ANNEXURE—A

LOK SABHA

PETITIONS FOR DISQUALIFICATION: TABULAR PRESENTATION

Total no. No. of No. of Petitions Petitions Petitions No. of

of petitions petitions allowed disallowed rendered MP’s
petitions under under infructuou disqualified
(cases) para 2(1) para 2(1) s
(a) (b)

39 21 18 13 19 7 131

1
Of these 13, four members who were disqualified during the Tenth Lok Sabha filed civil writ petition in the
High Court of Delhi, praying for the stay on the order of the Speaker, Tenth Lok Sabha disqualifying them. The
High Court granted stay on the order of the Speaker till disposal of the writ petition. Before the writ petition
could be disposed off, the Tenth Lok Sabha was dissolved, consequently, the said four members continued to be
members of the Tenth Lok Sabha till its dissolution. Hence, in net effect though13 members were declared
disqualified, actually nine members of the Lok Sabha stood disqualified.
 ANNEXURE—B

GRAPHICAL REPRESENTATION OF THE

PETITIONS FOR DISQUALIFICATION: (ALLOWED/ DISALLOWED)

GRAPH NUMBER: 1
 ANNEXURE—C

PETITIONS FOR DISQUALIFICATION (GROUNDS/NO. OF MEMBERS

DISQUALIFIED)

GRAPH NUMBER: 2
 ANNEXURE—D

RAJYA SABHA
CASES OF DISQUALIFICATION

TABULAR PRESENTATION

Total no. No. of No. of Petitions Petitions Petitions No. of

of petitions petitions allowed disallowed rendered MP’s
petitions under under infructuou disqualified
(cases) para 2(1) para 2(1) s
(a) (b)

2 2 - 2 - - 2
 ANNEXURE—E

KARNATAKA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY

CASES OF DISQUALIFICATION

TABULAR PRESENTATION

Sl. Year Date Name(s) of Number of Grounds Decision

No. when Petitioner(s) Respondents
Petition
given
Voluntarily
giving up Dismissed
1 1989 16.2.1989 Smt. 111 members membership on
Nagarathanamma of the 16.2.1989
original
party, i.e.
Janata Party
7 members
{Dr. N.L.
Bharati Voluntarily Dismissed
2 2002 13.12.2002 Shri. Jagadeesh Shanker, Ms. A giving on
Shetter Manju, V. membership 30.1.2004
Krishnappa, of BJP
K.H.
Hanumegowda,
Gundappa
Vakil, V.
Pappanna and
H.C.
Basavaraj}