Академический Документы
Профессиональный Документы
Культура Документы
ON
ANALYSIS OF INDIAN AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY
By
S. RAMPRASAD
Siruseri, Chennai
July 2010
Place:
Date: _______________________
The automobile industry, one of the core sectors, has undergone metamorphosis with the
advent of new business and manufacturing practices in the light of liberalization and
globalization. The sector seems to be optimistic of posting strong sales in the couple of years
in the view of a reasonable surge in demand. The Indian automobile market is gearing
towards international standards to meet the needs of the global automobile giants and become
a global hub. So investment in the stocks of the automobile industry is one of the attractive
options.
Investing in shares of a company is highly rewarding at the same time it is highly risky.
Moreover the Indian Stock market is highly volatile with large volumes being traded.
Analysis of stocks is highly helpful to reduce the risks and to make good money.
This project is aimed at analyzing the Indian automobile industry in the view of its
feasibility as an investment option. A detailed analysis of the Indian automobile industry is
covered in respect of past growth and performance. The fundamental analysis is done which
analyzes the economy in the broader sense and the industry is analyzed using Industry Life
Cycle, Porter’s Five Forces Model and SWOT Analysis.
Three companies namely Mahindra & Mahindra, Tata Motors and Ashok Leyland are
chosen and their financial and non-financial information are analyzed. The technical analysis
is also done for the stocks using some technical indicators.
Based on the analysis done the intrinsic value of the shares of the companies were found
out and their future price directions were determined.
Based on the analysis the future price directions are determined and recommendations are
given to make the project more meaningful.
CHAPTERISATION
1. Introduction to the project: This chapter gives a description about the project. It covers the
objectives, scope, limitations, methodology used and the sample design.
2. Introduction to Munoth Financial Services Limited: This chapter gives a brief overview
about the SIP Organization.
3. Introduction to Indian Automobile Industry: This chapter gives a bird’s eye view on the
Indian Automobile Industry.
4. Introduction to Fundamental Analysis: This chapter discusses about the Fundamental
Analysis and the various concepts of it in detail.
5. Introduction to Technical Analysis: This chapter discusses about the concept of Technical
Analysis in detail.
6. Indian Economic Analysis: This chapter analyses in the overall Indian economy in a
broader sense.
7. Indian Automobile Industry Analysis: This chapter gives details about the Indian
Automobile Industry and the industry is analyzed using tools like SWOT, Porter’s Five
Forces Model, etc.
8. Analysis of Mahindra & Mahindra Limited: The fundamental and technical analysis of
Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., is done in this chapter.
9. Analysis of Tata Motors Limited: The fundamental and technical analysis of Tata Motors
Ltd., is done in this chapter.
10. Analysis of Ashok Leyland Limited: The fundamental and technical analysis of Ashok
Leyland Limited is done in this chapter
11. Findings: This chapter gives the information on the findings of the analysis made in the
preceding chapters.
12. Conclusions: The conclusions are drawn based on the findings of the analysis
13. Recommendations: Based on the findings and conclusions recommendations are given in this
chapter
14. References: This chapter lists the sources from which the information for the project is
collected.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.1.Overview 1
1.
1.2.Objectives, Scope and Limitations 1
List of Tables
The automobile industry is one of the core industries in India and is optimistic of posting
good sales in the coming years. So, the investment in shares and securities of automobile
companies seems to be profitable.
Investing is one of the most crucial decisions that every earning individual has to make at
one point of the time or the other. One of alluring options available is the investment in the
shares and securities of companies. The investment in share market is highly rewarding but
highly risky.
The concept of analysis comes into picture when decision has to be made on choosing a
particular company’s shares for investment. Analysis includes fundamental and technical
analysis. A proper analysis helps in reducing the risks on investment in the share markets less
risky and highly rewarding.
This project is aimed at finding the analyzing the securities of select companies in the
automobile industries and to assist investment decisions.
Objectives:
Primary Objectives:
➢ The research report can be used by the organization to assist the investors in making
investment decisions.
Secondary Objectives:
In order to accomplish the primary objectives the following secondary objectives are to be
accomplished:
Limitations:
➢ The analysis is fully based on secondary data and hence the accuracy of data is a major
concern.
➢ Only three companies are selected for analysis because of time constraints.
➢ Since the annual reports for 2009-10 are not available for the selected companies
fundamental analysis is done using the data available till 2009.
➢ Analysis helps the investor in making investment decisions but not every investment is
entirely dependent on the analysis alone.
➢ Some important concepts would have been left uncovered in the project due to lack of data
availability and the project has to be completed in a short span of time.
➢ Type of Study:
The project will be exploratory in the initial stage and the knowledge thus gained will be
used for further descriptive research.
➢ Data:
The project is done using secondary data.
➢ Sample Size:
3 automobile companies listed in the National Stock Exchange.
➢ Sampling Design:
The companies for the project shall be selected using Convenience Random Sampling.
2. An Introduction to Munoth Financial Services Limited
Established in the year 1990 as a widely held public company, The Munoth Financial
Services Limited (MFSL) is the one on its growth pace among its peers. With a networth of
above Rs.10Cr the equity shares of the company are listed on the Bombay Stock Exchange
(BSE) & the Madras Stock Exchange (MSE).
With excellent infrastructure and a good research team the company has its operations
at Chennai and Bangaluru. The company provides diverse financial services to Institutional,
Corporate, Resident Indians and Non Resident Indian (NRI) customers. The company is also
planning to start online trading services soon.
Vision:
To provide all the capital market services under one roof to institutional, corporate and retail
clients with prudence and integrity.
Values:
The Munoth Group is driven by the ethics and philosophies of their ancestors and values that
are built over the past 100 years.
Objectives:
Corporate Stock Brokers: MFSL is a corporate stock broker with National Stock Exchange
(NSE) and member of Madras Stock Exchange and Over The Counter Exchange of India
(OTCEI). It executes business in both cash segment and F&O Segment.
Mutual Funds Marketing: MFSL markets Mutual Funds for major companies like Reliance
Mutual Funds, Sundaram BNP Paribas Mutual, LIC Mutual Fund, SBI Mutual Fund, etc.
IPO Offering: The Primary Markets Division of the company markets all the IPOs.
2.2. Clients:
The Company has been associated with over hundred initial public offerings, has
managed rights issue, open offer and ESOPs. The company has recently underwritten the
issues of Madras fertilizers Limited and has handled ESOP shares for Orchid Chemicals and
Pharmaceuticals Limited.
3.INTRODUCTION TO INDIAN AUTOMOBILE
INDUSTRY
The auto industry is the greatest engine of economic growth in the world. The global auto
industry is a key sector of the economy for every major country in the world. The industry
continues to grow, registering a 30 percent increase over the past decade.
In 2009, more than 60 million motor vehicles, including cars and commercial
vehicles were produced worldwide equivalent to a global turnover of around €2 trillion.
The automobile industry is one of the fastest growing industries in India. The Indian
automobile industry is the seventh largest in the world with an annual production of over 2.6
million units in 2009.
Withstanding a growth rate of 18% per annum and an annual production of more than 2
million units, it may not be an exaggeration to say that this industry in the coming years will
soon touch a figure of 10 million units per year.
In 2009, India emerged as Asia's fourth largest exporter of automobiles, behind Japan,
South Korea and Thailand. By 2050, the country is expected to top the world in car volumes
with approximately 611 million vehicles on the nation's roads.
• India ranks 5th pertaining to the number of bus and truck sold in the world.
The Indian Automobile industry is floated with both domestic and international players
and is highly competitive. One company is present in more than one segment of the industry.
Contributing a major share to the GDP, employing more people the industry also supports
many other industries. More about the industry is explored into and is analyzed in the
Analysis Chapter under Industry Analysis.
2.INTRODUCTION TO FUNDAMENTAL
ANALYSIS
An investor can make more money if his investment decisions are based on actual
movement of share price measured both in money and percentage terms. It is also very
important to predict the future movements and also the true value of the securities.
Equity analysis is used in order to find the true value of the securities and also to know
where the prices are moving. It covers many aspects including the calculating various
financial ratios and charts to extremely sophisticated indicators.
Equity Analysis is broadly divided into fundamental and technical analysis. Technical
analysis looks at the price movement of a security and uses this data to predict its future price
movements. Fundamental analysis, on the other hand, looks at economic factors, known as
fundamentals.
The following are the major differences between fundamental and technical analysis:
The fundamental information that is analyzed can include a company's financial reports,
and non-financial information such as estimates of the growth of demand for products sold by
the company, industry comparisons, and economy-wide changes, changes in government
policies etc.
