ' ... " . . ':' .. ",;" .', .:.~ . ,-~. . ' *

.... ~~~1 i ~.: .. ;':," . .' .. i . ~. • . ,........ . • '.

m~;"\~'<: _ .... JIelIaTh 910 }J;aeT B03MO)KHOCTb<PoP.MyJl"PO~ nn.«6»n~26.2 ~~;:"::'_:' n.nJl.'~COrJlaCHO·~OT()POH B)KHJlOH sone 3anpew.aeTOO-.C'fOgHKaT."HC~ '-, ... noPTBWK' CpeJlCTSBHe Cneu.HaJIbHO OTBe,tleHHhlX' Mectffi'1(J;Koe .~ pacno-

.' nOlKeHHe, KO'f.OpOe a8TpYAHSIer ,D,BH>KeH.He :neruexon:Q:~ H npoeaa

" O~~P~TKBHblX, HJIH cneun,a.nbHblX rpancnoprnux CPeAcm.,:npHMeEleHHe TaKO'R ,q,O',P:MYJ1H,pcOS:KH llaer BO,3M!O)l(:HOCTb corpYAH,HU;M ;t4HJlHltH'H ICqH ~ I

TaTb. CTORHKY npaKTHqeCKH B Jllo60M MeCTe >KWlOn} '~A:oHa'HapyweHH ~ eM: ,Il,lJJ{ ~ 'M J1eH~CT8()BaTb 'COOT,Be,TCTBeH:HO~' : .. :: ~ . . "

" -npaa,b1 JlH,OHH B STOM:?JlaBaihe nOCMOTpBN~--·. .' .', "

.. . . Bo-nep,BLlX~,B JllOtiOM >KHJlOM psAOHe M<~~101'e'R ac41aJIhTHp'OS3B ~ ~flde Rn OW.UKH. ,'''OTOphi! e n pep,u.aSHaqeHbI, ~Cne:I1HaJlbHQ NUl CTOHHKH ~paH.cno,pTHf)J~, CpeJ1,CTB H HH MH l{ero' HUOro. 3ro, ij',eC:Tb «cneUH~

,,~hHO 'oTse,neHHble MeCT8'>. ,.Ll0P0>KIUJlMH_3R.8K8MH tnu1 06b1QRO 'He

-

. .'

":f, t . .

.. . ..... , .. -

. . I·· ' .. ".

. . ' " . ( ~ : .

!.~t ' ~ 1i\W .. '~"'r' -,A:., ....

. "r~.,":i ' :- .;._.-1)J -:.. ' ." (.... . '"'" 'I.:" .

I-..J.).I ~:; -=- ... ~~. ,.::.:.~~ .. h I~-'~ -/ ).

';r.;' .;. . ., .-' ... ,,;Y- .._ ' , .. .

'I~ .. ; ........ ..;:.~-:4 i;-:' ~-:- .-:"._. --::" - !" .('(. ' • ••

%!".;;:~ .. ,~~.,.-::~ ......... .,_;;~I·~n.-·· '.' ,:." "

... '~ ,. '. . ~\-, .:';pt,' ~... '. , :~: ' •.

"~ • '" {' - !".I'. :-.,.. .......... " , -" .. - ....... j .... . .- ..

f;"aBQ 6~

-":l' •

'1- ..... ...

~,\'-011.-:- ••• • -- - ... , ... -.' ..... ,. , ~.. r._- -'I'" -. --. -:1"' .-:

.

r: ~_ n n __

-- - -

....... _i&&~

_.~~_MIik - . .

.. -' . && "_ 0 ._.- . _.-

_.

O'OO'3,HSQeH,b( t· Ho n}fii,ll Ii He. Tpe6Y:WT,. lJTO'O:bI Ta'KH'e, M~,~""_c4::lll.J':'

, np,e)l.enax ))(HJIblX a'OR 6~~Hpt)'OShalJeHLI cpe~CTBaMH peryJl .' , .... ,.A.iIU~iiiiv ,IlOPQ>KHOrO DJUJ>K'eHUR. '<KCT8TR, 60JIbUJHHCTBO DJlaTRYX::: ·'_.I.f.D;.~~~ Coiosa aSTOM06HJ1HCTO.S'-HMH 'ae Ol)03Ha'l'ellblTO>Ke.), , .' . -

naouiansax C'fORH~~ ~p8HcnopTHbiX CpeACTB 6y.n.el' 3aKoHRoit~~;~;:f .

-, - -', I'" ,"".:-, TaK·oe~)K·'HnaH 30Ha' ' ~<'~'~(

. ~. ,n.LI~ __ ~.a.iiae;~~~~~uo~~e~eJle~He:{)I(WJaH 30Hl .~'.'; · .~-~~~~

repparopaa; ,8 Ta~~_ q~'Ctlf Hialcene:H,H,bl~ nyRKTOB, 060,3H8' ',' ," "

PO.IKH~M 3HBKOr.r5.31 ~)Pa~eJl 5 npHJlO>KeHHH I nJJJlyr ,,- '.

,lJ,eJlbHble)l.BOpOBbieTeppHTOp"U3HaKaMH 5.31 H 5,.32 He 0003118' .

'HO a. H~X p.eAerBytOT 'Tpe6osaHHH paatr,ena 26 H8CTOfll1l.HX n~M

npasHJla )JJ3,H>KeHHfI B >KHJiOH 301re). _ . .' . '. '. > ;:q"'t"",,,"'!;lOSU:'iI;-[!;j:j ~".~~

"COTPYAHH'KH' M:Hn:Ht.{tI,U ,JI,iQ'6yro repparopmo, pacnonoxe .',,"'._.'-" ~,;_(1;~ ~

s::_mJ1eKe OT m:HJI~ ,Q,OMOO, C"I HTa lOT «OT,lleJIbHmi ,u,BopOBoA re ' nfl, r~, i:~1 f'ffi:;''t~ elf»' co BeeM:H,BblTeKitOU1)fMH-HOCJIeJJ,CTBHHMH. OJ],H3KO-a8 Cm.$R~A:' w

.9TO, KaK npasano, He T8K. ' ;.~ ~.

BOJILWHHC1'BO H8ceneHHH xpynaux ropOAOB (M HHeTMi,,1:t.O,,· -ftt,' ,'''ii':Pi'Jl HblX) . npOJKHSSeT' B" co.peMeHHblX >KHnblX MaCC,HBax. TaRue ... , " , ,. .;h(.~~~?~ npe.aCTSOJUUOT co601O"cnolKHoe nepennereHHe npOe3.nOB (KIND,,,, .' t:..~:;>'!:__~~.0:4"W~;jI:

CKB()3',~,MX)" 'T~plp'H'-'r: .-,~'p' '.lH:U·"W··:;' K' ,·'on' :' > )1;', 'e:' T' 'c-', K', H' 'x'c, 'C'-'Bll'" 0' 'B: "(: 'K" a·~'K··' np ~a~'B' ,,' HJI~ :,!'~':'O: -: .. ~~~,~·~o: ~"ro;,~,~::~ir,;~; \~

,. '" -o • 0 ~i,.' 1'.11; " ,.,', 'Ii • ,I _ " " ' , "... ~. ,t, ,.,,~"\.

" _....~. ~ , '" ' -. '11;.;;'::";""" ~. ; r: :.Jo ~

>Ke~Hblx), seneaux H3Ca>K,ll;eHHH, CTORW,HX Me>KJJY HHMHm'Iin~~"~':~_i~;'~ .

npyr' fIX - - .. ~.. I!!i.' th ~. '.' . - ", (/:r"

A~ ':'.~"'I. ,3A3H,HIf, ,ouec'n:e~rH,BalOlll.HX. H:H:~paCT'pyKTYPY ~.' M·e.lUI'nNliol.~~~\:',:("-·,

. ~ __ ~ _ , ---:- . ,__ _ __ _ _ to' ~ ...• ,.: .. " . '.;" ".~~" t .. ·;:~j··"J::!~~r-t: ,;,.,.~

KOMMYHaJlbH,blX,. TO'P- roBblX vup',~, ew"n,e'HH'H ' .' ..... , ,'" ~~~:~~ t).'1. '. :~~l'/j :; ... ~~,:, '

.~.. . ',' - - . . J" "',iI.'~ - '-' ... t., . . - ~ ~"~<" ~,! l," '\~!:fr-·. ", .. :~;

Talton >KHJ1oii' MaCtOS - MUKaK He «,n,BopoB3a Te'pp ,"" . ',.. ,~,~ ~; 'i " ~",<:,«~,"L":.i!<

. ~ sacn. uaceneaaoro nYHKT3. OH8, He 6YJJYlIH0603H3'1~"a,coO't:Ra~!iJi~-"p~ CTBylOUlHMH .IlOPO>KHblMH 3H8K8MH (qero, K8K npaB:HJlO~:~~e~- .. ",', CT3tyca}KHJlOH 30HbI B COOTBeTCTBHH e fUllI He HMeeT~ 'Si.ecb,lle"1~LB!"1I"1!:'C' ;"" .. -'".,....,,.,,,, OYIOT oclLUHe npaaaaa, npe.ayCMOTpeHHbIe NIH .n.BHlK~It~;rB " ': .' ,

HhlX nyHKTax. . . . ' .' .,' ; .' " " .' -;" .

·J~~.:uJliliN

, ,*pXHTe.KlY.P3 nOAot)HbJX . Ma~CHBOB rSKO!8, qTO !!Wl~,J'H'fh' «,~~~ "::' • a~~,_:,.-'ii.': . HbJ$kL1aQPQglj~Te,l!pHIQPUH» uelli03,MO>KHO~TH .. BoT, HanpuM~p':,<,C)r,' , "":.';;l[:lI'.!:, .npoeaxea qaCTH y.nnribl OTXQltlIT S'beS)l. B )KHJlOH: paUOH, C O.Oi;~Dpo;~ ,:'r~;r;" r{t~'-i'J.m

lib! or Hero - az(8HHe KHHOTeaipa H fIJlOwaJ].K8,l11lSl napKOBIUI f«B~~' . "~j :':,:-. , -

. npoe3lKeA sacra, HHKaKOT nee He OT.l1eneHHbIA), cJJ.pyroA ...... >KMoiJtoM'· :.' ~'!, :::1 , ~. pacnWl0>i<eHHwMH HB nepaos 9Ta>Ke Mar33HHaMH. aro ASopoaati rep-' " . -' t: .:;,' .~PHTOpHH? Her. H eCJIH GHa .He 0603Ha1JeH3 COOTBeTCTBYJOI.l\HM aHa!KoM.-,"-,I~~)

, '\ j{r. . . ,II'" . . ",/1·

o S'TO 'H'e )K H'Jl8S1, ,30,H',8. . '. " .. < • ~ .. - . ~= . . . < : : J: ... ~~

,j '.. . .. -

','~"':: ". A :B01 O'T' 9TiO,H n'p'oea,)Klen tIaCT" OTXOAH:T oeW,H,p"' OKas }l.O,P--:··OlKK8·:, , .:.,

-i. '- .' , . ' ...

f),H:,a ',n'p' 'OXO;.QH,T M:HMO, e,LUe o,n H'O'rO nOMa ~ a c ~py'-ro'H C,TOP- O·HbI ' ... 'ra3·0'H ~."-' - "

• _< ~ ~ ,,. . t

'f.I"OTOM OHa MosaeTes B eme oJUlY .u,opory - lJyrh WHpe It C TpC:)1ya:_ .

_ paMUtKoropaSl, B CHOro Oqepe)l,b, H)J,eT M,RMO mKOJIbI ••• cho Bee ABO;". -" - . . .

l' . j "

~~.pOBble· reppHTopHU? Her. Ha TaKHX BOT cospeMeHRbIX 'MfiCCHsa:x-- ..' .

~('~Boo6~e HeT «OT)J.eJIhHblX.llBOPOBbIX TeppHTopHH» - 3,lJ,eclS OHHHHKaK; . '\' '.

; .. . _. ~

.,. . . ' .. _.

~<a!;:.2~J:L.·· j=( ~If~ ·.:OTAen,eHbI OT OCTa~Jlb,H,blX:, aaecs, no, CyTH" BO'OOme ,HeT'~,[lOHHTHSI ~I~i ··,.~~aOp,:a~ -B,eCb"TaKOH M,.C·',C·lf',I.· 8 IC"iO··'M·:I" ,ft,·~e:·'lr:ce M',' ,O~H,:"O··.' pa .... .c .. c':",~:u.~om, ',:'p, .. u .....

~ ~.. ~ ... _1617 . _[~.rW·"d ,IP' .. _~ .. ",.4fRrM~.· '_

. ",' Ill" 810./1""0 "ate «uaem» H.4CeAell;lOZO nyN.lema», 1f.omopaJl

···i.~.?¢m,tJH.08,t4,~CJJ.. 3IC,I4Jl,oii a'''IJfJ/i, mo,ltbic;o \r-IC,o'eiJa o 603.H'a'leRiJ", co-

~~;:.. -t , , , , .. ' emc',m,8'Y"IO,JIUMU 3HtiltliMU.,.. ..' -, .r.s > ' • '".

~~: ~ - _.. - I . '. ..., - '. l... • - • • -=:~ r i' ". .' . ~ 'I \

" ':!~~~;.~:.( .: -: <no?"roMY B cnysae KO~H'~,iiB}tt~ c cO'TpVnHHK,a:M~H,~.MH{I~ ~H,H~.n9 no-

~~.".~.", .. _ s- r \. . • \. "'¥ _ J y • , .. .:,.... .~.~.. ' • '1,;'"

: " .,1) ~ OJIY' ,'CT'OSlHKH B TaKOM: . " ec'r~,~~~~o6;;HcHerifHH .caenyer. nanncars. . ' .

. :~(~.-Mecro,rJle npHnapKoB~lH MQIi'::Ii$.l1QM06nnb, He HBJUieTCSI >KHJ10H

;;,;~:·:~O!foi1.B CMblCJle n. L 10 n)lJJ; .... ·-H.8etb'HaCeJleHorO nyaxra - >KHJlOH

... =1.-=. .". .. 1- ,.

~_"'~ .... :._-.~ .. 'ceRB --. He 0603HaQeH3 D,OPQ${HblMH' .3H8K8MH «)i(HJI.aB 30Ha».

-I.Ji!l ...... II; .a , . HRas' Te'PP'HTO,PHH H~ S(,Bn,SI-e'TICfi' '··«OTAenb,HOH . )lBOPOBOH'· T,eppH'TOfaA»-, nOCKOJlbKY He orneneaa OT BeeR' ocraasaoa tepPHTOpHU ?KH ~

'._~ .,\. ,MaCCH,B,a, ,HHKaKHM,H apxarexrypauxn H~H)f(eHepHblM'H HnH

~, ~~~.~;~;';~Rbt~IH' coopy>keHHRMH, " nposecra rpaaaua Me.»UIy !3KHMfI reppa,,~' .. ~:~~:~:··>T'O'PHH~~ B llaH,H,oM .paHQ·ae HeBO~,M'O>K.H'O. no YK8,[3aHHOH J1pHQHH'e

:. ", ···.t~;.~' ClJHTalO, xro npaSHJI ABH>KeHHft H CTOHHKH B >KUJlOH aoae ft He Hapy.~) .. I'~<~>. tuan» .. MO>KHO raioxe ):to6a,BHTb, "TO 8STOMo6Hnb ne ooecnexea ,M'e ...

; .....

~:"~<" CTOM xpaneuas, T8K q,TO ,n8'pKOBaT,b ero .6'OJl.b:UJ,e Bee pasao aerne.

>. '.' .. i' 2· .KerBTH, Q OnlY HeT aanpera Ha OCT3HOBKy ,.JlB CTOstHKy 38 np'WeJla~

", ._'" ... r.... / ;IIi.'~ .' '_. _ _ ._~

£,,,',.,'~~, 'J."1.H80~~,H. HanpHMep, B TBK Ha3b1BaeMblX«3ene8b1X}~tlif!Yt'> I1J1.0'. Bo .. '

ti'7.:-' .',' " . . . ~. ",. tI ,.m ... . ,I:ii:iia

I~' .: .. ,~; ~"'.: ': _ A'H~enb,~ ,n.p,H,na,pKQBa'B,WHR c,B,o,A ,aBTOM06HJlb. B nOa06,H'OM ,M,eCre_"

~::> .. :.:.' .. npeacraer HapYWHTeJleM n.llll. J1HWb B OAHOM cnyqae-eCJUI aa B'be3~

K·:.~:-.~.-~. / ". ,/J.e U8 T:aKYID T~PPH'TOpHIO' H,Me·'e'TC·SI 3Ha~, 3anpemalOntH,R Jl.BH>KeH,Ue' HJlH

~.~y'" ~ ... ·BJ;.e3)l,. Ecna me 8STOM06HJ1b saexan B TaK}'1O SOH}' S8I(oHHO. TO H CTOHH~

f~F.~··· . KaraM TaiOKe He 6y.a,eT HapyrneHHeM.

·Wi '

~~ 't" . " . . ..

~;i'} :/~~:< •• .,

~. !... . .: - lu.· ...

.~~~;: ~· . :~r: .. ,~~:~,,~. _. . :' " .

~;·::,~dL;,~'>·.',.:··~· ,'" . ',' . ,~~ i:'''' '. '~".

(:~:~.~1~<~' <.~.r" " .

~i-;:~:} ~:,~:~ .: .... :.. .'

q.'l\;i" . .

r- r-' • . .,

~"j~ .: .: "

-j'1 - ..

:.'-:-.,:::= . " ..

-:--:::.. .

• !

..

,

, "

_, ... -

• - ..... ~~P

Ir. • •

• I '.I'

-. .' .

_ • I I, r' .... ~" ,."."rI' .......

.. I":'

. !

. '.

..

.': ~ .

,

. I

. ,-

I __ '

-,

, L

" .

'.

~

/ .: .. _ ..

. . .

~: '.:.~h: <.'" .'~: :

..

.... - -,_ ..... _-_. - - "-_.. - _-

r.na-' 88,···!7

•• ",-.: 1 .~ •• J ••• ·~I

, ,

, s> J'

.' .

I •• '.

BeAKa. BC ... ~ •• ·a

..

i

::;;~~~~~~~~~!!~~~!!!i;;~ils!~ ,

'" ,~

~=:;;:~ .. ~~, .' ,.>F~:~·~·:~:i~

_.,~ r I~:I .... ._( (.i =-...:. .~ .

. ~, ~ . ~ . . ... ~: !';·i;t:~~·~~~.·.< .: ~'i~

1 • ,y';;' I' .... '-... • ..... ..... .'. ~1 . ..... __ ,-'1

''': • • -~:..'.~ 1 ..... : : •. ::-:.:: .. -: .~';.''',..._ J' .~

.' • • I'!!"\ 1 r .-'./_ ... :,.; .... )..

.. ... . . .. . . " - . "... ' ..... ' ;~ ~' . >~.~ " · ,';'~::T~?)~

. . . - "_'.. '~" ,.1,t. ": 't":U/jJ-'

:..:: ',.' HHlorna HHcne'KTO:p_ BH/-lHT B JleH'CTBH'HX, B,oAHTenfi Ha,pyw,eH'He ·.R,_U)l;:· :~ .... L:'~·;~'~tf.\:.ft;"}'~

• "' .... -.' ." • • .. ~..: • 1 I ~~

: xorna CH'I)'alJ,HH SBRO ue CTOHT Bble,lJ.eHHOrO HHD.8. reM He MeHee, Bpe,.e;;,_·,.;;'·;~<';';:~~1

. .~ . . t .~ " .' ,.":"!..:¥,

,':HH H HepBOB HB TO, QTo6b1 OT6HTbCR OT 06BHHeHHH, MO)Ke~>9bI~~ nOTp~'~"r':">~1~,~:;:::~1

.; ,qeHO 'OqeHb Muoro. n09T()LN paCCMOTpHM 3Jl.eCb CJIY'laH :60nee MH, ':.?"i~tfor';~

• - . - ". ,t'l"!I! J' . . _ . ." ",:' .: '. .~". . ~~ \' "~"~"~i~': I ~:,'f::' ,.

,.·rMe'Hee 'T,HnH1{H.bI'e ,H nOK8m"eM, K3KH,M 06p-"'a30'M' MO'>KHO OTCJaH,~aTb CBOH"·~<~-·)~~~~~":·'~"':~':·~.0~:

. _. .. ~ . \ .. ..: " '.!i....... -, "}." I .. ~

.. n pas ·a- B'" n IO'filJO' ~ '6~' ·HhI" X:· C' rrr,\m, rIA'ax, , A'·, np H,:- M" 'e" po IB MO>KHO np HBeCT'H' 60nee q',e~M '\ .: : :~~<&.~ ... ; .. :/~!.,~

" ,~ ... , ,. .~.~ ... , ._ .' .-.I. .. ·JU.~,ln '. . ".' ~ , ,'_ .' - , . ',' . . .. .' .. ', . - .. . ..;,t, .... II,·:~{~~~~ .

, .nocrarosn '0' " . '.' . :' .. ',' 1.~3~;~;~~):~

~ ... " , .1', ,., "' ., ,J i1'.h."'.t..~

" : <~, 06llJ,eH3BeCTHo, "ITO BO,ll.HTeJlH MapwpyrHblx TpaHcnoprHblx Cp~CTB ·"{"#t:~

. .~~BTO~YC?B, TPOJlneH6YcoB, MapUIpyrH~X T3KCH )PeJ_U(0 CMOT~ ~. 3ep~ . .u {;j~'

K~ano saaaero BI\ll3, OTbe3>Ka,H or OcrB,HOB,KH. Coaaaaaue Ap,yrnM, yr-I,aCT ' .: ':"

,:-:uKaM"AB,H>KeHRfI nOMeXH HX IOObl,qHO M,aJ10 C.MYIUaIOT; ,6onee: TO,ro'I npn

-, f', ~ . . "

~. .rtepecrpoeaaax sa l1PYfYIO uonocy OHM B,eJIYT ce6H D'p.HMepHO· T8K >Ke,~,

"~"':'~~: ·'~M,aJlo roro, ''ITO ,HX 38 310 npa,KTHlJe'CKH HH,KOfAS se H,a,KaS:MB,81O'T • :' MHorHe COTpY.llHHKH bUI HCKpeHHe y6e>K,ll,eHbI~ 'ITO OUH UMelOT sa 3TO

n,:p:a 00, ' .. Ii Q'bI.S8,IO'T CJIylI,a,H, KOf)l3 BO,lUlTeJ1S1, He nponycrasurero pesxo '({I~;rqaJlHB,w,HH» OT 'OC,T'8HOB,.KH aBT'OOYC (xy>KP roro ~ He'ro)W,lOl1le npo\ ,eHt1l8J1H,B,We--ro!) nblT,aIOTCH ,H8K8S8Tb as aapyureaae n,p,aBHJI npoeana

:,.' ,8BT\o6Y'CHbiX OCT8,H'OBOK". .' - ., .'

-; .~~;~ ~~e>K,Oy rea, n.peUMy'tqBcm,8a MapwpymH.blX mpaucnopmnmx ~epeiJcm8 e coomeemcmeuu c flU ne cmruu, ~q'NIJ:U"J""D n .. :U6..

f .

a' -$-

...

.... -_ %-:'..1 ~ --- -- _- - --

,

- - .

- - -~. '-0-- - .'-" ._ ._ : .' -wzas

.. '. .

. • i'.: ..

"r I~.I: II . ~ r •

... .,.;:' .

~':::'o~~::;2li\"'~' '.~:. \' :.' .:~. .

- ~,. ,> '.: -:::.:8

~~~"I"~'·i,··"'-"'.:i. ",-=-.'

._", ....... ",,:_ .~ ...... -,.;:, '.: . ',L;;"

..... ' - .' 44- "- - 2.

K.. ;_ '. \. ". ~\~; '. . . .

'~;:'.J,l¢Iit'l\BHTeJlbHO, coraacao n.17.4 fIJUl, BQAHTeJlb, npH6JJH~ K aB~ ""..,.~,,,,' .,~,. '.6ycy,. MHKP08BTOQy'qr .Un~;lpOMe~:t$y:~y, HaqH.HaJO~eMy )l.B.H~eH,He AOj

e~.t-~c;;~-;'kNm.1lCTaHOBKH, OOR3aH CHM3m:~, cK6po~:::'i~~OCTaH()8HrbCRI ~06Ul;.r.aTii. <,-,:~:._ ~3MO>KH'OCTb H,aqaT:b AQ.e.HHe~ Ho a~ sacaemcn .Ha".aJllJ' 18/i1U~ . ;~.'~~" ··~~~1UUl He om ecex 'oc- im -, ~,.,~. ~~ :~. '~'i~i£, a ·:m~~it.~· lfI",a'ltc.nO:llo3ICeHHblX B 8.tl-

~. . -. "\;I. i<' ~ . Q'~~;..~. ,''r' ,

• .' I • ": • ...::;. ~- ,_....; ~!. I .. :~........ :.., ..... "... ....:. r-"'" "I _. • •

;.~~~~. ~·.:e3iJlIhIX «,lCapMaH.4X» :(" K;~;: 'i!~~BSe llalj'Q,oe·;~)Jg~'Q~:·AeAICTByeT TOJlbKO'

. ".~. .... '. ~ -' ~- .p~~;' ~ , . -~ -. :';'" './- . ';' . .' ..,,'

~~ ): ~,; a' ~aceneHHbIX nyaxrax), ,Ha.~ ocra~oB~~~Rm~H~e rpaae- ... ,

. ,.;~.~,: nopTH,ble:'CpencTB,a T8:KHX fi~.HM_CTS.He ;·lQfflelO·T.,,···~··. 'r,~" • "J'- .':. "" :~;

-=--- _ .• :::.; Ha3To H HY>i<HO ~6p~1"r~~.~.B"·CIletn"opa"A eCJIH ne.no- .

, .. ~'. '. _ ~.. : .. ~'". 't .~.' .E::t.: •. " .;r." " ::i J.;~'~ ?~_ ,..... • , •. ' . '.

,..,..",,_'N •. a, ;: ~or~eT, TO YK33aTb B 06"HeH~,"II¥X\,!ltflg;."·,~~i<<<O'~ta""?BKa Mapw~ .

, . x TpaHCnOpTHf:iX cpeiteTB)'·~SEf,<,:.~~py~JlHe.~ '~l:iptl~llJl. "Roeaa.a, ' ..

9f"::"9io,~jiL'1.,.~"'';''f·''-~PFIJ '- . H CO'CTaBJIeH npOTo,.KOI1:,. ·p·a·C[lOllllllKetl2, 'H!e·.8·'~,~'i$£lW(OM ({Kap.~~~ .

B'~""Yl'~1·' '. . .»,8 senocpencraeaao U8 KpalO npoeIDKetf lJiieia:"S' COOlseTCTinlH .'

~: _"~~'.f ,:~ •. ,-"":~~:< ', 17 4 n- . n n . '_." -+ '.': , ~~'

,~;;. ~-~:i':~ ~·~I1, .. : .•.. ~. ~, BO)l.HT'eJlb M,ap,'wp',' yrH·oro· r~p-·a",Hlc .. nepraoro cpencrsa He'

."j ..... '.~. . . . cl I '-.~ '. 'i . -: I . • ~ ... l y. ..

,~.....,,,..=.-;~,t~(:1;,".JI 3.l1.eCb npeuaymeeraa s JtBR~lfri:flf~o6fXir,lfM~HF,ro ,J)H. co~ .

.. r .•.. . . . . ." 1"1 I~" - ... ao:.'

.......-u· .... ,j,_, «'-'.: .. 3.n.aJJ' onaCHOCTb AJlH Moero ;')(BlnKeHHiru, T~KH~.(Jt;pa30M~· BH$>~9.H B

~'~:.;.;:.;. H,apy:weHHH IlM'» '.~.' '. . '.' . , .. ~ : ..... > -; '.'

__....,.lO."' ...... .J'< ..... :;, ••• >;,\nep~ paccMoTj,eH~eM ~~a B CYAe l{~~Cq9~.3U~:.SJ~~~.XQ~~

. . •• ~~"-T:a:ActBO '0.6 HCTpe6oB3HUH H3 AQpo>KahIX. ~:.~" .. NWflorO ~acT~"

:,:;, :' ;,;:~,~.: ',~K8 lt0POfH. Ha HeM 6y~eT 'qer},(i) BlfAHO,. ·~RTO. ': "~KOro 3,a~3JlHOro !~!:;:t:'('" 4;:~pMaHa» ,saeC;b He HMeeTCSI; 3THM MO>KHO·Sa'rJlff.lli1o nponeaoacrpa-

;~'~::' ••• ~':~~~,:; •• :;:'.':' ."' 1 p'O',B8J'b CY~'" QTO .BO)lJITenb, '06,B,HHeHH:blH 8· aapyureaaa.npasan npoea-

t~ .. · ":~- .:; .. ·:·/.aa O,CT~HOBO.K,. npaa, a OfLUll H.apYWHn .K8K P'I,S BO~T:eJlb M'~PWpyrH'O'ro

.,' i'-' '. . . '..'

'~~/y/,: .. .: TP~H~9PTHoro cpencrsa, Xonaraacrao A<w.KJI.O ~~:rb npoCb6y 0

'~~{':.«. ~. _ !·3a~phlrH.H.AeJ1a aa OTcyT'CTBHeM' CO'Cl~,Ba ,atl~,HHlfcrpa1\IJ~Hq"ro npasoaa ...

;.:s'~. _.' < .';', i.' :' p' - yw", '~"'e -' " ' .: ,,:.:, .~. . . '. .'. ') ..... '., . .... _ . ..

/',~ .;':~'.', ',", 1':-<' " H,Hft. _.' . "~.' ;.'. ·il>"-(.'~!; =: r :': . ~' . . •

~~;:~.(p.::::' .. ' M3Becre.tPo,ll,HTe.rIbCKHH 06b1QaH npe,nynp,QtAa.Tb. scrpesmsx cee ..

£:t/~:;·'>':TOM.4lap O,mM?:lfTO nepea HHMH aa )l.opore H~·:rr~:&ny>K6ycOT.py}.tHHKH t).~:i~~::~(·~~:<:<~:.-<·.·:"-- ,fAli. noCn~ue, ·aaMelUB TSK)1O' «CHrsaJlHaa·II"f;O»~. lf8ICTrO' nbJ'Ta.fOTCJJ.'

·~·01 ...... -:-:'. . '" ....

?(.;)"<~:(;;~·I . Ha.U.s·alb sa H,ee BOJIHTeJlH. . ,.,' .' . ,<;

~t~i(":' '. Me)KJly TeM, B niIll. npJlMoii sanpem Ha"np/IMeNeHue C8ema

r.M . /~ .. '.: .. . t/J 1 _;a' , ..~. ..;3 ~', , .-

""-:41~'~~"'·' . ': 'an Q.:/UI. CUl,1t4IUl3a,~!UU 0 «aaca·t1e» -·Me gc·mtt80Si/l,eH."I·· . '

~liir ~ .. _._. . . .. r· , ,. ." . . . '.' ~ ~. ",' .' .

'~"~./'~:_.i.~ ~~~., .. '~oonee Toro,. no,. «8» n:.t.9,~.1 rUIJl. np·S1,M<O rn.peJlY~MaTpHB,aeT· npH ~

.~. .... M'eHieHHe nepe'KJi.lOqeHH.R CBeT.a l<pap B ,K.aqeCT~e~·np,e.ltY1JiPle>K.lLafOlll:e:ro

. ". CHr:H,8J1(!,t 11· HHrAe· Hie CK8aaHo, 'l{TO n,e.p·eq·eHb· cn·ytl)~le:~t.' Kio·r)l.a 9TO Ae ... ·

~

n&Tb flDJl ,np'eIlnHC.bI·B,aIOT (Mst np.H.sne:Q·e"HJl·8HH,,_,b::tI:fJ 0.0 rio fi H,e·'M 0, ,~

ro·,!! JIll,S( C.Hr.HaJlH3HpIOB,a:H.H.R .B·CTpe:t{HIOMY. B~Ji.H'T·eJJ,iO.,i)· ae'O:()XOAHMOCT'H l1epe,KJ1lOlIeHHR CBeT8)- .RBJI.R·eTC:R HCKnKl'LJ··H·Ten·~H~.M ": ':to e~T.b 16'on bwe

H.HI($KHX 'C,H'rHa,JjJ'OB ~C:BeTOM~' cp.ap nOJ(3B8T'b;, H:enilS1J .. 'CO:OCT.seH,HO·, 38,- .'

.n.p'e'T· B 3TOlH o:6J[:a'CT'H y·cra:HOBJ1e.H· Ton,bJ.(O OAHH-~\:1l,9'~ 7. '-nn/l,): cHrHa.~. R.UTb AanbHHM 'OB·eTOM 3anpemaeTc.ft, KO.ra3 S"TiD. :M·rO:~eT n,pH,s,.eCTH· ._K ,ollQ'enn'eHIfJO':14Pyrux ,BOllHTene.H~ '(lr·o M·aJlQBe~p·Q.B'H10i;·<",anp',H:Mep" B

• 1 •

. .' . ,[tHe,B.H·oe B.pe;MfI,. _':'.: .~., . ~:~:-"i, ~ tF

• I.,/'

. .. ..... - . ..::....

"T"f-~.-~ o.!-.;t'· .. -:-· -"" ."':i-: ..... t: ~'I-

.m'I'X-iIiJ::.Ola! ~jFj~

_O' .. -_r ..

'. • r I"~ 1"-'. •

'!:'"

.... I.

" .

CorMCHO CT. 19 KOHC1:mywtH YKpaHHbI, HHKTO He MO)Ker ,t1W:fl? '.

HY>KAeH tleJIBTb TO,t QT'O ~pH."fl, He· npen;y·CMOTpe.HO 3:aKrOH·Qlt8· . '. ~,h~N B !T'Ol\1 IJHCJle H BOaAep)l(H8-e.~&Cll 01 CHr.HaJlHSaU;WH cpa.p.3M.H .• · . :.' : ... ~~. :~': '~~~~-~~~.-;~,/'~

I . '. :.~ r:'~' ~

· nOSTOMY B CJI·Y1iae,~T:e·'CJ1.,: BQAHTe/lfl n·l!tI,.a.IOT(~ft np·H'BJI'.,e1f-b g.. '.

:HHICTpaTHBHO:H OTBer'CTa;eHHO.CTH 33 nOAO'OlJble Jle·.RCT:B~fI, ~ 4: . .... .,' . iJOA.XHa 6fJlm~ IfJSepiJo.(l: «3mo H83anpeU4eHO I» ECJIlf:.. r,u:~~J~~

,n·OB,O,QbI H8 H.HCl1·)eK~TQ~p,a ae nOJleACTBOBan~H., B 06bflCHeH,HR~. K:·:.~

.~~ .... O'UIi('

TO KOJIYCJ1e.nyer ,~Ka3aTb: «npHM e HeH He caraaa H3aqRH CBeT~:, ~':~ i,#~

o M'eCTe aeceana CJlY>K6~ CO'TpYAHHK8MH M·,HJlH~.H·H. He -san .",' HM n';-D_,L(, HII Jlpy.r.HMH HO,PM8THBHl.-fIM'H ·aKT8M.H Y.K.paJfHbI. iH~~~, .BB '~~'."-_

B'SHHH 'q~ 1 CT~ 19 ~~iHCT:HTYU.HH Y·K.paHH.~1 TaK.He '~eHc"rBHH'~ ue laTCH' He.38KOHHhI'MH. ·OnaICHOICTH OCJ1e,nneHHH npyrax J.'. _

. .

nps "TO:M: He ,C,O,3,Zt,8s·anOC,b, .K npa "COCT·a:Bne.HHH· nporosona '.'.

HfI·K·aM" rAM ae 3a<j>HK'CH.po·saHbt n.Hu,.a". xoropue OblnH' 6,b(' '"t

. - -- ".

06pa3QM ocnenneasi. Ha 3TOM OCUOB8HMH ClJ.HTHIO ce~SI H_es,., ~filrtiijl

. H'bIM 8· Hlapyw·eH.HJf nJI)l»,· - . . ... : .-:::-' .. ,:~:_.;.~:~

_. Kcrara, PYX080JJ,HTe/.IH·fAH paaaux paaros B H~TepBwoCMHH.t ~ oAHOKpaTHo roaoPHJIH 0 TOM, liTO HWJerO aesasoaaoro B T8KOI¥:.· _. '.. .'

3,aUH'H' He'T :H .H·aK83b18aTb~·~OJl:"T·eJ1e.H .3~ 3'TO He CJ1eJlY·eT~ K: :.~' .~ ",~_';. 3TOMHeHHe He scerna pas.n.enHeTCRHX nO.ll.I:IHHeHHblMH. .. .: :.,. :;:I~~~":~.'>?~::.;~. . ...... - ..... _,,_

Cor JtaCHO n.ll·.2 . Il)Ul, sepeascosue TpaHcriop!~~ .. 1:;¢~~t@l:;~ ';~, "-"'<.'_~'''> p,OJUKHbI ABHraTbCSl'KaK:M<»KHO MU>Ke K npaBOMY KpalO'n~dlJac~::::;;:

Tn.' I~io qT~09~a~a~T 3-~O «~a~·MO)f{~o. MH>Ke»? nocYr,;~~:h~~~r:. ;i~~;~~;~' r:;~

.lJ.OmKeH onpeAeJlHl'b $TO CaM. B O,lUlOM cnysae Jl.8HraTbC~> B03J1e.:~~~!'~~~~;,~f{~~·~ 'ro K.p-··,8H n:p'GeS>KeH 'taCTH M,O)Ker MeW8'Tb caer, KOTOPblt··~rpe~.it:;W.':,,/·'/:~~~·'7:·~<l~J:~ .. ·

., .. . . , . . (. :I~ . <~ (, .. ,~,: . 'If(.~:' ~~~~~' , ... ~; ·~·~~1Itr-.W :\/$/1/%

'n";'p" 'K' y6o:p' Ke· nopora, '8· ~Ip~'y. 'rOM -- YVAWe,e ·Katle·'eTBO n'OKpJ;lJl1f~~~ .~:~Q.~:'. ~>f(~.~J.~~ij)~v'~~j.

! . " . - ~. '. . - _. ~ - - - _lIi.Jy .. nl-i"'Ij.,,·~·1 -;"Y.'o/ l'tF J •• ,. .. , '1'_'" ·t:I.·F-""~~"'~ ~.'j~'f:-~'!I~

• • i_. - I I ..... :, ...... ? .. 'j ".(.'~, ....... _~':''''': .HI", 'A~J'~I.:'''l)·'~';':;·:-",',.I!_i'.:.:/;;

KOJleHHOCTb, B03f{HK81!OUI;Jfe Ot>bJtJHO H3~3a.a.BH)KeHHfI r~,:, :"~<'t";8J~o;~~~~:1i~-:;;}tiv2'

rl!t.if.l·.neHu ' "·"M·· elOWHX ,6Ohbll'\1V1O Macey) Boo6me ,lJ.en8lOT ~~·nq"rip~~~\'f.~:ti\f~l' .

UrWl' "- , ,~ " .. - _- - . ' =, - .. ~J . .' .. ' '. ' .... " .' . '- :. 'B-' .. :!<" ·~-:y'r-~.'_:'t~';~.I:·:.~ ~;i'~' ';'~i--:~'*~" :t'~~'i:~(

BOH nMoce MeHee 0030naCHbl:M; qeM no .llpyrHM •.• ' .. ~Q!:~t)~U':I ... 9~{tc;i4~,'·;,)j'

C· ····M·'. H'-: c:n·-· e····:'KTo··p-.·.1 O'''M~ '. no 9TOMY'-"~oso~ Ha ngHHbIe 06CTOHTeJlbCtaa ~HQ;,c}(ft~~tT;~!.~· ,.

. ,,' .. , , .. , . ." .' .. - "V. ~ , .~ ~~."""". ""'~~{~U-"~~iJ '·1

. ',. ,~: . . :. .'. 'f:;'i/~? ~ ~',~'. ~J,

. _ . . . t· ... L{LI ... .!r~ '.' ;'.: ... ,' . :1 .... ~:L '~~I"'Y/II f :-;\1~. .11

P'3THTb B: HU"M: a' H' H'e . ; " i " 'jo!':' .1 .. I •. ~ •• ; :-;';r~"~'.~' -: .~'.o::_ ~< -

. .. r'".l· -U I ~ , .. ' -:;._ J.J.,::::;.r:; ~ ~, (

' .. I 'u I . _. J ! ',,' II. I' • _ ... : ,\.·r;i .... t.;;.-.,._.~ ........ '"

·T:·H'nH'J'H .. - a" H···· C- U"1Va·-.r· .• 'u'a·~·B: anJ.JTJeJlfI 06BHHHIOT B;H,a·.Py·we·H·HH '~.~60B_"~lA,···. ~·~"~j{;~>::·~i:'y.-

" ""'I - ~ .• "''''.1' ,.,~.Inl. ~.1 - . .., -I 1 .\.1>' ~ ~'..." .

,g'iO'PO')I(' ·H'L.IIX· a'H' '8'- K·O·'S .. ·· an' r:.1 p" a:g'MeTKH KO·TOpblX OH He BMelI: t{acto_rj(:M1 DT··~··· ~'>\\~.~:'J~:'j~.

~ __ ~ I, ',' I' _ ,J1.JI1 .-. I I. I . ',:--' .. : r:1 . '.'. . _. I'. '.' - - ~ .. '.:~ 'I};"'~: '~.:~~.:"~,,-,:Io

r{)BapIIB8IOT~ C03HaTMbHbJe HOpYUIHTeJlH. Ho 6W6aemAPMJ~60 .:':i(l~~~·~;··~

cu",yatfUU, ICoziJa aNa.lea .WI" pa&MemKU iJeiicinB"~AbHf!, 1l.t! :' : ';"';: .. ] 6I1iJHO., HaIlpHMep, p33MeTKa nOKpblTa caerOM HJlH aHaK,~Kp~3"~.p~S~ ..... ~:::':::!

'POC:WH:M,HCH ~BeTKlaM .. H ~epe-B~,,' .. _. _ _ .' _ ._._ .. _.~ _"._ .... :'.'~l:, .. ,:: - . ~ . ,. .'~ .:~

" EcnH no q,aK'IY aapywemul cocr8BmleTCft npoTOKOJI, flY*HO YK338Tb . . ,

.,o6bHCHeHHH Ha np'IflUtHbI,-Koropble nOMeillaJIH yBHJl,eT"b SHaK.· fu CY't

. IUeCTBoamuie -ne06XQB.HMo ~JOI(e AOK338Tb B CYJJ.e •. KaK 3TO .rJtW1STb? '.' .... .'. i

:': B cnyqae. ecnHpa3MeTKa OblJl3 nOKpblT8 cHero~,~. ~6pa~,fiT~.cft '. , . . ':

B: CY.ll., KOTOPblH' 6y.n,eT .paC'CMarpHB3Tb .ne.no, C XOJl.8.TSQ:OTIJOII 06 'H~~-, '.. !

60saHMH cnpaBKH H3 rHJlPOMeTeoc.ny.>K6b1 0 TOM,. Ha~~anCR JJ:H·: .. :. ,. ,I

,I ...

• 'so ••

..... • •••• " ....... e-» •

.. ."'. '.

u u 'YI . 'I:'

: H nO:KpOB B Jl8,HQOH M,eCTH~CT,H B on,peAeJI,e'HHblH ,Jl.e,Hb~ ";l:.CJ1'H 01'-,

: . ..,...-,- ·,;t5YAer.nOnO>KHTeJlbHbIM, OT,PHU3Tb" ,qTO- CHer ,neHCT,BHTenbB~-'C;KPbl__ ~q'.·.,~:·:]~~a3M,eTKY, 'OYller HeBO,9MO>KHO. Lt~e ecna nopory ,OlrtltnanH,

,.~0.3..'>" '. '-','1'" ',' e npoeaxen 'qa'CTU" ·T.e. 'T,a,M,;. rAe H8XOAHT"CH p,a,3M,eTK8~J.' ,Mor

.-' I.' 'T,l>Cl1 He6onhwoH CJtO'H CHera~,.. . ',.: /~: )' .. " , >j ~'.

'","",,""'-A!t'~"""".J<,~,.~~_-: ,E~H JlOPO>KHblH 3H8K saKJ1b1T BeTBHMH .o.epeolil, MO)l(HO .neHcTBOSBT&

~ .. ~I'o:.'= .. 'I!·a~,~,e'l ,A HM'e,H,HO '- nnCbMeH·,HO, 'OOP'8THTbCSl B .,lltDpU)Kfi:Q-·3Kc:nnyaTau.H~ .. 9~'HYIO ~Y>K6y II op,r,8HH3,a,l_lHIO, . orsereraeaayio ·'S9 . ~'OCT:O'ftHHe seneaux :, -. H,a'~a>tmeH'HJi. no 3a"Ko,HY· YKpa:HH,bl «0,6, o,6,p',ame'HH,RX' 'r·pa.)I(JJ.BH» . opra ~ . ·:··,flrH~~$H, nonytlHBliu,afl TaKO," sanpoc, o,G:Hsa,H3 ,nHCbMeHHO~: H8 Hero OT-

~.~"",W!ir " ,~,. YlIHTbJSaH CPOKU paCCMOT:p·eH,HH J\en 'oO"',a,llM,HHHCTpaTHBHblX

_~m '. uapyiueaaax, OT',BeT, cxopee scero, nocrynarno 3',aceAaHHH cyna,