The approach to fundamental analysis is often referred to as E-I-C Approach. The E-I-C
denotes the three parts of the fundamental analysis. The three distinctive parts of fundamental
analysis are:
1. Economic Analysis
2. Industry Analysis and
3. Company Analysis
2.1. ECONOMIC ANALYSIS:
Economic analysis is the analysis of forces operating the overall economy a country. It is
a process whereby strengths and weaknesses of an economy are analyzed and is important in
order to understand exact condition of an economy. The various factors considered are:
Countries go through the business or economic cycle and the stage of the cycle at
which a country is in has a direct impact both on industry and individual companies. It affects
investment decisions, employment, demand and the profitability of companies. It is very
important to determine the stage of the cycle into which the economy is passing through. The
four stages of economic cycle are depression, recovery, boom and recession.
BOOM
DEPRESSION
RECESSION
RECOVERY
DISINVEST
INVEST
Investors should attempt to determine the stage of the economic cycle the country is in.
They should invest at the end of a depression when the economy begins to recover, and at the
end of a recession. Investors should disinvest either just before or during the boom, or at the
worst, just after the boom. Investment and disinvestments made at these times will earn the
investor the greatest benefits.
A country needs foreign exchange reserves to meet its commitments, pay for its imports
and service foreign debts. If the reserves are not managed properly it may pose foreign
exchange risks.
Inflation
Inflation has an enormous effect in the economy. Within the country it erodes
purchasing power. As a consequence, demand falls. If the rate of inflation in the country from
which a company imports is high then the cost of production in that country will
automatically go up.
Interest Rates
A low interest rate stimulates investment and industry. Conversely, high interest rates
result in higher cost of production and lower consumption.
Taxation
The level of taxation in a country has a direct effect on the economy. If tax rates are
low, people have more disposable income.
Government Policy
Government policy has a direct impact on the economy. A government that is perceived
to be pro-industry will attract investment.
The first step in industry is to determine the cycle it is in, or the stage of maturity of the
industry. All industries evolve through the following stages:
1. Introduction
2. Growth
3. Maturity
4. Decline
There are competitive forces and it is these competitive forces that determine the extent
of the inflow of funds, the return on investment and the ability of companies to sustain these
returns. Porter has identified five competitive forces that shape every industry and every
market.
SWOT Analysis
SWOT analysis of an industry gives an investor the overall picture about the industry.
A scan of the internal and external environment is an important part of the strategic planning
process. Environmental factors internal to the firm usually can be classified as strengths (S)
or weaknesses (W), and those external to the firm can be classified as opportunities (O) or
threats (T). Such an analysis of the strategic environment is referred to as a SWOT analysis.
Company analysis is the final stage of fundamental analysis. The economy analysis
provides the investor a broad outline of the prospects of growth in the economy. The industry
analysis helps the investor to select the industry in which investment would be rewarding.
Now he has to decide in which company he has to invest. Company analysis provides the
answer to this question.
In company analysis the investor tries to predict the future earnings of the company
because there is strong evidence that the earnings have a strong effect on the share prices.
The level, trend and safety of earnings of a company, however depend upon a number of
factors concerning the operations of the company.
➢ The Management
➢ The Company
➢ The Annual Report
➢ Ratios
➢ Cash flow
The Management:
Management is the most important factor that should be first looked into in a company.
The performance of a company is primarily dependant on the effectiveness of the
management.
Investors must check on the integrity of the managers, proven competence, rating among
its peers, its performance at the time of adversity, its depth of knowledge, innovation and
professionalism.
The Company:
The annual report is the primary and most important source of information on a
company. By law, this is prepared every year and distributed to the shareholders. It contains
very important information relating to the performance of a company over a period of time.
The Annual Report is broken down into the following specific parts:
C. Financial Statements
Balance Sheet
The Balance Sheet details the financial position of a company on a particular date; of
the company's assets (that which the company owns), and liabilities (that which the company
owes), grouped logically under specific heads. It must however, be noted that the Balance
Sheet details the financial position on a particular day.
The Profit and Loss account summarizes the activities of a company during an
accounting period which may be a month, a quarter, six months, a year or longer, and the
result achieved by the company. It details the income earned by the company, its cost and the
resulting profit or loss. It is, in effect, the performance appraisal not only of the company but
also of its management- its competence, foresight and ability to lead.
Ratios:
A ratio is an arithmetical expression of relationship between two variables of the
financial statements. It helps in easy comparison. The comparison may be intra firm or inter
firm. A glance at the ratios of the company gives the complete information about the
company to an investor.
There are many ratios one can calculate and no single ratio can tell the complete story.
Ratios are generally classified as:
➢ Net Profit Margin:- The Net Profit Margin measures the relationship between Net Profits and
Sales of a firm. This ratio is indicative of management’s ability to operate the business
successfully and expresses the cost effectiveness of the organization.
A high net profit margin would ensure adequate return to the owners as well as enable the firm
to withstand adverse economic conditions like falling demand, rising costs, etc. while a low net
profit margin has the opposite implications.
➢ Debt-Equity Ratio:- This ratio is used to find out the long term solvency position of the firm.
This ratio serves of primary use to the creditors of the company. This ratio is also used by the
investors to know their claim in the company.
➢ Return on Equity:- This ratio expresses the profitability of a firm in relation to the equity
shareholders’ funds.
This is the single most important ratio to judge whether the firm has earned satisfactory return
to the equity shareholders or not.
➢ Earnings Per Share (EPS):- This ratio measures the profit available to the equity shareholders
on a per share basis, that is the amount they can get on every share held. It is the most widely
used ratio by investors.
Earnings Per Share=Net Profit available to equity share holdersTotal No.of Shares outstanding
This ratio only shows the profits earned per share but the same amount is not received by the
shareholders.
➢ Price Earnings (P/E) Ratio:- The P/E Ratio reflects the price currently paid by the investor
for each rupee of the reported EPS.
Price Earnings Ratio=Market Price per shareEarnings Per Sahre
It measures the investor’s confidence in the firm’s future. The higher the ratio, the larger is the
investor’s confidence in the firm’s future.
➢ Dividend Per Share (DPS):- This ratio shows the profits that are paid to equity shareholders
on a per share basis
Dividend Per Share=Dividend Paid to Equity shareholdersNo.of Equity Shares Outstanding
The DPS is a better indicator than EPS as the former shows exactly what amount is received by
the shareholders.
➢ Dividend Payout Ratio:- This ratio measures the relationship between the earnings belonging
to the equity shareholders and the dividends paid to them.
If the Dividend Payout Ratio is subtracted from 100 it shows the Earnings Retention Ratio,
which shows the profits retained in the business.
➢ Dividend Yield Ratio:- This ratio reflects the price paid by the investor for each rupee of the
dividend paid.
This ratio is very significant from the point of view of those investors who are interested in
dividend income.
➢ Book Value Per Share:- Book value per share represents the claim of the shareholders on a
per share basis. This ratio is sometimes used as a benchmark for comparison with the Market
price per share.
Technical analysis is a security analysis technique that claims the ability to forecast the
future direction of prices through the study of past market data, primarily price and volume.
In its purest form, technical analysis considers only the actual price and volume behavior of
the market or instrument.
Technical analysis mainly seeks to predict the short term price travels. Technical analysts
do not attempt to measure a security's intrinsic value, but instead use charts and other tools to
identify patterns that can suggest future activity.
A chart is simply a graphical representation of a series of prices over a set time frame.
Technical analysis uses various kinds of charts to show the movement of prices over a period
of time. The charts that are most commonly used for technical analysis are:
➢ Line Charts
➢ Bar Charts and
➢ Candlestick Charts
Line Chart:
Line Chart is the most common and simple charts as it considers only the closing prices
of the stocks and ignores other values such as open, close, etc. The line chart is drawn by
connecting the closing prices of a stock over a period of time. The above figure shows the
line chart for the Reliance Industries Limited for 3 months period (April to June 2010)
Bar Chart:
The chart is made up of a series of vertical lines and two small horizontal lines, one to the
left and another to the right. The vertical line represents the high and low for the trading
period, along with the small horizontal line on the left to show the open price and another on
the right side to show the closing price. The above figure shows the bar chart for Reliance
Industries Limited for 3 months period (April- June 2010).
Candlestick Chart:
Similar to a bar chart the candlestick chart also shows all the information like high, low,
open and close prices of the stock the only difference being the way it is visually constructed.
Usually traders feel that candlestick charts are easy to read because it clearly shows the
relationship between the opening and closing prices of a security. If the closing price is more
than the opening price the candle is shaded white. Conversely the candle is shaded black if
the closing price is less than the opening price.
The above figure shows the Candlestick price chart of Reliance Industries Limited for a
period of 3 months (April- June 2010) and also the patterns of candle sticks.
1.2. Volume:
Volume refers to the number of shares or contracts that are traded over a given period of
time. Usually a price chart is presented along with the volume which is represented by
volume bars. The higher the volume, the more active the security is. Volume is an important
aspect of technical analysis because it is used to confirm trends and chart patterns.
Any price movement up or down with relatively higher volume is seen as stronger and
more relevant move than a similar move with weak volume.
1.3. Trends:
Trend refers to the direction in which a security or the market is moving. In technical
analysis, it is the movement of the highs and lows that constitutes a trend.
➢ Uptrend:
A trend is considered to be uptrend if each successive high and low is more than the high and
low of the previous day. This is also called as bullish trend. In other words in an uptrend the
prices makes a series of higher highs and higher lows.
➢ Downtrend:
A trend is said to be downward if each successive high and low is lesser than that of the
previous day. Downward trend is also called as Bearish Trend. In other words in a downtrend
prices makes a series of lower highs and lower lows.
Support: Support refers to the price level beyond which the prices will not fall. It is the level
at which buyers take control over the markets and prevents the price from falling further. In
the above figure we can see that the support level is established at Rs.30.30
Resistance: Resistance refers to the price level beyond which the prices will not go up. It is
the levels at which the sellers will take control over the market and prevents the price from
rising further. In the above figure we can see that the resistance is established at Rs.31.90.
Role Reversal:
Once a resistance or support level is broken, its role is reversed. If the price falls below a
support level, that level will become resistance. If the price rises above a resistance level, it
will often become support. In the above figure we can see that the Support at Rs.51 has
become the resistance level on a later stage.
Technical indicators are mathematical formulas that, when applied to security prices,
clearly flash either buy or sell signals. Price data includes any combination of the open, high,
low or close over a period of time and most of the indicators use only the closing prices.
For analysis purposes, technical indicators are usually shown in a graphical form above or
below a security's price chart. Once shown in graphical form, an indicator can then be
compared with the corresponding price chart of the security. Sometimes indicators are plotted
on top of the price plot for a more direct comparison.
A technical indicator offers a different perspective from which to analyze the price action.
Some, such as moving averages, are derived from simple formulas and are relatively easy to
understand while some such as MACD uses complex formulas and are difficult to
understand.
The technical indicators can be broadly classified into leading indicators and lagging
indicators. The leading indicators are those indicators which are designed to lead price
movements. The most common leading indicators are RSI and ROC.
Lagging indicators are those indicators which follow price action and are commonly
referred to as trend following indicators. Some of the most common lagging indicators are
Moving Averages and MACD.
Some of the most common technical indicators that are used in this project are:
1. Moving Averages
2. Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD)
3. Relative Strength Index (RSI)
4. Rate of Change (ROC)
1. Moving Averages:
The moving averages are the most common and widely used technical indicators
because of their simplicity. Moving averages are formed by calculating the average price of a
security over a period of time. Moving averages smooth the price data to form a trend
following indicator. They do not predict price direction, but rather define the current direction
with a lag. Moving averages form the building blocks for many other technical indicators
including MACD.
Simple Moving Average (SMA): A simple moving average is formed by computing the
average price of a security over a specific number of periods. Most moving averages are
based on the closing prices. A 5-day simple moving average is the five day sum of closing
prices divided by five. As its name implies, a moving average is an average that moves. Old
data is dropped as new data comes available. This causes the average to move along the time
scale.
There are three steps to calculating an exponential moving average. First, calculate the
simple moving average. An EMA has to start somewhere so a simple moving average is used
as the previous period's EMA in the first calculation. Second, calculate the weighting
multiplier. Third, calculate the exponential moving average. The formula for calculating
EMA is
In the above diagram the SMA (15) and EMA (15) are plotted where we can see that the
EMA responds faster to recent price changes than SMA.
The length of the moving average depends on the analytical objectives. Short moving
averages (5-20 periods) are best suited for short-term trends and trading. Chartists interested
in medium-term trends would opt for 20-60 period moving averages. Long-term investors
will prefer moving averages with 100 or more periods.
The direction of the moving average conveys important information about prices. A rising
moving average shows that prices are generally increasing. A falling moving average
indicates that prices, on average, are falling. A rising long-term moving average reflects a
long-term uptrend. A falling long-term moving average reflects a long-term downtrend.
Two moving averages can be used together to generate crossover signals. A bullish
crossover occurs when the shorter moving average crosses above the longer moving average.
This is also known as a golden cross. A bearish crossover occurs when the shorter moving
average crosses below the longer moving average. This is known as a dead cross.
Moving averages can also act as support in an uptrend and resistance in a downtrend. A
short-term uptrend might find support near the 20-day simple moving average. A long-term
uptrend might find support near the 200-day simple moving average.
2. Moving Average Convergence and Divergence (MACD):
Positive and Negative MACD: Positive MACD indicates that the 12-day EMA is above
the 26-day EMA i.e. when the MACD Histogram is positive. This means upside momentum
is increasing. On the other hand, Negative MACD indicates that the 12-day EMA is below
the 26-day EMA i.e. when the MACD Histogram is negative. This means downside
momentum is increasing.
Signal line crossovers: A bullish crossover occurs when MACD turns up and crosses
above the signal line. A bearish crossover occurs when MACD turns down and crosses below
the signal line.
Centerline Crossovers: A bullish centerline crossover occurs when MACD moves above
the zero line to turn positive. At this time a BUY signal is generated. A bearish centerline
crossover occurs when MACD moves below the zero line to turn negative. At this time a
SELL signal is generated.
3. Relative Strength Index (RSI):
J. Welles Wilder developed the Relative Strength Index (RSI) and introduced it in the
June 1978 article for Commodities magazine. RSI is an extremely popular momentum
indicator.
RSI is a momentum oscillator that measures the speed and change of price movements.
RSI oscillates between zero and 100. The most popular is the 14 days RSI where the RSI is
calculated based on 14 days values. Traditionally the stock is considered to be overbought
when RSI is above 70 and oversold when RSI is below 30. Signals can also be generated by
looking for divergences and centerline crossovers.
Calculation:
The very first calculations for average gain and average loss are simple 14 period averages.
• First Average Gain = Total of Gains during the past 14 periods / 14.
• First Average Loss = Total of Losses during the past 14 periods / 14
The second, and subsequent, calculations are based on the prior averages and the current gain
loss:
• Average Gain = [(previous Average Gain) x 13 + current Gain] / 14.
• Average Loss = [(previous Average Loss) x 13 + current Loss] / 14.
RSI Signals:
➢ The stock is considered to be overbought if RSI goes above 70. Since the stock is
overvalued, it is the right time to sell the stock and make profits
➢ Conversely, a stock is considered to be oversold if RSI falls below 30. Since the stock
is undervalued, it is the right time to buy the stock.
➢ A RSI reading above 50 is bullish as the average gains are more than the average
losses. On the other hand a reading below 50 is considered to be bearish.
➢ A bearish divergence occurs when stock makes a higher high and the RSI makes a
lower high
➢ A bullish divergence occurs when stocks makes a lower low while RSI makes a
higher low.
4. Rate of Change:
The figure above shows the prices and Rate of Change for a period of 7 months.
Calculation:
ROC Indicators:
➢ ROC indicator which is at a high peak and starting to move down is an indication of a
sell signal, whereas an ROC at a low peak, but staring to move upward, is a buy
signal.
➢ A movement toward the zero line indicates that the existing trend is losing
momentum.
➢ ROC moving from above zero to below zero level is an indication of sell while ROC
moving from below zero to above zero level is an indication of buy.
1. Indian Economic Analysis
The Indian economy is one of the largest economies in the world. Presently India stands
in the 13th position in the world in terms of Gross Domestic Product (GDP). According to the
estimates of the World Bank the India GDP is worth 1217 billion USD or 1.96% of the world
GDP. According to a report published by domestic broking major Edelweiss Captal in March
2010, India's GDP is set to quadruple over the next ten years and the country is likely to be a
US$ 4 trillion economy by 2020. India will overtake China to become the world's fastest
growing economy by 2018.
(Figure 1)
In the Figure 1 we can see that India’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) expanded 7.90%
over the last 4 quarters. Its diverse economy encompasses traditional village farming, modern
agriculture, handicrafts, a wide range of modern industries, and a multitude of services. The
economy has posted an average growth rate of more than 7% in the decade since 1997.
With the help of strong financial policies and balanced stimulus packages the economy
could recover from the global slowdown in a faster pace when compared with many
developed nations which is a sign of political stability in the country. This made India as one
of the promising nations in the world for FDIs and FIIs.