~~~mJf:' ~,~,. , >Ke n'OBeCTK8· 83 CYM npaner paasme, MO)l(H9' 06pa'THTb'Cft C xO}l.a~ i 10M 0 nepeaeceuaa aaceA8'H,HSI B C,B,HaH c O,)KHMHHeM' OT,Be'Ta, 83 .' -:_':I'T~,e'TC;TBYIOIllHX 'opraHH38IU1H, aa KOTO,PblH Tpe,6y'eT"C5I c:OCJl.aTbC5I B

';'Cy,il.eOHOM a8Ce,lI,8HHH...· . .. . .. .'

~:/.~ KaKHM MO>KeT t)blTb TaKOH OTBeT? Cxopee acero, T3M 6Yll.eT yxa" , ." ': 0, Q'TO' '«OTMeQ'eHHbI'e HeAOC,r8'TKH)>- liMenu M:e:CTo" HO y>Ke y,cTpaHe~

.. :' -("JIB 6YI1YT YCTpaHeHbI B· OJIH>K3HweM· 6YAYllleM). ,3TO KaK pas H . .: .,~;' ~; 'ecn, T,O, caaoe aQKa,38TeJIbCTBO, ,K,OTOP' oe H,eooxoAH'M'O J_tn,R nO)l.TB,e'p-.,)I{-'

.,~ '\' . . .

;;:;~L:',~F~- .ll.eHHH cpaKT~: aOJI,HTenb .n;eRcTBHTeJlbHO Mor Hea3Me:rHTh 3H3K8 .•• To

'.}:·i?'/·· H<e caxoezacaerca c.nyqaeB, Kor.m,a SHaKIf BOOOll(e «CKPblThI>} OT 80-

~:/~~'~~;'_:' PSireJur aa!jepesMIMH lIJIH Jl.pyrHMH O(}'beKTaMH. (4aCTO ~TO ObiBaeT co

1.:... ...

J.ai".-..:. - •.. ~: .. / ... _ _. l. ... _ _ "._ _. 'u __

~~: '.~~.:' ... ' ~H~acKa'M"' '«n,e'~eXOJlHbI'H nepexon», YCTaHOBn'eHHbIMH T,a,K, xro neure .. ,

i/>~" \..... K0jD,8M ONH 3aM-eTHbI,8 BOT BO,IJ.HTe.JIHM - C TPYJlOM. OnaCHOCTb- sroro -.

~1~i~-;->:-~" HeTpyJUiO' n9IfiJTh •. ·)· . .' . ',". .. - -. . ..

~~{r-:~~:(-:; , . Hepe.D.Kct·~3H·aK HeB03MO>KHO S8MenfTb H3-33 npanapxosaaaoro ~~i\\~:·/·&.~.::·:::::. ·~K'p,.c·y·"'nH·o.r'a6a·p··:"·~HT·H.oro -rpancnopraorc cpencrsa, nanpaaep TSI>K,MO''''

~ . ,: -r , '.' "" . " . ',. .... ' . ". . ,~ ,.. - - , "', , , ..' .

:,.~~;~~ :( I . W ., - )' . _). . :'.' ... ', - .

i·:::··~,ii~·~~>::·. ::' ro ,rpY,30B,HK8, lIT'O, KCT,aTH,. SlBJlReTc.SI napyureaaex npaaan 'CTOftHKH.

~r··>f.:\t/;! ... '.' ~ , .,

i;r!;;:~*j<:~··.': IB"'TB,KOM cnysae B 06bHCHeHHH K nporoxony cnezyer yxaaars: «no,~

:;",:f".. ~J 1; .... : . . '

~ik.\:~~··:·.::'- ." .·,pO)l(H'OrO 3HaKa, He, B,l\ne,JI, T~K. O,H 6bJn aaxpur T,p,aHcnOpT'H,bJM .cpen-

~\,:"':.' CTBOM(YKa,33Th MapKY H Ho~ep), npanapxoeauaua c HapyweltHeM IJ~ ... nn. «3» n.15.9 nn.ll».

:{;:-'j.;'. Be scex 3THX CJJY'I3HX cynbe, pBCCMaTpHBalO~eMy .n.eno, Jl.OJI>KHO

6h1T:b 3aHBJleaO XOJla,r8,:HCTBO 0, npexpautennn nena aa OTcyrcTU:HeM 'COCTaBa aAM,H'HH'C,Tpa,TH:BHoro npasoaapyureaaa .. Taxoe .xotJ;BT'aH'CT':

B,O, ecna OHO' nonxpenneno AO,Ka3,aT'en,bCTB3MH,·· eyJJY' TPYJI.HO ne

YJl.OBJlleT:s,opHT,b,. . .

KOH'«PJ1'HKTbI 'c, corpYAH,HK,a,M:H MHJlHUHH '(a,a:K8H'[HSBlOin:HecSl 'C'O'~· CT,aB,Jl-eH\f~eM n'pO'TO,K0J10,B) naoma 'B03H,HK3,IOT' etue.no. GAHon np,HII':H'" ae.. Pens: ':8Ae'T 00 OOS3,3HHO'CTH ,BO,[{HTenB ~ >rlp~A:OC'TaBnSlT,b

.... -

'T,p8Hc·nop'THoe. cpencrso CO,TpYAHHKaM M,HII'HUH:·,H·.:H .;S_fJ8SI00\x,paHe·,HHft

AIIH JlOCT8,B,KU B fin:H,)KaAwele MeJlY'l,p'e>t(A,eHH:e n,HU" !UY*Jl8IOmHKC,R: B

. ,

:. ...

.'

j .

,

, .

. .. ....., .,,': ': 'J;f;r.:,1~;_:{,,~/j;·

• . .;., • . "" . '.' ' ~,t;o.-""~' ,::-;,:~ ,:' ':

• -; I... _, • .. '.., 1 •• _ 'II'II~ ;.«...~!"-r: .." I

. • . - ':.'. .' :': .••..• ,,_o.!. ~:~. ,~, 'I' ~ •. m/):~~:t:~···,· .~ ..

.. : . . :'.:: '. :':.::. • ~. ;' }' •. : .• ,:~~ L,",r, (:, .: t'~{r.·~: _..... : I

0""'

. '

......

+

_...:

T

,,_ H .

'1,.

H·~·

,

, .

t-

"'B,a,,1

c

...

,80M.

" "'"~

...... ,!!I;.'a~~,H:, H,

b··

L,:t' ,~ ,

"

Oii'

',H, ' .bl.:,

p

~.

acnopr 'T'

...



L'

.. ,

,8

fee . ~ ro:, " r '~' -- '·'ll·::-;'."- ~ ~o' c' --a' -

- ,_ I, _ j'

.. . ~ '_ - - .. '

...

"T,B'e"'

=-.'-: ,',.j

.' ." .. I ~ ~ I P ........

_ 'L ._~. L }"-:'~\:'_

~ ~. : r, : i._:-"*. I .. ~

~ _:: ,y

.. I .; •

. :.-;_:' I p .. : '! " .. ," _ .

,

t

, -

,'.: .....

r'l.~:.i;)~-!I. I ~ ~

. 'I')'. ~'1~

~

" ~

.. : .. ~

_J. I

.... "

. ~

·1 ,.

·A,· -':'a,

. ,

. ': (

.....

, .

," .. :0;:

, . ,

.--,

-

. .,

-

" - ---

. .

1t:::!: .. 21:_,..,.,....~~ .....• ". cmsgem mOAbICO e '1tiC~: ,,,efl:pomu8opectaUfed .. «oncmu-

~.f~~o..:IrI. •. yqUQ,HHbtM ·H:·OpMaM. . ".,' ·1 : •• :.: ; ••• ~+ ··:A. ~:i:.;;(' .

~~~~~y,.> .. :<aTO a nOJIHOH Mepe OTHOCHTCJr-HK: !?aKOHY «0 AOPO>KHOM:~H~

·-,IiMB». KaK B 3TOM.3aKoae, TaK RD· f:UUln QaCTH106H3b1BaJ01p.{}H c ..... ~,;;a.:LHTeJl'R· npenocraaasrs rpaacnopruoe cpeacrno :COTPY;AHHK8M ~~::". • JiJUiUHH II Me}J,HKaM, o6HapYlKHB8IOTCH ftBJU.Ie aeCOOTseTCTBMR .: KOHCTHTY'" .u..' HH~ 11 sro aaer .BOI1HteJlIO BO.3M·O·)K,HO'CTb 'OTCTaH.S8T.b.

i " . .. ~. -l~ I I I .

. . .

. ';89" .K.O·H.ICTHTY,U,HoHHble npasa B .cnysae, ecna: K ,HeMY npem.aaneao

· .. '·!·T····a.··K··'·'o··,:,e··, T,:p--e·"l!o·s'·a·HH·e·· " ., .'. ~ '" ". :,".".. ; ....

. ", " Iii-" . ~ _.' .' u· . '" ,.'. ,.. . .,. : . ." .' . ':'. ~ . . . .'

. ..: ..~He'lHo,.Jl,oKa3b1BaTb3To K3»\AOMY. cotPYAHHKY MH.afiu.HH "JiH Me~~~,' .,~..;_' ,)le'no enaa.na 6 .. naroaapuoe. Ho "Y>K,H,O·yqUT·bl'B,8.Tb, xro naa"~di~~:f.FL:1f-:a '~o.nO)KeHlUI 3aKOHa «0 ,lJ,OpmKHOM ,Il,BIDKeHHU»H'JUUl 06b1'1HO

I •• •

~':;J~';fIi_::A"':~'" '.,'.' .• ·.HSI]OT'C5I B y'CJlOBHHX, ,KO.rJt~.Y C9TPyn.ulf'K3 ,MHJI~lUIH npOCTO ReT

~ -

.," M'O)j(,HOCTH T'paTHTb, BpeM,R aa 'C'OCT8,Bn'eHHe npOT'OKOJIa.u .

~~~~ .:;k~K nocrynari., ecna npOTOKOJl-BCe me COcTaOJlHeTCSI?· ..

•. B~:-', . c 8:'O:'H"X 06,"'''"1,... CI C-"H- e','HHO'X aeo 6:x"O""H'M"O:' y .. xa 3·a·: T-'~ 'cJl'~e"'AY"'·: t,n,Tl~'e,~·e'·-« '8-': bI::' .....

.. ~; _".:. _.' ,... . .' un _.- n·_ i!.I: . ,I, •• _: _._ • ~._. ;i:. :.~. I' _ '._ '.r • ..u -, .' ,,' ,': I'J~'" ,'" ".-_: "',

" ,

. , .. ', -, ,H~H,H,e Tpe6oBaH'HfI ,0 npe)I.OC'TaBJI,e,HHH rpaacnopraoro CP~,ACT-

. . . . .

,..,..._~,-' .. .. 's,p,eMeH"HO JlHWaeT' MeH·.H B,'03MO'>KHOC,TH ,nO,Jlb,3'OB,aTbC'SI, ,M

"-=-:-;'="''>''', .:- I'"

~~~.:'PH)K~TbCH rpaacnoprnua .,cpe,aCT,BOM; 9'T9\',f{,BJlIfleT'CH aapy-

~,H,,~,eM~/:p.pa,~a, COOCT,aeHHOCTH_. ,J{aRH'bI,O"'CJlyqa,R He BXOJl.H,T B RC. , ·~.)(JI~:~·HT~,jIbHU.H', rtepeuens c,HTyaUM'H,t K,O'~Aa .. H,apyw,eH,H·e· {lp,aB,a,

. '~'~''__''''.\. :~C'OfPc,TB:eH:~:~C:T~H paspeiueao ,cT,.41·- KOH.CTH·T'YLlHH ··Y,K,p.8,HH'bI: Co,_ . ·::.,:-< .. r.n9C;HO CT .8·I{OHCTHTYU,HH, saxona H nopaaraaaueaxru ,lJ,OJl>KHbI "\,,.'.:,.'.'.·OTBeqaT,b eii~.HopMbl KOHCTHTYUHH HonHIOTCR.HOpM3,MH npsxoro .,~.,.~<~(-~:~_:>.'" ,.~~,ACT.B~~ •. JJ:(J~3TOMY' ,B cnynae rrporuaopevaa KOH~THTYIlHH ,H HHblX ':-(;:'.: aopMaTHB~hi.lt' :aKTOB npHMeHHIOTCR HOpMbI· KtUICTUTNHH, KOTO ~ ".ilii'K>I'~"'''''~~'::.~' ":~. -/~p~.ble ne. 'p"',a$p'~w,a:){)T B TaKOH cOTy.aUH" H'8,PY,tpeH,HR npasa C06CT-

'. ''- .. , .,: .•...•. ,- .. '. c· "fJ "",-1 . . . - ;.' . . ..

!lli(l'ff. •. _.,~~.~.~ " .~ • ' ;BeH H OCT"' . . .', :",·'8·' ~.'yKa3a H HblX OC'H 0,88 H :H ,SI X Cq'HT'a,M) CDO If AeH CT B,H'H'

:."..L""' v- '~:~>,;: ;, -np aB()M ep l,i:~~k~» .. _ ... ' ... .. . ' ... - -. ' ;,.- . '. . ,... . , .

.' ,'. ,3A~Cb cneJiyeT Y'IHT,blSaTL, 4TO paccaorpeaae l(en O,A8.HHO,H xa-

. ,.,·r-·TerQPHH .HapyweuHif OCTaSJleHO sa .l1.0Jl)KHOCTH~MIf' JlH~MH' rAM. ><'-1.:; .. E'CJIH :T8KP.M .. ,JlHIlOM auaeceno nO'C'TaSOBJ)le,H,He 0 ri,pMM:eaeH'HH ,K.BO-

.. ~:~' - .. -- ·Jl.HTe.ntO :MM:HHHCTpaTHBHOfO B3b1CK3HHfI, ero MO>KH9 '06maJlOBaTh B ,

~~(,~~~~;~:.":': :.. CYA. 'COC'Ta .. BJI.flH Ta~y,1O >KaJl'Oo'y, ,Hy>KHO, ,Kp'OMe KOH,CTlIry,UHH, \CO-. cnarsca aa n i-2 nOcr8H'OBJI'eHH,H Ilneayua Bepxoaaero cYJl.a YKp,8H" Rbi «'0 ,npHMe'HeHHH. KOHCTR'ry,UHH YK,p,3HHbI n'pH~(9cymeCT,BneHHH npasocynaa» OT 1.11.1996 r., rne YKa38Ho: «'CYJlbl.npH paccaorpe;H,80' KO:H,KpeTHblx aen ,)lOJl>KHbI oueHHS8Tb coJte,p.lKaHHe J),100or'o ··3,a ... K!Q,H8 'HJr,H' HH:!oro' ,HOPM8THBHo,-,n'paa,o'Bo.rO 3KT8 .c TOq'I«H '.3'p,e,H.'HH era C'OOTB,eTlCT'BHSI ,KO'HC.TH'tyl.\H,H H ,80 acex ,Heo6~,Q,n~,MLt'X(\.CJlyqaflx npa-

MeHHT,b KO,HCTH'ry.UHJO K8K a,K'T np,HMoro ,AeA'CTB,:HSI:, -CYl.leO'Hble 'peure,H",HR' AOn>KHbI Q,aSHpOB,8TbC,H ua K·OHCTH'TynHH·t.~ .a T.a·K>Ke ,H8 . . lI.eHCT'BYlOlUe,M 3,8KO·H'OAaTeJlbCT.Be, He np'OTH'Bopell,aine,M' eH ... ~·

_. eYA HenOCpe.l{CTSeHHO npHMeHfleT KOHcnnyUHIO B cnyqae •.. . .

3aK'O'H" Ae,HC,TB'OB8BWHH' .11.0 ,BB~~,HlIH 8 AeHCTBHe' ,KOHCT:HtyUH,H. H~~'I' "'iIiiI'!-~!II~".".o.!'J!!!

- tJ ~ .. : ~.' .

Hft'TbI'H nOCJ1e 3Toro, np'OT'HBo~p,e,q::HT eM }>'. '. . : '. 4' .: .~. < ":. " .Ji!.5,'!Ij ':o]iij/~

Clj>0pMy.nHPOB3HO .llOc:raTOl(HO He.ll.SYCMbICJleHHO. l1,naeT .

aocts Ka>l\nOMY, B 'TOM "'IRCJie H~BOJlHT[enlO" OTCT8HsaT'b B cyne C,B~H ..... '",. .. ',..y'=p';,.,,~:~4,iolC~

, .CTHTY~H'OH,Hble n,p'aB8.· _

CO,6CTB,eHHo" scex 'cHry'a,UHH, xoropue MOryr 'BO'3H"~HyT:b··H_:,~B.i. ~~~'11~

pore, He npellYCMOTpHlllb H IIH B KaKOH KHHre He onHweWb.'l1 TO'8 aa see cnysaa >KH,3·,fiH He ,AaWb, K,pOMe onaoro n .

'.~ B',H.H·'l'II,areJlbHeH,WHM o6,pa~'O,M ~H3yqH'T'b Ilpaanna AOpO>K,H~ro·:· ••

HHR H npHMeHRTb Hx,·npHl.feM He TOJlbKO 6YKB8JlbHOt a aHa,ifH3. HOP',Mbl H CO'OT,HOeft C ,AeHCrBYIO,UlI-I'M 3a,~oH,oJUiTen,bCT.80.M.·.'~·,yr ...... ~~

- . " . i J .

K'OTOPblH -Hay~HJlcH 3TO'Jlen~'Tb" .K,a.K n'O,K,8S,bIBae'T Q,n,'bIT, V~:\-,'~

a)lMHHHCTpatHBHoftoTBeTCTBeHHOCTH ropa3Ao cnO>KHe·e •. H .-=\""~ ... ~

HO-, He HY>KHO 60HT~CH OTCT3HBaTb CBOHnpaB8.0co6eHa:~'·.

. SHB,HH,H COOCTBeHHO'H' npasoru .

r. .

. .

. ..... .

',' ...

..: .. r :

'. '

. ..

. ! ~

, ..

,.

. ,

I'

. '

: .

,_. ..., ..

. '.

; ... I •

. -....... "'.". ; '.' ":~ ': >-~""

'.~ .' '. r •• ~

-' ..' ;~. .

I . !

.... ..,

I '!..... .

.. '1'"

' ..

"

• I'

." .....

'.. I .. I

.'

-, , .. -..... 'i!;.

, • ,£ .: 'I!

. r;. L "'!Il ,.' .

... ... ;_ . ~ .

..... • /: ....... :r.. <$¥' _.r.· ..•

• iI.. .. ·.IP'

" I •

+

" -

. .... ~ .

.

. ~ ... "-f

. i' '.

.c >, :

- .'.

·i, .:

" .

, .

.

}'

. '

'., - . , l·

•• " v ,

BeStKl.iR BCRqUHa

• ,,1' '. - - - -

.. , I •

.. , ...

:. : <' ... ~ ::/. I .;. :-"'~".' .. .

..~. .

~ • • I _ -

... '. •. . .,' ...... ..-=

';:,.;.~".<~~":, ': " .: ::.',"" .. :r.' .}.: .. '.> .'.

'~~;::,~\;;,OlfeHh p~np~.'OC,Tpa.HeHHaft· npH1.f.H.H.a KOH:(jlJIHKT'OB M~~m, BOJl}fTeJ1H-

•. ,1 I ., . '. " . ~".~

<';!:::'_~if'~d)TpYJ,lifUKaMa rAM - Hey.n.oaneTSOpHTeJI6Hoe,' C TOlJKH speHHR ':' ....... c.:,~,;:! ,:"":;:::~eJi~Hx:,<~(i~HHe rpascnopraux cpenera, npemrrCTBYIOWee HX

:)(":,~ " " :', ',,:;,i>.,_. __ : , ,aUHH. M' KOH$nHKThI SYrH·6blsalOT, nOlK8.nyii,

I!E'5D.IiM.J;""~l~" ':.tMaa6Mee·'·';" 'HHblMn flPWIHHB sroro npocra: pess a T3KHX c.nyqa~

a;r,.~":':"'l?iij;~~ 'lIe~Ko 06 8.lI.MH~HCTpaTH8HOiioTBerctBe~oCrH BO.D.H~SI, H~ ':~:;,ii 4\): ~an~Te~Cn.nyaTalUfH rpancnoprnoro cpeacraa. lITo QpeB8rO, K8K

~ .'..., . _..: .,' " , '

~ . . '. #C..,_ _ '

V:,, ,'~JIJlO,-, epUB,OM scex MaHOS a.na.ne.nhQB 8STOMOUlulfl, qacro'- H3PJUl-

',.:',':' ~MH 381'pa1'aMH H3 peMOIfT, H nO'ITH ecerna - norepea BpeMeHU na 00- ~-r;~'_;~,:'~ B fAH,itro6bI sa6p'STb HOMep" HbI,e ,3Ha.KH" H3bHTble H,H'cneK.TopO:M"

' ; ~ te .~ , .'. !. , , ' - . .

. ,->;,"::BO'r c nocaeaaero MbJ H Half HeM. nOCJ1e npHHSlTMSI HOBblX TIJUl,

~;-{~-(Y,:.: .. acrynHSWHx B .a.eHCTSHe c I J1HSapH 2002 r. t pacnpocrpaaanaej, CJI~1f 0 . ~,' '~;: .. ," :. TOM, .liTO aanpew.aTh sxcnnyarauaio He KcnpaSHbfX, TpSHcnopTHbIX

~~";.::~' ,',' Cpe.aCTB (iy.uyr reneps He: nyreM "S'bRTOH HOMepliLlX9HaKOB, a nyreM no ..

,:~:~~,~~: .. ,;.~ ~ ' .... : '. 'CT8HOBKH Ha WTP'~IlJIOllJ('"rro. . .'

~,< .Vi.,.,. .,' 't' ~"J'I . .

{,":~" ,:'c, .' Kak .lI.eJlO 06cTOHT B JleHCTBHTeJJLHOCTH? ,', ' .'..' ..

f'- •. " . , ' Q6pamMCSl k n.31.4 I1Jlll. TaM YK8a8Ho: «3anpew.aerCH 3KCl1Jlya-

to,> ~ ;" . Tatufft TpaHcnoprHhIX Cpe;J,CT8 B COOTBeTCTBHH CJJ.eiiCTsylolU,HM a8KOHO-

.,::,.','-,.zJrre.nbCTBOM ••• » llanee cne.nyer nepeseas He HcopaBHoCtell, xoropue

r; . ';, -"".,j. MOryI' ()biTb nOBo.d.OM JI,ilSI raxoro aanpeTa.· . " .' .

""'i"

. '.

-~ - - -:-..-!.p- ........:.. ...

,t

". • •• 'l'r",'," •

. ' ~

.~.:, .

.. -, .... :

, -,

F •

I.

. '....

• .. ,r

. , . '", r"

8

, ,_

-, ,

-- - - __ . ---

..

,

I .'

. I

r .... ~ ~' ..

1 _:-"'II ~ i"

a ...

.. ... ~ I

. .

.......... ~: ...

I' ~ ' ••

-: I -, ..

... .~~~:" ~ i. : L' ..

. .

. ,

" .

r ~ •

.

-,

.. .. r,

.. ~ - .. . ~ ..

. '

. ,

,. 6blBaeT, nwaIDTCR 3anpeTfUb9KcnnyaTaUHlO rpaaenoprnoro

1iII!a.&.""'. . no .HBHG -H~MaHHYM npHQHH8M, II 3STOMOOHRH HIl AQPOraX

~"<IL".lIIj._II!; CR B T8KO,M COCT08lHHH, xro ,A",~~'Jl8eWbCH ........ KaK ,OHM eute He,

,._"""""-",,,,"11":"" ..• ' ~' , " I ,HC:b ,8,3 'lIB:C,TH np.HM,Ct BO ,B,pe:,M~U/.tlBH)KeH~HH? . . . ..~.: .'- .

~i.fiIi:' ,;';-, - 'lfT,O KscaercSi COTPYJlHIII«lB fAIt" TIl; .nuraaes 3BnpeTHTb 3K~,~

;;n~y;;t!~UHIO TpaHcnopTHoro Cpe,lJ;CTB3 npH'O'fcyTCTBHHueHcnpaBHO" ~e)i,· RepeqHCJleHHblX B. 11.31.4 nUll, oaa CCblJIaIOTCH H8 n.31.1 . aBKJI.llaHHblH nyHKT npeacraansen coooro nexnapaun» 0 TOM;, . ·.c.'O'~:!'OHH,He. Tpa,Hcn'O,pTHBIX cpeacre. ,ltOnJKH,Q 'CO"OTB'eTCTBO,B3Tb . ,,~,a:lHBHblM 3KT8M U HOpMa1'HBHO-Te~Hlfq~CKOH>.1J;OKYMeHT:au.hH, B .. '~~~~TPYKU.HHM npe}J.npH$lTHH_-npo.H3BO.ltHTeJlen, •. C3Moe rnaaaoe: .' ' .~'~,PJUlB cnynae HeCOOTserCTBHR'TpaRCnOpTHtlfO Cp,e.ll.CTB8 ero .< 0~f:l~HHM npe.AYCM8TpHBseTT3K}'lO Mepy KaJ{ sanper sxcnnyara-

-! -3 n .. 31.1 - He npeJzy,cM3TpoBaeT. Jla uue.neno riLlno 6bJ aanpe ~ ~1!mij'jm~1'rl,:,:,.·~.-~K,C,~:n:yaT,a,U.HIO .rpaucnopraoro cpeacraa 'H3"!"3,a~ \ ,B'C"RKor,o

T~~TCT8HSI aaBo}J.cKoHHHCTPYKIl.HH no 3KCI1Jty3TalJ;HH ,R Jip!yrHM '"'

I'lIf-E'Io.J~l~I.M AO~yMeH'raM ~" . . "'. . ... , "1', "':.'?' .', . ." .. '.... . .'. - ,

• .....,_,_. '1tJ.', ... '.' .' .' - • • ..,. • •

~~.~ ~'~ ". ';,/:-Ia~pHMep, sa aBTOMOOFfJle saBO)J,OM p:8JJ;HonpueMHHK YCT8-

"- i.: ,;~(~a;u.eneu. erOCHSlJI. ECJlH IiIpHeMHHK_B lurCTpYKllHH-,yno~::~.;~~~<?' .. , '~~.~ .. ~)K~ -- He~COOT:B~TC,T'B'H,eu~ TaK 'qTO ,me, ,H3,~sa .. 3T'oro

"~'~," .~' •• 111"'~._ ""-.' .,', • a~~~3~npew.aTb? Jla'" IGIK~H" B.~'OTCyr:CTBHH ripueMHHKOB

.' :_!;~,:" _ »,.I]SI'· ~1J)Ke'~~~~ onaCHOCTb? H. T8Knx npaxepoa M_OlKH'() npaaecrn

. ';'.:. :~(/. C,KOJl,bK'O yrOll;HO, '. " 'r . .' .

.. ·,~:X<.,; ;Kp~f4e_T6r?:B CT.37 3aKOHa«O Jl~P~HO~A~:~~~mI'~~~; K~,KHB

~~·;,>F ':~ ·:DJ:3J.4 nJJJ[~}~~TKO rOBopuTCH 0 H'eHcnpaBRocTBX"lDP,H K:OTI'a.P,· ~~"X,' ~~K',C-:''''''

"'~'\" • , """. • • ~ .0;.. , " ~ iJ-N, J,

:?~y~: ::~:'~:<~aT:al{H'H rp~-~,cnop. 'T,HbJX, ,cp,eACT',B He nony~-",: 'C,Ka,~: 'e- T'·C~ H" M' enno ~T'-'O no

.. ., ' . . ,(_. ~'~' .' " ~',.r. ,_ "I... '" ,n ~ . I

":.:."._.....,. .. ,<::c~.aKoHyt: ~;'bJii:g:aaflHe MH sanpera 'SK,C,RJly',a:T'B'-'HR (':·K·.-,c- f.ra'T-'~'H-;' 'H": aca-

..... - +."II!!I'" .. • • r( .. ~ . ~ I. I ~ - - I , . ~ _ [ _, , 1_:-. ..-.

~~Te{~';}:,;:.\MOM' nYIJ~T,~'":~aBHJI CO,llep>KHTCH CCLlJlK3' Ha",o,lITO ,9KCnJIY8T3L\HR

~wr.-t>:'!'o:."'11~";, ,'3an~~w,aeT~'_"~M(mHO B COOTBeTCTBHH C:.l!;enClSYIOD..UIM 3aKOHO)l.8 ~

Od-·.o>:,,~.:oo;,;,,'r·:, reJlf)~TBO_M."l>-00~JlaCHOq.2 CT. 19 KOHCTffTYIJ.HH.AoJI:>KHOCTH'ble JIHIta

~i, ';,': op~a __ ~,IOB'~OCY~ClPcTBeHHoH BJI3CTHMOryr neiiCTB()BaTb TOJlbKO aa OC;. ~~ ~~~ .,' . _HO~aH~~i .~np~~~JIax nonHOMOlfHH " cno'COOOM, 'npe.1lYCMOTpeHHLlMH ~ r':';{, . ,~OHCT~eli':' H33KOHOM. To ecrs - aanperan, $KcnJIyaT8UHIO ~;·:r_",,;.:Tpa":~opT"?ro e~e.u.cTB~Ton~Ko npn HaJlHlIHH neacnpaenocrea, npe-

'~:I"~" -I s: l'JVcM,ATpeHHL"x n 31 4 n'JJLI . ,. .' . ,

~r' ' .. '. '~ ':--', , ..... e ,iYI"'. ~~.' 'iII~'~· _+"*+~.. t.; ":' .: ... ;~:.-.:::.,.: .. ' - .. ' .: .

$;~:5:~i' ," a, ,n~TOMY ncpe~eHbsTHx ueucnpaaaocrea ~}I(H~IJ)nKo 3M8Tb. H j.;,/;,.' . _ ~p~,.eHTHpOBa"HO npHMeHHTb B cnyxae KOH.pJUfKT3 ccorpynanxa-

1 .. '::.: M,HfAH~., . _::~ .. ,.,_.1:: ..... ,:"' ..

~re-(Y).,·~ . ~ , - . . .' . .,

~~~.: '~~: ... ' •••• • h np'HBeAeM' 'HeC'Kon,bKO npHMep'OB~ ; . .' .: ~"'. :.~' ..

t,: •• '.' . r .,. Hanpasrep, ynacnexropa nperenaaa no' nOB'OAY P>K80hlX xonec-

~:' HbIX, Jl;HC~OB_ "SBT'OMo,tS'H,nR. ,3):leCb ,H'y>K'H'O 'CO'CJl8T&Cn na nn, «E»'

, .'. 0.3-1 .4.~ IllfJl,r.n.e rrpe,nyCMOTpeH(), '-ITO- OCHOa3FlM:eM·.u;Ul .. sanpera

":~~:~~ .: __ \~ ., •. 3Kc,'Dnya,'T,BQ,HU' MOryr t)blTb Tonb,KO OTCYTCTB:He 6.0'JIT'3 un,," r.aH~H

.. ',...( .. !,!g ...,' " . I •

.:

- . .' .

KpenneHIUI'HnH rpeumau A~CKOB H OOO.ll:OBKOJIec. Tp'eUJ.HHbI, ,,'., ... "-',""j~.~11

K3K ne ·nOBe,p,XH'OCTHaH K'O'PP~$:~,H~", ':'_

.HHcneKTOp CqHTaeT, 'ITO ne,ltOnYCUIMO HanHqH,e rpeunm H3·m· SlGQ~ S'()M' crexne ,a:BTo,M,Ot)HJlH. -,8 310M' cnyqae H)'lKHO 'C,OcCJ[,3'Tbca: H3 nn, t'~~

rm. <{8» n~3,1 ,.4,.7 n~nJl. Ta.M 'Yl<8a3H'O, 'IIT'O ,9Kcnny8Ta:llHR TPi . a Mcn' ·w· Ifltl~~

\ ':

. ro CPeACTBB' aanpe:1I1ae~rcH, xorna n:pe;JycM,oTp.eH':HbIX K,OH:CT : K.J L:U r:t: 't :!;Im~IC4~

KOJI aooeme HeT, ,WI'll >Ke :R8 crexaa YCT8Hosn:eHbI nonOJl: . t,:i, ,.11.1 npeaaera, orpaH~Hlq:HBalOtnHe ocsopnocrs C MeCT8 BOD1lTena:

. Mo.;.

'W8IOWH.'e npoapaxnocrs. , ." e)KAy T1e::M, 'TpeIUH:Ha He R'BJI,H.eTCR BB UlI'j:

'TeJlbHhlM' npenaeroa (If eaea no .orpa.HH1JHBaeT '069'OP'H .~cl,rK~ ••

:HBJlUIJH:e caao no ceoe YKa3bI:BaeT' H,a TO, q'TO 'C.T'eKnO aa M

. .

" , , u _ _

My oc,~OBaH,HHJUIH' sanpera sxcnnyarauan Her fI' ,8 310M ,V''1H!~~i

. .

. HH,C,tJeKTOp' onrraer HeAonylc,THMbl:M OTcyrCTBHe ,6pbI3,~~n:~t ~~"'=c..')'

. ~'

CnpaBeJIJIHB9 TOJIbK,O Mn caysan, :KO.rA8 'OH,1i npenycaorpea '

UH'eH rpancnopraoro CpeJlCTB,a (rm, «e» n~31 ,.4.'7 IUl1l),..':'~'~ _lIg ,H3' ·MHorHX a'B,T'OMIOOHJ1HX naocrpaaaux ,M,a:poK) H,3roTOB, 1:',.1., 'Ieu~~~ttfilll :np'~CM'OTp<eHbI H He' 'YCT8,H'a:BJlHBaIOTCH,t Tp,aH:cn:O'PTH~~- '!li)U~~~I_"",~

>KeT 3'KcnnyaT:HpOB,aTbCH. ". I. . •. '.

-. .: ,)1':Hcne:KT'Op :o6:H,a'pY>K~ :He3Ha~q]~,Ten:bHoe nOJ1.T,eKa~~~.'iI! .. ".Ii' ILIII~!I

..... . , - '\.. f1k1f"'~.J~

rarens 'M nonaraer II·TO :B'.ra,Ko,M CO'C,TOfJ:HHH. aBTO,Mot}IIJtb.~.'3j'I\.'\m

. ~-' .... j ~~~~~

san, HeJIb3H. Hy>KHO npeJJIIO>KHTb euy HaUTH yno·." ." .

neacnpaaaocra a 0.31.4,. nna TaM OR T8K.OBOH He Hlia&llll1 nOBOA K ,3a:n'petyr!SlKcMyar:aLtH'H - HerepMe'THlI'H'O'C,Tb· .'

M,b], a Hie 'CHCT~:MlbI CM83KH,)UJH'raTeJlSI (n.St ~~.6). A -cn'en'lB.~mIHRtJliii'-U.,~~

. .

'. . .... '. I,.

.: .• .r,1 .. ' ~~. I':' ' '. ' ". ') .. .. ' ..

:,},,~"",'l:':F':lli<: i: ,.",~ > .: '..

·~~i .. ~:~~. ~ ::-:.' I ~ .. ' ':',': • I.~ ... / '::'.:' '" : ': .

'Ui, . _ .. _

.. HOBa'H:U" AJ1H Ha~HT':HH' ROMe,pHbI'X 3H8KOB HeT •.

':. .. Cnacox n,OAOoHbJ;X cHrya,UHR' 'Mo>KeT OblTb 6eCK ,._',:"" ,_""",,,=. it"k1!:I.a:II~tU¥J}:yx·~m~\1l

ysnosa JJ.eTaJleH, He ynoMHayrblx B n~31. 4 TIM, B _I ...... 1I!";.'iIII".~~

H. aa rpaacnopraoa cpencrse, H8XOAHmeMC,H B .9'KCr 'H:HKa:K, He MOryT p"a6C).taT~, lfAean'bH,O~.~ ~

.. " qT'o~~,a'Tb;.eCJIH·B DQA06'HO:H, caryauaa yCieAHTb, 11':11:",&1'1 !f!~'AU&I"'n

eA :npa,BOTe He, Yll~QC:"b'? . .