Foreign institutional investors (FIIs) were net investors of US$ 4.54 billion in equity and
US$ 4.71 billion in debt instruments during January- March 2010, according to the data
released by Securities and Exchange Board of India. India received FDI worth US$ 20.92
billion during April-December 2009, taking the cumulative amount of FDI inflows from
August 1991 to December 2009 to US$ 127.46 billion.
As on March 26, 2010, India's foreign exchange reserves totaled US$ 277.04 billion, an
increase of US$ 24.71 billion over the same period last year according to RBI.
Of the more than 200 companies from over 50 countries that form part of the World
Economic Forum's Global Growth Companies (GGC) Community, India today has the
second largest representation, with a total of 18 GGCs with a strong representation from
almost every sector.
The recovery of the Indian economy, as was broadly expected, worked well for the
advance tax figures. The all India direct tax collection between April and December 2009,
which includes corporate and personal taxes, increased 8.1 per cent to US$ 48.39 billion,
according to figures that are currently with the income-tax (I-T) department.
Exports from India were worth US$ 16.09 billion in February 2010, 34.8 per cent higher
than the level in February 2009, according to the Ministry of Commerce and Industry. India's
imports during February 2010 were valued at US$ 25.05 billion representing a growth of 66.4
per cent over February 2009.
The automobile industry in India is one of the fastest growing industries, growing at a
rate of 18% per annum. The industry is the seventh largest in the world by producing around
2.6 million units in the year 2009.
This part explains in detail about the Indian Automobile Industry and analyzes the
industry.
The automobile industry can be broadly segmented into Two Wheelers, Three Wheelers,
Passenger Vehicles and Commercial Vehicles. The Commercial Vehicles can be further
divided into Heavy Commercial Vehicles (HCVs) and Light Commercial Vehicles (LCVs).
The following diagram shows the composition of the major segments of the industry.
The Figure 2 shows that the two wheelers enjoy a major share in the Indian Automobile
Industry constituting 76% of the industry. While the passenger vehicles constituting for 16%
and Commercial Vehicles and Three wheelers constituting 4% each. This shows that India
has a great potential in the passenger vehicles segment which includes cars and vans because
increasing standard of living makes people to switch from two wheelers to cars.
The Indian automobile industry is floated with both domestic and international players
making it highly competitive. The fact is that almost 8 out of 10 global companies including
General Motors, BMW, etc. have their presence in India contributing 25% of the Country’s
production.
The top 10 companies in the Indian Automobile Industry are: Maruti Suzuki India Ltd.,
Hyundai Motor India Ltd., Tata Motors, Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Hero Honda Motors
Ltd., Bajaj Auto, General Motors Pvt. Ltd., Honda Siel Cars India Ltd., Toyota Kriloskar
Motor Pvt. Ltd., and Ashok Leyland respectively.
Many companies are present in more than one segment of the industry. For example Tata
Motors is present in HCVs, LCVs, MUVs and Passenger Cars.
The automobile industry has emerged as the key contributor to the growth of the
economy. In the last decade their share in the Indian economy is around 5% of GDP.
Economic progress is indicated by the amount of goods and services produced which give
the impetus for transportation and boost the sale of vehicles. Increase in automobile
production has a catalyst effect by indirectly increasing the demand for a number of raw
materials like steel, rubber, plastics, glass, paint, electronics and services. An interesting fact
is that the industry accounts for 7% of the total steel consumption.
Since transportation is the nerve center of every other industry, the well being of the
automobile industry is a good indicator of the health of the economy and every piece of
infrastructure development in the country stimulates the demand for automobiles.
Economic studies have shown that every truck manufactured creates anywhere between
eight to twelve jobs and a bus would create around seven, which would include salespeople,
drivers, mechanics, cleaners and servicing staff.
Strengths:
➢ Large Domestic Market: India has the largest domestic market which is not fully
exploited. In specific, the passenger vehicles segment has a bright scope in the
coming years.
➢ Cost Advantage: India enjoys lower labor cost of $ 8 per hour of skilled labor while
the labor cost of other developed countries is around $ 20 per hour. The cost of
creating an automotive design is very economical in India ($60 per hour) when
compared to Europe and US (around $800 per hour)
➢ Engineering Skills: India has a strong competitive advantage in design and
engineering skills when compared to other low cost economies. India is the ninth
country in the world to design a vehicle on its own
➢ Competitive Auto Component Vendor Base: Competitive auto component vendor
base which helps to get the required auto components at competitive rates leading to
lower manufacturing costs.
Weaknesses:
➢ Research & Development: Even though there is a development in R&D, Indian
R&D is not competitive with the other countries. The industry should improve its
R&D.
➢ Infrastructure Facilities: India is lacking proper infrastructure facilities. Many
companies view that the cost advantages in India is being eroded because of its bad
infrastructure facilities.
➢ Low Labor Productivity: The labor productivity in the country is low when
compared to the developed countries. This is mainly because of huge unskilled labor
force.
➢ High Interest Costs: High interest costs and other overheads make the competition
unproductive.
➢ Taxes: Various kinds of taxes push up the costs and hence companies are forced to
operate under low profit margins.
Opportunities:
Threats:
➢ Integration of Indian Economy with Global Economy: With the growing
integration of the Indian economy with the Global economy, events around the world
have a direct or indirect impact on the Indian automobile industry. In particular,
Indian financial markets are highly integrated to global financial markets. As a result,
liquidity and availability of credit, an important facilitator for automobile and tractor
sales in the Indian market, will be impacted by conditions in the Global markets.
➢ Pollution and Emission Controls: Stringent legislation on pollution and emission
requirements will increase the cost of the Company’s products for the Automotive
Sector. Holding the price line could have an impact on profitability. Price increases on
the other hand could impact volumes.
➢ Increased Competition: The entry of new players will result in ever increasing levels
of competition in all the segments of the automobile industry, resulting in intense
pressure on the profit margins of all participants
Automobile
Sector
Rs 627.35 (2.19%)
CMP
52 week
Rs.645.00/Rs.322.05
High/Low
Key Points:
➢ The company is one of the top Tractor selling brands in the world.
➢ The company has a huge market share for its tractors and passenger cars.
➢ The company is planning to invest Rs.250Cr. in Aerospace
➢ The group is going to decide on bidding to acquire Korean SUV Maker Ssangyong
Motor by July.
➢ The company is going to market many new variants in its motorcycle segment by the
end of the year.
➢ The company’s foray into the electronic vehicles segment is having a greater future
growth prospects.
➢ The company plans to open 300 outlets in various parts of the country in the next 3
years.
The Mahindra & Mahindra, a company established in the year 1945 as a franchise for
assembling Jeeps now a US $7.1 billion Indian multinational employing over 1 lakh people
across the globe. The Mahindra Group today is an embodiment of global excellence and
enjoys a strong corporate brand image. The company enjoys a leadership position in utility
vehicles, tractors and information technology, with a significant and growing presence in
financial services, tourism, infrastructure development, trade and logistics.
The Management:
The Mahindra Group is being managed by eminent persons from various industries who
bring diverse experience and expertise to the Board. The present group is headed by Mr.
Keshub Mahindra as the Chairman and Mr. Anand G. Mahindra as the Vice Chairman
Managing Director.
The Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., is in the automobile business which includes:
The Group exports its products to several countries in Europe, Africa, South America,
South Asia and the Middle East. The Automotive Sector continues to be a leader in the utility
vehicle segment with a diverse portfolio that includes mass transport as well as new
generation vehicles.
Mahindra & Mahindra’s foray into the three wheeler segment with Alpha and Champion
has also made it a leader in its category.
Mahindra Navistar Automotives Ltd. (MNAL), a joint venture between Mahindra &
Mahindra Limited and International Truck and Engine Corporation, will manufacture trucks
and buses for India and export markets. It will also provide component sourcing and
engineering services to International Truck and Engine Corporation.
M&M has a growing global footprint and has established itself in markets across the world
as one of the world’s most prestigious auto brands. The emphasis is now on establishing a
solid local presence in these countries as this was the key to long-term success and building
trust with the customer. With subsidiaries in South Africa, Europe and Australia and a strong
presence in over 15 countries, it aspires to be globally renowned in Utility vehicles.
The Mahindra Group entered into the two wheeler market by acquiring the assets of
Kinetic Motor Company Limited. The company has a partnership with Taiwan’s Sanyang
industry Company Limited which is a leading manufacturer of two wheelers. The company
has recently made an entry into the electric vehicles segment by acquiring a major stake in
Reva.
2. Farm Equipments Sector: The Mahindra group's Farm Equipment Sector (FES) is
amongst the top three tractor brands in the world. It has won the Japan Quality Medal in 2007.