Bo-nepaax, eCJIH COCT~BJI"e,TCR nparo'K.OJI 06, ,.:HH. '

,aORapyweH:R,u: aa "yn:p,8ueHHe 'TpaH'CnOp1,H,blM cpener ..... ,,~'!!~.o1.!"i!!',~QI~.\~:RIII[<I nllt::

'1&10, ,C KOTO,po:B ern :3,KCl1!IYaT3lUfH He aanpeuiena, B .

UV»l~O ,H8,nHcaTb: «Tlp OT'OKOJ1. C'OCT,aBJISl'e'TCSI B 'C'B)l3,H CUI ." .,.',' ~'B~:P~:7~~~~~:

~'''J'.'''' _ .. "," _ ' ~J".;; ,,-, -~ .'~ ,'f~"'itt'"~

npaSHOCTb, npliBJIeKl..U)1O BHHM3HHe HHCneKTOpa). )laHHaH He:Hcn'paB~?1~

He. HBJlReTC:R 'T8KOH" n,p~ HaJIUQHH KOTO,poA 3KCl1!IYar8QH'H TpaH'cnO,pT,~IP:> .',~,~:~~ CPeJI.CTBa aanpemeaa HB OCHOOSH"" 0.31.4 f1JIll (M'lee }'K33aTh, nOtlt)MY; ,_/''' "MeHHo). n03TOMY Ctlm810:, 'fTO B HapymeHlfR nJUl HHeBHHOBeH, a nporo- '}~ . .ii'5l' ~

KOJI c,ocra'BJ]eH H H'oM'e'p:uble~3'HaK.H H3:blM,atoTCH He'3aKOHHO»~ ..... .1' .... :' ,. - , ":'- \F'~~~~

Ho B nOP'ooHoHcmyaun.lt __ 3TO TOJlbKO nepBbJR stan, . ,_', • '~\': -;"'~PA

. BeJlb HOMepHble 3H8KH- Bee >Ke H3'bHTbI, a 6e3 DUX -Hea03MQHCHO>, ... nM,b30:Bar,bCS1 Tp.3Hc:nop_ TH'hIM .-CPe.AC,TB'OM,~ n03TOMY CJIe)lye'T B ,MO'Me:HT~ .~. , .. ' .. ' .. ,_.

. . f~'~'!' ~ .

, . . ~., .• ,.'.·t ... " .:'. :\ -, ~. ;.'-"<·:.<:.:.'l·b:

..': : .. ,r .. "." . . . r " " " .. t .. ,.'

. Texnusa.: . .' ' .. ', :,,:'?',~,;// -, t,: ;:.)~i~~:j;"::4>;~~'~~~~;;} .

. , •. '.' . ,~, '.. - ~ , ... ,. ~. . ',', '1:1:=i.!<"' ~~, [.. ..;";';

. .":- _: .... r: . . ',' -.i L .. :- .:-. .' .. :. ./: .,,' • J .. " .... , :-.~ -·:il,;_~.";·~~:·~:· -:.. .... ~~" ~~'"

.. _:.. ...

: .. :-~~ .........

:c:-rtb2l11 ·UR HO~Mep.HbIX 3.HaK:OB mQ'lNQ:,SHomb 1/ U,II.CneICmOp!fJ.L1!J: _IUJ.",OM

~~

IIUU OH· CAgJICum U &,~e~~,6ioym HaxoiJum,b\CIJ·:"~Mep·-

.~ ... EllUl,," (06f?1I.JHO iTO' ~ OllHo H TQ:'~ D9JJ.P83Ae.neIlHe ):. ' .. riOCJI,~~e:ro

, . .,;1.. .'

... ~. .. ·He:M,eMeHHO JlB,UT,beft TYAa" npea8~p,ttreJIhHO Hanuca8 8d~

, aino~;1IMI)pa3iJeit~ >3IUI8UHue. B HeM IlY.--

"'."""-:-.- ,I #,IlOZU,m,& .. o6cmo)Jtne;,i;"~RJBa np.O"'~ClUt!8UU1a(J: . t/J'aMUJl.UJ9 .<IJ

·.itd.e~·~.·,Haenll:iJH.'020 3ICetnO.Hd eoRlp'?·',,: . ,g. ·8H.ul(;a ~rAII; ?o,e· OIL 8aaefl·~

I· • ~ ~ r· ~ ~ r"

, '., .. '.·,o{JumeAII; neuc"paBIIOC •• ':'\~BJlau c.ltl(.llMftUeM somopoi;

.. i'iU{f6llmbl HDMepHbte'3H4Ru;· tUtall"olUlOCmfl;3anpema 'ICC-

. . .. ': . .' a8mOM06UJ1J1~ B~ CM3U., e·:"aQ·"SQU tlel"Onpla,8Hoc'm"~ .

• fi'!!IijI~· • ' HHH tty>KHO "3JlO>KMTb' npoCb6y uePNYTb HOMePuwe 3HSKH B u __ .)",C He3aKOHHOCT~ UK H3W111f~,'II' ,;e06i~AHMQcr&iO ~bH~Awefi

_o- .. --:"-c0"'-"-'F.,':. ........ , " .: ... , . 1 a,BT'OM06H11:R. :. ~ . ~ ... '~ ~ ~>, .: .. :,. 'J. .~. ~.;;,.. ../ \.:... .

~'!fiMI"'4'ld: '" '~.~~!' ~afUlJIeaHeM Hj')KHO oC>paTHTbCM ~ ,pvKO&OM:reJIJO nOAP~3- .. ..,. ~·:tAI1·t a aero 'OTCYTCTBHe, ~~K 3a~Me,cTHT.~to.IItJ::lU·ll~>KYp~OMY

~~:;;':~Ii";. _ .~, " eHHlO. Cxopeescerccnccaenyer KONlilifAa, f{o,,~p~ble

i.GH.'l.'.r:.I~~':P~Yrb.;. , .' ' .' _ '. ., - . ._ " '.' ;'" ". " ':. :". .'., .

, ' .' ~~t6 He np 0 H3oi\!ler , 8Aadueq mp~~"t?eo cpeOcm~:&INR.' ~e. m'" . ·'.fjIJItH,oe npaeo ,o6pa·mumbCIl _:)~ga. ... $(1:. iJ'OlueUfBHueM

,. . . '''H()~ U MOpfitu,"020.: ,YUfep6c4 4J)tJfIUNeSH.OIO H.eaa... . .

,'"- .. :: ~ . ,\. ' .. ..... - ., .. ~-..~ , ,. . .... MoD ~ ,. ,~ .

. 81Jt",~e.mOM, a,"CtlA~1Q,m4u,uu ,a,6I1J(J·. ,,_ ~. ''"~ IIAA·~.. ..... ... .

'. .:~;:L;~,'r: .L.. ~ .., ..

'. . ',~ .. :' ~:£Ule, 6.~~:'J~tleKT np.·otlneMbi. Jisltotliopwe,H4UC111lQ8IUJC"_' np«

.(. •• III I.. ~ •• ._.... •• {'.. • r

JS','iiOtitoptlli 'tcCNtyamaqUJI mp4HcnopllliJblx epeiJCmB BIlRp~elll'"

:,~:<c.;;;', ~ ,.' ,. ,'I':·· ma B mo"HbIX ~t:ui.e1lUJtX onpe(l~~ napaMe·

.':'i.. .'!a ~ ·,1 _. - I • _ ... •

~1it~l, :.;[~T:~~t.f."'!~. ;... ';: ' . ' '., BeJlHlIHH8 ,yKJIqH~,t Ha· KOT~~~t~Jl~'*~~YAep>l<HB~TIl .

. ·\~· .. ~~f·~~~.a~H·:·' .;, ,.' .' ' . 'CTOf[,HOqHblA··TOpMOO", n~tt.!,B pyn,e',B'OM 'ynpa,BJ)e-,

~. ( ..... -:' .:;1' 't~~ r ,> ~. - .' ':":' '.. I·'· .. .' -, ..' ?.~.~ " , , '

.... :;·.·f··.: .Ui'j'l.,ij·· .. S···· hi· ·00- Ta PHcyn- ,-.- 'UQ nptVrO'KTopa-- ·1.llltJ'H· H Tn·, . . .. ,

"'_"",,",,",'J .• ;'\~(.(~.~#..' i~ .. ,' , .;_.',1, .. : ~ .:;'. __ ' .'. ' .. ~ no ',: ~:J~ , ,> '; I.'~$' 1.: ,;, ...•. ' ,i .•.. • . , .: ~-'. J •

. , ":;::*')'~. '.' '.. ,. . 'ft cHryaLUfH. 'kOI"llI" ~B·oe).1.ICHQ H (}e3 .P3Me,pe"HH.~

fEEli'I&'u:.Ilr;;:>.,,:. -. J. I ..... ".:-"~" . I.. . • -: 1. or,: ~. • • I

, ~:~:;.,~h:;HflilpqMep:t,;iii)A;ua .BOO'c)lUe He HMee:T HHK8,Koro pnq'HKa ~POTe',KTopa, H8-

~:"~~:.'.HHaa.· c~~,e, roHOlJHblA «CJtHK»; H;Q' ecnH 'PHCYHOK nporesropa

.~~1 1 I , •••• .I~- • I, .' i I _ " .

""""""-"."'.' , :;";,nRHCyycmyeT!:py.nesoe ynpaBJleHHe paOOTOcnoco6HO~H T,J{.t '~Ml 8W.~

l'ZiM~tiQli;'ot-::'V' ",,> .. '.u",;;a{:'i.ti«~"'CJl AU' san.peUfeHltcUI tteuCIlTifJ8Ifi1eai", 'O{JHO-

"',...,."._ .e.: : ,;,':~·::i,,~(/~,~~':uSMepe"UJJ .. IT03TOMY HHcneKTOPY, npWlO>KHBrqeMY, M"'~; }.r.·:~.,' .. r: J(" .. p.p' "HNepy~,,"~qaTb pyneM, HY>KHO 38Jl.8Tb,OlJeHb npO,CT~ aonpec: «A

I "or •• • • I • I ... . . .. 1.1 I _.,

~!?.:~.:'~.'~"i' ·Bac, -·e!cr;bi<iitoCPTOMe~p?»' ECJlH npH60,p OTCyr~,8y~" a·)H8JlH,'JH,e .. He'H,c,-

..... --:: • .;.. :-., •• , .. .I! ...

, ~;.~:.~~:{~ .... 'opaBHoCT,H onpeseaserca «sa rn,a3IOK» t - Ta,Ka,R~ c n:QSB.04Ile~n? CK838Tb"

"~~/;' :·Ju.amQCTIfK8 He MO>KeT 6h1Tb HU nOBo,nOM K 3aIlPf?Y ~n.nyaTallH". Hit

............... ,.". ;(s:, .33TeJlbCTBOM no }.I.filry 063)l.MHHHcrPSTHBJ;I().,' npaOOHapyweHHH.

. i{.'~'aro 'Ka~e:rCS1~ H Qnpe.a.eJleHHSI CTeneHH npOS~tiHoeTif. TOHHpOBaHHbfX ,. ..~:.,., .... ~: .... ereson, ecaa TOJI&,KO c nepsoro B3r JlM8 ae 'l;lHAHq,,·'qro OHR 3epK,UbH:ble,

. ',:'./: :' ripHNeJleHHe KOrQPbJX npJlMO sanpetneao n~.3l d-;7. 'rmn. . . " :

. \,,:' ',' '_,.,: EMH COTPYJIJIH,K fAH npe.n,.no>KHJI He 'Y.¥JIOffeaaTnHytbCTORHOq~

" ."'11.:- •• ~ I .. • _- ! • r.,.... I I

\i ~ .. ~,,~ .. ~ .;~ .... _ ;kW~H·~ft)p· M03-, qT-O'O~ np ... O'B,epHTJ,'t YJ1ep'*lJ81a-eT~ 11K .'llS Tpa,HC,nOp'TIlOe'

:. • {' ,11, .:-- .' I \ ' L .." •

.,. ....... I~}' ~. .: ... .

:t.:;~,···:~...;.tj,~~: .. (,~.:: ::>.: . ., .

::.,

._._,_".".. ' 6b1Tb nOnOJKeHbI B"OCHO:Qy-C)'.ne6HOtO peurenaa, TO ectb_H Te, B , " bT8Te "pHMeHeHHR KOTOPblX'sOAHTeJl'R MOryr IipHBne1Jb{'K :&AMH ~

~'l'::<~., " " TUSHoll OTBe!CTSCHHOCTH), pf!.apemaemCJl npUMelUlmb,

, " , ",C"~mb U3 npOU3IJoiJcmBa U pesumm« U m.n. mOAb"O' lip" , .. ' 08UU, "mo DNa npotusu nosep'ICg UAU' aocgiJapcmseH,sgtO , ',;,f!._'!oeu'l.ec"ylO ammecmatfUHJ. Te·->Ke .cpeacraa R3MepHTeJlb-'_ , ,':':,:X;HHKH,lfa xoropue He pacttpocrpaaaerca rocy.a.apCTBeHliblH "p?JfOrHtfeeKH~ KOHTpon~, -paapeuraerca ,BblnyCK81lh H3 npOI:l3BOJ[. ~ ; ',_!?Jf~KO npa ycnoeaa, 'ITO OHM np01HJIH l(anfl6pOBK}' IIJIO MeTpo,~ ' .: ~C·I:<Y~ aTTeCT3UHIO. npHQeM K. riOCJIeJl}JHM,· .cor naCHO cr. 18 ¥~,,;,,:;;.::~~~ •• ,.~;a,oTHoC1lTCH cpeacraa H3MepHTeJIbHOH TemHKH, npnaeaae-

, '~-~., Pacnpocrpaanrs ,3TO onpeneaesae 88 npu,6.ophI, npaae-

".."'.iI; .... "JI, ...... ~-r:rAH BB:HO aarpyaa» ·T'en· b· I .. - I e=>>. . . ~ ... . ...

.: '. 1." ,. . ._. _ J~.1 .' c· ,I HO •. iIII • . • ..

.• "" ::, t" '" b~f(HaH MeTpOJIorH1IeCK3H' 'a~eCT~n~~H DOSepKa nposo-

.~n·_·~~~~~CTByrolllHMH 0 praHaMH HJlH MerpoJIo,rH1JeCKHMHlleHTpa, ,.CT~~pTa,a peaYAbtnamw maxoa ammecmauuu 'UII.U

..... ~ .... ~l!~"!:JICNbl 6wm6 ot/JopMAeNbi. coomsef!lcl1UJYIOUfUMU

: . '. J-:" . -, . ... .. •. J ."' I,... ... . ".

... .. .. .. • .. '1' I'.. ... I ~.-.. .1," • ~

.;_ '" I "".. .... "

_ . ,,' ~, na "KOTOPYW ae pacrrpocrpaaaerca rocy.u.aPCTB~HHblH . ...",.....,~. n.:r"..fti--"~~~_C~~M xoarpons, OR, ocy~ecT8:11l1eTCI: MeTpOJlOrH'.feCKH-. ,-. . . 6~JfqpraHoB rOCYJlBpCTBeHIfOH anacra, npe.u.npHATl:In, HJI" . f,;<: op~iI~9aU;UH~~·COr JIaCHO CTCT.29 ~ 31' aaKoHa/~<O MeTp-~ o.nO~~H)}'

._, . ., .,,, .. ,..... , ,~.. _ ... ,

,:,:'::{~p~CTB~'H~~epHTeJlbHOn TexHHKH, na soropue ue pacnpocrpaase-

___ .:llJ;=,'~ .. _ :'~;:;::C~rro~YA~pB:~HHbI i% MeTponorHfllecKHH· xosrpoas; nOM e>KaTMeTpo·'?;;,~~~'1~,C.~Q~'~1Je~Tau.HH H, KaJlH6poBKe, 1JeM<H".o.OJI>KHbJ ·S8HHMaTbcJ.

<::~~He'· . " ·'~e3YJIbT8TbI aTTeCTaIl,HH-H'IUiJIu6pOBKH .n.OJl>KHbI

·t)YTL ' 'f:A COOTBeTCTB~ YIO":'H-M·' H ROK' YMeHTa' H ("'" ~

. ~;:: ..... ~. ,> .. ,~:·'· .. 1.'.:'.,,_ .. :.· ..... : ... .'~, ~ .... ~ ... '.'. ,~.-', <·1 .... ',¥OpMhI AO,KY'",

...",.i. .... ,.. •. ~ ..... ;; ~,~HTOB ~~~aeT Ibccrasnapr YKpaHHbI):'~:< _ . -, , .

I~».mt·w ,:-,~ .. " .-Ha~HqH~-l~9KYMeHToB 06 arreorauaa, nOBepKe"HJlfl K2nR()poBKe i< :~ _:~:to 3a.n-or~:oroJ qyo:pe3YJlbraTbi H3MepeHuArolfHbI •. 5e3 .9TOrO ux

~jfu,~{~.x.\., ,':;~~c.'I;~~~JI~~~~~HMeHJIThB Ka1JeCTBe AOKa3aTeJIhCTB8 no .o.eJIy. '

A,"", :",'; ,~If,!,,~,!,:malCUX iJoICYMeHm061qJ3ICHO saiJainbfJOnpoC ·UHm~.~ ;:- .. ,: -. cne_lfmop!!i ~ ,!:p._UMelUllOU{eMg COOHlsemcmBYIOUfUe cpeiJcmBa ua,;.

~L~ '.~~.: •• :;. ,~!!p~e~ .. ~~ou. mexHUICUi Hacro ,HX Y Hero ne OKaSbI'Bae·TCSI... . .

. ~i>t: .ll.anee~-'8coOTBeTCTBHH lJ,3 CT.IO 3aKOHa «0. .:eTp(\Ro:,r· H···H': » p·e~

.' . ., . 'I.. , u.J.I. . ... _.u . , ... I

i&'~ .. ;:_0.·.~: ::~'.'3~Jl.6mafllbl U3MepI!HUU MOlgm 6b1mb 'ucnOAb308Cuu,,- IlpU gclto-

'., (, ';:, '8UU, ',,,mo' U9B!Ctnlf6(. coo meem cmsYIOUfUe " ~apa"mepucmu"u ".. ....... .,,~~' } '~_,.:_nOlpeUlNocmeu B. u3MepeHURX. 06 310M 1'3iOKe MO>KHO saaan, BO~'~ . '< :'- npoc HHCnel{TOpy. ECJIH 08 He MO>Ke H8 TaKOR aonpoe OTBeTHTb - 310 ~.(i:, .. "k ,,:Ylite nOBOlJ,K TOIdY, lJTo6b1 pesynsraru H3Mepemdi 'H~ MOrJIHOblTb HC~

, ... ~.,~.. 'n OJI·L_· '30- sa' Hr- a K .,' . .

, .~. ':._ ... ".. '_". _.~ .. , .. bf..aK~AJlH Sanp,eTa ,3.KCn·nya.Ta·IUf:H ·Tp',8HcnO.pTHOrO Cp@JlCT:Ba.

"i.~'3::C" .. ~::~i"l, . >" .. , '1aK H,~ Ka1JeCTBe J(.OK833TeJlbCTBa "PH paCCM01'peOHH B CY.Ae ,!leJla 06 an ~

~~.~!l·~}i : ... ~_. .... :·.:.~~HH~a~·HBHoM npaeoaapyureaaa. . ' .. 0 ,'.. • •

TI;.;lM;"'''t. ' ' .: i-. f.o ~ ." '. .. . -. :'.

,.I .. :"" /. . . .. ...

-, jo. ," ' -,

< •

~ .

. . .,

.. . .

• I I I','

:- ). _.....~~: ...

m't§' ~3' ;~-if'~! <:: : ,:;: :.:' .. ' . ;

,

Ha ece 310, H HyiKH~ lo6paTHT.b.BHHM8HHe COTpYAHHK,a rAH. ~,~"'}l~

OH see H<e aaxaer COCT8BnHTb ~pOTOKO\Jl. ·06 8Jl.MHHlfC;.Tpa,THB:H:OM ri·ri1.1 soaapynreuaa, ·TO B· 06~RC"eHltH ,HeoCixQ)UfMO Y·K,a3·a.Tb·: «Cq! :. ·~fi~~ ~aKT HaJlW'IHfl HeHcnpaBHOCT:tI He \ YCT3aOBJieH, T.K. H3Mepe~"R"~~~

(Y·K,a38Tb napanerp) He·n'pO.Be)JteH.bI» •. 3TO··KacaeTCHcnyq·a.R·, .