It also holds the distinction of being the first tractor company globally to win the Deming
Application Prize in 2003. FES is the first tractor company worldwide to win these honors.
This shows the strong focus of FES on Quality and Customer Satisfaction. Today, the
domestic market share of FES is around 42%. (Mahindra brand: 30% and Swaraj brand: 12%).
FES has a subsidiary agricultural tractor manufacturing company in India known as
Mahindra Gujarat Tractor Limited (MGTL).
The international operations of the Farm Equipment Sector are spread across six
continents and in around 25 countries. FES has state-of-the-art manufacturing plants in India
and China with a combined capacity to produce more than 1,70,000 tractors a year. Besides,
these plants there are assembly plants in USA and Australia. FES has more than 1000 dealers
world-wide.
In 2008, Mahindra acquired the majority stake in 3rd largest tractor company in China,
with forming a Joint Venture (JV) with Jiangsu Yueda Yancheng Tractor Manufacturing Co.
Ltd. (Yancheng Tractor), a leading Chinese tractor manufacturer.
Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Sources of funds
Owner's fund
Loan funds
Uses of funds
Fixed assets
Current assets, loans & advances 5,081.20 3,816.41 3,916.94 2,805.04 2,356.41
Less : current liabilities & provisions 4,797.76 3,468.77 2,854.20 2,254.37 1,980.58
Notes:
Number of equity shares outstanding (Lacs) 2726.16 2390.73 2380.33 2334.00 1116.48
Profit & Loss Account: (Table 2)
Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Income
Expenses
Preference dividend - - - - -
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Net cash from operating activities 1,631.30 825.83 1,168.95 686.90 379.21
Net cash (used in)/from investing activities -1,941.00 -2,075.08 -950.39 -502.66 -174.30
Net cash (used in)/from financing activities 696.91 811.34 418.08 -89.78 192.45
Net inc/dec in cash and equivalents 387.21 -437.91 636.64 94.47 397.36
Cash and equivalents begin of year 1,174.62 1,361.79 725.15 630.69 233.33
Cash and equivalents end of year 1,561.83 923.88 1,361.79 725.15 630.69
Financial Highlights:
➢ On looking at the balance sheet (table 1) we can see that in 2009 the debts (both
secured and unsecured) have increased by more than 50 % when compared with the
previous year. There is also a huge increase in Fixed Assets and Investments when
compared with the figures of 2008.
➢ On looking at the income statement (table 2) we can see that the sales revenue has
increased when compared with the previous year but there is a fall in the operating
profits which is mainly because of increase in the cost of materials. As a result there is
a decrease in the Net Profits also.
➢ On looking at the cash flow statements (table 3) we can say that the company has got
better cash flows when compared to the previous year (2008) which is mainly because
of increase in the income from operating activities.
1.2. Analysis of Key Ratios:
To better understand the financial position of the firm the following ratios are considered:
(Table 4)
Earnings Per Share (EPS) (Rs.) 30.69 46.15 44.88 36.72 45.92
Dividend Per Share (DPS) (Rs.) 10.00 11.50 11.50 10.00 13.00
Book Value Per Share (Rs.) 191.45 180.87 147.98 123.29 176.77
Inference: The Debt-Equity Ratio is the ratio between outsider funds and owner’s funds. A
Debt-Equity ratio of 1:2 represents high safety margin to the creditors. In the figure 5 we can
see that the Debt-Equity Ratio is increasing since 2005-06 which means that the debt is
increasingly used for every rupee of own funds.
Inference: The Return on Equity Ratio measures the returns on the equity funds employed
by the business. The figure 6 shows that the company made lesser and lesser returns on the
equity funds employed in the business since 2006-07.
3. Price Earnings Ratio: (figure 7)
Inference: This ratio brings out the relationship between the current prices and the EPS. It
shows the amount an investor is willing to pay per rupee of the earnings of the company. In
the figure 7 we can see that in the year 2009 the investor is ready to pay Rs.22.52 per rupee
of earnings. There is a rise in P/E ratio in spite of a fall in the EPS.
4. Dividend Per Share (DPS): (figure 8)
Inference: This ratio shows the earnings that are distributed to the equity shareholders on a
per share basis. The figure 8 above shows that the company has declared less dividends in
2009 when compared with the previous years of 2007-08 and 2006-07.
Inference: This ratio shows the percentage of profits earned that are distributed as dividends
to equity shareholders. In the figure 9 we can see that the company has been declaring lesser
and lesser percentage of earnings as dividends till 2007-08. In the year 2008-09 the company
declared the highest percentage of the earnings as dividends.
Inference: This ratio compares the dividends and the Market Prices of the shares. This ratio
shows what the investor gains if he buys the shares for the Market Price. In the figure 10 can
see that the Dividend Yield Ratio is not moving with the DPS ratio because the dividend
yield ratio also compares the Market Price. The Dividend Yield Ratio will be very low in
spite of high DPS if the Market Prices of the shares are very high.
Inference: This ratio shows the claim of the shareholders on a per share basis. This ratio
shows the worth of a share according to the books. From the figure 11 we can see that the
Book value per share is increasing since 2005-06.
1.2. Analysis of Technical Indicators
1. Moving Averages:
In the above chart two smoothing curves are drawn along with the price curve. EMA 20
represents the 20 day exponential moving average (fast moving average) while EMA 100
represents the 50 day exponential moving average (slow moving average). The purpose of
this chart is to identify the price trend and to identify trading signals.
Trend Identification: The moving averages are used to find the trend of the stock.
➢ The direction of moving average is used to find the trend. If the moving average is
rising, the trend is considered Up. If the moving averages are falling the trend is
considered to be Down.
➢ Price location. The location of the price relative to the moving
average can be used to determine the basic trend. If the price is
above the moving average, the trend is considered up. If the price is
below the moving average, the trend is considered down.
➢ The third technique for trend identification is based on the location
of the slow moving average relative to the fast moving
average. If the fast moving average is above the slow moving
average, the trend is considered up. If the fast moving average is
below the slow moving average, the trend is considered down.
Trading Signals: Two moving averages are used to find the trading signals.
➢ A BUY signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses above the slower
moving averages.
➢ A SELL signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses below the slower
moving average.
Inference:
➢ SELL signals were identified during the Mid February and Mid April periods when
the EMA 20 crossed below the EMA 50. We can also notice that the prices fell during
these signals were generated
➢ BUY signals were identified during the beginning of March, beginning of May and
end of May when EMA 20 crossed above EMA 50. We can also find that the prices
rose during the period when the signals were identified.
➢ As these signals identified late these signals can be used in the future period if the
trend repeats.
1. Relative Strength Index (RSI): (figure 13)
In the above chart the price line and the 14 day RSI line are plotted. The RSI line shown at
the bottom of the chart is used to identify the overbought and over sold situations. If RSI
crosses above 70 level the stock is considered to be oversold and so there are chances for
trend reversal. If the RSI falls below 30 level the stock is considered to be oversold and hence
undervalued. So there are chances for a trend reversal. An RSI between 50 and 70 is
considered bullish while below 50 is considered to be bearish.
Inference: The various overbought and oversold conditions in the figure 13 are identified
using and marks respectively.
In the figure we can also see that the RSI level is above 50 and is also rising. This shows that
there is a bullish momentum.
2. Rate of Change (ROC): (figure 14)
The rate of change is a pure momentum oscillator which shows the rate of change in
prices of the stock over a fixed period of time. In the above chart the price line is shown at
the top and 10 days Rate of Change is shown at the bottom.
The ROC value oscillates above and below zero levels which shows the percentage
change in the price. These values are also used to find the overbought and oversold
conditions. Generally the ROC value above 10 is considered to be overbought and below 10
is considered to be oversold. An ROC value above zero or moving from below to above zero
level is considered to be bullish. It is considered bearish when the ROC value goes below
zero or when it moves from above zero to below zero level.
Inference: From the figure 14 we can see that the ROC value is increasing after touching the
zero value. Hence the momentum is considered bullish.
3. Moving Average Convergence and Divergence (MACD): (figure 15)
The price curve and the MACD curve (red line) are plotted on the figure 15. The MACD
chart is plotted along with the MACD signal line (blue line) and MACD histogram (black
shaded region). The chart is plotted to identify the strongest momentum i.e. bullish or
bearish. This can be identified using signal line crossovers and centerline crossovers.
➢ Signal line crossovers: It is considered bullish if the MACD line crosses above the
signal line (its nine day EMA). If the converse happens it is considered bearish
➢ Centerline Crossovers: It is considered bullish if MACD crosses above the centerline.
If the converse happens the momentum is considered bearish.
➢ MACD indicator is highly volatile and hence it is always considered along with other
indicators.