Mep:W'Te.nb·Horo·· o6opYAO·cB,8.HftH Y H.HcneK.Topa ne OKa3.an.OCb... ~" '~' ::~~..,.;w;

,."_.,,. .... ..,.,

OH·O HMee.TCB~ HO He-C:OOTBercTsye'T nepesacnenaaa Bblw·e"y· "

TO cnenyer Ha.n,H~a'Th.: «.:l1a:MepeHHH nposeneau ·C ua ': ..

cpeacrno H3MepHTen:bHOH.TeXHHKH (YKB38Tb, K,8Koe) ~e ICHa~. :at

KYMeHTa,MH, ··CBH.ae'reJIbcTBylOIU.H~H 0 ·TOM~ QTO oao npouu •••

r,H'qeCKYtO 3TTeCT,aUHIO, nOBepKY nH,60 KaJJM(jp:q~· nposonaauree H3'Me:peHHH (COTPYAHHK rAM), He, CMorliO " ..

. :. .

. ,m,. I • ', ...

. xapBKTepHCTHK·H norpeumoerea B ]13M,ep,e:H·HSlX , T.e:. OH:H.~e·M·,:

; CTHbi. Bee 3TH OOCTOSl'TeJlbCTB8, cornacao CTCT.I t 2",4~ ~~,:' 2'0, .29,w3.l 3aKoHa YK.pa.HHbl ·«0· MleTpO,J)lorHH :H.· .. ",e· .. ~ii

.AeRTen:bHOCTH» ,. npe'R,RTcT·BYIOT· npoaenea HIO asxepea ,Hon npasane HSMepeHHH, _npO~eHHbJe C HapyllleH,~, _', ·

·1·~eJl:bCTB,a,. He MOryr CJly>KHTb ItCToq:HHK·Q,M J:lOKa3a~eJI, . I. --

3JlM:a,H·HCTpa·THBHOM npaBOHa.PYllJeHHH». '. ': .. ~.~:.'." . ~ .... ~._~

3aTeM, eCJlH HQMepHble· soaKH H3bHTbI, Hy)KHO,~~P,~T ,HBJleHHeM K.~· PYKOB'O,ltHTe·JIIO CO'OTB·e·TC.'TB."YlOmero r AH I B 38:HBn:eHH:H, 'JlOn>KHbI Obl:Tb HaJJ 01K.,e·HbI re me a .. ·':"iYm,,~q:ft[)1,,·:]te~Ja~

: K·OHH·OCTH ,)teiteT·BHH aacnexropa H npocsea 0 :803,8 ."""".- .... ,.~.; ~&

HhiX 3H8KOB. KaK. npasaac, CTonKcHYBWHCb, c a.'p Sa.UlHToH BOAH'T~J1-eM' -C·.ROUX npaa, ·HX B03Bpa:maIOT ••. ~.:.·~. ~!~""~j~~

H:e . npOHCXOJJ.HT , ,TO B{I.$AenbUj' aBt·OMo6H,nH OCTa~.· "",··iI t..!V, ~~EM

*II ~i

cynsa KOMneHc,anHeH,~M.aTe-pHanbH,oro H M·op,a,nbHO:.~1 .

Y· q.HTa"TeJlH MO)l(eT B03H~HKHyrb aonpoc: noscay 'h71-.<-:..~~I"":.~·H~a.:;.:

.BepK8X TeXHHlleCKoro' .CQCT-oa:HHH' ·Tp·aH,cnopTHbJ.X cp_·_ ,",, .. _'~ .. ''''W_

ne " c np'H.MeH.eHHe.M'tH3.MepHTeJlbHOA TeXH'lfK.H, M·b]~:. '-·I,~~i~~.f~ .. ' xonrpoae T10KCHIfHOC·TH Q,hlXJ10na? Pa3Be aa rasoa ~.'~' ·tII ~··I;:I~ I~

Me.HH,e.MbJe: AJIH· T,8Koro KOHTP'OJl:H, He pacnpocrpa _'r.·_I .... _""

11 e H H hi e: 'R 0 p M :bI 3 a K 0 H a « 0 :M erp OJ)" 0 r Ii H ", •.. :» ?:; .. : ·;"'~~~k':,£111!~'I:.J';iF'iII:

. ~ . J 'f<:k.~,,-"""!;i;

pacnppcTpa.·HH·IOTCH. H Hy>KHO ·npHM·eHflTb 3TH HOPMbI.~~f(':1,I'-I· ~·~b '._--' ."4._(~ .

npoaepxu TOKC·H"qHO'CTH ropHllHlfeCK,:He a:prYMe,HTbJ,., 38.I.U,HTbI JilHTepeCOB.BO).\H"I:eJlH;aTHM .l1aJ1eKO He HCqepnblBaIOTCJ.....,t(:{~:t:~~~ lEI

,06 3TOM Mbi cenlJac H noroaopax. Flposepxa TOKCHlIHOCTH o:rpa",:i',>:~. ~~~ T,8:BW .. H.X ra·310B -- oelllb· OqeHb.- pacnpocTpa.He·HHaH,~ n'po:Bep'Hi9~~:.~.;,·.: ."'P..i£~~ rpancnoprasre cpeacrsa ,HaXOJJ,JUIl.HeCfl B sxcnnyarauau H H3 Tex9~:~\:" .. :':I,'\41~' MOTpe, npOBepHI01' COTPYJlHHK.H rAM H8 nopore, aa 8'he3).laX B 1I~~9,3::;;::;,~' ropue peraoma, J1.8 euie Jlei%cTByeT «na 60JILWOH p.op()r~~,':,~.:~.:< ~KOJlOrHlIeCKaSi MHJIHqltft •• /Ka>KeTcSJ, Bce, KOMY' He neHb, «npow~psI~,;:,: ;.:<': ':," e >: :..- ..... ".....,. lOT CO» 11, aasepaoe, He Haii;J.eTcH BOJl,HTeJUI, '-Ieii aB,10"plSH;1Jb":,";,.,:,_"~.'.;i,, •...

. T exnusa ... · . .. ..', ;,;::, :(:::itJ;~~~{{,:'~~ ',L:' . ': '(~ '.";:;~>.,;1~,:~'

• ', .... I· ... -r ~ .: " ...... ,:"- ... ' I 1'- -~ :v ''''1 I' : ... -: f.(:IIj- ~:-1:"":"'" '1 .. .;.« "'(j"l .

. . '- .,.:.' ~:.'~;' .}: ~; / :: .. > . >- :.~~~ .. ~~/~: .,~:<~, l;~·~.i I.::;~·.~> ~.<~v ., <~'r ... ~ .

. . . i .' 'I.......... . I. 1;. ......... I .. 1('" I" -;-...; .. ~ ?~ .. -.;_-. .. ...: .. l' ..

an'cJI' O,b) "T,~lKO,H npesepxe. f1P:~ ·3'T'OM nosrn HU!CJJ:l:": HK M,3

1_,_',,-' ,pSl(J)Ul.H,~, H'H' KS npOBepfte:MbIX,_-(~ ne n[OJl03peS8,eT, ~a·K»M 06-

~ < •

, yperynapoaaaa ,sa,KO.H'OM 3Tt:I.,!cH:rya,UHft. "11" cooraercrseaao,

• ~ 1,:

o.n.,_~...,..~,'" ,'.:::; ... ,~ .' - HMeeT D'paso 08'<; !8 ~H,a II'TO - apy.r8;R .'c.ropOH,a, I 11 KO~Jl.a ,aBia , ...

""...,.,~,~~~ •. ;_''''''r.;IJ .... - .. b-aKCHJlyaTHpOBaTb ,MOX<.HO, a KorA8 'F: ,HeT. . . ' .,'

~D.n~'lnu.3'fOC TeM, .lJTO:OOPMW OTHOCHT(WbBO PQJlbWHHCTS8 napa- .

:~~'-""'.~I1,

:ilD:~'O,ClI HblXM,ft o',npeAeJI"e:HlfB CQCT'O'S:HH'ft·3BtO.M;O(},H'nSl, ecrs H'eno~

" B 0.3104' nnll, aoscocrasy orpaoorasamx rasoa 3TO He cs •. KaCaTeJlbHO srore nap~MeTpa Bee aeo6xOAHMble ,BeJlHlIHHbI

, '

"';.,~ 'i!!iiI.,~", ~, .. ~' .8 APyrHX·, HOpMIT.U8.H·blX axrax, B n,flJl npSlMO Y,KQa,a,HOt B

,' __ ',,1- "'I~',l)tt~ «.~'» Di31 ~4~6 ~·Me,e~¢ft CCblJlK8 ~a ~<('YCTaH,o,BJleHfllbl'e CT,a·H'-

. '. . . .

""!!!,,.,' .. ' ".& . a:O:,P,~bI » • ~ , . ~.~';. . .. ~. ~ . .' . ;: t

~"~~~lN:fI,wB~' ,9TH,H'O,P,M.'b.I? 'H, ,KaKll_.+o,opaSOM· OHH J1OJI>KH:'bl n,pHM'eH,HTb-'C;R"

,UBI:iT~'1Ji , 't.I~.:~,pq~HB'OpelJ'HJlO ,sa'KOQY? ~ . . "". _. , . " .

,~":,",,., ... -~~~._!Ini.IlIM. AOKyP4eHTOM t kOTOpbttr .onpenenser HQPMW· CO.a;ePHCaHH$I lI.tI.'~ ~~1fIi"'''''_ .fB _.8 'oTp~6oTa'~,wHX rasax ,BBTOM'o6Me,i{: c 6ea'3H"OP,blMH " -r..~ 'Cfl~co6~ u·a,·Mepe:,HH,fI:., jI'BJIHeT·C:H .npHHfI:T~lH~ ,ewe ·8 coios-

iilt};,~iM.i~~,,: •.. c:...~ .. rOcI .17.2i2.03~87.06pam8WHchK aeMy, MO}{(RO H3'~

-=- ....... ~ .• Ii"4_'r"'I'"'JI ~on·~.esFloro. ; .:, .::>,', .' _. ,. '., ~, ' .

. . ~{lX<e; UHTepecHoto CO.n.e-PlKtfTCSI 8' mlt rOCTe? ..", ." ..

.'- ' • .(,. ~""' •• '. ..... '.1 • 1_

t'}.::'~~:io9"JP'·'¥·~~p~:tOfllte p1acn.p'ocmpa.uem;ts HtI~ifleJl,"'tl PJJA~"am,e"

_. ·i;aot/Ji,':~:. It.Mo6uAeU. ECJlH Te.~ -.~OTO"· ~~Ie': ,·,H',M~' 'e~ .11,-'0.' ~UVIO"--,·'M' :[a'c-,e,-y"

, • ~ 'II r.,. ..~. r'" ',' . ~ .. , . 't',~ . ~.' . JV; II " "'I.~~I " y - -

_ :i;~-:':4QQ<~i.fL;BJIH MaKCHNanh,HYIO'CKOPOCl'~'40' ,ap. :KM/lJ .~ ,T • .I1.'.

~;o.':<.":."",.,' }f\~~;p~~alO'F9!:({cllaBHaTenbHo PeAKO; TO APyr.He:,:-·6oR~ pacnpocrpa-

_&1""'''-",,:-0<>:. ' i~~~··~ !~;~$¢(608aRHSI [OCTa, no . TOKCH1fHOCTIt ",1 pacnpocrpana ~

, ,~a./·j':t~pif$~'H C POTO'P,HblM,Hi' 'H AB:yxratcfHbI'MH, A8HrareJl1lMH.

: . ·.'-:"~'L\:~')I.~"!-~··r;- :'I.~.J,:.I.-: .' . '·1 "

. . _APJtC~ .. ~J;fH HelJacro t 00, nona.o.alOtCJJ..1UI ~Ha:WHX .lJ.opor,ax. •. Po ~

J.lr.:lfjl"lv':J •• H,::h.l~:.~,~~H, HanpHMep, YCTatla.~HBafQTCH H8 H,eKOTOpblX,'MO. ""HX:.'~; '·i~!f..~6HJleH «Ma3JJ,a» .. , ,JleYXT8lCT:HblMH' MOTOp~MH

.. ,.~~JJ~KT~~~¢~ JlerKOBbie aBTOM06HJI_~ .. np,OHa~OACTBa, rJl~ (~Tpa ~ "~f~~,~~.:~ __ ~?-) -, ~\u·/~:~;,>~~.:~;t~~r»)t··KOT'Op- ,blX B HaU1'eH~,CTn,aHei'~:O ·CH,X nop sscnny ro:o

I ;';~"~-?.1"' . .,.: "'_ ",,~ ~,.'!o!' "~." , .':1 .. ,J ~, ' . C ,tor ~. ~ .' v' ",..' "'.

:':-'~:'.~I_;ri~eT¢k:~A:-~ ·~~jrtaK:-y" )K Man'O, . . .;. '~ .• - ..', .: ' ,

" ".:-.>;~' ::~:".;.lrf;!~;:~ " : .;:,. ~~; ... :.'-'.-:-::'::-. ~.:f,' .' ',,', ,II! ~ - ',' J "':" ,,' - , .: .'.. ~ I ..... -. I.

,"m:t~'.::r ,.;~L:i, ~ ';;;'~~!A":~~~tUIIOlJeHHe: TPeOOB8U1ul. faCTa He paCllpOCTpaaSUQ~cSJ

:·\·:~:.a,:1J8roMQ_~_:.·Bbllcwe,ro KJI,a.cc·a~. '. ,'.: .~ ,I.: .~ ... _. ~ :' '~ •... ' ..• '

''''''0=-0..','-,... ..... )~~~(?B".G4~p~,K' la~O.BbfM OTHOCHJlHCh .ner.KOBble_ a&]~Mo6HJlH·t,np···.· en ~

_', .. -._. .~..r ii...· . I' . .' .... I'"

,;:~~afl_'tta,Bw.HeCB lijIft o,6CJIY,)K,H,SaH,HH. ,llO,JJ,>K,HO'C~TH·W~~,n.H-U ,BbI·,co,Koro If

· i;~:.1~;:~~~~~o YPOBHSf - 311M,: «·l{atiK3», 3HC·ll a~jl ,aSJlHQHblX MO ... a.r-~;~~~'";;.--; ",;~Jld'r; npH'leM :l!OJlbKOCTapble MOJ(enH'S He60~bWHX KonH~ectBax

)·->:1~~f~"Cb B lIac~HoM nOJlb30B8HHH. HblHe,.'WKHO;HKof.n.a BCTpeTHt~,

~_g,p. ':~~\~;:JSi,~p~Mepy, lfaCTuyro«l.Jai1:KY», Ho rl!a~H,ge, --r.,'K'BblcweMY KJIB~y·