Inference:
➢ The various Bullish and bearish signals are identified in the figure 15 using and
marks respectively.
➢ In the above chart we can see that at the end of June the MACD curve is below its
signal line. Even though the MACD shows a bearish crossover we can see that the
MACD is above zero line and the price is in increasing since many days and has
established a support.
1. Analysis of Tata Motors Limited
Sector Automobile
NIFTY 5312.50(+1.07%)
Key Points:
➢ The company is considering raising Rs25bn via equity or FCCB to trim debt pile.
➢ The Company is planning to launch Nano in Thailand.
➢ The company is about launch four new variants of its LCVs.
➢ The company is going to increase the production of Nano Cars by this year.
➢ Jaguar Land Rover (JLR), a Tata Motors company, is planning to set up a national
sales company in China this year.
➢ The company has reported a whopping 50% jump in its consolidated global sales for
the month of May 2010 compared to the year ago period.
➢ The company signs MoU with IOB for vehicle financing.
➢ The company is planning to setup Heavy Truck plant in Myanmar.
The Tata Group:
Started in the year 1868 as a private trading firm, today the Tata Group is the India’s
largest conglomerate with revenues of $70.8 bn in the financial year ending March 31, 2009.
Its 28 publicly listed companies have a combined market capitalization which is one of the
highest among all business houses in India and a shareholder base of over 3.5 million. Group
companies export products and services to over 85 countries and have operations in over 80
countries.
The Tata Group includes 88 companies ranging from consumer products, hotels to steel,
energy, IT sector, Telecom, finance, automobiles, chemicals, retail, etc.
The Company:
Tata Motors Limited is India's largest automobile company, with consolidated revenues
of Rs. 92,519 crores (USD 20 billion) in 2009-10. It is the leader in commercial vehicles in
each segment, and among the top three in passenger vehicles with winning products in the
compact, midsize car and utility vehicle segments. The company is the world's fourth largest
truck manufacturer, and the world's second largest bus manufacturer.
Tata Motors, the first company from India's engineering sector to be listed in the New
York Stock Exchange (September 2004), has also emerged as an international automobile
company. Through subsidiaries and associate companies, Tata Motors has operations in the
UK, South Korea, Thailand and Spain. Among them is Jaguar Land Rover, a business
comprising the two iconic British brands that was acquired in 2008. In 2004, it acquired the
Daewoo Commercial Vehicles Company, South Korea's second largest truck maker.
The company's commercial and passenger vehicles are already being marketed in several
countries in Europe, Africa, the Middle East, South East Asia, South Asia and South
America. It has franchisee/joint venture assembly operations in Kenya, Bangladesh, Ukraine,
Russia, Senegal and South Africa.
In January 2008, Tata Motors unveiled its People's Car, the Tata Nano, which India and
the world have been looking forward to. The Tata Nano has been subsequently launched, as
planned, in India in March 2009. A development, which signifies a first for the global
automobile industry, the Nano brings the comfort and safety of a car within the reach of
thousands of families. The standard version has been priced at Rs.100,000 (excluding VAT
and transportation cost).
Products:
The company produces passenger vehicles, utility vehicles, trucks, commercial passenger
vehicles, defence vehicles.
The Management:
Mr. Ratan N Tata, Chairman
Sources of funds
Owner's fund
Loan funds
Uses of funds
Fixed assets
Current assets, loans & advances 10,836.58 10,781.23 10,318.42 9,812.06 7,248.88
Less : current liabilities & provisions 12,846.21 12,029.80 8,321.20 7,888.65 7,268.80
Notes:
Number of equity shares outstanding (Lacs) 5140.08 3855.04 3853.74 3828.34 3617.52
2. Profit & Loss Account: (table 6)
Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Income
Expenses
Preference dividend - - - - -
Net cash flow from operating activities 1,295.02 6,174.50 2,210.13 -221.03 1,249.82
Net cash used in investing activities -10,644.67 -5,721.86 -2,805.10 -1.06 -956.57
Net cash used in fin. Activities 8,104.70 1,132.46 303.58 -855.27 940.67
Net inc/dec in cash and cash equivalents -1,244.95 1,585.10 -291.39 -1,077.36 1,233.92
Cash and equivalents- begin of year 2,386.77 806.21 1,118.15 2,196.79 771.12
Cash and equivalents- end of year 1,141.82 2,391.31 826.76 1,119.43 2,005.04
Financial Highlights:
➢ On looking at the balance sheet (table 5) we can see that in the year 2008-09 there is a
huge increase of above 100% in loan funds when compared to the year 2007-08.
➢ At the same time there is also a huge increase in the investments and a marginal
increase in the fixed assets when compared with the year 2007-08.
➢ On looking at the Profit & Loss Account (table 6) we can see that there is a decrease
in the sales revenue and increase in the cost of goods sold. This has mainly lead to the
lower profits for the year 2008-09.
➢ We can also find some increase in the financial expenses due to huge borrowings.
➢ On looking at the Cash Flow Statements (table 7) we can see that the company has
got a better cash flows when compared to the previous year in spite of very less
generated from operating activities and a heavy outflow on investment activities. This
is because of high amounts of cash is generated from financing activities.
1.2. Key Ratio Analysis:
To better understand the financial position of the firm the following ratios are considered: (table 8)
Earnings Per Share (EPS) (Rs.) 19.48 52.63 49.65 39.94 34.19
Dividend Per Share (DPS) (Rs.) 6.00 15.00 15.00 13.00 12.50
Book Value Per Share (Rs.) 240.60 202.70 177.33 143.58 113.15
Inference: The Debt-Equity Ratio is the ratio between outsider funds and owner’s funds. A
Debt-Equity ratio of 1:2 represents high safety margin to the creditors. In the figure 17 we
can see that the Debt-Equity Ratio for the years 2007-08 and 2008-09 is 0.49 which means
Rs.0.49 of debt is used with every rupee of own funds. The ratio of 1:2 for the last two years
shows high safety margin and low claim for the creditors.
Inference: The Return on Equity Ratio measures the returns on the equity funds employed
by the business. The figure 18 shows that the returns for the equity funds are very low in
2008-09 when compared to all the other years.
Inference: This ratio shows the earnings that are distributed to the equity shareholders on a
per share basis. The figure 20 shows that the company has declared lower dividends in 2009
when compared with all other years.
Inference: This ratio shows the percentage of profits earned that are distributed as dividends
to equity shareholders. In the figure 21 we can see that the company has been declaring lesser
and lesser percentage of earnings as dividends till 2007-08. Again in the year 2008-09 the
company declared the high percentage of earnings as dividends. This means that the company
has retained lesser profits in 2008-09.
Inference: This ratio compares the dividends and the Market Prices of the shares. This ratio
shows what the investor gains if he buys the shares for the Market Price. In the figure 22 we
can see that the Dividend Yield Ratio is not moving with the DPS ratio because the dividend
yield ratio also compares the Market Price. In 2009 the dividend yield ratio is very low only
because of very low DPS.
1. Moving Averages:
In the above chart two smoothing curves are drawn along with the price curve. EMA 20
represents the 20 day exponential moving average (fast moving average) while EMA 100
represents the 50 day exponential moving average (slow moving average). The purpose of
this chart is to identify the price trend and to identify trading signals.
Trend Identification: The moving averages are used to find the trend of the stock.
➢ The direction of moving average is used to find the trend. If the moving average is
rising, the trend is considered Up. If the moving averages are falling the trend is
considered to be Down.
➢ Price location. The location of the price relative to the moving
average can be used to determine the basic trend. If the price is
above the moving average, the trend is considered up. If the price is
below the moving average, the trend is considered down.
➢ The third technique for trend identification is based on the location
of the slow moving average relative to the fast moving
average. If the fast moving average is above the slow moving
average, the trend is considered up. If the fast moving average is
below the slow moving average, the trend is considered down.
Trading Signals: Two moving averages are used to find the trading signals.
➢ A BUY signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses above the slower
moving averages.
➢ A SELL signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses below the slower
moving average.
➢ The prices started an uptrend at the end of the month on noticing the candlesticks of
last few days.
➢ We can also see that the price is above both EMA 20 and EMA 50.
➢ Both the moving averages are rising
➢ The fast moving average (EMA20) is above the slow moving average (EMA 50)
The various trading signals identified using the moving averages crossovers are:
➢ SELL signals were identified during February and May where the EMA 20 crosses
below the EMA 50.
➢ BUY signals were identified in the beginning of March and at the end of June.
➢ The SELL and BUY signals are shown with and respectively.
1. Relative Strength Index (RSI): (figure 25)
In the above chart (figure 25) the price line and the 14 day RSI line are plotted. The RSI
line shown at the bottom of the chart is used to identify the overbought and over sold
situations. If RSI crosses above 70 level the stock is considered to be oversold and so there
are chances for trend reversal. If the RSI falls below 30 level the stock is considered to be
oversold and hence undervalued. So there are chances for a trend reversal. An RSI between
50 and 70 is considered bullish while below 50 is considered to be bearish.
Inference: The various overbought and oversold conditions in the above chart are identified
using and marks respectively.
In the figure 25 we can also see that the RSI level is above 50 and is also rising. This shows
that there is a bullish momentum.
2. Rate Of Change (ROC) (figure 26)
The rate of change is a pure momentum oscillator which shows the rate of change in
prices of the stock over a fixed period of time. In the above chart the price line is shown at
the top and 10 days Rate of Change is shown at the bottom.
The ROC value oscillates above and below zero levels which shows the percentage
change in the price. These values are also used to find the overbought and oversold
conditions. Generally the ROC value above 10 is considered to be overbought and below 10
is considered to be oversold. An ROC value above zero or moving from below to above zero
level is considered to be bullish. It is considered bearish when the ROC value goes below
zero or when it moves from above zero to below zero level.
Inference: From the above chart (figure 26) we can see that the ROC value is in falling
below the zero level. Hence the momentum is considered bearish.
3. Moving Average Convergence and Divergence: (figure 27)
The price curve and the MACD curve (red line) are plotted on the above chart. The
MACD chart is plotted along with the MACD signal line (blue line) and MACD histogram
(black shaded region). The chart is plotted to identify the strongest momentum i.e. bullish or
bearish. This can be identified using signal line crossovers and centerline crossovers.
➢ Signal line crossovers: It is considered bullish if the MACD line crosses above the
signal line (its nine day EMA). If the converse happens it is considered bearish
➢ Centerline Crossovers: It is considered bullish if MACD crosses above the centerline.
If the converse happens the momentum is considered bearish.
➢ MACD indicator is highly volatile and hence it is always considered along with other
indicators.
Inference:
➢ The various Bullish and bearish signals are identified on the chart using and marks
respectively.
➢ In the above chart (figure 27) we can see that at the end of June the MACD curve is
above its signal line. So there is a bullish signal crossover.
1. Analysis of Ashok Leyland Limited
ASHOK LEYLANDSHAREHOLDING
BASIC DETAILS
PATTERN (figure 28)
Sector Automobile
Rs 63.75 (-0.16%)
CMP
Investment Arguments:
The Hinduja Group established in the 1914 is one of the largest groups in the country
which now has its global presence in 30 countries across various field like Automotives
(Ashok LEYLAND), Energy & Oil (Gulf Oil), IT/ITES (HMT IT), Banking and Financial
Services (Hinduja Bank, Geneva), Media & Entertainment and Infrastructure.
The Company:
The Ashok Leyland was setup in the year 1948 in the name of Ashok Motors, a company
for assembling Austin Cars. Since then Ashok Leyland has been a major presence in India's
commercial vehicle industry with a tradition of technological leadership, achieved through
tie-ups with international technology leaders and through vigorous in-house R&D.
Ashok Leyland vehicles have built a reputation for reliability and ruggedness. In the
populous Indian metros, four out of the five State Transport Undertaking (STU) buses come
from Ashok Leyland. Some of them like the double-decker and vestibule buses are unique
models from Ashok Leyland, tailor-made for high-density routes.
Ashok Leyland has seven manufacturing plants - the mother plant at Ennore near
Chennai, three plants at Hosur (called Hosur I and Hosur II, along with a Press shop), the
assembly plants at Alwar, Bhandara and state-of-the-art facility at Pantnagar.
Ashok Leyland reached a major milestone in 1993 when it became the first in India's
automobile history to win the ISO 9002 certification. It has also become the first Indian auto
company to receive the latest ISO/TS 16949 Corporate Certification (in July 2006) which is
specific to the auto industry.
The NHAI awarded contracts worth 9000crores to the company of which 27% belongs to
South.
The Management:
➢ R J Shahaney, Chairman
➢ D G Hinduja, Co-Chairman
➢ R Seshassayee, Managing Director
Associate Companies:
Joint Ventures:
➢ Nissan Motor Company: To develop, manufacture and distribute LCVs. The JV will
launch products by 2011.
➢ John Deere: To manufacture and market Construction Equipments. The JV will start
production by the end of 2010.
➢ Ashley Alteams: To produce High Pressure Dye Casting used in telecom and
automotive sectors.
Products:
The company manufactures and markets Buses, Trucks, Engines and Defence Purpose
Vehicles. It caters to both domestic and international markets.
10.1. Analysis of Financial Information:
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Sources of funds
Shareholder’s Funds
Loan funds
Application of funds
Fixed assets
Current assets, loans & advances 3,195.69 2,759.38 2,544.92 2,183.13 2,161.15
Less : current liabilities & provisions 2,475.37 2,541.72 1,970.20 1,595.81 1,340.40
Notes:
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Number of equity shares outstanding (Lacs) 13303.38 13303.38 13238.70 12215.87 11892.94
Profit & Loss Account: (table 10)
---------------------------Rupees in Cr.-----------------------
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Income
Expenses
Preference dividend - - - - -
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Particulars Mar ' 09 Mar ' 08 Mar ' 07 Mar ' 06 Mar ' 05
Net cash used in investing activities -664.18 -809.68 -749.69 -133.59 -155.45
Net cash from Financing Activities 459.18 364.52 -289.38 -257.60 280.38
Net inc/dec in cash and equivalents -730.58 620.53 -539.12 -69.17 572.28
Cash and equivalents begin of year 815.73 195.20 850.32 919.49 348.19
Cash and equivalents- end of year 85.15 815.73 311.21 850.32 920.47
Financial Highlights:
➢ On looking at the balance sheet we can see that there is an increase in the fixed assets.
➢ The loan funds has increased and there is also a fall in the value of investments
➢ On looking at the profit and loss account we can see that the sales revenue fell by
almost 25% when compared to the sales figures of 2007-09. As a result the profits
have also reduced.
➢ On looking at the Cash Flow Statement we can see that the cash flows of the company
are better when compared to the previous year in spite of cash lost in operating and
investing activities. This is because the company has generated inflows by financing
activities.
10.1. Analysis of Key Ratios:
To better understand the financial position of the firm the following ratios are considered: (table 12)
Earnings Per Share (EPS) (Rs.) 1.43 3.53 3.33 2.68 2.28
Dividend Per Share (DPS) (Rs.) 1.00 1.50 1.50 1.20 1.00
Book Value Per Share (Rs.) 2.40 15.82 13.95 11.31 9.45
Inference: The Debt-Equity Ratio is the ratio between outsider funds and owner’s funds. A
Debt-Equity ratio of 1:2 represents high safety margin to the creditors. In the above graph
(figure 29) we can see that the Debt-Equity Ratio for the years 2005-09 is in rising trend
which means more and more amount of debt is used with every rupee of own funds.
Inference: The Return on Equity Ratio measures the returns on the equity funds employed
by the business. The above graph (figure 30) shows that the returns for the equity funds are
very low in 2008-09 when compared to all the other years.
Inference: This ratio shows the earnings that are distributed to the equity shareholders on a
per share basis. The graph above (figure 32) shows that the company has been declaring
higher dividends during 2004-07. But in the year 2008-09 the company declared less
dividend of Re.1 per share because of reduced profits.
Inference: This ratio shows the percentage of profits earned that are distributed as dividends
to equity shareholders. From the above graph (figure 33) we can see that the company has
been declaring higher percentage of profits as dividends except for the year 2007-08.
Inference: This ratio compares the dividends and the Market Prices of the shares. This ratio
shows what the investor gains if he buys the shares for the Market Price. In the above chart
(figure 34) we can see that the Dividend Yield Ratio is not moving with the DPS ratio
because the dividend yield ratio also compares the Market Price. In 2009 the dividend yield
ratio is very low because of low DPS and high Market Price.
1. Moving Averages:
In the above chart two (figure 36) smoothing curves are drawn along with the price curve.
EMA 20 represents the 20 day exponential moving average (fast moving average) while
EMA 100 represents the 50 day exponential moving average (slow moving average). The
purpose of this chart is to identify the price trend and to identify trading signals.
Trend Identification: The moving averages are used to find the trend of the stock.
➢ The direction of moving average is used to find the trend. If the moving average is
rising, the trend is considered Up. If the moving averages are falling the trend is
considered to be Down.
➢ Price location. The location of the price relative to the moving
average can be used to determine the basic trend. If the price is
above the moving average, the trend is considered up. If the price is
below the moving average, the trend is considered down.