....... ..._~ ..,..~ , -'~~fmr cosercxea KJl8CCHcPHKBIJ,HH) OTHOCm.CfI -,'60JIhWO~ ·KOJlHlfeCTpo

~~~ <)~~::':.B!fm.«o6HJleii HHOCTpaUHbiX, MapoK, ~T.~.ffu.cne it Jl.OBOJlbHO~aC-

... J I,;. " I' c...· ~'

~'&'R'.~", ·~e:'~:~1>OO1ipa~eHHble' (nanpaxep, npeAC~BII1renbCKWe «M,.epce.n:tcbI»

·':u~~;;;~: ~ ,,'::\J~~:;:'/:':~<:.':.,: '. . . rAUl' 8.

I ....... II,.l .. ' . ~

. "·:5::;_:<{ ':~,:~j:, ,j' '<, i. _

. 1...l':!1_1"~ ".JI;; ... ~ ~. ~ " • I .... -:. .' ... • ~

'" ...

If liMB c O,O,qbWHM pa'O'OQUM 'Qo'11e,M:OM. ,AaHraTen,H, [8 T8K)K:e u .... .:_ pRJl.8MepUI(3HCKHK. a-stOMo6HJJei). nOH9THO, 'A8J1eKQ He Bee HOBbie, HO ;(l,3)Ke y ~caMJ.,lX Ape.~ TaKHX a&TOM06HJleH n 01.1_

'TO,KCHQHOCTb OTp,aOOTaS;W,HX,' raaoa H aanpenrars H,X SK[c,nnyaft, iB

38 npesunresae YCl.aaOBJIeHKblX HOpM HeBb3R: HOPMbl 3TH ..;.,

H:HX! .v . ~

'CnHCO'K ,3'T:H.X H'C:K.ftJ"lo:q'eHHH JieCK:QJlbKO ,H3M,!eH'e,H yK'paH' " ,

napTOM 3649-91::,-eneph CT8-H,lUlPT He pacnpOCTpaHSleTCSI . V~"":'_A:;"" nopruue cpeACTSa, MaKCHMMbH3H CKQPOCTb KOTOPblX Y . ......,. ... ~:!:I'- ..... ~ H3fOTOBHTeneM;lJ.O 25 KM!q; C JlBHraTeneM, HMelOlU,lte Il~ ..

. u" ", "

nee H C nos ,HOM· M~acc,o:H no 1 'T; C HarpY3,KoR :H8 ocs H~ , ..... ':." .

. O,llHaKO,' K3K 6YAeT .nOIqllS3HO HJl)f(e, 8 CQOTBeTCTBHH C'IJ9Q¥~ .. CTHTYIlHH, xoropue peryJUfpYIOT ~ ,,8 K8KHX c.nyqaSlx HOpM2· •. '"" ... '".....-:=

,Mo,~eT - tI,M$t,b 'O'(ipaTHYtO .c,Wly,· aT,M· 1f3Me,HeHHH ~ P',Q . ". -.

· TOJlbKO H8/rpaacnQPtHble cpe.aC'I'sa, Bbloyw,eHHble:oq........... ~. 'I·!L..:;: .. HOB9ro' -CTaH.$\pT~ B: CHJJY. A t(bttCTPYKIJ,HSI TaKHx~ .. ,' -.-._ --.

, .

. u.pa BHJI 0 , snenae 003BOJIHeT. npaBecTH BbIXJIOn·~.· .,.' .~ ... ' .", .....

,;" !faflJlapTOM~. . :,~; _'~ .. _. ,.... . ,'<: :':;':.

: ~'II Ho caxoe HHTepecHoe·,n.a>Ke He ~.roCT . ,',.,.",'"-

"al& DICaaaHo B npeaM6gAe, H4 a8I1WM06UAU. • :'1 .... ~ .. _

u a'"tlAfJdlRu.pgeMwe·s;:C.CCP»., ..... .. .' "\:~;i

,. 4 T6: . Kacae-rCH ~epp"'TOPHH AeAcTBHSI, TO CT 'UI~T au~~l~ ~'""' •• c

· ~:Aqacpac",po~paHSleT~H 'us YKpaUHY. Ho nplfMeH, · ·pOBK3 03H8'taeT, ·gTO CT3H.MPTY, .llOJIlKHbl coornerct .6"11", soropsie ,H .npoaaaonstes, II 3Kcnnyanfp":-,, ,.-.-

.crpaae. KaK re, tfrOnpOH3BeJ1.eHbI Y Hac H HJlYT ' .. ~'PI"-"~;:o<o!

· IIfCc1I4gamupyeMflte II ,_Il4Ut,4CmpaHe UHOMa .... ' ...... P'_"4"l'

_.II.e FOCTa,. .noAY"tumiClI,lIe ,noiJnaiJalOtn (8H . . ,,_' '~

_ ,JUt Obi rOCTpacnp9CTpa05tJlca H3 aSTOM06HJlH t ... ~.

lUlU 3'KCfiJlyaTMpyeMwe B CCCP») ..

_ . npM 3TOM H~KalCHe nOCJ,Je.l1YIOUI,He nOJl38KOtlH,w, ,I E0a.

pacurapare c~epy AeACTBHSJ -craporo COlO3Horo . H3MieHeH,H:A' B Hero ~ 6eccM,~,cneHHo; noroay ·QT ""''"',,:~,_..'=..._,.;:~-=.Y.;o

craenaprox Y>Ke ue cyw.eCTBYI011lerO CCC~ H p,eAc ",*:r.n'i"·_.:'Jn~.I'!'iI"T

CTBHHC ,n.I-,nepexG.lliu:dx. nOJlO>Keiudi KONeT .

aGpMaTHBJihle. aKTY .o.eRCTRYJgT-B' YKpaHHe B qaCTH"He . .

qaw,eA YKpaHHCKOMY J~8Ko:HO.B.aTenbeTBY, HO Btl O,llHH·92,KOH • .

U KiI..iX Ben'OMCTB -v •

A,YCM8TpHBaeT nOJlHO.O~HH _ ·YKpaHHC .rJ· .: ·~-c'··~· ..• _ ,l"'-,i:j,_;,:-,,:;;. r~;;~~'!;:;

H3MeHeHHfI' B HOPM8T,lIlBHf,It" 3KT, no cyru, .llpyroro rocyp,apc~:<: :f'·.L,'p'y".':-'.''::-:--.Jt: ,("A: . ne aC:TB'OB,a~Tb cnoco60.M ·,KO:TOp'. ,blH ,n'p,")lMO· H,e YK,83,8H 8, 3a.K;OH,e·~~;J~i~~~~;':·:~~~~ ... ,

'. An, _ .' . .,-, .. ."" - 'i:J:.'r<..-.-:., .. r._ , ... ;.-:., :1· "l·. ,:>, ~'

. cynapcTseHHble opraau He HMelOT npasa BCOO!BeTQTBtI'\~:l~:·:J!f< """,,' 'u M"~ ~T.19 KOHCTHTYUHH .YKpaHHbI.) MeHflTb >Ke c$epy JleHCTBHSI.H~"~;)~t .. ,_ · .. n'_", :·...,. ... ·n"",

T" H' ,DR' oro 8K'Ta' K'OTopan onpeaeseaa liM eaMON, He BHOC;~i.~,,~':":N.),Jl~_ .". i;'·,

. ~ . _' _ ._'.,'.' _, ' '_ ' _ ' .' - '~. ,- " '.j> .... ~,.T .. --:ri.o'~ I' .·1 ~:'i'r"'" .':' -: , -'r'o" -'.~".( .. ,.~.,

" ' - ','.-' " . ~~~'Y"J""," L!"':"'I"~''';_' , v ", '.. '.. - ;.: .; " ~I: .. ~' .'. '

'I ,. 'I? I'~I ~ ·tl::: .. ~ ~'i ." I:'} ;;, I • i I • ~I"

I • 0'... ...~ ~ .f r I • .r-- ~.? . . ., I {' ' "./' 0:.. ~ ..

I :r':~' . :r-" .. ~. ·:::r~. ~'!-·;·""}"'.!:t~"·-""':'.I.:'~·- I, '-: ":" • ..-: '~I: .. :=-- :· ..... I·~·I ...

" . " -.:.. :."~, ,,'.J. < :0:,.lf!.~ .. l,!!~V .... ¢~ ":( . .~ ... ,.". ,.' ". ~ i-~' #V!:' "!- -.

::. • ~..,." ~-.-' \.: l":I,i:~~~ ," 1" "I . '-. .. . . .-..... I' {_ :- •• -:. -:v" ....

• .' ' .. ,. _};I~. = .. ., ....... ..: .('I(_,i.! '-:.' .I"r'" ~ 0"1 ... " ~.' .. I . j I.r~" .. ~:jI._" .. ~ I,.", :. ~

. ~ .'. ~ .. ~' "~' ~ ' .. L··~· ... { ~ - }.",-.!.t:.; J ~ .'.- . ":'I'~j'''' 'J~'l""" "

. ·t ... ;; I ", /\I~J~": ''rI~:'','':'1 "',.', }-~·.:.:...'Ij .. :l:. ~ .:/'.- .: ... .:.I.==~;lJI':.' (tl'r' I"~

'. ~ r -;'}I" ~ . /1 .-'!, Fr~ .. , ..... I'I'~'" ..... ~·;'LI .. '1. .' -'I i···~· ., ~l:i' . i ..... '~" ..

:... l'" - .. ' I.:: .:. ·.i ... - ..... \~ ::11 ~.t" ...... ··111... ~ _"'II~I ~:~(._..~ '1. 1 .. ~rll!

.' N, " ~;~:~ ',". '. .) ~~ J ~. "Q:\ ~'"t'" ';0 ',I rt. .'" ".' ,IT', . . Wj"~I:" 0:;,:; , ;"

• • ' •. :~ .;.: .. <,.OJ". , .1 •• J" : ........ ~j ~~.t ~ ... !~ "'~.~ _Ij,"'!' ... ._.. :-. ... !!! • b'I'~ • c! f ~'':--) ~ ;).1 i. ' "':- .

• • "J. •

HI3·Me·,H,eHHH .~ :310 IOPHJtHQeC.KHH H(}H'C'eHC~ M.bI )f.(e 'ue ,MO>K:eM i!\4' :. IT&" HanpH·~.ep;·-.,HU .B YrOJlOB~,W"\' HU B YrOnOBHO-npOne'cC:yaJ1'b.',' :KC;~,- HH B KO~e'KC 0'0 .3,AM,HH;HCTparHBHbI.X npaaoaapymeaa-

u

~~.~. _ H3MleHeHHH_He B.HOC.H·JI·H, :HO' aanpeasnueaae 'CKOpOCT.H T1e·-Oe.'p.b

~I~V" · .~M xapars B yronoaaoa nOpHAKe. 11J18:' B 'ynK H3MeHeHHAHe

~1ioI~""ili!!l"l·;I·: '.' . 0 npasa no,nCYAHMOrO OrpaHHtlHJIH. CY.lI.mTO Bee paBHO AOJh .

~B',M.' c·l.~·H,O HOpM3.M.H '. Y.IlK P·YKOB·OA.CTBOBaTbCJl~.~.Ka:>KAoe H3M·eae-

~~.,.,.."...." ... ~ • Y,._; ~ ~, • "'~

~~"1S1';. ~~e-;PbI perynapoaauaa Tex, fUIH MHbIX oraoureaaa ,lJ.OJUKHO

...... ~.iu.,~~L~ .;~.,j. .' M 'o:6pa30M. IOp~Hq,eCK.H O<j>op'M'nH.TbCB .. ,. ,·no SiT·on n·fJH·.. ~,~R~~~~fI,nblTaTbCft Ha8TH. B rOCTe TO" nero BIH~M··HeT·, H pac-

'. [I" ~ .,' . ' .

. _ ......... 'Iij..._ .. ~. ··-~~HT.&~::~ro H,a' ·Te· c'4lepbl, peryn.H.poB.8HHe ,K.OT'O·.PblX H'e

.' .. ··a-T.p~~anO~b ero C03A8TeJl.RMH. Hanpaaep, ,OYJleT npo:THBO'" . aKoHY' pacnpocrpaaesae K8KHM-JlH60 &eJJ;OMCTBeHHblM 8Kf{~~j1\. :' sa'linA fI'O TOKCMqHOCTH aa nee 3BTOM·O·6HJlH; H'eSBBH·C:H.MO

.~ .' -

u·.: ... ,\:A.;.'lf1i1ii~WU. "rQe!1!~r-~YK?T' JIM O'HO BbIweYKa3a.·:H-H.O~My ,ycn.OBH·IO: «,npo·~

1."" '. <=",,,,,-_D~,,a;.·btiU ~.~c;nJlYaTHpYlOt(!S1 B CCCP». no cyTH,,9TO tJyAeT 03H8w n_,~I'·."I " rp'9PBaHHfl' faCTa MY npHMeHS1eM~ a npyrae

~~"'~'.-J''"~'''. Oro iKe I'OCla ._ ortipacusaea, .XOTSI·.B caM C'T8HAap'T

_: ... .._ .. ,., ......... ii,QHOCH:fbHe HMeeM npaBa. ','" -. '.. . . .

: :.,: ,.~t.:eqJJH ,t)OJIee· noaauHe B~AO.MCTBeHH·&1e·,·HopMaTHBHble aKThi ,.' '. :·~~_!:~h'iO~.';.(p· :·aCWH·p·, RIOT') c,,",epy Jle.HCTBHH COIO'3.HOro· rOCTa 6es

..... ' . . . fr, - Cl"-ji_" '.' . -.' '. • '+' -'

1e>:!"< .'.+To.- •• ~ }l~CeilHi~'.'HeFp:)i3MeHeHHHt TO nOHHMaTb STO CJIe.nyer TaK: c'i>epa .a.eii -

Il'JJolV.. ~' ... ::~~JI. n;>ct~;::J~npe.lle.nReTcfl B COOTBeTCTBHH ~ HOBblM . HopMaTHBHblM

" 'i~' :~\~n9M .: (-H.~n~~~:i~PI, B rex l"~myqaJlX, KOFJl8 qTO~1,O CT8JP'blM '.€T8HJUiP·· TOM ue

~. I ,~:t.' , .tf~. ~,..,.... "'J !I

";;, ~~POP~b'8006IUe), HO~ .. sa HCKJlroqeHHeM rex c.nyqaeB. ua KOTO ...

:,,':p~ rpCrJfl.~j2~03-87 3aBeJJ,OMO He pacnpOCfpaHMC». . • . . ,.. .. ......,_,.~r=~. '; /,'~i,' ·,:Ka>j(.Dt' .'. ':·p~1'e.nb,Ka>KeTCH" H8HayCTb' a8ayoplfJl' IJ.HrpPbI nonyc-

r .• I. . I' • ~::.J.),I. -. ~ r:J1

r·,~' ': .. ··r(J:. ~Q.~_R~~~HHH· CO (sa nero n.pOBepHM)T;'J~·,Ule acero).« '1 ;5·~o

~ '. . ,~ ~ ~ .... '"'~~ . . )/ ......

. .. ;; ... ' .: , " ... t?ct~~~qppoTax, 2% - 88' nOBblweHHblX~O.ztHaKO'He Bee alia·

~'A.J:ft ~T<Q' "p",.H~·~~~ti.H::. npa nposepxe ,aBT·oMOOHJJeH,:;U8XOJl1lLUHX.Cft '8· 'SK'C-

. ~ ,..... .. ."} ~ ", "f.. "I ... ~. ' '. • • •

r ........ ~_,..,·~·" ' •..••. :, _' u..m'f~;;;jifailaMH fAli,. nepSBSI I.l;Iuppa noeuuiaerca.no 3 %.

. .. .' ." 'r: -. I~tttr' "t •• -j .

..... . ".... :-:~~il.·· uacnexrop nanexo He. Bc'erA8 r()BOp~1 MY 06·3·TOM .BO-

o' II I 1 ; ,,"z,_ aI!'. "';1;' :- 1,;. =.. ......... ,,' I. •

·.r;;o;:o:~=>'.".~>i::',iUrttJil()t~·~,,6-m·BreT~'·q~TO Hlo,M'ep,a CHHM'aKJT, e'ICJIH BblHBJI,H'WT .M8W.H·HY C

~-; .. ~~R'le'~- ~>K' :.-'~ l"H~:~~'" ~I''':·;C'-' 0:' . 2- col .' . . , . . - .

. '. ):II"'~'~ ~ ... p' . ~H *'M:"~', .'. . ~. ,U}O... .. '.' ..... .' . . ,

E.I!I';,=--;"IV\<' .: ~'.,/(tja!iA?IlYicltD ocgUf,ecmBlUlmb' ItOH.mpOAb; MolCcilqHOcmu? ",'·~:I'J!.CTiJaem·oRIIJem U na smom BOn.pOC. Ilpa 3Jren.nya'llQIJ.HH a8TO. :i~~:~~?)_o~H~.eH. --- ae pesce TID' ,Nq 2 HnH peMo.HT8 ys.n·(j·s·{ ~M,H.HJO.I.UHX U8 TO'K~

")!~~'F -~:~~. C;.Q~HOCTb~" Ilpa TO 8SToMot)·Hn.e'H ·UHA.HB·lQJya.lltia.blx BJI'anenb·ues H,

~~"f,V:>_ >.; .. ,. ,~;PHTb }l(e·, peuosre "£HCTe,M" BJlHHJOlLlHX :Ha.,TOKCHqHOCT'b,t Ilpa sana~~~",~".~~~,i:·'~·.~:~r~Jipfl~o.M·,peMoHTe· ~ so TOJIb.KO nacne aaBOJl.c·;KOA,QJt)·K3TKH.,. 11 npa ,c,e~

:'4;'~:iJ5.~koM BblnycKe 8BTOM06HJleH.,,~, ,- >_. .' ..

;"~ ... ~~, .,_, .'

~'"l'l.'<OF..~ ... ;'>,?_'Ho,YKa9aHHH raCTa 0 nepHo)I.HlIilGCTD nposepos HMelOT 60Jiee

i/;~a)J(Q()e~;aH8qeHHe. 113 q,opMynHpOBQK rOCTa Heft,BycMblcneHHo

. .....- _. '.. .' ..

. I. . . I'

"'_~"'_"~<2""s. ..': ::~~;} ~i;if ~~' !\:~~?:~~'~' ~'. " .

-...:::,,'.;""W;(: ".' - .. ' ~,~ .. ., - . ..'.

":.' ;""t! .... :('. ,~ ... .: ,.!., ...... ~ . ',.'. .. . -.

'I »: .,''1- .. ~Y-'l r : '1'.'''' -, , "'. • ••

rAa8a.8.~

J- 'I" _I 'fo,!-'-'

.... r •• ·.. -. •

. '.

. TeXHUlCa, •••

-~

"

v

, l'

_:-co" " __ ' • ..__.__'

.. '-:.

'< • '---!-.c

- ::..:~ _.

.. " ......... -_

.. w ••.

'-'H-i-

, ,

'n-- 0',

- '"_-

,M

..

Ttl

"T,'

,~

"', ,"

,."

- ,

,",

.. ,',

';:-:- I :-:

, "

.. _:

,.: "

.... - ,

.........

", ....

-

• "

,.::

':

':- .......

I:" I, '

,,;0

'_ _ !i

'.

, '

c

an"

,

"

...

~ .

~1fas'~ ,~~,,' "~I BelJP noaysaerca TaK:' ,HOpMbI. ,C,OAep>Ka:HHH COOT,B.~:TCT'BylO~X

~n,H AblMHQ~TH'. O.T,paOOT8,B,WHX ,raSO'B yCT,a:HaBJJHBalO:r~ crau-

J

,. a aa ,31,8 'T,pa'':Icno,PTHble C,peACT~a, CTa~pTblr He paenpocrpa-

~1r[1A ... 'T._ .. ' no 3aKOHY; 3H8'JHT, iJMI "UX, nos iJeucmBue cmalliJapmoB • .,.""_'J_,-,,, . -~Q~nailalOU4UX, mate" HOPMbI He ycmalWSJleHbL U ne iJeii.cm~

..... . .. .

...,. ..... <;=~._~: .. \ .... ~ ., cne,no,B3T'eJlbH'O'i ox ,BO,llHTeJlH ,He M'OryT:'OKa3aTbC.H H8pywH'Te;~

. CTB.YlOmero nyHKTa~. nJlJlu~ . . ·

, ',' AeJl8Tb BOJlHTenftM T'a~KHX 8BTO:Mo,r),Hnen, ( a 'T8IOKe' aBTOMO,()H'-:

...

~~~'~ .:~. ero KJI.8cca, C JlBy.xra:KTHbI,M'H HJlH POTOPHblM:H ABHraTeJJS,MH

".' ~'" ',' HX,HaK83b1Bam.;~3a CO,,», a C 8BTOMOOHJIH. C'HHMBIOT 80'8

~:.,-~. :-.':~ , '?~-':,;~' ., > ..' .,' ..

..... 'Iofl, ~P~~,~,.~~' . CB'oeM 66bSl·CHe,HH·U .. K '.npoToKony 06 ~HH:HcTpa,~ irRtII . -' np88oH~lpyweHHH CJJ~e:r sanHC3Tb: .« COrJlaCHO n~31.4.6 ' ..

. '.' .:MhI con.~p>KaHRH onpe.neneHHbI·x aeuiecrs B oTpa60TaBwHX- -, '.'

:.IIlc..:AIr:.· ·'-t~~~e· :~_ ~~fHOCTH YCT8HoBneHbI cTa~pTa~H. J1eikTBHe· .

. '. :.. . ··~:9~it~+'~a:B,:v~Mo~,H.nbrlJl~ p,ac,npocT'paH,ReT'Cft,i T,.,K" 8BTOMO-

" '. .. "~"O]lPBHHTHB craanapra (HJlH: npHHa,u,ne>KHT: qaCTHO.' --~,~"I;I.t'.,'~~.nfl~~eMYCSJ npe.llnpHH-HMaTen~:,:' ,!ltXo)J.H1eR B ......... ~-, ....... \~·:~·~'e<":nrppXOmtJI B: : no;CJI e)lH eel BpeMH p:eM'OHT.8 ·'CHcreM,,.

. ~.' i.. ~ -: I ~ "

'.,'r> .. ;'.i.,·~~Tpa6oTaBWHX r~30B;;HJlH·BblnylJ.teH sa npene-

. " /¥~paH"lbI" HMeeT· poropaaf ~HJI':H AByna.KT·u,y·j{ JtBHra-

.O'Filtl'Yt', ~ . ~. - .. K . 'Bblcwe'M'Y ,KJI·a.ccyu~' B . CJlY'fae $- H,eo6x.OJ1HM'O'C'TH .' ~

'ct,3jal, ~b ;.~e~CfCO.""b,KO 3TUX t,.6CTOHTenscTB)~·' aa rOCH'OB,aH'~H no-

, ~1i'OHCTHTVrli1A'H '~K· pa··HH~I~ CT··CT 2 4·', _.,..:~.&::.,.aa- xoaa "'Kp"a-'iI

. '~~" . . _. : ~ i ~r:,J '. J~' ,._ '_ _ . } 01,. .._.'- - .. '" ; .. ).'i:I!~.': . _. rJ ..' .' "t:iIl "IF-

.omn . PTH38lJ,HH», CT.! '3aKOHa~ «Q\;"OATB-eP>K,.I.\eHHH

; ;,{onpe.n,e.meHHe- nOHSITHfi- «np~R'»)' :'IlOJlO>KeHHA ~M·..,.87 .. H,8-0CHoBaH,HH H3JlO~e.HH'o',r:O 'C.II·HTaio,.~·LJ,T'O rpe ...

,;.,gg~' . He Ha.Py,W,8JI,t T'+K~ CT3QAaPT8MH 'YKaaaHHbI'e B n . .i3 f~,4~6 ~fmDftJ,ru1I·_··< ,jU.,I,_l!I'~~.'mx ".~~ , 8B·TOMo6u·n.ft· ae YCT.a:HoBneH8I, 'nO'CKOJl'bKY ,9TH CT,8H'-

'. ·'W~:pacnpOCTpa~SlIOTCSl. nGaTOMY -.;COBepmeHHH aJ1MH ~ -;·i·Rf"·V" ~'·~·lJpaBOHap·yweHHH· CQ·HT,8,tO .. ce()Ji' HeB,nQOBH,bi.M»"

~.':,'J: t.~ ~. . ..' J \

..:"'<,i:I,._£ .. ':":' ' .. ' ae'" eCJIH, H3M,epeHH,H n,poB'QllHJlH'Cb:~, H8·pY.w·e'HHe.M

. . ' ~~"' .. ':MeTp'OJIOrHHiU»'; 3TO T8'lOKe Hy>KII~ YK83a.Tb. '.

. . . J .i , ). .