➢ The third technique for trend identification is based on the location
of the slow moving average relative to the fast moving
average. If the fast moving average is above the slow moving
average, the trend is considered up. If the fast moving average is
below the slow moving average, the trend is considered down.
Trading Signals: Two moving averages are used to find the trading signals.
➢ A BUY signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses above the slower
moving averages.
➢ A SELL signal is generated if the faster moving average crosses below the slower
moving average.
➢ The prices started an uptrend at the end of the month on noticing the candlesticks of
last few days.
➢ We can also see that the price is above both EMA 20 and EMA 50.
➢ Both the moving averages are rising
➢ The fast moving average (EMA20) is above the slow moving average (EMA 50)
The various trading signals identified using the moving averages crossovers are:
➢ SELL signals were identified during the mid of February where the EMA 20 crosses
below the EMA 50.
➢ BUY signals were identified in the beginning of March.
➢ The SELL and BUY signals are shown with and respectively.
1. Relative Strength Index (RSI): (figure 37)
In the above chart (figure 37) the price line and the 14 day RSI line are plotted. The RSI
line shown at the bottom of the chart is used to identify the overbought and over sold
situations. If RSI crosses above 70 level the stock is considered to be oversold and so there
are chances for trend reversal. If the RSI falls below 30 level the stock is considered to be
oversold and hence undervalued. So there are chances for a trend reversal. An RSI between
50 and 70 is considered bullish while below 50 is considered to be bearish.
Inference: The various overbought and oversold conditions in the above chart are identified
using and marks respectively.
In the above chart (figure 37) we can also see that the RSI level is above 50 and is also rising.
This shows that there is a bullish momentum.
2. Rate Of Change (ROC): (figure 38)
The rate of change is a pure momentum oscillator which shows the rate of change in
prices of the stock over a fixed period of time. In the above chart the price line is shown at
the top and 10 days Rate of Change is shown at the bottom.
The ROC value oscillates above and below zero levels which shows the percentage
change in the price. These values are also used to find the overbought and oversold
conditions. Generally the ROC value above 10 is considered to be overbought and below 10
is considered to be oversold. An ROC value above zero or moving from below to above zero
level is considered to be bullish. It is considered bearish when the ROC value goes below
zero or when it moves from above zero to below zero level.
Inference: From the above chart (figure 38) we can see that the ROC value is rising from
below to above zero level. Hence the momentum is considered bullish.
3. Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD): (figure 39)
The price curve and the MACD curve (red line) are plotted on the above chart. The
MACD chart is plotted along with the MACD signal line (blue line) and MACD histogram
(black shaded region). The chart is plotted to identify the strongest momentum i.e. bullish or
bearish. This can be identified using signal line crossovers and centerline crossovers.
➢ Signal line crossovers: It is considered bullish if the MACD line crosses above the
signal line (its nine day EMA). If the converse happens it is considered bearish
➢ Centerline Crossovers: It is considered bullish if MACD crosses above the centerline.
If the converse happens the momentum is considered bearish.
➢ MACD indicator is highly volatile and hence it is always considered along with other
indicators.
Inference:
➢ The various Bullish and bearish signals are identified on the chart using and marks
respectively.
➢ In the above chart (figure 39) we can see that at the end of June the MACD curve is
above its signal line. So the momentum is considered Bullish.
10. FINDINGS
➢ From the above charts (figure 40) we can see that the EPS has increased considerably
in the 2009 and the net profits had recorded almost 100% growth after a fall in 2008-
09. These show that the company has recovered from the global slowdown and started
to grow again.
➢ The higher P/E Ratio (figure 7) shows that the investors’ confidence level is more
➢ The company is a global leader in tractors and has also entered into the electronic
vehicles segment which has a bright scope in the future.
Technical Analysis:
➢ From the above charts (figure 41) we can see that EPS was continuously rising till
2007-08 and during the year 2008-09 the EPS was very low because of global
slowdown and acquisition of Jaguar Landrover. But in the year 2009-10 the company
again started to post more EPS.
➢ There is also a rise in the Net Profit Margin which shows a sign of recovery.
➢ The Book Value Per Share (figure 23) is continuously increasing which shows that
the value of shares are increasing and the rising P/E Ratio (figure 19) shows
increasing investor confidence.
Technical Analysis:
➢ From (figure 24) we can see that the EMA 20 and EMA 50 are increasing which
shows that the current trend is upward. We can also notice that both the EMA are
moving closely which shows that the stock is highly volatile
➢ From (figure 25) we can see that the RSI is rising and it is above 50. This shows that
the bullish momentum is stronger
➢ In (figure 26) we can see that the ROC has gone below -10 many times which shows
that the stock is highly volatile. At the end of June we can see that the ROC is below
zero which indicates a bearish momentum.
➢ In (figure 27) we can see that the MACD is above its signal line which shows a
bullish momentum. We can also see that the MACD is moving close to its signal line.
This is also an indicator of high volatility.
1. Ashok Leyland Ltd:
➢ From the above chart (figure 42) we can see that the EPS was very low during the year
2008-09 and it has increased in the year 2009-10. Likewise the net profit margin also rose
from the previous year. This shows that the company has recovered from the slowdown
and is back to normal.
➢ In spite of falling Book Value Per Share (figure 35) we can see that the investor
confidence has increased i.e. P/E Ratio (figure 31)
➢ The company has also got a lot of projects from the government which ensures stable
returns for a few years.
Technical Analysis:
➢ In the figure 36 we can see that both the EMA 20 and EMA 50 are rising. The
difference between them is also high. This shows that the prices are making new
highs and hence the trend is considered upward.
➢ The figure 37 shows that the RSI is above 50 level and is rising. This shows that there
is a strong bullish momentum.
➢ The figure 38 shows that the ROC is above zero and is rising. This also shows that the
momentum is bullish
➢ In the figure 39 we can see that MACD is above the signal line and there is a bullish
signal line crossover. We can also notice that the MACD is moving close to its signal
line.
➢ The Indian Automobile Industry is growing at the rate of 18% per annum and
contributes around 5% to the GDP. It is expected to contribute to around 10% of
GDP in the future.
➢ The industry suffered from profitability during the slow down but has started to report
profits.
From the analysis and the findings we can conclude the following:
Indian Automobile industry: The industry has recovered from the global slowdown and
started to make good returns and the industry is expected to grow in the future years. So
investment in the automobile companies is good for long term.
➢ From the fundamental analysis we can conclude that the company is strong in its
fundamentals and has a good future value.
➢ From the technical analysis we can conclude that the prices are in uptrend even
though the MACD shows a bearish signal line crossover because the MACD is above
zero. So the prices are expected to rise in the near future.
➢ From the fundamental analysis we can conclude that the company is strong in its
fundamentals and has a good future value.
➢ From the technical analysis we can conclude that the prices are in uptrend and since
EMAs are moving closer and the stock is highly volatile. The ROC is negative which
shows a bearish signal. But we can see that the MACD is above its signal line. So
there is strong upward momentum, but the prices may fall very soon but will rise
again.
Ashok Leyland:
➢ From the fundamental analysis we can conclude that the company is strong in
fundamentals and prices are expected to rise in the future.
➢ From the technical analysis we can see that the EMAs are rising. We can also notice
that the MACD, ROC and RSI also show bullish momentum. So, we can conclude
that the prices will rise in the short term.
10. Recommendations
Fundamental Analysis is used for making long term investment decisions while Technical
Analysis is used for making short term investment decisions. Based on the fundamental and
technical analysis and conclusions drawn the following investment recommendations are
made to the investors:
The investor has to wait till the target price is reached or as soon as the EMA 20 and EMA 50
converge to make a crossover.
➢ KHAN M Y, JAIN P K., 2010. Management Accounting. New Delhi: Tata McGraw Hill
Education Private Limited.
➢ GREWAL T S., 2005. Analysis of Financial Statements. New Delhi: Sultan Chand & Sons
(P) Ltd.
➢ Available from: http://www.investopedia.com [Accessed between 1st June 2010 and 6th June
2010]
➢ Available from: http://www.mahindra.com [Accessed between 6th June 2010 and 10th June
2010]
➢ Available from: http://www.tatamotors.com [Accessed between 6th June 2010 and 12th June
2010]
➢ Avaiable from: http://www.ashokleyland.com [Accessed between 10th June and 20th June
2010]
➢ Available from http://www.oica.net [Accessed between 10th June 2010 and 16th June 2010]
➢ Available from http://www.siam.in [Accessed between 10st June 2010 and 16th June 2010]
➢ Available from http://icharts.in/oldcharts [Accessed between 1st July 2010 and 5th July
2010]
➢ Available from http://nseindia.com/historicaldata [Accessed between 1st July and 10th July]