.... :~{/y, ... :·\.;~~·.~,EcJJH# , ~ pa na 3TO, H,OM,epHble.·3H8.KH 'H3ldMaIOT" Ae .. HCT,BOS8'Tb

., ~~. . .'. (J.. 'J:

',' .. 'Q.:y,>ke.,::~I1It·,caHH,blM ssnne c.nO·COOO'"M,: o6~paTHT.bcH C··8UMeHHe:M (:8

. _>, ;.\ '-', ~pO,M:·~O>KeHa 13 me npaBOB8f1 apryMeHT~UHH) It 'pykOBOJlCTSY nOA"

....... ~.~,.,,~_r.;i'~e:n~~H, COTPY».HHK KOToporo J:l3'bHJI HOMeptlble 3H3KH. EcnH ~TO He

~~~~ "'·:~;-·t_Q~~_'·~~Q;Llle,HCT.BHSI, MO>KHO oopamaTbCR.·8 c,Y_1l. 3:8 B03Melllwe:HHeM M,are-

.'.~ f'.' . ~/ :

··"~.·:~P.HaJJbH'oro·.lI Mopan'bHoro ymepoa. -', ... ". . r. '.. . .: .' .

",,, .. ' ....... .,, • ~. 1'1 ( ". ::.:{o,;. .~ ~ ..' . .

~>~~~>~ .>. '" ·_Kcra:rit~;{o~np.a·BJlH.SlCb ,8 .noe3AKY no IO>KH:bI~'Pel1tOH,aM YKpa.HHbI, rne

. . {a. .

-~·PIlClI:...i1·[;U ..... '~'CTO B,crpe'Q,8IOT'CSI .OOCTbI uoapoaepxe TOKCHIIHOCT:H" :HMe ..

M~~~l~o',~M~CJI ~'CSlKH~ c.nyqaJl a3naCTHCb aapaaee OTneq~)TaHHblMH6.QaR-

.. I .. t~".~ :'1'11 J ,,"

. :~<Ka~6~t1!lJJJ·CBe.liH·8 H aaSlBJIeHHH., CB,H3,8HHYX C':9'THM (ocraaaa CBOOO)I.HOe

: ... '. '. . ... ;"~.I· . /'. A'·' ..... . ,

. >\;':~:~:: .: ~: 4~I:>,,:·>~,·-,··/'. . .

• • ~'I~ . .rio';:.-.!J ... I.. ~ ••••

. :.... . .. }-1 ,or.! :.. ,": • .....

............ "'_::,~.~. "'-: • .I • • •• .... • •

.. ,,::,:~"I~ >.... '~."." : .

. • • .~:' I •• ': '.~ r~~", ,I I "':. : :', •

, .

.: T B.XHUIC{I.." ••

~J

~~.

. "'

.....:..... ~.~

,. .

...

-

Mecro WISI HOMe" a IJPotO'KOJIa',; KIKOTOPo'M)' npanaraercs 06'bstCH '.

JUlH 4laMHJutH H J).OJDKHOCTH JlHJ..Ul;, KOTOPOMY 8ApecosaHO 33S1, . ,~_l:ift • .Iij,..i]Jj~'tf.i

BeJJ.b'npaROBaSl,~p:I)'MeHTau,HSI snecb~oCTaTO'l_H~ o6-LeMR3J1, H .'~'~ t~~l renscra HYJKHO nepetlHCJlHTb"MHOro. 11 ,lJ.eJl3Tb 3TO «Ha KOJIe • .' .

o.eHb YJl06HO.. ..... -1-. ·.·f . . ~(i~~ . . . . ... '. '. _ _.. .

.l(oHettHO, Jly'ulIe"scero, xorna aBT.OM06HJIb B XOPOIllCM '~t~

K3p6IOP3TOP orperynHpoaaH, a T3JlOHTOKCHttHOCTH JIe>KHT _~.

8M-e'CTe c BQnHTeJ1bCKH:M YAoCToaepeflHeM H TexnacnoproM . 'oCBo60>lQlaeT OT He06xoJ).HMoctH 6biTb roTOBhlM OTCTaHB _ ... --.",.. .....

-nepen «60puaMH 3(l-9KOJI0l1t:10». BeJI.h CQcTaB OTP869:r;lq;~~::~Lti_1l'$~

,)KeT. H3MeHHTbCB H H3'~,3a ',HeKaIfeCTBeHH,?f'O TOnJIHBa.~::,<\~;·:~ .' -~-M"<:'A

BHe3anHO B03HHKweitHeHcnpasaOCTH ... A Bee 3TO, n~~Wtt~j ".'~ ~"'~~;"j psanaux M8HOBHJIH, K npaaepy, HCnOpqeHHoro OTnx~~_( '.

YI eme OWlO~ ..... ". . . . ', .. >//>. .. + .. ',' ,~.~~;'~~~;>_~'PI:'~~~I':'W-'

.' Hexoropoe BpeMfi H83M PYKOBO,lJ,CTBO M~~'-:· .~.~ .~$~~

. N283, KOTOPblM, B qaCTHOCTH, OblJlO sanpetneuo n:mOAHTb KO:HTpOJl~ COC1'0S1:HHft rpancnopraax c r: ",': .. ~~. ·t •• ~~

~re. Me>KJlY np()lIHM,. B npeaM6YJle caaoro -n~HKa~a •...

\"H' .~nai·'·H •• OK eo.acnonaeaae HOPM 3aKOHOB YKpaHa~~; .,~, tirlill

.. "~ ~- - . ~ ~ ''_''.I'',~

. ')KeMHH» II «0 MHJUIll,HH»; 03HaQaeT JIB OTMeHa~Tp,~ ~~ioCl~

,. neps HX co6.nKWlTb COTPY)l.HHKaM rAM. He H}'>KHO~:; ~\ .... ".~ .... ~.---r:,=

-: .. - 3To TeMa OT.u.e,nhHOro paarosopa (BnpOqeM, o6;,_'~LUil •• ~'E

sopanocs Ii nHcanOOb, B TOM qHCJte It 8BTOpOM. 3' . ~3t'1M(~~&~

:~ pa36epeMca~.a,' . 10m AU "Paso ,oo6UJe CO.'

. mposupoec . e mpaltcnopmH020 n·i.) .~~~~

ze? OpeiJoc ... ' . AU 'UM maxoe ·npa80 .

. n:n., «0» n,.2.4 I1JUl,Tpe6Y'~T OT BO)lHTeJlH A8Tb

. TpY;ll,HHKY "'UJlRUHH- npOBepHTb TeXHHqeCKOe COCTOSl ....... , ~m:!;r,:",,",-:

noro cpeacrea. OJ).H3KO· K3K 3TO cor Jl3cyeTcSI . ~~:,:" .. ,,,, -.: "1":

80}lH'[enSl, npe,zzyC-MOTpeHHblMH· aBKOHOM? (KaK MbI.ft~i:,:;u"''''''''''''·'''11I1

.~. C'T ·1"'9::·: U'OiLIC'~THTV,"~U_-'tiH- 'Y-,- KP, '·aHHbI", H.HKTO He .MO>K~T· , I,

Ii 0·· . . < r\,.;, . n~ ·11 J -- .If.lIL. '. ,

Jl.eJla~b T~: qTO .ae npellYCMorpeHO 38KOHOM. ~oe . ' aKTOM ~ - a K T8KOBbiM OTHOCHTCSI H nM, ~ He MO . HOMeHa HOB3S1 06S133HHOCTb rpa>K,llaHHH8, KOTOP .' ~.v.~

npe.n.yCMoTpeHa.) . . . - . ..' _ . '. .' .' .. <;_';_~'~i:J'..'

n .14 CT .11 nosaenaer MHnHlJ,HH npOBOAHTb.DCMOT.pbI·Vf, "a:1F11:1_~1

HblX Cpe.o.CTB (06 OrpaHHlJeHHlIX, KOTopble H31U1a.D.blBaeT. aa . ~l!-·~frf:a~~

p - - . -' .... ,·tl·na· :K-U.HH~ y, nK~ Mb1 Y>Ke r,

:uecc HbI:He· Jle:HcTBYI01U3S1, .p"~: '., '" . .' .,_ ~ __ . """"" ...... ~-:.~~8~L"lla

OqesHJUlo, sro non onpe.u.eneHHe TaKoro OCMOTpa noan .ll[fillill~~1!i1

: .. ~"""""','_'

'Ie,C,KHH OCMO·TP··· . ~ .'

O}l.H3i<O nopHAOK ero npo~e.n.eHIUI, K8K H 06f13aHH~

HoweHHH .ztPyrHx nuu, ,D,aHHOA HOPMOFI He onpep,eJlSlIOT

~ fIUC' ne '11 KS' C3TeJ[bHO n

C'TH '·B,oAHTe,J1:H:, B· 'TOM "'. '-" -' .' - ... ' . - .' --;"JOrr< , • ....,... rh9N~~J'Ei

. ..

'I "',

~. :



.J'

;-';':..0..":.00... cnopraoro CPeACTSB AJUI' KOFIT{'OJIJr eroCOCT0;H.' H8~;Onpe.a.eJfH''''''"" ... , ..... ,' ...... ~OHOM' «0 "JtOpO')KHOJM~ nHat:eHHH»'~ ICo:rJi·~aC.H'O~:CT,.35:- STOr'Q:

~ifi,lih" , InPtiH~IlOpmtl.bte cpe~etnBa, 4ptJHUMlllQIljue gqac.ml(e 8

• lj;e;.-~. . MOM. a8t1:JICeiUlil,~ noiJAe.G~ . rJ6113fl'meJlbH.OMY ioeg-

,"HOMI! m,e:tRu"eCltOMg oc~ompy 8 nopJu]1te,' gem.,'

, 'J .' ,~a6u.HetnoM. MaHllcm.poti: YICpdUltbi. Tpaacnopraue

:e n'p·oweJUUHe' T~·aKo'A>o·CMOTPt K'JlM.bHeiweA ·3<KcnJJySTi·_··

~~C·Ka.K>T'CH. ·Corn·aCHO 'Q;2 cr .. 16 Sr9fO 3~a:K:oaa·,. B'O)1HTeJl'b ....

o.:.:.~"""',"~'" .I~.J~.. ,<npOIJero,: ceoespeaenao npe:}:tOCT8BJI"Tb rpaacnopr- _:'

~'Irl.a.~).J"~?Du%.a. j.1:., ~:9'~YABpICT·Be'HH.blii TeXH.Hlfe~KH~ CJCM·O·Tp.~, r01~ca.Mbf.H, : '="":~~.~.

9o.BleD_~·!R~, 8ft K:QTO poro ,Q,npe)len;e,H ~K:a6M OH,OM ~.. " : ~ ... ' . '. . .: ~

• I _ •

~:':*."'" ,-,-' pecyer ·He·~·B·eCb :nOPRAOK., a T,O, yC1,8H08Jl'-eH8 ,n'~ ne-. :'

""'~J[_""" -'. . . OCMoTpa ? !:', .' .'. .'. . .' . ,'.

"-JI.3'np~~ ~p~BeAeHHH rOCyNlP~seHROro- TexHH'~<' .' " ... ,. HJIe~taBT06ycOB; Mororp8Hcnoptaj"'npH1(e~.: _

.' •• ,~.,}. 1 •• xareropaaa "P"H~l~NOCTH l,paHc~opTHOro.·' '.: ':.' .. '.

.:tI ... ~.,.". . . WJJHlIaerCH; 80,llM!-> ce,iqac ).Ie ·B~ 3TQM.- ,lte·.. ....

1.U"I!;ii',~"Ei "lipofJepo.,,· ma_,,:~cxt1eo !eocmi:JiI,HUSI . :':. ' . :.~

.. h r, l' , .: .

~' ....... :A ......... ·:.He'· 110 .,BpeMJI.~,ocg8'apCmBleH"OZo mex- "'''':''1::'':/1'

r:A: ..... N'I. " :~ iz 1lp1l.MO IIQ. OoPOU"He 1qIe8gCMOt(Ip(JfIOH"' ' -. '

........ ',J.il.u3fhtOHOM Y"partIIW «0 ikJpo.eItOMDBu",

~~~~~~'A~.··~ >_:< ,,' KCTaTH',- OflH3aHHOetL B'OJlHT_ npe.ztOCTas.nStTb· .

!II"!:I',.".... . ..,..,..... ..... .<i! . H8 roCYJlS,pCTBeH'H'~A TexHM.~KHH OCMOT.p.:~ ... ·

emu npe{Joc,tllasJuc,m" 6aoh • " umex-

mmgJl~IH1I.. "RpIlMO Na iJop:oa~e.,-; .. ' m_.

,,,« npoaeplt4 mu"u~,",'fJ' . . n» 8' amo),- ,

• I ttJl '_..._: .... ..,'

,.-.-' PCTBeH:HLlH· Te~Hq~c.KU:i,·~·~PCMOt,p "'-, ~CTb (H tterKO' ..

,,'IIIiP".A.._,..... I i lero npoSene:H}rSI', bfiH9aHH()CT:b, ~BOJlMTen·eA· B.. '.

e.D;CTBHSI'HenpoXO>KJl,eHUft} A «tlpoBepKH» .~ HeT' .','"" -'

. .• ~~qTOH ¥oBddum~ eetO;"pyiJ;;iuiFAllie·~~~ !frO, ccrnacao To:A )He et.19 ,KOJlePlfrynHH, YKpaHHbI, ~II~ ... blNH J1HJJ.B.MH opraaa roCYAl(>ctaeHHoH anBeTH (MH-

, paso ·_AeA,c.TBo.Ba'Tb TOJIbf(O HS ,oCHtl&a.HHH,. B npeaenax

~;,.1.':;AI;tUtf.Jl]:n. !I'_;~'i l'Ii'$U,~?J _ CoOOMH, npaxo npe.nycMOTpeHHhlMH.98KOHOf,t M,.co-·

, . .' :~ .. ~ .. ,::. I.... .." .,. ,)l.eHCTBH,H. H8 K·oTopble 11'0 3aKo~ nMHOMdqH'H ':He lIMe~.

_~~fa~, ;:'::~:¢l»DaTb~ 'H~ Moryr.lla>Ke 8' ~OM' .~~, ~'ecjnl TaKHe

-. '.', '_, .. ,;/< ;""'. R~ nponacasu B nOJl3aKoHHOM.'(~<TOlIH~~"':'. npOTHBO-33KOH ..

!Im'.nlo.7_~Io:;. ,~M): 8~p,~a;I1tBHOM ane. . . . . . ,'>. ,.' . .' " '

~~~-;";';I.:H:f{:"'!:· b, He COrJl8CHhiH C T~M, IfFU' Ha Hero COCT&BJleH

, '9.lJ,MHHHCTpaTHBHOM npaBOH8pYweHHH sa ynpaB.1leHite P1!BIiS '··~Cpje.aCTBOM c .He:"'c:npaB~ctflM:Ht c. KOTOp.bI.M·H ero' ,3J<.C~ ': . . .ute'KB; 18 C TpaH,cno~rr:H·OlrO. ·CpeJ.lcrB3' U3oHT.&J' HOM'ep:H',b(e ,,_,' ,~._:9BoeM OO'MICHeHHH Ha npQTOKOJI. a "OTOM 'B S8flBJIeinm

<'.~ ... : )1~:·:i"·I."'" .. ;-·;.t~~_

',il L.·r ;" J " "' ... ;-: I ~:~.o . :_'

'" '1 I' " . .Ip. •

,. 7' .. T'" . •

~ i'Ji .,1.1 i- • '.' :'" 'III - .'1

~; . , .". '.: ":". '. ~ .

~ ~I'" J _.. . .... ~ I" .. r 8

t .. ~.;;:~::;:;?;.: : . .': ::.,.: .~, .. : J A·am "~ .'

t. " .... ·6J '. '.. '." .', , . .'

.:_~~:"J ..••. dIj'.. .' .... •

.. I: • ~ ..... ••••

I • II •

aa JfMSI~a~ ~ fI 'I1QP.P~' ,t: TAU, (0' soaspare. Ho~epHwX ~'i~ 'i~\~~;~

:KOB) :y~3a'Tb:l-« . QlI;H "npoB,epQ' 1e~HHqeCKOrO CO'CT:·O~.HHH ,'~'i

. . A ~. r .... r.1!."".. ... . .1 .... 1

nopraoro 'ICP , 98'1 ~DP~,*' ;~:J9~@eJI>b'HYIQ " <?T '. rOCYAap' . , '

~j(:UHqeC:Koro ., ~~~~·:'Jo~rAH_JleRCTaOB8JIRB I . SJ •

ribitO)f(e'HHH CT.19 Konct~~H:;'YKpaHHliu c npeBb!weHH

'p,MlKHOCTHbIX DOJ1HOIf)'fHif, ~OCKWJbKY ,TaKaS npoeepd Be .... i:y~

Pe~a Hit CT.353a~oA~¥,RpaHHbI «0 AQPO>KHOM .il,sIDKeJuUt· '.

0:: .. - I - ..

118Ma I npo~eAeH,.~ft '. rQ'CYAap~r,eH'H'oro' .:TeXHHqeC~K ,.~. ~.:~5~ ~'!ri

"~IJ~oMo6HJ1Ej~" aB~o6t~B, MO!OTpaHcnop-ra H npaue '~'~~I:IHo'A ~Dp'.Me· 3~".OHa ~~IVA·,e·eT·cH CChIJIKB" a, 06 ..

: ilp~ctaBJIHTb 1'pa~CnOpTlf9~ cpe.D.CT'O NU,I T81t,)H nDO~lllel __

C5Ja~peHa 11.2 cT.I0,3sKoHa «0 ilOpo}IQJOM JnJH>Ke '. .' HO, npQ'f#:leHl{~.:ra:·KoA 119o.Bep:·KH.ft~6eTc.,H. Hap.:'·.y·.w·eH.··.~·;~

i I :-. "~." '" I·.~ ~.~~ .. ",11 .• ." _. ~ .J. '. · .... L' .

~3a~·~UQ.Ten~c.t,8~,,<Co·:I!JJ,ac,ao .. ~t62 'KO.H·CTHTYWIH: Y;'

• • ...- • I I r -' I • .. ... I. . I .

\'B'1:~ q"CIie·'~;ti"coBepiUelnt8 ~~HHaPanfBH"· '., ",

~>.;": - 1.!iro J(n 'I'i.~., _. ·-t.nd·, - ,". '~~.'n' . " __'. ~!:I'ii."~.il-.<:;~

t:'" .,o~~rh.;·ua3:~t'·~JJiI~~'~.'Ha AQK,a~~·~·,lbCT,BaXt n .. '.'

~/J. I.. ..I .. -:'. .: ~., • ,i~

"~IHeM saRoHil» ,- ;.'. . '. "."?:"

.: ::,:':' : '>"":' ',';, ":' ,:".;. ',"' :- .. '.' :". ,_ .' .:' ~ .. -: , ' .; -. Tl~;;: .

v .. '" '" ,J1l9t?ne ",oro .• ~asaaJte 8·0JJ.ft.TenS .. ~~a· ·yn.pa,lkRe :;-~~~

.. '. - ~~M C ~eH~p~~~MHJ ~~~ .. alOji~i,_: ...... 'lII!i'fiI ..... ~

::;v~~,r.:·, :ensa:J1H 803~MQ>KHhf" .\c'· ~'If"'AeJlO B·ce,>Ke·· .

... . I. _.1 •• ~. • ~. '.

. . . TO He·o6:xow·~~:~d:· a~_HT~·XO.'~·gT··;,~~:ge~)rBo···· ,0 .• · 'e:! ,~, .

~ , f· ~,~ ... -~t4 -x- j • 'h~ J-~~ • ~~ , , ~;.,,~

> . epHhle aaaxaace ~e' He'6yn.yT1BoaBPaw.eHbl~i;jf:

:i)~o'BaH.tJ1JJ.o6HB~T~~,,~pea:' CY4 'BOa~emeHHR .. ',' "'.""~ -

:.:,.~." ~ -. . . <'. , . 'f, ~~

.~,'~:b,HO.r6 ytge . ", .

..--' .o' ( .

... (. II '.

r:-~llloiJ.:1 ~ T;···. .

,.t •. ' ). . .. .

~ ~ 1.:--: . '. "I ~ _I" . ~I' .0.

~~.~. : '. :).~. I '. -, I '.-

..t.r .. \. .1.,.1 "," .'.

?"f.~~ . '.

r -. ., .. ~ I~. - I" I •• ••

filE' =» : I.. •

·t··~ , ' .. : .:<'. .

~~... l.tll •• I .

~ t.-:' '~":.: :. .: ":':~~, • ~ _. •• ~ .'

. i.. I. ,,'7" = I

.. .

..

... '1' •

I ~ ·...1 . .. . - ::'.' -: .

I ~ r ..:. . I _. . I .' '·:·":.~·-:·-!I" •

• I 1.Jo .:.., ;. I .... {i:.J" '.-' ..

;... • I • I .. ~

~~~::" .. _. :,: ;"~'~' ': :" ' '.. . ' :,:~'~" f~' .. ;. ::, ~.:' .'

0 •• '1 .' I. :'

~~ )':.. . . .... (i:' .. ;:: :. I

r . - I ", • . I

r:; .... .. '-I~~I ~. .' .' I '" ~I·;. I I'

. .

. .

.

.' .' ,

.,

. J -,

.. '

• • I •

. . '. .: _,:,' - 1\ !toep:: ,;~e"'w~:'.illf.ra'l'tJlbt - B AOpory._ . . -"00 __ nuttit"oe HanyrerBlle:: :JlH rBOSAR" ;·HH .",' . ~Ji ~~~

TOJIb (;) BOT ecJI·H paCII"CTHT.h OT fBQ3AeA HaWB . .··ii.1I .,·eAB8 .~HKTO 8· eOC1OIIHHK, TO y6epeqbCH OT nenr '. n 'PO'" :. Hcv'Q' ;·n·,dUUl·-· X··' OT w.A~'II'!IAB 'ToAnl 'ep" -. 'ovn,e"T u·an_.lftI!t:b ", .: .. ' ·.r ~ -._ ,: .. 1 '.~-~l!I*' '" I'~ ~'. :. ..i~··f .. ·~~~ii'"

, "

.:. • ":.1\ •

~ -; . .

, i.

I ... • .1. _

.'

." .. .

~ - ' ..

. . . . ,

._

. s ~

. J. •

.... ~

. ..

"

.... I j-

(-I ••

~ .

I • • •

~. :,

< TeX,HU,,,a.,~,~ .

Оценить